Historic, archived document
Do not assume content reflects current
scientific knowledge, policies, or practices.
Reo Dri PMENT OF AGRICUIE PUKE:
BUREAU OF PLANT INDUSTRY—BULLETIN NO. 12.
B. T. GALLOWAY, Chief of Bureau.
STOCK TAMGES OF NORTH ESTERS CALIFORNIA:
NOTES ON THE GRASSES AND FORAGE PLANTS
AND RANGE CONDITIONS.
BY
JOSEPH BURTT DAVY,
Assistant Botanist, Agricultural Experiment Station, University of California.
PREPARED UNDER THE DIRECTION OF THE AGROSTOLOGIST,
GRASS AND FORAGE PLANT INVESTIGATIONS.
NW)
Mf
{,/
Ww
54
(CAB,
WASHINGTON:
GOVERNMENT PRINTING OFFICE.
1902.
EET TER OFS TRANSMITTAL.
U. 8S. DEPARTMENT OF AGRICULTURE,
BUREAU OF PLANT INDUSTRY,
OFFICE OF THE CHIEF, |
Washington, D. C., November 23, 1901.
Str: I have the honor to transmit herewith a paper entitled Stock
Ranges of Northwestern California: Notes on the Grasses and Forage
Plants and Range Conditions, and respectfully recommend that it be
published as Bulletin No. 12 of the Bureau series. The paper was
prepared by Mr. Joseph Burtt Davy, assistant botanist of the Agricul-
tural Experiment Station, University of California, and was sub-
mitted by the agrostologist.
Respectfully, B. T. GALLOWAY,
: Chief of Bureau.
Hon. JAMES WILSON,
Secretary of Agriculture.
el)
Rkeob ek Ol:
This report entitled Stock Ranges of Northwestern California:
Notes on the Grasses and Forage Plants and Range Conditions, was
prepared under my direction by Mr. Joseph Burtt Davy, assistant
botanist of the Agricultural Experiment Station of the University of
California. Mr. Davy, under commission from the United States
Department of Agriculture, through this Office, dated March 24, 1900,
made a very thorough investigation of the grasses and forage plants
of northwestern California, a region whose forage resources have not
heretofore been carefully studied. The report contains a compre-
hensive account of the whole region, its physiographic and climatic
conditions, and all the features bearing upon the forage problem.
The information it contains will be of use to ranchmen and dairymen
and all those interested in the stock industry, and will be found of
special value to those living within the region which it covers. In
addition to the presentation of this report, Mr. Davy collected a large
and valuable series of specimens of the native grasses and other plants
which supply more or less grazing, and a set of these specimens has
been added to the collections of the Office.
Mr. Davy wishes to express here his sincere thanks to Dr. Walter
C. Blasdale for invaluable assistance rendered in the collection and
preparation of specimens, for taking and preparing the photographs
which ilustrate this report, and for help in many other ways. With-
out this assistance the investigation could not have been successfully
accomplished.
F. LAMSON-SCRIBNER,
Agrostologist.
OFFICE OF THE AGROSTOLOGIST,
Washington, D. C., November 25, 1901.
CONG r i NS.
Ver OCC ENO Terapia eae een a etn NINN apie data nat SSL ia Ne Alan A) 8 igs MORN Me
Physicalehieatures: ofatherhesvompys is tigi ey hey Ws We ees te een
Nomi eilijuaaly Sula diay STO TIS cin ae hile ess ae a0 ed aide esi oat ued Wee
Moy oxoven 2) O18 tree Lt et a. acu hele: oyna Ae eae ei wakere eRe ee Pg le
Chinra FOO oy en yeaa ee see OLS aaa he AGE eT Maes a
MOTTA TA UU seat pa apnea eh a (Doe Wes UE Sa er OE le
IPGECM Mbt Oe eels Ogre cual oe Va et sty Se Satan Mere ean ha RO
Prevailing Winds_-__-_-__-- ROare Sys ms eee WS Terai eniNris Gage Od eed SEs
I EUesTa NCSU ERE ge nS Se a aN 1S pa ee eC a cn gy omy ge
amor @ Om Gil OMS Maren Slee rie MMA eT ile Lee ee Saga is Vsti a i
Mheslnterlorsela te aw Eve cio mi a0 eo ede Oe Sone Neg ee
JW Toy ora ata aly NY AG2 Haft halt sk ae ee co a ee Ip ee
Memperature ee a ee A eS Ey AOL A ails MEL Ab a ie eg
\YAYEH RMS) EN 0 yyy gaa aca LPS) ee ge apa et Se
SS OTIS ye iam ta eel cesta aoe cape une Td BNE AMAT EON cae Nat ee
NOT Clr eT OCU TS acne! meus ie LL soe wien pale ic iA ye wR A
hiemWaldeMeadowsianduPastures: 2? Stim eee a soi
Forage Value of the: Wald: Meadows 22222222 225 o6. the
improvement of Pasture and Meadow: 227-22 ):050022 002):
Forage Plants Recommended for Trial 6 6
mnie RWinolamed tame sean seek. knee Were 2" ae Ue eee te ds 8 a
- Temperature
ETC CIPO ENERO Gene ap rete re paee af CU SSF ih ea GMI bE Mecel A me
WU aW EWR EASTON 0) OY Rifas S65 120 DS shee tgp en boy ores gece pute, OE San
Soil ssc ose ate a Tee ts oe la 5 rei! NY ae Re eae AS NE Ld ety af
ENCED ACEO US PE aris ea) ie Sp is OV i eS ee a eh ea
D ENCORE ERS) acl ela of Roto dh ay ats ee i) Ce oa Py each eM men eee Ne len
Improvement of the Woodland Forage.___.--.-....5.2_..-.-.
HorageyPlantsiRecommended tor inal i eee
fey © ner fo cutstean lees eene ION A oe yBennene, Waianae pare oe MR UN ag We MINN eh aU oa ee
Stoel ema Oise ee ce re Meet oer tine Reuyihic abe pean rN ANG ur cp) sie SI
System of Range Rotation and Management_________________ Bees is
CAsgyaln oan © Aa City sues = ater toes enon peu aegl awunyer memes Se ee iam os ly eye
IPresentm Capaciin yest ee manne Mek ileo hye Kae Loe Tl
iHonmerns Ca pachtiypaessmee cp emp ium en ciety Mel BOUT One cA ho 7
8 CONTENTS.
Range Conditions—Continued.
The Interior Plateau Region—Continued.
Ranse Deterioration = 6s ase eee Begs ada fas ei tN
Primary Cause
BUnCHASTASSES) BE cea 1 ys Sh peat is ne ote se eee aoe
Sheep. sss Cate le eee a arr Ie See Fae
ee! zoe Soy Biota tate MCN DEC oe ay © SOBs, nee Ae ok Sir RE ter ge ee ee
Masuiun US. Opens Sfeceng Bla EEE: SS ecto 2 enh chet Seis
Range Renewal so 222 se ose 6 oe ise a ev eR a ie eee
Range Improvement ________- ie ae rp oe ay ees A
The Coast-bluit=Belt tesa 2S ie Se Ae eg eee es
Chima tology: 2 2 Ga ene Se Rak Sa et ean ee
Phe Meésashamds tics e252 5 ee ie city ree ee
Grassesiand Other Morager Plants se see oe ee eee
The White-ash:-Prairiese Vow sens ee 5 wees, eee gee ee
HMorage. Crops 22222 5.2 Rs Ss Se eine | eee
Tian: Vales ek ae sc ir
ere H ANG Al OAD 9} c1s (Mii eae te Miata Meier ie sre gua a orien mB gays st tee Oe
Native Sand Binders® oie" 5 ee ee ee
Methods of preventing drifting and reclamation of waste dunes_
Beach Grass 22s Re a eee ey he ee
wea yime! Grass. Gk ee eee ae ee ae Re ee eee
Witthzationzo& Sands Dunes s 3s a sea ee eee eee eee eee fete
The Redwood Beli :) 72 eee Pee ea ea oie a ene pene oe ee enn ee
MORGAET CROPS Oe soe a ea ea ee ne nae ent fe SLE SERS (GRRE arg ey a a
Fodder Crops Now Cultivated Sg in os a nie rs eee RE 3 ED) ee
Plants Recommended for Cultivation or Trial “22 See ee
(PoIsonous Plants: = 2s 5 Wesker eA ee eg
HTN OUS PPATASIGES 2 ie ST ate ey gen ee ee
Phy tographie sNOtes 220 se ais Sy A a ok a Ee Sees
RLU 100 00021 9h (GaeeiiaSRee ier Se SMa eg ect aes aterm MR OR RNS i eet lee Sk a
i b1\0 (=). Come ag Rees ene eee Cer Oe pes oe MR ee ee A es
Plate I.
ID
iu
1G
ILLUSTRATIONS.
PLATES.
Fig. 1. Hupa Valley, from the mountains, looking south. Fig. 2.
Summit of the plateau above Harris, looking west, showing the
upland ranges, the most important pastoral area in the region ____
Fig. 1. A mountain meadow, Sherwood Valley. Fig..2. The bor-
CUSIP OME AA AVS Iea aa ELEY 6 ON SR eS VR Ne i ah yc 0 ele
Fig. 1. The open range: Summit of the plateau above Harris, look-
ing east. Fig. 2. The chapparal. Walker Mountain, showing the
steep. rocky, sparsely clothed slopes, too barren even for pasture _-
Fig. 1. ‘‘ Prairie’’ pastures at low elevation, showing the timbered
~ character of the country. Oaks and buckeye along the Russian
VII.
WADE E
River. Fig. 2. ‘‘ Prairie’’ pastures below the woodlands, Sher-
VCO VO EBAY. INS) ies i PT Be Se at Ft il Za te ea Male cca
. Fig. 1. Russian River, showing the effect of flooding, due to heavy
rainfall on the untimbered uplands. Fig. 2. A perennial stream,
Hupa Valley, protected from washing and evaporation by trees
SUING LOTUS TN cee es Ree OAD oe Se ina i a TRU ae ole EG
. Fig. 1. A lagoon at Crescent City, caused by drifting sand. which
has flooded a large area of pasture land. Fig. 2. Yellow-sand ver-
bena (Abronia latifolia), of some use as a sand binder___________-
Fig. 1. Beach grass at Point Reyes, Cal. Fig. 2. Planting beach
STASS Alin Cappene OC Wass iaes a eae ones ec een ee Ee A ae
Fig. 1. View in grass garden, Agricultural Experiment Station,
Berkeley; Albardin at the right. Fig. 2. Sand-dune reclamation
at Cape Cod, Mass., showing protective covering formed of beach
orass(Aunmopiiiananenaria (Aa) imik)). see ee a
MAPS.
Maple ia prot: Calitormiam sees 5 cee el epU ie ANCA ie eae eee cer ay ees ae
II. Topographical map of northern and middle California____________-
III. Map of northwestern California, showing routes traversed ___.___-
Fig.
TEXT FIGURES.
Page.
