Skip to main content

Full text of "Australian garden history : journal of the Australian Garden History Society"

See other formats


HISTORY 





« *•*>%?* ■ IWW 


‘Dorothea and Dinah’ from Gertrude Jekyll’s Children and Gardens 
Courtesy: La Trobe Collection, State Library of Victoria. 



AUSTRALIAN 

GARDEN 

HISTORY 

SOCIETY 


Continuing the Story 

Restoring the Garden at Nutcote 
The Children s Garden at Rippon Lea 
With Mirrors & Rainbows - Part 2 
Charles Bogue LufFman - the Final Years 






Australian History Garden Society 
Mission 

The Australian Garden History 
Society will be the leader in 
concern for and conservation of 
significant cultural landscapes and 
gardens through committed, 
relevant and sustainable action. 

Patron 

Margaret Darling 

Executive Officer 
Jackie Courmadias 

Publication 

Australian Garden History, the official 
journal of the Australian Garden 
History Society, is published six times 
a year. 

Enquiries 

Toll Free 1800 678 446 

Phone (03) 9650 5043 

Fax (03) 9650 8470 

E-mail 

info@gardenhistorysociety.org.au 

Web-site 

www.gardenhistorysociety.org.au 

Postal Address 
AGHS 

Gate Lodge, 100 Birdwood Avenue, 
Melbourne, 3004 
Subscriptions (GST inclusive) 

For 1 year 
Single $48 
Family $63 
Corporate $75 
Youth $20 
(under 25 years of age) 

Advertising Rates 
1/8 page $132 
(2+issues $121 each) 

1 /4 page $220 
(2+ issues $198 each) 

1/2 page $330 
(2+ issues $275 each) 

Full page $550 
(2+ issues S495 each) 

Inserts $440 

for Australia-wide mailing 

Pro-rata for state-wide mailing 

Editor 

Nina Crone, 15 Acacia Road, 
Promontory Views,Vic. 3959 
Phone: (03) 5663 2381 

E-mail: ncrone@dcsi.net.au 

Design 

Jo Waite Design 

Printing 

FRP 

ISSN 1033-3673 

Editorial Advisory Panel 
Convener 
Anne Latreille 
Members 
Richard Aitken 
Max Bourke 
Paul Fox 
David Jones 
Megan Martin 
Prue Slatyer 
Christopher Vernon 



(from L.) Liz, Rodger and Ann chat with Jocelyn and 
Howard. 


A Botanical Tribute to Sarah 
King on her Birthday 
(during the AGHS trip to Lake Mungo in 
April 2003) 

Our Sarah fairer far is 
Than Melaleuca armillaris. 

And as graceful as Acacia wilhelmiana 
Is our lovely sexageneriana. 

Acacia stenophylla 

With due respect cannot outstyle her. 
Oh she is fair as she is sweet 
As the Sugar Gums at Ned’s Retreat! 
Oh! Eucalyptus cladocalyx 
Grant our Sarah love’s elix — 

-ir. And as the Alyogyne huegelii 

Like her spreads its bounties freely 

So Eremophila niaculata 

And the sweet divaricata 

Run riot but cannot outsmart her! 

Myoporum parvifolium, oh foolish 

Creeping Boobialla 

Don’t try to vie with cluey Sarah! 

Greetings Sarah from jasmine 



The Murray River at Ned’s Corner. 




- 

IjjAjav-'L 

"l “N» 



aT*.’* hill 


(from L.) Sue and Pam at the Mallee Garden, Walpeup. 


In the garden at Ned's Comer. 




Pens, sketchbooks and cameras recorded the AGHS trip to the 
Mallee, Mildura, and Lake Mungo. A full account of the excursion 
will appear in a later issue. These contributions, from Jasmine 
Brunner, Sue Keon-Cohen and Ann Miller, offer a preview of 
things to come. 


Copyright C Atittr.ili.in Garden History Society 2003. All rights reserved. No part of this publication may be reproduced, stored in a retrieval 
system, or transmitted in any form for commercial purposes wholly or in part (other than circumstances outlined in any agreement between 
the author/artist/photographer/illustrator and the Society) without prior written permission of the publisher. Permission may be granted 
subject to an acknowledgment being made. Copying for private and educational purposes is permitted provided acknowledgment is made in 
any report, thesis or other document which has used information contained in this publication. 


2 Australian Garden History Vol. 15!\ ! o 1 July/August 2003 













































CONTENTS 

THE CONTINUING STORY 



4 


Restoring a Garden in the Image of its Creator 

Helen Wood tells how she restored the garden at Nutcote, the home of artist and 
children’s storyteller May Gibbs. 



Yesterday’s Gardens for Today’s Children 

Nina Crone visits Rippon Lea and talks to Phil Tulk about the ideas behind an interesting garden 

for children. 


^4 

With Mirrors and Rainbows - Part 2 

Ken Duxbury continues the story of Edward William Cole with an account of his garden 
publications and his years at Earlsbrae Hall in Essendon. 


£0 


Charles Bogue Luff man: the final years 

Sandra Pullman concludes her series on the work and life of Luffman with reference to his public 
lectures, his writing and his garden design at Killamont. 


£4 


For the Bookshelf: 

Australian Planting Design by Paul Thompson 
Lilacs for the Garden by Jennifer Bennett 
People and Plants: A History of Gardening in Victoria by Mary Ellis 


£0 

Items of Interest 

£/ 

Diary Dates 


National Management Committee 
Chairman 
Peter Watts 

Vice-Chairman 

Richard Heathcote 

Treasurer 

Elizabeth Walker 

Secretary 

Helen Page 

Elected Members 
Max Bourke ACT 
Stuart Read NSW 
LeeTregloanVIC 
DianneWilkins SA 
Malcolm Wilson NSW 

State Representative 
Gabrielle Tryon ACT 
Kate Madden NSW 
Glenn Cooke QLD 
Wendy Joyner SA 
Helen Page VIC 
Deidre Pearson TAS 
AnneWilloxWA 

Branch Contacts 
ACT/Monaro/Riverina Branch 

Gabrielle Tryon 

4 Anstey Street 

Pearce ACT 2607 

Ph: (02) 6286 4585 

E-mail; gmtryon@netspeed.com.au 

Queensland Branch 
Glenn Cooke 
PO Box 5472 
West End QLD 4101 
Ph: (07) 3846 1050 
E-mail; glenn.cooke@qag.qld.gov.au 

South Australian Branch 
Di Wilkins 
39 Elizabeth Street 
Eastwood SA 5068 
Ph: (08) 8272 9381 

Southern Highlands Branch 
Chris Webb 
PO Box 707 
Moss Vale NSW 2577 
Ph: (02) 4861 4899 
E-mail: cwebb@cwebb.com.au 

Sydney & Northern NSW Branch 

Malcolm Wilson 
10 Hartley Street 
Rozelle NSW 2039 
Ph: (02) 9810 7803 

Tasmanian Branch 

Deidre Pearson 
15 Ellington Road 
Sandy Bay TAS 7005 
Ph: (03) 6225 3084 

Victorian Branch 
Helen Page 

c/- AGHS, Gate Lodge 
100 Birdwood Avenue 
MelbourneVIC 3004 
Ph: (03) 9650 5043 
E-mail: helenpage@bigpond.com 

Western Austrauan Branch 
Edith Young 
21A Corbel Street 
Shelley WA 6148 
Ph: (08) 9457 4956 
E-mail: young_ee47@hotmail.com 


Australian Garden History Vol 15 No 1 July/August 2003 3 




















■w 




~ ; 


llr 



Above: View over Neutral 
Bay to North Sydney 
from Nutcote balcony. 
October 2002. 

Courtesy: Yvonne Hyde. 

Right: View of Nutcote 
looking towards Neutral 
Bay and Sydney Harbour 
from the Lower Lawn 
with its iris rondel, 
caterpillar hedge and 
rose arbour (LH side). 
September 2002. 
Courtesy: Yvonne Hyde. 



A GARDEN IN 
THE IMAGE OF ITS CREATOR 

By Helen Wood 


Nutcote,a house and garden museum,sits onthe foreshores of Sydney Harbour at 
Neutral Bay. It was the home of its creator May Glbbs (1877 - 1969) and her husband 
James Ossoli Kelly (1868 - 1939), generally known as J.O. May lived and worked at 
Nutcote for over fortyyears, until 1969. 


Right: The original path 
leading through the rose 
arbour to the house 
showing the old planting of 
hydrangeas. September 
2002 . 

Courtesy Yvonne Hyde. 


M ay Gibbs was born in Surrey, England, but 
the family came to live briefly in Adelaide 
when she was aged four, and then settled in the 
Harvey District ofWestern Australia, and later in 
Perth. May was a talented artist from the 
beginning, encouraged by her father Herbert W 
Gibbs, a proficient watercolour and newspaper 
cartoon artist employed by the Western Australian 
Lands Department. 

As most Australians will know, May is famous 
as writer and illustrator of characters drawn from 
the Australian bush — the Gunmut Babies, 
Snugglepot and Cuddlepie, Little Ragged 
Blossom, the Big Bad Banksia Men - and many 
other‘bush and garden’ folk. There was also the 
underwater world with its characters Little 
Obelia, Ann Chovey and John Dory. Perhaps 
not so well known are the characters in May’s 
last book Prince Datide Lion, a Garden Wliim- 
Wham (1953). So it would appear that May 
gained her inspiration from her immediate 
environment. 



4 Australian Garden History Vol. 15 No 1 July/August 2003 






























Nutcote 1925-1969 


Saved from demolition 


May and J.O. built and moved into Nutcote in 
1925. With their family of Scottie dogs they 
would undertake long camping trips in their 
1927 Dodge Tourer, May affectionately calling 
the vehicle ‘The Dodg’em’. Together they 
explored coastal and country environs, and May 
later put those personal experiences into her 
prolific work. It is well known that May always 
spent her daylight hours in the garden, notepad 
and pencil in her apron pocket to jot down notes, 
observations and inspiration. She would then 
move into her Studio (overlooking the harbours 
comings and goings) and work until late into the 
night. 

So we see a middle to late aged couple 
enjoying similar interests and hobbies in their life 
at Nutcote, in particular the garden and their 
family of Scottie dogs. A gardener (Bill) was 
always employed to work with May andJ.O.,and 
they grew all their annuals from seeds. Extracts 
from J.O.’s letters and diaries make interesting 
reading: 

1935 Planted roses on the trellis. Planted privet 
hedge, roses on waterfront, watefront 
re-constniction - large boulders and fernery 
under the rocks. 

1936 September: Roses broke forth. Huge round bed 
of Irises mostly white, some purple. House was 
painted; lemon and plum trees. 

1936 October: Liquid manure in the making. Lady 
Hillingdon is preparing to burst forth. 

1937 January: Phlox drum on the other side, 
portulaca on edge. Phlox drum - 500 in every 
shade and colour down whole side path from 
road to house and watefront borders, asters and 
zinnias too. 

1937 June: Lemon tree 100 ripe lemons, cumquat - 
1000. Roses very wet. Poor garden looks so 
sad, depressed - cold. Starting another border 
on the watefront, having a quantity of 
excellent soil. Liquid manuring - according to 
Hazelwood’s instructions. ‘Etcile de Hollande’ 
and another exquisite pink rose are a joy. 
Hazelwood’s nurscry at Eppingfor roses. 

