Full text of "Natural science"

See other formats

■' • -. I

h , -

443

&c <*■*■

* '

P»

;*,

»s<

'^,

■«

«&

NATURAL
SCIENCE

A MONTHLY REVIEW OF
SCIENTIFIC PROGRESS

VOL. XL

JULY — DECEMBER 1897

LONDON

J. M. DENT & CO.

(57 SAINT JAMES'S STREET, S.W.

<?*. 6 <f[ t. <&*>- *¥

h^*

SUBJECT INDEX TO ARTICLES

These titles may be cut out and pasted on cards for a slip-catalogue.
Those who do not wish to use the decimal notation as a guide to
the subject matter can cut oft* the numbers.

507 Bolton, H. The Provincial Museum.— Nat. Sci., XL, 387 Dec, 1897

550.1 Howorth, H. H. A New Scheme of Geological Arrangement anil

Nomenclature.— Nat. Sri., XL, 321 Nov., 1897

551.47(98) Smith, B. L. Note on tin' warm Undercurrent in the Arctic Ocean

between Greenland and Spitsbergen. — Nat. Sci., XL, Is

July, 1897

551.79 Oldham, R. D. The Facetted Pebbles of India.— Nat. Sci., XL, 197

Sept., 1897

565.3 Bernard, H. M. Fossil Apodidae. —Nat. Sci., XL, 397 Dec, 1897

567 Lankester, E. R. TheTaxonomic Position of the Pteraspidap, Cephal-

aspidae, and Asterolepidae. — Nat. Sci., XL, 45 July, 1897

568 Ridewood, W. G. On the Restoration of Some Extinct Reptiles.—

Nat. Sci., XL, 190 Sept., 1897

569.(8) Ameghino, F. South America as the Source of the Tertiary Mammalia.

— Nat. Sri., XL, 256 Oct., 1897

571.1 Cunnington, W. The Authenticity of Plateau Man. — Nat. Sci., XL.

327 Nov., 1897

571.1 M'Kay, G. R. Evidence of the Antiquity of Man in East London, Cape

Colony, with a Note on the Castor-Oil Plant. — Nat. Sci., XL,
334 Nov., 1897

O O A

571.93(42.25) Abbott, W. J. L. Primeval Refuse Heaps at Hastings.— Nat. Sci.,
XL, 40, 94 July, Aug., 1897

572.(94.2) 'Theta.' Initiation Rites of the Arunta Tribe, Central Australia. —

Nat. Sri., XL, 119 Aug., 1897

575 Bulman, G. W. Bees and the Development of Flowers. — Nat. Sri.,

XL. 100 Aug., 1897

575 Hyatt, A. The Influence of Woman in the Evolution of the Human

Race.— Nat. Sci., XL, 89 Aug., 1897

575 Hutton, F. W. The Place of Isolation in Organic Evolution.— Nat.

Sri., XL, 240 Oct., 1897

575 Coste, F. H. P. Professor Schiller on Darwinism and Design. — Nat.

Sci., XL, 408 Dec, 1897

575.1 Hartog, M. The Fundamental Principles of Heredity.— Nat. Sri..

XL, 233, 305 Oct., Nov., 1897

575.1 Tayler, J. L. The Relation of Acquired Modifications to Heredity. —

Nat. Sci., XL, 247 Oct., 1E97

575.2 Pearson, K. On the Scientific Measure of Variability. — Nat. Sci.,

XL. 115 Aug., 1897

SUBJECT INDEX TO ARTICLES

575.2 Tayler, J. L. The Relation of Acquired Modifications to Heredity.

— Nat. Sci. , X I . , 24 7 Oct. , 1897

575.3 Hutton, F. W. The Place of Isolation in Organic Evolution. — Nat.

Sci., XL, 240 Oct., 1897

575.4 Henslow, G. Does Natural Selection play any part in the Origin of

Species among Plants.— Afad. Sci., XL, 166 Sept., 1897

575.8 Jordan, K. Reproductive Divergence. A Factor in Evolution? —

Nat. Sci., XL, 317 Nov., 1897

575.8 Yernon, H. M. Reproductive Divergence. An Additional Factor in

Evolution.— Nat. Sci., XL, 181 Sept., 1897

575.8 Yernon, H. M. Reproductive Divergence. A Rejoinder. — Nat. Sci.,

XL, 404 Dec, 1897

576.3 Beer, R. Cell or Corpuscle?— Nat. Sci., XL, 392 Dec, 1897

581.1 Beer, R. The Seed Production of Cut Flowers.— Nat. Sci., XL, 337

Nov., 1897

581.151 Klebs, G. Polymorphism in the Algae.— Nat. Sci., XL, 107

Aug., 1897

581.16 Bulman, G. W. Bees and the Development of Flowers. — Nat. Sci.,

XL, 100 Aug., 1897

589.3 Klebs, G. Polymorphism in the Algae. — Nat. Sci., XL, 107

Aug. 1897

590.7(7) Dean, B. A Californian Marine Biological Station. — Nat. Sci., XL,

28 July, 1897

590.7(7) Sclater, P. L. The Proposed Zoological Park of New York.— Nat.

Sci., XL, 36 July, 1897

591.15 Weldon, W. F. R. Karl Pearson on Evolution.— Nat. Sci., XL, 50

July, 1897

591.9 Carpenter, G. H. The Problems of the British Fauna. — Nat. Sci.,

XL, 375 Dec, 1897

591.9(9) Murray, J. On the Distribution of the Pelagic Foraminifera at the

• Surface and on the Floor of the Ocean.— Nat. Sci., XL, 17

July, 1897

593.12 Murray, J. On the Distribution of the Pelagic Foraminifera at the

Surface and on the Floor of the Ocean. — Nat. Sci., XL, 17

July, 1897

593.5 Stebbing, T. R. R. A Carcinological Campaign.— Nat. Sci., XL, 251

Oct., 1897

595.793 Bulman, G. W. Bees and the Development of Flowers. —Nat. Sci.,

XL, 100 Aug., 1897

599.9 Hyatt, A. The Influence of Woman in the Evolution of the Human

Race.— Nat. Sci., XL, 89 Aug., 1897

925. Liitken, C. F. Steenstrup.— Nat. Sci., XL, 159 Sept., 1897

NATURAL SCIENCE

A Monthly Review of Scientific Progress

No. 65— Vol. XI— JULY 1897

NOTES AND COMMENTS

The Cambridge Graces

On few recent educational questions have we felt such difficulty in
forming an opinion as on the proposal that the women students at
Cambridge should be granted the degrees for which they may have
passed the examinations. Anxious that the opportunities for women's
education should be extended in every way, our natural sympathies
were in favour of the proposals. There can be no doubt that those
Girtonians and Newnhamites who enter the educational profession
would find it a great advantage to have a Cambridge degree. To
refuse it to women who have resided at Cambridge for the necessary
number of terms, and have passed all the prescribed examinations,
seems to us unfair and almost churlish. Women who have done
the same work and stood the same tests as men, should surely be
allowed the same certificate of efficiency. It seems to us hopeless
to expect that popular opinion will ever estimate a Girton certificate
as of equal value to a Cambridge degree, while the university
refuses the latter. The present position of women students at
Cambridge seems to us anomalous, illogical, and very unfair. But
we doubt if the proposed changes would have improved matters.
No one denies that had the graces been passed, there would have
been a great increase in the number of women students at Cambridge.
It is affirmed by some Cambridge authorities, whose opinions are
usually entitled to respect, that the admission of women would have
been followed by a considerable decrease in the number of male
undergraduates. Suppose that in ten or twenty years' time, there
are half as many women students as men. It would then be
intolerable that the tutors and lecturers at the women's colleges and
halls should have no voice in arranging the courses of study. If
women be allowed the examinations and degrees, and form a third
of the registered students, it would be quite unfair that they should
not be eligible for all prizes and scholarships, and that their
interests should not be protected by direct representation on the

2 NATURAL SCIENCE [July

boards of studies. We should not grudge the women any prizes that
they won. The competition of the best women would do the men
nothing but good. The danger is that alterations would be made
in the interests of the weaker of the women, which might enable
men to gain degrees with even less work than at present. More-
over, a course of study suitable for men may not be suitable for
women. So long as women only enter for the tripos examinations,
this objection is not serious. But if women are to have degrees, it
would be absurd to allow men to take an easy poll degree, and
restrict women to the tripos. The training for an ordinary Cam-
bridge degree may not be an ideal education for men, although it
may do well enough for the average curate and country gentleman.
But in an education of that standard the requirements of men and
women are very different. If women are to be admitted to poll
degrees, then alterations in the examinations for them ought to be
made. Hence we are inclined to prefer a separate university for
women to a mixed university, at which both men and women would
have to put up with an hermaphrodite education suitable for neither.
Moreover, if women be allowed to enter the university and share in
the scholarships, there is no logical reason why girls should not be
admitted in separate classes to the public schools, to the students of
which so many of the best scholarships are restricted.

The Woman of the Future

One thing is still lacking to " the new woman." It is a beard.
But this, according to Dr A. Brandt, she may hope to have in the
course of some thousands, possibly hundreds, of years. Many
women have beards already. Some take a pride in them, and utilise
them as a source of income ; others keep them in check by the use
of depilatories, of forceps, or even a razor. As for moustaches they
are so common as to pass without remark, and a tender shade upon
the upper lip of a brunette may even be regarded as an added
beauty. Still, at the present period in the evolution of our race, it
is for the most part in old age that the beard comes to woman.
The beard does not appear in man before puberty, and increases in
strength with age, often compensating for a loss of hair on the head.
Dr Brandt, therefore, writing in the Revue Scicntifiquc for May 15,
regards the beard not as an ancestral, but as in part a second and
in part a senile character. Like other characters that first appear
late in the life of individuals, it is likely to be accelerated in its
development. In other words, hair will appear on the face at an
earlier and earlier age, as time goes on, both in men and women.
" Perhaps a day will dawn when we shall think a moustache in a
woman less ugly than a bust deformed by the corset."

NATURAL SCIENCE, VOL. XL

Plate I.

^ tysprUu ^

1897] NOTES AND COMMENTS 3

The Contributors to the ' Challenger ' Beport.s

The fifty volumes of the ' Challenger ' reports having been recently-
completed, a complimentary album was presented to the editor,
Dr John Murray, by his colleagues. The album was itself a
work of art, but its chief interest lay in the circumstance that
it contained the photographs of all who had contributed to the
literature of the Eeports. As some of these authors are no longer
among us, and others are dispersed over the four quarters of the
globe, it was an arduous undertaking to fill up this portrait-gallery
of scientific worthies. But Mr W. E. Hoyle, as Hon. Secretary to
the presentation committee, met with the friendliest response to
every application, and, with the assistance of Mr Walter Crane in the
artistic department, successfully coped with all the difficulties that
arose, whether expected or unexpected. After so much trouble had
been expended, the happy thought occurred to Mr Hoyle that many
who might never have a chance of seeing the original album, gleam-
ing in purple and gold, would welcome an opportunity of possessing
a copy of its contents. The Committee warmly approved of this
suggestion, and the result is seen in a thin quarto volume (price,
12 s. 6cl), uniform in size and binding with the reports. It con-
tains reduced copies of the 88 portraits on 19 plates, together with
reproductions in black and white of Mr Walter Crane's designs for
the cover and dedication. As a specimen of the portraiture we are
enabled to show our readers a likeness of the late Sir C. Wyville
Thomson, the original director of the civilian staff. Whether the
small edition of 200 copies will suffice for all who will wish to
possess this interesting volume may be doubted. The publishers
are Messrs Dulau & Co.

Phenacomys

The genus Phenacomys has no doubt existed at least as long as the
genus Homo, and specimens of this small vole may even have been
known to man, and have been hoarded by that acquisitive animal in
his museums for a considerable period. We know, in fact, that a
specimen obtained and presented by Mr J. K. Lord of the North
American Boundary Commission, has been in the British Museum
since 1863. None the less so short a time as eight years ago,
zoologists were unaware of the existence of this genus, although the
suspicions of a few may have been aroused by Nehring's descrip-
tion, in 1883, of some bones and teeth found in a cave in Southern
Hungary. Within the last eight years, however, no less than nine
living species of the genus have been described, all from Boreal
North America. Ninety-five specimens have been at the disposal of

4 NATURAL SCIENCE [July

Mr Gerrit S. Miller, jun., who, in the Proceedings of the Biological
Society of Washington (xi., pp. 77-87, April 21, 1897), considers
that there are six valid species. These fall naturally into three
groups, each of which occupies a different geographic region. They
generally inhabit dry, grassy plains and mountain parks, and,
except for some small characters in the teeth, are much like the
ordinary Microtus ; from the humid coast district of Oregon, how-
ever, there comes a long-tailed form, which appears to be strictly
arboreal.

The Geographical Distribution of the Dragon-flies

One of the greatest surprises in store for the student at the
outset of his study of zoo-geography is the discovery that animals
so different in their powers of locomotion as mammalia and birds
agree nevertheless so closely in geographical distribution, that
a map representing the zoological areas of the one class, will, in its
broad outlines, be equally applicable to the other. The obvious
inference to be drawn from this circumstance, the inference, namely,
that the actual means of progression, whether it be flight or swim-
ming or running, are far less important factors in determining the
dispersal of species than one would be led on a 'priori grounds to
suppose, is still further supported by a recent paper on " The
Geographical Distribution of Dragon-flies," published by Mr G. H.
Carpenter in vol. viii. of the Scientific Proceedings of the Royal Dublin
Society. Though this paper is chiefly nothing but a compilation
from Mr W. F. Kirby's catalogue of the Odonata, it is nevertheless
a valuable piece of work, since it represents in a concise and
intelligible form the range of all the genera of the great order of
powerful-flying insects, and is accompanied by a map showing how
closely in the main their distribution tallies with that of the other
orders and classes of terrestrial animals that have been faunistically
studied. Seven regions are recognised : the Holarctic, comprising
the Palaearctic of Sclater and Wallace, phis the Nearctic almost down
to the fortieth parallel of latitude ; the Ethiopian ; the Mascarene ;
the Oriental ; the Australian, including New Zealand ; the Sonoran ;.
and the Neotropical. It is interesting to note that there is no
evidence of a Mediterranean region in the Old World corresponding
to the Sonoran of the New, and that the species from Madagascar
are no more Ethiopian than Oriental in their affinities. The advo-
cates of Lemuria may get some satisfaction from the latter circum-
stance; but those who are in favour of an Antarctic area will not
gain much support from the dragon-flies, since the species of these
insects that inhabit Patagonia, Cape Colony, and New Zealand bear
no witness to a former land connection between these countries.

1897] NOTES AND COMMENTS 5

The AuTiiRoroDs of Funafuti

Part II. of the " Memoir on the Atoll of Funafuti," based on
collections made by Mr Charles Hedley, was published by the
Australian Museum, Sydney, on February 25, 1897. Its arrival
gives us rather a shock, for we were under the impression
that, when the Royal Society invited the Australian Museum to
send a naturalist on their expedition, a stipulation was made that
the representatives of the Royal Society should retain the right
of prior publication. If such an agreement was not made, it ought
to have been, in the interests not merely of justice, but, as this
publication proves, of science also.

Mr W. J. Rainbow undertakes to describe the whole of the land
arthropods, and his knowledge is scarcely commensurate with the
undertaking. Whose knowledge could be ? Probably it is not Mr
Rainbow who is to blame, but the authorities of the Australian
Museum, who, like the head officials in many other scientific
institutions, seem to think that they have only to say to a
subordinate, " Do ! " and he doeth it, even though it be a task for
which years of training are necessary. In recent zoology, just as
in palaeontology, work of this kind can only be done well by the
specialist having at his disposal large collections and complete
libraries. We have no wish to be hard on an obedient servant, but
we must justify our remarks by a few selected criticisms of Mr
Rainbow's work.

On p. 97, the syllable "Nob." following "genus Zispe," is, no
doubt, a printer's error for ' Latr,' since Latreille founded this genus
in 1796. We let this pass, but discover from the figure that the
single female specimen, here made the type of a new species of
Lispc, is not a Lispe at all, and does not even belong to the same
family. So far as may be judged from the figure, it is a Coelopa
(family, Phycodromidae.) " Nob." again, this time following " genus
Ebenia " ! Mr Rainbow may have described a genus under the
name Ebenia, though he gives no reference to the place where he
published it ; but the real Ebenia was founded by Macquart for a
Brazilian species having no sort of affinity with the two specimens
here described under that name. It is impossible to say whether
the four species of Diptera described, three on the evidence of single
specimens, are new or not ; the descriptions are too short to be of
value, the figures are atrocious, no reference is made to allied forms,
and the author, while including family characters, ignores those of
specific rank. With the exotic Muscidae {sens, lat.) in their present
state of chaos, every attempt of inexperienced workers to describe
new species is a distinct retarding of science.

Of Arachnida, 88 specimens were secured, and these are

6 NATURAL SCIENCE [July

distributed by Mr Eainbow into 25 species, of which 15 are
new. Fifteen ! At any rate Epcira ventricosa, and probably some
of the other species of Epeira described as new, appear to be nothing
but representatives of that wide-spread, highly variable, and well-
known species Epeira thc'is ; while Hyllus ferox and H. audax, sup-
posed new species, have been placed in a wrong genus, and are
probably old friends.

The scorpion described as " Btdhus brevicaudatus sp. n. " belongs
to a totally different family from Buthus; it is perhaps the best
known of all scorpions, and more than a century ago Fabricius
named it Hormurus australasiae.

Fortunately for Mr Rainbow and for us, he does recognise
that some of the species found on Funafuti are neither new nor
peculiar to that island, but that they have been introduced by man.
Among these are certain mosquitoes, which the natives catch with a
kind of racquet, the meshes of which are made of the glutinous
snares of orb-weaving spiders. White ants, Calotermes margini-
pennis, attack the coco-palms at a height of three to six feet above
the ground, tunnelling their way through ; as a result the trees are
snapped off by the gales. It is probable that both the tree and the
termite were introduced by human agency, via Hawaii, about two
centuries ago.

The Crustaceans and Echinodeems of Funafuti

These animals have fallen into the more experienced hands of
Mr T. Whitele^e. The Crustacea are the lords of the atoll, swarm-
ing into all vacant places. " The Coenobita," says Mr Hedley,
" wander across from shore to shore, and dispute any stray edibles
with the rats. Some crabs even take up their residence in the tree
tops of Pandanus, while, as everybody knows, Birgus is as much at
home on a palm bole as a squirrel on an oak. . . . Human habita-
tions are not even secure from crabs. . . . Active as they are during
the day, it is at night that the land crabs hold high carnival. On
the beaches the Crustacea were everywhere abundant, particular
species possessing each their special zone. About high tide mark
on the windward shore promenaded Grapsus maculatus, a crowd of
which scattered before the footsteps of a visitor, and sought refuge
under loose coral blocks or in deep pools. Eolling over a slab of
dead coral rock anywhere between tide marks, exposed the haunt of
a little community of Pctrolisthes dcntata and Lcioloplms planissimus.
Intercepted in their efforts to escape, these would flatten themselves
clown to the surface of the stone so closely that the collector's
fingers with difficulty grasped them. The deeper rock-pools at the
border of the reef-flat, the chief home of Salarms, were usually

1897] NOTES AND COMMENTS 1

tenanted by a few Calcinus clcgans, whose brilliant red, blue, and
white claws distinguished it as the dandy of the company. This
species is never out of the range of the rough waves. The extreme
windward portion of the reef left dry at low tide was but rarely
attainable ; Aniculus, whose bristly claws usually protruded from a
stolen Turbo shell, was a distinctive feature of this zone. In the
honey-combed pits of the millipore mounds that breasted the surf,
cowered Daira pcrlata. The close resemblance of colour and contour
to the surrounding rock rendered this crab difficult to detect, and
when seen the creature's powers of adherence and the sweep of the
Pacific rollers rendered it as difficult to seize."

Gcograpsus crinipcs, Dana, occurred in association with Coenobita
and Cardisoma, at a distance from the sea, among broken coral rocks
shaded by vegetation. This is the first instance of a grapsoid crab
living wholly on dry land, and it displays interesting adaptations to
terrestrial conditions. It breathes by hair-lined pores between the
bases of the second and third pairs of walking-legs ; and its colour,
a dirty yellowish-white, harmonises with that of the coral fragments.

Athelguc aniculi is a new Epicarid living on Aniculus typicus, a
hermit crab that lives in the shell of Turbo sctosus, on the outer edge
of the reef, most exposed to the surf.

The collection of echinoderms comprises 130 specimens, repre-
senting 19 species, mostly common forms : — 7 echinoids, 3 asteroids,
3 ophiuroids, 6 holothurians. A detailed description is given of
two specimens referred to Culcita acutispina. Most specimens of
this starfish, as also of Anthcnea acuta, common in Port Jackson, are
unsymmetrical when dredged up ; but, if placed on a level surface
in sea-water, they soon regain their natural form, and may be killed
in that state either by flooding them with fresh water or by placing
them in strong spirit. Neglect to take these precautions may have
led to the establishment of invalid species.

Granivorous Insects

Another of the excellent Bulletins (N.S. No. 8) issued by the
Entomological Division of the U. S. A. Department of Agricul-
ture has reached us. It is written by Mr F. H. Chittenden, and
deals with insects which have been observed in* North America to
injure stored grain and other vegetable products. It is of interest
to find included among these, certain beetles of the family Dermes-
tidae and their grubs. These insects, which include the well-known
' Bacon Beetle,' have long been notorious as devourers of dried
animal matter, but have not attracted attention as vegetarians. It
appears, however, that some of them can find sustenance on stored
grain, meal, and cloth.

8 NATURAL SCIENCE [July

A Study in Parasitism

Bulletin No. 5 (Technical Series) of the same department con-
tains an exhaustive account by Mr L. D. Howard of the insect-
enemies of the white-marked tussock moth (Orgyia leucostigma).
The hairy caterpillars of this moth have become, during recent
years, highly injurious to foliage trees in the cities of the northern
States. It appears that the vast multiplication of these caterpillars
began with the introduction of the European sparrow. This bird
has well-nigh exterminated other caterpillars which used to compete
with the ' tussocks ' for a livelihood on the trees ; it will not touch
the hair-protected ' tussocks ' itself, but it has largely driven out
the native birds which used to feed on them. Fortunately, how-
ever, an army of insect-parasites keep the caterpillars from increas-
ing beyond all bounds. Fifteen species of Hymenoptera and six of
Diptera are described as laying their eggs in either larva or pupa of
the Orgyia. These parasites are in their turn subject to attack by
thirteen species of minute Hymenoptera. An alarming increase of
the ' tussocks ' at Washington during the summer of 1895 was
accompanied by a corresponding increase in the parasites, so that
the vast majority of the caterpillars were destroyed. The next year,
however, owing to the work of the secondary parasites, the ' tussock '
recovered its ground to a considerable extent. Two species of tiny
hymenoptera were proved to be ' tertiary ' parasites, their grubs
devouring those of the secondaries. Finally, eleven species of
Diptera act as scavengers, their grubs feeding on the dead pupae and
cocoon-masses of the contending insect -armies.

A Study in Commensalism

It is cheering to turn from this summary of conflict and slaughter
to another side of insect-life lately investigated by Mr C. Janet.
In a little work of 6 2 pages (" Sur le Lasius mixtus, YAntennophorus
uhlmanni, &c. " : Limoges, 1897) he describes the relations which
subsist between social ants (Lasias) and certain gamasid mites and
other arthropods which are found in their nests. The mites of the
species Antennophorus uhlmanni are carried about by the worker
ants ; in their penultimate and adult stages they seem unable to
make their own way about the nest, and wait feeling with their long
front legs for an ant to which they can attach themselves. An ant
normally carries three of the mites — one under the head and one on
either side of the abdomen ; these positions are the least incon-
venient possible to the ant. The mites feed entirely on liquid dis-
gorged by their hosts. An individual under an ant's head naturally

1897] NOTES AND COMMENTS 9

draws his supply from the insect's mouth, especially when she dis-
gorges to feed a comrade. A mite carried on the abdomen of an
ant taps, with his two front pairs of feet, another ant which happens
to be near, and for thus asking obtains food. No benefit to the ants
from the presence of these mites is suggested, and the relation bears
the aspect of disinterested charity.

Another species of mite, Discopoma comata, is on the other hand a
true parasite. These gamasids attach themselves to the ant's ab-
domen, pierce the intersegmental membrane, and suck food-supplies.

A bristle-tail or thysanure, Lepismina polypoda, plays the part of
pickpocket in the ant-colony. He comes stealthily between two
ants when one is feeding the other, grabs the drop of liquid nourish-
ment in its passage, and makes his escape as quickly as possible to
levy contribution on other couples until his hunger is satisfied.

The Pigments of the Decapod Crustacea

Another interesting contribution has just been made to our know-
ledge of the pigments of the decapod Crustacea by Miss M. I.
Newbigin (Journ. Physiol, vol. xxi., pp. 237-257, May 1897).
She discusses the predominant characteristics of the pigments of
Homarus vulgaris, Nephrons norivegicus and Astacus nobilis. The
conclusions arrived at support recent observations on the same sub-
ject, but a speculative tone mainly towards the end of the paper
rather spoils the general effect.

Thus we cannot accept the conclusion "that there is some con-
nection between the little known substance in the muscle and the
formation alike of the blue pigment and of chitin." The conclu-
sion also that the red lipochrome is present as a calcium combina-
tion in the shell is only speculation. The pigment is laid down
there before calcification takes place : in fact pigment and calcium
salt are more or less independent of each other.

While in the earlier parts of the paper a distinction is drawn
between the yellow and red pigments, in the ' summary ' the former
is said to be partially derived from the latter " under the influence
of certain reagents." A ' lipochromogen ' is not a ' compound ' of
a lipochrome : it is a precursor of one. The return to Krukenberg's
term ' hepatochrome ' would certainly be unfortunate, as the organ
in which such pigment or rather pigments occur is not a liver but
mainly a pancreas, and although no band in red was recognised in
extracts of the digestive gland by Miss Newbigin there is a chloro-
phylloid pigment, which is better named enterochlorophyll, present
in most if not in all cases.

There is no mention of this spectrum given by the pigment itself

10 NATURAL SCIENCE [July

when the red hypoderniis is examined by the spectrum eye-piece by
means of reflected light.

We fail to find any evidence in this paper that the ' chemistry '
of the crustacean pigments has been advanced beyond the old stage
of solution and colour-change with reagents. What we want is
isolation and purification before we can say that our knowledge of
the subject has been largely increased.

However, in spite of these minor blemishes (and all new work
must be imperfect), we welcome this paper and hope the author may
continue her observations.

The Embryonic Shell in Bivalves

The shell, or rather pair of shelly valves of the young bivalve, that
forms before the little creature is hatched, is usually very different
in appearance to that enclosing the fully formed animal. The
prodissoconch, as it has been termed, is small, unornamented, and
may frequently be seen capping the umbones of the older shell.
It has been considered the sole stage prior to the exclusion of the
embryo from the egg-shell. Mr Felix Bernard, however, (Comptes
Renclus Acad. Sci. Paris, vol. cxxiv. pp. 1165-8) has detected an earlier
stage which he calls the protostracum, and he has been able to find
this protostracum on the summit of each prodissoconch studied by
him. The Glochidium stage in the Unionidae is the equivalent of
this protostracum. In most cases the hinge-line of the protostracum
undergoes no increase during the completion of the prodissoconch
stage. It consists of a series of interlocking crenulations, for which
Mr Bernard accepts Dall's suggested name of provinculum, with a
central ligament pit. The development of the Heterodonts is so rapid,
that, as a rule, the crenulations have no time to form, but are
superseded by the true teeth, whose development has already been
commented on in these pages (vol. ix. p. 358). This acceleration of
development of the hinge is correlative with the earlier incubation
of the individuals of this group, entailing an earlier use of the shell
with a consequent stimulation of the hinge through function.

The free swimming larval stage, which has its foot adapted for
creeping, and free mantel lobes, guiltless of siphons, and whose gills
are situated in the rear, whilst it possesses the velum characteristic
of all larval mollusca, is common to all Pelecypoda and representa-
tive of the ancestral form.

The Eeproduction of Diatoms

The two chief methods by which diatoms have hitherto been
supposed to reproduce themselves are (1) by simple vegetative

1897] NOTES AND COMMENTS 11

division, and (2) by the formation of so-called auxospores, which
are usually the result of conjugation. The former method of
division is of unusual interest in the diatoms, since, owing to the
peculiar arrangement of their valves by which one fits inside the
other, a formation of progressively smaller and smaller individuals
is a necessary result of simple division. The growth in size of the
valves is usually supposed to be impossible on account of their
silicified nature. It is imagined, however, that the production of
infinitely small individuals, which would obviously result from the
continuance of such a method of division, is prevented by the in-
terpolation of auxospore formation ; by the latter means the diatom
is given an opportunity of regaining its maximum size.

Mr George Murray, in a paper entitled " On the reproduction of
some marine Diatoms" (Proc. Roy. Soc, Eclin., Dec. 1896), has,
however, thrown new light on reproduction in this group. The
author has observed in some marine forms a very interesting and
totally new method of division. This form of reproduction was
observed in Coscinodiscus, Biddulphia, Choeboceros, &c, but was
followed out most fully in the first-mentioned genus. In Coscino-
discus the cell-contents divide by successive division into eight or
sixteen portions, and these become rounded off and lie free in the
mother cell like spores in a sporangium. Each of these portions
becomes invested with valves showing the characteristic markings,
and in fact becomes a young Coscinodiscus. These young forms ulti-
mately escape from the parent cell, and are found floating free in the
water as packets of eight or sixteen small individuals enclosed in a
delicate membrane ; later on the several individuals themselves
become completely free. It is by this method of division that the
enormous quantities of marine diatoms, occurring in many waters at
certain seasons, are doubtless produced.

As mentioned above, diatoms are usually supposed to be incapable
of superficial growth, owing to the silicified nature of their membrane ;
but, as Mr Murray points out, this view is hardly well founded.
At all events, it raises the question of the nature of the membranes
produced by the young diatoms inside the old valves. These diatoms
must obviously be much smaller than the parent, and so, in the
absence of growth, continued reproduction by this method would have
as disastrous an effect on the size of the species as the method of
simple division, and would similarly necessitate the production of
auxospores. With this question in view Mr Murray investigated
the nature of the membrane of the daughter forms, and his con-
clusion is that the valves are either not silicified or only incompletely
so. There is thus nothing to prevent the further growth of these
young diatoms to the full size of the species. That this later growth
takes place is supported by observation, for the very small forms of

12 NATURAL SCIENCE [July

certain species of Coscinodiscus which are abundant at one season,
disappear later in the year.

Plants and the Weather

We have received an interesting little pamphlet on the effects of
weather upon vegetation, the subject of a recent lecture to the
Bradford Naturalists' Society.

The lecturer, Mr John Clayton, has made some simple but none
the less instructive experiments, the results of which he put before
his audience. The effects of sunshine are, as we should expect, very
striking. Of twelve bean-plants, as like as possible in size and
health, six were placed in the ground where they would catch all
the sunshine of the day ; the other six were sheltered by a boarding
which effectually prevented any rays from falling upon them. When
freshly gathered in October the weight of beans and pods grown in
sunshine was more than three times as great as in the case of those
grown in the shade (99:29), while the weight of the dry beans was
in a similar proportion (16 : 5). The experiment was continued in
succeeding years. Thus in 1892 the fresh weight of beans and pods
grown from the sunshine-grown seed of 1891 was half as much again,
as in the case of plants from shade-grown seeds — all being grown in
sunshine and under precisely similar conditions in the second year.
In the fourth year plants with an exclusively shady ancestry produced
flowers, but failed to mature fruit.

A series of measurements illustrating the contraction of trees in
frost was made in the winter of 1894-5. A comparison of the
girth of tree-trunks in October, when growth had ceased but before
the frost set in, with the girth at 9 a.m. on February 8th, at a
temperature of 3° F., showed an appreciable contraction under frost.
In the sycamore it was from two to three sixteenths of an inch, in
the elm from three to five sixteenths, in the oak from five to six
sixteenths. On March 2, at a temperature of 39° F., the trunks had
expanded to their original measurements. To this contraction under
frost is due the frequent splitting of our forest trees.

An interesting review is also given of the distribution of sunshine,
rain, &c, in the different months of the year ; and various improve-
ments are suggested for individual months, which we recommend to
the consideration of the clerk of the weather.

Plant Chemistry

The chemistry of some common plants is discussed by Dr P. Q.
Keegan in a recent number of The Naturalist. The buttercup owes

1897] NOTES AND COMMENTS 13

its brilliant golden hue to a pigment called carotin (from its presence
in the carrot root), " which is amassed in discoidal bodies that nearly
rill up the cells of the epidermis, especially towards the base
of the petal ; in other parts, especially when the flower is fully
expanded, it seems diffused in oily droplets or amorphous granules."
In either case the starch grains in the subjacent tissue act as a
reflector, and contribute greatly to enhance the effect. The flower-
heads contain a considerable amount of sugar, starch, calcium oxalate,
and soluble phosphates, in these respects approaching more to the
character of leaves than is usual. The stem and root of this butter-
cup (Ranunculus bulbosus) are remarkable for the presence of an
acrid camphoraceous body easily decomposed into a volatile bitter
principle (anemonin) and an acid, even during the drying of the
plant, so that its original poisonous character disappears.

Bird'S|foot trefoil (Lotus comiculatus), with the brilliant orange
and crimson tints of its little papilionaceous flowers, is known to
everyone. To produce this vividness and lustre the epidermal cells
are swollen into papillae, and contain no less than three distinct pig-
ments. There are the solid carotin corpuscles, and also two colour-
ing-matters in solution in the cell-sap. One is a clear, yellow juice,
the other is identical with the anthocyan of the rose. Where the
latter predominates we get the deep red colour.

The tiny flowers of the cheerful little yellow bedstraw (Galium
verum) contain carotin, much yellow resinous matter, and " a curious
purplish substance (possibly purpurin) insoluble in cold alcohol or
benzene after purification." The flowers also contain a species of
ferment which, like rennet, has the power of coagulating boiling
milk. A substance known as rubichloric acid is present, not only in
the flowers but in the stem and root. It forms a colourless solution
in water, but when boiled with a few drops of hydrochloric acid,
suddenly produces a deep blue, then a green colour, and deposits a
dense, dark green precipitate soluble in ammonia. The disc florets
of the daisy are tinged with carotin granules ; the crimson of the
ray florets is due to a soluble pigment described as a tannin anhy-
dride. The blue of the harebell and chicory is again a tannin
derivative.

Two colouring matters are engaged in the decoration of the
primrose. At the base of the petal-limbs, where the tint is more
deeply orange, carotin granules are present ; the rest of the corolla
contains a pale yellow, soluble pigment. Although the tints are
comparatively feeble, chemical analysis shows that the plant is
capable of " an infinitely richer wealth of coloration " than it shows
in our climate, since " it seems almost impossible to exhaust the
flower heads of substances which yield vivid and powerful orange
and yellow dyes."

14 NATURAL SCIENCE [July

Ox Willows

The March number of the Botanical Gazette opens with a useful
paper by C. J. Chamberlain, entitled " Contribution to the life
history of Salix." The author has worked out the development of
the flower, and that of the microspores and macrospores, and their
germination, the process of fertilisation, and the embryology in
several species of willows growing in the northern United States.

In view of the results of the work of Treub, Nawaschin, and
Miss Benson, on Casuarina and various genera of the so-called
Amentiferae, considerable interest attaches to Mr Chamberlain's
researches.

He finds that Salix shows none of those striking divergences
from the usual course of events in the ovule, which have been
demonstrated in the above-mentioned genera, and his results con-
firm previous views as to the primitive simplicity of the willow
flower. A diligent search in buds, both of the male and female
flowers, failed to reveal the slightest trace of a rudimentary perianth,
such as might be expected were the floral simplicity the result of
reduction. The path of the pollen-tube is perfectly normal, an
entrance to the ovule being effected through the micropyle. The
synergids have a strongly developed beak, and breaking through
the embryo-sac, project into the micropyle and attract the
pollen-tube.

Great difficulty was experienced in finding the antipodal cells
in the embryo-sac; only in six cases out of several hundreds examined
were they clearly seen. This leads the author to suggest that their
reputed absence in Casuarina may be due to a similar difficulty.
The course of cell-division, in the development of the embryo from
the fertilised ovum, shows several differences in detail from that
described by Hanstein for Cajjsella.

Some interesting sports were also noted. Besides the well-
known mixed catkins, which were observed in considerable number
on a vigorous plant of S. glaucophylla in three successive seasons,
the writer describes and figures the growth of stamens inside the
ovary, an occurrence hitherto unknown in Salix. These intra-
ovarian stamens consisted generally of a one-celled stalked or sessile
anther, borne on the wall of the carpel or on a placenta-like out-
growth. Occasionally these ambisporangiate ovaries had a perfectly
natural appearance, but generally they were more or less deformed.
The ovules were generally inverted (anatropous), their normal form ;
but occasionally upright (orthotropous) ovules were found, sometimes
borne on a long stalk. Quite normal embryo-sacs and embryos were
produced in these sporting pistils. Masters in his "Teratology"
mentions only one authenticated case of the formation of stamens

1897] NOTES AND COMMENTS 15

within the ovary cavity, namely in Baeckca diosmifolia (a member
of the myrtle family). Certain ovaries of quite normal external
appearance contained numerous perfect or sometimes imperfect
stamens, but no trace of any ovules.

Some Basic Dyke-kocks from Southern India

A recent issue of the Records of the Geological Survey of India
(vol. xxx. part i.) contains a paper by Mr T. H. Holland dealing
with certain basic dykes widely distributed in Peninsular India.
On both geological and petrographical grounds they are correlated
with the Cuddapah lava-flows, and they shew none of the effects
of dynamic metamorphism so general in the older series of dykes
referred to in the Dharwar system. The author treats the rocks
under three groups : olivine-norite, augite-norite, and augite-diorite.
The first consists essentially of olivine, enstatite, augite, and a basic
plagioclase, with subordinate biotite. The second lacks olivine, and
has more augite relatively to enstatite. In the third group biotite
and usually enstatite have disappeared, a comparatively late crys-
tallization of augite gives a tendency to the ophitic structure, and
interstitial micropegmatite (sometimes with potash-felspar) is invari-
ably present. Considerable variations occur, including transitions
in the first group to peridotites and in the second to pyroxene-rocks.
To each group there are ' hemicrystalline ' equivalents corresponding
with the rocks of plutonic habitus, and some of these present types
not hitherto described but comparable with the limburgites or
magma-basalts. These contain phenocrysts of olivine, of enstatite,
or of both minerals in a dark compact matrix, largely of glass. The
author also points out resemblances between the dyke-rocks and the
Cuddapah lavas of which they are the probable equivalents.

The rocks styled augite-diorites seem to be practically identical
with some which in this country have been termed quartz-bearing
gabbros, etc., and the author makes an interesting comparison
between the Indian examples and those of Carrock Fell, St David's
Head, and Carlingford, with the well-known rocks of Penmaenmawr
and the Whin Sill. He finds no evidence to support Professor
Sollas' suggestion that the micropegmatite in such rocks is the result
of a later injection of a distinct acid magma into minute veins and
druses. He regards it as the final product of crystallization of the
rock formed under somewhat changed (' aqueo-igneous ') conditions,
consequent upon the concentration of the original water in the
residual magma. He suggests that distinct veins of granophyre
traversing the rock, as described by Sollas in thfe Carlingford dis-
trict, may be ' contemporaneous veins ' rather than later injections,

16 NATURAL SCIENCE [July

and that even the considerable bodies of granophyre so often
associated with gabbro in many districts may be due to the squeezing
out of the residual magma under greater pressure. Such a hypo-
thesis is certainly in accord with conclusions reached by quite
different lines of penological research, and has the advantage of
brino-ino* into relation a number of facts which are already well
known. In this view differences of pressure due to more or less
deep-seated consolidation are held to account for the association of
the pyroxene-plagioclase-aggregate and micropegmatite, sometimes as
contiguous and obviously cognate bodies of rock, sometimes as con-
stituents of one and the same rock.

Taking Time by the Fokelock

In these days when a determined effort is being made to settle
once for all the dates of publication of generic and specific names,
and when bibliographers like Mr Sherborn are devoting them-
selves to finding out the times of issue of classical works issued at
irregular intervals and with no record of their appearance, one is
horror-stricken to find a contemporary, held in high esteem by reason
of the beauty of its illustrations and the scientific character of its
letterpress, doing its best not merely to conceal the dates of the
appearance of its fascicules, but actually endeavouring to give a false
impression of punctuality.

The part of the Journal de Conchyliologic for October 1895, and
dated '1st October 1895/ appeared in this country on 3rd Sept.
1896, and contained the descriptions of several new species.

In the issue for Jan. 1896, ostensibly published ' 1st Jan.
1896,' but received on 21st Dec. 1896, these are referred to
in the following form : " [Genus, species, author], Journal de
Conchyliologie, vol. xxxiii., 1895," thus giving the impression ■
that they were published before they actually were, and laying
traps for the unwary priority-student of the future. We have
every sympathy with journals which try by prompt publication to
•live their contributors the fair reward of their labours, but — ' fair
play is a jewel.'

591.9/9 17

593.12

On the Distribution of the Pelagic Foraminifera at
the Surface and on the Floor of the Ocean.

THE pelagic Foraminifera play a most important role in the
economy of the present ocean, as well as in the geological
history of our planet. Living specimens of these pelagic Protozoa
are distributed everywhere in the surface waters of the open ocean,
about fifteen or twenty species being met with in the surface waters
of the tropics, and one or two dwarfed species are captured among
the floating icebergs of the Arctic and Antarctic regions. The dead
shells of these Foraminifera make up by far the larger part of the
carbonate of linie present in the deep-sea deposits known as Pteropod
and Globigerina Oozes, which cover about 50,000,000 square miles
of the ocean's bed. In addition, they make up the major part of
the carbonate of lime present in the other deep-sea deposits, such as
Diatom Ooze, Eadiolarian Ooze, Eed Clay, and the deeper terrigenous
deposits which are laid down in close proximity to continents and
oceanic islands. Indeed, it may be said that, taken as a whole,
nine-tenths of the carbonate of lime in marine deposits from depths
greater than one hundred fathoms is derived from the dead shells of
the pelagic Foraminifera.

When the Challenger set out on her cruise around the world,
all the naturalists of the expedition believed that the habitat of the
Glohigcrinae was on the sea-bed in deep water. This opinion was
held by Wallich,1 Carpenter,2 and Wyville Thomson.3 Gwyn
Jeffreys,4 however, took another view ; he regarded the Globigcrinae
as surface organisms, and the Globigerina Ooze as made up of dead
shells which had fallen to the bottom from the surface waters. The
fact that M'Donald5 and Major Owen6 had captured several species
of these Foraminifera in tow-nets at the sea-surface appears to have

1 The North Atlantic Sea-bed. London, 1862; also Deep-Sea Researches on the
Biology of Globigerina. London, 1876.

2 Proc. Roy. Soc, vol. xxiii. p. 234. 1875.

3 Proc. Roy. Soc, vol. xxiii. p. 32. 1874.

4 Proc. Roy. Soc, vol. xviii. p. 443. 1869.

5 See Huxley's Appendix to Dayman's Report on Deep-Sea Soundings in the North
Atlantic made in H. M.S. Cyclops in June and July 1857. London, published by the
Admiralty, 1858.

6 Journ. Linn. Soc LoncL, vol. ix. (Zool.), p. 147. 1866.

NATUBAL SCIENCE

[July

been overlooked or forgotten. Huxley1 discussed this question, and,
while not coming to any definite conclusion on the subject, he held
that the balance of evidence was in favour of those who maintained
that the Globigcrinae lived on the bottom of the ocean.

During the first few months of the Challenger Expedition
the attention of the naturalists was almost wholly taken up with the

Fk;. 1. — Ilastiycrina pelagica (d'Orbigny) [murrayi, Wyville Thomson] with floating
apparatus and pseudopodia extended, as found floating on the surface.

examination of the deep-sea organisms obtained in the trawl and
dredge, and with the larger animals procured at the surface. When,
however, the expedition entered the tropics I frequently observed
Globigcrinae, Orbulinae, Pulvimdinac, and Splicer vidinae at the bottom
of the glass globes into which the contents of the surface-nets were
washed, and the attention of Wyville Thomson and the other

1 Appendix to Dayman's Report, already cited.

1S97] DISTRIBUTION OF PELAGIC FORAMINIFERA 19

naturalists was called to the fact. It was Wyville Thomson's
opinion, however, that these shells really came from the deep-sea
deposits. It was the custom to sift and wash large quantities of
the ooze procured in the dredge on the deck of the ship, and it
was believed that some of the shells from the deck being washed
overboard were subsequently caught by the tow-nets dragging astern.
But the appearance of the shells taken in the tow-nets was so different
from that of those procured from the bottom that I could not accept
the above explanation. When the weather permitted, the tow-nets
were dragged, at considerable distances from the ship, from a rowing
boat, and Foraminifera were procured in abundance. By using a
water-glass I was sometimes able to dip up a single specimen in a
glass beaker without in any way touching it. When this specimen
was taken on board the ship, and placed under the microscope, the
whole sarcode of the animal was to be seen expanded outside of the
shell, as represented in Fig. 1. When our attention was once
directed to the subject, the pelagic Foraminifera were observed in
almost every haul of the tow-net. Many of the Globigerinae, the
Orbidinac, and the Hastigerinae are furnished with long spines, and
when the animal is expanded the sarcode rests between the spines.
In the Pidvinulinae, the Sphacvoidineic, and Pulleniae, which have
no spines, the shell is frequently so hidden in the expanded yellow-
coloured sarcode that it may escape observation.

On the return of the Challenger Expedition, the late Mr
H. B. Brady1 and others pointed out that, if the Globigerinae were
pelagic organisms, it was a most extraordinary circumstance that no
naturalist had recorded them in any of the numerous tow-net
gatherings about the British coasts. This, however, quite agreed
with the experience of the Challenger naturalists. Whenever the
ship entered a bay, an estuary, or, indeed, any coastal waters, the
pelagic Foraminifera became very rare or entirely disappeared from
the nets, although they may have been abundant fifty miles from
the coast. I have never seen a single specimen in the tow-nets
around the coasts of Scotland. In the Triton and Knight Errant
Expeditions pelagic Foraminifera were found in abundance in the
Gulf Stream waters which flow up the Faroe Channel, although not a
single specimen was observed in the Minch or North Sea waters.
The pelagic Foraminifera are truly oceanic creatures, even more so
than the Pteropoda : they are most abundant in true oceanic
currents ; where these currents flow directly towards a coast they
may be borne close to the shore, but usually they are only to be met
with far out at sea.

From an examination of the large number of microscopic pre-

1 Quart. Journ. Micro. S'ci., vol. xix., N.S., p. 292. 1879 ; see also Zool. Chall.
Exp., part xxii., pp. ix-xv. 1884.

NATURAL SCIENCE

[July

Globigerina sacculifcra, Brady.

»>

aequilateralis, Brady.

ccmglobata, Brady.

dubia, Egger.

rubra, d'Orbigny.

bulloides, d'Orbigny.

inflala, d'Orbigny.

digitata, Brady.

cretacca, d'Orbigny.

dutertrei, Brady.

pachydermia (Ebrenberg).

marginata (Renss).

linnaeana (d'Orbigny).

helicina, d'Orbigny.

parations and tow-net gatherings made during the Challenger Ex-
pedition, the following species of Foraniinifera have been recognised
as pelagic : —

Orbulina univcrsa, d'Orbigny.
Hastigerina pelagiea (d'Orbigny).
Pullenia obliquilocidata, Parker and Jones.
Sphaeroidina dehiscens, Parker and Jones.
Candeina nitida, d'Orbigny.
Cymbalopora ( Tretomphalus) bulloides

(d'Orbigny).
Pulvinulina menardii (d'Orbigny).

,, iumida, Brady.

,, canariensis (d'Orbigny).

,, micheliniana (d'Orbigny).

,, crassa (d'Orbigny). •

,, patagonica (d'Orbigny).

Cymbalopora bidloides1 (Fig. 3) can hardly be regarded as a true
pelagic Forarninifer. It was only captured in the neighbourhood
of coral reefs, and the curious thing about it is that not a single
specimen was taken containing ordinary sarcode, similar to that
observed in the other species of pelagic Foraminifera. In all the
specimens the shells were filled with immense numbers of minute
zoospores ; these latter spread over the field of the microscope in a
cloud-like swarm when a shell was broken under the cover-glass.

The usual colour of the sarcode of the pelagic Foraminifera is--
yellowish-brown. In Hastigerina it is bright red from the presence
of red coloured oil-globules and pigment. This red colour enabled
me to pick up this species with a beaker on the sea-surface more
easily than other species. In Globigerina bulloides (hirsuta) and
aequilateralis the yellow-orange colour of the sarcode is due to the.
presence of numerous oval-shaped xanthidise, or ' yellow cells,'
similar to those found in the Radiolaria. When the sarcode with
these ' yellow cells ' flows out of the foramina, and mounts between
the numerous spines outside the shell, the whole presents a very
striking object under the microscope ; the transparent sarcode can
be seen running up and down the long silk-like spines, and the
' yellow cells,' seated at the base of these spines, quite obscure the
body of the shell.

The majority of the species in the above list occur within the
tropics, and the thick-shelled species occur only in warm water, such
as Sphaeroidina dehiscens, Pulvinulina menardii (Fig. 4), Pullenia
obliquilocidata, Globigerina conglobata and saccidifcra. The number of
species becomes less in the temperate regions, Pulvinulina michelini-
ana and canariensis, Orbulina universa (Fig. 2), Globigerina bidloides
and injlata being the prevailing forms. In the Arctic and Antarctic

1 See Narr. Chall. Exp., vol. i., pp. 838-9, 1885.

1897] DISTRIBUTION OF PELAGIC FOBAMINIFERA 21

regions Globigcrina dutcrtrci and pachy derma, together with very
minute specimens of Globigcrina bulloidcs, appear to be the only forms
present in the surface waters. The gradual disappearance of the
tropical species, and their replacement by other species, as the colder
water to the north and south of the equatorial regions is entered, has

Fig. 2. — Orbulina imiversa (d'Orbigny), from the surface.

always appeared to me rather puzzling, especially when it is re-
membered that these changes take place in a continuous oceanic
current, like the Gulf Stream, flowing from the equator towards the
poles. It sometimes seemed as if the one form slowly passed into
the other with the changed conditions of surface temperature.

The same species inhabit all the great oceans, but in the Indian
and Pacific Oceans certain species appear to predominate, for

— _

NATURAL SCIENCE

[July

instance, Pullenia ohliqidloculata and Globicjcrina aequilatcralis ; on
the other hand, Pulvinulina menarclii and Gldbigcrina rubra appear
to be more abundant in the tropical Atlantic.

The species inhabiting the north and south temperate regions,
and the species inhabiting the two polar regions, appear to be
nearly if not quite identical.

The distribution of the dead shells of the pelagic Foraminifera
on the floor of the ocean corresponds exactly with the distribution
of the living specimens at the surface of the sea. It has sometimes
been urged that the dead shells of tropical species might be carried
a long way to the north or to the south by oceanic currents, but
this does not seem in any way to be the case ; the distribution of
the dead shells on the bottom does not appear to be much if any

Fig. 3. — Cymbalopora (Tretomphalus) bulloides (d'Orbigny). a, large surface specimen ;
b, small (young) specimens from the same gathering ; c, distal face of the
balloon-like chamber, showing the entosolenian orifice, seated in a slight
depression. All magnified 60 diam.

wider than that of the living specimens at the surface, and this
shows that the dead shells must reach the bottom a very short time
after the death of the organisms. The fact that the distribution of
these shells at the bottom of the ocean is governed by the surface
conditions is of itself almost conclusive proof that they live only at
the surface, for otherwise their distribution would be similar to
that of bottom-living, or benthos, species, which is wholly inde-
pendent of the temperature conditions prevailing at the surface of
the sea. Carpenter x and Brady 2 at one time held the view that
young individuals lived at the surface and adult ones at the bottom ;
in addition to the fact that no living specimen has ever been obtained
from the bottom, the above considerations with regard to distribu-
tion show that this view is not supported by any trustworthy obser-
vations. In the surface gatherings the young individuals are much

1 Op. cit.

- Op. cit.

1897] DISTRIBUTION OF PELAGIC FORAMINIFERA 23

more abundant than adult ones, still shells as heavy as any in the
deposits are occasionally taken in the surface-nets. The young
individuals are likewise more abundant at the surface than in the
deposit, when compared with the adult shells present ; this is
especially the case in deposits from very deep water. This arises,
as we shall see, from the more rapid solution of the young shells as
they fall through the sea-water to the bottom.

When examining a deep-sea deposit it is always possible to say,
from a study of the pelagic shells of the Foraminifera, whether the
sample comes from the tropics, the temperate or the polar regions,
but from the examination of these shells alone it would be extremely ^
difficult to say whether the specimen was from the northern or
southern hemisphere.

Off the Agulhas Bank at the Cape of Good Hope, off the east
coasts of Australia and Japan, and off the east coasts of North and
South America, oceanic currents from different sources meet and

Fig. 4. — Pulvinulina menardii (d'Orbigiiy), from the tropical deposits.

mix, and there is a wide range of annual temperature at the sur-
face. In these positions large numbers of pelagic Foraminifera (as
well as other organisms) appear to be killed by the sudden changes
of temperature, and consequently there are indications that the
deposits, so far as due to these shells, are accumulating more rapidly
in these areas than in other situations. It is a curious fact also
that in these regions the deposits of glauconite and phosphatic
nodules are more abundant than elsewhere.

In a certain sense the course of a surface oceanic current can
be traced on the bottom by means of these dead pelagic shells ;
for instance, the axis of the Gulf Stream is marked out by deposits
of Globigerina Ooze from the Strait of Florida to within the Arctic
circle. No similar warm current enters the Antarctic region, and
consequently no true Globigerina Ooze is found to the south of
lat. 50° S. When the Challenger took her first deep-sea sound-
ing after leaving Heard Island (in lat. 60° S.) there was much
speculation as to what the nature of the deposit would be. I

NATURAL SCIENCE

[July

ventured to say that it would not be a Globigerina Ooze, founding
that opinion on the fact that only one or two small Foraminifera
had been observed in the tow-nets for several days. When a
white-coloured deposit was brought on board from 1260 fathoms
the laugh was rather against ' the philosophers,' for in external
appearance it greatly resembled the calcareous oozes of the Atlantic.
On examination, however, it was found to be a Diatom Ooze with
only relatively few Globigerina shells.

The most striking peculiarity in connection with the distribution
of these dead shells on the floor of the ocean is the fact that they
are wholly absent from all the greater depths of the ocean,- although
at the surface their living representatives are as abundant over
these deep areas as elsewhere. If we suppose a volcanic cone to
rise from the greater depths of the ocean up to within 400 or 300
fathoms of the surface, it will be found that the summit of this
cone is covered with a calcareous deposit for the most part made up

Fig. 5.— Globigerina Ooze, from 1900 fathoms in the Atlantic ; magnified 25 diam.

of the dead shells of pelagic organisms, the deposit may contain
90 per cent, of carbonate of lime, and in it every species of shell
met with in the surface waters of the region is represented. As
we descend the sides of this cone into deeper water, the thinner
and more delicate shells, like Candcina and Hastigerina, disappear
first from the deposit (along with the Pteropod shells). In about
2000 fathoms the deposit consists chiefly of pelagic Foraminifera,
and the proportion of young shells is much smaller than in the
deposits at lesser depths. With increasing depth the whole of
these calcareous shells gradually disappear, till at 4000 and 5000
fathoms probably not a vestige of them can be traced, and the
deposit all round the cone in 3000 fathoms becomes a Red Clay

1897] DISTRIBUTION OF PELAGIC FORAMINIFFRA 25

with only traces of carbonate of lime in its composition. Again, if
we suppose a basin-like depression on the floor of the ocean, the
centre of which descends to 4000 or 5000 fathoms, while the rim
of the basin has only a depth of 1000 or 2000 fathoms, then, on
the rim deposits of Pteropod and Globigerina Oozes will be found
with 70 or 80 per cent, of carbonate of lime, while the centre of
the basin will be occupied by a Eed Clay with probably not a trace
of these carbonate of lime shells. The gradual disappearance of
these calcareous shells with increasing depth is evidently due to the
solvent action of sea-water, and especially of deep-sea water. In
the lesser depths a very large proportion of these surface shells
seem to reach the bottom before they are completely dissolved, and
accumulation takes place. With increasing depth the more delicate
shells are dissolved before reaching the bottom, and accumulation
becomes slower and slower, the last traces of these shells observed
in the deposits with increasing depth being broken fragments of
large Pulvinidinae and Sphaeroidinac. The greater quantity of lime
in solution which Dittmar found in the Challenger samples of deep-
sea water is apparently a consequence of the solution of the pelagic
shells here referred to.

During the early part of the Challenger Expedition, Wyville
Thomson was much puzzled to account for the origin of the fine
Eed Clay which occupies the basin-like depressions of the sea-bed
far from land, and he suggested that this was an ash x left behind
after the solution of the carbonate of lime shells. He was led to
this view by observing that when the shells were taken from the
purest samples of Globigerina Ooze, and, after being carefully
washed with pure water, were dissolved with dilute acid, a small
clayey residue of a red colour remained behind. I was not satisfied
with this experiment, for I observed that the colour of the residue
varied in different samples, and it seemed to me that the fine clayey
matter had infiltrated the shells after they had reached the bottom.
I accordingly collected, in the course of several months, about 10
grammes of pelagic Foraminif era from the surface of the sea. When
these shells were dissolved in dilute acid not a vestige of residue
was observed. It was subsequently shown that the Eed Clay came
from a variety of sources, and that in the deep sea far from con-
tinents it was chiefly derived from the trituration and decomposi-
tion of floating pumice.2

During the past year or two I have carefully collected all the
available temperatures of the surface waters of the ocean, and from
these have constructed a map showing the annual range of tempera-

1 Proc. Roy. Soc, vol. xxiii., p. 45. 1874.

2 See Murray, Proc. Roy. Soc. Edin., vol. ix., p. 247. 1876; also Murray and
Renard, Deep-Sea Deposits Chall. Exp., p. 294. 1891.

26 NATURAL SCIENCE [July

ture in different regions of the ocean. This map shows that the
surface of the sea may be grouped into five great zones, viz. : — (1)
A nearly continuous equatorial zone, where the temperature is high
and the range throughout the year does not exceed 10° Fahrenheit.
This zone includes all the principal coral-reef regions. (2 and 3)
Two polar zones, where the temperature is low and the annual range
likewise does not exceed 10° F. In these zones there are relatively
few lime-secreting organisms. (4 and 5) Two regions lying between
the equatorial zone and the two polar zones, where a wide range of
temperature occurs between the different seasons (the annual range
amounting to as much as 52° F. in some places). In these tem-
perate regions the secretion of carbonate of lime appears to be much
more active in the warmer than in the colder months. It thus
appears that the most favourable conditions for lime-secreting
organisms are met with in the warm, equable tropical waters of the
ocean, and here as a matter of fact we find the greatest develop-
ment of corals, and the largest number of lime-secreting pelagic
organisms. In the polar areas and in the cold water of the deep
sea there is, as is well known, a feeble development of all carbonate
of lime structures in marine organisms.

From experiments which have been carried out by Mr Irvine
and myself at the Granton Marine Station, we have reason to believe
that this distribution is dependent primarily on the physical or tem-
perature conditions of the oceanic waters. When carbonate of lime
is precipitated by alkaline solutions, such as carbonate of soda,
carbonate of ammonia, or carbonate of methylamine, the effect of
temperature is very marked, and it appears to be the case that the
secretion of carbonate of lime by organisms is of the nature of a fine
precipitation in the interior of the soft structures.1 If we add
sufficient carbonate of ammonia to sea-water at different temperatures
to convert all the lime salts present into carbonate, we obtain a pre-
cipitate which varies both in its crystalline form, in amount, and in
time of formation. At 32° F. the precipitate begins to form in
about six hours as small but distinct crystals of calcite, the quan-
tity in twenty hours amounting only to 0'2 gramme from a litre of
water. At a temperature of about 47° F. a mixture of calcite and
aragonite is precipitated; at 80° to 90° F. the quantity precipitated
is about 0*6 gramme, the precipitate begins to form in from a half
to one hour, and it appears to consist of minute crystals of aragonite.
It thus seems evident that carbonate of lime would be more easily
and more rapidly secreted in the high temperatures of the tropics
by means of the effete products of the organism.

As is well known, carbonate of lime in any form is easily soluble
in water containing carbonic acid, and the aragonite form is more

1 Murray and Irvine, I'roc. Roy. Soc. Ed/in., vol. xvii., pp. 79-109. 1S90.

1897 j DISTRIBUTION OF PELAGIC FOEAMINIFERA 27

quickly soluble than the calcite form in the proportion of about three
to two. Both aragonite and calcite are apparently very partially
soluble in sea-water which does not contain free or loosely-combined
carbonic acid, but when these dead shells are in contact with decaying
organic matter, giving off carbonic acid, they are rapidly dissolved.
An experiment with Globigerina Ooze in a sea- water containing
additional carbonic acid showed that the thin walls of the chambers
of the shells were first dissolved, leaving rings of the thicker por-
tions of the Pulvinulina shells, for example. Decaying organic
matter has a powerful solvent action on carbonate of lime, due to
two causes : (1) by the carbonic acid formed as one of the products
of this decay, and (2) on account of the formation of sulphides and
sulphuretted hydrogen, due to the reduction of the sulphides present
in sea-water.1 John Murray.

1 See Murray and Irvine, op. cit., table on p. 106.

590.7(7) 28 [July

II.

A California!! Marine Biological Station.

'©j

VHE European zoologist who visited the Pacific states would be
very apt to find his way to the old Spanish-Calif ornian town
of Monterey, and to the Marine Laboratory of the Leland Stanford
Junior University. As this station, however, seems to the present
writer surprisingly little known in proportion to its deserts, a brief
account of its equipment and surroundings may prove of interest to
the readers of Natural Science.

This at the present time is the only permanent biological station
on the American side of the Pacific. Temporary stations have
indeed been established within recent years. The University of
California has several times carried on a seaside school of zoology,
both at Pacific Grove near Monterey, and on the Santa Catalina
Islands in the region of Santa Barbara. Further northward, in
Puget Sound, Washington, a local society, that of the Young
Naturalists of Seattle, has done excellent faunal work during its
camping seasons ; and in the same region during last summer
Columbia University of New York established a laboratory at Port
Townsend.

The Stanford, or the Hopkins Laboratory, as it is called, is both
an annexe and an integral part of its university. It was, indeed,
contemplated as 'early as the time of the building of the university,
when it was decided that a portion of the studies in zoology and
botany might be carried on during the summer, the students to be
given the regular credit for their work as in the winter courses.
It was, accordingly, with a summer laboratory in view, that in 1891
two of the Stanford professors, Drs 0. P. Jenkins and C. H. Gilbert,
visited the region of Monterey (which had indeed been known to
Dr Gilbert previously during his studies on the fishes of the Pacific),
and made a reconnaissance to determine the particular point of the
bay which was best suited to the needs of the collector and investi-
gator. The site they then determined upon was at Pacific Grove, a
few miles westward of Monterey. Here, in the first place were
found most favourable fields for collecting. The shores were
unshifting, the coast was rugged, while huge rock masses and bluffs
alternated with sheltered harbours and beaches, rich in forms of
animals and seaweed life. The locality seemed also a particularly
convenient one on account of its facilities for the lodging and living

1897] A CALIFORNIAN MARINE BIOLOGICAL STATION 29

of students, a summer settlement of possibly five hundred people
being in the immediate neighbourhood. It was here finally that
land was obtained, a gift of the Pacific Grove Improvement Com-
pany, and the buildings were shortly put up and equipped, thanks
to the generosity of Mr Timothy Hopkins, after whom the laboratory
has been named.

The buildings are shown in the adjoining figure (Fig. 1), but

SK?.flW'"

Fig. 1. — The Hopkins Seaside Laboratory, near Monterey, California. East view.*

the picture gives only a slight idea of their surroundings ; thus they
are seen to be built on a level field, and there is but a glimpse of
the sea in the background. One needs, therefore, to imagine the
laboratory site as a small treeless plateau, on the top of an abrupt
rocky point which terminates about a hundred yards to the right in
the picture. The sea surrounds the buildings, therefore, on three
sides. In front there is a sheltered harbour and a small sandy
beach, furnishing an admirable landing place for the boats ; at the
back the surf is breaking on the rocks thirty feet below — hardly
far enough away as it has been proved, for in the winter storms the
waves have threatened to overturn the buildings, and have rendered
necessary the additional braces which one sees at the corners of the
building. From its position the laboratory becomes a prominent
feature of the entire neighbourhood. The visitor will not fail to
notice it even at the incoming of his train, for he naturally will be
looking seaward after his three hours' journey from San Francisco.
He will just have passed through the hot and dusty valley country,
but his interest revives as the train emerges on the sea-coast at
Monterey, thence to skirt the shore of the bay during the few final
minutes of the trip.

The bay of Monterey appears not unlike that of Naples. There
is the same long curving beach, broken with rocky points, the clear

* The illustrations have been prepared by Mr Percy Buckman from photographs
taken by the author.

NATURAL SCIENCE

[July

blue water, and the same setting of half tropical vegetation, although
the mountainous background is lacking. The climate is here less
variable than at Naples ; the temperature remains almost constant
throughout the year, each day averaging about 60°R, and during
six of the months outdoor life is not interrupted by rain. The
railroad line terminates at Pacific Grove. Here on one side of the
railroad are bluffs and the rocky point on which the laboratory is
situated, while on the other a tidy little town, with well kept villas,
bright shops, lines of tents for the summer campers, a good hotel,
and a small park-like square, rich in the deep greens and light
olives of Californian plants. All about are scattered forest trees —
live oaks, tall pines, eucalyptus and palms. With these are
numerous trees and hedges of the Monterey cypress (C. macrocarpa),
whose very restricted range gives it an especial interest.

Point Aulon, the little promontory on which the laboratory is
situated, juts out from the western end of the town. It has been

PB'JCKMAN.Jlf.

~^ee-:

!*£>.-"•:

'*ttil^^

'*p n^

Fid. 2. — The Hopkins Laboratory. West view.

fenced off as a kind of marine park for the cottagers ; and here at
all times throughout the summer may be seen clusters of people,
old and young, idling away their holidays, clambering about the
rocks, or watching the ceaseless strings of cormorants, or the doings
of the little school of boats huddled closely together off the point
salmon catching, or the return of the little fleet of Chinese fisher-
men, whose curious town may be seen on a projecting coast point
in the direction of Monterey. Such a thing as the sight of an
occasional whale or sea-lion, and these will come surprisingly near
the point, or even the loss of a straw hat, will cause a flutter of
excitement among the summer visitors, diverting their attention, as
a student will uncharitably believe, from their attempts to invade
the penetralia of the laboratory.

Our second illustration (Fig. 2) gives a west view of the two
buildings. The older, used during the first and second sessions of
the summer school in 1892 and 1893, stands to the left, long, and

1897] A CALIFORNIAN MARINE BIOLOGICAL STATION 31

with many windows. It measures sixty feet long by twenty feet
wide. The newer, smaller, but more substantial building measures
forty by twenty-six feet. From the figure one may also see the
two large salt-water tanks, which have been so arranged that each
can supply either building. The older building is now used mainly
for the classes of elementary students. It has two laboratories on
the ground floor, a small engine room, and a concreted workshop,
which serves as a dissecting room for the larger marine beasts.
Upstairs a long laboratory faces the east, and on the south side a
series of small separate rooms have been arranged for investigators.
In the newer building a laboratory occupies the rear end of the
ground floor, used during last summer mainly for students in the
botanical courses ; and on the floor just above there is a room of
the same size, with blackboards, cases, and portable tables, used
both as a lecture room and laboratory. The front part of the house
in both storeys is divided by partitions into a dozen rooms for in-
vestigators, and it has, in addition, a photographic dark room.
Throughout both buildings the fittings are simple but adequate.
There is an abundant supply of microscopes, reagents, glassware
and the usual set of dredges, tangles, and nets, a small beam-trawl,
and apparatus for sounding and temperature-taking. At present
the boat facilities include only a rowing boat and a small sailing
boat, the latter almost too small for dredging or trawling, except in
comparatively shallow water. Hitherto, however, the laboratory
seems scarcely to have needed collecting facilities for . the deeper
water — enough at least to warrant the support of a steam vessel.
The shore fauna has been of the richest, and dredging in shallow
water could well be done with the boat at hand. As a convenient
■means of collecting in the shallow rocky bays a water-glass has
been found of great service, especially in securing conspicuous
forms such as echinoderms and holothurians, and has to a certain
degree served as a substitute for diving apparatus, which here, as at
the French marine station at Banyuls, might well prove of the
greatest value. The station has never found difficulty in securing
an abundant supply of fish material, thanks to the Chinese fishermen
of the neighbouring village.

A whole article might be written on this small Chinese village
near Monterey. It is but a quarter of an hour's walk from the
laboratory, approached along the ledge of the railroad on the seaside
rim of the town — a daily walk for a number of the students, who
have come to have the greatest faith in the fishing powers of the
heathen. This walk is by no means an uninteresting one ; the sea-
birds are around, whitening the tall rocky ledges, and on every hand
there are quantities of little ground squirrels — a species of sper-
mophile — which sit up before the visitor like little prairie dogs.

NATURAL SCIENCE

[July

The village itself looks as though it has been imported from China
in its present condition, a huddled little town of unpainted shanties
sprinkled closely along a crowded street, with a few shops, a joss-
house, and a sky-line of picturesque scaffolding for fish-drying.
There will be a crowd of mushroom-hatted fishermen, a din of
chaffering, a mixture of nets, trawl lines and baskets, distinctly
unpleasant odours, placards of crimson and tinsel spattered with
Chinese characters. The people are Cantonese, many of whom have
been living here for two generations. They are classed as a
peculiar poor grade of Chinaman, and are, I am told, looked upon
at home as mere barbarians, if for no better reasons, that they have
lived in China only two or three centuries, and are unable to trace
their descent for more than seven generations. To the stranger, how-
ever, they certainly appear very industrious, honest (except in bargain-
ing), kindly and painstaking. They are excellent fishermen, and in

Fig. 3. — The Chinese Fishing Village at Monterey. A corner of the beach.

several instances very intelligent collectors. Their little fleet of
boats is often out before sunrise ; between seven and ten they have
become scattered along the coast, and their trawl lines are put out,
often six or more (each about five-eighths of a mile long) to a boat ;
about noon-time they return, their skiffs sometimes gunwale-deep
with fish-rock cod, black bass, flounders, mackerel, with an occa-
sional wolf-fish,1 their little latteen sails making the picture a still
more foreign one. In a few moments after landing, the fish are
carried off in shoulder baskets, to be shipped to San Francisco, and
the boats are drawn high up on the beach (Fig. 3). The little colony
also carries on a very successful squid-catching industry, so that at
night there is often as much life and excitement in Chinatown as
during the day. The amount of a catch will often be measured by tons.
1 Sebastodes (nebulosus) and melanops, Scomber (colias), Platichthys, Anarrhichthys.

1897] A CALIFORNIAN MARINE BIOLOGICAL STATION 33

The boats go out with nets and red pine fires, which are hung cresset-
wise over the sides of the boats to lure the squid. Some of these are
intended to be cleaned and dried on latticed trays as a staple article
of diet in Chinese markets. The bulk of the catch is, however,
spread over the fields for drying, then to be packed in matting bags
for export to China, as a rich fertilizer for the rice fields. Another
phase of their industry is that of collecting abalones, Haliotis, these
also to be dried for export. The people have their usual Oriental
thrift, — they are infamous at a bargain, but make up this deficiency
by the skill with which they separate the fertile or unfertile eggs of
sharks or Bdcllostoma, and recognise what they refer to as the ' hen '
or ' rooster ' sharks or rat-fish {Chimaera).

There is also another little imported village in this neighbour-
hood, nearer Monterey, namely, a settlement of Portuguese, who,
like the Chinese, have retained minutely their foreign ways. Their
boats are precisely those one would see in the Tagus, and, judging
from the writer's experience in Portugal, he believes that the
immigrants have not improved in the way of zoological collectors.

The laboratory has now completed its fifth season, and the work
of last year seems to have been carried on very much in the lines
of former years. There is a class in the dissection of types, and in
the study of methods, limited to twenty or thirty students, each
paying a stated fee for a term of six weeks. A second class includes
advanced students in zoology, mainly from Palo Alto. The investi-
gators, finally to be mentioned, occupy the private rooms in both
buildings. These are afforded their quarters, reagents, and collect-
ing facilities gratuitously. Class instruction is carried on by the pro-
fessors of the Stanford University, during the present year by
Doctors Jenkins, Shaw, and Wilbur. Among the investigators of
the past summer were W. R. Shaw, working on the development
of conifers, E. P. Wheeler, on the embryology of Dicyema and on
diptera, D. A. Saunders, on the brown seaweeds, H. Heath, on the
anatomy and development of Chiton, 0. P. Jenkins, on contractility
of muscles and conductivity of nerve-tissues in invertebrates, H. P.
Johnson, on the annelids, and W. E. Ritter, on the ascidians, W.
A. Setchell, on (laminarian) seaweeds, and the present writer, on the
development of Chimaera and Bdcllostoma. Many of these investi-
gators have previously spent summers at the laboratory. Among the
workers of former seasons might be mentioned H. Ayers, whose
lecture on Bdellostoma, published in the volume of zoological
lectures of Wood's Holl Laboratory (1893), has merited wide atten-
tion. Dr C. H. Gilbert, as the director of the station jointly with
Dr Jenkins, has also been a constant visitor, and has here prepared
no little part of his studies on the ichthyology of the Pacific. Dr
E. C. Price, also one of the zoological staff at Palo Alto, was the

c 33

NATURAL SCIENCE

[July

first of the several workers at the laboratory to secure embryos of
Bdellostoma ; while on the botanical side F. M. M'Farland and
L. H. Campbell have been in frequent attendance. President Jordan
has also taken the warmest personal interest in the work of the
station, and although his researches have hardly been carried on at
Pacific Grove, he has, nevertheless, been a constant visitor.

It is evident, perhaps, from the foregoing pages that the zoologi-
cal station of the Stanford University has neither the equipment
nor the subsidies of the Stazione at Naples, or even, as yet, of the
laboratory at Wood's Holl ; but the zoologist will certainly find
there all of the facilities for his work which can reasonably be
needed. The warm interest which Dr. Jenkins has shewn in the
welfare of each worker of the station will not be forgotten ; and it
is doubtless due in no small degree to this care that the visitor

Fig. 4. — The Coast of the Pacific at Cypress Point, near Monterey.

takes away with him the kindliest recollections of Stanford's hospi-
tality. The richness of the fauna and flora of this little nook in the
Pacific cannot fail to leave the strongest impression upon the
visitor's mind. He will remember the rugged shore line, with its
stunted and twisted cypresses (Fig. 4), the sunken rocks bristling
with the largest sea-urchins, the bright-coloured star-fishes, the
orange-red Cucumaria, a yard in length. So too the tidal rocks
covered with Pollicipes, the clumps of palm-tree-shaped Postelsia,
the tangled masses of bull-kelp (Nereucystis lutcana), whose stems
are often many fathoms in length ; the field-like areas of Macrocystis
(i)/. 'pyrifera) ; the rich molluscan fauna, including the red shelled
Haliotis, to be found even at the base of the laboratory rocks,
Cryptochiton (C. stellcri) seven inches long, and abundant nudibranchs.
There is a wealth of ascidians, annelids and hydroids. Nor does

1897] A CALIFORNIAN MARINE BIOLOGICAL STATION 35

this neighbourhood represent the vertebrates in a less interesting
way. Mr Leverett M. Loomis, curator of the California Academy
of Sciences, tells the writer that the coast line at Monterey is
particularly prolific ornithologically ; it includes among its common
birds, cormorants, pelican, auklets, murres, and albatross. Among
fishes there are several forms of especial interest. A species of
Chimacra (Hydrolagm collici) is plentiful in deeper water, twenty
or more being a not unusual catch by a single boat. The hag-fish
(Bdellostoma stouti) is one of the most common forms of the bay ;
and in some localities it is so abundant that it becomes a serious
nuisance to the fishermen.

Bash ford Dean.

Columbia University, New York City,
April 1, 1897.

590.7(7) 36 [JuLY

III

The Proposed Zoological Park of New York

TN the great city of New York, at the present time, the only place
-*- where living animals are kept for the edification and amuse-
ment of the public is what is called the ' Central Park Menagerie,'
under the control, we believe, of the Commissioners of the Public
Parks, which, though well kept and arranged, so far as it goes, is
utterly unworthy of one of the largest cities in the world, which is
adorned by so many and so various institutions. Several attempts
have been made at different periods to start a zoological garden on
a proper scale in New York, but it is only within the last few years
that the subject has been taken up seriously, and in a manner
which seems likely to produce definite results. So far, however, has
the matter now progressed, that we have before us the first Annual
Eeport of the New York Zoological Society, which received its
charter in 1885, with the worthy objects of "establishing a free
zoological park to contain collections of native and exotic animals,'"
of " preserving the native animals " of the U.S. from further de-
struction, and generally of promotiug the interests of zoological
science.

Let us now see what the first Annual Eeport of the New York
Zoological Society tells us about its progress and future prospects.
Its Executive Committee appear to be mostly business men of New
York, who are interested in the subject, but amongst them we note
the name (as chairman) of Mr Henry F. Osborn, who is well known
to all the scientific world as one of our leading authorities on
mammals, and amongst the ' Scientific Council ' we recognize the
names of Prof. Allen, Mr F. M. Chapman, Dr T. H. Bean, and other
gentlemen well known in scientific zoology. In Mr W. T. Hornaday
the Council have made a choice as director for their Park, of another
gentleman also well known in Europe, who possesses many excellent
qualifications for the post. One of the first steps taken by the Com-
mittee— and a very wise one — was to send Mr Hornaday off to
Europe for the purpose of inspecting and studying in detail the best
zoological gardens of England and the Continent, Mr Hornaday's
account of his tour of inspection, in the course of which he
visited fifteen zoological gardens, will be read with interest, and
we think we may say not without profit, by all those who wish

X.t TURAL SCIENCE, VOL. XI.

Platk II.

BIRD8-EYE VIEW i)F THE PROPOSED ZOOLOGICAL PARK AT NEW YORK
Photographed from the Society's Topographic Model

1897] PROPOSED ZOOLOGICAL PARK OF NEW YORK 37

to make acquaintance with this subject. Five of the gardens visited,
namely, those of London, Antwerp, Amsterdam, Hamburg and
Berlin, are classed by Mr Hornaday as being of ' first rank,' and
receive due praise for their success in various particulars. Warm
thanks are also offered to the officials of these and the other
gardens for the great help they have afforded to Mr Hornaday
in his investigations. The principal criticism made upon these
gardens by Mr Hornaday is that of want of space, many of them
being so overcrowded with buildings and yards, that little attempt
can be made to imitate the natural haunts of the creatures exhibited
in them.

In European gardens, Mr Hornaday truly observes, "the large
game — animals, such as the various species of deer, elk, bison,
buffaloes, etc., are kept in small pens, because ample park-space is
not available. Living trees are never utilized as homes for arboreal
mammals. Ledges of natural rock are entirely absent, but hills of
artificial rock, and small masses of stone, are quite common. With
the exception of the great ' flying ' cages of London, Eotterdam and
Paris, the homes provided for birds are always of the most conven-
tional and artificial character. The ' flying ' cages, however, just
mentioned are so very large, and contain so much of nature in the
form of living trees, shrubs, plants and water, that the birds within
them seem to be as much at home as if they were really in a state
of nature, in a leafy wilderness."

We shall see presently that in the proposed new garden in New
York, it has been wisely arranged that much more ample space shall
be provided than is to be found in the existing establishments in the
Old World.

Mr Hornaday also speaks of the attempts made in some of the
European gardens to provide oriental buildings for oriental animals,
and buildings of an elaborate architectural design. It is his
opinion, and we quite agree with him, that conformity to a plain
and uniform style of architecture is more desirable in such matters
than a " succession of startling contrasts."

But although we have derived much instruction from Mr
Hornaday's Beport, and from the appositeness of some of his remarks,
it is time now to turn to what our enterprising American friends
propose to do in order to found in New York a Zoological Garden,
certainly better provided with space, and, if possible, better ordered
in every other respect than those of Europe. In selecting for the site
of the proposed new garden South Bronx Park, a tract of "261 acres of
forest, meadow-land, and water," in the northern environs of the
city, in what is called the "annexed district," the Executive Council
appear to have made a wise choice. As will be seen by the bird's-eye
view of the surface of this piece of ground, taken from a relief model

8 NATURAL SCIENCE [jULY

of which by the kind favour .of that Council we are enabled to give a
copy herewith (Plate II.), the ground is sufficiently varied, well supplied
with water, and provided with plenty of trees for shade. It also seems
to be conveniently accessible by several lines of railway, electric and
otherwise, although perhaps rather far distant from the great centres
of New York population. But considering its large dimensions it
could hardly be expected to be nearer. If, however, the proposed
buildings are to be scattered about over so wide an area, it will
become necessary, we think, ultimately, if not immediately, to pro-
vide some mode of locomotion from one building to another within
the gardens.

The great extent of space available in South Bronx Park will
of course be highly advantageous to the larger Ruminants, and we
may expect that herds of deer, antelopes and other bovine animals
will hereafter form one of its marked features. Tlie manner in which
the Executive Committee propose to deal with animals of this
character will be seen by a second illustration which our friends
have likewise provided for us (Plate III.), and which represents " Elk
at sunrise, photographed from life." The following passages extracted
from the Report inform us generally of the views of the Society re-
garding its proposed collection of living animals, in the wisdom of
which we must all fully concur.

" As may fairly be expected, the first duty of the Society in the
formation of collections, will be to bring together a liberal number
of fine examples of the more noteworthy and interesting species of
the animals of North America, particularly of those species that are
threatened with extinction. No reasonable effort will be spared to
show each species of the larger mammals under conditions of
liberal space and surroundings which will at least suggest its
natural haunts, which will promote the comfort and longevity of
the captives, and render their contemplation by visitors a pleasure.
Next to the mammals, birds and reptiles of North America, the
fauna of South America will receive attention ; but the Society's
collections must of necessity include a sufficient number of the
living creatures of the Old World to furnish the student and the
general public with good examples of the principal orders, families
and sub-families of the higher land-vertebrates of the world.

" It follows that, in the formation of the numerous living col-
lections, which will find homes in the Zoological Park, the first to
be gathered will be the representatives of the ' great game animals '
of North America — the buffalo, elk, moose, mountain-sheep, ante-
lope, black-tailed deer, Virginia deer, and caribou, and also the
mountain goat, if it can be induced to survive in this climate. The
enclosures planned for these species vary in area from three to
twenty acres each. All will be abundantly provided with shade,

1897] rilOPOSED ZOOLOGICAL PARK OF NEW YORK 39

water and shelter, and such cliff-dwellers as the mountain-sheep
will be located on rugged masses of natural rock. It is proposed
that the buffalo herd shall contain about twenty-five carefully
selected animals, living in a twenty-acre range, and be in every
way worthy to represent this important species."

Tn conclusion, we are sure that all persons interested in Natural
History will wish full success to the Zoological Society of New
York, and will hope that the sum necessarily required to start such
a large undertaking may be speedily raised. From the well-known
munificence of the wealthy Americans in all matters of this sort it
cannot be doubted that these expectations will be abundantly
realised. P. L. Sclater.

571.93(42.25) 40 [JuLY

IV
Primeval Refuse Heaps at Hastings

"TTTHEN we reflect upon the abundance of refuse heaps left
VV by early man on the eastern coast of the North Sea, as
compared with similar accumulations on our own shores, we are
tempted to seek a reason for the remarkable difference. In the
former region these relics of man exist for many miles upon the
shores as enormous heaps, hundreds of yards long and hundreds of
feet in width, usually varying from three to six feet, but sometimes
attaining as much as ten or twelve feet in thickness ; while in
England they are practically unknown.

There are several facts in connection with these old refuse piles
which may assist us in our search for them in the British Isles.
In the first place they are the relics of a people who lived upon
fish, supplemented by such animal food as they were fortunate or
clever enough to obtain. Darwin, in his " Journal " (p. 234),
draws a picture of the shellfish-eating Tierra del Fuegians which,
though a very dismal one, would doubtless equally well describe
what might have been seen on the shores of the Baltic in the
period under consideration : — " The inhabitants living chiefly upon
shell-fish are obliged constantly to change their place of residence,
but they return at intervals to the same spot, as is evident from
the pile of old shells." Obviously, the refuse and rubbish of these
people would be confined to the coast, for had they penetrated into
mid-country their relics would necessarily be in the main of a
different nature. It is also evident that the comparative stability
of a coast line is essential to the existence of the " Kitchen-
Middens " ; and this idea is supported in Denmark itself, where
these accumulations are found far more plentifully around the more
permanent and protected fjords, than upon the ever-varying sea-
board. On the eastern side of England the cliffs have been
wasting practically ever since the incursion of what we call the
North Sea, and the breach by the Straits of Dover. It thus be-
comes obvious, that searching for these deposits in these or
similarly circumstanced localities would be hopeless. If, on the
other hand, we can get a firm unwasting coast line, furnished
with convenient rock-ledges, which at once offer shelter while
in use and immunity from destruction of deposits formed upon them,
we have all the necessary conditions for the existence of Kitchen-
Middens, and there they will doubtless be found all round the coast.

1897] PRIMEVAL REFUSE HEAPS AT HASTINGS 41

There is, however, no reason why the people who left these
mounds of refuse should not have proceeded inland, and there
formed settlements ; but under these conditions the relics left
behind would necessarily be of a very different nature. Certainly
they would not consist largely of shells as does the Midden
material near the sea-shore. If we found a similar set of animal
remains in the Middens and in inland settlements, it would be
something to indicate that both deposits might have been geologi-
cally contemporaneous. But this evidence would be by no means
conclusive, as the people inland, in the absence of a plentiful
supply of fish, might have been driven to the chase, and thus have
captured a large number of animals which eluded the skill of the
fisherman, remains of which would be present among the relics of
the former but not among the latter. Then again, the landsmen
would naturally be first to practise any kind of domestication of
animals for the purpose of food and clothing, and would doubtless
adopt this custom long before the fishermen annexed it to supple-
ment their method of obtaining sustenance. It will thus be seen
that, although a given set of animal remains might enable us to
fix approximately the geological ' age ' of the deposits, their
presence or absence would not be sufficient evidence to enable
us to correlate deposits found upon the sea-shore with those
occurring mid-land. Unfortunately the appearance and disappear-
ance of animals associated with man are not so clearly indicated
by our time charts, as at present constructed, as they ought to be ;
so that the fossils of man's mental evolution over a given locality
— namely, the exhibitions of skill in the production and fabrication
of articles to obtain the necessaries of life, and make it more
endurable, or gratify his desires — must serve as the figures upon
our chronograph. If, for example, all implements found in these
deposits were of the well-known Palaeolithic types, we should not
hesitate in classing the Middens as Pleistocene. If there were a
profusion of beautifully polished axes and barbed arrow heads, we
should assign them to the ordinary Neolithic men ; and if only
a single bronze implement were found, we should just as readily
relegate them to the age of metal. So also if we find a certain
set of relics differing from anything else previously recognised,
although they may tell us little of the actual age of the deposit,
yet they may prove invaluable in correlating the age of identical
objects found over a large extent of country, and justify our assign-
ing them to one race of people : and if from each of the localities
in which these are found we obtain supplementary evidence, we
may at last obtain a most comprehensive and reliable account of
the heretofore unknown people.

Judged by this standard, I do not at present see anything to

42 NATURAL SCIENCE [July

connect the people who left the Hastings " Kitchen Middens " with
those of the Baltic ; still a great deal of work remains undone on
both sides of the North Sea. The flora and fauna of the two
countries are too dissimilar for exact comparison ; but the imple-
ments in the two cases are practically quite unlike. Many of the
habits of both peoples were, and are, the common property of all
savages, or semi-savages, living under similar conditions ; but beyond
this I do not feel we can go safely, and I am therefore, from other
evidence, disposed to regard the Hastings Midden men as quite a
different race from those of the Baltic, and recognise their closer
relationship witli the race who made the identical curious little
implements in the Valley of the Meuse and other places.

We will next take a survey of some of the features presented by
the Hastings " Kitchen Middens," and note some of the points raised
by them, and the contained materials. For fuller description of
these on some points, to prevent repetition, the reader is referred to
the paper in The Journal of the Anthrojjological Institute, vol. xxv.,
plates x.-xiii.

Hastings has always been celebrated for its picturesque rock-
ledges, caves, and fissures, which exist on both sides of the old
town ; but few, if any, ever realize the antiquity of some of these,
dating back as they do to the very earliest history of the weald, and
will, doubtless, some day reveal to us our lost Miocene World.
There can be no doubt that the celebrated St Clement's Caves or
fissures originated in the great Earth movements above referred to :
that they were inhabited in later Palaeolithic times, and were
enlarged by ambidextrous Stone Age man, and still more extensively
excavated by right-handed Iron Age man, as shown by the pick
marks still extant. I have found fragments of Neolithic pottery in
them, and although much of their contents, dating back to the earlier
occupations, may have been cleared away by Iron Age man, I still
think they would well repay a thorough investigation. To what
extent they were used by the Midden men it is difficult to say at
present; but, so far as research has gone, it appears that the fissures
nearer the sea were used more by way of shelter, and it is the rock-
ledges outside these upon which the relics of the life of the time have
been preserved. Plate V. shows the general appearance of these
fissured and cavernous rocks ; the accumulation of Midden material
upon one of the ledges is seen in the front, as shown during the
excavations. These projecting surfaces exist at all altitudes up to,
say, 120 ft.; here were enacted all the dramas of domestic life,
hither were brought the trophy of the chase, the captures from the
sea, and the gatherings from the shore ; to this resort were taken the
pebbles from the beach, and here they were worked into the various
forms and implements that man required for his increasing needs :

1897] PRIMEVAL EFFUSE HEAPS AT HASTINGS 43

here he lit his fire, heated his pot or roasted the pony or deer he
had captured in the chase ; here he changed his broken flint tip
snapped in the chase, replaced it by a new one, and threw the
broken butt end upon the Midden. Here he also sat and split his
marrow bones, and feasted right royally upon the contained luscious
grease ; and here he piled up his refuse heaps of everything with
which he for the time being had done.

It is difficult to say which are the most interesting, the fauna of
the period, the relics of which have been stored up in these old
heaps, or the fossils of man's civilization in the form of flint and
bone implements, pottery, etc, We will take the latter first, as
belonging to the highest of the mammals represented.

THE WORKED FLINTS.

Being away from the chalk, the supply of flint had to be drawn
from the pebbles on the sea shore. These were taken up to the
settlement, and in several places heaps of these were found : they
were sometimes ' quartered ' when flat flakes were required, at
others they were flaked into long narrow flakes, which required but
little, if anything, done to them to make them fit for use. The
almost absence of the ordinary more or less circular-edged skin-
scraper- — the commonest of all Neolithic implements — is very
remarkable ; but some spatulate forms were found, several of which
were tanged for hafting. There were no large axes or adzes found,
nor even the small triangular form, which exist in such profusion in
the Danish Kitchen Middens, and no flint bore the slightest trace
of polishing. One of the most remarkable and interesting features
of the flints was the variety of forms of the chisels, gouges, and
gravers, the cutting edges being always well worked, and either
rounded or rectangular, turning now to the left and now to the
right. A peculiar feature which strikes one in connection with
these is, that they differ entirely from the majority of flint tools one
sees in museums, in which is shown the expenditure of extensive
trouble and work to bring the implement into an orthodox shape,
although the cutting or operating edge is confined to an exceedingly
small spot, and is entirely independent of the elaborate work of the
other part of the implement. In these, on the other hand, it is just
a simple flake, which is usually untouched, except at the point,
where it is worked in a straight or oblique inward or outward curve
or line ; occasionally they are large, but not very often. With
such a variety of carving tools in the possession of these old people,
one is disposed to feel disappointed at finding so little evidence of the
practice of carving. Still, it must be borne in mind that the
Kitchen Middens after all were only waste heaps, and nothing of
any value would be likely to be found in them, except an occa-

44 NATURAL SCIENCE [July 1897

sionally lost article. That bone was largely used we shall presently
see, and doubtless great care would be taken with these finely-carved
articles, and they may be found when the innermost recesses of the
fissures have been penetrated. That a large portion of flint flakes
were intended for arrow and fish-spear tips is certain from the fact
that many are secondarily worked into bilateral symmetry. Dis-
regarding mere chips the long-pointed flakes monopolise 75 per
cent, of the flints found ; they vary in size from 4 in. by f in. down
to \ in. and by \ in. They were doubtless used for lance and arrow
heads, fish-spears and fish-hooks ; no sign of a barb of any kind
was seen. A point of special interest in regard to these tips was
that very many of them had well-worked butts, sometimes showing the
removal of ten or a dozen small flakes in the formation of the well-
rounded, nicely-bevelled, square or circular-ended base. There was
one feature about these which puzzled me for a long time, and that
was that the present periphery of the flake-face of the flint usually
truncated these secondary flakings. It, therefore, became evident
that the secondary base was worked round a single or double ridge
while the lance-tip was yet upon the core, from which it was dis-
lodged by the last skilful blow. In experimenting I found this
practicable ; and ultimately I found a block of flint worked into
ridges in the process of manufacturing these tools in the way
suggested, with one base worked ready for the next blow to produce
a perfect implement. This specimen is shown in Plate VI. , at
the bottom right corner, and the arrow marks the point at which
the last blow would have been struck, that would have dislodged
the finished tip, such as is seen just at the left of it. That
the tips were used and broken in the chase or in fishing is certain
from the immense numbers of broken butt-ends that were found in
the Midden ; as it is only reasonable to suppose that, if these
were broken in fishing or in hunting, the broken butts would have
been taken off the line or shaft when the user returned to chez
lui and thrown upon the refuse heap, and replaced by new ones.
Large quantities were used as knives, and were hard worn.

The next most plentiful tool was the needle maker, or small
hollow-scraper ; these varied in size, say, from an inch or more,
down to a tool that would turn out a bone duplicate of a good-
sized thread needle.

There was an immense number of cooking stones indicative of
the method of applying heat. Charcoal was fairly plentiful ; and
many of the bones of horse, pig, sheep, &c., were burned in the
process of roasting upon the old hearths ; the latter still remained
in places. That the pots were put upon the fire, however, is certain
from the fact that many had a deposit of soot upon them.

W. J. Lewis Abbott.
(To be continued next month, with the illustrations.)

567 45

The Taxonomic Position of the Pteraspidae,
Cephalaspidae, and Asterolepidae *

IN his notice of the life and work of the late Professor Cope,
published in the June number of Natural Science, Mr Arthur
Smith Woodward writes : — " It is mainly due to his initiative that
we now regard the strange Pteraspidae, Cephalaspidae, and Astero-
lepidae (Ostracodermi or Ostracophori as Cope termed them) of the
Upper Silurian and Devonian rocks as the armoured extinct allies
of the modern lampreys (Marsipobranchii)."

No one, I am convinced, entertains a more sincere admiration
for the palteontological work of Professor Cope than I do. His
extraordinary insight (one might almost say ' instinct ') in dealing
with many problems of vertebrate morphology placed him in a very
high position amongst modern comparative anatomists. But his
genius was all the more astonishing owing to the fact that it was
accompanied by equally extraordinary mental deficiencies — namely,
a frequent failure of the power of correct conscious reasoning and
a love of what Mr Smith Woodward calls " wild guesses " and other
persons might term " baseless conclusions."

Mr Smith Woodward, in the passage quoted, cites with approval
one of Cope's most empty taxonomic vagaries concerning the class
of fishes ; he solemnly states that it is due to Cope's " initiative "
that " we " now regard the Ostracodermi as Marsipobranchii. Zoo-
logists are of course aware of the fact that Mr Smith Woodward
has given the weight of his reputation as an ichthyologist to this
remarkable proposition. It seems to be a proper occasion, now
that he tells us that there are others besides himself who have
been impelled by Cope's initiative into so astonishing a point of
view, to ask Mr Smith Woodward to state the reasons which
induce him deliberately to assert that Pteraspis and Cephalaspis
are armoured Marsipobranchii.

I think it will be generally admitted that it is not a sufficient
justification for upholding such a taxonomic novelty as the one in
question to point out that no one has s]iown any other position to

* For a general illustrated account of these extinct organisms see Natural Science,
vol. i. (1892), pp. 596-602.

46 NATURAL SCIENCE [jULY

be the proper one for the doubtful group ; we may not, for that
reason alone, boldly assert that they are Marsipobranchs. Nor
again will it be held to be sufficient in the opinion of most zoo-
logists to say " Mr X. was a very gifted man, and he used to say
that the so-and-so's are really such-and-such." It really is time
for Mr Smith Woodward to give us more solid reasons than such
as these for classing Ostracodermi with Marsipobranchii.

I shall be surprised if he can do so ; for I have turned the
matter over carefully and happen to have a rather intimate
acquaintance with both the Ostracodermi and the Marsipobranchii.
I am unable to find a single fact which can be considered as
positive evidence of affinity between the two groups.

It is true that we do not know of the existence of paired fins
in the Ostracodermi — -nor in Marsipobranchii — but though the
supposed pectorals of Cephalaspis are probably not to be regarded
as pectorals, we are not in a position to assert that Pteraspis had
no lateral fins, nor that the ' flippers ' of Ptcrichthys do not
represent such organs.

Before the proposition favoured by Mr Smith Woodward could
be seriously discussed in the terms in which it is stated, it
would be necessary to show that the Ostracodermi are a natural
group, and no one can pretend that this is the case. The Cepha-
laspids, the Pteraspids, and the Pterichthyicls were originally asso-
ciated as ' Ostracodermi ' for purposes of mere temporary con-
venience. It is a question whether in these days of an avowed
genealogical implication in our classifications, such ' lumber-
rooms ' as ' Ostracodermi ' are permissible. I think not. There
is absolutely no reason for regarding Cephalaspis as allied to
Pteraspis beyond that the two genera occur in the same rocks,
and still less for concluding that either has any connection with
Pterlchthys.

If, in view of this fact, we consider in a more detailed way the
suggestion of Cope, acclaimed by Smith Woodward, we find that it
amounts to the assertion, that there are evidences of the close genetic
relationship of the Marsipobranchii with either the Cephalaspids, or
the Pteraspids, or the Pterichthyids — or possibly with all of them.

So far as I am aware the only satisfactory evidence of marsi-
pobranch affinities which one could expect to be offered by fossil
remains of palaeozoic date, is the presence of a single median nasal
aperture. The characteristic monorrhine structure of the marsi-
pobranchs might have been recorded in the preserved remains of an
armoured marsipobranch, had such a creature ever existed. Is there
any evidence of such a single nostril in Pteraspids, or Cephalaspids, or
Pterichthyids ? Most assuredly there is not. There is no aperture in
the cephalic shields of any of these forms which can be assigned to

1897] TAXONOMIC POSITION OF PTERASPIDAE, ETC. 47

the nostril. If these fishes possessed a nostril, single or double (as
presumably they did), it seems that it was placed in such a position
as to avoid perforating the bony shields of the head. To assume — in
the total absence of evidence pro or con — that these fishes were
monorrhine, is surely illegitimate and arbitrary. Further, there
are in Eal,craspis and some other head-shields indications of lateral
chambers, remotely suggesting lateral branchial chambers ; but the
form and position of these would be equally consistent with
elasmobranch as with marsipobranch affinities.

It seems to me that even Huxley's cautious statement as to the
affinities of Ptcraspis and Cephalaspis goes too far. He says
(Quart. Journ. Gcol. Soc, vol. xiv., p. 279), " A careful consideration
of the facts, then, seems to me to prove only the necessity of sus-
pending one's judgment." So far I entirely agree with him. He
proceeds, " That Cephalaspis and Pteraspis are either ganoids or
teleosteans appears certain, but to which of these orders they
belong there is no evidence to show." That was written a long
time ago. It seems to me that whilst there is abundant evidence
to shew that Pteraspids and Cephalaspids, and also Pterichthyids were
craniate vertebrates, there is nothing to show conclusively that they
are referable to any known group of fishes, rather than that they
are to be regarded as representatives of isolated extinct lines of
descent. Their possession of paired orbits, fish-like scales, and fish-
like median fins, renders it the course involving least assumption con-
cerning matters of which we are ignorant, to treat them as detached
groups of primitive fish-like forms, concerning the closer relation-
ships of which judgment must be suspended.

The palaeontologist is, we must admit, entitled to make sug-
gestions and guesses as to the affinities of the organisms which have
left behind them the fragments with which he has to deal. On
the other hand, if he aspires to be a zoological taxonomist he must
accept the common point of view of zoologists. He does injury
rather than benefit to zoological science when (as is, unfortunately,
sometimes the case) he endeavours to impose an unwarranted
" gness " upon zoological taxonomy as though it were a soberly
worked-out conclusion, or reconstructs classifications hitherto based
upon the consideration of comprehensive anatomical data, in order
to give unnatural prominence to such characteristics alone as are
furnished by the hard parts of organisms — parts with which a
study of fossil forms renders him specially familiar.

E. Kay Lankester.

551.47(98) 48 [July

Note on the Warm Undercurrent in the Arctic Ocean
between Greenland and Spitzbergen

[In our review of Nansen's " Farthest North " (Natural Science, vol. x. p. 270,
April 1897) we took occasion to remark that the author's recognition of com-
paratively warm water beneath the cold surface of the Arctic Ocean was no
' surprising ' discovery, but merely confirmed " the observations of Scoresby,
Markham, and Maury, and the views of Lyell, Croll, and other people not
unknown." We now have the pleasure of further illustrating this point by
publishing the following observations, with which we have been favoured by
Mr Leigh Smith. They were written in 1875, but have not hitherto been
printed. — Edit. Nat. Sci.]

THE following table of deep-sea temperatures observed (with a
Miller-Casella thermometer) on board the Samson in 18*71-72,
seems to me to establish Maury's theory of a warm undercurrent
running into the Arctic Basin between Greenland and Spitzbergen.
I cannot find an account of the temperatures taken by me on board
the Diana in 1873, but they confirmed previous results.

Table of Deep-Sea Temperatures taken in 1871-72 on Board the Samsox.

T , T Surface Depth, m

Lat- LonS- temp. fathoms. TeraP-

81o,20' 18°'0'E 33 300 42-5

80-10 6-55E 34-5 600 39

80-1 6-36E 34 50 37

40
78-34 8-8 E 37 600* 33"5

77-16 4-38E 34-5 25 32

Surface

Depth,

temp.

fathoms.

300

34-5

600

? J

200

600*

34-5

J J

250

150

200

40-5

100

250

41-5

100

>»

250

32-5

) »

100

1001

i j

230

39 "5
76-36 2-14E 31 150 39"5

76-21 0-21E 36 150 39-5

i'3<
i-2J

76-20 0-21E 31 200 39"5

76-20 0-54E 33 50 40

48-5
30 12-55E 40-5 100 34-5

33-5
75-0 13-15E 41-5 100 34

42 '5
32-5 30 34

35-5
73-27 20-21E 38 100f 35

* After this sounding was taken the thermometer ought to have been lowered to
250 fathoms, as it is probable that there might have been warm water that the ther-
mometer passed through too quickly to register.

t South of Bear Island. Warm current going east.

1897] WARM UNDERCURRENT IN ARCTIC OCEAN 49

This warm undercurrent, after passing Hakluyt's Headland,
goes to the N.-E., and some of it may come to the surface in the
shallow seas on the western shores of lands lying in that direction.
This would account for the fact that Payer found open water and
a warmer climate to the north.

Dv Carpenter, in a paper read at the Royal Institution of Great
Britain on March 20, 1874, refers to his theory as "A general
oceanic circulation sustained by a difference of temperature alone."
In a paper read before the Royal Geographical Society, June 1,
1874, he also states his theory in the same terms. It is true that
he afterwards admits that difference of salinity will produce a
circulation, but then his theory simply becomes Maury's theory.

Independent of all theory the heaviest water will go to the
bottom ; therefore, if there is an oceanic circulation, whatever may
be its cause, a warm stream of heavy salt water will flow beneath
a cold stream of lighter brackish or fresh water.

Down the east coast of Greenland there is an Arctic current *
about 200 miles broad, bearing on its surface a mighty floating
glacier, which extends to Cape Farewell, a distance of 1400 miles.
The rate of this current is variously estimated from 5 to 15 miles
a day.t

How is the water and the salt so carried out of the Polar Basin
replaced ? Must it not be by an undercurrent of greater specific
gravity running into the Polar Basin ? B. Leigh Smith.

* See Scoresby's " Arctic Regions," Drift of the Hansa.

t I am anxious to establish the existence of this current, as two great authorities
have lately doubted it. I therefore append the following note, dated Feb. 16, 1897,
from Mr R. Kinnes, manager of several whalers cruising during the summer season
along the east coast of Greenland : — "The drift of the ice down the east coast of Green-
land varies from 10 to 12 miles per day, and I think this may be taken as a fair average.
If the wind is N.-E. it goes much faster, but with a S.-W. wind it travels eastwards.
The pack may vary from 150 to 200 miles in breadth, according to the season. The
current travels a little faster than the ice, and to the southward, near Cape Dan, it
becomes stronger." I may also add that in 1874 Captain David Gray was up the east
coast on the Eclipse, and he sent me the following extract from his log: — "July 24.
Found by to-day's observations that we have driven 43 miles S. by W. J W. true in the
past three daj-s, and that in the face of fresh winds from S.-W." — B.L.S., May 1897.

591.15 50 [July

VII

Karl Pearson on Evolution *

THE belief that the fundamental problems of organic evolution
are essentially statistical problems, which require numerical
treatment before they can be adequately solved, is constantly gain-
ing ground ; and with the growth of this belief the need for finer
methods of statistical inquiry has grown also. With the exception
of Mr Francis Galton, who worked for years almost alone in this
direction, no one has done so much as Professor Pearson to make
the systematic investigation of animal statistics possible. His
development of the theory of Chance enables us now to find fairly
simple mathematical expressions, by which masses of statistics,
hitherto incapable of arrangement in such a form that the mind
could grasp their meaning, may be easily and accurately represented.
Professor Pearson devotes four of the essays in his recently-pub-
lished volumes to a popular account of some of his results.

The first essay (" The Chances of Death ") begins by showing
how regularly " chance " is seen to operate, when a large series
of fortuitous events can be observed. The regular character of
such events, and the accuracy with which they can be predicted
in the long run, is illustrated by records of experiments of the
usual kind with coins, dice, and cards ; and it is then shown that
a law of the same form as that used to express the result of a long
series of games of chance may be used to express, with the same
degree of accuracy, the frequency with which given magnitudes
of a cephalic index occur in a race of men, or the frequency of
patients of given age among a large group of typhoid fever cases.
Finally, the frequency of incidence of death at various ages among
every thousand people born at the same time is exhibited as the
resultant of five series of fortuitous events, each series producing
its maximum death-rate at a particular period of life.

These examples are admirably fitted to show how such appar-
ently irregular phenomena as death, or attacks of fever, or variation
in the dimensions of a particular organ, may be easily and accu-
rately represented so that the mind can grasp the effect upon the
population as a whole, grouping the series of isolated instances

* The Chances of Death, and other Studies in Evolution. By Karl Pearson. 2 vols,
8vo, pp. xii. 388, and iv. 460. London: Edward Arnold, 1897. Price, 25s.

1897] KARL PEARSON ON EVOLUTION 51

simply and naturally under one general law. The reader who is
acquainted with the theory of Chance, as it is propounded in the
ordinary text-books, will appreciate the great extension of the
theory which is necessary in order to treat successfully such statis-
tical results as those expressed by the remarkable " curve of infan-
tile mortality," or even those relating to the incidence of scarlet
fever, enteric fever, and diphtheria, at particular periods of life.

These illustrations being given in the first essay, the second is
devoted to the results of roulette, as played at Monte Carlo, this
being chosen as an example of results which are so little capable of
prediction by the theory of Probability as to justify the belief that
some constant influence other than chance is at work. The point
of general interest is the smallness of the discrepancy between the
observed result and that given by the theory of Chance which can
be used as evidence of some constant disturbing factor.

The third essay, on " Reproductive Selection," contains a most
interesting study of the importance to be ascribed to variation in
fertility. The material used consists of two tables, showing the
number of children arising from each of a large series of marriages.
The first series contains 4390 marriages, which are spoken of as
" Anglo-Saxon " ; they are for the most part English and Americans
of the well-to-do classes, with some from the Almanach de Gotha.
The second series includes over 34,000 Danish marriages. The
result is so important that a rough outline at least must be given.
The following table shows the number of " Anglo-Saxon " mar-
riages which produced any given number of children : —

No. of Children, 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17
No. of Marriages, 546 656 682 628 496 383 336 228 172 118 63 47 22 8 2 1 2

The series contains no record of barren marriages ; but for
reasons fully discussed in the essay, 320 is assigned as the number
of barren marriages likely to have existed in a population with the
observed number of fertile unions. The above table may therefore
be regarded as representing the offspring of 4710 marriages.

The total number of children produced is 19,833, giving an
average of about four and a half per marriage; but the striking-
feature about the table is the demonstration that half of this entire
number of children is produced by little more than a quarter (25*8
per cent.) of the total number of marriages, so that half the second
generation are the offspring of a quarter of the first. Now, suppose
this character of excessive fertility to be completely inherited, Pro-
fessor Pearson shows that (in the absence of an enormous selective
death-rate) ninety-nine per cent of the -sixth generation would be
descended from the " superfertile " quarter of the original generation.
The effect of selection in checking this result among human beings

52 NATURAL SCIENCE [July

is examined, and the conclusion is reached that it is not sufficient to
make any great difference — half the adolescent members of the
second generation beiug produced by less than 29 per cent, of the
first.

It is evident that any character, possessed by this original 29
per cent, of " superfertile " couples, will quickly spread among suc-
cessive generations, unless it be extremely disadvantageous to its
possessors ; and as an example of the complicated problem presented
by this result, it may be mentioned that Professor Pearson found,
on examining 206 families, that the mean height of 133 men,,
fathers of less than five children each, was half an inch greater than
the mean height of 73 men, each of whom was father of more than
five children; but these 73 men produced between them 561 chil-
dren, the 133 less fertile producing only 394 children. On the
other hand, the more fertile mothers were sensibly taller than the
less fertile. Perhaps no example could show more clearly than this
the complex nature of the phenomena with which the student of
animal evolution has to deal, and the absurdity of trying to deal
with them otherwise than by the patient numerical evaluation of each
factor separately.

The last essay to which attention can here be called is that on
" Variation in Man and Woman." The object is to support the con-
tention that women are on the whole more variable than men ; and
an immense series of measurements has been collected, in many of
which — such, for example, as the cephalic index, the stature at par-
ticular ages, and others — this is undoubtedly the case. But it must
be borne in mind that Professor Pearson refuses to consider " second-
ary sexual characters," and that he proposes a peculiar measure of
variability. What exactly the rejection of secondary sexual char-
acters means, it is difficult to understand ; surely any character,
other than the structure of the reproductive organs, may be called a
secondary sexual character, if the two sexes differ with respect to
it ; and if this definition be adopted, Professor Pearson's position
becomes unintelligible ; if, on the other hand, the term be limited
to those characters which are directly affected by sexual selection,
then Professor Pearson should not permit himself to discuss the
relative variability of a particular organ in men and in women with-
out first showing that marriages occur at random so far as that
organ is concerned. No definition of a secondary sexual character
is offered in tlie essay, which is apparently directed against some
rash persons who have asserted that every character is more variable
in men than in women, and who attempt to deduce social and
practical consequences from this proposition.

A more important point is the assumption " that the only useful
sense in which we can study relative variability is by endeavouring

1897] KARL PEARSON ON EVOLUTION 53

to answer the problem : Is one sex closer to its mean, more con-
servative to its type, than the other ? and that the only scientific
answer to this lies in the magnitude of the per centage variations of
the two sexes for corresponding organs."

The meaning of this may be made clear by an example. Suppose
a number of sticks, about a yard long, to be chosen by some rough
process of measurement ; and suppose that more careful examination
showed the average length of these sticks to be 3 feet, while half
the sticks were between 2 feet 1 1 inches and 3 feet 1 inch in
length. Suppose, further, a second group of sticks, whose average
length is G feet, while half the sticks lie between 5 feet 10 inches
and 6 feet 2 inches. Now, since one inch is the same fraction of
three feet that two inches is of six feet, Professor Pearson asserts that
the only scientific view of the variability of the two sets of sticks is
that which treats the two bundles as equally variable ; and he
accordingly defines the " coefficient of variation," or measure of
variability, as the ratio of the " Standard Deviation " or " Error of
Mean Square " to the Mean.

Now, it may at once be freely admitted that the coefficient of
variation, as above defined, is an exact measure, and probably the
best available measure, of the degree to which a group of animals is
" close to its type " ; that is to say, it is a measure of the extent
and frequency of the mistakes a man would make, if he should
simplify a discussion of these animals by using, instead of the
individual animals, a series of perfectly average " types." It is
precisely the measure of accuracy of the customary morphological
definition of a species or variety. But the student of evolution may
have to concern himself with another measure of variability, when
he asks not " how close is the race to its type," but " how much
material for Selection is afforded by the variability of the race ? "

The functional importance of a variation of known magnitude,
and the effect of such a variation upon the selective death-rate,
seem legitimate, if difficult, subjects of scientific inquiry ; and if it
can be shown that an organ in one sex gives more scope for the
selective formation of varieties or races than does the corresponding
organ in the other sex, it is surely legitimate (neglecting the possible
complications due to peculiarities of heredity) to say that one sex
is more variable than the other. For example, it is certainly
possible, in the case of the common fowl, to produce races of cocks
which differ more from each other in the length of their tail-
feathers than do any hens yet produced ; and the statement, that
the tail of cocks in general is more variable than the tail of hens in
general seems thereby justified, whether the " coefficient of variation "
in the cocks of any one race be greater than that of the corre-
sponding hens or not.

54 NATURAL SCIENCE [July

No one acquainted with the facts of animal variation — certainly
not Professor Pearson himself — will assert that the " coefficient of
variation " is always a measure of the importance of variations ; no
one will believe that in any animal a deviation of ten per cent, in
excess of the mean of one organ has of necessity the same im-
portance as a deviation of ten per cent, in excess of the mean in
another organ. A finger nail of double the normal length, or a hair
of double the normal thickness, will hardly produce so much incon-
venience as a leg of double the normal length. It is even certain
that in closely allied species the same per centage deviation of
corresponding characters may produce widely different effects.

There is no doubt that the " coefficient of variation " is for
certain purposes a valuable measure of variability ; and Professor
Pearson has shown, in some of his more technical papers, that it is
of great use in establishing important propositions in the theory of
Chance. At the same time, students of evolution, paying attention
specially to the functional importance of variation, may need units
proportional to this importance ; and such units may well be different
in different cases. The violent assertion that there is only one
" scientific " measure of variability is therefore to be regretted.

Whether one agrees with Professor Pearson on this single question
or not, one cannot but be grateful to him for the four essays here
referred to, as well as for the more elaborate memoirs on which they
are based. The picture they present of the orderly treatment to
which animal statistics can be subjected, so that hitherto unwieldy
and perplexing masses of figures can be made to yield simple and
intelligible results, should do much to make the study of Probability,
in its application to the problems of animal evolution, more popular
than it is, and to enable biologists at last to put before themselves an
adequate numerical estimate of those phenomena which it is the
business of their lives to formulate and to explain.

W. F. R. Weldon.

1897] 55

SOME NEW BOOKS

Oui; Dead Volcanoes

The Ancient Volcanoes of Great Britain. By Sir Archibald Geikie, F.R.S. 8vo.
2 vols., pp. xxiv. and 478, and pp. xvi. and 492. With 7 folding maps and 383
illustrations. London : Maemillan & Co., 1897. Price, 36s net.

This work is an expansion of the two addresses given by its author to
the Geological Society of London in 1891 and 1892. Those of us who
have often marvelled at the amount of detail, largely new, that was
brought into the compass of the addresses, may have foreseen the solid
and permanent character of the two large volumes now before us.
In earlier years, Sir Archibald Geikie spent his leisure in volcanic
areas — travelling, observing, correlating, and storing up the wealth of
information which is now made orderly and accessible. The 270
pages — more than a quarter of the whole work — devoted to the
Devonian, Carboniferous, and Permian volcanoes of Scotland will be
welcomed on these historic grounds. And in later years, with the
resources of the Geological Survey at his command, the author has
been able to extend his area, so as to examine the whole range of vol-
canic phenomena in our islands. Ireland is not mentioned in the
strict title of the work, but is in reality dealt with in a manner that
atones for a great many omissions on the part of British text-books.
We have here, in fact, a basis which must be consultedbefore work is
begun on any igneous rocks of the British Isles, for Sir Archibald
frequently, and very properly, treats of holocrystalline and deep-seated
masses in addition to the volcanic relics associated with them.

So far as we can judge, the passages compiled from previous writers
have been drawn up with admirable accuracy, even to the use of the
rock -names employed in the original papers. These names, in fact,
would sometimes be the better for a little comment or revision, as in
the case of the French rock-term ' labradorite,' imported on p. 29.
The book is, however, written for geologists, and largely for those
engaged in actual investigation ; it has, at any rate, the merit of offer-
ing no encouragement to young persons 'reading' for examinations.

AVhile book i. is of a general character, there is much in it that is
admirable and suggestive to the worker in the field. We may note,
for instance, the diagram of " the gradual emergence of buried volcanic
cones through the influence of prolonged denudation " (p. 75). The
characteristic structures of iy-neous rocks are described, and are illus-
trated by photographs from actual specimens. The polished surface
of ' Napoleonite ' on p. 22, and the fluidal Antrim rhyolite on p. 23,
are perfect examples of their kind.

It is surely, however, an undue extension of terms to call the
structure of ' Napoleonite ' variolitic ;. and we could wish that vario-
litic and orbicular structure had not been separated from spherulitic
in the text. The ophitic structure, again, is referred to, as in so many

NATURAL SCIENCE

[July

works, from its superficial or microscopic aspect, the enveloping
crystals of pyroxene being described as ' large plates.' As all field-
workers know, they are often so uniform in length, breadth, and
thickness, as to produce the appearance of nodules on the weathered
surfaces of a rock.

In dealing with columnar structure, it is remarked that in one type,
of which the rock at Fingal's Cave is an example, " the columns pass
with regularity and parallelism from the top to the bottom of a bed."
The other type is of the irregular character. " At Staffa the regularly
columnar bed is immediately overlain with one of the starch-like
character." Though we are told that the two types may even pass
into one another, we should have liked an opinion as to their con-
tinuity in the case of Staffa. In vol. ii., p. 210, the photograph of
that island is used to show the ' bedded ' structure of the basalt ; and
the reader might easily regard the mass as formed of two successive
sheets. Some reference would be useful to Scrope's observations in

Diagram illustrating the gradual emergence of buried volcanic cones through the
influence of prolonged denudation.

the Vivarais ("Considerations on Volcanoes," 1825, p. 141), already
noticed in Prof. Judd's ' Volcanoes.'

Another case in which the opinion of Sir Archibald Geikie would
have been of service is in regard to the relation of laccolites to earth-
movement. How far does the pressure that propels the lava forward
enable it to lift up the dome of strata and to form a cistern for itself ?
In any case, we are not left with the vague idea that some expansive
force within the molten mass itself enables it to upheave the earth
above it (p. 87, and vol. ii. p. 361) ; but might not greater emphasis have
been laid upon the view stated on p. 98, where the cavities occupied
by the lava are themselves referred to earth-movement ? Mr Gilbert,
however, was undoubtedly of opinion in 1877 that the pressure on the
fluid mass was sufficient to produce the arching above the laccolite.

A good summary of the theory of differentiation in plutonic masses,
and of recent results on ' bosses,' is given on pp. 88-99. The variation
of an intrusive magma by absorption of surrounding rocks is also very
fairly dealt with.

Chapter vii. gives scope for some of those admirable descriptions
of landscape, which recur afterwards delightfully through the work,
and which constantly remind us of the open-air culture of the author.

1897] SOME NEW BOOKS 57

Page after page attests the energetic field-work on which each series
of results is based, though now and then acquaintance with the
ground is required, before wTe can detect how much is due to a grasp
of the features of the scene itself, and how much is culled from the
drier field of published memoirs.

We must not attempt, chapter by chapter, to touch on the
numerous new suggestions, or the revisions of previous work, con-
tained in the description of each special area. On p. 145, we note
that the Cambrian is stated to pass down conformably into the
Pebidian of St David's, which is included with it, the Arvonian and
Dimetian being intrusive ; and no pre-Cambrian rocks are tolerated
here. But in other places the earlier work of the survey is candidly
set aside, where the personal investigation of the author has led to a
change of view. Here and there, work remaining to be done is
indicated, as in the Malvern range (p. 170), and in the important
Borrowdale series (p. 227).

In the latter case, the discussion given in the present work does
much to fill the gap, and is a fine example of the caution with which
such altered masses must now-a-days be approached. We have done
with the broad structural diagrams, accompanied by ' theories of the
earth,' which had to serve as a basis for future observations, at a
time when the labourers were few ; and Sir Archibald Geikie writes
of the map of the lake district, " so rapid has the progress of certain
branches of geology been since these sheets were published, that the
map is even now susceptible of considerable improvement."

A strikingly new chapter, embodying results hitherto unpublished,
or, perhaps, only hinted at in the annual reports of the Geological
Survey, deals with "the Silurian Volcanoes of Ireland" (pp. 239-256).
"We note than an Arenig age is suggested for the crushed tuffs of
eastern Tyrone, formerly regarded as ' Dalradian ' ; but " no recognis-
able radiolaria have yet been detected " in the associated cherts.

An interesting point in the description of the Old Eed Sandstone
eruptions is the occurrence of infillings of sandstone in the cavernous
hollows of lavas poured out under water (pp. 283 and 333). In some
cases, these sandstones are even stratified, reminding one of the
material deposited in the interstices of a coral-reef.

"We are glad to note, on p. 346, the decided attitude taken up
with regard to the correlation of the Dingle Beds. Irish geologists
have, more or less, played with this important stratified series, usually
referring it to the Silurian, although it clearly caps the Ludlow beds.
Since Jukes led an attack upon the Devonian system as a whole, an
attempt has been made to do without that system in Ireland, the
Upper Old Red Sandstone being carried bodily up into the Carbonifer-
ous, and the lower thrust down into the Silurian. No man living can
speak with better authority on this point than Sir Archibald Geikie.

The first volume closes with a superb series of full-page photo-
graphs of the Carboniferous volcanic phenomena of Scotland. "While
these recall the wTork done by the Geological Survey of the United
States, we can only regret that in our own islands their publication,
on this ample scale, has been reserved" for private enterprise. "We
cannot resist mentioning by name the view of the agglomerate of the
Binn of Burntisland (p. 431), which equals the fine Cainozoic sections

58 NATURAL SCIENCE [jULy

in the neighbourhood of Budapest, and the spheroidal weathering of
dolerite at North Queensferry, given on p. 455.

The second volume opens with the Great Whin Sill, which is pro-
visionally referred to the Carboniferous period. A considerable series
of volcanoes is then included as Permian, or possibly Triassic, on the
ground that " there is usually ample proof that the strata in question
[associated with them] are much later than the Coal-measures, while
their geological position and lithological characters link them with
the undoubted Permian series of the north-east of England." The
best known mass placed in this group is the upper portion of Arthur's
Seat, Edinburgh, which, the author maintains, is independent of the
older and true Carboniferous series. He thus supports Maclaren's
view of 1839, in opposition to its subsequent revision by its author,
and to the well-known paper by Prof. Judd.

Some exceedingly pretty mapping of the fragmental materials in
a vent at Elie Harbour, Fife, is seen in Fig. 217 ; and the volcanic
sections of this district are again finely illustrated by full-page photo-
graphs. The capping of Titterstone Clee, in Shropshire, is referred
also to the Permian period.

Then comes the great gap in our volcanic history, book viii. open-
ing with Cainozoic times. The plateau - basalts are attributed to
fissure-eruptions rather than to repeated flows from central vents ;
and a very valuable chapter (pp. 260-269) supplies an account of such
eruptions in recent times in Iceland. It is, however, pointed out that
the tabular sheets are composed of the union of successive flows, one
overlapping on the edges of another (p. 193) ; and the fact that cones
are formed along the lines of fissure, each sending out its separate
flows, is clearly brought out on pp. 264 and 265. The absence of
clear evidence of the connexion between our dykes and the superficial
flows is very candidly stated (p. 268). The recognisable vents, such
as Slemish in Antrim, and other well-known necks in the same
county, indicate more normal conditions of eruption.

While there is this difficulty in correlating the intrusive basalts
with the lavas penetrated by them, we must also face the similar
difficulty arising from the lack of continuity between the gabbro
masses of Mull and Skye and the surrounding plateau-basalts. If the
dykes form the orifices for the extrusion of the latter, why may not
the heart of Skye have served equally as a great volcanic centre? In
both cases, the intrusive rock presented to us is that which last consoli-
dated in the vent ; its earlier and basal volcanic products may, how-
ever, remain to us in the surrounding lavas. Surely the great core of
Vesuvius is at this moment intrusive in the earlier lavas of its flanks.
The author recognises some such argument on p. 348, but will not
allow the site of the Cuillin Hills to have any direct relation to the
existing surface-products (p. 362). Granting that a number of small
vents suits the conditions recognised in Antrim, why may we not have
traces of more centralised activity in Mull and Skye ? The difference
of opinion between the author and Trof. Judd on this point appears
less fundamental, less to be insisted on, the more clearly we have laid
before us the relations of the dykes and plateau-basalts from the
fissure-eruption point of view.

It can hardly be expected that Ireland should receive more detailed

fca

1897]

SOME NEW BOOKS 59

treatment, in regard to its Cainozoic volcanic areas, than is accorded to
it in the present volume, which is far and away more generous than
any predecessor. While Ireland cannot at any point equal the crags
of Scuir na Gillean (p. 335), so finely set forth by Mr Abraham, yet
we should have liked some recognition of the strikingly scenic aspect
of the Mournes, one of the most ' self-contained ' and solitary moun-
tain-groups in the British Isles. One page deals with this district,
while as many as seven are devoted to the Limerick Basin, fourteen
to the toadstones of Derbyshire, and thirteen to St Kilda. To ask
for more, however, when we close these handsome volumes, is only a
well-merited compliment to their author. G. A. J. Cole.

A Live Naturalist

Round the Year : A Sekies of Short Nature Studies. By Professor L. C. Miall.
8vo, pp. viii. , 296. With illustrations chiefly by A. R. Hammond. London :
Macmillan & Co. 1896. Price, 5s.

