Skip to main content

Full text of "European plants in peril: a review of threatened plants in the European Community"

See other formats


oy the 


hs 


WORLD CONSERVA 


. 


N 


% 


Le 
ay aa 
oe f 


EUROPEAN PLANTS IN PERIL 


A Review of Threatened Plants in the 
EUROPEAN COMMUNITY 


Compiled by the 
WORLD CONSERVATION MONITORING CENTRE 


1989 


Prepared with financial support from the 
European Commission, Brussels 
and the 
Council of Europe, Strasbourg 


Digitized by the Internet Archive 
in 2010 with funding from 
UNEP-WCMC, Cambridge 


http://www.archive.org/details/europeanplantsin89wcmc 


WORLD CONSERVATION MONITORING CENTRE 


The World Conservation Monitoring Centre (WCMC) was formerty the 
Conservation Monitoring Centre of the International Union for Conser- 
vation of Nature (IUCN ). Today, it is a joint venture between the three 
partners in the World Conservation Strategy: IUCN —The World Con- 
servation Union, WWF — the World Wide Fund for Nature, and UNEP 
— the United Nations Environment Programme. Its mission is to sup- 

~~ port conservation and sustainable development through the provision 
fa 5 of information on the world’s biological diversity. Major IUCN publica- 
bl tions prepared in close collaboration with WCMC include tne IUCN 
Red Data Books and IUCN Protected Areas Directories. 


For more information about WCMC please write to: 


The Information Officer 

World Conservation Monitoring Centre 
219c Huntingdon Road 

Cambridge CB3 ODL, UK 


© World Conservation Monitoring Centre 


Text compiled by Sue Everett, Christine Leon and John Akeroyd 


Camera-ready copy by Tne Nature Conservation Bureau, 
122 Derwent Road 
Thatcham RG13 4UP, UK 


Cover illustration Primula allionii, a threatened plant found only in 
ftaly and France 


The views expressed in this document by the authors do not necessarily refiect tnose of IUCN, WWF, UNEP 
or other participating organtsations. The designation of geographical entities in this document, and the 
presentation of tne material, do not imply the expression of any opinion whatsoever on the part of IUCN, WWF, 
UNEP or other participating organisations concerning the legal status of any country, termory or area, or of 
tts authorities, or conceming the delimitation of its frontiers or boundaries. 


i 
my Pf: 
af uA) 

pr 


Biv SiiaeM KorrayNatro aso 


ght yherrnal coe GROW) ere? —s Hd Kaoecmenad ny eat 


eee gl redid immer) uM Ka see Qeiye rene) 

_ oe pean a Tae een” i Woun nase ‘3. Out 

bt Pca is. artic Dea 
mg DRM 2 nowt dienes 


caoaune! SPENT Racer ee Det ew 


| x cope spie Aira a bes joes canes 105 
BE = hy orale vig 
[ , Site Ry IeeS seis 7 bros moe j 


paren ple eee A Feet WO es pico ois we 


Pediatrie ins noterceird sow W?t 


yn () catia pby 


Bima) giintne 10 =/reril) agaee ayy Z 


sas | \eogQrere 
A) JCS “a? ene 


Stil Ors ferns 


pmoal eS see 3 awe 
i cathe genes oat! 
it aueion eerie 


rae ee. 
rar Ge yes. 


CONTENTS 


Page 
Acknowledgements iv 
The Authors iv 
Foreword Vv 
Introduction vi 
Key to Symbols xiii 
Plant Species Conservation Summaries 
Higher Plants 1 
Lower Plants 49 


Index 52 


ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS 


The production of this report would not have been possible without the help 
of many botanists and conservationists throughout Europe. To all those 
who have contributed we extend our grateful thanks. In particular, we wish 
to thank: 
D and Z Bramwell, P Creed, T Curtis, P Devillers, L Farrell, M Fernandez 
Molina, S Gardner, C Gomez-Campo, P Goriup, | Hepburn, V Heywood, 
C Jermy, S Jury, M King, A Machado, J V Malato-Beliz, V Morgan, D Phitos, 
S$ Pignatti, R Press, T Rich, R Schumacker, E Sérusiaux, W T Stearn, A Strid, 
H Synge, J Willison. 

We are equally indebted to the staff of the Royal Botanic Gardens, 
Kew, particularly the library staff, and J Cowley, K Ferguson, M Fothergill, 
B Mathew, E Nic Lughada and D Pegler. 


Thanks also go to colleagues in the Threatened Plants Unit of WCMC, 
particularly Judith Sheppard for her secretarial support, as well as Steve 
@vis and Robert Madams. 


The research done for this document has greatly benefitted from a 
co ‘current project being undertaken for the Council of Europe to revise 
Ai:..endix | of the Berne Convention. 


THE AUTHORS 


Sis Everett has been deeply involved in plant conservation projects for 
m.ny years. She served as Chairperson o* the British Association of Nature 
Curiservationists between 1985 and 1987 and most recently helped to 
dev2lop and taunch Plantlife, a new voluntary body devoted to plant conser- 
vation. She is currently a Director of the Nature Conservation Bureau. 


Christine Leon has been managing the Threatened Plants Unit of WCMC 
sinu2 January 1988 and has almost ten years experience with IUCN 
pro:ioting plant conservation in Europe and developing a data base of 
Eur. 9e’s threatened plants. She has prepared the Council of Europe's List 
of R::re, Threatened and Endemic Plants in Europe published in 1983 and is 
a joint author of a recent reference work entitled Plants in Danger: What Do 
We !‘now? published by IUCN. 


John Akeroyd is a freelance botanist who was formerly revising Volume | of 
Flora Europaea. He has travelled widely in the Mediterranean region and 
has published over fifty papers on its flora. 


aTAam 1otacwvous 


Sel aaiales ‘linidipund ype nr Wr eter jet to wotsdianeantt 
ee SewE ‘Maoiyect Rare eer ne aearn } a 
| ee ue AEE hoes) 0 trishm: aw Demcwo evenlionit: 
- sat? etl’) gates site T al | wena Ste 
(eee ae eerie ord ne® > ow a @ zal 

My e amereanee V2. oss ret aM chy @ oma 
ee oe VT WN leaden B.wekc 9." 8S T aT ea 


wa - pt UF va 'SintO8 Seo eit tare vl! 1 Dextehen (fale oa ai 

fore? iA. 28) SM amie A yrabines) L, te Nheesa stsulers oat yal eae 

ss ’ 4 ; a nite anew 

7 a & ae MDW fens ‘9 poopius? sdb iharpie mn wl ag Cue ' Pie NES 
RE. oe babe meaner peony °°" 


a. a 3 
Gian —* view der WasrGah sk ~~! aah 
. pate a Y) alive on 


2008814 SIT 


on & Beye econ ae am 
7 a 4 p> ara ht IVR 8 
Oe bn 5 fil 


FOREWORD 
Professor Vernon H Heywood* 


The European Community is rich in plant life. Within its frontiers it houses 
some of the world's most spectacular habitats and rich assemblages of 
plant species. Unfortunately many of these habitats have been encroached 
upon by the unrelenting march of human activity over the centuries. Indeed, 
many of the landscapes in the European Community are an artificial conse- 
quence of deforestation, agriculture (both small and large scale) and other 
changing kinds of land use. In recent years, reafforestation by exotic 
species not only changes the traditional landscape but diminishes the plant 
diversity. 


This booklet draws attention to the problems of habitat loss or degradation 
within the territory of the European Community and presents a selection of 
those plant species which are, as a consequence, under threat. It explains 
in uncomplicated language the nature of the different kinds of threat and 
gives an outline of the measures that are needed to ensure the conservation 
of the plant species that are at risk. 


Although only a small sample of the European Community's approximately 
2,000 threatened plants are covered by this bookiet, it will, | believe, serve 
its purpose in focusing the attention of the responsible authorities and 
decision-makers on the urgent need to conserve habitats and with them 
plant species threatened throughout the Community. If we are not to suffer 
further losses of our natural heritage, powerful instruments like the pro- 
posed ‘Habitats Directive’ will be needed. 


All those who have been involved in the compilation of this booklet are to be 
congratulated on producing such an urgent and persuasive publication. 


*Chief Scientist, Plant Conservation 
IUCN — The Word Conservation Union 
The IUCN Plants Office 

Kew, England, UK 


INTRODUCTION 


This booklet covers a small, though representa- 
tive, sample of the 343 plant species which have 


cies are themselves only a fraction of the total of at 
least 2,000 threatened higher plants found in the 
European Community. Unfortunately, the informa- 
tion available for the far more numerous lower 
plants was not sufficient to prepare a similar range 
of species accounts as has been done for 50 or so 
higher plants included in this booklet. Neverthe- 
less, a short section on lower plants has been in- 
cluded to draw attention to their particular needs 
which are no less urgent than those of higher 
plants. 

Each species account in the booklet aims to 
provide the reader with a ‘flavour’ of the types of 
species which are threatened, the range of threats 


Plants of the European Community 


Tne European Community is estimated to contain 
between 9,000 and 10,000 species of ‘higher’ plants. 
These are plants with vascular systems, and include 
herbaceous plants, grasses, ferns, sedges, rushes 
and trees. Today, in north-west Europe, It is an 
unusual event for a new species to be discovered - 
the floras of countries such as the Netherlands, Brit- 
ain and Denmark are very well known and not par- 
ticularly high in species (Figure 1). In contrast, the 
fioras of the southern states, particularly Spain and 
Greece, are less well known, are much richer in spe- 
cies, and new species continue to be discovered. 
The Community contains about 4% of the world’s 
250,000 higher plants. Some of these species have 
tiny populations, often confined to only one or two 
Member States (Figure 2). 

The conservation needs of lower plants are often 
forgotten. The lower plants include algae, fungi, 
lichens, mosses and liverworts. Relatively few scien- 
tists are interested in them compared to the higher 
plants, yet they play a very important role within 


been proposed for listing on Annex 1b of the pro- measures which are needed to protect them. 
posed ‘Habitats Directive’. Even these 343 spe- Maps showing the general distribution of each 


vi 


posed by damage and destruction of their habi- 


tats, and an indication of broad conservation 


species are also shown. These, unless otherwise 
stated, do not show individual localities or their 
surface area, more the general location of one or 
more sites. 

Most of the plants described herein are glob- 
ally Endangered or Vulnerable as well as being 
threatened within the Community's own territory. 
The Community therefore has as much a special 
responsibility to ensure their conservation as have 
the countries supporting tropical rain forests to 
conserve their diminishing plant resources. As 
threats mount from every quarter, as ranges de- 
cline and numbers grow fewer, the future flora of 
Europe looks increasingly forlorn. 


natural and seminatural ecosystems and many are 
important to humans. For example, seaweeds and 
fungi are still eaten throughout the Community and 
lichens are of increasing interest due to their relative 
sensitivity to air pollution: some are important indi- 
cators of atmospheric quality. There are far more 
lower plants in Europe than higher plants - perhaps 
as many as 50,000 species! Though Red Data Books 
and Red Lists are being drafted for some groups of 
lower plants, at present there is practically no infor- 
mation for many groups and it is not yet possible to 
assign conservation priorities or develop conserva- 
tion strategies for them. 


Threats to Plants of the European Community 


The main threat to European plants is the loss or 
degradation of their habitat. In northem Europe. 
there has been a dramatic decline of most natural 
and seminatural habitats over the past 40 years or 
so. Much of this damage and destruction has oc- 
curred in recent years as an indirect consequence 
of Community policies, notably the financial encour- 


nomoucoxTus 


ae ery ore me 


as tered, anvils vo teens <steatiGe: Veli! lema « swe er 


4 

: pa = aE TAIN aSICR, tedy |: ont 'o perins| 
eS , ail 10 off wanna HO gira cor beeogayied 

oS Seni fav3 . awiteed a 4 

. OMS switeet B (oe ena m.} 

aig Sty Cerecemett OOOS mag) 

Tit are. irene | 


Teer Hon oat et ocalent pe 


| 
: - ; : , » mie Of ints Pash fon eae 2 hh i 
EI»: D 7 Y a iS 
ba % , 3 hee) aart ' : 
- ore Ta “ oon es Nem) sar! Fo SrVOmRE “4 2% 
ia ee DW fillgod weir (i Dobe ag 
- yy hp-0) preity rales ais owl eg i" Sos i mpl ent ie 
o prone spit Te fl 
ind Set usr ot weber gietimg vere os pation acl 
; 7 — a 2 fe 4 Os bP “ 7 <a D tndhal & 
| BRE plea IY WL ot oo) ag et on. we 
} P ert ty iy i 
GP WuNONE gid -! ite! ol fovea egies 
wi Vechres? fie aie: we Neovel’ 4 iy : 
i 7 z wy at 7 
is ee ane he : Sores ott bere eam 2 
- Seer. cossaioas Jes ; 
F Sane i" A See, 
: ; _ wi _ ay 
' a 7 : 
- 
7 i 
4 
nua. ¥ Wellin 
i a ut 
h unt 7 | w 
7 - _ led Day rate a 
} ae Das ee Ot 7 
; a <a 7-3 4 searing iy ug oe ee 
r ‘ . “4 PRS pawy ie 
Be ~ = A , J aT : " 
’ Woot ; 
? hier 
> — 9 > ew 
, me j 
ee , une = nae 
| 
mi ied & OR, 
‘ a t ) ‘- 
ia oe 
7 ys 7 . : 0 ay 2 ah aad 5 r 
_ ite. Poely 7] ~< - _ = 
eh —_ ip : - ii a Pa i 
2 Ly J. eae! Tet J oo = | , oo 
iat a wrige o : 
i. “ in oe oe ; : aa — . " i ih a : 
i, eT ee pe > ee ee. 
- ~ i oe : : 
ap tan b a Z - Ca. — 7 
; 7 7 j 
a j al - = 
e ; ' 
7 _ SG 


2 


Ys 


— 


a 
\\\\ 


oe 


merg- = a 
—o Tn 


ss 
<= 


— 


Ss 


Ve 


AQAA KG 


Webb, DA 1978 Flora Euopaea: a retrospect. Taxon: 27(1): 3-14. 


Figure 1: Numbers of native plant species in Member States and islands of the European Community. 
Sources: Davis et a/. 1986 Plants in Danger: What do We Know? |UCN, Cambridge. 


vii 


species 


8 
F 
a 


Figure 2: Numbers of endemic plants in Members States and islands of the European Community. 


Source: WCMC, 1989. 


viii 


| 


No. of 
species 


-=/] 


Madeira 


Figure 3: Numbers of Endangered (E), Vulnerable (V) and Rare (R) plants (on a European scale) in 
Member States and islands of the European Community. 


Note: Only plant species threatened throughout their entire European distribution are represented. 
Source: WCMC, 1989. 


agement provided to farmers for increasing the area 
under crop production through the Common Agri- 
cultural Policy. Community funding for commercial 
forestry projects, such as the planting of conifers on 
Irish peat bogs and the planting of Eucalyptus on a 
massive scale in the Mediterranean region and Por- 
tugal, are more recent problems which are causing 
losses of important plant habitats in parts of Europe. 

Many of the Community's threatened plant spe- 
cies (Figure 3) are found in coastal areas in the 
Mediterranean or in attractive mountain regions. 
Such areas are under immense pressure from tour- 
ist developments. The construction of holiday flats, 
hotels and chalets, sometimes supported with funds 
from the Community's Integrated Mediterranean 
Programme, destroys important plant habitats. 
Piants and their habitats also suffer due to the in- 
creased accessibility of formerly remote areas fol- 
lowing tourism developments: fragile sand dune 
areas are trampled and sensitive mountain slopes 
are cleared of vegetation for ski-pistes. This booklet 
gives several examples of plants which are threat- 
ened by tourism including Curied Alkanet (Anchusa 
crispa), Savona Harebell (Campanula sabatia) and 
Sardinian Knapweed (Centaurea horrida). 

The widespread problem of pollution has de- 
graded many freshwaters in the Community with the 
result that formerly common water plants have dis- 
apoeared from many rivers and lakes. The Pillwort 
Fern (Pilularia globulifera) and Floating Water-plan- 
tain (Luronium nutans) have both significantly de- 
clined owing to eutrophication (nutrient enrichment) 
of pools and takes. The Pillwort, which has its most 
important strongholds in Britain, is now considered 
a VYuinerable plant in the European Community. 


The European Community’s Threatened Plants 


Over the last 10 years, the Threatened Plants Unit of 
WCMC has developed a data base containing no 
less than 2,000 plant species under threat through- 
out the European Community. However, criteria for 
Annex Ib of the ‘Habitats Directive’ specify that, for 
higher plants, only those in the IUCN categories ‘En- 
dangered’ or ‘Vulnerable’ (see below) at a European 
lev:l may qualify for listing on it. With the help of 
botanists and conservationists from Member States, 


those of the 2,000 threatened species meet ~_ 
criteria have now been identified and proto, s 
listing in Annex Ib of the ‘Habitats Directive 7 

The definitions for all IUCN Red Data ca:=~ | = 
are available from the Threatened Placcs 
WCMC, 53 The Green, Kew, Middx, TW9 3A-~ 


Endangered species 


According to IUCN, Endangered species @7= -- 
which are “in danger of extinction and wncs= 
vival is unlikely if the causal factors continue =~. ., 
ing. Included are taxa whose numbers h@-= =..,,, 
reduced to a critical level or whose habre= ~.,,, 
been so drastically reduced that they are GO&¢S—~=-> ,,, 
be in immediate danger of extinction.” 
Many Endangered plants have probabr:. 

been very common and they tend to be resi™§ === 
tiny areas of land. Many rare endemic specics = v1 
Mediterranean countries like Greece and Itai 
into this category, including the Mount Killin. =~=2, 


sy 


Deer 


Seah) 


ant's-eye (Adonis cyllenea) and the Sé=—.an 
Gooseberry (Ribes sardoum). Because © 2re 
geographically restricted, the pressures CT <= elr 
habitat mean that there is a very real possi=~- of 


their becoming Extinct in the near future. O<">2"- 


ing their habitat, therefore, is essential Th —n- 
agement of these tiny sites through Specie! ears 
tion Areas is very likely to be quite straight t<"+="0 
Thus many Endangered plants could be p°=-==-2d 
fairly simply and for relatively small cost 

A number of Endangered plants were 0N7= ~ >' 
numerous, but never widespread. These h@-= Sut. 
fered declines almost to the point of extinct.o7 Dw- 
ing to the deterioration and destruction © -~®!" 
habitats. The Brittany Eryngo (Eryngium vivic2-7), 
for instance, has declined because of drairzz= Of 


damp pastures and, in some localities, co2sé> =~ i 
grazing. The Brittany Eryngo is a good exumy2 > 4 
ge nr 


species which requires active management - a 
sure its survival, as it has become assoclat== nae 
traditional grazing and stock-keeping practice: zn 


cannot survive under modem land use syste™= 


Vulnerable species 


IUCN has defined Vulnerable species as thosé vmich 
are “believed likely to move into the ‘Endangered 


oem te + anak anime 


Bing & eae sagt . 
aig a - Te ee oa 7 


SE eke a eS ot 


ae ecg 2 - it~ 
iy yon eyed ne 
_ 7h Gt ot mb wie one cetdet See a 


fare Oi) Orns ki) neem! of pooh KLE 
WGA MoD al) Ha noe “rq qord tat 
Mary SP oribewt born) bie 

WO tetas Ss Gril) wil! an oud : 


076 HeKNiPaLs gers et Ge aod aE 
ACF butt tome? /inorermitibe | wa alege) 


~ Crh ad foie eneidicns “ecm noes 


wey rneD too Mbt My seaslete| rosa ceil 
wed trict CoavaineTes a" yen yetuerneR ot! & nah 


it A Wrenn Maen ot oct we © 


Onires mis 2 Oe 

ET el, oracom Ot om 

A RA No nekoucceos wT ae 
CGT Aw Bepagyc eqceterios & 


category in the near future if the causal factors 
continue operating. Included are taxa of which most 
or all of the populations are decreasing because of 
over-exploitation, extensive destruction of habitat 
or other environmental disturbance, taxa with popu- 
lations that have been seriously depleted and whose 
ultimate security is not yet assured, and taxa with 
populations that are still abundamt but under threat 
from serious adverse factors throughout their 
range.” 

