- ^ ^.
o LD |
OF TORON 567- |
UNIVERSITY 176 01 |
" |
i |
-j::c>r^
.Xv^O^n
c-f^//:
PLUTAECHI CHAERONENSIS MORALIA
EX RECENSIONE
RUDOLPI HERCHERI
VOLUMEN PRIMUM
^M%
>SriCE
IN AEDIBUS B. G. TEUBNERI
MDCCCLXXII
?0 fl%
JAN 2 3 1968 )j i"5/i V Gf ^OJ^
268730
VIRO ILLUSTRISSIMO
lOSEPHO VALENTINELLI
BIBLIOTHECAE MARCIANAE PRAEFECTO
PRAEFATIO.
Codicum lectiones, ad quorum auctoritatem Plutarchi orationem emendavi, plene et accurate in ampliore Moralium editione aperientur. Nunc satis habeo in medio collocasse ea, quae de mea aliorumve sententia citra manu scriptorum fidem novata sunt.
Opem auxiliumque plerisque huius voluminis libellis Parisinus tulit 1956, quem Wyttenbachius merito honore passim prosecutus est, saepius negle- xit, Diibnerus ut interpolatum pertinaciter asperna- tus est. Chartas Tischendorfianas adhibui libello qui de profectibus in virtute scriptus est, Heidelbergen- sem 153 Convivio Septem Sapientum. Praeterea ex- cerptiones habui in codicibus Venetis factas a me et iuris consulto Groningensi, de Fremery, cuius schedas benignissime mecum communicaverunt viri consiliorum meorum adiutores C. M. Franckenus, professor Groningensis, et W. N. du Rieu, biblio- thecae Lugdunensis conservator. Paucas mendas sustuli Riccardiani virtute, cuius collationem a Diib- nero institutam mihi tramisit Reinholdus Dezeimeris
VI
Burdigalensis, vir omnigena doctrina omatissimus et ad omnem humanitatis rationem commodissimus. Ad hos igitur codices orationem Plutarchi sex- centies refinxi, ut iam certiore sensu de illius stilo singulisque proprietatibus iudicari possit. Unde magis etiam emicuerunt eae sententiae, quibus non ex Plutarchi natura et ingenio, sed ex temporis et librariorum iniuriis color relictus est. Harum ali- quam partem coniecturis meis et aliorum eluisse mihi videor, reliquas (imprudentis enim est perpe- tuam sibi coniectandi fortunam spondere) viris com- mitto in distinguendis vitiis et curandis subtilissimis, ut liberent Plutarchum vitiorum isto contubemio, certaque medicina ad veterem salutem reducant.
nAOYTAPXOY TOY XAIPffiNEffiC
TA H0IKA.
PLUTARCHI CHAEROXENSIS
HORALIA.
riutarclii Moralia. Vol. I.
nEPi HAiASiN Arsiras.
1. Ti Tic av exoi eiTreTv Trepi ttic tujv IX€u0e'pajv 1 TTaibuuv dYiuYTic Kai tivi xpiw|Lievoi cTTOubaToi touc Tpo- uouc av dnopaTev 9e'pe CKeijJuu)ie0a.
2. BeXTiov b' icuuc dTTo Tfic Tcveceujc dpHac0ai
5 TTpdiTOV. ToTc TOivuv eTTi0u|ioOciv IvboStuv TeKVlUV Yevec0ai TraTpdciv uTro0ei'jur|v av eTtuTe |uf) TaTc tuxou- B caic TuvaiEi cuvoiKeTv, XeTuu be oiov eTaipaic fi TraX- XaKaTc" toTc Tdp TTaTp60ev f\ \ir\Tp6Qev dboHoic TeTO- vociv dveHdXemTa TrapaKoXou0eT Td Tfic bucTeveiac
10 oveibri Trapd TrdvTa tov piov Kai Trpoxeipa toTc eXeT- Xeiv KOi XoibopeTc0ai pouXoiuevoic. Kai coqpoc dpa nv 6 TTOiriTr|C 6c 9r|civ
'6Tav be KpriTTic ^x] KaTapXri0rj Tevouc 6p0ujc, dvdTKTi bucTuxeTv touc eKTOvouc'
15 KaXoc ouv Trappriciac 0r|caup6c euTeveia, fjc bi^ ttXcT- CTOV X6tov Troir|Te'ov toTc vojuiMOu TraiboTTOiiac T^ixo- Mevoic. Kai |aev bf| Td cppovriiuaTa tujv UTT^xaXKOv Kai KipbriXov ex6vTUJV t6 Tevoc c(pdXXec0ai Kai TaTreivou- C c0ai TreqpuKe, Kai ladXa 6p0ujc 6 Xctujv TTOiriTric qprici
20 *bouXoT Tdp dvbpa, kSv 0pacucTTXaTXv6c tic ^, 6Tav cuveibri juriTpoc r| TTaTp6c KaKd. ujCTTep djueXei iueTaXauxiac ejUTriTrXavTai Kai (ppudTiua-
1, 1-2H. 1,1-2E.
13. Sxav] Eurip. Herc. f. 1261 20. 6ouXoi] Id. Hipp. 424
1*
4 DE LIBERIS
Toc 01 Yoveujv biacrijaujv. AioqpavTov yoOv tov 0e- lniCTOKXeouc TToXXdKic XeTOuci qpdval koi iTpoc ttoXXouc ujc 6 Ti ctv aiiTOC pouXr|Tai, toOto Kai tuj br|)Liiu cuv- boKei TU) TuJv 'A6rivaiu)v. fi |uev fdp auTOc eSeXei, KOi fi |ur|Trip' ct b' Sv fi nriTrip, Kai GeiuicTOKXfic' as Db' av 0e)aiCTOKXfic, Kai TrdvTCc 'A0TivaToi. Trdvu be dHiov etraiveiv Kai AaKebai)uoviouc Tf^c laeYaXocppocu- vric oiTivec 'Apxiba)Liov tov paciXea dauTu»v eiCri)Liiuj- cav xpilM«civ, OTi )aiKpdv t6 lueteGoc Tuvaka Td)Liuj XapeTv UTteVeivev , eTreiTTOVTec ujc ou paciXeac dXXdio. paciXeibia Trapacxeiv auToTc biavooTTo.
3. 'GxoM^vov b ' dv eiri toutujv eiTreTv orrep oube ToTc TTpo fi)uijuv TTapeujpdTO. t6 ttoTov; oti touc evcKa TraiboTToiiac TTXr|CidZ:ovTac TaTc TuvaiHiv fiTOi t6 TTapd- TTav doivouc f\ lucTpiujc toOv oivuj)Ltevouc TTOieTcGai 15 iTpocfiKei t6v cuvouciac)a6v. cpiXoivoi Tdp Ka\ )li€9u- CTiKOi TivecGai cpiXoOciv ujv av Tfiv dpxnv Tf^c crropac
2 01 TTaTe'pec iv )Lie0i;) TTOiricd)Lievoi tuxujciv. fi Kai Aio- T€vric )ueipdKiov dKCTaTiK6v ibduv Kai TTapacppovoOv 'vea- vicKe' eqpjicev, '6 rraTfip ce )Lie0uujv lcneipe'. Kai Trepi 20 ^ev Tfjc Teveceuic TocaOTa eipficBuj juoi, TTcpi bk rf]C dTUJTTlc Kai bfi XeKTCOv.
4. KaGoXou juev eiTreTv, 6 KaTd tijuv Texvwv Kai Tujv dTTicTri)Liu)V XeTeiv eiu)0a)aev, TauT6 Kai KOTd Tfjc dpeTfjc cpaT^ov dcTiv, ujc eic Tfiv TravTeXfi biKaiOTTpa- 25 Tiav Tpia beT cuvbpa^ueTv, qpuciv Kai Xotov Kai e9oc. KaXu) be XoTOV )uev Tfiv |ud0r|Civ, ?0oc be thv dcKriciv. eici be ai )li€v dpxai Tfjc qpuceujc, ai hk rrpOKOTrai Tf^c
B )ia0f|ceujc, ai be XP^ceic Tfic )LieXeTric, ai b' oKpdTriTec TrdvTUJV. Ka9' 6 b' Sv Xei(p0fi toutujv, KttTd toOt' 30 dvdTKri x^^^v Tivec9ai Tfjv dpeTf|v. f) )uev Tdp qpu-
1, 2— 5H. 1, 2— 4E.
EDUCANDIS 5
cic aveu |aa6riceujc luqpXov, f] be jndOqcic bixct q)uc€ujc eWmec, fi be dcKncic x^pic d)ucpoiv dieXec. ujcirep b' em Tfjc YGuupTiac TrpuJTOv |uev dYoQnv UTidpHai bei Triv ff[v, eiTa be tov qpuTouptov eTTicTrijLxova , eiTa Td " cTTe'p|LiaTa cTTOubaia , tov auTOv Tporrov yY} |Liev eoiKev f) cpucic, TCWjpYiu be 6 iraibeuujv, CTTe'p|LiaTi be ai tuuv XoYUJV oTToSfiKai Ktti Td TTapaTTe^MCiTa. TauTa TTdvTa biaTeivd|uevoc dv eiTTOi|ui oti cuvf|\Ge Kai cuverrveucev C eic Tdc Tuuv Trap' dTTaciv dbo)uevujv qjuxdc, TTuQaTdpou Kai CujKpdTouc Kai TTXdTUJVOc Kai tujv ocoi boHric d6i)iivr|CTou TeTuxrjKaciv. eubai)aujv )uev ouv Kai Gec- (piXfic ei TUJ TauTa TrdvTa 6eujv tic dTTe'bujKev. ei be Tic oieTai Touc ouk eu TTeqpuKOTac juaGrjceuJC Kai |ue- XeTric TuxdvTac opGfic TTpoc dpeTfjv ouk dv t^v Tfic
15 q)uceujc eXdTTUJCiv eic Touvbexojuevov dvaXapeiv, 1'ctuj TToXXoO, ludXXov be toO TTavToc biajuapTdvujv. cpuceujc )uev Tdp dpeTfjv biacpGeipei pa6u)uia, qpauXoTriTa be eTTavop6oi bibaxfi • Kai Td juev pdbia touc d)ueXoOvTac qpeuTei, tci be xctXeTrd TaTc eni^ueXeiaic dXicKeTai. Ka-
- Ta.ud6oic b' dv ujc dvuci)uov TTpdTjua Kai TeXecioupTov D eTTijaeXeia Kai ttovoc ecTiv, erri TToXXd tujv TiTvojue- vujv eTTipXevpac. CTaTOvec )uev Tdp ubaTOC rreTpac KOiXaivouci, cibripoc be Kai xotXKOC Taic eTraqpaic tujv X^ip^v eKTpipovTai, oi b' dpiudTeioi Tpoxoi ttovuj
-5 Ka)ucp6evTec oub ' dv ei ti tgvoito Tfiv eE dpxfic bu- vaivTO dvaXa^eiv eOeuujpiav, Tdc t^ MHV KajUTTuXac Tujv uTTOKpiTUJv paKTripiac dTTeu6uveiv d|uf|xavov, dXXd t6 TTapd qpuciv tuj ttovlu toO KaTd qpuciv eTevcTO KpeiTTOv. )u6va dpa TauTa Tfiv Tfjc eTTi)ueXeiac icxuv
I, s— 7H. 1,4— GR.
4. Tov* 8. dv adiecit Emperius 15. dvaXaPeiv W: dvabpajaeiv 29. |u6va cipa*: Kal laova apa xfic*
6- DE LIBEKIS
biabeiKvuciv ; ouk, dXXd laupia em laupioic. dYa6fi yh E TtecpuKev • dXX ' d|ueXri9eTca x^PceueTai , Kai 6ciu Tfj qpucei peXTiuuv ecTi, tocoutlu iuaXXov eSapYriGeica bi' djueXeiav eHarroXXuTai. ecTi tic diTOKpoTOC Kai Tpaxu- Te'pa ToO be'ovTOC • dXXd YetupYTiQeica TrapauTiKa Ycvvai- s ouc KapTTOuc €Hr|veYK€. TToTa be bevbpa ouk oXiYUjpri- Ge'vTa |aev cTpepXd qpueTai Kai dKaprra KaGicTaTai, TuxovTa be 6p8nc TraibaYUJYiac eYKapna YiveTai Kai TcXecqpopa; TToia be cuj)uaTOc icxuc ouk eHajapXouTai Kai KaTaqpBivei bi' djueXeiav Kai Tpuqpriv Kai KaxeHiav;io Tic b' dc9evfic qpucic ou toTc YU|uvaca|uevoic Kai KaTa- F GXrjcaci rrXeTcTov eic icxuv eirebujKe ; Tivec b ' ittttoi KaXujc TTUjXoba)uvri9e'vTec ouk euTrei9eTc eYevovTo toTc dvapdTaic, Tivec bk dbd|uacT0i (neivavTec ou CKXripau- Xevec Kai 9u|uoeibeTc dTT^Pncav ; Kai Ti beT TdXXa 9au- ^^ ludZieiv, OTTOU YC tujv 9ripiujv tOjv dYpiujTdTUJv 6puj- |uev TToXXd KOi Ti9aceu6|ueva Kai xeipoii9ri YiYv6|ueva ToTc tt6voic; eu be Kai 6 GeTTaXoc epuJTri9eic Tivec eiciv 01 iiTTiujTaTOi GeTTaXuiv, eqpn 'oi TTau6|uevoi tto- 3 XejueTv'. Kai Ti bei Td TroXXd XeYeiv; Kai Ydp t6 rj^oc 20 e9oc dcTi TToXuxp6viov, Kai Tdc )i9iKdc dperdc eGiKdc dv Tic XeYr), ouk dv ti TTXri|U|ueXeTv bdHeiev. ivi be rrepi toutujv cti TrapabeiYnaTi xpricdjuevoc dTraXXdHo- juai ToO cTi TTepi auTUJV lurjKuveiv. AuKoOpYOC Ydp 6 Ttltv AaKebaijuoviujv vojuo9eTric buo cKuXaKac tujv au- "^^ Tujv Yoveujv Xapujv oubev ojuoiujc dXXrjXoic iiYaYev, dXXd Tov jLi^v dTT^qprive Xixvov Kai civdjuujpov, tov be dEixveueiv Kai 9ripav buvaT6v. elTd ttotc tujv AaKe- baijuoviujv eic TauTo cuveiXcYju^vujv , 'jueYdXti toi poTrfi
1,7-8H. 1,6-7R.
1. dAXa*: dXXd Koi 4. «CTi*: dXX' ecTi 21. ^Goc ad- didit Xylander 27. civdjuujpov lacobsius: civd|uopov
EDUCANDIS 7
Trpoc . dpeTfic Kur|civ ^ctiv avbpec' eqprjce 'AaKebai|u6- vioi Kai iGri Kai bibacKaXiai Kai Piuuv dTUJTai) KaiB tfd) xama ujuiv auTiKa br] |ud\a ttouicuj cpavepd'. eiTa TTpocaTCiTuJV Touc CKuXaKac biaqpfJKe , KaTa6eic eic iii- 5 cov Xoirdba Kai XaTwov KaTeuBu tujv CKuXdKUJV. Kai 5 |uev em tov XaTUJOv ^Hev, o be eni Tf)V Xorrdba ujp^rice. TuJv be AaKebaijuoviujv oube'rruj cujupaXeiv ex6vTU)v Ti rroTe auTuJ touto buvaTai Kai ti PouX6- )uevoc touc CKVjXaKac eTrebeiKvuev, 'outoi Toveujv' ecpi")
10 'tuuv auTujv d|U(p6Tepoi , biacpopou be TuxovTec dTUJ- Tfic 6 |uev Xixvoc o be GripeuTric diroPePriKe'. Kai irepi fiev e9ujv Kai piujv dpKeiTUJ TauTa.
5. TTepi be Tpoqpfic ^xoMCVOv av eir) Xifeiv. bei c be, ujc eTuJ dv (pairiv, auTdc Tdc lurjTepac Td Te'Kva
15 Tpe'q)eiv Kai toutoic toijc )uacTOuc UTrexeiv • cujurra- eecTepov Te Tdp Gpeqjouci Kai bid TrXeiovoc eTTi|ue- Xeiac, ibc av evboGev Kai t6 br\ XeToiuevov eH ovu- Xujv dTaTruucai Td TCKva. ai TiT0ai be Kai ai Tpoqpoi Tf)v euvoiav urropoXiiuaiav Kai TtapeTTpaTrTov exouciv,
20 ctTe luicGoO (piXoucai. briXoi be Kai f) cpucic oti bei Tdc |ir|Tepac d TCTevvriKaciv auTdc TiTBeueiv Kai Tpe- <peiv' bid Tdp toOto TravTi Zluuj TCKdvTi Tfjv ck toO TdXaKTOC Tpoqpfjv exopfJTrice. coqpujc be dpa Kai fi Trpovoia biTTOuc eve0riKe TaTc TuvaiEi touc luacTOuc,
25 iva, Kai €1 bibu|ua TCKOiev, biTTdc exoiev Tdc ttic Tpo- D qpfic TTriTdc. xujpic be toutujv euvoucTepai toTc tc- Kvoic TiTVOiVT' dv Kai qpiXriTiKiuTepai. Kai |ud Ai' ouK drreiKdTUiC" fi cuvTpoqjia Tdp (jjcttcp eTTiTOViov ecTi TTic euvoiac. Kai Tdp Td Oripia tujv cuvTpeqpojue-
i,9-llH. 1, 7-9E.
1. KOnciv] KTficiv W 23. coqpwc*: coq)6v 29. KOi Yap] Xenoph. Cyrop. II 1, 13
8 DE LIBEKIS
vouv dTTOCTTuuiaeva TaOia TToGoOvTa cpaiveTai. jadXiCTa jxkv ouv ujcTiep ecpriv auTdc rreipaTeov Td TeKva Tpe- cpeiv Tdc |uriTe'pac- ei h' dp' dbuvdTUJc exoiev f) bid cuu|uaToc dcGeveiav (xevoiTO Tctp «v ti Kai toioutov) fi Tipoc eTe'pujv TeKvujv CTreuboucai xeveciv, dXXd Tdc 5 Ye TiTGac Kai Tdc Tpoqpouc ou Tdc Tuxoucac dXX' ibc
E evi iLidXicTa crtoubaiac boKi|uacTe'ov ecTi. TTpiuTov |uev ToTc fj6eciv 'GXXrivibac. ujCTTep Yap fd jiieXri tou cui- LiaTOC euGuc dTTO yeveceujc TTXdTTeiv tuiv tckvujv dvaT- KaTov ecTiv, iva TauTa 6p6d Kai dcTpapfj cpuriTai, tov lo auTov TpoTTOV H dpxfic Td Tujv TeKvujv fi6r| pu6)LiiZ;eiv TTpocfiKei. euTTXacTOV Tctp Kai uTpov f\ veoTric, Kai TaTc TOUTUJV ipuxaTc dTraXaTc eTi Td juaefmaTa evTri-
p KCTai • TTttv be t6 cKXrip6v xot^^friJ^c juaXdTTeTai. Ka- 6dTTep T«P cqppaTTbec toTc dTtaXoTc evaTTO)udTTOVTai is KTipoTc, ouTUJC ai |ua6f|ceic TaTc tu)v cti rraibiujv ipuxaTc evaTTOTUTTOuvTai. Kai |uoi boKcT TTXdTUJv 6 baijuovioc ejLi|ueXujc rrapaiveTv TaTc TiT6aic }xf] touc TuxovTac )uu6ouc ToTc TTaibioic XeTeiv, iva )ufi Tdc toutujv vyuxdc eH dpxfic dvoiac Kai biacp6opac dvaTTi)UTrXac6ai cu|u- 20 Paivr]. Kivbuveuei be Kai 0ujKuXibr|c 6 TToiriTfic KaXujc TrapaiveTv Xctujv
'Xpf) TraTb' ct' eovTa KaXd bibdcKeiv epTa'. 6. Ou Toivuv oube touto TTapaXmeTv ctHiov ecTiv, 25 OTi Kai Td Traibia Td jueXXovTa toTc Tpocpijuoic uTrri- peTeTv Kai toutoic cvjvTpocpa Tivec6ai DiTTiTe'ov Trpuj-
1 TiCTa |uev CTTOubaTa touc Tporrouc, eTi )uevTOi '€XXri- viKd Kai TTepiTpava XaXeTv, iva )ufi cuvavaxpujvvujuevoi
1, U— 12H. 1, e— UK.
6. Tctc ante Tpoqpouc addicli 17, TTXciTuuv] Rep. p. 377 B 23. xpnl Bergk. p. 448 ^
EDUCANDIS 9
Pappdpoic Ktti t6 fjGoc )iOx6ripoic dtTroqjepuJVTai ti Tfic eKcivujv qpauXoTriToc. Kai oi TTapoi)uia£6)Lievoi be qpa- civ ouK drro tp6ttou Xcyovtcc, oti 'dv X^JuXu) Ttapoi- Kr|cric, UTTOCKdCeiv |aa6r|cri'.
5 7. '€TTei&dv Toivuv fiXiKiav Xdpujciv utto Traiba- YUiToTc TCTdxSai, evTauBa bx] TToXXfjv eTTi|ieXeiav ck- Te'ov -ecTi Tfic toutujv KaTacTdceujc, ibc jufi Xd9ujciv dvbpaTToboic ri pappdpoic f| TTaXi)up6Xoic Td TCKva TTapabovTec. errei vOv fe to Yiv6|aevov ttoXXoTc uTrep-
10 KaTafeXacT^v ecTi. tOov xdp bouXujv tuiv CTTOubaiujv Touc |Liev fCwjpYouc dTTobeiKvuouci, touc be vauKXfi- B pouc Touc be e)UTT6pouc touc be oikovojuouc touc be baveicTdc" 6 ti b' dv eupujciv dvbpdTTobov oivdXrirrTov Kai Xixvov TTpoc Trdcav TrpaYiuaTeiav dxpriCTOv, tou-
15 TLU (pe'povTec uTTogdXXouci touc uiouc. beT be tov CTTOubaTov TTaibaTUJYov toioutov eivai Tfjv cpuciv oi6cTTep fiv 6 0oiviH 6 toO 'AxiXXeujc TraibaYujY^c. To be TTdvTUJV jueTiCTOV Kai KupiuuTaTOv tujv eipriMevujv epxo)Liai qppdcujv. bibacKdXouc ydp ZirjTriTeov toTc t^-
20KVOIC, o'i Kai ToTc pioic eiciv dbidpXriToi Kai toTc Tpo- TTOic dveTriXTiTTTOi Kai TaTc e)UTTeipiaic dpiCTOi* uriTfl C Tdp Kai p\la KaXoKaTaGiac to vo|ui)aou TuxeTv Trai- beiac. Kai KaGdTrep Tdc xdpaKac oi T^ujpToi toTc cpu- ToTc TrapaTi6eaciv, outujc oi v6|ui)lioi tOuv bibacKdXujv
25 e)U)ueXeTc Tdc uTTo6fiKac Kai Trapaiveceic TrapaTrriTVuouci ToTc veoic, IV ' 6p6d toutujv pXacTdvi;] Td fi6ri. vuv be Tic kSv KaTaTTTuceie tujv rraTepujv eviujv, oiTivec Trpiv boKijudcai touc |ueXXovTac bibdcKCiv, bi' dTVOiav, ecTi b' 6t€ Kai bi' dTreipiav dvepujTroic dboKi|uoic Kai
J-, 12-15 H. 1, 11— 12R.
26. pXacxdvri*: pXacTOivoi 27. kSv*: Kai 29. gcri 6'*: ec9'
10 DE LIBERIS
Trapacriiuoic eyxcip^^ouci touc Traibac. Kai ouituj toO- t6 ecTi KttTaYeXacTOV ei bi' direipiav auTo TrpdTTou-
D civ, ^KeTvo be ecxdTiuc ctTOTTOV. t6 ttoTov ; evioTe Tdp eibOTec ttiv eviujv tluv TraibeuTuuv dTreipiav d|ua Kai MoxOripiav ojauic toutoic eTTiTpeTTOuci touc Traibac, o'i 5 |Liev TaTc tuuv dpecKeuo)uevuJV fiTTUi)Lievoi KoXaKeiaic, eici bk o'i Kai beo|uevoic x«pi26)aevoi (piXoic, Trapoiuoiov ttoi- ouvTec uJCTrep dv ei tic tuj cuu|uaTi Kdiuvujv tov cuv l7TiCTr||ur) buvri6evTa dv cuicai TrapaXiTTuuv, cpiXuj x«Pi' Zdjuevoc Tov bi' dTTeipiav dTToXe'cavTa dv auTov Trpoe- lo XoiTO, fi vauKXripov tov dpiCTOv dqpeic tov x^ipicTov boKijudceie (piXou berjGevToc. ZeO Kai Geoi TrdvTec,
E TraTrip tic KaXoujuevoc TtXeiuj Xdyov TTOieTTai Tfic tOuv beojuevujv x«PiTOc f| t^c tuuv tckvuuv Traibeuceuuc ; cTt' ouK eiKOTa TToXXdKic CujKpdTric ckcTvoc 6 TraXaioc ^'Xe- 15 Yev, OTi emep dpa buvaTov fiv, dva(5dvTa eTTi t6 |ueT- euup6TaT0v Tfjc TT6Xeujc )uepoc dvaKpaTcTv 'iD dvGpuu- TTOi, TToT (pepec0e, omvec xPIMotTuuv )uev KTnceuuc rrepi TTacav TTOieTcGe CTTOubfiv, tujv h' uieuuv, oic TaOTa Ka- TaXeiipeTC, jumpd cppovTiZieTe' ; toutoic b' dv e'TU)Te 20 TTpoc0eiriv oti 01 toioOtoi TraTe'pec TrapaTrXficiov ttoi- oOcw, otov ei Tic ToO )u^v uTTobf|)iaTOc cppovTiZoi, TOO be TTob6c oXiTuupuuc exoi. ttoXXoi be eic tocoOto tOuv
E TTaTe'puuv TTpopaivouci (piXapTupiac d)ua Kai )uicoTeKviac, UJC0' iva )ufi TTXeiova )uic06v TeXeceiav, dvGpuuTTOuc 25 Touc )uribev6c Ti)uiouc a\poOvTai toTc tckvoic TTaibeu- tdc, euuuvov d)ua0iav biiuKOVTec. f) Kai 'ApicTiTTTTOC ouK dK6)uvpuuc dXXd Kai Trdvu dcTeiuuc eTTecKuuipe tuj X6tuj TtaTepa voO Kai (ppevuuv Kev6v. ^puuTf|cav-
1, 15-17 H. 1, 12-14 E.
4. €ib6Tec*: eibdrec alc6o|u^vujv luaXXov aurotc toOto \e- t6vtujv 15. CujKpdTiic] Plat. Clitoph. p. 407 A
EDUCANDIS 11
•
Toc Tap Tivoc auTOV ttocov aiTOiri juicGov uTrep tfic ToO TeKvou TTaibeuceoic , 'xi^i«c' ^91 'bpaxnac'. toO be ''HpdKXeic' emovTOc, 'ibc uTrepTroXu t6 aiTr|)aa- buva|Liai ydp dvbpdTrobov xi^^^J^v Trpiac0ai,' 'TOiYap-
5 oOv' eiTTe ' buo e£eic dvbpdTToba, Kai tov uiov Kai dv 5 dv TTpir)'. t6 b' oXov ttOuc ouk citottov ti^ juev beEia cuveGiZieiv Td rraibia bexecGai Tdc Tpoqpdc, Kdv npo- Teivri Triv dpiCTepdv, eTTiTi|adv, |Liribe)Liiav be TT0ieTc9ai TTpovoiav ToO XoTiwv eTTibeHiujv Kai vo|li{|U(juv dKOueiv:
10 Ti ouv cujupaivei toic GaujuacTOic TraTpdciv, eTreibdv KaKuJc juev Gpeipujci KaKouc be Traibeucuuci touc uieic, eTuJ cppdcu). OTav Tdp eic dvbpac eTTpafp^vTec toO |uev uTiaivovToc Kai TeTaTMevou piou KaTa|ueXr|CUJciv, eTTi be Tdc dTdKTOuc Kai dvbpaTTobuubeic fibovdc dau-
15 Touc Kprijuvicujci, TOTe br\ jueTa|ueXovTai ttjv tujv tc- b Kvujv TTpobebujKOTec TTaibeiav, otc oubev ocpeXoc, toic dKeivuuv dbiKr||uaciv dbri)iOVoOvTec. o'i |uev Tdp auTuJv KoXaKac Kai TrapaciTouc dvaXajupdvouciv, dvGpuuTTOuc TTapacr||uouc Kai KaTapdTOuc Kai Tfic veoTriTOC dvaTpo-
20 Treac Kai Xujueujvac , o'i be Tivec ^Taipac Kai xaM^iTu- TTac MicOoOvTai co^apdc Kai TToXuTeXeic, o'i be KaToijJO- qpaToOciv, o'i be eic ku^ouc Kai kuumouc eHoKeXXouciv, fjbri be Tivec Kai tujv veaviKUJTe'pujv fiqjavTO KaKuuv, MoixeuovTec Kai oiKoqpGopoOvTec Kai mi«v fibovfiv 9a-
25 vdTOu TiMuuM^voi. cpiXocoqpia be OMiXficavTec outoi c oO ToiouTOic icujc TTpdTMCtciv ^auTOuc dv KaTaTrei9ek TrapecxovTO, Kai t6 t^ TTapdTTe^M" toO Aiotcvouc eMa9ov dv, 6c qpopTiKuJc m^v toTc piiMaciv dXri9ujc be toTc TTpdTMCici TrapaiveT Kai qprjciv 'eiceX9e eic TTOpveTov
1,17— 19 H. 1,14— 16 E.
7. irpoT6iv)3 Hertlinus: irpoTeiveie 19. Trapacfmouc * : dicriiaoiic 23. fii|javTO*: fiiTTOVTai 24. oiKoqpBopoOvTec
W: KiTToqpopoOvTec
12 DE LIBERIS
nm, iva inderic oti tuuv dEiouv la Tiinia oubtv bia- (p€per.
8. CuveXujv Toivuv iyih qprmi (Kai xP^ci-ioXoYeTv ladXXov Y] Trapaiveiv boEaijn' dv eiKOTuuc) oti ev npuj- Tov Kai |U€'cov Kai TeXeuTaiov ev toutoic KeqpdXaiov s dYiiUTn CTTOu&aia Kai Traibeia v6)lii|u6c ecTi, Kal TauTa qpopd Ktti cuvepfd rrpoc dpeTrjv Kai -rrpoc eubai|aoviav (pri)ni. Kai Td |uev dXXa tiIiv dYaGiJuv dv9pu)TTiva Kai
D MiKpd Kai ouK dHiocTToubacTa KaGecTriKev. euyeveia KaXov )Liev, dXXd TrpoY^vtuv dYaB6v. ttXoOtoc be ti- lo mov |nev, dXXd Tuxnc KTfi|ua, eTreibfi tuuv )aev exovTuuv TtoXXdKic dcpeiXcTo, toic b' ouk eXTricaci cpe^pouca TrpocfiveYKe , Kai oti 6 ttoXuc ttXoOtoc ckottoc CKKeiTai ToTc pouXojLievoic paXdvTia ToHeueiv, KaKoupYOic oikc- Taic Kai cuKOcpdvTaic, Kai to )aeYicTOv, oti Kai toTc i5 TTOvripoTdTOic laeTecTi. boHa Ye jufiv ceiuvov laev, dXX' dpe^aiov. KdXXoc be TrepiiudxriTOv |U€'v, dXX' oXiyo- Xpoviov. UYieia be Ti|niov |iev, dXX' eu|ueTdcTaT0V. icxuc bk ZiriXuuTOV |Liev, dXXd vociu eudXuuTov Kai YHpa- t6
E be oXov ei tic erri Tfj toO cuujuaTOc puujuri qppoveT, 20 |ua9eTuu Yvuujuric biajuapTdvuuv. tt6ctov Ydp ecTiv icxOc dv9pujrrivri thc tuuv dXXuuv Ziujuuv buvd|Lieuuc; XeYuu be oiov eXeqpdvTuuv Kai Taupuuv Kai XedvTuuv. Traibeia bk TUJV iv fijuTv }x6vov ecTiv dGdvaTOv Kai 9eTov. Kai buo Td udvTuuv ^CTi KupiuuTaTa ev dvBpuuTrivrj qpucei, 25 vouc Kai X6yoc. Kai 6 |uev voOc dpxiKdc ecTi tou Xoyou, 6 hk X6yoc UTiripeTiKOc toO voO, Tuxri juev dvdXuuToc, cuKoqpavTia be dvacpaipeToc, vdctu b' dbid^^opoc, Yfjpa b' dXu|iavToc. liovoc Ydp 6 voOc TTaXaiou|uevoc
1, 19— aoH. 1,16— 17 B.
1. -acA Cobetus: itou 13. 6ti* 16. C€|uv6v m^v*:
C€nv6v
EDUCANDIS 13
dvTiPoi, Kai 6 xpovoc raXXa Trdvt' dqpaipujv tlu TnPQi F TrpocTiGrici Triv eTricTri|uriv. 6 y£ MHV tt6X€|U0C x^iM^P" pou biKriv Trdvra cupujv Kai TrdvTa Trapaqpepujv iuovriv ou buvaTai Traibeiav TrapeXec0ai. Kai juoi boKei CTiX- 5 TTUJV 6 MeYapeuc qpiXocoqpoc dEio)uvri)Li6veuTOv TTOirjca- c9ai dTT^Kpiciv, OTe Ar||uf]Tpioc eHavbpaTTobicd|uevoc Triv Tr6Xiv eic ebaqpoc KaTe^aXe Kai tov CTiXTTuuva TipeTO |ur| Ti dTToXujXeKUJC exr\. Kai 6c 'ou bfiTa' eiTre, 'TT6Xe)uoc Tdp ou XaqpupaYuJYci dpeTr|v'. cujuqpujvoc G 10 be Kai cuviuboc Kai fi CujKpdTouc dTroKpicic TauTrj qpaivcTai. Kai Ydp outoc epujTr|cavTOC auTov |uoi bo- Kei fopYiou tiv exei Trepi toO /ueYdXou paciXeujc utto- XriMJiv Kai ei vojJiilei toutov eubai|uova elvai, 'ouk oTba' fqprjce 'ttujc dpeTfic Kai Traibeiac e'xei', u)C Tfjc 15 eubaijuoviac ev toutoic , ouk ev toic Tuxrjpoic dYaOoic Kei)uevric.
9. "QcTTep be Trapaivuj ttic Traibeiac tujv tc^kvujv luiibevTTOieicBai TTpoupYiaiTepov, outujc au TrdXiv qprijni beiv TTic dbiaqpGopou Kai UYiaivoucric e'xec6ai, tujv be 20 TTavriYupiKoiv Xtipujv ujc TroppuJTdTUJ Toijc uieic dTid- Yeiv. t6 Ydp Toic TroXXoic dpecKeiv Toic coqpoic ecTiv B dTTapecKCiv. /uapTupei be )uou tuj XdYtxi Kai GupiTribTic XeYUJV
'ifih b' dKOjuijJOc eic 6xXov bouvai X6yov, 25 eic fiXiKac be KUjXiYouc coqpOuTepoc.
exei be luoipav Kai T6b'* oi Ydp ^v coqpoic qpauXoi TTap' oxXuj luouciKiuTepoi Xe'Yeiv, opu) b' eYUJYC Touc Toic cupqpeTiubeciv oxXoic dpecTuuc
1, 20-22 H. 1,17— 19 R.
5. TTOiricacGai*: -rroificai 10. CwKpdTouc] Plat. Gorg. p. 470 E 24. Eur. Hipp. 986 26. ^\€i bk |UOipav koI
t66' accessit ex eodem y«P*= ^'
14 DE LIBERIS
Ktti K€xapic)Lievujc eTTiTribeuovTac \€Y€iv Kai tov piov ujc Tot TToXXd dcuuTOuc Ktti qpiXri^ovouc dTTopaivovTac. Kai vr) Ai' eiKOTOJC. ei Ydp dXXoic fibovdc ■jrapacKeud- ZovTCc d)LieXouci toO KaXou, cxoXri y' dv Tfic ibiac fibuTTaGeiac Kai Tpuqpfic uTTepdviu t6 dpOov Kai uYiec s TTOiricaivTO r\ t6 cujcppov dvTi toO TeprcvoO biuuHeiav. KaX6v Ydp TOi juribev eiKfi ixryte XeYeiv |Lir|Te TrpdTTeiv, Kai KaTd Tfjv TTapoi)Liiav 'xaXerrd Td KaXd'. oi b' auTO- cxebioi TU)V XoYUJV TToXXfjc euxepeiac Kai pabioupYiac eici TTXfipeic, ou0' 60ev dpKT€'ov ou6' ottoi TraucTe'ov lo ecTiv eiboTUJV. X^i>\c be toiv dXXujv TTXri|a|ueXri)LidTUJV o'i dv eK ToO TTapaxpfi)Lia XeYUJCiv, eic djueTpiav beivfjv
€KTTiTTTOUCl Kai TTOXuXOYiaV. CKe'»iJlC b' OUK ect TfjC
iKVOU)H€vric cu)Li)a€Tpiac t6v Xoyov CKTTiTTTeiv. 6 TTepi- DKXfic, 'ujc fiiuiv dKOueiv Trapab^boTai', KaXou)aevoc is utt6 toO bfiiuou TToXXdKic oux urrfiKOuce, Xe'YUJV dcuv- TaKTOC eivai. dicauTUJC be Kai Ar||uoc0evric ZriXujTfic Tfic TOUTou TToXiTeiac Ycvojuevoc KaXouvTUJV auT6v TuJv 'A0rivaiu)v cu)LtpouXov dvTepaivev 'ou cuvTeTa- Y)Liai' X^YUJV. Kai TaOTa nkv icujc dbecrroTOc ecTi Kai 20 TreTTXac)Lievri Trapdbocic ev be tui KttTd Meibiou.Tfjv Tfic CKenjeujc ujqpeXeiav evapYUJC TrapicTrici. (pr]c\ yoOv 'eYUJ b' ecK^qpGai )Liev ui dvbpec 'A0rivaToi qprnni kouk dv dpvriGeiriv Kai )ae)ueXeTriKe'vai fe ujc evfiv )LidXiCTa e)aoi' Kai Ydp dv dOXioc fiv, ei TOiaOTa TraOujv Kai «5 E TTdcxujv ^)LieXouv uiv rrepi toutujv epeiv e^neXXov'. t6 be beiv TTavTdTTaciv dTTobOKi^iidZieiv tujv Xoyujv Tfiv ^toi- laoTriTa f\ TrdXiv aij TauTriv ouk ^tt' dHioic dcKcTv ou qpairiv dv eYUJYe, dXX' ujc iv qpapjudKOu juoipci toOto
t, 22— 24H. 1,19— 21 R.
15. ix)c — Trapa6^6oTm] Demosth. p. 641, 34 21. Kard Mei&iou] p. 576, 17 23. dv6pec* Koi |Lte)uie\eTJiK^vai
Demosthenes: KaTaiiejueXeTriK^vai
EDUCANDIS 15
TTOiriTeov ecTi. )iie'xpi ^e Tqc tujv dvbpOuv fiXiKiac oii- bev eK ToO TTapaTuxovTOc dEiuu XeTeiv, dXX' oxav tic piZiujcri TTiv buvajaiv, Toxe tOuv KaipOuv KaXouvTuuv eXeu- GepidJeiv toTc Xotoic rrpocriKei. ujCTrep xdp ol ttoXuv
5 xpdvov beee'vTec Kdv ei XuGeiev ucTepov, utto Tfjc 110- p Xuxpoviou Tuuv bec)auuv cuvrjGeiac ou buvdjaevoi pabi- Zieiv uTTOCKeXiZlovTai , tov auTOV tpottov 01 ttoXXuj XpdvLjj Tov XoTOV cqpiTHavTec, Kdv ei TTOTe ck toO TTapaxpfiiua ber|ceiev eiTTcTv, oubev fiTTOv tov auxov
10 Tfic epjarjveiac x«pciKTfipa cpuXdTTOuci. t6 be ^ti TraT- bac ovTac edv ctti KaipoO XeTeiv jaaTaioXoTiac Tf^c ecxdTrjc aiTiov Ka6icTaTai. ZuuTpdqjoc q)aciv dGXioc 'ATTeXXfj beiSac eiKOva 'TauTriv' eqpn ^vOv T^TPCtqpct', 7 o be "^Kdv ei lix] Xe'TOic' emev 'oTba oti TaxO TCTpa-
iSTTTar GaujadZ^uu be ttuuc ouxi TOiauTac TTXeiouc TCTpct- qpac'. ujCTrep Toivuv (erravdTuu Tdp TTpoc Triv eH dp- Xnc ToO XoTOu uTToGeciv) t^v 0eaTpiKfiv Kai TTapaTpd- Tujbov, ouTuuc au TrdXiv Kai Tfjv c)aiKpoXoTiav Tfic XeSeujc Kai Tarreivujciv rrapaivuj bieuXaPeTcGai Kai qpeu-
soTeiv f] |Liev Tdp uTrepoTKOC dTToXiTeuToc ecTiv, y\ bk icxvf| Xiav dvcKTTXriKTOC, KaGdTrep be t6 cuj|ua ou jLiovov uTieivdv dXXd Kai eueKTiKov eivai xpx], koi t6v B XoTOV ujcauTuuc ouk dvocov juovov dXXd Kai eupuu- CTov eivai beT. t6 \xiv fap dcqpaXec erraiveTTai }i6-
25 vov, t6 be ^TTiKivbuvov Kai GauiadZieTai. t^v auTfjv be TUTxdvuj Tvuu|ur|v exuuv Kal TTepi Tfic ev Tfi MJuxfi bia- Geceuuc. ouTe Tdp Gpacuv out' dToXjaov Kai KaTa- TTXfiTCt TTpocfiKCV eivtti " t6 )aev Tdp eic dvaicxuvTiav, t6 be eic dvbpaTTobujbiav TrepiicTaTar evTexvov be t6
1,24— 25 H. 1,21—22»,
5. €1 14. Kav ei ,ur) X^yoic*: Kftl fjv |Li»i Xi^ryc. 25. auTiiv *
16 DE LIBERIS
Tfjv laecriv ev aTraci T€]uveiv e)U|ueXecTaTa. poii\o|uai b\ euuc eTi |ue|uvri|uai Tfic Traibeiac, ujc exuu boHric Trepi auTnc elTreiv, oti tov luovdKuuXov Xotov TrpuJTOv luev djuouciac ou luiKpov TTOioO)uai TeKjuripiov eTteiTa be xai TTpoc Trjv acKriciv dipiKopov Kai TravTeXujc dve- r. TTi|uovov eivai vo|uiZ;uu. )uovujbia Ydp ev ccTTaciv ecTi
C TTXr|C)ui6v Te Kai TrpocavTec, f) be TTOiKiXia TepTrvov, Ka6dTrep Kdv toTc dXXoic dTraciv, olov dKOucjuaciv f\ 6ed)Liaciv.
10. AeT Toivuv tov TraTba tov eXeu6epov |uribev6c lo jurib^ tuuv dXXuuv tuliv KaXou)uevujv etKUKXiuuv Traibeu- ludTuuv |ur|Te dvtiKOov |uf|Te d6eaTov eav elvai, dXXd TaOTtt fxkv eK TTapabpoiufic |Lia6eTv ujcTtepei Yeu)uaT0c ^veKCv (ev dTraci Ydp t6 TeXeiov dbuvaTOv), Tfjv be qpiXocotpiav Trpecpeueiv. exuu be bi' eiKovoc rrapacTfi- 15 cai Tfjv ejuauToO Tvuu|ur|v, wc dpa TrepiTrXeOcai |uev
D TToXXdc TToXeic KaXov, evoiKf|cai be Tf] KpaTicTr] XPHCi- |uov. dcTeiuuc bk Kai Biuuv eXcTev 6 qpiXocoqpoc oti ujCTTep 01 )uvriCTfipec Tf) TTriveXoTrr] TTXricidZeiv )ufi bu- vd)uevoi TaTc TauTnc ejuiYVuvTO 6epaTTaivaic, outuu Kai 20 01 qpiXocoqpiac |ufi buvd|U€Voi KaTaTuxeTv iv toTc dXXoic Traibeu)uaci toTc oubev6c dHioic ^auTOuc KaTacKeXe- Teuouci. bi6 beT Tf^c dXXric Traibeiac ujCTrep Keqpd- Xaiov TTOieTv Tfiv qp.iXocoqpiav. Trepi [xev fap Tfjv toO cuuiuaTOc eTTijueXeiav biTTdc eupov eTTiCTfi)uac 01 dv6puu- 25
TTOl , TflV laTplKflV Kai TflV T^lUVaCTlKflV, U)V tl [Xkv TfjV
uTieiav fi be Tfiv eueHiav evTi6rici. tuuv be Tfic vpuxnc dppuJCTri)udTuuv Kai TTa6uuv x] qpiXocoqpia |u6vri ^dpija- Kov ecTi. bid Tdp TauTnv ecTi Kai |U€Td TauTtic tvuu-
1,25— 27 H. 1,23— 24 R.
16. ujc fipa*: oicTrep Tctp 26. t)iv ante TUHvacriKfiv addicli
EDUCANDIS 17
vai Ti t6 KaXov ti t6 aicxpov, ti t6 biKaiov ti t6 abi- Kov, Ti t6 cuXXripbnv aipeT6v ti t6 cpeuKTOv ttwc 0eoic E TruJc YoveOci ttujc TrpecpuTe'poic ttijuc vojdoic rrOuc dp- Xouci TTuJc qpiXoic ttujc TUvaiHi ttoic t6kvoic ttOuc oiKeTaic
5 xpriCTe'ov ecTi • oti bei Geouc juev cePecGai, Toveac be Ti)aav, Trpec^uTe^pouc aibeicGai, voiuoic TreiGapxeiv, dpxouciv uTreiKeiv, qpiXouc dtaTTav, Trp6c TuvaiKac cujqppoveTv, tckvujv CTepKTiKOuc eivai, bouXouc )Lifi TrepiuPpiZieiv , t6 be jueTiCTOV, |uriTe ev TaTc euTrpaTiaic
10 TTepixapeTc |ur|Te ev TaTc cujaqpopaTc TrepiXuTiouc uTrdp- xeiv, lariTe ev TaTc f]bovaTc eKXuTOuc elvai |ur|Te ev TaTc opTaTc eKTraGeTc Kai Gripiujbeic. dTrep eTUJ Trdv- F TUJV Tujv Ik qpiXocoqpiac TrepiTivojuevujv dTa9ujv Trpec- PuTaTa Kpivuj. t6 )uev Tdp euTevuJc euTuxeTv dvbpoc,
15 t6 b' dveTriqpBovujc eunviou dvepiuTTOu, t6 be toTc XoTiCMoTc TrepieTvai tujv fibovoiv coqpoO, t6 bk opTnc KaTaKpaTeTv dvbpoc ou toO tuxovtoc ecTi. TeXeiouc be dvGpujTTOuc fiToO|uai touc buvajuevouc Tfjv ttoXiti- Kfiv buvaiuiv juTEai Kai Kepdcai Trj qpiXocoqpia, Kai buoTv 8
20 ovToiv jueTicTOiv dTaGoTv eTrriPoXouc uTrdpxeiv utto- Xa)updvuj, ToO Te KoivujqpeXoOc piou TroXiTeuo)uevouc, ToO T€ dKU)uovoc KOi TOf^ilvoO, bmTpi^ovTac rrepi qpi- Xocoqpiav. Tpiujv Tdp ovtujv piujv iLv 6 )uev ecTi rrpa- ktik6c 6 be 9eujpriTiK6c 6 be dTroXaucTiKOC , 6 )uev
25 ckXutoc Ktti bouXoc TLuv fibovuuv ^ujuubric Kai )UlKpO- TrpeTTric dcTiv, 6 be 9eujpriTiK6c toO TrpaKTiKoO btaiuap- Tdvujv dvujqpeXric, 6 be rrpaKTiKoc djuoipiicac qpiXoco- qpiac djuoucoc Kai TTXri)U)ueXric. TTeipaTe'ov oijv eic bu- va)uiv Ktti Td KOivd TrpdTTeiv Kai tiic qpiXocoqpiac dv- B
1,27— 28 H. 6, 24— 2GK.
2. t6 cpeuKT6v*: qpeuKxdv 3. vojjoic*: v6juoic udic
dWoTpioic IG. coqpoO*: cocpuuv
Plutarchi Moralia. Vol. I. 2
18 DE LIBERIS
TiXajupdvecOai Kaxd t6 napeTKOV tujv KaipiLv. outuuc eTroXiTCucaTo TTepiKXfic, oOtuuc 'ApxvjTac 6 TapavTi- voc, ouTuu Aiuuv 6 CupaKocioc, outuuc '€7Ta)ueivu)v- bac 6 0r|PaToc, u)v ctTepoc TTXdTUJvoc eT£veT0 cuvou- ciacTr|c, Ktti Tiepi juev Traibeiac ouk oib ' oti bei 5 TrXeiova XeTOVTa biaTpipeiv Tipoc be toTc eiprme- voic xpnci|Liov, )LiaXXov be dvafKaTov ecTi )uribe Tfic Tujv TTaXaiujv cuYTPaMILidTUJV KTrjceujc oXiTuupuuc exeiv, dXXd Kal TOUTUJV TTOieTcSai cuXXothv KaTd t6 t^iajp- TUJbec. Tov Tap auT6v tpottov opTavov Tfic TTaibeiac lo 11 XP^cic Tuuv pipXiujv ecTi, kui dTTo TTriTilc Triv eTTi- cir\ixr\v TripeTv cu]upepriKev.
C 11. Ou Toivuv dSiov oube Triv tujv cujjLidTUJV dTuiviav TTapopdv, dXXd TTejUTTOVTac ec TTaiboTpi^ou Toijc TraTbac iKavuic TauTa biarroveTv, d)ia ixkv if\c i5 TuJv cujfidTUJV eupu9)aiac eveKev, djua be koi Trpoc puu- )ariv KaXoO Tctp T^ipiwc 9e)LieXiov f\ ev Traiciv tuuv cuj)udTUJV eueHia. Ka9dTTep oijv ev eubia Td TTp6c t6v Xei)uu)va rrpocfiKe TrapacKeudZieiv, outujc ev veoTriTi ttiv euTttHiav Kai Tfjv cuucppocuvriv eqpobiov eic t6 T^ipac 20 dTTOTi9ec9ai. outuu be beT Ta)Liieuec9ai t6v toO cuujua- 1
Dtoc ttovov, ujc )ur| KaTaHripouc Tivo)Lievouc TTp6c jf\y Tfic Traibeiac em^ueXeiav dTraTopeueiv ■ KaTd Tap TTXd- Tuuva UTTVOi Kai Korroi )Lia9r||uaci TToXejuioi. Kai TauTa )Liev ToiaOTa* dXX' 6 TrdvTuuv ecTi KupiuuTaTOv tujv 2 eipriiLievuuv CTreubuu XeTeiv. TTp6c t«P touc CTpaTiuu- TiKouc dTuivac Toijc TraTbac dcKriT^ov ev dKovTicjuoTc auTouc KaTa9XouvTac Kai ToHeiaic Kai 9r|paic. *Td'
1,28-31H. 6,26—27
4. fitcpoc W: dKOtTepoc 17. r\ ^VTrfticiv*: tv Ttaiciv i^ 25. laev TOiauTa Emperius : laevToi TaOTa 28. TOi T^p]
Xenoph. Cyr. II 3, 2
EDUCANDIS 10
Tap 'tujv f)TTUJ|aevujv ' ev TaTc jndxaic 'dTa9d toic viKOJCiv d9\a TTpoKeiTai'. TToXeiuoc be ecKiaTpaqpri)ue- vrjv ca)|udTUJV eEiv ou bexeTai, icxvoc be CTpaTiuuTric rroXeiuiKajv dTUJVUJV e9dc Kai d9XriTfic rroXeiuiujv cpd-
5 XaTTac biuj9eT. ti ouv dv tic emoi; cu be hr\ TtepiE Tfic TuJv eXeu9epujv Traibujv dTUJTilc uTTOcx6)uevoc TTapaTTC^MttTa buuceiv eTreiTa qpaivr) Tfic \ikv tujv rre- vriTUJV Kai bTijiOTiKiuv Trapa|ueXujv dTUJTfic, fiovoic be ToTc TrXoucioic ojuoXoTeTc Tdc uTT09riKac bibovai. Trpoc
10 oijc ou xct^efTOV dTravTficai. eTUJ Tdp |udXiCTa dv PouXoi|Liriv Trdci KOivf) xP^lciimov eivai Tf]v dTUJTnv ei be Tivec evbeujc toTc ibioic TTpdTTOVTec d^uvaTricouci ToTc ejuoTc xpnc9ai TrapaTTe^Maci, Tfjv Tuxriv aiTid- F c9ujcav, ou Tov TaOTa cu/apouXeuovta. ireipaTe^ov |uiev
15 oijv eic buva)Liiv TfjV KpaTicTriv dTUJTfjv TT0ieTc9ai tujv Traibujv Kai toTc Trevriciv ei be |ufi, Tfi fe buvaTi^ XpncTeov. Kai TaOTa juev br] tuj Xotuj Trape^opTicd- |uriv, IV ' eqpeHfic Kai TdXXa Td qjepovTa Trpoc Tfjv 6p- 9fiv TUJV ve'ujv dTUiTnv cuvdv|;uj.
20 12, KdKeTvo cpri)ui , beTv touc TraTbac eTTi Td KaXd tOjv eTTiTribeu|udTUJV dTeiv Trapaivececi Kai Xotoic, jufi 9 lud Aia TTXriTaTc )urib' aiKiCjuoTc. boKeT Tdp ttou toTc bouXoic TaOTtt ludXXov f| toTc eXeu9e'poic TrpeTreiv dTTOvapKuJci Tdp Kai qppiTTOuci Trpoc touc Tr6vouc, Td
25 )Liev bid Tdc dXTTlbdvac tujv TrXriTUJV, Td be koi bid Tdc Oppeic. eTTaivoi bfe kqi vijotoi Trdcric eiciv aiKiac ujqpe- XijuujTepoi ToTc eXeu9e'poic, o'i |uev eTTi Td KaXd Trap- op|uu)VTec o'i be dTTO tOuv aicxpuJv dveipTOVTec beT be evaXXdH Kai noiKiXujc xpnc9ai TaTc eTriTrXfiHeci Kai
30 ToTc eTTaivoic, KdTreibdv TTOTe 9pacuvu)VTai, TaTc eTTi-
1,31-34H. 6, 27— 29 K.
4. Koi dQAriTric*: d9AriTU)v Kai 30. 6paci)vuuvTai * :
euqppavuJVTai
20 DE LIBERIS
TrXr|5eciv ev aicxiJvr) iroieTcGai, Kai TrdXiv dvaKaXeTcBai ToTc eTTaivoic Kai |m)neTc0ai xdc TiT9dc, aiTivec eTrei- bdv Td TTaibia KXauBjuupicuuciv, eic TrapriYopiav tov jLiacTov UTTexouci. beT be ciutouc iuribe toTc eYKuu|Liioic iTTaipeiv Kai qpucfiv • x«^voOvTai Ydp TaTc uTrep^oXaTc 5 Tujv ^Traivuuv Kai GpuTTTOVTai.
B 13. "Hbri be Tivac ey\h eibov Tratepac, oic t6 Xiav cpiXeTv toO juf) qpiXeTv aiTiov KaTecTr). Ti ouv ecTiv o pouXo)iiai XeYeiv; iva to» TrapabeiYMOtTi qpuuTei- v6Tepov TTOiricuu tov Xoyov. crreubovTec Ydp touc lo TraTbac ev Traci Tdxiov TtpuuTeOcai tt6vouc auToTc uTrep- lueTpouc eTTipdXXouciv, oic dTraubuuvTec dKTriTTTOuci, Kai - dXXuuc papuvojaevoi TaTc KaKOTraGeiaic ou be'xovTai Tf]v |ud9riciv euTiviuuc. ujCTrep Ydp td q>ma toTc |uev laeTpioic libaci TpecpeTai, toTc be ttoXXoTc TrviYeTai, tov i5 auTov Tpdrrov ipuxf) toTc fi^v cu|U|ueTpoic auEcTai Tr6-
Cvoic, ToTc b' urrepPdXXouci parrTiZieTai. boTeov ouv ToTc Traiciv dvaTrvofiv tuDv cuvexuuv Trdvuuv, ev9u|iOu- ju^vouc OTi Trac 6 pioc fi)uujv eic dveciv Kai crroubfiv birjpHTai. Kai bid toOto ou |u6vov eYpriYOpcic dXXd 20 Ka\ UTTVoc €upe9ri, oube Tr6Xe)uoc dXXd Kai eipnvri, oube x^iMiJ^v dXXd Kai eubia, oube evepYOi rrpdHeic dXXd Kai lopTai. cuveX6vTi be eirreTv f) dvdTraucic Tuuv tt6vuuv ecTiv dpTU|ua. Kai ouk eTTi tujv 2tbuuv |u6vuuv toOt' dv xboi tic Yiv6|uevov, dXXd Kai eTTi tuuv 25 dvpuxujv • Kai Ydp Td T6Ha Kai Tdc Xupac dvie|uev, 'iva eTTiTeTvai buvr|9uj|uev. Ka96Xou be cujZieTai cuujua Mev Ivbeia Kai TrXripuucei , HJuxfi be dvecei Kai Trdvuj. d£iov
Db' emTiMav tuuv rraTepujv evioic, oiTivec TraibaYUUYoTc Kai bibacKdXoic ^TriTpeqjavTec touc uieTc aCiTOi Tfjc 30
1,34— 35 H. 6, 29— 31 E.
3. TrapriYopiav*: TrapriYopiav udXiv
EDUCANDIS 21
TOUTUJV jaaenceujc out€ aiiTOTTTai YwovTai t6 TcapdTrav ouTe auTTiKOOi, TrXeicTov toO beovTOc d|uapTdvovTec. autouc Tdp Tiap' oXiTac fi)ie'pac bei boKifiaciav \a)i- pdveiv TuJv TTaibujv, dXXd }ir] Tdc eXTribac exeiv ev
5 jiicGujToO bia6e'c€V Kai ydp ^KeTvoi TtXeiova ttoiiicov- Tai Trjv eTTijLi€'Xeiav tujv Traibujv, jueXXovTec ^KdcTOTe bibovai Tdc eu9uvac. KdvTauGa bx] t6 pnQtv utto tou iTTTTOKoiiOu x«pi£V) '^^ oubev outuj TTiaivei t6v ittttov ujc paciXeujc 6(p0aX|Lt6c. TrdvTuiv be jiidXiCTa Tfjv |Livr|-
10 |iT^v Tiuv Traibujv dcKeiv Kai cuve9iZeiv • auTri ^dp E u)CTT€p TTic TTaibeiac dcTi TajiieTov, Kai bid toOto iuri- Tepa Tujv Mouciliv e|au9oX6Yricav eivai ttjv MvriMOCu- vr|v, aiviTTdjuevoi Kai TrapabriXoOvTec oti outujc oubev rfiv TTaibeiav T€vvav Kai Tpe'(peiv ujc f] ^vr\iir] rrecpuKe.
15 Kai Toivuv TauTriv k^t' d)uqp6Tepa dcKrjTeov, eiTe ^k qpuceujc Mvr|)uovec eiev oi Traibec , eiTC Kai TOuvavTiov €TTiXric|iovec. ttiv Tdp TtXeoveEiav Tfjc tpuceujc emp- pu)co|uev, Tfjv b' eXXeivpiv dvaTTXripuucojuev Kai o'i juev Tujv dXXujv ecovTai peXTiouc, o'i b' ^auTuiv. t6 Tdp
20 'Hci6b€iov KaXujc eipriTai
'ei Tdp Kev Kai c)uiKp6v eTTi cjuiKpuj KaTa9eTo Kai 9a)ad to09' epboic, Tdxa k€V |ueTa Kai p t6 TevoiTO.' \xr\ Xav0av€TUj Toivuv luri^e toOto touc uaTcpac, 6ti
25 t6 |uvrmoviK6v Tfic |ua9ficeujc |uepoc ou )u6vov Trp6c Tfjv TTaibeiav dXXd Kai TTp6c Tdc toO piou TrpdSeic ouk eXaxicTriv cu)ipdXXeTai )uoTpav. f] fap tujv T€Tevri)U€'- vujv TTpdHeujv )uvii|uti Tfic Trepi tujv jueXXovTUJV eupou- Xiac TiveTai TTapdbeiTM«-
J , 3E— 36 H. 6, 31—32 R.
7. t6 f)r\Qiv] Xenoph. Oecon, XII 20 14. Tfjv Ttai6eiav adiecit W 20. 'Hci66eiov] 0. et D. 361
22 DE LIBEIilS
14, Kai luevTOi Kai tfic aicxpoXoYiac dTTaKT^ov Touc uieTc" '\6toc y«P epTOu CKif]' KaTct ArnuoKpi- 10 Tov. CTi ye infiv evTeuKTiKOuc auTOuc eivai Ttapa- CK€uacT€OV Kai cpiXoTTpooiTopouc" oubev TOP WJC TCl dvevTeuKTtt tujv ti6div ecTiv outujc dEiOjjicTiTOV. eTi 5 Toivuv 01 TTaibec d)iiceTc TiTvoiVT' av toTc cuvoOci )Lif) TTavTeXuJc ev TaTc 2[riTficeciv diTapaxujpriTOi tiTvo- luevor ou Tdp t6 viKctv m6vov dXXd Kai t6 fjTTdceai eTTicTacGai KaX6v iv olc t6 viKdv pXapepov. ecTi Tdp ibc dXnQuJc Kai viKr| Kab)Lieia. exuJ be )idpTupa tou- lo Tujv €upiTTibr|V t6v co{p6v e7TaTaT€'c6ai XeTOVTa
B 'buoTv X€t6vtoiv, eaTe'pou eu)uou)ievou ,
6 \xr] dvTiTeivujv toTc Xotoic coqpiuTepoc.' 8 Toivuv Tuiv eipriiuevujv oubev fJTTOv dXXd Kai ^dX- Xov eTTiTribeuTe'a tdTc veoic Kai br] XeKTe'ov. TaOTa be i'> ecTi t6 t6v piov dTucpujTov dcKcTv, t6 xf\v TXOuTTav KaTe'xeiv, t6 Tfic opTfic uTTepdvw TiTveceai, t6 tOuv XeipuJv KpaTeTv. toutujv CKacTov fiXiKOv ecTi CKe- TiTeov • ^cTai bk im TrapabeiTiudTUJV TVUjpi^aiuTepa. oiov iva dTT6 Tou TeXeuTaiou ttpujtov dpEuj)aai, Tdc 20 XeTpdc Tivec uttocxovtcc Xf||U)aaciv dbiKOic t^v boEav Tuiv TTpopepiuJiuevujv eEexeav. ujc fuXiTTTToc 6 AaK€-
C bai)u6vioc Td caKKia tuiv xPl^dTUJV rrapaXucac q)UTdc dTTi-|Xder| Tfjc CTTdpTr|C. to Te )nfiv d^pTn^ov dvbpoc ecTi coqpoO. CujKpdTric )uev Tdp, XaKTicavToc auT6v 2' veavicKOu epacdoc )udXa Kai pbeXupoO, touc d)acp' auT6v 6pu)V dTavaKToOvTac xai c^abdlovTac ibc Kai biouKeiv auT6v ^eeXeiv, 'dpa' ^'qpnce ^Kai ei )li€ ovoc dXttKTicev, dvTiXttKTicai toOtov riEiuJcaTe dv'; ou )uf|v
1,36— 39 H. G, 32— 34R
5. ^Ti*: elxa 12. Nauck. p. 445 14. ovbiv fiTTOv*: oubevoc fiTT6v ^CTiv 16. t6 t6v Halmius: t6v
EDUCANDIS 23
eKeivoc Y£ TravTeXOuc KaTeTipoiEaTO , TrdvTuuv be auTov oveibiZiovTujv Kai XaKTicTr)v dTiOKaXouvTUJV dnriTHaTo. 'ApicToqpdvouc bi, oTe Tdc NetpeXac eSeqpepe, Tiav- Toiujc TTdcav u^piv auToG KaTacKebavvvjvTOc, Kai tivoc
5 Tujv rrapovTUJV ' ouk df avaKTeic ' eiTrovToc * ai GijKpa- Tec Td ToiaOTa dvaKuj)LiujbouvToc ' ; 'jud Ai' oukd eYUJYe' eqpricev *ujc Ydp ev cu,uttociuj laeYdXuj tuj GedTpuj CKLUTTTOjuai.' dbeXcpd be toutoic Kai cuZ^uTa qpavricovTai TreTTOiriKOTec 'ApxuTac 6 TapavTivoc Kai
10 TTXdTOiv. o )uev Ydp eTTaveX6uJv dTTo toO TToXejuou (cTpaTriYuJv be eTUTX«ve) tHV KaTaXapdjv K6X€pcuj)ae- V11V, Tov eTTiTpoTtov KttXecac auTfic 'uj)uujHac dv' eqjr)- cev 'ei |uri Xiav ujpTiZ;6)ariv'. TTXdTUJV be bouXiu Xixvuj Kai pbeXupuj 8u)aui6eic, tov Tfjc dbeXcpfjc uiov CTreu-
15 cirrTTOv KaXecac 'toOtov' e^ricev dTreX6u)v 'pdTTicov eTUJ Tdp rrdvu 9u|ao0)uar. xoiXerrd be TaOTa Kai buc- )LU,UTiTa qpairi tic dv. oTba KdTUJ- TteipaTeov oijv eic ocov oiov Te' ecTi toutoic TrapabeiTiuaci xpuJM^vouc E t6 TToXi) Tfjc OKpaToOc Kai )Liaivo)uevric uqpaipeTv opTnc"
20 oube Tdp ec TdXXa evdjuiXXoi TaTc eKcivujv ecjuev out' euTreipiaic ouTe KaXoKaTaeiaic. dXX' oubev tittov cKei- vujV; ujCTTep 9euJv iepoqpdvTai koi baboOxoi ttic coqpiac ovTeC; ocaTrep ecTiv ev buvaTUJ, TaOTa |ui)ueTc9ai Kai TrepiKviZ^eiv eTTixeipoO|uev. t6 Toivuv Tfjc t^<J^tt*1c Kpa-
25 TeTv (Ttepi toutou Tap ; uiCTrep UTTe9e|ir|v, eiTreTv Xoi- rrov) ei tic |uiKp6v Kai qpaOXov urreiXriqpe, TTXeTcTOv bia)uapTdvei Tfjc dXri6eiac. coqpov Tdp euKaipoc ciTf) Ktti TTavTdc XoTOu KpeTTTOV. Kai bid toOto |uoi boKeT F
1,30— 40 H. ' . 6, 34— 35 R.
5 Post -irapivTUJV erat t& TotaOTO dvaKUJ.uaiboOvToc, quod transposui 8. be* 15. ^dTricov*: Kp6Tricov 25. irepi — XoiTTOv] Aut librariorum aut ipsius scriptoris socordia excidit de pitu dTuqpuuTuj disputatio snpra sipmificata p. lOE
24 DE LIBERIS
Tcic jLi^CTr|piu)beic TcXeTdc oi rcaXaioi KaT^beiHav, iva ev TauTaic ciouTTav e8ic0^VTec erri Tfjv tu»v dvGpuuTri- vujv iLiucTrjpiujv ttictiv tov dTTo tuiv GeuJv incTaqpepuj- juev cpopov. Kai tap «0 ciuiTrricac ^iev oubeic iueTe- voTice , XaXiicavTec be TTa|aTrXri6eic. Kai t6 nev citti- 5 Gev dHeirreiv pdbiov, t6 be priGev dvaXapeiv dbuvaTov. laupiouc b' etuJYe oiba dKOucac TaTc iueYicTaic cuiucpo-
11 paic TTepmecovTac bid Tfjv thc yXuOtttic dKpaciav. u)v Touc dXXouc TTapaXiTTUJV dvoc f| buoiv tuttou eve- KCV eTTi)iivric8r|C0)Liai. tou ^ap OiXabeX^ou y^IMCivtoc w Tfjv dbeX^fiv 'Apcivoriv CuJTdbric emujv
'eic oux ociriv Tpu|aaXifiv t6 KevTpov ujGeTc' ev bec)aujTr|piuj ttoXuv KaTecdTTTi xpovov Kai ttic dKaf- pou XaXidc ou jaeinTTTfiv ebuiKe biKrjv, 'iva be YcXujTa Kapdcxr) toTc dXXoic, auT6c eKXaucev. dvdjaiXXa be i5 TOUTOic Ka\ cuZiuYa Kai QeoKpiTOc 6 cocpiCTfic eme Te Kai l'TTa0e, Kai ttoXu beivoTcpa. 'AXeSdvbpou yap TTopcpupac dc0fiTac KeXeucavTOc KaTacKeudZieiv touc
B"6XXTivac, \va. eTTaveX0ujv Td eTTiviKia tou ttoX€')uou Tou KaTd Tuiv pappdpujv 0uceie, Kai tujv e0vu)V KaTd 20 KCcpaXfiv elcqpepovTuiv dpTupov 'TrpoTepov inev' ^(pri- cev 'n)Li(picPr|TOuv, vOv be rjc8ri)nar caqpuic oti 6 'rrop- (pupeoc' '0)Liripou 'SdvaTOc' outoc dcTiv*. 15 uiv ^X0p6v eKTficaTO t6v 'AXeHavbpov. 'AvTiyovov be t6v PaciXea tujv MaKebovwv dTep6qp0aX)nov ovTa Tfjv TTn- 25 pujciv TTpo(pe'pujv eic ou incTpiav opYflv KaTe'cTrice. t6v fap dpxi)LidTeipov GuTpoTriujva YeTevri)Lte'vov ev Td£ei CKTT^iavpac TrapaTevec0ai TTp6c auT6v jiSiou Kai
C XoTOV bouvai Kai XapeTv. TauTa hk dTTaTTcXXovToc
1,40— 42 H. C, 35— 37B.
13. TtoXuv — xP<^vov*: iroWoOc xP^vouc 15. aOroc*: aOTOc TtoXuv xp6vov
EDUCANDIS 25
€Keivou Ttpoc auTov Kai TToXXdKic TTpociovxoc 'eO oTba' Iqpncev 'oTi diixov ^ie GeXeic tuj KukXuuki TrapaGeivai', 6veibiZ;ujv Tiu )uev oti Ttripoc, Ttu be oti jidYeipoc fjv. KdKeivoc 'TOiTapoOv' eiTTiuv 'ttiv KecpaXf)v oux eHeic
5 dXXd Tfic dfiupocTOjiiac TauTtic Kai jiiaviac buuceic bi- Kriv' dTTriYT€iXe Td eiprmeva tlu paciXei, o be TreVu^ac dveiXe tov GeoKpiTOV. Ttapd TtdvTa be TaOTO, STtep ecTiv lepoTTpeTTecTaTov, touc Traibac eGiZeiv TdXrjGfi XeTeiv t6 tdp ipeubecBai bouXorrpeTrec Kai Trdciv dvOpuuTTOic
10 dHiov juiceTcGai Kai oube /ueTpioic bouXoic cuytvujctov.
15. TaOTa |iev ouv ouk evboidcac oube laeXXfjcacD
Ttepi Tfjc TuJv rraibujv euKOCiiiiac Kai cujqppocuvric biei-
XeTM«i' TTcpi be toO pnQncecGai jueXXovTOc djuqpiboHoc
eijai Kai bixoTVuujauJV, Kai Tfjbe KdKeice iueTaKXivuuv ujc
15 eTTi TrXdcTiTTOc TTp6c oub' eTepov pe^jai buvaiuai, tto- Xuc b' OKVOC exei )ue Kdi Tfjc eicriTnceujc Kai ttic dTTO- TpoTTfic toO TTpdTjuaToc. dTroToX|uriTe'ov b' ouv 6)iujc eiTTeiv auTo. Ti ouv toOto ecTi; rroTepa bei touc epuuvTac tuuv rraibujv edv toutoic cuveivai Kai cuvbia-
20 Tpipeiv, f| TOuvavTiov eipTeiv auTouc Kai dTTOCopeiv E Tfjc TTpoc TouTOuc 6)uiXiac TTpocfJKev. OTav )uev Ydp dTTopXe'ijjuj TTp6c Touc TTaTepac touc auGeKdcTouc Kai t6v TpoTTOv 6)LiqpaKiac Kai CTpucpvouc, o'i bid ttiv tuuv TCKVUUV OPpiV OUK dvCKTflV TfjV TUUV dpuuvTuuv 6)uiXiav
25 fiTOuvTai , euXapoOjuai TauTric eicriTriTfic TCvecBai Kai cu)upouXoc. OTttV b' au rrdXiv evGujuriGuu t6v CujKpdTn t6v TTXdTUJva t6v EevoqpuuvTa t6v Aicxivriv t6v Ke^riTa, t6v rrdvTa xop6v eKeivujv tuuv dvbpuuv o'i touc dp- pevac eboKi)uacav epujTac Kai Td jieipdKia TrpofiTaTov
30 eiTi Te Traibeiav Kai br||uaTUJTiav Kai Tf^v dpeTfiv tujv
TpOTTUIV, TTdXlV eTepOC TlVO)Uai Kai Kd)LlTTTO)Uai TTp6c 1, 42-44 H. 6, 37-39 E
26 DE LIBERIS
F Tov €K€ivuJv Tujv dvbpujv ZfiXov. juapTupei be toutoic €upi7Tibric outu) Xcywv
'dXX' ecTi hx] Tic dXXoc ev PpoToTc epujc ipuxnc biKaiac ciucppovoc Te KdYa9fic', t6 be ToO nXdTUJVoc CTTOubr) Kai xapievTic)uuj ^epn- 5 TMevov ou rrapaXei7TTe'ov. eHeivai Ydp tprici beiv toic dpiCTeucaciv 6v ctv PouXujVTai tujv KaXdiv qpiXfjcai. Touc )Liev ouv Tnc ujpac eTTiGuiuoOvTac diTeXauveiv TTpocfiKe, Touc be Tfjc vjjuxfic epacTdc eYKpiveiv KaTd t6 cuvoXov. Kai touc )aev 0f|Prici Kai touc ev "HXibi lo qjeuKTCOv epujTac Kai t6v i\ Kpf|Tr] KaXou|uevov dp-
12 TraTiuov, touc bk 'AGnvrici Kai touc ev AaKebaijuovi lr]\ujiio\.
16. nepi ^ev ouv toutujv, 6ttujc eKacTOc auT6c ^auT6v TTeiTeiKev, outujc urroXaiupaveTUJ • eYUJ b' ^TTeibf] is Tiepi Tfjc TuJv TTaibuJv euTaHiac eipriKa Ka\ KocjuioTriToc, Ktti im Tfjv Tujv /ueipaKiujv f]XiKiav fjbri lueTapficojuai Kai |uiKpd TTavTdTTaciv Xe'Euj. rroXXdKic ydp KaTe|ue|u- vjjdjuriv Touc )uox8ripu)V ^Gujv TCTOvoTac eicriTITdc, oiTivec ToTc ju^v rraici TraibaTUJTOUc Kai bibacKdXouc 20 dTTecTricav, Tfjv be tujv )ueipaKiujV opjufjv dcpeTov eia-
B cav vejueceai, beov aij TouvavTiov iTXeiu) tiLv jueipaKiujv 7T0ieTc6ai Tfjv euXdpeiav Kai qpuXaKriv f\ tu»v rraibujv. Tic Tdp ouK oibev 6ti Td juev tuiv rraibujv TTXruujueXf]- juaTa juiKpd Kai TTavTeXuic icTW idcijua, TraibaTUJTUJV 25 oXiTUjpia Kai bibacKdXujv TTapaTUJTn Kai dvriKOucTia* rd bk tOuv fibri veaviCKCuOju^vuJv dbiKfijuaTa TToXXdKic uTrepqpua TivcTai Kai cxeTXia, djueTpia TCtcTp6c Kai KXoTTai TraTpujujv xPIMdTUJv Kai Kupoi Kai kujjuoi Kai
1, 41— 46H. 6, 39— 41 E.
3. Nauck. p. 367 5. TTXcxtujvoc] Rep. V. p. 468 B 10. iv* 25. uaibaYUJYCuv*: Tia\bafvj^(jjv icujc
EDUCANDIS 27
TTOTOi Kai Trap9evujv IpujTec Kai YuvaiKUJv oiKoq)9opiai YajueTuJv. oukoOv Tctc toutujv 6p|udc TaTc eiriiueXeiaic becjLieueiv Kai KaTexeiv rrpocfiKev. diTaiuieuTOV "fdp tOliv C ilbovuJv fi dKjaf] Kai cKipTriTiKOv Kai x«XivoO be6|aevov,
5 ujc9' 01 |iri Tiic fiXiKiac TauTtic IppuJia^vujc dvTiXajuPa- v6)aevoi Tr) dvoia bib6aciv eHouciav eiri Td dbiKr||uaTa. bei Toivuv Touc ejucppovac TraTepac rrapd toutov |Lid- XiCTa Tov Kaipov (puXdTTeiv eYpriYopevai cujqppoviCeiv Touc lueipaKicKOuc bibdcKOVTac diTeiXouvTac beo]ue)uouc,
10 TTapabeiYlnaTa beiKvuvTac tOuv bid (piXrjboviav |aev cu)U(popaic TTepmecovTUJV bid be KapTcpiav CTTaivov Kai boEav dYa9fiv TTepiTTOirica,ue'vujv. buo ydp TaOTa ujcrrepei CTOixeia Tfic dpeTfic ecTiv, eXTTic Te Tijufic Kai qpopoc Ti,uu)piac" fi |uev Tdp 6p|uriTiKUJTepouc Trpoc t^d
15 KttXXiCTa Tujv eTTiTribeu)iidTUJV o be 6Kvr|pouc TTpoc Td qpauXa tijuv epYUJV dTTepYdCeTai.
17. Ka96Xou be dTTeipYeiv TtpocfiKei touc TTaibac Tfjc TTpoc Touc TTOvripouc dv9puuTT0uc cuvouciac" drro- (pepovTai Ydp ti Tf^c toutujv KaKiac. toOto be TTapfiY-
20 YeiXe Kai TTu9aY6pac aiviYluaciv ciTTep cyuj TTapa9eic e£riYf|C0|uar Kai Ydp TaOTa TTpoc dpeTfjc KTficiv cu|u- pdXXcTai poTTriv ouk eXaxicTriv. oiov ' ixx] Yev)ec9ai )ue- Xavoupujv', toOt' ecTi juf] cuvbiaTpipeiv jueXaciv dv- GpuJTTOic bid KaKof|9eiav. ')ufi ZIuyov uTTcpPaiveiv/
25 oTi bei Tfic biKaiocuvric ttXcTctov TToeTc9ai X6yov Kai e
^ifl TauTr|v uneppaiveiv. 'juf] eTTi xoiviKoc Ka9icai/
fJToi (peuYeiv dpYiav Kai TTpovoeTv ottujc ttiv dvaY-
Kaiav TTapacKCudcojuev Tpo(pf|v. 'jufi TTavTi e)updXXeiv
beSidv,' dvTi ToO TTpoxeipujc ou beT cuvaXXdcceiv. Vn
1,46— 47 H. C, 41— 42K
13. ^CTiv*: eiciv 15. 6 Huttenus: r\ 28. iTapacK€ud- co.uev*: irapacKeudcujjaev
28 DE LIBERIS
(popeiv CT€v6v baKTuXiov/ oti bei tov piov ^TriXueiv Ktti )uf| becjauj TTpocdTTTeiv auTOV. *TTup cibripa» jar) CKaXeueiv,' dvTi toO }xr\ epeGiZieiv tov 6u)nou)aevov. 'Mn ecSieiv Kapbiav/ nToi pLX) pXdTTTeiv ttiv Hiuxnv Taic qjpovTiciv auTfiv KaTaTpuxovTO. ' Kudjauuv dTrexe- s
FcGai,' oTi ou bei TToXiTeuec6ar KuajueuTai xdp fjcav ejaTTpoc6ev ai ijjricpoqpopiai bi' ujVTTep eTreTi6ecav Tdc dpxdc. 'ciTiov eic d)aiba juf) ejupdXXeiv' eTTicn- )aaivei Ydp OTi eic TTOvripdv qjuxnv dcTeiov Xotov eppdXXeiv ou TrpocfiKev. 6 iuev Tdp Xofoc Tpocpfj bia- lo voiac ^CTi* TOUTOV bk dKd6apTov f] TTOvripia Troiei TuJv dv6ptJUTTiJuv. 'nn ^TTiCTpecpec6ai ctti touc opouc eX66vTac,' toOt' ecTi )ae'XXovTac dTTo6vr|CKeiv Kai tov opov ToO piou TTXrjciov ovTa 6pujvTac cpepeiv euK6Xujc Kai )ufi d6ujaeTv. dvaKdjuvpuj be dTTi Tfjv e2 dpxfic toO is XoYOu uTT66eciv dudvTUJv ydp ^Trep ^cpriv tu)V TTOvrj- piiJv dv6puuTTUJV dTrdYeiv bei touc Traibac, judXiCTa be
13 TU)v KoXdKUJV. OTrep Tdp TToXXdKic Kai TTp6c ttoXXouc Tiuv TTaTe'pujv biaTeXu) Xexujv, Kai vOv Sv eiTroi)ui. Ye'voc oubev ^ctiv eHujXecTepov oube )udXXov xai 6aT- 20 Tov eKTpaxriXi2[ov ve^TrjTa tujv KoXdKUJV, o'i koi touc TTaTe'pac Kai touc Traibac TrpoppiZiouc dKTpipouci, tuiv juev TO Y*lP«c eTTiXuTTOV, Tuuv be TfjV ve^TTjTa * * Troi- oOvTec, Tuuv be cu)aPouXeu|udTUJV beXeap dcpuXaKTOv TTpoTeivovTec Tfjv fibovfjv. Toic Traici tOuv ttXouciujv 25 01 TTOTepec vfjcpeiv Trapaivouciv o'i be )ae6ueiv, cujcppo- veiv o'i be dceXTaiveiv, cpuXdTTeiv o'i be baTravdv, cpi-
],47— 49H. 6, 42— 44 R
1. ^TTiXOeiv*: ^TtixribeOeiv 2. Kai ]jLf]*: koI jaf] 6eiv 3, Tov eujLioujuevov*: oO Ydp -rrpocfiKev dW' OireiKeiv toTc bp~{\Zo- jLidvoic 4. fixoi accessit ex Mantissa Prov. apud Leutschium Yol. 2. p.760 7. iDvTrep direTiGecav Tctc dpxoic*: uiv -rrepac lire- TiSecav Toic dpxaic 23. * *] ^iroveibiCTov supplet Schneiderus
EDUCANDIS 29
XepTeiv o'i be pa9u)LieTv, ' CTiT|uri xpovou ttcic ecTiv 6 B ^ioc' XetovTec. 'Z!nv oO 7TapaZ;f|v TrpocrjKei. ti be (ppovTiCTe'ov fifjiv tujv toO rraTpoc dTreiXujv; Kpovo- Xripoc Kai copobai|uujv ecTi, Kai jueTeujpov auTOV dpd-
5 )nevoi TTiv TaxicTTiv eHoico)nev.' Ka0f|Ke be tic Kai XajuaiTUTTTiv Kai TtporiTUJYeuce Ya|ueTr|V, Kai Td tujv TTaTepujv eqpobia toO THPWJC ecuXr|ce Kai TrepieKOipe. jniapov t6 qpOXov, uTTOKpiTai cpiXiac, dYeucTOi Ttappri- ciac, TtXouciujv |uev KoXaKcc TtevriTujv be uTtepoTTTai,
10 ibc eK XupiKHC Te'xvric dTti touc veouc dYOjuevoi , ce- cripoTec 60' oi TpeqpovTec YeXujci, Kai mjuxhc uTTOpo- Xiiaaia Kai v69a |Liepr| piou , Trpoc be t6 tuuv ttXou- c ciujv veO|ua 2uJVTec, Tfj tuxti |iev eXeu9epoi, Tfj rrpo- aipecei be boOXor OTav be JLifi v^pilixjvTai , TOTe Oppi-
15 Z;ec9ai boKoOvTec, 6ti indTriv TTapaTpeqpovTai. ujct€ ei TLU )ue'Xei Tujv TraTepaiv Tfic tujv t€kvujv euaYUJYictc, dKbiujKT€'ov Td )Liucapd TaOTa 9peju)LiaTa, eKbiujKTeov b' oux fiKiCTa Ktti Tdc Tujv cu)aq)OiTr)TUJV )uox9ripiac' Kai Ydp oijToi Tdc eTTi€iK€CTdTac (puceic iKavoi biaqp9eipeiv
20 eici.
18. TaOTa |jev ouv KaXd Kai cu)Liq)e'povTa " d be jLieXXuj XeYeiv, dv9pu)TTiva. oube Ydp aij TrdXiv touc TraTepac eYUJYe dHiuj TeXeujc Tpaxeic Kai CKXripouc eivai D Tfiv qpuciv, dXXd noXXaxoO Kai cuYX^Pflcai Tiva tlu
25 v€UJTe'puj TUJV d)LiapTr||udTujv, Kai lauTouc dva)Lii)Livf|- CKeiv oTi dYevovTo veoi. Kai Ka9dTTep laTpoi Td m- Kpd TUJV. qpap)idKUJV toTc yXukcci x^MoTc KaTajuiYVuv- T€C Tfjv TepiiJiv €Tfi t6 cu)uqp€pov TTdpobov eijpov, ouTUJ beT Touc TTaT€'pac ttiv tujv eTriTijuri|udTUJV dTTOTo-
30 juiav Tf) TTpaoTriTi juiYVuvai, Kai TOTe juev TaTc eTTi- 9u)uiaic Tujv Ttaibujv eqpeTvai Kai x^tXdcai Tdc fjviac,
1, 49-51 H. 6, 44— 45 B.
30 DE LIBERIS
TOie h' au TrotXiv dvTiTeivai, Kai judXiCTa |a^v euKO- E Xujc q)€peiv tcic d|uapTiac, ei be ixy] •(€, Ttpoc Kaipov opTicBevTac Taxeujc drroqpXeYiufivai. iuaXXov ydp oHu- 8u|iov eivai bei tov iraTepa r| papu0u|Liov, wc t6 fe buciuevec Kai bucKaTdXXaKTOv )LiicoT€Kviac ou juiKpov 5 TeKjuripiov ecTi. KaXov bk Kai evia tcuv d|uapTri)udTUJV juri^e eibevai boKeiv, dXXd t6 toO fHpiwc d)upXud)TTOv Ktti bucKtucpov em Td fiTV^iueva |ueTa(pe'peiv, ujc evia TUJV TTpaTTOjuevuJV opuJVTac )uri opdv Kai dKOuovTac |ufi dKOueiv. qjiXuJv d)iapTr|juaTa cpe'po)uev ti GauiuacTOV lo ei TeKVUJV, bouXujv TtoXXdKic KpaiiraXcjOvTUJV )ue0r|v ouK eSnXeTHaiuev **. eqjeicuj TroTe, dXXd Kai xopn- Tncov nTttvdKTricdc TTOTe, dXXd Kai cuttvuj0i. epou- F K6XTice TTOTe bi ' oiKeTOu • ttiv opTriv KaTdcxec. eE dTpoO TTOTe ZeOTOc dcpeiXeTo, rjXOe ttot€ \Qilf\c )ue0ric 15 dTT0TTve'ujv , dTVoncov luupujv oZiujv, ciTHCOV. outuj CKipTuJca veoTTic TTUjXobajuveTTai.
19. TTeipaT€'ov be touc tuiv fibovujv tittouc Kai Trpoc Tdc eTTiTiiuriceic bucTiK6ouc twmhj KaTaZieOHai, be- C)u6c Tdp ouTOc Tfic ve6Tr|TOC dccpaXecTaToc. eTT^d- 20 c0ai be bei toTc uieci T^vaTKac ixryie euTevecTepac TToXXuj )uriTe TrXouciuiT^pac- to Tdp 'ttiv KaTd cauTOV eXa' coq)6v. ujc 01 t^ )uaKpuj KpeiTTOuc eauTwv Xa)u- pdvovTCC ou Tujv T^vaiKUJV dvbpec, tuiv be TrpoiKuJv
14 boOXoi Xav0dvouci TiTv6|uevoi. 23
20. Bpaxea be TTpoc0eic en TrepiTpdHJUJ Tdc urro- 0riKac. Trpo TrdvTUJV Tdp beT touc TTaTcpac tuj )UTibev d)uapTdv€iv dXXd TrdvTa d bei TTpdTTeiv evapTec eau- Touc TTapdbeiTlua toTc tckvoic Trapexeiv, iva rrpoc tov
T0UTU)V Piov UJCTrep KdTOTTTpOV dTTOpXeTTOVTCC dTTOTpe- '0 1,51— 53 H. 6, 15— 47 R.
12. Hiatum significavi 14. KaTctcxec EmiDerius: Kaxdcxe
EDUCANDIS 31
THjuvTai TuJv aicxpujv epYUJV Kai \6yujv. ujc oiTivec ToTc djuapTdvouciv uioTc eTTiTijuujVTec toTc auToTc d|uap- THiuaci rrepirriTTTOuciv, em tuj eKeivwv 6v6|naTi \av- Gdvouciv eauTUJV Ka-friYopoi YiTVojuevoi, t6 b' 6\ov
5 (pau\ujc 2iuvTec oube toTc bou\oic rrappriciav dxouciv eTTiTiiuav, juri ti ^e toTc uioTc. X^AJPic be toutujv fi- B voivTO dv auToTc tOuv dbiKrnudTujv cu|upou\oi Kai bibd- CKa\oi. OTTOu Tdp TepovTec eiciv dvaicxuvTOi, ev- Tau6' dvdTKri koi ve'ouc dvaibecTdTOuc eivai. TTeipa-
10 Teov ouv eic t6v tujv tckvujv cujq)povic|u6v trdvO' oca TrpocfiKev eTTiTribeueiv, Z:ri\iJjcavTac €upubiKr|V; fiTic 'IWupic ouca Kai Tpipdppapoc, 6|uujc eTTi Trj |aa0r|ce.^ TU)V TeKVUJV 6i|je Tfic fi\iKiac fiqjaTO Traibeiac. iKavoic be auTfjc Triv (pi\oTeKviav crijuaivei TOUTTiTpaiujua , OTrep
15 dveGriKe Moucaic
€upubiKri MepaTTo\ifiTic Tovb' dveGriKe
Moucaic euiCTOv \\)v\f] eXouca Tr60ov. C
Tpd|U|uaTa -fdp juviMeici \6tujv lurjTnp TCTCiuTa TTaibuJv fipuuvTUJV eSeTT6vr|ce |Lia0eTv.
20 TO |uev ouv Trdcac Tdc TTpoeipiiiuevac cu|UTrepi\apeTv TTapaiveceic Tuxnc icujc epYov ecTi • t6 be Tdc TT\eiouc ^ri\iJJcai Kai auTo |uev eujuoipiac b€6|uev6v ecTi Kai TToWfjc eTTi|ue\eiac , dvucTov b' ouv dv0pujTTivri qpucei Ka0ecTriKev.
1,53— 54 H. G,47-48E.
8. OTTOuj Plat. Legg. p. 729 C 21. Tuxnc*: eOxnc
D nJlS AEI
TON NEON nOIHMAT^N
A K O T E I N.
1. €i |Li^v, ujc OiXoEevoc 6 TTOiriTfic eXcYev, (h MdpKe CribaTe, tujv KpeuJv tci ^r\ Kpea fibicTd ecTi koi tujv
E ixQuuJV 01 |Lif| ixQuec, dKeivoic dTToqpaivecGai TTapujjiev olc 6 KdTUJV Iqjri Tfjc Kapbiac Tfjv uTrepujav euaic9r|- TOT^pav uTTdpxeiv. oti bk tujv iv qpiXococpia XeYoiu^- s vujv o\ ccp6bpa vdoi toic i^n boKoOci qpiXocoqpujc |nr|b' dTTO CTTOubfic X^Tec9ai xaipouci laaXXov Kai TTopexouciv uTTTiKOOuc dauTOuc Kai xeipor|9eic, bfjXov ^tiv fiiaiv. ou Tdp Movov Td AicUuTTeia |uu9dp(a Kai Tdc ttoihti- Kdc uTTo9eceic dXXd Kai tov "Apapiv tov 'HpaKXeibou lo Kai Tov AuKUJva tov 'ApicTUJVoc bi€px6)nevoi Kai Td Trepi TU)V liJuxuJv boTMCiTa laeiuiTM^va |iu9oXoTia |Lie9'
F fjbovfic lv9ouciujci. bio bei |afi laovov dv Taic Trepi dbujbfiv Kai TTociv fibovaic biaqpuXdTTeiv eucxniaovac auTouc, ^Ti bi jidXXov dv TaTc dKpodceciv Kai dva- 15 Tvujceciv ^9iZ;eiv, ujCTrep 6v|jqj xpwpiivovc laeTpiujc tuj TepTTOVTi, t6 xpilciMOV dTT* auToO Kai t6 cujTfjpiov
I, 55— 56H. 6, 49-60B.
2. Cn6aTe Basileensis: cnSaTre 11. xai ante xi adie- cit W.
QUOMODO ADOLESC. POETAS AUDIRE DEBEAT 33
biiuKeiv. 0UT6 Yctp TToXiv ai KeKXeijuevai TtuXai rripoO- civ dvdXoiTov, dv bid ju>dc irapabeEriTai touc rroXe- luiouc, ouTC veov ai irepi Tdc dXXac fjbovdc eYKpdTeiai cujZIouciv, dv Y£ ^i' OKOfic Xd9r) irpoejLievoc auTOV, 15
5dXX' ocov judXXov avxx] tou qppoveiv Kal XoYi2ec9ai TTecpuKOTOc aTTTeTai, TOCOUTO jufiXXov d|ueXri9eica cp9ei- pei Ktti pXdrrTei tov rrapabeHdjuevov. errei toivuv out' icujc buvaTov ecTiv out' ujcpeXi|uov rroirijudTuuv dTreip- Yeiv Tov Tr)XiKOuTOv fjXiKoc oujuoc t6 t6 vOv CuuKXa-
10 poc lcTi Kai 6 coc KXeavbpoc , eu judXa TrapacpuXdT- Tuujuev auTouc, ujc ev TaTc dvaYVuuceci juaXXov f| TaTc oboTc TtaibaYUJYiac b60)ue'vouc. drrep ouv ejuoi Trepl TTOirijudTUJV eirreTv ttpujtiv eTTnX9e, vOv rrpoc ce Y^YpaM* jueva Trejuijjai bievor|9nv. Kai Xapdjv TauTa bieX9e, Kdv B
15 boKri coi juribev eivai qpauXoTepa tujv d|ue9ucTUJv Ka- Xoujue'vujv, d Tivec ev toTc ttotoic TrepidTTTOVTai Kai TrpocXajupdvouci , jueTabibou tuj KXedvbpuj Kai TTpo- KaTaXdjupave Tfjv qpuciv auToO bid t6 juribajuoO vuj- 9p6v dXXd TravTaxoO cqpobp6v Kai bebopKOC euaYuj-
20 YOTe'pav utto tOuv toioutuuv oucav.
'TTOuXuTToboc KeqpaXfi evi juev KaK6v ev be Kai
ec9X6v,' OTi Ppuj9fivai judv lcTiv fibiCTOC, bucoveipov b' uttvov IjuTTOieT, qpavTttciac TapaxiObeic Kai dXXoKOTOuc bexo-
25 juevov, lijc XeYOuciv. outuj br\ Kai TTOiriTiKr] ttoXu juev C t6 fibu Kai Tpoqpijuov ve'ou vpuxfic evecTiv, ouk eXaT- Tov be t6 TTapdcpopov Kai TapaKTiKOV, dv juf) TUYXdvi;] TTaibaYUJYiac 6p9fic f) dKpoacic. ou Ydp |u6vov ujc eoiKe TTepi Tfjc Aiyutttiujv x^P«c dXXd Kai Trepi Tfic
30 TTOiriTiKf|c ^CTiv eiTTeTv oti
1, 5G— 58H. 6, 50— 52 E.
17. irpocXaiupdvouci Stephamis: TrpoXajLipdvouci
Plutarchi Moralia Vol. I. 3
34 QUOMODO ADOLESCENS
cpdpjLiaKa TToWa |uev ecGXd laeiaifiLieva TroWd be
XuYpd' ToTc xpuJMCVOic dvabibuaciv.
'^v9' evi }xkv qpiXoiric, ev b' ijuepoc, ev b' 6apiCTuc irdpqpacic, fi t' ^KXeijje voov iruKa uep cppoveovTUJV.' 5 ou Tdp dKTCTai t6 dTtaTriXov auTnc dpeXTe'pijuv ko-
D luibn Kai dvoriTUJV. 5i6 Kai Ciiaujvibric }Jikv drreKpivaTO TTpoc Tov eiTTOVTa *Ti br| |Li6vouc ouK ^HaTTaTdc 0eT- TaXouc'; ' d)aa0e'cTepoi Tdp eiciv f| u)C utt' e|Liou eHa- TTaTdcGai'. fopTiac be ttiv TpaTiybiav emev dTrdTriv, lo nv o t' dnaTricac biKai6Tepoc toO }xr] dTTaTrjcavTOC Ktti 6 dTraTriGeic coqpOuTepoc tou |Liri dTraTr|0evTOc. TTOTepov ouv Tujv vcujv ujCTTep TUJV ' l6aKriciujv ckXtipuj Tivi Td tuTa Kai dTeTKTiu Kripuj KaTaTrXdccovTec dva^- KdZ;uj|Li€v auTOuc to '€TTiKoupeiov dKdTiov dpajLievouc i5 TTOirjTiKriv qpeuTeiv Kai TrapeHeXauveiv, fi ladXXov 6p0tD Tivi XoTiC)auJ TrepiCTeXXovTec Kai KaTabouvTec ttiv Kpi- civ, OTTUJC iufi TTapaqpe'priTai tu» t€'pttovti ttp6c t6 pXd- TTTOV, dTT€u6uvuj)Li€v Kai TTapaqpuXdTTUJjaev ',
E ' oub^ Tdp oub^ ApuavToc ui6c KpaT€p6c AuKOopToc ' 20 \3TiaivovTa voOv eTx€v, oti ttoXXOuv |i€6ucK0|ne'vuJV Kai TTapoivouvTUJv Tdc diuTTeXouc TTepuujv eHeKOTTTev dvTi ToO Tdc Kprivac eTTUTepuj TTpocdT€iv Kai ' |Liaiv6|u€vov ' 0€6v, ijuc qpriciv 6 TTXdTUJV, ' ^Te'puj 0€uj vnqpovTi KoXa- Z!6)Lievov' cujcppoviZeiv. dqpaipei Tdp rj Kpdcic toO 25 oivou t6 pXdTTTOV, ou cuvavaipoOca t6 xPn^il^ov. iLirib' fiiaeic ouv Triv Troir|TiKf|v f||U€piba tujv Moucuuv
1,58— 60 H. 6, 52— 53 R
1. Homer. b 230 4. Id. = 216 13. CKXnpi?' Meh-
lerus: KrjpLp 17. TiepicT^WovTec*: irepicTdvTec 20. Ho- luer. Z 130 23. -irpocdYeiv*: TrpocaYaYeiv 24. TTXdTUJv] Legg. VL p. 773 D
POETAS AUDIRE DEBEAT 35
eKKOTTTUujLiev jUTib' d(pavi2!uj|Liev , dW ottou \ik\ iiqp'F f]bovfic dKpdiou TTpoc boHav auGabujc Opacuvoinevov ilv^pilei KoX uXojuavei t6 iuuGujbec auTfjc Kai GeaTpi- Kov, dTTiXa|Lipav6|U€voi KoXouu)|uev Kai TTieZiujjuev • ottou
5b' ctTTTeTai Tivoc luoucric Trj xdpiTi Kai t6 yXuku toO XoYOu Kai dxujYOV ouk dKapTTOv ecTiv oube Kevov, evTauGa qpiXocoqpiav eicdYU))aev Kai KaTamtvuujjuev. ujCTTep Tdp 6 luavbpaYopac Taic djUTTeXoic TTapaqpuo- luevoc Kai biabibouc Tfjv buvaiuiv eic t6v oTvov |ua-
10 XaKUJTepav rroiei ttiv KaTacpopdv toic ttivouciv, outuj Touc XoYOuc fi TTOiricic ^K qpiXocoqpiac dvaXajupdvouca )uiTVU|uevouc Trpoc t6 juuGuJbec eXaqppdv Kai TrpocqpiXfi TTape'xei toic ve'oic Tfiv judGriciv. 60ev ou qpeuKTeov ecTi Td TT0if|)uaTa toTc qpiXocoqpeiv lueXXouciv, dXXd
15 TTpoqpiXocoqpr|Te'ov toic TToifijuaci e0iZ!o|uevouc ev tuj 16 TepTTovTi t6 xPnci|uov JriTeiv Kai dYaTrav ei be |ufi, bia|adxec0ai Kai bucxepaiveiv. dpxn Tdp auTr) Trai- beuceujc.
' epTOU be TravT^c fiv tic dpxnTai KaXujc,
20 Kai Tdc TeXeuTdc eiKoc ecO' outujc ixew' KaTd t6v CoqpOKXea.
2. TTpuJTov |uev ouv eicdTeiv eic Td uoifijuaTa bel t6v ve'ov ^Tibev outuj |U€|aeXeTr])uevov exovTa Kai rrpo- Xeipov ujc t6 'TToXXd qjeubovTai doiboi' Td |uev ^kov-
25 Tec Td b' dKOVTec. dKovTec |ue'v, oti rrpoc fibovf]v dKofic Kai xdpiv, ^v ol ttX€ictoi biujKOuciv, aucTripo- Tcpav f]TOuvTai Tfjv dXfi0€iav toO njeubouc. ti |uev B Tdp epTLU TiTvo^evri, Kdv dTepTTec exr) t6 TeXoc, ouk eHicTaTar t6 be TrXaTTOiuevov Xotuj pdcTa TTapaxuupei
30 Kai TpeTTCTai TTp6c t6 fibiov eK toO XuttoOvtoc. ouTe
1,C0— 61H. 6, 53— 55 B
19. Nauck. p. 246 24. Aristot. Metaph. I
3*
36 QUOMODO ADOLESCENS
Yotp ju^Tpov ouTe TpoTTOc 0UT6 XeEeujc oykoc out' eiiKaipia laeTacpopac ou9' dpiaovia Kai cuv9ecic ^x^x tocoOtov ai)LiuXiac Kai x«PiT0C ocov eu TreTrXeYiuevri bid9ecic fau9o\oTiac, dXX' aicTrep ev YpaqpaTc kivt]- TiKuuTepov ecTi xpuJMOt TP«MMnc bid t6 dvbpeiKeXov Kai s dTTaTiiXov, ouTUJC ev Tioiriiaaci |ie)aiT)uevov Tn9avdTriTi C HJeuboc eKTrXrjTTei Kai dTaTraTai (aaXXov Tfjc d)uu9ou Kai dTtXdcTou Ttepi iiidTpov Kal XeEiv KaTacKeufic. 69€v 6 CujKpdTrjc ^K Tivujv ^vuTTviuJV TTOir)TiKfic dvtjd|Lievoc auToc laev, ctTe br| tcTOVujc dXri9eiac dTujviCTr|c tov lo dTTavTa piov, ou Tri9av6c fjv oub' euqpufic ipeubuuv briiaioupTdc, touc b' AicuiTrou |nu9ouc eTreciv evcTeivev, ujc TToiriciv ouK oucav y} vpeOboc ^r\ TrpocecTi. 9uciac fiev Tdp dxopouc Kai dvauXouc icjaev, ouk icjuev b' d)Liu9ov oub' dijjeubfi TToinciv. Td b' 'G^aTTeboKXeouc is ^TTr) Kai TTap)aevibou Kai 9ripiaKd NiKdvbpou Kai tvuj- lnoXoTiai OeoTViboc Xotoi eici Kixpd|i€Voi rrapd rroiriTi-
DKfic ujcirep oxniLia t6 laeTpov Kai t6v otkov, iva t6 TTeZ;6v biaqpuTUJCiv. 6Tav ouv dTorrov ti Kai bucxepec ev ToTc Trojriiuaci Xe^THTai Trepi 9€uJv f) bai)i6vujv f\ 20 dpcTfic utt' dvbp6c eXXoTi^ou Kai boEav exovTOC, 6 |Liev ujc dXri9fi TTpocbeHd)Lievoc X6tov oixeTai qpep6)Lievoc Kai bie(p9apTai thv boEav, o be |ue|Livrmevoc dei Kal Ka- Texujv dvapTUJC Tf^c rroiriTiKfic Tfjv rrepi t6 vjjeOboc YoriTciav Kai buvdjaevoc XeTeiv ^KdcTOTC Trp6c auTr|V 25
*uj larixdvriMa Xutk6c aioXu>T€pov,' Ti TTttiZouca Tdc oqppOc cuvdTeic, Ti b' eEaTTaTijuca
ETrpocTTOieT bibdcKeiv; oub^v rreiceTai beivdv oube m-
1,61-C3H. 6, 55-57B
12. |LHJ9ouc ?TTeciv ^v^reivev*: roTc ^Treci |uu9ouc iv6- laiZev 17. Kixp(i|Lievoi Madvigius: KexpnH^voi 26. Nauck. p. 694 Xutk6c idem: Xutt^c
POETAS AUDIRE DEBEAT 37
cieucei qpaOXov, dX\' ^TTiXrmjeiai jiev toO (poPoujnevou Tov TToceibuJva Kai Tap^oOvTOc jur) Tfiv yfiv dvappnHri Kai dTroTUMViOcr] tov "Aibriv, eTTiXrm;eTai be toO tuj 'AttoXXujvi xcXeTTaivovToc uTrep toO rrpuuTOu TuJv 6 'Axaiujv,
*6v auToc ujuvujv auTOC ev baiTri TTapuuv auToc Tdb' eiTrujv auTOC ecTiv 6 KTavuuv/ TTauceTOi be tov 96it6v 'AxiXXea Kai tov 'ATa|ne')ivova Tov Ka6' "Aibou baKpuujv, dbuvdTouc Kai dc6eveic xei- 10 pac eTTiGujuiqi toO ^nv opeYOVTac. av be ttou cuvTa- pdTTr|Tai Toic TTd6eci Kai KpaTfiTai qpap)Liacc6|uevoc, ouK oKvricei Trp6c eauT6v eiTTeiv
'dXXd qpoujcbe TdxicTa XiXaieo" TauTa be TrdvTa
ic6', iva Kai |ueT6TTic6e Teri eiTTric6a xuvaiKi.' P
15 Kai Ydp toOto xctpicvTUJC "0)uriPOC eic ttiv veKuiav
eTirev, lijc TuvaiK6c dKpoaciv oucav bid t6 |uu6ujbec.
TomOTa ^dp ecTiv a TrXdTTOUciv CKOVTec oi TroiriTai*
TrXeiova b' d juf] TrXdTTOVTec dXX' oi6|uevoi Kai boEd-
2ovTec auToi TTpocavaxpuuvvuvTai t6 vpeOboc f)|aiv.
20 oiov erri toO Ai6c eipriKOTOc 'Ojufjpou
'ev b' ^Ti6ei buo Kfipe TavnXeYeoc 6avdToio, 17 THV |uev 'AxiXXfioc Tfiv b' "Gktopoc iTTTrobd|uoio, eXKe be juecca XaPuuv • perre b' "£KTopoc aici|uov
f^ap,
25 (iJxeTO b' eic 'Aibao , XiTiev be i Ooipoc 'AttoXXujv '
Tpafiubiav 6 AicxuXoc 6Xr|v tuj |uu6uj Trepie6riKev, eTri-
TpdHjac YuxocTaciav Kai TTapacTf|cac Taic TrXdcTiTHi
ToO Aioc ev6ev )aev Tfjv GeTiv ev6ev be Tfiv 'Huj,
1,63— 65 H. 6, 57— 59 E.
1. ToO G. Hermanus: auToO 3. toO adiecit idem 6. Nauck. p. 83 13. Homer. X 222 20. '0|ufipou] X 63 26. AkxuXoc] Nauck. p. 69.
38 QUOMODO ADOLESCENS
beo)uevac utt^p tluv uieiuv laaxoiaevujv. toOto be TTavTi bf]\ov, OTi )iu9oTroiri|ua Kai TrXdc|Lia Trpoc fjbovfiv f\ ^KTTXriHiv dKpoaToO Y^TOve. t6 bd B 'Zeuc, 6c t' dv9pw7TUJV Tajuiric TToXeiiOio T^TUKTai' Kai t6 5
'9e6c pikv aiTiav cpuei PpoToTc,
6Tav KaKiJucai bujjua TTajUTTribriv 9^Xri,' TaOTa b' r\br] KaTd boHav eipriTai Kai ttictiv auTuJv, fiv ^'xouciv dTrdTriv Trepi 9eu)v Kai dyvoiav eic fijLiac CKcpepovTUJV Kal jueTabibovTUJv. TTdXiv at rrepi Tdc i^ veKuiac TepaToupYiai Kai bia9^ceic ovojuaci qpopepoTc dvbriiuioupYoOcai (pdc)aaTa Kai eibujXa TroTajuujv qpXe- Yojuevujv Kai tottujv dYpiujv Kai KoXacjudTUJv cku- ^pujTTUiv ou TTdvu TToXXouc biaXav9dvouciv oti t6 juu- C 9d)bec auToTc ttoXu Kai t6 vpeOboc ujcTrep Tpo(paTc t6 is (papjuaKuJbec ^YxeKpaTai. Kai ou9' "Ojuripoc ouTe TTiv- bapoc ouTe CocpoKXfic TTeTTeicjuevoi TaOTa exeiv outujc CYpavjjav
'^'v96v t6v dTTeipov dpeuYovTai ckotov
pXrixpoi bvoq)epac vukt6c TTOTajuoi' 20
Kai
'TTdp b' icav 'QKeavoO Te podc Kai AeuKdba TreTpiiv' Kai
'CTevujTToc "Aibou Kai naXippoia Pu9o0.' ocoi juevTOi t6v 9dvaTov uuc oiKTp6v f\ xr\v dTaq)iav £5 ujc beiv6v dXoqpupojuevoi Kai bebiOTec qpujvdc eHevrj- voxaci
'jur| |u* aKXaucTOv d9aTTT0v iiJbv 6TTi9ev KaTa-
Xeirceiv'
1,65— 66 H. 6, 59-GOB.
4. Homer. A 84 6. Nauck. p. 39 19. Bergk. Piu- dari Fr. 107 (95) 22. Homer. uj 11 24. Nauck. p. 240 28. Homer. \ 72
I
POETAS AUDIRE DEBEAT. 39
Kai
'ipuxn b' €K pe6€ujv TTTafi^vri 'Aibocbe pepr|Kei, 6v TTOTiaov Tooujca, XittoOc' dbpoTriTa Kal fiPriv'D xai 5 'juri fi' dTToXecTic duupov f\b\} tdp t6 q)ujc
Xeucceiv Td b' urro fr\v \iy\ |u' ibeiv dvaYKdcric', auTai TreTTOveoTUJV eici Kai TtpoeaXujKOTUJV utto boHric Kai dTTdTTic. bio judXXov arrTOVTai Kai biaTapdTTOuciv fi|udc, dvaTTijuTTXa^evouc tou rrdGouc Kai t^c dcOeveiac 10 dcp' f|C XeTOVTai. rrpoc TaOTa br\ TrdXiv TTapacKCudZiuj- )nev euGuc eH dpxfic ^xeiv IvauXov oti TTOiriTiKfi )Ltev ou TTdvu jueXov ecTi Tfic dXriGeiac, f] be Trepi TaOTa dXfiGeia Kai toic laribev dXXo TTeTTOiriJuevoic epTOV f\ Tvujciv Kai indericiv toO ovtoc eu indXa bucefipaTOC E 15 ecTi Ktti bucXriTTTOC, ujc ojuoXoToOciv auToi. Kai Td '€jLiTTeboKXeouc ecTUJ rrpoxeipa TauTi
'out' eTTibepKTd Tdb ' dvbpdciv out' drTaKOucTd ouTe vouj rrepiXriTrTd ' Ktti Td Eevocpdvouc 20 'Kai t6 |iev ouv caqpec outic dvfip TeveT' oube
TIC ^Tttl
eibujc djucpi eeuJv Te Kai dcca XeTUj Trepi TTdvTuiv ' Ktti vf) Aia Td CujKpdTOuc eEo|uvu|ievou TTapd TTXd- Tujvi Tfjv TTepi TOUTUJV Tvuiciv. fiTTOv Tttp ujc eiboci F
25 Tl TTepi TOUTUJV TTpOCeHOUCl TOTc TTOlTlTaiC €V oTc TOUC
9iXoc6(pouc iXiTTiuJVTac 6pujciv.
3. "Gti be luaXXov emcTfico|Liev auT6v d|Lia tlu TTpocdTeiv TOic Troifjiuaciv UTTOTpdqpovTec Tfjv TTOirjTiKfiv
1, 66-C8H. 6, 60— 62 K.
2. Hom. rr 856. X 362 5. Eurip. Iph. A. 1218. 16. 'Eja- iTe6oK\eouc] Karsten. Philos. Gr. Rel. vol. 3. p. 90 Tauxi*: TOUTi oOtujc 19. Eevoqpdvouc] Karsten. vol. 1. p. 51
40 QUOMODO ADOLESCENS
6ti iuijLiTiTiKri texvri Kai buvaiuic icxw dvTiCTpoq)oc Trj Zuu- Ypatpiqi. Kai jar) jitovov ^KeTvo t6 epuXouju^vov dKr]Koibc lcTiu, Z;(juYpaq)iav |Liev eTvai qpGeYTOMevriv Trjv TToir|Civ, TToiriciv be ciTUJcav jriv Z^uuYpaqpiav, dXXd Trpoc toutuj 18 bibdcKuujaev auTov oti YSTpajLilnevriv caOpav y] TTi6r|K0V 5 f\ GepciTOu TTpocouTTOV ibovTec fibojueGa Kai 0aujadZ!o- jLiev oux ujc KaXov dXX' ibc ojaoiov. oucia jaev Ydp ou buvttTai KaXov Yevec0ai t6 aicxpov • f) be nijuricic, dv Te TT€pi qpauXov dv Te nepi xpictov ecpiKrjTai Tfic 6noi6Tri- Toc, eTTaiveiTai. Kai TOuvavTiov dv aicxpoO cuujaaTOC el- lo Kdva KaXfjv TTapdcxri , t6 ttpcttov Kai t6 eiK6c ouk dne- buuKev. Ypdcpouci be Kai TTpdEeic dTOTTOuc evioi, Ka0d- Tiep TijLiojLiaxoc Triv Mnbeiac TeKVOKTOviav Kai Oetuv Triv 'Op^CTOu juriTpoKTOviav Kai TTappdcioc Tfjv 'Obucceuuc
B TTpocTTOiriTOv juavittv Kai Xaipecpdvric dKoXdcTouc ojui- is Xiac YuvaiKuuv TTp6c dvbpac. ev oic judXicTa bei t6v veov d0iZec0ai, bibacKOjuevov 6ti Tfjv TrpdHiv ouk CTTaivoOjuev fjc Y^Yovev f) juijuricic, dXXd Tfjv Texvriv ei |ue)ui|uriTai TTpocriKOVTuuc t6 uTroKeijuevov. eTTei Toi- vuv Kai TTOiriTiKH TToXXdKic epYa cpaOXa Kai TTd0r| 20 juox0ripd Ka\ fi0ri juijuriTiKuuc drraYYeXXei, bei t6 0au|ua- Z;6|uevov ev toutoic Kai KaTop0ou|uevov jufiT' dTrobexe- c0ai t6v v^ov ibc dXri0ec juf|Te boKijudZeiv ubc KaXov, dXX' eTTaivew |u6vov ibc evapjuoTTOV tuj uTTOKeijueviu TTpocuuTTiu Kai oiKeTov. ujcrrep Ydp u6c pofiv Kai v|>6- 25
C qpov TpoxiXiac Kai TTveujudTuuv poiZov Kai 0aXdTTric KTUTTov dKOuovTec lvoxXou|ue0a Kai bucxepaivojuev, dv be Tic ui0avuuc TauTa fuijufiTai, Ka0dTTep TTap|uevuuv Tfiv uv Kal Oeobujpoc Tdc TpoxiXiac, fib6)ue0a, Kai vocuubri |u^v dv0puuTTov Kai uttouXov ujc dTepTTCC 0^a|ua 30 q)euYO|U€v, t6v b' 'ApiCToq)U)VTOC <I>iXoKTfiTriv Kai Tfiv
1,68-69H. 6, 62-63 B.
POETAS AUDIRE DEBEAT 41
CiXaviujvoc MoKdcTriv Ojuoiouc (pGivouci Kai dTroGvn- CKOuci 7T6Troiri)iievouc opujviec x«ipo)Lt€v, outuuc 6 ve'oc dvaYiYvuucKUJV d GepciTric 6 tc^wtottoioc f\ Cicuqpoc 6 (p06poc r\ BdTpaxoc 6 TTopvopocKOc \e'YU)v r\ irpdT-
o Tujv ireTToiriTai , bibacKecGuj Tfiv Mijuou|uevTiv TaOTa bu- d va,uiv Kai Texvrjv eTraiveiv, ac be biaGeceic Kai TTpd- Heic miaeiTai Kai TTpopdXXecGai Kai KaKiZleiv. ou xdp ecTi TauTO t6 KaXov ti Kai KaXujc ti )ai)ueic9ai. KaXuJc xdp ecTi t6 TTpeTTOVTUJC Kai oiKeiujc, oiKcTa bk Kai
10 TTpeTTOVTa ToTc aicxpoTc Td aicxpd. Kai Ydp ai Aa- |iu)viba Tou x^Xou KpriTTTbec, dc dTToXecac euxcTO toTc ToO KXevpavToc evap)u6cai ttoci, qjaOXai iuev ficav^ eKeivuj b' Tip)i0TT0v. Kai t6
'emep xdp dbiKeiv XP^I» Tupavviboc TTe'pi 15 KdXXicTOV dbiKeTv' Kai t6 E
'toO jaev biKaiou Tfjv boKriciv dpvuco, Td b' epYa toO ttSv bpujVTOc ^vGa KepbaveTc* Kai 20 'TdXavTOV f) TTpoiH. ixr\ Xd^uj; Zfiv b' ecTi |lioi TdXavTOV uTTepibdvTi; T€uHo|uai b' uttvou TTpoe')U€VOc ; ou biucuj be Kdv "Aibou biKrjV ujc iicepriKUJC eic TdXavTOv dpTupoOv; |uox6tiPoi M^v eici X6toi Kai lyeubeTc , 'CTCOKXeT be Kai 25 'fHiovi Kai TOKOTXuqpuj TrpecpuTr] TrpeTTOVTec. dv oijv uTTO|ai)uvf|CKUJ)uev touc rraTbac oti TaOTa ouk eTraivouv- T€c oub^ boKi|udZ;ovTec dXX' ujc dTOTra Kai cpaOXa F
1,69— 71 H. 6, 63— 65 B.
1. o.uoiouc Reiskius: 6moiujc 5. qpedpoc*: qpGopeOc
8. t6 KttXov Ti*: KaXov Ti vel t6 KaXov 14. Eurip. Phoen. 524 17. Nauck. p. 652 20, Meinek. lY. p. 668
42 QUOMODO ADOLESCENS
q)a\j\oic Kal dtTOTTOic fi9eci Kai ttpocijOttoic 7T€piTi6ev- Tec YPatpouciv, ouk av uiro xf\c boHric pXdTTTOivTO
TUJV TTOiriTlUV. dXXd TOUVaVTlOV f] TTpOC t6 TrpOCUUTTOV
UTTOvpia biapdXXei Kai t6 TTpaxiua Kai tov Xotov, dic cpaOXov UTTO q)auXou Kai XeYOjuevov Kai rrpaTTOiuevov. s oiov ecTi Kai t6 Tfic cuYKOi|ur|cea)c toO TTdpiboc eK Tfjc M«Xnc dTTobpdvTOC. oubeva Ydp dXXov dvGpuu- TTOV fi)Lie'pac cuYKOi)iU))Lievov YuvaiKi TTOiricac f) t6v dKoXacTov Kai |lioixik6v ev aicxuvr) bfjXdc ecTi Kai ipoYUj Ti6ejLievoc Tfjv ToiauTr|v dKpaciav. w
19 4. 'Gv bk TouToic eu |udXa TrpoceKTeov ei Tivac 6 TTOiriTric auT6c ^jaqjdceic bibujci KaTd tuuv XeYO)aevujv ujc bucxepaivo)uevuJv utt' auToO. Ka6dTTep 6 Mevav- bpoc ev Tu> TTpoXoYUJ Tfic 0aiboc TreTToiriKev
*e)Lioi luev ouv deibe ToiauTriv, 6ed, i5
epaceiav ujpaiav be Kai TTi6avfiv djia, dbiKoOcav dKOKXeioucav aiToOcav TTUKvd, |Lir|b€v6c epiDcav, TrpocTTOiou)ie'vriv b' dei.' B dpiCTa b ' "0|Liripoc tlu Ycvei toutuj KCXpriTai • Kai Yap TrpobmpdXXei Td qjaOXa Kai TTpocuvicTrici Td XP^CTd 20 TUiv XeYOjuevujv. TrpocuvicTrici )Liev outujc
^auTiKa lueiXixiov Kai K€pbaXe'ov q)dTO )li06ov' Kai
'Tovb' dYavoic eTT^ecciv epriTucacKC TTapacTdc'. ^v bk TU) TTpobiapdXXeiv luovovou juapTupeTai Kai bia- 25 YOpeuei ^r\xe xpnceai ^ifiTe Trpocexeiv ujc oijciv dTO- TTOic Kai qjauXoic. oiov tov t' 'AYa|U€')uvova )ueXXuJV biriYeiceai tuj lepei xP^J^^uevov dTrnvuJc rrpoeipriKev
1,71— 72 H. 6, 65-66 R.
7. fivSpuiTTOv W: dvGpuuiTujv 15. Meinek. IV. p. 131 22. Homer. Z 148 24. Id. B 189
POETAS AUDIRE DEDEAT 43
'dW OUK 'ATpeibr] 'ATttM^ILivovi fivbave GujLiLij, dWd KaKUuc dcpiei', toOt' ecTiv dYpiuuc Kai auGabujc Kai irapd t6 TTpocfi- c Kov Tip t' 'AxiXXei Touc Gpaceic Xoyouc TrepiTiericiv 6 ' oivopapec, kuvoc 6|ii)aaT' exujv, Kpabinv b' ^Xdqpoio ' Tfiv auTOu Kpiciv UTTeiTrujv
'TTriXeibric b' eHauTic oTapTripoic e7Te'ecciv 'ATpeibnv Trpoceeine, Kai ou ttiju XfiYe xoXoio.* KaX6v Ydp eiKOc oubev eivai |li€t' 6pYfic Kai aucTripujc 10 XeYOfievov. 6|uoiujc Kai eTTi twv TTpdHeujv
'fj pa, Kai "€KTopa biov deiKea iuribeTO 1'pYa, TTprivea Trdp Xexeecci MevoiTidbao Tavuccac' D eij be Kai T.aTc eTrippriceci XPHfai, KaBdTrep Tivd ipfj- qpov ibiav dTTi(pe'puJv toic TTpaTTOjuevoic fi XeYO|ievoic, 15 eTTi ju^v Tfic jioixeiac tou "Apeoc touc 6eoijc ttoiujv XeYOVTac
'ouK dpeTtt KaKd epYa- Kixdvei toi Ppabuc ujkuv,' eTTi be Tfjc toO "€ktopoc uTTepqppocuvrjC Kai jueYa- Xauxiac 20 ''ajc ecpaT' euxojuevoc, ve|uecrice be TroTVia "Hprj,' £TTi be Tfjc TTavbdpou ToEeiac
'(juc cpdT' "AOrjvairi, tuj hk (ppdvac dqppovi TTeT0ev.' auTtti |Liev oijv ai tujv Xoyujv dTToqpdceic Kai boHaiE TTavToc eici KaTibeTv toO TrpocexovTOC eTcpac b' ck 25 Tujv TTpaYndTuuv auTUJV TTapexouci |ua6f|ceic, ujCTrep 6 eOpiTribTic eiTTeTv XeYeTai TTp6c touc tov iSiova Xoi- bopouvTac ujc dcepfj Kai juiapov, ' ou pevTOi TrpoTepov
1, 72— 73H, 6, C7-68K.
1. Homer. A 24 5. Id. A 225 7. Id. A 223 11. Id. V 24 17. Id, e 329 20. Id. 0 198 22. Id. A 104 26, eupm16ric] Nauck. p, 389
44 QUUMODO ADOLESCENS
auTOV EK Tfic CKnvfic ilr\fayo\ f| tuj Tpoxo» Trpocr|Xa)- cai'. TTapa b' '0)ir|pLu ciiu7TuVev6v ^cti t6 toioOto Yevoc Tfic bibacKaXiac, ^xov b* dvaGeiupriciv 0)9^X1- laov in\ tujv biapepXrmevujv ladXicTa )au6ujv, oDc toTc TTdXai ^iev UTiovoiaic dXXriYopiaic bk vuv XeYO)i^vaic 5 F TtapapiaZ;6|ievoi Kai biacTpeqpovTec evioi jiOixeuoM^vriv qpaciv 'A<ppobiTriv urr' "Apeoc Mrjvueiv "HXiov, oti tuj THC 'A(ppobiTric dcT^pi cuveXGibv 6 toO "Apeoc ^ioixi- Kdc dTTOTeXei tev^ceic, 'HXiou b' dTTavaqpepoiiievou Kai KaTaXa)ipdvovTOC ou Xav0dvouciv. tov be Tfic 10 "Hpac KaXXujTTic)i6v ^tti t6v Aia Kai Tdc rrepi t6v KecT6v YoriTeiac d^poc Tivd Kd9apciv eivai pouXovTai
TU» TTUpUjbei TTXr|CldZ:0VT0C, UJCTTep OUK auToO Tdc Xu-
ceic ToO TTOiriToO bibovTOC. ev ^kv fdp toTc nepi ttic 'AqppobiTTic bibdcKei touc Trpoc^xovTac oti )LiouciKf| 15 qpauXr) Kai ac)iaTa TTOvripd Kai Xotoi )iox6r|pdc utto- Geceic Xa^ipdvovTec dKoXacTa ttoiouciv fi0ri Kai piouc 20 dvdvbpouc Kal dvGpiurrouc Tpuqpfjv Kai )iaXaKiav Kal TuvaiKOKpaTiav dxaTTOuvTac
^eifxaja t' IHrifioipd XoeTpd tc Gepnd Kai euvdc*. m bi6 Kai t6v 'Obuccea tuj Ki0apujbiij TTpocTdrrovTa TTerroiriKev
'dXX' dye bf| jueTdpriQi Kal iTtTTOU K6c)i0v deicov', KttXuuc uqpriYOU)ievoc t6 TTapd tujv qppovi)uiujv Kai voOv ^XOVTUJV XPnvai Xa)ipdveiv touc )iouciKOuc Kai TTOiri- 25 TiKouc Tdc uTTO0^ceic. dv bk ToTc TTepi Tfjc "Hpac B dpicTa Tfjv dTT6 qpap)idKUJV Kai YoriTeiac Kai ineTd bo- Xou TTp6c Touc dvbpac 6|iiXiav Kai x«Piv ebeiEev ou |Li6vov ^qpfijiepov Kai dvpiKOpov Kai dpePaiov oijcav,
1,73— -4 H. 6,68—701
12. Tivct*: Tivac 19. •fuvaiKOKpoTiav Meziriacus: Yuvai KOKpaciav 20. Hom. 9 249 23. Id. 9 492 *
POETAS AUDIRE DEBEAT 45
dXXa Kai ineTapdXXoucav eic exOpav Kai opYriv, orav Tci Tfic fibovfic dTT0|uapav9rj. TOiauTa Yap o Zeuc dTreiXei Kai XeT€i rrpdc auTr|v
'oqppa ibrjc fjv toi xP«icM1 cpiXoTric Te Kai euvf|,
5 f^v ejuiTric ^X9o0ca Oeuiv diTO Kai |li' dTtdTricac'. fi Yttp Tujv qpauXuJV bidOecic epYUJV Kai juijuricic Sv TTpocaTTobuj Tfjv cu|upaivoucav aicxuvriv Kai pXdPnv ToTc epYacaiaevoic, lijqpeXricev ouk epXaijje tov dKpo- Oujuevov. 01 YoOv qpiXocoqpoi TTapabeiYjiaci xP"JVTai,
10 vou9eTo0vT€c Kai TtaibeuovTec e? uTroKei)uevujv • oi be C TToiriTai TaOTa rroioOci TiXdTTOVTec auTOi rrpdYMCtTa Kai luuOoXoYoOvTec. 6 |uev ouv MeXdvOioc eiTe Ttai- Ivjv eiTe CTTOubdZiuJV eXeYe biacujZiecOai Tfiv 'AOrivaiujv TToXiv UTTO Tfic Tujv priTopujv bixocTaciac Kai Tapaxfic'
15 ou Yoip dTTOKXiveiv aTTavTac eic tov auTOV toTxov, dXXd YiYvecOai Tiva toO pXdTTTOVTOc dvOoXKf)v iv Tfi biaqpopa tujv TroXiTeuojuevuuv. ai be tujv uoiriTOJV UTTevavTiuOceic TTpoc auTouc dvTavaqpepoucai Tfiv rricTiv ouK euJciv icxupdv poTrfjV Ycvec9ai TTpoc t6 pXdrrTOv-
20 oTTOu |uev ouv auToTc t6 Ti9evai cuveYYuc eKqpaveTc TTOiei Tdc dvTiXoYiac, beT tijj peXTiovi cuvriYopeTv
UJCTTep ev TOUTOIC
'ttoXX', oi TeKvov, cqpdXXouciv dvOpuurrouc Oeoi'. i> *t6 pacTov eirrac, aiTiacacOai Oeouc'. 25 Kai TrdXiv
'XPucoO ce TTXf|9ei, Toucbe b' ou xaipeiv xpeuuv*.
'cKaiov t6 TrXouTeTv KdXXo |uribev eibevai' Ktti
'Ti bfiTa 9ueiv beT ce KaT9avou^evov'; \so 'd|ueivov oubeic KdjuaToc euce^eTv 9eouc.'
l, 74-76 H. 6, 70— 71 R.
4. Hom. 0 32 23.Nauck.p.345 27. t6 Stobaeus Flor.93, 7 (Nauck. p. 542): Ye 29. Nauck, p, 694 eOeiv Cobetus: oOciv
46 QUOMODO ADOLESCENS
xa fdp TOiaOTa Tdc Xuceic exei TrpobriXouc, ctv, ujcirep eipriTai, 7Tp6c Td peXTiova Trj Kpicei toOc v€'ouc KttT- • euGuvuujiev. oca b' eipriTai )Liev dTOTruiC euGuc b' E ou XeXuTai , TaOTa bei toic dXXaxoGi Trpoc TOUvavTiov elpriM^voic utt' auToiv dvTavaipeiv, |uri dxQojuevouc tuj 5 TtoiriTrj }ir\i)k xa^CTtaivovTac dXX' iv fjGei Kai |ueTd Traibidc TTpocq)epo|u^vouc. eu6uc, ei ^ouXei, Trpoc Tdc '0)Lir|piKdc TULiv Geuov piipeic utt' dXXriXuuv Kai Tpujceic utt' dv9pu)TTuuv Kai biaqpopdc Kai xctXeTTOTriTac
'oTcGa Kai dXXov |iO0ov diueivova ToObe voficai' lo Ktti voeTc vfi Aia Xotouc KpeiTTOvac dXXax66i Kai peX-
TlOVaC TUJV TOIOUTUJV
'6eoi peia Ivjovxec* Ktti
'tuj ^vi T^pTTOVTai ludKapec 0eoi fijLiaTa rrdvTa' i5 Kai F *ujc Ydp eTT€KXujcavTO 0eoi beiXoTci PpoToTci,
ZuOeiv dxvu|uevoic* auTOi bi t' dKtib^ec eiciv'. auTai fdp elciv uTiaivoucai nepi 0eujv boHai Kai dXri- 0eTc, eKeTva be TTeTrXacTai Trpoc ^KrrXriHiv dv6pujTTUJV. 20 TtdXiv €upiTTibou XexovTOC 21 ^TToXXaTci juopqjaTc 01 0eoi cocpiciiidTUJV
cqpdXXouciv fijuac KpeiTTOvec TreqpuKOTec' 01) xeTpov ecTiv urreveYKeTv t6
*ei 0eoi ti bpujci qpaOXov, ouk eiciv 0eoi', 25
PeXTiov eipriiLi^vov utt' auToO. Kai toO TTivbdpou cqpo- bpa TTiKpojc Kai TTapoHuvTiKuuc eipriK^TOc ;
1,76— 77 H. 6, 71-73R,j
7. Tipocqpepoiuevouc*: \eYO)u^vouc 10. Hom. H 358 11. j \6youc — ToiouTUJV*: Kai X^y^ic KpeiTXOv dXXaxoGi Kai pdX- Tiov Tct TOiaOxa 13. Homer. Z 138 15. Id. Z 46 17, Id. Q 525 22. Nauck, p. 519 25, Id.. p. 355
POETAS AUDIRE DEBEAT 47
'XP^l ^^ TToiv epbovi' djLtaupujcai tov ixQpov', a\y auToc Te cu X^tcic 6ti 'to Trdp biKttv tXuku TTiKpoTdTa iiievei TeXeuTd', 5 Kai Tou Co(poK\e'ouc
't6 Ke'pboc fibu, Kdv dTTo ipeubujv dr]% m\ jLiriv coO t' dKrjKoaiuev ujc
'ouK eHdTouci KapTtov oi lyeubeic XoTOi*. fTpoc b' CKeTva Td Trepi toO ttXoutou B
10 'beivoc Tdp epTTeiv ttXoutoc ec Te TdpaTa Kai TTpoc Td paTd Kai TroGev TTevric dvrip oub' ^VTuxuJV buvaiT' dv iLv epci Tuxeiv. Kai Tdp buceibk cwixa Kai bucuuvu)iiov TXuOccr) coqpov Ti6riciv eu|Liopcp6v t' ibeiv* 15 dvTiTrapa0r|cei TToXXd tOuv CocpoKXeouc, uiv Kai laOTd ecTi
'TcvoiTO Kdv dTTXouTOc EV TijaaTc dvrip'
Kai
■M Kttl
*oubev KaKiuiv tttujx^c, ei KaXuic cppovoT
'dXXd TU)V TToXXujv KaXuiv Tic x«Pic, ei KaK6pouXoc qppovTic eKTpe'qpei tov euaiujva uXoOtov*-; 6 be Mevavbpoc eTTfipe \xkv d)neXei ttiv cpiXriboviav Kai 25 uTrexauvujce toTc epujTiKoTc Kai bianupoic eKeivoic
1,76— 77 H. 6, 73— 74 B.
1. Isthm. IV 48 3. Isthm. VII 47 6. Nauck. p. 246 ir) Brunckius 8. Nauck. p, 118 10. Id. p. 118 gc Stobaeus Flor. 91, 27: Trp^c 11. Koi oniGev] x^b-aoQev
Stobaeus 17. Nauck. p. 247. 19. Id. p. 247 21 Id. p. 207
48 QUOMODO ADOLESCENS
'a7Tav9' oca 2rj Kai tov fiXiov pXerrei Tov Koivov fi|uiv, boOXa TaOT' ec9' fjbovfic'. TrdXiv b' eTTecTpeipe Kai TTepiecTrace Trpoc t6 KaXov fiiaac Kai Trjv 9pacOTr|Ta Tfic diKoXaciac eEeKOvpev eiTnOv '6veiboc aicxpoc pioc 6)liujc Kav fibuc ^'. 5
DTaOTa Totp eKeivoic |Liev ecTiv UTrevavTia, peXTio) be Kai xPnciMuOTepa. buoTv ouv 9dTepov f] ToiauTri tujv dvavTiuuv TTOiricei TTapd9ecic Kai KaTavoricic, f) TrapdHei TTpoc t6 peXTiov f| Kai toO xeipovoc dTT0CTr|cei Tfjv TTicTiv. av b* auTOi fifi bibujci Tojv dTOTTUJc eiprme'- lo vujv Xuceic, ou x^ipov ecTiv eTe'pujv evboEujv dTToqpd- ceic dvTiTdTTOVTac ujcttcp eTTi ZIuyoO peTreiv TTpoc t6 P^Xtiov. oiov ToO 'AXeEiboc kivoOvtoc eviouc oTav
*Tdc f]bovdc bei cuXXeYeiv t6v cuu(ppova. is
Tpeic b' eiciv ai y£ Tf]v buvajuiv KeKTri|uevai E Tfiv ujc dXr)9ujc cuvTeXoOcav tuj piuj,
t6 (paTeiv t6 TTieTv t6 Tfic 'AcppobiTric TUYxdveiv. xd b' dXXa Trpoc9r|Kac ctTravTa XPH KaXeTv',
UTTO)ivricTe'ov oti CujKpdTric TOuvavTiov eXeYe, touc fiev 20 (pauXouc lr\v toO ec9ieiv Kai Triveiv eveKa, toijc b' dYa9ouc ec9ieiv Kai Triveiv eveKa toO Zfiv. Trpoc be t6v YpdvpavTa 'ttoti t6v TT0vr|p6v ouk dxpr|CT0v ottXov d TTOvripia', TpoTrov Tivd cuveSo|aoio0c9ai KeXeuovTa ToTc TTOvripoTc, t6 tou AiOYevouc TrapapaXeTv ecTiv 25 F epujTri9eic Ydp ottujc dv tic djiuvaiTO t6v ^x^pov, *auT6c' 4'qpri 'KaXoc KdYa96c Yev6)Lievoc'. beT be tuj AioYevei Kai TTp6c tov Co(poKXe'a xp^icac^ar TToXXdc
1, 79-80 H. 6, 74— 76 E.
1 Meinek. IV. p. 266 5. Id. IV. p. 282 15. Id. III. p. 518. 18. t6 qjoYeTv t6 Trieiv* (445 F): t6 ineiv t6 qpoYeiv
POETAS AUDIRE DEBEAT 49
Yotp dvOpujTTUuv luupidbac e)LtiTeTTXriK€V dGu)uiac Trepi TU)V iuucTripiuuv TaOTa YpdijJac
'ujc TpicoXpioi K£ivoi PpoTuJv, o'i TauTtt bepxOe'vTec Te'Xr| 5 jLioXujc' ec "Aibou' ToTcbe Ydp luovoic eKei l\]v ecTi, Toic b' dXXoici TTdvT' CKei KaKd'.
Ai0Y€'vric 5' dKOUcac ti toiouto *ti XeYeic'; eqprj. *KpeiTTOva juoipav eSei TTaTaiKiuiV 6 KXerrTric dTroGa- vdiv fi '€TTa|U€ivu)vbac oti |ae)LiuriTai ; ' TijaoGe'uj |Liev Ydp 22
10 dbovTi Triv "ApTejaiv ev tlu GedTpuj |uaivdba Gudba (poipdba Xuccdba Kivr|ciac euGuc dvTeqpujvrice ''toi- auTri coi GuYdTrip ycvoito'. xo^P^^v be Kai t6 toO Biujvoc Tipoc Tov GeoYViv Xe'Y0VTa
'Ttdc Ydp dvrip Trevir] beb)ai-]|uevoc ouTe ti eiTTeiv
15 ouG' epgai buvaTai, Y^uJcca be oi bebeTai'
'rrujc ouv cu TTevnc luv qpXuapeic TOcauTa Kai KaTtt- boX€CxeTc fijuujv ' ;
5. AeT be )uribe Tdc €k tujv TrapaKeijuevujv rj cuja- B qppaZioiaevujv TrapaXiTreTv dqpop)udc rrpoc thv eTravop-
20 Gujciv, dXX' ujCTrep oi laTpoi Tfjc KavGapiboc oucrjc Ga- vacijuou Touc TTobac ojuujc Kai Td TTTepd PoriGeTv oiovTai Kai dvaXueiv Tfiv buvaiuiv, outuic ev toTc rroir|)uaci, Kdv ovojua kSv pfjjua TrapaK€i)uevov d)upXuTepav TTOirj Tfiv Trpoc t6 X£ipov dTraYUJYriv, eTTiXa.updvecGai Kai
25 TrpocbiacaqpeTv, ujc eTTi toutujv evioi ttoioOci
'toOto vu ttou Yepotc ecTiv oiZ^upoTci PpoToTci, KeipacGai Te Ko/ii-jv paXe'eiv t' dTr6 bdKpu TTapeiuuv' Kai
1,80— 82 H. 6, 76— 78 R.
3. Naiick. p. 247 14. Theogn. 177 22. Post 60va.uw videtur excidisse toO <papjadKou 26. Homer. 6 197 Plutarchi Moralia. Tol. I. 4
50 QUOMODO ADOLESCEINS
'luc Yap eTTeKXiucavTO Geoi beiXoici PpoToici, ruueiv dxvu|uevoic'.
C ou *fdp ctTrXuJc eiTie Trdciv dvGpuJTTOic utto Geujv eTTi- KeKXuJceai XuTTripov pioV; dXXd toTc dqppoci Kai dvori- TOic, ouc beiXaiouc Ktti oiKTpouc bid )aoxOr|piav SvTac 5 eiujGe 'beiXouc' Kai 'oiZiupoijc' TTpocaYopeueiv.