1937 September: Stocks over now - borders dug up. 
Barring the snapdragons, rose, sweet peas, and 
nemesias. Poplars in full leaf and looking 
fine. 

An excerpt by Beatrice Lilley, from Woman 
dated 29 January 1943, refers to May and her 
garden: 

Her chief joy she finds now in her garden, which 
tellingly reflects her personality. It is delightfully 
informal, colon ful andfriendly, and it seemed only 
logical that there should be a gum tree there, two 
boards combining with its twisted limbs to form a 
garden seat. Exactly the sort of gum tree one would 
expect to find in May Gibbs’ garden. 


Nutcote, designed by architect B.J. Waterhouse, 
was saved from the demolishing developers in 
1990 and restoration work began in 1992. The 
house was run down but fortunately no ‘modern’ 
alterations had been made to it. The garden was 
overgrown with weeds, however a few gallant 
garden plants survived and were listed: 

Hydrangeas 

Roses — ‘Dorothy Perkins’ (1901) and ‘Lady 
Hillingdon’ (1917) 

Banksia integrifolia (circa 1850) 

Ancient Casuarinas 
Port Jackson Fig 

Poplar (borer infested and later replaced with 
a Magnolia grandijhra) 

May’s Gum, the Bangalay, Eucalyptus 
botryoides (originally growing from sandstone 
crevices and replaced in 1996 because of 
white ant infestation) 



After 18 years of neglect Nutcote finally May Gibbs’cover design for 

opened to the public in 1994. Original structures the first edition of Prince 

still surviving are the all important brick garden Courtesy: Nut cote Archives. 
path leading from gate to front door, cement 
terracing and pocket rock garden borders along 
the sandstone-edged garden beds on the 
waterfront, and rough stone path and steps. With 
the restoration of the house, the original double 
garage was converted to a shop and admittance 
area incorporating a tearoom, terrace, and toilet 
facilities for public comfort. At this time the 
Nutcote Trust commissioned a landscape plan. 


Australian Garden History Vol. \5 No 1 July /August 2003 5 


















Plan of Nutcote Garden 
Courtesy: Helen Wood 


This cartoon strip, c. 1930s 
or 1940s, was Helen Wood’s 
inspiration for the ‘caterpillar' 
hedge. 

Courtesy: Nutcote Archives. 


This involved changing the gentle sloping site, on 
the street side, into three terraced levels, with an 
iris rondel surrounded by sandstone flagging, 
lawns and the reinstatement of a collection of old 
roses planted along the brick path. The shade 
border on the northern boundary was started 
with permanent plantings of Murrayas, Azaleas 
and Anemones. I have since added Sasanqua 
Camellias, old Fuchsias, species Iris, Viburnum, 
Philadelphus, deciduous Magnolia, and as stated 
earlier, the central focus and great screening plant, 
Magnoliagmndiflora, now the dominant feature of 
the of the ‘shade border’. Today all are maturing 
well, adding a voluptuous feel to this backdrop. 
With the initial structural work complete, funds 
dried up and any ongoing work ceased 
temporarily. 

Volunteers in the garden 

I became involved with the garden when I was 
studying Horticulture, and there was nobody 
available and no budget for garden development. 
The house was by now open to the public, and 


visitors expected to see a well-maintained garden, 
reflecting May’s life and time. Many visitors went 
away, loving the restored house and contents, but 
disappointed with the garden. As an initial 
supporter oPSave Nutcote for the Nation’ 1 had a 
strong motivation to redress this situation. 1 
voluntarily undertook the coordination of the 
garden and did so for over six years - a one to two 
day commitment each week, along with two or 
three other volunteers, usually retired women 
who worked most diligently. Now the garden is 
overseen by the Honorary Archivist and 
volunteer gardener, Yvonne Hyde, helped by 
more voluntary labour that is always most 
welcome. 

I widened the pathway garden beds to 2.5 
metres in 1995 and planted a box hedge as 
backdrop for the extensive and intensive 
cultivated annuals that were planted twice a year, 
with the Summer planting boosted by Dahlias to 
give an ‘over-blown’ feeling when walking to the 
house. The hedge was intended to introduce 
some whimsy back into the garden by shaping it 




''Tout.fi wood!” cried Tig. “A caterpillar br 
And tat down all the lawn for mt." 


6 Australian Garden History Vol. 15 No 1 July/August 2003 





























into a ‘caterpillar’ hedge, with smooth ripples up 
the slope, with its many legs (trunks) and its head 
kicked up for good measure. It has taken a while 
to ‘show’ but now looks as familiar as when May 
illustrated a garden caterpillar in a comic strip. 

The original Dorothy Perkins rambling rose 
on the southern boundary fence is a joy to behold 
in early spring. Dorothy Perkins is a character in 
'Prince Dande Lion’, and she is kept trimmed by 
the resident possum community. Wild life is 


welcome in the spirit of May’s memory, together 
with the handsome Dande-Lions. Along with 
the Dorothy Perkins rose, lovely old hydrangeas 
are originals that have survived. The year 1996 
saw the installation of a much-needed watering 
system and the re-instatement of the wooden 
trellis in front of the house to accommodate an 
original‘Lady Hillingdon’ climbingTea Rose, and 
also the annual show of Busby sweet peas in the 
only sunny patch in the winter. Near the trellis in 


May Gibbs at the bottom 
of the garden path, 
looking 

toward the street 
c. 1961. Note the 
English annuals, the rose 
covered arbour, the 
hedge lining the flower 
bed on the lawn side of 
the path - and May’s 
Scottie dogs. 

Courtesy: Y/onne Hyde. 


Australian Garden History Vol. 15 No 1 July/August 2003 7 








































































'Mr Bear was fast 
asleep' from Mr& 
Mrs Bear & Friends. 
A very domestic, 
suburban scene. 
There is a lot of May 
in Mrs Bear’s 
character. The 
picture shows May's 
bedroom window at 
Nutcote and the 
lemon tree. May's 
husband wrote a 
letter in the 1930s 
saying this was his 
favourite spot to sit, 
and perhaps May 
was thinking of that 
when she wrote this 
book, published in 
1943. Note also that 
the discarded 
newspaper is the 
Daily Bark. 

Courtesy: Nutcote 
Archives. 


May’s second 
cousin, Marian 
Shand, with her 
daughters walking 
up the garden path 
from the house to 
the street in 1961. 
Courtesy: Yvonne 
Hyde. 


1995 I planted a Eucalyptus haematoma (the 
Scribbly Gum - or the ‘Daily Bark’ to May). This 
autumn it has shown the first of its characteristic 
‘scribbles’. 

Of interest is a photograph, circa 1960s, that 
shows May with Scotties standing in the shade of 
a ‘gum’. May’s former bedroom window features 
in her book Mr. & Mrs. Bear & Friends (1943), and 
J.O. records sitting under the lemon tree. We 










re-instated a lemon tree in the exact same spot 
that May sketched in her picture. 

The Iris rondel was showing signs of 
discontent with the Irisgermanica in purple and 
white, obtained from an old farm garden. Sydney 
was just too humid for the Irises and as 30% were 
disappearing each year, I decided to replace them 
with Iris louisiana - deep purple in the centre of 
the bed, blue in the mid-centre, frothy white 
around the edge, and a fringing of Lobelia and 
white Alyssutn. 

The waterfront garden slopes towards the 
sandstone foreshore, and displays the original 
sandstone edged garden beds, path and steps, with 
a sloping lawn. Here the original Port Jackson 
Fig, under-planted with ferns, is keeping 
company with one of the most precious 
remaining original Banksia integrtfblia c.1850. 
Next to it are some ancient Casuarinas. In 
keeping with the indigenous plants I instigated 
smaller species native to the Sydney Harbour 
foreshores for the bank.They tumble down to the 
waters edge. Two Angophoras— A. costata (1995) 
and A. hispidata (1999)- and the ‘bad’ Banksia, 
Banksia serrata (1998), were added to this area. 

As initially I sought to re-create the 
atmosphere of May’s garden as closely as possible, 

I had first to come to know its creators by reading 
diary entries, personal correspondence to family 
and friends, by closely examining photographs 
and May s imaginative works in paintings, books 
and cartoons. These archives are most invaluable. 
Her work was always my primary inspiration for 
ongoing planting schemes on a seasonal basis, 
though it was never my intention to slavishly 
‘preserve’.That opportunity was eliminated with 
earlier site works. However the spirit of its 
creators, May and J.O., continues to inspire 
Nutcote’s evolving garden. 

I invite you to visit and enjoy this small but 
unique house and garden museum. Feel free to 
be swept into a ‘moment in time’ with colours, 
perfumes and a sense of being in an old friend’s 
garden. 


Helen Wood is a horticultural designer wlw was 
garden curator at Nutcote from 1996 until 2001. 
She works with her husband as an environmental 
planner. 

Nutcote: 5 Wallaringa Ave. Neutral Bay 

Ph. (02) 9953 4453. 

Opening rimes: 

Wednesday to Sunday 11.00am-3.00pm. 
Australian Open Garden Scheme: 
Saturday 15 and Sunday 16 November 2003, 
10am-4pm. 

Web-site: www.maygibbs.com/nutcoat.html 


8 Australian Garden History Vol . 15 No 1 July /August 2003 

































By NINA CRONE 


WITH CONTRIBUTIONS FROM HELEN BOTHAM, 

Richard Heathcote, 


Dugald Noyes, PhilTulk 

I n her memoirs Clara Webster (nee Sargood) 
wrote about the fun that she and her three 
brothers had in the first garden at Rippon Lea in 
the 1870s: 

From bare paddock and surroundings under the 
guiding hand of father, the garden began to grow, 
trees were planted, lawns were laid down and soon 
there was a croquet lawn, on which we children 
fought many a game of croquet; if we could get no 
companion it was immaterial, one person could 
play in turn with all the balls, taking sides quite 
impartially. 

Educated at home by a governess, the Sargood 
children were actively involved in the garden and 
the natural world, spending their free time bird¬ 
nesting, fishing and, in summer, tending their 
animals and their own gardens, encouraged by 
their mother, Marian, the first Mrs Sargood. 

We had our rabbits, pigeons, and gardens, which we 
had to look after ourselves,from the gardens we sold 
our poor little vegetables to Mother who always 
gave us praise for our labours. 

It was this last recollection that inspired the re¬ 
creation of the children’s garden at Rippon Lea in 
1998. Clara’s chance remark about the garden 
was not followed up with sufficient detail to 
identify the exact location of the children’s 
garden,but other comments captured the spirit of 
the children’s life in the wider garden at Rippon 
Lea. 

By and by the orangery became a favourite placefor 
our games. This was planned as a circle — a centre 
bed with a path round — a bed all round that, and 


and ... Gertrude Jekyll. 

another path, then a bed, a path, and all 
surrounded by orange, citrons, shaddock and lemon 
trees. 

This circle framed at either end with a path. 
Outside one opening was a grass circle in the 
middle of which was a tree, which served as "home” 
when we played hide and seek, and many a chase 
we had round those beds. 

