Skip to main content

Full text of "Journal of the Royal Society of Western Australia"

See other formats


JOURNAL OF 

THE 

ROYAL 

SOCIETY 

OF 

WESTERN 

AUSTRALIA 


Volume .6? » Part 3 • 1987 


ISSN 0035-922X 





THE 


ROYAL SOCIETY 
OF 

WESTERN AUSTRALIA 


PATRON 

Her Majesty the Queen 

VICE-PATRON 

His Excellency Professor Gordon Reid, Governor of Western Australia 


President 

Vice-Presidents 

Past President 

Joint Hon. Secretaries 

Hon. Treasurer 

Hon. Librarian 

Hon. Editor 


COUNCIL 1986-1987 


J. S. P. Beard, M.A., B.Sc., D. Phil. 

J. T. Tippett. B.Sc., Ph.D. 

J. S. Pate, Ph.D.D.Sc., FAA. FRS. 

S. J. Hailam. M. A. 

V. Hobbs, B.Sc. (Hons.), Ph.D. 

K. W. Dixon. B.Sc. (Hons.), Ph.D. 

W. A. Cowling. B..Agric.Sc. (Hons.), Ph.D. 
H. E. Balme, M.A., Grad, Dip. Lib. Stud. 
B. Dc!I, B.Sc. (Hons.), Ph.D. 


J. Backhouse, B.Sc., M.Sc. 

A. E. Cockbain, B.Sc., Ph.D. 

S. J. Curry, M.A. 

E. P. Hopkins, B.Sc., Dip.For.Ph.D. 

L. E. Koch. M.Sc., Ph.D. 

J. D. Majer, B.Sc., D.I.C.. Cert. Ed., Ph.D. 
K. McNamara. B.Sc., (Hons.), Ph.D. 

J. Webb. B.Sc.. Ph.D., Dip.Ed. 


Journal of the Royal Society of Western Australia, Vol. 69, Part 3, 1 987, p. 89-94. 


Grazing pressure by the tammar {Macropus eugenii Desm.) 
on the vegetation of Garden Island, Western Australia, 
and the potential impact on food reserves 
of a controlled burning regime 

by David T. Bell, Janine C. Moredoundl and William A. Loneragan 

Department of Botany, University of Western Australia 
Nedlands, W.A. 6009 

Manuscript received II February 1986: accepted 22 July 1986 


Abstract 

Tammar (Macropus eugenii Desm.) populations occur in a restricted number of Western Australia 
mainland locations and two offshore islands. From faecal pellet epidermal remnants and analysis of 
stomach contents, eleven plant species were documented as dietary species of the tammar 
population of Garden Island. Of special preference were the dominant shrub Acacia rosteltifera, 
introduced herbaceous species Asphadelus fistulosus and Asparagus asparagoides, and the native 
grass Stipa flavescens. Grazing damage to these species was generally restricted to localized sites thus 
assuring their continued survival on the island. Exclosure studies demonstrated a marked impact of 
grazing on Asparagus asparagoides. Geranium mode and Stipa flavescens. Two small ground herbs, 
Parietaria deoilis and Galium murale showed increases in cover in areas where larger species were 
removed by grazing. The tammar was generally attracted to areas of new growth regenerating after 
disturbance. This suggests that a planned fire management programme incorporating a system of 
fire breaks, fire protection access routes and low fuel buffers should meet the perceived objectives of 
protecting the naval installations, maintenance of the food resource and hence, continued survival 
of the tammar populations on the island. The remaining areas of long-unburnt vegetation should be 
retained to provide cover for the tammars and to conserve the native vegetation of the island, 
especially fire sensitive species. 


Introduction 

The tammar (Macropus eugenii Desm.) is a herbivore 
from the family Macropodidae. Its present range in 
Western Australia is restricted and includes only Garden 
Island, West Wallabi Island, and a few isolated pockets 
on the mainland in the south-west. In the early 1970s the 
number of tammars on Garden Island was ekimated at 
2 000 (Bakker 1973) where as current sampling suggests 
the population is around 1700 (A. Bradley, pers. 
comm.). This small wallaby is also found in South 
Australia and more panicularly on Kangaroo Island 
(Kelsall 1965). Its distribution patterns in south-west 
Australia have been associated with a range of site 
factors, but of special importance are dense thickets of 
vegetation which provide protection from predators and 
associated grass species thought to be a preferred food 
resource (Christensen 1981). 

Other studies on the tammar have concentrated on 
physiological factors (Kelsall 1965. Kinnear et ai 1968, 
Bakker et al. 1 982). Any reference to the dietary habits 
of the tammar in these studies was based on observation 
of grazing damage and extrapolations from other 
marsupial studies. Christensen (1981) studied the 
biology of the tammar in relation to fire and listed 
several major characteristics which might contribute to 
the adaptation of the tammar to a fire-prone habitat. 
These include: (1) seasonal breeding, (2) lack of 
repression of juveniles, (3) group territoriality, (4) wide 
dispersal, (5) absence of panic during fire, and (6) some 
fidelity to home range. It is, however, the direct effects 


of fire on the plant communities of Garden Island which 
will ultimately affect this population since fire 
protection is an important requirement of the recently 
established naval facilities on this island. 

Currently the W.A. Bushfires Board, W.A. 
Department of Conservation and Land Management, 
the Department of Defence (Navy) and the University of 
Western Australia Departments of Zloology and Botany 
are cooperating in a research effort to understand the 
ecology of the tammar and to develop an appropriate 
fire management plan that will both protect life and 
property and ensure the short- and long-term health and 
survival of this endangered species. The objective of this 
study was to determine the plant species important in 
the tammar diet and to make preliminary comments on 
the potential impact that a fire management plan might 
have on the population. 


Methods 

Garden Island (1I5°40’E, 32“I6’S) is a near-shore 
island centred approximately 35 km southwest of Perth 
and southward of Rottnest and Camac Islands. It 
measures 9.5 km from north to south and 2 km at its 
widest point. The islands are estimated to have been 
separated from the Western Australian mainland for 
6 000-7 000 (Main 1961). The major plant formations 
are dense stands of shrub scrub dominated by Acacia 
rostellifera and low forests dominated by Callitris 
preissii and Melaleuca lanceolata. For a more detailed 


1-53510 


89 


Journal of the Royal Society of Western Australia, Vol. 69, Part 3, 1987. 


discussion of the major landforms and the vegetation 
associations of the island, refer to McArthur and Bartle 
(1981). 

Exclosure studies 

Four tammar grazing exclosures measuring 10 x 25 m 
with 1.5 m high fences of 2 cm wire mesh were 
established in a range of plant communities and regions 
of Garden Island in May 1983 (Fig. I). Selection of the 
exclosure sites was based on evidence of local grazing by 
tammars, time since the last fire, and proximity to the 
Zoology Department’s population sampling sites. The 
Beacon Head Site, on the most northern portion of the 
island, was situated in an area classified as Acacia 
rostellifera Open Scrub; the Cliff Point Site near the 
central western coastline in an area of Melaleuca 
lanceolata Open Heath; the Denham Road Site in the 

GARDEN ISLAND 


N 



I J 


Figure 1 . — Map of Garden Island showing locations of grazing exclosures 
(•) and major vegetation types (modified from McArthur and Bartle 1981). 

90 


centre of the southern half of the island in Melaleuca 
lanceolata — Acacia rostellifera Low Open Forest, and 
the Quarry Road Site near the southeastern tip of the 
island in Melaleuca lanceolata Open Scrub. The Beacon 
Head Site was burnt in December 1982. The Cliff Point 
and Denham Road Sites probably last burned in the 
disasterous fire of January 1956 which burned most of 
the island north of Careening Bay (Baird 1958). The 
Quarry Road Site lies in a region which has probably 
remained fire-free for more than 40 years. 

Percentage cover values for all vascular species were 
visually estimated from permanently marked transects 
of ten 1 m^ quadrats. One transect was situated inside 
and one immediately adjacent but outside the exclosure 
at each site. Cover values for selected species were 
estimated in August 1983 and a full survey of all species 
was made in September 1985. From these estimates 
mean percentage cover values for species in each 
transect were determined. 

Tammar diet studies 

The dietary preferences of the tammar were 
determined by analysing the epidermal remnants from 
faecal pellets and from the stomach contents of two 
road-killed animals. A total of 40 faecal pellets were 
collected; 5 from outside each of the tammar grazing 
exclosure areas and 20 from a range of habitats generally 
distant from the Naval installations. The emphasis on 
native areas was made to reduce likely grazing by 
tammars of the irrigated lawns and domestic gardens 
within the settlement area which is known to occur 
(McArthur and Bartle 1981). One series of samples was 
obtained prior to the onset of winter rains (April, 1983) 
and a second in late winter (August, 1983). The road- 
killed animals were obtained during April 1983 from an 
area just north of the North Gate of the Naval 
installation. The stomach contents were removed 
immediately upon collection and frozen for later 
analysis. 

The identification of epidermi in the faecal pellet and 
stomach content materials followed the methods of 
Halford et al. (1984a) which were modified from the 
original techniques reported by Storr (1961) and Jain 
(1976X Comparisons of faecal pellet epidermal remnants 
to epidermal samples prepared from plant tissue 
provided information on tammar diet preferences. 
Frequencies of the proportions of the epidermal 
fragments from microscopic analysis provided an 
estimate of dietary preference (Halford et al. 1 984b). 

Direct grazing observation and re-establishment response 

Plants throughout the island were checked for direct 
signs of grazing and. where tammars could be observed 
grazing or browsing particular shrubs, these species were 
recorded. Plant species were also categorized for re- 
establishment strategy. Disturbance to a plant 
community can result from fire damage, animal grazing 
or the mechanical removal of vegetation such as occurs 
in firebreaks or alongside roads. Post-fire modes of re- 
establishment have been widely documented (Specht et 
al. 1958, Keeley and Zcdler 1978, Keeley and Keeley 
1981, Malanson and O’Leary 1982, Bell et al. 1984). In 
contrast there is a paucity of information concerning re- 
establishment strategies following grazing damage and 
mechanical disturbance. In relation to fire, species can 
be described as ephemerals, obligate seeders and 
sprouters (Bell et al. 1984), although re-establishment 
strategies may vary within a particular species as well as 


Journal of the Royal Society of Western Australia, Vol. 69, Part 3, 1987. 


between species. Mode of re-eslablishmeni may also 
vary depending upon the intensity of the fire or the 
degree of damage sustained from non-pyric 
disturbances. In the main, fire prone environments are 
high in the proportion of resprouting species (Siddiqi el 
al. 1976. Bell el al. 1984). Similarly, areas subjected to 
repeated mechanical disturbance might favour 
resprouters, although obligate seeders with a 
bradysporous habit may also survive clearing operations 
(Griffin and Hopkins 1981). Similar information is not 
available for grazed plants, but it might be assumed that 
resprouting species would, in the long term, have a 
greater chance of survival than obligate seeding species. 
The collection of re-esiablishmcnt data allowed the 
prediction of changes which might occur following an 
imposed controlled-burning regime. 


Results 

Exclosure studies 

Twenty-nine species of vascular plants were identified 
in and adjacent to the four lammar cxclosure study sites 
(Table 1 ). Only Acanlhocarpus preissii and Phyllanthus 
calycinus occurred in every' transect and only eight 
species occurred in more than half of the study transects. 
Of these common species, those showing major 
differences between the inside and the outside of the 
exclosurcs were Acanlhocarpus preissii. Asparagus 
asparagoides. Geranium molle and Stipa JJaveschis, 
which were much more common inside, arid Galium 
murale, Parietaria dehilis and Phyllanthus calycinus. 
which showed consistently higher cover values outside 
the grazing exclosures. The most obvious effect of the 
grazing exclosure occurred at the recently burned 
Beacon Head site where Asparagus asparagoides 


averaged 78.9% under protection and only 1.8% where 
exposed to grazing. 

Comparisons of mean cover values of the common 
species after about four months grazing protection 
(1983) and after more than two years protection (1985) 
showed an increase in the difference between protected 
and unprotected samples for those species with greater 
cover inside the exposures (Fig. 2). 

Faecal and stomach content studies 

Eleven different species of vascular plants were 
identified in the tammar faecal pellet material and 
stomach contents (Fig. 3). The most common were 
Asphodelus fistulosus, Acacia rostellifera and Asparagus 
asparagoides. The August faecal pellet samples included 
a greater variety of species (11 species) compared to 
either the April faecal pellet sample (5 species) or the 
April stomach contents sample (8 species). 

Re-establishment following grazing or fire 

Direct obsciwaiions of tammar grazing proved 
difficult although seven plant species were confirmed as 
dietary species. These seven species, however, had 
already been identified from faecal pellets or stomach 
content analyses. Of significance was that the tammars 
seemed to prefer young shoots of the resprouting species 
or seedlings. 

Of the forty-seven species identified from the 1983 
and 1985 samplings, only ten are known to re-establish 
from existing rootstocks following intense fires with the 
remainder either ephemerals (16 species) or obligate 
seeders (20 species) (Table 2). Of this total sample, 26% 
(12 species) were introduced, and, of the eleven dietary 
species, 27% (3 species) were introduced. 


Table 1. 

Mean percentage cover values for transects inside and outside the Garden Island Tammar exclosure study sites for data measured September 1985. 


Species 


Acacia rostellifera 
Acanlhocarpus preissii 
Anagallis spp.* 

Aspara^is asparagoides 
Asph odelus /isiulosus 
Carduus pycnocephalus 
Clematis microphylla 
Crassula cnlorata 
Daucus glochidiaius 
Eremoptula glabra 
Galium murale 
Geranium molle 
Guichenotia ledifolia 
Ilardenbergia compioniana 
Leucopogon insularis 
Leucopogon parvfJorus 
Oxalis pes-caprae 
Poranlhera microphylla 
Parietaria debilis 
Phyllanthus calycinus 
Rhagodia haccata 
Senecio lautus 
Solanum svmonii 
Sonchus oleraceus 
Spyndium glohulosum 
Stipa Jlaxescens 
Thnmasia cognala 
Trachyandra di varicata 
Zaniedeschia aelhiopica 


Beacon 

Head 


In Out 


— 3.1 

5.8 1.9 

5.2 1.4 

78.9 1.8 

— 1.4 

— 1.1 


— 0.1 

0.7 22.4 

4.6 48.8 

— 0.4 


— 0.1 

— 0.1 

0.5 6.5 


— 0.7 

3.6 0.2 


Cliff 

Point 


In Out 


0.1 0.3 

12.5 7.4 

— 1.7 

12.7 0.2 

1.3 10.1 

2.7 — 

7.3 0.4 


6.8 28.2 

23.7 0.1 

1.9 — 

9.5 — 


0.9 8.8 


0.5 — 

10.2 0.1 

0.2 — 

— 0.5 


Denham 

Road 


In Out 


2.0 43.7 

24.0 13.7 

1.1 — 

— 0.2 

— o.s 


— 0.2 

16.1 — 


6.2 56.1 

0.4 1.1 

0.3 — 


0.1 — 

5.8 0.1 


2.6 0.2 


Quarry 

Road 


In Out 


86.0 62.4 

— 0.1 


36.1 0.1 

— 0.1 

— 0.4 

1.0 0.8 

6.9 — 

8.1 — 

0.1 2.1 

0.1 — 

— 0.1 

3.4 4.2 

0.2 7.8 

0.4 — 

0.4 — 

0.3 — 

0.5 — 

— I.O 

— 1.3 

3.2 0.6 


*Includes both Anagallis arvensis and A. foemina 


91 


2-53510 


MEAN PERCENTAGE COVER MEAN PERCENTAGE COVER 


Journal of the Royal Society of Western Australia, Vol. 69, Part 3, 1987. 


35 _ 


Acanthocarpu8 

preissli 


Asparagus Geranium 

asparagoides molle 



1983 1985 1983 1985 



OUTSIDE 



1 983 



1985 


20 _ 


Stipa 

flavescens 


1 5 . 


10 _ 


rTL-N- 

1983 1985 


Par ietaria Galium 



1983 1985 1983 1985 


Island, direct grazing evidence was not apparent. Kelsall 
(1965) noted that Ihc tammar preferentially grazed this 
species in the dr\^ season. In this study no seasonal 
preference for Acacia rostellifera occurred between the 
late Autumn first sampling period and the late Winter 
second sampling when water would be readily available. 
During summer the thick central parenchymatous tissue 
of the phyllods of this species could be an important 
source of moisture. Preference for legume species could 
also relate to greater foliar nitrogen levels (Halford et al. 
1984b). 

Previous research established that grasses were a 
dietary preference in mainland populations of the 
tammar (Christensen 1981). Stipa flavescens has a 
relatively wide but discontinuous distribution over 
Garden Island occurring in higher densities in scrub 
communities where Acanthocarpus preissii was either 
absent or present in low densities. In these regions Stipa 
flavescens tussocks often showed evidence of grazing 
damage. The limited evidence for this species in the 
faecal and stomach content analyses, however, could be 
mainly an artifact of the laboratory technique. The 
nitric/chromic acid maceration technique entirely 
digests the epidermi of grasses and the digestion 
processes of the tammar could duplicate this process. 
Cautionary procedures regarding grass epidermal 
remnants have been pointed out previously (Storr 1961. 
Halford 1984a). 

The Beacon Head exclosure site located in a small 
experimental burn area show'ed vigorous regrowth of 
Asparagus asparagoides. The major cover differences 
between areas inside and outside the fences and the 
common occurrence of this plant species in both the 
faecal and stomach content samples implicate 
asparagoides as a favoured dietary component. Evidence 
of near complete digestion of epidermi of young leaves 


Figure 2. — Mean percentage cover values from the four exclosurc sites for 
selected species sampled inside and outside the cxclosure during 
August [983 and .September 1985. 


