Proceedings

= er Rp rng ee NSE NS

sont

by Nal
Nee _PROCEEDINGS

OF THE

American Forestry Association

ji

AT THE

Thirteenth and Fourteenth Annual Meetings,
December, 1894, and January 1896,
at Washington,
AND AT THE SUMMER MEETINGS AT

Brooklyn, N. Y., and Springfield, Mass.

Votume XI. PY. &

WASHINGTON, D. C.:
1896.

Ne
Ty

rs
Vi 4

The proceedings of the American Forestry Association have hitherto been
published irregularly, the volumes not being numbered. With the improved
financial condition of the association, and its increased membership, a regular
issue of the annual proceedings in future appears warranted, and it seems
desirable to designate, by numbers, not only the coming volumes but also
those previously issued. The present volume is, therefore, numbered XI.
The series of previous volumes includes the following publications. Of these,
those marked * are out print:

NWOT Teas

* Vol. I.—Proceedings of the special meeting at Montreal, August, 1882.
Papers read before the meeting printed separately by the Cana-
dian Government in the Ontario Fruit Growers’ Report. (The
proceedings of the first annual meeting, that held at Cincinnati,
April 25-29, 1882, were not published in pamphlet form.)

* Vol. II.—Proceedings of the second annual meeting, at St. Paul, August,
1883. Also, Forestry Bulletins No. 1 (May, 1884); No. 2 (Sep-
tember, 1884); No. 3 (January, 1885).
*Vol. III.—Proceedings of the special meeting at Washington, D. C., May,
1884, and third annual meeting, at Saratoga, New York, Sep-
tember, 1884.
* Vol. IV.—Proceedings of the fourth annual meeting, held at Boston, Sep-
tember, 1885.
* Vol. V.— Proceedings of the fifth annual meeting, held at Denver, Colorado,
September, 1886. (Newspaper report.)
*Vol. VI.—Proceedings of the sixth annual meeting, held in Springfield, Illi-
nois, September, 1887.
Vol. VII.—Proceedings of the seventh annual meeting, held at Atlanta, Ga.,
December, 1888, and of the eighth annual meeting, held at
Philadelphia, Pa., October, 1889.
Vol. VIII.—Proceedings of the summer meeting, held in Quebec, September,
1890, and of the ninth annual meeting, held in Washington, D.
C., December, 1890.

Vol. [X.—Papers read at joint session of the American Economic Association
and the American Forestry Association, held at Washington, D.
C., December, 1890.

Vol. X.—Proceedings at the tenth, eleventh, and twelfth annual meetings,
held in 1891, 1892, and 1893, and of the special meeting at the
World’s Fair Congress in Chicago in 1893.

OFFICERS FOR 1896.

ELECTED JANUARY 24, 1896.

Hon. J. STERLING MORTON, Washington, D. C., < - President.
Sm H. G. JOLY pz LOTBINIERE, Quebec, Canada, - — 1st Vice-President.
Hon. GARDINER G. HUBBARD, Vice-President for the District of Columbia.
FREDERICK H. NEWELL, 1330 F St., Washington, D. C., Corresponding Sec'y.
GEORGE P. WHITTLESEY, Washington, D. C., - Recording Secretary.
HENRY M. FISHER, M. D., Philadelphia, Pa., - ~ - Treasurer.

EXECUTIVE COMMITTEE.

The executive committee consists of the president, vice-president for the
District of Columbia, the secretaries, the treasurer, and the following members :

B. E. Fernow, Chairman.
Wii1iam H. Paitures.

GirForD PINcHOT.
CuHaRues C. BINney.

Epw. A. Bowens.
Cuarues A. KEFFER.

VICE-PRESIDENTS.

Sir H. G. Jony pe Lorsrnrere,
Pointe Platon, Quebec.
CHARLES Mour,
Mobile, Ala.
THomas C. MoRag,
Prescott, Ark.
D. M. Rrorpan,
Flagstaff, Ariz.
AsBoT KINNEY,
Lamanda Park, Cal.
E. T. Ensien,
Colorado Springs, Col.
Rogert Brown,
New Haven, Conn.

Wa. M. Cansy,
Wilmington, Del.
A. V. Crusss,

Pensacola, Fla.
C. R. Prrcrez,

Sandersville, Ga.
E. T. Perxrys,

Boise, Idaho.
L. B. Sipway,

Chicago, Ill.
James Troop,

Lafayette, Ind.
Tos. H. Macpripe,

Iowa City, Iowa.
J. B. Toosurn,

Syracuse, Kan.
A. M. Brown,

Eliazbethtown, Ky.
Joun E, Hoxsss,

North Berwick, Me.
F. H. Appieton,

Boston, Mass.
W. J. Beat,

Lansing, Mich.
C. C. ANDREWS,

St. Paul, Minn.
Wriuu1am TReLeEase,

St. Louis, Mo.
GerorGe P. AHERN,

Fort Missoula, Mont.
CHaruzs E. Bessey,

Lincoln, Neb.

Wn. E. CHANDLER,

Concord, N. H.
A. W. Cutter,

Norristown, N. J.
Epwarp F. Hozarrt,

Santa Fe, N. M.
Warren HIGLey,

New York, N. Y.
J. A. Hones,

Raleigh, N. C.
W. W. Barrett,

Church’s Ferry, N. D.
REvuBEN H. WaARDER,

North Bend, O.
E. W. Hammonp,

Wimer, Ore.
J. T. RorHRocs,

Philadelphia, Pa.
H. G. Russet,

E. Greenwich, R. I.
H. A. GREEN,

Chester, S. C.
L. McLours,

Brookings, 8. D.
Tomas T. Wricart,

Nashville, Tenn.
W. GoopricH JONES,

Temple, Texas.
C. A. Wuitine,

Salt Lake, Utah.
REDFIELD Proctor,

Proctor, Vt.
Epmunp S. Meany,

Seattle, Wash.
A. D. Hoprrys,

Morgantown, W. Va.
H. C. Putnam,

Eau Claire, Wis.
Etwoop Megap,

Cheyenne, Wyo.
GarpDIneR G. HuBBarD,

Washington, D. C.
Joun Onalc,

Wa. Lirrze,

Ottawa, Ont.
Montreal, Quebec.

/
ln Ua ee ‘
e " 10.208) Gas
id bing AON FLD

“a Shiga OKs

it iT aT iat i) 1

UAT ae

; ‘*
uF ; ie CA

MEMBERS.

* Life Members.

ALABAMA.
Carney, Miss Alice ................+00 Williams, Ala.
Mrone Dr. Olarles: o\.cicecss ence cssces 931 Dauphin St., Mobile, Ala.
ARIZONA.
EREMOETE TROND cae net icavenctacesens . Flagstaff, Ariz.
ARKANSAS.
MNES WOE 5) glpenacte Sadan cnascens -Paragould, Ark.
* McRae, Hon. Thos. C............... Prescott, Ark.
CALIFORNIA.
Saivore, Henry B:;.-..--'-:.:0+-..->s San Jose, Cal.
PAL WORGEY W RULIATH: js ccs eacncess cles. 400 California St., San Francisco, Cal.
*Atvord, Mrs. William: ..........:.. 2200 Broadway, San Francisco, Cal.
MHCBENON, ETOL. de Mo... sctsccavsse Stanford University, Cal.
AMIIIAN ES) E05 vaceck <0 che e/verasecscses Eureka, Cal.
* Blanchard, Nathan W............. Santa Paula, Ventura Co., Cal.
PETERSEN cock 0 os shns-w's sevene 1019 Bush 8t., San Francisco, Cal.
* Fernald, Charles....................Santa Barbara, Cal.
Gallaher, Frank M ................. Santa Barbara, Cal.
WATS V EAU soccassonccavsodescsvess Lamanda Park, Los Angeles, Cal.
TREE ETE desi oe'norcovsadisecseeres ask BBAGONAY Oal.
ORME PONT 5. cocecasconcxenes vive Supt. Golden Gate Park, San Francisco, Cal.
Simro. MS, A. Mee... 5 keccecese San Mateo, Cal.
PURMMGPENILN canes duc cves. sees arancwccesiy Niles, Alameda Co., Cal.
RMSE le Ph ac cu ciiy cians sageas sxeses Santa Barbara, Cal.
*Sutro, Adolph.......................30 Montgomery Block, San Francisco, Cal.
(LL SATIEIN® BD. sdocebunos Airs sconeciee ous Santa Barbara, Cal.
W0d, AGOIDN:, ics iiteiceneccsseseas San Bernardino, Cal.
COLORADO.
Berthoud, Edward L................ Golden, Colo.
Crandall, Prof. Chas. S............. Fort Collins, Colo.
BOIL. 65. Occ vaes auccicevenapeestnee Glenwood Springs, Colo.
Breveneax, WB ccsoneesosesesepnoves Glenwood Springs, Colo.
EIS S Ws 0 bas iddeoiren axemOnrpanasos Centerville, Colo.

PEEIO, LOTUS TR. cscce castes evexnsnuee Colorado Springs, Colo.

6

COLORADO— Continued.

Ensign, Edgar T.....0....s0sscorerces Colorado Springs, Colo,
Grimes, (Dire crevasse ornonnslspeesse es Box 450, Denver, Col.
Givonnead: WADE. oto. cs<vespsnshasves Capital City, Hinsdale Co., Col.
DAK WAY, is Cliseseneineaacaneuressacses Durango, Colo.
ANG SYANCIS | AGcncscessssss seas essen: Nathrop, Chaffee Co., Colo.
Maxwells gobi M, .2.cc.00c50s0s-es0s Leadville, Colo.
Moody, Mrs. Mary Blair............ Fairhaven Heights, New Haven, Conn.
McOnrie, AS ad icccecccusssccssnsnessceses Grand Junction, Colo.
*/Palmer, Gen, Wis dscsasssceccers Glen Eyrie, Colorado Springs, Colo.
Parsons, Geo. He. c.scscsvesessesue nes Colorado Springs, Col.
Rhoades, Nelson, Jr..........seseeeee 514 Pine St., Trinidad, Colo.
Robinson, Thomas D............... .U. S. Surveyor General, Denver, Colo.
TIGCOMD Wd ODN S..cccsecesceccedeases 36 Jacobson Block, Denver, Colo.
Van Diest. (bo El vecessecseess oaseeo DOMVEL, COLO:
WallaGe sy Wel Sccscsccrsscteveccutiees se Grand Junction, Colo.
Walkin; Charles Avo. ocs.0sserscexes Fairplay, Colo.
Wills, H. Le B........ ...............Colorado Springs, Colo.

CONNECTICUT.
PBrOWD, LOVES sarsscocss-scsccieceses Yale University Observatory, New Haven,Conn.
Cardy, Sualin MM. jiassesssasseucupaste: Ridgefield, Conn.
*Gold, Theodore Sedgwick....... West Cornwall, Conn.
Kellogg, Herbert H..... ........00 Editor Law Journal, New Haven, Conn.
ent, \AUberb: Wy soc activeen-asnel coace 279 Lawrence Hall, New Haven, Conn.
Keyser, Mrs. W. J .............-+-+..ast Norwalk, Conn.
ony WHrniesty Ms 5.52. ciccbsanecssensce 64 Lake Place, New Haven, Conn.
Northrop, rs eG ccs ananeuseware Clinton, Conn.
THOMPEON; DOWN AWicssscctsvensenve The Normandie, New Haven, Conn.
W strous; Goo iD. c.csssteseee sbaaceccs 153 Church St., New Haven, Conn.
Williams, Frederick Wells......... 135 Whiting Ave., New Haven, Conn.
Woolsey, Prof. Theodore &........ New Haven, Conn.

DELAWARE.

Oanby, Prof. Wim Wisssessesccrsctes 1101 Delaware Ave., Wilmington, Del.

DISTRICT OF COLUMBIA.

* Abbe, Prof. Cleveland............. Weather Bureau, Washington, D. C.
~ Binney, Charles C....................Dept. of Justice, Washington, D. C.

Ty LOWERS, UCWs. Av sy scstevervebattenes vs 1520 H St., Washington, D. C.
Bowler, Robert Bi .cccciessccccscccscs 1730 R St., Washington, D. C.
Butler, Mrs. Jo. Chesney.......... 1416 K St., Washington, D. C.
Wlarkewkrink aWirssvcssssccesioeecine U.S. Geol. Survey, Washington, D. C.
Dabney, Dr. Charles W., Jr ...... Department of Agriculture, Washington, D. C.
TPES, DIE. TE caavin: sucsdicrenses 1728 I St., Washington, D. C.
Meleaton:. Dr. oN. EL jc ce cccssecaecas The Woodmont, Washington, D. C.
Fernow, Bernhard E............ ...0 Dept. of Agriculture, Washington, D. C.

Fernow, Mrs. Bernhard E.......... 1620 22d St., Washington, D. C.

7

DISTRICT OF COLUMBIA—Continued.

Tuckerman, Miss Emily........
Tuckerman, Mrs. E. W...........
Walcott, Charles D....... .......
rest. Dr, BALD i csc cccace! avs
* Warder, Prof. Robert B......
Whittlesey, Geo. P..............
PR TALIES. BO WATL issue ian cecsacheeuens
Wilson, Nathaniel................
SPAGROD ys Oa. Wau scevevveveubsneenens

ETRE, As. W ae ncnesersans caevebens
* Mathieu, Jean A........6 ese.
VanKirk, W. d...c0<cccccess sees

OBbOR, IbAMmUs I"... ..csesaspeuce eaohen 2029 Q St., Washington, D. C.
Gannett, Henry.... ........... ......U. 8. Geological Survey, Washington, D. O.
Srlover, Charles G, scsasssheussissens 20 Lafayette Square, Washington, D. C.
Goodfellow, Mrs. Edward......... .1618 16th St., Washington, D. C.
Greenlees, Archibald................ 3129 N St., Georgetown, D. C.
Grout, Hon. William W............ The Arlington, Washington, D. C. (Vermont. )
Hale, Hon. Eugene. .... ............ 1001 16th St., Washington, D. C. (Maine.)
Herman, Baron Beno Reinhardt.Imperial German Embassy, Washington, D. C.
EAOERDIOWON, sO axetes scssacswe stecne 1402 M St., Washington, D. C.

“ Howard, George... .. .............Riggs Bank, Washington, D. C.
Hubbard, Gardiner G............... 1328 Conn. Ave., Washington, D. C.
ERGES sh HOMIBE occas ca cccdecssnsaheae Riggs & Co., Washington, D. C.
IOS! FAINGWY El ooo. <s)cncesuexs Sesto Gen’! Land Office, Washington, D. OC.
Jones, Dr. John D.............. ......Cor. 18th and I Sts. N.W., Washington, D. C.
Jones, Mrs. John D.............0000 Cor. 18th and I Sts. W.N., Washington, D. C.
Keffer, Charles A... .................Dept. of Agriculture, Washington, D. C.
PILLER MOVE! Dia cicva. ozaa,leder sai sSe Dupont Circle, Washington, D. C.
Luebkert, Otto J. J..................Dept. of Agriculture, Washington, D. O.
Maagox, SAMUEL « ..5 00. dds <sceneenscas 462 Louisiana Ave., Washington, D. C.
meOreIAnsley, VAL I. 1 3t5n usar gaseco Department of Agriculture, Washington, D. C.
* Morton, Hon. J. Sterling... .. ..Sec’y of Agriculture, Washington, D. C. (Nebr. )
McGee, W J........... pice pre eee A Bureau of Ethnology, Wasbington, D. C.
McLanahan, Geo. W .........- 2.008 1601 21st St., Washington, D. C.
McRae, Thomas C............. -..00 House of Representatives, Wash., D. C. (Ark.)
PRCA Tee ROTI YT Wp orns's qn ds'evansnvcns General Land Office, Washington, D. C.

_ Newell, Frederick H.................. U. 8. Geological Survey, Washington, D. C.
RIE GE AV IW ae nas ocast>consaecesens General Land Office, Washington, D. C.
Pellew, Henry Ti...... 1.52 )scosssenss 1637 Mass. Ave., Washington, D. C.

Phillips, Wm. Hallett............... 603 La. Ave., Washington, D. C.

PepeaTE ARTY OW cop ane.s sacwenavacas sas 1301 Mass. Ave., Washington, D. C.

Proctor, Hon. Redfield..... ........ U. 5. Senate, Washington, D. C. (Vermont. )
BEN EUIOE i coh.snae's enone cncesssessea- Department of Agriculture, Washington, D. C.
CURE OU ES ee ee Department of Agriculture, Washington, D. C.
Sudworth, Geo. B. ....00. 20000000. Department of Agriculture, Washington, D. C.

...1600 I St., Washington, D. C.

.1600 ISt., Washington, D. C.

....U. 8. Geological Survey, Washington, D. C.
....1504 H St., Washington, D. C.

Howard University, Washington, D. C.
1430 Staughton St., Washington, D. C.
Washington, D. C.

Pacific Building, Washington, D. C.

....Gen’l Land Office, Washington, D. C.

FLORIDA.

...-Pensacola, Fla.
pres Grove City, Fla.
....Pensacola, Fla.

GEORGIA.
Meendon: Sz Gi. .s.c.ccenaseceseoeee Thomasville, Ga.
Pringle SO URAcie iv vxsctaces stercace eee Sandersville, Ga.
Redfern) (sits sss vcotessesoseecsaces Savannah, Ga.
Reppard | HB iisie cvs cevcyonacicese=t Savannah, Ga.

IDAHO.

Chrisman, Lieut. Edw. R.......... University of Idaho, Moscow, Idaho.
Perkins, Edmund T., Jr............ U. S Geological Survey, Boise, Idaho.

ILLINOIS.
IBOWEIs; LiOyG | Wisesscoviecccaresaterat Law Dept., C. & N. W. R.R., Chicago, Il.
IBTOWDS Ha ecnts p etceecdesccoesetraeres 5520 Madison Ave., Chicago, Il.
Brown, Samuels drsscsscccsseaeeear Room 1001, 155 La Salle St., Chicago, Hi.
Closson, Prof. Carlos C............. University of Chicago, Chicago, Ill.
Coulter, Prof. John M.............. Lake Forest, Ill. ;
CTAWLOLA Oc Wirescsaclautaccenteesncse Masonic Temple, Chicago, Ill.
Deering, Charles W.........0.:ss00+ Fullerton and Clybourn Ave., Chicago, Ill.
Haines; Jamesiiicsscscses bidceteres Pekin, Ill.
Ball; Mllsworthidvicc..s sree. ssevbevees 7100 Eggleston Ave., Englewood, Ill.
Kent, Norton Ay... ccssccass) ease epee 2944 Michigan Ave., Chicago, Il.
Lombard, a listsccekeercksee nies eaee Title Guarantee and Trust Bldg., Chicago, Ill.
Maniers (Geo. HWriicss-scasheneren thee Minier, Il.
Nash; Bey: (Oye: -c.scssence WeGaneoesens Olney, Tl.
#sPetersons PiiSzcsessue scceeeeecates 164 La Salle St., Room 21, Chicago, Ill.
Forber Wii. W)'\73,7..2sascenrdusee nes 16 Fullerton Ave., Chicago, Ill.
BIO WAY, dai ie Soe cl eee 802 Monadnock Block, Chicago, Ill.
Bimonds, OO s watecersatserttu aries Station X, Chicago, Ill.