Vulnerable plants are chiefly found in threatened 
semi-natural and natural habitats like sand dunes, 
wetlands and ancient forests. Examples include the 
Bristle Ferm (Trichomanes speciosum) and Bog 
Orchid (Hammarbya paludosa). In general, Vulner- 
able plants would enjoy the greatest benefits from 
measures to protect, restore and enhance habitats. 


Endemic Plants in the European Community 


A significant feature of the European flora is the 
large number of endemic species which have al- 
ways been recognised as a prionty for conservation 
action. In particular, so-called ‘point endemics’ 
(species confined to a single locality or several adja- 
cent sites), are characteristic of the mountain ranges 
of central and southern Europe (e.g. the Sierra 
Nevada of Spain), stretches of the Mediterranean 
coast (e.g. Greece) and some islands (e.g. Crete). 
Where many endemic plants grow together, for 
example in north-west Sardinia and in the Gen- 
Nargentu mountains of east-central Sardinia, they 
form a ‘centre of endemism’. These centres are ob- 
vious first targets for designation as Special Protec- 
tion Areas under the proposed ‘Habitats Directive’. 


The Atlantic Islands 


Due to their remote situation and ancient volcanic 
origin, the Atlantic islands (Canary Isles, Azores and 
Madeira) support a flora so distinct from that of con- 
tinental Europe that they comprise their own botani- 
cal region. Indeed, there are so many endemic spe- 
cies in the islands that they provide one of the 
world’s best demonstrations of evolutionary proc- 
esses. Of special importance are the remaining up- 
land laurel ‘cloud’ forests (‘laurisilva’) that harbour 
many threatened endemic plants. 


xi 


Measures Needed to Protect Threatened Plants 


Conserving the Habitats of Threatened Species 


There are a number of relatively simple measures 
that individual Member States can take in order to 
secure the future of threatened plants. 

For species restricted to a few smail localities, it 
should be possible to establish suitable protected 
areas with full protection against any potentially 
damaging impacts. In coastal areas, for instance, 
public access may have to be restricted or carefully 
guided to reduce the effects of trampling. Else- 
where, the continuation of traditional land use prac- 
tices such as grazing, buming and low-yield rota- 
tional crop production may be necessary. Enforce- 
ment of special protection and management meas- 
ures like these demands trained staff who will be 
responsible for organising effective site manage- 
ment, liaising with local people, monitoring the 
threatened plants and carrying out other essential 
conservation work. 

In some areas, habitat restoration could be 
undertaken. For exampie, some former French lo- 
calities for Shore Dock (Rumex rupestris) have 
become invaded by the alien Hottentot Fig (Car- 
pobrotus edulis) whose clearance from coastal 
areas could result in the restoration of suitable habi- 
tat for the dock - a plant that has declined over much 
of its European range. 

Of course, for those species that may still be 
relatively widespread even if in continuous decline, 
it will not be feasible for Member States to designate 
all localities for such species as protected areas. 
Nevertheless, complementary measures relating to 
operation of general land use policy and practices in 
selected areas (perhaps designated as Environmen- 
tally Sensitive Areas under the Agricultural Struc- 
tures Directive) can be instituted. Thus, potentially 
damaging projects proposed in or near localities for 
a listed species, including agricultural intensifica- 
tion, tourist development or commercial forestry 
would be diverted. 


Proposal for an EC Council ‘Habitats Directive’ 


It is the loss of plant habitats rather than picking or 
uprooting that poses the major threat to most plant 


tatietetAT nek of Hebei eweeeet epee! Ieateo ot) veital us ; ropa | 
7 : 7 Son (iw pet behure: ooiesoe suctnbl 
; rye $e a CM ert QempuerA Fo wid priest oo! naTWUQo alt a 
on Pe werin «9 et Se BW Serie a wiete note; 
Se NW Se! wore ol > deere one Me 
wack INLD MoM gis! im! Mens niggyl gusle 
iw Wiel ing Ges 


Actos @ termine sh ni Wales vanes #7 
DN ap anil ans MOE ree wR exotic orm 
Sion Minions caMNUENED aa griontw Wi Hout eerme Si) om be 
sian eta J 9S Sa isis: sere stat} or 
nn ‘ : mw dnlerep nf tere ogee) 
AON! Gori takai 8 ne OluOle ae 
68d equi! te oe ee oe y 


Pin OD Netaou? ect A ies | 
> am a oat GGG), S aif w eh) 2 
vy) “ SR phen gersveme civiios G i 
" . Pe to? yin i & On ix@innggt 
(Sapne - ik) eee owning ne 


pi Weve vo yale! ale 2 or one 

AGN pribgs cor tes te ae 

pond $y) “we mene ae oe 
1% deol naatiel 


species. Sadly, few Member States have laws to 
conserve the habitats or sites of threatened species, 
although most have passed unenforceable laws or 
decrees listing them as ‘protected’ from collection, 
picking or uprooting. Measures to protect habitats 
and sites for threatened species would be far more 
effective, and the existence of a European Council 
Directive on habitat protection would serve to en- 
courage the development of and bolster national 
legislation in this regard. 

This is where the “Proposal for a Council Direc- 
tive on the protection of natural and semi-natural 
habitats of wild flora and fauna” of 21 September 
1988 breaks new ground: Annex 1b of this proposed 
Directive would oblige Member States of the Com- 
munity to protect the habitats of listed plants by 
designating appropriate Special Protection Areas 
SO as “to ensure the maintenance of the species 


xii 


specified ... at a satisfactory level in all regions 
where they occur’. 

The protection afforded to threatened plants 
through the implementation of Annex 1b of the pro- 
posed Directive would provide a much-needed 
boost and encouragement to Member States to 
pursue the protection of threatened plant habitats. It 
is also hoped that practical help in the form of funds 
to help protect specific threatened plant localities 
will be made available, thus making resources pos- 
sible to those Member States which have particular 
responsibilities for plant conservation according to 
Annex 1b. The implications of this Directive for pro- 
moting rural employment, whether directly for site 
management, or indirectly from low intensity coun- 
tryside recreation, and maintaining rural cultures 
should not be underestimated. 


” 


* sabiaiens a ee 
Tie. is 7 sai Tir hie , _ Doves spate 


& 
f, 
if 
oe 
a 
=< th 
. 
4 é 4 ¢ za 7 & 
7 = 
T > - 7 
" . 
7 1 
aA - 7 7 
- = 7 of 
: = esl 
Y)- b; 7 ~ 4 = 
. ,_G = <_— Cre 
t ont S e na 7 > q act =, 
a Pier ts i Sr 7 
, ‘ ie i "ah 7 
= 4 fy: 


Quick reference key 


1: Habitats of Threatened European Plants 


MOUNTAINS 
Vy 


\ WETLAND: Bogs, marshes, 
GRASSLAND and PASTURE floodiands, saltmarshes., 
\F 


=~ 
—= 


hc | COASTLAND: Sand dunes, shorelines 
& and intertidal areas, other habitats 
as | 


near the sea. 


CLIFFS, ROCKY AREAS, SCREES RIVER BANKS, RIVERS, STREAMS. 


SCRUB, including MAQUIS and 
GARRIQUE (spiny shrubland 
characteristic to the Mediterranean WM SIC IstSSIL ane wile tel) 


Region) 


2: Threat status of plants in the European Community 


Threatened at World level (and 
consequently also threatened in 
the European Community) 


Threatened in the European 
Community (not threatened at 
World Level) 


E IUCN Category: ENDANGERED V IUCN Category: VULNERABLE 
Endangered species are those Vulnerable species are those 
in danger of extinction i.e. believed likely to move into the 
whose survival is unlikely if the ‘Endangered’ category in the 
causal threat factors continue near future if the causal factors 


operating. continue operating. 


xiii 


N 
7 


re 


AX 
AY 


EN 


3: Threats to plants of the European Community 


TOURISM: Development of tourist 
complexes, trampling of vegetation 
by tourists and other tourist-related 
disturbances 


BUILDING CONSTRUCTION: 
Associated with urban, industrial and 
tourism development 


FIRE: Usually associated with tourist 
pressures or ‘management’ of 
vegetation for grazing purposes. 


OVERGRAZING: High stocking levels, 
causing destruction of vegetation, 
and in extreme cases, erosion 


LAND DRAINAGE: Usually associated 
with reclamation of land for intensive 
agriculture 


INTENSIVE AGRICULTURE: 


Including cultivation, land recdamation, 
and use of fertilisers 


USE OF HERBICIDES (weedkillers) 


INTENSIVE FORESTRY, including 
AFFORESTATION, the planting of 
non-native trees and various methods 
of intensive forest management 


PICKING, collecting, cutting or 
uprooting of plants . 


ra 
has 
a 
A 
Lag 


SKIING and disturbances associated 
with skiing, including bulldozing of 
vegetation for piste construction and 
erection of ski-lifts 


RECREATION, TRAMPLING and 
similar human disturbance 


QUARRYING, MINING 


DEFORESTATION 


INDUSTRIAL DEVELOPMENT 


REGULATION OF RIVERS: including 
straightening banks, clearance of 
bank-side vegetation and dredging 


AIR POLLUTION. including ACID 
RAIN 


WATER POLLUTION: from sewage, 
agricultural fertilisers, industry 


Vine thsqow 4dr Io eel on eagulT -£ 


nist te shoteqown Maen 
i Goliqnut! seglqnag 


ios 7 we a 


Wikbeansnie canemrtow SWIC 
iaabdicatuesdene ox amma 
Peaginevoh metas 


CONSERVATION SUMMARIES 


I; HIGHER PLANTS 


* ek 
” oa 
* * 
* * 

ky x 


A selection of threatened species from Annex I(b) of the 
"Proposal for a Council Directive on the protection 
of natural and semi-natural habitats and of wild fauna and flora" 


251A MIMS2 MOTT AV AS2K!0> 
. )BYMAIT SAROI :1 
az: _ 


Ps _ y's 
a 


_ wy an 
Cw, _ 7 
Z ) WE At... 
7 ot hd 7 ji 


® 
= * 
* 


© Mount Killini: Probably extinct 


® Mount Oligartos: Extant 


Mount Killini 
Pheasant’s-eye 


Adonis cyllenea 
[Ranunculaceae: Buttercup family] 


Mount Killini Pheasant’s-eye is a perennial plant with 
handsome bright yellow flowers 2-3 cm across. 


Discovered in 1948 on Mount Killini in the north-east 
Peloponnese, Greece, it was feared extinct for most 
of this century but in 1977 a small colony was found 
on Mount Pamias in the Oligartos massif south of 
Killini. Another botanist found a few plants in the same 
area in 1984, growing ina damp meadow surrounded 
by forest of Greek Fir at 1,340 metres. 


Today the Mount Killini Pheasant's-eye is known from 
four small sites on Mount Oligartos, each consisting 
Of less than 25 plants. Here it grows in damp pasture 
between 1,200 and 1,800 metres altitude. Its preferred 
habitat is thought to be in semi-shade at the base of 
limestone rocks which remain moist throughout the 
summer. The species appears always to have been 
rare and its future survival is threatened by the over- 
grazing of its habitat by sheep and goats. Killiniis also 
subject to growing pressure from tourists who visit 
the mountain in increasing numbers for skiing, walk- 
ing and mountaineering. 


Conservation measures needed for the Pheasant'’s- 
eye will require at least partial exclusion of grazing 
animals from its fragile habitat. Such an attractive spe- 
cies also needs protection from pliant collectors. 


Fortunately the survival of the species in cultivation is 
secure because plants have been successtuly grown 
and propagated in botanic gardens. The priority is 
therefore to protect the natural habitat of the species 
and the surrounding area with a view to conserving 
the remaining wild plants, encouraging their increase 
and possibly introducing some artificially propagated 
plants in order to augment the tiny wild populations. 


Apennine Adonis 


Adonis distorta 
[Ranunculaceae: Buttercup family] 


This small plant with white, occasionally yellow, flow- 
ers, grows in high mountain areas of the Apennine 
Mountains in central Italy, where it is endemic. It is a 
‘pioneer of lime-rich soils, being able to colonise 
coarse gravel and other unstable rock even when 
there is almost no soil, providing there is a constant 
source of moisture. Its habitat is therefore mostly 
breccias and coarse gravels on northern mountain 
slopes near snowfields. 


The Apennine Adonis is a very useful plant, being of 
medicinal value. The whole plant is poisonous and is 
used as a substitute for foxglove (Digitalis) as a heart- 
regulator, and also as a diuretic and for inducing 
hypertension. The flowers are also much sought after 
by casual visitors. For these reasons, its harvest and 
trade are regulated by a Royal Decree of 1932 and 
subsequent Regional Laws. 


However, the main threat to the species is loss of its 
habitat. In recent times, it has declined because of 
road construction, the use of four-wheel drive vehicles 
and the development of ski resorts. The creation of ski 
slopes has senously altered its habitat , due to clearance 
of the natural vegetation and levelling of screes and 
mountain slopes. 


Some populations of this species are included in the 
Mount Sirente protected area but no protection has 
been specifically granted to the flora within this re- 
serve. 


So far, insufficient action has been taken to protect 
this threatened plant. Priorities for its conservation 
must include a full assessment of remaining popula- 
tions with prompt action taken to protect and manage 
key areas of habitat where the Apennine Adonis grows. 


Part of the Apennine Mountain range where Apennine 
Adonis occurs 


ainobé. onto 


—  BSVRETD aicupa 
viens! quotas .dreomcourehl 


WNEION . sth a a 
wi ceo clainwoo’ pet a os 
» DRA pidtebrs a 1 mete yuo rao. a 1 ae 
pets oe aera 
o fave vinci eldiin onl: Sra twa eatin 
el erat! ORIbimog 658 OF RARE ee ome 
srcloreylt 0) iediter' 20 ant p aot 
“Merinon no seven amines Ne aesow tly 
al bain 
Res) 
Sa Np. 


i? 7. : 
- j 
. 

« 

7 

- +4) 
i 
— 
a 
at 
o 
za 
- 
, 
7 ‘ 
t 
Gy» : 
‘ j ; 
ad v 
7 a 
5 
‘i 
7 ? 7 
pie one 


Sardinia 


restrictions Pié==c 9n public access 


Curled Alkanet 


Anchusa cCrispa 
[Bcresmaceae: Borage family] 


This very rare 2="~ grows in sand dunes near tne seq 


and occasionai-. miand at altitudes between Se€2+eve ' 
and 700 metres f usually grows amongst Maram 3 


Grass (Ammop/i2 arenaria) and Cotton-weed (Ozan- 
thus maritimus, . = ts endemic to Corsica and Sarcinia 
The few remairs-<3 iocalities in Corsica number ten at 
the most and ar¢ restricted to the southern enc o¢ tne 
island at Favoné. Sonifacio, Porto Vecchio anc a: tne 
mouth of the Frver Rizzanese. It is now extinc: at 
Santa Severa. 22D Corseand the beach at Portiglioic 
The only known: ses in Sardinia are onthe north-west 
coast at Golfo =aima, Capo Argentiera on La Nurra 
and Capo de! Fa:cone, and on the north coast near 
Porto Torrés, St2gno di Pilo and La Pelosa. 


On both islands. Surled Alkanet is greatly threatened 
by trampling of fs vulnerable sand dune habitat and 
by other activities associated with tourism, including 
seasonal beacn cieaning. Sand-quarrying also threat- 
ens the piant at one Sardinian locality. The growtn of 
coastal towns (iargely associated with tourism) is 
posing an increasing threat to this plant throughout rs 
range. 


Urgent consideration must be given to designating 
the remaining localities as nature reserves, with some 
restrictions placed on public access. 


Approximate area of distribution on Corsica 


Ze 


Atlantic Angelica 


Angelica heterocarpa 
[Umbelliferae:Carrot family] 


This plant is endemic to France, where it is restricted 
to scattered localities in the regions Loire-Atlantique, 
Charente-Maritime and Gironde-Dordogne. It grows 
in muddy areas along the banks of three tidal rivers 
and estuares on the Atlantic coast, often in beds of 
reea (Phragmites). 


Its habitats are particularly under threat in the estuary 
of the river Loire and in the Gironde-Dordogne region 
as a result of watercourse management and regula- 
tion. Such activities are reducing the amount of suit- 
able habitat for the Angelica through the destruction 
cf reedbeds and other areas of marginal vegetation. 


Cne locality for the Angelica is located in a nature re- 
serve which was established in 1983 over the Bruges 
Marshes near Bordeaux. This is one of the region’s 
last remaining wetlands, and was originally protected 
for its migratory birds. 


=rench botanists have recommended that all areas 
wwnere this rare and endangered plant grow should be 
Srctected, and that conservation of the plants and 
wiic!ife which inhabit these wetlands must take prior- 
ty cver development projects, financial and sporting 
nterests. 


2? Current distribution in this estuary uncertain. In 1961 
known from the banks of the rivers Gironde, Garonne 
and Dordogne and along banks of the canal in the 
region of Hure, Fontet, Castets, Barie. 