Discussion 

The tammar wallabies on Garden Island appear to be 
versatile feeders. Preferred plants generally included 
young shoots from resprouiing species {Stipa flavescens. 
Asparagus asparagoides). seedlings {Sohnum symomi. 
Thomasia cognata) or short-li\ed ephemeral species 
{Asphodehis fhlulosus). Results obtained from the 
examination of faecal and stomach material indicated 
that the introduced ephemeral. Asphodelus flistidosus. 
dominated the diet of the tammar. This species is now 
particularly widespread over the island, although 
differences in cover values were not particularly 
apparent in the exclosurc studies due to a tendency of 
this species to be concentrated in disturbed areas such as 
along road verges and in fire breaks. At the Cliff Head 
site in the grazed area surrounding the exclosure, many 
individuals appeared to have invaded the area following 
an initial period of grazing. Grazing observations 
suggested that the tammar preferred areas where recent 
mowing or ploughing stimulated the production of new 
shoots or seedlings. 

The presence of Acacia rostellifera in both faecal and 
stomach material indicated a strong preference for this 
species. Other authors have reported various species of 
Acacia in the diet of the tammar and other Macropods 
(Storr 1961, Kelsall 1965, Christensen 1981. Halford et 
al. 1984b). Probably because of the high density and 
widespread distribution of Acacia rostellifera on Garden 


PERCENTAGE OF FRAGMENTS IN SAMPLE 
0 10 20 30 40 50 60 



Figure 3. — Proportions of fragments separated by species from the April 
and August, 1983 faecal pellet samples and the April. 1983 stomach 
content samples. 


92 


Journal of the Royal Society of Western Australia, Vol. 69, Part 3. 1987. 


of this species in the preparation of the voucher slides 
suggests that fragments noted from the faecal pellet and 
stomach content analyses probably underestimate the 
actual proportions ingested. 

Grazing damage to Rhagodia baccata on Garden 
Island has been previously documented (McArthur 
1957, Kelsall 1965. McArthur and Bartle 1981). The 
absence of this species in the dietary preferences noted 
in this study, however, is probably due to the particular 
location of the exclosure sites in respect to the 
occurrence of Rhagodia baccata. Other inconsistencies 
arising belw-ecn the direct observation of grazing 
pressure and the quantitative evidence may also be 
explained by the distribution and density patterns of 
individual species and/or relatively low number of 
pellets analysed. For example, CaUitm preissii, which 
did not occur in the transects, was identified from the 
stomach contents of the road-killed animals. 

In the twelve years since completion of the new naval 
facilities the tammar population has remained relatively 
constant: the difference of 300 animals between the pre- 
1973 and current estimates could be attributed to the 
general difficulty of accurately sampling animal 
populations. Given the feeding preference for young 
shoots and seedlings, combined with the known 


Characteristics of Garden Island vascular plants relating to 


behaviour of the tammar during fires (Christensen 
1981), a controlled burning regime on Garden Island 
could benefit the population of this rare marsupial by 
increasing the areas of regenerating vegetation. 
However, the large proportion of species requiring 
seedling re-establishment indicates that the vegetation of 
Garden Island does not normally have a regime of 
frequent natural burns and, therefore, it would be 
irresponsible to suggest that large areas of the native 
vegetation be burned to provide greater feeding areas for 
the tammar. In fact, the greater availability of preferred 
food following large area burns could result in 
unacceptably large population increases in the tammar 
population. Frequent fires could also increase the 
already considerable invasions of introduced species 
into the native plant communities of the island as has 
been noted elsewhere in small 'island-like* bushland 
reserves within metropolitan Perth (Baird 1977, 
Loneragan ei al. 1984. Wycherley 1984). The present 
proportion of introduced species on the island (26%) is 
similar to that included in the Star Sw'amp Bushland 
Reserve (25%) (Bell et al. 1979) even though the 
mainland reserve includes a greater diversity of habitats, 
communities and species. What could prove beneficial 
to both the tammars and the human population on 
Garden Island would be a series of control burns to 

2 . 

', re-establishmeni strategy, tammar diet, and floral afTiIiation. 


Acacia cochlearis 
Acacia rostellifera 
Acanthocarpus preissii 
Anagallis arvensis 
A namllisfopmi nn 
Aspara^s asparagoides 
. isphodelus fisiulosus 
Beyeria viscosa 
Boronia alata 
Callitris preissii 
Carduus pycnocephalus 
Carpohrotus aequilaterus 
Cenlaurium erythraea 
Clemaiis niicrophylla 
Crassula colorata 
Crassula pedicellosa 
Diploleana dampiera 
Daucus glochidiatus 
Eremopnila glabra 
Exocarpus sparteus 
Galium murale 
Geranium molle 
Guichenotia ledifolia 
Hardenbergia comptoniana 
Xfelaleuca huegelii 
Melaleuca lancenlata 
Lastapelalum opposiiifolium 
Leucopogon insularis 
Leucopogon parviflorus 
Olearia axillaris 
Oxalis pes-caprae 
Parietaria debilis 
Poranihera microphylla 
Phytlamhus calycinus 
Rhagodia baccata 
Scaevola crassifolia 
Scirpus nodosus 
Senecio lautus 
Solatium svmonii 
Sonchus oleraceus 
Spyridium globulosum 
Stipa flavescens 
Thomasia cognata 
Trachyandra divaricata 
Trachymene caerulea 
Trachymene pilosa 
Zantedeschia aeihiopica 


Observed 

grazing 

damage 

Re-establishment 

strategy 

Faecal 

pellet 

Stomach 

content 

Floral 

affiliation 


Resprouter 



Native 

Yes 

Resprouter 

Yes 

Yes 

Native 

— 

Resprouter 

— 

— 

Native 

— 

Ephemeral 

— 

— 

Introduced 

— 

Ephemeral 

— 

— 

Introduced 

Yes 

Resprouter 

Yes 

Yes 

Introduced 

Yes 

Seeder 

Yes 

Yes 

Introduced 

— 

Seeder 

— 

— 

Native 

— 

Seeder 

— 

— 

Native 

— 

Seeder 

Yes 

Yes 

Native 

— 

Ephemeral 

— 

— 

Introduced 

— 

Seeder 

— 

— 

Native 

— 

Ephemeral 

— 

— 

Introduced 

— 

Resprouter 

— 

— 

Native 

— 

Ephemeral 

— 

— 

Native 

— 

Ephemeral 

— 

— 

Native 

— 

Seeder 

— 



Native 

— 

Ephemeral 

— 

— 

Native 

— 

Seeder 

Yes 

Yes 

Native 

— 

Resprouter 

— 

— 

Native 

— 

Ephemeral 

— 



Introduced 

— 

Ephemeral 

— 



Introduced 

— 

Seeder 

— 

— 

Native 

— 

Resprouier 

— 



Native 

— 

Seeder 

— 



Native 

— 

Seeder 

— 



Native 

— 

Seeder 

Yes 

— 

Native 

— 

Seeder 

— 



Native 

— 

Seeder 

— 



Native 

— 

Seeder 

— 



Native 

— 

Ephemeral 

— 



Introduced 

— 

Ephemeral 

— 



Native 

— 

Seeder 





Native 

Yes 

Resprouter 

Yes 

Yes 

Native 

— 

Seeder 

— 



Native 

— 

Seeder 

— 

— 

Native 

— 

Resprouter 

— 

— 

Native 

— 

Ephemeral 

— 



Native 

Yes 

Seeder 

Yes 

Yes 

Native 

— 

Ephemeral 

— 



Introduced 

— 

Seeder 

— 



Native 

Yes 

Resprouter 

Yes 



Native 

Yes 

Seeder 

Yes 



Native 

— 

Seeder 

Yes 

Yes 

Introduced 

— 

Ephemeral 

— 



Native 

— 

Ephemeral 

— 

— 

Native 


Ephemeral 

— 

— 

Introduced 


93 


Journal of the Royal Society of Western Australia, Vol. 69. Part 3. 1987. 


create low flammable fuel regions around the Naval 
facilities and to break up the length of the island into 
units to prevent large areas burning as occurred during 
the summer of 1 956 (Baird 1958). 

Garden Island has been largely free of wild fires 
during the history of European settlement on the 
mainland. Indications from growth ring analyses from a 
small stand of Callitris preissii located in the northern 
end of the island which escaped the fire of 1956 showed 
that the trees were not much older than 50 years 
(Pearman 1971). This stand would now be around 65 
years old. .Although growth is generally slow, fuel build 
up during fire free periods can be considerable. 
McArthur (1957) reported that after 18 years of 
accumulation litter depths w'ere of the order of 5 cm in 
the Callitris Forest, 3 cm in Acacia rostellifera-M'wQd 
Scrub, and 1 cm in Melaleuca heugelii Scrub. His 
description of the vegetation at the time 4yr prior to the 
1956 fire also indicated that Stipa flavescens occurred in 
most of the plant communities and would have 
contributed to the flammability of the litter. 

Small spot fires accidentally lit by island visitors have 
occurred since the 1956 fire but documentation of these 
fires is unavailable. Controlled burning trials carried out 
by the W. A. Bush Fires Board in conjunction with the 
Department of Botany in April 1982 and December 
1982 in the Beacon Head region were the first 
documented fires for 27 years. Estimates following these 
small experimental control burns indicated that only 
about 50% of the lit area actually burnt, and indeed, on 
both occasions some difficulty was experienced in 
keeping the fires alight. These controlled burns were 
carried out under mild temperatures and in the absence 
of strong winds; in marked contrast to the conditions 
under which the 1956 fire burned when temperatures in 
the two weeks preceeding the wild fire averaged 38"C 
and strong south-westerly winds had orevailed. 

The ability to impose a controlled burning regime in a 
region which normally only rarely receives a fire should 
not be the only management decision for the regions of 
native vegetation on Garden Island. As was noted by 
Krinitskii (1974), ‘Man's help should be thoroughly 
worked out: he should not lightly and arrogantly recarve 
nature'. The protection of the Naval installations from 
wild fires could be achieved by a system of fire breaks 
and reduced fuel-load buffers, rather than the burning of 
large tracts of the native plant communities of the island 
which has the additional disadvantage of destroying 
most of the cover for the tammars. If the fire-breaks 
were of a firm-base construction (e.g. limestone) rather 
than ploughed annually, there would be minimal 
disturbance and, hence, greater probability of 
controlling weed invasion. Changes in the tammar 
population numbers that result from the increased areas 
of preferred food resources could then indicate further 
considerations for the management of the island. 


Acknowledgements — Funds for the research were provided from Ihe 
Garden Island Management Research Project. We wish to acknowledge the 
assistance of Professor S. D. Bradshaw and Dr. A. J. Bradley of the 
University of Western Australia Department of Zoology. The position of 
Senior Lecturer in Plant Ecology to Dr. Bell is supported by Alcoa of 
Australia Ltd. and Western Collieries Ltd. The .study was part of an 
Honours in Botany research project of Ms. Moredoundl. 


References 

Baird, A. M. (1958). — Notes on the regeneration of vegetation of Garden 
Island afterthe 1956 fire. J. Roy. Soc. IV.A.. 14: 102-107. 

Baird. A. M. (1977). — Regeneration after fire m King’s Park, Perth. 
Western Australia. / Roy Soc. H'.A.. 60: 1-22. 

Bakker. H. R. (1973). — W'ater and electrolyte metabolism of the tammar. 
Unpubl. Ph.D. Thesis, University of Western Australia. 

Bakker. H. R., Bradshaw. S. D. and Main, A. R. (1982). — Water and 
electrolyte metabolism of the tammar wallaby. Macropus eugenii. 
Physwl. ZooL 55:209-219. 

Bell. D. T., Loncragan. W. A. and Dodd, J. (1979). — Preliminary analysis 
of the vegetation of Star Swamp. Western .Australia. li'.A. 
Herbarium Res. Soles. 2: 1-21. 

Bell. D. T.. Hopkins, A. J. M. and Pate, J. S. (1984). — Fire in the kwongan. 
Pages 178-204. In Pate. J. S. and Beard. J. S. Kwongan (Eds). Plant 
Life of the Sandptain. University of Western Australia Press, 
Nedlands. Western Australia. 

Christensen. P. (1981). — The biology of Bettongia penicUlata Gray and 
Macropus eugemi Desm. in relation of fire. \V..4. For. Dep. Bull. 

91. 

Griffin. E. A- and Hopkins, A. J. M. (1981). — The short term effects of 
brush harvesting on the kwongan vegetation at Eneabba. Western 
Australia. B'w. Aust. Dep. Fish. & H'ildl. Rept. So. 45, 

Halford. D. A.. Bell. D. T. and Loneragan. W. A. (1984a). — Epidermal 
characteristics of some Western Ausialian wandoo-woodland 
species for studies of herbivore diets. / Roy. Soc. W.A., 66: 1 1 1- 
118. 

Halford, D. A.. Bell. D. T, and Loneragan. W. A. (1984b). — Diet of the 
western grey kangaroo {.\facropus fuliginosus Desm.) in a mixed 
pasture-woodland habitat of Western Australia. J. Row Soc. W.A., 
66:119-128. 

Jain. K. K. (1976). — Hydrogen peroxide and acetic acid for preparing 
epidermal peels from conifer leaves. Stain Tech., 51: 202-204. 

Keeley. J. E. and Keeley, S. C. (1981). — Post-fire regeneration of southern 
California chaparral. Amer. J. Bot , 68; 524-530. 

Keeley. J. E. and Zedler. P, H. (1978). — Regeneration of chaparral shrubs 
after fire: A comparison of sprouting and seeding strategies. Amer. 
.Midi Nat . 99: 142-161. 

Kelsall. J. P. ( 1 965). — Insular variability in the tammar {Macropus eugenii) 
of Western Australia. Unpubl. Ph.D. Thesis. University of 
Western Australia. 

Kinnear. J. E., Purohit. G. and Main. .A. R. (1968). — Ability of the tammar 
wallaby {Macropu.s ingenit. Marsupialia) to drink sea water. Comp. 
Biochem. Physiol. 25: 761-782. 

Krinitskii, V. V. (1974). — Protected areas in the world’s industrially 
advanced regions; importance, progress and problems. Pages 61- 
67. In Ellioil. H. (Ed.). Second World C'onference on National 
Parks. 1-U. C. N.. Morges. Switzerland. 

Loneragan, W. A., McMillan. P.. Townley, L. R. and Watson. L. E. 
(1984). — Star Swamp Bushland Reserve. Proposals for its 
Development and Management. Report to the .Australian Heritage 
Commission. Canberra. 

Main, A. R. (1961). — The occurrence of Macropodidae on islands and its 
climatic and ecological implications. /. Roy. Soc. IF A.. 44: 84-89. 

Malanson. G. P. and O’Leary. J. F. (1982). — Post-fire regeneration 
strategies of Californian coastal sage shrubs. Oecologia, 53: 355- 
358. 

McArthur, W. M, (1957). — Plant ecology of the coastal islands near 
Fremantle, Western .Australia. ./ Roy. Sck\ 40: 46-64. 

McArthur. W. M. and Bartle, G. .A. (1981). — The landforms, soils and 
vegetation as a basis of management studies on garden Island. 
CSIRO Div. Land Resour. Manage. Ser\. Bull. No. 7. 

Pearman. G. I. (1971). An exploratory investigation of the growth rings of 
Callitris presissii trees from Garden Island and Naval Base. West 
. lust. Nalur.. 12: 12-17. 

Siddiqi. M. Y., Carolin, R. C. and Myerscough. P. J. (1976). — Studies in 
the ecology of coastal heath in New South Wales. Australia. Part 3. 
Regrowth of vegetation after fire. Proc. Linn. Soc. M'.. 101: 53- 
63. 

Specht. R. L.. Rayson. P. and Jackman. M. E. (1958). — Dark Island heath 
(Ninety-Mile Plain, .South .Australia). VI. Pyric succession: 
Changes in composition, coverage, dry weight, and mineral 
nutrient content. Aust. ./- Bot.. 6: 59-88. 

Storr, G. M. (1961). — Microscopic analysis of faeces, and technique for 
ascertaining the diet of herbivorous mammals, .-iiisf. J. Biol. Sci.. 
14: 157-164. 

Wycherley, P. (1984). — People, fire and weeds: can the vicious spiral be 
broken? In Moore. S. (Ed.), .\fanagement of Small Bush .Areas in 
the Perth Metropolitan Region. Proc. of a Seminar held by Dept. 
Fisheries and Wildlife 20th Sept. 1983. 


94 


Journal of the Royal Society orWeslcrn Australia. Vol. 69. Part 3. 1987. p. 95-1 12. 