INDIANA. :
Troop, Prot. Janies.sc.soreceuseren Purdue University, Lafayette, Ind.

IOWA.

Berryhill, James G.. .........200.08- Des Moines, Iowa.
everett, Brank.ice-..-c-sssceseee ee U. 8. Geological Survey, Denmark, Iowa.
Macbride, Prof. Thomas H.......... Iowa City, Iowa.
* Perkins, Charles E........:.. .. ..Burlington, Iowa.
BAGS ELOL eke svcsedisvsesSekssueey Des Moines, Iowa.
WY RUPOUS Os Ms cy scsccceseevererenore Des Moines, Iowa.

KANSAS.
Adams, FranklinsG, <..:s:cs.sc. cscs Topeka, Kansas.
Georgeson, Prof. OC. Christian....State College, Manhattan, Kansas.
Marlatt, Frederick A. ..............- Manhattan, Kansas.
IMABON PrOLdS sO! sccscstcescenecers Manhattan, Kansas.
PAW HG IN ieccecsvussselvacspscteesects Kansas City, Kansas.
POPENOG, HELOL Mi, Ans scceosseessr ice Manhattan, Kansas.

SUHODULTIN IO is wecteseeusvicssoconpecnes Syracuse, Kansas.

9

KENTUCKY.
RCIOCES, Ek. WK: sn scatuguvesucernpinioveal Elizabethtown, Ky.
BOLORIL-» Vic, DA: stew abaiiedcimeen cuewesney Hopkinsville, Ky.
MAINE.
Adams, Dr. Charles E............... Bangor, Maine.
OMFG, AUST cccaedscnene vider ~ East Machias, Me.
PMS HN. Sena dann cecuaiin deansplaabwadin Box 264, Bangor, Me.
SPOBDY, WSO soca stxenccicessssacun Bangor, Me.
PRGISy DSNIGL ET sotichenscaseeccne cesses Bangor, Me.
Eastman, Theodore Jewett........South Berwick, Me.
AGS, ELON: FOUN nies: since wvernan oxnge Ellsworth, Me.
ERODE sh ORT Win vncaca csvavarsvevans North Berwick, Me.
* Jackson, Thomas............ ......Portland, Me.
ROME CO AS1 Fesvaucsvassuht.osoysnutvaess Augusta, Me.
Sawyer, Robert Wm....... .........Bangor, Me.
PEO GOD: Miactutes sastcesensee acne Portland, Me.
WURLEGI. od ONE Wie. caniwasignccscaveses Cumberland Mills, Me.
MARYLAND.
Alexander, Julien J............ reaaee Box 241, Baltimore, Md.
Gordon-Cumming, A. P............. Freedom, Carroll Co., Md.
MASSACHUSETTS.
Adams, Charles Francis............. 23 Court St., Boston, Mass.
Appleton, Francis H................. 251 Marlborough St., Boston, Mass.
To Lh SEO, Dg) OB a P. O. Box 1338, Boston, Mass.
Atkinson, Edward..... .......0ss00<0 Brookline, Mass.
Bartol, Elizabeth H.................17 Chestnut St., Boston, Mass.
BEBO UG as EIOTEOM ss vvecacccusesossse 36 Temple Place, Boston, Mass.
Beebe, J. Arthur......................06 Temple Pl., Boston, Mass.
Bemis, Albert Farwell............... The Charlesgate, Beacon St., Boston, Mass.
RUIN T TOES oxhice dinses bv skcd stonasatey The Charlesgate, Beacon St., Boston, Mass.
PEM EAOUEY O),. 0502 vc0sse assseu sass: Springfield, Mass.
Re MAPS 0. Ws cose casenscnesse The Charlesgate, Beacon St., Boston, Mass.
«Bowditch, James H........... .... 60 Devonshire St., Boston, Mass.
Brewer, Francis W..........2s- sss Hingham Center, Mass.
BPEHORBy EIGHTY): acvat catnns asvneeresss West Medford, Mass.
Brooks, John Henry. ............. Milton, Mass.
SPER. SOs irnssgcarnengeate ranexs 7 Arlington St., Boston, Mass.
Byington, Miss Alice................5tockbridge, Mass.
SENS, CAOO- Ss ocrssec xs aca Ne egetaante P. O. Box 1302, Boston, Mass.
~~ Godman, Philip.......02210csces-ee0e- Brookline, Mass.
Brerrord, Geo. "T.cevecvsecadunyenkia 85 Water St., Boston, Mass.
Denison, John H......0s.ccessasendaes Williamstown, Mass.

MRVOANOC, THOMAS. .50cccsccccssdnvesaas 21 City Square, Charlestown, Mass.

10

MASSACHUSETTS— Continued.

The Charlesgate, Beacon St., Boston, Mass. ©

Dunn SATAY, ..0ccccccecssencasvasenses
Edmunds, Prof. J. Raynor......... Cambridge, Mass.
Hhiot, CHATICS 2. .21-scoccesnscce senses . Brookline, Mass.

LONI Pay Ss ea I ee a oncond as, Gapcpacc Ane
Emmons, N. H
Estabrooks, John A
Farlow, Dr. W. G
*Fay, Joseph Storey
*Fay, Miss Sarah B

eee ee eee ee ee eeneee

Fields, Mrs. James T............-++.

Flagg, AUQUStUS ..........sseeeeeeere
* Forbes, John M
Forbes, W. H
Forbush, E. H
French, Jonathan
*French, J. D. W
* Gardner, John L
(GIN PEO WALG: sssesvess neat sactans=s
GoodalesDrsiGelirs.ssaccsteccienees
Graves, H. S
Hammond, George Warren .
*Hemenway, Augustus
Hounnewell, Hc sc ccenesossecees
Iasigi, Mrs. Oscar
Jackson, Edmund.............4..0+0:
Jackson, Robert T
James, Geo. B

See e ewe eee ne weee

Peete ree ee teeee

sO eee ee neee wanes

Ammen ee ee eee tant eeeee

stew eereneee

ere e ree eee errr reer eee.

Jewett, Miss Sarah Orne............

eee eee ee wee eet eee
Ane eee teen eenee
Teme eee eee eee
SRR eee Hee eee ee
Renee ee tweeee
ee ee

eee Ree meee eneeee

Pere eee eee CCC eCeereeer ary

Lodge, Mrs. Mary E
Lodge, Richard W..........s0c..s-«
Loring, Caleb William..............
* Loring, William Caleb...........
EMGOW sO ONT ive dibicshversacdeceneus abe
Manning, Miss A. A..........6..
Manning, Jacob W..........0

Manning, Robert
Manning, Warren
Marsh, D. J

a eee eee em ee ewes

SOR rene we eee eee

LAHOT A MLIGS sas Is cra san eeescndes eve

Peer eee err ee rere ere es

ee eee eee ewe e ew eeeeee

Perec eee eee eee

eee ee eee ee eee)

.149 Tremont St., Boston, Mass.

40 Water St., Boston, Mass.
.Milton, Mass.

24 Quincy St., Cambridge, Mass.
Woods Holl, Mass.

Woods Holl, Mass.

148 Charles St., Boston, Mass.
Little, Brown & Co., Boston, Mass.
Milton, Mass.

Milton, Mass.

Stanwood Hall, Malden, Mass.
160 State St., Boston, Mass.

160 State St., Boston, Mass.

22 Congress St., Boston, Mass.

.7 Tremont Place, Boston, Mass.

Cambridge, Mass.
Andover, Mass.

..... Hamilton, Commonwealth Ave., Boston, Mass.

10 Tremont St., Boston, Mass.

87 Milk St., Boston, Mass.
Stockbridge, Mass.

Marlborough St., Boston, Mass.

35 Gloucester St., Boston, Mass.
220 Washington St., Boston, Mass.
148 Charles St., Boston, Mass.
Topsfield, Mass.

39 Court St., Boston, Mass.
Milton, Mass.

Duxbury, Mass.

68 Chauncy St., Boston, Mass.
Stockbridge, Mass.

Groton, Mass.

Box 2221, Boston, Mass.

Box 73, Swampscott, Mass.

Mass. Inst. Technology, Boston, Mass.
Prides Crossing, Mass.

-50 State St., Boston, Mass.

Chelsea, Mass.

... The Charlesgate, Beacon St., Boston, Mass.
.... Reading, Mass.

101 Tremont St., Boston, Mass.
Brookline, Mass.

Springfield, Mass.

1 Walnut St., Boston, Mass.

11 ‘

MASSACHUSETTS— Continued.

May, John Joseph ..........000 scenes Box 2348, Boston, Mass.
MECRtON, Dr. Hel. < .cciscswurensenstt 17 Chestnut St., Boston, Mass.
MEOLCOI, CORN 3D)... us. seskacencons Vaeehs 151 Milk St., Boston, Mass.
Morton, Nathaniel ....... ena ..+++sPlymouth, Mass.
Olmsted, Frederick Law............ Brookline, Mass.
EEHEGOG cD a: C2 .ccbcs a tovnnnvenasdeactae Brookline, Mass.
Reet Es Ec ssceden « ss games Ran maa som 6 Joy St., Boston, Mass.
Warker, AUGUstus....cssscscesateonsts 218 Seaver St., Roxbury, Mass.
Parsons, Miss Katherine............ 54 Garden St., Cambridge, Mass.
Peabody, Oliver W.......-.cses.0e00 Kidder, Peabody & Co., Boston, Mass.
ERBOTOG, DBVIG scccsesescesscanarcanvhe Salem, Mass.
MALVOrs, GOO. Bis, Tesssastis vues’ ...Milton, Mass.
BPEOMING, Wis Eh. sanecsarssnnansates 252 Marlborough St., Boston, Mass.
RE PIOOTIOTE <W vicenasesrisceteus cir 26 Equitable Bldg., Boston, Mass.
Benseell, Henry A... .sivsscseessevcensts Milton, Mass.
Sedgwick, Henry Dwight.......... Stockbridge, Mass.
SIGES EOL. DOs £9 !consacreasuswcaesen Cambridge, Mass.
SRE s MPATICIS: 05. vanssdvanbvesseutssss Wayland, Mass.

' *Smith, Benjamin Greene ........Cambridge, Mass.
Sprague, Charles F...........0..s000 23 Court St., Boston, Mass.
Stevens, Mrs. Moses T............... North Andover, Mass.
SPeearane Sis Es: Ehasecicidantespsscde cases Newton, Mass.
Strong, John Ruggles................ 58 Shepard St., Cambridge, Mass.
Oy ESSE gh UPS Bai eee Newton Center, Mass.
Myton, George |B voscce: ..ise-deseses Milton, Mass.
Valentine, James J. ........000--e+ South Framingham, Mass.
* Warren, Samuel D................. Dedham, Mass.
PNP SECER RCW «Me cicpaccscecrsessoasds Boston, Mass.
gO i A, or Jamaica Plain, Mass.
PREC CISPION DT. 06550 sacecesnavensos 213 Commonwealth Ave., Boston, Mass.
White, Dr dames O.......12200..250: 259 Marlboro St., Boston, Mass.
Whitney, Miss Anne................ The Charlesgate, Beacon St., Boston, Mass.
Whitney, Henry M..........00..c000 Brookline, Mass.
PU RLRIRNI PORT Ds 5 cas seascuseesnseos 160 State St., Boston, Mass.

Woods, John M................. ..-..86 Canal St., Boston, Mass.

MICHIGAN.
Bees, Brot, Win. F scenes crvosevenss Agricultural College, Mich.
BEORMIAC.. COUALION: sisgrivtocssrsovcensas State University, Ann Arbor, Mich.
ELPILIAE CE, SOUR rasrane cauwensssiniensses Detroit, Mich.
Regmeryeas, J. Mi. .sscassescasecsocssncns Marquette, Mich.

MINNESOTA.
* Andrews, Gen. O. C..........-s000 833 Goodrich Ave., St. Paul, Minn.
* Ayres, Horace B..........s00-s0000+ Carlton, Minn.

Barrett, J. O .......4+. seseceseseeeseeeebFOWnS Valley, Minn.

. 12

MINNESOTA— Continued.

Brand (Oy Wsccsnsssscss cs scenseesarcens Faribault, Minn.
BROCK WAY (Es Dscrccovt secvcn adsl cence Windom, Minn.
Hatabrook. gd Ob DiVisiesiscns: ssa 699 Lincoln Ave., St. Paul, Minn.
Gale Nidward'@ iit. cs.sssserssrnaserees New York Life Building, Minneapolis, Minn.
Green, Prof. Samuel B. ........... University of Minn., St. Anthony Park, Minn.
Hall, Prof. Christopher W......... University of Minnesota, Minneapolis, Minn.
PVATTIS A OMNIS sa.cos capi bociresesoyosecs La Crescent, Houston Co., Minn.
Hays, Prof. Willet M.......... ..... St. Anthony Park, Minn.
Le Kale (reCcy a1 DO) Ih eG Boa arenh anc pa Minneapolis, Minn.
Gel wR O resssnsscetussccuonasuaccsters Rochester, Minn.
MOY Gl ei hic odscsactsscienesescetese res Montevideo, Minn.
MeMillan, Prof. Conway............ Minneapolis, Minn.
Nanas Se NGWiOnsescecdcscsrsncaessistens Minneapolis, Minn.
*SOwall dis. s-resrasssccccisisaslencnen 46 Gilfillan Block, St. Paul, Minn.
Snyder, Prof. Harry.................Prof. Chemistry, St. Anthony Park, Minn.
Wedge; Clarence... .....ccsccecccease Albert Lea, Minn.
Winchell, N. H....................... Minneapolis, Minn.
\ MISSOURI.

Broadhead.) Prof. Gi Gy.ccst. cre .6- State University, Columbia, Mo.
KeesslerGepr Eiicscecscscscespensadees Sec. and Eng. Park Com., Kansas City, Mo.
Murtfeldt, Charles W................ Box 53, Kirkwood, Mo.
Trelease, Prof. William... .........Mo. Botanical Garden, St. Louis, Mo.
Whitten; sProtids+ O7..cstesssese arate Columbia, Mo.
WHOM OCLO ct. caves sonccesnstadans Old Orchard, St. Louis, Mo.
Winslow, Arthur’. osjrerse-csseeaee8 Roe Building, St. Louis, Mo.

MONTANA.
IAN GFE MMOLE: Cl.) es sceservacsestnewane Ft. Missoula, Mont.
*Timory, Prot. 8. Mo. cscs. eeass Agr’l College, Bozeman, Mont.
Murdock, Lieut. John Stevens...Fort Assinniboine, Mont.
Reid: Rev. James .:.sscpsatereesssas. Bozeman, Mont.

NEBRASKA.
IBATTICS Wi Avsedentvatestavtsseasexvccsse Grand Island, Nebr.
Barry We AU CRE steacaiscusvsices cess Greeley, Nebr.
IBGHNB Uti OO ovscdent iss ¢ccsweveeen¥s Hebron, Nebr.
Bessey, Prof. Charles E............ University of Nebraska, Lincoln, Nebr.
Furnas, Hon. Robert W............ Brownville, Nebr.
MacLean, Pres. George E.......... University of Nebraska, Lincoln, Nebr.
ML GYRG PLS Nadtevic sactcatss ussoenesnscres Benkelman, Nebr.
* Morton, Hon. J. Sterling......... Nebraska City, Nebr.
MeNitt, Randolph............-....+« Red Cloud, Nebr.
ESE Sal) pW eoereocrsaes (euesuerensas ses Blue Springs, Gage Co., Nebr.
EOWA’, 1, (Addiccjedierece tesscveleaed Blair, Nebr.
PREVION UE MWictessuctseceisses eo essiscua Lincoln, Nebr.

Warde, Prof. Clyde Everistae....Belvidere, Nebr.

13

NEVADA.

Hamilton, Lieut. William R.......State University, Reno, Nev.

NEW HAMPSHIRE.

Chandler, Hon. Wm. E............. Concord, N. H.

Colby,. Prof. James F................ Dartmouth College, Hanover, N. H.
Dinsmoor, Mary B.............ss000 Keene, N. H.

Metis TONS GP 2) cc shaacctws dou casuneeberes Keene, N. H. :

DORMS NWN GP) 2. a cineae dts varediosésksnens Concord, N. H.

MERRIE IEE Got pod -crceanieducanasnenes Exeter, N. H.

Griffin, Gen. Simon G................ Keene, N. H.

RMR HGD TES Oe) BR oldanacennandeduassaue Franklin Falls, N. H.
Huntington,Rev. Geo. P.......... Hanover, N. H.

MADER. GeO. TE osc. cones :ccnsseecsoeeQOnCOrd, Ne Hi.

Murkland, Charles S.................. Agricultural College, Durham, N. H.
Twitchell, Dr. Geo. B............-. Keene, N. H.

Va Oe 0 Jackson, N. H.

NEW JERSEY.

Meertatte COHOTION | F5S-. cunecapepsdaenconen 1 Newark St., Hoboken, N. J.
REE AO Was sew cwanssousvevassaeds 24 Washington St., Norristown, N. J.
PIGVIS, SAINUGL Doc sseccsesssccencees Lakewood, N. J.

rE PIS WIS Ole ou sz ascten acovsn-acess Englewood, N. J.

French, Dr. J. Clement ........... 328 Belleville Ave., Newark, N. J.
PeOE AONE ©), cacecnnces sae ccneneane Mays Landing, N. J.

Girtanner, Jules...........0cessesse0s Linden, N. J.

Howell, George W...............se00e Morristown, N. J.

RUT TICRT 5) ¢ occa coe -sacce accor Montelair, N. J.

MNP WEEE 9S... ce nessancccie viens Vanderbeck Sons, Jersey City, N. J-
ce Un? el ee ee ee North Cramer Hill, N. J.

ig MARIN ERTENE 5s 00,5 siicce se sunen ‘ove Lakewood, N. J.

1: er ere Orange, N. J.

Smock, Prof. John C................ State Geologist, Trenton, N. J.
RT ES att cbse ese nevsenesaceyevas Deckertown, N. J.

Tucker, Herbert W...............000. 54 Sayre St., Elizabeth, N. J.
EMMA ES. bs inves cay ove ce eyysiubavei Taylor’s Hotel, Jersey City, N. J.
Watson, J: Madison.................. Elizabeth, N. J.

WHERE, FIGS ..0000..0080csrccesecrvesae Atlantic City, N. J.

NEW MEXICO.