6. "AXXoc Toivuv TpOTToc ecTi Tdc ev toTc Troir|- juaciv uTTOvpiac Trpoc t6 ^eXTiov ^k toO x^ipovoc jue- GicTdc 6 bid Tuuv 6vo|udTUJV Tfjc cuvnOeiac, Trepi 8v bei t6v veov YeTU)uvdc0ai iudXXov fi TTepi Tdc Xcyo- lo jLi^vac YXuJTTac. eKeivo )iev fdp qpiXoXoYOV, Kai ouk dribec oTi 'piYebavoc' KaKoGdvaToc ecTiv eibevar 'bdvov' Ydp MaKebovec t6v GdvaTOV KaXoOci, 'Ka)u- )aoviriv' be viKriv AioXeTc Trjv eS eTTi)Liovf]C Kai KapTe- piac, ApuoTTec be 'ttottouc' touc baijuovac. touti is
Db' dvaYKaTov Kai xpnci)iiov, ei )ueXXo|uev ck tujv TTOir)- )udTUJV d)cpeXri0ric€c9ai Kai juf) pXapf|cec0ai, t6 yitvuj- CKeiv TTuJc ToTc TUiv Geuiv 6v6)iaciv oi TTOiriTai XP^J^JV- Tai Kai TTdXiv toTc tuuv KaKUJV Kai dYaOuJv, Kai Ti Tf|v Tuxriv Kai Triv MoTpav vooOvtcc 6vo|udZ:ouci , Kai tto- 20 Tepov TaOTa tujv dTTXujc fj tujv TToXXaxuJc XeY0)uevujv ecTi TTap' auToTc, uJCTrep dXXa TToXXd. Kai Ydp 'oTkov' ttot^ )uev ttiv okiav KaXoOciv
'oTkov ec 0i|j6pocpov' TTOTe be TTiv ouciav
'ec0ieTai )uoi oTkoc,* Ktti ' pioTov ' TTOTe |uev t6 Zfiv
1,82— 84 H. 6,78—793
1. Homer. Q 525 3. eiTre*: eiTte Kai 16. iueXXojaev Madvigius: |a^\\oi,uev 24. Hom. e 42 26. Id. 6 318 27. Kai*: Koi Tov 6ioTOV W: piov
POETAS AUDIfiE DEBEAT 51
*d)Lievr|vujcev be oi aixiiinv KuavoxaiTa rToceibduuv, pioioio jueTiipac' TTOie be id xpilM«Ta
'pioTOV he |uoi dXXoi ebouci', 5 Kai TLu '^ dXueiv ' rroTe inev dvTi toO baKvecGai xai dTTOpekOai KexpnTai
'u)c e(pa9', rj b' dXuouc' drrePriceTO, TeipeTO b'
aivOuc' TTOTe b' dvTi ToO YOiupidv Kai xaipeiv 10 "'n dXueic oTi 'Ipov evkricac tov dXriTnv'; Kai Tuj 'GodZieiv' f| t6 KiveicGai criiuaivouciv, ujc Gupmibric
'Kf|TOC GodCov eH 'ATXavTiKnc dXoc', f| t6 Ka0eZ;ec9ai Kai Gadcceiv, dic CoOokXtic 15 'Tivac tt69' ebpac Tdcbe |uoi 9odZ;eT€ F
iKTripioic KXdboiciv eHecT€,u)uevoi ' ; Xdpiev be Kai t6 Triv xptictv tujv 6vo|udTUJV cuvoi- Keiouv ToTc uTroKei)Lievoic TrpdYluaciv, ujc oi YPOMMaTiKoi bibdcKouciv, dXXriv TTp6c dXXa buvajuiv Xaiupavov- 20 Tujv, olov ecTi
'vfj' oXiYriv aiveiv, laeYdXr) b' ivi qpopTia 9e'c9ai'. Tuj \xkv Ydp ' aiveiv ' crmaiveTai to eTTaiveiv , auTUj be TLU eTTaiveiv dvTi toO TTapaiTeic9ai vGv Ke'xpriTai, Ka- 9dTTep ev tt| cuvri9eia 'KaXuic' cpajuev 'exeiv' Kai 25'xaipeiv' KeXeuo)uev, OTav ijlx] b€uj)U€9a jurjbe Xa)upd- vujiuev. ouTUJ be Kai Tfiv 'dTTaivfjv rTepcecpoveiav ' 23 evioi qpaciv u)C TTapaiTTiTfiv eipfjc^ai. TauTr|v bx] Tfjv
l,8-i-8GH. 6, 79-80 R.
1. Hom. N 562 4. Id. v 419 7. Id. € 352 10. Id. c 332 392 13. Nauck. p. 523 15. 0. T. 2 21. Hesiod. 0. et D. 643
4* ■
52 QUOMODO ADOLESCENS
biaipeciv Kai bidKpiciv tujv 6vo|adTUJV ev toTc |Li€i2oci Kai CTTOubaiOTepoc TrapacpuXdTTOvTec dTto tuuv GeCuv Apxiu|ue6a bibdcKeiv touc veouc oti xPLuvTai toic tiuv 6eu)V ovojuaciv oi TroiriTai TiOTe )uev auTUJV tKelvuJv eqparrTdjuevoi tvi evvoia, iroTe be buvdjueic Tivdc wv s 01 6eoi boTfipe'c eici Kai KaGiiYCMOvec ojuujvujliujc rrpoc- aYopeuovTec. oiov eueuc 6 'ApxiXoxoc, OTav juev euxdjuevoc \iyri B 'kXu6' dvaS "HcpaiQxe mi |uoi cu|U|uaxoc yo^-
vou|uevuj 10
iXaoc Ycvou, x^Pi^^u ^' oidTrep x«Pi2:eai', auTov Tov 6e6v eTTiKaXou|uevoc bfjXdc ^ctiv OTav bk Tov ctvbpa Tfjc dbeXcpfic riqpavicjueVov ev 6aXdTTri Kai |uri TuxovTa vojuijuou Taqpf^c 6priva)V XeYr) jueTpiLUTepov av ir]v cujucpopdv evcYKeTv ie
*€i Keivou Ke(paXf|V Kai xapievTa /aeXea
"HcpaicTOC Ka6apoTciv ev eijuaciv djuqpe7T0vfi6ri ', t6 ttOp outujc, ou tov 6e6v TrpocriYopeuce. TrdXiv b' 6 juev Gupmibric eiTriijv ev opKUJ
'iu« t6v juct' dcTpujv Zfiv' "Apn tc qpoiviov' 20 auTOuc Touc 6€ouc wvojuace* toO be CocpoKXeouc Xe-
YOVTOC
C 'Tuq)X6c Ydp, (!> YuvaiKec, oub' opujv "Apric cu6c TrpocOoTruj TrdvTa TuppdZei KaKd'
t6v TToXejuov ecTiv uTTaKoOcai, Ka6d;Tep aij t6v xa\- 25
k6v 'Ojufipou XeYOVTOC
'tujv vOv aijua K€Xaiv6v euppoov djuqpi CKdjuavbpov kK^bac' 6Hijc "Apnc'.
1, 8G-87H. 6, 80-82 E.
9. Bergk. p. 553 16. Id. p, 538 19. 6upiTTi6ric] Phoeu. 1013 23. Nauck. p. 247 26. 'Ojuiipou] H 329
POETAS AUDIRE DEBEAT 53
TToXXujv ouv ouTUj \eYO|Ltevujv ei5e'vai bei Kai |nvri|Lio- veueiv OTi Kai tlu toO Aioc Kai Zrjvoc 6v6|LiaTi rroTe jaev Tov 0e6v tTOTe be ttiv tuxhv TroXXdKic be Tf]v ei- D |uap)Lievriv TTpocaTopeuouciv. OTav )nev t«P ^eYoici
5 'ZeO rrdTep, "IbrjOev inebeujv ' Kai
'uj ZeO, Tic eivai qprici coO cocpujTepoc * ; t6v 9€6v auT6v XeTOuciv oTav be TaTc aiTiaic Trdv- TU)v TUJV TiTVOjuevujv eTTOvojudZiujci t6v Aia Kai Xe'-
10 Twci
'Ai6c b' eTeXeieTO pouXrj',
TTiv ei)aap|ie'vr|v. ou Tdp t6v 9e6v 6 TtoiriTfic oTeTai KaKd )aTixavdc9ai toic dv9pujTT0ic, dXXd Tnv tujv TTpat- lndTUJV dvdTKnv 6p9ujc uTTobeiKvuciv, oti Kai TroXeci E 15 Ktti CTpaTOTTeboic Kai fiTejiOCiv, dv ^kv cujqppovujciv, eu TTpdTTeiv TreTTpujTai Kai KpaTeTv tujv TToXeiaiujv, av b' eic TTd9ri Kai diaapTiac ejiiTrecovTec uicTrep outoi biaq)e'pujVTai Trpoc dXXr|Xouc Kai CTacidZiuJCiv, dcxn* IbioveTv Ktti TapdTTec9ai Kai KaKujc dTraXXdTTeiv.
a> ' ei|aap|ae'vov Tdp tujv KaKUJV pouXeuiadTiuv KaKdc d|ioipdc ecTi KapKouc0ai PpoToTc'
Kai )ifiv 6 'Hcioboc t6v TTpo)ir|9e'a ttoiujv tlu '€Tri|ur|- 9eT TTapaKeXeu6|Lievov
'|ifj TTOTe bujpa 25 beEac9ai Trdp Zriv6c 'OXu|httiou dXX' dTroTT^|LiTT€iv ', eTTi Tr| Tfic Tuxric buvdjuei ti|) Aioc 6v6)iaTi Kexpnfar P
l,Sfi— 87H.^ 6, 82— 83 R
5. Hom. r 276. H 202. Q 308 7. Nauck. p. 694
11. Homer. A 5. Ante Ai6c erat iroXXctc 6' tqpGiiaouc njuxac "Axhi •npotaivev, quod expunxi 20. Nauck. p. 695 24. 0. et D. 86
54 QUOMODO ADOLESCENS
Tot Yap Tuxnpci Tujv dYaOuJv Aioc bujpa KeKXrjKe, ttXoii- Touc Ktti Yd|uouc Ktti dpxdc Kai irdvTa oXujc Td ektoc, uJv f) KTficic dvovriTOc ecTi toTc xPHcOai KaXujc |ufi bu- vajuevoic. bio Kai tov '€Tnjiil9ea qpaOXov ovTa Kai dvoriTOV oieTai beiv qpuXdTTecGai Kai bebievai Tdc s euTuxiac, wc pXapric6|uevov Kai biaqp0apTic6]uevov utt' auTujv. Kai TTdXiv OTav XeYr)
'juTibe ttot' ouXo|uevTiv Trevirjv 9u|uoqp96pov dvbpi TeTXa9' oveibiCeiv, iuaKdpujv b6civ aiev e6vTujv', 9e6cboTOv vOv t6 Tuxripov eiprjKev, ujc ouk dHiov eY- lo 24 KaXeTv toTc bid Triv Tuxriv Trevo|uevoic , dXXd ttiv |U€t' dpYiac Kai juaXaKiac Kai TToXuTeXeiac diTopiav KaKi- teiv aicxpdv Kai eTTOveibiCTOv oucav. outtuj Ydp auTo Touvojua TTic TuxTic Xe'YOVTec , eib6Tec be ttiv Tfic dTa- KTUJC Ktti dopicTUJC TTepiqpepo)uievr|c aiTiac buvajuiv is icxupdv Kai dqpuXaKTOV oijcav dv9pujTTivuj Xoyic|uui ToTc TuJv 9eu)V 6v6)aaciv eSeqppaZiov, ujCTrep fmeTc Kai npdYluaTa Kai fj9ri Kai vfi Aia X6youc Kai dvbpac eiuj9a|uev baijuoviouc Kai Geiouc TrpocaYopeueiv. outui bfi Td TToXXd TU)v dTdTTUJC TTepi ToO Aioc Xe'Yec9ai 20 boKouvTUJV eTTavop9uJTe'oV; iLv dcTi Kai TaOTa 'boioi Yap te TTi9oi KaTaKeiaTai ev Aioc oubei B KripLuv ejuTrXeioi, 6 /uev ec9Xu)V; auTdp 6 beiXujv' Kai
'opKia |uev Kpovibric uvpiZluYoc ouk eTeXeccev, 25
dXXd KaKd qppoveujv TeKjuaipeTai djuqpoTepoici ' Ktti
'TdTe Ydp pa KuXivbeTO TTiijuaTOC dpxn Tpujci Te Kai AavaoTci Aioc lueYdXou bid PouXdc',
1,88— 89 H. 6, 83— 85 E.
8. 0. et D, 717 22. Homer. Q 527 23. Plat. Rep. II. p. 379 D 25. Homer. H 69 28. Id. 9 81
POETAS AUDIRE DEBEAT 55
ujc TTcpi Tnc Tuxnc f| Tfjc ei|uap|Lievric XeTOjuevuuV; ev aic t6 dcuXXoTiCTOV fijuiv thc aiTiac cuveKcpaiveTai Kai t6 oXujc ou KaG' fi|uac. ottou be t6 TrpocfiKOV Kai [ KaTot XoTov Kai eiKOC ecTiv, evTauOa Kupiuuc ovoiudZie- I 6 c6ai Tov 9e6v vo)aiZ;uj|uev, uJCTtep ev toutoic [ . 'auTdp o Tujv dXXujv eTieTTUjXeiTO CTixac dvbpujv, C AiavToc b' dXe'eive ludxnv TeXajuujvidbao • Zeuc Tdp 01 ve|ueca 6t' djueivovi cpujTi |udxoiTO*
Kai
xo 'Zeuc Tdp Td |uev jueTiCTa qppovTiCei PpoTUJV, Td luiKpd b' dXXoic bai|uociv Trapeic ea'. ccpobpa be bei Kai toIc dXXoic 6v6|uaci rrpocexeiv, • KaTd TToXXd Kivoujuevoic Kai |ue9iCTa|uevoic utt6 tuuv TTOiriTuJv. oiov ecTi Kai t6 Tf^c dpeTfjc. eTTei Tdp ou
15 luovov ejucppovac TTapexeTai Kai biKaiouc Kai dTa9ouc D ev TTpdEeci Kai Xotoic, dXXd Kai boEac eTTieiKuJc Kai buvdjueic TTepiTTOieiTai, TTapd touto TroioOvTai Kai Tfjv euboHiav dpeTfiv Kai ttiv buvajuiv ovojudCovTec, ujcrrep ' eXdav ' t6v dTT6 Tfjc eXdac, Kai ' cpriT^v ' t6v drr^ Tfic
20 cpriToO KapTT6v 6)uujvu|uujc toTc cpepouciv. oukoOv 6 veoc f)|uTv, OTav |uev X^tuuci
■^Tfic b' dpeTHc ibpu)Ta 6eoi TrpoTTdpoi6ev e'6riKav' Kai
'TfiiLioc cqp^ dpeTfj Aavaoi pfiSavTO q)dXaTTac' 25 Kai
1, 89-90H. 6, 85— 87K.
2. cuveKqjmveTai*: cu|Lipa{veTai 3. t6 SXujc*: 6Xujc 5. vo^ituj|uev W: vo)Lii2oiuev 6. Homer. A 540 8. ve- ILiecacx' Aristot. Rhet. II 9, ve|ieca0' Plutarch. de Vita et Poesi Hom. §. U2. 8t* iidem: fiv 10. Nauck. p. 695
13. TToXXa Pieiskius: iroXXd updT,uaTa 18. Tr]v addidit Reis- kius 22. Hesiod. 0. et D. 289 24. Homer. A 90
66 QUOMODO ADOLESCENS
*€i be GaveTv ^eiaic, uibe GaveTv KaXov, eic dpetriv KaTabucajuevouc piov*, E euGuc oiecGcju Xe'Tec9ai TaOta Ttepi Tfic dpicTric Kai 9€iOTdTric eHeujc ev f])LiTv, fiv 6p96TriTa X6tou Kai dKp6- TriTa XoYiKnc qpucecuc Kai bid9eciv 6jLioXoTOU)nevriv 5 ipuxnc vooujuev. oTav b' dvaTiTVuucKr) rrdXiv t6 Te *Zeuc b' dp€Triv dvbpecciv oqpeXXei tc |aivu9€i Te' Kai t6
'ttXoutiu b' dpeTir) Kai KOboc ^irribeT', ^r] 'Ka9r|c9uj' touc rrXouciouc eKTT€7TXriTMevoc Kai 'Te- to 9iiTTUJc' Ka9dTrep ujviov eu9uc dpTupiou Triv dpeTriv exovTac, iurib' eTri Tfj Tuxri KeTc9ai Tf)v auToO cpp6- vriciv auHeiv rj KoXoueiv vojuiZiuJv, dXX' dvTi boHric ti buvd)Lieujc r| euTuxiac fi tivoc ojuoiou Tfj dpcT^ Kexpfj- F c9ai Tov TTOiriTfiv fiTeic9uj. Kai Tdp Tr) KaK^TriTi rroTe i5 nkv ibiujc criiaaivouci Ka^iav Kai juox^ripiav ujuxfic, ujc 'Hcioboc
'Triv jLiev Tdp KaK^TriTa Kai iXabov ^'ctiv 4Xec9ai', rroTe b' dXXriv Tivd KdKUJCiv fl bucTuxiav, ujc "OjLiripoc
^al^ja Tdp ev KaK6Tr|Ti ppoTOi KaTaTTipdcKOUCiv'. 20 eTTei Kai Tf]v eubaijLioviav eEaTraTii9eiri tic dv outuj Touc TTOiriTdc oi6)Lievoc XeTeiv, ujc 01 (piX6co(poi Xe- Touci Triv TTavTeXfi tOjv dTa9ujv eHiv fl KTfjciv f| Kai 25 TeXeidTriTa piou KaTd cpuciv eupooOvTOc, dXX* ouxi Ka- Taxpuj)Lievouc rroXXdKic tov ttXouciov eubaifiova Ka- 25 XeTv fl juaKdpiov Kai Tfiv buva^niv fj Triv b6Hav eubai- luoviav. "0)uripoc juev Tdp 6p9ujc Ke'xpriTai toTc 6v6- jLiaciv
J, 90— 92H. 6, 87— 88E.
1. Nauck. p. 529 7. Homer. Y 242 9. Hesiod. 0. et D. 313 18. Id. 0. et D. 287 19. "Ounpocj t 360
I
POETAS AUDIRE DEBEAT 57
'ujc ou Toi xaipiwv ToTcbe KTedtTecciv dvdcciu' Ktti Me'vavbpoc
'exuj be TToXXriv ouciav Kai ttXoOcioc
KaXoO)Li' uTTO TtdvTiuv, jnaKdpioc h' utt' ou&evoc', 5 GupiTTi&nc be TToXXfiv dpTdZcTai Tapaxnv Kai cuTXuciv OTav Xe'T»;}
'^iri jLioi YCVOiTO XuTrpoc eubai|uujv pioc* B
Kai
'Ti Tfiv Tupavvib', dbiKiav €ubai)iOva, 10 Ti|aac ' ; dv |Lirj Tic, wcTTep eTpriTai, TaTc laeTaqpopaTc Kai KaTa- Xpriceci Tujv 6vo|udTUJV eTTrjTai. TaOTa luev oijv iKa-
VUJC TTepi TOUTUJV.
7. 'GKeTvo b' oux dTraH dXXd TToXXdKic uTro|ivri-
15 cTeov ecTi toijc veouc evbeiKVUjLievov auToTc , oti |lii-
)iriTiKr)v f) TToiricic uTToGeciv exouca K6c)au) iuev Kai
XajUTTpoTriTi XPHTai Trepi Tdc UTTOKei)Lie'vac TrpdEeic Kal
Td fjeri, Tfjv h' ojuotoTriTa toO dXrjGoOc ou TTpoXeirTei,
TTic )ai)aficeujc ev tuj TTi0avuj t6 dYUJY^v Ixo^cric. bio C
20 Kai KaKiac Kai dpeTnc criueTa |ue)aiY)ueva TaTc rrpdEeciv
fi )ufi TTavTdTTaci Tfic dXriGeiac oXiYUjpoOca juifiricic
cuveK(pe'pei, uiCTTep f] '0|uf|pou rroXXd TTdvu toTc CtujT-
KoTc xaipeiv qppdZiouca, |uf|Te ti qpaOXov dpeTvj TrpoceT-
vai fifiTe KaKiqt xpilcTov dHioOciv, dXXd rrdvTUJC |uev
25 ev rrdciv djuapTUjXov eivai tov djuaGfj , TTepi TrdvTa
b' aij KaTop0oOv tov dcTcTov. TaOTa xdp ev TaTc
cxoXaTc dKOuo)uev. ev be toTc Trpdyiuaci Kai tiD piixj
Tujv TToXXujv KaTd t6v Gupmibriv
1,92— 93 H. C, 88— 8J^B.
1. Hom. 6 93 3. Meinek. IV, p. 266 7. Med. 603 9. Phoen. 552
58 QUOMODO ADOLESCENS
'ouK fiv Y^voiTO X^up\c icQ\a koli KOKd:, D diXX' lcTi Tic cuTKpacic'.
fiveu be ToO dXti9o0c lidXicTa iuev n TroiriTiKfi tuj ttoi- KiXuj XP^Tai Koi TToXuTpdTTUj. t6 Tap ^MTraSk Kai TrapdXoTOV koi dTrpocboKriTOV, lij TrXeicTn M€v ^kttXh- s £ic ^TTeTai TTXeiCTJi be xop>c, a\ jaeTajJoXal Trapexouci Toic ^uGoic Td b' dTrXouv dnoBfcc Kai fi^uBov. 60ev ouTC viKUJVTac dei TrdvTa rroioOci touc auTOuc out' euriiiepoOvTac ouTe KaTopSoOvTac. dXX' oub^ toic eeoTc, OTav eic dvGpujTrivac ^iutt^cujci TrpdSeic, dTra- lo 6e'ci xpuLJVTOi Kai dva)japTr|Toic , iva (ir|^ct)LioO t6 t€ TopdTTOv Kai t6 ^KTTXnrrov dpTrj thc TToir|ceujc dKiv- tuvov Kai dvaTiuviCTOv TiTVOfievov.
E 8. OUTUJC OUV TOUTUJV ^XOVTUJV ^TTdTUJVieV TOIC
TTOirmaci t6v v^ov \ir] TomuTac ^xovTa boEac Trepi tujv n KaXujv ^Keivujv Kal jaeTdXujv dvondTUJV, d)c fipa co- q)oi Kai biKaioi oi fivbpec fjcav, dKpoi Te paciXeic koi Kavovec dpeTfic dTrdcnc Kai dpGoTTiTOC dTrei pXaPnce- Tai fieTdXa boKi^dZujv TrdvTa Kai Te6nTrd)c, nr\ bucxe- paivujv be nribev jin^ * dKOuujv lin^ ' dTTobex6)uevoc toO 20 vpeTovToc auTouc ToiaOTa TrpdTTOvTac Ka\ XeTOVTac *a\ Tdp, ZeO Te TrdTep Kai 'A6Tivair| Ka\ "AttoXXov, )ir|Te Tic ouv Tpujujv edvaTOV <puT0i, 6ccoi €aci, F )ir|Te tic 'ApTeiujv, vujiv b' ^KbOfiev 6Xe6pov,
6q)p* oioi Tpoinc Upd Kpr|be^va Xuoijiev* ts
Kai
*olKTpoTdTnv b' rJKOUca fiTra rTpid^ioio 6uTaTp6c Kaccdvbprjc, Tf|v KTeTve KXuTaijnvrjcTpTi boX6)ir|Tic d^q)* ^Moi'
1,93— 94 IL «,90-«tB
1. Nauck. p. 294 13. dvaTiOvicrov W: dvTaTtiviCTOv
22. Homer. TT 97 37. Id. A 421
POETAS AUDIRE DEBEAT 59
Kai
'TTaXXaKibi 7Tpo|uiYfivai , iv' exOripeie Yepovta. Tr) TTi96|uriv Kai epeEa' Kai 5 ^Zev TTdiep, ou tic ceTo 6eijuv oXouuTepoc dWoc*.
luiribev ouv eTTaiveiv dGiZiecGuu toioOtov 6 veoc, juri&e 20 TTpoqpdceic XeTuuv |uribe TTapaTuuYdc Tivac euiTpeTreic erri TTpdxiuaci cpauXoic jurjxavuuiuevoc TTiGavoc ecTuu Kai TTavoOpYOC; dXX' CKeTvo iudXXov oiec9uu, |Lii)uriciv eivai
10 Triv TToiriciv ii9uuv Kai piuuv, Kai dv9puuTTiuv ou TeXeiuuv oube Ka9apijuv oub' dveTTiXrjTTTuuv TTavTdTTaciv, dXXd juejuiTMevuuv Trd9eci Kai boSaic vjjeubeci Kai dTvoiaic, bid b' euq)uiav auTOuc rroXXdKic )U€TaTi9evTuuv TTpoc To KpeTTTOv. fi Tdp TOiauTr) TTapacKeufi toO veou Kai
15 bidvoia, ToTc )aev eu XeTO/aevoic Kai TTpaTTO|uevoic eTTaipojuevou Kai cuvev9ouciuuvTOC, Td be qpaOXa juf] B TTpociejuevou Kai bucxepaivovTOC, dpXapfi TTapeSei Tfiv dKpoaciv. 6 be rrdvTa 9aujudZ;uuv Kai Traciv eEoiKeiou- )uevoc Kai KaTabebouXajjuevoc Tig boEr) Tfjv Kpiciv utto
20 TUUV flpUUlKUUV 6v0|udTUUV, UJCTTep 01 TflV TTXdTUUVOC dTTO-
)ai)uou)Lievoi KupTdTriTa Kai Tfjv 'ApicTOTeXouc TpauXo- Tr|Ta, Xr|ceTai rrpoc TToXXd tuuv q^auXuuv euxepfjc Tev6)ue- voc. beT be )af] beiXuuc ^r\b' ujCTTep utto beicibai|uoviac ev lepuj cppiTTeiv drravTa Kai rrpocKuveTv, dXXd 9appa-
25 Xeuuc e9i2;6)uevov eTTicpuuveiv ixr\bev tjttov toO ' 6p9uuc ' Ktti ' TTpeTr6vTuuc ' t6 'ouk 6p9uijc' Kai 'ou TTpocriKov- Tuuc'. oiov 6 'AxiXXeuc eKKXriciav cuvdTei tujv CTpa- c TiuuTuuv vocouvTuuv, dcxdXXuuv )aev dpToOvTi tlu tto- Xe|ULu )adXicTa TrdvTiuv bid Tfjv ev TaTc CTpaTeiaic
so ETTicpdveiav auToO Kai boHav, laTpiKoc h' uuv Kai |ue9'
1, 94— 96H, C, 81— 93K.
2. Hom. I 452 5. Id. T 365
60 QUOMODO ADOLESCENS
fiiLiepav dvdtTriv fj TaOra Kpivec9ai TrecpuKev aice6)aevoc ouK oucav cuvr|6ri Tfiv vocov oube cuvecTUJcav dno KOivdiv aiTiujv, dvacTdc ou brnuaYUJTei tov oxXov, dXXd ruj paciXei fiTveTqi cu)apouXoc
''ATpeibri, vuv dmae TraXiinTTXaYxQtVTac 6iu) 6
dip dTTOVOCTriceiv'^ D^pGuJc TauTa Kai jueTpiuuc Kai TrpeTtovTUJC. toO &e ludvTeujc bebie'vai qprjcavToc Tfjv opTriv tou buvaTuj- TttTou Tiijv 'GXXrivujv, ouKeT' 6p0u)c oube jueTpiuuc, dTT0)Li6cac \jLr\biva TTpocoiceiv x^ipac auTu» Zujvtoc au- lo ToO, TTpocTiGriciv
'oub' r|v 'AYa)ue'MVova emric*, dvbeiKVUjuevoc oXiYujpiav Kai TTepicpp6vr|civ toO dpxov- Toc. ^K be toutou iLidXXov TTapoHuvGeic ^tti t6 Siqpoc cpepeTai, c^dTTeiv biavooujuevoc, ouTe Trpoc to KaXov i5 opGiJuc ouTe rrpoc to cu)ii{pe'pov. eiT' au9ic )aeTa- voricac
'dvp ec KouXeov iZice ^ueta Hicpoc, oub' dTTi9rice E )Liu9iu 'A9rivairic ', 6p9ujc TTdXiv Kai KaXujc , 6'ti t6v 9u)li6v eKK^ipai TTav- 20 TdTTaci )if| buvri9eic , 6)iujc , TTpiv dvfiKecTdv ti bpdcai, )ieTe'cTnce Kai KaTecxev euTT€i9fi tiu XoTicjauj Yev6)Lie- vov. TrdXiv 6 'ATajue')Livujv ev juev toTc rrepi Tfjv ^k- KXriciav TiTVOjnevoic Kai XeTO)ne'voic utt' auToO KaTa- TeXacT6c ecTiv, dv be toTc TTepi Xpucriiba cejLiv6Tepoc 25 Kai paciXiKUJTepoc. 6 juev Tap 'AxiXXeuc dTOjn^vric Tfic Bpicriiboc
*baKpucac ^TdpuJV dqpap 'ileio v6c(pi Xiac9eic', ouTOc b' auToc eic Tfiv vaOv djupipdjujv Kai TTapabi-
1,96— 97 H. 6, 93— 94 R.
3. Tov Aldina: irpoc tov 5. Homer. A 59 12. Id. A 90 18. Id. A 220 28. Id. A 349
POETAS AUDIRE DEBEAT 61
bouc Ktti dTTOTreiuTTajv xriv dvGpuuTrov r\y oXiTqj Trpo- F c9ev eipiiKe ific Y«|iieTfic xrj euvoia trpoKpiveiv, oObev epujTiKov oub' aicxpov CTTOirice. Kai )afiv 6 OoiviS bid Tfjv TiaXXaKiba KaTdpaToc utto toO TTaTpoc ycvo- 5 juevoc
*t6v |Liev eYO)' qprjci 'PouXeuca KaTaKTdjuev 6He'i
dXXd Tic d6avdT(juv TTaOcev x6\o\, 6c p* evi 0u|LiLij bfmou GfiKe cpdTiv Kai oveibea ttoXX' dvBpuOTTUJV,
10 Obc lix] TraTpocpovoc iiieT' 'AxaioTciv KaXeoijLiriv'. 6 |iev ouv 'ApicTapxoc eSeiXe TaOTa Td eTrri (popri0eic' ^X^i be TTpoc t6v Kaip6v 6p9ujc, toO 0oiviKOC t6v 'AxiXXea bibdcKOVTOC oTov ecTiv opTfl Kai oca bid27 Gujuov dvGpujTTOi ToX^iujci, /Lifi xpiJU)uevoi XoTiC)auj )ur|be
15 Trei96)uevoi toTc TrapriTopoOci. Kai Tdp t6v MeXeaTpov ^TTeicdTei toTc TToXiTaic 6pTiZ!6)uevov, eiTa Trpauvojue- vov, 6p9u)C Td TTd9ri ijje'TUJV, t6 be |ufi cuvaKoXou9eTv dXX' dvTiTdTTec9ai Kai KpaTcTv Kai jueTavoeTv eTTaivujv ujc KaX6v Kai cu)acpe'pov. evTa09a )uev oijv fi biacpopd
20 TTpobriXoc • OTTOu b* dca^fj Td Tfic TVUJ)uric, biopicTeov ouTU) TTUic eqpicTdvTac t6v veov. ei )uev f] NauciKda Eevov dvbpa t6v 'Obuccea 9eaca)uevri Kai TTa9o0ca t6 Tfic KaXuvpoOc TTd9oc Trpoc auTov, ciTe bfi Tpucpujca Kai Td)uu)v ujpav exouca, TOiaOTO /uujpaivei TTp6c TdcB
25 9epaTTaivibac
'a'i Tdp e)uoi TOiocbe ttocic KeKXr])uevoc eiii ev9dbe vaieTdujv, Kai oi dboi auT69i )ui|uv€iv% ipcKTeov t6 9pdcoc -xxuTfic Kai Tfiv dKoXaciav • el be ToTc X6toic toO dvbp6c t6 fi9oc eviboOca Kai Gaujud- 30 caca Tfiv evTeuEiv auToO ttoXuv voOv exoucav euxeTai
1,97— 98 H. 6, 94— 96 B.
6. Hom. I 458 26. ^|uoi idem l 244: I|ae0
C.2 QUOMODO ADOLESCENS
TOiouTUj cuvoiK€iv )aa\\ov fi tt\ujtikiu Tivi Ktti opxrt- CTiKOi Tujv TTo\iTUJV, ctHiov dT«c9ai. TTd\iv Tvic TTrive- \6TTr|c Toic lavncTiipci 7Tpocbia\€YO|ueviic ouk drravGptJU- TTUJC, eK€ivujv b' auTrj xctpiZ;o|i€vujv i^dTia Kai Koc/aov dWov, fib6|iievoc 'Obucceuc 5
C ' ouveKa tujv inev biupa TTape\KeTO , 0e\-fe be
6u)a6v',
€1 )aev ^TTi Trj bujpoboKiqt Kai TT\€OveHia xaipt*^ tov KUJ)aujbou)aevov uneppdWei )LiacTpoTreia TTo^iaTpov
'eubai|uujv TTo\iaYpoc ic
oupdviov aiTa TT\ouTOcp6pov Tpeqpujv'"
€i be )aaWov oi6|Lievoc uTTox€ipiouc eEeiv bid thv i\- iriba Kai t6 )Lie\\ov ou TrpocbOKUJVTac , \6-fOv ^x^x ro fib6|Li€Vov auTuj Kai GappoOv. 6)uoiujc dTTi Tr) biapi- 6)ar|C€i Tujv xP1M«fujv, S cuveHe^riKav o\ OaiaKec 15 auTiij Kai dTTeTT\eucav , ei )iev d\ri6ujc ^v ^pri)aia to- DcauTT] Kai Tijjv Ka6' auTOV dcacpeia Kai dbri\6TriTi y€- fovujc TTepi TuJv xprmdTUJV qpopeiTai
*|Liii Ti o\ oTxujvTai Koi\Tic ^TTi VHOC fitovTec',
oiKTeipeiv dEiov Fj pbe\uTTec6ai vfi Aia Triv cpi\oTT\ou- 20 Tiav ei b', ujCTrep evioi \e'fouci, Trepi Tfic 'ledKric d)aq)iboHuJv oieTai Tfiv tujv xPIMdTUJV cujTripiav dTrd- beiEiv eivai Tfic tujv <t)aidKUJV ocidTrjToc (ou Ydp dv dKepbujc cp^povTac auTov eic dWoTpiav dKPa\eiv x^* pav Kai KaTa\iTTeTv, dTTOcxo)aevouc tuuv xPnM«TUJv), 25 ouTe cpau\uj TeK)aripiuj xpflTai, Kai Tfiv Trpdvoiav dEiov E dTtaiveiv. ^vioi b^ Kai Triv eK6eciv auTnv ei ^ev
1,08— 100 H. C, 96-97 R
6. Homer. c 282 10. Meinek. IV. p. 667 19. Ho-
mer. v 216 fiYOvxec ideni: fxovxec
POETAS AUDIRE DEBEAT 63
d\ri9uL)C eY£veTO KaGeubovToc ipeTouci; Kai Tuppiivouc iCTopiav Tivd cpaci biacpuXdTTeiv luc uTTVuubouc cpucei Tou 'Obucceuuc Tevo^evou Kai bucevTeuKTou bid touto ToTc TToWoTc ovTOC. cl b' ouK fjv dXrjGrjc 6 uttvoc,
odXX' aiboujuevoc )uev dTTOTre')m|/ai touc OaiaKac dveu Eeviujv Kai qpiXocppocuvTic, |uf] &uvd)Li€VOC be touc exOpouc XaGeTv eKeiviuv cujuTtapovTUJV exprjcaTO thc dTTopiac TTapaKaXu|U)LiaTt , KOi)Liuj)ue'vuj TTOincac ojlioiov eauTOV; dTTobexovTai. Kai Tauxa bri toTc veoic utto-
10 beiKvuoviec ouk edcojuev qpopdv Trpoc xd q)aOXa TiTve- c9ai TuJv r\Q(xiV dXXd tujv peXTiovujv ZifiXov Kai TTpo- aipeciv, eu9uc toTc )iev t6 vpeTeiv toTc be t6 CTraiveTv F dTTobibovTec. ^idXicTa be toOto TroieTv beT ev TaTc TpaTLubiaic, ocai Xotouc exouci Tn9avouc Kai Travoup-
15 Touc ev TTpdHeciv dboEoic Kai TrovnpaTc. ou Trdvu t^P dXri9ec t6 toO CocpoKXe'ouc Xe'T0VT0c
''ouK ecT' dTT' epTUJV juf) KaXujv ^tth KaXd*' Kai T«P ctuT6c ei'uj9ev fi9eci qjauXoic Kai dTOTTOic TrpdT- |uaci XoTOuc eTTiTeXujVTac Kai cpiXav9pujTT0uc aiTiac
20 TTopiZeiv. Kai 6 cucKrjvoc auTOu TrdXiv opctc oti Tf|v T€ Oaibpav Kai TrpoceTKaXoucav tuj GriceT TTerroiriKev 29 ujc bid Tttc eKeivou TTapavo)uiac epac9eTcav toO 'Itt- TToXuTou. TOiauTriv be Kai t^ '€Xevr) Trappriciav KaTd Tfic 'GKdPnc ev TaTc Tpujdci bibujciv, oio)aevri beTv eKei-
25 vriv KoXdZ;ec9ai judXXov oti )uoix6v auTfic eTCKe. ^r\- bev ouv TOUTUiv K0)uip6v fiTeTc9ai Kai TravoOpTOv 6 ve'oc e9iZ;ec9uj, )uribe TTpocjueibidTUJ TaTc TOiauTaic eupeciXoTiaic, dXXd pbeXuTTec9uj touc Xotouc ludXXov f| Td epTa ttic dKoXaciac.
1, 100— 101 H. 6, 97— 99 R
17. Nauck. p. 247 18. auxdc Emperius: oijToc 19. Nauck. Eurip. Fr. -430" p. 113 24. Tpujdci] V. 919
64 QUOMODO ADOLESCENS
9. '€tti iraci toivuv Kai t6 Tf^v aiTiav dKdcTOu B Tijuv XeTO)aevu)V eTTiZIriTeiv XP^^^IMOV ecTiv. 6 pev t«P KdTCJuv CTi Traibdpiov wv eTrpaTTe |aev 6 TTpocTdHeiev 6 TTaibaTUJTOc , aiTiav be Kai Xotov dTrr|T€i toO TTpoc- TdTiuaTOC" TOic be TTOuiTaic ou TreiCTeov ujCTrep -nai- ' baTuuToTc r\ vo)Uo9eTaic, dv }xr] \6tov exr} t6 uTTOKei- fievov. eHei be, dvTrep xphct^v ^* dv be laoxQripov, 6q)9r|ceTai Kev6v Kai /adTaiov. dW oi ttoXXoi tujv
|LieV TOlOUTUiV Tdc aiTiaC TTlKpUJC dTTaiTOUCl, Kttl bia-
TTuv9dvovTai ttujc XeXeKTai lo
'lJiY\be ttot' oivoxoriv Ti9€'juev KpriTfipoc uTTep9ev
TTIVOVTUJV'
Kai
'6c be k' dvfjp dTr6 iLv 6xeujv eT€p' apjua9' iKiiTai, C eTXei 6peHdc9uj'. 15
Tiuv be jaeiZiovujv dpacavicTUJC Trapabe'xovTai Tiqv Tri- CTiV; oia Ktti TauT' ecTiv
'bouXoT Tdp dvbpa, kSv 9pacucTTXaTXv6c tic fi,
OTav cuveibri |nriTp6c f\ TraTpoc Kaicd', Kai 20
'cjLiiKp6v cppoveTv XP^ t6v KaKUJC TreTTpaTOTa '. l KaiToi TauTa tujv ii9ujv drrTeTai Kai touc piouc bia- TapdTTCi, Kpiceic e|UTTOiouvTa cpauXac Kai boEac dTev-* veTC; dv |uri TTp6c ckoctov auTuiv €i9icjuevoi X^tiwmcv D bid Ti cjLiiKpov cppoveTv XPH t6v KaKuuc neTrpaTOTa 2.-, Kai |uf] ladXXov dvTaipeiv Trj tux^I Kai ttoicTv uijji-iXov ^auT6v Kai dTaTreivuuTOV ; bid Ti be, dv Ik TTaTp6c
1, 102— 103 H. 6, 09- 100 R
11. Hesiod. 0. et D. 739 14. Homer. A 30G 18.
Eur. Hipp. 424 21. Nauck. p. 695 ■treTTpaT^Ta Wagne- rus: ireTTpax^Ta 25. TrenpaT^Ta*: ireTTpax^Ta
POETAS AUDIRE DEBEAT 65
cpauXou Ktti dvoriTou yctovujc auTOc o» xPHCToc Kai (pp6vi|uoc, ou TrpocriKei |uoi bid Trjv e)ufiv dpeTfiv n4.fa cppoveTv dXXd KaTaTre7TXfix6ai Kai TaTieivov eivai bid Tfiv ToO TTaTpoc d)Liaeiav ; 6 Tdp outujc dTravTUJV Ka\
5 dvTepeibujv xai )uf) rravTi Xotuj rrXdTiov ujCTrep Trveu- juaTi TTapabibouc eauTov dXX' opGOuc exeiv voiuiZiujv t6 'pXdH dv9pujTT0C eTTi TravTi X6tuj cpiXei eTTToficGar, TToXXd biaKpouceTai tujv ouk dXriGujc oub' ujqpeXi|uuJC XeT0|uevuJV. TauTa )uev otjv dpXapfi TrapeSei Tfjv tOuv
10 Troir])LidTUJV dKpoaciv.
10. 'eTrei b' ujCTrep dv d)UTreXou qpuXXoic Kai kKy]- e luaciv euGaXouci rroXXdKic 6 Kaprroc dTTOKpurrTeTai koi Xav3dvei KaTacKia2;6]uevoc , outujc ev TroiriTiKfi XeEei Kai )uu0eu)uaci rrepiKexujuevoic rroXXd biacpeuTei tov
15 veov ujqpeXijua Kai xpi'ici)ua (bei be touto )ufi Trdcxeiv )ur,'o' dTroTrXavdc6ai tujv TrpaTjudTUJV; dXX' ejuqpuecGai )udXiCTa Toic TTpoc dpcTfjv cpepouci Kai buvajuevoic TrXdTTeiv to fi6oc), ou x^ipov ecTi Kai rrepi toutujv bieX9eiv i\ Ppaxeciv, dtjjd)uevov ujc ev tuttuj tujv rrpaT-
20 )udTUJV , |uf|Kri be xai xaTacKeudc Kai rrapabeiTjudTUJV oxXov eujVTa toTc eTribeiKTiKiuTepov Tpdqpouci. Trpuj- F Tov )uev ouv Td XPHCTd Kai Td qpauXa titvuOckujv 6 veoc fi9r| Kai TTp6cujTra toTc XeTO)uevoic TrpocexeTUJ Kal TaTc TrpdSeciv ac 6 TTOir|Tfic eKttTepoic TrpocriK6vTUJC
25 dTrobibujciv. olov 6 'AxiXXeuc Trpoc tov 'ATa|ue)uvova XeT€i, Kamep XeTUJV jueT^ opTnc
'ou Tdp coi TTOTe Tcov exuj Tepotc, otttt^t' 'Axaioi Tpujujv eKTre'pcujc' eij vai6)uevov TrToXie0pov ',
6 be 0epciTric TauTtu Xoibopoujuevoc XeTei
1, 103-105H. 6, 100— 102 K.
7. pXdS] P. 41 A 27. Homer. A 163
riutarclii Mor.ilia. Vol. I. 5
66 QUOMODO ADOLESCENS
*7TXeTai TOi xaXKoO xXiciai, TroXXai be YuvaiKec eiciv ^vi xXicirjc eHaipexoi, ac toi 'Axaioi 29 TrpujTicTUJ bibo)aev, euT' av TTToXie9pov IXiujuev', Kai TrdXiv 6 'AxiXXeuc
' ai K^ TTo9i Zeuc bujci TToXiv Tpoir|v euTeixeov dHaXarrdHai *, 6 be GepciTrjc
'6v Kev efuj br|cac dfdTUJ f| dXXoc 'Axaiiijv'. TtdXiv ToO 'AYa|Lie')avovoc ev Trj ^TTiTrujXr|cei tov Aio- |Ltr|briv Xoibopr|cavToc o |Liev oubev dvTemev
'aibec9eic paciXfioc evmfiv aiboioio', 6 be C9eveXoc, oij juribeic Xoyoc,
•'ATpeibri' (pnci, 'ixx] ipeube' ^TTicTdjuevoc cdqpa
eiTTeiv.
B fiiaevc TOi TTaTe'pujv /ieT' d)aeivovec eux6|ae9'i5
etvai'. f) fdp TOiauTri biacpopd luf) TTapopujjaevri bibdHei tov veov dcTeiov fiYeTc9ai Tfjv dTucpiav Kai jaeTpioTriTa, Tfjv be lieTaXauxiav Kai irepiauToXoTiav ibc cpauXov euXapeTc9ai. xPHCiMov be Kai t6 toO 'ATaiueVvovoc 20 KaTavoeTv dvTa09a. t6v |uev Tdp C9€veXov dTTpocau- briTOV TrapfiX9e, toO b' 'Obucce'ujc ouk ^iaAricev dXX' ^ILieivpaTO Kai TrpocriTopeucev
'ujc Tvuj x^OM^voio" TrdXiv b' 6 Y€ XdZieTO
)Li09ov \ 2J^
t6 laev Tdp Traciv dTToXoTeTc9ai 9epaTTeuTiK6v Kai ouk C dHiuJiaaTiKov " t6 be TrdvTUJV KaTacppoveTv uTrepficpavov
1, 105— 106 H. 6, 102— 104 R.
1. Hom. B 226 2. KXiciric idem: KXicfr) 5. Id. A
128 8. Id. B 231 11. Id. A 402 13. Id. A 404
24. Id. A 357
POETAS AUDIRE DEBEAT 67
Kai dv6r|TOV, apicta b' 6 Aioiaribnc ev ixkv Trj iudx^ ciujTTa KaKcuc dKOUuuv \jtt6 toO paciXeuuc" ^ieTd bk TTiv )iidxriv TTapprjCia XPHTai irpoc auTov
'dXKfiv iilv jJLOi TTpuJTOV oveibicac ev AavaoTcw*. 6 eu b' exei Kai q)povi|Liou bmqjopdv dvbpoc Kai )adv- Teujc TTavriYupiKoO }jLr\ TTapaXmeTv. 6 iuev ^dp KdX- Xac ou cuveTbe tov Kaipov, dXX' ev TTXri6ei TTap' ou- bev cTTOiricaTO KaTriTopficai toO paciXe'uJc aic tov Xoi- laov auToTc eTraYaTOVTOC • 6 bk NecTUjp PouX6|uevoc 10 ejLiPaXeTv Xoyov uTrep tujv TTpoc tov 'AxiXXea biaX- Xaf ujv, iva |Lif| bia^aXeTv boKfj tov 'AYa|ae'|Livova rrpoc d t6 TrXfiOoc ujc d|uapT6vTa Kai xPnc«M£vov opYr), 'baivu baTTa Yepouciv • eoiKe toi, ou toi d€iKe'c. TToXXujv b' dYpo)Lie'vujv tuj rreiceai 6c Kev dpicTriv 15 pouXfjv PouXeucr)'. Kai iLiCTd To beTTTVOv lHaTT0CTe'XXei touc TTpecpeic* toOto Ydp nv eTTavdpGujcic djuapTiaC; eKeTvo be KaTr]- Yopia Kai TTpoTTriXaKiCjuoc.
"€ti bk Kai Tdc ^v ToTc Yeveci biaqpopdc CKeTTTeov» 20 ujv toioOtoc ecTiv 6 tpottoc. oT juev Tpujec iTriaci |ueTd KpauYnc Kai Gpdcouc, oi b' 'Axaioi
'ciYri beibi6Tec crnudvTopac '. TO Ydp ev x^PcT tuuv TToXe|uiujv ovtujv qpopeTcGai touc E dpxovTac dvbpeiac d)ua Kai Treieapxiac cr)|ueTov. 69ev ^o 6 |uev TTXdTUJv iQilei touc vij6youc cpopeTcGai Kai Td aicxpd ludXXov f| touc Tr6vouc Kai touc Kivbuvouc, 6 be KdTUJV eXeYe qpiXeTv touc epuGpiuuvTac ludXXov f| Touc uJXpiuJVTac. ecTi be Kai tujv eTraYYeXiuJv ibioc XapaKTfjp. 6 )Liev Ydp AdXujv erraYYeXXeTai
1,106— 117H. 6,104— 105R,
3. Hom. I 34 12. Id. I 70 21. Id. A 431
68 QUOMODO ADOLESCENS
'xoqppa Tctp ec ctpaTov eijui biaiuTrepec oqpp' av
lKUJ|Liai
vn' 'AYajue)Livove'riv ',
6 be Aio|ur|bric eTTaYTe^J^CTai luev oubev, fJTTOv b' av F cprici qpoPnQnvai |ue9' eTepou iTe|UTr6)uevoc. 'GWriviKov & ouv Kai dcTcTov f) Ttpovoia, pap^apiKOv be Kai cpaO- Xov f] GpacuTric" Kai bei t6 )uev Z;r|XoOv t6 be buc- Xepaiveiv. excTai be tivoc ouk dxpriCTOu Geujpiac Kttl t6 TTcpi Touc Tpuuac Kai t6v "GKTopa TTdGoc, tou AiavToc auTUJ |uovo|uaxeTv |ueX\ovTOC. 6 |uev Ydp lo AkxuXoc 'lc6|uoT ttuktou TTXritevTOc eic t6 ttpocuuttov, Kai KpauTfic Tcvojuevrjc 'oiov' emev 'f) dcKricic dcTiv. 01 6euj)uevoi poOuciv, 6 bk TrXriTeic ciujTia'. toO be TTOirjToO XeTOVTOc oti t6v AiavTa iieta tluv ottXujv TTpoTovTtt XajuTTp6v 01 juev "GXXrivec ^'xaipov opOuv- is Tec, 30 ' Tpoiac be Tpojuoc aiv6c eTrr|Xu6e TuTa eKacTov, "GKTopi t' auTUj 6u|u6c evi CTr|6ecci TrdTacce', . Tic ouK dv dTdcaiTO Trjv biacpopdv; toS juev Kivbu- veuovTOc fi Kapbia Trriba juovov, ujCTrep TTaXaieiv vf) 20 Ai' f| CTabiobpo)ueTv jueXXovTOc, tuuv be 6euj)uevuuv Tpe)uei Kai TrdXXcTai t6 ctju)ua bi' euvoiav Kai qp6pov uTTep ToO paciXeuuc. evTa06a be Kai Tfiv tou KpaTi- CTOu Trp6c t6v KdKiciov biacpopdv dTTo6eajpr)T€OV. 6 nkv Tdp GepciTTic 25
'exeicTOC b' 'AxiXfii judXiCT' fiv nb' 'Obuctii',
b6 b' A\'ac dei Te tuj 'AxiXXeT TTpocqpiXfjC Kai TTp6c t6v "€KTopa XeTei Trepi auToO
1, 107H. 6, 105-107 E.
1. Homer. K 325 15. irpoiidvTa*: ttoioOvtujv 17.
Homer. H 215 26. Id. B 220
POETAS AUDIRE DEBEAT 69
'vOv jaev br) cdqpa eiceai oioGev oToc oToi Kai AavaoTciv dpicTfiec )neTeaci, Kai laei' 'AxiXXna pr|Er|Vopa 0u|uo\eovTa'. Kai toOto )Li^v 'AxiXXeuuc t6 e-fKd))ui6v ecTi, Td b' 5 iEr]c ijTTep dTrdvTOJV eipriTai XPHCIMUJC
'fi)Lieic b" ei)iiev toToi o'i dv ceGev dvTidcaijuev, Ktti TToXeec', ouTe |u6vov out' dpiCTOv dTToqpaivuuv ^auTov dXXd lueTd TToXXujv 6)uoiujc buvdjuevov d)uuvac9ai. TaOTa c n juev ouv kavd rrepi biacpopdC; dv )uri KdKeTvo pou- XuL))ue9a TTpocXaPeTv, oti tujv Tpuuujv daXuuKaci ttoX- Xoi ZiujvTec, oubeic be tuuv 'Axaiuuv, Kai tuuv juev uTTOTTeTTTiuKaciv cvioi ToTc TroXe)uioic, ujCTTep 6 "Abpa- CTOc, 01 'AvTi|udxou TTaibec, 6 AuKduuv, auT6c 6 15 "€ktuup b€6]uevoc Trepi Taqpfic toO 'AxiXXeujc, eKeivuuv b' oubeic, ujc papPapiKoO toO keTeueiv Kai uTroTTi- TTTeiv ev ToTc dYUJCiv ovtoc, 'GXXriviKoO be toO vmdv iaax6)uevov »1 dTT09vr|CKeiv.
11. 'GTTei b' ujCTTep ev TaTc vojuaTc f] )uev jue'- 20 XiTTa biuuKei to dv9oc, r\ b' aiH t6v 9aXX6v, fi b'D uc Triv piZiav, dXXa be Ziuja to CTTep)ua Kai t6v Kap- tt6v, outuuc ev TaTc dvaTvuuceci tujv TTOiri)udTuuv o juev dTTav9iZ!eTai Tfjv iCTOpiav, 6 b' eiuqpueTai tuj KdX- Xei Ktti Trj KaTacKeurj tuiv ovojudTuuv, Ka9dKep 6 'Api- 25 CTOcpdvric TTepi toO Eupmibou qpqci
'XpuJ)aai Ydp auToO toO cTojuaToc tlu cTpoT-
t6Xuj', o'i be Tuuv TTp6c t6 fj^oc eipri)uevuuv ujqpeXi|uujc exov- Tai, Trp6c ouc be vOv f^Tv 6 X6toc ecTiv, uTTOjui)uvfi-
1, 108— 109 H. 6, 107— 108 R,
1. Hom. H 226 6. Id. H 231 9. 6uvd|Lievov W: 6uva- luevujv 11. Kai ante iroWoi delevitW 26.Meinek. II. p.ll42
70 QUOMODO ADOLESCENS
CKU))iev auTOuc 6ti beivov dcTi tov )aev (piX6)uiu6ov )ari XavGdveiv Tct Kaivojc icTopou)Lieva Kai TrepiTTiJuc, }ir\hk Tov qpiXoXoYOv eKcpeuYeiv Td KaOapuJc necppac- E jLieva Kai priTopiKujc, tov be 9iX6ti)liov Kai (piXdKaXov Ktti ixx] TTaibiac dXXd Traibeiac evcKa Troir|)LidTUJV dTTTo- 5 )aevov dpYujc Kai d)LieXiJuc dKOueiv tujv TTpoc dvbpeiav f\ cujqppocuvriv dvaTtecpujvriiLi^vujv. oia Kai TaOT' ecTi
'Tubeibri, Ti TtaGovTe XeXdc)ae9a 0oupiboc dXKfic; dXX* dYe beupo, TreTTOv, Trap' eV iCTaco" i)Y\ Ydp
eXcYXOc 10
fcccTai, ei Kev vfiac eXrj KopuBaioXoc "€ktujp'.
t6 Ydp ^v Kivbuvuj ToO biaqpeapfivai Kai drroX^cGai fieTd TtdvTUJV ovTa tov (ppovi)LiLUTaTov opfiv t6 ai- cxp6v beboiK^Ta Kai t6 eTroveibiCTOv dXXd )Lifi 0dvaTOV, ejUTTa0fi Troif|cei Trp6c dpeTf]V t6v ve'ov. Kai t6 is
'xctipe b' 'AOrjvairi TTeTrvu)Lievuj dvbpi biKaiuj' F toioOtov eTnXoYic)Li6v bibujci, |ur|Te TtXouciuj tivi juirife KaXu) t6 cu)|ua )if|T' icxupui Tfiv 0e6v x«ipoucav dXXd qppovi|uuj Kai biKaiiij TTOificac. Kal rrdXiv t6v 'Obuc- cea qpdcKOuca ixr\ Trepiopfiv ixrihk TrpoXeiTreiv 20
'ouveK' ^TrriTf|C kTi Kai dYXivooc Kai exe^qppujv', ^vbeiKvuTai )Li6vov eivai tuuv fi|ueTdpujv OeoqpiXec Kai 0eTov dpeTfjv, eiYe bfi Td 6)Lioia xaipeiv toTc 6)Lioioic 31 TreqpuKev. eTrei be )LieYdXou boKoOvTOC eivai Kai ov- Toc ToO KpaTcTv 6pYfic p.e\l6v ecTiv fi qpuXaKfi Kai fi 25 Trpovoia ToO jufi TrepmeceTv opYfj |urib' dXujvai, Kai TaOTa bei xoTc dvaYiYViucKouciv uTTobeiKVueiv )Lifi Trap-
1,109-UOH. C,108-nOK.
5. iTai6iac Reiskius: TraiYviac 9. dW ciYe Homerus
A 313: &\\& Ye 15. To] 616 roO? 16. Homer. y 52
21. Id. V 332
POETAS AUDIRE DEBEAT 71
epYUJC, OTi Tov TTpia,uov 6 'AxiXXeuc ouk dvacxeTiKOC ujv oube Tipaoc ficuxiav dTeiv KeXeOei Kai ixr\ TiapoHu- veiv auTOv
'juriKeTi vOv |li' ipiQile, fipov (voeuj be Kai auToc 5 "eKTopd Toi Xucai, AioOev be jlioi dTTeXoc nXGe) [XY\ ce, Tepov, oub' auTov evi KXiciriciv edcuj, Kai iKe'Triv rrep eovTa, Aioc b' dXiTUjjuai ecpeTiudc', B Kai Tov "GKTOpa Xoucac Kai TrepicTeiXac auToc erri ttiv dtrrivriv TiBrjci, trpiv riKiCjuevov utto toO TraTpoc 10 6cp9fivai,
'juri 5 iuev dxvu|uevr| Kpabiri XoXov ouk ^pucaiTO, TTaiba Ibujv, 'AxiXfji b' opivBeiri qpiXov fiTOp Kai i. KaTaKTeiveie , Aioc b' dXiTriTai ecpeTjudc*. t6 Tdp eTTicqpaXujc Trpoc opTfiv exovTa Kai cpucei Tpa- 15 xuv ovTa Kai 9u|Uoeibfi |ufi Xav9dveiv eauTov dXX ' e5euXapeTc9ai Kai (puXdTTec9ai Tdc aiTiac Kai Trpo- KaTaXajupdveiv tuj Xoticjuuj TToppuj^ev ottujc oub'c OKUJV tuj TTd9ei TrepmeceiTai, 9au|uacTfic ecTi Trpovoiac. ouTUJ be bei Kai Trpoc |ue9riv tov cpiXoivov exeiv Kai 20 TTpoc ^pujTa Tov epujTiKov • ujcrrep 6 'ATriciXaoc oux UTTe|ueivev utto toO KaXoO cpiXri9nvai TrpociovTOC, 6 hk KOpoc oub' IbeTv Tfiv TTdv9eiav eToXjurice, tujv dnai- beuTUJV TOuvavTiov uTreKKaujuaTa toTc TTd9eci cuXXeTov- Tujv Kal TTpoc a )udXiCTa KaKujc Kai 6Xic9ripujc exou- 25 civ auTouc TTpoTeiuevuiv. 6 b' 'Obucceuc ou |u6vov ^auTov dvexei 9u)uou|U€vov, dXXd Kai t6v TriXeiuaxov CK ToO XoTou cuvibujv x«XeTT6v ovTa Kai juicoTTOvripov D d|upXuvei Kai irapacKeudZiei Tr6ppuj9ev fjcuxiav dTeiv Kai dvexec9ai, KeXeuujv
1 , 110-111 H. 6. 110—111 B.
3. auTov*: aOTov oOtujc 4. Homer. Q 560 11. Id. Q 584
72 QUOMODO ADOLESCENS
'el bi )u' dTi)Liiicouci bopLOV KOtTa, cov be qpi-
Xov KTIP T€TXdTLu ev cTr|0ecci KaKiuc TrdcxovToc djueio, fiv Trep Kai bid buj|Lia Ttobujv eXKuuci Qvpale r\ pe'X6Civ pdXXuucr cO b' eicopoiuv dvexecBar. 5 ujcrrep ydp touc ittttouc ouk ev toTc bp6|aoic x«^i-
VOUCIV dXXd TTpO TUJV bp6)UUJV, OUTUJ TOUC buCKaGCKTOUC
TTpoc Td beivd Kai 9u|uoeibetc TTpOKaTaXaiupdvovTec Toic XoTicjuoTc Kai TTpoKaTapTuovTec ctti touc dTUJvac dTouci. beT be lurib^ tujv 6vo|udTUJV djueXiiuc dKoueiv, 10 E dXXd Triv |uev KXedvGouc TTaibidv irapaiTeTcear KaT- eipujveueTai Tdp ^ctiv otc TToocTTOiou)uevoc iB]^d- c9ai t6
*ZeO TTttTep "Ibri^ev |Li€be'uJV' Kai t6 15
'ZeO dva AujbujvaTe' KeXeuujv dvaTiTVuucKeiv uqp' ev, iLc tov ^k Tfic t^c dva- 9ujuiuj)Lievov depa bid Triv dvdbociv dvabujbujvaTov ovTa. Kai XpuciTTTTOC bk TToXXaxoO T^icxpoc ^tiv, ou TTaiZiujv dXX' eupriciXoTUJV dTTi9dvujc, Kai TTapa^ia- 20 Zdjuevoc eupuoTTa Kpovibr|V eivai tov beivov ev tuj biaXeTec9ai Kai biapepriK^Ta Tr) buvd|uei toO X6tou. pdXTiov be TaOTa toTc TPajUjuaTiKoTc TTapevTac ^KeTva F ]udXXov TTi^Zleiv oic d)ua t6 xPHCij^ov Kai Tri0av6v evecTiv 25
'oube jiie 9u)Li6c dvojTev, eTrei |ud9ov e')U|uevai
k0X6c' Kai
1,111— 112 H. 6,111— 113 R.
1. Homer. ir 274 14. M. T 320 16. Id. TT 233 20. e6pr)Ci\0TU)v L. Dindorfius: eijpeciXoYOJv 25. ^vecTiv*: dcTiv 26. Homer. Z 444
POEI AS AUDIRE DEBEAT 73
'Traciv T«P eTTicTttTO fieiXixoc eivai*. Tr|v Te YWP dvbpeiav dirocpaivuiv |LidGr|)aa Kai t6 Trpoc- cpiXuuc CLjxa Kai Kexapic|uevujc dv0pujTTOic OjuiXeiv dTi' eTTicTrijLiric Kai KaTd Xoyov YiTvecGai vojuiZujv TrpoTpe- o TTei juf] djueXeiv eauTUJV, dXXd |uav9dveiv Td KaXd Kai Trpocexeiv toTc bibdcKouciv, liic Kai Tfjv CKaiOTriTa Kai Tfiv beiXiav djuaOiav Kai dTVOiav oijcav. cqpobpa be TOUToic KdKeTva cujucpujvd ecTiv d XeTei Ttepi tou Aioc Kai ToO TToceibujvoc
10 fi ludv d|ucpoTe'poiciv 6)i6v Tevoc r\b' la TrdTpr), 32 dXXd Zeuc TrpoTCpoc TeTOvei Kai TcXeiova rjbri.
GeioTaTOv Tdp dTTOcpaivei Tfjv cppovriciv Kai paciXiKiu- TaTOv, ev f} TiGeTai Tfjv lueTicTrjv uicepoxfiv tou Aioc, ttTe br] Kai Tdc dXXac dpeTdc eTrecGai TauTr) voixilujv. 15 e0icTeov b' d|ua Kai toutujv eTpriTopoTiuc tov veov dKOueiv
'vpeuboc b' ouK lpe'er |udXa Tdp TieTrvuiuevoc
ecTi'
Kttl
Kai
''AvTiXoxe, TTpocGev iTeTTVU|ieve, ttoTov epeEac; rjcxuvac iuev i}xf\v dpeTriv, pXdvpac be |uoi ittttouc'
TXauKe, Tiri be cu toToc eujv uTrepoTrXov eeiTiac; b
iL TTeTTOv, f\ T* eqpdjunv ce Ttepi cppevac e)U)uevai
25 dXXujv',
ujc ouTe vpeubo)aevujv tujv cppovijuujv ouTe KaKO)aaxouv-
Tujv ev ToTc dTufCiv outc Ttap' dHiav eTepoic eTKa-
XouvTUJV. Ktti Tov TTdvbapov be TreicGfivai Xe'TUJv bid
1, 112-1I3H. 6, n*-114R.
1. Homer. P 671 10. Id. N 351 17. Id. f 20. 328 20. Id. V 570 23. Id. P 170
74 QUOMODO ADOLESCENS
Tf]V dqppocuvriv xd opKia cuYXeai bfiXoc ecriv ouk dv dbiKficai Tov (ppovijuov fiYOUiuevoc. 6)Lioia b' ecTi Kai irepi cuuqppocuvric UTTObeiKVueiv IqpicTdvTa toTc outuo X€YO|ue'voic
'tuj be Yuvfi TTpoiTou eTrejufivaTO , bV "AvTeia, 6 KpuTTTabir] qpiXoTriTi )LiiYfi|uevar dWd tov ou ti C ireTG' dYa9d q)poveovTa, bdiqppova BeWepo-
qpovTriv ' Kai
'ri b' fJTOi t6 TTpiv |u^v dvaivcTO epYOV deiKec, lo
bTa KXuTai)uvficTpri • qppeci Ydp k^xP^t' dYa6^civ'. ev laev ouv toutoic rf} q)povficei Tf]V tou cuuqppoveTv alTiav dTTobibaiciv , ev be TaTc irapd Tdc |udxac k€- Xeuceciv ^KdcTOTe XeYuuv
'aibuuc, il) AuKioi. irdce qpeuYCTe; vuv 9ooi ^ctc* is Kai
'dXX' ev qppeci 9ec9€ ^KacTOc
aibuj Kai vejueciv • bf) Ydp lueYa veiKoc opiupev ' D dvbpeiouc eoiKe TTOieTv touc cuuqppovac bid t6 aibeT- c9ai Td aicxpd Kai Tdc fjbovdc buvajuevouc uTrepPai- 20 veiv Kai Touc Kivbuvouc uqpicTac9ai. dqp' wy koX Ti)u69eoc 6p|uri9eic ou KaKuuc ^v toTc TTe'pcaic touc "GXXrivac rrapeKdXei
'ce'Pec9' aibuu cuvepY^v dpeTdc bopi|udxou *", AicxOXoc be Kai t6 7Tp6c boHav exeiv dTucpuuc Kai |uf| 25 biacopeTc9ai |urib' eTTaipec9ai toTc TTapd tuuv ttoXXuuv iTTaivoic ev tu) qppoveTv Ti6eTai TTepi tou 'Ajuqpiapdou Ypdqpoiv
1, 113— 114H. 6, 114— 116E.
5. Homer. Z 160 10. Id. y 265 15. Id. U 422 17. Id. N 121 24. Bergk. p. 1271 ' 25. AicxuA.oc] Sept. 599
POETAS AUDIRE DEBEAT 75
*ou fap boKeiv dpicTOC dW eivai 9eXef, PaGeiav dXoKa bid qppevoc KapTTOiJ)iievoc, E
dqp' fic xd Kebvd pXacidvei pouXeu|naTa ' •
t6 Tdp ecp' ^auTUj Kai Tri bia9ecei Tr) Ttepi auTov 6 oucr] KpaTiCT»;! lneTaXoqppoveiv voOv exovTOc dvbpoc ecTi. TTdvTUJV ouv dvaTOjuevujv eic Trjv qppovriciv drrobeiKVUTai irav eiboc dpeTfic eTriTiTvd)Lievov ck X6- Tou Kai bibacKaXiac.
12. 'H laev ouv [ueXiTTa qpuciKUJC iv toTc bpijuu-
10 TaToic dv9eci Kai TaTc TpaxuTdTaic dKdv9aic eEaveu- picKei t6 XeioTaTOv laeXi Kai xpncTiKUJTaTov, oT be TTaTbec, dv 6p9ujc evTpeqpuJVTai toTc Troirijuaciv, Kai dTT6 Tujv qpauXouc Kai dTOTTOuc urroi|jiac exovTUJV eX- F Keiv Ti xPilci|uov djLiuJCTeTrujc |aa9ricovTai Kai ujcpeXi-
15 )iov. auTiKa touv uttotttoc ecTiv 6 'ATa|ae'|uvujv ujc bid bujpoboKiav dqpeic tt^c CTpaTeiac t6v ttXouciov eKeTvov t6v ttiv Ai9r|v xapicdjuevov auTU»
'bujp', iva )ur| oT eTToi9* utt6 "IXiov rjvejuoeccav dXX' auTOu TepTTOiTO iuevujv * jueTa Tdp oi ebujKev
20 Zeuc dqpevoc'. 6p9u»c be Te eiToiricev, ibc 'ApiCTOTeXric qpriciv, TrrTTOV dTa9fiv dv9pujTT0u toioutou 7TpoTi)ur|cac ■ oube Tdp Kuv6c dvTdHioc oub' ovou )ud Aia beiXdc dvfip Kai dvaXKic, UTTO ttXoutou Kai juaXaKiac bieppuriKoic. Trd- 33
25 Xiv aicxiCTa boKeT t6v uT6v fi GeTic eqp' fibovdc Tra- paKaXeTv Kai dva|ui)uvriCKeiv dqppobiciujv. dXXd Kdv- Tau9a beT 7Tapa9eujpeTv Trjv toO 'AxiXXe'ujc eTKpdTeiav, OTi Tqc Bpicriiboc epujv fjKOucric 7Tp6c auTov, eibibc Tfjv ToO piou TeXeuTfjv ifjvc oucav ou crreubei tujv
1, 1U-H5H. 6, 116-117 R,
7. ^K X6tou Krebsius: ^Kdcrou 17. tov* 18. Hom. V 297
76 QUOMODO ADOLESCENS
flbovujv 7Tp6c dTt6Xauciv oub' ujcttcp o\ ttoXXoi 7T€v- eei Tov q)iXov drrpaEia Kai 7TapaXeiq;ei tuuv KaGriKOv- TUJV, dXXct Tujv )uev fjbovtJuv bid Trjv XuTrriv dTTe'xeTai, Taic bk TTpdHeci xai Taic CTpaTriTiaic ^vepToc icix. TTdXiv 6 'ApxiXoxoc ouk drTaiveiTai XuTroujievoc )aev » B eTTi iw dvbpi Tfic dbeXcpfjc bieq)9ap|LievLu KaTd 9aXac- • cav, oivuj bk Kal TTaibid TTp6c Tf|v XuiTriv iudxecGai biavooujuevoc. aiTiav iuevToi Xotov Ixoucav eipriKev
'ouTe Ti Tdp KXaiiuv ir|C0)iai ouTe kukiov 9r|ciju TepTTiuXdc Kai 9aXiac dq^ertujv'. ei Tdp ^Keivoc oubev ev6|LiiZev TTOir|ceiv KdKiov Tep- TTUjXdc Ktti 9aXiac dcperTUJv, ttujc fiiiiv Td TTapovTa XeTpov e£ei qpiXocoq)oOci Kai TToXiTeuo|ievoic Kai TTpoT- C oOciv eic dTOpdv koi KaTa^aivouciv eic 'AKabriiueiav Kai TeuJpTictv dq)e'TTOuciv; 69ev oub' ai TTapabiop9(juceic q)auXujc exouciv aic KXedv9r|C ixpY\caTO Kai 'AvTic9e- vnc, 6 laev eu )adXa touc 'A9rivaiouc ibujv 9opupr|cav- TaC iv TUJ 9€dTpuj
'Ti b' aicxp6v el fif| toici xP^Mevoic bOKei'; TTapapdXXujv eu9uc
'aicxp6v t6 t' aicxpov, kSv boKrj kSv hy\ bOKrj', 6 bk KXedv9ric TTepi toO ttXoutou
'qjiXoic Te boOvai ciJu|Lid t' eic vdcouc TTecov _
baTTdvaici cujcai' )aeTaTpdq)UJV outuj D 'TTdpvaic Tc boOvai cuj)jd t' eic vocouc 7Tec6v
barrdvaic dTTiTpTqjai. Ka\ 6 Zi^vujv dTravop9ou|Li€Voc t6 toO Coq)OKXeouc
1,115— 116H. 0,117—119
9. Bergk. p. 687' 19. Nauck. p. 293 23. Eur
El. 428
i
d
POETAS AUDIRE DEBEAT 77
'ocTic bk rrpoc Tupavvov eiaTTopeiieTai , Keivou 'cTi boOXoC; kciv eXeOeepoc |li6Xii*
laeTeTpaqpev
'ouK lcTi bouXoc, fjv eXeu9epoc moXt]', 5 Til» eXeu6epqj vuv cuveKcpaiviuv tov dbea Kai laeTaXo- cpQova Kai dTarreivuJTOv. ti bx] KOiXuei Kai fiiiiac Taic TOiauTaic UTro(pujvr|ceci touc veouc TrapaKaXeTv irpoc t6 PcXtiov, outuu ttujc xpuJ)iievouc toic XeTO|Lievoic; T6b' ecTi t6 Z;riXujT6v dvGpuuTroic, otlu E
10 t6Eov |U€pi|uvric eic 6 pouXeTai rrecii. ouK, dXX'
OTUJ
ToHov laepijuvnc eic 6 cujuqpepei Tre'cr]. t6 Tdp a juf) bei pouXojuevov Xajupdveiv Kai tutx«- 15 veiv oiKTp6v dcTi Kai dZriXov.
*ouK eTTi rraciv c' eqpuTeuc' dTa0oTc, 'ATdjuejuvov, 'ATpeuc. beT be ce xaipeiv Kai XuTteTcGai*. |ud Aia, qprico)uev, dXXd bei ce xwipeiv, }ay\ XuTreTcGai 20 TUTXdvovTa jueTpiuJV •
ou Tdp eTTi Ttdciv c' eqpuTeuc' dTaGoTc *ATdjue)uvov, 'ATpeuc.
'aiai Tob' fibTi GeTov dvGpujTTOic KttKdv,
OTav Tic eibrj TdTa06v, XP^fai be juri'. F
25 0ripiuubec juev ouv Kai dXoTOV Kai oiKTp6v eiboTa to PeXTiov utt6 toO x^ipovoc eE dKpaciac Kai luaXaKiac dTec0ai.
1 , 116- 117 H. 6, 1 19-120 E.
1. Nauck. p. 253 9. Id. p. 695 15. d.Zr]Kov*: &Zr]- Xov xal 16. Eur. Iph. A. 29 23. Nauck. p. 449
78 QUOMODO ADOLESCENS
'TpoTTOc ^cG' 6 TreiOiJuv toO X^tovtoc, ou Xotoc*. Tponoc laev ouv kqi Xofoc f\ tpottoc bid Xotou, KaGdirep \TTTreuc bid x«^*vou Kai bid TtribaXiou ku- Pepvr|Tr|c, oubev outu» (piXdvGpiuTTOV oub^ cuTT^vec exoucric tiic dpeTfic opTavov dic tov Xotov. 5
34 'Trpoc 6fiXu veuei ^dXXov f| 'tti Tdppeva;
6ttou TTpocrj t6 KdXXoc, djucpibeHioc '. riv be peXTiov emeiv
OTTOu TTpocrj t6 coicppov, d)Li(pibe'Hioc iLc dXriGuuc Kai icoppoTTOc* 6 b' uqp' fibovfic Kai lo ujpac iLbe KdKei )ieToiaKiZ:6|aevoc ^TrapicTepoc Kai dp^- Paioc.
'q)6poc Td Geia toici cuuqppociv ppOTuuv*. Ktti lufiv oubajiwc, dXXd
6dpcoc Td 6eTa toici cuxppociv PpoTuJv, qpdpoc be toTc dqppoci Kai dvof|TOic Kai dxapicTOic, B OTi Kai Triv TravT^c aiTiav dTa6oO buvaiuiv Kai dpxnv ujc pXdTTToucav u^popuuvTai Kai bebiaci. t6 |i^v ouv Tfic eTTavop6uuceuuc t^voc toioOtov ^cti.
13. Tfiv b' im ttXcov tuuv XeTO)aevuuv XPIciv uTTebeiHev opeuuc 6 XpucmTTOC, oti bei iueTdTeiv Kai biapipdZleiv dTTi Td djuoeibfj t6 xPnOMOV. 6 Te Tdp 'Hcioboc eiTTuuv
'oub' av poOc dTToXoiT', el infi tcitujv KaKOC ein* Kai TTepi Kuv6c TauT6 Ka\ Trepi ovou X^t^i Kai Trepi ro TrdvTuuv 6jLioiuuc tuuv dTToXec6ai buvaiuevuuv. Kai iTdXiv ToO €upiTTibou XeTOVTOc ;
1, 117-118H. 6, 120— 122R!
1. Meinek. IV. p. 209 2. Tp6iT0C*: Kol TpoTTOc 3.
iTTTTCuc Grotius: iiTTroc kqI 6id*: Kal 6. Nauck. p. 283
13. Id. p. 695 24. 0. et D. 348
_J.
POETAS AUDIRE DEBEAT 79
'tic b' ^cTi boOXoc ToO GaveTv ctqppovTic ujv'; OTTaKOucTeov oti Kai rrepi ttovou Kai vocou TauTov ei- C prjKev. ibc t«P cpapjudtKOu Trpoc ev dp|u6cavToc v6- crma Tfjv buvajuiv KaTa)Lia96vTec oi laTpoi jueTaTOUci 5 Kai xpujVTtti Tipoc aTtav t6 TrapaTrXriciov, ouTui Kai X6tov KOivoOv Kai brmocieueiv Tf)v xP^iav buvdjuevov ou xPn Trepiopdv ^vi TTpdfMaTi cuvripTrmevov dXXd KiveTv eTTi TTdvTa Td 6|uoia, Kai touc ve'ouc eGiZieiv Tfjv KOivdTriTa cuvopdv Kal )ueTacpepeiv oHeuuc t6 ol- 10 KeTov, ev ttoXXoTc TTapabeiYluaci TTOioujuevouc |ueXe'Tr|v Kai dcKTiciv oEuriKoiac, Tva toO Mevdvbpou XeYOVTOC
'jUttKdpioc ocTic ouciav Kai voOv exei' toOto Kai TTepl b6Er|c Kai Trepi fiTejuoviac Kai TTepi X6tou buvdjueuuc eipfic9ai vo|uiZ!uuci, Tfiv be TTpocTovD 15 'AxiXXea tov ev CKupuj Ka9f|juevov ev TaTc TTap9evoic TeTevri|ue'vr]V CTTiTTXriSiv utto toO 'Obucceuuc
'cu h% uj t6 Xa|UTTp6v qpujc dTTOcPevvuc t^vouc, Haiveic, dpicTou TTaTpoc '€XXfivujv tcTiwc'; Kai TTpoc t6v dcujTOv oTujvTtti XeTec9ai Kai TTp6c t6v 20 aicxpoKepbn Kai TTp6c t6v d)ueXfi Kai dTTaibeuTOV TTiveic, dpicTou TTaTp6c '6XXf|vujv T^Tiuc, f) Kupeueic fi 6pTUT0K0TreTc f| KaTTriXeueic fj tokotXu- cpeTc, luribev |ueTa qppovujv |UTib' dHiov TfjC euTeveiac; '|un ttXoOtov emric. ouxi 9au|udZ[uj 9€6v 25 6v x^ KaKicToc pabiujc eKTfjcaTo'. E
ouKoOv jurjbe bdHav eiTrric )uribe ciu|uaTOC eujuopqpiav
1, 118— 120H. 6, 122— 124R.
1. Nauck. p. 523 2. Taurov*: TaiL)Td 6. koivouv W: KOivov 11. dEurjKoiac Stephanus: oEuKoiac 12. Mei- nek. IV. p. 103 17. Nauck. p. 653 19. oiujvTai*: olov T€ 24. Nauck. p. 294 25. x^ nescio quis: Kol 6
80 QUOMODO ADOLESCENS
lir\bk cTpatriYiKriv x5^«M^^c( jliti&' lepariKOV ciecpavov, ujv Kai Touc KaKiCTOuc 6pijujuev TUYX«vovTac.
'ttic beiXiac Tctp aicxpa YiYveTai TeVva'
Kai vai |ud Aia Tfic dKoXaciac Kal Tfic beicibai|uoviac
Kttl TOO (pGoVOU Kai TUJV dXXuJV VOCTl|udTUJV dTrdVTUJV. 5
dpicTa b' eipriKOTOc 'Ojuripou t6
'AucTTapi eiboc dpicTe Kai t6
F '"€ktop eiboc dpicTe'
(vpdTOu tdp dTTOcpaivei Kai Xoibopiac dHiov ih jurjbev lo ecTiv dYaGov euMopqpiac KdXXiov) eqpapiuocTeov touto TOic ojuoioic, KoXouovTtt Touc |ueYaXoqppovouvTac erri toTc jurjbevoc dHioic, Kai bibdcKOVTa touc veouc oveiboc fiYeTc9ai Kai Xoibopiav t6 'xP^ctciv dpicTe'
35 Kai 'beiTTVOic dpicTc' Kal 'rraiciv f| urroZuYioic dpiCTe' i5 Kai vf) Aia t6 XeYeiv ecpeHnc dpicTe. bei Ydp ck tujv KaXujv biuuKeiv Tfiv uTiepoxfiv Kai Ttepi Td TrpoiTai TTpujTOv eivai Kal |ueYav ev toTc )ueYicTOic* f) b' dTT6 luiKpujv boHa Kai qpauXujv dboHoc ecTi Kai dqpiXoTifioc. TOUTO b' fiiuac eu9uc UTTO|ui]uvTicKei t6 TrapdbeiYjua toO' Touc ipoYOuc dTTo96a»peTv Kai touc erraivouc dv toTc '0|ufipou ludXiCTa TTOif||uaciv • ^V^ctcic Ydp YiTveTai lueYdXri toO Td cojjuaTiKd Kai Tuxrjpd MH jueYdXrjc dEia CTTOubfic vojuiZeiv. ttpuutov }Jiev Ydp ev TaTc beSiuu- ceci Kai dvaKXfjceciv ou KaXouc oube TTXouciouc oub'25 icxupouc TTpocaYOpeuouciv, dXXd TOiauTaic euqpr|)uiaic XpuJVTai
B 'biOYevec AaepTidbri, TToXjufjxav' 'Obucceu'
:, 120— 121 H. 6, 124— 125 B
3. Nauck. p. 695 7. Homer. T 39 9. Id. P 142
M> toOto*: toOto Kai 20. toO*: t6 28. Homer. B 173
POETAS AUDIRE DEBEAT 81
Ktti
'■"€ktop uie TTpid)Lioio , Au lafiTiv dTdXavTe' Kai
'w 'AxiXeO TTriXeoc uie, )LieYa KOboc 'Axaiuuv' 5 Kai
'bie MevoiTidbri) tiu e|uuj Kexapicjueve eujauj'. etreiTa XoibopoOciv oubev ecpaTTTOiuevoi tuuv cuj)uaTi- Kujv, dXXd ToTc d)LiapTr|juaci touc i^jotouc eTricpe'povTec
'oivopapec, kuvoc 6)a|uaT' exujv, Kpabiqv b' 10 eXdcpoio'
Kai
Kai
'Aiav veiKOC dpicTe, KaKoqppabe'c "
'Mbo)ueveu, Ti Trdpoc Xa(Bpeuai; oube Ti ce XPH
15 XaPpaToptiv ejuevai' Kai
*ATav djaapToeiTec PouYdie'. Kai TeXoc 6 GepciTiic utto toO 'Obucceujc ou x^^^oc ou cpaXaKpoc ou KupTOC dXX' dKpiT6)uu9oc XoibopeiTai,
- Tov b' "HqpaiCTOV f) T€KoOca qpiXocppovoujuevri Trpoc- riTopeucev dTio Tf]c x^^otiitoc
'opceo KuXXoTTobiov, ejuov Te'Koc'. ouTwc "OjUTipoc KaTaYeXa tOuv aicxuvoiuevwv eTTi x^- XoTriciv fi TuqpXoTriciv, outc ipeKTOV fiYOU)aevoc t6 jjlx]
25 aicxp6v out' aicxpov t6 |ufi bi' fi|uac dXX' dTT6 Tuxnc YiYv6|uevov. buo br] TTepiYiYveTai jueYdXa toTc tOuvD TTOiriTuuv e9iZ!o)aevoic dKOueiv, t6 juev eic )aeTpi6Tr|Ta, laribevi Tuxr|V eTrax^iJuc Kai dvoriTUJc oveibiZieiv, t6 b'
1,121H. G, 125— 126 R.
2. Hom. H 47 4. Id. T 216 4. Id. A 608 9.
Id. A 225 12. Id. V 483 14. Id. V 474 17. Id. N 824 22. Id. O 331
Plutarchi Moralia. Vol. I. >>
82 QUOMODO ADOLESCENS
eic |aeYaXoqppoc\3vr|v, auTOuc xPHcaMCVOuc xuxaic |ar| TaTreivouceai ixr\b^ TapctTTecGai , qpepeiv be Trpdujc Kai CKijO|a)naTa Kai Xoibopiac Kai YeXuuTac, )udXicTa [Jikv t6 ToO OiXrmovoc exovTttc Trpoxeipov
'fibiov oubev oube laouciKiuTepov 5
^ct' 11 buvac8ai Xoibopouiuevov qpe'peiv*. av be cpaiVHTai tic emXrivyeujc beojaevoc, tujv diaap- TniuaTUJV Kai Tujv rraeujv dTnXa)apdv€c9ai, ujCTrep 6 Tpa*fiK6c "AbpacTOc, tou 'AXKiueujvoc eiTTOvTOC TTp6c auTOV 10
E 'dvbpoKTOVOu YVJvaiKoc 6)aoTevnc eqpuc', dTrcKpivaTO
'cu b' auToxeip T^ )ariTp6c fi c' dYeivaTo'. KaSdTrep Tap oi Td i)adTia juacTiTouvTec oux dTTTOVTai ToO cuj)LiaTOc, ouTUJC 01 bucTuxiac Tivdc f| bucTCveiac lo oveibiZiovTec eic Td ^ktoc evTeivovTai kcvwc Kai dvori- Tujc, Tfic vjjuxfic b' ou eiTTavouciv oube tujv dXrieuJc dTTavopeuiceujc beo)aevujv Kai bf|Eeujc.
14. Kai nr\v ujCTrep eirdvuj TTp6c Td cpaOXa koi
F pXapepd TTOifi)aaTa Xotouc Kai TVuj)aac dvTiTdccovTCC 20 evboEujv Kai ttoXitikujv dvbpujv dboKoO)aev dqpicTdvai Kai dvaKpoueiv Tfjv TricTiv, outujc 6 t» Sv dcTeiov eupuj)aev Trap' auTOic Kai xphctov, ^KTpeqpeiv XP^ '^cti auEeiv dTTobeiHeci Kai )aapTupiaic qpiXocoqpoic, dTTobi- bovTac Tfiv eupeciv eKeivoic. Kai Tdp biKaiov Kai 25 : ujcpeXi)aov, icxuv Tf)C TTicTeujc Kai dEiujjua TrpocXa)a- " pavoucric , oTav toTc dTr6 cKrivfjc XeTO.uevoic Kai TTp6c Xupav dbojuevoic Kai )aeXeTUJ)a€VOic iv bibacKaXeitu Td TTueaTopou boTMaTa Kai Td TTXdTUJVoc 6)aoXoTri, Kai
1,1 21-123 H. 6, 126-128 R.
5. Meinek. IV. p. 9 11. 13. Nauck. p. 695
POETAS AUDIRE DEBEAT 83
Td XiXouvoc TTapaTTeX|LtaTa Kai xd BiavTOC eiTi Tdc auTdc dT);i Tvwiuac eKeivoic toic TraibiKOic dvaYViuc- 36 laaciv. oSev ou Trape^pTiwc uTrobeiKTeov oti t6 jnev
'ou Toi, Te'KVOv e)Li6v, beboTai TToXe)ar|ia epTa, 5 dXXd cu t' iMep6evTa iueTepxeo epTa TotMOio'
Kai TO
•■Zeuc Totp Toi veMeca, 6t' djueivovi (puuTi ladxoio' oubev bia(pe'pei toO 'tvA0i cauT6v', dXXd ti^v auTriv exei bidvoiav eKeivoi" t6 be 10 'vnTTioi, oub' icaciv ocLu TtXeov fiiaicu TravToc '
Kttl t6
' 'f| b^ KaKri pouXf) Tuj pouXeucavTi KaKicTri'
TauT6v ecTi toic TTXdTuuvoc ev fopTia Kai TToXiTeiqt b b6TM«ci Ttepi ToO 't6 dbiKeiv KdKiov eivai toO dbiKei- i5c6ai' Kai toO KaKUJc Ttdcxeiv t6 Ttoieiv KaKUJc pXape- pouTepov. eTnppnTe'ov be Kai tuj toO AicxuXou
'edpcei* Tr6vou Tap ctKpov ouk exei xpovov'
OTi to0t6 ecTi t6 rrap' 'Gttikoupou BpuXoujuevov dei Kai eauMaZ;6|U€V0V , ujc 'oi jueTdXoi Tr6voi cuvt^mujc
20 eSdTOuciv, 01 be xp6vioi )ue'Teeoc ouk exouciv'. u)v t6 juev eipriKev 6 AicxuXoc evapTujc, t6 be tuj eipn- nevuj TrapaKei)iev6v ecTiv. ei Toip 6 ineTac Kai cuv- Tovoc ou Trapaiaevei tt6voc, ouk ecTi lueTac 6 Trapa- ILievujv oube bucKapTepriTOC. Td be toO 0e'cTTiboc
25 TauTi
1, 123— 124 H. 6, 128— 129 R.
4. ou Toi TeKvov I|i6v Homerus € 428: t^kvov kfxov ou Toi 7. Aristot. Rhet. II 9. Plutarch. de Vita et Poesi
Homeri §. 132 10. Hesiod. 0. et D. 40 12. Id. 265
13. ropTia] P. 473 A 17. Nauck. p. 83
6*
84 QUOMODO ADOLESCENS
'opac OTi Zeuc TuJbe TrpuuTeuei GeOuv, C ou vjjeuboc oube kojuttov ou juujpov ■^i.Xixiv
dcKoiv t6 b' fibu luoOvoc ouk eTricTaTai'
Ti biacpepei toO 'TTOppuu y«P ribovfic Kai Xurrric ibpu- Ttti t6 GeTov', dic TTXdTujv eXeTe. t6 be 5
' q)dcu))Liev 7tict6v KOboc exeiv dpeTdv ttXoOtoc be Kai beiXoTciv dvBpuuTTUJv 6|uiXeT'
XeYOiuevov utt6 tou BaKXuXibou Kai TTdXiv utt6 toO €upiTribou TTapaTrXriciuuc 10
'eTuu b* oubev TTpecpuTCpov vo|ui- 2uu Tac cuucppocuvac , eTrei' ToTc dTaGoTc dei cuvecTi' Kai t6 15
'Ti)udv Tttv i.TeTac6e, ttXoutiu b' dpeTdv KaTepTd- cacBai boKeTT', ev kOXoTc be Ka9r|cec6' dvoXpoi'
Dap' ouK dTTobeiSiv exei ujv 01 qpiXococpoi XeTOuci rrepi ttXoutou Kai Tuuv eKT6c dTaeOuv, ibc x^pxc dpeTfic dvuuqpeXujv ovtuuv Kai dvovr|Tuuv toTc exouci; t6 Tdp 20 ouTUi cuvdrrTeiv Kal cuvoiKeioOv toTc boTiuaciv eSdTei Td TTOiriiuaTa toO )uu6ou Kai toO TrpocuuTreiou , Kai CTTOubfjv TTepiTi6riciv auToTc xPnciimwc XeTO|U€voic' cti be TTpoavoiTei Kai TrpoKiveT Tfjv toO veou mjuxtiv toTc dv qpiXococpiot Xotoic. epxeTai Tdp ouk dTeucToc au- 25 Tuuv TTavTdTTaciv oub' dvriKOOC, oub' d^piTuuc dvd-
E rrXeujc iliv fiKOue Tfic |ur|Tp6c dei Kai TiT6ric Kai vfi
1,124— 126H. 0,129— 131R.
1. Nauck. p. 647 5. TTXdTuuv] Epist. III. p. 315 C
G. Bergk. p. 1237 ^ 11. Nauck. p. 523 16. Id. p. 523
d
POETAS AUDIRE DEBEAT 85
Aia ToO TTaTpoc Kai toO TraibaYUJToO , touc ttXouciouc eubai|aoviZ;6vTU}v Kai cePojuevuuv, qppiTTovTuuv be tov GdvaTOv Ktti Tov ttovov, dlrikov be Tr]v dpeTfiv Kai t6 luribev dveu xPHMdTiuv Kai b6?.r\c dTOVTUJV. oTc 5 dvTiqpuJva Td tujv qpi\oc6cpujv dKOuovTac auTOuc t6 TTpuJTov eKTT\riHic icxei koi Tapaxil Kai 0d)npoc, ou TTpoci€|Li€VOuc oub ' uTTO)LievovTac, dv MH KaGdTTep ^k CKOTouc TToWou |i€\\ovTec fi\iov 6pdv l9lC0UJClV OIOV ^v v60uj qpujTi K€Kpa|aevric )uu0oic d\ri0€iac auYnv 10 exovTi |aa\aKriv d\uTTUJC biap\eTTeiv Td ToiaOTa Kai ^fi qpeuTeiv. TTpoaKrjKO^Tec tdp ev toic TTOirjiaaci Kai TrpoaveYVUJKOTec
'tov cpuvTa 0priveiv eic 6'c' epxeTai KaKd, F
t6v b' au 0av6vTa koi tt6vujv TT€TTau|ue'vov 15 x^ipovTac euqpnjuoOvTac eKTTejuTTeiv b6)aujv' Ktti
'eTTei Ti bei PpoToTci TT\fiv buoTv |i6vov, Ar|)uriTpoc dKTfic TTUJ)uaT6c 0' ubprix6ou*; Koi 20 'iuj Tupavvi pappdpujv dvbpOuv qpi\ri* Kai 37
'fi PpoTiiJv t' euTTpaHia Tuijv Td\dxicTa YiTVCTai \uTTOU)ae'vujv ' fjTTOv TapdTTOVTai Kai bucKo\aivouci rrapd toTc cpi\o- -'.=' c6qpoic dKOuovTec Ouc '6 0dvaTOc oubev Trpoc fijudc' Kai '6 Tfic qpuceujc tt\oGtoc ujpicTai' Kai 'to eubai- |uov Kai )uaKdpiov ou xPHI^dTUJV TT\fi0oc oube TTpaT- )adTUJV OTKOc oub' dpxai Tivec exouciv oube buvdjueic, dW d\uTria Kai TTpa6Tric TTa0u)V Kai bid0ecic ipuxfic
1,126- 127 H. 6, 131-133 R.
9. qpujTi Reiskius: tpoiTi koI 13. Nauck, p. 395
17. Id. p. 507 20. 2-2. Id. p. 696
86 QUOMODO ADOLESC. POETAS AUDIRE DEBEAT
B t6 KttTa (pOciv opiCouca. bio Kai toutuuv evcKtt k<xi Tuuv TTpoeipriiaevujv dTrdvTUJV dYa9fic bei tuj veuj Kupepvriceuuc Trepi Triv dvdYvujciv, iva )ufi Trpobia- pXrjGeic dXXd ludXXov npoTTaibeueeic eujuevfic Kai qpi- Xoc Kai oiKeioc utto TroinTiKf]c eTTi qpiXocoqpiav Trpo- 5 TTeiiTTriTai.
1, 12TH. C, 133R.
n E p I TOT AKOTEIN.
1. Tfiv Tevo|uevriv |uoi cxoXfiv Tiepi toO dKoOeiv, Ou c NiKavbpe, drrecTaXKd coi Ypdn/ac, ottuuc eibric toO
TTeiGOVTOC OpSuiJC dKOueiV, OTC TUJV TrpOCTaTTOVTUUV
dTTrjXXaHai t6 dvbpeiov dveiXriqJUJC i)udTiov. dvapxict
5 |uev Tdp, f\\ evioi tujv veujv eXeu9epiav dTraibeucia VGjui2Iouci, x«^£TTUJTepouc CKeivujv tijuv ev rraici biba-D CKdXujv Kai rraibaYUJYuJv becTTOTac eqpicTnci Tdc eui- 0u|uiac uJCTTep eK bec|aa>v XuGeicac Kai KaGdTTep 'HpoboToc qpriciv d|Lia tlu xitujvi cuveKbuec6ai Tfjv
10 aibuu Tdc YuvaiKac, outujc evioi tujv veujv djua tuj t6 TTaibiK6v i)udTiov dTToeecGai cuvaTTo9e|uevoi t6 ai- beic9ai Kai (poPeic0ai Kai XucavTec Tr]v KaTacxriiuaTi- Zioucav auTouc TTepipoXfiv eu9uc eiiTTiTTXavTai Tfic dvaYUJYiac. cu be TToXXdKic dKriKod)C oti TauTov ecTi
15 t6 eKec9ai 9euj Kai t6 Trei9ec9ai Xoyuj , vojuiZ^e TfjV eic dvbpac ck TTaiboiv dYuJYHV ouk dpxnc elvai toic eij cppovoOciv dTToPoXrjv, dXXd lueTapoXfiv dpxovTOc, E dvTi fiic9cuToO Tivoc ri dpYupujvr|TOu 6eiov fiY€|a6va ToO piou Xajupdvouci t6v Xoyov, iL toijc ^Trojuevouc
20 dEiov ecTi laovouc eXeu9epouc vo|uiZ;eiv. |u6voi Ydp d bei pouXec9ai |ua96vTec, dic pouXovTai Ivjci' Taic b'
1, 128—129 H. 6, 13-1—135 R.
9. 'Hp650T0Cj I 8
88 DE RECTA
dnaibeuTOic Kai TiapaXoYOic 6p|uaTc Kai TrpdHeciv dYevvec 1'vecTi Kai jaiKpov ev ttoXXlD tlu )ii€TavooOvTi t6 ^kouciov.
2. 'eirei b' ujcTrep tujv eYTP«90)Lievujv eic Tdc TToXiTeiac 01 iuev dXXobaTTOi Kai Hevoi Koiuibri rroXXd s
F |ue|ucpovTai Kai bucKoXaivouci tujv YiTvo)aevujv, oi b' eK jLieToiKUJV cuvTpocpoi Ktti cuvriGeic tujv v6)liuuv 6v- Tec ou xct^^TTUuc TTpocbexovTai Td ^TTipdXXovTa Kai cTepYOuciv, ouTUJC ebei ttoXuv xpovov ev qpiXocoqpia TTapaTperpoiuevov Kai ttSv )iid0r|)Lia Kai dKOuc)Lia rraibi- lo k6v ttTT' dpxiic e9ic0evTa TTpocqpepecOai Xotlu qpiXo- cocpuj |ue)aiYMevov, eu)aevfi Kai oiKeiov fiKeiv eic qpiXo- coqpiav, r\ )u6vri t6v dvbpeiov Kai TeXeiov dic dXr|0uJc eK XoTou ToTc veoic TTepiTi0r|Ci k6c)l10v. ouk dv dribujc 38 b' oT|aai ce TrpoaKoOcai rrepi Tfic dKOUCTiKfjc aic0r|- i5 ceujc, r\v 6 GeoqppacTOC Tra0riTiKUJTdTr|v elvai qpnci rra- ujcv. ouTe Tdp opaTOV oubev ouTe t6vjct6v ou0' dTTT6v CKCTdceic eTTiqpe'pei Kai Tapaxdc Kai TTTOiac TrjXiKauTac f]XiKai KaTaXa)apdvouc» Tf]v MJUxnv ktuttujv tivOuv xai TraTdTUJV Kai fjxuuv Trj dKof) TrpocTTecdvTUJV. ecTi be 20 XoTiKUJTe'pa )udXXov f| TTa0riTiKU)T^pa. Tf) ^iev Tdp KaKiot TToXXd x^Jupia Kai )ie'pr| toO ca))LiaTOc Trapexei bi' auTUfV evbOcav di|jac0ai Tfjc ipuxfic, Tfj b' dpeTf) )iia XaPn Td iLTa tuuv veujv ecTiv, dv Ka0apd Kai
B d0puTTTa KoXaKeia koi X6toic d0iKTa qpauXoic dTT'25 dpxnc qpuXdTTHTai. bio Kai EevoKpdTnc toTc TTaici )adXXov f| ToTc d0Xr)TaTc eKeXeue TTepidrrTeiv d|uqpujTi- bac, ujc eKeivuJv )uev Td oiTa TaTc TTXrjTaTc, toutujv be ToTc X6toic Td r\Qr] biacTpeq)0)ie'vujv , ouk dvrjKoiav
1, 129— 130 H. 6, 135— 137 R.
4. eTT£i] Iti Emperius 15. TrpoaKoucai Madvigius:
TTpocaKoucai 2i. fiv Reiskius: Sv r^
EATIONE AUDIEJ^DI 89
oube KiuqpoTriTa TTpo|uvuu)aevoc, dXXd Ttuv Xofujv touc cpauXouc cpuXdTTecGai Trapaivujv, Trpiv eTepouc XPI- CTOuc, ujcrrep qpuXaKac IvTpaqjevTac utto cpiXocoqpiac TLU fiGei, Triv |idXiCTa Kivou|ae'vriv auToO Kai dvaTteiGo-
5 luevriv x^J^pav KaTacxeiv. Kai Biac 6 TraXaioc 'A)ad- cibi, KeXeuc0€ic t6 xPHCTOTaTov 6)lio0 Kai cpauXoTaTov dTTOTreiuipai Kpe'ac toO lepeiou, Tr^v T^ujTTav eEeXujv dTTeTieiavpev , ibc Kai pXd^ac Kai luqpeXeiac toO XeTeiv exovToc laeTicTac. oi Te ttoXXoi Td )uiKpd Ttaibia Ka- C
10 TacpiXouvTec auTOi Te tujv ujtuuv drrTOVTai KdKeiva toOto TTOieiv KeXeuouciv, alviTTO^aevoi )ueTd rraibidc OTi bei qpiXeiv )adXiCTa touc bid tujv ujtujv ujqpeXoOv- Tac. errei oti fe rrdcric dKpodceujc dTTeipYo^aevoc 6 veoc Kai XoYou )Ltribev6c Ytuo^evoc ou jaovov dKap-
15 TTOc oXujc Ktti dpXacTfic bia^evei TTp6c dpeTrjv, dXXd Kai biacTpeqpoiT' dv TTp6c KOKiav, ujCTiep ck x^Pctc dKivr|TOu Kai dpYHC dYpia TToXXd Tf|c vpuxfic dvabi- bouc, bflXov ecTi. Tdc Ydp eqp' fibovfiv bpjxac Kai Trp6c TTOvov UTTOtpiac (ou Gupaiouc oub' utt6 Xoyujvd
20 eTTeicdKTOuc , dXX' ujCTtep auToxOovac oucac faupiujv TtaGOuv Kai vocri)adTUJV TiriYdc) dv ed tic dqpeTOuc r) TreqpuKaci x^P^iv Kai |ifi Xoyoic xPHCToTc dqpaipujv f| TTapaTperrujv KaTapTur) Tfiv qpuciv, ouk ecTiv o tuuv 6r|piujv ouK av fi)uepujTepov dvOpuuTTOu qpaveir|.
25 3. Ai6 br] )LieYdXriv )uev ujqpeXeiav, ouk eXdTTuu be Kivbuvov ToTc veoic toO dKOueiv exovToc oijuai KaXuJc ix^w Kai TTp6c auT6v del Kai TTp6c eTepov biaXeYecGai Trepi toO dKOueiv. eTrei Kai toutlu KaKoic E Touc TrXeicTouc xPiJ^Mtvouc 6pu)|uev, o'i XeYeiv dcKoOci
30 Trpiv dKOueiv eGicGfjvar Kai Xoyou )uev oiovTai )ud6ri-
1,130- 131 H. C, 137— 139 R.
15. biajuevei Madvigius: 5iajudv€i
90 DE RECTA
civ eivai Ktti lueXeiriv, dKpodcei be Kai touc ottujcoOv Xpujjuevouc ujcpeXeicGai. Kaiioi toic |uev ccpaipiZ^ouciv a)Lia ToO PaXeiv Kai toO Xapeiv Triv ccpaipav fi iudGri- cic ev bk Tfj ToO XoYOu xP^i*^ to beHacGai KaXiJuc ToO npoecBai TrpoTepov ecTiv, ujcTiep toO TeKeiv t6 s cuXXa^eiv Kai KttTacxeiv ti tujv Tovijuuuv. Taic )aev ouv opvici Tdc urrriveiuiouc Xoxeiac Kai lubivac dTe- Xujv Tivujv Kai dipuxujv uTroXei|U)udTU)v dpxdc XeTOuciv eivar tujv b' dKOueiv \xr] buva,uevujv veujv )urib' F ujqpeXeicBai bi' dKonc eGicGevTUJV uTtriveiuioc ovtujc 610
XOYOC eKTTiTTTUJV
'dKXeific dibriXoc uKai vecpeecci KebdcOri'. Td )uev Tdp dTT£ia Trpoc Triv UTToboxilv tujv eTX€0)ue- vujv eTTiKXivouci Kai cuveTTiCTpeqpouciv , iv' eTXucic dXriQujc, |uri ckxucic TevriTai, auTOuc be tiu Xctovti 15 Trapexeiv Kai cuvapiuoTTeiv Trj Ttpocoxri Trjv dKpoaciv, ujc luribev CKcpuTri tujv xp^cijuujc XeTOjuevujv, ou )uav- 39 Gdvouciv , dXX' 6 rrdvTUJV KaTaTeXacTOTaTov ecTiv, dv juev Tivi TrpocTuxujci biriTOU)uevLU bemvov f| TTOjUTrfiv r| oveipov fi Xoibopiav TeTevriiuevriv auTuj Trpoc dXXov, 20 dKpouJvTai ciujTTrj Kai TrpocXiTrapoOciv • dv be tic au- Touc eTTiCTTacd|uevoc bibdcKr) ti tujv xpnci^wjv fi Ttap- aivri Tujv beovTUJV f\ vou9eTr] TTXri|U|ueXoOvTac f| KaTa- TTpauvr) xa^£TTaivovTac, oux uTTO|uevouciv , dXX' dv )uev buvujVTai, TTepiTevec6ai cpiXoTi|uou)u6voi bia)udxov- 25 Tai TTpoc Tov XoTov • ei be furi, cpeuTOVTec dTriaci Trpoc ^Tepouc XoTouc Kai cpXudpouc, ujc dTTeia cpaOXa Kai caGpd Td uiTa rrdvTUJV )udXXov f| tuuv dvaTKaiujv B eiuTTiTrXdvTec. touc )uev ouv iTTTrouc 01 KaXujc Tpe- cpovTec eucToiuouc tuj xa^ivuj, touc be Traibac eur)- 30
1, 131-132 H. ' ' 6, 139- 110 R.
17. iKcpuY»]*: ^KcpuYOi
RATIONE AUDIENDI 91
Koouc Tu) XoTUJ Trapexouci, TToXXd |uev dKoOeiv pLX] TToXXd be XeYeiv bibacKOjuevouc. Kai ydp tov '€TTa- lueivOjvbav 6 CTTivGapoc eTtaivOiJv e(pri |uriTe TrXeiova YiTViucKOVTi )iiriT' eXdTTOva qpBeYTOM^vuj pabiujc ev- 5 Tuxeiv eTepuj. Kai thv cpuciv r\}x(bv eKdcTUJ XeTOuci buo iuev ujTa boOvai, luiiav be T^uJTTav, ibc eXdTTOva XeTeiv r\ dKOueiv oqpeiXovTi.
4. TTavTaxou /aev ouv tuj veuj kocmoc dccpaXr|C icrw f] ciujTTri, /adXicTa b' OTav dKOuuJV eTe'pou p.r\
10 cuvTapdTTr) iurj^' eHuXaKTfj Trpoc CKacTov, dXXd Kdv C 6 XoTOc rj jari Xiav dpecTOC, dve'x'lTai Kai Trepijiievti TtaucacGai tov biaXeTOjuevov, Kai Traucajaevou juf) eu- Geujc empdXXr] Tfjv dvTippriciv, dXX' ujc Aicxivric q>Y\c\, biaXeiTTr) xpovov, eiTe TrpocOeTvai ti ^ouXoito
i'> ToTc XeXeTjuevoic 6 eipriKuuc, eiTe )ueTa6e'c9ai Kai dqpe- XeTv. 01 b' euBuc dvTiKOTTTOVTec, out' dKouovTec out' dKOu6)uevoi; XeTOVTec be Trpoc Xe'T0VTac dcxri- juovouciv 6 b' eTKpaTuic Kai jueT' aiboOc dKoueiv e0ic9eic tov juev ujqpeXi|uov Xotov ebe'HaTO Kai KaTecxe,
20 Tov b' dxpricTOv r| njeubfj judXXov bieibe Kai KaTeqpuj- pace, cpiXaXri9ric qpaveic, ou qpiXoveiKOc oube Ttpo- D TTCTfic Kai bucepic. 69ev ou KaKUjc evioi Xe'TOuciv OTi beT TtiJv veujv judXXov eKTTveujuaToOv t6 oiriiua Kai Tov TOqpov fi Tuuv dcKUJV Tov depa touc eTxecii ti
2j PouXo|uevouc xpncijuov" ei be jun, TCMOVTec otkou Kai qpucr||uaTOC ou rrpocbe'xovTai.
5. cj^eovoc Toivuv |U€Td pacKaviac Kai bucjueveiac oubevi |uev epTUJ TTapuuv dTa96c, dXXd Trdciv e|UTT6- bioc ToTc KaXoTc, KdKiCTOC b' dKpoujjuevuj ndpebpoc
1,132— 133H. 6, UO— 142R.
10. cuvtapdTTr)*: cuvTapctTTriTai 15. Kai] f| Kai Rei-
skius 28. diTaeoc*: dY0i66v
92 DE RECTA
Kai cu)jpou\oc, dviapd Kal dnbfi Kai bucTTp6cb€KTa TToiiJuv id dicpeXiiua bid t6 Trdci luaXXov fib€c9ai touc E (p9ovo0vTac r\ toTc eu XeYO)Lievoic. KaiTOi ttXoOtoc M^v ovTiva bdKvei Kai boHa Kai KdXXoc, ^Tepoic urrdp- XovTa, qp9ovep6c ecTi jliovov' dx9eTai ^dp dXXuuv 5 euTuxouvTuuv • 6 be Xotuj KaXiuc XeTO)uevuj bucxepai- vuuv UTTO Tuuv ibiuuv dYa9uuv dvidTOi. d)c ^dp t6 qpuuc Tuuv pXeTTOVTuuv, Kai 6 X6toc tuuv dKOUovTuuv dTa96v ecTiv, dv pouXujvTai b€'xec9ai. tov luev ouv €cp' ^Tepoic (p96vov dXXai Tivec dTraibeuToi Kai KaKai lo bia9eceic ejUTToioOciv, 6 bk TTpoc touc XeTOVTac 4k cpiXoboEiac dKaipou Kai (piXoTi)uiac dbiKOu Tevvuu)uevoc oube TTpocexeiv ed toic X€TO)uevoic t6v outuu biaKei- Fjuevov, dXXd 9opupei Kai TTepiCTToi ttiv bidvoiav, d)ua )aev Tfiv dauTfjc eHiv ^TTicKOTToOcav ei XeiTTeTOi ttic is ToO XcTOVTOc, d)ua be touc dXXouc eTTi^Xe^TTOucav ei oTavTai Kai 9au|ud2ouciv, eKTrXriTTO)uevriv tc utt6 tujv ^TTaivuuv KQi dTpiaivoucav TTpoc touc TTOpdvTac dv dTTobexuuvTai tov XcTOVTa, tuuv be X6tujv touc |uev eipniu^vouc eujcav Kai TTpoi€)uevriv, oti XuttoOci )uvr|- 20 )uoveu6|uevoi, TTp6c be touc XeiTTOVTac TapaTTO)uevriv Kai Tpe'|uoucav )uf) tujv €ipr|)ue'vuuv peXTiovec T€'vuuvTat, 40 CTTeuboucav be TdxiCTa Traucac9ai touc X^TOVTac OTav KdXXiCTtt XeTujci, Xu9eicric bk xfic dKpodceuuc TTp6c oubevi Tuuv eiprijuevuuv oijcav dXXd Tdc cpuuvdc Kai 25 bia9ec€ic tuuv Trap6vTuuv dTTiipriqpiCoucav, Kai touc )u^v ^TTaivouvTac ujcTrep ^)U)uavfi (peuTOucav Kai dTTOTTribuj- cav, TTpocTpexoucav hk koi cuvaTeXaZioiu^vriv toTc ipeTOUci Td €ipri)ueva Kai biacTpecpouciv • dv be ^ribev i) biacTpevpai, TTapapdXXoucav ^Tepouc Tivdc ujc d)uei- so vov eipHKdTac eic TauTd Kai buvaTuuTcpov, euuc
i, 133— 135 H. 6, 142— UIR,
EATIONE AUDIENDI 93
biaqpGeipaca Kai bia\u)LirivajU€V)i xfiv dKpoaciv dxpeiov ^auTrj Ktti dvovriTOv diTepTdcriTai.
6. Aio bei TiQ qpiXriKOia TTpdc Tfjv qpiXobo^iav B CTTeicdjuevov dKpodcQai toO Xe'TOVTOc iXeoiv Kai TTpdov,
5 ujCTTep eqp ' ecTiaciv lepdv Kai Ouciac drTapxfiv rrapei- XTi|a)aevov, eTraivoOvTa )aev oic eTriTUYXdvei Triv buva- luiv, dYaTTuJVTa be Tf]V TTpo9u|uiav auTfiv toO qpepov- Toc eic laecov d YiYVuucKei Kai neiGovTOC eTepouc bf u)v auToc TTeTTeiCTai. toic |aev oijv KaTOp6ou|uevoic
10 eTTiXoYicTeov ujc ouk diTo Tuxnc oub' auTO)idTUJc dXX' eTTiiueXeia Kai Trovtu Kai laaGficei KaTOpGoOTai, Kai |ui)uriTeov yc TaOTa 0au)LidZovTdc Ye bfi Kai Zr^XoOvTac" ToTc b' d|uapTavojue'voic eqpiCTdvai XPH Tfjv bidvoiav, uqp' ujv aiTiujv Kai oOev n TTapaTpoTTf) YCYOvev. lijc
15 Ydp 6 Zevoqpujv qprici touc oikovojuikouc Kai dTTO tuuv C qpiXujv ovivacOai m\ aixo tujv ex^puJV, outuj touc eYpriYopoTac Kai TTpocexovTac ou )u6vov KaTopGoOvTec dXXd Kai bia)iapTdvovT€c ujqpeXoOciv oi XeYOVTec Kai Ydp biavof|)uaToc euTeXeia Kai pf||uaTOc KevoTric Kai
20 cxfjiua qpopTiKov Kai TTToricic )ueTd xapdc drreipoKdXou Trpoc eTTaivov Kai oca ToiaOTa )udXXov dKpouj)uevoic eqp' eTepujv fi XeYouciv eqp' eauTuuv KaTaqjaivcTai. bio bei )U€Taqpepeiv Tf]v euGuviiv eqp' eauTouc dTTO toO XeYOVToc, dvacKOTToOvTac ei ti toioOto Xav0dvo)uev
25 djuapTdvovTec. pacTov Ydp ecTi tujv ovtujv t6 jueju- D qpecGai tov TTXriciov, dxpfjCTujc Te Kai Kevujc yiyv6- luevov, dv |ufi TTp6c Tiva bi6p0ujciv fl qpuXaKfjv dva- qpepriTai TuJv 6)uoiujv. Kai to toO TTXdTUJVOC ouk 6KvriTeov dei TTpoc auTov eTTi tujv djuapTav6vTUJV
1,135— 136 H. 6, U4-UGR.
11. KaTopSoOiai*: KaTopBoOvTai 15. Eevocpujv] Oe-
con. I 17 25. M^iuqpeceai * : |ue|UH;acBai 26. xe] 6e?
94
DE RECTA
dvacpOeTTecGai , '|ar| ttou dp' i^Oj toioOtoc;' ujc t«P i.v TOic djLiMaci tijuv TtXriciov eXXd|UTrovTa Td eauTuuv opujjaev, ouTUJC em tujv Xotujv bei touc eauTuiv evei- KoviZ^ecGai toic iTepujv, iva |Lir|T' dTav Opaceujc KaTa- ! 9povuJ|uev dXXujv, auTOic Te Trpocexuj)uev ev tuj Xe-
E Teiv errvueXecTepov. xP^l^il^ov be Ttpoc touto Kai t6 Tfic TTapaPoXfjc, oTav Tev6|Lievoi Ka6' auTOuc dTT6 thc dKpodceujc Kai XapovTec ti tOuv iir\ KaXuJc f| \xr] ka- vuuc eipfjcGai boKOuvTUJV eTTixeipOij)aev eic TauT6 Kai TTpodTUJ|uev auTOuc Td juev ujCTrep dvaTTXripoOv , Td lo b' eTTttvopGoOcGai, Td b' dTepuuc qppdZieiv, Td b' oXujc eH uTTapxfic eiccpepeiv TTeipu)|uevoi Trp6c thv uTT69eciv. o Kai TTXdTUJv eTTOirice TTp6c t6v Auciou X6tov. t6 laev Tdp dvTeiTTeiv ou xdKenov dXXd Kai Trdvu pdbiov eipriiLievuj X6tuj' t6 b' eTepov dvTavacTfjcai PeXTiova ^ TTavTdTraciv epTuubec. ujCTTep 6 AaKebaiiiidvioc dKOu- cac OTi OiXiTTTTOC "OXuvGov KaTecKavpev 'dXX' ouk dvacTficai t^ TOiauTTiv ' eqjr) ' tt6Xiv eKCivoc dv buvr)-
F0eiri'. OTav ouv ev tuj biaXeTecGai TTp6c Tfjv toi- auTTiv uTr60eciv )Lif) rroXu qpaivuuiaeOa tujv eipiiK^Tuuv biaqpepovTec, ttoXu toO KaTaqppoveTv dqpaipoujuev , Kai TdxicTa KoXoueTai t6 au0abec fi)Liujv Kai qpiXauTov ev TaTc TOiauTaic eXeTXOM^vov dvTiTTapapoXaic.
7. Tlu Toivuv KaTaqppoveTv t6 0au)LidZ;eiv dvTiKei- ILievov euTVUJ)LiovecTe'pac \xiv ecTi br|Trou Kai fi)LiepujTe- 25 pac qpuceujc, beTTai t^ M^iv oub' auT6 )aiKpdc euXa-
4lPeiac, Tdxa be Kai )Liei2ovoc- 01 )Liev Tdp KaTaqppovn- TiKOi Kai 0paceTc fiTTOv uiqpeXouvTai utt6 tujv Xctov- Tuuv, 01 be 0au)LiacTiKOi Kai dKaKOi )udXXov pXdrrTOVTai, Kai t6v 'HpdKXeiTOV ouk eXeTXOuciv eiTrdvTa ' pXdH so
1,136-137 H. 6,146-147E
1. lafi*: fi 30. pXdS] P. 28 D
KATIONE AUDIENDI 95
av6pujTroc eiTi TravTi Xotuj ^TTTofjcGai qpiXei'. bei be Tov laev eTTaivov dcpeXOuc toTg Xe'Touci Tf]v be ttictiv euXajBujc rrpoiecOai toic Xotoic, Kai Tfic |Liev Xe£euuc Kai TTpoqpopdc touv dTUJVi2[o|ue'viuv euinevfi Kai dTrXoOv
■ eivai 9eaTf|v, Tfjc be xP^iotc Kai Tfic dXri9eiac tujv XeTO|ue'vujv dKpipfj Kai TTiKpov eSeTacTf|v, iv' oi iuev XefovTec |ufi luicujciv, oi be Xotoi ixx] pXdTTToiciv. ujc B TToXXd i}jeubfi Kttl TTOvripd boTMOiTa Xav6dvo|uev euvoia Kai TcicTei Tfi TTpoc Touc XeTOVTac evbex6|uevoi. oi
10 juev ouv AaKebai)aoviujv dpxovTec dvbpoc ouk eu ^e- piujKOTOC Tvuj|Liriv boKi|udcavTec eTepuj TrpoceTaHav eiTTeTv euboKi|uouvTi Trepi tov piov Kai t6 fi9oc, 6p- 9u)c Trdvu Kai ttoXitikuuc e9i2ovT€C tov bfi|uov utto ToO TpoTTOu iudXXov r| toO Xotou touv cu)apouXeu6v-
15 Tuuv dTec9ai. touc b' ev qpiXococpia X6touc dqpai- poOvTa xPn Tf]v ToO XeTOVTOc boHav auTOuc eqp' eau- Tuiv eHeTdZieiv. ujc Tctp TroXe'|Liou, Kai dKpodceujc TToXXd Td Kevd ^Tt. Kai t«P TToXid tou XeTOVTOc Kai TTXdc)Lia Kai oqppOc Kai TrepiauToXoTia, ludXiCTa b'c
2" ai KpauTai Kai oi 96puPoi Kai Td TTribf||uaTa tujv Trap- 6vTUJV cuveKTrXfiTTei tov dTreipov dKpoaTriv Kai ve'ov ujCTrep UTTo peu)uaToc TTapaqpep6|uevov. e'xei be ti Kai f) XeEic dTTaTriXdv, OTav fibeia Kai TroXXfi Kai iiieT' oTKOu Tivoc Ktti KaTacKeufic eTriqpe'priTai toTc TTpdT)na-
25 civ. ujc Tdp Tujv UTT ' auXoTc dbovTUJV ai TToXXai Touc dKOuovTac d)uapTiai biaqpeuTOuciv, outuj TTepiTTf) Kai copapd XeEic dvTiXd^aTrei tuj dKpoaTf) rrpdc t6 briXou)aevov. 6 |uev Tdp MeXdv9ioc, ujc eoiKC, TrepiD Tfic AiOTevouc TpaTujbiac epujTri9eic ouk eqpri KaTibeTv
30 auTfjv UTTO Tujv 6vo)udTUJV eTTmpoc9oujuevr|v • ai be
1 , 137—138 H. 6, 147—149 E.
1. ^TTToficGai Xylander: Traibeueceai
96 DE RECTA
Tujv TToXXuJv biaXeHeic Kai jneXerai coq^icTuJv ou |u6vov ToTc 6v6|Liaci 7TapaTTeTdc|uaci xP^VTai tujv biavoriiLid- TUJV, dXXd Kai Tfjv qpujvrjv e)U)aeXeiaic tici Kai )aaXa- K^Ttici Kai TTapicouceciv eqpribuvovTec eKpaKxeuouci Kai 7Tapaq)e'pouci touc dKpouj|aevouc, Kevrjv f)bovr)v bi&6v- 5 Tec Kai KevujTepav b6£av dvTiXajupdvovTec. ujct' au- ToTc cujupaivei t6 utto Aiovuciou pri9ev, eKcTvoc Tdp,
E luc eoiKev, euboKi)aouvTi Ki9apujbuj Ttapd tiiv 9eav eTTaTY^iXdjuevoc bujpedc Tivac jueYdXac ucTcpov oubev ebujKev ujc dTTobebujKibc Tfjv x«Piv 'ocov Ydp' eqpr) w 'Xpdvov rjuqppaivec abujv, tocoOtov exaipec eXTTiZ^uuv'. toOtov be Tov epavov ai TOiaOTai TrXripoOciv dKpod- ceic ToTc XeYOuci* 9au)Lid2;ovTai Ydp eqp' ocov TepTTOU- civ, eiTa a|ua Tfic dKonc eEeppuri to fibu KdKCivouc TTpoXeXoirrev f) boEa, Kai iiaxr]v toTc )aev 6 xpdvoc i| ToTc be Kai 6 pioc dvdXujTai.
8. Aio beT To TToXu Kai Kevov dqpaipoOvTa Tfjc
F XeHeujc auTOV bioiKeiv tov KapTTov Kai jaijueTc9ai )af) Tdc CTeqpavriTTX6K0uc dXXd Tdc )aeXiccac. ai )aev Ydp errioOcai Td dv9ripd Kai euuubri tOuv q^uXXujv cuvei- pouci Kai biaTTXeKouciv fibu )aev eqjfijuepov be Kai ^iKapTrov epYOV a'i be TroXXdKic iujv Kai pdbujv Kai uaKiv9ujv biaTTCT^juevoi Xei).ujuvac erri tov TpaxuTaTov Kai bpi|uuTaTOv 9ujuov KaTaipouci Ka\ toutuj TTpocKd9- r}VTai
'2av96v jueXi )arib6)aevai ',
Kai Xa^oucai ti tujv xPnciM^JiJV dTTOTTeTOVTai Trpoc to
oiKcTov epYOV. ouTUJC ouv beT tov q)iX6Texvov koi
42 Ka9ap6v OKpoaTfiv Td faev dv9ripd Kai Tpuq)epd tuuv
1,138— 139 H. 6, 149— 151 E.
19. CTeqpavriTtXoKOUc * : CT€(pr]TTX6K0uc 26. Bergk.
p. 1135-'
RATIONE AUDIENDI 97
ovo.udTuuv Ktti Tuuv 7TpaY)iidTuuv Td bpa)LiaTiKd Kai Travri- YupiKd KTiqpnvujv pOTdvnv coqpiCTiuuvTUJV f]YOUM£VOV edv, auTov be Trj TTpocoxvj KaTabudjuevov eic tov voOv toO XoTOu Kai Tfjv bidOeciv toO Xctovtoc eXKeiv drr' auTfic
5 t6 xPnciMOv Ktti ujqpeXiMOV, |uejuvr|)uevov dic ouk eic GeaTpov oub' ujbeTov dXX' elc cxoXfiv Kai bibacKaXeiov dqpiKTai, Tuj XoYUJ tov piov eTravop9ujc6)uevoc. 66ev bx] Kai TTOiriTeov eTricKeqjiv Kai Kpiciv Tfjc dKpodceujc eE auToO Ktti Tfic Trepi auTov biaOeceujc, dvaXoTiZ6)ue-
10 vov ei Ti Tujv TTaOujv yeTove |uaXaKUJTepov, ei ti tijuv dviapOuv KOuqpdTepov, ei Gdpcoc ei qppoviDua ^epaiov, B ei Trpoc dpeTfjV Kai t6 KaX6v evGouciacjuoc. ou Tdp eK Koupeiou )uev dvacTdvTa bei tuj KaTOTTTpt^j rrapa- CTfivai Kal Tfic KeqpaXfjc aqjacGai, Tf]v TrepiKOTrfiv tujv
15 TpixuJV eTTiCKOTToOvTa Ktti Tfic Koupdc Tfjv biaqpopdv, CK be dKpodceuuc dKiovTa Kai cxoXfjc oOk eOGuc dqpo- pdv xpn TTp6c eauTOV, KaTajuavGdvovTa Tfiv ijjuxfiv ei Ti TuJv oxXripuJV drroTeGei|uevri Kai TrepiTTUuv eXa- qppOTe'pa TCTOve Kai fibiuuv. 'outc Tdp paXaveiou'
20 qpi]civ 6 'ApicTuuv 'ouTe Xotou juf) KaGaipovTOC ocpe- Xoc ecTiv'.
9. 'HbecGuu juev ouv utt6 Xotujv ujqpeXoujuevoc 6 C veoc* oO bei be t6 nbO Tfic dKpodceujc TTOieicGai Te- Xoc, oOb' oiecGai beiv ck cxoXfjc dmevai qpiXocoqpou
25 |uivupiZ:ovTa Kai T6Tttvuu|uevov , oObe 2;TiTeTv juupiZiecGai beojuevov e)uPpoxfic Kai KaTarrXdcjuaTOc , dXXd X"Piv Ixeiv, dv Tic uJCTTep KaTTvuj c)ufivoc Xotuj bpijueT thv bidvoiav dxXOoc rroXXfic Kai d)apX0TriTOc TCMOucav dKKaGnpr). Kai Tdp ei toTc XeTOuci TTpocfiKei \xf] Trav-
30 TdTTaciv fibovfiv exoOcnc Kai TTiGavoTriTa XeSeuuc Trapa- lueXeTv, eXdxicTa toOtou qppovTicTeov ecTi tu» veuj,
1, 139— UOH. 6, 151— 153 R.
Plntarchi Moralia Vol. I. 7
98 DE RECTA
t6 Ye TTpujTOv. ucTcpov be ttou, KaGdtTrep oi rrivov- DTec, oTttv TTaucujvTai binJoivTec, totc Tct TopeuiaaTa
TUJV eKTTUU]UdTUJV UTTOBeUipOUCl Kai CTpe'(pOUClV, OUTUJC
ejuTTXricGevTi boYindTUJv Kai dvaTTveucavTi boTeov Tfiv XeHiv ei ti K0|uvp6v exei Kai TTepiTT6v ^TTiCKOTTeiv. 6 5 b' eu0uc ^H dpxnc ^xr] toTc TTpdYjuctciv ejuqpuojuevoc dXXd Triv Xe'Hiv 'ATTiKfjv dHiuJV eivai Kai icxvfiv ojuoioc dcTi nf] pouXojuevqj TTieTv dvTiboTOv, av ^xx] t6 dYTcTov eK t^c 'ATTiKfic KUjXidboc ^ KCKepajueuiie'- vov, juTib' ijudTiov TTepiPaXecGai xeijLtuJVoc, ei juf^ TTpo- 1 pdTUJV 'Attikuuv eiri t6 epiov , dXX' ujCTrep ev Tpipujvi AuciaKOu XoYou XeTTTUj Kai qjiXuj Ka9f|juevoc dTrpaKTOc
E Ktti dKivriTOC. TttOTa Yap Td vocf|iuaTa TToXXfjv juev eprijuiav voO Kai qppevujv dYa0ijuv, TroXXfjv be Tep- 0peiav Kai CTUjjuuXiav ev TaTc cxoXaTc TreTToiriKe , tuiv i5 jueipaKiujv ouTe piov outc TrpdSiv ouTe rroXiTeiav qpi- Xococpou TTapaqpuXaTTovTUJV dvbpoc, dXXd XeHeic Kai pf||aaTa Kai t6 KaXuJc dTraYYe^^Xeiv ev eTraivuj Ti0eju^- vujv, t6 b' dTraYYeXXojLievov eiTe xp^cijuov €it' dxpn- CTOV €it' dvaYKaTov eiTC Kevov ecTi Kal TrepiTT^v ouk zcj eTTiCTajuevujv oube pouXojaevuJV dHeTdZieiv.
10. 'AKoXou0eT be toutoic t6 Trepi tujv TxpopXri-
F ILidTUJV TrapdYYeXjua. beT Ydp t6v eni beTrrvov fiKOVTa ToTc TrapaKeijuevoic xpnc0cxi Kai iuribev aiTeTv dXXo )irib' egeXeYXeiv* 6 b' ctti Xoyujv dqpiYMevoc kTiaciv, a
CtV JieV CTTl prjTOTC, dKpodc0UJ ClUJTTf) TOO XCYOVTOC
(oi Ydp eic dXXac uTTO0eceic dHdYOVTec Kai rrapeju- pdXXovTec epujTfiiaaTa Kai TTpocbiaTropoOvTec , oux fibeTc oub' eucuvdXXaKTOi TTp6c dKpoaciv 6vTec, ujqpe- ^ XoOvTai jLiev oub^v, t6v be XeYOVTa Kal tov Xoyov 3o o^oO cuvTapdccouciv)* 6Tav be toOc dKOuovTac 6
1, 140—142 H. 6, 153 - 155 B
RATIONE AUDIENDI 99
Xe-fujv cpuuTav Kai TTpopdWeiv KeXeucr), xPnci|u6v ti bei Kai dvaTKaiov dei TrpopdWovTa (paivec9ai. 6 |uev fdp 'Obucceuc KaTafeXdTai irapd Toic iiiVTicTfipciv 43 'amZiujv dKoXouc, ouk fiopac oub^ XeprjTac'*
MeTaXoqjuxiac -fdp riToOvTai cnneTov, d)C t6 bibovai s Ti Tujv fieTdXujv, Kai t6 aiTeiv. iudXXov b' dv tic dKpoaToO KaTaTeXdceiev eic |uiKpd Kai T^icxpa TrpopXri- fiaTa Tov biaXeToiuevov kivoOvtoc. oTov TepGpeuofie- jaevoi Tivec tujv ve'u}V Kai rrapeTTibeiKvuiuevoi biaXeKTi- Kr^v r| ^a9ri|aaTiKfiv eEiv eiu)9aci TTpopdXXeiv Ttepi Tfic lo Tujv dopicTUJV TO)afic, Kai tic fi KaTd TrXeupdv f| KaTd bid)ueTpov Kivrjcic. TTp6c ouc ecTiv eiTreiv t6 utto B 0iXoTi|Liou Trp6c tov eiarruov " Kai (p9iciu)VTa pr|9e'v. eTiei Tdp eXdXricev auTiI» (pap)udKiov aiTuJv TTpoc Trap- ujvuxiav, aic96)ievoc dTr6 Tfjc xpoac Kai Tfjc dva- i5 TTVofic TTiv bid9eciv 'ouK ^CTi coi' qjriciv *uj peXTiCTe TTepi uapujvuxiac 6 X6toc'. oubl coi Toivuv, u) ve- avia, TTepi toioutujv CriTilMaTUJV ujpa CKOTreiv, dXXd TTuJc oifmaTOC Kai dXaZoveiac epuuTUJV t€ Kai qpXua- piac dTToXu9eic eic piov dTuqpov Kai uTiaivovTa Kaia- 20 CTfjceic cauTov.
11. €u )adXa be XPH '^cii TTp6c ttiv toO Xctovtoc djiTTeipiav f| (puciKfiv buva)iiv fip)Lioc)ievov, ^v oic au- Toc ^auToO KpdTicTOC ecTi, TT0ieTc9ai Tdc epuJTfjceic, C Kai ixf] TTapaPidZ;ec9ai t6v laev Ti9iKU)Tepov qpiXoco- 25 qpoOvTa qpuciKdc eTrdTOVTa Kai |uia9ri)aaTiKdc dTTOpiac, t6v be ToTc qpuciKoTc ce|uvuv6|Lievov eic cuvr||u|uevujv eTTiKpiceic eXKOVTa Kai v|/eub(r)ue'vujv Xuceic. d)c Tdp 6 T^ KXeibi Td HuXa cxiZeiv Tfj b' dSivr) Tfjv 9upav
, U2— 143H. 6, 155— 156 R
4. Homer. p 222 8. oiov*: oTa 23. 06x60] Nauck.
p. 329
1 *
100 DE RECTA
dvoiTCiv 7T€ipiJu^€V0C ouK ^KcTva b6£eiev fiv ^Trnped- Zeiv, dXX' auTov dTTOCTepeiv thc ^KQTepou XPtictc Kai buvdjieujc, ouTcuc oi TTapd tou XeYovTOc 6 ^r\ TTe(puKe Hr]b* fJcKTiKev aiToOvTec, 8 b' ix^i Kai bibuuci ^r\ bpe- TTOjuevoi Mn^^ XaiJpdvovTec, ou toOto pXdTTTOVTai fio- 5 Dvov dXXd Kai KaKonQeiav Kai bucMeveiav TTpocoqpXi- CKdvouci.
12. OuXaKT^ov bk Kai t6 TToXXd Kai TToXXdKic auTov TTpopdXXeiv ^cti ^dp Kai toOto tpottov Tivd TTapeTTibeiKvuji^vou. t6 b' ^T^pou TTpoTeivovTOC dKpod- jo cSai ^ej' euKoXiac qpiXoXoTOv Kai koiviuvikov, &v )ar| Ti TU)V ibiuuv ^voxXrj Kai KaT€TTeiTT) TTd8oc diTicxe- ceiuc beo^ievov f| vocrma TTapnTopiac. Tdxa \xkv Tap oub* 'djjaeinv KpuTTTeiv d/aeivov', ujc qpriciv 'Hpd- KXeiTOc, dXX' elc pecov TiBevai Kai GepaTreueiv. av i^ b' 6pTn Tic ^ TTpocpoXfi beicibaiMOviac f| biaqpopd
TTpOC olKeioUC CUVTOVOC f\ Kepi^avfjC ii. IpuUTOC ^TTl-
GuMia
E 'KivoOca xopbdc xdc dKivrjTouc qppeviuv'
^nnapdEr) Tfjv bidvoiav, ou qpeuKT^ov elc ^T^pouc X6- 20 Touc dTTobibpdcKovTac xov IXeTXOv, dXXd Trepi au- tOuv toutuuv dKOucT^ov ^v xaic biaTpipaic, Kai jaeTd Tdc biarpipdc ibia TrpociovTac auTOuc Kai TTpocava- KpivovTac. dXXd nn TouvavTiov, ujCTrep o\ ttoXXoi Xaipouci ToTc qpiXocoqpoic TTepi dXXuuv biaXeTOfidvoic 25 Kai eau^dZlouciv • av bi touc dXXouc ^dcac 6 qpiXo- C090C auToTc ^Kcivoic ibia TTappricidZriTai Trepi tuuv biaqpepdvTuuv Kai uTT0)mpvr|CKr| , bucxepaivouci Kai tt€-
F piepTov vo|ii2ouciv. dTTieiKuuc Tap » uJCTrep tuuv Tpa- TUJbujv dv ToTc eedrpoic , Ka\ tujv qpiXococpuuv iv TaTc *)
1, 143— 144 H. 6, l.V> - 158 B.
9. oOxdv lagents: aOxdv 19. Nauck. p. 696
m
RATIONE AI3D1ENDI 101
cxoXaic oToviai beiv dKOueiv, iv be toTc eHiw TrpdT- laaciv oiibev auToOc eauTUJV bia(pe'peiv fiYoOvTai , Trpoc )aev ToOc cocpicTdc eiKOTUJC toOto tt€ttov96t€c (dva- CTdvTec Tdp dTro toO Gpovou Kai drroGeVevoi Td pt-
5 pXia Kai Tdc eicaTUJTdc ev toTc dXriBivoTc toO piou laepeci iuiKpoi Kai utto xcip« qpaivovTai toTc ttoXXoTc), rrepi be Tdiv ovtujc cpiXococpujv ou KaXuJc dTVOoOvTec oTi Ktti CTtoubri Kai TTaibid Kai veO)Lia Kai |H€ibia|ua m\ CKu0pujTTac|Li6c auTuuv, jLidXiCTa b' 6 Trpoc e^acTov ibia
10 Trepaiv6|uevoc X6toc exei Tivd KapTTOv ujqpeXiiuov toTc uTro)ueverv Kai Ttpocexeiv eGicGeTci. 44
13. AeTTai bk Kai t6 rrepi touc eiTaivouc KaGfi- Kov euXapeiac tivoc Kai lueTpiOTriToc bid t6 M^Te ttiv eXXeiipiv auToO )Lir|Te Trjv uTrepPoXriv eXeuGe^piov eivai.
15 ^apuc )uev Tdp dKpoaTrjc Kai cpopTiK^c 6 Trpoc TTCtv dTCTKTOc Kai dTevfic t6 XeTOjaevov, oirijuaTOc urrouXou Kai TTepiauToXoTiac evbia0e'Tou )uecT6c, iwc I'xujv ti Tijuv XeToiuevujv Pe'XTiov eiTreTv, )uriT' 6cppuoc KaTd- CTri)ia Kivujv )ufiTe cpujvfiv euTvuj|uovoc ludpTupa cpiXri-
20 Kotac TrpoTe)aevoc, dXXd ciTrj Kai papuTriTi KaTarrXd- B CTUJ Kai cxri)^ccTicmjj 0ripuj)U€voc boSav €UCTa0oOc Kai pd9oc exovToc dvbpoc, ujcTrep xP^M«tujv tujv ^Ttai- vujv ocov dXXuj lueTabibujciv auToO boKUJv dcpaipeT- c0ai. TToXXoi Tdp eiciv oi KaKUJC Kai Tiapd )ueXoc Tfjv
25 TTu0aT6pou cpujvfiv uTToXa)ipdvovTec. eKeTvoc )uev Tdp eK cpiXococpiac ecpricev auTuj TrepiTeTOTevai t6 ^ribev 0au)udZ!eiv • outoi be t6 luribev erraiveTv |uribe Ti)udv ev Tuj KaTacppoveTv Ti0evTai Kai t6 c€)uv6v uTrepoipia biuj- Kouciv **. 6 Tdp qpiXococpoc Xotoc t6 )uev e£ dTrei-
1, 144-14oH. 6, 158— 160R.