* 5 hy " 
SdllgenA sins 


PMB TaeN 3 


TY ak) Pees every! i 


COnMUsAT Re byt Sor iso! ctor ist madgeit 
\ We ait 5 PPA ary acetaray  }nitgen of at 
aniig th AAO Hots. Orie Sitis nS Satrigrpri)! By. i 
AT UN eernty te ene od) ore wenn vue a ai 
TOWER A AaiitS esO> A wt Caan oe 


i ong 0 


Wistigewein! ime oles. ocd faery 
TY Sema ar Clee nics, Bem a) te 
“ahem Daye. ive eee 7) Gece ode 
iia totes We Oars) OL ey 
araiiscnheut arty MguicnG aodosns eth at 
it ReB IN eri cen k wicar TUK) tree aagl 


5. Petite i.e bems0! 6) ood nora a 


ania Ne (20 Balt Ai art es Me now rig 
RO a a © 27 ma rg wee 
TERRE Roni “ow tats 2p 

Bes tiir 


i, 


= Bo katt eubartnerc sue) av aly =e 
: Ny Pvt evvinpeortasreag 

. beer ervhtyy a i eigen meth toal 
ae Be a niean isles saied sea if 


ria! never 


® Astragalus aquilanus 
‘0 Astragalus maritimus 
S Astragalus verrucosus 


Endemic Italian 


milk-vetches 
Astragalus spp. 


[Leguminosae: Pea family] 


Three milk-vetches which are endemic to Italy are 
Endangered both at European and world level. As yet, 
no localities for these species are subject to habitat 
protection measures. 


Astragalus aquilanus: This milk-vetch grows in grassy 
glades and in the edges of upland pine forest (altitude 
800-1,000 metres) at four localities within 2-3 square 
kilometres of each other at Pineta di Roio near the 
town of L’Aquila (Abruzzo, central Italy). The area 
where the milk-vetch grows is easily accessible due to 
the proximity of a good road and it is also close to the 
town. Consequently, the pine forest habitat of the 
Pineta di Roio suffers from heavy recreational use. 
Many sections of the forest undergrowth have disap- 
peared asa resultt, and the area is subject to dumping 
of rubbish. 


Although the Pineta di Roio is municipal land, it is 
insufficiently protected. Action is particularly required 
to control visitor access. 


Astragalus maritimus: Known from only one locality 
on the Isola di San Pietro, an islet off southwest 
Sardinia, A. maritimus grows on maritime sands and 
in coastal vegetation over an area of only 200 x 60 
metres. Building construction for the tourist industry 
is considered a threat. 


Astragalus verrucosus: Found only at one locality in 
southwest Sardinia in the coastal area of Arbus and 
south of Capo Frasca. It, grows in dry scrubby 
calcareous grassland near to the coast where it may 
be threatened by cultivation and other agricultural 
operations. 


Chouard’s 
Flowering Yam 


Borderea chouardii 
[Dioscoreaceae: Yam family] 


This is a plant which is on the way to extinction, with 
a total population of between 300 and 500 individuals. 
The sole population consists of three tiny colonies, in 
a tongue of land surrounded by a dam and road. In 
recent years, one of the colonies was almost totally 
obliterated due to widening of the road. Stones and 
other debris still threaten those that remain. Plant 
collectors pose an additional threat. 


The Borderea is endemic to a small area in the north 
of the Province of Huesca, north-east Spain, where it 
grows between 800 and 840 metres. It is dependent 
on shade and cool summer temperatures and is 
therefore found growing in rock fissues with a north or 
north-easterly aspect. 


Apart from the ever-present threat of collection, the 
construction of a dam in recent years has adversely 
affected the microclimate of its fragile habitat and it is 
believed that this has directly caused the local extiric- 
tion of several colonies. 


No conservation measures have been instigated to 
safeguard the remaining colonies of this species. 
Attempts have been made to propagate it in cultiva- 
tion, but these have not been very successful. There 
is a need, therefore, to continue attempts at artificial 
propagation. More important is the pressing need to 
protect the habitat of the species, by declaring the 
remaining colonies and their surrounding environ- 
ment as small nature reserves and ensuring that any 
future developments do not cause further damage to 
the plant’s habitat. Collection and picking should be 
prohibited, with the exception of properly regulated 
taking of bulbils and seed for an approved conserva- 
tion programme involving artificial propagation. 


Iberian Peninsula 


A 
~ (i 
ma) a i 
4 iy TR ee vd 
—s 
7 z pet ¥ H ¥ a 
‘ : 
1o7 f eee ee OF’ | 
Puo\ t S : oa 
ae, 
_ [Wi rar cones) creer ey noth): = 
oS f 


—- 
RW ApeTfKn Of ew a7UaN0 0! ONW Inte Sal eiT >a 
Aira h O07 Go et O NOT MRO ME , “ 
aqme 961! etn ad Hqag toa eT be 


7 Wy Snb 198 yt moun bree 
vigor Tenn) ARM es: _ i Seng 7 
Bea? Sear! wo omwnmpw ot sae 


rh THN ID gel) were tite a otis i 
ASST te nO Oa hag een » 
gra Oe 


Heer eer amas 4 of img ha 

Wake lad tok ition oes tee 

Sibreged zg)! asian 0.5 bib NOS 

SOF eewrmcT? Wire Kim Bae meial ne 

STEPS 0 PER tet att dyes 1h Qe a 0 a ’ : 
7 - pte! 


a) 


ae 
wl segtoelion to thunginwesd iw eh rg - 
(Wart. 20 cay thet mi +t WG 
GPW NiGert Bh on 37 Rep sa Tris 
“agri Goat art Vermin ‘rloaetinis +t haw 


@ _ Distribution of Fuerteventura Cabbage 


Fuerteventura Cabbage 


Some threatened 
wild cabbages 


[Crucite-== Cabbage family] 


The wild relative: 2-C ancestors of our domestic 
cabbages (including ==Sbages, broccoli, kale, kohi- 
rabiand cauliflower, == centred inthe Mediterranean 
region. An imponart 2 up of these plants occurs on 
coastal cliffs and rocx=_ =specially inthe islands of the 
western Mediterrane= “egion and on Crete. Coastal 
plant communities: 1 == European Community are 
increasingly threater &— Dy development of even quite 
remote areas for tourss—.. Asa resultt, several wild cab- 
bages are threatoneé= rcluding the following species: 


Egadi Cabbage: 2=ssica macrocarpa 


This rather shrubby 22rT has leafy stems upto 60 cm, 
yellow flowers and T13C+.. woody boat-shaped seed 
pods. It occurs only or <2 Egadilslands of Favianana 
and Marettimo off tné =3ast of western Sicily. These 
islands are rapidly "73 developed for tourism, re- 
sulting in the destruc on of coastal rocks and low 
cliffs where the Eg2ci ~abbage and other endemic 
plants grow. Areas & <iiit should be protected from 
building and satequa-=23 from the effects of adjacent 


tourist developmunts. 


Sardinian Cabbage: 3rassica insularis 


This is another rather STubby plant, with lobed basal 
leaves and stems 30 =m tall, fragrant white or pale 
yellow flowers, and Sender seed-pods up to 8 cm 
long. It is found at Ca=="ed localities on the coasts of 
Sardinia and Corsica arc on the small island of Fan- 
telleria off Sicily. I! a@S<c occurs in Tunisia, although 
Europe is its main cen==. and the Corsican plants are 
regarded asa distinct. Unique variety. The plant is not 
inimmediate danger. CLI is very vulnerable to coastal 


development. 


bersieoids omod 


a oe = ti he rabten 
yo Bins ao eae 
“ye aw pode Mb | Lea 
ee aa at ee ind 
wb, erg sah sthewad ba 7 

t } nm “a ‘ . 

i seteineanaies Nase euhe te f . 


ne ent ae) 3 


a 


yt neni en 
een te at NT te 

ac: a a 
ergy tschae ; 


Hairless Cabbage: Brassica glabrescens 


This cabbage has a somewhat different habitat to 
those described opposite, being found along gravelly 
and stony banks of the rivers Meduna and Cellina, 
north of Pordenone in north-east Italy. It is a small 
plant up to 25 cm tall, woody at the base, with rather 
Narrow leaves and a few yellow flowers. Hairless 
Cabbage is related to a group of dwarf cabbages of 
mountains and open ground in the lowlands from 
south Spain to the western Alps and was first de- 
scribed in 1973. Its restricted habitat is unusual for a 
cabbage, and the plant is vulnerable to gravel extrac- 
tionand other humaninterference with the river banks. 


Fuerteventura Cabbage: Crambe sventenii 


This wild cabbage is a peculiar white-lowered endemic 
plant confined to the island of Fuerteventura (Canary 
Isles) where it grows in mountain peaks and ridges of 
the south-central region at an altitude of between 200 
and 400 metres. 


Five colonies are known, each withno more than 5-20 
individuals. The plant is confined to cliff crevices and 
fissures away from the reach of predatory goats. 
Originally the plant formed part of an olive woodland 
community which has virtually disappeared on 
Fuerteventura and which has been replaced by semi- 
desert scrubland leaving many of the islands rare 
endemic plants in a very precarious state. 


Two of the five populations are included in protected 
areas according to the “Ley de Espacios Naturales” 
approved by the Canarian Parliament, Parques natu- 
rales de Pozo Negro and Montana Cardones. 


Egadi Cabbage 
Trapani Cabbage 
Sardinian Cabbage 
Hairless Cabbage 


ga@0o008e 


Legal protection should be given to the sites outside 
the natural parks. Additionally, seeds should be propa- 
gated and a programme of reintroducing plants to the 
wild should be funded. Because of the potential eco- 
nomic value of the species, seed needs to be bulked 
up for conserving in a local gene bank. More gener- 
ally, the problem of goat-grazing on Fuerteventura 
needs to be seriously tackled. Should goats be ex- 
cluded from sensitive zones it is possible that some 
degraded natural areas may recover and some of the 
rare endemic species could naturally extend their 
range and so reduce their current vuinerability. 


These cabbages represent an important genetic resource as relatives of cultivated:crops; For example, another species: Cretan 
Cabbage (Brassica cretica) is thought to have given rise to the cauliflower of commerce: The Cretan Cabbage is. a plant of coastal 
cliffs and gorges by the-sea in Crete and southern Greece. The Domestic Cabbage also grows onciliffs inthe western Mediterranean, 
from where it was taken centuries:ago to many countries around the world. The rare-wild cabbages:of the westem: Mediterranean 
have characters such as tongevity and perhaps resistance to diseases that may beof valuein any future plant breeding programmes. 
The:seeds of the genus Crambe yield a commercially important vegetable-oi! and Crambe sventenii may be of value as it has the: 
largest seeds of any species in the genus, but its:cil content and other potentially:usefu! properties have not yet been studied: 


Protecting the habitats of the Endangered and potentially. useful species: should be:a priority. with restrictions placed on activities: 
such as building development and tourism at sensitive localities. In the case of Brassica giabrescens controls over gravel extraction 
are necessary so as to ensure future protection ofits habitat. Itis also important that seeds are heidin gene banks with a view to future: 
phytochemicai studies and artificiat pro iON. ore pee 


pvoRady wackne wedde santris? ; 


oy AguGerl Sag Narre woz s ae aoigen IR 

yivony Goa oat pred #tesodc necranal) onl 

ani tae erste Mew ert! to Sine! ync’s Ore 

teeta gas em rons ro oo? wa 
ln? or 


“i Sraire rade ons Sd i 3" 
> pe aA nites ot pad toe : 
ie eats taco oe a ce tthe — 


Savona Harebell 
Campanula sabatia 


[Campanulaceae: Bellflower family] 


Savona Harebell is an attractive small blue-flowered 
plant which grows in bare places. Its usual habitats 
are limestone rock crevices and coarse gravels asso- 
Ciated with maquis vegetation. This habitat is often 
shared with other endemic Italian plant species. 


This plant is unique to north-west Italy and is known 
only from a few coastal localities south-west of Savona. 
This includes the islets of Gallinara and Bereggi. the 
headland of Capo Noli and some additional localities 
up to 12 kilometres inland. The species may also 
occur in northem Bordighera. 


Savona Harebell is threatened due to fire, building 
construction, road building and collecting. Increasing 
pressure from tourism is of concer at Capo Noli. 


There have been long standing proposals to establish 
anumber of regional parks and reserves on the island 
of Gallinara and at Capo Noli but so far no sites have 
been adequately protected. 


The localities at Capo Noli, Rocca di Perti and on 
Gallinara island are considered top priority for habitat 
protection and would benefit from Special Protection 
Area (SPA) status. 


Dia Carline Thistle 


Carlina diae 
[Compositae: Daisy family] 


This hairy, spineless, dwarf shrub grows up to 60 cm 
high and has flat-topped clusters of yellow flower- 
heads, each 1.5-3.5 cmacross. It is found only ina few 
coastal localities in northern Crete. It was first discov- 
ered on the island of Dia off the northern coast near 
lraklion, and later at two coastal localities on the 
Sidheros peninsula and on two islets, Dragonada and 
Yionisadhos, on the coast of Sitia province in north- 
eastern Crete. The Sitia populations are not immedi- 
. ately endangered, but are vulnerable due to the small 
numbers of plants present. Goats that have been in- 
troduced to the islands threaten the piant’s survival. 


The situation with the plants on Dia is more serious. 
Since 1958 this island has beena refuge for the Cretan 
Ibex or Cri-Cri, the famous wild goat of the White 
Mountains. These were threatened in their native 
habitat and were introduced to Dia to protect them. 
However, they have caused considerable damage by 
grazing the island’s plants and only three plants of the 
Dia Carline Thistle could be found in 1973, although 
others may have survived on inaccessible ledges and 
cliffs. Since the goats are now surviving well in the 
White Mountains, it should be possible to move at 
least some of them back to their native range. 


Domestic goats should also be removed from the 
islands off Sitia to preserve those populations of the 
thistle. The Dian and Sitian plants are genetically 
different, and it is therefore important to protect plants 
in both areas in order to conserve the genetic diversity 
of this species, which is handsome enough to have a 
future as an omamental plant. 


11 


sisal saifas) alia 
ApS SF1,'NG . "2 


(yard vale .eatzocy tice?) 


— (ae G! at eH ) duets ue papers jiert € 
wr Say * * Ct laut PSC a Cae | 
_ ie Bact wi pee rmgiae c G8.) oee 4 

gisint ore; Syn rier 7) aertaliae Ot te: 

Bis are Mmoiten pelt ho eG he ex a 0 b 
af 110 aaltieno: bayeoo «Avi Se wie) bas 
on saerOg RS. wig bi Ao Pace gaara OE 
_an0n ()acritve) 232 so tendo at AO ae 
Ukerrty Par a Toveuioe aS, eat 
mats Ot T ea hy gla ph wv ened 8 
ni need aghast 218 sean gi 
lanivnny & Mig. gir rovedet sheesh 


qunT oeorn @ ed onan a fg 
rin et 16! cat wen ea 
: Bier So leoy Cle uae! ort f 
avin Sart 9 panqrnond ww 
edi sees ame: ef ot ores Ewe | 
CL IIR I Ate > 
eh) heh Barveeg pba anisey et 
Agupcitis EVE af (wae os Simo ot 


tle pppoe! ekazen ua G0 Oe 

f : a0 ern Dose eT =e 
nh ig ova Gt eelielig He 
wi RQAeY eo as 


Sardinia 


@ = Centaurea horrida 


Centaurea horrida 


12 


Endemic 
Mediterranean 
knapweeds 


Centaurea spp. 
[Compositae: Daisy family] 


Knapweeds have flowers that are similar in appear- 
ance to thistles, but their foliage is less spiny. The 
flowers are attractive - usually purple, pink, yellow or 
white. They are an important element of the flora and 
vegetation in the Mediterranean region, where some 
180 species, and many subspecies, occur in the 
European part alone. Knapweeds are a significant 
component of dry grasslands and are a characteristic 
feature of old meadows. Some species are plants of 
rocks, cliffs, stony ground and other disturbed or 
open habitats. 


At present we know rather little about many of the rare 
knapweeds of the Mediterranean. They are of great 
scientific interest for understanding evolution and 
plant geography, and their distribution is often 
associated with that of other endemic species. The 
knapweeds are genetically interesting and appear to 
have undergone considerable evolutionary radiation 
in the Mediterranean, particularly in Greece and the 
Balkans. Many of them are widespread and common 
in the region but nine of those endemic to single 
Member States are Endangered at country, European 
and World level. 


The populations of these Endangered species are 
small, confined to a few localities and mostly occupy 
only tiny areas (in some cases a few square metres). 
Despite this, no habitat protection measures have 
been comprehensively undertaken at any of their 
sites, although a number are severely threatened and 
some may have already been lost. 


oimobadt | > ae 
ogoneTistibsi | ~ | Sele 


Ny “ay ; ne 
eg) Pan ray Paces ‘ { 
ts ria eet ie anl eiirhiedinl 
rg ees eneui® rivhe ork 
hatin ye od ie 
: i 


oO t 
— 


Saleen’ o  aimmeibria, sects to. uri - 
. J ‘ 
4, ‘yt eerlt 
7 4 ; : . C r) 
i 


The nine Endangered endemic species are: 


Centaurea balearica: Endemic to the north coast of 
Menorca (Balearic Islands, Spain) where it grows in 
sandy areas near the sea. Only five populations are 
known and all contain a small number of individuals. 
One of the populations has been reduced (cut in half) 
by the construction of a road to the beach. Uprooting 
of mature plants has occurred in at least one other 
population. 


This knapweed grows up to 1.5 m tall and up to2m 
in diameter. The survival rate of young piants is poor, 
so the presence of mature piants is very important to 
maintain a source of seed for future regeneration. 


The remaining sites for this rare species need official 
protection by designating their habitats and surround- 
ings as small nature reserves. In these localities, 
competition from other species needs to be reduced. 
Where appropriate, the remaining wild populations 
could also be reinforced by introducing plants propa- 
gated in cultivation. 


Centaurea heldreichii: Known only from one coastal 
locality on calcareous rocks in western Greece, east 
of Mesolongion, between the mountains Varrasova 
and Klokova. The population is small: part of it is 
threatened by quarrying and urgently requires pro- 
tection. 


Centaurea horrida: This species is endemic to rocky 
coastal areas in northern Sardinia where it occurs in 
two sites on the mainland and on three islets off the 
north-west coast. The maquis and garrigue habitats in 
which C. horrida grows are of great biological impor- 
tance - they also hold populations of other plants 
unique to the region and therefore merit special pro- 
tection for the purposes of both habitat and species 
conservation. 


Tourist developments are a major threat. For ex- 
ample, at Capo del Falcone tourism complexes and 


13 


Iberian Peninsula 


@ Centaurea baleanca 


new roads were being built in the 1970s, which re- 
sulted in the dissection of one C. horrida locality. 


Onthe islet of Tavolara, tourism and military construc- 
tions threaten another site. Tourist developments also 
threaten the localities at Capo Caccia and Punta del 
Giglio. On one occasion, vegetation was irreparably 
damaged when the area was used to make a film — 
part of the requirements of the script involved de- 
stroying a good deal of the vegetation. In addition, 
after the film was shot, the area was set on fire to 
destroy remnants of the scenery. 