PEMA Gs TOO West cddsvdouncdinastddvances Santa Fé, N. Mex.
NEW YORK.
Albright, John Joseph...........+.. Buffalo, N. Y.
Alexander, Robert C.................203 Broadway, New York, N. Y.
Armstrong, Seymour C............. Riparius, Warren Co., N. Y.

Barber, Amzi Lorenzo............++. 66 Broadway, New York, N. Y.

;

Bellows, Russell N..........
Bennett, Dr. J. A..........

14

NEW YORK— Continued.

wes oeee-247 Sth Ave., New York, N. Y.
seeeeeeee 4 Irving Place, New York, N. Y.

S Bishop, OUGL dice ssrsciescixeccsers 993 5th Ave., New York, N. Y.

eas uncptesedsnateeenn 448 Clinton Ave., Brooklyn, N. Y.

mca Men Sa saa Glens Falls, N. Y. .
D eegiaseo dete 76 Wall St., New York, N. Y.

So Cote ceceesseeee 48 West 59th St., New York, N. Y.
rosaxdsnn ps oense® 1153 Gates Ave., Brooklyn, N. Y.

reg guseie ane conve vais 40 West 54th St., New York, N. Y.
ArNecapariin serprtc Cazenovia, N. Y.

Boorum, Wm. B
Bowden, Hugh A
Bronson, Frederick
Brown, Geo. H
Brundage, Alfred H
Bryce, Miss Edith
Burden, Henry, 2d
Burke, Dr. Martin

Peaaccitreneeinccss 147 Lexington Ave., New York, N, Y.

Butler, Miss Rosalie........
Chichester, Charles F

.seeeeedL East 69th St., New York, N. Y.

aacaatrseectete 33 Kast 17th St., New York, N. Y.
saungaabencenessecle cess Childwold, N. Y.

ROPE incr 50 West 47th St., New York, N. Y.

Re reetany adhiscne sense tate Pres. H. B. Claflin Co., New York, N. Y.
seawcgnasctecsesaenanee Syracuse, N. Y.

fad vee eeotee Na eros tae Albany, N. Y.

Sdewie sewerage sieaseee yen 146 Franklin St., New York, N. Y.
pvdasaplnetsanesonseets Southfields, N. Y.

Guapo ceveterssiavecdesteats: 122 Lyell Ave., Rochester, N. Y.

Dror des teas ds tusameridenaanene 18 Broadway, New York, N. Y.

svedeaiel oiwueie? Room 516, 32 Nassau St., New York, N. Y.

Child, Addison
Choate, Miss Josephine

Cogswell, Wm. B
Colvin, Verplank
Cook, Martin R
Coxe, Macgrane

Cutting, W. Bayard
Dang, Oharles a iavcaecssesrcccees
deCamp, Wm. 8

-25 East 60th St., New York, N. Y.

poy ancieeaeaerertcoctecs 35 Mt. Morris Ave., New York, N. Y.
Dee dastevdieceracsaiee 45 Broadway, New York, N. Y.

HCE EM Ry ET REE 45 Broadway, New York, N. Y.

aig) okeaeWwedastvenvisbased Dolgeville, N. Y.

Dowd, Olney-B ys cevesescevereisstese 226 West 75th St., New York, N. Y.
Det aveodanstpuaeen aiecaaen 80 Pine St., New York, N. Y.

MET ey raver Leecececeeees-cee, 439 West 14th St., New York, N. Y.
caceqemseeueen ones Vien Albany, N. Y.

Erving, Wm. Van Renselaer...... 1144 Broadway, Albany, N. Y.
Vesibsswackas sos .....-45 South St., New York, N. Y.

Dieterich, C. F
Dodge, Geo. E
*Dolge, Alfred

*Dudley, P. H
Egerton, Wm. 8
Faile, Thomas H

Fairchild, Hon. Charles 8
Ferguson, Wm. E

fidesecd 76 Clinton Place, New York, N. Y.

Wee Hab tiucacenexactes 127 Produce Exchange, New York, N. Y.

*Flower, Roswell P...............

.-52 Broadway, New York, N. Y.

MOO ue A INOS SL) clicasvehccedsveetcoconeas 269 Lexington Ave., New York, N. Y.

puae achesnrouesevesccevkec’ Forest Commission, Albany, N. Y.

Guu cea natura tenes 36 Union Square, New York, N. Y.

Wevatessns¢ Cor. 3d Ave. and 141st St., New York, N. Y.
anuaablecaavera san Rochester, N. Y.

dadebhtasswewsescapat Albany, N. Y.

Gavadsheoneee 32 Nassau St., New York, N. Y..

Herrman, Mrs. Esther...............59 West 56th St., New York, N. Y.
Rataakeevoeneo lt vobese Roslyn, Queens Co., N. Y.

Gerhard, Wm. Paul
Greiffenberg, Frederick
Hamilton, Arthur §
Harris, Frederick
Hayes, Richard Somers

*Hicks, John S

15

NEW YORK—Continued.

Higley, Hon. Warren........ .....+. 32 Nassau St., New York, N. Y.
Higley, Mrs. Warren................- 68 W. 40th St., New York, N. Y.
Hildenbrand, Wilhelm ........... 1 Broadway, New York, N. Y.

Hoe, Mrs. Richard M..........+.-+s: 11 East 7lst St., New York, N. Y.
Hofferberth, Charles F.............- 132 18th St., New York, N. Y.
Hough, Romeyn B.........ss00 000+ Lowville, N. Y.

ECU DALG, RODE F..dkescccsciseosave Cazenovia, N. Y.

wames, Dr. Walter Biscscsc cnucovese 268 Madison Ave., New York, N. Y.
Jaques, ‘William H................... 30 West 73d St., New York, N. Y.
Jenkins, M. C...... Pibvashwssmaemsiine 143 Liberty St., New York, N. Y.
MeOH, MIOETIS! Hi. s.<0s0cecvsssepeee 52 William St., New York, N. Y.
MOUMAON, ETANK WG....05<crscsesessane Blithewood, Parkville, N. Y.
BRAEERESENTY ERS SU) ocasaddpscenn) oeshbonv nae Century Magazine, New York, N. Y.
Jones, Miss Caroline Ogden....... 293 Madison Ave., New York, N. Y.
Kelsey, Fred. W ....................145 Broadway, New York, N. Yeo
Bea We WY) cccscpazascessaisaecisass 368 Union St., Brooklyn, N. Y.
PESTA WL cca xocwvacts: chascnaisdacancd 840 East 166th St., New York, N. Y.
Mme, ENOMAS EF. 5.5 sscrvsecesesecs 115 Broadway, New York, N. Y.
Kang, Hon, John A ...2::.0.s06:s-.0s Great Neck, Long Island, N. Y.
TONE GLA US GARE aS on oer eae 100 Reade St., New York, N. Y.
Penne Erank: Wocc sos ascses0ss0s 894 Reade St., New York, N. Y.
PRPRMELUL ET Wis sensors casewasasoscunes Cazenovia, N. Y.

MacNaughton, James ............... 86 State St., Albany, N. Y.

MCAS EROY so edge chase es caccanecoasé 48 West 19th St., New York, N. Y.
Marston, Edwin S....................217 Clinton Ave., Brooklyn, N. Y.
LE ESL bs It ee Cor. Pearl and Pine Sts., New York, N. Y.
Meeker, Stephen J...............000. 95 Clay St., New York, N. Y.
Meredith, Eugene..................04. Cazenovia, N. Y.

LEE s 6 oN ee 38 Park Row, New York, N. Y.
MEME ORS a in awn vancorstescenns Mills Building, New York, N. Y.
Muller, L. G...................00. .....1 Broadway, New York, N. Y.
POOL O ON sos. ss cascsoeneseswansea Ballston Spa, N. Y.

Nash, Francis Philip, Jr............Geneva, N. Y.

DID VOR PANS. ATG 5.565 .000s. ensesess 233 Madison Ave., New York, N. Y.
Noyes, Dr. Henry D...............+0 233 Madison Ave., New York, N. Y.
Peabody, Prof. Geo. L............. 57 West 38th St., New York, N. Y.
Peck, Prof. Chas. H..................Botanist, State Hall, Albany, N. Y.
EERO OM, CISILOLG iiidic sis snidess:s ss carosap 2 Gramercy Park, New York.
Pittinger, James H...............000- Carroll St., Brooklyn, N. Y

EONS CROD.C Dice dedtabapsoaiaredteon Ghent, N. Y.

Prentiss, Prof. Albert N Lveaentiie's Cornell University, Ithaca, N. Y.
mere, GOO; UG sixesesonies's nagar ds Cazenovia, N. Y.

Raymond, Rossiter.......-.... sse++ 13 Burling Slip, New York, N. Y.
Rose, Arthur P... + sseeeeeeeesGreneva, Ontario Co., N. Y.
Satterlee, Mrs. Chaat sidhegunades 102 East 31st St., New York, N. Y.

Schofield, Peter F... s+seeeeeeeeb0X 2951, New York, N. Y.

16

NEW YORK—Continued.

#B6e. Mrs. FLOPACe... «ose saccee seen 40 West 9th St., New York, N. Y.

Seonr, Anson sG ia cncersssneniete-<ae Hotel St. George, Brooklyn, N. Y.

Simpson, John B...................-..5 East 14th St., New York, N. Y.

RISHONS MMLCUS Wives crcarssvcirevesiesec Potsdam, N. Y.

Smythe, OC. H., Jr....................9ec¢’y Wilmurt Club, Clinton, N. Y.

Spencer, Mrs. Lorillard............. 107 East 17th St., New York, N. Y.

Spencer, Samuel.........sscccsssseres 80 Broadway, New York, N. Y.

*Stephens, W. Hudson... ......... Lowville, N. Y.

PiMAON MACHT Ve Uiracescevacens'-coseps 32 Nassau St., New York, N. Y.

BLOAGATOSIS,, Biccscssecscvasdssesensesse Glenns Falls, N. Y.

eihay er, Ore Wills Asecsctaneconsesss Cooperstown, N. Y.

Thompson, Sidney De C............ Corn Exchange Bank Building, New York, N.Y.

*PHOMsON, LCMION ses scsssecncsressse 8 Ten Broeck St., Albany, N. Y.

Tratman, E. E. Russell............. 103 Tribune Building, New York, N. Y.

* Vanderbilt, George W............. 640 Fifth Ave., New York, N. Y.

Vanderbilt & Hopkins............... 126 Liberty St., New York, N. Y.

Wadsworth, W. Austin............. Geneseo, N. Y.

Walker VAlEVEC ccs sacs recesses eestor 43 Liberty St., New York, N. Y.

Ward; Dr. Samuel 'B:....2:,scse.ce .135 North Pearl St., Albany, N. Y.

Weed, Frederick A...........s0cs+00. Potsdam, N. Y.

WiGGU HWANG, cccossececesbvoucsess ects Potsdam, N. Y.

Wetmore, Jacob G..........seceseeeee No. 2 Wall St., New York, N. Y.

Walliams, Richard) Re. .cndccosecesas 124 St. James Place, Brooklyn, N. Y.

Wilson, James Grant.............00. 15 East 74th St., New York, N. Y.
NORTH CAROLINA.

HASH O;! Ws OW s cevewssecces sce eyedecerets = Raleigh, N. C.

Holmes) sPrOl. I. Avassesciversesdueree State Geologist, Raleigh, N. C.

Sohenck, ©. Alwin./;.c.ccseseasseee Biltmore, N. C.

NORTH DAKOTA.
Barrett, W. W....0..00sc0ssrouersssses Oren sienry, N. 1.

Brown, |O. 1G... .0. ccccesnensentseassete Minnewaukon, Benson Co., N. Dak.
Oarrick, GoM, ccsswisevstrsetest sae Minto, Walsh Co., N. Dak.

OHIO.
*Bambach, George.....csscssecceness Ripley, Ohio.
YOWD, PAOVANEIN sectcsccsssscsccscs Fernbank, Ohio.
Brown, Miss Anne F ...............North Bloomfield, Ohio.
ISTOWI AV GUUG tecstrsac a ececeestesses Euclid Ave., Cleveland, Ohio.
Canfield, Pres. James 4............ Columbus, O.
Ghambers, DiiBe. c.c.sesus<se Covaenecs Stewart Iron Co., Cleveland, Ohio.
HOKIGY HPONGY sca pce ces cens'cbseesvecscs 331 Middle St., Dayton, Ohio.
PISNGL VW. SLU DOGLIss cnc tecase ovede Cincinnati, Ohio.
Gamble, James N..........00.sseseees Carew Building, Cincinnati, Ohio.
CEENO SP ORMIA cc oeleucadte casuccs tite -College Hill, Cincinnati, Ohio.

(Farrand, Cenc. iisstesvevevec ecsaun 44 Johnson Bldg., Cincinnati, Ohio.

17

OHIO— Continued.

Migalls, Mi. Te)... nckiiasstainaneile «<alen Pres. C. C. C. & St. L. R.R., Cincinnati, Ohio.
* Lazenby, Prof. Wm. R...........State University, Columbus, Ohio.
Mather, Wr. Gis cd: ssestivcsotcecenbs Pres. Cleveland-Cliffs Iron Co., Cleveland, O.
Poindexter, Kev. James............ 41 North 4th St., Columbus, Ohio.
* Read, Prof. Matthew C........... Hudson, Ohio.
Roelker, Frederick G..........000+0. Allen Bldg., Cincinnati, Ohio.
Schmidlapp, J. G...... sscciseveeoese Union Trust Co., Cincinnati, Ohio.
Springer, Dr. Alfred............,.... Cincinnati, Ohio.
*Steele, Robert W....... .........000 Dayton, Ohio.”
Stein, Arthur.....................+0+e..Oincinnati, Ohio.
Storer, Hon. Bellamy................ Cincinnati, Ohio.
* Warder, Reuben H..... ........... North Bend, Ohio.
PERS MIDIS. kai nsadsicboesonanetionas Wilmington, Ohio.
OREGON.

Applegate, Elmer I............. ..... Klamath Falls, Oregon.
mente \OUGi ain cc<<cseccessesbesne Olene, Klamath Co., Oregon.
RIE WEOLE! (ALP cel yescccescscscaces Roseburgh, Douglas Co., Oregon.
Hammond, Edward W............+. Wimer, Jackson Co., Oregon.
Lloyd, Prof. Francis E.............. Pacific University, Forest Grove, Oregon.
Nickerson, Geo. S.........cescecseses Klamath Falls, Oregon.
PRIME E a MALUEN 5 .ip ag sdocbestin otvacsses ses Ashland, Oregon.
Scheydecker, M.......................515 Hancock St., Portland, Oregon.

by PENNSYLVANIA.
IAMS ELODEPG, isn .ccvseccsess secece 124 South 16th St., Philadelphia, Pa.
POEUN Os Ws secs casceasdtevaloe 1605 Walnut St., Philadelphia, Pa.
Beale, Edward F., Jr..... ..........231 Front St., Philadelphia, Pa.
Beaver, Hon. James A.............. Bellefonte, Penn.
PE RIMLING, SOND .......scecesseesros 25 N. Juniper St., Philadelphia, Pa.
Cadwalader, John....................505 Chestnut St., Philadelphia, Pa.
Ohase, Howard A. .... ...0.....0i0000 1430 So. Penn. Square, Philadelphia, Pa.
RIONGETHS, JOH H......<cessccncvvnvece 500 North Broad St., Philadelphia, Pa.
MONO, UranOIS Bi ..5.506-505.54c0ncs0e00 Germantown, Philadelphia, Pa.
WORG; OTS, BYINtON 24.55 :.020. 3250s 1515 Spruce St., Philadelphia, Pa.
woxe, Mrs. Eckley B.....052.s0sss00s Drifton, Luzerne Co., Pa.
Eavenson, Howard M................ 2013 Vine St., Philadelphia, Pa.
Edmunds, Hon. George F......... 1505 Locust St., Philadelphia, Pa.
Elwyn, Rev. Alfred L............... 1422 Walnut St., Philadelphia, Pa.
EG, ONAPIOB.. favesncsnatacbasscdes send 20th St. above York St., Philadelphia, Pa.
masher, Mies ‘ANNO... .ccsessecsevecsace 308 Walnut St., Philadelphia, Pa.
ee C602, Ths Léaninswnson vnieercvedes 308 Walnut St., Philadelphia, Pa.
MIBDOY,. Mrs. GeO: Hose cioss se eee 308 Walnut St., Philadelphia, Pa.
misher, Dr. Henry M 1: ....:s00.55. 317 So. 12th St., Philadelphia, Pa.
Bee. JOGO IH Ms... Milssenssncne sevens Broad and Pine Sts., Philadelphia, Pa.
Grant, J. Blackwood .............+0. Douglassville, Berks Co., Pa.

Haines, Francis O......... ssseress Haines St., Germantown, Philadelphia, Pa.

18

PENNSYLVANIA—Oontinued.

Haseltine: Frank, ..250 secve-ses-sdse 1825 Walnut St., Philadelphia, Pa.
*Haydon, James O.........2...-.000s Jeanesville, Luzerne Co., Pa.
Hester, Mrs.'Geo. T..:..00:05 0 ss.0s Newtown, Pa.

Hutchinson, Pemberton &......... 112 Chestnut St., Philadelphia, Pa.
SAMOS MAGE, peotavesee-cccscacvess «eK TADEKUD MEA.

Jayne, H. Lia Barre:....0-...0.002s00. 505 Chestnut St., Philadelphia, Pa.
Kreuzpaintner, Paul................ 1400 3d Ave., Altoona, Pa.
Dandreth, Burn6ty....:c+sc.-+s26<-000 Bristol, Pa. N

* Lea, Henry Charles................ 2000 Walnut St., Philadelphia, Pa.
Lun@y, Mrs. J. P....... Jecpanaceiosa ses 245 South 18th St., Philadelphia, Pa.
NB UTICOIOMIS. noscssiescesaccessotnee es Wilmurt Club, Athens, Pa.
Montgomery, Dr. E. E. ........... 1818 Arch St., Philadelphia, Pa.
PAU OCA -seusecrscsetesnsst sss 505 Chestnut St., Philadelphia, Pa.
‘Peabody, ODSsiBersccncessrencssese 1415 Spruce St., Philadelphia, Pa.
Porter, Prof. Thomas C............ Lafayette College, Easton, Penn.
Rothrock Drie ce vcsateases sancsste West Chester, Pa.

Ryman, Theodore,....2.0..... sess. So. Franklin 8t., Wilkes Barre, Pa.
Sellars, Williams.30c10;.:20sessse0ces20 1600 Hamilton St., Philadelphia, Pa.
Bry Ger Geo: WD si ccacssa. ccevern cust City Engineer, Williamsport, Pa.
Stewardson, Thomas............... Montgomery Ave., Chestnut Hill, Phila., Pa.
Van Sant, Miss Belle ................ Newtown, Bucks Co., Pa.