" Live Natural History ! " The phrase is our author's, and no better
example of it could be found than this book. It is, we may imagine,
just such a book as might have been written by Gilbert White had
he lived in these days, and had the benefit of a thorough scientific
training. Against the ' dry, marrowless, useless,' ' melancholy ' and
' stodgy ' catalogue-type of natural history, the author raises a just
protest. There "is also a style of natural history writing that consists
largely of phrases without knowledge and imagination unallied to
observation. Professor Miall gives us the attempted literary charm of
the latter with the accuracy and wealth of knowledge of the former.
He takes us out into the fields and over the mountains, but does not
forget that there is a well-stocked library at home. It is indeed a
feature that we would fain see more of in so-called popular ' Natural
Histories ' — this constant reference to fuller accounts and original
authorities. So many writers treat their readers as sheer dyspeptics,
unable to digest aught beyond pap.

As examples of the subjects so fascinatingly and suggestively
dealt with, we may mention : snow-flakes, birds in mid-winter, cat
and dog, the moon, spring crocuses, catkins, the oil-beetle, the botany
of a railway station, hay-time, cabbages and turnips, weeds, the love
of mountains, the reversed spiral, the structure of a feather, the
shortest day of the year.

It is now July, and we find our author treating of duckweed.
How many of us know its flower ? Now is the time to see it. Let
the field naturalist take some duckweed from the water, and, with
Professor Miall, let him examine, describe, and draw it. The reasons
for its peculiar shape may then be guessed at, and the guesses checked
by experiments with models. Thus he is led to understand more
about the relations of this common water-plant to its environment,
and the ways in which it may spread from one pool to another. How
widespread it is he must learn from books, such as Hegelmaier's "Die
Lemnaceen."

A word of praise is due to the illustrations, the fresh pen-and-ink
drawings by Mr Hammond being specially clear and artistic.

60 NATURAL SCIENCE [July

Sceaps from Serials.

The June number of the Westminster Review contains the conclu-
sion of an article by J. E. Hewitt on the cave deposits of the Ardennes,
which he thinks contain evidence to show that the palaeolithic dwellers
in those caves had a regular totemistic system.

There is no magazine in New Zealand, but the Press of Christ-
church attempts to supply the want by publishing, every Monday,
signed articles on literary, social, and philosophical questions. The
issue for April 26 contains an interesting account by Prof. Arthur
Dendy of the land-planarians, nemertines, and the Peripatus of New
Zealand.

The Photogram is publishing a useful series of articles on applied
photography. Application No. 5, which appears in the June number
is ' in Zoology,' by Dr R. W. Shufeldt, and is illustrated by some
admirable examples. A cognate subject is " Stalking with the
Camera," by K. B. Lodge, of which part 3 appeared in the May num-
ber. This appears to be quite as exciting as stalking with a gun, and
the results are both permanent and valuable.

Geologists who propose attending the International Geological
Congress, and who may be so fortunate as to have obtained tickets for
the excursion to the Caucasus, should study a sketch of the geology
of that region, published by V. Dingelstedt in the Nauchnoe Obozryenic.
Or in case this is beyond them, they will find an excellent summary
in the May number of the Scottish Geographical Magazine.

The Journal of School Gcogrcqjhy, edited by R. E. Dodge, New
York, maintains its bright and useful character. The April number
contains a short article on the geographical distribution of plants, by
Prof. Conway Macmillan, who contends that the study of plant dis-
tribution in a limited area, such as a pond and its shores, or a hill
and its slopes, would be of more value in schools than ' the ordinary
herbalism.'

In the numbers of the Revue Generate cle Botanique for the present
year some useful reviews of recent work done in certain departments
of the science are in progress. One by A. Prunet deals with results
in plant anatomy, published in the years 1892 to 1894. The first
four numbers treat of the anatomy of the cell under the headings of
Nucleus, Elements figures (including Crato's phi/socle, and certain chloro-
lenciles), and Membrane. The review is illustrated, and references are
given to original papers. The second, by Geneau de Lamarliere,
relates to descriptive work on mosses, published between January 1889
and January 1895.

New Serials

The Revista Italiana di Sociologia, Rome, intends to be a thoroughly
scientific and independent review. Since it numbers among its editors
such men as Salvatore Cognetti de Martiis, Augusto Rosco, G. Cavag-
lieri, G. Sergi, V. Tangorra, and Enrico Tedeschi, it is probable that
the promise will be fulfilled.

We have received No. 2 of the Aeronautical Journal, which to non-
members costs 2s., though it contains only 20 pages. It is thoroughly
practical, and brings together all that is taking place in the aero-

1897] SOME NEW BOOKS 61

nautical world, whether in the form of experiments, lectures, publica-
tions, magazine articles, inventions, or patents.

La Eevista Nueva is an illustrated monthly, which commenced
publication at San Jose, Costa Eica, in September 1896. The directors
are E. Fernandez Guardia and Alberto Masterrer, and they have the
moral support of the Government. The price is 60 cents a number,
1 dol. 50 cents a quarter. For the most part the Eevista is devoted to
general and literary topics ; but we notice that the earlier numbers
contain a series of articles by Anastasio Alfaro on the antiquities and
the mammals of Costa Eica. Among the coloured plates are repre-
sentations of figured jars in the museum of Costa Eica.

We have received the first two fascicules of Eevista Quindicinale
di Esicologia, Esicliiatria, Neuropatologia ad uso del Medici c dei
Giuristi, which is the expressive though cumbersome title of a fort-
nightly magazine, blessed with two directors, seven editors, and twenty-
nine collaborators. The chief editor is Dr Sante de Sanctis, E. Clinica
Psichiatrica, Via Penitenzieri, 13, Eome. The publishers are Fratelli
Capaccini, Via Sistina 22, Eome. Each fascicule, which consists of
16 pages, contains two original articles and several reviews. A year's
subscription (from May 1 in each year) is 6 lire. The Rcvista should
do much to produce healthy co-operation in Italy between the students
of pure psychology and their fellow-workers in criminal and patho-
logical psychology ; success seems guaranteed by the eminence of the
contributors.

Further Literature Received.

First Stage Mechanics of Fluids, G. H. Bryan and F. Rosenberg. First Stage Sound.
Light and Heat, J. Don : Clive. Text-book of Geology, W. J. Harrison : Blackie.
Hand-book to the Order Lepidoptera, W. F. Kirby : Allen. Catalogue of the Fossil
Cephalopoda in the British Museum, Part III., A. H. Foord and G..C. Crick. Cata-
logue of Tertiary Mollusca in the British Museum, Part I. , G. F. Harris : Trustees Brit.
Mus. The Concise Knowledge Natural History, ed. by P. Myles : Hutchinson. Field
Geology in South Westmoreland, H. G. Foster- Barham : Atkinson, Kendal. Investiga-
tions into Applied Nature, W. Wilson : Simpkin, Marshall, The Aeronautical Annual,
1897 : AVesley. The Psychology of the Emotions, Th. Ribot : Scott. Annual Report
of the Geological Survey of the United Kingdom, 1896, A. Geikie : Science and Art
Dept. Memoirs of the Field Columbian Museum, Chicago, Vol. I., No 2, Ornitho-
logical Series, No. 3, Botanical Series. Farmers' Bulletin, No. 4 : U.S. Dept.
Agriculture.

Poissons provenant des campagnes du yacht l'Hirondelle (1885-88), R. Collett. On
the Origin of the European Fauna, R. F. Scharff : Proc. Roy. Irish Acad. On the
Brains of two Sub-Fossil Malagasy Lemuroids, C. J. F. Major: Abstr. Roy. Soe. On
Nereids commensal with Hermit Crabs, N. R. Harrington : Trans. Neiu York Acad. Set.
Edward D. Cope, H. F. Osborn : Science. Comparison of the Carboniferous and
Permian Formations of Nebraska and Kansas, C. S. Prosser : Journ. Geol. Some
Observations on certain Species of Arion, W. E. Collinge : Journ. MalacoJ. On
Ctenoplana, A. Willey : Quart. Journ. Micro. Sci.

Jersey Times, June 7 ; Tunbridge Wells Gazette, May 26 ; Amer. Geol., June ;
Amer. Journ. Sci., June ; Amer. Nat., June ; 1' Anthropologic, March- April ; Botan.
Gazette, May; Feuille des jeunes Nat., June; Irish Nat., June; Knowledge, June;
Literary Digest, May 15, 22, 29, June 5 ; Naturae Novit. , May ; La Naturaleza (Madrid),
May 14, 28, June 8 ; Naturalist, June ; Nature, June 3, 10, 17 ; Natureu, May ;
Photogram, June; Review of Reviews, May, June; Revue Scient., May 22, 29, June
12 ; Science, May 14, 28, June 4 ; Scient. Amer., May 15, 22, 29, June 5 ; Scot. Geogr.
Mag., June ; Scot. Med. and Surg. Journ., June ; Victorian Nat., May ; Proc. Biol. Soc.
Washington, Vol. XL, May 13 ; Chivers' New Book List, June ; Halifax Naturalist,
Vol. II. No. 8, June ; Journ. School Geogr., May.

6 2 [July

OBITUARIES

AUGUSTUS WOLLASTON FRANKS
Born 1826. Died May 21, 1897

Sir Augustus Wollaston Franks, K.C.B., D.C.L., F.B.S., Pres. S.A.,
F.G.S., Trustee of the British Museum, late keeper of British and
Mediaeval Antiquities and of Ethnography at the British Museum,
was born at Geneva in 1826, and educated at Eton and Trinity
College, Cambridge, taking his M.A. degree in 1852. His taste for
the beautiful in works of art, and his appreciation of the niceties,
peculiarities, and fantasies of artists, whether the results were
produced with the inspiration of genius, or by handicraft and labour,
led him to collect largely in each department of artistic work, and
fortunately his ample means enabled him to do so. With munificent
liberality he gave many valuable collections to the National Museum
at Bloomsbury. It was thus that, not only theoretically, but practi-
cally and personally, he was acquainted with the extensive and many-
sided groups of antiquities and ethnographic exhibits under his
keepership. He was not a mere official custodian, but a cultured
connoisseur, and a high-class authority on all points connected with
the scientific and historical aspects of the materials or collections in
his charge. Necessarily his study of medieval things kept him in
touch witli those of prehistoric age in the British Collection which
was under his care ; and, indeed, of these there are many objects of
human workmanship dating from extremely early times. Con-
temporary with these were similar productions in European and
other countries. These are largely represented in the British Museum
by the " Christy Collection," which Sir Wollaston Franks augmented
by successive gifts of similar well-sorted examples from many localities.
Indeed, this notable department in the museum well deserves now
to be called the " Christy-Franks Collection."

In March 1864, Mr Henry Christy invited a party of his friends,
interested as antiquaries and geologists, to examine some of the bone-
caves on the Vezere, Dordogne district, in the south of France, which,
with his friend Edouard Lartet, he had for some time been investi-
gating with great care, and at considerable expense. The party
comprised Mr W. J. Hamilton (President of the Geological Society),
Prof. Rupert Jones (Assistant Secretary of the Geological
Society), Capt. (since Sir) Douglas Galton, Mr (since Sir) John
Lubbock, Mr (since Sir) John Evans, and Mr (since Sir) A. W.
Franks.* Not only had the last-named already interested himself in
Henry Christy's researches in the ethnographic relationship of various
textile fabrics, which had led him to Mexico, and in that country to
the observation of stone implements ; but A. W. Franks heartily
joined Christy in the study of stone implements, and of those who

* Quart. Joum. Gcol. S'oc, vol. xx., 1864, p. 444; and " Reliquiae Aquitanicae, "
Partxii., 1873, p. 161.

1S97J OBITUARIES 63'

made and used them, whether ancient peoples, recent savages, or
living workmen in some modern trades and manufactures. Together
with Dr Hugh Falconer, he aided H. Christy and E. Lartet in plan-
ning their great work, " Reliquiae Aquitanicae," which was intended
to comprise descriptions of all the Dordogne caves and their contents.
Unfortunately the death of both Christy and Lartet circumscribed the
work within smaller limits, for no more caves were worked out by
them, and but few plates were subsequently added to the eighty or
more already lithographed for its illustration. It is noticed, we see,
in the preface of the book that, " In bringing together and arranging
the varied materials supplied by friends at home and abroad desirous
of making the " Reliquiae Aquitanicae " useful in archaeology and
anthropology, the directing counsels of Mr A. W. Franks, F.R.S.,
have been constant and efficient, like his courtesy and knowledge."

He took charge of the " Christy Collection," at 123 Victoria Street,
S.W., for some time before it was transferred to the British Museum ;
and he individualised the specimens with accurate drawings by his
talented assistants — first, T. K. Gay, and subsequently Charles Read.
The latter worthily succeeded Sir Wollaston on his resignation, in
1894, as keeper in the British Museum.

It was with great caution that Sir Wollaston exercised his judg-
ment as to the authenticity of implements of stone and their relative
age. He was not an enthusiast in the subject of the great antiquity
of the Human Bace. Possibly, had he been induced to give more
leisure to the study of the geological aspect and details of the subject,
he might have become cognisant of the value of Sir Joseph Prestwich's
researches in the geological age of some of the older groups of flint
implements, especially of those collected with earnest and intelligent
care at Ightham, in Kent, by Mr Benjamin Harrison (see Natural
Science, Vol. V., p. 209, Oct. 1 894).

Sir A. Wollaston Franks contributed largely to scientific literature,
especially by memoirs and notices in the Transactions and Proceedings
of learned societies. He has greatly enlarged the knowledge of
antiquities and their real relationships, not only by original research,
but by his willing advice and ready information to enquirers, whether
in London or the provinces. He has bequeathed his collections to
the British Museum. He was elected to the Royal Society in 1854.
For many years an active and valued Fellow of the Society of
Antiquaries, he was elected Director of the Society in 1858. Sub-
sequently for some years he was Vice-President, and eventually he
became President in 1892. T. B. J.

JULIUS VON SACHS

Born October 2, 1832. Died June 1897

We regret to announce the death of Professor Julius von Sachs, the
botanist, who perhaps more than any other is responsible for the
present position of his science — be it good or bad — at any rate from
the point of view of the university or college curriculum. His
" Lehrbuch der Botanik," or its English translation, was for more than
twenty years the text-book for advanced students ; and even now it
holds an honoured place in all botanical libraries.

64 NATURAL SCIENCE [July

Born at Breslau sixty-five years ago, Sachs studied in the German
University of Prague, and in 1851 became assistant to Purkinje. In
1856 he was appointed Privatdocent for Plant Physiology in the same
University. In 1861 he was called to the Chair of Botany in the
Agricultural Academy of Poppelsdorf ; six years later he removed to
Freiburg ; and finally in 1868 he obtained the Professorship of Botany
at Wiirzburg, which he held until his death.

Sachs was a hard worker and a voluminous author. The Loyal
Society's catalogue enumerates 92 papers up to 1883 only. The first,
on the crayfish, appeared in Ziva, a periodical printed in Bohemian,
and published at Prague. If we turn over the numbers of Ziva for a
few years from 1853 onward, the great energy of the man and the bent
of his mind towards the morphology and physiology of plants is evi-
dent. Among the excellent figures which accompany the text and
which alone appeal to most of us, we see the originals of many which
have since become classical. Besides his Text-book of Botany, the Clar-
endon Press has put two other of Sachs' useful works within the reach
of all English-speaking students — the " Lectures on the Physiology of
Plants," translated by Prof. Marshall Ward, and the " History of
Botany." Some idea of the amount of his work may be gained from
the size of the collected contributions to plant physiology, published
in 1892-3, which form a book of more than 1200 pages, large octavo.
The relation of temperature and light to the living plants, chlorophyll
and assimilation, the measurement of water through the tissues, and
the transport of food-material, are the very wide headings under which
his work in this branch is grouped. Besides his numerous papers in
the Botanische Zeitung, Flora, and many other German periodicals,
Sachs founded and edited the Arbeiten des Botanischen Instituts in
Wiirzburg, the first volume of which appeared in 1874, and the third
and last in 1888. They represent mainly his own work or that of his
pupils, many of whom have since become well known as investigators
and teachers.

FLITZ MUELLEE

Born 1822. Died May 21, 1897

This eminent helminthologist, carcinologist, and field-naturalist died
last month at his residence in Blumenau, Santa Catarina, Brazil.
His earliest contributions to science appeared in Wiegmann's Archiv
fur Naturgeschichte in 1844, and were written under the Christian
name of Friedrich. Later on he appeared as Fritz, again as Friedrich,
and in more recent publications as Frederico — a series of changes
which have confused not a few librarians. So far as his contributions
to periodical literature are concerned, the list in the Loyal Society's
catalogue is correct, and in the tenth volume of that work we read
that Midler's full name was Johann Friedrich Theodor Mliller.
The latter, no doubt, was information received from himself, but
Miiller does not mention this fact in a sketch of his life in his own
hand that lies before us. He was a voluminous and steady worker,
but his chief claim to remembrance is his book, "Fur Darwin," which
was a first-class contribution to the subject of Natural Selection, and
was translated into English as " Facts and Arguments for Darwin,"
by the late W. S. Dallas. C. D. S.

1897] OBITUARIES 65

Baron Oscar Dickson, who died at his estate Almniis, near
Gothenburg, on June 5, aged 73, used his opportunities as one of the
wealthiest men in Sweden to succour all scientific and educati onal
enterprise, and especially geographical explorations, most notable
among which has been the voyage of the Vega through the north-east
passage under Baron Nordenskjold. Some years ago Baron Dickson
offered to contribute largely to an Antarctic expedition under the
command of Nordenskjold, if the Australian colonies would help, but
the scheme fell through.

There are also announced the deaths of :— Martin L. Linell, assistant in the De
partment of Insects in the U.S. National Museum, aged 47 ; C. A. L. Robertson, one
of the editors of the Journal of Mental Science, and well known through his work in
medical physiology ; H. V. Carter, for many years Professor of Anatomy and Physi-
ology in the Grant Medical College at Bombay ; E. Russow, ex -Professor of Botany at
Dorpat, on April 23, aged 56 ; Ch. Scholz, Professor of Geodesy in the Polytechnicum
at Delft ; Traill Green, first President of the American Academy of Medicine, and
author of the "Floral and Zoological Distribution of the United States" ; Dr Derou-
raix, Professor of Medicine at Brussels University and assistant Court Physician, on
May 22, aged 84 ; Antoine T. d'Abbadie, formerly President of the Academy of
Sciences at Paris, and the author of many valuable works on geographical exploration
and geodesy; Joseph F. James, at Hingham, Mass., on March 29 (of pneumonia),
teacher of botany at the Cincinnati College of Pharmacy, Miami University, and Mary-
land Agricultural College, and formerly connected with the Division of Vegetable
Physiology and the U.S. Geological Survey ; Emily L. Gregory, professor of botany at
Barnard College, U.S.A. ; Jakob Breitenlohner, professor of meteorology and clima-
tology in the College of Agriculture, Vienna ; Sinku Sakaki, professor of psychiatry in
the University of Tokyo ; Peter D. Keyser, formerly professor of ophthalmology at
the Medical Chirurgical College, Philadelphia, and surgeon to the Wills Eye Hospital ;
Ludwtg Hollaender, who wrote on dental anatomy ; Dr Feulard, a well-known
dermatologist, in the fire at the Paris charity bazaar ; Luoien Biart, a French physician
in Mexico, who had sent thence botanical and ornithological collections to the Paris
Museum ; L. Juranyi, professor of botany at the R. University of Hungary, and
director of its botanic garden, on Feb. 27, at Abbazia, aged 59 ; Edson Sewell
Bastin, professor of materia medica and botany at the Philadelphia College of
Pharmacy, and author of an "Elements of Botany," aged 54 ; the entomologist, C. J.
J. M. Bugnion, on Jan. 19, at Lausanne, aged 86 ; the coleopterologist, J. Hamilton,
of Alleghany city, on Feb. 12, in Florida, aged 69 ; Wilhelm Horn, director of the
forestry research station in Brunswick, on April 4, aged 68 ; Mrs Alice Bodington, a
well-known and accurate populariser of science, at New Westminster, B.C. ; the
coleopterologists, H. d'Achon in Orleans, and V. Maurice Teinturier in Clayeures,
France ; at the beginning of April, the professor of geology and palaeontology at the
Neufchatel Academy, Leon du Pasquier, aged 33 ; Victor Lemoine, of Reims, who
investigated the vertebrate fossils of the Lower Tertiary deposits near that city ; Edmund
Neminar, formerly assistant Professor of Mineralogy and Petrography at Innsbruck
University, on April 10, in Vienna ; Karl Kolbel, curator at the State Natural History
Museum in Vienna, and specialist in Arachnida, Myriopoda, and Crustacea ; on Ponape,
one of the Caroline Islands, J. S. Kubary, who had a wide acquaintance with the
fauna and flora of the South Seas ; on Feb. 7, in Lyons, the botanist, Alexis Jordan,
author of " Icones ad Floram Europae," aged 83; on Feb. 17, at Ashton-on-Ribble,
the entomologist, J. B. Hodgkinson, aged 73 ; Friedrich Wilhelm Klatt, teacher
of botany in Hamburg, on March 3 ; George W. Traill, the marine algologist ; on
Feb. 7, in Moscow, the curator of the Zoological Museum, Alexander N. Kortschagin,
carcinologist ; on Feb. 27, at Luebo on the Kassai, Congo State, the Belgian botanist,
Alfred Dewevre ; on Feb. 28, at Grange-over-Sands, the Rev. John Edward Cross,
author of a paper on the geology of N.-W. Lincolnshire, aged 73 ; on March 18, in
Cassel, the ichthyologist, Friedrich Seelig, aged 69 ; Prof. Hermann Friedrich
Kessler, student of Aphides in Cassel ; Heinrich Wankel, anthropologist, in
Olmutz, aged 76 ; Emile Magitot, President of the Societe d'Authropologie of Paris,
and an eminent odontologist ; A. Stocquart, Professor of Vertebrate Anatomy at
Brussels, aged 40 ; Leopold Manen, correspondent of the Paris Academy of Sciences
in the section of Geography and Navigation, in May last ; on Jan. 23, in Baltimore,
Md., Joseph Ewing Macfarland, who was connected with the U.S. Geological Survey,
and had been doing field work in Tennessee y Hugh Nevill, of the Ceylon Civil Ser-
vice, at Hyeres, on April 10, formerly editor and publisher of the Tabropanian,
and a successful collector of zoological specimens, as well as of Ceylonese antiquities ;
Madame Jean Dollfus, who for many years conducted La Feuille desjeunes Naturalistes,
founded by her son, E. Dollfus.

E «

66 | July

NEWS

The following appointments are announced : —

W. Garstang, of Lincoln College, Oxford, to be Naturalist to the Marine Biological
Association of the United Kingdom ; Dr Charles W. Dabney, jun., to be special agent
in charge of Scientific and Statistical Investigations in the U.S. Department of Agri-
culture ; Dr J. L. Prevost, to be full Professor of Physiology at Geneva ; Dr E. Kauf-
mann, privat-docent in Anatomy at Breslau, to be Professor ; Dr Max Wolters, privat-
docent in Anatomy at Bonn, to be Professor ; A. J. Moses, to be Professor of Mineralogy,
and H. M. Howe, to be Professor of Metallurgy, in Columbia University ; W. H. Lang,
to be Lecturer, and Miss D. Clark, to be Demonstrator in Botany, and Miss M. Maclean,
to be Demonstrator in Anatomy, at Queen Margaret College, Glasgow ; Dr Fritz Freeh, to
be Professor of Geology and Paleontology, at Breslau ; Dr Walter Kruse, to be Pro-
fessor of Hygiene, at Bonn ; D. W. Ule, to be Professor of Geography, at Halle ;
Dr Raphael Slidell, Freiherr von Erlanger, and Dr Paul Samassa, privat-docents in
Zoology, at Heidelberg, to be Assistant-Professors ; Dr J. Thomayer, to be Professor of
Pathology, at the Bohemian University, Prague ; Dr E. B. Copeland, to be Assistant-
Professor of Botany in the University of Indiana, as successor to Dr G. J. Peirce, who
becomes Professor of Plant Physiology in Leland Stanford Junior University ; Dr Ivan
V. Muschketoff, to be full Professor of Geology, at the Mining Institute, St Petersburg,
in place of A. P. Karpinski, resigned ; Dr A. Stoss, Prosector at the Veterinary
College, Munich, to be Assistant-Professor in place of Prof. Johannes Ruckert, who
goes to the University ; at the Geologischer Reichsanstalt, Vienna, A. Bittner, as
Chief Geologist, G. Geyer, as Assistant-Geologist, G. v. Bukowski and A. Rosiwal, as
Adjuncts ; Dr Tschirwinski, of Moscow, to be Professor of Pharmacology, at Dorpat.

The widow of Prof. G. vom Rath has presented his library to the University of Bonn.

Mr F. D. Godman has been elected president of the British Ornithologists' Union.

Mr H. H. W. Pearson has received from Cambridge University a grant of £100 for
botanical research in Ceylon.

The National Herbarium, U.S.A., is sending an expedition under Mr E. P. Sheldon,
late of Minnesota University, to explore the Blue Mountains, Oregon.

The memorial to the African explorer, Joseph Thomson, at his native place,
Thornhill near Dumfries, was unveiled on June 8, by Sir Clements Markham.

The Windward has taken out special stores for Mr Andree, in case he meets
with any accident and should be obliged to seek safety on Franz Josef Land.

A history of the Berlin Academy of Sciences is to be prepared by Prof. Harnack,
and to be published on the 200th anniversary of the Academy's foundation.

The city of New York is raising a loan of 500,000 dollars for the erection of a
further wing to the American Museum of Natural History.

Through the influence of President David Starr Jordan, says Science, arrangements
have been made for the establishment of zoological gardens in San Francisco.

Captain Aiiney, who delivered the sixth Robert Boyle Lecture before the Oxford
University Junior Scientific Club on June 1, took for his subject "The scientific
requirements of colour photography."

The first award of the Tilanus gold medal, to be decided every five years by the
University of Amsterdam, has been made to Dr Zwaardemaker of Utrecht, for his work
on the physiology of smell.

We much regret to hear that there is talk of withdrawing the Government subsidy
to the fresh-water biological station at Plon, where, under Dr Otto Zacharias, so much
valuable work has been accomplished.

The Russian Geographical Society and Academy of Sciences are sending an expedi-
tion to study the geography and natural history of the khanates of Roshan, Shignan,
and Darwaz.

1897]

NEWS 67

M 11 K. C. L. Perkins, who has been investigating the zoology of the Sandwich
Islands for a committee of the British Association and Royal Society has returned to
England.

■&'

The following numbers of students at the Imperial College of Science, Tokyo, were
recently given by Engineering : — Mathematics, 11; Astronomy, 2; Physics, 30;
Chemistry, 15 ; Zoology and Botany, 12 ; Geology, 14. In all there are 89 students.

Dr Louis Grehant, Professor of Physiology at the Musi'e d'Histoire Naturelle,
Paris, has been awarded 4000 francs by the French Government to assist his researches
on the hygienic applications of physiology.

An important change has just been made at the Spanish universities and other
educational institutions under State control. Foreigners are now allowed to study there
and to enter for the examinations, and to take degrees at the universities.

The Shute Scholarship in Animal Morphology, recently founded at Oxford Univer-
sity, has an annual value of £50, and is attached to no college. The examination takes
place this July, and is open to all who may be in need of assistance at the university,
and who have not been members of the university for more than eight terms.

The late Prof. Newberry, having left funds for the encouragement of scientific
research, it has been decided to apply the grant successively to geology and palaeon-
tology, zoology, and botany. A sum of 50,000 dollars will be awarded in the first
subject, on July 15, to competitors from among the Scientific Alliance of New York
City.

Cambridge University has made a grant of £300 to Prof. A. C. Haddon, to
enable him to make an expedition to the "Torres Straits to continue his researches on
the anthropology of that region. He will be accompanied by other anthropologists
from Cambridge, and by an expert in Melanesian languages.

The International Congress of Medicine and Surgery meets this year at Moscow
during August. Tli^ Russian Government has not only contributed some £8000
towards the expenses, but has arranged for a two weeks' excursion to the Caucasus, in
the course of which the mineral springs of Kislovodsk will be visited.

A laboratory for the study of cavernicolous animals has been started by Mr
Armand Vire in some subterranean passages, recently rediscovered beneath the Jardin
des Plantes and the Boulevard St Marcel, Paris. Water is supplied from springs by
means of pipes.

It is expected that the Belgiea, the ship of the Belgian Antarctic Expedition,
will arrive at Antwerp early in July, and that the expedition will start in August.
The expedition will stay from October to March on the eastern shore of Graham's
Land. The following year, after re-coaling and provisioning at Melbourne, it will visit
Victoria Land.

A survey of the Pribyloff islands is now being carried out by the U.S. Coast and
Geodetic Survey.

The Danes are charting the northern part of the east coast of Greenland, with the
help of some £1000 contributed from the Carlsberg Fund.

The Rev. Prof. Thomas Wiltshire, of Trinity College, Cambridge, for many years
treasurer of the Geological Society of London, has presented his library of scientific
works to the Woodwardian Museum, Cambridge. The donation comprises about 600
volumes and 900 pamphlets.

The Belgian Government has convened a second International Bibliographic Confer-
ence at Brussels, on August 2-4. Those who do not already subscribe to the Institut
International de Bibliographic may become members for a subscription of 20 francs, on
application to the Institut, 1 Place du Musee, Bruxelles. Among other subjects for
discussion is the state of bibliography of the different sciences.

The Geological Department of the British Museum (Natural History) has just
obtained an interesting series of teeth and jaws of the dwarf elephant discovered a few-
years ago by Dr Hans Pohlig in the cavern of Carini, near Palermo, Sicily. The species
seems to be Elephas mnaidriensis, the largest form met with in the bone-caves of Malta.
It may be merely a dwarfed race of the existing African elephant, which was stranded
and gradually became extinct on the islands of Malta and Sicily when the land barrier,
which once existed in that region between Africa and Europe, became destroyed.

A statement has lately appeared in many scientific journals that there exists on
the Pamirs a dwarf tribe, with dwarf domestic animals. This appears to have

68 NATURAL SCIENCE [July

originated from a journalist of St Petersburg. Lieut. Olofsen explains that the refer-
ence must simply have been to the Wakhanis, who are of true Aryan type and by no
means dwarfs, although, owing to their mixture with Mongolians, they are not tall.
Their domestic animals are half-starved but not dwarfed. Neither do the Wakhanis
worship fire, as has been reported.

Lieut. Peary, having obtained five years' leave of absence, will start about July 10
for Whale Sound on the N.-W. coast of Greenland, leaving scientific parties on the
coast of Labrador, Baffin Land, and Greenland. In July of next year, Lieut. Peary,
accompanied by a surgeon and six families of Esquimaux, will push up the coast from
Whale Sound to Osborne Fjord (81°N. ), where he will establish a base of supplies in charge
of some of the Esquimaux. About March of 1899 he will start for the north limit of
Greenland, wherever that may be, and for the Pole.

The Botanical Society of America will meet in Toronto, on August 17 and 18,
immediately before the meeting of the British Association, under the presidency of
Prof. J. M. Coulter. Dr C. E. Bessey, retiring president, will deliver his address on
Tuesday at 8 p.m. All foreign botanists, of whom many are likely to be in Toronto,
are invited to be associates of the society and to read papers.

The following bequests of the late E. D. Cope are mentioned by Science : His scien-
tific books, osteological collection, and collection of fresh-water molluscs, to the School
of Biology of the University of Pennsylvania ; his collection of minerals to the univer-
sity ; duplicates of fresh-water mollusca to the Cincinnati Society of Natural History
and the American Museum of Natural History ; spirit-specimens and skins to the Phila-
delphia Academy of Natural Sciences. The palaeontological collections are to be sold
in three lots, viz. (1) the North American, (2) the South American, from the Pampean
formation and West Indies and Mexico, (3) European collections, chiefly from the
Neogene of Allier, France. After the payment of private bequests, the money arising
from this is to found a professorship or curatorship in vertebrate palaeontology at the
Philadelphia Academy of Natural Sciences.

Ax important and urgent work is the collection of anthropological data from races
that are disappearing or losing their old customs. For this purpose Mr Morris K.
Jessup, president of the American Museum of Natural History, is fitting out an expedi-
tion under the leadership of Prof. F. W. Putnam, assisted by Dr Franz Boas. They
will proceed up the north-west coast of North America, cross Behring Strait, and so pass
down through eastern Siberia into China, and thence along the Indian Ocean to Egypt.
The expedition will be away six years, and is expected to cost over 60,000 dollars. The
pecial problem to be studied is the relation of the American races to those of Asia and
Africa.

Henry G. Bryant, of Philadelphia, accompanied by S. J. Entrikin and E. B.
Latham, has started for Alaska for the purpose of climbing Mount St Elias and making
explorations in the adjacent region. Mr Bryant, says Science, has had experience of
exploration in Labrador, and has made summer trips to Greenland. Mr Entrikin was
with Peary in Greenland and made an expedition over the inland ice. Mr Latham is a
member of the U.S. Coast Survey, and goes equipped for geographical work. The
party, having established a base camp on the west shore of Yakatat Bay early in June,
will cross the Malaspina glacier to the Samovar Hills ; from there ascend the Agassiz
glacier, and thence up the Newton glacier to the divide between Mount Newton and Mount
St Elias. A camp will be established on the divide, elevation about 13,000 feet, from
which the ascent to the summit of Mount St Elias will be made. Oh returning to the
Samovar Hills the explorations will be continued westward through an entirely un-
known region until a pass is discovered which will enable the explorers to cross the
St Elias Mountains and gain one of the branches of Copper River. The return to the
coast will be by way of Copper River. The party is well equipped, and has every
prospect of success.

A photograph of the new South African Museum at Cape Town, which, as we have
stated, was recently opened, is given in Nature for May 13. The building is at the
upper end of the Municipal Gardens, and consists of two floors, the upper of which con-
tains the principal exhibition rooms. A room 63 by 41 i feet contains the birds, reptiles,
and fishes of S. Africa, recent and fossil, while a room of equal size holds the general
collection of vertebrates. The S. African mammals are in a smaller room, and another
contains the anthropological collections both S. African and general. On the ground
floor are four exhibition rooms, the two larger containing the invertebrates and the
general geological collection ; the two smaller, the collection illustrating S. African
geology and mining and the local antiquities. Other rooms on this floor contain the
library, study collections, and offices. The taxidermist's shop and store-room aro in a
separate building. All the cases are made of glass and iron (see Dr Meyer's letter in
Natural Science, vol. ix., p. 142, Aug. 1896).

18971 NEWS 69

The Auckland Institute has decided to add a new hall, 50 feet square, to its museum,
on the east side of the ethnographical hall. It is intended to receive the statuary
presented by Mr T. Russell, C.M.G., which has hitherto found an incongruous home
among stuffed vertebrates. The space thus gained will be occupied by groups of the
larger mammals, and £100 offered by Mr Russell will be used to procure a group of the
larger carnivores.

Little Barrier Island, on which an attempt is being made to preserve the indigenous
fauna and flora of New Zealand, has been placed under the control of the Institute, witb
a grant of £200 for the first year's expenses. Mr R. H. Shakespear has been appointed
curator, and it is hoped that he may be able to stop the depredations of collectors.

Mi; H. C. Chadwick has been helping Mr J. J. Ogle at the Bootle Museum, and
has rearranged much of the zoological series with elucidatory diagrams. Many new
exhibition eases have been acquired, and in one of these the birds are to be rearranged,
after consultation with a specialist. The museum lends specimens to teachers for the
illustration of object-lessons, and the curator himself gives lectures, illustrated by the
lantern, which appear to be much appreciated by young people.

According to the Halifax Naturalist, the Natural History Museum of Halifax,
which was handed over to the County Borough Council about eighteen months ago by
the Literary and Philosophical Society, has now found a permanent home in the old
mansion named Belle Vue. The geological and botanical collections are very extensive
and valuable, but zoology is as yet very imperfectly represented. The herbarium has
lately been much enriched by the fine Gibson collection of British plants, the gift of
Lady Trevelyan. The Curator, Mr Arthur Crabtree, is making a praiseworthy attempt
to render the Museum of general educational value by adequate labelling, and we
sympathise with him in his aspirations for a competent committee of management to
direct and second his efforts. As he remarks, the ordinary municipal committees may
be very admirable bodies, but they are not able to comprehend the requirements of a
Museum of Natural History. He needs a committee of naturalists, of which there is no
lack in Halifax, and his proposals deserve to be carried out immediately.

We learn from V 'Anthropologic that the Museum of Moscow University has recently
received from the Commission of the Archives of Riazan a collection of skulls, mostly
prehistoric, of which the locality and conditions of finding are known in each case.

The same journal informs us that, near Elissavetpol, in the Caucasus, there have
recently been found by seekers after copper, at a depth of 3 metres, a massive bronze
bracelet and a copper spear-head of quadrangular shape and 35 cm. in length. In the
same locality, on the banks of the Tchovdar, are traces of prehistoric mining.

Some three thousand prehistoric objects in bronze, iron, bone, and pottery, have
been found on the site of ancient places of sacrifice of the Tchoudes at Gliadenevo, on
the left bank of the Kama, near Perm.

At Chita in Trans-Baikal, the local branch of the Russian Geographical Society has
founded a museum, which already contains valuable natural history, archaeological, and
Buddhistic collections.

On September 15, 1896, the National Museum of Costa Rica was definitely installed
in its new quarters, a two-storeyed building. A view of it is given in La Re\nsta Nucva
for October 1896.

Referring to this museum in his always valuable " Current Notes on Anthropology "
(Science, March 19), Prof. D. G. Brinton says that few localities in America offer better
specimens of aboriginal pottery and stone-work. The most abundant remains were left
by the Guetares, a tribe of whose language and affinities we are still ignorant.

Plenty of attempt has been made to introduce some study of common objects or of
nature into our elementary schools ; but the obstacle generally lies in the teachers. A
similar difficulty is felt in America, and to meet it the college of agriculture of Cornell
University has undertaken to help, free of expense, all teachers who may wish to be put
in the right way.

The same subject has been fully studied by a committee of sixty, appointed in May
1896, by the Chicago Institute of Education, and this committee has appointed sub-
committees to prepare maps of the neighbourhood, to prepare printed outlines and
suggestions for teachers, to look after appropriate books in the Chicago libraries, to
supervise the work of instruction and keep touch with the individual teachers, and also
to establish an exhibit of appliances, to arrange cheap means of transport, and to see to
finance.

Those who are advocating the extension of the study of experimental psychology in
this country will be glad to hear that it is 'proposed to establish a lectureship in that
subject, including the physiology of the senses, at Cambridge University. They will
not be so glad to hear that the salary is fixed at £50 per annum. Lecturing in an
experimental science is not much use ; one wants experiments, and for those one wants
apparatus and a laboratory.

70 NATURAL SCIENCE [July

The books bearing on lichens and the dried specimens belonging to the late Dr J.
Midler, generally known as Miiller-Argau, became at his death the property of the
Boissier Herbarium, at Chambesy near Geneva. Following the example of the trustees
of another important lichenological library, the " Tuckerman Memorial Library" at
Amherst College, Massachusetts, the directors of the Boissier herbarium have instituted
the " Foundation Midler- Argau," and the curator, M. Eugene Autran, now appeals to
botanists generally for copies of publications bearing on lichens which have appeared
since Midler's death, or may hereafter appear. Also that specimens of new or rare
species, or " materials for morphological and biological research " may be deposited in
the Lichenotheca Universalis Midler- Argau, in which is included the herbarium of the
Bernese F. Schaerer (1785-1853). Gifts will be acknowledged in the Bulletin of the
Boissier herbarium.

In connection with the Autumn Meeting of the Iron and Steel Institute at Cardiff, on
August 3rd to 6th, Professor Herman Wedding of the Berlin School of Mines has issued
a circular letter asking for subscriptions towards establishing a Central Laboratory for
the Testing of Iron and Steel. Such a Laboratory would be founded at Zurich under
the auspices of the International Society for the Unification of the Methods of Testing
Materials of Construction, which was formed in 1895, and the proceedings at which were
reported in the Journal of the Iron ami Steel Institute for 1895. The Secretary of the
Institute, Bennet H. Brough, has consented to receive the names of those who are
interested.

The Radcliffe Library at Oxford is known to scientific men for its wealth in
their peculiar literature, and to librarians for the excellence of its arrangements. Such
libraries grow rapidly nowadays. Want of room long felt has urged the Drapers' Com-
pany to offer to erect a new building, from plans by Mr T. G. Jackson, at a cost of
£15,000. The offer has been gratefully accepted by the University, which proposes to
transfer the space thus gained in the museum to the medical school, and especially to
start a library of pathology.

The new museum at Winchester College, built as a memorial of the quingentenary of
the school's foundation, was formally opened on June 16, 1897. There was an interest-
ing exhibit of Wykehamical antiquities, and the art department made a fine show, but
the arrangement of the natural history collections has hardly begun. When these last
are more advanced, we shall hope to give a detailed account of the building and its
contents in our series : Museums of Public Schools.

The first annual meeting of the South-Eastern Union of Scientific Societies was held
at Tunbridge Wells at the end of May. The Rev. T. R. R. Stebbing presided, and
delivered the inaugural address. He dealt with the changes in the attitude of the
public mind towards scientific research within modern times. Mr W. Cole contributed
the first paper on the objects and methods of local museums, referring especially to the
new Epping Forest museum. Prof. Boulger next discussed the duties of the com-
mittees of Field Clubs. Prof. Seeley described a geological section in the New
Athletic Ground at Tunbridge Wells, showing current-bedding in clay. ' ' The Search
for Coal in the South-East of England," the subject of a paper by Mr H. E. Turner, led
to a long and interesting discussion. The Mayor of Tunbridge Wells extended his
hospitality to the assembled delegates, and an interesting geological excursion ter-
minated the proceedings.

1897] "71

CORRESPONDENCE

OCEANIC ICHTHYOLOGY

The reviewer of Goode and Bean's "Oceanic Ichthyology" (Natural Science, vol. x.,
pp. 338-340) has made a gratuitous assumption, which devolves on me unmerited credit
and responsibility.

The reviewer says "it is to be noted that the literary part of the work bears signs
of having been intrusted to a third author not under proper control of the two
responsible authors." The "third author" is evidently myself. I feel compelled to
deny either credit or responsibility for all that is not specifically accredited to me. Dr
Goode devoted much time and thought to the keys, and I had nothing to do with the
original compilation.

The specific information that certain fishes have and others have not a mesocora-
coid, so far as the italicised portions credited to me are concerned, I am responsible for,
but not entirely for their application.

The critic remarks, "as a matter of fact, the vast majority of the fishes placed
here have not been examined with reference to this point. " True ; but enough have
been examined to authorise the deduction formulated. The same argument might be
adduced against other generalisations. . . .

As to the definition of Pterothrissidae, it will be evident from the context that the
mistake is due to unintentional repetition instead of the requisite antithesis. The
family Alepocephalidae is defined as having the "dorsal fin similar and opposite anal,"
and the Pterothrissidae should have been contrasted as having the dorsal fin unlike,
and longer than anal. Undoubtedly carelessness and oversight are manifest, and I am
willing to assume that I glanced over the proof and therefore to share the blame, but I
had nothing to do with the original manuscript. Drs Goode and Bean, as well as my-
self, had much on hand, and doubtless the proof sheets were often read in a perfunctory
manner. But in this respect, we have good company. . . .

Such mistakes unfortunately are too common and are generally designated as
" slips of the pen " or " lapsus calami." I do not defend them, but it does not become
the guilty to animadvert on them too strongly. . . .

What are or what are not family characters, is a question about which Dr Giinther
and I have long differed, and I wish neither to defend my view nor to attack those of
others on this occasion. All the many American naturalists, at least, agree with me on
such points. Other strictures I leave to the surviving of the authors, if he should deem
them worthy of attention.

Some notice of the remarkable novelties obtained since the publication of the
results of the Challenger Expedition might have been given by the reviewer, but I
shall not trespass further on your space to do so. Theo. Gill.

[We regret that Dr Gill should assume our review of Goode and Bean's ' ' Oceanic
Ichthyology " to have been written or inspired by Dr Giinther, who had no share what-
ever in its preparation. Like many unsigned reviews in Natural Science, it was the
work of more than one author, and expressed the views of the editorial management of
this journal, not those of any one individual. We have therefore omitted from Dr
Gill's lettter some remarks on Dr Giinther 's works.— Ed. Nat. Sci.]

Slugs

I have recently received from an American malacologist a communication, in which
he says that in a paper,* written in conjunction with Lieut. -Col. H. H. Godwin-Austen,
I have "wrongly applied the term slug by using it for such genera as Parmarion,
Microparmarion, &c."

It is very largely a question of individual opinion as to what genera should be
included under this term, but I fail to see any reason why Parmarion and its allies
should not be termed slugs.

The slugs are not a group by themselves which can be separated into distinct
families apart from the rest of the Pulmonata. On the other hand, very many genera
are closely related to genera in which there is a conspicuous shell. In the above-
mentioned paper the same opinion was expressed as follows :— " We think that future

* Proc. Zool. Sec, 1895, p. 249.

72 NATURAL SCIENCE [July

research will clearly show that many of the slugs cannot rightly be placed in families
by themselves, but will find their true position before or after the genera they have
descended from or developed into."

I would, therefore, include amongst the slugs all forms of Pulmonate molluscs in
which the shell is absent, or where, when present, it is incapable of containing the
whole of the animal. — Walter E. Collinge.

BUFFALO v. BISON

Mr G. H. Carpenter doubtless does well to be shocked ; but the Scientific American
you failed to correct has a fellow-sinner in another American, whose claim to the title
scientific not even Mr Carpenter would deride. Dr C. Hart Merriam, in Science for
May 14 last, writes : " The familiar story of the vanishing buffalo is only one of many."
It is to be feared that the influence of Fennimore Cooper is still strong even with the
purest of the pure scientific writers. — Buffalo Bill.

We have received an interesting note from Professor A. S. Packard, in which he
refers to our recent articles on the Arthropoda. In his well-known memoir on the brain
of Limulus (Mem. Nat. Acad. Sciences, vol. vi., 1893) he has already pointed out that
there are four lines of descent among these animals. Hence he considers the group to
be polyphyletic. He now writes : — "I do not believe the Crustacea and Trilobites had
a common ancestry. I think they evolved from separate vermian ancestors."

Our remarks on the so-called shooting of the golden eagle in Yorkshire have also
brought us communications from Mr Ernest Bell and Mr G. W. Murdoch. The
former urges the necessity of more stringent laws for the preservation of the rare British
birds ; the latter takes a more hopeful view of the case. It appears that Mr F. Boyes.
of Beverley, a thoroughly competent ornithologist, has personally investigated the
incident referred to in Mr Joseph Collinson's letter last May {Nat. Science, vol. x., p.
303), and finds that the bird in question was not an eagle of any kind, but a young
rough-legged buzzard. Mr Murdoch adds : — " I can bear out Mr Southwell's statement
(Nat. Science, vol. x., p. 432) that the golden eagle is in no danger of extermination in
this country."

NOTICE

To Contributors. — All Communications to be addressed to the Editor of Natural
Science, at 67 St James' Street, London, S.W. Correspondence and Notes intended
for any particular month should be sent in not later than the 10th of the preceding
month.

To the Trade. — Natural Science is published on the 25th of each month ; all
advertisements should be in the Publishers' hands not later than the 20th.

To our Subscribers and Others. — There are now published Ten Volumes of
Natural Science. Nos. 1, 8, 11, 12, 13, 20, 23, 24 being out of print, can only be
supplied in the set of first Four Volumes. All other Nos. can still be supplied at One
Shilling each.

Price of Set of Vols. I., II., III., IV £2 10 0

„ V., VI., VII., VIII 14 0

„ I.-VIII 3 10 0

One Shilling each Number of any Bookseller.

Annual Subscription, payable in advance to J. M. Dent & Co., 67 St James's Street,
London, S.W., Thirteen Shillings ($3*50), post free.

NATURAL SCIENCE

A Monthly Review of Scientific Progress

No. 66— Vol. XI— AUGUST 1897

NOTES AND COMMENTS

Co-operation among Naturalists

We had barely space in our last number to chronicle the second
annual congress of the South-Eastern Union of Scientific Societies.
We have now received The Transactions of the Union for 1897,
price one shilling. The Union already includes twenty-seven
affiliated societies, and in carrying out its motto, " Co-operation not
uniformity," is doing a really useful work. The papers and dis-
cussions at the congress were for the most part thoroughly practical.
It is recognised, as we have so often pointed out, that there is a
vast amount of labour wasted every year by enthusiastic naturalists,
whose misfortune it is to have no friendly and enlightened guidance.
The aim of such bodies as this Union is to co-ordinate scattered and
wasted effort, and to direct it into profitable yet no less fascinating-
paths. Thus it is suggested that the Union shall form research
committees to deal with special branches of scientific observation.
These committees would be similar to those of the British Associa-
tion, but they would confine themselves to local natural history.
Like the Midland Union or the New Zealand Institute, such an
union may become the publisher for all its affiliated societies, and
thus exercise a much-needed editorial discretion. It can also
organise lectures and lecture-apparatus, making a collection of
lantern-slides to be borrowed from by any society ; this is already
being done by the S.E. Union. Again, there are many legal questions
affecting naturalists and local societies, and these can best be dealt
with by a strong corporate body. The present congress discussed
one such question, namely, " How can the Technical Education
Grant assist local societies ? " It appears that it is out of the
question to ask for direct pecuniary assistance ; but there seems
no reason in justice or equity why local societies, engaged as they
are in the education of the public, should not be allowed the use
of a room in buildings erected with public money for purposes of

74 NATURAL SCIENCE [August

technical education, and we trust that on this matter the Union

may be able to enter into cordial relations with the County
Councils.

Government and Provincial Museums

The meeting of the Museums Association, held this year at Oxford,
July G-9, was not largely attended, and did not produce a plentiful
crop of papers. Even those that were submitted were not all read,
owing to the necessity this Association always feels itself under of
curtailing within narrow limits the time devoted to their readin<>-
and discussion.

The chief discussion took place on Prof. Flinders Petrie's sug-
gestion of a federal staff for museums ; by which he means that
small curators should be abolished, their place being supplied by
caretakers, and their work being done by peripatetic specialists.
The proposal was thought impracticable ; but there is no doubt that
more might be done to encourage co-operation. There are two
schemes that suggest themselves as the kind of ideals towards which
we might strive. One is that each curator of a small provincial
museum should endeavour to become thoroughly competent in some
one branch of his work, and that for two or three months in each
year he should change places with his fellow-curator from another
museum — equally competent, but in another subject. Thus the
museum, while paying one curator, would as years passed obtain the
experience of a dozen. The alternative plan that occurs to us is
that the staffs of the notoriously under-manned government museums
should be increased, and that it should be part of the official duty of
each specialist-curator to work for two or three months of each year
at provincial museums. Government would, of course, have to levy
some tribute from the provincial centres, to be applied to the salaries
of the government officials; but apart from this there would be a
gain to the specialist, to the head museum, and to the country, by
the co-ordination, investigation, and effective utilisation of all our
obscured scientific and artistic material, as well as by the increased
sympathies, knowledge, and experience of the specialist.

At present government officials seem to hold somewhat aloof
from the provincial museums, and from the Museums Association.
Whether it be that the hard-worked civil servant can ill spare days
from his holiday merely to talk shop, whether he thinks he will
learn nothing from these meetings, or whether he really takes no
interest in his life-work beyond the drawing of his salary, we do not
know. At any rate the Museums Association recognises that it, for
its part, has much to learn from the keepers and assistants in our
larger museums, and it wishes that government officials could be

1897] NOTES AND COMMENTS 75

given facilities for attending the yearly meeting not less than those
accorded to nearly all provincial curators by the much-abused town
and county councils.

The Protection of our Fauna and Flora

We have heard a good deal lately, both from naturalists and those
whom the world in its rude way calls faddists, about the exter-
mination of many of our native plants and animals. There is,
unfortunately, little room for doubt that, however ill-advised may
be the action of certain enthusiasts, their fears are on the whole
well founded. " Naturam expellas furca, tamen usque recurrit," is
only true up to a point : and when ' furca ' has to be translated
' bricklayer's trowel,' that point has been passed. Those who wish
to preserve at least a sample of what was once English country
should read the level-headed paper sent by the Kev. J. J. Scargill
of Bromley to the Congress of the South-Eastern Union. Here
is a suggestion of his: "There are, perhaps, a dozen animals,
furred or feathered, that are habitually killed by keepers. Let a
man devote himself to investigating the habits (of course, in its
wild state) of one of these — hawk, owl or magpie, stoat or weasel
— noting all that it feeds on, and recording his observations day by
day. In a few years, and with a sufficient number of observers, a
fair estimate of the truth might be arrived at. It would be no
easy task, but it would be good ' naturalists' work ' worthy the
attention of any follower of Darwin."

The want of thought that works so much ill can only be
checked by the creation of a public conscience. " There are," says
Mr Scargill, " several obvious means — 1st, County Councils should
be active in exercising their powers under the Act of last year,
and prohibit altogether the taking or killing of such birds as those
just mentioned ; 2nd, the editors of natural history magazines
should never let an issue pass without a few words on the subject;
3rd, instruction on the duty and the reasons for it should be
periodically given in every school."

As for the naturalists themselves, especially those whom Mr
Scargill describes as " the camp-followers of science, eager for the
loot, but inclined to shirk the discipline," they may remedy matters
in two ways. First, let them collect only for their local museum,
and themselves pay more attention to the habits or the structure
of the animals and plants they meet with ; secondly, let them leave
the butterflies and the petaliferous plants alone for a time : they
will find the flies, the grasses, the "mosses, the marine invertebrates
quite as interesting and far more profitable. Let us add that
there is never any harm in collecting fossils, for they are dead

76 NATURAL SCIENCE [August

already ; it is only necessary to keep careful account of locality
and horizon, and to spare the fossiliferous stones of ancient build-
ings. There is plenty of sport in fossil-hunting, and the merest of
mere collectors may provide the most philosophical of palaeontolo-
gists with valuable material, and in this way increase the value of
his own collection.

Fkou-frou and Feathers

All moralists have assured us that " when lovely woman stoops to
folly," she stoops very low indeed. And so when women attempt
to emulate the glories of a Choctaw chief or a South Sea islander, it
is not considerations of art or humanity or self-respect that will
stop them. Consequently it is not likely that the insensate votaries
of fashion, who disfigure their heads with baskets of artificial flowers
(irrespective of the season), virulently dyed scraps of ribbon, twists
of steel, and unnaturally clipped or coloured bird-feathers, will pay
any attention to a paragraph in a scientific journal. But we are
willing to leave the irresponsible half of creation all their chiffons
(which mean ' rags ' or ' women's dress ' as you please), their
coal-tar dyes, and their scrap-iron, if only they will leave us our
birds. The rate at which some of the rarest and most beautiful
birds on our planet are being destroyed to gratify this extraordinary
taste can hardly be realised. On the 13th of April last nearly
half-a-million birds were sold at an auction in London, and the
details of the consignment were thus given, by Mrs Edward Phillips

at tlie annual meet

mg oi tiie

bei borne society :

Osprey plumes,

• •

11,352 ounces

Vulture plumes,

186f pounds

Peacock feathers,

• •

215,051 bundle

Birds of Paradise,

, .

2,362

Indian parrots,

. 228,289

Bronze pigeons, including the

goura,

1,677

Tannagers and sum

Iry birds,

, .

38,198

Humming birds,

. 116,490

Jays and kingfishei

•s,

, ,

48,75 9

Impeyan and other

pheasant

and jungle fowl,

4,952

Owls and hawks,

. .

7,163

A similar sale took place in February, and others were to follow
in July and October.

It is small consolation to us to think that in a few years the
price of these luxuries will be prohibitive, or that, unless fashion
changes in the direction of sea-weeds or turnip-tops, there will soon

1897] NOTES AND COMMENTS 77

be no more birds to destroy. Nor can we overlook the terrible
suffering involved by this enormous slaughter : the young osprey
bereft of its parents left to die in hundreds, the heron with the
plumes torn from its back^ writhing into death. But Frou-frou
cares for these things no more than she does for the squalor of East-
end sweating-dens. Dear delightful doll that she is, she actually
attends a meeting of the Selborne Society with aigrettes in her
bonnet.

What can we do ? Frou-frou does not read Natural Science.
But at all events each of our many thousand readers must enjoy the
acquaintance of many ladies. He can at least use his influence in a
quiet way in the home-circle, if not beyond it. If each of us will
make sure of a few facts, and keep pegging away, perhaps we may
even make converts, and so widen the small circle of our influence.

National Geology

The annual report of the Geological Survey of the United Kingdom
for 1896 reaches us in its handy separate form, and each year's issue
contains a wealth of information about our islands. Sir A. Geikie's
far-seeing policy of attaching to the Survey men already qualified
by original research must tend to increase still further the scientific
character of its publications. Though the results may never appear
in so handsome and truly national a form as do those of the United
States, yet this annual summary shows strikingly the character of
the work in hand. Teachers can now, for the sum of sixpence, keep
abreast of the advances made by the Survey in England, Scotland,
and Ireland ; and, as all practical workers know, these advances
often concern even the broader boundaries on the map. The
classification of results in this year's report under the several
geological systems makes reference easy through its hundred
closely-printed pages. We would especially direct attention to
the progress of knowledge with regard to the pre-Cambrian and
older Palaeozoic groups. The occurrence of widely-spread diabasic
lavas with 'pillow-structure' (p. 37), and of two abnormal short-
lived volcanoes in Eaasay (p. 74), may be cited as among the
interesting igneous problems dealt with. One of the most im-
portant stratigraphical questions is the relation of the ' Upper
Greensand ' to the Upper Gault, referred to on p. 72.

It is obviously impossible to continually re-edit the engraved
maps of the Survey so as to embody current progress. If our
Parliamentary legislators, however", were more frequently trained
in scientific schools, they would find much to be proud of in
these annual reports, and would congratulate the State and them-

78 NATURAL SCIENCE

[August

selves on that zeal for discovery which raises the work of a public
department into one of international distinction.

Microscopy in Manchester

The Manchester Microscopical Society has recently issued its
"Transactions and Annual Eeport" for 1896, and an excellent
little publication it is. To our way of thinking it is almost a model
of what such a publication should be. Without claiming to contain
the results of elaborate original research, the papers are nevertheless
of a very useful and suggestive nature. Prof. Weiss, of Owens
College, in his presidential address gives a very good account of the
main facts known of the biology of those, from some points of view,
exceedingly familiar organisms, the diatoms. We believe that the
type of microscopist known a few years back as the ' Diatomaniac '
is wellnigh extinct, but if a few individuals of the species still
exist we feel sure a perusal of Prof. Weiss's paper would do much
to broaden their views of things in general and of diatoms in
particular. We heartily endorse the sentiment of Prof. Weiss when
he says, " I should like to plead for the union of two branches of
study, the systematic and the physiological or biological, the
severance of which is greatly to be regretted, and has proved
wherever it occurs to be a hindrance to the real progress of
Natural Science." Other papers in the Transactions deal with
" The Method of Eeproduction in Plants," more especially the
microscopical forms, " The Structure and Development of the
Hydrozoa," " The Lace-work Sponge," " The Defensive Devices of
Lepidopterous Larvae," " The Entomology of the Oak," and " The
Distribution of the Fresh-water Fauna." The latter is by Prof.
S. J. Hickson, and contains many most interesting facts and
suggestions. Prof. Hickson considers that the facts of distribu-
tion teach us that fresh-water animals may be divided into three
groups: (1) the Cosmopolitan group, including the large majority
■of fresh- water species ; (2) the Archaic group, represented by such
forms as Apus and Limnocodium ; and (3) the Eecent group, com-
prising species which have only recently migrated into fresh water,
such as Cordylophora and some of the prawns. The problems to
which this paper draws our attention increase our regret that this
country is still without any prospect of a fresh-water biological
station.

Altogether, judging from the papers and report, the Manchester
Microscopical Society seems to be in a very vigorous condition,
which is something to be thankful for in these latter days when
local societies are too often more asleep than awake.

1897] NOTES AND COMMENTS 70

The Apparent Disappearance of the British Phyllopods

In the course of the paper alluded to above Prof. Hickson makes
the very positive statement that the phyllopod Apus does not occur
at all in the British Isles. This may he true, in fact we are almost
forced to believe that it is true ; but it is also certain that this
animal used to live in this country, for Dr Baird records it as
having been taken by three different observers, although he does
not appear to have found it himself. Since the publication of the
" Xatural History of the British Entomostraca " in 1850, Apus
cancrtformis has never again been recorded, so far as we are aware,
and it does seem almost certain that it has totally disappeared from
<»ur fauna. The same fate also seems to have overtaken the brine-
shrimp, Artemia salina. In Baird's time this form was to be found
in the ' salt-pans ' at Lymington, and probably other places, but at
the present day one may search the old ' salterns ' in vain for any
:race of the creature. With regard to the beautiful Chiroc&phalus
diaphanus, which Baird mentions from a large number of localities,
the facts scarcely warrant our regarding it as totally extinct.
It has certainly been seen several times since 1850. Prof. G. S.
Brady mentions it from Yorkshire, and more recently it has been
taken near Birmingham ; nevertheless for all practical purposes
it now appears to have disappeared. We should, however, be
exceedingly glad to hear if any of our readers have taken this form,
say, within the last ten years.

Prof. Hickson attributes this dying out of Phyllopoda — he refers
to Apus more particularly — to the very limited means of dispersal
which these creatures have at command. They are comparatively
large forms, and cannot therefore be transported, attached to birds'
legs, &c, so readily as the smaller and commoner Entomostraca.
In addition to this they do not produce specially protected eggs
like many of the Daphnias, &c. It seems probable, therefore, that,
not being provided with the means of transport found in the cos-
mopolitan fresh -water forms, the phyllopods have not been able
to extend their geographical distribution, while owing to the drying
up of old lakes, and other changes, the localities in which they occur
are becoming fewer and fewer.

The Bibliography of Science

Of course we are glad to find that Mr Arctowski's article on the
Uenealogy of the Sciences, which appeared in Natural Science for
-Tune 1807, should so have pleased the editors of the Bulletin de
rinstitut Intcrnationcd de Bibliographic that they should have pub-
lished a French version of it in their number just received by us.

80 NATURAL SCIENCE [August

None the less we are surprised that a journal with so high-sounding
a title should so ignore the objects of its existence and the respon-
sibilities that it has assumed, as entirely to omit all reference to the
original place of publication of the article. We may also point out
the absence of an exact date of publication from the wrapper, the
pages, and the included catalogue-slips of this Bulletin. To parody
an old saying, we must really cry, " Bibliographer ! bibliograph
thyself."

The Belgian bibliographers seem to have found Mr Arctowski's
article as unpractical as interesting. One thing is certain, we are
not going to wait — not even the Eoyal Society Committee — for
someone to write us a phylogenetic history of science. Therefore
the impossibilities of the suggested classification do not greatly
matter. At the present moment work is being done in the biblio-
graphy of science on a definite and uniform plan, which may be
ridiculous, incorrect, confusing, but which is workable and being-
worked. There are no doubt plenty of beautiful, symmetrical
schemes, as clear as daylight, but they are not in use. The follow-
ing bibliographies are announced by the Institut International in a
catalogue of its publications : — Bibliographia Philosophica, B. Socio-
logica, B. Astronomica, B. Zoologica, B. Medica Italica, B. Ana-
tomica, B. Physiologica, B. Ostetrica e Ginecologica Italiana, while
there are in preparation a Bibliographica Geologica, B. Physica,
B. Medica Belgica, B. Agronomica Italica, and others.

Some of these bibliographies represent the adhesion to the
uniform plan of periodicals or societies hitherto working on other
lines, such as the Zoologischcr Anzeigcr, Anatomischer Anzeiger, and
II Policlinico. We notice too that the Biological Society of Paris
accompanies its 1896 volume with an analytical index to the
articles, arranged on the principles of the decimal classification.
All the subjects dealt with in over 300 articles are thus referred
to in two pages. These and numerous other facts, which it would
be wearisome to detail, show that the system is gaining ground,
whereat manv will marvel.

A Biological PiEcord

Yet another form of scientific bibliography comes to us in I' Annexe
Biologique, further described as "comptes rendus annuels des travaux
de biologie generate publics sous la direction de Yves Delage, pro-
fesseur a la Sorbonne avec la collaboration d'un Comitc' de Pi'dac-
teurs." The secretary to the editors is Dr Georges Poirault. The
work is published by Schleicher Kivres, 15 Puie des Saints-Peres,
Paris, at a price of 20 francs. The first volume, just received by
us, deals with the literature of the year 1895. We may describe

1S97] NOTES AND COMMENTS 81

it by saying that it treats of those papers that are noted by the
zeal of Mr J. Arthur Thomson in the first section of our own
Zoological Record, and that the plan of the work is like that of the
Zoologischer Jahresbericht and the Neues Jahrbuch fur MvmroHogie
combined. There are 53 collaborators, mostly French, so that the
task of abstracting is pretty sure to fall into competent hands.
The want of correlation to which this leads is compensated by the
several introductions as well as by special articles on general
subjects — e.g., on grafting, by L. Daniel ; experimental knowledge of
the correlation of animal functions, by E. Gley ; on polyzoism, by
J. P. Durand.

As to what is meant by biology, there is always a quarrel
simmering;. It is not long since we received an elaborate discussion
of the subject from Mr Henry de Varigny, extracted from the
" Dictionnaire de Physiologic" He defined it as " the science of
the relations of organisms to the environment and to other
organisms, present and past." Professor Delage, in his Preface to
the present work, does not waste much time in discussing what is
or is not biology ; for practical purposes, as a criterion of what
shall be included in L'Anne'e Biologiquc, he accepts every paper
that professes to give an explanation of biological phenomena (i.e.,
of the phenomena of living beings). It is easy for an analyser
or recorder to see whether an author professes to explain. But
Prof. Delage has opened a loop-hole for complaint, since he also
promises to record facts that may be connected with some future
explanation, or even those which " belong to general biology, and
are not of the same nature as others already known." Who is to
decide what facts will ultimately be of value in the explanation of
our ever-varying problems ? Each day has its own burning ques-
tion, casting others into the shade ; and what the riddle of to-
morrow may be we know not. Facts that were passed over a few
years ago are all-important now. What facts shall we be collecting
twenty years hence ? But, apart from this difficulty, only to be
overcome by a prophet, there is the certainty that hundreds of
facts undoubtedly worthy of record from Prof. Delage's point
of view, will be overlooked by himself and his collaborators. It
does not take us five minutes to discover a score of such facts,
published during 1895, often with full knowledge of their import,
but nowhere alluded to in this volume. We do not blame their
omission, for we cannot think that anything else is to be expected
on the present system of compiling bibliographies.

Taking this work for what it really is, and not for its unattain-
able ideal, we recognise that it is relatively complete ; that it is
well arranged and well executed, profiting by the experience of
predecessors. It is an aid that should be neglected by none with a

82 NATURAL SCIENCE [August

soul above species-mongering and section-cutting ; iu other words,
it will be welcome to all readers of Natural Science.

Natural Science in Japan

The historian of science in Japan is too apt to restrict his view
to the influence of European science, to the introduction of New-
tonian and Darwinian philosophy and of the Linnean system,
forgetful that there were philosophies and systems in the Far
East centuries before, or else thinking wrongly that these were of
small account. In an admirable Introduction to the first number
of Anaotationcs Zoologicac Japoneiiscs, Prof. K. Mitsukuri corrects
this error. Early in the eighth century of the Christian era there
was already established in Japan an Imperial University with 400
students, devoted to Ethics, History, Jurisprudence, and Mathe-
matics. There was also an office for Astronomy, Astrology, Calendar-
compilation, and Meteorology, as well as a Medical College with
professors of Medicine, Surgery, Acupuncture, Necromancy (the art
of healing by charms), and Pharmacology. In connection with the
last-named branch of study, much botanical information was acquired.
Towards the end of the ninth century the large Imperial library
contained numerous medical works, among others, on the diseases
of women and the diseases of the horse. In later times, under the
Tokugawa Shoguns, natural history, especially botany, was exten-
sively studied, and elaborate works were published, of which Prof.
Mitsukuri instances the ' Shobutsu Kuisan ' issued early in the
eighteenth century, and the " Honzo Komoku Keimo " by the
celebrated teacher of natural history, Ono Eanzan, published in
1803. Honzo, which strictly means botany, seems to have come
to include general natural history, for many of these works deal
also with stones, metals, and all kinds of animals. In Rosny's
" Catalogue de la Bibliotheque Japonaise de Nordenskiold " we
even find a note on fossil shells, which appeared so early as 1725.
The naturalists also held meetings at which they exhibited their
•; insures to one another and to the public. The Garden of
Medicinal plants at Tokyo was established in 1G81.

It was during the eighteenth century that western science first
came into contact with the Japanese, through the medium of the
Dutch language. The story of this and of the gradual development
of modern science in Japan has already been told in our pages by
Mr F. A. Bather (vol. iv., Jan., Feb., and March 1894); but many
details are added by Prof. Mitsukuri. Zoology, he notices, had
developed but slightly before the restoration of the Mikado in 18G8;
it was not till the appointment of Prof. E. S. Morse to the Chair
of Zoology at Tokyo University, in 1877, that it made any progress

1897] NOTES AND COMMENTS 83

The indefatigable American popularised the science, secured a band
of earnest students, established a museum, and organized the Tokyo
Biological Society, now the Zoological Society. He was succeeded
by C. O. Whitman, who introduced modern technical methods.

Since 1881 the development of zoology in Japan has been
entirely in native hands, and does not seem to have suffered from
that cause. All its main branches, including its practical applica-
tions, are now fairly represented. The Marine Station at Misaki
has been outgrown, and a larger one is being opened two miles north
of the present building. The teaching of zoology in the various
schools over the country is a recognised thing. Further, the
addition of Formosa to the territory of Japan has already been
taken advantage of by Japanese zoologists. One thing is wanted,
and that is literature. Prof. Mitsukuri appeals to the naturalists
of other countries to send their publications to the Imperial Uni-
versity, where they are sure to be warmly appreciated.

Growth-Changes ix the Spicules of Sea-Cucumbers

The sea-cucumber, trepang, beche-de-mer, or holothurian, is well
known to be a favourite article of food in the Far East ; especially
is this the case with the common namako of Japan. For the
protection and cultivation of this animal, Prof. Mitsukuri some
time ago began an inquiry, at the instance of the Ministry of
Agriculture and Commerce. One of the first questions to be
answered was the number of species, if there were, as was sup-
posed, more than one. The species of holothurians are often
determined largely by differences in the form of the minute cal-
careous spicules found in the skin. Now it so happened that those
who had examined this Japanese holothurian — namely, Selenka, ATon
Marenzeller, Lampert, and Theel — had failed to find the same appear-
ances in the spicules, and had founded two species, Sticlwpus armatus
and & japonicus, together with a variety of the latter, called typicus.
The shape of the spicules is that of a minute one-legged table made
of open fretwTork ; but some individuals contain no tables at all, only
smaller spicules something like round buttons with four or five holes
in the middle. Prof. Mitsukuri's investigations, now published
in Annotationes Zoologicac Japoncnses (i. pp. 31-42), show that all
these forms belong to Stichojms japonicus, and that in this species
the form of the spicules changes with advancing age. The youngest
individuals have an extremely large number of most perfectly formed
large-sized tables, and nothing but these. With the growth of the
animal, perfectly formed tables decrease both in number and size,
and tables in various stages of arrested development are found mixed
with them. This process continues with age, until in fully grown

84 NATURAL SCIENCE [August

individuals there are found nothing but the small plates above-
mentioned. These represent a small part of the original table top,
and are comparatively thinly scattered in the skin.

In the youngest stages the calcareous deposits are the most com-
plete, and have almost the character of a coat of armour, like that of
a star-fish or sea-urchin. This may be for the greater protection of
the young, in which the skin and muscle-layers are very thin and
pliable ; but it may signify the descent of the species from a more
richly plated ancestor. These differences are not entirely signs of
age, but, in conjunction with others, distinguish geographical races.
Thus forms with spicules in the shape of buttons are more common
in the north of Japan, and are also characterised by numerous long-
pointed papillae set in four rows along the back and sides, with
many smaller papillae between them. As one passes southwards
along the coast one comes gradually to forms that have only a row
of low papillae along the sides, and a few scattered over the back.
Habitat, however, has its influence no less than latitude. Those
that live among rocks have a larger number of tall papillae, and are
of a mottled brown colour, while those that live on sanely ground,
probably among sea-weeds, have lower and fewer papillae, and are of
a dark-green colour.

This interesting and doubly important paper makes one doubt
afresh the validity of the many species of holothurians that have
been based on the examination of the spicules of a few individuals;
it shows the necessity for the examination of many specimens in
various stages of growth from different localities ; and it affords one
more demonstration of the value of the study of all growth-changes
and not merely of those that occur in the embryo.

How a Brittle-Star Lives in Jatan

While the Japanese zoologists, K. Mitsukuri and T. Hara, were on
a collecting tour last year, they came, on April 1, to a sandy shoal
in the Bay of Kagoshima. Wading into the water, they were soon
struck by very curious objects. " Numerous slender stalks a few
millimeters in diameter and 10-15 centimeters high were standing
up from the bottom, looking like the stems of so many weeds.
Along one side of each stalk there was, however, a row of white
papillae-like structures. These stalks were mostly by twos, although
sometimes only one was standing by itself. We do not remember
having seen three making a group. As we dug, to learn more about
these curious objects, we were greatly surprised to find that they
were the arms of ophiurans, and that the papilla-like structures were,
therefore, no doubt, tubefeet. So far as we could see there was no
difference between the five arms of the animal, and why only one or

1897] NOTES AND COMMENTS 85

two of them should he thus thrust upwards into the water, and kept
upright there, was a mystery. It seemed probable to us that it was
done to secure respiration. The sand of the shoal was literally
packed with these animals, and there must have been hundreds of
thousands or, perhaps, millions in the whole shallow." The species
was near or in the genus Ophiopsila. The account is extracted from
the miscellaneous notes in the first number of Annotationcs Zoologicac
Japonenscs.

A Botanical Discovery from Japan

Botanists became greatly excited when, several years ago, Treub
published an account of his discovery of Chalazogamy in Casuarina.
By this term, as our readers may remember (see Natural Science,
vol. i., p. 132) he described a method of pollination, in which the
pollen-tube entered the ovule through the chalaza instead of at the
micropyle. Treub was so much impressed with the importance of
this and other deviations from the normal course of events in
Casuarina that he separated it from the rest of the seed-plants under
the name Chalazogamae, the latter, in which presumably pollination
was effected through the micropyle, forming the Porogamae. More
recent work has shown this revision of our classification to be un-
necessary, and that Casuarina, though certainly presenting remark-
able anomalies, must still be retained among Dicotyledonous Angio-
sperms.

There has recently come from the far East news, and confirma-
tion of the news, of a yet more startling discovery. S. Ikeno and
S. Hirase, working at Tokyo in Japan, have found that in the pro-
cess of fertilisation in Cycas and Gingko the male element (generative
nucleus) is converted before its escape from the pollen-tube, into a
motile spermatozoid. This swims through a epiantity of sap occurr-
ing in these genera between the embryo sac and the top of the
nucleus which forms a thin papery covering for the contents of the
ovule, and impregnation of the oosphere is therefore effected in the
same manner as in the Vascular Cryptogams. The spermatozoids
are much larger than hitherto known among the Cryptogams, and that
of Cycas is larger than that of Gingko. The shape is oval. The head
consists of three spiral windings in Gingko, and of four in Cycas, and
bears numerous motile cilia. The great importance of the discovery
of the Japanese botanists lies in the fact that it strengthens our
present system of classification. Hofmeister showed the near rela-
tion subsisting between Gymnosperms and Vascular Cryptogams
working chiefly from the development of the female spore (embryo-
sac) and the structures resulting therefrom. Now from the male
side comes a striking confirmation of his conclusions, — a confirma-

86 NATURAL SCIENCE [August

tion which, as Messrs Ikeno and Hirase point out, Hofmeister had
suggested would be forthcoming. It is of much interest that
Conifers represented by Gingho, as well as Cycads, show this rela-
tion ; as we have always been wont to consider the latter so much
the more ancient group both on palaeontological and morphological
grounds. And Gingho, the maiden-hair tree, which with its strange
fern-like foliage and non-conelike inflorescence, has always attracted
us, will become still more fascinating. The confirmation of the news
to which we have referred was supplied by Dr Scott, who at the last
meeting of the Linnean Society showed actual microscopic prepara-
tions which he had received from Japan. A few more details will
be found in a note communicated by the discoverers to the June
number of the Annals of Botany.

Fungi and their Hosts

It is generally understood that a fungus, when parasitic, preys upon
one and the same host during the whole period of its life-history.
Hitherto only a single exception to this rule has been recorded,
namely, that of certain ' rusts ' (Uredineae), whose heteroecism (as
change of host is technically termed) was first demonstrated satis-
factorily by De Bary in 186 4. Now, however, the Russian botanists
Woronin and Nawaschin (Zeitschr. fur Pflanzcnkrankcnheiten, vol.
vi., 1896, pp. 129, 199) have discovered an interesting case of
the same exceptional phenomenon, namely, in a new species of the
Ascomycetes which they have described and named Sclcrotinia
Jteteroica. The resting-stage (or Sclerotium) giving rise to the
Ecziza-iorm grows in the capsules of Ledum palustve ; the other
(or conidial) form they found as a destructive parasite on the leaves
of Vaccinium uliginosum. The fruit of Ledum palustre is attacked
at an early stage of its growth, and is gradually replaced by the
sclerotium. The diseased capsules, which do not differ much in
appearance from the healthy fruits, remain attached to the parent
plant during the winter, and fall to the ground in spring when
the stalked cup-shaped ascus-fruits are developed. The ascus
spores, scattered by the wind, light on the buds and young leaves of
Vaccinium, where they germinate and spread through the cells of
the plant. The conidial fructification, upright stalks with branched
chains of conidia, appear on the petiole and veins of the leaves,
which turn brown and gradually die. The authors by repeated ex-
periments established without doubt the relation between the two
forms ; but it is rather remarkable that they were able to cultivate
the conidial form from the ascus spores on a decoction of plums ;
and this fact, as pointed out by Fischer, interferes between the
parallel with the above case and that of the Uredineae. The

1897] NOTES AND COMMENTS 87

latter are obligative parasites, and no culture medium has been
substituted at any stage for the living host plants.

There are a number of parasites among the ' Fungi imperfeeti '
which may prove to be heteroecious forms of parasitic ascomycetes,
and it would be well worth while to carry out further experiments
on the subject.

A Bacterium Living in Alcohol

During the last year much of the rum manufactured in Demerara
has been found to be 'faulty,' and, the cause having been sought for
in vain, great loss has resulted to the colony. Mr and Mrs Victor
H. Veley, of Oxford, have recently discovered a micro-organism in
some samples of faulty rum sent them for examination. The
bacterium belongs to the group Coccaceac, adopting Zopf's classifica-
tion, and is probably a new species. Mr and Mrs Veley have
already obtained several stages in the life-history, by cultivation,
and hope shortly to publish an account of its development and the
chemical changes which it produces in the liquid. The fact of any
micro-organisms existing and multiplying in spirit correctly assessed
at 42° over proof, or about 74*6 °/o by weight, is of great interest
both from a scientific and technical point of view, and the investi-
gation is likely to prove of considerable importance.

John Jeffrey

In the Proceedings of the Biological Society of Washington (vol. xi.,
pp. 57-60), Mr F. V. Coville gives a sketch of the route taken by
John Jeffrey, " one of the most obscure " of the botanical explorers
who have done important work in North America. Botanists know
him only as the subject of the dedication of a Californian pine (Pinus
jejfreyi), described by Andrew Murray from material sent home by
Jeffrey. The brief account of his work as a traveller and collector
has been drawn up by Mr Coville by the aid of documents both
manuscript and printed, which have hitherto been almost unknown,
or at any rate unexamined. We know that Jeffrey was a Scotsman, and
that in 1850 he was sent to North America under the auspices of an
organisation formed in Edinburgh, with Prof. J. H. Balfour as chair-
man, and known as the " Oregon Botanical Association." He was
to go to Western North America, and collect the seeds of trees,
shrubs, and other plants suitable for horticultural purposes, in the
region traversed by David Douglas, " to complete his researches, and
to extend them into those parts of the country not fully explored by
him." Starting from York Factory on Hudson Bay in August 1850,

88 NATURAL SCIENCE [August

he worked by way of the Saskatchewan and Athabasca rivers to the
Kocky Mountains, which he crossed between Mounts Brown and
Hooker, and then descended the Columbia river to Fort Colville.
He arrived at this place in May 1851. The next two years were
spent in exploring the coast region between the Fraser river and
San Francisco. Collections were made on Mount Baker, the Cascade
Mountains, the Sierra Nevada, and other ranges in Southern Oregon
and California, and along many of the river valleys. Several collec-
tions were sent to Edinburgh, the last being those made in 1853,
when his term of employment by the association ceased, the original
contract being for three years' service. A letter to Andrew Murray
from a brother in San Francisco, dated May 1854, gives the last
information we have of a hard-working and enthusiastic but ill-fated
botanist. He planned an expedition to Fort Yuma on the Gila
river in Colorado, from which he never returned, and there seems
little doubt that he perished of thirst in the desert.

The Camel in Eueope

It is difficult to determine the natural geographical distribution of
an animal which has been so long domesticated as the camel. Dis-
coveries of its remains in surface-deposits need to be carefully
investigated by competent geologists before they can be accepted
as actual fossils, not as bones merely buried by man. Great interest
therefore attaches to an announcement by Dr G. Stefanescu, the
eminent Roumanian geologist, of the discovery of two portions of
the mandible of a species of Camelus in an undoubted Quaternary
gravel, six metres below the surface, on the river bank of the Olt
at Milcovul-de-jos, near Slatina, Roumania {Anuandu Mus. Gcol.,
Bucharest, 1895). Dr Stefanescu disinterred the specimens him-
self, and there can be no doubt as to their geological age. He
regards the species to which they belong as new, and names it
Camelus cdutensis. We believe that there are similar fragments
from the Volga basin in the collection of Prof. A. Rosenberg of
Dorpat (Jurjeff), but we are not aware whether any account of
these has been published.

Steenstrup

We regret to record the death of the doyen of Danish zoologists, the
veteran Prof. Steenstrup. We hope next month to publish a
short account of his life and work by Prof. Chr. F. Ltitken, with
a recent portrait.

575. 89

599.9

The Influence of Woman in the Evolution of the

Human Race

THE recent discussions of Mr Eeid's book, " The Present
Evolution of Man," in Natural Science (vol. x., pp. 184, 24<2,
305, 393) have interested me, both on account of their able
treatment of this subject from so many different sides and also
on account of their omissions of certain points of view. Man's
place in nature, the possible influence on his destiny of the position
he occupies as the terminal form of his own group, should, it seems
to me, be given more consideration as a possible factor in his evolu-
tion. This has received incidental consideration by the writer in
connection with studies upon the phenomena of evolution among the
Invertebrata, especially Cephalopoda, and the results are instructive
and quite similar to those reached by the distinguished English
palaeontologist, Mr S. S. Buckman.

The way in which man's position may possibly affect his
evolution and further prospects has been treated by the writer in
a lecture upon " Woman's Occupations and Habits and the Suffrage
from a Biological Point of View." This can be used as an example
of a certain mode of treating the subject, and an abstract of this
lecture may perhaps interest the readers of Natural Science. It is
also appropriate that it should appear first in an English periodical,
since, if the reports are true which reach this side of the ocean, some
leading Englishmen are so sadly deficient in knowledge of the
subject and its importance, that they consider the question of
whether the suffrage shall or shall not be granted to women as a
huge political joke rather than as a question dealing with matters
of importance to the future evolution of civilised races. People do
not yet recognise that the tendency of evolution is quite as often
towards retrogression and extinction as in the direction of pro-
gression ; the former indeed being the final result both in the life-
history of the individual and of his family, and finally of the race to
which he belongs. The laws of biology have not hitherto been used
to test the assumptions, that co-education and the changes of
occupations and habits induced thereby and by the legal freedom of
choice of occupation conferred by the use of suffrage upon women,
will be beneficial factors in the evolution of the future. The writer
has thus been endeavouring to call attention to this side of these

90 NATURAL SCIENCE [August

questions in Boston and Cambridge, U.S.A., and the following is a
brief abstract of the arguments employed in the lecture referred
to, lately delivered in these two cities.

(1) Men and women, like the males and females of most
animals, show by their organisation that they have been evolved
from a type in which both sexes were combined in the same
individual. The separation of the sexes did not destroy this dual
nature, as is demonstrated by the development of secondary male
characters in the old age of many species of animals and of women
in extreme age, and of feminine characters in aged men. This
opinion can also be supported by the structure of the tissue cells in
the body, the nuclei of which are made up of paternal and maternal
parts. This dual structure enables us to understand the fact that
secondary sexual characters are latent in both males and females, and
liable to make their appearance after the reproductive period is
passed through, or before this time and prematurely in abnormal
individuals, or perhaps under certain conditions of habit or sur-
roundings.

The maternal (in larger degree or wholly feminine) parts of the
nuclei are certainly prepotent during the entire reproductive or
adult stage of growth, and their constant employment in the
performance of feminine functions prevents the development of
latent male characters. During this time the paternal (in larger
degree or wholly male) parts of the nuclei have remained inert and
may be supposed to be still capable of multiplying by division and
producing extra growths, thus even in old age building up secondary
male characters, such as the comb, wattles, etc., in some birds, or
giving rise to secondary male characteristics in old women. This
may also take place prematurely through suppression of the natural
functions, either by change of habits or by surgical or other
artificial operations. These statements apply equally well to men,
and some of the most remarkable examples are to be found in this
sex, but the dangers of feminisation to the men, although possibly
greater than we now suppose, do not seem at least to be so im-
portant or threatening as those that lie in the possible future of the
women. These are striking out into new paths, and are being
helped by men who are equally ignorant with themselves of the
nature of their own organisation and of the possible dangers to their
race of the success of their efforts.

(2) In the early history of mankind the women and men led
lives more nearly alike and were consequently more alike physically
and mentally, than they have become subsequently in the history of
highly civilised peoples. This divergence of the sexes is a marked
characteristic of progression among highly civilised races. Co-
education of the sexes, occupations of certain kinds, and woman

1897] WOMAN IN EVOLUTION OF HUMAN RACE 91

suffrage may have a tendency to approximate the ideals, the lives,
and the habits of women to those of men in these same highly
civilised races.

(3) Such approximations in the future, while perfectly natural
and not in a common sense degenerative, would not belong to the
progressive stages of the evolution of mankind. Such changes
would be convergences in structure and character, and, although
they might lead to what we might now consider as intellectual
advance, this would not in any way alter the facts that women
would be tending to become virified * and men to become effeminised,
and both would have, therefore, entered upon the retrogressive
period of their evolution. The danger that men may become
effeminised may be greater than would at first sight seem probable,
but this might not take place at all or to such a slight extent as not
to affect seriously the progressive evolution of the race. On the
other hand, the danger to women cannot be exaggerated nor too
carefully considered, in view of the fact that advanced women have
adopted the standards of men, and have not tried as yet to originate
feminine ideals to guide them in their new careers and thus maintain
the progressive divergence of the sexes.

(4) There is a rise of the individual through progressive stages
of development to the adult and a decline through old age to
extinction. In the evolution of the stock to which the individual
belongs there is a similar law, a rise through progressive stages of
evolution to an acme and a decline through retrogressive stages to
extinction. These cycles of the ontogeny (the life of the individual)
and of the phylogeny (the evolution of the race or stock) can be
illustrated by two diagrams of lines arising from a point, diverging
to represent the progressive stages and converging to represent the
retrogressive. The divergences and subsequent convergences are not
simply physiological analogies, as heretofore supposed, but they occur
in obvious relations of structures and forms which indicate that one
law governs the development of the individual and the evolution of
the stock to which that individual belongs.

The various characteristics of an organism develop through youth
to the adult and end in the convergences of old age, which is termed
the gerontic stage. Species, genera, or genetic stocks of any kind
likewise progress from their origin and diverge to an acme, finally
converging in the phylogerontic period (the gerontic period of the
phylum). This last word is used because it conveys an accurate
meaning for which there is no exact equivalent in the English

* This term enables one to consider the future woman who has acquired manly habits
and character as tending to become mannish without being necessarily a degenerate
being either physically or mentally. In point of fact she may be virified and yet be,
according to the standards of advanced women of to-day, superior in both respects, so
far as bodily and mental vigour are concerned to the women of the present time.

92 NATURAL SCIENCE [August

language, and please observe the use of the word " degeneration "
is thus avoided.

The structural changes in the gerontic stage of the individual
are repeated with sufficient accuracy in the adult, and often even in
the younger stages of types that occur in the decline of the evolu-
tion of a phylum, so that one is forced to consider seriously whether
they may not have been inherited from types that occur at the acme
of the same group. The fact that these changes occur first in the
individual during the gerontic stage does not necessarily imply that
they first make their appearance after the reproductive period. No
gerontic limit is known to the reproductive time in the lower
animals, and it may well be that the continual recurrence of
gerontic stages in individuals during the epacme of groups may
lead to their finally becoming fixed tendencies of the stock or
hereditary in the phylum, and thus established as one of the
factors that occasion the retrogression or decline of groups. The
decline may also be considered as occasioned by changes in the
surroundings from favourable, as they must have been during the
progression up to acmatic time, to unfavourable during the succeed-
ing declining period in evolution. Still a third supposition is also
possible, viz., that the type, like the individual, has only a limited
store of vitality, and that both must progress and retrogress, complete
a cycle and finally die out, in obedience to the same law.

All of these views can be well supported, but, whatever may be
the true explanation, it is obvious that there are plenty of declining
types, which, in their full-grown and even in their adolescent
stages, correlate in characters and structures with the characters
and structures that one first finds in the transient old age or
gerontic stages of acmatic forms of the same type. These can,
therefore, be truthfully and accurately described as phylogerontic
or old in the phylum.

The position of man is at the extreme end of a series of con-
verging lines in his own stock. This is also indicated by his
structure and development which is phylogerontic, and it is
therefore of the highest importance for him to avoid all move-
ments tending to the increase of his natural and possibly inherent
tendencies towards retrogression. The approximation of the sexes
in habits of body or mind is therefore to be avoided, as possibly
leading to convergence of the progressive characters non-existin-
between the sexes and the inauguration of retrogressive evolution.

It is hoped that no pretence of being able to solve problems
requiring such vast knowledge and many-sided considerations will
be attributed to this article, which has been intended simply to call
attention to the scientific side of the question. It seems obvious
that the time has come when thoughtful men and women should be

1807] WOMAN IN EVOLUTION OF HUMAN RACE 93

warned, if this be possible, that their organisations are not of such
a kind that they can rely upon continuous and certain progress.
The laws of evolution point distinctly to a future in which retro-
gression and extinction is perhaps certain ; but man's past history
and the same laws also hold out hopes for the maintenance of
progress through an indefinite time, if he is capable of controlling
his own destiny through the right use of experience and of the
wonderful control over nature that his capacities have enabled him
to attain. Alpheus Hyatt.

Boston Society of Natural History,
Boston, Mass., U.S.A.

571.93(42.25) 94 [August

Primeval Refuse Heaps at Hastings

(Concluded from p. 44)

THE most remarkable of all the flint implements found in the
Hastings Kitchen Middens — or we may perhaps even say
anywhere else — is a group of highly specialised diminutive forms
totally unlike anything outside their own class. They are usually
exceedingly small, very rarely exceeding an inch and a half in
length, and sometimes are not one-sixth that size. They are
characterised by the peculiarity of their shape and outline, and the
method by which the flint has been worked. So persistent are the
quaint and curious types, and so unique the working of the flint,
that these delicate little implements have been recognised in Egypt,
Arabia, Spain, the Valley of the Meuse, and in England by four
different field workers. Around Sevenoaks I have found several
settlements, and in one case a barrow of these people, in which,
probably, the chief was cremated, with implements. Experiments
lead me to the belief that this peculiar work, in which the delicate
flakes average sometimes only one-thirtieth of an inch in length, was
performed by a slot in a piece of bone similar to a saw-setter, as with
a tool of this sort I can reproduce this work with its characteristic
rectilinear outline. More recently I have noticed a few spheroidal
flints, with the edges finely contused. I find that by using
these upon a flake lying upon a banker I can lever off small flakes,
giving rise to a kind of working very similar to that found on the
Midden flints. Amongst these queer little forms are crescents,
such as Nos. 8, 85, 10, 11, 12, 8, 4, and 81, which were probably
employed for fishing, by a method of suspension that has come
down to us, as shown in Plate VI.; also oblique (Nos. 4y and ^)
and incurved pointed tools (Nos. 85, 87, 88), probably used for
tattooing and other rites ; others are drills ; while the use of others,
such as those with trapezoidal outline (No. 40, Plate VI.), is past
conjecture. Many are simply sharp points, and were doubtless
used for fish hooks, being bound upon a crutch twig, in the manner
suggested in Plate VI. It is the extreme dissimilarity of these little
things from everything else that makes us feel justified in recognis-
ing them as the work of one and the same people wherever they are
found. They are not scattered indiscriminately all over the surface
like the ordinary neoliths, but are confined to settlements, which

1897] PRIMEVAL REFUSE HEAPS AT HASTINGS 95

are sometimes thirty acres in extent, but more frequently are not
more than a hundred yards square.

THE WORKED BONES

One or two of the fragments of bone showed signs of carving.
One was a well-made stiletto ; another a portion of a needle. A
third specimen was probably a potter's tool, as by its use the marks
seen round the rim of the pots could have been readily made. The
most interesting circumstance connected with the bones was, that in
two cases the flint wedges were found in situ in the bones, as they
were used for splitting them. Oue of these is shown in Plate VI.,
left lower figure. The whole of the marrow bones were thus split
up for marrow, and the skulls for the brains ; and even bones
which contain no marrow were often similarly reduced, possibly for
either boiling to extract grease or for use in making bone tools.
Several other flint wedges similar to the above illustration were
also found ; and numerous bones showed deep cuts connected with
the death of the auimals, or those that were made in cutting up
the trophy of the chase.

THE POTTERY

The pottery of the refuse heaps is of special interest, as it
represents probably the oldest domestic utensils with which we are
acquainted. Canon Greenwell has called attention to the fact that
most of our Neolithic pottery is funereal or associated with burials:
it is always of well-known special types, and none of these were
found at Hastings. Some of the pottery here was made from a
black, coarse, gritty, carbonaceous clay fairly well baked ; some was
better burnt and quite red. The majority of the vessels are of one
of these kinds. There was a much coarser kind of a deep red
colour, apparently composed of coarsely pounded flint, quartz, and
clay-iron-stone ; from this large utensils were made, and these were
often | of an inch thick. The vessels were for the most part of two
types — the cauldron and the dish ; they were all hand-made, none
showing a sign of the use of the wheel. The cauldrons were very
like the modern tar-kettle, with a flat bottom and no feet, the
reflected rim-flange reaching out nearly as far as the widest part of
the vessel. Several of these which I have restored give the
following measurements: — Height, 9 cm.; widest part of rim, 16
cm.; widest part of body, 17 cm.; bottom slightly convex outwards,
13 cm. Another gives in the same directions 12, 20, 22, and 16
cm. respectively. A flat dish gave height, 3*5 cm.; width of rim,
23 cm.; width of flat bottom, 18 cm. Two fragments of rims
showed decoration upon their upper edges. The first consisted of

96 NATURAL SCIENCE [August

circular hollows, such as could have been made by the flat round-
pointed bone tool, about 1 1 cm. long, found in the Middens ; and
the other was a crescent and line marking, such as could have been
made by a plano-convex tool with a straight edge. Usually the
upper edges of the rims were rounded ; in the flat vessels they
were not always reflected outwards ; and now and then an attempt
was made to thicken the top edge into a bead, although the thumb
only allowed of very poor success.

THE ANIMAL REMAINS

We next come to the animal remains found in the Middens,
which, for many reasons, are extremely interesting. In practically
all cases the marrow bones were split for the contained grease ; they
indicate an unaccountable number of young animals. Many of the
bones are also minus their spongy ends or have lost their epiphyses,
and some show the marks of teeth. The following are some extracts
from my notes upon the species represented : —

Bos longifrons (Celtic shorthorn). — Large limb bones were very
rare, and those discovered were all split for the marrow. Most of
the bones are young without epiphyses, and indicate small animals ;
two or three bones and fragments, however, are large and robust
enough for B. primigenius. The toe bones are all small. The horns
are small, short, and slightly curved, the longest measuring eight
inches along the outside and seven inches girth ; most of the horns
must have measured about five inches along the outside curve. In
eight cases the ends have been gnawed away. Vertebrae and all
irregular bones were very numerous. Jaws were always broken
into fragments, none carrying more than four teeth. Loose teeth
were fairly numerous, some of which were very much worn.

Sits scrofa (pig). — Parts of all bones were present, and all
marrow bones split. Nearly half have lost their articulating
surfaces, and only part of them show teeth marks. One bone
shows the marks of more spatulate teeth, which may have been
human. All the bones are young, few with epiphyses anchylosed.
Two or three of the latter were found not to be gnawed. One
radius is exceptionally stout ; otherwise the bones in general are
quite small, many being not more than one-third grown. Pieces
of head are numerous ; some of the jaws appear rather heavy,
and the longest canine measures five inches in length. Pigs' bones
were often burnt.

Equus caballus (horse). — There were about twenty bones of
horses, chiefly leg and toe bones, one piece of jaw and three odd
teeth, all pointing to small or very small animals : they appear

NATURAL SCIENCE, VOL. XI.

Plate V.

ymW- *■'■;:' *mSBbB:-}> V - N the

CLIFF AT HASTINGS WITH KITCHEN MIDDEN ON LEDGE BELOW A CAVERN

NATURAL SCIENCE, VOL. XI.

Plate VI.

FLINT IMPLEMENTS AND WORKED HONES FROM THE HASTINGS KITCHEN MIDDENS

1897] PRIMEVAL REFUSE HEAPS AT HASTINGS 97

to have been mere ponies. The limb bones are split for marrow,
and two pieces are burnt, though none show traces of gnawing.

Ovis aries (sheep). — All the bones of the sheep were found, and,
with two or three exceptions, they point to very small animals.
They were exceedingly numerous, about as much so as either pig or
ox. All the humeri are broken off short ; all the radii are split, as
are also some of the metacarpals and metatarsals. The bones of
this genus are extremely perplexing, as they differ both in detail
and proportions from any of the modern sheep with which I have
been able to compare them : nearly all of them belong to a small
long-legged variety, sometimes even approaching a small deer. One
or two bones point to an animal just as much the other way, being
altogether stouter than anything I am able to find.

Capra hircus (goat). — There are a few bones and a fragment of a
skull with horn core, which Mr E. T. Newton has identified as goat.

Caprcolus caprca (roebuck). — About the same number has been
referred to roe deer.

Can is fci'iniliaris (dog). — Two tibiae represent a dog of very
large proportions, almost stout enough for wolf ; and some half
dozen other bones point to one of full medium size.

Canis lupus (wolf). — One or two bones have been assigned to
the wolf.

Fdis catus (cat). — There are some half dozen bones belonging to
this species which are of large size, and one tibia has lost its soft
end, although it shows no teeth marks.

Canis vulpcs (fox). — Several bones unquestionably belong to the
fox.

Lepus timidus and L. cuniculus (hare and rabbit). — Both of
these species are represented by few bones. The former was not
very large.

Mcles taxus (badger). — This species is represented by an ulna ;
it agrees well with a fine specimen I have from the Thames Pleis-
tocene brick earth, although perhaps hardly so robust.

Birds. — When we come to the birds, I regret to say that our
public museums are still so deficient in skeletons for comparison
that the determinations are not all quite so satisfactory as could be
wished. A larger series for comparison may add several species to
the list or perhaps otherwise alter it. Of course there is always the
difficulty of being able to say how much variation from the present
examples one ought to allow, and this can only be decided more
correctly when we have much more modern material in our museums.
Mr Newton has identified the following : — Black and red grouse, a
species of duck, guillemot and carrion crow.

Fishes. — These include cod in very large quantities, gurnard,
mackerel, whiting, Coitus, turbot, plaice, and thornback (Raja).

98 NATURAL SCIENCE [August

The Batrachia are represented by the frog or toad.

M oil u sea. — These offer several points of interest. The first to
claim attention is a number of very large Helix aspersa, which are
represented both by whole and broken shells. These were found
under about three feet of midden material, and I have no doubt they
were eaten by man. Zittorina littorea, in point of numbers, stands
first, and the shells are also of very large size. The limpet {Patella
vulgatd) occurs next in quantity, and is represented by two or three
varieties. Cardium echinatum is fairly represented, but C. cdule
was not met with. The whelk (Buccinum undatum) is plentiful,
but Trophon was always absent. Purpura lapillus is represented by
a score or more shells, but whether eaten or employed for their
purple juice it would be difficult to say. One piece of bone recovered
was of a purple colour, suggestive of having been dyed, although it
is highly improbable that the stain would have lasted so long.
Most of the oysters (Ostrea edulis) are of medium size, suggestive of
shallow water ; but here and there some were very large, and may
have spent the greater part of their time in deep waters. The
mussel {Mytilus edulis) often occurred in large masses, although the
shells were always badly preserved. Natica, Pholas and Mactra are
represented by a single specimen each.

CONCLUSION

With this amount of material we are able to restore a fairly
satisfactory picture of the men who left the Eefuse Heaps at the
mouth of the Hastings caves. It is certain that they lived largely
upon fish, both those which could be obtained between tide marks
and those which would require the use of boats of some sort and the
employment of the hook and line ; although the spear in the hands
of dexterous people, perched upon the rock masses which strew this
coast, might have been the favourite instrument. We have no evi-
dence that they knew anything about the use of metal ; but they
were exceptionally skilful fabricators of flints, which they worked
in a manner essentially their own, of such diminutive sizes as to
suggest that the delicate little instruments were largely employed
for fish hooks. The absence of battle axes and all other heavy
tools would point to their not being much employed in wars or agri-
cultural pursuits. No cereals of any kind were found, and no
querns or large mealers ; although leaves and twigs were often pre-
served. They knew the use of fire, which they lit upon hearths, and
kept them going until they had baked the underlying ground for
seven or eight inches. They also employed cooking stones, or " pot
boilers " as they are sometimes called. Their pottery, although
coarse, was fairly well modelled considering there is no sign of the

1S97] PRIMEVAL REFUSE HEAPS AT HASTINGS 99

knowledge of the wheel. It was also fairly well baked, and would
stand the fire, as is shown by the deposit of soot upon some of the
fragments. They appear to have known nothing about the art of
polishing flint or the barbing of arrow heads. In none of the settle-
ments where the characteristic implements have been found, has
anything been obtained to conflict with the evidence of the Middens
in any way. The barrow at Sevenoaks, which contained similar
relics, it is true, was nearly round, pointing to the close of the Neo-
lithic period ; but further research induces me to consider that these
people might nevertheless have preceded the days of the barbed
arrow and the polished axe, and this conclusion is strengthened by the
geological evidence of Dr Colley March in Lancashire. It is prob-
able that the ox, the ' sheep,' and the pig were confined in en-
closures, where they lived in a semi-domesticated state. Man also
seems to have domesticated the dog, which possibly assisted
in keeping the cattle, although the canine bones sometimes look
as if they had been gnawed. It is certain from the large
quantities of bones present that animal food was indulged in
whenever obtainable, perhaps even more so than was the case with
the Baltic Midden men. But the motley group of animals repre-
sented at Hastings showT the men there to have been anything but
epicures, as they appear to have eaten anything upon which they
could lay their hands.

The occurrence of these implements thirty or forty miles inland
in a number of places, suggests their being the work of a Nomadic
people, but whether or not the trans-European localities can be taken
to indicate the line of original migration, further researches will alone
decide. This much is however proved, that the Midden men will
henceforth have to be added to the pre-historic races of Britain.

W. J. Lewis Abbott.

575. 100 (August

581.16

595.793

III

Bees and the Development of Flowers

IN the " Origin of Species," Darwin expressed the view that we
owe the gay colours and varied forms of our flowers to the
selective action of insects. " We may safely conclude," he writes,
" that if insects had never existed on the face of the earth, the
vegetation would not have been decked with beautiful flowers, but
would have produced only such poor flowers as are now borne by
our firs, oaks, nut, and ash trees, by the grasses, by spinach, docks,
and nettles."

This theory of the selective action of insects on flowers has
been elaborated in great detail by Hermann Miiller in Germany,
and by Sir John Lubbock and Mr Grant Allen in this country ;
and almost every writer on Natural Selection has accepted this view
as a part of the Darwinian scheme of evolution. In this case, as in
many others, more recent observers, assuming that the foundations
are secure, have spent their time in elaborating structural details in
the hypothetical edifice. But when we lay the ingenious conception
along the straight rule of facts in nature, the measures do not
correspond. In other words, the foundation, the habits of insects
with regard to flowers, does not support the hypothetical super-
structure.

Professor Henslow, again, has proposed an amendment, in which,
although selection by insects is still the motive power, the modus
operandi is different.

Stated briefly the Darwinian theory is as follows : —

Insects come to flowers for honey and pollen, and in so doing
do not visit all indiscriminately, but select those which take their
fancy, or suit them best. If they are seeking honey they will
choose those flowers which afford the most, or in which it is most
easily obtained ; if they have a special liking for any colour, say
blue, they will pick out the bluest flowers ; if any special shape of
flower affords them greater convenience for alighting, they will visit
these rather than others. Now in any species of flower all these
things — amount and position of honey, colour, and shape — vary in
different individuals. If, then, insects possessed the requisite dis-
crimination, we might suppose them selecting, generation after
generation, those flowers in which these desirable points were most
highly developed. The flowers thus visited would obtain the

1897] BEES AND THE DEVELOPMENT OF FLOWERS 101

benefits of cross-fertilisation, and their descendants would therefore
be more numerous and vigorous than of those not visited. This
more vigorous progeny of the insect-visited and cross-fertilised
flowers would gradually live down the less vigorous offspring of the
unvisited flowers. Hence any particular character perseveringly
selected by insects for many generations would come to predominate,
be gradually perfected, and finally form a new specific type.

Such is a brief outline of the theory which has captivated the
minds, not only of men of science, but also of the public, and which
has been accepted by almost every evolutionist as the explanation
of the form and colour of flowers. Professor Henslow's amendment,
while still depending on selection and the benefits of cross-fertilisa-
tion, attributes the alteration in the shape and colour of the flower
to the direct stimulus of the insect's action. Thus an insect hanging
to the lower petal of a flower elongates the same by its weight, and
the lengthened petal is transmitted by heredity ; the irritation
caused by its feet in walking along the flower causes the appearance
of colouring matter, and the colour is likewise transmitted ; as it
probes for honey it causes a flow of sweet sap to that part, and this
also becomes hereditary. This view is quite too Lamarckian for
England or Germany, whatever may be its fate in America.

The weight of authority supporting the insect selection theory,
and its wide acceptance in scientific circles, renders it perhaps a
little rash to criticise it adversely ; yet a series of observations on
the habits of bees with regard to flowers extending over many years,
has forced me to the conclusion that it has no sufficient foundation
in fact. Details of some of these observations have been given else-
where, and I shall here state only the general results. Bees have
been chosen because, of all insects, these are the easiest and most
interesting to watch in their visits to flowers. They are also
the most important of insects for the theory, since they are by far
the most frequent and regular visitors of flowers. If the bee's action
can be shown to be insufficient, no one will support the claims of any
other insect. Let us, then, see what the bee really does in the way
of selecting special forms and colours of flowers by watching it in
the fields and gardens, and consider what effect this can have on the
flowers visited.

It has been frequently pointed out that Sir John Lubbock's ex-
periments prove that bees have special tastes for certain colours, and
that they prefer red and blue, especially the latter. This preference
of the bee for blue is one of the cardinal points of the theory, and
has been considered almost sufficient in itself to justify the assump-
tion that blue flowers have been evolved by their selective action.
But without wishing in the least to disparage the work of one of our
great authorities on insects, I submit that observations of what bees

102 NATURAL SCIENCE [August

actually do in the way of visiting flowers is of more importance to
the theory than any such experiments ; and, as we shall see pre-
sently, bees in visiting flowers do not show any marked preference
for blue ones.

The analogy between man's selection resulting in artificial breeds,
and natural selection resulting in species, was often and strongly in-
sisted on by Darwin ; while the action of the insect in evolving a
new species of flower specially adapted to its requirements in form
and colour, has been compared to that of the gardener in the pro-
duction by selection of his special varieties. The extreme care re-
quired from the gardener, not only in the selection of the requisite
variation, but also in its isolation and preservation is well known.
If the new variety in the process of its evolution be allowed to cross
with the parent stock it is lost. Darwin even went so far as to
warn gardeners against allowing crossing between different indivi-
duals of the new variety, as such tends to produce reversion. It is
a little difficult to understand how the bee, even if it possessed all
that nice discrimination of form and colour, and all that constancy
required by the theory, could accomplish that which demands such
care and patience on the part of the gardener. In order to evolve a
race of blue flowers from those normally of another colour, bees
would have to select those among the slight natural variations which
had a tinge of blue. If they really preferred to gather honey from
blue flowers — they would not have merely to prefer blue in the ab-
stract— they would do so, and these bluish flowers would receive the
benefits of cross-fertilisation. But the few bluish flowers among the
many normal ones would not suffice : the bees, from the necessity of
obtaining honey, would be obliged to visit the normally-coloured
ones also. Thus the new variety would be blended with the parent
type and lost, for pollen would be carried from the one to the other.
In order to isolate the bluish variety, the bee would not only have
to prefer blue, but also steadily refuse to visit any other colour ;
and if it did so when the bluish flowers were first appearing it
would starve for want of honey. But we have no proof that the
bee even possesses the taste. In all my observations of bees I
have met with nothing to support the view that they prefer to take
their honey out of blue flowers. Some blue flowers they visit fre-
quently, others they visit very seldom. No blue flowers are more
frequently visited than others which are yellowish-green, pink, and
various other shades. Some uncompromisingly green flowers — as
the plane tree and red currant — are frequently visited. As regards
colour, then, the bee seems to have neither the taste to select, nor
the ability — through the necessity of obtaining sufficient honey — to
restrict itself in the manner required. Moreover, the fact that the
same species of bee may be seen visiting flowers of the most diverse

1897] BEES AND THE DEVELOPMENT OE FLOWERS 103

shapes, from the simplest to the most complex, does not seem to
imply that they have the requisite selective tendency as regards
form. This is further illustrated by the fact that bees may at times
be seen visiting ilowers which have lost their corollas wholly or in
part. Thus \ have seen them visit petal-less flowers of wild
geranium, bramble, and cistus. Darwin relates his observation of
the same fact. More recently Professor Plateau of Ghent has
removed the corollas of certain flowers, and found that this proceed-
ing made little difference to the insects visiting them. Bees may
also be seen to visit abnormally developed, as well as half -faded
flowers. In many cases, again, bees instead of using the form of the
flower supposed to be specially fitted for their convenience, and the
outcome of taste, will bite a hole near the base of the corolla, and
get the honey through it. These holes may frequently be seen in
heath and the bush vetch.

Again, if our native flowers are the result of the selective action
of our native bees, and those which they have specially chosen for
countless generations, how is it that bees take so readily to many
flowers of verv different forms introduced into our gardens from
abroad ? For such introduced plants are in many cases freely visited
by native bees.

In order to evolve and keep distinct new species bees would
have to be extremely constant in their visits to flowers : in a single
journey from the nest, or until they got rid of all the pollen
adhering to their bodies, they would have to visit only a single
variety. If they did not do so they would not merely be unable to
develop and differentiate new varieties ; they would even retard by
intercrossing, varieties developing into species by any other means.
It is pretty generally believed that the bee is very constant in its
visits to flowers, and that when it begins with any particular species
it keeps to that until it has obtained its load. So long ago as the
time of Aristotle, indeed, the constancy of the bee was noted as a
fact in natural history. But while it is true that bees do show a
considerable amount of constancy and often visit a large number of
flowers of the same species in succession, they are far from possessing
that amount of constancy required by the theory. For this they
would require to restrict themselves, not merely to a single species,
but to one variety of that species. This is obvious, since all species
are supposed to have begun as varieties ; and it is even more import-
ant that they should restrict themselves to one variety than to one
species, since such varieties will be more readily crossed by transfer-
ence of pollen. But it is a well-established fact that bees pass freely
from variety to variety of the same species in our gardens. Darwin
has observed this, and it is one of the most firmly established results of
my own observations. They do not even confine themselves in a single

104 NATURAL SCIENCE [August

journey to varieties of the same species. In numerous cases I have
seen bees visit two, three, and even four species in the course of a
minute or two. The general results of ray observations on this
point are as follows : —

Hive bees are much more constant than wild bees, yet they pass
freely from variety to variety, and not by any means rarely from
species to species. As to the latter, take any wild bee, and if you
can follow its movements for twenty visits or more, the chances are
something like ten to one that it will be seen to change its species
of flower. If we suppose that the bee of the past acted as the bee
of to-day, then it seems to me that in this habit alone we have a
complete refutation of the theory.

Another of the foundations of the theory is the benefit supposed
to result from the cross-fertilisation effected by the bee in flying
from flower to flower. Darwin's well-known experiments on
cross-fertilisation point to the conclusion that the seedlings of
cross-fertilised plants are more numerous and vigorous than those
of the self-fertilised. Without wishing to throw doubt on the
general deductions from these experiments, I may be permitted to
point out that certain facts regarding fertilisation in nature render
them of doubtful support to the theory. First, there is the fact
that certain species of flowers which are habitually self -fertilised are
among the most numerous and vigorous of our native plants. Such,
for example, are Polygonum aviculare, the least visited by insects,
and yet the most abundant of its genus : Veronica hederaefolia,
one of the commonest of the veronicas, yet very seldom visited by
insects, as H. Midler points out : while among the geraniums, G.
molle and G. pwsillum, which Midler states to be the most fre-
quently self-fertilised, and perhaps the most common of their genus
with the exception of G. robertianum. Professor Henslow, indeed,
has sone so far as to state that " in nature whenever self-fertilisation
can be effected more seed is borne than by the forms requiring
crossing." Among the orchids again, some species exhibit the most
complicated arrangements for avoiding self- and securing cross-
fertilisation ; others exhibit equal complications for securing the
former and avoiding the latter. And if the inference is that the
contrivances in the former case were evolved because cross-
fertilisation was an advantage, then it follows equally that in the latter
case they were evolved because self-fertilisation was an advantage
Darwin, in accordance with his general views on cross-fertilisation,
believed that such self-fertilised orchids were dying out, but the
increased number of such now known seems to forbid this view,
and it is difficult to understand how such self-fertilised orchids can
have been evolved from a race specially fitted for cross-fertilisation
on the supposition that this latter method is always beneficial.

1897] BEES AND THE DEVELOPMENT OE E LOWERS 105

Those flowers of the original race which were cross-fertilised should
have survived rather than those self-fertilised. The passage from
perfect adaptation for cross-fertilisation to perfect adaptation to
self-fertilisation is a long one, and must have been spread over
many generations in each of which the latter was an advantage, if
it is to be accounted for on the principles of natural selection.
But it has been suggested that the change has been due to the
absence of insects and that thus only those plants which were able
to fertilise themselves survived. If, however, we suppose that in the
ancestral orchid the apparatus for cross-fertilisation was as perfect
as in many species at the present day, it would be incapable of
self-fertilisation, and therefore die out in the absence of insect
visits. Even if it could in a few cases fertilise itself, how could its
fewer and weaker progeny compete with the stronger seedlings of
nearly related and cross-fertilised species probably occupying the
same station ? If, however, in the ancestral orchid the arrangement
for fertilisation was such that self-fertilisation usually took place
in default of insect visits, then no benefit would arise from change
of form to perfect adaptation for self- and avoidance of insect-
fertilisation. With regard to the benefits resulting from cross-
fertilisation generally, Professor Henslow points out that orchids,
the most remarkably adapted of all plants for cross-fertilisation by
insects, " set the least amount of seed even when fully exposed to
insects."

Another fact established by Darwin in relation to cross-fertilisa-
tion is that the offspring of the cross is more vigorous when between
slight varieties of the same species, or between individuals grown
under slightly different conditions. This fact is also adverse to the
theory of the development of a species of flower by the selective
action of the bee. For among the offspring of the crosses affected
by it those will be strongest which occur between varieties, or be-
tween plants grown at a distance, and therefore likely to differ
slightly from each other. But these are precisely the individuals
in which the incipient characters tending to the formation of a
new species will be least marked. Hence the action of the bee is
rather to retard development ; and Darwin himself has remarked
that frequent in-crossing tends to give uniformity to species varying
slightly as they do in a state of nature.

A brief allusion to Professor Henslow's amendment of the
Darwinian insect selection theory will suffice. Apart from the
extreme improbability — as shown by recent research — that such
acquired characters as the lengthening of the petal of a flower by
the weight of an insect stretching it, or the coloration caused by
the irritation of an insect's feet, are transmitted, Professor Hens-
low's theory splits on the same rock as the older one. For, like the

106 NATURAL SCIENCE [August

other, it requires a discriminating taste and constancy on the part
of the bee. It involves, moreover, the assumption, that while cer-
tain simple and regular flowers visited by insects have remained
simple, others originally equally regular and simple have had im-
pressed on them all sorts of irregular and complex forms by the
same insects visiting them in the same way and for the same pur-
pose. If the direct action of the insect in visiting one simple and
regular flower is to elongate one petal and form a hood of another,
how has it been possible for it to visit a host of others for countless
generations without producing any such effect, or altering the
simple regularity of their form ? It is not probable, then, that
Professor Henslow's amendment will be adopted, at least in these
days of scientific doubt as to the transmission of acquired characters.
Other insects, it is generally admitted, are even less discriminat-
ing, and more erratic, in their visits to flowers than bees. Hence,
if bees cannot be accepted as evolvers of new species of flowers by
their selective action, the whole theory of insect selection fails.
It remains a fact that no alternative explanation of the origin of
the colour, scent, and form of flowers on Darwinian principles has
yet been brought forward. In this fact, indeed, we have the only
— if insufficient — reason why the theory has been so long retained.

Gr. W. BULMAN.

REFERENCES

1. Darwin, C. — " Origin of Species." London, 1859.

2. Lubbock, Sir John. — " British Wild Flowers in relation to Insects." London,

1875.

3. Darwin, C. — "Cross- and Self-fertilisation of Plants." London, 1876.

4. Bennett, A. W. — " Constancy of Insects in their visits to Flowers." Journ. Linn.

Soc. Zool., vol. xvii., p. 175. 1883.

5. Christy, R. M. — " On Methodic Habits of Insects when visiting Flowers." Ibid.,

p. 186.

6. Allen, Grant. — " The Colours of Flowers." London, 1882.

7. Mllller, Hermann. — " The Fertilisation of Flowers " [English translation]. London,

1883.

8. Henslow, Rev. George.— " Floral Structures." London, 1888.

9. Bulman, G. W.— " On the Supposed Selective Action of Bees on Flowers."

Zoologist [3], vol. xiv., p. 422. 1890.
10. .— " The Constancy of the Bee." Science Gossip, 1892.

581.151 107

589.3

Polymorphism in the Algae

THE following is a translation of an extract (pp. 171-186) from
Professor Klebs' recent work " Die Bedingungen der Fort-
pflanzung bei einigen Algen und Pilzen," Jena, 1896, reviewed in
Natural Science, vol. x., p. 128 (Feb. 1897).

The pages in question are written a propos of Prof. Klebs'
interesting discovery that the well-known alga, Botrydium granu-
latum, is not in reality so polymorphic as the botanical world has
believed since the publication in 1877 of Eostafinski and Woronin's
researches, but that the forms therein described belong, in reality,
to two very distinct algae, Botrydium granulatum, Wallroth, and
Brotococcus botryoidcs, Kiitzing, the latter being renamed Brotosiphon
lotryoidcs (Kiitzing) Klebs.

But my immediate object is not so much to call attention to
this or any other of the interesting discoveries of which an account
is given in Prof. Klebs' important book, as to put into a form easily
accessible to everyone interested a most lucid and admirable dis-
cussion on a question which, to judge from my own experience,
must continually perplex students of algal literature. No one who
knows his work can doubt Prof. Klebs' authority to speak on the
topic, and it is unfortunate that his luminous remarks, which are
perfectly complete in themselves, should remain buried in the
middle of a chapter of his bulky volume, where they can only be
read by a few specialists. Prof. Klebs and his publisher, Dr
Fischer of Jena, have most kindly accorded me permission to
publish this translation. A. G. Tansley.

Although a number of the lower green algae were described in
the first half of this century, it was by Kiitzing and Nageli that the
foundation of our present knowledge of these forms was laid.
Kiitzing described an enormous number of species which he
distributed partly into new genera, partly into those which Nageli
had with admirable judgment already established. Side by side
with the tendency to a thorough-going splitting of species, we find
in Kiitzing the belief that lower algae transform themselves into
higher forms, even into mess-protonema. Hitherto these poly-
morphistic ideas of Kiitzing's have not succeeded in establishing
themselves, since they are obviously based on too cursory investiga-

108 NATURAL SCIENCE [August

tions. The description of new species and genera of lower algae went
quietly forward till Cienkowski published in 1876 his observations
on the palmella- condition of the filamentous algae, Stigeoclonium,
Ulothrix, etc. These very reliable observations seemed to prove
that lower algae are only developmental stages of the filamentous
forms. Cienkowski himself, and other workers also, went so far
as to express doubt as to the independence of most unicellular
green algae. In order to decide the question, I established from
1879 to 1881 many cultures of these forms. My observations,
from which I published a short extract in 1883, showed that the
lower algae, treated by the methods then accessible to me, were as
much independent organisms and remained as constant as any
higher plant. The common, universally distributed organism,
Pleurococcus vulgaris, for instance, reproduced itself only by
vegetative division, and it could not by any method be converted
into another alga. Artari (1892) again investigated this question,
and answered it in the same sense. Gay also (1891) has proved
by means of cultures the independence both of Pleurococcus and of
other forms. Nevertheless, the old idea of a far-reaching poly-
morphism among the algae is constantly reappearing.

Since Hansgirg in 1885 came to the conclusion that all possible
algae are forms of a single species, and thus showed himself as
uncritical as Kiitzing before him (cf. my criticism, Botanischc
Zcitung, 1886), Chodat, and especially Borzi, have quite recently
announced the genetic connection of many algae which were
hitherto considered independent. Both workers have tried to give
greater weight to their opinions by means of evidence obtained from
culture experiments. To what an extent Borzi is dominated by the
idea of polymorphism is shown in his most recent work (1895) by
the treatment of the life cycle of " Protoderma viride," to which he
assigns species of the following genera : Protococcus, Botryococcus,
Chlorococcus, Limnodictyon, Physodictyon, Palmella, Tetraspora,
Neplirocytium, Trochiscia, Oocystis, Sccnedesmus, Raphidium. The
connection of all these forms Borzi thinks he has proved by means
of cultures. According to the view of this worker, the various
developmental states have " stadii anamorfici"; thus, for instance,
the Raphidium- and Scenedcsmus-iorms ' have the power under
certain circumstances of remaining and multiplying as such for
years, and then when opportunity offers they again turn into the
higher forms.

Chodat does not go nearly so far as Borzi in his belief in
polymorphism, and he expresses himself less clearly and distinctly.
He contents himself with believing (1893-4-5) that such an alga as
for instance Raphidium, is very variable, so that it may take on the
form of a Sccnedesmus, a Protococcus, a Characium, a DactylococcusT
or a Sciadium. The Sccnedesmus behaves under certain circum-

1897] POLYMORPHISM IN THE ALGAE 109

stances as a Dactylococcws, and the latter as a Sccnedesmus. But in
spite of all his belief in the existence of transitions between the
various forms of lower algae, in spite of the fluctuation of all their
characters and of the melting away of all limits, Chodat still holds to a
certain independence in the various types ; only it does not appear from
anything he says whether the deviations from these types are due to
the definite effects of external conditions or whether they belong to
constant varieties or races. Neither has Chodat always drawn
accurate inferences. If his observation is correct, that the already-
mentioned Pleurococcus vulgaris can grow out into a Stigeoclonium,
it must be assigned to the branched filamentous type of algae. But
Chodat says, " I do not think that Pleurococcus is a state of a higher
alga. I think that it must be considered as a type degenerated
through the influence of its habitat, and which in water and under
favourable conditions can tend towards its primitive state." Thus
Pleurococcus is to be considered a degeneration-form of a Stigeo-
chmiam, although it behaves as an independent simple alga. If one
takes the observations of Chodat and Borzi together, so far as they
relate to the same form, for instance Baphidium polymorphum (or
braunii), one obtains a picture of a species which for excentricity
certainly leaves nothing to be desired, and which is unique in the
organic world. Baphidium, according to Borzi, belongs to the
cycle of forms of various higher algae (Prasiola, Ulothrix, etc.) ; it
is produced in this way — two zoospores, in consequence of their
escape from the sporangium taking place abnormally, grow together
by their hinder ends, and this pair then turns into a Baphidium
(Borzi, 1895, p. 231, " My cultures exclude all doubt as to this
fact "). If it had not been such a well-known and eminent algologist
as Borzi who put forward these opinions they would not have been
worth the trouble of wasting a word upon, but under the circum-
stances they must be taken into account. In any case it is clear
from what has been said, that unlimited confusion prevails in the
classification of the lower algae, and that the most contradictory
views are held even about the simplest and commonest organisms
such as Pleurococcus, Baphidium, etc.

We cannot decide on theoretical grounds whether a form is
independent or genetically connected with another. It has in fact
happened in the history of the subjects that forms which at one
time were considered independent have been certainly proved to be
developmental states of other species. It is conceivable that out of
the enormous number of described species of algae many others will
meet with the same fate. The only possible way to arrive at clearness
and knowledge is to use a -scientific method which will stand the
test of criticism.

It is remarkable that so little has been learnt from the history

110 NATURAL SCIENCE [August

of science. In the history of botany the same struggle about poly-
morphism has taken place twice, first in the case of the fungi and
then in that of the bacteria. On both occasions as it gradually be-
came recognised that the pure culture of the organisms in question
is the necessary starting point of every research, the fruitless
theoretical discussions were replaced by work on really scientific
lines. Likewise in the present case ; for the solution of the
problems with which they were concerned Chodat and Borzi
ought to have started with pure cultures ; but this is just what
they failed to do. The method of pure cultivation has hitherto played
no part in algology ; our knowledge has been obtained by the method
of direct observation, which has been employed in a most thorough
way by such investigators as Thuret, Cohn, Pringsheim, De Bary,
and others. The fact is that the distinctive characters of many
algae are quite sufficient to allow of their recognition among other
organisms, and to enable their development to be followed by con-
tinuous direct observation ; and the artificial cultivation of many
of these algae is beset with great difficulties. There are also
many of the lower algae among which no confusion arises in
impure cultures. Forms such as Hydrodictyon, for instance, allow
of their entire development being observed in the presence of other
larger or smaller forms. But the matter is quite otherwise in all
those algae which possess but few external readily recognisable
characters, and among which at the same time there is such a
multiplicity of closely allied species that all possible so-called
transitional forms exist. This is the case, for instance, in the
subaerial Ulothrix-like organisms, and also among the lower green
algae such as the numerous species of Pleurococcus, Protococcus,
Palmetto,, etc., which are extremely easy to confound with one
another. Furthermore, the higher algae possess developmental
stages which to outward appearance are exactly like certain
lower forms ; and the false conclusion that therefore all lower algae
are developmental forms of higher algae is often enough drawn.
Swarming gametes of Chlamydomonas cannot be distinguished
from gametes of Ulothrix; but it does not follow that Chlamy-
domonas belongs to Ulothrix. Similarly filamentous algae form
Protococcus-like stages ; but again it does not follow that all species
of Protococcus belong to filamentous algae. Simple similarity in
appearance or the apparent identity of two forms decides nothing,
and anyone who relies upon it runs the risk of falling into the
grossest error. Even two such distinguished investigators as Iiosta-
finski and Woronin were baffled in their observations on Botrydium
simply because the developmental stages of the real Botrydium and
of Protosiphon have a striking external resemblance.