18. ocppuoc KaTdcTrijLia Lobeckius: 6qppOv KOTd cxr^fia 29. Signavi hiatnm dTreipiac Xylander: dTTopiac
102 DE RECTA
C piac Ktti dYVoiac OaOjua Kai GdjuPoc eEaipei YVuOcei Kai xcTopia Tnc rrepi «acTov aiTiac, t6 b' euKoXov Kai i^eiXixov Kai qpiXdvSpuuTrov ouk dTToXXuci. toTc Ydp dXriBivuuc Kai Pepaiiuc dYaGoic Ti|ar| tc KaXXicTiq To Ti)Lificai Tiva tuuv dEiuuv, Kai k6c|Uoc euTrpeTrecTa- 5 Toc t6 erriKOCjuficai t6v ev rrepiouciot boHnc Kai dq)0o- via YiTVOjuevov. oi bk YXicxpoi irepi touc ^Tepouv eTtaivouc eTi TrevecGai Kai rreivfiv ^oiKaci tuiv ibiuuv. 6 b' evavTioc aij TrdXiv toutuuv, lari^^v eTTiKpivujv dXXd KaTd pniaa Kai cuXXa^fiv eSicTdjievoc Kai KeKpa- lo
DYiJ^c, eXaqppoc tic luv Kai 6pveuL)bric, rroXXdKic /aev oub' auToTc dpecKei toTc dYuuviZ;o|Lievoic , dei bk XuTreT touc dKpoiu)uevouc , dvacopdJv Kai cuveEaviCTdc Trapd YviJU|ariv, oiov eXKOjuevouc pia bi' aibo) Kai cuveTtri- XOuvTttc. oubev b ' uj(peXri9eic bid t6 Tapaxuubr) Kai i5 rroXuTTToriTOV auTiiJ Ttepi touc erraivouc YCTOvevai ttiv dKpoaciv dTTepxeTai tijuv TpiOuv ev (pep6|Lievoc ' eipuuv Ydp ^ KoXaE f) Trepi Xoyouc dTreipoKaXoc eboHev eivai. biKnv |uev oijv biKdZiovTa beT |nr|Te Trp6c ex^pav Tivd
E iLifiTe Ttpoc xdpiv dKOueiv dXX' dTr6 Yvuujur|c TTp6c t6 20 biKttiov • ev be TaTc qpiXoXoYoic dKpodceciv ouTe vojuoc oubeic 0C6* opKoc fiiuac dTieipYei |uf| iueT' euvoiac dTtobexeceai t6v biaXeYOjuevov. dXXd Kai t6v '€pfifiv TttTc Xdpiciv 01 TiaXaioi cuYKaBibpucav, ibc judXicTa toO Xoyou t6 Kexapicju^vov Kai TrpoccpiXec dTiaiTouv- 25 Toc. oub^ Ydp oT6v Te TravTeXuuc outuuc dKpoXi- juov eivai t6v XeYOVTa Kai birijuapTriiuevov , ujcTe lufire voOv Tiva TrapacxeTv dHiov dTiaivou |uf|T* dTrojuvr||u6- veuciv ^repuuv |tif|T' aurfiv Tfiv UTr69eciv toO X6you Kai
1, 145— U6H. 6, 160-161 R.
1. ^Eaipel W: ^HaCpei 3. inctXixov*: ju^fa 6. t6v iv* 10. ^Eicxdiuevoc Emperius: ^qpicrduevoc
RATIONE AUDIENDI 103
Trpoaipeciv, dXXa iJir[be XeEiv ti bidOeciv tOuv XeTO|Lievujv, 'ujc dv' exivoTTobac Kai dvd rpiixeiav ovuuviv
qpuovrai juaXaKuuv dvGea XeuKotuuv'. F
OTTOu Ydp e)Lie'Tou Tivec eTKuu|uia Kai TTupeToO Kai vr\
5 Aia x^Tpac eTTibeiKVUjuevoi TTi0av6TriTOC ouk djuoipoO- civ, r\ 7T0U XoYOC utt' dvbpoc djuuucYerrujc boKOuvTOC f\ KaXouiuevou qpiXococpou TTepaiv6|uevoc ouk av oXuuc dvaTTVoriv Tiva Kai Kaipov dKpoaTaic eujueveci Kai (piXavBpuuTTOic Trapdcxoi TTpoc eTTaivov; oi yoOv ev
10 ujpa TTdvTCC, ujc cpriciv 6 TTXdTUJV, d|uriYeTTri bdKVOUCi Tov epuuTiKdv, Kai XeuKouc |uev Beuuv Traibac dvaKa- Xuuv lueXavac b' dvbpiKOuc, Kai tov yputtov paciXiKOv Kai Tov ci|i6v errixapiv tov b' luxpov M^^iXPOuv urro- 45 KopiZ;6|uevoc dcTrdZleTai Kai dYaTra* beivoc Ydp ecTiv
15 6 epujc uucTrep kittoc auTov eK rrdcric dvabficai rrpo- cpdceuuc. TToXu bx] ludXXov 6 qpiXriKooc Kai qpiXdXoYOC dei Tivoc aiTiac eupeTucoc ecTai, bi' nv ouk dTTo Tp6- TTOU Tuuv XeY^VTuuv eKacTov eTraivuuv qpaveiTai. Kai Ydp 6 TTXdTuuv tov Auciou X6yov ouTe KaTd Tfjv eu-
20 peciv eTTaivujv Kai Tfic dTaHiac aiTiuuiuevoc 6)uuuc au- ToO Tfiv dTTaYYeXiav eTraivei, Kai oti 'tuuv ovojudTuuv caqpujc Ktti cTpoYYuXujc eKacTov diT0TeT6pveuTar. |iie|LnpaiTO b' dv tic 'ApxiX6xou |uev Triv urr^Geciv, B TTapjuevibou be Triv CTixoTroiiav, OujKuXibou be Triv
25euTeXeiav, Gupmibou be Triv XaXidv, Co(poKXe'ouc be Tfjv dvuj)uaXiav, uJCTrep djueXei Kai tujv priTdpuuv ecTiv 6 )uev ouK exuuv fjOoc, 6 be Trpoc ttqGoc dpY6c, o b' Ivbefic x«piTuuv eKacT6c fe jufjv erraiveiTai KttTd t6 ibiov Tfjc buvd)ueujc, iJj Kiveiv Kai dYeiv Tre'q)UKev.
1,146— U8H. 6, 161— 164 K.
6. 6,uujcYeTTUJc Reisldus: (iWvjc ye ttujc 10. TTXdTUJv] Rep. V. p. 47 lE ly. TTXdTUJv] Phaedr. i>. 234 E
104 DE RECTA
UJCT€ Ktti ToTc dKOuouciv euTTopiav eivai Kai dcpGoviav ToO (piXoqppoveicGai touc Xe'-fovTac. dvioic ydp e2ap- K€i, Kav )nfi bid (puuvfic ^TTiinapTupujMev , 6|JMaT0c rrpaoTriTa Kai YO^nviv TTpocuuTrou Kai bidGeciv €U|ievn Kai dXuTTov enTTapacxeiv. dKeiva juev ydp r\hr] Kai &
C TTpoc Touc 6Xuoc aTTOTUTxdvovTac ujcTrep ^TKUKXia Kai KOivd udcric dKpodceuuc ^cti, KaGebpa tc' tic dGpu- TTTOC Kai dKXivfic ev dpGuJ cxrmaTi Kai upocpXenJic auTi|> Tuj Xe'TOVTi Kai TdHic ^vepToO TTpocoxnc, Kai TrpocuiTTOu KOTdcTacic KaGapd Kai dve^qpaTOC oux lo uPpeujc oub^ bucKoXiac jiovov dXXd Kai tppovTibujv dXXu)v K(jti dcxoXiuJv. ev epTUJ bk ttovti t6 }ikv Ka- Xov Ik ttoXXuiv oiov dpiGmuv eic eva Kaipov fiKOV- Tujv utto cuMiLieTpiac tivoc Kai dpjjoviac ^TTiTeXeiTai, t6 b' aicxpov ii. ivoc toO tuxovtoc dXXeinovTOC F| if^ TTpocovTOc dTOTTUUc euGuc ^Toi^i^v exei Tfjv Teveciv,
D uJCTTep 4tt' auTTic Tfjc dKpodceuuc ou jjovov papuTric eTTicKuviou Kai dr|bia ttpocuuttou Kai pXemaa pefiPuubec Koi TrepiKXacic cuuiuaTOC Ka\ MHPiJuv ^TTdXXaEic dTrpeTrfic dXXd Kai veO)ia Kai v|Ji9upic)Li6c Trpoc eTepov Kai ^ei- 20 biajia XttC|aai t€ uTTVuubeic Kai KaTfjcpeiai Kai Trav e\' Ti TOUTOic eoiKev uTreuOuvov ecTi Kai beiTai TToXXfic euXapeiac.
14. 0'i bk ToO \ikv X^TOVTOC oiovTai ti ^ptov eivai, ToO b* dKOuovTOc oubev, dXX' eKCivov la^v 25 dHioOciv fiKeiv TreqppovTiK^Ta Kai TTapecKeuac)a^vov, auTOi b' dcKCTTTOi Kai dqppovTibec tuuv KaGriKOVTuuv ^lupaXovTec KaG^ZiovTai KaGdTrep dTexvuuc ^tti beirrvov
EiiKOVTec, eu TraGeiv Trovouiaevujv ^Tepuuv. KaiTOi koi cuvbeiTTVOU Ti xopitVTOC epTOV ^CTi, ttoXu be )adXXov so
1,148— 149H. G, 1G4-165R.
7. T^ W: bi 12. dv W: Ojc tV
RATIONE AUDIENDI 105
otKpoaToO. Koivuuvoc Tcip ecri \6tou xai cuvepToc ToO XcTOVTOC, Ktti ou Tot |uev eKeivou TrXrilLiMe^nMCtfa TTiKpuJC eHeTotZieiv ocpeiXei KaTci pniua koi TrpaTiua rrpoc- diTUJV Tfjv euGuvriv, auToc b' dveuGuvuuc dcxtiiuoveTv
5 Kai TroXXd coXoiKiZ^eiv Trepi Tf)v dKpoaciv, dXX' ujCTrep ev TUJ cqpaipiCeiv tuj pdXXovTi bei cuTKivoujaevov eu- pu0|ua)C cpe'pec6ai tov bex6)aevov, outuuc eTTi tujv Xotouv ecTi Tic eupuGjLiia Kai Tiepi tov XeTOVTa Kai Trepi tov dKpouujaevov, dv ^KaTCpoc t6 TtpocfiKOv auTuj qpuXdTTi;]. P
10 15. Aei be luri^^ faic qpuuvaic tuuv eTtaivuuv dic ^Tuxe xP^lcOai. Kai Tdp 'GrriKoupoc eTTi toTc tuuv qpi- Xuuv eTTiCToXioic KpoToGopupouc TiTvecOai Trap' auTuuv XeTuuv drjbric eCTiv. oi be toc 5evac cpuuvdc toTc dKpoaTripioic vOv eTreicdTOVTec, outoi Kai 'Oeiuuc' Kai
15 ' GeoqpopfjTUJc' Kai 'dTrpociTuuc' eTTiXeTOVTec, ibc ouk- e'Ti ToO 'KaXuuc' Kai toO 'coqpuuc' Kai toO 'dXriOuJc' eHapKoOvTOC, oTc oi rrepi TTXdTuuva Kai CuuKpdTn Kai 'YTTepeibriv expuuvTo crjjueioic tuuv erraivuuv, urrepa- cxriiuovoOci Kai biapdXXouci touc Xe'TOVTac ibc uTrepri- 46
20 (pdvuuv Tivuuv Kai TTepiTTuuv &eo)ue'vouc eTraivuuv. cqp6- bpa b' dr]beTc eici Kai oi |ue0' opKOu toTc Xe'TOuciv ujCTTep ev biKacTripiuj Tdc juapTupiac dTTobib6vTec. oux fiTTOv be TouTuuv 01 TTcpi Tdc TTOi^TriTac dcToxoOvTec, OTav qpiXoc6qpuj )uev eTTiqpuuvuJci 'bpi)ue'uuc', TepovTi b'
25'euq)uuuc' f| 'dvOripuuc', Tdc tuuv TraiZidvTuuv Kai Trav- r|Tupi2:6vTuuv ev TaTc cxoXacTiKaTc jueXeTaic qpujvdc erri touc qpiXoc6qpouc jueTaKOjuiZiovTec Kai X6tuj cuu- qppovoOvTi TTpocqpepovTCC eTraivov eTaipiK6v, uocTrep B dOXriTfi Kpivujv f\ p6bujv CTe'qpavov, ou bdqpvr|c oube
1, 149-150 H. 6, 165— 167 R.
3. TTpocdfUJV Reiskius: TrpocxTUJv 12. 'Gttikoupoc]
Diog. L. X 5
106 DE RECTA
KOTivou 7TepiTi9evT€C. €OpiTTibric \jikv ouv 6 TToiriTric, ujc uTtoXeTOVTOC auToO toic xoptUTaTc ibbr|v Tiva rre- TToiriiLievriv eqp' dpiuoviac eic eTeXacev, 'ei jur| tic ^c dvaic9TiT0c' eiTTe 'Kai cnxaQr\c, ouk dv eTeXacac ejuou /iiHoXubiCTi abovTOc'. dvfip b' dv oT|uai cpiXocoqpoc 5 Kai TToXiTiKoc dKpoaToO biaKexujue'vou Tpuqprjv eKKO- vpeiev eiTTUiv 'cu |uoi boKeic dvoriTOc eivai Kai dvd- YiuYOC' ou Ydp dv ejUoO bibdcKOVTOC r\ vou9eTOuvTOc f) bmXeYOjaevou TTepi 9eiJuv fj TToXiTeiac f| dpxnc eTe- peTiZiec Kai TTpocuupxoO toTc Xoyoic'. opa Ydp dXr)- 10
C 9ujc oiov ecTi qpiXocdqpou Xe'YOVTOC drropeiv toijc eHuu- 9ev UTTO Tuuv evbov pouuvTuuv Kai dXaXaZiovTUJV TTOTe- pov auXoOvTOC x] Ki9apiZ!ovTOC ii opxoujuevou tivoc 6 erraivoc ecTi.
16. Kai jLifiv TU)v Y€ vou9eciujv Kai tujv eTTiTTXr]- 15 Heu)v out' dvaXYnTuuc out' dvdvbpujc dKOucTeov. 01 Ydp euKoXujc Kai oXiYuupuuc t6 KaKuJc dKoueiv utto Tujv qpiXocoqpuuv qpepovTec, uJCTe YcXdv eXeYXojLievoi Kai Touc eXeYXovTac erraiveTv, ujcTTep 01 TrapdciToi Touc Tpe'qpovTac, OTav utt' auTuiv XoibopuJVTai, TTav- 20 TdTTaciv iTajuoi Kai 9paceTc ovTec, ou KaXfjv oub* dXri9fi biboaciv dTTobeiHiv dvbpeiac Tfjv dvaicxuvTiav. CKuJjujua juev Ydp dvu^picTOv ev TTaibia tivi jLieT' eu-
D TparreXiac dqpeijuevov eveYKcTv dXuTTUJC Kai iXapuJc ouk dYevvec oub' drTaibeuTOV dXX' eXeu9epiov Trdvu Kai AaKuiviKOV ecTiv eTraqpfic bk Kai vou9eciac rrpoc eTTav- 6p9ujciv fj9ouc ujcrrep qpapjndKUJ bdKVOVTi Xoyiu XP^- juevric eX^YXOVTi juf) cuvecTaXjue'vov dKOueiv jurib' ibpuu- Toc Kai iXiYYOu juecT^v jurib' aicxuvr) qpXeY^juevov Tfjv vyuxnv dXX' ccTpeTTTov Kai ceoipoTa Kai KaTeipujv€u6- 30
1,150— 151H. 6,167— 169E.
iC. oi*: o\* Te 29. ^xnh'*
RATIONE AUDIENDI 107
ILievov, dveXeuGepou tivoc beivoic Kai dTra9ouc Trpoc ro aibeTc9ai veou bid cuvri9eiav d)iapTri|udTUJV Ka^ cuvexemv, ujCTrep ev CKXripa capKi Kai TuXuubei t^ lijuxrj lULuXiurra ixx) XaiupdvovTOc. toutujv be toioutujv e
5 ovTujv 01 Tfjv evavTiav bid9eciv exovTec veoi Kdv dTTaE TTOTe dKoucujci KaKuuc, cpeuTOVTec dveTTiCTpeTTTi Kai bparreTeuovTec eK qpiXocoqpiac, KaXriv dpxr^v Trpoc t6 cuj9fivai t6 aibeTc9ai Trapd Tfic qpuceujc exovTec, drroXXuouci bid Tpucpfjv Kai luaXaKiav, ouk CYKapTe-
10 poOvTec ToTc eXeTXoic oube Tdc eTTavop9uuceic bexo- ^ievoi TevviKUJC, dXX' ctti Tdc Trpocr]veTc Kai d^raXdc dTTOCTpeqpovTec ojuiXiac Td uiTa, KoXdKUJV TivuJv r| cocpiCTUJv dvujqpeXeic Kai dvoiiTOuc fjbeiac be qpuivdc KaTabovTUJV. ujCTrep oijv 6 iueTd Tfjv TOjifiv qpeuYUJV
15 Tov iaTp6v Kai tov erribecjuov luf) Trpociejuevoc t6 juev dXYeivov dvebeEttTO, t6 b' ujqpeXijuov oux uTTejueive F Tfic 9epaTTeiac outujc 6 tuj x«P«^C(vti Kai TpuucavTi XoYui Tfjv dpeXrepiav drrouXujcai Kai KaTacTfjcai |uf] TTapacxuJV drrnX^e brjxQeic Kai dXYHcac ck qpiXocoqpiac,
20 ujcpeXr]9eic be luribev. ou Ydp Movov, ujc Gupmibric qprjci, t6 TriXeqpou TpaOjua
'TTpicToTci XoYxnc 96XY€Tai pivf||uaciv ', dXXd Kai t6v ck qpiXocoqpiac e|uqpu6|U6Vov euqpueci veoic47 briYMov auT6c 6 Tpuucac Xoyoc idTai. bi6 beT Trdcxeiv
25 juev Ti Kai bdKvec9ai, |uf] cuvTpipec9ai be jurib' d9u- jueTv t6v dXeYXo^evov , dXX' ujCTrep ^v TeXeTr) KaTTiPY- |Lievt]C auToO qpiXocoqpiac touc ttpujtouc Ka9ap|uouc Kai 9opuPouc dvacxdjuevov eXTriZieiv ti y^^ku Ktti Xaju- TTp6v dK Tfjc TTapoucric dbriiuoviac Kai Tapaxfic. Kai
30 Ydp dv dbiKUJC f] eTTiTi|uricic YiTvec^ai boKiQ, KaX6v
1,151 152 H. 6, 16»— 170 E.
22. Nauck. p. 462
108 DE RECTA
dvacxecGai Kai biaKapTepficai XefOVTOC* Trauca|ueviu b' auTov evTuxeiv dTroXoYOU|Lievov Kai beojuevov Triy Tiappriciav iKeivriv Kai tov tovov , iL vuv Kexprirai B TTpoc auTov, eic ti tuuv dXriGuuc d)aapTavo|aevujv qpu-
5 XttTTeiV.
17. "Eti TOivuv ujcrrep ev Tpd)U|uaci Kai Trepi Xu- pav Kai TraXaicTpav ai TrpuJTai )Liaer|ceic ttoXuv exouci Gopupov Kai TTovov Kai dcdqpeiav, eiTa TrpoiovTi KaTd luiKpov ujCTtep Trpoc dvGpiuTTOuc cuvriGeia TToXXr) Kai
10 Yvujcic eYTevoiLi€'vri TtdvTa q)iXa Kai xeipor|9r| Kai pa- bia XeYeiv Te Kai TTpdTTeiv Trape'cxev, outu) bf] mi qpiXocoqpiac exoucric ti Kai Y^icxpov djueXei Kai dcuv- riGec ev toTc TrpuiTOic 6v6|Liaci Kai TrpdY|Liaciv ou bei (poPri0evTa Tdc dpxdc vjjoqpobeuuc Kai dToXiuujc
15 eYKaTaXeiTreiv, dXXd TTeipu))uevov eKdcTOu Kai Trpoc- C_ XiTrapoOvTa Kai Y^ixo^evov tou Trp6cuj Tfjv rrav t6 KaX6v f|bu TTOioOcav dva).ie'veiv cuvr|0eiav. fiHei Ydp ou bid jUttKpoO TToXu qpujc eTTiqpepouca Tr) )Lia9r|cei Kal beivouc ?pujTac ^vbiboOca Trp6c Tfjv dpeTriv, u)v
20 dveu rrdvu TXr|)Liovoc dvbpdc ecTiv r| beiXoO tov dX- Xov urrojueveiv piov, eKTrecovTa bi' dvavbpiav qpiXo- cocpiac. icujc )Liev oijv exei ti Kai Td TrpdYjuaTa toTc dTreipoic Kai veoic ev dpxv) bucKaTav6riTov * ou }xy\v dXXd Tr| Ye TrXeicTri TrepmiTrTOuciv dcacpeia Kai dYVoia
25 bi' auTouc, drr' evavTiujv qpuceujv TauT6v d|uapTd- vovTec. o'i juev Ydp aicxuvri tivi Kai qpeiboT toO Xe'-D YOVTOC 6KVo0vTec dvepe'c9ai Kai Pepaiijucac9ai t6v XoYOV, ujc ^xovTec ev vlu cuveTTiveuouciv, o'i b' uTr6 qpiXoTi|uiac duupou Kai Kevfic Trp6c ^Tepouc d)LiiXXric
30 6HuTriTa Kai buvajuiv eu)ua9eiac eTribeiKvu^uevoi, rrpiv ri XapeTv exeiv ojuoXoyoOvtec, ou Xajupdvouciv. eiTa
1, 159-153 H. 6, 170-172
RATIONE AUDIENDI 109
cujupmvei toTc |uev aibriiuoci Kai ciDUTrriXoTc eKeivoic, Siav dtTTeXGuuci, XurreTv auTouc Kai dTTopeTcGai, Kai TeXoc au6ic utt' dvdTKric eXauvo|Lievouc cuv aicxuvr) laeiZiovi ToTc eiTrouciv evoxXeTv dvaTTuv6avo|uevouc 5 Kai )ueTa6eovTac, toTc be (piXoTiiuoic Kai 6paceciv dei TrepiCTeXXeiv Kai dTroKpuTTTeiv cuvoiKOucav Tfjv d)ua6iav.
18. TTdcav ouv dTTuucdiuevoi Tfjv TOcauTriv pXa- E Keiav Kai dXaZ[oveiav Kai Trpoc t6 |ua6eTv iovTec Kai
10 Trepi t6 Xa^eTv Tri biavoia t6 xpnci)uiuc XeTO/uevov 6vT€C uTro|uevuujaev touc tluv euqpuuuv boKOuvTuuv YeXujTac, ujCTrep 6 KXedvOnc Kai 6 EevoKpdTric ppa- buTepoi boKOuvTec eivai tujv cucxoXacTutv ouk drre- bibpacKOV CK Tou )uav6dveiv oub' drreKa)uvov, dXXd
15 (p6dvovTec eic lauTOuc CTraiCov, dYTeioic t€ Ppaxu-
CTOjuoic Kai TTivaKici x«XKaTc dTreiKdJovTec, ujc )u6Xic
)uev Trapabex6)uevoi touc Xotouc, dccpaXijuc be Kai pe-
Paiujc TripoOvTec. ou Tdp |u6vov, ujc qprjci OujKuXibric
'ttoXX' dTraTri6nvai biZ!r|)uevov e)U)uevai ec6X6v*,
20 dXXd Kai TeXac6iivai beT TroXXd Kai dboHiicai Kai F CKuu)U)uaTa Kai pujjuoXoxiac dvabeHd)uevov ujcac6ai TTavTi Tuj 6u)uuj Kai KaTa6Xficai Tf]v d)ua6iav. ou )uf]v oube Tfic TTp6c TOuvavTiov djuapTiac d)ueXriTeov, iiv d)uapTdvouciv o'i )uev utt6 vuu6eiac, dribeTc Kai kottuu-
2o beic ovTec* ou Tdp e6eXouci Tevdjuevoi Ka6' auTOuc 48 TrpdT)uaTa exeiv, dXXd Trapexouci tlu XeTOVTi, TroXXd- Kic eKTruv6av6)uevoi irepi tujv auTuuv, ujcTrep a.Tnr]- vec veoccoi KexnvoTec dei TTp6c dXXdTpiov CT6)ua Kai TTdv eTOi)uov fibri Kai biaTreTTOvri)uevov utt' dXXuuv e,K-
30 Xa^pdveiv e6eXovT€c. eTepoi be Tipocoxfic Kai bpi)uu-
1, 153— 155H. 6, 172— 174K.
19. Bergk. p. 448 ^
110 r>E IIECTA
xnTOC ev ou beovTi 9ripuj)nevoi boHav dnoKvaiouci XaXioi Kai TTepiepTia touc Xe'T0VTac, dei ti irpocbia- TTOpoOvTec toiv ouk dvaTKaiuuv Kai ZriTouvTec djTO- beiHeic Tujv ou beoiuevuuv. outuuc
'oboc Ppaxeia T^TveTai jiiaKpd', 5
B UJC qpnci CocpoKXf]c, ouk auTOic )u6vov dXXd Kai toTc ctXXoic. dvTiXa|upav6|aevoi Tdp ^KdcTOTe KevaTc Kai TiepiTTaTc epujTriceci toO bibdcKOVTOc, ujcrrep ev cuv- obia, t6 evbeXexec ejUTTobiZiouci Tfic |aa9r|cea)C, em- CTdceic Kai biaTpipdc Xajapavoucric. outoi |uev ouv lo KaTd Tov 'lepuOvu|Ltov ujciTep oi beiXoi Kai TXicxpoi CKuXaKCC Td be'p)LiaTa bdKvovTec oikoi Kai Td TiXjuaTa TiXXovTec Tujv 9r|piujv auTUJV oux dnTOVTar touc b' dpTOUc eKcivouc napaKaXuuiuev, oTav Td KeqpdXaia Tfj voricei TrepiXdpuuciv, auTOuc bi' outujv Td Xomd cuv- iS Ti9evai, Kai Trj luvrmr) x^ipctTUJTCiv Tfjv eupeciv, Kai
C Tov dXX6Tpiov X6tov oiov dpxnv Kai crrepiLia Xap6v- Tac eKTpecpeiv Kai auSeiv. ou ^dp ujc dTTCiov 6 voOc diroTTXripuuceujc , dXX' uTTeKKau)aaToc )a6vov ujcrrep uXr) beTTai , 6p|uf]v eiuTroioGvToc eupcTiKfiv Kai opeHiv ctti 2<j TfjV dXfi9eiav. ujcTrep ouv ei tic ck t£it6vuuv Trupoc b€6)uevoc, eiTa ttoXu Kai Xa|UTTp6v eupujv auToO Ka- ^ Ta)uevoi bid TeXouc 9aXTT6|uevoc, outujc ei tic f^KUJV X6tou lueTaXapeTv rrpoc dXXov ouk oTcTai beTv (puuc oiKeTov eSdTTTeiv Kai voOv ibiov, dXXd xcipwJV Tfi 2!i
DdKpodcei Kd9riTai 9eXT6)uevoc, olov e'peu9oc eXKei Kal Tdvuj)ua Tfiv b6Hav dTTo TuJv X6tujv, tov b' ^vtoc eupujTa TTic Mjuxfic Kai l6q>ov ouk eKTe9epdireuKev oub' eSeuJKe bid qjiXocoqpiac. ei beT tivoc oijv Trpoc
1, 155— 156 H. 6, 174-171 B. .
6. Coq)OK\fic] Antig. 237 11. T^icxpoi] Xixvoi W
28. ^KTeGepiiTieuKe Emperius: iKTeG^piuaKev
I
RATIONE AUDIENDI 111
dKpoaciv eiepou TTapaYTe^M«TOc , bei Kai toO vOv eipriMevou )avri|uoveuovTac dcKeiv d)aa Tfj )Lia9r|cei ttiv eupeciv, 'iva jnfi coqpicTiKtiv 'eiiv }xr\b' iCTopiKf)V dW
evbidGeTOV Kai cpiXococpov Xa)Lipdvuu)aev, dpxnv toO 5 KaXujc piujvai t6 KaXOuc dKoOcai vojuiZ^ovTec.
1, 156H. 6, 176E.
naS AN TIS
AIAKPINEIE TON KOAAKA TOT ^IAOT.
1. Tijj cqpobpa (piXeiv lauTov, ili 'Aviioxe Oi\6- TraTrire, qpdcKOVTi cuttvu)|litiv |aev aTiavTac 6 TTXdTUJv Fbibovai (prici, KaKiav be cOv noXXaic dXXaic dTTiTve- c6ai (acTicTriv, Ocp' fic ouk ecnv auToO KpiTfiv biKaiov oOb' dbcKacTOv eivai- 'TucpXoOTai Tdp t6 qpiXoOv Trepi 5 t6 qpiXouMevov', av |Lir| tic laaGuuv eGicGr) Td KaXd Ti|udv Kai bicuKeiv ladXXov r\ la cuTTevn Kai oiKeia. toOto to) KoXaKi rroXXfiv |ueTaHu thc qpiXiac eupuxuj- piav &ibiuciv, 6p|uriTr|piov eqp' fi)udc euqpuec exovTi Tfjv qpiXauTiav, &i' ryv auT6c auToO KoXaH eKacTOc lo 49 u)v TTpuuTOc Kai |ueTicToc ou xc^eTTiJuc TTpocieTai tov eEuuGev ujv oieTai Kai pouXcTai iudpTuv d|aa auTUj Kai pePaiujTfiv TTpocTiTvdjuevov. 6 Tdp Xoibopoujuevoc qpiXoKoXaE cqpobpa qpiXauToc ecTi, bi' euvoiav dau- Tuj TTdvTa juev UTTdpxeiv pouX6|ievoc rrdvTa b' oio- is juevoc uJv fi |uev pouXrjCic ouk dTorroc f) b' oiri- cic eTTicqpaXfjc Kai beo/uevri rroXXfic euXapeiac. ei be bx] OeTov f) dXii6eia Kai '^TTdvTUJV |uev dTa6u)V 6eoTc
1, 157H. 6, 177— 178 K.
2. TTXdTUJv] Legg. V. p. 731 DE
QUOMODO ADUL. AB AMICO INTERNOSC. 113
TTdvTuuv b' dvGpUurroic ' dpxr) Kaxd TTXdTUDva, Kivbu- B veuei BeoTc ex^poc 6 KoXaH elvai, tiu be TTuGiuj bia- qpepdvTUJC. dvTiTdTTeTai Ydp dei TTpoc t6 'yvujGi cauTov', drrdTriv eKdcTUJ TTpoc eauTOV ejUTTOiuiv Kai
5 dYVOiav lauToO Kai tujv TTepi ^auTov dYaGdiv Kai Ka- KLuv, Td |aev eXXiTTn Kai dTeXii Td b' oXujc dvcTrav- 6p6ujTa TTOiuiv.
2, €i juev ouv, ujc Td TTXeiCTa tujv dXXujv KaKuuv, 6 K6XaH fJTTTeTO |a6vov y\ iudXiCTa tujv dYevvujv Kai
10 cpauXujv , ouK dv f|v outuj beivov oube bucqpuXaK- tov CTTei b' uJCTTep oi Gpmec evbuovTai ladXicTa ToTc dTTaXoTc Kai YXuKeci HuXoic, outuj Td qpiXoTiiua TuJv r|9ujv Ktti xpilcTd Kai eTrieiKfj tov KdXaKa bexeTai Kai Tpecpei Trpocqpuojaevov, eTi b' tucTTep 6 Ci|LiUJVibric c
15 Tf]v ' iTTTTOTpoqpiav ' cpriciv ^ ou ZaKuv9uj OTTabeTv dXX' dpoupaici TTupo96poic', outuj Trjv KoXaKeiav optuiaev ou TTevriciv oub' dbdHoic oub' dbuvdTOic dKoXou9oO- cav, dXX' oiKUJV Te Kai TrpaYMdTUJV jueYdXujv 6Xic9r|Ma Kai v6crma YiYvo|Lievr|v, TToXXdKic be Kai paciXeiac Kai
20 fiYeiuoviac dvaTpe'7T0ucav, ou luiKpov epYOV ecTiv oube cpauXric be6|Lievov Trpovoiac f] Trepi auTfiv iTricKeipic, ujc dv ladXiCTa Trepiqpujpoc oijca }Jir] pXdTTTrj juribe bia- pdXXr) Triv qpiXiav. oi iuev Ydp qp6eTpec dTriaciv dTro Tujv TeXeuTUJVTUJV Kai dTroXeiTTOuci Td cuuiuaTa c^ev-D
25 vujuevou ToO aijuaTOC eH ou TpeqpovTai, touc be ko- XaKOC oub' oXujc ibeTv ecTi rrpdYjuaci EripoTc Kai KaT- evpuYjuevoic Trpoci6vTac, dXXd TaTc bdHaic Kai TaTc buvdjueciv eTTiTi9evTai Kai auEovTai, Taxu b' ev TaTc ^neTapoXaTc dTToppeouciv. dXXd Tf|v TOTe TreTpav ou
-159H. 6, 178-180R.
1. TTXdTuuva] Legg. V. p. 730 C 14. CiiLiujvi6r|c] Bergk, |p. 1122 3 22. pXdTTxri — 6iapd\Xr)*: pXdTTTOi — biapdUoi
Plutarohi Moralia. Vol. I. 8
114 QUOMODO ADULATOR
bei Trepi|Lie'veiv dviucpeXfi , iuaXXov be pXapepctv koi ouk diKivbuvov oucav. xo.\i.-nr\ Tctp ev Kaipuj beo)Lievuj (piXuuv f) Tujv \xr\ qpiXoiv aicericic, ctVTiKaTaXXaYfiv ouk exouca xpIctoO Kai Pepaiou Trpoc dpepaiov Kai Kipbri- Xov. dXX' ujcirep vojuicjua bei tov qpiXov exeiv irpo s
E Tfjc xpciac beboKi)aacjuevov , \xr\ utto Tfjc xpeiac dXcT- XOMCVOV. ou ydp bei pXapevTac aicGecGai, dXX' ottujc |ufi pXapOijjuev ejuTreipiav Xapeiv Kal KaTavoriciv toG KoXaKOc. ei be \xr\, TauTo TreicojueGa toic aic9avo)ue- voic tu) TTpoT€Teuc6ai tujv 0avaci)uujv q)ap)adKUJV eic lo Tfjv Kpiciv dTToXXuvTec ^auTouc Kai biacp6eipovTec. ouTe Tdp hr\ toutouc eTraivou]uev ou9' -Scoi tov qpi- Xov eic t6 KaXov Ti9e|uevoi Kai luqpeXiiuov oiovtoi touc K€xapic)uevujc 6|uiXouvTac eu9ijc ^x^iv eTt' au- Toqpijupiu KoXaKac eiXTijujuevouc. oube Tdp dr|bfic 6 15 qpiXoc oub' ttKpaTOC, oube Ttu TTiKpuJ ce)uv6v r\ ^iXia
F Kai aucTTipuJ, dXX' auT6 bfi toOto t6 KaX6v Kai t6 ce)uv6v auTric r\b\) Kai TTo9oujuev6v ecTi,
'TTdp' b' auTfj XdpiTCC te Kai "Ijuepoc oiKi'
e6evT0 ', ^
KOl OU buCTUXOOVTl JUOVOV
'eic ojujuaT' euvou qpujT6c ^jupXeipai t^uku* KaT* €upiTTibriv, dXX' oubev tittov toic dTa6oTc fjbo- vfiv ^TTiqpepouca Kai x<ip*v ^ tujv KaKuJv dcpaipoOca Tdc XuTTac Kai Tdc drTOpiac TTaperreTai. Kai Ka6dTTep 60 6 €uTivoc eiTTe , tOuv fibucjudTUJV t6 ttOp eivai KpdTi- ac CTOV, ouTUJ TUJ piuj )uiHac Tfiv qpiXiav 6 9e6c ctTTavTa qpaibpd Kai TXuKea Kai TrpocqpiXfi TauTric TTapoucr]C Kai cuvaTToXauoucric ^TToir^cev. erTei ttujc Sv 6 KoXaE uirebueTO Taic fibovak, ei Tfiv qpiXiav ^uOpa t6 fibu
1, 159-161H. 6, 180— mii
19. Hesiod. Tbeog. 64 22. edpnribriv] lon. 732
i
AB AMICO INTERNOSCATUR 115
)ariba|uoO TTpocie|uevr|V ; ouk ecTiv eiTTeiv. aXK' ujcTiep xd vjieuboxpoca xai xd Kipbr|Xa ifiv XaiairpoTriTa ToO xpucoO Kai t6 Y«vu)|Lia )Lii|aeiTai juovov, outujc eoiKev 6 KoXaH toO qpiXou t6 fibu Kai Kexapic)ie- B
5 vov eKjaijLioujLievoc dei irapexeiv iXapov Kai dven- pov Kai 7Tp6c )uribev dvTiPaivovTa }xr]y uirevavTiou- jLievov ^auTov. 69ev oube touc iTtaivoOvTac eu9uc djc KoXaKeuovTac dTrXuJc ucpopaTeov ' erraivoc Ycip oux fiTTOv ev Kaipuj vyof ou ^iXia TtpocriKei , )LidXXov be to
10 )Liev bucKoXov oXujc Kai laejunjijuoipov dcpiXov Kai dvo- juiXriTov, Tfic b' d(p96vu)C Kai 7Tpo9u)au)c t6v eTti toic KaXoTc dTTObiboucric etraivov euvoiac Kai t6 vou9e- Touv au9ic Kai 7Tappricia26)uevov eXaqppuic Kai dXuTTUJC uTTO|uevojuev , TTiCTeuovTec Kai dYttTTuJVTec ujc dvaT-
15 Kaiujc ipe^fovTa t6v fibeujc iTraivoOvTa.
3. XaXeTr6v ouv qjairi tic dv ecTi biaKpivai t6v C KoXaKtt Kai t6v qpiXov, ei )uri9' fibovr^ )ur|T' eTTaivuj bia(pe'pouci • Kai ydp iv UTTOupYiaic Kai biaKOviaic TToXXdKic ibeiv eCTi Tr^v qpiXiav utt6 Tfic KoXaKeiac
20 TrapaTpexo)ue'vr|V. ti b' ou jueXXei; (pricojuev, dv tov dXri9iv6v KoXaKa Kai |U€Td beivoTriToc Kai Texvr|C drr- TOjuevov ToO TrpdTiuaToc biujKUJ)uev, dXXd )ur), Ka9dTrep 01 TToXXoi, Touc auToXr|Ku9ouc toutouc XeYO)u^vouc Ktti TpaTreZe'ac Kai )ueTd t6 KaTd x^ipoc libujp dKOu-
25 o)uevouc ujc Tic eiTre KoXaKac vo)uiZ;uj)uev, iliv dv )uia XoTtdbi Kai KuXiKi )ueTd puj)uoXoxiac Kai pbeXupiac fjD dveXeu9epia YiTveTai KaTdbr|Xoc. ou ydp br|TT0u Me- Xdv9iov ebei t6v 'AXeHdvbpou toO Oepaiou TrapdciTOV egeXeTxeiv , oc toTc epujTuici ttujc 'AXeHavbpoc eccpdtrj
30 'bid TTic TTXeupdc' eXexev *eic Tfiv TacTepa Tfjv e)ur|v', oube Touc d|u<pi TtXouciav TpdTieZav IfKUKXouiuevouc,
1, IGl— 163H. 6,182— 184K.
8*
116 QUOMODO ADULATOR
ouc ou TrOp ou cibapoc oube xa^KOC eipYei pif\ cpoiiav em beiTTVOV, oube idc ev KuTrpuj KoXaKibac, eTreibr] bie^ricav eic Cupiav, KXijuaKibac TTpocafopeuBeicac, oti
E Taic YuvaiHi tOuv paciXeiuv dvapaiveiv eTri Tdc djudSac bi' auTuov uTTOKaTaKXivQjievai napeixov. 5
4. Tiva ouv bei qpuXdTTecSai; tov }iy] boKOuvTa )Lirib' ojLioXoYoOvTa KoXaKCueiv, ov ouk ecTi XapeTv Trepi TouTTTdviov, oub' dXicKCTai cKidv KaTajueTpujv Tf]v eTTi t6 beiTTVov, oub' eppiTTTai |aeeuc0eic ottujc eTuxev, dXXd vrjqpei Td TToXXd Kai TToXurrpaYHOvei Kai 10 TTpdHeujv laeTexeiv oTeTai beiv Kai Xoyujv dTroppr|TUJv PouXeTai Koivujvoc eivai, Kai oXujc TpaYiKoc dcTiv ou caTupiKoc cpiXiac uTroKpiTfic o6be KUJmKoc. ujc Ydp 6 TTXdTUJV (pr\dv 'dcxdTric dbiKiac eivai boKeiv bi-
F Kaiov [xr\ ovTa', Kai KoXaKeiav fjYnTeov xc^^Trfiv Tf)v 15 XavGdvoucav ou Tfiv ojuoXoYoOcav, oube Tfjv TraiCou- cav dXXd Tfjv CTTOubdCoucav " auTri Ydp dvaTriiuTrXrici Ktti Tfjv dXriGivfiv q)iXiav dTriCTiac, cuveKTrirrTOucav auTr) TroXXdKic, dv juf) Trpocexujjaev. 6 |Liev ouv Tuj- ppuric eic CKOTeivov oiKTi)ia tlu jLidYty cpeuYOVTi cuveic- 20 Trecujv Kai Yev6)aevoc ev biaTrdXaic ^TTicTdvTa Kai biaTTopoOvTa tov Aapeiov ^KeXeucev u}9eiv Kai bi ' djLicpoTepujv • fijueTc be, ei |Liriba|Lifi |Lir|ba)Liujc erraivoO- )Liev t6 'eppeTUJ cpiXoc cuv dxBpuJ', bid ttoXXuiv 6|uoio- 61 TfiTUJV Tov KoXaKa Tuj (piXuj cu)UTreTrXeY)Lievov dTrocTrd- 25 cai ^TiToOvTec 6cpeiXo|uev eu judXa qpoPeTcGai fifi ttu)c ri Tuj KaKijj t6 xpilciMOV cuveKpdXuj)uev r| cpeibojuevoi ToO oiKeiou tiIi pXdrrTOVTi TTepmecuj^uev. ujcTrep Ydp oT)iai Tujv dYpiujv CTTep)udTUJV oca Kai cxfi)Lia Kai
1, 163—164 H. 6, 184—185 E.
1. oO TrOp] Meinek. II. p. 487 9. Triv ^Ttl t6*: iTti
14. TTXdTiuv] Rep. p. 361 A 24. epp^xuj] Nauck. p. 696
-J
AB AMIGO INTERNOSCATUR 117
|neT€9oc TrapaTrXiiciov exovia tuj Trupuj cumae')aiKTai x«- XeTriiv exei Trjv otTTOKdGapciv (f| -^ap ou bieKTTiTTTei Tujv CTevoTepuuv TTopuuv f\ cuveKTTiTTTei bia Tujv dpai- ujv), ouTUJC f] KoXaKeia Tfjc qpiXiac eic Trav TrdOoc Kai 5 TTdv Kivrma Kai xP^icv Kai cuvnGeiav eauTrjv !caTa)iii- Tvuouca bucxiupicToc ecTiv.
5. "Oti luevToi ye TrdvTUJV fibicTOv ecTiv r\ qpiXia Kai oubev dXXo iudXXov euqppaivei, bid toOto Kai oB KoXaE fibovaic uTTdYeTai Kai Trepi fjbovdc dcTiv. oti
10 b' fi xapic Kai f) xptici ■xx] qpiXia TTapeTTeTai (Ka9' 6 hx] Kai XeYCTai TTupoc Kai ubaTOC 6 qpiXoc dvaTKaiOTepoc eivaO, bid touto einpaXujv eic Tdc UTTOupTiac eauTOV 6 KoXaH d)LiiXXdTai CTroubacTiKoc dei qpaivecGai Kal doKVOC Kai TTpoGujuoc. eTrei be t6 iudXiCTa qpiXiac
15 dpxnv cuvexov ojuoiottic eCTiv eTriTribeujadTWV Kai f|6ujv, Kai oXujc t6 xctip^iv toic auToTc Kai t6 TauTd qpeuxeiv ttpujtov eic tout6 cuvdTei Kai cuvicTr]ci bid Tfic ojuoiOTTaGeiac, touto KaTibubv 6 KoXaH auT6v ujCTTep uXrjv Tivd puGiaiZiei Kai cxnMCtTiJei , TTepiap- C
20 laocai Kai TrepmXdcai JriTiuv oic dv ^TTixeipr] bid jui- jufjceujc, uYp6c ujv Kai TTi9av6c jueTapdXXec9ai ctti Tdc eHojuoiuuceic, ujct' eiTTeTv
*ou TTaTc 'AxiXXeujc, dXX' eKcTvoc auT6c ei*. 6 be TTdvTUJV ecTiv auToO TTavoupYOTaTOv , aic9av6-
25 juevoc TTiv TTappriciav Kai Xef ojuevrjv Kai boKOucav ibiav elvai qpujvfiv ujCTrep tiv6c Cujou ttic qpiXiac, t6 b' drrappriciacTOV dqpiXov Kai dyevvec, oube TauTr|v djuijuriTOv dTToXeXoiTTev , dXX' ujCTrep oi beivoi TuJv onJOTTOiujv ToTc TTiKpoTc x^MO^c Kai aucTripoTc fibucjuaci
soxpuJVTai, Tuuv yXuKeujv dcpaipouvTec t6 TTXf|C|uiov, ouTUJC 01 KoXaKec ouk dXr|9ivfiv oub' ujcpeXijuov dXX'D
J, 1 4— 166H. 6, 185— 187 B.
23. Nauck. p. 696
118 QUOMODO ADULATOR
oiov eTTiWuuTTTOucav eS oqppuoc Kai TttpTaXiZioucav (XTexvaiC rrappriciav Trpocqpepouciv. ^cti |uev ouv bid TauTa bucqpuOpaToc 6 dvrip, ujcrrep tuuv eripiuuv oca tt€- cpuKOTa Tfjv xpoctv TpeTTecGai cuvaqpoiLioiouTai toic utto- KeijLievoic \p{bnac\ Kai xwipioic eTTei b' dKeivoc eEa- 5 TraTtt Te Kai TrepiKaXuTTTeTai TaTc ojuoioTriciv, fmeTepov epYov ecTi Taic bia^opaic dvaKaXuTTTeiv Kai dTTO- TU|uvouv auTOV 'dXXoTpioic xP^JUMaci Kai cxn^aciv', fj qpriciv 6 TTXdTUJV, 'xnf^i okeiujv Koc)uou)Lievov '.
6. GuGuc oijv dTTO ttic dpxnc CKOrrujiuev. dpxriv lo be qpiXiac eqpaiuev eivai toTc TrXeicTOic Triv TauTd )uev E eTTieiKuuc dcTTaZ;o|uevriv e9ri Kai fiGri toTc b' auToTc xai- poucav ^TTiTiibeujuaci Kai TTpdTiuaci Tai biaTpijBaTc ojuoio- TTaGfi bidGeciv Kai qpuciv, eqp' fjc Kai TaOTa eipriTai
^Tepuuv TcpovTi y\(uccav fjbicTriv exei, i5
TtaTc TTaibi, Kai TuvaiKi TTpoccpopov Tuvfj, vocuuv t' dvfip vocoOvTi, Kai bucTrpaHia Xr|99eic eTTUjboc ecTi tlu TTeipuujuevLu'.
eibubc oijv 6 KoXaH oti t6 xwiptiv toTc 6)uoioic Kai t6 xP^c9ai Kai dTaTTciv ^juqpuTov icxi , TauTri ttpuutov 20 F enixeipeT TrXrjcidZieiv dKdcTiy Kai TrapacKrjvoOv, ujCTrep ^v Tici vojuaTc 9ripiou toTc auToTc eTTiTribeu)uaci Kai biaTpiPaic TTepi TauTd Kal CTroubaTc Kai biaiTaic dTpe')Lia TTapapdXXuuv Kai TTpocavaxpuuvvujuevoc, dxpi ou Xapfjv TTapabuj Kai vpauovTi Ti9ac6c T^vriTai Kai 23 cuvf|9nc, vp^Tuuv juev oic ^KeTvov aic9dveTai TTpdT- )uaci Kai pioic Kal dv9puuTT0ic dx96|uevov, ^TTaiveTric be Tujv dpecKOVTuuv ou jueTpioc dXX' ujc9' uTTeppdX- 62 Xeiv cuv eKTTXfiHei Kai 9au|uaTi 9aiv6)uevoc, pepaiuuv
1,166— 167 H. 6, 187-139 R
8 TT\dTuiJvl Pliaedr. p. 239 D 15. Nauck. p. 696
I
AB AMICO INTERNOSCATUR 119
hk t6 qpiXoOv Ktti t6 mcoOv ujc Kpicei |ua\Xov r\ Trd- 0ei YiTv6|uevov.
7. TTuuc ouv eXeTX^Tai Kai ticiv dXicKeTai biaqpo- paTc, ouK u)V Ojaoioc oube YiTvojuevoc dXXd |ai)iiou-
5 luevoc ojuoiov ; irpajTOV )uev opdy bei ttiv 6|uaX6TtiTa Tfjc Trpoaipeceojc Kai t6 evbeXexec, el x^^P^^ ^e toic auTOic dei Kai TauTd eTraivei Kai Ttp^c ev drreuBuvei Kai Ka9icTrici TtapdbeiTlua t6v dauToO piov, ujCTrep eXeuGepuj ^iXiac ojuoiotpottou Kai cuvn.Geiac epacTf)
10 TtpocriKei, toioOtoc Ydp 6 qpiXoc. 6 be KoXaE aTe bfi |uiav ^CTiav fiGouc ouk exujv |u6vi)uov oub' eauTo» piov l(bv aipeTov, dXX' ^Tepuj Kai TTp6c eTCpov TtXdT- B Tujv Kai TtpocapiuoTTUJV ^auTov, oux dTiXoOc oub' eic dXXd TravTobaTToc ecTi Kai TroiKiXoc, eic dXXov eE
15 dXXou TOTTOv ujcTTep t6 jueTepuu.uevov ubujp Trepippeujv dei Kai |ueTacxTiMaTiZ;6|uevoc toTc UTTobexo)uevoic. 6 |uev Tdp iuTOc, lijc eoiKe, )ui,ueTc9ai t6v dvBpujTTOV eTTixeipuuv dXicKeTai cuYKivoujievoc Kal cuvopxoujuevoc, 6 be KoXag aOT6c dTepouc CTrdTeTai Kai TraXeuei, |ui-
2) |aou|uevoc oux 6)uoiujc dTravTac dXXd tuj juev cuvop- Xou)uevoc Kai cuvdbujv, tuj be cujUTraXaiujv Kai cut- Koviofievoc- 9r|peuTiKoO be Kai KuvT^YeTiKoO Xap6)uevoc jAOVOvou Td THC Oaibpac dvapoujv eTreTai
*Trp6c 0eOuv epaiuai kuci 0u)uEai C
2'- PaXiaic eXdqpoic eYXPiT^TOjuevoc ',
Kai oubev auTuj TrpdYiua Trp6c t6 0r|piov, dXX' auT6v eKcaYiiveuei Kai TrepipdXXeTai t6v kuvtiy^v. av be 0ripeuri qpiXoXoYov Kai qpiXojua0fi veov, au0ic ev ^i- pXioic ecTi Kai ttujyujv TTobfipric Ka0€TTai Kai Tpipuj-
1,107-1 G9H. 6, 189-m±
15. |a€T€piu)aevov Lobeckius:, |aeTaip6|uevov 24. Eur.
Hipp. 218
120 QUOMODO ADDLATOR
vocpopia t6 XPH^ct koi dbiaqpopia, koi bia CT6MaT0C oT Te dpi6)aoi Kai tci 6p0o-fuJVia TpiYUJva TTXdTiJuvoc. ei Te pdeu^oc tic iixniTxaxKiv auBic koi q^iXoTTOTric Kai irXoiicioc,
' auTdp 6 TUMVU)0r| ^aKewv iroXunnT^c 'Obucceuc ', »
DeppiTTTai \xkv 6 .Tpipujv, KaTaKeipeTai h' 6 ttiutujv ujcrrep dKaptrov e^poc, qjuKTfipec be Kai cpidXai Kai teXujTec ^v TrepmdToic Kai CKuuiaMaTa Ttpoc touc 91X0- coqpoOvTttc. ujCTtep ^v CupaKOucaic cpaciv, ^rrriviKa nXdTUJV dcpiKCTO , Ktti Aiovuciov ifiXoc ^cxe Trepiiaa- 10 vfjc (piXococpiac , Td paciXeia KOViopToO y^MCIv utto TTXrieouc Tuiv T£<J^M£TpouvTUJV • ^TTei be TTpoce'Kpouce TTXdTUJV Ktti Aiovucioc dKTTecibv q)iXocoq)iac TTdXiv eic TTOTOuc Kai Tuvaia Kal t6 XripeTv Ka\ OKoXacTai-
E veiv fiKe (pep6)ievoc, dOpdujc fiTravTac uJCTTep h Kip- » Kric laeTajLiopcpujeevTac d^oucia Kai Xrieri Kal eurieeia KttT^cxe. MapTupei bfc Kai Td tu)V laeTdXujv IpTa ko- XdKUJV Ka\ Td Tujv briMOTuJTuJV , iLv 6 ^ctictoc 'AX-
KlPldbnC, 'AenVTlCl IH^V CKUJTTTUJV Ka\ \TTTTOTpOq)U)V KOl
H€Td euTpaTTcXiac Zijuv xai x«PiTOc, iv bt AaKCbai- «0 liQvi K€ip6|aevoc iv XP^ ^^^ Tpipujvoqjopuuv Ka\ qju- XpoXouTuiv, iv bk GpdKr) rroXemJUV Ka\ rrivujv dTTe\ hk Kpoc Ticcaq)^pvr)v dq^iKCTO, Tpuq)rj Kai dppoTriTi Ka\ dXaZioveia xPiAJMevoc dbii|aaTu)T€i Ka\ KaeujpiXei Tuj cuvaq)0)aoiouv Ka\ cuvoiKeioOv ^auTOV STraciv. ou " P^fiv toioOtoc '€TTa|aeivu)vbac oub' 'ATnciXaoc, dXXd TTXeicTOic 6mXr|cavTec dvepuuTroic Ka\ TT6Xeci Ka\ pioic t6 TrpocnKOv f|eoc auToic rravTaxoO Kai CToXri Kai biaiTr) Ka\ X6tuj Ka\ piiy bieq)uXaTTOV. outuj Ka\ TTXd-
1,169-170H. 6,191— 193B
3. €l T€*: €?T€ 6. Homer. x 1
AB AMICO INTERNOSCATUR 121
TU)v ev CupaKOucaic oioc ev 'AKabri|ueia , Kai irpoc Aiovuciov oioc TTpoc Aiuiva.
8. Tdc be Tou KoXaKOc ujcirep ttoXutto&oc TpoTrdc pqicTa q)ujpdceiev ctv tic auTOc eiTi TToXXd boKU)v Tpe-
5TTec0ai, Kai ipe'YUJV juev 6v errrivei TTpoTepov piov, ok b ' fjxOeTo TTpdYiuaciv f| biaiTaic r| Xotoic ujc dpecKov- Tac eHaicpvric TTpocie'|aevoc. onjeTai tdp auTov ouba- 53 fiou pepaiov oub' ibiov oub' oiKeiuj TTdOei qpiXouvTa Kai imcouvTa Kai xaipovTa Kai XuTTOU)aevov, dXXd biKTiv
io KaTOTTTpou TTa9u)v 60veiu)v Kai piuiv Kai KivrnndTUJV eiKovac dvabex6|uevov. toioutoc ydp oioc ei ipeYoic Tivd TU)V qpiXuJV TTp6c auT6v eiTreiv 'Ppabeujc Treqju)- paKac t6v dv0pujTTov ejiioi |aev ydp oube TTpoTepov fipecKev'. dv b' au TTdXiv eTTaivrjc )aeTapaXX6)aevoc,
15 vf) Aia qpricei cuvribec0ai Kai x«Piv ^'x^iv auT6c uirep Tou dv0pu)rrou Kai TriCTeueiv. dv be piov dXXaKTeov eTcpov eiTTrjc , oiov eic dTTpayiaocuvriv Kai f]cuxiav eK B TToXiTeiac laeTapaXojuevoc, 'TTdXai ye ^XPHv' qpHci '0opuPujv fiiadc dTTriXXdx0ai Kai <p96vujv'. av be
20 TTdXiv 6p)Liav boKrjc Itti t6 TTpdTTeiv Kai Xe'Yeiv, uTre- cpujvTicev *dHia cauTou qppoveic" f\ b' dTTpaYMOCuvri yXukij juev, dXX' dboEov Kai TaTTeiv6v'. eu0uc ouv XeYeiv xpf| TTp6c t6v toioutov
'dXXoioc |Lio», Heive, (pdvrjc veov ^e Trdpoi^ev',
25 ou beoiaai qpiXou cuM|ue0iCTa|Lie'vou Kai cuvemveuovTOC (n Ydp cKid TttOTa TTOieT jadXXov), dXXd cuvaXri^euovTOC Kai cuveTTiKpivovTOc.
Gic |Liev ouv tOuv eXe'YXuuv Tporroc toioutoc ecTiv (9) eTepav be bei Taic 6|aoiujceci TOiauTTiv Trapaqpu- C
1,170— 171H. 6,193— 194B.
24. 2eTv6 qpdviic Homerus u 181: Setv' ^qpdvrjC
122 QUOMODO ADULATOR
XdiTeiv biaqpopdv. 6 )uev dXriOrjC qpiXoc ouxe )ui)ur|Tr|c ^CTi TTdvTuuv out' eTtaiveTric TTp69ujuoc, dXXd tujv
dpiCTUUV jUOVUJV
'ou Ydp cuvexOeiv dXXd cujuqpiXeTv eqpu' KaTd Tov CocpoKXe'a , Kai vx] Aia cuTKaTop9ouv Kai s cujiqpiXoKaXeiv, ou cuvajuapTdveiv oube cuppabioupYeiv, dv }xr\ Tic oTov 6qp9aX|iuac dTTOppofi Kai dvdxpiucic ttKOVTa bi' 6juiXiav Kai cuvr|9eiav dvaTcXricr) cpauXoTTi- Toc f) ■TTXr|)U)ueXeiac tivoc. ujc ttou Kai TTXdTUJVoc dTT0|ui)ueTc9ai qpaci touc cuvr|9eic t6 eTTiKupTOv, 'Api- lo
D CTOTeXouc be t6v TpauXic|u6v , 'AXeHdvbpou be tou PaciXeujc Tfjv eTKXiciv toO TpaxnXou Kai Tfjv ev TuJ biaX6Tec9ai TpaxuTriTtt thc qpujvfic" Td Tdp TToXXd Xav9dvouciv evioi Kai dTT6 tuuv t^^ujv Kai dTT6 tujv piuuv dvaXa)updvovTec. 6 be KoXaS dTexvuuc t6 toO is Xa)uaiXeovTOc TTe'rrov9ev. eKeTvoc tc Tdp dTTdcr) xpoa TrXfiv ToO XeuKoO cuvaqpo)uoiouTai, Kai 6 KoXaE ev toTc dSioic CTTOubfjc 6)uoiov dauT6v eHabuvaTuuv TTapexeiv oub^v dTToXeirrei tuuv aicxpuuv d|ui)UTiTOv, dXX' ujcTrep 01 qpaOXoi ZiiuTpdqpoi tuuv KaXuuv eqpiKveTc9ai )uf] buvd- 20 luevoi bi' dc9eveiav ev puTici koi qpaKoTc Kai ouXaTc
E Tdc 6]uoi6TriTac dvacpaivouciv , outuuc cKeTvoc dKpa- ciac TiTveTai )ui]uriTfic, beicibai)aoviac dKpoxoXiac, tti- Kpiac Trp6c oiKeTac, dmcTiac TTp6c oiKeiouc Kai cut- TcveTc. qpucei Te Tdp dqp' dauToO TTp6c Td x^ipova 25 KaTdvTrjc ecTi, Kai boKeT TToppuJTdTuu toO ijjeTCiv t6 aicxp6v elvai )ui|UOU|uevoc. uttotttoi Tdp 01 Td peX- Tiuj Z;»iXoOvTec Kai boKoOvTec dx9ec9ai Kai buCKoXai- veiv ToTc d]uapTf|)uaci tuuv qpiXujv 0 bfi Kai Aiovuciuj
1,171— 1T2H. 0, 194— 19GR.
6. CoqpOKX^a] Antig. 53.3 22 dvacpaivouciv*: dvaqp^-
pouciv 28. 2riXoOvT€C Reiskius: ilriToOvTec
AB AMICO INTERNOSCATUR 123
j Aiujva Kai Cdmov <t>i\i7r7TLu Kai K\eo)i€vri TTTo\e|aaiuj
' biepa\e Kai dKuu\ec€v. 8 be pou\6|uevoc eivai Kai boKeiv 6)noiujc fjbuc a)aa Kai ttictoc toic x^ipoci |ua\- \ov uTTOKpiveTai x«ipeiv, lijc utto toO cqp6bpa (pi\exv
5 oube Td cpaO\a bucxepaivujv , dWd cu)iiTra0f)C TTdci F Kai cujuqpufic TiTv6|uevoc. 69ev oube tuuv dpou\riTUJV Ktti Tuxripujv d)uoipeiv dEioOciv, dWd Kai voceTv 6)uoia TTpocTTOioOvTai, Ko\aK6uovTec Touc vocuubeic, Kai )LiriTe p\eTTeiv oHu hy\t' dKoOeiv, dv OTroTucp\oic f| uttokuu-
10 qpoic cuvujciv, uJCTrep oi Aiovuciou K6\aKec d)ap\uuj- TToOvToc e)UTTiTTTOVTec dWrj^oic Kai Tdc TTapoipibac ev Tuj beiTTveiv KaTapdWovTec. Ivioi be Kai )ud\\ov dTTT6)ievoi Tujv Tra9u)v ^vboTe'puj iroioOciv eauTouc, Kai KaTa)uiTVuouciv dxpi tujv dTTOppr|Tu>v Tdc 6)uoio-
15 TTa9eiac. aic96iuevoi Tdp ri TTepi Tdjuov bucTuxoOvTac 54 f-| TTpoc uiouc f| Trpoc oiKeiouc utt6tttu)C exovTac au- Toi cqpujv auTUJV dqpeiboOci Kai dTTobupovTai Trepi Te'- Kvujv ibiujv f| TuvaiKoc f| cuttcvOuv f| oiKeiujv, aiTiac Tivdc dTToppiiTOuc eEaTopeuovT€C. fj Tdp 6)uoi6Tric
20 cu)UTTa9ecTe'pouc rroiei, Kai )ud\\ov ujCTrep 6)uripa be- beTjuevoi TTpoievTai ti tuuv drToppfiTUJV auToTc, rrpoe- )U€voi be xpuJvTai Kai bebiaciv eTKaTa^meTv Tfjv tti- cTiv. dTU) b' oibd Tiva cuveKPa\6vTa ttiv ya}xeTr\v, ujc 6 qpi\oc dTTeTTe)uv|jaTO ttiv dauToO* Kpuqpa bk cpoi-
25 Tujv Trpoc auTriv Kai biaTTe)UTT6)i6voc €qpujpd0ri , cuvai- B c9o|uevric Tfic toO qpi\ou TuvaiK6c. outuJc drreipoc fiv K6\aKoc 6 vojuiZiujv Td la^upeTa TauTi tlu KapKivtu )ud\\ov f\ Tuj K6\aKi TTpocfiKeiv
^TacTrip 6\ov to cu))ua, rravTaxfi P\€'ttujv
30 6qp9a\|u6c, eprrov toTc oboOci 9ripiov'
J, 172— 174H. 6, 196— 198R.
23. Ti^iv* 29. Meinek. p. 489. Bergk. p. 1309 ^
124 QUOMODO ADULATOR
TTapaciTOu fdp 6 toioOtoc eiKOviciuoc ecTi
'tOuv irepi TdTnvov Kai juct' dpiCTOv (pi\ujv% ujc GuTToXic qpriciv.
10. Ou \ir]v dXXd TauTa )aev eic tov oiKeiov dva- 9uj)aeea ToO Xotou tottov iKeTvo be ixi] Trapujjaev ev s Taic iLiiiLiriceci t6 coqpiciaa toO KoXaKOC, oti Kotv tujv
C KaXujv Ti |Lii)afiTai toO KoXaKCuojaevou , biacpuXdTTei Trjv uTTepoxrjV eKeiviu. toTc |uev fap dXrjGujc qjiXoic ouTe ZfiXoc oubeic dcTi TTpoc dXXr|Xouc ouTe qpBovoc, dXXd Kdv icov exujciv ev tuj KaTopGoOv Kdv eXaTTOv, lo dvcTraxOuic KaT ^eTpiujc (pe'pouciv. 6 be KoXaH del lavriMoveuuJv toO Td beuTepa Xeyeiv uqpieTai ti^ 6|uoi6- TriTi Tnc icoTTiToc, fiTTdc0ai TravTaxou Kai dTToXeirTe- cSai TtXfiv Tujv (pauXuJV 6juoXoyujv. iv be toTc (pau- Xoic ou TTapirjci t6 TrpujTeTov, dXXd qprjciv, dv eKeTvoc is ^ bucKoXoc, auT6v eivai lueXaYXoXiKov • dv eKeTvoc beicibaiiuujv, auT6v eeocpopriTOv • dpdv dKeTvov, juaive- ceai b* auTOV. 'dKaipujc' qpriciv 'exeXac, eYuj b' eHe-
DevriCKOV utt6 toO tcXujtoc'. dXX' ev fe toTc xP^ICtoTc TOuvavTiov. auToc qprici Taxeujc Tpe'xeiv, mTaceai b' 20 eKeTvov auT6c iTTTreueiv eTTieiKuuc, 'dXXd Ti Trp6c t6v iTTrroKevTaupov toOtov; euqpufic eiui TroiriTfic Kai cti- Xov ou qpauXoTaTov fpacp^x),
'PpovTdv b' ouK d)Li6v dXXd Aioc.'* d|na tdp auToO boKeT Kai TfjV Trpoaipeciv dTroqpaiveiv 25 KaXfjv |ii)Liou)aevoc Kai Tfjv buvajLiiv dveqpiKTOV tittuj- )Lievoc. ev )li^v ouv TaTc €Ho)noiuuceci ToiaOTai Tivec eiciv ai toO KoXaKoc biaqpopai TTp6c t6v qpiXov.
1, 174— 175H. 6, 19S— 199E.
2. Meinek. II. p. 489 ineT'] Kax' Schaferus 24.
Bergk. p. 13553
AB AMICO INTERNOSCATUR 125
11. '€iTei b' OjCTrep eipriiai Kai t6 rfic fibovfic KOivov ecTi (xciipei Tap o^X tittov toic (piXoic 6 XP^- CToc f| Toic KoXaHiv 6 qpaOXoc), q)epe Kai toOto bio- picuujuev. ecTi be biopic|Li6c f) irp^c t6 tcXoc dvacpopa
5 TfjC flbOVnC. CKOTiei h' OUTUUC. IveCTl jUeV TTOU TUJ E
iuupuj t6 euujbec, evecTi b' ev dvTiboTiu. biaqpepei b' OTi toOto juev 7Tp6c fibovf]v Ktti TTpoc oubev eTepov YCYOvev, dKei be t6 Ka9aTpov r\ t6 GepiaaTvov f| t6 capKoOv Tfic buvdiueiuc dXXiuc euiubec ecTi. TrdXiv oi
10 YpaqpeTc dv9r|pd xP^J^M^tTa Kai pdjLi|uaTa |uiYVuouciv, ^CTi bk Kai Tujv laTpiKoiv (pdpjudKuuv evia Triv oijiiv dv9npd Kai Trjv xpo^v ouk dTrdv9pujTTov exovTa. ti Toivuv biaqpepei; f| ou bfjXov oti tlu TeXei ttic xpciac biaKpivoOjuev; oukoOv ojuoiujc ai juev tujv q)i\ujv x«-
15 piTec eTTi KaXuj tivi Kai ujqpeXijuuJ t6 euqppaTvov uJCTrep F eTrav9o0v exouciv, ecTi b' otc Kai Traibia Kai TpaTreZi)! Kai oivuj Kai vf) Aia Ye^iuTi Kai (pXudpiu Trp6c dXXf|- Xouc oiov f]buc|uaciv expf|cavTo tujv KaXuuv Kai cttou- baiujv. TTp6c 0 bx] Kai XeXeKTai t6
20 '|uu9oiciv TepTTovTO TTp6c dXXf|Xac lve'7T0VTec' Kai t6
*oube Kev dXXo d)U)ue biexpivev qpiXeovTe tc TepTTOjuevuj Te'.
toO be KoXaKOC toOt ' epYOv ecTi Kai TeXoc , dei Tiva 55 25 Traibidv fi TTpaHiv fi Xoyov eqp' fibovrii Kai TTp6c fibo- vfiv oipoTToieTv Kai KapuKeueiv. cuveXovTi b' eiTreiv 6 |uev iva fibuc ^ TrdvTa beTv oieTai TroieTv, 6 b' dei TTOiujv d beT TToXXdKic |uev fibuc TToXXdKic b' dribf|C ecTiv, ou toOto pouXojuevoc, ei be PeXTiov eir), lurjbe
1, 175— 177 H. 6, 199— 201 B
13. oi)* 20. Homer. A 643 22. Id. 6 178
126 QUOMODO ADULATOR
toOto qpeuTuJV. ujCTrep Yap laTpoc, Sv cu)i(p€'pri, Kpo- Kov f\ vdpbov eTrepaXe Kai vf] Aia TroXXdtKic ^Xouce npocrivijuc Kai eGpeipe qpiXavGpuuTruuc , ecTi b' ottou toOt' edcac KacTopiov dveceicev
^f\ TToXiov Papuocjaov 6 br\ pificTOV obuubev' 5 B Ti Tiva eXXepopov Tpivpac eKTTieiv rivdYKacev, out' evToOGa t6 dribk out' eKei t6 fibu Troiouiuevoc TeXoc dXX' iq>' tv bi' d)U90Te'puuv erri t6 cu)aqpe'pov dfuuv Tov 0epaTTeu6|uevov , outuuc 6 qpiXoc ^'cti |Liev 6Te cuv eTTaivLU Kai xapiTi iuefaXuvuuv Kai euqppaivuuv dTei lo TTpoc t6 KaXov, ujcrrep outoc
'TeOKpe, q)iXr| KeqpaXri, TeXa)auuvi€ , Koipave
XaiLv,
pdXX' ouTUJ* Kai 15
'ttuuc dv ^TreiT* 'Obucnoc dfuu Geioio Xa0oi)Lir|v ' ; OTTOu b' aij TcdXiv dTTicTpoqpfic beiTai, Xotuj brjKTr) Kai TTappricia Krib€)LioviKf) Ka0aTTT6)uevoc C 'dqppaiveic, MeveXae bioTpeqpec, oub^ Ti ce XPH
TauTTic dqppocuvnc '. «o
lcTi b' OTTOU Kai Td ^PTOV a)Lia Ttj!» X6tiw cuvfivpev, ibc Mevdbri)ioc 'AcKXriTTidbou toO ^iXou t6v ui6v dcuuTov 6vTa Kai dTaKTOv dTTOKXeiuuv Kai ^xi] TrpocaTO- peuuuv ecuuqppovice, Kai Bdiuuvi Tfjv cxoXfiv diTeiTTev 'ApKeciXaoc, OTe TTp6c KXedv0riv CTixov erroiricev ^v «5 KU))iiubia, TTeicavTOC be t6v KXedv0riv Kai )Li€Ta^eXo- )ievou biriXXdTri. bei Tap luqpeXoOvTa XuTreiv tov qpi- Xov, ou bei bi XuTToOvTa ttiv qpiXiav dvaipeiv, dXX'
1,177— 178H. 6,201— 2C3R.
5. Nicander Ther. 64 10. nefaXvvwv*: ixifaXvvwv
dei 12. Homer. 0 281 16. Id. K 243 19. Id.
H 109 24.. Bdxwvi Meinekius: pdtTUJ
d
AB AMICO INTERNOSCATUR 127
ibc qpapiudKLU TUJ bcxKvovTi xPnc6ai, ciiuZiovTi kqi qpu-D XdTTOVTi t6 9epaTT€u6)a€vov. 68ev ujCTiep dpiaoviKOC 6 qpiXoc Trj 7Tp6c t6 KaX6v Kai cu|ucpepov jaeTapoXri Td |uev dvbibouc d b' eTriTeivujv TToXXdKic iuev f]b\ic
5 dei b' ujqpeXi|u6c ecTi. 6 be KoXaE dqp' evoc biaypdiu- juaToc dei t6 nbu Kai t6 TTp6c xdpiv eiuuBujc urroKpe- Keiv out' ^pfov oibev dvTiTeivov ouTe pniua Xuttouv, dXXd )u6vuj TTapeTT€Tai tuj pouXo|uevLu, cuvdbujv dei Kai cujuqp9eYTO)uevoc. ujcTTep ouv tov 'AYilciXaov 6 Hevo-
10 qpujv fibe'ujc eTTaiV€Tc9ai qpriciv utt6 tujv Kai vpeTeiv e9€X6vTUJV, ouTUj bei t6 euqppaivov Kai x«Pi^o)aevov fiYeTc9ai cpiXiKOVi dv Kai XuttcTv ttot^ buvriTai koi dvTiTeiveiv, Tfjv be cuvexn TaTc f^bovaTc Kai t6 iTp6cE xdpiv ^xoucav oKpaTov dei Kai dbriKTOv 6)uiXiav utto-
lovoeTv, Kai vfi Aia t6 toO Aokujvoc exeiv TTpoxeipov, oc eTTaivoujuevou XapiXXou tou PaciXeujc 'rruuc outoc' eqpT] 'xPncToc, oc oube toTc TTOvripoTc TTiKpoc ecTi';
12. ToTc )uev oijv Taupoic tov oTcTpov evbuec9ai TTapd t6 ouc X^fouci, Kai toTc kuci tov KpoTUJva'
20 tOjv be qpiXoTijuiAJV 6 KoXaS Td iuTa KaTexujv toTc eTrai- voic Ktti TTpocTTeqpuKUJC bucaTTOTpiTCTOc ecTiv. 69ev ev- Tau9a beT ludXicTa Trjv Kpiciv exeiv efpriTopuTav Kai TTapaqpuXdTTOucav tt6t€pov toO TTpdTiuaToc r\ toO dv- F bp6c 6 eTTaivoc ecTiv. ecTi be toO TTpdTjuaToc, dv
25 dTT6vTac ludXXov f| TTapovTac ^TTaivuJciv, av Kai auTOi TauTd pouXdjuevoi Kai ZriXoOvTec |ufi )u6vouc fijudc dXXd TrdvTac erTi toTc Ojuoioic eTTaivujciv, dv juf) vOv )uev TaOTa vOv be TdvavTia TTpdTTOVTec Kai XeTOVTec ^ai- vuJVTar t6 be )U€tictov, Sv auToi TiTVuucKUj)uev eau-
30 Touc )af] )U€Ta)ueXo|uevouc eqp' oic eTTaivouju€9a )ur]b '
1, 178—180 H. 6, 203- 205 K.
28. qpaivuivTai * : ^aivoivTO
128 QUOMODO ADULATOR
alcxuvo|a^vouc iUTibe iLiaXXov fi|uiv TotvavTia toOtuuv TreTTpaxOcti Kai XeXexQai pouXojuevouc. f) ^ap oiKo9ev Kpicic dvTijuapTupoOca Kai }xy\ TTpocbexo)uievr| tov etrai- 56 vov dTTa0ric ^ti Kai a9iKT0C Kai utto toO KoXaKeuov- Toc dvdXujTOC. dXX' ouk oTb' orruuc oi ttoXXoi Tdc & |Li^v dTTi ToTc dTUxnMaci TTapriTopiac oux uTTO|aevouciv, dXXd laaXXov urro tuuv cuveTTi0privouvTiJUV dYOVTai Kai cuvobupoiuevijuv OTav b' d|iapTdviJUCi Kai TrXriiajLieXuJ- civ, 6 ji^v eXeYXiw Kai i|j6yuj bnTMOv eiUTTOiujv Kai jue- Tdvoiav ex0p6c bOKei Kai KttTriTopoc, t6v b' errai- lo voOvTa Kai KaTeuXoToOvTa Td TreTrpaTiLieva dcirdZov- Tai Kai vojaiZiouciv euvouv Kai qjiXov. ocoi iuev ouv
B f\ TTpdHiv ti XoTOV f| CTTOubdcavTOc otioOv fi CKiuipav- TOC euxepiuc eTraivoOci Kai cuveTriKpoToOciv, eic t6 Trapov eiciv outoi Ka\ Td utto xcTpct pXaPepoi juovov • i5 ocoi be rrpoc t6 fi0oc dHiKVoOvTai toTc ^Traivoic Kai vf| Aia ToO TpoTTOu Tfi KoXaKeia 0iTTdvouci, TauTo TTOioOci tOuv oiKeTUJV ToTc laf) dTTO ToO cujpoO KXe- TTTOuciv dXX' dTT6 ToO CTre'p)LiaTOc • CTT^piua Tdp tujv TTpdHeujv oucav Tfiv bid0eciv Kai t6 fi0oc dpxnv Kai 20 TTriTflv ToO piou biacTpecpouci , Td Tfic dpeTfic 6v6)iaTa t^ KaKia TTepiTi0dvTec. dv laev Tdp TaTc cTdceci Kai ToTc TToXejUOic 6 GouKubibric (pnciv 6ti 'Tfjv eiuj0uTav dSiujciv TU)V ovojLidTUJv ec Td IpTa dvTriXXaHav Tfi biKaiiOcei. TdXjua juev Tdp dXoTicTOC, dvbpeia qpiXeTai- 25
C poc evo|Liic0ri, laeXXTicic be Trpo|Liri0fic beiXia euTTpeTrfic, t6 be cOuqppov toO dvdvbpou Trpocxriiaa, Kai t6 TTp6c aTTav cuveT6v eTri Trdv dpTov'. ev be TaTc KoXa- Keiaic 6pav xpfl xai TrapaqpuXdTTeiv dcujTiav iuev eXeu- OepioTriTa KaXouiuevriv Kai beiXiav dcqpdXeiav, ejUTrXri- 30
1, 180—181 H. 6, 205—206 B.
23. OouKubiSnc] in 82
AB AMICO INTERNOSCATUR 120
Siav b', oEuTriTa, laiKpoXoYiav be ciuqppocuvriv , tov b' epuuTiKOV q)iXocuvii9r| Kai qpiXocTopYOV, dvbpeiov be Tov opYiXov Kai UTrepnqpavov, (piXdvGpuirrov be Tov euTeXfj Kai TaTreivov. ujc ttou Kai TTXdTUJV qpriciD
6 Tov epacTHv KoXaKa Tiltv epuujue^vuuv ovTa tov laev ci- inov KaXeiv eTtixapiv, tov be yPuttov paciXiKOV, |LieXa- vac b' dvbpiKOuc, XeuKOuc bk OeOuv Traibac* t6 be jueXixpouv oXiuc epacTOu Ttoiriiua eivai uTroKopiZ;ojue'vou Kai euKoXuuc qpepovTOC Tfiv wxpoTriTa. KaiTOi KaXoc
10 )Liev eivai TteicGeic 6 aicxpoc f\ iueYac 6 |iiKp6c out€ Xpovov TToXuv Tfi dTTaTri cuvecTi Kai pXdTTTeTai pXd^riv eXaqppdv Kai ouk dvrjKecTOV • 6 be TaTc KaKiaic eeiCoiv E ^TTaivoc ujc dpeTaic, ujc |uf) dxOojuevov dXXd xcii- povTa xpficOai, Kai t6 aibeicSai tujv d)uapTavo|uevujv
15 dqpaipuuv, outoc lTTeTpii|je CiKeXiiuTac, ttiv Aiovuciou Kai OaXdpiboc ujiuoTriTa luicoTrovnpiav TrpocaYopeuuuv, ouTOc AiYUTTTov dTTuuXece , Tfjv TTToXeiuaiou 9riXuTriTa Kai 9eoXr|v}jiav Kai oXoXuYjuouc Kai TU|UTTdvuuv x«P«^€ic eucf'peiav dvonaZujv Kai 9euuv XaTpeiav, outoc Td
80 Tuu)uaiujv fi9ri TriviKauTa Trap' oubev fjXGev dvaTpevjjai Kai dveXeiv, Tdc 'AvTUJviou Tpuqpdc Kai dKoXaciac Kai TTavTiYupiCjuouc iXapd TraiYiuaTa Kai qpiXdv9puuTTa xpuJ- luevric dqp96vujc auTUJ Tfic Tuxnc urroKopiZioiuevoc. TTto- P Xeiuaiui be Ti TTepifiqjev dXXo qpop^eidv Kai auXouc,
25 xi be Nepuuvi TpaYiKfjv €TTf|gaTO CKrivfjV Kai TrpocujTreia Kai Ko96pvouc Trepie9riKev ; oux 6 tuuv KoXaKeuovTuuv eTTaivoc; oi be TToXXoi tuuv PaciXeujv ouk 'AttoXXuuvgc juev dv juivupicuuci, Ai6vucoi b' av |ue9uc9uuciv, 'Hpa-
1,181— 183H. 6, 20G— 20SR.
4. TTXdrujv] Rep. V. p. 474 E 8. irouijua Plato: -rrpoc- TTOiriiiia 18. x«pa-€ic L. Dindorfius: dYxapaEeic 22.
iraiYnaTa*: TrpdY,u«~a 23. auTuj Tfjc*: aOTut buvdfjieujc koi Plutarchi Moralia. Vol. I. 9
130 QUOMODO ADOLATOR
KXeTc b* av TraXaiciJuci 7TpocaTopeu6)aevot xai x«i- povTec eic aTiacav aicxuvrjv utto Tfjc KoXaKeiac eEa- YOVTai ;
13. Aio q)uXaKTe'ov ecTi judXicTa tov KoXaKa TTepi Touc eTTaivouc. oTTep oub' auTov eKeivov X^Xri0€V, s 57 dXXd beivoc Cuv q)uXdTTec0ai t6 uttotttov, dv \xkv euTraputpou tivoc dYpoiKOU Xdpr|Tai ^opivnv Traxeiav qpepovTOC, 6Xiu tuj lauKTfipi xPHTai , Ka6dTTep 6 CTpou- 0iac ejLiTTepiTTaTaiv tuj BiavTi Kai KaTopxou|Li€VOc Tfjc dvaic0riciac auToO toic eTraivoic lo
"AXeHdvbpou TiXeov Tou paciXeuJC TreTTUJKac' Ktti
'YeXujTi TTpoc Tov KuTTpiov eK0avou)Lievoc*. Touc be KOjuqjoTepouc opujv evTau0a ludXicTa TTpoc- i5 e'xovTac auTOic Kai q)uXaTTO|Lievouc to x^piov touto Kai Tov TOTTOv ouK dTT' eu0eiac eTrdYCi tov eTraivov, dXX' dTraYaYUiV Troppuj KUKXoOTai Kai B 'TTpoceiciv, oTov dvjJoq)riTi 0pe|U)LiaToc' eTTiqjauujv Kai dTTOTreipuuiaevoc. vOv pLkv Ydp eTe- 20 pu)V Trepi auToO tivujv eTtaivouc dTraYYeXXei, Ka0d- TTep 01 prjTopec, dXXoTpiuj TrpocxpOujiievoc ttpocwttuj, ievoic XeYUJV ^ 7TpecpuTe'poic ev dYopqi judX' fibeujc TrapaYevec0ai rroXXd KdYa0d |ue|Livr||Lievoic auToO Kai ' 0au)udZ!ouci • vOv b' au udXiv aiTiac eXaq)pdc 25 Kai vjjeubeTc TrXacdjaevoc Kai cuv0eic in' auTov, ujc dKriKOujc 4Te'puJv dqjTKTai )ueTd CTTOubfjc, 7Tuv0av6-
1,183— 185H. 6,208— 210R,
7. Tivoc Schellensius: tivoc r^ 11. 'AXe5(iv6pou —
Tr^TTUJKac Menander apud Meinek. IV. p. 152: dXeEdv6pou ToO PaciX^iuc TtXdov Tr^TtiUKac 14. Meinek. IV. p. 153
tKeavouiaevoc W: ^vi-jeouiuevoc 16. oOtoIc Reiskius:
auTU)
AB AMICO INTERNOSCATUR 131
f.i€VOc TToO toOt' eiTTev r\ ttoO toOt' CTTpaEev. dpvou- laevou b\ ujc eiKoc, auToGev eXtJuv e)apep\riKev elc touc eTTaivouc tov avGpuuTTOV 'e.f\jj b' eGaujuaZ^ov ei cu c KaKOJC Tiva TUJV cuviiOoiv eiTTac 6 ^ribk touc ex6pouc 5 TTeqpuKiOc, ei cu toic dWoTpioic eTrexeipricac 6 to- cauTa Td)V i&ituv &iJupou)aevoc '.
14. "GTepoi Toivuv, uicTrep oi Ivjfpacpox m <pw- Teivd Kai XaiaTTpd toTc CKiepoic Kai CKOTeivoTc eTTiTei- vouciv eTT^LJC TTapaTi9€)Lievoic, outuj tuj vpeTeiv Tdvav-
15 Tia Kai XoibopeTv r| biacupeiv Kai KaTaTeXdv XavGd- vouci Td TrpocovTa KaKd toTc KoXaKeuoiiievoic eTTai- voOvTec Kai Tpeq)OVTec. cuxppocuvriv t€ Tdp ujc oTpoiKiav ipeTOuciv ev dciuTOic Kai TTXeoveKTaic Kai KaKOupTOic Kai ttXoutoOciv dTTO TrpaTiudTUJV aicxpuiv
15 Kai TTOvnpuJV, auTdpKeidv Te Kai biKaiocuvriv uic dToX- d uiav Kai dppujCTiav Trpoc t6 TrpdTTeiv OTav be pa6u- ILioic cxoXacTttTc Kai Td |Lteca cpeuTouci tujv TToXeujv 6|niXu)Civ, ouK aicxuvovTai TroXiTeiav |uev dXXoTpio- TrpaTiav eTrirrovov , 9iXoTi|Liiav be KevoboHiav dKapTTOv
20 6vo|adZ;ovT€c. fibri hk mi pr|Topoc Ictiv o'i KoXaKeia bie'cupav qpiXococpov, Kai Trapd TuvaiHlv dKoXdcTOic euboKi)ioOciv 01 Tdc ^aovoXexeTc Kai qpiXdvbpouc dva- (ppobiTOuc Kai dTpoiKOuc dTTOKi^oOvTec. uTreppdXXei bk |Liox6ripia t6 ixr\b' ^auTwv drrexec^ai touc KoXaKac.
25 ibc Tdp oi TTaXaicTai t6 cuj)Lia ttoioOci TaTreivov, ottujc ^Te'pouc KaTapdXujciv , outuj tu» ipeTeiv lauTouc eic E t6 6au|ud2:eiv touc TrXriciov urroppeouciv. 'dvbpdrro- bov eijui beiX6v ev 6aXdccr]; Trpoc touc rrovouc dTra-
1, 185—186 H. 6, 210— 212 B,
2. ^Xuiv Courierus: ^x^JV 15. xe*: bk 20. ^ctiv
01*: ^CTiv Stc 21. feiecupav*: 6iacupai 22. e06oKi-
laoOciv oi*: e()6oKi)Lio0ci
9*
132 QUOMODO ADULATOR
YopeOo), iLiaivojiai KttKUuc dtKOucac irn' ^pYnc. dXXd TouTtu' qpticiv 'oub^v dcri beivov, oubev Ttovripov, dXX' ibioc dvGpujTToc, TrdvTa Trpduuc q)epei, rrdvTa dXuTTUJc'. dv b' ^ Tic oiojuevoc rroXuv exeiv voOv Kai PouX6|uevoc aucTiipoc eivai Kai au9eKacT0C utto s br\ Tivoc opBoTriTOC dei TTpopdXXriTai t6
'Tubeibri, |ir|T* fip |li€ |udX' aivee |ar|Te TiveiKei',
Fou TauTr] irpdceiciv 6 TexviTrjc K6XaH, dXX' ecTi tic ^Tepa lirixavfi Trpoc tov toioOtov. fiKei Ydp auTUj TTepi TTpaTMdTuuv ibiuuv uic bfi qppovrjcei TrepiTTOTepuj iff cuMPouXeuc6)aevoc, Kai (prici iudXXov (jev eTepouc exeiv cuvnGeic, evoxXeiv b' dvaYKaiuuc dKeivLU* 'ttoT Ydp KaTacpuYuuMev oi Yvuu)Lir|c beojuevoi, Tivi be TTicTeucuu- (Liev;' eiT* dKOucac 6 ti av eTrir), xP^^^Mov eiXriqpe'vai (pricac ou YVuuMnv dTreiciv. dv be Kal X6yuuv tivoc i: ^MTTeipiac opd MeTaTTOiouiuevov, ebuuKC ti tujv auTuj 58 YCYPttMM^vuuv, dvaYVuuvai Kai biopGuucai KeXeucac. Mi- 0pibdTri be TuJ paciXei cpiXiaTpoOvTi Kai TeMeTv Ivioi Kai KaOcai rrapecxov auTOuc tuuv ^Taipuuv, epYtu ko- XttKeuovTec ou Xoyuj* M«PTupeTc9ai Ydp dMTteipiav 4b6K€i TTicTeuoMevoc utt' auTuuv.
'TToXXai M0P9Cti tuuv baiMOviuuv,' tA be Yevoc toOto twv dpvouMevuuv eTTaivuuv Travoup- YOTepac be^Mevov euXa^eiac eXeYKTe'ov eTriTribec dT6- TTOuc ^KTdTTOVTa cuM^ouXiac Kai uTro9riKac, Kai biop- 26
B 9uuceic TTOiouMevov dXoYouc. TTpoc }Jir\biv fap dvTiXe- Yuuv, dXXd rrdci cuveTriveuuuv Kai dTTobexoMevoc TTdvTa Ktti powv TTap' eKacTOV ujc eu Kai KaXuuc, YiTveTai KaTa(pavric
1,186— 188 H. 6, 212— 213 B,
7. Homer. K 249 12. trol*: ttoO 22. Eurip. Alc.
1159 et passim 27. dTro5ex6|uevoc Reiskius: 6ex6|bi€voc
J
AB AMICO INTERNOSCATUE 133
*cuv0r]|it' epiuTiDv, aWo jwacTeuuuv xP^oc', enaivecai Kai cuvcTTiTucpuucai pouX6|uevoc.
15. "Eti Toivuv ujcTtep evioi tvjv ZiuJYPCicpiav ciw- TTUJcav dTr€<pr|vavT0 rroinTiKriv, oOtujc ecTi tic KoXa-
5 Keiac ciujnuucric eTraivoc. oocTrep xdp oi 0ripeuovTec av |ur| toOto rroieiv dX\' obomopeiv y\ ve'|ueiv f| Yeujp- Teiv boKujci , iudXXov Td 0ripeu6)aeva Xav0dvouciv, ou- TUJC 01 KoXaKec arrTovTai judXicTa toic eTraivoic, OTav eTraiveiv \xr\ boKuiciv dXX' eTepov ti TrpdTTeiv. 6 Tdp
10 ebpac eiKUJV Kai KXiciac eniovTi Kai Xe^ujv TTpoc bfj- ^ov r\ pouXfjv dv ai'c0riTai Tiva tujv nXouciujv Pou- C XoMevov eiTreiv, dTrociujTTuiv ineTaHu Kai Trapabibouc To pfiiia Kai Tov XoTOv evbeiKVUTai ciujttujv judXXov ToO pouJVToc OTi KpeiTTova vojuiJei Kai biacpepovTa
15 Tuj qppoveiv ^Keivov. 60ev opdv ecTiv auTouc ebpac Te Tdc TrpuuTac ev dKpodceci Kai 0edTpoic KaTaXaiu- pdvovTac, oux oti toutujv dEiouciv auTouc, dXX' OTTUJC uTreEiCTd|Lievoi toic TrXoucioic KoXaKeuujcr Kai XoTOu KaTdpxovTttc ev cuvoboic Kai cuvebpioic, eha
20 TTapaxujpoOvTac ujc KpeiTToci Kai |ueTaTi0e)aevouc pa- cTa TTpoc TouvavTiov, dvTtep rj buvaToc r| ttXouciocD r) e'vbo£oc 6 dvT»Xe'TU)v. Jj Kai ladXiCTa bei Tdc toi- auTac uTTOKaTaKXiceic Kai dvaxuipriceic eHeXeTXCiv, ouk eiiTTeipiaic oub' dpeTaic oub' fiXiKiaic ucpieiaevujv dXXd
25 ttXoutoic Kai boHaic. 'ATreXXfic luev Tdp 6 ZiuJTpdcpoc, MeTapuZ;ou KapaKa0icavToc auTuj Kai Trepi TP«MMnc Ti Kttl CKidc pouXo|Lievou XaXeiv, *6pac' e(pr| 'Td Trai- bdpia TauTi Td Tfjv lariXiba TpipovTa; rrdvu coi TTpoc- eixe Tov voOv ciujttijuvti, Kai Trjv rropcpupav e0au|uaZ;e
so Kai Td xpwcia • vOv be cou KaTaTeXd Trepi uJv ou \xe- E
I, 188-189 H. ' 6, 213-215E.
1. Nauck. p. 297
134 QUOMODO ADULATOR
judGrjkac dpHajuevou XaXeiv '. Kai CoXujv, Kpoicou Ttepl eubai|uoviac TTuveavou|Lievou, TeXXov Tivd tiuv ouk eTTicpavujv 'AGrjvnci Kal BiTuuva Kai KXeo^iv dTTe'cpiivev euTTOTjLioTepouc. 01 be KoXaKec touc paciXeac Kai ttXou- ciouc Kal dpxovTac ouk oXpiouc |u6vov Kai juaKapiouc 5 dXXd Kai tppovncei Kai Texvij kui dpeTrj TTdcr) TTpuj- TeuovTac dvaTOpeuouciv.
16. GiTa Tuiv |Liev CTUiiKUJV oub' dKOueiv evioi UTTO|uevouci Tov co{p6v 6|uo0 rrXouciov KaXov euYevn paciXea TTpocaTOpeuovTUJV , oi be KoXaKec tov ttXou- lo ciov 6|uo0 priTOpa Kai TTOiriTnv, dv be pouXriTai, Kai
F ZuJTpdqpov Kai auXrjTriv dTToqpaivouci Kai TTobuuKri Kai puj)uaXeov, uTTOTrirrTOVTec ev tuj iraXaieiv Kai dTTO- Xi]UTTav6|uevoi BeovToc, ujcTrep Kpicujv 6 'IjuepaToc dTre- Xeiq^eri biaeeujv TTpoc 'AXeHavbpov, 6 b' aice6)uevoc i5 TiTavdKTrjce. Kapvedbric b' cXeTe oti ttXouciujv Kai paciXeujv Traibec irtTTeueiv |u6vov, dXXo h' oubev eij Ktti KttXujc luavedvoucr KoXaKeuei Tdp auTouc ev TaTc biaTpiPaTc 6 bibdcKaXoc erraivdiv Kai 6 rrpocTTaXaiujv uTTOKaTaKXiv6jLievoc , 6 b' ittttoc, ouk eibujc oube cppov- 20 rilixiv ocTic ibiujTric fj dpxujv fj ttXoucioc f] Trevnc,
59 iKrpaxriKil^i touc juf) buva|uevouc oxeTceai. eijrieec Toivuv Kai dpe'XTepov t6 toO Biujvoc 'ei t6v dTp6v IjueXXec eTKUJ)uidZ:uJV eucpopov rroieTv Kai euKapTTOv, ouK dv d|uapTdveiv eboKeic toOto ttoiujv ludXXov fi s^ CKd-TTTUJV Kai TTpdTjnaTa exujv ou Toivuv oub' dvepuj- TTOuc dTOTTOC dv eir]c eTTaivujv, ei toTc eTraivoujuevoic
1, 189— 191 H. G, 215— 2nB,
11. 6|LioO*: 6|iioO Kal 14. GeovTOC*: eeovTUJv Kpi-
cujv*: Kpiccujv 22. euriGec — t6*: eOriOr) toivuv Kai d.^i\- Tepa Tci 24. ^jueWec*: ^iueWe 25. eboKeic*: eJ>6K€v
26. dvGpiijTTOUC Dobraeus: fiv9puj7roc 27. eiric*: e'ir\
AB AMICO INTERNOSCATUR 135
ujq)e\i)Lioc eci;) Kai Ttpoccpopoc*. 6 |uev Tap «Ypoc ou YiYveTai xeipwv eTraivouiuevoc, av6puj7rov be TuqpoOci Ka» dnoXXuouciv oi i|/eubijOc Kai Tiap' dHiav eTiai- vouvTec.
5 17. TaOTtt jLiev ouv dTToxpr) Trepi toutuuv IqpeHfic bk t6 Tfjc Trappriciac ibiu|uev. ^bei |uev Ydp, wc 6 TTdTpoKXoc ToO 'AxiXXeiuc Td OTtXa TTepipaXXojuevoc b Kai Touc iTTTTOuc e^eXauvujv eTri Tfiv |udxriv juovnc ouk dToXfiTice TTic TTnXidboc BiYeTv dXX' aq>f\Kev, outuj tov
10 KoXaKa TOic toO (piXou cKeuoTTOiou|uevov Kai dva- TtXaTTOjaevov eTricrmoic Kai cumPoXoic fiovrjv Tfjv rrap- pnciav ujCTTep eEaipeTov pdcTaYMa (piXiac
'Ppi6u |ueYa CTiPapov' KaTaXeiTTeiv d6iKTov Kai duiMn^^ov. errei be ^euYOVTec
i5t6v iv ^4.\<x)T\ m\ dKpdTLu Kai CKUUjU|uaci Kal Traibiaic iXeYXOV eic oqppuv aipouciv f]br| t6 TrpdYMoi Kai ko- XaKeuouciv ecKu^pujrraKOTec Kai ipoYOv Tivd Kai vou- c 6eciav rrapaiuiYvuouci, qjepe |ur|be toOto TTapaXeirruJiLiev dpacdvicTOv. oT|uai .be, uicTTep ev KU))uujbia Mevdv-
20 bpou VeubripaKXfic TTpoceici poTTaXov ou CTipapov ko- juiCuJV oub' icxupov dXXd xciOvov ti TrXdc|ua Kai bid- Kevov, ouTuj Tfjv ToO KoXaKOC Trappriciav (paveic6ai Toic Treipujiuevoic luaXaKfiv Kai dpapfi Kai tovov ouk exoucav, dXXd TauTd toTc tiuv Y^vaiKaiv rrpocKeqpa-
25 Xaioic bpuicav, d boKoOvTa TaTc KeqpaXaTc dvTepeibeiv Kai dvTexeiv evbibujci Kai uTreiKei ludXXov ujCTrep f] KipbrjXoc auTri Trapprjcia Kevov exouca Kai njeubfi KaiD UTTOuXov OYKOV eEnp6ri Kai lubncev, iva cucTaXeica
1,191- 192 H. 6, 217-218 K.
1. gcr)*: kxi irpocqjopoc lagerus: iTdiuqpopoc 13.
Homer. TT Ul 20. ^oTraXov] Meinek. IV. p. 225 21.
Kevov Winckelmanuus 23. toTc*
136 QUOMODO ADULATOR
Ktti cu|LiTrecoOca b^ErjTai Kai cuv€TncTrdcr|Tai t6v Kaia- (pep6)a€vov eic auiriv. f) laev ydp dXriGfic Kai (piXiKT^ nappricia toTc d)LiapTavo)a^voic CTTKpueTai, cuuTripiov €Xouca Kal KribejiOviKdv to XuttoOv, ojcTrep t6 \ii\\ 10. fiXKU))n^va bdKVouca Kai KaGaipouca, TfiXXa b'5 ujqpeXiiaoc ouca- Kai YXuKeia, Trepi fic ibioc ecTai X6- Toc. 6 be KoXaH TTpoiTov )l1^v dvbeiKVUTai t6 ttikpoc eivai Kai TrepiCTrepxfic Kai dTTapaiTriTOc ^v toTc ttp6c dTe'pouc (oiK^Taic tdp auToO xw^ctt^c dcTi Kai cuf- tevujv Koi oiKeiwv dTr€)apfivai b€iv6c d^apTfiiaaci Ka» lo
E )arib€'va 0au)idcai ^rfie ce)uvOvai tujv ^kt6c dXX' uTrep- cpdv, dcuTTvai|Liujv bk kux bidpoXoc iv tlu TTp6c 6p- THV dT€'pouc TrapoHuveiv, 9ripu))Lievoc )LiicoTrovripiac boEav, ujc ouk av dKUJV uqpejuevoc Trappriciac auTotc oube TTOificac oubev oub' einujv TTp6c xdpiv), ^TreiTa is be Tujv \xev dXriGiviuv Kai i-ieTdXujv d]napTr|)idTUJV ou- bkv eibevai TrpocTroiou)ievoc oube TiTvtucKeiv, rrpdc bk Td )aiKpd Kai Td ^kt6c dXX€i).t)naTa beivoc dHai Kai )LieTd Tovou Ka0d^jac0ai Kai ccpobpoTriToc , av CKeOoc diueXuuc Tbr) Keifievov, av oiKoOvTa (pauXuic, Sv 6Xi- 20 |
F TwpoOvTa Koupdc f| d)aTr€x6vr|c fj kuvoc tivoc f\ m- TTOu )an k^t' dEiav dm^aeXo^aevov *** Toveujv bk 6X1- Tujpia Kai Traibuiv d^aeXeia Kai dTi)aia Ta)a€Tfic Kai TTp6c oiKeiouc uTrepovpia Kai xP^MdTUJV oXeOpoc oub^v ^CTi TTpoc auTov, dXX' dqjujvoc ^v toutoic Kai StoX- 25 | laoc, ujCTTep d0Xr|Tfiv dXeirrTric ^ujv )ue0ueiv Kai dKO- AacTaiveiv , eiTa TT€pi Xtiku0ou x«^€tt6c ujv koi ctX€t- Tiboc, f| Tpa)a)aaTiK6c ^TTiTrXfiTTUJV Traibi Trepi b^XTOu Kai YPW^ciou, coXoiKiZovToc be Kai papPapiZovTOC ou
], 192— 193H. 6, 218-220B
6. 1610C icTax X6foc] P. 66 E 22. Intercidisse non-
nulla j^ienificavi
AB AMICO INTERNOSCATUR 137
boKuiv dKOueiv. TOiouTOC T«P 6 KoXaH, oloc priTopoc (pauXou Kai KaTaYeXdcTOu laribev emeTv irpoc tov X6- Yov, dXXd TT€pi THC qpuuvnc aiTictceai Kai xaXeTTuJc eT- 60 KaXeiv OTi Triv dpTripiav biacpGeipei qjuxporroTujv, Kai
5 cuTTpaMMCt KeXeuc9eic dOXiov bieXGeiv aiTidcGai t6 XapTJov ujc bacu Kai tov TPacpea |iiap6v Kai oXituj- pov dTTOKaXeiv. outuj be Kai "rTToXejuaiuj (piXo|ua9eiv boKoOvTi irepi TXwTTric Ktti CTixibiou |biax6|Lievoi Kai icTOpiac ^expi iiecuJv vuktiLv direTeivov uj)a6Tr|Ti
10 be xpiAJMtvou Kai uppei Kai diTOTuiitTraviZovTOc Kai cTpepXoOvTOC oubeic evecTii tujv tocoutujv. uicTrep ouv ei Tic dv9pujTrou cpuiiiaTa Kai cupiTTac exovToc B laTpiKuJ C|aiXiuj Tdc Tpixac Te')itvoi Kai touc ovuxac, ouTUJC 01 K6XaKec Triv rrappriciav Trp6c xd |if| Xuttou-
15 laeva )ae'pri iuri^' dXToOvTa TTpoccpepouciv.
18. "Gti be TOUTUJV ^Tepoi TravoupTOTepoi Kai TTp6c fibovrjv xPuiVTai tui TTappricidZ;ec9ai Kai vpeTeiv. Ka9dTTep 'Atic 6 'ApTeioc, 'AXeHdvbpou tc^ujtottoiuj Tivi iLieTdXac bujpedc bibovToc, utto cp96vou Kai XuTTrjC
20 eHeKpaTev 'uj Tf|c TToXXfic dTOTTiac', eTricTpe'qjavTOC be ToO ^aciXeujc TTpoc auT6v opTfi Kai 'ti bf) cu Xe- Teic'; eiTr6vT0c ''6|aoXoTuj' cpriciv 'dx9ec9ai Kai dTa- vttKTeiv , opujv u)iac touc ck Aioc TCTOvdTac aTravTac 6|aoiujc K6XaEiv dv9pujTT0ic Kai KaTttTeXdcToic xwipov- C
25 rac. Kai Tdp 'HpaKXfic KepKUivpi tici, Kai CeiXrivoTc 6 Aiovucoc eT^pTTeTO, Kai Trapd coi toioutouc ibeTv ecTiv euboKijLioOvTac*. TiPepiou hk Kaicapoc eic Tfjv cuTKXr|T6v TTOTe TTapeX96vToc eic tujv KoXdKUJV dva- cTdc ecpri beTv eXeu9epouc ovTac rrappricidZec^ai Kai
1, 193— 195 H. 6, 220-221 E.
10. (iiroTU|iiiavi2IovToc*: TUjLiTraviZovToc 11. CTpe-
PXoOvToc Gatakerus: TeAoOvTOC
138 QUOMODO ADULATOR
inribev uirocTeWecGai )Lir|b' diTTociujTTav tujv cujucpepov- Tuuv ctvaTeivac be irdvTac outuuc, Tevo|uevric auTtu ciujTrfic Ktti ToO Tipepiou TtpocexovTOC, 'aKOucov' e(pr| 'KaTcap a coi TtdvTec eYKaXou)Liev , oubeic be ToXiuqi (pavepujc XeYeiv. d)LieXeTc ceauToO Kai TTpoiecai t6 s ca)|Lia Kai KaTaTpuxeic dei qppovTici Ka» ttovoic uTrep
Drmujv, ouT€ |Lie6' fnuepav ouTe vuktoc dvaTTau6|aevoc '. TToXXd b' auToO ToiaOTa cuveipovTOC, emeTv qpaci tov prJTopa Kdcciov Ceufipov 'auTr) toOtov fj TTappncia Tov dvOpujTTOV drroKTeveT'. w
19. Kai TauTi |iev eXdTTOvd Ictiv. CKeTva h' fjbr) xakena. Kai Xu|aaiv6|aeva touc dvor|Touc, oTav elc TdvavTia TrdOri Kai vocrniiaTa KaTriYopujciv (ujcrrep 'ljae'pioc 6 K6Xa5 tujv TTXouciuJV Tivd tov dveXeuOepuu- TaTOv Kai qpiXapTupujTaTov 'A9r|vr|Civ ujc dcujTOv eXoi- is bdpei Kal djueXfi Kai TTewncovTa KaKuJc iueTd tuuv Te-
E Kvujv) Y\ Touc dcujTOuc au TTdXiv Kai TToXuTeXeTc elc juiKpoXoYiav Kai puTrapiav 6veibi2ujciv (ujCTTep Nepwva TiTOC TTeTpujvioc) fj touc ixjjuujc Kai d^piujc TTpocqpepo- ILi^vouc dpxovTac uTTriKdoic dTTo9e'cGai KeXeuujci Tfjv 20 TToXXfjv eTTieiKeiav Kai tov dKaipov eXeov Kai dcuja- <popov. ojuoioc be TouTOic Kai 6 tov euf|9ri Kai pXdKa Kai dpeXTepov ujc beivdv Tiva Kai TTavoOpyov Ka\ qpu- XdTTec9ai Kai bebievai TTpocTTOioOjuevoc, Kai 6 toO PacKdvou be Kai tu» KaKoXoyeTv dei Kai ipeTeiv xai- 25 povToc, dv TTOTe TTpoax9eic erraive^cr) Tivd tuuv ivho- EujV; Ka9aTTT6)uevoc Kai dvTiXeyujv ibc vdcrijua toOto
F exovToc, dv9puuTT0uc CTraiveTv Mn^evoc dHiouc. 'Tic ydp oiJTdcecTiv f| Ti XajLiTrpov eiprjKev f] TTerroirjKe'. judXicTa be TTcpi Touc epujTac toTc KoXaKeuoju^voic erriTieevTai
1, 195— J97H, , 6,221—2238,.
14. TOV*
AB AMICO INTERNOSCATUR 139
Ktti npoceKKdouciv. dbeXcpoic juev y«P opuivtec bia- (pepoiaevouc f| Yoveuuv uTtepcppovoOvTac f| irpoc y^- vakac auTuuv uTrepoTTTuuc exovTac ouTe vou6eTo0civ ouT* lYKaXoOciv, dWd Kai npoceTTiTeivouci Tdc opYdc. 6'ou Yap aicGdvi;) cauToO' Kai 'cu toutoiv aiTioc, dei eepaTTeuTiKujc Ttpocqpepoiuevoc Kai TaTreivujc'. dv be rrpoc iTaipav fj iuoixeuTpiav ^pujjae'vriv KvriC|Lidc tic eE gi opYHC Kai 2;r|XoTUTTiac ^YYevriTai, TidpecTiv euGuc |ueTd rrappriciac Xa.uTipdc fi KoXaKeia, TTup erri TtOp eicqpe- 10 pouca Kai biKaioXoYou|uevri Kai KttTriYopoOca toO epoJVTOC ujc dvepacTa TToXXd Kai CKXripd Kai veiaecriTd
TVOIOOVTOC.
*uu bucxdpicTe, Tuuv ttukvuuv qpiXrijudTUJV.' ouTuuc 'AvTuuviov 01 (piXoi Tfjc AiYUTTTiac epuuvTtt Kai
15 Kaouevov dveTreiGov ibc utt' eKeivrjc eptuTO, Kai Xoi- bopoOvTec eKdXouv dTraGfj Kai uTrepfiqpavov. 'r\ jjlIv Ydp Yuvf] KaTaXmoOca ^aciXeiav TOcauTriv Kai bia- Tpipdc eubaijuovac qp6eipeTai jueTd coO CTpaTeuo|U£vri, B cxniua TraXXaKiboc exouca*
■ko 'coi be Tic ev cTfi6ecciv dKiiXiiTOc vooc ecTi' Kai Trepiopdc auTfiv dviwjLievriv.' o b' fibeujc eXeYXO- luevoc ibc dbiKuuv Kai toTc KaTriYopoOci x«^PUJV ujc oube Toic eTTaivoOciv eXdv6ave tlu vou6eTeiv boKoOvTi TTpocbiacTpeqpOjuevoc. eoiKe Yap n TOiauTn irappricia
2.- ToTc Tuuv dKoXdcTuuv bfiYjuaci Y^vaiKuuv, eYcipouca Kai YapYaXiZiouca tuj boKoOvTi XuTteTv t6 fiboMevov. Kai Ka6dTTep tov oKpaTOv dXXujc Pori6o0vTa Trpoc t6 kuO- veiov dv djUjuiSujci rrpoceiupaXovTec auTuj, KOiuibn ttoi- oOci Tfiv ToO q>ap)udK0u buvaiuiv dpof|6r|Tov, 6Seujc c
1, 19T— 198H. 6, 223-223 B.
3. inrep^TTTUJC W: OTrepoTrTiKuuc 13. Nauck. p, 32
20. Ilomer. k 329
140 QUOMODO ADULATOR.
dvaqpepoiievriv eiri xriv Kapbiav utto GepiaoTriTOC , outu) Tfjv irappriciav e7TicTd|uevoi |ue'Ta Por|9ri)Lia irpoc Trjv KoXaKeiav oOcav oi Ttoviipoi bi' auTfic KoXaKeuouci TTic Trappriciac. 69ev oub' 6 Biac dTreKpivaTO KaXujc To» Tru9o)ae'vuj ti tuuv Zldiuuv x«^£^u^TaT6v ecTiv, djTO- 5 Kpivdjuevoc OTi Tujv fjLev dYpiujv 6 Tupavvoc, tujv b' flfiepujv 6 KoXaH. dXri0e'cTepov Tdp riv emeiv oti tiuv KoXdKUJV %epoi iuev eiciv oi Tiepi t6 PaXaveiov Kai
DTTepi Tf|v TpdTreZav, 6 b* eic Td bujjiidTia Kai Tfjv YuvaiKUJViTiv eKTeivujv ujcttcp rrXeKTdvac t6 TToXuTrpd- lo Y)nov Kai bidpoXov Kai KaKori^ec dYpioc Ka\ 9r|pit0bric Kai buc|LieTaxeipicToc.
20. €ic be Tic €0iK€ TpoTTOc €ivai qjuXaKfic t6 TiTViwcKeiv Kai |uvr||uoveueiv dei oti Tfic vpuxfic t6 juev dXr|9iv6v Kai qjiXoKaXov Kai Xotik6v exoucric, t6 i5 b' dXoTov Kai (piXoipeubec Kai rra^riTiKOV, 6 iuev qpi- Xoc dei Tuj -KpeiTTOvi TTopecTi cuiupouXoc Kai cuvfiTO- poc, ujCTTep iaTp6c t6 uTiaTvov auHujv Kai biacpuXdT- TUJV, 6 be KoXaH tu» TTa9riTiKuJ Kai dXoTUJ TrapaKd-
E 9riTai , Kai touto kvoi Kai TapT«Xi2ei Kai dvaTTei0ei 20 Ktti dqpicTTici toO Xotic)uoO, |urixaviJU|uevoc auTUJ iTOvri- pdc fibuTTa9eiac. uucTTep oijv tujv ciTiujv ecTiv d |uf|9' aiVaTi TTpocqpueTai )uf|Te TTveu)uaTi, )uribe veupoic Tivd Tovov ri )uu€XoTc TTpocTi9r|civ, dXX' aiboTa TrapaKiveT Kai KOiXiav eTeipei Kai cdpKa TToieT ca9pdv Kai uttou- 2^ Xov, OuTUJC 6 ToO KoXaKOC XoToc oubev tuj qppo- voOvTi Kai XoTi2o)uevuj TTpocTi9riciv, dXX' fibovfiv Tiva Ti9aceuuuv epujTOc r\ 9u)u6v evTeivuJV dvoriTOV f\ biepe- 9iZ;ujv (p96vov f| <ppovf||uaTOC otkov ejuTTOiujv errax^fi Kai Kev6v x] Xuttt) cuveTri9pnvuJv i] t6 KaKori^ec Kai so
1, 1P8-19DH. 6, 225— 226 B.
23. |ar]&^*: jafixe
4
AB AMICO IIsTERNOSCATUR 141
dveXeuGepov Kai fiKicTOv dei xici biapoXaic Kai npo- F aicericeci bpipiv m\ i^jocpobeec ttoiijuv Kai ijttotttov oO biaqpeijgeTai toOc TrpocexovTac. dei Ydp uqpopjuei tivi TTd6ei Kai toOto TTiaivei, Kai TrdpecTi poupdjvoc biKnv 6 cKdcTOTe Toic uTTOuXoic Kai (pXeTMaivouci Tfjc vpuxnc eTriYiTVOiaevoc. '6pTi2;ri; KoXacov. eTTi6u|ueTc; ujvr)- cai. q)oPrj; qpuTUJjuev. UTrovoeTc; TricTeucov.' dv be TTepi TaOTa bucqpiOpaTOC ^ Td TTd6ri, bid cqpobpoTrjTa Kai MeTe6oc eKKpouojuevou toO XoticmoO, Trepi Td |ui-
io Kpd Xapfiv TrapeSei iuaXXov , omoioc ujv. Kai Tdp ev 62 UTTOipia KpaiTrdXric tivoc ii TrXr|C|Liovfic Tev6)uevov Kai bicTdCovTa Trepi XouTpou Kai Tpoqpnc 6 iuev qpiXoc dqpeEei, qpuXdTTec6ai Kai Trpocexeiv Trapaivujv, 6 be KoXaE eic t6 paXaveTov eXHei, Kai KeXeucei veapov ti
15 TTapaTi6evai Kai |ifi KaKoOv dvaTdcei t6 cvj^xa, kox Trpoc obov f| ttXoOv fi Tiva TrpaSiv opujv dTrojiaXaKi- ZioMevov ou qpr|cei KaTerreiTeiv t6v Kaipov, dXXd TauTO TTOiriceiv UTrep6e|uevouc f\ T[i}x\\iavTac cTepov. dv b' uTTecxriiu^voc dpTupiov okeiuj tivi baveiceiv ii eTTibuu-
20 ceiv |ueTa)ueXriTai |iev aibfiTai be, t^ xeipovi poTrri B TrpocTi6eic eauT6v 6 KoXaE eTreppuuce Tfiv eic t6 pa- XdvTiov Tvuu|UTiv Kai t6 bucujrroujuevov eEeVoijjev, dic dvaXicKOVTa TroXXd Kai ttoXXoTc dpKeTv oqpeiXovTa qpeibec6ai KeXeuuJV. 66€v ei |ufi Xav6dvo|uev lauTOuc
25 eTri6u|uo0vTec dvaicxuVToOvTec dTrobeiXiuJVTec, ou
XrjceTai fi|udc 6 KoXaE. ^cti Tdp 6 cuvriTOpujv dei
TouToic ToTc Trd6eci Kai Trepi Tdc toutujv CK^dceic
TTappiiciaZ;6|ievoc. TaOTa |uev ouv kavd Trepi toutujv.
21. 'eTTi be Tdc xpe»c(c Kai Tdc uTroupTiac iuj|u€V
1, 199—201 H, 6, 226—228 K
1. TTpoc8ececi Emijerius 14. eXtei — KeXeOcei*: l\-
K€i — KeXeOei 28. ^Kpdceic] IvcTctceic W
142 QUOMODO ADULATOR
f\tr]- Ktti Top ^v TauTaic noXXriv ancpToZeTai cuTX'JCiv C Ka» dcdicpeiav 6 KoXaE Tfic npoc tov <piXov biaqpopdc, doKVOc boKuJv €?vai Kai TrpoeuMOc tv Trdci Kai dTrpoq)dci- cToc. 6 |n4v Totp ToO q)(Xou Tponoc OOcnep 6 Tfjc dXn- 6€iac )iO0oc dTtXoOc €cti KaT' Gupmibnv koi dqpcXfic & KOi dnXacTOC, 6 bk. toO KoXaKOc dvTuuc
'vocujv dv auTip q)ap|idKUJV bciTai cocpuuv*
Kai noXXuJv vf) Aia Kal nepiTTuiv. ujcnep ouv dv toTc dnavTr|C€civ 6 m^v q)iXoc ^ctiv 6tc nf|T' elnibv ^fjT* uKOucac MH^^v dXXd npocpXevpac Ka\ /ieibidcac Td lo euMCvk Kai Td oiKeTov evboGev bouc TaTc 6i|ieci Kai
DbeEoMevoc napfjXeev, 6 be KoXaE Tpexei KaTabiujKei be£ioOTai noppujBev, kSv npocaTopeu9fi npdTCpov 6(p6eic, dnoXoTcTTai M€Td MapTupujv Ka\ fipKwv noX- XdKic, ouTUJC iv TaTc npdEeci noXXd napaXeinouciv is 01 q)iXoi Ta)V fiiKpuJv, ouk ^EaKpi^oOvTec oub^ noXu- npafMOvoOvTCC oub^v, oub' ^auTouc eic ndcav unoup- Tiav ^MPdXXovTec. dXX' ^KeTvoc ^vTa06a cuvexnc Kai ^vbeXexnc Kai dTpuToc, ou bibouc ^Tepiu Tonov oub€ Xuipav biaKOviac, dXXd pouXojievoc KeXeu€c6ai, kSv • MH K€X€uc6fi, baKvdjLievoc , lidXXov b' fiXoic ^£a6uMuiv Kai noTviijO)i€VOC.
22. "CcTi Mtv ouv KQi xaOTa br|Xa»MaTa toTc voOv
E exouciv OUK dXri6ivfic q)iXiac oub^ ciJuq)povoc dXX* ^Taipoucnc Kal nepmXeKOMevnc 6€p)i6T€pov toO b^ov- 25 Toc. ou jifiv dXXd beT npojTOv ^v TaTc ^naTTcXiaic CKoneiv Tt^v biaq)opdv. eO Tdp eipriTai Kai toTc npd f|MU)V q)iXou jicv ^Keivnv elvai thv ^naTTcXiav
1.201-202H. 6, »»—13011.
f>. €Opinibnv] Phoen. ■',' Kav*: flv
6^0VT0C " -■• --•5: TU»V fcli i.tvoiv
i
AB AMICO INTERNOSCATUR 143
'ei buvaiuai leXecai te Kai ei TeieXecfaeVov ecii', KoXaKOC be Tauiriv
'auba 6 Ti qppoveeic*. Kai Yap 01 KUjjuiKOi toioutouc eicdYouciv 5 e)Lie', NiKOjaaxe, rrpoc tov CTpaTiijOTriv TdHaTC,
dv jur) TTOir|CiJU TieTTOva |LiacTiYUJV oXov,
dv ]jLf\ TTOiriciJU CTroYTidc luaXaKuuTepov
t6 TTpOCUJTTOV.
€TT€iTa Tuuv )aev (piXoiv oubeic YiTveTai cuvepTOC, ei F 10 )ufi T^TevriTai cujupouXoc TrpoTepov, dXX' OTav boKi- judcri Kai cuTKaTacTrjcri Tfiv iTpdEiv eic t6 TTperrov f| t6 cujuqpepov 6 be KoXaE, Kdv dTTobil» tic auTUj t6 cuvboKijudcai Kai cuvaTTocpr|vac0ai Trepi toO TTpdTjua- Toc, ou jjovov uTTeiKeiv Kai x«pi^£ceai PouXojuevoc, i5 dXXd Kai bebiujc uTroipiav okvouvtoc Trapexeiv Kai qpeuTOVTOc t6 epTOv, evbibujci Kai cuveSopjud ttiv eTTi- Gujuiav. oubeic Tdp ecTi pabiujc ttXoucioc oube paci- Xeuc oioc eiTTeiv
'ejaoi Tdp eiri tttujxoc, ei be pouXeTai, 63
20 TTTUJXoO KaKiujv, ocTic (juv euvouc ejuoi (pdpov TTapeXGujv TdrTO Kapbiac epei', dXX' ujCTTep 01 TpaTLuboi xopoO beovTai ^iXujv cuva- bovTUJv fi eedTpou cuveTTiKpoToOvToc. 6eev fi }xk\ Tpa- fiKfi MepoTrri TTapaivei
'qpiXouc be touc juev |un \a\(ijviac ev XoTOic KeKTrjCO, Touc be ttp6c xdpiv cuv fibovr) Trj cri TTOvripouc KXrjepov eipTeTUJ CTe'TTic%
1. -202— 203 H. C, 230—231 R,
1. Homer. = 196. C 427. € 90 3. Id. = 195. C 426. e 89 5. Meinek. IV. p. 669 10. TeYdvriTai Pflugkius: YeviiTai
16. TTiv 47Ti6u,uiav idem: t^ 4Tri9u|uioi 19. Nauck. p. 386 29. Id. p, 373
144 QU.OMODO ADULATOR
B o'i be Toiivavxiov bpOuci), touc juev yif\ xaXiuvTac ev XoYOic dXX' dvTipaivovTac Onep toO cu|acpepovToc dcpocioOvTai , Touc be Ttpoc x«Piv irovripouc Kai dve- Xeu6epouc Ka\ YoriTac ou luovov KXr|9pa)v Kai CTeYnc evToc dXXd Kai TraGuJv Kai rrpaYiudTUJV dtrOppriTUJV s XajLtpdvouciv. iliv 6 |uev dTrXoucTepoc ouk oieTai beiv oub' dSioT cujLipouXoc etvai TrpaYiudTUJV tiiXikoutujv dXX' uTTOupYoc Kai bidKOVoc, 6 be TravoupYOTepoc e'cTr| juiev ev tuj cuvbiaTTopeTv Kai Tdc dqppOc cuvdYeiv Kai cuvbiaveueiv tCu TTpocujTriu, XeYei b' oubev dv lo b' CKeTvoc eirrr) t6 qpaivdjuevov, *iu 'HpdKXeic, ^'(p9r|c |ae' qprjci 'laiKpov eiTTiOv, eYU-' Ydp auTO touto XeYeiv ejLieXXov'. ibc Ydp oi inaGrjMO^TiKOi Tdc eTiiqpaveiac
C Kai Tdc YPCtMMdc XeYOuci MrjTe Kdja7TTec9ai juriTe bia- Teivec9ai |ur|Te KiveTc9ai Ka9' ^auTdc, vorjTdc Kai dcuj- is ludTouc oucac, cuYKd)aTrTec9ai be Kai cuvbiaTeivec6ai Ktti cu|Lijue9icTac9ai toTc cuu|Liaciv «I)V Tre'paTd eiciv, ouTUJ Tov KoXaKa qpujpdceic de» cuvemqpdcKOVTa Kai cuvaTToqpaivojaevov Kai cuvnb6)uevov vfi Aia Kai cuv- opYi26)aevov, ujcTe TravTeXujc ^v fe toutoic euqpiJupa- 20 Tov eivai Tf)V biaqpopdv. ^ti be lufiXXov ev tuj tpottuj Tfjc uTTOupYiac. Y] )Liev Ydp Trapd toO qpiXou x«pic
D u3cTTep Ziujov ev pd9ei Tdc KupiujTdTac e'xei buvdjueic, eTTibeiKTiKOV be Kai TravriYiJpiKov oubev eTrectiv dXXd TToXXdKic, ujCTTep laTpoc Xa9iJuv e9epdTTeuce, Kai qpiXoc 25 ujqpeXricev evTuxuJV f| biaXucd|Lievoc , dYVOouvTOc ctti- |aeXri9eic. toioOtoc 'ApKeciXaoc Trepi t€ TdXXa Kai vocoOvTOc 'ATTeXXoO toO Xiou ttiv Treviav KaTajua9ujv eTravfiX9ev au9ic exujv eiKOCi bpaxiudc, Kai Ka9icac . TrXriciov ^evTa09a |u^v' emev ^oubev ii Td '€)U7Tebo- so^ KXe'ouc cToixeTa TauTi
1.203— 204H. C, 231-233Bi
AB AMICO INTERNOSCATUR 145
'nOp Kai ubcup Kai Yaia Kai ai9epoc fJTTiov
uvpoc'. dXX' oube KatdKeicai cu beHiiI>c', d|Lia be biaKiviLv t6 TrpocKeqpdXaiov auToO, XaGibv urrepaXe t6 KepjudTiov.
5 ujc ouv fi biaKOvoOca TrpecpuTic eupe Kai 9au|adcaca e TU) 'ATTeXXr] TrpocriYTeiXe , YcXdcac eKeivoc "ApKeci- Xdcu' eiTre 'toOto t6 KXe)ii|iia'. Kai |Lif]v doiKOTa y^ TeKva qpueTai YOveOciv ev qpiXocoqpia. AaKubrtc yoOv 6 'ApKeciXdou Yvwpi)aoc dTi' eicaYYtXiac cpeuYovTi
10 biKriv KriqpicoKpdTei laeTd tujv dXXujv qpiXujv TrapeiCTri- Kei. ToO be KaTriYopou tov baKTuXiov aiTricavToc, 6 pev fjcuxfi TrapaKaefiKev , aic96)uevoc b' 6 AoKubric eTrc^Ti TUJ Trobi Kai dTreKpuijiev • ^v Ydp 6 eXeYXoc ev eKeivuj. laeTd be Tfjv dTToqpaciv toO KriqpicoKpdTOuc
15 beSioujuevou touc biKacTdc eic tic ujc ^oikcv ^opaKujc F t6 Yev6|uevov eKeXeuce AaKubr) x«piv exeiv Kai t6 TrpdYMa biriYHcaTO, toO AaKubou TTp6c luribeva qppd- cavToc. ouTUJC oi)uai Kai touc 9eouc euepYeTeiv Td TtoXXd XavOdvovTac, auTuJ tuj xctpi2ec9ai Kai eu Ttoi-
80 eiv qpuciv exovTac fibec9ai. t6 hk toO KoXaKoc ^pYov oubev lx€i biKaiov oub' dXTi9iv6v oub' dTrXoOv oub' eXeu9epiov, dXX' ibpujTa Kal KpauYfjV Kai biabpoiafjv Kai cuvTaciv ttpocuuttou KoioOcav e|uqpaciv Kai boKriciv eTTiTTOvou xpeiac Kai KaTecTreuciaevric , ujcTrep ZiuJYpd- 64
25 qpriiua TrepiepYOv dvaibeci qpapiudKOic Kai K€KXac)aevaic CToXici Kai puTici Kai Ywviaic IvapYeiac qpavTaciav iTTaYOiuevov. ^cti be Kai biriYOujuevoc ^Trax9f]c dic 4'TTpaSe rrXdvac Tivdc ctt' auTuJ Kai qppovTibac, eiTa diTex9eiac TTp6c eTepouc clTa rrpdYluaTa |uupia Kai
30 laeYdXa Ttd^n bieHiiuv, ujct' eirreiv ouk dSia TaOTa keivujv TTdca /aev Ydp 6veibiZ:o|aevri xap'c ^Trax^nc
1 , 205—206 H. 6, 233—235 R.
Plutarchi Moralia. Vol. I. jq
146 QUOMODO ADULATOR
Ktti dxapic Kai ouk dveKTri, laic bk tOuv KoXdKUiV ov\ iicTepov dXXd 7TpaTT0)aevaic evecTiv euGOc t6 dTTOvei-
B bicTov Ktti 5ucui7To0v. 6 be qpiXoc, dv emeiv ber|crj t6 TTpaTMtt, laeTpiiJuc dTTriTTeiXe, Tiepi auToO b' eiTTev oubev. rj br\ koi AaKebaijuovioi Cjiupvaioic beoiuevoic s ciTOv TT^)LH4;avT€c , luc e6au)ua2ov eKeivoi Triv xdpiv, 'oub^v' ecpacav 'nifa' iuiav Tdp fi,uepav ipriqpicdiaevoi t6 dpicTOV dcpeXeiv ^auTuJv Kai toiv uttoZIutiujv TaOTa *n9poica|iev '. ou Tdp laovov eXeuGepioc fi TOiauTTi xdpic, dXXd Kai ToTc Xaiupdvouciv fibiujv, oti touc wtpeXoOv- lo Tac ou laeTdXa pXdTTTecGai voiaiZiouciv.
23. Ou Toivuv fidXicTa tu; rrepi Tdc uTTOupTiac eTrax6ei toO KoXaKOC oube t^ irepi Tdc dTraTT^Xiac
C euxepeia Tvoir) tic dv TfjV qpuciv, dXXd |udXXov ^v tuj KaXuj Tfjc XP£i«c ^ aicxpu) Kai biacpepovTi TTpoc fibo- 15 vfiv f\ luqpeXeiav. 6 |aev Tdp cpiXoc oux, tJUCTTep dTTeqpaiveTO ropTiac, auTtu |a^v dSiuucei Td biKaia t6v (piXov UTTOupTeTv, ^Keivtu b' auT6c uTTripeTf|cei TToXXd Kai Tuiv |Lifi biKaiujv
' cuccujqppoveTv Tdp, ouxi cuvvoceTv ^'(pu.* 20
ludXXov ouv KdKeTvov dTTOTpe'vpei tujv |uf| TrpocriKOVTuuv " dv be ^i] Trei6r), KaX6v t6 cJJujKiujvoc 7Tp6c 'AvTirTaTpov 'ou buvacai iuoi Kai cpiXu» xpfic6ai Kai KoXaKi', toOt* ^CTi Kai (piXuj Kai |jfi (piXuj. cuvepTeTv Tdp beT tuj (piXiy, |Lif) cujUTTavoupTeTv,Kaicu|j3ouXeueiv,|jf)cuveTripouXeueiv, 25 Kai cu)a|aapTupeTv, ixx] cuveHarraTdv, Kai cuvaTuxeTv vf)
D Aia, \xr] cuvabiKeTv. oube Tdp t6 cuveib^vai toTc (piXoic Td aicxpd, TToeev T€ bY\ t6 cuiarrpdTTeiv Kai cuvacxri^o- veTv aipeTov ecTiv; ujcrrep ouv AaK6bai|a6vioi ladxri KpaTri6evTec utt' 'AvTmdTpou Kai Troioujaevoi biaXuceic 30
I, 206-208 H. 6, 285-237 R.
3. flv*: Kflv 20. Eurip. Iph. A. 407
4
AB AMICO INTERNOSCATUR 147
rjEiouv 6 Ti pou\€Tai Z:r||uiuJb€C, aicxpov be |urib€v eTriTdTT€iv auTOic, outujc 6 qpiXoc, av tic f\ baTrdvriv r| Kivbuvov f| TTOvov exouca XP^iw KaTaXaiupdvr] , TTpoi- toc dHioT KaXeicGai Kai laeTexeiv dTTpocpacicTiuc Kai
5 TTpoGujiUJC, OTTOu hk. TTpocecTiv aicxuvr) , |u6vov edv Kai qp€ibec0ai TTapaiTeiTai, dW fi fe KoXaKeia tou- vavTiov ev )iiev Taic eTTiTTOvoic Kai KivbuvuObeciv uTroup- Yiaic dTraYopeuei, Kdv biaTreipibiuevoc Kpoucrjc, ca- e 0p6v €K Tivoc TTpocpdceujc uTrrixeT Kai dTevve'c • iv be
10 TaTc aicxpaTc Kai TaTreivaTc Kai dboHoic biaKOviaic dTToxpricai TrdTricov, oubev fiteTTai beivov oub' uppi- ctik6v. opac tov TTi0riKov; ou buvaTai ttiv oiKiav qpuXdTTeiv ujc 6 kuujv, oube ^acTdZieiv ujc 6 mTTOC, oub' dpoOv Trjv YHV wc oi poec u^piv ouv (pe'pei Kai
13 puijuoXoxiav Kai Traibidc dvexeTai, ye^iajtoc opYavov ejUTtapexujv ^auTdv. outuj bri Kai 6 KoXaH ou cuvei- TteTv ou cuveiceveTKeTv ou cuvafUJvicacOai buvd|uevoc, TTOvou Te Ktti CTTOubfic aTTdcric dTToXeiTTOinevoc, ev TdTc UTTO ludXric TTpdHeciv dTTpoq)dciCT6c ecTi, Kai ttictoc p
20 epujTOC uTtripeTric Kai Trepi Xuciv Trdpviic dKpipfic Kai tt6tou baTtdvric ^KKaOfjpai Xoyicjuov ouk djueXfic, oube pd0u|uoc ev beiTTVujv TrapacKeuaTc, ©epaTreuTiKoc be TTaXXaKibujv, Trpoc hk KrjbecTdc dTro0pacuvec0ai KeXeu- c0eic Kai cuveK^aXeTv taiueTfiv dTeyKTOc Kai dbucuu-
23 TTriTOC. ujCTe lurjbe TauTr) bucqpuupaTov eivai tov dv- bpa" TTpocTaTT6|U€VOC Tdp 6 ti pouXei tujv db6Hujv 65 Kai )ufj KaXujv €toi|uoc dqpeibeTv eauToO, tuj TrpocTdT- TOVTi x«pi^OM€voc.
24. Oux fiKiCTa b' dv tic auTov Iv Tfj rrpoc touc
30 dXXouc qpiXouc bia0€cei KaTajudOoi ttoXu toO qpiXou
1, 208-209 H. 6,237-239».
4. dSiot — 7TapaiT€iTai * : dSiwv — uapaiTeTceai
10*
148 QUOMODO ADULATOR
biaq)e'povTa. TUJ )aev Yotp ribiCTOV ecTi iiieTd ttoXXujv (piXeTv Ktti qpiXeicGai, Kai toOto TrpdTTiuv del biaTeXei TTepi Tov qpiXov onujc TroXOq)iXoc Kai 7ToXuTi|uriToc ecTar Koivd fap Td qpiXujv fiYOujuevoc oubev outujc oTeTai beiv koivov ujc touc cpiXouc uTrdpxeiv • 6 be s
B vyeubnc Kal voGoc Kai uTtoxaXKOC ujv, aTe* bf\ ludXiCTa YiYVUJCKUJV ^auTOV dbiKoOvTa Tfjv qpiXiav ujCTrep- v6- )nic)Lia TTapdcriMOV utt' auToO Yevo)aevriv, ecTi )aev Kai q)ucei q)6ovep6c, dXXd tuj q)66vuj xP^lTai Trpoc touc 6)Lioiouc, bia)aiXXu))aevoc uTreppaXec6ai Puj|LioXoxia Kai lo CTTep)aoXoYia, tov be KpeiTTOva Tp^)uei Kai beboiKev, ou )ad Aia * Trapd Aubiov dpjua TreCoc oixveuujv ', dXXd 'rrapd xpucov lq)66v', ujc q)rici Ct)iujvibric, 'dKripaTov oube )Li6Xupbov ^'xujv'. OTav oijv eXaq)p6c u)v Kai eTriTriKTOC Kai drraTriXoc ^YT66ev dvTeSeTdZriTai rrpoc 15
C dXTi6ivfiv Kai e)aPpi6fi qjiXiav Kai cq)upr|XaTOV, ouk dva- qjepujv dXX' ^HeXeYX^f^evoc TauTO TTOieT tuj Z!ujYpaq)r|- cavTi Touc dXeKTpudvac deXiujc. ^KeTvoc Te Yap eKeXeue Tov TraTba touc dXri6ivouc dXeKTpu6vac dTToco^eTv dTTUj- TdTUJ ToO TTivaKoc, o\jt6c Te Touc dXri6ivouc dTTOCopeT 20 q)iXouc Kai ouk iq TrXricid2eiv * Sv bk ^r) buvriTai, qjavepujc )Liev \JiTocaivei Kai Trepi^Trei Kai T^6riTTev ujc d)Aeivovac, Xd6p(x b' uq)irici Tivac Kai uTTOCTreipei bia- PoXdc. Kpuq)iou be X6you KvncavTOC cXkoc, Kdv )afi TTavTeXuuc eu6uc epYdcriTai, t6 toO Mribiou q)uXdTTei 25 )ae)Livri|u^voc. ^v b' 6 Mribioc toO Trepi tov 'AXeHav- bpov xopo^ TuJv KoXdKUJV ofov eHapxoc Kai coq)iCTfic
D Kopuq)aToc Itti touc dpicTouc cuvTeTaYjaevoc. ^KeXeu- cev ouv 6appo0vTac d7TTec6di Kai bdKveiv TaTc bia-
1, 209—211 H. C, 239—240 R
12. Bergk. Pind. fr. 190 (222) 13. Ci|aijuvi6r]c] Id.
p. 1140* 15. ^iTiTriKTOC lacobsius: dTTiKTriToc
AB AMICO INTERNOSCATUR 149
PoXaic, bibdcKaiv oti, Kctv Gepaireiicr) t6 eXKOc 6 be- briYiuevoc, n ouXfi lueveT ttic biapoXfic. TauTaic laev- TOi Taic oOXaic, luaXXov be YCiTTpaivaic Kai KapKiviu- |uaci biappujQeic 'AXeHavbpoc dTTuuXece Kai KaXXic9evTi
5 Kai TTapiaeviujva Kai OiXuuTav • "Atvuuci be Kai BaToi- atc Kai 'fK^r\c\aK kolx ArijuriTpioic dcpeibujc dvebujKev ^auTOV i)7TOCKeXiz;ec0ai , 7TpocKuvou|Lievov Kai KaTacTo- XiZoiaevov Kai dvarrXaTToiLievov utt' auTujv ujcrrep dTaX)Lia papPapmov. outuj jaeTdXrjV exei t6 trpoc E
10 xdpiv buvaiaiv, Ka» jueTicTriv ujc eoiKev Iv toTc laeTi- cToic eivai boKoOcr t6 Tdp oiecGai Td KdXXicTa iueTd ToO pouXecGai TricTiv d|aa tlu KoXaKi Kai Odpcoc bi- boici. TU)V |u€v Tdp TOTTUJV Td uv|jriXd bucTTpocoba Kai buceqpiKTa TiTveTai toTc eTTipouXeuouci, t6 b' ^v HJuxfj
5 voOv ouK Ixo^cri bi' euTuxiav fj bi' eucputav uvjjoc Kai qppovriiaa toTc niKpoTc Ka\ TaTreivoTc iudXicTa pdci- l^ov ecTiv.