Vieux, Js Wosecsrscebs ssedcscoresanpas 505 Chestnut St., Philadelphia, Pa.
Walker Wialliam:.cScedecsevesesuses 45 S. 3d St., Allegheny, Pa.

Welsh Herbert: csascicesssiececrcssen 1305 Arch St., Philadelphia, Pa.
Wilmsen, Bernhard.................. 43 Commerce St., Philadelphia, Pa.
Wolfe; \DriS vcccetsosssheercriseen essa 1701 Diamond St., Phila., Pa.

Wood, Stuart. + seeeereeee-400 Chestnut St., Philadelphia. Pa.
Zimmerman, De M. W. SU OSSLEEE 1633 Chestnut St., Philadelphia, Pa.

RHODE ISLAND.

Brown, John Nicholas............. 50 So. Main St., Providence, R. I.
Emmons, Arthur B.....:.:sccscscosss Newport, R. I.

Mason, Miss Ida. + ..iccsedesssscscses Rhode Island Ave., Newport, R. I.
Russell; Honry Gievesu eee East Greenwich, R. I.

* Wetmore, Geo. Peabody. ........ Newport, R. I.

SOUTH CAROLINA.

CETGON MCLOLs Els HA. cscaasciot eeesdiees Chester, South Carolina.
Love, Col. R. A...... desde hak oases Chester, S. C.
McKie, Dr. Thomas. J ......... «ese Woodlawn, 8. C.

SOUTH DAKOTA.

BEGLIOUUN, IPT. Als, pss0nvusonsin ¢s30eUed Agr’l College, Brookings, S. D.
Williams, Prof. Thomas Albert.. Brookings, So. Dakota.

19

TENNESSEE.
Callender, Dr. John H..............Nashville, Tenn.
PeMIGIng, BB. Li.ccesscesessucnsessapve Chattanooga, Tenn.
een. PNOMas’E oF visissssccsxveeok Nashville, Tenn.

TEXAS.
Sno, Dr. Isaae My 02k. wocsapesssss Weather Bureau, Galveston, Texas.
MO Ws CLOOOTION .axswecarasasssss Pres. Temple Nat. Bank, Temple, Texas.
Koppel, Mrs. I ....................-...24th St. and Broadway, Galveston, Texas.
Montgomery, R. E............. ...... Fort Worth, Texas.
CMEC EE Coico acis \nasncxstanacan shaven Temple, Texas.
ENTRY Doe Bic ccncouiasnes tovsbevivess Temple, Texas.
UTAH.

PRMMIOTES GOO. Qocis coctcclsacccduccses Salt Lake, Utah.
Mathes PLot. PON: Giisicei ssvveecsosss Salt Lake, Utah.
Paul, Prof. J. H......................Agricultural College, Logan, Utah.
PETES. LOL. CO, Avcicep a, sees ences University of Utah, Salt Lake, Utah.

VERMONT.
Battell, Joseph............ pala vaeertes Middlebury, Vt.
Cannon, Le Grand B................ Burlington, Vt.
Fairbanks, Mrs. Horace...... ..... St. Johnsbury, Vt.
Faller, Levi K.......:............... .brattleboro, Vt.
Grout, Hon. W. W. Revsusneceaaioaeds Barton, Vt.
ERTS EPP SS Bisse cc cctaeuveas tates. Brattleboro, Vt.
Proctor, Hon. Redfield.............. Proctor, Vt.
ACOMD, JORN W....... ..csscvesseceve St. Johnsbury, Vt.

VIRGINIA.
PREC. PROC ris cya nxanswveaaraxberans Blacksburg, Va.

WASHINGTON.

Harrington, Prof. Mark W. .......University of Washington, Seattle, Wash.
MR ETOTUION Ls, asc sstunadeis heed scents North Yakima, Wash.
Meany, Edmund 6................... University of Washington, Seattle, Wash.
Page, Miss Anne..........02cseeseeees Buckley, Wash.
MIRAE FAS Es acute tuavial shaded taanee North Yakima, Wash.

WEST VIRGINIA.

Corbett, Prof. L. C........ ..........Morgantown, W. Va.
Hopkins, Prof. A. D........006 -cs0ee Morgantown, W. Va.

20

WISCONSIN.
Adams, Pres. Charles K............ Madison, Wis.
Pntnam, HC vase ccscsscerossss-ssssau Claire, Wis:
Sohinke; sMaxsiGistccst<s ssa -s0 ane sec Asst. City Engineer, Milwaukee, Wis.
SLATE VID. iecsosecvnscsscsscsscs scecer Eau Claire, Wis.
Riwilt, OM aioe cecdencccwenssare ieheses Eau Claire, Wis.
RBI; Wee bletinsss se ssasee sees sonasces Marshfield, Wis.
Weyerhauser, Fred............00.s00es Chippewa Falls, Wis.
WYOMING.
IMGAdFTHIWOOG sncssasirscecercccests cons Cheyenne, Wyo.
CANADA.

Aberdeen, His Excellency the

BlarliOb Mi cuesskete oscsesaevecesrseeee Government House, Ottawa, Canada.
Allan, George William.. ........... Moss Park, Toronto, Canada.
Boyes Mey Mieescsccaciestrtccmeu et eran Bobcageon, Ontario, Canada.
Campbell, Archibald................ Quebec, Canada.
Gapaig; de C. ..ssccesecssnsetcents sre St. Denis, Kanawaska Co., Quebec, Canada.
Oraig TORN i-...\ecscensvelasamacressce Dominion Expt. Farm, Ottawa, Canada.
Crown Lands, Department of...... Quebec, Canada.
Crown Lands, Department of...... Treasury Department, Toronto, Canada.
* Denton, John Mirs.csececss sane London, Ontario, Canada.
* Drummond, Andrew T........... 265 University St., Montreal, Canada.
Heneker, R. W....... cuales tepabienerdeee Sherbroke, Quebec, Canada.
* Joly de Lotbiniére, Sir H. G....Point Platon, Quebec, Canada.
Mattie, Woalliam.5:..c:ssscacscasevcesee 404 Board of Trade, Montreal, Quebec, Canada.
Macauley, Thomas B................ Westmount, Montreal, Canada.
Price, Herbert MM. &i--.2ccsecsnseeee Quebec, Canada.
Robitaille, Vis Ane. cscsecsventer Box 652, Quebec, Canada.
088). David:..ccccclecsceteasieeredetee P. O. Box 222, Quebec, Canada.
Saunders, Prof. Wrmscessteee eso Experimental Station, Ottawa, Canada.
Shanley, Waltersi2eccuveresssavestos Montreal, Canada.
Thane, |b; Say ka asesecsmacteeseee Ottawa, Ontario, Canada.

Puxtion, HICHATAY,.cesnsvebescrseis;.ee Quebec, Canada.

CONSTITUTION

OF THE

AMERICAN FORESTRY ASSOCIATION.

Arriotr 1. This association shall be known as the American Forestry
Association.

ARTICLE 2. The objects of this association shall be the discussion of subjects
relating to tree-planting, the conservation, management, and renewal of forests,
and the climatic and other influences that affect their welfare; the collection
of forest statistics ; and the advancement of educational, legislative, or other
measures tending to the promotion of these objects. It shall especially en-
deavor to centralize the work done and diffuse the knowledge gained.

ARTICLE 3. Any person may become a member of this association, subject to
approval by the executive committee, by the payment of the annual dues.
The annual dues shall be two dollars. Any member may become, by the pay-
ment of fifty dollars at one time, a life member, and shall not be liable there-
after to annual dues. Any person contributing one hundred dollars to the
permanent fund of the association shall be a Patron. The members of any
local forestry association which shall vote to afiiliate itself with the American
Forestry Association, under such rules as the executive committee may adopt,
shall become, by virtue of their membership in the local association, associate
members of the American Forestry Association, and be entitled to all of the
privileges of regular members, except the right to vote and hold office in the
American Forestry Association.

ArTIcLE 4. The officers of this association, to be elected at the annual meet-
ing, shall be a president, one vice-president for each state, territory, and
province represented in the association, a treasurer, a recording secretary, a
corresponding secretary, and six other persons to serve on the executive com-
mittee. The executive committee shall consist of the president, the vice-
president for the District of Columbia, the treasurer, the two secretaries,
together with the six persons above designated. Three of this committee shall
constitute a quorum. This committee shall choose its own chairman.

Antioie 5. The president shall preside at all meetings of the association
in general session, and in his absence a vice-president shall preside.

ArTicLE 6. The recording secretary shall keep a record of the proceedings

22

of the association, and shall be custodian of all documents, books, and collec-
tions ordered to be preserved.

Arrticte 7. The corresponding secretary shall conduct the correspondence
of the association.

ArTicLE 8. The treasurer shall have charge of all funds, and pay out the
same on the direction of the executive committee.

ArticLe 9. The association at any regular meeting, or its executive com-
mittee in the intervals between its meetings, may appoint such local or special
committees as may be deemed proper, and shall define their duties.

ArtioLEe 10. The annual meeting of the association shall be in the months
of August, September, or October, or at such times and places as shall be
determined by a vote in general session, or by the executive committee.
Special meetings may be called by the executive committee.

ARTICLE 11, At each annual meeting there shall be an election of officers.
for the ensuing year, and they shall remain in office until others are chosen.
In cases of vacancies occurring in the intervals between the annual meetings,
they may be filled by the executive committee until others are selected. In case
of absence of an officer at aregular meeting his place may be deemed vacant.

ArtTIcLe 12. The officers of states, territories, provinces, or local forestry
associations, or their delegates, or the delegates of any Government, may
participate in the proceedings of the association as honorary members.

ArtIcLE 13. This constitution may be amended by a two-thirds vote of the
members present at any annual meeting.

BY-LAWS.

1. Papers or abstracts of papers to be read must be sent two weeks before
any meeting, for classification, to the corresponding secretary.

2. The following classification of subjects is adopted for the reading of
papers :

Section A. Forest planting, forest management, forestry proper, preserva-
tion of forests.

Section B. Forest economy, technology and statistics.

Section CO. Applied science and climatology, general topics.

3. Contributors who are present shall have the preference in reading their
papers.

4. Any member shall be entitled to the privilege of using any books or
documents, not of record, at the discretion of the recording secretary.

SPECIAL MEETINGS

AT

Brooklyn, New York, and in the White Mountains,
New Hampshire.

By invitation of citizens of Brooklyn and of the New Hampshire
Forestry Commission, the Association held meetings August 21 to
27, 1894, consecutively, in Brooklyn and in the White Mountains,
conjointly with the American Association for the Advancement of
Science.

The evening of August 21st was devoted to a lecture by Mr.
Fernow on “The Battle of the Forest.” On the following day,
in the absence of the President, Rev. George W. Minier, one of the
Vice-Presidents, occupied the chair. A number of persons proposed
for membership in the Association were elected.

Mr. J. C. Chapais, delegate from the Province of Quebec, delivered
an address on the condition of the forests in that Province.

Mr. William H. Dall, of the Smithsonian Institution, then spoke
on the Forests of Alaska. His remarks were based upon personal
observations made at various times during the last thirty years.
Prof. J. C. Smock, State Geologist of New Jersey, read a paper on
the forests of that State. He called attention to the geologic division
of the State into five nearly parallel sections with corresponding
forestry conditions. Much of the northern portion of the State
has been to a great extent denuded, so that this section suffers
from droughts and the effect of sweeping winds, seriously affecting
the agricultural interests. The southern or coastal plain region has
a large amount of forest, but it is mostly of a low, scrubby character,
of little commercial value. Forestry in New Jersey, on account of
the water supply, is of vital importance to the large and increasing
population, especially in the neighborhood of Newark and of New
York. The next address was by Mr. Verplanck Colvin, on the
Adirondack Forests.

Mr. Fernow spoke on the Condition of our Public Timber Lands
and Forest Reservations, and offered the following resolution, which
was unanimously adopted:

24

Resolved, That the American Forestry Association desires to express again,
emphatically, its approval of the efforts of the Public Lands Committee of the
House of Representatives, and its chairman, the Hon. Thomas C. McRae, for
the enactment of a law providing not only for thecare and protection but also
for the rational use of the timber and other resources in the forest reservations
and on all public timber lands. The policy of reserving can hardly be con-
sidered an advantage to the forestry interests unless followed up by an
intelligent and efficient administration of the reservations.

This Association emphatically denies that it advocates, in the policy of forest
reservations, the unintelligent exclusion from use of large territories and the
resources contained therein, but, on the contrary, it reiterates that it conceives
the reservations made for the purpose of their rational use, under restrictions
and control, apart from private interests, in expectation of possible occupancy.
If uncared for by the rightful owner, the Government, the door is opened to
greater destruction and depredation than before. We, therefore, desire to im-
press upon our representatives in Congress the immediate necessity of making
provision for the better care of the public timber and other resources, as urged
heretofore by this Association.

After the adoption of the foregoing resolution, the chairman, Mr.
Minier, read a paper on Tree Planting, and the Association took a
recess till afternoon.

At the afternoon session Professor A. D. Hopkins, of West Vir-
ginia, in a discussion of the Relations of Insects and Birds to
Present Forest Conditions, noted the interdependence and mutual
checks of animal and vegetable life under natural conditions, and
pointed out as one of the effects of forest removal in certain dis-
tricts of West Virginia the destructive work of the spruce insects
and pine bark beetle, which afforded an unusual opportunity for the
study of insect life as affecting forest growth, and the utility of
birds as insect destroyers. He controverted the generally accepted
belief that birds are especially useful as the destroyers of noxious
insects, taking the position that they kill as many helpful as harmful
species, and hence have little influence on the problem, one way or
the other.

Professor F. H. King, of Wisconsin, in a paper on Windbreaks,
gave numerous experiments to show the effectiveness of windbreaks
in preventing evaporation from the soil of protected fields, and
urged their great utility, especially in light soils.

Mr. John Gifford, of New Jersey, presented a paper on Forest
Fires in South Jersey. After mentioning the principal causes of
fires, he noted one instance of malicious incendiarism, in which
60,000 acres of timber were burned. Young timber is killed out-
right by these fires, and the vitality of old trees is greatly im-

25

paired. The country has been reduced to a barren condition over
large areas by repeated fires. Two hundred thousand acres of
woodlands have been burned over in the last sixmonths. A recently
enacted fire law will be helpful, and a society for the prevention of
forest destruction has been formed.

Mr. H. C. Hovey, of Massachusetts, in an instructive lecture,
illustrated with lantern slides, on the Petrified Forests of Arizona,
pointed out that these interesting and valuable remnants of former
forest glory were just as rapidly and wantonly destroyed as the
present forests, by grinding them into emery.

Other papers read were as follows: Western Pine Timberlands,
H. C. Putnam, Wisconsin; Prevention of Forest Fires, C. C. An-
drews, Minnesota; Prairie Forestry, L. H. Pammel, Iowa.

Other papers were offered, but for lack of time could only be
read by title.

Thursday, August 23, was given up to an excursion by steam-
boat to West Point on the Hudson, by invitation of the Brooklyn
committee of arrangements.

On Friday evening the Association convened for another meeting,
under the auspices of the New Hampshire Forestry Commission, at
Plymouth, New Hampshire. The Hon. William E. Chandler, Vice-
President of the Association for New Hampshire, presided. After
an address of welcome by the Hon. Geo. H. Adams, the Hon. Jos-
eph B. Walker, of Concord, gave a very full and detailed account
of the history, development, and present condition of the White
Mountain region, embracing the legislation which had been obtained
for the protection of the forests, and the difficulties of preventing
their destruction. Mr. George H. Moses, secretary of the New
Hampshire Forestry Commission, then gave a foretaste of the
scenes awaiting the Association on the following days of the meet-
ing by exhibiting some beautiful lantern slides presenting views of
the mountain region.

On Saturday, August 25, by courtesy of Messrs. Henry and Sons,
the Association was taken to their extensive lumber camps and saw-
mills in the Pemigewasset Valley. From their mills the Associa-
tion went to the Flume House, remaining only long enough for din-
ner and a visit to the “ Flume,” and then took carriages for the Pro-
file House. Here, in the evening, a session was held in the spacious
dining-room, and the guests of the house were invited to be present.
The Hon. Mr. Chandler presided, and made an opening address, in
which he spoke of the reckless methods of the lumbermen in prose-

26

cuting their business. He then introduced Mr. George B. James,
editor of the American Cultivator and president of the New Hamp-
shire Land Company. Mr. James advocated the formation of a
large association or league for the purpose of saving the mountain
forests by purchase. Mr. J. R. Edmunds, representing the Appa-
lachian Club, and Warren Higley, Esq., of New York, representing
the Adirondack League Club, spoke in the same line with Mr.
James. Mr. George T. Crawford, of Boston, for many years a for-
est surveyor, said a good word for the pulp mill owners, saying that
they took only the spruce that was more than twelve inches in
diameter. Mr. Fernow spoke on the different purposes served by
the forests, and urged the great importance of the enactment of
proper fire laws as necessary to forest preservation.

Sunday was by most members of the Association spent quietly at
the Profile House, a portion, however, making an excursion to the
summit of Mount Washington, which was not included in the itine-
rary.

On Monday, August 27, the Association spent the day in going
through the Crawford Notch to Glen Station. Here carriages were
in waiting to convey them*to Wentworth Hall, in the town of Jack-
son. In the evening another and final session was held. Mr. F. H.
Appleton, of Boston, Vice-President for Massachusetts, presided.
Senator Chandler again addressed the Association, some business
matters were attended to, several new members were elected, and
in the absence of Dr. Rothrock, who had been expected to lecture,
Mr. Fernow repeated his lecture on the Battle of the Forest. The
meeting then adjourned after a most enjoyable excursion, and one
which gave unusual opportunity for studying the forests.

N. H. Easton,
Secretary.

Thirteenth Annual Meeting.
1894.

The thirteenth annual meeting of the American Forestry Associa-
tion was held at the Department of Agriculture, Washington, D. C.,
on the 28th day of December, 1894.

In the absence of the President or any of the Vice-Presidents, Mr.
Fernow was appointed chairman. Before the formal business of
the Association was entered upon, by a previous arrangement of the
Executive Committee, the members of the Association present pro-
ceeded to the Executive Mansion to meet the President of the United
States and commend to his favorable consideration and helpful action
the work of the Association for the preservation of the public forests.
The President received the Association with courtesy, listened to
their statements with attention, expressed his increasing interest in
their work, and promised to give whatever assistance was in his
power.

On the return of the Association from the visit to the President,
the Recording Secretary read the minutes of the last annual meet-
ing, which were approved. The Corresponding Secretary then read
his annual report, which was accepted. On motion, a Committee
on Resolutions and Nominations was appointed by the chairman,
consisting of Messrs. Keffer, Owen, Moses, French, and Warder.
The report of the Executive Committee was then read, accepted, and
referred to the Committee on Resolutions and Nominations. A
number of persons were proposed for membership, the names being
referred to the Executive Committee for final action.