The question now presents itself, how must we proceed in order

1897] POLYMORPHISM IN THE ALGAE 111

to solve the problem of the independence or genetic connexion of
two or more algae with the greatest possible certainty ? In my
view such an investigation demands attention to three important
points : —

(1) The pure cultivation of the organisms in question

Just as a pure culture is obviously essential for any research
into the history of development of a fungus or of a bacterium, a
similar culture is the necessary starting point in the investigation
of the life-history of a lower alga. In general, the algae grow
much more slowly than the fungi and bacteria ; cultures, therefore,
have to be maintained for a longer period, and the chance of the
accidental introduction of foreign forms into an originally pure
culture must not be neglected. Minute cells or spores of Proto-
coccoideae, etc., are present in the dust of the air. It is only
necessary to leave a sterilised solution of nutritive salts, not very
well protected, in the light, in order to convince oneself that algae
set into it with the dust. It is clear from the works of Chodat and
Borzi, that these workers had only impure cultures at their disposal,
since, on the one hand, they used material taken direct from its
natural habitat, and containing numerous species of algae, and on
the other, they paid no attention to the sources of error arising from
the exposure of their cultures to dust.

(2) Direct observation

In the case of the lower algae it is always necessary to observe
directly under the microscope, the course of development or the
transformation of one form of cell into another. In default of a
pure culture, this method may, under certain circumstances, do
instead ; but it should be used in any case, even if the culture is to
all appearance pure. A combination of the two methods leads to
very certain results. Chodat and Borzi have employed them far
too little. For instance, Borzi ought to have isolated the double
zoospores of Prasiola, etc., and then uninterruptedly observed their
subsequent fate, in order to convince himself that they actually
turned into Baphidium. And similarly it would be necessary to
observe directly the development of the filamentous alga, whether
Prasiola or Protoderma, from Baphidium, a thing which it appears
Borzi never really saw. The same criticism holds in regard to
Chodat's statement that Pleurococcus vulgaris changes into Stigeo-
clonium. The immediate transformation of an undoubted Pleurococcus
cell into a Stigeoclonium has not been seen, any more than a trans-
formation of the latter into Pleurococcus.

112 NATURAL SCIENCE [August

(3) An accurate knowledge of the conditions under which
the individual developmental stages occur, or the
transformation of one form into another obtains

This point has received as yet scarcely any attention in algae or
other organisms, e.g., fungi, and such knowledge has never been
recognised as necessary, since it has not hitherto been believed that
it was possible to determine these conditions. In works which deal
with polymorphism, from Klitzing to Borzi, great significance has. it
is true, been attributed to external conditions in the transformation
of forms, but only in quite a general, undefined and vague way.
Never in any case has a given developmental form been clearly
recognised and demonstrated as the necessary consequence of definite
external conditions ; such forms have mostly been observed merely
by chance. In his work on Eremosphaera, Chodat describes, besides
the well-known typical cells, certain dwarf forms with somewhat
different structure, he describes Pahnclla-Gloeocystis-st&ges, he also
brings a Chlamydomonas-iovm into connexion with these ; all of
which are developmental forms or (it may be) independent species
found accidentally in the same culture of Eremosphaera. "We never
get a hint of an explanation how such various states of the same
alga can appear in the same culture.

But since my observations have shown that external conditions
actually decide the appearance of the reproductive stages of many
algae, it has become necessary in all similar work to attempt at
least to discover the appropriate conditions of the , appearance of
each developmental form.

The next goal to be attained is such an exact knowledge of the
conditions that we can elicit a given developmental form at will.
Such investigations as these naturally demand much time and
trouble ; and even so in the case of many organisms they do not
lead to the desired result. Thus, in certain species, in spite of the
firm conviction that external conditions must be of great significance,
these conditions are not yet sufficiently clearly understood, as for
instance in the case of Ulothrix zonata, ITormidium nitens, etc.
Thus there remains a gap in our knowledge, which, later on,
with the aid of better methods, will be filled up. On the other
hand, there is the alternative that a given developmental form is
produced as a result of the operation of inner causes which we are
not able to elucidate ; in that case we shall find by experience that
it will appear quite regularly and can always be observed at the
appropriate stage in the life-history of the species. But in all the
lower algae — and these are the forms I am specially considering
here — my whole experience leads necessarily to the conviction that
external conditions determine the appearance of each developmental

1897] POLYMORPHISM IN THE ALGAE 113

form ; and hence in all work on such algae this line of investigation
demands the greatest attention.

If in the future the lower algae are investigated on the lines
I have indicated, it will be possible for us to emerge from the
confusion prevailing at present, and to bring the study of these
organisms on to a higher plane. Such investigations will, according
to my view, be of very great value in advancing the systematic know-
ledge of species, not only because they will enable the cycle of forms
belonging to a given species to be completely determined, but also
because in the diagnosis of the species they will enable new charac-
ters to be recognised. The way in which the various stages in the life-
history of a lower organism react to external conditions, especially
the way in which its reproduction depends upon the external world,
furnish specific characters as important as the morphological ones.
And these physiological characters become so much the more
valuable in proportion as the external characters become less con-
spicuous. In the bacteria we have already been compelled to take
such characters into account ; and the time is not far distant when
it will be self-evident that in the diagnosis of a new alga, there
must be placed alongside of the accurate description of its structure
and the history of its development, a clear account of its behaviour
in relation to the external world. To-day the mere determination
and the giving of a name to a species is far too generally the
sole aim in systematic botany, and it is here, among these lower
organisms, that the proper goal of the systematic knowledge of
plants may be soonest reached — to present a complete picture of all
the peculiarities of each several organism.

The whole of my more recent experiments with algae confirm
my earlier experience, and correspond with the results of the in-
vestigation of bacteria and fungi — they show, namely, that within
the time available for experiment, the hereditary characters of an
organism are not markedly altered by external conditions. The
variations in size, form, cell-structure, and reaction to external
influences, oscillate within definite limits — limits which up to the
present we have not been able to pass. The constancy of the species
meets us with striking clearness in all cultivations and experiments
under existing conditions ; it remains for further experiments, carried
on for longer periods, and with the aid of better methods, to decide
whether these limits cannot be broken through. The important
observations on certain bacteria, in which it was found that heredi-
tary characters such as virulence and pigment-production, could be
suppressed for a long time, point in this direction. But anything
like such a result has not hitherto been obtained among the algae,
although it is possible that it may be obtained in the future.

In spite of the actual constancy of specific character among the

114 NATURAL SCIENCE [August

algae, the difficulty of arranging the species into genera and families
is extraordinarily great, since there has been an enormous multi-
plicity of species production. There exist, between the species
typical of the various genera, numerous other forms, varieties, etc.,
each of which is a perfectly constant type, but which confuse the
limits between genera and families. Very soon the dictum which
I laid down in connexion with my systematic working up of the
Flagellata in 1892, will apply equally well to the algae, namely,
that the more we take into consideration the multitude of forms,
the more difficult to construct and the more artificial our system
becomes. The contradiction between the constancy of the single
form, whether we call it species or variety, and the variability of all
characters within the limits of an extended circle of forms, be it
genus or family, has not yet been explained ; Darwinian teaching
has brought clearly to light the existence of this contradiction, but
it has not yet discovered how to resolve it.

Geobg Klebs.

575.2 115

On the Scientific Measure of Variability

a HO review the reviewer is always a profitless task, and yet I
am tempted to repeat what must be more or less of a failure.
In this case, however, the reviewer happens to be a man whose
opinion deservedly carries weight, and many readers may consider
that he must have fairly epitomised the statements made in my
paper on " Variation in Man and Woman." This does not seem to
me to be the case ; and, in justice to myself, I wish to distinctly
repudiate one or two opinions Professor Weldon fastens upon me
{Natural Science, vol. xi., pp. 50-54).

In the first place, Professor Weldon states that the object of
my paper " is to support the contention that women are, on the
whole, more variable than men." I wish to entirely disclaim any
such object. The paper was written with the purely scientific
aim of comparing the variation of man and woman, and was due
to the fact that a study of numerous writers on the subject had led
me to believe that there was as yet no evidence to show greater
variation in one sex than the other ; that most of the reasoning on
the subject was invalid and nearly all partizan. I may safely say
that the two friends who undertook with me the lengthy arithmetic
involved had no " contention " and no bias. We simply thought
that no evidence of a satisfactory kind was forthcoming,
in the case of man, for Darwin's law of the greater variability
of the male ; and we determined, so far as was possible, to
undertake a thorough investigation of the question. And what is
the general conclusion reached ? That the female is more variable
than the male — which is the impression any reader must form
from Professor Weldon's review ? Not at all. In the summary
I distinctly state that, in the material considered, there is no
evidence of greater male variability, but rather of a slightly
greater female variability. In the body of the paper it is stated
that the less civilised races have nearly equal variability for the
two sexes, while, in the more highly civilised, woman — probably
owing to the lessening of her struggle for existence as compared
with man — has apparently greater variability. I conclude : — " I
would ask the reader to note that I do not proclaim the equal
variability of the sexes, but merely assert that the present results
show that the greater variability often claimed for man remains as

116 NATURAL SCIENCE [August

yet a quite unproven principle." The " contention " of the paper
is that there is no proof forthcoming of man's greater variability.
Whether either sex is the more variable is left for the future to
settle in the following words : —

" When more material is available, and finer methods are
applied, then perhaps it will be possible to detect a more note-
worthy preponderance of variability in the one or other sex."
And, again, in referring to the slight preponderance of variability
observed in woman : — " I strongly suspect that this preponderating
variability of women is mainly due to a relatively less severe
struggle for existence." These are not the words of one whose
" object is to support the contention that women are, on the whole,
more variable than men." They seem to me the words of one who
wishes to reach a scientific conclusion without any party or sex
bias.

In the next place, Professor Weldon objects to my use of the
co-efficient of variation. He apparently wishes to assert that
absolute variation is the real test of most things. I am some-
what surprised to see him advocating this test. It is not so
many months since an American critic pointed out how fatally
this measurement of variation affected the conclusions of a certain
paper of Professor Weldon's on selective mortality in crabs. I
have not seen any answer to that criticism, and I very much doubt
if one can be found. Some years ago I pointed out to him that
the same measurement of variability led to absurd results in the
case of the selective mortality of men.

But even here Professor Weldon puts in my mouth opinions I
have never expressed. He writes : — " The violent assertion that
there is only one ' scientific ' measure of variability is therefore to
be regretted." Now, so far from asserting the validity of only one
measure of variability, I carefully state in paragraph (c) of my
conclusions : —

" There is more than one method of quantitatively measuring
variability, but the measure which is really significant for pro-
gressive evolution has not hitherto been determined."

On p. 343 I write, " We may stay to ask whether the statistics
of skull capacity do not in themselves give us any information with
regard to the superiority of either standard deviation or the co-
efficient of variation as a test of that variability which is valuable
for progressive evolution," and on p. 345 I conclude that the
results do not enable us to say offhand that absolute or percentage
variation is a better measure of the variability which is a source
of progressive evolution. These are hardly the words of one who
lias made a " violent assertion that there is only one measure of
variability."

1897] THE SCIENTIFIC MEASURE OF VARIABILITY 111

What is it then that I have asserted ? Simply this, that if it
be necessary to compare the variability of the same organ in two
sexes which have on the average different sizes, it is absurd to use
absolute variations. This conclusion is nothing new ; it has long-
been familiar to craniologists and anthropologists. They have, for
instance, compared brain-weight relative to body-weight or to
stature. I contend that the proper measure is the percentage
variation on the mean. My words are, " I hold that the only
useful sense in which we can study relative variability is by
endeavouring to answer the problem. Is one sex closer to its
mean, more conservative to its type than the other? and that
the only scientific answer to this lies in the magnitudes of the
percentage variations of the two sexes for corresponding organs."
It will be seen at once that this is not, as Professor Weldon appears
to misinterpret it, an assertion of a single scientific measure of
variability but a statement of opinion as to the only useful way
in which we can compare in the two sexes the relative variability
in the same organ. Professor "Weldon, indeed, seems to confuse
two things, the scientific measure of variability and the effectiveness
of this variability for different organs in the struggle for existence.
Because the variability of one organ is said to be twice that of
another organ, it does not follow that the functional importance is
doubled. The scientific measure of variability is one thing, the
effectiveness of this amount of variability in the struggle for exist-
ence is another and different thing. But even here I am prepared
to assert, although I have not done so in my paper, that the co-
efficient of variation, without being proportional to the " effective-
ness," is far more reasonable as a measure of effectiveness, when we
are dealing with the same organ in different sexes, or in individuals
of the same sex at different ages, than absolute variation. It seems to
me that the non-regard of this point has led to the nugatory character
— not of the splendid system of measurements on crabs made by Pro-
fessor Weldon — but of several of the conclusions he has endeavoured
to base upon those measurements. I cannot get over the fact that
the variation of an inch in the leg of a pony is not the same thing
as a variation of an inch in the leg of a horse. Out of the 155
cases dealt with in my paper, woman is in 62 or 63, I think,
absolutely more variable than man, and man absolutely more
variable in some 85 ; in the remainder the sexes are sensibly equal.
But since woman is smaller than man in the weight and size of nearly
all organs, absolute variability can only be adopted with the same
justification as we should say that an inch is the same variation in
the leg of a pony or a horse, -or a cubic centimeter the same varia-
tion in the capacity of the brain of a man or a new-born infant.

If Professor Weldon asserts that taking the co-efficient of variation

118 NATURAL SCIENCE [August

as a standard, then the same amount of variation in man and woman
has more effectiveness in one sex than the other, I must reply, no
one has yet investigated this point ; my own conclusions on skull
measurements, so far as they have yet gone, seem to show that the
co-efficient is at least a rough measurement of effectiveness. But it
must be clear that until we have investigated the relation of effective-
ness to some clear measure of variation, Darwin's law of the greater
variability of the male is entirely unproven. Whether we put
effectiveness as a function of mean and of standard deviation, or as
a function of mean and the ratio of standard deviation to mean, is
not, at first sight, a matter of great importance ; it is to be settled
rather by what the algebraist considers a convenient shape for his
formulae. It is the biologist who has to determine the form of the
function. It probably varies widely from species to species and
organ to organ, but it may reasonably be supposed to vary only
continuously and gradually with age and sex. If the selective
death-rate of any species, however, be a function only of the mean
and standard-deviation of any particular organ, then the theory of
dimensions shows us at once that the death-rate cannot be a
function solely of absolute variation, but must be a function of the
ratio of absolute variation to the mean, i.e., of the co-efficient of
variation.

Lastly, if Professor Weldon thinks I have reviewed my biological
critic harshly, I would remark that I submitted my paper a year
ago in proof to a valued biological friend, I still have in a familiar
hand-writing "no suggestions to make." That Professor Weldon
should find in my paper a " violent assertion " to be regretted, con-
firms my view that modern biology is a house divided against itself.

Karl Pearson.

572.(94.2) 119

Initiation Kites of the Arunta Tribe,
Central Australia

IN Natural Science for April of this year (vol. x., pp. 254-2G3)
we gave an account of the Horn Expedition to Central Aus-
tralia, and drew special attention to the valuable anthropological
observations of Mr F. J. Gillen. This gentleman's residence of
fourteen years among the Aruntas of Alice Springs in Central
Australia has enabled him to associate himself with them on
terms of the closest intimacy, and he is looked on as a full
member of the tribe. Since the Horn Expedition, three years
ago, Professor Baldwin Spencer of Melbourne has been in constant
correspondence with Mr Gillen, and has twice used the university
vacation to revisit the district, although the heat during the summer
months is exceedingly trying to any European. During the summer
of 1896-7 Professor Spencer undertook the long and difficult
journey to Alice Springs in order to witness the most mystic rite
of the Aruntas, and the one of rarest occurrence, namely, the fire-
ceremony, for which preparations had been made by the tribe for
eighteen months beforehand. His unique experiences were com-
municated to the Eoyal Society of Victoria on his return, early in
April, and the following interesting account is given in The Aus-
tralasian for April 17, 1897 : —

Within a mile or two of the picturesquely-placed telegraph
station, with its tiny cluster of stone houses, the strange aboriginal
ceremonies were to be celebrated, and here for four months Pro-
fessor Spencer made his headquarters. In order to be at hand
when all the rites were being performed, Mr Gillen and the pro-
fessor occupied a wurley, built on the sacred ground of the natives,
and provisions were brought out from the station. Driven to
desperation by flies, which had to be actually brushed off every
article of food while it was being put into the mouth, slowly
grilling under the tropic sun, and choked by the clouds of dust
which every gentle breeze raised, the two observers had to make
notes, take photographs, and measure evil-smelling natives for
scientific purposes, when other employment slackened. The un-
certainty as to when and where the next ceremony would take
place kept Mr Spencer and Mr Gillen at all times on the qui vive,
and on several occasions they had to tear after the blacks at mid-day

120 NATURAL SCIENCE [August

over two or three miles of scrubby, stony ground, carrying heavy
full-plate camera and notebook to get an accurate record of what
was going on. In all, 200 photographs were taken under extremely
trying conditions. It is little wonder that the many friends of Pro-
fessor Spencer were rather shocked to see him looking so parched
and sun-dried on his return to civilisation.

Initiation Rites. — The Arunta tribe, like several other Aus-
tralian tribes, is divided into sections or classes, which are four
in number. In their details the relationships of these classes are
very complicated, and are fixed by definite rules which are carefully
observed by the blacks. It may be briefly stated that a man must
marry out of his own class, while the children belong to yet a third
class, certain members of which class are then his tribal brothers
and sisters.

There are four grades of initiatory ceremonies which an Arunta
man must go through before he becomes a full member of the tribe.
Up to about ten years the boy lives in the women's camp, and
accompanies them in their search for such food as roots, seeds, grubs,
and the like. His tribal brothers then paint him on the chest and
back, and he is thrown up into the air and caught. This is sup-
posed to be beneficial to his growth. After this he now lives in
the bachelors' camp, and accompanies the bachelors on their hunting
expeditions.

Eight or ten years later he has to submit to circumcision and
subincision, as described by Dr E. C. Stirling and Mr Gillen in the
results of the Horn expedition. After that he may take a wife,
and engage in other ceremonies. In the tribes of the East of Aus-
tralia this stage is marked off by the knocking out of one of the
front teeth, a ceremony to which a good deal of importance is
attached. Amongst the Aruntas, though a front tooth is occa-
sionally knocked out, yet the habit seems devoid of any sacred
import, and appears to be a survival, the meaning of which is
forgotten.

Totem and Churinya. — When the candidate has reached thirty,
or in some cases forty years, he takes part in two sets of ceremonies
which extend over several months, and it was these ceremonies
which Messrs Spencer and Gillen had such unique opportunities of
observing. The first set deals with the various totems of the tribe.
There are very large numbers of totems in the tribe, and to one of
these each black owes allegiance, and may be called by its name.
Some may be kangaroos, others native peach trees, others dingoes or
witchetty grubs, and so on. It has long been known that the
marriage rules of the Arunta were governed, not by the totems, but
by the classes previously alluded to, and why certain persons are
attached to certain totems is one of the most peculiar and important

1897] INITIATION RITES OF THE ARUNTA TRIBE 121

results which Messrs Spencer and Gillen have obtained. Closely
interwoven with the idea of the totem is the significance of the
churinya, or sacred stones and sticks. These objects are flat, oval, or
elongate pieces of stone or wood, carved all over with incised lines
which, in the Central Australian tribes, are circles or segments of
circles, while in Western Australia they take the form of zig-zag
lines. Each man has his own churinya, which is apparently looked
on as another embodiment of himself, and yet at the same time
it possesses a mysterious sacred significance. The women and the
uninitiated are not allowed to look at it. The carvings on the
churinyas of persons of the same totem are very similar. The
churinyas are not kept by the blacks to whom they belong, but they
are carefully hidden in some definite locality by one or two of the old
men, each totem having its own particular set of such stations. The
blacks state that in the ' dream-times ' of the far distant past, when
their ancestors came into the country, those of each totem kept
strictly by themselves. At this time they are not quite clear as to
whether those whose totem was, say the wild duck, were really
human beings, or partly the animals or plants the names of which
they bear.

The lines of these migrations are related in great detail in
their traditions, and each camping ground is exactly located, so that
the whole country is interlaced with lines of route, and dotted over
with innumerable camps. When one of these ' dream-time ' an-
cestors died, he was turned into a spirit-child, and as such dwells
near one of the camping grounds, always carrying in his hand one
of the churinyas. Conception is believed to take place by the
entry of one of these spirit-children into the mother, the spirit-
child dropping his churinya on the ground at the time. On the
birth of the child the place is searched for the lost churinya, and
by the kindly offices of one of the old men the search is usually
successful. If it be not, a wooden one is made of hardwood, such
as mulga. The stone churinyas are the more ancient form, and do
not appear to be made at the present day. This then fixes the
totem for the individual, and explains why in the Arunta tribe the
child is not of the same totem as one of the parents, as is the case
in some of the neighbouring tribes of Central Australia.

The members of each totem have a ceremony connected with
their totem, which they alone are allowed to perform, and which
has for one of its objects the increase of the animal or plant from
which the totem takes its name. The eating of this animal is not
tabooed to those who bear its name, as is frequently the case in
other parts of the world ; in -fact, it is considered necessary for the
chief performer to eat a portion of his totem, or the ceremony will
fail.

122 NATURAL SCIENCE [August

General Programme. — In their general plan these ceremonies
are much alike. The chief performer is elaborately decorated with
patterns in eaglehawk down stuck to his body with blood drawn
from some member of the party. This down is coloured red and
yellow with ochre ; other parts of the body are smeared with a
black pigment mixed with grease. The amount of blood drawn on
these occasions is at times surprising, it being estimated that one
man allowed five half-pints to be taken from him during a single
day. The decoration of this performer is completed while the black
candidates, if they may be so termed, are away hunting. On their
return to the sacred ground they dance vigorously round him for
some time. In most of these performances the decorated men then
imitate the actions of the animal whose totem they bear, and in
some cases the acting is described as wonderful. In one mock
combat two performers represented two eaglehawks struggling for a
bone, and wildly flapping their wings, which were represented by a
bunch of gum leaves in each hand.

The ' parra,' or sacred ground, was laid out with great care, and
one of the most peculiar sights was to see the candidates lying in a
row with their heads close to a long bank of earth, as they were
required to do during most of the nights. Absolute silence was
entailed, and the strain during the months through which the
ceremonies lasted must have been great, and have considerably
influenced the hysterical, exalted frame of mind which they at
times showed.

Fire Rites. — After a month devoted to preliminary rites the
fire ceremonies began. The men to be initiated formed into a body,
and, holding a shield of gum leaves over themselves, went to the
women's camp. They were accompanied by a number of the old
men swinging bull-roarers. This seems to be the only occasion on
which the women, on hearing the dread sound, do not run and hide
themselves, nor are they at any other time allowed even to gaze
upon the sacred implement. The women who were prepared, ran
at the body of men, and threw burning branches on to them, which
the men tried, not very effectually, to ward off with their roof of
leaves. This ceremony was repeated daily for about a fortnight.
Next, a large fire, about twenty feet across, was made and covered
with green leaves ; on this terrible heap the candidates lay for some
time, several at once, others calmly standing by and waiting their
turn. The heat of the fire was very considerable. Professor
Spencer knelt on the heap to try it, but could not endure it, even
with thick trousers on. This performance was concluded by all
present howling and hurling fircsticks about.

During the evening, when all the candidates were lying in a
row as usual, one of the old men seated himself before them with a

1897] INITIATION RITES OF THE AUUNTA TRIBE 123

decorated piece of wood which he held upright, and slowly and
steadily knocked on the ground. At each side of him another old
man sat holding his wrist, and assisting in this wearisome work,
which, with most remarkable endurance, was kept up without a
pause from half-past nine at night till about five next morning.

The number of candidates was very large, there being more than
a hundred who were initiated. On the day following the final
ceremony took place, the men crossing over to the women's camp,
and each kneeling on a tire there.

Concluding Notes. — Each of the old men who were directing
operations had men of his own totem under his charge, and for
their proper initiation he was responsible. During the whole
period of nearly four months they were not allowed to speak to
him. At the conclusion of the rites they had to bring him some
food-offering, such as cooked wallaby, and begged him to make them
speak. He then touched their lips, and the ban of silence was
removed.

A good deal of the significance of many of the ceremonies has
probably been lost, but their main object seems to have been to test
the endurance of the young men, and to teach them the past
history of the tribe, while the possession of a knowledge of the
correct method of procedure by the old men, who practically formed
a council for the administration of the whole series of rites, would
naturally cause them to be held in high esteem.

As this ceremony is only performed at intervals of many years,
it is more than likely that, with the advance of the white man, the
present may be the last occasion on which it will be performed with
the completeness in which it was witnessed by Professor Spencer
and Mr Gillen. The results so laboriously obtained are conse-
quently of peculiar value. 0.

124 [August

SOME NEW BOOKS

The Structure of Corals

Microscopic and Systematic Study of Madreporarian Types of Corals. By
Miss Maria M. Ogilvie, D.Sc, Phil. Trans. Roy. Soc, London. Vol. 187, 1896,
pp. 83-345. Price, lis. 6d.

Miss Ogilvie's work on the microscopic and systematic study of
Madreporaria, read before the Eoyal Society in November 1895, was
a long time in appearing in print. It is a copious and an ambitious
work, one which reflects great praise on the industry and the capacity
of the authoress, yet, as must always be the case in a work of such
pretensions, it is open to a considerable amount of criticism in details.
To criticise it adequately one would have to enter into minutiae which
are of little interest except to the specialist ; to criticise it at all one
must necessarily enter into details which are unfamiliar even to
zoological readers, unless they happen to have made a special study
of corals.

It is well known that the stony corals, though they present but a
limited range of structural peculiarities, are so rich and various in
detail and display such infinite variety of form, that their classification
presents great difficulties. These difficulties have been enhanced by
the fact that even now the anatomy of the polyps is only known
for a relatively small number of forms, and that there is a vast assem-
blage of extinct corals of which we only can know the structure of the
skeletons : the nature of the polyps to which the skeletons belonged
can only be inferred from the small knowledge we have of the
anatomy of recent types. A great number of the palaeozoic forms of
corals appeared to differ so much in their characters from later and
recent corals that they were classified apart by Milne Edwards and
Haiine under the names Eugosa, Tabulata, and Tubulosa. The groups
Tabulata and Tubulosa have disappeared some time since, but the
group Eugosa has remained, in spite of the fact that several authors,
but especially Gottlieb von Koch, have shown that the intimate
structure of the coralla of many Eugosa is in all essential characters
the same as that of recent corals. The group of Eugosa has survived,
against the better judgment of many investigators, because it was
convenient to palaeontologists, and in the study of corals as in that of
many other groups, palaeontologists and zoologists have worked with
too little heed to each other's doings. Miss Ogilvie writes as a
palaeontologist, but as one whose ideas are moulded by the teachings
of zoology. A great part of her work refers to the structure of
recent forms, and her conclusions as to the nature and systematic
position of ancient corals are founded on the knowledge which she
has gained from her studies of living forms. The result is that
she has turned the old classification of Milne Edwards and Haime
upside down, and even those who have accustomed themselves

1897] SOME NEW BOOKS 125

to the modifications introduced by Martin Duncan and Quelch will
scarcely recognise the classification set forth in a very ingenious
diagram on page 331 of this work. Corals are divided into two
sections, Zaphrentoidea or Madreporaria Haplophracta and Cyatho-
phylloidea or Madreporaria Pollaplophracta. The former section is
divided into two sub-sections, the Coenenchymata, including the
families Poritidae, Madreporidae, Pocilloporidae, Oculinidae ; and the
Murocorallia, including the Zaphrentidae, Turbinolidae, Amphias-
traeidae and Stylinidae, the two last named being new families, or
nearly so. Ev/phyllia is taken as the living type of the Amphias-
traeidae, Galaxea of the Stylinidae. The section Pollaplophracta is
divided into two sub-sections ; the Septocorallia, including the families
Cyathophyllidae, Astraeidae and Fungidae, and the Spinocorallia,
including the family Eupsammidae. It will be seen that the old
groups of Aporosa and Perforata as well as the Kugosa disappear
altogether ; that corals which were known as perforate are placed
alongside of aporose corals and vice versa ; thus the Eupsammidae
are ranked near the Astraeidae, the Pocilloporidae near the Madre-
poridae.

These sweeping changes are based upon a microscopic examina-
tion of the coralla of many recent and extinct forms. Make a section
through a coral skeleton and you will recognise in the middle of each
septum, or other component, a dark line or centre. With thin sections
and high powers the dark line resolves itself into a series of dark
spots, from which the crystalline elements of the corallum radiate
outwards in diverse ways. A close comparative study of these features
has convinced Miss Ogilvie — or we should rather say now, Mrs
Gordon — that they afford a new and natural basis for classification,
one which is applicable to the study of both extinct and recent corals,
because the feature in question is usually well preserved in fossil
remains. A further convenience is the fact that the microscopical
structure of the corallum may often, if not always, be inferred from
its superficial characters, e.g. granules, striae, and serrations of septa.
To give details of the septal characters is here impossible ; the struc-
ture is intricate and demands much space for explanation. It need
only be said that anybody, having read this part of the work, may
easily verify the truth of the statements made. Points which have
hitherto escaped notice are here brought forward for the first time,
and the new observations are invested with an importance which, if
not always acceptable, is invariably interesting and suggestive.

Miss Ogilvie not only describes the microscopic character of the
corallum ; she also accounts for it by seeking to prove that the
ultimate elements of the coral skeleton are minute scales, each com-
posed of a bunch of minute crystalline fibres, and that each such scale
is in fact a calcified cell or calicoblast, which is bodily converted into
the calcareous tissue of the skeleton. In making this assertion Miss
Ogilvie treads on contentious ground. She adopts and expands a
view originally put forwTard by von Heider, but not generally accepted,
because it appeared to_be negatived both by examination of fresh adult
coralla and by the embryological researches of von Koch. The latter
author, whose statements are worthy of the utmost credit, states most
positively that in the development of Astroides calycalaris, the first

126 NATURAL SCIENCE [August

deposit of calcareous tissue takes place between the basal ectoderm
and the surface of attachment, and that it is secreted by, not formed
within the ectoderm cells. These statements are confirmed by H. V.
Wilson for Manicina areolata, and in a question of this sort it requires
very strong evidence to upset the proofs from embryology. Miss
Ogilvie's evidence is hardly strong enough ; the appearances which
she describes are not unfamiliar to students of corals and are suscep-
tible of a different interpretation, but she has at least reopened the
question, which will have to be settled on better evidence than that
which she has adduced.

Amongst the many figures which illustrate the work there are
several showing the relations of hard and soft parts in recent corals.
Some of them are correct, others are misleading, if not positively
incorrect. Take, for instance, the diagram of Turbinaria on p. 209.
The anatomy of this genus has been thoroughly described by Dr
Fowler, and we learn from him that there is a system of canals which
permeate the corallum and communicate with the polyp cavities.
These canals anastomose freely, but Miss Ogilvie's figure shows only
a few digitate or branched diverticula ; no anastomoses, no network,
and no transverse communications with the polyp cavities. The
figure of Fungia on p. 169 can only be called a diagram of theoretical
relations. As a matter of fact the soft parts of Fungia have not the
structure shown in the figure. Miss Ouilvie homolosnses the tissues
on the aboral face of Fungia with the edge-zone of other corals. This
is right enough, but it is not right to assume, as she does, that there
is no communication between the synapticula and through the theca
between the cavity of the edge-zone and the general cavity of the
body. As a matter of fact definite canals pass between the synapticula,
some are united below the level of the synapticula by a radial canal,
some are directly continuous with the cavities of the edge-zone. The
mesenteries are best developed above the synapticula, but some extend
also between and even below them, the rule being that the mesenteries
are attached to synapticula, either above or at their sides, but some
extend far down and send narrow mesogloeal bands to be attached to
the basal wall of the disc. Other features, such as the position of
the tentacles, are not correctly represented. The writer has the more
confidence in making these statements since he has recently examined
the anatomy of Fungia, in order to test the correctness of this figure.
One is inclined to suspect that Miss Ogilvie, whilst making plentiful
use of the anatomical researches of other authors, has not herself any
great familiarity with the structure of coral polyps. There is some
internal evidence that, after deciding in her own mind how the
corallum was formed, she has inferred the anatomy of the polyps from
the microscopical characters of their coralla, without studying the
actual relations in a sufficient number of instances. Such inferences
are apt to be misleading. Whether this is the case or not, Miss
Ogilvie has been led by her views on the formation of calcareous
tissue to give a lively but an unlikely accotmt of madreporarian
development and evolution, an account which is in harmony with the
figures criticised above, but which does not and cannot explain the
diagnostic character of the Madreporaria Perforata of M. Edwards and
Hainie — viz. the presence of a complex canalicular system in the wall,

1897] SOME NEW BOOKS 127

the septa and the coenenchyme. For her the form and structure of
the calcareous laminae or bars are the result of foldings, wrinklings,
and tuckings in and over of the flexible zooid. On p. 315 there is an
imaginative' description of the evolution of the madreporarian zooid,
which is represented as pulling in and tucking up its body in various
places, forming invaginations here, evaginations there, as if guided by
some predetermined impulse, and we are to believe that the form of
i he corallum is determined by these almost purposive wrinklings and
corrugations of the zooid, which fills up the cavities and folds of the
creases in its body with calcareous tissue. Eeferences, scattered
throughout the volume, to invaginations — a word, by the way,
which is used in a most puzzling variety of meanings with regard
to spatial relations — show that Miss Ogilvie is dominated by the
idea that the wrinkling and pitting of the soft tissues was the
antecedent, the formation of calcareous structures the consequent.
The skeleton, it is true, is formed by the soft tissues, but it by no
means follows that the form of the skeletal parts is the result of the
pre-existing form of the soft parts. The two elements have been
formed pari passu, changes in the one reacting upon the other, and
the final shape and mutual relations are the result of a continuous
correlated development of which wre cannot affirm, at any given
point, that the growth of the one part preceded or dominated the
growth of the other. On Miss Ogilvie's supposition it is most
difficult to account for the formation of the canal s}'stem in perforate
corals, and we cannot but suspect that this difficulty has led to her
giving a theoretical rather than an actual picture of the structure of
Turbinaria and of Fungia. Not that Fungia is a perforate coral.

In classifying the Fungidae, Miss Ogilvie has left out of con-
sideration the fact that the young Fungia is a true aporose coral,
indistinguishable from a Turbinolid, even to the absence or at least
the very slight development of synapticula. This fact points to a
close relationship between the Fungidae and the Turbinolidae, yet
they are classed far apart, the former among the Pollaplophracta
Septocorallia, the latter among the Haplophracta Murocorallia. In
fact, the more one examines the grounds of the classification adopted
in this work the less satisfactory does it appear. The group
Coenenchymata strikes one as purely artificial. The subsections
Murocorallia and Septocorallia are founded on the presence or
absence of so-called ' thecal ' pieces. This is a partial revival of
the classification proposed by von Heider and adopted by Ortmann,
it has been severely criticised by von Koch and others, and it is not
too much to say that it is founded on a misconception. There is
no essential difference between ' thecal ' and ' septal ' structures.
Both are formed in the same manner from the same regions of the
polyp. In many forms sections taken low down in the corallum
show an alternation of septal and apparently thecal pieces. Higher
up it is found that calcareous lamellae project inwards from the
supposed thecal pieces, so that the last named appear as septa. The
same coral appears to have an ' eutheca ' in one part, a ' pseudotheca '
in another part, is therefore a Murocorallian in one region, a Septo-
corallian in another. This fact has been repeatedly emphasised by
von Koch, and a clear and convincing discussion of the question is to

128 NATURAL SCIENCE [August

be found in his recent work in Gegenbaur's "-Festschrift." The
Turbinoliclae are a standing example of the unreliability of a classifica-
tion founded upon the supposed difference between an Eutheca and a
Pseudotheca. They are positively stated on p. 319 to have " a well
built thcca, whose fibrous elements are set in a direction at right
angles to those of the septa." Caryophyllia is regarded as a typical
Turbinolid, yet the writer has sections of Caryophyllia smithii which
demonstrate conclusively that there are no such thecal pieces with
fibrous elements set in a direction at right angles to those of the
wall. The wall is in fact a typical pseudotheca, formed by the
coalescence of the thickened peripheral ends of the septa. The same
must be asserted of Steplianotrochus and others. Remembering that
the wall of Caryophyllia is a pseudotheca, it is difficult to place
FlabcUwm in the same group with it, and Miss Ogilvie's remarks on
Flabcllum suggest that she has not grasped the meaning of von Koch's
argument that its ' theca ' is in fact an epitheca.

It would not be difficult to find other materials for criticism, but
enough has been said to show that Miss Ogilvie's more general
conclusions must be received with caution. So long as she deals
with the matter of her own original observations she is on safe
ground, and in describing the finer structure of the coralluin she has
added largely to our knowledge, and has opened up a suggestive field
of research. But she has marred her work by an effort to be too
comprehensive, and in her attempt to form a complete system she
has been obliged to rely on characters other than those which have
been the object of her researches, and therefore has, in our opinion,
been led into error. However extensive and excellent her work, it is
not yet sufficient to allow of the making of a wholly new and general
scheme of classification. But whilst one cannot accept the classifica-
tion as it stands, one must feel that it abounds in suggestions. The
suo'ii-ested lines of descent of living from extinct forms, offer
most interesting material for enquiry. There is an ingenious, but
not wholly new, suggestion as to the probable relation of mesenteries
in palaeozoic corals, involving an explanation of tetrameral arrange-
ment of septa. The explanation of the nature of the fossula is
ingenious and probable; unfortunately it is one of those points which
can scarcely be proved by observation.

In conclusion, the work, though it may have defects, is a most
useful one ; it must always influence other workers in the same field,
and it is probable that some of the main features of the classification
will come to be universally adopted. One thing, at least, is certain,
nobody will henceforth speak of the group of Bugosa.

G. C. Bourne.

B, Hertwig's Text-book of Zoology

Lehrbuch der Zoologie. By Dr R. Hertwig. Fourth improved edition. 8vo.
Pp. xii. 612, with 568 text-figures. Jena: G. Fischer, 1S!>7. Trice in paper
wrappers, 11 marks 50 pf. ; bound, 13 marks 50 pf.

It is just two years since we reviewed the third edition of this clear
and correct text-book, a fact that proves, at all events, the success of
the work. The present edition differs from its predecessors, not only

1897] SOME NEW BOOKS 129

in the slightly increased size, but in some extension of the parts
dealing with the Sporozoa and the Vertebrate. The Sporozoa have of
late years assumed great economic importance, especially in reference
to the breeding of fish and to certain diseases of man, as was insisted
on by Professor Eay Lankester in Natural Science for August 1896.
I)r Hertwig has therefore done well to give them greater prominence.
Among the Vertebrate, while Dr Hertwig has endeavoured to ac-
commodate Boulenger's classification of the Keptilia to the restricted
needs and limits of a text-book, he has found himself still unable to
introduce the modifications in the classification of birds that have
been held necessary by certain recent anatomists.

In our former review we alluded to the weakness of the palaeonto-
logical part of this otherwise admirable book, and we regret to find
that weakness just as conspicuous. It leads to sins, not merely of
omission, as the passing over of all the differences between an
ammonoid and a nautiloid shell, and the absence of any account of
the shell in the decapodous cephalopods, but also of commission, as
the long obsolete division of the crinoids into Palaeocrinoidea and
Xeocrinoidea. A knowledge of palaeontology, too, would have saved
Dr Hertwig from devoting space to the views of Haeckel on the
Cystidea, when that space is so valuable that this most important
class of all the echinoderms has to be dealt with in a dozen lines.
We trust that the fifth edition, which is sure to be called for, will
show some consideration to those extinct animals on the knowledge
of which our classifications must ultimately depend.

Aethropods for Beginners

Through a Pocket-Lens. By Henry Schcrren, F.Z.S. 8vo. Pp. 192.
London : The Religious Tract Society. 1897. Price, 2s. 6d.

Me Scherren is well known as a writer of attractive little books on
natural history for beginners, and his reputation in this respect is not
likely to suffer from the volume that is now under notice. Its object
is to show how much may be learnt with an ordinary pocket-lens and
simple appliances ; but it is surely somewhat of a pity that the title is
not more indicative of its contents. For the purpose could have been
carried out with equal satisfaction if minerals, or any group of the
smaller plants or animals, had been selected for study. As a matter of
fact Mr Scherren's choice fell, and fell wisely, upon the Arthropoda, a
group to which he has devoted much of his spare time, and which is
peculiarly suitable for the purpose in hand on account of the abund-
ance and obtrusiveness of its species, its attractiveness to young
naturalists and collectors, and the extent of the variation in structure
and habits that it displays.

The first chapter contains much useful advice on the question of
lenses, needles, forceps, beakers, etc., showing that all needful ap-
pliances for the investigations illustrated in the following chapters of
the book may be obtained by the expenditure of a small sum of
money. In the way of lenses, however, there is one object which
seems to have escaped Mr Scherren's notice, and to which he will
perhaps be glad to have his attention drawn. This is the ordinary
watchmaker's lens, which will be found invaluable for dissecting

130 NATURAL SCIENCE [August

purposes, since with a little practice it can be held in the eye,
leaving the two hands free for the manipulation of the needles
and forceps.

The types for study have been advisedly selected, being those, like
the cockroach, water-beetle, garden-spider, and prawn, which can be
obtained in almost every country district, or in any of our towns or
their neighbourhood, and may very easily lie kept alive in suitable
surroundings. For one of the great merits of this little book is, that
it recommends an observation of the habits of the species before they
be submitted to the process of dissection.

The errors of the book are few and, on the whole, unimportant.
It is not however usual to regard the carapace in the Crustacea as
synonymous with the cephalothorax ; and to say that the former
consists of fourteen segments in the prawn, when it really represents
the tergal elements of but two is misleading. Moreover, and since
Mr Scherren — not without the countenance of authority— applies the
word 'joint' to the internode or segment of a limb, it would be
interesting to learn by what term the point of junction of two
' joints ' is to be recognised. Lastly, Dr David Sharp will not be
flattered by the ascription to him of the authorship of the ' Myria-
poda ' in the Cambridge Natural History. In spite of these blemishes,
however, the book may be cordially recommended to beginners as an
excellent practical lesson in the elements of the morphology and
bionomics of the Arthropoda. R. I. POCOCK.

For the Young Entomologist

Faune de France : Orthopteres, Neuropteres, Hymenopteres, Lepidopteres, Hemi-
pteres, Dipteres, Aphanipteres, Thysanopteres, Rhipipteres. Par A. Acloque.
viii. and 516 pp., with 1235 figures. Paris: Bailliere, 1897. Price, 8 francs.

The Young Beetle-Collector's Handbook. By Dr E. Hofmann, with an introduc-
tion by W. Egmont Kirby, M.D. 8vo. viii. and 17S pp., 20 coloured plates.
London : Swan Sonnenschein & Co., 1897. Price, 4s. 6d.

The fauna of France in the groups mentioned above may be estimated
at about 15,000 species, and M. Acloque disposes of them in this
small volume. We have previously (Natural Science, May 1896,
p. 346) explained the plan of the work, and need only add that, in
the volume now before us, the necessity of keeping the number of
pages within assigned limits has caused the author to abandon the
attempt at dealing with species in the more extensive and difficult
families ; so that in these cases we find only tables of the genera.

In his preface the author recognises that this volume does not
accomplish all that was intended when the scheme of dealing with
the whole fauna of France in four small volumes was adopted. The
system of terminations used in the names of the systematic groups is
extremely repellent : the well-known family name Apidae becomes
Apisidi; and as sub-family names we find Andrenii and Bombii,
derived from Andrena and Bombus. Possibly the system is theo-
retically excellent, but it reminds us of Montgomery's lines about
Nebuchadnezzar, who

" murmured as he cropped the unwonted food,
It may be wholesome but it isn't good."

Dr Hofmann's work is remarkably well printed, and the twenty

1897] SOMJE NEW BOOKS 131

plates include about 000 almost tolerable figures. But the matter
contained in the pages is somewhat disappointing. It consists of
brief descriptions, and of an introduction, too short and vague to be
of much use, dealing with more general points. D. S.

The Museums Association

Museums Association : Report of Proceedings with the Papers read at the seventh

Annual General Meeting held in Glasgow, July 21 to 2i>, 1890. Svo, pp. 107.
London: Dulau & Co., 1896. Price 5s.

If anything were needed to show the growth of interest in the ques-
tions connected with the administration and development of museums
it may be found in the institution and continued prosperity of the
" Museums Association," and the issue of the compact volumes of
papers read at their annual meetings. Last year's meeting took place
at Glasgow, and for the first time since its foundation seven years ago
the association had an " Art-man " as its president in the person of
Mr James Paton, curator of the Kelvingrove Museum and Corporation
Art Galleries in that city. In his presidential address Mr Paton
gives an extremely interesting account of the institutions under his
direction, but considering that the majority of his audience must have
been men of science, I think that he might safely have omitted telling
them that the aim of the picture gallery is " higher and holier," pre-
sumably from the context, than the scientific museum. Few scientific
men are wholly blind to Art, many are in the highest degree sus-
ceptible to its influence, but all the same — comparisons are invidious !

Mr F. A. Bather's paper entitled " How may museums best retard
the advance of science," being of a satirical vein throughout, is very
entertaining reading ; and, on the whole, I think we may give ready
assent to most of the ideas which he has chosen this method of
conveying.

Other papers in the volume are: — Mr H. Coates on the Arrange-
ment of the Perthshire Natural History Museum ; Mr E. M. Holmes
on Type Specimens in Botanical Museums ; Descriptive Geological
Labels, by Mr H. Bolton ; Mr F. A. Bather on Electrotypes in
Natural History Museums ; Mr G. W. Orel on Chemistry in
Museums ; Suggestions for a Proposed Natural History Museum
in Manchester, by the late Prof. Huxley; Clara Nordlinger on
a Visit to the Directress of the Schleswig-Holstein Museum ;
Illustrated Lectures in Art Galleries and Museums, by T. Eennie ;
and the Lighting of Museums, by Thomas White.

The perusal of these papers brings under our notice two important
questions connected with museum economy. The first of these
relates to Type Specimens. It is extremely desirable that all
museums should publish catalogues of the types contained in their
collections, and by many museums this has already been clone. But
the idea of bringing together all the type specimens in the kingdom,
perhaps in the world, as some people possibly desire, is not only utterly
impracticable, but from some points of view not even desirable. A
little travel is not at all a bad thing for a zoological worker, and no
doubt when he visits other towns and other countries for the purpose
of consulting type specimens he will have the opportunity of enlarg-

132 NATURAL SCIENCE [August

ing his mind in other directions as well. At the same time it may be
readily conceded that the possession of type specimens by small
provincial museums in out-of-the-way places, is not for the advantage
of science.

But perhaps of greater importance, from a general point of view,
is the disposal of the exhibited collections for educational purposes.

The now well-known idea that the exhibited portion of a museum
should be a collection of labels, illustrated by specimens, may be
carried a great deal too far — so far as to upset the fundamental idea
of a museum without attaining the object desired. Those who wish
to study any particular branch of Natural History ought to find, in a
well-arranged typical collection, where the specimens are provided
with suitable descriptive labels, much invaluable assistance — but
such labels can never supply the place of proper text-books, studied
at home as well as in the museum or laboratory. We may take an
example in this connection from Mr H. Bolton's set of descriptive
labels for the geological collection in the Peel Park Museum, Salford,
which are published in full in this volume. These labels are in
themselves very good and praiseworthy summaries of the present
knowledge of the geological formations in Great Britain, but to the
serious student who possesses a good text-book of geology they are
wholly unnecessary, while to those who, like most of the general
public, are previously entirely ignorant of the subject, they must
be utterly unintelligible. The use of a label is, T presume, to tell
what a specimen is and what it shows, and not to enter into a
dissertation on any general subject, that being the business of the
text-book and of the teacher.

Mr Ord's plan for teaching chemistry by specimens, diagrams,
models, and descriptive labels, is to my mind carrying the educational
theory of museums to a pitch of absurdity. A collection of metals,
salts, &c, is no doubt a desirable feature in connection with the
chemical department of a school or college, but you will learn
chemistry only in the laboratory, and certainly not in a museum.

But, however some of us may disagree with some of the notions
of individual writers of papers in the present volume, the Museums
Association is bound to do good by promoting the free discussion
of the questions at issue. E. H. Traquair.

The Geological Department of the British Museum

A Guide to the Fossil Invertebrates and Plants in the Department of Geology
and Palaeontology in the British Museum (Natural History), Cromwell Road,
London, SAY. 8vo. Pp. xvi. 158, with 182 text-figures. Printed by order of the
Trustees, 1S9". Priee, Is. ; also in two parts, price 6d. each.

Tins is a remarkable shillingsworth, so much so that anything less
than effusive thanks for it smacks of ingratitude. Thanks, we are
sure, the public will oiler to the trustees, to Dr Henry Woodward,
the popular keeper of the department, and to the able set of colla-
borators whose help he acknowledges. Only had the book been
priced at five shillings or so could we have ventured on any criticism.
We might then have asked for a little more co-ordination between the
parts, a keener sense of proportion, and more careful selection of
illustrations. With thirty-six pages devoted to the eephalopods, the

1897] SOME NEW BOOKS 133

four other classes of the Mollusca might have had more than eight.
We should not, even in a geological guide, expect to find the Bracbio-
poda and Bryozoa associated with the Arthropoda and Vermes as a
' Subkingdom Annulosa.' To balance the fifteen pages on sponges,
or the seventeen figures of trilobites, we should have asked for more
than twenty-four lines on those particularly interesting forms, the
Cystidea and Blastoidea, especially as our national museum possesses
not only a fine collection of these rarities, but an officer well qualified
to deal with them. And, in the account of the sponges, one might
have suggested that a simple division into Silicispongiae and Calci-
spongiae scarcely represented modern ideas of classification. Finally,
we should have demanded very much better paper and printing ; and
even now we hardly consider that the get up of the work befits a
great public department — it is certainly inferior to that of previous
Guides.

But whether regarded as a text-book or as a guide there is no
doubt that in many respects the work is a great advance on anything
hitherto attempted at the price. We hope that the public will
recognise this, and that the speedy exhaustion of the edition may
pave the way for another with all the merits and without the few
defects of the present one.

" PALAEONTOGRAPHICA " AMONG CRIMINAL LITERATURE

Relics of Primeval Life. By Sir J. W. Dawson, K.C.M.G., F.R.S. 8vo, pp. ix.
336, with 67 figs. London : Hodder & Stoughton, 1897.

Sir William Dawson's book on " The Dawn of Life " having been
for some time out of print, he has prepared the present volume to
take its place. A good deal of the old matter and many of the illus-
trations therefore naturally reappear. The familiar story of the dis-
covery of Eozoon, and of the spread of the belief in its organic
structure, is again told, and Sir William Dawson refers to the prin-
cipal criticisms on the other side. On pp. 273-274 Eozoon is made to
tell the story of its own existence in an imaginary autobiography.
It candidly admits its low intelligence and that it did not know
whence it came ; but " at length a change came. Certain creatures
with hard snouts and jaws began to prey on me." Apparently the
most objectionable of the hard-snouted generation was Mobius, whose
work, in spite of its "large and costly figures" (p. 161), is described
as valueless, owing to " that narrow specialism and captious spirit for
which German naturalists are too deservedly celebrated." Mobius,
according to Sir William Dawson, " did his best ; " but so bad is his
best that the publication of his memoir " was a crime which science
should not readily pardon or forget on the part of the editors of the
German periodical " in which it appeared.

Sir William Dawson does not give his opponents a very cordial
invitation to continue the discussion, for he remarks in reference to
the honest way in which Eozoon did his duty, that those who " dispute
as to his origin and fate " are " much less perfectly fulfilling the ends
of their own existence." So we will try to fulfil the ends of our own
existence by discussing subjects in which an adverse verdict is not a
" crime."

134 NATURAL SCIENCE [August

Our Naturalists

Mr L. Upcott Gill, 170 Strand, has kindly sent us " The Naturalist's
Directory," 1897; price Is. This, the third edition, will undoubtedly
be useful to us, for it contains a large number of names that are not
to be found in the ordinary lists of learned societies or in the invalu-
able " Zoologisches Adress-1 >uch " of Friedlander. We presume the
majority of those included in the above-mentioned works are here
omitted of set purpose ; there would be no difficulty in comprising
them. At the same time, some hint might have been given as to the
principles on which the selection was made. It is pleasing to find
that there are so many people claiming to be naturalists in the British
Isles. As for the foreign and colonial lists, their similar vagaries are
perhaps due to the fact that they are avowedly restricted to persons
desiring to correspond or exchange specimens with collectors and
students in this country. The extension of these lists, no difficult
task, would be of much use. The book also contains a trade-directory,
a list of societies, field-clubs, and museums in the British Isles, a list
of the principal natural history works published during 1896 in the
British Isles, and a somewhat erratically selected but useful list of
natural science magazines, in which, if we may judge from our own
case, the information is not always so correct as it might be.

Botanical Bibliography

The Cambridge Botanical Supply Co. are distributing samples of
their card catalogue of current literature relating to American botany.
Items are arranged according to authors' names, but an edition of
subjects is also in preparation. The matter is prepared by a board of
editors, which includes the leading botanists of Columbia College, the
National Herbarium, and other institutions, and is published under
the direction of a committee of the American Association for the
Advancement of Science.

The cards used are of heavy linen ledger paper made to order for
this purpose. They are cut with extreme accuracy by an expensive
machine. The size is 50 by 125 mm. The number of cards issued in
1891 averaged 49 per month ; for 1895 the average was over 60, and
the total number of cards to April 1897, 2319. Subscriptions ($5, paid
in advance) may be sent to Wm. Wesley & Son, 28 Essex Street,
Strand, London.

We commend this useful enterprise to the notice of the British
Association for the Advancement of Science.

Westmorelandshire's Field Geology forms the subject of a paper
by Mr H. G. Foster- Bar! lam, which was read before the Burneside
Mutual Improvement Society on February 11, 1897. The paper,
which is illustrated by sketch-maps and sections, is published by
B. Atkinson, Stramongate, Kendal, at Is., post free, and gives a general
account of the interesting district.

Scraps from Serials

The ever interesting Scottish Geographical Magazine gives two
lively articles in its July number. Sir Henry Tyler writes on the

1897] SOME NEW BOOKS 135

Geography of Communications, showing the enormous progress that
has been made during the Victorian era, and Major A. C. Yates
describes Loralai, a frontier cantonment in Baluchistan.

An article that should interest ethnologists is J. F. Hewitt's "The
History of the Week as a Guide to Prehistoric Chronology," in the
Westminster Ecriciv for July.

The American Journal of Science for July contains a description
of Ctenacanthus spines from the Carboniferous Keokuk Limestone of
Iowa, by Dr C. E. Eastman ; a morphological account of two species
of Cyperaceae, Fuirena squarrosa and F. scirpoidea, by T. Holm ; con-
tact metamorphism between slate and diabase in the El Pasco range,
California, described by H. W. Fairbanks, who also writes on tin-
deposits at Tenescal ; notes on outliers of the Comanche series (Lower
Cretaceous) in Oklahoma and Kansas, by T. W. Vaughan.

The July Photogram contains yet another article on the Photo-
graphy of Birds' Nests, by Dr E. W. Shufeldt. An article on Tech-
nical Photography describes the studios of J. Bulbeck & Co. "We
should like to see something on the application of photography to the
illustration of scientific papers. It is a failure in nine cases out of
ten, no doubt, but whether it is worse than the ordinary draughtsman
is a delicate point.

The Irish Naturalist for July is chiefly devoted to "Some Observa-
tions by English Naturalists (E. Standen, L. E. Adams, G. W.
Chaster, and J. E. Hardy) on the fauna of Eathlin Island and
Ballycastle District."

The Naturalist for July contains Mr John Cordeaux's Presidential
Address to the Yorkshire Naturalists' Union. It deals with glaciers,
plant-distribution, the antiquities of Holderness, and ' Yorkshire
ornithology. Following this, G. 0. Benoni encourages others by his
example to take notes on natural history matters. One thing to be
noticed is " the young oak thrusting up from [the field mouse's]
abandoned home and store after a mild winter, as he stalks his rabbits
down the woodside." It is indeed.

New Serials

Messrs Gixn & Co., Boston, U.S.A., announce The Zoological
Bulletin, a companion serial to the Journal of Morphology, de-
signed for shorter contributions in animal morphology and general
biology, with no illustrations beyond text-figures. It is pro-
posed to publish six numbers a year of about fifty pages each
in the same form and style as the Journal of Morphology. The
Bulletin will contain nothing but scientific communications. The
editors are C. O. Whitman and W. M. Wheeler, assisted by a number
of collaborators. The subscription price per volume of six numbers
is $3.00, and single numbers are sold separately at 75 cents, each.

We have already announced the new quarterly East Asia, edited
by Dr H. Faulds of Stoke-on-Trent, and published by Hughes & Harber
of Longton, Staffordshire, at one shilling a part. The first number,
published at the beginning of July, proves both entertaining and in-
structive. The chief articles are " Judicial Reform in China," by Dr
Sun Yat Sen; "The Numeral System for the Blind in China," by Miss

136 NATURAL SCIENCE [August

C. F. Gordon-dimming ; " At a Japanese Barber's," by F. A. Bather ;
and an interesting account of " The Community in Cocos-Keeling and
Christmas Islands," abstracted from a Blue-book. There is a list of
recent books and magazine articles dealing with the far East. The
Eeviews and Notes would be better for more exactness of reference,
and prices of books should be given. Anthropologists will find in
this excellently printed journal many an item to interest them.

Further Literature Received

Synoptical Flora of North America, vol. i., pt. i., fasc. ii., A. Gray, ed. B. J.
Robinson: American Book Co., New York. The Life-histories of the British Marine
Food-fishes, W. C. Mcintosh and A. T. Masterman : C. J. Clay. Traite de Zoologie,
fasc. xi., xvi., ed. R. Blanchard : Rueff, Paris. Catalogus Mammalium tam viventium
quam fossilium, ed. nov., fasc. ii., E. L. Trouessart : Friedliinder. Thirty-first Ann.
Rep. Museums and Lecture Rooms Syndicate, Cambridge. Ann. Rep. Raffles Library
and Museum, Singapore, 1896. Third Rep. Whitechapel Public Library and Museum.
Society for the Protection of Birds — Educational Series, No. 12.

The Reading of Words, W. B. Pillsbury : Aoner. Journ. Psychol. Humanitarian
League Correspondence. An Extraordinary Case of Colour Blindness, F. H. P. Coste
(extract ?).

Jersey Times, July 9 ; Amer. Geol. , July ; Amer. Journ. Sci. , July ; Amer. Nat. ,
July ; Annot. Zool. Japan, May ; Feuille des jeunes Nat., July ; Illinois Wes. Mag.,
June; Irish Nat., July; Journ. School Geogr., June; Knowledge, July; Literary
Digest, June 12, 19, 26, July 3 ; Nat. Novit., June ; La Naturaleza (Madrid), Nos. 18, 19 ;
La Naturaleza (Mexico), No. 17 ; Naturalist, July ; Nature, June 24, July 1, 8, 15 ;
Nature Notes, July ; Photogram, July; Rev. Scient. , June 26, July 3, 10 ; Science,
June 11, 18, 25, July 2 ; Science Gossip, July ; Sci. Amer., June 12, 19, 26, July 3 ;
Scot. Geogr. Mag., July ; Westminster Rev., July ; Proc. Biol. Soc, Washington,
vol. xi., pp. 145-174 ; Bull, de l'lnst. Internat. Bibliogr., ii., fasc. 3 ; Trans, and Ann.
Rep. Manchester Micros. Soc, 1896 ; Bull. Alabama Agric. Exper. Station, No. 80 ;
La Bibliographie Scient., Bull. Trimestr., vol. ii., No 4 ; L'Annee Biol., 1895.

18971 137

NEWS

The following appointments are announced : —

Dr J. Biittikofer, of the State Museum in Leiden, to be director of the
Zoological Garden at Rotterdam ; Dr Johannes Martin to be director of the
Natural History Museum in Oldenburg ; Dr W. B. Pillsbury to be instructor in
psychology and director of the Psychological Laboratory in the University of
Michigan ; Dr Antoneo Crocichia to be professor of biology at the Catholic
University, Washington ; Prof. W. T. Engelmann to succeed the late Prof. Du
Bois Reymond as professor of physiology at the University of Berlin ; Adolf
Beck, from professor-extraordinarius to professor of physiology at Lemberg ;
Mr Muir, of Halifax University, to be professor of psychology in Mount Holyoke
College ; Dr C. E. Seashore to be assistant-professor of psychology at the University
of Iowa ; E. M. Weyer and M. Matsumoto to be assistants in the Yale Psycho-
logical Laboratory ; Jas. H. MacGregor to be assistant in zoology at Columbia
University ; Dr Ludwig Heim to be professor-extraordinarius of bacteriology at
the University of Erlangen ; Dr G. Boccardi to be associate-professor of micro-
scopical anatomy at Naples ; Dr J. J. Zumstein to be professor of anatomy at
the University of Marburg ; Dr Mayr to be prosector at the Veterinary College,
Munich ; Dr H. Baum to be professor of osteology at the Dresden Technical
High School ; Miss Mary E. Pennington to be Thomas A. Scott felloAv in
hygiene at the University of Pennsylvania ; Dr Brault to be professor of
tropical diseases at Algiers ; S.I. Franz to be assistant in psychology at
Columbia University ; Dr T. Fuchs to be associate-professor of palaeontology at
Munich ; Miss Bertha Stoneman to be professor of botany in the Huguenot
College for "Women in Cape Colony ; Prof. Georg Volkens to be assistant in the
Botanical Museum of the Berlin University ; J. R. Campbell to be lecturer in
agriculture at the Harris Institute, Preston ; Dr A. O. Kihlman to be assistant -
professor of botany at Helsingfors ; Herbert M. Richards to be tutor in botany
at Columbia University ; Dr J. Szadowski to be associate-professor of geology at
Klausenburg ; W. S. Boulton, of Mason College, Birmingham, to be lecturer in
geology at University College, Cardiff ; Dr Pliilijapi to be assistant in the
Geologico-Palaeontological Department of the Natural History Museum in
Berlin ; Frederick L. Ransome to be assistant geologist on the U.S. Geological
Survey ; T. I. Pocock, of Corpus Christi College, Oxford, to be assistant geologist
on the Geological Survey of the United Kingdom ; R. E. Dodge to be professor of
geography at the Teachers' College, New York ; Dr W. F. Hume and L. Gorringe
to be assistants on the Geological Survey of Egypt ; E. W. MacBride to be
professor of zoology in McGill University, Montreal.

A biological station will shortly be opened near Sebastopol.

A summer school of biology on the Mississippi, not far from Monmouth, 111.,
has been organised by Drs Maxwell and Swann.

The Derby and Mayer Museums at Liverpool have acquired the fine collection
of flint implements brought from Egypt by Mr Seton-Karr.

L'Association Francaise pour l'Avancement des Sciences meets at St Etienne,
August 5-12, under the presidency of Prof. E. J. Marey.

According to Science the University of Montana, at Missoula, has decided to
erect a main building at a cost of $47,500, and a science hall at a cost of $12,500.

138 NATURAL SCIENCE [August

It is proposed to erect a monument at Moscow to the zoologist and anthro-
pologist, Anatole Bogdanow, who died in April 1896.

A giant salamander of Japan, that had lived in the Jardin des Plantes for
thirty-seven years, died on June 15, having a length of 1\30 metre and a weight
of 24 kilograms. Two survivors mourn its loss.

Science states that a zoological club of nineteen members has been organised
at Springfield, Mass., the president being W. W. Colburn, and the secretary Miss
M. A. Young.

With reference to the note in our last number on the biological station
at Plon, we now learn that the Prussian Government will assist it after October
1898.

An expedition, under the leadership of Mr C. M. Harris of Augusta, Me., and
at the cost of the Hon. Walter Rothschild, is studying the fauna and flora of the
Galapagos Islands.

An expedition to Okhotsk and Kamtschatka, under the leadership of K.
Bogdanowitsch, has found gold at thirteen different places in the river-systems
of the Jana, Kyran, Nemuj, Mute, and Lantar.

A botanical society, named after Baron F. von Muller, has been founded
at Perth, W. Australia. Its president is Sir John Forrest, the indefatigable
Premier, and its secretary, Mr Skews.

Sir Martin Conway and Mr E. J. Garwood have returned to Spitzbergen to
continue the exploration of the interior of the main island. Afterwards they
will go to Horn Sound and finish the exploration of the southern peninsula.

Science states that it is proposed to enlarge the Missouri Botanical Garden,
by the gradual addition of 80 acres, of which 21 will be drained and graded
during the present season.

Dr J. E. Humphrey, botanist, and Prof. W. K. Brooks, zoologist, are con-
ducting a course of marine biology in Jamaica for students of Johns Hopkins
University. The laboratory has formerly been at Port Henderson, on the south
side of the island, but this year it is at Port Antonio, on the north.

The U.S. Senate has agreed to admit free of dutjr printed books over twenty
years old, books in foreign languages and those devoted to scientific research,
and books and scientific instruments imported for public and educational
institutions.

Dr J. Walter Fewkes, of the Bureau of American Ethnology, is making a
third expedition to the Pueblo Region, where, says Science, he will survey and
excavate the ruins of Kintiel, near Navajo Springs, Arizona. He is accompanied
by Dr W. Hough of the U.S. National Museum.

Messrs E. M'Illhenny, W. E. Snyder, and N. G. Baxton have gone to Point
Barrow to collect the fauna and flora of N.E. Alaska. Science hears that the
collections will go to the National Museum, U.S., and the University (if
Pennsylvania.

A biological station, under the direction of Prof. C. W. Dodge, is to be
established by the University of Rochester, N.Y., on Hemlock Lake. We have
not yet heard that any fresh-water biological station is to be established in
England.

The Scottish Geographical Magazine states that on May 8 an expedition under
Lieut. Drizhenko left St Petersburg for Lake Baikal, which will be sounded and
surveyed, while natural history collections will be made. The work will be
continuedfor five years.

1897] NEWS 139

The tenth congress of Russian naturalists and physicians, which was to have
been held this August in Kiev, has, in consequence of the International Con-
gresses of Geology and Medicine both meeting in Russia, been postponed till
August 1898.

The University of Pennsylvania is to have a new Museum of Archaeology and
Palaeontology. The architecture, says the American Naturalist, will be in
Italian renaissance style. A botanical garden, covering ten acres, will surround
the museum.

The International Postal Congress has decided that henceforth objects of
natural history, animals, dried plants, or preserved zoological specimens may be
sent as samples of merchandise, at |d. for every two ounces, the maximum weight
being 350 grammes.

Another expedition to Alaska is that of Dr W. H. Evans of Washington,
who has gone to examine the agricultural resources of the district south of the
Aleutian peninsula. Dr Sheldon Jackson goes on a similar errand to the Yukon
basin.

The Societe helvetique des Sciences Naturelles holds its eightieth animal
meeting at Engelberg, near Mt. Titlis, Sept. 12 to 15. The president of the
annual committee is Dr E. Etlin, Sarnen, Obwalden, to whom those who wish to
attend should apply.

Mr R. H. Kitson, of Trinity College, has been awarded the Harkness Scholar-
ship in Geology and Palaeontology at Cambridge University. Mr V. H. Black-
man of St John's College and the British Museum, has been awarded the
Hutchinson Studentship, for his researches on Algae.

The Zoological Society of London has awarded its silver medal to Mr
Alexander Whyte, recently naturalist to the Administration of British Central
Africa, who has sent home large collections illustrating the fauna and flora of
Xyassaland.

With reference to our note on the extinction of the bison (which some call
buffalo), it is interesting to learn from Nature that a variety known as the ' wood-
bison ' is still to be met with near Fort Chipewyan, south of the Great Slave
Lake, where it was seen in 1894 by Mr Caspar Whitney. There is no specimen
in the British Museum. Nature says there ought to be, and so do we.

At Danesdale, near Driffield, Yorkshire, are some 200 mounds, locally known
as Danes' Graves. These have recently been excavated by Canon Greenwell,
Mr J. R. Mortimer, and Mr T. Boynton, who have found remains of a chariot and
various articles of iron and bronze, tending to show that the graves are of pre-
Roman age, though more exact determination is at present not attempted.

General Russell Sturgis has offered New York University a site on his
estate at Hamilton, Bermuda, for the establishment of a marine biological station.
Prof. C. L. Bristol, Prof. W. H. Everett, Dr Tarleton H. Bean, Dr W. M.
Rankin of Princeton, and three students of the University have gone to prospect
and to collect.

The seventh session of the Australasian Association for the Advancement of
Science is to be held at Sydney in the second week of January next, under
the presidency of Prof. Liversidge. Capt. F. W. Hutton is to be president of
the Geological section, Prof. T. J. Parker of the Biological, and Mr A. W. Howitt
of the Ethnological. „

A living specimen of Pleurotomaria beyrichi was obtained last March by Mr
Alan Owston of Yokohama, and was examined by Prof. Mitsukuri. It appears
that two lobes, one on either side of the foot, envelop the shell to some extent, and

140 NATURAL SCIENCE [August

this may account for the fact that the shells of this genus are always very clean.
The relations of the mantle to the slit on the outer lip could not be observed.

After descending Aconcagua, Zurbriggen and Mr Stuart Vines ascended tlie
neighbouring Tupungato, which proved to be a volcano, 21,000 feet high. An
active volcano was seen to the west.

Another large volcano, Orizaba, has recently been ascended by Mr K. T.
Stoepel. Its extreme height is 18,333 feet, the length of the crater 1540, its
breadth 1300, its depth 330.

With the idea that a fresh outlet may be provided for the grain-bearing
provinces of Canada, an exploration of Hudson Bay is now in progress, under
the command of Capt. Wakeham. Dr R. Bell and Mr Low, of the Canadian
Geological Survey, will make geological and topographical surveys of the coasts
and islands, while Capt. Wakeham on the Diana will investigate the naviga-
bility and fishing resources of the waters.

On August 10, Lord Kenyon, President of the Shropshire Horticultural
Society, will unveil the statue of Darwin that has been erected by the Society
at the entrance to the Public Library and Museum, the former school-buildings,
of Shrewsbury. The statue, which is in bronze on a granite pedestal, is the work
of Mr Horace Montford of Shrewsbury, and is not wholly unlike the fine statue
in the Natural History Museum, London, though somewhat more alert in
expression.

An influential meeting was held in the rooms of the Royal Geographical
Society on July 5 to induce the Australasian Premiers to bring the subject of
Antarctic exploration before their respective Governments. It was stated that
the Society was prepared to contribute £5000 towards the amount subscribed
by the Colonies. Elocpient and convincing speeches were delivered ; but the
Premiers were unable to be present.

Under the directorship of Dr T. Kochibe, the Geological Survey of Japan has
been making good progress, and the staff has been increased. There has for some
time been accumulating a collection chiefly illustrative of practical geology, and
it is now proposed to build a proper geological museum in Tokyo. A short time
ago some valuable phosphatic beds of Tertiary age were discovered along the
north-east shore of the province of Kyushu, and Dr Tsuneto, of the Agronomic
division of the Survey, has been experimenting with the material so as to make it
available for the small Japanese peasant-farmers to use as manure. The organic
remains in the deposit are those of marine invertebrates.

The Commissioners of the Whitechapel Public Library and Museum, in their
third report, are glad to note the life infused into the museum by the Curator,
Miss K. M. Hall. The average daily attendance is 275. A series of science lec-
tures has been given free by eminent workers, and has been fully attended. Two
exhibitions of spring flowers, and two of children's natural history collections,
have been held. Twenty visits of classes from Elementary Schools have been
made under Article 20 of the Education Code. The only thing in this report
that is not satisfactory is the absence of Natural Science from the list of periodicals
in the news-room.

Last October the Museum, Art Gallery, Public Library, and Technical Insti-
tute of Worcester, combined under the title of the Victoria Institute, were moved
into a new building. It was soon found, oddly enough, that the space for the
museum was less than in the old building, and it was necessary to appropriate the
basement for the exhibition of the geological and ethnological specimens in spite of
l lie little light available. This is a pity, for the local geological collection is a
good one in itself, and further contains specimens of some historic interest from

1897] NEWS 141

the collections of Hugh Strickland, \V. S. Symonds, and Wynnington Ingram.
Among other collections in the Museum are one of local birds, and a good one of
foreign marine shells the gift of the late Sir Geo. Whitmore. The heavy task of
transferring and re-arranging all the material falls on the shoulders of the curator,
Mr W. H. Edwards.

The Zoological Museum of the Royal Academy of Science, St Petersburg, has
acquired thirty-three specimens of fossil bones and numerous remains of Post-
Tertiary mammals collected by J. Savenkov at Krasnoyarsk. Among them are
some bones and a piece of skin of Rhinoceros tichorhinus, which were taken from a
well-preserved specimen of a rhinoceros, covered with skin, found 60 versts east
of Kasatschje, on the bank of the Charaula, a left tributary of the Tomskaja.

In the Annuaire Ge'ologique et Mineralogique de la Russie, vol. ii. livr. 3-4,
from which this news is taken, Marie Pavlov describes, with photographs, the
occurrence of a mammoth (Elephas primigenius trogontherii) near the town of
Yaroslavl, found during the making of a railroad, at a depth of 6 metres. The
remains have been sent to the Geological Museum of Moscow University.

That there is still something new to be found in England is constantly
being shown by the active members of the Hull Scientific and Field Natur-
alists' Club. The last item is the Moonwort (Botrychmm lunaria), which Mr
Waterfall has seen growing wild at York. Mr Fierke, in a lecture on crabs,
gave a list of those found on the Yorkshire coast, and urged members to devote
a little more of their attention to the rocks and pools of the sea-shore, where,
we agree with him, they will find a rich field for useful work. The programme
of excursions and meetings for July-September should induce a large number to
join this vigorous body, which also holds out the inducement of a new and
better room over a cycle shop.

Among those who received Jubilee honours were : Dr Edward Frankland,
Dr Huggins, Mr J. Norman Lockyer, Dr Thome Thome, Mr Wolfe Barry,
President of the Institute of Civil Engineers, and Admiral Wharton, Hydro-
grapher to the Admiralty, to be K.C.B.; Mr W. H. M. Christie, Astronomer
Royal, to be C.B.; Sir William MacCormac, President of the Royal College of
Surgeons, Dr S. Wilkes, President of the Royal College of Physicians, and Mr
Thos. Smith, Surgeon-in-ordinary to Her Majesty, to be Baronets ; Sir Joseph
Hooker and Lieut. -General Strachey to be G.C.S.I. ; Mr William Crookes,
President-designate of the British Association, and Dr Gowers, to be knights ;
Sir Herbert E. Maxwell to be Privy Councillor.

We have received the report of the Raffles Library and Museum, Singapore,
for 1896, by Dr R. Hanitsch. A number of new cases have been introduced, and
the museum has undergone entire rearrangement. There is now exhibited the
beginning of a collection of the local marine fauna. A shifting of specimens has
also taken place, allowing more room to the birds and reptiles, and concentrating
the ethnological collections. Owing to the absence of a workshop, the exhibition
rooms had to be closed while the changes were in progress. Among the acquisi-
tions of the museum is a specimen of Madreporaria reticulata {!), 4 ft. 5 in.
by 2 ft. 8 in., picked up on October 20, 1896, by the Cable ship Sherard
Osborne in the Bali Straits, at fifteen fathoms, where it had grown round a
cable laid in 1888, thus giving another proof of the rapid growth of corals.
Lieut. Harvey, R.E., lent a boat and crew for dredging excursions on several
occasions, and other dredging trips were arranged by Mr G. Holt and the Com-
mittee. A zoological station has often been proposed, and is greatly needed ; a
simple movable shed, with plain furniture, jars, and preserving iluids, is all that
is absolutely required.

142 NATURAL SCIENCE [August

Many interesting matters are dealt with in the report of the Albany
Museum, Cape of Good Hope, for 1896, to which we have already alluded in
part. The alarming spread of insect pests in the Eastern province was thought
to be largely due to the wholesale destruction of insectivorous birds. The pro-
tection of certain birds under an Act already existing was therefore recom-
mended by the committee, who also suggested that saloon rifles, air-guns and
catapults should be placed under the same restrictions as firearms. These pro-
posals have been agreed to by the municipalities of Grahamstown, Port Eliza-
beth, Port Alfred, Uitenhage, East London, Somerset, East Cathcart, and the
divisional Councils of Albany and Bathurst. - The birds for which protection is
desired are : Vultures, secretary bird, several hawks, especially the jackalsvogel
(Buteo jakal) and the black-shouldered kite (Elanus coerulexis), owls, goat-
suckers, swallows, kingfishers, hombills, cuckoos, honeyguides, woodpeckers,
barbets, thrushes (excluding fruit thrushes), warblers, sunbirds or honeysuckers,
flycatchers, butcherbirds, crows (but not the rook), spreeuws (excluding redwing
spreeuw Amydrus morio), larks, wagtails, plovers, and sandpipers. This list
purposely omits rarities and game-birds.

Dr Schonland has started a small botanic garden for S. African plants,
and intends to transfer these to the ground round the museum.

We are glad to see that the geological and mineralogical collections of the
museum are being used for teaching purposes, since Dr Schonland lectures to
those students of St Andrew's College, Grahamstown, who are studying for the
first mining examination of the University of the Cape of Good Hope. This,
it is hoped, will lead to more thorough geological examination of the surrounding
country.

Dr Schonland has examined some peculiar rock-drawings in Bechuanaland,
supposed to be the work of bushmen. They can, he says, only be looked upon
as some kind of writing resembling to a certain extent early Semitic writing.
An account of these, with photographs, was published in the South African
Telegraph.

On June 3rd a second expedition to make deep borings into the coral atoll of
Funafuti set sail from Sydney. Towards the expense of this, Miss Eadith
AValker, of Yaralla, has contributed £500 ; the Government of New South
Wales has lent a diamond drill ; the Hon. Ralph Abercromby has furnished an
oil-engine at a cost of £100 ; the Hon. H. C. Dangar and Prof. T. P. Anderson
Stuart have provided a fine boat ; the Royal Society, London, contributes £100
directly, and probably another £100 through its coral-boring committee ; finally
the London Missionary Society has offered to bring the party back to Sydney in
September. The expedition is under the auspices of the Royal Geographical
Society of Australasia, and its leader is Prof. T. W. E. David, of Sydney. He
and Mr G. Sweet of Melbourne are going at their own expense, and will take
charge of the borings. Mrs David accompanies them as store-keeper and
botanical collector. Mr W. Poole, an engineer of Sydney University, will
manage the light boring apparatus, and will be aided by Mr Woolnough, who
also takes charge of the zoological collecting. These gentlemen give their
services free. The large diamond drill is in charge of Mr Hall, a foreman of
considerable experience, who has under him two sub-foremen and three drill-
workmen. In view of the difficulties already met with at Funafuti, a special
boring plant has been provided under the direction of Chief-Inspector W. II. J.
Slec, and weighs over 25 tons. The main bore, on the central island of Funafuti,
will In: begun with a standpipe having an inside diameter of G inches, and the
lining pipe at first is to be 5 inches inside diameter. If, at two or three hundred
feet, the friction should become too great, 4-inch pipes will be lowered inside
these. It is thought that the foundations of the atoll will be reached between

1897] NEWS 143

200 and r>oo feet, but the apparatus taken permits of a depth of 1000
feet being reached. The core obtained will be forwarded first to the Royal
Society of London, which will return one-half to the Royal Geographical
Society of Australasia. The expedition will also make smaller borings on the
sand cay in the middle of the lagoon, will conduct dredging operations for
Sydney University and the Australian Museum, and will collect samples of sea-
water for Prof. Liversidge to examine for gold.

Our information is gathered from an article in the Sydney Morning Herald of
June 3, kindly sent us by Mr C. Hedley.

From the thirty-first Annual Report of the Museums and Lecture Rooms
Syndicate, Cambridge University, we glean the following information. The
course in Botany is still largely attended, too largely for the accommodation ;
plans for enlargement of the buildings are under the consideration of the Sites
Syndicate. The Herbarium has received a fine collection of Pyrenean and Alpine
plants made by the late Chas. Packe of Christ Church, Oxford, and presented by
his widow. Large collections of Canadian and Indian species have also been re-
ceived. In the Zoological museum a fine adult male skeleton of Balaenoptera
musculus, a specimen known as the ' Pevensey whale,' has been articulated by Mr
E.Lane, and supported on iron- work designed by Mr W. E. Dalby. The collection
of Polyzoa has been stored in the cabinet made after the pattern described by Canon
Norman in the Report of the Museums Association for 1895. " I am confident,"
says Mr Harmer, " that anyone who tries this system will be grateful to Dr
Norman for its excellence." Some such method of storing was much needed
owing to the large increase in the collection of Polyzoa, mainly owing to the
generosity of Miss E. C. Jelly. The series is very rich in Australian species, and
excellently illustrates the papers of the late P. H. MacGillivray. Another
notable addition is a series of slides of the appendages of cirripedes, made by
Darwin when working on his well-known monograph. Unfortunately many of
the preparations have greatly deteriorated. Prof. Mitsukuri, a former student,
has presented some beautiful specimens of deep-sea hexactinellid sponges. The
additions to the collection of Reptilia are noteworthy, including the large cast of
Iguanodon presented by the King of the Belgians, a fine male of the rare Testudo
elephantina, presented by the late Lord Lilford, a skeleton of Gavialis gangeticus
from the Jumna, the gift of Mr E. H. Hankin, and many valuable skeletons sent
from Borneo by Mr C. Hose. The trustees of the late Duke of Hamilton have
presented the skeleton and skin of a bull from the Cadzow herd in Hamilton
Park, believed to descend from the ancient wild cattle of Great Britain. These
gifts, which at present stray into the lecture-rooms, render the enlargement of
the museum a matter of pressing necessity. Dr Sharp states that Mr G. D.
Haviland's collection of Termitidae, already alluded to by us, is the most valuable
ever formed, for it almost doubles the number of known species. The professor
of Human Anatomy remarks on the increase in the anthropology classes, due to
the enthusiasm of Dr A. C. Haddon. Geology also continues to increase in
popularity, and the want of space under which it has so long been suffering is
naturally not less felt. The chief donation is that of several of Mr Whidborne's
type and figured specimens, illustrating his monograph on the Devonian fauna of
S. England. The list of books presented by Rev. T. Wiltshire is printed, and
includes many rarities.

In our comment on willows last month (p. 14), we regret to have overlooked the fact
that the growth of stamens inside the ovary in Salix had already been noted by the Rev.
George Henslow. In his " Origin of Floral Structures " (p. 296, Fig. 78) lie figures two
autheriferous carpels of Salic, and one example of the same arrangement in Ranunculus
mi ricomv.s.

144 [August

CORRESPONDENCE

ANATOMY OF BIRDS

It is hard to be accused of heresy by one whose orthodox faith has been disturbed by
his own misreading of a very good text. Mr Pycraft [Natural Science, vol. x. p. 415)
complains of my having described "certain membrane bones, to wit, the maxilla,
premaxilla, quadrato-jugal, and jugals, as modifications of the first visceral arch,"
and that this statement does not tally with the analytical diagram. (Article Skull,
Newton's Dictionary of Birds. ) Of course it does not, because that diagram is correct,
and because I did not include the premaxilla ,and the maxilla as modifications of the
first visceral arch. In my copy of the Dictionary (p. 872, line 5), the words "the
right and left maxillae " are separated from what follows by a semicolon, and this alters
the meaning of the sentence as much as the proverbial fly's dot in Hebrew texts. In
the diagram the premaxilla and the maxilla are treated as visceral arches, just as
they should be, but I am so orthodox, or courteous, as to leave to the palato- quadrate -
mandibular arch its time-honoured name of first visceral.

Mr Pycraft would have done better not to mention Mehnert, as all " those who have
given the matter their attention " ought to know, that Mehnert's conception of the
pectineal process is erroneous, and this process is one of the chief clues to the homologies
of the pelvic components.

Lastly, are not the Saxon terms "greater, middle, and lesser" as good as major,
medium, and minor ? And if the minor wingcoverts come too near the edge of the wing
they become marginals, which as such, by the way, have been mentioned in the article
"Tectrices."

However, I have no reason to complain of my reviewer. He has let me off kindly,
and has drawn a veil over certain real faults which I should find it difficult to explain
away. ■ H. Gadow.

Cambridge, June 2\st, 1897.

THE OSTRACODERMS OF PROFESSOR COPE

In reference to Professor Ray Lankester's interesting note (supra, pp. 45-47) on the
affinities of the early Palaeozoic organisms termed Ostracodermi by Cope, I regret that
no new facts of fundamental importance for the discussion of the problem have been
obtained since my brief summary published in Natural Science for October 1892. A re-
statement of the basis of Cope's view would thus be merely a repetition of the facts and
comparisons contained in the literature of the subject up to that date. I should like,
however, to remark that neither Professor Cope nor I have ever placed the Ostracoderms
in the Marsipobranchii. In the obituary notice of Cope, I expressly referred to them as
' allies ' of those animals ; and they have always been mentioned as at least a distinct
sub-class. The chief difference between the views of Profs. Cope and Lankester
seems to be, that the latter considers the unpaired character of the nasal aperture in the
Marsipobranchii of fundamental importance, while the former regards it as a secondary
specialisation of no notable significance from a phylogenetic standpoint. Prof. Cope
believed that at the base of the craniate vertebrata, immediately below the true fishes,
there could be recognised a class of organisms destitute both of the lower jaw and of paired
limbs. He termed those the Agnatha, and eventually placed among them the two distinct
sub-classes of Ostracodermi and Marsipobranchii. It still seems to me that this was a
great step in advance towards the true phylogenetic arrangement of the lower vertebrata,
and it was this that I ventured to ' acclaim ' in the sentence which led to Prof.
Lankester's protest. It is well that we who are accustomed to spend so much time in
deciphering the tattered relics of extinct organisms in the rocks should occasionally be
checked thus in our tendency to speculation ; but, notwithstanding the imperfection of
our materials, it becomes continually clearer as we proceed that Palaeontology alone
furnishes the criterion for estimating the relative taxonoinic value of the different
morphological characters of any group of organisms that happen to possess hard parts
capable of fossilisation. A. Smith WOODWARD.

NOTICE

To Contributors.— All Communications to be addressed to the Editor of Natural
SCIENCE, at 67 St James' Street, London, S.AV. Correspondence and Notes intended
for any particular month should be sent in not later than the 10th of the preceding
month.

NATURAL SCIENCE

A Monthly Review of Scientific Progress

No. G7— Vol. XI— SEPTEMBEE 1897

NOTES AND COMMENTS

Polar Exploration

The balloon voyage of Andree in the Arctic Regions seems to have
monopolised public interest this month, and the absence of news
from him has caused some very unnecessary anxiety as to his safety.
Even if the winds be favourable and the balloon do not leak, he is
not due on the coast of either America or Asia until well into
August ; and it is then quite possible that he may have to spend
the winter in some northern post, from which news may not reach
Europe until the spring. Several other important expeditions are
in the field. Lieutenant Peary is leading another party to Green-
land, where he hopes to make arrangements for his proposed Polar
expedition and to secure the great block of meteoric iron which
could not be removed last summer. He will be accompanied by
Mr Charles Schuchert and Mr White, who hope to make large col-
lections of the famous fossil plants of Disco Island. Sir Martin
Conway and Mr Garwood are continuing the exploration of Spitz-
bergen by crossing the northern ice-sheet on ski. The Windward
has again sailed for Franz Josef Land, and ought to be back in
September with news of Mr Jackson's latest achievements. Mean-
while but little has been done in Antarctic research. The Belgian
expedition under Dr Gerlache and M. Arctowski have at length
obtained the necessary funds, and left Europe in the middle of
August. The proposed German expedition is still appealing for sup-
port, but does not appear to be very warmly taken up. We hope,
however, that the Royal Geographical Society will see its way to a
vigorous agitation during the winter in favour of its proposed
British Antarctic Expedition.

Arctic Geology

REGRET at an ignorance concerning Antarctic geology is increased
by two papers in Nature, in which Dr J. W. Gregory reminds us

146 NATURAL SCIENCE [September

of the interesting problems connected with the history of the Arctic
regions. In the first paper, a summary is given of the geological
structure of the land masses surrounding the Arctic Ocean ; the
variations in the relative positions of land and water are traced, and
it is argued that the Polar Basin has been formed by subsidence
during Tertiary times. In the second paper, the author considers
the changes in climate that have taken place in the North Polar
Regions. He refers to the famous theory according to which the
Arctic regions were once clothed in tropical vegetation and their
shores were once fringed by coral reefs. The evidence on which
this theory rests is, however, shown to be very untrustworthy. The
plant determinations made by Heer are unreliable, and there is no
evidence that coral reefs were ever formed within the Arctic Circle.
Corals grew in Arctic seas in earlier times as they do to-day, but
there has been no adequate proof that they ever formed reefs. Dr
Gregory accordingly distrusts all the theories as to the great size of
the sun in Palaeozoic times and the universal uniform climate in
the pre-Tertiary period, which have been based on the asserted
Arctic palm-groves and coral seas. That climatic changes have
occurred is not disputed, but the author does not think it possible
to estimate their extent until the palaeontology of the Arctic regions
has been carefully revised. The most important work on this
subject now being carried on is Professor Nathorst's redescription of
the fossils about which Heer theorised so wildly. Dr Gregory also
concludes that palaeontological evidence tells strongly against the
view that the position of the Poles has altered to any great
extent.

BlliDS AND THEIE STOMACHS

The United States Department of Agriculture, knowing that the
welfare of the country depends largely on the prosperity of the
farming class, has undertaken for long past a proper . consideration
of birds in their relation to agriculture. In its fifty-fourth bulletin
it deals with the stomach-contents of some twenty common birds.
Among these may be mentioned the cuckoos, woodpeckers, bluejays,
ricebirds, blackbirds, orioles, cedarbirds, catbirds, bluebirds, &c.
There is a good deal of practical common-sense in the introduction
of this pamphlet by Mr P. E. L. Beal, who points out the tendency
to dwell on the harm done by birds rather than the good. He goes
on to say : —

" Within certain limits, birds feed upon the kind of food that is
most accessible. Thus, as a rule, insectivorous birds eat the insects
that are most easily obtained, provided they do not have some
peculiarly disagreeable property. It is not probable that a bird

1897] NOTES AND COMMENTS 147

habitually passes by one kind of insect to look for another which is
more appetizing, and there seems little evidence in support of
the theory that the selection of food is restricted to any particular
species of insect, for it is evident that a bird eats those which by
its own method of seeking are most easily obtained. Thus, a ground-
feeding bird eats those it finds among the dead leaves and grass ;
a flycatcher, watching for its prey from some vantage point, captures
entirely different kinds ; and the woodpecker and warbler, in the
tree tops, select still others. It is thus apparent that a bird's diet
is likely to be quite varied, and to differ at different seasons of the
year.

" In investigating the food habits of birds, field observation can
be relied on only to a limited extent, for it is not always easy
to determine what a bird really eats by watching it. In order to be
positive on this point, it is necessary to examine the stomach
contents. When birds are suspected of doing injury to field crops
or fruit trees, a few individuals should be shot and their stomachs
examined. This will show unmistakably whether or not the birds
are guilty."

In his notes on the tree-sparrow (Spizdla monticola) Mr Beal
shows that the stomachs of these birds in winter are crammed with
the seeds of weeds, and he estimates that in the State of Iowa
alone, if there are only ten birds to a square mile, no less than 875
tons of weed seed are consumed by this single species' in a single
season, basing his calculations on the modest estimate that each bird
eats one fourth of an ounce a day for a winter season of 200 days.
This may be used as an argument by the ignorant to show how
much they eat of grain in the summer, but examination of stomachs
of the same birds in summer shows conclusively that one third
of the bulk is made up of insects (not available for consumption in
the winter), grass and weed seed, and a little oats. The young
birds also are largely fed on insects.

We cannot spare space to quote the statistics of other birds, but
the story is much the same in each case. It is for the farmer
to decide whether he cares to spare a little grain in the summer in
order that his fields may be kept comparatively free of weeds
from year to year, or whether he prefers to kill the birds and have
his pockets emptied by paying for weeding, and the destruction of
hosts of insects which are kept at bay solely by the birds he so
religiously endeavours to destroy.

We have already one work on the economic ornithology of Great
Britain on the. lines of this bulletin (" Ornithology in relation to
Agriculture and Horticulture," by various writers, edited by John
Watson, 1893); but a real benefit would accrue to the farmers in
enabling them to know accurately their friends and their enemies

148 NATURAL SCIENCE [September

(should they care to do so), if the Government or the County
Councils would take up the question officially and systematically.
But such a work would involve much original research.

Amekican Economic Entomology

We have also received from the U.S. Department of Agriculture
a short but interesting pamphlet by Mr C. L. Marlott on " Insect
Control in California." The well-known plan of introducing lady-
bird beetles to prey upon the imported scale-insects which
devastate the western fruit-orchards has been successfully extended ;
while an efficient artificial insecticide has been found in hydrocyanic
acid gas with which the trees are fumigated after being covered with
a temporary canvas tent. Mr F. H. Chittenden writes on the
European Asparagus beetles which, like so many old-world insects,
have been introduced into the Atlantic States. Dr L. D. Howard
gives an illustrated account of various portable steam pumping-
engines used for spraying trees with insecticide fluids.

Glands in Insects

In the latest part of the Transactions of the Entomological
Society of London (1897, pp. 113-126, pt, v.), Mr Oswald H. Latter
describes the structure and function of the sternal gland found in
the prothorax of the caterpillar of the " Puss " moth (Cerura vinula).
The formic acid secreted by this gland has long been recognised
as a defence to the larva against its enemies. Mr Latter has now
shown that at the end of larval life the secretion has another
function. Mixed with the silk the acid serves to make the cocoon
which contains the pupa exceedingly hard and waterproof as well as
strongly adherent to foreign substances such as the chips of wood
which this caterpillar habitually works into its cocoon.

Mr Latter points out that in other lepidoptera and insects
of different orders, many segments of the body possess glands which
may reasonably be considered serially homologous with that under
consideration ; he suggests that all these glands represent the coxal
glands of arachnids. The prothoracic gland of C. vinula opens into
a shallow vestibule, whence arise branched eversible tubes bearing-
groups of spines in their cavities. Mr Latter is unable to suggest a
satisfactory function for these tubes, but he points out that the
groups of spines recall the parapodial setae of chaetopods, and that
the whole structure supports Mr Bernard's view that such glands
are derived from the acicular gland sacs of ringed worms. Should
these relationships prove to be correct, Mr Latter believes that they
" will go far towards establishing the primitive nature of the cruci-
form larva of which many observers are already in favour."

1897] NOTES AND COMMENTS 149

The Photography of Microscopic Organisms in Motion

According to the Scientific American, the principles of the kineto-
scope have been applied to the microscope with some interesting-
results by Dr Eobert L. Watkins of New York. The instrument
employed, termed a micromotoscope, has been very difficult to devise,
owing to the manipulation of the light and lens. When the light
is concentrated sufficiently for photography, it very quickly kills or
seriously injures almost any kind of life in the microscopic field.
The greater the magnification, the more intense and the nearer the
lens the light must be. Difficulties are also multiplied by the
length of time sometimes taken in arranging the focus on the sensi-
tive film. After repeated efforts, however, Dr Watkins has obtained
some measure of success, and motions that are not too rapid have
been very satisfactorily recorded. He has been able to produce
about 2500 pictures per minute. This is not a sufficiently rapid
process to photograph the motion of the blood circulating in the
web of a frog's foot ; but it has served admirably in the case of at
least one rotifer, which exhibits the most interesting form of cell
motion yet reproduced.

The Great Auk in Ireland

Remains of the extinct Great Auk (Alca impennis) have already
been recorded from the north of Ireland, but the known range of
this interesting bird has just been considerably extended by the
discovery of a few bones in a Kitchen Midden on the coast of
Waterford, nearly as far south as 52° N. latitude (E. J. Ussher,
Irish Nat., vol. vi., p. 208). A humerus, tibia and metatarsus
have been identified by Dr Hans Gadow and Professor Alfred
Newton. They were associated with bones of common domestic
animals and the red deer, and thus probably do not date back to
an earlier period than the remains already found in the refuse-
heaps of Caithness and Durham.

Extinct Birds of Madagascar

During his stay in Madagascar Dr Forsyth Major spent several
months in the Sirabe district searching for remains of Aepyornis.
What success attended his efforts has already been noticed in these
columns, but besides Acpyomis, Dr Major discovered remains
of numerous other birds associated with it. Mr C. W. Andrews, to
whom we are indebted for the careful description of these Aepyornis

150 NATURAL SCIENCE [September

remains, is now collecting in Christmas Island, but before setting
out on this expedition he left for publication a paper which has just
appeared in the Ibis (July), dealing with the most remarkable
of these other Madagascar birds. Those here described are mainly
carinate and were associated with Ac. hildebrandti of Burckhardt, in
a marly layer indicating an old lake bottom at a depth of 1 2 to 1 5
feet. Above the marl comes a coarse gravel consolidated with
carbonate of lime and containing rolled and broken bones, which may
mark a volcanic outburst accompanied by hot springs charged with
that mineral. Above this deposit is another of black earth from
5 to 6 feet in thickness, in which bird bones occur though rarely. It
is interesting to note that Ac. hildebrandti does not occur in the black
earth, but remains of the smaller Ac. mutteri were found together
with well-preserved bones of Mullcrornis agilis.

The most important of Dr Major's discoveries as described by Mr
Andrews may be briefly enumerated. A large Anserine bird, having
resemblances to Chcnalopex pugil, from Lagoa Santa, Brazil. This
has been called Ccntromis majori. Another Anserine is closely
allied to Chenalopcx acgyptiacus, but the numerous slight differences
between the fossil and the recent species induced Mr Andrews
to term it C. sirabensis. He however thinks it possible that when
further remains are found, it may turn out to be Sarcidiomis
mauritianus, an extinct bird described by Newton and Gadow from
Mauritius. A new rail, Tribonyx roberti, is described from a
pelvis ; while a well-preserved tibia is also referred to this species.
Ardea, Platcdea, Astur, and Plotus, are among the other remains
discovered, but at present the material is not of a sufficient quantity
to justify further description. It may be as well to note, however,
that Ccntromis is described from remains of four or five individuals ;
and the Chenalopcx from a large collection of bones, many of which
were found associated.

The Origin of the Edentate Mammals

The phylogeny of the edentate mammals has long been a standing
puzzle to palaeontologists, and this gap in our knowledge has
rendered it impossible to come to a full understanding of the
South American fauna. So far as the typical or American forms
(sloths, ground-sloths, ant-eaters, and armadillos) are concerned, the
problem has been solved by the labours of Dr J. S. Wortman, of
the American Museum of Natural History, of which an illustrated
account has appeared in the Bulletin of the Museum (vol. ix. pp.
59-110). A valuable illustrated article on the same subject, by
Prof. 0. C. Marsh, has also been published in the American Journal
of Science (vol. iii., 1897, pp. 137-140).

1897] NOTES AND COMMENTS 151

For many years there have been known more or less imperfect
remains of certain remarkable and puzzling mammals from the
Eocene of the United States, which have been described under the
names of Hcmiganus, Psittacotherinm , Calamodon, and Stylinodon ;
the two first being from the Puerco beds, while the third is from
the Wasatch, and the fourth from the Bridger and Wind river.
The unfortunate animals to which these bones and teeth belonged
have been shifted about from place to place, according to the fancy
or bias of each individual describer ; one of their last resting-
places being among the Tillodontia.

Dr Wortman has, however, succeeded in showing that whereas
in the latter it is the second incisor in each jaw which (as in the
rodents) undergoes hypertrophism, in the animals forming the
subject of his memoir it is the canine which undergoes special
enlargement. Obviously, therefore, there can be no intimate re-
lationship between the two groups ; and as the one he has specially
investigated requires a new title, the name Ganodonta has been
proposed.

To enter into details of the structure of these ganodonts would
obviously be out of place here. But any competent anatomist who
may take the trouble to consult the excellent descriptions and
figures given in the original memoir can scarcely fail to be con-
vinced that in these animals Dr Wortman has succeeded in
identifying the long-missing ancestors of the American edentates.
Although the Puerco forms have enamelled and rootless molars, in
the latter types the roots at first become confluent, and finally
disappear, while at the same time the enamel becomes restricted
to bands, and the whole structure of the tooth is simplified.
The canines, too, become more and more like those of the Pliocene
and Pleistocene ground-sloths ; while the resemblance between the
skulls and limbs of the latter and these of the ganodonts is such
as to render no other conclusion possible but that the one group is
the forerunner of the other. Not only, therefore, have the ancestors
of the true edentates been discovered, but we have proof that the
first tooth of the modern sloths is a canine, and not a premolar.

The Ganodonta are regarded as forming a sub-order of the
Edentata ; the genera mentioned above constituting one family
(Stylinodontidac), while a second family (Conorydidae) is made up
of the genera Conorydcs and Onychodectcs, to which further allusion
is unnecessary in this place. Whether the living Old World
families (Orycteropodidae and Manidae) should or should not be
included 4n the Edentata, Dr Wortman leaves an open question ;
but in either event he confesses himself unable to draw up a
satisfactory definition of the order.

152 NATURAL SCIENCE [September

The South American Edentate Mammals

Having satisfactorily demonstrated the ancestral position of
the Ganodonta to the modern American Edentata, Dr Wortman
goes on to observe that if this be true, " it follows that all the
South American edentates must have been derived from the
North American Ganodonta, since their earliest appearance in
South America does not antedate the Santa Cruz epoch. In this
formation they appear suddenly in great numbers and variety,
without apparently any announcement in the older Pyrothcrium
deposits. This fact in itself would seem to indicate that they
were migrants from another region, and while we are as yet unable
to place these deposits in the time-scale with accuracy, it is yet
highly probable that the Santa Cruz beds are not older than our
North American Oligocene. In North America the Ganodonta
appear in the very earliest Puerco deposits, and continue without
interruption into the Bridger, where they disappear. No evidences
of them have up to date been detected in the Uinta or White
River beds.

" Now it is currently believed by geologists that no land con-
nection existed between North and South America from the close of
the Cretaceous to the close of the Miocene, when an extensive land
bridge was formed. I am not familiar with the geological evidence
upon which the conclusion rests, but if one is permitted to judge
from the subjoined statements of Mr F. C. Nicholas, it is at the
very least open to question. It is, of course, possible that the
Ganodonta may have reached South America by way of Europe,
Africa, and Antarctica, but on the whole it seems infinitely more
probable that there was a land bridge of short duration during
Eocene time between North and South America, and that they
reached their destination in this way, than by the questionable and
circuitous route just mentioned. If they gained entrance into
South America by the European- African route, it seems indeed
strange that they should have left no remains in the later Tertiaries
of Europe. "With the exception of a single specimen of Calamodon
Europaeus, from deposits corresponding with the Wasatch in age, all
traces of the American Edentata are absent in Europe, Asia and
Africa."

To the first paragraph in this ([notation no exception can be
taken. With regard to the second, we have not the pleasure of
being acquainted, either personally or by his writings, with Mr F.
C. Nicholas, who may be a most excellent person, bnt the rambling
extracts from a letter of his, which Dr Wortman prints in a foot-
note, can scarcely affect the problem of a land connection between
the two Americas in early Tertiary times. Apart from this, the .

1897] NOTES AND COMMENTS 153

evidence adduced by Dr W. B. Scott and others as to the separation
of North and South America cannot be overthrown by the con-
clusions drawn from one group of animals, more especially when an
alternative route of migration will explain the facts equally well, if
not indeed better.

The Old World Edentate Mammals

While it may be admitted that one swallow does not make a
summer, it cannot be contended that a single tooth is not amply
sufficient to prove the existence of the group of animals in the
country where it was found. And as Dr Wortman expressly states
that Calamodon europaeus — founded on a canine from the Swiss
siderolithes — is a member of the Ganodonta, there is ample evidence
of the existence of that group in Europe during the Eocene. Prob-
ably Dr Wortman is unaware how rare mammalian fossils are in
those deposits, and why he should make a point of their absence
from the later European Tertiaries passes our comprehension. With
regard to Africa, no Eocene or middle Tertiaries are known, and
consequently no arguments can be drawn one way or another.
Moreover, it is known that when the later South American ground-
sloths succeeded in entering the northern half of the New World
during the Pliocene, they flourished excellently well, and if their
ancestors reached the South from the North, it is difficult- to see why
the group should have immediately died off in the latter area.

To our own thinking it is much more probable that the Eocene
Ganodonts of the northern hemisphere migrated southwards from
Europe to Africa, and eventually reached South America by that
route, as appears to have been the case with certain other groups of
mammals. This, of course, opens up the question whether the Old
World, so-called Edentates may not after all really belong to that
group. Without denying the possibility of this, it may be urged
that whereas the skulls and limb bones of the Ganodonta are
strikingly like those of the South American edentates, those of
Manis and Orycteropus are as strikingly unlike. If, therefore,
they belong to the same stock, they would appear to have diverged
before the Ganodonta assumed their characteristic type. But as
this was acquired in the early Eocene, the Edentate origin of
Orycteropus and Manis seems very problematical. At the same
time we have at present no other group in which to look for the
parentage of those strange creatures.

New Light on the Ova of Vertebrata

In the series of observations published by K. Mitsukuri, of Tokyo,
in the Journal of the College of Science of the Imperial University,

154 NATURAL SCIENCE [September

Japan, we have a fresh instance of the admirable work done
by certain of the Japanese morphologists. Mitsukuri's researches
concern the fate of the blastopore, the relations of the primitive
streak, and the formation of the posterior end of the embryo in
Chelonia, together with some remarks on the nature of meroblastic
ova in vertebrates. But, as is not infrequently the case, the most
important results are those which receive least consideration in the
title of the paper. The nature and fate of the ' yolk-plug ' (or cell-
mass projecting between the lips of the blastopore), which undergoes
very complex changes and shiftings of position, is far more interest-
ing than that of the blastopore itself, owing to the theoretical con-
siderations which Mitsukuri's view of it involves. The previously-
asserted homology of this cell-mass with the yolk-plug of the
Amphibia, and with a similar structure observed by Van Beneden in
Mammalia, is well-maintained. The necessity for a re-classification
of vertebrate ova into ' primary ' and ' secondary ' types is clearly
established, if the theory of the loss and acquisition of yolk in verte-
brate eggs several times in the course of phyletic development be
correct. The primitive plate and yolk-plug in Chelonia are shown
to be rudiments of a large primary yolk-mass which existed in the
early history of amniote eggs. The large yolk-mass seen in amniote
eggs of the present day has been secondarily acquired, and the
enclosure of this mass by the blastoderm is a coenogenetic process
having nothing to do with gastrulation. On the other hand, the
enclosure of the primary yolk-mass by the blastoderm is closely
connected with gastrulation. Mammalian ova are supposed to have
lost even the secondary yolk-mass. Any comparison, therefore,
between the various classes of ova can only justly be made when
these facts are given due weight, and they are likely to throw
additional light on questions dealing with the primitive character or
otherwise of various groups.

Peimitive Methods of Trepanning

In V Anthropologic (vol. viii., pt. ii., 1897) a most interesting account
is given by Dr H. Malbot, assisted by Dr E. Verneau, on the Tre-
panning of the Skull by the Chaouias of the Aures Mountains, in the
province of Constantine, Algeria. A preliminary account of these
people and their country was given in the previous number of the
same journal. It is a most curious fact that in a remote district in
the above-named region, this people of mixed racial origin practise
trepanning on an elaborate scale, and apparently maintain this prac-
tice as an heritage from ancient times. Trepanned skulls have been
found in ancient cemeteries in Algeria, and prove the practice to be
an old one in the region. The Chaou'ias have established a great

1897] NOTES AND COMMENTS 155

name for success in this operation, which they conduct in a manner
which is characterised by great boldness, combined with decidedly
rough and ready methods. The surgical equipment is of the
simplest description, the principal instruments being a kind of auger
(brima), or centre-bit rather, and two kinds of very rude saws
(mcnchar) of peculiar hooked shape and very short cutting edges.
The text-book, there is but one, is a manuscript, a copy of which is
possessed by each qualified trepanner. The brima is used for ex-
ploring, and holes are drilled into the bone of the skull, at first
through the outer table only, for examination of the diploe ; but, if
necessary, the hole is extended through the inner table, exposing
the dura mater. Large portions of the skull are, if it is deemed
desirable, removed through the agency of the brima, several holes
being drilled with it very close together, and when, after some weeks,
necrosis has destroyed the narrow bridges of bone between the holes,
the whole piece of bone round which the holes were drilled is
detached with a lever and removed. The saw is used for grave
cases, and the sawed grooves are sunk to the inner table, the remain-
ing thickness of bone being scraped away with a hooked instrument.
In other cases the grooves are less deep, and necrosis does the rest
of the work, the final detachment of the bone being effected as before
with a lever. Prayers and incantations always accompany the
operation. They must be needed ! Some stubborn cases demand
the trial of every class of trepanning, and at successive sittings the
operator puts them all in practice ; ' ' C'est une veritable orgie de
trepanation ! " The most peculiar part of the whole thing is that
the patient as a rule recovers, this being due rather to the natural
physical qualities of the Berber race, than to the skill of the operator.
Eecovery may, in fact, be said to be in spite of the surgeon. Dr
Malbot was fortunate enough to obtain a skull showing all the
methods practised, a most striking specimen of which he gives a
figure. The skull is now preserved in the Museum of Natural
History at Paris.

This paper should be read in connection with Dr Eobert Munro's
paper on " Prehistoric Trepanning and Cranial Amulets," which has
been lately republished in his book on " Prehistoric Problems."
This gives a good and well-illustrated general account of ancient
trepanning, a special reference being made to cases belonging to
Neolithic times. The use of fragments of skulls as amulets is also
gone into in detail, and the fact made clear that trepanning was in
some cases surgical, in others posthumous, following Broca's famous
memoir of- 1876. Dr Munro gives a sketch of the geographical
distribution of this operation, and discourses on the methods
employed in early times. It is a pity that so few details regarding
the practice of trepanning amongst modern primitive peoples are

156 NATURAL SCIENCE ^ [September

forthcoming, and it is greatly to be hoped that attention may be
directed to this custom wherever it occurs, as the procedure observed
amongst races in a low condition of culture may help to throw
further light upon the archaeological aspect of the question.

Speak-throwers from New Guinea

Mr T. Jennings (Proc. Linn. Soc, N.S.W., 1896, p. 793) has
recently described in detail and figured two Papuan spear-throwers
of bambu from New Guinea. These instruments have only com-
paratively recently been recognised as occurring in New Guinea,
though numbers have now been received in the various European
museums. The type is interesting for its form, which differs from
that of the well-known hook-ended spear-throwers of Australia, and
resembles rather that of the socket-ended examples from the Caro-
line and Pelew Islands, figured by Dr von Luschan. The addition
of a wooden flange as a rest for the spear is peculiar to New
Guinea, and the carving on these rests is often elaborate, and is varied
individually, no two, probably, being quite similar. The original
design in nearly all cases has apparently been some animal form
grotesquely treated. The two examples described by Mr Jennings
differ somewhat in detail from those figured by Dr von Luschan in
his more elaborate paper on the subject, published in the Bastian
Festschrift. Mr Jennings adds a few remarks upon the peculiar
geographical distribution of these implements, but his account does
not aim at being a complete one, and the distribution is pretty well
known.

Cycads

In our last number (p. 85) we referred to some recent work by a
Japanese investigator which gave additional interest to an ancient
and always interesting group of plants. The Cycads are the oldest
family of seed-plants. They had reached and passed their maxi-
mum (in Triassic and Jurassic ages) before the appearance of the
angiospermous type which is dominant at the present day. Their
habit, a simple, short stem with a crown of leaves, recalls the
tree-fern much more than our dicotyledonous forest-tree with its
widely branching axis and small deciduous leaves. And the dis-
covery, of which we gave a short account last month, was only an
additional evidence of the fact, recognised now for more than
thirty years, that Cycads, if not a connecting link, are at any rate
representatives of a type of plant-life occupying a place in the
scale of evolution between ferns and those seed-plants in which
the ovules are packed away in a closed ovary-chamber. Their
occurrence to-day is what we should expect in a disappearing but

1897] NOTES AND COMMENTS 157

once dominant group. There are only nine genera with about
seventy-five species, but the order is widely distributed in the
warmer parts of the earth, though individual genera and species
have a very limited distribution. The old world has five genera,
the new world four, but America possesses by far the greater
number of species, Central America and Mexico being the richest
areas, while Australia is the largest centre in the old world.
Cijcas (sixteen species) is the most widely-spread type, occurring
in the warmer parts of Asia up to south Japan, in Australia,
Polynesia and the Malagasy Islands. Stangcria and Bowenia are
monotypic genera from Natal and Queensland respectively. Dioon
has two species in Mexico ; Encepltalartos, twelve in South and
tropical Africa ; Macrozamia, fourteen in Australia. Zamia is the
largest genus with thirty species, and is found from Peril to the
West Indies and Florida ; Ceratozamia is Mexican with six species,
and Microcycas is a monotypic genus from Cuba. But a much
larger number of fossil genera have been described, chiefly from
leaves, though fruits and other reproductive organs are also known.
Tims Engler in his Pflanzenfamilicn enumerates twenty-three
" more important " ones found almost exclusively in Europe, but
occasionally in Greenland and Spitzbergen. Our nine genera are
obviously scattered remnants of a once large and dominant family.
Even individuals are isolated ; except in the case of species of
Cycas they are few and far between.

In the June number of the Botanical Gazette, H. J. Webber gives
an account of his investigations into the structure and behaviour of
the pollen-tube in a species of Zamia. One of his figures shows
a peculiarity in the growth of the tube, which at first penetrates
the nucellus for a short distance and then resumes growth at the
other end, that, namely to which the grain is still attached. The
important generative cell remains at the pollen-grain end in which
it is carried down into the cavity above the archegonia or female
organs. Webber describes two centrosome-like structures in this
generative cell, the function of which is doubtful. The most
interesting part of his communication is contained in a note
which records the discovery, as the paper was going through the
press, of motile antherozoids. As to how or where they arise,
whether they are or are not in any way connected with the
strange bodies in the generative cell, we are left completely in
the dark, and can only hope for a continuation in our next.

The Fossils of the English Chalk Pock

Thanks to Mr Henry Woods, we have now an intelligent and
careful account of the mollusca of one zone of the Cretaceous

158 NATURAL SCIENCE [September

system of England. We say intelligent advisedly, because Mr
Woods has not included in his lists those scraps of fossils which
are considered by some authors worthy to occupy their text and
their plates. The mollusca of the Chalk Bock have been described
in the Quarterly Journal of the Geological Society, vols. Hi. and liii.,
and comprise ten cephalopods, sixteen gasteropods, and twenty-nine
lamellibranchs, and of these some seven of the first group occur in
Saxony and Bohemia, two or three only of the second group, and
about one half of the third. Fossils from this zone are rarely
obtained in a perfect condition, and are frequently denuded of their
shell, but Mr Woods has succeeded in figuring some typical speci-
mens which will be useful to the collection. In looking through
part ii. of his paper, we do not see any mention of Dover, where the
Chalk Eock is easily accessible and fairly rich in fossils ; indeed, in
a few hours we have collected all but two of the gasteropods men-
tioned by Mr Hill in the Quarterly Journal, vol. xlii. As the ener-
getic members of the Geologists' Association were observed in
numbers at the Chalk Eock of Dover last Easter, Mr Woods might
easily have obtained a list of specimens. It is gratifying to read
that the author intends to proceed with the Inocerami, for they are
in worse confusion than most other shells. His synonymies of
Lima hoperi and Spondylus spinosus are interesting and important.
Mr Woods will forgive us perhaps if we point out to him that
Salvius did not print the molluscan part of Linne's edition xii. until
1767, and therefore the date cannot be 1766 ; but why not use the
tenth edition, 1758, now almost universally recognized?

A list of other remains identified is supplied, and discussions on
the distribution and relations of the fauna and conditions under
which the Chalk Eock was deposited are given. The whole is a
useful and valuable paper which will be largely in request.

TlERKA DEL FUEGO

In September last year we were favoured by Dr Ohlin with an
account of the zoological results of Baron Oscar Dickson's expedi-
tion to Tierra del Fuego. A preliminary notice of the geographical
results of that expedition is now published in the Scottish Geo-
graphical Magazine for August. The country consists of a wood-
less tableland in the north, and a mountainous district in the
south, the latter being the extreme continuation of the Cordilleras.
The boundary between the two zones is almost a straight line.
The northern country is stated to be of Tertiary age, covered partly
by gravel and partly by moraine.

NATURAL SCIENCE, VOL XI.

Platk VII

JOHANNES JAPETUS SMITH STEENSTKUl'
Born March 8, 1813; died June 20, 1897

921.8 150

Steenstrup

JOHANNES JAPETUS SMITH STEENSTEUP was born on
March 8, 1813, in the northern part of Jutland, in the
district termed Thy, where his father was a parson. In the year
1832 he was sent from the cathedral - school of his native
province at Aalborg to be a student at the University of
Copenhagen. In two succeeding years (1833-35) he was obliged
to remain in the paternal home, occupied with teaching his
younger brothers and with natural history excursions into his
native country, collecting numerous examples of its interesting
natural productions, its plants and animals, its fossils and geological
features. Of scientific facilities or aids he had very little ; a copy
of the published parts of the celebrated " Flora Danica," of Linne's
" Sy sterna Naturae," of 0. M. Miiller's " Prodromus zoologiae
danicae," were, I believe, almost the only books of science avail-
able for Steenstrup in these early times of his scientific self-
training and self- education ; his only helper at this time being a
gifted parson, his uncle, formerly a pupil, especially in botany and
entomology, of the renowned naturalist and teacher Melchior, at the
college of Herlufsholm. After his return to the university in 1835,
in the full bloom of a self-made young naturalist, he became the
pupil and friend of Schouw, the botanist, of Forchammer, the
geologist, and of Eeinhardt, sen., the zoologist, whose ingenious
lectures left an impression on Steenstrup's mind never to be effaced.
Among the particular friends of those days of his youth were the
gifted botanist Drejer, lost at an early age, Liebmann, Schouw's
successor as Professor of Botany after his return from Mexico,
Eeinhardt, jun., the celebrated zoologist and traveller in Brazil, etc.
Only two years after his return to the university Steenstrup earned
the honours for two prize essays, the one (never published, only
epitomised in my text-book, " Dyreriget," and therefrom in Palmen's
work on the migrations of birds), " on the differences between the
wanderings of birds and fishes," the other, published afterwards
(1842) in the Transactions of the Danish Academy of Science,
" on the geological investigation of certain forest-moors on Seeland,"
etc. — a work of great sagacity and acute observation, the first to
elucidate the sequence of the different forest-vegetations charac-

160 NATURAL SCIENCE [September

teristic of the early periods in the recovery of our country after
its emergence from the waves and the close of what is now termed
" the Ice- Age " — the ages of the aspen (Populus tremula), of the
fir {Pinus sylvestris), the oak (Quercus sessiliflora), and ulti-
mately the alder (Alnus glutincsa) and the beech (Fagus
sylvatica). Much time was destined to elapse before these
studies of the gifted rising naturalist, so important for the history
of the life of our globe, were taken up elsewhere in other northern
regions.

In the year 1839-40 Steenstrup was sent by the Government,
with an Icelandic student, Hallgrimson, and Mr Schytte, afterwards
Professor of Chemistry in Chile and Governor at Puntas Arenas on
the Straits of Magellan, to Iceland for an economic investigation of
this country. The story of this voyage, though interesting to those
who have had the good fortune to hear Steenstrup's reminiscences
of the country, its nature and its people, was never published ; nor
was his interesting and fruitful discovery that the so-called " Surtur-
brand " in the Tertiary trap formation of Iceland contained a series
of remains of an arboreal vegetation, with its tulip-trees (Lirio-
dendron), etc., most resembling that of certain subtropical regions,
until his Icelandic materials and figures were placed in the hands of
Oswald Heer. Steenstrup's investigations on the volcanic formation
of Iceland have been taken up by younger minds, who have no
doubt been much benefited by the information that was in Steen-
strup's possession. Another discovery made by Steenstrup on this
trip to Iceland happened during some sunny days near the coast of
Norway, viz., the discovery of the metamorphosis of crabs (Hyas
araneus) and soldier crabs (Pagurus bcrnhardus), at a period when
metamorphosis in Crustacea was very little known, and therefore
was received by excellent zoologists with considerable doubt. Steen-
strup's letters to Eeinhardt on this subject were printed in the
Proceedings of the Royal Danish Academy in 1870. The
specimens collected were also sent down to his teacher. They
were seen here by Ptathke, who described them together with the
material collected by himself. The history of the metamorphosis
in the higher Crustacea now occupies an extensive literature ;
among the first pioneers in this important chapter Steenstrup's
name must have its place.

Shortly after his return from Iceland in 1841 Steenstrup was
appointed lecturer in Potany and Mineralogy (geology) in the
Academy of Soroe in Seeland, the only place in Denmark where
Natural History and a knowledge of modern languages had its
rightful place among the classical lines of study. Here he remained
until 1846, occupied especially witli two of his best known works,
published as programmes of the college, viz., "The Alternations of

1897] STEEXSTRUF 161

Generations" (1842), and "On the Existence of Hermaphroditism
in Nature" (1845). The first of these is too well known to need
any explanation here ; it can only be wondered that this doctrine so
wonderful at the time of its publication has been so little modified
in its essential points and lost or gained so little in extension since
that time. Space forbids me to enlarge further on this topic, which
more than any other of Steenstrup's writings has spread his name
and fame over the whole civilised world. His second work, that
" On Hermaphroditism," was less successful, though its subject was
in intimate connection with lines of thought resulting from or con-
nected with " metagenesis," as it is now generally termed. One may
admire the author's acuteness of perception and the extent of his
comparative studies, and confess that he quite rightly abolished many
cases of unfounded hermaphroditism among inferior animals ; but it
must be allowed that hermaphroditism is still fully recognised, with
few exceptions, among leeches, flukes, tapeworms, pulmonate and
opisthobranch snails, barnacles, etc. (Tardigrada have lately been
thrown off), without our being able to give an adequate natural
reason for its presence in some tribes and its absence in others.
In recent times Steenstrup's memoir has awakened the important
remark, that in all probability hermaphroditism has not been the
primordial rule in any division of higher or lower zoological rank,
but must be a " later acquisition " in the course of evolution, for
which no satisfactory reason can yet be given. While speaking
still of Steenstrup's residence at Soroe, it should be mentioned that
here he pursued, in the course of other faunistic studies, an examina-
tion into the specific duplicity of our common frogs (Rana temporaria)
and the distinctive characters of what he termed R. oxyrhinus and
R. platyrhinus, which have played a rather important part in the
recent study of the Anourous Batrachia.

In 1846, after the death of Eeinhardt, sen., Steenstrup was
nominated to replace him in the chair of Zoology at the University
•of Copenhagen, and as Director of its modest zoological collection.
He was a beloved and admired teacher for the students of medicine
and for the pupils of the polytechnic school, and at the same time the
gifted chief leader of the " Natural History Society." A member of
ithe Royal Society of Science from 1842, he was its secretary after
Forchammer's death until after years of great activity he gave up
this post in 1878. The election to the Presidency after Madvig's
•death he declined, as he had more than once declined the Rectorship
of the University, being anxious not to be drawn too much away
from his scientific studies and his professorial duties. In 1848 he
was with Forchammer placed at the head of the " Poyal Natural
History Museum," with the recommendation of the Minister of
Education to promote its union with the University Museums — a

162 NATURAL SCIENCE [September

proposal which naturally enough interested Steenstrup much, hut
met with some opposition, not only from the University, which
reasonably feared the increased pecuniary obligations involved in
such a scheme, but also from the majority of the keepers at the
Eoyal Museum. At last the battle was won by the bill of 1863,
which ordered the construction of a much wanted building in the
grounds of the University. It was finished and opened to the
public and to Science in 1870, and has since been the handsome,
but perhaps not sufficiently large home of zoological science with us,
constructed by the gifted architect, Chr. Hansen, whose genius was,
I believe, strongly fertilised by Steenstrup's ideas. Steenstrup was
not, as originally planned, the sole director of the new museum, but
by the election of the University the president of its council,
consisting of two keepers (inspectors), Schodte and Bernhardt, and
himself as administrators of its different departments. I shall not
here speak of the difficulties and painful controversies connected
with this organisation. Steenstrup retired from his position as
Professor of Zoology in the year 1885, after a painful period,
rendered more distressing through an unfortunate accident (a
fracture of collum femoris). I shall confine myself to a short
resume" of his chief scientific work from 1846 to 1885, the years
of his professorship.

It was one of Steenstrup's characteristic features that he was
not only an excellent zoologist and a specialist in some of its
branches, but also a good geologist and botanist, capable of discuss-
ing many topics relating to different sciences ; and it may be
said, that he had a certain predilection for those points of
science, where its different sections meet and intercross. It will
therefore be easily understood that a man with his abilities and
constitution of mind must play an important part in a large
scientific community. It is, of course, a difficult task to classify
his works, which can often be referred to more than one of the
related sciences, and whose value may be judged from different
points of view. It will be understood that while his humble suc-
cessor in the chair of Zoology since 1885 may think himself
entitled to judge of his purely zoological work, he must speak some-
what more discreetly, notwithstanding the partly natural historical
character of Steenstrup's archaeological and related publications, on
this part of his literary work, and leave the ultimate judgment
to his historical and archaeological colleagues.