50
B. P. I.—14. Agros.—93.
STOCK RANGES OF NORTHWESTERN CALIFORNIA: NOTES ON THE
GRASSES AND FORAGE PLANTS AND RANGE CONDITIONS.
INTRODUCTION.
PHYSICAL FEATURES OF THE REGION.
Northwestern California as here defined includes the counties of
Lake, Mendocino, Humboldt, Trinity, Del Norte, and the portion of
Siskiyou lying west of the California and Oregon Railroad. It is
approximately bounded by lines drawn at 39° and 42° north latitude,
and 122° 30’ and 124° 30’ longitude west of Greenwich. (See Map I.)
It is a fairly well-defined topographical area, bounded on the east
by the inner Coast Range Mountains and on the west by the Pacific
Ocean. It covers the whole of the drainage basins of the Eel, Mad,
Trinity, Lower Klamath, and Smith rivers and the smaller streams
along the coast north of the Gualala River. On the south it extends
beyond this naturally delimited area to include Lake County and the
southern boundary of Mendocino County, thereby taking in the drain-
age basin of Clear Lake and the headwaters of Russian River.
AGRICULTURAL SUBDIVISIONS.
This region is divisible into seven agricultural areas, which are
more or less clearly marked topographically, climatically, and phyto-
logically. They are:
1. The Interior Plateau Belt, dissected into long ridges separated by
deep canyons, some of them running in a more or less northwesterly
direction, other and shorter ones almost due west. This belt is
bounded on the west by the redwood forest and on the east by the
Mayacama, Yallo Bolley, and South Fork mountains. Lying at a
higher altitude, 2,000 to 4,000 feet, it enjoys a warmer summer tem-
perature and less moisture than the Coast Bluff belt; also its soil is
heavier, containing more clay and less sand. With the exception
of a few mountain valleys included within its limits this is almost
exclusively a pastoral area.
2. The Coast Bluff Belt, a narrow stretch of agricultural and pastoral
land varying from 1 to 3 miles in width, and occupying a mesa or
1]
12 STOCK RANGES OF NORTHWESTERN CALIFORNIA.
bench between the shore line and the summit of the first mountain
ridge, which is about 1,600 feet high. This ridge marks the western
edge of the redwood belt. For the most part this belt is elevated some
50 or more feet above the sea, but at Humboldt Bay and Crescent City
it has been eroded almost to sea level, there forming a large and very
fertile flood plain. It is subject to heavy summer fogs, enjoys a more
equable summer climate and a greater amount of moisture than is
found in the interior, and is relatively cool. The soil is considered
poor except at a few points; it is light, being abundantly charged
with drift sand.
3. The Redwood Belt, lying between and parallel with the coast
bluff belt and the interior plateau, and consisting of rough ridges,
separated by narrow V-shaped canyons. It is covered by a more or
less dense growth of redwood (Sequoia sempervirens), and is a cli-
matie and phytological rather than a geographical area, embracing
and being limited to the redwood forest. It runs almost the whole
length of the coast of northwestern California, apparently being inter-
rupted in only one or two places, and lies for the most part away from
the coast line, sheltered from cool and violent winds behind a ridge
which runs nearly parallel with the shore. Seattered redwood trees
are but rarely found outside of this belt, which comprises the forest
proper. The heavy summer sea fogs, drifting high overhead across
the narrow bench of bluff land, are intercepted in their course by the
trees on the summits of the ridges, or, when they le low, roll along
the broad river vallevs and more numerous narrow Ganyons opening
into the redwood forest, saturating the tree tops, and by their means
also the soil below, with abundant moisture. The actual conditions
which delimit this redwood belt are not at present clearly understood,
but climate appears to have been, above any other evident physical
cause, a potent factor in the development of the forest. The soil con-
ditions appear to be generally comparable to those of the plateau can-
yons, except for the additional amount of humus due to the presence
of the trees.
4. The headwaters of the Russian River, forming a connecting link
between the distinct topographical region of northwestern and that of
western middle California, otherwise called the San Francisco Bay
region, to the latter of which it strictly belongs. It is included in this
report because it lies within Mendocino County and because it was the
starting point of the expedition.
5. The drainage basin of Clear Lake, for the most part a stony
and mountainous region, walled in on all sides, and with little levet
land. Its resources are mainly pastoral, though the lake is fringed
by some rich farming and fruit land.
6. Trinity County, an isolated mining region, almost walled in by
high mountains, and including the headwaters of Trinity River.
Searecely anything is known of the botany of this very distinct topo-
Bul. 12, Bureau of Plant Industry, U. S. Dept. of Agriculture. PLATE lI.
. FIG. 1.—HUPA VALLEY FROM THE MOUNTAINS, LOOKING SOUTH.
FiG. 2.—SUMMIT OF THE PLATEAU ABOVE HARRIS, LOOKING WEST, SHOWING THE UPLAND RANGES,
THE MOST IMPORTANT PASTORAL AREA IN THE REGION.
f
Bul. 12, Bureau of Plant Industry, U. S. Dept. of Agriculture. MAP |.
Or
CAILMFOIRNIA
SHOWING
TO POGRAPHICAL REGIONS.
DOTTED PORTION SHOWS THREE
COUNTIES IN NORTHWESTERN REGION
COVERED BY INVESTIGATION .
123° j 120° TSARE 116° Stevenson Del.
ro
4
7
%
‘
PHYSICAL FEATURES OF THE REGION. PS:
graphical area, but the collections of Chestnut and Drew* indicate
that it may be phytologieally distinct from the section west of the
South Fork Mountains.
plants are practically identical with those of the adjacent open ranges,
of which they are simple continuations like the bays and inlets along
the shores of an ocean.
THE WOODLAND OR WINTER RANGE.
The gulches and steep sides of the canyons, especially their eastern
slopes, are thickly covered with trees and underbrush. Several species
occur, and there appears to be little of the preponderance of one kind
over another which characterizes the river bottom lands.
Trees.—The prevalent trees are: Douglas spruce (Pseudotsuga taxi-
folia); Black or Kellogg oak (Quercus californica), which is the largest
species of oak in Mendocino County, sometimes 6 or 7 feet in diameter
and with 50 feet of trunk clear of branches (Clarke); white oak
(Quercus garryana); tan oak (Quercus densiflora), sometimes attain-
ing 130 feet in height and 7 feet in diameter, one measured by the
writer on the Clarke ranch having a circumference of 30 feet at 1 foot
from the ground, one of its branches measuring 11 feet 9 inches in
circumference at 7 feet from the trunk, and five or six limbs nearly 9
feet in circumference; Madroiie (Arbutus menziesii); and along the
streams, pepper wood (Umbellularia californica). Less abundant,
but by no means uncommon, are the yellow pine (Pinus ponderosa),
chinquapin (Castanopsis chrysophylla), Oregon maple (Acer macro-
phyllum), and tree dogwood (Cornus nuttalli). The California nut-
meg (Tumion californicum), incense cedar (Libocedrus decurrens),
and Oregon ash (Fraxinus oregana) are occasionally met with, and
the sugar pine (Pinus lambertiana) oceurs on Mount Sanhedrin. The
redwood (Sequoia sempervirens) scarcely ever grows beyond the limit
of its own particular belt or isolated grove. The valley oak (Quercus
lobata), golden oak (Q. chrysolepis), and other trees occur in the
Bul. 12, Bureau of Plant Industry, U. S. Dept. of Agriculture. PLATE IV.
Fig. 1.—‘‘ PRAIRIE’ PASTURES AT LOW ELEVATION, SHOWING THE TIMBERED CHARACTER OF THE
COUNTRY. OAKS AND BUCKEYE ALONG THE RUSSIAN RIVER.
see
FIG. 2.—‘* PRAIRIE’? PASTURES BELOW THE WOODLANDS, SHERWOOD VALLEY.
THE WOODLAND OR WINTER RANGE. 29
plateau section, but do not form a characteristic feature of the
woodland.
Underbrush.—The woodland is frequently fringed with a belt of
manzanita (Arctostaphylos). In the woods there is abundance of
underbrush, in which the deer find shelter and on which they browse.
It consists principally of hazel (Corylus rostrata californica), poison
oak (Rhus diversiloba), cascara sagrada or pigeon berry (Rhamnus
californica), mountain rose (Rosa gymnocarpa), salal (Gaultherva
shallon), huckleberry (Vaccinium ovatum and V. parvifolium), wild
blackberry (Rubus vitifolius), ete. In certain localities deer brush
(Ceanothus integerrumus, C. incanus, and C. velutinus) and a species
of service berry (Amelanchier) are found.
Herbaceous plants.—Grass species and individuals are not abund-
ant in the shady woods, and most of those which occur have sparse
foliage, affording but little feed for stock. The species most commonly
met with are Bromus levipes, Melica bromoides, M. torreyana, and
Trisetum canescens. Festuca californica, ‘‘ vanilla grass” (Savastana
macrophylla), and Hlymus glaucus are not uncommon.
Other perennial herbaceous plants, such as Achlys triphylla, Van-
couveria parviflora, Iris douglasiana, I. purdyt, Viola lobata, Aspidium
munitum, Adenocaulon sp., HKriophyllum spp., and Brodicwa spp. are
abundant, but annual plants are comparatively rare.
Forage plants.—From off this miscellaneous assortment of plants
cattle, horses, sheep, and hogs have to ‘‘rustle” a living during sev-
eral months of the fall and early winter, yet they are said to keep in
good condition in spite of the unpromising nature of the forage.
Cattle and horses browse on poison oak, hazel, white oak, deer brush,
and the few grasses they can find. Sheep freely eat, in addition to
the above, the very tough and astringent leaves of. the manzanita.
This is shown in a striking and very characteristic manner by the neat
way in which each bush is trimmed, sheep-head high, and divested of
every leaf within reach.
Hogs find better picking in the woods than do other stock, and are
left to run there almost the year round. They are said to live largely
on the acorns of the three oaks above mentioned, on chinquapin nuts,
pepper nuts (Umbellularia californica), madrohe, manzanita, and
poison-oak berries, the bulbs and tubers of liliaceous and other plants,
and on grasses and clovers. In August the manzanita berries ripen,
and the hogs feed on them till the poison-oak berries, acorns, and
other nuts and fruits mature. Bythe.time these crops are exhausted
the grasses and clovers are fit for food and continue till the end of
June. July is the month of poorest hog feed, and it is necessary to
provide corn or grain till the manzanita berries are again ripe, in
August.
The acorns of the white oak are said to make the best and sweetest
feed and to produce the best bacon, but the crop is very uncertain.
The tan oak is the most reliable acorn producer.
30 STOCK RANGES OF NORTHWESTERN . CALIFORNIA.
Improvement of the woodland forage. —Except in portions of the red-
woed belt, the timber occupies land which would probably never be
fit for agricultural purposes on account of either or both of the fol-
lowing reasons: First, the steepness of the slopes, which makes them
practically inaccessible and exposes them to soil washing to a ruinous
extent as soon as cleared of the protecting timber and brush; seec-
ond, the poor and rocky nature of the soil. The clearing of the land
would therefore be unprofitable, unless for the sake of the timber.