The designation of key C. horrida localities has been 
called for by the Inchiesta del Gruppo Conservazione 
Natura della Societa Italica, who have recommended 
that nature reserves be established on Isola Asinara, 
Isola di Tavolara, Capo del Falcone, Capo Caccia and 
Punta del Giglio. 


1 Sint) aired) at! =) i Ks ; earned : 
MW deci Rist leumets thresh onamiel) eonbaehl: | 
BO Biased wh WS oer of mir cs ona yong 
Mhulvitn! 1b schriyn tee ig 

“TRE La) Comer & a 

GOfiagigy .to@no ort co oken | 
TARO etc 


27] 4p beri 


' elrniey wraugaien Ip 


Cu 
a. L 
af 


- notieuged | 


rm 20a or Win 2.2 oO 
Wag af Aries gioy ‘> or Wo nue eT | 
OF INGO TH yiny 2 coeln erutort 1 aang 

Ferre wie ar! wo! peas fe « 


eV. boa eetrege pics ett: 
eo Tue CE araciefor! ie 
Jae geal | 
DARE OA il doe cylteqe tert mon ; 
ACRES Siw pimiaiie att Menqow 
SPIT IANS OTE TL OUT? 5 


ett ni hued: get een gone voi ESS Waste ying evans \\ioltaaath 
VAD ent to nokta er ri! hutlus Eh HE TREN fi OKO cuereolge tigt 
ne avauIMmaN. WA UEM UO neeted ive. . 

"2 8 0'tey Tain & weiegody SAT earn ’ 
Ts SOE Yon oom wiyrerD WR “Ah 


Vang) alone «gatos uot waite 
A) RUDD 9 etre mide erat ream 
Wt Ty) teh werirno tine Grohe ade 

eter eupmes ten misgen gett eae 
One men ones ane ko ahi ewitrey: ; 
REDD i BHAbeluecy Bort emhh 

“ONT tsoeAe tNeM srotveer't fru Relies Oe 
MN AVA fades vitae} \ eROEET UGE 


Centaurea heldreichii 
Centaurea kalambakensis 
Centaurea lactifiora 
Centaurea megarensis 
Centaurea niederi 
Centaurea peucidanifolia 
Centaurea princeps 


14 


Centaurea kalambakensis: Endemic to two localities 
in Greece, on the rocks of the Meteora near Kalam- 
baka in central Greece (near the famous monaster- 
ies), and at onelocality in Pella province (Macedonia) 
where only 30-40 plants have been found. The 
Macedonian population is apparently under threat 
from the use of herbicides and requires urgent protec- 
tion. 


Centaurea lactifiora: Endemic to a small area near 
the village of Koniskos, 15 kilometres east of Kalabaka 
in central Greece. Its habitat is dry roadsides and field 
margins. Some time ago it was considered to be 
under threat from a road-widening scheme and may, 
in fact, already be Extinct. 


Centaurea megarensis: Endemic to the summit of 
Mount Gerania in western Attica, to the east of the 
isthmus of Corinth where it grows in small and scat- 
tered populations and is under considerable pressure 
from overgrazing by sheep and goats. 


Centaurea niederi: Endemic to western Greece this 
plant is known from calcareous rocks and cliffs on 
roadsides near Mount Arakinthos above Mesolongion 
and in the north-west Peloponnese (Achaia prov- 
ince). in total, less than 80 plants are known from 
these two localities. 


Centaurea peucedanifolia: Endemic to Mount Athos 
in northem Greece where it is restricted to two sites, 
one anarea of 200 metres of roadside near the port of 
Daphni, the other in the vicinity of the monastery of 
Agios Pavios, where it grows on rocks and walls. The 
roadside locality is vulnerable to road improvements. 


Centaurea princeps: Endemic to Mount Timfristos 
above Karpenision in central Greece where only a few 
plants are known, growing close to a quarry. 


ee ee 


Cretan Helleborine 


Cephalanthera cucullata 
{Orchidaceae: Orchid family] 


This small orchid with slender stems 15-30 cm tall 
bearing a loose cluster of up to 20 creamy-white to 
pink flowers is restricted to about six localities on 
Crete. The localities are situated in the south-west 
(Samaria Gorge National Park and White Mountains), 
central Crete (Psiloritis forest) and eastern Crete (Mount 
Dhikti range). The orchid grows at altitudes of be- 
tween 700 and 1,500 metres in montane forest and 
scrub of native cypress, Calabrian Pine and Kermes 
Oak. 


Detailed studies of three localities during the 1970s 
showed a decline from about 150 plants to perhaps 
less than 30 over seven years. Recently, three addi- 
tional localities for this rare species were discovered, 
in 1985 and 1986, one with a population of about 150 
plants. In total there are probably less than 250 plants 
of this Endangered species. 


Like several Greek and Cretan endemic plants, the 
Cretan Helleborine has probably always been rare 
and could easily become Extinct. Overgrazing by 
sheep and goats is the principal threat, and urgent 
action is required to fence off plots to protect the 
surviving plants. This would allow the vegetation to 
recover and give the orchids a chance to flower and 
set seed. 


Although many of Crete’s endemic plants are wide- 
spread and under no threat, those that have only 
small populations, such as Cretan Helleborine and 
Cretan Catmint (Nepeta sphaciotica) are particularly 
susceptible to the heavy grazing pressure in the 
island’s mountains. Small nature reserves to protect 
the habitats of such species should be established, 
with partial or total exclusion of grazing animals. 


ica 


1 Samaria Gorge and White Mountains 
2 Psilontis Forest 
3 Mount Dhikti Range 


FE <j 
ie 
ra 2 
es. = ‘ > 
-_ ——- | 


SA H x 
|| 5a 
> a Fae ; é ) i ae 
_— el er aif 
se oe — — | lust Ax wal mate “ioe aiw oie Dee anit 
a al Shriya OP 01.10 to Wil) pet eo (wetteod ; 
eb - : io Soo! Mis Wwe ; pyrene a 4) } 
ad fu. pda: is Talkies: yeni: ate comnnnlh. genic, 4 


faoyllioe oitnl biiculieates coiathe! ad? BAD 
daetionn( aaa? Gre OW fer otal agpeathented 7! 
Td) wan radia bow 2 Jnoie) nan titines > 


LkeUGN WOW bon naar’ ee? BASH) GSN peTtom OUST Ii OCT repowt ds 
io ‘ doue abana? ' seo Ste. ont nedaic? «ogy evtbert to dinar . 


GOAN GOI iets, 


ev 


BOSS or ooh eattine ot?) ealtaute 
agetbien a) ginny Ger mack oad otis 
and ai Winsor iosy cw Se eyO TE Tie 
bitawcigltgiaw ¢cinen. cin sini) pediepel 
ost woids Wy Ale 0 eu areey was coe . 
pinay 2s ksi uso yiincloyg wr eee Aa 


2 Leveagrisiendl, 


oihaiun: pended) One ee 
ain feed cy awit yitecot, sdf paROcglell 

VE.poitorigatv® janis omonad inee tivee 
gry tig rer! Wp ey wet shee Be 
ah oekog a atoo No cow! oF Reape 
OP nciomesy en! were bipow SsAT eeeny 
bha TOW op aanerty = ebtslrey wet Gigs 


Shlw oe ariglg sarutas 2'eri> te ye 
Vin Wart fart aso aww’ Gn fale 
Monee’: ae clue were 

Tepicynewyy 


Iberian Peninsula 


Coincy’s 
Rock Cabbage 


Coincya rupestris 


[Cruciferae: Cabbage family] 


This biennial herb with yellow, violet-veined flowers, 
lives in north-facing crevices of vertical karstic lime- 
stone rocks in the Sierra de Alcaraz in the province of 
Albacete, Spain. It is restricted to an area of about 0.4 
square kilometres at an altitude of 1,100 metres. 


A site survey in 1979 estimated there to be as few as 
500-1,000 flowering plants plus perhaps twice as 
many non-flowering individuals. 


Present threats are from building construction coupled 
with collecting. There is also a possible threat from 
another plant species (Sisymbrium arundonum) which 
occupies the same ecological niche and may com- 
pete for space with the Endangered Coincya. Careful 
monitoring is therefore essential to ensure that the 
Coincya does not become displaced by the Sisymbnum. 


The seeds of Coincy's Rock Cabbage were once 
used locally as a kind of mustard but this use has now 
ceased. It is of considerable scientific interest and 
belongs to a small group of related endemic Spanish 
species. 


No conservation measures have yet been taken for 
this plant but the creation of a small reserve has been 
recommended. Strict vigiance wil be needed to ensure 
that building does not encroach on the area. Its 
habitat and setting are attractive and very vulnerable 
to development. 


er 
egeddn’ y AdoF 


OTSeOn Gi 


(ginal vote woe) 


wan Haris: Haak) weriay ‘tw. chase} leionaid cif 
Tel tae thon 15 aealetr tl yam «mit (1) pew 
Yo eanieeig thu Ser zh wel putt NEBR aos 
®.(nigeate nate nig o: Ge itee 2) i bed oiconsla 

cera eT OT, FO ettiitio ne ie eeTiamoly wrawpe 


owen lanl qr ened tyaubyyisan ATUN cl uvase ots A 
— Soeitieg lis aiRks Privo! 06, 1-008 
IRAE Or ONO R- fod Yrlgm 


ag Anitsud mga ei ata Wit eke 
slic & Otis alll? cottogiing aw 
PRS UA TCMIPRCK TRS cath) fee) bettas 
arfow\ non coe ory WY terpucge 
*> oe Malate Saalte os! ees 
ou! Movin? EB pniasinm 
Ad tendins bh artnet kat eacll weaved 


1 OpeeiB® won avorioD 9 Abia oy 
ceca bee Ora niny teciol day 
sHinere Widevwhonce ‘o ki I! Leagan 


AY Nas dontizuern nalinvioonas OM 
pe CO itiow) om tart fra yr edey iat 
SONGS Shh wes 


Brittany Eryngo 


Eryngium viviparum 
[Umbelliferae: Carrot family] 


The eryngos are a group of distinctive plants with 
sharply spined leaves. The Brittany Eryngo is known 
from Brittany (France), around Porto (northern Portu- 
gal) and Spain (north-west, Galicia and Léon). In both 
Portugal and Spain the plant is severely Endangered 
and is threatened with extinction. In France, the plant 
probably survives at few more than ten localities 
distributed over a smail part of Brittany. The plant is 
confined to these three Member States of the Euro- 
pean Community. 


The Brittany Eryngo grows in damp pastures, in de- 
pressions which are subject to winter flooding. Many 
populations have disappeared due to the abandon- 
ment of pastures and the removal of grazing stock. As 
a consequence. such areas have become invaded by 
tall vegetation in which the eryngo has been unable to 
survive. 


Other localities where the eryngo used to grow have 
disappeared due to urban and industrial development, 
afforestation by pines and land drainage. Trampling is 
an additional problem to populations around the French 
town of Carnac. 


The creation of nature reserves for the protection of 
this species and its habitat is urgent. In such reserves 
control over the water regime will be necessary to 
ensure the maintenance of winter flooding. In addi- 
tion, the grassland must be grazed to prevent inva- 
sion by tall vegetation. 


France and the Ibenan Peninsuia 


ent 


o Ra: Ma? WG eB 
ga 


= va 


18 


Gomeran Spurge 
Euphorbia lambii 


[Euphorbiaceae: Spurge family] 


Only three small populations of this local endemic of 
the Canary Isles are known. As its name suggests, the 
Gomeran Spurge is confined to the island of La 
Gomera, where it lives in damp crevices or at the foot 
of cliffs at the lower edges of the laurel forest zone 
between 600 and 1,000 metres. It grows in damp 
shallow soils, usually in small groups of three or four 
plants. 


Over-grazing is one of its main threats throughout 
most of its small area of distribution, and in some 
places its habitat has been reduced due to the clear- 
ance of native laurel forest and its replacement with 
inappropriate forestry species. Furthermore, the 
immature fruits tend to suffer insect damage and 
many capsules develop without seeds. 


Populations on the north-west side of La Gomera are 
protected in the Lomo de Carreton park but an impor- 
tant population at Benchijugua is without formal pro- 
tection. This situation could be rectified by extending 
the boundaries of the Los Roques park down to 700 
metres. In addition, to prevent genetic erosion, it may 
be appropriate to bulk up the wild population using 
material of wild origin that has been propagated 
locally. 


snide ngetsioW 
Mittin eros 


fetrrnad apg :eitouminren kre 


WD Giigbrer yon Gi io an sieycon juurre een th wie 
Ot Ama DUE oie Bhs sons AiR Ti er A 
£1 teil ga) of beniirmo a ogwGl netanod 
woh acid He wert reper eggevatyt mail ff qui maine) 
enag inated lene! ic 16 copier weGi ds 14 ND to 
Qmeo ni tact | dorm, OO.) Gre COS ewig 
Wohw went lo eqtang Wena ni Visua wdc wolw 
zie 


Negri rit 2A 4 atin 2) a iokbs yavO 


ARS tng j uel ieee iS ata 
na i piiaache <i 

rasitn Orit ei mruiernred 
poate dy 


Sicilian Bedstraw 


Galium litorale 
[Rubiaceae: Madder family] 


Endemic to westem Sicily, this plant is restricted to 
coastal sands. Its habitat is much threatened by 
agricultural developments and by building construc- 
tion for the tourist industry. 


Sicilian Bedstraw is known from near Marsala, Mazara, 
Selinunte and Campobello at a total of four localities 
within about 30 km of one another. Protection of a 
large area of coastal sand is essential to arrest the 
continuing decline of this species. 


Downy Gypsophila 
Gypsophila papillosa 
[Caryophyilaceae: Carnation family] 


This species is only known from one locality in north- 
em Italy, above the eastern shore of Lake Garda, 
where it grows on dry stony soils in hills between 50 
and 200 metres above sea level. 


Field observations in 1970 indicated that the entire 
population of the plant was confined to an area less 
than 0.25 hectares but since then it has apparently 
declined even further. The species is considered to be 
in great danger of extinction due to building develop- 
ments as well as from collection (mostly by foreign 
botanists). 


The whole belt of hills around Lake Garda are being 
ireparably damaged by building construction 
associated with the tourist industry. Despite this, the 
critical habitat where Downy Gypsophila continues to 
survive so precariously remains unprotected. 


ay 


@ Downy Gypsophila 
© Sicilian Bedstraw 


hes AAD, 


TT DORA) Ali) he wo UW oF Sa = 
yi caetedierdt? (Sin; 2l bwicar a 2boee bee 


Ltaoee Biibdue yet Ong whecosirat) lew tongs m 


sian Wea ert a 


ert eee Vale rar net» Aa tebod aie 
pattie sl Witt 8S tant Gan Clays bev omnaraa le wk 
EO Ce Dates ono o 7 OE Rods i ie : 
ot oer! joven that lever to ee 


alidqosqy oe 


oeclligsn eknocagye 


i fylleia' Mall ticks) nt ae ois ihe) a 
a 
ai _ 
_ “fI0GN coviliEnolerny ino cord aio 6 ese 
a | Biked) ote! © corte rece ot woods | 


TE. wowisd atm ri wing yor oneal A 
Svs) oe ovots one Ott 


7 : iw of iw? eoaahonl UNE ale 
ml oe ene GY bare oe wie rr 
(Oita tin aay viele arte Red ser wigper & 
BU OUGe baron AmoeraadT sactade 
EG vs pues cat ent rays Vinee Yo Sagrada 
Higher, 2 yilteon) nolkeetics: eniow em Hem 


ci 


Iberian Peninsula 


20 


Spanish Gaudinia 
Gaudinia hispanica 


[Gramineae: Grass family] 


This grass species occupies a very limited and dis- 
junct area; the two known localities on the Huelva 
Coast in south-west Spain are 70 kilometres apart. 


The natural habitat of the Gaudinia is sandy acid soils 
with a low water table, where it forms part of the 
ground vegetation normally found under stands of 
Stone Pine (Pinus pinea). 


In the past two decades one of its localities was 
subject to disturbance and afforestation with Euca- 
lyptus, an activity which has affected wild species and 
habitats throughout the region in recent years. Fortu- 
nately, the Gaudinia has so far survived below the 
planted Eucalyptus. However, it is feared that in future 
years accumulating litter from the planted trees will 
alter nutrient levels in the soil and prevent the plant's 
survival at this locality. 


The second locality is situated inside the Dohana 
National Park and therefore there is some regulation 
over development of its habitat. 


It is possible that further populations occur between 
the two existing disjunct ones so the surrounding 
area ought to be explored. In any case, the most 
westerly locality which has been subject to Eucalyp- 
tus afforestation, should be given some protection 
and the population monitored regularly. If the species 
begins to decline as a result of the effects of litter 
accumulation from the Eucalyptus, then measures 
will need to be taken to restore the original habitat. 
This will involve clearance of the Eucalyptus and 
restoration of the semi-natural Stone Pine woodland. 


28 


<  ginibued datasq?2 
i Schnaget Si\Gumc) 
fydevet wet uesnrinnto| 


_ eb Ding Heder wy a awquave asin gm sony = 
“igviauht 6 Ao eeliadc) oNord G7 url ert lon 
Tikes eesti 4 O° tra lege aewattyon a! joo o 


‘slip tiga yOoine ev Grrsent arth 40 preted Men. carraeT 
MONG Pilla SNS wet Aksar vette wet & tw 
eas anes deh bitua? (ideruahy ‘engaged oir 
fradiaainy vals wold 


4 
ay ito sig esbes4D wr leer, 1 nl 
Cat eres bank. ecient 01 Foy ive 
Pebptoattinstl duitweyivitne nn autor 

‘Oui ee a ai nd agin ort nignign cist qrmsicart 
na vie val ai Geis’ Wet toner 


jczasieerigonl tsitnwky 
2 aertt ene fear pehaanyait ray’ 
i See vit tH an re 20%, 

sailecot Sartre tevives 


| late nia erent 


nau macht iiciabicrainc 


ry barely a Pes pe 


eer apicy ain aie evilem 


qe 1 e 
= y P 
a 
wa 
all ‘ 
= 
' 
4 
= 
v 
oe 
~- ea < 
_ — 


Styx Globularia 


Globularia stygia 
[Selaginaceae: Globularia family] 


The Styx Globularia is a prostrate, woody, perennial 
with slender branches, small almost circular leaves, 
and compact heads of tiny violet to bluish flowers. It 
grows in small numbers on rocks and screes above 
2000 metres on a few mountains in the northern 
Peloponnese in Greece, principally Mounts Chelmos 
and Killini. The summit areas and higher ground of 
these two mountains are excessively grazed by sheep 
and goats and despite their rich fioras there is no 
protection for rare species such as this Globularia. 