One of Steenstrup's great services was, that he induced — what
was then a rarity — some of our excellent seafaring men of the navy
or of the merchant line, to devote their leisure hours to collecting
the animals of the seas through which they sailed, making careful
notes of the localities examined with their nets, and in this manner

1 897] S TEENS Til UP 163

furnishing the museum with pelagic and other material from almost
every part of the ocean. Several parts of this "Plankton" have
since been worked upon by his pupils and others {e.g., Boas on the
Pteropoda, Traustedt on the Salpae, Lutken on the Dolphins and
the " hemi-metamorphoses of fishes," Bovallius on the Hyperidae,
etc.). With this series of studies may also be reckoned the memoir
of Steenstrup and myself on the parasitic Entomostraca of the
ocean with several other forms of the same tribe ; also the former's
anti-critical note on the genera Sllcnium, Lesteira and Pegasimallus,
and his papers (too numerous to be enumerated here) on Cepha-
lopoda (Notac teuthologicae, etc.) in the Transactions and Proceed-
ings of the Academy of Science, in the Vidcnskabcligc Mcddclcl-
scr fra den naturhistorishe Forcning, and elsewhere in popular
journals. I shall dwell, however, more particularly only on two
points. Firstly, there is his surprising demonstration that the
apparently abnormal development of one or occasionally two arms
in male cuttlefishes, hitherto overlooked or not understood, was in
fact the homologue of the well-known " hectocotyle " in the pelagic
Octopoda. His eager desire to throw the light of his genius and of
his science on obscure problems, led him also to investigate the tale
of the wonderful sea-monk, the monster that was cast ashore in our
vicinity in the sixteenth century, described and figured by Belon,
Bondelet and Gesner, and playing an important part in the semi-
mystic Natural History of the Benaissance. Nobody had been
able to decipher this enigmatical monster until Steenstrup deprived
it of its fabulous investment, demonstrated it to be simply a decapod
giant cuttlefish. Specimens of this same kind {Architeuthus) have
been thrown on our shore, formerly and later on the shores of Ice-
land, Faroe, Jutland, Newfoundland and Japan, and happily one of
our captains did find such an animal floating in the Atlantic, and
secured to Steenstrup some of its most important parts. Steen-
strup's full account of these remains was partly in print, though
never completely published ; but some of his plates have been
placed in the hands of his fellow-zoologists. To the other purely
zoological articles of Steenstrup, I shall only allude briefly, namely,
to those on Sphenopus (Sabclla marsiqrialis Giil), on Philichthgs,
Phizochilus, Xenobanalus, Pachybdclla and Pdtogaster, on the enig-
matical objects correctly interpreted as the " gillrakers " of Sdachus
maximus, on the natural systematic place of the walrus, etc. His
interpretation of the wandering of the eye in young flounders has
not been accepted with unanimity, but still has some trustworthy
points to fall back upon. Our common memoir on the Mola-tvihe
(Orthagoriscus) and its larval stages, has not been published in its
complete form ; perhaps it may be so still. Several palaeonto-
logical papers on mammals, birds and reptiles (turtles) found in our

164 NATURAL SCIENCE [September

peat-beds or other formations have appeared at least in abstract, as
also some account of the refuse-heaps or shell-heaps (" kitchen-
middens ") of our shores, whose correct interpretation was the work
of Steenstrup, and has obtained world-wide notice and given birth
to many investigations in other countries. Some papers on
Helmintha {e.g., Fasciola intestinalis) should not be forgotten. His
interpretation of the Brachiopoda as not belonging to the true
Acephala has in later time become popular ; his interpretation of
the partly operculated "Palaeozoic corals" (Cyathophyllidae) as not
being Anthozoa-proper, but something else, perhaps allied to Ser-
polidae, Hippuritidae or Brachiopoda, has met with decided doubt
and opposition, but in my opinion, not found its final decision. In
the study of the newer (Glacial) geological formations, Steenstrup
took an active part with his lamented younger friend and colleague,
Johnstrup, and some of his later papers briefly give his views on
some of the theories advanced in Scandinavia concerning this im-
portant part of Scandinavian geology. That he with Nathorst, the
Swedish botanist-geologist, partook in the discovery of the earliest
glacial plant remains in our Scandinavian peat-bogs, should also be
remembered. He was present at most of the meetings of the
Scandinavian naturalists during the period of his scientific activity
and has left the marks of his influence in the reports of the meet-
ings of the Americanists and Archaeologists at Copenhagen and
Brussels. Beyond his travels in Iceland and his visit to the Faroe
Islands, he made several journeys to Germany, France, Northern
Italy, Switzerland, Dalmatia, and England, enriching his knowledge
and adding to his acquaintance and friendly relation with eminent
men of many countries and many sciences. His scientific corre-
spondence would fill many volumes.

Already in the earlier part of his career, Steenstrup had
published some papers of a chiefly historical aim, throwing light on
obscure phenomena, elucidated from a naturalist's point of view
(e.g., on the so-called " havgaerdinger," on Ottar's relation to King
Alfred on his travels in northern seas, and on the passage of King
Harold through the Limfjord). After he had retired from his
zoological professorship in 1885. he treated with great emphasis
several archaeological problems of the same character (e.g., the Haell-
ristningar, the voyages of the Zeni, the Yak-Lungta-Brakteats, the
silverplates found at Gundestrup, the mammoth station at Predmost
in Bohemia. Most of them have been published, though not the
first. I shall not do more than point out the existence and
interest of these remarkable papers, not being competent to pass a
scientific judgment upon them ; but, at the same time, I would ex-
press my conviction, that they will remain through all future time a
testimony of the great insight, sagacity and knowledge of my gifted

1897] STEENSTRUP 165

friend and teacher, the glory of his country, of Europe, and of his
century. That he was honoured with the highest distinctions from
his country and from many other sources, I need not tell, nor
enumerate the learned societies (Stockholm, Christiania, Berlin,
Paris, London, etc.) of which he was a member. This sketch of
Steenstrup's life and work may appear longer than usual to the
readers of this journal, but it is not long or detailed enough to do
justice to what ought to have been said. I cannot conclude with-
out naming his wife, Ida {nee Kaarsberg), the love of his youth, lost
several years before her husband died. Several children died
earlier or later ; one daughter is left, and there is one son, Johannes
Steenstrup, Doctor in Law and Professor Iiostgaardianus in History
at our University, whose work on the history of the Normans will
especially be known to many English readers.

Che. Fk. Lutken.

575.4 166 [September

Does Natural Selection play any part in the Origin
of Species among Plants ?

INTRODUCTION. — The objects of the present paper are to
answer this question in the negative, and to prove that natural
selection is a superfluous factor as an aid in the origination of new
varietal characters ; though it has much to do with the " survival
of the fittest " in " the struggle for existence " among beings in any
particular locality. It is, of course, the Darwinian conception that
these factors are somehow concerned in the origin of species ; but I
would maintain that they must be kept totally distinct from it.
Darwin, in truth, insisted upon this fact himself ; that whatever the
causes or origins of variations might be, such were questions with
which natural selection had nothing whatever to do. His words
are : — " The direct action of the conditions of life ... is a totally
distinct consideration from the effects of natural selection . . . [it]
has no relation whatever to the primary cause of any modification
of structure."1 What I wish to show is that sufficient variations
to constitute a variety are always the result of a direct or indirect
response to the " definite action " of a new environment ; indeed
many, if not all the organisms, of whatever kind they may be, which
are subjected to it, often vary more or less in a like manner.2 It
will then be seen at once that not only are there no " indefinite
variations " for natural selection to deal with, but as a consequence
its raison 'd'etre, as an aid in the origin of species is gone ; and it
can take no part in the origination of varieties.

I wish also to point out that Darwin's theory of natural
selection rests entirely upon a series of a 'priori assumptions or
deductions, which have never been verified ; nor, indeed, do they
seem capable of verification.

Definition of a Species. — In order to be clear, it is desirable
to state precisely what one understands by the term " Species."
According to the method pursued by systematic botanists in
describing plants, a species may be defined as follows : — " Any
particular species of a genus is known by a collection of characters
taken from any or all parts of the plant. These characters are, or

1 "Animals and Plants under Domestication," vol. ii., p. 272.

2 Hence, arises the fades characteristic of aquatic, desert, alpine, and other plants :
as I have described in my work — " The Origin of Plant Structures."

1897] ORIGIN OF SPECIES AMONG PLANTS 167

are theoretically assumed to be, constant." One or more of these
characters may be found on another species, which in a similar
manner is known by its collection of constant characters.

What may have been their origin, and how the survival and
maintenance of any superficial characters of a plant have been
secured, are philosophical questions with which the systematist has
no concern at all.

Useless Characters. — Before showing that the hypothesis ef
natural selection is superfluous in the origination of varietal charac-
ters, let us turn to the descriptions of plants given in some standard
work, say, Sir J. D. Hooker's " Students' Flora of the British Isles."
It will be found that many characters are taken as specific or
generic which cannot, with any show of reason, be regarded as
specifically useful ; such as the numerical excess or deficiency in
the number of parts in the floral whorls ; e.g., Gcntiana campestris
is described as having the calyx "four-partite"; while in G-. amarella,
it is " five-lobed " ; but fours, fives and sixes may be often found on
one and the same plant, as in a corymb of elder flowers, due to an
accidental deficiency or excess of nutriment, respectively ; and no
vital importance can be attributed to the trivial specific distinc-
tion between " partite " and " lobed." Such illustrations of quite
unimportant characters regarded as specific can be multiplied to
any extent ; but they are some of the very characters which
Darwin admits are not due to natural selection. He says :
— " We thus see that with plants many morphological changes
may be attributed to the laws of growth and interaction of parts,
independently of natural selection." l They are, in fact, simply
the inevitable results of a response to environmental conditions, using
the term in the broadest sense.

With regard to such indifferent characters being hereditary,
Darwin first says that he " felt great difficulty in understanding the
origin or formation of parts of little importance ; almost as great,
though of a different kind, as in the case of the most perfect and
complex organs," 2 and he devotes a section to a theoretical
interpretation of them. Indeed he, on several occasions, recognises
the existence of useless characters ; e.g., he says, " I am inclined to
suspect that we see, at least in some of the polymorphic genera,
variations which are of no service or disservice to the species ; and,
consequently, have not been seized on and rendered definite by
natural selection." 3 In this passage the word " disservice " almost
seems as if he had a suspicion that " injurious " characters might
sometimes be present, though he elsewhere says : — " Any actually
injurious deviations in their structure would, of course, have been

1 " Origin of Species," 6th ert., p. 175 ; see also p. 367.

2 " Origin, etc.," p. 156. ■"' " Origin, etc.," p. 35.

168 NATURAL SCIENCE [September

checked by natural selection." Secondly, the following are Darwin's
words with reference to the inheritance of characters which are no
longer useful : — " No doubt the definite action of changed con-
ditions . . . have all produced an effect, probably a great effect,
independently of any advantage thus gained. ... I fully admit that
many structures are now of no direct use to their possessors, and
may never have been of any use to their progenitors." . . . He
mentions the webbed feet of upland geese, etc. ..." With these
important exceptions, we may conclude that the structure of every
living creature either now is, or was formerly, of some direct or
indirect use to its possessor," l He would thus include all rudi-
mentary organs as having been formerly useful, but now useless ; of
these he remarks that rudimentary organs from being useless are not
regulated by natural selection, and hence are variable. If they be
so in the animal kingdom, they are not so in the vegetable ; e.g., the
staminodes and rudiments of ovaries of flowers are constant in form
to each species, genus or order which is characterised by them,
respectively; as, e.g., Er odium, Samolus, Mercurialis, Parietaria,
Valerianeae, Myrsineae, etc., and are recognised as permanent
diagnostic characters.

Injurious Characters. — In many flowers there have been
acquired and retained by heredity, what may be called by Darwin's
term "disservice," or even "injurious" characters. For if, e.g., the
use of flowers be to set good seed, then anything which tends to
hinder that process is obviously injurious. Such occurs in the
structure of the flowers of most orchids, and in many adaptations
to insect fertilisation, as dichogamy, protandry, polymorphism, etc.,
whenever they tend to bar self-fertilisation.

For it need hardly be observed now, that Darwin's assumption
from the numerous adaptations in flowers for intercrossing by
insects, that self-fertilisation was " injurious," was based on a quite
erroneous deduction altogether. The fact being that in nature
autogamous, or self-fertilised plants, are by far the most prolific,
perfectly healthy, most abundant in individuals, and most widely
dispersed.2

On the other hand, all special adaptations to secure self-
fertilisation are obviously useful, are quite as numerous and
excellent in the adjustment of the organs, as are those for inter-

crossing.3

Now it is worth while observing that the result of such injurious

1 "Origin, etc.," p. 160.

2 The reader is referred (should he require it) to the writer's papers on "Self-
fertilisation," Trans. Linn. Soc. 1877; Review of Darwin's "Cross and Self-fertilisa-
tion of Flowers" in "Gardener's Chronicle" (1877); and "The Origin of Plant
Structures." , .

3 See Kerner & Oliver's "Natural History of Plants;" "Autogamy, vol. n.,

p. 331, n;

1S97] ORIGIN OF SPECIES AMONG PLANTS 169

features may even be the actual extinction of a species ; for it is
conceivable that if a plant cannot set seed by self-fertilisation, and
is not crossed by insects or the wind, it will die out, if it be an
annual or not propagated by its vegetative system. It will thus be
eliminated by natural selection.1 But the process falls within the
subject of the distribution of species, both in time and space, and
has nothing whatever to do with the origination of such harmful
structures ; which, as long as they exist, are regarded as specific or
generic characters.

The survival of the fittest, therefore, and the destruction of the
least fit and incapable to survive, are questions altogether inde-
pendent of the Origination of Structural Variations, upon which
the survival, or destruction in some cases, may actually depend.
The reader must constantly bear in mind Darwin's words which I
again quote, because of their importance : " The direct action of the
conditions of life ... is a totally distinct consideration from the
effects of natural selection . . . [it] has no relation whatever to the
primary cause of any modification of structure." 2 This last is the
sole matter with which I am concerned.

Individual Differences. — These according to Darwin3 and Dr
"Wallace are the chief materials for natural selection to act upon.
As I have already fully discussed this subject in Natural Science i
and pointed out that as a rule they are quite incapable of giving rise
to varietal characters which a systematist would take note of, I need
say no more than invite the reader's careful attention to my article.

I might, however, briefly point out a fallacy in Dr Wallace's
conclusion. He has given numerous tables in his work, " Darwinism,"
and argues that any excess in dimension of an organ from the mean
is eliminated by natural selection ; so that a species keeps its dimen-
sions pretty constant, annually.5 But no intimation is given as to
how great a deviation, in excess or deficiency of the mean, is required
to prove destructive to the creature itself. Experience, however,
shows that both nanism and gigantism are common phenomena in
nature among plants ; in which the customary deviations are vastly
exceeded. Moreover they can be induced to arise under cultivation
coupled with perfect health, fertility and heredity. Therefore, the
whole of this argument falls to the ground.

Supposed Requirements of Natural Selection in the For-
mation of New Varieties. — The primary condition assumed by
Darwin and Dr Wallace is a large population. In order to produce a
new variety these writers tell us that " in the great majority of cases
a new species arises amidst the population of an existing species."

1 "Origin, etc.," p. 57.

2 " Animals and Plants under Domestication," vol. ii., p. 272.

8 " Origin, etc.," p. 34. 4 Vol. vi., p. 385 (1895).

5 Journ. Linn. Soc. {ZouL), vol. xxv., p. 483.

170 NA TUBAL SCIENCE [September

" The greatest clanger," writes Dr Wallace, " to a species under new
and adverse conditions is, that it should not be able to adapt itself
to thein with sufficient rapidity. It is for this reason that, as
Darwin concludes, new species arise from those which have a large
population, which occupy a wide area, and which present much varia-
tion, a combination . . . rarely found except in continental areas." l
How far is this hypothesis borne out by facts ? As a matter of fact
the majority of species of a country have not a large population,
nevertheless many of such species have varied as much as, if not
more, indeed, than the more gregarious species with large popula-
tions ; thus, it is easy to think of plants, of which large populations
exist, generally gregarious, and therefore supplying the primary
condition supposed to be requisite for natural selection ; but the
remarkable feature about them is that they have never been known
to vary ! Thus, Sir J, D. Hooker gives no varieties whatever to any
of the following species, Ranunculus Jicaria, Caltha palustris,
Lychnis diurna, Erica cinerea, Bcllis pcrcnnis, Urtica dioica, Galium,
verum, Scilla nutans, Lemna minor, Pteris aquilina, &c. And
when we cross the channel (though England is really or physically
part of the Continent) we find no more signs of variation there,
whether in France, Germany, Switzerland, the Tyrol, &c.

On the other hand, take an extremely common plant, Polygonum
avictdarc ; though abundant, it is scarcely a social plant, at least, to
the extent of those mentioned. It produces several varieties, but
are they found in the midst of the commonest, say, the roadside
type ? Sir J. D. Hooker says : — " Var. P. littorale (littoral) a
passage to P. maritimum (maritime) ; Var. agrestinum (field
form) ; Var. arenastrum (sand-loving form) ; Var. rurivagum (way-
side form) ; " hence these varieties are not found in the midst of
the commonest form, but away from it, in localities characterised
by special physical features. In other words, these varieties arise
by self-adaptation to their special environments, respectively.

The second condition requisite for variations consists of " changed
conditions of life." Both Darwin and Dr Wallace admit that " a
change of climate and food " is requisite for a new variety to arise
among the parent type. The latter writer says : — " Now let some
important change occur, either in climate, in abundance of food, or
by the irruption of some new and hitherto unknown enemies, a
change which at first injuriously affects the species." 2 Similarly
Darwin writes : — " Let the external conditions of the country alter,"
and again, "take the case of a country undergoing some . . . change."3

The question at once arises, where and when do we find these
changes occurring in, or coming to, any particular district, where
some species with a large population happens to be ? Is nature

1 Lot: cit., p. 484. - Loc. tit., p. 483. 3 "Origin, etc.," p. 63.

1897] ORIGIN OF SPECIES AMONG PLANTS 171

dependent upon geological catastrophes for producing variations in
plants and animals ? Indeed, this would seem to be Darwin's view
in his discussion on geologic time, in which he says : — " It is
probable, as Sir W. Thomson insists, that the world at a very early
period was subjected to more rapid and violent changes in its
physical conditions than those now occurring; and such changes
would have tended to induce changes at a corresponding rate in the
organisms which then existed."1

But when we find that one species will change into another
recognised species under our very eyes, if its environment be altered,
why need one appeal to millions of years for aid ? Dr Wallace,
e.g., notes how " Arabis anchoretica has tissue-papery leaves due
to its growth in hollows in the rock. Seeds of this plant when
cultivated at Kew produced the common species A. alpina. The
same thing occurs with many plants as every cultivator knows."

Darwin and Dr Wallace agree in requiring " rapid adaptation,"
but Darwin admits " that natural selection generally acts with
extreme slowness." 3

Now, if nature has to wait for catastrophes before some
"chanced conditions of life" come to her organisms, is not this
something like trying to bring the mountain to Mahomet, instead
of letting Mahomet walk to the mountain ? Which is easier to
do, to let plants and animals migrate to a place with a different
climate and abundance or deficiency of altered food, rather than
imagine the latter to come to them ?

Migration is so obvious a process that Darwin cannot help
alluding to it, as when he says : — " Among animals which unite for
each birth and are highly locomotive, doubtful forms ranked by one
zoologist as a species and by another as a variety, can rarely be
found within the same country, but are common in separated areas." 4
They have not, therefore, arisen at one common spot.

A new climate and abundance of food are often supplied by
domestication and cultivation, and the anticipated results follow,
viz., variation ad libitum, the consequences also being often heredi-
tary as they are in nature.

Acquired Characters are Hereditary in Plants. — Dr Wal-
lace writes : — " Climate and Food undoubtedly produce modifications
in the individual, but it has not yet been proved that the modifications
are hereditary. If this could be proved the whole discussion on
the heredity of acquired characters would be settled in the
affirmative." 5 But surely cultivation proves it every day ? Our
garden vegetables are all derived from wild plants, and they come
true by seed.

1 "Origin, etc.," p. 286. ■ Natural Science, vol. v. p. 182. 3 "Origin, etc.," p. 84.
4 "Origin, etc.," p. 37. 5 " Darwinism," p. 489.

172 NATURAL SCIENCE [September

What more do we want to prove that acquired characters are
hereditary ? I do not understand what he means when he says : —
" In every case these changes can be interpreted as . . . adapta-
tions or individual, non-hereditary modifications in the case of
plants." 1 That garden races are adaptations to their environment
is obvious, and to say that they cannot be hereditary is, as it seems
to me, to shut one's eyes gratuitously to the most conspicuous facts.
The " Student" Parsnip was "fixed" in five years, i.e., from 1847
to 1852, having been raised by Professor J. Buckman from seed
of the wild plant, and it is still pronounced to be " the best in the
trade " ; its acquired characters have been, therefore, relatively fixed
for half a century, though the plant's variability may never cease
to exist, because no so-called " fixed race " is absolutely stable.
Hence we constantly hear of Mr A's improved race of Mr B's pea,
bean, or what not. Nevertheless, that the typical garden form is
always reproduced, and that its sub-varieties or races come relatively
true by seed, is all that is wanted to establish the truth of acquired
characters being hereditary in plants.

Migration, essential. — With regard to the origin and fixation
of varieties in nature a closer observation shows that, as a rule,
contrary to the Darwinian view, new varieties of plants have not
arisen among the parent types, but away from them. Thus,
Sir J. D. Hooker, who in his knowledge of the geographical distribu-
tion of plants is facile princcjjs, says : — " As a general rule the best
marked varieties occur on the confines of the geographical area which
a species inhabits." 2 Darwin also quotes A. de Candolle's opinion
that " plants which have very wide ranges generally present varieties ;
and this might have been expected (he writes), as they are exposed
to diverse physical conditions." 3 Precisely so ; but then this is
due to migration together with adaptation to the new physical
environments ; for the " diverse physical conditions " do not come
to the plants where the large populations have been supposed to
"row. It is interesting to see that both Darwin and Dr Wallace,
after asserting the importance of large populations ■ among which
new varieties are said to arise, are compelled by facts to admit
precisely the contrary. Thus, both Dr Wallace and Darwin observe
that the struggle for existence will be " most severe between in-
dividuals of the same species ; for they frequent the same districts,
require the same food, and are exposed to the same dangers." Such
is the condition said to be required for natural selection ; but now,
on the contrary, he tells us, " as an effect of this principle [?] we
seldom find closely allied species of animals or plants living together,
but often in distinct though adjacent districts where the conditions

1 Loc. cit., p. 490. 2 " Introductory Essay to the Flora of Tasmania," p. v.

:! "Origin, etc.," p. 43.

1897] ORIGIN OF SPECIES AMONG PLANTS 173

of life are somewhat different," If so, and this statement is quite
in accordance with Sir J. D. Hooker's view already quoted, how
could the varieties have arisen in the midst of the plant type ?
Similarly, Darwin says that mountain breeds always differ from
lowland breeds ; and " a mountainous country would probably affect
the hind limbs from exercising them more, and possibly even the
form of the pelvis," &c. What is all this but the formation of new
varietal structures by a response to the direct or definite action of
the environment ? But, then, it is obvious from Darwin's remarks
that the mountain breeds are not supposed to have arisen among
the lowland forms or vice versd ; just as the submerged forms of
Ranunculus could not have arisen among land buttercups or vice
versa. Consequently Darwin could not shut his eyes to the fact
that " isolation is an important element in the modification of
species." l Again, he says : — " Migration and isolation are necessary
elements for the formation of new species." 2

On the other hand, Dr Wallace says : — " Physical isolation, I
believe with Darwin [?], to be of comparatively little importance,
and to have very rarely been the chief agent in modification."

If migration and isolation, which are only to be secured on
the confines of the geographical area of a species, as Sir J. D.
Hooker says, are so important, then it becomes obvious that the
centre of the parent population is not the place, as a rule, to look
for the origin of a new variety, but as far away from it as possible.
From this it follows that the less struggle for- existence
there be with the parent type, the better it is for the origi-
nation of new varieties; and it is best of all where there
is no struggle at all.

Dr Wallace enquired of two experienced British botanists if
there " are any cases of well-marked varieties, which occupy a con-
siderable area to the exclusion of the parent species, and do not occupy
any area, or only a very small one with the type." 3 One example
of a Rubus was given him ; but a more important question, however,
as it seems to me, would be : — Is a sub-species or variety usually
found within the area occupied by a large number of the parent
type ? Take, e.g., Hicracium, a most variable genus ; of this Sir
J. D. Hooker writes : — " Variable as the genus is, the sequence of
its forms is so natural as to have been recognised by all botanists.
This sequence represents to a considerable extent the spread of the
forms in altitude and area in the British Isles." 4 Now Hicracium
is not a genus with gregarious species ; for though the sub-species
and varieties are very many, the relative quantity of each is not
particularly great anywhere ; and thus, so far from lending any

1 " Origin, etc.," p. SI. 2 " Origin, etc.," p. 82.

3 Loc. cit, p. 494. 4 ' Students' Flora," p. 232.

174 NATURAL SCIENCE [September

countenance to Darwin's idea, that a species must have a numerous
population to produce varieties, the rule seems rather to he that
these two features do not necessarily coincide at all.

Supposed Aids to Natural Selection. — In order to secure
the survival of the fittest, i.e., a new variety among the parent form,
it was perceived that two additional and hypothetical aids were
necessary, viz., (1) some degree of infertility with the parent, and
(2) a rapidity of adaptation.

With regard to the first, all experience goes to prove that it
does not exist ; for when cultivators wish to fix a new race, as of
cabbage, &c, they are obliged to grow it as far as possible away
from the parent stock. Indeed, considering how freely species can
be hybridised, the probability of an offspring refusing to be crossed
by the same species is very small or nil. Neither Darwin nor Dr
Wallace bring forward any examples of infertility with the parent
among plants.

Secondly, a rapidity of adaptation is claimed hypothetically.
This does often really exist, but it is a little uncertain whether
these authors were aware of it. For when a plant finds itself in a
new and markedly different environment, which strongly affects it,
it then grows by self-adaptation in response to the new external
influences : as when passing from water to land, or vice versa ; from
the wild state to the artificial soil of a garden ; from lowlands to
alpine or subarctic localities, &c, as I have shown in " The Origin of
Plant Structures."

The Persistence or non-retention of new varietal
characters. — To come to what Dr Wallace regarded as the
most important point in his paper. Four times does he mention
it, only slightly altering the expression, e.g., he says: — " No attempt
has been made to show, even hypothetically, how, through the
action of known causes, such characters [useless ones], when they
do arise, can become first extended to every individual of a species,
and then be totally obliterated as regards any portion of the species
which may become modified so as to constitute a. new species.
Useful characters thus strictly limited are the necessary and
logical results of modification through survival of the fittest. No
agency has been shown to exist capable of producing useless
characters similarly limited." l As illustrations to meet Dr Wal-
lace's demand, it may be observed that the races of cultivated
pears are spineless ; yet they are derived from the wild Pyrus
communis, which has useless abortive branches as spines. Similarly
is it the case with some varieties of plums derived from Prunus
communis.

With regard to the retention of injurious characters, the

1 Loc. cit., \\ 491.

1897] ORIGIN OF SPECIES AMONG PLANTS 175

obstruction to self-fertilisation produced by the rostellum is
common in orchids, and generally occurs in all the species of
any particular genus. Yet it is obliterated in PKajus blumei,
Chysis aurea, species of Chrysoglossum, Avundinia speciosa, and Evict
flavcscens, &c, so that these species set plenty of good seed by self-
fertilisation, whereas 40,000 blossoms of Dcndvobiwm spcciosum set
one pod. I have already had occasion to allude to the rudimentary
organs of Mercurialis, Erodium, &c., which are retained in all the
species alike.

Is Dr Wallace, therefore, justified in making the above asser-
tion at all, or in demanding that either useful or useless characters
should be limited ? Why should either one or the other be
obliterated when a new variation arises ? The fact that a genus,
which is the result of sufficient variation in a species (unless it be
monotypic), does retain both useful and useless characters in some,
many, or all of its species, shows that there are no grounds for his
statement. Natural selection may demand it, but nature utterly
refuses to be obedient to that theory.

Too great stress is laid upon a necessary fixity, as a proof of
specific characters, by many writers. This is purely a relative
matter. Cultivation has been suggested as a test of a species ; but
this is the very best means of inducing a wild plant to vary, as all
cultivators know. The fixation of any variation is a matter of
time. About five years may, perhaps, be regarded as the average
period under cultivation in " fixing " races : but nothing is known
about wild varieties. In either case the rule is that the environ-
ment must be constant.

Indefinite Variations, non-existent. — This is the second
hypothetical source of new variations according to Darwinians.

With regard to all the offspring varying approximately alike
and not " indiscriminately " (Eomanes) or " indefinitely " (Darwin)
when subjected to changed conditions of life, I wish to emphasise
the fact most strongly that experiments show conclusively that
if seedlings are subjected to a markedly different environment,
when they grow up to maturity, the rule is, that all that do
change, change in precisely the same way. They do not vary
indefinitely among themselves ; so that there is no material here —
any more than with " individual differences " — for natural selection
to act upon. Thus, in cultivating the wild parsnip or carrot, all
the seedlings that change, do so by beginning to assume the same
new characters — viz., an increased size with a greater fleshiness in
the root, larger dimensions of the leaves, reduction of hair, &c,
with a corresponding alteration in the anatomical structures.

So, too, if the seeds of an amphibious plant as Bamtnculus
heterophyllus be sown in a garden border, all grow absolutely alike

176 NATURAL SCIENCE [September

in adaptation to the aerial medium. Numerous other illustrations
could be given.1

I think it must be from not being aware of the abundance of
evidence of this sort, that the idea arose that all the offspring did
not acquire the same characters when the external conditions were
changed.

Dr Wallace doubts it because, he says, " the argument is, that
the same causes will always produce the same or closely similar
results. But this is only true when the same causes act upon
identical materials and under identical conditions."2 Dr
Wallace is mistaken in supposing that nature pays any attention
to " individual differences " which occur between any number of
plants of the same kind. It is not a question of argument, but
of facts. These differences are of no moment whatever when
self-adaptation is required to take place. The external influences
cause all the individuals to change alike in the same direction, and
utterly ignore the various dimensions among the " individual differ-
ences " described above. The result is that the same facies is ac-
quired by all the individuals, though a new set of individual differences
may readily be found among the individuals of the new variety.

Secondly, besides doubting the occurrence of the same definite
variations in the whole of the offspring subjected to new but
similar external conditions, Dr Wallace adds : — " It must do more
than this, for it must produce a variation so exceptionally stable
that it constantly recurs in all the offspring of successive genera-
tions, even though those offsprings are subjected to considerable
change of conditions." 3

But the stability of a species, I repeat, is a purely relative
matter and depends upon time. Some plants are very plastic,
others are not so, some variations may become very (but never
absolutely) rigidly fixed, while others may refuse to be reproduced
by seed with any certainty at all. Not only is this true when the
plant is propagated by seed but it is also true for vegetative multi-
plication. Tulips, &c, introduced from the East, though they have
presumably been constant in form for unknown ages, yet often
become unrecognisable in three years though propagated by bulbils
only ; apple trees, though propagated by grafts alone have given rise
to numerous varieties ; even different kinds of apples raised on
stocks, but grown in the same States of N. America, respectively,
often bear fruit of approximately the same form.4 On the other
hand the Jerusalem artichoke, asparagus, sea-kale and celery oiler

1 The reader is again referred to " The Origin of Plant Structures'' for further
details.

'-' Loc. cit., p. 488. :! hoc. cit., p. 489.

4 "Hud Variation and Evolution," Natural Science, vol. vii., p. 103. An essay in
Mr Bailey's work "The Survival of the Unlike," 1896.

1S97] ORIGIN OF SPECIES AMONG PLANTS 177

but little variations to select from. Of common vegetables, parsnips,
carrots, radishes, Brassica oleracea, &c, have supplied numerous
varieties which come true by seed ; though each may still furnish
an improved " race."

Similarly, if a useless character be acquired among cultivated
plants, not only may it occur in every individual but it may become
hereditary and relatively fixed ; just as in the examples of wild
plants already mentioned. Thus, there is no special advantage in
the mere variety of colouring of flowers as of pansies, nor in double
flowers, nor in excess of neuter flowers of composites, nor in the
abortive pedicels of the feather hyacinth, &c.

With regard to the fixation of characters, therefore, there is no
absolute rule whatever, nor can we say why one plant is so plastic
and another refractory.

Nature recognises no "must" in her processes.1

Darwinism, an Unverified and Unverifiable Deduc-
tion.— It is a common statement that Darwin placed the Doctrine
of Evolution on a scientific basis when he pronounced the theory of
" The Origin of Species by means of Natural Selection." It is against
this statement. that I would venture to protest most strongly. To
take the latest example, Ludwig von Graff says : — " The selection
theory of the celebrated Englishman, Darwin, first based the idea
upon a scientific foundation. The obvious phenomena of heredity
and of variability are the foundations of his bold system, the axles
of life's mechanism ; and the motive power of this mechanism is the
struggle of all living things for the preservation and procreation of
life."2

Darwin's theory, however, as stated in the title of his book,
;< The Origin of Species by means of Natural Selection," is a pure
deduction; and deductions (i.e., a priori reasoning), though useful
as working hypotheses are not scientific or useless, until they
have been verified by induction and experiments.

The theory was based on two primary deductions ; out of these
secondary ones followed. They were, first, that " Individual Differ-
ences " could supply materials for natural selection to act upon;
secondly, that when offspring of any species varied under the action
of new conditions of life, they generally varied indefinitely, so afford-
ing fresh material for natural selection. It has been shown that
both of these fundamental assumptions are groundless.

As an illustration of his deductive method of reasoning, let us
take the following typical passage which states Darwin's theory
clearly and concisely : —

1 Dr Weismann says : — " Doubt is the parent of progress ;" yet in about a page and a
half of Nature (June 11, 1896), in an epitome of his theory, he uses the word " Must"
fourteen times !

2 Natural Science, vol. ix., p. 193.

178 NATURAL SCIENCE [September

" It may metaphorically be said that natural selection is daily
and hourly scrutinising, throughout the world, the slightest varia-
tions ; rejecting those that are bad, preserving and adding up all
that are good." l This, as far as the origin of species is concerned,
is a pure assumption ; and what I contend for is, that since observa-
tion and experiment show conclusively that variations can arise
rapidly under one's very eyes, there is no need to assume any other
process whatever than the protoplasmic response to environ-
ments. Thus, rhizomes are often recognised as being of specific or
other diagnostic value, but when an aerial stem is made to grow
underground, its new growth at once begins to assume the charac-
ters of an ordinary rhizome. Eoots, stems and leaves normally
living submerged have characters which are at once more or less
assumed by a terrestrial plant if it be made to grow in water, and
vice versd ; or if a water plant send a shoot into the air the change
is abrupt at the level of the water. Plants in damp places are often
very different as a whole from those in excessively dry situations.
Ee verse their positions and each at once begins to assume the
characters of the other as soon as they grow in response to their
surroundings. If lowland plants or their seeds be grown in
high alpine regions they at once assume the facies of normal
alpine plants. The markedly peculiar features of desert plants at
once begin to break clown, when a normally desert plant is grown
in ordinary soil, just as the wild carrot or parsnip may quickly
acquire the characteristic features of the cultivated form.

If Darwin had fully realised the significance of these and such
like facts, he could hardly have continued the above passage with
the following words : — " We see nothing of these slow changes in
progress, until the hand of time has marked the lapse of ages ; and
then so imperfect is our view into long past geological ages, that we
see only that the forms of life are now different from what they
formerly were." 2 That all this is due to natural selection is
simply an unverified deduction.

Self-adaptation, by Response to the Definite Action of
Changed Conditions of Life, the True Origin of Species. —
That plants vary by self-adaptation to a new environment is proved
by inductive evidence and amply verified by experiment.

Let me repeat. — The struggle for life is incessant. Apart from
ill-luck, which applies to all alike, the weaker in constitution are
often expunged, while the stronger survive and the general dis-
tribution of plants in time and space is the result. This however,
as Darwin insisted, is a quite different thing from the origin of
species.

The origin of species is due, for the most part, or as a broad

1 " Origin, otcA" p. 05. 2 " Origin, etc.," p. 66.

1897] ORIGIN OF SPECIES AMONG PLANTS 179

general rule : first, to migration and isolation from the parent type,
with as much freedom from the struggle for existence as possible ;
secondly, to self-adaptation by the inherent power of response in
living protoplasm, excited by the physical influences of the new
environment. The result is for the most part new structures in
harmony with the new environment. If there be a thousand
seedlings of one and the same plant which germinate and grow
together, they will all put on, more or less, the same features under
the same definite action of the same surroundings ; though individual
differences will still be found among them as before.

Conclusion. — Lastly, the answer to the question which heads
this paper is that natural selection plays no part in originating new
varieties, nor is it required as " means " or an aid in the origin of
species ; but is all-sufficient in the distribution of plants.

Now the above conclusion is practically admitted by Dr
Wallace himself, in the following sentence : — " Should they [fixed
varieties of plants] be found to occur more frequently in other
countries [i.e., ' Representative plants,' which are indeed innumer-
able] as varieties of birds, mammals, and reptiles, &c, occur in
separate areas in North America — they may be usually
explained as adaptations to very different climatic condi-
tions, in which case the distinguishing characters will be
utilitarian [or otherwise] and the local varieties will be really
incipient species." The passage I have spaced represents pre-
cisely the views expressed in this paper. Darwin, too, admits the
possibility of the origin of species without the aid of natural selec-
tion. His words are as follows : — " By the term definite action, 1
mean an action of such a nature that, when many individuals of
the same variety are exposed during several generations to any
change in their physical conditions of life, all, or nearly all the
individuals are modified in the same manner. A new sub-variety
would thus be produced without the aid of natural selection." *

Lastly, this was the conclusion of Mr Herbert Spencer, in 1852,
seven years before Darwin and Dr Wallace superadded natural
selection as an aid in the origin of species. He saw no necessity
for anything beyond the natural power of change with adaptation ;
and I venture now to add my own testimony, based upon upwards
of a quarter of a century's observations and experiments, which
have convinced me that Mr Spencer was right and Darwin was
wrong. His words are as follows : — " The supporters of the
development hypothesis can show . . . that any existing species,
animal or vegetable, when placed under conditions different from
its prervious ones, immediately begins to undergo certain changes of
structure fitting it for the new conditions . . . that in the

1 "Animals and Plants under Domestication," vol. ii., p. 271.

180 NATURAL SCIENCE [September

successive generations these changes continue until ultimately the
new conditions become the natural ones. . . . They can show that
throughout all organic nature there is at work a modifying, influence
of the kind they assign as the causes of specific differences ; an
influence which, though slow in its action, does in time, if the
circumstances demand it, produce marked changes." x

All, therefore, I ask of my readers is to weigh well the evidence
that has been again of late years brought forward in favour of
adaptation in lieu of natural selection as the means by which
varieties originate ; and not to be biassed by, it may be, many
years of conviction that Darwinism was all-sufficient. It is solely
a question of evidence, and as the doctrine of evolution ultimately
broke down men's faith in Creation by " Fiats " and the
Argument of Design, so it is hoped that before this century closes,
it will be seen that Darwin's deduction of " The Origin of Species
by Means of Natural Selection " was a most unfortunate one, as it
is quite incapable of verification ; while the conclusion of Mr
Herbert Spencer has been abundantly verified, both by inductive
evidence and experimental proof. Geokge Henslow.

i i<

Essay on The Development Hypothesis," 1852.

575.8 181

III

Reproductive Divergence : An Additional Factor

in Evolution

SOME ten years ago the late G. J. Komanes propounded his theory
of Physiological Selection,1 which was founded on the fact that
certain individuals of a species, though fertile with some, may be
perfectly sterile with other individuals. Supposing such incom-
patibility to run through a whole race, then these varieties,
separated by a physiological barrier from the rest of the members
of the species, would be preserved, and might vary independently,
and so become gradually split off from the parent species in respect
of other characteristics as well.

This theory has not been generally received, and Wallace, in
particular, has demonstrated 2 very clearly that in the form - pro-
pounded by its author the theory cannot stand. Nevertheless, the
theory served to draw attention to the importance of variations in
the reproductive powers of organisms as a factor in evolution, and
to emphasise certain unexplained difficulties in the theory of natural
selection, more especially with reference to the sterility of first
crosses between species, coupled with the fertility of those between
varieties, the swamping effects of intercrossing, and the frequent
inutility of specific characters.

In the present paper I wish to bring forward a theory which is
also concerned with variations in the reproductive powers of organ-
isms as an important factor in evolution, but which is essentially
different from that propounded by Eomanes. This theory may be
enunciated as follows. Supposing that among the members of
any species, those individuals, more alike, in respect of
any characteristic, such as colour, form or size, are slightly
more fertile inter se than less similar individuals, it
necessarily follows that in the course of succeeding
generations the members of this species will diverge more
and more in respect of the characteristic in question,
whereby ultimately the original species may be split up
into two or more fresh species.

This principle I have ventured to call " Reproductive Diverg-
ence." It is best illustrated by a concrete example. Supposing

1 Journ. Linn. Soc. (Zool.), vol. xix., p. 337, 1886.

2 "Darwinism," p. 180.

182 NATURAL SCIENCE [September

that in the Lepidopterous Ithania urolina, an insect found in the
Amazon valley, small individuals were slightly more fertile with
other small individuals than with larger individuals, whilst these
were also more fertile inter se, then it would follow that fewer
individuals of intermediate size would be produced, and in course of
time the species would be split up into a small and a large variety.
These varieties would continue to diverge as long as the principle
of " reproductive divergence " was acting, till at length they might
become differentiated into two mutually sterile species. Supposing,
on the other hand, this variation in fertility were correlated with
slight differences of colour, then in course of time varieties differing
in respect of colour would be produced, or if it were correlated with
both size and colour, varieties differing in respect of both charac-
teristics might be produced. As a matter of fact, this insect does
actually occur as four distinct varieties, differing in colour, form and
size,1 though whether in consequence of the operation of repro-
ductive divergence, it is of course impossible to say.

It will be observed that the theory enunciated is made up of
two parts, the first of which can only be verified by experiment,
whilst the second is the statement of a fact, which is capable of
mathematical demonstration. This we will now proceed to afford.

Let a certain number of individuals of a species, say 900 males
and 900 females, be divided up into three groups, according to their
size. Let there be 300 small males, #,300 medium sized ones, M,
and 300 large ones, L. Let the 900 females be similarly divided
up into the three groups, s, m and I. In order to maintain the
number of individuals constant in each generation, let it be granted
that any number of males and females breeding together give rise
to the same number of males and females. Then if these 900
males and females be allowed to breed together, on an average 100
small males, S, will breed with 100 small females, s, and 100 male
and female offspring, Ss, will arise. Similarly also there will be
100 male and female offspring, Sm, and 100 SI. Again, with
reference to the medium sized males, there will be 100 male and
female, Ms, Mm, and Ml offspring ; and with reference to the large
sized males, 100 male and female, Ls, Lm and LI offspring. Now
let it be granted that the offspring SI and Ls are of the same size
as Mm, and that Sm and Lm are respectively of the same size as
Ms and Ml. Then as the result of the chance breeding of the 900
males and females, we shall have the following numbers of individuals
of each sex formed : —

100 Ss, 200 Sm, 300 Mm, 200 Ml, 100 LI.

Now let us suppose that the comparative fertility of the various
sized individuals is slightly changed, so that the principle of " repro-
1 H. W. Bates, Trans. Linn. Soc, 1862, p. 545.

1897] REPRODUCTIVE DIVERGENCE 183

ductive divergence" may come into operation. Let 100 individuals
breeding with similar sized individuals, give birth to 120 offspring
of either sex instead of 100, whilst 100 individuals breeding with
moderately smaller or larger individuals (i.e., M and m breeding with
s and S or I and L) give birth to, on an average, only 95 offspring,
and 100 individuals breeding with considerably smaller or larger
individuals (i.e., S or L breeding with / or s) give birth to only 80
offspring of either sex. Then it will be found that the 900 males
and females breeding together will give birth to the following : —
120 Ss, 190 Sm, 280 Mm, 190 Ml, 120 LI,

That is to say, whilst the largest and smallest individuals have
increased in numbers by 20 per cent., the medium sized ones have
decreased by 7 per cent, and the ones intermediate between these
by 5 per cent. The fact that the medium sized individuals have
decreased in number, in spite of the 100 M and m individuals which
breed together having produced 120 Mm, offspring, is of course due to
the fact that only 160 Mm individuals are produced by the crossing
of the 100 S and 100 L individuals with the 100 / and s.

In a similar manner, in succeeding generations, the numbers of
individuals intermediate in size will gradually become smaller and
smaller, whilst those of the extreme ones will increase. But, it
may be said, even then the two varieties thus formed will not
differ in size to a greater extent than the extreme individuals in the
original 1800 taken. This is not the case. Thus supposing the
three groups of individuals were respectively on an average 65'5,
68*5 and 71 '5 inches in length, the extremes among the small
individuals being 64 and 67 inches, those amongst the medium 67
and 70 inches, and those among the large 70 and 73 inches.
Then suppose that by the principle of reproductive divergence the
individuals were separated into two groups "of an average of 64 and
73 inches in length. Then it follows that these groups would
(approximately) contain individuals varying between 6 2 '5 and 65*5
inches, and 71'5 and 74*5 inches respectively. That is to say,
considerably smaller and considerably larger individuals would be
formed than were originally present. Also if the principle of
reproductive divergence continues to act amongst the two varieties
of the original species formed, the individuals will continue diverg-
ing more and more in respect of this characteristic, with which the
reproductive power of the organism is correlated. Also, if it be
granted, that on an average, the more widely any two individuals
differ in size, the greater is the relative degree of sterility between
them, it follows that in course of time the individuals of the two
varieties will become mutually sterile : or in other words, that from
the original species two new species will have arisen.

Having demonstrated the correctness of the second part of the

184 NATURAL SCIENCE [September

hypothesis enunciated, it remains to bring forward experimental
evidence of the validity of the first part — i.e., it is necessary to
prove that in some cases more closely similar individuals of a species
show greater mutual fertility than less similar ; in other words, that
there may be a partial sterility between varieties. On this point
Darwin has collected a considerable amount of evidence in his
" Variation of Animals and Plants under Domestication." x A few
of the cases mentioned there may be now cited. Thus Gartner
found that a variety of dwarf maize, bearing yellow seed, showed a
considerably diminished fertility with a tall maize having red seed,
though both varieties were perfectly fertile when crossed inter se.
Again, in the genus Verbascum, numerous experiments were made by
Gartner with the white and yellow varieties of V. lychnitis and V.
blattaria, he finding that crosses between similarly coloured flowers
yielded more seed than those between dissimilarly coloured flowers.
These experiments have been repeated and extended by Scott with
confirmatory results. Again, Girou de Buzareingues crossed three
varieties of the gourd, and concluded that their mutual fertilisation
is less easy in proportion to the difference which they present.
Still again, the blue and red varieties of pimpernel, which are con-
sidered by most botanists as varieties, were found by Gartner to be
quite sterile when crossed.

With regard to members of the animal kingdom, there is very little
evidence. Such as there is, is related only to domesticated animals,
and can be at once objected to on the ground that it merely shows
that the animals in question are descended from two or more dis-
tinct species. Thus Youatt 2 states that longhorn and shorthorn
cattle, when crossed, show a diminished fertility. This statement
has, however, been denied by Wilkinson.

The evidence determinable from certain anthropological data is,
on the other hand, of more value. Thus Professor Broca has brought
forward evidence 3 that some races of man show diminished fertility
together. Again, according to statistics collected in Prussia from
1875 to 1890, it was found that Protestants, Catholics and Jews,
marrying among themselves, had, on an average, respectively 4'35,
5-24 and 4*21 children. When, however, the husband was a Jew
and the wife a Protestant or Catholic, the numbers of children were
only 1*58 and 1*38 respectively; and when the wife was a Jewess
and the husband a Protestant or Catholic, only 1*78 and 1*66 re-
spectively. Whether this apparent partial sterility was due to
differences of race or to social reasons it was impossible to say.4
Still again, from the natality tables of Korosi,6 which are calculated

1 2nd ed., vol. ii. p. 82. s " Cattle," p. 202.

3 " On the Phenomena of Hybridity in the Genus Homo." 1864.

4 Quoted from Mayo Smith's "Statistics of Sociology," p. 115.

5 " Phil. Trans.," 1895, B. 781.

1397] REPRODUCTIVE DIVERGENCE 185

from the marriage statistics of 81,000 couples in Buda-Pesth, it is
possible to obtain evidence supporting our theory. Thus from these
figures one may see that parents of similar ages are more fertile inter se
than parents of dissimilar ages. With very young mothers the most
fertile fathers are, on an average, from three to six years in advance
as to age ; but with increasing years of the mothers the ages of the
fathers become less and less in excess, till at about thirty years of age
they coincide. At greater ages they gradually become slightly in defect.
Though this greater mutual fertility of individuals like in respect of
age can be of no influence in modifying the species, or splitting it
up into varieties, yet it gives us reasonable ground to suppose that
the fertility may also be found on examination to be greater with
individuals similar in respect of some other characteristic. In such
a case there would be a tendency for two or more varieties to be
formed, unless there were some other agency counteracting it.

It will be seen that the evidence adduced in favour of a partial
sterility sometimes existing between varieties of a species is, in the
case of animals at least, very meagre. The reason of this is not far
to seek. Thus wild animals, when placed in confinement, will not,
in the majority of cases, breed at all. Domesticated animals, on the
other hand, do not afford evidence of much value, for the reason
given above. Also, it is generally held that domestication of itself
tends to increase fertility, and so would overcome any tendency to
sterility of varieties.

In order to obtain evidence as to the existence of- a diminished
fertility between varieties, I have made a considerable number of
observations on the effects of crossing the various colour varieties
of the sea urchins, Sphaerechimbs gramdaris and Strongyloccntrotus
lividus, and have found that from a given number of ova the num-
ber of blastulae and the number of larvae subsequently produced
are appreciably smaller for crosses of dissimilar colour varieties than
for those of similar ones. Also, the larvae produced are, on an aver-
age, about 5 per cent, smaller. As, however, it will be necessary
to repeat these observations a large number of times before the
proof of such a partial sterility can be considered quite unexception-
able, and as moreover I hope to be able to make similar series of
observations among other classes of the Animal Kingdom, it would
be premature at this point to refer to these investigations at any
greater length.

It should be borne in mind that the theory of Reproductive
Divergence does not require that there should be a partial sterility
between the varieties of species in all cases, or in even the majority
of cases. It merely premises that such sterility does exist in cer-
tain instances, and that in these the members of the species will
gradually become more and more divergent in respect of one or more

186 NATURAL SCIENCE [September

characteristics, unless of course other causes are at work counter-
acting its influence. Probably in the majority of cases, in most
stable species in fact, there is no such variability of fertility between
slightly differing individuals, and hence there is, from this cause, no
tendency to the formation of more or less distinct varieties. Very
probably, however, there is a latent possibility of such a variability of
reproductive power arising in almost any species, when for instance
some of its members are exposed to fresh environmental conditions,
in consequence of migration or change of climate. If this is so,
then a species will tend to split up into varieties just at the most
opportune moment, the varieties thus formed becoming by the action
of Natural Selection gradually more and more adapted to their sur-
roundings, and so fresh species produced. That change of environ-
mental conditions has a very great influence on the reproductive
powers of both animals and plants is a well-known fact, and one on
which Darwin has collected much valuable evidence.1

It now remains to be demonstrated how the theory of reproduc-
tive divergence can successfully account for some of the chief objec-
tions which have been brought against the theory of Natural Selec-
tion, objections indeed which have been of considerable weight in
deciding many scientists against the doctrine of the all-sufficiency of
Natural Selection as the cause of Evolution.

The fact of the very general infertility of crosses between species
and their hybrid offspring, coupled with that of the fertility of
crosses between varieties, and of their mongrel offspring, was recog-
nised by Darwin as a formidable objection. Though this distinction
between species and varieties is now recognised as not of such uni-
versality as it was formerly believed to be, yet it is still admitted to
be a difficulty hitherto by no means adequately accounted for. The
theory of reproductive divergence offers a most satisfactory and con-
vincing explanation. Thus according to it, as we have seen, varieties
and ultimately new species have, in many cases at least, been formed
by the operation of a slight and accumulating sterility between
unlike individuals, whereby two or more groups of individuals be-
come more and more segregated, and so capable of undergoing inde-
pendent variation. This divergence of species takes place quite
independently of Natural Selection, but this principle can always be
exerting its action at the same time, whereby the new or modified
characteristics produced can, if useful to the species, be accumulated
and rendered better adapted to the environmental conditions.
Whether the very general sterility of crosses between species is
due originally in most or in all cases to reproductive divergence, or
whether it came into operation but seldom, it is not as yet possible
to say. If extended series of experiments show that it is in fairly

1 " Variation of Animals and Plants nnder Domestication," vol. ii., pp. 130-149.

1897] REPRODUCTIVE DIVERGENCE 187

frequent operation in those species having a tendency to split up
into varieties, it may be concluded that it was, and is, an extremely
important factor in the production of sterility of crosses between
species. Thus, as has already been mentioned, it is not supposed
that reproductive divergence comes into effect in fixed and stable
species, but only in those which, probably in consequence of changes
of conditions of environment, are in the course of splitting up into
varieties and new species.

Connected with the fact of the general mutual fertility of varie-
ties, is that of the swamping effects of intercrossing. Thus if
varieties are perfectly fertile with the parent form, it is difficult to
see how they can ever establish themselves as incipient species,
unless they become separated from the parent form by a geographi-
cal or other barrier. If, however, these varieties have arisen in
consequence of the operation of reproductive divergence, it is obvious
that they can preserve their characteristics unobliterated, and con-
tinue to exist in the same region as the parent form.

One of the most important objections to the doctrine of the all-
sufficiency of Natural Selection as a cause of evolution, is that of
the very frequent inutility of specific characters. Some naturalists,
especially Wallace, are inclined to maintain that all specific charac-
ters are of use, and that it is only due to our ignorance that they
appear to us useless. It is a more generally received opinion, on
the other hand, that these characters can frequently be of no useful
purpose to the organism, and must therefore have originated by some
other means than Natural Selection. Darwin himself was fully
alive to this objection, and considered that such useless specific
characters might owe their origin to the correlation of organs, or to
the laws of growth, and to so-called spontaneous variability.1 These
seem but very inefficient causes for such frequently occurring effects,
and hence there is a strong prima facie evidence that some other
principle is at work. The principle of reproductive divergence offers
a satisfactory solution of the problem. Thus, as we have seen, by
means of it species are caused to diverge in respect of one or more
characteristics, and so fresh or altered characteristics can be originated
without the influence of Natural Selection. To take a concrete in-
stance, one mentioned by Bateson.2 The commonest forms of lady-
birds are the small Coccinella dcccmpunctata, and the larger C.
scptempundata. The small insect is very variable in colour and
the pattern of its colours, whilst the large is almost absolutely con-
stant in these respects. This difference in specific characters may
have originated by a common parent form having had its colour
marking, and also the size of the individuals to a slight extent corre-

1 "Origin of Species," 6tli ed., p. 171.

- " Materials for the Study of Variation," p. 572.

188 NATURAL SCIENCE [September

lated with reproductive power. After the splitting up of this parent
form into a large and a small species, in each of which the colour
marking was invariable, the variations in fertility in the larger form,
as correlated with colour marking, may have ceased, owing perhaps
to the conditions of environment having changed from a variable to
a more constant state, and the species would now become constant
in this respect. The smaller form, on the other hand, may still be
in the course of splitting up into two or more other species, differing
in respect of colour marking, and maybe, of other characteristics.

Another not fully explained question with regard to the origin
of species is that of the divergence of character. Why is it that
in the course of evolution, species have widened out into diverse
branches, and have not continued in merely linear series ? This
question of divergence has been examined somewhat fully by
Gulick.1 Darwin seeks to answer the question " from the simple
circumstance that the more diversified the descendants from any
one species become in structure, constitution, and habits, by so
much will they be better enabled to seize on many and widely
diversified places in the economy of nature, and so be enabled to
increase in numbers." 2 As Komanes points out,3 this argument is,
however, assailable in one particular, i.e., it ignores the fact of the
swamping effects of intercrossing. Thus, in Darwin's own words,
it is where specific forms " jostle each other most closely " in an
overstocked area that Natural Selection will be enabled to act most
favourably on any members which may depart from the common
type. Now, any varieties formed under these conditions by the
splitting up of a species will be almost inevitably swamped by
their mutual intercrossing, unless there be some degree of sterility
between them. Under these conditions, therefore, reproductive
divergence can act at a great advantage, as not only can it
originate varieties, but by the mere fact of so doing it ensures
these varieties not being eliminated by the swamping effects of
their mutual intercrossing.

It is unnecessary on this occasion to show how the theory of
reproductive divergence may be applied to the other questions anil
difficulties connected with the theory of Natural Selection as an
explanation of the mechanism of the origin of species. Suffice it
to say that to some points in connection with Geographical Distri-
bution, with the origin of rudimentary organs and other questions,
it offers most material aid. The objections to the theory itself, as
far as they present themselves to me, seem to be but few, and of
but little weight. One of the most obvious is the frequently made
statement, that crosses between varieties generally produce indi-

1 Jourv. Linn. Roc. (Zool.), vol. xx., p. 189.

2 " The Origin of Species," p. 87. 3 Loc. cit., p. 385.

1897] REPRODUCTIVE DIVERGENCE 189

victuals of greater vigour and fitness than the parents. As far as I
am aware, there is no evidence to show that this greater vigour is
the result of the differences of morphological form, but rather that
it is due to the individuals being descended from different stocks,
whereby the evil effects of in-and-in breeding are avoided, or to
being exposed to differences of environmental conditions, whereby
they may perhaps be rendered physiologically unlike individuals
to a slight degree, rather than morphologically unlike. That mere
exposure to differences of environmental conditions may be sufficient
to give rise to a vigorous race even when this is propagated by the
closest in-and-in breeding, is shown by the case of the rabbits on
the Island of Porto Santo, all of which are descended from a single
pregnant individual.

Another objection which might be raised is, that in the case of
both plants and animals it has frequently been found that varieties
showing considerable differences of external form are perfectly
fertile inter sc. Even if this is the case, it is no argument against
the theory of reproductive divergence, for it was specially men-
tioned that this is not supposed to be invariably in operation when
a species is in course of splitting up into varieties. At the same
time, it may reasonably be doubted whether this statement as to
the perfect fertility of varieties is a fact, because a very slight
degree of sterility would easily escape notice unless extensive series
of breeding experiments were made, and careful records kept.

H. M. Vernon.

568 190 [September

IV
On the Restoration of some Extinct Reptiles

THE exhibition of large diagrams in museum cases has met with
the disapproval of many who are in a position to give an
authoritative opinion ; but, by way of justification of such a practice,
it may be pointed out that it frequently happens in a museum
that, since it is only possible in rare instances to have cases
specially made to accommodate definite series of specimens, spaces
will occur which are a source of much trouble to the curators ; and
diagrams, from their elasticity of size, can always be relied upon
to fill what must otherwise be left blank. It is just such a
difficulty that has to be confronted in planning out some of the
cases at the Natural History Museum. The wall-cases, for instance,
on the south side of the third Bay on the left-hand side of the
Entrance Hall are devoted to the elucidation of the more important
features which are made use of in the classification of reptiles, and
contain stuffed specimens, casts, and skeletons, articulated and
disarticulated, of representative members of each order. But the
cases are ten feet in height, and the upper compartments are too
far removed from the eye of the observer, and too badly lighted, to
admit of the recognition of much detail in the specimens exhibited
there. The framework of the back of the case, also, is too slight
to bear heavy specimens, and it is here, if anywhere, that the
exhibition of wall-diagrams is justified.

As complete skeletons of extinct reptiles of such a size as to
fit conveniently into these wall -cases without crowding out the
recent members of the class, or being lost among them by reason
of their diminutive size, are almost impossible to obtain ; and as
the disjointed parts of the skeleton of these extinct forms are
efficiently represented either by actual specimens or by casts in
the table-case, it was, when recently planning out this wall-case,
considered sufficient for the purposes of the Index Collection to
represent the Ornithosauria, the Ichthyopterygia, the Sauropterygia,
and the Anomodontia by bold diagrams of the whole skeleton of
one selected species of each, drawn to such a size as to fill the
four top spaces. The diagrams, which have now been completed
and are exhibited in the cases, measure about 27 inches in
height, and 41 inches in breadth. They are bold outline dia-

1897]

RESTORATION OF EXTINCT REPTILES

191

grams, in black lines on a white ground, executed by Miss G. M.
Woodward with the artistic skill and excellence of technique which
invariably characterise her work.

The species chosen to represent the Order Ornithosauria is
Dimorphodon macronyx, from the Lower Lias of Lyme Eegis (Fig 1).
Owen's well-known restoration of this species (" Liassic Eeptilia,"
Mm. Pal Soc, 1870, pi. 20., and "Hist. Brit. Foss. Rept.," 1 849-84,
vol. iv., pi. 17), naturally formed the basis of the diagram, but
the shapes and proportions of the bones were taken from the
actual specimens, of which the Geological Department of the
museum can boast a good many.1 The correctness of Owen's
restoration of the pelvis was severely criticised by Seeley in 1891

Fig. 1. Dimorphodon macronyx, from the Lower Lias of Lyme Regis, (x').

(Ann. and Mag. Nat, Hist., ser. G, vol. vii., pp. 235-255), and
recourse was had to figures 11 and 13 of this paper when drawing
the pelvic region of the skeleton. The pteroid bone, or backwardly
directed metacarpal of the rudimentary thumb, which is incorrectly
shown on the ulnar side of the limb in Owen's figure, was in-
troduced from the specimen (E. 1034) in the Geological Gallery,
and the details of the caudal vertebrae from specimen (41346),
figured by Owen in the " Liassic Eeptilia " (pi. 19, fig. 4). Since the
back part of the skull is crushed in the Natural History Museum
specimens of Dimorphodon, the outlines of the quadrate bone and
the supra-temporal and lateral temporal fossae were added from

1 The more complete skeletons were described and figured by Bucklaud, Owen,
and others, and references to the descriptions and figures are to be found in the Brit.
Mus. Cat, Foss. Beptilia, part i., pp. 37-39.

192 NATURAL SCIENCE [September

Newton's figures of the skull of the allied genus Sccqthognathus
(Phil. Trans. 1888, B. pi. 77 and 78). There appears to be
no palaeontological evidence to warrant the great length which
Owen gave to the hindermost ribs in his restoration, and these
have, therefore, been considerably shortened, so that the contour
of the ventral abdominal wall now passes evenly from the ribs
to the ischial bones of the pelvis. So little is yet known con-
cerning the coracoids and sternum of Ornithosauria that, beyond
representing the sternum as keeled and as articulating with the
first few ribs, but little has here been attempted.

Of the four restorations which form the subject of the present
article the greatest interest probably centres around that of
Ichthyosaurus, inasmuch as the recent additions to our knowledge
of this genus have rendered possible a very complete restoration.
The species chosen is Ichthyosaurus communis from the Lower Lias
of Lyme Regis, and the specimens which form the basis of the
reconstruction are those in the Geological Gallery bearing the
register numbers (41849) and (2000,1*). This is the same
species as that of the well-known restoration of Owen's (" Anat. of
Vert.," vol. i., 1866, p. 170). An illustrated summary of recent
papers on the Ichthyopterygia has already appeared in the pages of
this journal (Lydekker, Nat. Sci., vol. i., 1892, pp. 514-521), and
in this article is reproduced Fraas's figure of the wonderfully well-
preserved specimen of Ichthyosaurus quaclriscissus, showing the
complete outline of the body and affording incontrovertible evidence
of the presence of a bilobed tail with the vertebral column running
down the ventral lobe, and the existence of a series of irregular
integumentary fins along the back (Fraas, Ncues Jahrb. f. Mineral.,
1892, Bd. 2, pp. 87-90). These details are reproduced in the
present restoration (Fig. 2), and, while the proportionate size and
the details of the paddle skeleton are taken from the specimens of
Ichthyosaurus communis above specified, the postaxial flap of the
paddle, not supported by skeletal parts, is added from Fraas's figure,
from the museum specimen of Ichthyosaurus intermedins (R. 1664),
described and figured by Lydekker (Gcol. Mag., dec. 3, vol. vi.,*1889,
pp. 388-390), and from Owen's figure of the paddle of Ichthyosaurus
communis (?) (" Liassic Reptilia," part hi., 1881, pi. 28, fig. 5). The
outline and details of the skull were introduced mainly from speci-
mens (39492) and (R. 1164) of Ichthyosaurus communis, both of
which exhibit a very complete side view of the skull. In none of
the specimens of Ichthyosaurus communis at the Natural History
Museum are the bones of the pectoral girdle undisturbed, so that in
restoring this part of the skeleton the shapes of the constituent
bones were taken from specimen (41848), but their mutual relations
from the very complete girdle which the museum possesses of

1S97]

RESTORATION OF EXTINCT REPTILES

193

1-3

O
■^>

194 NATURAL SCIENCE [September

Oplithahnosaurus icenieus (B. 2137), described and figured by Seeley
(Proc. Roy. Soc, vol. liv., 1893, fig. 1, p. 151). No such difficulty
beset the restoration of the pelvis, since the parts are hardly at all
displaced in specimen (41849).

The diagram of the Plesiosaur is mainly based on the splendid
specimen of Plcsiosaurus rostratus from the Lower Lias of Char-
mouth, Dorsetshire, exhibited in the Geological Gallery of the
Museum, and bearing the register number (38525). This specimen
was described and figured by Owen in his " Liassic Eeptilia "
(Sauroptcrygia, 1865, pi. 9), but it did not form the basis of his
well-known text-book restoration of Plcsiosaurus (" Anat. of Vert.,"
vol. i., 1866, p. 52), the species of which, according to Lydekker
(Brit. Mus. Cat. Foss. Rcpt., part ii., 1889, p. 121), is macroccphalus.
The number of cervical vertebrae in PUsiosaurus rostratus is not
definitely known. Owen put it down as twenty-four, but there
were probably more, since in the specimen (38525) there are
evidently some vertebrae missing after the seventeenth (see
Lydekker, loc. tit., p. 272). Judging from the shape and relations
of the cervical ribs flexion of the neck must have been as difficult
of achievement in Plcsiosaurus as in our modern crocodiles, and so
the vertebral column in the cervical region has been drawn nearly
straight (Fig. 3), instead of being allowed the graceful sinuous curve
which characterises Owen's figure. The outline of the body has
been introduced from the figure given by Dames (Abkandl. konigl.
Almcl. Wiss., Berlin, 1895, ii., p. 79) ; and special attention may be
called to the shape of the tail fin, and to the presence of an integu-
mentary extension of the paddle behind the part supported by the
internal skeleton. The transverse temporal ridge at the back of
the skull would probably not have influenced the general contour of
the body to the extent suggested by the diagram. This improba-
bility should have been avoided by making the vertebral column
articulate a little higher up the occiput, and by putting the cranial
axis more in a line with the cervical vertebrae.

The cranium of the specimen above mentioned is considerably
crushed ; therefore, while preserving the proportions of the cranial
bones of this species, the actual details were added from the more
perfect skull (49202) of the allied species P. macroccphalus, de-
scribed and figured by Andrews (Quart. Journ. Geol. Soc, vol. lii.,
1896, pp. 246-253, pi. 9). The skeleton of the paddles in the
specimen of Plcsiosaurus rostratus is extremely well preserved, and
nothing more was necessary than to copy the outlines of the
constituent bones ; but as the bones of the pectoral and pelvic
girdles are disturbed, a certain amount of restoration was here
inevitable, and the assistance derived from the perfect girdles of
Muracnosaurus plicatus (R. 2428) and Crypt oclldus oxoniensis

1897] RESTORATION OF EXTINCT REE TILES 195

(R. 24 16) and (R, 26 1G) and the descriptions and figures of these
specimens by Andrews {Ann. & Mag. Nat. Hist., ser. G., vol.
xvi, 1895, p. 429; ibid., ser. 6., vol. xv., 1895, p. 333; Qeol.
Mag., dec. 4., vol. iii, 1896, p. 145) should here be acknow-
ledged.

Fariasaurus baini was chosen to represent the Anomodontia,
chiefly because of the completeness of the skeleton exhibited in
the Reptile Gallery of the Geological Department of the museum.
This skeleton (R. 1971), from the Karoo formation (Trias), was dis-
covered by Prof. H. G. Seeley, near Tamboer Fontein in Cape
Colony, and was described and figured by him in the Phil. Trans.
(1892, B.,pp. 311-370, pis. 17-19, 21-23). The Anomodontia con-
stitute such a heterogeneous collection of reptiles that it would be
difficult to say what species might be considered to be most typical
of the Order. But the completeness of this specimen of Fariasaurus
certainly renders it more suitable for the purpose in hand than any
other Anomodont yet known. The diagram (Fig. 4) is not a

Fig. 4. Pariasaurus baini, from the Trias of Cape Colony, (x.'s)

restoration in the same sense as the other three, because, in the
first place, the completeness of the skeleton renders possible a very
close adherence to nature, and, in the second, because, the whole
of our knowledge of the species being derived from this one speci-
men, a reconstructed diagram would be less instructive than an
outline drawing of the specimen boldly treated. The unimportant
cracks in the bones shown in the large folding plate in the Phil.
Trans, have been omitted, and a little diagrammatic cross-shading
has been employed here to give the effect of distance, although it
was not found necessary in the other three diagrams. The legs are
shown articulating in the glenoid cavity and the acetabulum, as in
the mounted specimen but not as in the plate ; and the anterior
cervical vertebrae, which during fossilisation were united into a
block of extreme upward curvature, are given a more convenient
disposition so as to articulate with the condyle of the skull,

196 NATURAL SCIENCE [September

which is not the case in the plate, nor in the specimen as now
mounted.

My grateful acknowledgments are due to Sir William Flower,
K.C.B., for permission to reproduce these figures for publication,
and to Mr A. Smith Woodward, assistant keeper of the Geological
Department, for sundry hints and advice during the construction of
the diagrams. W. G. Ridewood.

551.79 19'

The Facetted Pebbles of India

IT is now nearly forty years since the first account (1) of evidence
of ice action in Palaeozoic times and within the tropics was pub-
lished, and though the concept of a Permian glacial period is now one
of the accepted results of geological research, the opposition to its
acceptance is by no means dead. Some ten years ago this opposi-
tion received an access of strength by the arrival and exhibition in
England of certain peculiar fragments of rock, first discovered by Dr
Warth (2) in the Permian boulder beds of the Salt Eange, which
did not merely show a striation like that produced by glaciers, but
bore several surfaces or facets which met in obtuse angles, and some-
times completely surrounded the stone. A number of these were
sent home, unaccompanied by stones of other types, and an idea
seems, perhaps not unnaturally, to have sprung up that these were
the normal type of boulder, and not, as was the case, curiosities
which were strange to geologists in India, and sent by them to their
colleagues in Europe, with a view to enlightenment as to the mode
of origin of a feature with which they were not acquainted as a
result of ice action.

Specimens were exhibited at the Geological Society (3), the
British Association (4), and elsewhere, and the general opinion may
be expressed in the words of a letter by Dr W. T. Blanford to the
Geological Magazine (5), that " the great difficulty in accounting for
the origin of these facetted blocks is that whilst the smoothed sur-
faces are in every respect similar to those on stones worn by glacial
action, no fragments from moraines, from boulder-clay, or from other
glacial deposits, are known to exhibit the peculiar facetting charac-
teristic of the present specimens."

Such was the general opinion held by most, if not all, of- those
who saw the specimens, and in the museum at Zurich one of these
very facetted stones may be seen, with an endorsement on the label,
by Professor Heim, to the effect that he had seen nothing like it in
recent glacial deposits.

In these circumstances, the facetted stones being supposed to be
the evidence on which was based the claim for a glacial origin of
the beds in which they were found, it was natural that the opposi-
tion to the claim should be strengthened. In reality, however, the

198 NATURAL SCIENCE [September

supposition that these facetted pebbles were in some way the result
of ice action was based on the fact that they were found in beds
which, on quite independent grounds, were believed to be of glacial
origin, and this belief would have been in no way affected if the
facetted stones had been shown to owe their peculiar form to any
other agency than ice.

All this while, however, there was on record the description of
boulders of precisely similar character in glacial boulder clays of
Post-Tertiary age. In 1879 Professor Credner published an account
of the scratched stones found in the neighbourhood of Leipzig, (6) in
which he mentions three types ; the first being those on which a
fiat surface had been ground away on one side ; the second com-
prising those on which two or more such surfaces are found meeting
in obtuse angles ; the third, those which show no facets, but are of
a rounded or sub-angular form, and bear grooves and scratches
scattered over their surface. It would be impossible to give a better
classification of the stones found in the boulder beds of the Salt
Range, and the closeness of resemblance is only enhanced when
Professor Credner's detailed description is read.

This account appears to have been overlooked by all those who
saw the Salt Range specimens, for which small blame can be laid,
as the volume of glacial literature is so vast that the greater part
must remain unread — even by those who devote themselves specially
to this subject — and the paper might have remained unnoticed in
this connection had it not been accidentally stumbled on while a
very different line of research was being pursued. Struck with the
light it threw on the origin of these curious pebbles I wrote to
Professor Credner asking for further particulars, and in reply was
informed that in the collection of the Saxon Geological Survey there
are a large number of ice-worn stones showing two or more facets,
meeting at an angle, and that in some these facets were distributed
round the whole circumference of the stone. He also informs me
that after a comparison of the specimens in Leipzig with the figures
and descriptions of Drs Warth (2) and Noetling (7),- he considers
that their nature as glaciated fragments of the same character as
those of the " griind-morane " of the northern ice-sheet is beyond
doubt.

From this it is evident that we have, in Post-Tertiary glacial
deposits, ice- worn fragments showing all the peculiarities of those
found in the Permian boulder beds of the Salt Range, and with this
the last objection to accepting their glacial origin should disappear.

R. D. Oldham.

REFERENCES.

1. Blanford, H. F. and W.T., and Theobald, W. — On the geological structure and rela-
tions of the Talcheer coalfield in the district of Cuttack. Mem. Geol. Surv. Lid.,
i., pt. i., p. 33 (1859).

1897] THE FACETTED PEBBLES OF INDIA 199

2. Warth, H. — A facetted pebble from the boulder bed (speckled -sandstone) of Mount

Chel in the Salt Range in the Punjab. Bee. Geol. Surv. Ind., vol. xxi., p. 34
(1888).

3. Blanford, W. T. — On additional evidence of the occurrence of glacial conditions in

the Palaeozoic era, &c. Quart. Journ. Geol. Soc, vol. xlii., pp. 249-263 (1886).
1. Wynne, A. B. — A facetted and striated pebble from the Olive group conglomerate of
the Chiel Hill in the Salt Range, Punjab, India. Bep. Brit. Assoc, lvi., pt. ii. ,
631 (1S87). Geol. Mag., 3rd decade, vol. iii., p. 492 (1886).

5. Blanford, W. T. — On a smoothed and striated boulder from the Punjab Salt Range.

Geol. May., 3rd decade, vol. iii., p. 574 (1886).

6. Credner, H. — Ueber gletscherschlifl'e auf Porphyrkuppen bei Leipzig, und iiber geritzte

einheimische Geschiebe. Zcitschr. deutsch. Geol. Ges., vol. xxxi., pp. 21-24
(1879).

7. Noetling, F. — Beitrage zur Kenntniss der glacialen Schichten permischen Alters in der

Salt-Range, Punjab (Indien). Neucs Jahrbuch, 1S96, vol. ii., pp. 61-86.

200 [September

SOME NEW BOOKS

A French Treatise on Zoology

Trait^ de Zoologie Concrete. Vol. I. La Cellule et les Protozoaires. By Yves
Delage and Edgard Herouard. Pp. xxx. 584, with 870 col. figs. Paris: Schleicher
Freres, 1896. Price 25 francs.

This is the first instalment of a work which, if it finishes as it has
begun, will be of the greatest value, since it combines completeness
and erudition with a method of treatment at once highly original and
well adapted to the end in view.

The primary object of the authors is to smooth the path of the
student and to help him in his difficulties, and in their preface they
are at pains to explain how it is intended to bring about this result.
Every one knows how difficult it is, when commencing the study of a
group of animals with the help only of an ordinary text-book of com-
parative anatomy, to apply the more or less vague generalities of
which such works are composed to the case of a particular form.
The usual method of describing a group of animals in the text-books
or treatises on zoology is to commence with a chapter or chapters in
which the comparative anatomy of the group is described organ by
organ in a purely abstract manner — that is to say, without reference
to the remaining organs of the body. This is followed by a systematic
portion in which the families or genera are catalogued and distin-
guished by means of their external characters. The great defect of
this mode of treatment is the want of any proper link between the
abstract and the concrete, between the general and the par-
ticular. The beginner who is as yet unfamiliar with the group in
question finds an extreme difficulty in forming a clear idea of how a
particular form is organised in its entirety, since he has to combine
in his mind a brief summary of its external characters with the rather
vague mental image of its anatomy which he constructs by wading
through the comparative chapters and picking out such portions as
may apply to the form under consideration. Hence text-books of
this class, though extremely valuable to the advanced student or
teacher as works of reference, are confusing to the learner, who
requires above all things something real and concrete, upon which to
found his general notions.

It is not every student who has the time or opportunity to obtain
the empirical basis so necessary for a clear grasp of the main prin-
ciples, by consulting the special memoirs or monographs dealing with
the forms he is studying, and in order to help him out of the diffi-
culty a large class of practical text-books of zoology has sprung up
in recent years, in which particular forms are chosen as typical
examples of the larger systematic groups and described in great
detail. In this way a division of labour has come about whereby the
treatise of comparative anatomy is supplemented and elucidated by

1897J SOME NEW BOOKS 201

the concrete examples of the practical text-book. It is, however,
only to a limited extent that such co-operation is possible or prac-
ticable. The number of types which can be described within the
limits of a practical text-book must be necessarily few by comparison
with the ground covered by the more abstract treatises, and illustra-
tive only of the greater systematic divisions. The design of our
authors is an ambitious one. It is nothing less than to effect a com-
promise, so to speak, between the abstract and the particular, and to
impart a general knowledge founded upon judiciously constructed,
concrete examples.

A complete knowledge of a natural group of animals might be
supposed attainable only by a separate description of each of the
species in it. But allied species and even genera only differ amongst
themselves by secondary characters, and it is not until we come to
families or orders that we find anatomical characters of sufficient
importance to warrant detailed treatment in the limited compass of a
text-book. Hence for each such systematic division the authors pro-
pose to commence with the description of a generalised type, in which
the characters of the subgroup — in most cases a suborder — shall be
found combined, and then to proceed to point out how the various
forms comprised in the subgroup differ severally from the essential
type. But such generalised and fundamental types are to be found
but rarely in nature. The authors have therefore invented and con-
structed a morphological type for each suborder, a fundamental
form " which summarises in itself that which is common to all the
actual forms of the group, or which is presented as a simple initial
form, from which the others would be derived by progressive com-
plications." In this way it is possible to present general notions in a
concrete form. It might be objected that the morphological types
are not real but represent to a certain extent ideal abstractions. In
answer to this it is pointed out that the term concrete does not
mean real. "A type may be concrete even though it is ideal
What does it matter to a student when he reads a precise description
with the indication of all the organs and of their relations, whether
the being thus described really exists in nature or whether it repre-
sents only the mean, we might almost say the composite portrait,
of a small group of real beings ? The idea he will obtain of the being-
described, and later of the entire group, will be none the less precise
and none the less accurate."

For the reasons that have just been set forth, Messrs Delage and
Herouard call their work a treatise of concrete zoology, as opposed
to the more abstract zoology of the ordinary text-books. They
claim, and we think justly, to have helped the student over one of his
greatest difficulties, though as they acknowledge, the Protozoa are
scarcely a fair test for the efficiency of the method on account of their
simple structure, and we are begged to suspend our final judgment
until the appearance of the volumes to follow. At the same time the
great store of information brought together in a most painstaking and
laborious manner renders the work very useful to others than
beginners, chiefly on account of the simple and methodical arrange-
ment that has been adopted, and the consequent ease with which any
required facts can be hunted down.

202 NATURAL SCIENCE [September

The present volume contains two parts, the first dealing with the
cell and its functions, the second with the Protozoa. In the first part
the authors give a review of general cytology, and deal with the vexed
questions of protoplasmic and nuclear structures. Here, as they admit,
they are often on very controversial ground, and experts would find
much to criticise and to dispute in the opinions put forward. It
cannot, however, be laid to the charge of our authors that they have
neglected or passed over other views, though their criticisms upon
them are occasionally perhaps rather one-sided ; for having in view
once more the exigencies of the student they have divided the work
into two parts, one printed in large type composing the main text,
the other in small type contained in the footnotes. In the former
the objects are described in a simple and straightforward manner from
the point of view taken by the authors, while to the footnotes are
relegated the more controversial subjects as well as details concerning
the less important or doubtful genera and similar matters. In this
way the work is rendered extremely complete, and while on the one
hand the student is treated to a clear and continuous, if at times
dogmatic, expose of the subject, he is enabled, on the other hand, to
greatly extend his knowledge, if he wish, by means of the references
and discussions in the footnotes.

The portion of the work dealing with the Protozoa contains a mass
of information which it would be impossible to criticise in detail. We
must, however, take exception to one innovation which has been
introduced into this work, namely, the manner in which the authors
have changed the names of the groups, in the attempt to introduce
one uniform system of terminations for the equivalent taxonomic
subdivisions. The results have been in some cases almost disastrous ;
we can hardly recognise such familiar groups as the Flagellata and
Ciliata when we see them written as " Fla^ellia " and " Ciliae "
respectively. In science a very good excuse is always necessary
before the alteration of well-established names can be permitted. In
the present case it is again solicitude for the student which is
responsible for this well-meant but, we think, injudicious reform.
It is supposed, for instance, that to make the names of classes end in
ia, and subclasses in iae, in all cases, will tend to clearness. Not
only, however, is this alteration of names rather confusing, especially
to the beginner, but it involves the assumption, which can scarcely be
maintained, that the various categories known as classes, subclasses,
orders, and so forth, are of the same taxonomic value in all groups.
The fact alone, however, that in the classifications of different authors,
different names are given to equivalent divisions, is a sufficient refuta-
tion of this view, for where one author has a subclass divided into
orders, another may have an order divided into suborders. It is,
therefore, rather premature to coin a uniform termination for sub-
classes or orders until the value of these categories is more fixed.
But further, Messrs Delage and Herouard have given new names in
their scheme to just those taxonomic categories for which, being of
lesser and therefore of more definite value, the almost universal custom
of naturalists has already established a uniform terminology. Nearly
everywhere now names of families are made to terminate in idae and
subfamilies in inae ; yet our authors choose to employ the termination

1897] SOME NEW BOOKS 203

idae for suborders and inoe for families. The alteration in this way
of an already uniform and established system of nomenclature seems
to us quite unjustifiable.

In the classification of the Protozoa we notice a certain number of
new names, some of which are coined for the purposes of new classi-
fications, while others are older groups renamed. The Sporozoa are
divided into two subclasses (1) Amoebogeniae (nov.) with amoeboid
sporozoites, and containing the Myxosporidia, and (2) Ehabdogeniae
(nov.), with sporozoites of definite form, including the remainder of
the class. The Ehabdogeniae are further divided into the two orders,
Dolichocystida (nov.), comprising the Sarcosporidia, and Brachycystida
(nov.), which includes the remaining forms, namely, the Gregarinidae,
Cocciiliidae,Haemosporididae(2)/'^a?iw^W'm,etc.)and Gymnosporididae
(Hacmamocba and others). In the Ciliata Stein's four orders are
maintained. The Holotricha are divided into Gymnostomidae, cor-
responding to Butschli's Gymnostoma, and the Hymenostomidae
(nov.), corresponding to Butschli's Trichostoma Aspirotricha. The
Peritricha are divided into Scaiotrichidae (nov.), comprising Butschli's
Lienophorina and Spirochonina, and Dexiotrichidae (nov.) = Yorticel-
lina. In the former the adoral zone of cilia has a sinistral (Jl,ko.i6s)
twist, in the latter a dextral (Ae£io$).

The work is illustrated throughout by excellent diagrammatic
figures, for the most part coloured, some even in as many as four
colours. None of the familiar " vieux cliches " which persistently
haunt one text-book after another, are permitted to intrude between
these covers, all the figures being either specially constructed diagrams
or else copied or modified from the original figures in the special
memoirs. In short, the whole book is characterised throughout to a
marked degree by one most precious quality, that of clearness and
lucidity both in description and illustration. In conclusion, we con-
gratulate Messrs Delage and Herouard most heartily on the first
results of their labours, and wish them all success in the great task
which they have before them. E. A. M.

GONIATITES IN THE BRITISH MUSEUM

Catalogue of the Fossil Cephalopoda in the British Museum (Natural
History). Part iii. Containing the Bactritidae and part of the suborder
Ammonoidea. By Arthur H. Foord and George Charles Crick. Pp. xxxiv., 303.
Published by order of the Trustees. London, 1897. Price, 12s. 6d.

The first part of this Catalogue, published in 1888, and the second
published in 1891, dealt with the Nautiloidea and were written by
Dr Foord alone. - That gentleman's removal to Dublin made some
help imperative, and Mr Crick, the assistant in charge of the Cepha-
lopoda in the Geological Department of the British Museum, has
proved a worthy collaborator. The experience gained from previous
work, combined with this fortunate co-operation, has brought the
present volume, which treats of the older Ammonoidea, very near our
ideal of what such a museum-catalogue should be. Some of these
publications of the Natural History Museum have been important
contributions to knowledge, but have left us still in the dark as to the
precise extent or value of the Museum collections ; others have dis-

204 NATURAL SCIENCE [September

played a marvellous zeal in the hunting up of ancient literature and
the compilation of synonymies, but have not greatly assisted the
student ; others again have been dry lists of specimens, jotted down
in haste and repented of at leisure, but having at least this merit,
that they told us what material the Museum contained.

The present volume seems to us to combine the advantages, with-
out the defects, of those predecessors to which we have referred. The
descriptions of the species are most carefully drawn up, each being
based, where possible, on examination of the type-specimen itself, and
following a uniform plan, which greatly facilitates comparison. A
useful diagram explains the terms employed. The difficulty of
describing the all-important suture-line has been avoided by giving
a tracing made from an actual specimen, if possible the type. There
are also woodcuts of specimens, many of them from original drawings
by Miss G. M. Woodward. The references to literature, in the form
of lists of synonyma, are carefully done, but occupy a disproportionate
space. When a species has never received more than one specific
name, e.g., Prolecanites becheri, it seems unnecessary to trace this
through all the obvious genera, such as Ammonites and Goniatites, to
which it has been referred by older authors, including the compilers
of text-books and nomenclators. The information is useful, but might
be put in less compass. Finally, this is a true catalogue ; every
specimen in the Museum is mentioned in such a way that it can be
identified, and the number under which it is entered in the Museum
lists or registers is printed. Thus the foreign student can gauge pre-
cisely the wealth of the collection, can tell whether what he wants to
see is contained in it, and on reaching the Museum can ask for the
definite specimen he requires.

One or two improvements may be suggested for future volumes of
this and other catalogues. The statements of locality are misleading :
under each species comes a series of statements made with reference
to the species in general, including the usual size attained. After
"Size" follow "Form, and Log" These, however, refer not to the
species, but to the particular specimens in the Museum. It would be
better to give the general geological and geographical distribution of
the species, and to refer to definite localities under the individual
specimens, as is already done in cases where more than one locality
is represented. It would be well to draw more forcible attention to
the type-specimens, e.g., by broad-faced type, also to distinguish
cotypes, paratypes, and the rest. It is good to know the names of
donors, especially when they are such men as J. E. Lee and John
Kofe ; but it would also be good in other cases to know the names of
those from whom specimens have been purchased, since these must
often have been geologists of repute, whose statements of locality and
the like would be of more value than those of an ordinary dealer or
inefficient collector. It is sad to see how many specimens are entered
with "History unhwivn" and of how many others " Transferred from
Mas. Pract. Gcol." the necessary details are not recorded; but this is
no fault of Messrs Foord & Crick.

A catalogue is not a text-book ; nevertheless the Catalogues of
the British Museum have come to be looked for by us outsiders as
likely to introduce some improved system, and to unravel the tangle

1897] SOME NEW BOOKS 205

of conflicting authorities. We look for some pronouncement on
debated points, and for some clue through the maze that perplexes
us. In these respects the present work leaves us unsatisfied. There
is no exposition of the principles of the classification adopted ; there
are no keys ; and there is little to indicate the relations of the species
to one another. The authors suffer from an excess of caution : they
tell us what Hyatt has written, what Haug thinks, what is the
opinion of Branco, and what one will find in Zittel ; hut what their
own views are, wild horses will not drag from them. It is the duty
of people with such advantages as have our authors, not only to have
opinions but to express them. It is not enough to tell us of so
interesting a form as Clymenia that its derivation "is at present
enigmatical " ; it has been that for half-a-centurv. But one doubts
occasionally whether even the authors know their own minds. There
is a vast deal of quotation as to the systematic position of Bactrites,
but where it is placed after all, we cannot understand. In Part I. of
the Catalogue, Dr Foord inserted it among the Nautiloidea ; in Part
II. he said that he would refer it to the Ammonoidea ; and now in
Part III. it is hung up in the air, as though it were an Archi-
cephalopod or a Schematic Mollusc. Again, among the quotations
bearing on this, we find a passage from Hyatt and some of his
figures ; but we find no quotation of the destructive criticism of this
passage published by Mr Crick himself, in conjunction with Mi-
Bather, in Natural Science for December 1894 (vol. v., p. 425). It is
less strange, but quite as inexcusable, that there should be no refer-
ence to the important papers by J. M. Clarke in the American
Geologist. There is always some excellent excuse for the suppression
of evidence, and we shall no doubt learn that this is all for the good
of the Government — or its officials.

It is curious, in a volume dealing with the Goniatites, to find no
family Goniatitidae and no genus Goniatites. The type-species of
Goniatites is the Nautilites sphacricus of Martin, a perfectly well-
known form, which appears in this book as a Glyphioceras. There
seems no room for doubt that Glyphioceras must rank as a synonym
of Goniatites, since the latter has some sixty years' priority.

With the few exceptions mentioned, the volume is brought well
up to date, and the care with which it has been compiled augurs well
for the continuation of the series.

Popular Natural History

The Concise Knowledge Library — Natural History. Edited by Alfred H. Miles.
8vo, pp. xvi. and 771, with 530 original illustrations. London : Hutchinson &
Co., 1897. Price, 5s.

This volume is the first of a projected series, the purpose of which is
shown in the title, and in the editorial preface. The volumes are
intended to be " concise and popular ... at once accurate in state-
ment, handy in form, and ready of reference " ; and the results hoped
for are, " that much time may be saved to busy people and much help
afforded to students." The plan is excellent, but the execution is
scarcely so successful as one would expect from the names which
figure on the title page. Mr Lydekker is responsible for the mammals,

206 NATURAL SCIENCE [September

reptiles, amphibians, fishes, and cyclostomes ; Dr R Bowdler Sharpe
for the birds ; Mr Garstang for amphioxus and balanoglossus ; Mr
W. F. Kirby for the arthropods ; Mr B. B. "Woodward for the mol-
luscs ; Mr Bather for the lamp shells and starfishes ; Mr Kirkpatrick
for the moss animals ; Mr Pocock for the " worms " ; and Mr and
Mrs Bernard for the coelenterates and the protozoa. There is, of
course, a good deal of excellent work in the book, which is a marvel
of cheapness ; but some of the sections dealing with vertebrata read
as if they were made up of popular newspaper articles, hurriedly, and
not very skilfully, welded together. The best part of the book is that
dealing with the lowest vertebrates and the invertebrates. The sections
on lamp shells and starfishes deserve special mention; and students of
the bryozoa will be grateful to Mr Kirkpatrick for appending to
his section a classification and bibliography. In a second edition it
would be well to adopt the same zoo-geographical regions for mammals
and birds; and the puzzling sentence on p. 122 — "the teats of the
female elephants are placed between the hind legs, and the young calf
sucks with its mouth, and not with its trunk " — should be deleted.
Stricter supervision, too, should be exercised over the illustrations.
Fig. 86 (p. 156) bears the inscription Tragclaphus angasi, about which
no word occurs in the text ; the inscription of Fig. 82 (p. 349) does
not refer to the bird figured ; the illustration of the bearded reedling
(p. 368) bears the generic name Calamophilus, while Panurus is given
in the text, though it does not appear in the index. The misprints,
of which there are considerably more than are justly chargeable to the
printer, should be carefully sought for and corrected. Alunda, Teirao,
Phasiandae, Paro, Syrrhoptes, Scolopaeinae, Nydierax nycticrax, Try-
panns, Anthrophysa (and many others) are likely to prove hindrances
rather than helps ; and some readers may stumble at " catenanan
formation." " Pellage," too, is an unusual form in English books ;
while " Leydecker " and " Brydden " conceal familiar names.

Moths

A Handbook to the Order Lepidoptera. By W. F. Kirby, F.L.S., F.E.S. Vol.
V. Moths. Part 3. 8vo, pp. 332, plates 32. (Allen's Naturalist's Library.)
London : W. H. Allen & Co., 1897. Price, 6s.

With praiseworthy celerity, Mr Kirby has brought his handbook of
lepidoptera to a conclusion. It is unfortunate that his account of the
noctuids, the geometers, and the whole of the so-called " micro-
lepidoptera " has had to be compressed into the volume now before
us. The space is quite inadequate for a clue treatment of these groups,
especially as the author continues to devote a quarter or half a page
to the synonymy and references of each species which he selects for
description. Although a large number of moths are described and
figured, the families are necessarily much more cursorily treated than
those dealt with in the preceding volumes. For example, among the
noctuids we find only one British species, each of such large genera as
Acronyeta, Lcucaui/*, and Ayrotis, and not a single representative of
Hadena ; and turning to the geometers, the large and important
genera Eiipithecia and Cidaria are altogether omitted. As for the
" microlepidoptera," Mr Kirby states in his preface that he has found

1S97] SOME NEW BOOKS 207

it " impossible to do more than describe and figure a selection of
species belonging to various families."

It is a considerable disappointment to find that in his classification
of the noctuids and geometers, Mr Kirby closely follows the arrange-
ment proposed forty years ago by Guenee, instead of availing himself
of the work of those modern writers who have critically studied the
structure of these moths. There is probably hardly a serious student
of the noctuids who would not closely associate the genera which
Guenee distributed between his two " families," Apameidae and
Hadenidae ; yet Mr Kirby treats these assemblages as sub-families,
and separates them widely in his series. It is sincerely to be hoped
that in the coming volumes of his great catalogue of the lepidoptera
Mr Kirby will adopt a more modern classification. Otherwise the
value of his work will be seriously diminished.

It could not be expected that much space would be devoted to the
habits of the moths which are mentioned, but a few notes of consider-
able interest on this subject are given by Mr Kirby. He has rescued
from a long obscurity an account published in 1830 by the Eev. L.
Guilding on the aquatic larva of a West Indian pearl-moth (Petrophila
fluviatilis). He also calls attention to de Eiville's account, published
nearly one hundred and fifty years ago, of a Mediterranean Antispila,
whose caterpillar mines in vine leaves.

A large number of species are figured in the coloured plates, a good
proportion of them for the first time. Though the effect of some of the
colouring is rough, and there is a want of uniformity in the setting of
the specimen, these figures will be helpful for the determination of
species. Mr Kirby's wide knowledge of insects and their literature
must needs make his writings useful to naturalists, even if they do
not care to adopt all the changes in well-known names which he
believes to be necessary. G. H. C.

A BlBLIOGEAPHICAL ENIGMA

Manuel de Geograprie botaxique. Par Oscar Drude. Traduit par Georges
Poirault et revu et augmente par l'auteur. Livraisons, 14-16. 8vo, pp. 513-552,
with 4 maps. Paris : Klincksieck, 1897.

We are glad to receive this, the completion of a useful translation and
edition of Drude's work on plant geography. The previous parts
have been noticed as they appeared ; the last consists chiefly of an
exhaustive, and so far we have tested it, accurate index, a list of
additions and corrections, and four folding maps. The price of the
book as a whole is 18 francs. While commending the work, we must
call attention to a serious omission, from a bibliographical point of
view. The title page, just issued, bears date 1897 ; but the first part
appeared in June 1893, and the remainder at various dates between
1893 and 1897. As the covers of the individual parts all bear the
same date, viz., 1893, and as there is no reference to successive dates
in the text, its issue in parts will be lost sight of, and the whole will
seem to have appeared in the present year. Thus another puzzle
will be added to the future bibliographer's list — a list already far too
long. To lessen this evil as far as possible wTe append the dates of

208 NATURAL SCIENCE [September

notice in Natural Science of the individual parts. As Natural Science
is wont to be prompt, this gives a very fair indication of the dates of
publication : —

Part 1, noticed in vol. iii., p. 152 (Aug. 1893).

Parts 2 and 3, noticed in vol. iv., p. 464 (June 1893).

4 and 5, „ vol. vii., p. 214 (Sept. 1895).

6 and 7, „ „ p. 282 (Oct. 1895).

8 to 10, „ vol. viii., p. 62 (Jan. 1896).

„ 11 to 13, „ „ p. 393 (Dec. 1896).

New Serials

We learn from Science that the Italian Societa Positivista has
established a bi-monthly journal, // Pensiero Moclerna, published at
Via Collegio Romano 26 (Home ?), and edited by Prof. Sergi. The
object of the society is to demonstrate the importance of science for
modern life.

The American X-ray Journal is edited and published by Dr Heber
Roberts, St Louis, Mo., and is intended for the medical profession.

We may mention here the Bulletin of the Geological and Natural
History Survey of the Chicago Academy of Sciences. The first is a
monograph of the lichens of Chicago and the neighbourhood by
W. W. Calkins.

Further Literature Received

First Principles of Natural Philosophy, A. E. Dolbear : Giim, Boston. The
Choniostomatidae. H. T. Hansen : Host, Copenhagen. Euclid (Books i.-iv.), and The
Tutorial Trigonometry : Give. System der Bakterien, W. Migula : Fischer, Jena.
Untersuchungen liber das Erfrieren der Pflanzen, H. Molisch : Fischer. Allgemeine
Physiologie, M. Verworn, ed. 2 : Fischer. Open-Air Studies in Botany, C. Lloyd
Praeger : Griffin. Elementary Biology, T. Jeffrey Parker, ed. 3 : Macmillan. Twenty-
seventh Ann. Rep. Entom. Soc, Ontario, 1896. U.S. Dept. Agriculture, Technical
Series, No. 6. Ann. Rep. Manchester Museum, 1S96-97. Journ. Inst., Jamaica, vol.
ii., No. 4. First Ann. Rep. Geol. Commiss., Cape of Good Hope, 1896.

Crustacea of Norway, G. 0. Sars. vol. ii. , pts. v., vi. : BergensMus. The Asparagus
Beetles, F. H. Chittenden : Ycar-Book U.S. Dcpt. Agric. Insect Control in California,
C. L. Marlatt : ibid. The Use of Steam Apparatus for Spraying, L. 0. Howard : ibid.
The Protective Value of Action, volitional or otherwise, in Protective Mimicry, F. M.
Webster: Journ. New York Entom. Soc. Biological Effects of Civilization on the Insect
Fauna of Ohio, F. M. Webster: Ann. Rep. Ohio State Acad. Sci.

Jersey Weekly Press, August 7 ; Amcr. Geol., August ; Amer. Journ. Sci., August ;
Amer. Nat., August ; l'Anthropologie, May- June ; Botan. Gazette, June- July ; Feuille
des jeunes Nat., August; Irish Nat., August; Literary Digest, July 10, 17,2-1,31,
August 7; Naturae Novit., No. 12, June; La Naturaleza (Madrid), Nos. 20-22;
Naturalist, August ; Nature, July 22, 29, August 5, 12 : Naturen, June, July :
Photogram, July, August ; Review of Reviews, July, and do. Australia, May; Revista
Quind. Psichologia, &c, vol. i., fasc. 1-7 ; Rev. Scient., July 17, 24, August 7,14:
Science, July 9, 16, 23, 30 ; Sci. Amer., July 10, 17, 24, 31, August 7 ; Scot. Geogr.
Mag., August ; Scot. Med. and Surg. Journ., August ; Froe. Biol. Soc, Washington,
vol. xi., pp. 213-230 (July 15).

1897] 209

OBITUARIES

Sib John Charles Bucknill, one of the first editors of Brain and
editor of the Journal of Mental Science for nine years, was, at the
time of his death recently, acting in the capacity of Censor, Councillor
and Lumleian Lecturer in the Royal College of Physicians. In 1866
he was elected Fellow of the Royal Society, and in July 1894 he was
knighted. He produced a large number of psychological works,
making insanity and similar subjects a specialty. He became
especially popular through his psychological essays on the " Mad folk
of Shakespere."

Mb Samuel Laing, who died on August 8th at the advanced age of
87 years, was formerly chairman of the Brighton Railway and had a
lifelong connection with railway interests. He devoted his leisure to
scientific pursuits, and his principal original work was the exploration
of the prehistoric refuse heaps of Caithness, which he described, with
the aid of Prof. Huxley, in 1866. During recent years he successfully
devoted himself to the popularisation of science, his best known works
being entitled " Modern Science and Modern Thought " and " Human
Origins."

'6'

The death of Captain Bertram Lutley Sclater at Zanzibar on July
24th will excite widespread sympathy among English naturalists for
his father, Dr P. L. Sclater, as well as deep regret at the loss of an
officer whose career was full of promise. His main work was road-
making in British Central and British East Africa ; during which he
accomplished many careful surveys. His maps form a valuable
addition to our knowledge of the geography of those countries, in the
future development of which the work which cost him his life will
play an important part.

Another geographer whose death cannot pass unnoticed in Natural
Science was the late Ney Elias, a man whose work, though popularly
very little known, was of such importance as to place him among the
greatest English travellers of this century. His first paper, " Notes of
a Journey to the New Course of the Yellow River," is one of the
classics of physical geography. His exploration of western
Mongolia during a journey from Pekin to Nijni Novgorod is one of
the six great feats in Asiatic travel. In 1885 he settled the vexed
question as to the sources of the Oxus, and later on made numerous
less famous journeys in the Indian borderlands. His shyness was exces-
sive, and he had no ambition for notoriety. His great feats are recorded
in technical geographical papers, but these will live. His reputation
as a traveller will probably be greater in a century's time than it is
to-day. But in the meanwhile it would be very useful if his papers
were collected and republished with some sketch of his life.

210 NATURAL SCIENCE [September

The death is announced of Theophile Chudzinski at Paris on June
18th, aged 55. By birth a Pole, he studied at Moscow until the insur-
rection of 1863 caused him to give up his studies and join in the move-
ment. This was followed by an incarceration of several months in
Austria, but escaping he made his way to Belgium and subsequently
to France, where he spent the rest of his life. It was in pursuing his
anatomical researches that he was first noticed by Broca at Paris, who
later gave him a post in the Laboratoire d'Anthropologie des Hautes-
Etudes. For several years Chudzinski assisted his master until the
latter's death, when he devoted himself to anatomical works, particu-
larly to the study of the brain and the anatomical resemblances and
differences between that of man and of the anthropoid apes. A large
number of anthropological and anatomical works were the result of
his minute researches. These, although edited in Paris, were not
published in French.

LuciEN Biart, who died recently, was a talented author, and although
he chose to veil his scientific knowledge in the form of novels, that
knowledge was incontestable. A great love of travel took him in
1845 to Mexico, where he studied archaeology and ethnography. In
addition to his novels, the chief of which are " Le Eoi des Prairies,"
" Entre deux Oceans," etc., he wrote a volume on the red races for the
Bibliotheque ethnologique, as well as a monograph on the Aztecs.

The deaths are also announced of : — Paul Schutzenbergee, the physiological
chemist of the College de France, Paris, aged 67 ; P. C. Plugge, Professor of Pharma-
cology and Toxicology at Gcittingen ; Arminio Nobile, Professor of Geodesy, and author
of many valuable papers on astronomy, at Rome ; Professor Oertel of Munich, dis-
tinguished for his researches on the etiology of diphtheria ; Alfred Moquart, Pro-
fessor of Anatomy at Brussels, on June 5, aged 42 years ; Martin Wilckens of the
Agricultural School of Vienna, on June 10, aged 64 ; Count Victor Trevisan di
San Leon, the cryptogamist, in Milan, on April 8, aged 79 years ; Robert Douglas,
known for his work in arboriculture and forestry, on June 1, at Waukegan, 111., aged
84 ; G. Ossowski, the geologist, on April 16, at Tomsk ; P. B. L. Verlot, botanist,
at Verrieres-les-Buisson ; Rev. Robert Hunter, botanist, on Feb. 25, at Eppiug
Forest, aged 74 ; Samuel James Augustus Salter, botanist, on Feb. 28, at Basing-
stoke, aged 72 ; Geheimrat Heydenreich, student of Lepidoptera, on May 18, at
Osnabruck ; the coleopterologist, Daniel Muller, on May 22, at Barcelona ; the
oologist, C. Q. Aschan, schoolmaster at Kuopio, Finland ; Dr Anders Johan
Malmgren, a well-known ichthyologist and student of Annelida, of Uleaborg, Finland ;
Dr Wolfert and a mechanic named Knabe, who fell while sailing at a height of 1000
feet in a navigable balloon, at Tempelhof, near Berlin ; Ferdinand Beclard, palaeon-
tologist at the Brussels Museum, who was in the midst of important studies of Devonian
brachiopods ; R. Allan Wight, the economic-entomologist of Paerva, near Auckland,
N.Z., on the 22nd December 1896, aged 73 years ; Michael Angelo Console, professor
in Palermo University, and well-known as a cactus-hunter, on May 13, aged 85 ;
Peter von Tunner, of the mining district of Leoben, on June 8, aged 89 years ;
Dominik Hofer, the veterinarian of Munich University, on June 13, aged 80; Dr
Jules Jullien of Havre, the zoologist (Bryozoa) ; Charles F. Wells and J. W.
Jones, who were exploring the West- Australian deserts, killed by the natives in June ;
Friedrich C. Straub, the botanist, at Liberia, on March 21, aged 26 ; Alfred
Sutton, of the well-known firm of J. Sutton & Sons, Reading, on August 9, aged 80.

18971 2l1

NEWS

The following appointments are announced : —
Henry Charles Williamson, as Naturalist to the Fishery Board for Scotland ;
W. W. Watts, of the Geological Survey, as assistant-professor of geology in the
Mason College, Birmingham ; Miss Bertha Stoneman as professor of botany in
the Huguenot College for Women at Cape Town ; Dr Edward Fischer to succeed
his father, Prof. L. Fischer (retired), as professor of botany in the University of
Bern ; Dr Julius Paoletti of Padua to be professor of natural history at the
Melfi Technical Institute ; Dr Pio Bolson as second assistant in the Botanical
Garden of Padua ; Dr M. Raciborski of Cracow and Dr Zehntner of Pasoeroean
(Java) to be professors of botany and entomology at the experimental station for
sugar production at Kagok Tegal (Java) ; Hugo Miinsterberg of Freiburg as
professor of psychology in Harvard University ; Dr Antonio Crocichia as pro-
fessor of biology in the Catholic University of Washington ; Dr H. Fling to the
chair of biology, F. A. Mitchell to the chair of geography, and Dr F. D.
Sherman to the chair of psychology at the Oshkosh Normal School ; Ernest B.
Forbes as assistant state entomologist in Minnesota ; Dr C. E. Beecher as pro-
fessor of historical geology at Yale University ; Dr L. V. Pirsson as professor of
physical geology in the Lawrence Scientific School ; Dr Geo. B. Shattuck as
assistant in geology at Johns Hopkins University ; Oliver L. Fassig as instructor
in climatology, and Dr Charles R. Bardeen as assistant in anatomy at the same
University ; Dr Albert Schneider as professor of botany, pharmacognosy and
materia medica in the School of Pharmacy of the North-Western University,
Chicago ; E. B. Copeland, of the University of Wisconsin, to be assistant-
professor of botany in the University of Indiana ; Dr G. J. Pierce to be assistant-
professor of botany in Stanford University ; Henry Kraemer to the chair of
botany and microscopy in the Philadelphia College of Pharmacy ; Cleveland
Abbe, jun., as a fellow in geology of Johns Hopkins University.

Sir Frederick McCoy has retired from his professorship in the University
of Melbourne.

Mr A. W. Bennett has succeeded Prof. Jeffrey Bell as editor of the Journal
of the Royal Microscopical Society.

Mr C. Da vies Sherborn has resigned the secretaryship of the Geologists'
Association of London, and will be succeeded in October by Mr Percy Emary.

Mr C. W. Andrews should have arrived at Christmas Island before this
number appears. He left Batavia about the 21st July on Mr Ross's schooner.

The Irish Field Club Union held their annual excursion in July around the
north coast of Antrim, making Ballycastle Bay their headquarters.

Mr R. T. Gunther is on his way to Lake Urumiya on the Persian frontier, to
study the fauna of that lake. We regret to hear that he has had a temporary
breakdown in health, and hope he will soon recover and proceed on his way.

We learn from the Revue Scientifique that it is proposed to found an experi-
mental station in Madagascar, for the introduction of European cereals and the
improvement of local vegetable produce.

212 NATURAL SCIENCE [September

Lady Humphry, widow of the late Sir George Humphry, Professor of
Surgery at Cambridge, has presented her husband's library to the surgical
department of the university.

On July 8th, the Geographical Institute of Lisbon, founded in commemora-
tion of the 400th anniversary of Vasco da Gama's departure for the Indies, was
opened by the Geological Society of Portugal.

The German Botanical Society begins its annual meeting at Brunswick on
September 21 at the same time as the German Association of Naturalists and
Physicians. There will be an exhibition of scientific apparatus.

Prof. Gustav Born, of Breslau, has received the Sommering prize from the
Senckenberg Society of Natural History at Frankfurt for his investigations on
the growth of the larvae of amphibia.

In the absence of Prof. Biitschli, Prof. V. Carus presided over the annual
meeting of the German Zoological Society at Kiel, June 9-11. There were present
thirty-seven members and thirteen guests. The next meeting will be held at
Heidelberg at Whitsuntide, 1898.

Dr Henry Woodward, keeper of the department of geology in the British
Museum (Natural History), has been permitted by the Treasury to retain his
office for another two years. According to the rules of retirement in the Civil
Service, his term of service would have expired next November.

The Darwin statue at Shrewsbury was duly unveiled, and stands in front of
the Free Library. It is the work of a Shrewsbury man, Mr Horace Mountford,
is said to be an excellent likeness, and is the gift of the Shropshire Horticultural
Society.

Professors D. T. Macdougal and Campbell, representing a Commission from
the American Universities, have visited Jamaica with a view of founding there a
botanical research laboratory. Other Commissioners have gone to Trinidad. On
their return to the United States they will compare notes as to the best locality
and come to a decision.

Mr George Murray and Mr V. H. Blackman have returned from their trip
to Panama, after a successful and profitable voyage. They have obtained a large
quantity of plankton containing many new specimens, which will shortly be
worked out, and have made numerous interesting observations on living forms.
They spent two or three days in Jamaica on the way.

According to Science, Mr B. W. Porter and Mr A. V. Shand, who are with
Lieut. Peary, expect to pass the winter in Baffin Land for the purpose of ethno-
logical and zoological studies and collections. In the summer of 1898 they hope
to travel further north and to return to Aberdeen on a whaling ship from Cum-
berland Sound.

The first meeting of the Jersey Natural Science Association was held on
August 5, Dr A. C. Godfray in the chair. The attendance was small but
enthusiastic, and included many well-known names. We wish the Association
every success, but hope they will not find the usual trouble arising from the pro-
posed library and museum.

Among those visiting Russia during the meeting of the Seventh International
Geological Congress at St Petersburg are :— Dr John Ball, Mr L. Belinfante, Mr
F. A. Bather, Prof. J. F. Blake, Mr J. H. Cooke, Mr P. Emary, Mr L. Fletcher, Sir
Archibald Geikie, Mr Upfield Green, Mr G. F. Harris, Dr Frazer Hume, Prof.
M'Kenny Hughes, Mr Philip Lake, Mr D. A. Louis, Mr Henry Louis, Prof.
Sollas, Dr P. L. Sclater, Mr G. A. Stonier, Mr J. J. H. Teall, Prof. II. G. Seeley,
Mr H. Bauerman, and Dr Wheelton Hind.

1897] NEWS 213

The British Museum (Natural History) has acquired the Savin collection of
vertebrate remains from the Norfolk forest-bed and other deposits of that coast.
A collection of gault fossils from the 300 feet level of the shaft of the Dover coal-
field has also been received, and Ave understand that the whole of the remains
from this very interesting and important shaft will be preserved for the national
collections, as a typical reference series for the underground geology of the S.E.
of England.

The new Botanical Garden of New York will be on an imposing scale,
rivalling the new Zoological Garden which Dr Sclater recently described in these
pages (Natural Science,\ol. xi., p. 36). The coniferous trees will occupy thirty acres,
the deciduous trees more than seventy acres ; the space for the herbaceous plants
will be not less than eight acres, while the bog-plants alone will cover five acres.
The area of the lakes and ponds will be six acres. The museum will have a
frontage of 300 feet, with two wings, each 200 feet in length.

We learn from Science that an important change has been effected in the
administration of the U.S. National Museum. Acting upon the advice of Hon.
Chas. D. Walcott, at present assistant-secretary of the Smithsonian Institute,
three sections have been formed — the section of anthropology, with Dr W. H.
Holmes, of the Field Columbian Museum of Chicago, as head curator ; that of
geology, with head curator Dr George Merrill ; and of biology, with Dr Frederick
W. True as curator.

Harvard University has received under the will of Mr A. W. Thayer
$30,000 as an endowment fund to assist poor students. University College,
Liverpool, receives £7000 as becpxest from Mrs Gee for the advancement of the
medical department. It has been decided to institute a Bobert Gee fellowship in
anatomy of £100 a year and four entrance scholarships of £25 each for one year.
Yale University receives land valued at $25,000 by the will of Dr J. T. Atwater
of Foughkeepsie ; and the Ohio State University an estate left by the late Mr
Henry F. Page.

The following have received awards from the Academy of Sciences at Berlin
to assist them in their researches : — Prof. Engler, 2000M. (for African botany) ;
Dr B. Hesse, 500M. (eyes of lower marine animals) ; Prof. H. Hiirthle, 850M.
(muscles) ; Prof. Cohen, 1500M. (meteorites) ; Dr G. Lindau, 900M. (lichens) ;
Prof. B. Bonnet, 800M. (for a work on blood-vessels) ; Dr L. Wulff, 1500M.
(artificial crystals) ; Dr Liihe, 2000M. (fauna of North African salt lakes) ; Prof.
F. Freeh, 1500M. (geology) ; and Dr G. Brandes, 300M. (Nemertina).

The Lancet announces that Prof. Engelmann, the successor of Dr du Bois-
Beymond as Professor of Physiology at Berlin, is about to make some alterations
in the Institute. Of the four departments, those for microscopical and biological
work and for chemical physiology will continue with their present directors.
Prof. Engelmann intends to enlarge the department for special physiology, and
to share the work of direction with Dr Hermann Munk. The department for
physical physiology will for the future be known as the Department for the
Physiology of the Sensory Nerves. Prof. Konig, director of the last-mentioned
department, will lecture upon the sensory organs during the last four weeks of
summer, and Prof. Thierfelder, of the department for chemical physiology, during
the first four weeks of winter, on physiological chemistry.

The Fifty-Eighth Annual Beport of the Boyal Botanic Society shows a much
more favourable prospect. The lease of the Gardens in Begents Park has been re-
newed for a further term of twenty-one years. The Council has decided to open a
school of practical gardening, granting certificates to gardeners, and the material

214 NATURAL SCIENCE • [September

for practice is assuredly ready to hand. This new school has been officially recog-
nised by the Technical Education Board, who have voted £100 to the Society in
aid of the scheme. The Council further intends to establish an institute for the
teaching of botany and for promoting original research ; but as this is a bold and
ambitious scheme, outside aid will be necessary to give it a practical effect.

M. Henri de la Vaulx, now travelling in Patagonia, has written to the
Societe" de Geographie de Paris from Rawson, the capital of Chubut. He has
visited the Monsonero Indians, where he has found a tolderia 18 leagues south of
Keurskeule. The cacique, Sayhueke, received him with great cordiality, and he
witnessed a komaruko, a religious fete. M. de la Vaulx has made an ethno-
graphical collection and taken some photographs. On the shore of Lake Colhue
the explorer discovered ancient stone sepulchres, in which he found a skeleton
almost perfect, as well as ten skulls of Telhuelche Indians. There were a large
number of arrowheads, knives, and stone boleadoros. These discoveries will prove
of great importance to the study of the ancient peoples of Chubut.

In connection with the South-Eastern Union of Scientific Societies, a section for
geological photographs has just been established. Its objects are : — (1) To stimu-
late interest in the observation and recording of geological phenomena ; (2) to
form annually a set of lantern slides dealing with some part of the geology of the
south-east of England, and to circulate these, with an explanatory lecture, among
the affiliated societies during the winter session ; (3) to form a permanent collec-
tion of geological slides and photographs ; (4) to contribute to the national
collection of geological photographs now being formed at the Jermyn Street
Museum under the auspices of the British Association. Particulars as to the
work may be obtained from Mr H. E. Turner, the hon. secretary, Bank Street,
Ashford, Kent.

The Bill which the Duke of Devonshire presented to the House of Lords
concerning the University of London has been withdrawn for the Session. It
proposes to appoint the following Commissioners : — Lord Davey (chairman), the
Bishop of London, Lord Lister, Sir William Roberts, M.D., Sir Owen Roberts,
Professor Jebb, and Mr E. H. Busk, whose powers continue till Dec. 31, 1898,
and whose duty is "to make statutes and regulations for the University of
London in general accordance with the scheme of the report " presented by the
previous Commissioners, with any " modification which may appear to them ex-
pedient after considering the changes which have taken place in London educa-
tion of a university type since the date of the report, &c." The Bill provides that
"after the expiration of the powers of the Commissioners, the Senate of the
University shall have power to make statutes and regulations for altering or
supplementing any of the statutes or regulations made by the Commissioners."
The Senate, consisting of the Chancellor and fifty-five other members, to be
nominated by the Crown and certain learned and public bodies, " shall be the
supreme governing body and executive of the University. All University pro-
perty shall be administered by the Senate, and the Senate shall have the entire
conduct of the University and all its affairs and functions, provided always that
no religious test shall be adopted, and no applicant for a University appointment
shall be at any disadvantage on the ground of religious opinions ; no procedure
to a higher degree shall be allowed without examination or other adequate test,
nor shall any honorary or ad etindem degree be conferred unless the Senate, in
exceptional cases, think fit to confer such a degree on a teacher of the University ;
no disability shall be imposed on the ground of sex."

1897] 215

CORRESPONDENCE

WOMEN WITH BEARDS

The idea of the woman of the future having a beard, noticed in Natural Science, vol.
xi., p. 2, as set forth by Dr A. Brandt, is scarcely new. If it is not definitely stated
by Darwin in his " Descent of Man," at any rate it is an obvious conclusion from what
he has to say concerning the appearance of distinctive masculine characters, such as
horns, sometimes in the male sex only, sometimes in both sexes. The appearance of the
beard in Homo is quite analogous to that of horns in other animals ; and just as horns
have apparently been acquired b}r the females of certain species by what may be called
"inherited transference " from the males, so will beards be obtained in time by the
future females of Homo.

I thought I had actually drawn attention to this matter of beards in "Some Laws
of Heredity" (Proc. Cotteswold Field Club, vol. x., 1892), but I cannot find it. I
had it and the case of horns, etc., in my mind when I wrote therein (p. 275), "A
marked character of the male sex . . . being transmitted in accordance with the law
of earlier inheritance, ultimately appears early in life in the male. Then the character
tends to appear in the female sex also, though why it does so is not clear." Also the
transference may be from female to male, which would appear to be the case with
rudimentary mamma in the male of Homo.

Let me point out another biological aspect of the case : — Facial hairiness is ex-
hibited more by the unmarried than by the married women. It seems that each woman
receives from her male parent latent beard-characters. If she have children she
certainly transmits such characters to them. If she has no offspring it seems that the
characters tend to develop in her own person. So it will be in the old woman, and not
in the "new woman " of the future, that the beard will be most prominent — a startling
retribution that the most masculine characters should appear in those who are the
greatest old maids. S. S. Buckman.

Cheltenham.

CHEMISTRY IN MUSEUMS

In his notice of the " Report of the Proceedings of the Museums Association," 1896
(Natural Science, voL xi., p. 132), Dr R. H. Traquair, after referring to my paper on
" Chemistry in Museums " as carrying " the educational theory of museums to a pitch
of absurdity," goes on to say: " A collection of metals, salts, &c, is no doubt a desirable
feature in connection with the chemical department of a school or college, but you will
learn chemistry only in the laboratory, and certainly not in a museum." The phrase
"pitch of absurdity " is too often on the lips and on the pen points of scientific men, and
coming from the quarter whence it does is only a too effective means of killing sugges-
tions which might possibly lead to beneficial improvements. As to the sentence I have
quoted, one might generalise in the same heedless fashion about any of the sciences
which museums seek to illustrate. But it is not intended in these institutions to supply
a complete course of study in any branch of science, but to place such illustrations of
them before the public as will be helpful to those interested in the study. Hundreds of
cases of stuffed birds and mammals will not teach the science of zoology ; all the dried
plants and wood sections in the museums of Europe will not teach the science of botany,
nor can we learn palaeontology by looking at a fossil Glyptolaemus in a museum case.
These sciences also can only be "learnt in the laboratory." Would Dr Traquair on
that account refuse the stuffed bird or mammal, the dried plant and the fossil, a place
in the museum ? Do not the many mineralogical cases which litter the floors of museums
contain simply "a collection of metals, salts, &c." ? and these teach, if they teach any-
thing at all, a very little of the science of chemistry. Is Dr Traquair of opinion that a
good artificial crystal of common salt is of less educational value than an indifferent
natural crystal of Halite ?

At the time when my paper was written I was fresh from the laboratory of a tech-
nical college, and thought I saw a way to help not only the laboratory student, but
also that larger class which is interested in science but cannot obtain access to the
laboratories. I did not, be it observed, advocate the formation of a new museum de-
partment ; I merely asked for the re-arrangement and extension of a department already
existing in some museums. In the Edinburgh Museum of Science and Art, for instance,

216 NATURAL SCIENCE [September

there is, as far as case-room is concerned, a very fair section devoted to the illustration
of chemical science, hut the arrangement followed is so antiquated, and the specimens
are so few — many of the cases are almost empty — and so little representative, that the
whole thing is distinctly farcical.

It seems to me that men like Dr Traquair, looking down from a great height on the
unscientific rabble, are too much in the habit of dividing the population into three
classes — scientific men, who have little use for museums ; science students, who have
their manuals and their laboratories ; and the general public, who have to be amused
with stuffed animals and big crystals. They forget that large and increasing class, who
are the main support of such papers as Knowledge, Science Gossip, and even Natural
Science, who look, and have a right to look, to museums to illustrate their reading. It
is for this class that museums must cater more and more. The museum of the future,
if it is to be of any educational value whatever, must become the laboratory, the
technical college, the university, of those who have to earn a livelihood by their hands.
Consequently the formation of such a collection as I advocated, were it only in view of
its importance as an adjunct to the evening lecturer, is an absolute necessity.

Kelvingrove Museum, Glasgow. George W. Ord.

Several correspondents have noted an unfortunate misprint which escaped correction
in the June number (vol. x., p. 427, line 34), where "a cross between Myxine and the
cod " ought to read " a cross between the megrim and the cod."

NOTICE.

To the Trade. — Natural Science is published on the 25th of each month ; all
advertisements should be in the Publishers' hands not later than the 20th.

Price of Set of Vols. I., II., III., IV £2 10 0

„ V., VI., VII., VIII. . . .14 0
,, I.— VIII 3 10 0

One Shilling each Number of any Bookseller.

Annual Subscription, payable in advance to J. M. Dent & Co., 67 St James's Street,
London, S.W., Thirteen Shillings ($3 "50), post free.

NATURAL SCIENCE

A Monthly Review of Scientific Progress

No. 68— Vol. XI— OCTOBEE 1897

NOTES AND COMMENTS

The Training of the Biologist

The most striking feature of late in the study of animals, at least in
this country, is the marked tendency of the orthodox school of
teachers to break through the narrow bounds which have confined
them since ' Biology ' replaced the old-fashioned natural history
and comparative anatomy. It is, indeed, strange that while the
methods of Darwin have had such an immense influence upon the
lines of advanced work and research, they should have had so little
effect upon the curriculum of elementary teaching. As Prof. Miall
well said in his recent address to Section I) of the British Asso-
ciation, " the animals set before the young zoologist are all dead ; it
is much if they are not pickled as well. When he studies their
development, he works chiefly or altogether upon continuous sections,
embryos mounted in balsam and wax models. He is rarely encouraged
to observe live tadpoles or third-day chicks with beating hearts. As
for what Gilbert White calls the life and conversation of animals,
how they defend themselves, feed, and make love, this is commonly
passed over as a matter of curious but not very important informa-
tion ; it is not reputed scientific, or at least not eminently scientific."
Finally, as to the inter-relationships of animals, the average graduate
of the orthodox university school is in a state approaching blissful
ignorance. He is usually led, if not actually taught, to look down
with scorn upon the ' systematist.' He imagines he has mastered
the whole of the principles of Biology before he has acquired the
most elementary notions of generic and specific characters and the
phenomena of variation.

There have been two noteworthy utterances on this subject
during the past month, that of Prof. Miall in his Presidential
Address already referred to, and that of Mr Walter Garstang in the
last number of the Quarterly Journal of Microscopical Science (vol.
xl., p. 211). Both urge that the time has arrived for some reform
in the methods of elementary training, and we commend their plea

218 NATURAL SCIENCE [October

to the careful consideration of all teachers interested in the future
progress of biological science.

Mr Garstang gives a practical illustration of the importance of
the study of living animals in his interesting paper " on some modi-
fications of structure subservient to respiration in Decapod Crustacea
which burrow in sand." It is to this that his general remarks are
prefaced, as follows : —

" A good deal of scepticism has been expressed in recent years
by various writers as to the utility of the more trivial features which
distinguish the genera and species of animals from one another. I
do not think that such scepticism can excite much surprise if one
remembers that the vast majority of ' biologists ' are almost ex-
clusively engaged in the study of comparative anatomy and embry-
ology. The amount of attention paid to these branches of biology
has long been utterly out of proportion to the scant attention
devoted to the scientific study of the habits of animals and of the
function of the organs and parts composing their bodies. With
isolated and noteworthy exceptions, the only naturalists who
seriously add to our knowledge of the latter subjects are those who
travel in distant countries, and who are thus thrown into close re-
lations with animals in their native haunts. Yet all the time there
are thousands of forms living on our own coasts and almost at our
very doors of whose detailed habits and life-conditions we know
practically nothing. I venture to think that the time has come
for consideration whether the subject of bionomics (in Prof.
Lankester's sense of the word) should not receive more adequate
recognition than it does at present in the curriculum of our univer-
sities. That such recognition would almost immediately produce
effects in a rapid extension of our knowledge is certain ; and the
subject is invested with so much intrinsic interest, as well as with
such important bearings on the problems of evolution, that I believe
such recognition would also have the effect of attracting many
students to the pursuit of morphology who at present avoid it as a
region of mere comparative anatomy. . . .