Wetlands of the Darling System — A geomorphic approach to 

habitat classification 

by C. A. Scmcniuk 

21 Cilcnmerc Road, Warwick. W.A. 6024 
Maniisaipi nrciwei 17 June I^S6: acccpicd IS November 1986 


Abstract 

A classiflcalion utilising the 2 primary components of wetlands, the “wetness" and "landform" 
components, is proposed here. The water component distinguishes wetlands from other terrestrial 
habitats and also influences biological response by its presence, permanence or longevity, depth, 
chemistry, and movement. The landform determines wetland size, shape and depth. Using 
subdivisions of cross-sectional landform geometry there arc recognised: basins, channels, and Hats. 
Within the category of water longevity, there arc recognised: permanent inundation, seasonal 
inundation, and seasonal waterlogging. Combining these “wetness" and landform allribulcs 
provides 7 categories of common wetlands: I. permanently inundated basin lake: 2. seasonally 
inundated basin sunipla/u/: 3. seasonally waterlogged basin dampland: 4. permanently 
inundated channel river, 5. seasonally inundated channel creek: 6. seasonally inundated flat 
floodplain: and 7. seasonally waterlogged flat - pafusplain. Water and landform 

descriplors/modifiers are used to further augment the nomenclature of the primary units. Modifiers 
for water include salinity and its consistency. Modifiers for landform include size and shape. Since 
there arc only seven primary wetland types, the classification provides a practicable number of 
categories for mapping. The addition of more precise or detailed information as 
modifiers/descriptors increases the abilily to discriminate individual wetlands from each other. 


Introduction 

This paper presents a geomorphic classification of 
wetlands in the Darling System (Swan Coastal Plain and 
Darling Plateau; Fig. 1). an area occurring in the 
subhumid and humid region of soulhw'cstern .Australia 
and encompassing coastal plains and dissected plateau. 
Many classifications of wetlands to date in Western 
Australia and elsewhere have been based on vegetation 
and water quality but it is considered that a geomorphic 
classiflcalion best provides the initial framework to 
understanding the various types of wetlands, their 
distribution and their relationship to biota. The 
rationale of the geomorphic approach is that ultimately 
wetlands arc related fundamentally to landform 
development and water maintenance. 

The classification presented here may be used for 
recognising the varied wetland types that occur in the 
Darling System. Information such as this is needed to 
establish a geographic, stratigraphic, hydrological and 
biological pattern in the distribution of wetland types, to 
determine regional and local significance of wetlands, to 
determine conscr\ation strategies.and to manage 
wetlands. 

It has long been recognised that wetlands range from: 
permanent lakes, small to large seasonal lakes, small to 
large areas of seasonally water-logged soils, fluviatile 
systems, estuarine systems, and marine systems, and 
that these categories can be inicrgradational. Figure 2 
illustrates the intergradalional relationship between, and 
attributes of. the various wetland systems, recognising 
that there are land-based, marine-based and 
intermediate (estuarine) categories. This paper deals 
with the land-based wetlands. Estuarine systems and 
marine systems will be the subject of a later study. The 
approach of this paper is to provide a review of 


international literature on wetland classification and 
nomenclature followed by a review of local studies that 
deal with wetlands of the Darling System. This is in turn 
followed by a description of the classification adopted 
here. 


Review of international literature on classification and 
terms for land-based wetlands 

Definition of wetland 

In the more recent literature the definition of wetlands 
encompasses lakes, water-saturated basins, estuaries and 
fluvial systems (UNESCO 1971. Bayly and Williams 
1973, Cowardin et ai 1979, Department of 
Conservation and Environment 1980, Adam et ai 
1985). However in the older literature the concept of 
wetland was more rigidly confined to encompass only 
lakes and water-saturated basins. 

A variety of wetland definitions from the international 
literature is presented here to indicate the wide range of 
concepts of what constitutes a wetland. The Ramsar 
Convention defined weilands as “areas of marsh, fen, 
peailand or water, whether natural or artificial, 
perrnanent or temporary, with water that is static or 
flowing, fresh, brackish or salt, including areas of marine 
water the depth of which at low tide docs not exceed 
6m" (UNESCO 1971). Zoliai and Pollel (1983) define 
wetlands as areas where wet soils arc prevalent, having a 
water table near or above the mineral soil for most of the 
thawed season, supporting a hydrophilic vegetation, and 
pools of open water (-^^2m deep). This includes shallow 
open water. It does not include areas that become 
temporarily flooded, but remain relatively well drained 
for most of the growing season. Hill (1978) identifies 


3-53510 


95 


Journal of the Royal Society of Western Australia, Vol. 69. Part 3. 1987. 



Figure 1. — Location of the study area, the System Six Region in 
southwestern Australia. 

wetlands by the presence of vegetation typically adapted 
to life in areas inundated or saturated by water with the 
appropriate duration and frequency to promote that 
vegetation, Cowardin el aL (1979) define wetlands as 
lands transitional between terrestrial and aquatic 
systenjs where the water table is usually at or near the 
surface or the land is covered by shallow water. 
Cowardin el ai (1979) define wetlands as having one or 
more of the following attributes: I) at least periodically 
the land supports hydrophytes, 2) the substrate is 
predominantly undrained hydric soil 3) the substrate is 
nonsoil and is saturated with water or covered by 
shallow water at some lime during the growing season of 
each year. Bates and Jackson (1980) define wetland as a 
general term for a group of wet habitats and include 
areas that are permanently wet and/or intermittently 
water covered, such as coastal marshes, tidal swamps 
and flats, and associated pools, sloughs and bayous. 

A consensus of Western Australian workers define 
wetlands as: 

“Areas of seasonally, intermittently or permanently 
waterlogged soils or inundated land, whether 
natural or otherwise, fresh or saline, e.g. waterlogged 


soils, ponds, billabongs, lakes, swamps, tidal fiats, 
estuaries, rivers and their tributaries’' (Wetlands 
Advisory Committee 1977). 

The definition is adequately encompassing and is 
adopted herein. 


II 'etland classificalions 

Wetlands have been examined and/or classified from 
a number of disciplines: biologically (e.g. mires, swamps; 
Ivanov 1981, Gore 1983): physically (e.g. riverine lakes, 
glacial lakes, tectonic lakes; Hutchinson 1957); 
biologically/chcmically (e.g. fens, bogs: Tansley 1939, 
Gorham 1957, Reeves 1968, Moore and Bellamy 1974, 
Ruttner 1975, Gore 1983); chemically (e.g. 

minerotrophic, ombrotrophic etc.; Kulczynski, 1949; 
Hakanson and Jansson 1980, Wetzel 1983); 

ontogenetically: and others. It is not proposed to present 
a historical review of all the terms nor is it intended to 
explore the meanings of terms w'hich arc not widely 
used. Rather this review documents current 
terminology, discusses the relevance of those terms to 
the present classification, and assesses their applicability 
to the wetlands in the Darling System. 


I'erms for types of wetlands 

Currently inland water bodies can be separated into 4 
types; rivers, lakes, mirelands and marshlands. Rivers 
refer to channelled surface water. Lakes, mirelands, and 
marshlands arc “basin-like" or flat wetlands which are 
differentiated on the basis of plant colonisation. The 
recent distinction between running water (Lolic 
environment) and standing water (Lenlic environments) 
basically identifies the broader categories of riverine 


BROAD CATEGORIES OF 
WETLAND SYSTEMS 


GEOMORPHIC/HYDROLOGIC 

SYSTEM 


SALINITY 


CLOSED 


Basins 

and 

Flats 


OPEN 


Riverine 


Deltaic 

and 

Estuarine 


Fresh 


o 

Mixed or 
Alternating 


Marine 


Saline 


Stippled area marks the categories of land-based wetlands 
that are the subject of this paper 


Figure 2. — Conceptual summary of types of broad wetland categories and 
their inter-relationships in terms of geomorphic/hydrologic setting and 
their salinity. 


96 


Journal of the Royal Society of Western Australia, Vol. 69. Part 3, 1987. 


versus ‘'basin-lypc" of wetlands. The fluvial systems 
(encompassing rivers, streams, creeks and all other 
forms of established surfacx* water flow) generally in the 
past were not considered to be wetlands. Since the 
documentation and analysis of fluvial systems have been 
separated traditionally from that of other types of wet 
habitats, the approaches to their classification have been 
variable (Schumm 1977. Leopold el al. 1964, Twidale 
1968, Fairbridgc 1968, Bloom 1978). 


Fluvial Welland systems 

Fluvial systems already have been described and 
categorised according to geomorphic principles (Gilluly 
and Waters 1951, Schumm 1977. Leopold el al. 1964, 
Chorlcy 1969, Bloom 1978. Strahler 1978, Cant 1982. 
Lecdcr 1982). Both land and water criteria have been 
combined to identify and nominate the features of a 
fluvial system. The recognised geomorphic features of 
fluvial systems include channels. Hood basins and 
floodplains, levees, crevasses, sw'amps, and ox-bow lakes 
(op cit). 

Fluvial channel patterns have been subdivided by 
workers using the criteria of I) genetic relationship to 
landform. 2) channel size and position in relationship to 
branching pattern. 3) sinuosity, 4) water permanence 
and 5) sediment load. The genetic classification used 
terms such as subsequent, consequent, obsequcnl and 
insequent. and the terms "first order stream”, "second 
order stream”, etc were used to categorise relationship of 
channel to branching pattern. Several classes of channel 
are recognised on the basis of sinuosity (i.e. the ratio of 
channel length to valley length): these include straight, 
transitional, regular, irregular, tortuous, sinuous, 
meandering, straight-and-braided, and anastomosing 
(Schumm 1977, Leopold el al. 1964, Miall 1977. Cant 
1982, Smith 1983); some of these terms arc 
synonymous. C'hanncis occupied by water for different 
periods of time are referred to as permanent, 
intermittent, and ephemeral. Predominant sediment 
transport mode also has been used to classify channels 
(Schumm 1977) resulting in a similar set of classes as 
those derived from sinuosity criteria, but with the 
additional information on channel stability i.e. whether 
the channel is stable, eroding, or depositional. 


Basin wetland systems and flats 

Research into “basin-type” inland water bodies or 
wetlands, has been largely concentrated in the areas of 
the Temperate, Boreal and Arctic zones of the Northern 
Hemisphere, particularly Europe, where precipitation is 
greater than evaporation and/or drainage. The wetlands 
of these regions arc permanently inundated or 
waterlogged areas and the terms derived from these 
areas tend to describe only this limited range of 
wetlands. Examples of wetland terms from these regions 
are (Gore 1983): lake and mircland (English), moor, sec 
(German), myr (Swedish), suo (Finnish), boloto 
(Russian), veen (Dutch), myri (Icelandic) and muskeg 
(Canadian). 

Basins were divided, on the presence or absence of 
emergent vegetation, into 2 water depth types, i.e. those 
deeper than 2m and those shallower than 2m. The 
current terms used to distinguish these types arc lake 
and mireland. Lake has been defined as an “inland body 
of standing water occupying a depression in the earth's 
surface, generally of appreciable size (larger than a pond) 
and too deep to permit vegetation (excluding 


subaqueous vegetation) to take root completely across 
the expanse of water: the water may be fresh or saline” 
(Bates and Jackson 1980). Mircland refers to any area 
which remains waterlogged and is vegetated (Ivanov 
1981). 

Lakes have been classified for specific purposes, 
according to dissolved mineral content, or thermal 
properties, but the most widely used classification is 
according to origin (Hutchinson 1957. Reeves 1968, 
Hakanson 1980, and Jansson 1983, Wetzel 1983). Thus 
tectonic, glacial, volcanic, solution lakes etc., have been 
distinguished. 

Mirelands have been subdivided into mires and 
swamps. Mires are permanently waterlogged areas which 
must include a minimum thickness of peat (Gorham 
1957, Moore and Bellamy 1974, Ivanov 1981). They are 
further divided into two types: bog and fen. A bog is 
domed, raised above the level of the surface of the 
surrounding terrain, often with a steep marginal bank 
(rand). Bogs arc oligolrophic. because they rely on 
atmospheric precipitation, and as a result support a 
typical vegetation of Sphagnum mosses. A fen occurs in 
hollows or depressions, is minerotrophic and as a result 
supports a variety of vegetation including mosses, 
graminoids, or trees. Swamps arc permanently 
waterlogged seasonally inundated, or permanently 
inundated, vegetated areas. Swamps have alternatively 
been identified or defined as peat-forming, and non-peat 
forming (Holmes 1944, Golct and Larson 1974, Ivanov 
1981). Swamps arc subdivided into numerous different 
types according to the physiognomy of plant cover 
(Hofsteller 1983, Anderson 1983, Gore 1983. Denny 
1985, and others), e.g. conifer swamps, hardwood 
swamps, reed swamps, and Ti-lrec swamps. 

Wetlands other than mirelands, lakes and rivers, arc 
fewer in number in the Northern European climatic 
zones, but they exhibit enough common similarities in 
terms of biotic and water parameters to be classified 
collectively as marshlands. Marshlands have been 
defined as seasonally inundated or waterlogged, with or 
without a well developed peat, and supporting a 
graminoid or herb plant cover (Gorham 1953, Riggcri 
1964-1966, Zollai and Bollet 1983. Golct and Larson 
1974, Campbell 1983, Hofsletler 1983. Denny 1985). 
The term has also been applied to vegetated peripheral 
flats of estuaries. Marshlands may be "basin-like” or 
flats. The types of marshlands arc: 1) marshes, 2) 
swamps, 3) meadows, and 4) wetlands. The range and 
inconsistency in terms have been brought about by the 
variability in marshlands occurring outside Europe. 
Authors describing areas which satisfy only part of the 
marshland definition (e.g. the seasonal waterlogging of 
soils) but have different vegetation structure, often use 
an alternative term or a modifying term to avoid 
confusion. 

Marshes arc subdivided on basis of saline and fresh 
water, geographical distribution (e.g. coastal and inland), 
and water depth during the growing season (Martin el al. 

1 953, Golct and Larson 1 974). The term swamp, used in 
the sense of. and as a synonym of marsh (Zoltai I 983, 
Junk 1983, Hofstctler 1983. Howard-Williams and 
Gaudcl 1985) as distinct from a subdivision of mircland 
is defined as an area intermittently or permanently 
covered with water, supporting woody plants and 
essentially lacking peat development. In fact, marsh, 
swamp, and wetland are sometimes used 
interchangeably and the general term wetland has been 
used to describe all land/watcr interfaces. 


97 


Journal of Ihe Royal Society of Western Australia. Vol. 69. Part 3. 1987. 


(k’mral classijlcadons 

A variety of classillcalions have been produced by a 
number of workers. Some have been comprehensive and 
generally exhaustive (Cowardin c/ al. 1979) whereas 
some have concentrated mainly on limnologic wetlands 
or some specialised aspect of wetlands (Marlin ct al. 
1953. Hutchinson 1957. Bayly and Williams 1973, 
Ivanov 1981. Wcl/el 1983, Rutiner 1963). Two of these 
classifications are outlined below. 

Marlin ci al. (1953) produced a classillcation of 
wetlands based on I) geographical position 2) water 
quality 3) period of Hooding 4) depth of water during the 
growing season and 5) vegetation type within the 
wetland. The freshwater wetlands were then divided into 
meadows, marshes, swamps, open water and Hals, and 
were ditTercniiated on the criteria of water depth and/or 
vegetation cover. Similar wetland categories were 
proposed for inland and coastal areas and again for 
saline wetlands. An example from Marlin ci al. ( 1953) is 
as follows: “Fresh Inland Meadow: No standing water, 
but saturated within a decimeter of the soil surface. 
Shallow depressions. Communities dominated by 
graminoids and herbs". Within the classification by 
Martin ct al. (1953). hovvever. criteria were not applied 
consistently. In the case of “wooded swamps" the period 
of Hooding is omitted whereas in the categories of “salt 
Hal", “salt meadow" and "irregularly Hooded salt 
marshes", it becomes the distinguishing factor. The use 
of salinity is another problem with the classiHcaiion. 
Salinity was noted to be cither fresh or saline. There is 
no class of wetland which is gradational or dynamic. The 
cross sectional shape of the wetlands was not 
differentiated in each class. The terminology docs not 
allow for wetlands with variegated vegetation pattern. 
Also, the w'alcr levels are loo specific and in cases, where 
this is the only differentiating factor, it is loo precise for 
use in Australia. 

The classification by C'ow'ardin ct al. (1979) is a 
hierarchial one based on recognition of classes, orders 
and progressively lower levels of taxonomic 
differentiation. The classification al the onset denotes 5 
systems of wetlands that “have certain homogeneous 
natural attributes": these arc the marine, estuarine, 
riverine, lacustrine and paluslrinc systems. Each system 
is composed of subsystems of littoral and limnetic 
habitats. The systems are divided into classes and then 
dominance types, and finally modifying terms arc 
added. The class to which a wetland belongs is 
determined by the dominant life form of the vegetation 
(or in the absence of vegetation, the allributcs of the 
substrate): the dominance type refers to the dominant 
plant or animal species present: the modifiers refer to 
soil and water attributes of the wetland. The 
classification was designed so that it could be applied at 
all levels of data collection. As the information on a 
wetland increases, the classification may be refined so 
that two objectives were satisfied: the wetland could be 
classified immediately within a regional framework, and 
secondly the wetland could be finally described and 
differentiated on important individual characteristics. 

A number of classifications for wetlands also have 
been devised by workers in Australia. These 
classifications are intended mainly for local use 
(Goodrick 1970. Cowling 1977, Jacobs 1983). Many 
generally appear to ulili/e existing overseas schemes and 
amend them where appropriate for the local system (e.g. 
Riggcrt 1964-66. sec later). More recently F^aijmans ct al. 
(1985) provided an overview of Australian wetlands and 


proposed 6 categories of wetlands (lakes, swamps, land 
subject to inundation, channels, tidal Hats and coastal 
water bodies). Their approach however is loo broad for 
this study and their categories are based on a variety of 
mixed criteria. 