25. "06ev dpxojuevoi Te toO Xotou TTapeKeXeucd- jueGa Kai vOv TrapaKeXeuojueGa t6 qpiXauTOv eKKonTeiv
^o ^auTUJV Kai Tfjv oir|Civ • auTr) Tdp fijudc rrpoKoXaKeu- F ouca |uaXaKujTe'pouc TToieT toTc Gupaioic KoXaEiv, ibc dToi|uouc ovTac. dv be TTei06|uevoi tlu 0eiu Kai t6 'Tvu)0i cauT6v' ujc ^KdcTip toO rravT^c dHiov ecTi iLiaGovTec d|ia Kai (puciv Kai Tpo^fiv Kai Traibeuciv
-" eauTUJV dva0eu)pOu|uev ^XXei|a|uaTa |iupia toO KaXoO Kai TTC^u t6 qpauXuJC Kai eiKfi cu|a|ue]uiT|ue'vov exoucav iv TTpdSeciv ev Xotoic ^v TrdOeciv, ou Trdvu pabiujc e|u- TrepiTTaTeTv toTc KoXaHiv dauTOuc TTapeHo|uev. 'AXeHav- bpoc juev Tdp dTTicTeTv icpx] toTc 0e6v auTov dvaTO-
1 , 211—212 H. e, 240—242 R,
6. 'AYHcictic] 'A-fici W 15. r\ 61' eO^utav] De-
let W
150 QUOMODO ADULATOR
peOouciv ev tuj KaGeubeiv ladXicta Kai dqppobicidZIeiv, ibc dTevvecTepoc irepi TaOTa Kai TiaGriTiKuuTepoc auToO
66YiTv6|uevoc' fi)ueic be TioXXd iroXXaxoO tiIjv ibiiuv alcxpd Kai XuKTipd Kai dTeXfi Kai fi|uapTri|ueva Ka9o- pujVTec dei q)uupdco)uev eauTOuc ouk dTtaivoOvTOc cpiXou 5 Kai KaTeuXoyoOvTOC beoiue'vouc, dXX' eXcTxovTOC Kai 7TappTiciaZ;o|ue'vou Kai ipeTOVTOC fi)udc vfi Aia KaKuuc TTpdTTOVTac. oXiYOi )uev ydp eK tcoXXOuv eiciv oi Trap- pricid2;ec0ai ludXXov f| xapiZiec9ai toTc (piXoic toX)uujv- Tec* dv be toTc oXiYOic au9ic ou pabiuuc dv eupoic lo eTTiCTa)uevouc touto TTOieTv, dXX' oio)uevouc, dv Xoibo- puuci Kai vpeYuuci, TTappr|cia xpnc9ai. KaiToi Ka^drrep
B dXXiu Tivi cpapfidKijj, Kai tuj TTappricidZ;ec9ai [xr\ tu- XOVTi Kaipou t6 XurreTv dxpncTuuc Kai TapdTTeiv rre- piecTi Kai TTOieTv Tpdrrov Tivd |ueT' dXYr|b6voc 6 TTOieT is |ue9' fibovfic t6 KoXaKeueiv. pXdTTTOVTai Ydp ouk eTTaiVoujuevoi |u6vov dKaipuuc dXXd Kai ipeY6)uevor Kai toOto ludXiCTtt ToTc K6XaHiv euXf|TTTOuc Kai rrXaYiouc Trapabibuuciv, dTTO tuuv cqpobpa rrpocavTUJv Kai dvTi- TUTTuuv uicTTep ^Tri Td KoTXa Kai luaXaKd biKriv ubaTOC 20 dTToXic9dvovTac. bio beT Tfiv Trappriciav fj9ei KeKpd- c9ai Kai XoTov exeiv dcpaipoOvTa to dYav Kai to dKpaTOV auTnc ujCTrep q)ujT6c, iva |ufi TapaTT6)uevoi lurib' dXYOuvTec utto tuuv aTravTa |ue|U(po|uevuJV Kai Trdciv eYKaXouvTuuv KaTaqpeuTwciv eic Tfiv toO KdXaKOc 25 C CKidv, Ktti TTpoc t6 )ufi XuTToOv dTTOCTpecpuuvTai. TTd- cav fxhf y&p, (b OiXdTTaitTre , KttKiav q)euKTeov dcTi bi' dpeTfjc, ouxi bid Tfic evavTiac KaKiac, ujCTrep evioi boKoOciv aicxuvTTiXiav juev dvaicxuvTia cpeuTeiv dTPOi- Kiav be pujjuoXoxia, beiXiac be Kai luaXaKiac dTTuuTdTUJ so Ti9ec9ai tov tp6ttov dv iTYiCTa q^aivuuvTai Xajuupiac
i, 212—214 H. C, 242-243 R.
AB AMICO INTERNOSCATUR 151
Kai GpacuTTiTOC. ^vtoi be Kai &eicibai|iioviac dGeoTriTa Kai TTavoupYiav dpeXTepiac dTroXoYriMa TtoioOvTai, Ka- GdTiep EuXov t6 ^9oc ck KajUTrfic eic TouvavTiov dTiei- D pia ToO KaTop0oOv biacTpe'{povTec. aicxicTn be Ko\a-
5 Keiac dpvncic dvuucpeXujc XuTrripov eivai, Kai KOjuibii Tivoc djLioucou Kai dTe'xvou Tipoc euvoiav ojuiXiac dribia Kai xciXeTroTtiTi q)euYeiv t6 dYevvec ev qpiXia Kai TaTteivov, ujcrrep dTreXeuGepov ev KUUjLiujbia Triv kolty]- Yopiav icriYopiac dTtoXauciv fiYou|uevov. ^Ttei Toivuv
10 aicxpov )uev ecTi KoXaKeia Trepmeceiv biuuKOVTa t6 Ttpoc xapiv, aicxp6v be qpeuYOVTa KoXaKeiav Trappri- ciac djucTpia biaqpOeipai t6 cpiXiKov Kai KribeiaoviKov, bei bk )uri9' eTcpov TTa9eiv dXX' ujCTrep dXXuj tivi Kai Trj Ttappricia t6 KaX6v ck toO jueTpiou Xa^eiv, auT6c E f 15 loiKev 6 X6yoc 6 t6 ^qpeSnc dTraiTiIiv emTiOevai Trjv Kopuuviba Tilj cuYYpdiujaan ■
27. "QcTTep ouv Kfipdc Tivac eTioucac t^ Trappn- cia TrXeiovac opujvTec TrpuuTOV dqpaipuujuev auTfic xr\v qpiXauTiav, eu ladXa qpuXaTTojLievoi |ufi bid ti tuuv ibiuuv
20 otov dbiKOU|aevoi Kai dXYoOvTec eEoveibiZieiv boKuu|uev. ouTe Ydp utt' euvoiac dXX' utt' opYnc oiovTai YiTve- cOai t6v UTTep auToO toO Xcyovtoc YiTVO/aevov Xoyov, o^jTe vouOeciav dXXd |ue|uipiv eivai. qpiXiK6v Ydp fi TTappricia Kai cejuvov, fi be |ue'juipic Kai qpiXauTOv Kai
25 mKpoXoYov. 69ev aiboOvTai touc TrappriciaJojLievouc Kai OaujudJlouci, toTc be |Lie|aqpo|uevoic dvTeYKaXouci Koi KaTaqppovoOciv. tjjCTTep 6 'AYa|ae'|uvuJV t6v 'AxiX- F Xea TTappri<:id2ec9ai boKoOvTa jueTpiuuc oux uTTe'jLieive, ToO b' 'Obucceujc Ka9aTTTOjue'vou ttikpOuc Kai XeYovToc
30 'ouXojuev', aT9' ujqpeXXec deiKeXiou CTpaToO dXXou ctijaaiveiv'
1, 214-215 H. 6, 243-245 B.
30. Homer. = 84
152 QUOMODO ADULATOR
e'iK€i Kai KapxepeT, tlu KTibeiaoviKu» toO Xofou Kai voGv exovTi cucTeXXoiaevoc. oijToc ^kv Yotp ouk ^x^v Ibiac 67 Trpocpaciv 6pff\c drrappricmZeTo Tipoc auTov urrep Tfic 'EXXdboc, ^KeTvoc be bi' auTov eboKei ladXicTa x^^^- Traiveiv. auTdc fe \ir\y 6 'AxiXXeuc, KaiTrep ou f\v- s Ku9u)i0C ijuv oub' dTavoqppoiv dXXd *bciv6c dvrip, oioc Kai dvamov aiTidac9ai*,
TrapeTxe tlu TTaTpoKXuj ciuuTrr) KaTaqpe'p€iv auToO TioXXd TOiaOTtt
' vriXe€'c, oOk dpa coi fe TxaTfip fjv irrTTOTa TTriXeuc !<> oub^ OeTic MriTTip- Y^ctuKri bi ce TiKTe 9dXacca TreTpai t' nXipaToi, oti toi vooc dcTiv dTrrivnc*.
B ujCTrep Tdp TTrepeibrjC 6 ^rjTiup »i2iou CKOTieTv 'A9r|" vaiouc juri ^ovov ei ttikpoc Ictiv, dXX' ei rrpoTKa tti- Kpoc, ouTiuc fi ToO qpiXou vou9ecia Ka9apeuouca irav- is Toc ibiou TTd9ouc aibecTOV ecTi Kai cejnvov Kai dvav- TipXeTTTOv. dv be bx) qpavepoc ^ tic ev Tqj Trapprjcid- Zec9ai Td inev eic auTov d|uapTrijaaTa toO qpiXou KO|Liibfi TTpoTe')aevoc Kat dTroXeiTTUJV , dXXac be' Tivac auToO TrXr|)i|aeXeiac eXeTX^Juv Kai bdKvwv eqp ' ^T^poic Kai ^xt] 20 qpeibo^evoc, diuaxoc 6 tovoc Tfic Trapprjciac out6c ecTi Kai Trj y^ukuttiti toO vou9eTo0vTOC ^rriTeivuJv t6 TTiKp6v Kai aucTrip6v Tf^c vou9eciac. o9ev eO )aev eVpriTai t6 beTv ev TaTc dp^aTc Kai TaTc biaqpopaTc
C TaTc Trp6c touc qpiXouc )adXicTa TrpdTTeiv ti Kai cko- 25 TreTv Tujv dKeivoic cu)aqpep6vTwv r| TrpenovTUJV, oux fjTTOV bk TouTOu qpiXiKOv dcTi t6 Trt«popdc9ai Kai d|ue- XeTc9ai boKoOvTac auTouc uTrep dXXuiv djaeXoujaevuiv
1, 215-216H. 6, 245— 247 R.
7. Homer. A 652. N 775 10. Id. TT 33 17. biy*:
bi] KOi
AB AMICO INTERNOSCATUR 153
TTappT]CidZ;ec9ai Kai iJTrom|Livr|CKeiv. ujc nXdTuuv iv Taic -apoc Aiovuciov uTTOvjJiaic Kai bmqpopaic ^Tri- caTO Kaipov evTuxiac eiTa 6 |Liev ebuuKeV; oiojuevoc uTTep auToO ti (aeVM^acGai tov TTXdTujva Kai bieXGeiv,
5 6 bl nXdTuuv ouTU) TTUJC bieXe'xOri rrpoc auTOV. 'ei Tiva aicOoio, Aiovucie, buc)Lievfi TTCTTXeuKOTa eic Ci- KeXiaV; KaKov ti ce TTOificai pouXojuevov ouk exovTaD bk Kaipdv, Sp' dv edceiac auTov eKrrXeucai Kai TTepi- iboic dOujov dTTaXXaTevTtt' ; 'ttoXXoO b^uj' emev 6 Aio-
10 vucioc ' iL TTXdTUJv ■ bei tdp ou Td ep^a tujv ^xOpuJv ILiovov dXXd Kai ttiv Trpoaipeciv laiceTv Kai KoXdileiv'. 'ei Toivuv' emev 6 TTXdTUJV 'eTT' euvoia tic dq)iY|ue- voc Tvj crj beOpo pouXeTai |u^v dtaOoO tivoc aiTioc coi Y€vecOai, cu be Kaipov ou TTapexeic, clEiov ecTi
15 toOtov dxapiCTUJC rrpoecOai Kai oXiYuOpuuc'; epujTti- cavTOC be toO Aiovuciou tic ecTiv outoc, 'Aicxivric' eTrrev 'dvfip tuj Te fjOei TTap' ovTivaoOv tujv CujKpd- Touc ^Taipujv eTTieiKfjc Kai tuj Xoylu buvaToc erTavop- OoOv oic dv cuvfj • TTXeucac be beOpo rroXXfiv OdXaT- E
20 Tttv, ujc cuTTtvoiTO coi bid cpiXocoqpiac , i^iueXriTar. TaOTa ouTUJC eKivrice tov Aiovuciov, uucTe Tdc laev xeipac tuj TTXdTuuvi euOuc uepipdXXeiv Kai KaTacTrdZe- cOai, Tf)v eu|ueveiav Kai laeTaXoqppocuvriv dTdjLievov, ToO b' Aicxivou KaXujc Kai iueTaXoTTpeTTuuc eTTiiaeXriOfivai.
25 27. AeuTepov Toivuv uicrrep CKKaOaipovTec Oppiv dTTttcav Kai TcXuuTa Kai CKtu)a)Lia Kai puu)uoXoxiav fibu- CjuaTa TTOvnpd Tfjc rrappriciac dcpaipuj|uev. ujCTrep Tdp iaTpoO cdpKa tciuvovtoc eupuO|uiav Tivd bei Kai KaOa- P pioTriTa Toic epToic eTTiTpe'xeiv , opxncTiKfiv be Kai
1.21G-217H. 6, 2-17— 248B.
2. uTTOiviaic Graeco-Latiua a. 1624: 6Tr€poi|;iaic 19.
Sv cuvri*: cuveir)
154 QUOMODO ADULATOR
TrapdpoXov Kai TrepiTpexoucav uTPotriTa Kai TTepiep-fiav dtTTeivai Tfic x^ipoc, outujc f] Trappticia bexeTai t6 ^tti- beHiov Kai t6 dcTeiov, av f) x«Pic tiiv cejuvoTriTa cwlt}, 9pacuTr|c be Kai pbeXupia Kai OPpic TrpocoOca TidvTa biacpOeipei Kai dTToXXuciv. 69€V 6 jiev ipdXTnc •'')
PUK dTTl9dvtJUC OUb' djUOUCUUC ^TT€CT6)LllCe t6v 0iXlTTTTOV
^TTixeipoOvTa Trepi Kpou)idTUJv biaqpep€c9ai Ttp6c au- Tov, eiTTiuv ')ufi YtvoiTO coi ouTUJC il) paciXeO KaKUJC,
68 'iv' i^oxj cx) TaOTa peXTiov eibrjc'. '€TTixap|Lioc b' ouk 6p9u)C, ToO 'l^puivoc dveXovTOC ^viouc tiLv cuvr|9ujv lo Kai )ue9 ' fi)u^pac ^Xixac KaXecavTOC ^tti bemvov auTov, 'dXXd TTpiuriv* eqpr) '9uujvtouc (piXouc ouk dKdXecac'. KaKUfC be Kai 'AvTiqpuJv, Trapd Aiovuciuj ZiriTriceujc oucr|c Kai XoTou 'ttoioc xa^K^c dpicTOC,' 'dKeivoc' elTrev, *il ov 'A9fivrici KttTecKeuacav Tdc 'Ap^iobiou Ka\ 'Api- ir- CTOTeiTOVoc ekdvac'. ouTe Tdp uJcpeXeT t6 XuTrrip6v Kai TTiKpov, ouT€ TepTtei t6 PujjuoXoxov Kai TraibiiLbec, dXX' ?CTi KaKori^eia Kai uppei |ue)uiT)u^vric dKpaciac
B)ueT' €x9pac t6 toioOtov elboc, iD xP^M^voi Ttpoc- aTToXXuouciv auTOuc, Tqv Ttepi t6 qppeap opxriciv dTe- -^o Xvujc 6pxou)uevoi. Kai Tdp 'AvTiqpujv dTre9av€V utt6 Aiovuciou Kai Ti)uaTevr|C ^EeTrece Tfic Kaicapoc qpiXiac, dXeu9^pa fuev oubeTTOTe qpujvri xPncdjuevoc, iv be toic cu)UTTOcioic Kai Toic TTepmdToic ^KdcTOTC Trp6c oub'
flVTlVOOv CTTOUbf|V »5 ]
'dXX' 6 Ti 01 eicaiTO T^Xoiiov 'ApTeioiciv* akiav qpiXiac ijjCTTep c6qpic)ua Xoibopiac Trpoqpepojuevoc. errei Kai toic kuj)uikoTc TToXXd TTp6c t6 9eaTpov au-
1, 21T— 21i)H. C, 248-230 E
5. udvTa Reiskius: Trdvu 9. cu TaOTO*: TauTa cu
26. Horner. B 215 27. iTpoqiepoiLievoc Reiskius: npocqpe-
p6|a€voc 28. aucTripOjc*: aucTiipd
AB AMICO mTERNOSCATUR 155
CTripujc Ktti TrXrjKTiKUJC eiTeTToiriTO • cu|U|Lie|uiYMevov be t6 YeXoiov auTOic Kai P(ju)iioX6xov, ujcrrep cmoic uTT6Tpi|U|ia c |uox6rip6v, eSiTriXov eTTOiei Tfjv Trappnciav Kai axprj- CTov, ujcie TTepifiv KaKoriGeiac b6Ha Kai pbeXupiac toTc 5 XeTOuci, xpncijuov be toic dKOuouciv oubev oitto tujv XeTO|uevujv. aXXujc )uev ouv TtpocoicTeov ecTi Kai TTaibidv Kai TeXujTa toTc q)iXoic" f) be Trapprjcia cttou- bfiv exe'TUj Kai flGoc. dv b' uTiep )ueiZ;6vuJv ^, Kai TTdGei Ktti cxfiiuaTi Kai t6vuj cpujvfic 6 X6toc dEi6TTi-
10 cTOc ecTUJ Kai KivriTiK6c. 6 be Kaipoc ev TravTi /aev TTapeGek |U€TdXa pXdTTTei, iudXicTa be Tfjc TTappriciac biaqpBeipei t6 xpilci|uov. oti |uev ouv ev oTvuj Kai )Lie9ri To TOiouTO q3uXaKTe'ov, eubriXdv ecTiv. eubiaD Tdp errdTei veqpoc 6 kivuuv ev rraibia Kai qpiXocppocuv)!
15 X6tov oqppOv dvacTTuJVTa Kai cuviCTdvTa to Trpdc- uuTTOv, ujCTTep dvTiTaTT6|Lievov tuj Auaiuj Geuj Kai 'XuovTi To Tujv bucqp6pujv cxoiviov fiepijuvOuv ' KaTd TTivbapov. exei be Kai Kivbuvov f] dKaipia peTav. dKpocqpaXeTc Tdp eiciv ai qjuxai rrpoc opTnv bid tov
20 oTvov, Kai TToXXdKic f] |ue9ri TTapaXapouca Tfjv TTap- pr|ciav €x9pav eTToirice. Kai oXuic ouk ecTi TevvaTov oube 9appaXeov dXX' dvavbpov ev tui vfiqpeiv dTrap- priciacTou to TTappricidZ:ec9ai Tiapd TpdTreCav ujcrrep 01 beiXoi Kuvec. oubev ouv beT Tiepi toutuiv XeTovTU
25 juriKuveiv.
28. '€tt€i be ttoXXoi touc qpiXouc eu qpepojuevouc E ev ToTc TTpdTjuaciv out' dEioOciv outc toXjuujci pu9|ui- Zieiv, dXX' oXuic dTTp6ciT0v Kai dveqpiKTOV fiToOvTai
1,219— 220H. 6,250— 252R.
1. TTXriKTlKUJC*: TroXlTlKd fireTTOiriTO*: TTeTTOUlTO
4. pbeXupiac Reiskius: pbeXupia 16. Auaiai W: Aubiuj
18. nivbapov] Bergk. fr. 232 (124)
156 QUOMODO ADULATOR
vouQeciqi t6 cutuxoOv e?va», ccpaXXojaevoic be Kai TTTaiouciv dTriTiSevTai Kai TraToOciv utto \eipa Kai Ta- Tteivouc YeT€vri|aevouc , ujcTrep peO)aa KeKpaTrnuevov Ttapd cpuciv Tfiv TtappTiciav depoujc lcpi^vTec auTOic Kai dTToXauovTec dciuevoi Tfjc laeTa^oXfic bid Tfiv 5 TipocOev uTTeponiiav eKeivuiV auTUJV b' dc0€'v6iav, ou xeTpov ^Ti Kai Trepi toutujv bieX0eTv Kai dTtOKpiva- c0ai TU) Gupmibri X^yovti
'6Tav b' 6 bai)aujv eu bibu», ti beT (piXujv';
F 6ti beT iiidXiCTa irappriciaZoiaevujv cpiXujv toTc euTu- lo Xouci Kai t6 dtav ucpievTUJV toO qjpovfmaTOC. oXitoi Ydp eiciv oic laeTd toO euTuxeTv napafiTveTai t6 qjpoveTv oi be ttoXXoi qjpevOuv eTieicdKTUJV beovTai Ktti XoYicjatuv TTieZovTUJV ^Hu)0ev auTOiJC utt6 Tfjc tu- Xric qpucuj)aevouc Kai caXeuo|aevouc. OTav b' 6 baijaujv is KaTapdXr) Kai TrepieXr] t6v otkov, auToTc toTc rrpdT- laaciv ^vecTi t6 vou0eToOv Kai laeTdvoiav eiiiTToioOv. 60ev oub^v ^PTOV totc Trapprjciac qpiXiKfic oube X6- Yuiv pdpoc exovTuiv Kai br^YMOV, dXX' lijc dXri0u)C ev ToTc TOiauTaic laeTaPoXaTc 20
69 *elc 6|a|iaT' euvou cpujT6c djupXeipai yXuku* rrapriTopoOvTOc Kai Trapa0appuvovToc, ujcTrep toO KXe- dpxou t6 TrpocujTTOV 6 Eevocpujv ev TaTc fjdxaic Kai Trapd Td beivd qjriciv 6puO|aevov eu|aevk Kai qpiXdv- 0pujTrov eu0apcecTepouc iroieTv touc KivbuveuovTac 25 6 hk Trappnciav Kai briTM^v dv0pujTruj bucTuxoOvTi TTpocdTUJV uJCTrep 6SubopKiK6v 6|Li|aaTi Tapacco)aevuj Ktti qjXeTlwaivovTi , ^eparreuei |aev oubev oub' dq^aipeT
1. 220-221 H. 6, 252-254 K
8. €i)pnT(6ri] Or. 667 21. Emip. lon. 732 23. =e-
voqpOuv] Anab. II 6, 11
AB AMICO INTERNOSCATUR 157
ToO XuTToOvTOC, opTHV be Tfj XuTrr] TrpocTiGrici Kai TrapoSuvei tov dviuujaevov. auTiKa yoOv uTiaivoiv |aev B Tic ou xtt^eTTOC lcTiv oub' dtpioc TtavTdTraciv dvbpi qpiXuj vjjeYOVTi )Liev cuvouciac Kai ttotouc auTou \pi-
5 YovTi b' dpYiav Kai dYujuvaciav Kai XouTpd cuvexf) Kai rrXnciaovdc dKaipouc vocouvti b' ouk dveKTOv dXXd MeiJujv vococ dKOueiv oti TauTd coi Y^YOvev il dKpaciac Kai laaXaKiac Kai bi' 6\\)a m\ YuvaiKac. w if\c dKaipiac, dvGpiuTTe" biaGrjKriv Ypdqpuj Kai Trapa-
10 CKeudZeTai |uoi KacTopiov r\ cKaiuiuviov utto tuuv ia- TpuJv, cu bk vouBeTCic Kai (piXocoqpeic. outuj Toivuv Ktti Td TtpdYiuaTa twv bucTuxouvTaiv ou Ttappriciav evbe'xeTai Kai YVUJ|uoXoYiav, dXX' eTtieiKeiac betTai Kai c PorjOeiac. Kai Ydp ai TiTeai toTc Ttaibioic TrecoOciv
15 ou Xoibopr|c6jLievai TrpocTpe'xouciv, dXX' fJYeipav Kai TrepieTTXuvav Kai KaTecTeiXav, eiG ' outujc iTTmXriTTOuci Kai KoXdZouci. XeYeTai be Kai AnjurjTpioc 6 cpaXripeuc 6t€ Tfjc TTaTpiboc lEeTtece Kai Trepi GriPac dboEuJv Kai TaTTeivd TTpdTTUJV bifJYev, oux nbeujc ibeiv TrpociovTa
20 KpdTriTa, Trappriciav kuviktiv Kai Xoyouc TpaxeTc Ttpoc- b€x6|uevoc • evTux6vToc be Trpdujc auTuj toO KpdTriToc Kai biaXexOevTOC rrepi cpuYnc ujc oub^v exei KaKov oub' dHiov qpepeiv papeujc TTpaYjudTujv ccpaXepiJuv KaiD dpepaiujv OTTriXXaYiuevov, a|ua be GappeTv eauTuj Kai
85Tri bia9ec€i TrapaKaXoOvTOC, fibiujv Yevojuevoc Kai dva- eapprjcac rrpoc touc qpiXouc eiTre 'cpeO tujv TrpdSeujv ^Keivujv Kai dcxoXiujv bi' Sc dvbpa toioOtov ouk l'Yvuj)uev '.
' XuTTOuiaevuj juev juOeoc eujuevfic q)iXujv,
30 dYav be juujpaivovTi voueeTJijuaTa.'
1, 221-223 H. 6, 254-256 R.
13. ^vb^xetai Empeiius: ^Kfe^xeTav 29. XuTroujLievqj]
Nauck. p. 524 ja^v*: yc«P
158 QUOMODO ADULATOR
ouTOc 6 ipoTTOc Tuiv Tevvaiujv qpiXoiv oi b' dYevveic Kai TaTreivoi tujv euTuxoOvTujv KoXaKec, 'ujcTrep la. E priYMaTa Kai Tot CTrdcjLtaTd ' qprici ATi)noc9evric ' 6mv Ti KaKov t6 cujjua Xdpr] totc KiveTcGai', Kai outoi TaTc jueTapoXaTc eTriqpuovTai , KaBdrrep fjbojuevoi Kai 5 dTToXauovTec. Kai Ydp av &€'riTai tivoc uTTOjuvr|ceujc ev oic bi' auTov CTTTaice pouXeucdjuevoc KaKuic, ka- vdv kTi t6
'ou Ti KaG' fijueTepov Y€ voov fudXa Ydp toi
eYUJYe 10
TtoXX' dTTejuu9e6|ur|v'.
29. '6v Ticiv ouv cqpobpov eivai bei tov qpiXov Kai TT^Te Tu» t6vlu xPne6ai Tfic Trappriciac; OTav fibo- vfic r| 6pYfic ^ uppeu)c eTTiXape'c6ai cpepojuevric oi Kai- F poi TTapaKaXujciv ti KoXoOcai cpiXapYupiav f| dTTpoceHiav lij dvacxeTv dvdriTOv. outujc eTrappricidZieTO CdXuJv TTpoc ' KpoTcov utt' euTUxiac dpepaiou bieqpeopoTa Kai Tpu- qpuuvTa, t6 TeXoc 6pdv KeXeucac* outuj CujKpdTric 'AXKipidbriv eKdXoue, Kai bdKpuov eHfJYev dXTi9iv6v eHeXeYXojue'vou Kal Tfjv Kapbiav ecTpeqpe. TOiaOTa Td Kupou TTpoc KuaEdprjv Kai Td TTp6c Aiujva TTXd- Tujvoc, oTe XajuTTpoTaToc fiv Kai rrdvTac eic dauT6v dv9pujTrouc ^rrecTpeqpe bid t6 KdXXoc tujv TrpdHeujv Ktti t6 jue'Yeeoc, TrapaKeXeuojuevou q)uXdTTec9ai Kai 70 bebievai Tfiv 'au9dbeiav, ujc eprijuia Huvoikov'. eYpa- ^ qpe be Kai CTreuciTtTroc auTUJ jufj jueYa qppoveiv ei tto- Xijc auToO XoYoc ecTiv dv Traibapioic Kai Y^vaioic, dXX' opdv OTTUJc ocioTnTi Ktti biKaiocuvrj Kai vojuoic
1, 223-225 H. 6, 256-257 R
9. Homer. I 108 20. ScTpeqpe*: dvecxpeqpc 25.
aOed6£iav] Plat. £p. IV. p. 321 B
AB AMICO INTERNOSCATUR 159
dpicTOic KOC|ur|cac CiKeXiav 'euKXea Gricei' ifiv 'AKa- briiaeiav. Guktoc be Kai euXaioc, ^Taipoi rTepceuuc, euTuxoOvTi juev dei Trpoc xdpiv ojuiXouvTec Kai cuve- TTiveuovTec ujcrrep oi Xoittoi TrapriKoXou9ouv ' eTrei 5e
5 Ta))Liaioic cu|LipaXujv Trepi TTubvav eTTTaice Kai eqpu-fe, TrpocTTec6vT€c eTTeTiiuuuv ttikpujc Kai dveiuiiuvricKov iLv eErmapTev f| TTopeibev, CKacTOV e2oveibi2ovTec, ctxpi ou biaXYricac 6 dv6pujTT0C utto XuTrric Ktti opYnc a\i- B q)OTepouc tlu HicpibiLu TTaiujv dveiXev.
10 30. '0 )biev oijv koivoc outuj upoopic9uj Kaipoc* ouc be TTapexouciv auTOi TToXXdKic ou XP^ TTpoiec6ai Tov Kribojievov qpiXujv dXXd xpiic6ar Kai Ydp epuuTTi- cic evioic Kai biriTricic xai n/ofoc djuoiujv eq)' ^Tepoic f| eTTaivoc ujCTTep Ivbdci^ov eic TTappriciav ecTiv.
15 oiov eX6eiv ArmdpaTOV eic MaKcboviav ck Kopiv6ou XeTOUCi Ka6' 6v xpovov ev biaqpopa TTpoc Tfjv TuvaiKa Kai Tov uiov 6 OiXmTTOC fiv' dcTTacajuevou b' auTov Tou 0iXiTTTTOu Kai TTu6o|aevou TTUJc upoc dXXr|Xouc Ixouciv 6|Liovoiac oi "QXrivec, eiTTeiv tov ATmdpaTov c
20 euvouv 6vTa Kai cuvri6n ' Trdvu toOv uJ OiXiTTTre Ka- Xov ecTi coi TTUv6dvec6ai luev rrepi Tf^c 'A^rjvaiujv Kai TTeXoTTovvTiciujv ojuocppocuvTic , Tfiv b' oiKiav Trepiopav Tf^v ceauToO TOcauTiic CTdceujc Kai bixovoiac •feVo^- cav'. eu be Kai AiOTevnc, 6c eTrei TTapeX6d)v eic t6
25 ToO 0iXiTTTTOu cTpaTOTTebov, Stc TOic "€XXticiv epdbiZ;e jaaxoujuevoc, dvf|x6ri Trpoc auTOV, 6 b' dYVOUJv tiptu- Tricev ei KaTdcKorroc ecTi, 'TTdvu yikv ouv' eqpri ^Ka- TttCKOTTOC ui <l)iXiTTTTe THC d^ouXiac cou Kai Tfic dvoiac, bi' riv oubevoc dvaTKdZiovTOC epxri TTepi Tfic
1 , 225—226 H. 6, 257—259 B.
1. €V)K\ea ef|C€i] Eurip. Phoen. 1732 12. qpiXujv Reis-
kius: qptXov 29. Tfic*
160 QUOMODO ADULATOR
DPaciXetttc Kttl ToO cu))iaTOC ujpa mfi biaKuPeOcujv ' ToOto yii\i ouv ictuc cqpobpoTcpov, (31) ^Tcpoc bk m\- p6c dcTi vouOcciac 6Tav utt' aWiwv Xoibopr)9^vT€c i(p' olc d|LiapT(ivouci TaTreivoi T^vuivTai jcat cucTaXuiciv. iL XPMJTO fiv ^maeXiiJc 6 xcip»€ic touc m^v XoibopoOv- & Tac dvaK^TTTujv Kai biaKpouojievoc, tbia b* auTdc
dTTT^JiCVOC TOO q>{\OV Kai UTTO)ilMVnCKU>V djc cl bid
ixt]bkv fiXXo TTpoccKT^ov auTui , 6ttu)c y€ m^I Qpaceic luciv o\ dxOpoi. ' ttoO Ydp Icti toutoic Td CTd/ia bia- pai, Ti bi TTpoceiTTcTv, fiv d(pr|c ToOTa Ka\ |S(v|>r|C d<p' «
E oTc KaKouc dKoueic ' ; riTveTai ydp outuic t6 m^v Xu« TTtipov ToO XoibopoOvToc, t6 b' wqp^XiMOV toO vou- GeToOvTOc. ^vioi bk KomvdTcpov, fiXXouc vp^TOVTec, ^mcTp^qpouci touc cuvnGeic • KaTritopoOci ^dp ^T^pwv S TtpdTTOvTac ^Keivouc icaciv. 6 b' fijieTepoc Ka6ri- *' TtlTi^c 'Ammujvioc dv beiXivrj biaTpipr| tujv TVUJpfMwv rivdc alcGdjievoc t^picTriK^Tac oux dTTXoOv fipicrov ^KAeucev Ibiuj Traibl TTXriTdc dnPaXeiv t6v dTTeXeu- Gepov, ^TTeiTTibv 6ti x^^Pic 6Eouc dpicTdv ou buva- Tai. Ka\ &Ma TTp6c f|Mdc dTT^pXeipev, &ct€ tOuv iv6- «g Xujv fiiiJac6ai Tf)v ^rriTiMriciv.
32. "Cti Toivuv euXapTiT^ov kT\v iv ttoXXoic Trappriciq xpnc^ai rrpdc qpiXov, ^veu)iOU)i£vov t6 toO
F nxdTujvoc. dTTei Tdp 6 CujKpdnic livijaTd tivoc tujv cuvti6ujv cqpobpdTepov ^tt\ TaTc TpaTT^Zaic biaXcTdMe- voc, *ouK fiM^ivov i^v* 6 TTXdTwv ?<pr| *lbiqi ToOTa Xe- X^x6ai*; Koi 6 CujKpdTr|C 'cu b* ouk fiM^JVOv' elTrev 'dTToincac Sv Ibiq rrpdc ^m^ toOto elTTiI^v'; TTuGoto- pou bk TpaxuTepov ^v ttoXXoTc TvujpiMUj TTpoc€V€x6^v- Toc dTTdTEac6ai t6 M€ipdKiov X^touciv, ^k toutou bk »
«M-887H. 0,S9»-Mt]
10. TTpOCEinciv] TTpO<P^p£lV KflsklU»
>-Mtl|
i
AB AMICO INTERNOSCATUR 161
|Lir|be7roTe tov TTuGaTopav auGic dXXou irapovTOC a\- Xov voueeTficai. 5eT Totp UJC vocr||uaToc ouk eurrpe- iToOc Tnc d)LiapTiac Tfjv vouGeTriciv Kai dTroKdXuipiv dTToppriTov eivai Kai juf) TTavriTupiKriv ixY\h' eTTibeiKTi- 71
5 Kiiv )unbe judpTupac Kai 9eaTdc cuvdTOucav. ou Tdp (piXiKOV dXXd coqpicTiKov dXXoTpioic eveubOKi)ueiv cq)dX|Liaci, KaXXajTTiZ;6|Lievov TTpoc touc TrapovTac, ujc- Trep 01 x€'PO"PToOvT€c ev toic GedTpoic laTpoi Trpoc dpToXapiav. dveu be Tfjc uppeuuc, fiv oubeiaia Oepa-
10 Treia TTpoceivai biKaiov ecTi , Kai t6 Tfic KaKiac CKe- TTTeov qpiXdviKov Kai au6abec. ou Tdp dTrXuJc 'vou- 9eTOU)aevoc ^pujc )LidXXov TrieZei ' k^t' Eupmibriv, dXX* dv vouBeTfi Tic ev rroXXoTc Kai }xr] (peibdjuevoc, Trav B vocriiua Kai Trdv rrdeoc eic t6 dvaicxuvTOv Ka9icTriciv.
15 ujcTTep ouv 6 TTXdTUJV touc TrapacKeudZiovTac ev toTc veoic aicxuvnv Te'povTac auTOuc dSioT ttpujtov aicxu- vec9ai touc veouc, outuj tujv (piXujv r\ bucujTrou|uevr| TTappricia bucojTreT iudXicTa, Kai t6 )ueT' euXapeiac dTpe)ua TTpocievai Kai &TTTec9ai toO d)uapTdvovToc
20 uTTepeiTrei Kai biepTdZieTai Tfiv KttKiav dvaTTijUTTXaue- vrjv Tou aibeTc9ai t6 aiboujuevov. 69ev dpiCTa |uev exei t6
'dTXi cxujv KecpaXnv, iva )ufi TT€ueoia9' 01 dXXoi', tiKiCTa be TTpe'TTei Ta^eTfic dKOuoucric dvbpa Kai TTai- c
25 bujv ev ovpei TraTepa Kai epacTfjV epuj)uevou TrapovToc f\ Tvujpi|uujv bibdcKaXov dTTOKaXuTTTeiv • eHicTavTai Tdp utt6 XuTTric Kai 6pTfic eXeTx6|uevoi Trap' oic eubOKi- lueTv dHioOciv. oifiai bk Koii KXeTTOC oux outuj Trapuj- Suve bid t6v oTvov, ujc oti TroXXuJv TrapovTUJV eboKei
1, 227-229H. 6, 261— 262 E.
12. €upiTri6nv] Nauck. p. 449 15. TTXdTUJv] Legg.
p. 729C 22. Homer. a 157 28. TTapiuEuve*: TrapoSOvai Plutarchi Moralia. Vol. I. 11
162 QUOMODO ADULATOE
KoXoueiv "AXeHavbpov. Kai 'ApicTO|U€vric 6 TTToXe- ILiaiou KttGriYnTnc oti vucTdZiovTa Trpecpeiac TrapoucTic eTrotTaHev ^SeTeipuuv, Xa^riv Tiva Trapecxe toic KoXaHi, 7TpocTroiou)Lievoic dTavaKTeiv UTrep toO paciXeuuc Kai D XeYouciv * ei TOcauTa kottiujv Kai dYpuTTViJuv KaTrive- 5 XQnc, ibiot c€ vouGeTeiv ujqieXev, ouk evavTiov dv-
GpUUTTUJV TOCOUTUUV TTpOC9€'p€lV TttC X£IP«C'. 6 b€
qpapiadKOu KuXiKa -nifjL^tac ^KeXeucev eKTTieiv tov dv- GpuuTTOv. 'ApicToqpdvrjc be Kai tov KXeuuva toOt* €T- KaXeTv (priciv oti lo
'Hevuuv TTapovTuuv Triv ttoXiv KaKuuc XeYei'
Ktti TTapoHuvei touc 'AGrivaiouc. bio bei (puXdTTecGai Ktti toOto iiieTd Tuuv dXXuuv touc jun TrapeTTibeiKVUcGai \xr\bk bTiiLiaYuuYeiv dXX' ovriciqpopuuc Kai GepaTreuTiKuuc XpncGai Tfi TToppricia pouXo|ae'vouc. Kai juriv oKcp 6 is
E GouKubibrjC Touc KopivGiouc XeYOVTac Trepi auTuuv tt€- TTOiriKev, ujc*dHio{' eiciv eTepoic '^TreveYKeTv lyoYOv', ou KaKuuc eipr|)ue'vov, ebei TrapeTvai toTc TrapprictaZo- laevoic. Aucavbpoc iuev Ydp u)c ?oik€ Trpoc tov ^k MeYdpuuv Iv toTc cujajudxoic TTappriciaZdiaevov uTTep 20 TTic '€XXdboc ^qpri Touc Xoyouc auToO TToXeuuc beTcGar Trappricia bk TravTOC dvbpoc fiGouc icuuc beTTai, Kai toOt' dXriGecTaTOv dcTiv eTTi tuuv ^Te'pouc vouGeTouv- Tuuv Ktti cuuqppoviZ;6vTuuv XeYojuevov. 6 youv TTXdTuuv eXeY€ vouGeTeTv tuj piiu tov CTreucmKOV, uicTrep djue'- 25 Xei Kai TToXe^jauJva EevoKpdTric dqpGeic juovov ev Tfj
F bittTpipr) Kai dTropXe'ipac TTpoc auTov dTpeipaTO Kai jueTeGriKev. IXaqppoO be Kai qpauXou 10 fjGoc dv-
1, 229— 230H. 6, 262— 264R
6. tJjqpeXev*: 6q)ei\o|uev 13. touc W: Td 16.
GouKubi6r]c] I 70
AB AMICO INTERNOSCATUR 163
GpuuTTou \6fUJ Trappriciac dTTTO|aevLU TrdpecTi Trpoc- qcai t6
'dXXuuv laTpoc auTOC eXKeciv ppuaiv'. 33. Ou }Jir]v dXX' dTrei qpauXouc te ovTac auTOuc 5 ^Tcpoic Te TOiouToic ojaiXouvTac eEdYei Td TTpdYMaTa TToXXdKic eic t6 vouGeTeTv, eTTieiKecTaTOC av ein Tp6- TTOc 6 cuveiuTTXeKUJV Kai cu)aTrepiXa|updvuuv diaTTfeTTn Tuj eYKXriiaaTi tov TTappriciaZ:6)nevov • ecp' tl» XeXeKTai Kai t6 10 'Tubeibri, ti Tra96vTe XeXdc|aeGa Ooupiboc dXKnc;' KOi t6 '2
'vuv 5' oub' ^voc dHioi eiMev
"€KTOpOC'.
Kai 6 CuiKpdTric outujc dTpe')aa touc veouc fiXe-fxev,
15 ujc iurib' auToc dTTriXXaY|ae'voc d|aa0iac, dXXd laeT'
iKeivujv oidjuevoc beiv dpeTfic eTTijaeXec0ai Kai Z^riTeiv
To dXriGe'c. Kai ^dp euvoiav Kai ttictiv exouciv oi
TauTd |Liev d|aapTdveiv, eTravopGoGcGai be touc q)iXouc
ujCTTep auTOuc boKoOvTec. 6 be ceiavuvujv eauTov ev
20 TU) KoXoOeiv eTepov, ujc br| tic eiXiKpivfic Kai dTTa-
Gr|c, Sv |Lif| noXu KaG' fiXmiav ^ irporiKUJv jLiri^' ^Xiwv
dpeTTic ojaoXoYOUjaevov dHiujjaa Kai b6Hr|c, eTTaxGfjC
qpaveic Kai papuc oubev ujqpeXricev. 6Gev oux dTrXujc B
6 OoiviH IvepaXe Td uepi auTOV dTuxniaaTa, bi' 6p-
25 Ynv iTTixeipncavTOC dveXeiv tov rraTepa Kai Taxu \xe-
TOYVdvTOC,
'ujc }Jir] TraTpo(p6voc |a€T' 'Axaioiciv KaXeoijiinv', ha jaf) ^OKX] vouGeTeiv ^Keivov ujc auToc drraGnc u)V
1, 230-231H. 6, 264-266B.
1. TTdpecTi TTpocacai ('occinere' interpres)*: Trepiecxi irpoc- aKoOcai 3. Nauck. p. 545 27. Homer. I 461
11*
164 QUOMODO ADULATOR
utt' opTnc Ktti dvajudpTriTOc. evbueiai fap iieiKwc id TOiaOTa, Kai iuaXXov eiKouci toic 6)aoiOTTa9eTv dXXd [ir\ TTepicppoveTv boKOuciv. enei b' ouTe qpujc Xa|a- npov ojujLiaTi qpXeYMOiivovTi TTpocoiCTeov, out' e)UTTa9fic HJuxf) TTappriciav dvabe'xeTai Kal vou9eciav otKpaTov, 5 C ev Toic xPnci|uujrdTOic ecfi xujv Por|9ri|udTUJv 6 Trapa- |LiiYVU|uevoc eXacppoc eTTaivoc, ujcrrep ev toutoic 'ujueTc b' ouKeTi KaXd |ue9ieTe 9oupiboc dXKfic TTdvTec dpicToi eovTec dvd cTpaTov. oub* av
eYujYe 10
dvbpi |uaxeccai|uriv octic TToXejioio |ue9eir| XuYPoc eujv ujuTv be vejueccCujuai rrepi Kfipr Kai
TTdvbape, ttoO toi toHov ibe TTTepoevTec 6icToi Kai KXe'oc, il) ou Tic toi epiCeTai ev9dbe y' dvfip ;' 15 ccpobpa b' ejuqpavujc dvaKaXeTTai Kai Td ToiaOTa toOc uTToqpepojuevouc
'6 b' OlbiTTOuc TToO Kai Td KXeiv' aiviYjuaTa;' Ktti
'6 TToXXd bf| TXdc 'HpaKXfic XeYei Tdbe;' «(
D oO Ydp juovov dvirici toO ijjoyou t6 Tpaxu Kai KeXeu- CTiKov, dXXd Kai lr\Kov ejuTTOieT Trpoc eauT6v aibOu- juevuj Td aicxpd t^ tOjv KaXuuv uTTO)uvf|cei Kai TTapd- beiYJLia TTOioujuevLu tuuv peXTiovuJV dauTOV. OTav b' CTepouc oiov nXiKac fj TToXiTac f| cuYY^veTc rrapapd- 25 Xujjuev, dx9eTai Kai biaYpiaiveTai t6 qpiXoviKov Tfjc KaKiac, Kai toOto TroXXdKic eiuj9€v UTToqpujveTv juct' opYflc 'Ti oijv ouK drrei TTp6c touc ejuoO KpeiTTovac,
1,23 1—23-2 H. 6, 266—267 K,
8. Hom. N 116 14. Id. € 171 18. Eurip. Phoen.
168 20. Id. Herc. f. 1250
AB AMICO INTERNOSCATUR 165
e|Lioi be pix] 7Tape'x€ic TTpdTMCtTa;' qpuXaKieov ouv t6 iTcpouc eiraiveTv TrappriciaZio^evov irpoc eTe'pouc, av |Lif] VY\ Aia YOveTc uiciv. yic 'ATa|ae'|Livujv
'fi oXiTov 01 TraTba eoiKOTa T^ivaTO Tubeuc', E 5 Kai 6 ev ToTc CKupioic 'Obucceuc
'cu b', il) t6 Xa|aTrp6v q)ujc Kaiaicxuvujv tevouc, Eaiveic, dpicTOu TTaTp6c 'GXXrivujv tctwc;'
34. "HKiCTa hk TTpocr|K€i vou0eTOU|Lievov dvTivou- OeTeTv Kai Trappricia TTapprjciav dvTeKcpepeiv • Taxu Tdp
10 eKKdei Ktti TTOieT biaqpopdv, Kai oXwc ouk dvTiTrap- priciaZo)ae'vou boEeiev dv dXXd TTappr^ciav |ufi (pe'pov- Toc 6 TOiouTOC uj9ic|u6c eivai. peXTiov ouv uTTOiue- F veiv t6v vou0€TeTv boKOuvTa qpiXov dv Tdp ucTcpov auT6c djaapTdvri Kai be'riTai vou0eciac, auT6 toOto ti^
15 TTappricia Tporrov Tivd Trapprjciav bibujciv. UTT0|ui)iivri- CKOiaevoc Tdp dveu livriciKaKiac oti touc qpiXouc Kai auT6c eiuu0ei jufi nepiopdv d|uapTdvovTac dXX' eHeXeT- Xeiv Kai bibdcKeiv, judXXov evbuucei Kai TrapabeSeTai Triv eTTav6p0ujciv , ujc oucav euvoiac Kai x«piT0c oO
'^o )Lie'|Luyeujc dvTarrobociv oub' opTric.
35. "€ti Toivuv 6 juev OouKubibric (priciv 'octic 73 ^TTi MeTiCTOic to eTTiq)0ovov Xa|updvei, 6p0uJc pou- XeueTai'* tuj bk cpiXuj TrpocfiKei t6 €k toO vou0eTeTv eTTax0ec uTrep fieTdXuJv dvab€'x€c0ai Kai cqpdbpa bia-
25 qpepovTUJv. Sv b' eTri naci Kai Trp6c TrdvTa bucKo- Xaivr] Kai jufi (piXiKuJc dXXd TraibaTUJTiKUJc rrpoccpe- priTai ToTc cuvfi0eciv, d)apXuc ev toTc lueTicTOic vou- 0eTujv ^'cTai Ktti dTTpaKTOc, ujcrrep iaTp6c bpijau laev
1, 232— 234 H. 6, 2G7— 270B.
1. t6 Reiskius 4. Homer. € 800 6. Nauck.
p. 653 21. 0ouKu6i6r]c] II 64
166 QUOMODO ADULATOR
(pdpiuaKOv f| TTiKpov dvaYKttTov be Kai iroXuTeXec eic B TToXXot Kai |iiKpd Kai ouk dvaYKaia bieXiLv Tri Ttap- pricia KaTaKexpriiuevoc. auToc |uev ouv cqpobpa qpu- XdHeTai t6 cuvexec toO (piXaiTiou* dTepou be laiKpo- XoYou|uevou Trapd TidvTa Kai TtapacuKOcpavToOvToc 5 ujCTTep evbocijuov eEei Trpoc Td jueiZiova tuuv djuapTri- judTuuv. Kai Ydp laTpoc OiXotijuoc eiuTTuou t6 fiTTap dvGpuuTTOu beiHavTOC auTuj tov bdKTuXov fiXKUJjue'vov 'ouK ecTi coi' emev 'uj 'Tav Trepi rrapujvuxiac 6 X6- Yoc'. ouKoOv Kai tlu cpiXuj bibujciv 6 Kaip6c eiTreiv lo TTpoc t6v eTTi luiKpoTc Kai |uribev6c dHioic cYKaXoOvTa 'Ti Traibidc Kai ttotouc Kai qpXudpouc XeYO)uev; outoc, u) 'Tdv, dTT0Tre)uipdc6(ju Tf]V eTaipav y\ iraucdcGuj ku- Peuujv, Kai Td dXXa eau]uacT6c fiiuTv dv9pu)Troc ecTai'. C 6 Ydp eic Td jLiiKpd cuYYVuujuriv Xapdiv ouk dnbijuc eic i5 Td fjeiZiova tiu cpiXuj Trappriciav bibujciv 6 b' eYKei- luevoc dei Kai TravTaxoO ttikpoc Kai dTepnfic Kai TrdvTa YiYvuucKUJV Kai TToXuTrpaYjuovuJv oube naiciv dveKTdc o^b' dbeXcpoTc, dXXd Kai bouXoic dcpopriTOC.
36. '€Trei b' ouTe tuj fr\pa udvTa TTpocecTi KaKd 20 KaT' Gupmibriv ouTe Tr) tOuv cpiXuiv dpeXTepia, beT |ufi )u6vov djuapTdvovTac dXXd Kai KaTop6o0vTac eTriTn- peTv Touc cpiXouc, Kai \r\ Aia TTpo6u)uujc erraiveTv t6 TTpiJUTOV ei6' ujcTTep 6 cibripoc TruKVoOTai Trj Trepi- D vpuEei Kai bexcTai Tfiv cto^uujciv dve6eic TrpuuTov utt6 25 6ep|u6TriT0c Kai |uaXaK6c Yev6)uevoc, outuj toTc qjiXoic biaKexu|uevoic Kai 6ep)ioTc ouciv utt6 tuuv eTraivuuv ujCTTep pa^nv dTpef^a Tfjv Trappriciav eTrdYeiv. bibujci Ydp 6 Kaip6c eirreTv "^fip' dHiov CKeTva toutoic Trapa-
1, 234— 235 H. 6, 270—271 B.
4. ToO qpiXaiTiou Reiskius: Kai qpiXaiTiov 14. ^cxai*:
kTiv 21. 6upnTi6r)v] Phoen. 532
AB AMICO INTERNOSCATUR 167
PaXXeiv; opoic t6 KaXov oiouc Kaptrouc otTTobibuJCi; xauTa dTTaiToujaev oi qpiXoi, TaOT' ecTiv oiKeia, Trpoc TaOTa TTecpuKac" eKeiva b' dTTobioTTO)iiTTriTeov
*eic opoc f\ ec KO|Lia TToXucpXokpoio 9aXdccr|C*.
^ ibc ydp laTpoc euTvuO|ua)v pouXoiT' dv uttvlu Kai Tpo- cpri judXXov f| KacTopiiu Kai cKaiuujviLU t6 v6cr||iia XOcai ToO Kd|LivovTOC, ouTO) Kai cpiXoc eTTieiKric Kai rraTfip XPncT6c Kai bibdcKaXoc eTraivLu ludXXov fi vpoYUJ xctip^i E TTpoc eTTav6p0(Juciv fi9ouc xP^I^£voc. oubev ydp dXXo
10 TTOieT t6v TTappriciaZojuevov fiKiCTa XuTreiv Kai judXicTa 9epaTreueiv r\ t6 (peib6|uevov opYfjc ev fj9ei Kai )ueT' euvoiac TTpoc(pepec9ai toTc djuapTdvouciv. 69ev out' dpvoujuevouc bei TTiKpuic eHeXeYxeiv ouTe KwXueiv dTTo- XoTOUjuevouc, dXXd Kai TTpoqpdceic eucxr||uovac djuiuc-
15 Ye'TTUJC cuveKTTOpi^eiv Kai Tf^c xeipovoc akiac dqpiCTa- luevoic auT6v evbibovai |ueTpiujTepav , luc 6 "€ktujp 'baijuovr, ou luev KaXd xoXov Tovb' ev9eo 9uiuuj' TTp6c t6v dbeXqpdv, ujc ouk dTrobpaciv oube beiXiav F oucav dXX' opxfiv Trjv eK ttic judxnc dvaxtupr|civ au-
20 ToO. Kai TTp6c t6v 'AYajuejuvova 6 NecTUjp 'cu be cuj |ueTCxXr|TOpi 9u|uuj eiEac'.
ri9iKU)Tepov tdp oT,uai toO 'r|biKr|cac' Kai ' ticxri)u6vri- cac' t6 'ouk eTTecTricac' Kai ' iiYVOTicac ', Kai t6 '|ufi 25 qpiXoveiKei TTp6c t6v dbeXqp6v' fi t6 '|ufi. qp96vei tuj dbeXqpuJ', Kai t6 'qpuYe ttiv Y^vaTKa biaqp9eipoucav ' 74 fl t6 ' TTaOcai Tfiv Y^vaTKa biaqp^eipujv '. toioOtov Ydp
1, 235— 237 H. 6, 271— 273 E.
4. Homer. Z 347 15. dqpiCTaju^voic Hauptius: dtqpiCTO-
ixivovc 17. Homer. Z 326 21. Id. I 109 24. t6
ouK Rciskius: Kai ouk koI riYvoricac W: toO riYVoricac
168 QUOMODO ADtJLATOR
fi eepaTTeuTiKfi rrappricia lr]jei xpoTTOV, f] bk TtXriKTiK?) Tov evavTiov. oTav Ydp f| iueXXovTac djuapTdveiv ck- KpoOcai beticri ii TTpoc 6pjur|v Tiva piaiov laeGiCTaiue- vouc eH evavTiac cpepoiuevriv ** f| TTpoc Td KaXd m»- XaKuJc Kai dTTpo6u|aiuc exovTac ^VTeTvai Kai Txapop}JLf\- 5 cai 6e\r|ciJujLiev, eic aiTiac bei TTepiqpepeiv dTOTTouc Kai )iiri TTpeTTOucac t6 YiTv6)Ltevov. luc 6 Trapd CoqpOKXei Tov 'AxiXXea TTapoSuvuuv 'Obucceuc ou tpriciv opyile- c6ai bid t6 beiTTVOv, dXX' B 'fjbri' cprici *Td Tpoiac eicopuuv ^biuXia lo.
beboiKac',
Kai rrp6c TaOTa TrdXiv tou 'AxiXXeuuc biaYavaKToOvTOC
Kttl dTTOTTXeiV Xe'YOVT0C
'eYUJb' o cpeuYeic, ou to jaf) KXueiv KaKUJC, dXX' eYYuc "Gktuup ecTi* ou |ae'veiv KaXov'. is
tov Mev oi5v 6ujLioeibfi Kai dvbpuubr) beiXiac boHr), tov be ctuqppova Kai k6c|uiov dKoXaciac, t6v b' eXeu6€piov Kai laeYaXoTTpeTTfi juiKpoXoYiac Kai q)iXapYupiac bebiT- T6)Lievoi TTapopjuiuci TTp6c Td KaXd Kai tuuv aicxpujv dTteXauvouci, iueTpioi iiiev ev toTc dvriKecToic iRralo- 20 C juevoi Kai to XuTTOujuevov Kai to cuvaXYoOv ttXcov ev Tiu TTappTicidZ;€c6ai toO ipe^YovToc exovTec, iv be TaTc KuuXuceci Tiuv d)uapTavo)i6Vuuv Kai Trp6c Td TTd6ri bia- judxaic cqpobpoi Kai dTrapaiTriToi Kai cuvexeTc ovTec ouToc Ydp 6 Kaip6c euvoiac d6puTTT0u Kai TTappnciac 25 dXr|6ivfic ecTi. tu» be ipe'Y€iv Td TTpax6evTa Kai touc ^X^pouc KaT' dXXfjXujv 6puj)uev xpwjuevouc, OucTTep AioYevric eXeYev oti tuj )ueXXovTi CLuZ;ec6ai beT qpiXouc
1,237— 238H. 6, 273— 275 B.
1. TrXriKTiKi^ * : irpaKTiKi^ 3. |ue0icTaM^vouc * : icra-
ILidvouc 4. Hiatum significavi. Infinitivum deesse vidit
Eeiskius 10. Nauck. p. 129
AB AMICO INTERNOSCATUE 169
dTaGoiJC f\ biaTTupouc ex^PO^LJc uTrdpxeiv o*i jLiev ydp bibdcKOuciv, o'i b' eXeTXOucri. peXxiov be rdc d)Liap- Tiac (pu\dTT€c0ai toic cujupouXeuouci TTei96|uevov r\ laeTavoeiv djuapTovTa bid touc KaKoic Xe'TOVTac, KaiD
5 bid TOUTO bei Kai Tiepi ttiv TTappriciav cpiXoTexveiv, ocLu )Lie'TiCT0V Kttl KpdTiCTOV ecTiv ev qpiXia (pdpjuaKOV, eucTOXiac Te KaipoO ^dXicTa Kai Kpdceiuc lacTpov exou- cr|c dei beo)Lievr|.
37. '€TTei Toivuv, uicTTep eiprjTai, TToXXdKic f]
10 TTapprjcia tuj Geparreuoiuevu) Xurrripd ■necpme , bei fii- lueicGai touc laTpouc* ouTe Tdp eKeivoi Te'|uvovT6c ev Tuj TTOveiv Ktti dXTeiv KaTaXeiTTOuci t6 TreTToveoc, dXX' evePpeEav TTpocrivujc Kai KaTriovricav , ou6' oi vouGe- TOuvTec dcTeiujc t6 ttikpov Kai briKTiK6v TTpocpaXovTec
15 dTroTpe'xouciv , dXX' 6|uiXiaic CTepaic Kai XoTOic cTriei- Keciv eKTTpauvouci Kai biaxeouciv, ujCTTep oi X160H601E Td TrXriTevTa Kai TrepiKOTrevTa twv dTaXjudTUJV eTTi- XeaivovTec Kai T«vouvTec. 6 be TrXriTeic juev Tr) TTap- prjcia Kai xapax6eic, d(pe6eic be Tpaxuc Kai oibujv Kai
20 dvujjuaXoc urr' opTiic bucavdKXriTOC aij6ic ecTi Kai bucTrapriTopTiTOC. bio Kai touto bei TrapaqpuXdTTeiv ev Toic ludXiCTa touc vou6eTo0vTac Kai ^r\ TrpoaTTO- XeiTTeiv, lurjbe TT0ieic6ai Trepac 6)uiXiac Kai cuvouciac t6 XuttoOv Kai TTapoSuvov touc cuvr|6€ic.
1, 238—239 H. 6, 275— 276E.
75 Hi^ AN TK
AIZ0OITO EATTOT nP0K0nT0NT02 EH' APETHi.
B 1. Tic TuJv XoTuiv, d» Coccie CevcKiujv, cujcei ttiv auToO ^XTioujievou Tipoc dpeTriv cuvaicOticiv , ei ^r\- benictv ai TrpoKOTrai iroiouci Tfjc dqppocuvric fiveciv, dXX* Tciu CTaejiif» rrfiav f] KOKia rrepmSenevri
'no^u^bic uicTe biKTuov KaT^crracev ' ; 6
oub^ Tdp Iv ^ouciKOic Tic f) Ypan^ttTiKOic embibouc 6v TVoiT] nr\bev ev Tip ^avGdveiv dnapuTiuv ttic rrepi TaOTa d^aGiac dXX' Tcric dei Tfic dTexviac auTu» Trap- ouCTic oube Kd^ivovii eeparreia ^ifj rroioOca ^octuj- v?]V ^iTi^ Kouqpic^ov d^iwcfeTrwc toO vocrmaTOc urrei- lo KOVTOC Kai xctXujVTOc aicericiv av Trapexoi biaqpopdc, C TTpiv eiXiKpivfi Tf|v dvavTiav eEiv ^tT€ veceai TravTd- rraciv dvappwceevTOC toO ciu^aTOC. dXX' uicTrep i\ TouTOic ou TrpoKOTrrouctv , dv TrpOKOTrrovTec dvecei ToO papuvovToc oiov ^iri ZutoO rrpoc TOuvavTiov is
1, 2M-M1H. 6, rn~ 878R.
4. nepmO^nivi] Emperitu: irepiOen^vr) 6. Nauck.
p. 247
J
m VIRTUTE SENTIAT PROFECTUS 171
dvacpep6|Li€voi }jly\ yiTvuuckuuci ifjv |H€TapoXriv, oOtuuc ev To) qpiXococpeTv ouTe TTpOKOTrfiv ouTe Tiva irpoKo- Knc aic9nciv uTroXrirrTeov, ei |ur|bev n vpuxn (aeGirici nr]h' dTTOKaGaipeTai Tnc dpeXTepiac, dxpi be toO Xa-
5 peTv t6 dKpov dTa96v Kai TeXeiov dKpdTLu tuj KttKUj XpfiTai. Kai xdp ev dKapeT xpovou Kai oipac ck Tf|cD ujc evi ludXiCTa qpauXoTriTOC eic ouk l'xoucav urrep- poXfiv dpeTfjc bid9eciv i^eTapdXoi dv 6 coqpoc, ei fjc oub' ev XPOVLu TToXXuj |ae'poc dcpeTXe KaKiac d|Lia rracav
10 eEaicpvric dKTTeqpeufe. KaiTOi fibri touc TaOTd ye Xe- TOVTac oic9a bfiTTOu TrdXiv TToXXd TrapexovTac auToTc TTpdTMaTa Kai laeTdXac drTopiac Trepi toO biaXeXri96- Toc, oc auT6c dauT6v oubeTTuu KaTeiXriqpe t€Tovujc co- (poc, dXX' dTVoeT Kai djnqpiboHeT tuj KaTd |LiiKp6v ev
15 xpovuj TToXXuj Td |Liev dqpaipoOvTi Td be TrpocTi9evT^ TiTVOiaevnv thv eTTibociv Ka^drrep TTopeiav Tfl dpeTfi Xa9eTv dTpe'|aa TTpoc|aiEacav. el be' t' eiH Tdxoc to- coOtov Tfjc )Li€TapoXfic Kai |Lie'Te9oc, ujct€ t6v TrpLij E KdKicTov ecTrepac TGTOvevai KpdTicTOV, f| dv outuj
20 Tivi cuvTuxri Td Tfic laeTapoXfic, KaTabap96vTa qpaO- Xov dveTpec9ai cocp6v Kai TrpoceineTv ^k Tfic ipuxfic He^eiKOTa Tdc xQiZidc dpeXTepiac Kai drrdTac
'HJeubeTc Sveipoi, x«ip€T'" oub^v fjT* dpa*, Tic av dTVofjceiev auToO biaqpopdv ev auTuj TOcauTrjv
25 Tevojuevriv Kai qppovriciv d9p6ov eKXdjUMJacav; ^iuoi |Liev Tdp boKei inaXXov fiv tic, ujc 6 Kaiveuc, tcvo- liievoc KaT' euxnv dvfip ^k TuvaiK6c dTvoficai Tfjv iue- TttKOciLiriciv, fi cuuqppujv Kai qppovijuoc Kai dvbpeToc ck
1, 241— 242 H. 6, 278-280B.
6. dv Xylauder 8. el Madvigius 17. t' ein*= TC
r^v 20. KaTa6ap96vTa W: KaTabapOevxa 23. Eurip.
Iph. T. 569 24. Sv Emperius
172 QUOMODO QUIS SUOS
FbeiXoO Kai dvoriTou Kai dKpaToGc dTTOTeXecGek Kai laeTapaXiuv eic Setov Ik. Gripiiubouc Piov dKapn biaXa- 9eTv auTov.
2. 'AXX' 6p6ujc )Liev eipriTai t6
'trpoc CTd0)Liri "s
TTeTpov Ti0ec6ai, iun ti Tipoc TreTpuj CTd0jariv'. 01 be jLtn Ti6e'|aevoi Td b^YMaTa Trpoc toic irpdTliaciv dXXd Td TrpdYMaTa Trpoc TaTc dauToiv uTro6ececiv, ojnoXoTeTv fifi TtecpuKOTa KaTapiaZ!6|Lievoi ttoXXwv dTTO- 76 piujv e)LiTTeTTXr|Kaci thv qpiXocoqpiav , laeYicTric be t^c lo eic |uiav ojaou KaKiav TTdvTac dv0puOTTOUc TTXfiv evoc ToO TeXeiou Ti0ejaevric, uqp' fjc aiviTMa TCTOvev f) Xe- TO^evTi TTpoKOTTri, iniKpov dTToXeitTOuca ecxdTric dqppo- cuvTic , Touc be nn TrdvTUJV djua TTa6a)V Kai vocriiLidTUDV dqpei|ae'vouc ijtt* auTfic eTi toTc fiTibevoc dTTriXXaTjue- is voic TU)v KaKicTUJV ojuoiujc TTape'xouca KaKobaijaovoOv- Tac oijToi |Liev oijv dauTouc eXeTXOuciv, ev jaev TaTc cxoXaTc icnv dbiKiav Tfjv 'ApiCTeibou Tr^ OaXdpiboc Ti6ejLievoi, Kai beiXiav TfjV Bpacibou Trj A6Xujvoc, Kai Bvfi Aia TfjC MeXf|TOU jarib' 6tiouv Tfiv TTXdTUJVoczo dTVU)|Liocuvriv biaqpepoucav , ev be tlIj piuj Kai toTc TTpdTjLiaciv eKeivouc juev eKTpeTT6jLievoi Kai qpeuTOVTec ibc djLieiXiKTOuc, toutoic b' ujc dHioic ttoXXoO Td jue- TiCTa Kai xpiw|Lievoi Kai TTicTeuovTec.
3. 'HjueTc be TTavTi Ttvei KaKoO, ladXiCTa be tuj ^^ TTepi HJUxnv dTdKTUJ Kai dopicTUj t6 ladXXov Kai fiTTOV eTTiTv6)aevov opujvTec (x} Kai bia(pe'pouciv ai ttpoko- TTai, Ka6dTTep CKidc dvecei Tfic |aox6ripiac toO X6tou
1,242— 243H. - 6, 280— 282 B.
5. Nauck. p. 697 8. ratc — 6Tro0^ceciv*: rac —
(iTToG^ceic 14. }xf] W
m VIRTUTE SENTIAT PROFECTUS 173
biaqpouTiZovTOc dTp^jLia ttiv Miuxfiv Kai biaKaGaipovTOc) ouK clXoTOv oi6|ae9a Trjv cuvaic9r|civ elvai Tfic jiieTa- PoXfic ujCTrep eK pu9o0 tivoc dvaqpepo/ievoic , dW exoucav emXoYic)Liouc. ujv CKOTrei tov ttpujtov eu- C
5 9uc. ei Ka^drrep oi t6 dxavec 9eovTec iCTioic TreXa- Yoc djua Tuj xpovuj Trp6c ttjv toO TrveujuaTOC pu))Lir|v dvajieTpoOvTai tov bp6|uov, ocov eiK^c ev tocoutlu TeT0v6Ti UTTO TocauTric KomZ;o|uievoic nvuc9ai buvd- laeujc, ouTUJC dv tic ev (piXococpia to evbeXexec Kai to
10 cuvexec Tfjc Ttopeiac Kai fxi\ TtoXXdc bid )iecou ttoiou- Ibievov dTTicTdceic, eiT' aij9ic 6p|udc Kai eTriTtribriceic, dXXd Xeiujc Kai 6|uaXujc toO TTp6c9ev eTriXajLipav6)Lie- vov dei Kai biiov dTTTaicTUJc bid toO Xotou TeKjuripiov ^auTUJ TTOirjcaiTO TrpoKOTrfic. to Tdp
15 'ei Tdp Kev Kai c)uiKp6v ctti c)aiKpuJ KaTa9eio Kai 9a|ud to09' epboic' ou TTp6c dpTupiou )a6vov auHr|Civ eipriTai KaXuJc, dXX'D eic dTtavTa TTOiei, ludXicTa b' eic dpcTfic eTTibociv, TToXu Kai TeXecioupTov e9oc toO Xotou TTpocXajupd-
20VOVTOC* ai b' dvuj|uaXiai Kai d)upXuTr|Tec tujv cpiXoco- cpouvTwv ou )u6vac ttoioOciv eTToxdc uJCTrep i\ bh(b Tfic TTpoKOTTfic, dXXd KOi dvaXuceic, del tuj Ttapei- KOVTi KaTd cxoXfiv Tf]c KaKiac eTriTi9efa€vr|c Kai Trp6c TouvavTiov dv9uTtoqpepoucric. touc )uev Tdp TTXavf|Tac
25 01 |ua9r]fiaTiK0i CTHpiZleiv Xe'Touci Traucajuevric Tfic eic TOU|UTTpoc9ev auTuuv TTOpeiac, ev be tuj qpiXocoq^eiv ouk l'cTi XriToucrjc bidXeiju)ua TTpoKOTTfjC oube CTripiT|u6c, dXX' dei Tivac ^xouca Kivfjceic f) q)ucic ujCTtep eTti E 2uToO peTTeiv €9eXei Kai KaTaTeivec9ai Taic peXTiociv,
1 , 243—245 H. 6, 282—284 R.
5. t6*: irpoc 7. 6cov Reiskius: tbc 15. He-
siod. 0. et D. 361
174 QUOMODO QUIS SUOS
f\ xaTc dvavTiaic Trpoc t6 xiipov otxcTai qpepoiaevri.
fiv OUV KaTOt TOV boGdVTtt XPnCjJOV 'AjLiqpiKTUOClV UTTd
ToO 6eo0 'Kippaioic TtdvT' fi)iaTa koi Tidcac vuKTac iToXejietv' ouTUj cuvibrjc ccauTov f||ie'pac Te Kai vu- KTtup dei Tr) KaKia bia|ae)aaxriMt'vov , f\ )an TToXXdKic 5 T€ TfjV qppoupdv dveiKOTa \jLx\he cuxvoic Trap' auTflc otovei KTipuKac f|&ovdc Tivac f| ^qicTuuvac f\ dcxoXiac ^Ki cTTOvbaTc TTpocbebeTMevov, eiKOTiuc fiv euGapcfic KOi TTp69u)aoc paGiCoic dTTi t6 XeiTTOMevov.
F 4. Ou ^r\v dXXd kSv fj biaXei|a)iaTa fiTvo^eva lo toO q)iXoco9eTv, Td b' ucTepa tujv TTpoTepov dbpaio- xepa Kai laaKpoTepa, criiaeTov ou q)auX6v dcTiv dKSXi- Po)ae'vric tt6vuj koi dcKf|C€i Tf^c paGu^iac* t6 b' dvav- Tiov TT0vr|p6v, ai )aeT' ou ttoXuv xpovov TToXXai Kal cuv€X€Tc dvaKOTTai, Tfic TTpo6u)aiac oiov dTTO)aapaivo- 15 laevnc. u)c Tdp n toO KaXd)aou pXdcTricic, 6p)afiv
77lXoyca TTXeicTHV dTr' dpxfic eic ^afJKoc 6)aaX6v Ka\ cuvex^c, t6 TTpuiTOv iv biacTf|)aaci laefdXoic 6Xi- fac Xa)apdvouca TTpocKpouceic Kai dvTiKOTTdc, €l6' oiov utt' dcGiaaToc dvuj bi' dc6€'v€iav dTraTOpeuouca 20 TToXXoTc dvicx€Tai Kal ttukvoTc toTc T6vaci, toO TTveu- ^aTOc TTXriTdc Kai Tp6)aouc Xa)apdvovTOC, outujc 6coi t6 TTpujTOV )a€TdXaic dKbpo^aic ^xPncctVTO TTp6c qpiXo- coqpiav, elTa TToXXd Kai cuvexfi TrpocKpouc)aaTa Ka\ biacTTdc)aaTa Xajapdvouci ^r|bev6c bia(p6pou TTp6c t6 25
B PeXTiov dTTaic6av6)aevoi , TeXeuTUJVTec dHe'Ka)aov Kai dTTTiT6p€ucav. 'Tijj b' euTe TTTepd TiTV€To' bi' dxpi-
1 , 245—246 H. 6, 884— S86 B.
2. 'A^qpiKTuociv* 6Tr6 toO GfoO Ktppaioic Boissona-
diu8: Ktppaloic un6 xoO GeoO 4. cuviiric Reiskius: cuv-
iibr\c 6. cuxvOuc Emperius: cuvexwc 27. tlu b']
Homer. T 386 cuxt*: auT€
IN VIRTUTE SENTIAT PKOFECTUS 175
Xemv qpepoiaeviu Kai biaKOTiTOVTi Tdc Trpoq)dc€ic uJCTrep oxXov eiaTTobujv ovTa pu))uri Kai TTpoeujuia Tfic dvu- ceujc. Ka9dTTep ouv IpujTOc dpxojuevou crmeiov ecTiv ou To xctipeiv Tuj KaXuj TrapovTi (toOto Ydp koivov)
5 dXXd t6 &dKV€c0ai Kai dXYeiv dTrocTTuO|uevov , outujc ciYOVTai |iiev utto cpiXocoqpiac ttoXXoi koi ccpobpa ^e cpiXoTiiuujc dvTiXa|updv€c9ai toO ^av9dv€iv boKoOciv, av b' dTTeX9ujciv utto TTpaYMdTUJV dXXujv Kai dcxoXiujv, eHeppur) t6 TTd9oc auTUJV eKeivo, Kai pabiujc qjepouciv.
10 'oTiji b* ^pujTOC bfJYMCt TraibiKUJV Trpocrj/ C
)Lt€'Tpioc |Li^v dv coi qpaveiri Kai TTpaoc ev tuj TrapeTvai Kai cu|uq)iXococpeiv • OTav b' dTT0CTTac9ri Kai x^Jupic yc- vriTai, 9€uj q)X€Y6)Li€vov Kai dbrijaovoOvTa Kai &ucko- XaivovTa Trdci TrpdYMaci Kai dcxoXiaic, MvnM';! he qji-
15 Xujv ujCTTep dXoYOC eXauveTai tt69ljj tuj TTp6c 91X0- coq)iav. ou Ydp bei toic X6yoic €uq)paiv€c9ai ixkv TTap6vTac ujcTrep toic juupoic, dTTOCTdvTac be |ufi Ir]- Teiv )uri^' dcxdXXeiv, dXXd Treivr] tivi Kai biipr) Trd9oc ojaoiov ev toTc dTTOCTrac|iioTc TrdcxovTac ex€c0ai toO
20 TrpoKdTTTOVTOC dXri9uJc, dv T€ Yd|uoc dv t€ ttXoOc dv T€ q)poupd Tic dv t€ CTpaTCia TrpocTrecoOca TroiricriD Tov xiwpiC)Li6v. ocLu Ydp TrXeov ecTi to Trpoc€iXri)a)Lie- vov Ik qjiXoco^iac, tocoutlu laaXXov IvoxXeT t6 dTro- X€iTT6)Lievov.
25 5. TOUTUJ b' 6)LIOO Tl TttUT^V CCTIV r| CUVCYYUC TO
TrpecPuTaTOv briXuj|ua TrpoKOTrfic toO 'Hci6bou, juriKe'Ti TrpocdvTr) jurib' 6p0iov dYav dXXd pabiav Kai Xeiav Ktti bi' euTreTeiac eivai ttiv 6b6v, oiov dKXeaivoMc^vriv Tfi dcKricei Kai qpujc ev tuj q^iXocoqpeTv Kai XajHTrpd- 30 TriTa TToioOcav eH dTropiac Kai TrXdvric Kai laeTaiae-
1 , 246—248 H. 6, 286—288 E.
21. qppoupd*: qpiXia 26. 'Hci6?)ou] 0. et D. 289
176 QUOMODO QUIS SUOS
Xeiojv, aic 7TpocTUYX«vouciv oi (piXocoq)oOvTec t6 TTpuuTOV, uJCTrep 01 Ynv dTToXiTTOVTec tiv icaci, iuribeTrui
Ebe KaGopiuvTec dcp' f^v TTXeouci. TTpoejaevoi Yctp Ta
■- Koivd Ktti cuvr|9n TTpiv f\ Tci peXTiova Tvwvai Kai Xa- PeTv, iv M^CLu TTepicpepovTai TToXXdKic uTTOTpeTToiaevoi. i Ka9dTTep cpaci Ce^Tiov tov TuujaaTov dcpeiKOTa Tdc dv Trj TToXei Tijidc Kai dpxdc bid cpiXococpiav , dv be tiu 9iXocoqpeTv au TrdXiv bucTTa9o0vTa Kai xpu^^Mtvov to» XoYUj xoXeTTUj t6 ttpuutov, 6XiY0u beficai KaTa^aXeTv ^auTov ^K Tivoc biripouc. Kai Trepi Aioxevouc 6|aoia k ToO CivujTTeujc iCTopoOciv dpxo|Lidvou (piXoco(peTv, tXjc 'A9Tivaioic fiv ^opTr) Kai beTTTva briiuoTeXfi Kai 9eaTpa,
F Kai cuvouciac iiieT' dXXrjXujv exoVTec dxptuvTO Kuujioic Ka\ TTavvuxiciv, 6 b' €v tivi •nuvia cuvecTieipaiui^voc dic Ka9eubr|cujv eve'TTiTTTev eic Xoyic)liouc TpeirovTac i auT6v ouK dTp^jLia Kai 9pauovTac, u)c oub' dTT6 laidc dvdYKTic elc ^iriTTOvov Kai dXXoKOTOv t^kujv Piov au- t6c uqp' ^auToO Kd9r|Tai tujv dYa9ujv dTrdvTujv icte- p»liaevoc. elTa nevTOi ixvv Tiva TTpocepTTucavTa XeYe- Tai TTepi Tdc vpixac auToO Tf)c }ialr\c dvacTpeqjec^ai, 2 t6v b' au9ic dvacp^peiv tuj qppovrjiaaTi Kai XeYeiv TTp6c ^auT6v oiov eTTmXriTTOVTa Kai KaKiZlovTa ''Ti qpijc, iZ»
78 AioYCvec; toOtov ja^v euujxeT Td cd Xei^iaaTa, cu b* 6 Y€VvaToc 6ti laf) |ae9ueic ^KeT KaTaKei/aevoc i\ aixa- XoTc Kai dv9ivoTc CTpuOjLiaciv 6bupri Kai 9priveTc ceau- a Tov; 6Tav ouv ol toioOtoi KaTacTTac|aoi YcvuuvTai |uf| TToXXdKtc, ai Te TTp6c auTOuc ^Eepeiceic Kai dvaKpou- ceic ToO cppovf||aaTOC ujCTTep ^k tpotthc TaxeTai TTapuuci Kai biaXuuuci pabiuuc t6v dXuv Kai Tf)v dbniaoviav, ^v Tivi pepaiuj beT vo|ai£eiv TfjV TTpoKOTifiv e?va». a
G. 'GTTei b' ou /advov ii auTuuv Td KaTaceiovTO
1,218— 249 H. 6, 288-2D0
IN VIRTUTE SENTIAT PHOFECTUS 177
Kai ctpeqpovTa Trpoc TOuvavTiov ilitt' dcGeveiac eTriYi- YV£Tai TOic qpiXocoqpoOciv , dXXd Kai qpiXujv cu|npouXai B laeTd CTTOubfic Kai biaqpopuuv dvTiXrjiiJeic ev YeXuuTi Kai TTaibia YiTv6|bievai KdjLtTTTOuci Kai iJaXdccouciv, eviouc
^hk mx TeXeov fjbn cpiXococpiac eHeceicav, ou q)aOXov dv Ti TTpoKOTTfic eir) criiueiov f) Trpoc TaOTa TTpaoTric ^KdcTou Kai t6 [xt] TapaTT6)uevov |Ltribe KViZ!6|uevov urro Tuuv XeY^VTUJv Kai 6vo|ua26vTiJUV fiXiKdc Tivac Iv au- XaTc paciXeuuv euriMepoOvTac r\ qpepvdc erTi Ydiuoic
10 Xa)LipdvovTac f| KttTidvTac utto TTXf|6ouc eic dYopdv ^TT* dpxf|V Tiva r| cuvrjYopiav. 6 Ydp dv^KTTXriKTOc iv TouTOic Kai dTeYKTOC fibri bfjXoc ecTiv €iXri)U)Lievoc fiv Trpocf|Kei XapfjV urro qpiXocoqpiac. ou Ydp oTov t6 C TTaucacBai ZiriXoOvTac aTrep oi ttoXXoi 6au|LidZ:ouciv,
15 olc dv )ifi To Bav^aZew dpeTfjv eYY^vriTai. rrpoc juev Ydp dv6puuTTouc dTTo6pacuv€c6ai Kai bi' opYnv dvioic TTap^cTri Kai bid TTapaqppocuvriv • uiv be 6au)udZ[ouciv dv6puuTT0i TTpaYludTuuv ouk ecTiv dveu qppovfi/uaToc dXrjOivoO Kai pepaiou KttTaqppovficai. bio Kai TaOTa
20 TTapapdXXovTec CKeivoic erriYaupoOciv eauTOuc, ujCTrep 6 CoXuuv
'dXX* f]|ueTc auToTc oO biajueiiydiueea xfic dpcTfic Tov ttXoOtov, ^TTei To luev ejUTrebov
aiei,
25 XP^MCiTa b' dvGpujTTuuv dXXoTC dXXoc exei'.
Kai AiOYevric Tfiv eic 'AGfivac ck KopivGou Kai rrdXivD eic K6piv6ov eS 'AGrivuuv jueTdpaciv eauToO rrapepaXXe TaTc paciXeuuc ^apoc |u^v dv Coucoic Kai xeiMuuvoc ev BapuXuuvi, 6e'pouc b' iv Mribia biaTpipaTc Kai 6
30 'AYHciXaoc rrepi toO jueYdXou paciXeoic 'ti YWP ^MoO
1,249— 250 H. 6, 29C— 291R.
1. JTTiYiTveTai Keiskius:^TriTeiv6Tai 22. Bergk. fr. 15
Plutarchi Moralia. Vol. I. 12
178 QUOMODO QUIS SUOS
1
}jie\lujv €K€ivoc, ei ixr\ m\ biKaiorepoc'; 6 b' Api- CTOT€'Xr]C irpoc 'AvTirraTpov Trepi 'AXeHdvbpou Ypdcpujv eqpri \xx] |n6vov ^Keiviu TrpocriKeiv oti ttoXXuiv KpaTei laeta qppoveiv, dXX' oubev fJTTOv ei' xic opGijuc yiTvlO-
E CKei Tiepi 8eaiv. 6 be Zrivuuv opiJuv tov OeocppacTov s em Tiu TToXXoOc exeiv laaGrjTdc 9au|uaZ;6)Lievov, '6 'Kei- vou xopoc' etpn 'laeiZiaiv, oujuoc be cuiuqpujvoTepoc'.
7. "OTav oijv ouTUJC Td Tfic dpeTTic rrpoc Td eKToc dvTiTiGeic uTteKxeric q)96vouc Kai ZriXoTUTriac Kai Td KviZiovTa Kai TaTieivouvTa ttoXXouc tujv dpxojLievujv lo cpiXococpeiv , jLteYa Kai touto briXuj)aa ceauTuJ toO Ttpo- K^TTTeiV TTOieTc. OUK ecTi be jLiiKpov oub ' f) TTepi ToOc XoTOUc lueTapoXri, TTdvTec ydp ujc eiTTeiv oi dpx6)Lie- voi qpiXococpeiv toOc ttpoc b6Hav biujKouci judXXov, o'i juev ujcTTcp 6pvi9ec cttI Tfjv XajUTTpoTrjTa tuiv cpu- 15 ciKiuv Kai t6 uipoc utto Koucp^TJiToc Kai cpiXoTi)uiac KaTttipovTec, o'i b' 'ujCTTep TdcKuXdKia' cpriciv 6 TTXd-
FTUJV *TU) eXKeiv Kai CTrapdTTeiv x^ipovTec' ^tti Tdc epibac Kai Tdc OTTopiac Kai Td cocpic)uaTa x^PoOciv, 01 be TrXeiCTOi toTc biaXcKTiKoTc evbuvTec eu90c ctti- 20 ciTiZiovTai TTpoc cocpicTeiav, 4'vioi bk Kai xpciac Kai icTopiac dvaXeTdjuevoi Trepiiaciv, uicTrep 'Avdxapcic IXeT€ Tijj vo)aic|uaTi Trpoc oubev rj t6 dpi9jueTv X9^- |i€vouc opdv ToOc "€XXrivac, outuj toOc Xdyouc Trap- api9juou|uevoi Kai TTapajueTpoOvTec , dXXo b* oubev eic 25 79 ovriciv auTUJV Ti9e)U€voi. cu)upaivei br] to toO 'Avti- cpdvouc, 6 Tic eiTTev eTti tujv TTXdTUJvoc cuvr|9ujv. 6 Tdp 'AvTiqpdvnc eXeTe TraiZiujv ev tivi tt6X€i Tdc qpujvdc €u90c XeTOjuevac TTr|TVUc9ai bid ipuxoc, ei9*
1, 250 -251 H. 6,291— 293B
17. nXdTUJv] Rep. VIT. p. 539 B 27. elTrev k-nl Mad- vigius : eliTe
IN VIRTUTE SENTIAT PROFECTUS 179
ucT€pov dvi€|uev(juv dKOueiv 6e'pouc a toO x^^Mwvoc bieXexOncctv • ouiiu br\ tujv utto TTXdTUJVOC ecpri veoic ouciv eTi \ex6e'vTUJV |li6Xic noTe touc noXXouc aicGd- vecGai -^ipovTac Y€VO|Lie'vouc. Kai TTpoc oXriv hk toO-
5 To Trjv qpiXococpiav TTenovGaciv , dxpi ov KaTdcTaciv f\ Kpdcic XapoOca toTc fjeoc ei^TroioOci Kai |ueYe6oc dpHr|Tai cujucpepeceai koi CriTeiv Xoyouc, uiv KaTd tov AicujTTOV eicuj ladXXov f| eHuj Td ixvri TeTpanTai. B ujcnep Ydp 6 CocpoKXnc eXefe tov AkxuXou biane-
10 naixujc oykov eiTa t6 niK.p6v Kai KaTdTexvov Tfic auToO KaTacKeufic TpiTOv nbr| t6 Tfic Xe'Heujc ^eTapdX- Xeiv eiboc, onep ii6iKa»TaT6v Icti Kai peXTiCTOv, ou- Tujc 01 ^iXocoqpoOvTec, oTav ck tujv navriYupiKuiv Kai KaTaTexvujv eic t6v dnTOiuevOv fiOouc Kai nd6ouc
15 XoYov laeTapujciv , dpxovTai Tfjv dXri6fi npoKonfiv npo- KonTeiv Kai dTucpov.
8. "Opa bi] )Lif| iLiovov (piXocoqpujv cuYTpdjuiaaTa bieHiujv Kai X6youc dKOuuJV ei )af] nXeov toTc 6v6)aaci C |a6voic npocexeic r\ toTc npdY|uaci |uribe jndXXov iui-
20 Tiribdc ToTc t6 bucKoXov exouci Kai nepiTT6v fi toTc t6 xPnciMOv Ktti cdpKivov Kai ujqpeXiiLiov, dXXd Kai noirjiuaciv ojiiXuuv Kai iCTopia napaqpuXaTTe ceauT^v ei firibe'v ce biaqpeuYei tuuv np6c ^nav6peujciv f]6ouc r| ndeouc K0uqpic)a6v e)a|ueXuuc XeYOjaevujv. uicnep Ydp
25 dveeciv 6)aiXeTv 6 Ci)aujvibric qprjci Tfjv )aeXiccav 'Hav- 66v )aeXi )aribo)aevav ', oi b' dXXoi xp6av auTuiv koi 6c)afiv, eTepov b' oubev dYanuJciv oube Xa^apdvouciv, ouTUJC 6 Tujv dXXujv ev noiii)aaciv fjbovfic evcKa Kai
1,261— 253H. 6,293— 295E.
3. TroT^*: b\\)i 9. CoqpoKXi^c] Emenclandi conatus
enumerat lahnius ad Soph, El. p. 2 25. Ci|uu)vi6r]c]
Berglj. p, 11353 28. outujc 6 Madvigius: o^jtuj
12*
180 QUOMODO QUIS SUOS
Traibictc dvacrpecpoiaevujv auTOC eiipicKUJV ti Ka\ cuv- DdTUJV CTTOubfic ciEiov eoiKev fibri YVuupicTiKOC uno cuvTi9eiac Kai qpiXiac toO KaXoO Kai oiKeiou fefovi- vai. Touc |iiev ydp TTXdTuuvi Kai ZevoqpujVTi \p^x)\xi- vouc bid Triv XeEiv, eTepov bk laribev dXX' f) t6 Ka- 5 Gapov Te Kai *Attik6v ujcirep bpocov Kai yvoOv dTTO- bpeiroMevouc Ti dv dXXo qpai»ic f| cpapndKUJv t6 |iev euOubec koi dv0rip6v dYaTrdv, t6 b' dvwbuvov Kai KaBapTiKov ^f] rrpocieceai ^rjbe YiTVujCKeiv; dXX' oi
Y€ fldXXoV €Tl TTpOKOTTTOVTeC OUK dlT^ X6yUJV /iOVOV 1
dXXd Kai GeaiLidTUJV Kai TTpaYiJdTUJV TrdvTUJV liiqpeXei- E cGai buvavTai Kai cuvdYeiv t6 oiKeiov Kai xPHCiMov, oia Kai Trepi AicxuXou XeYeTai Kai Trepi fiXXujv byioi- ujv. AicxuXoc |aev Ydp Nc9|noT 0€uj)aevoc dYUJva ttu- KTUJV, ^TTei TiXriYevTOc toO ^Tepou t6 GeaTpov ^EeKpaYe, i vuHac Tujva tov Xiov '6pac' eqpn 'oiov kTiv fi dcKr)- cic; 6 rrerrXriYiwc ciujTra, oi be 0euj|U€VOi poujciv'. Bpacibac be laOv Tiva cuXXapujv dv icxdci Kai brix0€ic dqpfjKev' eira TTp6c dauTOv 'il» 'HpdKXeic' eqpr)» '^ajc oub^v ecTi niKp6v oub' dc0evec, 6 |ifi ZrjceTai toX- HuJv d)iuvec0ai'. AiOYe'vr|C be t6v rrivovTa Taic x^pci 0eacd|Li€VOC ^Ee^aXe Tfic rrfipac t6 TTOTfjpiov. outuj F t6 TTpocexeiv Kai TeTdc0ai Tfjv dcKnciv aic0riTiKOuc Kai beKTiKOuc TTOieT tujv TTp6c dpeTfiv qpepovTUJV dTrav- Tax60ev. YiTveTai bk toOto ladXXov dv ToiJc Xoyouc i TttTc TrpdHeci laiYvuujci, |afi laovov, lijc OouKubibnc ■ IXeYC, 'fi€Td Kivbuvujv TTOiouiaevoi Tdc laeXeTac,' dXXd Kai TTp6c fibovdc Kai TTp6c Ipibac Kai Trepi Kpiceic Kai cuvriYopiac Kai dpxdc, oiov dTrobeiEiv auToTc tiuv boY-
1, 253—254 H. 6, 296 -297 R,
16. kTiv f] ficKnctc Stobaeus Flor. XXIX 89: i) ficKncic icrw 26. 0ouKub(6nc] I 18
IN VIRTUTE SENTIAT PROFECTUS 181
ludTwv bibovTec, jLioAXov be tiu xpflcQai TTOioOvTec Tct boTMaTa. ibc touc fe |Liav0dvovTac eTi Kai Trpaf- 80 iaaTeuo|Lievouc Kai cKOTToOvTac o XaPovTec €k qpiXo- coq)iac euGuc eic dtopdv f| ve'ijuv biaTpipfjv fi paciXi-
5 kov cujaTTOCiov eKKUKXricouciv, ou ludXXov oiecGai XPH (piXoco(peiv r\ touc Td qpdpjaaKa TruuXouVTac laTpeueiv ^dXXov b' oXuuc oubev 6 toioutoc coqpicTric biaqpepei Tfic 'OjuripiKfic 6pvi0oc, 6 ti dv Xdpri toTc |Lta0riTaic ujCTTep 'dTTTfici veoccoTciv Trpo(pe'piuv' bid toO CTOiuaToc.
10 'KaKujc be Te oi TreXei auTuj'
|Lir)bev eic ovriciv oiKeiav dvabibovTi laribe KaTane^T- TovTi Tuiv Xa|iPavo|ae'vujv.
9. "O0ev eTTiCKOTreiv dvaYKaTov ei xp^bixeQa tiu B XoTUJ Trpoc eauTOuc laev xpncTiKiIic, Trpoc eTe'pouc be
15 )af] bdHric eiKaiac eveKa iurib' eK cpiXoTiMiac, dXXd ludXXov dKoOcai ti Kai bibdHai PouXojuevoi, iudXicTa b' ei t6 (piX(3veiK0v Kai bucepi rrepi Tdc ZriTficeic iKpeT- Tai Ktti TreTTau|Lie0a xouc Xotouc ujcrrep ifidvTac fj cqpaipac emboujuevoi Trpoc dXXfiXouc Kai tui TraTdHai
i^o Kai KaTapaXeTv iudXXov fj tuj |ua0eTv ti Kai bibdEai XaipovTec" n Ydp ev toutoic eTTieiKeia Kai TrpaoTnc Kai t6 |Lifi )aeT* dTuJvoc cuvicTac0ai |Lif|Te biaXuec0ai laeT' opYfic Tdc KOivoXoTiac jurib' oiov eqpuPpiZeiv C eXefHavTac f| x^^eTrctiveiv eXeYX^evTac iKavoic Trpo-
-'-' KOTTTOVTOC eCTlV. ebfjXuJCe b' 'ApiCTlKTTOC €V TlVl X6-
YUJ KaTacoq)ic0eic utt' dv0pu)TTOu ToXiuav |aev exovTOC, dXXuiC b' dvofjTOu Kai luaviKoO. xctipovTa ydp opujv auTov 'if\h |uev' eiTTev *6 eXefxQeic dTTeijai coO toO
1,254— 255 H. 6, 297— 299 R.
8. 'OjuripiKfic] I 323 Xdpri Pflugkius: Xctpoi 9.
V€occoTciv*: veoccoic ttpoqpepujv*: Trpocqpepuiv 19.
TiepiboOjuevoi W
182 QUOMODO QUIS SUOS
eXeYHavTOC fibiov Kaeeubncuuv '. ^cxi be Kai XeTovtac eauTuiv Xaiapdveiv bidTreipav ei |ur|Te ttoXXujv Tiapd TTpocboKiav cuveXOovTUJV utto beiXiac dvabu6jae9a, |ar|T' ^v oXiTOic d9u|ioOMev dTuuviZiojLtevoi , |ir|Te Tcpoc
D hf\ixov r\ TTpoc dpxnv emeiv befjcav evbeia Tfic irepi 5 Triv Xe'Hiv TrapacKeufic Ttpoie)ie9a tov Kaipov, oia Trepi ATijaoc9evouc XeYOuci Kai 'AXKiPidbou. Kai xdp outoc voficai |uev rrpdTiuaTa beivoTaTOc wv Trepi be Triv Xe- Hiv d9apcecTepoc ^auTov bieKpouev ev toic TrpdTjuaci, Kai TToXXdKic ev auTUJ tuj XeTeiv Ztitujv Kai bnuKUJV lo 6vo)na Kai pfi|ua biacpeOTOv ^EeTTiTTTev ** "Qjunpoc be Tov TTpiXiTov ou birive'x9r| tujv ctixujv eHeveTKUJV d)ue- Tpov • tocoOtov Trepifiv auTiij (ppovf|)uaToc eic Td Xomd bid Tfjv buvajuiv. ouKoOv judXXov eiKOc ecTiv, oTc
E TTpoc dpeTfjv Kai t6 KaXov f) d|uiXXa, tuj Kaipuj Kai is Toic TrpdT)uaci xpfic9ai tujv Itti Taic XeHeci 9opuPujv Ktti KpoTUJV eXdxicTtt qppovTiZiovTac.
10. Ou )u6vov be bei touc Xotouc dXXd Kai Tdc TTpdHeic eKacTov eTTiCKOTreiv ei to xP^i^bec toO Travr|- TupiKoO Kai ToO rrpoc eTTibeiHiv auTaic ttXcov evecTi 20 To TTpoc dXfi9eiav. ei Tdp dXri9iv6c epujc TTaib6c r| TuvaiK6c ou JriTei judpTupac, dXXd KapTToOTai t6 fibu Kdv Kpucpa KaTepTdcriTai t6v tt69ov, Iti )adXXov eiKoc icTi t6v qpiXoKaXov Kai <piX6cocpov cuvovTa bid tOuV TTpdHeujv T^ dpcT^ Kai xpu^M^vov auT6v ev ^auTUJ 25 ciujTTri )ue'Ta qppoveiv, ^rraiveTUJV juribev be6|uevov.
F ujcTtep ouv 6 KaXujv eKeivoc oikoi Tfjv 9epaTTaiviba Kai pouJv/9e'acai, Aiovucia, Tre'TTau)uai TeTuqpw|ue'voc', ouTUJC 6 TToif|cac Ti xdpiev Kai dcTeiov eiTa toOto
1, 255— 256 H. 6, 299 -301 B
11. Hiatum signavi. De Demosthene apodosin excidisse vidit Wyttenbacliius
IN VIRTUTE SENTIAT PROFECTUS 183
biriT0u)it6V0c Ktti irepicpepujv dTravTaxoce biiXoc ecTiv eEu) pXeTTuuv Iti Kai Trpoc boEav eXKOjuevoc, outtiju be xfic dpeTnc Y€TOVUJC GeaTrjC, oub' UTrap dXV ovap auTTic dv eibuuXoic Kai CKiaic pejapoiuevoc , ei^' ujCTiep 5 ^ujTpdqpriMa TTpoTi9eic Itti Ge'av t6 TTeTrpaTMe'vov. ecTiv
OUV TOU TTpOKOTTTOVTOC OU jaOVOV bOVTa TUJ qpiXLU Kai 81
Tvu»pi)Ltov euepTeTncavTa ^fi qjpdcai Ttpoc dTe'pouc, dXXd Kai ijjfiqjov ev TToXXaTc 6e'|uevov dbiKOic biKaiav Kai TTpoc evT€u5iv aicxpdv TrXouciou tivoc fj dpxov-
10 Toc dTTicxupicdjuevov Kai bujpeac uTiepibovTa Kai vf] Aia biijjricavTa vuktujp Kai iuf) TriovTa fj Trpoc qpiXriiLia KaXfic fi KaXoO biajuaxecdjievov, ujc 6 'ATriciXaoc, ev lauTUj KaTacxeTv Kai ciTficai. to Tdp auTov eubOKi- fioOvTa Trap' eauTuj ixf\ KaTacppoveTv dXXd xctip^iv Kd-
15 YaTrdv ujc iKavov ovTa judpTuv d|ua Kai GeaTfiv tujv KaXiLv beiKvuci tov Xotov evToc r\br] Tpeqpojuevov Kai B piZioujuevov ev eauTuj Kai KaTd ArijuoKpiTov auTOV eE eauToO 'Tdc Te'pvpiac IGiWiuevov Xa|updveiv'. oi |uev ouv T€UJpToi Tujv CTaxuujv fibiov opoici Touc KeKXi|ue'-
20 vouc Kai veuovTac eTri thv , touc b' utto KOuqpoTriTOc aipo)uevouc dvuj Kevouc fiToOvTai Kal dXaWvac* outuj bf| Kai TuJv qpiXocoqpeiv pouXo|uevujv veujv oi ludXiCTa Kevoi Kai pdpoc ouk exovTec Gpdcoc ^xo^JCi Kai cxfiiua Kai pdbic|ua Kai rrpocujTTOv uTrepoi|jiac Kai oXiTUjpiac
25 laecTov dqpeiboucrjc dTidvTUJV, dpx6|i€V0i be irXripoO- c9ai Kai cuXXeyeiv KapTT6v dTTO tuiv Xotuiv t6 co^a- pov Kai qpXoiuJbec dTroTiGevTai. Kai KaGdrrep dTTeiuuv C Kevujv uTpov b€XO|uevujv 6 €vt6c dfjp uTreSeiciv Ik9Xi- P6|U€V0C, outujc dvGpujTroic rrXripouiuevoic tuuv dXr|9i-
30 vujv dTa90uv evbibujciv 6 tO^oc Kai TiTveTai t6 oiri|ua
1, 256—257 H. 6, 301—302 R.
13. xd Madvi^ius: ouroc
184 QUOMODO QUIS SUOS
iaaXaKU)T€pov , Kai nai)6)uevoi toO biot TtiuYujva Kai Tpipoiva (ppovew iueYa Tfjv acKriciv em Tf]V ipuxiiv lieTacpepouci , Kai Tqj briKTiKtu Kai TriKpu) xP^J^VTai -rrpoc eauToOc iudXicTa, toTc b' aXXoic irpaoTepov evTUTX«- vouci. t6 be (piXocotpiac 6vo)Lia Kai Tfiv toO (piXoco- 5 cpeTv boHav oux dpTrdZouciv lauToTc u)c rrpOTepov Doube TTpocTpdqpouciv , dXXd TTpocaTopeuGeic ucp' i-xi- pou T^ rrpocTiTopia TauTri qpGdcac dv eucpufic veoc eiTTOi |neT* ^pu9r|)iaToc
'ou Tic TOi Geoc ei)Ltv ti |li' dGavdToiciv eicKeic;' lo 'veac' M^v Tdp 'TuvaiKOc', u)c AicxuXoc q)riciv, 'ou Ti XavGdvei qpXeTWV
6cpeaX|a6c, fiTic dvbpoc ^ TtTeuiaevn ' ' vetu b' dvbpi T€uca^e'viu TTpoKonfic dXriGoOc ev qpiXo- coqpia Td CaTTcpiKd TauTi TTapeTreTai 15
'Kdja }xkv TX»Jucca ^'aT€, XeTTTov b*
auTiKtt XPUJ TTup uTTobebpoiaev ', dGdpupov b' oipei Kai rrpaov oixiia, cpGeTTOM^vou b' E dv dKoucai TToBnceiac. ujCTrep Tdp 01 TeXoufievoi k^t' dpxdc |iev iv Gopupuj Kai porj cuviac4 Trp6c dXXnXouc 20 uiGouMevoi, bpujjuevujv bk Kai beiKvuiLie'vujv tijuv lepuuv Trpocexouciv r\hr\ |ueTd cpopou Kai ciU)7Tfic, outuj Kai cpiXococpiac dv dpxrj Kai Trepi Gupac ttoXuv GopuPov oipei Kai XaXidv Kai GpacuTriTa, uj9ou|u^vu)v Trp6c ttiv boHav eviujv dTpoiKUJC Te Kai piaiujc" 6 b' evT6c t€- 25 vojuevoc Kai |ae'Ta cpujc ibuuv, oiov dvaKTopwv dvoi- TOjaevujv, cTepov Xapujv cxfijua Kai ciujrrfiv Kai ed|u-
1, 257-258H. 6, 302-304B.
10. Homer. tt 187 11. AlcxuXoc] Nauck. p. 61
16. Kon — b'* (Bevgk. p. 8793); Kaxct |li^v T^wccd -{e Xe-
TTTOV
IN VIRTUTE SENTIAT PROFECTUS 185
^oc ujcTrep Geuj tuj X6Ttu 'TaTreivoc Huve-rreTai Ka\ Ke- Kocjarifievoc'. eic be toutouc eoiKe Kai t6 MevebriiiiuP TreTraif laevov KaXwc Xe'Tec8ai • KaTaTtXeiv Yap eqpri touc TToXXouc eTTi cxoXfjv 'A9r|va2€, cocpouc t6 ttpujtov,
5 eiTa YiTvecGai (piXoc6qpouc, tou xpovou be TTpoiovToc ibiuuTac, ocLU juaXXov aTTTOVTai toO Xotou, laaXXov t6 oiriiua Kai t6v Tucpov KaTaTiGeiuevouc.
11. TuJv TOivuv beo)aevuJV laTpeiac oi |aev obovTa TTOVouvTec f| bdKTuXov auToGev pabiZ^ouci Trp6c touc
10 eepaTreuovTac , oi be TrupeTTOVTec oiKabe KaXoOci Kai beovTai poriGeiv, oi b' eic laeXaTXoXiav r\ qppeviTiv fj TTapaKOTTfjv fiKOVTec oube cpoiTuuvTac eviaxou TTpoc auTouc dvexovTai, dXX' ^HeXauvouciv f| qpeuTOuciv, ut:6 toO cqpobpa voceiv jurjb' 6ti vocoOciv aicGavojne- 82
15 voi. ouTLu bx] Kai Tujv djuapTavovTwv dvrjKecTOi jnev eiciv 01 Trp6c touc eXe'TX0VTac Kai vou0eToOvTac ex- Gpd)C Kai dTpiujc biaTi0e'|aevoi Kai x«^€TTaivovT€C* oi b' uTTOjuevovTec Kai TTpocie'fi6voi TrpaoTepov exouci. t6 b' eauT6v djaapTovTa TTape'xeiv toTc eXe^TXOuci Kai
20 t6 TTd0oc Xe'Teiv Kai ttiv )iox0r|pictv biaKaXuTTTeiv Kai |Lifi xttiptiv Xav0dvovTa jarib' dTaTTdv dTVOoujuevov dXX' ojLioXoTeiv Kai beicOai toO dTTTOjLievou Kai vou0€- ToOvTOc ou qpaOXov dv eir) TrpoKOTrfic crmeTov. ujc TTOu AiOTevric eXeTC tuj cujTripiac beojuevuj CrjTeTv TTpocriKeiv f) cpiXov CTTOubaTov fi bidTTupov ex0p6v, OTTUJC ^XeTXOM€voc f| 0epaTTeu6|aevoc dTToqpeuTOi Tf)V B KaKiav. ctxpi b' ou tic eTTibeiKVuiiievoc puttov f| Krj- XTba xiTuJvoc f| bieppujT6c uTTobTULia KaXXujTTiZieTai Trp6c Touc eKT6c dTucpia Kevri Kai biacKuuTTTUJV auT6c 4au-
30 t6v dic |uiKp6v f| u)c KupT6v oieTai veavieuec0ai, Td
1, 258— 259 H. ' 6, 304- 305 K.
1. Euv^TieTai] Plat. Legg. p. 716 A
186 QUOMODO QUIS SUOS
b' evToc aicxn Tfjc m/uxtic Kai Ta nepi tov piov dYXPeM- |uaTa Ktti cpGovouc Kai KaKoriGeiac Kai luiKpoXoTiac Kai <pi\r|boviac Kai ujcirep IXkti TrepiCTeXXujv Kai dTTOKpu- TTTUJV oubeva 6iYeTv oube Trpocibeiv ea bebiibc tov eXcTXOv, dXiyov auTuJ TTpOKOTrfic )ue'TecTi, /aaXXov b' 5
C oubev. dXX' 6 toutoic 6]u6ce x^P^v Kai ludXicTa iuev auTOC lauTov dXYuveiv tc koi KaKiZeiv djaapTdvovTa, beuTepov be irapexeiv lTe'pou vou9eTo0vTOc eTKapTe- poOvTa Kai Ka0aip6|uevov utto tujv eXeTX^v Kai buvd- jLievoc Kai pouX6|uevoc, oijTOC dTroTpipojieviu xai ^be- lo XuTTO)uevLu Triv )uox0r|pictv dXrieujc eoiKe. bei jaev Tdp djueXei Kai t6 boKeiv eivai TTOvripov albeicGai Kai cpeuT€iv 6 bk Tfjv ouciav thc |uoxeriPi«c luclXXov fj Triv dboHiav bucxcpaivujv ou qpeuTei t6 KaKujc dKoO- cai Kai eiTTeiv erri tuj peXTiuJV T€vec0ai. xapi^v Tdp is t6 toO AiOTevouc TTp6c Tiva veavicKOv 6(p6e'vTa juev
D ev KaTTriXeiuj, KOTaqpuT^VTa b' eic t6 KaTTriXeTov, 'ocuj' Tdp eiTTev 'evboTepuj qpeuTeic, luaXXov ev tuj KaTTri- Xeiuj TiTVi;)*. Kai tujv qpauXujv CKacTOC ocuj |uaXXov dpveTTai, tocoutuj ludXXov evbueTai Kai Ka6eipTVuciv 20 ^auT6v eic Tf]v Kadav. djueXei tujv TTevojuevuJv 01 TTpocTToioujuevoi TTXouTeTv eTi luaXXov TTevovTai bid Tfiv dXaCoveiav 6 be rrpoKdTTTUJV dXri0a)C t6v 'Itttto- KpdTri TTOieTTai TrapdbeiTjua , t6 TTepi Tdc paqpdc Tfic KeqpaXfjc dTvori6ev auTuJ Kai eHaTopeucavTa Kai Tpd- 26 vpavTa, XoTi£6)uevoc oti beivov ecTiv eKcTvov juev,
E OTTUJC dv eTepoi juf] t6 auT6 TTd6ujciv, eauToO Tqv djuapTiav KaTemeTv, auT6v be Tiva |ueXXovTa cujCe- c9ai |ufi ToXjuav eXeTX€c6ai |urib' 6jUoXoTeTv Tfiv dpeX-
1, 259— 2G0H. 6, 305-307B.
23. t6v Emperius: Kai rdv 'IrtTroKpdTTi] T. IX.
p. 340 F. Cbavter.
IN VIRTUTE SENTIAT PROFECTUS 187
Tepiav Ktti djuiaBiav. Kai ]ufiv xd fe BiavTOC Kai TTup- pujvoc ou TTpoKOTrfic dv Tic dX\d iueiCovoc eEeujc cr|- iueia GeiTO xai TeX€iOTe'pac. o )iiev Tdp nSiou touc cuvriGeic oiecGai TrpoKonTeiv oTav tOuv XoibopouvTUJV
5 OUTUJC dKOUUiClV UJC XetOVTUJV
' Hetv', eTtei out€ KaKUJ out' dqppovi (pujfi €oiKac, ouXe Te Kai jueTCtxaipe, Geoi be toi oXpia boiev'.
TTuppujva be qpaci TiXeovTa Kai KivbuveuovTa ev x^'- F |lau)vi beXqpdKiov ti beiSai xpu^M^vov dc|Lievujc KpiGaic
10 TTapaYKexujuevaic, Kai eiTreiv TTpoc touc eTaipouc oti ToiauTrjv dirdGeiav TtapacKeuacTeov ^k Xotou Kai co- qjiac Tov utto tujv ttpoctutx«v6vtuiv TaodTTec9ai ur> PouXopevov.
12. "Opa br) Kai t6 tou Zrivujvoc ottoiov ecTiv.
15 r|Hiou Tdp dTto tuuv oveipujv eKacTov eauToO cuvaiced- vecOai rrpoKOTTTovTOc, ei |iiri9' fibojuevov aicxpoO tivoc ^auTov |iiriT€ Ti rrpocieiuevov f| TTpdTTovTa tluv beivujv Kai dTOTToiv opd KaTd touc uttvouc, dXX' oiov Iv Pu- 9uj TCtXrjvric dKXucTOu KaTacpavei biaXdiuTTei Tfic vpuxrlc
20 t6 (pavTacTiK6v Kai Tra9riTiK6v biaKexu)Ltevov utt6 toO XoTOu. toOto bh. Kai TTXdTuiv, ujc eoiKe, cuvibdiv 83 TTpoTepoc eEeiaopqpujce Kai bieTUTTUJce Tfic qpucei Tupav- viKfic Hjuxnc t6 qpavTacTiK6v oia KaTd toijc uttvouc opqi. VlTpi T€ Tdp eTTixeipei fiiTVuc9ai' Kai TTp6c
25 ppujceic opiaa TTavTobaTrdc , TrapavoiaoOv Kai xpw/ievov lauToO TttTc ^Tri^ujuiaic oiov X€Xu|ue'vaic , ac |U€9' fijue- pav 6 v6|uioc aicxuvr) Kai qpopiu Ka9eipTVuciv. ujcTrep
J, 260-261 H. 6, 307-309 R,
6. Heiv'* (Homer. Z 187): Oi S^v' 7. Id. tw 402
8. ^v* 21. TTXdxujv] Rep. IX. p. 571 D 24. -jrpdc*:
Ttcpi
188 QUOMODO QUIS SUOS
I
ouv Tot TT€Traib€u|i€va KaXufC tuuv uttoZuyiiuv, oub* fiv dqprj TCic fiviac 6 fipxujv, dTTixeipei TrapaTpeTrecGai koi
B dTToXeiTTeiv thv 6b6v, dXX\ ujcTiep eiBicTai, TTpoeiciv dv TdHei, biaqpuXdTTOvTa Tfjv Tropeiav dTTTaiCTOV, o(5- TUJC oic dv euTTei6ec nbri t6 dXofOV Ka\ TTpfiov f| t€- i Y0v6c utt6 toO X6tou Kai KeKoXac^evov, outc Ka6' uTTVOuc ou8* utt6 vocujv ^Ti ^qibiujc d£uPpiZ!eiv f\ na- pavoiaeiv ^6eX€i TaTc eTTiGuMiaic, dXXd Ttipei Kai bia- pvriMOveuei tov d6ic)a6v, icxuv ^^TToiouvTa Trj rrpoco- Xrj Ka\ t6vov. cl ydp Kai t6 cuj)aa Tr| dcKrjcei Tfic i dTTaeeiac uTTriKOov ^auT6 Kai Td Mepri TTOpexeiv TT^tpu- Kev, ujc 6(peaX)aouc t€ ttp6c oTktov icxeceai baKpuujv Kai Kopbiav Trr|bri)iaTOc dv q)6poic, aiboid t€ cujqppd-
C vuic exeiv dTpe)iice Kai janb^v dvoxXeiv Trapd KaXoTc f\ KaXaTc, ttu»c ou )idXXov €Ik6c ^cti t»ic ^juxhc toO i| rraeriTiKoO Tfjv ficKnciv ^TTiXapoMevriv olov ^KXcaiveiv Kai cucxrm«Ti2etv Td cpavTdc)iaTa Kai Td Kivri)LiaTa laexpi Tujv UTTVUJV TrieZoucav; ola XeteTai Trepi toO <piXoc6qpou CTiXTTujvoc, 6c ibeTv ^boEe KaTd toOc uTTvouc 6p"f»Z;6)a€Vov auTu» t6v TToceibwva ^fi eOcavTi PoOv, uJCTTep ^eoc f|v Me'fapeuciv, auT6v bk ^x]- b^v €KTTXaY^VTa 'Ti Xereic* q)dvai 'ui TTdceibov; ^ ujCTTep TTaTc iiKeic )a€mi)i)iOipujv 6ti |afi baveicdfaevoc
D evCTrXrica Kvicnc thv tt6Xiv, dXX* dcp* Jjv efxov ^eucd coi ^eTpiwc oiKoeev;* Kai la^vTO» boKeTv aurip tdvii' TToceibOuva (aeibidcavTa Tfjv beEidv TrpoTcTvai Kai cIttcTv vbc dq)uujv (popdv MeTCtpeOci TTOif|C€i bi* ^kcTvov. oic ouv ouTUJC €u6v€ipa Ka\ (pavd Ka\ fiXuTTa, (popepdv bk )arib^v fj Tpaxu larjb^ KOK^neec J^ ckoXi6v ^k tujv uTTvujv dTTavaqp^pCTai , toutoic ttic TrpoKOTTfic dnau- 3o
l,26I-l(;3H. e,S09— 311B,
21. McTaptOciv Hauptius: UpcOciv SO. toutojc*: ToOra
IN VIRTUTE SENTIAT PEOFECTUS 189
Yacjuouc Tivac eivai \ifo^ev, oicrpouc bk m\ Trioiac Kai q)UYac dYevveic Kai TTaibiKoic Trepixapeiac Kai oXo- qpupceic evuTTVicuv olKiputv Kai dWoKOTiJuv paxiaic tici Kai cdXoic eoiKe'vai, ipuxfjc ouuiu t6 kocjuouv exouctic
5 oiKeiov , dXXd TTXaTTOjaevric eTi boHaic Kai v6|uoic, wv dTnuTdTcu YiYVOMevri KttTd touc uttvouc au9ic dvaXue- E Tai Kai dveXiTTeTai toic Trd9eci. TaOTa |uev ouv cuv- eTriCKOTTei Kai auT6c, eiTe TrpoKOTrfic ecTiv eiTe tivoc eEeuuc fibTi pePaioTriTa Kai KpdTOC dxo^cric ^Tri toic
10 X6yoic dcdXeuTOV.
13. 'Grrei b' f] rravTeXfic dTrdQeia |ueYa Kai 9eTov, dvb6cei be tivi Ktti TipaoTriTi TTa9ujv eoiKev luc Xe'Yo- |u€v f) TTpoKOTTri, bei Kai TTpoc auTd Kai Trpoc dXXnXa Td TrdGn CKOTToOvTac Kpiveiv Tdc biacpopdc* Trpoc au-
li Ttt |uev, ei vuv eTTi9u|uiaic t€ xP^M^Qot luaXaKuuT^paic Tuuv TTdXai Kai qpdpoic Kai opYaTc, Taxu tlu X^yuj t6 F eSdTTTOv auTUJV Kai qpXeYJuaivov dqpaipoOvTec Ttpoc dXXriXa be, ei judXXov aicxuv6|ie9a vOv f| (popou|ue9a Kai Z;riXoO)uev f| (p9ovou|uev Kai qpiXoboEoOjuev fi qpiXo-
20 xpr||uaToO)uev , Kai oXujc ei Aoipioic )udXXov f| Aubioic ujCTTep oi ^ieXoiboOvTec urrepPoXaTc d|uiapTdvoM€v, ckXti- pdTepoi TTepi Tfjv biaiTav ovTec y\ luaXaKouTepoi , Kai PpabuTepoi rrepi Tdc TTpdHeic f| TrpoTceTecTepoi , Kai 9au|uacTai TTap' o beT X6yujv Kai dv9pLU7TU)V fj KaTa-
25 qppovrjTai. Ka9dTT€p Ydp ai tujv v6cujv eic Td )uf] ku- 84 pia luepri toO ciujuaToc ^KTpOTTai criiueTov ou qpaOXdv eiciv, ouTUJC f) KttKia tujv ttpokottt^vtujv eoiKev eic ^TTieiKecTepa TTd9r| )ue9icTa|uevri KOTd )uiKp6v ^SaXeiqpe- c9ai. 0pOviv )uev Ydp oi eqpopoi TaTc eTTTd xop^aTc
1,262— 264H. G, 311— 312 R.
1. \^YO|uev Reiskius: X^youciv 21. OiTepPoXaic] 6tt€p-
poXaic Kai ^Weivt/eciv W 29. OpOviv W: Opuvviv
190 QUOMODO QUIS SUOS
buo TTap€VTeivd|Lievov fipuuTUJV Tr6Tepov Tdc ctvuuGev f| Tdc KdTUjOev eKT€)Lteiv auToic TtapacxeTv d6eXer fi|ua»v be beiTai juev rrujc Td dvuu Kai Td KdTiu Trepi- KOTTfic, ei )ueXXo|Liev eic t6 jue'cov KaeiCTac6ai Kai )ue- Tpiov • f) be TTpoKOTTiri Tdc uTTepPoXdc TTpoTepov Kai 5 Tdc oHuTTiTac TuJv TTa9u)V dvirici
B 'TTpoc dcTTep 01 laapTUJVTec evTOVUiTaTOi'
KOTd Co{poKXe'a.
14. Kai iuiriv oti t6 Tdc Kpiceic eTTi Td ^'p^a |ueT- dxeiv Kai touc Xof ouc |af| Xoyouc edv dXXd TrpdSeic lo TTOieTv iLxdXicTa thc TTpoKOTrfic ibiov ecTiv eipriTai. bf|- Xuj|Lia b' auToO TrpdiTov |aev 6 TTpoc Td eTraivou|Lieva ZifiXoc Kai t6 TTOieTv elvai TTpo6u)uouc a eau)udZ:o|Liev, d be tiJeY0|Liev iufi deeXeiv lurib' UTTOjueveiv. dTTel ttuv- Tac |aev 'Aenvaiouc eiK^c fjv eiTaiveTv TfjV MiXTidbou i5 ToXjuav Kai dvbpeiav , 0e|uiCTOKXfic b' eiTrujv ujc ouk eci Kaeeubeiv auT6v dXX' eK tujv uttvujv dvicTnci t6
C MiXTidbou TpoTTaiov, ouK eTTaivuiv )u6vov oube 6au- judZujv dXXd Kai ZriXuJV Kai )ui|uou|uevoc eOeuc f\v Ka- Taqpavfic. c)uiKp6v ouv oieceai xpf) TrpoKOTTTeiv, dxpi 20 ou t6 eau)udZ:eiv touc KaTop6ouvTac dpYdv ^xojuev Kai dKivriTOV eH ^auToO Trpoc )ui)uriciv. ouTe ydp epujc ciu)uaTOC evepToc, ei )uf| )ueTd ZiriXoTUTTiac IvecTiv, out' erraivoc dpeTfic bidrrupoc Kai bpacTfjpioc 6 )ufi vut- TUJV nvibk KevTpiZiuuv )ur)be ttoiuuv dvTi qpedvou ^fiXov 25 €TTi ToTc KoXoTc , dvarrXTipuOceujc 6peT6)uevov. ou Tdp utt6 tu)v Xotujv beT toO qpiXocoqjoOvTOc juovov uiCTrep
D 'AXKipidbric eXcTC Tfjv Kapbiav cTpecpeceai Kai bdKpua eKTTiTiT€iv, dXX' 6 Tc rrpoKOTTTUJV dXrieujc, judXXov
1,264H. 6, 312— 314 E.
7. Nauck. p. 248 28. 'AXKtPid&nc] Plat. Conv,
p. 25 E
J
IN VIRTUTE SENTIAT PROPECTUS 191
epTOic Kai TTpd^eciv dvbpoc dTaGoO Kai leXeiou Trapa- pdXXuuv eauTOv, d)aa tlu cuveiboTi toO evbeoOc ba- Kv6)Lievoc Kai bi' eXTiiba Kai ttoGov x^ipiJuv Kai jaecToc (juv opiafic ouK nP^MOucric oioc i' Icti KaTci tov Ci|liiu-
5 vi&nv
'clGriXoc iTTTTLU TTuJXoc (juc djLtct Tpe'xeiv ', Tiij dTaGuJ |liovovouxi cu)nq)Ovai TXiXo.uevoc. Kai Tap toOto TipoKOTTfic dXriBoOc ibiov ecTi TTd9oc, uJv ZrjXoO- laev Td epTa Tfjv bid0eciv qpiXeiv Kai dTaTTdv Kai |LieT'E
10 euvoiac dei Ti|uf)v eucpr|)uov dTTobiboucrjc eHojioioOcBai. cpiXoveiKia b' otuj Kai cpGovoc evecTaKTai TTpoc touc KpeiTTOvac, outoc ictu) boHnc tivoc y\ buvd)aeujc lr\- XoTUTTia KviZ!6|Lievoc, dpeTnv be \xr] ti)hujv jurjbe 0au-
15 15. "OTav ouv ouTUJC dpxiujLieOa tiuv OLfaQibv epdv, ujcTe jJLx] )a6vov KaTd TTXdTujva ixampxov )Liev auTOV fiTeic0ai Tov cuuqppova, 'jiaKdpiov be tov Huvr|Koov
TUUV eK TOO CUJqppOVOOvTOC CTdjUttTOC iovTuuv XoTuuv', dXXd Kai cxfi.ua Kai pdbicjna Kai pX€|U)aa Kai ^neibiajia
20 0au)LidZ[ovTec auToO Kai dTaTTuuvTec oiov cuvap|u6TTeiv Kai cuTKoXXdv eauTOuc ujjuev TTp60u)aoi, T6Te XPH vo- )iiZ;eiv dXriOuuc TTpoK^TTTeiv. cti be )adXXov, civ )Lif) F ia6vov eurjjaepoOvTac touc dTa0ouc 0au)LidZ;uj|uev , dXX' ujCTTep 01 epuuvTec Kai TpauX6TriTac dcrrdZovTai tuuv
25 ^v ujpa Kai uJXp6TriTac, Tfic be TTav^eiac Kai bdKpua Kai KaTfiqpeia TTev0oucric dpa Kai KeKaKUUjuevric eEe'- TTXrjHe Tov 'ApdcTTriv, outuuc f])aeTc |ur|Te qpuTnv 'Api- cTeibou \xr\Q' eipT)a6v 'AvaHaT^pou fifiTe rreviav Cuj- KpdTOuc f) KttTabiKriv OujKiujvoc uTTobei)Lia{vuj)aev, dXXd
1,2G4— 265H. 6, 314- 315 R.
4. Ci!uujv(fer)v] Bergk. p. 738' 16. TTXdTUJva] Legg.
IV. p. 711 E
192 QUOMODO QUIS SUOS
KQi fj€Td TouTwv dEiepacTOV fifouiuevoi ttiv dpeTfjv 6)a6ce x^J^PiJ^M^v auTfj, t6 Gupimbeiov ^qp' ^KdcTuj qpOeYTOMevoi 85 'cpeO, ToTci Yevvaioiciv ujc drrav Ka\6v'.
t6v Ydp dxpi ToO Ktti Td (paiv6|Lieva beivd fif] bucxe- s paiveiv dXXd 6au|udZ;eiv Kai 2iiXoOv dv0ouciacja6v ouk av Iti Ye TuJv KaXuuv oubeic dTroTpevpeiev. fibri bfe TOic TOiouTOic TrapeTreTai t6 pabiZlouciv im rrpdEeic Tivdc f\ XapoOciv dpxfiv fi xPncotMevoic Tuxri Ti6ec6ai iTpo 6qp6aX)iujv touc 6vTac dYa6ouc r\ YeYevriiuevouc, Kai biavoeiceai *Ti b' dv eirpaEev ^v toutuj TTXdTuiv, Ti b' av eTirev '€TTa)LieivuJvbac , ttoioc b' av wcpQx] B AuKoOpYOC r\ 'AYnciXaoc', oiov rrpdc ecoTtTpa KOC/ioOv- Tac ^auTOUc Kai )aeTappu6juiZ;ovTac r| cpujvfic dYevve- CTepac auTuuv eTTiXa)apavo)Lievouc r| rrpdc ti Trd6oc dv- TipaivovTac. oi juev Ydp eK)ae)Lia6riK6Tec Td tujv 'Ibaiujv baKTuXujv 6v6)LiaTa xpu^VTai Trpoc touc qp6pouc auTOic ibc dXeEiKdKOic, dTpejua KaTaXeYOVTec cKacTov x] bk Tujv dYa6uJv dvbpuJv errivoia Kai |uvti)ari Taxu rrapi- CTajjevri kai biaXa)updvouca touc TrpoKOTrTOVTac iw Trdci Trd6eci Kai drTOpiaic drrdcaic, 6p6ouc t€ koi drrTUJTac biacpuXdccei. 66ev ecTU) coi Kai toOto cti- (ueiov ToO TTpoc dpeTfiv ^TribibdvTOC.
16. TTp^c be TOUTUJ t6 ^xr^Kixi TapdTTec6ai cqpo- C bpa )urib' epu6pidv ^rib^ KaTaKpurrTeiv r\ |ueTacxri)^aTi- Ceiv Ti TUJV Ka6' ^auTdv, dvbpdc ^vbdHou Kai cujqppo- voc ^EaTrivric ^TTiqpavevTOC, dXXd 6appeiv 6)u6ce x^jpoOv- Ta Toic TOiouTOic i^^x ToO cuveib^TOC Tivd pepaiujciv. 'AX^Eavbpoc /a^v Ydp ujc loiKev dYY^^ov ibujv Trepixapfi
1,265— 266H. 6,315— 317n.
2. 6upiTri6€iov] Nauck. p. 953 13. olov Schaeferua:
oI6v Ti 14. Kol Emperius: i^ 15. aOtOJv W: aOTuiv
IN VIRTUTE SENTIAT PROFECTUS 193
Trpoc9eovTa Kai iriv beSidv irpoTeivovTa 'ti |ioi |Lie\- Xeic' eiTrev 'ui 'Totv dTraTTeXeTv ; f\ oti "Oiaripoc dva- PePiiuKev;' oubevoc auTuJ Td TrpdTiuaTa TrXfiv ucTepo- q)r||aiac oi6|uevoc evbeiv. veiu 5' dvbpi peXTiou)uevuj
5 t6 ^Goc oubevoc epujc ejucpueTai judXXov f| KaXoic KdTaGoTc dvbpdciv eTKaXXujTTicacBai Kai TrapacxeTvD oiKiav auToO KaTacpavfj, TpdTreZav TuvaTKa, iraibidv CTTOubriv, X6touc XeTO|uevouc f| TP«(po|Lievouc, uJCTe Kai bdKvec0ai TraTpoc TeGveuuToc fj KaSriTnToO |ue|LiVTi-
10 inevov ouK eTTibovToc auTOv ev biaBecei TomuTr), koi jLirjbev dv outuuc euHacBai Ttapd tuuv GeiJuv, ujc CKei- ' vouc dvapiiucavTac auTip T£vec9ai toO piou Kai tOuv TtpdEeiuv 9eaTdc. ujcrrep au TOUvavTiov oi KaTajieXri- cavTec ^auTuuv Kai biacp0apevTec oub' ev uTivqj touc
15 TTpocrjKOVTac dTpejua Kai dbeujc 6pujciv.
17. "Gti Toivuv TTpocXape toTc eipriiuevoic crmeTov E ou |uiKp6v, ei pouXei, t6 lurjbev eTi luiKpov fiTeTc9ai Tuiv djuapTavo|ue'vuJv dXX' eHeuXapeTc9ai Kai Trpocexeiv dTraciv. uiCTrep Tdp oi xo TtXouTriceiv dTreTvujK^Tec
20 ev oubevi Ti9evTai Td lumpd baTravrJiuaTa, |ur|bev oi6- luevoi TTOirjceiv |ueTa t6 juiKpiD tivi TrpocTi9e|uevov , f) b' ^XTTic ^TTUTe'pu) toO TeXouc pabi2ouca tuj ttXoutiij Tfjv qpiXoTrXouTiav cuvauEei, outujc ev toTc rrpoc dpe- Tfiv TTpdTluaciv 6 luf) TtoXXd cuTXwpOuv tuj 'Ti Tdp to
25 Ttapd toOto ; ' Kai ' vOv |uev outujc au9ic be PcXtiov % dXXd TTpocexuJV eKdcTUJ kov eic t6 C|uiKp6TaT0v f) Ka- Kia TTOTe TuJv d|uapTri|udTU)v evbOca cuTTViO|uriv rropi- F ZriTai bucavacxeTuiv Kai bucKoXaivujv bfiXdc ecTiv fjbri Ti Ka9ap6v ktu)|U€voc ^auTiiJ Kai oub' ottujcoOv dEuIiv
1, 266-267H. 6, 317— 318 R.
7. iraibidv Emperius: iraibia 10. ToiaOrij idem: toc- auTT) 17. MiKp6v] Hesiod. 0. et D. 361
Plutarcbi Moralia. Vol. I. 13
194 QUOM QUIS SUOS IN VIRT. SENT. PKOF.
puTtaiveceai, t6 be |iiribev oiec0ai Kax' aicxuvnv fie^YOt )jLr\b' ^x^iv euxepeic TTOiei Kai 6XiYibpouc Tipoc ra jai- Kpd. Kai fctp aiMacidv Tiva Kai GpiYKOv oiKobo|aoO- civ ou biaq)epei EuXov t6 tuxov f| XiGov uTiopaXeiv Xubaiov f\ cthXtiv uTTo9eivai Traparrecoucav dTT6 jivn- 5 ILiaTOC, ola TTOiouciv 01 qpaOXoi, TTdcav ^pTaciav Kai TTpdEiv ujc ^TUxe cujjqpopoOvTec eic TauTo Kai cuupeu- SeovTec" dXX' 01 fe TTpoKOTTTOVTec, oic ^bn, Ka6dTT€p lepoO Tivoc oiKobo|Lir|)LiaTOC Kai paciXiKoO toO piou 'KeKpoTJixai xpvjcea KpriTric', oubev eiKfj tuuv TiYvo|Lievujv lo TTpocievTai, dXX' oiov dTT6 CTdGjnnc toO Xotou TTpocd- Youci Kai TTpocapiuoTTOuciv eKacTov. uTrep ou t6v TToXuKXeiTOV oi6)neGa Xeyeiv ujc ecTi xaXeTTUJTaTOv t6 epYov OTav eic ovuxa 6 TTriX6c dqpiKriTai.
1, 267—268 H. 6, 318— 3W,
10
j
10. KeKpdTTjTOi] Bergk. Pind, fr. 176 [206] W: oic fiv
1-4. oxav
AN TI2 TH' EXeP^N ^^EAOITO.
1. 'Opuj |Liev OTi Tov TTpaoTaTov lu Kopvr|\ie TToOX- Xep TToXiTeiac rjpricai TpOTTov, ev iD ludXicTa toic KoivoTc ujcpe\i|aoc ujv dXuTTOTaTOV ibia Tok evTUYX«- vouci TTopexeic ceauTOv. 'GTrei be x^pc^v jiev d9ripov 0
5 ujcTTep icTOpouci Tfjv Kpr|Triv eupeiv ecTi, iroXiTeia be firiTe qp66vov evnvoxuia |ar|Te ZiiXov f| qpiXoveiKiav, ex^pac YOvi|au)TaTa TTd6ri , |iexpi vuv ou YtTOvev (dX\' ei lUTib^v dWo, TaTc ex6paic ai qpi\iai cufiTTXeVouciv f||uac- 8 Kai XiXuJv 6 coqpoc vorjcac tov eiTTOVTa
10 juTibeva ^xeiv ex6p6v ^piuTricev ei laribe cpi\ov exei), boKeT |uoi Td Te dWa Trepi ex6puJv tuj tto\itiku) bie- CKeqpeai TrpocriKeiv Kai toO HevoqpujvTOC dKriKoevai
|Llfl TTape'ptUJC eiTT^VTOC OTl TOO VOOV ^XOVTOC eCTl KO!
'dTTo Tujv ex6pujv ujqpe\eTc6ai '. ctTTep oijv eic toOto 15 Trpujriv eiTTeTv )aoi TrapecTri , cuvataYUJV 6juo0 ti toTc auToTc 6v6)iaciv dTTecTa\Kd coi, qpeicdjLievoc ujc ^vf|V |ad\icTa Tujv ev toTc TTo\itikoTc TTapaYT€\Maci t€- -
1, 269H. 6,320—3-2111
1 TToO\xep Xylander: iToOXxep fixep 12. Ecvocpuiv.
Toc] Oecon. I 15
13*
196 DE CAPIENDA
DTpaMMevujv, eTrei KdKeTvo t6 pipXiov 6pai ce Trpo- xeipov exovta TToXXotKic.
2. 'e£r|pKei Toic TtaXaioTc utto tuiv dXXoqpuXujv Ktti dYpiiuv 2ujiuv |afi dbiKeTcGai, Kai toOto tOuv npoc Td 9Tipia TeXoc fiv dYouvuJV CKeivoic • oi b' licTepov 5 fibri xP^cQai MaGovTec auToTc Kai luqpeXouvTai capri Tpecp6|U6VOi Kai GpiEiv djLtqpievvuiuevoi Kai xoXaTc Kai TTUTiaic iaTpeu6|uevoi Kai bepiaaciv OTrXiZiovTec dauTOUc, ujct' dHiov eivai bebievai \xf\ tOuv Gripiujv eTTiXiTT6v- Tujv Tuj dv9pu)TTUj 9r|pujubric 6 pioc auToO xevTiTai Kai lo dvriiLiepoc. eTtei Toivuv toTc jaev dXXoic iKav6v ecTi
E t6 |Liri TTttcxeiv utto tuiv ex9piLv KaKuJc, touc be voOv exovTac 6 Zevoqpujv Kai u)(peXeTc9ai qpriciv dTTo tuiv biaqpepoMevuiv, dTTiCTeTv jnev ou xpil, ^riTcTv be Me9o- bov Kai Texvriv bi' y\c toOto irepiecTai t6 KaXov oic is Xujpic dx9po0 lf\v dbuvaT6v ecTiv. ou buvaTai Tiav eHTi|Liepu)cai bevbpov 6 YCUjpYoc, o^bfe Trav Ti9aceucai 9ripiov 6 kuvtiy6c* d2r|TTicav oijv Ka9* ^Tepac xP^iac 8 Mev Ik TuJv dKdprruJV 6 b' dTrd tujv dYpiujv ujqpe- jt XeTc9ai. Tfic 9aXdTTric t6 ubujp dTT0T6v icxi m\ tto- 26 vr|p6v, dXX' ix90c Tpe'qpei Kai tt6|utti)li6v dcTi TrdvTri Kai Tropeuci|Liov oxriiLia toTc KOMiZoiaevoic' toO be ca- fi
F Tupou t6 TrOp (ibc TrpOuTOV ujqp9Ti, PouXom^vou qpiXfi- cai Kai TrepipaXeTv, 6 TTpoiLiri^euc
'TpdYOc' eqpri 'Y^veiov fipa TTev9f|ceic cu fe*) 255
Kdei Tov dvjjdMevov, dXXd qpuJc Trapexei Kai 9epM6Tr|Ta Kai Texvrjc dTrdcric 6pYav6v ecTi toTc xpflcQai |ua9o0ci. CKOTrei bfi Kai tov ex6p6v, ei pXaPep6c u)v TdXXa Kai j bucMCTaxeipiCTOC, dMUJCY€TtuJC dqpfiv evbibujciv auTou
1, 269— 270H. 6, 321—323 Bl;
25. Nauck. p. 53 icpr\*
EX miMICIS UTILITATE 197
Kai xpnciv oiKeiav Kai wqpeXiiuoc ecxi. Kai tujv TipaY- 87 ludTUJv dqpiXa noXXa Kai dTrexOn Kai dvTmaXa toTc dvTUYXdvouciv • dXX' 6pac oti Kai vocoic evioi cuO)iia- Toc eic dTrpaTMOcuvriv exprjcavTO, Kai rrovoi ttoXXoic ' 5 rrpocTTecovTec eppiucav Kai T]uHricav. evioi bk. kolx TTaTpiboc cTe'priciv Kai xPnM«TiJuv dTTOpoXfiv eqpobiov cxoXfic eTTOiricavTO Kai (piXocoqpiac, wc AioYevric Kai KpdTTic* Zrivuiv be', Tfjc vauKXripiac auTiu cuvTpipei- cnc, Tru66)aevoc eiTTev 'eu t€ «I» Tuxn TTOieic, eic tov
*io Tpipujva cuveXauvouca fi|Liac '. ujCTrep tap Td pu))ua- i' XeiuTaTa touc CTOiiidxouc Kai uYieivoTaTa tujv ClUujv ocpeic dc9iovTa KaTarreTTei Kai CKopTriouc, eCTi b' a Kai Xi6oic Kai ocTpdKOic TpecpeTai, laeTapdXXei be bi'B euToviav Kai eepjuoTriTa TTveu)uaToc, oi 5e ciKxoi Kai
15 vocuubeic dpTOV Kai oivov Trpocq)ep6)Lievoi vauTiuuciv, ouTuuc oi laev dvdriTOi Kai Tdc cpiXiac biacp6eipouciv, oi be q)p6vi)Lioi Kai Taic ex6paic emaeXuuc xpfic6ai bu- vavTai.
3. TTpoiTOV fxkv ouv boKe? |uoi Tfjc ex6pac t6 pXa-
20 pepuuTaTOV uj^eXiinuuTaTOV ctv Yevec6ai toic Trpocexou- civ. Ti be to0t6 ecTiv, eqpebpeuei cou toTc TrpdYi^a- civ ^YPnTopuuc 6 ex6p6c dei Kai Xapfjv ZriTuuv TravTa- X6eev TTcpiobeuei Tov piov, ou bid bpuoc |u6vov opuuv ibc 6 AuYKeuc, oube bid Xi6uuv Kai ocTpdKUJV, dXXd c
25 Kai bid qpiXou Kai oiKeTOu Kai bid cuvfiOouc rravToc ibc dvucTdv ^CTi qpuupuuv Td TrpaTTdjueva Kai Td pou- Xeu6)Lieva biopuTTUJV Koi biepeuvuujuevoc. oi )Liev Ydp qpiXoi Kai vocouvTec fijudc rroXXdKic Kai dTTo6vficKOV-
1, 270— 271 H. 6, 323-324 B.