The clearing of such lands would seriously affect the water supply
of the upper ranges. This has been conclusively demonstrated near
‘Scotia, and near Guerneville, in Sonoma County, where the clearing
and keeping clear of the redwood land for pasture purposes has
resulted in the drying up of many springs and small creeks which
were formerly perennial. The way in which the stream beds are
flooded with ‘‘ waste” water from the treeless upland ranges in times
of heavy rain is shown on the accompanying plate (Pl. V, fig. 1),
and, by contrast, the beneficial effect of a heavy covering of timber
and brush, which protects the tributary springs and creeks from
evaporation, is shown in figure 2 on the same plate.
The timber produced (outside of the redwood belt) is not at pres-
ent considered worth lumbering, but is used for fuel and fencing.
The tan oak (Quercus densiflora) is highly valued for its bark, used
for tanning, and an extensive industry in oak bark is carried on in
the more accessible canyons near the coast. It is quite possible that
the future demand for tan bark, which is becoming scarcer each
year,* may warrant the systematic planting of the tan oak on these
canyon slopes. This would result in a large increase of hog feed in
the acorn season."
Forage plants recommended for trial.—It is not improbable that by
establishing pasture plots of shade-growing forage plants in small
clearings among the timber and brush the winter feed of the wood-
®Some idea of the extent of the annual destruction of tan oak can be gathered
from the statement that in 1899 there were shipped 1.500 cords of bark (a cord
weighing 2.300 pounds) from Point Arena and 1,500 from Greenwood: 500 cords
are annually peeled at the Union Lumber Company's camps near Fort Bragg, and
large amounts are annually shipped from Gualala, Iversen, Navarro, Albion,
Little River. Mendocino City. Caspar. Westport. Usal, and Bear Harbor, as well
as from other points. We met twenty-one 4-horse wagon loads of bark en route
to Bear Harbor in a morning’s drive between Kenny and Thorn.
The bark from the Greenwood lumber camps is supplied *‘to the California
Tanning Extract Company, who have a plant in conjunction with the Greenwood
mill. The bark is reduced to a liquid form. and is barreled and shipped, princi-
pally to Japan. One cord of tan bark weighs 2.300 pounds; when in liquid form
it is reduced down to about 550 or 600 pounds.”
» Acorn-fed pork is. at best. considered poor in quality. being soft and oily; it
brings 14 cents per pound less than corn-fed pork; it is claimed that even though
‘finished off *’ on corn the quality of the fat remains the same. Poland-China
hogs are used almost exclusively for range feeding, being much more docile than
Berkshires, which become wild and unmanageable with the freedom of the range.
Bul. 12, Bureau of Plant Industry, U. S. Dept. of Agriculture. PLATE V.
FiG. 1.—RUSSIAN RIVER, SHOWING THE EFFECT OF FLOODING, DUE TO HEAVY RAINFALL ON THE
UNTIMBERED UPLANDS.
FiG. 2.—A PERENNIAL STREAM, HUPA VALLEY, PROTECTED FROM WASHING AND EVAPORATION BY
TREES AND BRUSH.
thy
SA ee
FAD aon han
ets
qe hacen
Seat
‘ THE CHAPARRAL. ol
land ranges could be increased. As these ranges are used for fall and
early winter feeding, the grasses that will be of greatest benefit in such
situations will be those that make the earliest winter growth.
Among the grasses which make the earliest winter growth at
Berkeley the following are recommended for trial: Orchard-grass
(Dactylis glomerata), tall oat grass (Arrhenatherum elatius), wood
meadow grass (Poa nemoralis), reed fescue (Mestuca arundinacea).
It must be borne in mind, however, that we can not expect to make
first-class pastures out of timbered lands. It is impossible to success-
fully combine good timber cultures and good pastures, for the objects
and needs of the two are diametrically opposed, and what will benefit
the one may injure the other. The timber and brush are needed in
order to preserve the flow of the springs. All we can hope to do in
the way of improvement, therefore, is to somewhat increase the amount
of grass produced in the open spaces.
THE CHAPARRAL.
Chaparral is the Spanish word for a thicket of low shrubs, and was
used by the Spanish-Californians to designate the thickets of scrub-
oak (Quercus dumosa) which are so noticeable a feature of rocky
ridges in this region. It is now apphed promiscuously to any low,
dense brush of prickly or rigid shrubs growing in similar situations,
as well as to the individual species of which the mass is composed.
In these senses the words chaparral and chamisal are often used
interchangeably; chamisal strictly means, however, a_ stretch of
burned over chaparral, from the Spanish chamizo, a piece of half-
burnt wood. The term is now generally restricted to the ‘‘chamise”
bush (Adenostoma fasciculatum).
So local and strikingly characteristic are these chaparral areas that
they have become landmarks, the word chamisal, sometimes cor-
rupted into chemisal, chemise, or chimese, being adopted as a local
name. ‘Thus, we find on the map of Humboldt County a ‘‘ Chemisal
Creek” and ‘‘Chimese Ridge” in the vicinity of Harris, and a ‘‘ Che-
mise Mountain,” near Shelter Cove.
As before stated, the chaparral covers dry, stony ground, where the
soil appears to be too scant and poor to support a generous herbace-
ous vegetation. It is usually composed of such shrubs as Adenostoma
fasciculatum, Ceanothus cuneatus, Quercus dumosa, Cercocarpus
sp. (mountain mahogany), species of Arctostaphylos (manzanita),
Garrya fremonti, Hriodictyon californicum (Yerba santa), ete., the
component species varying with the locality, and frequently one or
other being so prevalent over a large area as to give it specific
individuality.
The grasses usually met with in these arid, rocky spots are tufted
in their habit of growth, and consequently come under the common
category of ‘‘ bunch grass.” The species are fewin number. Melica
o2 STOCK RANGES OF NORTHWESTERN CALIFORNIA.
californica, M. harfordu, Stipa lemmoni, Sitanion multisetum, S.
planifolium, Elymus glaucus, species of Poa, Festuca, Bromus carina-
tus, and occasionally Festuca ovina being the only ones collected.
Lotus americanus and oceasionally a clump of ‘‘ deer brush” (Ceano-
thus integerrimus) are the only plants met with, other than grasses,
which are known to be of forage value.
The individuals of these forage plants are so few and far apart as
to afford only the scantiest pickings for animals, and the brush is
usually so dense that stock can penetrate it only with difficulty.
Under these circumstances a piece of chaparral is naturally consid-
ered so much waste ground, being not only unproductive or almost
entirely so, but, on account of the poverty of the soil, not worth the
cost of clearing.
SUBALPINE MEADOWS.
In the Trinity and Inner Coast Range mountains subalpine mead-
ows are occasionally met. with at an altitude of about 6,500 feet,
which resemble to a considerable extent those of the Sierra Nevada,
not only in physical and climatical features but also in phytological
aspect.
I had opportunity to visit a group of such meadows on Trinity Sum-
mit, to the east of Hupa Valley, between June 21 and 23, 1899, but
found that it was still too early in the season to find any but the
earliest spring flowersin blossom—Suliz, Ribes, Erythronium, Frasera,
Kalmia, ete. With the exception of Melica spectabilis the grasses
and sedges which form a dense turf on the alluvial soils in hollows
just below the peaks were just commencing their new growth, and
in many places were still under snow. Appearances indicated, how-
ever, that here at last we had found patches of the primitive flora
still almost entirely unaduiterated by admixtures of alien species.
The meadows are so completely isolated from the distant valleys
and lower grass-covered ridges by steep rocky chaparral ridges
and stretches of spruce and tan-oak forest, covering the whole of the
altitudinal distance of about 6,000 feet from the floor of Hupa Valley,
that it has proved difficult for aliens to cross this natural barricade.
A few specimens of sheep sorrel (Rumex acetosella) were found in
open spots along the trail, and even on Trinity Summit, being appar-
ently the first of the alien horde to reach those grazing grounds. It
will be interesting from an ecological standpoint to watch whether
other species succeed in following this irrepressible and pernicious
weed.
As the growth of vegetation in these subalpine meadows is later
than that at lower altitudes, on account of lower temperature and
consequent persistence of snow, they are valuable adjuncts to the
stock ranges, providing green pasturage for several weeks after the
upland ranges at lower altitudes are dry and brown.
SYSTEM OF RANGE ROTATION AND MANAGEMENT. 39
On the plateau, where the greatest elevation does not exceed 4,000
feet and but little snow falls in winter and none remains into the sum-
mer, the grasses mature early, and there are no late alpine meadows.
SYSTEM OF RANGE ROTATION AND MANAGEMENT.
In California the season of activity in plant growth commences
with the early autumn rains (September and October), while the heat
rays still have power to warm the soil below the surface. It is then
that the seeds of annual plants, dormant since the time of ripening in
early summer, commence to germinate and the seedlings to establish
themselves in the loosening soil.
Though they germinate so early in the season these annuals do not
make much upward growth until the advent of the warm spring days
during February or early March, after which their progress to maturity
is usually rapid. By April-May or May-June, according to the season,
they have attained their maximum growth and begin to ripen or are
at least flowering.
The flowering season is short, and with the arrival of the hot, dry,
north winds in June or July the open hillsides rapidly assume that
brown and barren aspect so characteristic of a California summer.
During the fall and early winter months, when the ‘‘ bands” of cattle
and sheep have been reduced by summer sales of fat stock, it is cus-
tomary, on ranges under the best management, to confine the stock to
the woodland or winter range. This method gives the seedling annual
grasses and clovers, which furnish most of the forage on the summer
rar ge, a chance to get well anchored in the soil and fairly established;
otherwise, on account of their shallow rooting, a large proportion
would be destroyed by trampling or pulling.
As soon as feed is sufficiently plentiful the ‘‘ bands” are permitted to
return to the summer range. With the advent of the dry season the
animals are usually ready for market and stockmen begin to thin out
their flocks and herds. A general exodus soon commenees, the mar-
ketable animals being driven to Ukiah or Eureka for shipment to San
Francisco.
With this exodus of sheep and cattle summer travel over the stage
road from Ukiah to Eureka becomes more than ever unpleasant. The
roadsides which a short time previous were carpeted with grasses and
wild flowers are quickly stripped of every blade of green, and the
roads, hitherto fairly good, become thick with dust, which is thrown
up in clouds by the numerous droves of animals passing each day.
The reserve ‘‘ bands,” now much reduced in size, continue to find
subsistence, and even keep fat for some time, on the ripening heads of
soft chess and other forage plants which are now dried into‘a stand-
ing crop of short hay. This cured hay is considered highly nutri-.
tious until it has been washed by the early rains, when. it) seems to
lose its palatableness. |
18766—No. 12—02——_-3
34 STOCK RANGES OF NORTHWESTERN CALIFORNIA.
In the Trinity and Inner Coast Range mountains, as well as in the
Sierra Nevada, it is customary to drive the stock up the mountains to
the subalpine meadows for summer pasture. For several years the
Hupa Indians have followed this practice on Trinity Summit, the
meadows which occur at about 6,500 to 7,000 feet altitude being a
favorite range for the cattle of the reservation.