" It must in any event, however, remain clear that the great
problems which Darwin left us as his heritage, after so greatly
illuminating them, are not to be solved by the exclusively morpho-
graphical researches which occupy the time and zeal of the great
majority of naturalists to-day. Even in the best of hands such
researches are capable of obscuring even the simple facts of structure
which they profess to elucidate ; while the study of the functional
relations of parts, side by side with the anatomical elucidation of
the parts themselves, provides not only the data for generalisations
of intrinsic importance, but assistance of an invaluable character in
the field of morphological criticism."

1897] NOTES AND COMMENTS 219

The Historical Method in Teaching Biology

Prof. Miall, in his Presidential Address, not only emphasises
the importance of the study of living animals in a manner that will
scarcely bear abstracting, he also adds another important sugges-
tion, that too little attention is bestowed by biological teachers upon
the historical development of the subject. Many students attend
the lectures and demonstrations simply because they are compelled
to do so by the college curriculum or by the exigencies of a certifi-
cate. Those who happen to have no preliminary inclination to the
subject thus find many of the statements of bare facts dull, unin-
teresting, and useless for mental discipline. Suppose that that well-
worn topic, the Alternation of Generations, is being treated. As
Prof. Miall remarks, " the lecturer defines his terms and quotes
his examples ; we have Salpa and Aurclia and the Fern, and as
many more as time allows. How can he expect to interest any-
body in a featureless narrative, which gives no fact with its natural
circumstances, but mashes the whole into pemmican ? What
student goes away with the thought that it would be good and
pleasant to add to the heap of known facts ? The heap seems need-
lessly big already. And yet every item in that dull mass was once
deeply interesting, moving all naturalists and many who were not
naturalists to wonder and delight. The Alternation of Generations
worked upon men's minds in its day like Swammerdam's discovery
of the butterfly within the caterpillar, or Trembley's discovery of
the budding Hydra, which when cut in two made two new animals,
or Bonnet's discovery that an Aphis could bring forth living young
without having ever met another individual of its own species.
All these wonders of nature have now been condensed into glue.
But we can at any time rouse in the minds of our students some
little of the old interest, if we will only tell the tale as it was told
for the first time."

Of course, there are many practical difficulties in carrying out
this suggestion. It entails much reading of ancient literature,
which the ordinary teacher rarely sees. It trespasses upon the
allotted lecture hours, already too short for the material to be
treated. At the same time, if it succeeded in infusing a little
more philosophy into our medical students and others, who are
too apt to look upon the preliminary biological course as drudgery,
it would well repay the additional labour involved in preparation.

The Times on Archaeology

The foregoing matters are of more or less professional interest. So
also are the geological questions — the pre-Cambrian problems of

220 NATURAL SCIENCE [October

Canadian geology — treated by Dr George M. Dawson in his admir-
able address to Section C at Toronto. Sir John Evans' address as
President of the British Association, however, is one to interest
even the least scientific of the general public. It is a valuable
expression of opinion of one of the foremost minds upon the
question of the Antiquity of Man, and recent attempts in Europe
to carry the human period backwards much further than the
Palaeolithic gravels. As might be expected, Sir John Evans'
opinions are conservative. The engraved Pliocene shell, Pcctunculus,
is dismissed with ridicule. For the asserted Indian Miocene man
he accepts the explanation ably advanced in Natural Science by Mr
R D. Oldham ; the form of the fractured flints of the Cromer
Forest Bed he attributes to natural fractures ; he wishes for more
evidence as to the age of the beds which yielded Pithecanthropus
erectus, and the claims advanced in favour of ' Eolithic ' man from
the high level gravels near Sevenoaks, he considers, as he did in
1890, to be still unproved. In all these points we regard Sir
John Evans' scepticism as healthy ; and as he is unquestionably
one of the best living authorities on stone implements, his opinion
must carry great weight. The asserted pre-Glacial man of East
Anglia, based on implements supposed to have been found beneath
the glacial deposits, the recent excavations by Mr Clement Eeid
seem to have conclusively disproved. And in the other cases
referred to the evidence is either wholly discredited or still
inconclusive.

The most remarkable expression of opinion called forth by
this learned and calmly scientific exposition of the facts was an
astounding leading article in The Times. Most of the scientific
members of the staff of that paper seem to have gone to
Canada, and the reactionary journalists apparently resolved to
make the most of their opportunity. Accordingly, we read con-
cerning archaeology, in the first leading article of August 19th,
that —

" All its speculations upon neolithic and palaeolithic man are
founded upon a single observation, as yet completely unrelated, save
by the loosest conjecture, with any other portion of human know-
ledge. That observation is that flints, chipped or polished in a
manner for which natural agencies do not seem to account, have
been found in certain deposits at widely-separated points on the
surface of the globe. That they were chipped by man as we know
him is a mere conjecture. How they came to be so widely dis-
tributed is a question that baffles even the licence of surmise.
Geology does not attempt to fix within a thousand centuries the
age of the beds in which they are found ; and geological specula-
tions themselves rest upon assumptions which may be plausible

1897]: NOTES AND COMMENTS 221

where all real knowledge is wanting, but which can never be scien-
tifically verified. Attentive perusal of Sir John Evans' address
itself suffices to show that archaeology is in no sense a science, but
rather a recondite and remote branch of historical speculation."

This extract is long, but it is worth reprinting, since it is a sad
reminder of how slowly knowledge of the elementary facts of science
really spreads. After this, it is perhaps unnecessary to consider
any of The Times later criticisms of the President's address or of
his proposed Imperial Ethnographic Bureau. It was, however,
unfortunate that Sir John Evans should have prejudiced his pro-
posal by suggesting that the work might be undertaken by the
Imperial Institute.

The Mammals of the Lost Antarctic Continent

As soon as space permits, we hope to publish some further interest-
ing contributions to our knowledge of primaeval man and the ques-
tion of his antiquity. This month we go a little further back in
the history of the mammalia, and print a translation of an import-
ant address to the New University of La Plata by Dr Elorentino
Ameghino, which is liable to be overlooked in its separate form in
the original Spanish. We do not pretend to endorse his conclusions;
we look upon some of them, indeed, as visionary speculations. But
during the past ten years the brothers Ameghino have done more
than anyone else — not even excepting the eminent Director of the
Museum La Plata (Dr F. P. Moreno) — to elucidate the geology and
the mammalian fossils ; and Dr Florentino Ameghino, who is an
accomplished zoologist and comparative anatomist, commands a re-
spectful hearing, if only on account of the remarkable contributions
he has made to our knowledge of the Tertiary mammals and birds.
We have already referred to the progress of his researches on several
occasions in Natural Science.

It is well known that, according to our present information, the
chief types of the higher mammals all suddenly appear both in
Europe and North America at the dawn of the Tertiary period.
We are acquainted with old land surfaces of the late Secondary
period in both countries, but hitherto we have not found a trace of
the ancestors of the higher Tertiary mammals on any of them. Dr
Ameghino now claims to have discovered these long-lost ancestors of
the Cretaceous period in Patagonia. He believes in the theory of
an Antarctic Continent, which split up at the beginning of the
Tertiary period into South America, New Zealand, Australia, South
Africa, and less important islands. Here he considers that the
Mesozoic ancestors of the mammals were evolved. He believes that
they first wandered into the Euro-Asiatic Continent at the end of

222 NATURAL SCIENCE [October

the Cretaceous period from South Africa, which then became
directly connected with the lands of the northern hemisphere.
These mammals passed directly from the Euro-Asiatic Continent by
a land-bridge into North America. Then the isthmus of Panama
was formed, and many of the later Tertiary mammals were able to
wander back to the land of their primeval ancestors in the direction
of Patagonia.

The theory is a pretty one, and we only wish the facts support-
ing it were more convincing ; for some theory of this kind would
explain many mysteries in the distribution of animals. For our own
part, we cannot recognise the very antique and ancestral features
which Dr Ameghino perceives in his ' Pyrotherium- fauna ' from
Patagonia ; but we must await the promised memoir in which the
remarkable new mammals in question are to be fully described.

The Geology of Patagonia

The interest aroused in the age of the tertiary deposits of
Patagonia will be still further fostered by a forthcoming paper
by Mr J. B. Hatcher of Princeton University, who visited the
district in 1896. Mr Hatcher has already recorded a few notes
in the American Journal of Science for September. In south
latitude 51° 31/ he discovered, near Cape Fairweather, a series of
marine beds with a fairly abundant invertebrate fauna, overlying
the Santacruzian formation, which in that locality are well-de-
veloped and full of fossil mammals. These Fairweather beds, as
Mr Hatcher has named them, have been deposited upon an eroded
surface of the Santacruzian formation, and consist of some 30 to 40
feet (as at present observed). The lower part is fine-grained,
incoherent sandstone, the upper a coarse, loose, but in places an
extremely hard conglomerate, which passes insensibly into the
overlying Patagonian shingle formation, from which it can only be
distinguished by the fossils it contains. The marine invertebrata,
according to Prof. Pilsbury, point to a Pliocene age, but they do
not promise to be of much service in determining the vexed question
of the age of the Santacruzian beds. Mr Hatcher at present believes
that the Fairweather beds are the equivalent of those beds dis-
covered by Darwin in North -Eastern Tierra del Fuego, and pro-
visionally referred by him to the Santacruzian beds discovered by
Fitzroy at the mouth of the Gallegos river, and he has, in support
of his view, fragments of crabs' legs very similar to those which
occur in the bluffs of San Sebastian Bay. The general dip of the
strata also lends colour to his deductions. We shall await with
interest the more detailed report which Mr Hatcher promises.

1897] NOTES AND COMMENTS 223

The Sirenian Mammals

The want of all definite knowledge of the ancestry of the
Tertiary land-mammals is strange. Our absolute ignorance of the
origin of the marine mammals like the whales, dolphins, and sea-
cows is still stranger. Marine deposits of the Cretaceous and early
Eocene periods are recognised nearly all over the world, but not a
trace of the Cetacea and Sirenia has been found in them. So far as
known, these curious types appear fully evolved at the top of the
Eocene.

Nor does embryology help us much. It has shed a little light
upon the nature of the Cetacea ; we might therefore expect some
information from this source concerning the Sirenia. Thus far, how-
ever, the results are small, and Prof. Willy Kukenthal's new memoir
on the Sirenia (in Semon's " Zoologische Forschungsreisen in Aus-
tralien und dem Malayischen Archipel," vol. iv., lief. 1), which is
one of the most important monographs issued during the past month,
does not contribute much to the solution of the great problem.
The available material, it is true, is small — only four stages of
Halicore and six stages of Manatus — and only three chapters
(external form, integument, and dentition) are published. It is a
most important contribution to the facts of the case, and for this
alone we must at present remain grateful.

The Origin of the Irish Fauna

Not only is it almost impossible as yet to fathom the mysteries
connected with the dawn of the present order of things in the dis-
tribution of life on the various land-areas ; it is very difficult to
discover the routes of the migration and distribution of organisms
even during comparatively modern periods. During the last few
years, however, much attention has been paid to the relations of the
existing faunas and progress made in the determination of their
affinities. Among others, many Irish naturalists have discussed in a
very interesting manner the relations of the fauna of their island,
and have arrived at various conclusions, some of which may prove
to be of permanent value.

Quite recently Dr E. F. Scharff, Keeper of the Natural History
Collections in the Dublin Museum, has returned to the subject, and
published an interesting paper in the Proceedings of the Eoyal
Irish Academy (ser. 3, vol. iv., No. 3, 1897, pp. 427-514). The
contribution is lengthy, and it is written in a somewhat disconnected
style ; and how the author gets from his premises to his conclusions
is not always apparent. Dr Scharff argues that part of the Irish
fauna lived in Ireland in pre-glacial times ; that the lower con-

224 NATURAL SCIENCE [October

tinental boulder-clay is Pliocene ; and that it is a marine formation
deposited in a great sea which covered a large tract of Eussia and
Central Asia ; that the Siberian mammals migrated into Western
Europe to the south of this sea ; and that the British Pleistocene
fauna and flora do not indicate former Arctic conditions in this
country. The range of subjects discussed in this memoir is con-
siderable. The conclusions are startling, but only when considered
apart from the statements on which they are based. " The occur-
rence in almost all the English boulder-clays of marine shells " is an
example of Dr Scharff s sensational statements. The paper cannot
be discussed in a short notice. Our chief fear is that Dr Scharff' s
speculations will prejudice the use of zoological distribution in
geological investigation.

Franz Josef Land

Captain PlObertson, the enterprising commander of the whaler
Balacna, has given an interesting description of his voyage this
summer to Franz Josef Land. His geographical discoveries are
interesting. He found some new islands on the south coast, but his
most important achievement was returning westward from Franz
Josef Land along the 79 th parallel of latitude. He thus passed
over the site of the two famous islands reported by Johannesen and
Andreassen in 1884 ; but he found no trace of them. The Nor-
wegian seamen must, therefore, have been out in their reckoning.
The sea this summer was exceptionally free from ice, and the polar
pack had receded far to the north. Captain Eobertson thinks that
in such a ship as the Balacna the whole Franz Josef Land archi-
pelago could be charted in a single summer. This opinion renders
the results of the Jackson-Harmsworth expedition all the more dis-
appointing so far as can be judged from the accounts already pub-
lished. But now that the expedition has returned we may hope for
a final account of its work by the members themselves. Perhaps
this may remove the somewhat widespread prejudice roused by the
unjust publication of private letters and the injudicious advertise-
ment of the London agents. The expedition is said to have cost
some £49,000. We hope Mr Harmsworth is satisfied.

Mimicry and Protective Colouration

The questions of protective colouration and mimicry have a
perennial interest for naturalists and the general public. Now that
the conclusions of Trimen, Bates, and Wallace are being dogmatically
taught in magazine articles and popular books, it is only to be ex-
pected that they should begin to be discredited by some of the
younger school of biologists, and several of the works attacking the

1897] NOTES AND COMMENTS 225

' orthodox ' theories have been noticed in Natural Science. In de-
fence of the old positions we notice a short paper by Mr F. M.
Webster of Ohio, in the Keport of the Entomological Society of
Ontario for 1896 (pp. 80-86). The author minimises the value of
experiments, tending to show that insects with ' warning ' colours
are not always distasteful. He points out that the fact that Prof.
Plateau enjoyed feeding on the caterpillars of the magpie moth
does not prove them palatable to more usual enemies. No insect
is so familiar an example of ' warning ' colour as the North
American danaid butterfly, Anosia archippus. Mr Webster narrates
an instance of a number of these butterflies being eaten by mice in
Texas, and tells how he himself observed a colony of brightly-
coloured cabbage bugs (Margantia histrionica) devoured by the same
rodents. But he believes that mice must be very exceptional
enemies to these species, and that the bright colours may be of
' warning ' value to animals that eat insects habitually.

The same author in another paper (Journal New York Entom.
Soc, 1897, pp. 67-77) deals with the mental or instinctive factors
in protective resemblance. It is well known that in addition to
the form and colour of the insect, a special attitude or a position on
some particular background of leaf or twig is essential to the per-
fection of the illusion. Mr Webster believes that such habits have
not been developed without the action of some conscious will and
intelligence on the part of the creatures concerned. He compares
the young twig-like caterpillar to the human infant who has
inherited none of the accumulated knowledge of his ancestors,
though he has inherited an aptitude for learning.

The Effect of Civilisation on the North American Insect

Fauna

Another subject of general interest, lately dealt with by Mr
Webster (Fifth Annual Report of the Ohio State Academy of Science),
is the effect of civilisation on the insect fauna of North America.
In few other parts of the world has so rapid a change been made in
the natural aspect of the country by the advent of the pioneer and
the farmer, and the transformation of swamps and forests into cul-
tivated fields has led to the extinction of many native species of
insects. Some species, however, have adapted themselves to the
changed conditions, while a considerable introduction of Tropical
and European forms has been a direct result of the advance of
civilisation. Mr Webster rightly lays stress on the importance of
systematic observations on the natural history of new countries,
wherever possible, before the balance of nature has been disturbed
by the advent of the white man.

226 NATURAL SCIENCE [October

ASPIDIOTUS

The San Jose" scale (Aspidiotus pemiciosus) is a subject of perennial
interest to the American entomologists. Last year the U.S. Depart-
ment of Agriculture issued a pamphlet by Messrs Howard and Marlatt
on the spread of the insect in the States, and now from the same
Department we receive a bulletin (No. 6 Technical Series) on
the systematic position of the scale, and the structural points which
distinguish it from its allies. This work is from the pen of Mr
T. D. A. Cockerell, and it will prove of great value to the student
of the coccids, as it contains not only full descriptions and figures of
A. pemiciosus and the species nearly related to it, but a geographical
list of all the described species of Aspidiotus, with a short summary
of their characters.

Care of the Brood in Holothurians

Prof. Hubert Ludwig of Bonn writes to the Zoologischer Anzeiger to
say that he is able to record an antarctic Chirodota, in which the
care of the brood is well marked. The species is Chirodota co7itorta,
was described in 187-4, and forms an abundant part of the material
obtained by the Hamburg-Magellan Collecting Expedition. Prof.
Ludwig says that in this species he has discovered a form of care of
the brood previously unknown among echinoderms. In the female
(the sexes are separate in the species) the genital canals themselves
become receptacles for the brood, and the entire development is
passed through within them. The young at 3 mm. in length are
born through the genital aperture ; they have then seven tentacles,
and the ' wheels ' and ' hooks ' are already well developed.
Further details of this discovery of Prof. Ludwig's will appear in
his forthcoming memoir on Antarctic Holothuria.

SOLIFUGAE

When revising a genus or describing a whole series of new genera
and species, the average describer looks upon all details of habit or
economy as beneath his notice. Not so Mr E. I. Pocock, who
frequently appends to his papers notes as interesting to the general
reader as important to the cabinet naturalist. In the September
number of the Annals and Magazine of Natural History Mr Pocock
deals with the group Solifugae, which contains arachnida of the
genera Galeodes, Solpuga, etc., coming from tropical Africa. After
a revision of the family and a description of the genera and species
we find a note on the sound produced by a Natal species of Solpuga.

1897]

NOTES AND COMMENTS 227

Mr G. H. K. Marshall, the observer, seems inclined to attribute the
sound produced to "trituration of the creature's powerful jaws
against the hard ground in which they seem to prefer to dig their
holes, the operation being performed with the jaws, and the sound
ceasing when the spider stops digging." Although Mr Marshall
kept them alive he failed to detect any stridulation, though they
made a considerable noise by energetically biting at the sides of the
boxes, one of them nearly succeeding in escaping by gnawing its way
through at one spot. A further note is to the effect that the
Solfugae succumb more rapidly to the cyanide bottle than the ordinary
spiders or scorpions ; and Mr Pocock, in emoting Mrs Monteiro, to
the effect that a large black scorpion was confined eight hours in a
strong poison bottle before it succumbed, states that this is no doubt
due to the fact of the richer development of the respiratory system
in Solpuga. A further note of Mr Marshall's corroborates Hutton's
observation as to the use of the terminal organ on the palpus. This
is a gelatinous fan-shaped sucker with which the animal has the
power of picking up objects, probably prey, and conveying them to
its mandibles. The principal food of the Solpugae, according to
Mr Marshall, are termites, " a small species which makes no mound,
but builds mud tunnels along the surface of the ground among dead
leaves, sticks, etc. When the Solpuga comes across such tunnelling
it examines along it carefully, then suddenly breaks through the
mud and extracts a termite, the presence of which it detects, I
suppose, by either hearing or touch."

The evidence as to the poisonous nature of these animals varies.
A Kaffir boy declared them very poisonous, sometimes fatally so,
and a bite supposed to be from S. darlingii did not subside till the
fourth day ; on the other hand, Mr J. M. Hutchinson of Estcourt,
Natal, finds the bite of & hustilis " to be quite harmless, the forceps
being unable to pierce the tenderest skin."

The British Pleistocene Mollusca

In 1890 a valuable summary of the Pleistocene (non-marine)
mollusca of the London district was published in the Proceedings of
the Geologists' Association by Mr B. B. Woodward. This paper treated
the material from a geographical point of view, describing the geology
of the localities where the shells were found, and concluded with a
valuable table of distribution, in which were distinguished the living
and extinct species. It was hoped that Mr Woodward would extend
his researches into other districts, and we have now to welcome a
second paper by Mr A. S. Kennard and himself, to which Mr W. M.
Webb has contributed, on the Post-Pliocene (non-marine) mollusca
of Essex (Essex Naturalist, x., pp. 87-109). This paper is treated

228 NATURAL SCIENCE [October

in practically the same way as the former, with the addition of a
bibliography, and deals with that important series of shells obtained
by the late John Brown of Stanway at Copford, as well as series
from many other deposits. The mere mention of Grays, Ilford, and
Clacton, as some of these other deposits, will show at once the special
interest of the paper to London geologists and conchologists.

Among the more interesting notes given to us is the confirmation
of the rarity of Helix hortensis in a fossil state ; the absence of H.
pomatia ; the occurrence of II. aspera in the Lea Valley ; the
elimination of Eulota fruticum from the recorded fauna of Copford ;
the restriction of the distribution of Pomatias elegans ; and the
observation as to the increased size of Hdicclla caperata since
Pleistocene times.

We have now a great advance in our knowledge of the geo-
logical history of the non-marine mollusca of our home district ;
and though some of the names in Messrs Kennard and Woodward's
list may be a little startling to the uninitiated, we are glad to see a
possible termination of the confused nomenclature which has
prevailed for so many years.

Triassic Cephalopoda

The description of Triassic Cephalopods occupies an important part
of the recently-issued volume of the Denkschr. d. h. Akarl. Wissensch.,
Wien. Franz v. Hauer, who has been contributing to the literature
of Triassic Cephalopods for more than thirty years, and although
now considerably past his threescore years and ten, furnishes a
paper on the Trias Cephalopods of Bosnia. This author has already
described Triassic Cephalopods from this region, but he now records
from a new locality both Nautiloids and Ammonoids, among the
latter being the new genus Bosnites. Dr E. von Mojsisovics, so
well known for his work on the Trias Cephalopods, contributes a
very important paper on the Upper Triassic Cephalopod-fauna of
the Himalaya. It is based not only upon the older collections
made by Strachey, Stoliczka, and Griesbach, but also upon the rich
collection obtained by Messrs Griesbach, Middlemiss, and Dr Diener
during their expedition into the Central Himalaya in the year
1892. As was to be expected, many new species are described and
not a few new genera are proposed. The author points out that
there is a marked contrast between the Upper Triassic fauna of the
Indian province and the homotaxial fauna of the Mediterranean
province, but he believes there was a sea connection between the
two regions during Upper Triassic times, and is of opinion that an
examination of the intervening districts will probably render the
provincial character of these two regions less apparent.

18971 NOTES AND COMMENTS 229

Lobster Fishery

Me -I ames Hoknell has contributed two long letters to the Jersey
Times and the Jersey Evening Post relative to the Lobster
Fishery of the ' Channel Islands. There is a marked and general
decrease in the size of the catches, and some arrangements are
needful for regulating and preserving the supply. Mr Hornell is
of the opinion that the geographical position of the Channel Islands
precludes — in view of the powerful currents sweeping their coasts —
any useful purpose being served by the hatching and liberation of
fry, wherever fry are surface swimmers for any considerable length
of time. He does not forget in his argument that the currents
may reverse their direction at regular times, but urges the import-
ance of a detailed and exact investigation of current action around
the islands before costly means are undertaken for stocking pur-
poses. And at the same time he casts doubts from his own obser-
vation on the accepted idea that the young lobster is a pelagic
animal, because he has found that in some experiments he has made
that while he lost most of the fry by the surface pipe of his
aquarium, those of the age of three days seemed inclined to sink
to the bottom and abandon a surface life. Again, Mr Hornell has
never once taken lobster fry in his almost continuous towings with
fine muslin nets on the south coast of Jersey, while the fry of
crabs, prawns, and Squilla occur in countless thousands. His
method for the improvement and protection of the Lobster Fishery
would be to rigidly enforce the protection of the berried female
and all lobsters under nine inches, rather than to commence a
nursery, both costly and difficult to manage. At the same time, if
experiment were to prove the non-pelagic nature of the fry, then
culture and liberation might be useful, in addition to the protective
regulations referred to above.

'o*

Pre-Cambrian (?) Radiolaria in Australia

Prof. Edgeworth David and Mr Walter Howchin announce in the
Proceedings of the Linnean Society of New South Wales, pt. 4, 1896,
the discovery of Ptadiolaria in rocks of supposed Pre-Cambrian age
in the neighbourhood of Hallett's Cove, about fifteen miles S.S.W.
from Adelaide. The fossils occur in a dark, greenish-grey silicious
limestone, and in a fine-grained laminated grey clay-shale, but they
are very obscure and badly preserved.

Although no other fossils have been found at Brighton and
Crystal Brook in the rocks in which the Padiolaria occur, there is a
rich and abundant fauna in the Cambrian series of the district ; but

230 NATURAL SCIENCE [October

in a subsequent note to this paper the authors state that they have
found a great number of ArchacocyatJiinae at Normanville in lime-
stone, which " appears to be conformable to strata which most resemble
those in which the radiolarian casts have been observed." Hence
they are inclined to believe that the Eadiolaria may be in Lower
Cambrian or passage beds rather than Pre-Cambrian.

Freezing of Plants

Messrs G-ustav Fischer, of Jena, have just issued, in book form
(73 pages 8vo), an account of some researches by Prof. Hans
Molisch on the freezing of plants. The author, by means of an
arrangement which he describes in the first chapter, has observed
under the microscope the changes which occur in freezing not only
in plant-cells and tissues, but also in colloidal substances, emulsions,
coloured liquids, and salt-solutions. For observation the microscope
is placed in a triple box. The outer case is of wood, then comes a
hollow-walled zinc chamber, inside which is fitted the instrument,
the tube projecting through the top. Sawdust is placed between
the outer wall and the zinc chamber, and the hollow walls of the
latter contain the freezing mixture. A wide zinc tube allows
light to pass from the outside to the reflector. Several figures are
given, showing the appearance of non-living substances as freezing.
In all cases particles of ice are formed by separation of the water,
while the gum, particles of latex or concentrated salt-solution
occupy the intervening spaces. Three figures (p. 17) of an amoeba,
alive, frozen, and thawed respectively, are of interest. In the
frozen state the organism forms a lump of ice intersected with a
highly complicated network, consisting of protoplasm very poor in
water, concentrated cell-sap and air-bubbles. When thawed there
is a much less sharply defined reticulum of dead protoplasm, the
lacunae in which are the spaces which in the frozen state were filled
with ice. Spirogyrci cells (p. 22, fig. 10) in freezing lose about half
their diameter by withdrawal of water, which then freezes on the
outside ; on thawing the cells swell to their original size, but proto-
plasm, chlorophyll band and nucleus form a disorganised central
axis between which and the walls is contained the water.

After experimenting for five winters with hundreds of objects, the
author comes to the conclusion that, as a rule, it is immaterial to the
preservation of the life of the object whether thawing is rapid or
slow, and that death by freezing is the result of an excessive loss of
water, through ice formation, if the protoplasm by which its struc-
ture (" architektur ") is destroyed, and that all the facts of the case
can be easily and natui'ally explained from this point of view.

1897] NOTES AND COMMENTS 231

Funafuti

The third part of the Memoir of the Australian Museum on the Atoll
of Funafuti contains further interesting additions to knowledge of the
zoology of that island. Mr E. R. Waite has described the collection
of mammals, reptiles and fishes made by Mr Hedley. The most
interesting part of Mr Waite's memoir is an account of the habits
of the fruit-eating Pacific rat, for which, following Thomas, he
adopts Peale's name of Inus cxulans. An interesting fact is recorded
in reference to the edibility of fishes : at the time the expedition was
on Funafuti the natives would only eat fish caught in the lagoon,
all those from the reefs being condemned. The native explanation
is that the pumice which was then being washed on to the beach ren-
dered the fish poisonous ; but as the pumice is harmless, Mr Hedley
concludes that some marine organism arrived with it which rendered
the fish unwholesome. Mr Waite quotes a remark of Wyatt Gills
that good food fish become poisonous by eating the worms of the
genus Nereis. The two species of Enteropneusta collected are
described by Mr J. P. Hill ; one of the two is a new species
(Ptycliodera hedleyi). Mr Whitelegge's account of the Alcyonaria
includes a description of four new species and a redescription of
several previously very imperfectly known. We regret to find that
some remarks concerning the publication of this Memoir, made in
reference to Part II. (Natural Science, July 1897, Vol. xi., p. 5)
were based on a misunderstanding.

lO'

The Great Indian Earthquake

At five o'clock in the afternoon of June 12, 1897, Calcutta and
north-eastern India were startled by an earthquake which is re-
garded as having exceeded even the famous Lisbon earthquake
in the area affected. The Geological Survey of India immedi-
ately set to work to collect the data for a complete investigation.
An immense amount of information has already been obtained,
which it will take considerable time to digest. Sufficient has,
however, been done to enable Mr R. D. Oldham to contribute a
preliminary note to the Records of the Geological Survey. The
area affected by the shock included more than a million and a
quarter square miles, while its effects appear to have been felt
even in Edinburgh and Rome. The shock was most destructive
in Assam : at Shillong in the Khasi Hills it is said that hardly
one stone has been left standing on another. Heaps of road metal
have been scattered into layers a few inches deep. All masonry has
been shattered into pieces, so that the roofs fell bodily down on
to heaps of ruins. A cylinder seismometer had fortunately been

2 32 NATURAL SCIENCE [October

erected at Shillong in 1882, and this was thrown to the north-
east : it enables the velocity of the wave to be calculated. The
range of motion is estimated at 7*4 inches. So Mr Oldham con-
cludes that " the violence of the shock at Shillong was at least
equal to a backward and forward shake of 7 inches repeated sixty
times a minute." All telegraphic communication was of course
destroyed, and the accompanying illustration (reproduced from
a plate of the Indian Survey Eecords) shows the effect on the
railway lines produced by the movement of the surface soil. The
rate of transmission of the shock was over 100 miles a minute.
The fuller account promised will be awaited with much interest,
for it will probably yield suggestive information as to whether the
Himalayan movements are still in progress. It is fortunate that
the work will be carried on under the supervision of Mr Oldham,
who is keenly interested in all the broader problems connected with
seismic movements.

Geology in New South Wales

The most noteworthy point in the recently issued Eeport of the
Geological Survey of New South Wales is the discovery of Devonian
plant remains and Lower Silurian graptolites by Mr Joseph Carne.
This is the first identification of Lower Silurian Eocks in the
Colony, and they are of special interest in that they contain in the
neighbouring Colony of Victoria the famous saddle reefs of Bendigo.
The graptolites were found in a black slate in the Parish of Lawson,
Wellesley Co., and occur as shiny films. Mr W. S. Dun identifies
them as Didymograptus furcatus (Hall), D. cxtcnsus (Hall), Dicrano-
graptus, Diplograptm, and Phyllograptus. The Devonian plants
comprise a Pecopterid fern and a Sphenoptcris. They came from
Genoa Eiver, Co. Auckland.

NATURAL SCIENCE, VOL. XI.

Plate VIII

BRIDGE ACROSS NALLAH AT HALDIBARI

LINK BETWEEN HALDIBARI AND MOGHAL HAT

575.1 233

The Fundamental Principles of Heredity

IN the recent elaboration of the Theory of Descent, as first fully
published by Charles Darwin, two schools of thought have
arisen. The one, though professing discipleship pure and simple,
has laid extreme stress on the principle of Natural Selection, which
owes so much to Darwin, but has rejected his belief in the
internal tendencies of races to vary in adaptation to changed
surroundings ; while the other has attributed the greater share in
the transformation of species to the latter factor, and sent Natural
Selection in the background. The two most illustrious leaders
of scientific thought have been August Weismann on the one side
and Herbert Spencer on the other. Their debates have long since
obtained an audience among the cultured laity ; but while the
arguments are well known, some of the most important facts have
been rather taken for granted than fully stated and clearly co-or-
dinated even in the scientific press. I allude especially to the
coarser relations of the actual mechanism of reproduction and of
the act of transmission from one generation to the next of the
form which clothes on or assumes the parental characters. Such
an exposition as we have to make cannot be limited to the higher
organisms which are familiar to us in our daily life, for these are
complex elaborations ; while the primitive types, though still existing
abundantly, are only to be studied with the microscope. It is in
this field, hidden if not buried, that we must first labour, if we wish
to rightly understand the foundations of the wonderful superstructure
of the higher Organic Kingdoms. We shall endeavour to use as
few unfamiliar terms as possible, bearing in mind that the reader
has no Handy Atlas to help him in following the exploration of this
foreign country, with its outlandish names.

Only two centuries ago the microscope revealed to mankind an
immense world of minute living creatures as well as the details of the
structure of the familiar Animal and Plants. Naturally enough
the early observers, or ' philosophers,' as they were then called,
inferred that these strange small creatures must have as complex
a structure as our own. They proceeded zealously to search
for, and sometimes to proclaim, the existence therein of brain,
heart, blood-vessels, etc., just like those of ordinary bird, beast, or

234 NATURAL SCIENCE [October

fish.1 Since then we have learned that the ultimate units of
structure of the familiar organisms are identical in character with
the entire organism of one of such microscopic being ; and the
search we have referred to would be now regarded as equivalent to
seeking in a limestone pebble the pillars and buttresses, the vaults
and domes of a great cathedral in miniature. Such units of struc-
ture are called ' cells,' an ill-chosen term indeed, whose signification,
however, as a nucleated unit of protoplasm, is familiar to everyone.
The lower organisms consist of single cells or of aggregates of
similar cells ; the higher ones consist of complicated arrangements of
those dissimilar aggregates of cells which we call tissues. The
former we call Protists, distinguishing between Protozoa and Proto-
phytes according as the mode of existence is animal or plant-like ;
the higher animals and plants we term Metazoa and Metaphytes
respectively, the appropriate conjoint term, ' Metists,' not having
been coined by any recognised authority.

Throughout the higher groups the act of reproduction2 of the
race consists in the separation from the complex organism of single
reproductive cells, which may either independently grow up into the
original form, or else one with another fuse to produce a new cell
which grows up. Again in most Plants and many Animals multi-
cellular portions of the body may become detached, and finally develop
into complete organisms ; this we shall call ' propagation,' not ' repro-
duction.' In either case the parent body continues to exist, alive or
dead, after the detachment of these cells or groups of cells. In Protists,
matters are very different ; for here, when the cell individual has
attained its full size, it usually divides into two new cells, and itself
is no more, alive or dead. We call the original cell a ' mother cell,'
the new ones ' daughter-cell s,' by a convenient metaphor ; but we
must remember that the devoted mother here absolutely merges her
very existence into that of her offspring, a self-denying type of
maternity often imagined but never realised among ourselves. Thus
as Weismann first explicitly stated, the Protists may escape personal
death by the sacrifice of their individual life ; he therefore terms
them 'immortal.' It is with cellular pedigree, according to
the mode of parentage we have just explained, that we shall mostly
have to deal in this paper.

The modes of reproduction among Protists are many and various.

1 Thus Baker writes in the middle of the last century : " Search we further and
examine the Animalcules — many Sorts whereof it would be impossible for an human Eye
unassisted to discern ; those breathing Atoms, so small they are almost all Workman-
ship ! in them too we shall discover the same Organs of Body, Multiplicity of Parts,
Variety of Motions, Diversity of Figures, and Particular Ways of Living as in the
larger Animals. — How amazingly curious must the Internal Structure of these Creatures
be ! The Heart, the Stomach, the Entrails and the Brain. How minute and line the
Bones, Joints, Muscles and Tendons ! How exquisitely delicate beyond all Conception
the Arteries, Veins and Nerves!" ("The Microscope Made Easy," by Henry Baker,
ed. v., 1767.)

- In the limited sense, distinguished from ' propagation,' as defined immediately.

1897] FUNDAMENTAL PRINCIPLES OF HEREDITY 235

The most familiar is the simple halving of the cell each time it has
attained double its original bulk (Herbert Spencer's 'limit of growth'),
a process termed in Hibernian phrase 'multiplication by simple
division.' Sometimes, however, the first division is followed im-
mediately by another, and so on, so as to produce with little delay
grandchildren or great-grandchildren, &c. ; this process is called
' brood-division,' or, when the progeny do not immediately separate,
'segmentation.' Again the progeny of brood-divisions may as-
semble in groups, usually in pairs, which fuse to form a new or
' coup led- cell ' ; this process is called 'conjugation,' or, if the
'pairing-cells' are dissimilar, 'fertilisation.' We must bear
in mind that conjugation processes are not, strictly speaking,
processes of multiplication ; for the act of pairing halves the total
number of cells for the time being, one replacing two: the two
literally become one flesh.

We very often find these three reproductive processes recurring in
cycles, e.g., a succession of simple divisions at the limit of growth is
wound up by brood-formation, and the brood-cells conjugate ; the
coupled-cell then initiates a fresh cycle. But the order of the processes
varies in different cases, and sometimes even different modes of brood
division may alternate. Thus a common Gregarine, parasitic in the
Earthworm, shows the following : after conjugation the coupled-cell
undergoes repeated brood divisions so as to form many hundred of
brood cells ; each of these matures into an oat-shaped body sur-
rounded by a hard shell. After a time the oat-shaped cell divides
again by brood formation into eight sickle-shaped cells, which finally
leave the oat-shaped case and migrate into the living cells of the worm.

In many cases the separation of the daughter- or brood-cells is
not complete, and they remain associated in more or less close union.
Such an assemblage of cells of common origin is called a biological
'colony' in the strict sense, the term 'social aggregate'
being used for an assemblage formed like a human colony by the
flocking together of originally isolated organisms. Protist colonies
may be formed in three ways, the third being only a combination of
the first two :

(1) Cell division, alternating with intervals of growth, gives

rise to daughter-cells which remain united together.

(2) Brood division (segmentation) produces a number of

cells which remain united together.

(3) A colony first formed by segmentation continues to enlarge

by the division after growth of its several cells, the
daughter-cells still remaining connected.
Colonies of the first and third type may be propagated by the

separation of a part of the colony ; if the separated part consist of a

single cell this merges into true reproduction.

236 NATURAL SCIENCE [October

In the most primitive colonial Protist, all the cells of a colony
are practically alike ; and the colony ultimately breaks up into its
individual cells, which reproduce in one or other of the ways de-
scribed above. But in some cases the colonial habit has induced
differentiation among the cells. There is a striking example of this
in Protospongia haeckclii (a small organism found in pond-water by
Savile Kent), which consists of a large mass of cells united by a
gelatinous secretion. Those at the outside of the mass are provided
with a waving lash, the base of which is surrounded by a funnel or
collar of protoplasm. These cells take in the food particles brought
into contact with them by the waving of the lashes in the surround-
ing water ; while the cells at the centre of the colony appear to be
only indirectly nourished by the food, which is digested and trans-
mitted to them from the collared-cells. Our knowledge of the life-
cycle of the organism is still very incomplete, but it appears certain
that only the central-cells can truly act as reproductive cells by
segmentation, while outer-cells may possibly separate to propagate
the race also by the slower process of nutrition and growth, followed
at intervals by simple division. We might almost regard this as a
Metazoon with two tissues — the outer one nutritive, the inner repro-
ductive, and ascribe the specialisation to the relative position of the
two layers : the outer one is favourably situated for obtaining food
from the ambient water ; while the inner, debarred from all activity
by its position, and fed and sheltered from the stress of contact with
the unkind world by the outer layer, devotes its energies to the
reproduction of the species.

Indeed, this organism, as its name implies, is, as it were, a fore-
runner of the Sponges, and probably represents a last survivor of
their ancestral type. For a simple Sponge is a sack attached by
the bottom and widely open above, with the wall pierced by
numerous pores. This wall consists of three layers, an outer
epidermic layer, an intermediate layer, and an inner or stomach
layer, the cells of the last possessing lash and collar. The lashes of
the stomach-cells produce a constant current of sea water through the
sack, which passes in through the pores and out through the mouth,
and brings with it the food particles which the stomach-cells
alone can take up, the two other layers being nourished by them.
In this case it seems that only such fragments of the Sponge as
contain all three layers can propagate it ; and in nature, indeed,
hollow outgrowths of the sack are formed as branches, and may even
be detached as buds. But only the intermediate layer, sheltered as
it is on every side, differentiates certain cells as reproductive-cells.
These by brood divisions produce male and female pairing-cells ; and
the coupled-cell after fertilisation grows up into a fresh Sponge.
We have here a very marked advance on the primitive colonial

1897J FUNDAMENTAL PRINCIPLES OF HEREDITY 237

Protists ; for here the colonial organism can only be propagated by
the co-operation of all three kinds of cells. The individual cell is
no longer a Jack-of-all-trades, but it has been so specialised that it
needs the association and co-operation of cells specialised in other
directions to form a complete self-sufficing organism ; and each kind
of cell can by growth and division only reproduce its own type and
tissue ; but not the complete organism of which it formed a part. This
has been aptly termed by Orpen Bower a process of sterilisation.
We have noted the richer endowment of certain of the inter-
mediate-cells. We must now follow up the fate of the coupled-cell
(fertilised egg, oosperm). This divides afresh repeatedly, and by
its segmentation gives rise to a hollow spherical colony, one hemi-
sphere being composed of smooth cells, while the other is provided
with lashes. The latter now sinks into the former so as to give
the colony the form of a lined skull-cap. The lining is composed

s£omcx,c7\ gbZZs V segme.7i£oc^rcci-rz.

qZccZeT-rrzoc c<>Z£&. ?nzx£cZ£e, ceZ&s

A '

&7~oooZ 6Zii/£sio77s

of collared-cells, which are the stomach-cells; the outer layer of
cells again divides into two layers, the epidermic and middle
cells respectively. This is essentially the processes of reproduction and
early embryonic found growth in all Higher Animals, save that the
middle layer may be formed from the inturned cells instead of, or as
well as, the outer ones, and that the reproductive cells may be formed
in different layers in different classes. The annexed genealogical
table, starting with the coupled-cell and ending with the pairing or
sexual cells, represents the cellular pedigree in a Sponge.1

From the above it is clear that the coupled-cells, though they
are descended from middle-cells only, yet produce by their divisions
offspring that ultimately become cells of kinds which are different,
and have never been in the line of their direct descent. We might
compare this with a race of which the older and the younger

1 In this and the tables to follow we use the signs X to indicate segmentation,
A A to indicate brood divisions, and II to indicate divisions alternating with growth.

238 NATURAL SCIENCE [October

members of a family were always sterile and different in character
and endowments from the intermediate, fertile children, but where
every fertile couple produced among its progeny some resembling
the parents, others with the endowments and characters of the
sterile uncles and aunts ; x we must, however, bear in mind that any
comparison of a strict cellular pedigree with the genealogical table
of the members of a Metazoan race is only an analogy.

While the main features of reproduction in the Higher Animals
run on the same general lines as the Sponges, certain of them may
present differences ; and especially, as above noted, the relation of
the middle and the reproductive cells to those of the two original
germ layers respectively, varies in different groups.

Propagation by budding! in the higher animals, and regener-
ation, or the repair of injuries, are essentially two different aspects
of the same phenomenon. In both cases the cells of one or more
tissues multiply rapidly, and revert more or less closely to the state
they possessed in the developing embryo. In some cases these
' embryonic cells ' can only give rise to tissues like those they
respectively sprung from, or, at least, to tissues belonging to the
same layer ; but in the lowest Worms the middle- cells are capable
of thus forming other layers. In the Vertebrata the regenerative
functions are strictly limited ; thus, if the surface of the skin is
completely removed over an ulcer or burn, the new epidermis only
grows over by gradual extension of the living epidermis at the
edges, not by its direct growth upon the raw. This is the rationale
of the modern practice of ' skin grafts,' which implanted at intervals
over the surface of a healing wound give so many centres for the
new overgrowth of epidermis to start from, thus accelerating the
process of ' skinning over.'

Most tissues of the Higher Animals retain sufficient ' vitality '
to be able to enter at once on processes of regeneration of their own
individual kind in cases of wounds ; and in the Newts, for instance,
even a complete structure like a limb or an eye can be renewed
after amputation. The epiderm of Vertebrates retains in its
deepest layer an almost indefinite power of growth and reproduction,
the cells next the true skin forming a continuous stratum, each cell
of which is constantly growing and dividing, the upper cell at each
division becoming horny, to be ultimately cast off as other horny
cells are formed beneath it, while the lower retains the original
power of growth and division. This layer is absolutely comparable
to the layer of cells that forms cork in most green plants. The
periosteum or layer of cells overlying the bone has similar but less
active powers.

1 The case we have suggested for comparison is actually found in social Insects with
their ' sterile castes ' in each generation.

1897] FUNDAMENTAL PRINCIPLES OF HEREDITY 239

Reviewing the facts, we find that

(i.) In Protista, each cell retains the power of reproducing in
its offspring its own characters or those of a direct ancestral cell,
which we may term the law of direct cellular transmission
uninterrupted or alternating, according as only one or several
alternating modes of cellular reproduction constitute the genetic
cycle.

(ii.) In Metazoa, the power of reproducing a complete organism
is confined to certain reproductive cells, which must beget in their
progeny cells like those which are only related to them collaterally ;
this we call the law of collateral cellular transmission.

(iii.) The remaining cells of the Metazoan can seldom or never
revert closely enough to a primitive type to produce all those other
tissues of which they are collaterals, though their propagative power
may be very great. This limitation of reproductive power we may
call the law of specialised sterility.

(iv.) In most cases of animal budding or repair we find that the
several tissues co-operate to produce a complete organism ; this we
call the law of co-operative propagation.

Marcus Hartog.

(To be continued.)

575 240 [October

575.3

The Place of Isolation in Organic Evolution

ALTHOUGH most writers on evolution mention the subject of
isolation, very few attach much importance to it, Professor
Cope even considering it as a function of natural selection,1 which
is putting the cart before the horse. This neglect of isolation is
probably due to the term ' selection ' having been used in such a
variety of ways and having been made to include almost every
process in evolution, even the origination of variations. But such
indiscriminate use of a word which has a very definite meaning is
objectionable, for it confuses in our minds several totally different
things. To me it seems self-evident that all the known factors of
organic evolution should be arranged under two heads : (1) the
origin of variations capable of being transmitted by amphimixis or
by environment, or by use and disuse, or by any other means ; and
(2) the preservation of variations by isolation or segregation, as it
has also been called. Possibly ' internal tendency,' ' kinetogenesis,'
or ' action of the environment ' may be other causes which tend to
preserve variations, but they have not yet been clearly established as
such, while there is strong evidence in favour of isolation being the
chief, if not the only, cause of the preservation of variations. The
subject of this paper is to point out the important part which
isolation must play in evolution.

Professor Y. Delboeuf has shown 2 that if in any species a
number of individuals, bearing a ratio not infinitely small to the
entire number of births, are in every generation born with a
particular variation, which is neither beneficial nor injurious, and if
it is not counteracted by reversion, then the proportion of the
new variation to the original form will increase until it approaches
infinitely near to equality. Now the effect of the isolation of a few
individuals is to largely increase the ratio of any new variation
which may appear among them to the total number of births, and
thus to largely increase the chances of its preservation. On the
other hand, every variation which arises in a few individuals, and
which is subject to the free intercrossing of a large number of other
individuals, will tend to disappear. Intercrossing is probably
favourable to the production of variations, although it is unfavour-

1 "Primary Factors of Organic Evolution," p. 386.

2 Quoted in Murphy's " Habit and Intelligence," p. 241.

1897] PLACE OF ISOLATION IN ORGANIC EVOLUTION 241

able to preserving them ; for while cross fertilisation (amphimixis)
may stimulate variation, it also prevents the variations from
progressing by their mutual interference, and thus it tends to
keep a species constant, but ready to vary when circumstances
require it to do so.1 Self- fertilisation, on the other hand, may be
unfavourable to the production of variations, but when one does
appear it has a good chance of being established.

The general belief that breeding in-and-in is injurious has led
to the conclusion that a large and healthy progeny cannot arise
from a few parents if they are kept quite apart from all others.
But that cross-fertilisation is not necessary for the rapid increase
and continued health of the descendants from a few common an-
cestors is proved by the successful naturalisation of many animals
in New Zealand from very limited stocks. The honey-bee was
introduced by the Reverend Mr Cotton, chaplain to Bishop Selwyn,
who procured a few hives from Sydney; and, in 1S6G, wild bees
were common in the forests of the North. Island. Seven Chinese
pheasants were introduced in 1851, and six more in 1856 — more
than half being cocks ; and pheasant shooting near Auckland com-
menced in 1865. A few black swans were introduced by Sir
Walter Buller in 1864. A few cirl buntings were turned out
near Dunedin about 1868. A very few silver-gray rabbits were
released at Ivaikoura ; and, I believe, only three Tasmanian opos-
sums were turned out in the forests of Southland ; yet all these
species are now abundant and healthy. The herd of deer in the
Wairarapa (Wellington) has sprung from one stag and two hinds
turned out in 1863 ; and the herds in other parts of New Zealand
have all started from very few progenitors. Also many of the self-
introduced insects — as the English lady-bird {Coccinclla undecim-
j)v ' aetata), the drone-fly (Eristalis tcnax), the horse-bot {Gastropliilus
equi), and Lucilia cacsar, could only have been introduced in small
numbers, for each has spread from a single centre ; but yet they
have been very successful. It is true that several failures to
naturalise animals could also be given, but these failures do not
invalidate the evidence supplied by successful naturalisation, and it
is evident that, when the surroundings are favourable, it is quite
possible for a few individuals to give rise to a new and vigorous
species which might in time become dominant.

Isolation must therefore be a true cause of the preservation of
variations, and also it must be an important one. The artificial
selection of animals and plants by man might just as well be called
artificial isolation. The breeder, or the horticulturist, certainly
selects the variation he wishes to preserve, but he also isolates it ;
and it is the isolation which causes the variation to be preserved —

1 See Professor H. R. Orr's " Development and Heredity," p. 234.

242 NATURAL SCIENCE [October

selection only securing that the variation is a good one. The
natural selection of Darwin works in the same way : that is, it
isolates beneficial variations by killing off the others. It is not so
much natural selection as natural elimination ; for, as Professor
Lloyd Morgan has pointed out,1 it is not by the survival of the
fittest, but by the elimination of the least fit, that new species are
made. Isolation by elimination must always tend to preserve
variations which are useful to the competing individuals, while
isolation by other means may preserve not only useful, but also
indifferent and even injurious, variations, as in the case of domesti-
cated animals and cultivated plants.

Isolation by Selection — or natural selection in a restricted
sense — implies an outside agency as selector for whose benefit the
isolation is made. These cases of true natural selection are limited
to selection by insects. Several kinds of beetles, domesticated by
ants, have become blind, and some of them are unable to feed them-
selves. These variations are evidently injurious to the domesticated
animals, but useful to the ants, as they prevent the beetles from
running away. The sticky secretion of aphides must also be in-
jurious, if we may judge by the eagerness with which they allow the
ants to remove it ; and we must, therefore, suppose it to be due to
selection by the ants. But how the selection was made we do not
know.

The structural growths which, in many flowers, necessitate the
visits of special insects to fertilise them, are also probably due to
natural selection in its narrow sense, for it is very doubtful whether
they are useful to the plants. In the first place the plants which
have the most elaborate apparatus for securing fertilisation by
certain insects only are uniformly rare ; while self-fertilising and
anemophilous plants are abundant.2 Secondly, very few annual
plants, which must set seeds every year, have complicated flowers,
and some of these — such as the annual peas and beans — are also
self-fertilising. Thirdly, many perennial plants with elaborate
flowers have resorted to other means to secure fertilisation in case
insects fail to visit them. Fourthly, the great number and abund-
ance of plants, whose inconspicuous gamopetalous flowers show that
they have reverted from insect fertilisation, is a sufficient proof that
they have not suffered any harm by doing so. We must therefore
conclude that the elaborate flowers found in many of the so-called
entomophilous plants are quite unnecessary for their well-being, and,
indeed, must be sometimes harmful, for they render fertilisation

1 " Animal Life and Intelligence," 2nd ed., ]>. 791.

2 Henalow, "On the Self-Fertilisation of Plants," Trans. Linn. Sac, 2nd series
(Botany), vol. i., p. 317.

1897] PLACE OF ISOLATION IN ORGANIC EVOLUTION 243

uncertain and irregular. There is still another reason for coming
to the same conclusion. If it be good for a plant to have its flowers
fertilised by pollen from other plants, then the grouping of flowers
into a head or spike must be injurious, because it almost insures
that the flowers shall be fertilised by pollen from other flowers of
the same inflorescence, which Darwin says does little or no good;
and yet plants with capitate flowers are numerous and prosperous.

That cross-fertilisation is useful is proved by the fact that all
the higher animals are bisexual ; but that it is not essential is also
proved by the existence of large numbers of asexual organisms, and
by the fact that the highest plants are hermaphrodite. The first
phanerogams were, no doubt, diclinous and anemophilous. As the
number of species increased the individuals of each species would
diminish, and, consequently, fertilisation by the wind would become
more uncertain ; and, probably, it is for this reason that the higher
angiosperms became hermaphrodite. But this hermaphroditism was
tempered by dichogamy, the origin of which is not connected with
insect fertilisation. The visits of insects came later. They com-
menced to cultivate, as it were, the flowers for their own use, each
species trying to preserve the honey for its exclusive benefit ; for it
is evident that all these floral arrangements — including colour, capi-
tate flowers, scent, etc. — are very useful to the anthophilous insects,
for whom the honey is preserved. But these flowers, elaborated by
insects for their own benefit, have secured complete isolation for the
plants to which they belong, and the variations have therefore been
preserved, whether they were useful or indifferent, or even when they
were injurious, as in the reduction of stigmatic surface in the
orchids, the abortion of one half of each anther in Salvia, and the
asexual condition of the ray-florets in some of the Compositae. All
the changes, however, are useful to those insects which alone can
fertilise the flowers, and Dr Hermann Miiller thinks that different
kinds of insects have evolved different kinds of flowers suited to
their tastes. In fact, these flowers have been cultivated by moths
and bees, just as ants have domesticated some beetles and aphides.
The plants that have escaped from their cultivators have run wild
again, like rabbits in Australia and New Zealand.

Isolation by Elimination — or natural selection in Darwin's sense
— must always have a utilitarian cause, because the elimination is for
the benefit of the remainder — that is, for the selected. It may be
a struggle for food, or it may be a struggle for protection against
enemies, or it may be a struggle to secure the persistence of the
species ; but in all cases it must be a struggle with death as the
penalty for being vanquished, because, without elimination by death,
there can be no selection and no isolation. It is only the struggle

244 NATURAL SCIENCE [October

for food which is brought about by the rapid increase of the members
of a species ; the struggle for protection and the struggle for per-
petuating the species do not at all depend upon the doctrine of
Mai thus. On the contrary, the more individuals there are of a
species, the less the necessity for securing special means of pro-
tection, and the less is the risk of the species dying out. But in
all cases the power of natural selection increases as the structures
which influence the struggle get more perfect and as competition
gets keener. It can hardly come into play in the early stages of a
variation, or where competition is checked by geographical isolation ;
but it has increased in importance with the age of the earth, and is
now the dominant factor in the evolution of species among the
higher animals and plants.

Geographical Isolation. The rapid increase of the individuals
of a species not only leads to competition for food, and thus to iso-
lation by elimination, but it also leads to emigration and change of
habits, and thus to geographical isolation. This subject has been
fully discussed, especially by Moritz Wagner,1 the Eeverend J. T.
Gulick,2 and Professor Romanes,3 and I will merely give a new
illustration of the principle. There are twelve different kinds of
albatrosses belonging to three genera which roam over the Southern
Ocean, most of them mixing freely together — nine or ten occurring
in the Tasman Sea — but each having its own separate breeding-
places, to which it retires every year. Now, as these birds have no
enemies, and as their specific characteristics are not connected with
the struggle for food, we cannot suppose that each species was
formed by competition on the ocean, and that each subsequently
chose a separate breeding - ground, or — in other words — that the
development of their specific characters preceded their isolation.
Evidently isolation preceded, and caused the preservation of, the
variations, which in time became of specific importance. The three
species of the North Pacific must also have originated in the same
way. It should be noticed that these species are nearly, if not
quite, as well characterised as those species which have been de-
veloped by natural selection ; the intermediate varieties having
died out, although there can have been no elimination by com-
petition. And as all live under the same conditions, the variations
can hardly be due to the action of the environment. Geographical
isolation must often have been the means of preserving, not only
indifferent characters, but also the incipient stages of useful ones,
which have been subsequently developed by elimination.

1 Sec Gulick in Journ. Linn. Soc. (Zool.), vol. xx., p. 193.

2 Journ. Linn. Soc. (Zool.), vol. xi., p. 496, and vol. xx., p. 222.

3 Jour n. Linn. Soc. (Zool.), vol. xix., p. 848.

1897] PLACE OF ISOLATION IN ORGANIC EVOLUTION 245

Physiological Isolation. This was first brought forward by
Professor G. J. Romanes.1 By it is meant those cases where the
individuals of a species mix together during the breeding season,
but, for some reason or other, certain individuals are restrained from
having sexual intercourse with others. The simplest case is that of
a sexual reproduction which insures that each individual is isolated
from all others, and, consequently, any variations that may arise
are preserved, unless counteracted by reversion. Probably this is
the cause of the immense variety found among the Bacteria, Dia-
toms, Fungi, Radiolarians, and Foraminifera ; and perhaps it is the
reason why Bacteria are so readily modified when placed under new
conditions by cultivation. Self-fertilisation is nearly as efficient ;
but a cross may occasionally occur. Ferns and many other plants,
as well as many Coelenterates, are thus isolated and able to preserve
indifferent variations.

Partial sterility with the parent form (the physiological selec-
tion of Professor Romanes) ; the selective association of Dr A. R.
Wallace ; and change in the season of flowering or of pairing, all
appear to be true causes of physiological isolation. I have lately
given an example of the process of species manufacture by the last
process in the case of some petrels on the Kermadec Islands.2 Two
varieties of Aestrelata neglccta — the mutton-bird and winter mutton-
bird of the settlers — breed on the same island, but at different times
of the year. The first has the neck and breast, and sometimes the
whole under surface, gray ; while the winter mutton-bird has only
a gray band on the breast, the rest of the under surface being white.
Here physiological isolation is bringing about much the same result
as geographical isolation has done in the case of the albatrosses, for
— as with them — we must suppose that the change in the time of
pairing preceded the change of plumage.

Sexual selection is better considered as a form of physiological
isolation than of natural selection, for there is no elimination of the
males ; they are not killed off, but can, after defeat, try again to
obtain a partner. Some males secure the females either by greater
strength or by superior weapons of offence, or by superior means of
capturing them, while others are selected or rejected by the females;
and in the case of birds, the latter mode of selection seems to ex-
plain the preservation of many beautiful variations in plumage.
Dr Wallace supposes that these beautiful variations in plumage
have been produced by the greater vigour of certain males, which is
probably true ; but no amount of vigour in the male would, by
itself, secure the preservation of these variations without isolation,
and this has been clue to sexual selection. It is possible that the
females select the males for their vigour and not for their beauty,
1 Journ. Linn. Soc. (Zool.), vol. xix., p. 350. 2 Proc. Zool. Soc, 1893, p. 753.

246 NATURAL SCIENCE [October

although there is much evidence to the contrary ; but, in either case,
isolation by sexual selection is necessary for the preservation of any
variations the males may possess.

From this examination of the place of isolation in organic
evolution I conclude that species generally originate by the pre-
servation of individual variations by means of geographical or
physiological isolation, which may be brought about in many ways ;
and that, in most, but by no means all, cases they are improved and
developed by competition and natural selection ; and this competi-
tion they find only in large and well-populated areas.

F. W. Hutton.

575.1 247

575.2

III

The Relation of Acquired Modifications to Heredity

TO most evolutionists it must be evident that a distinct change
is coming over the controversy on use-inheritance. Not only
are the views expressed less positive, but there also seems some
likelihood of a compromise. A letter to Nature, last April, by
Professor Baldwin, was, I think, expressive of the feelings of
evolutionists generally.

Bateson has remarked l that " The study of variation thus offers
a means whereby we may hope to see the process of evolution."
This position does not seem to have received the attention which, I
think, it deserves ; and it is with the hope of helping to turn atten-
tion to these points that I offer two suggestions on this subject.

Ever since Galton put forward his "Theory of Heredity," the
problem of use-inheritance has been coming more and more to the
front, and became almost the main point at issue after the publica-
tion of Weismann's Essays ; so that we have now the curious
anomaly of evolutionists of the highest eminence occupying all
grades between the extremes of Professor Henslow, who denies the
action of natural selection altogether in the formation of species,
and Professor Weismann, who nearly as emphatically denies the
action of use-inheritance.

This is the more extraordinary when it is remembered that the
intermediate position, occupied by Eomanes and Lloyd Morgan, has
practically disappeared, owing to the death of Romanes and the
secession of Lloyd Morgan to the Neo-Darwinian position.

The difficult if not impossible task of finding any really satis-
factory test case that is capable of only one explanation is no doubt
largely responsible for the divergence of opinion. But I believe
there is also another cause for this divergence, namely, that the
vast field which the subject covers compels all but the most
powerful minds to limit themselves to a portion only of the
subject. It will be seen on reflection that most of the Lamarckians
have mainly studied either the lower forms of life generally,
have been more or less exclusive botanists or palaeontologists,
or have devoted their attention to less important structures
or easily variable species ; while on the other hand the Neo-Dar-
winians have studied large living groups of animals or the more
1 " Materials for the Study of Variation. "

248 NATURAL SCIENCE [October

highly-developed and more differentiated organisms in animal or
vegetable kingdoms. While such men as Darwin and, to a less
extent, Romanes have occupied a more general position, the numer-
ous almost unconscious impressions that come to an investigator in
any branch of science, the little details of practical experience which
are rarely if at all jotted down, even by the most painstaking re-
corder, give, I believe, a general and correct, though usually uncon-
scious, colouring to all his work, original or otherwise, and are
largely influential in determining his convictions.

It is to this colouring from different surroundings that I attri-
bute the positions taken up by the various evolutionists, and I
think, had it been possible for the Neo-Lamarckians and Neo-
Darwinians to have exchanged positions at the commencement of
their scientific studies, that both sets of investigators would have
materially altered their opinions.

The conclusions drawn, both on theoretical and practical
grounds, from the study of the principal works of both sides,
seem to me to support the following propositions : —

(1) That the simpler the organism, the greater the power of

use-inheritance.

(2) That the higher stages of evolution entail increased differ-

entiation, and therefore increased difficulty of direct
adaptation to environment, and therefore increased de-
pendence on natural selection.

(3) That high specialisation must be accompanied by a corre-

spondingly increased stability, and, therefore, increased
difficulties in the action of use-inheritance, on account
of the increased dependence of those specialised parts on
each other.

(4) Lastly that, with the increase of natural selection, the varia-

tions must become increasingly adaptive.

The second point has special reference to the theories of
heredity. To anyone who considers for a moment the immense
importance assigned to automatic, unconscious, and reflex actions
in Psychology, Physiology, and Pathology, and the large amount
which has been written on habit and its effect on the organism,
it must seem remarkable that so little importance has been given
to it in evolution and heredity. Erasmus Darwin considered that
as the embryo was made up of two portions which had formerly
belonged to its parents, it was reasonable to suppose that it would
to a large extent retain the habits of those parents.

More lately, Professor Ewald Hering has extended this idea to
what he aptly defines as unconscious memory. His explanation of
heredity lies between the physiological and morphological schools.

1897] RELATION OF MODIFICATIONS TO HEREDITY 249

He supposes first that under appropriate circumstances a small
amount of the original substance may be capable of governing the
course of the future organism, just as the mathematician may con-
struct from a small portion of a curve its whole extent. And,
secondly, —

" If in a parental organism, by long habit or constant practice,
something grows to be second nature, so as to permeate, be it ever
so feebly, its germinal cells, and if the germinal cells commence an
independent life, they will aggrandise and grow till they form a
new being, but their single parts still remain the substance of the
parental being."

The objections to this theory lie, I think, in the fact that direct
communication with the reproductive organs becomes with increas-
ing specialisation increasingly difficult, and therefore heredity and
reproduction would cease when a certain point in the specialisation
was reached.

Nevertheless, some kind of provisional theory such as the fol-
lowing would, I believe, explain better than any other theory most
of the phenomena of inheritance : —

(1) That in every cell there are certain reproductive units

which are necessary to the development of that par-
ticular cell.

(2) That these reproductive units having a very complicated

structure (being composed of specialised protoplasm), are
capable of modification when acted on by external forces.

(3) That the various impressions made upon the cell would of

necessity be made upon these units also, and that this
impression will be proportional to the length of time and
intensity of the impression made.

(4) That as specialisation of tissue occurs, each reproductive

unit will tend to reproduce its own history, past im-
pressions becoming with each successive addition more
and more blurred.

(5) That the stronger and more numerous the past impressions,

the more difficult will it become for present impressions
to affect them, hence progressively diminished power of
use-inheritance.

(6) That the reproductive units have the power of self multi-

plication when in the latent condition, and that this
multiplication will be difficult in proportion to their
specialisation and complexity. Hence latent germs
would tend to be carried on from one generation to
another, and increase the general stability of the
organism.

250 NATURAL SCIENCE [October

(7) That when not required in cell development they will tend
to pass into the system of the organism, and that when
suitable conditions arise they will tend to reproduce the
cells from which they are derived.

In the earlier forms of life these units will diffuse themselves
throughout the organism (Protozoa), but as differentiation occurs
these units will tend to become localised at one or more places
(Hydrozoa). Of these places one will become more important
either from habit or position, and this will become fixed and
subsequently specialised (ovary or testis). The cell differentiation
will at last become so great that it will stop all reproduction of
parts except at the specialised centre. Partial renewal of limbs, etc. ,
in the earlier vertebrates becoming rarer and ceasing altogether as
we ascend to the higher vertebrates.

x&"

(8) That these reproductive units having once started a

phenomenon in any given direction, the direction will tend
to be kept up and continued by physiological laws.

(9) That each unit would tend from habit to occupy in a new

organism a position similar to that which it occupied in
the parent.

This theory would explain the constancy of type, as there
would be a continually increasing balance in favour of heredity. It
would satisfactorily explain the recapitulation theory of embryology.
It would account for the recognised antagonism existing in both
plants and animals between the reproductive and bodily growth, and
it would afford an explanation of growth in abnormal situations.

In conclusion, I think it will be found that we are brought
back to a closer study of the causes of variations as the only
satisfactory means of solving the fundamental problem of use-
inheritance. J. Lionel Tayler.

593.5 251

A Carcinological Campaign

DURING the last few months there has been remarkable activity
in discussing and describing new and peculiar forms of the
smaller Crustacea.

At Liverpool last autumn Mr A. O. Walker (15) announced his
new Cumacean genus Leuconopsis, in which the male has on the
second joint of the third foot a pair of curved blade-like processes,
the feature unique, the function not yet explained.

In the Transactions of the Royal Irish Academy, Mr W. T.
Caiman (3) has enriched the caridea or true shrimps with a new
family, Bresiliidae, established for a specimen taken at a depth
of 750 fathoms off' the south-west coast of Ireland. In the
Transactions of the Royal Society of Edinburgh, Mr Caiman (2)
has re-described and re-figured the Anaspidcs Tasmaniae of G. M.
Thomson, with a view of discussing the systematic position of this
extremely interesting crustacean. It is found in Tasmania in pools
at an elevation of 4000 feet. It is in structure at present quite
unique. This combination of uncommon form with uncommon
habitat led its learned discoverer to say that " owing to long isola-
tion it has undergone very profound modification." But it may
equally well be supposed that its isolation has enabled it to retain
characters which in other crustaceans have been profoundly modified.
Reasons are given by Mr Thomson for the opinion that the ancestral
forms of Anaspidcs found their way from the sea into the streams
and lakes of Tasmania as far back as Mesozoic times. Its thoracic
limbs being divided into walking and swimming branches, it has
reasonably been grouped with the Schizopoda or " cleft-foot "
shrimps, and in some respects it seems to come nearest the
Euphausid family, so distinguished for luminous organs. To such
organs I fancied that the minute group of ' ocelli ' on the back of
the head, which Mr Caiman has pointed out, might perhaps belong,
but .the guess has found no favour, although visual ocelli can
scarcely be needed to supplement the stalked eyes. In the seg-
ments of the trunk the animal is rather like an amphipod, which it
also resembles in having simple branchial vesicles. But these are
in pairs. Mr Caiman speaks of this latter circumstance as without
parallel in adult malacostraca, overlooking, it would seem, the

252 NATURAL SCIENCE [October

' accessory branchiae ' in certain aniphipoda to which the late
Professor Wrzesniowski first called attention. In appearance
Anaspides not only has seven thoracic segments distinct as in the
Amphipoda, but also a segment immediately in front of these
distinct. Here, however, Mr Caiman maintains that the appearance
is delusive, and that we have only to do with the well-known
cervical groove of the carapace. He may be right. He may be
wrong. The suggestion is certainly very ingenious. It would be
inconvenient here to follow him into the details of so technical a
question, or through the important comparison which he institutes
between Anaspides and the palaeozoic Crustacea, Pcdacocaris, Gamp-
sonyx, and Acanthotdson. To all seeming, however, Acanthotclson is
much nearer to the isopod genus Apiscudes than to a schizopod, and
the figures of Packard's restoration would have been better omitted,,
since they do not agree either with the original figures of the fossils
or with the description given in the text. Meek's figures (Geological
Survey of Illinois, vol. III., p. 549, etc., 1868) probably give all the
information that can be depended upon.

Professor Gr. 0. Sars (12) is bringing out in rapid succession
the parts of his Isopoda of Norway, always with the fulness of
satisfying illustration and exact description for which his work is
celebrated, throwing a flood of light upon groups, such, for example,
as the minute species of Munna, which before were puzzling and
obscure. In his account of the Anthuridae he does not notice, and has
perhaps forgotten, the view taken by Dohrn and Gerstaecker, and later
brought into prominence by Dr Charles Chilton (3), that in this
family the longer branch of the tail-feet or uropods is not the inner
branch, as authors have generally supposed, but in accordance rather
with homology than appearance, the outer branch. Dr Chilton also
doubts whether this longer branch is ever really two-jointed, though
it is open to maintain that it is sometimes actually and always vir-
tually so. These are points on which the Norwegian professor's ex-
pressly declared opinion would be of much value. For the correct
name of the very common Isopod, generally known as Idotea tricus-
pidata Desmarest, Professor Sars selects 'Idothea haltica (Pallas).' As
the synonymy of this species was exhaustively investigated by
Harger in 1878, by Miers in 1881, and by Dollfus in 1895, it is
amusing to note that, in the name finally adopted by each, they all
differ from Sars and each one from the other. Harger was unable
to consult Pallas' work. He therefore acknowledges that Meinert
(1877) may have rightly regarded Oniscus balthicus Pallas as the
earliest name of the species. The generic name Idotea came into
the world with one letter missing, and this same much victimised
letter is found as a superfluity in the specific name hdthicus, so
that Idotea balthica (Pallas) will be the form upheld by those of

1897J A CARCINOLOGICAL CAMPAIGN 253

us who think the spelling used by our scientific forefathers worth
preserving.

For number of remarkable novelties the palm is carried off by
M. Jules Bonnier. He describes (1) six new genera and forty-five
new species of sessile-eyed crustaceans, obtained by Prof. Koehler
on board the " Caudan " in the Bay of Biscay. The depths ranged
from 200 to 1700 metres. Out of 52 species taken 39 proved
to be totally blind. The new Cumacean genus Procarrvpylaspis, like
Mr Walker's Leuconopsis, displays an unexpected character, the
' linger ' or terminal joint of the second maxillipeds being cut into
strong unequal teeth, giving the appendage what might almost be
called an unnatural appearance. The rapid movement of modern
science is exemplified in the circumstance that M. Bonnier's new
anthurid, Calathura affinis, is scarcely published before it has to be
transferred, as it evidently must be, to Sars' new genus Lcptanthura.
To the family Arcturidae M. Bonnier contributes a new species,
Astacilla Giardi, which is remarkable not only for a quite abnormal
appendage on the breast of the male, but also because the male is
slenderly drawn out to a length thrice that of the female. The
exiguity of the creature recalls the vermiform male of an anthurid
discovered by Professor Haswell wriggling into serpula-tubes in
Australia. Another of M. Bonnier's striking results is the discovery
of a crustacean parasite upon a Cumacean species. But this novelty
also has been already transferred to a new genus by Dr H. J.
Hansen, who, in a work noticed elsewhere, has described no less
than seven new species of such parasites.

Miss Mary J. Kathbun (8, 9) concerns herself only with the
Brachyura, but, as in more than one of her recently described new
species, the full-grown crab is less than the fifth of an inch in
length, these species at least may be classed among the smaller
crustaceans. On the other hand, M. Adrien Dollfus (6) speaks of
a new woodlouse, Porccllio eximhis, from the north of Africa, as
"cette magnifique espece." It has the outer branch of the uropods
in the male half as long as the body, as though it were a kind of
peacock among woodlice, proud of its tail. Possibly these prolonged
appendages enable their owner to execute strategic movements to
the rear with caution and tact.

Miss Harriet Eichardson (10, 11) has this year described two
new species of Sphaeroma, and given figures of one of them. The
first is notable for its habitat, having been taken not from the sea
but from a warm spring in New Mexico. The second is notable for
its objectionable habits, having been found boring the piers on St
John's river at Palatka, Florida. The mischievous little creature
has powerful jaws, and in eight years reduced timber of 16 inches
diameter to less than half that measurement.

254 NATURAL SCIENCE [October

In his Pelagic Entomostraca of the Caspian Sea, Sars (13) dis-
cusses eighteen species, of which thirteen are new. Six belong
to the new genus Ccrcopdgis, meaning " sling-tail." Were these
animals twelve feet long instead of a twelfth of an inch they would
rank among the most striking objects in zoology. The eye is
enormous. The thread-like caudal process is sometimes half an
inch long, fully six times the length of the body. Near the end
this lash is " bent in a peculiar sling-like manner, the opposite edges
of the sling armed with a double row of recurved denticles." Fur-
thermore, out of a kind of gastric sympathy, the intestinal tube
forms also a sling-like flexure or loop. In the female the incubatory
pouch rises abruptly from the back and inclines forward, this mon-
strous sack of young ones being sometimes as large as the body which
supports it.

In the Proceedings of the Biological Society of Washington (vol.
xi., pp. 153-167, June 9, 1897), Miss Rathbun gives 'A Eevision
of the Nomenclature of the Brachyura.' It appears to be thor-
oughly sound in principle, and is certainly based on wide and
accurate knowledge. Only, in a few points of detail, one may be
permitted to question the results arrived at, and to defend, for in-
stance, the name Carcinus for the shore-crab, Thelphusa for the
river-crab, Macrocheira for the giant-crab of Japan, since the reasons
for displacing these familiar names seem to be at least not impera-
tive. Owners of Herbst's Naturgeschichtc clcr Krabben und Krebsc
and of Leach's Malacostraca Podopkthtdma Britanniac, will find in
Miss Rathbun's paper exceedingly useful tables, establishing the
dates of the numerous parts of those works, the publication of
which extended in the one case over two-and-twenty years, and in
the other over no less than sixty.

The excellent plan of printing the very day of publication on
cover and title-page is followed in Miss Rathbun's paper. Therefore,
for her new generic name Ucides, in place of Latreille's pre-occupied
Uca, we know precisely that the date is June 9, 1897. But of Dr
Ortmann's Ocdiplcura, also a new name for Uca of Latreille, we can
say nothing positively. Some supplementary notes of correction at
the end of his valuable Carcinologische Studien are dated " Princeton
University, New Jersey, d. 29 Mai 1897." This date was probably
written on the proof copy. The paper was printed and published
in Jena. It is for the publishers to tell us the exact date of
publication. Until they do an expectant world cannot know for
certain which has the priority, Ucides or Ocdiplcura.

It should be understood that the above remarks touch only a
small part of the papers mentioned, and also that they leave un-
noticed contributions by many other well-known writers, highly
worthy of attention, though the forms discussed may not happen to

1897] A CARCINOLOGICAL CAMPAIGN 255

be quite so eccentric as those to which allusion has here been
made.

REFERENCES.

1. Bonnier, J. — "Resultats scientifiqucs de la Campagne du ' Caudan ' dans lc Golfe de

Gascogne — Aout-Septembre 1895 — Edriophthalmes." Ann. Univ. Lyon, pp.
527-689, pis. 28-40. 1896 (? 1897).

2. Caiman, W. T.— " On Deep-Sea Crustacea from the South-West of Ireland."

Trans. Boy. Irish .trad., vol. xxxi., pt. i. (Reprint), pp. 1-22, pis. i., ii.
1896.

. — "On the genus Anaspides and its Affinities with certain Fossil

Crustacea." Trail*. Roy. Soc, Edinburgh, vol. xxxviii., pt. iv. (No. 23), pp.
787-802, pis. i.-ii. 1896.

3. Chilton, C. — ''The subterranean Crustacea of New Zealand." Trans. Linn. Soc,

London, vol. vi., pt. 2, p. 217. 1894.

4. Dokrn, Anton. — " Untersuchungen iiber Ban und Entwickelung der Arthropoden."

Heft v., p. 96. Leipzig, 1870.

5. Dollfus, A.— "Les Idoteidae des cotes de France." Feuille des Jeunes Naturalistes.

No. 292, p. 10. 1895.

6. . — "Les Isopodes terrestres du Nord de l'Afrique. Du Cap Blanc a

Tripoli." Mem. Soc. Zoo L, France, vol. ix., p. 536. 1896.

7. Meek and Worthen. — Geological Survey of Illinois, vol. iii., p. 549. 1868.

8. Rathbun, M. 3.— Proc. U.S. Nat. Mus., vol. xix., No. 1104, p. 141. 1896.
9. . — Proc. Biol. Soc, Washington, vol. xi., p. 99.

10. Richardson, H.— Proc. U.S. Nat. Mus., vol. xx., No. 1128. 1S97.

11. . — Proc. Biol. Soc, Washington, vol. xi., pp. 105-107.

12. Sars, G. O. — " An Account of the Crustacea of Norway." Vol. ii. Isopoda, pts.

iii., iv., v., vi. Bergen, 1897.
13. . — "Pelagic Entomostraca of the Caspian Sea." Pp. 1-74, 8 pis. Ann.

Mus. Zool. Acad. Petersbourg, 1897.

14. Thomson, G. M. — "On a Fresh "Water Schizopod from Tasmania." Trans. Linn. Soc,

London, vol. vi. pt. 3, pp. 285-303, pis. 24-26. 1894.

15. Walker, A. O.—Eep. Brit. Assoc 1896. P. 419. London, 1896 (? 1897).

T. E. E. Stebbing.

Ephkaim Lodge. The Common, Tunbridge Wells.

52J 256 [October

980

South America as the Source of the Tertiary

Mammalia 1

OF the Argentine Territory during the Archaean era there only
existed the frame of the massive mountains of the north-west
and a few points and islets, which to-day form part of the various
isolated mountain chains which rise from the plain of the Pampa,
from Salta to Patagonia.

The oldest fossiliferous deposits of the first Palaeozoic epochs
rest on these Archaean rocks : all the organisms are marine. In
the latest times of the Palaeozoic era, during the Carboniferous and
Permian periods, these small islands served as a nucleus for a
greater extension of the land, and then great numbers of terrestrial
organisms appeared, of a uniform aspect, precisely as the temperature
in all parts of the globe was uniform.

The deposits of the greater part of the Mesozoic era, with rare
exceptions, are found in the Cordillera, where they appear on either
side in the form of narrow bands running north and south, proving
that then as now the Cordillera of the Andes already existed as a
long and narrow land which separated the Atlantic from the Pacific.
Both oceans reached the foot of the Cordillera, but in the Atlantic
the mountain chains of Tandil, Ventana, Cordoba, San Luis, and
various others formed large islands. At this time the geographical
differences of temperature began to be felt, causing climatic zones,
the most active of the factors which operate in the differentiation of
organisms — a differentiation which allows us to determine the rela-
tions of the floras and faunas of different regions, and to restore the
routes which they followed in their migrations across the lands of
other times, which are not the same as those of to-day, furnishing
us with the data to reconstruct the ancient connections of the lost
continents.

We have now reached the latest time of the Cretaceous period,
the most recent of those which constitute the Mesozoic era. Water
predominated in the northern hemisphere, and land in the southern
— the reverse of what happens at the present day. The European

1 Translated by Mrs Smitb Woodward from "La Argentina al travc's de las ultima
('j)ocas geologicas," an address delivered at the inauguration of the University of La
Plata, April 18, 1897. (8vo., pp. 35. Buenos Aires : P. E. Coni & Sons, 1897.)

18971 THE SOURCE OE THE TERTIARY MAMMALIA 257

continent had not appeared, except as a few small islands. North
America, completely separated from South America, formed a great
island, with large lakes of brackish water ; and this part of South
America had lost its insular and peninsular form. The Argentine
Territory had completely emerged, and extended to the east towards
South Africa, while to the south and west it was prolonged to form
a large continent, which placed it in connection with Australia and
New Zealand.

It was during this epoch in that great southern continent, and
especially in its central portion now constituting the Argentine
Territory, that the highest organisms developed, the great class of
the mammals which immediately spread over the southern lands,
and subsequently penetrated by different routes into the northern
hemisphere.

The great barrier of the Andes was then low, and did not hinder
the atmospheric currents. The climate was hot and humid, and a
luxuriant vegetation covered all the Argentine Territory. As far as
the present Patagonian plains, to-day dry and sterile, there flourished
large forests of palms and conifers, whose petrified remains fill whole
deposits, in which one continually finds huge tree trunks trans-
formed into flint still occupying their natural position and constitut-
ing dead forests, forests of stone, columns of flint such as that which
one can see opposite the Museum of La Plata crowned with the bust of
the unfortunate Crevaux, and which the imagination of the dwellers
of the Patagonian deserts, on account of the undulation of the land,
takes to be the masts of petrified ships.

Alternating with the branches and tree trunks transformed into
stone, which fill the deposits of sandy rock appearing at various
points of the Patagonian Territory, large bones are met with
similarly petrified, belonging to terrestrial vertebrates of the ex-
tinct group Dinosauria. They were reptiles with an enormously
thick tail, and the hind limbs much longer and thicker than the
fore limbs, so that, supporting the body on the hind limbs and tail,
they could assume a semi- vertical or oblique position resembling
that of a kangaroo.1 When one says that as a matter of fact they
could have looked over the roofs of most of the buildings at La
Plata, one can judge of the truly colossal size which some repre-
sentatives of this group attained.

The birds of that time were no less noteworthy than the reptiles.
They were such as Physornis and Phororhacos, true monsters, bipeds
with short and thick wings, the claws of an eagle, and the beak of

1 Of the three sub-orders into which the Dinosauria are divided, namely, Sauropoda,
Theropoda, and Orthopoda, the characters mentioned above are peculiar to the two last.
The sub-order of the Sauropoda, to which the gigantic genera of Patagonia, Argyromurus
and Tilanosaurus Lyd. , belong, have the four limbs more or less equal, or the front pair
scarcely any shorter than the hind pair.

258 X AT URAL SCIENCE [October

a condor, of whose size we may form an idea from the head, which
is much larger than that of a horse.1 Being great runners, they
gave chase to the mammals of that epoch, even to the most gigantic
of them, and were doubtless not afraid to measure their strength
with the Dinosaurs themselves.

But the animals of that period which in our formations offer
special interest are the mammals. While in Europe and North
America only some small representatives of that class lived, insig-
nificant and little specialised, in Argentina they had attained an
extraordinary development ; they were large and small, of the most
varied forms, showing that the Cretaceous deposits of our country
contain the ancestors of almost all the groups of mammals which
have succeeded each other one by one in different regions of the
earth.

It would be a lengthy task to give you an account of the
mammalian fauna of that time ; it is only possible for me to outline
the subject and to limit myself to noticing some forms related to
others with which you are familiar.

That which first attracts the attention of the naturalist in this
fauna is the presence of remains of the Primates or inferior quad-
rumana {Notopithccidae) of a greatly reduced size, which appear
to be the ancestors of the extinct lemurs of Europe and North
America, and of those existing in the South of Asia and Africa,
while another branch leads to the Homunculidae (Homunculus,
Anthropops, Pitheculus, etc.) of the Tertiary of our own country,
which are the ancestors of the monkeys of both worlds, and conse-
quently of man.

The carnivorous mammals were represented solely by a group
to which I have given the name Sparassodonta, whose size varied from
that of a ' laucha ' (Pharsophorus) to that of the largest bear (Probor-
hyaena) ; they exhibit a mixture of the characters of placentals and
marsupials, and represent the stock whence were derived the car-
nivorous marsupials of the Australian continent, the placental
carnivores of both hemispheres, and a large number . of the extinct
forms of the northern hemisphere designated under the name
of Creodonts.

Another most interesting group is that of the Plagiaulacoidea
{Polydolopidae, Abdcritidae, Epanorthidac, etc.), small marsupial
mammals with a dentition of the type of the Australian kangaroos,
but with the limbs more nearly equal, with five digits on each foot,
and with traces of syndactylism. They were extremely numerous,
and gave origin to the greater portion of the marsupials of Australia,
designated under the name of Diprotodonts, a group of which the

1 These fossils may now be seen in the Department of Geology in the British Mnsenni
(Natural History). —Trans.

1897] THE SOURCE OF THE TERTIARY MAMMALIA 259

kangaroos form part. A few years ago no one would have sus-
pected that these latter could have taken their origin in any
continent other than that of Australia, and still less in Argentina,
separated to-day from the Australian lands by the immense abyss
of the Pacific.

These primitive Plagiaulacoidea or Diprotodonts were accom-
panied by the Pyrotheria {Pyrothcrium), mammals of very variable
size, with pentadactyl feet, the limbs in the form of perpendicular
columns of support, a short neck, large head, square grinding teeth
with two transverse ridges like those of Dinotheriitm, large upper
and lower tusks as in the oldest Mastodonts, and a large trunk like
that of the elephant. They are the stock whence have sprung the
proboscidians which appear completely developed on the Euro-asiatic
continent in the Tertiary period, their origin until now having been
an indecipherable enigma.

Together with the Pyrotheria, there lived the Archaeohyracoidea
{Archa colli/ rax, Argyrohyrax, etc.), small plantigrade mammals half-
hoofed and half-clawed, whose external aspect was that of a cavy
(Cavi«), and which have given origin to the Hyracoidea (Hyrax)
existing in Asia and Africa, whose ancestors have not been known
until now in these continents. The Notohippidea (Morphippus,
Rhynchippus, etc.), small pentadactyl ungulates, but with the middle
digit much larger than the side ones, constituted the stock from
whence the horses have sprung. The Notostylopidea (Notostylops,
Trig<mostylops, etc.), 'whose dentition has a rodent-like ■ appearance,
and give rise to the Tillodonts of the northern hemisphere. The
Isotemnidea {Isotemnus, Trimcrostcphcmos) which probably represent
the source of all the ungulates. The Homalodontotheria (Asmodeus,
etc.), the oldest ancestors of the extinct Ancylopoda of Europe,
Asia, and North America, curious and anomalous herbivores which
possessed all the characters of perfect ungulates, except in the
digits, which were bent in the form of hooks and armed with com-
pressed claws like the unguiculates.

I have only mentioned a small portion of the ungulates of this
period, which were very numerous. They were gigantic and with
large tusks, like the Parastrapotheria, of medium size and generalised
characters, like the Nesodonts and the Leontinidea ; small, sturdy,
and annectent forms between the ungulates and unguiculates, like
the Hegetotheridea (Prohegctothei-iiim), the Trachytheridea, and the
Protypotheridea (Arcliaeophylus) ; tall and slender, like the deer,
and with a single hoof on each foot imitating the horses in minia-
ture, like the Proterotheridea (Deuterotherium), or with ambiguous
affinities between the even and odd toed animals like Didolodiis.

Of these different groups some few have completely disappeared,
and the rest have dispersed over the Argentine Territory, passed on

260 NATURAL SCIENCE [October

to other regions, where by means of successive transformations they
have given rise to the different orders of mammals which live, or
have lived, in all parts of the earth. But besides these primitive
mammals, which have left no successors here to reach to our epoch,
one also meets with the ancestors of those which to-day are charac-
teristic of our country, such as the hystricomorphous rodents and
the opossums (Didclphys), which were represented by types more or
less resembling the living forms, but exceedingly reduced in size.
Together with the Peltateloidea {Pcltephilus), singular armadillos
with variable, pointed, bony horn-cores above the snout, there were
already armadillos almost similar to those now living, by the side
of others very different called Palaeopcltis, which gave rise to the
Glyptodons of more modern periods, and sloths, generally small, but
similar to those which later were destined to reach the gigantic size
of the Mylodonts and Megatheria.

In a sentence, at the end of the Secondary period there lived in
the Argentine Territory not only the ancestors of the mammals
which inhabit it now, but also of those which live in all parts and
all climates of the world.

The Secondary era closed and the Tertiary opened with a dis-
turbance and a general change in the orography of the continents,
and in the distribution of land and water. Great volcanic eruptions
accompanied the elevation of the large mountain ridges previously
only indicated, and the oceanic waters were shifted from north
to south. The northern hemisphere was transformed into a con-
tinental one, and the southern hemisphere into an insular and penin-
sular one. The antarctic continent has remained split up, and the
faunas of its different parts have thenceforward evolved separately.
South America became reduced to an island of varying outline, and
the ocean in this tremendous encroachment covered the territory of
the Republic, rolling over the isolated sierras of the Pampa, reached
as far to the west as the base of the first spurs of the Andes and
the great mountain mass of the North-West. This land served as
the refuge for the terrestrial mammals which were saved from the
catastrophe. It was in the bottom of this ocean that the beds of
the marine formation called Patagonian were deposited, which can
be traced along the greater part of the Atlantic coast to the south
of the Rio Negro, with a thickness at times of 300 metres, and
corresponding to the middle or lower part of the Eocene period.1

During the Upper Eocene period another great upheaval of the
land or a retreat of the ocean took place, the territory of the Re-
public rising again with its eastern shores more to the east than at

1 The Patagonian formation lias no species in common with the territory of Chile
(excepting the system of Lebu), as I have said, but there are some in the formation
immediately above, which is "known as the Santacrnzian.

1897] THE SOURCE OE THE TERTIARY MAMMALIA 261

the present time. Freshwater and atmospheric agencies accumu-
lated on this newly-raised land the great Santacruzian formation,
which, with a thickness of more than 200 metres, appears exposed
in different parts of Patagonia, and especially in the region of the
Rio Santa Cruz.1

The mammals which had taken refuge in the heights
turned to descend to the plain, but already many had become
extinct. The Hyracoidea, the Coudylarthra, the Pyrotheria,
and the Tillodontia had disappeared. Of the Notohippidea, pre-
viously so numerous, there scarcely remained any trace. The
Ancylopoda had diminished remarkably in size and number. The
iSTotopithecidea of the Cretaceous {Notopithecus, Ewpithecops, etc.) had
been transformed into the Homuuculidea, which are the direct
ancestors of the monkeys of both continents. The Typotheria and
Astrapotheria had also begun to decline. On the other hand, the
rodents, the Plagiaulacoidea, the Sparassodonta, the Nesodonta, and
the Litopterna (Thcosodon, Proterothcrium, etc.) had increased in an
extraordinary manner, the same as the armoured and unarmoured
edentates. The groups of the Glyptodons and the Megatheria were
already perfectly developed, but with representatives of a com-
paratively small size.

The data concerning the period in question are still much
confused, but we know that at the beginning of the Oligocene epoch
the Argentine Territory suffered a fresh submergence, accompanied
bv new volcanic and tectonic disturbances. The sea flowed back to
cover the greater part of the plain, while the lava streams thrown
out by the submarine volcanoes formed the sheets of basalt which
cover like a black shroud the older formations of the Patagonian
slates. Later, during the beginning of the Miocene, impetuous tor-
rents brought down from the rugged, rocky heights granite and
porphyritic blocks, rocks of all kinds, which, beaten by the waves of
the sea, formed that great deposit of boulders which covers the sur-
face of Patagonia without break from the Eio Negro to the Straits
of Magellan.2 The inhabitants of the plains migrated again to the
heights, many of them perishing, others adapting themselves to the
new conditions.

At the end of the Oligocene period the ocean made a retrograde
movement, and took up the position it occupies more or less to-day,
and the mammals returned to live on the plains, but again fewer
than they had been. The Nesodonts, the greater part of the

1 The Santacruzian formation exhibits a considerable number of species of fossil
mollusca which are also met with in the Tertiary system of Navidad in Chile, which
proves that both formations belong more or less to the same geological period.

2 It is this formation which has been designated under the name " Tehuelche Forma-
tion." There have been recently found in it beds of fossil shells, which show that it is
a marine formation, probably of the same epoch as the Tertiary system of Coquimbo in
Chile.

262 NATURAL SCIENCE [October

Typothcria, the Ancylopoda, the Astrapotheria, the Peltateloidea,
the Plagiaulacoidea, and the monkeys had disappeared. Of the
Sparassodonta and Litopterna few traces remained. On the other
hand, the Glyptodons and Megatheria, though in smaller numbers,
were represented by forms which frequently attained a gigantic size.
The hystricomorphous rodents had increased extraordinarily in
numbers and size : the fossiliferous deposits of the Parana contain
remains which indicate the former existence of mice of the size of
oxen and horses.

Let us see what was happening meanwhile in the other con-
tinents. Since the submergence and disintegration of the Antarctic
continent, Australia has remained isolated until our days ; the
primitive fauna of the Sparassodonts and Plagiaulacoidea, which
were derived from the ancient Argentine continent, continued their
evolution independently until they formed the Thylacines, the
Dasyures, and the Kangaroos, living and extinct, of the same
region.

South Africa, on the loss of its connection with South America,
united itself with Asia, which already formed a continuous land with
Europe ; but the Atlantic, which extended over the Sahara as far' as
trie Red Sea, opposed a barrier to the direct passage of the faunas
of South Africa to Europe, and vice versa. On the other hand, with
the continental transformation of the northern hemisphere, lands
emerged, which put the Euro-asiatic continent in more or less direct
communication with North America.

The ancient mammals of the Argentine Territory, which by
reason of the submergence of the Antarctic continent had remained
in South Africa, passed on at once to the Asiatic Continent, where
they found conditions favourable to their development and evolution.
The Pyrotheria developed into the Proboscidia, the Archaeohyracoidea
into the living Hyracoidea, the Notohippidea into horses, the Con-
dylarthra into Artiodactyles and Perissodactyles, the Sparassodonta
into Creodonts and Carnivora, etc. The remaining South American
mammals, such as the Monkeys (Homunculidae), the Hystricomorphous
Eodents and the Opossums, invaded the Euro-asiatic continent by
the same route. From Asia they passed on to Europe, and from
Europe to North America, where they became specialised under
different forms, each more bizarre and fantastic.

We return to South America. We fiud ourselves in the last
third of the Cainozoic era at the end of the Miocene period. The
mammalian fauna has continued to diminish in number. The
Proterotheridea and the large rodents of the previous epoch have
disappeared. Of the numerous order of the Toxodonts, there only
remains the genus Toxodon, whose representatives attained the size of
large rhinoceroses. The Megatheria and Glyptodons reached the

1897] THE SOURCE OF THE TERTIARY MAMMALIA 263

summit of their development, to end in those gigantic beings whose
skeletons fill the galleries of the Museums of Buenos Aires and La
Plata. The two Americas had been separated until now by the ocean,
and the territories of Panama and Central America had been sub-
merged in a deep sea which put the Atlantic and Pacific in com-
munication.

Great tectonic movements produced a general raising of the
mountain chains which traverse the New World from south to
north, followed by a great retreat of the waters of the ocean.
The continental mass acquired a larger extension, and both Americas
were put into communication by the raising of a vast land-surface,
in which to-day are the Gulf of Panama and the Caribbean Sea.
The Galapagos Islands on one side and the Antilles on the other
remained surrounded in this newly-risen land, and America in the
form of a great rectangular continental mass extended from pole to
pole.

The terrestrial faunas, confined hitherto by the inter-American
sea, on the disappearance of this barrier began to move in opposite
directions, that of the north towards the south and that of the south
towards the north, producing a zoological interchange which had, as
a result, the formation of a mixed fauna, whose origin has hitherto
been a little inexplicable. Passing from the upper part of this
recently- upheaved land, and describing a complete circle through
time and space, there returned to Argentina many of the forms
which had lived there during the Cretaceous period, but' all of them
modified and disguised. There emigrated at this epoch from North
to South America the Mastodons, which had become extinct on the
plains of the Pampa when, long geological periods previously, their
forefathers the Pyrotheria disappeared from our land. With the
Mastodons came the dogs, the felines, and the other carnivores
descended from the ancient Sparassodonts, the llamas and the deer,
the horses and the tapirs, which lived and multiplied on the
Argentine plains by the side of the Toxodons, the Glyptodons and
the Megatheria. But passing across these same lands the Argentine
fauna advanced to the north and invaded North America. The
clumsy Toxodon of our land was exterminated in Nicaragua. The
heavy Glyptodons of the Pampa wandered away as far as Anahuac,
where their carapaces are found on the slopes of the valley of
Mexico in the neighbourhood of the city of the same name, and still
further to the north in the surface deposits of the plains of Texas.
The carpincho (Hydrochoerus) of the Paver Parana wandered as far
as Florida accompanied by the Ohlamydothermm, the most robust of
the true armadillos which lived in our land. The snR'antic extinct
sloths of the Buenos Aires plains, the Mylodons and the Megatheria,
advanced to a still greater distance, their remains being met with

264 NATURAL SCIENCE [October

in the States of Virginia, Georgia, Carolina, and in the whole of the
valley of the Mississippi, mingled with the most characteristic
representatives of the North American fauna.

We arrive at the beginning of the Anthropozoic era, and with it
ceased the communication between the two Americas, the land
which for a long time had united them being again submerged.
We see then during the Quaternary times North America invaded
by new forms ; the Mastodons were replaced by gigantic elephants,
accompanied by various other genera and species from the Old
World. We see the Elephas columbi, the bisons, the Equus tau, and
E. conversidens descending by the valleys of Mexico and advancing
towards the south as far as the isthmus of Panama, but they found
it interrupted and were not able to tread the South American
soil.

A last retreat of the ocean which made itself felt over the greater
part of the American coasts of the Atlantic left dry great shore
banks of marine shells, like those of the neighbourhood of La Plata,
which provide material for the building of this beautiful city, made
by the genius and energy of our sympathetic rector [of the uni-
versity] ; this fresh continental encroachment upon the ocean again
united both Americas, when the ElepJtas columbi and the other great
mammals which had accompanied it in its migration to the south had
already disappeared from the north. The bridge reappeared in the
form of a narrow and tortuously long piece of land, which served
from that time as a highway to the pre-Columbian peoples of our
hemisphere who migrated successively, and backwards and forwards,
from north to south, and from south to north, strewing the road with
ruins, in which the mixture of a hundred peoples to-day misleads
the cleverest investigators of the prehistoric past of the world of
Columbus. Florentine Ameghino.

18971 265

SOME NEW BOOKS

" Terra Australis Incognita "

The Naturalist ix Australia. By W. Saville-Kent. 4to., pp. xv. 30'2. Illus-
trated by 50 full page collotypes, 9 coloured plates by Keulemaus and other artists,
and over 100 illustrations in the text. Loudon : Chapman & Hall. 1897.
Trice, £3, 3s.

Naturalists of all classes, and a good many other people besides,
including the inhabitants of the nursery, should be grateful to Mr
Saville-Kent for producing such a magnificent picture book of the
natural history of the most interesting and least known region of the
earth, and for pouring out such a wealth of observation and enter-
taining anecdote as are to be found in his latest volume. We can
attempt no summary of so discursive a work, but may perhaps give
some idea of it by extracting a few of the new bits of information that
it contains. The book is in some sense supplementary to Mr Saville-
Kent's former fine volume on the Great Barrier Beef of Australia,
reviewed in Natural Science for June 1893 (vol. ii., pp. 453-460), and
deals chiefly, though by no means exclusively, with Western Australia,
about which little has heretofore been written from the naturalist's
point of view.

In chapter i. we are introduced to various aborigines of Western
Australia, where they have been less exposed to the undermining in-
fluences of civilisation than in the more settled colonies. An advantage
of civilisation, however, from the native's point of view, is the introduc-
tion of glass, whether in the form of bottles or telegraph insulators, from
which wonderfully fine spear heads are manufactured, not by blows
nor by breaking off with a bone, but by pressure with a hard stone or,
preferably, a piece of iron. The frictional methods of kindling fire
are described, but the author adds that they are seldom used — not
because of the introduction of lucifer matches, but because it is the
duty of the women to maintain the lire unquenched, and during
migrations to carry lighted firesticks with them. This casts a light on
the origin of the Vestal Virgins of antiquity.

A good deal has been written about the spurs on the hind feet of
the duck-billed platypus. Mr Saville-Kent suggests that they are
claspers used by the male (to whom they are confined) for the retention
of the slippery female. Similar spurs are found in the male echidna,
and in each case they are connected with a gland on. the back part of
the thigh. The echidna, also known as the spiny ant-eater, does not,
it appears, eat ants at all — that is to say, not adult ants, but it breaks
open the ant-hills and devours the nymphs, larvae, and pupae.

Another error common to the text books, is the representation of
phalangers flying from tree to tree in a horizontal position or with the
head lower than the rest of the body. The truth, according to our
author, is that the head and shoulders are always kept at the highest
level, with the forearms outstretched ready to grasp the first object

266 NATURAL SCIENCE [October

reached. It is a pity that the photograph given is no proof, owing to
the absence of accessories.

Passing from mammals to birds, we regret to learn that the lyre-
bird, Menv/ra superba, is in danger of extinction. At the same time
we can hardly wonder at it, since it is the supposed duty of every
globe-trotter to bring home for his female relatives, present or future, a
pair of the splendid tail-feathers to which the bird owes its name. In
the excellent chapter on birds the greatest space is devoted to the fern-
owls, Podargus strigoidcs ; and the humorous series of photographs, illus-
trating the remarkable changes of form and expression in these quick-
change artistes, should render them familiar in our mouths as household
words. The familiar name, however, "more-pork," is based on a
misapprehension, since the bird which utters this melancholy cry is
really Ninox boobook. Other birds on which valuable notes are given
are the Queensland shrike (Cracticus torquatus), the 1ST. Queensland
laughing jackass, various finches (Poephila), and the firetail (Estrdda
bella.)

Zoologists will not be surprised to find a large space devoted to
the frilled lizard, Cldamydosaurm kingi, since they will all be familiar
with the interesting observations that Mr Saville-Kent has published
on this reptile. Reptile one must call it, though its favourite mode
of progression is rather that of the Anglo-Saxon messenger in " Alice
through the Looking-glass," as shown in the figures. Another text-book
error is to represent this animal with its frill extended, but with its
mouth closed, a physiological impossibility, for the frill is supported by
processes of the hyoid or tongue-bone, which are pressed out by the fall
of the lower jaw. The bearded lizard (Amjdiibolurus barbatus), the
mountain devil (Moloch horridus), the stump-tailed lizard (Trachysaurus
rugosus), and many others are vividly brought before us by the author's
pen and camera.

Chapter iv. introduces those marvellous structures, the homes
of the termites or white ants, and gives some striking photographs
of them. Among other things not generally known, we are told that
both termites and termitaria may be used as food. The animals
themselves, though eaten in Africa and India, do not yet grace the
menu of Australian colonists or black-fellows, but the latter satisfy
their hunger with the earthy substance of the mounds, which con-
tains a large amount of proteaceous matter in the form both of
termite-secretions and of microscopic fungi. Here we may also note
that the green ants, described in another chapter, make, when mashed
up in water, an acid drink pleasant to the European as well as to the
native palate. Perhaps Mr Saville-Kent knows that Swedish children
acidulate lump-sugar by leaving it in an ant-hill for half-an-hour.
As for the food of the termites themselves, it is only too well known
by those who have spent any time in our southern colonies, that
many species have such a craving for wood that they will eat one
out of house and home if constant care be not exereised. Their
efforts produce a result like the sleeping palace of the fairy-tale, in
so far as furniture and walls are outwardly sound but crumble to dust
as soon as touched. There is therefore some consolation in learning
from this book that the mound-builders do not eat wood but grass,
sallying forth from their fortresses by night along hastily constructed

1897] SOME NEW HOOKS 267

covered ways, reaping the harvest, and garnering it for future use.
It is probably the silica contained in the grass-stalks that imparls
such firmness to the walls that these Neuroptera build. Before leav-
ing them, we notice a figure, here published for the first time, of au
infusorial parasite of the Tasmanian termite, described by Mr Saville-
Kent under the name Trichonym/pha l&idyi.

Though this volume does not deal with marine life to the same
extent as did its author's last monograph, yet room has been found
for a fascinating account of the island group known as Houtman's
Abrolhos, oh" the coast of Western Australia. Here, in consequence,
it is conjectured, of a southward flowing current from the Indian
Ocean, there is a tropical marine fauna, including coral islands in all
stages, situated in a temperate climate, and only a few hours' sail
from the port of Geraldton. Mr Saville-Kent urges the advantages
offered by Houtman's Abrolhos for the foundation of a biological
station, and hi* account inclines one to cut the painter of bread-
winning necessity and set sail for these Treasure Islands without
delay. The guano, for which these islands are worked, need not
deter us, for it is "absolutely devoid of smell." This, however, does
not suit the farmer, who values his manure by its stink ; and appro-
priately malodorous chemicals must be added before the guano can be
placed on the market. Upon these reefs we shall find specimens of
the corals which Mr Saville-Kent here describes and figures, appar-
ently for the first time, as Madrepora protad^ormis [sic] and Monti-
pora circinata. Another new species, that may be found here, is the
magnificent nudibranch mollusc Doris imperial^, which forms the
subject of a coloured double-plate.

Brilliancy of colour also characterises many of the fish found in
Australian waters ; and that the chromo-plates of Syngnathiclae (sea-
horses) and Plectognathi are far from exaggerated in this respect will
be admitted by anyone who has visited the little aquarium started at
Hobart by Mr Saville-Kent himself. That these colours are more
brilliant in the mating season, and therefore due to sexual selection,
is not proved for all species, but is known to be the case with Mona-
canthus rudis, even as it is with our familiar stickleback. A very
important observation recorded by our author is that on the latent
colour-markings of certain fish. In the daytime longitudinal colour-
bands are conspicuous, but at night there appear further dark trans-
verse markings. These markings, controlled by the nerve-centres in
the adult (as proved by a blinded fish, which behaved as though it
were always night) are, in some cases at least, constant in the young,
a fact suggesting that the species are derived from transversely-banded
ancestors.

Chapter vii. does for the pearl-fisheries of Western Australia
what the author's former work did for those of Queensland. We are
not surprised to read that Mr Saville-Kent has unpleasant memories
of wading ashore through the mud-flats of the port of Broome, which
is the headquarters of the pearl-fishing fleet, and we are happy to be
able to assure him that the substantial jetty for which he longs has
already been built, and that from it there embarked as many as fifty
passengers only a month or two ago.

Marine miscellanea are dealt with in the following chapter, which

268 NATURAL SCIENCE [October

contains the account of a remarkable anemone, Acrozoanthus australiae,
that builds itself a home on the outside of the tubes of a nereid worm.
This the worm does not like, and stretches out its habitation in another
direction. The anemone, equal to the emergency, follows the new
branch, whereupon the worm strikes out again like a doubling hare.
The process continues till the anemone secures its inevitable victory,
and results in the formation of a singularly regular zig-zag polyp-
stock. Many of these polyparies grow side by side on submerged
rocks, sticking upwards when covered by water but hanging down
when exposed by the ebb of the tide like the corkscrew ringlets of an
old maid. We feel it our duty to note that in this chapter another
new species of coral is proposed, " provisionally associated with the
title of Turbinaria revoluta." Some day naturalists will recognise the
futility of excusing their new names on the ground of their " provi-
sional " nature. At present the phrase is generally diagnostic of the
amateur, and should be shunned by so accomplished a naturalist as
Mr Saville-Kent.

Insect oddities and vegetable vagaries are the titles of the last two
chapters, to which space does not permit further allusion. It is, how-
ever, in these that some of the most beautiful illustrations of the
volume are contained, notably of the shy-flowering cacti. Of the
other illustrations, those of most interest to the naturalist are of the
animals taken under water ; and in this new branch of photography
the author has made good progress since we first had the pleasure of
calling attention to his efforts. The group of holothurians (Colochiriis
ancc/ps), is a notable and instructive example of this genre. A
word of praise is clue to Messrs Waterlow, whose reproductions and
printing do the fullest justice to the art of the author. The chromo-
plates are ambitious, but, with the exception of plate 4, representing
a madrepore-reef, and Mr Frohawk's drawing of Chlamydosaurns, they
do not appeal to us. The attempt to reproduce the vivid colours of
the animals results in glaring masses devoid of life and natural
chiaroscuro. It is with the camera pure and simple that the author
is most successful, and he has learned the art of applying the scissors
to his photographs with the happiest results. We wish, for his own
.sake, that he would apply those useful instruments to his prose. His
golden rule is : never use one syllable when a word of four syllables
is to hand, never use one word when six will do, and don't bother too
much about the meaning of your phrases. When he wants to tell us
that a certain lizard will eat any food, he says " the gastronomic pro-
clivities of Trachysaurus are essentially omnivorous," and it amuses
him to speak of a hansom cab as "that indispensable anticlimax of
British Citizenship." To photograph an animal is "to immortalise it
with the camera," an expression which shows that the author properly
appreciates his own work. Neither can we fail to be struck by the
number of slips in the names of people, and even in some of the long
words so dear to him. Thus we find H. F. Blandford for W. T.
Blanford, J. I>. for G. D. Haviland, \l C. for A. C. Haddon; Gunther
for Gunther, Rontgen fur Rontgen : If. M. Johnston of Hobart is called
Johnson, though he must be well known to Mr Saville-Kent: even
four of the officers at the very museum where the author was formerly
an assistant are incorrectly referred to; Ipswich is confused with

1897] SOME NEW BOOKS 269

Norwich. The lmshman who says " triantelope," or, as we have
heard, " triantulope " instead of turantula, is said to he "less illi-
terate": what particular malapropism ought we to apply to a
scientific writer who uses such unusual spellings as "chaelae"'
" 1'ulchra," "inede," " Myrmicobius," "vestigeal," " synonomy,"
"Ostraea," "Geomiter," "Ehoea," and "spinnaret"? If, as our
author might say, this sumptuously embellished volume he dedicated
to a public with a predilection for the literary pabulum furnished by
the now senescent lions of the Daily Telegraph, then our critical
shafts are supererogatory. But the hook deserves a higher circle of
readers and a longer life, and therefore deserved a trifle more trouble
in the preparation. Let Mr Saville-Kent learn, before it is too late,
that one cannot take a snap-shot at immortality.

The Fossil-spotter's Manual

Die Leitfonsiliex. Von Ernst Koken. Svo, pp. 848, with about 900 illustrations in
the text. Leipzig : C. H. Tauchnitz, 1896. Price, 14 marks.

The ohject of this book is not to teach palaeontology, but to present
the geologist with a means of discovering for himself the genera to
which his collected fossils belong : the hook may be described, in
brief, as a guide to fossil-spotting. The aim is not one with which
we have great sympathy ; but within limits such a work is of value.
Dr Koken will certainly have done good service if his book leads any
geologists or others to pay more attention to the essential diagnostic
characters of genera and species, as detailed by their authors in the
text of their monographs, and to rely less on the superficial features
shown in the illustrations, which, as every worker knows, are often
incorrect.

The book is professedly incomplete, dealing as it does only with
Invertebrata, and omitting even from them such forms as are not of
much use to the stratigrapher. All the Tertiary species, too, find no
place in the second half of the book, although the more important
genera are discussed in the systematic section. The illustrations also
though many are good, are very unevenly distributed. A book of
tins kind needs more diagrams, such as those of Cardinia (p. 200),
Megalodon (p. 205), goniatite suture-lines (pp. 60, 61), and trilobites
(p. 18), and can well spare elaborate pictures, such as that of the rare
Silurian Pollicipes (p. 6, or the uninstructive Polyjerea (p. 332).
Illustrations that suited Dr Koken's excellent semi-popular work
"Die Vorwelt" (see Natural Science, vi., pp. 127-1 29, Feb. 1895)
are not adapted to the present student's manual, however much the
publisher may wish to utilise old cliches.

The first part of the book consists of a series of analytical keys,
arranged in the form of short paragraphs, each connected by reference
numbers with those that follow. It is an attempt to reduce dicho-
tomous tables to the recpiirements of the printed page, and is at first
somewhat perplexing. Let us try it in practice. Here is a small
brachiopod from the Upper Chalk. Section I. is " without hinge :
this has a hinge: turn to section II. II. A. are forms without free

270 NATURAL SCIENCE [October

arm-skeleton ; our fossil, however, has an arm-skeleton consisting of
a narrow loop, which projects forward into the shell cavity, and this
places it in II. B. c. 2. The first sub-division of this is according to
the length and curve of the loop, and our brachiopod agrees with the
second paragraph, "Loop recurrent, long. 11." Turning to 11, we
read " The loop free," which does not agree with our specimen ; and
then, " The loop again fixed to the median septum of the small valve.
16." Reference to 16 again gives us two sub-divisions, the first of
which includes shells that are "Smooth, . . . have large foramen,
and rudimentary deltidium. 17." Number 17 includes 3 genera,
Kinqena, Magas, and Rhynchora. Kingena has " median septum in
the large valve," and a "cross-band connecting the recurrent loop-
hands " ; these structures are not found in our fossil. Bhynchora has.
" hinge-line straight, long, large valve with area " ; this also does not
fit. We are therefore restricted to Magas, and find in fact that the
specimen agrees with the characters here ascribed to that genus.
Now this is admirable, and as scientific as it is possible for such keys
to be. But how often will the student or the field-geologist have a
specimen of Magas pumilus showing all, or even a few, of the necessary
characters ? Not one specimen in a hundred shows them. In tact
Professor Koken himself says of the Brachiopoda : " Since the delicate
calcareous bands are usually destroyed or only discoverable _ by
laborious preparation, other characters have to be used in practice."
In short, give the student a decent work of reference, such as David-
son's Monograph or the " Paleontologie Franchise," and he will have
determined genus and species long before you have made up your
mind whether the specimen has a brachial skeleton at all. The
truth is that the principles of classification are one thing and the
methods of fossil-spotting are another. The first essential for the
latter is an extensive acquaintance with specimens. Any collector
of Chalk fossils can tell Magas pumilus if he has once seen it, When
he has this acquaintance, then he can proceed to the true knowledge
required for the best systematic work. We must learn these concrete
sciences like we learn a language : get a good vocabulary first, and
proceed to the structure and syntax afterwards.

The second section of the book gives short diagnoses of the chief
species characteristic of the various formations, and is to be used after
i »ne has determined the genus. It is inevitably incomplete, and chiefly
intended for German students. Even for the fossils of Germany it is
not to be relied on without confirmation by the more complete original
monographs ; and this being so, it is a pity that there are no references
to literature. The fortunate collector of a Taxocrinus rhenanus cer-
tainly should not be able to identify it as a Cyathocrimis, the genus in
which Dr Koken leaves it. Some of the genera and species to which
reference is made, especially among the Gastropoda, we have been
unable to discover in literature at all, and have a strong suspicion
that they are here introduced for the first time (e.g., Ectomaria, p. 395).
This is undoubtedly the case with the name Amorphocystites, intro-
duced in a footnote (p. 41 1) as proposed by Jaekel for Caryocyslis
testudinarius Von Buch and C. pumilus Eichwald. It is very doubt-
ful if any such change of nomenclature be needed ; and in any case this
hole-and-corner method of bringing out new names has never yet been

1897] SOME NEW BOOKS 271

productive of aught but confusion, and wo are astonished to find it
adopted by so careful a worker as Professor Kokcn.

We realise the enormous labour expended on this work, which
may be of use to many under the guidance of a good teacher, and as
a supplement to scientific palaeontology on the one hand and to iield-
work on the other. But we ourselves prefer Professor Koken when
playing his other parts of original investigator or high-class populariser.

Miniatures by Hansen'

Tine Ciioniostomatidak. A Family of Copepoda, Parasites on Crustacea Malacostraca.
By Dr H. J. Hansen. 4to, pp. 206, with thirteen copper plates. At the expense
of the Carlsberg Fund. [Author's Motto: — "We want facts, not inferences,
observations, not theories, for a long time to come." — Natural Science, 1896.]
Copenhagen : Andr. Fred. Host & Son, 1897.

Within the memory of men still living an artist could obtain a
respectable reputation and a good income by painting miniatures.
The features of the original might reach any assignable degree of the
plain and the commonplace. It mattered not ; the portrait on ivory
was always like and always lovely. All this delightful flattery has
been destroyed or banished by photography, cheap and (sometimes) cruel.
But Dr Hansen's volume proves that there are mysteries of portraiture
with which the camera is still incapable of dealing. Though the
likenesses are not those of decorated officers or fashionable beauties,
but of forms more fitted to excite wonder than admiration, the picture
of each is drawn by him with exquisite delicacy of touch and the
most minute attention to detail. Each is confined within the compass
of an inch or two. But really this is a gigantic enlargement. The
true miniature is the natural object, often only one-hundredth of an
inch in length, and sometimes much less. Under a powerful micro-
scope animals of this size may become decently conspicuous. The
same can scarcely be said of the mouth, which in the Choniostomatidae
is not only absolutely but relatively small. It may be left to pro-
fessed arithmeticians to calculate the dimensions of their two pairs of
antennae and three pairs of jaws and the joints thereof, all which
need observing for purposes of full and accurate scientific description.
When it is added that the animals are not transparent, and that they
will not submit to pressure, the microphotographer will probably
leave them for the present, without attempting to challenge the
deftness of Dr Hansen's pencil.

For the neglect which this curious family has till lately ex-
perienced there is more excuse than usual. The poet might bewail
that in labouring to lie short he became obscure. These Copepoda
were probably short without labour and obscure by preference. How
else can we account for their choosing to belong to the neglected class
of Crustacea, choosing a life of self-effacement within that class,
choosing their hosts chiefly among its unpopular and little known
sessile-eyed groups, and burying themselves for the most part in
brood-pouches and branchial cavities ? To lie plain, they are crus-
taceans parasitic on crustaceans principally on Amphipods, Isopods,
and Cumacea, having been found in only a few instances on stalk-
eyed shrimps. A solitary species courts the public gaze on the outside
of its host's body.

272 NATURAL SCIENCE [October

Some prejudice attaches to the habit of existence in which these
creatures indulge. On the other hand, the Parasite in Lucian
maintains that his profession and personality are the true charm
and glory of social life. The parasite in zoology may urge in its own
favour that it is an eminent preacher and teacher of cleanliness, and
an unanswered advocate for the theory of evolution. The family
Choniostomatidae is at present divided into six genera. Forty-rive
species are known, chiefly through Dr Hansen's researches. The
first published, however, was Sphacronclla hiickarti, described by
Salensky in 1868. Thus, so far as their history is known, it is open
to suppose that the whole batch has been specially created within the
limits of the present century. But the reverential motive which
prompts hypotheses of that kind is surely undermined when they
require us to contemplate one set of crustaceans as specially contrived
to live and multiply, and another set of crustaceans as specially
contrived to be vampyres on the first set, and to stop them from
breeding. The latter strange effect produced by the presence of some
crustacean parasites on their crustacean hosts was first expounded by
Prof. Giard. Dr Hansen finds reason to believe that, as a rule, with
the exceptions to which all rules are liable, the Choniostomatidae
prevent their entertainers from rearing a family. With the opinion
advanced by Giard and Bonnier in regard to the Epicaridea, that each
parasite has its particular host, and is found on no other species, he
does not fully agree, and he also adduces evidence to show that such
a rule is not applicable to the whole of the present group. Certain
members of it have been discussed by the French authors just
mentioned, and some of their results are subjected to rather severe
criticism. This, amid the intricacies of a new subject, will be highly
acceptable to the general reader. Apples, for choice, need a subacid
flavour. They must not be so sharp as to set one's teeth on edge.
As the eminent authors reciprocally compliment one another in the
names of the new species, there is evidently here no very desperate
quarrel. By the extraordinary patience with which during several years
Dr Hansen has been accumulating his observations he is entitled to be a
little intolerant of more rapid methods, which cannot fail to be hazardous
in a material so difficult. The remark which he quotes on his title-page,
" We want facts, not inferences, observations, not theories, for a long-
time to come," is from Natural Science itself, so it must be true, and a
paragraph of his own, beginning, " Now-a-days many authors have a
remarkable weakness for publishing innumerable immature notes,"
deserves cosmopolitan circulation. In another passage Dr Hansen
says, " I confess that, though I honour everybody who is capable of
suggesting a theory which proves to be well founded and fertile in
results, I have always felt, and, as time goes on, feel more and more
distaste for superficial conjectures." But this is almost like saying,
"There are too many anglers ; what we want is fish." People will go
on angling to please themselves, without regard to what we want.
Allowance must lie made for differences of temperament and taste.
Some misguided persons hear of the discovery of new families, genera,
and species with a stolid want of enthusiasm. They perhaps for
their part think nothing important but the course of the nerves or
the action of the hepatopancreas. Mr Henslow dismisses the origin of

1897] SOME NEW BOOKS l»7:i

species by means of natural selection as a superficial conjecture, and
hopes for a speedy recognition that Darwin's deduction, as he calls it,
was a most unfortunate one. Supposing it to have heen so, the world
could well do with one or two more misfortunes of a similar kind.

Dr Hansen's hook is in English. This is evidently part of a
conspiracy to discourage the English-speaking peoples from studying
foreign languages, a plot in which llussia has, unfortunately, not yet
joined. The translation from the Danish manuscript has heen well
executed by Miss Louise von Cossel. It is unlucky that one fre-
quently recurring word has heen too literally rendered 'list,' not in
any of the accepted English senses of the word, hut to signify a ridge
or linear prominence, or possibly a seam or an unraised line of
hardening of the integument. In naming the mouth organs Dr
Hansen himself adopts the terms maxillulae and maxillae, respectively
for the first and second maxillae, on the analogy of antennulae and
antennae for the first and second antennae. The great objection to
these terms is that sometimes the first maxillae and the first antennae
are larger, even very much larger, than the second, and then the
diminutives are misleading. As a matter of fact, in a paper published
only last year by F. Vejdovsky, the second antennae are called the
antennules. The confusion is not unnatural in describing Anrphi-
pods, which often have the second antennae shorter than the first,
occasionally less than one-fifth as long. But these are not matters of
vital concern. For the pith and marrow of the research the reader
must have recourse to Dr Hansen's volume. It is a masterly piece
of work, which will confirm and increase his high repute as a
naturalist of distinction. T. R R S.

Prehistoric Problems, being a Selection of Essays on the Evolution of Man and other
Controverted Problems in Anthropology and Archaeology. By Robert Munro,
M.A., M.D. 8vo, pp. xix. + 371. London: Blackwood, 1897. Price, 10s.

In these days of scattered scientific literature, the bringing together
into a single volume of a number of essays by one author is a very
desirable thing, particularly when, as in the present instance, the
author is a scientist of distinction. Although the volume contains
comparatively little that has not already appeared in print, Dr
Alunro's newly-published selected essays on " Prehistoric Problems "
will be welcomed by many as a valuable addition to Archaeological
literature. The book consists of a number of chapters, each of which
is a separate and distinct essay. This collection of essays is of a
decidedly heterogeneous nature, comprising as it does so varied a
selection of subjects as : The Pise and Progress of Anthropology ;
Man's Antiquity and Place in Nature ; Prehistoric Trepanning ; Otter
Traps ; Bone Skates ; and Prehistoric Saws and Sickles. The very
varied nature of the subjects discussed imparts a character of in-
equality to the volume, and imposes a certain lack of proportion,
which is evident to the reader who, taking the book as a whole,
would read it straight through from beginning to end. Taken indi-
vidually, the essays are decidedly both instructive and interesting, and
the first four, which form Part I. of the volume, may well be taken
together, as they form a very fairly eonneeted and consecutive series.

274 NATURAL SCIENCE [October

They chiefly deal with the Antiquity of Man and his Place in Nature,
together with a brief history of the scientific study of Anthropology,
a field wide enough to have tilled the whole volume, and one which
we would gladly have seen treated in a more complete and less
condensed manner by Dr Munro. So far as the allotted space admits
the subject is skilfully handled, and the points are clearly brought
out; the style, too, is simple, so that it does not require a trained
scientific mind to grasp either the general conclusions or the details.
The first part of the book is, in fact, well suited to the general reader,
as well as of value to the scientist. 1 >r Muuro is hopeful in regard to
the possibility of bridging over the gap between the Palaeolithic and
Neolithic civilisations in Western Europe, and advances the important
finds of M. Piette in the Mas-d'Azil cavern, and the curiously similar
finds in a cave at Oban described by Dr J. Anderson, as helping
possibly to link the two periods. The evidence of a continuity
between the two periods is not as yet sufficiently complete, but a step
has been made in the right direction, and Mr A. Evans' researches in
the Balsi Rossi caves are much to the point in this connection.

One of the most interesting essays in the book is that dealing with
the importance of the assumption of the Erect Posture as a factor in
the physical and intellectual development of Man. Dr Munro is a
strong advocate of the enormous advantage which Man derived from
the attainment of the erect posture, and the consequent differentiation
of the limbs into hands and feet ; in other words, the releasing of the
fore-limbs from locomotive duties, so that they might become the
servants of the brain in other directions, and thus assist the develop-
ment of mental qualities. The position of Pithecanthropus crcctus in
the human phylogeny is reviewed in a judicial manner, and it is
pointed out how the calvaria and femur of this seemingly inter-
mediate type bear out the theory of the erect posture having preceded
the higher development of the brain in Man.

A slight rearrangement of the material in Chapters II. and IV.
would have obviated a certain amount of repetition in connection
with this point.

The second part of the volume, headed " Archaeological," comprises
four essays on quite distinct and unconnected subjects. These will
probably appeal less to the general public than those contained in
Part I., as dealing with more special points of archaeological interest.
The chapter on " Prehistoric Trepanning " is well worth reading, and
the subject is rather to the fore just at present, it having been dis-
covered that, in addition to the interest attaching to the primitive
surgical methods adopted in conducting so important an operation,
and the fact of the patient having so frequently recovered, there is
also a good deal of folk-lore connected with the practice, well worthy
of study. Dr Munro has brought together, in Chapter VI., all the
available data regarding the curious wooden objects which he on
fairly good grounds calls "otter and beaver traps." He handles tho
subject with skill, and, in the absence of direct evidence, the probable
use of these objects can only be arrived at by comparative study of the
examples. Space does not allow more than the mere mention of the
essay on "Bone Skates," whose claims to be in some instances con-
sidered as prehistoric are called in question, and that on " Prehistoric

1897] SOME NEW BOOKS 275

Saws and Sickles," in which is giveu an excellenl general account of
these implements, together with views on such controversial matters
as, for instance, the use of the wooden-handled Hint "saws" from
Polada, which Mr Spurrell regards as sickles allied to those found
by Mr Petrie at Kahnn.