5. r\\j^r]cav*: f\cKr\cav 11. f)UJ|Lia\eu()TaTa* (f)UJ|ua-
XeuiTepa Suidas v. cikxoc) : ^u)|aa\^a touc CTOjudxouc
Suidas: Toic CTO)adxoic 13. laeTapdWei*: jaeTapdWouci
198 DE CAPIENDA
Tec XavBdvouciv d)ieXoOvTac Kai 6XiTiwpo0vTac, tuuv b* dxQpuiJV laovovouxl Kai touc dveipouc TToXuTrpaTMOvoO- jnev • vocoi hk Kai baveic)iioi Kai biaqpopai Trp6c tuvai- Kac auTouc dKeivouc laaXXov fj tov dxOpov Xav6dvouci. (jdXicTa bi Tuiv d)LiapTnI)v Ix^Tai Kai TauTac ^Hixveuei. s DKai KaOdTtep o\ yOttcc in\ xdc 6c|idc tujv bieq^eopo- TUJV cuuiuidTUJV q)epovTai, tOuv be KaGapiJuv Kai uYiai- vovTwv aicGnciv ouk ^xo^civ, outuj Td vocouvto toO piou Kai (paOXa Kai TTeTTov96Ta Kivet tov dx9p6v, Kai
TipOC TaOTO o\ ILllCoOVTeC aTTOUCl Kai TOUTUJV &TTT0V- 10
Tai Kai cTTapdTTOuci. toOto ouv uicpAiiaov ^cti; TTdvu }xky/ oijv ** euXapou)nevov lr\v kox ttpoc^x^iv ^auTiu, Kai jLiriTe TTpdTTeiv iir\bk.v 6XiTu)pujc koi dTTepiCK^rrTUJC ^rjTe X^Yeiv, dXX' dei biaqpuXdTTeiv ujcTTep ^v dKpiPei biaiT»;j Tov piov dveTTiXriTTTOV • fi Yop outu) cuctcX-
E Xouca Td TTd9ri Kai cuv^xo^ca tov Xoyic)li6v euXdpeia |LieXeTr|V e)LiTToiei Kai TTpoaipeciv toO Zfjv drTieiKuuc Kal dveYKXriTUJC. Ka9dTTep Ydp al ttoX^^uoic dcTUYeiTOVi-^ KoTc Ktti CTpaTeiaic dvbeXex^ci cujcppoviZ^d^evai TToXeic euvo)aiav koi TToXiTeiav uYiaivoucav TiYdTTr|cav, outujc oi bi' €x9pac Tivdc dvaYKacOevTec ^mvricpeiv tuj piui Ka\ 9uXdTT€c9ai t6 pa9u|aeiv Kal KaTacppoveiv KaV jieT* euxpncTiac eKOCTa TTpdTTeiv Xav9dvouciv ek Td dva)adpTr|TOV utt6 Tfic cuvriOeiac dYO^evoi Kai KaTa KOC)LiouM€voi t6v tp6ttov, fiv Ktti mKp6v 6 XOYOC cuv eTriXanpdvriTai. t6 Ydp
F 'fj Kev YnQncoii TTpia^oc TTpid)ioi6 Te TTaibec* oic dcTiv dei TTpoxeipov, eTTiCTpeqpei Kai biaTp^TTei Kai
dcpicTTICl TUJV TOIOUTUJV ^9' olc o\ ^X^pOl XOtipOUCl Kttl
KaTaYeXuici. Kai ^xf\v toOc Trepl t6v Aidvucov Texvi- so
1, 2T 1 -273 U. G, 824-386 j
12. **] SigUHvi hiatum 27. Homer. A 255
i
EX INIMICIS UTILITATE 199
tac 6pd)|uev eKXeXujLievouc Kai d7Tpo9u|aouc Kai ouk dKpipuJc TroXXctKic dTUJVi2o|aevouc ev toic Gedxpoic ecp' eauTUJV OTav b' ajuiXXa Kai dTUJV Tevr|Tai Trpoc ^Tepouc, ou iLiovov auTouc dXXd Kai Td opTava |udX- 5 Xov cuveTTicTpecpouci, xoP^o^oTouvTec Kai dKpiPecTe- pov dpMOTToiuevoi Kai KttTauXouvTec. octic ouv oibev dvTaTuuvicTTiv piou Kai boEnc tov ex9p6v ovTa, Trpoc- exei iLidXXov auTuJ , Kai Td TrpdTMCtTa TrepiCKOTreT Kai 88 biapiiioTTeTai t6v piov. dTtei Kai touto t^c KaKiac
10 Tbiov ecTi, t6 touc ex9pouc aicxuvec9ai iudXXov f| Touc (piXouc ecp' oic eHa|uapTdvo|uev. 69ev 6 Naci- Kdc, oio|LievuJV tivOjv Kai XeTOVTUJv ev dccpaXei t^- Tovevai Td 'Pujjuaiujv TrpdTjuaTa Kapxn&oviujv fiev dvr)pri|uevujv 'AxaiiLv be bebouXujjuevujv, 'vOv juev
isouv' eiTrev ' eTTiccpaXujc exojuev, |ur|9' ouc cpoPnQuJ- jiiev |ur|9* oOc aicxuv9uj|uev eauTotc dTToXeXomoTec'.
4. "Eti Toivuv TrpocXape Tfjv AioTevouc dTTOcpaciv, B q)iX6cocpov ccpobpa Kai ttoXitiktiv oucav. 'ttujc d|uu- voOjuai t6v ex9p6v;' 'auT6c KaX6c KdTa96c Tev6|Lie-
20 voc'. iTTTTOUc ex^pujv opujvTec euboKi|uoOvTac fj Kuvac eTTaivou|uevouc dviuJvTar civ x^J^^Piov eKTreTrovrilLievov ibujciv, dv eu9aXo0vTa ktittov, eTricTevouci. xi ouv oiei, ceauTov eTTibeiKVU|U€voc dvbpa biKaiov dpTicppova XPncTov, iv XoToic euboKiiuov, ev TTpdgeci Ka9ap6v,
25 ev biaiTri K6c|aiov,
'3a9eTav auXcKa bid (ppev6c KapTrou|uevov, eH ric Td Kebvd pXacTdvei PouXeujuaTa'; ^viKiju|uevoi' cprici nivbapoc 'dvbpec dTpuHia bebev-
1, 273—274 H. 6, 326-327 B.
20. f^ Kuvac ^TTaivouiLievouc dviuuvrai*: dviOuvTai KOvac iTraivouia^vouc 26. paGeiav] Aesch. Sept. 793 28.
TTtvbapoc] Bergk. fr. 214 [253]
200 DE CAPIENDA
Cxai', oux dTTXuuc oube TTotVTec, dXV ocoi viKUUjievouc auTouc opujciv UTTO TuJv exOpoiv eTTijueXeia xphctottiti jLieTaXocppocuvri cpiXavGpuJTTiaic euepteciaic- TauTa ' dTTocTpeqpei TfjV YXiIiTTav' ibc 6 Armoceevric (prjciv» * e)Li(ppdTTei t6 CTOjiia, dYX€i, ciiUTTav TTOieT'. s
'cu TOi bidqpepe tujv KaKoiv ^HecTi tdp.* ei G^Xeic dvidv tov |nicoOvTa, lufi Xoibopei Kivaibov iuribe juaXaKov yir\b' dKoXacTov fiiribe piu)LioX6xov inrib' dveXeuGepov, dXX' auT6c dvfip k0i Kai cu)q)p6vei Kai dXi^Geue Kai xpui qpiXavBpuuTTUJC Kai biKaiujc toTc ev- io|
D TUYXdvouciv. av be Xoibopfjcai TTpoaxGric, dTraTe TTop- puJTdTuu ceauT6v iDv XoibopeTc eKeivov. dvbuou Tfi vijuxfi, TTepiCKOTTei Td caGpd, |Lif| Tic coi TTo6ev utto- (pQif^ryrai t6 toO TpaYUJboO
'dXXujv iaTp6c auToc eXKeci Ppuujv*. 15 1
dv dTTaibeuTOV ei'TTr)c, dTriTeive t6 (piXo)Lia9ec ^v ce- J auTu» Kai q^iXoTTOvov av beiXov, eYeipe judXXov t6 0appaXe'ov Kai dvbpuibec dv dceXYn Kai dKoXacTOv, eHdXeicpe ttic Mjuxfjc ei ti XavGdvov dcTi qpiXriboviac ixvoc. oubev Ydp aicxiov dcTi pXacqpriiLiiac TraXivbpo- 20^ juoucric oube XuTTripoTepov, dXX' eoiKe Kai toO qpu)T6c t6 dvaKXuu)aevov iudXXov evoxXeTv Tdc dc9eveTc opd- ceic Kai Tuiv liiOYUJV 01 TTp6c auTouc dvaqpepojuevoi
E Touc ipe^YOVTac utt6 Tfic dXri0eiac. ibc Ydp 6 Kamiac Td ve'qpr|, Kai 6 qpaOXoc pioc dqp' lauT6v IXKei Tdcasj Xoibopiac.
5. '0 jLiev ouv TTXdTUJV 6cdKic dcxriinovoOciv dv-
1, 274— 275H. 6, 327-329 R.
4. AtiMOce^vvic] P. 406, 5 6. cu] Eurip. Or. 251
13. OiToqpGeYTriTm * : OuocpG^YYITm KaKia 15. Nauck.
p. 545 16. €iirr)c Boissonadius: einr) ce 18. fiv*:
kSv 24. U)c T«P] Nauck. p. 660
EX INIMICIS UTILITATE 201
epiuiTOic TrapaYevoiTO , trpoc auiov eioOGei Xifeiv *}xr\ 7T0U ap' eYiw toioutoc;* 6 be Xoibopricac tov lTe'pou piov av euOuc eTTiCKOTTfj tov dauToO Kai |H€0ap)d6TTr] TTpoc TOuvavTiov (XTTeuGuviuv Kai dTTOCTpeqpuLiv , eHei
5Ti xpnciiuov Ik toO Xoibopeiv, dXXouc dxpncTOu koi KevoO boKOuvTOc eivai Kai 6vtoc. oi )uev ouv ttoX- Xoi YeXuJCiv, dv tic uiv <paXaKp6c f| KupT6c CTepouc eic TauTa Xoibopr| Kal CKWTTTri* TeXoTov 5' oXuuc dcTiP To Xoibopeiv Ktti cKuuTTTeiv oTioOv dvTiXoibopriGfivai
10 buvd)nevov , ibc Aetuv 6 BuZidvTioc utt^ KupToO Xoibo- priGeic elc Tf|v tuuv 6|n|ndTiJuv dcGeveiav ' dvGpouTTivov ' ecpri 'TTdGoc oveibiZeic, drri toO vUutou qpepuuv Trjv vejLieciv'. ouKoOv |Lir|be jlioix6v Xoibopncric , auT6c uuv TTaibo|uavric • iurib' dcuuTOv, auT6c uuv dveXeuGepoc.
15 'dvbpoKTovou YuvaiK6c 6|uoYevfic ecpuc' 7Tp6c Tov "AbpacTOv 6 'AXK|ueiJuv. ti ouv eKeivoc; ouK dXXoTpiov dXX' Tbiov auTUJ TTpoqpe'piJUV oveiboc
'cu b' auTOxeip fe |LtriTp6c fi c' eYeivaTo'. 89
TTp6c t6v Kpdccov 6 AoiuiTioc 'ou cu juupaivric dv
20 z:u)Ypeiuj coi Tpeqpoiuevric elTa diToGavoucric CKXaucac;' Kai 6 €T€poc 'ou cu Tpeic YuvaiKac eKKOjuicac ouk ebdKpucac;' ouk euqpua bei t6v Xoibopr|c6|Lievov eivai Kai laeYaXoqptJUVov Kai iTajLiov, dXX' dXoibopriTov Kai dveYKXrjTov oubevi Ydp outujc eoiKe TrpocTdTTeiv 6
25 ee6c d)c TU) jueXXovTi ipeYciv eTepov t6 'yvuuOi cau- Tov', iva nr\ XeYOVTec & 0eXouciv dKOuuuciv d iufi 0e- Xouci. 'qpiXei' Ydp 6 toioOtoc KOTd t6v CoqpOKXea
'Y^uJccav eKxeac judTriv B
OKuuv dKOueiv ouc eKubv eiTrr) Xoyouc*.
1 , 275—276 H. 6, 329—331 R.
2. 7T0U fip'*: 7T11 5p' 15. Nauck. p. 695 18. Id.
p. 69P 27. CoqpoKXea] Id. p. 261
202 DE CAPIENDA
6. TouTi |it^v oOv ^vecTi tuj Xoibopeiv rov 1%- 6p6v ibcpeXi|uov Kai xpilciMOV • oOk eXaTTOv b' eTepov, Td XoibopeTcSai Kai KttKtuc dKoueiv auTOv urrd tiLv exOpufV. 6Gev opeoic 6 'AvTicGevnc eiTTev 6ti toic fieXXouci cibCecGai cpiXuuv bei Yvnciiuv f| biaTTupujv & exBpuiv ■ o'i jLi^v TOP vou9eTo0vT€C touc d)aapTdvovTac o'i be XoibopoOvTec dTroTp^TWuci. ^trei b' fi cpiXia Td vOv icxvoqpujvoc TeTovev ev tui TrappiicidZ^eceai , Kai t6 KoXaKeOov auTfic XdXov dcTi t6 be vouBeToOv
C dvaubov, dKOucTeov ^cti TTapd tuiv ^x^PUJV thv dXr|- i( 9eiav. ibc Ydp 6 Tr|Xeq)OC oiKeiou }xr] TUTxdvujv ia- Tpou Tuj TToXe)iiiu bopaTi t6 eXKOC UTTe9nK€V, ouTUi Touc dTTOpoOvTac euvoiac vou9€Toucr|C UTTO)aeveiv dvdTKTi (aicoOvTOc dx^PoO Xotov, fiv eX^TXO ^^^ '^o- \dlr( TTiv KOKiav , ckottoOvt^c t6 epTov dXXd fxi] TfjV i| TviJU)ariv toO KaKUJC XeTOVTOc. ujCTTep Tdp 6 t6v 0€c- caXov TTpoiLiriGea KTeTvai biavoTi9eic ^TTaice tiD £i<p€i t6 cpOiua Kai bieiXev outujc ujct€ cujGnvai t6v dv9puj- TTOV Kai dTraXXaTfivai toO q)U)aaToc ^aT^VTOc, outuj TToXXdKic utt' dpTnc ^ Ix^pcc TrpocTrecoOca Xoibopia
DKaKOV ijjuxfic f| dTVOOU)nevov f\ d)aeXou)aevov e9epd- Tieucev. dXX' oi ttoXXoI XoibopriGevTec ou ckottoOciv ei TTpdcecTiv auToTc t6 XeTd^uevov, dXXd ti ttp6c€ctiv ^Tepov Tuj XoibopoOvTj, Kai Ka9dTTep oT TraXaiovTec Tfiv Koviv oux ^auTuiv dTTOvpujci Tdc Xoibopiac, dXXd s| cu^TTdccouciv dXXf|Xouc eha q)upovTai Kai dvaxpuOv- vuvTai cu)LiTT€c6vTec utt' dXXfjXujv. bei b* dKOucavTa KaKUJC utt' ex9po0 t6 )a€v Kpoc6v dcpaipeiv auToO liiaXXov f\ KTiXTba irpocoOcav \fiaTiiu Kai bcix9eTcav • fiv b^ Tic \ifr) Td jaf) TTpocovTO, 6)aujc CriieTv thv alTiav
J . 276—278 H. 6, 33 1—333
30. Tfjv*
EX miMIClS UTILITATE 203
dcp' fic fi pXacqprmia TeTove, Kai (pu\dTT€c9ai koi E bebievai |ar| ti Xav6dvu)|Liev f| cuveTTuc F| 6|uoiov tuj XeTO)uevuj TxapaiuapTdvovTec. oiov AaKubnv tov 'Ap- Teiujv paciXea KOjLiric tic bidGecic Kai pdbic|aa Tpucpe-
5 pujTepov eic laaXaKiav biepaXe Kai TTonTTriiov t6 Ivi Kvdc0ai Tf]V KeqpaXfjv baKTuXLu, 'aoppujTdTU) GnXuTTi- Toc Kai dKoXaciac ovTac. Kpdccoc be tujv lepujv iuia iTap6evujv aiTiav ^cxe TrXricidZieiv , x^JiJPiov ti KaXov ujvricacGai Trap^auTfic pouX6|uevoc Kai bid toOto ttoX-
10 XdKic evTUTXdvujv ibia Kai 6epa7Teuujv. TTocTou|uiav be t6 TcXav iTpoxeipoTepov Kai XaXia xpflceai 6pacu- F Tepa TTpoc dvbpac bie^aXev, ujctc Kpi0fivai qp6opac. eupe6ri )uev oijv Ka0apd Tfjc aiTiac, dTToXucac b' au- Tfjv 6 dpxiepeuc CKopioc Mivoukioc urreiuvrice |ufi XPH-
15 c6ai XoToic dce^voT^poic toO piou. 0e|uicTOKXei be TTaucaviac luribev dbiKoOvTi TTpoceTpivjjaTO Tf)v utto- vpiav Tfic TTpobociac bid t6 xPTlc6ai (piXuj Kai Tpa<peiv cuvex&c Kai TTe|UTTeiv TTp6c auTov.
7. "OTav ouv Xex6fi ti juf) aXr|6ec, oux oti ipeO-
20 boc ecTi bei KaTacppoveiv Kai diueXeTv, dXXd ckottcTv Ti Tujv utt6 coO XeTO)uevuJv f| rrpaTTOjuevujv f| cttou- 90 ba2o|uevujv f| cuvovtujv oiuoioTriTa Tf) biapoXfj TTap- ecxriKC» Kcti toOto bieuXapeTc0ai Kai qpeuTeiv. ei Tdp eTepoi rrpdTluaciv dpouXfiToic TTepmecovTec bibdcKOVTai
25 t6 xpnci|uov, ujCTTep f) MepoTTri (pnciv
'ai Tuxai hi |U€ )uic06v XapoOcai tujv ejuujv Td cpiXTaTa coqpfiv e'0r|Kav', Ti KUjXuei bibdcKaXov d)uic6ov XapovTa tov ^x^pov
1, 278-279H. 6, 333— 335 R.
4, Tic*: Tivoc 7. SvTOC*: SvTfl 22. cuvovtujv] Re- CLuiritur ckujtttom^vujv vel naiZioM^vujv 26. Nauck. p. 396
204 DE CAPIENDA
wqpeXtiefivai Kai laaeeTv ti tOuv Xav0av6vTujv ; TToXXa Yap 6 €x0p6c aic0dv6Tai toO (piXou luaXXov ('TuqpXoO- Tai' Ydp 't6 (piXoOv Tiepi t6 q)iXou|Lievov ', wc 6
B nXdTUJV <pnci), Tuj be iuiceiv iueTd toO uoXunpaTlno- veiv Kai t6 XaXeiv ^vecTiv. 6 Mepiuv utto tivoc tujv s Ix0pwv eic triv buciubiav dXoibopr|0ri toO CTOiuaToc. dX0ujv ouv oiKabe Trpoc Tfjv YuvaiKa 'ti XeYeic;' ei- TT€V, 'oube cu |uoi toOto ecppacac;' f\ b' ouca cuO- (ppujv Kai ttKaKOc 'ujjuriv' elTrev 'oti toioOto TrdvTec 62ouciv 01 dvbpec '. outuj Kai Td aic0riTd Kai Td w cujjaaTiKd Kai Td KaTacpavf) TTdci Trapd tujv ex0pu)V )Lia9eTv irpoTepov ecTiv y\ tujv (piXujv Kai cuvr|0uJv.
8. "Aveu hk TouTOu Tf|v rrepi Tf|v Y^i^JTTav ^y- KpdTeiav, ou )LiiKp6v dpeTfic |ae'poc oucav, urrriKoov
C dei TUJ XoYicjLiuJ Kai TT€i0riviov txeiv ouk IvecTiv, dv is ILiri Tic dcKr|C€i Kai iueXeTr) Kai cpiXoTTOvia Td KdKicTa Tuiv TTa0uJv, oiov ecTiv f] 6pYr|, KaTepYdcriTai. f] Ydp 'dKouciujc ^KTriTTTOuca (pujvfi' koi t6 'Ittoc (puYev epKoc 6b6vTU)v',- Ktti t6 ' Ivia dEiTTTac0ai tujv prmdTUJv auTOjuaTa * toTc 20 dvacKTjToic iudXicTa 0u)lioTc oTov 6Xic0dvouci Kal biap- peouciv eTTiYiYveTai bi' dc0ev€iav 0u|aoO, bi' dKpaTfj YVDUjariv, bi' dYUJYflv Opaceiav. Xoyou hk KOutpoTdTOu TTpdYinaTOC papuTdTri Srmia KttTd t6v 0eTov TTXdTUJva Kai Trapd 0eujv eTTCTai Kai Trap' dv0pujTru)V. x] be 25
DciYf) TTavTaxoO |aev dvuTTeu0uvov (ou juovov dbnjjov, uic qpTiciv 'iTTTTOKpdTric), dv be Xoibopiaic cejav6v Kai
1 , 279—280 H. 6, 335—336 B.
4. TTXdTiuv] Legg. V p. 731 E 10. alcGrird Reiskius:
alcGriTiKA 13. t^v Stobaeus Flor. XXXIV 9 23. 6i'
dTiwTnv Bpaceiav Reiskius: biaiTri Gpaccicji 24. TTXdxujva] Legg, XI. p. 935 A 27. Xoibopiaic Stob. Flor.XIX 1 : Xoibopiot
EX INIMICIS UTILITATE 205
CuuKpaTiKov , ^aXXov b' 'HpdKXeiov, ei fe KdKeivoc *oub'6ccov juuiac cTUTepiuv diuTTd^eTO lauGiuv*. ou lafiv TOUTOu ceiLivoTepov Kai KdXXiov ecTi t6 Xoibo- poOvToc .exQpoG Trjv ficuxiav ciTeiv 'Xiccdba TreTpav 5 (piXoK€pTO)aov ujc irapavrixOHevouc', oub' dXXr) laeiCujv dcKricic. dv Ydp exQpov eGicerjc XoibopouvTa q)epeiv ciujTTrj, ndvu ^abiuic oiceic YuvaiKOC opTfiv KaKiiJc XeTOucrjC, Kai (piXou cpujvdc Kai dbeXq)0u TriKpOTdTac dKOuujv u7T0)ueveic d9opuPujc* TiaTpi be Kai iuTiTpi tu-
10 TTTOiaevoc Kai paXX6)Lievoc TiapeHeic d6u|aov Kai d)Liri- viTOV ceauT6v. 6 iuev Tdp CujKpdTric eqpepe Tfjv Zav- E eiTTTTriv 0u)Lioeibfi Kai xciXeTTfiv oucav, uic euKdXujc cuvec6|aevoc 4Te'poic, dv ^Keivrjv uTTO|Lieveiv eGicGri* TToXu be PcXtiov dx^Pi^v Kai dXXoTpiujv iy^v^xvaca-
!'> iuevov pbeXupiaic Kai opTaTc Kai CKU)ju|naci Kai Xoibo- piaic I9icai tov 9u|Lidv fjcuxiav ciTeiv txr]b' dcxdXXeiv ^v Tuj XoibopeTc0ai.
9. TTpadTriTa ^kv oCv Kai dveHiKaKiav outujc ecTiv lveTnbei£ac0ai TaTc ex0paic, drrXdTriTa be Kai iueTa-
20 Xocppocuvrjv Kai xPICT^TriTa iuaXXov iv TaTc cpiXiaic. qjiXov |Li^v Tdp oux outuj to eO TTOieTv KaX6v, ujcF aicxpov Td iuf) TTOieTv be6]uevov ex0pOu bk kolx to ti- (jujpiav TTapaXeirreiv KaipoO TTapacx6vT0c dTTieiKe'c ^CTi. t6v be Kai TTTaicavTi cu|LiTra9f|cavTa Kai beri-
25 eevTi cuXXap6|nevov Kai iTaiciv ^x^PoO Ka\ oiKeioic Kai rrpdTMaciv ev xpeia T€VO|Lidvoic CTTOubfjv rtva Kai
1, 280—281 H. 6, 336— 338 R.
3. oO*: oOt€ t6] toO Reiskius 6. oO&' &X\r\
lueiZujv ficKiicic Emperius: dWd |ue(2ujv f\ ficKricic 6. Yctp
idem 7. 6pTiiv W: 6p|if)v 23, irapaXeiTreiv koi-
poO*: itapaXiireiv dv Kaip<?i 25. olKeioic KOi Eeiskius:
olKeioic
206 DE CAPIENDA
npoGu^iav dvbeiHd^evov Sctic ouk fiTCtTai tfic .€u^€- veiac oub' ^jraivei tr\v xPncTorriTa, 'KeTvoc 91 'eE dbd)navToc
f\ cibdpou KexdXKeuTai ^eXaivav Kapbiav*. Tu» Kaicapi KeXeucavTi Tdc TTojLiTTtiiou Ti)Lidc dvacTO- 5 Gfjvai KaTapepXriiaevac 6 KiKepujv 'touc TToiaTTniou' q)riciv 'dvbpidvTac dv^cTticac, touc bk couc ^TrriEac'. 66ev oub' enaivou qpeicTeov oub^ Ti)afic nepi dvbpoc exOpoO biKaiuuc euboKi)LiricavTOC. liTaivov Te Tdp <pi- pei )uei2ova toTc dTraivoOci, Kai ttictiv ix^i ndXiv if- lo KaXOuv, ujc ou Tov dvbpa )aicujv dXXd Trjv npdEiv dnobOKi)ad2u)v • t6 be KdXXicTOV Kai xPHCiM^TaTOV,
B dnujTdTUJ KaGicTaTai toO qpGoveTv Kai (piXoic euTuxoO- ci Kai KaTopGoOciv oiKeioic 6 touc ^xQpouc d9ic6eic dnaiveiv Kai lafj bdKvec6ai jirib^ pacKaiveiv eu npaT- is TdvTWV. KaiTOi Tic ficKTicic ^T^pa laeiZova ujqpAeiav dvepYdJeTai TaTc ipuxaTc f\ bid6eciv KpeiTTova Tfic dqjaipoucTic t6 bucZriXov n|iu»v Kai q)iX6(p6ovov ; tuc- nep Tap ^v noX^)Liuj noXXd tujv dvoTKaiujv fiXXujc bk qjauXujv f6ouc XapdvTa Kai vd^ou buvaviiv ouk Icti 20 pabiujc dnujcac6ai pXanTO)Lievouc , outujc n ex9p« cuv- eicdTouca tuj )ilc€i q)66vov, 2riXoTuniav dnixaipeKO- Kiav )LivriciKaKiav dvanoXeinei. np6c bk toutoic Kai
C navoupTia Kai dndTr) Kai dnipouXri, bOKoOca }ir] (pav- Xov elvai inrib' dbmov np6c ^x^pov, Sv ^TTevriTai, 25 napa)Li^vei bucandXXaKTOc * eTTO xP*A»VTai np6c touc qjiXouc un6 cuvri6eiac, av ^x] qjuXdEujvTai npoc touc dx6pouc. etnep oijv 6p6u)C 6 TTu6aT6pac, iv dX6- Toic Zlujoic d^iCujv dj)i6TriToc dn^x^ceai Kai nXeov-
1. 281— 282 H. 6, 3 <8-340 B.
1. AyaTai*: dTair^ 3. Bergk, Pind. fr. 100 [88]
27. q)(Xouc*: q)(\ouc ftCiTOl
EX INIMICIS UTILITATE 207
eEiac, opveuuv re Gripac TrapriTeiTO Kai PoXouc lijvou- ILievoc ixOuuJv eKeXeuev dcpievai, Kai TravToc fmepou lujov qpovov otKriTopeue, ttoXu brjTTOu cejuvoTepov ^ctiv iv biaqpopaic TTpoc dvGpiuTTOUc Kai qpiXoveiKiaic, fev-
5 vaTov exOpov ovTa Kai biKaiov Kai dipeubfj , Tot juox- D 0iipd Kai dTevvfj Kai TTavoOpYa Trd9ri KoXdZeiv Kai TaTTeivd TToieiv, ottuuc ev toTc rrpoc touc q)iXouc cujn- poXaioic TTavTdTTttciv dTpeiarj Kai dTTexriTai toG Ka- KOupTeTv. CKttOpoc exOpoc fjv Ao)aiTiou Kai KaTriYO-
10 poc. oiKeTrjc ouv toO Aojamou TTpo Tfjc biKTic fiKe TTpoc auTOV ibc exuiv ti |Lir|vOcai tujv XavGavovTuuv eKeTvov, 8 b' ouk eiacev eiTTeTv, dXXd cuXXapiJuv tov dv6pu)TT0v dKiiYaTe TTpoc tov becTTOTriv. KdTUJVi bk Moupr|vav biiuKOVTi briiuoKOTTiac Kai cuvdTovTi touc
15 eXeTXOuc ii eGouc Trapr|KoXou9ouv oi Td TrpaTTOMeva rrapaqpuXdTTOVTec. iroXXdKic ouv auTov ripiJUTUJV ei Ti jueXXei crmepov cuvdTeiv fj TTpaT|uaTeuec9ai TTpoc E Tfjv KaTriTopiav ei be |Lifi qpairj, TriCTeuovTec dTT^ecav. TaOTa jLiev ouv auToO ttic boSric exei TeK)Lif|piov |ue'Ti-
2?cTov dXXd piexlov Kai KdXXioV; oti tuj biKaiuj xpf\- c9ai Ktti TTpoc ex9pouc e9ic9evTec ouberroTe iufi TTpoc- evex9uj)Liev dbiKUJC Kai TTavoupTUJC toTc cuvfi9eci Kai qpiXoic.
10. ''6TTei' bk 'TTdcaic KopubaXXici XPH Xoqpov 25 eTTevec9ai ' KaTd tov Ci)aujvibTiv, Kai TTaca qpucic dv- GpuuTrou qpepei qpiXoviKiav Kai Ziri^OTUTTiav Kai q)96- F vov, ' Keveoqppovujv dvbpuuv eTaipov', uuc qpr|ci TTiv-
1,282— 2S3H. 6, 340— 341 K.
1. Sripac*: GtipeuTctc 20. KdXXiov Reiakius: KdXXi-
CTOV 24. Ttdcaic*: Trdcaici 25. Ci)auuvi6iiv] Bergk.
p. 1141 3 niv&apocj Bergk. fr. 196 (231)
208 DE CAPIENDA
bapoc, ov iueTpiijuc av tic ujqpeXoiTO tujv TraGuiv tou- Tujv TTOioujLievoc eic Touc exepouc dTroKaedpceic Kai diiocTpeqpwv (jJCTtep 6xeT0uc TToppujTdTU) tujv eTaipuiv ' Kai oiKeiujv. Kai toOto, ujc eoiKC, cuvibujv ttoXitikoc dvrip 'Ovo)adbri)Lioc, ev Xiuj Tfic KpaTouctic |uepiboc ev 5 CTdcei YevojLievoc, Ttaprjvei toTc eTaipoic |un rrdvTac
92 eHeXdcai touc dvTiCTacidcavTac, dXX' uTroXmeceai ti- vdc, 'oTTUJc' ecprj 'jufi Trpoc touc (piXouc dpEuj|ue0a bia^epecGai, tuiv exOpOuv TravTdTraciv dTtaXXaYevTec'. ouKOuv Kai fiiuujv KaTavaXicKOiueva TauTa Td TrdGri ^o TTpoc Touc exOpouc fJTTOv evoxXrjcei toic cpiXoic. ou Ydp KepajLiei bei Kepaiuea qpGoveTv oub' doibov doibui KaG' 'Hciobov, oube YeiTOva 2tiXoOv oub' dveijjiov oub' dbeXqpov 'elc dqpevoc CTteubovTa' Kai TUYxdvov- Ta xpncTuiv TrpaYMdTUJV. dXX' ei fxr^beic TpoTTOc ecfiv is
B dXXoc dTTaXXaYflc epibuiv Kai qpGovujv Kai qpiXoviKiuiv, eGiJe ceauTov bdKvecGai tuiv exepCDv eurijuepouvTUJV, Ktti TrapoSuve Kai xap«TTe t6 qpiXoviKOv ev eKeivoic enYOjuevov. ujCTTep Ydp oi xctpievTec YeujpYOi Td poba Ktti Td la peXTiuj TTOieTv vojuiCouci CKOpoba Kai Kpoju- 20 ^ |iiua TrapaqpuTeuovTec (dTroKpivcTai Ydp eic CKcTva rrdv ocov evecTi ti^ Tpoqpi^ bpiiuu Kai bucuibec), outuj Kai 6 exep6c dvaXajupdvuJV Kai Trepierrujv t6 KaKorieec Kai pdcKavov, eu|ueve'cTep6v ce rrapeHei toTc qpiXoic eij TTpdTTouci Kai dXuTTOTepov. bi6 Ktti Tdc djuiXXac Ttpoc 23 1 eKcivouc dcTi TTOiriTeov urrep boHric ti dpxfic f| Tropi- CMUJV biKaiujv, [xf] baKVOjuevouc movov, dv ti irXe^ov fiiiiuiv ^xiwciv, dXXd Kai TidvTa TrapaqpuXdTTOVTac eH
C iliv TtXeov exouci, Kai TTeipujjue'vouc uTteppaXeceai TaTc eTTiiueXeiaic Kai qpiXoTTOviaic Kai tiIi cujqppoveTv Kai 20
1, 283-285 H. ' 6, 341-343 B,
13. 'Hcvobov] 0. et D. 23 24. C6 Eeiskius
EX INIMICIS UTILITATE 209
TTpocex€iv ^auToic, tLc OeiuicTOKXfjc eXeyev ouk iav auTov KaGeubeiv Triv ev Mapa9ijuvi MiXTidbou viKtiv. 6 |iev YCtp euTuxia biaqpepeiv auTou tov exOpov f]TOU|uevoc ev dpxaic r\ cuvriTopiaic f\ rroXiTeiaic ri
5 napd q)iXoic Kai fiyeiuociv ^k tou TrpdTTeiv ti Kai Zln- XoOv eic t6 pacKttiveiv TravTdTraci koi d6u|Lieiv KaTa- bu6)a£voc dpYiu tu» (pGdvuj Kai dTTpdKTUj cuvecTiv 6 be ixr\ TuqpXoujuevoc Trepi t6 laicoujuevov dXXd Kai piou Kai fi9ouc Kai Xotujv Kai ^pTUJV TiTv6|uevoc Gearfic
10 biKaioc Td TfXeicTa KaToijjeTai tujv Z;r|Xou|Lievu)v 42 D lTTi|ueXeiac Kai Ttpovoiac Kai TrpdHeuiv xPHctujv Trepi- TiTv6)aeva* ToTc KeKTrmevoic, Kai Trp6c TaOTa cuvTei- vwv ^TTacKfjcei to qpiX6Ti)Liov auToO Ktti q)iX6KaXov, t6 hi xac|Liijubec eKK^ipei Kai pa9u)Liov.
15 11. ei be Tivac oi exOpoi KoXaKeuovTec r| Travoup- T0u\T6c r\ beKdZiovTec f| )Liic9apvo0vTec aicxpdc Kai dveXeu9e'pouc boKoOci KapTTo0c9ai buvd|ueic ev auXaic fl TToXiTeiaic, ouk evoxXficouciv fi)udc dXXd ludXXov eucppavoOci, Tf)V auTUJV eXeu9€piav Kai t6 Ka9ap6v
20 ToO piou Kai dvOppicTOV dvTiTi9evTac. aTTac Tdp 6 urrep thc Kai urro thc xpuc6c dpeTfic ouk dvTdSioc E Kard TTXdTUJva, Kai to toO CdXuivoc Ix^iv dei bei TTp6xeipov
*dXX' fiiueTc auToTc ou bia|U€H|;6|ue6a
25 Tfic dpeTfjc t6v ttXoOtov' oube Te Podc bebeiTTViCfievuiv 9edTpu)V oub^ Ti|udc Kal TTpoebpiac Trap' euvouxoic Kai TraXXaKaTc oube caTpa- TTeiac paciXe'uJV £riXujT6v Tdp oubev oube KaXov ii
1,285— 286H. ' 6, 343— 345 R.
22. nXdTiwva] Legg. V. p. 728A C6Xujvoc] Bergk.
p. 427' 27. o06^*: Kai caTpoTreiac Reiskius: ca-
TpaTreiaic
Plutarchi Moralia. Vol. I. 14
210 DE CAPIENDA EX INIMICIS UTILITATE
r aicxpoO (pu6)nevov. dXX' lirei TuqpXoOiai t6 (piXoOv 7T€pi t6 (piXoujLievov , ujc (pticiv 6 TTXdTiuv, Kai [xak- Xov fiiuiv 01 ex6poi Trapexouciv aicericiv dcxnMOVoOv- Tec, bei juriTe t6 x«ipov ^qp' oTc djaapTdvouciv dpT6v elvai, |nr|Te t6 XuTTOujaevov l(p' oic KaTopGoOciv, dXX' 5 e7TiXoYiZec6ai bi' d)i(poTe'pujv ottujc Td fxkv (puXaTTO- laevoi peXTiovec iujiev auTUJV, Td be )uii)aou)aevoi /ir) Xeipovec.
1,286H. «,345B
2. TTXdiTiuv] Legg. V. p. 731 E
n E p I 03
no AT^IAIAS.
]. Meviuva tov OeTxaXov oiojaevov ^v XoYoic iKavuuc 13 ■fefUMvaceai Kai toOto bf] t6 utto toO 'CjaTrebOKXeouc AeTOMevov
'coqpiric in' oKpoici 0a)aiZ;eiv'
5 ripiuTncev 6 CuJKpdTric ti dpeTri ecTiv • dTroKpiva)ie'vou b' iTajaoic eKeivou xai Trpoxeipiuc oti Kai Traiboc dcTiv dpeTH Kai TrpecpuTOu Kai dvbpoc Kai YuvaiKOc koi dpxovToc Kai ibiuuTou Kai becTTOTOu Kai eepdTTovTOC, 'eu Y£' eiTrev 6 CoiKpdTnc *6ti laiav dpeTfjv aiTrieeic
10 cMfivoc dpeTujv KeKivriKac', ou KaKuic TeK)iaip6)uevoc OTi )aribe)aiav eibdic dpeTfiv dvepujTTOC TioXXdc ujv6)aa- z;ev. dp' ouv ouxi Kai r\\x\v dv tic CTTixXeudceiev 6ti fjribeTruj |iiav (piXiav KeKTimevoi pe^aiujc qpopoujaeea C ^11 Xdeuj^ev eic TToXuqpiXiav e)aTrec6vTec ; cxebov ydp
i'> oubev biacpe'po)aev dvepwTTOu koXoPoO Kai TuqpXoO, (popoujaevou )ufi Bpidpeujc 6 eKaTdfxeip Kai "Apfoc 6 TTav6TTTr|C ftvriTai. KaiTOi tov yc Trapd tuj Mevdv-
1,287H. 6, 346- 347 R.
4. coqpiric Sextus Enipiricus: coqpiac 5. CuJKpctTric]
Plat Men. p. 71 E 17. Mcvdvfepuj] Meinek. IV. p. 241
14*
212 DE AMICOEUM
bpiu veavicKOV tJirepqpuujc eiraivoOMev eiTTovra 0au- luacTov ocov vojLiiZieiv 'dYaGov CKacTOv', av 'exijl (piXou CKidv'.
2. 'GvavTioOTai be jueTd ttoXXujv dXXuuv oux nKicTa Trpoc qpiXiac ktticiv f) Tfic TioXuqpiXiac 6pe5ic, ujcTtep dKoXdcTwv YUvaiKuJv tuj TToXXdKic Kai ttoXXoTc cujli- DTrXe'Kec6ai tu»v TrpujTuuv KpaTeTv fif) buvaiueVoic djue- Xou^ievujv Kai drroppeovTUJV * iudXXov b' ujCTrep 6 ttic Tii/iTTuXric Tp6qpi)Lioc eic tov Xei|biu)va KaGicac ebpeTrev
'eTepov eqp' eTe'puj aip6)ievoc lo
dypeuju' dvBdujv fibojueva ipuxa
t6 vfjTTiov dTrXricTov exujv', o(5tujc CKacTOv fijuuiv bid t6 qpiXdKaivov Kai dipiKopov |j 6 Trp6cqpaT0C dei Kal dveiLv drrdYeTai, Kai jaeTaTi- ' Grici rroXXdc 6|iAoO Kai dTeXeic dpxdc rrpdTTOVTac qpi- is Xiac Kai cuvr|9eiac, epuJTi toO biujKOja^vou rrapepxo- E iLievouc t6 KaTaXa|LiPav6|Lievov. TrpuiTov |u^v ouv ujcTrep dqp* ecTiac dpHdjLievoi thc toO piou qpf||uric r\\ urrep qpiXujv Pepaiuiv dTToXe'XoiTTev fi|LiTv, t6v |LiaKp6v Kai TTaXai6v aiujva ludpTupa djua toO Xoyou Kal cu|uPou- Xov Xdpuj)uev, ev dj KaTd 2!eOYOC qpiXiai XeYOVTai 0ri- ceuc Kai TTeipi8ouc, 'AxiXXeuc Kai TTdTpoKXoc, 'OpecTric | Kai TTuXdbric, OivTiac Kai Adiuujv, '£TTa|Lieivujvbac Kai TTeXoTribac. cuvvojuov Ydp f) qpiXia Iwov ouk d^e- XaTov ecTiv oube KoXoiujbec, Kai t6 dXXov auT6v 25 flY€Tc6ai t6v qpiXov Kai rrpocaYOpeuetv
*t6v ^TaTpov 'eTepov' oubev dcTiv n fieTpLu' qpiXiac t\} budbi XPiuMevujv. ouTe Ydp bouXouc ouTe
1, 287— 289 H. C, 347— 350 B,
4. ivavTioOTai*: airiov 5. irpoc*: elc 10. Nauck.
p. 468 12. a-rrXriCTOv p. 661 F: fixPICTOV 17. t6 Reis-
kius: Tov 21. qpiXiai Steplianus: qpiXiac 27. t6v*
J^rcLTlTUDINE 213
qpiXouc ecTi KTrjcaceai ttoXXoOc drr* oXrfOU vo)nic)aa- F Toc. Ti oijv v6mc)Lia ^iXiac; euvoia Kai x«pic )-i€t' dpeTfic, u)V oub^v ^x^i cTravioOTepov f) q)ucic. oOev t6 c(p6bpa cpiXeiv Kai cpiXeTceai upoc ttoXXouc ouk
5 ecTiv, dXX' ujcTTep oi TTOTajuoi noXXdc cxiceic Kai Ka- TaTO)idc XajupdvovTec dceeveic Kai X€tttoi peouciv, ouTUJ To cpiXeTv ev vpuxTJ cq)obp6v tt€(puk6c eic ttoX- Xouc )nepi26)Lievov eHa^aaupoOTai. bio Kai tijuv ZIujijuv t6 qpiXoTeKVOV toTc )liovot6koic icxup6T€pov d^q)ueTai,
10 Ktti "O^ripoc dxaTTriT^v ui6v ovojndZ^ei ')noOvov tti- XuT€Tov', toOt' ecTi t6v toTc \iY\T' Ixouciv eTepov to- 94 veOci )ar|e' eEouci ■f€T€vri|ae'vov.
3. T6v be q)iXov fi)aeTc 'jlioOvov' )Ltev ouk dEioO- |i£V etvai, ^eT' dXXou be TriXuTeT6c tic Kai oqjiTOvoc
; 15 lcTU), TOV epuX0U)LieV0V CKCTVOV Xp6\{U TUJV dXuJv CUT-
l KaTebribOKUJC nebi^avov, oux uJCTrep vOv ttoXXoi q)iXoi Xe- T6)ievoi cu)iTTi6vTec a-nal f\ cucq)aipicavT€C rj cuTKupeu- cavTec f| cuTKaTaXucavTec ^k TravboKeiou Kai rraXaicTpac Kai dTopac q)iXiav cuXXe'TOuciv. ev be TaTc tujv ttXou-
i^o ciujv Kai f]Te)LioviKUJV oiKiaic ttoXuv oxXov Kai edpu- B ^ov dcTraZ!o)ie'vujv Kai beEiou)Lievujv Kai bopuqjopouvTUJV opuJVTec €ubai)aoviZ;ouci touc TroXuqjiXouc. KaiToi rrXei- ovdc T€ )nuiac ev toTc orcTavioic auTuiv opuJciv. dXX' oue' auTai TTic Xixveiac out' CKeTvoi Tfic xP^iac ctti-
-'^ XiTTOucric TTapa)Li^vouciv. eTrei b' f\ dXrieivfi qjiXia Tpia Z;r|T€T jidXicTa, Tfjv dpeTfjv ujc KaX6v, Kai Tfiv cuvfieeiav ibc fibu , koi Tfjv xpeiav ujc dvaTKaTov (bei Tdp dnobeEaceai KpivavTa Kai xwipciv cuv6vTa Kai xpficeai be6|uevov, a TrdvTa TTp6c Tf]v TroXuqjiXiav uTrev-
^o avTioOTai , Kai )adXicTd ttujc t6 KupiuiTaTOV f) Kpicic),
l, 290— 291 H. 6, 350-35211.
10. "OMripoc] I 498. ir 19 11. |inT'*: ixi)
214 DE AMICORUM
CKeTTT€OV 7Tpu)Tov €1 buvttTov dcTiv ^v PpaxcT xpovoi C boKi|Lidcai xop^^Tcic cuYXopeucojuevouc, epeTac 6|uop- po6ricovTac, oiKeTac xpJIMaTuuv erriTpoTrouc f\ TeKvuiv TraibaYUJYOuc dco|Lie'vouc , \xy\x\ ye cpiXouc ttoXXouc eic (xYuJva Tidcric Tuxnc cuvaTTobuco|uevouc, div ^KacTOC 5 auToc 9' auTOV
*TrpdTTUJV eu TOrjCiv eic |ae'cov, ToO bucTuxoOc Te XaYxavuuv ouk dxSeTai'.
ouTe vaOc eTri tocoutouc eXKETai xeiMu^vac eic GdXaT- Tav, ouTe xwpioic OpiYKOuc Kai Xi|ae'ci rrpocpdXXouciv w epKri Ktti x^bjjiaxa thXikoutouc Trpocbexdiaevoi Kivbu- Dvouc Kai tocoutouc, ocujv eTtaYYeXXeTai (piXia KaTa- qpuYnv Ktti por|0eiav, dpGujc Kai pepaiujc eHeTacGeica. Tujv b' dveSeTdcTuic TtapappuevTUJV ujcTiep vo|iiC)Lxd- Tujv dbOKi|uujv eXeYXOMtvujv ^^
*oi laev ecTepriMevoi Xaipouciv, o\ b' exovTCC euxovTai q)UY€iv'.
^cTi be toOto xctXeTTOv Kai ou pdbiov, t6 q)UY€Tv f| dTTo9ec0ai bucapecTOU|Lievr|v qpiXiav. dXX' uicirep ciTiov pXapepov Kai bucxepaivoiuevov ouie KaT^x^iv oiov Te 20 [XX] XuTToOv Kai bia(p0eTpov out' ^KpdXXeiv olov eicfiX- 0ev dXX' eibex0ec Kai cu|iTTeq)up|iievov Kai dXXoKOTOv, ouTUJ (piXoc rrovripoc fj cuvecTi Xuttuiv Kai Xujaaivo- luevoc, f| pi(x iuct' ex0pac Kai bucjueveiac uJCTTep xo^ Tic eHeTTece. 25
E 4. Aio bei |ufi p(xbiujc TTpocbex€c0ai |Lir|^€ koX- Xdc0ai ToTc evTUYX«vouci jurib^ qpiXeTv toijc biwKOv-
1, 291—292 H. 6, 332—355 E.!
1. cKeittdov*: CKeTTT^ov bk 7. Nauck. p. 697
10. -rrepipciXXouciv * ? 16. Nauck. p. 215 23. Xu|iai-
v6|aevoc*: XunoOjaevoc
MULTITUDINE 215
TCtc, d\Xa ToOc d2iouc cpiXiac biujKeiv. ou Tdp ctipe- reov iTdvTUJC t6 pabioic dXiCKoiuevov. Kai Ydp dTra- pivr|v Kai pdTov eiTiXa)Lipavo)Lievriv uTteppdvTec Kai bnjucdjaevQi pabiZ;o|Liev ^tti thv eXdav Kai thv d|UTTe- 5 Xov. ouTuu bei jJix) Tov euxepoic TTepiTTXeKoiuevov ttoi- eic0ai cuvriGri, dXXd toTc dHioic CTTOubfic Kai luqpeXi- laoic auTOuc TrepmXe^KecGai boKi|adcavTac.
5. "QcTTep ouv 6 ZeuHic aiTiuJiLievuJV auTov tivuuv F oTi Z!uJYpacpeT Ppabeujc, 'ojuoXotu)' eiTTCV 'ev TtoXXuj 10 xpovLU Tpdcpeiv, Kai Ydp eic ttoXuv', outuj (piXiav beT Kai cuvriGeiav cibZieiv TrapaXapdvTac ev ttoXXuj Kpi^eT- cav. dp' oijv KpTvai ^iv ouk ecTi ttoXXouc q)iXouc pdbiov, cuveTvai be ttoXXoTc 6juo0 pdbiov, fi Kai toOto dbuvaTOv; Kai )ufiv dTToXaucic ecTiv fi cuvn^eia 15 Tfic qpiXiac, Kai t6 fibiCTOV 4v Tiu cuveTvai Kai cuv- biriiuepeueiv •
' ou )uev Tdp Ziujoi Y€ cpiXuJV dTrdveuGev ^Taipujv PouXdc ^Ziojuevoi PouXeuco)uev'. Kai TTepi ToO 'Obucce'ujc 6 Meve'Xaoc 95
20 'oube' Kev dXXo
a)U|ue bie'Kpivev qpiXeovTe tc TepTTO|ae'vuj t€, npiv t' oTe bf] GavdTOio |ueXav ve'qpoc djiqpe-
KdXuipe'. TouvavTiov oijv eoiKev r\ KaXoujuevri TToXuqpiXia TTOieTv. 25 f] juev Tdp cuvdTei Kai cuvicTrici Kai cuvexei KaTaTTu- KVoOca TaTc ojuiXiaic Kai qpiXoqppocuvaic
'ujc b' 6t' 6tt6c TdXa XeuK6v eTOjUqpoicev Kai
CTTnHe '
1, 292-293 H. 6, 355-357 E.
5. bei W: ctei 6. cuvrjQri*: cuvnBri KaX6v 7.
&OKi)adcavTac Reiskius: 6oKi|a(S3ovTac 17. Homer. V 78
20. Id. 6 179
216 DE AMICORUM
B Kai' 'G)aiTeboKXe'a (TomuTriv y«P H (piXia pouXeTai TTOieiv evoTriTa Kai cujaTTriHiv), f) be TToXuq)iXia biicTrici Kai dTTOCTTci Kai dirocTpecpei, tuj iueTaKaXeiv Kai iueTa- ; (pe'peiv dXXoTe Kpoc dXXov ouk eujca Kpaciv oube KoXXrjciv euvoiac iv Trj cuvr|Qeia rrepixuGeicri Kai ua- 5 Yeicr] teveceai. touto b' eueOc urtopdXXei Kai Trjv TTepi Tdc uTTOupYioic dva))iaXiav Kai bucKoXiav Td Tdp euxpncTtt Tfic q)iXiac bucxpncTa Y»TveTai bid Triv rtoXucpiXiav.
'dXXov TpoTcov' Tdp 'dXXujv ^Ycipe» qppovTic dv- iji
epuuTTUJV ' • ;
ouT€ Ydp o\ (puceic fmuLiv ^tti TauTd Taic opiaaTc pe- ; rrouciv, ouTe Tuxaic 6|liotp6ttoic dei cuvec)Liev oi t€ ]
C tOjv TrpdHeujv Kaipoi KaedTTCp Td TTveujuaTa touc fiev <pe'pouci ToTc b' dvTmiTTTOuci. i
6. KaiTOi Kdv TtdvTec d|aa tuiv auToiv oi (piXoi bewvTai, xa^^TTOV dHapK€'cai TTdci pouXeuo)Lievoic F| TToXiTeuo)ievoic r| (piXoTijLiou)Li^voic r\ uTrobexoi^evoic. dv b' ^vi Kaipil» biaqpopoic TTpdYiaaci Kai TTdeeci Ttpoc- TUTX«vovTec 6)LioO TTapaKaXujciv 6 ^lv TrXeujv cuv- a aTTobri)^eTv , 6 be Kpivoiuevoc cuvbiKeTv, 6 be Kpivujv cuvbiKdZleiv, 6 be TrmpdcKUJV n dTOpdZujv cuvbioiKeTv, 6 be TttM^v cuveOeiv, 6 be edTTTUJV cujUTreveeTv,
'rroXic b' 6|Liou |aev eu|Liia|LidTUJV ^ipirTi,
6)Liou b^ TTaidvujv t€ Kai CTevaTindTUJV ' 25
Dt[ TToXucpiXia, TTdci iuev d)ir|xavov TrapeTvai, |Lir|b€vi b' dTOTTOV, ^vi b' urroupToOvTa TTpocKpoueiv rroXXoTc dviapov
1 , 293-294 H. 6, 357-358 R.
7..6ucK0\iav Emperius: buciuiTiftv 10. Bergk. p. 1344^ 24. Soph. 0. R. 4
MULTITUDINE 217
'oubeic "fap «TCTTUJV auToc d)ieX€i6' f)beujc'. KaiTOi Tcic d|LieXeiac Kai paeujiiac tujv ^iXuuv TrpaoTe- pov cpepouci, Kai Totc TOiauTac dTToXoTiac d|nriviTUJC bexovTai TTap' auTuJv * 4HeXa96)ariv ' ^nTVorica'. 6
5 be Xe'TUJV 'ou TtapecTriv coi biKnv exovTi, TrapicTdjLtriv Tdp eT€'puj qpiXuj', Kai * TTupe'TTOVTd ce ouk elbov, tuj beivi Tdp cpiXouc ^CTidiVTi cuvricxoXou|Lir|v ' akiav Tf|C djneXeiac Tfjv eTepujv eTTijLieXeiav Troioujuevoc ou Xuei TTiv |ae)aqjiv, dXXd TTpoceTTipdXXei ZiriXoTurriav. dXX' E
10 oi TToXXoi Tdc TToXuqpiXiac a buvavTai TTapexeiv iiiovov U)C eOlK€ CKOTTOUCIV, 0. h' dvTaTTaiTouci TTapopujci , Kai oii |ivri)noveuouciv oti bei tov rroXXoic eic d beiTai Xpu))uevov TToXXoTc beojuevoic dvGuTTOupTeiv. ujcTTep ouv 6 Bpidpeujc ^KaTov x^pciv eic TcevTriKOVTa cpopuJv
lo TacT€'pac oub^v fi)LiuJv TrXe'ov eixe tujv drTo buoTv xepoTv )Liiav KOiXiav bioiKOuvTUJV, outujc ev tuj rroX- XoTc qpiXoic xpncOcti Kai t6 XeiTOupTeTv ttoXXoTc ev- ecTi Kai t6 cuvaTuJvmv Kai t6 cuvacxoXeTcGai Kai t6 cuTKd)aveiv. ou Tdp GupiTTibr) TTeiCTeov XeTOVTi
2^ ^XPnv Tdp )LieTpiac eic dXXfiXouc cpiXiac GvriToiJc dvaKipvacGai Kai |ufi TTp6c dKpov )LiueX6v ipuxfjc, F
euXuTa b' eivai CTepTnGpa qppevuJv, dTTO t' ujcacGai Kai HuvTeTvai', 25 KaGdTTep TToba veujc evbibovTi Kai TTpocdTOVTi TaTc Xpeiaic Tfiv qpiXiav. dXXd toOto )uev, uJ €upiTTibii, )aeTa6u)|uev eTTi Tdc ex6pac, Kai KeXeuujjaev jueTpiac
3, 294-295 H. 6, 358-36' B.
1. Meinek. IV. p. 282 16. Iv tu) itoWoic (pi\oic
XpficGai Halmius: Iv toic qpiXoic xPnciMOv 18. t6 cuy-
Kdiuveiv*: cuYKd.uveiv 20. laeTpiac — qpiXiac* (Hippol.
253): jueTpiav — cpiXiav 23. CT^pYriGpd*: e^\-fnTpa
218
DE AMICORUM
TTOieTcOai xdc blacpopdc Kai \xr\ Trpoc fiKpov ^iueXdv ipuxnc, euXuTtt b' eivai )iicn Kai dpydc Kai ^empi- ILioipiac Ka» uTTOvoiac" dKeivo b^ ^dXXov f]|iTv rrapai-
OCvei t6 TTuGafopiKov ')ifi ttoXXoTc ^iapdXXeiv beEidv*, TOUT* lcTi piX] TToXXouc TTOieTcGai qpiXouc \xr\bk ttoXu- Koivov \xr\bi TTdvbr|)iOV dcTrdJecGai cpiXiav Ka\ Trpoc ^vavTinv f| ^eTd ttoXXiuv TTaOuiv eicioOcav, ujv to |j^v cuvafuividv Kai cuvdxOecBai Kai cuinTTOveTv Ka\ cuTKivbuveueiv rrdvu bucoiCTov toTc dXeu9^poic Kai Yevvaioic dcTi. t6 be toO cocpoO XiXuuvoc dXri6^c, 8c TTpoc t6v eiTTOVTa nri^tva ix^iy ^xOp6v *foiKac' ^qpn *cO liribe qpiXov Ix^iv'. a\ fap Ix9pa> toTc cpiXiaic euGuc dTTaKoXouOoOci Kai cu|iTTXeK0VTai, ^Trei-
B TTep (7) ouK ^cTi cpiXov txr] cuvabiKeTcOai ^r\bk cuva- boEeiv ^n^^ cuvaTTexOdvecOar ol tdp ^x^poi t6v cpi- Xov euOuc ucpopiiJVTai Te Kai ^icoOciv, ol be cpiXoi TToXXdKic cpOovoOci tc Kai 2[riXoTUTToOci Kai TTepiCTTU)- civ. ujcTTep ouv 6 tuj Ti)ir|cioi irepl thc dTTOiKiac 6o- Oeic xPncMOC TTporiYopeuce
*Q}xr]\a lieXiccdiuv Tdxa toi koi ccpnKec ^covtoi',
ouTUJC 01 (piXuuv ZtitoOvt€c dc)i6v ^XaOov dxOpoiv ccprjKiaic TTepiTTec6vT€c. Kai ouk icov &f€\ CTaOiudv ^xOpoO livnciKaKia Kai q)iXou xop>c. 6pa bk touc 0i- C XiiiTOu Kai TTapineviujvoc qpiXouc Kai olKeiouc S bi^- 9tik€V 'AX^Eavbpoc, & touc Aiuuvoc Aiovuctoc Ka\ ss Touc TTXauTou Nepuuv koi touc CniavoO TiP^pioc CTpe- pXoOvTec Ka\ dTTOKTivvOovTec. wc Tdp t6v Kp^ovTa Tf\c 6uYaTp6c oubev 6 xpuc6c oub' 6 tt^ttXoc dbcp^- Xei, t6 bk ttOp dvaq)0^v alcpvibiuuc TTpocbpa)i6vTa Ka\
l, 295—297 H. 6, 360— 362F
25, Aiovucioc Kal*: biovOcioc
MULTITUDINE -219
TTepiTTTuHavia KateKauce Kai cuvaTTubXecev, outuuc evioi Tuuv q)iXiJuv oub^v (XTToXaucavTec cutuxouvtuuv cuv- aTtoXXuvTai bucTuxoOci. Kai toOto iudXiCTa Trdcxouciv 01 9iX6coq)oi Kai xcpi^vTec, djc Giiceuc tuj TTeipi9uj 5 KoXaCojuevLu Kai bebeiueviu
'aiboOc dxaXKeuToic cuve2euKTai Trebaic',
Iv be Tuj Xoijauj cpriciv 6 GouKubibtic touc dpeTficD ludXiCTtt jueTaTTOioujLievouc cuvarroXXucGai toTc qpiXoic vocouciv nqpeibouv ^dp cqpOuv auTuuv idvTec Trapd i^ Touc eTTiTTibeiouc.
8. "09€v THC dpeTnc dcpeibeiv ou ttpochkov dX- Xot' dXXoic cuvbouvTac auTriv Kai cuiaTTXeKovTac, dXXd Toic dSioic Tfjv auTfic KOivuuviav qpuXdTTeiv, toOt' ecTi TOic OMoiiuc qpiXeiv Kai KOivujveTv buva-
15 iuevoic. Kai ^dp bx] touto TrdvTUJV nificxov ecTiv evavTiujjua TTpoc Tfjv TToXucpiXiav , 8ti Trj cpiXia t^ve- cic bi' 6juoi6Tr|T6c ecTiv. okou Tdp Kai Td dvpuxa Tdc juiSeic TTpoc Td dvdjuoia TioieTTai jueTd piac dvaT- KaZ;6|Lieva Kai oKXdZei Kai dTavaKTei cpeuTOVTa dTT ' e
20 dXXriXujv, ToTc be cuttcv^ci Kai oiKeioic 6jLioiOTTa9eT Kepavvujueva Kai TTpocieTai thv KOivuuviav Xeiujc Kai |neT' eujueveiac, ttujc oiov Te qpiXiav fi9eci bia(p6poic €TTevec9ai Kai TTd9eciv dvojuoioic Kai pioic eTe'pac rrpoaipeceic Ixouciv; f| juev Tdp TTepi ipaXiuouc Kai
20 qpdpiuiTTac dpjuovia bf dvTicpuOvuJv exei to cujucpuj- vov, oHuTrici Ktti PapuTrjCiv djuujCT€TTuuc 6juoi6TriTOC
1, 297— 298H. 6, 3f32— 364B.
6. aiboOc*: Tre6aic dxotXKeuxoic cuveZicuKTai Stepha-
nus: dxaXKeuToiciv gZ^euKtai ■ir^6aic*: Ttobac 7. 9ou- Ku6i6nc] II 51 11. 69ev*: 69ev oOtudc 17. fin^uxa]
fiXoYa W 20. 6|uoiOTTo9ei W: 6|aoiTa9ei
220 "DE AMICORUM
eYTiTVO)aevric • ific be q)i\iKfic cujucpujviac Taurnc Kai dpjaovmc oubev dv6|Lioiov oub' dviu)uaXov ovb' dvi- cov eivai bei jii€'poc, dW eH dTrdvTuuv ojuoiuuc exov- F Tuuv 6|LioXoT€iv Kai ojLiopouXeiv Kai 6]uoboHeTv Kai cuvojLiOTTaGeTv, OucKep jaidc ipuxnc ev nXeioci birjpri- 5 jLievr|c ciu|Liact.
9, Tic oijv lcTiv ouTUJC dveTTijuovoc Kai jueTdpo- Xoc Kai TravTobaTToc dvGpujiTOC, ujCTe ttoXXoTc ^auTov - eEojLioiouv Kai TrpocapjuoTTeiv Kai jur| KaTaTeXdv toO GeoTViboc TiapaivoOvTOc lo
'TTOuXuTTObOC VOOV lCXe TTOXUXPOOU, 6C TTOTl
TteTpri , T^ TTep 6mXr|cr), toToc ibeTv eqpdvri;*
KaiTOi Tou TToXuTToboc ai jaeTapoXai pdGoc ouk exou- civ, dXXd Trepl auTriv TiTvovTai t^v eTTicpdveiav, ctu- i5 97 cpoTTiTi Kai jLiavoTriTi Tdc dTTOppodc tujv TTXriciaZiovTUJV dvaXajupdvoucav • ai be qpiXiai Td fiGri ZItitoOci cuveHo- juoioOv, Kai Td Trd9r| Kai touc Xotouc Kal Td ^TTiTr;- | beujaaTa Kai Tdc bia8k€ic. TTpuJTeujc tivoc ouk eu- | TuxoOc oub^ TTdvu XPTICTOO TO ^PTOV, dXX' urro Ton- ^ Teiac ^auTov eic ^Tepov eiboc eH eTe'pou jueTaXXdTTovToc i iv TauTUJ TToXXdKic, (piXoXoTOic cuvavaTiTVuucKOVTOC Ktti TTaXaiCTaTc cuTKOVioiuevou Kai (piXoGripoic cut- KUvriTeToOvTOC Kai (piXorroTaic cu|ajLie9ucKOja€'vou Kai uoXiTiKoTc cuvapxaipecidZiovToc, ibiav fj9ouc lcTiav 25 ouK exovTOC. dic be Tfiv dcxriMctTiCTOV 01 cpuciKOi B Kai dxpOujaaTOV ouciav Kai uXriv XeTOuciv uTTOKeijue- vrjv Kai TpeTTOjLtevnv uqp' auTfic vOv juev (pXeTec9ai vOv b' €HuTpaivec9ai, totc b' €Haepo0c9ai TTriTVuc9ai
1, 298-299 H. 6, 364-366 B,
7. dvenfiuovoc*: ^ttiuovoc 11. Bergk. p. 500 ^
MULTITUDINE 221
b' aijGic, ouTuuc apa Trj TToXuqpiXia Hiuxnv uTTOKekeai bericei, TToXuTraGfi Kai ttoXutpottov Kai UYpdv Kai pabiav lueTapdXXeiv. dXX' r\ qpiXia CTdcijuov ti Z!r|Tet Kai pepaiov riGoc Kai d)iieTdTrTUJTOV ev fiia. x^P« Kai 5 cuvr|6eia. bio Ktti CTrdviov Kai buceupeTov ecTi qpiXoc Pepaioc.
1, 299H. 8,866E.
nEPi TrxH2.
1. 'Tuxn Tct GvriTuJv npdYiiaT', ouk eupouXia*. TTOiepov oub€ biKaiocuvri Tct GvnToiv npdTMaTa oub' »c6- TJic oube cwqppocuvr) oub^ KOciaioTric, dXX' ^k tuxhc H^v KOi bid Tuxnv 'ApicTeibnc dvcKapTeprice Tfj Trevia,
DTToXXOuv xPnMaTiuv Kupioc T€v^c6ai buvd|aevoc, koi ^ CKiTriuuv KapxTibova dXiuv oub^v out' ^Xa^ev out' clbe Tu>v Xaqpuptuv , eK Tuxnc be Kai bid tuxtiv 0iXo- KpdTTic Xapwv xP^ciov napd OiXinnou 'ndpvac koI IxeOc TiYopaJIe', Kai AacG^vnc Kai eOeuKpdTTic dniO- Xecav "OXuveov, 't^ yacTpi jieTpoOvTec Kai toic al- cxicTOic Trjv eubai^oviav;' dn6 Tuxnc b' 6 |iev <t>i- Xinnou 'AX^Eavbpoc auTOc Te tuiv aixMaXuuTiuv dnei- X6T0 TuvaiKuiv Ka\ touc OppiJIovTac ^KoXaZev, 6 bk TTpid)iou bai|iOvi KaKuJ koi tux»,i xPlcdMevoc cuveKOi- mSto ttJ toO gdvou YuvaiKi, Ka\ Xapdiv auTfiv iwi- i'
E nXr|C€ noX^MO^ »<ai KaKuuv Tdc buo T^neipouc ; cl ydp TaOTa TiYveTai bid Tuxnv, Ti KujXuei Ka\ Tdc YaXfic Kai Touc Tpdyouc koi touc nier|KOuc cuvexeceai q)d- vai bid TuxTiv Tatc Xixveiaic Ka\ toic dKpociaic Ka\ TaTc PwMoXoxiaic ; so
l.SCO— 301H. «,8«T-S«8RJ
1. Nauck. p. C07 15. iv^TtXticc*: iv^TrXiic^ t€
19. ToTc pWMoXoxiaic • : PuiMoXoxiaic
DE FORTUNA 223
j 2. €i b' ?CTi cuuqppociivri Kai biKaiocuvr) Kai dv-
bpeia, TTUJC XoTov Ixei ^xf] eivai cppovriciv; €i be (ppo-
I VTicic, TTUJC eupouXiav |uti eivai; f) tap cujq)pocuvr| cppovricic Tic ecTiv ujc Xctouci, Kai fi biKaiocuvri ttic
5 qppovr|ceujc beiTai Ttapoucric, jnaXXov be thv euPouXiav Kai Tfiv cppovriciv ^v |uev fibovaic dTa8ouc rrapexo- |U€'vriv CTKpdTeiav Kai cujcppocuvriv KaXou|uev, ^v be Kivbuvoic Kai TTOvoic KttpTepiav Kai dvbpaTaGiav, ev be KOivujvfmaci Kai iroXiTeiaic euvo|aiav Kai biKaio-
10 cuvrjv. oOev ei Td ttic euPouXiac l'pTa ttic Tuxric bi- P KaioG|U€v eivai, ecTUJ Tuxnc Kai Td t^c biKaiocuvnc Kai Td Tf|c cujqppocuvrjc , Kai vfi Aia t6 KXerrTeiv tu- Xnc lcTUj Kai t6 paXavTiOTOjueiv Kai t6 dKoXacTaiveiv, Kai |Lie9e|U€voi tujv oiKeiujv XoTicjuiwv eic t^v tuxtiv
15 ^auTOuc dq)ujjaev uJCTrep uTr6 TTvevj|uaTOC rtoXXoO ko- viopt6v ^ cup(peT6v eXauvojuevouc Kai biaqpepoiaevouc. eOpouXiac Toivuv juf) oucric oube pouXfiv eiK6c etvai TTepi TTpaTMdTUJV oube CKeipiv oube tf|Tr|civ toO cu)li- q)epovTOc, dXXd eXfipricev eiTTibv 6 CoqpoKXfic oti
20 'TTav t6 2nTou|uevov 98
dXujTov, eKqpeuTei be TdiaeXouiaevov * Kai TidXiv au Td TTpdTiaaTa biaipwv
*Td juev bibaKTd |aav9dvuj, Td b' eupeTd ZrjTUJ, Ttt b' euKTd TTapd 9eOuv f|Tricd|ar|v'.
25 xi Tdp eupeT6v f| Ti |aa9riT6v ecnv dv9pa)TT0ic , ei TTdvTa TTepaiveTai KaTd Tuxnv ; ttoTov b* ouk dvaipei- Tai pouXeuTfjpiov TToXeujc f| ttoTov ou KaTaXueTai cuv- ebpiov paciXeujc, ei utt6 Tfi tuxti TTdvTa ecTiv, r\v tu- cpXfiv XoibopoOjuev, luc TuqpXoi TTepiTriTTTOVTec auTiD;
1, 301—302 H. 6, 368—370 R.
2. U* 16. Kai W: ?| 19. Co<poKXfic] 0. R. 110
23. Nauck. p. 243
224 DE FORTUNA
B Ti b' ou |aeXXo|Li€v, orav ujcirep 6|Li)LiaTa Tfjv eOpou- Xiav dKKOijjavTec auTuJv toO piou Tuq)Xfjv x^ipcYuJTov XajLipdvuj)Li€V ;
3. KaiTOi (pdpe Xe'Yeiv Tiva fijuujv u)C tux»1 tci Tujv pXeTTovTuiv TTpdtTiLiaTa, ouk 6ipic oOb* 'ojjijxam^ (pujcq)6pa', q)riciv 6 TTXdTujv, Kai Tuxn Td tu)v dKOU- ovTwv, ou buva)Liic dvTiXriTTTiKfi TTXtiYfic depoc bi' djToc Kai dTKeq)dXou TTpocq)epo|uevric * KaXov b*, wc foiKev, eOXapeicGai Tfjv aicGriciv. dXXd lafjv Tfjv oqjiv Kai dKofiv Kai tcOciv Kai 6cq)priciv Kai Td Xomd |Lie'pri « ToO cuijLiaTOc Kai Tdc buvdiaeic auTu»v ujrripeciav eu-
C PouXiac Kai q)povr|ceujc r\ q)ucic fjveTKev fijuTv, Kai 'voOc 6p^ Kai voOc dKOuei, TdXXa' be 'KU)q)d Kai Tuq)Xd'. Kai ujciTep fiXiou ^fi ovtoc eveKa tu)V dXXu)V dcTpuJV euq)p6vnv dv fJTO)Li€v, ujc cpY\civ 'HpdKXeiToc, * ouTUJC ^V€Ka Touv aic6f|ceujv, ei )uf| voOv lurjb^ Xotov 6 dvGpujTTOC ^cxev, oubev dv bie'q)epe tuj piuj tujv Sripiujv. vOv b' ouK dTTo Tuxnc oub' auTO)udTUJC Tre- piec|uev auTujv Kai KpaToOjuev, dXX' 6 TTpO|ur|6euc, toOt' ecTiv 6 XoTiC)u6c amoc
iTTTTUJv 6vujv T* 6xeia Kai Taupujv Tovdc bouc dvTibujpa Kai ttovujv ^KbcKTopa
DKaT' AicxuXov. eTTei Tuxri T€ Kai q)ucei T€ve'ceujc djueivovi Td TrXeTcTa tujv dXoTUJv KexPHTai. Td juev ' Tdp ujTrXicTai Kepaci Kai dboOci Kai KevTpoic, 'auTdpas dxivoic' (pr]c\v '€jUTTeboKXfic
'oHupeXeTc x«iTai vujtoic ^TTiTreqjpiKaci ', Td b' uTTob^beTai Kai ^juqpiecTai q)oXici Kai Xdxvaic
1, 302-304 H. 6, 370—371 Bi
6. TTXdTUJv] Tim. p. 45 B 11. koI xac feuvd|Lieic Reis-
kius: 6uvd|ueujc 21. Nauck. p. 50 24. dneivovi Reis-
kius: fijaeivov 26. ^x^voic Stephanus: ^xivoc
DE FORTUNA 225
Kai xn^ctic Ktti 6TTXaic dTroKpoTOic* ^ovoc b* 6 fiv- epujTroc Kaia tov TTXdTUJva 'tumvoc Kai doTrXoc Kai dvuTTobriToc Kai dcTpujTOc' Otto Tfic (puceujc dTToXe- XeiTTTai. 5 *dXX' 'ev biboOca TidvTa luaXedccei Tdbe', Tov XoTic|Li6v Kai Tfiv eTTiiueXeiav Kai Triv Trpdvoiav. E 'fi Ppaxi) |U€V ceevoc dvepoc" dXXd
TTOlKlXia TTpaTTlbUJV
beivd |uev qpOXa ttovtou 10 x^oviujv t' depiujv t€
bd)avaTai pouXeu)aaTa'. KOucpoTaTOv iTTTToi Kai ujKUTaTOV, dvepiuTTUj hk eeouci • iLidxiMOV Kuujv Kai eu)ioeibec, dXX' dvepujTTOV qpuXdT- Ter fibuTaTov ixeOc Kai TToXucapKov uc, dvepiuTTUj be 15 Tpoqpf) Kai 6v|jov dcTi. ti laeTZov eXecpavToc f\ cpope- piuTepov ibeTv; dXXd Kai oGtoc TTaiTviov TCTOvev dv- epiuTTOU Ktti ee'ajua TravriTupiKov, 6pxr|ceic Te |uavedvei Kal xopeiac Kai TTpocKuvr|ceic, ouk dxpfjcTUJC tuuv toi- ouTUJV TTapeicaTOMtvujv, dXX' iva |uavedvuj|uev ttoT F 20 Tov dvepujrrov f) qppovricic aipei Kai tivujv uTrepdvuj TTOieT, Kai TTuJc KpaTeT rrdvTujv Kai TrepiecTiv.
'ou Tap TTUTiudxoi ei).tev d)Liu)iovec oube Tra-
XaiCTai , oube TTOCi KpaiTTVUJc eeo)uev', 25 dXX' ev TTfici TouToic dTuxecTepoi tujv eripiujv ec)ue'v ' e)UTreipia be Ka\ |uvr|)uri Kai coqpia Kai Texvr) k^t' 'AvaEaTopav cqpujv t' auTd»v xPiwMe6« ^ai pXiTTO)uev
1,304— 306H. 6, 371-3T3R.
2. TTXdTUJva] Protag. p. 321 C 5. Nauck. p. 300
7. Id. p. 295 9. cpOXa ex p. 959 D 14. dvepuiTnu*:
dv9pij(jTT0ic 16. oOtoc Reiskius: toOto 19. ttoi*:
uoO 22. Homer. 0 246
Plutarchi Moralia. Vol. I. 15
22G DE FORTUNA
Kai d)a€XTO)iev Kai cp^poiaev Ka\ Sto^iev cuXXa)iPdvov- T€C, ujct' ^VTaG9a piriblv Tfic Toxric dXXd TtdvTa thc eOpouXiac eivai. 09 4. 'AXXd ^fiv Kai tu t€kt6vujv bnTTOu TTpdTMttTa
GvriTUJV ^Tl, Kttl Td XCt^^KOTUTTUJV KUl 0iK0b6|iUJV Kai 5
dvbpiavTOTroidjv, dv oic oubev auT0)adTU)c oub' ibc ^Tuxe KaTopGou)ievov 6pujMev. 6ti ^dp 'Ppaxeia co- (puj Tuxn TTap€)iTTiTTTei , Td b^ ' TTXciCTa Ktti ' ixifiQia' Tiliv ^pYUJv a\ T^xvcti cuvTeXoOci bi' aviTutv, Ka\ outoc UTTObebriXujKe ' lo i
'PdT' eic 6b6v bi] Tiac 6 x€»pa>va£ Xeujc, o'i Tfiv Ai6c TopTuiTTiv '€pTdvnv CTaTOic XiKvoici TTpocTpeTt€c6e ' • B Triv Tdp 'GpTdvriv ai Texvai Trdpebpov ou Tf)v Tuxnv exouciv. NedXKTi jievToi qpaciv ittttov ZuJTpaqpouvTa 15 ^ Toic ji^v dXXoic KaTopGoOv eibeci Kai xpiJ^M«c»> toO b' d(ppoO Tf|V 7r€p\ Ttu xa^ivuj KOTTTOjievriv xauvdTrjTa Ka\ t6 cuveKTTiTTTOv dc9Ma )ifi KaTop9o0vTa Tpdcpeiv T€ TToXXdKic Kai eEaXeicpeiv, TeXoc b' utt' 6pTfic Trpoc- paXeTv tlu TtivaKi t6v cttottov t&cnep elxe tujv qpap- 20 MOKUJV dvdTTXeujv, t6v be TTpocTTec6vTa 9au)iacTU)C dvaTTOMdHai Ka\ TTOifica» t6 beov. toOto IvTexvov Tuxnc )Li6vov \cTopeTTai. Kav6ci bk Kai CTa^MoTc Kai MeTpoic Kai dpi^MoTc navTaxoO xP^J^VTai , iva Mn^«MoO C t6 eiKH Kai dic 4'tux€ toTc ^pToic dTT^vrjTai. koi m^v 2^ a\ T^xvcxi M*'^?**^ Tivec elvai X^TOVTai qjpovfjceic, MdX- Xov b' dnoppoa\ qppovficeujc Ka\ dnoTpiMMCtTa dvbi- ecnapMeva Taic xptiaic Taic nepi tov piov, uicnep
1, 306—308 H. «, 8?8— 37:. U
7. Ppaxcia] Epicunis ap. Diog. L. X 144 11. Nnuck.
p. 248 14. *€pTavnv*: ipTdvriv Kal Tfjv denvdv J5.
N€(i\Kn Madvigius: Iva 29. xpeiaic ralc*: xpciaic
DE FORTUNA 227
aiviTTexai t6 TrOp utto toO TTpo|uri6euJC laepicGev aXXo dXXij biacrrapfivai. Kai Tctp Tiic qppovriceujc jLiopia Kai CTTdc|uaTa |iiKpd Gpauojuevnc Kai KaTaKep)uaTiZ!o|Ltevric eic TdEeic Kexwpnxe.
5 5. GaujuacTov ouv ^cti ttujc al luev Te'xvai Tnc Tuxnc ou beovTai Trpoc t6 oiKeTov TeXoc, f\ be Tracuuv jjeTicTri Ktti TeXeiOTdTTi Texvn Kai t6 KecpdXaiov Tfjc dv0pujTTivric eucpriiuiac Kai biKaiuuceujc oubev ecTiv. dXX' dv eTTiTdcei }xkv Kai dvecei xop^uJv eu^ouXia tic
10 ecTiv r\v luouciKriv KaXouci , Kai Ttepi dpTuciv 6vyu)v r[v |uaTeipiKf|v 6vo|udZ;o|uev, Kai Ttepi ttXuciv i|uaTiujv f\v TvaqpiKriv, touc t€ Traibac Kai uTtobeicOai Kai TiepipdX- D XecOai bibdcKO)uev Kai Trj juev beHia Xajupdveiv toO ovjiou Tfi b' dpiCTepa KpaTeiv tov dpTov, ujc oube toutuiv
15 TiTVO)uevu)v dTt6 Tuxnc dXX' eTTicTdceujc Kai Trpocoxfic beo|uevujv Td be jueTiCTa Kai KupiuuTaTa TTp6c eubai- juoviav ou TTapaKaXei Tf]v qjpovnciv, oube lueTexei toO KaTd XoTOv Kai Trpovoiav ; dXXd t^v |uev oubeic ubaTi beucac dcpfiKev, ujc dTT6 Tuxric Kai auTOjudTUJC TtXiv-
20 9ujv eco|ue'vujv , oub' epia Kai cKUTr) KTrjcdjuevoc Kd- GnTai Tf) Tuxri TTpoceuxdjuevoc ijudTiov auTUJ Kai utto- bfifuaTa T€vec9ar xP^Jciov be ttoXu cu|uq)opf|cac Kai dpTupiov Kai TTXfi9oc dvbpaTTobujv Kai TToXu9upouc E auXdc TrepipaX6|uevoc Kai KXivac TTpoc9e'|uevoc ttoXutc-
25 XeTc Kai TpaTTe^ac oiCTai TaOTa cppovficeujc auTuj ^fi TTapaTevojuevric eubaijuoviav ecec0ai Kai piov dXuTTOv Kai luaKdpiov Kai d|ueTdpXriTov ; TipujTa tic 'lcpiKpdTriv Tov cTpaTHTOv, ujcTrep eHeXeTX^v, tic ecTiv; *ouTe
~— 310H. C, 375-37CB.
9. Koi dv^cei xop&u)v Benselerus: xop&u)v koi dv^cei 12. TC*: bk 13. |u^v*
15*
228 DE FORTUNA
Totp 6TTXiTric ouT€ ToEoTric ouTC TTeXTacTnc'. KdtKeTvoc *6 TOUTOic' ^cpr) 'rraciv dmTdTTiuv Kai xP^Mevoc'. 6. Ou xpuciov fi q)p6vr|cic ^ctiv oub' dpTupiov F oube boHa oub^ ttXoOtoc oub' urieia oitb* lcxuc oubfe KdXXoc. Ti ouv ^CTi; t6 Tiaci toutoic KaXuic xpflcSai buvd)Li€vov Kai bi' 6 toutujv ^KacTov f]bu YiYveTai Kai IvboEov Ktti ujqpeXi^ov • fiveu b^ toutou bucxpncTa Koi fiKapTra Kai pXapepd, Kai papuvei Kai KaTaicxuvei t6v KeKTrmevov. i^ nou KaXiiJC 6 'Hciobou TTpo^ri9euc Tuj '€7Ti|Liri6ei napaKeXeueTai lo
*\xr] TTOTe biLpa b^EacGai irdp Ztiv6c *OXu)LiTTiou dXX' dTTOTT^iiXTTeiv ', 100 Td TUXTipd X^Y^J^v Kai Td dKTOc, ujc ei TTapeKeXeueTO )if) XupiZeiv dnoucov 6vTa iurib' dvaYiTvuOcKeiv dTpd)Li- laaTOv larib' iTtTTeueiv dvmTTOV, outuj TrapaKeXeuoiaevoc | auTu» nf) fipxeiv dv6riT0V 6vTa \xr\bi TrXouTeiv dveXeu eepov iurib^ TaM^iv KpaTouiaevov utto TuvaiKOc. ou I Tdp laovov * t6 eu TTpdcceiv TTapd ttiv dEiav dqpopiafi i ToO KaKUJC qjpovcTv toTc dvofiToic TiYveTai ', ujc Ar|- 1 HOcGevric elTrev , dXXd t6 euTuxeTv TTapd Triv dSiav ^ dqjopnf) ToO KaKUJC TTpdTTeiv toTc }JiY] (ppovoOciv.
1, 810—811 H. 6, 376— 37T U
9. 'Hcidbou] 0. et D. 86 14. XupiJeiv»: cupfCciv
19. AnMOce^vric] Olynth. I 23
nEPi APETH2 KAI KAKIAX
1. Td iiadTia boKei Gepjidveiv tov dvGpujTTOv, ouk auTd briTTOu TtpocpdWovTa Tfjv SepiaoTnTa (Ka9' dauTo Ydp eKacTov auTuiv ipuxpov ecTiv, fi Kai iToXXdKic Kau)iaTiZ:6)n€voi Kai TtupeTTOvTec e5 eTe'piJuv eTepa iiie- laXaiapdvouciv), dXX' tiv 6 dvGpiuTToc dva&ibuuciv eS C eauToO 6ep|a6Tr|Ta, TauTr|v f\ icQr\c tuj ciJujuaTi TTpoc- TtecoOca cuvexei Kai rrepicTeXXei , Kai Ka6eipTvu|Lie'vriv eic t6 cuj|ua ouk ed rrdXiv CKebdvvuc6ai. TauTO br\ toOto Toic TrpdfMaciv uTrdpxov eHaTraTd touc ttoXXouc,
io ujc, dv oiKiac laefdXac TrepipdXuuvTai Kai TTXn6oc dv- bpaTrobiuv Kai xPni^dTijuv cuvaTdTuuciv, fibeuic piwco- jLievouc. t6 b' fibeujc lf]v Kai iXapujc ouk eHuj6ev ecTiv, dXXd TouvavTiov 6 dv6pujTT0c toTc rrepi auT6v TTpdTMaciv nbovfiv Kai xdpw ujcnep eK TrriTfic toO
,15 fj6ouc TrpocTi6riciv.
'ai6o|Lievou be TTup6c TcpapuuTepoc oTkoc ibe'ceai', D Kai ttXoOtoc fibiujv Kai boHa XajaTTpoTe'pa Kai buva- laic, av t6 dTT6 t^c vpuxfic exr) Tn9oc. ottou Kai Tre-
1, 319H. 6, 390— 391 K.
2. ftriTrou*: 6fjTrou 6€p)aaivovTa Kai 3. oi Stephamis 16. Nauck. p. 343
230 DE VIRTUTE
viav Ktti cpuYrjv Kai Tfipac eXacppuuc Kai rrpocrivOuc Trpoc euKoXiav Kai TipaoTriTa TpoTtou qpepouciv.
2. 'Qc Tap dpiuiuaTa Tpi^uuvac euuubeic Kai pdiKia TTOieT, ToO b' 'Atxicou t6 ca)|ua ixujpa Ttovripov eEebibou
WuuTOu KaTOCTdZovTa puccivov qpdpoc', 5
outoi laeT' dpeTfic Kai biaiTa TTotca Kai ^ioc dXurroc
ecTi Ktti eKiTeptrric, x] be KOKia Kai Td XaiaTrpd qpaivo-
E l^eva Kai TToXuTeXfi Kai ce)avd mYvuiaevri Xurrripd Kai
vauTiuubr) Kai bucTrpocbeKTa Trapexei toTc KeKTr||aevoic.
'ouToc iixaKdpioc ev dYopa vo)aiZ!eTai. n
eTtdv b' dvoiEri Tdc 0upac, TpicdGXioc,
Yuvfi KpaTei TtdvTuuv, eTtiTdTTei fidxcT' dei'. KaiTOi fuvaiKOC ou xa^efruJC dv tic dTraXXaYeir) Trovr)- pdc dvf]p ujv, jufi dvbpdTTObov* Trpoc hk rr\v dauToO KaKiav ouK ecTi YPOtH^dfaevov dTToXeivpiv fjbri TrpaYiad- 15 ; Tujv d(peTc0ai Kai dvaTTauec0ai Yevojuevov Ka0' auTov, dXX' dei cuvoiKoOca toTc CTrXdYXVOic Kai TtpocTreqpu- KuTa vuKToip Ktti )ae0' fi|ue'pav
*euei dTep baXoO Kai d}\xw YHPdi buuKe', F Papeia cuve'Kbrifioc ouca bi' dXaZioveiav Kai ttoXutc- 20 Xfic cuvbemvoc utto Xixveiac Kai cuykoitoc 6buvripd, qjpovTici Kai |Liepi)Livaic Kai Z^riXoTuniaic eKKOTTTOuca Tov unvov Kai biaqp0eipouca. Kai Ydp 8 Ka0eu- bouci, ToO ciu)uaTOc uTTvoc ecTi Ktti dvdTTaucic, Tfic be vpuxfjc TrToTai Kai oTcTpoi Kai Tapaxai bid bei- 25 cibaijuoviav.
'oTav be vucTdZiovTd \x' f) XuTrri Xdpri,
dTT6XXu)u' UTro tuuv evuTTviuuv*
1,312-313H. 6, S80-382R
5. Nauck. p. 168 10. Meinek. IV. p. 157 19,
Hesiod, 0, et D. 705 25. oTcTpoi*: oveipoi 27. Mei-
nek, IV. p. 669
ET VITIO 231
^rici Tic. ouTU» hh. m\ qpGovoc Kal cpopoc Kai eujuoc Ktti diKoXacia biaTiGrici. )iie8' fnaepav |Liev Yap eEut pXerrouca Kai cucxri|LiaTi2o|Lievri Trpoc iTepouc fi KaKia buciwTTeTTai Kai TrapaKaXuTTTei tci TrdGri, Kai ou irav- loi 5 Tdiraci TaTc opjuaTc eKbibuiciv eauTrjV dXX' dvTiTeivei Kai biajudxeTaiTToXXdKic* ev be toTc utrvoic dTToqpuToOca bd£ac Kai vojuouc Kai TToppujTdTUJ Y€V0|aevn toO bebie- vai TC Ktti aibeTcGai rrdcav em9uMiav KiveT, Kai dTTav- eYeipei t6 KaKoriGec Kai dKoXacTOv. ' MnTpi tc Ydp ^tti-
10 xeipeT iLiiTvucQai ', ujc qpriciv 6 TTXdTujv, Kai Ppujceic d9ec|uouc TTpoc(pepeTai Kai TTpdHeuJc oubeiuiac dTTexeTai, dTToXauouca toO TTapavojueTv ibc dvucTov ecTiv eibuuXoic Kai (pdc|iaciv eic oube)uiav fibovfiv oube TcXeiujciv toO dTTieu)ioOvToc TeXeuTUJCiv, dXXd KiveTv |u6vov Kai bia- p
15 Ypiaiveiv Td TTderi Kai Td vocr|)uaTa buva^ievoic.
3. TToO Toivuv t6 nbu Tfic KaKiac Ictiv, €i )uriba- )ioO t6 djiepijuvov Kai t6 dXuTTOV |urib' auTdpKeia jurib' dTapaEia ixr]b' ficuxia; TaTc |uev ydp Tfic capK6c flbovaTc f) Tou ciujuaToc euKpacia Kai ufieia x^pa.y
20 bibujci • Tfi be ipuxri ouk Ictiv eYT€ve'ceai yh^oc oube xapdv pe'paiov, av )ufi t6 eu9u)Ltov Kai d^o^ov Kai eappaXeov ujCTTep ebpav f| YaXf|vriv SkXuctov uTTopd- XriTai, dXXd Kctv uTTO)ueibidcr) tic eXrric fj Te'pi|Jic, auTH Taxu qppovTiboc eKpateicnc OucTrep €V eubia ctti-
25 Xdboc cuvexu9ri Kai cuveTapdxen-
4. "Aepoi^e xpuciov, cuvaYe dpYupiov, oiKob6|uei c TTepmdTOuc, ^juttXticov dvbpaTTobujv Tf]v oiKiav Kai XpewcTujv Tfjv TToXiv. dv )ufi Td TTden Tfic ipuxfic KaTacTopecric Kai Tfiv drrXricTiav Traucric Kai qpopujv
1, 313— 314H. C, 382-3S2E.
6. 6iajuid(xeTai*: jidxeTai 10. TTXdTUJv] Rep. IX.
p. 571 D 12. etbiuXoic] ^v eibiiiXoic Stephanus
232 DE VIRTUTE ET VITIO
Kai (ppovTibujv dTraXXdHric cauTov, oTvov biriOeic ku- peTTbvTi Kai xo^i'^'?' M^^^ Trpocqpepeic Kai ciTia Kai 6^ia KOiXiaKOic ^TOiiadZeic Kai bucevTepiKOic, ^y\ ctc- YOuci ^r{bk. pUJVVU)ievoic dXXd TTpocbia^Geipoiiievoic utt' auTujv. oux 6pac touc vocouvTac oti toiv Ppuj- 5 lidTUJV Td Ka6apu)TaTa Kai troXuTeXdcTaTa bucxepai-
D vouci Kai biaTTTuouci Kai TrapaiToOvTai TipoccpepovTUJV Kai piaZ;o|i^vujv, eiTa ttic Kpdceujc /ieTapaXoucric Kai irveuiiaTOc xPICtoG Kai YXuKeoc ai|iiaT0c eYT^voiaevou Kai Gep^oTTiToc oiKeiac dvacTdvTec dpTOv Xitov eTTi lo Tupui Kai KapbdMiu x«ipouci Kai dc|ieviZ!ouciv dc9iov- Tec; TOiauTtiv 6 Xofoc eiHTToiei tQ ipux^ bidGeciv. auTdpKTic ecr), av Md9ric ti t6 KaXov KdTa96v dcTi* Tpucpnceic dv TTevia Kai PaciXeuceic Kai tov dTTpdTinova piov Kai ibiuJTriv oubfev fJTTOv dTauriceic r| tov ^tti is CTpaTriTiciic Kai fjTejiioviaic' ou piujcr) cpiXocoqjricac dri9u)C, dXXd rravTaxoO lf\\ fibe'ujc |bia9r|cri Kai dTT6 TrdvTUJV euqjpavei ce ttXoOtoc ttoXXouc euepTeToOvTa
E Kai TTevia TToXXd infi jiiepiiavaiVTa Kai boHa Ti|iAuO|Lievov Kai dboHia ixr\ q)9ovou)aevov. 20
1, 314-315 H. 6, 381-385 E.
11. k9iovT€c lannotius: ^ceovrec
nAPAMTOHTIKOS HPOS AnOAA^NION.
1. Kai irdXai coi cuvr|\Tr|ca Kai cuvnxQccOilv, 'AnoX- Xuuvie, dtKoucac Trepi Tfic toO TrpocqpiXecTdTOu Trdciv fmiv uioO cou TTpoiupou jLieTaXXaTfic toO piou, veavi- cKou Kocjaiou Trdvu Kai ciutppovoc Kai biacpepovTUJc
5 Td Te TTpoc Geouc Kai Trpoc yoveac Kai cpiXouc ocm Kai biKaia biaqpuXdHavTOc. TOTe |Liev ouv utto tov Tfic 102 TeXeuTfic Kaipov evTUTXaveiv coi Kai TrapaKaXeTv dv- epuuTrivuuc (pepeiv t6 cuiupepriKoc dvoiKeiov fjv, Trapei- inevuj t6 Te cuj|ua Kai Tf)v ijJuxfiv utto Tfic TrapaXoTOu
10 cuju^opdc • oube Tdp oi PeXTicToi tujv iaTpuiv TTp6c Tdc dGpoac tuiv peujndTuiv eTricpopdc eu6uc Trpocqje- pouci Tdc bid TiiJv qpapiLidKUJV porjGeiac, dXX' eujci t6 Papuvov tfic (pXeTiuovfic bixa Tfic tujv eEujGev Ttepi- XpicTUJV eTTiGeceujc auT6 bi* ^auToO iXaPeTv TTe'i|Jiv.
15 (2) eTTeibfi be Kai xpovoc 6 TrdvTa TreTraiveiv eiu)9ujc eTTeTOve Tfj cujuqpopa Kai f) Trepi ce bidOecic dTraiTeiv B ^oiKe Tfiv Trapd tuuv qpiXuuv pofi0eiav, KaXuuc exeiv
l, 316-317H. 6, 386— 387R.
5. Koi npdc Stephanus: koI xd irpoc 10. cujnqpopac
cujaqpopac Kol cu|aiTa9eTv 6' t^v dvaTKaiov 15. 6^*: ouv
234 CONSOLATIO
tjTreXapov tujv Trapa)Liu0nTiKU)v coi )ueTaboOvai Xotuuv Trpoc dveciv Tfic XuTrric Kai TraOXav tujv TTevSiKoiv Kai jaaTaiwv 6bupjuujv.
'ipuxnC Tap 'vocoucnc eiciv laTpoi Xotoi, OTav Tic iv Kaipuj Te MaXGdccr) K^ap.' KaTci Totp Tov cocpov GupiTTibnv
*aXXo be' "i' in' fiXXr) q)dp)LiaKOV KeiTai v6cqj" XuttouilI^vuj |iev (iOGoc eujnevfic qpiXujv, aTav be laujpaivovTi vouGeTrmaTa'. C TioXXujv Tdp ovTuuv vpuxiKuJv TTaGujv, n XuTrri t6 \a- XeTTuuTaTOv TT^qpuKev eivai TTdvTUJV.
'bid XuTTriv Tdp' cpnci 'Kai inavia TiTveTai
TToXXoici Kai vociijLiaT' ouK Idcijaa,
auTOuc t' dvripriKaci bid XuTTriv tiv^c'.
3. T6 laev ouv dXTeiv Kai bdKvec9ai TeXeuTricav- 1
Toc utoO q)uciKfiv exei thv dpxfjv Tfjc XuTrric, Kai ouk
icp' fi|uiv. ou Tdp eTiuT€ cu^cpepo^ai toic Tfiv
dTpiov u|avoOci Kai cKXrjpdv dTTd9eiav, eEuj Kai toO
buvaToO Kai toO cujJcpepovTOc oucav dqpaipficeTai
Tdp fijuujv auTri Tfiv ^k toO (piXeTc9ai Kai (piXeiv eu-
D vOiav, Tiv TTavT6c iuaXXov biaciuZeiv dvaTKaiov. t6
bk Txipa ToO laeTpiou TrapeKcpepec9ai Kai cuvauEeiv td
TTev9ri Trapd (puciv eivai ^riiai Kai utt6 Tfic ^v fmiv
qpauXiic TiTvec9ai boEnc. bi6 Kai toOto laev daT^ov
ibc pXapep6v Kai cpaOXov Kai CTToubaioic dvbpdciv ss
flKicTtt TTperrov, Tfiv bk |LieTpiOTTd9eiav ouk dTToboKi-
1,317— 318 H. 6, 387-3S8R
4. H»ux»1c] Acsch. Prom. 379 6. €upnT{6riv] Nauck
p. 524 12. Mcinek. IV. p. 43 q)r)Ci koI jiavia yi
Yverai iroWoici* (Stobaeus Flor. XCIX 1): <paci xal iuaviav yivtc9at iroWoic 22. nexpiou Pflugkius: n^tpou
'lav i
d
AD APOLLONIUM 235
luacTeov. *|Lifi Ycip vocoT)aev' qpnciv 6 dtKabriiuiaKoc KpdvTuup, Wocr|caci bi Trapeiri tic aicGricic, eiT* oOv TejLivoiTO Ti TUiV fifieTepuuv eiT' dTTOCTTuJTO. t6 Tdp dvoObuvov toOto oOk dveu laeYdXuuv eYTiTveTai laicGujv
5 Tuj dvGpuuTruj" Te9TipiuJc6ai ydp ekoc eKei /aev cuujua evTauOa bk ijiuxiiv'. E
4. Out' oOv dTraGeic eTTi tuuv toioutuuv cufiqpo- pujv 6 XoYoc d2ioT YiYvecGai touc eO cppovouvTac ouTe bucTTaGeTc t6 |iev Ydp dTCYKTov Kai Gripiuubec,
10 t6 b' dKXeXujuevov Kai YuvaiKOTTpeTTec. eOXoYicToc b' 6 Tov oiKeTov opov exujv Kai buvd|uevoc (pepeiv be- 5iu)C Td Te TTpocrivfi Kai Td XuTTripd tuuv ev tuj pioi cujupaivovTUJV, Kai TTpoeiXriqpiLc oti Ka9dTTep iv bniuo- KpaTia KXfjpoc ^cti tujv dpxuuv Kai beT XaxovTa iuev
15 dpxeiv dTToXaxovTa be cpepeiv dveTTax9uuc Tfjv Tuxnv, ouTuu Kai Tfi biavo^fi tuuv TTpaYiudTuuv dvcYKXfiTUJC Kai TTei9riviuuc eTTecOai. toOto Ydp oi /af) buvdjuevoi TroieTv p oObe Tdc eOTTpaYiac av e|U(pp6vuuc cpepeiv buvaivTO Ktti jueTpiuJC. Tuuv |uev y«P KaXujc XcYojuevujv ecfiv
20 dv UTroOf|Kric |U^pei Kai toOto
'lurib' eOTuxTiiaa jurjbev uJb' ecTuu |ueYa, 6 c' eHeTTapeT iueTZov f| XP^UJV qppoveTv, jurib' dv Ti cuiapfj bucxepec, bouXoO TrdXiv, dXX' auT6c aiei |ui|ave, Tfiv cauToO cpuciv
25 ciXiZwv pePaiuuc, ujct€ xP^c6c ev Trupi'.
TTCTTaibeujuevuuv be dcTi Kai cuuqppovuuv dvbpuuv Trpoc Te Tdc boKOucac eOTuxiac t6v oOtOv eivai, Kai Trp6c 103 Tdc dTuxiac qpuXdHai Ycvvaiujc t6 TrpeTTOv. Tfic Ydp eOXoYiCTiac ^pYov ecfiv fi qpuXdSacOai t6 KaK6v em-
1,318— 319 H. 6,388— 390E.
5. cuJjLia Dohnerus: cOL"; • toioOtov 21. Nauck.
p. 524
236 CONSOLATIO \
(p€p6)aevov fi biopeuOcaceai fevd^evov f| cucTciXai TTpoc t6 ppaxuTttTov r\ TrapacKeudZeiv auTuj thv utto- Movfiv appeva Kai Yevvaiav. Kai yap trepi TaTaedv f] cppovncic TTpaYiaaTeueTai TCTpaxuJc, f\ KTuuiaevri tol- Yaed f\ (puXdTTOuca f| auHouca f\ xpuJMevri beEiujc. s, ouToi Tfic qppovrjceuuc Kai TuJv dWiuv dpeTUJv eici Kttvdvec, oic rrpoc diaqpoTepa xPHCTeov. B *ouK fcTiv* fap '6cTiCTrdvT' dvfip eubai|aoveT*
Kai vf| Aia
't6 Toi xpeuiv oOk ^ti infi xpeiuv TTOieiv*. lo
5. "QcTTep tdp iv qpuToic ttotc iiev TToXuKaprriai TiTVOVTai TTOTe b' dKapTTiai, Kai iv Jluoic rroTfe |iev TToXuTOviai TTOTe b' dTOViai, Kai iv eaXdTTri eubiai Te Kai xeiMuivec, outuj Kai iv piiu TToXXai Kai ttoiki- Xai TrepiCTdceic TiTv6)aevai Trpoc Tdc evavTiac Trepi- ia| dTOuci Touc dvepuiTTouc Tuxac. eic dc biapXeipac dv Tic ouK dTTeiKOTUJC emoi
'ouk dTTi TTdciv c' dqpuTeuc' dTaeotc C 'ATa|a€|bivov 'ATpeuc.
bei b^ c€ xttipeiv Kai XuTreicear evrjTdc T«P ^'9uc. kSv pir\ cu eeXric, Td eeujv ouTUj pouX6|aev* ecTai' Kai t6 uTr6 toO Mevdvbpou ^rieev
'ei Tdp ^T^vou cu, Tp6qpi|ae, tujv TrdvTUJV jadvoc, 6t' eTiKTev r\ lafjTtip c', dqp' d» Te biaTeXeiv 25
Trpdccujv d pouXei Kai bieuTuxujv dei,
1, S19H. 6, 390— 391 B,
8. Nauck. p. 447 10. Id. p. 697 13, 6**: bk
Kol 18. Eurip. Iph. A. 29 22. PouX6|lI€v* Euripides:
gouXo|Li^viuv 23. Mevdvbpou] Meinek. IV. p. 227
25. T€ Schaferus: t^
I
AD APOLLONIUM 237
Ktti toOto tOuv eeujv tic dJinoXoTrice coi, 6p9d)c dYavaKT€ic" ^'cti Ydp c' evpeuciiievoc, ctTOTrov te TreTroiriK '. ei b' ini toic auToTc vojaoic ecp' oTcTrep niLieic ectracac tov depa 5 Tov KOivov, 'iva coi Kai TpaxiKuuTepov XaXiiu, D DicTeov ajLieivov TauTa Kai XoTicTe'ov. t6 bk KecpdXaiov tujv Xotujv, dvOpiuTTOc el, ou iLieTapoXriv GdTTOV Trpoc ui|;oc Kai TrdXiv TaTreivoTTiTa Zujov oubev Xainpdvei. 10 Kai ^dXa biKaiuuc dcGevecTaTOV Tdp 6v q)ucei laeTiCTOic oiKOVOMeiTai TTpdTnaciv, OTav Tvecri be, TrXeicTa cuvTpipei KaXd. cu b' ou9' uTTeppdXXovTa Tpocpifa' dTrdiXecac dTaOd, Td vuvi t' icri |ne'Tpid coi KaKd. E
15 ujct' dvd jnecov ttou Kai t6 XoiTr6v bidcpepe'. dXX' 6|aijuc TOiouTiuv 6vt«juv tujv TrpaTiadTUJV evioi bid Tfjv dcppocuvriv outujc eiciv d^eXTepoi Kai Kevau- Xeic, ujCTe |niKp6v eTrapOevTec r\ bid xprmdTUJV Trepi- ouciav dcp9ovov fi bid ineTeOoc dpxnc fi bid Tivac 20 Ttpoebpiac KoXiTiKdc f| bid Ti|adc Kai boHac eTraTreiXeiv ToTc fiTTOci Kai eHuPpiZeiv, ouk ev9u|Liou|i6Voi t6 Tfic F Tuxric dcTaTOV Kai dpePaiov, oub' 6ti pabiujc Td uvpriXd TiTveTai TaTreivd Kai Td x^aiLiaXd rrdXiv uipoO- Ttti TttTc 6Eupp6Troic |ne9iCTd|Li€va Tfic Tuxric iiieTaPo- 25 XaTc. ZriTcTv ouv iv dpePaioic Pepaiov ti XoTi2o|a^- vujv ecTi TTepi tuuv TrpaTiudTUJV ouk 6p9u)C'
'TpoxoO* Tdp 'TrepicTeixovToc dXXo9' fjTepa dipic uTTep9e TiTveT' dXXo9' fjTe^pa'. 6. KpdTicTov bf) Trp6c dXuTriav qpdpjuaKOV 6 Xotoc
'1, 319-321 H. 6, 391— 394B.
2. c' Grotius 13. r'*: 5* 14. xd vuvi Bentleius:
xavOv 15. bmcpepe*: cpipe 27. Bergk. p. 1358'
238 CONSOLATIO
Kai f] bid TOUTOu TrapacKeuf) Trpoc Ttdcac toO piou Tctc lueTapoXdc. XPH T«P ou jitovov eauTOv eibevai evTiTov ovTtt Triv (puciv, dXXd Kai oti 0vtituj cuTKXri- poc ecTi piiu Kai TipdYMCici pqibiujc )Lie6icTajLtevoic Trpoc 104 TOuvavTiov. dv6pu)TriJuv fap ovtuuc 6vriTd |uev Kai 5 eqprjiLiepa Td cuu)LiaTa, GvriTai be Tuxai Kai Trderi Kai TTdv6' dTTXuJc Td KaTd tov piov, dTrep
' ouK ecTi q)UTeiv ^poTOV oub' urraXuHai ' t6 TrapdTrav dXXd
'TapTdpou TTu6)Lifiv TTieZ^ei c' dcpavoOc cqpupriXd- la TOic dvdYKaic', ujc qprici TTivbapoc. 66ev opeuJc 6 OaXripeuc Aiiiuri- Tpioc emovToc €upiTribou
'6 b' oXpoc ou pe'paioc dXX' eqprnuepoc' Kai 6ti 15
'jLiiKpd Td ccpdXXovTa, Kai jui' fiiLiepa
Td ^iev Ka6eiXev uip66€v Td b' fip' ctvuj' B Td \xev dXXa KaXOuc eqpri XeYeiv auT6v, 'PcXtiov b' dv exov fjv, ei jufi jniav fiiaepav dXXd CTiYMfiv eiTTe xpovou '. 20
'kukXoc Yap auToc KapTriinoic Te Yfic qpUToTc
6vriTUJV Te Yeved. toic |Liev auHeTai pioc,
Tujv be qpeivei Te KdK6epiZ;eTai TrdXiv.' 6 be TTivbapoc ev dXXoic
'Ti be Tic; Ti b' ou tic; CKidc ovap «6
dvepujTTOC, eiuqpavTiKOuc cqp6bpa Kai qpiXoTexvujc uTrepPoXri XPHca-
1, 321— 322 H. 6, 394—394 R,
8. Homer. M 326 10. Bergk. p. 357 ^ 13. €u-
pnTifeou] Phoen. 558 16. |uiKpa xd* (liuc iuiKpot rct Stobaeiis
.Flor. CV 1. Nauck. p. 388): luiKpdxaTa 19. ^xov fjv*: eTx£v
6v 21. Nauck. p. 387 24. TTivJ;apocj Pyth. VIII l.-i.5
1
AD APOLLONIUM 239
jiievoc Tov TOiV dvGpuuTTUJV piov ^briXuJce. ti ^ap CKiac dcGevecTepov; t6 be TauTric ovap oub' dv eKqppdcai Tic eTepoc buvriGein cacpoic. toutoic b' enoiLievujc Kai c 6 KpdvTUjp Trapa)Liu9oujuevoc eTTi Tr] TuJv tckvujv tc- 5 XeuTfj Tov 'iTTTTOKXea qprici ^TaOTa ydp Trdca auTr) n dpxaia qpiXocoqpia Xe'Tei Te Kai TTapaKeXeueTai. uJv ei bn-Ti dXXo ixx] dTrobex6|ue6a , t6 yc TToXXaxfi eivai IpYUJbri Kai buCKoXov tov piov dTCtv dXriGec. Kai xdp ei \xr\ qpucei toutov exei tov tp6ttov, utt6 y^ rijaujv 10 eic TOUTO dqpiKTai bia(p0opac. fi t€ dbT]Xoc auTTi tu- Xn TT6ppuj0ev fijuTv Kai cti dTr' dpxnc iiKoXou0riKev oub' l(p' ^vi uTie», q^uojaevoic Te juiTvuTai tic ev Trdci KaKoO inoTpa' Td Tdp toi CTTe^piaaTa eu0uc 0vriTd ovTa TauTrjC KOivujveT Tfic aiTiac, eg fic dqjuia juev qjuxiic, 15 vocoi be Kai Kr|bea Kai jaoTpa 0vr|TU)v eKeT0ev fijnTv epTTei'. ToO bfi xdpiv eTpaTT6|ue0a beOpo; Tv' eibeiii- d |uev OTi Kaivov oubev dTuxeTv dv0pujTruj dXXd Trdv- Tec TauTO TTeTT6v0ajuev. 'dcKOTroc Tdp n Tuxr)' qpnciv 6 0e6qppacTOc 'Kai beivf] TTapeXec0ai Td TTporreTTovri- 20 jLieva Kai jiieTappTiiJai Tfjv boKoOcav eurijuepiav, oubeva Kaipov exouca TaKTOv'. TaOTa be Kai dXXa TOiauTa Kai Ka0' lauTov eKdcTUj XoTicac0ai pdbiov, Kai dXXuiv dKoOcai TraXaiuJv Kai coqjiiuv dvbpuiv uiv TTpOuTOC jaev ecTiv 6 0eToc "Ojuiipoc, eiTTuuv 25 'oubev dKibv6Tepov T«Ta Tpeqpei dv0puJTTOio.
ou jaev Tdp ttotc q)r]ci KttKOV TTeicec0ai OTTiccuj, oqpp' dpeTfiv Trapexujci 0eoi Kai TOuvaT' opujpr]' dXX' oTe bfi Kai XuTpd 0eoi jadKapec TeXecujci, Kai Td qpepei deKaZiojuevoc TeTXrjoTi 0unu)' E
1, 322-323 H. 6, 395— 397K.
15. 6^*: Te 17. ovbiv druxetv Reiskius: dtuxeiv
ovbiv 28. reXkujci* (Homer. c 133): xeX^ouci
240 CONSOLATIO
Ktti
'toToc Yotp v6oc dcTiv ^ttixOoviujv dvGpuuTTUJV, oiov eir' fjjaap clYrici TtaTrip dvbpa»v Te eeuuv te* Ktti ev ctXXoic
'Tubeibri jLieTdGujae, Tin Tcvefiv ^peeiveic; oiTi TTep qpuXXuJv Tcveri, Toir) be Kai dvbpuJv. q)uXXa Td |aev t' dveiuoc x«M«^ic x^^i, dXXa be
G' uXn TriXeGoujca <puei, eapoc b' dTtiTiTveTai ujpn* u)c dvbpujv Tevef) f] laev qpuei n b' dTToXriTei'- F TauTT] b' OTi KaXujc ^xPnccxTO Txji eiKOVi ToO dv9puj- Tteiou piou bfjXov 15 iX»v ev dXXuj tottuj cpriciv outuj
'PpoTujv eveKa TTToXeiniZiuj
beiXOuv, o'i q)uXXoiciv doiKOTec, dXXoTe |aev T€
ZaqjXeTcec TeXeSouciv dpoupnc KapTTov IbovTec,
dXXoTe be q)0ivu9ouciv dKripioi, oube tic dXKrj'.
105 Cijiujvibric b' 6 Tuiv i^eXujv TroiriTr|c, TTaucaviou toO
PaciXeujc tujv AaKebaijiioviujv |a€TaXauxou)aevou cuv-
exoic eTTi TaTc auToO TrpdHeci Kai KeXeuovToc dTraT-
TeTXai ti auTUJ coq)6v jaeTd x^ewtxcMoO, cuveic auToO i
xfiv uTTepriq)aviav cuvePouXeue |Lie|Avfic0ai 6ti dv0pu)-
TTOC lcTi' OiXiTTTTOC b' 6 Tuiv MaKebovujv paciXeuc
TpiOuv auTqj TrpocaTTeX9evTUJV euTuxriM«TUJV uq)' eva
Kttipov, TTpuJTOu laev 6ti Te^piTTTTiu veviKriKev 6Xu|LiTTia,
beuTepou b' oTi TTapiaeviuJV 6 CTpaTriToc fadxri Aap- )
B baveac eviKTice, TpiTOU b' 6ti dppev auTqj Traibiov
iKuricev 'OXu|LiTndc, dvaTeivac eic tov oupavov Tdc
XeTpac 'uj baTjuov' eme, '|ueTpi6v ti toutoic dvTiGec
^XdTTUJiaa', eibujc 6ti toTc laeTdXoic €utuxi^M«ci q)0o-
1, 823—325 H. 6, 397—398 B;
2. Homer. C 136 6. Id. 2 145 13. Id. <t> 463
TrTo\e|Li{2iv * : TTToXejuiCeiv
I
AD APOLLONIUM 241
VeTv TrecpuKev f) Tuxri- 0ripa)ne'vric b' 6 Yevojuevoc 'AGtiviici Tujv TpidtKOVTa Tupdvviuv, cujuTrecoucric Tfic okiac ev f\ |ueTd rrXeiovujv ebemveij iLtovoc cuj9eic Kai TTpoc TrdvTuuv eubai)uoviZ;6)Lievoc, dvacpaivr|cac |ue- 5 YdXri Trj qpoivrj '01 Tuxr)' eiTrev, 'eic Tiva )ie Kaipov dpa cpuXdTTeic;' |li€t' ou ttoXuv be xpovov KttTacTpe- pXa)9eic utto tujv cuvTupdvvuuv eTeXeuTricev.
7. 'Yrrepcpuujc be cpaiveTai Trepi Tf)v Trapa)iu9iav 6 TTOiriTric euboKi|Lieiv, TTOiricac tov 'AxiXXea Xeyov- C 10 Ta Trpoc Tov TTpiaiLxov fiKOVTa eTri XuTpa toO "€ktopoc
TaUTl
'dXX' dye bri k^t' dp' eCeu Itti 9p6vou, dXTea
b' ejuTTric ev 6u|auj KaTaKeic9ai edcojuev dxvujuevoi Trep* 15 ou Ydp Tic TrpfiEic TreXeTai Kpuepoio yooio.
ujc Tdp eTTeKXujcavTO 9€0i beiXoici PpoToTci, Jiueiv dxvujuevoic- auTOi be t' dKrjbe^ec eici. boioi ydp Te Tri9oi KaTaKeiaTai ev Aioc oiibei buupujv oia bibujci, KttKUjv, cTepoc be edujv. •io iL |ue'v k' d]U|uiHac buuri Zeuc TepTTiKepauvoc,
dXXoTe |uev Te KaKip 6 te KupeTai dXXoTe b' D
ec6Xu)- i3j be K€ Tujv XuYpuJv buOri, XuupriTov e9r|K€ Kai i KaKri pouPpuucTic eTTi xQova bTav eXauvei, 25 cpoiTd b' ouTe 9eoTci TeTijuevoc ouTe PpoToTciv '.
6 be |ueTd toutov Kai Trj boEr} Kai tuj xpovuj, KaiTOi Tujv Moucujv dvaYopeuuuv eauTov |ua9riTfiv 'Hcioboc, Kai ouToc ev Tri9uj Ka9eipEac Td KaKd, thv TTavbuj- pav dvoiHacav dTToqpaivei CKebdcai t6 TrXfjeoc eTTi 30 TTdcav Y^v Kai 6dXaTTav, XeYuuv ujbe
1 , 325-326 H. e, 398-400 E.
12. Homer. Q 522
Plutarchi Moralia. Vol. I. 16
242 CO]S^SOLATIO
'dXXd ^vvx] xeipecci Trieou iueYa tivjjx' dcpeXoOca ' E ecKebac'' dv0piuTTOici be )ar|caTO Krjbea XuYpd.
laovjvri b' auToSi '6Xttic ev dppriKTOici bojLioiciv ^vbov l'ji£ive TTieou urro xeiXeciv, oube eOpaZe eEeTTTri' TTp6c0ev ydp eTreXXape TTuu|ua Trieoio. dXXd be jLiupia XuYpd k^t' dv0pijUTTOUC dXdXtiiai. TrXeiri )iev ydp Taia KaKiuv, TrXeirj bk edXacca. ] voucoi b' dvepuuTTOiciv ecp' fmepr) ai b' im vukti auTOjaaTOi qpoiTuJci, KaKd ©vrjTOici cpepoucai ciYr), ^TTei cpujvriv eSeiXeTO lariTieTa Zeuc'. P 8. 'ATTr|pTii|uevuuc be toutoic 6 kuj|uik6c eTTi tujv
bucTra0ouvTUJV diri TaTc ToiauTaic cu)U(popaTc TauTi
Xe-fei
'ei Td bdKpu' fi)LiTv tuuv KaKUJv r\v cpdpiaaKOV, dei 0' 6 KXaucac toO ttovcTv eTraueTo, ilXXaTT6)uec0' dv bdKpua, b6vTec xpuciov. vOv b' ou TTpocexei Td TrpdT)uaT' oub' dTTopXeTrei eic TaOTa, becTTOT', dXXd Tfjv auTfjv 6b6v, edv Te KXdr]c dv Te )af|, TTopeueTai. Ti ouv TTOieTc ttXcov; oubev r\ XuTrr) b' exei 106 ujcTrep Td be'vbpa toOto KapTrov t6 bdKpuov'.
6 be TTapa,uueou]a€VOC ifiv Aavdriv bucTrev0oOcav Ai-
KTuc qprici
'boKeTc Tov "Aibrjv cuuv ti cppovTiZieiv touuv Kai TTaTb' dvf|C€iv t6v c6v, el eeXoic CTeveiv; TraOcar pXeTrouca b' eic Td TuJv TreXac Ka^d pdujv Tevoi' dv, ei XoTi2!ec0ai eeXovc
1 , 326—327 H. 6, 400— 40J 35"
1. Hesiod. 0. et D. 94 11. 6 Kuj)aiK6c] Meinek. IV.
p. 23 15. diei Stobaeus Flor. CVIII 1: alei 20. TroieTc
TtXeov Meinekius: uX^ov iToioO|uev 21. t6 ftdKpuov Sto-
baeus: xa 6dKpua 24. Nauck. p. 366
I
AD APOLLOXIUM 243
ocoi Te becjaoTc ^|j|ae)i6xXeuvTai PpoTiuv, 6coi Te YnP«CKOuciv opcpavoi Te'Kvuuv, touct' eK iueTiCTOV oX^iac Tupavviboc t6 ^xribkv ovTac. TaOTd ce CKOTreTv xQeiJjv*. B
5 KcXeuei Totp auTinv ev0ujueTc6ai toi tiuv ica Kai jueiZluu bucTuxouvTiJUV, ujc ecojuevriv eXaqppoTepav.
9. '€vTau6a Tdp dv tic ^XKuceie Kai Triv toO CtUKpdTouc cpujvriv, thv oiojuevriv, ei cuveiceve'YKaijiiev eic t6 K0iv6v Tdc dTuxiac, ujCTe bieXec6ai t6 icov
10 eKacTOV, dc)Lievujc dv touc TrXeiouc Tdc auTUJV dva- XapovTac dTTeX6eTv. ^xPHcaTO be Tr) TOiauTr] dfuj-ffi Kai 'AvTi)uaxoc 6 TTOiriTric. dTTo6avoucr|c Tdp Tfic fu- vaiK6c auTuj Aubric, TTp6c fiv qpiXocTopYuuc eixe, Tra- pa|uueiov Tfic XuTTrjc auTuj eTTOirice Trjv eXefeiav Trjv
15 KaXou|uevriv Aubriv, eHapi6|uricd|uevoc Tdc f)pujiKdc cu)u- 0 cpopdc, ToTc dXXoTpioic KaKoTc eXdTTUJ Trjv ^auToO TTOiujv XuTTriv. uJCTe KaTOcpavec eivai 6ti 6 TTapa).iu- 6ou)4evoc t6v XeXunriuevov Kai beiKVuuuv koivov Kai TToXXuJV t6 cuiupepriKoc Kai toiv iTepoic cuupepriKOTUJV
20 eXaTTOV Triv boHav toO XeXuTrri.uevou |U€0icTr,ci Kai ToiauTriv Tivd TTOieT TricTiv auTui, oti eXaTTOV f| f[Ki- Kov ujJeTO t6 cujuPeprjKoc ecTiv.
10, '0 b' AicxOXoc KaXuuc ^oiKev ^TTiTrXriTTeiv ToTc vojuiZouci t6v 6dvaT0V eivai KaKOv, XetuJV uibe
25 'uic ou biKaiuic 6dvaT0V ex6ouciv PpoToi, ocTTep )ueYiCTOv pO|ua tuiv ttoXXujv KaKUJv'. toOtov Tdp dTTe)uijur|caTO Kai 6 eiTruuv
1, 327— 328H. «, 402-404B.
1. imi€|a6xXeuvTai Bentleius: iK|a€)a6xerivTai 3. iu^-
TiCTOV Elmsleius: |a€YicTr]C 10. dvaXaPovTac*: XaPovTac
20. JXoTTOv Reiskius: ^XdTTOva 23. AicxuAoc] Nauck.
p. 81
16*
244 CONSOLATIO
D 'u» edvare Traictv laTpoc |u6\oic'.
Xi)Lifiv Yctp SvTuuc 'Aibac dv' aiav. [xi^a Ydp ecTi t6 jaeTd Treic|LiaToc TeGappriKOTOc eiTreiv
'tic b' ecTi boOXoc toO GaveTv dqppovTic ujv;* Kai 6
'"Aibrjv b' ^x^jjv pori66v ou Tpe'juuu CKidc'. Ti ydp t6 xct^^TTOv ecTi Kai t6 bucavnliv ev tuj t€ evdvai; Td ^dp toO eavdTou )Lir|TTOTe Kai Xiav fi|uTv ovTa cuvner) Kai cujucpud iTdXiv ouk oib' Sttujc buc- aXYn boKcT eivai. ti Ydp eau|LiacT6v el t6 T|LiriT6v lo TeTjuriTai, ei t6 ttikt^v TeTriKTai, ei t6 KaucT6v KeKau-
E Tai, ei t6 (pOapT^v ecpeapTai; ttotc Ydp ev fuuTv au- ToTc ouK ecTiv 6 edvaToc; Kai, fj q)riciv 'HpdKXeiToc, 'TauTuj t' fvi 2ujv Kai TeOvriK^c Kai eYpriYop6c Kai Kaeeubov Kai veov Kai YHPCtiov ' Tdbe Ydp iueTaTTecov- 15 Ta eKeTvd ecTi, KOKeTva TrdXiv )ueTarrec6vTa TaOTa'. ujc Ydp ^K Tou auToO tttiXoO buvaTai tic rrXdTTUJV Idja cuYxeiv Kai TrdXiv TrXdTTeiv Kai cuyxciv Kai toO- To ev TTop' ^v TTOieTv dbiaXeiTTTUJC, outuj Kai fi q)ucic eK TTic auTfjc uXric TrdXai |uev touc TrpoYovouc fnuuuv
F dvecxev, eiTa cuvexeTc auToTc eYevvnce touc TraTepac, eiTa fi|uac, cTt' dXXouc err' dXXoic dvaKUKXiicei. Kai 6 Tfic Ycveceujc TroTa|Li6c outujc evbeXexuJc peujv ou- TTOTe CTr|C€Tai, Kai rrdXiv 6 eH evavTiac auTui 6 Tfic <peopdc eiT€ 'Axepujv eiTe Kujkut6c KaXoujuevoc utt6 25 Tujv TTOiriTuiv. fi TTpujTri ouv aiTia fi beiHaca fiiuTv t6 ToO fiXiou (pOuc, fi auTfi Kai t6v Zoqpepov "Aibriv dYCi.
1,328— 329 H. 6, 404— 405 EE,
1. Nauck. p. 64 4. Id. p. 523 6. Id. p. 697
7. 6ucaviiuv Reiskius: 6ucavia)v KOi 14. xauTuJ Bernaysius: TaOto Kai ^YPIYop^c Kal Reiskius: Kai t6 ^YPITopoc
Koi t6
i
AD APOLLONIUM 245
Ktti juriTTOTe ToObe eiKiijv ^ 6 rrepi fiiudc dr|p, ^v Trap'
ev fiiuepav Kai vuKTa rroiujv, eTTafujYOuc rujiic Te Kai
GavdtTOu Kai urrvou Kal eYpriTopceujc. bio Kai juoipi-
biov xpioc eivai Xe'TeTai t6 lr[V , ujc dTroboGric6|ue-
5 vov 6 ebaveicavTO fi)Liu)V oi TrpoTrdTopec, 6 hr\ kqi 107
euKoXujc KaTapXriTeov Kai dcTevdKTUJc, OTav 6 bavei-
cac drraiTrj' euYVUj|uovecTaToi Ydp av outui qpaveiniiiev.
11. Oi)aai be Kai Trjv qpuciv opujcav t6 tc dTa-
KTOV Kai Ppaxuxp6viov toO piou dbrjXov Troificai thv
10 ToO 9avdTou TrpoGeciuiav " toOto ^dp fiv d|ueivov. ei
Ydp Trporibei)aev, Kdv TTpoeHeTfiKOVT6 Tivec Taic XuTraic
Ktti Tipiv dTToGaveiv eTe0vf|Kecav. opa be Kai toO piou
TO obuvripov Ktti To TToXXaTc cppovTiciv eTTTiVTXriiuevov,
dc ei pouXoi)Lie9a KaTapi9|ueTc9ai , Xiav dv auToO KaTa-
15 Yvoir|)uev, eTTaXri9eucai)Liev be Kai Tf]v TTap' Ivioic Kpa-
ToOcav b6Hav ujc dpa KpeTTT6v ecTi to T€9vdvai toO
Zifiv. 6 YoOv Ci)uujvibric
' dv9pujTTUJV ' qpriciv 'dXifov )uev KdpTOC, dTrpa- B KTOi be )aeXrib6vec, 20 aiujvi be TTaupuj tt6voc djuqpi Trdvuj.
6 b' dcpuKTOC 6)uu)C eTriKpe)aaTai 9dvaTOC* Keivou Ydp Tcov Xdxov )ue'poc o» t' dYa9oi ocTic Te KaK6c'. TTivbapoc be 25 *ev TTap' ec9X6v cuvbuo TTf||uaTa baiovTai
PpoToTc d9dvaT0i. Td |uev u)v ou buvavTai vfjTTioi k6c)uuj cpepeiv'.
1,329— 330H. 6,405— 407B.
2. ^TraTUJ-fouc Emperius: ^iraYUJYac 17. Ctnujvibric]
Bergk. p. 1132 3 ^i. TTiv6apoc] Pyth. III 81 25.
SaiovTa» Pindarus: &aivuvTai
246 CONSOLATIO
CoqpOKXfic bi
'cu b' fivbpa Gvnxov ei KareqpGiTO CT^veic,
eibujc t6 laeXXov oubev ei Kepboc qpepei;' Gupmibnc be
'Tot GvtiTd TrpdtMaT' oibac fiv fx^i (puciv; C boKuJ nev ou" TToGev fdp; d\X' dKOue ^iou.
PpoTOic dTTaci KaTSaveiv dcpeiXeTai,
KOUK l'cTiv auTiuv 6cTic eEeTTicTaTai
T^v aupiov laeXXoucav ei piuuceTai.
t6 Tfic Tuxnc Tdp d(pavk oi TTpoPnceTai*. TOiouTOu br\ ToO piou Tiuv dvepuiTTiuv 6VT0C OIOV OUTOl (paa, TTuuc ouK eubai)LioviZ!eiv ^dXXov TTpocnKei touc dTToXu9^VTac Tiic dv auTtp XaTpeiac f| KttTOiKTeipeiv Tt Kai 9p»iveiv, 6tt€p oi ttoXXoi bpujci bi' d)ia9iav; D 12. '0 bk CujKpdTnc TTapaiTXriciov ^Xeyev eivai u t6v 9dvaT0v fiTOi tlu pa9uTdTUJ uttvuj ri dTTobniaiqt liaKpd Kai TToXuxpoviuj f\ TpiTOV qp9opa Tivi Kai dqpa- vic)nuJ ToO Te cuJiLiaTOC Kai Tfic ipuxnc, KaT' oub^.v be TOUTujv KaK6v elvai. Kai Ka9' ^KacTov eTT€TTopeueTO,
Kai TTplJUTOV TUJ TTpUJTUJ. cl Yap bfl UTTVOC TIC ^CTIV a|
6 9dvaTOC Kai TTepi touc Ka9eubovTac m^^^v dcTi ko- k6v, bfiXov uic oub^ rrepi touc TeTeXeuTriKOTac eln fiv Ti KaKOV. dXXd )if|v y' 6ti nbicTOC ^ctiv 6 pa- 9uTaToc Ti bet Kai XeTeiv; auTd Ydp t6 TrpdTiaa qpa- vepov dcTi TTdciv dv9pu)TT0ic, laapTupei be Kai "OMri- ^^^ poc ^tt' auToO XeTuiv
'vfiTpeToc iibiCTOc, 9avdTUj dTXiCTa ^oikuOc*. E dXXaxoO be Kai TaOTa XeTei
1, 330—331 H. 6, 4JT-408R.
1. CoepoKXfic] Nauck. p. 248 4. €0piTri6nc] Alc. 780
ty. CuuKpdiTiic] Plat. Apol p. 10 C 25. "O.unpocJ v 80
AD APOLLONIUM 247
'ev9' "YTrvo) EujapXrjTO, KaciYvriTUj ©avcxTOio'
Kttl
'"Yttvuj Kai GavdTUJ 5ibu|adociv ', 6\\)E.\ Tfjv ojaoioTtiTa aiiTujv briXuJv • Td ydp bibujua
5 Tiiv ojuoioTriTa iudXiCTa rrapeiucpaivei. TrdXiv Te ttou cpnci Tov 0dvaTOv eivai 'xdXKeov uttvov', thv dvai- c9riciav fi|ua)V aiviTTojuevoc. ouk d)uoucuuc b' eboSev dTToqp/ivac0ai oub' 6 eirrujv tov uttvov Td luiKpd toO 0avdTou jaucTripia" Trpo)auricic ydp ovtujc ecTi tou
10 9avdT0u 6 uttvoc. trdvu be cocpujc Kai 6 kuvikoc F AiOYevric KaTevex9eic eic uttvov Kai iueXXujv eKXeiTreiv Tov piov, bieYcipavTOc auTov toO laTpoO Kai 7tu9o- laevou |ur| ti Trepi auTov eir| xotXerrov, 'oubev' ecpn' '6 ydp dbeXqpoc tov dbeXcpov rrpoXaiupdver.
15 13. 6T YC MHV drrobriiuia TrpoceoiKev 6 9dva- toc, oub' ouTUJC ecTi KaKov |ui'-|TTOTe be TouvavTiov dYa96v. t6 Ydp p.i] bebouXujjuevov capKi Kai toic rrd- 9eci TttuTric bidYCiv, ucp* ujv KaTacTTLUjuevoc 6 vouc Tfic 9vriTfic dvarriiuTTXaTai qpXuapiac, eubai)u6v ti Kai
20 luaKdpiov. 'juupiac |uev Ydp fi|uiv' qpriciv 6 TTXdTUJV 108 'dcxoXiac Trapexei to cuj|ua bid Tfiv dvaYKaiav Tpo- 9riv eTi be, edv Tivec vocoi TTpocrrecuJciv, ejUTTobiCou- civ fi|uiv Tfjv ToO ovToc 9ripav, epuuTUJv be Kai eTTi9u- )uiujv Kai qpdpujv Kai eibuuXujv TravTobaTTUJV Kai ^Xua- piac e)LiTTiTrXriciv iiudc, ujctc to X€Y6)uevov ujc dXri9ujc Tuj ovTi utt' auToO oube qppovficai fiuTv eYYiYveTai oubeTTOTe oubev. Kai Ydp rroXejuouc Kai CTdceic Kai
1,331-332H. 6, 408-410E.
1. Homer. = 231 3. Id. TT 672. 682 6. xa>».Keov]
Id. A 241 14. TrpoXaupdvei Dohnerus: -npo\a)updvei 6
Ottvoc tov Gdvaxov 17. 6e6ouXuj|Lidvov I. C. Orelliiig:
bebouXOJceai 20. TTXdtujv] Phaed. p. 66 B
248 CONSOLATIO
ladxac oubev aXXo Trapexei f| t6 cuj)aa Kai ai toutou €7n0u)aiar bid Tdp Trjv tujv xPIMdTUJV KTficiv TrdvTec
B 01 TToXejaoi YiTVOVTar Td be xP^lMCtTa dvaTKaZ:6)Lieea KTdcOai bid t6 ciju|ua, bouXeuovTec Tfj toutou eepa- Treia • Kai eK toutou dcxoXiav dTOjaev cpiXocoqpiac s TTepi bid TttuTa TrdvTa. t6 b' ecxaTOV TrdvTUJv, oti edv Tic fiiaiv Kai cxoXr) TevnTai dTt' auToO Kai Tpa- Truu)aeea TTp6c t6 CKOTreTv ti, ev TaTc Zr|Tr|ceci Trav- TaxoO TrapaTTTTTTOv edpupov Trapexei Kai Tapaxfiv Kai dK7TXf|TTei, uiCTC juf] buvaceai utt' auTOu KaOopdv Td- lo Xrieec. dXXd toi ovti f]|uTv bebeiKTai 6ti ei |ieXXo|uev TTOTC Kaeapojc ti eiceceai, dTraXXaKTeov auToO Kai auTfj T^ ipuxf) eeaTeov auTd Td TrpdT)uaTa" Kai TOTe,
C ujc eoiKev, f]|uTv ecTai oij dTTieu|uoO)aev Kai ou qpa^aev epfiv (ecTi bk qppovricic), erreibdv TeXeuTfjcuj^aev, ujc 6 isj XoTOC crijuaivei, Ziujci b' ou. ei Tdp )ufi oiov Te jueTd ToO ciu|LiaTOc )Liribev KaeapOuc Tvwvai, buoTv edTepov, n oubajuoO ecTi KTf|caceai t6 eibevai f\ TeXeuTf|cacr TOTe Tdp auTfi KaO' auTfiv ecTa» fi ipuxfi X^pxc toO ca)|uaTOC, TrpoTepov b' ou. Kai iv Jj dv 2d))uev, ou- 2»^ Twc, dic eoiKev, eTTUTdTUJ ic6\xeQa toO eibevai, edv j OTi ludXiCTa ^ribev 6|uiXu)|uev tuj cuu)uaTi |uribe koivu)- | viJu)uev, 6 Ti )ufi Trdca dvdTKr), wbk dvaTTi)UTTXu))ueea Tfjc TouTOu (puceujc, dXXd Kaeapeuujjaev dTr' auToO,
D eujc dv 6 ee6c auT6c dTioXucri fi)udc. Kai outuj )uev 25 dTTaXXaTTO/aevoi ttic toO ciujuaToc dqppocuvric, ujc t6 eiKOC, )ueTd toioutujv dc6)aeea, bi' fi)au)V auTwv Trdv t6 eiXiKpivec opujVTec" toOto be ecTi t6 dXriOec. plt] Kaeapuj Tdp KaeapoO eqpdiTTeceai \ir\ ou Qeixnov ^*. ujcTe ei Kai TTpoceoiKe MtfdTeiv eic l'Tepov tottov 6 30
1, 333— 334 H. C, 410— 412R.
1. ai Plato: ai drrd
AD APOLLONIUM 249
Odvatoc, oOk ecTi KaKov )uri7T0T€ Totp Kai tujv dfa- 0ajv dva(paivriTai , KaGdTrep dTrebeiHev 6 TTXdTUDV. bio Kai Ttdvu bai|uoviujc 6 CujKpdTric Ttpoc touc biKacTdc ToiauT' ^qpn 't6 xdp bebie'vai, ui dvbpec, tov 0dva- E
5 Tov oubev dXXo ^ctiv fi boKeiv cocpov eivai jufi ovTa* boKeiv tdp eibevai ecTiv d ouk oTbev. oTbe ^ev ydp oubeic Tov OdvaTOV oub' ei TUfxdvei Ttu dvOpuuTTUJ jueTiCTOv TTdvTUJV ov Tujv d*fa0ujv, bebiaci b' ujc eu eiboTec oti jjeTicTov tujv KaKuJv ecTiv'. ouk dTrdbeiv
10 b' eoiKe TOUTU)v oub' 6 eiTTuuVi
'luribeic (popeic0uj 0dvaTOV dTToXuciv ttovuuv', dXXd Kai KaKUJV tujv iieYicTuuv.
14. AexeTai be toutoic luapTupeTv Kai t6 OeTov. TToXXouc Ydp TTapeiXiicpajuev hi' eucepeiav TTapd 0eujv
15 TauTric TuxovTac Tf^c buupedc. ujv touc )uev dXXouc
qpeiboiuevoc Tiic cu|UfieTpiac toO cuTTpd|ujuaTOC Trapa-
/ Xeivpuu" |uvric6r|co)uai be tuuv ovtujv eiuqpavecTdTUJV Kai
TTdci bid CTOjuaToc. TTpuuTa br| coi Td Trepi KXeopiv P
Kai BiTuuva touc 'ApTeiouc veavicKOuc biriTilco)uai.
20 qpaci TOP ffic )unTp6c auTuuv iepeiac oucric Tfjc "Hpac eTTeibfi Tfic eic t6v veuuv dvapdceujc fiKev 6 Kaipoc, Tuuv ^Xkovtuuv Tfiv dTTf|vnv 6peuuv uct€- pncdvTUJV Kai Tfjc uupac erreiTOucric, toutouc utto- buvTac utto Tf]v dnfiviiv dTaTeiv eic to lepov Tfjv juriTepa, Tfiv b' uTTepric0eTcav Tfj tujv uiujv eucePeia KaTeuEac0ai t6 KpdTicTOV aOToTc Trapd Tfjc 0eou bo0fivai Tuuv ev dv0puuTTOic, touc be KaTaKOijuri0evTac )uriKeT' dvacTfivai, Tfic 0€oO tov OdvaTOV aOToTc ttic eOcepeiac d)uoipfiv bujprica)ue'vric. Kai Trepi 'ATajufibouc 109
30 be Kai Tpoqpujviou qpnci TTivbapoc t6v veuuv t6v ev
1, 331-3C5H. 6, 412— 413 E.