Application of international classifications to the Darling 
System 

Wetlands of the Darling System are quite variable in 
shape, size, vegetation, soil, peal, water quality and 
water maintenance. Wetlands with permanently or 
seasonally inundated soils have been predominantly 
described in the lilcralure, but those with seasonally, 
waterlogged soils generally have been neglected. 
According to the current international literature most of 
the wetlands of the Darling System would fall into the 
categories of 1 ) channels. 2) lakes. 3) mirclands (fens and 
swamps) and 4) marshlands. There arc no bogs as found 
in Northern Europe. Marshlands, however, are the most 
dominant but there are types of marshlands which do 
not conform to the definition presented above e..g. there 
are open bodies of water which arc fringed by a range of 
vegetation types, and there arc areas of seasonally 
waterlogged soils supporting variable vegetation. 

L’se of riverine terms 

The genetic and quantitative classifications for rivers 
and streams (Twidale 1968, Fairbridge 1968) are 
considered inappropriate for channels of the Darling 
System because they do not provide precise information 
on the important features of shape, size and 
permanence, factors that are considered to be important 
in the identification of the wetland habitat. The terms of 
these classifications furthermore have neither ecological 
nor descriptive gcomorphic implication. The 
classification involving sediment load relates to stream 
function and also docs not convey the necessary 
de.scriptive information useful to identify the various 
channel wetlands. The terms used to describe sinuosity 
arc appropriate to describe wetland channels because 
they convey geometric impressions of the channel 
system particularly if used in conjunction with size 
terms. However it is necessary only to use a limited 
range of these terms to convey channel sinuosity: these 
arc: straight, anastomosing, irregular and sinuous. 

i'sc of vegetation in classification 

Vegetation (using features of Horistics or structure, or 
both) has been used to classify wetlands (Martin ct al. 
1953, Goodrick 1970. Cowardin ct al. 1979. Briggs 
1981. Campbell 1983, Sjors 1983, Pisano 1983, and 
others). In some cases vegetation has even been used to 
unravel! the edaphic features of w'cliands. For instance, 
Ivanov (1981) deduces hydrology, stratigraphy, origin 
and development from the use of restricted plant 
habitats in mire ecology and uses species presence and 
structure in relation to micro-relief to determine the 
structure of mire formations. Vegetation has been used 
to differentiate types of mires and swamps (e.g. spruce 
swamp, pine bog). 

It is considered here, however, that vegetation should 
not be used as a primarv- criterion to classify wetlands of 
the Darling System. * The vegetation structure is 
dependent upon hydrological and gcomorphological 
factors such as water maintenance, water quality, micro- 
relief and soils, so that the primary classification of 
wetlands solely based on vegetation structure may not 


98 


Journal of the Royal Society of Western Australia. Vol. 69. Part 3, 1987. 


allow any differeniiaiion of other wetland properties. 
Also, because of the relatively limited species pool that 
dominantly contribute to the vegetation of wetlands, the 
use of vegetation as a primary criterion would result in 
many different wetlands being classified into one group. 
Consider for example paperbark forests and woodlands 
which occur on deltas, along river banks, on flood plains, 
along the edge of basins, in blow outs, in interdune 
depressions and fringing the shores of estuaries: the use 
of this vegetation in classification would not bring out 
the various and different primary wetland categories. 


Use of wafer quality in classification 

Wetlands have been subdivided variably on the basis 
of different water types, such as ombrolrophic and 
mineroirophic, or aspects of salinity (Tansley 1939, 
Martin etal. 1953. Bayly and Williams 1973, Moore and 
Bellamy 1974. Gore 1983) and in some cases it forms the 
primary criterion for classification. More usually the 
subdivision of water categories merely provides a 
secondary subdivision of wetland types. 

Since most of the wetlands in the Darling System arc 
maintained by groundwater, it must be concluded that 
they are to some extent mineroirophic. However, the 
input of rain during the wet season shifts wetlands to the 
ombrolrophic end of the spectrum. Although this simple 
division based on dissolved mineral content cannot be 
used successfully, the division according to salinity or to 
the presence of one or more minerals may be attempted. 
The use of w'atcr quality is considered impodant at 
lower hierarchial levels but not at a primary level. 
Accordingly salinity terms such as freshwater, brackish 
water, subsaline, hyposaline, saline water and 
hypersaline water become applicable (Davis and 
DeWiest 1966. Logan et al. 1974. Cow^ardin et al. 1979, 
Dreva 1982. Hammer et al. 1983). An excellent review 
of the problems of terminology of categories of water 
quality is provided by Hammer (1986). The consistency 
of water quality also is considered here to be relevant in 
classification at lower hierarchial levels, because of the 
seasonal variation in water quality of many wetlands of 
the Darling System. 


Use of peat /stratigraphy in classification 

The sccondao' classification of mirelands into fens 
and bogs is based on the presence/absence of peat and 
essentially underscores botanical and shallow 
stratigraphic aspects of wetlands. Taken to conclusion 
the stratigraphic approach would result in wetlands 
being categorised on the origin of their surficial soils 
such as peal, carbonate mud, diatomile. gypsum 
deposits, etc. Welland shallow stratigraphy in the 
Darling System is primarily determined by the 
vegetation type, the gcomcrphic unit in which the 
wetland is situated, and the developmental history of the 
wetland. This shallow' stratigraphy is often complex and 
necessitates detailed analysis. Thus although it is very 
important in understanding wetland formation, 
stratigraphic information is considered to be 
inappropriate at the higher hierarchial levels of 
classification. 

An additional complication relates to the age of peat 
units. Peal and peaty sand occur in many of the w'cllands 
in the Darling System and are forming under present 
conditions: they are young and often less than a metre 
thick. In some places, however peal has been buried to 
some depth and is essentially a “fossil" deposit. The 


buried peal horizons may be relics of a different climatic 
or wetland regime and should form no part of a 
classification dealing with modern processes. 


Use of internal morphology in classification 

Morphological criteria such as internal relative relief 
is used by a number of authors for basin wetlands 
(Moore and Bellamy 1974, Ivanov 1981, Gore 1983) but 
its use has tended to be subtly introduced at all stages of 
classification. Where not directly mentioned, the 
wetland internal morphology often is implied in the use 
of vegetation structure and the water quality. For 
instance with bogs and fens, use is made of vegetation 
structure to infer the varieties of depressions, hollows, 
basins, flats or slopes. In essence the use of internal 
morphology in the international literature is merely a 
variation of the use of vegetation criteria. 


Use of external morphology in classification 

The morphology of fluvial systems has been 
successfully classified by a number of authors and 
according to these approaches fluvial wetlands of the 
Darling System could be classified as to channel shape 
and water permanence. The external shape of basin- 
wetland landform, however, generally is not directly 
considered in the international literature even though it 
is one underlying factor for the presence and extent of 
the wetland itself and therefore should be a primary 
factor in the classification of w'ctlands. In the Darling 
System the morphological components of the landforms 
produce definite, recognisable types of w^cllands, and 
small scale scdimcntological features of wetlands can 
also be used for more detailed categorisation. The larger 
morphological components are considered to be crucial 
in the primary classification of wetlands from a 
geomorphic viewpoint as will be discussed later in the 
paper. 


Discussion 

The review of international literature shows that 
classifications and nomenclature of w'eilands have been 
based on amost every edaphic or ecological aspect of the 
sy stem: water supply, w ater chemistry, type of landform, 
morphological structures within the wetland, shape of 
wetlands, vegetation cover, and occurrence/types of 
peat. There have been integrated approaches such as the 
genelico-gcotopic classification of Ivanov (1981), the 
w--etland classes of Zoltai el al. (1983), and the five major 
systems of Cow'ardin el al. (1979). There also have been 
numerous classifications based on a single feature, the 
mo.st common being vegetation. 

The primary^ classification of wetlands into lake, 
mireland and marshland is inconsistently based on the 
duration and depth of water supply and shows no clear 
demarcation between wetlands with different water 
levels and longevity. Three types of water longevity are 
explicitly recognised by authors: 1) permanent 

inundation, 2) permanent waterlogging, 3) seasonal 
inundation or w-atcrlogging, but the terms lake, mireland 
and marshland clearly do not mirror these categories: for 
example: 

• Permanently inundated areas may be termed lake or 

swamp 

• Permanently waterlogged areas may be termed mire, 

swamp, marsh 


99 


Journal of the Royal Society of Western Australia. Vol. 69. Part 3. 1987. 


• Seasonally inundated or waterlogged areas are termed 
wetland, marsh, meadow, swamp. 

There is no term other than marsh to refer to seasonally 
waterlogged areas, as opposed to seasonally inundated 
surfaces. 

It is also dear that most classifications of wetland rely 
heavily on categorisation using vegetation (which is 
presumed to reflect water longevity and quality) at a 
primary or secondary level. The classification of 
wetlands where landform is linked to water 
permanence/longcvity generally is not an approach 
adopted in the literature. For instance, wetlands divided 
into lake or mireland then are subdivided according to 
biotopes (i.e. the presence or absence of peat and. on the 
physiognomy of the plant cover). The third major factor 
in categorising wetlands appears to be the use of water 
quality. This may be based simply on aspects such as 
minerotrophism. or specific salt content, or acidity. 

Further subdivisions or classifications ot wetlands 
have been based on the genetic morphologic 
relationships of the entire wetland systems at a regional 
scale, or on vegetation-related internal morphological 
components of the wetland and the resulting structure of 
the vegetation, or the presence of specific vegetation 
(Moore and Bellamy 1974. Cowardin c/ al. 1979. Ivanov 
1981, Gore 1983. Ruuhijarvi 1983. Sjors 1983). 

The terms available in the literature that are useful in 
classifying wetlands at a primary level therefore are: 

the term wetland itself, 
the term lake. 

riverine geomorphic nomenelature such as river, 
creek, channel sinuosity terms, etc. 

A wide variety of wetland categories or terms 
therefore are considered inapplicable for the Darling 
System because they arc genetic, or they have imprecise 
definition- or have strong vegetation connotation, or 
soil/stratigraphy connotation, or they should be at lower 
stage levels of hierarchy in classification, or because they 
do not fully estend across the range of wetlands available 
in the Darling Systems: these are: 

1. genetic chemical categories such as ombroirophic. 
minerotrophic etc.: 

2. morphogenetic categories such as volcanic lake, 
glacial lakes: 

3. floristic categories such as swamp, meadow, marsh, 
muskeg: 

4. chemicakfloristic or soil-floristic categories such as 
mire, swamp, moor, fen. bog etc.: 

5. geologic /geographic base categories such as paludal, 
continental: 

6. the terms lake, swamp, marsh as used in a 
sedimentoiogic sense. 


Previous local classification of wetlands 

There have been previous classifications of the 
wetlands of the Swan Coastal Plain and Darling Plateau 
of the Darling Svstem, notably by Serventy, Owen and 
Pirrott (cited bv Clarke el al. 1971), Riggeit ( 1 964- 1 966). 
Tingay and tingay (1976) the Wetlands Advisory 
Committee (1977). and Allen (1980). All these 
classifications devised to date have useful purposes since 
each was developed for a specific task. These systems of 
classification are briefly discussed below. 


Classification adopted by Serventy, Owen and Pirrott 

Serventy et al. (1971) (cited by Clarke el al. 1971) in 
an unpublished document probably provided the first 
classification of w^ellands in the Darling System. Three 
genetic types of lakes or swamps were distinguished: 1) 
isolated portions of the ocean: they cited examples such 
as Preston-Clifton Lakes; 2) relic abandoned river 
courses of which Herdsman and Perr>' Lakes are cited as 
examples and 3) chance depressions. 


Classification adopned by Riggerl 

As part of a study into wetlands of Western Australia 
bv the Department of Fisheries & Fauna, Riggert (1964- 
1966) classified and evaluated wetlands of Western 
Australia (including the Darling System) (see Fig 1). The 
sludv was oriented to evaluating the utilisation ot 
wetlands by waterfowl. Riggeit postulated that the 
presence or absence of waterfowl provided an indication 
of the physical stale of a wetland. The wetlands were 
classified on criteria developed by Martin et at. (1953) 
into 22 types. These were A. INLASD FRESH AREAS 1 . 
Seasonally flooded basins or flats 2. Flooded 
.Agricultural Land 3. Inland fresh meadow's 4. Inland 
shallow fresh marshes 5. Inland deep fresh marshes 6. 
Inland open fresh water 7. Permanent Open Water 
(Reservoirs) 8. Shrub swamps 9. Wooded swamps and 
10. Bogs: B. ISIAND SALINE ARP:AS 1 1. Inland saline 
flats 12. Inland saline marshes and 13. Inland open 
saline water: C. COASTAL LRhSH AREAS 14. Coastal 
shallow fresh marshes 15. Coastal deep fresh marshes 
amd 16. (Coastal open fresh water: and D. CO.iSTAL 
SALINE AREAS 17. Coastal salt flats 18. Coastal salt 
meadows 19. Irregularly flooded salt marshes 20. 
Regularly flooded salt ma'rshes 21. Sounds and bays 22. 
Mangrove Sw'amps. 

Examples of these eategories of w'etlands in Western 
Australia were described in an inventory approach by 
Riggert noting size, depth, total surface area and 
vegetation. The wetlands were also categorised and 
evaluated on the basis of utilisation by waterfowl, in 
terms of numbers of waterfowl per year, and types of 
utilisation (e.g. breeding, feeding, migration and 
loafing). 

The approach by Riggert (1964-1966) indicated that 
there was much variability in wetland types. However, it 
did not distinguish between the mans types ot wetlands 
that exist in the Darling System that can be separated on 
the basis of geometrv', vegetation, degree of water 
permanence and other faunal groups apart from 
avifauna. For instance, riverine w'cllands were not 
distinguished. 


Classification adopted by Tingay and Tingay 

As part of a study into wetlands of the Darling System 
prepared for the Environmental Protection Authority, 
Tingay and Tingay (1976) classified and compiled an 
inventory of wetlands in the southwest of Western 
Australia. They adopted the classification of Hutchinson 
(1957) and Bayly and W'illiams ( 1 973), wherein wetlands 
in the first instance are classified into lentic and lotic. 
Tingay and Tingay (1976) utilised schemes that 
subdivided the lentic categories into 1) lakes: tectonic, 
volcanic, landslide, glacial, solution, fluviatile, wind 
action or coastal types, and 2) shallow water bodies: 
underground water, springs, water associated with 
terrestrial vegetation, puddles, rock pools and ponds. 


100 


Journal of the Royal Society of Western Australia, Vol. 69. Part 3. 1987. 


either permanent or temporary. Lotic categories were 
sub-divided as permanent, temporary or episodic, and 
also on features such as unidirectional flow, fluctuation 
in flow rales, linear morphology, etc. 

Tingay and Tingay applied the classification to the 
Darling System and noted that lenlic wetlands dominate 
the Bassendcan, Quindalup. Spearwood and Pinjarra 
geomorphic systems of Mc.A.nhiir and Bcttenay (1960), 
and that each wetland type within a geomorphic system 
may have similarity in terms of origin, nature and biota. 
Tingay and Tingay classified the lakes at Yanchep for 
instance, as lentic solution lakes, and the wetlands of the 
Bassendean system as Icntic wind action dune water 
table lakes. They further subdivided the lenlic wetlands 
of the coastal plain on the basis of soil elements and 
series (i.e. they adopted soil associations as 
environmental indicators) and they devised an acronym 
symbol system to distinguish them. The lotic wetlands 
were subdivided by Tingay and Tingay on a geographic 
basis into Moore, Swan, Peel. Lcschcnault, Capel and 
Hardy types with no further subdivision. 

The approach of Tingay and Tingay (1976) 
constituted a useful categorisation of wetlands for 
inventory' purposes. The categories provided a checklist 
of features to be determined for each wetland and 
highlighted the variability of wetlands. However, the 
system adopted is too genetic in the first instance, as well 
as too complicated both for classification purposes and 
for mapping. It involves a worker having to determine a 
wide range of factors such as soil mosaics and landform 
origin before a classification is possible. Yet a simpler 
classification is possible based on readily-availabic 
features gathered from maps and short field surveys. It 
should be noted, however, that many of important 
features of wetlands used by Tingay and Tingay arc 
utilised in the classification developed herein. 


Classification adopted by Wetlands Advisory Committee 
'(1977) 

The Wetlands Advisory Committee (1977) in a report 
to the Environmental Protection Authority also devised 
a classification of wetlands in the Darling System. The 
main subdivisions adopted by the committee were: 1) 
Lentic (non-flowing). 2) Lotic (flow'ing). 3) Estuarine, 
and 4) Artificial. Thereafter the wetlands were 
subdivided on criteria of size, salinity, permanence, and 
degree of vegetation cover. These criteria were 
considered important to determine the potential value of 
a wetland for particular uses (e.g. waterfowl drought 
refuge; or use for aquatic recreation). This approach 
produced a total of 15 potential types of lentic wetlands, 
which together w'ith the lotic, estuarine and artificial 
types identified a total of 18 wetland types throughout 
the Darling System region. 

Wetlands classified by the Wetlands Advisory 
Committee were allocated* symbols (similar to Tingay 
and Tingay 1976) to distinguish them. Thus Lake 
Jandabup at Wanneroo was designated LE.fLp.se 
(lenlic. fresh, large, permanent, semi-closed vegetation 
cover), the Swan River upper reaches were designated 
LO (lotic): the Swan River at Fremantle was designated 
E (estuarine) and ornamental lakes in Kings Park were 
designated A (artificial). 

The classification of the Wetlands Advisory 
Committee (1977) provided a useful categorisation of 
various types of wetlands. It addressed many of the 
major attributes of wetlands and clearly showed their 
variability and complexity in the Darling System. 