The area in which the plant grows on Chelmos is the 
steep northern slopes of the mountain in the Styx 
valley, a region which together with the adjacent 
Zarouchlia forest to the east is rich in narrowly en- 
demic plants and other rare plants that are otherwise 
found only in northern Greece or Anatolia. The steep 
cliffs of the Styx valley provide some protection against 
grazing, but increasing tourism threatens the Styx 
Globularia and other rarities through collecting. 


The Styx valley requires national park status, as itisan 
area of outstanding botanical importance. It also has 
considerable cultural interest, as the cave from which 
the waters of the river Styx emerge was to the ancient 
Greeks the entrance to Hades, the river being the 
River of the Underwonrd. 


21 


a ; 7 aie oi 
— STUB) KIC. . a 
Pan ie ‘ — ~ glowi2 shelter a 

. ~feag 

= fylitiect sheqOok) jasenpigeted) a8 ‘ 


Aiciromn) ./bOOw Aiea @ sf shake ayitedt 
soi Taeenis Bers nent 2 eran sebrelg die 
4 a votAniic G2 zaNbiv yi? to vee nagenga bre 
VGGD Ruse HS. e429) Po perry eae 
meinen or A -salpatiinin «af. a op SEtOn O 
anti canveh! yileqganhy «cand ni 7 
id SO Og asigid bas sects Sirwiue ott : 
howe iiscysranap-ondannel p 
Os nemete waOH Ton lent sttqce® tne ange. Bete | 
ar WAUMOWD siti! aa rtove eciooda gin Td sic 


a 7. 
AL. 

ard @) norriithD (vo -eyeey x: cece rt 
q72 ott moniter’ ed lo eoqele prertnon'¢ 
Tree oe itt ns , 
“Te YM: on ot pichiaceniy= ; 
sia wits mete saiteles rere tate 


Se 


ie 
ay 


Indicates present in these States (scale too smail 
to map accurate distribution) 


Bog Orchid 


Hammarbya paludosa 
[Orchidaceae: Orchid family] 


This small and inconspicuous green-flowered orchid 
grows in acid bogs in north-west Europe, witha range 
extending circumpolar to temperate north-east Asia 
and North America. In Europe it extends from Ireland 
eastwards to European Russia. 


Bog Orchid grows in one of Europe’s most threat- 
ened habitats: peatland, where it is usually found 
growing with Sphagnum moss and other typical 
peatland plants. 


Everywhere in Europe this wetland habitat is greatly 
threatened by land drainage, peat-digging, reclama- 
tion for agriculture or other developments, and by af- 
forestation. As a result, this orchid is threatened over 
three-quarters of its European range, including Bel- 
gium (declined by 80%), Czechozlovakia, Denmark 
(declined by 90%), the Faeroe Isles, Finland, France, 
the Federal Republic of Germany, Ireland (declined 
by 90%), the Netherlands (declined by 75%), Roma- 
nia, Switzerland and Russia. In some of the other Eu- 
ropean countries in which it occurs it is experiencing 
serious decline as a result of habitat destruction. For 
example, although the Bog Orchid is not officially 
considered as threatened in Britain, it has been lost 
from at least 50% of its former localities since 1930. In 
particular, many of its Scottish strongholds are inade- 
quately protected and have been lost or are threat- 
ened by afforestation. 


Conservation priorities for this species must include 
the special protection of all major localities of Euro- 
pean importance, and the prevention of further de- 
clines by ensuring that damaging activities such as 
forestry and peat-digging are directed away from 
places where the Bog Orchid grows. In those Member 
States where the Bog Orchid has declined by 90%, all 
remaining localities ought to be protected. 


Me 


ee 


— ah S 
en Y 


bisior) god | 
Kedbuleg Hic aTirish 
iy terest tanta ear sshit) 


Detailed distributional information 


The following information has been obtained from 
various plant atlases which have mapped the distribu- 
tion of rare and threatened plants in certain Member 
States. However, figures on very recent declines are 
difficult to compile. Many of the plant atlases use 1950 
or earlier as a base-line for recording the presence of 
absence of a species. For example, data from the 
Federal Republic of Germany records that Bog Or- 
chid has been recorded from 53 ‘hour-squares’ since 
1945. Itis likely that significant land use changes since 
then have led to the disappearance of Bog Orchid at 
many localities within these squares. The scale of 
decline is therefore considerably greater than might 
therefore be assumed from the data provided below. 


Belgium 


Formerly known from 25 localities but since 1940 it 
has only been seen in four of these. 


Denmark 


Before 1950, there were 112 areas of suitable habitat 
for Bog Orchid in Denmark. Since 1950, 93 of these 
areas have been destroyed, usually as a result of land 
drainage for agriculture. Of the 19 localities (probably 
less now) that were thought to remain, most were 
situated in lowland mires along the west coast, with a 
few very scattered and ecologically separated locali- 
ties on islands to the east. 


Federal Republic of Germany 


Before 1945, Bog Orchid had been recorded from 
more than 190 ‘hour-squares’, with many localities in 
the extreme north: Schleswig-Holstein, Liineberg, 
Hanover and Weser-Ems districts, and in the south 
along the Austrian border. Since 1945, it has only 
been recorded from 17 ‘hour-squares’ in Ihe north of 
the country and 37 inthe south. Bog Orchid is consid- 
ered as Endangered in the Federal Republic of Ger- 
many. 


23 


France 


A rapid decline in the species has been recorded 
throughout France to the extent that it is now Extinct 
in a number of regions such as the Paris Basin and 
Lévezon. Bog Orchid is considered as Vulnerable in 
France. 


Ireland 


Formerly known from more than 50 sites but has only 
recently been seen at six sites, although it is possible 


- that it has been overlooked in others. However, many 


peatland sites in Ireland have been destroyed or 
damaged over the past 30 years as a result of peat- 
digging, drainage and afforestation. 


Netherlands 


Before 1950, the Bog Orchid was known from 122 
hour-squares scattered throughout the Netherlands. 
Since 1950, it has been observed in only 33 of these. 
This decline has been caused by land reclamation 
and particularly by drainage and the use of agricul- 
tural chemicals, especially fertilisers. 


United Kingdom 


Bog Orchid still occurs in over 150 localities in Eng- 
land, Scotland and Wales but nevertheless, this figure 
masks a serious decline experienced over the past 50 
years. Britain is considered to hold more than half of 
the total population of Bog Orchid in north-west Eu- 
rope, with the main stronghold in western Scotland, 
where there are over 100 localities. Elsewhere in 
Britain, the species is confined to a few scattered 
localities with a notable population in the New Forest 
(a large area of lowland heath in southern England 
with associated lowland mires, maintained by tradi- 
tional grazing and commoning practices). 


Asin many other countries of north-west Europe, Bog 
Orchid has declined in recent times as a result of land 
drainage and other land improvements for agricul- 
tural purposes and due to commercial afforestation of 
peatlands by conifer trees. 


een 

“ nae se ois ft cr woe 

fynadawer ih Last nei Ge on eerie footQuare 
mane or elt ap ees doa padre prt 
1 , —, 


ALE 4 « ; 7 
ak ong e re geen aos wn \ (“¥7) 
ram ievewaht erseio rales 

cut a‘ wf? wl. “ liad hn 
‘ oe ey ogc 
' pai row OE, ; 


natiemToD ti Yerouuditath tole 


iO (aaptiekiots~ reed tert nolnernqie prawoudh eet” 
ud ively GAME boescpey Siem oy ven) Vida tow epee trl 

HTM Alek 1) <crG Der owl Doe ergy ‘ 
se Ser These yy nO ae) Qevownl aeiase: ; = 
DOB oot. somtiia Welo eM! ta Yneld .olgmog — 
eee o i Or ocr weed e ea y 


SOME? galt 20 x tc } 
por: eehortin nm 


Madeira F 


Canary Isies 


VIS 
NY = 


Q 
eo 
Aree 


Cockscomb Foxglove 


lsoplexis chalcantha 
[Scrophulariaceae: Foxglove family] 


Endemic to the island of Gran Canaria, Canary Isles, 
where only four populations with a small number of 
individuals (5-20) are known from the north slopes of 
the island between 600 and 800 metres above sea 
level. This foxglove is always associated with the 
scarce remains of laurel forest (‘laurisilva’) on Gran 
Canaria, particularly in ravines of the humid, shady 
mountainous part of the island, specifically Los Tiles 
de Moya and Barranco de la Virgen. 


Of the Canary Isles archipelago, Gran Canaria is the 
island most affected by forest clearance, with only 
about one percent of its original laurisilva surviving. 


lsoplexis species are used in local popular medicine 
as anaesthetics in the treatment of toothache, for 
treatment of diabetes and as a cardiotonic. In addi- 
tion, chemical studies have revealed that this genus 
contains glucosides which are important as heart 
stimulants. 


Populations ofthe Cockscomb Foxgloveare included 
within the limits of the Monte Doramas Natural Park, 
recently established by the Canarian Parliament. 
Additional specific measures which need to be taken 
to ensure the future survival of this species inciude the 
development and implementation of a conservation 
management plan specific to the plant and its natural 
habitat. Studies of the species’ reproductive biclogy 
and a programme of artificial propagation should also 
be adequately funded. 


a, 48 


24 


~ 9volyxoT dusoozis0) 
Riiaasinens Cuerace 


tone evo jetenptetierigg ie) 


bet yranad perenne io toads. ete onneDeS 


to mcinun lama 6 féw erediucag idl Yio wernt 
18 saqots chon ert oh Mavarot ae (SS) aha aPAhn! 
hak eve eormaen 068 Gre NG newacted tirnial get 
0 tthe Sambora Pyaits e avaige! ant save! 
. And ao Teveeniel) aero eros GE sion suse 


> oirtut etic seve nf vigaeeinen srwTe) 


aah octtnhat hao. cyom 4b 


“ge a ahaned and i gol vianin.> 4th 1 
Lele. yo tiftodita Bete: oe: 
Wi 1p Bios @ 4 am Woe 


= ay he eon 
goo) vi Oaeae 1a 10 parr 
:: ant 


7 eS Yilectionge hewie eto fag avorintsucm 
ee “anegiy 


Watson’s Lettuce 


Lactuca watsoniana 
[Compositae: Daisy family] 


This large white-flowered perennial grows up to 2 
metres tall. It is one of Europe's rarest plants, found 
only ina few small sites in the Azores Archipelago, on 
the islands of Sao Miguel, Terceira, Faial and Pico at 
500-900 metres above sea level, in sheltered places 
on wet ground, in ravines and old volcanic craters. In 
these locations Watson's Lettuce is often found grow- 
ing with other plant species which are endemic to the 
Atlantic |slands or are otherwise threatened in the Eu- 
ropean Community, including the ferns Woodwardia 
radicans and Trichomanes speciosum. 


Watson's Lettuce prefers locations with a permanent 
water supply or permanently moist ground in combi- 
nation with high relative humidity and is restricted to 
the native laurel cloud forests (‘laurisilva’) for which 
the Atlantic Islands are so famous. The laurisilva con- 
tains some of the rarest plants of the Azores as well as 
some endemic birds such as the Pridlo or Azores 
Bullfinch. In the Azores this habitat is severely threat- 
ened and very little now remains due to clearance of 
the forest for agriculture and for plantations of Japa- 
nese Larch (Cryptomeria japonica). For example, the 
forest of Caldeira da Santa Barbara on Terceira re- 
quires urgent protection - as recently as 1986, Cryp- 
tomeria was being planted at this important site, 
although this activity may now have stopped. 


Even those areas of unexplored and relatively inac- 
cessible laurisilva may hold populations of rare en- 
demic plants, and it is therefore important that the 
remaining laurel cloud forests are given full protec- 
tion. Two of the sites for Watson's Lettuce in the 
Caldeira da Santa Barbara (Terceira) and on north- 
east O’Pico (Pico) are very small. The population on 
O’Pico is in a small wooded gully only about 15 
metres square and is completely surrounded by pasture. 
Urgent measures are therefore required to protect 
these fragile and vulnerable areas. 


é 


25 


@ Known extant localities for Lactuca watsoniana: 
Caideira da Santa Barbara (Terceira) 
North-east O'Pico (Pico) 

Lagoa do Canario (Sao Miguel) 


A tew other localities, not recently confirmed (not mapped) have 
been recorded for Pico, Terceira and Faial. 


~ ga haw am eaves ori iy 


ECS We ‘ 
a 

; € a | 7% 
[yierret ga amiaQn i] te 


¢ of @/ ewe) are tape opie her oqel lat 49 
brunt sie arn ¢ tec" ‘cand oe 8 Rel sevien- _ s 
Re PgR sven” artnet « e tame wolaniylag | 
wags Lele mca T le os3 tooteaet 
enang Karmic ee Mvet oe 9 cue manta OOROOR TS a3 
AL. gipiane, climes ho Ore venivin 1 bewog MWg ine 
Woe Sao into & 220 Ot Ta. vee eno a“ asin 0 5 
efht rss ciretiove txt ety Sa ege amg Wart 
wt aa rthencntiuwl & acubL =» chreie Ate] 
atamewieegN aryl att yo outor \pireranoD A } 
ithatinsie eanamocat bree alin 


+ = 


Were Tag B fiw anoleow eee sot eg 4 a 
Atircs Abang Scen vib tare reey 10 Yi i 

ot hetsiies! 4 Ses yatimun ovurgtenrtigut a 
Aertel (evésual) Baer! bendy 
<poayigtuctadtT sional on te abt 


Sardinia 


26 


Sardinian Thistle 


Lamyropsis microcephala 
[Compositae: Daisy family] 


The Sardinian Thistle is a very thorny thistle with 
whitish-pink flowers. It occurs over a small area on the 
western and southem slopes of Mt. Bruncu Spina in 
the Monte del Gennargentu. The thistle is a montane 
species and grows at altitudes of between 1,500 to 
1,700 metres on rocky slopes vegetated with scat- 
tered shrubs (such as juniper), herbs and grasses. 


Its habitat is badly degraded by intense grazing and 
grubbing by semi-feral pigs and is additionally threat- 
ened by the construction of winter ski facilities. These 
pressures together contribute to soil erosion, a gen- 
eral threat to the area. The thistle occurs over a 
restricted area totalling no more than one hectare, so 
far unprotected, and it is considered one of Sardinia’s 
most threatened endemic plants. 


The Monte del Gennargentu supports an extremely 
rich and diverse flora with many endemic Sardinian 
plants in addition to the Sardinian Thistle, some of 
which are found nowhere eise on the island. Locally 
important medicinal plants such as the Great Yellow 
Gentian (Gentiana /utea), Purple Foxglove (Digitalis 
purpurea), together with a variety of mints, thymes 
and junipers also grow in profusion. 


However, the threats to the Sardinian Thistle are also 
responsible for the general degradation of the area as 
a whole. It is essential that the region is declared a 
protected area and that appropriate management is 
introduced to redress problems of erosion and 
vegetation destruction. Priority measures are the 
regulation of grazing and tourism to levels compatible 
with the conservation of the region's plant life. 


ar 
i. 


sheild tT nsiniined pF 2 
Patwyssoioun megowes. 
tyrant vain -Gataw OO} - ib < 


haw eteint whed? yey ©. eteetT eeiniwe wiT { ee 
OrNG nena ken n IerAOTEAIDIO H eVOWwoR deig-zreeaiy : Gog 


maaan ales hepa at ag lear 


v, | ; E r 
ie pegtt. no ray 
oT ieee +i 
oJ oni ha 


irre , 


en er tos eG 


1 me . Ai sd 
nergesrorangeant yoo 
pn ag. 7 ake one 


Long-rayed Las er Iberian Peninsula 


Laserpitium longiradium 
[Umbelliferae: Carrot family] 


This species used to be abundant along the banks of 
the River Monachil in the Sierra Nevada mountain 
range of southern Spain. However, only one small 
population numbering a dozen individuals is currently 
known, growing at an altitude of between 1,200 and 
1,500 metres. At the only known locality, the plant 
grows on very wet ground in almost total shade. It is 
thought that the former localities have become un- 
suitable for this wetland plant owing to pollution of the 
River Monachil and other damaging activities which 
have affected its headwaters. For example, for some 
years the river has been receiving all the effluent from 
aski resort. The species’ survival is further threatened 
due to overgrazing of its habitat by local goat herds. 


The Sierra Nevada is recognised as one of the most ‘i 

important areas of plant diversity and endemism in RG x 

the whole of Europe. More than 60 plant species are SLID AID 

endemic to this mountain range and in 1988 the rai Zz 
highest part of the mountain range was declared asa SREY 

Natural Park. Despite this, the region continues to be , . 
subject to increasing tourism development and damage WY; , ; 
from mining. As a result, the specialised ecological tk a 
requirements of rare plants such as Laserpitium are Ss CG \} ij 
becoming increasingly scarce. ~ Bea 
Measures are urgently needed to improve protection B/ N\SS - gy 
of the Sierra Nevada as a whole. These include ex- PR hao 
tending the limits of the Natural Park and effective SX 


implementation of a conservation management plan. 
Such a plan will need to consider the placing of 
restrictions on future tourism and mining develop- 
ments, control over grazing pressures and the instal- 
lation of effluent treatment plants in existing tourist 
developments so as to reduce water pollution. 


Aprogramme of artificial propagation should also be 
undertaken for the Laserpitium, together with regular 
monitoring of the wild population and its habitat. 


NN 4a 


27 


os ; 
1928 beysi-gnol a9 


MUCe WOT TWh Sees 2 


— 


a 


Sn 
- 9 


(ylitet Fone. Benet} 


in sung atl pools idea cit geht bee eakagg itt _ 
nino Balveel hrm ent of Retenes wi et 
lnrrabane vin vwwRwitt smi sevtiuor to age. gs 
JUN fey iS 2) eae it erase 5 rein i 
nxn O0S1 Asowint! jo ehuera nc 0 oniwany 40 j 
nal <4 vikgobi worl yinw est A eoueey BOT | « 
# tt oherts (Hol momigr? pntiow mew ey no aa 
ll goad Eyal dvilaao! verteo! evtt tert! Sipoe 
tito SAO GDI ® inig Girne iiew eit vol eles 
rivhy #tinoize Grinch vaio Lm kiogoM 
(nedn sof Bigiiéay 7 crotevogerd gy 
méeitprevifle Si Ar oneienk net eta) Ofttirmae 
Dette i athyt or leviue pikegalertT Jeet 
abide nag tia! yd Bice! oT 10 Oriemipwye Gis 
es 


a 


om ef) ip afte ee Damapeon) evel aR 
hi oenaire bie yinew \riwig uae Qf 
an aikge ingly OO Marta cRA Lge te akan 
at eS! i one giigedinnionr ri al Sine 
bes Geil0b ony sdrspetten| 3 rey ap 
93,8 OsUNRT HEiG Brit car?) or 3! 
Nee : rae " 
renin pen hore 
Sym crv) cts aa a eeany a 
gna yy 


Maléa Toadflax 


Linaria hellenica 
[Scrophulariaceae: Foxglove family] 


The Maléa Toadflax is an annual plant with branched 
stems up to half a metre tall, narrow fleshy leaves and 
showy yellow flowers about 1.5 cm long. 