3. C'JUKpuTnc] Plat. Apol. p. 29 A 11. Nauck. p. 697
250 CONSOLATIO
AeXqpoTc oiKobojuir|cavTac aiteTv Trapd toO 'AttoWujvoc )aic06v, Tov b' auToTc eTraYTeiXcicBai eic epboiariv fme- pav dTTobuOceiv, ev tocoutiu b' euuuxeTcSai TrapaKeXeu- cacGar touc be TTOiricavTac t6 TTpocTax^ev Trj ^Pb6)nr) vuKTi KaTaKOi^rjQfVTac TeXeuTficai. XeYCTai bk m\ 5 auTUJ TTivbdpuj eTTicKJinJavTi toTc Trapd tujv Boiujtujv TTe/aqpGeTciv eic 6eo0 TTu9ec6ai 'ti dpicT6v ^ctiv dv-
B 6pu)TT0ic' dTTOKpivac0ai Tfjv TTp6)LiavTiv OTi oub' au- Toc dYvoeT, ei fe ra ypacpivxa Trepi Tpoqpujviou Kai 'ATa)nribouc dKeivou dcTiv ei bk Kai TT€ipa0fivai pou- lo XeTOi, ^ieT' ou ttoXu €C€c0ai outuj TTp6briXov. Kai ouTUJ TTU06jn€vov Tov TTivbapov cuXXoTi2[€c0ai Td Trpoc tov 6dvaT0v, bieX66vToc b' 6XiTou xpovou TeXeuTfi- cai. Td be TTcpi tov 'iTaXov Gu0uvoov ToiaOTd qpaci Tev€c6ai. eivai ^kv ydp auTov 'HXuciou Tepivaiou, 15 TiJuv ^KcT TTptwTOU Ktti dpeTfj KOi ttXoutuj Kai bdEr), J TeXeuTHcai b' dEaTTivr|c aiTia tivi dbf|Xuj. tov ouv J 'HXuciov eic€X6eTv oTrep icujc kSv dXXov €icfiX6e, iufi- ]
C ttot' eiri qpap^OKOic dTToXujXujc* toOtov ^dp eivai ] fidvov auTuJ eTT' oucia TroXXfj Kai xPnMctciv. drro- 20^ poOvTO b' OTUJ Tp6TTijJ ^dcavov Xdpoi TOUTUJV, dqpiKe- c6ai eTTi ti vjJuxo|aavTeTov, TTpo6ucd|uevov b' ujc vdjuoc eYK0i)jac6ai Kai ibeTv 6v|jiv TOidvbe. bdEai rrapaYeve- c6ai Tov TTaTepa tov ^auToO' ib6vTa be bieHepxec0ai
TTpOC aUTOV TTCpi THC TUXnC T^C KttTa TOV Ul6v, Kai 23
dvTipoXeTv TC Kai beTc0ai cuveHeupeTv tov aiTiov ToO 6avdT0u, koi t6v '^tti toutuj' qjdvai 'tikuj. dXXd beEai TTapd ToObe d coi qpepei, ^k ydp toutujv aTravT' eicri ujv TTepi XuTrrj'. eivai b' ov ^cfjjarive veavicKov D ^TT6)Lievov auTUJ, eiaqpepn Te tuj uiuj Kai Td toO xpdvou 30
1, 335-3:J7H. 6, 413-416 B.
15. 'HXuciou*: fi\uciou TTaxpoc xoO
A.D APOLLONIUM 251
re Kai xa Tfic fiXiKiac eYT^c. ^pecGai ouv octic eiri- K-ai Tov qpdvai 'baijaiuv toO uieoc cou', Kai outuj bf) opeEai 01 TPaMMaTibiov. dveiXricavTa ouv auTO ibeiv eTY€TP«MM^va Tpia TaOia
5 'n TTOu vriTTiericiv dXuouciv q)pevec dvbpujv. €u9uvooc KeiTai /aoipibiLu GavdToi. ou ydp eriv ZioDeiv KaXov auTUJ oube yoveOci'. ToiaOTa bri coi Kai Td Tduv biriTIMttTUJV tOuv Ttapd ToTc dpxaioic dvaTeTpotMM^vu^v.
10 15. €i TC M^iv 6 BdvaToc TeXeia tic ^cti qpGopd E Kai bidXucic ToO Te ciujLiaToc Kai Tfic MJuxnc (t6 Tpi- tov Tdp fiv toOto Tiic CoiKpaTiKfic eiKaciac), oub' ou- TUJ KaKOv ecTiv dvaicBncia Tdp tic k^t' auTov yi- veTai Kai Trdcric dTraXXaTri Xurrric Kai qppovTiboc. Trepi
15 Tdp t6 6v Kai t6 uqpecTriK^c KaGdTrep t6 dTa96v ire- qpuKe Tivec9ai , t6v auT6v TpoTTOV Kai t6 KaKov ■ Trepi be t6 |uf) 6v dXX' ripiaevov eK tujv ovtuuv oub' iTepov TOUTUJV uTfdpxei. eic Triv auTriv ouv TdEiv oi TeXeu- TiicavTec Ka9icTaVTai Tfi TTp6 Tfic T€veceujc. tucTrep F
20 ouv oubev fiv fiiLiiv TTp6 TTic Tcveceuic out' dTa96v ouTe KttKov, ouTUJC oube laeTd ttiv TeXeuTiiv. Kai Ka- BdTTep Td Trp6 fijLiujv oubev fjv TTp6c fiudc, outujc oube Td )ue9' fiMdc oubev ecTai TTp6c f]|adc'
'dXTOc' Tdp ovTUJC 'oubev ctTrTeTai veKpoO.'
25 't6' Tdp 'm'! Tevec9ai tuj 9aveTv icov Xctuj.' f] Tdp auTf] KaTdcTacic ecTi Tr) TTp6 Tfic Tcveceujc f]
1,337- 338 H. 6, 416-417 R,
5. ?\ TTOU lunius: rjpou vriiTi^riciv (iXOouciv*: v»im€
flXucie 7. ou T«P ii]"^*- ouk riv Top ou5e G. "Wolf-
fius: ouxe 14. q?povT(6oc * : qppovxiboc ujCTrep TOP out'
dYCtQov liiaiv Stt€Ctiv outuic ou6^ KaKov 24. fi\TOc] Nauck. p. 64 25. t6] Eurip. Troad. 636
252 CONSOLATIO
)LieTd Trjv TcXeuTriv. dX\* oiei ci> biaqpopdv etvai ixx] Yeveceai f\ Y€v6)Lievov dTroTeve'c0ai; ei \ii] Kai ttic oi- Kiac Kai TTJc ecGfiTOc fiiauJv ineTd TfjV cpGopdv ijtto- Xaiupdveic Tivd biaqpopdv eivai irpoc tov 6v oubeiTiu KaTecKeudc9r) xpovov. ei b' erri toutujv oubev ecTi, 5 110 bfiXov ujc oub' eiTi ToO 6avdTou itpoc TfjV rrpo Tfic Yeveceujc KaTdcTaciv ecTi biacpopd. x«pi£V Tdp t6 Tou 'ApKeciXdou. 'toOto' cprici 't6 XeTdinevov KaKov 6 GdvaToc iuovov tujv dXXujv tu)V vevo)aic|iie'vujv Ka- Kujv TTapov |Liev oubeva ttujkot' eXuTTricev, dTTov be lo Kai TTpocbOKUJiaevov XuTreT.' tuj ydp ovti ttoXXoi bid Tfiv oubeveiav Kai Tf|v rrpoc tov 6dvaT0v biaPoXfiv dTTo6vricKOuciv, iva iufi dTToedvuJCi. KaXOuc oijv 6 '£TTixap|iJ0c 'cuveKpi6ri' «piici 'Kai bieKpieri Kai dTTfiv- B 6ev 66ev f|v6e rrdXiv, Yd M^v eic Tdv, TTveOjLia b' dvuj. i5 Ti Tujvbe xoXeTTOv; oube ^v'. 6 KpeccpovTric be ttou 6 TTapd Tuj Gupmibr) TTepi toO 'HpaKXeouc Xctujv 'ei |nev Tdp oiKeT' cprici 'vepTepac utto xQovoc ev ToTciv ouKeT* ouciv, oubev dv c6evor. toOto |ueTaTTOir|cac emoic dv
'ei jLiev Tdp oiKeT v€pTe'pac utto xQovoc ev ToTciv ouKeT* ouciv, oub^v dv TTd6oi*. TevvaTov be Kai t6 AaKUJviKov
'vOv dMjuec, Trpoce' dXXoi 46dXeov, auTiKa b*
dXXoi, (Iiv djujuec Ttvedv ouKeT* eTTOipoiLieea' Kai TTdXiv
1, 338—339 H. 6, 417-4191
7. T^P] ^^?* 14. dTrnvGev — fjvGe Scaliger: dtTrfiX-
Gev — »^\ee 17. eOpnribr]] Nauck. p. 396 24. iQa-
Aeov L. Dindorfius: iGdWeov
AD APOLLONIUM 253
'o'i Qdvov ou t6 Z:fiv Gejaevoi KaXov oube t6 C
9vricKeiv, dXXd t6 TttOTa KaXujc diacpoTep' iKTeXecai'. Trdvu be KaXOuc Kai 6 €upiTribric eiri tujv Tdc )naKpdc 5 vocriXeiac uTro)uev6vTUJV qprici
'iLiiciju b' ocoi xPVI^ouciv iKTeiveiv piov, PpujTOici Kai rroToTci Kai juaYeujuaci TTapeKTpeTTOVTec 6xeT6v ujCTe )Lifi Gavetv. ouc XP^V, eTTeibdv |ur|bev lijqpeXiuci t^v, 10 GavovTac eppeiv KdKTTobibv eivai veoic*.
f) be MepoTTTi XoYOuc dvbpiObeic Trpoqpepojuevri Kivei D Td GeaTpa, Xeyouca TOiauTa
*Te9vdci Traibec ouk e)uoi luovri PpoTUJV, oub' dvbpdc ecTepri|ue9 ', dXXd )uupiai 13 t6v auT6v dErivTXricav ibc eTtu piov'.
TouTOic Tctp oiKeiujc dv tic TaOTa cuvdvpeie 'ttoO Tap Td cejuvd KeTva, ttoO be Aubinc lueTac buvdcTr|c KpoTcoc fi ZepHrjC papuv ZeuHac 9aXdccric auxev' 'GXXricTTovTiac; 20 dTTavTec dibav fiX9ov Kai Ad9ac bojuouc', '£
Tujv xpnM«TUJV d|ua toTc cd))uaci bia(p9apevTUJV.
16. Nfi Ai' dXXd touc ttoXXouc KiveT Trpdc Td TTev9ri Ktti Touc 9pr|vouc 6 dujpoc 9dvaT0C. dXXd Kai ouTOc ouTUJc ecTiv €UTrapa)Liu9riT0C , uicTe Kai utt6 25 TUJV TuxovTUJV TroiTiTuuv cuv€ujpdc9ai Kai T€TuxriKevai Trapa)uu9iac. 9eacai Tdp oia Trepi toutou cprici tujv KUJ)uiKUJV Tic Trp6c t6v eTTi tuj diupiu XuTT0U)UeV0V 9avdTUj
1, 339— 340 H. 6, 419-421 B.
1. Bergk. p. 1189' 4. €^piTri6ric] SuppL 1109
13. Nauck. p. 396 17. Bergk. p. 1357' 18. PaeOv
W 20. fiTravx' ^c "Aibav f\\Qe Bergkius
254 CONSOLATIO
'eiT' ei )uev rjbeic otti toOtov tov piov, 6v ouK epiuuce, Idjv bieuTuxrjcev dv, 6 GdvaToc ouk euKaipoc" ei b' fivexKev au ouTOC 6 Pioc Ti Tujv dvriKe'cTUJV, iciuc 6 GdvttTOc auToc coO Y£TOvev euvoucTepoc'. 5 F dbrjXou ouv ovTOc TTOTepov cujacpepdvTUJc dveiraucaTo Tov piov eKXiTTiijv Kai )aeiZ;6vujv dTroXueeic KaKUJV y\ ou, xPn W cpepeiv outuj papeoic ibc dTioXujXeKOTac TrdvG' ocujv ujri9ri)aev TeuHecBai nap' auToO. ou q)au- Xujc Tdp dv boHeiev 6 Trapd tuj TTOiriTr) 'A|Licpidpaoc lo TTapa^u9eTc0ai ttjv 'Apxe|u6pou juriTepa bucxepaivoucav OTi vrjTTioc u)v 6 TraTc Kai dYav dujpoc eTeXeuTrice. (pr[ci Ydp ouTUJC
' ecpu )aev oubeic octic ou TToveT PpoTuJv. GdrrTei Te TeKva xdTep' au KTdTai vea, i5
auTdc Te GvrjCKer Kai Tdb' dx9ovTai PpoToi 111 elc Y^v (p€'povTec y^v. dvaTKaiuJc b' e'xei
piov GepiZeiv utcTe KdpTTijuov CTdxuv, Kai Tov )uev elvai tov be \xy\. Ti TaOTa beT CTeveiv, aTTep beT KaTd cpuciv bieKTrepdv; 20
beivov Tdp oubev tuuv dva^KaiuJv PpoToTc'. 17. Ka96Xou Tdp XPii biavoeTcGai TrdvTa Tivd Kai TTpoc auTov Kal TTpoc dXXov bieHidvTa )ueTd CTTOubfic ujc oux 6 )uaKp6TaT0C pioc dpiCTOc dXX' 6 cfroubaid- TttTOC. oube Tdp 6 TrXeTcTa Ki9apujbricac n priTopeu- 25 B cac ^ Ku^epvncac dXX' 6 KaXujc eTraiveTTai. to Tdp KaXov ouK ev )ur|Kei xpovou GeTeov, dXX' ev dpeTrj
1 , 340 - 34 1 H. 6, 421—422 R.
1. Meinek. IV. p. 669. V. p. CCCXLVII 6tti] b\-
6ii lacobi 3. aO* 5. 6 Sdvaxoc Meziriacus
14. Nauck. p. 468 17. yf^v dva-fKaiuuc 6' Grotius: ti^v
6' dvaYKaioic
i
AD APOLLONIUM 255
xai Tfj Kaipiuj cujUiueTpia* toOto fap eubaijuov Kai GeoqpiXec eivai vev6|aiCTai. bid toOto yoOv touc unep- oxuuTdTOuc Tujv fipiOuJV Kai qpuvTac dTio 9eujv Trpo Yripujc eKXiTTOVTac tov p(ov oi TtoniTai napebocav 5 f]juiV; ul'CTrfp KaKeTvov
'6v fTepi Kfjpi cpiXei Zeuc t' aiTioxoc kcI
'AttoXXujv TravToiriv qpiXoTriT', oub' iKeTO Ynpcoc oubov'. TTiv Ydp euKaipiav iiidXXov, ou Tfjv euYriPi«v TravTaxn
10 Geujpouiaev TrpujTeuoucav. Kai t«P cpuTtuv dpiCTa Td C TrXeicTiiv KapTTuJv ev ppaxeT qpopdv TTOiou|aeva, Kai Ziujujv d(p' ujv ev ou ttoXXuj xpovuj TToXXfiv Ttpoc tov piov ujqpeXeiav ixo^ev. t6 Te ttoXu briTT0u9ev fi )lii- Kpov oubev biaqpepeiv boKei TTpoc tov dTreipov dqpo-
i- pujciv aiujva. Td y«P Xi^k^ ^ai Td )aupia KaTd Ci- luujvibriv eTri cTiY|uf| Tic ecTiv d6picTOC, juaXXov be |u6pi6v Ti PpaxuTaTov CTiY|iific. eTtei Kai tOuv ZIujujv eKcivwv, drrep iCTOpoOci Tiepi tov TTovtov Yivojueva Tfjv Ziujfiv exeiv fijuepriciav, e'uj9ev )uev Yswuujueva, ,ue'cric b' fifaepac dKjudJovTa, beiXric be YripwvTa Kai TeXeioOvTa t6 Zf\\/, ouxi KaKeivuJV fiv dv t6 Ka9' fijudc Trd9oc toOto, emep njuxn tic dv9pujTrivri Kai XoYic|a6c eKdcTOic evfiv, Kai TauTd bf|TTOu y' «v cuveTrmTev, D ujCT€ Td TTpo iuecric ttic fi)Liepac eKXeirrovTa 9pfivouc
25 rrapexeiv Kai bdKpua, Td be birijuepeucavTa TrdvTUJC eubaijuoviZiecGai ; )ue'Tpov y«P toO piou t6 KaX6v, ou
t6 TOO XPOVOU jufJKOC.
18. MaTaiouc Yap Kai TroXXfic euri9eiac fiYTiieov elvav Tdc ToiauTac eKqpujvficeic ^dXX' ouk ebei veov
1, 241—342 H. 6, 422— 424B
6. Homer. o 245 25. Trdvrujc*: TrdvTUJC fiv
250 CONSOLATIO
6vTa dvapnaYfivai '. tic fap Sv eiTTOi ibc fbet; ttoXXo be Kai fiXXa ^9' iLv &\ tic eirroi ujc 'ouk ^bei irpa- xOnvai' neTTpaKTai Kai TTpdTT€Ta» Kai TrpaxOrjceTai
E TToXXdKic. ou Ydp voMo6€TricovT€c Trdpec^ev eic tov Piov, dXXd TreicoMevoi toTc biaTeTaT/ievoic uiro tujv 6 Td 6Xa TTpuTaveudvTUJV Geujv Kai toic Tqc eifiapfaeVTic Kai TTpovoiac Gecfioic.
19. Ti b'; 01 TTev9o0vTec touc outiuc dTToGavovTac ^auTuJv eveKa TrevSoOciv f| tuuv KaToixo|ieviuv ; el |aev ouv ^auTuJv, 6ti ttic dTTO tujv TeGveuuTUJV fibovfic f) ic Xpeiac f| TripopocKiac dcT€pr|9ricav , qpiXauToc x] Tf\Q XuTTiic TTpoqpacic ou Ydp ^Keivouc TTo9o0vTec dXXd Tdc dTT' auTujv ujqpeXeiac (pavr|covTai. el bk rujv Te9veu)TUJV ^veKa Trev9o0civ, dTTiCTr|cavT€c 6ti dv ou-
F bevi KaKLu TUTXCtvouciv 6vt€C, dTraXXaYncovTai Tfic i.i Xurrric, dpxaitu Kai coqpu» TT€ic9^VTec Xotuj tu» irapai- voOvTi Td M^v dTa9d TTOieTv ujc laeYiCTa, Td be KaKd cuCTeXXeiv Kai TaTreivoOv. el jaev ouv t6 TTev9oc kTiv dTttOov, bei TTOicTv auTo ujc TrXeTcTov Kai m€Tictov el b', ujCTrep f] dXri^eia ^x^i , KaKdv auTO 6moXotoO- M€v elvai, cuctAXciv koi ttoicTv ujc ^XdxiCTOv Kai dEaXeiqpeiv eic t6 buvaTdv. ujc bk toOto (bctbiov, ko- Taqpavk Ik Tfic ToiauTric TTapa)au9iac. qjaci tdp tivo Tujv dpxaiujv qpiXocoqpujv eiciovTO Trpoc 'Apcivdriv Tf|v 112 paciXiccov TT€v9o0cav t6v ui6v toioutuj xP''lcac9ai X6- S^ YUJ, qpd)i€vov 6ti Ka9' 6v xpovov 6 Zeuc fve^e toTc boiMOc» Tdc Ti^dc, ouK ^Tuxe irapdv t6 TT^v9oc, fjbri be veveMnMCvujv f^X9ev ucTepov. t6v ouv Aia, ibc i^Eiou Koi auTiJj TtMfiv bo9fivai, dTTOpoOvTo bid t6 f^bri KaTr|vaXuuc9ai Tidcac toTc dXXotc, TouTriv outiu so boOvot T^iv ^Tri toTc TcXeuTiicoct YiYVOn^vnv, olov
I
AD APOLLONIUM 257
bdiKpua Kai XtjTTac. ujcTtep oijv touc aXXouc bai)iOvac, ucp' iLv Ti|LiiuvTai, TOUTOuc dTaTrav, tov auTov Tpo- 7T0V Kai t6 TTeveoc. 'edv iuev ouv auTo dTijudcric, B iL Yuvai, ou TTpoceXeuceTai cor edv be TijiidTai utto 5 cou ^TTijieXujc TaTc boGeicaic auTuj TifiaTc , XuTTaic Kai Gprivoic, dYaTTricei ce Kai dei ti coi 7Tape'HeTai toiou- Tov ^q)' Jj Ti)aiiGriceTai iTapd cou cuvexuJc'. Gauiua- ciujc bx] qpaiveTai tuj Xoyuj TTeicac outoc TrapeXecGai Tfic dvGpujTTOu t6 TTevGoc Kai touc Gpr|V0uc.
10 20. T6 b' oXov eiTTOi tic Sv TTp6c tov TTevGoOvTa 'TTOTepa TTaucri ttotc buccpopujv r\ dei beTv oirjcr) Xu- TTeTcGai Kai TTap' oXov t6v piov; ei |uev Ydp dei lae- vgTc CTTi Trj bucTTaGeia TauTr), TeXeiav dGXioTriTa ceauTtu TTapeHeic Kai TTiKpoTdTriv KaKobaijuoviav bid ipuxric C
15 dTevveiav Kai ^aXadav ei be iueTaGricr) ttotc, Ti ouk iibri jueTaTiGecai Kai ceauT6v dveXKeic eK ttic dTuxiac; oic Tdp XoTOic ToO xpovou TrpoTovTOC xPncdjuevoc dTToXuGncr) , TOUTOic vOv TrpoccxuJV dTTaXXdtriQi Tfjc KOKOuxiac' Kai ydp eTTi tOuv cuj)aaTiKUJV 7TaGri|udTUJv
20 f) TaxicTr) Tf)c dTTaXXaYfic oboc djjeivujv. o ouv |ueX- Xeic Tuj xpovuj xapilecQai, toOto tlu Xoyuj xdpicai Kai Tri Traibeia, Kai ceauT6v cKXucai tujv KaKuJv.
21. "AXX' ou Ydp tiXttiZ^ov' qprici 'TaOTa TTeice- cGai, oube TTpoceboKUJV '. dXX' expfiv ce TTpocboKdv D 25 Ktti TTpoKaTaKCKpiKevai TuJv dvGpujTTeiujv ttjv dbriXo- TriTa Ktti oubeveiav, Kai ouk dv vOv dTTapdcKeuoc ujCTTep utt6 TToXeiuiujv eHaiqpvric eTTeXGovTUJV ^XricpGrjc. KaXujc Ydp 6 TTapd tuj Gupmibr) Grjceuc TTapecKeudcGai cpaiveTai TTpoc Td xoiaOTa* CKeTvoc Ydp cprjciv
1,343— 344H. , 6, 426-427 E.
6. ce Perizonius: t6 29. Gi)piTri6ri] Nauck. p. 381
Hutarchi Moralia. VoL I. 17.
258 CONSOLATIO
*ifOj b^ ** TTapa coqpoO tivoc jiaeuOv eic qppovTibac voOv cujuqpopdc t' €PaXX6|ar|v, cpuYdc t' ejuauTO) TrpocTi6eic TrdTpac i}jLf\c eavdTOUc t' dujpouc Kai KaKUJV ctXXac obouc, iv' ei Ti TTdcxoiiii' ujv ibolalov qppevi, 5
E |Lir| )iOi veiupec TTpocirecov juaXXov bdKOi'. "
01 b' dYevvecTcpoi Ka\ dvacfKriTUJc biaKei|a€Voi oube dvacTpoqpfiv dvioTe Xaiupdvouci Trpoc t6 pouXeucaceai Ti Tutv eucxTmovujv Kai cu|Liqpep6vTU)V, dXX' dKTpeTTOV- Tai TTpoc Tdc ecxdTac TaXamujpiac , t6 larjbev aiTiov 10 cuj|aa Ti)iUjpou|Li€voi Kai Td ^r\ vocoOvTa KaTd tov 'Axaiov cuvaXTCiv dvaTKdZiovTec.
22. Aio Kai TTdvu KaXOuc 6 TTXdTUJV lome iTapai- veiv ev ^TaTc' TOiauTaic 'cuiaqpopaTc f^cuxiav exeiv, ujc ouTe br|Xou ovtoc toO KaKoO Kai toO dyaeoO, 15 F ouTe eic xd rrpdceev oubev rrpopaTvov tuj xc^€ttu)C qpe'povTr ^jLiTTobujv ydp YiTveceai t6 XuTTeTceai tuj Pou- Xeueceai Trepl toO yctovotoc Kai ujCTTep dv TTTuOcei ^ Kupujv Trpoc Td TreTTTUJKOTa Tieeceai Td ^auToO Trpd- YiuaTa, Srrr] X6yoc aipeT PcXtict' dv exeiv. ou beTv 20 ouv TrpocTTTaicavTac KaedTrep TraTbac exoiaevouc toO ^ TrXriY^VTOC poav, dXX* deiZeiv Triv vpuxfiv 6ti TdxicTa ■ YiYveceai Trepi t6 idceai t€ Kai ^TravopeoOv t6 tt€c6v Te Kai vocficav, laTpiKfi eprivujbiav dqpaviZiovTac'. tov Tujv AuKiujv vo)uoeeTTiv qpaci TrpocTdHai toic auToO 26 TToXiTaic, ^TTdv Treveujci, YuvaiKeiav T^|aqpi€C)ae'vouc dcefiTa ireveeTv, ^iaqpaiveiv PouXrieevTa 6ti YuvaiKiubcc 113 t6 Trdeoc Kai oux dp/adTTOV dvbpdci KOCjaioic Kai Trai-
1,344— 345H. 6, 427-420R
6. veujpic Musgravius: v€ap6v bctKOi Galenus vol. 5. p. 151 Chart. : bdKrj 12. 'Axai6v] Nauck. p. 587 13. TTXu- Tujv] Rep. X. p. 604 B 20. P^Xtict' fiv Plato: pdXTicta
X(i- j
'2
AD APOLLONIUM 259
beiac tXeuGepiou laeTaTTeTroirmevoic. GfiXu t«P ovtiuc Ktti dc0evk Koi dYevvec t6 TrevGeTv Y^vaiKec Tcip dvbpoiv eici (piXorrevGe^CTepai Kai oi pdppapoi tuuv '€XXr|vuJV, Ktti auTujv tujv pappdpujv oux oi tev-
5 vaiOTaTOi KcXtoi Kai TaXdTai Kai TrdvTec oi qjpovri- ^aToc dv5peioTe'pou TiecpuKOTec IjUTrXeoi, laaXXov b', emep dpa, AifUTTTioi Te Kai Cupoi Kai Auboi Kai Tidv- Tec ocoi TOuTOic TiapaTTXricioi. toutujv xdp touc |uev B eic p66pouc Tivdc KaTabuvTac icTopouciv eTi» TiXeiouc
10 fi|ue'pac jie'veiv, ixr]be t6 toO fiXiou qpujc opav PouXo- ILievouc, eTieibri Kai 6 TeTeXeuTrjKiuc dTtecTepriTai toutou. "lujv ToOv 6 TpaTiKoc TroiriTrjC, ouk dvrJKOOC ujv Tfjc TOUTUJV euriOeiac, TreTToiriKe Tiva Xe'TOucav 'eHfiXGov u)au)V keTic fipujVTUJV Tpocpoc
15 TTaibujv, p66pouc XmoOca TrevGriTripiouc '. Tivec be Tu)V pappdpuiv Kai jjiipr] toO cujjLtaToc diTO- Tejiivouci, pivac Kai uiTa Kai t6 dXXo cuj|aa KaTaiKi- ZovTec, bOKoOvTe'c ti x«pi2iec6ai toTc TeTeXeuTriKociv drrapTUJiuevoi ttic KaTd q)uciv ev toTc toioutoic jacTpioc
20 TTa6€ia.
23. 'AXXd vf) Aia rivec uTTOTUTXavovTec ouk erTi C TravTi 6avdTuj Td nevQr] beiv oTovTai Tivec6ai, dXX' eTTi ToTc dujpoic, bid t6 |Lirib€v6c TeTuxTiKe'vai tujv ^v Tuj piuj vevo|aic/ievujv dTa6u)V, oiov Td)iOu Traibeiac
25 TeXeioTriToc TToXiTeiac dpxuJv (TaOTa Tdp eivai Td Xu- TToOvTa fidXiCTa touc €tti toTc dujpoic dTuxoOvTac, bid t6 dq)r)pfic6ai TTp6 toO beovTOc ttic eXTriboc), dTvooOvTec oTi 6 dujpoc 6dvaToc ujc TTp6c Tfiv tujv
J, 345-S47H. 6,429— 431B.
1. eXeuGepiou Hertlinus: IXeueepou 4. 'CXXrivuJv koi
cOtujv*: '€X\rivujv Kai ot xeipouc fivSpec tiLv d|i€iv6vujv kqi aiiTujv bi 12. "luuv] Nauck. p. 576
17*
260 CONSOLATIO
dv9pu;TTUJV qpuciv oubev biacpepei. Ka9dTrep Tdp ttic eic Koivfiv TraTpiba TTopeiac TcpoKeijuevric Traciv dvaT- Kaiac Kai dTrapaiTviTOu o"i |aev TrpoTropeuovTai o'i b' eTTaKoXou9ouci , TrdvTec b' im t6 auTo epxovToi, tov auTov TpOTTOV Tu»v eic t6 xpcdjv 6beu6vTUJv oubev 5
D rrXeov ^xovTec tutx«vouciv 01 PpabuTepov dcpiKVOu- )jevoi Tujv 9dTTov TrapaTivoiuevujv. ei t£ MHV 6 duu- poc 9dvaT0c KaKov ecTiv, duupoTaToc dv eir) 6 tujv vriTTiuJv Kai eTi iudXXov 6 tujv dpTi T£T0v6tujv. dXXd Touc TOUTuiv 9avdT0uc pabiu)c q)e'po^ev Kai eu9u)aujc, 10 touc be tOuv fibri TrpopepriKOTUJV bucxepuic Kai TTev9i- KU)C bid t6v ck TiiJv laaTaiujv eXTribujv dvaTrXacjuov, fibri vo)Lii26vTUJV fi|uu»v pe^aiav exeiv Tfjv tOuv TriXi- KOUTUJV bia)aovr|V. ei be 6 ttic lojr[c tujv dv9pujTTUJV
■ xpovoc eiKOcae^Tric nv, t6v TrevTeKaibeKaeTri drroTevo- js laevov evo|ai21o|uiev av firiK^Ti dujpov TeXeuTdv dXX' fjbri laeTpov fiXiKiac exovTa iKavdv t6v be Tfjv tuiv
E eiKOciv eTuJv TTpo9ec)uiiav eKTrXripiucavTa ^ t6v ^tt^JC T€v6)Lievov ToO xuiv eiKOCiv eTuJv dpi9)LioO ttovtujc dv l|aaKapiZ;o)aev ibc eubai)aove'cTaTOV Kai TeXeiOTaTOv 20 biaTTepdcavTtt piov. ei be biaKociujv ctuiv fjv, t6v lKaT6v dTUJV TeXeuTfjcavTa TrdvTUJC fiv dujpov vo|ai- ZovTec eivai TTp6c 6bup)aoijc Kai 9pf|vouc eTpaTT6)ae9a. 24. AfiXov ouv 6ti Kai 6 XeTo^aevoc dujpoc 9d- vaToc euTTapa|au9r|T6c ^cti bid t€ TaOTa Kai Td rrpo- 25 eipri)ae'va ev toic l|a7Tpoc9ev. ^aeiov Tdp ovtujc ebd-
F Kpucev TpujiXoc r\ ripiaiaoc auToc, ei TTpoeTeXeuTricev eT' dK)aaZ;oucric auTuj Tfic paciXeiac Kai ttic TOcauTric Tuxnc Tiv e9pf|vei. oia toOv ttp6c t6v ^auToO bie- Xex9ri ui6v "€KTopa, TTapaivuJv dvaxuipeiv dTT6 Tf^c 30
1,317— 348 H. 6,431-432»
8. TU)v vritTiujv*: tujv 7Tai6ujv Kai vriTriujv
AD APOLLONIUM 20 1
TTpoc Tov 'AxiXXea ludxric, ev oTc (pnciv
'd\X' eicepxeo Teixoc, e/aov tckoc, oqppa cauucric Tpaiac Kai Tpiudc, \xr\be )ae'Ya KOboc 6p^2t;ic TTriXeibr), auTOC be ^iXrjc aiujvoc djuepGric. 5 TTpoc b' i[ik Tov bucTrivov eTi (ppove'ovT' e\e'ricov, 114 bucMopov, 6v pa TtaTfip Kpovibr|c eiri Yripcioc
oubiu aicr) ev dpYaXer) qpGicei, KttKd ttoW embovTa, uidc t' 6X\u|uevouc, d^KrjGeicac Te GuxaTpac, 10 Kai 6a\d|aouc Kepailofievouc , Kai vriTTia Te'Kva Pa\\6)U€va TCOTi TCiiri) £V aivrj briiOTfiTi, e\KO|aevac te vuouc ^Xofjc utt6 xepciv 'Axaitjuv, auTov b' dv TTuiiaTov jue Kuvec TrpuuTrici Guprjci iblirjCTai epuouciv, eTrei Ke tic 6He'i xaXKtu 15 Tuipac r\e paXdbv peGeuuv ck 0u)li6v ^XriTai. B
dW oTe bri Tro\i6v t€ Kdpn tto\i6v Te xeveiov aibuu t' aicxuvuuci Kuvec KTa|uevoio YcpovTOC, toOto br\ oiKTicTOv TT€\eTai b€i\oTci PpoToTciv '. SvTuuv ouv coi TTaiuTToWuuv TTapabeiTiudTuuv rrepi tou- 20 Tou evvor|0riTi t6v 9dvaT0V ouk 6\iTouc dTTaXXdTTeiv jueTdXuuv Kai xaXerruuv KaKuuv, u>v, ei drrepiuucav, Trdv- Tuuc dv eTTeipdGrjcav. a cpeiboiuevoc Tfjc toO X6tou C cumaeTpiac irapeXiTTov, dpKec0eic toTc eipriiaevoic TTpoc t6 juf] beTv Trepa toO cpuciKoO jueTpou TTp6c drTpaKTa ^'" TTevGri Kai 0pr|vouc dTevveTc eKTpeTTec0ai.
25. T6 Tdp iix] bi' auT6v KaKuuc rrpdTTeiv 6 juev KpdvTuup cprjciv ou mKp6v eivai Kouqpicjua Trp6c Tdc
1,348— 349H. 6, 432-434E.
3. Tpoidc* (Homer. X 56): Tpiuict&ac 14. ^pOouciv*:
^picouciv aut IpOcujciv 18. ppoToiciv*: Pporolciv ^ p^ 6
tepujv TToXiotc 6' fip' dva Tpixac 6\k€to xepd TiWuuv ^k Kccpa- Xfic o06' CKTOpi eu|u6v e-rreiGev 24. laeTpou*: Kci jueTpiou
262 CONSOLATIO
Tuxac, ifOj b' fiv eiTTOijii cpdpiaaKov dXuniac eivai laeYicTOv. t6 bk qpiXeiv tov laeTaXXdHavTa Kai CTep- Yeiv ouK ev Tqj XuTieTv lauTOuc ecTiv, dXX' i\i tuj tov dYaTr(jO|uevov luqpeXeiv lucpeXeia b' ecTi toic dqpriprme-
D voic f) bid Tfjc dYaGnc Hvriiaric xi^r]. oubeic Ydp dYa- 5 Goc dHioc Gpnvujv dXX' ujlivujv Kai Traidvaiv, oube Trev9ouc dXXd Mvr||ur|c euKXeouc, oube baKpuuuv dTTuubu- vujv dXX' eTeiujv dirapxujv, ei f(. 6 laeTnXXaxuJC 0ei6- Tepov Tiva piov lieTeiXriqpev , diTaXXaYeic Tfic toO cuu- |i«Toc XaTpeiac Kai tu»v dTpuTUJV toutujv qppovTibujv 10 Te Kai cujLKpopuJv, Sc dvdYKti touc eiXrjxoTac tov 9vri- Tov piov uTTO|ae'veiv , eu)C av dKTTXr|cujci tov emKXuj- cG^VTa Tfjc Zujfic jaiTOv, 6v ebujKev fmiv fi qpucic ouk eic dTTavTa tov xpovov, dXXd Ka9' eKacTOV drreveijLie Tov |aepic9evTa KaTd touc t^c eijuapjLievric vojuouc. 15
E 26. Aio Touc eO qppovoOvTac in\ toic dTTO0vf|- CKOuciv ou xPn Trepa toO qpuciKoO ja^Tpou Tfjc rrepi Triv Tuxnv XuTTric eic drTpaKTa Kai papPapiKd TTevGn 7TapeKTpeTTec9ai Kai to09' OTTep ttoXXoic fjbri cuvePn rrepijieveiv, uucTe iTpiv dTTujcac9ai Td 7Te'v9r| KaKOuxou- 20 jaevouc TcXeuTficai tov piov Kai iv toTc TTevGijuoic Tfic KaKobaijiOvoc TaqpfjC jaeTaXapeiv, ajaa tujv Te dviapoiv Kai TUJV ^K Tfic dXoYiCTiac KaKuiv cuYKribeuojaevujv auTOic, ujct' dmqp9^YHac9ai t6 'OjaripiKOV
' laupojuevoici bk. toici jueXac erTi ^Trepoc fiX9e '. - • 25
F bi6 Kai TToXXdKic auToTc TTpocbiaXeYec9ai xpn 'Ti bai; 7Tauc6jae9d rroTe XuTTOujaevoi f) dKaTaTraucTLij cujuqpopa cuvec6jLie9a jaexpi rravT^c toO piou;' t6 Ydp br] are-
1, 349-351 H. 6, 134-436 R.
6. iraidvijuv Leuuepius: ^iraivuuv 8. dTeiuuv Reiskius:
diCTciajv 13. fiirov*: piov 18. tOx»1V W: ^v\f]V
25. |Liupo|L»^voici] W 109. a 4-2.3. c 305
i
AD APOLLONIUM 263
XeuiriTOv voiaiZeiv t6 TTev6oc dvoiac ecTiv ^cxoittic, Ktti Tau0' opuJVTac ibc Kai oi papuXuiroTaTOi Kai ixo- XuTTevGecTaTOi TtpaoTaTOi Y^TVovTai TToXXdKic urro toO Xpovou, Kai ev oic ebucxepaivov ccpobpa juvrnuaciv
5 dvoi)aLij2ovTec Kai cTepvoTUTTOUjuevoi XajUTTpdc euouxiac cuvicTavTai iueTd iuoucoupYuJv Kai Tfic dXXr|c biaxu- ceuuc. juejurivoTOC ouv ecTi t6 outuuc UTToXajapdveiv TTapd|uovov eHeiv t6 TTev9oc. dXX' ei XoTiZ^oivO' 6ti115 TTauceTai Tivoc Y£VO)ievou, TTpocavaXoYicaiVT' dv xpo-
10 vou bnXabri ti TTOirjcavToc • t6 Ydp YeY€vr||uevov oube Geuj buvaTov ecTi TTOifjcai dYevr|TOv. oukoOv t6 vOv TTap' IXTTiba cu|upepr|K6c Kai rrapd Tfjv fiiueTepav boHav ebeiHe t6 eiuu96c TTepi ttoXXouc YivecOai bi' auTUiv tOuv epYouv. Ti ouv; dpd y* n^eic toOto bid toO
15 XoYOu )ua6eTv ou buvd|ue9a oub' lTTiXoYicac0ai, biOTi 'TTXeiri |uev Yaia KaKiuv TTXeiri be OdXacca' Kai 'Toidbe 6vriT0ici KaKd KaKujv djiqpi le Knpec eiXeOvTai, Kevefi b' eicbucic oub' B
ai9epi;'
20 27. TToXXoTc Ydp Kai coqpoTc dvbpdciv, uic q)rici KpdvTUjp, ou vOv dXXd TTdXai KeKXaucTai Tdv9puuTTiva, Ti^uupiav fiYou)ue'voic eivai t6v piov Kai dpxfjv t6 yc- vec9ai dv9puuTT0V cujuqpopdv thv lueYicTrjv. toOto be cpriciv 'ApiCTOTeXric Kai t6v CeiXrivov cuXXricp6evTa tuj
25 Mibqt dTToqpfivac9ai. PcXtiov b' auTdc Tdc toO qpiXo- coqpou XeEeic TTapa6ec6ai. qprici bfi Iv tuj €ubfi|uiu dTTiYpa(po)uevuj f| TTepi vyuxfic TauTi. 'bioTTep, iL Kpd- TicTc TTdvTuuv Kai juaKapicTOTaTe, Trp6c tuj )uaKapiouc Kai eubaijuovac eivai touc TeTeXeuTHKOTac vo)uiZ!eiv C
1, 351—352 H, 6, 436—438 E.
♦
2. Ktti Ta09**: KOiTOi Y€ 10. t6*: t6 ju^v 16.
TT\eln] Hesiod. 0. et D. 101 17. Bergk. ISU^
264 CONSOLATIO
Ktti t6 Mjeucac6ai ti KaT' auTUJV Kai t6 pXacqpriiueTv oux ociov nY0U)ae9a ujc KttTd PeXTiovujv Kai KpeiTTO- vujv fjbri YCTovoTUJV. Kai Tau6' outujc dpxaia Kai naXaid biaTeXei vevo|aic|ue'va nap' fiiiiTv, uicTe t6 na- pdiTav oubeic oi&ev ouTe tou xpovou Tfjv dpxnv ouTe 5 t6v 6evTa TrpujTov, dXXd t6v dTteipov aiiijva tuyx«- vei bid TcXouc ouTU) vevo|aiC)ae'va. ttp6c be br\ tou- Toic bid CTOjuaToc 6v toTc dv9pu)TT0ic opac o ck ttoX- Xu)V eTUJV TrepiqpepeTai 6puXou|Lievov.' 'ti toOt';' i(pY\. KdKeTvoc uTroXapuuv * ibc dpa |afi Yivec6ai )aev * 10
D l'q)Ti 'dpicTOv TTdvTwv, t6 be Te6vdvai toO Zfiv ecTi KpeTTTOv. Ktti TToXXoTc ouTUJ TTapd ToO baijLioviou |Lie- lnapTupriTai. toOto jli^v eKeivuj tuj Mibqi XeTOuci bfi- TTOu )LieTd Tfjv 6fipav ujc eXa^e t6v CeiXriv6v biepuj- TU)VTi Kai TTuv6avo)ae'vuj ti ttotc ecTi t6 P^Xtictov 15 ToTc dv6pujTT0ic Kai Ti t6 TTdvTUJV aipeTuuTaTov, t6 )aev rrpujTOV oubev e6eXeiv eiTTeTv dXXd ciujTTdv dppf|- KTUJC" eTTeibfi be' ■nore )li6Xic rrdcav )LiTiXCtvfiv )Ltrixavuj- jLievoc TTpocriYdTeTO (p6e'YHac6ai ti TTp6c auTov, outujc dvaYKaZ:6)Lievov eirreTv ' baijuovoc ^kittovou Kai Tuxric 20 XaXeTTfic e9fi)Li€pov CTTe'p]Lia, Ti )li€ (3idZ:€c6e Xe'Yeiv d
E u)LiTv dpeiov ^fi YVUJVai; |aeT' dYVoiac Ydp tujv oiKeiuJV KaKujv dXuTTOTaTOC 6 pioc. dvepujTTOic bk TTdjLtTrav ouK ^CTi Y€vec6ai t6 TrdvTUJV dpiCTOV oube lucTacxeTv Tfic ToO peXTicTou qpuceujc (dpiCTOv dpa Trdci Kai Trd- 25 caic t6 }xr\ Yeveceai)- t6 jiievTOi laeTd toOto koi t6
1,352— 353H. 6, 43&-439R.
2. i^YOU|Li€ea dic Kara peXxiovujv*: liic Kard peXTiovuuv riYoujneGa 6. tuyx<^v€i*: TUTXcivoua 8. ov Hal-
mius: tv 6*: uuc 15. PeXTiCTOV Meziriacus: P^Atiov
17. dtppiiKTUic Reiskius: dppriTUJc 25. fipa Bernaysius:
Yctp
AD APOLLONIUM 265
TTpujTOV Tujv dv9p(JUTruj dvucTuiv t6 T€V0)aevouc dtTro- Gaveiv dic TotxicTa. bfiXov ouv ujc ouctic KpeiTTOvoc Tnc ^v Tuj Te0vdvai biaYuuTnc r\ Tfic ev tuj lr[v, ou- Tuic dTiecprivaTO '. jnupia b' eTTi laupioic dv tic exoi
sToiaOTa TTapaTi0ec9ai Tipoc t6 auT6 KecpdXaiov* dXX' ouK dvaYKaiov jiaKpnYopeTv.
28. Ou xPn oSv Touc dTToGvriCKOVTac ve'ouc Gpn- F veTv oTi Tijuv ev tu) iuaKpuj Pilu vo)LiiZ;o)aevu)v dYaGwv dTTecTepnvTai • touto Ydp dbriXov, ujc TroXXdKic emo-
io|Liev, eiT€ dYttGujv dTrecTeprmevoi TUYXdvouciv eiTe KaKuJv TToXXuj Ydp rrXeiova Td KaKd. Kai Td \xkv |u6Xic Kai bid rroXXujv cppovTibuJV KTuOiaeGa, Td be KttKd TTdvu pabiujc" cTpoYY^Xa Ydp eivai cpaci TauTa Kai cuvexn Kai TTp6c dXXriXa qpepoiaeva KttTd TToXXdc
isaiTiac, Td b' dYaGd biexfj Te Kai buCKoXujc cuvepxo- |ieva TTpoc auToTc tou piou toTc Tepiaaciv. eTTiXeXr)- ciaevoic oijv eoiKajuev oti ou juovov, ujc qpriciv Eupmi- 116 brjc, 'Td xP^MCiTa' ouk 'Tbia KCKTiiVTai PpoToi', dXX' dTrXuJc Tujv dvGpwTrivujv oubev. bi6 Kai Itti rrdvTUJV
20 XeYeiv XPH
'Td Tujv 6eu»v b' exovTec eTTijaeXoujaeGa. OTav be \pr{l[jjc\ auT' dqpaipouvrai TrdXiv'. ou beT ouv bucqpopeTv, edv a expncav fi)LiTv TTp6c 6Xi- Yov, TauTtt dTTaiTiIJCiv • oube Ydp oi TpaTTeHTai, KaGd-
25 TTep eiu)Ga)aev Xe'Yeiv rroXXdKic, dTraiTOujuevoi Td Ge- liaTa bucxepaivouciv eTTi Tfj dTTobocei, edvrrep euYvuj- liovuJci. TTp6c Ydp touc ouk eu)Ltapujc drrobibovTac eiKOTUJC dv Tic eiTTOi 'erreXdGou oti TaOT' eXa^ec erri B
1, 353— 354 H. 6, 439-441 B.
1. dvepUjTruj dvucTuuv Reiskius: fiWiuv dvucTov t6*: 5euT€pov be t6 2. liUc] 6ti ijDc Reiskius 17. 60pi-
TTibric] Phoen. 555 21. Ibid. 556
266 CONSOLATIO
Tuj otTToboOvai;* toOto bx] toic GvriTOic aTiaci cujup^- PriK€v. exojLiev yap t6 lx]v ujCTrep eTii TrapaKaTa0e|ue- voic 0eoTc eH dvdTKric, Kai toutou xpovoc oubeic ecTiv ujpic|Lie'voc Tfic dTToboceuuc, ujCTrep Oube toic TpaTTeZiTaic Tfjc tujv 0e)LidTUJv , dX\' dbriXov rroTe 6 5 bouc dTTaiTrjcei. 6 ouv f| auToc |ue'XXujv dTTO0viiCK€iv f| Te'Kvujv dTTo0av6vTUJV UTTepaYavaKToiv ttujc ou Ka- Taqpavuic ^TTiXeXricTai oti Kai auT6c dv0pujTr6c ecTi Ktti Td TeKva 0vr|Td etevvricev; ou ydp ecTi cppevac exovToc dv0pu)TTOu dYvoeiv oti 6 dv0pujTToc Zuj6v 10 lcTi 0vriT6v, oub' oTi Ye'Y0vev eic t6 dTro0aveiv. el C YoOv f) Nidpri KaTd touc |uu0ouc TTpdxeipov eixe Tfjv uTT6Xr|iyiv TauTrjV oti Kal f)
'0aXe0ovTi piuj
pXdcTaic Te Te'KvuJV Ppi0o|ueva Y^^Kepdv 15
q)doc opuica' TeXeuTricei, ouk dv outujc ebucxepaivev ujc Kai to 2fiv e0eX€iv iKXiTTeTv bid t6 |U€Ye0oc thc cujuqpopdc, Kai Touc 0eouc eTTiKaXeTc0ai dvdpTTacTov auTf]V Yevec0ai TTp6c dTTiOXeiav Tfiv xa^eKUJTdTriv. bu' ecTi tojv AeX- (piKUJv YPCMMdTUJV Td ludXicT* dvaYKaioTaTa TTp6c tov piov, t6 'YVUJ01 cauTov' Kai t6 'mh^^v dYav'" ^k tou- D Tujv Ydp fjpTriTai Kai Td dXXa rrdvTa. TaOTa Ydp ecTiv dXXf|Xoic cuvLubd Kai cuiucpujva, Kai bid 0aTepou 0d-' Tepov eoiKe briXoOc0ai KaTd buvaiuiv. 4'v Te Ydp Tiy 25 YivuicKeiv lauT6v TTepie'xeTai t6 ^ribev dYav, Kai iv TouTiu t6 YivujcKeiv ^auTOV. bi6 Kai Trepi |u^v toutou qpriciv 6 "Iujv outujc
't6 'YVUJ01 cauT6v' toOt' cttoc |uev ou MeTCi,
^PYOV V ocov Zeuc |u6voc ^TTicTaTai 0€ujv', so
1,354— 355 H. 6, 441— 442 B
2. iTr\* 14. Bergk. p. 13433. Nauck. p. 697 29.
Nauck. p. 576
AD APOLLONIUM 2G7
6 be TTivbapoc
^co^oi be' qpiici 'Kai t6 '|iirib^v aTav' erroc ai- vrjcav 7T€piccujc'. 29. TaOra ouv ev biavoiqt tic exujv ujc TTu06xpn- 5 CTa TTapaYTe^MO^Ta 7Tp6c TTotVTa Ta toO piou TrpdYMCiTa E pabiuuc eqpapMoJeiv buvr|C€Tai Kai qp^peiv auTa beEiujc, eic Te Tfjv auToO qpuciv dq)opujv Kai eic t6 ^y\ Tre'pa Tou TTpocr|KOVTOc ^v Toic TTpocTriTTTOuciv T] biaip€c9ai Trpoc d\aZ:oveiav f| TaTTeivoOc0ai nai KaTaTTiTTTeiv Trp6c 10 oTktouc Kai 6Xo(pup|iouc bid t^v Tfic ij/uxric dc0eveiav Ktti t6v ^MqpuoMevov fiiiiTv toO 0avdTOu q)6pov Trapd TTiv dtvoiav tOuv eiuj06TUJV iv xqj piuj cujnPaiveiv KaTd Tfiv THC dvdYKTic r| TTeTTpuJMe'vric MoTpav. KaXuuc b' 01 TTuOaTopeioi TrapeKeXeucavTO Xe'TOVTec 15 'occa be baiMOvirici Tuxaic PpoTOi dXTe* exouciv,
r]V av luoTpav exric, TauTriv exe nr\b' dTavdKTei' V Kai 6 TpaTiK6c AicxvjXoc
'dvbpujv Tdp ecTiv evbiKUJV Te Kai coqpuuv ^v ToTc KaKoTci mh Te0u]Liu)C0ai 0eoTc* 20 Kai 6 Gupmibric
*6cTic b' dvdTKr) cuTKexu)pr|K€V PpoTuuv coqp6c TTap' fiiLiTv Kai Td 0€T' erricTaTai' Kai ev dXXoic
'Td TTpocTTecovTa b' ocTic eu qpepei PpoTujv, 25 dpiCTOc eivai cuuqppoveTv T€ |aoi boKeT'. 117
30. Oi be TToXXoi TTdvTa KaTaiiejucpovTai Kai TrdvTa Td trapd Tdc eXrTibac auToTc cuMPePnKOTa eH eTrripeiac Tuxnc Kai baijLiovujv T€ve'c0ai vojuiCouci. bio Kai eTTi
1, 355^356 H. 6, 443—444 E.
1. nivbapoc] Bergk. fr. 201 (235) 15. Carm. Aur, 17
17. AicxOXoc] Nauck. p. 543 20. 6upnTi6ric] Id. p. 524
24. Id. p. 412 28. TevkGai*: riveceai
268 CONSOLATIO
uaciv 6bupovTai, CTevoviec Kai Tfjv ^auTuuv dtTuxiav aiTiu))aevoi. irpoc ouc uttotuxujv dv tic eiTToi
'Oeoc be coi TTfjiu' oubev dX\' auToc cu coi'
Kai f] bid Tf)v dTtaibeuciav dvoia Kai TtapaqppocuvTi.
bid TauTTiv ToOv Tfjv biriTraTri)ae'vriv Kai ipeubn b6£av
TtdvTa KaTa|ud)LKpovTai GdvaTov. iav lu^v xdp ev dTTo-
B br|)uia tic ujv dTToOdvri, ctcvouciv eTTi\e'TOVTec
'buc)Liopoc, oub' dpa to) *ft TraTfip Kai TTOTVia
)af|Trip
occe Ka9aipf|couciv ' • ^dv b' ^TTi TTic okeiac TTapovTuuv toiv Toveujv, 6bu- povTtti ujc eHapTTacGevTOC eK twv x^ipwJv Kai t^v ev 6qpea\)aoic obuvriv auToTc eqpevTOC. edv dcpujvoc ixx]- b^v TTpocemujv TTepi jaribevdc, KXdovTec \eTouciv
' oube Ti )Lioi eiTTac ttukivov eTTOc, ou t^ kcv aiei C )ae)nvf))ariv '.
ddv TTpoco)ai\f|cac ti, toOt' dei Trpoxeipov 4'xouciv ujCTTep uTTeKKttuiaa Tfjc \uTrric. ^dvTax^ujc, dbupovT \eTOVTec 'dvriPTTdc6ri'- ^dv laaKpujc, laeiuqpovTai 6 KaTaqpGivficac Kai Ti|uujpri0eic dTT^Gave. TTdca Tdp Trpoqpacic kavf) Trpoc to Tdc \uTTac Kai touc 9pf|vo cuveTeipeiv. TaOTa b' ^Kivncav oi TTOiriTai, Kai )a XiCTa TouTUJV 6 TTpuJTOc "0|aripoc \eTU)v
' ujc be TTaTfip ou Traiboc 6bupeTai 6cTe'a xaiujv,
vu)aqpiou, 6c T€ 9avujv bei\ouc dKdxnce TOKfjac*.
1,356— 357 H. 6,444—446
8. cu co! (Soph. OR. 379) Reiskius: auTuj cO coi 8. Homer. A 453 11. olKtiac Reiskiiis: oiKEiac Traxpiboc
13. ^cpdvTOC*: dcp^vTOC ^av*: ^civ 6* 15. Homer,
S2 744 24. Id. V 222 25. TOKriac*: TOKf^ac fippTiTo|
ii TOKeOci f6o-v koI tt^vGoc ^GrjKe (icl. P 37)
i
AD APOLLONIUM 269
Kai xauTa inev outtuu bfiXov ei biKaiuac obupeTai, dXX' D opa t6 eHiic
'laoOvoc TriX0Y€TOc rcoXXoiciv em KTedTecci*.
' (31) Tic Tdp oibev, ei 6 6e6c TraTpiKuJc KTib6|uevoc
6 ToO dv6puuTreiou T€VOuc, TTpoopiujuevoc Td |ueXXovTa cujupiicec6ai TrpoeHdTei Tivdc eK toO li]w duOpouc; 66ev oubev dTTeuKT6v vojuicTe'ov auTOuc ndcxeiv
('beiv6v Tdp oubev tuuv dvaTKaiuuv PpoTOic* ouTe TLuv KaTd TTpor|Tou|uevov Xotov cujuPaivovTuuv
10 ouTe Tujv KaT' eTTaKoXou6riciv) Kai oti oi ttX€ictoi E 6dvaT0i TTpo dXXuuv bucxepuuv lueiZovuuv TiTvovTai, Kai oTi ToTc )Liev oube Tevec6ai cuvecpepe, toic b' a|ua tu» Tevec6ai dTTo6aveiv, toic be TrpoeX6ouciv eTTi mKp6v toTc b' dK)udZ;ouci. TTp6c TrdvTac bi] toutouc touc
15 6avdTouc eXacppuuc ^kt€'ov, eiboTac oti Tfjv luoTpav ouK ecTiv eKcpuTeiv (TreTraibeu|uevuuv b' Ictiv dv6puu- TTuuv TTpoeiXriqpevai biOTi Ppaxuv xpovov TTpoeiXr|cpaciv fiiuac ol boKoOvTec duupoi toO lf\y ecTepfic6ai • Kai Tdp 6 luaKpoTaTOC pioc oXitoc kfi Kai cTiTjuaToc TTp6c t6v
20 dTreipov aiuuva) Kai oti ttoXXoi tuuv eTTi ttXc^ov TTev- F 6r|cdvTuuv jueT' ou ttoXu toTc utt' auTuJv KOTobup^eT- civ eTTr)KoXouericav , oubev Ik toO Trev6ouc ocpeXoc TTepiTTOiricd|aevoi, )udTriv be auTOuc KaTaiKicdjuevoi TaTc KaKOuxiaic. PpaxuTdTOu be toO ttic ^TnbTi)uiac ovtoc
25 ev Tiu pitu xpdvou, ouk ^v TaTc aux)LiripaTc XuTraic oub' Iv Tuj KaKobaijuovecTdTuj TTev6ei biacp6eipeiv eau- ToOc beT TaTc obuvaic Kai TaTc toO cuu)aaT0c aiKiaic TrapaTeivojuevouc , dXXd ^ueTapdXXeiv eTTi t6 KpeTccov
J, 357-358 H. 6, 446—447 R
3. Homer. I 492 7. d-rreuKT^v =*= : qpeuKxov 8. 6eiv6v Yctp ou6ev Clemens Strom. IV. p. 587 (Nauck. p. 468, 757, 9): oub^v T«P &eiv6v
lU
I
270 CONSOLATIO
Kai dvGpaimKiuTepov Tieipujn^vouc , Kai CTTOubdZiovTac 118 ^VTUYXaveiv dvbpdci \xy] toTc cuX\uTTOU)aevoic Kai bie Teipouci Td 7T^v0n ^i" KoXaKeiav, dXXd toIc d^aipou- iuevoic Tdc XuTrac bid tevvaiac Kai ceiivfic TiapriTOpiac, eTtaKouovTac Kai ^xovTac ev vuj t6 'OjiripiKov toOto €TTOc, orrep 6 "€ktiup ttpoc ttiv 'Avbpo)ndxriv dvTmap riTopiLv auTfiv eiTTev ibbi
'baijioviri, Mr| |ioi ti Xirjv dKaxi^eo Gujauj'
ou Tdp Tic \x' uTTep aicav dvfip "Aibi TTpoidq;ei,
liotpav b' ou Tivd qprmi TreqpuTM^vov Imnevai lo
dvbpwv, o\) KttKOV oubfe ^xiv ^cGXov, iTTfiv Td TTpujTa TevrjTai'. TauTriv bk Tfjv )iOipav ^v dXXoic 6 TToiriTfic cprici B ' T£ivo|ievuj ^Tre'vric€ Xivuj, 6Te )iiv Te'Ke ixryxr\p\
32. TauTa TTpo biavoiac XapovTec Tfic dTTpdKTOUM Kai Kevfic dTTaXXaTric6|ue0a papuTrevOeiac, 6XiT0u bf| TravTdTTac» toO lieTaSu xpovou Tfic Juifjc 6vtoc. CTTeu CTeov ouv 6ttujc eu0u)i6v tc Kai dTTapevdxXrjTOV TaTc TTev0iKaTc XuTraic biaTdTuj)i€v , Td toO tt^v 0OUC TTapdcTi)ia )i€0^)ievoi Kai Tnc toO ciu^aTOc dTTi jieXeiac cppovTicavTec Kai Tfjc tujv cuiuPiouvtujv fi)iTv cuJTTipiac. KaX6v bk Kai )ie)ivfic0ai tujv Xotujv, olc KttTd t6 eiK^c dxPncd)ie0d ttotc ttp6c cuTTCveTc f| qpi- Xouc dv TaTc TTapaTTXricioic T£VO)ievouc cu^q)opaTc, C irapa^iuOouiuevoi Kai TTei0ovTec Td Koivd toO piou cu^- as TTTUJnaTa KOivuJC qp^peiv Kai Td dv0puiTTiva dv0pujTTivujc, Kai |ifi ToTc )iev dXXoic eTTapKcTv TTp6c" dXuTTiav buva- c0ai, ^auToTc hk )iribev 6q)eXoc etvai Tfiv toutujv ufTd- jivriciv, bi' iLv beT t6 dXToOv Tfic HJuxnc drco^epaTTeueiv
1, 358-359 H. 6,447-4491
4. bid*t 6i6 Tf^c 8. Homer. Z 486 14. Id.]
Y 128 17, cneucT^ov*: qpcicT^ov
AD APOLLONIUM 271
Ttaiujvioic XoYOu cpapiLidKOic , ujc TrdvTUJV laaXXov f| dXuTTiac dvapoXrjv bei TTOieicGai. Kaixoi fe tov ev 6tujo\jv dMPoXiepYov ctTaic qprici TiaXaieiv, t6 kukXoij- inevov toOto Trapd Trdciv cttoc • tcoXu b' oT|uai ludXXov D
5 Tov uTTepTi6e'|U€V0v Td Tfic vpuxric dxOeivd TTdSri Kai bucdvTHTa Trpoc tov dTTiovTa xpovov.
33. 'ATTOpXe'Treiv be Kai ttpoc touc euYevujc Kai laeTaXocppovujc touc eTri toic uioTc Tevo|uevouc Gavd- Touc Kai Trpdujc uTTOCTdvTac, 'AvaHaTopav tov KXa-
loZojLieviov Kai ArijiiocGevTi tov 'A9r|vaTov Kai Aiujva Tov CupaKociov Kai tov paciXea 'Avtiyovov, Kai cu- Xvouc dXXouc Toiv t6 TTaXaiuJv Kai tuuv Ka9' f])adc. TouTujv Tdp 'AvaEaTopav TTapeiXrjcpaiuev , ujc cpaci, cpucioXoToOvTa Kai biaXeToiaevov toTc TVUJpi|uoic,
15 dKOucavTa Trapd tivoc tujv dvaTT^iXdvTUJV auTuJ ttiv
TTCpi TOV UIOV TeXeUTrjV, jUlKpOV eTTlCXOVTa TTPOC TOUC E
TTapovTac eiTreTv 'fjbeiv oti GvriTov ^Tewrica tov uTov'. TTepiKXea be tov Kai 'OXu|uttiov TrpocaTOpeu9evTa bid Tfjv rrepi tov Xotov Kai ttiv cuveciv UTrepPepXriiLievriv
20 buvaiaiv, TTu96juevov d|U(poTe'pouc auToO touc uTouc ^eTrjXXaxevai tov piov, TTdpaXov tc Kai Zdv9iTTTT0v (ujc qprjci TTpujTaTopac , eiTTUJV outujc 'tujv Tdp uie'ujv verivie'ujv ovtujv Kai KaXwv, ev 6ktuj be Trjci Trdcr]civ fijuepriciv dTTo9av6vTUJv vriTTev9e'ujc dveTXr). eubiric Tdp
25 eixeTO , IH fic ttoXXov uuvriTO KaTd Trdcav fiM^Pnv eic euTTOT|iir|V KttT dvujbuviriv Kai TfjV iv toTci ttoXXoTci f
1, 359— 360 H-. 6, 449— 451 E.
3. djLiPoXiepTov] Hesiocl. 0. et D. 414 8. eavdrouc
KCii W: Gavdxouc 10. Kai — 'A6r]vaiov] Post 'AGrivalov
Hertlinus addit Kai ZevoqpujvTa tov 'A6rivaTov. Fuisse vide- tur Kol TTepiKXifa Kai EevoqpOuvTa Kal Ari,uoc6evri toOc 'Aer^- vaiouc 18. Tov*
272 CONSOLATIO
boHav itSc f&p tic )niv opeuuv xd eauToO TtevGea ep- piujne'vijuc (pe'povTa, ineYaXoqppovd Te Kai dvbprjiov ebo- Kee eivai Kai ^auToO Kpeiccuu, KdpTa eibibc Triv lauToO ev Toioicibe TrpdTMaci dMTiXctviriv ')> oub^v fjTTOV ecTC- q)avuu)Li^vov KaTd t6 TidTpiov e6oc Kai XeuxeijuovouvTa br||uriTopeiv 'PouXdc t' ^HdpxovT* dYa9dc' Trpoc t6 Tov TToXejaov eTTiTrapopiaijuvTa touc 'AGnvaiouc. Eevo- qpujvTa be tov CujKpaTiKOV 6uovTd ttotc, Tiapd tOuv dTTeXuuv dTro toO TToX^jaou Tru06)aevov oti 6 uioc au- ToO fpuXXoc dTUJVi26)uevoc eTeXeuTrice , TrepieX^iuievov lo 119 Tov CTecpavov eHcTdZieiv Tiva Tp^rrov eTcXeuTrice. tlDv be dTraTT€iXdvTuuv oti Tevvaiuuc dpiCTeuuuv Kai ttoX- Xouc Tuuv TToXeiuiuuv KaTaKTeivac, iuiKpov TravTeXuuc bmcTricavTa xpovov Kai tu) Xotic)uuj to TTdGoc TTapa- : KaTacx6vTa , eTri0e|uevov TrdXiv tov CTe^avov drriTeXeiv ii Tfiv 6uciav, Kai Trpoc touc dTTeXouc eiTreiv oti '6eoTc TiuHd|uriv ouK dOdvaTOV oube TToXuxpoviov Tevec6ai |uoi Tov uiov (t6 Tdp toioOtov dbrjXov ei cu|ucpepei), dTa06v be Kai qpiXoTraTpiv, 6 bi] Kai TCTOvev'. Aiuuva B be t6v CupaKociov cuvebpeuovTa |ueTd tuliv qpiXuuv, KaTd Tfjv oiKiav 6opuPou Tevo|uevou Kai |ueTdXr|C KpauTnc, TTu06|uevov Triv aiTiav Kai t6 cujupeprjKoc OKOucavTa oti 6 ui6c auToO KaTaTrecujv dTTo toO ct^- Touc eTeXeuTiicev, oubev eKTrXaTevTa t6 |uev cuu|udTiov KeXeOcai toO lueTaXXdHavToc TaTc Tuvairi TrapaboOvai 23 TTpoc Tfjv v6)ii|uov Taqpnv, auT6v be Trepi uJv biecK^- TTTCTO |ufi TTapaXmeTv. toOtov JrjXuucai Xe'TeTai koi Ar|- |uoc6evri t6v pf|Topa, Tfiv |u6vnv Kai dTaTrriTfiv drro-
1, 360—362 H. 6, 451—452 K.
4. djurixctvir)v*: d)LirixaviTiv • toOtov fup eOGuc lueTci ri]v TTpocaYTE^icv d)LicpoTepu)v tujv ui^ujv 6. pouXdc] Homer.
B 273 18. el*: 6ti
AD APOLLONIUM 273
XecavTtt euTarepa, uepi fic cprjciv Aicxwnc, KaTrjYOpeTv auToO boHac, TauTi. '^pboiariv b' fi)iiepav Tfic GuTa- Tpoc aOTUj T€T€\euTriKuiac, Ttplv TrevGficai Kai Tct vo|ai- C Z:6|ueva TTOificai, CTcqpavujcdiuevoc Kai XeuKriv ecGfiTa
5 dvaXaPujv epou0uTei Kai Trapevojiei , Tfiv |u6vriv 6 bei- Xaioc Kai 7rpuuTr|v auTOV TraTepa TTpocemoucav dTTO- Xe'cac'. oCtoc jiev ouv priTopiKUJC TTpo0e'ja€voc auToO KaTntopficai TaOTa bieSfjXGev, dTvouJv oti bid toutujv auTov eTTaivei t6 TrevGeiv TTapujcdjuevov Kai t6 (piX6-
10 TraTpi TTpo Tfic Tujv dvaTKaiujv cu|LiTra6eiac eTTibeiHd- laevov. 'AvTiTOVov be t6v paciXe'a Tru96|uevov TfjV 'AXkuov€ujc toO uioO TeXeuTfjv ev TTapaTdHei T€VO|ie- vnv |LieTaXo(pp6vujc Te TTp6c touc dTTaTT^iXavTac auTUJ Tiiv cuiuqpopdv dTTibeiv Kai |uiKp6v emcx^vTa Kai KaTri-
15 cpidcavTa TrpoceiTTeTv ^u» 'AXKUoveO, ovpiTepov jueTfiX- D XaHac t6v piov, outujc dqpeibujc lHop)uu)V eTTi touc TioXe)uiouc Kai ouTe ttic ^auToO cujTripiac outc tuuv ejuujv TTapaiveceujv <ppovTi2ujv '. toutouc bfi toCic dv- bpac GaujudZouci |uev Tfic lueTaXoqppocuvric TrdvTec Kai
2odTavTai, |ui|ueTc0ai b' em tujv epTUJV ou buvavTai bid THV CK Tfic dTTaibeuciac dc0eveiav ttic i|Juxfic. ttXtiv rroXXujv ovtujv TTapaberfMdTUJV tujv bid Tfic TcTopiac fi^Tv Trapabibojuevujv Tfjc Te 'EXXriviKfic Kai Tnc 'Puj- uaiKfic Tujv T€vvaiujc Kai KaXuJc ev raic toiv dvaT-
25 Kaiujv TeXeuTaTc biaTevojuevujv dTToxpfjcei Td eipriiueva TTpoc Triv dTT60eciv toO rrdvTUJV dviapoTdTOu 7Tev0ouc Ktti TTic ^v TOUTLU TTpoc oubev xpnciMOV juaTaiOTTOviac. E 34. "Oti Tdp oT TaTc dpeTaTc bieveTKdvTCC wc
1, 362—363 H. 6, 452 -454 K.
1. Alcxivric] adv. Ctesiph. p. 64, 38 5. irotpevoiiei
Aescliines: Trapriv6|U€i 16. eTti*: iTpoc 26. rrdvTUJv
Reiskius: iTavToc
Plutarchi Moralia. Vol. I. 18
274 CONSOLATIO
eeoqjiXeic veoi jueTe'cTr|cav rrpoc t6 xP^^v Kai TrdXai )uev bid TUJV irpoceev uTrejLivrica Xoyujv, Kai vOv be 7Teipdco|aai bid PpaxuTdTuuv dTribpajiieTv, TTpoc)LiapTupr|- cac TLu KaXujc \j7t6 Mevdvbpou prieevTi tovjtuj
'6v 01 eeoi q)iXoOciv dTroevr|CKei veoc'. 5
dXX' icujc uTTOTuxtuv av qjairic 'ATtoXXujvie q)iXTaTe, cq)6bp' r\v eKiT€Teu|uevoc 6 veaviCKOC 'AttoXXujvi Kal P laoipaic, Kai ce ebei utt' iKeivou TeXeiou TevojLtevou KTibeuefivai laeTaXXdEavTa tov piov touto tap elvai KaTd qpuciv. Triv fi|aeTe'pav briXovoTi Kai Trjv dvepu)- 10 TTivriv, dXX' ou KaTd Trjv tujv oXujv TTpovoiav Kai ttiv K0C|LiiKfiv bidTaHiv. eKeivuj be tlu jaaKapiceevTi ouk flv KaTd qjuciv TTepaiTe'puj tou dTTOvejurieevTOc auTUJ Xpovou TTpoc Tov evedbe piov TTepi)aeveiv , dXX' euTd- KTUJC TOuTov eKTrXf|cavTi TTpoc Triv eijaapjLievriv CTravd- 15 Yeiv TTopeiav, KaXoucr|c auTfic, q)r|civ, fibri Trpoc eau- Tf|v. dXX' dujpoc eTeXeuTrjcev ; oukoOv euTTOTiaoTepoc bid toOto Kttl KaKUJv dTreipaToc ecTiv 120 '6 pioc Ydp' qpriciv Gupmibric 'ovojii' exei piov
liOpOC Y€TUJC'. 20
ouTOC b' eTTi Tfic euaveecTdTric fjXiKiac TTpoaTteqjoiTTi- cev 6X6KXripoc fjieeoc, Z!riXujT6c Kal TrepipXeTTTOc Trdci ToTc cuvfieeciv auTuj, q)iXoTrdTUjp Yev6|ievoc Kai qjiXo- |Lif|TUjp Kai qpiXoiKeioc koi q)iX6coq)OC, t6 be cujuTrav eiTreiv q)iXdvepujTTOC , aiboujuevoc juev touc TrpecPuT^- zs pouc TuJv qpiXujv ujcTtep TraTepac, CTe'pYUJV be touc ojLifiXiKac Kai cuvfjeeic, Ti)Ltr|TiK6c be tujv KaeriYncajue'- vujv, Hevoic be Kai dcToTc TrpadTaTOc, Trdci be jueiXixoc
1, 363—364 H. 6, 454—456 E.
5. Meinek, IV. p. 105 8. (noipaic] MoOcaic Madvi-
gius 17. fiuupoc Didotiana: diOpuJC 19. Nauck. p. 524
?X€i Piov |i6poc*: ^x^i TTOVOC Y^Yiwc Nauckius: kfix) c'
AD APOLLONIUM 275
Ktti cpiXoc bid T6 Tfiv eH oijjeuuc xapiv Kai Tf)v euTipoc- B riTopov qpiXavOpujTTiav. dXXa "fdp eKeivoc )aev Tfic Te cfic eucepeiac Kai ttic ^auToO Tfiv TTpe'Troucav eu- qpriiuiav exuuv irpoc tov dei xpovov TTpoaTre^poiTrice
5 Tou GvriToO piou, KaGdrrep ck cujaTiociou, Trpiv eic Tiva Ttapoiviav eKTreceiv Tfiv tuj iuaKpuj Ynpa TrapeTTO)ievTiv. ei b' 6 Tujv TraXaiujv Te ttoititujv Kai cpiXococpujv X6- Yoc ecTiv dXnOfic ujCTrep ekoc exeiv, outuj Kai toTc eucepeci tOuv |neTaXXaHdvTujv dcTi tic TifLifi Kai Trpo-
10 ebpia KaGdTTep XeTeTai, Kai xujpdc tic dTroTeTaT|ue'voc ev dj biaTpipouciv ai toutujv Uiuxai, KaXdc eXTribac 0 exeiv ce bei Trepi toO |uaKapiTOu uieoc cou, oti tou Toic cuYKaTapi6|uri6eic cuvecTai.
35. Ae^eTai b' uTro juev tou jueXiKoO TTivbdpou
15 TauTi Trepi tujv eucepoiv ev "Aibou,
*Toki XdjuTrei |uev jievoc deXiou Tdv Iv6dbe vu-
KTtt KaTUU,
q)OiviKop6boic ev Xei)uuuvecci TrpodcTiov auTuuv Kai Xipdvuj CKiapov Kai xP^Jceoic KdpTTOic pe-
ppi66c. Ktti Toi juev iTTTTOic YUMvacioic Te Toi be TreccoTc, Toi be (pop|uiTT€ci Te'pTrovTai, Trapd bi ccpiciv
€uav6f]c ctTrac Te'6aXev oXpoc, 6b|ud b' ^paTOV KaTd x^jpov KibvaTai aiei 6ua mTvuvTUJV Trupi T^XeqpaveT TravToTa 6eaiv
eTTi puujuoTc'.
«-3C6H. 6, 456 -458 R.
5. ^K*: ^K ToO 14. TTiv6dpou] Bergk. fr. 106 (95)
18. qpoiviKOpobotc ^v (6' ^vi Bergkius) Xei)mjuv€cci p. 1130 C: qpoiviKOpobiai Te XeiiuuJvec TrpodcTiov G. Hermannus:
TTpodcTeiov 19. xpwc^oic Kdpiroic Bockhius: xP^coKdp-
TToici peppiOoc Reiskius: pdppi6e 21. itnioic tuMva-
cioic TeHermannus: iTTTreioic YUMvacioic 25. Gua iclem:
•iu|aaTa
18*
276 CONSOLATIO
D Ktti iniKpov TrpoeXGiijv ev clWuj Gprjvuj nepi MJUxnc Xe- Yuuv qpnciv
•■oXpiot b' aTravtec aica Xucinovov TeXeuidv. ' Kai cuujLia ixkv TrdvTUJV erreTai GavdTO) TtepicGeveT, 1\jj6v b' eTi XeiTTeTai aiuuvoc eibiuXov • t6 Ydp 5
ecTi juovov dK 6€a)V. eubei be TrpaccovTUJv jueXeujv, dTdp eu-
bovTecciv ev ttoXXoTc oveipoic
beiKVuci TepTTVuuv ^cpepTTOicav xctXeTTiI»v Te Kpiciv '.
36. '0 be 6eToc TTXdTUJv TroXXd f.iev iv tuj TTepi lo
vjiuxric Trepi ttic d6avaciac auTfic eipriKev, ouk oXiYa
E be iv TTj TToXiTeia Kai tuj Mevujvi Kai tuj ropYia Kai
CTTOpdbriv ev toTc dXXoic biaXoYOic. dXXd Td iuev ev
TUJ TTepi Miuxfic biaXoYtu pr|6evTa kot' ibiav utto-
)uivri|uaTicd)aev6c coi TTape'Hojuai, dbc ePouXri6ric' Td is
be TTpoc t6 TTapov Kaipia Kai XP^ICIM" Xex6dvTa
t6v 'A6rivaTov, ^TaTpov be Kai |aa6r|Triv fopYiou toO
priTopoc. cprici Ydp 6 rrapd tuj TTXdTUJVi CujKpdTric,
'ctKoue bri, qpaci, ludXa KaXoO Xoyou, 6v cu jaev fiYri-
cei, lijc eYiij oijuai, |au6ov, eYuJ be Xoyov ujc dXriefi 20
Ydp ovTa coi XeEuj a laeXXuj Xe'Yeiv. «jJCTrep Ydp
"Ojuripoc Xe'Yei, bieveiMCtVTo Tfiv dpxnv 6 Zeuc Ka'»
6 TToceibuiv Kai 6 TTXoutujv, eTreibfi rrapd toO rraTpoc
F TtapeXapov. ^v ouv v6|lioc obe Trepi dv6piuTrujv Kai
eTTi Kpdvou, Kai dei Kai vOv ^ti ecTiv ^v 6eoTc, tuiv
dv^poiTruJV t6v }xkv biKaiujc bieX66vTa tov piov Kai
ociuic, eTteibdv TeXeuTJici^, eic juaKdpujv vfjcouc dmovTa
1,366— 367 H. 6, 458-459 R
3. Bergk. fr. 107 (95) 5. Ziubv b' «ti vit. Eom. c.
28: l&v bk 6. ^CTi |a6vov ibiclem: |u6vov ^ct{ 10.
irepi Reiskius: Ttepl Te 18. TTXdTuuvi] Gorg. p. 523 C
19. 9aci Plato: qpricl
AD APOLLONIUM 277
oiKeTv iv TTdci;) eubaijLiovia eKtoc KaKujv, tov hk. dbi- 121 Kujc Kai dSeuuc eic t6 ttic biKric tc Kai Ticeiuc becjLiai- Tripiov, 6 brj TdpTapov KaXoOciv, ievai. toutujv be oi biKttCTai im Kpovou Kai eTi veujcTi toO Aioc ttiv
5 dpxnv ^xovTOc CujvTec fjcav ^uuvtujv, dKeivr] Trj fijnepq biKdCovTec rj laeWoiev TeXeuTav. erreiTa ai biKai TrOuc ou KaKuJc eKpivovTo; 6 tc ouv TTXoutujv Kai oi em- laeXriTai oi ck jaaKdpujv vricujv iovTec eXetov Ttpoc tov Aia oTi qpoiTtuev cqpiciv dvGpujTTOi iKaTepujce dvdHioi.
10 eiTTev ouv 6 Zeuc 'dW dfuj' eqpri 'Traucuj toOto fi- Tv6|uevov. vOv fi^v xdp KaKUJC ai biKai biKdil^ovTai. d)LiTrex6)Lievoi Tdp ' eqpri *oi Kpiv6)uevoi KpivovTar Ziujv- B T€c fdp KpivovTai. TToXXoi ouv icujc' fj b' 6c 'tto- vripdc vpuxdc 1'xovTec r^iuqpieciuevoi eici cu))LtaTd tc KaXd
15 Ktti Tcvri Kai ttXoutouc, Kai eTreibdv f) Kpicic ^, ep- XOVTai auToTc rroXXoi )aapTupricovTec ujc biKaiuJC Pe- PiuuKaciv. oi ouv biKacTai utt6 Te toutujv eKTrXriTTOv- Tai, Kai d)Lia Kai auTOi d)LiTTex6)Lievoi biKdCouci, Trpo Tfic vpuxfic Tfjc eauTujv oqpGaXjuouc Te Kai ihra mi oXov To cuJ)Lia TTpOKeKaXujLijLievoi. TaOTa hx] auToTc irdvTa eTtiTTpocGev YiTVCTai , Kai Td auTUJV d)uqpiec|uaTa Kai Td Tujv Kpivo)ae'vujv. TrpujTOV ixkv ovv TraucTCOv ecTi TTpoeib6Tac auTOuc tov 0dvaTov vOv Tdp upot- C caci. toOto laev ouv Kai bf] eipr]Tai tiu TTpo)uri9eT, OTTUJC av TTaucri auT6. eTreiTa tu)uvouc KpiTe'ov dTrdv- Tujv TOUTUJV TeGveOuTac Tdp beT KpivecGai. Kai tov KpiTfjV beT Tu)uv6v eivai, TeGveujTa, auTfj Tfj ipuxfi
;.>37-368H. 6, 459-4618.
6. TruJc oO KaKU)C*: ttujc ou Ka\u)c 13, ttoXXoI Plato :
TToXXol M^v 17. ^KirXriTTOVTai koI idem: ^KTiXriTTovTai
21. dTTiTTpocGev idem: ^7Tmp6cericic outujv idem: ^auTUJv 23. vOv idem: vOv jn^v
278 CONSOLATIO
auTfiv xfiv vpuxnv BeujpoGvTa ^Haiqpvnc dTxoBavovTOC dKdcTou, epriMov dTrdvTUJV tiuv cufTevOuv, Kai KOTaXi- TTovTa im Tfic y^c TtdvTa eKeivov tov Kocf^ov, 'iva biKaia fi Kpicic ^. eYib oijv TaOTa dtvujKiuc irpo- Tepoc f| ujueic erroiricdiaTiv biKacTdc uieTc eiaauToO, buo 5 |Liev ^K Tfic 'Aciac, Mivuu tc Kai 'Pabd/iaveuv, eva be
D ^K Tfjc Gupumric, AiaKOv. outoi oijv iTTCibdv TeXeu- Tf|cujci, biKdcouciv iv TLu \ei)LiuJvi, dv Tfi Tpiobuj ^S f|C qpepeTov TU) 6biju, x] |Liev eic jaaKdpuuv vf|couc, fi b' eic TdpTapov. Kal touc ^iev ^k ttic 'Aciac 'Pabd- lo |aav9uc KpiveT, touc b' ck Tfjc GupiuTrr|c AiaKOC" Mivui be rrpecpeTa biucuu embiaKpiveiv edv dTTopfiTOv ti tuu ^Tepu), iva ujc biKaiOTdTti Kpicic fj Tiepi tj^c TTopeiac ToTc dvOpuuTTOic' toOt' lcTiv, (Ju KaXXiKXeic, d i-^uj dKr]KOUJc TTicTeuu) dXriBfj eivar Kai ^k toutuuv tujv 15 XoYuuv Toiovbe ti XoyiZiojuai cu)iPaiveiv, oti 6 GdvaTOc TUYXdvei ujv, luc d/aoi boKeT, oubev dXXo f) buoTv
E TTpaTiadTOiv bidXucic, Tfjc ipuxfic Kai toO cuujuaTOc dTT' dXXiiXoiv.'
37. TaOTd coi cuvaTaTuuv, *AttoXXuuvi€ cpiXTaTe, 20 xai cuvGeic laeTd TToXXfic CTTijaeXeiac drreipTacd)ariv tov TiapaiauBriTiKOv coi Xotov, dvaTKaiOTaTov ovTa coi TTpoc Te xfiv Tfic TTapoucric XuTTric drraXXaTriv Kai toO TrdvTUJV dviapoTdTou TrevBouc TraOXav. TTepi^x^i be Kai Tfjv rrpoc tov GeoqpiXecTaTOV uiov cou 'AttoXXujviov TTpeTTOucav Ti|af|v, TToeeivoTdTriv oijcav toTc dqpiepuu- 6eTci, Triv bid Tfic dTaefjc luviiaric Kai Tfic dbiaXeiTTTOu TTpoc Tov dei xpdvov euqprnaiac. KaXuuc ouv TTOuiceic
1, 368 -369 H. 6, 401— 46i' R
, 2. cuTTCVuiv Kcl Plato : cuTTevuJv 4. iTp6Tepoc idem : TtpdTepov 12. dTTopfiTdv ti Tib ^T^pu) idem: dit6pp)iT6v
Ti ^ TU) dT^pu) 16. TOi6v6€ idem: toi6v (sic) 22. coi
aiite X6yov deleam 25. Trpoc] elc?
AD APOLLONIUM 279
Ktti Tuj "Kofw TTeiceeic Kai tlu iuaKapiTri cou uiuj X^P^" F cd|i6Voc Kai jueTaPaXujv ck ttic dvuucpeXoOc Trepi t6 ca)|ua Kai Triv vpuxnv KaKuuceuJc Kai KaTaqpGopdc eTri Tfjv cuvr|9ri coi Kai KaTd qpuciv biaYUJTr|V. ibc ydp
5 oube cujuPiOuv fijuiv fjbeujc euupa KaTriqpeTc ovTac outc ce ouTC Tfiv juriTe'pa, outujc oube vuv |ueTd Geuiv u)V Kai TOUTOic cuvecTiiujuevoc euapecTriceiev dv Tf) toi- auTri ujuujv biaYUJYrj. dvbpoc ouv dYa6oO Kal Y£V- vaiou Kai cpiXoTCKVOu qppovrijua dvaXapdiv ceauTOV tc
10 Kai Tfiv jurjTepa toO veavicKOu Kai touc cuYY^veic Kai q)iXouc ^KXucai ttic TOiauTric KaKobaifioviac , elc YaXri- 122 voTepov lueTeXGujv piou cxn|ua Kai TrpocqpiXecTepov tuj Te uiuj cou Kai rrdciv f)|uiv toic Kribojuevoic cou KaTd To rrpocfiKOV.
1, 369 -370 H. 6, 4C2— 463R.
4. 6iaYUJYf|v Reiskius: 6iOYUJYflv ^X9eiv 12. Trpoc-
qpiXkrepov idem: iipoccpiX^CTaTov
rriEINA nAPArrEAMATA.
1. MOCXIQN. Cu bri rXauKOv x^ec, ^ ZeuHmTTe,
Tov laipov d7T€Tpe'v|Jiu cujucpiXocoqpeiv u|aiv pouX6)aevov.
ZeYEinTTOC. Out' dTreTpevpdiJTiv , u) qpiXe Mo-
cxiuJV, out' ipouXeTO cujnqpiXococpeiv ^Ketvoc, dXX'
C ecpuYOV Kai eq)oPri9riv XaPnv qpiXoiuaxoOvTi rrapacxevv. 5 ev laev Tdp laTpiKiii Ka9' "0)uir)pov 6 dvnp 'ttoXXuuv dvTdEioic dXXuuv', ouK eu)aevr|C be TTpoc qpiXocoq^iav , dXX' dei ti Tpaxu Kai bucKoXov i\iuv ev toTc Xoyoic. Kai vOv IvavTioc eqp' fiiaac exwpei, pou)V eTi 7Tp6cuj9ev ou iniKpov oub' lo enieiKec epTov fmTv cutxuciv opoiv TeToX)Lific9ai, bia- X€x9eTci TTCpi biaiTrjC UTieivnc. 'x^PiC Tdp ^qpn Td qpiXoc6qpujv Kai laTpujv ujCKep tivuiv 'Mucujv Kai ct>puTU)V 6pic)aaTa', Kai Tiva tuiv ou )LieTd CTTOubfic, ou ixf]V dxpflcTUJC €!pri)aevujv TTap' fifiOuv bid CT6|uaT0C i5
D exujv ^CTTdpaTTev.
MOCXIQN. 'AXXd Kai toutujv Itujtc Kai tujv dXXujv, uj ZeuEiTTTTC, TTp69u)ioc dKpoaTfic fjbeujc dv
T€VOi)HTlV.
1, 371H. 6, 464— 465 R.
2. <)|Liiv Meziriacus: i^iaTv 6. "0)iripov] A 515
12. xi"Pic] Nauck. p. 725
DE TUENDA SANITATE PRAECEPTA 281
Z6YHITTTT0C. OiXococpoc Tap €? ttjv (puciv, tu
Mocxiuuv, Kai Tiij |afi cpiXmTpoGvTi xttXeTtaiveic cpiXo-
coqpuj, Kai dTavaKTeic ei luaXXov auTov oieTai rrpocri-
Keiv Tew|LieTpiac Kai biaXeKTiKnc Kai iiiouciKfic opacGai
5 |Lt€TaTTOiou)Lievov ri ZlriTeTv Kai iuavGdveiv PouXojuevov
*6tti Toi ev jaeTdpoici KaKOV t' dTa06v tc t^-
TUKTai '
Tuj ciuiaaTi. KaiTOi rrXeiouc dv Tboic eKei GeaTdc, ottou GeujpiKOV Ti ve'|ueTai toic cuvioOciv, uJCTrep 'AOrjvricr E
10 tul)V eXeuGepiujv be Texvuiv iaTpiKf) t6 fiev TXaq)up6v Ka\ TrepiTTov Kai eTTiTepTrec oubeiuiac evbeecTepov exei, 6eujpiK6v be )aeTa toic qpiXoiaaOoOci Tfjv cujTripiav Kai Triv uTieiav eTTibibujciv. ujct' ou Trapdpaciv opujv eTTiKaXeiv bei toTc Trepi uTieivuuv biaXeToiaevoic qjiXo-
15 cocpoic, dXX' ei \xr] TTavTdTTaciv dveXovTec touc opouc oiovTai beTv ujcTTep ev |aia x^P^ koivujc eiaqpiXoKaXeTv, d|aa t6 fibu tuj Xotuj Kai t6 dvaTKaTov biuuKOVTec.
MOCXIQN. *AXXd fXaOKOv juev euj|aev, uj Zeu- HiTTTTe, uTr6 ceiavoTriToc auTOTeXfi pouXdiaevov eivai P
20 Kai dTTpocbed qjiXocoqpiac, cu be touc Xotouc fi|aTv bieXGe TTdvTac ei be PouXei, TrpuJTOuc eKeivouc uJv eqprjc ou TTdvu |aeTd CTTOubfjc eiprnaevujv eTTiXajupdve- cGai t6v rXaOKOV.
2. Z6YZITTTT0C. "Cqpri Toivuv 6 eTaTpoc fiiaujv
. dKOucai Tivoc XeTOVTOC ujc t6 Tdc x£ip«c dei Gepiadc exeiv Kai lafi Trepiopdv ipuxoiaevac ou |aiKp6v eir) TTp6c 123 uTieiav, Kai TOuvavTiov f) tuuv dKpujv TTepiqjuEic eic Td ^eca cuveXauvouca t6 6ep|a6v ujCTTep Tivd cuvfj- Oeiav f| laeXeTriv eiuTTOiei TTupeToO* t6 b' eHuj CTpe-
1 , 37 1— 373 H. 6, 465—467 R.
6. Homer. b 392 15. xoOc 6pouc oiovxai 6eiv Reis-
kius: oiovrai beiv touc opouc
282 DE TUENUA
qpovTa |i£Td thc GepMOTtiTOc ^Xk€iv dm TrdvTa Kai biav€|i€iv Tfjv v\r]\i uYieivov. dv |i£v oOv ^vepYoOv- T^c Ti TttTc x^pc» Ktti xpiJ^MCVOi TUYXotvuJMev , auTtiv Tfjv Kivnciv dTTdTeiv ^vTttOGa Kai cuvexeiv t6 6ep)i6v tp-fuuv bk TOiouTUJV cxoXfiv dfovTac fiKiCTa beiv Trpoc- 5 bexecSai toic dKpoic t6 ^juxpov.
3. "€v )Li^v ouv toOto tuiv YcXacG^vTUJV r\v beu- Tepov b' oI|Liai t6 Trepi Tdc Tpoqpdc dc TipocqpepeTe
B ToTc Kd|ivouciv. dTTTecGai fdp auTuiv bid xpovou TTaprivei Kai YcOecGai, cuveGl^ovTac auTOuc ^v tuj lo uTiaiveiv Kai |ifi TpeiiOVTac ujCTTep Td Traibdpia, ^r\bk MicoOvTac ^Keivriv Tf]v biaiTav, dXXd Troioujn^vouc dTp^lia xctpofi6r| TaTc dpeSeci Kai cuvTpoqpov, 6ttuuc ^v TuJ voceTv )Lifi bucxepaiviju)iev ibc (pdp)iaKa Td ci- Tia, }Ar\b' dcxdXXuu/iev drrXoOv ti Kai dvoijjov Kal is fiKVicov Xa)ipdvovTec. 6e€v oub' dXouTOuc rroTe qpeu- KT€OV dX6€Tv dTTi Tpoqpfjv, oub' ubiup TTieTv oivou Tta- pdvTOC, ovbi e€p)i6v iv eepei, x»6voc TTapaK€i)i^vnc,l
C Tdc )i^v ^TTibeiKTiKdc Kai coqpicTiKdc xaipeiv duiVTac dnocxdceic tujv toioutujv Kai )i€TaXauxiac dTri TaTc dTTocx^ceciv, auTOuc bk kqO' dauTOuc ciujtt^ thv t€ fipeHiv d)ia toO cu)iqp^povTOc uTrf|Koov ^eiZovTOc elvai )i€T' euKoXiac, Kai Tfic njuxnc dqpaipoOvToc TTdppujOev Iti Tfiv TTcpi TaOTa )iiKpoXoTiav ^v raic vdcoic Ka\ t6 dTTiepriveTv, dvobupo)ievric ujc il fibovOuv )i€TdXujv » Kai dTaTTTiTujv eic dTevvfj Kai TaTreivfiv dTTeXnXaTai biaiTav. eO Yap €lpri)J^vov t6 '^XoO piov Tdv fipi- CTov, fibuv b' auT6v fi cuvf|6€ia TToincer Ka\ KOTd )i^poc ujc ^'KacTa TTeipuj)ievuj xpnc>)Li6v dcTi, ^dXicTa b^ Tuuv Tr€p\ id cuu)ia biaiTTi)idTUJV ^v toTc OTieivoTd- »
873—374 H. 6, 467 - 469 B
2. oOv Meziriacus 29. (bc] etc W
I
SANITATE PRAECEPTA 283
TOic ^TTdTOVTa Tf]v cuvr|6eiav eu|Lievn Ka\ Yvujpi|iia Trj (pvjcei Ktti oiKeia TrapacKeudZieiv, |Lie|uivri)iievov d nd- cxouciv evioi Kai ttoiouciv ev TaTc dppiucTiaic, \OL\e- D TTaivovTec koi bucavacxeToOvTCC libaToc 9ep|uo0 irpoc-
5 qpepo)Lie'vou Kai pocprijuaTOC f) dpTOu, jLiiapd iuev TauTa Kal dribfi jumpouc be Kai xaKeTxoxjc touc dvaYKdZ^ov- Tac drroKaXouvTec. ttoXXouc be Kai XouTpov dmJuXe- cev, oubev ev dpxri ^^fo. KaKov exovTac dXX' f\ t6 |Lifi buvacGai lurjb' uTTOiueveiv Ye^cac6ai Tpocpnc dXouTOUC.
10 iLv Kai TiTOc fjv 6 auTOKpdTuup , d)C qpaciv oi vocri- XeucavTec.
4. "Gti TOivuv ^XexOri toioOtov, ujc dei jaev uYiei- voTepa ciu)uaTi Td euTeXe'cTepa, ludXiCTa be qpuXaKTeov TTXr|C)uovdc Kal )ue9ac Kai fibuTTa6eiac lopTfjv Tiva )ue'X- E
15 Xoucav r\ q)iX(juv uTToboxnv ^v X^pciv exovTac rj TTpoc- boKiiJvTac ^CTiaciv paciXiKf|V Kai fiYejuoviKfiv Kai cu)i- TTepiqpopdv dTrapaiTriTOv , olov eTTiovTOC dve'jiou Kai KUjuaToc eucTaXk t6 cu»)ua Kal Kouqpov ^v eubia Tra- pacKeud2ovTac. epYov Ydp ^ctiv iv cuvouciaic Kai
20 qpiXocppocuvaic auT6v eTTi tuiv )ueTpiuiv Kai tuuv cuvf|- 6ujv qpuXdHai )ufi TTaci ^€Td dribiac beivnc eTrax6fi qpavevTa Kai qpopTiKOV. iv* ouv )ufi ttOp ini TiOp, ujc F qpaci, TrXric)uovf| tic ctti TTXriCjuovri Kai dKpaTOC ctt' dKpdTLu Y£vriTai, to Traix6ev dcTeiujc utt6 OiXiTTTTOu
25 )ueTd cTroubnc ^ii)UTiTeov * fjv be toioutov. dvOpujTTOC auT6v eTTi x^P«c uic cuv oXiYoic ovTa beiTTvficai TTapeKdXecev, eT9' 6pujv noXXouc dYOVTa TrapecKeua- cjuevujv ou TToXXOuv iTapdTTeTo. cuvaic96|uevoc ouv 6 OiXiTTTTOC uTTeTTefiTre Tuiv qpiXuJV ^KdcTtxi KcXeuuJV rrXa-
30 KouvTi KaTaXmeiv x^^^pav, o'i be TTei96juevoi Kai Trpoc- 124 boKujvTec eqpeibovTO tujv TTapaKei)ue'vujv. fjpKecev ouv
1,374— 375 H. 6, 40.0— 471E.
284 DE TUENDA
ctTTaci t6 beiTTVov. outuj bf) TrpoTrapacKeuacTeov au- Touc icTi TLuv dvaYKaiujv cuiuTTepiqpopujv, Kai SipLU Kai TT^|Li)aaTi Kai \r\ Aia }JieQri x^pav qpuXdTTOVTac ^v tuj coujLtaTi, Kai TrpocqpaTOv eTTi TaOTO Kai PouXo(ae'vriv Tfiv opeEiv ciYOVTac. 5
5. "Av hk TOiaOTai Tivec ficpvuj PapeTc ovTac f))uac Ktti biaKei)ae'vouc qpauXujc dvdTKai KaTaXd^ujciv fiYe- )i6vujv TTapdvTUJV f| Hevujv iTTiqpavevTUJV uir' alboOc PabiZeiv eic TauTO toTc iKavuic exouci cu)iTTiveiv, dv- B TttOGa iLidXiCTa beT TrapaTeTdxOai Trpoc 'Tfiv )aeTa ci- 10 vojLievriv dvbpac aibuu ' Kai bucujTriav, Td toO TpatiKoO KpeovTOC XefovTac
'KpeTccov be )ioi vOv Trpdc c' dTrexBecGai, Heve, f\ )aaX0aKic0e'v9 ' ucTepov [xvfa cTeveiv'.
t6 Ydp dTpoiKiac qpoPr|0e'vTa boHav eic TrXeupiTiv ^ qppevTTiv liupdXXeiv ^auTov dTpoiKou tiv6c ujc dXri0u)C
iCTX KOX VOOv OUK €X0VT0C OUbe XOTOV dveu KuXlKOC
Kai KviCTic dv0pujTToic eTricTd)Lievov 6)LiiXeTv. fi t€ Tdp TTapaiTricic av t6 eTribeSiov Kai t6 dcTeTov ^\ri, oux flTTOv ecTai Kexapic^ie'vr| thc cuiuTrepiqpopac* dv Te tic C irapexujv kTiaciv uiCTrep dTeucTOu 0uciac auT6c dTr^- XTiTai, TTapd Te Tf) kuXiki Kai Tr) TpaTre'Zr) ncxa Ttpo- 0u)niac Kai qpiXoqppocuvric d)ia ti TraiCujv Kai X^twv €lc ^auTdv, fibiujv qpaveTTai toO cu)Li)ue0ucKO)U6vou koi cuvoi^JoqpaToOvToc. d)avf|c0ri bl tujv }xkv TraXaiuiv 28 'AXeHdvbpou )aeTd ttotov ttoXuv aicxuv0evTOc dvT€i-
1 , 375-376 H. 6, 471— 472 E.
4. TaOta Kal Reiskins: TaOra 9. fxowci idem
^Xouci Kal 10. T^v] Homer. Q 45. Hesiod. 0. et D. 318
13. Eurip. Med. 290 21. ctTeOcTou Ouciac*! euciav ixfey)- CTOv 22. Trapci T€] Traprj bi W
J
SANITATE PRAECEPTA 285
TreTv Mnbiuj TtapaKaXoOvTi Kai KaTapdXXovTi auGic eE dpxiic auTOv eic dKpaTOv d^' ov bieqpBdpri, tuuv be KttO' fmdc 'PriYXou toO TraYKpaTiacToO. KaXoOvTOC tdp erri t6 XouTpov djua fijue'pa Titou Kaicapoc fiKe Kai D
5 cuveXoucaTO, Kai ttiujv dTraH, ujc qpaciv, dTTOTrXriHiac KaTaXapoucric eu6uc dTTe'0av€. TaOG' fijuTv 6 FXaOKOc ^v Ye^uJTi TTpouqpepev ujc Trai&aYujYiKd • tuuv b' dXXuuv ou Ttdvu Trp69u)uoc fjv dKoueiv, oub' fjiueTc eKeivuj biriYeTc9ai. cu b' eTriCKOTrei tOuv XexOevTUJV eKacTOV.
10 6, TTpujTOV |uev 6 CujKpdTTic TTapaKeXeu6|uevoc q)uXdTTec9ai tujv PpujjidTUJV oca |ufi TreivuuvTac ec9ieiv dvaTTei9ei, Kai tuiv TTWjudTujv oca Triveiv jufl biMJuJVTac, oux dTrXujc t6 xpf]c9ai toutoic dTrriY^peucev , dXXd Xpfic9ai beojuevouc ebibacKe Kai t6 fibu KaTaTdTTOVTac E
15 auTujv eic t6 dvaYKaTov, ujCTrep oi Td 9eujpiKd ttoioOv- Tec ev TaTc Tr6Xeci CTpaTiujTiKd. t6 Ydp fibu Ttii cpucei luexpi dv ^ juepoc toO TpeqpovTOc oiK6T6v ecTi, Kai bei TreivujvTac Iti tujv dvaYKaiujv dTToXaueiv tujv fibeujv, ibia be jufi KiveTv dTe'pac opeEeic tujv koivujv dTrriX-
20 XaYjuevouc. OucTrep Ydp tuj CoiKpdTei Yujuvdciov flv ouK dribec f) dpxncic, outujc iIjtivi t6 TT^jujua Kai t6 TpdYriMCi beTTTVov ^ti Kai citiov, fiTTOv pXdTTTe- Tar t6 b' dTre'xovTa t^ qpucei t6 jueTpiov Kai Tre- TiXripujjuevov eTTibpdTTec9ai tujv toioutujv qpuXaKT^ov
25 iy ToTc judXiCTa. qpuXaKTeov be Tfjc Trepi TaOTa qpiXri- F boviac Kai YctCTpijuapYiac oubev ^ttov dTreipOKaXiav Kai qpiXoTi^iav Kal Ydp aijTai TroXXdKic cuvavarrei- 9ouci |uf| TTeivuJvTac Ic9ieiv evia Kai Triveiv jufi bi-
1, 376—377 H. 6, 472- iUB.
10. TTpuuTov W: TTpujToc 18. diroXaOeiv Reiskius:
dTToXaOeiv f\ 20. tuj*: ai}T(\) CujKpdTei] Xenoph.
Conv. II 17
286 DE TUENDA
, vpujVTac, ctveXeuGepouc KO|aibfi Kai qpopTiKdc uTTOpdX- Xoucai (pavTaciac, iwc aTOTrov ecTi TrpdY)LiaToc CTraviou Kai TToXuTeXoOc |Lifi dTToXaOcai TrapovToc, oiov ou9a- Toc f| fiUKriTouv 'iTttXiKUJV f| CajLiiou TrXaKoOvTOC i^ Xiovoc ev AifuTTTiu. TaOTa xdp briTTOu TtpodYeTai 5 TToXXdKic xpilcOai toTc TiepiPoriToic Kai CTravioic, uic- Ttep UTTO Kvicric thc Kevfic boEric dYOjue'vouc Kai t6 125 c(u[xa KOivuJveTv iuribev beojuevov dvaYKd^ovTac, ottujc exujciv ^Tepoic biTiYeTc9ai, ZriXouiuevoi Tfic dTToXauceujc Tujv ouTU) bucTTopiCTUJV Kai uepiTTuiv. 6|ioia b^ Kai 10 TTpoc YuvaiKac evboHouc Trdcxouciv. ibiaic |aev Ydp ecTiv oTe Kai KaXaTc Kai dYaTTiOcaic cuvavaTTau6|uevoi Triv ficuxiav dYOuci, Opuvr) tc TeXecavTec dpYupiov r\ Adibi Kai t6 cujjaa cpauXujc Kai TTp6c cuvouciav dpYUJC ^'xovTec biaKeijLievov eYeipouciv djua Kai TTopa- 15 KaXouci t6 dKoXacTov eTTi Tfjv f]bovf]v u7t6 Tfjc Kevfjc boErjc. auTf) yoOv ^Xe^ev f\ 0puvr| TTpecPuTe'pa yc-
B Y€VTi|ue'vn TfjV ipuYa TTXeiovoc TtujXeTv bid Tfjv boEav. 7. "€cTi be jue'Ya Kai 9au|aacT6v, dv ocov f) <pucic beojievri be'xeTai tujv fibovOuv Trpocieiuevoi tlu cujjaaTi, 20 ^dXXov b' dv Td TToXXd Trapd Tdc TTpdHeic auTuj bia- liiaxdiuevoi Kai dvapaXX6)ievoi Kai |li6Xic Tidvu TaTc . dvaYKaiaic xp^MciTiZovTec y\ ujc qprjciv 6 nxdTUJV Kai bdKVOVTOc Kai KaTaTeivovTOC dvbibovTec dpXapeic dTTaXXdTTUJiuev. Tdc b' dvdTraXiv eK Tfjc vjjuxnc erri 25 t6 cujjaa KaTioucac lTn9ujuiac Kai KaTaPiaZojuevac toTc eKeivric uTrripeTeTv Kai cuveHavicTac9ai Trd^eciv oube-
C jLiia jurixavfi t6 laf) cqpobpoTdTac pXdpac Kai jueYiCTac ecp' fibovaTc dc9eveci Kai djaaupaTc ^vaTroXmeTv. nKi-
1, 377—379 H. 6, 474—476 R
21. iTapd Tac irpdSeic] ttpbc xdc 6p^S6ic Reiskius 23. liJc qpnciv 6 TTXdTUJv] Suspecta Wyttenbachio
SANITATE PRAECEPTA 287
CTtt be MJ^Xflc eTTiGuiaioi cujjua Tipoc f]bovac KiVTixeov fi fap apxn TTapd cpuciv YiTveiai. Kai Ka9dTt€p ai Tujv laacxaXuJV vpn^cxqpriceic ouk ibiov oube Trpaov oub' iXeujv fiXwTa Trj vpuxri TTape'xouciv dXX' eoiKOTa
5 cTtacjuuj Kai xa^^^ov, outuj TrdXiv ocac t6 coijLia vut- Toiuevov UTTO Tnc M^uxnc fibovdc icxei Kai TapaTTOiae- voV; €KCTaTiKai Kai TapaKTiKai auTai Kai dXXoTpiai Tfic cpuceujc eiciv. oTav ouv ti tujv crraviujv dTro- XauciadTUJV f; evboSujv TrapaTevriTai , Taic dTTOCxececi D
10 lidXXov qpiXoTiiai-iTeov f| TaTc dTToXauceci, |ae|avri|Lievouc OTi KttGdTrep 6 Ci|aujvibric eXexe |LiT]beTroTe auTUJ laeTa- lueXficai ciYricavTi, q)9eTHa|uevuj bi rroXXdKic, outujc f]juTv ouTe oipov Ttapujcaiaevoic |ueTe|LieXricev ouTe ubujp dvTi OaXepivou ttioOciv. dXXd TouvavTiov ou |u6vov
15 ou TTpocpiacTeov icii Tfiv qpuciv , dXXd Kdv beojuevr) rrpocqpepriTai ti tujv toioutujv, ctti Td XiTd Kal cuvf|Gri TToXXdKic dTTOTpenTe'ov e6ouc eveKa xai |LieXe'Tric Tfiv upe£iv.
'eirrep Ydp dbiKeTv xPH'
20 (priciv 6 GriPaToc ouk opGOuc Xe'YUJV, E
'Tupavviboc TTe'pi
KdXXlCTOV dblK€Tv''
fllLteTc be peXTiov ujc, emep cpiXoboHeTv TTp6c Td toi- auTa, €TKpaT€ia KdXXicTOV uTTep uTitiac. ou iufiv
25 dXXd Kai luiKpoXoTia Kai TXicxpOTric eviouc dvaTKd^ei TTieZovTac oikoi Tdc eTTi9u|aiac Kai KaTicxvaivovTac e|UTTiTTXac9ai Trap' ^Tepoic tujv TToXuTeXuJv Kai dTTO- Xaueiv, Ka^drrep Ik TToXeiaiac dqjeibujc emciTiZioiae- vouc* eua KaKuJc biaT€9evTec dTriaciv, eic Tfiv uctc-
30 paiav eq^obiov ttic drrXriCTiac Tfjv dTTeqjiav exovTec.
; -380 H. 6,476-478B.
19. Eurip. Phoen. 527 24. tfKpaxeia. W: ifKpdxeia
288 DE TUENDA
r 6 |iev oijv Kpdiric bict ipucpfiv Kai TToXuTeXemv oio- jLievoc oux TiKicia tdc cxdceic Kai idc Tupavvibac eMcpuecGai Taic tT^Xeci, iueTd Ttaibidc rraprivei ')Liri TTpo qpaKTic XoTtdb' auEoiv eic CTdciv d|U|ue pdXric'* 5
auTOC be Tic eauTUj TrapaKeXeuecGai |ifi Trpo cpaKtic Xorrdb' auHujv |nr|be TrdvTuuc uTrepPaivujv Tnv Kapba- ILiiba Kai Triv eXdav eTTi t6 9piov Kai tov ix^uv elc CTdciv ^K TTXriC|uovf]c t6 cuj)iia Kai Tapaxdc ejupdXXeiv
26 Kai biappoiac. Td Ydp euTeXfi KpaTei Tfjv opeSiv ^tti 10 TU)V 9uciKU)V jueTpujv, ovpoTToioiv bk Te'xvai Ktti bri- luioupTuiv Kai
*Td TTavoOpta TaOT' oipdpia xuTroTpijLi)uaTa' KaTd Tov kuj)liik6v dei touc opouc Tfjc fibovfic jueTa- Ti0riciv eic TOujUTTpocGev Kai irapaXXdTTei t6 cuficpe- 15 pov, ouK oib' ovTiva TpoTTov fijuujv Tdc TVJvaiKac ocai qpiXTpa /arixavujVTai Kai YoriTeiac im touc dv- bpac pbeXuTTOjuevujv Kai bucxepaivdvTUJV, )uic9ujtoic be Kai bouXoic TTpoie|ue'vujv Td ciTia Kai Td oipa ^o- vovou juaYTaveueiv Kai qpap)udTTeiv. ei Toivuv Kal 20 TtiKpoTepov (paveiTai t6 toO 'ApKeciXdou TTp6c touc )uoixiKOuc Kai dKoXdcTouc eiprijuevov, '|ur|bev biacpe- peiv 6TTic9ev Tiva f| ^jurrpoc^ev eivai Kivaibov', ouk
B dvdpjuocTov icTX toic uTTOKei)ue'voic. Ti Tdp lijc dXrj- 0UJC bia(pe'pei caTupia TTpocdTOVTa KiveTv Kai Trap- 25 oEuveiv t6 dKoXacTOv eTTi Tdc fibovdc, f\ Triv TcOctv 6c|uaTc Kal KapuKeiaic epe0iZ!eiv Kai ujcTrep Td ipujpiuivTa Kvric)uujv dei beTc9ai Kai TapTaXicjUuJv ;
1, 880-381H. 6,478— 470Ri
4. Bergk. p. 670' 5. elc Athenaeus IV. p. 158 B: dei 7. XoTcdb' auEujv*: \0Tx6.ba auSujv aiei 14:. KiujaiKOv]
Meinek. IV. p. 670 16. oOk 0T6' W: oOk oT6a 6e
SANITATE PRAECEPTA 289
8. "AXXoTC |Liev oijv Trpoc xac fibovdc XeKieov icuuc, TO KttXov Kai cejuvov ecp' ^auToO Tfic etKpaTeiac oiov ecTi beiKvOovTac" 6 be vOv Xoxoc uTiep ttoXXujv fibovujv Ktti lueTdXujv ecTiv. ouTe Tdp TrpdHeic out€
5 eXTTibac ouTe dTTobrmiac ouTe biaTWTdc ai vocoi to- cauTac ocac f]bovdc fi)Liiuv d(paipouvTai Kai bia(p9ei- pouciv. 69ev fiKiCTa XuciTeXei KaTaqppoveiv ttic uti- C eiac TOic iudXiCTa thv fibovf]V biujKOuci. Kai Tdp cpi- Xocoqpeiv dppuiCTiai ttoXXoic Trapexouci Kai CTpaTriTeiv
10 vfi Aia Kai paciXeueiv, f]bovai be cuJiaaTiKai Kai dTTo- Xauceic eviai laev oub' oXujc Teveciv ev voctu Xaiapd- vouciv, ai be Xajupdvoucai Ppa^u t6 okeiov Kai ou Ka9ap6v dXXd cujaTTeqpup^evov ttoXX^j tuj dXXoTpiiw Kai (ie|iUjXujTTiC|ievov ujCTTep ck ZdXrjc Kai x€iM"JVoc
15 dvaqpepouciv. ou t«P ' ev TTXric)iOvaic KuTTpic ', dXXd ).;dXXov ev eubia capK6c Kai TctXfivr). Kai KuTrpic eic flbovfiv TeXeuTol Kai ppoicic Kai ttocic" f] b' uTieia TaTc fibovaic ujcTTep f) TaMvn TaTc dXKuociv dcqpaXfi D Kai KaXfiv Teveciv Kai Xoxeiav evbibujci. kojuijjujc
20 Tdp eoiKev 6 TTpobiKOC eiTreTv oti tujv fibuc|udTUJV dpicTOv ^CTi t6 ttOp* dXri9ecTepov Tdp dv tic emoi Tfjv UTieiav fjbuciaa 9ei6TaTOv eivai Kai TTpocrivecTa- Tov. Iqp9d juev Tdp Kai 6TTTd Kai TreTTTd PpOOjuaTa vocoOciv f| KpaiTTaXuiCiv f| vauTiiJuciv oubeiuiav fibovfjv
25 oube x«Piv dTTObibujci, Ka9apd be Kai dKpaiqpvfjc 6pe- Hic uTicxivovTi dJujuaTi TTfiv fjbu TToieT Kai 'dpTTaXeov', ujc "0|uripoc eqpn, Kai TTpocqpopov.
9. '€Trei b' uucTrep 6 Ari|udbr|c TToXe|uiKOuc dKaipujc Touc 'A9rivaiouc ovTac eXeTe jun^cTTOTe x^ipoToveTv E
1, 381-382 H. 6, 479-481 E
15. ^v TTXnc|novatc] Nauck. p. 506 27. "OiuriPoc]
e 164
Plutarchi Moralia. Vol. I. 19
290' DE TUENDA
ciprivriv av€u iiieXdvujv i|aaTiuuv, outuj xai fmeic oObe'- TTOTe |ie|avr||ae9a Xittic biaiTric Kai cuuqppovoc aveu Kauceujv Kai KaTanXaciadTiuv • ev Te toutoic fiTVOMe- voi TTieZojuev ccpobpa Tdc djuapTiac, dvTepeibofievoi t^ lxvr]yLri m\ KaGdirep oi noXXoi vOv |iiev depac vuv 5 be xiJ^pac lKi|ae|uq)d|aevoi vocuObeic, eHaipou|uevoi Tfic aiTiac Tfjv dKpaciav Kai qpiXriboviav. dXX' ujcTrep 6 Aucijaaxoc ev PeTaic cucxe9eic bivprj Kai napabouc ^auTov )uieTd toO cTpaTeujuaToc aixiadXouTOV eiTa muuv
F ubujp qjuxpdv 'ixj 9eoi' eiTTev, 'ujc ppaxeiac fibovnc 10 ev€Ka iueTdXriv eubaijioviav dnepaXojLiriv', outujc dvoi- CTe'ov ^v Tatc dppuiCTiaic Trpoc auTOuc ujc bid UJuxpo- TTociav r\ XouTpov dKaipov f| cujtiTrepiqpopdv iroXXdc juev auTuuv bieq)9eipa|aev fibovdc, KaXdc be npdHeic dTTiTeprreTc t€ biaTUJYdc dTTuuXecajaev. 6 Tdp ^k tuuv 15 TOiouTUJv dvaXoTicjauuv briTJuoc aijudccei Tfiv jLivrjiunv, ujCTe oiov ouXfiv Trapajaevoucav ev tijj UYiaiveiv eu-
127 XapecTe'pouc TTOieiv TTepi Triv biaiTav. oube Tdp $v t6 uTiaTvov cuiMa qpuceie MeTdXac lTTi9u|uiac oube buc- TT€i9eTc oOb' dcuvr|9eic oObe buccKPidcTOuc, dXXd 20 beT 9appeTv TTpoc Tdc opeHeic ^Kqpepoiue^vac Kai IrrmrT buucac TaTc dTToXauceciv , ujc eXaqppov Kai TTaibiKov exoucac t6 |Lie|avpi|aoipoOv Kai KXau9jiupi26|Lievov , eiTa TTauo^evac dp9eicr|c thc TpaTTeZ^nc Kai jarib^v ^TKaXou- cac larib' dbiKOU|uevac, dXXd ToOvavTiov Ka9apdc Kai 25 iXapdc Kai oO papeiac oObe vauTiuubeic TTepijuevoucac
1, 382-383 H. 6, 481-482 R.
4. dvT£p€i66|uevoi*: ^vaTrepei66|uevoi 6. vocu)6eic*:
vociiibeic dlTrobriiaiac (lTri6riiaiac Xylander) ri. xivac \i- Youci 9. ToO* 14. feieqpGeipaiuev Eeiskius: ftiaqpGei-
po|uev bi W: t€ 18. dv*: &fav 19. (pOceie*:
90c€i
d
SANITATE PRAECEPTA 291
Tfiv aupiov. ujcrrep djneXei Kai Ti)u66e6v cpaciv emeiv B Tr| rrpoTepaia bebeirrvriKOTa ev dKabriM£i« trapd TTXd- Tiuvi laouciKov Kai Xitov bemvov, iajc oi Trapd TTXd- Tujvi bemvricavTec Kai eic aupiov fibeuuc YifvovTai. 5 XeTeTai be m\ 'AXeHavbpoc eiTreTv toOc Tfjc "Abac ovpoiToioiic dTTOireMMJdjuevoc ibc exei peXTiovac dei cuv auTuj, npoc fiev t6 dpicTov Triv vuKTOTiopiav, TTpoc be t6 bemvov ttiv 6XifapicTiav.
10. OUK dTVOai b' OTI Kttl bid kottouc TTUpeTTOU-
10 civ dvGpuiTTOi Kai bi' If^auceic Kai bid TTepinJuHeic. dXX' ujcTTep ai tOuv dv9e'ujv 6c)iiai Ka9' lauTdc dc9€- veTc eici, mx^eTcai be tuj eXaioi puu)ariv icxouci Kai Tovov, ouTUJ TaTc €Suj9€v aiTiaic Kai dpxaTc oTov ou- ciav Kai cujjaa TTapexei t6 TTXfj^oc uTTOKei)Lievov. dv€u C
15 be TOUTOu xci^€tt6v oubev , dXX' eHafjaupoOvTai Kai biaxe'ovTai pabiujc, aVjuaToc XctttoO Kai TTveujaaToc Ka9apo0 bexo)aevou Tfjv Kivriciv ev be TTXfi9ei Kai TTepiTTuujuaTi oTov iXuc dvaTapaTTOjuevri iniapd TTOieT TrdvTa Kai bucxepfi Kai bucaTTdXXaKTa. bi6 beT )af|
20 Ka9dTTep oT dta^oi vauKXripoi TToXXd bi' dTTXricTiav e|LipaX6|U€voi, TOuvTe09ev fjbri biaTeXoOciv dvTXoOvTcc Kai uTreHaipoOvTec Tfjv 6dXaTTav, outujc e)LiTTXficavTac t6 cu)|aa Kai papuvavTac uTT0Ka9a{peiv au6ic Kai utto- KXuZeiv, dXXd biaTripeTv eucTaXec, ottujc, kSv TTiec6ri D
25TroTe, qpeXXoO biKTiv utt6 KOucp^Tr^TOc dva(pe'priTai.
11. MdXicTa bk Trpo9uXaKTe'ov ev TaTc Trporra- 9eiaic Kai TTpoaic9f|ceciv. ou tdp dTracai KaTd t6v
1 , 383—384 H. 6, 482—484 B.
1. cpaciv* 6. peXTiovac Stobaeus Flor. CI8: PeXTiovac fiT€>v 15. toOtou Reiskius : toutujv 20. dTaGoi] ko-
Koi Emperius 22. uTieSaipoOvTec W: iiTreEaipovTec
19*
292 DE TUENDA
'Hciobov eTTicpoiTaiciv ai vocoi
'ciYri, eixei cpuuvnv ^HeiXero inriTieTa Zeuc*, 6.\y a\ nXeiCTai Ka6dTT€p irpoaTTeXouc Kai irpobpo- ILiouc Kai KHpuKac Ixo^civ dTrevi^iac Ka\ bucKivriciac. *PapuTr|Tec Kai KOTTor cpriciv 'iTTTTOKpdTric 'auToiaaTOis voOcov cppdZouci', bid TTXfjOoc iIjc loiKev ^vtoc bid- Taciv Kai cqprivuuciv toO TTepi Td veOpa TTveu)LiaTOC
E exovTOc. dXX' 6)liujc auToO inovovouxi toO cuO|iaTOC dvTiTeivovToc Kai KaTacTTujvTOC im t6 KXivibiov Kai Tfjv ficuxiav o'i ixkv utto Xai^apTiac Kai qpiXriboviac lo IjapdXXouciv ^auTouc ^tti Td paXaveia Kai CTTeubouciv im Tdc rrpoTTOceic, ujCTTep eic TToXiopKiav eTriciTiZio- ILievoi Kai bebioTec )Lif| (pGdcr) KaTaXapiijv auTOUc 6 TTupeTOC dvapicTOUc, o'i be KOjLHjJOTepoi ramri )aev oux dXicKOVTai, TTdvu b' dpeXTepujc aicxuv6)aevoi is KpamdXrjv f| dTTevpiav bjioXofexv mi birmepeueiv ^v ijnaTioic, ^Tepujv elc t6 Tujuvdciov Pabi2l6vTUJV Ka\ TrapaKaXouvTUJV dvacTdvTec cuvaTrobuovTai Kai TauTd
F rrpdTTOuci toic uTiaivouci. touc be TTXeiovac dKpa- ciac Kai luaXaKiac cuvriTopov ^xouca tfiv TTapoi)Liiav 20 dXTTic dvaTTeiGei Kai rrpodTeTai pabiZeiv iTa^LiOuc im Tf|v cuvf|9eiav, ibc oivuj br\ t6v oivov kpaiTTdXr) bk Tfjv KpaiTTdXriv ^HeXujVTac Kal biaqpopficovTac. Trp6c )iev ouv TauTriv Tfjv dXTTiba ttjv toO KdTUJVoc euXd- Peiav dvTiTaKTeov fiv qpnciv eKeivoc 6 dvfip 'Td )n^v 25 jueTdXa iniKpd TtoieTv Td be )LiiKpd TTavTeXijuc dvaipeiv', 128 Kai 6ti KpeiTTOv 1'vbeiav uTTO)Lieivai bid Kevfic Kai fjcu-
1, 384-385 H. 6, 484—486 E.
1. 'Hciobov] 0. et D. 104 5. 'iTriroKpdrric] Ai)hor. II 5
19. dtKpaciac koI inaXaKiac*: dKpacia koI laaXaKia 20.
Ti?iv Reiskius 23. ^SeXOuvTOC Kal 61090^1*1^0^x0^ W; ^Ee
X6vTac KOi bioqpoprjcavTec
i
SANITATE PRAECEPTA 293
Xiav fj biaKuPeOcai TTpoc XouTpov djcajnevouc Kai bei- TTVov. €1 }ilv Yap icii ti, pXdqiei t6 fXY] (puXdHacGai nrjb' eTTicxeiv ei 5e pir\bi\, ou pXdiyei t6 cucTaXnvai Tuj cu6|uaTi Kai Y€ve'c0ai Ka0apa}Tepov. 6 be Traiba-
5 piuubric ^Keivoc Kai toic cpiXoic bebiijuc Kai toTc oiKe- Taic qpavepoc Y€V€'c0ai biaKeijaevoc eK TrXriciuovfic f| KpaiTTdXric dribuuc, aicxuvojuevoc dTreipiav 6)aoXoTncai Tr||uepov, aupiov 6)aoXoTr|cei KttTdppoiav f| TTupeT6v f| CTpoqpov.
10 ' aicxuv6)ievoc aicxiCTa TTeviav Sv qpe'poic', TToXu b' aicxiov dTTeipiav Kai papuTriTa Kai TTXriC|LiovTiv B cuj)LiaTOc eic PaXaveTov dXKO)ite'vou Ka0dTTep eic 0dXac- cav ca0poO ttXoiou Kai iiiri cTe'Y0VT0C. uicTTep xdp d)ueXei TTXe'ovTec evioi x^iMuJvoc ovtoc aiboOvTai eTr'
15 dKTfic biaTpipeiv, eiT' dvax0evTec aTcxicTa bidKeiVTai PoujVTec Kai vauTiuJvTec, outujc Iv uTtoii/ia Kai Trpo- TTa0eia ciu^aTOc dYevvec f]YOU)Lievoi )Liiav fi)ae'pav ev KXivri bidTeiv Kai ^x] Trapa0e'c0ai TpdTTe2!av , aicxicTa TToXXdc fi)Li€'pac KeTvTai Ka0aip6)iievoi Kai KaTaTTXacco-
20 laevoi Kai 0uuTTeuovTec laTpouc Kai 0epaTT€uovT€c, oTvov aiToOvTec f| ipuxp6v ubu)p, dTOTra koi dYevvfi rroXXd TTOieTv Kai q)0e'TT€c0ai bid t6v ttovov Kai t6v qpdpov C uTTO)LievovTec. Kai lafiv touc fe bid Tdc fibovdc )Lifi KpaToOvTac dauTUJV dXX' ^TKXivovTac fl qpepo^evouc
25 i)tt6 tuuv dTTi0u)LinI)V KaXuJc ^xex bibdcKeiv Kai dvajii- luvfiCKeiv OTi ttXcTctov eK toO cuijuaTOC ai f)bovai Xa)u- pdvouci, (12) Kai Ka0dTT€p oi AdKUJvec oHoc Kai dXac bovTec Tuj laaTeipuj Td Xomd KeXeuouciv ev tuj lepeiuj ZriTeTv, outujc ev tuj cuuiaaTi toO upocqpepo)Lie'vou Td
30 KdXXicTtt TUJV f)buc|udTUJv ecTiv, ^VTTep uTiaivovTi Kai
I, 385—386 H. 6, 486—487 K.
10. Meinek. IV. p. 291 fiv Porsonus
294 DE TUENDA
KaGapu) npoccpepriTai. tXuku |uev Ydp f| TroXuTeXec eEuj Kai Ka9' auTO t6 toioOtov ecTiv, fibu be ireqpuKev iv Tuj fibo)ie'viu Kai iueTd toO fiboiuevou YiYvecOai KaTd
D qpuciv exovTOC" ev be bucapecTOic Kai KpaiTraXuJci Kai (pauXujc biaKei|aevoic TtdvTa Tfjv auTUJv xapw kolx 5 ujpav dTToXXuci. bio bel nr\ CKOTreiv tov ix^uv ei TrpoccpaTOC, latibe tov dpTOv ei Ka9ap6c, juribe t6 pa- Xaveiov ei 9ep|u6v, iuribe ttiv ^Taipav ei euiuopqpoc, dXX' dauT6v ei |ufi vauTiuubric |ur|be 9oXep6c larib' ^'uj- Xoc iuribe TeTapaYMevoc. ei be iuri , Ka^drrep eic oiKiav 10 TTev9o0cav eiuPaXovTec cttikujmoi )Lje9uovTec ou qpiXo- qppocuvrjv Trapecxov oub' fibovfjv dXXd KXau9)aouc Kai obupiLiouc iTTOiricav, outuj Kai dqppobicia Kai oipa Kai
E paXaveia Kai oivoc ^v cui/iaTi KaKuJc Kai Trapd qpuciv exovTi |LiiYVU|Li€va toTc juf) Ka^ecTouci Kai bieqp9op6ci 15 qpXeYiua Kai xoXfiv Kivei Kai TapdTTei Kai TrapeHicTn- civ, fibu b' oubev dSioXoYUJC oub' dTroXaucTiK6v oubev oiov TrpoceboKficaiaev drrobibujciv.
13. 'H juev ouv dKpipfjC cqpobpa Kai bi' ovuxoc XeYO|uevri biaiTa to Te cujiua KO)aibfi ijjoqpobeec Trape- 20 XeTa» Kai cqpaXep6v, auTfic tc Tfjc MJuxnc t6 YciOpov KoXouei TtdvTa TrpdYinaTa Kai Tidcav oux fJTTOv iv f]bovaTc n tt6voic biaTpipfjv uqpopuj)uevnc Kai Trpoc )iribev iTa)xu)C Ktti 9appaXeuJC pabiCoucnc beT b' ujc-
F Ttep iCTiov t6 cu))ia nfjTe cucTeXXeiv eubiac oucric Kal 25 TTieZeiv cqp6bpa, lufiT' dvei)A€vujc xpnc9ai Te Kai KaTa- qppoveiv ^v uTTOHJia Y€v6|uevov, dXX' dvbib6vai Kai
1, S86— 388 H. C, 487—489 B ,
2. xd toioOtov*: tuiv toioOtujv 10. ^auTov Stobaeus
Floril. CI 11: oOtov 13. Koi 66up)io0c idem 17.
irapeSicTriciv*: itpoceEicTr|Civ 21. Te Stobaeus: bk
24. f\ Madvigius: koI 6iaTpipi?iv Stobaeus: fttOTpiPi^v KOt
irpoEiv 28. Y£v6)acvov idein: Yiv6|aevov
SANITATE PRAECEPTA 295
TTOieiv ^Xaqppov ujcrrep eipriTai, Kai \ir] Trepijueveiv dTreijJiac xai biappoiac jiri^^ 9ep|uaciac laribe vdpKac, tjqp' uiv evioi )i6Xic ujcrrep utt' dTTe^uuv f| KXriTopuuv, TTupeToO Trepi 6upac ovtoc fj5r|7 6opupou|aevo» cucTeX- 129
5 Xouciv ^auTOuc, dXXd Troppujeev eSeuXa3eic6ai 'Trpo X€'iM«TOC, ujct' dvd TrovTiav dKpav pop^a TTveovToc'. dTOTTOv tdp ecTi KopdKUJV |Liev XapuTYic|ioTc Kai kXuj- cjaoic dXeKTopibuJV Kai *cuciv Irri qpopuTuj laapTai-
lovoucaic', ujc ^qpn ArmoKpiTOC, eTriineXaic Tipocexeiv, criMeia TroioujLievouc TrveujidTUJV Kai d|iippujv, Td be Tou ciJujuaTOC KivrjiuaTa Kai cdXouc Kai TTpOTraeeiac jufi TrpoXajLipdveiv junbe TrpoqpuXdTTeiv, \xr\b' exeiv cri- |ueTa x^iM^voc ev lauTiu Tevncofjevou Kai jueXXovToc.
15 6eev ou Trepi ipoqpfiv juovov oube T^Mvdcia beT qpu- XdTTCiv t6 cujjua \ir\ Trapd t6 eiuj66c dTTTr|Tai toutujv B OKvripuic Kai dTrpo6ujuujc f\ rrdXiv bii^iujbec ^ Kai Trei- vaXeov ujc ou TreqpuKCV, dXXd Kai tujv uttvoiv t6 jufi cuvexec jurjbe XeTov dXX' dvuijuaXiac exov Kai biacTta-
20 c|JOuc euXaPeTc6ai , Kai vfi Aia tujv evuTTviuiv Tfiv dTOTriav, dvrrep ujci |uf) vojuijuoi jurjbe cuvfjeeic ai qpav- Taciai, TrXfi6oc r| Tidxoc UTpOuv r| TrveujuaTOc Tapaxnv evT6c KaTTiTopoucav. fjbri be Kai Td Tfic Hiuxfic Kivfj- fjaTtt t6 cu)|ua lurjvuei TTp6c vocov iTricqpaXujc ^x^iv.
25 dXoToi Tdp icxouciv d6u|uiai Kai qpopoi TToXXdKic utt' oubev6c qpavepou, Tdc eXTTibac dqpvuj KaTacpevvuou- C cai ■ TiTvovTai be Kai TaTc 6pTaTc ^TrixoXoi Kai oHeTc Kai fuiKpoXuTTOi , Kai baKpuppooOci Kai dbTmovoOciv
1, 888—389 H. 6, 489—490 B.
3. Oqp' Salmasius: dq?' 6. Bergk. p. 1344^ 7.
Pop^a idem: Poppo 17. i)*: icTi 22. TrveOiiaToc Sto- baeus CI 11: irveuiiidTaiv
296 DE TUENDA
oiav dTMOi TTOvripoi Kai dva9u|uidceic TriKpai cuvicid- )i€vai 'xaic THC vpuxnc', ujc (priciv 6 TTXdTuuv, dva- KpaGujci 'Trepioboic'. bi6 bei CKOTreTv oTc Sv TauTa cu|LiTriTTTrj Kai )L»vri)Liov€ueiv oti ciuiLiaTiKov dcTiv aiTiov
UTTOCTOXfiC TIVOC ^ Ka0dpC€UJC b€d|Ll€VOV. 5
14. Xpr|Ci|Liov be Tidvu Kai t6 touc qpiXouc €tti- D cKeTTTO^evov dcGevoOvTac lKTTuv9dv€C0ai Tdc amac, \xr] cocpiCTiKuic |Liri&e Trepi€'pYuuc dvcTdceic Kai TTapejLi- TTTUJceic Kai KOivoTriTac XaXoOvTa Kai TTapembeiKVu- ILievov laTpiKujv 6vo|adTU)v Kai TpoMMdTUJV ^jLiTTeipfav, lo dXXd TauTi Td qpauXa Kai Koivd iLif) TTape'pYUJC dKOu- ovTa, TTXfi9oc fiXiujciv kottov dYpuTTviav, juot^iCTa be biaiTav fj xPWM^voc lTTupeH€v €T9' ujcrrep 6 TTXd- TU)v drri tOuv dXXoTpiuJV d)LiapTri)LidTUJV eiuO^ei Xe'Teiv 'ixr\ TTOu dp' itOu TOiouTOc;' ouTUJ Td TTep» auT6v ^v is ToTc TrXriciov eij Ti9ec0ai, koI (puXdTT€c9ai Kai )Livr||Lio- veueiv Sttujc oy TTepirreceTTai toTc auToTc oub' auT6c E eic Tf|v KXivriv KaTaTrecujv ujuvricei tto9ujv tt*iv ttoXu- Ti)ariTOv vfkiav, dXX' ^T€'pou TrdcxovToc ^vcrnuaveTTai TTp6c ^auT6v lijc dHiov ttoXXoO t6 uYiaiveiv Kai beT 20 toOto biaTripeTv auTuj Trpoc^xovTa Kai qpeibofievov. ou x^ipov bfe Kai Tfjv ^auTujv TTapeTriCKOTreTv biaiTav. dv Tdp Iv TTOceci Kai TTpoc(popaTc n tici ttovoic koi dTaHiaic ^T^paic TUTXdvuj)nev TeTovoTec, t6 be cuj)Lia |Lir|be)Liiav uTroMjiav TTape'xri )Liribe Trpoaic9riciv, 6)jujc 25 auTOuc bei (puXdTT€c9ai Kai TrpoKaTaXa)a(3dveiv €k juev
1 , 389-390 H. 6, 490-492 R.
2. TTXdTUJv] Tim. p. 47D 4. livrnuovcueiv*: |iivri(jo-
veueiv fiv |Liri6^v ^ itveuiuaTiKov 12. rjXiujciv Erasmris:
r^ Xeiiuciv 14. tuuv dXAoTpiuJv &|uapTri|adTUJV*: Toic d\-
XoTpioic d|aapTri|uaciv Kifnv'^: Xdteiv diniOv 15.
fip'*: fipa KOl
SANITATE PRAECEPTA 297
dtppobiciujv Ktti KOTTiuv dvTttC dvaTraucei Kai riciJXi<!tj )n£Td b' oTvuuciv Kai cujaTTepiqpopdv ubpoirocia, jLidXi- F cTa be TpoqpaTc KexpnMevouc djLippi0e'ci Kai Kpeujbeciv Ti TTOiKiXaic oXiYociTeTv Kai inribev uTToXiTTeTv TTepiTTuu-
5 )LiaTOC 7T\fi9oc Iv Tuj cuj)uaTi, Kai Ydp auTd TauTa bi' auTd TToXXujv aiTia vocujv ^cti, Kai TrpocTiGrici TaTc dXXaic akiaic uXriv Kai buvaimv. 60ev dpicTa XeXcKTai 'Tpocpfic dKopinv Kai ttovujv doKViriv Kai CTT^PlLiaTOC ouciric cuvTriprjciv uYieivoTaTa eivai'. Kai 130
10 fdp fi Tcepi Tdc cuvouciac dKpacia tlD |idXicTa Triv buvajaiv ^KXueiv •uqp' fic x] Tpocpfi biaTroveTTai , ttXcov TTepiTTUJ|ua TTOieT Kai TrXfi0oc.
15. Au0ic ouv dvaXapovTec eS dpxfjc TTepi ^KdcTou,
TTpUJTOV be TTepi TU|liVaClUJV CpiXoXoTOlC dpjiOTTOVTUJV
vj XetuJiuev oti ujcTrep 6 (prjcac inribev Tpdqpeiv TTapa0a- Xaccioic Trepi XouTpOuv (bibdSeiv Tdp Tfjv xpeiav), outuj Kai q)iXoX6TOic cpain tic dv lurib^v Tpdcpetv TTepi T^liiva- ciujv. f) Tdp Ka0' fmepav toO Xotou xpeia bid qpujvnc Trepaivo|ne'vTi 0au|nacT6v oiov ^cti T^invdciov ou |lx6vov
20 TTpoc uTieiav dXXd Kai TTpoc icxuv, ou TraXaicTiKriv oube capKOucav Kai nuKVOucav Td cktoc ujCTrep oiko- B bo|ari|iaTOC, dXXd toTc ZuuTiKUJTdTOic liepeci puj|ir|V ev- bid0eTOv Kai tovov dXri0iv6v djUTToioucav. oti |aev Tdp icxuv biboici t6 TTveu|ua br|XoOciv oi dXeTTTTat,
25 Touc d0Xr|Tdc KeXeuovTec dvTepeibeiv TaTc Tpiipeci Kai TrapeTKOTTTeiv evTeivovTac dei Td TrXacc6|ieva |Lie'pri Kai ipn^ctqpujiieva toO cuu|aaToc" fi be qpujvii, toO Trveujua-
1, 390—391 H. C, 492-494B.