CARRYING CAPACITY.
Present capacity.—lIt is difficult to obtain exact data as to the pres-
ent carrying capacity of the ranges, stockmen being loath to give fig-
ures for obvious reasons. The Blue Rock Range, of 2,500 acres, is
said to carry 1,200 head of sheep and 100 head of horned stock, or an
equivalent of an acre and a half to a sheep and 7 acres to each head
of cattle. This is the same ratio for sheep as is reported for the
prairies around Sherwood Valley. On the ranges near Bells Springs
the maximum e¢apacity is given as little more than an acre to one
head of sheep, and 5, 6, or sometimes even 10 or 12 acres to one head
of cattle. It is said that on the poorest ranges, which have become
worn-out by overstocking, it takes 20 acres to support one head of
cattle.
The ranges on Walker Mountain and Sherwood Mountain seem to
be in better condition than those north of Cummings. Danthonia and
soft brome grass are much more abundant and the maximum earry-
ing capacity is higher (at present), the ratio being reported as only 4
or even 5 acres to one head of cattle. The latter figures may, how-
ever, apply only to open range or may include winter pasturage in
the meadows instead of on woodland ‘*‘ browse.” Such heavy stock-
ing can not long be maintained, however. Mr. Blair, on Sherwood
Mountain, has 200 acres of range and carries 60 to 80 head of hogs,
40 to 50‘head of cattle, and a few horses.*
On the ranges which were found to be in the best condition it was
learned that not less than 8 acres was allowed for each head of cattle
and 13 acres for each sheep.
Colonel Harding’s range of some 13,000 aeres is said to carry about
400 eattle, 100 horses, and 5,000 sheep, or a total equivalent of some
1,600 head of cattle, about 1 to 8 acres.
These ratios are supposed to inelude both open and woodland or
brush range. It is said that there are usually about 2 acres of the
latter to every 1 acre of clear land, but the proportion varies some-
what with the locality. Open range alone is said to be ecapabe of
carrying 1 head of cattle to 4 or 5 acres and | head of sheep to 1 aere
during the season.
Former capacity.—The first white settlers in the valleys north of
Walker Mountain appear to have located in 1852 or 1853, and they
“It is possible that my i.formant was in error as regards these figures. I much
doubt whether any range in the region is as heavily stocked as this statement
would indicate.
CARRYING CAPACITY. aD
either brought bands of cattle with them or drove them in a year
or two later, and for several years the region was a great unfenced
eattle range. Humboldt County was first settled in the vicinity of
Humboldt Bay in 1849 or 1850. A eattle ranch was maintained in
Clear Lake Valley prior to 1849 by Andrew Kelsey and Charles Stone,
who were murdered by Indians in December, 1849.
According to Carl Purdy,* ‘“‘for years Mendocino County was a ecat-
tle county, with all the wild lawlessness which pertains to that indus-
try and conflicting squatters’ rights. As the wild animals were killed
out the high price of wool stimulated sheep growing; until 1875 the
mountainous country was almost entirely devoted to that branch of
grazing. Then the mountain land was surveyed and landowners
obtained titles, lands were fenced, and the second stage of grazing
reached. The large profits in sheep raised the price of grazing lands
to too high a figure, and graziers were tempted to overreach them-
selves by the purchase of surrounding lands.” Then came a fall in
the price of wool, and many rangers replaced their sheep with cattle;
others, ‘‘overloaded with debts accrued by land purchases, went into
bankruptey.” At present the sheep and cattle industries on the
ranges are of about equal importance.
It is even more difficult to obtain information as to the actual con-
dition and vegetation of the ranges in the first years of occupation by
white people than about the present carrying capacity. There are
various indications, however, pointing to a much more highly pro-
duetive condition in those early days than has been realized for
many years.
The fact that at the present time the three most abundant grasses
are adventive species of foreign origin favors this view. There is evi-
dence that they have become naturalized within comparatively recent
years. Small barley grass and soft chess are not recorded as occur-
ring in the State at the time of the State geological survey in the
early sixties, and Dr. Bolander, who at that time was making a special
study of the grasses of California, does not appear to have collected
squirrel-tail in either Mendocino or Humboldt when he visited these
counties in 1864 and again in 1865. It is evident, therefore, that these
grasses, now so abundant, are not only naturalized aliens, but also
that they must have replaced other and equally abundant species,
since it is inconceivable that in such a climate fertile soil could long
remain other than densely clothed with some kind of vegetation. Old-
timers are unanimously agreed, moreover, that the feed on the ranges
has changed materially since they first settled in the country. Mr.
Bell, of Bells Springs, says that the feed on his ranges has changed
several times during the twenty-seven years he has lived there, ‘‘ new ”
(adventitious) species coming in, becoming predominant, and in their
turn giving place to others.
* Ukiah Dispatch-Democrat.
36 STOCK RANGES OF NORTHWESTERN CALIFORNIA.
Colonel Harding states that small barley grass (locally called fox-
tail) was brought in by sheep, being observed first along their tracks.
The questions, then, arise, what were the components of the primi-
tive vegetation which oceupied the place of the present alien flora;
how did it compare with the latter as regards forage value, and what
new species came in, became prevalent, and then gave place to others.
The earlier floras appear to have been composed of plants more gen-
erally acceptable to stock than the weedy species now prevailing,
otherwise they would scarcely have given such complete place to alien
species. In other words, if they had not been highly paiatable to
stock they would not have been ‘‘eaten out,” and if the adventive
species had been equally palatable they could scarcely have acquired
a foothold under the system of heavy stocking which has prevailed.
Few residents in this region are sufficiently familiar with plants to
define the actual changes in the flora which take place over a period
of years. Some, however, have noticed the change in composition of
the range feed. Mr. Bell, Mr. Joseph H. Clarke, and others state
that danthonia and other ‘‘ bunch grasses,” wild oats, alfilerilla,
clovers, wild-pea vines (Lathyrus sp.), and wild sunflower (Wyethia
sp.) were formerly the most abundant plants on the ranges. All
these, they state, have been materially reduced in quantity or have
disappeared altogether, and in their places squirrel tail, small barley —
grass, and soft chess have become established since they settled in the
county. These statements are in part confirmed by Menefee, who,
DIIFQ
writing in 1875, says of this section of Mendocino County:
The soilis * * * covered with a rich growth of clover, wild oats, bunch
grass, and rosin weed or wild sunflower.
All of the above-named plants are now relatively scarce.
Wild oats and alfilerilla were not, however, the primitive forage
plants, for they also are aliens, natives of the Mediterranean region,
their introduction into California probably dating from the Spanish
occupation. Being adventive, they too must have replaced other
plants which were probably native in the sense of not having been
introduced through the ageney of man or his domestic animals, since
we have no records of immigration earlier than that of the Mission
Fathers.
On account of their wide distribution in the State, and their abun-
dance and prevalence in the fifties, many persons have refused to
believe that wild oats and alfilerilla could be other than native to the
soil; even Bolander, writing in the early sixties, was inclined to believe
that they must be native alike in southern Europe and California. To
anyone who has watched the rapid spread of alien weeds in the rich
soil and favorable climate of this State, and has observed one alien
gradually give place to others, the century and a quarter which has
elapsed since the Spanish occupation will appear none too short to
witness the occupation of the whole State by such prolific plants as
NATIVE SPECIES OF THE REGION. oil
,
wild oats and alfilerilla, and the later disappearance of one or both of
them by overstocking. This matter will be more fully discussed after
the causes of range deterioration have been considered.
Col. Redick McKee, United States Indian agent, with a military party,
passed over the plateau region from Santa Rosa to Humboldt Bay in the
fall of 1851. Mr. George Gibbs, who kept the official diary of the party,
mentions® that wild oats were very abundant on the slopes of the
lower foothills from Santa Rosa northward. Before reaching Feliz
Valley, the most northerly Spanish ranch in the Russian River Val-
ley, he notes: ‘‘The hills passed to-day were covered with bunch
grass, the wild oats having disappeared.” Wild oats were again
observed on what is now known as Walker Mountain, but were not
noted from any place to the northward, though bunch grasses are
frequently mentioned. There is no mention of alfilerilla. Colonel
McKee’s party seems to have been only the second white party to
make the overland trip.
What then were the prevalent plant species before the advent of
wild oats and alfilerilla? Though no written record appears to exist,
this question can be answered in a fairly satisfactory manner by infer-
ence. It is unreasonable to suppose that in the comparatively short
time (some fifty years only) which has elapsed since these hills were
first ranged by white men any of the then prevalent plants could
have become extinct. We must therefore look for them among the
species still to be found in protected places on the ranges. In fenced-
off areas surrounding some of the springs on the Bell’s Springs Range
and a few other places, are still to be found luxuriant growths of native
clovers, grasses, and other plants which have been somewhat pro-
tected from their natural enemies, the range stock. Of course weedy
grasses, with alfilerilla and wild oats, have found their way there also;
but the native species have been able to hold their own to a greater
extent than elsewhere. The vegetation of such places gives us a clew
to the former condition of things. Here are found the native annual
clovers, Trifolium cyathiferum, T. bifidum decipiens, T. tridentatum, T.
variegatum var., T. microcephalum, and T. furcatum virescens, mak-
ing a luxuriant growth, sometimes almost knee-deep. Sheep fescue
(Festuca ovina), danthonia (Danthonia californica), Sitanion multi-
setum, S. planifolium, S. villosum, and Elymus angustifolius, all pro-
miscuously known as ‘“‘ bunch grasses,” together with ‘‘ wild pea-vines”
(species of Lathyrus) and ‘‘ wild sunflower” (species of Wyethia), are
also plentiful. In dry, rocky places California melic grass (Melica
californica), Lemmon’s buneh grass (Stipa lemmoni), and one or two
species of meadow grass (Poa, allied to P. fendleriana) are frequently
found. These are also called ‘‘ bunch-grasses.”
“Gibbs, George: *‘Journal of the expedition of Col. Redick McKee, United States
Indian agent, through northwestern California, performed in the summer and
fallof 1851."’ Published in Dr. Henry Schooleraft’s Archives of Knowledge,
99-177. Philadelphia, 1860.
38 STOCK RANGES OF NORTHWESTERN CALIFORNIA.
It thus appears that these same clovers and other annual plants and
the same perennial ‘‘ bunch-grasses,” which are now but sparingly
found, were in former times the common plants of the open range,
and that the species now most abundant, ineluding alfilerilla and
also wild oats, were unknown here before the Spanish occupation of
California.
The following conclusions, therefore, were accepted:
1. The prinitive forage plants were the ‘‘ bunch-grasses” (Dan-
thonias, Stipas, Melicas, Poas, and perennial Festueas), with annual
and perennial clovers, wild pea vines and wild sunflowers; these were
much more abundant in former times than now, and on account of
their palatableness they largely disappeared with overstocking.