This rare and Endangered species is confined to a few 
coastal sites in the south-eastern extremity of the 
Peloponnese (Greece), within an area of about 20 
square kilometres on the Maléa Peninsula around the 
town of Neapolis and on the nearby island of Elafonisos. 
Only discovered and described in 1955, the toadflax 
has probably always been rare due to the restricted 
area of its habitat of sandy beaches and other level 
sandy areas (both cultivated and uncultivated) near 
the sea. More recently, it has become critically 
threatened by the loss of this habitat through modern 
agricultural methods, especially the use of herbicides. 
The open, coastal habitat is naturally unstable, and is 
under threat from both tourism and _ industrial 
development. 


By the late 1970s Maléa Toadflax was present in only 
four of its seven known stations. The remaining popu- 
lation are tiny, with the largest containing some 100 
individuals, while three others support only a handful 
of plants each. 


Suitable sandy areas in and around the localities of 
this Endangered plant require urgent protection. In 
particular, damaging activities such as herbicidal weed 
control and building construction for tourism and 
industry must be prohibited in these areas. 


Aspecis of Linaria 


Q Waal 


28 


zelibaoT sbicht 
Gavialor" ena 
jyteas! dvoler :eieoenshrigasc) a 
Bechecring sitive antlc isin fre at xatteoT oGia oriT 


tin epee veiw aecsrenet JA arageTC a ort yt Gu are» 
Orel es 2. acs eywPedgiay ye" 


samiiedi — 1 
("ener > - Caaet At 7 


e 


Succulent 
Birdsfoot-trefoil 


Lotus kunkelii 
[Leguminosae: Pea family] 


Endemic to Gran Canaria, the Succulent Birdsfoot- 
trefoil is Known only from a single very threatened 
locality at the mouth of the Barranco de Jinamar. It is 
a prostrate, woody-based plant with succulent leaves 
bearing long silky hairs. It grows in the littoral sands 
on the coast between 15 and 20 metres above sea 
level. 


Until the early 1960s several populations of this spe- 
cies occurred along the sandy areas of the coast of 
Gran Canaria but extraction of sand for construction, 
and disturbance from roadbuilding, urban develop- 
ment and other activities have had an enormous 
impact on the habitat of the plant, reducing its distri- 
bution spectaculany. 


The only surviving locality is extremely small (approxi- 
mately two hectares) and is situated between the 
coast and the main Las Palmas Airport road and 
alongside industrial sites containing seawater distilla- 
tion and electricity generating stations. 


Although the site where the trefoil grows has been 
declared a protected area by the Canarian Parliament 
no specific or effective habitat conservation meas- 
ures have yet been taken and protection against all 
negative activities, particularly mineral extraction, is 
required. Artificial propagation of the species in a 
botanic garden is likely to be successful if funding can 
be secured and this could, in turn, lead to a pro- 
gramme of reintroducing the species to suitably pro- 
tected habitats in the wild. 


ze A 


29 


: id Yo” Py ote b 2 ) i¢ 
e . ’ —_— ‘ - 
od a tant tantoietet 

y i : a 
} ‘| ‘ “. % ; ee 
‘ 
. ye ua] J 
me, 


Sn Taitt—siwy i - ae 9) ene 1 MrT at Tiekent 1% 
aie safe Whats sitt > rear erly 16 ¥Rlano/ AA 
WVhSLWO hiociua iwory U ead Yi SISTA tH =] 

20 Tied ley ar? al ewe ar yitlta 9°ot Eritned 1: 
un Te aia OF hy: ton egt aad ont) AGE 
Saver Fe 


i QO MSL pOGKIUGrG werer ORR? Yee iol 
(BOS et SPTa VW ORS St) Ce f , 
US EO aa! (ies (7s fod a 
\CMVED TPC orerhe<then; wad 
nore ry bed er eames verthy Sng. 
USD 26 Ot be T 1 iT te Ne Ar 
cee oo 


AE Ta) lara viet ie Lad y tin octgr 
1) (upaivone Ree? Ie “ needa : 
ie CAO) Dy, elantigS smd ra. wand 
Tidktesh) wy, WibOs DNV ering catia fed 

I er Sip ealre oo i" 


ets | aworg Watery! mip ss 

bent TCIM Ohh ied Bert 
RAL HCO apnahaaricgsy Seuslcs art 

te einaQn of tra 


per a ronan ag ot 
“ney hr ea oe edie 
aig } RE OF aE a ae ; ; 


Iberian Peninsula 


Wavy Loosestrife 


Lythrum flexuosum 
[Lythraceae: Loosestrife family] 


Wavy Loosestrife is a small annual plant, 3-10 cm tall, 
with pinkish-purple flowers. It is a wetland species, 
preferring seasonally inundated depressions, and is 
found in sites scattered throughout central Spain in 
the provinces of Toledo, Ciudad Real and Cuenca y 
Guadalajara. It may also occur in the provinces of 
Albacete and Teruel. 


This loosestrife grows on the edges of brackish pools 
and depressions on subsaline and mineral-rich soils 
which are flooded in the winter and which usually dry 
Out at the beginning of the spring. Like so many other 
wetland habitats, this habitat has been severely re- 
duced throughout Spain due to widespread land 
drainage and pollution. As a result the scattered 
populations of Wavy Loosestrife have declined dra- 
matically. 


To protect this threatened plant, it is necessary to 
establish small reserves to ensure the protection of 
the main populations. These reserves should be 
protected from further drainage operations. 
Consideration should also be given to controlling the 
use of agricultural fertilisers and other sources of 
pollution in the vicinity of sites where the Wavy 
Loosestrife grows. 


Hairy Clover Fern 


Marsilea strigosa 
[Marsileaceae: Clover Fern family] 


The Hairy Clover Fern, as its name suggests, has 
long-stalked leaves of four wedge-shaped hairy leaf- 
lets arising from a short creeping stem. Also on the 
stem are lentil-sized pods containing reproductive 
bodies (spores). 


This highly Endangered plant is found in seasonally 
wet hollows in maquis and in similar rock depressions 
on basalt and other metamorphic rocks such as 
schistose gneiss. It withstands the long dry summers 
of the Mediterranean climate, by losing its leaves, and 
protecting its vulnerable spores in a thick homy pod. 
This splits open during winter rains and the sticky 
spore mass is believed to be dispersed on birds’ feet. 


In total, it is estimated that less than 50 plants of the 
Hairy Clover Fern survive today. Its few localities are 
situated in south-east Italy and Sardinia, Menorca 
(Balearic Isles) with another possible site in south 
France (Herault). In Menorca, the locality is under 
threat from tourism development. At the French site, 
although the fern is protected in a nature reserve, it is 
in danger of becoming overgrown by encroaching 
vegetation due to lack of suitable management. 


Outside the European Community, the fern is found 
only at two coastal localities in Algeria and Morocco, 
where it is also rare and threatened. 


A closely related species Marsilea batardae is also 
Endangered, and its total world population is con- 
fined to Portugal and western Spain. 


a 
“ie 


31 


vor wish = 


. 


| es ervree: ve - wi ish ett 
Sasad (inka ie SCI. Hit vibe! Davilatengewt 
sAr OLOde os iis ate 2 ono orisha wel 


Fi 

: 

weubettel on mao eoog Devletine) over eae. a 
uoqge) aeihee 

iq 


TBO GRaee 1) CO a ‘ag tet 3 virigiet eirf tt 
SnGivadricna A007 ms ume 28 RE aay 
P bs inet off Bande in he Tema nie” 
DOT CUsYS BIO! Ot eh eee 


is Tes  Eey tee BY) Portia vO Herdoe cnerenatt 
\ baie’ yrncie soit s preoethe siirenwelt th 


i] 
art Arh alan soln Orin negh Saga eth 


¢ 


Kilhig cinnitg ete aoe te werrneily2 a 7 lator nt 
12 sulihatiod wollen vate aviv Hat (TON 
10) UN ot pec” sing “tay i bere m. = 
Th fC omar Gldtegiy Ten oy emuae (eenled Ry 
inden of YfINGON aA aucrorioM nf aNnbl : 
oe wie Vy Jnafies vst vigayee 
owontanien ail Kolsetong al yeaa 
ai ROT Yel aT a ‘orifneesmd te, 
ineitigqursn AWRinde a ae 


fires? ad crete matt vee ae taa eon 
como brid Begs fi i aint ea 


Geld cbeb Tits Gave veM aseata oud ae 
od 2)rolilicieg Chow, Mie as Saw teeage 
fage mighew oe gguinat ¢ 


Federal Republic of Germany 


32 


The Lake Constance 
Forget-me-not 


Myosotis rehsteineri 
[Boraginaceae: Borage family] 


In the European Community, this species occurs in 
restricted areas in the Federal Republic of Germany 
and Italy where it grows along the shores of Lake Con- 
stance near Langenargen, Kressbronn, Constance 
and Bodman, and on the banks of the river Rhine 
down to Basle. It is also known from the shores of 
Lake Starnberg and from along the banks of the river 
Ticino. This species is endemic to the Alps. Outside 
EC states, it occurs in Austria, Liechtenstein and Swit- 
zerland where it is considered Endangered. 


Along the shores of Lake Constance, the Forget-me- 
not grows on sand and shingle associated with other 
wetland plants characteristic of shallow water and 
periodic submergence. 


The species has experienced a rapid decline due to 
tourist pressure (especially camping and boating), 
pollution and consequent eutrophication. Water pol- 
lution is thought to have caused the extinction of the 
Lake Constance Forget-me-not in the Lake Lugano 
area. 


Some of the localities around Lake Constance are 
protected, but eutrophication remains a problem. A 
combination of habitat protection, improved pollution 
control, habitat management and restocking measures 
is required if the continuing decline of this species is 
to be prevented. 


Cretan Mint 


Nepeta sphaciotica 
[Labiatae: Mint family] 


The Cretan Mint is a perennial herb with white flowers, 
which grows to a height of about 10-20 cm. 


This Endangered plant is one of many species which 
are endemic to the island of Crete, where it grows on 
the northern side of Mount Svourichti in the Lévka Ori 
(White Mountains) at an altitude of about 2,300 metres. 
The piant is confined to calcareous rocks and screes 
on a north-facing slope. Like many of the rare en- 
demic plants of Crete, this species has always had a 
restricted distribution and inhabits a relatively inac- 
cessible location. 


However, there is concern that overgrazing in the 
Cretan mountains may be threatening the survival of 
the Cretan Mint because sheep eat the flowers and 
prevent the production of seed. In the late 1960s less 
than 50 plants were found to be surviving and the 
species is now considered to be in great danger of ex- 
tinction unless a combination of habitat protection 
and other conservation measures can be immedi- 
ately taken. 


The main priorities are to protect the habitat from 
overgrazing, with parallel measures to take the spe- 
cies into cultivation with the aim of reintroducing 
nursery-grown plants back into the wild. Without these 
measures, the Cretan Mint may well become extinct in 
the near future. 


33 


A species of Nepeta 


Ant i mm Pe te i et eye _ . ! , 


ahat> 


“se , wwe aia TE 4 Be i by 1 ort a ergs 4g 
: ; ny ewe Hirao Mle ; y 
Sant Rae ‘SD chavs rm je | 
2istSstins ek eye 60! 
' 6 oe nT 7 (iain smi » 
; tee) WV Eis Sov canoes 


It? YESS 5 ED a 


wt). A grikeusieve te STIS 
ifiet02 GC) Oringladi'! ec ve 
A MSEwOe sri ves ces Ripe 


Sel FIVE oYE aif fl bese & 
ai) ban Onis ec 31 Gru) oew ainaiq 
29S IONS Hag Led w bowtienoo wore 
Ne Ladletario rrouversidinos. « nani 
Gan. wa wa Mery ; Tic taRSS, 


(Mot) Tedur ef? ‘cern of et emlingh 
O94 nil! aay Grae “Lemar i@tomedg rw Be Te 
CARCI to fle ary cer nee 
Gaertn Nw wt) ats Aeed-aruiy he 
Abia Umea Sew yor fingered? 


Federal Republic of Germany 


= 


Distribution of Elb Water Oropwort in the Federal Republic 
of Germany. Belgian localities not shown (data not 
available). 


Elb 
Water Dropwort 


Oenanthe conioides 
[Umbelliferae: Carrot family] 


This plant is known only from the valley of the Lower 
Elbe and tributaries between Zollenspieker/Howe 
near Hamburg and Gluckstaat in Schleswig-Holstein, 
Federal Republic of Germany, and two localities in 
Belgium. It grows with other tall wetland plants in riv- 
erside wetlands depenaent upon a special flooding 
regime. 


The Elb Water Dropwort has declined in all its loca- 
tions. In the FRG it is primarily threatened by dyking 
and deepening of the River Elbe. This activity has 
eliminated the seasonal flooding necessary for the 
survival of this Endangered plant. Embankment of 
many tidal rivers with resulting disturbance and frag- 
mentation of remaining populations has caused fur- 
ther declines. 


Four nature reserves have been established but the 
largest remaining population of 200 plants at Moor- 
burg is threatened by works to extend the harbour. 


Rhodes Peony 


Paeonia rhodia 
[Paeoniaceae: Peony family] 


The Rhodes Peony grows up to 40 cm tall and has 
large dark green leaves cut into oval segments and 
white flowers 7-10 cm across with orange-yellow sta- 
mens and a strong and fragrant smell of cloves. This 
most handsome plant, related to the Cretan peony 
(Paeonia clusii) of Crete and Karpathos, is Virtually 
restricted to the island of Rhodes, although scat- 
teered populations are found on the islands of Kos, 
Lesbos and Samos in the eastern Aegean. 


Itis known from nine localities in total, five of which are 
on the slopes of Mount Profitas Elias in the centre of 
Rhodes, where the peony is still locally frequent. How- 
ever, the habitat is not extensive and has suffered 
from severe forest fires, especially during the summer 
of 1987 when huge areas of the island's woodland 
and scrub were devastated. 


On Profitas Elias, the Rhodes Peony grows between 
400-800 metres in small stands of a few square 
metres within open woodland dominated by Calabrian 
Pine and cypress. It provides a magnificent spectacle 
in April, flowering alongside several species of wild 
orchid including the spectacular Komper's Orchid 
(Comperia comperiana) at one of its few European 
Stations. These woods are of considerable importance, 
not only for their rich flora but also because they 
contain stands of native cypress on the steep and 
rocky ground. 


The Rhodes Peony is threatened by the destruction. 
of its habitat, notably through fire, the risk of which 
grows with the increasing numbers of tourists. The 
summit ridge of Profitas Elias is easily accessible by 
road, and the plants are therefore vulnerable to pick- 
ing and trampling by both tourists and villagers, espe- 
Cially at Easter when peonies and other striking flow- 
ers are used to decorate churches. Profitas Elias 
should be established as a nature reserve, and full 
protection given to its forests and diverse fiora. 


£8 A\ a 


35 


qed zobod A = 


aso Mm Bac 25 wi 


\ 
i¥iri ul yrue= lao Re ay tel | le 
aaet beye Tet md OF-O3 Glenroy yaa tod at 
-trter atmareien aves enh ia egvEel MuNYP ad apts! J 
ius waltay ones (iiwitgets ne Ot % nanan asthy 
tt T cewsgir in. eens Wie fe putinedageanih | - 
yacess iter) el} os Deteest tex) aepagonedt t= 
itevtaa seat nie an) tS Seen 
SS 


ae eat ahinees Ree : : 
—" Amo tses © a 


Cretan Date Palm 


Phoenix theophrasti 


[Palmae: Palm family] 


> Main area af distribution (Crete) 


e Outlying locality on Nisiros 


The Cretan Date Palm is one of only two species of 
palm native to Europe. This, together with its classical 
appearance and its tendency to form palm groves at 
isolated localities behind sandy bays along stretches 
of Cretan coastline, have attracted increasing interest 
from tourists and film-makers alike. 


Within the European Community, the palm is con- 
fined to Crete, although one outlying locality is be- 
lieved to occur on the Aegean Island of Nisiros. Until 
about two years ago, the Cretan Date Palm was 


Gn 


believed to be endemic to Greece, but new palm- 
groves have now been located on the Datca Penin- 
sula of south-west Turkey. 


A slender tree, up to 12 metres high, the Cretan Date 
Palm often has several trunks and acrown of leaves 2- 
5 metres long. Its typical habitat consists of damp 
gullies and valleys leading down to the sea which 
have high water tables and are subject to seasonal 
flooding. 


On Crete, five main populations are known, the larg- 
est being at Vai in the north-east extremity of the 
island, where it extends over an area of around one 
square kilometre and supports some 700 trees. Due 
to tourist and other human pressures in the past, this 
site has now been declared a nature reserve and 
access to the grove is by permit only. Elsewhere on 
the island, however, the remaining populations are 
small, scattered and receive no protection. At Preveli, 
on the south coast, the palm grove is located in a 
small riverine valley and is threatened by campers 
who cause major damage by cutting the basal fronds 
for use as shelters. As the palm regenerates from the 
base of the main trunk, this activity is very harmful and 
unless itis prohibited, the palm grove will become ma- 
ture and eventually die out from the lack of young 
trees. The site at Preveli has also suffered from fires 
started by campers and because protective Pistacia 
scrub has been cleared to make access easier. 


Even though the palm grove at Vai is protected, it is 


still the target of thousands of tourists who visit each 
year to see the palms and picnic. Potential danger 


from fire is therefore high. 


mied sie neisiD 
eC OB Aner! 


Fylrru! relat geri) 


rpm tartcomepey o fe 
neg teteno! wor mwmD 
wari mene aut 


The place name ‘Finiki’, meaning palm, is not uncom- 
mon in the Aegean region and this suggests that the 
palms remaining today may represent the fragments 
of a formerly much larger and more widespread 
population. This beautiful tree has a strong place in 
local culture and has now become a tourist attraction 
on Crete, featuring on postcards throughout the is- 
land and as a theme for café names. This suggests 
widespread support for the palm’s protection. Any 
conservation measures taken must therefore take 
into account, not only the paim’s special ecological 
requirements, but the needs and demands of the local 
community and the tourists that flock to see it each 
year. 


Of the Cretan localities, only the one at Vai is ade- 
quately protected. Additional conservation measures 
are needed atits other localities, particularly at Preveli, 
the second largest population on Crete. 