11. TiXiov — tioxii Stobaeus Flor. CI 12: irXeiov — TroieiTai 16. XouTpiLv 6i6dEeiv Tctp*: 666vtujv dbibaHe
17. |aT]6ev*: |lii'i 21. Tci Reiskius: Tr)v 24. icxOv
idem: icxOeiv 26. IvTeivovToc*: TripoOvTac
298 DE TUENDA
Toc oOca Kivricic, ouk dmTTOXaiujc dXV ujcirep iv -nr]- Yaic Trepi xd cnXdYXva pa)vvu|aevn, t6 Gepjaov auHei
C Kai XeTTTuvei t6 ai)Lia, Kai TTacav nev eKKaOaipei qpXe- Pa, TTttcav b^dpTTipiav dvoiTei, cucTaciv hk koX TrnHiv UYpoTriTOC ouK ea 7TepiTTUJ|uaTiKfic ujcTTcp UTrocTd9)aTiv 5 Y£ve'c9ai toic ttiv Tpocpfiv TrapaXa)uipdvouci Kai KaTCp- Ya2o|ue'voic dYYcioic. bi6 bei ludXicTa TTOieiv ^auTOUc TOUTqj Tiu YUMvaciuj cuvr|9eic Kai cuvTpocpouc IvbeXe- Xu)C XeYOVTac, dv b' ^ tic uTTOVjjia tou coJiaaTOc ev- beecTepov fj KOTTUJb^CTepov exovToc, dvaYiYvuOcKOVTac lo Kai dvaqpuJvoOvTac. oiTep Ydp aliwpa Kp6c YUMvdciov ecTi, TouTO TTp6c bidXeEiv dvdYvujcic, ujCTrep eTr' 6x11- laaTOC dXXoTpiou Xoyou KivoOca juaXaKUJC Kai biaqp^- pouca TTpduJC TTiv qpujviiv. f) be bidXeHic dYuJva Kai cqpobpoTriTa TTpocTi9nciv, d|Lia thc n/uxnc tuj cuuiaaTi i5
D cuveTriTi9e|Lievnc. KpauYdc iuevTOi TrepiTTa9eic Kai CTra- paYMaTOubeic euXaPnTeov * ai Ydp dvujjaaXoi TrpocPoXai Ktti biaTdceic toO TrveujuaTOC ^riYMaTa Kai CTrdcjuaTa TTOiouciv. dvaYvdvTa b' f] biaXex9evTa XiTrapd Kai dXeeiv^ Tpiqjei xPlcTeov Trp6 toO TrepmdTOu Kai |ua- 20 XdHei Tfic capKoc, ujc dvucTov Icti, tujv CTrXdYXvujv TTOiou)uevov dqpfjv Kai t6 TTveOjua TTpdujc biOjuaXuvovTa Kai biaxeovTa fieXPi tujv OKpujv. lueTpov be toO ttXii- 9ouc Tfic Tpiijjeujc ecTUj t6 TTpoccpiXec t^ aic9r|cei Kai
E dXuTTOv. 6 Ydp outuj KaTacTncac thv dv pd9ei Tapa- a Xnv Kai bidTaciv toO TrveujuaToc, dXuTTUj tc xP^iTai tuj TTepiTTw)uaTi, Kttv dKaipia tic i^ Xpeici KUjXucrj Tdv TTepiTTaTOv, oubev ^cti TrpdYiua* t6 Ydp oiKeiov f) qpu- cic dTTeiXriqpev. 69ev out€ ttXoOv TToiriTeov out€ Ka-
1,391— 392 H. • 6, 494— 495 E
11. KOlW: f\ 17. TTpoPoXol Salmasius 21. dvu-
CTov Stephanus: dvoiCT6v 29. oure tiXoOv*: ovbk ttXoOv
I
SANITATE PRAECEPTA 299
TttTUJTnv ev TTavboKeiuj citfic Trpoqpaciv, oub' av Trdv- rec KaTaYeXuJciv. ottou tap oOk aicxpov t6 cpaTeiv, oube t6 TU)Livd2ec9ai br|TTOu0ev aicxpov dW aicxiov t6 beboiKevai Kai bucoiTreicGai vauTac Kai opeuuKoiuouc
5 Kai TTavboKcac KaTaTeXuuvTac ou toO c(paipi2[ovTOC Kai CKia/iaxoOvTOC dXXd toO XeTOVTOc, av ajua bibdcKr) F Ti Kai tr\Tf} Kai )iav9dvri Kai dvaiaifivriCKriTai TUMva- 26)ievoc. 6 juev Tdp CuuKpdTric eXeTev oti iqj ki- voOvTi bi' 6pxr|ceuoc auT6v eTTTdKXivoc oTkoc iKavoc
10 ecTiv eTTUMvdCec^ai , tuj be bi' dibfjc f\ Xotou T^Mva- ZJojLieviw T^iLivdciov dTTOxpuuv Kai ^tuuti Kai KaTaKei- juevuj TTdc TOTTOC TTapexei. laovov CKeivo qpuXaKTeov, OTTuuc |ir|T€ TTXriCjiOvfiv |Lir|Te XaTveiav |ar|Te kottov eauToTc cuveiboTec evTeivuujLie9a Trj ^uuvri TpaxuTepov,
15 0 TTdCXOUCl TTOXXOI TUUV pTlTOpUUV Kai TUJV coqpiCTuuv,
o'i jufev utt6 boHric Kai qpiXoTijuiiac, o'i be bid |aic9oucl31 fi TToXiTiKdc djiiXXac eEaTOjaevoi Ttapd t6 cuiuqpepov dTuuvi2Iec9ai. NiTpoc b' 6 fi|Lie'T6poc ev TaXaTicx co- qpiCTeuuuv dKav0av dTUTX«V€V ix9uoc KaTaTTeTTuuKuuc
20 eTe'pou b' eTTiqpavevTOc eHuu0ev coqpicToO Kai jaeXeTuuv- Toc, uqp€i|ue'vou bdEav TTapacxeTv oppuubuuv, ^'ti Tfic dKdv0r|c dvicxoM^vnc ^iueXeTrice* |ueTdXric be qpXeTMovfic Kai CKXripac Tcvo|uevric, t6v ttovov ou qpepujv dvebe- EaTO TO|ufiv eEuj0ev pa0eTav. f] |uev ouv dKav0a bid B
25 ToO Tpau)uaTOC lErip^0n , t6 be TpaO)ua xotXeTT6v t€v6- juevov Kai peu|uaTiK6v dveTXev auTov. dXXd TaOTa juev dv Tic uCTepov euKaipuuc uTTO|uvr|cei€.
fujuvacaiuevouc be XouTpuj xP^c9ai vpuxpuj |ucv dTTibeiKTiK6v Kai veaviK6v ludXXov f| uTieivov ecTiv.
1 , 392—393 H. 6, 495—497 R.
8. CujKpdtTic] Xenoph. Conv. II 18 10. YUMvaZoM^va)
tuMvdciov d-rroxpijuv Reiskius: YUMvdciov drrdxpn TUjuvaSoM^vuj
300 DE TUENDA
fiv Tap boKei buCTtdGeiav TroieTv Trpoc xa e'2uj Kai CKXri- poTTiTa ToO cu)|aaTOC, auTii ^ieiZov dTrepTaZeTai Trepi Tot evToc KaKOV, eviCTaiaevri toic Tiopoic Kai tci uTpd cuvdTouca Kai TtriTvuouca Tdc dvaGumdceic dei x«' XdcGai Ktti bia(popeTc0ai pouXo|aevac. Iti b' dvdTKri s Touc i|iuxpoXouToOvTac eic eKeivriv auGic ^iupaiveiv iiv
C qpeuToiuev dKpipfi Kai TeTaTMevrjV dTtoToiiiJuc biaiTav, dei rrpocexovTac auToTc Mn TrapaPaivujci TauTnv, luc 1 euGuc eEeXeTXOnevou ttikpujc TtavToc d|aapTr||aaTOc. fi be GepiLioXoucia bibujci ttoXXtiv cuTTVU))iriv- ou Tdp lo tocoOtov euToviac uq)aipeT Ktti pu))aric, ocov ujqpeXeT TTpoc uTieiav, evb6ci|ia Tr| TT^iyei Kai iiiaXaKTiKd Trap- exouca, toTc bk Tfiv TreiiJiv biaqpeuTouciv, dv t^ br) |ufi uavTdTtaciv uj)ud Kai |a€Te'ujpa M^ivri, biaxuceic dXuTTOuc TrapacK€ud2ouca Kai kottouc ^KXeaivouca Xav- u|
D edvovTac. ou lanv dXX' oTav f] (pucic Trap^x^l M^Tpiujc biaKei|iievou Kai kavuic toO cu)|uaTOC aicGnciv, ^aTeov t6 paXaveTov. dXeijuiua be t6 ttp6c TtOp PeXTiov, dv dXeac beriTai t6 cij&)iia, TajaieueTai Tdp auTu) tiiv Gep- jaoTriTa. 6 b' fiXioc ouie )idXXov ou0' fiTTOV dXX' dic 2«j K€KpaTai TTp6c t6v d^pa K€XPnc9ai bibujci. TaOTa iuev ouv kavd Ttepi Tu|iivaciujv.
16. 'Gtti be Tpoqpfiv TTapaT€VO|U^vouc, Sv }xkv fj ti | tOuv TTp6c0ev ocpeXoc Xotujv oic Tdc opeHeic ^ktiXoO jiev Kai KaTeTTpauvo|Li€v, dXXo ti xPH TrapaiveTv tujv 25 ^qpeEfic' av b' ujciTep ^k b€C)iu)V XeXu)ievaic xaXeTT6v
1, 393-395 H. 6, 497- 499 B.
8. iTdpaPaivuJCi Reiskius : irapapaiveiv 10. noXArividem: TToWu) 12. luaXaKTiKd*: iuaXaKd 18. TtOp Reiskius: TTupl 19. Ti^v GepM^TriTa idem: ttic SepiadTriToc 24. ^KriXoO-
|U€V Kal KaTeiTpaOvoiaev idem : KriXoO|Liev Kal KaTaTrpaOvo|iev 26. XeXuiLidvaic idem: XeXujievr)
J
SANITATE PRAECEPTA 301
• fj XP»lcOcxi Ktti cpiXov6iK€iv TTpoc YacTepa (Lia ixr\ ^\ov- E cav, ujc eXeYC KdTiuv, biajarixavTiTeov tt^ ttoiothti Tnc Tpoqpfjc ^XaqppoTepov Troieiv to 7TXfi9oc. Kai Tot )aev cTepea Kai TroXuTpoqpa tujv citiujv, oiov tci Kpeuubri
5 Kai TupuObn Kai cuKUJV TCi Sripct Kai uiujv toi eqpGd, rrpocqpepecGai rreqpuXaY|uevujc dTTToiiievov (epYOv Ydp dei TTapaiTeTcGai), toTc be XeTTToTc ejLiqpuec6ai Kai kou- qpoic, oia Ttt TToXXd tujv Xaxdvujv Ka\ Td TTTnvd Kai Toiv ixOuujv 01 \xr\ TTiovec. Icti Ydp Td ToiaOTa TTpoc-
10 qpep6|aevov Kai xctpi2€c9ai TaTc opeSeci Kai t6 cuJiia F )ifi TTieZieiv. iiidXiCTa be Tdc dTr6 Kpetjuv qpoPnfeov dTTeviJiac' Kai ydp euOuc cqpobpa Kai papuvouci, Kai Xeivijavov eica09ic Trovr|p6v dTT' auTuJv TTapa|ae'vei. Kai KpdTicTov luiev e9icai t6 cuJMa |aribe|niac rrpocbei-
15 c9ai capKoqpaTiac • TToXXd Tap ou juovov Trp6c biaTpo- qpfiv dqp9ova dXXd Kai Trp6c eu7Td9eiav Kai dTToXauciv dvabibujciv f) Yfj , toTc jxev auT69ev dTrpaYMOVUJc xpri- c9ai 7Tape'xouca, Td be laiYvujueva Kai TTavTobaTTuJc TTapacKeuaZojueva cuvnbuveiv. errei be t6 e'9oc TpoTTOv 132
20 Tivd qpucic ou TTapd qpuciv Y^YOvev, ou beT xpfic9ai KpeujqpaYia TTp6c dTTOTrXiipujciv 6pe'2eujc, ujCTTep Xukouc f| XeovTac, dXX' oiov UTTepeicjaa Kai bidZiujcjua Tfjc Tpoqpfic ejaPaXXo|uevouc ^Tepoic ciTioic xpr|c9ai Kai ovpoic, d Kai Tuj cujjuaTi judXXov dcTi KaTd qpuciv, Kai
2o xfic vjjuxnc fiTTov djupXuvei t6 Xoyikov, ujcTrep ck Xi- Tfic Kai eXaqpp&c uXtic dvarrTojuevov.
17. Tuiv b' uYpjJuv YdXaKTi juev oux ujc TroTui XpricTeov, dXX' ujc ciTtuj buvajuiv ^MPpi9n Kai ttoXu- Tpoqpov exovTi. TTp6c be t6v oTvov dTrep eupiTribric B
l , 395—396 H. 6, 499—500 R.
24. Uri Xylander: ^cti koI 29. eOpiiribric] Nauck.
p. 523
302 BE TUENDA
TTpoc Tfjv 'AqppobiTTiv XeKTeov
'eiric fioi, jueTpiov be ttujc
eir|c, |Lir|^' dTToXemoic'. Kttl T«P TTOTOIV UJ(p€Xl)LHJUTaT6v ^CTl Kttl (pap|ndKUJV fibi- CTOV Kai OipUJV dciKX^TaTOV, dv TUX';) TfjC TTpOC TOV Kai- 5
pov euKpaciac jadXXov fi ttic rrpoc t6 ubujp. ubujp b* ou ia6vov t6 laifvuiaevov TTpoc oTvov, dXXd Kai t6 Ka6' ^auT6 ToO KeKpajievou laeTaHu TTiv6|Lievov dpXapecTepov TTOieT t6 KeKpaii^vov. IGictcov ouv TTapd Tnv KaG' f|)Liepav biaiTav ubaTOc TTpoc(pe'pecGai Kai buo Kai Tpia lo TTOTripia, Tr|v t€ buvamv tou oivou TTOioOvTa )LiaXa- C KUJTepav Kai toO cuuiuaTOc cuvrjGri thv ubporrociav, OTTujc, OTav ev XPti» TevriTai, |nr| HevoTTaGr) larib' dTTavaivriTai. cujapaivei tdp ^viouc (pe^pecGai Trpoc t6v oTvov oTav iLidXicTa xpci«v ubpoTTOciac exujci. 15 Kai Ydp fiXiujGevTec Kai pifUJcavTec ndXiv Kai c(po- GpoTepov eiTTOVTec Kai cuvTovuuTepov (ppovTicavTec
Kai OXUJC |U€Td TOUC K^TtOUC Kai TOUC dtUlVaC OlOVTttl
TTOTeov eivai tov oTvov, ujc Kai thc qpuceujc dTrai- Toucric euTrdGeidv Tiva tu» ciu)iaTi Kai ^eTaPoXriv eK 20 D TU)V TTovujv. f) be (pucic euTTdGeiav )a^v, ei tic euTtd- Geiav KttXei Tfiv fibuTrdGeiav, ouk drraiTeT, )aeTapoXfiv , b' dTTaiTei Tfjv eic t6 \iico\ fibovnc Kai ttovou KaGi- CTdcav. bi6 Kai Tpo{pf]c u(paipeTeov ev toutoic, Kai t6v oTvov F| TTavTeXuJc dqpaipcT^ov r| TTpocoiCTeov 25 TToXXrj KaTaKepavvujaevov bid )Liecou Kai KaTaKXuZoiue- vov ubpoTTOcia. TTXriKTric xdp ujv Kai oHuc eTTiTeivei Tdc ToO cuj^aTOC Tapaxdc, Kai TpaxuTepa TTOiei koi TTapoHuvei Td TreTTXriY^Lieva , TrapriYopiac beojueva Kai
1, 396—397 H. 6, 500-502 K,
1. \€KT^ov Reiskius: SiaXcKTeov 14. (pipuQax*: cpi-
pecBai ladXiCTa
1
SANITATE PRAECEPTA 303
XeioTTiTOc, Sc jadXicia t6 uboup evbibuuci. Kai fotp «v ou bivi^iIiVTec, dXXujc be Gepinov ubuup Ttiuujaev lacTd Touc KOTTouc Ktti Tttc biaTdceic Kai Td Kau|uaTa, xa- E Xdc|iaT0C Kai laaXaKOTriTOC aic9av6)ae6a irepi Td evToc*
5 fJTrioc tdp T) ToO ubaTOc utpoTric Kai dcqpuKTOC, f\ be ToO oivou q)opdv exei TroXXriv Kai buvainiv ouk eu)aevfi TOic TrpoccpdTOic TrdOeciv oube q)iXdv9piJUTT0V. Ktti fdp dc Xetouciv evioi tlD ciu|aaTi Tfjv dciTiav bpi- )iUTr|Tac eTTCVvdv Kai TTiKpoTriTac ei tic be'biev n Ka-
10 edTrep 01 Traibec beiv6v fiYeiTai Trpo toO TrupeTTeiv |afi TTapaTieec9ai TpdrreZiav ev uTTOvpia YeToviuc, eudpino- CTOv f) ubpoTTOCia McQopiov. Kai Tdp auTiu tuj Aio- vucuj TToXXdKic vricpdXia euoMev, l9iZ;6juevoi KaXiiuc ixy\ lY\Te\v dei t6v dKpaTov. 6 be Mivuuc Kai tov auX6v P
15 dqpeiXe ttic 9uciac Kai t6v CTeqjavov utt6 Xutttic. Kai- Toi XuTTOUMevriv MJUxnv iciLiev ouTe utt6 CTeqjdvuuv ouTe utt6 auXuuv TTa9o0cav cuu|Lia b' oubev outuuc icxupov ecTiv, Jj TeTapaTMevLU Kai q)XeTMaivovTi TrpocTrecuuv olvoc ouK TibiKr|ce.
20 18. Touc jaev ouv Aubouc ev tuj Xijliuj XeTOuci bidTCiv fiMepav Trap" fi)Lie'pav Tpeqjojtievouc , eiTa TTaiZovTac Kal KuPeuovTac q)iX6XoTOV b' dvbpa Kai q)iX6)aoucav Iv Kaiptu beo)aeviu ppabuTepou beiKvou 133 bidTpa)ajia TTapaKei)aevov fj ti pipXiov r| Xupiov ou
25 TTpoieTOd Tf] TttCTpi XeriXaTOU|aevov, dXX' dTrocTpe'q)uuv cuvexujc Kai jaeTaq)e'puuv eTri TauTa Tfjv bidvoiav dTT6 Tfic TpaTTeZiric uiCTrep 'ApTTuiac Tdc opeHeic biacoprjcei Tttic Moucaic. ou Tap 6 juev CKu9ric, OTav Trivri, TroXXdKic eq)dTTTeTai toO toHou Kai TTapavpdXXei Tf]v
1,397— 398H. C, 502-503B.
1. fic Reiskius: oTc 21. 6idT€lv*: biaTOTeiv 23.
{ieo|ae'vuj Meziriacus: beojuevov
304 1>E TUENDA
veupdv, dKXu6)i€vov utto ttic jieGnc dvaKaXoO^evoc Tov 6u|i6v, "GXXtiv b' dvfip cpoPnceTai touc KaTare- XOuvTac auTOu Tpd)j)aaci Kai pipXioic dTviujiOva Kai bucTTapaiTriTOV ^Tri8u)aiav dvievTOc dTpe^aa Kai xo^^wv-
B Toc; TU)V )iev ydp napd tu; Mevdvbpuj veavicKuuv 5 UTTO ToO TTopvopocKoO TTapd TTOTOv ^TTiPouXeuojievwv KaXdc KOi TToXuTeXeic elcdtovTOC iTaipac ^KacTOc, ujc cptici,
'Kuvpac KttG' auTov tujv TpaTtmdTUJV fcpXa',, q)uXaTT6)ievoc Kai q)opou)ievoc ejipXeTTeiv 01 be 91X6- 10 XoYOi TToXXdc Ka\ nbeiac dTToii^eic Kai dTTOCTpoqpdc Ixouciv, dvTTep dXXujc jifi buvuJVTai t6 kuvikov Ka\ eripiwbec tuuv 6p^EeuJv KaT^x^iv TTapaKei^^vric Tpane- lr[C. dXeiTTTUJV bk qpujvdc Kai TTaiboTpipujv X6touc ^KdcTOTe XeydvTUJV ujc t6 Trapd bemvov q)iXoXoTeiv 1» Tfiv Tpoq)fiv biaq)9eipei Kai Papuvei Tfjv Keq)aXfiv TdTe
C q)oPriT€ov OTav tov 'Ivbov dvaXueiv f) biaXeTec6ai TTepi ToO KupieuovTOC iv beiTTviu )ieXXuj)iev. tov fxi\ Tdp ^TK^q^aXov toO q)oiviKOC, tXukuv Svto cqpobpa, K€q)aXaXT6v XeTOuciv elvar biaXeKTiKf) bk 'TpujTdXiov' w, ^TTi beiTTVUJ 't^uku* |i^v ouba)iuJc Kcq^aXaXT^ ti Kai KOTTuibec lcxupuic dcTiv. 5v b' fi)idc )ifi dXXo ti Ix]- Teiv fi q)iXocoq)eTv f\ dvaTiTvwcKeiv TTapd bemvov dujci TuJv ^v Tuj KaXuJ Kai ujq)eXimjj t6 ^ttotujt^v uq)' fibovfic Kai tXuku ndpiov ^x6vtujv, KeXeucojiev auTOUc a
D |ifi dvoxXeiv, dXX' dTTidvTac dv tuj Euctlu TauTa Kai Taic TTaXaiCTpaic biaXeTeceai toTc deXriTaic, oOc t(juv pipXiujv ^EeXdvTec dei biniiepeueiv Iv CKuj/ijnaci koi
1,898— S93H. 6,603-505
9. Meinek. IV. p. 280 xae' W: ic 10. <p»\6X0Toi
L. Dindorfius: 91X0X6^01 koXAc Kai 20. K€<paXaXTic vel
KeqpaXaXTiK^v idem rpuJTaXiov] Bergk. p. 329. 1368»
SANITATE PRAECEPTA 305
puujLioXoxiaic eGiZoviec, ujc 6 K0|avp6c 'ApicTuuv eXete, Toic iv YUMvaciLu kiociv ojuoiiuc Xmapouc treTroiriKaci Kai Xi9ivouc. auTOi be TreiGojLievoi toTc laTpoTc napai- voOciv dei ToO beirrvou Kai toO uttvou Xaiupdveiv |ue- 6 Gopiov Kai |Lifi cujacpopricavTac eic t6 ciJU|Lia Td ciTia Kai t6 7Tve0|ua KaTa9Xii|javTac iufi euGuc ujjur) Kai le- ovcrj Trj Tpoqpri papuveiv Triv TTe'ipiv dXX' dvaTrvofiv Kai xaXac)aa TTapexeiv, ujcrrep oi Td cuu)iaTa KiveTv luieTd beTTTvov dSioOvTec ou bp6|uoic oube TTaYKpaTioic E
10 toOto TTOioOciv dXXd pXrixpoTc TTepmdTOic Kai xopeiaic llijueXeciv, outujc Kai fmeTc oiricojieGa beTv Tdc ipuxdc biaq)e'peiv |ueTd beTrrvov |ur|Te TrpdYiuaci iuriTe qppovTici f.ir|T€ coqpiCTiKoTc dYuici Trp6c djuiXXav eTribeiKTiKfjv fj KivriTiKfiv TTepaivojuevoic. dXXd TToXXd juev icvi tujv
15 qpuciKuiv TrpopXrmdTuiV ^Xaqppd Kai TTiGavd , TToXXai bk birjYTjceic f\BiKa\ Kai CKeipeic Ixoucai toOto bx] t6 'luevoeiKdc', ibc "0|ir|poc Iqpri, Kai |ufi dvTiTUTTOv. Tdc b' iv TaTc icTopiKaTc Kai rroiTiTiKaTc ^nTriceci biaTpipdc ouK dnbujc evioi beuTepac TpaTre'Z;ac dvbpdci qpiXoXo-
20 YOic Kai qpiXoMOucoic TrpoceTTTOV. eici bk Kai biriYn- ceic dXuTTOi Kai juuGoXoYiai , Kai t6 Trepi auXoO ti Kai F Xupac dKoOcai Kai eiTreTv eXaqppoTepov f| Xupac auTnc qp9eYY0|uevric dKoueiv Kai auXoO. lueTpov be toO Kai- poO t6 TTic Tpoqpfic Ka9iCTa)uevric dTpejua Kal cu|UTTve-
25 oucric Tfiv TTe'4Jiv eYKpaTTi Yevec9ai Kai uTrepbeEiov. 19. '€Trei b' 'ApicTOTeXnc oieTai tuuv bebemvriKO- Tujv t6v juev irepiTraTOV dvappmiCeiv t6 9epju6v, t6v
1,399— 400 H. 6, 505-507 E.
6. ^i] delet Xylander 8. izapixeiv*: Ixew 10.
dWdi pXrixpoiC L. Dindorfius: dW dpXrixpoic 11. outuuc
Koi Reiskius: outujc 17. Tdc 5' kv Taic Xylander:
Toic be
Plntarchi Moralia. Vol. I. 20
306 I>E TUENDA
h' U7TV0V, 5v eii0L)C Kaeeubuuci, KaTaTrviYeiv, cTepoi be TTiv |Liev ficuxiav oiovTai toic TTeipeic PeXTiovac 134 TToieTv, Triv hk Kivnciv TapdTTeiv Totc dvaboceic, Kai toOto touc )tiev TTepmaTeTv euGuc dTTO bemvou touc b' dTpejLieTv tr^TTeiKev, djLi(poTe'pujv dv oiKeiiuc eqpdTTTe- s] cGai boleiev 6 t6 inev cujjaa cuv9d\TTUJv Kai cuvexojv ueTd t6 beTTTVOV, ttjv bk bidvoiav ixr] KaTaqjepdjaevoc ILirib' dpTuiv eu6uc aW ujCTrep eipriTai biaqpopujv eXa- 9pajc t6 TTveupia koi Xctttuvujv tuj XaXeTv ti Kai dKOueiv Tujv npocrivujv Kai ixf] baKVOVTUJV nribe papu- la
VOVTUJV.
20. '€)bi^Touc bk Kai KOiXiac KaGdpceic iStto (pap- lidKUJV, jiiapd "■ TTapa|iu8ia TTXric|iiovfic', dveu (ieTdXric
B dvdYKTic ou KivriTe'ov, oiCTTep oi rtoXXoi Kevujceujc eveKa TTXripoOvTec t6 cujjaa Kai TTdXiv ^k TrXripuJceujc i| KevoOvTec TTapd qpuciv, TaTc TrXnciaovaTc oux tittov r\ TaTc evbeiaic dviu»)uievoi , laaXXov b' oXujc ttiv /lev TTXiipujciv ujc KuuXuciv dTToXauceujc Papuv6)Lievoi, thv b' evbeiav ibc x^pciv dei TaTc fjbovaTc TtapacKeudZov- I T€C. t6 Ydp pXapep6v ^v toutoic ttpoOtttov ecTi • 2C Tapaxdc t€ Ydp diuqpdTepa tlu cuujuaTi TTapexeTai Kai | cTTapaTiLiouc. ibiov be tJj iuev djueTUj KaK6v TTpocecTi ' t6 Tfjv dTrXriCTiav auHeiv tc Kai Tpeqpeiv • TiTvovTai Tdp ai TTeTvai Ka6dTrep Td dvaKOTTTOf^eva p€T6pa Tpa-
C X€i«» »<«* Tapaxujbeic, Kai pia Tfjv Tpoqpfiv cXkouciv 25 dei XuTToOvTac, ouk dp^Eeciv eoiKuTai citiujv beoj^e- vaic dXXd qpXeT)LiovaTc qpap)adKUJV Kai KaTarrXaciadTUJV. 66€v fibovai ^ev ^HeTai Kai dTeXeic Kai ttoXuv ^xo^cai cqpuT|ii6v Kai oTcTpov Iv TaTc dTroXauceci Xa)ipdvouciv
Ij 400—401 H. 6, 507—509 B
15. ^K* 24. dvaKOTTTojueva Madvigius: KOTTToiueva 26. bpiliciv loiKmai Reiskius: opeHiv loiKmav
SANITATE PRAECEPTA 307
auTouc, biaidceic 6e Kai TTXnT«i Tropujv Kai Trv€U|Lid- Tuuv ^varroXriijieic biabe'xovTai , )afj TTepijLievoucai Tdc KaTct cpuciv ^EaTUJTac, dXX' iTriTToXdZoucai toTc cuj- iuaciv uJCTrep unepdvTXoic CKdcpeci, q)opTiujv eKpoXfic
5 ou TrepiTTUj^idTuiv 5eo)Lievoic. ai be Trepi Triv KdTuj KOiXiav eKTapdEeic bid cpapiaaKeiac cpGeipoucai Kai Tri- Koucai Td uTroKei|Lieva TrXeiova ttoioOci TTepiTTuiciv t] eSdTOuciv. ujCTrep ouv ei tic 'GXXrjvuJV oxXov ev d TToXei papuv6)Lievoc cuvoikov 'Apd^ujv eiLiTrXriceie Kai
10 CkuGujv Tf|V rroXiv errriXubujv, outujc evioi toO Trav- Toc biaiaapTdvouciv irx' eKpoXrj TrepiTTUJ|LidTUJV cuvri- eujv Kai cuvTp6(pujv ejnpdXXovTec eHujBev eic t6 cu)|ua k6kkouc Tivdc Kvibiouc Kai CKaiaujviav Kai buvdjaeic dXXac dcuTKpdTOuc Kai dTpiac Kai KaGapjuoO beojnevac
15 ladXXov f| KaOfipai Trjv (puciv buvainevac. dpiCTOV m^v ouv t6 jueTpia biaiTri Ka» cujqppovi t6 cujjiia rroieTv TTepi Te Kevuuceic Kai TrXripuuceic auTOTcXec dei Kai cu|Li|ueTpov • ei b' dvdTKn TTOTe KaTaXdpoi, toOc ytkv eiaeTouc rroiriTeov dveu cpapMaKeiac Kai rrepiepTiac,
20 }xr\bkv CKTapdTTOVTac dXX' ocov dTretpiav eKcpuTeiv e auT69ev dqjievTac dTrpaTjLidvujc tlu TrXeovdZiovTi ti^v dTTepaciv. ujc Tdp Td 606via pujLijLiaci Kai xctXacTpai- oic TrXuv6|aeva naXXov eKTrXuveTai tiDv ubaTOKXucTUJV, ouTUJC 01 iLieTd cpapiidKUJV eineToi Xu|aaivovTai tuj cuu-
25 jLiaTi Kai biaqp9eipouciv. uqpiCTaiuevTic be KOiXiac ou- bev qpdpiuaKOv oia tuuv ciTiuuv evia luaXaKdc evbibdv- Ta TTpo0ujuiac Kai biaXuovTa Trpduuc, u»v fi xe TreTpa irdci cuvr|0nc Kai f\ xP^cic dXuTToc. dv be toutoic dTTei0ri, nXeiovac fiiae'pac ubpoTTOciav f| dciTiav r] kXu- f
1, iOl— 402H. 6,509— 510B.
2. ^vaTroXri'|)eic*: ^vairoXeiiyeic 14. dcuyKpciTouc
Meziriacus: dcuYKpiTouc
20*
308 DE TUENDA
cxfipa TTpocbeKTeov inaXXov r| xapaKTiKdc Kai cpGapTi- Kttc (pap)LiaK€iac , dcp* ac oi ttoXXoi (pepovTai TTpoxei- ptuc, Ka9dTTep dKoXacTOi YuvaiKec, ckPoXioic XPiJ^M^- vai Kai (pGopioic uTrep toO TrdXiv TTXiipoOcOai Kai fjburraOeTv. 5
21. 'AXXd TOUTOuc nkv eaTeov ot b' cifav au rrdXiv dKpiPeic Kai TeTaTinevac Tivdc dK TTepiobou Kpi- 135 TiKdc ejLipdXXovTec dciTiac ouk 6p9ijuc thv (puciv |ufi beo|aevnv bibdcKOuci beTc9ai cucToXf^c Kai TTOieTv dvaY- Kaiav Tfiv ouk dvayKaiav u(paipeciv iv Kaipuj 2titou- 10 juevov e9oc dTTaiToOvTi. PcXtiov Yap eXeu9epoic toTc ToiouTOic xPnc9ai KoXac|ioTc eic t6 cOuina, |Lir|be|Liidc TTpoaic9r|C€UJC guctic firib' UTTOipiac, Kai Tfjv dXXrjV biaiTav, uicTTep eipriTai, Trp6c t6 cuvtuyx«vov dei TaTc jLieTapoXaTc uTTriKOOv ^'xeiv, jufi KaTabebouXuj|a^vr|V 15 ILirib' evb€b6)Lievr|v evi cxrmaTi piou TTpoc Tivac Kai- pouc f| dpi9)Liouc fi rrepiobouc dYec9ai laeiueXeTriKOTOc.
B ou Yctp dc(paXec oub^ pabiov oube ttoXitik6v oub' dv9pujTriK6v dXX' 6cTpe'ou tiv6c l{ur) rrpoceoiK^c f\ CTeXe'xouc t6 d|LieTdcTaTOv toOto Kai KaTnvaYKac)ue'vov 20 ev Tpo(paTc Kai dTTOxaic Kai Kivriceci Kai ficuxiaic ** eic drricKiov Tiva piov Kai cxoXacTfiv Kai juovotpottov Kai dcpiXov Kai dboSov dTTUJTdTUJ TToXiTeiac Ka9icaciv eauTOuc Kai cucTeiXaciv, ou 'KaTd Ye Tfiv Ijuriv' eq>r] 'Yva))UTiv'. (22) ou Yap dpYiac ujviov f) uYieia Kai 25 drtpaEiac, d ye br] lueYiCTa KaKUJV TaTc vocoic Trpoc- €CTi, Kai oubev biacpepei toO Td 6]U|uaTa tuj ^jlx) bia-
C pXeTreiv Kai Tfiv qpujvfiv tuj juf) qp9eYYec9ai (puXdTTOV-
1,402— 403 H. 6, 510-512E.
12. |ari&6|uiac*: |uri6€|Liiac b^ 21. Signavi hiatum
22. luov^TpOTTOv * : |uov6tpott6v Tiva 26. jLidTiCTO Xylan-
der: ixificxa YvuOjLiriv
SANITATE PBAECEPTA 309
Toc 6 Triv uYieiav ctxpticTiaic koi ficuxiaic XP^^eiv oi6|ucvoc' oubev Yap ^auTuJ xPnc«iTO dv tic uficti- vovTi Kp€iTTOVi Ttpoc TToXXdc Kai (piXavGpouTrouc rrpd- Heic. fiKicTa bfi Tfjv dpTiav ufieivov unoXTiKTeov, el
5 t6 Tfic uTieiac TeXoc d7T6XXuci , Kai oub' dXriOec ecTi t6 iudXXov uTiaiveiv Toijc fjcuxiav dYOVTac* ouTe fdp EevoKpdTTic iLidXXov biuYiaive OaiKiujvoc ouTe AriMTi- Tpiou 0e6cppdcTOC, '€TTiK0up6v tc Kai Toijc Ttepi 'Gtti- Koupov oubev ujvrjce rrpoc Tfjv u|iivou)aevriv capKOC
10 eucTdOemv f) TTdcT^c cpiXoTi)aiav exoucric TTpdHeiuc dTro- bpacic. dXXd Kai ^Te'paic eTTi|neXeiaic biaciJucTe'ov ecTi D Tuj ctOjnaTi Tf|V KttTd q)uciv eEiv, dic TravToc piou Kai v6cov bexo)Lte'vou Kai uTieiav. ou ^fjv dXXd Kai toic TToXiTiKOic eqpri TTapaiveTe'ov eivai TouvavTiov oij TTXd-
1 ' TUiv TTap^vei ToTc veoic. eKeivoc jaev xdp Xefeiv ^k TTic biaTpipfjc dTTaXXaTT6|iievoc eiuj0ei 'dte, ottujc eic KaX6v Ti KaTa9f|cec0e Tfjv cxoXf|v, uj Traibec* fijueTc b' dv ToTc TToXiTeuo)nevoic TTapaive'cai|iev eic Td KaXd Xpfic0ai ToTc tt6voic Kai dva^KaTa, jjf) )uiKpujv ev€Ka
-■ ur|be cpauXujv t6 cu))aa TTapaTeivovTac , ujCTrep oi TToXXoi KaKOTTa0oOciv ^TTi ToTc Tuxouciv, dTTOKvaiovTec eauTOuc dypuTTviaic Kai TrXdvaic Kai TrepibpojuaTc eic E oubev xPncTov oub' dcTeTov, dXX' errripedZovTec ^Te'- poic f| q)0ovouvTec f| ^iXoveiKouvTec f| bdEac dKdp-
-3 TTOuc Kai Kevdc biujKOVTec. TTpoc TouTouc fdp oT)aai ludXiCTa Tov Ar|)a6KpiTOV eiTreTv ujc ei t6 cujjua biKd- caiTO Tfj vyuxfl KaKiuceujc, ouk dv auTfjV dTToqpuTeTv.
1 , 403—405 H. 6, 362—36-1 R.
1. dxPICTiac Koi Vicuxiac W: dxpriCTia Koi i^cuxia 3. qpiXavBpiuTTOUc Xylander: dqpiXavepdjTTOuc 7. biUYiaive
W: fer uTieiav 10. ■trdcric idem: Trdcric Kal 14.
TTXdTUJv] Legg. I. p. 643 B 20. djCTTCp Reiskius: ujc xap
310 DE TUENDA
Tcuuc ji^v Top Toi KQi 6€6q)pacT0c dXnOec elTrev, €' TTuuv dv ^eTaqpopfi ttoXu tuj cu>)iaTi TcXeiv ^voikiov Triv vjjuxnv. TrXeiova m^vtoi t6 cOu^a Tfic MJuxnc (iTTo- Xauei KaKCt ^n KaTct X6tov auTuJ xpi^^M^vnc ^r\b' ibc Trpocr|K€i e€paTTeu6)i€vov • 6Tav Top ^v TtdOeciv Ibioic T^VHTai KOi dtTU)Ci Kai CTTOubaTc, dq>€ib€i tou cu>Ma-
F Toc. 6 M€v oOv 'Idcujv ouK olba 6 ti TraSujv 'Td ^iKpd beiv dbiKeiv* €X€T€v '?v€k€v toO rd neTdXa biKaioTTpaTeiv '. fmeic b* &v eOXdTujc tuj ttoXitiku» TTapaiV£cai)Liev Td ^iKpd ^aBujieiv Kal cxoXd2[€iv Ka\ lo' dvaTTaueiv auT6v ^v ^Keivoic, cl pouXeTOi TTpdc Tdc 186 KttXdc TTpdEeic Kai MttdXac m^ bidTTOvov Ix^iv t6 cuj- Ma MH^' dMPXu Mni>' drraTopeuov dXX" uucTrep ^v veuiX- Kicji T^ cxoXri TeBepaTTeuMevov , 6ttujc au9ic ^ttl Tdc Xpeiac thc u/uxnc dToucnc -MlM
'fietiXoc Vttttuj ttuiXoc «Juc diMtt '''p^X';!*' J^m
23. Ai6 Tujv TTpaTMdTuiv bib6vTUJV dvaXnTTT^ov dauTOuc mhO' uttvou q^eovoGvTac tuj cuimcjti mHT* dpi- CTOu MHTC ^qcTujvric tov m^cov nbuTTaeeiac Kal KaKO- naeeiac (puXoTTOVTac 6pov, 6v o\ ttoXXoI ^f] (puXdT- ^ TOVT€c ^TTiTpipouc» t6 cuumci Taic M^TapoXaTc, uiCTTep t6v paTTT^Mevov cibripov, 6Tav dvTaerj koi meceri ' cq)6bpa ToTc tt6voic, aOeic iv nbovalc ttik6m€V0v diu
B Tpujc Kal Xeip6M€Vov, eha irdXiv ii dq)pobiciujv kui oivou bidXuTov Kai MCtXoKdv elc dTopdv f^ auXf|v f\ r^ Tiva TTpaTMaTeiav biaTTupou koI cuvt6vou beoM^vnv CTTOubfic dXauv6M€vov. 'HpdKXeiTOC m^v Tdp ubpujTtid-
1,40»-«06U. 6,5U-Mr.K
1. To» ReUkiue: n 16. Bergk. p. 7a8» 19. tdv
Salmasins: t6 KaKonaSciac idem: KaKonadeiac \xf\ri
20. ^uXdTTovToc W: (puXarroOcrjc 6v ol noXXoi m»^ S«1- masias: olov ol iroXXol S4. X€i06m€vov W: eXip^Mevov
SANITATE PRAECEPTA 311
cac ^KeXeuev ^auxMov dS iTroiaPpiac' TToificai tov ia- Tpov ' 01 be TToXXoi ToO TiavToc djiapTdvouciv, OTav iv KOTTOic Kai TTovoic Kai ^vbeiaic T^vcavTai, ladXiCTa Taic f]bovaTc ^HuTpaiveiv Kai dvaTriKeiv Td ciuM«Ta
5 rrapabibovTec , auGic bk jLieTd Tdc fjbovdc oiov im- CTpeqpovTec Kai KaTaTeivovTec. f] Tdp qpucic ou lr]Tei TOiauTrjv dvTaTTobociv toO cu»)LiaTOc. dXXd Tfic ipuxnc t6 dKoXacTov Kai dveXeu0epov ^k tujv ^Trmoviuv ujc- c Trep 01 vaOTai TTpoc nbovdc Kai dTToXauceic lippei
10 q)ep6)H€V0V Kai /i€Td Tdc fjbovdc ndXiv in ' epTaciac Kai TTopiCjuouc uj9ou)Lievov ouk ia Xapeiv Tfjv qpuciv fjc judXiCTa beiTtti KaTacTdceuuc Kai T«Xr|vnc, dXX' eS- icTrici Kai TapdTTei bid Tfjv dvuj|LiaXiav. o» be voOv exovTec fiKicTC txkv fjbovdc ttovoOvti tuj cwjiaTi
15 TTpoc(pe'pouciv • ou Tdp beovTai t6 TTapdrrav oube )Lie)avrivTai tujv to»outu)v TTpoc tuj KaXuj TfjCJTpdHeujc Tfjv bidvoiav exovTec, Kai TuJ xcipovTi Tfjc ipuxfic f| D CTToubdZovTi Tdc dXXac eHa|aaupoOvTec eTTiGujuiac. 6- TTep Tdp cpaciv eiTreiv tov 'Crrajaeivujvbav |ueTd rrai-
2obidc, dvbp6c dTaGoO rrepi Td AeuKTpmd vocuj TeXeu- TficavToc, *(L 'HpdKXeic, ttujc ecxoXacev dvfip dTTo- GaveTv iw tocoutoic rrpdT^uaci', toOt' dXri6ujc ecTiv eiTTeTv ^TT* dvbpoc f\ TToXiTiKfiv TrpdEiv f\ cpiX6cocpov qppovTiba bld x^ipoc ^XOvtoc, 'tic be cxoXf) tiu dvbpi
25 TouTLu vOv dTTeTTTeTv fj fie6ueiv f| XaTveueiv ; ' Tev6)ae- voi be TTdXiv dTT6 tujv TrpdSewv Iv ficuxia KaTaTi0evTai t6 cu))aa Kai biavaTTauouci, tOjv Te tt6vujv touc dxpn- CTouc Kai fiaXXov eTi tujv fibovuiv Tdc oOk dvaTKaiac E ujc Tfj qpucei TroXe^iiiac q)uXaTT6)U€V0i Kai qpeuTOVTec.
1, 406-40T H, 6, 515—517 E.
17. TiJj x«fpovTiW; Td xcipov 18. CTrou&diZiovTi Hal-
mius: cnovb&Zov tcic fiWac — 4TTi8ufi(ac Xylander: toIc fiWaic — ^Trieuiiiaic
312 DE TUENDA
26. "HKOuca TiPepiov itotc Kaicapa emeiv dic dvfip unfep dHriKOvra TeToviuc erri Kai npoTeivaiv laTpuj xeipa KaTttTeXacToc Ictiv. iixoi be toOto iiiev eipnceai bOKei coPapiuTepov, ^Keivo b' dXnOec eivai, t6 beiv EKacTOv auToG \xr\Te ccpuYMuiv ibiOTriToc eivai dTrei- 5 pov (TToXXai Ydp a.\ Ka9' eVacTOV biacpopai) iunTe Kpa- civ dtvoeiv riv ex€i to cuiMa 0ep)a6Tr|TOc Kai HriPOTn- Toc, ixr\Q' oic iwcpeXeTceai xpu>M£vov f| pXdiTTeceai Tie- q)UK€v. auToO Tdp dvaic0riT6c dcTiv Ka\ TucpXoc dvoi- KcT Ttu ciujiaTi Kai Kiuqpoc 6 TaOTa inavedvujv nap ' lo
F ^Te'pou Kai 7Tuveav6|U€Voc toO laTpoO TT^Tepov mSXXov e^pouc fj X€>Mujvoc uTiaivei, Kai tt6t€Pov Td uTpd paov f\ Td Hripd TTpocbex€Tai , Kai noTepov (pucei | ttukvov lx€i Tov cqpufMov y\ )Liav6v' Kai Ydp dicpeXi- |iOv €ibe'vai Td ToiaOTa Kai ^cibiov, dei T€ hi\ neipuj- 1* |ae'vouc Kai cuvovTac. ppujindTUJV be Kai nu)|LidTUJV Td Xpr|Ci|aa |ii«^^ov rj Td fibea TiTvuucKeiv npocriKCi, Kai MaXXov t'|iTTeipov elvai tujv eucTO|ndxujv f| tujv eucT6- Mujv, Kai Tuiv THV n^ipiv mh TapaTT6vTujv f\ tuiv ttiv 137 TtOciv ccp6bpa TapTaXiZ;6vTUJV. t6 Tdp nap* iaTpoO »j nuv0dvec0ai ti bucnenTov f^ eunenTov auTui Kai ti bucKoiXiov f| euKoiXiov oux nTTOv aicxp6v ^tiv f| to nuv0dv€C0ai Ti t^uku Kai niKpov Kai aucTripov. vOv bk Touc |L»ev 6v|Jonoiouc dnavop0oOciv, ^ianeipujc biai- c0av6Mevoi noO nX^ov to tXuku toO npocr|KOVTOc f\ 25^ To dX|aup6v ^ To aucTripov evecTiv auTOi b' dTvoouci Ti TUJ cuujLiaTi Mix0ev ^Xaqppov Kai dXunov ^'cTai Kai Xpr|ci|aov. 60ev rujjaoO ^kv dpTucic ou noXXdKic d)aapTdveTai nap' auToTc, auTOuc b' 6)ao0 cpauXuJC koi
13 KaKUJc dpTuovTec 6cri)aepai noXXd nap^xouci npdTMCt- 3o
407— 408H. 6,517— 519E.
1. ^KOUCa W: rJKOUca Toivuv
SANITATE PRAECEPTA 313
xa Tok iaTpoTc. Zouiuov )uev t«P ouk apiCTOV fjYoOv- Tai Tov Y^uKUTaTov, dXXd TtoXXd Kai bpi)aea cu)ii|ni- YvOouciv • eic be t6 cui)aa noXXdc Kai KaTaKopouc e)Li- pdXXouciv fibovdc, Td )n^v dYVOoOvTec Td b' ou [i\r\-
5 juoveuovTec oti toTc uticivoTc Kai ujqpeXijLioic f| qpucic fibovfiv dXuTTOv Kai d]LteTa)Lie'Xr|Tov TrpocTiGriciv. dXXd Kai TaOTa bei )Livr|)uoveueiv, Td cu)iq)uXa Kai irpoccpopa TLu ciu)aaTi Kai TouvavTiov ev Taic Ka9' ujpav )uieTa- poXaTc Kai TaTc dXXaic TrepicTdceciv, eiboTac oiKeiiuc
10 TTpocapjLiOTTeiv eKdcTLu Triv biaiTav.
25. "Oca )Liev Tdp juiKpoXoYiac Kai dveXeuGepiac C TTpocKpoujuaTa Xa)updvouciv oi ttoXXoi Tiepi tc cufKO- )aibdc KapTTUJV Kai Tripriceic eTTmovouc, dTpuTiviaic Kai Trepibpo)aaTc IHeXeTXOVTec Td ca6pd Kai uTTOuXa tou
15 ca))LiaTOc , ouK dHiov ^cti bebievai )afi TrdGujciv dvbpec qpiXoXoTOi Kai ttoXitikoi, Trpoc ouc evecTriKev fi)aTv 6 XoTOC" dXX' eTe'pav Tivd (puXaKTe'ov ecTi toutoic bpi- )uuTe'pav ev Tpd)a|uaci Kai )aa0r|)uiaci luiKpoXoTiav, uqp' fic dqpeibeTv Kai d)i€XeTv toO cuu)uaTOc dvaTKdZovTai,
20 TToXXdKic dTtaTopeuovTOC ouk evbibovTec dXXd upoc- D PiaZ:6|uevoi 6vriT6v d0avdTotc Kai THTevec 'OXujuTrioic cuveHa)uiXXac0ai Kai cuveHavuTeiv. eiTa ujc 6 PoOc TTpoc Tfiv 6)u6bouXov eXeTe Kd)uriXov, eTTiKoucpicai ToO qpopTiou jufi pouXo)uevriv • 'dXXd Ka\xh. Kai TaOTa
25 TTdvTa )ieTd )uiKp6v oiceic', 6 Kai cuvepri TeXeuTri- cavTOC auToO, outujc f) liiuxfj )uiKpd xct^«cai Kai TTopeTvai )ifi PouXo)ievri ' ttovoOvti Kai beo|uevuj, )ueT' oXiTov TTUpeToO tivoc f) CKOTU)]uaTOC e)UTrec6vT0C
1, aOS— 409H. 6, 519— 520 B.
26. oiJTUJC i^ ijiuxi^*: ouTUj cujiPaivei Tfj vjjuxfi |nt- Kpa Meziriacus: Kal juiKpa 27. Pou\o|uevri * : PouXo- M^vrj
314 DE TUENDA SANITATE PRAECEPTA
dqpeica Tct pipXia Kai touc Xotouc xai tcic biaTpiPac dvaTKdZeTai cuvvoceTv eKeivtu Kai cuTKdiuveiv. 6peuJc E ouv 6 TTXdToiv rraprivece iiiriTe cu)|Lia Kiveiv dveu vjjuxnc )Lir|Te ipuxnv dveu ciujuaToc, dXX' oiov Tiva Suviupiboc icoppoTTiav biacpuXdTTeiv, oti ^dXicTa t^ H^uxr) cuvepTei 5 Td cu)|aa Kai cuYKd)ivei, TrXeiCTnv ^TTi|i^Xeiav auTuj Kai Geparreiav dTTobibovTac Kai Tf)v KaXfjv Kai |epdc|aiov uTieiciv ujv bfbwciv dTaGoiv KdXXicTov fiTOuju^vouc bibovai To rrpoc KTfjciv dpeTfjc Kai XP^civ Iv Te X6- Toic Kai TTpdHeciv dKiuXuTov auTuiv. i»
1 , 409- 410 H. 6, 520-521 8
2. mdTU)v] Tim. p. 88 B. Phaedr. p. 246 B 5. 6ti
Reiskius: 6t6 8. OTieiav idem: uyieiav (STro6i56vTac
TAMIKA HAPArrEAMATA. 138
nA.0TTAPX02 nOAAIANiJi KAI ETPTAlKHi ET nPATTEIN.
Meta Tdv TrdTpiov Geciuov, 6v umiv f] Tnc ArnnriTpoc B lepeia cuveipTvujievoic ^qpnpiuocev, oijiai Kai tov X6- Yov 6)LioO cuveqpaTTTOiLievov ujinjuv Kai cuvu)LievaiouvTa Xpr|Ci)aov av ti TToificai Kai tuj vo/aiu Trpocujbov. ev
5 |Li^v Ydp Toic iLiouciKoTc 2va tuiv auXriTiKujv vojliujv iTTTToGopov eKdXouv, |ae'Xoc ti toic ittttoic opjafic eTTe- YepTiKOv ujc eoiK€V evbibovTtt TTpoc Tdc oxciac q)i- Xocoqpia hk ttoXXujv Xoyujv Kai KaXuiv ^vovtuiv, ou- bevoc fiTTOv dEioc CTTOubfic 6 Yct|Lir|Xi6c ecTiv outoc, C
10 i3j KaTcibouca touc ^tti piou Koivuivia cuvi6vTac eic TauTd Trpdouc Te Trap^xe» Kai xe>por|0eic dXXnXoic. u»v ouv dKriKdaTe TToXXdKic iv cpiXocoqpia TrapaTpeqpdMevoi KeqpdXaia cuvTdHac ev ticiv oiuoiOTrici Ppaxeiaic, ujc eujuvTi|a6veuTa judXXov ein, koivov djuqpOTepoic TTejuTTuj
15 bOupov, euxdiuevoc Tri 'AqppobiTri Tdc Moucac Trapeivai Kai cuvepYciv, uic juriTe Xupav Tivd juriTe KiSdpav jLiaXXov auTttic f| Tfjv TTepi Ydjuov Kai oTkov ^jaiueXeiav
1,410-4UH. 6, 522-523 K.
7. Trpoc Reiskius: irepl
316 CONIUGALIA PRAECEPTA
fip)Ltoc|Lievriv Trapexeiv bia \6fov Kai dpMOviac Kai qpi- Xocoqpiac TTpocfiKOV. Kai t«P oi TraXaioi Trj 'Acppobiiri Tov '€p|ufiv cvjYKa0ibpucav , ujc Tfic Trepi tov yomov fibovfic iLidXicTa XoYOU beojuevric, Trjv tc TTei0uj Kai D Tdc XdpiTac, iva TTei0ovTec biarrpdTTUuvTai rrap' dX- XriXuJV a pouXovTai, ^xf] |aax6)ievoi iuribe (piXovei- KoOvTec.
1. '0 CoXujv ^KeXeue Triv vuiuqpriv tuj vu)aq)iuj cuf- KaTaKXivec0ai )ar|Xou Kubujviou KaTOTpaYoOcav , alviT- TOjaevoc ujc eoiKev oti bei Tfjv TTpiuTriv dTTo CT6)LiaT0C lo KOi (pujvfjc x&pxv eudpjLiocTov elvai Kai fibeiav.
2. '€v BoiujTia Tf]v vuiaqpriv KaTaKaXuqjavTec d- ccppa-fia CT€(pavouciv • eKeivri Te xdp nbicTOv €k Tpa- XUTdTHC dKdv0ric KaprTov dvabibujciv, fi Te vu)Li(pri tuj ixx] qjuT^VTi )Lif)Te bucxepdvavTi Triv TrpiuTriv xc^e^rro- m TriTtt Kai dribiav auTfic fiiuepov Kai YXuKeiav TTapeHei;
E cujupiujciv. 01 be Tdc TrpuuTac tuuv ,Trap0e'vujv biaqjo- pdc |ifi uTTOjLieivavTec oubev dTToXeiTTOuci tujv bid Tov ojaqpaKa Tfiv CTaqjuXfiv ^Te'poic TTpoieiaevujv. ttoX- Xai be Kai tuiv v€OTd)Liu)V bucxepdvacai bid Td TTpuiTa Touc vu|aq)iouc 6|lioiov erra^ov TTd0oc toTc Tfiv nky TTXriTnv Tf]C ineXiTTric uTro|Lieivaci , t6 be Kripiov Trpo- eiaevoic.
3. 'Cv dpxfj ladXicTa b€T Tdc biaqpopdc Kai Tdc TTpocKpouceic qpuXdTTec0ai touc T^TaMnKdTac, opuiv-! Tac 6ti Kai Td cuvap)aoc0€'vTa TiiJv CKeuuJv KaT* dp Xdc juev UTTO Tfjc Tuxoucric ^cibiujc biacTrfiTai rrpoqjd-
F ceujc, Xp6vuj be tiuv dp)aujv cu)aTTri£iv XapdvTUJV }x6- Xic UTTO TTupoc Kai cibfjpou bioXueTai.
1,111— 412H. 6,523— 525B
10. TTpUjTriv* 11. €ivai*: elvai TrpuuTnv 13. dccppa- fiq.*: dcfppaTiuvia
I CONIUGALIA PRAECEPTA 317
4. "Qcrrep t6 ttOp lEdTTTeTai fjiev euxepuuc ev dxu- poic Ktti 9puaXXibi Kai OpiEi XaTuicnc, c^evvuTai be Tdxiov av |ir| tivoc eTe'pou buvajLievou CTeyeiv aiiia Kai Tpecpeiv ^mXdPnTai, outuj tov dTro ciuiaaToc Kai
5 uipac 6Euv IpujTa tujv veoTdfiujv dvacpXcTd^evov bei |ifi biapKfi fxr\bk Pe^aiov vo^i^eiv, av |ifi Trepi t6 fiGoc ibpuOeic Kai ToO qppovoOvToc dvjjd^ievoc emjjuxov Xdpr) bid9eciv.
5. *H bid TU)V qpapiidKUJV 0r|pa Taxu ^k\ aipei 139 10 Ktti Xaiipdvei pabiujc tov ix9uv, dppujTOv be TTOiei Kai
q)auXov outuic ai q)iXTpa Tivd Kai TotiTeiac emTexvuu- jLievai Toic dvbpdci Kai x^ipouiLievai bi' fiboviic auToiJc ejiTrXriKTOic Kai dvofiTOic Kai bi€cp9ap|i€'voic cuii^ioO- civ. oube Tdp TTiv KipKHV ujvrjcav oi KOTacpapiiaKeu-
13 9evT€C, oub' ^xP^lcaTO Trpoc oubev auToTc uci Ktti ovoic Tevojievoic, tov b' 'Obuccea voOv exovTa Kal
? cuvovTa qppoviiiujc uTrepriTdTTricev.
6. Ai pouX6|i€vai ^idXXov dvorJTujv KpaTeiv dv- bpuJv f\ qppoviiiujv dKoueiv ^oiKaci toTc ev obuj Pou-
20 Xo|ievoic lidXXov obriTeTv TuqpXouc fi toTc titviuckou- civ dKoXou9eTv Kai pXeTTOuci.
7. Tfjv TTaciqpdriv dTTiCToOci Po6c epac9fiVai paci- B XeT cuvoOcav, eviac opujcai touc laev aucTripouc Kai cujqppovac papuvo|ievac, toTc b' eS dicpaciac Kai qpi-
K Xriboviac K€KpaTrmevoic ujcTtep kuciv f\ TpdTOic fibiov cuvoucac.
8. Oi ToTc iTTTTOic dqpdXXec9ai |ifi buvd|ievoi bi' dc9ev€iav fj liaXaKiav auTOuc ^Keivouc OKXdileiv Kai
l, 412 -413 H. 6, 525—526 R.
20. TuqpXouc Stobaeus Floril. LXXXV 9: TuqjXoic 25. KCKpaTriuevoic Coraes: KCKpaiievoic
318 CONIUGALIA PRAECEPTA
uTroniTTTeiv bibdcKOuciv outujc evioi tujv XaPovTuuv euYeveic fj rrXouciac Yvjvakac oux eauToOc ttoiouci PeXTiouc dXX' eKeivac trepiKoXououciv, u)c ladXXov dp- HovTec TaTreivoiv xevoiuevujv. bei b' ujctrep iTtrrou t6 laeTeGoc qpuXdTTOVTa Kai t6 dHiuJiia thc YuvaiKoc XPH* cSai Tu» xctXiviij. C 9. Trjv ceXnvriv, 6Tav dTTOCTrj toO fjXiou, nepi- cpavfi Kai XaiuTrpdv 6pu)Mev, dcpaviZeTai be Kai Kpu- TTTeTai TrXriciov Tevoiiievri' Tf)v be cuOcppova TuvaiKa | bei TOuvavTiov 6pdc0ai ladXiCTa jueTd toO dvbp6c oij- cav, oiKOupeTv be Kai KpuTTTec0ai jitfi rrapovToc.
10. OuK 6p0uJc 6 'HpobOTOc emev oti f) f\jvf\ d)Lia Til) xiTUJVi iKbueTai Kai Tfjv aibuj" TOuvavTiov '■ Tdp f) cuiqppujv dvTevbueTai Tfiv aibuj, Kai toO indXi cTtt qpiXeiv tlD ladXiCTa aib€ic0ai cujliPoXuj XPwJVTai i TTp6c dXXf|Xouc. ,
11. "QcTTep ctv qp06TTOi buo cujLiqpujvo» Xriqp0ujci, ] D ToO papuTepou TiTveTai t6 iueXoc, outuj Trdca TrpdEic i
iv oiKia cujqppovoucr] TTpdTTCTai juev utt' d|LtqpOTe'pujv ojuovoouvTUJV, eTTiqpaivei be Tfiv toO dvbp6c f)Te|Lioviav 20 Kai Trpoaipeciv.
12. ^O fiXioc t6v popeav eviKricev. 6 Tdp dv0puj- TTOc ToO |Liev dve')Liou piaZioiaevou t6 iiudTiov dqpeXe'- c0ai Kai XajLiTTp^v KaTaTrveovToc ^dXXov ecqpiTTC Kai cuveixe Tfiv TiepiPoXfiv ■ toO b' f\\iov ixem t6 TTveO|aa 25 0epfioO Tevo|Lievou 0aXTT6|uevoc eha KauiuaTiZojuevoc Ktti t6v xiTuJva Tuj i|LiaTiuj TrpocaTrebucaTo. toOto TroioOciv ai TrXeiCTai TuvaiKec. dqpaipouinevoic Toic
E dvbpdci pia Tfjv TpuqpfjV Kai Tfiv TToXuTeXeiav biaiad-
1,413— 414H. 6, 526-527 B
12. 'Hp6&0T0c] 18 14. ToO Reiskius: tuj
CONIUGALIA PRAECEPTA 319 •
XOVTtti Ktti xaXeTtaivouciv* Sv bk TreiGoiVTm f^eTd X6- You, TTpdujc dTTOTiGevTai Kai lieTpidCouciv.
13. '0 KdTUJV ISepaXe Tfic pouXnc tov cpiXricavTa 5 Tfiv lauToO YUvaiKa thc OuYaTpoc Trapoucnc. touto
jaev ouv icujc cqpobpoTepov ei b' aicxpov tcTiv, ujc- TTep ^CTiv, ^Te'pujv rrapovTUJV dcTrdCecGai Ka\ (piXeTv Ktti TTepipdXXeiv dXXriXouc, ttijuc ouk aicx»ov eTe'pujv TTapovTUJV XoibopeTc6ai Kai 5iacpepec9ai rrpoc dXXn- loXouc, ** Tdc |Li^v evTeuHeic Kai cpiXocppocuvac dTTop- pi^TOuc TTpoc Tfiv YuvaTKa TTOieTcGai, vouGecia bk Kcn iueiiipei Kai Trappriciqi xPHcOai cpavepql Kai dvaTreTTTa- P
Mtvri;
14. "Qcrrep ecoTTTpou KaTecKeuacMevou xP^cuj Kai 15 XiGoic oqpeXoc ou5ev eCTiv, ei ixi) beiKVuci ttiv )aopcpf)v
6)LiOiav, ouTUJC oub^ TrXouciac YCiMeTfic ovricic, ei \xr\ Trapexei tov piov ojlioiov tui dvbpi Kai cujicpujvov t6 ?\Qoz. ei x«»povTOC |Liev eiKova CKuGpujTrfiv dTTobibuici t6 l'coTTTpov, dx6o|aevou be Kai CKu0pujTTdZovTOC iXa-
20 pdv Kai cecripuTav, f))LiapTr|)Lievov ecTi Kai ^auXov. ouKoOv Kai YVJvfi cpauXoc Kai dKaipoc r\ rrai^eiv juev ujp)Lir|)a^vou Kai cpiXocppoveTcGai toG dvbp6c ecKuGpuj- TTaKuTa, CTTOubdZovTOc bk TraiZiouca Kai YeXujca* to laev Ydp dribiac, t6 b' dXiYujpiac. beT be, uJCTrep oi 140
25 YeujfaeTpai Xe'YOuci Tdc Ypa|i|Lidc Kai Tdc eTTicpaveiac ou KiveTcGai Ka9' ^auTdc dXXd cuYKiveTc9ai toTc cui- )Liaciv, ouTUJ TfjV YuvaTKa laribev ibiov TTd0oc exeiv, dXXd KoivujveTv tiu dvbpi Kai crroubfic Kai Traibidc Kai cuvvoiac Kai yeXujtoc.
30 15. Oi Tdc YuvaTKac \xr\ fibe'ujc pXe^TTOVTec ec9iou- B cac fieT' auTUJV bibdcKouciv e)UTriTTXac9ai juovac Yevo-
1,414— 415H. C, 527-529R.
8. Signavi hiatum
320 CONIUGALIA PRAECEPTA
^evac. ouTUDC oi vifi cuvoviec iXapujc laic YuvaiHi laribe Traibiac KOivuuvoOvTec auTaic Kai YeXuiTOc ibiac fjbovdc X^Pic auTuov ZriTeTv bibdcKOuciv.
B 16. ToTc TU)V TTepcuJv paciXeOciv ai Tvnciai yu- vaiKec TrapaKdGnvTa» bemvoOci Kai cuvecTiCuvTai • pou- X6|Lievoi bk TTaiCeiv Kai |ae0ucKec9ai TauTac ^iv aixo- 7Te'|uiTrouci, Tdc be jaoucoupYOuc Kai TraXXaKibac KaXoO- civ, 6p9uLJC toOto fe rroioOvTec, oti t6 cuvaKoXacTai- veiv Kai TrapoiveTv ou lieTabiboaci TaTc YCtMeTaTc. dv oijv ibiouTric dvrip, dKpaTfjc be Tiepi Tdc fibovdc Kai lo dvdYUJTOC eHaiadpTr] ti Trpoc ^Taipav f| 9epaTTaiviba, beT Tfiv TCtMeTfiv \xr\ OTavaKTeTv txr]bk xctXeTTaiveiv, XoTi2o|Lievriv oti TTapoiviac Kai dKoXaciac Kai Oppeuuc aibouMCVOc auTf|v ^Tepa laeTabibujciv.
C 17. Oi qpiXoiiOucoi tujv paciXeujv ttoXXouc mouci- i5 Kouc TTOioOciv, oi cpiX6XoTOi XoTiouc, oi q)iXa9XriTai TU)ivacTiKOuc. ouTuuc dvfip (piXociu|aaTOC KaXXuuTTi- CTpiav TuvaTKa KoieT, qpiXnbovoc ^TaiplKfjv Kai dK6- XacTov, q)iXdTa9oc Kai qpiXoKaXoc cuOq)pova Kai ko- cpiav. «■
18. AdKaiva TTaibiCKr), TTuv9avo|Li^vou tivoc ei fibri dvbpi TrpoceXr|Xu9ev *ouk ^twtc' eiTrev 'dXX' inoi ^KeTvoc'. ouToc 6 tp6ttoc, oTnai, Tfjc oiKobecTToivnc miTe q)€uTeiv ^fiTe bucxepaiveiv Td ToiaOTa toO dv- bpoc dpxo|Lievou |Lif|Te auTfiv KaTdpx€c9ai ' t6 fi^v Tdp 25
D dTaiptKdv Ka\ iTaMdv, t6 b' uTTepfjq^avov Kai dq)iX6-
CTOPTOV.
19. Mbiouc ou beT q)iXouc KTac9ai t^v TuvaiKa, KOivoTc bk xpfic9ai toTc toO dvbpdc* oi bi Qeox q)iXoi TTpCuTOi Kai li^TiCTOi. bi6 Kai 9eouc ouc 6 dvfip vo- so niZei cepec9ai Tfi TaMtTfj Kai tiyvu»ck€iv m6vouc TTpocfj-
^,415— 416a 6,589-531B
Ji
CONIUGALIA PKAECEPTA 321
K€i; TiepiepYoic be 9pricK6iaic Kai He'vaic beicibai|uo- viaic dTT0K€K\€Tc9ai ifiv auXeiov. oubevi Tctp 9eijuv lepa KXeTTTOjueva koi Xav9dvovTa bpdTai Kexapicjiievujc UTTO TuvaiKoc. 6 20. '0 TTXdToiv qpriciv eubai|Liova Kai luaKapiav eivai TToXiv, ev fj 't6 ejuov Kai t6 ouk e|Li6v' fiKicTa cp0eTTO|Lie'vujv dKOuouci bid t6 koivoic ujc evi pdXicTa E XPnc9ai ToTc dSioic CTTOubfic touc TToXiTac. ttoXij be laaXXov tK TotMOu beT Tfjv T0iauTr|v cpwvfiv dvripfic9ai.
10 ttXtIV tJJCTT€p 01 laTpOl Xe'TOUCl Tdc TUJV 6UUJVU)LIUJV
TrXriTdc Triv aic9riciv ^v toTc beHioTc dvaqjepeiv, outui Tfiv TuvaTKa toTc toO dvbp6c cu|LiKa9eTv KaX6v Kal Tov dvbpa ToTc tt^c TuvaiKOc, iv' ujCTiep oi bec|aoi KOTd Tfjv eTTdXXaHiv icxuv bi' dXXr|Xujv Xajupdvouciv,
15 ouTujc eKaTe'pou Tf|v euvoiav dvTiCTpocpov dTrobibov- Toc f) Koivujvia cujJriTai bi' djuqjoTv. Kai Tdp fi qpu- cic laiTVUci bid tuiv cujiudTUJV fi)udc, iv' ii dKaTe'pujv F luepoc XapoOca Kai cuTX^txca koiv6v djU(poTe'poic drro- buj t6 T€vvuu|uevov , ujctc jurib' CTepov biopicai juribe
20 biaKpTvai t6 ibiov fj t6 dXXoTpiov. auTTi Toivuv Kai XprijudTUJV KOivujvia TTpocfiKei |udXicTa toTc TaiuoOciv ek juiav ouciav TrdvTa KaTaxeaiuevoic Kai dva|uiSaci |ufi t6 luepoc ibiov koi t6 juepoc dXXoTpiov dXXd TTdv ibiov fiTeTc9ai Kai iiY]bkv dXXoTpiov. ujCTrep t«P t6
25 Kpd|ua KaiToi ubaTOC M^^exov TtXeiovoc oTvov KaXoO- juev, ouTUJ Tfiv ouciav beT koi t6v oTkov toO dvbpoc XeTec9ai, Kdv fi T^vfi TrXeiova cujupdXXriTai.
21. OiXottXoutoc fi '€Xevri, qpiXfibovoc 6 TTdpic* cppovijuoc 6 'Obucceuc, ciOcppujv f\ TTriveXoTTri. bid
1, 416-4I7H. 6, 530-632E.
5. TTXdTUJv] Rep. V. p. 462 C 6. Koi t6 Stobaeus
Floril. LXXIV 43: Kai 12. kuXov*: juaXAov 24. yap*
Plutarcbi Moralia. Vol. I. 21
322 CONIUGALIA PRAECEPTA
141 toOto naKctpioc yoimoc 6 toutujv Kai ZiriXiuToc, 6 b' eKeivujv MXidba KaKuJv "€\Xr|ci Kai pappdpoic e- TTOiricev.
22. '0 'Puj|aaToc utt6 tuiv qpiXujv vou0€TOU|Lievoc 8ti cuucppova YuvaiKa Kai TrXouciav Kai ujpaiav dTre- 5 TTe')nv|jaTO , Tov KdXTiov auToTc TTpOTeivac 'Kai Tdp oijToc' ecpri *KaX6c ibeTv Kai Kaivoc, dXX' oubeic oTbev OTTOu )Lie 9Xiper. beT toivuv ^r\ rrpoiKi iuribe fevei |ur|be KdXXei Trjv TUvaTKa TTiCTeueiv, dXX' ev oic dTTTeTai |Lid- XicTa ToO dvbpoc, 6)LiiXiqi Te Kai fj9€i Kai cujaTrepiqjopa, lo TaOTa )Lifi CKXripd jari^' dvituvTa Ka9' fi)Lie'pav dXX' eudp-
B )iOCTa Ktti dXuTTa Kai TrpocqjiXfi TTape'xeiv. uiCTTep Ydp 01 IttTpoi Touc eg amujv dbf|XuJV Kai KaTd |aiKp6v cuX- X€TO)Lie'vujv Y€vvuj|uevouc TTupeTOuc judXXov beboiKaciv fi Touc ^)Liq)aveTc Kai )aeYdXac Trpoqjdceic exovTac, i5 ouTUJ Td Xav0dvovTa touc ttoXXouc juiKpd Kai cuvexn Kai Ka9ri)Liepivd TTpocKpou)uaTa Y^vaiKoc Kai dvbp6c )aaXXov biicTnci Kai Xu)aaiveTai Tfjv cujapiujciv.
23. '0 paciXeuc OiXiTTTTOC fjpa GeccaXfic yuvaiK^c aiTiav exoucrjc KaTaqjapjuaKeueiv auTov. ecTTOubacev 20 ouv f) 'OXu)LiTTidc XapeTv Tfjv dv9pujTT0v uTTOxeipiov- ujc b' eic oqjiv eX9o0ca t6 Te elboc euTrpeTTfic eq)dvri Kai bieXex9ri TTp6c auTfiv ouk dYevvuJc oub' dcuve-
C Tujc, ' xcipcTujcav ' eiTrev n 'OXujumdc 'ai biapoXai' cu Ydp ev ceauTi^ Td cpap^am exeic'. djuaxov ouv 25 Ti YVYveTai TTpdYlua Y«M^T^n Tuvfi Kai v6)ui|uoc, dv ev ^auTrj Trdvta 9£)uevri, Kai TrpoTKa Kai ygvoc Kai q)dp- luaKa Ktti t6v KecTov auTov, fi9ei Kai dpeTf) KaTepYd- criTai Tfiv euvoiav.
1, 417-418 B., 6, 532— 534K.
6. KdXTiov impressi: K<i\Kiov 27. ^auT^ Stobaeus
Floril. LXXIV 47: afiTiJ
CONIUGALIA PRAECEPTA 323
24. TTdXiv f] 'OXu/aTTidc, auXiKoO xivoc veavicKOu YrnnavTOc euTTpeTrfj YuvaiKa KaKoic dKOuoucav, *ou- Toc' emev 'ouk exei XoYic)a6v ou Ydp av toTc 6<peaX)iioTc ifriixe'. &eT fce juf) toTc oiu^aci YaM^iv
5 ^r]be toTc 6aKTuXoic, ujCTrep evioi vpiiq)icavTec u6ca (pe'poucav Xajupdvouciv, ou KpivavTec ttuic cuiupia»- D Qoyiivr\v.
25. *0 CujKpdTric CKeXeue tujv koTTTpiZojae^vujv veavicKUJV touc |aev aicxpouc eTravop0ouc6ai tv] dpe-
10 Tri , Touc be KaXouc iuri KaTaicxuveiv Tiii KaKia t6 ei- boc. KaXov ouv Kai Tfjv oiKobecTTOivav , 6Tav iv TaTc Xepciv ex»;] t6 ecoTiTpov, auTrjv eauTf] biaXaXeTv, t^v juev aicxpdv 'ti ouv, dv jufj cu)(ppujv Tcvujjiai;' Tfjv be KaXf|V *Ti ouv, av Kai cujcppujv "^ivujfxai;' Tr| Ycip
15 aicxpa ce)uv6v ei cpiXeTTai bid t6 fjGoc f| t6 KdXXoc.
26. TaTc Aucdvbpou GuYaTpdciv 6 Tupavvoc 6 CiKeXiK6c i)LidTia Kai TrXoKia tujv TroXuTeXiijv eTtejLi- ipev 6 be Aucavbpoc ouk eXa^ev eiTrujv 'TaOTa Td E Kocjuia KaTaicxuveT juou )udXXov fi Koc|uf|cei Tdc 6u-
20 YaTe'pac '. rrpoTepoc be Aucdvbpou CoqjOKXfic toOto eiTiev
'ou KOCjuoc, ouK, iu tXtijuov, dXX' dKOCjuia (paivoiT' dv eivai coiv tc ^uapYOTric cppevujv'. 'k6c)uoc Ydp ecTiv', ujc eXeYe KpdTric, 't6 kocjuoOv'* 25 KOCjueT be t6 K0C)uiujTepav YVJvaTKa ttoioOv. TTOieT be ToiauTrjV ouTe xpuc6c outc cjudpaYboc out€ kokkoc, a\y oca ce^uvoTriTOC euTaHiac aiboOc e)uq)aciv rrepi- Ti0riciv.
27. Oi Tr) YOMilXia eOovTec "Hpci Tf)V XO^HV ou .
1, 418-419H. 6, 534-525B
12. auTi?iv Reiskius: auTr)v Iv 20. Coq>OK\f\c]
Nauck. p. 249
21*
324 COiNlUGALIA PRAECEPTA
F cuTKaBaYiCouci toic 6tXXoic iepoTc, dXV eEeXovrec eppivjjav Trapd tov ^{jjjxov, aiviTTO)Li^vou toO vo|ao- G^TOu t6 |Lir|be7T0Te beiv xo^HV Wb* 6pYnv fajnu Tiap- eivai. bei Yoip eivai ttic oiKobecTroivric ujCTrep oivou t6 aucTtipov ibcpeXi)aov Kai f)bu, laf) TtiKpov ujcirep 5 dXoTic, jaribe (pap^aKu»bec.
28. '0 nXdTiuv TLu EevoKpdTei papuT^puj t6 fi9oc ovTi TciXXa bk KaXuJ KdTa6Lij TrapeKeXeueTO Gueiv TaTc Xdpiciv. oT|Liai bx] Kai Tfl ctucppovi indXicTa beTv Trpoc
142 t6v dvbpa xciplTiuv, iv', ujc ^Xeye MriTpobuupoc, fibeujc lo cuvoiKrj Kai '^r] opTiZoiievr) oti couqppoveT*. beT ydp |Lir|T€ Tfjv euTeXfi Ka6api6TTiTOc dineXeTv jiriTe Tfjv (piX- avbpov q)iXoqppocuvric" iToieT ydp fi x«^eTT6Tric dribfi TfjV euTaHiav Tfjc YuvaiKOc, ujCTrep f] puTrapia thv dtpeXeiav. is
29. 'H (popou)Lie'vTi ye^dcai Trp6c t6v dvbpa Kai TTaTSai ti, iva infi qpavrj epaceTa Kai dKoXacToc, oubev biacpepei Tfjc iva lufi boKfi |uupi2ec6ai Tfjv KecpaXfjv jiTib' dXei(po|Lievr|C, Kai iva |afi (puK0uc6ai t6 ttpocujttov laribe viTTTO|LievTic. 6pu))Liev be Kai TTOiTiTdc Kai ^fjTO- 20 pac, 6coi qpeuTOuci t6 Trepi Tfiv \ih\ 6xXik6v Kai ^
B dveXeu6epov Kai KaKoZiriXov, toTc rrpdTliaci Kai TaTc oiKOVoiaiaic Kai toTc fj6eciv dTeiv Kai KiveTv t6v dKpoa- Tfjv cpiXoTexvouvTac. bi6 beT Kai Tfjv oiKobecTTOivav TTav To TrepiTT6v Kai TravriTupiK6v Ka\ ^TaipiKov, eij 25 TTOioOcav, qpeuTeiv Kai TTapaiTeTc6ai, ladXXov bk <piXo- TexveTv ev TaTc ii6iKaTc Kai piuuTiKaTc x«Pici Trp6c t6v dvbpa, Tuj KaXuj |ae6' fibovfjc cuve6iZ:oucav au-
■ Tov. dv b' dpa cpucei tic aucTripd Kai dKpaToc t^- vrjTai Kai dvfjbuvTOC, euTVUJ|LioveTv beT t6v dvbpa, 30
I, 410-420H. 6,535— 537E,
17. TraiEai W: TTpSEai
I
CONIUGALIA PRAECEPTA 325
Ktti KaGctTTep 6 <t)iJUKiajv, toO 'AvTmdTpou rrpaHiv au- Tiij TTpocTaTTOVTOc ou KaXrjv oube TrperroucaV; eiTrev 'ou buvacai laoi Kai cpiXuj xPHcQai Kai KoXaKi', outw C XofiZiecGai Tiepi thc ciufppovoc Kai aucTnpac YuvaiKoc 5 ' ou buvaiuai Tfj auTrj Kai d)c TCiMeTrj Kai ujc eTaipa cuveTvai*.
30. TaTc AiYUTTTiaic uTtobiiiLiaci xPncQ"» TrdTpiov ouK f^v, oTTiuc ev oiKUJ &iTi)Liepeucujci. toiv be TrXei- CTUJV TuvaiKUJV av uTTobrmaTa bidxpuca TrepieXric Kai
10 vpeXXia Kai TtepicKeXibac Kal Ttopcpupav Kai juapYapi- Tac, evbov laevouciv.
31. 'H Geavd» Trapecprive Triv xexpa TtepipaXXo- |n^vn t6 i|adTiov, eiTTovToc be tivoc 'KaXoc 6 Trfi- Xuc', 'dXX' ou briMOCioc' ecpx]. bei bk |Lif) jLtovov
15 Tov TTfixuv dXXd iuribe tov Xoyov bri|Li6ciov etvai Tfic D cuuqppovoc, ** Tiiv (puivrjv ujc dTTOTU|nvujciv aibeT- cGai Kai cpuXdTTecGai rrpoc touc eKToc* IvopaTai Tdp auTrj Kai TrdGoc Kai ii0oc Kai bidGecic XaXoucric
32. Triv 'HXeiujv 6 Oeibiac 'AqppobiTrjv eTioirice 20 xeXuuvriv rraToOcav , oiKOupiac cujliPoXov TaTc TuvaiHi
Kai ciujTTTic. beT Tdp f| Trpoc tov dvbpa XaXeTv f| bid ToO dvbpoc, laii bucxepaivoucav ei bi' dXXoTpiac TXiJuccr]C ujCTTep auXriTfic qpGe^TTcrai ce/iVOTepov.
33. Oi TrXoucioi Kai oi paciXeTc TiiuuJVTec touc 25 (piXococpouc auTOuc Te KOC)aoOci KdKeivouc, oi be qji-
Xdcoqpoi Touc rrXouciouc 9epaTreuovT€C ouk eKeivouc E TToioOciv evboEouc dXX' auToijc dboHoTe'pouc. toOto cunPaivei Kai Trepi Tdc TuvaTKac. uTroTdTTOucai juev Tdp dauTdc toTc dvbpdciv ^TraivoOvTai, KpaTcTv bk
1, 420— 422H. 6, 537-339R.
13. ei-rrdvTOC bi tivoc Stobaeus Floril. LXXIV 49: tivoc b' ciTrovTDC 16. Hiatum significavi
320 CONIUGALIA PRAECEPTA
pouXojLievai laaXXov tujv Kpaiouju^vujv dcxn^ovoOci. KpateTv be bei tov avbpa Tfic TuvaiKoc oux ibc be- CTTOTnv KTr|)LiaTOc dXX' ibc ipuxnv ciOjiaToc, cu)iTTa9o0v- Ta Kai cu/uiTreqpuKOTa tiq euvoiqi. ujcTrep ouv cuuiaaToc ecTi Kr|bec9ai ixx] bouXeuovTa toTc fjbovaTc auToO Kai 5 KaTc eTri9u)uiaic, outuj YuvaiKoc ctpxeiv eucppaivovTa Ktti xap\l6ixe\/ov.
34. Tujv cujjidTUJV o\ q)iX6co(poi Td )aev ^k bie- F CTUJTUJV XeTOuciv eivai Ka9dTT€p ctoXov Kai cTpaTO-
TTebov, Td b' ^K cuvarrTOiuevujv ujc oiKiav Kal vaOv, lo Td b' f]vuj)Lte'va Kai cu)iqpud Ka9dTrep tujv Zujujv €Ka- CTOv. cxebov ouv Kai YdMOc 6 laev tujv epuOvTUJV nvuj)Lievoc Kai cu/iqpuric kTiv, 6 be tuliv bid TrpoiKac f| Te'Kva Ta)iOuvTUJV ^k cuvafrTOjievujv, 6 hk xww. ** cuTKa9eub6vTujv eK biecTuuTujv , ouc cuvoiKeTv dv tic is dXXriXoic ou cu)iPioOv vo|biic€i€. bei bi, ujCTrep oi 143 cpuciKoi TuJv vfpijjv X^TOuci bi' oXuuv T€ve'c9ai Tfjv Kpdciv, ouTuu TUL)V Ta)iouvTUJV Kai cuj)iaTa Kai xp^llJaTa Kai (piXouc Kai oiKeiouc dvaMiX^fivai bi* dXXf|Xujv. Kai Tdp 6 'PuJMaToc vo|uo9eTric dKuOXuce buupa bibovai 20 Kai Xajupdveiv rrap' dXXf|Xujv touc T€Ta)iTiK6Tac , oux iva )iribev6c )ieTaXa)iPdvujciv , dXX' \'va TTdvTa KOivd vojuiZ^uuciv.
35. '€v AeTTTei Tf^c AipOric TToXei rrdTpidv dcTi tQ )ieTd Tov Td)iOV fm^pa Tfjv vu)iq)riv trpoc rfiv toO 25 vuiicpiou ^TiT^pa rr^jLivpacav alT€tc9ai x^Tpav f) b* ou bibujciv oube qpriciv exeiv, ^ttujc ^tt' dpxnc ^tti- CTa)aev»T t6 Tfjc ^Kupdc )iTiTpuiuubec , fiv ucTepdv ti cu)iPaivr) TpaxuTepov, lif) dTavaKTf) }JLr]bk bucKoXaivri.
],422H. C, 539-510 R
11. xaedTrep*: KaQdTrcp icrl 14. Hiatum siguavi.
Excidisse videtur i^ibovfic fveKO
CONIUGALIA PRAECEPTA 327
toOto bei YiYVuucKoucav Trjv YuvaiKa Gepaireueiv thv TTpoqpaciv ecTi be iriXoTUTTia Tfic nrjTpoc uirep euvoiac B Trpoc auTHV. eepatreia be )nia toO 7Td9ouc ibia |aev euvoiav tuj dvbpi TroieTv Trpoc dauTnv, Tfjv be |uriTp6c 5 juf) TrepicTTdv ^Y\b' eXaTTouv.
36. Touc uloOc boKoOci ludWov dtaTTdv ai |ir|Te- pec wc buvajuevouc auTaic poriQeiv, oi be rraTepec Tdc 9uYaTepac dic beo|uevac auTujv poriOouvTtuv ■ icujc hk Kai Ti|u^ Tf) TTpoc dXXf|Xouc 6 eTepoc t6 |udX-
10 Xov oiKeiov Tuj eTepuj pouXeTai )udXXov dcTraZ!6|uevoc Ktti dTaTTUJV q)avep6c elvai. Kai toOto |u^v Vcujc dbid- <pop6v ^cTiv, ^KeTvo b' dcTeTov, dv f) fvvx] ludXXov dTTOKXivaca Tfj Ti^f) Trp6c touc Yove'ac toO dvbp6c r| Touc ^auTfjc pXemiTai, Kdv ti XuTrfiTai, Trp6c ^Keivouc C
15 dvaqpepouca, touc b' auTfic Xav9dvouca. rroieT Yap Ktti t6 TTiCTeueiv boKeTv TricT€uec9ai, Kai t6 <piXeTv q)iXeTc9ai.
37. ToTc Trepi t6v KOpov "GXXnci TrapfiYYeiXav oi CTpaTriYOi Touc rroXeiuiouc, dv |uev poujvTec dTriujci,
20 bdxec9ai )ueTd ciujTrfjc, dv b' eKeivoi ciujttujciv, au- Touc |U€Td pofic dvTegeXauveiv. ai be voOv Ixo^cai YuvaTKec ev TaTc opYaTc twv dvbpuuv KeKpaYOTUJV |uev flcuxdZiouci , ciuunOuvTac be TrpocXaXoOcai Kai rrapaiuu- 9ou)uevai KaTaTrpauvouciv.
25 38. 'Op9ujc 6 €upiTribric aiTidTai touc Tf) Xupa D Xpujjuevouc Trap' oivov ebei Ydp erri Tdc opYdc Kai Td Trev9ri )udXXov Triv )uouciKfiv rrapaKaXeTv f\ rrpoc- eKXueiv Touc ev TaTc fjbovaTc ovTac. vo^uiZieTe ouv ij)ueTc djuapTdveiv touc fjbovfic eveKa cuYKa9eubovTac
1, 422— 424H. 6, 540-542R-
11. dbidqpopov Reiskius: bidiqpopov 25. €C»pini6ric]
Med. 190
328 CONIUGALIA PRAECEPTa
dXXnXoic, oTttv b' ev ^pTrj Tivi TevujVTai Kai bta- (popa, xiJupic dvanauoiaevouc Kai ixr\ TOTe |ndXiCTa Tfjv 'AcppobiTriv TTapaKaXoOvTac , laTpov oucav tujv toi- ouTUJV dpicTriv. ujc ttou Ktti 6 iroiriTfic bibdcKei, Triv "Hpav TTOioiv Xeyoucav 5
*Kai c(p' ciKpiTa veiKea Xucuj E eic euvf|V dve'caca 6)auj9fivai cpiXoTriT»'.
39. 'Aei iLiev bei Kai TravTaxou qpeufeiv t6 rrpoc- Kpoueiv to» dvbpi Tfiv YuvaiKa Kai t\) YuvaiKi tov fivbpa, judXiCTa bk q)uXdTTec6ai toOto TTOieTv ev tuj 10 cuvavaTTauec0ai Kai cuTKaGeubeiv. f\ )aev Ydp lubi- vouca Kai bucqjopoOca TTp6c touc KaTaKXivovTac au- Tfiv eXete 'ttujc b' av x] kXivti TaOTa Geparreuceiev oic im TTic KXivric TTepieTTecov ; * dc b' fj kXivti Ycvva bm- (popdc Kai Xoibopiac Kai opTdc, ou pdtbiov ecTiv ev 15 dXXuj TOTTUJ Kai xpovuj biaXuefivai.
40. 'H '€p)ai6vri boKcT ti Xe'Teiv dXriGk XeTOUca F 'KaKuJv TvJvaiKuJv eicoboi ^' dTruiXecav'.
toOto b' oux dTrXujc TiTv6|uev6v ecTiv, dXX* oTav a\ TTp6c Touc dvbpac biacpopai Kai JriXoTUTTiai toTc toi- 20 auTaic TuvaiHi mh Tdc Gupac |u6vov dXXd Kai Tdc dKodc dvoiTUJCi. t^tc ouv beT iudXtCTa Tfjv voOv exoucav dTTOKXeieiv Td uiTa Kai qpuXdTTecBat t6v vpt- 6uptc|a6v, iva )ufi TrOp eTTi TrOp Tevr|Tat , Kai TTp6xetpov ^Xeiv To ToO OiXiTiTrou. XeTeTai Totp ^KeTvoc utt6 25 Tujv qpiXujv TTapoHuv6)Lievoc eTri touc "GXXrivac ujc eu TrdcxovTac Kai KaKuic auTov Xe^TOVTac emeTv 'ti ouv, dv KaKUJC TTOiujjuev auTOuc;' oTav oijv ai biapdXXou- cai XeTUJCiv oti 'XurreT ce qpiXoOcav 6 dvfip Kai cuj-
1,424H. 6, 542-543R,
4. 6 TroiriTiic] = 206 209 13. fiv idem: Sc 18.
Eurip. Andr. 930 28. flv*: Qv Kai
d
CONIUGALIA PRAECEPTA 329
(ppovoOcav', *Ti oijv, av mceiv auTov ap2u)|Liai Kail44 dbiKeiv ; '
41. '0 Tov bpaTreTrjv ibibv bid xpovou Kai biiu- Kujv, lijc KaTeqpuTC cpGdcac eic |uu\iuva, 'ttoO b' av'
5 eq)n *ce laaXXov eupeiv epouXri9r|v ii evTaOGa;' '^v\y\ Toivuv bid Jri^OTUTTiav diroXeiiiiiv fp6.q>ovca Kai xa- XeTTuJc exouca XeTeTuj TTpoc ^auTrjv 'ttoO f av r\ tx]' XoOcd |ae ladXXov fjcGeiri 9eaca|uevr| Kai ti TroioOcav il XuTTOU|aevriv Kai cTacidZoucav Trpoc tov dvbpa Kai 10 Tov oTkov Kai Tov 9dXa)Liov TTpoieiuevriv ; '
42. *A9r|vaioi TpeTc dpoTouc lepouc ciyouci, Trpo»- Tov ini CKipuj, ToO TTaXaiTdTOu tOuv crropujv utto- B fivriiua, beuTepov ev Tr| 'Papiqt, TpiTOv urro ttoXiv tov KaXou)Lievov BouZuyiov. toutujv be TrdvTUJV lepiuTepoc
15 ecTiv 6 faMn^ioc CTropoc Kai dpoTOc iixx Traibujv t€- KViOcei. KaXujc Trjv "AqppobiTriv 6 CocpoKXfic 'euKap- TTOv Ku9epeiav' TTpocrjfopeuce. bio bei ludXiCTa tou- Tuj xpnc9ai |ueT' euXapeiac tov dvbpa Kai Tfjv tuvai- Ka, tu)V dviepujv Kai Trapav6|uujv Trpoc lTe'pouc dtveu-
20 ovTac 6|uiXiu)V, Kai lur) crreipovTac eH iliv oubev auToTc q)uec9ai 9eXouciv dXXd Kdv tevriTai KapTToc aicxuvov- Tai Kai dTTOKpurrTouct.
43. ropYiou ToO ^HTopoc dvaYVovToc ev 'OXuju- TTict XoTov Trepi 6|uovoiac toTc "CXXriciv 6 MeXdv9ioc
25'oi5TOc fi|uTv' ^qpn * cu|uPouXeu€i irepi 6|uovoiac, 6c 0 auTov Kai Triv fuvaTKa Kai Tfjv ^epdTraivav ibia Tpeic ovTac ojuovoeTv ou TreTreiKev'. ^v fap ujc Ioik^ tic
1 , 424—425 H. 6, 543—545 R.
1. Tt oOv] Excidit <pric€t fiv*: flv Kal 10. oTkov*:
oiKov auTov 13. it6\iv Xylander: ttAiv 14. i€pUj-
Tepoc Madvigius: (cpujTaToc 16. CoqpoKXf^c] Nauck. p, 249
24. MeXdvBioc Xylander: |a^\av0oc
330 CONIUGALIA PRAECEPTA
^puuc ToO ropTiou Kai ZriXoTUTTia Tfic YuvaiKoc irpoc t6 GepaTTaivibiov. eu toivuv fipiuocjaevov tov oikov elvai bei tuj lueXXovTi dpinoTTecBai ttoXiv Kai dtTopav Kai q)iXouc" jaaXXov Tctp eoiKe Td tu»v YuvaiKuuv fl Td TTpoc yuvaiKac d)aapTfmaTa Xav9dveiv touc 5 rroXXouc.
44. €1 Ka9dTrep tov aiXoupov 6b|Liirj iuupuuv CKTa- pdTTec9ai Ka\ )aaivec9ai XeTouciv, outuj toc TuvaiKac
D dTpictiveiv Kai TTapaq)poveiv utto liupujv cuvepaive, beivov ^v fifj dTTex€c9ai inupou touc dvbpac, dXXd lo br fjbovfjv auTUJV ppaxeiav outu) KaKouinevac tt€p»- opav. inei toivuv TaOTa TTdcxouciv ou |aupiZ;o|Lie'vu)v Tuiv dvbpOuv dXXd cuttiTVO)li^vu)v ^T^paic, dbiKov lcTiv fibovnc 'evem jiiKpdc ^tti tocoOto XuttcTv Kai cuvTapdTTeiv Tdc TuvaiKac Kai iuri, Ka9dTT€p Taic ine- 15 XiTTaic, a'i boKoOci bucxepaiveiv Kai |adxec9ai toTc | peTd TuvaiKuiv T€VOMevoic, dTvouc Kai Ka9apeuovTac i dT^pujv cuvouciac TTpoci^vai TaTc TUvaiHiv. 1
45. Oi TTpocidvTCC iXicpaciv k^fjTa XaiuTTpdv ou Xa|Lipdvouciv, oube (poiviKibac 01 Taupoic biaTpiaive- 20
E Tai Tdp UTTO Tuiv xP^MaTwv toutu)V ladXicTa Td Zuja" Tdc be TiTpeic q)ac\ TT€piTUjUTTavi2[o|uievac ^K|Liaivec9ai TTavTdTTttCi Ka\ biacTTdv dauTdc. eTTe\ Toivuv Kai tuiv dvbpuiv 01 |Li^v ^c9fiTac KOKKivac Ka\ rropq^updc opiuv- Tec bucavacxcToOciv , o'i be KUjLipdXoic Ka\ TujjTTdvoic 25 dx9ovTai, Ti beivdv dTTex€c9ai toutu)v Tdc TUvaTKac Ktti |Lifi TapdTTeiv |nri^€ TTapoHuveiv touc dvbpac, dXXd cuveTvai laeT' eucTa9eiac Ka\ TrpaoTriToc;
46. ruVrj Tic TTpoc t6v <l>iXmTT0v dKOucav icpeX-
1,425-42CH. 6. 545-546B.
4. tocoOto Eeiskius: TocouTqj 16. ai*: 6ti
CONIUGALIA PRAECEPTA 331
k6|U€V0V auTrjv 'aqpec ne' eme* 'iraca Yuvf] toG Xu- Xvou dpGevTOc f) auTri ecTi'. toOto Trpoc touc moi- F XiKOuc Ktti dKoXdcTouc eipriTai KaXOuc, ttiv be fa^xe- ir\\ bei ladXiCTa toO (pujToc dp0evToc eivai ixr\ ir]v 5 auTriv TaTc Tuxoucaic TuvaiHiv, dXXd qpaivecGai toO cuujuctTOC /ifi pXerroiaevou t6 cu/cppov auTfic Kai ibiov Tuj dvbpi Kai UTroTeTaTMevov Kai q)iX6cTopTOV.
47. '0 TTXdTUJv toTc rrpecpuTaic ludXXov trap^vei aicxuvecGai touc veouc, iva KdKeTvoi irpoc auTouc
10 aibrmovujc exiuciv 'ottou' ydp 'dvaicxuvToOci fi- povTCc', oubeiaiav aibuj toTc veoic oub' euXdpeiav eTYiTveceai. toutou beT |ue)Livri)uevov tov dvbpa |uri- beva iLiaXXov aibeTc0ai Tfjc YuvaiK6c, dic tov 0dXa- ^ov auT^ bibacKaXeTov euTaHiac fi dKoXaciac Ycvrico- 145
15 /aevov. 6 be tiLv auTujv fjbovujv auToc laev drro- Xauujv eKeivrjv b' drroTpdTrujv oub^v biaqpe'pei toO KeXeuovToc bia)udxec0ai Tfiv YuvaTKa Trpoc touc TToXe- laiouc, oTc auToc ^auT6v TtapebujKe.
48. TTepi be qpiXoKocjuiac cu juev, oi €upubiKr|, 20 Td Trpoc 'ApicTuXXav utt6 Ti)uoHevac YeYP«MMeva
TTeipuj bia|ivr||uoveueiv • cu be, iu TToXXiave, fifi v6- luiiZie TTepiepYiac dq)eHec0ai Tfiv YuvaTKa Kai TToXuTe- Xeiac, dv 6pa ce ^x) KaTacppovouvTa toutujv ev ^tc- poic, dXXd Kai x«ipovTa xpwcouceciv eKTruj)udTUJV Kai B 25 YpacpaTc oiKTDuaTiwv Kai xXibujciv f])ai6vujv Kai ittttujv TTepibepaioic. ou Yap ecTiv dHeXdcai Tf^c YuvaiKUJvi- Tiboc ^v laecri Tr) dvbpujviTibi Tfiv TToXuT^Xeiav dva- CTpecpoiuevnv.
1, 426—427 H. 6, 546—548 E.
7. fjiroTeTaYM^vov Reiskius : TeTOYia^vov 8. TTXdTUiv]
Legg. p. 729 C 20. YtTPOMM^va*: yefpafJL^iva dvaYvoOca
25, x^i^uJCiv Stephanus: x^'&iJt;ceciv
332 CONIUGALIA PRAECEPTA
Kai cu |Liev ijjpav ^x^^ Ti&ri qpiXocoqpeiv toic |LieT* dTTobeiHeujc Kai KaTacKeufic XeTOjuevoic eTriKociuei t6 f\Qoc, evTUTXdvuuv Kai irXricidCtuv toic ujqpeXoOcv Trj be TuvaiKi TravTax60ev t6 XPHCIMOV cuvdToiv uic- TTep ai jueXiTTai Kai cpe'pujv auT6c ev ceauTu; iueTabi- s bou Kai TrpocbiaXeTou, (piXouc auTr) ttoiujv Kai cuv-
C riGeic tuiv Xotujv touc dpicTOuc. TtaTfip iuev Tdp '^cci* auTrj 'Kai TtoTvia MnTrip r\he. KaciTvrjTOc'" oux fJTTov be ce)Liv6v dKOucai TaineTfic XeToucric 'dvep, ' dTdp cu )aoi ecci ' Ka0r|TriTr)C Kai ^iXocoqpoc Kai bi- lo bdcKaXoc Tujv KaXXicTUJV Kai 0eioTdTUJv'. Td be TOiauTa |Lia0r|)LiaTa TrpujTOV dcpicTrici tuiv dTOTrujv Tdc TuvaiKac* aicxuv0ticeTai Tdp 6pxeTc0ai Tuvfi T€Uj|Lie- Tpeiv )iav0dvouca, Kai q)ap)adKUJV ^Ttujbdc ou Trpoc- be£eTai toic TTXdTUJVOc ^Traboiiievri Xotoic Kai toTc is EevoqpuJVTOc. av be tic iTtaTTeXXriTai Ka0aipeTv ti^v ceXrivrjV, T^XdceTai Tfiv djua0iav Kai Tfjv dpeXTepiav Tuiv TauTa TTei0o)Lie'vujv TuvaiKUJV, dcTpoXoTiac /if) dvriKoujc 4'xouca Kai Trepi 'ATXaoviKrjc dKr^KOuTa Tqc 'HTnTopoc ToO GeccaXoO 0uTaTp6c 6ti tuiv ^KXei- 20
D TTTiKUJV liiTTeipoc ouca rravceXfivujv Kai TTpoeibuTa t6v xpovov ev il> cu|upaivei Tfjv ceXfivnv utt6 ttic CKiac dXicKec0ai, rrapeKpoueTO Kai cuveTrei0e Tdc tu- vaiKac ujc auTfi Ka0aipoOca Tfjv ceXfjvriv. Traibiov |aev Tdp oubefiia ttot^ Tuvfj XeTeTai Kufjcai bixa 25 KOivujviac dvbpoc, Td b' djLiopqpa KufijLiaTa Kai cap- K6eibfi Kai cucTaciv ^v iauToTc ck biaqp0opac Xa^- pdvovTa ji^^ctc KaXoOci. toOto hr\ 9uXaKTe'ov dv TaTc vjJUxaTc TiTV€C0ai tu)V T^vaiKuiv. dv Tdp Xotujv
427— 429 H. 6, 548- 550 R
7. TTarr^p] Homer. Z 429 19. 'ATXaoviKrjc Reiskius:
(iTav(Kric 25. KUficai W: Ttoificai
4
CONJUGALIA PRAECEPTA 333
XpricTuiv cirepiaaTa [xi] bexwvTai ^itibe koivujvijuci uai- beiac ToTc dvbpdciv, auTai Ka6' auTdc ctTOTra TroXXd E Kai cpaOXa pouXeiJ)iaTa Kai TrdGn kuouci. cu b\ (h €upubiKri, jidXiCTa Treipu) toTc tujv cocpujv Ka\ dYa-
5 eOijv YuvaiKuuv dTToqpGeTjuttciv oiuiXeTv Kai bid CTOiaa- toc dei Tdc cpujvdc ^xeiv dKeivac u»v Kai TtapGevoc ouca Tiap* fiiLiTv dveXdjapavec, ottujc euqppaivi;ic |ufev Tov dvbpa, 6au|LidZ;ri b' utto tu)v dXXuJv TuvaiKuiv, ouTuj KOC)Liou|uevri TrepiTTuJc Kai cejuvOuc dTTO lunbevoc.
10 Touc juev Tdp Tficbe ttic TiXouciac |uapTapiTac Kai Td Tncbe Tfic Hevr|c cripiKd Xa^eTv ouk ^ctiv oub^ Tiepi- 6ec6ai luf) ttoXXou TTpia|uevriv, Td bk GeavoOc Kociuia Kai KXeopouXivTic Kai fopToOc Tfic Aeujvibou TuvaiKOc Kai Ti)uoKXeiac Tfic GeaTevouc dbeXqpfic xai KXaubiac P
15 Tfic TTaXaidc Kai KopvnXiac Tfic CKiTTiuivoc Kai ocai CTevovTO 6au|uacTai Kai TrepipoTiToi, TaOTa b* eEecTi TTepiKeijuevnv TTpoiKa Kai KOC)uou)U€vriv auToTc dvboEujc d^a pioOv Kai luaKapiujc. ei Tdp fi Carrqpuj bid ttiv ^v ToTc )u^Xeci KaXXiTpaqpiav ^qppovei ttiXikoOtov uicTe 14:6
20 Tpdvpai Trpoc Tiva TTXouciav
'KaT6dvoica be Keiceai, oube tic |uva|uocuva ciQev eceTar ou Tdp uebe'x€ic ^obuiv TuJv eK TTiepiac', TTuic ouxi coi )udXXov iHecTai [xifa qppoveiv ^qp' ^au-
25 Tfi Kai Xa)uiTTp6v , Sv )ufi TU)V pobujv dXXd tujv Kap- TTUJV |ieTexr]C, ujv ai MoOcai qpepouciv Kai xapiZiovTai ToTc TTttibeiav Kai ^iXocOqpiav 6au|udZ!ouciv;
1 , 429—430 H. 6, 550—552 R.
18. CaTiqpiw] Bergk. p. 898' 21. KaTGdvoica p. 646 P:
KaTeovoOca 22. ■n€bi\e\c ibidem: Tral6' i^eic
TiiN EHTA 2:04>iiN STMnOSION.
1. *'H TTOu TTpoiujv 6 xp<5voc, ili NiKapxe, noXu cko- Toc indlei toIc 7TpdY|iaci Kai nacav dcdtpeiav, ei vOv dm ixpocqpdTOic outuu koi veapoTc Xotoi vj/eubeic cuv- TeG^VTec ^xo^ci ttictiv. outc Tdp m6vujv, ujc u)ieic
C dKrjKoaTe, tujv ^TiTd yefove Td cujiTTdciov, dXXd s TrXeidvujv f\ bic tocoutujv (iv oic Kai auToc nv, cuv- rjGric Mtv u)v TTepidvbpuj bid Tfjv Texvriv, Hevoc be GdXew Tiap* djioi tdp KOTeXucev 6 dvfip TTepidvbpou KeXeucavToc), ouTe touc Xofouc dpeiuc dTT€|ivriMdveu- cev 6cTic f\v u|iiv 6 biriYouMevoc f\v b' ujc foiKev n oubeic TiiJv TrapaYeYOvoTwv. dXX' dTcei cxoXri tc Trdp- ecTi TToXXfi Kai to THPac ouk dEiOTriCTOV dYYur|cac0ai Tf)v dvapoXf)v ToO Xotou, TTpoeu|Liou|ievoic ujitv dn' dpxnc dTTavTtt biriTncojLiai.
D 2. TTapecKeudKei fi^v Tdp oOk iw tti TToXei Tf|v id unoboxfiv 6 TTepiavbpoc, dXX' iv tuj nepi t6 A^xchov ^CTiaTopiiy napd t6 Tfic 'Aqppobirnc iepov, fic t^v koi f] eucia, ^eTd Tdp tov lpu)Ta ttic )Lir|Tp6c auToO npoe/i^VTic Tov piov dKOuciwc ou TeOuKUJC Trj 'Aqppo-
2, 1—2 H. 6, 5.'>3— j:.1 R.
6, j^v*: r^junv 10. 6 Pflugkius
1
SEPTEM SAPIENTUM CONVIVIUM 335
biir) Toxe TrpuiTOV €'k tivujv Ivuttviujv Tfic MeXiccric ujpiiTice Tijuav kqi GepaTreOeiv ttjv 0e6v. tujv be Ke- KXrme'vuJv ^KdcTUJ cuvujpic kavuuc KeKOCjuril^tvri npoc- rixOn' Kai Y«P "Jpct 6e'pouc fjv, Kai Tr]V obov aTtacav
0 uTTo TTXr|9ouc djiaEuiv Kai dv6pujTru)v ctxpi 6aXdTTTic KOViopToc Kai 06pupoc KaTeixev. 6 luevTOi GaXfic t6 2!e0Yoc eTTi TaTc 0upaic ibuuv Kai lueibidcac dcpfJKev. ePabiZoiaev oijv eKTpaTT6]Lievoi bid tuiv x^wpiujv Ka0' E ficuxiav, Kai )Lie0' fifiuiv TpiToc 6 NauKpaiiTric NeiX6-
10 Hevoc , dvfip dTTi€iKf)c Kai toTc Trepi C6Xujva Kai GaXfiv ■feTOVUJC ev Aituktuj cuvfi0r|c. eTUYXCtve bi TTpoc BiavTa TTdXiv dTrecTaXjaevoc" u)v be xdpiv oub' au- Toc rjbei, rrXfiv uTTevdei TTp6pXr||ua beuTepov auTiI» KO|diZ!eiv ev pipxiiu KaTacecri)iiacjue'vov • eipriTO ydp, ei
15 Biac dTTaTopeuceiev, eTTibeiSai toTc coqpujTdToic '€X- Xf|vu)v t6 pipXiov. 'epiaaiov' 6 NeiXdHevoc e'(pr| 'iiioi TeTovev evTaO0a XapeTv ctTTavTac u|Lidc, Kai ko^H^jj F To pipXiov ujc opdc eTTi to beTTTVov'. d)iia b' fijuTv eTTebeiKvue. Kai 6 GaXfic T^Xdcac 'ei TiKaKov' emev,
2o*au0ic eic TTpifivriv biaXOcei Tdp 6 Biac, ujc bieXu- ce To TTpujTov'. 'ti b' r\v' ecpnv eTU) 'to ttpuitov;' *i€p6Tov' eiTTev 'enejLiHiev auTU), KeXeOcac to ttovti- pdTaTOV eHeX6vTa Kai xP^CT^TaTOv dTTOTTeiuvjjai Kpeac. 6 b' fijueTepoc eu Kai KaXujc Tfiv TXuJTTav eHeXibv
25 dTTeTTe|ui|J€V • 60ev eOboKi)uu)v bfiXOc Icti Kai QavixaZo- 147 )uevoc'. 'oO bid TaOTa' ^cpri '|u6vov' 6 NeiX6Hevoc, *dXX' oO (peOTei to <piXoc eivai Kai XeTec0ai paci- Xeujv Ka0dTrep 0)ieTc, ^Trei coO t^ Kai TclXXa Qav^a- l€\, Ktti TTic TTupajuiboc Tfjv jueTpTiciv Onepqjuujc iiTd-
2, 2— 3H. 6, 554-556 B.
7. Kai delet Hertlinus 10. 0aXf\v*: QA\r\Ta
20. 6U\uce*: 6i^\ucev auxoc 25. dTr^TTe)Livpev*: liTe)LHj;6v
336 SEPTEM
TTricev, 6ti Trdcric aveu TrpaY|iiaTeiac xai laribevoc 6p- Yotvou beT]9eic dXXa ttiv paKTripiav CTrjcac tTri tuj irepaTi ttic CKiac fiv fi Trupajaic eTToiei, Yevoneviuv t)} eTraqpi^ Tfic dKTivoc buoTv TpiYUJVUJV, ebeiHac 6v f\ CKid irpoc Tfjv cKidv Xoyov eixe Tfjv TTupajiiiba Trpoc 5 Tfiv paKTripiav exoucav. dXX', onep eqpriv, biepXf|6ric
B jLticopaciXeuc elvai, Kai Tivec OppicTiKai cou Trepi tu- pdvvuDV dTTO(pdceic dveqpepovTO TTpoc auTov, ujc ^puu- TriOeic UTTO MoXTraYopou toO "Icuvoc Ti TrapaboHoTaTOV eiric dopaKUJC, dTTOKpivaio 'Tupavvov Y^povTa', Kai 10 TrdXiv ev Tivi ttotuj, Trepl eripiiuv Xoyou YevO)iidvou, cpairic KdKicTOv eivai tuuv )aev dYpiuuv 6ripiujv tov Tupavvov, Tuuv b* fiiaepuuv tov KoXaKa* TaOTa Ydp, ei Kai TTdvu TrpocTroioOvTai bia(pe'peiv 01 paciXeic tuuv Tupdvvuuv, ouK eujuevuuc dKOUouciv'. 'dXXd toOto is ILiev* eiTTev 6 OaXfic 'TTiTTaKoO dcTiv eipriiLtevov dv Traibia TroTe TTpoc MupciXov • eYuu be '6au]adcaiju' dv'
C ecpx] 'ou Tupavvov dXXd KuPepvfjTriv Y^povTa 6eacd- laevoc'. TTpoc bk Trjv )LieTd6eciv t6 toO veavicKOu TTeTT0v6a toO paXovToc inev ^tti Tfjv Kuva TraTdHavTOC 20 be Tfjv i^riTpuidv Kai eiTrdvToc 'oub' outuu KaKuuc*. bi6 Kai CoXuuva cocpuuTaTOv fjYricdjLiriv ou beHdiaevov TupavveTv. Kai rTiTTaKOc outoc ei iuovapxia jufi Trpoc- flX6ev, ouK av etTrev ujc ^xaKeTiov icQXov ^iLijLievai'. TTepiavbpoc b* loiKev ujCTrep ev vocfjjuaTi TTaTpiuiu t^ 25 Tupavvibi KaTeiXriiLijLidvoc ou q)auXuuc eSavaqjepeiv, xpui- lievoc 6|uiXiaic vYieivaTc dxpi TC vOv Kai cuvouciac
D dvbpuuv voOv dxovTwv eTraYojuevoc , dc be Gpacupou- Xoc auTUJ KoXouceic tuuv ctKpuJV ou)li6c TroXiTric uqpri- YeiTai |Lif| Ttpoci^iuevoc. Y^uupYoO Ydp aipac Kai aiYi- 3o
2, 3-4 H. 6, 556— 558 B.
30. aipac W: «Ypac aiYiXujTrac*: 6pvi9ac
SAPIENTUM CONVIVIUM 337
Xujirac dvTi TrupuJv Kai KpiGujv cuTKOiniCeiv eGeXovTOC oubev biaqpepei Tupavvoc dvbpaTrobujv inaXXov dpxeiv f) dvbpiuv pouX6)Lievoc • ev xdp dvTi ttoXXuiv KaKU)v dTaedv ai buvacTeiai Tf]v Tijufiv exouci Kai t^v bo-
5 Hav, dvTtep dYaGuJV ujc KpeiTTOvec dpxujci Kai f^eTd- Xujv |LieiZ;ovec eivai boKuJcr Tfjv b' dcqpdXeiav dYa- TTuJvTac dveu toO KaXoO TtpopdTUJv ebei Kai ittttujv Kai poujv dpxeiv, |afi dvGpujTTUJV. dXXd tdp eic ou- bev TtpocriKOVTac e)apepXr|Kev fi)Liac' eqpri '6 Eevoc E
10 ouTOCi XoTouc, djLieXricac XeTeiv Te Kai Zr|TeTv a dp- juoTTei eTTi beiTTVov pabiZiouciv. fi Tdp ouk oTei, Ka- 0dTT€p dcTidcovToc ecTi Tic TTapacKeufi , Ktti beiTTvncov- Toc elvai; CupapiTai iiiev Tdp UJC eoiKe rrpo eviauToO Tdc KXrjceic TcoioOvTai tuuv TuvaiKuiv, ottujc eKTevoiTO
15 KttTd cxoXfiv TTapacKeuacajaevaic ecGfiTi Kai XP^cuJ (poiTav CTTi t6 beiTTvov eTuJ be irXeiovoc oTjaai xpo- vou beicOai Tfjv dXr|9ivfiv toO bemvricovTOC 6p9ujc TrapacKeuriv, oti xaXeTrujTepdv ecTiv fi9ei t6v TtpeTTovTa Kociaov f| ciJujiaTi tov TrepiTTOV eSeupetv Kai dxpncTOv.
20 ou Tdp liic dTTeiov fiKei KOjuiiZiuJV eauTov e/iTTXficai F TTp6c t6 beiTTvov 6 voOv exujv, dXXd Kai cTToubdcai Ti Kai TTaiEai Kai dKoOcai Kai eiTreiv u»v 6 Kaipoc Tta- paKaXei touc cuvovTac, ei iueXXouci |iieT' dXXfjXuiv fibeujc ecec9ai. Kai Tdp Kai 6\\fov TT0vr|p6v ecTi Tra-
25puucac9ai, Kdv oTvoc ^ (paOXoc, ^tti Tdc vuiucpac KaTaqpuTeTv • cuvbeiTTVoc hk KeqpaXaXTnc Kai papuc Kai dvdTUJTOc TravT^r |aev oivou Kai ovpou Trdcric be /iou- coupToO xapiv dTToXXuci Kai XujuaiveTai, Kai oub' dTTejaecai ttiv TOiauTr|v dribiav eTOijuov ecTiv, dXX*
30 dvioic eic dTravTa tov piov e|Li|u€'vei t6 TTp6c dXXri- us
2, 4-5H. ■ 6, 558-5€-,)R.
7. irpopdTUJV*: irpopdTUJv ttoXXuuv 22. ujv W: 6
Plutarchi Moralia. Vol. I. 22
338 SEPTEM
Xouc bucdptCTOv, OucTTep eouXoKpacia tic uppeiuc f\ opTnc ev oTviy Y€VO|Lievric. oGev dpicTa XiXuuv, xa- Xouiaevoc ex6ec, ou TTpoTepov ibiioXofricev f| TtuGe^cGai Tujv KeKXriiaevuuv eKacTOV. eqpn fap oti cu)LiTrXouv dYVuujiova bei qpe^peiv Kai cucktivov ok TrXeiv dvdTKri 5 Kai cTpaTeuecGar to be cuiiiTroTaic eauTov ujc eTuxe KaTajaiTVueiv ou vouv exovToc dvbpoc ecTiv. 6 f AiTUTTTioc CKeXeTOc, ov eTTieiKuuc eiccpepovTec eic Td cu)LiTr6cia TrpoTiGevTai Kai TrapaKaXouci laeiavficGai Tdxcx B bx] ToiouTOuc eco|Lie'vouc , KaiTrep ctxapic Kai dujpoc 10 eTriKUJiaoc tikujv, ojaujc exei Tivd Kaipov, Kai ei }ir] Ttpoc t6 TTiveiv KOi fibuTraGeiv dXXd TTpoc q)iXiav Kai dTdTiriciv dXXrjXujv TrpoTpe^TTCTai , Kai TrapaKaXeT tov piov jufi Tuj XP<^viu Ppaxuv dvTa TrpdTjaaci KaKoic laaKpov TTOieTv'. 15
3. '€v ToiouToic XoToic Tevojaevoi KaTd Tfjv obov d(piK6|Lie0a TTpoc Tfjv oiKiav, Kai XoucacGai juev 6 0a- Xfic ouK ii0eXr]cev, dXriXi)Li|aevoi Tdp fjiaev eTTiujv be Touc Te bpdjaouc dGeaTO Kai Tdc TTaXaicTpac Kai to dXcoc to Trapd Tfjv GdXaccav iKavuJc biaKeKOCiHTme- 20 vov, utt' oubevoc eKTrXr|TT6)aevoc tujv toioutujv, dXX' C oKujc laf) KaTaqjpoveTv boKoir) |urib' uTrepopdv toO TTe- pidvbpou Tfjc (piXoTijuiac. tOuv b' dXXujv tov dXei- Mjd|Lievov 11 Xoucdjuevov o\ 0epdTTOVTec eicfiTOV eic tov dvbpuLiva bid Tfic cToac. 6 b' 'Avdxapcic ev t^ cTod 25 Ka0ficTO, Ktti TTaibicKri TrapeiCTfjKei Tfjv K6|Litiv TaTc xepci biaKpivouca. TauTTiv 6 GaXfic eXeu0€piuuTaTd TTUJc auTuJ Trpocbpaiaoucav eq^iXrice Kai TeXdcac 'outujc' i(pr\ 'rroiei KaXov tov Hevov, ottujc fiiaepuuTaTOC uuv
2, 5— 7H. «, 560— 5C2R,
26. 7Tap€tCTr]Ke»*: irpoeiCTnKCi 27, 6*
i
SAPIENTUM CONVIVIUM 339
ixf] qpopepoc iq tx\v oipiv Y\}xiy mH^' aYpioc'. e)LioO b' epojutvou rrepi Tfic iraiboc iiTic etii, 'Ttiv coqpiiv' eq)r| 'koi 7Tepip6r|Tov dYVoeic €u|LinTiv; toOto xdp auTrjv D 6 iraTfip auToc, oi be ttoXXoi TtaTpoGev ovoiadZouci
5 KXeopouXivrjv'. Kai 6 NeiXoHevoc einev 'f\ ttou Triv Ttepi Td aiviYiaaTa beivoTrjTa Kai coqpiav ' ^(pr) ^Tfjc Kopnc eTraiveic" Kai Tdp eic Aiyutttov evia tOuv rrpo- PaXXo)ae'vujv utt' auTfic biiKTai'. 'ouk eYuuTe' eiTrev 6 GaXfjc" 'toutoic fdp OucTrep dcTpatdXoic, oTav
DTux»], TraiZiouca XP^^ai Kai biapdXXcTai Trpoc toijc evTUXOVTac. dXXd Kai (pp6vri|uia 0au|LiacT6v Kai voOc evecTi TToXiTiKoc Kai q)iXdvGpuuTrov fjGoc , Kai t6v rra- Tepa ToTc TioXiTaic 7Tpa6Tepov dpxovTa Trapexei Kai brmoTiKiuTepov'. 'eiev' 6 NeiX6Sevoc eqpri, 'Kai cpai- E
15 veTai pXeTTOVTi Trpoc tt^v XiT^TrjTa Kai dcpeXeiav au- ' Tiic' 'Avdxapciv be TrdGev outiu TrmeXeT cpiXocT6p- •fojc;' 'oTi' eqpn 'cuucppuuv dvf|p ecTi xai TroXufia9f|C, Ktti Tf|v biaiTav auTfj Kai tov Ka6ap)a6v, uj xpwvTai CKuGai TTpoc Touc KdjLivovTac, dcp96vuuc Kai TTpo9u-
20 jiujc TrapabebuuKe. Kai vOv oi|Liai rrepie^TTeiv auTriv tov dvbpa Kai qpiXoqppoveTc9ai , |uav0dvoucdv ti Kai Trpoc- biaXefOfievriv '. fjbri be ttXticiov ouciv n|uTv toO dv- bptuvoc dTTf|VTricev 'AXeHibri)Lioc 6 MiXficioc (fiv be GpacupouXou toO Tupdvvou v69oc) Kai eH^ei TeTapaf-
23 )nevoc Kai cijv opYfj tivi Trpoc auTov oubev fi|uTv t£ F cacpec biaXeT6)aevoc. ibc be tov GaXfiv eibe, )uiKp6v dveveTKujv Kai KaTacTdc 'oiavuPpiv' eiTTev 'cic fiudc TTepiavbpoc OppiKev, eKTTXeOcai juev ouk Idcac ibpjLiri- fjevov dXXd TTpoc)aeTvai ber|9€ic tu» beiTTVuj, eX96vTi
2, T-SH. 6, 562-564 R.
3. toOto Top auTrjv*: outuu t^P TaOT»iv 19. -TTpoc*:
TTtpi
22*
340 SEPTEM
bi vi^wv KXiciav ati.uov, AioXeac be Kai vriciuiTac Kai Tivac Yap ouxi ©pacupouXou TrpoTijiujv • Opacu- pouXov Tap ^v d|Lioi tov iTeiLivMavTa TrpoTrriXaKicai 149 pouX6)Lievoc Kai KaTapaXeiv bnXoc kTiv'. 'eha' Iqpn 'cO bebiac |Lifi KaSotTTep Aitutttioi touc dcTe'pac uijjuj- 5 ILiaTa Kai TaTreivuuiuaTa XajupavovTac ^v toic tottoic oOc bieSiaci T»TV€c9ai PeXTiovac f\ xeipovac ^auTuiv Xe^TOuciv, ouTUJ Ttepi ce bid tov tottov djiaupujcic f\ TaTteivuJcic TevriTai; Kai toO AdKUJVOC ?cr| (pauXo- Tepoc , 6c ^v xopuJ tivi KaTacTa9eic eic ttjv ecxdTriv lo Xujpav uTto ToO dpxovToc 'eu T€' eiTTev '"eEeupec, UJC Kai auTd ?vti|lioc TtvriTai'. ou KaTaXapovTac ' eqpr) 'tottov laeTd Tivac KaTaKei)Lie9a bei CriTeTv, /LiaX- Xov b' OTTUJC eudpiuiocTOi Toic cuTKaTaK6i|Lievoic ui)Liev, dpxfjv Ktti Xapfiv cpiXiac ev auToTc CtitoOvtgc indXXov i5
B b' exovTec t6 |ufi bucKoXaiveiv, dXX' eTraiveTv 6ti toi- ouTOic cuTKaTeKXivrilnev • ujc 6 fe t6ttuj KXiciac buc- Xepaivujv bucxepaivei tuj cuTKXiTi;i ladXXov f^ tu» k€- KXr|K6Ti , Kai TTpoc djacpoT^pouc drrex^dveTai '. ' X6toc ' €(pr| 'TauTa dXXujc ^ctiv' 6 'AXeSibTiiuoc , 'epTuj be 20 Kai Touc coqpouc ujudc 6puj t6 Ti|Lidc9ai biuuKOVTac', Kai d|aa TTapajueiijjdiaevoc fijudc dTTfiX9e. Kai 6 OaXfic 7Tp6c fmdc Tfjv dTOTTiav ToO dv9pu)TT0u 9au|udJovTac '?|LiTTXriKTOc' ecpri, 'Kai dXX6K0T0c qpucei, ^ttci Kai lueipdKiov €Ti, laupou cTTOubaiou GpacuPouXuj kojlii- c9€VToc, eic ijJUKTfipa KaTCpdcac jueTav Kai TTpoceT-
C xiac OKpaTOV eEemev, ?x9p«v dvTi qpiXiac GpacuPou- Xuj biaTTeTTpaT|Li€VOc'. ^k toutou TTapeX9ujv uTTTipeTric
2, 8-9H. 6, 564— 566 E
4. KaToPaXeiv*: KarapaXetv dic bi\ TrepiopOuv 8. oO-
Tuj W: oOtujc ri 15. Zr|ToOvT€c Reiskius: TriXoOvTec
28. irapeXeibv idem: Tr6pie\9iuv
1
SAPIENTUM CONVIVIUM 341
'KeXeOei ce TTepiavbpoc ' ^qpn *Kai 0a\fiv irapaXaPov- tac toOtov eTncKeipac0ai t6 KeKO|uic)aevov dpTiuuc auTuj iTOTepov aXXuJc TCTOvev r\ rx criiaeTov ecTi Kai Te'pac' auToc laev Ydp loiKe TeTapdxOai cqpobpa, )uiac)na Kai
5 KTiXiba Tfjc Guciac fiYoujaevoc'. ^}ia b' dTTfJYev fijudc eic Ti oiKtiMa toiv Ttepi tov KfjTtov. evTauGa veavi- CKOc ujc eqpaiveTO voiaeuTiKoc, outtuj Y€veiujv dXXujc T€ t6 eiboc ouK dYevvf|c, dvarrTuEac Tivd btq)9e'pav ebeiHev fiiiiv Ppecpoc dic eqpn Y£Tov6c e5 ittttou, Td
10 )aev dvuj nexpi tou TpaxnXou Kai tujv x^ipujv dv- 6pajTT6)aopqpov, Td Xoirrd b' exov ittttou, Tfi be qpujvf) D Kaedrrep Td veoTvd TTaibdpia KXau0)aupiZ6)a€vov. 6 fiev ouv NeiXoHevoc 'AXeHiKaKe' eiTTuiv ' dTTecTpdqpn Tfjv ovyiv', 6 be 0aXnc TTpoce'pXeTre tuj veavicKiu ttoXuv
5r> xpovov, eiTa laeibidcac (eiu)6ei b' dei TTaiZeiv TTpoc e}ik Trepi ttjc Texvric) 'r\ ttou tov Ka6ap)u6v ili Aio- kXcic' ecpn 'KiveTv biavof) Kai TTapexeiv TTpdT)uaTa ToTc dTTOTpoTTaioic, ujc Tivoc beivoO Kai )Lt€TdXou cuji- pdvTOc;' 'Ti be' dTTOv *ou laeXXuj; CTdcewc Tdp, ui
' GaXfi, Kai biaqpopdc t6 cri)LieT6v ecTi, Kai bebia |ufi jaexpi Td)Liou Kai Tcvedc eHiKriTai, TTpiv f| t6 ttpujtov eSiXdcac6ai }xr\vi}JLa, Tfjc 6eo0 beuTcpov ujc 6pac TTpo- qpaivoucric'. Trp6c toOto |ar|bev dTTOKpivdjuevoc 6 E OaXfic dXXd tcXujv dTTrjXXdTTeTO. Kai toO TTepidv-
- bpou TTpoc TaTc 0upaic dTravTficavTOc fi|iTv Kai bia- 7Tu6o)ae'vou TTepi iIjv eibo)aev, dqpeic 6 0aXfic |ie Kai Xapd^evoc Tfic eKeivou X€>Poc eqpri 'a )uev AiOKXfic KeXeuei bpdceic Ka6' ficuxiav ^t^ bi coi TTapaivuj veoic ouTUJ )afi xpfic6ai vojaeOciv 'ittttujv, f\ bibovai
-iOH. 6,566-5688.
1. TrapaXapovTac Reiskius: TrapaXaP6vTa 25. TaTc
eOpaic*: Tctc Gupac
342 SEPTEM
YuvaiKttc auToic'. eboSe inev ouv |lioi tujv Xoyujv dKOucac 6 TTepiavbpoc fic9fivai cqpobpa* Kai Yotp ege- Ye'\ace Kai tov GaXfiv TrepiXaPiJuv KaTricrrdcaTO. Kd- Keivoc 'oTjaai be' elrrev ' ui AiokXeic , Kai Trepac elxe F t6 criiaeiov * opac Yotp n^iKOv KaKov YtTOvev fiiaTv, 5 'AXeHibr||Liou cuvbeirrveTv ixr\ GeXricavTOC '.
4. 'ETtei b' eicr|X9o|aev, fjbri lueTZiov 6 OaXfic (p9eY- Hdiaevoc 'ttoO be' eiTrev '6 dvf]p KaTaKXivdjuevoc ebuc- xepavev;' dtrobeix^eicric be ttic x^Jpac TTepieX9ujv cKeT KaTeKXivev ^auTOV Kai fijaac "^ dXXd Kotv dTrpidjLirfv ' k eiTTijOv ''ApbdXuj KOivujveTv fiidc TpaTreZ^nc'. fiv be TpoiZifivioc 6 "ApbaXoc, auXujboc Kai lepeuc tujv 160 'ApbaXiujv MoucuJv, dc 6 TraXaioc "ApbaXoc ibpucaTO 6 TpoiZfivioc. 6 b' Aicu)TTOC (cTUYXave Ydp utto Kpoicou veuucTi TTpoc tc nepiavbpov ctjua Kai Trpoc 11 Tov 9e6v eic AeXqjouc dTrecTaXjuevoc, Kai Trapfiv eTTi bicppou Tivoc xttM«i2!f|Xou TTapd tov CdXujva Ka9f||Lie- voc dvuj KaTaKei|ievov) 'fiiniovoc b" iq>r] 'Auboc ev TTOTaiuuJ Tfic oipeujc eauToO KaTibiiiv eiKova Kai 9au- ILidcac t6 KdXXoc Kai t6 |LieYe9oc toO cu)|uaTOC ujp- 2 ILiTice 9eTv uiCTrep ittttoc dvaxaiTicac. eiTa iuevToi cu|li- (ppovfjcac ujc ovou ui6c eiri, KaTeTrauce Taxu t6v B bp6|uov Kai dcpfiKe t6 cppuaYiua Kai t6v 9u|u6v'. 6 be XiXujv XaKUJvicac t^ (pujv^ 'Kai Tuvri' ecpri 'Ppa- buc Kai Tpe'xeic t6v fjiuiovov'. ck toutou TrapfiX^e 2 |uev fi MeXicca Kai KaTCKXivri Trapd t6v TTepiavbpov, fi b' €u|LiriTic eKd9ice irapd t6 beTTTVOv. Kai 6 0aXfic e|ue TTpocaYopeucac eTrdvuj toO BiavTOc KaTaKcijuevov 'ti ouk eqppacac' eiTrev 'ih AioKXeic BiavTi tov Nau- KpaTiTTiv Hevov f^KOVTa |ueTd TrpopXriiudTUJV paciXiKUJV s
2, 10-12 H. 6,568-569
27. beiTTVov*: beiTrveiv
SAPIENTUM CONVIVIUM 343
au9ic eir' auTov, ottiuc vri(pujv Kai Trpocexuuv eauTU» Tov XoYOv bexiTai;* Ktti 6 Biac 'dW outoc \xiv' ecpr) 'TrdXai bebiTTeTai TaOTa TrapaKeXeuoinevoc , ifOj be Tov Aiovucov oiba Td t' dWa beivov ovTa xai C
5 Auciov dTTO coqpiac TrpocaYopeuoMevov, ujct' ou be'- bia Tou Geou jLiecToc T€v6|Ltevoc }ir\ d9apce'cTepov dYiJUvicuujuai'. ToiaOTa |aev eKeivoi TTpoc dWriXouc d|aa beiTTvoOvTec erraiZov e|Lioi be t6 beiTTvov euTe- XecTcpov 6pu)VTi toO cuvri9ouc evvoeiv eTt^ei Trpoc
10 e)aauT6v ujc coqpuuv KdYa9uJV dvbpuJv uTToboxr) Kai KXfjcic oubeiaiav TTpocTi9rici baTidvriv dXXd cuCTeXXei ILidXXov, dqpaipoOca TrepiepYiac oipujv Kai laupa EeviKd Kai TTefijLiaTa Kai TroXuTeXujv oTvujv biaxuceic oic Ka9' fl)Lie'pav xPi^^M^voc errieiKujc 6 TTepiavbpoc iv Tupav- D
15 vibi Kai ttXoutiu Ktti TTpdYjuctci, TOTe TTp6c Touc dv- bpac CKaXXujTriZieTO XiTOTriTi Kai cuiqppocuvr) baTrdvric. ou Ydp Movov TUJv dXXwv dXXd Kai thc YuvaiKOC dcpeXujv Kai dTTOKpuijjac tov cuvrj^n kociuov iTtebeiKvue cuv euTcXeia Kai neTpi6Tr|Ti KeKOCMri)Lievtiv.
20 5. 'GTrel b' ^Trr|p9ricav ai TpdTre^ai Kai CTecpdvuiv Trapd Tfic MeXiccnc biabo9evTUJV fijLieTc inev ecrreica- laev fi b' auXriTpic dTri(p9eYHa|ue'vri iniKpd Taic crrovbaic ^K in^cou laeTecTTi, rrpocaYopeucac t6v 'Avdxapciv 6 "ApbaXoc iipuuTncev ei Trapd CKu9aic auXriTpibec ei-
25civ 6 b' ^K ToO TrpocTuxovTOc 'oub' diuTreXoi' eiTre. E ToO b' 'ApbdXou TrdXiv eiTrovTOC ^dXXd 9eoi yc Cku- Gaic eiciv', 'Trdvu |Liev oijv' eqpri ^Y^wccric dv9pujTri- vric cuvievTec, oux ujcrrep b' oi "GXXrivec oioiaevoi Cku9ujv biaXeYec9ai PeXTiov 6,uujc touc 9eouc 6ctuiv
30 Kai HuXuJV nbiov dKpoac9ai vo|ai2;ouciv'. 6 b' Aicui-
2, 12— 13 H. 6, 569— 571 E.
5. dTTO*: Otc6
344 SEPTEM
TTOC ' €1 Yop ' ciTTev ' eibciTic , (x) Eeve , touc vOv auXo- TTOiouc ibc TTpoeiaevoi td vePpeia xpuuMevoi toic oveioic PeXTiov nxeiv Xefouciv. bio Kai KXeopouXivri TTpoc Tov <t»puTiov auXov ^viEaTO F ' KvriMri veppoYOVOc )Lie Kepaccpopiu ouac ^Kpoucev, s ujCTe 6au)id2!eiv tov ovov ei TraxuTaTOc Kai djuouco- TaToc u)v TdXXa XeTTTOTaTov Kai ^ouciKuuTaTOV 6cto0v TrapexeTai'. Kai 6 NeiXoHevoc 'djieXei TaOTa' e(pri 'Kai fi)Liiv ToTc NauKpaTiTaic ^YxaXoOci BoucipiTar Xpu))ie0a Yap ^H toic oveioic eic tov auXov. eKeivoic lo hk Kai cdXTciTtoc dKOueiv dGe^iTOV, ibc ovuj cp9eTT0- (aevrjc ojaoiov. ovov b' urt' AiYUTTTiujv icre bnnou bid Tuqpujva TTpOTTTiXaKiZ:6)nevov'.
6. Tevoiievric be ciwtttic 6 TTepiavbpoc 6paiv pou- X6)ievov |iev 6KVo0vTa b' ctpHaceai toO Xotou tov is 151 NeiX6Eevov ^ifd) toi' eiTrev 'ui dvbpec dTraivui Kai Tr6Xeic Kai dpxovTac, 6coi Hevoic ttpujtov, eua ttoXi- xaic xpilMCiTiZioucr Kai vOv boKei faoi touc )nev fmc- ' Te'pouc X6touc oiov emxujpiouc Kai cuvr|6eic Ppaxuv Xpovov dmcxeiv, TTp6cobov b* uJCTTcp ^v ^KKXricia J boOvai ToTc AiTUTTTioic eKeivoic Kai paciXiKoTc, ouc 6 PeXTicTOC fiKei KO|iiZ:u»v NeiXoEevoc BiavTi, Biac be PouXeTai Koivrj cKe'niaceai )Lie6' u)au)v'. Kai 6 Biac 'ttoO Tap f| MeTd Tivuiv' etpri ' TTpoeu)a6Tepov dv tic dTTOKivbuveuceiev, ei beoi, Trpoc TOiauTac dTTOKpiceic, s dXXuic Te ToO paciX^ujc KeXeucavTOc dpEaceai fikv
2, 13-14H. 6, 571-573K
1. ei Tap*: €tT€ 3. KXeo^ouXivri W: KXe6PouXov V|
4. ^viEaxo idem: fiEaxo 5. v€pp6YOv6c (ae G. Hermannus: vePpOT6vocai)ue iKpoucev idem: ^KTiKpouce 10.
bi]*: r\br] 23. 0)au)v Meziiiacus: riiaOuv 25. ei 6^01*:
ei fcel
i
SAPIENTUM CONVIVIUM 345
dTt' e|uoO, TTepieXGeTv b' eic aTraviac u|Liac tov \6- B Yov;' ouTUJ br\ Trapebibou |aev auTu» t6 YpamiiaTeTov 6 NeiXoHevoc, o b' auTov eKeXeuce XucavTa Trdciv ec fjecov dvaYVoivai. bidvoiav be TOiauTriv etxe Td
5 YeTpaMM^va.
'BaciXeuc Aiyutttiuuv "Ajuacic XeY€i BiavTi co(puj- TaTiy 'GXXiivujv. BaciXeuc AieioTTUJv exei Trpoc e)iie cocpiac dmXXav. fiTTuO|uevoc be toTc dXXotc eTri Trdci cuvTe9eiKev dTOTtov eTtiTaYMa Kai beivov, eKTrieTv ^e
10 KeXeuujv ttiv GdXaccav. ecTi hk XucavTi \ikv exeiv KiuMac Te TroXXdc Kai TroXeic tuiv eKeivou, )Lifi XucavTi b' dcTeujv Tu)V Trepi 'CXeqjavTivriv dTtocTfivai. CKeH/d- C Mevoc ouv euGuc dTTOTreMTTe NeiXoHevov. d be bei (piXoic coTc f\ TToXiTaic Y€vec0ai Trap' fiiiuiv ou Tdjud
15 KujXucei.'
TouTUJV dvaYvuJcGevTUJV ou ttoXuv xpovov eTTi- cxujv 6 Biac dXXd laiKpd mcv auToc TTpoc auTUJ ycvo- laevoc MiKpd be tu» KXeopouXiu rrpocoMiXricac eYY^c KaTaKeiMeviu 'Ti XeYeic' eiTTev 'iL NauKpaTiTa; paci-
20 Xeuujv dv6pu)TTUJv tocoutujv "Ainacic, KeKTriiuevoc be Xuipav dpicTrjv TocauTriv e0eXr|cei eTTi KUJ|Liaic dboHoic Kai XuTTpaTc eKTTieTv 0dXaccav;' Kai 6 NeiXdSevoc Ye- Xdcac 'ujc 0eXr|covTOc' eiTrev 'uJ Bia cKOTrei t6 bu- vaTOV'. 'cppaZeTUJ Toivuv' eqpn 'tuj Ai0ioTri touc D
25 e)LipdXXovTac eic Td TreXdYn rroTaMOuc eTTicxeTv, eujc dv auTOC iKTTirj t^v vOv oucav 0dXaccav* Trepi Tau- Tr|C Ydp t6 erriTaYMCi Ye'YOvev, ou Tfjc ucTepov eco- Mevnc'. ujc be TaOTa emev 6 Biac, 6 ^ev NeiXoEe-
2, U— 16H. 6, 573— 574 B.
3. XiicavTa Reiskius: XOcavTo irdvTa 23. GeXricov-
Toc Pflugkius: GeXncavTOC 26. Qv* ^KTrirj*:
^KTTlVr]
346 SEPTEM
voc iicp' f)bovfic ujpiarice TrepiPaXeTv tov Biavta Kat cpiXncar TuJv b' ctXXiuv eTraivecdvToiv Kai ctTTobeEaiLie- viuv teXdcac 6 XiXiuv 'ui NauKpaTiTa' etpri 'Eeve, TTpiv d7T0Xe'ceai Tfjv GdXaccav eKKoGeicav dTtdTTeXXe ■nXeucac 'Ajudcibi |Lifi ZriTeiv ottuuc aX|LiTiv dvaXuucei r, TocauTHV, dXXd iuaXXov ottuuc ttotimov Kai YXuKeiav E Toic uTTTiKOOic Tfjv paciXeiav TTapeHer TTepi TaOTa ydp beivoTaTOC Biac Kai bibdcKaXoc toutuuv dpicTOC, & )ia9ujv "AjLiacic oubev eTi toO xP^coO beficeTai TToba- viTTTfipoc em Touc Aitutttiouc, dXXd eepaTTeucouci lo TTdvTec auTov Kai dTaTTficouci xPICTov ovTa, Kdv ^iupidKic f| vOv dvacpavrj bucTeve'cTepoc*. 'Kai |ufiv' eqpTi 6 TTepiavbpoc 'dHiov t^ ToiauTac dTrapxdc to» PaciXeT cuveiceveTKeTv ctTTavTac 'dvbpaKdc', ujcrrep ecpiicev "0|nripoc* eKeiviu tc Tdp av TtvoiTO TTXeiovoc i5 dHia TTic ejurropiac ii TrapevefiKri , Kai fiiuTv dvfi TTdv-
TOUV UJ(peXl)LlOC'.