The Children’s Garden at Rippon Lea 

To-day’s Children’s Garden at Rippon Lea 
occupies a triangular area at the southern end of 
the orchard, just beyond the remnant metal base 
plate of the former windmill. ‘The Chase’where 
the Jones children rode their bicycles 60 years 
after the Sargoods had played in the orangery, 
runs along its western boundary. 

At the end of the current Children’s Garden is 
a fine old Mahogany Gum which Clara 
described: 

Here was a large red gum, up which we were fond 
of climbing and sad to say many a bird’s nest was 
robbed. My brothers sending me up when the nest 
was in too high and difficult a position for them to 
risk their limbs. 

The design of the Children’s Garden was 
dependent on the imagination and creativity of a 
young gardener in the late 1990s. In Brian 
Worsley Rippon Lea found someone 
sympathetic to the project. He designed and built 
the distinctive lychgate at the entrance to the 
garden, as well as the bush-house cum cubby- 
house and the gangly scarecrow that sits outside it 


Australian Garden History Vot. 15 No 1 July/August 2003 9 



Plan of Children’s Garden at Rippon Lea 


Percy’s Garden 



Jerusalem Artichoke 
Celery 
Carrot 

Lamb’s Lettuce 
Leek 

Swiss Chard 



Clara’s Garden 


Onion 

Lovage 

Eschallot 

Borage 

Sunflower 

Oregano 

Winter 

Savoury 

Sage 


Lavender Chives Maijoram 
Bergamot Rosemary Catnip 


Shallots 

Pyrethrum 

Lemon 

Verbena 

Rue 



Scallions 


Society Garlic Thyme Parsley Salad Burnet Lavender \ 


Freddie’s Garden 


Norman’s Garden 


Cape Gooseberry 
Pea ‘Greenfeast’ 
Turnip 
Potato 

Palm Tree Kale 
Leek 

Savoy Cabbage 
Broccoli 
Cauliflower 


Asparagus Tree Angelica 
Globe Artichoke 


Cape Gooseberry 
Pea 'Oregon Dwarf’ 
Kohl Rabi 
Kohl Rabi 
Beetroot 
Radish 
Potato 
Raspberry 



Scarlet Runner Bean 
Strawberry Sweet Pea Feverfew\ 
Rhubarb Sorrel 


to enjoy the last of the autumn sun after his 
summer duties are done. Brian’s successor, 
Dugald Noyes, has brought specialist knowledge 
of vegetable gardening, experience in working 
with children, and great enthusiasm to his tasks in 
the garden. 

The cubby-house effectively cuts off the apex 
of the triangular site to provide an excellent place 
for the rabbit hutch and for billy tea under the tall 
gum tree that Clara mentioned in her memoirs. 

In front of the cubby-house are four separate 
gardens named for the Sargood children - Percy, 
Clara, Freddie and Norman. Clara, the eldest and 
apparently the most enthusiastic gardener, has a 
garden full of vegetables, herbs and flowers. The 
largest garden, it has a low, woven boundary fence 



in the centre.This is an interesting legacy from 
a lecture-workshop given at Rippon Lea in 
2001 by French architects Patrice Taravella 
and Sonia Lesot, known for their recreation of 
a medieval monastery garden at the prieure 
Notre Dame d’Orsan, in Berry, France. 

Freddy’s and Norman’s gardens are 
devoted to heritage vegetables grown from 
seed from Clive Blazey’s Digger’s Collection 
at Heronswood at Dromana. The varieties 
grown vary from season to season and year to 
year. The palm-tree kale always attracts 
attention and one year there was much 
interest in the aerial radish planted at the 
suggestion of Sally Williams, a visitor from 
Boston. It was duly harvested and served with 
smoked salmon. 

The youngest Sargood child gardener was 
Percy whom Clara chastised for his untidiness. 
Richard Ideathcote, the National Trust of 
Victoria’s Director of Development, says 
Percy’s garden has always been a challenge to 
professional gardeners for whom untidiness is 
anathema. 

The re-establishment of a Children’s 
Garden at Rippon Lea has added another 
dimension to the National Trust site - 
children’s play to stimulate historical 
imagination. Whereas a set program of display 
through conducted tours and interpretive 
signs is used inside the Rippon Lea mansion, 


10 Australian Garden History Vol. 15 No 1 July/August 2003 
























the Children’s Garden offers a more open-ended 
experience with seasonally changing gardens, 
Billy the scarecrow, a bush-house and appropriate 
tools. 

The Edwardian contribution 

Much of the thinking behind the Children’s 
Garden at Rippon Lea was gathered from 
Gertrude Jekyll’s delightful book Children and 
Gardens that still reads as well as it did when 
published in 1907, long after the Sargood 
children had grown up. The text is generally as 
relevant today, nearly a century after it was 
written, but the photographs of children, like the 
cover photo of this issue, are staged - but 
wonderfully evocative of the Edwardian days of 
peace and plenty that prevailed in England before 
the First World War. 

Jekyll recalled the things from the natural 
world that made a great impression on her as a 
child — ‘the difficulty in making daisy-chains ... 
the scent of mown grass’ and explained how the 
‘Dandelion remains with me as a London Smell.’ 

A thoroughgoing artisan from her steel¬ 
framed spectacles to her sturdy boots, and a 
considerable force in the Arts and Crafts 
movement,Jekyll believed that: 

... children should be taught the use of tools.There 
is always a vacant spot in the kitchen garden where 
they can practise, under careful teaching, the three 
most important operations — hoeing, digging and 
raking. 

Further, she enumerated the tools children 
should be given for cultivating their own 
garden: 


. . . spade, rake, hoe, a little wooden trug basket, 
and a blunt weeding knife; a good cutting knife, a 
trowel, a hand-fork and a little barrow ... there will 
also be wanted some raffia,for tying ... 

The weeding knife was defined very 
precisely: ‘a short strong knife with a smooth, 
horn handle that costs sevcnpence.’ 

A children’s PLAYHOUSE 

Jekyll details a plan for a playhouse and its garden. 
This is far more formal than a bush ‘cubby’ that 
the Sargood children might have known. Jekyll’s 
playhouse garden was intended to produce 
vegetables and herbs that could be used by 
children to prepare quite sophisticated dishes like 
Soupe Bonne Femme, French Julienne Soup or 
simpler things like scrambled eggs. 

It makes an interesting comparison with 
colonial Clara Sargood’s account.: 

There was the great gravel heap and alongside it the 
swings and the summer house, where later we girls 
were given a small stove on which on a Saturday 
morning we made many weird dishes. 

From the order and control of the playhouse 
area, Jekyll takes children further afield 
encouraging them to observe, to handle plants 
and create things like cowslip and primrose balls 
recalling that she herself made ‘an immense 
cowslip ball two feet in diameter’. When talking 
of serrate leaves she explains that the name 
Dandelion is really Dent-de-Lion because of the 
lion’s tooth shape of the edge ofits leaf. This leads 
into quite formal botanical discussion in Chapter 
7, before the next chapter describes the garden 
that she and her sister, Carry, made. 


Left: The lychgate entrance 
to the Children’s Garden 
Courtesy: Rippon Lea 
Archives 

Right: Inside the Children’s 
Garden at Rippon Lea 
Courtesy: Rippon Lea 
Archives 


Australian Garden History Vol. 15 No 1 July/August 2003 11 









Above: Billy the Scarecrow 
takes time off. 

Top: Detail of Clara’s 
Garden showing 
wickerwork 



‘A equicateral triangle' 


This section is full of practical information 
offering lots of activities for youngsters. 
Instructions on making plans, elevations and cross 
sections, suggestions for bedding plants that can 
be ‘begged from the gardener’, and advising that 
‘a few tufts of Daffodils, Crocuses and 
Snowdrops’ will give variety to planting. Jekyll 
warns that a sharp watch must be maintained for 
weeds as ‘one years seeding making seven years’ 
weeding’. 

Observation, conservation and 

IMAGINATION 

Jekyll encouraged children to go barefoot (after 
putting shoes and stockings tidily away on a 
bench), to make sandcastles, collect fir cones, 
make fern pegs, build picnic fires and bury any 




Above: ‘Like a pigeon pie' 

Top: 'Like cutlets in a dish' 

Gertrude Jekyll's view of kittens 
From: Children and Gardens 


rubbish or take it home. ‘Bits of paper go back 
into the picnic baskets and not even a chicken 
bone must be left on the ground’. 

‘Pussies in the Garden’, the final chapter, 
shows what empathyJekyll had with children and 
animals. It evidences her sense of fun and her 
creative and imaginative approach to play, to 
observation and to language as she relates how a 
little girl described a kitten purring as ‘Puss has 
got the flutter-mill going’. And her artist’s eye sets 
a wonderful example to children when she 
writes: 

It is amusing to see the different patterns that 
kittens lying in a round basket will sometimes get 
into. I have seen five kittens almost symmetrically 
arranged like cutlets in a dish, and four with their 
little paws all up in the air in the middle like a 
pigeon pie. It is almost impossible to believe that 
only four small people could have so many little 
toes. Three kittens at nearly equal distances round 
a saucer of milk make quite a pretty pattern. The 
architect [a reference to her friend Edward 
Lutyens] says it was an equicateral triangle! 

Before you visit the Children’s Garden at 
Rippon Lea, you should read Gertrude Jekyll’s 
Children and Gardens. 



PINKir WIST CLKVATION 


12 Australian Garden History Vol . 15 No lJuly/August 2003 








Plant List for the Children’s Garden at Kippon Lea 

From Dugald G. Noyes 



Annual Vegetables (Winter) 


Allium cepa ‘White Lisbon’ 

Scallions 

Allium cepa 

Shallot 

Allium cepa var. Aggregatum 

Eschallot 

Allium cepa' Paris Silverskin' 

Pickling Onion 

Apium graveolens var. dulce 

Celery 

Beta vulgaris 

Beetroot 

Beta vulgaris var. cida 

Swiss Chard 

Brassica oleracea var. acephala 

Palm Tree Kale 

Brassica oleracea var. botrytis 

Cauliflower 

Brassica oleracea var. captiata ‘Savoy King’ 

Cabbage 

Brassica oleracea var.^tm^yMes'Purple Vienna’ 

Kohl Rabi 

Brassica oleracea var. italica 

Broccoli 

Brassica rapa‘Purple Top White Globe’ 

Turnip 

Daucus carota ‘Chatenay Red Cored’ 

Carrot 

Pisum sativum ‘Greenfeast’ 

Pea 

Pisum sativum ‘Oregon Dwarf’ 

Pea 

Raphanus sativus ‘Scarlet Globe’ 

Radish 

Solatium tuberosum ‘Pink Fir Apple’ 

Potato 

Solatium tuberosum ‘Rippon Lea Phoenix’ 

Potato 

Valerianclla locusta 

Lamb’s Lettuce 

Viciafaha ‘Cole’s Early Dwarf’ 

Broad Beans 

Herbs 


Allium schoenaprasum 

Chives 

Aloysia triphylla 

Lemon Verbena 

Artemisia abrotanum 

Southernwood 

Borago officinalis 

Borage 

Calendula qftcinalis 

Pot Marigold 

Chrysanthemum cinerariifolium 

Py rethrum 

Chrysanthemum parthenium 

Feverfew 

Foeniculum rn/iyirUPurpureum’ 