The Cretan Date Palm is related to the Cultivated Date 
Palm (Phoenix dactylifera) and could prove important 
in the future for breeding new hybrid cultivars, possi- 
bly with improved disease resistance, which may 
prove to be economically valuable. 


@ Distribution of the main localities of Cretan Date-palm on Crete 
(other localities consisting of scattered trees are not mapped) 


37 


38 


Sardinian 
Gooseberry 


Ribes sardoum 
[Grossulariaceae: Gooseberry family] 


The Sardinian Gooseberry is known from only one 
locality on Sardinia, where it grows at Monte di Oliena 
in Su Prada. It is a small spineless shrub, reaching a 
height of 1.5 metres, which grows on calcareous 
rocks at an altitude of 1,200 metres in a small damp 
valley. There are only 30 or so gooseberry shrubs in 
the sole population which extends over approximately 
200 square metres in a habitat of scrub and upland 
garrigue. Many other of Sardinia’s rare or endemic 
plants also grow in this area. 


Monte di Oliena is included in the area of the pro- 
posed National Park of Gennargentu but is not yet 
protected. The main threat to the Sardinian Goose- 
berry is fire and its poor regenerative capacity. Italian 
botanists consider that this species may be heading 
for extinction in the wild. 


Full protection of its habitat is required, together with 
suitable management in situ to produce better condi- 
tions for its survival. Such management should in- 
clude reducing grazing pressure, creating fire breaks 
and consideration to a programme of artificial propa- 
gation with subsequent reintroduction of plants to the 
wild. A study of its population biology may also shed 
light on why it does not reproduce well in the wild. 


=, 


aniseed 


Muu Aas SEC 
yarn Viner oon) cannes cece) 


om yo met Far @ yredwiows, « bie 
Gre) leno elm ewenn 4 ow bos miritiié, a re VAC 
Orie Gils aetna: lene ¢ gh ee 
See es Ao een fotiw Soe’! | pte 
Cry arr, bh eptn OOS, ? \) etal ig Hi 1S a. 
Oe watteang 02 wo OF YO EE eT yore 
wv @Ghere, foriw egy oc at 
Bee cio SS WA) BA ae ti tt Wc sO 
ow 2 rinses 6 write yA Maprty. 


‘ ypeva aiggan won 'c wieia 


et eff oo pure ati Wi betwen a a Pel 1b arcs 
Wy fon a Bid Windyinrie? 90 Wis) onetiayi DetDg 
—9000D henite? ort oF imei} aime ori) cay ousdg 
nowtatl VERSO vilarany Uerrman a! Tapia 420 
gewbant. act Ym werceiye Wf %i Ter Bas Abinto: 


Hwee eoitaritas 1 


lillies him peli br AMD exiito ead 
dice vaned 821 ab oh Oh Ne: POWtoiy ull Sen, 
“fl UhIOre Inammagariam cisU liviiie 2)! 0! sel! 
Steet cit grime weusind prime proud” shu 
“qety leksiine joerrrmeirs © OL @yebeoSo bile 
SMaLarNa te hotouboNeA INeypartive Miw noling 
Certs Gute. Ya gis nolniuady atte yous & bw 
le Ort nt Maw qaubenqe) lof sent NW ynw nc Migl 


sivas © 


Shore Dock 


Rumex rupestris 
[Polygonaceae: Dock and knotweed family] 


The Shore Dock is undistinguished in appearance 
and might be thought to be just another wayside 
dock. However, it is one of the world's rarest docks, 
restricted to the Atlantic coasts of Europe from north 
Spain to Wales. It has erect, branched stems 30-100 
cm tall, oblong to narrowly oval, rather bluish-green 
leaves, and clusters of small flowers - the fruits of 
which bear 3 corky floats by which they are dispersed 
in sea-water. 


This dock is known from Galicia in north-west Spain, 
Britanny and Normandy in north-west France, the 
Channel Isles, south-west England and from Angle- 
sey inWales. The localities are scattered and the plant 
is nowhere common. For example, although wide- 
spread in Britain at the beginning ofthis century, 1989 
figures indicated that only about 13 sites remain, eight 
of which contain a total of less than 250 plants. 


The habitat of the Shore Dock is the upper part of 
seashores, especially where a stony beach lies adja- 
cent to a Cliff that is damp with fresh water seepage, 
but sometimes in damp places in sand dunes. The 
plant is Vulnerable and has declined dramatically due 
to pressures of tourism, including both seaside build- 
ing development and trampling of its unstable habitat 
by large numbers of visitors. Afforestation of sand 
dunes has also destroyed suitable habitat for it at one 
Welsh locality. In Finistere (France) the Shore Dock 
has become Extinct at many former localities due to 
the invasion of its habitat by Hottentot Fig (Carpobro- 
tus edulis), an introduced daisy-like plant originally 
from South Africa. 


It is very important that the remaining localities be 
protected from unrestricted public access and other 
pressures. Consideration should also be given to the 
restoration of former habitats that have become 
degraded by, for instance, invasion of Carpobrotus. 


a 


39 


we 


ity 


ltanig ~ 
NUCHING Of 
¥v80 Orn 
Gra \x 
“garb Hi 
| deley 
390 ear - 
Vth arty 


oe ti 
~ 3 
he etsy 


(ey) 


——_—- 


Venetian Glasswort 


Salicornia veneta 
[Chenopodiaceae: Goosefoot family] 


The Venetian Glasswort, like all members of the genus 
Salicornia, is confined to shallow saline waters and 
has fleshy, cylindrical stems that ‘crackle underfoot’. 
Many species of Sa/icornia are considered a delicacy 
and are popular in local cuisine. The Venetian Glasswort 
is confined to the tidal shores of the Venice Lagoon, 
which is a fragile coastal environment, threatened by 
infilling for the construction of industry and other 
developments. Pollution has also altered the water 
quality and plant life of the lagoon. In particular, 
pollution from sewage and agricultural fertilisers has 
caused a plague of seaweed, large quantities of which 
have to be dredged from the lagoon each day. The 
ecology of the shoreline and intertidal areas is 
particularly threatened by accumulating piles of rotting 
seaweed which are stranded at high tides and by 
mechanical beach-cleaning operations which become 
necessary to clear them. 


The Venetian Glasswort is an example of a species 
where a combination of measures are required to 
ensure its protection. As a priority, the fragile shore- 
line habitat must be safeguarded, by prohibiting land 
reclamation and other damaging developments. In 
addition, there is an urgent need to curb the use of 
agricultural fertilisers, so that pollution of rivers enter- 
ing the lagoon and the consequent effects of the 
seaweed plague are reduced. 


~~ $rowzeals) neiisna¥ 
gjerey Birnoots2 


{yirtat rootsens. 2 satacelboeare | 


gating vittlo redo heretl noaant) auras ori 
tera 27eNew ofillec wollte Gg) Santings ci E@cucnind 
Sapte wldcin7' we! eenate igcivbnitys fies" eat 

dparetiennn mero vie eo ease vr" 


sanat wer io oll intact POS YBa 


Holzmann’s Catchfly 


Silene holzmannii 
[Caryophyllaceae: Carnation family] 


This small catchfly is an erect, unbranched annual 
plant upto 20 cmtall, with paired lance-shaped leaves 
and small pinkish flowers. It is a rare plant of scattered 
distribution through the European part of the south- 
ern Aegean Sea, where it is mostly restricted to very 
small islands. Some of these islands are remote, but 
many are adjacent to larger islands or mainland coasts 
which are becoming increasingly susceptible eitherto 
severe disturbance from repeated visits by tourists or, 
more seriously, by the use of these islands for short 
term grazing by goats. 


Holzmann’s Catchfly is thought to occur at 13 locali- 
ties but further investigation is needed to establish 
whether the plant still survives at all these sites. It is 
part of a unique community of small plants that has 
evolved on islands; its fine adaptation to this habitat is 
shown by its fruits which are able to float and survive 
in sea water and this is its major method of dispersal 
from one island coast to another. 


The often tiny islands where the catchfly grows could 
be granted strong protection if grazing were prohib- 
ited. (Apparently, even a few goats left on these 
islands can cause total destruction to the vegetation 
in a very short time.) 


Furthermore, careful diversion of tourists away from 
sensitive zones on some of the more accessible 
islands, especially in Attica and eastern Crete, would 
benefit greatly the chances of this species’ survival. 


41 


4 

Wrists. e'nasosloHl -s 
a at A ' > 

>a 

bh os eae 

(yirewt rcnir mn ' ONMIO] J eo) i 

vasa hertscrmnu ») Anno. heme eat a 


eevee tage Weal Dewi Tm IMS OR or quanmg® 47 
peestente sh M159 sito aie A 2 owed? hall: ners Ene ‘ies 
STE ATO PUN) eodeicy i 
Vw OF beriiae yen 

td 220i ory) alriae! we 
saeco Wiektan we ttre 
ONIN ORR arn y Chan 

4G ATRL vd ote ote 201! 
Perit 3) sOttiele’ Geil > ae: o 


“gol 6? te twode of Why ortt wi yitriatad @ 
fioiiieme of bobeer & icitegtnevnd verte 
27 cite eta) th io auviviim GH melg 

tar tert} ainsi) Verre to giiareneae eupir ate 
2 Petiev) 8h oI novetehs oni ay: shnatel 9 Ge 
aun bit jeo8 ct shige soir asuvt af ye 
Weerscnib to Davila Milern at a oir: tra? 
teffinen et Ran | * 


Bion ewer L) yiriotan art} wart etnies? yi 
iY SEV HRIZBID |) NoMoNtany once 
new. ne Mi! lies wel a ave vie 
MGlisiegay ela! neitoutient) (ted pare 
I aes 


hed yows cue! newnevid Mires 
elkfennion 0) @1 to emo af 2 
bow 20S resiae DIT ea/nA yim 
ivi aoigeete eit 6 Caco, aril’ 


= 
i 
= 1 
—— 
+ * i 
—2 9 - 
+ 

Se ae a 

‘i 


Bristle Fern 


Trichomanes speciosum 
[Hymenophyllaceae: Filmy Fern family] 


A fern with thin, membranous and highly dissected 
leaves some 10-40 cm long which arise froma creep- 
ing stem usually embedded in fissures of sandstone 
or similar porous rock close to streams and waterfalls. 


The Bristle Fern grows in situations with constant 
flowing water, and because of its very thin texture, is 
confined to highly moist, often dark, crevices and 
gullies in deep narrow wooded valleys in areas of high 
rainfall. Throughout its range it is threatened by defor- 
estation and the drying out of small watercourses. It 

: has also become established in isolated man-made 
Note: Bristle Fern is also scattered throughout the Atlantic : : 

Islands (distribution not mapped here) wells or mine-shafts in France and Ireland. 


This Vulnerable fernis a representative of a fast dimin- 
ishing ancient subtropical flora and is of high scientific 
interest. 


The Bristle Fern is scattered throughout the Atlantic 
Islands where it is often associated with the native 
laurel cloud forest, a habitat which is critically threat- 
ened. In northern Spain it is present in a number of 
localities where it is particularly threatened by 
encroaching Eucalyptus plantations. The few popula- 
tions inthe French Pyrenees are Endangered and the 
single Portuguese population may be Extinct. In both 
Britain and Ireland it islegally protected and one of the 
British sites is located within a National Nature Re- 
serve. One population is known inthe Apuane Alps of 
northern Italy where it requires protection. 


In the past this attractive fern was highly sought after 
for decorating the sitting rooms of Victorian England 
and elsewhere in Europe, and many wild populations 
a were completely removed as a result. 


CC) 


42 


= ; . Lo ae f 
wio4 shziva : i 
muaciogaz caratiariont = . 4 
fytodh tia yor arapccnyrianderny | a . 
perpen escape PME : -% 4 
paren tpt ses Git Aig ae oe, 
seweel 1) BOD yHeL Sli 
sane aaenpotere Fm ony ~ ; : we. 
se ail wi eo 


YL gwar erie ath 
Ne saueerall ee tire 


par ayant eer a 
_ ee ee oe oe 


Senglih pte tele veceiece oom tl 
(eget Deep ear? OM 


Threatened tulips 


of Greece 
Tulipa spp. 


[Liliaceae: Lily family] 


Goulimy’s Tulip (Tulipa goulimyi) is a beautiful tulip 
which grows to about 10-25 cm tall and has brilliant 
orange-red flowers 4-5 cm across. It occurs only in 
the most south-eastern part of the Peloponnese, the 
adjacent islands of Elafonisos and Kithira, and at one 
station on the most westerly extremity of Crete. Alto- 
gether this tulip is known from 18 localities, but at 
almost all of them only a few individuals are present. 
Of these, even fewer actually flower each year and 
these are frequently picked by villagers. Reproduc- 
tion is principally by offsets from the bulbs, but this is 
threatened by the gathering of the sweet-tasting bulbs 
for food. Furthermore, the plant's habitat of sandy 
fields and stony or gravelly places amongst low scrub, 
often near the sea, is being eroded by ine expansion 
of arable cultivation and glasshouse construction and 
by the development of the coast for tourism. Bulbous 
plants, suchas the Goulimy’s Tulip, are vulnerable not 
only to the use of herbicides for weed control, but also 
to modern deep ploughing which precludes their sur- 
vival even on the margins of arable fields. 


In order to conserve this threatened plant, areas of 
suitable habitat should be protected against agricul- 
tural and building development, especially on Kithira 
where Goulimy’s Tulip is still locally frequent. Digging 
up the bulbs, mostly done by children, should be 
strongly discouraged, perhaps as part of a general 
educational campaign about the value of wild flowers. 


Another species, Wavy4eaved Tulip, (Tulipa undulati- 
folia), which grows in cultivated fields, may be even 
more critically threatened as a result of deep plough- 
ing. 50 years ago it was sold by the bucket in the 
Athens flower market but the main reason for its 
decline is changing agricultural methods rather than 
picking. 


Total known distribution of Goulimy’s Tulip 


Wavy-leaved Tulip 


uly 
it creas AR 
ste 5 < o> i 
eios Dsiisiedig 
- 4 — 
YIOTO Ve ai 
~ : ib 
= r a 
Nat vis \amecisell ft esl 
vs u 
i: iG 
CR TNR Sand a at. “yer, MOG Si\\uT) Ott y Witikane). z 
NM tsit- tes lM tte Beery te Of ewety mini, © (7 
; r. 
MVIeP UA ff op ' 


EN ARORA Neti 40 nen cc aemarttone Nheaer ark ih 
APS 20S ESBS ole bys 2 Hcy iol) Neches mreomba aD 
- Line 4 ; ! ocha 
“OTA IGS CUREIAD witty tec 2 i he notte 5 
Gwe GT iow wwced m led cute see 
JNQIAIG HAG eye rit te thy 
AE IORY AS ee yRance awh Hee ae as 
UIAREA ebay at bassin: ert wat eet. 
Rett Sud aay) my Vist! ein aed 
PON Dil teenetatiy ny 


Lin 
Na ot (llepeonatiy Sheng * 
) | grit atime 4 
VADeriti: Oy chailebe rt. 2, verte, SU Suing? /Bogtiss 
WUDA WOR ni tig oe 7G yilevin oe verte 
ORME Ott y6i lepucrc Yreecs-ii aus oft aan 
BA yo thar Ladies er NOs hoepenm 
PUCICNE .Teetmticet set ba . . 


Sort! ty eu ae ark 
TOE larvae he gue ligt fe Vries orifee Aoi Je 


PUIG IC Severe hows eg russ Sore 2h Men eae pattem 
WE NaH? at ipnehy Hl aisdets 
atigod a; 


i. 
sie 
y 


rue uss arp 
COU aA orth age 
lo aun aig tonnietnaans oh e-iaburtog ot Sty | 
gins Tht. Ces oct Siverie ead wig 
WARN nig) ¥ Mactan te Orewa ved prviteliud Bog : 
On Es0: snniiD sn) Cr deo) Ith a CRT Senne a 

FE Dhcie snagstilithe vet eceviy witseen olen galt 
Run 22 tay on atateg CORR Yigrg 
sara DIN TS ania srt yaw eataqonns Cu a t 


4 * 


A species cf Veronica 


Mount Iti Speedwell 


Veronica oetaea 
[Scrophulariaceae: Foxglove family] 


Mount Iti speedwell is a rather hairy annual plant not 
more than 5 cm tall, with tiny, narrow leaves and 
inconspicuous flowers. Despite its diminutive stature, 
it is one of the most interesting plants of the Greek 
mountains, being restricted to the upper slopes of 
Mount Iti, south-west of Lamia in central Greece, 
where it occurs in just two temporary pools formed 
from snow melt in the spring. Its nearest relatives 
occur in western Asia. 


The habitat of Mount Iti Speedwell is a very special- 
ised one which is vulnerable and very localised through- 
out Europe. Not long after the discovery of the spe- 
cies in 1976, its only known site became threatened 
due to bauxite mining nearby. This brought consider- 
able disturbance to the general area. Ancilliary devel- 
opments such as the construction of mine and for- 
estry roads placed further pressures on the area. 


A site survey is now needed to determine whether the 
species has survived this interference as the pools 
themselves are very fragile, being shallow and only a 
few metres in diameter — they are therefore very 
sensitive to even quite small changes in the local 
environment. 


It is imperative that any further mining of bauxite or 
construction of roads be directed away from these 
pools and their catchment area. Indeed, the whole 
area of Mount Itiis of major scientific interest and has 
a rich flora that includes a number of species rare or 
endemic to Europe. It is therefore clear that Mount Iti 
merits special protection, and any activity likely to 
damage the flora (and fauna) should be prohibited. 


‘ 


=—~< 


~~ Ilbswheege itl tauel 
BHMHO BNO 
iyi? evens seman gc) 


fa jasly hounine hniayettin oo We;tesce tH invol! — 
phe eves WOR) VON Maw Meouna-2 nant aon 
ilies eviunlonih atl liq cower ayougenouni 
eres olen le Hehe ai fi 
o We MA OF Dayarveiy Delby enimrivorn 
Witte re gintes To Rawerituce Jt iin 

beceryt ecko OTN GW! JCheL Muieso Y ater 
pean Waser 6) .oneds sitet Ren: wune ap) 
EA Matta of itigao 


PA) ® pe 9 HT Wen es petiokeirt apt 
a he aims + ort wio cee 
pm ye 0M age dc 

re, a BEF ai ebm 
Mac horonrsteo yon ‘patties qeindor sub 

| pet iaaitarA aan tewrigg gio: esendym!s 90r 

(Ae re arten to nora ntarioo «tt on dae ptieemnas 


nO seminal Vor tx omi2 eve) ihe 
towbar wen siyiarwa ote A 


Viviparous 
Chain Fern 


Woodwardia radicans 
[Blechnaceae: Chain fern family] 


Arobust fern, with leaves up to 2.5 metres long arising 
from a short thick stem that remains close to the 
ground. The blade of the leaf comprises deeply toothed 
leaflets and bears near the tip a young plantlet which 
eventually establishes itself independently. The re- 
productive bodies (clusters of spore-cases) are in 
chain-like groups on the underside of the leaf. 