However the classification did not utilise wetland shape, 
only distinguished between two sizes of wetland (small 
and large), did not separate types of Lotic systems and 
did not distinguish between various “basin-type” 
wetlands or identify wetland flats. 


Classification by Allen 

As part of a geohydrology study of the Swan Coastal 
Plain. Allen (1976, 1981) identified wetlands as lakes 
and swamps and further categorised them into six types 
on the basis of age, inferred origin, and geographic 
location. Allen identified the following: 1) Bambum 
type. 2) Gnangara type, 3) Forrestdale type, 4) 
Joondalup type. 5) Gwelup type and 6) Cooloongup 
type. These categories I -6 were listed in order of inferred 
decreasing age. 


Other studies 

In addition to the works cited above in which 
classification of wetlands was a primary or important 
motive, there arc other works in which .some form of 
wetland classification or wetland vegetation 
classification was utilised. These works include Evans 
and Sherlock (1950), McComb and McComb (1967), 
Seddon (1972). Bell et al. (1979), Watson and Bell 
(1981); Muir (1983), Pen (1983), Speck and Baird 
(1984). Congdon and McComb (1976) and Baird (1984). 
Each of these works utilised established international 
classification schemes. Thus the Yanchep wetland 
system was termed a sw'amp and fen formation 
(NlcComb and McComb 1967), Star Swamp and Yeal 
Sw'amp were termed swamp and swampy flat, 
respectively (Watson and Bell 1981, Baird 1984), and 
Seddon (1972) utilised terms such as wetland, swamp, 
lake. 


Discussion 

All classifications devised to date have not provided 
an approach that enables categorisation of the variety of 
wetlands across the whole Darling System. Only 3 of the 
classifications have attempted to be comprehensive. 
These arc the works of Riggcrt (1964-66), Tingay and 
Tingay (1976). and the Welland Advisory Committee 
(1977). However, even the most detailed of these 
classifications use an essentially similar primary 
subdivision of lenlic and lotic types (Tingay and Tingay 
1976. Wetlands Advisory Committee 1977). The 
distinction between still-s’tanding water and flowing 
water (which is the basis of the lentic and lotic 
subdivision and essentially allempls to separate fluvial 
from lacustrine w'ctlands) however becomes indefinite in 
some systems, e.g. some channels are slow flowing, and 
in fact, have slower flow rales than some lakes, that are 
pan of a groundwater drainage system. The approach to 
classifying lakes by Tingay and Tingay (1976) is too 
genetic to be of use and secondly only considers part of 
the range of wetlands available, since many wetlands 
may have no free-standing water at any lime of year. A 
classification that separates the wetland into numerous 
types as proposed by Riggcn (1964-1966) serves as a 
useful function in identifying wetlands for use of 
avifauna but docs not provide the adequate distinction 
for additional purposes between the many varied 
wetland types existing in the Darling System. 

All the above classifications to date however have not 
adequately addressed the identification and 


101 


Journal of the Royal Society of Western Australia. Vol. 69. Part 3. 1987. 


nomenclature of waterlogged soils, or types of water 
saluration/inundaiion or the full range of cross-sectional 
and plan geometry of wetlands, or the range of sizes of 
wetlands. 


Classification — this study 

Philosophical approach lo classification 

Ideally classifications should initially be non-geneiic 
and then with additional information the non-genetic 
categories should relate to genetic categories. 
Landform/gcomorphic and water/wetness criteria are 
non-genetic and the proposed classification of wetlands 
is based fundamentally on the two major features which 
determine the existence of wetlands i.c. the water and 
landform components. The water component is the 
major feature that distinguishes the wetland habitat 
from other terrestrial habitats and also the component 
which inlluences biological response by its presence, 
depth, chemistry, and movement. The landform 
essentially is the “water container* and thus it 
determines the size, shape and depth of a wetland. Any 
wetland classification thus should reflect variability or 
attributes of these two components (Figure 3). In 
combination, the variables or attributes of these two 
components result in a wide spectrum of possible 
wetland types. As a prerequisite to examining these 
combinations, a fuller explanation of the types of 
subdivision of water and landform is presented below. 


The water component 

The component of water in a wetland may be viewed 
from 4 inter-related aspects: 1) its persistence or 

longevity, 2) its quality. 3) the consistency of water 
quality, and 4) the mechanism by which water maintains 
the wetland. 

The longevity of water residing in a wetland, i.c. its 
permanence or” intcrmittency. is directly related to the 
precipitation and evaporation, mechanisms of water 
supply, the permeability of underlying sediments, and 
the shape of the wetland. Three types of longevity are 
distinguished: 1) permanent inundation 2) seasonal or 
intermittent inundation 3) seasonal or intermittent 
waterlogging (without inundation). 

Water quality referring to the dissolved solids, rather 
than pH or coloration, may be subdivided into 
categories of: fresh, brackish (or mixosaline). saline and 
hypersalinc. However, there is inconsistent use of terms 
and definitions for categories such as brackish, saline, 
hypersaline (Davis and Dewiest 1966. Drever 1982 
Cowardin ei al. 1979, Logan ei al. 1974, Hammer et ai 
1983. Hammer 1986). The category terms and 
boundaries adopted in this paper arc presented in Table 
1. It also should be pointed out that many w'ctlands vary 
in salinity during the year due to variable input ol water 
sources and evapo-transpiration. Wetlands that are 
seasonally variable in salinity are categorised by the 
salinitv stale in which the wetland exists for the major 
part of each year e.g. a wetland that ranges from 
freshwater for most of the year, to brackish during the 
season of reduced water supply, w'ould be classified as 
freshwater. However, a term is introduced to denote 
whether salinity is constant or variable. Water quality 
that is consistent throughout the year (i.e. it remains 
totally within a given salinity field, e.g. the freshwater 
field or saline water field) is termed stasohalinef water 
quality that markedly fluctuates throughout the year is 


termed poikilohaline*. For instance a wetland that 
ailernaies seasonally from freshwater to saline is 
described herein as poikilohaline. In areas of seasonal 
inundation and seasonal waterlogging. the 
determination of salinity throughout the year will^ 
necessitate sampling the shallow groundwater for part of 
the year. 

Table 1 


Classification of water salinity based on total dissolved solids 


Salinity mg/1 

Water Category* 

less than 1,000 

Fresh 

1.000—3,000 

Subhaline 

3.000—20,000 

Hyposaline 

20.000—50.000 

Mesosaline 

50.000—100.000 

Hypersaline 

100,000 and greater 

Brine 


♦The terms and boundaries for fresh, subhaline, hyposaline mesosaline and 
hypersalinc arc from Hammer 1986: the term “brine” is delineated by 
Davis and Dewiest 1966. 


The mechanisms by w-hich water maintains the 
wetland arc variable and include direct precipitation, 
groundwater seepage, surface inflow, ponding etc. 
However the mechanisms of water maintenance will not 
be considered further here. 


Landform component 

The landform component of a wetland can be 
categorised on the basis of cross sectional geometry, plan 
geometry and scale. The cross sectional geometry' 
subdivides a wetland into basins, flats and channels. 
Basins and flats have no external surface drainage 
system. Basins range from flat bottomed lo concave, 
from steep lo gentle sloping sides, from shallow to deep 
and arc represented by many ot the common and 
ubiquitous lakes and “swamps" of the Swan Coastal 
Plain. They have clearly defined centres or depressions 
but may have shaip or broad margins. Cross sectional 
shapes of basins include: broad u-shape, steep u-shape. 
saucer, and slightly concave depressions. It is on the 
basis of a topographic depression that an individual 
basin is recognised. This factor is particularly important 
when a number of basins may form a nearly coalescing 
network: the local central depressions define each basin 
even though the littoral zones of adjacent basins may 
merge or overlap. Flats arc marked by little or no 
marginal relief, and have diffuse lateral boundaries. 
Flats in the Darling System commonly occur on the 
tributary interfluves of creeks and rivers, as overbank 
floodplains, and on broad alluvial flats and slopes in 
front of foothills of the Darling Scarp. 

Channels refer to any incised water course, or reach, 
including those connecting basin-type bodies of water. 
Channels have clearly defined margins and may be 
bedrock confined or alluv'ial and this distinction may 
result in deeply incised channels as opposed to shallowly- 
incised channels. The alluvial channels vary according to 
their hydraulic characteristics which arc determined by 
their slabilitv. channel and valley slope gradients, the 
mode of transport, and composition of their load 
(suspended vs. bedload). 


*siaso aticr Greek Stasimos ( -constanl) 

♦poikilo aher Greek Poikiios ( variable) 


102 


WETLAND COMPONENTS FOR USE IN CLASSIFICATION 


Permanently 

inundated 

Seasonally 

inundated 

Seasonally 

waterlogged 


WET I I LAND I 


WATER PERMANENCE 


CROSS-SECTIONAL SHAPE 


1 


Basin 

Channel 

Flat 


CRITERIA USED TO 
DEVELOP 

PRIMARY WETLAND 
CATEGORIES 


Fresh 

Subsaline 

Hyposaline 

Mesosaline 

Hypersaline 

Brine 


Poikilohaline 

Stasohaline 


3 


WATER SALINITY 


SIZE 


CONSISTENCY OF 
WATER SALINITY 


PLAN SHAPE 


Megascale 

Macroscale 

Mesoscale 

Microscale 

Leptoscale 

Linear — 

Elongate 
Irregular 
Ovoid 

Round — 

Straight — 

Sinuous 
Anastomosing 
Irregular — 


CRITERIA USED TO 

DEVELOP 

SECONDARY 

WETLAND 

CATEGORIES 


Telluric — 
Meteoric — 
Marine — 


WATER MAINTENANCE 
( ORIGIN ) 


STRATIGRAPHY 


ORIGIN 


CRITERIA NOT USED 
IN THIS PAPER 


Figure 3. — Components or attributes of wetlands and their terminology used in the proposed classification. 


Channel terms include rivers, streams, brooks, creeks, 
drainage lines or troughs. Only the terms rivers and 
creeks are used in this classification. 

In plan form, encompassing the limnetic and littoral 
zones (Hutchinson 1957, Cowardin el al. 1979), wetland 
shapes arc easily discernible and may be described as 
linear, elongate, irregular, ovoid or round, for basins; 
and straight, sinuous, anastomosing, or irregular for 
channels (Fig. 4). 

Wetlands may be further categorised according to 
scale. For basins and flats the categories of geomorphic 
scale (modifed from Semcniuk 1986) are: 

Megascale: Very large scale wetlands larger than a 
frame of reference 1 0km x 1 0km 

Macroscale; Large scale wetlands encompassed by a 
frame of reference 1 000m x 1000m to 10km x 
10km 

Mesoscale; Medium scale wetlands encompassed by 
a frame of reference 500m x 500m to 1000m x 
1000m 

Microscale: Small scale wetlands encompassed by a 
frame of reference 100m x 1 00m to 500m x 
500m 

In the case of channels, a definitive width to length 
relationship is used: 

Macroscale: Large scale channels I km and greater 
wide, by several to tens of kilometres long. 


Mesoscale; Medium scale channels hundreds of 
metres wide, by thousands of metres long. 

Microscale: Small scale wetlands tens of metres 
wide, hundreds of metres long. 

Leptoscale: Fine scale channels several metres wide, 
tens of metres long. 

The suggested order of importance to classification for 
the components of landform is presented in Figure 3. 


I'he proposed classification 

The classification of wetlands proposed here has been 
developed by combining the various components of 
water and landform. Using primary subdivisions of 
cross-sectional landform geometry there are recognised: 

• basins 

• channels 

• Hats 

Within the category of basin, using primary subdivision 
of water there are recognised: 

• permanently inundated types 

• seasonally inundated types 

• seasonally waterlogged types. 

Within the category of channels there arc: 

• permanently inundated types 

• seasonally, or intermittently, inundated types. 


103 


Journal of the Royal Society of Western Australia, Vol. 69, Part 3, 1987. 


Within the category of flats there arc; 

• seasonally, or intermittently, inundated types 

• seasonally, or intermittently, waterlogged types. 

This categorisation then allows recognition of 7 main 

wetland types: 


Water 


Landform 


Longevity 

Basin 

Channel 

Flat 

Permanent 

inundation 

Permanently 

inundated 

basin 

Permanently 

inundated 

channel 

— 

Seasonal (or 

intermittent) 

inundation 

Seasonally 

inundated 

basin 

Seasonally 

inundated 

channel 

Seasonally 

inundated 

flat 

Seasonal (or 

intermittent) 

waterlogging 

Seasonally 

waterlogged 

basin 

— 

Seasonally 

waterlogged 

flat 


These basic 7 categories require nomenclature so that 
they may form the primary units of wetland 
differentiation. Permanently inundated flats and 
seasonally waterlogged channels arc not common 
wetlands. 


1. 

2 . 

3. 

4. 

5. 

6 . 
7. 


The proposed terms for the basic wetland units arc: 


Permanently inundated basin 
Seasonally inundated basin 
Seasonally waterlogged basin 
Permanently inundated channel 
Seasonally inundated channel 
Seasonally inundated flat 
Seasonally waterlogged Hat 


= LAKE 

= SUMPLAND 

= DAMPLAND 

-RIVER 

-CREEK 

-FLOODPLAIN 

-PALUSPLAIN 


Some of the terms above arc established and well 
defined previously in the literature and hence have been 
rc-utilised. Others (i.e. sumpland, dampland, palusplain) 
have been coined in this paper. The rationale for. the 
definition of, and the origin of the terms arc described in 
Table 2. A comparison of the proposed wetland terms 
with other previously established terms is provided in 
Table 3. It should be noted that the terms river and creek 
are used to denote permanence and intcrmittcncy of 
water flow, respectively; the size of the river or creek is 
indicated by the use of the scale modifier. 


Areas such as damplands and palusplains which are 
rarely or infrequently inundated do not necessarily 
qualify to be termed sumplands and floodplains. The 
characteristic of seasonal waterlogging should be a 
prevailing, recurring feature and this is the deciding 
factor in determining the categorisation of a wetlarid by 
the longevity and type of its “wetness". The occasional 
or infrequent flooding of terrain can take place anywhere 
during torrential rainfall or sheet flooding but such 
phenomena do not categorise the temporarily inundated 
land surface as a wetland. .An example illustrating how a 
basin cross sectional geometr>' interacts with a varying 
water level to develop 3 categories of wetland (i.e. lake, 
sumpland and dampland) is presented in Figure 5. 

Further uses of water and landform 
descriptors/modifiers are implemented to elaborate and 
ornament the nomenclature of the primary units. For 
example, the Swan Coastal Plain contains numerous 


PLAN GEOMETRY OF WETLANDS 



examples of freshw'ater large scale ovoid, permanently 
inundated basins, that remain fresh throughout the year; 
these would be simply and obviously termed freshwater, 
stasohaline macroscale, ovoid lakes. Lake Coogee for 
instance is a hyposaline. stasohaline, macroscale, ovoid 
lake; Lake Joondalup is a freshwater, stasohaline 
macroscale lake; Lake Pinjar is a freshwater, stasohaline 
megascale sumpland. 

The full range of descriplors/modifiers are listed in 
Figure 3. A variety of wetland types developed by 
various combinations of water and landform features are 
listed in Table 4 together with some examples of each. 
Figure 6 illustrates a typical range in geometry and size 
of various wetlands in the Darling System. 


104 


Journal of the Royal Society of Western Australia, Vol. 69, Part 3, 1987. 


Table 2 

Definition and origin of terms 


Wetland term 

Definition 

Defined by 

Origin of term 

Usage in this paper 

Lake 

Permanently inundated 
basin of variable size 
and shape 

Mill (1900-1910) 
Monkhouse ( 1 965) 
Bates & Jackson ( 1 980) 
Fairbridge (1968) 
Ruttner(1953) 

Established term, from Latin 
(acus, a hollow. 

The usage in this paper does not 
distinguish between shallow lakes and 
deep lakes. 

Sumpland 

Seasonally inundated 
basin of variable size 
and shape 

This paper 

After “sump" meaning site of 
water retention or ponding or 
accumulation; The term is 
fortuitously similar to “sumpf' 
the German term for swamp 

As defined. 

Dampland 

Seasonally waterlogged 
basin of variable size 
and shape 

This paper 

After “damp” meaning moist or 
wet. Thus it refers to a dampness 
or waterlogging of soils of some 
basin wetlands 

As defined. 

River 

Permanently inundated 
channel of variable size 
and shape 

Swayne (1956) 
Trowbridge (1962) 
Morisawa(1968) 

Established term from Latin of 
most mm, a stream (Shipley 
1982) 

This usage conforms with the concept of 
other authors that a river is defined as 
channelled water flow, but is different to 
most authors in its necessity for 
permanence of water. The permanence of 
water, also generally implies a channel of 
large rather than small size. 

Creek 

Seasonally inundated 
channel of variable size 
and shape 

Whittow(I984) 
Monkhouse (1965) 
Trowbridge (1962) 

Bates and Jackson 
(1980) 

Established term 

This usage generally conforms with that of 
Australia and southwestern U.S.A. 

Floodplain 

Seasonally inundated 
flat 

Mill (1900-1910) 
Monkhouse (1965) 
Moore ( 1 949) 

Established term 

This differs from other authors in that 
inundation of the plain need not be linked 
to a river; in general however a floodplain 
is associated with a river or creek. 

Palusplain 

Seasonally waterlogged 
flat 

This paper 

After latin palus meaning 
“marshy”; thus the term refers to 
flats which are similar to 
dampland basins. 

As defined. 