Bronze Fennel 

Helianthus (innuus ‘Italian White’ 

Sunflower 

Lavandula dentata 

French Lavender 

Levisitcum officinale 

Lovage 

Melanosolanum dicepietis 

Tree Angelica 

Mentha cordifolia 

Common Mint 

Mentha suaveolens 

Apple Mint 

Monarda didyma 

Bergamot 

Nepeta cataria 

Cat Mint 

Origanum vulgarc 

Oregano 

Origanum vulgare ‘Aurcum’ 

Golden Maijoram 

Petroselinum crispum var. Neopolitanum 

Italian Parsley 

Rosmarinus officinalis 

Rosemary 

Ruta graveolens 

Rue 

Salvia doisiana 

Fruit Salad Sage 

Salvia officinalis 

Sage 

Sangtiisorba minor 

Salad Burnet 

Satureja montana 

Winter Savoury 

Thymus serpyllum 

Thyme 

Trapaedum majus ‘Peach Melba’ 

Nasturtium 

Tulbaghia violacea 

Society Garlic 

Perennial Vegetables and Fruits 


Acca sellowiana 

Feijoa 

Asparagus officinalis 

Asparagus 

Cynara scolymus 

Globe artichoke 

Eriobotrya japonica 

Loquat 

Fragaria x ananassa'Red Gauntlet’ 

Strawberry 


Fragaria vesca 
Helianthus luberostis 
Phaseolus coccineus 
Physalis peruviana 
Rheum rhabarbarum 
Ribes nigrum 
Ribes rubmm 
Ribes uva-crispa 
Rubus idaeus 
Rumex scutatus 

Flowering Plants 

Annuals and Biennials 
Alyssum sp, (white) 

Antirrhinum majus 

Campanula medium 

Centaurea cyanus 

Chrysanthemum paludosum 

Digitalis purpurea (white and apricot) 

Lathyrus odoratus 

Lunaria annua (white) 

Viola tricolor 

Bulbs and Corms 

Delphinium sp. 

Frcesia x hybrida (orange) 

Calanthus nivalis 
Gladiolus sp. (pink) 

Hyacinthoides hispanica 
Hyacintlnts sp. (blue) 

Narcissus sp. 

Narcissus jonquilla 
Tulipa sp. (red) 

Perennials 

Alcea rosa 
Aquilegia sp. 

Diantluis deltoides 
Dietes grandijlora 
Erbium candicans 

Geranium sp. (red, pink and white) 

Gypsophila elegans 

Heuchcra ‘Cathedral Windows’ 

Myosotis sylvatica 

Nemesiafoetans' Vanilla Mist’ 

Passiflora incarnata 

Penstcmon ’Osprey” 

Tagetes lemonii 

Viola cornuta 

Hedges 

Ligustrum ovalifolium 
Muehlenbeckia complexa 

Trees 

Eucalyptus botryoides 


Alpine Strawberry 
Jerusalem Artichoke 
Scarlet Runner Bean 
Cape Gooseberry 
Rhubarb 
Black Currant 
Red Currant 
Gooseberry 
Raspberry 
French Sorrel 


Sweet Alice 
Snapdragon 
Canterbury Bells 
Cornflower 
Chrysanthemum 
Foxglove 
Sweet Pea 
Honesty 
Wild Pansy 


Delphinium 

Freesia 

Snowdrop 

Gladioli 

Bluebells 

Hyacinth 

Dwarf Daffodil 

Jonquil 

Rock Tulip 


Hollyhock 
Columbine 
Carnation 
Wild Iris 
Bee Flower 
Geranium 
Baby’s Breath 
Coral Bells 

Chinese Forget-Me-Not 

Nemesia 

Passion Flower 

Penstcmon 

Lemon Scented 

Marigold 

HornedViolet 


Privet 

Muehlenbeckia 


Mahogany Gum 



Australian Garden History Vol. 15 No 1 July/August 2003 13 



Ken DUXBURY CONTINUES THE STORY OF EDWARD WILLIAM COLE WITH AN ACCOUNT OF HIS 
PUBLICATIONS AND HIS OWN GARDEN AT EARLSBRAE HALL IN ESSENDON. 


I 

I 

i 

I 



Above: Edward William Cole 
(1832-1918) 


The Happifying Garden Hobby 

T he first edition of the book generally known 
as The Happifying Garden Hobby was 
published in 1902, under the overall title of 
Garden Lovers Book of Gems. It reflects its 
origin as a compilation of snippets gathered from 
a wide variety of sources (generally non- 
Australian) — a sort of horticultural version of 
Cole’s Funny Picture Book. A lengthy 
introductory essay written by E.W. Cole carries 
die ‘chapter heading’ of‘The Happifying Garden 
Hobby’ and the compilation section of the book 
carries the same title as a running page heading. 

For some reason this original edition of the 
book is very rare, and surprisingly little known. 
The only copy I have been able to track down 
resides in the rare books section of the La Trobe 
Library in Melbourne. Although the first edition 
bears no print date, it can be dated fairly 
accurately by an advertisement for the 1902 
edition of One and All Gardening Annual, by 
references to the ‘Lord Rous’ daffodil as ‘being 
new this season’ (1902), and by references to 
Cole’s childhood ‘sixty years ago’. It is an 
attractive production of 216 pages (and 24 
preliminaries), measuring 22 x 10cm. with 
coloured decoration of stylised flowers, good 
quality paper, solid cloth binding, and very well- 
produced photographic illustrations. 

Cole’s introductory essay is of great interest, 
and is worth quoting at some length. Cole began 
by describing the composition of his book: 

It consists mainly of 200 pieces and poems in 
praise of gardening and flowers, [written by] 
eminent personages who have seen and felt the 
great value of the gardening hobby to mankind, 
morally, physically and socially. Gardening is one 
of the best hobbies we have, for it brings 
knowledge, and health, and happiness in many 
ways. 



He continues to amplify the various benefits of 
gardening: 

It brings us health in a most satisfactory manner... 

It is as good an exercise for health as general 
gymnastics, and gives more lasting satisfaction; and 
it gives us all this pleasant exercise and recreation 
close to our home, and turns to profitable account 
the very act of beautifying the home. 

Flowers bring refined pleasure and, consequently, 
happiness ... Flowers smell the sweetest and look 
the loveliest of all earthly things, and most men and 
women throughout the world dearly love them; and 
the cherished wish of nearly all mankind is to go lo 
a world beyond the grave where everlasting spring 
abides and never-withering flowers ... 

Flowers bring happiness in other ways. They bring 
solace to the sick, beautify the house, adorn the hell 


14 Australian Garden History Vol . 15 No l July/August 2003 


















and the altar, and deck the bride and the grave ... 
Perhaps the most valuable effect of a garden, 
especially a Jlower garden, is to make a happy 
home. Hie people who live in houses with gardens 
of their own planting are nearly always happier, all 
other things being equal, than those who live in 
houses without gardens. 

Cole describes his childhood memories of 
flowers and gardens and laments the fact that 
despite his love of flowers, circumstances had 
always prevented him from indulging in a garden. 
He goes on to describe some of the features of the 
ideal garden: 

A garden, if possible, should have a summer¬ 
house, covered with beautiful creepers, or vines, 
or passionffuit; also creepers over every unsightly 
fence, wall, etc.; one or more plots of grass; and a 
small pond to grow aquatic plants and hold a few 
tame fish, and perhaps a tame frog or two, to sing 
‘bollop’, if such is the choice. 

He concludes with the warning: 

Do not have a large garden unless you can 
afford a gardener, or have plenty of leisure time 
on your hands, it would cause you too much 
trouble. Make gardening a pleasant recreation, a 
labour of love, not a slavery and a worry. 

In 1918, a new edition of the book was 
brought out as part of what appears to have been 
a standard uniform edition of Cole’s works, and 



Anyone can Grow their own Mushrooms if they choose. 


From The Happifying Garden Hobby 

this entire book (451pp) bears the title The 
Happifying Garden Hobby. This is the edition 
that is widely known today. However as Victor 
Crittenden notes: ‘Many of the quotations and 
illustrations are the same [as in The Garden 
Lover’s Book of Gems]. Most of the Australian 


references have been removed including Cole’s 
interesting long introduction.’ 

The extracts which make up most of the 
work are so miscellaneous that they are virtually 
impossible to summarise, except that very little of 
the material seems to be of Australian origin - 
perhaps because of copyright laws or the 
likelihood of their being enforced. The section 
on the language of flowers is more 
comprehensive than the list in the Funny Picture 
Book and includes flower dialogues.There is also 
a section on the way more complex — and 
sometimes rather nasty — messages can be 
conveyed, for example: 

Your frivolity and malevolence will cause you to be 
forsaken by all. 

1 Frivolity ... London Pride 

2 Malevolence... Lobelia 

3 Forsaken... Laburnum 

Theflowers should be bound together until a fading 
leaf. 

OTHER GARDENING PUBLICATIONS 

About 1905, Cole edited a booklet entitled 
Cotton growing: the coming leading industry in 
Australia. He believed that Australia was ideally 
suited for growing cotton because: 

It has got the finest climate in the world and 
the largest and best territory in the world for 
growing cotton ... But in this vast tropical region, 
the un-aedimatised, white-skinned man cannot 
work. He can plan and superintend, and find the 
necessary capital to raise products, and find 
markets for them when produced,but he will not 
and cannot do the labouring work. And here 
comes in our fortunate position with respect to a 
splendid supply of suitable coloured labour (in 
India, China, Japan and Java). 

E.W. Cole published the second edition of 
The Fruitgrower’s Handbook by Hamilton 
McEwin in 1913. The book contains 226 pages 
(plus index) and deals with the commercial 
growing of a wide range of fruit including apples, 
pears, apricots, peaches, citrus fruits, grapes, 
raspberries, currants, passionfruit and 
strawberries. There are several photographic 
illustrations of tropical fruit such as bananas and 
pineapples, but these are not mentioned in the 
text that mainly deals with conditions in 
Tasmania, where McEwin lived, andVictoria. 

There are four full-colour photographic 
illustrations of different varieties of apples — 
including Jonathan,‘The favourite eating Apple 
of Australia’, and Newton Pippin,‘The favourite 
Apple of America’. The illustrations soon found 
their way into editions of Cole’s Funny Picture 
Book No. 2 as a two-page spread, bordered by 
apple leaves and blossom and with the text 




Apples refresh Man and 
make Him Healthy 





From E. W. Cole, The 
Happifying Garden Hobby, 
v E.W. Cole Book Arcade, 
Melbourne 1918. 


Australian Garden History Vol. 15 No 1 July /August 2003 15 












E.W. Cole in the garden at 
Earlsbrae Hall, Essendon c. 
1916, showing the rainbow 
bed and palms. 


commentary:‘Apples, the Best Fruit in the World. 
The best kinds should be plentifully grown and 
eaten by everybody, every day, for health’s sake 
read Apples andTobacco — All Booksellers.’ 