A proposal was offered that the Association should hold a special
meeting in California, in connection with the meeting there of the
American Association for the Advancement of Science. This was
favorably referred to the Executive Committee. By request, Prof.
Marcus E. Jones, of Utah, made a statement in regard to the forest
condition of that State. He reported great destruction of the
forests, and said that sheep had injured the grass to a great extent
upon the higher grounds; also had prevented the growth of new
forests. The farmers of Utah are generally opposed to the sheep
industry, as being destructive of the forests. They desire the
establishment of Forest Reserves, especially one around Fish Lake.

28

Mr. Moses spoke in regard to the condition of forestry in New
Hampshire. He said that the Forest Commission are endeavoring
to increase popular interest in the preservation of the mountain
forests, to secure legislation to prevent forest fires, and to induce
lumbermen to use a more rational method of carrying on their work.
Mr. Gifford spoke of the cause of forestry in South New Jersey.
He reported a great destruction of forests by lightning. He said
that some progress was being made in forest education through
the schools and by the publication of a forestry paper. A Forestry
Association has been formed, which has now one hundred members.
Mr. Owen said that the mountains of northern New Jersey had
been stripped of their original forests. Trees now were largely cut
when of the hoop-pole size. The greatest interest now is in regard
to the water supply. An effort is being made to establish county
parks. He said there is probably more worthless timber land in
New Jersey than in any other State.

At the afternoon session the report of the Treasurer was read
and referred to Messrs. Gifford and Luebkert as an auditing com-
mittee. The Committee on Resolutions and Nominations reported
as officers for the ensuing year those now in office, with the follow-
ing changes: Mr. F. H. Newell as Corresponding Secretary in
place of Mr. J. D. W. French, who declined further service as such,
and on the Executive Committee Mr. Keffer in place of Dr. J. D.
Jones, and Prof. R. B. Warder in place of Mr. Newell, elected
Corresponding Secretary.

The Executive Committee were authorized to provide for the ex-
penses of the office of the Corresponding Secretary for the ensuing
year. The Committee on Resolutions and Nominations reported
for adoption the following resolutions:

Resolved, That The American Forestry Association finds reason for encourage-
ment in the increased interest shown in the forestry question during the past
year, and pledges its continued support to every movement tending toward
the enlightenment of the people upon this important subject.

Resolued, That we hereby express our gratification at the passage of the
McRae bill in the lower House of Congress, and tender our thanks to our

associate, the Hon. Thomas C. McRae, for his energetic, well-directed, and
successful endeavors in behalf of the principles for which this Association
stands.

Resolved, That we urge upon the committee of the Senate, to whom the
measure has been referred, to report the same atan early date, with such amend-
ments as may more fully secure the objects of the bill, and we urge upon the
whole body of Senators the necessity of passing the same without delay.

Ttesolved, ‘That we recommend national legislation looking toward the estab-

29

lishment of courses of instruction in forestry in such institutions as are bene-
fited by aid from the public treasury, and the establishment of a National
Forestry School in some part of the national domain.

Resolved, That the appalling results of forest fires experienced in many
States during the past summer compel the belief that the present statutory
protection against forest fires in these States is inadequate or negligently ap-
plied. And we appeal, therefore, to these States, in the interest of rational
husbandry and in the name of humanity, to enact and enforce such legislation
as will prevent the recurrence of such serious loss of life and property.

The resolutions were adopted and referred to the Executive Com-
mittee for publication and for distribution to various State officials.
The Committee on Resolutions and Nominations reported back for
adoption the reports of the Corresponding Secretary and the Execu-
tive Committee, and they were adopted. On motion, it was

Resolved, That the Association takes pleasure in expressing its thanks to Mr. J.
D. W. French for his earnestness and fidelity in discharging the duties of Cor-

responding Secretary, and his kindness in giving his services under the disad-
vantages of his situation and other demands upon his time and attention.

A sketch of a bill for the establishment of a Post Graduate School
of Forestry in connection with the Division of Forestry in the De-
partment of Agriculture was offered informally for the consideration
of the Association. The subject was discussed briefly with much
interest by Messrs. French, Newell, and Ledyard.

The Auditing Committee reported that the account of the Treas-
urer had been examined and found to be correct. At 5 o’clock the
Association adjourned, subject to the call of the Executive Com-
mittee. In the evening a joint meeting with the National Geo-
graphic Society was held, to listen to an address by Prof. N. 8.
Shaler, of Harvard University, upon the Economic Aspects of

Erosion.
N. H. Eaeueston,

Secretary.

Special Meeting at Springfield, Mass.
1895.

The Association held its summer meeting for 1895 at Springfield,
Massachusetts, on September 4th and 5th, in connection with the
American Association for the Advancement of Science.

The President of this Association, the Hon. J. Sterling Morton,
Secretary of Agriculture, was prevented by official business from
attending, but sent his regards, together with expressions of deep
interest in the objects of the meeting.

Capt. Francis H. Appleton, Vice-President for Massachusetts,
presided and opened the session by a brief address detailing the
condition of forestry in Massachusetts and referring to the action
of the State Board of Agriculture through its Forestry Division.
The first business was the appointment of Messrs. Fernow, Higley,
Moses, Walker, and Appleton as a Committee on Resolutions to
report at the end of the session. The Hon. G. F. Talbot, of Maine,
made an address in which he advocated that all worthless lands for-
feited by tax sales be permanently held by the State and devoted to
the purpose of the production of trees, such lands being admirably
adapted to this end. He spoke of the fire laws of Maine and stated
that the adverse interests of forest owners was the great obstacle
to any reform in the direction of proper control. Under a sharp
competition the land was stripped of everything salable and the
refuse left where it happened to fall, thus ultimately becoming,
through its inflammability, a menace to all neighboring property.

Mr. George H. Moses, Secretary of the New Hampshire Forestry
Commission, reviewed the history of legislative attempts to provide
suitable protection to the forests, and spoke of the creation of the
present Commission, organized to investigate the extent and char-
acter of the forest cover, the removal of lumber, the annual receipts,
and the general relations of forests to climate, water, and health.
The commissioners are empowered simply to investigate, but much
of their energy has been given to attempts to convince the lumber-
men that it is for their personal interests as well as that of the State
to introduce less wasteful and destructive methods. They are also
striving to preserve some of the natural beauties of the White Moun-

31

tain region, as the summer resorts, if destroyed or injured, will
cause great annual loss to the State.

Hon. Joseph B. Walker, of Concord, New Hampshire, followed
with a description of the present condition of the forests, especially
those in the northern portion of the State. Here large areas are
owned by individuals whose sole object is to make the most money
in the shortest period, and who have no interest in obtaining a future
crop of trees. Everything is cut that can be sold, either for lum-
bér or matches. Vast sections are denuded one after the other,
the fires in the “slasings ” sweeping the ground clean after the lum-
bermen have left. There is a beginning, mainly from the senti-
mental side, to make an attempt to prevent this great destruction,
and the fire laws have been so improved that the selectmen or
county commissioners are required to appoint fire wardens, whose
duties include the watching for fires and the summoning of aid to
prevent their spread. No penalty for failure is provided, but popu-
lar sentiment is being aroused to such an extent as to render the
law generally effective. The farmer is beginning to appreciate the
necessity of the*forests, as these, if properly managed, will furnish
him opportunity for labor during the winter months. At present
he labors seven months of the year, and from his farm alone cannot
derive revenue for the remaining five months.

Rey. Julius H. Ward, of the editorial staff of the Boston Herald,
read a paper on the present situation in the White Mountains. He
noted the increased regard being expressed by lumbermen for the
young trees which ultimately should become valuable for lumber.
He described the ordinary operations, and stated that the com-
panies now at work in the White Mountains expected to cut every-
thing before them, not leaving a stick of any value.

Mr. Charles Eliot, of the firm of Olmsted, Olmsted & Eliot,
of Brookline, Mass., read a paper on the new public forests near
Boston, illustrating this by maps of the locations of these forests
and described their general characteristics. The most important
of these public reservations is the Blue Hills area, consisting mainly
of rugged hills and swamps. Next in importance are the Middle-
sex Falls, and besides these are numerous smaller localities notable
for the beauty of their scenery. The chief enemy to these is fire,
and, to guard against this, the larger reservations are blocked out
into fire districts, and watchmen employed to patrol the grounds.

Mr. E. H. Forbush, Director of Field Work of the Gypsy Moth
Department of the Massachusetts Board of Agriculture, spoke of

32

the work in confining this insect pest within certain limits. It
originated in specimens imported by an entomologist, these escap-
ing and multiplying until the trees and bushes within many towns
were destroyed as completely as by fire. By means of sufficient
appropriations it would be possible to exterminate this insect, but
Massachusetts has only granted a sum sufficient to hold it in check.
Thus there is constant danger that the moth may escape and start
new colonies in every direction. If allowed to spread it may over-
run the whole country. He stated that the native birds will not
eat the eggs of this insect, but that possibly some foreign birds
which eat the eggs in their own country might be imported.

Mr. Cornelius C. Vermeule, of the New Jersey Geological Survey,
read a paper upon forests and rivers, this relating mainly to the
conditions within the State of New Jersey, reference being made to
data from Massachusetts, New York, and Pennsylvania. In his
conclusions he stated that the river measurements failed to indi-
cate any notable effect of forests upon evaporation or upon the
very highest or lowest rate of flow. The measurements do show
what is quite as important, namely, a more equable flow, fewer
floods, and shorter periods of extreme low water upon well forested
catchments. Some of Mr. Vermeule’s conclusions were called in
question by Mr. Fernow as not being applicable beyond the areas
studied.

Hon. Warren Higley, of New York, spoke of the progress of leg-
islation in his State, and described the inception and growth of the
Adirondack Park. The lands within the Park limits are being ac-
quired by the State through tax sales or by purchase, excepting
such as are owned or controlled by clubs or corporations whose in-
terests in forest protection are identical with those of the State. It
was the original intention to manage this Park upon rational prin-
ciples and dispose of the ripe trees for timber wherever this could
be done without injury, but the Constitutional Convention adopted
& provision against the sale of any timber upon lands owned or to
be acquired by the State, the people thus putting themselves upon
record as being able to buy and maintain these forests without the
aid of revenue from the sale of forest products.

Colonel William Fox, Superintendent in charge of the State For-
ests, briefly described the organization of the commission under
which he is employed, and stated that it was the intention to pur-
chase 80,000 acres as soon as possible. The forests could undoubt-
edly be improved by cutting, but, since this was prohibited by the

33

constitution, a rational system of forestry must be held in abey-
ance for the present.

Prof. J. C. Smock, State Geologist of New Jersey, stated that
some of the largest land holdings in that part of the country are
in southern New Jersey. The Geological Survey is performing, to
a certain extent, some of the functions of a forest commission and
is making examinations as to the relation of forests to water supply
and sanitary conditions. The agricultural interests are as a rule
subordinate in New Jersey to the question of water supply,
especially in the northern part of the State, where are situated the
great metropolitan districts. For the southern part the main
source of anxiety is the forest fires, one of these alone having
burned over and destroyed probably a million dollars’ worth of
lumber and other property. Such a fire leaves only the bare white
sand, destroying even the soil.

Baron Beno Reinhardt von Herman, Chamberlain to the King of
Wurtemberg, Forestry Councillor and at present Attaché for For-
estry and Agriculture to the German Legation, read a brief address
upon forestry management in Germany, and spoke of the special
education of the foresters in colleges devoted to this purpose, and
their subsequent training by practical experience in the woods.

The remaining papers on the program for Tuesday were not read
owing to the absence of their authors. Adjournment was taken
till Wednesday, September 4th.

On Wednesday morning, September 4th, the session was called
to order by Vice-President Appleton, the first paper being by Mr.
T. S. Gold, Secretary of the Board of Agriculture of Connecticut.
He spoke of the causes tending to re-establish wood growth in his
State, these being mainly the decrease of profit in wood cutting,
owing to the extinction of the iron furnaces. Many trees are being
set by the roadside and the State has enacted legislation protecting
such trees. Spikes having the letter ““C” in the head are to be pro-
vided, and when driven into one of the roadside or shade trees this
spike must not be removed even by the owner, and any destruction
or injury to the tree is punishable by a heavy penalty. The
drought of the past year has destroyed many trees, especially the
chestnut, resulting in widespread injury to woodlands.

Dr. B. G. Northrop, of Clinton, Connecticut, described the inter-
est shown in Arbor Day in the Hawaiian Islands and in Japan, at
the time of his visit to those countries. In Japan the Emperor’s
birthday has been designated as Arbor Day, memorial trees being

34

planted in his honor. Great enthusiasm was expressed and inter-
est shown in the reclamation of sea-coast and the planting of the
sand dunes.

A letter from the Hon. J. Sterling Morton, President of the
Association, was read. This called attention to the necessity of
urging upon the States legislation compelling the proper care of
waste from timber cutting in order to prevent forest fires. Mr.
Morton also wrote of the necessity of bringing about co-operation
between the United States Geological Survey and the Forestry
Division of the Agricultural Department, in order that during the
preparation of the topographic map the forest areas might be prop-
erly represented. He showed that by slight additional expense it
would be possible for an expert to classify the woodlands while the
map was being made, and obtain the material for a report upon the
condition and value of the forests, and the steps to be taken for the
proper protection or treatment of these resources. By this means
the completed map would show not only the altitude and slopes of
the country, the roads, trails, and improvements, but also the char-
acter and extent of the timber.

Mr. F. H. Newell, Secretary of the Association, spoke of the
progress of the great map of the United States now being prepared
by the United States Geological Survey, and described the methods
of representing wooded areas, dwelling upon the benefits which
would follow the more accurate designation of timber lands. By
suitable co-operation with the Agricultural Department, it might be
possible to concentrate efforts upon the areas covered by the
national forest reservations and complete the mapping and descerip-
tion of these within a few years. Remarks were made by Messrs.
Talbot, Moses, Elwyn, Pinchot, Smock, and others, showing the
inaccuracy of the present information concerning the forests and
the difficulties of obtaining exact facts through local officials.

Mr. George T. Powell, of Ghent, New York, spoke upon the
benefit to the farmers of the preservation of forest areas. He stated
that too many unproductive acres are now cultivated, and that in
the Eastern States often the cost of production exceeded the value
received. By tilling a smaller number of acres with greater care
and devoting the poorer lands to the growth of timber far larger
results might be obtained.

At this point Mr. Appleton resigned the chair to Hon. Warren
Higley, Vice-President for New York. A discussion was entered
into as to the necessity and value to this Association of a forestry

35

journal. This was participated in by Messrs. Fernow, Newell,
Talbot, Ward, and Pinchot, the general opinion being that such a
journal was highly desirable, provided the editorial and business
management could be undertaken by any competent person. On mo-
tion of Dr. G. B. Northrop, the matter was referred to the Execu-
tive Committee, with power to act.

Mr. B. E. Fernow, Chief of the Forestry Division, at the begin-
ning of the afternoon session made a statement as to the progress
in national forestry legislation, and reviewed the history of attempts
made in the past to secure passage of bills endorsed by this Asso-
ciation.

Mr. R. U. Johnson, of the Century Magazine, then spoke of the
action of the New York Chamber of Commerce and Board of Trade,
and urged the advisability of endorsing the resolution of that body
calling for the creation by Congress of a Forestry Commission, con-
sisting of three persons, empowered to examine into the forest con-
ditions of the country.

Mr. Gifford Pinchot then read a paper upon the present condition
of the national forests and the necessity of action in protecting them.
He held that, since past efforts of this Association had been in a large
degree ineffectual, the proper method of procedure was through
a Forest Commission such as that proposed by Mr. Johnson. His
views were strongly controverted by Mr. B. E. Fernow on the ground
that the time was ripe for action rather than for investigation, and
that Congress would be more likely to consider legislation already
discussed during the past session rather than take a backward step
in the appointment of a commission. The matter was urged by
Messrs. Johnson and Pinchot, and under a suspension of the rules
the following resolution was adopted:

Resolved, That we, this Association, join with the New York Chamber of Com-
merce and Board of Trade in hearty advocacy of the establishment of a Forestry
Commission of three members to make a thorough investigation of the public
forest lands, and to make recommendations concerning their disposition and

treatment, and the Executive Committee is hereby directed to represent the
Association in support of such legislation.

Prof. Dwight Porter, of the Massachusetts Institute of Tech-
nology, read a paper upon the fluctuations of water supply in Con-
necticut river and the possible connection between these and forest
removal. His general conclusion was that, as far as the flow of the
lower river is concerned, there is no proof of permanent injury
through cutting of the forests at the head waters. Mr. Talbot called

36

attention to the fact that, taking the basin as a whole, there might be
at present as much growing timber as formerly, since on this point
there are no statistics available.

Mr. Leonard W. Ross, of Boston, read a paper upon sea-coast
planting as practised on the Province lands of Cape Cod, and de-
scribed the attempts being made to prevent the shifting sands at
the extremity of Cape Cod from injuring the settlements and har-
bor. He spoke of the various kinds of grasses and shrubs which
have been planted to hold the sands, and of the results attained,
and exhibited specimens showing the cutting of twigs due to the
sand carried by the wind.

Mr. H. C. Bliss, of Springfield, Massachusetts, read a description
of methods of planting trees in the vicinity of his city. He has
planted an average of 100 trees a year for over twelve years, and
has had great success in thus adding to the beauty of the various
streets. He described his methods and offered many practical sug-
gestions.

Mr. John M. Woods, of Boston, Massachusetts, described the
changes in the hard-wood trade during the past thirty years, and
spoke of the uses of the more valuable of the ornamentdl woods
native in the eastern and southern parts of the United States.

Hon. G. F. Talbot presented a formal invitation from the Goy-
ernor of Maine and the Mayor of Portland, inviting the Association
to hold a meeting at Portland, Maine, during the next summer.
Invitations were referred to the Executive Committee for action.

The Committee on Resolutions then made its formal report, and
the following resolutions were adopted paragraph by paragraph,
after which the Association adjourned :

Resolved, That the American Forestry Association learns with satisfaction of
the recent enactment of laws for the protection of forest property against de-
struction by fire in Wisconsin and Minnesota, and of the successful operation
of such laws in Maine, New Hampshire, and New York, deprecating at the same
time the continuance of forest destruction by fire in other States, and especially
on the publie domain.

That the question of dealing with forest fires is still the first and most

important one to be settled in nearly all the States of the Union before rational
forestry methods can become practicable.

That inasmuch as forestry property is taxed for the support of government,
it has the same right to consideration and protection as other property, and
that the legislatures of the different States which have no efficient forest-fire
laws are recommended to provide the same.