Stasohaline 

Water of relatively 
constant salinity 

remaining in a given 
salinity field 

This paper 

After staso (Greek) meaning 
constant 

As defined. 

Poikilohaline 

Water of variable 
salinity fluctuating from 
one salinity field to 
another 

Originally defined Dahl 
(1956) 

After poikilo (Greek) meaning 
variable 

As defined. 

Waterlogged 

Area in which water 
stands near, or at the 
land surface 


Established term 

Usage conforms with Golet and Larson 
(1974), Martin et al., (1953) and most 
other authors. 


The use of vegetation in describing and classifying 
wetlands has always been accepted by wetland workers. 
Vegetation has been viewed in previous work in terms 
of: 1) structure. 2) life form, 3) species dominance, 4) 
percentage cover of area, and 5) zonation. Each of these 
parameters significantly increase understanding of an 
individual wetland, and its uniqueness or similarity to 
other wetlands. The methods for describing vegetation 
have been thoroughly documented by numerous authors, 
as have interrelationships with physical chemical and 
biological variables. Vegetation also becomes important 
when correlating or establishing ecological linkage for 
chains or series of wetlands in the same physiographic 
settings, but because it is a dynamic, responsive and 
mutable feature, it is suggested that the use of vegetation 


should only be employed in a later stage description of 
individual wetlands as opposed to initial stage regional 
descriptions of wetlands. It is suggested that the use of 
vegetation be applied in a tertiary or quaternary 
modifier capacity. As such, it is suggested that 
vegetation be used as an adjectival modifier to the 
wetland classification by utilising floristic and structural 
terms with a primary w'ctland class. However it should 
be pointed out that catcgorisation/classificalion of 
w'etland vegetation becomes a difficult task where 
vegetation is not a simple extensive unit but rather 
concentrically zoned, or in the form of complex mosaics. 

The use by many limnologists and biologists 
(Hutchinson 1957, Wetzel 1983, Ruttner 1953, Bayly 


105 


Journal of the Royal Society of Western Australia, Vol. 69, Part 3, 1987. 


Fable 3 

Comparison of wetland terms used in this paper with established classifications 


This paper 

Martin 

elal.{\957>) 

Cowardin 
et al. (1979) 

Golet & 
Larson (1974) 

Paijmans 
ei fl/. (1985) 

General 

European 

General 
N. American 

Lake 

Open fresh water 
Deep fresh marshes 
Open saline water 

Lacustrine 

Open water 
Shrub swamp 
Deep marsh 

Lakes 
Swamp 
Coastal water 
bodies 

Lake 

Swamp 

Lake 

Swamp 

Sumpland 

Wooded swamp 
Seasonally flooded 
Basins 

Shallow fresh marshes 
Deep fresh marshes 
Saline marshes 
Open saline water 

Palustrine 

Deep marsh 
Shallow marsh 
Shrub swamp 
Wooded swamp 
Open water 

Lakes 

Swamp 

Marsh 

Marsh 

Meadow 

Dampland 

Fresh meadows 
Wooded swamp 

Palustrine 

Meadow 

— 

— 

Meadow 

River 

— 

Riverine 

— 

River and 

creek 

channels 

River 

Stream 

Creek 

Brook 

River 

Stream 

Creek 

Brook 

Creek 

— 

Riverine 

— 

River and creek 
channels 

— 

.Arroyo 

Floodplain 

Shrub swamp 
Wooded swamp 

— 

Seasonally flooded 
flats 

Land subject to 
inundation 

Floodplain 

Roodplain 
Seasonally 
Flooded flat 

Palusplain 

Wooded swamp 
Saline flat 
Salt meadow? 

Palustrine 

— 

— 

— 

— 


BASIN WETLANDS IN RELATIONSHIP TO WATER LEVEL FLUCTUATION 


LAKE SUMPLAND DAMPLAND 



Figure 5.— The development (based on permanence of water) of the 3 basin wetland categories, which in this example are related to 
landform position with respect to fluctuating water level. 


106 



Journal of the Royal Society of Western Australia, Vol. 69, Part 3, 1987. 


and Williams 1973, Cowardin et al. 1979) of the terms 
limnetic and littoral to denote physical regions of a basin 
wetland is important in this classification. By denoting 
these separate zones, a wetland can be viewed in its 
entirety rather than as two or more separate wetlands 
e.g. the gradation from inundated surface to waterlogged 
soil may be seen as a continuous system. Thus the 
exposed marginal zone of a lake need not be viewed as a 
sumpland. but rather as a littoral zone. 

Application of the proposed classification to wetlands of 
the Darling System 

Several areas in different physiographic regions have 
been selected to indicate the practical use of the 
proposed classification and to display the range of 
wetlands occurring throughout the Darling System in 
their variability of geometry, size, and salinity. Figure 7 
presents maps from four d'lffcrcnt geomorphic settings 
on the Swan Coastal Plain (Mc.Arthur and Beltenay 
1960) and illustrates a range of wetland types in each 
selected area. Figure 8 presents hydrographs of selected 
wetlands from these areas to illustrate their hydrologic 
properties. The areas selected are: 

1 . Gnangara area 

2. Ballajura area 

3. Coogee area 

4. Pt. Becher area 

fable 4 


Classification of some typical wetlands in the Darling system 


Wetland 

Primary 

Category 

Full Classification * 

Lake Joondalup 

lake 

macroscale, elongate 
stasohaline, lake. 

fresh. 

Lake Bambun 

lake 

mesoscale. round subsaline 
stasohaline. lake. 

Lake Coogee 

lake 

mesoscale, elongate hyposaline 
stasohaline. lake. 

Lake Bibra 

lake 

macroscale. irregular 
poikilohaline, lake 

fresh. 

Lake Cooloongup 

lake 

macroscale, ovoid hyposaline 
poikilohaline, lake. 

Carine Swamp 

sumpland 

mesoscale. ovoid 

stasphaline. sumpland. 

fresh. 

Lake Pinjar 

sumpland 

macroscale. ovoid 

stasphaline. sumpland. 

fresh. 

Bollard Bullrush 

Swamp 

sumpland 

macroscale. round 

poikilohaline. sumpland. 

fresh. 

Melaleuca Park 

sumpland 

microscale. ovoid 

poikilohaline, sumpland. 

fresh. 

Stable Swamp 

sumpland 

microscale. linear 

stasohaline. sumpland. 

fresh. 

Lake Bindiar 

dampland 

mesoscale. round 

stasohaline. dampland. 

fresh. 

Lake Adams 

dampland 

macroscale. ovoid 

poikilohaline. dampland. 

fresh. 

Yalbanberup Pool 

river 

mesoscale. sinuous hypersaline, 
poikilohaline. river. 

Ellen Brook 

creek 

microscale. sinuous 

poikilohaline. creek. 

fresh. 

Collie River 

tributory at Schotts 

creek 

microscale. straight 

stasohaline, creek 

fresh. 


* Information for this classification based on 3 years of seasonal surveys. 


The Gnangara area (Fig. 7) set in the Bassendean 
Dune system of McArthur and Bettenay (1960) is 
dominated by numerous unnamed microscale, round 
stasohaline, freshwater, sumplands and damplands. 
Lake Gnangara itself was an isolated macroscale, round, 
stasohaline freshwater lake; in recent years it has 
changed to being a sumpland. Snake Sw'amp is a 
mesoscale. ovoid, stasohaline, freshwater dampland. 
Badjerup Lake is a mesoscale. ovoid, stasohaline, 
freshwater sumpland. 

In contrast, the Ballajura area set in the Bassendean 
Dune system and Pinjarra Plain alluvial system of 
McArthur and Bettenay (1960), contains wetlands that 
are mesoscale, straight and sinuous stasohaline creeks, a 
mesoscale. freshwater, poikilohaline river, mesoscale to 
macroscale floodplains which arc poikilohaline. and 
microscale, freshwater, stasohaline sumplands and 
damplands. 

The Lake Coogee area set in the Spearwood Dune 
System of McArthur and Bettenay (I960) has the 
following wetlands: Lake Coogee North is a mesoscale, 
elongate, poikilohaline. mesosaline sumpland; Lake 
Coogee South is a mesoscale elongate, stasohaline, 
hyposaline lake: the Henderson wetland complex is 
comprised of mesoscale, elongate, poikilohaline, 
freshwater sumplands; and Brownman*s Swamp is a 
mesoscale ovoid, poikilohaline freshwater sumpland. 

The Pi. Bccher area, set in the Quindalup Dune 
system of McArthur and Bettenay 1960, is one in which 
microscale, ovoid, linear to irregular shaped, 
poikilohaline freshwater sumplands and damplands 
predominate. 


Discussion 

Wetlands arc inherently complex ecological habitats 
but their analysis is simplified somewhat by a 
classification which brings into prominence the 
important wetland components of water and landform. 
Since there are only seven basic geomorphic wetland 
types, to which are added modifiers/descriplors of scale, 
plan geometry, and water properties, the classification 
enables one to distinguish a practicable number of 
wetland types. The basic wetland categories can then be 
ornamented/embellished to illustrate further variability 
with the addition of more detailed field information. But 
even without the more detailed studies a given wetland 
still can be readily classified into the primary categories 
with a minimum of field surveys. Thus the approach 
provided here has the advantages when additional 
detailed information becomes available of increasing the 
discrimination of individual wetlands from each other 
and from their surrounding areas; with less precise 
information available, categorisation at a broader level 
into a regional physiographic setting is also feasible. 

The proposed classification also can provide useful 
mapping units since the various wetland types may be 
readily identified and mapped as categories. The 
regional differences and similarities between wetlands 
also would emerge more clearly and may be linked to 
other types of mapping parameters, e.g. contours, 
climate, geology. The "diw" wetland types in the Darling 
System, i.e. the damplands. which in the past were in 
some cases excluded, or included as wetlands on the 
basis of mixed criteria, can now be consistently 
identified as a category of wetland. 


107 


A LAKES 



0 


A6 






B SUMPLANDS 



C DAMPLANDS 


OC3 


D CHANNELS: RIVERS and CREEKS 



C8 


0 


\ ” 


Q C7 

oC? 


0 

0C4 


o 


C5 


0 






FLOODPLAINS and PALUSPLAINS 


E1 


E4 




£V.° J Floodplain 
l~ i Palutplain 


A1 

Loch McNess 

C1 

A2 

Nowergup Lake 

C2 

A3 

Lake Joondalup 

C3 

A4 

Jandabup Lake 

C4 

AS 

Lake Monger 

C5 

A6 

Lake Richmond 

C6 

A7 

Lake Cooioongup 

C7 

A8 

Bibra, North Lakes 

C8 



C9 

B1 

Lake Karrinyup 

D1 

B2 

Wallabuenup Swamp 

D2 

B3 

Balcatta 

D3 

B4 

Lake Claremont 

D4 

B5 

Lake Pinjar 


B6 

Bollard Bullrush Swamp 

B7 

Lake Banganup 

E1 

B8 

The Spectacles 

E2 

B9 

Wright Road Swamp 

E3| 



E4I 

0 

5 km 

E5 

L 

1 

E6 


Lake Adams 
Sydney Rd, Gnangara 
Piney Lake East 
Nicholson Rd, Forrestdale 
West of Yangebup 
Canning Vale Area 
Johnson Rd, Casuarina 
Bindiar Lake 
Yeal Swamp group 


Canning River 
Ellen Brook 
Serpentine River 
Gin Gin Brook 


West Rd, Keysbrook 
Muchea Area 
" Timaru ” near Brand 
Hwy and Chandalla Bk 
Chandalla Brook 
Canning River 


Figure 6. — Typical range of wetland categories in the Darling System. 


108 



Figure 7. — Maps showing types and distribution of wetland categories for four selected areas. 


HYDROGRAPHS OF TYPICAL BASIN WETLANDS 


LAKE 


SUMPLAND 


DAMPLAND 



0 Bibra Lake 
• Jandabup Lake 
A Lake Joondalup 
A Lake Cooloongup 
■ Lake Coogee 


o Henderson System 

• Stakehill Swamp 

^ North Lake Swamp 

* Wright Road Swamp 
■ Mungala Swamp 


o Gnangara Pine Forest 1 
• Gnangara Pine Forest 7 
^ Stoney Rd, Gnangara 
A Lake Adams 
■ Ballajura area 


Figure 8. — Hydrographs of some typical basin wetlands on the Swan Coastal Plain. 


Journal of the Royal Society of Western Australia. Vol. 69. Part 3. 1987. 


Various wetland categories have a range of 
multifarious ecological functions and the proposed 
classification may parallel these functional delineations. 
For instance lakes, damplands and creeks are utilised by 
fauna in different ways because each of these wetlands 
arc essentially different habitats as determined by the 
longevity and type of water input. For example some 
avifauna and reptiles use open water lakes for a specific 
range of purposes, whereas the vegetated sanctuary of 
many typical damplands may be utilised by mammals 
and other species of avifauna in a different capacity. 
Nutrient pathways and trophic inter-relationships also 
may be fundamentally distinct bctw'ccn these various 
primary wetland types. Botanists. zoologists, 
educationalist, recreational and land use planners may 
be able to make preliminary' assessments of the di^ ersity. 
dependence, complexity etc. of wetlands from the class 
to which it belongs. The advantage of the proposed 
classification also is that it can be used as a basis for any 
wetland study regardless of the ultimate discipline of the 
study (e.g. hydrology, stratigraphy, botany, zoology), and 
so circumvents the problem of a proliferation of 
nomenclature arising from specific applications/studies. 
Thus it provides a non-genelic framew-ork upon which to 
base further detailed work. 

Finally it is apparent that with the proposed 
classification a wetland can still be placed in its 
appropriate category^ even if it has been substantially 
altered by clearing of vegetation and disturbance of soils. 
As long as the mechanisms of water maintenance and 
basic geometry have not been destroyed then the 
inherent geomorphic wetland entity remains and can be 
identified and named. 

Acknowlcdgemem.s — The manuscnpi was critically reviewed by D. 
Glassford. I. LeProvost. V. Semeniuk and P. A. S, Wurni. Their help is 
gratefully acknowledged. Some of the research for this study was funded by 
veSRG. Research and Educational Consultants and LeProvost. Semeniuk 
and Chalmcr. Environmental Consultants. 


References 

Adam. P.. Unwin, N.. W'eincr. P.. Sim. 1. and W'iner, P. (1985). — Coastal 
^Vctlamis of New South ^^'a^es. Report for Department of 
Environment and Planning. 

Allen, T. (1976). — Outline of the hydrogeology of the superficial formations 
on the Swan Coastal Plain H ..1. Gcoi. Surv. Ann. Kept. 1975: 31- 
42. 

Allen. T. ( 1981 ). — fJroundwalcr Resources of the Svvan Coastal Plain, near 
Perth. Western Australia. In: Groundwater Resources of the Swan 
Coastal Plain. CSIRO. Proceedings of Symposium by CSIRO and 
Western Australian Slate Committee of Water Research 
Foundation. 

Anderson, J A. R. (1983). — The Tropical Peat Swamps of Wesleni 
Malesia. In: Gore. A. J. P. (Ed.) Ecosystems of the World. 4H. 
.Xfires; Swamp. Bog. Fen and Moor. Regional Studies. Elsevier 
Scicntilic Publishing Co., pl8]-l99, 

Baird. A. M. (1984). — Observations on regeneration after fire in the Yule 
Brook Reserve near Perth. Western Australia. J. Roe. Soc. 
11.4.67:1-13. 

Bayly, J. A. E. and W'lUiams, W. D. (1973). — Inland X\'utcrs and Their 
Ecology^ Longman Cheshire. 

Bates. R. L. and Jackson. J. A. (1980). — Glo.'isuiy of Geology. .American 
Geological Institute. 

Bell. D. T.. Loneragan. W. .A. and Dodd. J. (1979), — Preliminary 
vegetation survey of Star Swamp and vicinity. Western Australia. 
Herbarium Res. Notes Number 2: 1 -2 1 . 

Bloom. A. L- (1978). — Geomorphology. 1 Systematic .inanlysis of Late 
Cenozotc Landforms. Preniice-IIall Inc., pi 97-278. 

Briggs. S. V. (1981). — Freshwater Wetlands. In: R. H Groves (Ed.). 
-iusirahan I'egelaiion. Cambridge University Press. London, 
p335-.^60. 

Campbell. E. O. (1983). — Mires of Australasia. In; Gore .A. J. P. (Ed.) 
Ecosysiemi of 'he li orld. 4B. Mires; Swamp. Bog. Fen and .Moor. 
Regional .*>tudk’s. Elsevier Scientific Publishing Co.. pl53-180. 

Cant. D. J. ( 1 982)-Fluvial Facies Models and their .Application. In: Scholle. 

P. A. and Spearing. D. (Eds.) Sandstone Dcposifional 
Environments, .-im. .-l.s5oc. Petrol. Geoi. Mem 31: 115-121. 


Chorlcy. R. J. (1969). — The Drainage Basin as the Fundamental 
Geomorphic Llnit. In; Chorley. R. J.. (Ed.) Introduction to Fluvial 
Processes. Methuen & Co. Ltd. p30-5 1 . 

Clarke. E. de C.. Pridcr. R. T., Tcichert. C. (1971). — Elements of Geology 
for A usiralian Students, University of W..A . Press. 

Congdon. R. A. and McComb. A. J (1976). — The nutrients and plants of 
Lake Joondalup, a mildly enirophic lake c.xperiencing large 
seasonal changes m volume. Roy. Soc. W.A.. 59: 14-23. 