The spread is preceded by a page headed 
‘Funny History of the Apple’ which includes a 
paragraph headed ‘What Little Boys and Girls 
should Do’. It runs as follows: 

Little boys and girls should always have plenty 
of apples to eat, and all little boys and little girls 
should frequently, but respectfully, try to 
impression this upon the minds of their parents; 
and that their parents should eat them too. 

Little boys and girls should always ask their 
parents to plant some nice kinds of apple trees in 
the garden; and whether they have a garden or 
not, to keep some apples, fresh or preserved, in the 
house, to eat for health and pleasure’s sake. 

These days of course, children are far more 
likely to frequently, but not always respectfully, 
impress upon the minds of their parents the need 


to visit McDonald’s - and not for the roof-of- 
the-mouth-burning‘Apple Pies’ either. 

While preparing this article 1 noticed for the 
first time, that the colour plates used to show the 
apples in The Fruitgrower’s Handbook were also 
used in the Funny Picture Book. It is quite likely 
that the Funny Picture Book was seen as a good 
opportunity to recycle these plates — which 
would have been expensive to prepare — and 
which would have been readily available at Cole’s 
own printery in the Book Arcade. It is possible 
that the existing illustrations of the very 
appetising looking apples implied the apple 
section of the Funny Picture Book, much as the 
Pickwick Papers were initially written around 
some pre-existing illustration owned by the 
publisher. It is also possible that Cole’s enthusiasm 
for apples implied both the decision to include 
colour plates of apples in the Fruitgrower’s 
Handbook (where no other fruits are illustrated 
in colour) and also the Funny Picture Book No. 2 


16 Australian Garden History Vol . 15 No 1 July/August 2003 

















xA-T- 

,vrV 


article on apples. In any case this episode 
illustrates the way in which Cole’s activities were 
closely interconnected, and also his great skill at 
recycling and repackaging material and for ‘cross 
promotion’. 

In 1914.E.W. Cole, Book Arcade, Melbourne 
published another important gardening book. It 
was written by A.E.Cole, incorrectly referred to 
on the title page and cover as A.F.Cole, and 
entitled The Bouquet: Australian flower 
gardening. A.E. Cole was a practical gardener 
based in Sydney. He does not appear to be related 
to E. W. Cole. 

The book was available in both cloth and 
paper covered issues with the covers referring to 
the book as A Bouquet: Australian Flower Garden 
Handbook - Cole’s books are indeed a great trial 
to the bibliographer! The book has 176 pages and 
contains a large number of illustrations and 
diagrams. Crittenden’s bibliography notes that: 

A number of line drawings explaining the 


layout of a garden, the preparation of soil, path 
making, tree and shrub planting. There are also 
some amusing plans for garden lay out with 
winding paths and star shaped flower beds, also a 
lawn in the shape of Australia - a popular device 
at the time of Federation. 

This book is probably the best contemporary' 
description reflecting the distinctive, char¬ 
acteristic Australian garden style that might be 
called Federation Gardenesque. 

About two years later, Cole published a 
second work byA.E.Cole, entitledThe Australian 
Floral Almanac. One hundred and twenty-six 
pages in length with an illustrated paper wrapper, 
it appears to have been published by the Sydney 
branch of the Book Arcade and E.W. Cole may 
have had little or no direct involvement in its 
publication. Crittenden describes this work as 
‘An enjoyable book giving the monthly garden 
information in a light-hearted fashion . . . His 
remarks are mainly about annuals, with some 


2002 - Earlsbrae Hall, now 
Lowther Hall Anglican 
Grammar School. The arc 
of the rainbow has gone to 
accommodate oli-street 
parking but much of the 
front lawn remains. The 
palms too, have gone but 
the native trees have been 
maintained. 

Courtesy: Lowther Hall 
Anglican Grammar School 
Archives. 


Australian Garden History Vol 15 No 1 July/August 2003 17 


























bush-house notes and information on roses and 
chrysanthemums.’ A.E. Cole was later to write a 
small book Half-Hours in the Bush House, 
published by Angus and Robertson in 1922. 

The move to Essendon 

Cole’s wife died on 15 March 1911. Until that 
time Cole and his family had lived in a flat at the 
Arcade probably because Mrs Cole preferred city 
living. Shortly after his wife’s death, and when his 
health was failing at the age of 79, Cole’s life 
underwent a dramatic change. He purchased 
Earlsbrae Hall, in Leslie Street, Essendon, then a 
sparsely settled suburb six miles to the north of 
Melbourne. 

Earlsbrae Hall had been built during the 
1880’s land boom by Collier McCracken, a 
brewer, and had reputedly cost £35,000 to build. 
The facade was dramatised by 16 Corinthian 
columns, creating a sort of ‘land boom 
Parthenon’ character. The house contained 27 
rooms and stood on 2Vz acres or slightly more 
than one hectare of land. A photograph taken of 
Earlsbrae Hall in 1899, when the McCracken 
family occupied it, shows a typical Victorian 
‘mansion garden’ with palm, cordylines and 
circular flowerbeds. 

Cole purchased the property for £6,000 after 
it had been tenanted, and occasionally 
unoccupied, for several years. The house and 
garden were in poor condition and needed a lot 
of attention. Cole appears to have retained the 
general character of the garden as a photograph 
of his family taken in 1916 from almost the same 
location and angle as the 1899 photograph shows 
little change. 

It is likely, however, that the garden was 
somewhat simplified and that some of the 
elaborate floral displays would have been 
converted to lawn, probably before Cole’s 
occupancy and possibly during the later stages of 
the McCracken’s occupancy when their financial 
problems became increasingly pressing. Cole 
appears to have found the property more than he 
could easily cope with. His daughter, Mrs Ivy 
Rudd recalled that: 

It was simply too large, too expensive, and too 
dilapidated. The sewerage system was 
malfunctioning, the garden needed tending and 
the fences mending. In our time, we too found 
the upkeep eventually impossible. 

Despite these challenges Cole soon made his 
own unique and idiosyncratic contribution to the 
house and garden, so that they became almost as 
much a reflection and extension of his personality 
as his Book Arcade. The property was rapidly 
transformed into a sort of Xanadu of the intellect. 
It soon became known, somewhat predictably, as 
King Cole’s Castle. 


Most famously. Cole, or his gardeners, planted 
a giant 75foot long rainbow in front of his house 
alongside the curving driveway. A highly 
evocative photograph of the aged, white- 
bearded, Cole sitting in a chair and enjoying the 
sun beside his flowerbed is included in the 
pictorial biography of Cole prepared by his 
grandson, Cole Turnley. Cole also devised a 
complicated, periscope-like system of mirrors so 
that he could view the rainbow bed and other 
parts of his garden from his bedroom. In one 
gesture Cole had combined his lifelong interest 
in flowers and gardens with the almost obsessive 
preoccupation with rainbows and mirrors that 
had created the memorable character of his Book 
Arcade. 

Cole also established a remarkable menagerie 
at Earlsbrae Hall. It included a gigantic aviary 
with birds ‘of notable voice to enhance the song 
of the local birds in the trees’; several of Cole’s 
favourite monkeys,‘smaU,gende marmosets who 
could be trusted to run around the grounds 
without trying to escape’ as well as a half-breed 
British bulldog, a tame kangaroo named Ivy, 
(perhaps after Cole’s daughter), and a young 
cheetah named Leo who was soon passed on to 
the Melbourne Zoo. 

The context of Cole’s rainbow 
GARDEN BED 

Despite its unique character, Cole’s rainbow bed 
was not altogether outside the garden design 
fashion of the day - what might be termed 
‘Federation Gardenesque’. Melbourne already 
had the star-shaped garden bed, in Alexandra 
Gardens adjacent to Princes Bridge, which 
appears to represent the six-pointed Federation 
Star. And a garden bed in the Carlton Gardens, 
adjacent to the Exhibition Building, took the 
form of the Australian coat of arms, die old 
unofficial version, surmounted by a rising sun. 

The Bouquet: Australian flower gardening 
contains illustrations showing a great variety of 
novel, decoratively-shaped flower beds and 
garden features. A lawn in the shape of Australia 
and Tasmania, girt by gravel. A garden featuring a 
circular flowerbed and one shaped like a Maltese 
Cross with a circular centre. A garden with two 
flowerbeds shaped like an ‘exploding star’ with 
four long and four shorter points. And a page 
showing six different flower bed designs 
including a lily and a shamrock. 

One of the illustrations in Garden Gems 
(1902), but better known from the 1918 edition 
retitledThe Happifying Gardening Hobby,shows 
a ‘curious garden’ with garden beds in the shape 
of two dogs (or possibly a dog and a cat), a duck, 
(or possibly a chicken), a man with outstretched 
arms spreadeagled on the ground and two giant 


18 Australian Garden History Vol . 15 No 1 July/August 2003 






footprints. The garden also features two giant 
topiary hands and what appears to be a topiary 
watering can. 

The final years 

Cole remained mentally active — occupying 
much of his time bringing out a collected unified 
edition of the books he had written and 
compiled, printing some of them at a printing 
press set up at Earlsbrae Hall. He also made 
regular visits to the Book Arcade, accompanied by 
one of his daughters and a marmoset monkey 
who had free range of their brougham coach. 

Edward Cole died at Earlsbrae Hall on 16 
December 1918, aged 86. He was buried in a 
Church of England compartment at Boroondara 
Cemetery where his gravestone is an open book. 
It could be a bible, one of the many books 
written, compiled or published by Cole - The 
Real Place in History of Jesus and Paul or some 
other religious or philosophical tract - or perhaps 
The Happifying Garden Hobby, or even the 
Funny Picture Book. Or perhaps the book is 
intended to be an anonymous representative of 
each and every one of the millions of books sold 
by Cole at his Book Arcade. The stone book bears 
the simple inscription: 

FATHER EDWARD WILLIAM COLE 

BORN 4TH JANY 1832 
PASSED AWAY 16TH DEC 
1918 

Aftermath 

Shortly after Cole s death Earlsbrae Hall was sold 
to the Church of England and became Lowther 
Hall, an Anglican Girls’School. The property has 
not been subdivided and the main building 
remains substantially intact, at least externally. 
Generally the garden has been engulfed by 
buildings, but the original driveway, and much of 
the front garden still remain, although the 
rainbow flowerbed, and most of the palms, 
cordylines, and other Victorian style plantings 
have long since disappeared. 

The Book Arcade foundered through 
inadequate management: leases were not 
renewed, the old Fernery was converted into a 
stationery department, and the first financial 
losses ever recorded since the inception of the 
Arcade led to the winding up of the business in 
1929 when the freehold properties were 
auctioned. The best of the monkeys were given 
to the Melbourne Zoo and the remainder were 
destroyed — a sad tale indeed for ‘the animal next 
to man’! As for the distorting mirrors, once the 
major attraction ofWonderland, they were sold to 



Luna Park and can be seen today in the Body and A 'curious garden'. 

Mind section of the new Melbourne Museum. ^ ror !] Happifying 
The building in Collins Street was also soon 
demolished. However, the old bluestone building 
in Little Collins Street remains remarkably intact, 
and pedestrians walking along Flowey Place are 
still sheltered from the elements by the steel and 
frosted-glass roof erected by Cole. And, visiting 
the site while researching this article, I looked up 
at the root and beheld — incorporated into the 
ornamental ironwork, painted rusty brown but 
still unmistakable — a RAINBOW. 