That the policy of establishing forest reservations and parks is to be encour-
aged, and for the purpose it is recommended that timber lands offered for sale

37

for non-payment of taxes be acquired by the State and held to form the nucleu
of State forest reservations. :

That it is the first duty of Congress in regard to the public timber lands to
enact proper legislation for the national protection and administration of the
forest reservations and unreserved timber lands, and we appeal to the Public
Lands Committees of the Senate and House of Representatives to secure the
passage of bills which received the sanction of the Senate and House of Rep-
resentatives in the 53d Congress, and failed to become laws only for lack of
time for consideration of amendments in conference.

That the American Forestry Association, recognizing that a practical advance
in rational forestry methods requires the services of men trained in forestry
practice, indorse the legislation proposed in the last Congress by Mr. Hainer,
and expresses the hope that the same will be enacted during the coming Con-
gress.

That the knowledge of the extent and conditions of our forest resources is a
necessary basis for intelligent forest legislation, and that therefore the Ameri-
can Forestry Association recommends the co-operation of various Government
departments as far as practicable in ascertaining these areas and conditions,
and especially recommends that both a topographic and forestal survey of
National Forest Reserves be instituted.

F. H. Newe tt,
Corresponding Secretary.

Fourteenth Annual Meeting,
1896.

The fourteenth annual meeting of the American Forestry Asso-
ciation was held in Washington, D. C., on the 24th day of January,
1896. In the absence of the President and Vice-Presidents, Mr.
Fernow was chosen chairman.

The report of the Corresponding Secretary was read showing,
among other things, the election of 192 new members during the
last year. The report was accepted and approved, with the sug-
gestion that in publishing a list of the members their geographical
location be designated.

The report of the Treasurer was read, accepted, and referred to
Messrs. O. J. J. Luebkert and G. B. Sudworth as an auditing com-
mittee.

As the report of the Treasurer has not been published for a num-
ber of years, the following abstract has been prepared covering the
expenses and receipts for the entire period since date of the report
printed on page 32 of volume VIII:

Henry M. Fisher, Treasurer, in account with American Forestry Association.

Dr.
Dec. 30, 1890. Balance to credit of current expenseS...... ....csseseeee $136 20
Balance to credit life membership fund................00+ 550 00
Dec. 28, 1891. Receipts from life memberships, interest $12.87....... 262 87
Annual dues and contributions, interest $4.33 ......... 453 33
Dec. 29, 1892. Receipts from life memberships, interest $20.49....... 120 49
Annual dues and contributions, interest $5.37......... 388 37
Receipts from sale of proceedingS............2ssceeeeceeees 1 00
Dec. 20, 1893. Annual dues and contributions, interest $11.36....... 357 11
Receipts from sale of proceedings, etc. ..... ....seeeeeee 4 00
Dec. 27, 1894. General Secretary fund, interest $29.02 .............000 1,023 11
Receipts from life memberships, interest $58.34...... 258 34
Annual dues and contributions, interest $9.94......... 684 19
Receipts from sale of proceedings, etC..........004seeee 5 00
Dec. 28, 1895. Interest on general Secretary fund............ssecesesseees 40 37
Receipts from life memberships, interest $34.98...... 384 98
Annual dues and contributions .. ...........000. eenstaneeee 1,072 50
Interest on U. 8; bondl.,.05. ssvcs svsesccetsaccaeeeeene 75 00
Receipts from sale of proceedings..........ccsecseesseeeeees 10 10

$5,726 86

39

Cr.

Dec. 28, 1891. Expenses for printing, postage, CtC.......-s000:sseeeeseeees $409 69
Dec. 29, 1892. Postage, $26.24; stationery, $24.80............c:ceeeceeeee 51 04
RUMI, «asc 0are spneve san nu cbesenashacdacabnn next sa: salegnesy § veaehh 48 83

Type-writing, $33.90 ; advertising, $10.00; sundries,
Pedy cesses sgt concsessudue ras popabe pas sadendaewasaanaeeeperd> «3 70 65
Forest Leaves........++. Se pa ee as 36 56

Dec. 15, 1898. Postage, $24.70; type-writing, $32.15; papers,
LOO peeecay on aren dccca ten ude en aseeeb eee damien Sirhddeansyersloncces 72 66
PPP jaan nok cance. secag> setae eee LS) 20 10
Forest Leaves, 1892 audi 1893, 3,297 copies at 8 cents, 263 76
Painting for World’s Fair.. apie eer aaseces 50 00
Counsel before Oomnbitteds on EPablic Tend. voatinas apa 125 00
Dec. 31, 1894. Postage, stationery, and Expressage.........s0..-ssee-eeees 128 41
Printing proceedings, circulars, CtC..........sessesesseeees 400 80
Forest Leaves, 1894, 2,272 copies at 8 cents............. 181 76
Type-writing, $9.50; clerical service, $49.78.......... 59 28
Dec. 31, 1895. Postage, $143.74; stationery, $21.15................scee0e 164 89
Printing proceedings, CbC..2..02....2c..cccssscse ecces ccescee 393 70
MELO Gr PCAC a arencananscscsel teieaesinca aces secancaaresdaescstie 223 04

Clerical services ($60.74, $183.36), Secretary’s travel-
PTET GR ONSORY aac decades -csaaeeuntes ssenacctnsas sencbv sec cers 269 10
Advertising, $8.00, express, CfC...........ccccsccscsesesces 12 81

Bonds 2, $1,000, U. S. 5’s ($1,053.80 from general
MUCLOLALY ACCOUND)'- cece tavesdseevenesoscuecesnas'sstasseasce 2,297 50
Balance current expense account........ ..cesesseee seeee 114 30
Balance life membership account............sscsceceeseeees 332 98

$5,726 86

The report of the Executive Committee was then read as follows:

The year has witnessed a very considerable increase of interest in the for-
estry movement, which is reflected not only by a large increase in the mem-
bership of our Association and by a more general appreciation of our efforts in
the press (and more especially the lumber trade journals), but also by definite
progress in the establishment of forestry principles in various parts of the
country.

Of more interest to us directly is the progress in the establishment of a
rational policy with reference to the public timber lands.

At the last annual meeting, occurring during the Christmas holidays, it was
a pleasant duty to announce the passage by the House of Representatives of
the McRae bill, which provides for an administration of the forest reservations.
The passage had been secured through the efforts of our fellow-member, the
Hon. Thomas C. McRae, after accepting various compromises with the wishes of
western representatives, which, while somewhat weakening the efficiency of the
legislation, left the principle underlying it clear and undisguised.

The same bill essentially was passed in the Senate with various additional
amendments, some desirable and some objectionable. Unfortunately, how-

40

ever, the form in which the amendments were made, namely, by striking out
from the bill passed by the House all after the enacting clause and substituting
the same reading with additions, made it appear like a new bill. Hence, in the
unfortunate absence of the Chairman of the House Committee, who would
have recognized the disguise, the Senate bill was sent back to the Public
Lands Committee instead of going to conference, where the differences could
have been adjusted and the enactment as a law made possible. Further action
was precluded by the adjournment of Congress.

In the present Congress the same bills, slightly modified, have been intro-
duced in each house, namely, 8. 914, by Senator Teller, and H. R. 119, by Mr,
McRae, securing the same number which it had during the last Congress.

It is hoped that the fact that these bills were passed in the two houses of the
former Congress will naturally aid in securing their enactment as a law in the
present. The consent of the Chairmen of the Public Lands Committee both
of the Senate and the House to address the present meeting with reference to
this legislation lends additional hope for this long-desired action. Meanwhile
not much activity has been exercised in securing an extension of the forest
reservations, since without proper administration, sought through the legisla-
tion referred to, such an extension did not appear especially desirable to the
executive officers of the Department of the Interior. There are, however, a
number of proposals for reservations prepared, to be brought forward when
the administration feature has been provided. The discovery of valuable ore
deposits on some of the reservations, and the consequent attempt to have them
returned to the public lands for entry under the laws relating to mineral lands,
makes the passage of a law regulating the use and occupancy of all reserva-
tions the more urgent.

While, then, in national matters a slow but sure advance has been made,
several States have also progressed towards a more rational forest policy.

In Pennsylvania the splendid campaign of the Pennsylvania Forestry Asso-
ciation has resulted in the permanent establishment of the office of Forest Com-
missioner in connection with the Department of Agriculture, and the appoint-
ment of Professor Rothrock to the position has placed the movement upon a
business basis as far the State is concerned. From New Jersey comes encour-
aging news regarding the growth of the State Forestry Association, which is
accentuated by the establishment on a permanent basis of a journal, The For-
ester, appearing in bimonthly issues and promising in interest and general
character.

The two States of Minnesota and Wisconsin, alarmed by the disastrous fires
of the preceding year, were induced to pass forest-fire legislation proposed by
the Forestry Associations of the respective States—one the oldest, the other
the youngest of such associations. In Minnesota a special forest-fire warden,
one of our charter members, is active in organizing the fire service, while in
Wisconsin the function is unfortunately assigned to an officer already charged
with other duties.

The Forest Commission of New Hampshire continues its laudable efforts to
lay the basis for a permanent forest policy of the State. The Forest Commis-
sioner of Maine, in addition to exercising the functions of a fire warden, issues
a valuable report with studies of the mercantile side of forest growth in that

41

State. New York has increased the area of the Adirondack reserve by purchase
of 75,000 acres.

For the Southern States an opportunity was had at the Cotton States and
International Exposition to present not only the wealth and varied character
of their forest resources, but also their condition, their reckless exploitation
and the evil consequences of irrational deforestation, in a specially constructed
forestry building, awakening the interest of her own people as well as of North-
ern visitors.

This exhibit, at which the American Forestry Association was properly rep-
resented, has been pronounced the most instructive and attractive of its kind
ever seen in this country.

From the far West we hear of a growing appreciation of a needed change in
the national forest policy, and although in Colorado and California no return
to the official recognition of the abandoned State policy can be noted, the inter-
est seems more generally diffused among the people. Utah has entered among
the States having forestry associations, and from Montana indications come of
the possibility of establishing one.

Two special meetings were held during the year; the one, a peripatetic meet-
ing, in May, in connection with and at the invitation of the New Jersey Forestry
Association, was designed to inspect the encroachment of the sand dunes, as a
result of destruction of the protecting forest cover, which damage many of the
seaside resorts of the lower coast, and also to give an impetus to the efforts of
securing protection against the forest fires which ravage the plains of that State.

The other meeting was held at the invitation of citizens of Springfield, Mass.,
in connection with the meeting of the American Association for the Advance-
ment of Science, advantage being taken of the presence of many scientific and
influential men. At this meeting the Executive Committee was instructed to
exert itself in securing the appointment of a commission to investigate and
report on the conditions of the public timber lands, as a basis for further leg-
islation. It was, however, decided by the Executive Committee that such a
move would be prejudicial to the passage of the definite legislation now before
Congress. The Secretary of the Interior, however, who again in his annual
report refers in strong language to the need of a change in policy with regard
to the public timber lands, has proposed to submit the question to the National
Academy of Sciences, the legally constituted adviser of the Government on
matters scientific, asking for an expression of opinion on the need and manner
of such a change.

With all this quiet but persistent growth of the forestry movement, the Ex-
ecutive Committee feels that greater responsibility comes to the Association and
its officers.

The work of the Secretary is growing more and more burdensome, and it may
hardly be expected that it can be much longer carried on by a busy man in
jeisure hours. The need of a paid Secretary, urged again and again, becomes
more apparent as we grow, but so far the Executive Committee has not felt jus-
tified in making an appropriation for this purpose. If, however, the mem-
bership, by the exertion of the present members, increases at the rate of the
past year, it is expected that the current income of the Association will
presently permit this most desirable departure.

42

It has also been the subject of consideration in the Executive Committee and
at the Springfield meeting, whether in addition or instead of the volume of
Annual Proceedings the publication of a regular monthly or bimonthly journal
would not be a desirable—nay, necessary—policy, in order to keep the member-
ship informed and interested in the progress of the movement.

At present the members are supplied with Forest Leaves under contract with
the Pennsylvania Forestry Association, but as the movement grows in Pennsyl-
vania that journal, by necessity, must give more and more space to local con-
ditions and questions, losing thereby partially in interest to our members in
other sections.

The appearance of The Yorester in the neighboring State of New Jersey
would make it appear that the field of journalism in forestry was by no means
exhausted; but, while these journals may readily satisfy a local constituency, it
is thought that a publication from the National Association should have a dif-
ferent character, and one more difficult to determine.

Garden and Forest, while an admirable journal, devotes a preponderant space
to the first subject of its title, and cannot be expected to fill the object of the
contemplated publication.

Diffidence in our ability to sustain without a paid editor a high-class journal,
which would satisfy the needs both of intercourse with our membership and
with the general public regarding the forestry movement and give instruction
on technical matters that would be welcome to those who desire to apply
forestry principles in practice, has deterred the committee from launching such
an enterprise. It is, however, proposed to begin with the present year the
issue of a series of bulletins, appearing more or less regularly, which shall test
the practicability and desirability of a more regular publication.

Another matter of important internal organization has come before the com-
mittee, namely, the need of a plan for affiliation with the various State organ-
izations.

From the inception of the National Forestry Congress and the organization
of the American Forestry Association in 1882 it has been the policy of this As-
sociation to encourage the formation of State Forestry Associations; and the
meetings of this Association have been held again and again with this object in
view. While in this way local interest could be best secured, no definite plan
of co-operation or relationship between the mother and daughter associations °
was developed. The absence of such a plan of affiliation has become more no-
ticeable of late, and a committee has been appointed to formulate a plan, which
it is proposed to bring before the present meeting.

The difficulties that originally surrounded the incorporation of the Associa-
tion under the national law, namely, lack of sufficient members resident within
the District of Columbia, has been happily overcome, and the articles of incor-
poration are now drawn up, and only await the formalities attendant on filing to
make the Association a body corporate.

In submitting this report your Executive Committee feels that the Association
and the public are to be congratulated upon the progress within the year, and
the rich promise of the immediate future. Increased efforts are demanded on
our part with the growth of the forestry movement; the membership should
be doubled within the next year, a watchful interest should be sustained in

43

matters relating to State and national legislation, and above all the Association
should further in every possible way all efforts to disseminate information of
what constitutes rational forestry.

For the Executive Committee,
B. E. Frernow,

Chairman.

The report was accepted and made the basis of a discussion of
the various subjects embodied in it. Prominent among these was
that of effecting an affiliation of the Association with the State as-
sociations. A subcommittee of the Executive Committee to which
this subject had been assigned for consideration had made a report,
which the Executive Committee brought to the consideration of the
Association. This embodied an amendment to the constitution as
necessary in order to carry out the proposed plan of affiliation.
After considerable discussion of the plan, it was referred to the
Committee on Resolutions.

The subject of issuing a monthly or less frequent publication was
then considered. The discussion resulted in showing a general
opinion that an endeavor should be made to effect the consolidation
of existing publications before undertaking the issue of another of
similar character, and the subject was referred to the Committee on
Resolutions.

On motion, it was voted that a Committee on Resolutions be ap-
pointed, to consist of not less than five members, and a Committee
on Nominations, not to exceed three. Messrs. French, Smock, Moses,
Binney, Ledyard, and Keffer were appointed as the Committee on
Resolutions, and Messrs. Bowers, McLanahan, and Newell the Com-
mittee on Nominations.

Mr. Egleston in a brief address declined a re-election as Record-
ing Secretary.

AFTERNOON SESSION.

The Committee on Resolutions reported the following resolu-
tions:

Resolved, That the subject of the publication of a forestry journal be re-
ferred to the Executive Committee with full powers. The Executive Com-
mittee, however, is requested, before coming to any final decision, to corre-
spond with the managers of Garden and Forest, Forest Leaves, The Forester,
of New Jersey, and other papers published in the interest of forestry, to see
if any measures can be adopted for the publication of a forestry paper repre-
senting the interests of all concerned.

Resolved, That the Executive Committee is requested to send circulars to all
the Vice-Presidents and prominent members of the American Forestry Associa-

44

tion in each State and Territory where there is no local forestry organization,
asking that a meeting be called annually of all the members resident in such
respective State or Territory for the purpose of forming a section or branch of
the American Forestry Association, to promote closer relationship with the
National Association by advocating such measures as are set forth in its con-
stitution or may be adopted at any time by vote, and also to increase the mem-
bership of our society.

The foregoing resolutions were discussed and adopted.

The committee also reported an amendment to the constitution,
Article 3, which, after discussion and amendment, was adopted as
follows:

‘‘The members of any local forestry association which shall vote to affiliate
itself with the American Forestry Association, under such rules as the Execu-
tive Committee may adopt, may become, by virtue of their membership in the
local association, associate members of the American Forestry Association, and
be entitled to all of the privileges of regular members, except the right to vote
and hold office in the American Forestry Association.”

The following resolutions were reported by the committee and
adopted:

Resolved, That we recognize in House Bill No. 119, introduced in the present
Congress, the principles of genuine forestry for which we have long contended,
and we urge upon Congress the speedy passage of a bill to accomplish the
objects contemplated therein.

Resolved, That we note with satisfaction the enactment of laws in the States
of Minnesota and Wisconsin for the prevention of forest fires, and we express
our hope that similar legislation, adapted especially to local needs, may soon
be enacted in other States where the interests of the forest demand it.

The Committee on Nominations reported a list of officers to be
appointed for the ensuing year. Their nomination was approved
and officers were elected, as shown on page 3.

The following resolution was offered by the Committee on Reso-
lutions:

Resolved, That the thanks of this Association are hereby extended to Dr. N.
H. Egleston for his long and faithful service as Recording Secretary of the
Association.

The resolution was adopted.

Mr. Birkinbine offered the following, which was adopted:

Resolved, That the American Forestyy Association desires to express its ap-
preciation of the excellent display of forest interests at the Atlanta Exposition
by the U. 8. Department of Agriculture.

Several persons were proposed for election as members of the
Association. Their nomination was referred to the Executive Com-
mittee for action.

45

The Auditing Committee reported that they had examined the
accounts of the Treasurer and found them to be correct.

The subject of special meetings of the Association, in connection
with an invitation from Portland, Maine, was considered, and, with
the annual meeting, was referred to the Executive Committee for
decision.

The Association adjourned subject to call of the Executive Com-

mittee.
N. H. Eatezsron,

Secretary.

In the evening a joint meeting was held with the National Geo-
graphic Society, at Metzerott Hall. Hon. J. Sterling Morton pre-
sided and made a brief address, and then introduced in order the
speakers of the evening: Hon. Fred. T. Dubois, Chairman of the
Senate Committee on Public Lands, Hon. John F. Lacey, Chair-
man of the Committee on Public Lands of the House of Represent-
atives, Hon. Thomas C. McRae, and Mr. William E. Smythe, of
Chicago, Ill., President of the National Colonial Clubs.

REMARKS OF

FHion. J. STHERLING MORTON,

SECRETARY OF AGRICULTURE AND PRESIDENT OF AMERICAN
Forestry ASSsocraTION.