Woodwardia radicans, like all chain ferns must have 
its roots in water or moist soil and are found associ- 
ated with rocky streams in steep-sided valleys or in 
scrubby more open valley floors where natural under- 
ground drainage channels provide the right environ- 
ment. The species is therefore Vulnerable and threat- 
ened by schemes to remodel watercourses and other 
activities involving the management and canalisation 
of drainage channels. 


The main centre for the Viviparous Chain Fern is the 
Atlantic !slands: the Canarylsies, Madeiraand Azores, 
where the fern is characteristically found in gullies and 
ravines associated with remnant laurel forest, a criti- 
cally threatened habitat which has been subject to 
much recent clearance and replacement with forestry 
plantations of Japanese Larch (Cryptomeria japon- 
ica). Remnant populations of the Viviparous Chain 
Fern in north Portugal and northern Spain are threat- 
ened by re-afforestation and the making of extraction 
roads which is changing water-courses. There are 
only three sites in Italy, where the species is protected 
by provincial laws, and one in Sicily, but active man- 
agement is needed if it is to survive. The sole French 
site is in north Corsica and is unprotected. The single 
population in western Crete is threatened by agricul- 
tural development. 


45 


Note: Also present througnout the Atlantic Islands 


Ss 


[4a 


iV { 

. ‘ i, 

~ he i ‘en. 

: Sreeli cit lavas ee 


| ~ = 2% 
} Ti eitsitan wit) aouwtjei5) ; . 
\ 


Ours Trot Aa ii GL <3 eal thy a tauigy A: q 
iT Oo) SSgio aso tet! role Rt | 

Hariiocnvicsco annttqies fo! ati to aad at pan 
‘Soh taunplg qruny Gaal etl (en eed Sg gela) 79 
a) wit ylnetwi i ‘lon euceaies Macarena © 
MY. ott (eee ee io "ev; SHbed as 


| tool Ota wy Mi equeng qbrnera ia 


~+-- —-- - Team? evil iucrene: carp il6 el rai 
Heahial NEAR we Neon I towses omy Leen \ ‘Kosee Diuat ore op jor ‘ero Ty eee ee ’ 
a ow. " ¢ O10 BVEaSY. Dot Cmers 0| arr yiigy pote - 
[ WetrThs ares OCI WHOS VBE Td E 
oa. ! oy iES Wior @efl abit 
- eT PAs iy aa 
‘seitio Soc ee elites! i 
Togs lei Gre ieeriegioriam au y 


i] e¢ 


321 ae suc atte ai 
sTosAQ pene) A der! “nee 
Cris uel hed fitinvGt malay aie 
a> o batch iain iirwier 

ot tisayhey fel amit iti oe 
ie vicar Fin prion: Oats 
SOR BION VD} ITT 


Bf Linana algarviana 


Cabo St Vincente 


@ Thymus camphoratus 


© Thymus cephalotus 


Atlanac Ocean 


Cabo St Vincente 


Distribution of some rare and threatened endemic plants of the 
Algarve, Southern Portugal 


Some threatened 
plants of Portugal 


Wild plants 
of the Algarve 


Thymus camphoratus and Thymus cephalotos 
[Labiatae: Mint family] 


Linaria algarviana 
[Scrophulariaceae: Foxglove family] 


The Portuguese Algarve remains a wondertul place 
for its wealth of wild flowers, although pressure for 
tourism developments is constantly reducing the extent 
and distribution of natural and semi-natural vegeta- 
tion. One of the richest areas for plant life in Portugal 
is the ‘Berrocal’ region of the Algarve - a zone of 
limestone which begins at Cabo St Vincente (the 
south-west corner of Portugal), extending to Tavira to 
the east. Many interesting and colourful plants are 
found in this area, including a number of species 
which are endemic to Portugal, such as the Berrocal 
Thyme “Tomilho Cabegudo” (Thymus cephalotos), a 
distinctive aromatic dwarf shrub which grows in open 
stony areas. 


Two other plants endemic to the Algarve and of world 
Endangered status also grow nearby, along a short 
windswept stretch of coast to the east of Cabo St 
Vincente, between Odeceixe and Sagres. This area of 
spectacular limestone coast is known as the ‘Barlav- 
ento’. Its grazed headlands support a rich flora of 
herbs and aromatic dwarf shrubs including the Cam- 
phor Thyme (Thymus camphoratus) and Algarvian 
Toadflax (Linaria algarviana). The latter species has 
attractive violet-coloured flowers measuring up to 2.5 
cm iniength, which are spotted with white or yellow. 


‘bemeisoill sao 
legaiie4d to 2inely 


@asig bHW 
gvizniA attic | 
eons autrHtT tye talaclivdss cute 


fee rl aes) 
pharcurne onnras 
Ehoueail aarpaealusrigde 3": | 


hetngabind ovina gesiunio’ siT 
atte arewol fer. iat ot ac! 

: harcsh kyr vil) abiios 

‘ bets tat pode ore 
emt eae desHiSh ett Own youl 
@tt im nows? ‘Bone ort. 


io ae Binet id 


i 


hw 


acy *o CHMRIQ Sr vctred Geraase! One wed 


~~ ¢ 
<o- 


j 
f 
} 
: 


- The south-west coast of the Algarve, and the ‘Berro- 
H cal’ limestone zone are both very important floristi- 
{ cally and many foreign ‘botanical tourists’ visit the 
: area every year. It is to the credit of the Portuguese 
* government that illegal building has recently been 
stopped in some parts of the sensitive coastal zone 
near Cabo St Vincente, but pressure for tourism de- 
velopment everywhere in the Algarve remains signifi- 
cant and there are further threats from quarrying. 
Actionto protect remaining areas of natural and semi- 
natural vegetation, including the zones where the two 
endemic thymes grow, is urgently required. Such 
areas are undoubtedly worthy of special designation, 
such as a Special Protection Area. 


Abrotea 


Asphodelus bento-rainhae 


@ Abrotea: area of distribution 


[Liliaceae: Lily family) 


This elegant white-flowered asphodel is a herbaceous 
perennial which grows up to one metre tall. It is 
endemic to Portugal and is known from east-central 
Portugal where it grows in clearings and glades in 
native forests of Pyrenean oak (Quercus pyrenaica) 
and along the edges of roads. The Abrotea has a 
restricted distribution, usually on slopes with a north- 
easterly aspect and is confined to the mountain area 
of Guardunha, around Fundao. 


It is permanently threatened from fire, mostly started 
deliberately and further threatened because of un- 
regulated and increasing expansion of cherry or- 
chards on the mountain slopes. 


The exact population and distribution of this rare plant 
is not precisely known. However, the creation of 
nature reserves at Guardunha is urgently required in 
order give protection to the Abrotea and the remain- 
ing native oak forests in which it grows. 


47 


onad ert! ona, viens aii ig mao Ver a | ” 
Hieron nerreard Wikw aiod m5 2 08 storgril Yay F 
wi tly “Stehuoy hamymiod’ nyt? yr ene lla 
apa gurot are to nero-arit cy al 4 Wiay Cove megs 
cesgytnass: tar newbies wae iat ine meee ti 
“cpt tdimess wviftares wie ahoq whee ni pen ay 
AETROuOT ts! Geet Wet ata 3 Od8D taan 
fiity fe TMA eit rit vacwerave memigaey = 
RONTalp ot Alec t witout gue earth one mag: hr! 
{ofne DOR TUNE io een tir mervuat ri eal i 
onl A IL eID a(th Orioulont.« . 
tsue Catugar vines & «ng pose a 'S 
Nie ab iBiowes fo yt ove ya 


A icltors 


oe gS jonas 
iii vom ne a 4 GRP UOT wubtenge 


“i (yene vil ome, . f 


rer #5) lanereyne to awceatintwerr 
2) aa Siem ah GO) ov ewan (elev | 
Faas ings! Wetyeh at bene gun of 


a 


7 4 buna vat i 
} fi) fe 
s 1 “0 


a i 


na 
o 


CONSERVATION SUMMARIES 


2: LOWER PRANES 


fo Se 
* * 
* * 
* *« 
ete ok 


A selection of threatened species from Annex I(b) of the 
"Proposal for a Council Directive on the 
protection of natural and semi-natural habitats and of wild fauna and flora" 


49 


ie 


SaLAAMMU2 VOITAV Ssavi0? ae 
2TMAIT ASWOE SS eo 


Distribution: All Member States of the EC 


ik 


Member States where Large Crimson Wax Cap is 
threatened (declining in ali otners) 


i) 
8 @ 
C) 
eG ) 


50 


Large Crimson 
Wax Cap 


Hygrocybe punicea 
[Hygrophoraceae: Wax Cap Family] 


Large Crimson Wax Cap is a large, bright red toad- 
stool which is a species of old, agriculturally unim- 
proved grassland. It prefers calcareous soils, usually 
of clay or loam which are poor in humus. 


This fungus has declined over its entire range, par- 
ticularly in the north-west European lowlands. 


Large Crimson Wax Cap is threatened for a variety of 
reasons including abandonment of pastures and their 
afforestation, the use of artificial fertilisers and liquid 
manure, and the ploughing up of old grassland. 


In view of the intensification of agricultural practices 
throughout Europe, this species is regarded as ex- 
tremely Vulnerable, even in areas where it is still 
relatively frequent. 


Many other species of fungi which are characteristic 
of old pastures are similarly threatened, including 
those belonging to the genera Hygrocybe, Camaro- 
phyliopsis, Entoloma, Dermoloma, Clavaria, Clavul- 
inopsis and Geopglossum. 


The Large Crimson Wax Cap is listed as threatened in 
the Netherlands, Federal Republic of Germany, Po- 
land and Sweden. The most pressing conservation 
requirement for this species is to ensure that tracts of 
old grassland are maintained by traditional grazing 
practices without the use of modern fertilisers and 
liquid manures. In addition, abandoned ancient pas- 
turelands need to be identified and appropriate graz- 
ing management reinstated on them. This should also 
benefit many other declining wild flowers and lower 
plants characteristic to this threatened habitat type. 


eed wall ihe as 
“i sett son ; 


° 


a 
‘ Te et ele -_ : 
. : : i? — 
NES ok Se 
‘ . a. oe 
j ae es 


Pendulous Lichen 


Usnea longissima 
[Usneaceae] 


This is the longest pendulous lichen known in the 
northern hemisphere. reaching a length of 1-2 metres 
in favourable conditions. It can form impressive fes- 
toons hanging from tree branches and swaying with 
the wind. 


The lichen grows on trees in virgin undisturbed for- 
ests, mainly in primitive stands of spruce. Neither can 
it survive any disturbance of its habitat and disap- 
pears as soon as the air is contaminated by pollution, 
even at extremely low and undetectable quantities. It 
cannot colonise tree plantations, even in apparently 
suitable conditions. Lichenologists regard this spe- 
cies as the symbol of the vanishing lichens -- unable 
to survive modern forest management (such as re- 
moval of old and dead trees, drainage and clearance 
of the understorey) and the formidable disaster of 
acid rain. 


Fifty years ago, Pendulous Lichen was quite common 
in Scandinavia and the mountains of central Europe 
including the Alps and the Carpathian Mountains. It 
has already disappeared from all its localities in the 
Federal Republic of Germany, the French Alps and 
Italy. It is on the verge of extinction in Switzerland, 
Austria and southern Scandinavia. The only healthy 
populations now remaining are in north-west Spain 
and in two sheltered valleys in the central Pyrenees in 
France. 


The future of the species can only be secured by 
absolute protection to the undisturbed forests in which 
it survives and by implementation of strict measures 
to control all forms of air pollution throughout Europe. 


aes peri 
Aa aay iY 


vated 


ab wey HAG 
1 ee, eA TE Rey 


un 
Vy 
| 


France 


Feptnane WF A 


uf 


0 7 . uN 
\ ‘ \ 
at 
eh , 
Lavy y 
+ : se 
Ke pe oe Beal 7 ‘ 
un t OU POA Tht ‘ yy 
J phew sl 
WORD {Deny ey P \ 
+ D “bh ji ees ? te vay 
‘ r Hy Fa 7 a0 A Sates 
f a J a ve te 7 


{Cigrop ys 


\ 


‘ 


= ie 3 4 a | 
j ieee spare evolu ‘haat yi 
a : é . [evtsertet 


at mm ceaq renioli av ue 
aeenS-T 9 MPa) dB. /968" ts hon 
- arieat rg tt arco vt 
22) ervedipacters sri noo places oi 


Neto Griese in Brew oor! mg 4 Bass 


oat WOGUION Sigoy dat eNO 
fies orient (acura fo ef ee eleeregar 
Qeuh ing PA ct © == 
restated Vee rieecs = * 
A aeRdras) eke oo we ee eae 
{ wired ge Mi nit 4) ONES ort oe 
Be Sega MND Sahn) ata (nario ich rar 
Sidenn « gnorall.ceinevey srt. lo tage 
2h ee risiie) Warrejaren Reick es 
sanenets bn aQaVeTy ses) Ons Gee 
Yo mews okiehirao ai! ove hun 


PRETUTID SAI, HI ois euch g 
7 Teas fo emer ait bre: 


_- oe Shi ee igen ent one ad 
PY) = ae ri apittane! 98 te mor Omeagcaeas 
- = eee ore viigrnsat tobi 


Abrotea 

Adonis cyllenea 

Adonis distorta 

Adonis, Apennine 
Alkanet, curled 
Ammophila arenaria 
Anchusa crispa 
Angelica heterocarpa 
Angelica, Atlantic 
Asphodelus bento-rainhae 
Astragalus aquilanus 
Astragalus maritimus 
Astragalus verrucosus 
Bedstraw, Sicilian 
Birdsfoot-trefoil, Succulent 
Bog-moss 

Borderea chouardii 
Brassica cretica 
Brassica glabrescens 
Brassica insularis 
Brassica macrocarpa 
Cabbage, Coincy’s rock 
Cabbage, Cretan 
Cabbage, Egadi 
Cabbage, Fuerteventura 
Cabbage, hairless 
Cabbage, Sardinian 
Camarophyllopsis 
Campanula _ sabatia 
Carlina diae 
Carpobrotus edulis 
Catchfly, Holzmann’s 
Centaurea heldreichii 
Centaurea balearica 
Centaurea horrida 
Centaurea kalambakensis 
Centaurea lactiflora 
Centaurea megarensis 
Centaurea niederi 
Centaurea peucidanifolia 
Centaurea princeps 
Cephalanthera cucullata 
Clavaria 


INDEX OF PLANT NAMES 


pb 
anh &F kWWOND N 


Py 
aAoaOnN 


NM 
Ny oO 


—s 
omonwonwaA oO ON 


5 


52 


Clavulinopsis 
Coincya rupestris 
Comperia comperiana 
Cotton-weed 

Crambe_ sventenii 
Cryptomeria japonica 
Dermoloma 

Digitalis purpurea 
Dock, shore 
Dropwort, Elb water 
Entoloma 

Eryngium viviparum 
Eryngo, Brittany 
Eucalyptus 
Euphorbia lambii 
Fern, bristle 

Fern, hairy clover 
Fern, viviparous chain 
Fig, hottentot 
Forget-me-not, Lake Constance 
Foxglove 

Foxglove, cockscomb 
Foxglove, purple 
Galium littorale 
Gaudinia hispanica 
Gaudinia, Spanish 
Gentian, great yellow 
Gentiana lutea 
Geopglossum 
Glasswort, Venetian 
Globularia stygia 
Globularia, Styx 
Gooseberry, Sardinian 
Gypsophila papillosa 
Gypsophila, downy 
Hammarbya paludosa 
Harebell, Savona 
Helleborine, Cretan 
Hygrocybe punicea 
Isoplexis chalcantha 
Juniper 

Knapweed 

Lactuca watsoniana 


20,42 


12-14 


; _— a 


x 22M AM TUALS 10. XAG { — 


aat=one | 
* 


48ER8 


7 
ot 


mio 


i 


Wi rl, } 


a8: 
J 


a 
—s 
7 
m° 
- 


a 


: Se era ee RIES ee erer ee sens 


Lamyropsis microcephala 26 


Larch, Japanese 25 
Laser, long-rayed 27 
Laserpitium longiradium 27 
Lettuce, Watson’s 25 
Lichen, pendulous 51 
Linaria algarviana 46 
Linaria hellenica 28 
Loosestrife, wavy 30 
. Lotus kunkelii 29 
Lythrum flexuosum 30 
Marram 4 
Marsilea batardae 31 
Marsilea_ strigosa 31 
Milk-vetch 6 
Mint, Cretan 33 
Myosotis_ rehsteineri 32 
Nepeta sphaciotica 33 
Oak, Pyrenean 47 
Oenanthe conioides 34 
Orchid, bog 22 
Orchid, Komper’s 35 
Otanthus maritimus 4 
Paeonia clusii 35 
Paeonia rhodia 35 
Palm, Cretan Date 36-37 
Palm, Date 37 
Peony, Cretan 35 
Peony, Rhodes 35 
Pheasant’s-eye, Mount Killini 2 
Phoenix dactylifera 37 
Phoenix theophrasti 36,37 
Phragmites 5 
Pine, stone 20 
Pinus pinea 20 
Pistacia 36 
Quercus pyrenaica 47 
Reed 5 
Ribes sardoum 38 
Rumex rupestris 39 
Salicomia veneta 40 
Silene holzmannii 41 
Sisymbrium arundonum 16 
Speedwell, Mount Iti 44 
Sphagnum 22 


Spruce 51 


Spurge, Gomeran 
Thistle, Dia carline 
Thistle, Sardinian 
Thyme, Berrocal 
Thyme, camphor 
Thymus camphoratus 
Thymus _ cephalotus 
Toadflax, Algarvian 
Toadfiax, Maléa 
Trichomanes speciosum 
Tulip, Goulimy’s 

Tulip, wavy-leaved 
Tulipa goulimyi 

Tulipa undulatifolia 
Usnea longissima 
Veronica oetea 
Wax-cap, large crimson 
Woodwardia radicans 
Yam, Chouard’s flowering 


25,42 


‘ 3 HIT « 
ty/it 
a wet 
2 
‘ Ty 
flings AeeT 


web lalfy sMhot 

ate. “aati aA 

Ry? iste aot 
bovpghyew glu? 
ePMGOO wells 
Yeu wally 
pryian gate) 
neaeO Holts 

toot! Ogiat qi 
oe aay Wr peeE! 


oorawet eee many 


 * 


g* on 


s (eo 


As 

( c 

i 

t 

7% 
i . 
oe 
a a 


Phd 


: 


aR 
.