2. With the advent of white settlers and their domestic animals,
wild oats and alfilerilla (Hrodium cicutarium) took possession of the
country; these increased in relative abundance as the native forage
plants became scarce; as the latter diminished in quantity cattle took
to eating the former until they in like manner succumbed, while
other plants took their places.
3. Small barley grass, squirrel tail, and soft chess were among
the next weedy introductions; the two former, when in a maturing
condition being disliked by cattle, have had a chance to spread and
cover the ranges, but cattle having acquired a taste for soft chess,
it is being kept in check, if not diminishing, on closely grazed ranges.
4. A third immigration is now taking place, in which musky alfile-
rilla (Erodiwm moschatum), broncho grass (Bromus maximus gussont),
barley grass (Hordeum murinum, locally called fox-tail), tacalote (Cen-
taurea melitensis), hawkbit (Hypocheris glabra), bur-clover (Medi-
cago denticulata), and other weeds are establishing themselves along
the roadsides and around ranch houses. Of these, the bur-clover, and
the musky alfilerilla, have some forage value. Barley grass is eaten
green in the spring before heading out, but afterwards becomes one of
the most objectionable weeds for a stock range. The other aliens
are destined to cause irreparable injury to the ranges unless kept in
check and prevented from becoming firmly established.
RANGE DETERIORATION.
Primary cause.—Range deterioration is traceable to the desire to
make as much off the land as possible, coupled with two mistaken
ideas: (1) That a range can continue to carry the maximum number
of stock without deterioration year after year without any rest; (2)
that in order to get the most out of a range in a given period of time
it must be stocked to its maximum ¢arrying capacity.
By maximum e¢arrying capacity is meant the highest possible num-
ber of stock that the range will turn off in good condition at selling
time, witbout taking into account the condition of the range itself;
in other words, it has reference purely to the present crop of stock,
‘RANGE DETERIORATION. 39
without reference to the range or to future production. The opti-
mum carrying capacity, on the other hand, means the highest num-
ber that can possibly be carried without injury to the range, providing
for the production of future crops, and eventually, therefore, bringing
the best results both to range owner and occupier.
On ranges which are not stocked beyond the optimum the animals-
are not likely to depasture any one spot, and a sufficient number of
plants of alfilerilla, native clovers, danthonia, and other bunch grasses
will thus be left to ripen seed for another season’s growth. Having
more space over which to roam, the stock will spend less time in one
place, doing less injury to the bunch grasses by their trampling. The
number of stock which make the difference between the maximum
and optimum carrying capacity costs more to the range owner in per-
manent and irreparable damage to his property than they can bring
back in cash value. While every head of stock put upon the range,
until the optimum is reached, is equivalent to so much additional
profit, every head carried beyond the optimum net only ceases to bea
source of profit, in that it limits the supply of nutritious plants both
for itself and the rest of the herd, but also causes deterioration to
the range. The amount of deterioration can not be measured by the
actual amount of feed eaten, but increases with geometrical progres-
sion to an astonishing degree, determined by the number of useful
plants left to ripen seed for the next year’s crop. Looked at from
this standpoint, it is evident that when an annual range begins to
deteriorate the deterioration will continue at a rapid rate until checked
by a change of method in management.
Stockmen all admit that overstocking is a bad practice, and con-
demn it; but each man has his own conception of what overstocking
is, the number of acres required per head ranging all the way from
3 to 20 acres, varying somewhat, to be sure, according to the condition
and situation of the range. Doubtless the point where the over-
stocking commences is determined, with most stockmen, by the con-
dition of the stock, without regard to that of the range; few would
realize that by running all the stock the range will carry they are
actually overstocking—that is to say, seriously depleting the range and
reducing the number of head which can be carried in future years.
Unlike arable land, which is cultivated and resown artificially year
after year and on which the crops can therefore be cropped close
without injury, a stock range has to seed itself naturally, and on
account of the high mortality percentage among seeds under ordinary
conditions it must be allowed to seed itself heavily or else it will
deteriorate.
Excessive land valuations.—In discussing values the distinction
between an annual and perennial range must be borne in mind. The
annual range is much more subject to change than the perennial
range; therefore the difference between maximum and optimum
A() STOCK RANGES OF NORTHWESTERN CALIFORNIA.
capacity is very much greater in the case of the former than of the
latter. The value of a range, moreover, depends not alone on the
number of head it will carry, but also, and primarily, upon the nature
and quality of the forage. If the prevailing forage plants are annuals,
or even perennial bunch-grasses, the maximum ¢arrying capacity, for
a few years at least, may be as high as a range producing turf-forming
or creeping-rooted grasses, but its optimum will be much lower.
How overstocking effects deterioration.—Two factors are at work on
range deterioration. One is the destruction of the choicest forage
plants by selection; the other the introduction of uneatable weeds
which, multiplying rapidly, crowd out the often less vigorous, useful
species, and fill the spaces left vacant.
So long as there is a choice left to them, stock naturally wander over
a range, picking out from among other plants the specially palatable
species. Thus, by close cropping, the favorite forage plants may be
almost entirely prevented from seeding. On an ‘‘annual” range
most of the plants, being shallow-rooted annuals, are easily pulled out
and destroyed. As they depend entirely on the production of seed for
the propagation of their kind, it is clear that in this way their num-
ber is rapidly diminished. A few always escape, on account of their
situation in secluded places, or because of their depauperate size, or
from other causes, but these are too few in number or too poor in seed
production to maintain the productiveness of the range.
On a virgin range there is not only an abundance of plants sufficient
to feed all the stock and to seatter seed as well, but also a large quan-
tity of ungerminated seed lying dormantin thesoil. Onthis account
‘it is clear that such a range may be stocked to its maximum capacity,
for a short time, without injury. After a year or two, or perhaps a
still shorter time, the granary of surplus seed is exhausted and heavy
stocking prevents the formation of more than a small quantity of
new seed. Then deterioration commences. Every plant eaten means
not only the loss of one individual but also the destruction of so
much reproductive power. Formerly there were plants enough not
only for forage but also for seeding; now, every one eaten represents
so much seeding capacity destroyed. And herein les the difference
in value (now represented by many dollars) between the annual and
the perennial range. As an annual range depends on the production
of seed for its preservation, close feeding means the destruction of
the next generation as well as the present. A perennial range, on the
other hand, does not depend upon seed for its preservation and often
not for its reproduction; for the individual plants live on from year
to vear and the best of them propagate themselves from their run-
ning underground stems. Such plants can be pastured comparatively
close, not only without injury but with absolute benefit, for close
grazing induces them tc throw out more roois and form a denser turf.
The selection by stock of the choicest of the annual plants hastens
WILD OATS AND ALFILERILLA. AA
deterioration in another way. The reduction in the number of plants
leaves so much more nutriment and space available for the growth of
weeds and other less valuable species. Weeds invariably follow the
introduction of stock, into a country. By range weeds we mean any
plants of thrifty, vigorous habit, which are distasteful to stock. Just
as certainly as the selection by eattle of the choicest plants makes it
difficult for them to maintain a foothold, so surely does the same
process of selection allow the weeds every opportunity to increase, by
maturing and scattering seed without let or hindrance.
These weeds are largely alien species, introduced chiefly by acci-
dent, with the advent of the white man, or along with the domestic
plants and animals introduced by himata later date. They are often
plants which have become hardened to much more adverse conditions
of soil and climate than they find in California, and therefore grow
with greater luxuriance and spread with greater rapidity than species
which have, by long continuance under uniformly favorable condi-
tions, shown a tendency to ‘‘run out” or to deteriorate. The struggle
for existence seems to be as keen among plants as among human
beings, and if one species or race is killed out by its animal or other
enemies, another race, less liable to attack by the same kind of enemy,
steps in to fill the space. Under these conditions it is evident that
on an overstocked annual range those species which are especially
palatable to stock will have little chance to propagate their kind.
Wild oats and alfilerilla.—lf the destruction of the most palatable
forage plants by selection is constantly going on, how could such pala-
table species as wild oats and alfilerilla ever have become so abund-
antly naturalized as to be the prevailing plants on the ranges in the
relatively short time since the Spanish occupation of California? And
if they had at one time been able to establish themselves as aliens
would not the same factor which enabled them to establish them-
selves prevent their being killed out by pasturing at a later date?
Is it not more probable that they are indigenous species, which have
suffered numerical diminution in the same way as have the wild elo-
vers? Such are the questions asked in this connection. We are not
at present prepared to answer them decisively, but to anyone who
has watched the spread of introduced weeds in California, especially
those from the Mediterranean region, the exotic origin and rapid
increase of wild oats and alfilerilla will not appear improbable, even
in the face of general range deterioration. Usually European weeds
find themselves quite at home on the soil of this State, new to them,
and comparatively unimpoverished. Annual species, especially,
spread with great rapidity. If the wild oats and alfilerilla were intro-
duced at the time of the Spanish occupation, when cattle were com-
paratively few in the land, they would have abundant opportunity to
“take” the country in spite of being relished by stock. Later, how-
ever, as cattle multiplied, and sheep were introduced, forage became
42 STOCK RANGES OF NORTHWESTERN CALIFORNIA.
relatively less abundant, and at the same time weedy species, such as
small fox-tail and squirrel-tail, less liked by cattle, came in, grad-
ually monopolizing the ground left vacant by the destruction of the
wild oats and alfilerilla.
Exactly the same process of introduction and eradication is taking
place at the present time under our own eyes. Soft chess has,
within recent years, taken possession of the hills in some parts of the
State, much to the disgust of stockmen. Sooner or later the cattle
have taken such a faney to the new forage, either from necessity or
choice, that it, in turn, has been almost eaten out, enough being left
to show that it was once there, and other species not yet liked by
cattle are taking Its place. |
So this process of elimination or natural selection goes on. Species
which are liked by stock, but which are unable to retain their hold on
the soil when grazed or trampled, disappear or become scarce, and
other species come in and take their place. These, in turn, must pass
away if unfitted to maintain the struggle for existence. Only the fit-
test survive—the fittest from the standpoint of the plant—the least
fit (the weedy, useless species) from the standpoint of the rancher.
Bunch grasses.-—The fact has already been alluded to that the
so-called ‘‘ bunch grasses ” are not as well adapted for grazing as are
running and turf-forming species. On account of their tuft-forming
nature the former are more easily pulled out than are species which
spread by means of underground rootstocks.
Sheep versus cattle.--Cattlemen think that the great depreciation in
carrying capacity is due to sheep, claiming that sheep do far more
injury to a range than do cattle. This is only partially true, however,
and while it may be true that a range overstocked with sheep will
suffer more on account of their close biting than one overstocked with
cattle, which do not graze so clo:ely, it is equally true that a sheep
range carrying only the optimum number can be kept in better con-
dition than a cattle range which carries the maximum number. Sheep
do no more damage than cattle if properly handled and not crowded,
and they can be kept without injury to the range; in fact, it was
claimed by intelligent stockmen, accustomed to handle both sheep and
cattle, that certain sheep ranges in Mendocino County were at the
time of this investigation in better condition under sheep after three
years of comparative drought than they were thirty years ago.
it is an indisputable fact that some men have made a financial suc-
cess of sheep raising on the open range, and that at the same time
their ranges are in as good condition, and in some cases better, than
adjoining cattle ranges.