[At the Joint Meeting of American Forestry Association and Na-
tional Geographic Society, January 24, 1896.]

During the 20 years from 1875 to 1894 American farmers sup-
plied nearly twelve billion dollars in value for foreign markets, or
more than 75 per cent. of all the exports of the United States—the
result of labor and skill applied to the cultivation of the soil. Dur-
ing the same 20 years American axemen cut down enough trees to
make lumber and timber for export of a value approximating 500
million dollars, or 25 million dollars per year—the result of labor and
skill applied to the despoliation of our rich inheritance in forest
wealth without thought of reproduction. This export has increased
in later years, reaching a maximum in 1890 with near 294 million
dollars, and averaging more than 28 million dollars since.

These figures are mere indices of the vast areas of land which
have been culled or denuded simply for the purpose of export. It

46

is no exaggeration to say that, since such materials must be of a
high grade of quality, the 500 million dollars paid to the exporters of
forest products in these 20 years represent the spoliation of wood-
land equal to as much as one-fifth of all remaining forest growth in
the United States ; while home consumption, which is estimated to
equal in value each year this large export figure for the 20 years
referred to, must needs hasten this process of exhausting our tim-
ber wealth at a still more alarming rate.

It is needful, therefore, that the American Forestry Association
reinforce itself with zeal and intelligent members in behalf of forest
conservation and also of reforestation in some sections of the Union.
Loss of soil by erosion and consequent sterility are visible in each
one of the older States as a result of inconsiderate devastation of
the forest cover on the slopes. In Ohio there are reported to be
more than a million of acres of land now unproductive and unused,
which have been defertilized in this manner. While no estimates
are at hand to enable me to give a grand total of the lands which
have been destroyed and rendered infertile throughout the United
States, it is well known that the evil is wide-spread and the area
must be enormous. It is time that as a nation we do something
that will arrest this loss of our very bases of existence.

Permit me to quote from Irving, as a conclusion to these some- *
what arid statements, that—

“There is something noble, simple, and pure in a taste for the
cultivation of forest trees. It argues, I think, a sweet and generous
nature to have this strong relish for the beauties of vegetation, and
this friendship for the hardy and glorious sons of the forest. He
who plants an oak looks forward to future generations and plans
for posterity. Nothing can be less selfish than this.”

And from another citizen of this Republic, who said with great
vigor of truth: ,

“Keeping up a fit proportion of forests to arable land is the
prime condition of human health. If trees go, men must decay.
Whosoever works for the forests works for the happiness and _per-
manence of our civilization. Now is the time to work, if we are to
be blessed and not cursed by the people of the twentieth and twenty-

first centuries. The nation that neglects its forests is surely destined
to ruin.”

47

THE NEED OF A FOREST POLICY FOR THE
WESTERN STATES.

By Frep. T. Dvuszors, U. S. Senate.

As Chairman of the Senate Committee on Public Lands I am
necessarily much interested in all questions which relate to the
policy of their treatment,—their forest cover included.

In addition I represent a State in which the forest stands in
intimate relation to all the leading occupations of the people, sup-
plying timber for her mines, affording a reservoir for her irrigation
systems, and thus becoming a factor in her future agriculture.

It affords me, therefore, great pleasure to meet with you this
evening and to participate in your discussions of a problem which
affects directly the varied interests of the West, and of my State in
particular, and is at the same time one of the most important and
the most difficult. I cannot hope to solve the question of an ade-
quate forest policy for our Government, nor do I have very definite
ideas as to what is best to be done, but I can at least express my
sympathy with the objects of your Association, and my earnest
hope that some measure will soon be adopted by Congress by which
the timber lands which yet remain in the public domain may be
protected and managed rationally, for the benefit of the present as
well as the future of the States in which they are situated.

In the earlier years of our country’s history the public lands were
disposed of with reckless prodigality. The country was vast, the
inhabitants few, and the first need of the new nation was that its
domain should be peopled and be made productive.

Almost two hundred years elapsed before the presence of the
yast treeless plains was known. From the first the American pio-
neer on the Atlantic coast had to clear away the forest in order to
make a home. And by reason of this necessity we seem to have
become imbued with the spirit of forest destruction. We have
watched the disappearance of the magnificent white pine forests of
New England without regret, and almost without comment. It has
only been in the last decade that there has been anything like a
general awakening of public sentiment on the forestry question.
The whole East is a great forest, and in spite of farmer, and
logger, and the fire fiend, the country east of the plains is yet rich
in forest wealth.

In the West we have known from the first that our timber sup-

48

plies, outside the coast region, were limited to the mountains. Not
a Western State or Territory but has vast stretches of dry plains
which only need water to make them the most productive fields in
the world. Unlike the Eastern country, where the whole land is a
potential forest, there are hundreds of miles in our great Western
country where no tree casts a refreshing shade, where rivers hide
their waters beneath burning sands in the dry midsummers, where
without man’s aid desolation reigns.

In the earlier settlement of the mountain States the farmer con-
fined his operations to the mountain valley, where each man could
turn the water from the stream onto his adjacent fields. With the
rapid development of the country and the need of more extensive
farming operations, it was discovered that the great plains, lying
miles away from the snow-clad heights, needed only water to make
them as productive as the mountain valleys ; and with the experience
that the forest cover of the mountains has, as you teach, a close
relation to waterflow, I have no doubt the interest in forest pro-
tection will grow accordingly.

At first the Western settler, like his ancestors of Eastern pioneer
days, found the forest cover an impediment. It was in his way in
prospecting, in mining, in farming, and he used the quickest means
of getting rid of it—the fire. The railroads that crossed the
mountains cleaned their right of way by fire and permitted it to
spread beyond control, taking no thought of the tremendous damage
done both within and beyond their limits. The mountains were
everywhere forest-clad, and the few inhabitants considered them as
inexhaustible, as were the pineries of Maine and Michigan looked
upon by the loggers of earlier days ; and this feeling is still abroad.

In the mountains of the West we have yet to create a public senti-
ment favorable to the protection of the forests for the sake of the
future. The efforts of the Government to protect the forests of the
public domain have thus far been futile, mainly for the absence of
such sentiment. Government agents have found it well nigh im-
possible to convict men for the violation of the timber laws because
the whole sentiment of the people was opposed to the laws, beliey-
ing rightly, I think, that they worked a hardship on the individual
settler, while not protecting the forests against corporations which
sought gain only.

In the East—where the needs of a great population, coupled with
wasteful methods of logging and the action of fire, have reduced
the productive capacity of the forests very materially, destroying,

49

indeed, forest industries in many localities—public attention has
been more readily directed to the necessity of forest conservation,
and considerations of the future appear more natural. With us in
the West the present demands all thought, all energy; with a limited
population the timber supply seems still unlimited, and the rela-
tionship of forest cover to other conditions has hardly yet dawned
on us.

It may be that the increased perspective which distance gives has
enabled the membership of this Association to gauge relative values
better than those of us who consider a tree only as a possible min-
ing prop, and so look upon the contents of our mountains as of in-
finitely greater value than the trees that cover them.

You would teach us a better appreciation of relative values, and
you would impress deeply on the Western mind a lesson that it is
slow to learn—namely, that there is an interdependence between the
elements that constitute the wealth of the West; and at the base of
them all, supporting them, and making possible their highest de-
velopment, demanding the best thought of their people for protec-
tion and care, stand the mountain forests.

My own State of Idaho is, to a great degree, typical of the moun-
tain States as regards the importance of its forest areas, as well as
regards the attitude of the people toward theories of forest protec-
tion. Throughout its entire area Idaho is traversed with mountains
which group themselves variously into well-defined ranges, such as
separate the State from Montana, or into great irregular circles, such
as mark the confines of the Coeur d’Alene, or into tangled masses of
short ranges, which seem quite without order, such as mark the
central portion of the map of the State.

Separating these great mountain regions is the Snake river with
its tributaries. In the south this river runs through a vast treeless
lava plain, which traverses the State from the east and extends
along the western border, embracing 30,000 square miles in its ex-
tent, a wide plain with its mountain borders remote from the great
river, which has its sources in the forests of northwestern Wyom-
ing.

The central mountains of Idaho, while they support a consider-
able forest cover, are poor in this regard when compared with the
northern part of the State, where the forest wealth is developed
second only to that of the Pacific States in economic value. Here
we claim to have the only large amounts still standing of magnifi-
cent white pine—a different species, to be sure, from the Michigan

50

pine, that is just furnishing its last logs to the mill, yet a very good
substitute. Here larch of dimensions and quality superior to the
famed European article invites the miller, and giant cedar with
trunks up to 12 feet in diameter cast a sombre gloom over the
mossy floor of the deep valleys. Red firs, lifting their spires 200
feet above the mountain side, suggest the yet greater forest wealth
of the Pacific Coast.

The Coeur d’Alene region in northern Idaho presents, perhaps
best, the condition of much of our mountain forest and its fate.
Here are working, within an area of but little more than 9,000
square miles, the opposing forces of man and nature. Hidden away
in the mountains of the Coeur d’Alene is a wealth of mineral that is
even yet only partially revealed. Covering their slopes and darken-
ing their narrow valleys with their crowded crowns, pine and fir and
hemlock and cedar clothe the region in perennial green.

From the first settlement, man has delved for the metal and con-
sidered the forest cover only as so much additional waste to be
cleared away—as so much débris, compelling additional labor for
its removal, and increasing by so much the cost of mining.

The soils of the Coeur d’Alene are nowhere of the highest fer-
tility, and in only limited areas are there good farming lands. The
soils are too porous, and do not retain moisture. With a heavy
rainfall and freedom from frosts the forest growth had developed
to a phenomenal degree, so that thirty-four years ago, when the first
Government road was opened through this region, trees of the
largest dimensions abounded everywhere.

When the road through the Coeur d’Alene was built, emigrants
flocked westward along the trail to the valley of the Columbia. The
deep stillness of the Coeur d’Alene valleys was depressing to the
spirits of these wanderers, who longed for the sun they had so hated
on the plains, and they set fire to the woods, if only to make a hole
in the dense leaf canopy and let in the sunshine. Then the railroad,
that vanguard of Western civilization, sought a route to Puget
Sound. No aid so potent to man as fire to cleave a pathway through
the impenetrable woods, and with only best intentions the torch was
applied. True, the railroad owned but a certain amount of the land;
but nobody owned the rest—it is so much easier to regard the Gov-
ernment as an entity here in Washington, where great buildings and
thousands of workers give it a personality, than in the West, where
the only evidences of its existence are the broad spreading, unoccu-
pied acres !—nobody owned the land beyond the railway’s claims,

51

and the fires which swept away thousands of the great trees burned
deep into the soil and crept over hundreds of miles of this forested
country, all but ruining its reproductive power. And after these
came the miner. The precious metal was discovered in the Cour
d'Alene, and the busy prospector ‘covered the hills, seeking every-
where for leads. The miner, like the pioneer and the railroad builder,
burned away the forest cover; his only interest was in the few acres
immediately about him, but he had no timie to guard against the
spread of the fire, and during the past fifteen years hundreds of
miles of forest have been thus destroyed.*

An agent of the Department of Agriculture, in an interesting re-
port, yet unpublished, on the forests of the Coeur d'Alene, says:
“In 1884 I traversed miles upon miles of primeval forest in a jour-
ney through the Coeur d’Alene to Montana. In 1895, along the
same route, there was not a single foot that the axe and fire had not
run through, and the larger quantity had been uselessly and totally
destroyed.” Fifty per cent. of the accessible forest of this region
has been absolutely destroyed, and 20 per cent. more has been
culled, in the brief period since Mullin’s road was built.

Unlike the fires in the East, which sweep through the forest with
such rapidity as to be a menace to human life, the moist woods of
the Ceeur d’Alene burn very slowly, and life is not endangered.
Thus the only great incentive to the protection of the forest—the
element of personal danger—is reduced toa minimum. Fires have
been known to smoulder in the humus-covered forest floor of this
region for two months, beneath deep snows. Hence, once ignited,
it becomes a matter of the greatest difficulty to quench them, and
is usually only possible with the aid of the returning rainy season.
Thus we have here an example which can be duplicated in every
State of the West; before even a settlement is effected much of the
natural wealth has been destroyed uselessly ; snowslides, landslides,
washing of the soil, excessive water stages in rivers, have been in-
vited by the denudation of the mountain slopes, and the future
made more difficult.

Now I appreciate that this treatment of our great forest resource
is not rational. While at present we have more than we need, the
rapidly developing West requires an increasing supply of timber for
its varied interests, and it should be home grown—not, as has be-
come necessary in many regions, brought from long distances.

The mines, much the largest users, should be saved the expense

* John B. Leiberg, of Hope, Idaho.

52.

of long hauls. The cities and towns, which are springing up on
every hand, should not be put to the disadvantage of freighting
lumber from far distant sources. The varied manufacturing inter-
ests that are sure to follow the development of intensive farming,
made possible by irrigation, the whole progress of our great moun-
tain country is threatened by the wholesale destruction of our tim-
ber supply. For the Cour d’Alene is only extraordinary in the
wealth of its forests and their quick destruction. Throughout the
Rocky Mountains the traveller has only to glance from the car win-
dows to see great stretches of blackened tree trunks, or a worthless
young growth of stunted poplar, where once magnificent forests of
pine and spruce covered the land. The devastation is widespread ;
but the mere destruction of merchantable material, however in-
trinsically valuable, is as nothing to the greater danger which
threatens our water supply.

The water supply of Idaho, taking the State as a whole, is large,
the quantity in comparison with the total area of land to be irri-
gated being probably as great as that of any State of the arid region.
Unfortunately, however, a great part of this water supply is not
available for the development of the dry agricultural lands from the
fact that it occurs in the great rivers draining the high mountains
and narrow valleys of the northern part of the State or flows in the
deep gorge cut by Snake River. Thus it happens that with the
exception of the Snake River, near its head waters in the eastern
part of the State, the streams of importance to agriculture are rela-
tively small, and depend for their supply upon the lower, less rugged
catchment areas. From these there is less runoff in proportion to
the rainfall, and to reach the highest and best development possible
for the rich farming lands commanded by its waters every drop
should be saved and utilized.

The farmers who have lived in the country and watched the streams
year by year believe that the runoff is closely connected with de-
forestation. They assert that on account of the destruction of the
forests by fire, or injury to the character of the covering of the soil,
the amount of water available is diminished either by being less in
quantity or by coming in destructive floods. These floods, even
under the best conditions, are wasteful, and reservoirs must be built
in the future upon or near many of the streams to equalize the flow
and to hold water until later in the growing season. The problem
of protecting these from being filled by silt is one of the most im-
portant considerations, and one which in many localities can be solved

53

only by protecting the verdure npon the catchment basin, this in
turn holding the soil from being washed away.

Even in the case of the head waters of the Snake River, deriving
its supply from over .10,000 square miles of mountain area, it is
questionable whether the wanton destruction of the forests will not
seriously affect the flow of the stream. The farmers believe that it
will, and as a rule, wherever their attention has been called to the
subject, are in hearty accord with the objeets of the Forestry As-
sociation.

In the State of Idaho there still remains vacant land to the extent
of about 75,000 square miles, this being very nearly +5 of the whole
area of the State. Of the remaining portion, only about 5,700
square miles has been disposed of by the General Government, this
being between 6 and 7 per cent. of the entire area of the State, and
3,500 square miles is reserved mainly for the use of the Indians.
No forest reservations have been made, although the State contains
vast stretches of heavily timbered land from which come the streams
employed in irrigation. Considering the State as a whole, there is
estimated to be in timber forests nearly 11 million acres, and in
woodlands over 21 million acres, including under this head lands
which do not furnish trees of size for dimension timber, but from
which firewood and mining props can be cut. This leaves about 21
million acres as absolutely treeless, the greater part being broad
undulating plains covered, during a part of the season at least, with
a scanty vegetation furnishing forage for cattle. According to the
last census the total area of improved land was a trifle over 600,000
square miles, most of this land depending for its value upon the
water supply.

What shall be done?

It is one thing to recite the story of existing evils, and quite
another to effect a remedy for them. Many considerations, diffi-
cult to understand at this distance, must enter into the determina-
tion of a practical working policy for the forests of our public do-
main. Were the forests which the United States owns situated in
the East, surrounded by a dense population, motives of self-interest
or of public welfare would render their protection easy. Located
as they are, remote from centers of population, far distant from the
markets of the world, usually difficult of access even from the moun-
tain cities, without roads, with no definite boundaries, and sur-
rounded by a population accustomed to a very liberal interpretation
of private rights in public property, the difficulties in the way of

54

an efficient management are indeed great. It must not be forgot-
ten, moreover, that a hundred years of neglect of the public domain
has instilled in the minds of the people impressions that will be
difficult to eradicate. Indeed, the very slow progress of the for-
estry movement here in the East,is proof enough of this. Our
people feel themselves in great measure justified in their treat-
ment of the public timber lands. They are jealous of interference
with their rights ; they fear curtailment in their use of the resources
at hand.

From the bills now pending before Congress, which I believe are
partly or wholly endorsed by your Association, I see that the pro-
posed administration provides not only for protection but f for use of
the timber. This is a correct principle.

If the United States Government proposes to.retain these moun-
tain forests, it should not only guard them properly, but aid instead
of preventing their use, and make their rational exploitation possi-
ble.

Experience has shown the existing legislation to be vicious, to
result in hardship to the settler and miner, without preserving the
property. That a change is desirable has been urged for many
years by various Secretaries of the Interior and by all people who
have an interest in the matter.

What that change is to be permits, however, of wide differences.
of opinion.

Mr. Teller, in Senate bill 914, has proposed a plan which his
familiarity with Western conditions would warrant me to accept in
the main as practicable. It is, in the first place, intended to be ap-
plied to the forest reservations, but might with advantage be ex-
tended to all forest lands of the public domain.

Once inaugurated in a proper manner, when it is shown that the
intention is to allow the use of the forest resources by the people
of the States, with only such safeguards as will prevent their anni-
hilation, I have no doubt that the sentiment of the people them-
selves will be with your endeavors.

One of the most hopeful aspects of your movement is that, as far
as I have been able to observe, an increasing public interest is
everywhere manifest, and with its growth Congressional action will
not be wanting.

I close, then, with the hope that the problem of establishing a
rational forest policy for the Government of the United States may
have a speedy and wise solution.

ee eS

55

THE DESTRUCTION AND REPAIR OF OUR NAT-
URAL RESOURCES.

By Joun F. Lacey, M. C., Oskaloosa, Iowa.