The illustrations are numerous, and for the most part good ; the
text is not always free from blemish, in the shape of curious printer's
errors, which have survived the proof-reading ordeal ; there are also
sundry awkwardly turned sentences. These, however, do not in any
way affect the value of the work, nor do the unimportant, if inartistic
slips, impair our indebtedness to the author. H. B.

Some Elementary Text- Books.

First Stack Physiography (The Organised Science Series). By A. M. Davies. 8vo,

pp. viii. 238, with 110 illustrations. London: W. B. Olive & Co., 1897. Price, 2s.
Elements of Physical Geography. ByS. 15. J. Skertchly. 28th Edition ; revised

by J. H. Howell. 8vo, pp. viii. 224. London : F. Murby, 1896. Price, 2s.
A Text-Book of Geology. By W. J. Harrison. 8vo, pp. viii. 343, with 140

illustrations. London : Blaekie & Son, 1897. Price, 3s. (3d.
First Stage Mechanics of Fluids (The Organised Science Series). By G. H. Bryan

and F. Rosenberg. Svo, pp. viii. 208, with 77 illustrations. London : W. B.

Olive & Co., 1S97. Price, 2s.
First Principles of Natural Philosophy. By A. E. Dolbear. Svo, pp. x. 318,

illustrated. Boston, U.S.A., and London : Oinn & Co., 1897. Price, 4s. 6d.

The constant alterations in the syllabus for Physiography in the
.Science and Art Department's examination render necessary a
continual series of new or greatly revised text-books. Mr A. M.
Davies' " First Stage Physiography " will, therefore, no doubt be
extremely useful. It has all the merits of a good elementary text-
book ; it is concisely and clearly expressed, it is thoroughly reliable
and up to date ; it is illustrated by a series of well-selected diagram-
matic figures of which many are new ; and the definitions are ex-
plained by homely illustrations which are so chosen as to be very
suggestive to an intelligent student. The only point in the book we
regret is the use of the metric system for all dimensions, an inno-
vation in an elementary book on this subject which we think hardly
likely to lead to accurate perception among students. It was perhaps
a pity to refer to a lustre in the explanation of the form of a prism ;
for as the point in which students most often go wrong is by regard-
ing a prism as a triangular pyramid, an error for which comparison
with a lustre, which has a pointed end, is apparently generally
responsible. It is not cpuite correct to say that the snow-line reaches the
sea-level in Greenland. But except for one or two trivial points like
these, there is nothing in the book with which we can find fault.
AVe can only wish the bock the circulation it deserves.

Opportunity has been taken of the issue of a 28th edition of
Skertchly's small " Physical Geography " to subject it to extensive
revision, which might, however, have been made even more thorough.
The book, as it now stands, has many good points, the chapter on
" Astronomical Relations " being probably the best ; subjects such as
the precession of the equinoxes, and the method of finding latitudes
are generally stumbling blocks to the beginner, but they are here
clearly explained. The main points to which the editor might attend

276 NATURAL SCIENCE [October

in the preparation of a future edition is greater uniformity of
standard, and the reduction in number of needless technical terms.
In regard to the latter, the editor even proposes new terms in the
course of the book, describing some springs as " transtatic." Even if
the term were useful, its first publication in a shilling text-book
could hardly be commended. The restriction of "isothermal" to mean
annual temperature is neither usual nor convenient. There are still
many points in which revision is necessary ; Africa is not now
regarded as exempt from earthquakes (as stated on p. 154); it is too
late to say that the cause of the rising of the Nile is covered by
"much obscurity," or to affirm that glacier ice is "not plastic." The
geological classification of lakes into two divisions only (p. Ill) is
quite inadequate, while it is only burdening a student with useless
definitions to separate rivers into oceanic and continental, according
to whether they flow into the ocean or not. The appendix on the,
geographical distribution of animals could do with thorough revision :
Colubus is not a " tail-less ape " (p. 209) ; and to say that the long-
tailed manis and the ground-pig are "almost exclusively African" is
an error from excess of caution ; the python is not only found in the
Indian region ; Lepidosiren is not a reptile, and it is not excusable
now to include the crocodile among the lizards.

Mr W. Jerome Harrison is a very experienced science teacher, a
practical geologist, and has always shown himself a painstaking and
accurate worker ; hence it is not surprising that his " Text Book of
Geology " has reached a fourth edition. It now appears so much
enlarged and revised that it is practically a new book. The syllabus
for geology issued by the Science and Art Department is reprinted at
the end, accompanied by the questions set at the May examinations
for the past eight years. This fact suggests the class of students the
author wished to help ; and for the elementary stage of that examina-
tion we know of no better class-book. The book is, as a rule, reliable
and well up-to-date ; but we notice a few old figures that might have
been omitted, and a few points that might be revised. #The author
might have added the supposed land plant Berwynia to the list of his
pseudo-fossils, instead of accepting it as unhesitatingly as he has done
on p. 177. The pre-glacial age of man is not proved by either the
Cae Grwyn Caves or the Brandon implements. The explanation of the
Moel Tryfaen shells as "pushed up to their present heights in front
of" a glacier [the italics are Mr Harrison's] is one of the type (if
explanations which prejudices the anti-marine theory. The statement
(p. 180) that crinoids " are dying out, a few specimens only lingering
at the bottom of the deep seas," is a survival from twenty years ago,
which still lingers in many elementary works. Another common
mistake is regarding the Neocomian as the equivalent of the whole of
the Lower Cretaceous. The illustrations are numerous and good, and we
hope the book will soon reach a fifth edition.

The fourth and fifth books are not quite within our range; but
geographers and geologists occasionally have to deal with questions to
which some knowledge of the mechanics of fluids is essential. We
therefore need make no apology for calling attention to works in
which tin' elemental)' principles of the subject are clearly and simply
taught.

1SP7 J

SOMti XKW HOOKS 277

The Nectaries of Flowers

Beitjrage zttk Kenntnis her Seftalnectarien. By J. Schniewind-Thies. 8vo,
pp. 87, with 12 plates. Jena : Gustav Fischer, 1897. Price, 15 marks.

Tins volume, with its largo well-spaced text and its beautiful supply
of nicely lithographed plates, including 266 figures, once more brings
home the fact of the extreme specialisation of present-day science.
It is surprising to know that Mr Gustav Fischer can find it worth
while to publish at fifteen shillings an independent work dealing
with a special kind of simple honey-secreting tissue, and containing
about as much matter (if we except the plates) as half of a single part
of our Linnean Society's Journal.

Septal nectaries are the honey-secreting layers found, sometimes
on the outer surface of the ovary, but generally in the walls separating
the ovary chambers, in many genera of Liliaceae and other petaloid
monocotyledons. They have attracted the attention of various
botanists during recent years, and we could add to the references to
papers cited in footnotes by Mr Schniewind-Thies. The author gives
an account of the structure and position of the nectaries in genera of
Liliaceae, Amaryllideae, Scitamineae and Bromeliaceae, and dis-
i inguishes seven groups. In the simplest the secretion is effected by the
epidermal cells of the whole exterior surface of the ovary, from its base
to the origin of the three style-arms. The only examples given of this
are in two species of Tofieldia, one of the simplest genera of Liliaceae.
In the second group a " double nectary " is found, secretion occurring
on the surface of the ovary in three furrows lying along the septa, and
in three slits which permeate the separating walls of the- carpels. Ex-
amples are found in Yucca and Agapanthus. In the third group there
are no superficial glands, secretion occurring only in true septal slits as
in Funlia and species of Allium. Where the ovary is only partly
superior a double nectary may occur in the upper part and internal
ones only in the lower, as in Haivorthia and Urginea, or only in the
inferior part, as in Phormium and other Liliaceae, where a further
complication ensues in lateral branching of the slits and strong
development of vascular tissue in their vicinity. Where the ovary is
wholly inferior, as in Amaryllideae, Irideae and Scitamineae, and some
Bromeliaceae, secretion is confined to three septal slits, or occurs also
in three outer furrows at the thickened style-base. In Bromeliaceae,
with a superior or half-inferior ovary, the most complicated arrange-
ment is found, since, besides the double nectary as described for the
second group, there are also three internal glandular surfaces pene-
t rating the dorsal suture of each carpel, and opening upwards into the
ovary-chamber. Thus, it is suggested, increased complication in the
form of the nectary accompanies a similar change in final com-
plexity. In the second part of the paper the histology of the secreting
cell and the part played by the various constituents of protoplasm and
nucleus are discussed. In conclusion, we must again refer to the great
number of excellent drawings, which add greatly to the interest of a
communication consisting largely of somewhat detailed structural and
histological descriptions of individual cases.

27S X AT URAL SCIENCE [October

The Origin of the Diamond.

Papers and Notes on the Genesis and Matrix of the Diamond. By the late
Henry Carvill Lewis : Edited from his unpublished MSS. by Professor T. G.
Bonney, D.Sc, etc. London: Longmans, Green & Co., 1S97. Pp. 72, with 2
plates and 35 figs. Price, 7s. 6d.

The late Professor Carvill Lewis was much interested in the remark-
able occurrence of the diamond at Kimberley, and shortly before his
death devoted considerable care to a study of the rock in which the
diamonds are found. He communicated two papers on the subject
to the British Association in 1886 and 1887 with the intention,
apparently, of continuing his researches and of writing a book on
the general question of the origin and occurrence of the diamond.
This work was cut short by his premature death, and the present
volume contains merely the full text of the two British Association
papers, with a few notes and an appendix by Professor Bonney.

The most diverse opinions have been held regarding the nature
and origin of the peculiar rock, known as " Blue Ground," in which
the diamonds of Kimberley are embedded. A vertical column of
serpentinous material, unlike anything else upon the surface of the
earth, extending to an unknown depth, and of enormous dimensions,
it was supposed by some to be the neck of a volcano, by others to be
a volcanic breccia due to a sort of mud eruption. The object of Pro-
fessor Lewis's papers is to show, by an elaborate and minute
microscopic study of the rock itself, that it was a true igneous lava,
or, to use technical language, the ' Blue Ground ' was, according to
him, a porphyritic volcanic peridotite or basaltic structure, an olivine-
bronzite-picrite-porphyrite, rich in biotite (now very much de-
composed), and for this remarkable rock he proposed the name
" Kimberlite."

The chief argument upon which his conclusions were based is that
in twTo American localities, namely at Syracuse, New York, and in
Elliott County, Kentucky, a precisely similar rock occurs, though
without diamonds, and is there obviously an eruptive rock. Professor
Bonney 's appendix consists of a detailed description of these two
rocks, which he also regards as practically identical with "Kimberlite,"
although he does not quite agree with Professor Lewis's views con-
cerning the origin of the latter.

It has generally been supposed that the diamonds in the blue
ground were either caught up from some underlying rock or are due
to the fusion of the carbonaceous shales through which the blue
ground passes, or are decomposition products. Professor Lewis em-
phatically states his opinion that the diamond is an essential
constituent of the rock like any of the other minerals which if
contains; in this view he probably stood alone at the time of his
death, and it is not one which lias been generally accepted since.

It cannot be said, therefore, that these papers contribute much
to our knowledge of the origin of the diamond; they constitute a
careful description of the rock in which the precious mineral occurs
and establish the existence of a similar rock elsewhere, but no reason
is suggested why it only contains diamonds at Kimberley.

Professor Bonney has done well in giving these posthumous
papers to the world, and has considerably enhanced their value by

1897] SOME NEW BOOKS 279

appending his own description of the American Kimberlites. Ashe
slates in the preface that he has purposely avoided all reference to more
recent literature, the reader musl he content to miss any allusion to
the occni'rence of diamond in meteorites, although the resemblance
hetween Kimberlite and certain meteorites is frequently mentioned,
neither will any account he found of recent experiments upon the

solvent action of the blue ground u] diamond, or of the artificial

production of the mineral.

For these reasons the hook can only he regarded as a publication
cf papers that should have appeared ten years ago, which, though
interesting and important as a petrographical study, do not throw
much light upon the vexed problem of the genesis of the diamond.

H. A. Mieks.

Landslips.

REroKT ex the Geological Structure and Stability 01 the Hill-Slopes around
Naini Tal. Y>y T. H. Holland. Officiating Superintendent, Geological Survey
of India. Pp. viii., 85, with a map and 11 plates. Calcutta: Office of the
Superintendent of Government Printing, India. 1897.

This report shows the practical value of a thorough knowledge of the
geological structure of a district as a Heeling its suitability for habita-
tion. It is entirely a practical work, written for the guidance of
engineers and others familiar with the locality, and treats the subject
from a purely utilitarian stand} >oint.

Naini Tal is a lake in the north-west provinces of India on the
flanks of the Himalaya. There is a hill station located here, but the
district suffers somewhat from the frequency of landslips. It is,
indeed, probable that the lake owes its origin to the damming up of a
stream by a great landslip, as was suggested by Dr Ball in 1878,
though his views have not been universally accepted.

The object of the investigation, of which this report is the outcome,
was to discover the cause of the instability of the hill-slopes in the
district, to determine the extent of the insecure sites, and to suggest
means for increasing their stability.

The methods adopted by the author were the following : —

(1) On a large scale (20" to 1 mile) contoured map were inserted
details of the distribution and penological characters of the rocks.

(2) The angle of repose of the rocks under different conditions was
determined.

(3) Cross-sections were constructed from the map showing the
slope along the selected lines, and the portions of the rock lying out-
side the lines of safety were determined from the angles of repose.

The direction of the movements is shown in the report to be
governed by the direction of the stratification planes, which in many
areas have a dip in the same direction as the slope of the hill-sides
but smaller in magnitude.

The rocks most affected are shales and dolomitic sandstones, and
the lubricant is provided by the decomposition of the rock, which is
brought about by water percolating along the stratification planes, and
forming in the first instance a slippery clay, and in the second a layer
of loose sand.

The great difference between the angle of repose of dry broken

280 NATURAL SCIENCE [October

slate and that of the same material when disintegrated and wet, is
shown by the fact that the former will stand at an angle of 37°, while
the angle of rest of the latter is not more than 16°, and the author
points out that " the maximum angle of safety of interbedded rocks is
determined by that of the weakest constituent."

The author devotes a few pages to the classification of the land-
slips according to Heim's scheme, and proceeds to describe the warn-
ings which foreshadow a landslip, such as the opening of cracks
parallel to the strike of the beds and changes in the courses of streams.
Besides landslips of the ordinary type there occur subsidences caused
l>y the removal in solution of the dolomitic cement of the sandstones
and the consequent settling down of the loose material.

The most efficient methods of preventing the landslips appear to
be the provision of means for the removal of the rain-water before it
can percolate into the ground, and also for the discharge of subter-
ranean water by the construction of adits.

The Report concludes with a detailed description of three particular
sites, whose characters illustrate the results of the various forces-
described by the author. The value of the work is increased by the
well-drawn diagrams and sections, and by the excellent map for which
a special survey was made ; but it may be worth while to ask whether
such terms as ' demi-official ' and the contraction ' para ' for paragraph
are improvements on the conventional modes of expression.

Investigations into Applied Nature. By William Wilson, Junior. 8vo, pp. viii.,
143. London: Simpkin, Marshall & Co., 1896.

This little book hardly calls for serious review. The author may be
a pleasant enough companion in a country walk, if one were willing
to be a little bored, and may also have certain powers of observation,
but he is unable to arrange his matter in book-form or to express him-
self in English. The book is a strange conglomeration. The first few
chapters relate to " Our Indigenous Flora as Food-Plants " ; " On the
Habits and Instinct of the Rook " ; " Our Birds and their Functions " ;
" The Potato Disease"; and so on. The first paper has already been
inflicted upon the British Association, another on the Inverness Scien-
tific Society, and another on the Keith Literary Institute. Of pasture
plants Mr Wilson says, "We have not as much in general use, taking
the knowledge of variety as known to the average agriculturist into
account, as we can scarcely say there is any variety in them." And
speaking of the winter food of animals, " We find that human in-
genuity has invented a large number of so-called spices or condiments
to assist in feeding and keeping them (besides the fields' produce,
turnips and straw), and are generally used." The funniest chapter is
that on the crow, which, " like most objects of natural history, is very
imperfectly understood." It seems to be a selfish and quarrelsome
bird, but wily withal ; " unusual operations on the part of man on the
top of a stack is watched by the rook with suspicion, and in nine cases
out of ten that stack will be avoided by them." "Atmospheric
changes produce a very marked effect on them. There is no doubt
but this causes the peculiar reeling in the atmosphere [!]. Before
rainfall a dulness passes over them, early brightening up after the

1897] SOME NEW BOOKS 281

rain is over. Late nut of doors, so to speak, before snowstorm, and
the same again before a thaw in many cases." Dealing " with the
horses of Britain, it is supposed that they were first introduced by
Julius Caesar into history." The hackney " is a class of beast well
adapted for many requirements to which horseflesh has been attached
in " : and the sheep, "our most arduous animal inhabitant of pastures."
In Ins preface the author congratulates the public generally on the
spread of technical education and the increasing association of agricul-
ture and pure science. We regret that we cannot congratulate either the
author or the public on the appearance of these " Investigations,"
which tend to the advancement neither of pure nor applied Science.

A Malagasy Geology

Geology. Nataon-d Rev. R. Baron, F.G.S., F.L.S. Vol.1. Nohazavain' ny Sary 51.
Pp. vii. + 91, with 51 figs. Antananarivo : London Missionary Society's College,
1896. Price. 6s.

This very interesting production of the London Missionary Society's
press is the first and possibly the last geological work in Malagasy
that we shall see. The author divides his work into three sections and
twenty-five chapters, and deals with mineralogy, and the dynamics of
volcanic, metamorphic, and sedimentary rocks, with notes on the
several districts from personal observation and otherwise. Vol. II. is
promised, and will deal with the fossils. As it is difficult to give a
fair criticism on a book written in Malagasy we can only offer a
specimen of the author's easy style : — " Koa ny horohorontany dia
fipararetan' ny hoditry ny tany, fa mievotrevotra ka manalonalona
hoatra ny rano izy, ary ny toetran' izany fievotrevony izany dia
tahaka ny fitopatopan' ny alon-drano hiany. . . ."

Scraps prom Serials

In the last number of La Feuille des Jeunes Naturalistes (No. 323,
Sept. 1897), M. L. Vignal concludes his notes on the fossil shells of
the family Cerithiidae from the Eocene of the Paris Basin, this final
instalment being illustrated by two photograped plates.

In the Scottish Medical and Surgical Journal for September
Prof. Cossar Ewart prints his address delivered at the Graduation
Ceremonial in the Edinburgh University last July. He announces
that he has " practically proved that, notwithstanding the statements
of Weismann and the experience of scientific German breeders, there
is apparently such a thing as Telegony." He promises to contribute
a note on the subject to the next number of the same journal.

New Serials

Messrs Schleicher Freres of Paris announce a forthcoming inter-
national journal for zoology, botany, physiology, and psychology,
entitled Intermediarc des Biologistes. It is to appear on the 5th and
20th of each month, under the editorship of M. Alfred Binet. The
price and the date of the first issue are not yet decided.

According to Science, a small scientific monthly of a popular
character has been established at De Land, Fla., entitled Studies from
Nature.

282 NATURAL SCIENCE [October

A syndicate in Boston has purchased the American Naturalist
from the executors of the late Professor Cope, and the September
number is the first issue under the new management. Dr Eobert P.
Biy-elow is now chief editor.

Further Literature Received

Elements of the Comparative Anatomy of Vertebrates, adapted from the German of
R. Wiedersheim by W. N. Parker, ed. 2 : Macmillan. Volcanoes of North America,
I. C. Russell : Macmillan. Guide to Zermatt and the Matterhorn, E. Whymper : Murray.
The New Psychology, E. W. Scripture : W. Scott. A Critical Period in the Develop-
ment of the Horse, J. C. Ewart : A. & C. Black. Beitriige zur Dioptrik, A. Kerber :
Fock.

Variations in the Spinal Nerves of Hyla aurea, G. Sweet : Proc. P. Soc. Victoria.
Affinities of Tarsius, C. Earle : Amer. Nat. Princeton Contributions to Psychology,
vol ii., Nos. 1, 2. Baeveren i Norge, R. Collett : Beryens Mus. Field Columbian
Museum, Chicago, Geol. Series, No. 18 ; Zool. Series, Nos. 19, 20 ; Anthrop. Series, No.
16. U.S. Dept. Agriculture, Rep. No. 9. Australian Mus., Sydney, mem. No. ii.
(Atoll of Funafuti). Journ. Marine Biol. Assoc, vol. v., No. 1. U.S. Bureau of
Ethnology, 14th and 15th Ann. Reports. Roemer Mus. Hildesheim, mitth. No. 9.
The Glacio-marine Drift of the Vale of Clwyd, T. M. Reade : Quart. Journ. Geol. Soc.
Anatomy of Apera burnupi, W. E. Collinge : Ann. Mag. Nat. Hist. Australian
Termitidae, pt. ii. , and other papers, W. W. Froggatt : Proc. Linn. Soc. N.S. Wales
and Agric Gazette. Glacial Observations in the Umanak District, Greenland, G. H.
Barton : Tcchnol. Quarterly. The Diplochorda, A. T. Masterman : Quart. Journ. Micro.
Sci. Ann. Rep. Trustees S. African Mus., 1896. Ratzel's History of Mankind, Eng-
lish Trans., pt. 20: Macmillan. Journ. Coll. Sci. Imp. Univ. Japan, vol. x., pt. 2.
Bull. Nat. Hist. Soc. New Brunswick, No. xv.

Shooting Times, Aug. 21 ; Newcastle Courant, Aug. 21 ; Pharmaceutical Journ.,
Sept. 4; Amer. Geol., Sept.; Amer. Journ. Sci., Sept.; Amer. Nat., Sept.; L'Anthro-
pologie, July-Aug. ; Feuille des Jeunes Nat., Sept.; Irish Nat., Sept.; Journ. Essex
Techn. Lab., May- July ; Journ. Malacol., July; Knowledge, Sept. ; Literary Digest,
Aug. 14, 21, 28, Sept. 4; Naturae Novit., July-Aug.; Naturalist, Sept.; Nature,
Aug. 19, 26, Sept. 2, 9, 16 ; Nature Notes, Sept. ; Naturen, Aug. ; New Age, Aug. ;
Photogram, Sept.; Psychol. Rev., Sept.; Review of Reviews, Aug.; Rev. Scient., Aug.
21, 28, Sept. 4, 11 ; Rev. Sci. Nat. Quest., vol. vii., No. 1 ; Science, Aug. 13, 20, 27,
Sept. 3 ; Sci. Gossip, June-Sept.; Sci. Amer., Aug. 14, 21, 28, Sept. 4 ; Scot. Geogr.
Mag., Sept. ; Scot. Med. and Surg. Journ., Sept.; Victorian Nat., July ; Westminster
Review, Sept.

1897] 283

OBITUARIES

SAMUEL ALLPOET

Born January 23, 1816. Died July 7, 1897

We learn from the Geological Magazine of the death of the veteran
petrologist, Mr Samuel Allport, who was one of the pioneers in the
microscopical study of thin sections of rocks, and one of the most
generous helpers of the younger generation studying his favourite
subject. He was horn in Birmingham, where he resided for the
greater part of his life. For eight years only he was absent as
manager of a business at Bahia, in Brazil, and there he made his first
original observations on geology, collecting the cretaceous fossils from
the coast near Bahia and contributing a paper on the subject to the
Geological Society in London in 18G0. On returning again to Birming-
ham his interest was excited by the work of Dr Sorby on the micro-
scopical study of rocks, and thenceforward he became an accomplished
petrologist. He made his own sections with great skill, and amassed
a large collection of slides. His papers, chiefly published by the
Geological Society, were not numerous, but very valuable, and related
almost exclusively to the structure of igneous rocks. In 1887 he
received the Lyell Medal from this society in token of appreciation of
his researches. In 1880 he quitted business occupations and became
librarian of the Mason College, Birmingham, an office which he held
for seven years, until failing health necessitated his retirement.

FRANCIS AURELIAN PULSKY

Born 17th September 1814 Died 9th September 1897

Francis Pulsky, the great Hungarian patriot, and the friend of
Kossuth, is dead. His political life needs no mention here. On his
return to Austria after the Imperial pardon, he became Director in
1869, and in 1872 General-Director, of Hungarian Museums and
Public Libraries. An archaeologist, Pulsky's chief claim to the re-
membrance of our readers is his " Copper Age in Hungary," which
was published both in Magyar and German.

Thomas Brumby Johnston, the Queen's Geographer for Scotland,
died at Edinburgh on September 9th, in his eighty-fourth year. He
was the last of the firm, of which he became a partner in 1852.

Sir Everett Millais died on September 7th. He was born in 1856,
and paid especial attention to the breeding of dogs and stock, and for
some time was editor of The Stock Breeder.

284 [October

NEWS

The following appointments are announced :

Dr Rodet to be professor of bacteriology in the University of Lyons ; Dr
W. Ernest Thomson to the chair of physiology in the Andersonian College,
Glasgow ; Dr Alfred Osann to be teacher of mineralogy in the Chemical School
of Miilhausen ; Prof. Raphael Blanchard to be ordinary professor of botany in
the Medical Faculty of Paris ; Prof. Vladimir I. Belajeff, professor of botany in
the University of Warsaw, to be director of the Botanical Garden in the same
city ; Prof. Vladimir I. Palladin, of Kharkoff, to be director of the Pomological
Garden at Warsaw ; Dr H. V. Neal, of Harvard, to be professor of biology at
Knox College, Galesburg, Illinois ; Prof. George Ruge, of Amsterdam, to be
professor of anatomy and director of the Anatomical Institute at Zurich ; Dr
Joseph Baldwin and Wm. S. Sutton as professors, and W. W. Norman, as
assistant-professor, of biology in the University of Texas ; Dr H. Fling, pro-
fessor of biology at the Oshkosh Normal School ; Prof. H. de Vries and Prof.
Ph. Stohr to be professors of botany and anatomy in the University of Wurz-
burg ; Miss A. A. Smith as assistant in botany in Mount Holyoke College,
Mass. ; Ernest Wm. MacBride as professor of zoology in McGill University ;
and Dr Kihlman as assistant-professor of botany in the University of Hel-
singfors.

Women are now admitted to the College of Physicians in Chicago.

Mr Alex. White is the recipient of the silver medal of the Zoological Society
as a reward for his researches in the fauna of Nyassaland.

Dr 0. F. von Moellendorff, the well-known conchologist, formerly German
Consul at Manilla, has removed to the German Consulate at Kovno, Russia.

Professor R. Koch has returned to South Africa to continue his experiments
on the nature of the rinderpest. The conference of the South African States on
this great scourge was held in Pretoria during the first week of August last.

The Cothenius Gold Medal of the Imperial Leopold-Caroline Academy has
been awarded to Prof. Albert von Kolliker, the veteran anatomist of Wiirzburg.
The Baly Medal of the Royal College of Physicians of London has been presented
to Prof. E. A. Schiifer in l'ecognition of his imjjortant researches in physiology.

The first Fliickiger Medal — an honour to be awarded every five years by the
Gec^nan and Swiss Pharmaceutical Societies alternately — has been presented to
Mr Edward Morell Holmes, Curator of the Museum of the Pharmaceutical
Society of Great Britain. A short account of Mr Holmes' work in botany,
illustrated by an excellent portrait, appears in the Pharmaceutical Journal for
Sept. 4.

Mr William Shaus of Twickenham, late of New York, has presented his
collection of tropical Lepidoptera, comprising over 10,000 specimens, to the
American Museum of Natural History. Mr E. A. Hoffman has also presented
to the same museum his collection of North American Lepidoptera.

According to the Hevue Scientijique, the late M. J. Jackson left a legacy of
100,000 francs each to the Geological Society of France, the French Association
for the Advancement of Science, and to other similar bodies.

1897] NEWS 285

The Brazilian Government has decided to offer two prizes of $110,000 each
to the discoverer of a bacillus of yellow fever and its precise characters, and to
the investigator who shall determine the most efficacious means of dealing with
the disease. The Medical Institute of Rio de Janeiro, the Pasteur Institute of
Paris, and the Hygienic Institute of Berlin are conjointly to make the award.
Dr Sanarelli is likely to be recipient of the first prize.

Dr H. H. Field's Concilium Bibliographicum is again showing promising
activity. We have received a parcel of slips relating to the contents of Natural
Science. Dr Field is, we are glad to say, restored to health.

A bronze statue was unveiled at Crevalcore, near Bologna, on Sept. 8, to
Marcello Malpighi, the famous anatomist and microscopist. Dr Vallardi promises
a volume " Malpighi e l'opera sua " as a memorial of the event.

The University of California, having $4,000,000 promised or received, has
advertised for plans, the competition for which is international.

Science states that Peoria, Illinois, is to have a University on the death of Mr
Washington Corrington of that city, who is now eighty-five years of age, and
will leave a sum of over $1,000,000 for the new foundation.

Various donors have subscribed $100,000 to Hope College, Holland, Mich.
The Laman Missouri Educational Association has received a gift of $10,000 from
.Mr D. A. Beamer.

The Indiana Academy of Science is now receiving State aid in the printing
and publication of its Proceedings. It now holds much the same relation to the
State that the National Academy of Sciences bears with respect to the Congress
of the United States.

A bill for providing for a geological survey of the State of West Virginia
was passed by the legislature last session. The commissioners will be the
governor, treasurer, and president of the West Virginia University, the president
of the State Board of Agriculture, and the director of the West Virginia Agri-
cultural Exjjerimeut Station, who will serve without compensation, except out-
of-pocket expenses. They will appoint a geologist of repute and such assistants
as may be necessary. The survey is to examine the geological formation of the
State, with especial reference to economics ; soils and adaptability to particular
crops ; forests ; physical features with reference to occupations, industrial de-
velopment, and prosperity of the people ; and to make geological and economic
maps, and special reports on the geology and resources.

The American Association for the Advancement of Science will meet next
year — its fiftieth anniversary — at Boston, under the presidency of Prof. F. W.
Putnam. The Vice-Presidents for the sections are as follows : — Geology, H. L.
Fairchild of Rochester ; Zoology, A. S. Packard of Providence ; Botany, W. G.
Farlow of Cambridge ; Anthropology, J. McKeen Cattell of New York City.
M v L. O. Howard of Washington was elected Permanent Secretary. A con-
siderable number of papers have already been entered, a full list of which will
be found in the American Journal of Science for September.

Apart from the President's Address, the addresses of the Presidents of the
Section, especially interesting to the readers of this Journal, are those of
Dr G. M. Dawson, Prof. Miall, Dr Keltie, Sir Win. Turner, Prof. Michael
Foster, and Dr Marshall Ward. Dr Dawson dealt with the Ancient Rocks of
North America, tracing the history of the discovery, differentiation, and clas-
sification of the Palaeozoic formations. Prof. Miall protested that we study
animals too much as dead things, and are content, many of us, to name and
arrange them, according to our own notions of their likeness or unlikeness, and
to record their distribution. Dr Keltie gave a sketch of recent progress in

286 NATURAL SCIENCE [October

geography, and pointed out directions for further work. Sir William Turner's
paper dealt with distinctive characters of human structure, and was largely
concerned with the erect attitude. Prof. Michael Foster reviewed the progress
of Physiology since the Association last met in Canada, in 1884, and Dr Marshall
Ward gave a long and interesting paper on the economics of Fungi.

" The Globe " of Toronto provided a good account of the proceedings of the
Association, and illustrated it with amusing portraits and interesting informa-
tion ; one of the series of pictures gave the coats of arms of past presidents. The
Honorary LL.D. of Toronto University was conferred on Lords Kelvin, Rayleigh
and Lister, and on Sir John Evans ; the D.C.L. of Trinity on Lords Kelvin and
Lister, Sir John Evans, Sir Wm. Turner, and Sir George Scott Robertson. The
following grants were made to Committees of Biology and Geology : — Seismo-
logical Observations, £75 ; Erratic Blocks, £5 ; Investigation of Coral Reefs,
£40 ; Geological Photographs, £10 ; Age of rocks near Moreseat, £10 ; Pleistocene
fauna and flora of Canada, £20 ; Table at Naples Zoological Station, £100 ;
Table at Plymouth, £20 ; Index generum et specierum Animalium, £100 ;
Biology of Ontario Lakes, £75 ; Oysters, £30 ; Climatology of Tropical Africa,
£30 ; North- Western Tribes of Canada, £75 ; Glastonbury Lake Village, £37, 10s. ;
Ethnography, £25 ; Silchester excavations, £7, 10s. ; Ethnology of Canada, £75 ;
Torres Straits Expedition, £125 ; Changes of nerve cells, £100 ; Fertilization in
Phaeophyceae, £15. The total amount granted was £1350. The total attend-
ance numbered 1362.

We understand that, after various delays, the fitting and arrangement of the
new Paris Museum of Natural History are now making good progress. It is
hoped that the public galleries will be ready for opening early next year.

We hear from Science that plans have been submitted to the Department of
Buildings, New York, for two additions to the American Museum of Natural
History — one, a lecture hall at the north end of the Museum ; the other, a six-
story building attached to the west wing.

The Report of the Trustees of the South African Museum, Cape Town, for

1896, received this month, records the re-organisation of the staff and the com-
pletion of the new buildings, to which we have previously referred. The Museum
now has the services of Mr W. L. Sclater as director ; Mr L. Peringuey as
assistant-director, with special charge of the insects ; Dr W. F. Purcell as keeper
of land invertebrates ; Dr G. S. Corstorphine as keeper of geology and miner-
alogy ; and Dr J. D. F. Gilchrist as honorary keeper of marine invertebrates.
During the year 1896 a special grant was expended upon the purchase of a series
of large mammals for the collection, while an exchange with the La Plata Museum
furnished an important series of South American mammals and birds. Large
acquisitions of European rocks and fossils were also purchased for comparison
with the South African specimens.

We have received from Dr J. W. B. Gunning, Director of the Museum of the
South African Republic, Pretoria, a list of acquisitions for the month of July

1897. The Zoological Department is being especially enriched with examples of
the South African fauna.

The trustees of the Albany Museum, Grahamston, have decided to erect a new
and more commodious building. The necessary funds are already in hand, and
the work is to be proceeded with at once. The plans have been prepared by Mr
Viesebosse, architect of the Cape Town Museum. The new museum will be a
two-storied building, 150 feet long by about 60 feet deep.

We have received the first annual report of the Geological Survey of Cape
Colony, under the direction of Prof. G. S. Corstorphine. The new department
seems to be much hampered by a clamour for immediate economic results. We

1897] NEWS 287

hope the Colony will not be too impatient, but realise that the purely scientific
part of the survey must first be accomplished in more or less detail before the
economic problems can be satisfactorily attacked.

According to the American Nahiralist, the Academy of Natural Sciences of
Philadelphia is trying to raise $50,000 to purchase the palaeontological collec-
tions of Professor Cope. Since the fund received from the sale of the collection
is to go to the Academy for the foundation of a professorship of palaeontology,
it would seem appropriate that the collections themselves should become the
property of this society.

We have received the last part of the Bulletin of the Natural History Society
of New Brunswick (No. XV.), containing a long review of the scientific work of
Abraham Gesner, pioneer in the geology and mineralogy of Nova Scotia, by Dr
G. F. Matthew. Dr Matthew also describes supposed evidence of a thysanurous
insect from the early Palaeozoic rocks (Little River Group) of New Brunswick.
The thirty-fifth annual report of the Society makes the gratifying announcement
that the membership has considerably increased during the year. The library
also increases rapidly, and H.M. Treasury has generously presented to it a
complete set of the ' Challenger ' Reports.

We have received from Mr C. A. Snazelle, the energetic honorary secretary
of the Jersey Natural Science Association, a report of the second meeting of this
new society, and the first programme for the winter's meetings. In addition to
the meetings for general papers and lectures, there will be small sectional com-
mittees for various departments of detailed scientific work. We regret to learn
that Natural Science is so little cultivated in Jersey that the total membership
of the Society is still less than 50.

Mr William Bidgood, the Curator of the Museum of the Somersetshire
Archaeological and Natural History Society, in Taunton Castle, has just issued
the sixth edition of his Guide. The Museum is chiefly remarkable for its archaeo-
logical collection relating to Somersetshire, while among the geological specimens
are the cave remains from Banwell, Bleadon, Sandford Hill, and Hutton.

The total number of visits of students to the reading-room at the British
Museum during the year was 191,363, being 3,600 less than that of 1895, which
again was lower than that of 1894 by 8,000. This we regard in a very favourable
light, as it shows that the wise regulations of Sir Maunde Thompson, regarding
a certain class of readers, have resulted in greater comfort for the more serious
students. It also shows indirectly the value of Free Libraries.

The last number of the Journal of the Marine Biological Association of the
United Kingdom (vol. v., No. 1, issued August 1897) contains the annual report
of the Director and of the Council for 1896-97. Under the direction of Mr Allen
the Plymouth station continues to flourish and increase in utility. The Associa-
tion is also fortunate in retaining the services of Mr Holt, for the time beinc, as
Honorary Naturalist. The Lords Commissioners of H.M. Treasury in granting
the usual £1000 for the year 1897-98, have made it a condition that the Associa-
tion will give all the assistance in its power to the Inspectors of Irish Fisheries
in investigations which they desire to be made on the habits and migrations of the
mackerel visiting the Irish coast. This important work has thus been begun, and
the principal contribution to the new number of the Journal is Mr Allen's report
on the present state of knowledge with regard to the habits and migrations of the
mackerel (Scomber scomber). Most of the other papers also have an important
economic bearing. The large laboratory in the Plymouth station has been pro-
vided with a new flat tank, eight feet by five feet and eight inches deep, in which
Mr Garstang has been making the observations on Crustacea to which we refer
elsewhere. The sea-water supplied to the laboratory is still kept distinct from

288 NATURAL SCIENCE [October

the general circulation in the show tanks, and is never returned to the laboratory
tanks after it has passed through them. Experience shows that the theory of
'circulation,' as applied to aquaria, is illusory and in jiractice disastrous.

Science announces that the Zoological Expedition sent by Columbia Uni-
versity this summer to Alaska have lost all the results of their season's work by
the wreck of the City of Mexico, in which they were returning. Fortunately
all the members of the party were landed in safety. The Duke of the Abruzzi and
his companions successfully ascended Mount St Elias on July 30, 31. The height
of the mountain was ascertained to be 18,100 ft. Dr Sella was of the party and
we may hope for excellent photographs as illustration to the report of the
expedition.

We are indebted to Mr Duerden for an interesting account of this summer's
work of Prof. W. K. Brooks' party of Baltimore students in studying the tropical
life of Jamaica. As we have previously announced, the party this year was
under the direction of Prof. J. E. Humphrey, and established a temporary
laboratory in an hotel at Port Antonio, a locality in many respects more advan-
tageous than Port Henderson, the former headquarters. The director, one of
the most distinguished of the younger American botanists, collected and preserved
a large amount of botanical material, giving special attention to the shell-perfor-
ating algae and to the embryology of certain flowering plants. We deeply regret
to add that towards the end of the course of study he became ill and died almost
immediately. Another botanist, Mr A. Fredholm, dried a large collection of
Jamaica plants for the herbarium of the U.S. National Museum. Dr F. S.
Conant continued his researches on the medusae, begun last year. The chief
object of his investigation this season was the function of the sensory organs of
the medusa, and material was prepared with especial reference to a study of the
changes, under the influence of light and darkness, in the pigment of the retina
of the eyes. Dr H. L. Clark also continued his previous researches on the
echinoderms. He devoted special attention to the life-history of the interesting
holothurian Chirodota. Mr Sudler returned to Port Henderson to dredge for the
small crustacean Lucifer, which he could not find at Port Antonio. Mr Grave
studied various ophiurans, and doubled the number of species recorded from
Jamaica. The eggs of one species were artificially fertilised in the laboratory, and
a complete series of the embryos from the single cell to the fifteen-day Pluteus
stage was satisfactorily preserved for future examination. Mr E. N. Berger
devoted his time chiefly to insects and arachnids, obtaining many embryonic
stages, especially of a pseudoscorpion, probably Obisium. There were also j unior
students. Mr Duerden, as Curator of the Jamaica Institute, was invited to
join the party ; he profited by the occasion in enriching the Museum collection,
and in continuing his researches on the corals.

ERRATA
Page 88, lino 3. For ' invariable ' read ' variable.'
„ 148, ,, 6. „ 'Marlotf „ 'Marlatt.'
,, l.r>8, ,,12. ,, 'collection' ,, 'collector.'

NATURAL SCIENCE

A Monthly Review of Scientific Progress

No. 69— Vol. XI— NOVEMBER 1897

NOTES AND COMMENTS

The Confirmation of Darwin's Theory of Coral Islands

During the past few years there has been a lull in the long contro-
versy regarding the origin of the coral atolls of the Pacific. The
arguments for and against Darwin's theory had been so often repeated
that people were tired of deductive reasoning on a problem which
might at any time be solved by a practical test. It has been
admitted for many years that the only method of ending the con-
troversy is to make a deep boring in an oceanic atoll. The first
attempt to apply this method was made during the expedition of
the United States cruiser, the Tuscarora, but the boring tools broke
at a slight depth. In 1891 a committee was appointed by the
British Association to arrange a plan for a new attempt. The
Admiralty was willing to assist by help of a surveying ship, and
the Government of New South Wales was ready to lend the bor-
ing equipment. A report was prepared, and it was recommended
that Funafuti, one of the Ellice Islands, should be the site of the
experiment. Accordingly a joint expedition was sent out by the
Royal Society and the Australian Museum at Sydney, and was led
by Prof. Sollas. Valuable natural history collections were made
at Funafuti, and many interesting anthropological observations re-
corded ; but the main object of the expedition was not accomplished,
as the boring failed. The observations collected were claimed by
Admiral Sir W. J. L. Wharton as opposed to Darwin's theory ;
whereas Mr Chas. Hedley of the Australian Museum maintained
that the general survey of the island strongly supported it. With
splendid perseverance the Australian authorities resolved to renew
the attempt. Accordingly a new expedition was sent out under
the command of Prof. T. Edgeworth David of Sydney. A tele-
gram from Sydney on October 4 announced that all the difficulties
had been successfully overcome, and that the boring had been
carried to a depth of 5 5 7 ft. , and was still in coral rock. A further
telegram on October 12 announces that the depth of 643 ft. has
been reached and the boring is still being carried through coral rock.

290 NATURAL SCIENCE [November

Prof. Edgeworth David may therefore be congratulated on
having finally proved conclusively the truth of Darwin's brilliant
theory. It may be objected that it is too soon to shout, as the
cores have not yet been subjected to microscopic examination, and
that one boring is not sufficient. But neither objection is worth
much. Coral-reef rock is of very varying composition ; the coral
grows in hummocks separated by more or less narrow spaces, which
are filled up by coral sand, broken shells, foraminifera, &c. Micro-
scopic examination of fragments of limestone broken from coral reefs
sometimes shows no trace of coral. Coral, moreover, is more readily
decomposed than shell sand or foraminiferal limestones. Hence it
will not be surprising if most of the slices cut from the deep core
shew no trace of coral structure. But that will not prove that they
are not to be regarded as reef rock. Nevertheless it is to be hoped
that some parts of the limestone from the bottom of the core will be
sufficiently well preserved to show the nature of its formation.

To the objection that one boring is not sufficient to prove a
theory proposed for so many islands, it is only necessary to point
out that Darwin himself insisted that his theory was not universal.
He never intended it to apply to the coral reefs of the West Indies,
the Eed Sea or the Persian Gulf. What the Funafuti boring has
proved is that the subsidence method is possible ; and if one island
in the Ellice Archipelago is sinking, it is probable that the other
islands in that group are also doing so. No doubt some cases will
be found in the Pacific of coral islands formed on banks left by
denuded volcanoes. But the arguments which Darwin used to show
the improbability of many of the atolls having been formed in this
way are still valid ; and they are strengthened by the demonstration
in the only atoll yet tested, that the basis is a block of subsided
reef limestone.

There is some zoological evidence in support of a former migra-
tion of land animals across the area now occupied by the coral sea ;
and naturalists are now at liberty to explain their distribution by
the former existence of land in that area.

The persistence with which the Australian naturalists have
persevered in their attempt to settle this controversy, and the skill
with which Prof. Edgeworth David has overcome the mechanical
difficulties, are worthy of the highest praise.

The Temperatuees of Eeptiles, Monotremes, and

Marsupials

Several other interesting contributions have reached us this month
from the Antipodes, and among the most valuable may be noted an
account of some new experiments on the body-temperature of verte-

1897] NOTES AND COMMENTS 291

brates by Mr Alexander Sutherland (Proc. Boy. Soc. Victoria, n. s.,
vol. ix., pp. 57-67, pi. vi.). For many years past there has been a
tendency to diminish or ignore the distinction between the cold-
blooded and the warm-blooded types of animal life. The new
results, however, seem to confirm the idea that the distinction is a
real one, though they show more clearly than ever that several
gradations between the two types still survive in the existing world.
Cold-blooded animals sometimes develop a capacity for heat-pro-
duction in the action of their viscera. Mere digestion, for example,
may increase the temperature of a snake from 2° to 4° C, while
amatory emotion is known to have the same effect on snakes,
lizards, and frogs. But in general this excess of warmth is not
great, and it leaves the gap between the warm-blooded and the cold-
blooded type quite evident.

Mr Sutherland's first two experiments were arranged to re-
determine to what extent the temperature of a reptile varies with
that of its surroundings. He placed some lizards in a tank of
water, leaving only their noses uncovered, and then warmed the
water at various rates of speed by means of one or more lamps. In
each case he found the rise in temperature of the animal and of the
water to correspond almost precisely. Other observations also point to
the same conclusion, namely, that cold-blooded animals at rest take
their temperature almost absolutely from their environment.

Mr Sutherland next records his experiments with the Monotreme
Mammalia. Their low temperature has often been remarked upon.
Baron Miklouho-Maclay once determined that of the duck-billed
platypus (Ornithorhynchus) to be only 24*8° C, while the average
temperature of forty-five specimens of the higher orders of the mam-
malia (excluding monotremes and marsupials) observed so long ago
as 1825 by John Davy, was proved to be nearly 39° C. — a result
subsequently confirmed by Max Fiirbringer. The platypus is,
indeed, almost a cold-blooded animal, and the echidna rises very
little higher in the scale. Mr Sutherland finds the average tem-
perature of Echidna hystrix to be 2 9 "4° C, but it curiously varies : —
"An echidna one cold morning was so low as 22° ; another, brought
in from the forest in a sack exposed to a fierce midday heat, regis-
tered so high as 3 6 "6°. . . . This is an immense range for a mam-
mal, and suggests a reptilian want of capacity for temperature
regulation."

As the result of 126 observations, Mr Sutherland determines
the average temperature of sixteen different species of marsupials to
be 36° C, or three degrees below the average of the higher mam-
mals. The marsupial most nearly approaching the monotremes in
temperature proves to be the wombat (34*1° C). Next comes the
flying squirrel (Petaurus), with average 35*7° C. Eighty-three

292 NATURAL SCIENCE [November

observations on the koala (Phascolarctos) show its average tempera-
ture to be 3 6 "4° C. The range in any one individual at different
times is generally proved to be very small. Mr Sutherland, how-
ever, observes : — " I have often known healthy specimens (of Phas-
colarctos) that had been for a while in the sun stand as high as
37'9°, while on a cool day, or in a very shady place, the same indi-
viduals would be only 35-3°, a range greater than we would find
under the same circumstances in any of the higher mammals. The
highest register I ever obtained for a thoroughly healthy koala was
3 8 '4°, which is a degree and a half above the normal temperature of
man; the lowest was 34*9, or nearly two degrees below man's
normal. The former temperature would in man imply some con-
stitutional derangement, a distinct case of feverishness ; in the
koala it denotes only that it has been out in the sun. The lower
temperature, though common in the koala, is never met with in man
except in rare pathological conditions."

It is clear, therefore, that there are grades of temperature, and
that the mammals which are classed lowest on anatomical grounds
are not only of the lowest temperature, but also of the greatest
range, and they are likewise, of all mammals, those which are under
the strongest and most direct influence of the temperature of the
environment. Similar, though more incomplete, connecting links
may also be noted in the case of birds.

In a very general way (concludes Mr Sutherland), and not
forgetting numerous limitations and contradictions, it may be said
that bodily activity depends on body temperatures, that creatures,
such as insects and reptiles, are active only when warmed up from
without, but become torpid with decreasing temperature. The type
in which activity is generally habitual, maintains its own body
temperature. This is seen in the mammals, but more still in the
birds. But this warm-blooded active condition was produced by no
sudden emergence ; the monotremes and marsupials form a gentle
gradation between the reptile and the carnivore or ungulate ; while,
so far as indications point, there is reason to believe that the lower
birds still are reminiscent of a once existent chain of links which
equally joined the cold-blooded lizards to those warmest-blooded of
all creatures, the passeriform and fringilliform birds.

Entomology in Australia

Mr W. W. Froggatt has published (Proc. Linn. Soc, N.S. Wales,
1896, pp. 510-552) the second part of his work on the termites of
Australia. A short account of the life-history and social economy
of the insects, unfortunately written without reference to Grassi's
recent researches, is followed by a revision of the genera, which

1897] NOTES AND COMMENTS 293

will be valuable to naturalists elsewhere than in Australia. The
Australian species which have come under observation are carefully
described and figured.

In addition to such systematic work, Mr Froggatt turns his
attention to economic problems, and we have received several of his
entomological notes from the Agricultural Gazette of New South
Wales for the current year. Some of the insects dealt with are
native species, which have become destructive in gardens and
orchards, while others are familiar British forms introduced with
European plants.

The Cuckoo

The nesting habits of cuckoos are always interesting, and Mr A. J.
Campbell has recorded in the Victorian Naturalist for August a list
of the foster-parents of the Pallid Cuckoo (Cuculus pallidus, Lath.)
of Australia. The observations show that the cuckoo almost always
selects open nests, and that the Honey-eaters are the most favoured
foster-parents. Mr Campbell mentions that the supposition that
the cuckoo throws out the egg or eggs of the foster-parent to make
room for its own has not been proved with regard to the Pallid
Cuckoo ; but he has found a broken egg of the bird underneath the
nest of the White-shouldered Caterpillar-catcher (Zalage tricolor).
At present there is no record of any cuckoo's egg having actually
been taken from any Caterpillar-catcher's nest, though one of these
birds has been observed feeding a young Pallid Cuckoo.

The Mental Development of a Child

The latest of the series of larger monographs published by the
editors of the Psychological Review is a careful record by Mrs
Moore of the behaviour of her boy during his first two years. Such
records by psychologically-instructed observers are likely to be of
much use for child-psychology ; and this may be said of the present
one, though the want of arrangement in the earlier part detracts
seriously from its value. Great masses of facts are bewildering
unless arranged on some principles. The writer begins very sug-
gestively by distinguishing four periods — first, of seeing till the end
of the fourth month ; second, of feeling or fingering things till the
seventh month ; third, of examination or more systematic explora-
tion ; fourth, of speaking from the close of the first year. Unfor-
tunately, this division does not reappear in the body of the work.
The classification of movements is also confused. But having said
this, we may be grateful to Mrs Moore for what she has given us ;
and it will be best here to select a few of the interesting points
which occur in the course of the work. The first is a notice of

294 NATURAL SCIENCE [November

certain epochs or periods in which the child made very rapid pro-
gress, on the thirty-fifth day, in the eleventh month, etc. (pp. 6, 7)
— an important observation on which more data are desirable.
Under the head of movements (Part I.) there is a useful record
of voluntary movements, pointing to the growth of volition out of
" repetition of an act which had originally caused either a cessation
of discomfort or a sense of gratification" (p. 27). Many of the
conclusions drawn are naturally rather corroborative of current
psychology than pointing in any fresh direction. Parts II. and IV.
are inferior in quality to the rest. Under Part II., which deals
with Sensations, we have, on pp. 45 and 56, the note that even
on the second day the eyes followed the movement of a bright pair
of callipers — a date important on its bearing on the theory of visual
space-perception. On page 66 we have the less important denial
of an unborn ability of localising sounds. On pp. 80, 81, there
are some remarks on the localisation of pain, which is declared to
follow that of "other" dismal sensations. On page 87 it is denied
that attention, at any rate in its involuntary form, comes late : the
child gazed at a patch of light continuously on the thirtieth day
(p. 46). Part IV. deals with language, giving careful tables of the
sounds used and the principal substitutions of sounds for one
another, as well as full vocabularies of the child at the close of the
second year. The order at which the different parts of speech
begin to appear is noted, as well as their numerical importance.
One point which is emphasised more than once (pp. 123 and 97)
is that the child's first names do not refer to indefinite or vaguely
conceived individuals, but that the child does not understand the
necessity of a name for each separate thing, and his words stand
for what is interesting to him in his experience. As against any
idea that general concepts arise from the fusion of individual
precepts — this is however what would generally be understood.
Mrs Moore's work will be a useful repertory of facts, to which
she has been careful to supply an index.

The International Geological Congress

The Seventh Session of the International Congress was held
in St Petersburg last August with great success. The attractive
programme offered by the Russian geologists, with the aid of their
Government, brought together a large number — nearly a thousand —
especially from Germany and Austria. Americans and French were
well represented, largely by mining engineers anxious to study the
rich ore deposits of the Ourals. Englishmen were no doubt diverted
to the other side of the Atlantic by the meeting of the British Asso-
ciation, and were therefore proportionally few.

Of the excursions before the Congress, those to Finland and

1897] NOTES AND COMMENTS 295

Esthonia seem to have been more successful than that to the Ourals,
owing to the difficulty of transporting the larger number in the
latter case. Those who visited Finland had an opportunity of test-
ing the classification of supposed Archaean rocks recently put forward
by Mr J. J. Sederholm (see Natural Science, vol. x. 1897, p. 79).
The general opinion seemed to be that the evidence was insufficient
to warrant the ascription of an Archaean age to many of the rocks.
Under the leadership of r>aron de Geer the glacial phenomena of
the district were studied, and the Asar, with which many English
geologists made their first acquaintance, gave rise to interesting dis-
cussions. The main object of the Esthonian excursion, under the
direction of Akademiker Friedrich von Schmidt, was the examination
of the Cambrian, Ordovician, and some of the Silurian rocks of the
Province. The junction of Ordovician and Silurian was not over
easy to follow under the conditions of the excursion, but the grand
series of absolutely unaltered Cambrian with Platysolcnites, Olencllus,
Obolus, and Dictyohema, was a revelation to many. The party had
also the advantage of the presence of A. von Mickwitz, whose palaeon-
tological work in these Cambrian beds has been of the highest value.

At the Congress itself, if no practical results were arrived at,
still many discussions on matters of general importance to geologists
took place. The main problem put before the Congress was the
classification and nomenclature of rocks, both stratified and igneous,
but chiefly the former. Treatises by Messrs Freeh, Bittner, Walther,
and Loewinson-Lessing formed the basis of discussion: This re-
sulted in the following resolutions : " The Congress is of opinion
that the historical method of classification must be adhered to,
though it should continually be made more natural. The council
is to nominate a committee to study the principles of classification in
this spirit." " The introduction of a new stratigraphic term into
international nomenclature should be based on a clearly defined
scientific necessity supported by peremptory reasons. The appella-
tions applied to a terrane in a definite sense cannot be applied in
any other sense. The date of publication is to decide the priority
of stratigraphic names given to the same series of beds." " For the
minor stratigraphical divisions, sufficiently characterised palaeonto-
logically, in the case of the creation of new names, it is preferable to
take as their basis the most important palaeontological characteristics.
Geographical or other names should only be used for divisions of a
certain importance containing many palaeontological horizons, or
when the terrane cannot be characterised palaeontologically." "Names
badly formed from an etymological point of view are to be corrected
without excluding them from the domain of science." Certain proposals
of minor importance were referred to the above-mentioned committee.

There is no doubt that with the advance of geological knowledge

296 NATURAL SCIENCE [November

we suffer from a superabundance of names. But it is to be hoped
that the promulgation of these rules will not call into existence an
army of nomenclaturists, whose delight it will be to search antique
literature for forgotten appellations, or to puzzle their brains with
lexicons in the attempt to make all names pass the same etymo-
logical standard. We have enough of this sort of thing in system-
atic biology, and we don't want any more of it.

After the Congress about half the members took part in the
various excursions that culminated in the Caucasus and the Crimea.
The Carboniferous rocks of the Moscow neighbourhood, the Permian
of Nijni-Novgorod, the' Mesozoic and Cainozoic strata of the Volga
and Donetz basins were introduced to the foreign geologists by such
able students of them as S. Nikitin, A. Pavlov, W. Amalitzky,
T. Tschernyschev, and N. Sokolov. The difficulties of transporting
and personally conducting such large numbers were successfully
overcome, but necessitated the compression of the passage of the
Caucasus into far less time than was desirable or was originally
intended. Side excursions to Elbruz, Grozny, Astrakhan, the Tsei
and Devdorak glaciers, and other points of interest compensated
for this in some measure, and usually proved to be the most
enjoyable parts of the excursion. After ridding themselves of
superfluous roubles in the bazaars of Tiflis, the visitors explored
Baku, the city of petroleum, and then crossed the Black Sea to
study the Jurassic, Cretaceous and igneous rocks of the Crimea
under the leadership of A. de Lagorio, N. Andrussov, C. de Vogt,
and others. F. Loewinson-Lessing, after his arduous Caucasus
campaign, engaged in the no less difficult enterprise of transporting
some forty persons, of both sexes, to Ararat. With the rough way
made plain for them and the crooked straight, those who took part
in this excursion declared that in beauty and interest it was worth
all the rest put together. Its close was unfortunately saddened
by the loss of Mr Stoeber, a lecturer on pharmacy at Vladikavkaz,
who was helping Professor Lessing. Joining in an unsuccessful
attempt to ascend Great Ararat, he was more rash than his com-
panions, who subsequently found him frozen to death.

The pleasure of many of these excursions was seriously marred
by the great numbers that availed themselves of the exceptional
opportunity. Worse still, it appeared that many of the members
were hardly geologists. An attempt will probably be made in
future to restrict the membership of the International Geological
Congress to recognised workers. There is no reason why such a
body as this should have its dignity and usefulness marred by all
the tag-rag-and-bobtail that choose to rush for railway passes and
free champagne, and we shall warmly support any movement for
the more sparing distribution of its privileges.

1897] NOTES AND COMMENTS 297

A Floating Scientific Station
An important proposal was laid before the International Geological
Congress by Professor Andrussow. It was that a ship, fitted with
scientific laboratories and apparatus, should constantly be maintained
at sea by international contributions, and that geologists and biolo-
gists of all contributory nations should be allowed a place on board
for carrying out observations. The importance of the study of the
ocean-floor, and of all marine deposits now forming, will be denied
by no geologist, but the opportunity as a rule is lacking. Hence
geologists no less than biologists are interested in the maintenance
of such a floating scientific station. The difficulties in the way of
the proposal are too obvious to need comment, but if there is a real
desire to see it put into effect nothing need prove insuperable. Since
the idea received the warm support of Dr John Murray, Professors
von Zittel, Haeckel, Walther, Prinz, and other influential scientific
men, there is no doubt but that we shall hear more of it, and we
wish it all success.

The Black Sea
An excellent illustration of the geological value of thalassography was
afforded by the Black Sea. On the steamer that conveyed the main
body of geologists from Batoum to Odessa, dredging apparatus was
provided and a small laboratory fitted up, enabling those who wished
to verify for themselves the interesting account of this sea given by
Professor Andrussov in the Livret Guide. The most striking
peculiarity of the Black Sea is the absence of all life except bacterial
at depths exceeding 100 fathoms. The cause of this may be put
briefly thus. Into the deep and steep-sided Euxine basin there is
poured, especially on the northern side, a vast amount of cold fresh
water from the rivers. Thus there is started in the direction of
the Bosphorus a surface stream,

" Whose icy current and compulsive course
Ne'er feels retiring ebb, but keeps due on
To the Propontic and the Hellespont."

From the Bosphorus into the Black Sea a very slow under-current
brings the warmer but Salter and therefore heavier waters of the
Aegean. These scarcely mingle at all with the surface waters, but
sink to the bottom. The exchange takes place so slowly that, ac-
cording to the calculations of Admiral Makarov, it requires at least
1700 years to renew the water of the lower strata, whereas the
water of the upper 100 fathoms is renewed annually. Below 100
fathoms, therefore, the quantity of oxygen contained in the water
diminishes rapidly, and while the cold brackish water of the surface
and of the narrow shelving shore is unfavourable to the develop-
ment of ordinary marine life, the deoxygenated water of the depth,
despite its saltness and warmth, is absolutely fatal to all organisms
other than bacteria.

298 NATURAL SCIENCE [November

The action of these deep-sea bacteria is truly remarkable. In
other seas the rain of dead organisms from the surface plankton
forms the food of other organisms living in the depths. But here
the rain, after it has fallen through the upper 100 fathoms, finds
no organisms to eat it. The microbes have it all to themselves.
The albumen of the descending dead organisms putrefies under the
influence of the bacteria ; oxygen is taken from it to form carbon
dioxide, and hydrogen sulphide is evolved. The carbon dioxide
appears to help in the formation of the fine precipitate of carbonate
of lime that is found in the depths. The hydrogen sulphide partly
acts on the salts of iron in the water, forming iron sulphide, partly
decomposes as it reaches the oxygen of the surface.

The gradual establishment of this peculiar state of things can
be traced. Geological evidence shows that in Oligocene and
Miocene times the Euxine and Caspian basins were connected, only
being separated by the final upheavals of the Caucasus. Connection
with the Aegean was due probably to the cutting down and lower-
ing of a river-channel, of which the Bosphorus and Dardanelles are
the remains. When this took place is uncertain. It cannot have
been long ago, geologically speaking, because the shells of Drcissensia
and other brackish-water molluscs are found lying on the bottom of
the Black Sea at depths where neither they nor any animals can
now exist. On the other hand the northern character of the Black
Sea fauna, notably the presence of the common porpoise, suggests
that the connection existed already during the Glacial Period.

Further interesting details, together with a description of the
deposits now forming in the Black Sea, will be found in Professor
Andrussov's guide. We have merely quoted enough to show the
intimate relations between geology and oceanography, relations which
we are glad to see officially recognised by the International Congress.

An Extinct Sea- Cow

Last month (p. 223) we briefly referred to our unfortunate lack of
knowledge of the ancestors of the Sirenian mammals commonly
known as sea-cows. In reference to this subject, we have now
been favoured by Mr A. S. Woodward, of the British Museum, with
the accompanying restored drawing of the skeleton of the best-
known extinct Tertiary Sirenian, Halitherium, which he has recently
had prepared for a forthcoming work on Vertebrate Palaeontology.
This figure (p. 299), which is of about one-fifteenth the natural size,
is mainly based upon a skeleton in the Museum of Mayence and
upon the researches of Dr G. E. Lepsius, of Darmstadt.

Halithermm schinzi is found in the Lower Miocene sands of
Hesse Darmstadt, and so dates back to the early part of the Ter-
tiary period. It will be seen, nevertheless, that it only differs from

1897]

NOTES AND COMMENTS

299

300 NATURAL SCIENCE [November

such a Sirenian as the existing manatee in but the smallest par-
ticulars. Some of its teeth seem to have been replaced by vertical
successors. The vertebrae exhibit distinct traces of terminal epi-
physes in young animals. The hind limb is represented not only
by the rudimentary pelvis, but also by a trace of the femur.
Otherwise, its skeletal parts are almost identical with those of its
surviving relative. Since the Sirenians came into existence, indeed,
very little change has taken place among them.

The Beaver in Norway

The beaver, which was once so common throughout northern
Europe, still survives in Norway, and several notices of its occur-
rence in that country have been published in recent years. These
notices, however, are more or less limited in their scope, and Prof. K,
Collett, the eminent zoologist of Christiania, has lately done good
service in investigating the whole subject with thoroughness. His
results are published, with twelve beautiful photographs of the
modern beaver-haunts, in the first article of the Bergens Miiseums
Aarbog for 1897.

Trade in beaver skins was carried on in Norway in the Middle
Ages, and the former wide distribution of the animal in the country
is indicated by reference to it in many place-names. Now, how-
ever, its range is much restricted, and unless the laws for its pre-
servation are rigidly enforced it will soon become quite extinct.
It is chiefly confined to the Stifts of Christiania and Christiansand,
and the largest colony is at present located in the middle and
southern parts of the river Nisser (or Nid) in Nedenaes Amt. The
banks of this river are for the most part covered with forests of
Pinus sylvestris, and wherever these are interrupted by trees with
deciduous leaves the beaver is to be found. Its chief food is the
fresh bark of the last-mentioned trees, especially of Populus tremula 'r
and for winter use small branches with the bark on are submerged in
the water in front of the habitations. Bark that has been gnawed
off is not collected for winter provender. Most trees are felled
quite close to the water, and they are rarely brought from a distance
of more than 300 metres.

Immediately after the break-up of the ice in spring, the beaver
commences to search for food, and traces of it are sometimes seen in
the snow. Work on the lodge or habitation is mainly done in the
autumn, and almost exclusively at night. When the animal is seen
in the daytime, it is as a rule only swimming in the water without
any set task on hand.

The trees cut down by the beaver do not fall in any one definite
direction, but lie pointing in every way. The current of the river
is used for transport purposes whenever possible ; but most of the

1897] NOTES AND COMMENTS 301

lodges are situated in still water, and there the animal must itself
convey the logs, holding them between its fore paws, while swim-
ming solely by the hind legs. The construction of a lodge occupies
at least two years, and it is repaired annually. It is usually
elongated in shape, rarely round or conical, and it is always far dis-
tant from its nearest neighbour. Numerous burrows are made in
the bank of the river near the lodge, but rarely in connection with
it. They seem to be inhabited chiefly by young individuals, and
they are the first refuges formed by the beaver at any spot where it
has decided to settle down and build.

As to the inhabitants of a lodge, Prof. Collett thinks that only
one pair with their latest young occupy each. The older litters
•either migrate or occupy the neighbouring burrows.

The Fishes of the North Atlantic

We have also been favoured by Prof. Collett with a copy of his
handsome memoir on the fishes collected by the Prince of Monaco
on his yacht the Hirondellc during the years 1885-1888, which is
one of the most important contributions to Ichthyology of the last
decade* It is published in the sumptuous style with which the gener-
osity of the Prince of Monaco has nowmade us familiar,and the illustra-
tions are among the most exquisite figures of fishes we have yet seen.

The fishes obtained belong to ninety-five species, and are of
great interest not only in their elucidation of the ordinary pelagic
fauna of the North Atlantic, but also in the light they shed upon
the geographical and bathymetrical distribution of a certain number
of remarkable forms obtained from depths of no less than 2000
metres. Only six new species are determined, and only one new
generic name is proposed, namely, Halosauropsis for Halosaurus mac-
rochir of Giinther — an emendation also made some time ago by Goode
and Bean, who, however, proposed to term the genus Aldrovandia.

The classification of Giinther is mainly adopted in this memoir,
and the new specimens of the more important species are carefully
described in detail. The value of the work is also greatly enhanced
by the copious references to the literature of the subject, and the
comparison of the results with those of previous authors. It would
tend much towards the progress of systematic zoology if this
laborious method were more generally followed by the authors of
such reports. When recording new facts, it adds much to the toil
of the work to incorporate them and correlate them precisely with
existing knowledge ; but the additional labour is well spent, and it
converts dry catalogues, comprehensible only to a few narrow

* Poissons provenant des Campagnes du Yacht V Hirondclle (1885-1888). By
Robert Collott. 4 to, pp. viii., 198, pi. vi. (Resultats des Campagnes Scientifiques
aecomplies sur son Yacht, par Albert ler-> Prince Souverain de Monaco, fasc. x., 1896.)

302 NATURAL SCIENCE [November

specialists, into readable narratives which any zoologist can
appreciate.

The Study of Botany

At the meeting of the London County Council on October 12, the
following resolution was adopted : — " That it be referred to the Parks
Committee and to the Technical Education Board, to consider and report
as to the practicability of laying out plots of ground in certain parks
in such manner as will afford assistance to scholars of elementary and
secondary schools in the study of practical botany." We hope the
Committee and Board concerned will report favourably and that
some of the resources of the London parks will be turned to account
in the interest of the humble student of botany. If we consider
only those who sit each year for the examination of the Science and
Art Department, there must be a large number of students scattered
through the metropolis, to whom the suggested arrangement would
be very welcome. Examiners tell us that answers to the questions
show knowledge derived mainly or entirely from books, and insist
on the necessity of more thorough practical work. But the London
student has not much opportunity for such. The Botanical De-
partment of the British Museum in Cromwell Eoad, by means of
carefully dried specimens, models and illustrations, supplies an
excellent systematic review of the plant-world, and by skilfully
prepared fruits and seeds, and wax models remarkable for their life-
like accuracy and beauty, associated with clearly written labels and
explanatory sketches, demonstrates to all who come to see such
matters as the structure and mode of operation of insect-eating
plants, or the means of distribution of fruits and seeds. But there
is still much which can only be learnt from the living plant. We
believe that Kew and the Eoyal Botanic Society's Gardens
are the only ones to which the student can get access ; the former
by right (after 12 o'clock), the latter by courtesy only of the
Council at certain times on certain days. The latter are
useful for those living in a certain part of North London, while
a journey to Kew means the underground railway or a happy
day on the South - Western. And after all, life is short, and
there are often other subjects which must be studied in addition
to Botany. With even very little alteration or additional expense
a park, such, for instance, as Battersea Park, might be made
very helpful to an elementary student. There is a sheltered path
by the lake where, in the summer, tree-ferns and cycads flourish,
and in the same sub-tropical garden grow palm trees, most of them
quite large enough to show a characteristic habit. But if we re-
member aright, many have no labels at all, and labels when present
are very inadequate. A bare binomial name conveys little informa-
tion ; the addition of the group or order to which the plant belongs,

1897] NOTES AND COMMENTS 30

•>

and the country of which it is a native will help to crystallise
certain ideas about that group or order which have been vaguely
floating in the student's mind. A considerable sum of money must
be spent every year in providing the chrysanthemum shows which
are to be found in many of the parks each autumn. Some of the
chrysanthemums are beautiful, others very ugly ; but we are of
opinion that the money would be better spent in keeping a variety
of plants which need the shelter of a house all the year round.
Such as, for instance, a few temperate orchids, examples of in-
sectivorous plants and the like, which the ordinary student knows
only from pictures. The resolution now before the County Council
has reference probably to laying out beds to illustrate some of the
more important families. This might be done at very little expense,
and under proper management would be a great boon to the would-
be botanist.

Botany of the Azores

The Eighth Annual Report of the Missouri Botanical Garden, issued
by Prof. Trelease, the director, has just reached us. It is prepared
in the same clear and elaborate style as its predecessors, and gives
an exhaustive account of the work, educational as well as horti-
cultural, achieved during the year. Excellent reproductions of
photographs taken in the gardens are again an interesting feature.
One gives us an idea of the destruction caused by the memorable
tornado of May 27, 1896, which worked such havoc in St Louis.
Though the grounds were not actually traversed by the cyclonic
funnel, the violence of the wind was such that a number of the
structures were either unroofed or totally wrecked, while some
450 trees, often of large size, where wholly or practically destroyed,
and many of those left standing were seriously broken. Six
days before the tornado " the most destructive hailstorm that has
ever been experienced at the garden," also caused great damage.
The scientific papers which occupy the greater part of the volume
are extra-American in interest, and embody the results of some
work by the director in the Azores. Mr J. Cardot supplies an
account of the mosses found on the nine islands. These (excluding
bog-mosses, of which there are eight) number eighty, fifty of which
occur also in Madeira and the Canaries, sixty-one in Europe,
especially the Mediterranean region, and in Algeria, and about forty
in North America. One found in Elores has been known hitherto
only from Madagascar and equally distant relationships are shown
in the distribution of the genus Sciaromium, which has three
species in the Azores, while nearly all its other representatives
are to be found in New Zealand and temperate South America.
Seven species are described for the first time. The fact that several
of the most important islands do not as yet muster together more

304 NATURAL SCIENCE [November

than fourteen species indicates that there is still much to be done
before a satisfactory knowledge of the bryology of the islands is at-
tained, and Mr Cardot believes that the number (eighty) could
easily be doubled. The fungi are practically unstudied, and many
species should be found in the moist wooded regions. The list of
marine algae, " though unquestionably small, may doubtless be in-
creased considerably by collections prosecuted through the entire
year, while there is reason to expect a very large number of diatoms
and desmids, as well as many representatives of other groups of
fresh-water algae, whenever careful collections shall have been
made." As regards flowering plants and ferns, though the list
is probably nearly complete, there is still scope for much interest-
ins work, such as a detailed local flora for the islands, with an
analysis of the influences which favour the extended distribution of
one species while restricting another to a very limited area. For
such an enterprise the catalogue which Prof. Trelease appends to
his botanical observations would form a useful basis. Most of the
species, it is suggested, " may have been introduced by ordinary
means, largely through human agency, since the discovery of the
islands, for they are so precisely comparable with similarly named
species from other parts of the world as to suggest the lapse of a
very short time since their separation from the parent stock." Only
a few are peculiar. Some of the latter are limited to one or other or
several of the islands ; but the native flora has clearly suffered so
much through the inroads of man and domesticated animals, that it
is impossible to say whether or not these local limitations have
always existed. The greater number of the flowering plants are
either wind-fertilised or adapted for pollination by but little-
specialised insects, having as a rule open flowers, with readily
accessible nectar or pollen. As regards relation between plants
and animals, Prof. Trelease remarks that, as there are only seven
species of wild mammals found in the islands, and nine endemic or
commonly concerned with plant-dissemination elsewhere, and few
birds capable of aiding in this work, except for aquatics or marsh
plants, " it is scarcely to be expected that special dissemination
adaptations would be found on the part of aboriginal plants, which
presumably have been associated with these animals for a relatively
short time, nor of recently introduced plants, unless the relations
have been established and the modifications worked out before
either plant or animal reached the Azores." "Well developed burrs,
for instance, are found only on recent introductions, and the great
majority of species " either have no special modification adapting
them to certain dissemination, but depend upon gravitation, the
wind, or hygroscopic movements of their seed vessels, or else their
adaptations are out of harmony with their surroundings."

575.1 305

The Fundamental Principles of Heredity

( Concl uded from p. 239)

rr^HE power of propagation of animals by small fragments is pos-
-L sessed very largely by Sponges, some Coelenterates, Starfishes
and certain Flat worms ; it is practically lost in the higher groups for
several reasons, considerations of nutrition being most important.
An Animal fragment can only obtain the nutritive matter for form-
ing new cells by eating up, as it were, part of itself, until it has
formed new organs for the prehension and digestion of food. To do
this, the fragment must be always big enough to render this sacri-
fice possible ; and, moreover, the tissue-cells must not be too special-
ised to adapt themselves to the altered conditions. Thus, the
complex tissues of a human arm, accustomed to be served by a con-
stant supply of blood current bearing in an abundance of food and
oxygen and carrying off all waste materials, and to the guidance of
a highly developed nervous system, can never adapt themselves to a
life of isolation. In this respect Animals contrast markedly with
Plants.

To study in the way we have applied to Animals the laws of
reproduction and propagation in Plants, we must revert to those
Protists whose life is essentially vegetal. These possess a coloured
portion of protoplasm (green, yellow, or red), in which, under the
stimulus of light, inorganic materials are combined to form the
organic food on which (like animals) they feed. As these inorganic
materials exist in solution, they can soak into the cell, which needs
neither mouth nor stomach ; and the cell can exist, grow, and
multiply by division at the limit of growth, even while invested
with a thin coating of the papery material, cellulose. If the cell
start as a cylinder or ovoid, and the divisions are always in the
same direction, at right angles to its length, the product (a colony of
our first type) is an elongated filament, like those which form the
green, slimy scum on our way-side ditches ; if the divisions take place
in two planes, the colony will form a plate or disk ; if in three, a solid
mass which is much more rare. When a period of increased vital
activity ensues, brood-formation sets in ; the brood- cells are at first
naked, lacking the cellulose wall, and usually provided wiih swim-
ming lashes. The brood-cells may in one and the same species1

1 The filamentous Alga Ulothrix zonata.
Y

806

NATURAL SCIENCE

[November

have very different fates. They may (1) settle down within the
wall of the parent cell, and grow out into filaments, which finally
rupture the parent cell-wall by their elongation ; or (2) they may
escape, and only after swimming about for a short time settle down
to grow into filaments ; or (3) they may pair first of all, and then

/Sfoo?-e

mx>&& ft,Zcxrme.7i£s

f N \? \r

ZjulcLq

(jtxxis

dcccZa

cm Cfccmecz?-

f\ Si- ~

A X 3crmxz£c,TnG<? fcrr?7x&

the coupled-cell, after a rest, makes a fresh start of life and growth
and multiplication within the cell-wall. The life-cycle may be very
complex. We may even find states in which the cell- walls of the
filament gelatinise, and the cells themselves round off, the colony
forming a very irregular mass.

1897] FUNDAMENTAL PRINCIPLES OF HEREDITY 307

In some forms that are in other respects very primitive, we tind
a true differentiation that has advanced further than Protospowjia,
the lowest animal type we have selected as an illustration. Volvox
globator is a beautiful green sphere the size of a small pin's head,
found actively rolling over and over, as its name implies, in still
waters fully exposed to the light. On microscopic examination it
is seen to consist of many hundreds or even thousands of green cells
imbedded in the surface of a spherical mass of gelatinous cellulose,
and sending their active lashes into the water. Scattered among
these are a few larger cells, which may be seen in all stages of
segmentation ; and as these grow and segment, they protrude into
the cavity of the sphere, and filially rupture it and become free as
new individuals. The ruptured sphere sinks to the bottom, and the
colonial cells at its surface soon die, whether from the unfavourable
conditions or no it is impossible to say. At the time for pairing it is
only the few large cells that become or give birth to pairing-cells ; the
resulting coupled-cell segments to form a new colony. Here again
we have a well-marked sterilisation of tissue-cells, and their characters
are transmitted only through the reproductive cells, their collaterals.
Prom our standpoint Volvox must rank as a lowly Metaphyte.

The majority of Metaphytes show a much higher differentiation
and a power of colonial propagation far greater and more continu-
ously exercised than in any Animals.

The first that we shall consider are the Scale and Leaf-mosses.
As is well known, the little capsule or urn is full of a fine dust con-
sisting of reproductive brood cells or ' spores.' These germinate and
grow, as in Protophytes, into filaments consisting of elongated cells,
some of which are green and run on the surface of the ground, while
others penetrate it and serve as roots. But so little specialised are
they that the reversal of a minute sod containing them will deter-
mine a change of their relative character and functions. On branches of
these other cells are formed, which are short and thick. These divide,
and by their colonial growth the proper leafy moss-plant is formed,
but only the lower part for the time being assumes the condition of
the moss tissues, the uppermost cells being colourless, nourished by
the green cells of the stem and leaves, and assuming and retaining
the functions of an embryonic tissue. This constitutes the ' growing
point' characteristic of all the higher plants.

Ultimately, in the deeper parts of certain outgrowths, near the
growing point, are formed reproductive-cells which give rise to
pairing-cells, male or female, as the case may be. Fertilisation is
internal, the male cell swimming up to the immovable female, and
fusing with it in situ. The coupled-cell remains imbedded in
the Moss-plant, and is nourished thereby as a parasite, and,
undergoing segmentation, is converted into a colonial mass. The

308

NATURAL SCIENCE

[November

outer layer of this colony in the most primitive Scale-mosses
is converted into a capsular wall, while the inner cells are re-
productive cells, each of which forms a brood of four spores. In
the Leaf-mosses the colonial body formed by the segmentation of the
coupled-cell is much more modified, with increase of specialisation

Jyem--scaZe

sSfro

ve.ce. fa <*ice <fe.?^> ■ is.es

jzgssSstSsizfk ^ssssss

rc/brocAxctivs. cclis

■ A

own. r<?o&s.}

yeqeCiz.&£trG Zc&szi&o

t 'cye&r <3£t/e fCast&es

7VybroclJcAc£ive. ceCCs

1/cccCs

6tjcc£&

CvuZ^;

s/joreji

and corresponding sterilisation ; for its lower part is converted into
a bristle-like stalk, and the wall and centre of the urn-shaped
capsule are both composed of green tissue adapted for the formation
of organic food materials.

Before we group these facts into a table we must notice the

1897] FUNDAMENTAL PRINCIPLES OF HEREDITY 309

extraordinary powers of propagation of the Moss-plant : if cut up
into fragments, almost any green cell, whether of the Moss-plant or
the young urn, is capable of growing out into a green filament that
will produce new leafy plants ; and this is in addition to the propa-
gative power by ordinary branching or budding of the embryonic
tissues at the growing point. We will, according to custom, begin
our table with the coupled-cell.

It will be seen here that there is no necessary colonial death (as
in Volvox) of the leafy Moss-plant, though the older tissues of the
stem and the leaves usually die down after the maturation of the
parasitic capsule, and that the power of propagation possessed under
certain circumstances by the green cells of the Moss-plant and urn
make them possible direct ancestors of reproductive cells.

Still, in what we may regard as the normal cycle, the repro-
ductive cells produce among their offspring collaterals as well as
direct ancestral forms. The character of the cycle is noteworthy ;
two systems of colonial growth each beginning with a single cell
are determined or closed by the production of brood mother-cells;
and these systems contrast both in the characters of the colony and
in the nature of the brood-cells. The colonial outcome of the spores
is the filamentous growth and the leafy Moss-plant, and the brood-
cells formed therefrom are the sexual pairing-cells; the colonial
outcome of the coupled-cell is the capsule, and its brood-cells are
the asexual spores. This is then an ' alternation of generations ' in
the sense of colonial or habitual terminology. Botanists have termed
the contrasting colonial plants ' Sexual ' and ' Asexual,' Gametophyte
and Sporophyte, respectively from the character of the brood-cells
which each produces in turn.

In the ascending scale of the Vegetable Kingdom we first meet in
the Moss-plant with those tissue-cells which we term 'embryonic' ;
these must be defined as colonial cells nourished by the adult part
of the colony, and having for their sole function growth or con-
tinued division at the limit of growth to form new cells and organs.
Such cells are obviously not at all ' primitive,' as they are fre-
quently called, but on the contrary are the essential outcome of
high colonial differentiation. That the whole colony may exist in
this condition in the early stages of development is only rendered
possible in the ease of the Moss-urn by its receiving nourishment as
a parasite from the leafy plant.

The Fern is only comparable with the Moss by a complete
detachment from preconceived ideas. Most readers know that
the Fern sheds from the brown ridges or spots on the under side
of its leaves a fine dust, whose particles are the spores. Each
spore in germinating produces a cellular filament, which soon
expands into a green plate, the equivalent of the leafy Moss-

310 NATURAL SCIENCE [November

plant, or, better, the ' plant ' of the Scale-moss or Liverwort, to
which it bears a close resemblance. On this are borne sexual
organs which produce sexual cells. The coupled-cell, as in the Moss,
is at first parasitic on the scale, and develops into a Fern ' plant,'
such as we know it with stem, roots, and leaves, and finally spores.
The essential difference here is that in the Mosses the spore-forming
plant is entirely parasitic and of limited growth, while in the Fern it
becomes independent, and is of unlimited growth, being provided
with organs of support and conduction as well as of nutrition. We
may well say that the sterilisation (to use Bower's term) of part of
the colony has led to so extended a power of colonial growth and
branching, that the power of forming reproductive cells is in the end
enormously increased. The propagative capacities of Ferns by buds
from embryonic tissue are very great ; those of fragments of the
spore-bearing plant are slight ; but the sex-bearing scale may be
artificially propagated by being cut into small pieces, although its life
is usually limited by the formation of the parasitic Fern-plant from
the coupled-cell.

Ferns then show the same alternation between spore-bearing and
sex-bearing generations as Mosses, but the order of relative con-
spicuousness and abundance of colonial growth is inverted. We
have seen that in Mosses a vegetative transition by cell growth
might take place from the spore-bearing generation to the other.
In Ferns similar transitions are possible both ways, so as to cut out
the stage of brood cell formation, which we regard as the critical
reproductive stage.1 Thus in many Film-ferns, instead of producing
spores, the leaves grow out into scale-plates bearing sexual organs,
while in the common Cretan fern, the scale produced from the
spore grows out directly into the spore-bearing leafy Fern-plant
instead of giving rise to sexual cells. In flowering plants the
relations of the sex-bearing plant are much obscured, and it
would lead us too far to explain them here. Suffice it to say
that the 'plant' as we know it corresponds to the Fern-plant
or moss-capsule : it is the Sporophyte, not the Gametophyte. The
parasitism of the embryo formed from the coupled-cell is usually
intense and prolonged.

A very remarkable character of Dicotyledons or Exogens is the
continuation downwards from the growing point of a zone of em-
bryonic tissue, the 'cambium,' which habitually by its growth and
multiplication forms zones of wood on the inner side, and inner-bark
(or bast) on the outer. This layer has, in cuttings, an especial tendency
to form buds. But all the living cells retain a power of forming a
similar tissue at or near an exposed surface ; for instance, such a
layer is formed a little within the surface of trees to produce the

1 These transitions have been aptly termed "short circuitings " by Sir Edward Fry.

1397] FUNDAMENTAL PRINCIPLES OF HEREDITY 3 1 1

cork, — this is known as the cork-cambium. We are all of us
familiar with the little brown scars on plums, &c, that have been
slightly injured when green : these are due to the local development
of a layer of embryonic tissue below the injured surface, and the
formation of a thin protective layer of cork therefrom.

Colonial propagation in Flowering Plants may take place by the
separation of buds (which form normally at the growing point), or
by development of so-called adventitious buds from the embryonic
cambium zone of the stem or roots. Such propagation by minute
fragments as occurs in Mosses is unknown here ; but larger frag-
ments of leaves can frequently produce buds and ultimately plants.
The cells within the cut surfaces produce an embryonic tissue, which
gives rise both to a protective skin of cork and to adventitious buds.

The readiness to form cork and adventitious buds in this way
varies extremely, and with this the power of leaf propagation. For the
formation of cork is an indispensable protection against the opposite
dangers of drying up on the one hand, and of the attacks of microbes
and moulds on the other. Again most Begonias are readily propagated
by pieces of leaf ; but the bulbous varieties form a mass of embryonic
tissue, well protected by cork, which remains for months or years
before active buds are developed, so that they were long thought in-
capable of this mode of reproduction. Not only Begonias, but Gloxinias
and other members of the showy order Gesneriaceae, the Peperomias
with their massive speckled or veined foliage, and Chrysanthemums,
are habitually multiplied in this way ; and the list of possibilities in
this direction is daily increasing.

On reviewing these facts we see that the law of collateral trans-
mission applies to Plants as well as to Animals, but that they have
much greater powers of colonial propagation, by the formation of
embryonic tissue from already specialised colonial cells, and by the
persistence of a portion of the colony (the growing point, and in
Exogens the cambium layers) in the embryonic state. The fact that
green cells can manufacture plant food in the light explains the
greater vitality and propagative power of small Vegetable fragments
as compared with those of Animals ; and it is needless to assume
any more recondite intrinsic differences. Even in this mode of
propagation, the law of collateral transmission holds ; for many of
the cell-forms of plants, such as hairs, wood-cells, &c, are abso-
lutely sterile, and consequently can never take part in the formation
of an embryonic tissue capable of giving rise to a new plant.

Thus, throughout the Higher Kingdoms we find the problem of
heredity rests on different data to those supplied by the Protista.
In these lowly forms, where the law of direct transmission prevails,
it is easy to admit that when a cell resolves itself into two new ones
which exactly reproduce its original state, they should each possess

312 NATURAL SCIENCE [November

its original qualities ; even where the transmission is alternate, we
may admit that the different conditions at the different stages of a
genetic cycle modify the organisms produced. In the simplest case
of collateral transmission, as presented by Volvox globator, the steril-
ised colonial cells so closely resemble more primitive independent
forms in their behaviour and character, that we may well believe
that they have inherited these from such forms, directly and un-
altered, from some Protist ancestor, while the reproductive cells have
become modified. But it is impossible to suggest such an explana-
tion for the higher Animals and Plants, since a nerve-cell with its
outgrowths many feet long, or a woody fibre which has expended all
its living protoplasm in the building up of a firm wall, can only have
been evolved as portions of a highly-specialised colonial organism.

The difficulty of explaining the mechanism of collateral trans-
mission in Metazoa and Metaphytes by the direct transmission in
Protista has been the origin of the recent lively discussions on
heredity. To biologists saturated with the implicit conviction that
only direct cellular transmission was alone possible, some mysterious
agency, that should be contained in the reproductive cells, and be
handed down by them in their direct cellular descent, was an
essential assumption ; and this agency is supplied by Weismann in
his Germ-Plasm Theory. The reader will do well to bear in mind
that it has been presented to the world in successive editions ; each
has been greeted as final by the disciples, who have made light of
the objections raised thereto, though on every occasion such objec-
tions induced the Master to recast the theory in his next work.
Our presentment of the theory upheld in the " Germ Plasm ; A
Theory of Heredity," published in London in 1893, may therefore,
for aught anyone can tell, become obsolete very shortly, owing to
the author's " having (to use his own phrase) in the meantime gained
a deeper insight."

Weismann conceives that in the nucleus of what we have
termed ' reproductive ' (and also, in part, ' embryonic ') cells is a
mixed plasm, the ' germ-plasm,' composed of certain entities, the
' determinants ' for the several organs of the colony ; that when the
cell divides at the limit of growth into two similar cells, the germ-
plasm and the several determinants divide in the same way, so that
the determinants are the same in each of the daughter-cells as they
were in the parent. But in those divisions which give rise to
specialised cells the germ-plasm divides as a whole, in such a way
that the determinants are only distributed between the daughter-
cells, some to one, some to another : we may say that there is
distribution or repartition, not the true division of the several
determinants. Similarly, the determinants each contain a group of
minor entities the biophors, and in the ultimate divisions of the cells

1897] FUNDAMENTAL PRINCIPLES OF HEREDITY 313

of an organ these biophors are distributed between the cells ; and
the proper biophors in each cell constrain it to play its specific part
in the organism.

Those cells which constitute the direct line of descent between the
reproductive cells of one generation and those of another are formed
by true divisions of the germ-plasm, with all its determinants. But
we are met by the facts of propagation by fragments composed only
of tissue-cells in Animal, and still more in Plants, where specialised
tissue-cells revert to an embryonic condition, or rather beget
embryonic cells with a complete germ-plasm. To explain this diffi-
culty, we must suppose that in these cases a portion of complete
germ-plasm has passed at their formation into such tissue-cells, and
that it has remained dormant until the stimulus of separation from
the colonial organism has revived its vitality. Again in the four-
celled stage of the segmented embryo of various widely distinct
Animals (even in the sixteen-celled stage of some Medusae) it is
possible to isolate a single cell, which then develops into a complete
embryo, though had it remained associated with its fellows it would
have formed only a definite part of the embryo. Here again we find
the assumption of the existence of dormant determinants, which be-
come active only in the separated cell, adduced by Weismann to save
the theory. This assumption is also used to explain alternation of
generations, where the Moss-plant and Moss-urn, or the Fern-scale
and Fern-plant alternate ; their germ-plasm must contain two sets of
determinants, one for the first, the other for the second- generation,
alternating in sleep and waking like the printer and the hatter in
Box and Cox. We are reminded of the complex epicycles required
to render the universe workable on Ptolemy's geocentric hypothesis,
and the Spanish king's comment thereon. " Had I been consulted
at the creation, I could have simplified matters."

So far indeed, this might be held as a formal or fictive hypo-
thesis to explain the mechanism of heredity on the basis of Special
Creation — each organism being created fully equipped with its
own proper germ-plasm, determinants, biophors, and all. But no ;
Weismann is a firm believer in the theory of common descent, and,
as we have seen, he and his school profess to be the only true
Darwinians ; and we come to his Theory of Variations.1

The germ-plasm with its contained determinants, as it lies
in the reproductive cells of the body, is subject to nutritive
changes, and consequently to constant slight variations which
apparently are not correlated with anything else whatever. The
haphazard variations, of the determinants induce corresponding, and

1 This essay was written nearly two years ago. Since then Weismann has enlarged
his theory by the hypothesis of germinal selection. Without going into this we may
note that it makes no difference to the present argument.

314 NATURAL SCIENCE [November

therefore haphazard, variations of the organism ; and the Almighty
Natural Selection now steps in, weeds out the unfittest, and so
induces the endless variety of form and function in the Organic
Eealm. This has been irreverently termed the 'toss-up' or 'dice-box'
theory of variation. It is hard to see how variations in feeding or
starving hypothetical determinants can have ever ended in the
development of a vertebrate eye, or in the exquisitely co-operating
organs that render possible the parasitism of the offspring on the
viviparous mother : it would be difficult if we had limitless aeons of
biological time at our disposal, instead of the paltry million of
centuries conceded as an outside limit by Lord Kelvin, even when
multiplied by 4000, as Perry and Poulton suggest. We have all
heard of the German astronomer who was reading Lucretius, and
said to himself as noontide approached, " So if the atoms had been
flying about for all time, cold potato, oil, vinegar, garlic, and salt
might have combined to form a salad." " Yes, dear," said his wife,
who had come in unperceived to call him to dinner, " but not as
good as you shall have with your beef."

It must be admitted that marvellous ingenuity is shown in giving
explanations on this theory to cases where they are not needed ; we
may cite the limitations of propagation by small fragments of
Animals or Plants, and the variations in the power of leaf propaga-
tion in the latter, which are so readily explicable without the germ-
plasm hypothesis. On this hypothesis, however, we are asked to
overlook the plain and obvious questions of nutrition, cork-formation,
and bud-formation, and to concentrate our ideas on the presence of
more or less dormant germ-plasm in the tissue-cells. We may well
note here that among " Inductive Fallacies " Bain cites the error of
assigning more causes than a phenomenon needs. " It is involved
in the very idea of cause that the effect is in exact accordance with
the cause ; hence the proof that more causes were operative than the
effect needs defeats itself." l

But the cardinal defect in the theory is its objective base-
lessness. It professes to be founded on the microscopic study
of the changes in the nucleus in cell-division ; but there we
find nothing to justify the assumption of two modes of nuclear
division in the embryo, the one dividing the determinants, and
the other only distributing them between the daughter-cells. To
justify such a theory there should at least be some such basis in
fact, as indeed there is for the author's ' id ' theory of the relations
of ' amphigonic ' inheritance (from two parents),'2 which does not

1 "Logic," by Alexander Bain. Part II., Induction, ed. 2, 1873, y>. 395.

2 To avoid complication and the undue lengthening of this essay we have been
obliged to omit the consideration of the effect of double parentage in the higher
organisms that reproduce sexually. lint it is obvious that of itself it must tend to efface
and not to accentuate the variations from the average standard of the race.

1897] FUNDAMENTAL PRINCIPLES OF HEREDITY 315

come within the purview of the present article. As it is, the
theory falls under the ever-trenchant blade of Occam's razor,
" Entia non sunt multiplicanda praeter necessitatem."

The antagonistic school, of Herbert Spencer, regard Living Beings
as characterised by their continuous adjustment of internal relations
to external conditions, and cannot see a priori grounds for regarding
the reproductive cells as especially lacking in this power of
adaptation. They regard instinct as only explicable as habit
transmitted and relatively fixed by constant transmission from one
generation to the next, and are disinclined to admit (even as a formal
hypothesis) any scheme that leaves all such considerations on one
side. They therefore are compelled to refer variations in the offspring
to the adaptive reaction of the parent to the environment, and hold
that there must be some mechanism of transmission other than
that of direct cellular inheritance, by which the reproductive
cells hand clown to their differentiated cell-offspring the characters
of the corresponding cells in the parent organism as a whole.

Charles Darwin felt this need so keenly (in a way largely ignored
by those who style themselves his only true disciples) that he for-
mulated his elaborate provisional hypothesis of Pangenesis to supply
the mechanism that he postulated. He supposed that every cell in
the body gave forth minute buds or ' gemmules ' which circulated in
the blood, and were carried by its current to the reproductive cells
where they were stored up, and that in the development of the embryo
they induced the formation of cells like those from which they were
given off. Galton tried the crucial experiment of transfusing blood
from one breed of rabbits to another, and found that this had no
effect on the purity of the offspring. This not only shattered the
theory of Pangenesis, but settled in the negative every conceivable
theory of hereditary transmission based on the conveyance of formed
material particles or of chemical substances from the other parts
of the colonial organism to the reproductive cells.1

The second theory is that of Herbert Spencer, of 'biological units,'
of definite form and relation, which by their polarity tend to complete
the organism. I shall describe that development of it recently put
forward with great skill and ingenuity by Wilhelm Haacke under
the title of the " Gemmaria theory." 2 He holds that all living
plasma is composed of minute units, the ' gemmae,' grouped
together in aggregates, the ' gemmaria,' both being of definite form
and size, in virtue of which they tend to assume certain relations of

^'Life and Habit," Loud. 1878; and "Unconscious Memory" (Lond., 1890).
The latter work contains a translation of Hering's paper. " A Theory of Development
and Heredity," by Henry B. Orr (London and New York, 1893), is written essentially
from this point of view.

2 See "Gestaltung und Vererbung," Leipzig, 1893, and "Schopfung der Tierwelt."
Both these works arc written in a German style of exceptional charm, ease, and
vivacity.

316 NATURAL SCIENCE [November

equilibrium in the cells and in the whole organism. Owing to this
being a labile equilibrium, any disturbance due to an altered
condition of the environment will alter the ' set ' of the
gemmaria and change the conditions of their equilibrium. It is
as the result of their relation to the organism at large that
the gemmaria of the reproductive cells E of an organism A are
compelled to reproduce the likeness of A ; consequently when the
continuance of altered surroundings alters A to A', the gemmaria of
the reproductive cells will get a ' set ' changing them to E', which
will reproduce the altered organism A'. Now, as a formal hypo-
thesis, this serves to give a very pretty provisional explanation of
many phenomena of organic life ; but we have no sufficient micro-
scopic evidence in its favour, and, to me at least, much that speaks
against it. We know too little of the physical relations of cell-
life to be able to accept, even provisionally, a theory based mainly
on geometrical and mechanical conceptions.

The most satisfactory explanation, perhaps, is that put forward by
Hering and Samuel Butler,1 the latter of whom has written with
singular freshness and an ingenuity which compensates for the
author's avowed lack of biological knowledge. This theory has
indeed a tentative character, and lacks symmetrical complete-
ness, but is the more welcome as not aiming at the impossible.
A whole series of phenomena in organic beings are correlated
under the term of memory, conscious and unconscious,
patent and latent. Our memory is conscious, when we say a
lesson or remember a birthday ; unconscious, when we let our
fingers play of themselves a piece of music of which we could
not write down a note ; patent, when we remember to call at a
friend's house ; latent, during the interval while the servant is
waiting at the open door, until the sight of the familiar stick in
the hall recalls the owner's name which would not recur to our con-
sciousness. Of the order of unconscious memory, latent till the
arrival of the appropriate stimulus, is all the co-operative growth
and work of the organism, including its development from the repro-
ductive cells. Concerning the modus operandi we know nothing :
the phenomenon may be due, as Hering suggests, to molecular
vibrations, which must be at least as distinct from ordinary physical
disturbances as Eontgen's rays are from ordinary light, or it may
be correlated, as we ourselves are inclined to think, with complex
chemical changes in an intricate but orderly succession. For the
present at least the problem of heredity can only be elucidated by
the light of mental and not material processes.

Qceen's College, Cork. MARCUS HarTOG.

1 " On Memory as a Universal Function of Organised Matter" (Vienna, 1870, ex.
S. Butler in " Unconscious Memory," p. 97).

575.8 317

Reproductive Divergence : A Factor in Evolution ?

IN the September number of Natural Science (p. 181) Mr H. M.
Vernon propounds a new theory, called Reproductive Divergence,
which, he says, is essentially different from Romanes' Physiological
Selection. Inasmuch as both Reproductive Divergence and Physio-
logical Selection are a process, not a cause, are based on the occur-
rence of the same kind of variation among the individuals of a
species, and have the same end in view, the differences between the
two principles do not appear to me to be of great importance ; the
premise of Reproductive Divergence is, however, more general, and
the way in which the principle is demonstrated is certainly inde-
pendent. Reproductive Divergence (like Physiological Selection) is
brought forward to show that under certain propositions given
differences between the individuals of a species inhabiting the same
locality and presumed to stand under the same external influences
will develop into specific differences solely by means of Reproductive
Divergence. What we have to understand by specific- differences
is quite clear in this case : it is that kind of difference which we
find to exist between two morphologically very closely allied forms
which, though existing together in the same locality, are entirely
independent of one another, the two forms (1) breeding true, the
one never producing an individual that belongs to the other, and (2)
never fusing into one form, in spite of their not being mutually
absolutely sterile. In another place x I have referred at some
length to Physiological Selection, and endeavoured to show that this
principle does not hold good in so far as the outcome of Physio-
logical selection, as propounded by Romanes, is, at best, dimorphism,
not specific distinctness ; and I came to the conclusion that forms
deviating from each other in the way just mentioned cannot be
evolved without the aid of some kind of local separation.2 It does
not seem to me that Mr Vernon's arguments in support of Repro-
ductive Divergence as a factor in the evolution of specific distinct-
ness are any more valid than those which were adduced by Romanes
in favour of Physiological Selection. The occurrence of such a

1 " Novitates Zoologicae," 1896, p. 426 if.

2 Local races are now generally termed subspecies ; their high significance, especially
in questions of general Biology, will doubtless be recognised in time also by those
systematists who still persist in ignoring subspecies.

318 NATURAL SCIENCE [November

correlation between morphological characters and fertility of the
specimens of a species as the theory requires cannot be denied. It
is quite conceivable that, for instance, in insects the copulatory
organs of one or the other species vary correlatively with the size of
the individuals in a similar way as the horns on the head and
thorax of Dynastid beetles, or the mandibles of stag-beetles do ;
such a variation in the copulatory organs of the males and a cor-
responding variation in the females would necessarily have the
result, that copulation between specimens of different size could be
less easily effected, and would be less effective than copulation
between individuals of the same size. Hence the premise of the
theory, or ' the first part,' which ' can only be verified by experi-
ment,' must readily be accepted, and would be admissible even if
there were as yet no facts observed which proved that the required
variation actually occurs. Mr Vernon promises (p. 185) to make
further experiments in this direction, for which biologists will surely
be very thankful.

The second part of the theory, or the statement, that, if the
above premise is given, a species will necessarily develop into two
or more varieties or even fresh species, is ' demonstrated mathemati-
cally.' Let us examine this mathematical demonstration. Mr
Vernon divides the 1800 specimens of a hypothetical species, which
is assumed to vary in size from 64 to 73 inches, into three sets of
males and females, of 300 specimens each, the sets being designated
as S, M, and L, and s, m, and 1 respectively ; then, if it is further
assumed, that on an average of the 300 S, 100 S will copulate
with s, another 100 with m, and the third 100 with 1, and so also
in the case of M and L, the total number of offspring will be — the
total number of individuals is accepted to be constant in each
generation —

I. 100 Ss, 200 Sm, 300 Mm, 200 Ml, 100 LI.

If now " the comparative fertility of the various sized individuals is
slightly changed," so that for instance 100 specimens copulating
with individuals of the same size will give birth to 120 offspring,
100 specimens copulating with individuals of slightly different size
will produce 95 offspring, and 100 individuals copulating with
specimens of considerably different size will give birth to 80 off-
spring of either sex, the total number of offspring will be distributed
as follows : —

II. 120 Ss, 190 Sm, 280 Mm, 190 Ml, 120 LI.

By a comparison of II. with I. Mr Vernon comes to the two conclu-
sions (a) that the limits of variation, which originally were 64 and
73, will be altered to 02*5 and 74"5 ; and (b) that the individuals

1897] REPRODUCTIVE DIVERGENCE 319

of intermediate size will, in succeeding generations, decrease in
number, while the individuals of small and large size will increase.

To show that inference (a) is correct, Mr Vernon argues as
follows: — (1) Variety S varied originally from G4 to G7 inches, the
mean being 65*5, and L from 70 to 73, the mean being 7l'o ; (2)
let us then suppose that by the principle of Reproductive Divergence
the average of S were reduced to 64, [the specimens varying now
from 6 2 "5 to 65*5], and that of L increased to 73, [the individuals
varying from 71*5 to 74-5] ; (3) then " it follows that these groups S
and L would (approximately) contain individuals varying between
62'5 to 65*5 inches, and 7l'o to 74*5 inches respectively." But
surely this inference (3) is merely a re-statement of assumption (2) !

And as to the conclusion (b) that the intermediate individuals
will disappear, it has apparently escaped Mr Vernon that the figures
given under II. are nothing else but a re-statement of the proposition
that 100 pairs of equal size give birth to 120 offspring (etc.) ; the
result of the chance-breeding is quite different. We must divide
the original 900 individuals into five sets, and then compare these
five sets with the five sets of II., thus : —

I. 180, 180, ISO, 180, 180 = 900.
II. 120, 190, 280, 190, 120 = 900.

It is not for me to point out under which new conditions the range
of variation would be widened and the species be split up into
varieties. Under those propositions upon which Mr Vernon bases
his mathematical demonstration, the mean of S will not decrease, and
that of L will not increase, but the smallest and largest specimens
will very soon disappear altogether, and the species become mono-
morphic, as a mathematical consideration of the chance-breeding in
succeeding generations will show. If we start with 300 S, 300 M,
and 300 L, the number of small, medium-sized, and large individuals
in the first generation of offspring will depend on the size of the
offspring of each pair; the offspring of a pair may be the same in
size as the parents, or may be smaller or larger. It is sufficient to
consider two of the infinite possibilities. (1) The 300 S produce on
an average equal numbers of small, medium-sized, and large offspring,
and so do the 300 M and 300 L. The result will be that the
numbers of different-sized individuals will not be altered in suc-
ceeding generations, and the variation of the species will also remain
the same. This is the usual result of chance-breeding, if no special
factors come into play. (2) The 100 S which copulate with 100 s
will produce 100 small specimens Ss, no medium-sized and large
ones ; the same applying as to M and L. This is what Mr Vernon
assumes to take place. Though this assumption cannot be allowed to
stand, as what is here assumed to be true is one of the characteristics

320 NATURAL SCIENCE [November

of specific distinctness which the principle of Eeproductive Divergence
is propounded to explain, we will accept, for the sake of argument,
that parents of the same size breed true. Then of the 120 Ss of the
first generation 24 will copulate with small females and 24 each
with the other four sets ; hence there will be produced only 2 9 Ss.
These 2 9 will have to copulate with nine sets, and so on. The same
applies to LI. Or to put it generally, if A is the number of indi-
viduals of each original set, a the number of original sets, x the sur-
plus fertility, n the number of generations, then under the proposi-
tions adduced by Mr Vernon,

n _ f]Q0 + x\H A

bs " V 100 ;■

a ((a-l)2+l).((a-l)3 + l)...^(a-lf+lN)

In our case the numbers of S in the succeeding generations will,
therefore, be— T. = 120 ; II. = 29 ; III. = 4 ; IV. = 0, 3.

That is to say, after the fourth generation, the largest and
smallest specimens will be weeded out, and this result will not
materially be altered, even if we assume that the largest and
smallest individuals are mutually absolutely sterile. (Compare also
Galton's regression towards the mean.)

Although Eeproductive Divergence does not achieve what Mr
Vernon claims for it, it is not altogether to be rejected under other
premises than those accepted by Mr Vernon. There are certain
species, for instance among Lepidoptera, which vary in the same
locality in such a way, that there are two well-marked varieties
which breed freely with one another, but produce comparatively few
intergraduate specimens, the offspring belonging mostly to the one
or to the other variety.1 Here Reproductive Divergence may
eventually have free play, and then necessarily will evolve incipient
dimorphism into complete dimorphism, and in so far Eeproductive
Divergence might be called a factor in evolution.

Karl Jordan.

Zoological Museum, Tring.

1 Standfuss, " Handbueh f. Schnietterlingssammler," 1895. — See also Giard, Natural
Science I. p. 388 (1892) ; Romanes, ibid. p. 398.

550.1 321

III

A New Scheme of Geological Arrangement and

Nomenclature

Pakt I

THE only scientific men whom Charon will carry across the Styx
without a fee will probably be those who conform to orthodox
shibboleths. For the rest, including most of the editors of and
contributors to Natural Science, I mean the purveyors of audacious
heresy, a heavy charge will no doubt be made. Meanwhile we
ought to have our turn in this world and if we shock those who
sit on velvet and dislike to have the picturesque dust of their
cherished prejudices disturbed, they will remember that they will
have their comfort when the Conservative old boatman leaves the
flagrantly and impudently wicked in the mud.

In venturing to ventilate a fresh heresy I thought it needed
such a preface.

The systematic arrangement of the various beds which compose
the Earth's crust began, as is well known, with the Italian writers
of the seventeenth century. It was Lehmann, however, who first
really proposed a rational arrangement by separating the crystalline
unstratified rocks, which he called Primitive, from the beds arranged
in successive strata, which he called Secondary.

This classification with modifications including notably the
introduction of a third class of beds called Transition, and answer-
ing largely to our present Cambrian and Siberian strata, continued
in vogue until the beginning of the present century, and it was,
in fact, the only possible arrangement so long as petrographical
considerations were alone considered of importance in discriminating
between different rocks, for it was early and easily seen that beds
of very different chemical composition might graduate horizontally
into each other, being therefore probably on the same horizon,
while in other cases beds of the same chemical composition
were clearly situated at different horizons.

The key to the problem which finally unlocked the geological
riddle was the discovery, not made at one bound, but first applied
systematically by William Smith, namely, that different geological
horizons are marked by different species of fossil remains. This
prime discovery has, of course, enabled us to map out the long

322 NATURAL SCIENCE [November

series of stratified rocks in a continuous chain and to unerringly
distinguish any particular horizon in discussion by its particular
ear mark, namely, the special fauna and flora whose debris are
found in it.

This I need not say is the corner stone of modern strati-
graphical geology, and this, so far as we can see it, will remain.
I have nothing to say about the key which is an absolutely in-
dispensable one. What I propose to criticise, however, is the
arrangement founded upon the facts thus ascertained, and I
propose to attack it in two ways and on two grounds. If our
object is to ascertain the past sequence of events in any particular
spot on the earth's surface, we cannot do better than make a boring
at the particular spot and describe in detail the successive beds
lying upon one another or which we can fairly conclude once lay
upon one another in that particular spot. This will undoubtedly,
so far as that spot is concerned, give us the sequence of events.
If the record be complete it will, of course, be a complete story.
If some pages be torn out of the book it will, of course, be in-
complete. This we may or we may not be able to infer. What
is clear is that the column of different strata thus pierced represents
not a general universal geological pedigree, but the geological
pedigree of one particular spot only. This, of course, is universally
admitted. No fact is more elementary than that two wells dug
in the same parish may present us with very different columns
of strata. Some thin out, some grow thicker, some disappear,
and some make their appearance. The one cardinal fact, however,
remains, that so long as we remain in the same " Zoological
Province " so long will these beds when found together be found
arranged in the same order.

This being sj3 it is perfectly justifiable and perfectly logical so
long as we remain in the same zoological province to collect all the
beds occurring within that province and to arrange them in
sequence, and having done so to make that sequence a test and
touchstone by which the relative position of any particular bed in
any particular section may be ascertained ; always remembering,
however, that we do not mean by this arrangement that the
sequence of events in every spot within this area was precisely the
same. In some cases certain stages were possibly absent as the
record seems to infer, or a particular stage in one area may have
become a complicated series in another. These are, however,
mutters of detail in which we have no necessity to guard ourselves
since they are obvious and simple. What it is important to
remember, and what has been made the subject of adverse comment
by more than one distinguished palaeontologist, is the fact that the
arrangement we have been considering only holds good and is alone

1897] NEW SCHEME OF GEOLOGICAL ARRANGEMENT 323

useful when applied within one zoological province, and becomes
utterly misleading when applied to any other. Let me explain
what I mean. Zoologists have divided the land surfaces of the
earth into several provinces marked by special faunas. Of these
divisions that proposed by Mr Sclater long ago, and which was
founded mainly on the distribution of birds, is the most popular.
Each one of these provinces is marked by a special animal and
vegetable facies. Similar provinces with a similar variation in
their inhabitants occur also beneath the sea. Now it is clear that
each of these life provinces has a special pedigree of its own. It
may be that they all converge eventually upon some common and
universal original, but the various lines of descent must have been
separate from early geological times. How then is it possible or is
it profitable to attempt to measure and test in any way whatever
the geological record of one zoological province by that of another ?
We may eventually be able to say what was the character of the
different zoological provinces contemporary with different geological
horizons in our own country, but this kind of knowledge will profit
us little. What we want to know is the pedigree of each zoological
province by itself, and to keep that pedigree intact and separate and
unsophisticated by any false correlations with the pedigrees of other
provinces. When I am asked if a particular bed in India is
Miocene or Pliocene, or a particular bed in New Zealand is Tertiary
or Quaternary, etc., etc., I cannot attach any useful meaning to the
question. If it mean that the bed is actually contemporary with,
or that it is homotaxial with the beds so-called in Europe, the
question is desperately hard to answer and of very little use when
answered. If it means that a particular bed is the penultimate or
the ante-penultimate geological stage in each area irrespective of
actual equating of periods and dates, it may convey some meaning
but it is a meaning crossed and sophisticated with danger and with
doubt. What we want to do if we are to do justice to the great
fact of the continuity of life, is to keep the two stories entirely
apart, and to do so if possible by using a nomenclature which shall
not be misleading.

If then we are to retain the present geological nomenclature and
arrangement for the beds of the pan- Arctic or hoi-Arctic region where
a common fauna now prevails, we" ought to apply an entirely
different nomenclature to the arrangement of the beds in the
Neotropical, the South American, the Indo-African, the Australian,
the Indonesian, and the New Zealand provinces. We may then
indulge in theories and systems of liomotaxis without any danger,
and we shall always be sure that we are measuring the horizon we
are dealing with by a fixed and not by an unstable barometer.
This is the first parable I wish to preach.

324 NATURAL SCIENCE [November

Secondly. In the last sentence I commenced with a very large
" If " because I am afraid my heretical perversity carries me a good
deal further than I have yet dared to admit.

Before Herbert Spencer held up his great lamp and bade us see
in animal and vegetable life not a discrete collection of disintegrated
units but a continuous unbroken chain, it was prudent and wise
perhaps to be content with an arrangement of the stratified beds
marked by no other law or rule than their mere order of super-
position in any particular place. This will no longer content us.
We want to know a great deal more than this. We want to know
what was the route and road by which a particular fauna and flora
came to occupy a particular zoological or botanical province,
and what were the stages of its growth and development. For
this supreme purpose we must go further afield than merely
examine the column of strata existing in any particular place. A
very cursory examination at once shows us that in every such
column marine beds are intercalated with sub-aerial beds, and no
ingenuity can possibly derive the fauna of the land from that of
the sea and vice versd by successive jumps and starts. They have
absolutely nothing to do with each other, and if our purpose is not
merely to calendar the revolutions of land and sea which have
occurred in a particular place, but to trace out the history of the
particular fauna occupying a particular province, either of the land
or of the sea, and thus to track the continuous history of each of
these divergent portions of the earth's surface along lines of con-
tinuity and growth, we must absolutely discard our present method
of geological arrangement and nomenclature for a very different one.
In the first place (and the change is so obvious that it has always
seemed to me a paradox that it was not made long ago) we must
absolutely separate the marine beds from the sub-aerial ones, put
them into two entirely different columns and perhaps give them
entirely different names. To apply the term Pliocene to the marine
beds marked by the Norwich or the Weybourn Crag and to apply it
also to the sub-aerial beds known as the Forest bed, is not an illumin-
ating but a darkening process. These two sets of beds may have
been contemporary but they have no other element in common, and
it is utterly misleading to give them a common name because the
marine and land debris are sometimes mixed as in the Norwich
Crag just as Ammonites and Mammoths both may be mixed with
striated boulders in the soft beds on the coast of Holderness. If we
are to retain our present geological nomenclature for the pan-arctic
region we must qualify each name by a distinctive epithet showing
whether the bed we mean is in the marine or the sub-aerial series.

Again, we continually read in geological books of unconform-
ability, an excellent term expressing a very patent fact when we

1897] NEW SCHEME OF GEOLOGICAL ARRANGEMENT 325

are dealing with what 1 would call parochial geology, but a term
which ought to have no place in a general scheme in which the
progressive history of a life province is to he illustrated. If there
is a hiatus and a gap here, it must be in the evidence and not in the
actual story. It is the imperfection of the geological record and not
the occurrence of a real unconformabilitv in two successive stages
of the history of a life-province which is the infirmity of our
inquiry, and we disguise and distort the picture utterly by painting
it as we do.

The ideal arrangement of our beds ought to correspond with their
history in time as marked, not by their accidental sequence in any
particular spot, but by the successive phases of their life contents.
The land surface of the Palaearctic zoological province of to-day
must have been in geographical contact and continuity with a corre-
sponding land surface yesterday, and so on to the beginning of time.

A succession of land bridges must have connected the present
land surfaces with those of the primitive world by a perfectly un-
broken chain, unless we postulate the complete periodic destruction
of land faunas and their re-creation ; and similarly with the marine
faunas. This being so, unconformability and break ought to entirely
disappear from our series. If we find signs that a marine sub-
mergence intervened between two stages of sub-aerial history of
some locality and caused a breach between them, we must, neverthe-
less, conclude that these two stages were connected geographically
at some point or points by a third one affording us the intermediate
chapter, and it is along these bridges that we ought distinctly to
travel. This seems to me to open up an entirely different mode of
arranging and studying our beds to that usually current in text-
books, one more consonant with modern zoological and palaeontologi-
cal notions.

Our first step, as I have said, is to entirely separate the sub-
marine and the sub-aerial beds from one another, and to range them
in two series. Secondly, to arrange the beds, not according to their
vertical distribution in one or more spots, but according to their con-
tinuity in regard to conditions of deposition. This will lead us along
some unexpected and some not infertile lines of inquiry. Once we
grasp this notion we shall cease to attach much, if any, value to the
accepted generic terms of stratigraphical geology — the primary,
secondary, tertiary beds, etc. In our own country, no doubt, the
beds are separated by great gaps, represented fairly by their names,
and if we are studying English geology only, the nomenclature and
classification are justified ; but these gaps cannot have existed every-
where, unless we are to reverse all our modern teaching. The story
of biological development must have been quite continuous, and the
book in which it was recorded must have contained a continuous

326 NATURAL SCIENCE [November

series of pages, imseparated by gaps, dislocations, and unconforma-
bilities, and this in the marine series just as much as in the sub-
aerial series.

There are two initial lessons, then, I wish to press home before
I venture on to more concrete lessons, namely : — 1. That our pre-
sent system of geological arrangement and nomenclature is only
adapted to the purely local sequence of facts and history of the beds
of Western Europe, and not to the whole world. 2. That we
ought to arrange our beds on a universal and ideal system in two
perfectly continuous series, one marine and one sub-aerial, marked
not by their superposition in any one spot, but by the successive
changes in the biological history of the world, and by no other test.

Henry H. Howorth.

571.1 327

IV
The Authenticity of Plateau Man

THE antiquity of man and the locality of his birthplace are
problems of perennial interest, to which Sir John Evans'
address to the British Association has again directed general
attention. Sir John Evan's emphatic dismissal of all the evidence
yet advanced in favour of the existence of man earlier than the date
of the Palaeolithic gravels will no doubt arouse controversy, espe-
cially as in the time at his disposal he could give only a passing
reference to any single case, and not state the grounds of his dis-
trust. As I have during the past year given careful attention to the
asserted ' Eolithic ' implements found in the high plateau gravels
near Sevenoaks, with the result that I have had to abandon my
first belief in their human origin, it may be of interest if I state
the reasons for my change of opinion.

The implements come from the deposits described by my late
friend Sir Joseph Prestwich in an important paper published by the
Geological Society in 1891. The chipped flints themselves were
described by Prestwich in a paper read to the Anthropological
Institute a year later. Further descriptions have been given by
their original discoverer, Mr Benjamin Harrison of Ightham, by
Professor T. Kupert Jones, Mr Lewis Abbott, and other writers.
Some geologists objected to the idea that the plateau flints had been
worked by man at the time of their first description ; but the drift
of expressed opinion has been lately rather in their favour.

Early in 1896 I visited Ightham, and Mr Harrison kindly
showed me the great collection of chipped plateau flints which he
has formed during the past thirty or forty years with an inde-
fatigable perseverance that has excited the admiration of every
student of archaeology. As Mr Harrison's specimens lay side by
side there appeared a remarkable recurrence of the same external
form. This fact led me to accept the conclusion that the specimens
had been shaped by man, but a more searching examination
necessitated the abandonment of this opinion, as the flints them-
selves tell me quite a different story.

Let us first examine the flints and see what traces they show of
the natural agencies that have acted upon them.

The flints occur as a gravel on the surface of the chalk plateau,

328 NATURAL SCIENCE [November

or on the upper part of the escarpment face. That the flints have
been derived from the chalk is unquestioned, and the process by
which they were removed from it need not be considered. During
the first stage of the life history of the independent flints they were
split into slabs or tablets, most of which have one flat side, and one
showing the original external surface. Some of the flint slabs were
flat on both sides, and they are often six or eight inches in length.
The formation of these flint slabs was probably due to extreme cold,
as many of the fractured surfaces resemble those of frost-flakes.
Then a siliceous encrustation was deposited over the flint. The
next process — leaving the chipping of the edges out of considera-
tion for the present — was the staining of the flints to a red or
reddish brown colour. The staining was no doubt due to the action
of ferruginous solutions. The iron may have been derived from
beds of iron sand in which the flints were once embedded, as grains
of dark ferruginous sand are found still adhering to the flints in the
hollows of chipped surfaces. Subsequently to the staining, the
flints were scratched by some glacial agent. The striae are very
abundant, and closely resemble those produced by ordinary glacial
action. They were no doubt caused by the movement of pointed
flints across the flat surfaces of other flints under considerable
pressure. The movement of frozen masses of gravel might produce
these scratches as well as the flow of dirt-laden ice, so that it is
perhaps unnecessary to assume the existence of true glaciers in Kent
on the evidence of these scratched flints alone.

The next change in the flints was the deposition over them of a
thin layer of silex, which covers most of the chipped surfaces, and
often fills up the scratches. The silica occurs in two varieties, one
brown and often very fibrous, and the other white. They may have
been deposited at different dates. The material is a variety of
chalcedony, sometimes having the characteristic botryoidal form of
that mineral.

The nature of this siliceous encrustation is not yet completely
understood, but it must have been deposited by some siliceous
solution similar to that which has often re-cemented shattered flints.
There is, for example, in the Devizes Museum a flint that has
been broken into countless fragments, many of which are as fine as
grains of sand ; but they are all united by a chalcedonic infiltration
into a mass sufficiently solid to bear a high polish. The occurrence
in situ of flints which have been similarly crushed and re-cemented
has been recorded by Englefield and Mantell.

One feature that renders this siliceous encrustation the more
interesting is that it was sometimes deposited later than one set of
glacial scratches and earlier than another set.

The last process which the plateau flints have undergone is a

NATURAL SCIENCE, VOL. XL

Plate IX.

So-called Flint Implements from the Plateau Gravel of Kent.

1897] THE AUTHENTICITY OF PLATEAU MAN :'»29

certain amount of polishing by the action of blown sands. Some-
times the whole surface of the flint has been thus polished, but
specimens often occur in which the action has been limited to one
side. Many of the flints of the Thames gravels, as, for example, at
Clapham, show the same feature. In the cases of these low level
gravels, the polishing was probably effected at a time of drought,
when the pebbles were exposed and the river sand was dry and loose.

We therefore see that these plateau flints have been subjected
to six different processes, all of which are undoubtedly natural, and
each of which has left clearly recognisable traces. Taken in order
of date, the processes are : — 1st, splitting of the original flints into
slabs, probably by frost ; 2nd, a deposition of a siliceous encrusta-
tion ; 3rd, iron staining ; 4th, scratching by some glacial agent ;
5th, deposition of a second siliceous encrustation ; 6th, polishing by
blown sand.

This series forms a chronological table by which we can
determine the relative dates of the various chippings of the flints
which are affirmed to be the work of man. I think it is quite clear
from the evidence of the flints that natural agencies are sufficient to
account for every splinter and scratch that they exhibit.

The first fact that tells against the artificial chipping of the
flints is that the chipping is of very different dates. The process
must have been continued for a considerable length of time. It is
not difficult to distinguish between the chippings of different periods.
The earliest fractures are the largest, as might be expected, since the
conditions were the most rigorous. As the climate became milder
the forces that acted on the flints became feebler, and the chips
removed were therefore smaller. On some specimens it is possible
to detect chippings of three different periods. The first set were
struck off before the flints were coloured red ; the second set broke
acrpss the margins of the first, and sometimes exposed part of the
uncoloured flint below. Then came an interval during which the
glacial scratches were made. These scratches cut across the surfaces
formed by the first two sets of chippings. The fractures of the third
set, on the other hand, are never scratched, but have themselves cut
across the striae. These latest chips were small, and usually more
distinctly conchoidal than the others, and in many instances they
present the appearance of small frost-flakes.

As definite illustrations of the different dates of the chippings,
let us examine in detail four flints which were given to me by Mr
Harrison as fairly good implements (Plate IX.).

The first is shewn in Fig. 1 of the Plate.1 It was found by Mr
Harrison at South Ash, and is numbered 4997. Its size is 6 cm.

1 For the photographs I must express my indebtedness to Mr T. H. Powell of
Denmark Hill.

330 NATURAL SCIENCE [November

long by 5 cm. wide. One surface is flat and smooth, while the
other is convex and rough, as about one-fourth of it is part of the
original surface of the flint. From the convex side two large flakes
have been forced off, probably by frost, and no doubt at about the
same time as the formation of the flat face. Both sides of the flint
are scratched. After the scratching a thin coating of white silica
was deposited over the two large-flaked surfaces, filling up some of
the scratches. And after this a second set of scratches has cut
across the siliceous encrustation.

The history of the chipping of this specimen is as follows : — The
curve at a is the result of natural forces acting on the thin edges of
a natural hollow of the flint : the hollow retains the original surface,
except at the edge, where three or four small chips have been forced
off at a period later than the flaking. The single chip at b has
been forced off from the other side of the flint, and probably dates
from about the same period as the chips of the a series.

The almost straight side of the specimen (c) was formed by
chipping at a much earlier period, before the stone was stained red,
but later than the large frost flakes.