It is not improbable, however, that sheep do more damage than
cattle to perennial ‘‘ bunch-grasses.”
Summary.—The cause of range deterioration, therefore, is over-
stocking, and it is the animals themselves that do the damage. Fur-
RANGE PRESERVATION. 43
ther, the point at which overstocking commences has not been
decisively defined and varies with the individual range. What, then,
can the stockman or. range owner do to improve his condition? He
may well say that the range is run for the sake of the stock that can
be raised on it and not for the sake of preserving the feed, and that
though stock may be the cause of range deterioration they can not be
eliminated from the problem.
The task is only just begun, however, and the problem can not be
solved immediately. In the following pages some suggestions are
offered which it is hoped will prove steps toward the desired end.
RANGE PRESERVATION.
it is important to reiterate that if range renewal or improvement is
to be accomplished, the practice of carrying the maximum number of
stock on the range, or, in other words, of overstocking, must be aban-
doned. It is believed that it is possible to permanently raise the
optimum carrying capacity, but it is impossible to do so while heavy
stocking is practiced. ,
Suecess on one range, as compared with failure on an adjoining one,
is not due to any difference in location or other range conditions, nor
to any differences in the grasses or other plants composing the pas-
ture; the natural conditions generally are, or have been, identical
with those of adjacent and less-productive ranges. The secret lies in
good management, and good management primarily consists in carry-
ing the optimum number of stock and allowing plenty of grass to go
to seed—to go to waste, as the majority of stockmen would eall it.
Mr. J. H. Clarke and Colonel Harding, both successful stock
ranchers on a large scale, are agreed in declaring that over thirty
years of experience proves that this surplus grass, instead of being
wasted, is equivalent to so much capital invested in the range, and is
the cause of the prosperity of the few as compared with the failure or
poverty of the many. Such men do not stock nearly up to the maxi-
mum. Owning their own ranges, and therefore not having to pay
exorbitant interest on the capital invested, they are content with the
profits obtainable from the optimum number of stock. As aresult of
this, they not only maintain a uniform carrying capacity without
deterioration, but gain in other ways. Their wool is always cleaner
and commands a half a cent a pound more than that of their neigh-
bors, and both their mutton sheep and theirlambs command a higher
price. ‘‘ We aim,” writes Mr. Clarke, ‘‘to keep no more stock than
the range will easily support. Better a superabundance of feed than
a scareity.” The amount of grass to be left to seed and the optimum
carrying capacity can be determined only by actual experience. Both
Colonel Harding and Mr. Clarke find, however, that about 8 acres
to a head of horned stock and 13 acres to a sheep are all that their
ranges can carry without injury.
44 STOCK RANGES OF NORTHWESTERN CALIFORNIA.
Formation of a seed bed.—The advantage gained by allowing a
great deal of grass to go to seed is not only the amount of seed seat-
tered, but also the formation of a seed bed of decaying leaves and
stems, which encourages germination and protects the young seedlings.
Preserve the timber and brush.—Next in importance to preservation
of the forage plants is the conservation of moisture in the soil and the
preservation of the water supply. The ranges which we are discuss-
ing lie along the headwaters of the main streams of the coast, and
the preservation of a perennial flow of water in these streams is of
as much importance to places many miles away as to the ranges
themselves.
In their desire to increase the carrying capacity of the range many
men commence first to clear the land of all timber and brush with a
view to producing just so many more acres of pasture. Unfortu-
nately, however, by clearing away all the brush and timber from the
guiches and springs the moisture content of the soil is diminished,
the available drinking water for stock is rendered less accessible, and
there is probability of greater financial loss than profit from the
labor expended. In the Redwood belt it is noticeable that where
both timber and brush have been cleared away springs and small
streams have been dried up, although the conditions for the preserva-
tion of perennial springs and streams are more favorable there than
on the upland ranges. Not only is the summer water supply dimin-
ished by removing timber and brush from the headwaters of the
streams, but the soil on the steep slopes washes away with much
greater rapidity, owing to lack of protection from fiercely beating
rains, thus increasing the depth and steepness of the canyons, which
in turn facilitates the washing away of soil from the upland slopes.
In Europe and elsewhere much valuable land has been ruined in this
manner.
Maximum versus optimum stocking.—While it is impossible with
our present imperfect knowledge of the facts of the case to deter-
mine the exact difference between the maximum and the optimum of
‘ange capacity in any case, it seems certain that a very slight reduc-
tion in size of the ‘‘ band” of stock to a point below the maximum
would soon make an appreciable improvement in the carrying capacity
of the range and would be a step toward its renewal.
The practical stoeckman will naturally inquire whether the result-
ing gain would be worth the sacrifice of even that number of head of :
stock, representing just so much hard cash deducted from the annual
profits of the range. If it would not, he will not be likely to take any
further notice of the suggestion. In order to get as accurate an
answer to this question as is possible without direct experiment, let
us take a hypothetical case by way of illustration.
We will suppose that we are dealing with a range of 1,800 acres,
stocked to its maximum earrying capacity, and that this maximum is
tai ie ad ea
MAXIMUM VS. OPTIMUM STOCKING. 45
5 acres to one head of cattle, and its optimum 8 acres to one head.
This range would thus be carrying 360 head of stock; reduced to the
optimum, the herd would number 225, a reduction of 135 head, or 375
per cent.
Though such a reduction seems heavy, it must be borne in mind
_ that some of these annual ranges have naturally suffered a reduction
by overstocking till it takes 10, 12, or even 20 acres to support an
animal, which means that the herd has been reduced from sheer lack
of feed from 360 to 180, 150 or even 90 animals to an area of 1,800
acres. This does not take into consideration the possibility of still
further reduction of carrying capacity to 20 acres to a head, which is
said to be sometimes the case, but which is perhaps due to very excep-
tional circumstances.
The question to be considered is whether it is more profitable (1) to
continue stocking up to the maximum capacity of the range, with the
almost certain result of a forced reduction of the herd by 50, 60, or
possibly 75 per cent in a comparatively short time from lack of feed,
or (2) to voluntarily reduce the herd to the optimum capacity of the
range, equivalent to, say 37% per cent reduction, with the result that
this capacity can be maintained indefinitely, that the stock will be in
Getter condition all the time, and will command higher prices than
those from depreciated ranges.
A few figures may help to make the caseclearer. We have no data
as to the actual number of years that one of these annual ranges can
continue to carry the maximum number of head without deterioration,
nor do we know how long it has taken them to run down to their pres-
ent poor condition. It does not seem probable, however, that it would
take more than fifteen years of carrying all the stock a range can pos-
sibly feed to reduce its capacity from 5 acres to 10 or 12 acres per head.
If, for argument’s sake, we take the arbitrary figures of fifteen
years, and assume, moreover, that the range of 1,800 acres has been
used to fatten yearlings, all of which were sold off the succeeding year
and new stock purchased, the aggregate number of cattle carried in
the fifteen years under the plan of stocking up to the maximum would
be 3,930, and at the end of the period the carrying capacity would
have been reduced from 360 head to 150 head. Supposing that this
ratio of 150 head could be maintained for the next thirty years, we
should have an aggregate number of 8,430 head of yearlings raised in
the forty-five years.
If, however, we reduce the herd to the optimum at the outset, we
should find the aggregate number raised would be 3,375 head, in fif-
teen years 050 head less than by the old method; but at the end of
the fifteen years the herd numbers 225 instead of 150, and this num-
ber can be maintained indefinitely; in ten years more we find that the
aggregate has risen to 5,625, as against only 5,430 by the maximum
method, an increase of 195 head, and by the end of forty-five years
46 STOCK RANGES OF NORTHWESTERN CALIFORNIA.
the aggregate is 10,125 head, an increase of 1,695, which at a valua-
tion of $15 per head would be worth $25,425.
Unfortunately these figures are not decisive, owing to lack of data
as to the actual length of time it takes an overstocked range to deteri-
orate from 5 acres per head to 10 or 12 acres per head. It is hoped,
however, that they will be of some service to stockmen in calling to
their attention a method by which they may calculate for themselves,
with the data of their own ranges before them, whether it will pay to
reduce their flocks and herds to the optimum carrying capacity of
their ranges.
But whether the hypothetical figures are based on correct premises
or not, the accuracy of the statement can not be denied that there are
men to-day who are profitably running cattle and sheep ranges on the
basis of the optimum carrying capacity of the range, while their
neighbors on the maximum method find it hard tomake a comfortable
living, and many of them have mortgaged their ranges up to the limit
or have lost them through foreclosure.
RANGE RENEWAL.
The stoeckman whose range capacity is already as low as 10 or 12
acres per head is less interested in the difference between maxi-
mum and optimum than in the problem of range renewal, i. e., the
possibility of restoring his range to a capacity of 8 or possibly 5 acres.
Though something can be done toward range renewal, probably
without actually diminishing the income over a period of years,
by ascertaining the optimum carrying capacity and reducing the
band correspondingly, it may be found necessary, where a range
is worn out, to resort to other measures to restore it to a profitable
condition. In such cases a complete rest of one or even two years
will undoubtedly prove highly beneficial, giving the native forage
plants a chance to attain a luxuriant growth, and to produce and
seatter the largest amount of seed possible, in order to reestablish
themselves. Where a mortgage has been foreclosed, such a period of
rest can often be accomplished while waiting for a purchaser or ten-
ant. But to make it effective, the fences must be maintained in good
condition, in order to keep out stray stock, especially horses. Some
of the ranges in Mendocino County, which were lying idle during the
summer of 1899 on account of foreclosure proceedings, instead of
improving by the enforced idleness, suffered from the depredations of
bands of stock which had either strayed there or were purposely pas-
tured free of charge, en route to market, having gained access through
gaps in the dilapidated fences. If a range is worth anything at all, it
is surely worth keeping well fenced, and the cost of maintaining good
fences should be as a mere trifle compared with the increment of
value gained by a period of complete rest.
In many cases it may not be necessary to give the whole range a
RANGE RENEWAL. 47
rest at one and the same time. Mr. Bentley, in his report’ on the
forage plants of central Texas, tells us that in that region, where over-
stocking has resulted in serious range deterioration, ‘‘ some of the lead-
ing stockmen are now dividing up their holdings into several pastures,
one being held exclusively for winter use, another for spring, another
for midsummer or autumn. This practice will, inthe case of the winter
pasture, enable the early grasses to ripen and shed their seeds.”
Such a course may not prove as practicable or as beneficial, however,
on the annual ranges of northwestern California, where the majority
of the forage plants start growth together and mature at almost the
same time, as it may be in central Texas, where, as Mr. Bentley says,
‘‘there is a great variety of native forage plants and grasses, com-
prising species that appear in succession from February to Novem-
ber.” The practice may prove more adaptable, however, to the
ranges of the coast-bluff belt.