The people of this continent do not sufficiently appreciate the
immensity of the period that nature employed in building the New
World and preparing it as a home for civilized man, nor how easily
those advantages may be destroyed. When first Columbus set his
foot upon these shores the vast forests and splendid prairies lay rich
and inviting as the home of the coming race. The forest, which
has done so much to prepare the earth for man’s use, was en-
countered by the early settlers along the whole Atlantic shore.
The necessity of clearing away this vast mass of vegetation led the
pioneer to look upon the woods as the enemy of man. The axe was
used unsparingly, and but few specimens of the original continental
forests still remain.

Trees have their poetic as well as their practical side. While
sensible to their beauty, we are now deeply concerned in their
utility. All they have asked heretofore has been standing room.
Give them but place, and they will patiently do their work. Their
long arms have reached out for ages, and gathered from the air
the elements of growth which they have added to the soil. As one
poet has expressed it:

‘* Cedars stretch their palms like holy men at prayer ;”

and another speaks of them in winter,—
‘‘ With their bare arms stretched in prayer for the snows.”

They gather the sunshine year by year and store it away for future
use. They fertilize the soil; they beautify it.

In a few old churchyards on the eastern shore of Maryland may
be seen the remains of the splendid forest that once covered that
region. The sight of these specimens makes us regret that larger
areas of the ancient forest had not remained untouched. It was
necessary to cut down a part of the forests, but man has swept
them from the earth with the besom of destruction.

We are beginning to realize the wastefulness with which we have
treated the gifts of nature. We found this continent a storehouse
of energy and wealth. The climate was salubrious. The soil was

56

fertile. The forests spread on every hand. The rivers teemed with
fish. The earth and air alike furnished supplies of game. Great
coal deposits were found in almost every State. Coal oil and nat-
ural gas arose to the explorer from the bowels of the earth.

The prodigality of the sun is something amazing. When we
think how few of its rays strike the earth or any of the planets in
proportion to those that are constantly shed from its surface, we are
led to wonder if they ever can be exhausted. Manis as prodigal of
his natural possessions as the sun of its heat, ight, and energy.
We have not been content with improving upon nature, but have
acted the spendthrift part in wasting her stores. The coal has
been preserved in spite of man by vast strata of earth and stone,
and there has been less wasteful extravagance in the use of this
valuable mineral than, perhaps, any other of nature’s gifts, and yet
we are beginning to compute the time when the anthracite will only
be found in the collections of museums. The coal oil has been
wasted and wells have been opened and fields destroyed as though
the supply was inexhaustible. Natural gas deposits have been
tapped, and the wasting gas set on fire, lighting the country for
miles around. These vast stores of nature’s forces are being
rapidly exhausted.

It has not been so very long ago that terrapin were so plentiful
in Maryland that it was found necessary to enact a law preventing
masters from feeding their slaves more than a given number of
times each week upon that toothsome viand. Terrapin three times
a day, three hundred and sixty-five days in a year, was found to be
monotonous. No such law would be necessarynow. In Connecti-
cut the law forbade that an apprentice should be required to eat
salmon more than twice a week for the same reason that the slave
was protected against too much terrapin. Now the Connecticut
salmon is a delicacy for the rich alone.

The extermination of the buffalo is too recent and too shameful
to speak of excepting in the highest terms of indignation. Instead of
taking these vast herds and, after giving them proper marks of
identity, dividing them up and assuming proprietary rights over
them, they have been slaughtered by the hundred thousand for the
sheer pleasure of killing, until now a little handful of two or three
hundred is all that is left of the millions which roamed the plains
forty years ago; and this was called sport. It required nothing
like the expert skill of the pig sticker who, covered with blood, pre-
sides over the scenes of carnage in one of our great slaughter-
houses.

57

The same indiscriminate slaughter which has practically destroyed
the salmon of Connecticut has been followed on the Columbia. Fish-
wheels along the banks of the stream have been throwing out of the
water enormous quantities of the most beautiful fish in the world,
catching them at the very time when they were en route to the head
waters of the stream to deposit their spawn. Legislation upon the
part of Oregon and Washington has at last been reluctantly enacted,
in time, I trust, to save these fish from extermination.

It is to the forests that we wish more particularly to direct our
attention at this time. But the streams are the children of the
forest, and the fish are the children of the streams. In the early
days men often cut down trees for the wild fruits that grew upon
them. The beautiful service-berry has been well nigh exterminated
by this barbarous practice. This was a sin against nature. <A few
years ago I visited the great region of the Northern Pacific Coast,
where to-day is perhaps the grandest forest now remaining on the
face of the earth. It can no longer be described as

‘the continuous woods

Where rolls the Oregon, and hears no sound

Save his own dashings; ”
for the hand of man is busily engaged in building up new States in
that splendid country. Arriving upon the cars at The Dalles some
one said to me to run out quick and I would see Mount Hood. I
presumed Mount Hood was one of the permanent features of Oregon
and I saw no reason to be excited or to hurry to see it, and took a
little time to go to the point where the peak could be seen through
the open street. I watched it for a moment and then the smoke
and fog covered it. It was the first and last glimpse I ever had
of Mount Hood. The whole country was covered with a pall of
smoke. The same “improvement” was being perpetrated there
as in early days on the Atlantic Coast. The promised destruction
of the world by fire was progressing.

Splendid trees, five and six feet in diameter and hundreds of
years of age, were being destroyed. Auger holes were bored in the
tree near the ground, coal oil poured in the holes, a match applied,
and tke tree burned down. Other holes were bored in the body of
the tree, and with the assistance of more coal oil a splendid tree
was soon reduced toashes. During the dry season these fires were
permitted to escape and pass through the forests, covering and
concealing the whole earth with a cloud of smoke, and rapidly
working in this new field the same useless destruction which has
followed in man’s footstep in every part of the continent.

58

This sin on the Pacific Coast is only greater than that which was
committed on the Atlantic shore because the forests are finer, and
the mistakes made in the wanton destruction of the timber in the
East ought to have been a warning in the West. They have an
awful example to shun and not to follow.

In the hills of Virginia and West Virginia I remember in my boy-
hood days the little streams that were fed by springs, and favorite
swimming holes could be found along them all. They were full of
fish, and a source of delight to the young and old. After forty
years’ absence I revisited some of the same old streams. The trees
had been cut from the hillsides. The springs had dried up. The
old swimming holes were gravelly and sandy wastes,—as dry as
Sahara, except where the channels were filled with muddy torrents
for a few hours after a big rain.

In the older settled parts of the country the same condition of
things occurred much longer ago.

I believe it was in 1842 that Doctor English described a similar
condition, asking his old schoolmate to remember

‘‘ The shaded nook by the running brook
Where the children went to swim.
Grass grows on the master’s grave, Ben Bplt,
And the spring of the brook is dry.”’

This wail touches the heart in every part of the settled portions
of the country.

In Central and Southern Italy the Appennines are a striking
illustration of the results of forest destruction. The ghastly seams
into which the rains have washed lands that were once as fertile as
any in the world have utterly destroy ed much of that country for
agricultural purposes. Surrounded as Italy is by the Mediterranean,
the effects upon her climate have not perhaps been as bad as would
follow in the interior part of the continent. But nature seems to
have given eS the struggle with man, and Hawthorne tells us that
where man’s hand has carved a stone in Italy its reclamation from
nature is permanent, whilst in the north of Europe, or in the British
isles, nature claims its own again, and covers the bricks and rocks
with moss, lichens, or ivy.

Nothing is so beautiful as a running stream in a state of nature.
It is a living thing, always sparkling, never growing old. The brook,
where the forests still protect it from destruction in its course to
the sea, is a symbol of eternity. To the poet it says,

‘*Men may come, and men may go,
But I go on forever.”

59

But in the land of the Holy Writ, where the forests were but few,
the brook was no such type of constancy. In Job, the brook is de-
scribed as an emblem of deceit, frozen up in the winter and dried up
in thesummer. ‘“ My brethren have dealt deceitfully as a brook, and
as a stream of brooks they passaway. * * * The paths of their
way are turned aside; they come to nothing and perish.”

The brook that Horace describes in his journey to Brundusium
still flows in the same banks, and seems like a living thing, speak-
ing of the poet of two thousand years ago.

The Hon. Timothy Brown, one of the leading lawyers of Iowa,
has a discouraging theory which he supports with a considerable
array of corroborating facts. He assures us that the magnetic pole
is moving eastward at the rate of seven miles a year, and as it moves
the area of drought in the Rocky Mountain region progresses at the
same rate, and in due time Ohio will be as arid as Wyoming or
Nevada.

We must not mistake mere weather for climate. We may have
a scarcity of rain-fall, and that scarcity may become serious enough
to lead us to apprehend a dangerous permanent change of climate,
whilst it may be true that a similar condition of things has prevailed
many times in the past in the same region, followed by a return
of sufficient moisture.

But it seems to be the united opinion of all ages and in all coun-
tries that rain produces forests, and that forests produce rain; that
great and injurious changes of climate almost certainly follow any
sweeping and general destruction of the woods.

Trees set out along hedge rows will undoubtedly do much in
ameliorating climatic conditions, but great masses of forest, where
considerable regions are shaded and protected, are essential to the
preservation of the climatic conditions that have brought so much
prosperity to this country in the past.

In the Northwest the last few years of drought have prepared the
people as a whole for the study of this question. The shrinking of
the Great Lakes is already plainly noticeable, and active efforts for
their preservation and restoration should be made without delay.

In Iowa some of the most beautiful of the little lakes have been
drained and turned into fertile fields, whilst others have dwindled
so as to be only a mere reminder of their former beauty. If the
destruction of these bodies of water only entailed the loss of their
beauty, a practical people might accept the change without any very
great regret; but when the reclamation of a comparatively small

60

area of land to cultivation imperils the water supply of thousands
of surrounding farms, it is high time to call a halt and demand a
restoration of these sources of water supply. All land must at times
lie fallow. The best rest that it can enjoy is when, covered with
timber, it returns for a time to its natural condition, sheltered and
fertilized by the woods once more. A reasonable portion of the
country should at all times be thus given up to its native woods if
we would preserve the fertility of the whole.

The practical question of to-day is how, as far as possible, to undo
the mistakes of the past ; how to prevent them in the future. Agi-
tation and discussion are necessary to call the attention of the peo-
ple to the importance of maintaining, and to at least partially re-
storing, the primitive forests of this country. The recent policy of
withdrawing from settlement or sale large regions upon the head
waters of streams, and creating forest reservations, is the greatest
step in the right direction that has thus far been taken.

We must give up some part of our country to nature in order to
keep the remainder for ourselves. The policy of most of the old
States in regard to timber has been well summed up in six words:
“To get rid of the timber.”

With wood used for nearly every purpose from toothpicks and
matches up to great grain elevators and ship masts, the proper and
reasonable requirements for man’s necessities and luxuries involve
ereat and constant encroachment upon our forests. The old back-
log of our forefathers has given place to the terra-cotta gas log of
a new generation.

With barbed wire for fencing, and the decrease of wooden houses
in the larger towns and cities, the overworked forests ought to have
some rest. But the increase in population and the wear and tear
upon old buildings make such calls for timber that, of necessity, a
great drain upon the old forests continues.

Our fathers cut down beautiful black walnut trees for rails, and
our own generation has pulled up the old stumps of the same tree
for furniture making.

The peasants of France during the Revolution, it is said, would
cut down two trees to make a pair of wooden shoes. Mark Twain,
a few years ago while in Paris, promised to send as a wedding
present to a friend the rarest and most expensive thing he could
obtain in that city, and selected two small logs of fire-wood for that
purpose, and, tying them together with red, white, and blue ribbon,
laid them among the bric-a-brac at the wedding reception.

61

We ask ourselves what remedy we should adopt in America.
This is more easily asked than answered. To call the attention of
the people to the mistakes of the past before it is too late will lead
to a conservation of groves and forests still in existence. The de-
struction from fires has already attracted much attention, and rigid
laws to prevent them have been enacted in every State.

Groves and small wood-lots upon each farm will, in some meas-
ure repair the loss of the more extensive woods, but there must
be considerable areas of country in which the forest must take con-
trol if we would preserve the climate, the springs, the streams, the
soil, the birds, and the fishes. Even now the business of sinking
wells for farm use to a depth of several hundred feet is being
actively carried on in the West. The surface water is disappearing.

Private owners cannot perform the duty of forestry in America.
We have no rich old families who from generation to generation
have been able to set apart large tracts of land for the growth
of trees. We have none of the beautiful old ruins that grace
so many parts of the forest-planting kingdoms of the Old World.
We have no ruins more picturesque than a defunct bank, a bank-
rupt insurance company, or a railway in the hands of a receiver. No
baronial game preserves are set apart in America. Only the Govern-
ment lives long enough to plant trees extensively. The private in-
dividual is too constantly reminded of the fleeting character of life
to lay out a forest for succeeding generations. The Government
alone can hold tracts either long enough or large enough to effect
the great climatic purposes involved in the preservation of our
forests. A great step in this direction was taken in the laws pro-
viding for timber reservations. These reservations should be kept
for use and growth. A thorough system of cutting of this timber
ought to be provided for at some time in the future when the wants
of the people require that the ripened or dead trees should be
utilized. But this should be done with such system as to preserve
them as a whole.

The people should be taught the value of these reservations by
thorough education upon the subject. Arbor Day celebration and
the planting of fruit and timber trees will lead a new generation to
realize that the forest is not the enemy of man, but his fast friend
—a friend without whom nations cannot expect to prosper.

62

NATIONAL FORESTRY LEGISLATION.

By Hon. Tuomas C. McRag, M. C., Vice-President for Arkansas.

Speaking without notes, Mr. McRae recalled his own attitude
towards the forestry movement when the subject was first brought
to his attention. His own State of Arkansas was so rich in forest
wealth that the citizens did not appreciate its value, but looked upon
the forest as a thing to be got rid of. No one buys wood for
such uses as fencing, or lumber for a barn or house; his neighbor
is glad to let him have all he wants, provided he will clear the brush
as he cuts the trees needed for lumber. It is only when the denizen
of the Arkansas forest is lured away from home to the treeless plains
that he learns to appreciate his trees. Mr. McRae was never out of
sight of trees until he had passed his thirty-fifth year, and he recalled
the joy of some of his old-time neighbors, who, after a vain attempt
to make a new home in the prairies of Texas, returned to Arkansas
and could scarcely refrain from hugging the old pines that were
their childhood’s companions.

With such an environment it is not strange that the subject of
forest protection should not appear an important one. When the
first committee of this Association appeared before the Public
Lands Committee, he took but little interest in their propositions. He
regarded them as sentimentalists with somewhat visionary notions.
But as the hearing progressed he was impressed with the fact that
they were men of strong common sense, having a mission of great
practical importance to the particular regions affected by the pro-
posed legislation, and one of general interest to the country at large.

When Mr. Fernow told him that he had just exerted himself to
get $3,000,000 of English capital into the State of Arkansas for the
purpose of developing the oak forests on the agricultural bottom
lands of that State, he began to realize that the object of the Asso-
ciation was not to prevent the use of the timber but to have it used
rationally, to have it cut judiciously, nay, even to have it cleared
away when the soil could be better used for agricultural purposes.
He also realized that what was desirable and proper to be done
in his State might not be desirable in other parts of the Union, and
that the conditions of the regions in which the public timber do-
main is situated were different, as Senator Dubois had shown, from
those of his own State.

He became a convert, and, as is apt to be the case with converts who

63

enter the lists for their adopted cause, is now an enthusiastic advo-
cate of forest protection, aud a member of the Association.

He saw, however, at once, that the original bill which he was
asked to introduce in Congress was too elaborate a measure, pro-
viding as it did for a full administration scheme; and although he
was persuaded that the scheme was a rational one, carefully worked
out, he knew that it would be impossible to have it enacted.

The majority of Congress, just as the majority of the people, were
not yet educated up to the point of appreciating fully the necessity
and the importance of such an administration as the one proposed.
He therefore advised to go slowly and try to secure by degrees the end
sought, suggesting that the bill be cut down to the shortest
possible expression of the idea involved, namely, the idea of pro-
tecting from spoliation. Even this much could not be secured in
the 52d Congress.

Yet it was found that the forest reservations which Presidents
Harrison and Cleveland had created under the new policy of the
law of March 3, 1891,—over 17,000,000 acres, in the Western moun-
tains—were worse off than if not reserved, for there was no legisla-
tion affording them any protection; they were simply lands with-
drawn from sale and from use, interfering with mining and other
industries which, under proper regulations, might be carried on
without injury to the forest itself. This absolute withdrawal from
use threatened to injure or overthrow the entire reservation policy,
for the Western people found themselves cut off from the rightful
use of the resources surrounding them. Meanwhile timber thieves,
sheepherders, incendiaries continued their vocations unmolested.
Hence the passage of a bill to secure a proper administration of
these reservations became urgent.

Again, this bill (H. R. 119, 53d Congress) was made as brief and
simple as possible, embracing only the salient points of the original
comprehensive measure presented by the Association.

It left the detail of administration mainly to be provided by the
Secretary of the Interior, giving him the right to determine the con-
ditions under which mining and lumbering should be carried on ©
and any other occupancy of the reservation might be allowed, and to
organize a protective service, in which also the army might be used.

After much consultation with members representing the Western
States and adjusting provisions of the bill to satisfy their ideas, it
became possible to pass the bill and send it to the Senate.

Unfortunately, although the bill was passed by the Senate sub-

64

stantially as it stood, with some amendments, the form in which it
- came back to the House made it appear like a new bill, and instead
of being sent to a conference committee for the purpose of adjust-
ing the differences, it was returned to the Committee on Public
Lands for reconsideration. This action was taken in the unfortu-
nate absence of Mr. McRae, who had he been present would have
been able to point out the error in the conception that it was a new
bill and could have secured the conference and possibly its enact-
ment. As it was, there was no time left to bring the bill out of
committee before the adjournment of Congress.

The main point of difference between the two bills passed by the
House and by the Senate was the omission in the Senate bill of the
provision that the army be utilized for the purpose of protecting
the reservations against depredation.

He had now introduced substantially the same bill aad had been
fortunate in securing the same number for the bill that it had in
the last Congress, namely, H. R. 119, which might be considered a
good omen. It seemed to him that there should be no difficulty
in securing its enactment as a law during the present Congress.

It was certainly a non-partisan measure, based on sound policy
and rational consideration of the needs of this property of the
nation as well as of the needs of the people living near to it.

These, he was happy to believe, had also become more and more
persuaded that the General Government should take the protection
of its forest property under its special care, provided this does not
mean interference with its legitimate use.

The finding of valuable mineral deposits within the boundaries
of some of the existing reservations, and the consequent clamor to
have the reservations restituted to the public domain for entry, be-
cause under present conditions the development of their resources is
stopped, made it especially urgent to pass this bill: unless by the
piecemeal restitution of the lands themselves the policy of reser-
vation itself, so happily inaugurated, be nullified and its benefits
lost.

American Forestry Congress
Proceedings

Biological
& Medical
Serials

“LIBRARY

UNIVERSITY OF TORONTO

”