Ken Duxbury has a Master of Landscape 
Architecturefrom the University of Melbourne. He 
has worked in urban and environmental planning 
and as a consultant on historic gardens. Among his 
interests are antiquarian books and collecting 
historic postcards. 


Australian Garden History Vet. IS No 1 July/August 2003 19 














Sandra Pullman concludes her study of the work and life of Luffman by 

DISCUSSING THE LECTURE HE GAVE IN 1901 ON THE PROPOSED DESIGN OF THE 
NATIONAL CAPITAL CITY, THE PAPER HE GAVE CHALLENGING THE DESIGN IDEAS OF 

Walter Butler, his garden design at Killamont and his later life. 


Ideas for a national capital 



Charles Bogue Luffman 
Courtesy: Archives, Burnley 
Campus, The University of 
Melbourne. 


I n 1901 Luffman was invited to speak at a 
congress of architects and engineers in 
Melbourne on the design for the new federal 
capital. Later published as The Agricultural, 
Horticultural and Sylvan Features of a Federal Capita? it 
concentrated on presenting the options of what a 
city needs to make it an attractive and pleasant 
residential place. Luffman believed that choosing 
the right site was of cardinal importance. It needed 
to be undulating surfaces, permanent streams, and 
‘one or more fine sweeps of hills, or deeply groined 
mountain side.’ He continued to stress the need for 
a source of water for all agricultural industries and 
a good depth of soil to reduce the cost of 
construction and maintenance of sites. Luffman 
also believed that the native timber and naturally 
occurring features should be maintained. 

One interesting idea he put forward was that 
farming areas should break up the suburban 
development. In effect he was suggesting the 
creation of‘green belts’. He also considered that 
Australia should use its native flora as symbols of the 
nation rather than copying the symbols of other 
countries.- 

He understood that Australia’s climate and flora 
were unique and in 1903 he published a book 
written for Australian conditions. Based on a series 
of six lectures he had given. The principles of 
gardening for Australia was one of the first books to 
draw attention to the special features of the 
Australian environment and its application to 
horticulture. It is a practical book, giving good 
advice on designing and preparing a site for a 
garden. Its writing is somewhat romantic in tone, 
although not to the extent ofVI vagabond in Spain, 
rather it is informative language giving the reader 
things to think about. The book covers topics such 
as: 

The Principles of Garden Architecture, 

Designing Gardens to Meet Local Conditions, 
Materials Available and the Practical Work of 
Making the Garden, 

The Selection and Arrangement of Permanent 
Plants in Garden Schemes, 


Planning. Forming and Maintaining 

Small Gardens, 

Garden Management and a Rose Garden. 

Luffman and Butler 

Together with Walter Richmond Butler, Luffman 
was supposed to give a lecture to members of the 
Royal Victorian Institute of Architects (the RV1A) 
on 30 June 1903. Unfortunately on that particular 
night Luffman was ill and only Butlers paper was 
presented. Luffman delivered his paper on 26 April 
1904, nearly a year later. Had it taken place as 
originally planned it would have been an 
interesting meeting between these two men who 
had opposing philosophies. 

Butler was an English-trained architect who 
had been involved with the Arts and Crafts 
Movement in England and had been influenced by 
William Morris and Reginald Blomfield. He 
believed that the architect should design the garden 
because the garden was not part of the natural 
environment any more than the house was, and 
therefore, like the house, the garden should be a 
work of art. 3 It was Butler’s opinion that the house 
and garden were inseparable and that there should 
be unity between the inside and the outside of the 
house. 

Luffman spoke of the design of the garden and 
of the importance of doing it properly in its own 
right. He tried to build a bridge between the 
architect and landscape gardeners. 4 He talked 
about designing in accordance with nature, climate, 
depth of soil, style of house and surface form. He 
believed that the natural soil level of a particular 
area is rarely sufficient and soil must be brought in. 
He believed very strongly in preparing the site by 
trenching for planting and said ‘We make our 
gardens with too much haste.’ He also talked about 
the gardener’s input into the design suggesting the 
gardener should appear early on the scene, when 
plans were being discussed with the architect. 
Luffman raised the question as to whether a home¬ 
owner was prepared ‘to keep a good gardener, or 
only a man?’ He then went on to talk about the size 
and architecture of the house suggesting that small 


20 Australian Garden History Vol 15 No 1 July /August 2003 




Key 

1 Main Drive 

7 Swimming Pool 

12 Shrubs 

2 Picket Fence 

8 Tennis Court 

13 Rose Garden 

3 Entrance 

9 Garage 

14 Lawn 

4 Ponds 

10 Croquet Lawn 

15 Brick Wall 

5 Bridge 

11 Vegetable Garden 

16 Bamboos 


houses should not have tiny lawns or grass borders. 
Finally he spoke of the costs of good design and 
preparation suggesting that a small investment of 2- 
5% on the garden could add 12-20% value to the 
cost of the property. 

Marilyn McBriar discusses Luffman’s and 
Butlers contributions to garden design in her 
article‘A Edwardian Discussion, Formal or Natural 
Gardens for Australia?’ In this paper she says 
Luffman did not reject the formal garden 
completely, but that he believed that architecture, 
position and financial resources determined the 
style of the garden. 5 McBriar also stated that 
Luffman believed that the informal garden suited 
Australia better than the formal style. It was 
because the Australian use of dark red brick with 
very dark wood, gables and strongly marked 
windows and doorways topped with an over¬ 
awning of red tiled roofs gave a heavy and sombre 
appearance that Luffman argued was a Gothic style. 
He said the Gothic style was all vertical and 
graceful curves and these were present in nature. 6 

The YEARS AFTER Burnley 1908-1920 

After finishing his work for the Metropolitan Golf 
Club in Melbourne 7 Luffman returned to Spain to 
work and also to hone the notes he had submitted 
to the publisher John Murray in 1904. These were 
an account of his earlier travels in Spain and were 
published in 1910 as Quiet Days in Spain. 


The appeal of citrus fruit drew Luffman to 
Florida and he later visited Japan on behalf of the 
United States of America. He investigated the 
Japanese orange industry reporting back to the 
USA on how the Japanese managed to control 
disease problems in citrus orchards. This 
experience led to his next book The Harvest of 
Japan’', published in 1920. In it Luffman describes 
the Japanese as ‘nature worshippers, gardeners, 
artists and handicraft’s people’ and he regarded 
them as superior to Europeans. What he felt stood 
out about the Japanese is not their ability to 
replicate nature on a small scale, but their 
understanding and subtle knowledge of all the 
elements and phenomena of tree growth. 9 

During the First World War and the last year of 
his life Luffman was working as a gardener at Wyke 
Regis, Dorset in England with his apprentice 
Agnes Sleet. He was also lecturing on gardening to 
the returned servicemen. Sadly on 6 May 1920 he 
died of cancer in a rented room at Babbacombe in 
Devon. 

Killamont 

The only known garden left by Luffman, on a 
property in the Western Goulburn Valley near 
Kyabram, is Killamont. In 1896 James Finlay 
bought the property from James McNee. It dates 
back to 1869 when the original kitchen of the 
homestead was built. 10 


Australian Garden History Voi . 15 No 1 July/August 2003 21 










































Top: Killamont, looking 
across the flower garden to 
the homestead. 

Bottom: Looking across the 
croquet lawn between the 
shrubberies. 


James Finlay married Eleanor Affleck in 1898 
and she lived at Killamont until she died in 1969. 
When the final additions to the house were done 
in 1904-5, Eleanor turned her attention to the 
garden that was used extensively for recreation and 
enjoyment to entertain friends and family. There 
was a tennis court and croquet lawn. James also 
kept an aviary filled with exotic birds. 

How Luffinan became involved is unknown, 
but as Mathews points out he was the Principal of 
Burnley Horticultural College and that would 
have given him some status. Before Luffinan 
redesigned the garden it was a simple, formal, 
symmetrica] garden with ‘wide straight paths 
around the house edged with terra cotta edging 
tiles.’ 11 After Luffinan redesigned it, it became a 
garden of tranquillity and peace. 


The garden is approximately two hectares, 
regular in shape except for the northern section 
that juts out on an angle. There is a picket fence, a 
curvilinear driveway and one of Luffinan’s 
signature features, a pond large enough to 
accommodate boating. 

The garden was a series of spaces with distinct 
features but all spaces interconnect with each other. 
Popular trees of the time were English Oak 
(Quercus robur), the Peppercorn ( Schinus areira) and 
the Coral Tree ( Erythina crista-galli). There was also 
a shrubbery and an orchard - very important in the 
early days as properties has to be self-sufficient. The 
garden was designed to provide interest throughout 
the year, with use of French hawthorn ( cratageus x 
lavallei ) that has good autumn colour. Crepe 
myrtles ( Lagerstroemia indica) added their interesting 


22 Australian Garden History Vol . 15 No 1 July /August 2003 










bark and there were colourful flowers and autumn 
foliage as the garden was well planted with bulbs, 
perennials and annuals. 

The present owners of Killamont, Neville and 
Wendy Varcoe have carefully restored the garden as 
they were fortunate to find old photographs, the 
original garden plan and notes by Luffman on how 
to establish it. 

Charles Luffman was a good practitioner and 
communicator. His success was his ability to 
educate. He well understood how to establish an 
orchard and dry fruit industry. Unfortunately his 
tendency to be hot-blooded probably actually held 
him back because he was too difficult to deal with 
and thus he may have lost opportunities that could 
have furthered his career. Luffman was a promoter 
of the natural landscape and of ideas on how to 
achieve it. He was not as well known as his 
contemporary, William Guilfoyle, because he did 
not design many landscapes. Instead he wrote and 
lectured. 


Sandra Pullman, an undergraduate student at 
Burnley College, University of Melbourne is a 
member of the Landscape Committee of the 
NationalTrust (Victoria). She contributes articles on 
garden history to the Age and is particularly 
interested in the work of early Burnley graduates. 

1 C.B. Luffman, The Agricultural, Horticultural and 
Sylvan Features of a Federal Capital, J.C. Stephens, 
Melbourne 1901. 

2 ibid, pp.1-3. 

3 M. McBriar, ‘An Edwardian Discussion, Formal or 
Natural Gardens for Australia?’, Australian Garden 
History,V 61. 1, No. 6, 1990, AGHS, Melbourne, p.6. 

4 C.B. Luffman,‘Garden Design in Accord with Local 
Needs’ Journal of Proceedings Royal Victorian Institute 
ofArchitects; Vbl.2, No. 2,1904-5, p. 44. 

5 M. McBriar, op. cit. p. 9. 

6 ibid. p. 10 

7 See Sandra Pullman ,‘Charles Bogue Luffman, Part 
Two: the Burnley Years’, Australian Garden Flistory, 
Vol. 14, No. 5, May/June 2003,pp. 16 and 18 

8 C.B. Luffman, The Harvest of Japan, T.C. and E.C.Jack 
Ltd, 35 Paternoster Row, London, 1920. 

9 ibid. 