Cowardin. L. M.. Carter. V., Golet. F. C. and LaRoe. E. T. 
(1979). — Classification oj wetlands and deepwater habitats of the 
United Staled. U.S. Dept, of the Inlerior; Fish & Wildlife Service 
Dec. 

Cowling, S. L. ( 1 977). — Classification of the wetland habitats of waterbirds. 
Aust. Mar. Sci. Bull.. 58. 

Dahl. E. (1956). — Ecological salinity boundaries in poikilohaline waters. 
Oikos. 7: 1-21. 

Davis. S. N. and DeWiesi. R. J. (1966). — Hydrogeology. John Wiley & 
Sons Inc., pi 1 8. 

Denny. P. (Ed.) (1985). — The Ecolo.gy and .Management of .African wetland 
vegetation. W'. Junk Publishers. 

Department of Conservation and Environment (1980). — Wetlands 
Guidelines for protection and management. Dept. Conservation & 
Environment Bulletin No. 79. 

Drever. J. 1. (1982). — The Geochemistry of Natural H ater. Prentice-Hall. 
Inc. 

Evans. G. A. and Sherlock. N. V. (1950). — Butler's Swamp Claremont. 
H 'cstern .Australian Nalurali.st.,2: 1 52. 

Fairbridgc, R. W, (Ed.) ( 1 968). — The Encyclopedia of Oeomorphology. I 'ol. 
Ill Dow’den. Hutchinson Sc Ross Inc. 

Lceder. M. R. ( 1 982). — Sedimentology Process Product. .Allen & Linwin. 

Gilluly. J.. Walers. .A. C. and Woodford. .A. O. (1951). — Principles of 
Geology. Freeman & Co.. p224-231 . 

Gold. F. C and Larson. J. S. (1974). — Classification of Freshwater 
Wetlands in the Glaciated Northeast. Resource Publication 1 16. 
US. Fish and Wildlife Seivice Washington. D.C. 

Goodrick. G. M. (1970). — .A Surv’cy of Wetlands of coastal New South 
Wales. CSIRO Division of Wildlife Research Technical 
Memorandum No. 5. 

Gore. A. J, P. ( 1 983). — Introduction. In: Gore A. J. P. (Ed.) Ecosystems of 
the World. 4.A. .Mires.- Swamp. Bog. Fen. and Moor. General 
Studies. Elsevier Scientific Publishing Co., pi -34. 

Gorham, E. ( 1953). — Some Early Ideas Concerning the Nature. Origin and 
Development of Peat Lands. Jour. Ecology.. 41: 257-273. 

Gorham. E. (1957), — The Development of Peatlands. Quart. Review 
Biology.. 32: 147-164, 

Hakanson, L, and Jansson, M. ( 1983). — Principles of Lake Sedimentology. 
Springer-Verlag, p5-l7. 

Hammer. I'. T.. (1986). — Saline Lake Lcosysrems of the H'orld. Dr. W'. 
Junk Publishers. 

Hammer, IL T. Shamess. J.. and Haynes. R. C. (1983). — The distribution 
and abundance of algae in saline lakes of Saskatchewan. Canada. 
In: U. T. Hammer (cd.) Saline Lakes Proc. 2nd Int. Symp 
Aihalassic Inland Saline Lakes. Dev. Hydrobiol 16 Junk. The 
Hague. p)-26. 

Hill, J. R. Jr. (1978). — Corps of Engineers efforts related to Wetland 
Protection. In: Montanan, J. H. and Kusler. J. A. (Ed.) Proceedings 
of the National Wetlands Protection Sympo.sium. 1977. Reston. Va. 
O.S. Dept of the Interior Fish and Wildlife Serv ice FWS/OBS- 
78/79. Washington D.C. 

Hofsletter. R. H. (1983). — Wetlands in the United Slates. In; Gore. A. J. P. 
(Ed.) Ecosystems oJ the H 'orld. 4B. Mires; Swamp. Bog, Fen and 
.Moor. Regional Studies. Elsevier Scientific Publishing Co.. p201- 
244. 

Holmes, A. (1944). — Principles of Physical Geology. Nelson. p437-440 and 
P67I-675. 

Howard Williams. C. and Gaudet. J. J. (1985).— The Structure and 
functioning of African Swamps. In: Denny. P. (Ed.) The Ecology (S 
Management of .African Wetland Vegetation. VV. Junk Publishers, 
p 153-1 76. 

Hutchinson. G. E. ^1957). — A Treatise on Limnology. 1 V>/. I. Wiley & Sons. 

Ivanov. K, E. ( 1 98 1 ). — H atcr .Movement in .Mirelands. .Academy Press. 

Jacobs. S. W. L. (1983). — Vegetation. In: Haigh. C (Ed.). H'etlands in 
N.S.W. Parks and Wildlife, pi 4-1 9. 

Junk. W. J. (1983). — Ecology ofSwamps on the Middle Amazon. In; Gore, 
,A. J. P. (Ed.) Fcosystetm of the H'orld. 4B. Mires; Swamp. Bog. Fen 
and Moor. Regional Studies. Elsevier Scientific Publishing Co.. 
p269-294. 

Kulczynski. F. (1949). — Peal bogs of Polesic, Mem .icad. Sei. Cracovic.. 
Ser. B: 12356. 

Leopold. L, B.. Wolman, M. G. and Miller. J. P. (1964). — Fluvial Processes 
in Geomorphology. W. H. Freeman & Co.. San Francisco. 


110 


Journal of the Royal Society of Western Australia, Vol. 69, Part 3, 1987. 


Logan. B. W.. Read. J. F-, Hagan. G. M., Hoffman, P.. Brown. R. G.. 
Woods, P. J. and Gcbclcin. C. D. (1974). — Evolution and 
Diagencsis of Quaternary Carbonate Sequences, Shark Bay, 
Western Australia. .-Iw. /I.v5w. Petrol, (ieoi, Mem. 22. 

McArthur, W. M, and Beiienav, E. (I960). — The Development and 
Disinbulion of the Soils of the Swan Coastal Plain Western 
Australia, CSfROSoU Publicaiton'^io. 16. 

Martin. A. C.. Hotkiss. N.. Uhler, F. M. and Bourn, W. S 
(1953). — ClassiHcation of Wetlands of the United States. V.S. Fbh 
Wild!. Servian. Spec. Sa Rep. H ildl. No. 20. 

McComb, J- .A. and McComb, A. J. (1967). — A Preliminary .Account of the 
Vegetation of Loch McNcss, a swamp and fen formation in 
Wc.slem Australia. Roy. Soc. H'.A . 50: 105-112. 

Miall. A. D. (1977). — A Review of the braided river depositional 
Environment: i'tirr/j 617. Rev., 13: 1*62. 

Mill. H. R, (J900-19I0). — In: Sir Dudley Stamp (Ed.) 1966. A Glossary of 
Geographical Terms. 

Monkhouse. E. J. (1965). — A Dictionary' of Geography. E. Arnold and 
Chicago Aldinc. 

Moore. P. D. and Bellamy. D. J (1974). — Peatlands. London. Elek Science, 
p9-183. 

Moore. W. G. (1949). — A Dictionary of Geography. Penguin Books. 
Harmondsworlh. Middlesex. 

Morisawa. M, (1968). — Streams.' Their dynamics and morphology. New 
York. McGraw-Hill Book Co. 

Muir, B. G. (1983). — Drainage. Swamp Structure and Vegetation 
Succession at Melaleuca Pk. Northern Swan Coastal Plain. 
Herbarium Research Notes. No. 9: 27-39. 

Paijmans, K.. Galloway. R. W., Faith. D. P., Fleming. P. M.. Haantjens, H. 
A.. Hcyligers, P. C.. Kalma, J. D. and Loflier. E. (1985). — Aspects 
of Australian Wetlands. CSIRO Aust. Div. Hater Land Resources 
Techntcal Paper No. 44: 1-71. 

Pen. L. J (1983). — Pcnpheral Vegetation of the Swan and Canning 
Estuaries 1981. Dept, of Conservation and Environment. Bull. 113. 

Pisano, E. (1983). — The Magellanic Tundra Complex. In; Gore. ,A. J. P. 
(Ed.) Ecosystems of the World. 4B. .\fires. Syy-amp. Bog. Fen and 
Moor. Regional Studies. Elsevier Scientific Publishing Co.. p295- 
330. 

Reeves, C. C. Jr. (1968). — Introduction to Palaeoltmnology. Elsevier. 

Reineck, H. E. and Singh, I, B. (1973). — Depositional Sedimentary 
Environments. Springer- Verlag. 

Riggert, T. L. (1964-1966). — Wetlands of Western Australia Department of 
Fisheries and Fauna West. Aust. 

Ruttner. F. (1953). — Fundamentals of Limnology University of Toronto 
Press. 

Ruuhijarvi, R. (1983). — The Finnish Mire Types and Their Regional 
Distribution. In: Gore. A. J. P. (Ed.) Ecosystems of the World. 4B. 
Mires; Swamp. Bog. Fen and Moor. Regional Studies. Elsevier 
Scientific Publishing Co.. p47-68. 


Schumm, S. A. { 1977). — The Fluvial System. John Wiley & Sons. 

Seddon. G. { 1 972). — A Seme of Place. University of W,A Press. 

Scmcniuk, V. (1986). — Terminology for geomorphic units and habitats 
along the tropica] coast of Western Australia. J Roy. Soc. W.A. 68: 

Shipley. J. T. (1982). — Dictionary of Word Origins. Littlefield. Adams & 
Co. 

Sjors, H. (1983). — Mires of Sweden. In: Gore. A. J. P. (Ed.) Ecosystems of 
the World. 4B. .Mires: Swamp, Bog. Fen and .Moor. Regional 
Studies. Elsevier Scientific Publishing Co.. p69 94. 

Smith, D. G. (1983). — Anastomosed fluvial deposits: modern examples 
from Western Canada. In; J. D. CoHinson and J. Lewin (Ed.) 
Modern and Ancient Fluvial Syslenu. Special Publication Number 
6 of the Inlcmalionql Association of Sedimcnlologisis. Blackwell 
Scientific Publications. pl55-!68. 

Speck. N. H. and Baird, A. M. (1984). — Vegetation of Yule Brook Reserve 
near Perth, Western Australia, ./, Roy. Soc. H 66: 147-162. 
Slrahler, A. N. and Strahlcr. A. H. (1978). — .Modern Physical Geography. 
John Wiley Sops. 

Swayne. B. (1956). — A Concise Glossary of Geographic Terms. In: Sir D. 
Stamp (Ed.) ( 1 966) .4 G/os.sary of Geographic Term.s. 

Tansley. A. G. (1939). — The British Islands and Their Vegetation. 

Cambridge University Press. Cambridge. 

Tingay. A. and Tingay, S, R. (1976). — ^The Wetland of System Six. Dept. 
Conservation & Environ. Bull. 28. 

Trowbridge, A. C. (Ed.) ( 1 962). — Dictionary of Geological Terms. American 
Geological Institute, Washington D.C 
Twidale, C. R. (1968). — Geomorphology. Nelson, pl48-203. 

UNESCO (1971), — Article I. part 1, Convention on wetlands of 
international significance especially as waterfowl hibitats. 
Published in Australia, 1976, for Department of Foreign Affairs by 
Australian Government Publishing Service, Treatv Series 1975 
No. 48. 

Watson, L. E. and Bell. D. T. (1981). — The Ecology of Star Swamp and 
surrounding bushlands. North Beach. Western Australia. J. Roy. 
Soc. W.A..63: 103-117. 

Wetlands Advisory Committee ( 1 977) — The Status of Welland Reserves in 
System 6. Report of the Wetlands Advisory (Tommittee to the 
Environmental Protection Authority. 

Whiitow. J. B. ( 1984). — Pengidn Dictionary of Physical Geography. Penguin 
Books Hammondswonh. Middlesex. 

Wetzel. R. G. ( 1 983). — Limnology. Saunders College Publishing. 

Zoltai, S. C. and Poiletl, F. C. (1983). — Wetlands in Canada: Their 
Classification, Distribution and Use. In: Gore, A. J. P. (Ed.) 
Ecosystems of the World. 4B. Mires: Swamp. Bog, Fen and Moor. 
Regional Studies. Elsevier Scientific Publishing Co., p245-268. 


Ill 






W' 


fX p. 




m 




n 




i?; 










X 






\4^“ 


5^ 




>h ^ 


* ; 






# 






►•<^K 


rH-# 


IV 








«i 


a 


£? 






I*- 








*» -* 




i 






•- *1‘ . }*! 


?> 


A» 




V«? 




V ^ 


/ * 


Kii 


't 








1^ 


iiA- 


^ isi- -V W 




s.*£ 


r 


? -f- < 

«•■!''. '?'.■' ■■ ‘ i.'-. 


Kj 












^ * fn _<r 




* >* 




'P' # 




». ... 'r i' ./ a'* X* .* . 

^ tbP ^ vA 




V;> .. 


''n. V**" 




t 




^ '-I. P r<: 










- *' r'^ vi« A 


^ i .-P y€ > X J*X 




.. , .,....;.-3ii^-'y :'-.^'^i,^-. ?ys.: 

-» V',-' 

^ ^». ^ -f- ^ ^ $!d-^r. 


c4i^ h 


, ,.«^'*‘‘V A iVf -r ^\ivT> ^ ^ ^ 




" ’* 't' 

pfKPti'^T'' % 


* -f .. 1^ yAiT> 'v 


V' ^ V *- >lf ^ ^ . 


•m 




%.W85S«>--,SS4i-f>'.V' 5 *'>i!t' ,*4?.. ' < A.-.' 










V >> 


^#,^7, %V*A - ^ .c t. 


.. ■ ^‘4S:^iv- yiiv* 

. ,- P-. ' 


■e*® s-i 


-»-.<'#>i- 5 ff; 

1 '4r • "^j ' 'AA'* "^V 




.■>sr 




■ /%..■ ■'. ■•'’ '':;:'/ 7 /--' v-.'-.' . •■", 






^ ^ 1 - 2 '' £i* 




i' < 'S 'V>3.i ", f‘fC-^■'^■^•‘f^ 'a ''’^ r>-f 




’* ^ ' **; .< ^ k'^ ’ t- ;v£^ 


A* 




*SyX-' 








;.7^v^'^cv -»?. 


f i. "i >i^\- 


K^xf. 


r<»v 


,< -, ; ., ^ ‘^,*t;3. }► Ij -JA- ^ / 'J4? •’ 




> ; 




f4? 


fii .’f' ^..v ' . I: A' ‘ 'C 


k‘^'€'-m 






Journal of ihc Royal Society of Western Australia. Vol. 69. Part 3. 1 987. p. 113-116. 


Rb-Sr Geochronology of granitoids from Mount Mulgine, Western Australia 

by J. R. De Laeter and J. L. Baxter 

School ofPhysics and Geosciences. Curtin University of Technology. Bentley. Western Australia. 6102. 


Manuscript received 15 July 1986; accepted 16 December 1986 


Abstract 

The Mulgine Granite is highly fractionated with greisen sheets containing tungsten-molybdenum 
mineralisation. The Mulgine Granite forms a dome-shaped body which has been intruded by an 
unmineralised discordant porphyritic-biotite adamellite. 

The best estimate of the Rb-Sr whole rock age and initial ^^Sr/^^Sr ratio of the Mulgine Granite is 
2684 * 79 Ma and 0.701 ± 0.005 respectively. It is unlikely that it had an extended crustal pre- 
history. The cross-cutting porphyritic-biotite adamellite has a Rb-Sr whole rock age of 2596 ± 35 
Ma with an initial ^^Sr/®%r ratio of 0.704 i 0.004. Although the experimental errors do not show a 
significant difference in the ages, the isotopic data indicate that the porphyritic-biotite adamellite is 
younger than the Mulgine Granite: a result consistent with the field relationships. A subset of the 
samples of the porphyritic-biotite adamellite gives an approximate Rb-Sr whole rock age of 2330 Ma 
and an initial ^^Sr/^^Sr ratio of 0.713. Two Rb-rich samples of granitoid from the Mulgine Granite 
give similiar model Rb-Sr ages which indicate that a later thermal event has affected both granitoid 
suites. 


Introduction 

The Yilgarn Block in Western Australia is one of the 
largest segments of .Archaean crust in the world. Gee et 
al. (1981) subdivided the Yilgarn Block into three 
granitoid-greenstone provinces (the Murchison, 
Southern Cross and Eastern Goldfields provinces), and a 
predominantly gneissic terrain (the Western Gneiss 
Terrain), which occupies an area around the western 
periphery' of the granitoid-greenstone province. 

Granitoids account for about 70 per cent of the crustal 
exposure of the Yilgarn Block, which has an area of 
approximately 650,000 km- (Gee et al. 1981). Older 
synkinemalic granitoids have been described by 
■Archibald and Bettenas (1977) and Watkins and Tyler 
{ 1985) in the Kalgoorlie and Cue districts of the Yilgarn 
Block respectively. Younger post-tectonic granitoid 
batholiths intrude these foliated rocks. 

The most common compositional types in both 
synkinematic and post-tectonic plutons arc adamellite 
and granodiorite in contrast to many other granitoid- 
greenstone terrains where more tonal ite and 

trondjcmilic rocks predominate (Libby 1979). 

In the Murchison Province the greenstone belts arc 
intruded by a number of discrete or coalescing ovoid 
plutons (Muhling 1969). The synkinemalic granitoids 
are emplaced prior to deformation and metamorphism 
within the greenstone belts (Watkins and Tyler 1985), 
each commonly containing co-planar ' foliation. 
Deformation and metamorphism in the synkinematic 
granitoids and greenstone belts are consequently often 
co-eval. 