Instead of resting the whole range at once and thereby, perhaps,
missing a season of exceptionally good prices or of more than the usual
quantity of feed, a portion of the range, say one-seventh part, could
be fenced off and rested each year, the herd being weeded out at the
same time, so that it will not exceed the optimum for the remainder
of the range. At the end of seven years the rotation should be
repeated, and there is little doubt that by some such method the ¢ »-
rying capacity could be gradually raised.
Where injurious weeds, such as tacalote (Centaurea melitensis)
abound it will be found worth while to mow them off before they
head out.
There are two questions to be answered in deciding the policy of
range holding and stocking. First, is it good policy to allow the cash
value of the range to deteriorate, if there is a way to prevent it? It
is a true proverb which says ‘‘ you can not both eat your cake and
have it;” and overstocking is, as we have endeavored to prove, equiv-
alent to living upon both interest and capital, a sure way to diminish
both. :
The stoeckman who owns his range will see the force of this point
more quickly, and will be more willing to act accordingly, as far as
he is able, than the renter. He will realize that as long as he can
make a living off his range he ean not do better than invest any sur-
plus in improving the condition of both range and herd by weeding
out and keeping the number down to the optimum. The stockman
who rents his range, however, acts on a different principle. His sole
object is to make the most out of the range and to invest his surplus
in more stock or in other lines. Naturally he does not care anything
about maintaining the value of the real estate, as if does not belong
to him, and as a result the rented range usually suffers most severely.
“Bentley, H. L.: A Report upon the Grasses and Forage Plants of Central Texas;
U.S. Dept. Agric., Div. Agros., Bull. 10: p. 10, 1898.
48 STOCK RANGES OF NORTHWESTERN CALIFORNIA.
This evil can be remedied to a great extent by one or other of two meth-
ods: (1) A system of long-term leases, under which it is tothe tenant’s
interest not to materially reduce the carrying capacity, at least during
the term of his occupation; and (2) a clause in the lease limiting the
number of head to be carried on the range. In the latter case it will
obviously be necessary to exercise great care not to sign for more
than the optimum.
The second point to be considered is one which affects both the
owner and the holder of a long-term lease. It is whether it is ever
wise, from the point of view of personal economy, to stock beyond the
optimum earrying capacity. In view of the fact already pointed out,
that when once commenced the deterioration of an annual range pro-
ceeds with great rapidity, it would be poor policy to continue to carry
1 head to 5 aeres, or 360 head on a 1,80)-acre range, with the certainty
of its reduction to perhaps 150 head in fifteen years’ time, if by redue-
ing the herd at the start to 1 head to 8 acres, or a total of 225 head, the
same total profits could be obtained in a total period of twenty years
and the size of the herd and the range capacity be undiminished at
the end of that time.
RANGE IMPROVEMENT.
By range improvement we mean not only its restoration to its
former carrying capacity, but also an improvement of the character
of the range and of the quality of the feed. This is effected by the —
introduction of other kinds or races of forage plants.
In order to understand fully the problem of range improvement,
thereby guarding against wasted effort in directions which offer little
chance for success, it is necessary to appreciate the conditions which
determine the character of the forage plants on a particular range.
What causes the difference between the annual and the perennial
ranges of northwestern California? The perennial ranges (if we
exclude alpine meadows) are found only along the coast bluffs, where
the climate is relatively cool and moist in summer, owing to proximity
to the ocean and the prevalence of summer fogs. It must not be sup-
posed from this that these maritime perennial ranges keep green
throughout the summer. They do, however, keep green some weeks
later than the interior ranges, which feature, together with the fact
that they do not deteriorate as rapidly as the annual ranges, makes
them more valuable than the latter.
The annual ranges, on the other hand, are found in the interior, :
beyond the reach of the sea fogs. The open ridges are exposed to
the full force of the scorehing north winds and great sun heat dur-
ing a period of sometimes eight to ten or even more weeks of absolute
freedom from rain.
It is evident that the essential characteristics of good forage grasses
best adapted to the dry, interior ranges are: (1) Adaptability to the
peculiar climatic conditions; (2) tenacious hold on the soil, i. e.,
THE COAST-BLUFF BELT. 49
capability of withstanding trampling and grazing; (3) persistence for
more than one year; (4) propagation from the roots rather than from
seed.
The species which appear to best meet these requirements, and
which are therefore reeommended for trial on the annual ranges, are:
Buffalo grass, blue grama, white clover, red fescue, sheep’s fescue,
hard fescue, bur clover, California lotus, and Australian ray grass.
All these species have proved suited to the climate and conditions at
Berkeley, but whether or not they will be found thoroughly adapted
to the climate of Mendocino and Humboldt counties can be deter-
mined only by experimental culture on the ranges themselves.
If possible, they should be planted out at the time of the first fall
rains. They should in any ease be carefully fenced from stock until
thoroughly established. It will be advisable to sow at the same
time seed of some annual species, such as soft chess, which will act as
a nurse crop while the perennial species are establishing themselves.
If it is intended to sow seed in quantity, it will be wise to have it
earefully examined at the time of the purchase, and only to purchase
clean seed, free from seeds of injurious weeds. Some stoekimen have
injured their ranges almost as much as they have benefited them
by the introduction of injurious weeds along with the seed of valu-
able forage plants.
The writer does not presume to preseribe an absolute and infallible
remedy for worn-out ranges. Each range has, to some extent, its own
individual peculiarities, and the man who has lived several years on
the land, through divers seasonal variations, should be the one best
fitted to decide how to treat that land. In matters of range renewal
and improvement it is the practical and well-informed stoekman him-
self who will have to bring the ranges back to their fuil carrying
capacity. However, such a man is always looking for suggestions,
and it is with the view of bringing them directly to his notice that
these pages have been written; they are simply suggestions, and their
adaptability to divers conditions must be decided by the stockman.
THE COAST-BLUFF BELT.
CLIMATOLOGY.
The climate of the belt lying immediately along the coast is more
equable than that of the higher interior region; proximity to the
ocean renders the winter climate milder, and snow is almost unknown,
except, perhaps, on the high peaks of Cape Mendocino. In summer
the prevailing northwest winds are cold and the heavy sea fogs prevent
any excess of sun heat, so that even in July and August warm under-
clothes and an overcoat are acceptable adjuncts to a stage ride. The
summer precipitation is greater here than in the interior.
This moisture of the atmosphere makes it difficult to harvest a good
18766—No. 12—02-——4
50 STOCK RANGES OF NORTHWESTERN CALIFORNIA.
quality of grain hay, and oat hay, of which a considerable quantity is
raised, is usually dark in color. The greater moisture also favors the
development of rust, which does much damage to grain hays.
The stock ranges along the coast are limited to the narrow mesa or
beneh between the cliffs and the first mountain ridge which separates
it from the redwood belt on the east. At Point Arena, Point Gorda,
and Cape Mendocino the mesa is broader, as the redwood belt does
not follow the coast line, which juts into the ocean at these points.
The topography at the two latter-named places is exceedingly moun-
tainous and the country correspondingly wild and sparsely settled. |
THE MESA LANDS.
Soius.—The soils on the coast bluffs differ materially from those of
the interior plateau and from those of the valleys. In many places,
as on the bluffs at Point Arena and Fort Bragg, they contain a large
admixture of blown sand, which renders them light and friable. Such
soils are often poor in quality and unfitted for the production of good
grass crops, except where they have been fertilized.
By heavy manuring every other year good crops of red and black
oats are produced. The second year stock are grazed on the ‘‘ volun-
teer” crop, or the ground is planted with potatoes, which are well
suited to the soil conditions. The soil also seems to be well adapted
to carrots, mangel-wurzel, and cabbages, which are grown as fall
feed for cows. |
These poorer sandy lands are usually characterized by growths of
the dwarf native pines, Pinus muricata and P. contorta.
Between Manchester and Greenwood, and particularly on a strip of
land some 5 miles long near Miller, a richer and apparently deeper
soil oceurs, producing splendid crops of wheat, barley, and other farm
produce, and proving well adapted to the cultivation of beans and
potatoes. Sweet peas, field peas, edible peas, cabbages, and other
horticultural crops, in spite of the foggy summer climate, are here
grown as seed crops for the San Francisco market. Some 80,000
bushels of grain and 1,500 tons of hay are reported as having been
produced in this vicinity in 1899.
Grasses and other forage plants.—As before noted, perennial grasses
are relatively more abundant in numbers, both of species and indi-
viduals, along the coast than in the interior. On account of the length
of time occupied by the inland journey and the occurrence of an
exceptionally dry season, the writer’s coast trip was made too late in
the season to find all the grasses in condition to collect, and the deter-
mination of some of the most important of them has therefore to be
left to a future occasion.
Danthonia californica, Festuca rubra var., an undetermined species
of Poa, Calamagrostis aleutica, Deschampsia ceespitosa and D. holct-
formis are the prevailing grasses, danthonia being the most abundant
:
Fr
;
‘THE MESA LANDS. Hill
and often forming a dense turf of excellent pasturage. The ray
grasses, perennial, Italian, Australian, and many-flowered, have been
introduced and are now freely naturalized in many localities, adding
materially to the value of the uncultivated forage. Soft chess is met
with but sparingly.
Bull clover (Trifolium wormskjoldi) is common in springy places,
and bear clover (7. fucatum virescens) on slidy, clay soils on the higher
ranges; these two are considered as among the best native forage
plants. White clover (7. repens) has become established along road-
sides; bur clover (Medicago denticulata) and black medic (J. lwpulina)
are sparingly naturalized. Red clover (7. pratense) has become nat-
uralized in a few localities.
California lotus (Lotus americanus) is commonly met with in dry
places among brush and on the open ranges on Bear River Ridge.
Rib grass (Plantago lanceolata) is naturalized in several places, and
furnishes a small quantity of late summer feed.
A variety of red fescue forms a somewhat sparse turf on the sandy
summits of the cliffs. In crevices and on ledges of the rocky cliffs
Calamagrostis aleutica, Agrostis densiflora, Poa unilateralis, and spe-
cies of Bromus and Elymus hold the soil in company with such mari-
time plants as Hrigeron glaucus, Mesembryanthemum cquilaterale,
Lupinus micheneru, ete.
The cooler and moister summer climate of the coast induces the
forage plants to keep green two or three weeks later than on the inte-
rior ranges; they are at their best in the months of May and June.
The yield of forage diminishes seriously toward the end of July, and
the feeding of dairy stock with forage crops then begins. At Point
Arena some dairymen commence feeding with field peas, which are
fed green, following with root crops, of which carrots and mangel-
wurzel are principally used. The improved strains of cattle parsnip
are well worth trial in this section.
Few sheep are now run on the mesa lands; cattle are raised through-
out the belt, there being a steady demand for beef in the lumber
camps of the adjacent redwood region.