10 D. Mathews, Killamont Conservation: Analysis of the 
Historic Garden of Killamont, 1991. Final Project 
(unpublished). Royal Melbourne Institute of 
Technology. 

11 ibid. 


Acknowledgments 

The author acknowledges the generous help of John 
Patrick, John Hawker, Ettie Pullman, Joss Tonkin and 
Wendy Varcoe in providing material and assistance in the 
preparation of this series of articles on Charles Bogue 
Luffman. 


Reference Bibliography 

Andrews, L., 2000, History of Burnley Gardens 1860-1939, 
Honours Thesis, Bachelor of Applied Science (Hort), 
University of Melbourne, Institute of Land and Food 
Resources, Richmond, Melbourne pp. 177,182 
Bate. W, 2001, Sustaining Their Dream, Metropolitan Golf 
Club, Oaklcigh, pp. 19,237 

Blake, L.J. (ed), 1973, Vision & Realisation — A Centenary 
History of State Education in Victoria, Education 
Department,Victoria, pp. 298,346 
Blomfield, R., The Formal Garden in England. 1901, 
Macmillan and Co Limited, New York 
Luffman, C., 1900, Report by the Principal of the School of 
Horticulture, Annual Report, Department of 
Agriculture, pp. 262,262,327,328 
Luffinann, C.B.. 1903, The Principles of Gardening 
for Australia, The Book Lovers’Library, Melbourne, p. 34 
Luffinann, C.B., 1904-05, Garden Design in Accord with Local 
Needs, Journal of Proceedings Vol. 2, Royal Victorian 
Institute of Architects pp. 40-42 
Luffinann C.B., 1901, The Agricultural, Horticultural and Sylvan 
Features of a Federal Capital, J.C. Stephens, Melbourne, 
National Library of Canberra 

Luffman C, B., 1920, 77ie Harvest ofJapan, T.C & E.C.Jack, 
Ltd, 35 &36 Paternoster Row, E.C. London, pp. 57,92 
Nairn, B., Serle, G., (ed), 1986, Australian Dictionary of 
Biography, Patrick, J., Vol 10, 1891-1939 Lat-Ner, 
Melbourne University Press, Carlton, Victoria, 

p. 166 

Nairn, B., Serle, G., (ed), 1986, Australian Dictionary of 
Biography, Mettison M.,Vol 10, 1891-1939 Lat-Ner, 
Melbourne University Press, Carlton.Victoria, p.167 
McBriar, M., 1990,‘An Edwardian Discussion, Formal or 
Natural Gardens for Australia?’Australian Garden History 
Society Journal, Vol. 1, No. 6, April/May /June 1990, 
Melbourne pp, 6-11 

Mordaunt, F... 1937, Sinahada, Michael Joseph, London, pp. 
114,118,119 

Patrick J., 1988,‘Gardens and Garden Designers ofAustralia’s 
Past’, Journal of Proceedings, Australian Institute of 
Hortiadture Inc. 

Patrick, J., 2002, The Oxford Companion to Australian Gardens, 
Oxford University Press.Australia,p.381 
Winzenried.A. P., 1991, Green Grows Our Garden, Hyland 
House, p.l 1 

1896-1897, Mildura Settlement- Report of a Mildura Royal 
Commission, Papers presented to Parliament -Session 
1896 Legislative Assembly Vol. Ill No. 19, Australian 
Parliamentary Papers Box, LTMS 1896V3 & 4,1897VI, 
V66,p. 125-128 
Microfiche 

1837-1956, St. Catherine’s House England and Wales, June 
Quarter, Lid — Mak 2735, La Trobe Library, State 
Library, Swanston Street, Melbourne 
Newspaper Articles 

The Australasian 25 January 1908, p. 189 ‘Luffman’s 
Retirement’, Hugh George, 

The Mildura Cultivator, 20 June 1896, Royal Commission, 
N.B. McKay, Midura p. 1 
Maps 

Luffman, C., 1905, The Farm Homestead, Tear Book of 
Agriculture for 1905, By the Staff of the Department, 
Chapter VI, Department of Agriculture, Held at the 
Department of Natural Resources and Environment, 
Victoria Parade, East Melbourne 


Australian Garden History Vol . 15 No 1 July/August 2003 23 


o 


OO K .S HFLF 


U-H 


Australian Planting Design 
PaulThompson 
Lothian Books, 2002 
ISBN: 0 7344 0438 7 
RRP: $65.00 

Reviewed by Marion Pennicuik 

Australian Planting Design is passionately written 
by the acknowledged expert on Australian 
planting design, Paul Thompson. A renowned 
landscape architect often called upon for his detail 
in planting design, Paul has been involved in a 
number of significant public planting projects, 
including the 25ha Australian Garden at the 
Royal Botanic Gardens, Cranbourne where he 
worked with landscape architects Taylor Cullity 
Lethlean. 

Thompson pays homage to Glen Wilson, the 
Australian plant guru of thel960s and 1970s, but 
his book is contemporary. He is a member of the 
Design Study Group of the Australian Plants 
Society. His book is quite different from that of 
the convener of the group, Diana Snape, whose 
The Australian Garden is aimed firmly at the 
domestic garden designer. 

Paul’s book is ambitious, aimed at an audience 
that includes both domestic-scale and, 
particularly, larger developments. He includes 
detailed information on soils and earth form, 
manipulation of space, light, water, structures and 
vegetation. His knowledge of plants is excellent 
and his bias is towards local Australian plants, 
particularly trees. 

Paul covers the components of a garden, 
planting design, and garden management over 
time. He emphasises that gardens are not static, 
and that planting designs must be reassessed at 
regular intervals, with plants replaced as they 
become senescent or obsolete when 
neighbouring plants mature. He cites patterns of 
change in the Australian bush, the effects of fire 
and drought, and includes numerous design case 
studies to illustrate his arguments. His line 
drawings illustrate his arguments well. 


Australian Planting Design includes extensive 
footnotes, further reading lists, a general index 
and a botanical index to both common and 
scientific names. The dust-jacket design is 
evocative of the bush, the outback, the light, the 
texture and the colour that is Australia. Paul 
mentions texture only fleetingly, yet the stunning 
images that illustrate his ideas are alive with 
texture! 

Exceptional and contemporary, Australian 
Planting Design encapsulates the design emphasis 
that the landscape profession has brought to the 
notion of indigenous planting. An essential 
reference for all landscape architects. 


Marion Pennicuick currently edits ‘The Spirit of 
Progress’for the Art Deco Society. 

Lilacs for the garden 

Jennifer Bennett 
Firefly Books 2002 

Distributed in Australia & New Zealand by 
Florilegium 
ISBN: 1552975622 
RRP: $39.95 

Reviewed by Nina Crone 

Apart from Colette who wrote of its‘toxic aroma 
of prussic acid’, lilac has received good press - 
from Amy Lowell, Vita Sackville West, Eleanor 
Perenyi, Joan Law-Smith and, most recently, 
Lynne Strahan - yet it is often thought of as old- 
fashioned. Jennifer Bennett’s Lilacs for the garden 
puts a sound argument for its place in the 
contemporary landscape as ‘a shrub for today, 
tomorrow and yesterday.’ 

In the first book on lilacs for the gardener for 
nearly 80 years, Bennett describes how the 
common lilac (Syringa vulgans) migrated from the 
Balkans across Europe and the Atlantic to 
America. It found particular favour in France 
where three generations of the Lemoine family 


24 Australian Garden History Vol. IS No 1 July/August 2003 




persevered with hybridisation to produce the 
double lilacs and hyanthijlora hybrids. She traces 
the successive arrivals of the Chinese varieties 
into 19th century Europe and the later evolution 
of the great lilac collections in St Petersburg, 
Paris, Kew Gardens and at the Arnold Arboretum 
in Massachusetts. Her account of the work of 
Isabella Preston,John Fiala and FreekVrugtman 
brings the story up to date. 

Although the book is strongly oriented to the 
American market, it contains valuable and 
interesting material for an antipodean lilac lover. 
A Canadian, Bennett considers lilacs 'the chain 
letters of horticulture . . . you simply pried a 
rooted shoot from the base of a shrub and planted 
it somewhere else’,just as George Washington did 
at Mount Vernon. 

The major part of the book is devoted to 
growing lilacs including their place in the 
landscape (as specimen shrubs, in formal and 
informal groupings and in beds of perennials). 
There are pages on companion planting, hedging 
with lilacs, growing them in containers and as cut 
flowers. Most helpful is a comprehensive listing 
of the common cultivars as well as more 
uncommon varieties ‘for the connoisseur’. 

Well-indexed and enticingly illustrated 
the book makes pleasurable reading. It lists mail¬ 
order nurseries and public collections, albeit 
American. The web-sites given include 
minv.lilacs.-freescrvers.com for the International Lilac 
Society and www.lewisriver.-com/lilacs.html, a 
somewhat folksy site introducing the Hulda 
Klager Lilac Gardens. 

People and Plants 
A History of Gardening in Victoria 
Mary Ellis 2003 
Distribution: Mary Ellis 
P.O. Box 67, Fish Creek,Victoria 3959 
ISBN 0 975033 40 9 
$48 plus $7 p & p 

Reviewed by Nina Crone 

Mary Ellis uses an interesting method of 
arranging material gathered during six years of 
research into Victoria’s garden history. 
Throughout her book people and places are 
associated with particular plants. The birthplace 
ofVictorian horticulture, Churchill Island, leads 
to Araucaria lieterophylla (Norfolk Island Pine) and 
Melaleuca, notably M. lanceolata (Moonah), the 
biographical note on Alex Jessep prompts 
consideration of camellias, Clement Hodgkinson 
is followed by a discussion of elms Jean Galbraith 
heralds Correa and so on. Although this 
framework takes some getting used to, it proves 




an effective means of linking 
seemingly disparate material. 

Inevitably some readers 
will ponder the inclusions and 
exclusions. Why is Margaret 
Stones not given equal weight 
with Ellis Rowan and Celia 
Rosser in the section on 
botanical artists, or Carl 
Nobelius not included with 
the Brunnings and Tesselaars 
in the chapter on the horti¬ 
cultural industry? The temp¬ 
tation to cross-reference Ellis’s 
material with the Oxford 
Companion to Australian Gardens 
is irresistible. Ellis includes 
additional subject matter 
pertinent to Victoria and her 
accounts of the ‘Eucy’ men, 

Maud Gibson, Moomba and 
the work of Lyle and Elvie 
Williams make enjoyable 
reading. There are some slight 
discrepancies between the two 
publications on the birth date 
of some people and fur¬ 
ther editing would have 
strengthened Ellis’s work. 

Compared with a lavishly 
illustrated coffee table book on 
a single subject - Leo 
Schofield’s The Garden at 
Bronte for instance - Plants and 
People is a ‘no frills’ publication 
and needs to find its own niche 
market. This niggled for a time 
as the writing is somewhat 
uneven and in parts too 
discursive, yet there is much 
valuable factual material and a 
warm humanity in the biographical essays. The 
quality of some photographs is poor but Pat 
Dale’s line drawings and those from Thompson’s 
Gardener’s Assistant, published in 1907,redeem the 
illustrations. 