This specimen therefore exhibits surfaces of four distinct dates —

1. The original surface of the flint.

2. The flat side and the two large frost flakes.

3. The chippings on the straight edge before the iron-
staining.

4. The chippings at a and b subsequent to the iron -staining.
No. 4390. A flint from Branshatch (Fig. 2) 14 cm. long by 8 cm.

wide. This specimen has the original rough surface of the flint on
one face and a flat frost-flaked surface ; both have been encrusted
by silex. The specimen is much chipped. The chips have been
forced off by pressure mostly from the flat side, but at the larger end
the chipping was done from both sides, forming a slight irregular
ridge. The significant point about this specimen is that most of the
chipping occurred subsequent to the dark staining of the flint.

No. 2711. A tablet of very dark-red flint from Rogersfield, near
Ightham, measuring 15 cm. by 9*5 cm. This slab of flint was also
chipped before the date of the staining, and also shews chipping by
pressure from opposite sides. The chips are of different dates ; the
first and second sets are scratched, and the third set are insignificant
and irrelevant to the main chipping. The whole surface is encrusted
by silica except where it chipped.

No. Pit VI. A triangular slab of flint (Fig. 3) probably flaked from
a large block by frost. The original surface occurs on the convex side
and extends over a third of the edge marked a. Ancient chippings
from opposite sides occupy the edges d, and some of about the same
date occur along b. These chips were all earlier than the iron-

1897] THE AUTHENTICITY OF PLATEAU MAN 331

staining. The whole of the original surface is scratched, and the
scratches sometimes extend over the edges and also cut across the
surfaces left by the chips previously referred to. A dark brown, in
parts fibrous, incrustation of silex thickly covers the original surface
of this specimen. This was succeeded, after the glacial scratching,
by a deposit of white silex filling up the hollows and scratches ; the
whole has been subsequently smoothed down and polished by blown
sand. This specimen was dug from one of the pits in the Plateau
gravel in 1890".

These four specimens illustrate the main process which the flints
have undergone. They show that the drippings were not all formed
at one period, a fact which it seems to me is quite inconsistent with
the theory that they were artificially shaped by man. The objection
seems especially convincing as, according to the advocates of that
theory, all the shaping must have been done before the flints were
imbedded in the gravel in which they now occur. If the flints were
worked, used, and then thrown down again, we should expect to find
them widely scattered over the surface as is the case with palaeo-
lithic and neolithic implements. What possible agency could have
picked them all off the surface and collected them together into this
gravel bed ? Further, we are told that the shaping and working of
the flints by man " had taken place before the flint entered into the
remarkable deposit which so altered the surface of the stone, and
changed its colour into that characteristic dark-brown." * So accord-
ing to the theory, the flints were first chipped into shape, and then
carried into the plateau gravel. They were coloured subsequently,
and the deposition of the siliceous encrustations, the glacial scratching,
and the sand polishing all took place while the flints were in the
gravel in which they now lie.

Another objection to the human working of these flints is the
uselessness of the shapes into which they have been made. Flints
often break naturally into a triangular form, and as the chipping
has mainly acted on thin edges, abundant examples of pointed forms
are found. Some of these resemble in outline the implements of
later dates, but all the details of the flaking are different. Less
importance is apparently placed on these triangular flints than on
those with concave edges, which are supposed to have been used
as flesh-scrapers. Some of the South Sea Islanders have, it is true,
been observed scraping their limbs with stones ; but we can hardly
suppose that such vast numbers of these concave flints would have
been required by the plateau folk for this purpose, especially as they
would never wear out, and one would last for an indefinite time.

The chipping in some cases has not only been useless, but has
even spoilt stones that might otherwise have been useful. Some of

1 Nat. Set., April 1894, p. 259.

332 NATURAL SCIENCE [November

the specimens with sharp concave edges would have served a
better purpose as scrapers if left as nature had shaped them. The
irregular chippings on the edges of the natural curves has spoilt
them as tools.

The vast number of the ' flint implements ' from the plateau
gravels is another difficulty in the supposition that they have been
made by man. The ' implements ' occur in an abundance described
as ' marvellous ' by their discoverers. We are told that two pits,
dug in 1894 into a bed of gravel one foot in thickness, yielded
thousands of artificial flakes and some hundreds of hollow-notched
and horseshoe-shaped scrapers. The pits dug in 180*6 in the same
beds have yielded a similar profusion. Such results are indeed
startling. Plateau man must have been a very prolific race, for his
implements, almost all of one hollow-scraper type, far outnumber
those of his palaeolithic successors.

In ordinary palaeolithic gravels the proportion of implements to
pebbles is extremely small, and there is no difficulty in drawing a
line between artificially and naturally shaped flints. But on the
chalk plateau the stained flints are all more or less chipped. There
are millions of flints on the plateaux, and it is therefore not sur-
prising that a large number occur in which the shape resembles
that of palaeolithic implements. But no distinctive line can be
drawn between flints which are described as ' good implements '
and others which are admittedly only naturally broken.

But if the chipping be not the work of man, what agency, it
will be asked, could have produced it. Careful examination of the
chipped flints soon suggests suspicious features. In the first place
the chipping is limited to the edges of the slabs ; there are no
known instances in which the flint has been artificiallv flaked into
the form of the weapon ; the asserted human workmanship is limited
to chipping of the edges of naturally-shaped flints.

Mr Harrison maintains that the chips were forced off by an
agent which worked only from one face of the flint slab.1 He
regards this feature as an argument in favour of the artificial nature
of the chipping. Why eolithic man should have worked only on
one surface of the stone is not explained. But. it is really rare to
find an example that was chipped on one side only. Palaeolithic
man certainly never allowed the utility of his tools to be limited by
any such restriction.

The chipping was evidently due to some pressure which acted
more or less at right angles to the flat surface of the flint slab.
The pressure and crushing that take place during movements of
frozen gravel would, it seems to me, be quite sufficient to account
for all the chipping. Pebbles in the gravel would be pressed
1 Proc. Geol. Assoc, November 1893, vol. xiii. p. 162.

1897] THE AUTHENTICITY OF PLATEAU MAN 333

against the upper edges of the flint slabs and force off small flakes.
Then if the flint slab be moved and inverted, renewed pressure
would similarly crush the other edge, and thus account for the cases
in which both edges have been chipped.

A fact which seems to me conclusive proof that the chipping
was due to pressure by some yielding material from above is sup-
plied by hollow flints. The decay of a sponge often leaves a hollow
in the middle of a flint block ; the edges of such hollows in plateau
flints are chipped in precisely the same way as the edges. The arti-
ficial chipping of such edges by blows from another stone would be
difficult, and the work would have been absolutely wasted to eolithic
man. But the forcing of the finer constituents of the gravel across
the hollows under the pressure from overlying material might easily
have produced these crushed and apparently worked edges.

The view that the plateau flints show no sign of human work-
manship I am glad to find supported by the high authority of Sir
John Evans, who, in a letter of April 1896, said: " I see nothing
upon them that is undoubtedly the result of human work or use ;
on the contrary, the rolling and wearing of the edges seem to me
more probably caused by natural agencies — I see nothing but the
hand of nature upon them." After a careful study of specimens
lately selected as the most convincing by Mr Harrison himself, I
am in absolute agreement with this opinion. And as the chipping
of the flints was apparently caused by the action of extreme cold
upon the gravels, movements in which were produced by the action
of ice, I propose for these shaped flints the name of ' Glacioliths.'

Wm. Cunnington.

571.1 334

Evidence of the Antiquity of Man in East London,
Cape Colony ; with a Note on the Castor-Oil
Plant.1

ABOUT the year 1857, in opening up a quarry on the left bank
of the Quigney Biver, at its junction with the Buffalo, a shell
mound was discovered, forming a rounded bluff roughly measuring 150
by 150 by 40 feet deep. The mound was clothed by 18 inches of
made soil, masked by vegetable growth on the surface, and con-
tained abundance of shells of recent mollusca {Patella, Mytilus,
Ostrea, Haliotis, etc.), with bones of fish, birds, antelopes, hippopo-
tami, and other mammalia, layers of ash, fragments of charcoal, and
pieces of coarse pottery. No other implement of any kind was
found, but burnt stones were very common ; most of the deposit was
removed to fill up a lagoon behind the East Training Wall of the
Buffalo Biver.

The locality had remained unaltered since 1827, for in 1867
the writer accompanied the Rev. W. B. Thomson on a visit
there, and heard him say that the spot was quite unchanged. The
same trees and the same track remained, and but for the impedi-
ment caused by the construction of the West Training Wall of the
river Mr Thomson would have undertaken to drive a bullock waggon
along the same track as he had done in 1827. This track, it may
be of interest to mention, ran in a straight line from where Mr A.
Webb's house now stands, to the right bank of the Quigney at its
mouth ; then skirting the mound, it proceeded for one hundred yards
along the Buffalo Biver towards the mouth, and from thence on the
east bank it crossed the river diagonally to the ravine at the large
quarry on the west bank.

So far as is known this kitchen-midden is the most recent trace
of primitive man at East London, and yet must be in itself of vast
antiquity.

Passing to the back of the new jail one sees a small excavation
in the railway cutting, which in 1887 was covered with castor-oil

[l The following personal observations by Mr Geo. R. M'Kay, relative to discoveries of
ancient man in East London, have been forwarded to the editor by Dr Schiinland.
They formed part of a lecture delivered in 1887, and the editor is glad to put them on
record.]

1897] ANTIQUITY OF MAN IN CAPE COLONY 335

plants.1 This was dug out for material to construct the railway
embankment close by, and when undisturbed was clothed with the
ordinary dense bush of the district. The section showed from above
downwards 4 to 5 feet of stiff' clay overlying a foot of rolled gravel,
the gravel resting on decomposed rock. The gravel had all the
appearance of shot of all sizes, from buckshot downwards. A little
above the gravel a large number of Hint implements were found, the
bulk of which appeared to be "rubbers" possibly used for dressing
skins or similar purposes. There were a few spear heads, some
fragments of coarse pottery, and a few limpets.

This excavation is forty feet above the present level of the
Quignev, and the gravel probably belongs to that river; the clay is
assumed to be the accumulated wash from higher levels. The
place appears to have been a workshop, for its position would afford
the warmth of the morning sun with the coolness of shade in the
afternoon.

On the north bank of the Buffalo, about twenty chains from the
river, and just W. of the road to the Pontoon, is the residence of
Mr Gately. The house and grounds stand on the rounded top of
an isolated knoll, which is connected with East London East by a
narrow neck of land. This neck is the watershed of two small
water courses which unite at the S. of the knoll, and run S.W.
into ' 1st creek.' On the top of the knoll there are from 2 to
3 feet of black mud, separated from the base rock by 1 to 2
feet of decomposed rock. The black mud is again seen to the E.
of the road to the Pontoon. In this black mud on the- knoll Mr
Gately has found round pierced stones, stone flakes, spear heads,
coarse pottery, and teeth and bones of hippopotamus. The de-
position of this black mud was contemporaneous with the two water
courses when they were at a level with the top of the knoll.

Fringing the whole of the south-eastern coast of South Africa
there occurs in detached patches a peculiar wind-stratified calcareous
sandstone. Cove Rock and Bats' Cave at East London, the ' bluff '
at Natal, and the Sisters and Fountain rocks near the Fish and
Kowie rivers, are conspicuous examples of the formation. At Cove
Bock and Bats' Cave it abounds in fossils, especially at the latter.
These consist of land and sea shells, mammalian bones, chiefly
ruminants, and teeth of hippopotamus, with remains of fishes,
apparently all of recent species. The rude and shifting nature
of the stratification leaves no doubt that this is an aeolian formation,
and comparable to that of the adjoining sandhills.

1 An idea is prevalent that the castor-oil plant might be profitably grown as a pro-
ducer of a cheap lubricant. My own experience is, that it flourishes only where rivers
have cut deeply into their banks and exposed deeply seated soils, or where deep cuttings
are made, or around the f arth -holes of the porcupine and ant bear. It springs up on
this new soil with amazing rapidity, and crowds out every other plant ; but something
ails it, as after a few years, whether cultivated or not, it dies down and disappears.

336 NATURAL SCIENCE [November

Out of this deposit I have myself taken three well-formed stone
spear heads of the ' Moustier ' type. They were at the level of low
water, and in a position where they must have at one time been
covered by 180 feet of the deposit. One of these is still in my
possession, one is in the Albany Museum, and the third was given
to a friend, who subsequently sent it to Sir John Lubbock. These
aeolian deposits extend, so far as my own observations go, to a dis-
tance of certainly one mile into the ocean from the present shore.
Between Sand Hill and Bats' Cave the low water platform has been
cut back in many places for a width of over 200 yards by wave
action. A visit to Cove Rock on a calm day will verify this if one
stands on the larger of the two masses forming the rock-face on the
south, for there one will see a similar platform, only at a much
lower level, extending as far as the eye can follow it. The sub-
merged reef off Nahoon Point is of this aeolian formation, and the
sea has been observed to break on it upwards of a mile from the
shore, while the Sisters and Fountain Rocks are really small isolated
masses three-quarters of a mile from present low-water line. About
one-third of the distance from the Sand Hill to Bats' Cave there
is an isolated mass of this formation which becomes an island at
high water ; on the land-face of this mass there is a heap of shells
embedded 12 feet above high- water mark. This is about 12 feet
long by 3 feet thick, and contains, besides shells, fish bones and
splintered bones of mammals ; and although there are no traces of
ashes or charred wood, I am satisfied myself as to its artificial
deposition.

The facts concerning the aeolian deposit enumerated above leads
us to the following conclusions. Since the three spear heads were lost
we have to account for a depression of the land and advance of the
shore-line for at least a mile, and from the average inclination of the
bed of the Indian Ocean at this point, that means a land depression
of over 50 feet. Then we have to allow for the gradual emergence
of the land, which has enabled the sea to cut the rock back for a
distance of a mile, up to its present level, which it has maintained
long enough for the sea to cut a platform over 200 yards in width.

Geo. R. M'Kay.

East London, W., South Africa.

581.1 337

VI
The Seed Production of Cut Flowers

IN the second number of the Botanische Zeitung for this year (Jan.
16th 1897, p. 17) Ludwig Jost brings to light a very curious
fact in historical botany. He points out that at the close of 1896
H. Lindemuth has re-discovered a phenomenon, which has already
twice before been described as new.

It is a well-known feature of many bulbous plants that their
flowers are normally sterile, and that their reproduction takes place
exclusively by the vegetative process of bulb formation. More than
three hundred years ago (1577) Konrad Gesner noticed that if the
flower stalks of these plants be separated from the bulb, the flowers
will set their seed. This observation, however, fell into the general
oblivion which overshadowed the whole of Gesner's work. In 1790
— two hundred years later — Medicus re-discovered the fact, and
wrote of it in his paper " Ueber Saamenansezen an abgeschnittenen
Bltithenstengeln einiger Zwiebeln und Knollengewachse " (Romer
and Usteri's Magazin fur die Botan., vol. xi., p. 6.). He was
examining the tubers of Stellar ioides canalicuta (? Anthericwm),
and in doing so cut off the inflorescence, which he stood up in a
corner of the greenhouse for the gardeners to clear away. Returning
to the house a few days later he saw that the flower still remained
where he had left it, and that, moreover, it was still fresh and
unwithered. This interested him, and he determined to see how
long it would last thus " cut off from its bulb and standing in a
dry position exposed to the sun heat."

Stellarioides had been grown and flowered in this greenhouse
during the three previous years without once setting seed. " I was
no little surprised, therefore," he says, " to find that in due course of
time the older flowers of this inflorescence, which had been separated
from its bulb, formed true seed capsules." " This really remarkable
and cp;iite unexpected result," he continues, " led me at once to other
experiments. For twenty years past Amarillis reginae L. had
bloomed in this greenhouse without once setting seed ; as soon as
the flowers drooped, it was seen that their ovaries and all they
contained withered likewise." Medicus next proceeded to cut off
an inflorescence, including three flowers, and to leave this standing
in the greenhouse. After a time all three flowers formed seed

338 NATURAL SCIENCE [November

capsules. The same phenomenon was seen in Amaryllis formosis-
sima.

In discussing these observations Medicus writes : — " Those plants
which have the property of reproducing themselves by roots, especi-
ally marked, are most unfortunate in setting seed, although no
observer can deny the presence or completeness of the sexual organs.
The true cause of this seems to be that these plants expend all their
energy in increasing their roots and concentrate their nutritive
activities on these parts, and so leave none over to contribute to
the formation of seed. Annuals, or plants with a limited existence,
on the contrary, for the most part, set seed, because they have little
or no power of multiplying by their roots, which decay as soon as
the seed is formed, and their allotted span of two to five months
passed." Referring again to the complete sterility of Amaryllis
reginae, under ordinary conditions, he adds that " scarcely, however,
have we separated the inflorescence from its root, and laid it aside
without moisture, than it forms large seed capsules, and clearly
shows us that these would always be produced if the vigorous root
formation did not rob them of all nourishment."

With the exception that we now regard bulbs and tubers as
stem rather than root structures, these words have a very modern
ring about them, and plainly show that what we now call correlation
between the different organs of a plant was already then recognised
by Medicus. One thing is very noticeable about his writings, and
that is the charm of his literary style, an item which by no means
graces too many of the scientific essays and memoirs of the present
day.

Medicus' paper was written in May of 1790, and in the
century which has elapsed since that time both Gesner's original
observation and Medicus' re-discovery have been so completely for-
gotten that in 1896 Lindemuth published an account of the same
phenomena without any idea that it had ever been noticed before.
Thus, as Jost's paper in the Bot. Zeit. points out, we have here a
fact which has three times been discovered as new, after having
been twice completely forgotten. H. Lindemuth {Berichte der
deutsch. Bot. Gesell., pt. 7, vol. 14), after describing precisely similar
facts to those which Medicus had already set down, using, however,
Lachenalia luteola and Lilium candidum as his experimental objects,
proceeds to recount some facts which go beyond those which his
predecessors had seen. These he embodies in a second paper, con-
tained in the same number of the Berichte. On 25 th March he cut
off forty inflorescences of Lachenalia luteola, and placed them in
water. About three weeks later he noticed that the lower part of
the stem which was under water was now curiously granulated.
Here and there a granule had become larger than its neighbours,

1897] THE SEED PRODUCTION OF GUT FLOWERS 339

and was easily recognised as a bulbil. At first these granules are
covered by the green epidermis of the flower-stalk, but as they
gradually increase in size they burst through this as little white
lumps. Microscopic examination shows that these bulbils are
always exogenous in their origin. Inflorescences of hyacinth which
were cut off close to the bulb and placed in water then had their
flowers also removed, so that nothing but the peduncle remained.
When examined nearly two months later, it was found that bulbils
had developed close to the places where the flowers had been situ-
ated. In this case it seems that the food-stuff in the peduncle was
first cut off from the bulb, and so travelled towards the flowers,
but finding its passage blocked here also by the removal of the
blooms, it expends itself in forming bulbils close to their remains.
Finally, Lindemuth ends his paper with practical conclusions for the
culture of bulbous plants drawn from these experimental data.

This brief English note has been written in order to call the
attention of those into whose hands the Bot. Zcit. does not usually
fall to the services which Medicus rendered to plant biology. To
glance through the pages of Professor Sachs' History of Botany, the
only knowledge that we can gain of this older observer is in a few,
scant, depreciating references. Granted that the light of genius did
not lead him into the right path in one section of botany (anatomy)
we still should not allow the memory of an enthusiastic and careful
observer in other departments of the same science to be altogether
forgotten, or, worse still, to be alone remembered for the errors into
which he fell. Most of us, even to-day, are not always in the right,
and this should teach us to " render the deeds of mercy " towards
the memory of others who, living at a less enlightened period, some-
times went astray with their fellows, and did not rise above their
times, but who on other occasions saw things with an " inward light "
which was denied to their contemporaries. It is no doubt the ex-
traordinary work of Professor Sachs himself and his school which has
quite placed in the shadow all older writings upon plajit physiology.

Eudolf Beer.

340 [November

SOME NEW BOOKS

The Flora of North America

Synoptical Flora of North America. Vol. I., Part I., Fascicle II. By Asa Gray,,
continued and edited by Benjamin Lincoln Robinson. Imp. 8vo, pp. ix. to xv.,
207 to 506. New York : American Book Company, June 10, 1897. Price, lis.

Those of our readers who are interested in North American botany
will remember that Dr Gray himself published the portion of this
flora dealing with the Gamopetalous orders of Dicotyledons. The
\wo parts which appeared in 1878 and 188-i were re-issued by the
(Smithsonian Institution in 1886. For some time before his death Dr
Gray was engaged in monographing the earlier orders of the Poly-
petalae, and after his death the work was continued by Dr Sereno
Watson and then by Dr Eobinson. The first fascicle of the present
part was issued in 1895 and contained an account of the orders
beginning with Eanunculaceae and, following the system of Bentham
and Hooker's Genera Plantarum, ending with Frankeniaceae. The
second fascicle now before us carries the work on as far as Polygalaceae.
It has been printed from Dr Gray's manuscript, continued and edited
by Dr Eobinson, with the collaboration of Professors Trelease, Coulter
and Bailey. A third fascicle to include the Leguminosae is in pre-
paration. The work forms a concise but complete and carefully
elaborated account of the flowering plants of North America (north of
Mexico). The descriptions, which are sufficiently full and clear, are
in English ; the synonymy and bibliography of genera and species are
included, and the geographical range of species and varieties is indi-
cated. Identification of the plants is facilitated by the introduction
of generic and specific keys. We congratulate Dr Eobinson and his
colleagues on the portion already done and wish them a speedy and
successful termination of the Flora.

Mollusca

Traitf, de Zoologie publie" sous la direction de Raphael Blanchard. Fasc.
xvi., Mollusques. Par P. Pelseneer. Pp. 187, tigs. 8vo. Paris: Ruetf et Cie.,
1897. •

This, which we understand is one of the first fascicules published of
what promises to be a most important and valuable work, contains, in
addition to the subject announced on the title, a two-page appendix on
Rhodoye. Otherwise it amounts in fact to a second edition of Pelseneer's
" Introduction a l'etude des Mollusques," to which we called attention
on its publication {Natural Science, iv., 1894, pp. 387-388).

It is, however, so much added to and revised, that it almost amounts
to a new work. At the same time, we very greatly regret to see that the
useful bibliographies formerly given at the end of each section have
now been omitted. On the other hand, certain omissions to which we
called attention have been supplied. Chlamydoconcha finds a place,
and some of the more important fossil families are inserted in the
systematic part, which otherwise remains unaltered. A revised phylo-

1897] SOME NEW BOOKS 341

genetic tree is also added. "When Dr Pelseneer comes to study the
gastropoda as systematically as he has done his own favourite bivalves
we are convinced he will abandon the classification of the Prosobran-
chiata that he at present takes from Bouvier {Ann. Sci. Nat., ser. vii.,
vol. iii., 1887), which classification is founded solely on the nervous
system. He will also add some notice of Thyrophorclla.

The principal shortcoming, however, of the work as a whole is, we
think, the scanty reference to the shell, which is after all an important
feature of the mollusca, and in a treatise on zoology merits a place.
In this respect the work is an exception to the generality of such pro-
ductions where the animal is neglected. Curiously enough it is the
Pelecypod shell that is the most curtly dismissed, and this in the light
of Bernard's researches is the more to be regretted.

In the development of Pelecypods, too, we miss all reference to the
second origin of gill filaments, by the splitting up of a previously ex-
isting lamella, as shown to occur in Cyclas and Teredo by Korschelt
and Heider, and again in Scioberetia by Bernard. Likewise our author
appears to have overlooked the fact that the glochidial stage is not
peculiar to the Unionidae, it having been found by Dall to occur in
Philobri/a. Other minor points for criticism are doubtless to be found
by those who care to make diligent search for them, but the work all
the same merits and will attain a high place in the estimation of those
most competent to judge of it, and the praise we ventured to bestow
on the first edition is yet more merited in the present one. It will be
the author's fault if subsequent editions do not carry us far towards an
ideal work on the subject.

It is only fair to add that a word of praise is but due to the
printers and publishers for the excellent way in which they have
carried out their share of the undertaking. The illustrations are, of
course, those of the previous edition, enlivened in some cases by
touches of colour to bring out the salient features they are intended
to illustrate. There are two good indexes at the end of the part.

(BV)2
The Vivarium

The Vivarium, being a Practical Guide to the Construction, Arrangement, and
Management of Vivaria. By Rev. Gregory C. Bateman. 8vo, pp. 424, with
plates. London: L. Upcott Gill, 1897. Price, 7s. 6d.

For very many years Mr Bateman has kept living batrachians and
reptiles as pets, and the beautifully got-up little volume now before
\is embodies the results of his experience. The work, however, is far
more than a practical handbook. The author has added to his own
personal observations several illustrated chapters, in which the more
striking forms of batrachian and reptilian life are described in a
popular manner. He thus appeals to a much wider circle of amateur
naturalists than those who keep vivaria. We can thoroughly re-
commend the book to the general reader who desires a reliable, well-
written, and non-technical account of the much neglected animals of
which it treats. Our only complaint is that the illustrations are of
very unequal merit, in many cases, indeed, far from accurate ; and
this is all the more to be regretted, since most of them are newly
drawn, and might have been made admirable by a little more
supervision of the artist.

342 NATURAL SCIENCE [November

Bibliography

The Theory of National and International Bibliography, with special reference
to the introduction of system in the record of modern literature. By Frank Camp-
bell. 8vo, pp. xvi. and 500. London : Library Bureau, 1896.

The main object of the present work is to demonstrate and enforce
the responsibility of the government of each nation in the matter of
cataloguing the literature published within its boundaries. As the
author points out, it is impossible for any other body to do this work
thoroughly and economically, because no other can bring pressure to
bear upon the publishers. There is also this further reason for urging
upon governments to discharge this obvious duty, that it is just in the
department of State papers that the greatest confusion reigns and the
labours of the bibliographer are most difficult. Witness Mr Camp-
bell's imaginary, but most lifelike, conversation between a librarian
and a reader in some large public library.

This main theme is treated in a series of papers which have for
the most part been read before the Library Association and other
bodies, and published in their journals, and in addition there are
essays upon various collateral topics, such as "the influence and
functions of the learned societies in regard to bibliography " — a
chapter which we wish their councils would all " read, mark, learn
and inwardly digest."

Mr Campbell's book is eminently suggestive, and his schemes if
carried out would reduce confusion to something approaching order.
With the form of his work we are not so satisfied ; the plan he has
adopted of reprinting essays leads to much repetition, and he often
sins against his own ' theories of compilation ; ' but as he explains in
the preface that illness prevented him from carrying out all his inten-
tions, it would be ungenerous to dwell upon these defects, which are
small in comparison with the solid value of the book.

W. E. H.

Flight and Flying Machines

The Aeronautical Annual for 1897. Edited by James Means. 8vo, pp. 178,
pis. xviii. London : W. Wesley & Son, 1897. Price 5s.

The "Aeronautical Annual" for 1897 contains much that is valuable
and interesting, since the contributors are nearly all of them men
who are actively engaged in solving the great problem how flight may
be made possible for men. First among these must be mentioned Mr
Langley, who contributes an account of the experiments which, after
many disappointments, ended in the manufacture of an aerodrome
which actually rose in the air and continued rising and advancing for
about one and a half minutes, after which it alighted rather than fell.
As in the case of Mr Maxim's flying machine, screw-propellers driven
by steam-power were employed. The action of the propellers is to
drive the machine onward : the spreading wings have a slight upward
slope, so that the force is resolved, and there is progress not only
onward but upward. This aerodrome, as compared with Mr Maxim's,
had the great advantage of being light, weighing, in fact, only about

1897] SOME NEW BOOKS 343

25 lbs., so that experiments with it were easier and much less
costly.

Mr Langley has shown, then, that flying machines can be made
which will rise in the air, fly for a short time, and descend without
mishap. But before the problem of flight is solved many difficulties
must be got over, the difficulties of (1) launching without any
elaborate apparatus ; (2) maintaining equilibrium in gusty winds ; (3)
carrying sufficient fuel for long flights ; (4) alighting safely even when
the circumstances are not specially favourable. An oil engine is now
being made to be affixed to the gliding machine. As an aeronaut will
be on board, a distinct advance on Mr Langley's aerodrome, which had
no living pilot, is contemplated.

The article on sailing flight by Mr Chanute reviews the various
theories on the subject judiciously. There is no doubt, as he says,
that in very many cases birds soar by the help of ascending currents
of air. But it is probable that sometimes when there is no such
current available, they nevertheless succeed in rising without a beat of
their wings. Over level ground in Egypt, covered with green crops,
where great heating or unequal heating of the surface seemed out of
the question, so that there was nothing to start an upward current,
the present writer has seen kites soaring with perfect ease.

Mr Chanute thinks that birds can soar by the help of a ' nearly
uniform ' horizontal breeze, but happily he does not, in contempt of
dynamics, hold that an absolutely uniform horizontal breeze can lift
them. He makes some good remarks on the question why some birds
frequently soar, whereas others, and among them very good flyers,
never do. He thinks that soaring depends on the arching of the
wing, and it is quite possible that this may be the case. In the rapid
pulsations of ' rowing ' flight the front margin of the wing does the
main work. In the stately gyrations of the soaring adjutant it is
probable that the ample concavity is of more service. But far more
cross-sections of wings than he gives are wanted before it is possible
to accept this explanation, and in particular small birds should be
well illustrated. It is remarkable that no bird so small as a thrush
ever soars.

The subject of flight does not so often as formerly give rise to
utterly wild theories. The Annual as a whole is remarkably free from
wild writing. But the old tendency shows itself in Mr Huffaker's
theory that a bird in soaring causes a down-current, which in turn
starts an up-current, which supports him as he rises !

F. W. Headley.

Contemporary Psychology

The Psychology of the Emotions. By Th. Ribot. 8vo, pp. xix + 455. London:
Walter Scott (Contemp. Sci. Ser.), 1897. Price, 6s.

The New Psychology. By E. W. Scripture. 8vo, pp. xxiv + 500. London:
Walter Scott (Contemp. Sci. Ser.), 1897. Price, 6s.

These two volumes of the Contemporary Science Series exhibit
Psychology in very different aspects. Prof. Eibot's work on the
emotions is characterised by breadth of view, wide range of know-
ledge, admirable lucidity of presentation, bold and yet critical use of

344 NATURAL SCIENCE [November

hypothesis, and a distinctly genetic motive. The subjects with which
it deals are of necessity vague in outline and indefinite in limitation.
The social and moral feelings, the religious and aesthetic sentiments,
the emotions associated with intellectual endeavour — all these present
us with such a variety of factors, such an interlacement of the threads
of our mental life, so much overlap and so much that is dependent on
individuality of character, that anything like mathematical exactness
or precision of measurement is at present, and is likely long to remain,
impossible.

On the other hand, Dr Scripture's New Psychology is characterised
by limitation of field, a devotion to exactness of measurement, a love
of mathematical and formulated presentment, an impatience of hypo-
thesis, and a refusal to look beyond the formulated facts. The sub-
jects with which it deals are carefully restricted to those which lend
themselves to physical measurement. The new psychology — a re-
markably unsatisfactory and somewhat arrogant title — deals with a
comparatively small area of the field of mental endeavour, and one in
which there is no luxuriant profusion of mental products. But it
endeavours to deal with this small area with an exactness and pre-
cision which is in itself wholly praiseworthy. And if the results
attained by the large expenditure of time, money, and energy in the
well-equipped psychological laboratories across the Atlantic would
seem at present scarcely commensurate with the cost, this will not,
we trust, damp the ardour of enthusiasts like Dr Scripture. Psychology
is a great subject of which we are only just beginning to realise the
importance. There is plenty of scope both for the breadth of treat-
ment we find in Prof. Eibot and for the patient experimentation of
those whose work is described in the New Psychology.

A Blind Guide

Nature -Chat. By Edward A. Martin, F.G.S. 8vo, pp. 141. London:
It. & A. Taylor, 1897. Price, Is.

There are numbers of folk who derive much innocent enjoyment from
natural history, and who have a harmless enthusiasm for ' Nature.'
No one would wish to interfere with their amusement ; but the matter
assumes a different aspect when their trivial observations and inaccu-
rate assertions are obtruded upon the public. This is the case in the
latest addition to the biblia abiblia which are now so freely issued
from the press — " Nature - Chat," by Mr Edward A. Martin. Mr
Martin is a leading light of the Selborne Society ; . he guides the
members in their summer rambles, and lectures to them on winter
evenings. He has written a bibliography of White of Selborne, and
seems to think he follows the methods of ' Gilbert,' as he affection-
ately styles him.

Disraeli said that the critics were men who had failed in literature;
Mr Martin makes it clear that a teacher may be one who has never
succeeded in learning. He has brought together in this volume a
number of paragraphs, many of which, we believe, have appeared in
a local magazine or newspaper ; others are "parts of letters addressed
to friends," who must, we think, be somewhat bored by the honour of
Mr Martin's correspondence. We look in vain for a single addition
to knowledge in this collection of trivialities.

1897] SOME NEW BOOKS 345

The following paragraph may be quoted as exemplifying at once
Mr Martin's scientific attainments and his literary style : —

" To be thoroughly acquainted with the beautiful grasses of Great
Britain is to possess a knowledge of which I am ambitious. As I
was collecting grasses on my walk, I pulled some concerning which
I was at a loss to know whether they were of identical species, or
whether they were distinct. Almost as the thought passed through
my mind, my eyes lighted upon a grass of which the lower half of the
blossom was fully expanded. This showed the features of one speci-
men, whilst the upper part, which evidently was yet to expand, showed
the features of the other. Thus Nature answered her own problem
which she had put to me." (P. 34)

We are tempted to ask why Mr Martin has not acquired the
" knowledge of which [he is] ambitious " ? The number of common
British grasses is not large ; every manual contains their description.
But it is only too clear that Mr Martin has not even a slight acquaint-
ance with grasses, for he talks of ' the blossom ' when he means the
inflorescence, just as he speaks of a ' specimen ' when he means a
species. And what was the plant after all ? He tells us that "Nature
answered her own problem," but does not give us her reply. We
feel inclined to imitate Nature in " putting a problem " to Mr Martin
— What useful purpose can be served by printing paragraphs of this
kind?

Mr Martin made the strikingly original observation that the flowers
of the everlasting pea turn blue when fading. He then "watched the
creeper closely, with the result that it has borne blossoms which were
blue in the first place." This curious consequence of Mr Martin's
vigilance leads him to say — " the seeds it will be well to collect " :
but he was counting his chickens too soon, for on p. 77 we read : " In
a former letter I referred to the blue blossoms of the everlasting pea
which had appeared in my garden. Neither of them have been suc-
ceeded by the usual pods of seeds, so that I shall not have the satis-
faction of rearing seedlings from them, as I had anticipated." Can Mr
Martin suppose that this kind of thing adds to our knowledge ?

But the author rises to higher flights than these. " You know,"
he says, " the yucca, which is said [inaccurately, but this Mr Martin
does not know] to flower but once in a hundred years. Then comes
such a burst of brilliance that it requires a period equal to that which
allows our orb to roll its ponderous body along its tremendous path
around the sun, a hundred times or thereabouts, in order to recover
its flowering energy. What an act of self-denial is this : what an act
of self-immolation, in order that its duty may be fulfilled ! " The only
parallel to this reflection is one which occurred some years since in
the catalogue of a picture exhibition in South London — " Scene in
Ceylon : Elephants bathing. How much the elephants in the Zoo
have given up for our sakes ! "

The book is full of inanities and ineptitudes, and the literary style
is in harmony with the subjects discussed. If a fly tumbles into the
milk-jug, Mr Martin speaks of its ' unwelcome last sad bath.' Dead
nettles are ' magnificent ' and ' gorgeous.' Certain flowers smell like ' a
glass of sherry ' ; two plants in the same paragraph ' rejoice in ' their
names. The author speaks of his ' legal brother,' as if he had another

346 NATURAL SCIENCE [November

brother who was not legal, though we think he only means to say that
the gentleman in question is a solicitor. And what are we to make of
the following sentence : — " We are so matter-of-fact in our science —
too matter-of-fact — to thoroughly appreciate the science which has
become science, become what is known (scio, I know) by the labours
of the great men of the past, who alone, perhaps, when discovering,
were able fully to realise the poetry of their own discoveries." It is
perhaps our own fault, but we are unable ' to thoroughly appreciate '
either Mr Martin's facts or his style.

JJohn Hunter

John Hunter : Man of Science and Surgeon (1728-1793). By Stephen Paget. With
Introduction by Sir James Paget. 8vo, pp. 272. London : T. Fisher Unwin,
1897. Price, 3s. 6d.

Mr Stephen Paget's small volume on John Hunter inaugurates a
new series, entitled " Masters of Medicine," edited by Dr Ernest Hart,
and published by Mr Fisher Unwin. It is not a technical work
appealing merely to the medical profession ; it is a well-written and
highly entertaining account of one of the greatest students of biology
in the last century, full of interest to the general scientific reader.
The volume does not contain much new matter ; but Mr Paget has
spared no pains to go to the original sources for information, and he
has made good use of the letters and records preserved in the Eoyal
College of Surgeons, London.

John Hunter, as a great pioneer in biology, is perhaps too much
neglected by the present generation. His infusion of purely scientific
methods into the profession of surgery led to results of such moment
that his labours in other directions are apt to be overshadowed and
forgotten. Those, however, who are familiar with such of his biologi-
cal and geological writings as were recovered and edited by Sir
Eichard Owen in 1861, can estimate the old surgeon at his true worth ;
and it is of no little importance that his memory should be kept green
in the minds of those who are now following in his footsteps. Mr
Paget's delightful chapters can scarcely fail in this purpose, and we
urge all who have not yet realised the extent and bearing of John
Hunter's researches and the influence of his personality, to read the
new biography at once. His favourite maxim was — " Don't think,
try ; be patient, be accurate." The story of his life will be found
inspiriting by any plodding student.

Pengelly

A Memoir of William Pengelly, of Torquay, F.R.S., Geologist, with a Selection
from his Correspondeuce. Edited by his daughter, Hester Pengelly. With a Sum-
mary of his Scientific Work, by the Rev. Professor Bonney. 8vo, pp. x. 341,
portrait and 10 illustrations. London : John Murray, 1897. Price, 18s.

Not only the numerous personal friends of William Pengelly but also
all who are interested in the progress of our knowledge of the anti-
quity of man and allied subjects, will be glad to learn that Miss Hester
Pengelly has published an account of her father's life. The hand-
some volume of over 300 pages which we have just received, contains

1897] SOME NEW BOOKS 347

an ample selection from his correspondence arranged in chronological
order, with paragraphs welding them into a connected story ; and this
is followed by an interesting chapter by Professor Bonney on the
general character and value of his scientific work.

Pengelly's genial personality was so widely known and beloved,
not only by men of science but by many devoted to other intellectual
pursuits, that his biography will find no lack of enthusiastic readers.
The story of his early life as a Cornish sailor ; of his career as
a schoolmaster at Torquay ; of his growing fame as a geologist,
his discoveries of fossil fish- remains in the Devonian rocks of Corn-
wall, and so forth ; of his share in the exploration of Brixham
cavern in I8f>8 ; and finally, of his great work in arranging and per-
sonally superintending the excavation of Kent's cavern — all this is
told in an entertaining manner in his letters. The various little
incidents in his career are recalled as we read, and those who knew
the man himself will recognise his characteristic traits and modes of
expression. We have only one criticism to offer, namely, that far too
much of the correspondence is printed. A considerable proportion of
it is very trivial and ephemeral, of no interest to anyone except his
immediate family, for whose private view alone it was intended.
Some other letters, we think, are inserted with rather questionable
taste, as, for example, one in reference to a candidate's touting for the
fellowship of the Eoyal Society on p. 282. Biographers ought to
distinguish between strictly personal matters and those bearing upon
the progress of a life's work. The latter alone are worthy of being
preserved in a memorial volume.

Professor Bonney's summary of Pengelly's researches, occupying
only thirty pages, is an admirable contribution. It is both concise
and clear, and written in a style readily comprehensible to the general
reader. The first section deals with the geologist's first serious under-
taking, the investigation of the Tertiary deposits of Bovey Tracey ;
the next part is concerned with the examination of the caverns, in
association with which the name of Pengelly will be longest remem-
bered ; and the third or final part includes a number of miscellaneous
geological studies of the south-western district of England. We will
not attempt to analyse this chapter ; it must be read in its entirety
to be appreciated.

Miss Pengelly's biography appropriately concludes with a list of
her father's writings, more than 100 in number, and it is prefaced by
a very successful copy of A. S. Cope's portrait of Pengelly, which was
painted in 1882.

The Vertebrate Skeleton

The Vertebrate Skeleton. By Sidney H. Reynolds, M.A. 8vo, pp. xvi. 559,
with 110 illustrations. Cambridge : University Press, 1897. Price, 12s. 6d.

The latest volume of the Cambridge Natural Science Manuals
(Biological Series) is a useful small compendium of osteology by Mr
S. H. Reynolds, Lecturer and Demonstrator in Geology and Zoology
at University College, Bristol. For the most part the work is a
laborious compilation, which sometimes rather detracts from its
interest and value ; but the actual descriptions of certain typical

348 NATURAL SCIENCE

[November

skeletons are based upon personal observation and research, while the
clear diagrammatic illustrations are nearly all refreshingly new, many
of them taken from the beautiful preparations in the central hall of
the British Museum (Natural History), others from specimens in the
Cambridge University Museum of Zoology.

The plan adopted by the author is to give first an account of the
general skeletal characters of the group of which he is treating, with
the characters of its several sub-divisions ; secondly, to describe in
detail the skeleton of one or more selected types ; and thirdly, to treat
the skeleton as developed in the group in question, organ by organ.
The account of each type skeleton is made complete in itself, so that
the elementary student can, if he wishes, use the book merely as
a laboratory guide to the few leading forms of skeleton to which he
ordinarily confines his attention.

The author is, of course, a teacher, and he presumably knows the
requirements of his students ; but we are inclined to think that the
handbook he has produced is far from well-arranged for practical
purposes. The information is admirable, usually up-to-date, and not
often faulty — though a work of such wide scope must necessarily have
its imperfections ; but there are endless repetitions as we turn over the
pages, the facts concerning a single structure or phenomenon are some-
times inconveniently scattered, and there is a lack of some fundamental
idea to unite the various parts of the work into one harmonious whole.
The facts of embryology may sometimes be of doubtful import, and
our present knowledge of palaeontology may encourage many fanciful
notions and speculations. But if both these aids to formulating a
scheme be rejected, there is still the good old-fashioned method of
Comparative Anatomy, which (in our opinion, at least) is more useful
for teaching purposes than the disconnected mode of treatment in the
handbook before us. We have noted similar want of coherence in
Cambridge biological teaching before. Since the days of Francis
Maitland Balfour, the philosophy of the subject seems to have become
gradually neglected, while the dry facts have been more and more
constantly presented in unattractive array. Mr Eeynolds is likely to
have the opportunity of revising his manual in a new edition very
soon — for it fills a decided gap, and will be helpful to many who have
hitherto been compelled to turn to numerous and varied abstruse
treatises for guidance. We would therefore urge him to consider
these important points, and render his work more worthy of the great
labour he must have bestowed upon it.

Two New Editions

Lessons in Elementary Biology. By T. Jeffrey Parker. Third edition. 8vo, pp.
xxm. 503, with 127 illustrations. London: Macmillan & Co., 1897. Price,
10s. 6d. '

Elements of the Comparative Anatomy of Vertebrates. Adapted from the
German of Dr Robert Wiedersheim. By W. N. Parker. Second edition, founded
on the third German edition. 8vo, pp. xvi. 488, with 333 illustrations. London :
-Macmillan & Co., 1897. Price, 12s. 6d. net.

These two text-books by the brothers Parker are too well known and
widely appreciated to need any recommendation here. It suffices to
record the publication of a new and revised edition of each of them.

1897] SOME NEW BOOKS 349

Prof. Jeffrey Parker's "Elementary Biology,' in its new form,
differs from the preceding editions in the increased attention devoted
to the higher animals and plants. The general chapter on the higher
animals has been expanded into four beautifully-illustrated chapters,
dealing respectively with an outline - classification, the starfish, the
crayfish, the fresh-water mussel, and the dogfish. The additional
botanical matter refers in the same style to Equisetum, Salvinia,
Sclaginella, the Gymnosperms, and the Angiosperms. These supple-
mentary sections will indeed, as the author himself remarks, contri-
bute much to the usefulness of the book.

Prof. Newton Parker's second English edition of " Wiedersheim "
may almost be described as a new book. The original descriptions
and arrangement are retained as far as possible, and most of the old
figures are reproduced, although a few have been replaced and others
added. Prof. Wiedersheim has also revised the whole. But to bring
the work up to date, and at the same time not increase the size of the
volume, it has been necessary to abridge much of it and recast other
portions ; while the useful bibliography in the appendix has been
considerably expanded to increase its usefulness to advanced students.
We only notice one serious blemish, namely, the unreliable character
of some of the references to the skeleton in extinct animals. The
figures of the pelvic arch of Plesiosaurus on p. 115 are quite errone-
ous, and might easily have been replaced. " Ldbyrinthodon rueti-
mcyeri " is certainly not a labyrinthodont. The wing-finger in the
Pterodactyles is not the fourth but the fifth digit. Before the next
edition we would suggest that this section of the work be submitted
to someone skilled in vertebrate palaeontology for revision.

Sceaps from Serials

Me Adrien Dollftjs has paid considerable attention to the terrestrial
Isopoda, the wood-lice of the world, and has published a paper in the
October number of La Feuille des Jewries Naturalistes showing the wide
range of some of these little animals. Considering the mode of life of
these Isopoda, it is not at all surprising to find certain species have a
wide distribution, but it is interesting to have this distribution put on
record. 'The species dealt with are Armadillo murinus, Brandt ;
Armadillidium vulgare, Latr. ; Porcellio scaber, Latr. ; P. laevis, Latr. ;
M ' etoponorthus pruinosus, Brandt; Ligia exotica, Roux. Of these five
the Metoponorthus has the widest range, being recorded for America
(N. to S.), Azores, etc., the whole of Europe, Africa (N. to S.), Asia
(E. to W.), and Australia (N. Caledonia and Marianna Islands) ; Por-
cellio laevis is the next most widely distributed, having much the same
range as the Metoponorthus, but found also in the Bermudas, Mel-
bourne, and various islands of Oceania, and restricted to the N. of
Africa. A sketch map accompanies the paper, which has an additional
value in that it mentions the collections in which the particular
specimens recorded are to be found.

The American Journal of Psychology, vol. viii. No. 3, contains a
' Study of Apperception,' based on experimental work on the reading
of words by Dr Pillsbury. Typewritten words photographed on lantern
slides were projected on a ground-glass screen, and exposed for two-

350 NATURAL SCIENCE [November

tenths of a second. They were mis-spelt by the omission of a letter,
the substitution of a wrong letter, or the blurring of a letter by print-
ing an x over it. The object was to determine the relative influence
of the objective factor in the visual stimulus, and the subjective factor
through association and apperception. The experiments were, so far
as possible, carefully tabulated, and it required not a little skill (and
some imagination) to educe results of any decisive value. A good
resume of Prof. Wundt's views on apperception is given, and the
conclusions reached are in line with those obtained in a quite different
way by Dr Stout in his recent work on Analytical Psychology.

The New Age, which was started in April, is published on the loth
of each month by the proprietor, 68/2 Shikdar Bagan Street, Calcutta.
The annual subscription is Es. 2.12. The editor is S. C. Mukho-
padhaya, M.A. There is some want of discrimination shown in
the selection of tit-bits for this " Journal of universal information,"
but it will probably be of interest to the readers for whom it is in-
tended, and it interests us as an expression of the views of the educated
Hindu community.

We regret to learn that with the October number the Inter-
national Journal of Microscopy and Natural Science, for sixteen years
the organ of the Postal Microscopical Society, has ceased to exist from
lack of adequate financial support.

The Psychological Review, vol. iv. No. 5, contains a suggestive paper
by Prof. Mark Baldwin on the " Psychology of Social Organisation."
The author is one of those who are in sympathy with biological studies,
and who seek to correlate the biological and the psychological factors
in the development of social life from its pre-social beginnings. The
same writer gives in the " Princeton Contributions to Psychology," re-
printed from the preceding number of the Psychological Review, a dis-
cussion of " Determinate Evolution," which should prove of interest to
biologists.

In the Albuquerque Morning Democrat, Prof. Cockerell gives a report
on the Mexican dietary as studied by Prof. Goss. He finds that the
principal food of the Mexican peasant is flour, corn meal, and chili,
and that he is using more carbo-hydrates and less proteids than is
desirable. The Mexican gets most of his proteids from frijoles, and for
the better nourishment of the peasant Prof. Goss suggests a larger use
of frijoles in proportion to the flour and meal. The work is being
carried on at the Mesilla Park experiment station, and the object
aimed at is an improved dietary after examination of soils and im-
provement in agricultural produce.

In the Transactions of the Perthshire Society of Natural Science, vol.
ii. pt. 5, Colonel Duthie writes on the British abode of the Crested
Titmouse (Parus cristatus) ; Messrs Coates and Macnair on a banded
Hornblende Schist at Balhoulan Quarry, Pitlochry ; and Mr Macnair
on Pocks of Highland Perthshire. The president, Mr Coates, also gives
a presidential address entitled The Origin of Soils, with special refer-

1897] SOME NEW BOOKS 351

ence to the soils of Perthshire ; making altogether a good geological
part of the Transactions.

Timchri for June contains Nesting of some Guiana Birds, by C. A.
Lloyd ; Tobacco and Cotton Cultivation in the British West Indies,
by W. H. Burnley ; Result of Eecent Scientific Researches into the
Agricultural Improvement of the Sugar Cane, and on other Sugar
Cane Experiments, by J. B. Harrison.

New Serials

The Institute of Jamaica has now begun to issue Annals in
addition to its well-known Journal. We have received the first part
containing a list of the Decapod Crustacea of Jamaica by Mary J.
Eathbun of the U.S. National Museum.

The Archives de Parasitologic, under the direction of Raphael
Blanchard, is a new review announced to appear in Paris next
January. The parts will be published at variable intervals, each
containing about 160 pages, and four will constitute a volume, price
30 francs. The journal will comprise both original articles and
reviews of progress.

The Archives of Skiagraphy has changed its title to Archives of
the Roentgen Ray. It is edited by W. S. Hedley and Sydney Rowland,
and is published by the Rebman Co. The illustrations are chiefly of
medical and surgical interest.

Further Literature Received

Vorlesungen iiber Bacterien, A. Fischer : Gustav Fischer. An Introduction to
Geology, W. B. Scott : Macmillan. Traite de Botanique, L. Courchet : Balliere. The
Mathematical Psychology of Gratry and Boole, M. E. Boole : Sonnenschein. In
Northern Spain, Hans Gadow : Black. Catalogus Mammalium, fasc. iii., E. L.
Trouessart : Friedliinder. Darwin and After Darwin, III. Post-Darwinian Questions,
G. J. Romanes : Longmans. Familiar Wild Flowers, F. E. Hulme : Cassell.

An Address on Acquired Immunity, G. Archdall Reid : Lancet. Notes on the
Coccidae, T. D. A. Cockerell : Rev. Mus. Paulista. On the Nature of the Rontgen
Rays, Sir G. G. Stokes : Manchester Lit. and Phil. Soc. Harvard University, Dept.
Zoology, 1897-98.

Timehri, June ; Amer. Geol., Oct. ; Amer. Journ. Sci., Oct. ; Amer. Nat., Oct. ;
Ann. Inst. Jamaica, Vol. i., No. 1 ; Annot. Zool. Japan, Vol. i. , Part iii. ; Botan.
Gaz., Sept. ; East Asia, Oct. ; Feuilles des Jeunes Nat., Oct. ; Irish Nat., Oct. ; Journ.
School. Geogr., Sept. ; Knowledge, Oct. ; Literary Digest, Sept. 11, 18, Oct. 2, 9;
Naturae Novit. , Sept.; Naturalist, Oct.; Nature, Sept. 23, 30, Oct. 7, 14; Nature
Notes, Oct. ; Naturen, Sept. ; New Age, Sept. ; Photogram, Oct. ; Rev. Scient. Sept.
18, 25, Oct. 2, 9 ; Science, Sept. 10, 17, 24, Oct. 1 ; Sci. Amer., Sept. 11, 18, 25, Oct.
2 ; Scot. Geogr. Mag., Oct. ; Scot. Med. and Surg. Journ., Oct. ; Victorian Nat., Aug. ;
Westminster Review, Oct.

352 [November

OBITUARIES

WILLIAM AECHEE

Born May 6, 1830. Died AuGust 14, 1897.

William Archer, who died in Dublin on August 14th last, was born
on May 6th, 1830. He devoted himself for many years to the investi-
gation of the lower plants and animals, especially the Desmids and
certain groups of the Ehizopods and Infusoria. From 187b' till 1880,
he acted on the editorial staff of the Quarterly Journal of Micro-
scopical Science, in which most of his important work was published.
Many of his valuable papers, however, were issued by the Dublin
Natural History Society, now extinct, whose proceedings are, unfor-
tunately, very scarce. He was an original member, and for many years
secretary of the Dublin Microscopical Club. His eminence as a
microscopist led to election into the Eoyal Society in 1875. In 1876
he became librarian to the Eoyal Dublin Society, and when the bulk
of the collection was transferred to the Government to form the
National Library of Ireland, Archer became head of the new institu-
tion. His later years were busily occupied in the duties of this
office, and he laboured unremittingly in the transfer of the books
to new quarters, and their arrangement and cataloguing on the
Dewey system, of which he was an enthusiastic advocate. Two
years ago he was compelled to retire, having reached the age of
sixty-five. His familiar figure will be sadly missed among Dublin
men of science, whose respect for his wide learning was accompanied
by hearty admiration for his personal worth. G. H. C.

The following deaths are also announced : — Karl Vogel and Wilhelm Liebenon,
eminent German cartographers ; Karl Wilhelm Petzold, the physical and astro-
nomical geographer ; J. H. Trumbull, philologist and member of the National Academy
of Sciences, U.S.A.; Ernest Hutu, professor in Frankfort and well known as a popu-
lariser of science ; Emil Schmidt, a teacher of zoology in Berlin ; Edgar Maclure,
professor in the Oregon State University, recently killed by a fall on Mount Rainier,
which he was exploring with a party ; at Port Antonio, Jamaica, Dr J. E. Humphrey,
associate professor of botany in Johns Hopkins University, Baltimore ; C. S. Roy, pro-
fessor of pathology in the University of Cambridge, aged 43 ; August Mojsisovics,
professor of zoology and comparative anatomy in the Universit}' of Graz ; Dr Holm-
gren, professor of physiology in the University of Upsala, aged 66 ; and Dr Welcker,
professor of anatomy in the University of Halle.

1897] 353

NEWS

The following appointments are announced : — Dr Lehman Nitsche to be
keeper of the department of Anthropology in the La Plata Museum, in succession
to Dr Ten Kate ; Dr P. Zwaardeniaker to be professor of physiology in the
University of Utrecht ; Dr Carl Zelinka to be professor of zoology in the
University of Czernowitz ; W. L. Bray to be professor of botany in the Univer-
sity of Texas ; H. L. Jones to be associate professor of botany in Oberlin College ;
Dr Hans Reusch, director of the geological survey of Norway, to be Sturgis-
Hooper professor of geology in Harvard University, for the season 1897-98.

We have had occasion to refer to the good work that has lately been done in
the Bootle Museum. The Committee did well when, some three years ago, they
engaged Mr H. C. Chad wick as museum assistant. We therefore regret to learn
that they can no longer afford to retain his services.

The new Museum of the Brooklyn Institute of Arts and Sciences was opened
early in October, when President Eliot of Harvard delivered an address.

Dr Alexander Hill, Master of Downing College, has been elected Vice-
Chancellor of the University of Cambridge.

The Eighth International Geological Congress is to meet in Paris in 1900, the
year of the Exhibition. The visit to Vienna, which was to have taken place in
that year, is postponed to 1903.

Reuter announces that Nossilor has arrived at Tiumen from the Kara Sea.
He has explored the Yalmal peninsula, and discovered a shorter waterway
between Siberia and Europe, and one free from the sea ice.

It is proposed to decorate the Zoological Park at Washington with bronze
groups of Indians and wild animals. Mr Edward Kemeys will probably receive
this commission, which will put on record many vanishing types of animal life.

The Botanical Gazette announces that the Smithsonian Institution has ap-
pointed a commission, with Dr V. Havard as chairman, to collect information
concerning the medicinal qualities of the plants of the United States of America.

Mr R. C. Christie has presented to the Owens College, Manchester, his share
of the estate of the late Sir Joseph Whitworth, estimated at about £50,000. The
fund is to be devoted to a new building with which the name of Whitworth can
be associated.

According to the Athenceum, it is proposed to establish at Swansea a branch
University College in association with either Cardiff or Aberystwyth. This town
already possesses an important library and museum in the Royal Institution of
South Wales.

The Academy of Sciences of Berlin has granted a sum of 3000 marks to Prof.
B. Hagen, Frankfurt, for the publication of an anthropological atlas ; 1500 marks
to Prof. Kohen, Greifswald, for mineralogical researches ; and 800 marks to Prof.
R. Bonnet, Greifswald, for anatomical work.

Science states that plans have already been made for the new building of the
American Geographical Society, New York, although the site has not yet been

354 NATURAL SCIENCE [November

decided upon. The Society owes its present flourishing condition to Judge Daly,
who has been its president for thirty-three years.

A collection of horns of mammals made in South Africa by Mr J. Rosen is
now being exhibited on loan in the Brighton Museum. Most of the known
species are represented, and many of the specimens are remarkably fine. One
pair of horns of a koodoo measure 47 inches in length.

The Louisiana Society of Naturalists was founded on July 22nd. It starts
with forty-five members under the presidency of Prof. J. H. Dillard of Tulane
University, the secretary being Mr E. Foster. According to Science the Society
will establish a museum and library, and will publish proceedings.

The Museum of the Perthshire Society of Natural Science is progressing
favourably, though hampered by want of funds. We trust the town authorities
will help in the matter after so much energy has been spent in getting things into
shape. The Society's library has received a set of the ' Challenger ' Reports from
the Government.

Next year Mr J. E. Spurr will lead an expedition to Alaska to make a further
survey of the gold resources. $5000 has been appropriated by Congress for the
purpose, but according to Science an effort will be made to increase the appropria-
tion to $25,000 in order that a complete survey may be made and a geological map
of the region prepared.

During the present session Prof. Boyd Dawkins will give a series of twelve
short addresses on geological subjects in the Manchester Museum. These are to
be delivered alternately on Saturday and Sunday afternoons. We are glad to
note that the Museum has just received a donation of £1500 from Mr Edward
Holt towards the building fund.

According to the American Journal of Science, the Geological Survey of Canada
has recently acquired a mass of meteoric iron from Thurlow, Hastings Co.,
Ontario. It is an irregularly-shaped, truncated pyramidal mass, with a more or
less rectangular base, measuring O^m. by 0-135m., and weighs 5*42 kilos. It is
to be named the Thurlow meteorite.

The International Ornithological Congress will meet this year at Aix on
November 9. The International Congress of Zoology will meet at Cambridge on
August 23, 1898. Sir William Flower has issued a circular letter asking for
co-operation with the general committee in raising a fund to defray the necessary
expenses of the meeting. The committee has just met in London to arrange
the preliminaries.

Prof. Michael Foster has been delivering lectures in Baltimore during
October, and he now proceeds to deliver a course of Lowell Lectures at Boston.
In the middle of the month, Dr Nansen passed through London on his way to
America, where he has many engagements. Science announces that at the close
of his first lecture at New York a medal will be presented to him by the American
Geographical Society.

At the annual meeting of the Hull Scientific and Field Naturalists' Club,
held on September 29, it was reported that great progress had been made during
the year. Thirty-eight new members had been elected, and the attendance at
meetings had increased by 50 per cent. The Society wisely arranges its pro-
gramme so that lectures of general scientific interest alternate with its more
technical and original local work.

The Trustees of the British Museum have been approached by the Council of

1897] NEWS 355

the British Association with regard to the establishment of a Bureau of Eth-
nology for Greater Britain. If this arrangement can be come to there is no doubt
that the information obtained would be of great service to science and utility to
the Government. Sir John Evans, Sir John Lubbock, Mr C. H. Read, and Prof.
E. B. Tylor made the report which was placed before the British Association.

Sir Joseph Hooker has finished the " Flora of British India," begun twenty
years ago, and has received, according to the Kew Bulletin, a despatch from the
Government of India, through Sir George Hamilton, recognising his services to
India in cordial and sympathetic terms. Sir J. Hooker has, we are also glad to
learn, offered to undertake the preparation of the remaining volumes of the late
Dr Trimen's " Handbook to the Flora of Ceylon," and the necessary material and
specimens have already arrived at Kew from Peradeniya.

Among the Russian geologists who took part in the Oural excursion, none
endeared himself more to his fellow-travellers than the young candidate in
Natural Science, L. Spendiarow. He died suddenly of heart disease almost
immediately after the return to St Petersburg. His father has given to the
International Geological Congress the sum of 4000 roubles, the triennial interest
of which is to be awarded by the President of each Congress as a prize for the
best geological work done during the preceding three years.

We learn that the Government have presented a set of the ' Challenger '
reports to certain local scientific societies. This is a very excellent stimulus, no
doubt, but we hope the familiar notice that is to be found inside the Record
Office publications deposited in our Free Libraries is to be found also in these
scientific reports. Local societies exist by the enthusiasm of the few, and when
they fall into decay such volumes might well be taken from them and passed on
to another centre where they will be more appreciated.

The Bulgarian Government has received by bequest from Eulogius Georgieff,
the founder of the Sofia University, the sum of 20,000,000 francs for public
purposes. This includes 6,000,000 francs for a technical school for Sofia. The
University of Lyons will devote 42,000 francs to complete the biological labora-
tory of Tamaris, near Toulon, and will probably endow it to a moderate extent.
Indianapolis will receive fifty-six acres of land for a botanical garden and ornitho-
logical preserve from Mr W. W. Woolen. Yale University has received $5000 by
the will of Miss Julia Lockwood for the foundation of a scholarship.

The University Extension Lectures in London for the coming session were
listed by The Echo on October 5. The following may interest some of our
readers : — The Geography of Britain and the British Seas, by H. J. Mackinder,
at Gresham College ; the World's Great Explorers, by H. Yule, Oldham, at
Toynbee Hall ; Evolution and Darwinism, by E. O. Paskyn, at Lewisham ;
Physiology of Plants, by E. O. Paskyn,' at Morley College ; the Earth, by F. W.
Rudler, at Croyden and Toynbee Hall ; Our Common Minerals, by F. W. Rudler,
at West Ham ; and Human Anatomy, by Chalmers Mitchell, at Toynbee Hall.

Miss Kate M. Hall, Curator of the Whitechapel Museum, has made arrange-
ments to co-operate with the teachers of the elementary schools in the district in
demonstrations to their classes when they visit the Museum. As is well-known,
the Code of 1895 allows visits to be paid during school hours under proper guid-
ance to museums, art galleries, and other institutions of educational value, such
visits being counted as "attendances." At Whitechapel each headmaster or mis-
tress is invited to bring one assistant and forty-five pupils on each occasion. The
pupils are divided into three groups, the teachers and Miss Hall each taking one.
Such specimens as may be removed from the cases are arranged on three tables.

356 NATURAL SCIENCE [November

Each group spends a quarter of an hour at each table, and the rest of the
hour is devoted to questions or to a general survey of the Museum.

The meeting of the Botanical Society of America, which was held at Toronto
at the time of the visit of the British Association, seems to have been a great
success. Dr J. M. Coulter was the president, and there were present a large
gathering of English and Foreign botanists. N. L. Britton of New York was
chosen president for 1898, which session will be held in Boston, an invitation
from the Missouri Botanic Garden for the spring of that year having been
reluctantly declined. The chief papers were — A case of ecblasteris and axial
prolification in Lepidium apetalum, by B. L. Robinson ; Movement of protoplasm
in coenocytic hyphae, by J. A. Arthur ; Pollen grains and antipodal cells, by
J. M. Coulter ; The transition region of the Caryophyllales, by F. E. Clements ;
A revision of the species Picea occurring in North-Eastern America, by D. P.
Penhallow ; Bibliographic difficulties, by E. L. Greene ; and the botanical gardens
of Jamaica, by W. Fawcett.

1897] 357

CORRESPONDENCE

INHERITANCE OF ACQUIRED CHARACTERS

In view of the doctrine which constitutes the corner - stone of Prof. Weismann's
theories of heredity — the non -inheritance of acquired characters — any exceptions to the
rule which he lays down may be worth notice. I desire to submit to your readers for
consideration one which has appeared to me to bear upon this question — viz., the direc-
tion in which the hairs slope on the extensor surface of the forearm in certain hairy
Quadrupeds and in man. The course which the hairs take on this small area varies in
ifferent animals, but, as far as I can learn, in two main directions only. In the first of
these, which one may look upon as more ' normal, ' the slope is on the whole directed
in the axis of the limb towards the distal extremity, and is thus in keeping with the
general slope of hair on the other areas of this and the posterior extremity of the animal,
as in the great Ungulate order and a few species of monkeys. The second type of direc-
tion presents a certain reversal of the slope — viz., that the hairs after a mauus-ward
course on the flexor surface curve round the lateral borders of the fore-arm, and when
they reach the extensor surface they pass in a reversed direction, in some animals on the
whole area, in others on the proximal portion only, towards the trunk. This second
type is seen clearly in man at all ages, in the anthropoid apes, especially in the long-
haired Orang, to an extent exceeding any other animal I have seen, in most lower
monkeys, and in the Carnivores. In the last-named order the direction is visible in the
terrestrial Carnivores, Arctoidea, Cynoidea and Aeluroidea, especially in the shorter-
haired forms, but in those with longer hair on the limbs the general set of hair on this
area is towards the trunk, even if indistinct in some. It is the second of these types to
which I would draw attention as being a departure from the first, which is seen in
Ungulates, and which is more in accordance with the natural arrangement of hair. In
this great group of animals, the Ungulates, there is a very general habit of flexing the
fore-limb in the attitude of repose, as one sees commonly in a herd of cows and horses
grazing, when these limbs lie doubled up and the hoofs are resting under the fore part
of the trunk. The same position can be observed in other families of this order in con-
finement. A similar slope of hair is also seen in certain Marsupials, Kangaroos, for
example ; and in these animals, which almost always lie on their sides when at rest, the
position would be indifferent as to influence upon the slope. In Ungulates the pressure
thus exercised when the limb is in acute flexion would act at right angles to the axis of
the limb, and, except in so far as it would confirm the original slope of the hair on the
extensor surface, it would be indifferent in its effect on the hair-slope. But in the
Primates, Carnivores, and certain other animals in which the surface of this limb-seg-
ment in question is exposed to pressure acting in a different manner, one is not surprised
to find a different slope of hair. In Man it is frequently subject to pressure against some
underlying fixed surface. In apes and monkeys of all kinds it is extremely common in
their sitting posture to see their upper extremities strongly flexed at the elbow and rest-
ing against their lower limbs. In terrestrial Carnivores the normal attitude of repose
is, except on the occasions when they lie • asleep stretched out on their sides, that the
fore-limbs are planted in front of the trunk, seen most noticeably in the ' couchant '
position which they commonly assume. In all these instances it is obvious that there is
a slowly acting mechanical force in the downward and forward direction by reason of the
weight of the limb itself, and the fore part of the trunk which is supported by it. The
effect of this pressure would be to cause the hairs to slope towards the trunk, as is found
to be the case in these animals. There are of course many apes and monkeys, notably
the chimpanzee, gorilla, and orang, in which the same direction is taken by the hairs on
other aspects of the same limb on regions where no pressure can influence it. In these
the general set of hair towards the trunk is probably due in part to the effect of gravi-
tation on the long hair, and perhaps, as Mr Wallace has suggested, to the influence of
heavy rain in tropical forests when the hair would act to the body as thatch does to the
roof of a house.

The direction of hair-slope on this area is, of course, congenital ; it is therefore a
primary character, not one acquired by the individual through secondary forces. It is
congenital in the human infant, in the young monkeys and young Carnivores which I
have been able to examine, and presumably it is so in all in which it is found.

358 NATURAL SCIENCE [November

The consideration of this point leads us to the conclusion that the character before
us is one which it is impossible to look upon as having any ' survival- value,' or as due to
any form of selectional processes within the germ acting under adaptive requirements.
An adequate secondary cause is suggested for its original production in the ancestors of
those which now exhibit it. Perhaps someone more qualified to speak could determine
whether or not this is one of the exceptions to Prof. Weismann's rule, the non-in-
heritance of acquired characters. Walter Kidd.

12 MONTPELIER ROW,

Blackheath, S.E.

INSECTS AND FLOWERS

Without at this time attempting to discuss the general arguments used by Mr Bulman
in his interesting paper in your August number, I should like to draw attention to the
following paragraph (p. 103) : —

" Again, if our native flowers are the result of the selective action of our native bees,
and those which they have specially chosen for countless generations, how is it that
bees take so readily to many flowers of very different forms introduced into our gardens
from abroad ? For such introduced plants are in many cases freely visited by native
bees."

I think we need more information about this matter. I have found, here in New
Mexico, that garden flowers do not as a rule attract many species of native bees, unless
they are very closely related to native flowers. A flower garden is nearly always dis-
appointing as a hunting-ground, the bees found there being mainly certain widely dis-
tributed types which visit very many species of native plants. In a luxuriant garden at
Santa Fe the best collecting is on the weeds, not at all on the cultivated flowers.

Solidago canadensis is a native plant very common in New Mexico. It is also grown in
gardens in Europe, and a small list of common flies visiting it there is given by Hermann
Mailer. In Las Cruces, on Aug. 30 of this year, Prof. C. H. T. Townsend was sweeping
S. canadensis for flies. He swept at the same time a lot of hymenoptera, which he
handed to me. I have sorted out the fossores and bees, and here is the list : —

Anthophila

Agapostemon melliventris, Cress. 3 • Nomia nevadensis, Cress.

radiatus, S&y. 6- Melissodes agilis, Cress. 8 ■

Panurgus rhodoceratus, Ckll. Perdita sphaeralceae, Ckll., one 6 •

Colletes americana, Cress. Epeolus lunatics, Say vel peraff.

Ealictus stultus, Cress, vel peraff. Podalirius maculifrons, Cress.

ligatus, Say.
sp.

Fossores

Microbembex monodonta, Say. Slizus godmani, Cam.

Philanthus vcntilabris v. frontalis, Cress. Aphilanthops laticinctus, Cress.

,, sp. Ccrceris acanthophilus, Ckll.

Stcniolia dupiicata, Prov. Mijzinc frontalis, Cress. M. S. 9 .
Oxybelus quadricolor, Ckll. and Baker, $. fj hyalina, Cress. <$•

,, sparideus, Ckll. Anacrabro boerhaaviai, Ckll.

,, abdominalis, Baker. <$ • (new to Paratiphia, sp.

N. M.). Scolia, 2 spp.
sp.
Plcnoculus cockerellii, Fox.

I have on former occasions done equally good collecting from the Solidago. Who can
show a similar list in Europe collecting from the same plant ? I doubt if it can be done,
yet the plant belongs to a European genus, and is much less specialised for insects than
many others. T. D. A. Cockerell.

Mesillo, New Mexico, U.S.A.,
Sept. 3, 1897.

* I suspect that this came from a Sphaeralcea growing among the Solidago, especially as there are
in the lot two beetles which breed on Spiiaeralcea. These may, however, have strayed from their normal
plant.

1897] CORRESPONDENCE 359

WOMEN versus BIRDS

In Natural Science for August (p. 77), the question is asked as to what more we can do
besides attempting to influence women in the home-circle so as to prevent their bar-
barian slaughter of the birds for decoration of themselves. I think we could do a great
deal more, and will instance this by an account of what occurred here some years ago.
A Frenchman settled down in the neighbourhood of Mount Ophii in Malacca as a col-
lector of bird skins for the trade. He employed a large number of native hunters, and
the slaughter of our most beautiful birds — sun-birds, trogons, fairy bluebirds, and many
others — was horrible. However, the Government, on learning this, passed an ordinance
forbidding the killing of birds in the colony without a licence. The man then moved
to one of the native states out of colonial jurisdiction, but the law was immediately
introduced there. Then it is said he sold the goodwill of the business to an unsuspect-
ing native and disappeared. The native, of course, on attempting to carry on the
business was arrested. Since then our birds have returned to their desolated haunts
and are as plentiful as ever, and no further attempt has been made to establish the trade
in this country. Indeed, I can hardly remember a case where it has been found neces-
sary to put the law in force, though, of course, a few birds are now and then illegally
killed by shooters. Of course we are much assisted by the licensing of guns. Natives,
for excellent reasons, are only allowed gun licences for purposes of defence against tigers,
robbers, etc., or to keep away wild pigs or other destructive animals, and this checks
bird-killing very well.

In Borneo, under British rule or influence, the Mias is also protected, no person
being allowed to kill one except by special permit, only granted for scientific purposes.
And licences to collect orchids are also issued there to check the wholesale destruction
of these plants.

The forests of the Dindings, especially one jungle round a hill called Gunong Tungul,
are tenanted by rhinoceroses, which the natives used to trap in pitfalls. As the animal
is perfectly harmless, and a very interesting beast, the District Officer, Mr W. C. Mit-
chell, endeavoured to prevent its destruction, and though the Government did not see
their way to legislating to save it, he succeeded in preventing any more from being
killed. The Rhinoceros is considered by the Chinese as a very valuable medicine, or
rather collection of medicines. They pay large sums for its carcase, and dry and pre-
pare every bit of it to ship to China. This was the only inducement to the Malays to
kill it. Thanks to this action there are still plenty in this district, where I have more
than once come across them, or heard them gallop off snorting like a pony.

Now, for the trade in bird-skins in colonies or countries under British influence there
can be no excuse. It can and should be stopped by local ordinance. The difficulty lies
in countries not under our control, such as Mexico, Brazil and New Guinea. In nearly
all these places, however, there are naturalists, and often Natural History Societies. It
should be the duty of all scientists in these countries to bring pressure to bear upon
their Governments to check or prevent the trade in bird skins. Part of New Guinea is
under British influence, and any destruction of Birds of Paradise here could be pre-
vented. The naturalists of Holland and Germany might also be asked to approach
their Governments on the subject, and to stop the trade in their Colonies.

In the list of birds destroyed given in the article in Natural Science, it is not alto-
gether easy to guess from what part of the world the skins and plumes are derived.
Some are evidently Indian — e.g., Peacock, Indian Parrots, Impeyan Pheasant, &c. ;
others Tanagers and Humming Birds from South America. Let our naturalists at home
first trace up the sources of the supply, and then those in the countries whence the
skins come can be appealed to to bring the matter before their respective Governments.
This plan, though it will probably not entirely stop the trade, will at least save the
birds of some corners of the world, and will strike a blow at the fashion which I trust
it may never recover. H. N. Ridley.

Singapore, April 25, 1897.

AUSTRALIAN NATURAL HISTORY

As an Australian worker I trust that you will allow me to protest against the hostile
criticism of an Australian student, as sucb, by a London authority, as such, on p. 5 of
this volume. Criticism of Australian work upon its merits will always be welcome, but
when a reviewer is invoked to write down a paper because if a certain arrangement
"was not made it ought to have been " then fair play is disregarded and the honest
aims of criticism made subservient to less worthy ends. For it is evident that under
ordinary circumstances the brilliant writer of your editorial would not have stooped to
crush a weaker brother on the score of a few misprints, and the difference which will
ever exist in their view of what constitutes a 'species' between a ' splitter ' and a
' lumper.'

360 NATURAL SCIENCE [November

More than a year ago three naturalists gathered each a miscellaneous collection from
a Pacific Atoll ; two of these went direct to London, the third to Sydney. Not a word
has as yet been written on the material sent to England. A generation since Darwin
complained, in sorrow and surprise, that he could not secure specialists to work out the
results of his South American journey. To-day boundless wealth of material pours into
London, but what proportion of it is ever studied ? There is no lack in London of
material, of Pacific material, even of Funafuti material for students with an appetite for
work : yet is it touched ? But if a local student makes an honest attempt to further
the cause of science, a bitter cry arises from the British Museum specialist — defrauded
of his rights ! J. Douglas Ogilby.

Livingstone Road, Petersham, Sydney,
25th August 1897.

FUNAFUTI

In the first paragraph of your review of " Australian Museum Memoir III. (on Funafuti
Atoll), part 2," which appeared in your July number, is a statement of your impression
that a stipulation had been made for the Royal Society to have the right of prior
publication, and that if such an agreement was not made it ought to have been.

I am directed by the trustees of the Australian Museum to put you in possession of
the actual facts of the case ; and, as your statement has been made public, to request
that this also might be given the same prominence.

On 7th April 1896 the Local Committee in Sydney, representing the Royal Society
of London, asked the trustees to nominate an officer to accompany Prof. Sollas on the
Expedition to Bore a Coral Reef, and Mr Charles Hedley was appointed. The trustees
were informed in a letter, signed by the Chairman of the Local Committee, that "in
regard to the secondary objects, that is, the Collection of Specimens of Natural History,
each member of the expedition will be at liberty to retain or exchange anything he may
obtain. The expedition as an undertaking, therefore, does not interfere with the col-
lections of [Mr Hedley]. Your trustees are thus at liberty to impose what conditions
they think best upon their representative in this respect." In addition to this, the
question of publication was raised at a meeting of the Local Committee, at which one of
the trustees of the Museum and the curator were present as well as Prof. Sollas, and the
reply was that no restriction would be placed on it.

It will thus be seen that, in taking part in the expedition, a stipulation was
made beforehand for the right of publication of the results obtained by the trustees'
representative.

S. Sinclair,
Secretary to the Trustees of the Australian Museum.

Sydney, 8th September 1897.

[We deeply regret that information which we had from two independent sources,
believed to be authoritative, should have led us to make any suggestion of unfairness on
the part of our friends and fellow-workers in Sydney. A correction of our error was
published before the various Australian protests reached us. The rest of our remarks,
whether of praise or blame, remain absolutely unaffected by this correction. — Ed.
Nat. Sci.]

NOTICE

To the Trade. — Natural Science is published on the 25th of each month ; all
advertisements should be in the Publishers' hands not later than the 20th.

Price of Set of Vols. I., II., III., IV.

„ V., VI., VII., VIII.
,, ,, ,, 1. Vill. • • . ,

One Shilling each Number of any Bookseller.

Annual Subscription, payable in advance to J. M. Dent & Co., 67 St James' Street,
London, S.W., Thirteen Shillings ($3 "50), post free.

NATURAL SCIENCE

A Monthly Review of Scientific Progress

No. 70— Vol. XI— DECEMBER 1897

NOTES AND COMMENTS

The Fauna of the Deep Sea

One of the most important publications of the past month is Dr
Gunther's Presidential Address to the Linnean Society of London,
just issued in this Society's Proceedings. It is a critical review of
our present knowledge of the depths of the sea, by one who has
made a life-long study of the subject, and added no small contribu-
tions to the solution of the problems in question from the biologist's
point of view. Dr Glinther treats the subject under geographical
headings, being of opinion that this arrangement brings out some
points of interest more prominently than a general historical state-
ment would do. He is careful, however, to emphasise the fact that
he still believes the deep-sea fauna to be one indivisible whole ;
such types as seem to be characteristic of some particular region of
the ocean being "accidentally or ignorantly imported into the deep-
sea fauna," or else forms of which the wide range has not yet been
ascertained.

Among the many interesting points discussed, there are two
expressions of opinion of great importance from one who has so
many qualifications to speak authoritatively. The first relates to
the question of the permanence of the abyssal ocean depths ; the
other refers to the presence or absence of life in the middle-depths
of the oceanic waters.

Dr Giinther is emphatically in favour of the idea that the
abysses of the ocean are not permanent, but may well have changed
many times in the past. He declares that the opposite view
"cannot be accepted by the student of the terrestrial fauna." He
remarks : " I cannot help thinking that our knowledge of the
nature of the rocks at the bottom of the sea is, at present, to use a
mild expression, most imperfect. Is it not possible that continental
rocks at the abyssal sea-bottom are so hidden under the deposit
which has been in progress of formation for untold ages, as to pre-
vent us from penetrating to them ? Possibly the day may come
when borings or some similar operation will be successfully carried

2 c

362 NATURAL SCIENCE [December

out in the abysses, entirely upsetting our present ideas of the geo-
logical nature of the sea-bottom. Besides, we have no other means
for accounting for the distribution of the terrestrial fauna, more
especially in the southern hemisphere, except by assuming that
great changes have taken place in the extent and position of conti-
nental land, and, moreover, that these changes were still in progress
at periods at which our present fauna, or at least part of it, was
already in existence."

The question of the existence of a " mid-water fauna " is con-
sidered by.Dr Giinther to be still an open one, to be " decided only
by continued tow-net experiments in great depths of the open ocean,
with a bottom of clean ooze or mud." Agassiz, as is well known,
maintains that there is no such fauna. Dr Giinther, however,
observes that the experiments of the distinguished American
naturalist " prove too much. His tow-nets came up always empty
from the intermediate zones. It is very singular that he should
not have caught even some of the dead bodies which, like rain,
drop constantly from the surface to the bottom. Further, so far as
fishes are concerned, there is no reason why certain forms should
not permanently inhabit intermediate zones, inasmuch as also pelagic
fishes are undoubtedly free swimmers for nearly the whole of their
life, without being tied to the proximity of terra firma. The ova of
many species which live in the mature stage at the bottom of great
depths are pelagic, and hatched at or near the surface. The young
continue to live for some time under pelagic conditions {Plagusiae,
Lcptocephali, Polyprion), but as they grow they descend to the deep
sea. It is very improbable that this descent is rapid ; it must be
gradual in order to allow the physiological functions to get used to
abyssal conditions ; or, in other words, these fish must live for some
time in mid-water."

Finally, Dr Giinther adds an appropriate plea for more deep-sea
work in the Indian Ocean and the Antarctic regions. The ordinary
survey of the sea's round British India is now nearly completed, but
researches on the fauna have only proceeded just far enough to
demonstrate their interest and biological importance. " It seems a
pity," as Dr Giinther remarks, " that while the experience gained on
board the ' Investigator ' is at least still partly available in the ser-
vice, no further benefit should accrue from it for science." In refer-
ence to the Antarctic Ocean, he points out that our knowledge of
its abyssal life rests merely on six trawlings of the ' Challenger.' We
trust that ere long the British Government will be induced to help
further in this important biological work. To use Dr Giinther's
words, " the beneficial influence which every purely scientific under-
taking exercises upon mankind reaches far beyond its immediate
aim." Science " is the mother as well as the daughter of peace."

1897] NOTES AND COMMENTS 363

The International Zoological Congress, 1898

The meeting of the General Committee appointed to arrange for the
next meeting of the International Zoological Congress was marked
by an unfortunate lack of union. One well-known zoologist described
it as the most turbulent meeting he had ever attended. The Congress
is to meet in England next August, and the original arrangement was
that it should be held in London, which, for various reasons, has now
been altered to Cambridge. The success of a similar Congress in
America in 1891 was seriously affected by a change in the place of
meeting, which led to the abstention of a great number of American
men of science, who objected to the alteration. Cambridge does not
now oeeupy the position in the English zoological world which it did
in the days of F. M. Balfour. There are no doubt strong reasons
for the selection of Cambridge, although the town is not central.
But remembering the consequences of the change of locality of the
American Congress in 1891, the advocates of Cambridge might have
done their best to conciliate provincial representatives. Their attitude
was decidedly the reverse. When, for example, Colonel Wardlaw
Bamsay proposed that in order to secure one Scottish member on
the executive, Sir William Turner should be elected a vice-president,
Professor Newton formed the minority of one who voted against it.
Professor Poulton, also anxious to make the committee more repre-
sentative, proposed that the presidents of the Linnean and Entomo-
logical Societies should be ex officio vice-presidents, which secured at
once the warm support of the meeting. The chairman, however,
expressed himself confident that Mr Poulton, on thinking the
question over, would see the advisability of withdrawing his resolu-
tion and allowing the executive committee to select itself the
additions to its number. But Mr Poulton remarked that he
did not see the advisability of his withdrawing his resolution, and
thought it much better not to trust the executive committee to make
the additions recommended. The resolution was carried by an over-
whelming majority. So the cut and dried plans of those who had
arranged the agenda were not accepted quite as they stood. A
member who proposed one of the official resolutions read it out as
" the resolution I have been ' instructed ' to propose ; " and then re-
commended it to the meeting by one hostile criticism. Dr Murie
proposed that the executive committee should be composed of an
equal number of members from England, Ireland and Scotland, a re-
markable suggestion that only fell non-seconded because the zoologist
who attempted the feat could not complete his sentence until the
meeting was well advanced in the consideration of the next business.
A few proposals of this sort, by claim for zoological independence for
Wales and the Manxmen, kept the meeting merry. But it seems

364 NATURAL SCIENCE [December

quite clear that the provincial and non-official London zoologists
view the present committee with suspicion, as not sufficiently repre-
sentative of British zoology. Sir John Lubbock has succeeded Sir
William Flower in the presidency, and he may be trusted to prevent
any further irritation of the majority by a tactless disregard of its
manifest wishes. It is a source of the deepest regret to all British
zoologists that Sir William Flower himself should be compelled, by
need of rest, to refrain from any active part in the arrangements.

Stratigraphical Geology

In connection with Sir Henry Howorth's articles on Geological
Nomenclature which we are now publishing, attention may be
directed to a paper by Dr Charles E. Keyes, recently read before
the St Louis Academy of Sciences, and abstracted in Science for
October 29 (n.s., vol. vi., p. 655). Dr Keyes declares that " for more
than a score of years that branch of geology called stratigraphy has
been practically at a standstill. Its methods are the same that were
used fifty to seventy-five years ago." At last, however, the problems
of the correlation of sedimentary rocks can be attacked in a new way
suggested by the field-work of many American geologists. Organic
remains, it appears, may now be entirely omitted from consideration,
and the relative age of the various strata can be determined solely
by observing the succession of geographical changes in the various
large areas under comparison. These new methods, Dr Keyes
remarks, are more or less complex and far from simple ; but he is
hopeful that they will eventually lead to a really natural classifica-
tion of the rocks and definitely put an end to what has been aptly
termed ' parochial geology.' He is especially sanguine as to the
value of the results to be obtained from a detailed study of the
phenomena of mountain-formation. We cannot follow the whole
argument from the brief abstract ; but any advance in methods
which will enable us to restore the geographical features of wide
areas of the earth's surface at different successive geological periods
will not only make a new era in geological science but also contri-
bute most materially towards the solution of some of the perplexing
problems of zoology.

The Geology of Patagonia

This leads us to refer again to the question of the Tertiary deposits
of Patagonia and their remarkable mammalian fossils, discussed by
Dr Florentino Ameghino in our October number (p. 256). Mr J. B.
Hatcher, who has spent much time in studying this southern ex-
tremity of the American continent, now expresses the opinion that

NATURAL SCIENCE, VOL. XL

Plate X.

RESTORED SKELETON OF AN EXTINCT STRUTHIOTJS BIRD

Aepyornis liHrfi brandti

From a Peat-deposit, Strobe", Central Madagascar

[Obtained fur the British Museum {Natural History) by Dr Forsyth Ma.tou]

1897] NOTES AND COMMENTS 365

there is no geological basis for Ameghino's asserted discovery of the
Cretaceous ancestors of the mammalia in that region (Amer. Journ.
Sci. [4], vol. iv., pp. 327-354, Nov. 1897). He finds, apparently,
Jurassic rocks there on the Mayer river ; he also identifies the sup-
posed Cretaceous series containing Dinosaurian bones. When in
Patagonia, however, he never discovered either a mammal bone
or a tooth in the - deposits yielding Dinosaurian remains, and he
arrived at the conclusion that the beds containing Pyrotherium were
not only later than these, but probably more recent even than
the Marine Patagonian Formation itself. His words are : — " It is
certainly remarkable that in these beds containing Dinosaurian
remains, associated, according to Ameghino, with the remains of
mammals, some of them, as for example Pyrotherium, of immense
size, only a little less than that of the elephant and consequently
easily to be seen, I could have searched for weeks without ever
finding a single mammalian bone, while every day I found Dino-
saurian remains."

We await Dr Ame°'hino's observations on Mr Hatcher's results
with great interest, for on the settlement of the Patagonian prob-
lem great issues depend. It is to be hoped that ere long some
other geologist skilled in the modern methods of stratigraphy will
investigate the subject and give us another independent opinion.

The Aepyoenis of Madagascar

We have several times referred to the important results of Dr
Forsyth Major's explorations and researches in Madagascar. We
now have the pleasure of directing attention to the latest fruit of
his labours in the form of a nearly complete skeleton of the extinct
struthious bird, Aejyyornis, which was mounted' for exhibition last
month in the public galleries of the British Museum (Natural History),
South Kensington. The skeleton is shown in the accompanying
photograph (Plate X.), for which we are indebted to the courtesy of
the Editor of the Geological Magazine, and it was described
last June in the journal just mentioned by Mr C. W. Andrews.
The bird must have been about five feet in height when alive, so
that it represents one of the smaller species of the genus. The
bones do not belong to one and the same individual, but they have
been selected from a very large series and have every appearance of
giving the animal its correct proportions. The skull is imperfect in
front, but the top of the brain-case is marked with rows of deep
pits, which appear to indicate the original presence of a crest of
large feathers. The mandible is very stout. The vertebral column,
as reconstructed, consists of twenty true cervicals and eight vertebrae
bearing free ribs ; the fused pelvic vertebrae are about twenty in

36G NATURAL SCIENCE [December

number. The sternum, or breast bone, is very short and broad,,
while the coraco-scapula is much like that of a cassowary. The
wing is reduced to a mere rudiment, namely a small humerus and
one other bone which seems to represent the whole of the rest of
the limb. The hind-limb has three toes, and there also seems to
have been a rudimentary hallux, though this has not yet been
found. The specimen in the Museum is appropriately placed by
the side of JDinornis and the ostrich, and is one of the most striking
additions to the collection of fossil birds acquired during recent
years.

Swedish Arctic Exploration

We are very glad to learn that the Swedish Arctic expedition,
which Prof. A. G. Nathorst has been advocating for some time, is
likely to take definite shape next year. The necessary means have
at last been procured, thanks chiefly to the liberality of King Oscar
and the late Baron Oscar Dickson. The main objects of the expedi-
tion, Prof. Nathorst informs us, are the scientific, and especially
the geological, investigation of the east coast of Spitzbergen, which
as yet is very little known ; the charting and exploration of Kung
Karl's Land ; and, should time permit, of the little known islands
between Spitzbergen and Franz Josef Land. It is proposed to take
an observer specially familiar with the study of recent land move-
ments and glacial action, a botanist, two zoologists, who amongst
other things will, together with the hydrographer, make observations
on the plankton ; the hydrographer will also be a meteorologist.
In addition there will be a combined cartographer and photographer,
and a specialist in degree-measurement. An arc of the meridian
will be carefully measured on the east coast of Spitzbergen, but
during the course of one summer it will only be possible to make
the preliminary studies for this work. Professor Nathorst himself
will continue his previous studies in both the botany and geology of
the region, as well as having the command of the expedition. He
hopes to be able to take three scientific helpers in addition to those
mentioned, but this will depend on the size of the vessel that is
obtained.

With the notable exception of Andree's bold attempt, Sweden
has of late not taken her usual share in Polar exploration, but the
names of Torell, Loven, Nordenskibld, and other Swedes are so
intimately connected with Spitzbergen that the forthcoming expedi-
tion is but the natural sequel to a long series of scientific voyages.
With the fresh forces now at his command for attacking the prob-
lems of the Arctic seas, Professor Nathorst may expect, and we
sincerely hope that he will meet with, even more success than his
predecessors.

1897] NOTES AND COMMENTS 3G7

American Fossil Brachiopoda

Despite the many valuable monographs that have been issued of
late years by our American colleagues, the study of the fossil
Brachiopoda has hitherto been a task to be undertaken with trepi-
dation. The labours of James Hall, J. M. Clarke, C. E. Beecher,
and Charles Schuchert have considerably changed our views as to the
inter-relationship and classification of these animals, and have
rendered necessary extensive revision of nomenclature. But while
we had an uneasy feeling that the names in our text-books and the
labels in our museums were of too ancient a kind, we shrank from
the difficult duty of resorting and renaming. The magician prepared
to substitute new lamps for old arises in the person of Mr Charles
Schuchert, who essays the task for the American fossil species ; and,
since North America seems to have been the gathering-place of the
brachiopod clans in Palaeozoic times, much of this welcome light is
also available for European species.

The book that forms the necessary keystone to previous writ-
ings is entitled " A Synopsis of American fossil Brachiopoda, including
bibliography and synonymy," and has just been issued from "Wash-
ington as Bulletin, No. 87, of the United States Geological Survey.
It has, however, been prepared after official hours, and represents
the work of eleven years. The main part of the book is the " Index
and Bibliography of American fossil Brachiopoda ; " which occupies
227 pages and contains about 10,000 references. All names that
have ever been applied, rightly or wrongly, to fossil brachiopods of
North and South America, are here given in alphabetical order. The
names accepted by the author, after careful research, as valid, are
printed in bolder type, and under each is given the geological age,
chief localities, and a list of synonyms. Under each generic name is
quoted the name of the species, whether American or not, that
served as the original type of the genus ; Mr Schuchert calls this the
' genotype.'

The index is preceded by some useful and interesting chapters
on general questions, accompanied by some elaborate tables. These
chapters are : — " I. Geologic development and geographic distribution
of American fossil Brachiopoda." " II. Brachiopod terminology,
applied to fossil forms " — practically an alphabetical glossary of
terms. " III. Biologic development of the Brachiopoda " — an ex-
ceedingly important chapter. " IV. Morphology of the Brachia,"
contributed by Dr C. E. Beecher. " V. Classification of the
Brachiopoda," in which the point of chief importance is the entire
dismissal of the old division into Lyopomata and Arthropomata
( = Inarticulata and Articulata), as discordant with the facts of race-
development.

36S NATURAL SCIENCE [December

While this book will, as we have said, be an important aid to
students of the European fossil brachiopods, it by no means fills the
gap that has long yawned before them. A corresponding European
work is greatly to be desired. E. Beclard began something of the
kind, but death has stopped his energetic research. In England we
hardly take our fair share in the production of these useful biblio-
graphic lists of recent or fossil organisms ; and yet their publication
would prevent many of the descriptions of supposed new species
that are constantly being thrust upon us. Once upon a time there
was a great flourish of trumpets over a new edition of Morris'
" Catalogue of British Fossils " as a memorial to that geologist, but
though the talkers were many the labourers were few. Surely the
scheme might be undertaken by half a dozen really serious workers,
and brought up to the end of the century.

To return to Mr Schuchert. We can do no more than thank
him for the result of his labours : he has given us a key to the
writings of the last two decades, he has simplified our researches,
and has taken a heavy load off our minds. We congratulate him
on the completion of his task, and are glad to place another solid
contribution to zoological literature on our bookshelves.

Wasps and Weather

On two previous occasions {Natural Science, Vol. iii., pp. 273-275,
and vi., pp. 178-179) Mr Oswald H. Latter has called attention in
these pages to an apparent connection between abundance or scarcity
of wasps and certain meteorological phenomena. Briefly, his con-
clusion then was — (1) that wasps were favoured by dry springs and
early summer, while if these seasons were wet wasps were scarce
in the later summer and autumn ; (2) that low temperature during
the winter and early spring had little or no effect. He now favours
us with a supplementary communication, pointing out how his obser-
vations and enquiries during the present year confirm his earlier
conclusions. " A complete survey," he remarks, " must begin with
September 1896 : this was the wettest September known for many
years, the rainfall at Godalming amounting to 7'12 inches; from
that month up to the end of May of the present year the rainfall
for every month, except November, was considerably in excess of
the average, while that of March amounted to 5'01 inches. The
total rainfall for the nine months, September 1896 to May 1897,
amounted to 30*38 inches, which is rather more than 2h inches in
excess of the annual rainfall. Thus the period of hibernation and
nest-founding among wasps was extremely rainy. The temperature
of these months, notably that of February and March, was decidedly

1897] NOTES AND COMMENTS 369

above the average, and thus many Queens were early tempted from
their winter quarters. Turning now to the numbers of wasps
observed — in spring there were many ' Queens ' to be seen, and
many persons observed to me that we might expect a recurrence of
the ' plague ' of 1893. This prediction was entirely falsified, for in
all parts of the country wasps were conspicuously absent during
August and September. My own observations on this point were
conducted in Surrey, Hampshire, Norfolk, Hertfordshire, and Kent,
and I am informed by friends that the same was noticeable in Scot-
land, Lancashire, and Somersetshire. These facts seem to me
sufficiently conclusive of the truth of my former conclusion, and I
should esteem it a favour to be allowed to invite information from
any of your readers whose experience may perhaps, during the past
year, have furnished further evidence in the same or the opposite
direction."

Models of Cells

Prof. A. L. Herrera has recently published in the Memorias y
Eevista dc la Sociedad Cicntifica 'Antonio Alzate,' Mexico, 1897,
two interesting essays, in which he describes some attempts of his
to make working models of the impact of forces upon cells and
protoplasm. He points out that in the part of physiology dealing
with the elaborate mechanisms of higher animals the construction
of models, such as those to illustrate the flight of insects or the
action of the valves of the heart, has been useful ; and he attempts
to apply the same principle to the fundamental phenomena of
protoplasm. To a certain extent he has been anticipated by
Butschli and others, and we are bound to admit that his working
models are of coarser texture and apparently less adapted to the
delicate reaction of protoplasm than the oil foams of his predeces-
sors. None the less, many of his experiments are interesting and
ingenious, and may serve a useful purpose in kindergarten science.
In the first essay, entitled ' Los Infusorios Artificiales,' he tries to
explain vibratile movements of cilia by means of elastic tubes con-
taining diffusible liquids and placed in other liquids. His idea
appears to be that osmosis currents between protoplasm and water
and the stresses produced in the elastic cell-wall set up the vibra-
tions. In the second essay, written in French, he describes a series
of experiments showing the reaction of elastic spherical bodies to
pressure by the elastic surfaces. He obtained a number of results
strikingly resembling known animal and plant forms. We com-
mend his essays to the curious.

370 NATURAL SCIENCE [December

A New Scientific Serial from Jamaica

As we briefly announced last month (p. 351), Jamaica furnishes us
with one more promising infant in an over-populated world of
scientific literature ! To such a new-born child it can scarcely be
said, " weeping thou sat'st while all around thee smiled," for, while
the infant chuckles, distracted naturalists shed inky tears. It
might sound rude to say that all such babes must come to the
workhouse. To the house in which the specialist works sooner or
later they have to come. If every name in the atlas of the world
insists upon having its own separate representative in serial scientific
literature, the wasteful dissipation of energy will increase in a
lamentable degree. The diligence of the student will be more and
more exhausted in a vain attempt to garner all the scattered
fragments of information, which may or may not be of value,
concerning each strictly limited branch of enquiry. It is, therefore,
only with a moderate rapture of welcome that we can greet this
first number of the Annals of the Institute of Jamaica.

The opening number is entirely devoted to a list of crustaceans.
Faunistic catalogues are not unfrequently a weary waste of mis-
applied industry. They often contain no guarantee whatever that
the author knows what he is writing about. When the identifica-
tions are original, they are as likely as not to be wrong ; when they
are borrowed, they are not ver}*- unlikely to be the endorsement of
some ancient error. Miss Eathbun's " List of the Decapod Crustacea
of Jamaica " stands on a different footing, because she happens to
combine with a very exact knowledge of the objects catalogued a
full and accurate acquaintance with the literature of the subject.
The list, therefore, is a critical list, and great confidence may be
placed in the names and synonyms and geographical distribution of
species which it records. But it also contains notes and descriptions
of independent importance. Some of these are quoted at full length,
though without marks of quotation, from earlier papers, while others
contain corrections of previously published opinions. Surely in the
interests of science the repetitions would have been better omitted,
and still more surely in the interests of science the corrections
would have better appeared in the Proceedings which published the
original statements.

While placing the highest value on Miss Rathbun's knowledge
and acumen, we cannot always accept her decisions on points of
nomenclature. The name Stenorynclius scticomis (Herbst) should
stand, whether Slabber were right or wrong in stating that his
specimen came from the East Indies. He appears to have kept his
East and West Indian crabs together, and may have made some
confusion, and if not, as the present list shows, the same species of

1897] NOTES AND COMMENTS 371

crab may occur in both the Indies. In naming Uca heterochela
(Lamarck), the change from Lamarck's more scholarly hetcrocltdos is
unneeded, since the Greek irs^jjXo; applies equally to the masculine
and feminine genders. In dealing with the genus Palaemon, Miss
Rathbun unhappily relies on Latreille's ' Considerations generates '
of 1810, a book with a long-winded title too troublesome to quote,
a book crowded with definitions that don't define, and endimr with
a list of types that are not described.

A Year-Book of Agriculture

The Year-Book of the U.S. Department of Agriculture for 1896
has just reached us, and set us wondering why we have not a
Department of Agriculture manned by scientific experts, which
might issue each year for the benefit of farmers and others in-
terested in the subject as much useful matter as is contained in
the six hundred odd pages of the Transatlantic publication. The
history of the year-book is this. It is the successor of the Agri-
cultural Beport which, in its original form, was made up almost
wholly of business reports for the use of Congress. When, how-
ever, it began to circulate more freely among farmers, papers on
agriculture, and discussions on the results of scientific investigations
were introduced, and it gradually became more and more a popular
report, business and executive matter being reduced to the smallest
possible proportion, till finally it was decided (in 1895) to issue
it in two parts — viz. (1) an executive and business report, (2) a
volume of papers " specially suited to interest and instruct the
farmers of the country," and to include also " a general report of
the operations of the Department for their information." This
second part is the Year-Book, and the one now before us is the
third of the series. It is published in an edition of 500,000 copies
for free distributing, and is therefore, as the assistant secretary
remarks in the preface, " in many respects unique." Following
the report of the Secretary, which occupies nearly fifty pages and
is eminently suggestive, are thirty papers (filling 500 pages) con-
tributed by nearly as many scientific expert members of the staff.
The 164 figures and six plates are a useful addition. Thus the
value of a paper on some common poisonous plants is much
enhanced by very passable pictures of the poison ivy {Rhusradicans),
water hemlock (Cicuta maculata), death cup {Amanita phaUoides),
and others. The same applies to some remarks by Mr Herbert
Webber on the influence of environment on plant varieties.
Enumeration of some of the titles will give an idea of the wide
scope of the Year-Book : — extermination of noxious animals by
bounties — potash and its function in agriculture — the country

372 NATURAL SCIENCE [December

slaughter-house as a factor in the spread of disease — the blue jay
and its food — migration of weeds — diseases of shade and orna-
mental trees — care of dairy utensils — and finally one by M. E.
Tisseraud, Councillor of State and Director of Agriculture of France,
entitled, An Ideal Department of Agriculture and Industries, which
is reprinted from a report of a House of Commons committee on
the establishment of a Department of Agriculture and Industries
for Ireland ! An appendix of one hundred pages includes an
account of the organisation of the Department of Agriculture,
copious statistics of crops, exports, imports, and numerous items
of useful information.

An Ideal Agriculture Department

We make no apology for remarks on Agriculture, which is only
practical Natural Science on a large scale, pursued for the best
possible object — the benefit of the race. In the paper to which we
have just referred M. Tisseraud raises certain points which are
worthy of emphasis. The agriculture of Europe, like an old and
leaking ship, tossed and buffeted on a sea of breakers, needs, to save
it from foundering, to be steered by abler hands and navigated by
pilots who will join to a thorough practical training a profound and
extensive knowledge — scientific knowledge. Hence the need for a
Ministry of Agriculture ; not a sort of Providence on which all may
lean, and which by a series of miracles can supply remedies for all
evils, nor a central authority which shall absorb all services and
assume the functions of private individuals and voluntary associa-
tions, but an authority which shall tend to awaken the spirit of
initiative and independence, and to stimulate and develop it among
the agriculturists themselves. M. Tisseraud refers to the methods
of control, in France, where by co-operation with local societies and
associations, the encouragement of private agricultural schools, and
the establishment, with the assistance of skilful farmers, of from
3000 to 4000 'champs de demonstration' each year, the State is
able to accomplish an enormous amount of good with a very little
expenditure.

Another task of a ministry of agriculture is to induce the most
eminent scientists to occupy themselves with agricultural questions.
It " must not be niggardly in its encouragements and subsidies to
such men. for their discoveries will repay, with large interest, the
expenditure which may have been incurred to enable them to carry
on their researches." By this means there will be prepared for
agriculture " an elite of men to direct it in the way of progress and
of the application of science." The Minister, in the nature of
things as at present constituted, must lie a politician, but not so

1897'

NOTES AND COMMENTS 373

the men at the head of the different divisions of the department,
who should unite to a great experience of administration profound
technical knowledge and an incontestable authority in the questions
with which they have to deal, and whose office should be of a per-
manent character. Such a director must have the choosing of the
stal't' placed under his orders. He must be their master, and be
able to reward those who show merit and zeal, and to remove or
punish those who cannot or do not properly discharge their duties.
" Let the director himself be absolutely responsible for the good
working of his department, and let him be replaced if he proves
inefficient." Finally, M. Tisseraud suggests the appointment of
scientific counsellors selected from the most distinguished agricul-
turists and men of science, and technical committees of professional
men, specialists, and practical experts, from whom the Minister may
obtain " trustworthy advice and indispensable light for rightly
seeing, and judging, and forming in full security the decisions
which concern the department over which he presides."

Catalogue of Fibre Plants

ANOTHER excellent specimen of the work of the United States De-
partment of Agriculture comes to hand almost while writing the
above. It is a descriptive list of useful fibre plants of the world by
C. E. Dodge, special agent in charge of fibre investigations. More
than a thousand kinds are enumerated under the botanical names of
the plants producing them, while common and native names are also
included in the alphabetical arrangement. The book is a large
octavo of 360 pages; there are more than one hundred figures
in the text, and thirteen excellent photographic plates showing the
habits of the various plants. Much information is given about the
more important kinds, including the structure and properties of the
actual fibre, the source and method of cultivation of the plant, the
preparation of the fibre, and references to the literature. The great
number of native names possessed by some species is evidence of
their long use. New Zealand flax (Phormium tenax), a liliaceous
plant, has nearly sixty native names. Captain Cook, who first
brought it to the notice of Europeans, found it in common us<
among the aboriginal New Zealanders ; he speaks of it as " a grass
plant like flags, the nature of flax or hemp, but superior in quality
to either, of which the natives make clothing, lines, etc." Mr Dodge
gives in a useful introduction a general account of the history,
chemistry, and structure of fibres, and suggests also a classification.
His system of arrangement serves to show what very various parts
of the plant are used for the purpose ; for it includes not only true

374 NATURAL SCIENCE [December

fibres derived from the wood or bast tissue respectively, but whole
stems, roots or leaves, or split and shredded leaves, as well as ex-
ternal hair-like growths, such as cotton, and also a class of " pseudo-
fibres." The last comprises certain mosses, like Sphagnum, used for
packing, seaweed wrought into lines or cordage, and the mycelium
of certain fun^i. The book will be a welcome addition to the
libraries of individuals and institutions interested in economic
botany. To enhance the value of future editions, the author
requests notes or further information on any fibre plants, and
especially photographs of foreign species.

Wing Neuration in the Lepidoptera

Mr A. Eadcliffe Grote has been insisting both in German (///.
Wochenschr. f. Entomologie, band II., no. 28), and in English (Entom.
Record, vol. ix., no. 10) on the advantage of employing photography
in the illustration of the wing-nervures of moths and butterflies, as
by this means only can absolute accuracy be ensured. British
entomologists will be specially interested by Mr Grote's severe
strictures on Mr Meyrick's descriptions and drawings of wing-
neuration in his revision of the Geometridae {Trans. Ent. Soc, 1892)
and his recent " Handbook of British Lepidoptera." Comparison of
Mr Meyrick's figures with the photographs have led Mr Grote to the
conclusion that in the former " the distances, relative direction, and
at times the point of origin are frequently all wrong. Worse than
this, Mr Meyrick supplies nervures which have no existence . . .
and omits nervures . . . which are distinct in nature." We await
with interest Mr Meyrick's reply to this criticism.

591.9 375

The Problems of the British Fauna

IN the current volume of Natural Science (pp. 223-4) appeared a
short editorial comment on my friend Dr E. F. Scharffs paper
on the Origin of the European Fauna.1 The Editor has misunder-
stood Dr Scharffs views in several particulars, and has nevertheless
expressed the fear that his "speculations will prejudice the use of
zoological distribution in geological investigations." As the prob-
lems raised are of great interest to all naturalists, a further
examination of the subject may perhaps be allowed. It is some-
what unfortunate that the present writer approaches the ques-
tion from the same standpoint as that of Dr Scharff- — zoological
geography. But it is to be hoped that some of the special students
of our Pliocene and Pleistocene deposits will, in due course, favour
us with their criticism.

The problems suggested by the fauna and flora of the British
Islands appeal in a marked degree to naturalists who live in Ireland,
especially if those naturalists happen to be English immigrants to
the sister isle. A botanist or a zoologist who has grown up in the
south of England, and has then transferred himself to Ireland, is
struck by the absence of many of his familiar wild friends, and the
presence of many forms of life hitherto unknown to him as British
species. The peculiarities of the Irish flora, such as the occurrence
of Pyrenean saxifrages and Mediterranean heaths in western Ireland,
have long been familiar to naturalists, and are discussed in the
classical memoir of Forbes.2 It may be well, however, to recall a
few of the corresponding facts regarding the fauna. The student of
vertebrates notices the absence, for example, from Ireland of the
Common Hare {Lepus europaeus), the Voles, the Mole, the Weasel, the
Polecat, the Nightingale, and all reptiles except the Viviparous Lizard.
The entomologist misses such conspicuous insects as the Stag-beetle
{Lucanus cervus), the great water beetle Hydrophilus piceus, and
the Large tortoiseshell butterfly {Vanessa pohjchloros). These are
representatives of a group of animals to which the present writer has
applied the term " Teutonic fauna,"3 while Dr Scharff, in his recent

1 Proc. E. Irish Acad. (3), vol. iv.,pp. 427-.r>14. An excellent summary appeared
in Nature of October 28th, 1897.

2 Mem. Geol. Survey Gt. Britain, vol. i., 1S46.

3 Jfuseums Assoc it. Report, 1894.

376 NATURAL SCIENCE [December

paper, designates the mammals among them as distinctively ' Eastern '
or ' Siberian.' The absence of these Siberian mammals from Ireland
may perhaps be regarded as the central fact on which his views con-
cerning the British fauna are founded. Most of the animals of this
group die out in Great Britain as one travels north or west. It must
be specially noted, however, that the mammals range over the greater
part of the island. The Common Hare extends from Cornwall to
the shores of the Pentland Firth ; the Weasel and the Viper range far
north into Scotland. But most of the corresponding invertebrates
are not found north of the Trent or west of the Severn.

Trie naturalist in Ireland is compensated for the loss of this
eastern fauna by the presence of two most interesting and distinct
sets of animals, almost unrepresented in the south-east of England.
It has been mentioned that the Common Hare is absent from
Ireland, but the Varying Hare {Lqms variabilis) occurs all over the
country, from north to south, both on the hills and in the plain.
This is a typically arctic and alpine animal, with a complete circum-
polar range, confined in Great Britain to the Highlands of Scotland.
Quite a number of insects, which in Great Britain are to be found
only in the north range to the extreme south of Ireland, such as
the marsh ringlet butterfly (Coenonympha typhon) and the ground-
beetles Carabus clatliratus and C. glabratus. But perhaps the most
striking example of this northern fauna is the ground-beetle
Pclophila borealis, which has been found in most of the northern
and western counties of Ireland, from Antrim to Kerry in the far
south-west. This beetle is, so far, unknown on the mainland of
Great Britain, but it occurs in the Orkneys ; on the continent it is
an inhabitant of high northern latitudes. Together with this arctic
and alpine group may be mentioned the three species of North
American fresh-water sponges, Ephydatia crateriformis, Hdero-
meycnia Byderi, and Tubella pennsylvanica, which Dr Hanitsch 1 has
lately described from lakes in western Ireland. These are com-
parable to the few North American plants which grow wild in the
same districts. One or two of the plants have Scotch stations ; but
both plants and sponges are unknown on the continent of Europe.

The second characteristic group of the Irish fauna — like the
peculiar plants of the western counties, the Arbutus, London Pride,
and St Dabeoc's Heath — shows striking affinity with the life of
south-western Europe and the Mediterranean region. Forbes, in
his memoir already referred to, expressed the opinion that no fauna
corresponding to this Hibernian flora exists in the British Isles.
Everyone, however, agreed in assigning to this type the Portuguese
slug, Geomalacus maculosus, when it was discovered spread over a
small area in counties Cork and Kerry. Recently a number of
1 Irish Nat., vol. iv., 1895, pp. 122-131.

1897] THE PROBLEMS OF BRITISH FAUNA :\77

animals have been recognised which undoubtedly show similar
faunistic relationships. Some of these are new discoveries, and
are apparently confined to Ireland, such as the millipede Pohy-
desmtis gallicus,1 the earthworms Allolobqphora veneta and A. georgii,-
and the weevil Otiorrhynchus auropunctatvs.* Others have long
been known as British animals, and their occurrence in the west of
Great Britain as well as in Ireland lias probably caused their
faunistic import to be overlooked. Such are the snail Helix pisana,
the wood-louse Platyarthrus hoffmanseggii, the ground beetle Eury-
iifbria complanata, and the weevil Mesites tardyi. Some of these
animals are found both in the east and west of Ireland, others only
on the east coast. In Great Britain they occur mostly in the
south-west, but the last-named is an example of a section which
ranges northward into western Scotland. Abroad all are charac-
teristic of southern and south-western Europe, while several are
found in the Azores, Madeira, and Canary Islands. It is most
important to take the foreign range into consideration when assign-
ing animals to a distributional type. Just as the Common Hare is
spread far to the north in Great Britain, as compared with many
other members of the ' Siberian ' fauna, so a number of animals
belonging to the South-western fauna range farther to the east than
the more typical species of the group. For instance, the slugs
of the genus Tcstacella must be referred to the South-western
section, when we consider the general range of the genus, though
some species occur in our eastern counties. And Dr Scharff would
add to this fauna many of our widely distributed species — the
Bullfinch among birds, for example.

He believes moreover that this South-western fauna merges
gradually into a ' South-central ' fauna, including the Badger
among mammals, and Helix virgata, H. acuta, and H. nemoralis
among snails. And to these combined southern groups he is
inclined to ascribe the bulk of the Irish animals, even those with
a wide range both in Ireland and in Great Britain ; except a few-
species that may have invaded the country since it became an
island — such as the white butterflies, Pieris brassicae and
P. rapae, and the ' painted lady,' Pyrameis cardui, or that have
been apparently introduced by man — such as the rats and the
house mouse.

A few remarks are necessary regarding the relative ages which
are to be ascribed to these different sections of the British fauna. The
South-western group, the most typical members of which are found
in the most remote parts of the country, with ranges often discon-
tinuous, are evidently the oldest. The ' Siberian ' animals, which

1 R. I. Pocock, Irish JYaL, vol. ii., pp. 309-312. 2 H. Friend, id., vol. v., pp. 69-73.

3 G. H. Carpenter, id., vol. iv., pp. 213-218.

2 D

378 NATURAL SCIENCE [December

are confined as a rule to eastern and south-eastern England, and
none of which have been able to reach Ireland, are clearly the
newest. The Northern animals must therefore come between these
two in regard to the time when they entered our area. It will be
remembered that Forbes, when discussing the distributional groups
of British plants, regarded the most western (' Hibernian ') flora as
the oldest, the ' Germanic ' flora as the newest, and the arctic and
alpine flora as of intermediate age. Forbes, however, considered
the plants of general British distribution to have entered the country
subsequently to the arctic and alpine species. And as he observed
that there is a gradual transition from the most typical ' Germanic '
to the most widely-spread ' British ' type, he regarded all the
immigrants since the Northern flora — that is to say the ' British,'
' English ' and ' Germanic ' types of Watson,1 as belonging to one
great central European flora, some of whose members have spread
much more widely in our islands than have others. Forbes, more-
over, separated two small groups of plants, one typical of Cornwall
and Devon (' Norman ' flora), the other characteristic of the chalk dis-
tricts of south-eastern England (' Kentish ' flora), which he believed
to be entirely distinct from the recent Germanic flora. To these
small sections he ascribed an age between that of the South-western
and that of the Northern flora.

Dr Scharff's estimate of the relative ages of the sections of the
British fauna differs from Forbes' view of the ages of the corre-
sponding sections of the flora in one important particular. While
Forbes placed the bulk of our widespread plants later than the
arctic and alpine species, Dr Scharff considers that — at least as
regards the species found in Ireland — the vast majority of the
animals are of southern origin, and not more recent than the arctic
and alpine species. As mentioned above, he believes that there is
a gradual transition from animals of the most typical ' Hibernian'
type, such as Geomalacus maculosus, to such widespread animals of
his ' South-central ' group as the Badger and the Fox.

The question of the exact geological period during which each
section of the fauna entered the British area, and by what route the
animals reached our territory, must now be considered. With regard
to the flora, Forbes believed that the Hibernian plants lived on a
now sunken Atlantis in Miocene times, and reached their present
Irish and Iberian stations from the west before the Ice Age. The
Cornish and Norman floras were supposed to have come into the
country from the south-west or south — of course across the dry area
of the Channel — also before the Ice Age. The arctic and alpine
plants, Forbes naturally thought to be the relics of the Glacial
Period itself. And he believed the rest of the British flora — the

1 " Cybele Britaunica," London, 1870.

18971 THE PROBLEMS OE BRITISH FAUNA 379

1 British,' ' English ' and ' Germanic ' types — to have entered the
country from the east and south-east across the dry area of the
North Sea and the Straits of Dover during the subsequent period
when the British territory had emerged from the Glacial sea, England
being united to the Continent, and Ireland to Great Britain.

At the time when Forbes wrote, the glacial deposits were
believed to have been laid down on the bed of a sea covered with
Moating ice. The subsequent adoption by the majority of geologists
of the theory that the Boulder Clay represents the ground moraine
of vast sheets of land ice has led most recent writers on the British
fauna and flora to regard most if not the whole of the living things
in our area as post-glacial immigrants. Whatever animals and
plants lived in these islands during Pliocene times are presumed
by Professor James Geikie, and those who share his views, to
have been exterminated by the terrible rigour of the glacial condi-
tions during the Pleistocene age. And the general view at present
is that it was not until the climate improved in later Pleistocene
times that the country again became the abode of animal and
vegetable life. On this theory it would seem certain that the
arctic and alpine species were the first to establish themselves in our
area.

Now, the results to which Dr ScharfF s studies have led him are
in startling opposition to the current opinion just mentioned. He
believes that, with the exception of the ' Siberian ' section, the
whole of the British fauna entered the country in Pliocene or the
earliest Pleistocene times. With regard specially to the Irish
fauna, he considers that all the animals which now inhabit Ireland
must have passed into that island in the Pliocene, or, at latest,
about the opening of the Pleistocene period, there being, in his view,
no evidence 'of any land-connection between England and Ireland
after that date. It is hardly necessary to recall the fact that the
absence of so many British animals and plants from Ireland has
led naturalists without exception to regard that country as an older
island than Great Britain, whatever geological age they may ascribe
to the fauna and flora.

It is specially the study of the past and present distribution of
the British mammals that has led Dr Scharff to his results. The
' Siberian ' mammals which are found — living or extinct — in Great
Britain, but not in Ireland, furnish, as has been said, the key to his
argument. Piemains of these mammals, preserved in the continental
Pleistocene deposits, enable the course of their migration from east
to west to be traced in considerable detail. They lived in Siberia in
Pliocene times, but in Europe their remains are not found except in
beds later than the Lower Boulder Clay, which Dr Scharff suggests
was laid down in the northern part of a sea connecting the

380 NATURAL SCIENCE [December

Caspian and Aral with the White Sea and the Baltic, thus forming
an effectual barrier to the westward course of the mammals. The
existence of such a sea is supported by the presence of arctic forms
of life in the Caspian, and the occurrence of the Caspian mollusc
Dreyssensia polymoiyha in the Lower Boulder Clay of Germany. As
this central European sea was replaced in part by a land surface,
the way was opened for the Siberian mammals to pass on into
western Europe. Now we are confronted with the startling fact that
the British deposit in which these mammals first appear is the
Forest Bed, usually considered the newest member of the Pliocene
series. Are we to suppose, Dr Scharff asks, that the animals made
their way into England by Asia Minor, Greece and ►Southern
Europe, and so reached our shores before Central Europe was open
to them ? That part of the older southern fauna — the ' South-
Central ' section — travelled into Western Europe by this route from
Siberia during Pliocene times he does believe. But, he argues, it
is impossible that the true ' Siberian ' animals could have passed
that way, seeing that their remains are entirely absent from South
European, as well as from Irish, Scottish and Scandinavian, deposits.
He is therefore driven to the conclusion that the Forest Bed and
other British deposits usually classed as Newer Pliocene must be
considered as rather later than the Lower Continental Boulder Clay,
and reckoned to be of Pleistocene age. In support of this correla-
tion he also brings forward the presence of arctic shells in the newer
crags.1

Having thus fixed the period when these Siberian mammals
appeared in England, Dr Scharff believes that he has obtained the
latest possible date for the ' last link ' of the land-connection be-
tween England and Ireland. For if the way into Ireland remained
open long after these mammals reached English territory, what can
have prevented their onward course to the western island ? The
wide range of the mammals as compared with the restricted range
of the invertebrates of the same faunistic section has been dwelt
upon in the opening part of this paper. It is certain that the vast
number of widespread invertebrates that inhabit Ireland as well as
Great Britain must have passed over the Irish Se,/ when it was a
lake and river valley, or crossed the later northern isthmus which
joined northern Ireland to south-western Scotland. But as the
Siberian mammals were kept out of Scotland by the Pleistocene sea,
this northern isthmus may be left out of reckoning as far as they
are concerned. If the slowly-moving army of spiders, beetles, snails

1 The reader is referred to Dr ScharfFs paper for the numerous references supporting
these positions. It will he seen that the editorial statements of Dr SchartFs views
{supra, p. 224, "that the lower continental boulder clay is Pliocene . . . that the
Siberian mammals migrated into Western Europe to the south of this sen ") convey the
exact reverse of the opinions really advocated by the author.

1897] THE PROBLEMS OF BRITISH FAUNA 381

imd slugs did not invade Ireland until after the Siberian mammals
were in England, why were the latter unable to reach Ireland as
well? Such, briefly, is Dr ScharfFs argument for the pre-Glacial
immigration of the Irish fauna.

Turning to the Northern section of the fauna, Dr Scharff argues
that it must have entered Scotland by a land-connection from Scan-
dinavia,, ami so passed southwards into Ireland. This land-connec-
tion he believes, in common witli most geologists, to have been
■continued northwards to Spitsbergen, and westward to Greenland
and North America. Thus a way was open for animals with a
circumpolar range to wander southwards, while North American
forms were able to invade Western Europe. The continuous coast-
line to the north of the Atlantic, shutting off that ocean from the
Arctic Sea, must have ensured a mild climate to its waters and
shores. The vast majority of geologists would, of course, regard this
land-connection and the migrations which passed over it as post-
glacial. Dr Scharff, necessarily considering the northern fauna
older than the Siberian, believes, on the contrary, that its entry into
our area must be put back to the time when the ice-laden sea of the
Lower Boulder Clay covered Central Europe and the newer crags were
being laid down in eastern England. The land-connection between
Scandinavia and Ireland he considers, however, to have persisted
into late Pleistocene times.

It has already been mentioned that the bulk of the Irish fauna
is supposed by Dr Scharff to have come from South-western and
South-central Europe, and that the more western section is regarded
by him (as the corresponding section of the flora was regarded by
Forbes) as the oldest section of the whole British fauna. Dr Scharff
does not share Forbes' view of an extensive Atlantic continent ; he
believes that a western continental coast-line, including, of course,
.a tract to the west of the present British and Irish area, meets all
the requirements of the facts. Across the valleys which occupied
the present beds of the English and St George's Channels the animals
of these southern migrations passed into Great Britain and Ireland ;
.according to Dr Scharff, through the Pliocene and up to the earliest
Pleistocene period. But the land-connection between Great Britain
and Ireland broke down in the south sooner than in the north, so
that the arctic migration could go on after the southern migrations
had been cut off. Some of the animals of the ' South-central '
migration are traced by Dr Scharff back to Siberia, where he believes
they originated. He points out, moreover, that the same species
•can sometimes be proved to have taken part both in the ' South-
central ' and in the (later) true ' Siberian ' migration. In such
cases, however, a distinct race of the species usually characterises
each migration. For example, the Irish race of the Pied Deer is the

382 NATURAL SCIENCE [December

small-antlered form which can be traced, by its remains in south
European beds, from Western Asia into Greece, and " along the
borders of the Mediterranean, at the time when Corsica and Sardinia
were still connected with Sicily and Greece on the one hand and
with Tunis on the other." In this wav it is suggested that animals
from western Asia and south-eastern Europe found their way to
the western edge of the continent, while the central European plain
was still covered by sea.

If Dr Scharffs views as to the geological periods during which
the British fauna entered the country be accepted, it follows that
the vast majority of our animal population must have survived the
rigours of the Ice Age ; as regards Ireland, the whole fauna (ex-
cept comparatively modern immigrants) must have lived in the area
from a time before the deposition of the British Lower Boulder Clay.
It will be remembered that Forbes, who believed the distinctive-
South-western flora to be pre-glacial, suggested that the plants sur-
vived in a sunken land to the south-west. Dr Scharff, however,,
rejects the idea of such an asylum for the fauna on the ground that
the south-western corner of Ireland is remarkably poor in species,,
many forms of life, common throughout the rest of the island,
being absent from the peninsulas of counties Cork and Kerry ; fur
example, the Helices of the sub-genus Xcwphila. He insists that
portions at least of the present Irish area must have been able to-
support the present animal population throughout the Pleistocene
period.

Those geologists who adopt the extreme view of the glaciation
of Ireland, advocated by the Bev. M. H. Close, and accepted by
Professor Hull,1 will naturally reject Dr Scharff's conclusions with
decision, if not with derision. For, according to the opinion of this
school, an ice-sheet of great depth covered the whole country. It is
needless to say that Dr Scharff rejects with equal decision the
existence of such an ice-sheet. In the closing section of his paper,
he expresses his agreement with those geologists who believe that
the Boulder Clay was formed in an ice-laden sea, and not as the
ground-moraine of vast glaciers. Of course, this view requires the
submergence of much of the country. But, recalling the opinion
of several geologists that the western margin of the British area
stood higher in relation to the eastern during the Glacial Period than
now, Dr Scharff reconstructs the physical geography of our islands
during that time of greatest submergence, which left shell-bearing
gravels on the Dublin mountains and Moel Tryfaen. According to
his map, the Scottish highlands, the Hebrides, and northern, western,,
and southern Ireland formed a peninsula still continuous witli
Scandinavia ; the Scottish lowlands and northern England were an.