The high bluff lands of Cape Mendocino, from Bear River Ridge to
the Upper Mattole, furnish probably the finest perennial stock ranges
of Humboldt County. Danthonia forms a large part of the forage,
and perennial ray grass has become established in many spots, add-
ing much to the early winter feed. Rib grass is occasionally met
with and furnishes a small amount of late feed, but it is of very
little value for cattle. Our visit was made too late in the season to
find the native grasses in condition for collection and determination.
Orchard grass and oats are successfully cultivated on these hills,
and are used both for hay and silage, two or three silos having been
built during the last two years. Several creameries are in use, the
butter being carried a distance of 10 to 15 miles to the nearest rail-
52 STOCK RANGES OF NORTHWESTERN CALIFORNIA.
road for shipment to Eureka, whence it is sent down to San Francisco
by steamer. .
The Cape Mendocino ranges are in greater need of early winter-
growing grasses than of summer grasses, differing entirely in this
respect from the ranges of the interior. The species which seem most
likely to answer this need are: Many-flowered millet grass (Oryzopsis
miliacea), reed fescue (Festuca arundinacea), Texas blue grass (Poa
arachnifera), tall oat grass (Arrhenatherum elatius), Japanese wheat
grass (Brachypodium japonicum), rescue grass (Bromus willdenow2),
awnless brome grass (Bromus inermis). ,
THE WHITE-ASH PRAIRIES.
On the ridges which separate the smaller coast streams, e. g., the
Noyo and Albion rivers, are found the ‘‘white-ash prairies,” or
‘“white plains,’ which are almost confined to this part of the State.
They do not cover the whole of a ridge, but predominate near its
western extremity where the sandstones outcrop. As its popular
name implies, the soil on these prairies is white and powdery; it
quickly works up into a thick dust resembling white wood ashes. It
is about a foot in depth, overlaying a sandstone of very loose texture,
and is said to be so impervious that after water has been allowed to
stand for two weeks it scarcely penetrates more than an inch or two.
A preliminary examination, kindly made by Prof. R. H. Loughridge,
of the agricultural experiment station at Berkeley, shows that this
soil contains a high percentage of humic acid and a low percentage
of phosphates and mineral matter; the subsoil (sand) is weak in phos-
phates. Dr. Loughridge points out that on such soil grain crops could
not be expected to live, though a few of the hardier grasses might
succeed, and that liming the soil would probably improve it, counter-
acting the excessive acidity.
As might be expected of a soil with such marked peculiarities, it is
characterized by a distinctive flora; such trees and shrubs as attain a
normal height on adjacent soils become dwarfed to almost pigmy
size on these white plains; the species most frequently met with are:
Tan-oak (Quercus densiflora), Prickle-cone Pine (Pinus muricata),
Coast Scrub Pine (Pinus contorta), Gowan Cypress (Cupressus goveni-
ana), Chinquapin (Castanopsis chrysophylla), Salal (Gaultheria shal-
lon), Huekleberry (Vacciniwm ovatum), Rhododendron (Rhododen-
dron californicum), Myrica (Myrica californica), Labrador Tea
(Ledum glandulosum), Manzanita (Arctostaphylos nummularia and
other species) and species of Ceanothus.
Sub-shrubby and herbaceaous plants are also dwarfed; the follow-
ing are common: Polygala californica, Helianthemum scoparium,
NXerophyllum tenax, Hypericum concinnum, Gentiana menziesii, G.
oregana, Liliwm maritimum, Panicum unciphyllum, Agrostis pringlet,
and Lotus lewcopheus.
THE WHITE-ASH PRAIRIES. ers)
Perhaps owing to the sandy and impervious nature of the soil, sphag-
num and peat swamps have formed in the low hollows on the plains,
a particularly remarkable feature at such a low altitude, and especi-
ally so as neither peat nor sphagnum are known to us as occuring
elsewhere in the Coast Ranges of northern California. The plants
most commonly met with in these swamps are: Ledum glandulosum
(the prevailing species), Lomaria spicant, Gaultheria shallon, Myrica
californica, Veratrum fimbriatum, Viola sarmentosa, Trientalis ewro-
pea latifolia, Sisyrinchium californiceum, Lotus formosissimus, Cor-
nus canadensis, Hypericum anagalloides, Gentiana menziesii, Pote-
rium officinale, Phalaris cerulescens, Drosera rotundifolia, Campanula
linneifolia, Calamagrostis aleutica, C. bolanderi, C. crassiglumis,
Agrostis pringlei, Juncus bolandert, J. falcatus paniculatus, J. supin-
iformis, several species of Carex, among which (according to Boott *)
oceur the following: C. phyllomaniaca, C. mendocinensis, C. vallicola,
OC. sterilis, C. salina mutica, C. livida, C. polymorpha, C. gynody-
namia, and C. luzulina. The grasses are remarkably few both in
Species and individuals.
According to the State Survey Botany,* the sphagnum moss appears
in the three species, Sphagnum cymbifolium, S. mendocinum, and 8S.
subsecundum longifolium.
Other plant species occur on the plains and in the sphagnum
Swamps, but are generally less abundant or less noticeable. An
analysis of the flora as above listed shows that its most character-
istic feature does not consist so much in the presence of endemic spe-
cies as in the commingling of the adjacent redwood and coast floras,
with the addition of species commonly found in thin soils at compara-
tively high altitudes, and of certain peculiarly boreal species, rarely
if ever found at other points in the Coast Ranges, and when met with
elsewhere in the State, usually occurring at very much higher alti-
tudes. The phenomenal feature is, therefore, the occurrence of sev-
eral species belonging to high altitudes and latitudes, along a narrow
coast mesa not more than 200 feet above sea level, and between the
thirty-ninth and fortieth degrees of north latitude. (ALI the species
here listed with the exception of Arctostaphylos wva-ursi were col-
lected between the Navarro and Tenmile rivers).
To make this point clearer we may classify them as follows:
_ Plants met with on comparatively dry ridges at various altitudes in
the redwood belt: Cupressus goveniana, Quercus densiflora, Poly-
gala californica, Castanopsis chrysophylla, Xerophyllum tenax, Gaul-
theria shallon, Vaccinium ovatum, Hypericum concinnum, Helian-
themum scoparium, Rhododendron californicum, Ceanothus spp.,
Myrica californica, Arctostaphylos nummularia, and other species.
Plants of moist, shady spots in the redwood belt: Viola sarmentosa,
Trientalis europea latifolia.
“Brewer, Watson, and Gray, Publications of the Geological Survey of Califor-
nia, Botany, 2 Vols., 1876 and 1880.
o4 STOCK RANGES OF NORTHWESTERN CALIFORNIA.
Coast-bluff species: Pinus contorta, P. muricata, Calamagrostis
aleutica, Phalaris coerulescens, Sisyrinchium californicum, Lotus
formosissimus, Gentiana oregana.
Boreal plants: Cornus canadensis, Arctostaphylos uwva-ursi, Juncus
supiniformis, Hypericum anagalloides, Poteriwm officinale, Drosera
rotundifolia, Lomaria spicant, Ledum glandulosum, Sphagnum men-
docinum, S. cymbifolium, S. subsecundum longifolium, Carex valli-
cola, C. salina mutica, C. livida (reported from ‘‘peat bogs and pine
barrens from New Jersey and New York to Labrador and Lake
Superior and high northward Alaska”).
Species apparently endemic: Veratrum fimbriatum, Lilium mari-
timum, Campanula lnneerfolia, Carex phyllomaniaca, C. mendoci-
nensis, C. gynodynanmia, Agrostis pringlei, Calamagrostis bolandert,
C. crassiglumis. |
Attempts to cultivate the white-ash prairie lands have been made
with great labor and little result. Oats, potatoes, beans, peas, corn,
and cabbages will grow fairly in the best spots, and velvet-grass
(Holcus lanatus), a little ray grass, and squirrel-tail seem to thrive;
orchard grass is said to grow but poorly. Tall oat grass would proba-
bly thrive as well as the velvet grass and make a more valuable crop.
Taken all in all the conditions are very unpromising for the produc-
tion of agricultural crops, and it is doubtful whether the land would
ever pay for the cost of clearing and breaking. Danish settlers claim,
however, that it would make good farm land if laid down to some
pasture grass, grazed first with horses, second with cows, third with
sheep, and finally plowed and treated with all the stable manure
available. The writer could not find that any one of them had tried
to put this precept into practice, however, and it is at best highly
doubtful whether any good pasture grass could be induced to grow
there.
The native vegetation of the white-ash prairies furnishes almost as
clear an indication of the physical and chemical nature of the soil as
do the alkali weeds in the Great Valley Region and the Colorado
Desert. The poor soils are invariably indicated by the low stature
of such shrubs and trees as grow more luxuriantly on adjacent areas
of good soil, particularly salal, chinquapin, cypress, Xerophyllum,
and bracken, and the presence of labrador tea, Lomaria, and Arctos-
taphylos nummularia. -
BOTTOM LANDS.
Alluvial lands are not commonly met with in northwestern Cali-
fornia on account of the mountainous nature of the country. The
principal alluvial areas in the coast section are the bottom lands of
Eel River, with its broad flood plain, the flood plain which fringes
Humboldt Bay, and the bottom lands of Smith River. The notes here presented were prepared by Dr. W. C. Blasdale.
‘ FUNGOUS PARASITES. 75
upland ranges are singularly free from pests of this sort, but in the
moister bottom lands many of the common grass-inhabiting species of
rusts and smuts are found.
Ustilago avene (Pers.) Jensen, oat smut, is seldom absent from
fields of cultivated oats, and in certain seasons is said to cause con-
siderable injury. It is occasionally found on the wild oats.
Ustilago holwayt, Dietel., is frequently found on Hordeum nodosum,
but can seareely be considered a pest.
Ustilago bromivora, Fisch., is found on Bromus hordeaceus glabres-
cens, but is not widely distributed.
Puccinia rubigo-vera (D. C.) Wint., orange leaf rust, is not un-
common on Bromus secalinus and 6B. carinatus, but the amount of
injury effected by it is not great.
A yellow-spored Uredo is almost constantly associated with Holcus
lanatus, and, were this grass a more valuable one, the rust might be
considered a serious pest. Observations on this species in other por-
tions of the State have shown that it persists throughout the year with-
out the formation of other spore forms, which renders its identification
impossible.
Uromyces minor, Schroet., clover rust, freauently injures certain
species of Trifolium, especially 7. dubtwm and T. microdon. In other
portions of the State it is especially injurious to 7. gracilentum.
What is probably the uredo stage of Uromiyces striatus, Schroet.,
was also found in abundance in a single locality on Medicago
lupulina.
Pseudopeziza trifoli, Fekl., is widely distributed and injures
nearly all the species of Trifolium, but especially 7. cyathiferum and
T. microdon.
The species enuinerated below are of frequent occurrence, though
of no special economic significance: Afcidium sommerfelti Johan-
son, on Aquilegia truncata; Afcidiwm hydrophylli Peck, on Hydro-
phyllum capttatum,; Afcidium pseudo-balsameum D. and H., on Abies
grandis; Actinonema rosae (Lib.) Fr., on Rosa gymnocarpa; Doas-
sansia alismatis (Nees) Cornu, on