From an extensive Rb-Sr whole-rock study of 
granitoids and gneisses across most of the Yilgarn Block, 
Arriens (197!) found three distinct episodes between 
3100-2900 Ma, 2700-2550 Ma and 2300-2200 Ma. 
.Arriens pointed out that many of the granitoids which 
had Rb-Sr ages between 2700 and 2600 Ma have an 
initial ^^Sr/^^r ratio of approximately 0.704 suggesting 
a crustal pre-history for these samples. .Arriens (1971) 
estimated that these granitoids could not have existed 
for longer than 120 Ma as crustal materials, assuming an 
average Rb/Sr ratio for the granitoids of 0.85. However. 
Gee et aL (1981) argue that this period of crustal 
prehistory may be 200 to 400 Ma in duration. Oversby 
(1975) considers that the high ^ values recorded in some 
Eastern Goldfields granitoids indicates that these rocks 
had existed as crustal material for at least 300 Ma before 
the - 2600 Ma lectono-ihermal event. On the other hand 
Bicklc c/ al. (1983) argue that Pb-Pb whole rock isotopic 
data from synkinemalic plutons in the Diemals area 
indicate that the crustal history of the precursor material 
is less than - 200 Ma. 

De Laeter et al. (198 la) have reviewed the 
geochronological data in the Yilgarn Block. Few results 
from the Murchison Province have been reported. 
Granitoids from the Cue-Mount Magnel-Paynes Find 
region give a Rb-Sr whole-rock age of 2706 ± 264 Ma 
(.Arriens 1971). Two muscovites from Mount Mulgine 
give model Rb-Sr ages of 2632 and 2614 Ma (Arriens, 
1971 ). Muhling and De Laeter (1971) also reported Rb- 
Sr whole-rock ages for granite-adamellite and 
granodiorite from the Poona baiholith (a complex 
granitoid body cast of Cue), of 2535 ±. 23 Ma and 2550 
± 51 Ma respectively. Fletcher (Pers. Comm.) has 
obtained Sm-Nd model ages of 2820 Ma and 2730 Ma 
on two of these samples. 



Figure I. Regional map of Mount Mulginc in the Murchison Province of Western Australia. 

1 14 



Journal of the Royal Society of Western Australia, Vol. 69, Part 3, 1987. 


Geology of the area 

The Mt. Mulgine district contains a mafic volcanic 
supracrustal succession intruded by the synkinematic 
Mulgine Granite and a discordant porphyritic (lath 
granite) adamellite (Fig. 1). Both granitoid suites are 
unusually highly fractionated with Rb-Sr ratios ranging 
from 0.88 to 49.5. 

The Mulgine Granite is a 1 km diameter ovoid stock 
near the axis of a regional anticline. The northern, 
eastern and western margins of the stock are parallel to 
layering in the adjacent volcanic sequence (Baxter ! 979). 
Foliation and lineation in the volcanic rocks and the 
granite are parallel. Greisen sheets intrude the volcanic 
sequence along the northern perimeter of the stock. The 
greisen has induced polymetallic scheelile-molybdeniie- 
fluorite mineralisation in potassium metasomatized 
ultramafic rocks in the adjacent volcanic sequence. 
Pegmatites and greisen sheets associated with the 
Mulgine Granite occur up to 2 km from the stock 
contact. The volatile rich nature of the Granite is 
indicated by the wide halo of hydrothermal alteration 
around the stock. 

Porphyritic-biotite adamellite intrudes the southern 
margin of the Mulgine Granite (Fig. 1). This is an 
apophysis of a batholith of coarse-grained porphyritic 
and even-grained adamellite lying to the south and east 
of Mulgine Hill. 


give model ages of 2362 Ma and 2282 Ma respectively. 
The choice of initial ratio does not affect the model ages 
to any significant extent. 

Subsequently, another five drill-core samples of the 
Mulgine Granite were obtained, and if these are 
combined with the original seven samples, a Rb-Sr 
whole rock age of 2644 ± 17 Ma and Rj = 0.7026 ± 
0.0012 is obtained with a MSWD of 28. Thus the effect 
of the additional samples is to increase the scatter in the 
data, and to lower the age slightly. A Model 2 assessment 
of the age, initial ratio and errors is 2643 ± 87 Ma and 
^ Rj = 0.7026 ± 0.0061 respectively. 



Experimental procedures 

Samples were reduced to -200 mesh using a jaw 
crusher and an agate Tema-type mill. After chemical 
extraction, the samples were analysed in a 30.5 cm 
radius of curvature, 90* magnetic sector field, solid 
source mass spectrometer. Techniques are essentially 
those reported by De Laeter ei al. (1981b). 

The value of *^Sr/^^Sr for the NBS 987 standard was 
0.7102 ± 0.0001 normalised to a *^Sr/^^Sr value of 
8.3752. A value of 1.42 x 10'”yr’* was used for the decay 
V constant of ®^Rb. All the Rb-Sr ages quoted in this paper 
have been corrected where necessary, to this decay 
constant. The data have been regressed using the least 
squares programme of McIntyre et al. (1966). All errors 
are given at the 95% confidence level. 

Results and discussion 

Two suites of samples were available for analysis — the 
Mulgine Granite and the postkinematic discordant 
porphyritic-adamellite. Isotopic data are listed in Tables 
1 and 2 for these two granitoids. 

Mulgine Granite 

Initially nine samples of the Mulgine Granite were 
collected and subsequently analysed. Seven of the nine 
samples form an isochron with an age of 2694 ± 30 Ma 
and initial ^"^Sr/^^Sr ratio (R,) of 0.7000 ± 0.0018 (Fig. 
2). The mean square of weighted deviates (MSWD) is 
6.3, indicating that there is a real dispersion in the data 
greater than the experimental errors associated with the 
measurements. A better estimate of the age, initial ratio 
and associated errors is 2684 ± 79 Ma and R, = 0.7007 

± 0.0053. This Model 4 age implies a real scatter in age 
and initial ratio. Taking into account the average Rb/Sr 
ratios of these samples, it is unlikely that there was an 
extended period of crustal pre-history for these samples. 
The remaining two samples (numbers 255 and 247) have 
a much higher Rb/Sr ratio with respect to the group, and 


0 5 10 15 20 25 30 35 40 45 50 55 60 65 70 75 

"Rb/”Sr 

R7 R7 R/x 

Figure 2. — Sr/®°Sr vs ® Rb/^°Sr isochron diagram for the Mount Mulgine 
Granite. 


It is of interest to note that the average age for the two 
muscovite samples reported by Arriens (1971) is 2623 
Ma. These two samples, presumably from pegmatites 
associated with the Mulgine Granite, were obtained 
from drill-core by Newmont Pty Ltd, who held leases for 
molybdenum prospecting at Mount Mulgine. The Rb/Sr 
values for these muscovites are exceptionally high. 

Porphyritic Adamellite 

Ten samples of the porphyritic-biotite adamellite were 
originally analysed and the results are displayed in 
Figure 3. Six of the ten samples fall on an isochron of age 
2570 ± 65 Ma and Rj = 0.7055 ± 0.0071 with a MSWD 



115 


Journal of the Royal Society of Western Australia, Vol. 69, Part 3, 1987. 


of 2 . 4 . Subsequently three additional samples were 
analysed, and if the resulting nine samples are fitted to 
an isochron, an age of 2596 ± 35 Ma and = 0.7039 ± 
0.0043, with an improved MSWD of 1.8 is obtained. 

The remaining four samples (numbers 270, 266, 267 
and 271) give a poorly fitted isochron with a Model 3 
age and initial ratio of 2332 ± 296 Ma and 0.7133 ± 
0.062 respectively. This age, despite its large error, is in 
good agreement with the average model age 2322 Ma, of 
samples 255 and 247 from the Mulgine Granite. 

Conclusion 

The Rb-Sr whole rock analyses of two suites of 
granitoids from the Mount Mulgine district indicate that 
the Mulgine Granite is older than the discordant 
porphyritic-biotite adamellite, thus supporting the field 
relationships. The low initial ratio of the Mulgine 
Granite suggests that the rocks were derived from the 
mantle, with a relatively short crustal history prior to the 
Rb-Sr isochron age. The best estimate of this whole-rock 
age is 2684 ± 79 Ma with an initial ratio of 0.701 ± 
0.005. However if one takes into account all the isotopic 
evidence available, it could be argued that an age of 
approximately 2650 Ma and an initial ratio of 0.702 is 
more appropriate for the Granite. 

The discordant porphyritic biotite adamellite gives a 
younger age of 2596 ± 35 Ma with an initial ratio of 
0.704 i 0.004. In terms of the errors associated with the 
two sets of samples, it is not possible to state that the 
ages and initial ratios are significantly different, 
although the isotopic data are consistent with the field 
evidence. 

A subset of the porphyritic adamellite suite gave an 
approximate age of 2330 Ma with a high initial ratio of 
0.713. This younger age is in good agreement with model 
ages from two Rb-rich samples from the Mulgine 
Granite, and reflects a younger Proterozoic 
metamorphic event which has reset some of the samples 
from each granitoid suite. It is possible that this event 
could be associated with the basic magmatic 
emplacement of Proterozoic dykes in the Yilgam Block. 


Acknon/ec/gefnenfs — 

This project was proposed by Associate Professor D, I. Groves of the 
Geology Department of the University of Western Australia, who also 
commenled on an earlier draft of this manuscript. Initial field work and 
sample collection was earned out by Mr F. D. Turner, under the 
supervision 9 f Associate Professor Groves. The authors would like to thank 
Dr K. Watkins. Mrs P. R. Harris. Mr E. Schmidt and Mr D. J. Hosie for 
their assistance! This project was supported by the Australian Research 
Grants Committee. 


References 

Archibald, N. J. and Beitenay. L. F. ( 1 977). — Indirect evidence for tectonic 
reactivation of a pre-greenstone sialic basement in Western 
Australia £arlh Planet. Set. Lett., 33: 370-378. 

Arriens, P. A. (1971). — The Archaean Geochronology of Australia. Spec. 
Publ. Geol. Soc. Aust., 3 : 1 1-23. 

Baxter, J. L. (1979). — Molybdenum, tungsten, vanadium and chromium in 
Western Australia, Aust. Geol. Survey. Min. Res. Bull. 

Bickle, M. J., Chapman. H. J.. Bcticnay, L. F.. Groves, D. I. and De Laeier. 
J. R, (1983). — Lead ages, reset Rb-Sr ages and implications for the 
Archaean Crustal Evolution of the Diemals area. Central Yilgam 
Block, Western Australia. Geochim. Cosmochim. .Acta, 47: 907- 
914. 

De Laeter. J. R., Libby, W. G. and Trendall, A. F. (1981a). — The older 
Precambrian Geochronology of Western Australia. Spec. Publ. 
Geol. Soc. /lujl.. 7:145-157. 

De Laeier, J. R.. Williams. I. R.. Rosman. K. J. R. and Libby, W. G. 
(1981b). — A definitive 3350 Ma age from banded gneiss. Mount 
Narryer area. Western Gneiss Terrain. West Aust. Geol. Surv. Ann. 
Rept. 1980:94-98. 

Gee, R. D„ Baxter, J. L., Wilde, S. A. and Williams, I. R. (1981). — Crustal 
development in the Archaean Yilgam Block, Western Australia. 
Spec. Publ. Geo!. Soc. .Aust., 43-56. 

Libby, W. G. (1979). — Regional variation in granitic rock. Report Geol. 
Surv. 9 : 53-109. 

McIntyre. G. A., Brooks. C., Compslon, W. and Turek, A. (1966). — The 
statistical assessment of Rb-Sr isochrons. J. Geophvs. Res., 71: 
5459-5468. 

Muhling, P. C. (1969). — The geology of the granitic rocks of the Poona- 
Dalgaranga area, Murchison and Yalgoo Goldfields West. Aust. 
Geol. Surv. Ann. Rept l968:5C)-52. 

Muhling, P. C. and De I.aeter. J. R. (1971). — .Ages of granitic rocks in the 
Poona-Dalgaranga area of the Yilgam Block, Western Australia. 
Spec. Pub! Geol. Soc. Au.'tt., 3 : 25-31. 

Oversby. (1975). — Lead Isotope systemalics and ages of Archaean acid 
intrusives in the Kalgoorlie-Norseman area. Western Australia. 
Geochim. Cosmochim. Acta, 39 : 1 107-1 125. 

Watkins, K. P. and Tyler. I. M. (1985). — Structural and stratigraphic 
relationships in the Archaean granite-greenstone terrain around 
Cue, W.A- West. Aust. Geo! Sun.. Rept. 14: 46-56. 


116 


INSTRUCTIONS TO AUTHORS 


The Journal publishes (after refereeing) 

^papers dealing with original research done in Western Australia into any branch of the natural sciences; 

^papers concerning some biological or geological aspect of Western Australia: 

^authoritative overviews of any subject in the natural sciences, integrating research already largely published in 
the more specialized national or international journals, and interpreting such studies with the general 
membership of the Society in mind: 

^analyses of controversial issues ofgreat scientific moment in Western Australia. 

Prospective authors of papers in the last two categories should consult the Hon. Editor for further advice. 

C ontributions should be sent to I'he Honorary Editor. Royal Society of Western Australia. Western Australian 
Museum, Francis Street, Perth, Western Australia, 6000. Publication in the Society’s Journal is available to all 
categories of members and to non-members residing outside Western Australia. Where all authors of a paper live in 
Western Australia at least one author must be a member of the society. Papers by non-members living outside the 
State must be communicated through an Ordinary or an Honorar>’ Member. Submission of a paper is taken to mean 
that the results have not been published or are not being considered for publication elsewhere. Free reprints are not 
provided. Reprints may be ordered at cost, provided that orders arc submitted with the return galley proofs. Authors 
arc solely responsible for the accuracy of all information in their papers, and for any opinion they express. 

Manuscripts. The original and two copies must be submitted. They should be typed on opaque while paper with 
double-spacing throughout and a 3 cm margin on the left-hand side. All pages should be numbered consecutively, 
including those carrying tables and captions to illustrations, which appear after the text. Illustrations, both line 
drawings and photographs, arc to be numbered as figures in a common sequence, and each must be referred to in the 
text. In composite figures, made up of several photographs or diagrams, each of these should be designated by a letter 
(c.g. Figure 2B). 

Authors are advised to use the most recent issue of the Journal as a guide to the general format of their papers. 
Words to be placed in Italics should be underlined. To facilitate editing, papers must be accompanied by a table of 
contents, on a separate sheet, showing the status of all headings. 

References must be set out as follow's: 

Paper Jackson A 1931 The Oligochacta of South-Western Australia. J R Soc West Aust 17:17-136. 

l^ook Jacobs M R 1955 Growth Habits of the Eucalypls. ForTimb Bur, Canberra. 

C liaptcr in book Dell J 1 983. The Importance of the Darling Scarp to Fauna. In: .Scarp Symposium (ed J D Majer). 
W A Inst Technol, Bentley. 17-27. 

The Title should begin with a keyword. The Abstract should not be an expanded title, but should include the main 
substance of the paper in a condensed form. The metric system (SI units) must be used. Taxonomic papers must 
follow the appropriate International Code of Nomenclature, and geological papers must adhere to the International 
Stratigraphic Guide. Spelling should follow the Concise Oxford Dictionary. 

Authors should maintain a proper balance between length and substance, and papers longer than 1 0 000 words would 
need to be of exceptional importance to be considered for publication. Authors will normally be charged page costs 
where papers exceed 8 printed pages. 

Illustrations. These should be prepared to fit single or double column wudihs. Illustrations must include all necessary 
lettering, and be suitable for direct photographic reduction. No lettering should be smaller than I mm on reduction. 
To avoid unnecessary handling of the original illustrations, which arc best prepared between 1.5 and 2 times the re- 
quired size, authors are advised to supply extra prims already reduced. .Additional printing costs, such as those for fold- 
ing maps or colour blocks, will be charged to authors. 

Suppleinenlary Publications. Extensive sets of data, such as large tables or long appendices, may be classed as 
Supplementary Publications and not printed with the paper. Supplcmentarv Publications will be lodged with the 
Society’s Library (C7- Western Australian Museum. Perth. WA 6000) and with the National Library of Australia 
(Manuscript Section. Parkes Place. Barton, ACT 2600) and photocopies mav be obtained from either institution 
upon payment of a fee. 


JOURNAL OF THE 

ROYAL SOCIETY OF WESTERN AUSTRALIA 
CONTENTS VOLUME 69 PART 3 1987 


Page 

Grazing pressure by the tammar {Macropus eugenii Desm.) on the vegetation of Garden Island, Western 
Australia, and the potential impact on food reserves of a controlled burning regime. D. T. Bell, J. C. 
Moredoundt and W. A. Loneragan 89 


Wetlands of the Darling System — A geomorphic approach to habitat classification. C. A. Semeniuk 95 


Rb-Sr Geochronology of granitoids from Mount Mulgine, Western Australia. J. R. de Laeter and J. L. 
Baxter 


Edited by B. Dell and I. Abbott 


Registered by Australia Post — Publication No. WBG 0351 . 

No claim for non-receipt of the Journal will be entertained unless it is received within 12 months after publication of Part 4 of each Volume. 
The Royal Society of Western Australia. Western Australian Museum, Perth. 


53510/3/87-000-L/4223 


By Authority WILLIAM BEN60W, Acting Government Printer