Plants and People will prove an invaluable 
resource for secondary school VET and TAFE 
students of horticulture and associated studies. 
The language is direct and much of the material 
should appeal to the older adolescent. It could be 
a most useful textbook offering an excellent 
springboard for discussion on contemporary 
issues such as developing sustainable gardens, seed 
saving, hydroponics, roadside planting and plant 
variety rights, as well as giving an introduction to 
the fascinating subject ofVictoria’s garden history. 


Australian Garden History Vol . 15 No 1 July/August 2003 25 





ITF.M.S 


of INTEREST 


Notice of Annual General Meeting 

The 23rd Annual General Meeting of the 
Australian Garden History Society will be held in 
Mueller Hall at the Herbarium, Melbourne, on 
Monday 13 October 2003 at 7pm. 

Items for inclusion on the Agenda should be 
posted to the Secretary, Helen Page, c/- AGHS 
Office, Gate Lodge, 100 Birdwood Avenue, 
Melbourne, 3004 by 22 August 2003. Branches 
should also nominate their representative for the 
National Management Committee by this date 
and forward the name to Helen Page. 

There will be one vacancy on the National 
Management Committee. Current Chairman, 
Peter Watts, is standing down due to work 
commitments. Nominations to the National 
Management Committee open on 28 July and 
close on 2 September 2003. To obtain a 
nomination form contact Jackie Courmadias on 
03 9650 5043 or Toll Free 1800 678 446. 

Elections offer an opportunity for members to 
participate in the management of the Society. 
Each year the NMC holds three face-to-face, full- 
day meetings, which are interspersed by three 
meetings of one-hour duration via a telephone 
link-up. 

Elected members of the National Manage¬ 
ment Committee serve a 3-year term and are 



eligible for re-election for a maximum of one 
additional term of 3 years. An allowance, to assist 
with travel cost for meetings in Sydney and 
Melbourne, is available if required. 

E-commerce for AGHS 

One of the benefits of upgrading 
www.gardenhistorysociety.org.au is that the 
society has entered the world of e-commerce. 
As this will be a secure site, members will be able 
to subscribe or renew subscriptions, book for 
the annual national conference and purchase 
merchandising items on-line. Much more 
information is being added to the site. Abstracts 
of articles in past issues of the journal will be 
gradually added to the publication pages. 
Branch pages will have a similar format but will 
allow for individual arrangement and inclusion 
of material. The aim is to have a clear, 
informative and interactive site. 

Our valued packers 

Sincere thanks to Di Ellerton.Janc Johnson,John 
Joyce,Ann Miller, Sandi Pullman, Kaye and Mike 
Stokes and Sandra and John Torpey for their help 
in packing the last issue of the journal. 



IARY 



ATE S 


July 

16 Wednesday 

Victoria, East Melbourne — Working 
Bee at Bishopscourt Helen Page 
(03) 9397 2260. 

20 Sunday 

New South Wales, Rouse Hill Estate — 
Rose Pruning and Propagation 
Workshop. An intensive three-hour 
workshop to learn how to prune and 
grow modern and species roses. Enjoy 
a Devonshire tea with rose-hip jam 
and take home potted rose cuttings. 
Bring secateurs, a hat and sensible 
shoes. Cost: General $20, 
Concessions/Members $15. 
Bookings: (02) 9518 6866. 


26 Saturday & 27 Sunday 

Victoria, Castiemaine - Working Bees 
—Tute’s Cottage (Saturday- 
Vicroads 287 70) and Buda (Sunday 
—Vicroads 287 4Q). Helen Page 
(03) 9397 2260. 

27 Sunday 

Western Australia, Gosnells — AGM 
Day — a visit to a pioneer cemetery at 
Kenwick, lunch and AGM at Gosnells 
Hotel followed by a visit to the 
Wilkinson Homestead (formerly 
the Orange Tree Farm Museum) in 
Gosnells. 



August 

5 Tuesday 

Sydney & Northern NS W— AGM - 
7pm. Light refreshments will be 
available from 6pm, followed by a 
short meeting and election of office 
bearers at 7pm, and then an illustrated 
talk. Venue: History House, 133 
Macquarie Street, Sydney. No charge 
but please confirm you are attending 
with Malcolm Wilson on 
(02) 9810 7803. 

7 Thursday 

Victoria, Melbourne - AGM Victorian 
Branch at 7.15pm followed by a 
Lecture ‘The Getty Garden: the 
Garden, the Art Museum and the Death 
of Art’ given by Associate Professor 


26 Australian Garden History Vol. 15 No 1 July/August 2003 







David Marshall of the Art History 
Program of the School of Fine Arts, 
Classical Studies and Archaeology, 
University' of Melbourne. Venue: 
Mueller Hall, Birdwood Avenue 
South Yarn. Time: 8pm. Cost: $12 
($16 non-members). Helen Page (03) 
9397 2260. 

9 Saturday 

Tasmania, Launceston - 10.30am AGM 
and Guest Speaker GregLeong an 
international and local artist who will 
present an interesting insight on the 
‘Chinese Connection’. Venue: 
QueenVictoria Museum,Wellington 
Street, Launceston. Lunch will be 
followed by a visit to the corner of 
Charles and Canning Streets where 
stone from the Great Wall of China is 
incorporated into a seat and the 
footpath. Acceptances to Deidre 
Pearson (03) 6225 3084 and 
Monica Harris (03) 6331 3679. 

Sydney, Vaucluse House — Up the 
Garden Path —‘In the Fountain 
Garden with Dave’. From 9-11 am 
join Dave Gray and the Vaucluse 
House gardening team to dig up, 
design and replant a section of the 
circular flower bed around the 
fountain. Get some valuable tips 
while helping and enjoy a 
ploughman’s lunch afterwards.Cost: 
General $20, Concession/Members 
$15. Bookings (02) 9518 6866. 

10 Sunday 

Southern Highlands, Exeter - AGM 
and Speaker. Dr James Broadbcnt 
Will speak on ‘The “How and 
Why” of conserving and/or 
restoring an Historic Garden’. 
Time: Registration 10.30am 
followed by Lecture,AGM, Lunch and 
a Garden Visit. Venue: Exeter 
Community Hall. Further details 
from Ros Craig (02) 4862 2535 or 
Kate Madden (02) 4861 6845 


10 Sunday 

Sydney & Northern NS W, Harris Park 
(near Parramatta) Heritage Garden 
Tool Show. 10am-4pm at 
Experiment Farm Cottage. An 
exhibition of old tools, talks on their 
history and design, and maintenance 
workshops. Also house and garden 
tours, water divining and stalls selling 
quality tools, plants, books and food. 
Entry $10 ($5 for members and 
children). Held in association with the 
National Trust (NSW). For 
information contact Silas Clefford- 
Smith (02) 9569 3417 or Malcolm 
Wilson (02) 9810 7803. 

20 Wednesday 

Victoria, East Melbourne — Working 
Bee at Bishopscourt. Helen Page 
(03) 9397 2260. 

24 Sunday 

Friends of the Royal Botanic Gardens 
Cranbourne - Winter Lecture Day at 
the Frankston Fire Station (Melways 
102 D3). Dr Rachel Webster, 
astrophysicist, will speak about Global 
Warming and Climate Change: the 
local impact, and Doug Evans, author 
of Indigenous Plants of the Sandbelt 
will speak on the use of indigenous 
plants for domestic gardens. Cost 
(includes lunch) Members $18 Others 
$25. For bookings, phone 5990 2200. 

30-31 Saturday & Sunday 

Victoria, Birregurra — Working Bees at 
Mooleric (Saturday -Vicroads 92 6E) 
and Turkeith (Sunday-Vicroads 
92 6E). Helen Page (03) 9397 2260. 

September 

13 Saturday to 21 Sunday week 

Throughout New South Wales - History 
Week 2003:‘Minding the Past’ will 
explore the complex processes of 
remembering and forgetting, the fine 
balance of conserving, managing and 
accessing history, and the necessity' of 


engaging with the past for our future. 
Further information from Roslyn 
Burge on (02) 9385 1070 or on the 
web-site: 

www.historycouncilnsw.org.au. 

17 Wednesday 

Victoria, East Melbourne - Working 
Bee at Bishopscourt. Helen Page 
(03) 9397 2260. 

Victoria, Melbourne — Edna Walling 
Forum - See AGHS web-site and 
Letter toVictorian Members. Helen 
Page (03) 9397 2260. 

27 Saturday 

Victoria, Bulla — Working Bee at 
Glenara (Melways 177 C9). Helen 
Page (03) 9397 2260. 

Advance Notice 
October 

5 Sunday 

Victoria, Colac & Birregurra — Mooleric 
and Turkeith - a visit to these two 
great Guilfoyle gardens.Travel by car, 
meeting at the Colac Botanic Gardens 
at 9.00am. Further details Helen Page 
(03) 9397 2260. 

13 Monday 

Victoria, Melbourne National AGM 
7.00pm, followed by a Lecture ‘ Walter 
and Marion Burley Griffin and their 
Melbourne Influences' given by 
Christopher Vernon from the 
Faculty of Landscape andVisual Arts, 
University ofWestern Australia. 
Venue: Mueller Hall, South Yarn. 
Time: 8pm. Cost $12 ($16 non¬ 
members). Details: Helen Page (03) 
9397 2260. 



Australian Garden History Vot. 15 No 1 July /August 2003 27 










I n the past 76 years,’Mawarra’ has only 
changed owemship twice. 

Described by Edna Walling as a ‘symphony of 
steps and trees’, the majority of the gardens at 
‘Mawarra’ remain as they were when Edna 
designed them in 1927. 

‘Mawarra’ has never been open to the general 
public. Privacy and seclusion have been the 
priorities of the previous owners. But now, for 
those who understand the essence of an old 
garden and the magical qualities that lie within, 
‘Mawarra’s’ new owner, Mr. Jess Exiner has 
opened a ‘Garden Stay’. 


He and his partner, Jonathan Seares, offer an unforgettable ‘Garden Experience’ where their guests are 
invited to indulge in some of the pleasures that living on a property like ‘Mawarra’ can provide. 


© Explore inner tranquillity around the reflection pond with a cognac or a cup of camomile tea. 

© Spend time reading many of the 1st edition books by Edna Walling whilst reclining on one of the 
‘daybeds’ in the Manor House library. 

© Take gentle exercise in ‘Mawarra’s’ indoor heated swimming pool. 


As one would expect, only two parties of guests are accommodated on ‘Mawarra’ at any one time 
in either 


‘Wendy’s Cottage’ 

Designed as a child’s playhouse in the 
early 1930s, ‘Wendy’s Cottage’ was 
styled on ‘The Little House’ at Royal 
Lodge for the Princesses Elizabeth and 
Margaret. It is now a fully self-contained 
cottage for only two adults. 

or 

‘The Lodge’ 

A1917 Arts & Crafts style home on 
3 acres of parkland which has become 
an extension of the land held by 
‘Mawarra’. 



For bookings and further information on ‘Mawarra’ and our ‘Garden Stay’ please contact Jess Exiner or Jonathan Seares. 

Telephone ( 03 ) 9755 - 2456 Fax ( 03 ) 9755-1969 

[Advertisement] Email int '°@ raawarra - net - au Print Post No. 34584/0016