7. EiTTovTOC oijv ToO XiXuuvoc wc CoXuuv KaTdp- F x^ceai ToO XoTOu biKaioc ecTiv, ou iuovov oti TTdv- Tujv TTpofiKei Kae' fiXiKiav Kai TUTxdvei KaTaKei)uevoc a TtpwTOC, dXX' oTi Tfiv jueTicTTiv Kai TeXeiOTdTriv dp- Xnv dpxei, vdjiouc 'Aerjvaioic ee)aevoc, 6 NeiXoHevoc ; ficuxn rrpoc ^|ue 'TToXXd tc' e»TTev 'uu AioKXeic tti- CTeueTai vpeubuuc, Kai x«ipo^civ oi ttoXXoi Xotouc dveTTiTribeiouc Trepi cocpuuv dvbpuuv auToi Te TTXdTTOv- a Tec Kai bex6|uevoi TTap* ^Tepuuv dToijauuc, oia Kai TTpoc fliadc ek ATtutttov dTTnTTe^^n Ttepi XiXwvoc, wc dpa biaXucaiTO t^v TTpoc CoXuuva qpiXiav Kai Heviav,
2, 16— 17 H. 6, 574 -576 B,
1. irepipaXeTv*: uepipdWeiv 12. bucTev^ctepoc Reis-
kius: &ucT€V^CTaToc 15. "0|ariPOc] v 14 22. 6*: 6
oOv 26. ^TOl,UWC W: fe'TOl.U0l
J
SAPIENTUM CONVIVIUM 347
oTi Touc v6|uouc 6 CoXuuv lcpncev djueTaKivnTOuc eivai. 152 Kai ifdj 'TcXoioc' ecpnv *6 Xoyoc* outiu Ydp bei TTpuuTOv dTT0TT0ieTc9ai tov AuKoOpYov auToTc v6)iioic oXnv )LieTaKivr|cavTa Tf|V AaKebai|aoviujv TtoXiTeiav'.
5 ^iKpov ouv emcxujv 6 C6Xuuv 'ejuoi )Liev' ecpn 'boKei ludXiCT^ dv evboHoc Y£vec0ai Kai paciXeuc Kai Tupav- voc, ei br||U0KpaTiav ck juovapxiac KaTacKeudceie toTc TToXiTaic'. beuTepoc b' 6 Biac eTrrev 'ei dTpeTtToic XPUJTO ToTc v6)Lioic Tfic rraTpiboc'. ejTi toutuj b' 6
10 OaXfic ecpT]cev ' eubai|aoviav dpxovTOc vo^uiCeiv, ei tc- XeuTrjceie YHPdcac KaTd qpuciv'. TCTapTOC 'Avdxapcic 'ei ^\] )a6voc eiri qppovijuoc'. rre^uTTTOc be KXe6pou- Xoc *ei )Liribevi mcTeuoi tujv cuvovtujv'. cktoc b' 6 B TTiTTaK6c 'ei touc uTTr|K6ouc 6 dpxujv rrapacKeudceie
15 qpoPeTcGai )ufi auTov dXX' uTTep auToO'. ^iCTd toOtov 6 XiXuJV eqpri tov dpxovTa XPHvai ixr\hkv (ppoveTv evriT6v, dXXd TTdvTa dOdvaTa. priee'vTujv bk toutujv riHioOjuev fijueTc Kai auTov eiTreTv ti tov TTepiavbpov. 6 b' ou )LidXa qpaibpoc dXXd cucTr^cac t6 ttpocujttov
20 'eYUJ Toivuv' eqpr) ' rrpocaTToqpaivojuai Tdc eipri)Lie'vac YViJU|uac dTrdcac cxebov dqpiCTdvai toO dpxeiv tov voOv exovTa'. Kai 6 Aicujttoc oTov eXeYKTiKOc 'ebei Toivuv' e^ri 'toOto Kae* eauTOUc irepaiveiv Kal )uri, cu)upouXouc qpdcKOVTac eivai Kai qpiXouc, KaTriYdpouc C
■25 YiYveceai toiv dpxdvTUJV '. dvpd)uevoc oijv auToO ttic KeqpaXnc 6 CdXujv Kai bia^ueibidcac eiTTev 'ouk&v bo- KeT coi jucTpiujTepov dpxovTa TroieTv Kai Tupavvov
2, 17— 18 H. 6, 576— 578 R.
1. ?q)ricev*: ?q)Ti djuexaKivriTouc D6hnerus: jueTaKi-
vr|Touc 8. dTpeTTTOic*: TrpuiiTOC vel Tpoiroic 12. ixi}
Stobaeus Floril. XLVIII 47 21. dqpicTdvai W: d(pe-
CTdvai
348 SEPTEM
eTTieiKecTepov 6 TreiGuuv d)c cliaeivov eTr| t6 ixx] apxeiv r\ t6 ctpxeiv;' 'tic b' av' ecpr) 'coi toOto TreicGein luaXXov r\ tuj eeuj q)pdcavTi KaTa t6v rrpoc ce e€C)L»6v
'eubaijnov TTToXieGpov ^v6c KripuKOc dtKoOov;' 5 Kai 6 CoXuiv 'dXXd |ar|v' ecpri 'Kai vOv ev6c 'Aer|-
D vaToi KiipuKOC dKpoujvTai Kai dpxovTOC toO v6)aou, brmoKpaTiav ^'xovTec. cu be beiv6c ei KopdKwv eTTdieiv Kai KoXoiODv, Tfic be eeou cpujvfic ouk dKpipujc eHa- Koueic, dXXd ttoXiv |uev oiei KaTd t6v ee6v dpicTa lo TTpdTTeiv Tfjv dv6c dKOUoucav, cujaTTOciou b' dpeTr]v vo^iZieic t6 TTdvTac biaXeteceai Kai Trepi TrdvTUiV '. ' cu Ydp' ^'q)Ti 6 AicoiTTOc 'outtuj "feYpacpac oiKe^Tac jufi laeeOeiv, lijc eYpaq;ac 'Aenvriciv oiKeTac [xx] dpav juribe Sr|paXoi(peiv'. feXdcavTOc ouv toO CoXujvoc KXeo- i5 bujpoc 6 laTpoc 'dXX' dvoiuioiov' eepr) 't6 SripaXoi- cpeiv Tuj XaXeiv ev oivuj ppex6)aevov fibiCTOv fap
E ecTi*. Kai 6 XiXujv uTToXapujv ecpri 'bid toOto toi lifiXXov d(peKTe'ov auToO'. TrdXiv b' 6 Aicujttoc 'Kai lariv' e'(pr| 'GaXfic l'boHev eiTTeiv oti TdxicTa yripdcei'. 20
8. feXdcac ouv 6 TTepiavbpoc, '^xoM^V eiTTev 'AicujTTe Tfjv biKrjv ttpoctikovtujc, TTpiv r| touc 'A)Lid- ciboc ouc TTpoeiX6|Lieea rrdvTac eicaYaTeiv Xoyouc eic ^Te'pouc eiLiTTecovTec. opa bfi, NeiXoEeve, Td Xomd
TfjC dTTlCTOXfiC, KOl XP^ TTapoOciV eV TaUTUJ TOIC dv- 25
bpdciv'. 'dXXd lifiv' 6 NeiXoHevoc ^<pr] 'Tfjv laev ToO AieioTTOc eTriTaHiv oubev dv tic dXXo TrXfjv
2, 18-20 H. 6, 578-5S0R.
5. dKoOov nescio quis: dKoOeiv 9. GeoO Reiskius: coO
13. Y£TP«9CC idem: T^TPO^pcc 6ti 6|uoiov 16. d.v6-
laoiovW: 6)uoiov 22. npocriKovTUJC Reiskius: TipocnKov-
TUJC 6ti 25. xaviTu) idem: toutiu
I
SAPIENTUM CONVIVIUM 349
* dxvu)Lievriv CKurdXriv' npoceiTTOi kot' 'ApxiXoxov, 6 be coc Sevoc "AjLiacic fmepiuTepoc ev toTc toioutoic F TtpopXiiiaaci Kai luouciKUiTepoc fifovev eK^Xeuce Ydp auTov emeTv t6 irpecpuTaTOV Kai t6 koXXictov Kai
5 t6 |Lie'YicTOV Kai t6 coqpuuTaTOv Kai t6 KOivoTaTOV, Kai vai )Lid Aia Trpoc toutoic t6 ibqpeXijLiuuTaTOv , Kai t6 pXapepuuTaTov Kai t6 icxupoTaTOv Kai t6 pdcTov. dp' ouv d-rreKpivaTO Kai bieXuce toutouv cKacTOv;' 'ouTuic' 6 NeiXoHevoc eqpri' 'KpivcTe h' u|ueic dKou-
10 cavTec. Trepi ttoXXoO xdp 6 paciXeuc rroieiTai iuriTe 153 cuKoqpavTuJv dXujvai Tdc dTTOKpiceic, ei Te ti cqpdX- XeTai mj' auTdc 6 dTTOKpivdjLievoc, toGto jLifi bia- qpuTeiv dveHeXeyKTOv. dvaYVuucojLiai b' u)liiv uuCTrep ttTTeKpivaTO. Ti TTpec^uTaTov ; xpovoc. ti |Lie'TiCTOv;
13 Kocjuoc. Ti coqpOuTaTOV ; dXrjGeia. ti KdXXiCTOv ; qpuuc. Ti KOivoTaTOv; GdvaTOC. ti ujqpeXijuuuTaTOV ; Geoc. ti pXapepuuTttTov ; baijuwv. ti puujuaXeuuTaTov ; Tuxri. ti pdcTov; fibu.'
9. TouTuuv rrdXiv dvayvujcGevTUJV , uu NiKapxe,
20 Yevo|uevric ciuuTTfjc GaXfic ^puuTrice t6v NeiXoHevov ei TTpocfjKaTo Tdc Xuceic 6 "Aiuacic. cKeivou b' eiTTOVTOc 6ti Tdc juev dTTebeHaTo TaTc b' ebucKoXaive, 'koi |ufiv B oubev' eiTTev 6 OaXfic ' dveTTiXriTTTOV ecTiv, dXX' exei TTdvTa biajuapTiac )U€YdXac Kai dYVoiac. oiov euGuc
25 6 xpovoc TTuuc civ eir| TTpec^uTaTOv , ei t6 |uev auToO YeY0v6c t6 b' evecTuuc ecTi t6 be lueXXov; 6 Ydp |ue9' fjjudc ecojuevoc xpovoc Kai TTpaY|udTuuv tuiv vOv Kai dv9pu)Trujv veuuTepoc dv qpaveir). t6 bk Tfiv dXfi^eiav
•2,-:0-21H. 6, 580-581 R,
1. dxvuju^vjiv] Bergk. p. 708* 7. t6 ante pXaPepui-
TOTov* ^fiCTOv*: ^acTov eiTTCiv 12. kot' auTdc
Madvigius: KaTct TauTac 6 "W
350 SEPTEM
f]'f€ic0«i coqpiav oubev e^oi bOKCi biaqpepeiv toO t6 q)ujc oqpSaXnov diTTocpaiveiv. ei be t6 (pilic KaX6v ujCTrep ecTiv evoiniJe, ttuuc t6v fiXiov auT6v Trapeibe; Tijuv b' dXXuuv fi )nev Ttepi Geiuv Kai bai^oviuv diTo-
C Kpicic Gpdcoc ^xei m\ Kivbuvov, dXoyiav be Kai TrXd- 5 vnv fi Trepi Tnc Tuxnc ou Ydp Sv ^eTe^rriTTTe ^abiuuc OUTUJC, icxupoTaTOV ouca tuuv ovtuuv Kai puu)LiaXeuu- TaTOV. ou M^v oub' 6 6dvaToc KOivoTaTov ecTiv ou Ydp dcTi 7Tp6c Touc ZuuvTac. dXX* iva |nf| bOKuuiiev euGuveiv Tdc tuuv ^Tepuuv diroqpdceic, Tdc okeiac Taic lo tKeivou 7TapapdXuu|aev * e|nauT6v be napexuu ttpuutov, ei pouXeTai NeiXoSevoc, epuuTav Ka8' ^KacTOv'.
'Qc ouv etevovTO TOTe, KdYuu vuv biriYncojuai toc epuuTr|ceic Kai Tdc dTTOKpiceic. 'Ti rrpecPuTaTov;' 'Geoc' eqjri GaXfic" 'dTewnTOC Tdp kTi'. 'ti neTi- 15
D cTOv;' ^TOTTOC TciXXa yikv Tdp 6 k6c|uoc, t6v be ko- C|iOv oijTOC TTepiexei'. 'ti KdXXtcTov;' Kociaoc" Trdv Tdp t6 KaTtt ToHiv toutou fjepoc kTi'. *t( coqpuuTa- Tov;' 'xpovoc* Td |uev Tdp eupriKev outoc r\br\, xa i b' eupfjcei'. 'Ti KOivoTaTov;' 'eXTTic* Kai Tdp oic 2* aXXo Mri^e'v, auTri TTdpecTi'. 'ti ujqpeXi)au)TaTov ; ' *dpeTf|* Kai Tdp TciXXa tlu xPTIcOai KaXuuc ujqp^Xi)aa TTOiei'. 'Ti pXapepuuTaTOV ; ' 'KaKia' Kai Tdp Td nXei- CTa pXdTTTei 7TapaTevo)uevr|'. 'Ti icxupoTaTov;' 'dvdT- Kr|* liovri Tdp dviKTiTOc'. 'Ti pdcTOv;' ' t6 KaTd qpuciv, 25 eTcei Trp6c f^bovdc t^ ttoXXoi TToXXdKic dTTaTopeuouciv'.
E 10. 'ATTobeHa)L»evuuv hk TTdvTuuv t6v GaXfjv, 6
2, 21-22 H. C, .V''!— ns;: i{
2. KaX6v djCTTCp ^ctiv Redskius: dicTTcp koXov dcxiv 5. nXdvriv idcm: ttoXXi?)v 15. dT^vvr)TOC*: dT^vvr|TOv
25. jLiovri TOP uviKnToc*: )u6vov Top «iviKiiTOv 2C. noXXol Hanptius
4
SAPIENTUM CONVIVIUM 351
KXeobujpoc eiire 'TOcaOia epuuTav Kai dTTOKpivecGai paciXeOciv, ui NeiXoHeve, TrpocfJKOv ecTiv 6 be Ttpo- TTivuuv THV GdXaTTav 'Ajudcibi pdppapoc ^beiTO Tfic TTiTTaKoO ppaxuXoYiac, rj Trpoc 'AXudTTriv dxpr|caT0
5 TTpocTdTTOVTd Ti Kai YpdqpovTa Aecpioic uTrepricpavov, dTTOKpivd^evoc oubev dXX' r| )li6vov KeXeucac Kp6)Li|iiua Kai 9ep)a6v dpTOv ecGieiv*. uTroXapdjv ouv 6 TTepiav- bpoc 'dXXd iufiv Kai toTc TraXaioTc "GXXriciv e8oc fjv, w KXedbuipe, ToiauTac dXXfiXoic dTTopiac TTpopdXXeiv.
10 dKOuo|uev xdp oti Kai TTpoc Tdc 'A|icpibd|LiavTOc Taqpdc F eic XaXKiba tuiv TdTe coqpujv oi bOKijauuTaTOi rroiriTai cuvfiXGov fjv b' 6 'Ajuqpibdiaac dvfjp TToXejuiKdc, Kai TToXXd TTpdfiuaTa rrapacxujv '€peTpieOciv ev TaTc Trepi* AriXdvTOu iiidxaic ^TTecev. eTTei be Td TTapecK€uac|Lieva
10 ToTc TToiriTaTc eTTr| xci^tTrnv Kai bucKoXov eTToiei tviv Kpiciv bid t6 eq)d|uiXXov, fi Te boHa tujv dYUJViCTUJV, '0|uf|pou Kai 'Hci6bou, TToXXfjV dTTopiav iueTd aiboOc ToTc Kpivouci TTapeTxev, eTpdrrovTO TTpoc TomuTac epwTfjceic, Kai TrpoupaXe |iiev ujc ^aci Aecxnc
20 'MoOcd |aoi evveTre KeTva, Td juf|T' eYe'vovTO lo4-
TTdpoi9e |if|T' ecTai ^eTOTTic^ev ', dTTeKpivaTo b' 'Hcioboc eK toO TrapaTuxovTOc
' dXX' oTav d|iiqpi Ai6c TU|aPuj KavaxfiTTobec ittttoi dpjaaTa cuvTpivpuuciv eTreiTOiuevoi Trepi viKric'. Kai bid toOto XexeTai )idXiCTa 9au|uac9eic toO TpiTTO- boc TuxeTv'. ^Ti be TaOTa' 6 KXeobuupoc eiTre 'bia- qpepei tuiv €u|iif|Tiboc aiviT|LidTUJV ; a TauTTiv iuev icujc B ouK dTTpeTTe'c ecTi TraiZioucav Kai biartXeKOucav ujCTrep
30 eTepai Zuuvia Kai KCKpuqpdXouc TrpopdXXeiv TaTc yu-
i, 22— 23H. 6,583— o84R.
14. AriXdvTOU*: XiXdvTOU
352 SEPTEM
vaiSiv, ctvbpac be voOv exovtac ev tivi CKOubrj Ti9e- c9ai YeXoTov*. fi inev ouv €u|LiriTic fibeaic av eiTToOca Ti rrpoc auTOV, uic eqpaiveTO, KaTecxev lauTfiv utt' aibouc, Kai dveTr\ric9ii t6 irpociwTTOv epu9r||LiaT0C ' 6 be AicojTTOc olov diiiuvoMevoc urrep auTfic 'ou fe-5 XoioTepov ouv' eiTTe 't6 iiifi buvac9ai TaOTa biaXueiv, oiov ecTiv 8 )LiiKp6v ^HTcpocQev f]ix\v toO beiirvou Ttpou- paXev
*dvbp' eibov TTupi xciXkov ^tt' dve'pi KoXXncavTa;*
C Ti toOt' ecTiv exoic dv eirreiv;' 'dXX' oube iuaOeiv lo
be'o]Liai' eqpri 6 KXeobujpoc. 'Kal \xr\v oubeic' etpn • ' coO toOto iLiaXXov oTbev oube TTOieT PcXtiov • ei b* dpvri, iLidpTupac exuj ciKuuuviac'. 6 \xkv ouv KXeo- bujpoc ^teXace' Kai tdp expfjTO iudXiCTa TaTc cikuuj- viaic Tuiv Ka9' auT6v iaTpujv, Kai boHav oux fiKicTa 15 To pori9ri|iia toOto bi' CKeTvov 4'cxriKe.
11. MvriciqpiXoc b' 6 'AOrivaToc, ^TaTpoc u)v Kai ZrjXujTfic CoXujvoc, 'exuj toi' eiTTev 'u) TTepiavbpe t6v Xoyov dHiu) Ka9dTTep t6v oivov |iifi TTXouTivbrjv D |ar|b' dpicTivbriv dXX' il icou TTficiv uiCTTep ev brmo- i KpaTia ve|Liec9ai Kai koiv6v eivar tOuv b' dpTi TTepi dpxnc Kai paciXeiac eipriiu^vujv oubev fi|nTv toTc brijuo- TiKoTc iLteTecTiv. oOev oi6jue9a beiv TTdXiv CKacTOv u)Liujv TTepi TToXiTeiac icov6|iou YviOiuriv Tivd cujupaXe- cOai, dpEaiuevouc au9ic dTT6 CoXujvoc'. eboKei bfi TttOTa TTOieTv. Kai ttpujtoc 6 CoXujv 'dXX' dKrjKoac jLidv' emev 'uJ MvriciqjiXe ineTd TTdvTUJV 'AOrivaiujv tiv ^x^ TVWMIV TTepi rroXiTeiac* ei be pouXei Kai vOv dKOueiv, boKcT /lioi ttoXic dpiCTa rcpdTTeiv Kal |udXi- CTa cibZieiv brnuoKpanav, ^v fj tov dbiKiicavTa toO so
2, 23-24 H. 6, 584:-536B,
d
SAPIENTUM CONVIVIUM 353
dbiKnQevTOC oubev fiTTov oi ^x] dbiKnOevTec rtpopdX- E XovTtti Ktti KoXdZ;oucr. beuTcpoc b' 6 Biac ecpri Kpa- TicTnv eTvai bTi)iOKpaTiav iv fj irdvTec ujc Tupavvov cpopouvTai Tov v6)aov. em toutuj 9aXfic Tfjv |af|Te
5 ttXouciouc dtav )JLr]je rrevriTac exo^eav TToXiTac. laeTd be TOUTOV 6 'Avdxapcic ^v f) tujv dXXiuv Tcwv vo|lii- Z!o|a^viuv dpeTfi t6 peXTiov 6pi2!eTai, KaKia be t6 xeT- pov. ireiiTTTOC b' 6 KXeopouXoc eqpri indXiCTa cuuqppoveTv bfiiiiov oTTou t6v ipoYov laaXXov oi TToXiTeuo/ievoi be-
10 boiKaciv f| t6v vojaov. cktoc be TTiTTaKoc , ottou toTc TTOvnpoTc ouK eEecTiv dpxeiv Kai toTc dxaGoTc ouk IHecTi |Lifi dpxeiv. iiieTaTpaTTeic b' 6 XiXuuv dTTeqpnvaTO Tfjv lidXiCTa v6)Liu)v fiKicTa be pr|T6pujv dKOuoucav F TToXiTeiav dpicTHV etvai. TeXeuTaToc be TTdXiv 6 ITe- L 16 piavbpoc eTTiKpivuJv ^(pr\ boKeTv auTqj TTdvTac CTTaiveTv briMOKpaTiav Tf)V ojLioiOTdTnv dpiCTOKpaTia.
12. TeXoc be Kai toutou toO Xotou XapovToc ilHiouv tfOj Kui TTepi oTkou ^ xp^ctcov emeTv touc dvbpac fiinTv 'PaciXeiac ja^v tdp Kai TToXeic oXiyoi
20 Kupepvujciv, ecTiac be ttcIciv fjiuiTv Kai oTkou ineTecTr. 165 YeXdcac ouv 6 ATcujttoc 'ouk, eTte tujv TTdvTUJV ' eqpri 'Kai 'Avdxapciv dpi9|aeTc" toutuj xdp oTkoc ouk ecTiv, dXXd Kal ceiavuveTai tuj doiKOC eivai , xpfJcOai b' djLid- Hri, KaGdTTcp t6v fiXiov Iv fipiuaTi XeYOuci TTepmoXeTv,
25 dXXoT ' dXXriv eTTive|Li6|Lievov toO oupavoO x^P«v '• Kai 6 'Avdxapcic 'bid to0t6 toi' etTrev *ii |li6voc f| ladXiCTtt Tuiv eeujv eXeu9ep6c dcTi Kai auT6vo|Lioc, Kai KpaTeT udvTuiv, KpaTeTTai b' utt' oubevdc, dXXd paci-
2, 24— 25H. 6, 586— 588R.
2. Iqpri Stobaeus Floril. XLIII 131: ^qprice 7. KCKia
(KaKicji Pflugkius) 6^ Stobaeus: xal KaK(a 12. liexaTpa-
•neic] laeTci toutouc W
Plutarchi Moralia. Vol. I. 23
354 SEPTEM
Xeu€i Ka\ f)viox€i. irXfiv c^ t€ t6 apiaa XeXr|9ev au- ToO ujc iJ7Tepq)uk KoiXXei Ktti ^eT^Oei Gaujidciov icjw
B ou Yop Sv TtaiCujv em tcXujti napePaXec dKeivo toic nfieT^poic. oTkov bi jioi boKcTc , iJu ATcwTre , TauTl to TTriXiva Kai ^uXiva KaT Kepainea cTeYdciuaTa vo/iiJleiv, 5 uJCTtep el KOxXiav fiToTo t6 K^ucpoc, dXXd nr\ t6 Zujov. eiKOTUJC oOv coi yeXujTa TTape'cx€v 6 CoXujv, OTi Tou Kpoicou TTiv oiKiav KeKOC|ur|)ievTiv TToXuTeXOuc eeacdjievoc ouk eu6uc dTTeqpfivaTO tov KeKTimevov eubai^dvujc oiKeTv Kai jLiaKapiujc , &ie bfj Ttuv ev au- lo Tuj ladXXov dYaGujv fj tujv ttop* auTiI» pouXo^ievoc YevecOai 0eaTf|C' cu b' eoiKac oube ttic ceauToO |ivr|- lioveueiv dXiUTTeKOC. ^Keivn ixkv ydp eic dTuuva ttoi- KiXiac KaTacTttca TTpoc Tfjv TTdpbaXiv nHiou to ^vt6c
C auTfic KttTa/iaGeTv t6v biKacTf|V, TTOiKiXujTepa Ydp ^KeT- u Gev (paveTc6ar cu be Td TeKTovujv Kai Xi6oi6ujv IpTCi TTepivocTeTc, oTkov fiTOUMevoc ou Td ^vt6c d^dcTOu Kai oiKeTa, TTaibac Kai Tdjiov Kai cpiXouc Kai 6epdTT0VTac, oic Kdv iv liup^riKiqi tic fj veoTTK^t voOv ^xouci Kai cwqppovoOci KOivujvfi Tiijv u7t6vtu)V, xpncT6v oIkov oiKeT Kai inaKdpiov. dTib |i^v ouv' ^(pr) 'TaOTO Ka\ TTp6c ATcujTTOv dnoKpivo|iai Kai AiOKXeT cu^pdXXoiiar T&v b' d\Xujv ^KacTOC dTio^aivecGai biKaioc dcTi Tf|v ^auToO TVuOnnv'- toOtov oijv dpiCTOv 6 C6Xujv eiTTev auTuj boKeTv oTkov, 6ttou to KTf||iaTa ^fjTe KTUjfievoic ^
D dbiKia )if|T€ q)uXdTTouciv dTTiCTia^ fif|Te baTravujci )i€- Tdvoia TTp6c€CTiv. 6 be Biac iv \h toioOtoc ^ctiv 6 becTT^TTic bi' auT6v oioc eHuj bid t6v vojiov. 6 be GaXfic i\ (L TTXeicTiiv dTeiv tuj becTT^Trj cxoXfjV lE-
^.iS-JTH, 6,588-590»
24. toOtov - elTTCv Stobaeus Floril. LXXX 14: oiItujc 6 c6\uiv fipiCTOv
1
SAPIENTUM CONVIVIUM 355
ecTiv. 6 be KXeopouXoc ei TrXeiovac ^'xo^ "^^"^ cpo^ou- ILievujv aiiTov touc qpiXoOvTac 6 becrroTric. 6 be TTit- TaKOC emev ' ibc SpiCTOC oTkoc ^tiv 6 tujv TTepiccoiv larjbevoc be6)ievoc Kai tujv dvaYKaiujv jiiri&evoc evbe6-
b laevoc', 6 bk XiXuiv lcpri beiv indXiCTa paciXeuo|Lie'v»;) Tr6Xei rrpoceoiKe'vai tov oTkov. eiTa TrpoceTremev oti Kai AuKoOpYOC Trpoc tov KeXeuovTa bril^OKpaTiav ev Tr| KoXei KaTacTTicai 'TrpuiTOc' icpx] 'Troincov ev Tfj oiKict E cou brijiOKpaTiav'.
lu 13. '€TTei be Kai outoc ecxev 6 Xoyoc TeXoc, y[ }jik\f €upriTic eHfiXGe jneTd Tfic MeXiccric, toG be TTe- pidvbpou TUJ XiXujvi TrpoTTiovTOc eu|a€T€Gri KuXiKa, Tuj b^ BiavTi ToO XiXujvoc, "ApbaXoc eTravacTdc Kai TTpocaTOpeucac tov Aicujttov ' cu b' ouk- dv ' eqpri ' bia-
ij TTe|LU|jaio beOpo t6 rroTiipiov TTp6c fi|Lidc, opuiv tou- Touc ujCTrep Tfjv Ba6uKXe'ouc KuXiKa biaTTe|UTro|Lievouc dXXfiXoic , dTepuj be ]ufi )i€Tabib6vTac ; ' Kai 6 Aicujttoc 'dXX' ou bei toOto' eqpn 'to TroTripiov brnuoTiKOV eT- P var C6Xu>vi Tdp eKTraXai TrapdKeiTai |li6vuj'. tov ouv
-0 MvricicpiXov TrpocaTopeucac 6 TTiTTaKOC ^PiwTrice ti ou Trivei 6 C6Xujv dXXd KaTaiuapTupei tujv TTOiri|udTUJV ^v oic TeTpa^ptv
'epTtt be KuTTpoTevoOc vOv )aoi (piXa Kai Aio-
vucou
■^j Kai Mouce'ujv, d TiGnc' dvbpdciv eucppo-
cuvac'. uTTOcpGdcac b' 'Avdxapcic 'ce Tdp', iJu TTiTTaK^, Kai Tov cov iKeTvov tov xc^eTTOV q)oPeTTai v6)iOV, ev iL TCTPCKpac '€dv tic otioOv lueGuujv ajJLapirj, bi-
1, 345-347 H. 6, 429— 131 R.
4. |ur|6ev6c 6€6|uevoc Stobaeus 18. ovi 6e? Madvi-
gius: oi<bk 23. Bergk. p. 430^
356 SEPTEM
TrXaciav f| tuj vricpovTi Tfjv Ir^ixiav elvai '. Kai 6 TTit- TaKOc 'cu be te' eiTrev *outu)C eHuppicac eic tov voMov, uJCTe Trepuci rrapa XiPut' dbeXqpu» |ie9uc0eic 166 deXov aiTeiv Kai CT^qpavov'. 'ti b* ouk ?|ueXXov' ^qpri 6 'Avdxapcic 'tuj TrXeiCTOv movTi 7rpoKei)Lievu)v 5 d0XuJV TTpuiTOc |Lie0uc0eic dTcaiTeiv Td viKriTripiov ; ri bibdHaT^ |Lie u|Lieic, ti TeXoc ^cti toO ttoXuv Trietv dKpaTOV f| t6 |ae9uc0rivai'. tou be TTiTTaKoO teXd- cavTOC 6 AicuiTTOC X6tov eiTre toioOtov. ' Xukoc ibdiv TTOi)uievac k0iovTac ev CKriviii rrpdpaTOV i^ffvc Trpoc- lo €X0u)v 'n^iKOc dv ^v' e(pr| 'ujiaiv 06puPoc, ei ifih toOto ^TToiouv.' Ktti 6 XiXuiv '6p0u)c' eq)ri 'Aicw- TTOC ^ILi^vaTO, fiiKpov €|LiTrpoc6€V dmcTO|aic0eic uqp' nmjuv, elTa vOv 6pu)v eTe'pouc t6v MvricicpiXou X6yov uqpripTTaK^Tac' MvriciqpiXoc Ydp riTr^^ri Triv urrep C6- »5 Xu)voc dTidKpiciv'. ^Kai Xeyu)' 6 MvnciqpiXoc eiTrev
B 'eibdic OTi C6Xu)vi boKei Trdcric T^xvric Kai buvdfieujc dv0pu)TTivric Te Kai 0eiac epyov elvai t6 YiTv6|aevov HdXXov f| bi' ou YiYveTai, Kai to t^Xoc y\ tol Trp6c Td TeXoc. uqpdvTric Te Ydp dv oT|aai x^ci|auba Troiri- 20 caiTO inaXXov ^pYov auToO Kai iiiidTiov fj Kavdvujv bid9eciv Kai dveYepciv dYVu0ujv, x^^Keuc tc KdXXriciv cibripou Kai ct6|iiujciv TreXeKCUJc jLiaXXov fj ti tujv IveKa toutou YiYV0|Lievu)V dvaYKOiujv, oTov dv0pdKUJV ^KZujTTUpTiciv fl XaTUTTric uapacKeuriv. cti be iiidXXov 25 dpxiTeKTUJV |ie')Lii}jaiT ' dv fi|ndc epYov auToO ^x] vaOv yir\bk olKiav drroqpaivovTac , dXXd TpuTTfjcai HuXa Kai
C qpupdcai TtriXdv ai be MoOcai Kai TravTdrraciv , ei vojiiZoiiiev auTuiv ^'pYOV eivai Ki0dpav Kai auXouc,
2, 28—29 H. 6, 691— 593 B.
3. irapd AiPouxdbr) AeXqpil» Madvigius 16. \dYU) W:
X^Tiwv 20. TTOincaiTo idem: TTOiricw
SAPIENTUM CONYIVIUM 357
dXXa }ii] t6 Traibeueiv td fiGri Kai irapriYOpeTv xd Tid- e»! Tujv xpiJUMtvujv iLieXeci Kal dp)ioviaic. oukoOv ou- be Tfjc 'AcppobiTric epTov ecTi cuvoucia Kai iniHic, oube Tou Aiovucou ^eGr) Kai olvoc, aW r\v eiurroiouci bid
5 TOUTUJV qpi\oq)pocuvriv Kai ttoGov Kai 6)iiXiav f\}jdv Kai cuvnGeiav 7Tp6c dXXriXouc" TauTa Tdp epya Seia KaXeT CoXuJV, Kai TaOrd (prjciv dTaTrav Kai bituKeiv ladXiCTa TTpecpuTTic Tev6|Lievoc. ^cti be Tfic )iev TTp6c TuvaTKac dvbpujv 6|ao(ppocuvTic Kai cpiXiac brmioupT^c
10 fi 'AcppobiTTi , toTc ciu)uaciv uqp ' fibovnc djua cu|a)ii- D Tvuouca Kai cuvTf|KOuca Tdc vpuxdc toTc be ttoXXoTc Kai jLifi Trdvu cuvf|9eci p.r]V dTCtv Tvujpi)aoic 6 Aio- vucoc ujCKep dv Trupi tuj oivijj /iaXdccujv Td f^Gri Kai dvuTpaivuJv dpxnv Tiva cuTKpdceujc TTp6c dXXr^Xouc
15 Kai 9iXiac dvbibujciv. St^v be toioOtoi cuveX0u)Civ dvbpec, oiouc 6 TTepiavbpoc ujidc TTapaKeKXriKev, ou- bev ^pTov icfiv oT)aai kuXikoc oub' oivoxoric, dXX' ai MoOcai Ka0dTTep KpaTnpa vricpdXiov dv )aeciu TTpo- 0e)aevai t6v Xotov, ip TtXeTcTOv fibovfjc d)aa Ka» Ttai-
20 bidc Kai CTTOubfic ^vecTiv, cTeipouci toutu) Kai KaTdp- bouci Kai biaxeouci Tfiv (piXoqppocuvrjV , eujcai Td E TToXXd Tfjv oivoxorjv dTp^)ua KeTc0ai 'KprjTfipoc UTrep- 0ev', OTTep dTTTiTopeucev 'Hcioboc ev toTc TTiveiv iudX- Xov ri biaXeTec0ai buva)Lievoic. ^Trei Tdc t^ ttpotto-
25 ceic' Iqpri 'XiTdc TTuv0dvo|aai TTiveiv touc TraXaiouc, 'baiTpov', Ouc "Oiuripoc lq>x], Kai )aeTpriT6v ^koctou TTivovTOC, eiTa ujcTrep aiac )aepibac ^ueTabibovToc tiu
2, 29-31 H. 6, 593- 595 H.
22. KpriTfipoc*: KpaTf^poc 23. 'Hcioftoc] 0« et D. 742
24. TC Reiskius: tc 25. XitAc*: outcic Tiiveiv touc
TraXaioOc*: X^t^iv toTc TraXaiotc 26. 6aiTp6v Meziria-
cus: lv6ejvov "Oiniipoc] A 262 27. aiac] Xeiac
Hauptius
358 SEPTEM
TtXriciov*. emovToc be TaOra toO MvriciqpiXou Xep- F ciac 6 TTOiriTric (d(peiTO Tctp n^H Tnc aiTiac Kai bir|X- XaKTO Tuj TTepidvbpuj veajCTi, XiXujvoc ber|6evT0c) 'ap' oOv' ^q)ri 'koi toic GeoTc 6 Zeuc, ujCTrep toic dpi- CTeOciv 6 'AYa|ae|nva)v, |LieTpr)T6v evexei t6 ttotov, Ste n TtpouTTivov dXXriXoic dcTiuujuevoi Ttap* auTuj;' Kai 6 KXeobwpoc *cu b' u) Xepcia' emev, 'ei Tfiv d)appo- ciav Tuj Au TTeXeidbec Tivec KojuiCouciv, ujc u/ieic Xe- YCTe, Tdc TTXaYKTdc uTTepTreTOjLievai xct^cn^uJc Kai fx6- \\c, ou voiaiZeic Kai t6 v^KTap auTuj bucTropiCTOv eivai lo 157 ^^^ CTTdviov, UJCTC qpeibecGai Kai Ttapexeiv ^KdcTUJ Te- Ta)iieu|ievov ; '
14, '"lcujc' emev 6 Xepciac" 'dXX* Ittci TrdXiv Trepi oiKOVOiaiac Xoyoc YeYOve, Tic av u)liujv qppdceiev f\)x\v t6 dTtoXeiTToiaevov j dTToXeiTreTai b' oi|uai kttj- w ceiOc Ti Xapeiv jueTpov auTdpKOuc Kai kavfic ko)ae- vric'. Kai 6 KXeopouXoc 'dXXdToTc /i^v cocpoTc' Iqpn '/aeTpov 6 v6)i0c bebu)K€, Trpoc bk. touc qpauXouc Ipui XoYOV Tfic ejLific 9uYaTp6c 5v TTp6c t6v dbeXq)6v et- Ttev. eq>x] Ydp Tf|v CeXf|vriv beicGai Tfjc ^auTfjc janTp^c 20 8ttujc auTTi xiTutviov uq)fivri cu)H|aeTpov • Tfiv b* eiTreTv B 'Kai TTUJC cu)n|ueTpov u(pf|vuj; vOv m^v Ydp 6puj ce TTavce'Xr|Vov, aOeic be )Lirivoeibfi , tot^ b' d)aq)iKupTov '. ouTUJ br\, <J) q)iXe Xepcia, Kai TTp6c dv6pujTT0v dv6ri- Tov Ka\ q)aOXov oubev dcTi lueTpov ouciac • dXXoTe 25 Ydp dXXoc ecTi TaTc xptiaic bid Tdc eTTi6u)aiac Kai xdc Tuxac, ujcrrep 6 Aicujttou kuujv, 6v outoci q)riciv ^v TU) xciM^J^vi cucTpeq)6)aevov Kai cucTreipu))Lievov bid t6 piYo£(y oiKiav TTOieTv biavoeTcGai, eepouc b' au TTdXiv ^KTeTajui^vov KaeeubovTa q)aivec6ai )u^Yav ^au- 30
2, 31-32 H. 6. 595-597 R.
14. TT€pi W
SAPIENTUM CONVIVIUM 359
Tiu Ktti ^ryr' dvaYKaiov fiYeicGai lariTe jiiKpov ^pTOV oiKiav TTepipaXecBai TOcauTnv. f\ Tctp oux 6pac' eiTTev ^uj Xepcia, Kai toOc cpaiiXouc vOv |uev eic fiiKpd ko- luibn cucTe'X\ovTac ^auTouc ibc CTpoTTuXujc Kai AaKUj- c
6 viKoic piiuco|u^vouc, vOv be, ei iuf) Td TrdvTUJV ^xo^civ ibiuJTUJV djua Ktti paciXeujv, un' dvbeiac dTToXeTc9ai vo)LiiZ;ovTac ; ' ujc ouv 6 Xepciac dTreciujTrricev, uTToXa- pdjv 6 KXeobujpoc 'dXXd Kai Toijc coqpouc' emev 'u)Lidc 6puj)iev dvicoic )ae'Tpoic Tdc KTriceic vev6)Liri)Lid-
10 vac TTpoc dXXr|Xouc ^xovTac*. Kai 6 KXedpouXoc '6 Tdp Toi vojuoc ' eTrrev ' uj pe'XTiCTe dvbpuiv, ujc u(pdv-
TT^C ^KdcTUJ t6 TTpe'TTOV fl)LlU)V Kai To |ue'Tpiov Kai t6 dpiiOTTOV dTTobibujci. Kai cu Ka0dTT6p vojuiiu Tiu XoTip D Tpe(pujv Kai biaiToiv Kai <pap)LtaK6uujv touc KdiiVovTac
15 ouK icov iKdcTUJ, t6 be rrpocfiKOV dTrove'|ueic dTTaciv '. uTToXapujv b' 6 "ApbaXoc ' dp ' ouv ' ecpr) ' Kai t6v iTaT- pov u)uu)V CoXujvoc be Hevov 'GTTi^evibrjv vojuoc tic drTc'- XecGai tujv dXXujv ciTiujv KeXeuei, Tf^c b' dXijuou bu- vdjueujc r\y auTdc cuvTi0rici )uiKp6v eic t6 CTOjua Xa)u-
20 pdvovTa biriiuepeueiv dvdpicTOv Kai dbeiiTVOV ; ' em- CTricavTOC be toO X6tou t6 cujurrociov 6 )uev GaXf^c eTTiCKUJTTTUJV eij qppoveTv eqpri tov 'ETTi^uevibrjv 6ti jufj PouXcTai TTpdTfiaTa ^x^iv dXuJv Td cma Kai ttcttujv dauTUJ, Ka0dTT6p TTiTTaKoc. ctuj Tdp' eiTre *Tfic E
25 Eevnc fJKOuov dboucTic Trp6c t^v juuXriv, ^v 'Cpecuj Tev6)uevoc,
'dXei ^iuXa dXei'
Kai Tdp TTiTTaK6c fiXei
)ueTdXac MiTuXdvac paciXeuujv'.
30 6 be CoXuJV e(pn 0au)udz;eiv t6v "ApbaXov ei t6v v6-
2, 32-33 H. 6, 597—599 K.
3. qpaOXouc*: jniKpoOc 13. KaBdrrep*: KaGdTrep riD
360 SEPTEM
|Liov ouK dveTVUJKe Tfjc biaitric toO dvbpoc ev toTc ^Tteci toTc 'Hciobou TeTpa|a)Lie'vov * ^kcTvoc Tdp ^ctiv 6 TTpujToc '€7Ti|uevibri cn^pinata thc Tpocpfic TauTric Trapacxiuv Kai ZiriTeTv 6 bibdgac
'ocov ^v laaXdxr) tc Kai dcqpobe^Xiu )ae'T' oveiap'. 5 F 'oiei Tdp' 6 TTepiavbpoc eiTre 'tov 'Hciobov lvvonca{ Ti toioOtov, ouk eTiaiveTriv 6vTa qpeibouc dei Kai Trpoc Td XiTOTaTa tujv oqjujv ujc fibicTa TrapaKaXeTv fiindc; dTaGf) |Liev Tdp f] ^aXdxn PpujGnvai, tXukuc b' 6 dv6e'piK0C" Td b' dXijaa TaOTa Kai dbiipa qpdpi^aKa lo jLidXXov ^ ciTia TruvGdvo^ai, Kai jLieXi Kai Tupov Tiva PappapiKov bexecGai, Kai crrepiLiaTa TTd)iTToXXa tuuv
OUK eUTTOpiCTUJV. TTUJC OUV OUK Sv TU» 'Hciobuj TO 'TTTlbdXlOV |Ll^V UTT^p KaTTVOU ' Kei|Lievov
'^PTa poujv b' dTToXoiTO Kai fmiovujv TaXaep- is
TiiJv', ei TOcauTric bericeie TrapacKeufic ; eau|ndZ;uj be cou t6v 158 g^vov w CoXujv ei AnXioic ^vaTXOC TTOiricdjaevoc tov /aeTav Ka6ap|a6v oux iCToprice nap' auToTc eic t6 le- p6v KO|Lii26iaeva Tfic TTpuuTrjC uTTO)ivr||LiaTa Tpoqpfic Kai 20 beiTMaTa |ieT' dXXujv euTeXujv Kai auToqpuuiv laaXdxnv Kai dve^piKOv, iLv eiKdc ^cti koi t6v 'Hciobov TTpo- SeveTv niLiTv Tf|V XiTOTriTa Kai Tf|V dqpeXeiav'. 'ou TaOTtt' ^qpri *)li6vov' 6 'Avdxapcic *dXXd Kai TTp6c uTieiav ^v toTc iudXicTa tuiv Xaxdvujv ^KdTcpov ^TTai- veTTai'. Kai 6 KXeobujpoc '6p6u)c' ^qpn 'XcTeic- ia- B tpik6c Tdp u)V 'Hcioboc bfjXoc ecTiv ouk d|ieXuJc oub*
2, 33—34 H. 6, 699—6(10 R.
2. *Hci66ou] 0. et D. 41 13. flv Pflugkius: Iv
Hci6buj] 0. et D. 45 14. yikv* 17. b€»ic€i6*: 6enc€i
27. Ouv 'Hc{o6oc*: r)clo6oc iwc
1
J
SAPIENTUM CONVIVIUM 361
dTT€ipujc TTepl bmiTric koi Kpdceuuc oivou Kai dpeTfic ubaTOC Kai XouTpoO Kai YuvaiKoiv biaXeTo.uevoc Kai cuvouciac KaipoO Kai Ppe(pujv KaGiceujc. dXX' 'Hcio- bou }xk.v iiioi boKei biKaioTepov Aicujttoc auTov dTto-
5 cpaiveiv )ua9riTfiv r\ '€Tn|uevibr|c • toutuj t dp dpxnv T^c KaXfjc TauTnc Kai iTOiKiXric Kal uoXufXiuccou co- q)iac 6 TTpoc Tr^v drjbova Xotoc toO ie'paKoc TTape'cxri- Kev. It^ b' av fibeujc dKOucaifii CoXujvoc eiKOc Ydp auTOV TT€TTuc6ai, TToXuv xpovov 'AOrjVTiciv '6TTi)Lievibrj
10 cuf Tev6)Lievov, 6 xi br| TraGujv r| cocpiZoiaevoc Itti toi- auTHV fiXGe biaiTav'.
15. Kai 6 CoXujv ecpri 'ti be toOto iKeivov dpuj- Tdv ebei; bfiXov fdp r\v oti toO )ieficTOu tujv dfaGujv C Kai KpaTicTou beuTepov ecTi to beicGai Tpoqpfic Ppa-
i^X^TdTric, ei fe ^nefiCTOv coi boKei t6 )nr|b' oXujc Tpo- 9fic beicGai'. 'ouba^auuc' 6 KXedbujpoc 'e^uoife' eiTTev, 'ei bei Td (paiv6)ievov eiTreTv, Kai )LidXiCTa TTapaK€i|Lie- vric TpaTTeJric, fiv dvaipoOciv aipo)Ltevric Tpocpfjc cpiXiuJV Geujv pujjiov oucav Kai Heviujv. ibc be GaXfjc Xefei
20 Tfic f fic dvaipeGeicric cufxuciv tov oXov ^'Heiv kocjuov, ouTUJC oiKOu bidXucic ecTi* cuvavaipeiTai fdp auT^ ttOp ecTioOxov ecTia KpaTfjpec UTtoboxai HeviC)aoi, q)i- XavGpujTT^TaTa Kai TrpOuTa KOivujvf|)LiaTa Trpoc dXXrj- Xouc, )LidXXov be cu)LiTTac 6 pioc, ei fe biafujffi Tic D
25 ecTiv dvGpujTTOu TTpdHeujv ^xo^ca bieHobov, uiv f) ttic Tpocpfjc xptia Kai TrapacKeuf) Tdc TTXeicTac rrapaKaXei.
2, 34—36 H. 6, 600—602 B.
3. Kaeiceujc] Hesiod. 0. et D. 750 'Hci66ou] 0. et
D. 203 15. ei f€*: et td coi W: eu 18. rpa-
n^Ztic r\v ai6oO|aai qpiXiujv GeiJuv Puu^iov oOcav xai Heviujv et ouTwc oiKou 6idXuclc kxi aipojuevric Tpoqpfic W 24. ei
fe Xylander: ei xf
362 SEPTEM
beivov |uev ouv, iL draTpe, Kai t6 T^iwpYiac auTfj" biaXuo|a^VTi Totp auGic dTroXeiTrei yr\v f)|LiTv a)aopq)ov Kai dKd6apT0v, uXnc dKdpTrou Kai peu)LidTiuv TTXri|U|Lie- Xujc (pep0|aevujv utt' dpYiac dvdTrXeujv. cuvaTToXXuci 6e Kai Te'xvac rrdcac Kai epYaciac, iLv ^Hapxdc ^ti 5 Kai Trapexei pdciv Trdcaic Kai uXriv, Kai t6 nribiv ei-
E ci, TauTHc GKTTobujv Y€V0)Li^vTic. KaTaXuovTai bk Kai Ti)aai 0eu)v, 'HXiiu )iev )LiiKpdv, eTi b' ^XdTTUj CeXrjvri Xdpiv auYfic )u6vov Kai dXe'ac dvGpuJTTUJV exovTUJV. 6)appiiu be Aii Kai npoTipocia Ar||aiiTpi Kai qpuTaXjiiuj lo TToceibuivi TToO Puj|li6c ecTai, ttoO be Gucia; ttuic b' XapiboTric 6 Aiovucoc, ei beric6)ie6a )ur|bev6c ujv bi- bujci; Ti be 0uco)li€v fj CTreico|U€V; Tivoc b' dTrapHo- )Lie6a5 TTdvTa Ydp TaOTa tuiv jueYicTUJV dvaTpoTTfjv Kai cuYXVJCiv exei TTpaY)idTUJV. fibovfic be TTdcrjC ^kv ttc- i5 pie'x€c6ai Kai rrdvTUJC dXoYicT^v Icti, Trdcav be qpeu- Yeiv Kai TrdvTUJC dvaicGnTOv. Tfjv luev oOv vjjuxnv eTepaic ticiv fibovaTc xpnc9«i KpeiTTOCiv urrapxeTUj,
F Tuj be cui)uiaTi XapeTv fibovfiv Tfic dTT6 toO Tpe'(pec6ai biKaiOT^pav ouK ^ctiv, OTrep oubeva Xe'Xri0ev dv6puj- 20 TTUJV • TauTHV Y«P cv )i^cuj 6e|Li6voi KoivujvoOciv dXXfi- Xoic beiTTVUJV Kai TpaTreZiric , dqjpobiciujv be vuKTa Kai
TTOXu TTpopdXXoVTai CKOTOC, fiYou)Lievoi t6 TOUTUJV KOl-
vujveTv dvaicxuvTOV eivai Kai 6ripujubec, ujc t6 )afi KOivujveTv ^Keivrjc'. uTToXapujv ouv eYuJ toO KXeo- bujpou biaXiTTOVTOC 'cKeTvo b' ou Xe'Y€ic' elTTOv, '6ti Kai t6v uttvov djua Tfj Tpoqpfi cuveKpdXXo|Liev; uttvou 169 be jifi 6vT0c oub' oveipoc ecTiv, dXX' oiX€Tai t6 Trpe-
2, 36—37 H. 6, 602—604 R.
7. bk Meziriacus 8. iuev Eeiskius: bi 11. Icxai
idem: ^CTi 20. ^cxxv*: ^ctiv eOpeiv 23, t6 toOtujv
Reiskius: TaOTnc t6
SAPIENTUM CONVIVIUM 363
cpuTaiov fijuiv laavieTov. ^ciai be liovoeibfic 6 pioc, Kai rpoTTOv Tivd M«Tr|v to cuj)aa rrepiKeiceTai if\ ipu- Xrj" Td irXeiCTa ydp auTOu Kai KupiOuTaTa tujv iLiepuJV im Tfjv Tpoqprjv optava TrapecKcuacTai , Y^wTTa Kai
5 6b6vTec Kai CTOjuaxoc Kai fiTrap. dpTOV Tdp oubev ^CTiv oube TTpoc dXXriv cuvTeTaYMevov xP^ictv' ujc0' 6 ^fi beojaevoc Tpocpfic oube cwjLiaToc beiTai. toOto b' auTov fjv auToO |af] beicGai • cuv cu»|aaTi ydp fijaujv ^KacToc'. 'fiiueic pev ouv' eqjriv t{dj 'TauTac Tr|
10 f acTpi cujuPoXdc €iccpe'pO|uev' ei be CoXujv fj tic aX- Xoc Ti KaTriTopei, dKouc6|ue9a.'
16. 'TTdvu )Li€v ouv' ^cpx] 6 CdXotv, '/afi Kai tuiv B AiYUTTTiujv dKpiTiuTepoi <pavu)|a€V, o'i tov veKpov dva- T€|i6vTec ebeiHav tuj fiXiuj, ** eiT' auTd luev eic tov
isTTOTafiov KaTe'paXov, toO b' dXXou cuuiuaToc ujc fibri KaGapoO T€TOv6toc dTTijU€'XovTai. Tqj Tdp 6vTi to0t6 ecTi t6 luiacjua t^c capKoc fnuoiv Kai 6 TdpTapoc 6 ev "Aibou, beivijuv Tivujv peujudTUJV Kai TTveufiaTOc 6|uo0 Kai TTupoc cu|UTTe<pup)ue'vou Kai veKpOuv TTepmXeujc.
80 Z^oiv Tdp oubeic ott' oubevoc Tpe'(peTai ZidjvToc, dXXd GavaToOvTec Td cjuvpuxa Kai Td (pu6|ueva tuj Tpeqpe- c0ai Kai auEec0ai |ieTe'xovTa toO Zfiv diroXXuvTec dbi- KoOjuev. drr^XXuTai Tdp eH ou TT€'(puKe to |ueTapdXXov C eic fiXXo, Kai Tracav q)0eip€Tai <p0opdv, ottujc av 0a-
25 Tepou Tpoq)fi TtvoiTO. TO b' dTTe'xec0ai capKuiv ebuj- biic, ujCTTep 'Opq)ea tov TraXaiov icTopoOci, c6q)ic|ua lifiXXov f| q)UTfl TuJv Trepi Tfiv Tpoqpnv dbiKrijudTUJV ecTi. q)UTf) be |uia Kai KaGapjuoc eic biKaiocuvriv t6
2, 37— 38H. 6, 604— 60CR.
13. dvaTe|Li6vT€C W^inckelmannus: dvoT^luvovTcc 14.
Feci asteriscos 20. ou6€ic Reiskius 28. t6 teAciov
KOl*: T€\eiot
i
364 SEPTEM
TcXeiov Ka\ auTdpKri koi dTTpocbefi Y€vec9ai. il» b* (5v€u KaKUiCCuuc ^T^pou Tfjv auToO cuiTripiav dprixavov 6 Gedc TTeTTo(riK€, toutuj Tf]v qpuciv dpxnv dbiKiac TTpocT^GeiKev. dp' ouv ouk fi£iov, ili q)iX€, cuv€kt€- Heiv dbiKiqt KoiXiav Ka\ CTOfjaxov Ka\ ?iTTap, S KaXoO t D )i€v oubevoc aicGriciv fmiv oub* 6p€Eiv ^vbibiuci, CKeueci hk. )iaT€ipiKOic, ota KOTTibec Kai X^prjTCC, to be ^uXtudpiKoTc Kai Ka^ivoic Ka\ cppeiupuxoic Kai }xa-
KTTlpioiC ?01K€V; dT€XVOuC bi TUJV TToXXuJV ibOl TIC fiv
uicTTep iv ^uXuJvi Tuj cuufiaTi Tf|v ijiuxfiv ^TKCKaXuii- 1 ^evTiv dei TTep\ Tfjv ttic Tpoqpfjc xptiav KUKXoOcav, uicTTep dji^ei Ka\ fmeic dpn ^tv ouG' ^ujpu»|i€v d Xr|Xouc out' T^Kouo|i€V, dXX' ^KacTOC dtKeKuqpiuc ^boii Xeue Tr) Trepi Tf^v Tpoqpnv xpc>a- vuv\ b' ^TrapGeicOu' tOuv TpaTTe2[uiv ^XeuOepoi feTOvoTec wc 6pqic, ^CTcq^a vuj|i€VOi TTep\ XoTOuc biaTpipoMCV Kai dXXriXoic cuv
E ecfiev Ka\ cxoXfiv dTO|i€v, elc Td jif) beic8ai Tpocpf^ dXriXue6T€c. dp' ouv, dvTTep f| vOv ouca Trep\ n^di eEic dTTaucToc bia^evri Trapa TrdvTa t6v piov, ouk d€ cxoXfjv ^Eo^ev dXXf|Xoic cuveivai, |in bebioTec neviai ^nb' elbdTec ttXoOtov; 6 Tdp tujv ncpiccuiv lf\\o{ euSuc dKoXou0ei Ka\ cuvoiKiZcTai n^ XPtia tuiv dvaf Kaiu)V. dXX* oieTai beiv Tpo(pfiv eivoi KXeobwpoc 6Trujc xpdneZai Ka\ KpaTf\pec iZici, koi ArmnTpi kq Kdpij eOw^ev. ^Tepoc bi tic dEiouTUJ Moxac elva Ka\ ndXejiOV, iva Ka\ Teixn Ka\ veujcoiKouc Ka\ 6nXo-
F efiKac ?xi"Mfv Ka\ eOwiiev ^KaTO^qpdvia, Kaedn€p q)aci vd^ov elvai Mecrjvioic. fiXXov bk npoc Tfiv Oritiav
8,98— 40 H. 6.«»-««
11. Tpo<pf|c Amiotus: «|>uxf)c 14. inapecicdiv W:
napaTcQcuujv 24. Kol AfjMnTpi*: a"5 bfjMriTpi *25. 00-
lU^CV*: eOeTCi {ti
J
SAPIENTUM CONVIVIUM 365
oTjuai xctXeTraiveiv • beivov Top ei mi^^voc vocoOvtoc 011 CTpuu)avfic ^Ti jiaXaKfic oqpeXoc oii kXivhc, oub' 'AckXtittiuj Gucoiaev oOk dTroTpOTraioic, iaTpiKf) bk nera opxdviuv Kai qpapiLidKUJV KeiceTai tocoutuuv dKXefic Kai
5 dTToGecTOC. f| Ti TaOTa eKeivujv biaqpe'pei; Kai xdp r\ Tpoqpf) XijuoO qpdp/aaKov irpocdYeTai, Kai GepaTteueiv eauTouc XeTOVTai TrdvTec oi Tpeqpojnevoi, oux wc r\hv 160 Ti Kai Kexapicjuevov dXX' wc dvaTKaiov toOto t^ qpu- cei TTpdtTOVTec. eTiei XuTrac t€ TiXeiovdc ecTiv dTto
10 TTic Tpoqpfjc Tuuv fibovOuv TiTVOjuevac KaTapi9|Lificai, ludXXov b' f] |Liev fibovfi Kai tottov exei Ppaxuv ev tu) cuu|LiaTi Kai xpovov ou ttoXuv fj be TTepi Tfjv bioi- KTiciv auTfic dcxoXia Kai bucxepeia ti bei XcTeiv ocujv aicxpOjv Kai obuvripujv fmdc ejaTTiTrXriciv ; oT|iai Tdp
15 eic TaOTa pXe'ipavTa tov "0|UTipov dTTobeiHei KexpficGai Trepi GeOuv toO fir\ dTToGvfiCKeiv tlu |Lifi TpeqpecGai 'ou Tdp cTtov Ibouc', ou TTivouc' aT9oTTa oTvov touvck" dvaijLiovec eici Kai d9dvaToi KaXeovTai*,
U)C jLlf] ILIOVOV TOO IflV dXXd Kai TOO dTT09vf|CK€lV Tf|V B
20 Tpoqpfiv ^qpobiov oijcav. ck TauTric Tdp ai vocoi cuv- Tpeqpd^evai toTc cuuiuiaciv ouk eXarrov dvbeiac KaKov exouci Tfjv TrXfjpujciv TToXXdKic be Kai )ieT26v dcTiv ^PTOv ToO TTOpicai Tpoqpfiv Kai cuvaTaTeTv to Kar- avaXuicai Kai biaqpopficai TTdXiv eic t6 cOujLia TTapa-
25 TevojLievriv. dXX' OuCTTep ei biarTopoTev ai AavaTbec Tiva piov PiuucovTai Kai Ti TTpdEouciv drTaXXaTeicai Tfic TTepi t6v TTi9ov XaTpeiac Kai uX?ipuuceuJC , outuu
2, 40—41 H. 6, 608- 6 10 B.
2. ou6'*: ouK 4. KciceTai*: dTTOKeiceTai 5. d-rrd-
OecToc W: dTr69eToc 7. Tpeqpofaevoi Reiskius: Tpe(p6)i€-
voi biaiTav 9. f€ idem: Te vel toc 15. ToOTa Pflug-
kius: TocaOTO 17. Homer. € 341
366 SEPTEM
biaTropoO|a£v fmek, €i tcvoito TraucacGai qpopoOvTac C eic Tfjv YCicT^pa jf\v ctTpuTOv eK ff]c a)ia mi GaXdtTTric TOcaOTa, Ti 7TpdEo)aev dTreipia tijuv KaXuJv tov Im ToTc dvatKaioic CTepyovTec piov. ujCTrep ouv oi bou- XeucavTec, oTav eXeuGepujGujciv, a TidXai toTc becTid- 5 Taic ^TTpaTTOv UTtripeToOvTec , TaOTa TrpdTTouciv ou- ToTc Kai bx' auTOuc, outujc fi v|juxfi vOv |nev Tpecpei t6 cdijua TioXXoTc ttovoic Kai dcxoXiaic, ei b' dTtaX- XaTein Tfic XaTpeiac, auTf|v bnTTouOev eXeuSepav t^- vo|aevTiv 9pe'ipei Kai piuuceTai eic auTfjv opujca Kai Tfjv lo dXf|9eiav, oubevoc TrepicrrujvTOC oub' dTtdTOVTOc/ Td |iiev ouv pTi9€'vTa Ttepi Tpocpnc, «B NiKapxe, toOt' y]v. 17. "€ti bk ToO CoXujvoc Xctovtoc €icfiX9e rdp- Toc 6 TTepidvbpou dbeXqpoc • eTUTX«ve Tdp eic Taiva- D pov dTT€CTaX|iievoc ck tivujv xPICMwv, tu» TToceibiJuvi is 9uciav Kai 9€U)piav dTtdTUJV. dcTTaca)Ltevujv b' fiiuujv auTov Kai ToO TTepidvbpou TTpocaTaTO)Lie'vou Kai q>ikr\- cavTOC Ka9icac rrap' auTov im Tfjc kXivtic dTTJiTTei- Xev ciTTa bf| TTpoc iiiovov cKeTvov, 6 b' TiKpodTO, TToXXd TTdcxovTi TTpoc Tov XoTov 6|iiOioc uJv. Td )aev 20 Tdp dx96)aevoc Td b' dTavaKTuiv eqjaiveTO, TToXXdKic ] b' dmcTUJV, eiTa 9au)iidz:ujv • TeXoc be Tc^dcac ttp6c i]\x&c ' pouXo)iiai )aev ' ^cpri ' Trpoc t6 TTap6v qppdcai t6 TTpocriTTeXjLi^vov • 6kviju b' dKOucac 0dXeu) TTOTe eiTTOV- E Toc oTi beT Td |u^v eiKOTa Xe'T€iv, Td b' d|Lif|xava ciuu- i TTdv'. uTToXapujv oijv 6 Biac 'dXXd Kai toOt'' eqpii ' OdXeuj t6 coqpov ecTiv, oti beT toTc |iev €x9poTc Kai TTepi Tujv TTiCTujv dTTicTeTv, ToTc be qpiXoic Kai Td dTTicTa TTicTeueiv, dx9pouc )Lie'v, ctujt ' fiToOjuai , touc TTOvripouc Kai dvof|TOUC, qpiXouc bk touc xPHCTOuc Kai qppovi- so ^ouc auToO KaXoOvToc'. 'oukoOv' Iqpn 'XeKT€'ov eic
2, 41— 42 H. 6, 610— 611 B,
10
I
SAPIENTUM CONVIVIUM 367
anavTac, u) r6pY€, )id\\ov b' ^HapKteov touc veouc TOUTOuc bi6upd|iPouc uTrepq)8eTT6M€VOV dv fiKeic \6tov f]ixiv KO|aiZ!ujv'.
18. "Eqpri toivuv fopYoc oti Tf|C Guciac eqp ' f]\ii-
5 pac TpeTc cuvTe\ec6eicric urr' auToO Ka\ Tf) TeXeuTaia TTavvuxiboc oucric Kai xopeiac tivoc Kai Traibidc Trapd F Tov aiTiaXov f] |Liev ce\fivri KaTe\ajaTTev eic Triv ed- XaTTav, ouK ovtoc be TTveujuaTOC dWd vrive)iiac Kai Ta\f|vric TToppiueev dq^euupdTO (ppiKti KaTiouca Ttapd
10 Tf]v dKpav, dqppov Tiva Kai vppqpov dTOuca tiu poeiiu TTepi auTf]v TTo\uv, ujCTe TidvTac eTri tov tottov ou TrpocpdWeiv eineWe KaTabpaiaeiv eau)adcavTac. Trpiv b' eiKdcai t6 rrpoccpepofievov otto Tdxouc, &eXq)Tvec uj(pericav, o'i )nev dep6oi Tre'piE kukXouvt€C, o'i b' uqjri- 161
15 Toujuevoi ToO aiTiaXoO Trpoc to XeiOTaTOv, dXXoi b' eH^TTiceev, oTov TrepieTrovTec. ev juecuj b' dveTxev urrep Tfjc eaXdccric otkoc dcaq)fic Kai dcriMoc oxou- laevou cuu)aaT0c, laexpi ou cuvaTWT^VTec eic TauTo Kai cuverroKeiXavTec eHe'eriKav eTri t^IV dvepujTrov
20 ^fiTTVOuv Kai Kivoujuevov, auToi be rrdXiv Trpoc Tfiv OKpav dva9ep6)ievoi iudWov f\ TrpdTepov dHfjXavTO, TraiZovTec uq)' fibovfic tivoc ujc eoiKe Kai CKipTujvTec. 'f)|iuuv be' 6 r6pT0c €q)r| 'ttoWoi )uev bmapaxeev- Tec eq)UTOv dTro Tfjc eaXdccnc, 6XiT0i be )li€t' e)LioO
25 eappficavTec rrpoceXeeTv eTVuOpicav 'Apiova tov Kiea- pujbdv, auTOV TOuvo)ia q^eeTT^M^vov ^auToO, Kai tx} B CToXf] KaTaq)avfi T€v6)Lievov • tov Tap evaTiuviov ctut- Xavev d)iTT€x6)Li€voc k6cjuov, iL Kieapujbuuv expfiTO. ko-
2, 42-43 H. 6, 611-613 R
1. b' dcTdov Hauptius*: bk dKx^ov ^ttI 12. irpocpdX-
Xeiv ^iLieXXe Reiskius: irpoc^iaeXXe 18. cuvaTOT<ivTec W:
cuvciTOVTec 28. ^xP^to*: ^xpflcctTO
368 SEPTEM
/iicavT€c ouv ^TTi CKrjvnv auTov, ujc oObev eTx€ KaKOV dXX* f| bid Tdxoc Ktti poTi^ov ^qpaiv€TO Tfjc q)opac ^KXeXujiievoc Kai KeK)uriKUiC, tiKOucaMev Xoyov duiCTOv dTTaci ttXtiv fiinOjv tujv Geacaiaeviuv t6 TeXoc. IXeye Ydp 'Apiuuv ujc TTdXai )aev eTvuJKUJC ^k ttic 'iTaXiac 5 dTiaipeiv, TTepidvbpou be rpdviJavTOC auTu» TTpoGu^o- Tepoc Tev6|Lievoc 6XKdboc Kopiv9iac TTapaqpaveicric euGuc ^TTipdc dvaxOeiri, M^Tpiuj be TTveu|aaTi XP^M^- vujv fm^pac TpeTc aicGoiTo touc vauTac dTTipouXeuovTOC
C dveXeTv auTov, elTa Kai Trapd tou KuPepvr|TOu ttuQoito t Kpucpa firivucavTOc ibc Tfj vukti toOto bpfiv auToTc ^Tti beboYluevov. Iprmoc ouv luv porieeiac Kai dTTO- pujv 6p)arj tivi xPHcaiTo baijLioviuj t6 ^ev ciu^a KOC|if^- cai Kai XaPeTv evTdqpiov auTuJ t6v ^vayujviov Iti Iwv Kociaov, iiacax be t6v piov TeXeuTuiv Kai |af| T€vec6ai i» KaTd toOto tu»v kukvujv dTevvecTepoc. dcKeuac^e'voc ouv Kai TTpoeiTTUJV 6ti TTpoGu^ia tic auT6v ^xo' tujv voMUJV bieX9eTv Tdv TTueiK6v uTrep cujTripiac auToO Ktti Tfjc veujc Kai tu»v diaTrXeovTUJV , KOTOCTdc Trapd
D t6v toTxov ^v TTpu)avrj Kai Tiva eeujv TreXaTiujv dvd- 20 kXticiv TTpoavaKpoucd|ievoc aboi t6v v6)aov. Kai 6cov ourruj laecoOvTOC auToO KaTabuoiTO iikv 6 f^Xioc elc ttjv OdXaTTav, dvaqpaivoiTO b' f] TTeXoTrdvvricoc. ouk- ^T* ouv Tujv vauToiv Tfjv vuKTa TT€pi|aev6vTUJV dXXd XUJpouvTUJV ^TTi t6v qpovov, ibujv Eiqpr) T^Tuiavuj^i^va 2J Kai TTapaKaXuTTT^jaevov fjbri t6v Kupepvf|Triv, dvabpa- faujv ^iijjeiev dauT6v ujc buvaT6v fjv ladXicTa rrdppuj TTic 6XKdboc. TTpiv b' oXov KOTabOvai t6 cuiMa beX- qpivujv UTTobpafi6vTUJV dvaqp^poiTO, )aecT6c uiv drropiac l m\ dTUJviac Kai Tapaxfjc t6 rrpujTOV • ^Trei bk pacTujvr]
2, 43— MH. 6. 613-615
16. t6v p(ov ReiBkius: Ttli piiu 30. dTuiviac * : dTvoCac
SAPIENTUM CONVIVIUM 369
rfic oxnceujc fjv, Kai ttoXXouc duupa d9poito|iievouc Trepi auTov eujuevujc Kai biabexojnevouc ujc dvaYKaiov E ev iuepei XeiTOupYimct Kai irpocfiKOV Traciv, x] h' oXKdc dTcoXei(p9eTca Ttoppuj toO toxouc aic9r|civ Trapelxe,
5 )ar|Te tocoOtov eqpn beouc upoc 9dvaTOV auTuJ jliiit' eTTi9u)aiac toO lf]v ocov qpiXoTiiaiac eTTevec9ai Trpoc Tfjv cujTripiav, ujc 9eocpiXfic dvfip cpaveir) Kai Xdpoi Ttapd 9euJv boHav Pepaiov. a)iia bk Ka9opd»v tov ou- pavov dcTe'pujv TrepiTrXeujv Kai Tfiv C€Xr|vr|V dvicxou-
10 cav euqpeTTfi Kai Ka9apdv, dcTUJcric Te TrdvTri Tfjc 9a- Xdccric dKujaovoc ujcrrep Tpipov dvacxiZiojuevov tuj bpo- F |uuj, biavoeTc9ai Trpoc auTov ibc ouk ecTiv eic 6 Tfjc AlKnc 6q)9aX|u6c, dXXd Trdci toutoic eTriCKOTreT kukXuj 6 9e6c Td TrpaTTOiueva rrepi fr\v re Kai 9dXaTTav. tou-
15 TOic be hi] ToTc XoTicjuoTc eqpri t6 Kd|uvov auTuJ Kai Papuvdjuevov fibri toO cium«toc dvacpepecOai, Kai Te- Xoc eTrei Tfjc OKpac dTravToucnc dTroTOjuou Kai uipriXfic e\j Trujc (puXaHdjuevoi Kai Kd|uqjavTec (ev XP^J Tdp evfj- XovTO Tfjc Tfic) uJCTrep eic Xi|ueva CKdqpoc dccpaXuJc
20 KardTOVTec ,** rravTdTraciv aicOecOai 9eo0 Kupepvficei 162 TeTovevai Tfiv KO)uibfiv. TaOTa' 6 fopTOc eqpri 'toO 'Apiovoc eiTTOVTOC rjpoiuriv auTov ottou Tfjv vaOv oie- Tai KaTacxf|ceiv. 6 be rrdvTUJC )uev elc KopivOov, TToXu )uevTOi Ka9ucTepeTv* auT6v Tdp lcrrepac eKTre-
25 covTa TrevTaKOciujv ou \ie\ov oiec9ai bp6)uov CTabiujv K0)uic9fivai, Kai TctXfivTiv eu9uc KttTacxeTv.' ou lufjv dXX' dauT6v 6 fopToc eqpr) Tru96|uevov toO Te vauKXn- pou TOuvo|ua Kai toO KupepvfjTOu Kai Tfjc vedic t6 Trapd- crijuov eKTre'juvpai rrXoTa Kai CTpaTiuuTac ini Tdc KttTdp-
3, 44-46 H. 6, 615-616 E.
8. irapct Reiskius: Trepi 10. xe*: bk 19. dcqpo-
\ilic Reiskius: dcqpaXec 20. Hiatum significavi
Plutarchi Moralia. Vol. I. 24
370 SEFTEM
B ceic TrapaqjuXdSovTac • tov b' 'Apiova iuct' auToO ko- ^ilew diTOKeKpuiujLievov , ottuuc jafi TtpoaicGojLievoi Triv cuuTripiav biacpuYOiev. ovtujc ouv eoiKevai Geia ivyri t6 irpa-f Ma • irapeTvai Ydp auTOuc d|Lia beupo Kai ttuv- GdvecGai Tfic veujc KeKpaTrmevric uiro tujv CTpaTiwTUJV r, cuveiXfiqpGai touc ejuiTopouc koi vauTac.
19. '0 jufev ouv TTepiavbpoc eKeXeucev eu9uc eHa- vacTdvTa tov fopTOV eic qpuXaKriv d7To9ec6ai touc dv- bpac ou iLiTibeic auToTc Trpoceici ixr\bk (ppdcei tov 'Apiova c€cu>c|Lie'vov • 6 b' Aicu)ttoc 'dXX' ujueTc' eqpri 'touc eiiiouc lo xXeudZ^eTe koXoiouc Kai KopaKac ei biaXeTOVTai • beXq)T- vec be TOiaOTa veavieuovTai ; ' KdTUJ Trpoc auTov ' dX- Xo Ti XeTUJ|nev' ecprjv 'ui AicujTre' toutlu be tuj Xotuj
C TTiCT€uo)Lie'vuj Kai TPatpojuevuj Trap ' fi|LiTv TtXeov ri xiXia €Tri biaTCTOve Kai dTio tiuv 'IvoOc Kai 'A9djuavT0C i Xpdvujv'. 6 be CdXujv uTToXapuuv 'dXXd TaOTa \xev, w AiOKXeic, iffvc Geujv ecTUJ Kai uTrep fiiLiac* dv- 6pu)Trivov bk Kai Trpoc fijuac t6 toO 'Hcidbou TTd6oc' dKf|Koac Tdp icujc t6v Xotov'. 'ouk ^t^jtc' eiTTOV. 'dXXd jufiv dHiov TTu6ec6ai. MiXr|ciou Tdp, ujc eoi- 20 Kev, dvbpoc, (I) Heviac eKoivu)vei 6 'Hcioboc Kai biai- Tric ev AoKpoTc, Tfj toO Hevou 6uTaTpi Kpuqpa cutt^- vo)Li€vou Kai q)Ujpa6evToc UTTOvpiav 4'cxev iLc tvouc
D dTT' dpxfic Kai cuveTTiKpuqjac t6 dbiKniua, )LiTibev6c uuv aiTioc, opTrj b' dKaipuj Kai biapoXfj TrepiTrecwv dbi- 25I Kujc. dTTCKTeivav Tdp auT6v 01 ttic TraibicKric dbeXqjoi TTepi t6 AoKpiK6v Nejueiov evebpeucavTec, Kai iueT' auToO t6v dK6Xou6ov, tL TpujiXoc fjv ovojua. toiv be cuujadTUJV eic Tf|v 6dXaccav ujc6e'vTuuv t6 |uev toO Tpuji-
2, 46-17 H. 6, 616-618 B.
19. eTtrov Reiskius: elirev 25. bpfq 6'dKaipiu*: 6pYnc be Kaipil) 29. TpuiiXou*: rpiJuiXou eic tov bdqavov TroTaiuov
SAPIENTUM CONVIVIUM 371
Xou eHuj (popou)U6VOV eTrecxeGn TrepiKXucTUJ xoip«^i ILiiKpov UTrep THV GdXaccav dvexoucr)- Kai laexpi vOv TpoiiXoc f) xo'pdc KaXeiTor toO b' 'Hciobou tov ve- Kpov eu0uc drro y^IC UTtoXapoOca beXqpivujv dfeXn E
.. TTpoc t6 Piov iKoyixle. eTUTXave be AoKpoic r\ TiJuv Tiujv Ka6ecTa)ca 9ucia Kai TravriYupic, nv ctYOUciv eTi vOv eTCKpavujc Ttepi tov tottov eKeivov. uic b' ujcpGn TTpoc9ep6)aevov t6 cuuina, eaujndcavTec ibc eiKOC eiri Tfjv dKTf^v KaTebpaiuov, Kai Yvuipicav-
10 Tec CTi TTpocqpaTOv t6v veKp6v dTravTa beuTepa toO Z^nTeTv t6v (povov €ttoioOvto bid ttiv boHav toO 'Hciobou. Kai toOto fiev Tax€'ujc eTTpaEav, eupovTec Touc q)ove'ac' auTOuc Te Tdp KaTCTTOVTicav Z^uJvTac Kai Tf)v oiKiav KaTecKavpav. eTdcpri b' 6 'Hcioboc
i'> TTp6c TUJ Ne)Lieiuj' t6v be Tdqjov oi ttoXXoi tujv Eevoiv ouK icaciV; dXX' dTTOKe'KpuTTTai ZrjTOujuevoc utt' 'Op- XO/ieviujv, ujc qpaci, PouXo)Ltevujv KOTd xPlc^ov dve- F Xec9ai Td Xeiipava Kai Gdvpai Trap' auToTc. eTrrep ouv ouTUJC exouciv oiKeiujc Kai qpiXavGpiuTTUJC Trp6c touc
20 dTTO0av6vTac , cti )ndXXov eiKOc ecTi toTc Ziujci porj- OeTv, Kai ladXiCTa KriXr|0evTac auXoTc fi tici iit^Xeci. TouTi xdp fibri TrdvTec i'c)Liev, oti )aouciKfj Td 2uja TaOTtt xctipei Kai bituKei, Kai TTapavfJxeTai TTXoioic eXau- vo)ie'voic TTp6c uibfiv Kal auX6v ev eubia xop^ictic
'.^:> TepTT6)Lieva. xctip^* ^£ xai vf|Heci TTaibujv Kai KoXu)a- Poic djiiXXdTai. bi6 Kai v6)Lioc dbeiac dYpaqpoc ^ctiv 163 auToTc" 0ripa Ydp oubeic oube Xu)LiaiveTai , TrXfjv OTav ev biKTuoic Yev6)aevoi KaKOupYuici Trepi Tf)V dYpav,
:.', 47— 48H. 6, 6J8-C20E.
5. t6 'Piov*: t6 f>iov Kai r^v |uo\uKpiav 6. 'Pteiujv
Ileiskms 23. TrXoioic Piiugkius: toIc 24. xopeiaic W: nopeiaic 27. ou6e*: ouTe 28. KOKOupYuici Pflugkius:
KaKOUOYoOci
372 SEPTEM
TrXriYctTc KoXd^ovTm KaGdTrep Traibec diaapTOVTec. \xe- fivriiLiai be Kai irapd Aecpiuuv dvbpujv dKOucac cuuTri- piav Tivd Kopric -oTro beXcpTvoc eK 6aXdTTric Tev€'c0ai XeTOiuievov dKpipOuc. dXX' 6 TTiTTaKoc eTrei TiTVwcKei, biKaioc ecTi TTfpi TouTUJV bieXGeTv*. 5
20. "Gqpn Toivuv 6 TTiTTaKoc evboHov eivai Kai )iivrmoveu6jLievov urro ttoXXujv tov Xotov. xP^c)li6v Tdp TevecGai toTc oiki^ouci Aec^ov, oTav epiiiaTi TtXeovTec
B TrpocTuxtticiv 6 KaXeTTai Mec6T€iov, t6t€ evTaOBa rTo- ceibOOvi |uev TaOpov 'AiacpiTpiTr) be Kai Nripriici Ziujcav 10 Ka6eTvai TTap6evov. ovtujv ouv dpxnTetwv dTTTd Kai paciXeuJv, oTboou be toO '€xeXdou TTu6oxpr|CTOu Tfic dTTOiKiac fiTe|u6voc, outoc iuev rii6eoc fjv eTi, tujv b' CTTTd KXripoujue'vujv, ocoic dTa|uoi TraTbec fjcav, KaTa- Xaiapdvei 0uTaTe'pa C|uiv6eujc 6 KXfjpoc. iiv ec6fiTi is Kai xP^cuJ Koc)ur|cavT€c ujc eTevovTO KaTd tov Tdnov, ejueXXov euEdjuevoi Ka6f|ceiv. eTuxe be tic epujv auTfic tujv cu)UTTXe6vTu)v, ouk dTevvnc ujc eoiKe veaviac, ou Kai TOuvo)ua bia|uvri|uoveuouciv "GvaXov.
C ouTOc djufixavdv Tiva toO pori6eTv Trj Trap6evuj Trpo- 2<i 0u|uiav ev tuj t6t€ TTd6ei Xapubv Trapd tov Kaipov ujpfxrice Kai TTepmXaKeTc 6)uo0 cuTKa6fiK€v lauTov eic Triv 6dXaTTav. eu6uc )uev ouv qpfiiuri tic ouk exouca t6 pepaiov, dXXutc be TTei0ouca ttoXXouc ev tu» CTpa- 1 TOTTebuj birivex0ri rrepi cujTripiac auTuiv Kai KO|uibfic. sa ucTepuj be xp6vuj tov "€vaX6v qpaciv ev Aecpiu (pa- ^ vfivai Kai XeTeiv ujc utto beXqpivuJV qpopriTOi bid 6a- XdTTric eKTTecoiev dpXapuJc eic Tfiv fiTreipov, cti b'
, 48— 49H. 6, 620-622B.
1. 6|uapT6vT€C*: d|uapTdvovT€C 4. knei TiTvutiCKei
W: iTTiTiTviucKei 7. XPICMOV yap -fCvicQm*: xpriC|LioO
Totp Tevojn^vou 11. KaGetvai*: KoGievai 28. ?ti*: Icti
d
SAPIEKTUM CONVIVIUM 373
d\Xa Geioiepa toutujv €K7T\iiTT0VTa Kai KriXoOvTa touc rroWouc biriteicGai, TTdvToiv be TTicTiv epTUJ rrapa- cxeTv. KUiaaTOC Yctp rjXipdTOu rrepi Triv vf]Cov aipo- D jaevou Kai tuuv dvGpujTTuuv bebioTUJV drTavTficai , laovov
5 GaXdTTri eTTecGai TTo\uTTobac auTUj rrpoc t6 lepov toO noceibLuvoc. u)v ToO laeyicTOu \i9ov KO|ai2ovTOC Xa- PeTv Tov "€va\ov Kai dvaGeTvai, koi toOtov "GvaXov KaXoO^ev. Ka06\ou b' emeTv, ei tic eibein bmqpopdv dbuvdTOu Ktti dcuvr|9ouc Kai iTapaXoTOu Kai TTapabo-
loHou, iudXiCT' dv, uj XiXujv, |ar|Te TriCTeuujv ujc eTuxe )iriT' dTTiCTuuv t6 'larjbev OYav' 6 cu TTpoceTaHac bia-
(pu\dTTOl.'
21. MeTd be toOtov 6 'Avdxapcic emev oti toO 0d\euj Ka\u)c uTTo\a)apdvovTOC ev TTdciv eivai toTc
15 KupiuiTttTOic jLiepeci ToO Kociaou Kai lueYicTOic MJUxriv, E ouK dHiov ecTi 9au|adZ:€iv ei Td KdWicTa TTepaiveTai 9eo0 Tvwiari. 'vpuxnc Tdp opTavov t6 cujMa, GeoO b' fi vpuxrj* Kai Ka9dTT€p cuu^a TToWdc |aev eH auToO Kivnceic exei, Tdc be TT\eiCTac Kai KaWicTac u7t6 viju-
zoxfic, OUTUUC aij 7Td\iv f] ijjuxri Td |aev uqp' eauTfic Kivou|aevri TTpdTTei, Td be tuj Geuj TTapexei xpiJU|LievLu KaTeu9uveiv Kai TperTeiv auTfiv fi pou\eTai, TTdvTuuv opTdvuuv euTp€Tr€'cTaTOV ouca. beiv6v Tdp' eiTrev ^ei ttOp |aev opTavov ecTi GeoO Kai TTveOjLia Kai ubuup Kai
25 vecpr) Kai 6|appoi, bi' iLv TToWd juev cuj^ei t€ Kai F Tpeqpei, TToXXd b' dTToWuci Kai dvaipeT, Ziujoic be xpfi-
2, 50-51 H. C, 022— 624B.
7. "GvaXov Steijhanus: el 8. b' eiTreiv*: bi eTrrev
dbeir] Pflugkius: elbev f| 10. XiXujv W: xiK{u\ Koi
11. o*: (juc biaqjuXdTTOi W : biaqpuXaTTUJV 22. au
Tir)v r) PouXcTai*: ^auTJiv fj PouXoito
374 SEFTKM
Ttti Trpoc oubev diTXujc TuJv utt* auToO Yiyvoneviuv, dXXct ladXXov eiKOc eEnPTnM^va Tnc toO 9eo0 buvd- laeouc uTTOupYeTv, Kai cu)jna9eiv Taic toO 9eo0 Kivri- ceciv f) CKu9aic ToSa Xupai b' "GXXrici Kai auXoi cvjjl- Ka9o0civ. ^TTi be toutoic 6 TTOiriTnc Xepciac dXXuuv r. T€ cqj^evTtuv dveXTTiCTUJc e)ne')avr|To Kai KuipeXou toO TTepidvbpou TraTpoc, 8v oi Ke)Liqp9evTec dveXeiv veo- Yvov ovTa TTpoc)aeibidcavTa auToic dTTeTpdTTovTO" Kai 164 TTdXiv laeTavoricavTec ^CriTOuv Kai oux eupov, eic ku- ipeXriv UTTO Tfic |ur|Tp6c dTT0Te9evTa, bio Kai tov oT- lo Kov Tov i\ AeXqpoic KaTecKeuacev 6 KuvpeXoc, wc toO 9€o0 t6t€ tov KXau9)iupic)Li6v dTTicxovToc, 6ttujc biaXd9oi Touc 2r|ToOvTac'. Kai 6 TTiTTaKOC TrpocaTo- peucac t6v TTepiavbpov 'eu ye' etpn 'TTepiavbpe Xep- ciac dTToirice )nvTic9eic toO oikou- TroXXdKic Ydp^Pou-«5: \6\xr]\ €p€c9ai ce tOuv paTpdxujv thv aiTiav ^Keivuuv, Ti pouXovTai TTepi t6v TTu9)ieva toO qpoiviKOC dvT€T0- peui^evoi tocoOtoi, Kai Tiva TTp6c tov 0edv f| tov dva9evTa Xoyov ^xovci*. toO bk. TTepidvbpou tov ■ Xepciav epujTdv KeXeucavTOc, eibevai Ydp dKeivov Kaizo^ B TTapeTvai tuj Kuvjj^Xuj Ka9i€po0vTi t6v oTkov, 6 Xep- ciac ^eibidcac 'dXX' ouk dv' ^^n '(ppdcai)ai TrpoTe- ' pov f| TTu9ec9ai Trapd toutujv 6 ti pouXeTai t6 ')uin- bev fiY«v ' auToTc Kai t6 ' yvu)9i cauT6v ' Kai toOto bfi t6 ttoXXouc |iev dYd)iouc ttoXXouc b* dTricTOUC dviouc 2-, be Kai dqpujvouc TreTToiriK^c 'i-^fva napa b' fiTa'. *Ti b" eiTTev 6 TTiTTaKOC 'fmdiv b^r) TaOTa <ppa26v- Tujv ; TTdXai Ydp Aicujttou Xoyov elc ^KacTov ujc ^oik€
2, 51— 52 H. 6, CS4-6i5R.
1. dirXOjc Reiskius: ArrXwc oOb^Truj 8. Trpoc|i£i6id-
cavxa idein: TTpoco|uiiXrjcavTO 11. t6v* 11. tuc roO*:
lijciTep
_J
SAPIENTUM CONVIVIUM 375
TOUTuuv cuvxeSeiKOTOc eiraiveic'. Kai 6 Aicoittoc 'oTav Te ■nailri Ttpoc ejae Xepciac' eme' crroubdZiujv be tou- Tujv "Ojuripov eupeTTiv ciTrobeiKvuci Kai (pr\ci tov |uev "€KTOpa fiTVUJCKeiv eauTOv, toTc t«P aWoic d-rriTi- C 5 0e|aevoc
*AiavTOc dX^eive iudxriv TeXajaujvidbao"' Tov b' 'Obuccea tou ' pribev dTav ' dTraiveTriv tuj Aio- lurjbei irapaKeXeuecGai
'Tubeibri, piryv' dp' jue fidX' aivee |ur|Te ti veiKei*. 10 THV b' eTTur^v oi fiev dXXoi XoibopeTv auTov ujc npa- T|ua beiXaiov Kai ludTaiov oiovTai XeTOVTa
'beiXai Toi beiXuJv t^ xai eTT^ai eTT^^daceai ', Xepciac b' ouToci qpnci Triv "Attiv utto toO Aioc pi- qpfivai Tf} eTTuri TTapaTiTVO|uevriv fiv eTTuricdjuevoc 6 15 Zeijc ecq)dXri Trepi Tfic toO 'HpaKXeouc Teve'ceujc'. D uTToXaPujv b' 6 CoXuJv 'oukoOv' eqpii 'Kai tuj coqpuj- TdTLu TTiCTeuTeov 'Ojuripuj
'vijH b' ribri TeXe9er dTaGov Kai vukti Tri6ec9ai'. CTTeicavTec ouv Moucaic Kai TToceibuJvi Kai 'AjucpiTpi- 20 TT) biaXuuj|uev ei boKeT t6 cujuttociov '.
ToOto ecxev, ui NiKapxe, Trepac x\ TOTe cuvoucia'.
2, 52—53 H. 6, 625— €26 K
3. "OMnpov] A 542 6. K 249 9. 6 351 17.
'0|iinpiu] H 282 293 21. toOt'] toioOto Reiskiua
HEPI AEI2IAAIM0NIA2.
1. Tfjc TT€pi Geujv ctjLtaGiac Kai dYvoiac eu6uc eH dp- Xnc bixa pueicTic t6 inev ujcTrep dv x^AJpioic CKXripoic ToTc dvTiTUTTOic fj9eci Tf]v dOeoTnTa, t6 b' ujcrrep ev uTpoic ToTc dTraXoTc ttiv beicibaijaoviav TteTToiTiKev. dTtaca iikv oSv Kpicic vyeubnc , dXXiuc t€ Kdv fj Tcepl 5 TttOTa, jLioxeTipov f) be Kai TtdGoc TrpocecTi, |aox6np6- TaTOV. TTdv Tdp Tideoc eoiKev TtXriYfi cpXeYMaivouca F elvai- Ka\ Ka6dTrep ai /aeTd Tpau)LiaToc ^KpoXai tu>v dpepuuv, ouTUJC ai |i€Td rrdeouc biacTpoqpai Tfic vj/uxfic XaXeTTUJTepai. dTojuouc tic oTcTai Kai k€v6v dpxdc lo elvai Tuuv oXujv. ipeubfic y\ uTToXrivpic, dXX' eXKOc ou TTOieT oube c(puYM6v oub' obuvnv TapdTTOucav. utto- XaMPdvei tic t6v ttXoOtov d^ae^v eivai mct»ctov. 165 TOUTO t6 vpeOboc i6v e'xei, veVeTai ttiv vjjuxnv, il- icTTiciv, ouK i& Kaeevjbeiv, oVcTpujv eMTriTrXTiciv, lijeeT is KaTd TTeTpuiv, dTX€i, Tfjv rrappriciav dqpaipeTTai. Trd- Xiv oTovTai Tivec €?vai cuiMa ttjv dpeTfjv Kal ttiv ko- Kiav. aicxp6v Tcujc t6 dTvoriMa, 6privujv be Kai 6bup- MUJV ouK dHiov, dXX' aiTivec eici TOiauTai Kpiceic Kai uTToXfivyeic 20
2, Oi— 55 H. 6, 627 - C2S K.
7. iT\riT>i*: dnTciTrj
I
. DE SUPERSTITIONE 377
*u; iXfiiLiov dpeTii, Xoyoc fip' ^c9'* ifOj hi ce
ujc epTOV fjcKOUv' dqpeic Triv ttXoutottoiov dbiKiav Kai TrjV tovijuov dTxd- crjc fibovfic dKoXaciav, TauTac dEiov ecTiv oiKTeipeiv 5 6)iou Kai bucxepaiveiv, oti iroXXd vocr|)naTa Kai TrdGri B KaGdTiep euXdc Kai cKujXriKac dvTiKTOuci TaTc nJuxaTc TrapoOcai.
2. OuKoOv Kai Ttepi «Iiv 6 Xotoc, f) |li^v dGeoTric Kpicic oijca qjauXri toO iuribev eivai fuaKdpiov Kai d-
10 q)9apT0V eic diTd9eidv Tiva boKcT Tfjj dTriCTia tou 9eiou Trepi(pe'peiv , Kai TeXoc ecTiv auTfj toO nr\ vojuiCeiv 9eouc t6 ixi] q)oPeTc9ar Tr^v beicibai|uoviav be iurivuei Kai Touvojaa boHav ejLiTTa9fi Kai beouc TTOiriTiKf)V urro- Xrinjiv oucav ^KTaiTeivoOvTOC Kai cuvTpipovTOC tov
15 dv9puuTrov, oi6|aevov ^iev elvai 9eouc, eivai be XuTTri- pouc Kai pXaPepouc. Ioikc Tdp 6 )aev d9eoc dKivr)- Toc elvai TTpoc t6 9eTov, 6 be beicibaijuujv Kivoujiievoc C ujc ou TrpocfiKei biacTpe(pec9ai. f) Tdp dTVOia tuj laev dTTiCTiav ToO uJcpeXouvTOC ejUTrcTToiriKe, tuj be Kai bo-
20 2av oTi pXdTTTei TTpocTe9eiKev. 69ev fi fxkv d^eoTric XoTOC ^CTi bieijjeucjuevoc , f\ hi beicibaijuovia TTd9oc eK XoTOu ipeuboOc eTTeTevri)ie'vov.
3. Aicxpd )uev bfi TTdvTa Td ttic vpuxric vocf|)uaTa Kai Trd9r|, t6 be TcOpov evioic 6)uujc Kai uipriX6v Kai
25 birip)uevov evecTiv utto KouqpoTriTOC, bpacTripiou b' 6p-
)ufic oubev uic eTTOC emeTv dTrecTepriTai. dXXd toOto
bfi t6 K0iv6v e'TKXri)aa TTavT6c TTd9ouc dcTiv, oti TaTc
. TTpaKTiKaTc 6p)uaTc eKpiaZ;6)aeva KaTCTTeiTei Kai cuvTei- D
vei t6v XoTiC)a6v. )a6voc b' 6 qpopoc, oux fJTTOV uiv
30 ToXjiric Ivbefic f| XoTic)aoO, dTrpaKTOv Ix^i ^^^ oTTopov
2, 55-57 H. 6, 628 -630 R.
1. Nauck. p. 698
378 DE SUPERSTITIONE •
Kai djirixavov to dXoTicxov. fj Kai beT)Lia Kai rdpPoc auToO t6 cuvbeov 6)no0 Trjv ipuxrjv Kai TapdTTOv wvo- l^acTai. (popuuv be TrdvTiuv dTrpaKTOTaTOc Kai diro- pujTaTOc 6 Tfic beicibai)uoviac. ou qpopeiTai GdXaccav 6 |uf] irXeiJuv oube TToXeiaov 6 juf) CTpaTeuojuevoc , oube 5 XrjCTdc 6 oiKOupujv oube cuKoqpdvTr|V 6 Tre'vric oube q^edvov 6 ibiuiTric, oube ceic)u6v 6 ev TaXdTaic oube Kepauv6v 6 dv AiGioipiv 6 be 9eouc bebiwc iTdvTa E bebie, tnv edXaTTav depa oupav6v ckotoc (pujc KXr)b6va ciujttiiv oveipov. oi boOXoi tuiv becTTOTUJv lo eTTiXavedvovTai KaeeubovTec, toTc TTebr|Taic CTTeXacppu- vei Tov becfi6v 6 uttvoc, (pXefjuovai Trepi TpaujuaTa Kai vo|iai capKoc eripiiObeic Kai TTepiuibuviai KOi)Liuj)Lie- vujv d^icTavTai.
'W CpiXOV UTTVOU eeXYnTpOV ^TTiKOUpOV VOCOU, 15
ibc fibu )Lioi TrpocfiXeec ev beovTi fe\ toOto ou bibujciv eiTTeTv f] beicibaijLtovia ()u6vn Ydp ou cTTevbeTai TTp6c t6v uttvov, oube Trj ipuxf) t6t€ YoOv bibujciv dvaTTveOcai Kai dvaeappficai Tdc TTiKpdc F Kai papeiac TTepl toO eeoO bdHac dTTUJca^Lievrj), dXX' 20 tjjCTTep ev dcepOuv x^PM^ tuj uttvlu tujv beicibai)a6vujv eibujXa cppiKujbri Kai TepdcTia (pdc)LiaTa Kai TTOivdc Tivac dYeipouca Kal cTpoPoOca Tfjv deXiav qjuxfiv eKbiuuKei ToTc oveipoic eK tujv uttvujv, )aacTiZ;o)iievr)V Kai KoXaZofj^vriv auTfjv ucp' auTfic ujc ucp' dTepou, Kai 25 beivd TTpocTdYjuaTa Kai dXX6K0Ta XajLipdvoucav. eiT' ^HavacTdvTec ou KaTecppdvricav oube KaTCYeXacav, oub' fjceovTO OTi Tiijv TapaHdvTUJV oubev fjv dXrjeivdv, dXXd CKidv (peuYOVTec dTTdTric oubev KaK6v ^xouctic
1 , 57—68 H. 6, 630 -632 E.
15. Eurip. Or. 208 18. T^xe Pflugkius: troTe
DE SUPERSTITIONE 379
Orrap eEairaTiJuciv eauTouc Kai baTTaviJuci Kai CTTa0uj- 160 civ eic cxYupTac Kai Yoi-jTac ejUTrecovTec XeTovTac 'dW eiT' evuTTvov q)dvTac)aa qpopei, XSoviac 0' '6KdTr|C ku))liov ebeHoi',
5 Tfiv TTepi|udKTpiav KdXei YpaOv Kai pdTTTicov ceauTOV eic 0d\accav Kai Ka0icac dv rf] ^x} birnnepeucov.
'(h pdppap' dHeupovTec "GWrivec KaKd' Tfi beicibai)Liovia, TTTiXouceic KaTapopPopuOceic paTTTi- c|biouc, pivjjeic eTTi TtpocujTTOV , aicxpdc TTpoKa0{ceic,
10 dWoKOTOuc TTpocKuvriceic. biKaiuj tuj CTOiaaTi touc Ki0apLubouc eKeXeuov abeiv oi Tfiv vojliimov laouciKfiv ciiuZieiv boKoOvTec* fmeic be toTc 0eoTc dHiou|Liev 6p0ilj B TuJ CTOiuaTi Ktti biKaiLU rrpoceuxec0ai, Kai inf] Tf)V eTTi Tiuv cTTXdyxvuJV laev YXuuTTav ei Ka0apd Kai 6p-
15 0fi CKOTTeTv, Tfjv b' dttUTOuv biacTpe(povTac Kai laoXu- vovTOc dTOTToic ovojiiaci Kai pfiiuaci pappapiKoTc KaT- aicxuveiv Kai TTapavo)aeiv eic t6 0eTov Kai rrdTpiov dEiuu)Lia tt^c eucepeiac. dXX' 6 ye KUj)iiK6c ouk dribOuc eipriKe ttou Trp6c toijc KaTaxpucoOvTac toi KXivibia
20 Kai KaTapYupoOvTac oti
'ttpoTko laovov ebujKav fi)aTv oi 0eoi Tov uttvov. Ti toOto TToXuTeXec cauTUJ TTOieTc ; ' ecTi be Kai TTpoc t6v beicibaijuova eiTTeTv oti t6v C UTTVOV oT 0eoi Xf|0riv KaKuJv ebocav r\}jav Kai dvdTrau-
25 civ. Ti toOto KoXacTfjpiov cauTuJ TTOieTc eTTi)Liovov Kai obuvripov, Tfjc d0Xiac ipuxnc eic dXXov tottov dTTO-
?, 58-60 H. 6, 632—634 K.
1. ciiaOujciv*: TapdiTTovjciv 3. Nauck. p. 698
8. paTtTic|uouc Bentleius: caPPaxiciuoOc 17. eic* 18.
KUj|aiK6c] Meinek. IV. p. G70 21. -irpoTKa — Geoi idem:
|u6vov ^buJKav r||utv oi eeoi TrpolKa 22. cauTiu idem:
ceauTiu 26. tottov*: uttvov
380 DE SUPERSTITIONE
bpavai plx] buva)a€vr|c; 6 'HpdKXeiToc qpnci toTc ifpx]- ■fopociv eva Kai koivov Kocpov elvai, tuuv be KOi)iuj- jaeviuv eKacTOV eic ibiov dTTocTpeqpecGai. tlu be bei- cibai)Liovi Koivoc oubeic oub' ibioc ecTi Kociaoc- outc YCip €TP»lTopujc Tuj q)povoOvTi xPHTai ouTe KOi)nw)Lie- 5 voc dTraXXdTTeTai toO TapdTTOVTOC, dXX' dveipiuTTei )Liev 6 XoTiCjaoc, expriTope ^' 6 q)6poc dei, qpuTn ^* ouK ecTiv oube )aeTdcTacic.
4. 'Hv cpopepoc iv Cd)LiLu TToXuKpdTtic Tupavvoc, ?\v iv Kopiv6uj TTepiavbpoc , dXX' oubeic dqpopeiTO lo D TOUTOuc )aeTacTdc eic ttoXiv eXeu9epav Kai bri)aoKpa- TOUjaevriV- 6 be thv touv GeOuv dpxnv d)C Tupavviba (poPou)Lievoc CKuGpuuTTfiv Kai dirapaiTriTov ttoi lieTacTr) •iToT qpuT»;i, TToiav thv d9€0V eupr], iToiav 9dXaccav; eic Ti KaTabuc toO K6c)aou laepoc Kai diTOKpuipac is ceauT6v, uJ TaXainujpe, TTicTeuceic oti tov 6e6v diTO- TTeqpeuTac; ^cti Kai bouXoic vdjuoc eXeu9epiav diTo- TvoOci TTpaciv aiTeTc9ai Kai becTT^Tnv iiteTapdXXeiv eTTieiKecTepov • f) be beicibai)uovia eeOuv dXXaTHV ou bibujciv, oub' ecTiv eupeTv 6v ou qpoPr|ceTai eeov 620 q)oPou)iievoc touc TTaTpujouc Kai T^veeXiouc, 6 qjpiT- Tujv Touc cujTfipac Kai )LieiXixiouc, 6 Tpe)iujv Kai be- E boiKUJC irap' iLv aiTou)Lieea ttXoOtov euTTopiav eiprivnv 6)Li6voiav opeujciv X6fujv Kai epTUJV tujv dpicTujv. eiTa oijToi To bouXeueiv dTuxriMCi fiToOvTai Kai XeTouci 25 'beivri Tic dvbpi Kai TuvaiKi cu)aq)opd bouXouc Tcveceai becTTOTac t€ bucxepeTc XapeTv ' *
2, 60-61 H. 6, 634— 635E
4. oOb' ibioc Matthaeus 13. tioT — ttoT*: tioO —
TToO 22. 6 rp^iaujv Reiskius: rp^mjuv 26. Nauck.
p. 698 27. bucxepek Valckenarius: bucruxcTc
DE SUPERSTITIONE 381
TTOciu be beivoTcpov oiecGe iTdcxeiv auTOuc dveKqpeu- KTOuc dvaTTobpdcTouc dvuTTOCTdTOuc XaMpdvovTttc; ecTi bouXuj ^euHi^oc Puj|u6c, ecTi Kai XriCTaTc dpepn^a TToXXd Tujv iepu)V, Kai TroXejuiouc oi qpeuxovTec dv
5 dTdX|LiaTOC XdpuuvTai f\ vaoO GappoOciv • 6 be beici- bai|uijuv TaOTa judXicTa qppiTTei Kai qpopeiTai Kai hi- boiKev, ev oic oi qpopounevoi Td beivoTaTa Tdc eXTTi- bac exouci. ixx] dTTocTra tov beicibaijuova toiv iepuiv P evTaOGa KoXdteTai Kai Ti|uujpeTTai. Ti beT juaKpd Xe-
lOYeiv; 'rrepac ecTi tou piou Trdciv dvGpiuTroic 6 Gd- vaTOc'* TTic be beicibaijuoviac oub' outoc, dXX' uTrep- pdXXei Touc opouc eTTe'Keiva toO lr]v, luaKpoTepov toO piou TTOioOca Tov qpopov Kai cuvdTTTOuca tu» GavdTiu KaKUJV eTTivoiav dGavdTUJV, xai 8Te rraueTai TTpayiud- 167
15 Tuuv, dpxecGai boKoOca |uf) Trauo|uevujv. "Aibou Tivec dvoiTOVTai TTuXai paGeTai, Kai TroTOiuoi rrupoc 6|uo0 Kai Ctutoc diToppaiTec dvaKepdvvuvTai , Kai ckotoc ejuTriTrXaTai TToXuqpavTdcTUJV eibuuXuJV \a\ena.c |uev on/eic oiKTpdc be qpujvdc eTTiqpepovTUJV , biKacTai be
20 Kai KoXacTai Kai x«c)aaTa Kai )uuxol )uupiujv KaKUJV Te|uovTec. outujc f) KaKobai)uutv beicibai)uov{a tti TTe- piTTrj Trpoc oTrav t6 bOKoOv beiv6v euXapeia Xav- edvei eauTTiv uTTopdXXouca TravToiotc beivoTc.
5. TouTUJV oubev Trj dGeoTriTi TrpocecTiv, dXX' f)
25 |uev dTVOia xo^^f^ kci'i t6 Trapopdv Kai TuqpXujTTeiv Trepi TriXiKaOTa cu)ucpopd )ueTdXr| M^uxfic, ujCTrep oju- B ludTUJV t6 qpavoTaTOV Kai KupiuJTaTov dTTecPec)uevric Tf]v ToO GeoO voriciv. TauTr) be t6 e^uTraGec, uicTrep
2, 61— 64H. 6, 635-6 <7R.
2. dvuTtocTdrouc Meziriacus: dvaTrocrdTOUc 18. ^|U-
TTiTrXaTai — €l6u)\u;v Stobaeus Floril. t. IV. p. 245: ^qprj- TrXujTai Tro\uq)dvTacTov elbiuXuJv Tivuiv
382 DE SUPERSTITIONE
£ipr|Tai, Ktti ^XKUjbec Kai xapaKTiKOV Kai KaTabebou- Xiufievov euGuc TrpocecTi Tri boEr]. laouciKriv cpnciv 6 TTXdTUJV ^juueXeiac Kai eupu9|Liiac briMioupxov dvOpuj- TTOic UTTO Geoiv ou Tpucpfic eveKa Kai Kvriceujc ujtujv boGfivai, dXXd oiCTe tujv ttic HJUxnc Tiepiobujv koi 5 dp|noviu)V t6 TapaxuJbec Kai TTeTtXavrmevov ev cu))iaTi, |Lio\jcr]c Te Kai xdpiToc Ivbeict TToXXaxn bi' OKoXaciav Kai TrXri)Li|a^Xeiav e2uppi2ov, auGic eic TdHiv dveXiTTOu- C cav oiK€iu)c Kai TrepidToucav KaGiCTdvai.
*6cca be ^x) TTecpiXriKe Zeuc' qprici TTivbapoc ^dru- 10
2ovTai podv
TTiepibujv diovTa*' Kai tdp biaYpiaiveTai Kai dYavaKTei, Kai Tdc TiYpeic be' q)aci TTcpiTujLiTTaviCoiievac eKjuaivecGai Kai TapdTTecGai Kai TeXoc auTdc biacTTdv. eXaTTOv ouv KaKOV oic 15 bid KUJcpoTTiTa Kai rrripujciv dKofic dTTdGeia TTpoc )liou- ciKf]v Kai dvaicGricia cu|apepr|Kev. 6 Teipeciac expfiTO bucTuxia |un pXeTTUJV Td T^Kva }j^r]be touc cuvfiGeic, 6 b* 'A6djLiac ineiJovi Kai n 'ATaufi, pXe'TTOVTec ibc D Xe'ovTac KaieXdcpouc* Kai tuj 'HpaKXei bfjTTOu |uavevTi 20 Touc uieic ^XuciTeXei lafiTC ibeiv ijfiTe aicGecBai Trapov- Tttc fi XPncQcci ToTc qpiXTdTOic ujc TToXe)aioic.
6. Ti ouv; ou boKei coi Kai t6 tujv dGeujv rrpoc Touc b€icibai|uovac Trd8oc ^'xeiv TOiauTrjv biaqpopdv; o'i |ifev oux 6pu)ci Touc Seouc t6 TrapdTTav, o'i be Ka- Kouc UTTdpxeiv vojaiZiouciv • o'i )Liev TTapopOuciv, o'i bk boEdiCouci cpopep6v t6 eu)aevec Kai TupavviK6v t6 TTa- tpik6v Kai pXapep6v t6 Kribe)aoviK6v Kai t6 d)aiKT0v
I.64-66H. C, 037-039 B,
I
3. TTXdTiov] Tim, p. 47D 9. KaGiCTdvat * : Koeicxav
10, nivbapoc] Pyth. I 13 25. |i^v Pflugkius: |j^v
oOv
I
DE SUPERSTITIONE 383
ctTpiov eivai Kai Gripioibec. eTra x"^kotu7toic )uev TreiGovrai Kai XiGoHooic Ktti KripoTrXdcTaic dvGpoiTTo- )Ltop<pa TiLv Geujv Td eibr) ttoioOci, Kai TOiaOTa TrXdTTOuci Kai KaTacKeudZiouci Kai TTpocKuvoOcr 91X0- E
r. cocpujv bk. Kai TToiriTiKiJuv dvbpujv KttTacppovoOciv, dTTobeiKVuvTUJV Triv ToO 6eo0 cejiivoTriTa laeTd xPncTO- Tr|TOC Kai jueYaXocppocuvnc Kai eujueveiac Kai Kribe)uo- viac. TTepiecTiv ouv toTc (uev dvaicGricia Kai dTTicTia TU)V ujqpeXouvTUJV, toTc bk Tapaxri Kai qpdpoc Trpoc Td
10 ujqpeXoOvTa. koi oXujc f) juev dGeoTric dTrdSem rrpoc t6 GeTov ecTi )uf] vooOca t6 dTaGov, fi be beicibai|uo- via TToXuTTd0eia kokov t6 dYa66v UTTOvooOca. qpo- poOvTai Touc 6eouc Kai KaTaqpeuYOuciv eTTi touc 6eouc, KoXaKeuouci Kai XoibopoOciv, euxovTai Kai KaTajueV*
15 qpovTai. K0iv6v dv6pa)TTUJv to }xr] TrdvTa bieuTuxeTv • F 'KeTvoi tdp t' dvocoi Kai dTnpaoi TTOvujv t' dTreipoi, papupoav rropeiuov TreqpeuYOTec 'AxepovTOc', 6 TTivbapoc qpnci, Td b' dv6pujTriva TTd6ri koi TTpdt-
20 juaTa luejuiKTai cuvTuxiaic dXXoTe dXXoic ^eoucaic.
7. 0€pe bf] TTpuJTOV ev toTc dpouXrjTOic CKOTrei t6v d0eov Kai KaTa|udv6av€ Tfjv bid6eciv, dv ^ TdXXa )LieTpioc, xPiJU)Jevou ciujTTrj toTc TrapoOci Kai TTOpiZiov- Toc auTLU pori0eiac Kai TrapriYopiac, dv be bucqpoprj
25 Kai TTepiTra0rj , TrdvTac drri Trjv Tuxnv Kai t6 auTojua- Tov drrepeibo^aevou touc obupjuouc Kai Poujvtoc ujc I68 oubev KaTd biKrjV oub' ^k rrpovoiac dXXd TrdvTa cut- Kexu)Lievujc Kai dKpiTUJc qpepeTai Kai CTTa0dTai Td tujv dv0pujTTUJV. ToO be beicibai|uovoc oux outoc 6 Tpo-
i 2, 66— 67 H. 6, 482— 184 K.
5. TTOiriTiKuJv*: TroXiTtKuJv 16. t«P t' p. 1076 A: Top 19. niv6apoc] Bergk. fr. 120 (107)'
384 DE SUPERSTITIONE
TTOC, dW €1 Kai ILllKpOTaTOV aUTUJ KaKOV CU|dTT€TTTUJ-
Koc ecTiv, dXXa KdBriTai Trd6r| xd^errd Kai |ueYdXa Kai bucarrdXXaKTa Tf] XuTrr) TrpocoiKobo)aaiv , Kai TrpocejLi- cpopujv auTLu bei)aaTa Kai cpopouc Kai uTTOipiac Kai Tapaxdc, TtavTi 9privuj Kai rravTi CTevatiixuj KaearrTO- 5 jaevoc* ouTe Ydp dvGpujTTOV ouTe Tuxnv ouTe Kaipov B ou6' eauTov dXXd TrdvTUJv tov 6e6v aiTidTai, KdKei- eev err' auTov fiKeiv Kai (pepec6ai peO|ua bai|a6viov ttTric cpr]c\, Kai \hc ou bucTuxrjc luv dXXd eeojuiicric Tic dv6pujTroc uTr6 tujv 6eujv KoXdZ;ec6ai Kai biKriv 10 bibovai Kai TidvTa Tidcxeiv TrpocriKovTUJc bi' auTov oieTai. vocujv Te 6 deeoc dKXoTiZieTai Kai dva|Lii|uvri- CKCTai TrXTicjuovdc auToO Kai oivuOceic Kai dTaHiac Ttepi biaiTav fi KOTTOuc urreppdXXovTac fi iueTapoXdc depujv drieeic Kai tottujv, erreiTa TrpocKpoucac iv TroXiTeiaic 15 Kai TTepiTTecujv dboHiaic Trp6c oxXov r| biaPoXak TTp6c fiY€|u6va Tfjv aiTiav eE auToO Kai TuJv rrepi auT6v
CKOTTeT
'nn TTape^Pnv; ti b' epeHa; ti jlioi be'ov ouk eTe-
Xec6n ; ' 20
TU) be beicibai)Liovi Kai cuu|LiaTOc dppujcTia rrdca Kai C xPIMOtTUJV dTToPoXf) Kai tckvwv 6dvaT0i Kai Trepi tto- XiTiKdc TrpdSeic bucriiuepiai Kai dTTOTeuHeic TrXriTai eeoO Ktti TTpocPoXai bai|uovoc XeTOVTai. o6ev oub^ ToXjuql P0Ti6eiv oube biaXueiv t6 cu)upepriK6c oube eepaTTeueiv 25 oub' dvTiTdTTeceai , jufi boHr) eeojuaxeiv Kai dvTiTeiveiv KoXa2;6|uevoc , dXX' uj6eiTai ju^v ^Hui vocouvtoc 6 ia- Tp6c, dTTOKXei€Tai be tt€v6o0vtoc 6 voueeTuJv Kai Trapajuueoujaevoc cpiXocoqpoc. 'la |ue' cpriciv 'dvepuiTre
2, 67— 69 H. 6, 641— 642 B
1. KOKov*: KaKov Ti vel KaKov xd 19. Pythag.
Carm. Aur. 42
DE SUPERSTITIONE 385
bibovai bkriv, tov dcePn, tov ^TtdpaTov, tov GeoTc Ktti baijaoci )Lie|uicrmevov. ecTiv dvGpiuTTOu |Lifi TieTTei- D ciuevou 6eouc eivai \uTtoujLie'vou b' dWuuc Kai TrepiTta- GoOvTOC dTTO)idEai bdKpuov, dTTOKeipai KOiuriv, dqpeXe-
5 c6ai t6 ijadTiov tov be beicibai.uova ttwc dv TTpocei- TTOic fi rrfi pori6)iceic; e£uu Kd8riTai caKKiov exuuv Kai TTepieZ;uJC|aevoc pdKeci puTTapoTc, TToWdKic be YUjavoc ev TTTiXiu KuXivboujuevoc eHaTopeuei Tivdc d)aapTiac auToO Kai TTXri|U|aeXeiac, ujc Tobe qpaTovTOC f| movToc
10 r\ pabicavTOc obov iiv ouk eia t6 bai)a6viov. av b' dpiCTtt TTpdTTri Kai cuvri TTpdtu beicibaijuovia, rrepi- 6eiou)aevoc oikoi KdGriTai Kai TTepiiuaTTOjuevoC; ai be Ypdec 'Ka^drrep TTaTTdXtjj' ^riciv 6 Biujv '6 ti av E Tuxuiciv auTUj TTepidTTTOuci qpepoucai Kai TrepiapTuJci'.
15 8. T6v Tipipa2[6v cpaciv utt6 tuuv TTepcujv cuX- Xa|upav6)aevov CTTdcac6ai tc t6v dKivdKr)v, eupoicTOv ovTa, Kai bia|udxec6ar juapTupoiuevuiv be Kai pouuv- Tuuv OTi cuXXa)updvouciv auT6v PaciXeuuc KeXeucavTOC, auTiKa t6 Eiqpoc KaTa^aXeTv Kai tuu \eipe cuvbfjcai
20 TTapacxeTv. dp ' oijv oux Ojuoiov ecTi t6 YiTv6|uevov : oT fiev dXXoi bia)udxovTai cujuqpopaTc Kai biuueoOvTai Td TTpdTMaTa, qpuydc eauToTc )ar|Xavuj)aevoi Kai TTapa- TpoTTdc Tuuv dpouXf|Tuuv 6 be beicibai)uuuv oubevoc dKoucac, auT6c TTp6c auT6v emuuv 'TaOTa rcdcxeic, F
23 u) KaKobaiiuov, eK Trpovoiac Kai 6eo0 KeXeuovTOc' eppnjje TTdcav ^XrTiba, TrpofiKaTO ^auTov, eqpuye bie- KpoucaTO Touc Por|6o0vTac. rroXXd tuuv )ueTpiuuv Ka- Kuuv 6Xe6pia ttoioOciv ai beicibaijuoviai. Mibac 6 TraXaioc, dic eoiKCv, eK tivuuv ^vuTTviuuv dGufuuuv Kai
30 TapaTTOjuevoc outuu KaKuuc ecxe Ttiv viJuxfiv, ujc6' ^kou-
2, 69-71H. 6,642— fiUR.
11. Trpaeia Reiskius Trepi6€io0,uevoc*: Tr€pi9u6juevoc
1-2. Kai Reiskiits 15. TipipaZiov*: Tr^piPaZov
Plutaxchi Horalia. Vol. I. 25
386 DE SUPERSTITIONE
ciujc dTTO0aveTv aijaa xavjpou tthjuv. 6 be tiIjv Mecri- viujv PaciXeiic 'ApiCTobriiuoc ev tuj ttpoc AaKebaijuo- viouc TToXeMUJ, kuvujv Xukoic ujpuo)Lievujv ojuoia Kal TTcpi Tfjv dcTiav auToO Triv TTaTpiuav ctYpuJCTeujc dva- pXacTavoucnc Kai tujv judvTeujv Td crmeTa cpopoujae- 5 vujV; eHaeu|ar|cac Kai KaTacpeceeic TaTc eXTTiciv auToc 169 eauTov dTTCccpaHev. nv b' icujc Kai NiKiqi tuj 'Aer|- vaiujv CTpaTriYqj KpeTTTOV outujc dTraXXaTfivai Tnc beicibaijuoviac ujc Mibac f| 'ApiCTobrmoc r| qpoPnQevTi Triv CKidv ^KXirroucric ttic C€Xr|vr|C KaencGai rrepiTei- lo Xi26|Lievov UTTO tujv TToXejuiuJv, eTe' ojuou TeTTapci juupid- civ dvepujTTUJV (poveu0evTUJv Te Kai 2u)Vtujv dXovTUJV UTTOxeipiov T6ve'ceai Kai bucKXeiDc dTToOaveTv. ou ydp Ync dvTiqppaHic iv jue'cuj Tevojuevnc cpopepov, oube beivov ev Kaipuj Trepiobujv CKidc rrpoc ceXrivnv dTrdv- i5 THCic, dXXd beivov t6 ttic beicibaijuoviac ckotoc eju- B Trec6v dvepujTTOu cuTXeai Kai TuqpXujcai Xotic|u6v ev TTpdTJuaci ludXicTa Xoticjuou beojuevoic.
* rXauK', opa, paeOc Tdp fjbri Kujuaci TapdcceTai TTOVTOC, djucpi b' OLKpa Pupeujv 6pe6v icTaiai 20
vecpoc, cfijua xeifJuJvoc*.
toOto ibujv KupepvriTric euxeTai juev uTreKcpuTeTv Kai 0eouc cTTiKaXeTTai cujTfipac, euxojuevoc be t6v oiaKa jrpocdTei, TfjV Kepaiav uqpirici, 25
'qjeuTei jueTa XaTqpoc UTTOCToXicac epePuubeoc ^k
0aXdccric'.
«, 71— 72H. 6,644— 646B.
2. AaKebaiiuoviouc Xylander: jueccriviouc 8. KpciT-
Tov Reiskius: KpdTicTov 15. nepiobuuv Xylander: 710-
buiv 16. ^juTTecov*: ^jUTtecovToc 19. Bergk. p. 696*
rXaOK' 6pa paGuc Canterus: Y?^auK€opdp6oic 20, fu-
p^tuv Xylander: Tupiwv 26. Bergk. p. 1351*. Nauck. p. 698
I
DE SUPERSTITIONE 387
6 'Hcioboc KeXeuei irpo dpoTOu xai ciropou tov fe^ap- Tov euxec8ai 'Au xQoviuj ArnuriTepi 9' dYvfi' ttic exeTXric ex6)a€vov, "Ojuripoc be tov AiavTd qprici tuj "€KTopi iueWovTa laovojaaxeiv euxecGai KeXevjeiv touc
5 "GXXrjvac UTiep auTou toTc 0eoic, eiT' euxo)aevuuv eKei- vujv OTtXiZiecGai. Kai 6 'AYajue'juvujv otc toTc juaxojae- voic TTpoceTaHev
' eij |uev tic bopu GriHdcGuu, eu b' dcTtiba 9e'c9u) ', TOTe Ttapd ToO Aioc aiTeT
10 *b6c |ue KaTd TTprivec paXeeiv TTpidjuoio jueXa-
9pov' dpeTfic fdp ^Xttic 6 9e6c ecTiv, ou beiXiac TTp6(pacic. dXX' MoubaToi cappdTUJV ovtujv ev dtvdTTTOic Ka9e- 216|uevoi, TU)V TToXeiuiujv KXijuaKac TTpocTi9e'vTU)V Kai
15 Td Teixn KaTaXa|upav6vTUJV, ouk dvecTrjcav dXX' ejuei- vav uJCTTep ev catrivr) juia Tri beicibai)uovia cuvbe- be)uevoi.
9. ToiauTH |uev dv toTc dpouXr|TOic Kai rrepicTa- D TiKoTc XeTO)uevoic TTpdfluaci Kai KaipoTc fi beicibaijuo-
2ovia, PeXTiujv b' oubev oub' ev toTc fibioci Tfic d9e6- Tr|TOC. fibiCTa be toTc dv9pu)Troic ^opTal Kai eiXaTri- vai TTpoc lepoTc Kai luuficeic Kai 6pTiac)uoi Kai KaTCuxai 9euuv Kai TrpocKUvf|ceic. evTau9a Toivuv CKdTrei tov d9eov yekAvTa |uev )uaviK6v Kai Capboviov flXvjxa
23 ToTc Troiou)uevoic Kai ttou TTapaqp9eTT6)uevov dTpe|ua TTpoc Touc cuvf|9eic oTi TeTuqpuJVTai Kai bai)uovu)Civ 01 9€oTc TaOTa bpac9ai voiuiCovTec, dXXo b' oubev exovTa KaKdv. 6 be beicibai|uujv pouXeTai juev ou buvaTai be xcipeiv oub' fibec9ai,
2, 73-74 H. 6,646— 647B.
1. 'Hdo6oc] 0. et D. 463 3. "O^ripocl H 193
8. B 382 10. B 414
25*
388 DE SUPERSTITIONE
'ttoXic b' 6)LioO )aev 6u)iia)adTUJv TeV^», E 6)ao0 bk TTaidvoiv re Kai cTevaTiudTUJV '
fi ijjuxn ToO beicibai)aovoc. dcTeq)avuu)jevoc uJXPid, 6uei Kai qpopeiTOi, eux^Tai ^ujvrj TTaXXo^aevri koi x^p- civ eKi0u)Liiqi Tpe)iOucaic, Kai 6Xujc dTTobeiKVUci tov 5 TTu6aY6pou Xotov qpXuapov emovTOc oti 'peXncTOi TiTv6|ie6a irpoc touc 6eouc pabi^ovTec'" t6t€ Tdp d6XnjuTaTa Kai KdKicTa KpdTTOuciv oi beicibaiiLiovec, ujCTTep dpKTuiv qjuuXeoic f| xti«ic bpaKdvTUJV f| fiu-
XOIC KTITIJUV TOIC TUJV ScOuV )a€TdpOlC f| dvaKTdpOlC 10 TTpOCl6VT€C.
10. "06ev ejuoiTe koi Bavptaleiv eTTeici touc ttiv F d6e6TTiTa qpdcKOVTac dcepeiav eivai, )ari qpdcKOVTac bk. THV beicibai)aoviav. KaiTOiTC 'AvaEaTopac biKriv Iqpu- Tcv dcepeiac ctti tu) Xi6ov emeiv tov nXiov, Ki^^ae- is piouc b' oubeic eiTTev dcePeic 6ti tov nXiov oub* eivai TO TTapdTTav vo)aiZ;ouci. Ti cu XeTeic; 6 )afi vo)aiiIujv 6€0uc dvdcioc -^CTiv; 6 be toioutouc vo)aiZ[ujv oiouc 01 beicibaijuovec, ou )aaKpu) bdEaic dvociujTepaic cuv- ecTiv; ^Tuj ToOv fiv d6e'Xoi)ai judXXov touc dv6pu)TT0uc 20 170 XeTeiv Tiepi ejioO )aribe TCTovevai to TiapdTrav )arib' d- vai TTXouTapxov f\ XeTeiv 6ti TTXouTopxdc kTiv dv- 6pujTT0c dpepaioc eO^eTdpoXoc, euxepnc TTpoc dpTnv, €TTi Toic TuxoOci Ti]aujpr|TiK6c , )aiKp6XuTT0c, 6cTe, dv
KaXOuV dTtl beiTTVOV ^TCpOUC TTapaXlTTTlC ^KCIVOV, dv 2a
dcxoXiac coi Tcvofaevric ^tti eOpac ixr\ IX6r]c F| [xr] TTpoceiTTric, biebeTai cou t6 cu))aa TTpocqpuc Kai cuX- Xapdiv dTTOTUjaTTaviei t6 rraibiov, f| 6Tipiov toTc Kap- TTOic eqpncei Kai Xu)aaveiTai ttiv dTTuupav. toO Ti)ao-
2, 74-75 H. C, 647-649 B.
1. Soph. 0. R. 4 18. eeouc Schellensius: Geouc el-
vQi 21, \.ir\bi*: ^if]Ti 24. 6ct€* 28. e»iptov^
erjpiov ?xujv
DE SUPERSTITIONE 389
Geou rfiv "ApTcmv abovxoc ev 'AGrjvaic Kai XeTOVXoc eudba qpoipdba fioivdba Xuccdba Kivr|ciac 6 ^eXouoioc CK Tuiv GeaTUJV dvacTdc 'TOiauTri coi' eiTre 'GutdTrip B y^voiTO '. Ktti infiv 6|Lioia toutoic koi x^ipuj rrepi
5 'ApTeiaiboc oi beicibai)aovec UTToXajiPdvouciv ai tc kSv dTT' dTXOvac diEaca ai t6 KaXexdva KvaicaTe ai Te Kav CKCKpoc liaiouca av Treqpupjueva eciiXGec ai Te koi eK Tpmdbujv KaG' epiudTeuciv eTTiCTTuu^eva tuj TTaXa- livaiuj cu)LiTTXex6€Tca. oubev be toutuuv eTTieiKecTepa
10 qppovoOci TTepi 'AttoXXujvoc Trepi "Hpac Trepi 'Acppobi- Ttic" TTdvTac Ydp toutouc Tpejuouci Kai beboiKaci. KCtiTOi Ti tocoOtov fi Nidpri TTcpi ttic AriToGc e^Xa- cqpriMricev, ocov r\ beicibai|Liovia TTe'TreiKe TTepi ttic GeoO Touc dqppovac, ujc dpa XoibopnOeTca KaTeToSeuce thc C
15 d6Xiac YuvaiKOC
*€5 nkv 9uTaT€'pac, eS b' uieac fiPouovTac;*
ouTuic dTTXricTOc dXXoTpiujv KaKOuv t^v Kai dviXacTOC. ei fdp dXriBujc r\ 0e6c xo^fiv €ix€ Kai iuicoTTOvripoc fjv Kai fiXfei KaKUJC dKOuouca Kai infi KaTexeXa thc
20 dvOpujTTivric d)aaeiac Kai dfvoiac dXX' ^YCivdKTei, TOUTOuc ebei KaTaToHeOcai touc TocauTiiv luiaoTTiTa Kai TTiKpiav KaTai|;eubojLie'vouc auTnc Kai TOiaOTa Xe- TOVTac Kai TpdqpovTac. Tfjc toOv 'GKdpric TTpo^aX- Xd|je0a Tfiv TTiKpiav ujc pdppapov Kai 0ripiuj0n Xe-
25 Toucric
'toO eTUJ )Lie'cov fiTTap ^xo»Mi D
Ic0e'^evai TTpocqpOca',
Tfjv be Cupiav Oeov oi beicibai)aovec vo^aiCouciv, av
2, 75— VC H. 6, 649- 650 E.
5. Lobeck. Aglaoph. p. 633. Bergk. p. 1316» 13. Scov*: oTov 16. Homer. Q 604 ui^ac*: uieTc 21 KOTa-
ToEtOcai Reiskius: ToEeOcai 26. Homer. Q 212
390 DE SUPERSTITIO-NE
inaivibac Tic f] dcpuac qpdT»;i, td dvTiKvrnuia biecGieiv, eXKCCi t6 cu))aa TrijuTrpdvai, cuvTriKeiv t6 fiTrap.
11. 'Ap' oijv t6 |uev Xereiv Td ^aOXa rrept tujv GeOuv dvociov, t6 be bolalew ouk dvociov; f| Kai TTjv (pujvf)v ctTOTrov f) boHa Troiet toO pXaccpriiuoOvTOC ; 5 Ktti Tdp TiMCic TTiv pXac(pri|uiav oti buc|ueveiac crnueTov dcTi TrpopaXX6jue9a, Kal touc KaKouc fijudc XexovTac exQpouc vo)uiZ;o)uev ujc Kai KaKuuc qppovoOvTac. 6pac b' oia Tiepi Tujv eeujv oi beicibaijuovec qppovoOciv, E e|UTtXriKTOuc dTticTouc eujueTapoXouc TijaujpriTiKOuc lu- 10
jUOUC lUlKpoXUTTOUC UTTOXoiUpdvOVTeC , i^ U)V dvdTKTi
Kai luiceiv t6v beicibaijuova Kai qpopeiceai touc eeouc ; Tiujc Tdp ou ^eXXei, Td )ueTiCTa tujv KaKuJv auTu» bx^ CKcivouc oi6)uevoc TCTOvevai Kai TrdXiv Tcvrice- ceai; juiciuv be eeouc Kai qpopoujuevoc dxepoc ecTt. 15 KaiToi TTpocKuvei Te Kai Guei Kai KderiTai Ttp6c lepoic, Ktti ou GaujuacTov ^cti " Kai Tdp touc Tupdvvouc dcTrd- ZovTai TrepieTTOuci xP^coOc dvicTdciv, dXXd juicoOci ciTri 'Kdpa ceiovTec'. 'AXeHavbpov '€p)u6Xaoc deepd- Tteue, TTaucaviac ebopuqpopei OiXiTTTTOv, Xaipe'ac fdiov, 20 F dXX' ^KacTOC toutujv eXeTe TrapaKoXoueuJv
'fi c' dv Ticaijuriv, ei fioi buva)uic t€ Trapeir]'. ouK oieTai eeouc eivai 6 deeoc, 6 be beicibaijuuiv ou pouXeTai, TTiCTeuei b' dKUJV qpopeiTai Tdp dTTicTeiv. KaiTOi t' uJCTtep 6 TdvTaXoc UTreKbOvai t6v Xieov 25 eTTaiujpoujuevov outuj koi oijtoc t6v qpdpov lijc oux flTTOV Ott* auToO TrieZ;6)uevoc dTOtTTticeiev dv, Kai jua- Kapiceie Tf]v toO deeou btdeectv tuc dXeueepiav. vuvi bk Tip )uev dGeiu beicibatjuoviac oubev jueTecTtv, 6 bk beicibai)uujv Trj Trpoatpecet deeoc ujv dceev^cTepoc ^CTtv 30 fl UJCTC boHdJetv Trepl eeiijv 6 pouXeTOi.
2, 76—78 H. 6, 650 -652 B.
19. Kdpa] Soph. Ant. 326 22. Homer. X 20
DE SUPERSTITIONE 391
12. Kai |afiv 6 aGeoc beicibaijLioviac oiibaiafi cuv- 171 aiTioc, r\ be beicibai|Liovia Tf} dSeoTriTi Kai -fevecGai Trapecxe koi Tevo)ae'vr;) bibuuciv dTToXoTiav, ouk dXri9fi jnev oube KaXr|v, Trpoqpdceiuc be tivoc ouk d)Lioipov
5 oucav. ou Ydp ev oupavuj ti liejuTTTOv oub' ev dcTpoic oub' ev ujpaic f| Ttepioboic ceXr|vr|C f| Kivr|ceciv fiXiou Trepi T^v, 'fi|Lie'pac Kai vuktoc bnjmowPToic', r\ Tpo- qpaic Cdjujv r| KapTruJv Teve'c6ci TrXri)Li|aeXec Kai dTaKTOV dvibovTec ouTUJc dGeoTriTa tou rravToc KaTCTVujcav,
10 dXXd Tfic beicibai|aoviac ^pTa Kai TrdGTi KaTaTeXacTa, Kai pr||LiaTa Kai KivrnaaTa Kai TonTeicti Kai iuaTeiai B Kai TiepibpojLiai Kai TUjuiTravic/aoi Kai dKdGapTOi jaev Ka6ap|aoi puTTupai b' dTveiai, pdppapoi be Kai Tia- pdvo)ioi Tipoc lepoTc KoXacjuoi Kai upoTrnXaKic^oi,
15 TaOTa bibuiciv ^vioic XeTeiv iLc )afi eivai Geouc djuei- vov f| etvai, TOiauTa juev bexo)ae'vouc toioutoic bk XaipovTac, outuj b' uppiCTdc, outuj be iuiKpoXoTOuc Kai )aiKpoXuTTOuc.
13. OuK djLieivov oijv fjv FaXdTaic ^Keivoic xai 20 CKuGaic t6 TrapdTrav jur|T' ^vvoiav exeiv Geuuv )ur|Te
qpavTaciav )uri9' icTopiav f| 9eouc eivai vo)uiZ;eiv x«i- povTac dv6pujTrujv cqpaTTO^uevujv aijuaTi Kai TeXeujTd- Triv 6uciav Kai lepoupTiav TauTriv vojuiZlovTac ; Ti be; C KapxTibovioic ouk eXuciTeXei KpiTiav Xapouciv f| Aia-
25 Topav vo)uoeeTriv dTt' dpxfic jurJTe Tivd baijuovujv )ur|Te 6euJv vo)ui2^eiv f| ToiauTa 6ueiv oia tuj Kpoviu eeuov; oux uJCTTep '€)UTTeboKXfjc qprici tujv Td 2iua 6u6vtujv Ka6aTTT6juevoc
' )uopqpfiv b' dXXdSavTa TtaTfip qpiXov uiov deipac
30 cqpdZiei eTTeux6)uevoc )ueTa vriTrioc',
2, 78—80 H. 6, 652— 6M B.
3. Trapecxe*: iiapic\iv &p\f\v 7. Plat. Tim. p. 40 C 30. cqjdZei Sextus Empir. adv. Math. IX 129: cqjdEei
392 DE SUPERSTITIONE
dXX' eibotec koi yiyvuuckovt€c auToi Tct auTuuv TtKva KaGiepeuov, oi b' ciTeKVOi Trapd tujv rrevriTUJv iLvou- litevoi Traibia KaTe^ccpaZov KaBdTrep dpvac f| veoccouc,
D TrapeicTiiKei h' r\ )ur|TriP dTeYKTOc Kai dcTevaKTOc. ei be CTevdHeiev r| baKpuceiev, ebei Tfjc Ti)Lific CTepecGai, to be 5 Traibiov oubev f|TTOV eGueTO, KpoTOu Te KaTeTTi)UTTXaTO TTttVTa Trpo ToO dYdXjuiaToc eTrauXouvTUJV Kai TUjLiTTavi- ZdvTUJV evcKa Tou )ufi YiYvec6ai jx\v Pofiv tujv epfjvujv eHdKoucTOv. ei be Tucpojvec Tivec f| PiYavTec fjpxov fi)uu)v TOiJC Geoijc eKpaXovTec, TToiaic dv fibovTO 9u- lo ciaic f| Tivac dXXac lepoupYiac dTTfiTOuv; "A)Lir]CTpic b' f) EepHou Yuvf) buubeKa KaTwpuHev dvGpuuTTOuc Z^uJv- Tac uTTep auTfic TuJ "Aibri , 6v 6 TTXdTwv (pnci cpiXdv-
E OpwTTOV ovTa Kai coqpov Kai ttXouciov, Trei9oi Kai XoYUJ KaTexovTa Tdc ipuxdc, "Aibnv uJV0|udc9ai. Ee- 15 vocpdvric b' 6 cpuciKOc touc AiYUTTTiouc KOTrTO)uevouc i\ Taic ^opTaTc Kai 9privo0vTac opujv uTTCjuvricev oi- Keiujc. 'ouToi' (prjciv 'ei juev 9eoi eici, juf) epnveiTe auTouc" ei b' dv9pujTT0i, )ufi 9ueTe auToic'.
14. 'AXX' oubev outuj TroXuTrXavec Kai TToXuTTa9ec 20 ; v6cr|,ua Kai jue|uiY)uevov evavTiaic boHaic Kai )uaxo|ue- vaic lijc t6 thc beicibaijuoviac. cpeuKTeov ouv auTfiv ■dccpaXuJc Te Kai cujuqpepdvTUJc, oux uJCTrep 01 XriCTuJv f| 9ripiujv ecpobov r\ TrOp dTrepiCKerrTUJC Kai dXoYicTUJC
F TTepicpeuYOVTec ejuTriTrTOuciv eic dvobiac pdpa9pa Kai 25 Kpriiuvouc exoucac. outu» Ydp evioi cpeuYOVTec Tfjv beicibaijuoviav e)UTriTrTouciv eic d9e6TriTa Tpaxeiav Kai dvTiTUTTOV, uTTepTTribficavTec ev juecuj Keijuevriv Tfiv eucepeiav.
2, 80—81 H. 6, 654— G55 B.
13. nxdxujv] Crat. p. 403 C 21. juaxoiuevaic*: jnaxo-
H^vaic jaaWov
PA |
Plutarchus |
4368 |
Plutarchi Chaeronensis |
A2 |
Moralia |
1872 |
|
v.l |
PLEASE DO NOT REMOVE CARDS OR SLIPS FROM THIS POCKET
UNIVERSITY OF TORONTO LIBRARY
v%.
^y--i
-^v^
w^vt^
H ■■H I^Pll £^^^ __|_ 1m ^^H ,, ^mt^, . ^Hi' ^^H |