1 " The Physical fieology and Geography of Ireland," London, 1878.

1897] THE PROBLEMS OF BRITISH FAUNA 383

archipelago ; central and southern Wales an island ; while the south
and midlands of England were joined to France by an isthmus. The
sea covered nearly the whole of eastern England, and stretched across
north Wales, and over eastern and central Ireland. Zoological
evidence for this transgression of the northern sea over eastern
Ireland is found in the distribution of the arctic marine crustacean
3fysis rdicta, which forms part of the ' relic fauna ' not only of the
Swedish lakes, but also of Lough Neagh. The sea separating
southern and central England from Scotland, as well as from
Ireland, checked the northern as well as the western progress of
the ' Siberian ' mammals. None of these animals are found fossil in
Scottish Pleistocene deposits, though the recession of the glacial sea
has in recent times opened a way to the north, of which the sur-
viving species have availed themselves. But meanwhile the isthmus
between Scotland and Ireland had become broken through.

Having thus put forward a summary of Dr Scharff's views as to
the ages and paths of migration of the various sections of the British
fauna, I venture, with some diffidence, to offer a few observations
and suggestions. I entirely agree with Dr Scharff in considering the
South-western as the oldest section of our fauna, and I have no
doubt that it came into our area long before the Glacial Period.
The North American plants and animals seem to me to be more
ancient than Dr Scharff is inclined to admit. He classes them
with the general Northern fauna, but I believe that their very
restricted and discontinuous ranges along the extreme western margin
of Europe mark them as decidedly older than those northern animals
and plants which have a general circumpolar distribution.

Study of the distribution of British insects shows that there is a
Southern fauna1 distinct from the South-western, in that its members
occur generally in southern Britain, as well as in Ireland and
western Britain, and have a wide continental range. It is clearly
newer than the South-western fauna, yet the fact that it is confined
in Ireland to the south and west suggests that it is of considerable
geological age. Along the west coast of Ireland the insects of this
group often range some distance to the north, and their general
British distribution around the west and south of our islands renders
it likely that they held the country west and south of the area where
the Glacial deposits were being formed, and have, since the retroces-
sion of the agent which produced those deposits, been unable to
spread far eastwards in Ireland or northwards in Great Britain. This
fauna may safely be regarded as comparable to Forbes' Norman and
Kentish floras, and older than the Arctic fauna. As yet, however,
I am not prepared to accept so great an antiquity for the bulk of

1 Examples of this group are the ground-beetles, Carnbus cancellatus and Panagaeus
cru.r-major, the butterflies Gonepteryx rhamni, and Leplida sinapis, and the moths Zeuzera
pyrina and Stauropus fagi.

384 NATURAL SCIENCE [December

the widespread Irish animals as Dr Scharff claims by referring them
to his ' South-central ' group.

I quite agree with Dr Scharff in rejecting the theory that the
whole of our fauna is post-Glacial, since that theory would require
us to regard the Arctic animals as the oldest, whereas the distribu-
tional facts require us to consider the South-western section the
oldest. But it seems to me that we are equally bound to consider
the animals of the Northern fauna — restricted as they are to the
hill regions and the west — as more ancient than the widespread
species which form the dominant element in our fauna to-day. I
am quite prepared to believe that many of these widespread species
inhabited the southern part of our area throughout Pleistocene times,
but it seems unlikely that they extended their range far to the
north or west until the glacial conditions had passed awTay. Dr
Scharff apparently believes that, the glacial deposits being due to a
marine submergence, sufficiently extensive land tracts must have
been left to enable the whole fauna to survive. But even many
geologists who reject the theory that the Boulder Clay is a ground
moraine, consider that the polished and scratched rock-surfaces
beneath that deposit are evidences of a former extension of land-ice.
In the opening paragraphs of his paper, Dr Scharff makes the
suggestive remark that the study of the fauna of a single island is
the best starting-point for the study of a continental fauna. Hence
he takes Ireland as the key to the greater problem of Europe. It
seems likely that considerable light would be thrown on the special
British problem by one of the smaller British islands, and I believe
that in the Isle of Man we have evidence of a post-Glacial land-
connection between Ireland and western England. Professor Carvill
Lewis x and Mr Percy F. Kendall 2 found traces of glaciation up to
the summit of the highest hills in the island, the former remarking
that the whole shape of Snaefell is that of a ' roche moutonnt^e.'
Whether we believe with these geologists that the ' Irish Sea
glacier ' passed over the summit of Snaefell, or prefer to consider
the high-level drifts, boulders, and striated rock-surfaces as evidences
of an ice-laden sea, it seems equally certain that the present in-
habitants of Man must have reached that isle since the climax of
tin; Glacial Period.

Now the fauna of the Isle of Man ^sembles on the whole that
of Ireland, western England, and Wales. Its cliffs form the most
northern station for certain species of moths, such as Dianthoecia
luteago var. barrcttii, D. cacsia and D. ccqjsojjhila , some of which are
scattered along the western British and the eastern ami southern
Irish coasts as far as Land's End and Dingle Bay. If the Isle
of Man could not have supported any fauna during the height of

1 "Glacial Geology of Great Britain and Ireland," p . 3f>7-!>. 2 Op. cit., pp. 433-4.

1897] THE PROBLEMS OF BRITISH FAUNA 385

the Glacial Period, we are forced to the conclusion that its shores
must, since then, have formed part of the northern coasts of a
gulf opening to the south, down St George's Channel. As the
climatic conditions improved, I believe that many animals of the
old South-western fauna — such as Helix piscina, Euryncbria com-
planctfdj Otwrrhynchus auropunctatus — which had doubtless lived to
the south of England and Ireland from Pliocene times, were able
to make their way northwards along the shores of this ever-widen-
ing gulf to their present stations on the eastern Irish and western
British shores. North of this gulf, I believe that the vast majority
•of our present widespread species passed from north-western Eng-
land into Ireland, where they have spread from east to west. The
difficulty raised by Dr Scharff that the ' Siberian ' mammals were
in England, and should have passed over to Ireland with the rest,
is doubtless serious. But these mammals were kept out of Scotland
until recent times, and they may well have been kept out of north-
western England by an arm of the sea until the Irish land-con-
nection had broken down. One of them, the English Hare, inhabits
the Isle of Man, showing that the barrier which confined them to
the east had been removed in time for that one species to spread so
far, though not as far as to Ireland. The fact that the other
mammals of the group — -such as the Voles and the Mole — are
absent from the Isle of Man proves that the Hare must have made
the most of her chance to spread north-westward.

While, then, I find myself in almost complete agreement with
Dr Scharff with regard to the older sections of our fauna, I think
that those widespread species which survived the Glacial Period
must have been confined to the more southern parts of our area, and
have only subsequently spread northwards and westwards to Scot-
land and Ireland. Doubtless the speculations of the extreme glacial
school regarding the total extinction of all life in our countries in
Pleistocene times need revision in the light of the past and present
•distribution of species. At the same time there seems enough
agreement among those who have specially studied the drift
■deposits to warn students of animal distribution that the conditions
over much of the British Islands must have been unfavourable to
the presence of a rich flora and fauna.

But in any case it seems to us a necessity to believe that a
considerable proportion of the British flora and fauna did survive
the Glacial Period in our area, or in the now submerged tracts
adjacent thereto. Readers of Natural Science will doubtless recall
Mr G. W. Bulman's paper,1 in which a plea was entered for the
pre-Glacial age of our animals and plants on the ground that no
geological evidence of an elevation subsequent to the Ice Age could

1 Vol. iii., pp. 261-6.

3S6 NATURAL SCIENCE [December

be brought forward. Neither of the rival glacial theories requires
belief in the annihilation of all living things in our area. On the
land-ice hypothesis there must have been a now submerged tract
bordering on the Atlantic, and stretching beyond the present
south coast of Ireland, which the late Professor Carvill Lewis recog-
nised as an unglaciated area. A similar elevation to the west of
our present British islands is believed to have accompanied the
submergence by which the other school of geologists explain the
Pleistocene deposits. And it is generally agreed that the south
and, in part at least, the midland areas of England were free from
glacial conditions. When we remember how distinctly temperate
and even sub -tropical forms of life can be found to-day close to
areas of glaciation, it must be admitted that there is no impossibility
in the suggestion that the ancestors of the older plants and animals
which we now see around us witnessed in our territory the coming
and passing away of the age of ice.

Geo. H. Carpenter.

507 387

The Provincial Museum

WHAT may fitly be called the provincial museum question
has of late rapidly assumed considerable importance.
The need for these institutions or the enthusiasm of their staff
is not called in question ; as a matter of fact, it is in a great measure
to the energy of provincial curators, as manifested at meetings of
the Museums' Association, that much of the present awakening is
due. The evils from which these museums suffer are acknowledged
to be a general lack of means, undermanning, and a partially or
wholly untrained staff. The widespread attention which the subject
receives even from the lay mind is evidence of a knowledge that
better things are possible, and that a satisfactory settlement will
tend to the public good and educational progress. The museum
question has hitherto been attacked in two ways. The late Dr
Goode in America, and Sir W. H. Flower in this country, have
laboured alike to educate the public mind to the value and necessity
of these institutions as factors in education, and to direct and
stimulate museum workers. The second form of attack has been
made by Professor Petrie (Brit. Assoc, Liverpool), and more recently
by the editorial comments of Natural Science (Vol. xi., No. 66, Aug.
1897). It may be defined as the suggestion of remedial measures.
The addresses and papers of Sir W. H. Flower and Dr Goode have
undoubtedly done much to pave the way for better progress, but
before the remedial measures which are now advocated can be
made effective or adequate to the needs of provincial museums, it will
be necessary to consider fully their present position as a whole.

Even a brief consideration of the provincial museum reveals
much that is anomalous and unsatisfactory. Hardly any two can
be said to work upon a common plan, whilst most develop and
exist rather as the sport of circumstances than as the outcome of
definite purpose and design. We much doubt if one can be pointed
out which has an income at all equal to its needs, or which is able
to develop and maintain its various sections according to their true
value and proportion.

We find also that Government recognition is accorded to pro-
vincial museums in a vague and half-hearted manner. The Libraries
and Museums Act can be put into operation if the people of a

388 NATURAL SCIENCE [December

borough demand it, but the operation of the act is dependent upon
the action of the very people who are most needing instruction by
museum agency. Not infrequently the act is put into operation to
gain a library, and a museum of ill-assorted material grows up with
it, by a system of accretion rather than assimilation. Indeed, it is
this accretionary growth for want of a defined plan which is the bane
of provincial museums, and one which the curators themselves are at
present powerless to prevent. Further, museums are recognised by
the Educational and Science and Art Departments in that attend-
ance at a museum by school children and science students is, under
certain conditions, allowed to count as class attendance, and specimens
are loaned to them from the Art collection of South Kensington.

It has followed from the operation of causes such as those in-
dicated that a type of museum has arisen throughout the country
which justifies the charge of ill-conceived, lacking in proportion,
wanting in utility and inadequately supported and staffed. If we
bear the present conditions in mind, and consider the proposed
remedies, it is manifest at once that the utmost difficulty would be
experienced in the attempt to create a federal staff of scientific ex-
perts on the lines which have been advocated by Professor Petrie.
The museums are so unequal, their sections vary so strangely, both in
ratio to one another and in their value, that the attempt to send to
a series of museums a number of specialists, devoting equal amounts
of time to each, would result in confusion and failure.

The first plan suggested in the editorial comment of Natural
Science of August last is practically that of Professor Petrie, with
the added proviso that the specialists should be resident, one at each
museum, whilst the same round of visits was maintained. Other
considerations apart, municipal jealousies would effectually kill the
scheme.

The second plan is delightful by reason of its naive character
rather than its practicability. The visits of specialists from the
Government museums are red-letter days to the provincial curator,
valuable alike for the rare good fellowship meted out to the humbler
brother in science, for the gratuitous work done, and the remarkable
stimulus and enthusiasm imparted; but that the arrangement and
scientific work of provincial museums should be left to the staff of
Government museums, increased in numbers for the purpose, is a
plan hardly likely to commend itself to the provincial curator or his
governors, and even less likely to Parliament, which would need to
be approached to decide the question.

There is much in each plan that is admirable, but after all they
are in the nature of makeshifts rather than a solution of the
question. What seems to be needed is a thorough grapple with
flii; whole question of museum development, and (to borrow a

1897 J THE PROVINCIAL MUSEUM 381)

sentence from Natural Science) of the means of "co-ordination, in-
vestigation, and effective utilisation of all our obscured scientific and
artistic material," together with the creation of means by which those
aspiring to take up curatorial work may receive a thorough training.
A somewhat rough-and-ready classification of provincial museums
seems to indicate naturally a string of suggestions which might
possibly be elaborated into a workable and effective scheme. At
present provincial museums may, we think, be placed in three or
four classes as follows : —

T. Museums of University Colleges, and of large cities possess-
ing large collections and a trained staff.
IT. Museums of important manufacturing centres, or county
towns, with usually fair collections and a self-educated
staff.

III. Museums of small towns, and of scientific societies which

are managed by honorary curators, or once arranged and
afterwards left unaltered in the hands of a care-taker.

IV. Museums under the Libraries and Museums Act which are

managed by the librarian in addition to his own work,
outside help being obtained from time to time. Some of
these museums rank in importance with those of Class II.

That a relative importance of provincial museums exists such as
that implied in this classification will, we think, be admitted, and
upon this assumption the following suggestions are formulated as a
means of bringing about that co-ordination and improvement of
museum development which is so much desired.

Suggested Plan

I. Creation of an annual museums' grant by Government in aid
of provincial museums of the first class, the sum allotted to each
being determined by considerations similar to those which guide the
application of the present University Colleges' Grant.

Upon the strength of such a grant the Government could charge
each museum with a definite scope of work and the attainment and
retention of a certain standard of excellence.

For example, a museum might be called upon as a condition of
receiving the grant to have special aims such as the following : —

(a) The specific task of investigating and demonstrating by col-

lections the natural history, &c, of a defined geographical
area of which the museum would be the centre.

(b) The formation and continued progress of a good general

collection suited to the needs of the area served by the
museum.

390 NATURAL SCIENCE [December

completeness.

(d) An adequate staff.

Means could be devised by which certain of the museums in
classes II. and IV. could be raised to the standard of class I., so that,
speaking generally, the country would become parcelled out into
areas, in each of which a museum was maintained, in constant good
order, and ministering in a special as well as a general manner to
the needs of the population.

II. Remaining museums might be subsidised through the agency
of County Councils, upon certificates of efficiency and progress re-
ceived annually from an accredited visitor, who might be an official
of the Government or of one of the first-class museums.

Great help would be rendered to the curators of small museums
if, as a condition of the subsidy, a member of the staff of the first-
class museum had a seat and vote upon the committee. Such a po^t
might well be honorary, and would be analogous to that which
obtains in the case of certain Grammar Schools, a governor serving
upon the board by appointment from one of the larger Colleges or
Universities.

III. The small museums might be grouped around the larger
according to locality and function, and by means of a nominal con-
tribution to the funds of the larger have a claim for help and
direction.

The advantages, if a scheme of this sort be applied to the whole
country, might be dealt with at considerable length, but it will be
less likely to confuse if we narrate briefly what we consider to be
the chief.

Museums' aims, management, and development would become
organised throughout the country, and lead at the outset to the
abolition of a needless overlapping where several museums exist in
a large town or city under different management.

More museums of the first class would be created, and the
curators of county museums, and students generally, would find help
nearer at hand than at present. The conditions of existence of the
large museums would require that the systematic study of the fauna,
flora, &c, of large districts be prosecuted with diligence and the
salient features of each being demonstrated in the museum collections.
The whole would necessarily become of prime importance to the
public, a permanent memorial of the scientific value of the area
served, and of great usefulness to the specialist and the nation.

The small museums might have a similar charge, though, of
course, in a smaller and more localised degree, whilst being also re-
quired to maintain a good type-collection suited to the wants of the
population.

1897] THE PROVINCIAL MUSEUM 391

Museums would be brought into direct communication with each
other, and the transference of specimens to centres where they would
be of most use would be immensely facilitated, while the small
museums would naturally become agents of supply of material
obtainable in their districts. The whereabouts of material for the
specialist would be better known, and be more readily available.

The linking up and increased usefulness of provincial museums
would provide a healthy stimulus to local scientific societies, would
result in increased and more thorough field work, and do much to
aid that federation of remote scientific workers which is so desirable.
Moreover, it must not be forgotten that such a chain of museums
offers the best means whereby the collections of the humblest and
most distant worker might be conveyed to the one best fitted to
deal with them.

The plan we advocate is crude, but designedly so, for elaboration
provokes criticism of detail rather than of principles, and it is the
latter which are all-important to determine in connection with the
present phase of the provincial museum question.

Herbert Bolton.

576.3

"' 9 2 [December

III

Cell or Corpuscle ?

/^~\NE of the youngest and most vigorous among the sciences is
^S that which has been named Cytology.

Its strength, in all probability, is due to the fact that it has
sprung from a broad foundation, and that it still rests, not upon oner
but many pillars of support. The botanist, the zoologist, the physi-
ologist, divergent from one another as their daily walks unfortunately
are, yet agree to join hands over the common basis of their sciences
— the organic cell.

With such splendid results already gathered into its encompass
and with the hope and promise of such a brilliant future before it, it
is all the more to be regretted that the language of Cytology is not
only in contradiction to common sense, but such that it must assuredly
lead to endless perplexities.

The word cell, the very watchword of the science, is one that in
this mouth means one thing, in that quite another.

Dealing with the lower plants, the botanist will speak of the
' swarmspores ' as cells, whilst when he turns to the phanerogams
he will apply the same term to the elements of cork or sclerenchyma,
notwithstanding the fact that the former consist of protoplasm and
nucleus without a cell wall, whilst the latter are composed of cell
walls without either protoplasm or nucleus.

Such inexactitude as this, such a want of definite expression,
must hang as a burden around the neck of the science, impeding its
progress at every turn.

More especially is it from the side of the student of vegetable
life that this confusion is felt, the zoologist, although he uses the
word cell in a sense which stands in flat contradiction to its every-
day meaning, yet attaches a significance to it which is clear and
precise in his own mind.

However desirable, therefore, it may be for a more common sense
terminology to be introduced into zoology as well as botany, it is not
absolutely essential for scientific advance. When it is remembered
also that any change of nomenclature in this respect must involve
with difficulties the immense mass of zoological literature which has
gathered together since 1839, it should make us pause before we
suggest giving up the word cell, in the zoological sense, in favour of
energid or biophor.

897J CELL OR CORPUSCLE? 393

It seems to me that there are only two possible ways of reform
open to us, and both are accompanied with grave difficulties.

We may introduce that change from the word cell to that of
energid (Sachs) or biophor (Hansen), which, it has already been
pointed out, will bring countless troubles with it in respect to the old
and classical literature ; or we may effect an alteration in nomencla-
ture within the science of botany itself. Retaining the word cell to
express protoplasm and nucleus, we may bring in a new name for the
cell wall minus its living contents. Here also great confusion would
result to the older writings, but the confusion would be within a
more limited sphere. As we have already mentioned, it is in the
province of the vegetable kingdom that the difficulties with regard
to the meaning of the term 'cell' have arisen, and in reading the
older memoirs we are frequently brought to a pause to enquire
whether it is cell-wall or living cell-contents that are being referred
to under the name of cell. The perplexities accompanying a substi-
tute for the word cell in its significance of cell-membrane would,
therefore, not be so heavily felt as those associated with a new word
for the protoplasmic contents. The changes involved would be heavy
within their sphere (it is not simply the word cell but the compound
expressions which have been formed from it which would have to give
place to the new order of things), but still this range would be a
fairly limited one. It would be only the single science of botany,
already perplexed with difficulties of meaning and not the additional
provinces of zoology and animal (and human) physiology, which are
clear in their use of the word, which would suffer from the innova-
tion. What substitute might be employed for the word cell in its ap-
plication to the membrane and the cavity included by it, is not easy
to see — perhaps the word ' vesicula ' is not altogether inappropriate,
but if changes on these lines should ever prove applicable, it will
then be time enough to look about for a new term.

The first alternative, which was mentioned above, is the one
which hitherto has alone been dealt with by biologists.

Sachs, in his two notes in Flora (1892, 1895), has proposed
to call the nucleus, together with the protoplasm governed by it at
any time, an energid. If such an energid be included within a
membrane it is to be spoken of as a cell. The distinguishing
characteristic of an energid is the living element (protoplasm and
nucleus), whilst that of a cell is the membrane.

From this point of view, therefore, the swarmspore of Ulothria
is an energid, whilst immediately that it forms a wall around itself
it reaches the further dignity of a cell : the elements of cork tissue
are also cells. In plants of the type of Vaucheria the protoplasm
is studded with nuclei, and the whole mass is enclosed within a single
cell-membrane. Each nucleus may be conceived as exerting its in-

2 E

394 NATURAL SCIENCE [December

fiuence over a limited area of protoplasm, and ruler and ruled may
together be mentally mapped off as a unit. The body of Vaucheria
can therefore be described as consisting of a number of units — the
energids — enclosed within a single cell wall.

Quite lately another small work dealing with these matters has
been written by Dr Adolph Hansen, Professor of Botany at the
University of Giessen.1

That part of the little book which deals with the ' Geschichte '
is most carefully and judiciously written, and it at the same time
has a life and vigour in its sentences that fire our enthusiasm for
the subject. When we turn to the latter pages of the pamphlet in
which the ' Kritik ' is embodied, it awakens very mixed feelings
within us. It sets us thinking, which is a good thing, but nowhere
does it bring conviction with it. Where the views are most de-
finitely stated we feel the greatest doubt, and where the arguments
should be the most irresistible we are the least convinced.

Glancing at what is written on pp. 50-58, we see that the
zoological definition, if I may so term it, of a cell is taken as the
starting-point of the argument. The zoologist {e.g. Professor Oscar
Hertwig) defines a cell as a little mass of protoplasm that includes
a nucleus within its substance.

From this point of view Hansen maintains that the general
assertion ' that plants are composed of cells ' is untenable, since the
larger mass of them is built up of cell-walls ; moreover, whilst a
naked swarmspore may be correctly named a cell, it ceases to be
such immediately that it forms a wall around its surface.

In considering these statements we must first ask whether it is
really a general assertion that ' plants are composed of cells.' I do
not think so. I myself, and all whom I have ever heard, have
always, both in animal and plant histology, stated that the plant or the
animal, as the case may be, consists of cells and the products of
cells. Our author meets this qualification in part, perhaps, by saying
that those who assert that plants consist of cells (in the zoological
sense) approach the difficulties in the above cases by regarding the
membrane as ' secondary ' or ' unessential,' and in that case he goes
on to argue how are we to look upon Caulerpa, whose whole form
and existence is determined by the cell- wall ?

Secondary and unessential the cell-wall certainly is, however,
when we compare it with the protoplasm and nucleus.

The latter determine whether a structure is living or dead ; the
former merely influences the manner of life.

Caulerpa as a genus is undoubtedly dependent on the presence
of a membrane, but Caulerpa as a living thing is due to the co-

1 " Zur Geschichte and Kritik <les Zcllcnbegritfes in der Botanik," yon Dr Adolph
Hansen. Giessen: .1. Kicker, 1897.

1897] CELL OR CORPUSCLE ? 395

existence of protoplasm and nuclei. Hansen cannot maintain that
the fibres and inorganic parts of a bone are not ' secondary ' in im-
portance when placed side by side with bone corpuscles, and yet
the whole form and existence, nay, the whole use of the bone,
depends upon their presence.

Another, and perhaps even more analogous case, is furnished by
the elastic fibres of certain ligaments (Ligamentum nuchae) : the
whole existence of these bands is justified by the elastic fibres they
contain, and yet when valued against the protoplasmic corpuscles
upon which their origin depends, these fibres must be relegated to a
' secondary ' place.

The white connective tissue fibres, the elastic fibres, and the
vegetable membranes are all of enormous importance in the phylo-
genetic development of the organism ; without them neither animals
nor plants would ever have been able to rise above the state of mere
flabby masses of protoplasm of limited size, but that which stands
higher than race development, the existence of life is interwoven
with the protoplasm and its nucleus. It is only compared with this
high standard that we dare speak of the membrane of plants as
' unessential ' or ' secondary.' When Hansen, however, a few lines
further on, indicates that those who use these two words when
speaking of the cell-wall do so alternatively with the expression of
' no importance,' he altogether misunderstands their position.

The next few pages are occupied with a criticism, more or less
destructive, of Sachs' views on energids ; this is followed by a pro-
posed improvement. The word energid shall be dropped ; in such
cases as the Siphoneae the separation of energids is artificial, and
therefore to be avoided ; in its place the whole contents of a single
membrane, or the whole mass of a membraneless organism, shall be
named a ' biophpr,' whether this be uni- or multi-nuclear. "When a
* biophor ' is enclosed by a wall it becomes a cell. " The cell," he
adds, " consists always of a biophor and a membrane." When,
therefore, a few lines further, he says that with the adoption of this
nomenclature there is no reason why the elements of wood or cork
should not be named cells — cells that have lost their biophors —
certain inconsistencies of statement become apparent. Dr Hansen
himself points out that the name biophor has already been used by
Weismann in quite another sense. I cannot think that it would
be wise therefore to employ it in this new relation, as even suppos-
ing Weissmann's biophors do not prove all that was hoped of them,
they certainly will take a permanent historical value, and fresh
troubles will appear on the horizon in consequence.

Although the last eight pages of Hansen's pamphlet seem to me
to be open to criticism, the fifty foregoing pages can only give
pleasure and satisfaction to those who read them.

96 NATURAL SCIENCE [December

The historical account of the cell theory is one of the best that
has been written for a very long time, and the frequent apt quota-
tions from and references to the original memoirs breathe a spirit of
life into the story which one only seldom finds in these retrospective

writings.

Before leaving the subject of reform by change in the name of
• protoplasm plus nucleus ' it may be mentioned that if a new term
is to be given to these parts, a more justifiable one than energid is
that of ' corpuscle.' It is a name which is already used in this
sense by the zoologist: he speaks of the white blood corpuscle, the
bone corpuscle, etc., and its introduction into botany would be far
from insurmountable. To speak of a swarmspore as a ' corpuscle '
would be both common sense and simple. The membrane which
this ' corpuscle ' manufactures might be termed a ' cell,' and we
should be speaking both logically and intelligibly when we spoke of
the ' corpuscle ' which lies within the ' cell ' when we dealt with an
element of the cambium, or if we spoke of an aggregate of corpuscles
lying within the cell when we treated of Vauchcria. When the
elements of cork came into view they would be cells pure and
simple.

If a collective name for the living contents of a cell be required
we might resort to the terminology which has already been employed
by Professor Strasburger. A corpuscle, in the above sense, might be
described as consisting of cytoplasm and nucleus, and the name
protoplasm be applied to the cytoplasm or the nucleus, or both
together, whether one nucleus or many, or none, were associated
with the cytoplasm.

In what has been written above I only wish to throw out a
few rough suggestions which may perhaps help the cytologist in a
small degree as he gropes in the darkness for the right path.

It is either the wall of the cell or the living contents of the cell
which must be re-named. , If it be the former the difficulty will
fall upon the shoulders of the botanist but leave the zoologist
unharmed ; if the latter, much depends upon the nature of the
alteration.

If we radically change things by bringing into use a new name'
(energid, biophor) endless perplexities will undoubtedly arise, but
if we resort to a word like that of ' corpuscle,' and employ it in the
way indicated, the troubles may be smoothed over. It is a word
that the animal histologist has already often used, and one that is
not really difficult for the botanist to adopt; it is one that is com-
mon sense, and which likewise would allow the term cell to be
brought into the same category.

I will leave matters here, however, for others to judge and to-
criticise. Kudolf Beer.

565.3 -397

Fossil Apodidae

EVERY group of animals contains in itself its own record if we
could but decipher it. The zoology of the future is bound
under the fascination of this idea to devote itself to an ever closer
comparative study for the express purpose of gaining insight into
the lines of their past development. "We have no royal roads, and
the hopes which were held out to us a few years back that embryology
would provide us with one have not been realised. It can only
supply us with hints, the full meaning of which we must learn by
other methods. Most hopeful of good result are those groups in
which allied forms, recent and extinct, offer themselves in sufficient
numbers for comparison. None can compare in this respect with
the Crustacea. There is an enormous wealth of known crustacean
forms extending upwards from the very lowest fossiliferous strata
and still swarming in every suitable part of the globe. The
problem has long been to find a genealogical key to reduce this
immense stream of organised life to some order of development.

The first and most striking feature noted was the fact that all
but the most extreme forms are segmented, and the natural inference
was that the common ancestor of the whole immense family must
have been some less specialised segmented form. Of recent years
the attention of zoologists in search of the most primitive form
among existing Crustacea has been concentrated upon the freshwater
Apus which appears sporadically in rain pools all over the world.
"When the pools dry up the eggs remain in the mud ; indeed it is said to
be a necessary condition of development that they should be so dried.
How long they remain capable of development is not known. These
facts are interesting because they suggest to us a way in which Apus
may have survived, practically isolated from the struggle for exist-
ence, almost unchanged from the days when the Crustacea first
appeared on the planet. Those who claimed the primitive character
of Apus were not disconcerted by the absence of fossil remains which
could be definitely assigned to Apus. There was, of course, always
the hope that such might be found, and further there was the strik-
ing fact to which they could appeal that one of the most prolific of
early crustacean forms, the Trilobites, possessed many characters in
common with Apus. The great Paleozoic family of the Trilobites

398 NATURAL SCIENCE [December

are thus claimed as relations of the modern Apus. Now, however,
that the claims of Apus to have been co-existent with and in some way
closely related to the Trilobites are being reasserted on the basis of
a new interpretation of the morphology of the former and of new
facts as to the organisation of the latter — other mysterious relations
are cropping up. With two of these — viz., Protocaris from the Lower
Cambrian, and Dipeltis from the Lower Carboniferous, Mr Schuchert
deals in the Proceedings of the U.S. National Museum (vol. xix.).
Neither are quite new, the former having been figured and described
by Walcott,1 and the latter, from very imperfect material, by Packard.
Mr Schuchert gives a new figure of Protocaris showing a little more
detail, refigures the type specimens of Dipeltis, and is fortunate
enough to be able to describe three new and almost perfect speci-
mens of the same, one of which represents a new species.

Mr Schuchert has no hesitation in claiming both these as
Apodidae, a welcome claim to any who, as above described, have
interested themselves in placing Apus with the Trilobites at the
root of the crustacean phylum. But inasmuch as Mr Schuchert
only deals with these new claimants very generally, it has been sug-
gested that a cross-examination of them from this special point of
view would not be uninteresting.

*o'

Protocaris marshi

This fossil, only known in one specimen from the very oldest fos-
silif erous strata, speaks for itself (see fig. 1 ). Its large cephalic shield
spreading backwards over the trunk segments, the extraordinary
shortness of these segments in strong contrast with the wide anal seg-
ment with its pair of cercopoda, and lastly, which is a new detail
added by Mr Schuchert, the pair of circular markings suggesting
eyes near the anterior margin of the carapace — all proclaim its close
affinity to Apus. Indeed, on first acquaintance with this fossil, I
went so far as to suggest that it might with advantage be called
Apus marshi.

Since studying Mr Schuchert's paper, however, I have been struck
by two features which seem to me to have been generally over-
looked, one of which is of prime importance. A comparison of
the abdominal segmentation of Protocaris and Apus appears to
show that the former retained a primitive condition which has been
secondarily lost in the latter.

One of the principal arguments in favour of the great antiquity
of Apus was found in the fact that a great and varying number of
posterior segments are fixed in a rudimentary condition. The evi-
dence for this was found in the progressively diminishing sizes of the

1 Bull U.S. Geol. Survey, 10, 1884, p. 50, pi. x. fig. 1 ; Amcr. Nat., 1885, p. 293 ;
Mem. Nat. Acad. Sri., Hi. pt. 2, p. 145, pi. v.

1897]

FOSSIL APODIDAE

390

limbs (see fig. 6), each pair being provided with a pair of abdominal
sanslia. It was, of course, more or less of an assumption that these
limbs and ganglia represented true segments, because to all appear-
ance the true segments are marked off on the body as shown in the
fio\ 6. Further, authors were not wanting who definitely claimed
that the apparent segmentation was the true one, and that the
multiplication of the limbs, as many as four, five, and even six to
one single segment, was due to some kind of secondary reduplication

] . Protocaris marshi, Walcott ; 2. Dipeltis carri, Schuckert ; 3. Dipeltis diplocliscus,
Packard ; 4-5. Another specimen of the same, showing the under surface and part
of the upper with the eyes ; 6. Apus glacialis, var. spitzbcrgensis from the side,
with left half of the carapace cut away to show the whole trunk ; bp. left limbs of
the eleventh segment modified into a brood-pouch, p. pore leading into the water
sacs over the eyes. [Figs. 1-5 after Schuchert.]

of organs on one and the same segment. The present writer, on the
contrary, maintained that, as at the front end of the body each pair
of limbs with its pair of ganglia corresponded with a true body seg-
ment, the whole series of the limbs should be taken as true seg-
mental structures, and where, after the eleventh segment, marked
by its brood pouch (hp.), the limbs begin to diminish in size, there
being more than one to each external division of the body, these

400 NATURAL SCIENCE [December

external divisions must be considered as secondary rings and not as
true segments.

The correctness of this suggestion seems to me to be entirely
borne out by the abdominal segmentation of Protocaris in which
this secondary ringing has not taken place. If a body-ring were
marked round the abdomen of Apus for each of the pairs of limbs,
leaving out the most minute at the posterior end (cf. rigs. 1 and 6),
we should get a condition, at least for the limb-bearing portion of
the abdomen, not unlike that shown in Protocaris, in which a multi-
tude of very small segments (though not diminishing quite so clearly
as they would in Apus) are in striking contrast with the anal seg-
ment.

It should, however, be noted by the way that this interpretation
of the segmentation of Apus which receives such unexpected and
welcome support from Protocaris was greatly complicated by the
presence in Apus of a varying number of limbless segments in front
of the anal segment. These still require explanation ; at present I
am inclined to look upon them as secondary reduplications of the
anal segment.

This difficulty must not, however, be thought to stand in the
way of my interpretation of the segmentation of Apus. That inter-
pretation has already received abundance of support from the fact
that the same fixation of rudimentary segments is found in the
Trilobites. Inasmuch, however, as the relationship between Apus
and the Trilobites is still a matter of discussion, it is especially
welcome to obtain direct evidence from a fossil whose close affinity
with Apus cannot be for a moment doubted.

The second point arises from the peculiar shape of the shield.
Mr Schuchert describes it as subquadrangular, and quotes Clarke's
suggestion that it has probably been subjected to some horizontal
distortion in the shale. The longer I contemplate the figure of this
shield the more convinced I am that it has simply been flattened
out, and that in its original shape it was folded down at the sides
of the body. Not only do the two anterior lateral projections of
the shield suggest this, but the absence of the usual spikes at the
postero-lateral corners of the shield are quite in accord. In Apus
these spikes are turned up somewhat on to the back (fig. 6), and in
the Trilobites they are spread out wide of the body in the horizontal
plane. If the shield were folded down at the sides, these spikes would
be a serious danger to the limbs and abdomen, and would be sooner
or later dispensed with. Whether, again, the dotted lines running
along the shield, shown in Mr Sclmchert's figure (reproduced in fig.
1), lend any support to this view, I should not like to say, because
we have no means of getting at their true meaning, but they cer-
tainly suggest to my mind a dorso-ventral flattening.

1897] FOSSIL APODIDAE 401

We have then, it seems to me, a simple and natural interpreta-
tion of the shape of the shield of Protocaris without assuming any
other distortion than that due to flattening. Had there been any
horizontal distortion, it would, one would expect, be more apparent
in the abdomen than in the shield. 1 am therefore disposed to look
upon Protocaris as an Apus in process of folding down laterally
its whole carapace, a modification which, as I have shown in some
detail elsewhere,1 would lead on to the peculiar organisation of the
ostracods. I lay stress upon the word ' whole,' because if only the
free lateral flaps behind the head region are folded down, we
should get a form which might lead on to the other bivalve-
entomostraca, the Daphnidae and Estheridae. In making these
suggestions I am again taking up my original position that Apus is
the protonauplius of authors, and that from it or its young stages
all the Crustacea can be deduced. I may add indeed that nothing
which has been said during the last five years has shaken me in
that conviction, based originally upon my study of Apus. On the
contrary, all the new facts which have come to light have tended
without exception to confirm it. I refer mainly to the brilliant
researches of Beecher on the limbs of the Trilobite, Triarthrus, and
to these fossil Apodidae now under discussion.

The whole question, however, must of course be decided solely
by the evidence ; hence, I may remark in passing, it is somewhat
surprising to find a zoologist declaring that he has no " sympathy
(sic) with the peculiar phylogenetic speculations of Bernard." Anti-
pathy against the views of a fellow-worker, however unscientific
such an attitude of mind may be, is perhaps excusable, but it is not
so excusable merely to refer readers to a semi-popular summary
and not to the papers containing the detailed evidence for the
hypothesis condemned. Readers could then judge for themselves
whether these ' peculiar phylogenetic speculations ' are speculations
at all, and not rather necessary deductions from established facts.

Mr Schuchert's claim that ' eyes ' can be faintly seen on the
specimen will be noticed below.

Dipeltls

The claims of this fossil, of which only four specimens are known,
to belong to the Apodidae, seem to me far more intricate than are
those of Protocaris. It appears at first sight as if it might be a
transition form between Apus and the Trilobites, and yet it only (so
far as at present known) appears on the scene in the Lower
Carboniferous, when the Trilobites were already beginning to pass
away.

] " Apodid.'e," Section xv., p. 252.

402 NATURAL SCIENCE [December

We note, particularly at the outset, that Mr Schuchert evidently
assumes that the head of Dvpeltis corresponds to the head of Apus
with its five segments. There is no reason to doubt the correctness
of this assumption.

When analysing the differences between Apus and the Trilobites,1
I came to the conclusion that the essential distinction between them
was as follows : — In Apus, after the formation and fixation of the
head region out of five fused segments, the cephalic shield grew
backwards as a large free carapace over the trunk segments, which
remained cylindrical, whereas in the Trilobites the head shield did
not grow backwards freely over the body, but was repeated, by
the familiar process of segmental repetition, on each of the trunk
segments, giving rise on them to their pleural extensions. This
curious difference in the mechanism of development resulted in two
such apparently distinct forms as Apus and the Trilobites.

Dipeltis now conies on the scene. Its general appearance is
that of Apus, but its repetition of the head shield is that of the
Trilobite. The head shield and its two large segmental repetitions
together appear as if they imitated the true free carapace of Apus.
They only appear to cover the trunk segments, as the carapace of
Apus covers its cylindrical trunk. Further, the trunk segments
also show in their small pleurae a slight repetition of the head
shield, or rather of the last of the two large repetitions of the head
shield. These are unmistakable Trilobitic characters. On the
other hand, the anal segment with its pair of cercopoda, the arrange-
ment of the large eyes with anterior eyes or pores at the front of
the head, the smooth round forehead without glabella or furrows,
are unmistakably apodidan features. The animal looks remarkably
like a cross between an Apus and a Trilobite ! The only explana-
tion I can suggest of this singular creature is that it resulted from
a second attempt on the part of the main- or ^Ms-stem of the
crustacean phylum to adopt the Trilobitic modification ; that is, for a
second time these primitive Crustacea tried the segmental repetition
of the early head shield instead of its free backward extension as a
carapace. I would explain the Apus-Uke appearance of this second
attempt as being due to the fact that it started from a true Apus,
whereas the Trilobites owe their peculiar characters to the fact that
they branched off before the Apus type was fixed — i.e. while the
head region was still in process of formation — hence the glabella,
the transverse furrows, and the uncertain position of the eyes on the
head shield, with the three longitudinal regions running along the
dorsal surface due to the segmental repetition of that head shield.

Turning, in conclusion, to the eyes in figure 3, these are shown
very like those of Apus as to position and arrangement, while in front

1 V- Jowrn. deal. Soc, vols. li. and lii.

1897] FOSSIL APODIDAE 403

of these larger eyes are two spots. These are also found on another
specimen, part of which is shown in figure 5, copied from Dr
Schuchert's paper. In Apus in front of the paired eyes is a median
pore (fig. 6, p>-) leading into the water sac, in which these paired
eyes are now sunk. Tn the base of the channel leading from this
pore to the water spaces above the eyes a body called the median
eye is suspended. The structure of this eye and its probable origin
— as suggested by its structure — out of a pair of anterior eyes I
have discussed elsewhere.1 It is therefore of some interest to me
to find an animal, with such claims to be a relative of Apus, having
a pair of what appear to be eyes in front of the usual pair. It is
true that this anterior pair persists in Limulus, but here again the
relationship between Apus and Limulus is still matter of discus-
sion. It is therefore once more pleasant to find what appears to be
a direct confirmation of one's morphological deductions in an animal
certainly related to Apus. What the peculiar ovals round these
anterior ' eyes ' are in fig. 5 it is impossible to say. It may be that
here we see these eyes being drawn into the median line and below
the surface.

In Protocaris I should regard the two eyes, suggested in figure
1 , as corresponding with the paired eyes of Apus : perhaps owing
to the bending of the carapace they are sunk deeper in the water
sacs.

I quite agree then with Dr Schuchert in calling these early
crustaceans fossil Apodidae. Protocaris I suggest is a modifica-
tion of Apus in the direction of the bivalve Ostracods, Dipeltis
as a second attempt of a true Apus to adopt the Trilobitic modi-
fication of repeating the head shield as pleurae along the trunk
segments, while preserving for some reason or other the habit of
Apus. Henky M. Beknakd.

1 "Apodidae," pp. 100-111.

575.8 404 [December

Reproductive Divergence : A Rejoinder

IN the last month's number of Natural Science (p. 317) Dr Karl
Jordan criticises a theory which I had briefly suggested in a
previous number of the journal (p. 181), and which I had entitled
" Eeproductive Divergence : an Additional Factor in Evolution." I
had there maintained that my theory differed essentially from
Eomanes' theory of Physiological Selection, for I endeavoured to
show that if the less similar individuals in any species were at the
same time less fertile inter se than the more similar, it would neces-
sarily follow that in the course of succeeding generations these
members would diverge more and more from each other, till eventu-
ally two or more new and mutually sterile species would be formed.
I still hold, in spite of Dr Jordan's view to the contrary, that this
theory is essentially different from Eomanes', which maintains that
if a portion of the members of a species happen to be sterile with all
the other members, they will, in virtue of this physiological barrier,
be enabled to vary independently of the parent stock, and so give
rise to a new species.

I stated that my theory was made up of two parts, one of which
was capable of mathematical demonstration, whilst the other could
only be verified by experiment. Dr Jordan takes exception to the
former, but accepts the latter, he holding that the " correlation between
morphological characters and fertility of the specimens of a species
cannot be denied." He also adduces an additional instance in support
of the existence of this correlation.

The mathematical demonstration of the validity of the theory
which I gave was, it would seem, rather too brief for its purpose.
In excuse I must plead that my paper was intentionally of only a
short and preliminary nature, as I thought a more extended discus-
sion had better be deferred till I had more experimental evidence at
my command. As, however, Dr Jordan appears to have entirely
misunderstood my reasoning, he holding indeed that in the particular
example 1 adduced to prove a divergence of character there would
on the contrary be a convergence, I must now endeavour to explain
the mathematical basis of the theory more fully. Thus of its validity
I am convinced there can be no question. Its adequate demon-
stration depends only on skill in manipulation of figures, though
this I am afraid 1 do not possess.

18971 REPRODUCTIVE DIVERGENCE 405

The fresh example I propose to adduce is founded on actual data,
namely, the measurements of human stature in the case of parents
and their offspring, which are given by Galton in his work on
"Natural Inheritance" (p. 208). Here the relations between
the stature of 205 'parents of each sex and of their adult
offspring are classified. The mid-parents 1 split up into three
nearly equal groups — viz., those below 6 7 "8 inches in stature, those
from GT'S to G9'2 inches, and those above 69'2 inches. These
groups were found to give rise to more or less equal numbers of
children. The numbers of children of each stature which were
given birth to by each of these three groups of short, medium and
tall mid-parents were then determined, partly by plotting out the
various numbers and calculating from the smoothed curves, and
partly by direct enumeration of the numbers. By then taking
means between the numbers of tall children produced by tall parents
with those of the short children produced by short ones, and also
between the numbers of short children produced by tall parents with
those of tall ones produced by short parents, roughly speaking the
following mean values were arrived at : —

Short.

100 short parents give . 54

100 medium . . .31

100 tall . . . 15

100 100 100

From these figures it is seen that the percentage numbers of children
are given, and not the actual numbers. This plan was adopted in
order that the numbers of children might be kept the same as that
of the parents. We see, therefore, that if 100 short, medium and
tall parents of each sex be taken, the numbers of short, medium and
tall children will still remain at 100, in spite of the fact that the
children of each group produced by the different parents vary from
15 per cent, to 54 per cent.

In addition to the children produced by short, medium and tall
parents, it is for our purpose necessary to know the numbers pro-
duced by intermarriages of short and medium, and of medium and
tall parents. These numbers may be approximately obtained by
taking means between the percentages for short and medium parents
on the one hand and for medium and tall ones on the other. Thus :

Short. Medium. Tall children.

100 short and medium parents give 425 34'5 23

100 medium and tall . . .23 345 42*5

It is also necessary to assume, as Galton has shown his statistics
warrant us in doing, that short and tall and also tall and short

Medium.

Tall children

406 NATURAL SCIENCE [December

parents give rise to the same numbers of children in each group as
do medium parents.

If we now take the case of 900 parents of either sex and divide
them into three groups of 300 short, medium and tall individuals, it
will be found that, as- the result of their chance intermarrying, they
will give rise to the following numbers of offspring of each sex :

293 short. 314 medium. 293 tall.

These numbers thus differ slightly from the 300 of each group
which were started with, but it is not possible to arrange the numbers
resulting from the various intermarryings so as to give quite identical
figures. This, in fact, is not necessary, as it is only sought to
compare two different cases, in one of which a correlation between
fertility and stature is absent, and in the other of which it is present.
This latter case we will now proceed to discuss.

Let it be granted that, in pursuance of this principle, 100
parents intermarrying with parents of similar stature now give rise
to 120, and not 100 offspring of each sex. When on the other
hand they marry with moderately taller or shorter individuals, let
the number of offspring remain unchanged, and when tall or short
parents marry with short or tall, let only 80 offspring instead of
100 arise. If now the same 900 parents of either sex intermarry
according to the laws of chance, it will be found, on calculating out
the numbers in accordance with the data given above, that the
following numbers of offspring will be produced :

Short. Medium. Tall.

300-6 318-8 300-6

instead of 293 3,14 293.

That is to say, the numbers of short and tall individuals will have
increased by 2-59 per cent., but those of the intermediate ones by
only 1-52 per cent. There is thus a gain of about 1*07 per cent,
in favour of the extreme individuals over the intermediate ones, or
supposing the original 3,00 medium individuals had again been
produced, there would now be 303-2 instead of 3,00 tall and short
ones. This seems a very small amount in comparison with the
fairly large differences of fertility we assumed to be present. It is,
however, none the less genuine, in spite of its smallness, and it will
of course become increasingly larger in succeeding generations.
Thus supposing that in the next generation respectively 3,03-2, 300,
and 303-2 short, medium and tall individuals of each sex inter-
marry, the short and tall offspring will be increased by slightly
more than 1-07 per cent. ; by in fact about 1/08 per cent. There
will now, therefore, be 300 + 3-2 1 + 3'24 = 306*45 short and tall
offspring, instead of 300. In succeeding generations the increase
will gradually become more and more marked, and the divergence

1897] REPRODUCTIVE DIVERGENCE 407

of the race into two distinct races more and more obvious. Again,
I had supposed that the more widely any two individuals differed,
the less on an average would lie their mutual fertility. Hence this
principle of reproductive divergence is a cumulative one, and the
later stages of divergence will be very much more rapid than the
initial ones.

Again, Dr -Jordan objects to my statement that as the race
diverges, shorter and longer individuals than those originally present
will gradually be evolved. This seems to me to be so obvious as to
scarcely need demonstration. Thus, let us suppose for the moment
that our 900 individuals of each sex are split up into 450 short
individuals and 450 tall ones. The members of each of these
groups will deviate in either direction from the average size in the
same proportion as the members of the original single group did.
For instance, in the 928 adult offspring obtained in the above-
mentioned anthropometric data, the mid-stature or median of the
whole group was about 68*2 inches, and 10 per cent, of the group
were below G4-5 inches in height. Supposing now the median of
the new group of short individuals be 6 5 "8 inches, it follows that
10 per cent, of this group will be below 62-2 inches in height.
That is to say, individuals shorter than any of those originally
present will have arisen. The tall individuals will, of course,
deviate in a similar manner in the opposite direction.

This fresh attempt to demonstrate the correctness of the prin-
ciple of reproductive divergence will not, I am afraid, appear much
more easy to understand than the former one, but it at least has
the merit of being roughly founded on actual data, so that fewer
preliminary assumptions are necessary, and the result obtained is a
more absolute one, and is moreover independent of the Law of
Regression towards mediocrity.1 To me it seems the principle is
sufficiently obvious without the help of any mathematics at all, if
it be looked at in the following manner. Let any number of
individuals in a species be divided up into two groups — the larger
ones and the smaller. Then if there be a correlation between size
and fertility, it follows that those larger individuals which happen
to breed with the smaller ones will give rise to fewer individuals of
intermediate size than they would have done if there had been no
such correlation. That is to say, the race will begin to diverge,
and as this divergence is cumulative, it will ultimately split up into
two or more new races. H. M. Vernon.

1 •' Natural Inheritance," p. 95.

575 408 [December

Professor Schiller on Darwinism and Design

I SUPPOSE that it must, on the whole, be reckoned as an encour-
aging sign of gradual advancement that, from time to time,
articles dealing with physical science are allowed to appear in the
monthly Reviews ; for the appearance of such articles indicates that
the editors of these strictly commercially-conducted Reviews can
safely reckon upon a tolerable percentage of their readers being
interested in physical science.

This apparent gradual spread of an interest in physical science
is comforting ; and it is good that the huge section of the public,
who never by any chance read scientific books or scientific periodi-
cals, should yet, through the medium of the Revieivs, acquire some
slight taste for physical science and some trifling knowledge of
recent advances therein. From this standpoint, then, the practice of
inserting scientific articles in the lay Reviews is much to be com-
mended ; but it is not to be denied that there are compensating dis-
advantages, and these are due to two factors.

In the first place, the editors of these Reviews, being usually —
like most other " well-educated " Englishmen — utterly ignorant of
physical science, are hopelessly unable to estimate for themselves
the value of any scientific article submitted to them, and are thus
entirely incapacitated from exercising any truly editorial functions
with regard to such articles ; and, in the second place, all these
Reviews are conducted upon strictly commercial principles, being-
regarded primarily as money-making machines, and only secondarily
as organs of education and enlightenment. Both these factors con-
spire to bring about one and the same result, viz., that the editors
taboo all articles not signed by a big name — which' is at once the
guarantee of profit to their purses and of safety to their ignorance —
and are naturally tempted to exclude controversial replies. Usually
their assiduous worship of big names safeguards them from any
fiasco ; but now and then there creeps into a Review an article which
betrays only too signally the fact that it was entirely unintelligible
to the " editor," and that that omnipotent functionary was education-
ally disqualified from perceiving the extraordinary nature of the
statements and arguments appearing in his Re/view.

To this category seems to belong the article on Darwinism and
Design, contributed by Professor F. C. S. Schiller to the Contemporary

1897] SCHILLER ON DARWINISM AND DESIGN 409

for -Tune last — an article that, though dealing with physical science,
bears the most obvious traces of a metaphysician's handiwork. I
certainly do not propose to criticise this article in detail ; for such a
criticism, to be at all adequate, might require an article a good deal
longer than Professor Schiller's own : and, fortunately, any such de-
tailed criticism were superfluous ; firstly, because all readers who have
any familiarity with biological science may perceive for themselves
the errors into which Professor Schiller has fallen ; and, secondly,
because those readers of his article who are entirely ignorant of the
subject would hardly be among the readers of Natural Science, nor
would they perhaps be affected by my arguments even if they read
them. I propose, therefore, merely to call attention to two or three
notable points in Darurinism and Design.

The article, which opens with somewhat of a flourish of trumpets,
and excites expectations that are by no means realised in the sequel,
is directed to prove that ' Darwinism ' has not necessarily excluded
the possibility of a teleological conception of organic nature ; but
that, properly scrutinised, evolutionism rather strengthens the argu-
ment from ' Design' than otherwise.1 Now Professor Schiller makes
one or two initial omissions of a notable character. He intentionally
confines himself to " living nature," thus putting aside altogether the
awkward question as to whether the evolution of solar systems be,
or be not, ascribable to Design ; and he writes as though evolution-
ism and Darwinism were the same thing — as though to demonstrate
an error in any one of Darwin's initial assumptions were to at once
clear out of the way all biological objections to the teleological con-
ception of the world. The former omission is highly significant of
the philosophical value, or otherwise, of Professor Schiller's article ;
the latter oversight appears to me to vitiate his entire argument, and
to render it little more than a beating of the air ; and one is tempted
to say that the article would have been topical in 1860, but is a
generation out of date now.

Professor Schiller is good enough to tell us that the old-fashioned
argument from design was rotten even before the advent of Dar-
winism ; but he proposes to recast the argument in such fashion
that ' Darwinism ' shall be no obstacle, but rather indeed an as-
sistance, to the teleologist. He tells us that " before the argument
from design has any theological value, two things have to be shown :
(1) that intelligence, i.e., action directed to a purpose, has been at
work ; and (2) that the intelligence has not been that of any of the
admitted existences." 2 The former part of this statement reads
rather curiously ; but it only means that, for the author's purpose,
it is essential to prove that the adaptations in organic nature have
not been brought about solely by a blind mechanical process, but

1 Cf. p. 144. 2 Contemporary Review, p. 868.

2 F

410 NATURAL SCIENCE [December

are due, at least partly, to intelligent effort on somebody's part.
To make good this position, Professor Schiller has recourse to some-
what strained arguments. For instance, he suggests that " a com-
plete denial of design in nature must deny the efficacy of all
intelligence as such. ... If that view were true, we should have
to renounce all efforts to direct our fated and ill-fated course adown
the stream of time " (p. 868). But this ingenuous attempt to make
the anti-teleologist damn himself — on the plea that logically he is
bound to deny the efficacy of all intelligence if he deny the argu-
ment from design — seems to me a mere trifling with words, and
recalls the old saying that " words are wise men's counters, they do
but reckon with them; but they are the money of" metaphysicians.
Professor Schiller must know perfectly well that the " denial of de-
sign " is merely an elliptical phrase meaning the "denial that the
adaptations in nature evidence the design of an over-ruling Divine
intelligence " ; and that this denial, neither logically nor historically,
implies anything so absurd as the denial of " the efficacy of all in-
telligence " — such intelligence itself being regarded by consistent
evolutionists as a notable adaptation to our environment. But this
playing with words, this use of words in Humpty-Dumpty's port-
manteau fashion, so that two very different meanings are packed
into one word, is typical of Professor Schiller's article. Of this we
have a glaring example in the following passage, which is, to a
certain extent, the key to the author's position : —

" The ease with which the Darwinian argument dispenses with
all intelligence as a factor in survival, excites suspicion. It is
proving too much to show that adaptation might equally well — i.e.,
as completely, if not as rapidly — have arisen in automata. For
we know that we ourselves are not automata, and strive hard to
adapt ourselves. In us at least, therefore, intelligent effort
is a source of adaptation, and the same will surely be admitted
in the case of the higher animals. . . . Intelligence therefore is a
vera causa, as a source of adaptations, at least co-ordinate with
natural selection ; and this can be denied only if it is declared in-
efficacious everywhere — if all living beings, ourselves included, are
declared to be automata. ... If, however, intelligence is read-
mitted as a vera causa, there arises at least a possibility that other
intelligence besides that of the known living beings may have been
operative in the world's history" (p. 871 ; spaced type mine).

It is worth while to realise the fallacy involved in this passage ;
for, when once that is realised, there is not much left in our author's
case. The whole fallacy lurks in that word adaptations. It is
obvious that individual animals do functionally adapt themselves
in many ways to their environment ; and that, the greater their in-
telligence, and the better consequently their adaptations, the greater

1897] SCHILLER ON DARWINISM AND DESIGN 411

their chance of life. But, to Professor Schiller's argument, it is
essential to show (1) that structural adaptations can be, and are,
thus brought about; and (2) that such adaptations are inherited.
This Professor Schiller does not even attempt to prove ; but it is
the crux of the entire argument. If Professor Schiller can prove
that individual intelligence is capable of producing direct structural
modifications — i.e., modifications at which it has directly
aimed — and if he can farther show that such modifications are in-
herited, he will certainly have made out the former part of his hypo-
thesis,viz., that "intelligence, i.e., action directed to a purpose, has been
at work." This proof, however, he does not even attempt; but contents
himself with asserting of ' adaptations ' what is true, so far as we
know, only of individual functional adaptations; and by thus using the
word ' adaptations,' simply and without any expressed qualifications,
he obtains a fictitious appearance of a demonstration ; for the term
' adaptation,' when used in such arguments by evolutionists, is used in
the sense of ' inherited structural adaptations ' — as Professor Schiller
ought to know perfectly well. It is simply the old metaphysical
sophism of using one and the same word in two distinct senses, and
crediting to the one sense of it what is readily granted to the other ;
and to perceive the fallacy involved in his use of the word ' adap-
tations ' is to knock a pretty considerable hole in the bottom of Pro-
fessor Schiller's argument. Can our author see no difference in kind
between the functional adaptations of an individual man to a mari
time life or a desert life and the structural adaptations of a whale
and a camel to these respective modes of life ? We all know that
individual men, by varying their food and clothing, can thus in-
telligently adapt themselves to very different conditions of life ; but
how does this fact create any presumption that even the camel's
stomach or the whale's form is the result of intelligent action
directed to a purpose, and still less that the countless wonderful
adaptations of which no man even is conscious until he studies
anatomy, and over which even then he is powerless to exert any
intelligent control, and which work best when he is unconscious
— such adaptations, I mean, as the valves of the heart and countless
•others — are the outcome of intelligent action directed to a purpose ?
It does not indeed seem clear that even Lamarckian factors would
avail Professor Schiller here, unless, possibly, the proverbial mouse
■could be shown to have acquired a neck a yard long by intelligently
and purposefully directing its gaze to the unattainable cheese above it;
for it were one thing to admit that the effects of use were inherited,
but quite another to assert that any evolution has been due to the
intelligent action of animals directed to the purpose of adapting
themselves to their surroundings. Even were Mr Spencer's argu-
ment concerning the giraffe conceded by his opponents, I scarcely see

412 NATURAL SCIENCE [December

how this would help Professor Schiller ; for not even the most fervid
Lamarckian ever dreamed that the giraffe, when straining at the
leaves, was intelligently and purposefully directing the develop-
ment of muscles and bones and the rearrangement of his internal
and external anatomy generally. Thus the very modifications, on
which the whole value of his Lamarckian neck rested, were due to
blind mechanical action over which he exercised no intelligent con-
trol. Moreover, it does not appear that Professor Schiller had even
cleared up his notions of ' adaptations ' so far as to think of appeal-
ing to Lamarckism to support his contention that intelligent action
is responsible for many adaptations ; for in that section he does not
even mention Lamarck, though soon afterwards he remarks in pass-
ing (p. 872) that " it is practically certain that some Lamarckian in-
fluences must affect both the number and the character of the
variations " — the metaphysician, with typical assurance and hasti-
ness, thus dogmatically deciding a question over which our leading-
biologists, who alone are competent to speak authoritatively, are
hopelessly at variance.

I pass over the curious passage in which Professor Schiller cites
the action of the ' general physical and chemical laws of nature ' as
barring variations in certain directions, and thus rendering impossible
the indefinite variation on which Darwin founded his arguments
(p. 872),1 and I will not comment here upon his strange citation
of Bateson's work on Discontinuous Variation — which he fondly
supposes to constitute a stumbling-block to Natural Selection — for
I have already replied to that argument in the columns of Natural
Science (May, 1895) ; but we will pass at once to the concluding
section of Professor Schiller's article. This is really suggestive and
ingenious ; and, had the author excised the first ten pages of his
article and retained only the latter part, he would probably have
stood higher in the opinion of biologists. The pith of this latter
part of his argument may be stated in very few words.

Darwin assumed that organisms vary indefinitely in
every direction, and that the evolution of species is due to the
action of natural selection in seizing upon and fixing a few among
these countless variations. Were this assumption a literal
statement of fact, any possibility of interpreting the universe
teleologically would be barred al> initio ; but, if variation be not
indefinite in every direction, but more frecruent in one direction than
in others, it may be purposive ; and thus the ground is cleared for
building up a new teleology. Now Darwin's assumption was not
a statement of fact, but a methodological assumption, exactly
analogous to the economic assumption of an ideal ' economic man,'

1 The same sort of* objection might be brought against the first law of motion, and in-
either case is obviated by the insertion of the words ' tends to — '

1897] SCHILLER ON DARWINISM AND DESIGN 413

or to the mathematician's assumption of a single body in an other-
wise void space. By arguing from such methodological assumptions,
the ' laws ' of motion and the ' laws ' of economics were obtained ;
but all these ' laws ' are applicable to concrete facts, only with
modifications, and after re-introducing the qualifications that were
methodologically omitted from the premises, and the methodological
assumption must never be accepted as a statement of literal
facts.

Now this is certainly a very interesting and ingenious thesis, and
I do not remember previously to have seen the suggestion made
that Darwin's assumption was thus purely methodological ; but it
does not seem likely that Professor Schiller's ingenuity will be of
any service to the teleologist. It were necessary before any teleo-
logical argument can be founded that he should prove (1) that
variations are not indefinite but definite ; and (2) that such
definite variation can be attributed to no mundane factors, but can
be explained only by the assumption of supra-mundane purposive
intelligence.

The former hypothesis — for the sake of the argument — we will
grant to Professor Schiller, although he has not even attempted to
prove it, except by his curious remarks about ' chemical and
physical laws,' &c. : x but what is it worth to him ? Nothing ! for
that ' ultra-Darwinian ' Weismann has already contended that
variation is definite in direction, and he has offered a purely
mechanical explanation of such definiteness ;2 so that what was to be
treasured up as the trump card of the teleologist has already been
played on the other side. But is it not indeed significant that the
author of this curiously belated article, seeking to turn the evolu-
tionists' flank and to clear the field for the teleologists, should be
unaware that our most prominent living evolutionist had already,
by anticipation, outflanked his flanking movement more than a year
ago ? Thus the only really at all valuable part of Professor
Schiller's article, the one part not invalidated by fallacious trifling
with words, is yet invalidated by his ignorance of the science that
he seeks to press into the service of teleology. What, in this year
1897, can be more hopelessly belated than the following remarks
(p. 875) : " It is clear then that, to explain the changes which have
resulted in the existing forms of life, some variable factor has to be
added to natural selection. And as to the nature of that factor,
Darwinism qua Darwinism tells us nothing." Perhaps it is even
clearer that, had Professor Schiller possessed any acquaintance with

1 It is one thing to argue that Darwin did not prove variation to be indefinite, quite
another to prove that it is not intrinsically indefinite ; and the teleologist must prove
the latter proposition, and prove it by a wide induction from multitudinous details and
experiments, before he can even talk of teleology.

2 See his "Germinal Selection."

414 NATURAL SCIENCE [December

Weismann's work — of the whole of which, and, indeed, even of
Weismann's existence, he seems to be profoundly ignorant — this
passage, and the whole of his article besides, would have remained
unwritten. It does seem to me rather hard that metaphysicians
who want to write about evolution will not take the trouble to find
out what evolutionism connotes at the present day ; but Professor
Schiller's ignorance of recent advances in biology is quite on a par
with the curious and fatal misconception of the processes and factors
of evolution that prevails throughout his article ; and the cue to his
philosophical status is afforded by his very theological conclusion,
from which we learn that, if the whole of his argument be valid,
evolutionism rather helps than hinders the teleologist, since he is no
longer compelled to attribute perfection, but only gradual perfec-
tioning, to this very imperfect scheme of nature, nor to saddle an
omnipotent deity with the responsibility for deliberately planning
and designing all the cruelty and suffering prevalent throughout the
world. In other words, he proposes, by the help of evolution, to
save divine morality at the expense of divine power ; his directing
Intelligence being, not an omnipotent fiend, but only an unpractised
though well-meaning bungler. I hope that the theologians will be
duly grateful to their very candid friend.1

lie theory of an innate tendency to vary in a definite direction of advance was,
e, advocated long ago by Nageli. In an article on "Evolution and Teleology "

1 The
of course,

that appeared in the Nev) Science Review of July, 1S95, I pointed out how strongly the
recent advances in botany have told against this theory, and how in nearly every line of
ascent evolution upwards has ended in a blind alley.

F. H. Pekey Coste.

•i i r>

SOME NEW BOOKS

"Let us now Praise Famous Men!"

The Founders of Geolocy. By Sir Archibald Geikie. 8vo, pp. x+ "298. London:

Macmillan & Co., 1897. Price, 6s. net.

If, as Emerson has said, all history may be read in the lives of a few
great men, this may be regarded as specially true of the history of
science. The facts of science, no doubt, are accumulated by a multi-
tude of workers ; but ideas have their genesis in the brains of the
leaders, and the growth of the ideas may best be studied as it took
place originally in the minds of a few individuals. Hence Sir Archi-
bald Geikie. when eager to dispel the lamentable ignorance of most of
us concerning the historical development of geology, could have chosen
no better means than tins skilful and charming narration of the
endeavours of the early pioneers.

The occasion of this work was the inauguration of the George
Huntington Williams Lectureship at Johns Hopkins University, and
one can imagine the delight with which American geologists listened
to the polished periods and lucid exposition of Sir Archibald. Some
of the perorations, indeed, are better adapted to the lecture-platform
than the study, and an occasional weakness in the usually correct and
forceful style suits the written less than the spoken word. Careful
revision, for instance, would have eliminated such a sentence as this :
" His father . . . died while the son was still very young, to whom
he left a small landed property in Berwickshire." We test the author
by his own high standard.

The geologists referred to in this book are — Leibnitz and Buffon
(who, however, are not regarded as among the founders of geology, but
as the last of the cosmogonists), Guettard, Desmarest, Pallas, De
Saussure, Lehmann, Fuchsel, Werner, D'Aubuisson, Von Buch,
Hutton, Sir J. Hall, Giraucl-Soulavie, Cuvier, A. Brongniart, Omalius
d'Halloy, Bev. J. Michel], William Smith, Murchison, Sedgwick,
Logan, Agassiz, ISucol, Sorby, Lyell, and Darwin. Many others are
mentioned incidentally and, in relation to these, the pioneers. For
the expressed purpose of the book, this list is an excellent one. No
doubt, every one that has read much in the early literature of geology
will be ready with suggestions for its amendment. The fact is that
a vast number of these old writers were not so ignorant or so foolish
as we are too ready to suppose. Guettard is one whose claims have
been strangely overlooked, and we are delighted to see this admirable
appreciation of his many services to our science. But the list, it will
be noticed, is almost entirely confined to French, German, and British
geologists : Linnaeus and Wallerius are dismissed in a single line.
Linnaeus, however, did more than arrange certain minerals in one of
his kingdoms of nature : he studied the strata in which minerals and
organised fossils occurred, travelling through Sweden and making

416 NATURAL SCIENCE [December

careful geological observations, which he published in the accounts of
his journeys to Gotland, to Oeland, and, above all, to Westrogothia
and Scania. He drew a section of the strata composing Kinnekulle,
and paralleled them with beds in other parts of Sweden, subsequently
using his knowledge to interpret the structure of Scania. "Thus,"
said he, " the section of Kinnekulle serves as introduction to Strata
terrae or the anatomy of the earth-crust, not only here in Westro-
gothia, but probably over the greater part of the world." He recog-
nised that the strata had been deposited in the sea throughout many
long-vanished periods, and attempted to classify them according to
their relative age. Thus Linnaeus laid the foundations of the
Wernerian system before Werner was born ; and it was not long
before his fellow-countryman Bergman erected upon that foundation
the actual framework that Werner filled in. Other Scandinavians
might have been mentioned, such as Gyllenhahl, with his truly re-
markable palaeontological study of Echinosphaera, and Hermelin,
with his geological maps of Southern Norway and Sweden. The
most curious omission, however, considering the occasion of the
lectures, is that of citizens of the United States. Featherstonhaugh
and H. D. Rogers are just alluded to, but that remarkable and much-
abused geological genius, Ebenezer Emmons, is not even named.

We have not mentioned these omissions for the sake of fault-
finding, but as further evidence of the amount of good work done by
many whom it is the fashion of the present day to disregard. We
sympathise warmly, as we have already said, with Professor Miall's
recent plea for a more historical method of teaching the natural
sciences, and, as a help in that direction, no book is better adapted
than the present. But those who imagine, if such there be, that they
have passed beyond the student stage, would yet do well to dip now
and again into the battered volumes that grow dusty on topmost
shelves. There are many observations and many shrewd suggestions
hidden in those old books, made perhaps too early in the day to have
taken effect, but waiting to be applied by us now with our modern
knowledge and methods. Eosinus, for instance, 178 years ago, de-
scribed the course of the nerve-canals, "foramina jure meritoque pro
nervorum canalibus reputanda," in the cup of the lily-encrinite, in
language that Dr W. B. Carpenter (the modern discoverer of that
nerve-system) could not have bettered. The fact is that the worth of
a man's work does not necessarily depend on the number of his years
or on the century in which he lives.

Some of the most valuable passages in this book are those in
which Sir Archibald uses the weight of his experience to enforce
the morals to be derived from the study of the older writers, hi
one place he quotes Fitton's review of the Wernerian school : " A
Wernerian geognost is chiefly employed in placing the phenomena he
observes in the situations which his master has assigned to them in
his plan of the mineral kingdom. It is not so much to describe the
strata as they are, and to compare them with rocks of the same
character in other countries, as to decide whether they belong to this
or that series of depositions, supposed once to have taken place over
the whole earth, ... to ascertain their place in an ideal world."
Similar criticism might justly be applied to-day in various branches

1897] SOME NEW BOOKS 417

of science. Sir Henry Howorth's ' heretical ' article in our November
number did little more than translate the words of Fitton. Then are
there not a good many hard-working zoologists and botanists who are
perfectly satisfied if they can assign their specimens to certain pigeon-
holes made for them in a rather hypothetical cupboard called a System?
It is even a fact that many excellent old writers are ignored jnst
because they could not, or would not, use a regular Linnaean termin-
ology. Their works are neither read nor to be found in our scientific
libraries. Into such obscurity even Hutton's great work, " The
Theory of the Earth," may fall. It is nothing that we saw it
characterised recently in the catalogue of a second-hand bookseller
as " This extravagant theory which was defended by the celebrated
Professor Play fair " ; but we were indeed surprised to find no copy of
it in the geological library at the Natural History Museum.

"With reference to Playfair's defence, known as " Illustrations of
the Huttonian Theory," Sir Archibald remarks : " For precision of
statement ami felicity of language, it has no superior in English
scientific literature. To its early inspiration I owe a debt which
I can never fully repay. Upon every young student of geology
I would impress the advantage of reading and re-reading, and reading
yet again, this consummate masterpiece. How different would geo-
logical literature be to-day if men had tried to think and write like
Playfair \ »

Put it may be objected, How can we find time to read these old
authors, much less to write like the best of them ? We have to read
the modern literature, and even a small part of that is overwhelming.
We have so much to do that we cannot waste our energies on mere
style, and we must rush out our results the easiest and quickest way
we can, or we shall be anticipated. Sir Archibald's answer should be
laid to heart, not merely by geologists old and young, but by all
scientific workers. He finds his consolation in " the conviction, borne
in upon us by ample and painful experience, that a very large mass
of the geological writing of the present time is utterly worthless for
any of the higher purposes of the science, and that it may quite safely
and profitably, both as regards time and temper, be left unread. If
geologists, and especially young geologists, could only be brought to
realise that the addition of another paper to the swollen flood of our
scientific literature involves a serious responsibilit}'', that no man
should publish what is not of real consequence, and that his state-
ments when published should be as clear and condensed as he can
make them, what a blessed change would come over the faces of their
readers, and how greatly they would conduce to the real advance of
the science which they wish to serve." There is not a dull page in
" The Founders of Geology," but, were it only on account of this last
paragraph, we should wish for it many readers in all parts of the
world.

The Death of Rocks

A Treatise on Rocks, Rock-Weathering, and Soils. By G. P. Merrill. 8vo, pp.
xx + 411, pis. xxv. New York : The Macmillan Company, 1897. Price, 17s.

What the unsatisfactory preservation of fossils is to a palaeontologist
and surface drift to a' stratigrapher, decomposition of rocks has long

418 NATURAL SCIENCE [December

been to the petrologist. Each is regarded as an unmitigated nuisance,
interfering with the observation of facts for which the enquirer is-
searching ; and as the stratigrapher is expected to map solid rock
through its drift covering, the petrological specialist, when consulted
as to the character of a rock, is expected to say, not what it is, but
what it may once have been.

Professor Merrill, however, has endeavoured, in the work under
review, to make the processes and results of weathering as interesting
and full of real importance as the American and English glacialists
are making the drift. For it is the weathering of rocks which forms
soil, the link between the dead earth-crust and the living plants and
animals upon it. Geologists have studied rocks in all their various
kinds, their origin, differentiation, and metamorphism, their birth,
growth, and life ; we have now to study their death, and the earliest
parts of the process which culminates in their resurrection.

In order to make his book self-contained, Professor Merrill devotes
several chapters to considering the chemical and mineralogical com-
position structures, mode of occurrence, and various types of rocks ;
this is a fairly useful summary, but we are inclined to doubt whether
the geologist will need, or the lay-reader understand it. Many of the
illustrations in this part are admirable, and the abundant analyses are
particularly valuable for reference later on. To many of these no
references are appended, and we may conclude that they are due to
the author himself, who must have expended a great deal of time and
labour on the analyses throughout the work.

Part III. is devoted to the weathering of rocks, each of the
chemical and mechanical agencies being taken in turn. Several
valuable instances of the effect of alternations of high and low
temperature are given, and the effect of cold rain on highly heated
surfaces is referred to. While stress is laid on the effect of hydra-
tion, the work of carbonated rain-water, and of the humic, ulmic,
and crenic acids naturally comes in for a lion's share of consideration.
The action of the first of these solvents upon many silicates can be de-
tected within ten minutes, while forty-eight hours' digestion will obtain
from some amphiboles, epidotes, felspars, etc., quantities of lime, mag-
nesia, iron, alumina and silica, amounting to from 0*4 to 1 per cent,
of the mass. Hornblende is more easily acted upon than felspar, and
even magnesian silicates are attacked, so that serpentine cannot be
considered a final product of decomposition. Increasing the pressure
on the solvent has much more effect than prolonging the time of its
action. Daubrce's experiments on attrition are referred to, and the
work of plants, bacteria, termites, and marine animals on the sea-bed,
is not neglected.

Special cases of weathering are next treated in detail and illus-
trated by full analyses. Mere bulk analyses of the fresh and
weathered rock are misleading, as thev do not show all that has
actually occurred. It is necessary to ascertain which constituents
are least liable to be leached out, and to recalculate the analyses on
the assumption that they remain constant. Alumina and iron oxides
are least liable to this, and the analyses of acid rocks are worked out
on this assumption. An example will show the value of this method ;
the one chosen illustrates, in addition, that while only 30 per cent, of

1897] SOME NEW BOOKS 419

the original rock was soluble in hydrochloric acid and sodium car-

1 1< mate, the proportion is now nearly 70 per cent. The instance is
that of a gneiss from Virginia.

FRFSH

OHBISS.

imposed

GNEISS.

CA1.CULATKI

) AMOUNTS SAV

ED AND LOS

Percentage of

Percentage

Bulk

Soluble

Bulk

Soluble

each con-

analysis;

portion.

analysis.

portion.

Total loss.

stituent
saved.

stituent
lost.

SjO* .

60-69

10-09

45-31

17-69

31*90

47-55

52-45

Al2Os .

16-89

13-54

26-55

24-86

o-oo

100-00

o-oo

FeaO» .

9-06

12-88

11-80

1-30

85-65

11-35

CaO .

1*61

Tr.

0-06

4-44

o-oo

100-00

MgO .

1-06

0-89

0-40

0-37

0-80

25-30

74-70

K80 .

4-25

2-40

1-10

0-75

3-55

16-48

83-52

XaoO .

2-82

1-10

0-22

0-25

2-6S

4-97

95-03

P2O5 ■

0-25

0-23

0-47

—

o-oo1

100-

o-oo1

Loss on

ignition

0-62

13-75

13-40

o-oo1

100-

o-oo1

100-08 30-17 99-9S 69-18 44-67

i Ga'n.

This table makes at once obvious the great loss in silica, lime, and
alkalies, and the gain in water ; while it further indicates from the
increase in the soluble portion that the state of combination in many
of the compounds has changed. Mechanical separation and micro-
scopic examination of the decomposed material throws further light
on the character of the decomposition and nature of the surviving
minerals.

In basic rocks the loss of silica is rather less, and that of iron and
magnesia more conspicuous, while in a French basalt the felspars
were the first to yield, and the augite and olivine the last.

Under the heading " Physical Manifestations " are treated : Dis-
integration without decomposition, influences of crystalline and rock-
structure, mineral composition (roughening and crusting), indura-
tion and colour changes. Original characters are sometimes lost
entirely through weathering, basalts pass into apparent argil-
laceous deposits, and granites and gneisses with their veins and
every structural detail well preserved, may become so soft that a
stick can be thrust deeply into them. Chemical compounds become
on the whole simplified by weathering, but oxidation and all chemical
change, except hydration, seems to cease below the permanent water-
level. More refractory and dense residues, like xenotime, monazite,
tourmalines, rutiles and precious gems, have tended to accumulate in
favoured spots, on account of the weathering and destruction of the
rocks in which they were originally contained.

The rate of weathering is influenced by composition, texture, and
position of rocks, and by humidity of climate. Weathering in humid
climates differs in kind, as well as degree from that effected in dry
climates as shown in California by the author and by Judd in the
Xile delta. Prehistoric implements and old surfaces covered uncon-
formably by newer deposits may sometimes enable us to guess at the
amount of work done in a given time, but the ascertaining of the actual
rate of work is difficult, and the results not very satisfactory. Geikie's
results, on this branch of the subject, not quoted here by the author,

420 NATURAL SCIENCE [December

are important. A summary of the work of transporting agents con-
cludes this portion of the work.

The fifth and last part of the hook is devoted to the consideration
of the regolith, a term used to include the soil which covers the solid
rocks like a blanket (p>/yo?), an incoherent mass of varying thickness
composed of materials essentially the same as those which make up
the rocks themselves, but in greatly varying conditions of mechanical
aggregation and chemical combination. The materials of the regolith
are either sedentary or transported, the first class being either residual
like wacke, laterite, terra rossa, &c, or cumulose like peat. Residual
deposits are generally unstratified and may possess characteristics
which they have ' inherited ' from hundreds or even thousands of feet of
rock which have totally disappeared. Transported deposits are col-
luvial (scree and avalanche debris), alluvial and aeolian, or glacial.
Alluvia vary in character and to a striking extent in fertility according
to whether the river bearing them drains a dry or a damp country ; in
the former case the undecomposed silicates will be rich in plant food.
Where saline deposits are absent, indeed, the soils of very dry
countries are of an extremely fertile character and only need rain to
be covered with luxuriant vegetation, and this is especially the case
because percolating rain has not been present to concentrate the clay
into a ' hard-pan ' below the surface.

The averages of several hundred analyses of soils in dry and humid
regions show that the soluble constituents of the soil in arid tracts
amount to 30 and in wet tracts to 15 per cent., the greatest differences
being in the quantity of lime, magnesia, and alkalies.

Richthofen's aeolian hypothesis is considered satisfactory when
applied to the Chinese loess, but not to that of America, which latter
the author supposes to be the result of streams draining from the ice
of the glacial period.

An important organic agent in the formation of marine deposits in
inlets is found in the eel-grass, which grows vigorously as soon as a
little mud has formed on the bottom, and then by deadening all cur-
rents promotes very rapid deposition of fine salt.

In dealing with the ' rock-flour ' brought down by glaciers, Pro-
fessor Merrill alludes to the small amount of actual clay present. It
has been proved by Mr E. Dickson that what there is of this material
is ground up felspar and not kaolin.

To illustrate the wonderful degree of comminution reached in soils,
it is pointed out that the total surface area of the grains in a cubic
feet of soil amounts on an average to 50,000 square feet. On areas
like this the operation of organic acids, plants, animals, and water
must be enormous. Ants working in such soil effect as much change
as the earthworms studied by Darwin, and Shaler's calculation that
the former bring a layer of soil one-fifth of an inch thick to the surface
every year finds a close parallel in the figures obtained by Darwin.

Professor Merrill's book is an admirable introduction to a com-
plicated and difficult subject. It is packed with facts, not perhaps
arranged in the best possible manner, and illuminated with a wonderful
series of analyses which contain a fund of valuable information. The
author is modest in his deductions, not eager to generalise, and only
adopting or advocating a conclusion after full discussion. It is to be

1897] SOME NEW BOOKS 421

hoped that his work will lead to the more detailed study of the
changes produced in rocks as they weather down and pass into their
final, but by no means least useful, form. The illustrations are for the
most part clear and well chosen, but it would be well to indicate the
exact magnification of the diagrams oi' microscopic objects in the text.

Tht. Volcanoes of North America

Volcanoes of Nobth America : A Reading Lesson for Students of Geography

AND Gkoliicy. P>y Israel C. Russell, Professor of Geology, University of Michigan.
Svo. Pp. xiv + 346, with 1(5 plates and 11 figs, in text. New York: The
Macmillan Co. ; London : Macmillan & Co., Ltd. 1897. Price, 16s. net.

The second title of this handsomely printed book must be regarded as
that which expresses the intentions of its author. To the American
reader, the work is an introduction to the study of volcanoes, com-
parable to those of Prof. Judd and others, which are already
familiar to us in Europe. Only 170 pages, or half the book, deal with
the volcanoes of North America ; and it is to these that the professed
geologist will most naturally turn. Considered, then, in its dual
aspect, Prof. Russell's work must do much to stimulate curiosity
and observation in the United States, by pointing out the absorbing
interest of volcanic phenomena, and the extraordinary illustrations of
the subject possessed by the North American continent.

Vesuvius, as seems inevitable, introduces the description of com-
plex volcanic mountains ; and the famous photographs of 1872
repeat themselves on the second plate. Nor will the beginner feel
any irritation at perusing the graphic details provided by the
younger Pliny. He is directed to Mr Lobley's book on Vesuvius for
a history of the mountain ; and wTe should have liked a reference also
to the classic work of Phillips. Palmieri's experiences, and the report
of the Krakatoa committee, are then drawn on ; and these passages
conclude with a remarkable quotation, from " one of our most pro-
found students of volcanic phenomena " (p. 28), to the effect that
the performances of Vesuvius " are mere Fourth of July fireworks
in comparison with the Day of Judgment proceedings of Krakatoa."
Prof. Russell's own good taste and style fortunately prevent his
imitating this profundity, even where, as in Chapter VIII., he allows
himself romantic possibilities.

Dutton and Dana furnish the account of Hawaii, and the Deccan
trap and the Newark system of the Atlantic coast are quoted as
examples of surface-flows of vast extent. In the latter instance,
we may remind ourselves of the wide field of literature and ' solid
geology ' already traversed by Prof. Eussell in the Eastern States.

The terms ' aa ' and ' pahoehoe ' seem to have gained vitality in
geological literature (pp. 60-62), just as we might borrow with profit
many of the names by which a Highlander or a Welshman designates
the various forms of mountains. Prof. Eussell refers the ' aa ' type
of lava-surface to imperfectly fluid streams, in opposition to what has
been stated to occur upon the slopes of Vesuvius. The pahoehoe,
on the contrary, flows easily and cools in thin sheets before it
can break up, furnishing a smooth and often glassy surface.

The classification and description of igneous rocks professes only

422 NATURAL SCIENCE [December

to be a sketch, and granite is selected as the deep-seated type, fol-
lowed by four lavas. Augite or soda-augite, as well as hornblende
and biotite, should, we think, have been mentioned among the com-
mon constituents of rhyolite (p. 122) and trachyte (p. 124). We do
not quite gather the meaning of the description of andesites " as gener-
ally dark, and mostly fine-grained rocks, with a restricted amount of
glassy base, but larger than in the trachytes."

On p. 127 we commence the study of North American volcanoes,
and it is interestingly pointed out (p. 133) that the two ends of the
great western line are highly active, while there is a " middle region
of extinct or, perhaps, in part, dormant volcanoes, extending from
central Mexico through the western part of the United States and
far into Canada."

Considering the enormous area to be covered, no one geologist can
be expected to have an intimate acquaintance with North American
volcanoes ; and hence the description of those in Central America and
Mexico is necessarily a compilation from works already published.
So little is known of this district, however, that we are glad to be put
in touch with the amazing history of lzalco, the growth of which, from
nothingness to a height of 1500 feet, was witnessed by the cure of
Sonsonate during his quiet country life, or the catastrophic explosion
of Consesuina in 1835, which seems to have been connected with
earthquakes that carried ruin into < 'bile. Among recent accounts
— still far too few — we have those of Prof. Heilprin's ascents in
Mexico. There seems some contradiction, however, between p. 178,
where we are promised mountaineering excitements on Ixtaccihuatl,
and the mere comparison with Popocatepetl on p. 183.

A country that possesses the denuded necks near Mount Taylor
(PL 6, fig. B), and the exquisitely preserved Ice Spring craters of
Utah (PL 7), is truly a paradise for the student ; but the distances
from point to point must still remain obstacles to research. The cone
near Lassen's Peak, described by Diller, is of admirable freshness, and
may have been active in the present century. Hence there are
further volcanic possibilities in store for observers within the
limits of the United States.

On p. 234 we gain a conception of the huge chain of peaks, still
awaiting detailed enquiry, that runs north from San Francisco into
Washington. These seem to result from Tertiary eruptions, and are
not unworthy companions of the Andes, which are more familiar to
us, owing to the pre-eminence of certain of their -summits. The photo-
graph of Mount Rainier (PL 14) may be cited, among the beautiful
series of illustrations that adorns Prof. Russell's book. •

The account of the Columbia lava (p. 250) will interest students
of fissure-eruptions. Prof. Russell clearly points out that the enor-
mous area, 200,000 to 250,000 square miles, is not buried in one
vast flow ; " the lava sheets overlay) and supplement one another so
as to form a continuous and highly compound system." Individual
flows have, however, been traced on canon-walls for a score or more
of miles.

When we reach Alaska, we welcome the photographs of peaks and
islands on Plates 15 and 10, and feci more than ever grateful for the
records that Prof. Russell has brought together in the American

1897] SOME NEW BOOKS 423

portion of his book. This portion concludes with an account of the
great part played by volcanic 'lust in the soils of many of the western
States. A reference to Prof. Judd's paper on the lavas of Kraka-
toa {Geological Magazine, L888) would have excellently supplemented
the important quotation from Diller on p. 293, to the effect that vol-
canic dust is richer in silica than its parent lava.

In the 'theoretical considerations' of chapter VII., we fancy
that there is a certain amount of slaying of the slain. But this walk
across the battlefield is in reality of service to learners, who are liable
to regard all printed text-hooks as infallible. The suggestion on
p. 314 that " volcanic activity increased with geological ages, and
reached its maximum in Tertiary times," is confessedly based on the
geological history of North America, and is, we fancy, not even well
founded for that area. The amount of denudation that has laid bare
the Archaean rocks of the north-east has probably wrought havoc
along many old lines of volcanic activity.

Prof. Eussell regards the water in lavas as collected during the
passage of molten matter, moving under earth-pressure, from the
lower into higher and waterlogged regions of the crust (p. 318) ; and
the liquid matter may arise during local relief from pressure, as the
product of rocks previously solid (p. 312). Hence he considers
steam rather as a variable and unessential factor in determining a
volcanic outburst.

The work is, as we have hinted, admirably produced by the pub-
lishers. The printers give us ' Koichthofer ' for ' Eichthofen ' on
p. 252, and, far more excusably, ' lavas ' and ' lava cases ' for
■ larva? ' and ' larva cases ' on p. 209.

Geenville A. J. Cole.

Another Memoir on Funafuti

The Ethnology of Funafuti. By Charles Hedley. Australian Museum, Sydney.

Memoir III., part 4, 1897.

The pressing necessity of a systematic and immediate survey of the
ethnology of the islands of the Pacific is again brought clearly before
us by Mr Hedley's paper. It is only too manifest that the strictly
native culture of Funafuti is rapidly dying out, that the older arts,
customs, and appliances are changing apace under the influence of
European missionaries and traders. In a few years' time the very
recollection of the older culture will die out, and it will be impossible
to obtain for our museums even models of the former appliances made
with any accuracy at any rate. Hence every careful contribution to
South Pacific ethnological literature must be welcomed. Mr Hedley's
paper does not profess to be in any way an exhaustive monograph,
but is, in the main, a descriptive list of the ethnological specimens
and models collected by himself and others, and placed now in the
Australian Museum at Sydney. Most of these are described clearly
and in some detail, while their interest is increased by reference to
the resemblances observable between the various native implements
of Funafuti and those of other islands, as bearing upon their affinities
and upon the probably complex origin of the general culture of the
inhabitants of the island. Funafuti seems to have drawn its culture

424 NATURAL SCIENCE [December

from various directions. Though in the main Polynesian, more par-
ticularly Samoan, in general character, there is evidence in the arts
and appliances of affinities with Micronesian culture, while even
Melanesian traces are not wanting. The curious shell-bladed cocoa-
nut scraper, mounted upon a wooden, elbow-shaped stock, belongs to
a type of tool which has been recognised in Matty Island, to the
north of New Guinea, while Mr Hedley might have added that the
same is also found in the Solomon Islands, and that it crops up again
in Ceylon, with a metal blade substituted for the shell. In North
India, too, a nearly allied implement is found with a knife-blade
replacing the scraper. The details given regarding the various types
and the manufacture of fish-hooks are of importance, and point to
affinities with the fish-hooks, both of the eastern and the western
Pacific groups. The canoes are described in detail. The various im-
plements, toys, etc., are too numerous even to be mentioned here, but
all are recorded with care. It is a pity that the term 'drum' is
applied to the hollow trough-shaped wooden instrument of Funafuti.
This belongs to a very widely distributed type of instruments, which
belongs essentially to the gong series, and should on no account be
confused with the drums, which are characterised by a sounding
medium of tense membrane. The vague descriptions of some travel-
lers constantly confuse the two perfectly distinct instruments, and
ethnologists should studiously avoid falling into the same error. Mr
Hedley is wrong in supposing that the 'ploughing' method of pro-
ducing fire by friction is the only one employed in the Pacific Islands.
The simple twirling drill has been described from New Zealand, the
New Hebrides, and Carolines, and other instances might be men-
tioned. In this, as in many other instances, a specialist would, no
doubt, have added greatly to the information given in the paper, but
at the same time Mr Hedley 's contribution should prove a useful one,
and welcome to ethnologists. Henry Balfour.

A Catalogue of Mammals

Catalogus Mammalium, Tam Viventium Qxtam Fossilium, a Dr E. L. Trouessart.
Nova editio (prima completa). Fasciculus II., Carnivora, Piimipedia, Rodentia
I. (Protrogomorpha and Sciuromorpha), pp. 219-452 ; Fasciculus III., Rodentia II.
(Myomorpha, Hystricomorpba, Lagomorpha), pp. 453-664. Berlin : R. Fried-
lander & Sohn, 1897. Price, 10 marks each fasciculus.

The second and third portions of this admirable and most useful
list fully bear out the promise of the first part, noticed in Natural
Science for May. They contain, besides the Carnivora and Pinnipedia,
which the author separates ordinally, the whole of the rodents, the
most difficult and most numerous order of mammals, and will there-
fore be most welcome to every working mammalogist. The list
seems throughout to be remarkably complete and up to date, and we
have scarcely been able to find a single omission. The print and get-
up are even better than in the first parts, and the misprints due to
some of the specific names being printed with capitals are reduced to
a minimum (though not to nil). Acting on a suggestion in our pre-
vious notice the original localities for the names considered to be
synonyms have been printed opposite the latter, so that it can be seen

1897] SOME NEW BOOKS 425

at a glance what forms have been described from different parts of the
main area.

En passant we may note two accidental mistakes — the first that a
number of rodents from Mashonaland, described by Mr de Win ton in
189G, have been wrongly credited to the present reviewer, and the
second that by a confusion of two similar names, the marsupial
Thylamys rani, of Trinidad, appears as a rodent in the genus
Ti/lomys.

We may express a hope, in conclusion, that this invaluable list
will not be allowed to come to an end without having a good index
appended to it, at least of the genera names and their synonyms (with
page, not number, references), as this will enormously increase the
facility of its use, and will make it really worthy of its claim to be
Edifio complrta. 0. T.

Parasitic Flies

Revision of the Tachinidae of America North of Mexico. By D. W. Coquillett.
Pp. 15-4. "Washington. 1897. (U.S. Department of Agriculture, Division of
Entomology. Technical Series, No. 7.)

Like most of the publications of the admirable Washington depart-
ment, this work will be welcomed both by the systematic student and
the practical farmer. The flies described are parasitic on various
insects, usually on the caterpillars of moths, hence they play an
important part in keeping the numbers of injurious species within
bounds. The work contains tables of the parasites with their hosts
and the hosts with their parasites, together with synoptical tables,
and full descriptions of all the Nearctic genera of species. As most of
the genera are identical with those of Europe, the monograph should
be valuable to dipterologists generally. We notice with regret that
there are no illustrations. In the study of so difficult a family, a few
figures of structural details would be of great help to the beginner.

Further Literature Received

Das Kleine Botanische Practicum, E. Strasburger, ed. 3 : Gustav Fischer. Bau und
Leben unserer Waldbiiume, K. Biisgen : Gustav Fischer. The Span of Gestation, J.
Beard : Gustav Fischer. Wild Traits in Tame Animals, L. Robinson : Blackwood. La
Face de la Terre, French Trans, of Suess, Das Antlitz der Erde, by E. de Margerie, vol.
i. : Colin, Paris. The Living Substance as such and as Organism, Mrs E. A. Andrews :
Ginn, Boston. Cheltenham as a Holiday Resort, S. S. Buckman ; Norman, Sawyer &
Co : Cheltenham.

On some European Slugs of genus Arion, and on two new species of Parmarion,
W. E. Collinge : Proc. Zool. Soc. On Flow-Structure in an Igneous Dyke, and on Augite-
diorites, by T. H. Holland : Rcc. Gcol. Surv. India. A Dictionary of the Call Notes of
British Birds, C. L. Hett. Field Columbian Museum, Papuan Crania, G. A. Dorsey.
Ratzel's History of Mankind, pts. 21, 22: Macmillan. U.S. Dej)t. Agriculture,
N. Amer. Fauna, No. 13. Concilium Bibliographicum, cards relating to Nat. Sci.

Amer. Geol., Nov.; Amer. Journ. Sci., Nov.; Amer. Nat., Nov.; Botan. Gaz., Oct.;
Feuille des Jeunes Nat., Nov.; Irish Nat., Nov.; Journ. School Geogr., Oct.; Literary
Digest, Oct. 16, 23, 30, Nov. 6 ; Naturae Novit., Oct.; Naturalist, Nov.; Nature, Oct.
21, 28, Nov. 4, 11, 18 ; Naturen, Oct.; Photogram, Nov.; Psychol. Rev., Nov.; Rivista
Quindicinale di Psichologia, vol. i., fasc. 9, 11 (Sept., Oct.) ; Revue Scientifique, Oct. 16,
23, 30, Nov. 6, 13 ; Science, Oct. 8, 15, 22, 29, Nov. 5 ; Scientific American, Oct. 9, 16,
23, 30, Nov. 6 ; Scot. Geogr. Mag., Nov.; Scot. Med. and Surg. Journ., Nov.; Vic-
torian Nat., Sept., Oct.; Westminster Rev., Nov.

•1 U

426 [December

OBITUARIES

CHARLES SMART ROY
Born at Arbroath, 1854. Died at Cambridge, October 4, 1897

The death of the professor of pathology in the University of Cam-
bridge is a serious loss to the scientific study of that subject. Roy
received his training at St Andrews and Edinburgh. His earliest
research work, that on the pleuro-pneumonia of cattle, was conducted at
London, chiefly in the Brown Institution, of which Burdon-Sanderson
was head. Proceeding to Berlin, he studied in the laboratories of
Virchow and Du Bois-Reymond, and produced his paper " On the
influences which modify the work of the heart," published in the
Journal of Physiology. In 1879 Roy became assistant at the Physio-
logical Institute of Strassburg University under Prof. Goltz, where he
invented the sphygmotonometer and other instruments for measuring
the changes in blood-vessels. Here also he invented the well-known
ether freezing microtome. Passing next to Cohnheim's Institute at
Leipzig, he invented the renal oncometer for the study of variations
in blood-flow through the kidney. From here in 1880 he came to
Cambridge as George Henry Lewes' student in physiology, and
worked in the laboratory of Prof. Michael Foster. In 1882 Roy
succeeded Dr Greenfield as Director of the Brown Institution, a post
which he held for two and a half years, during which time he visited
the Argentine Republic to investigate a disease raging among the
cattle of Entre Rios. In 1884 he was elected a Fellow of the Royal
Society and to the newly-founded chair of pathology at Cambridge.
His chief work was on the mammalian heart, partly carried out in
conjunction with Prof. Adami. In prosecuting this research he
invented yet other ingenious instruments. Among his students at
Cambridge may be mentioned the names of Kanthack, Hankin,
Griffiths, Lorrain-Smith, Cobbett, Lloyd-Jones, Rolleston, and
Wesbrook. Many of these came as J. Lucas Walker's students in
pathology, an endowment which he himself was largely instrumental
in securing. Prof. Roy's health had been failing for some time, and
for the past year his work at Cambridge has been undertaken by Dr
Kanthack, who has now succeeded him.

PETER BELLINGER BRODIE
Born 1815. Died November 1, 1897

The veteran geologist, the Rev. P. B. Brodie, who had been a Fellow
of the Geological Society of London for more than sixty years, passed
away on the first day of last month. He was born in London in 1815,
iiiid early proceeded to Cambridge, where he came under the influence

1897] OBITUARIES 427

of Sedgwick, and was for some time volunteer assistant in the Wood-
wardian Museum. His first paper, on land and fresh water shells in
association with mammalian bones in the gravels around Cambridge,
was read before the Cambridge Philosophical Society so long ago as
1838, but he became best known by his numerous discoveries of fossil
insects in the secondary rocks, and in 1845 he summarised all that
was then known in reference to this subject in his small illustrated
volume, "A History of the .Fossil Insects in the Secondary Kocks of
England," dedicated to his revered teacher Sedgwick. In the deter-
mination of the insects the author was assisted by the late Prof. J. 0.
Westwood. In 1838 Brodie entered the Church and became curate at
Wylye, Wiltshire ; in 1840 he removed to Steeple Claydon, Bucking-
hamshire ; next year he was elected vicar of Down Hatherley,
Gloucestershire ; and in 1855 he became vicar of Bowington, near
Warwick, where he died. In all these districts he accomplished
much original work, and he contributed several papers to the
Geological Society of London, besides others to the British Associa-
tion and various Field Clubs. In recognition of the value of his
labours the Geological Society awarded to him the Murchison Medal
in 1887. He amassed a large collection of fossils, of which the more
important specimens have been acquired by the British Museum, and
he was indefatigable in his exertions to spread an interest in science
among those by whom he was surrounded. In 1854 he was instru-
mental in founding the Warwickshire Naturalists' and Archaeologists'
Field Club, and at the time of his death he was President both of this
Club and of the Warwickshire Natural History and Archaeological
Society. An excellent portrait of Mr Brodie appeared in the Proc.
Warivick Field Club early this year, and it is reproduced, with an
extended biographical notice, in the November number of the Geological
Magazine.

ANDEEW MATTHEWS
Born June 18, 1815. Died September 14, 1897

At the ripe age of eighty-two one of the most accomplished of our
clerical naturalists has passed away. The Ptev. Andrew Matthews,
who had held the living of Gumley, Leicestershire, since 1853, was a
close observer of Nature, and interested in botany and ornithology.
His fame will rest, however, on his studies of the family of minute
beetles known as the Trichopterygidae. He published a beautifully
illustrated monograph of these insects in 1872, and we are glad to
know that the MSS. and drawings of a second volume had been com-
pleted by him in recent years, and will probably be issued shortly.
He also contributed the account of these beetles to the " Biologia
Centrali-Americana." All collectors of coleoptera are familiar with
the catalogue of the British species of the order which he compiled in
conjunction with Canon Fowler in 1883. That entomologist, in an
appreciative notice of Mr Matthews in the Entom. Monthly Mag.
for November, claims that the deceased naturalist was worthy to
rank with Gilbert White as an observer, while he far surpassed the
famous parson of Selborne as a close student of minute structure.

428 NATURAL SCIENCE [December

LOUIS CALOBI

Born February 8, 1807. Died November 1897

Louis Calori, the doyen of the Italian anatomists, was born at San
Pietro in Casala, Bologna. His father was a doctor of medicine in
practice at San Pietro, and young Louis attended the University of
Bologna, becoming M.D. in 1829. In 1830 he was elected assistant
professor of anatomy at his University ; in 1835 he obtained the chair
of comparative anatomy ; and in 1844 that of human anatomy. He
was ten times President of the Bologna Academy, and that body
published a bibliographical list of his works in the fifth volume of the
fourth series of the Ades. In the same year, 1884, the Academy
gave a fete in his honour. Calori's chief zoological work was done
among the Eeptilia, but his researches threw light on many other
groups of the animal kingdom.

Captain Edward Yerbury Watson, who was killed by a sniper on
November 8 at Simla while with Sir Wm. Lockhart's camp, was well
known as an authority on the Hesperidae. He had arranged the
collection at the British Museum before returning to India. Captain
Watson was acting as Deputy-Assistant Commissary-General, and
had seen a good deal of service in Burmah. He was promoted to the
captaincy in 1895.

Dr Otto Volger, whose death was announced at the end of October,
was a well-known German educationalist. His chief claim to posterity
was his worship of Goethe and his care of the Goethehaus, but he was
an indefatigable writer in the teaching of natural history and geology,
both in Switzerland and Germany, and has left many minor works on
those subjects.

The deaths are also announced of : —

Henry Calderwood, professor of moral philosophy in the University of Edinburgh,
on Nov. 19 ; Leopold Auerbach and Rudolf Heidenhain, professors of physiology
in the University of Breslau ; Hjalmar Heiberg, professor of pathological anatomy in
the University of Christiania ; E. Le Gros, professor of physiology in the new Univer-
sity of Brussels, aged 36 ; Edmund Drechsel, professor of pharmacology in the Uni-
versity of Berne ; Giuseppe Fissore, sometime professor of pathology in the University
of Turin, aged 82 ; W. Marme, director of the pharmacological institute of Gbttingen ;
Alexander Milton Ross, author of several works on the fauna and flora of Canada, at
Montreal, Oct. 27 ; Dr Mietschke, the German entomologist and naturalist ; Max
Sintenis, the German entomologist ; Isaac N. Travis, taxidermist at the American
Museum of Natural History ; Rev. Samuel Haughton of Trinity College, Dublin ; Dr
M. F. Heddle, late professor of mineralogy in the University of St Andrews ; GEORGE
Harry Piper, geologist of Ledbury, Herefordshire ; John Calvert, mining expert,
aged 86 ; and William Scott, director of Royal gardens and forests, Mauritius, aged 38.

1897] 429

NEWS

The following appointments are announced : — Dr A. A. Kanthack to be
professor of pathology, and J. Graham Kerr to be demonstrator of animal mor-
phology, in the University of Cambridge ; Dr A. W. Sheen to be demonstrator of
anatomy in the medical department of University College, Cardiff; Dr Max von
Frey, of Leipzig, to be professor of physiology in the High School of Zurich ; Dr
W. Eothert, of Kazan, to be professor of botany and director of the physiological
division of the botanical department of the University of Charkow ; Henry S.
Pritchett, of Washington University, St Louis, to be superintendent of the U.S.
Coast and Geodetic Survey ; William S. Carter to be professor of physiology in
the University of Texas ; Dr Arthur Allin to be professor of psychology in
Colorado University ; Dr Francis Kennedy to be demonstrator in experimental
psychology in Princeton University.

Sir Archibald Geikie has been appointed Romanes Lecturer at Oxford for
1898.

Dr Hans Molisch of Prague intends to spend the coming winter in botanical
research at Buitenzorg, Java.

Dr Arthur Willey has returned to Cambridge, where he proposes to
investigate his collections during the winter.

The tenth annual meeting of the Geological Society of America will be held
in M'Gill University, Montreal, at the end of December.

Letters from Mr C. W. Andrews announce his safe arrival in Christmas
Island, where he has already made some progress in collecting.

We are pleased to learn from Sir Frederick M'Coy that our announcement of
his retirement from his professorship in the University of Melbourne is premature.

' The Louisiana Society of Naturalists ' has been founded at New Orleans to
investigate systematically the fauna and flora of the State of Louisiana, which has
hitherto been much neglected.

The new building for the Radcliffe Library at Oxford is to be towards the
western end of the south front of the University Museum, that is to say, the end
where the chemical laboratories are.

A Laboratory for Experimental Psychology has, says the Psychological
Review, been opened in the Illinois Eastern Hospital for the Insane, at
Hospital, 111., under the direction of Dr W. O. Krohn.

According to Science, the University of the State of New York, following the
plan it has adopted of lending to the schools libraries and pictures, offers to make
loans of specimens of natural history from the State collections.

The Annual Report of the Preston Scientific Society for 1896-97 records the
accession of more than one hundred members during the year. Sections for
technical scientific work have been formed, and we look forward to interesting
results.

430 NATURAL SCIENCE [December

Dr Franz Steindachner superintends the zoological work on board the
Austrian ship Pola, which this year continues the scientific exploration of the
Red Sea, covering the ground between Jedda and Aden. Researches in physical
oceanography will also be carried on.

Prof. Schauinsfeld, Director of the Bremen Museum, has returned with a
large collection from a voyage of fourteen months in the Pacific. He spent some
time on the small island of Laysan, and visited among other places the Sandwich
Islands, Samoa, New Zealand, and Chatham Island.

The sum of £500 has recently been granted to the Manchester Museum at the
Owens College for the purpose of installing the electric light. We understand
that Mr Edward Holt's donation of £2500, lately announced, is to be devoted
entirely to the rebuilding of the gymnasium of the College.

The Geological Circle of the Upper Holloway Centre of the London Society
for the Extension of University Teaching will issue a strong programme for 1898.
AVe expect great things from a Society with a name of such dimensions, and shall
look for the programme with interest. Mr Rudler is the President.

The Imperial Russian Geographical Society is sending an expedition to
Abyssinia, chiefly for the anthropological investigation of the country. The
leader of the party is Mr Nicolas Dmitrieff, of Astrakhan, who has had some
experience of the country as medical volunteer with the Italian army.

Messrs Schuchert and White, of the U.S. National Museum, have returned
from Lieut. Peary's las Greenland expedition with a collection of Cretaceous
and Miocene plants, as well as many Cretaceous invertebrates from the Noursoak
peninsula. They seem to think the last word on these plants was said by Heer,
which is hardly the view of European palaeobotanists.

The Jersey Natural Science Association is wisely including in its programme
economic questions of general interest. At the October meeting Mr J. Hornell
read an important paper on " The Possibilities of Fishery Improvement in Jersey,
with Notes on the present state of Marine Pisciculture and Fishery Regulation."
It appears in full in the Jersey Weekly Press of October 16.

One of the results of the terrible famine in India last year shows itself in the
increase of deaths from wild animals. The greatest increase was in the North-
West Provinces from wolves, and in the Sunderbunds from tigers, and was, no
doubt, the result of a more vigorous search for food by the natives in the jungles.
Snake-bites, however, decreased considerably, there being only 21,000 deaths in
the year.

An Act was passed at the last meeting of the West Virginia Legislature,
establishing a State Geological and Economic Survey in connection with the
W. Virginia University, Morgantown. For its expenses a sum of 3000 dollars
per annum has been appropriated. Dr Israel C. White is Superintendent, Prof.
S. B. Brown is First Assistant Geologist and Curator of the Collections, and
Professor J. L. Johnson is Assistant Geologist.

The Hull Scientific and Field Naturalists' Club opened its winter session by
an Exhibition and Conversazione which ran for two nights — namely, November
10th and 11th, from 7.30 to 10 p.m. The whole of the exhibits were from the
collections of members of the club, and testified to commendable activity in many
right directions. The President of the club is Dr J. Hollingworth, and the
Secretary is T. Sheppard, 78 Sherburn Street, Hull. The annual subscription is
four shillings.

1897] NEWS 431

Science announces that the United States Geological Survey has practically
completed the distribution of the Educational Series of Rocks, 17") suites of 15G
specimens each having been sent out during the past summer to universities,
colleges, and technical institutions in the United States. There remains a small
number of incomplete sets, wliich will be placed in such smaller colleges as will
make them most useful. The Educational Series were prepared by the Survey
with much care, for the purpose of aiding students in acquiring a general and
special knowledge of rocks and promoting the study of geology.

The illustrations of geological sections as aids to the geologist who ventures
into a museum are familiar to everyone who visits the museums at Jermyn Street,
Cromwell Road, and many places on the Continent and in America ; but there is
one particular section — that built in the gardens of the Landwirthschaftliche
Institut of the University of Halle, in honour of Dr Julius Kuehn — which we do
not think has been brought to the notice of readers of this journal. It is built up
of the rocks themselves, and represents a section through the mountainous district
of north and middle Germany. This very striking representation of geology was
described by Professor K. v. Isitsch as long ago as 1891. Besides forming an
unique memorial to Dr Kuehn, it has considerable value for the teaching of
geology.

We learn from the Shooting Times that the Guildford Natural History Society
have been considering the question of the preservation of Wolmer Forest, which
is only fifteen miles from that town, and have decided to present a petition to the
Commissioners of Woods and Forests, praying that Wolmer Forest may be reserved
as a sanctuary for wild birds, in which they, their nests, and eggs may remain
unmolested throughout the year ; that it may not be let at any time for game
preserving, or for any purpose inimical to bird life ; and that it may remain in
perpetuity as a national memorial to the greatest outdoor naturalist England has
produced — Gilbert White of Selborne. Such a recognition, the society iirge,
would show that the admiration of Gilbert White in the nineteenth century was
so practical as to be of value to the naturalist and the English-speaking race for
all succeeding time. The society have no wish to attempt to interfere with the
use of the forest by the War Office for the purposes of military manoeuvres.

An editorial comment in the American Naturalist for October includes some
complimentary remarks on the British Association, which will be read in this
country with interest : — " We may be pardoned if we point out some features in
which we think the British Association superior to our own. In the first place,
the Presidential Addresses delivered before the British Association strike us as, on
the whole, better than those with which our audiences are greeted. While now
and then an American address will rise to as high a standard as anything that
Great Britain can boast, theirs are on the average the more thoughtful and
scholarly, while ours too often have a perfunctory air and lack in breadth of view.
In personnel of those who attend, the British Association again has the advantage.
In England it is the fashion to attend these annual meetings, and no one there
has reached such a pinnacle of greatness that he can afford to ignore or neglect
this national society. As a result, at their gatherings one can be reasonably
certain of meeting most of those who are the leaders in English scientific thought.
In America, on the other hand, the tendency is in the other direction. It would
be an easy matter to give a considerable list of names of those prominent in
American science whose faces are never seen at the association meetings."

432 NATURAL SCIENCE [December

CORRESPONDENCE

LACEPEDE'S TABLEAUX. . . . DES MAMMIFERES ET DES OISEAUX ; 1799

Lacepede' s "Memoire sur line nouvelle table methodique des animaux a mamelles "
was read before the Institute on 21 Prairial an 7 [9 June 1799]. It was published in the
Memoires de l'lnstitut, vol. iii., in 1801. Louis Agassiz quotes the table as Mem. de
l'lnstit., iii., 1797, an obviously incorrect date ; but many others have quoted it as 1799
without giving any evidence as to the accuracy of the quotation. As great importance
attaches to the proper date of this paper, it became necessary for me to investigate the
matter carefully, but I could not discover any definite statement except that of Engel-
mann, who in his Bibl. Hist. Nat. 1846, p. 376, refers to it as "in-4. Paris, an vii.
(1799). Plassan. (38 pag.)." Up to the present, however, I have completely failed to
find this 4to tract ; it cannot be a separate of the Mem. de l'lnst. paper because that was
printed by Baudouin, and Engelmann gives Plassan as the printer of the tract ; besides
the pages of the Institute paper are 32 against 38 of the tract referred to by Engelmann.
But I have found, quite by accident, in Didot's issue of Buffon's Hist. Nat., 18mo Paris,
76 vols., 1799-1806, in the xiv. vol. of Quadrupedes, this interesting tableau, and it is
dated 1799, and it was printed by Plassan. The title of the two papers (for the birds
are included) are as follows :—" Tableau des divisions, sous-divisions, ordres et genres
des Mammiferes, Par le Cea Lacepede ; Avec l'indication de toutes les especes decrites par
Buffon, et leur distribution dans chacun des genres, par F. M. Daudin " (pp. 143-196).

"Tableau des sous-classes, divisions, sous-divisions, ordres et genres des Oiseaux,
Par le Cen Lacepede ; Avec l'indication de toutes les especes decrites par Buffon, et leur
distribution dans chacun des genres, par F. M. Daudin " (pp. 197-346). Both of these
are referred to as one tract, " in-18. Paris, 1802. Plassan," by Engelmann, Bibl.
Hist. Nat. 1846, p. 322. ,

It will be noted first— That the Genera only are by Lacepede ; and secondly— that all
the species are by F. M. Daudin.

As the period 1798-1801 is a critical one for nomenclature, I need do no more than
point out the interest of this recovery ; but my friend Oldfield Thomas hopes to prepare
an analysis of the Mammalia. Ornithologists will find many interesting points to con-
sider in nomenclature when comparing the above paper with Daudin's ' ' Traite
Elementaire," which it undoubtedly precedes.

C. Davies.Sherborn,

17th Nov. 1897. INDEX Animalium.

Mr R. Quick writes from the Homimau Museum, that an examination of Mr Harrison's
collection of flints from the Plateau gravels of Kent has convinced him that these are
truly primitive implements. He thus agrees with Sir Joseph Pretwich, and considers
that Mr Cunnington's reasoning in our last number (pp. 327-333) is not cogent.

Erratum.— Page 321, line 25. For ' Siberian ' read ' Silurian.'

NOTICE

To Contributors. — All Communications to be addressed to the Editor of Natural
Science, at 29' Bedford Street, London, AV.C. Correspondence and Notes intended
for any particular month should be sent in not later than the 10th of the preceding

To the Trade. — Natural Science is published on the 25th of each month ; all
advertisements should be in the Publishers' hands not later than the 20th.

Shilling each.

Price of Set of Vols. I., II., III., IV £2 10 0

„ V., VI., VII., VIII. . . .14 0

I! „ „ I— VIII. . . . : 310 0

One Shilling each Number of any Bookseller.

Annual Subscription, payable in advance to J. M. Dent & Co:, 29 Bedford Street,
London, W.C„ Thirteen Shillings ($3 -50), post free.

CHANGE OF ADDRESS.

Messrs J. M. DENT & CO. beg to give notice that from January 1, 1898,
the Publishing and Editorial Offices of NATURAL SCIENCE will be removed
to their new premises, 29 Bedford Street, W.C.

1897]

433

INDEX

An Asterisk (*) indicates (hat a figure is given.

* ABBOTT, W. J. L. , on Hastings Refuse

Heaps, 40, 94.
Aconcagua . 140
Aepyornis, 149, 365
"Aeronaut. Journ.," 60
Agriculture, Year Book of, 371
Agricultural Department, an Ideal, 372
" Agri. Gaz. N.S.W.," 282, 293.
Alaska. 138,139

Albany Mus., Graharastone, 142, 286, 336
" Albuquerque Morning Democrat," 350
Alca i ut pi' a a >'* in Ireland, 149
Algae, Polymorphism in, 107
Anieghino, F., on Tertiary Mammalia,

256
American Assoc, 285

,, Geogr. Soc, 353, 354
" „ Journ. Sci.," 135, 150, 222
■" ,, Journ. Psychol.," 136, 349

„ Mus. Nat. Hist., 66, 68, 150,
284, 2S6
" „ Nat.," 282

" ,, X-ray Journ.," 208
Auckland Institute, 69
" Anatom. Anz.," 80
Andree Expedition, 66, 145
Andrews, C. W., 211
"Annals of Botany," 86
" ,, Inst. Jamaica," 351, 370

" „ Mag. Nat. Hist," 226, 282

" ,, Rep. Missouri Bot. Garden,"

303
*• ., Rep. Ohio State Acad. Sci.,"

208, 225
" Annee Biol.," 80, 81
"Annotat. Zool. Jap.," 82, 83, 85
Antarctic Continent, Mammals, 221
Antarctic Exploration, 140
" L Anthropologic," 154
Anthropology, 68
Ants and Mites, 8
"AnuaruluMus. Geol.," 88
*Apodidae, 397
Appointments —

Abbe, C, 211

Allin, A., 429

Baldwin, J., 284

Bardeen, C. R., 211

Baum, H.. 137

Beck, A., 137

Beecher, C. E., 211

Belajetr, V. I., 284

Bittner, A.. 66

Blanchard, R., 284

Boccardi. G. 137

Bolson, P., 211

Boulton, W. S., 13"

Appointments — (continued) —
Brault, Dr, 137
Bray, W. L., 353
Buttikofer, J., 137
Bukowski, G. von, 66
Campbell, J. R., 137
Carter, W. S., 429
Clark, D., 66
Copeland, E. B., 66, 211
Crocichia, A., 137, 211
Dabney, C. W., jun., 66
Dodge, R. E., 137
Emary, Percy, 211
Engelmann, W. I., 137
Erlanger. Freiherr von, 66
Fassig, O. L., 211
Fischer, E., 211
Fling, H., 211, 284
Forbes, E. B., 211
Franz, S. I., 137
Freeh, F., 66
Frey, Max von, 429
Fuchs, T., Dr, 137
Garstang, W., 66

Geikie, A. (Romanes Lecturer), 429
Geyer, G., 66
Gorringe, L. , 137
Heim, L., 137
Hill, A., 353
Howe, H. M., 66
Hume, W. F., 137
Jones, H. L., 353
Kauthack, A. A., 429
Karpinski, A. P., 66
Kate, T., 353
Kaufmann, E., 66
Kennedy, F. , 429
Kerr. J. G., 429
Kihlmann, A. O., 137, 284
Eraemer, H., 211
Kruse, W., 66
Lang, W. H., 66
M 'Bride, E. W., 137, 284
MacGregor, Jas. H., 137
Maclean, M. , 66
Martin, J., 137
Matsumoto, M.. 137
Mayr, Dr. 137 '
Mitchell, F. A., 211
Moses, A. Y., 66
Miinsterberg, H., 211
Muir, 137

Muschketoff, T. Y., 66
Neal, H. V., 284
Nitsche, L., 353
Norman, W. "W., 284
Osann, A., 2S4

2 H

434

INDEX

[1897

Appointments — (continued) —

Palladin, V. J.. 284

Paoletti, J., 211

Peirce, G. Y., 66

Pennington, M. E., 137

Philippi, 137

Pierce, G. J., 211

Pillsbury, W. B., 137

Pirsson, L. V., 211

Pocock, T. I., 137

Prevost, Y. L., 66

Pritehett, H. S., 429

Raciborski, M., 211

Ransome, F. L., 137

Reusch, H., 353

Richards, H. M., 137

Rodet, 284

Rosiwal, A., 66

Rothert, W. , 429

Rnckert, J., 66

Ruge, G., 284

Samassa, P., 66

Schneider, A., 211

Seashore, C. E., Dr, 137

Shattuck, G. B., 211

Sheen, A. W., 429

Sherman, F. D., 211

Slidell, R., 66

Smith, A. A., 284

Stohr, P., 284

Stoneman, B., 137, 211

Stoss, A., 66

Sutton, W. S., 284

Szadowski, J., 137'

Thomayer, J., 66

Thomson, W. E., 284

Tschirwinski, Dr, 66

Ule, W., 66

Volkens, G., Prof., 137

Vries, H. de, 284

Watts, W. W., 211

Weyer, E. M., 137

Williamson, H. C, 211

Wolters, M., 66

Zehnter, 211

Zelinka, C, 353

Zumstein, J. J., 137

Zwaardemaker, P., 353
Apus, 79
*A2nts glacititis, 399
Archaeology, "The Times" on, 229
"Arch. Parasitol," 351
" „ Roentgen Ray," 351
" ,, Skiagraphy," 351
Arctic Exploration, 366
Arctic Geology, 145

,, Ocean, Warm Undercurrent, 48
Arthropods, 72

,, of Funafuti, 5

Arunta Tribe, 119
* Assam Earthquake, 231
Ascomycctes, 86
Aspidiotus, 226
Assoc. Franeaise, 137, 284
Asterolepidae, 45
Athelgue anicidi, 7
Atoll, sec Funafuti, 5
Auckland Inst. Mus., 69
Australia, Entomology, 292

Australia, Natural History, 359

Radiolaria, 229
Australasian Assoc, 139
Australian Mus., Sydney, 5, 143, 231r

289, 360
Azores, Botany of, 303

Bacon beetle, 7

Bacteria of Black Sea, 297

Bacterium in Alcohol, 87

Baffin Land, 212

Baikal, Lake, 138

Baly Medal, 284

Basic dykes in India, 15

Beards on Women, 2, 215

Beaver in Norway, 300

Bedstraws, 13

Beer, R. , on seed production, 337

Beer, R., Cells or Corpuscles, 392

Bees and flower development, 100 ; and

flowers, 35S
Bennett, A. W., 211
" Bergens Mus. Aarbog," 300
Berlin Ac. Sci., 66 ; awards, 213 ; grants,

353
Berlin Institute, 213
* Bernard, H. M., on Fossil Apodidae,

397
Bibliography of Science, 79
Biol. Soc. , Paris, 80

,, Training, 217
Birds, anatomy of, 144 ; Madagascar, ex-
tinct, 149 ; protection of, 75, 359 ;

stomachs of, 146
Bison, 139

Bivalves, embryonic shell, 10
Blackman, V. H., 139, 212
Black Sea, 297
Bogdanov, Anatole, 138
Bolton on Provincial Museums, 387
Bonn Univ., 66
Books free into U.S., 138
Bootle Mus., 69, 353
Born, Gustav, 212
" Botanical Gazette," 14, 157

,, Soc. of America, 68, 356

Botany of Azores, 303
Study of, 302
Botrychium lunaria, 141
Boyle Lecture, 66
Brachiopoda, American Fossil, 367
Brighton Mus., 354
British Assoc, 217, 285 ; grants, 286
British Mus., 3, 62, 63, 67, 132, 139, 190,

191, 192, 194, 195, 203, 204, 212, 213,

287, 298, 302, 348, 354
Brittle-Star, Japan, 84
Brooklyn Inst. Mus., 353
Buckman on Bearded Women. 215
Buffalo v. Bison, 72
"Bull. Amer. Mus. Nat. Sci.," 150
" ,, Boissier Herbarium." 70
" ,, Entomol. U.S.

fcure,",7

" ,, Geol. Surv. Chicago," 20S
" ,, Inst. Inter. Bibl./' 79, 80
" „ Tech. U.S. Dept. Agriculture," 8T

226
" ,, U.S. Dept. Agriculture," 146

Dept. Agricul-

1897]

INDEX

435

Bulman, (i. W.. on Bees and Flower-
Development, 100

Bureau of Ethnology for Greater Britain,
355

Buthus brevicandatus, 6

Buttercups, 13

"Calcutta, Earthquake, -231
"California, Hopkins' Lab., 28

,, Insect Control in, 148

,, Univ., 285

Cambridge (Engl.) Mus., 67, 348
Cambridge Univ., 353 ; Degrees for

Women, 1
Camel in Europe, 88
( 'ainelus alutensis, 88
Cape Colony, Prehistoric Man, 334
Cape Town,' S. African Mus., 68, 286
Carcinology, 251
Carotin, 13

Cavernicolous Animals, 67
Castor-Oil Plant, 335
Cells, 392

Cells, Models of, 369
Centrornis, 150
Cephalaspidae, 45
Cephalopods of Trias, 228
Centra vinula, 148
Chalazogamy, 85

Chalk Rock, Fossils of English, 157
"Challenger" Album, 3; Reports, 3,

354, 355
"Chances of Death," Pearson's, 50
Chcirocephalus, 79
Chemistry, plant, 12

,, in museums, 215

Ckcnalopex, 150

Chicago Univ., 284 ; Institute, 69
Child's mental development, 293
Chirodota contorla, 226
Chita (Trans- Baikal) Mus., 69
Chubut, ethnology of, 214
Civilisation and Insects, 225
Cockerell on Bees and Flowers, 358
Collections —

Cope, E. D., 68
Haviland (Termites), 143
Hoffmann (Lepidoptera), 284
Miiller-Argau (Lichens, &c. ), 70
Rosen (S. African horns), 354
Savin (Forest Bed), 213
Schauinsfeld (Pacific), 430
Seton-Karr's Implements, 137
Shaus (Lepidoptera), 284
Collinge on Slugs, 71
Colouration, protective, 224
Commensalism, 8
" Comptes Rendus Acad. Sci. , Paris,"

10
Concilium Bibliographicum, 285
Congresses —

Intern. Bibliographic, 67
,, Postal, 139
,, Geological (8th), 212, 294, 353

(9th), 353
,, Medicine and Surgery, 67
„ Ornith., 354
,, ZooL, 354, 363
Puss. Nat. and Physicians, 139

Cope bequests, 68

Copenhagen, Nat. Hist. Mus., 161, 162

Coral Reef Poring, 142, 289. See Funa-
futi

Cornell Univ., 69

Corpuscles, 392

Costa Rica, Nat. Mus., 69

Cothcnius Medal, '284

Crustaceans of Funafuti, 6

Crustacea (Decapod), pigments of, 9

Cuckoo, nesting of, 293

Client us /in// ill us, 293
*Cunnington, W., on Plateau Man, 327

Cut flowers, seed, 337

Cycas, 85

Cycads, 156

,, new discovery in, 85

Darwin Statue, 140, 212 ; Theory of
Coral Reefs, 289

Danesdale Graves, 139

Darwinism and Design, 408

Dates of Books, 16, 432

David exped. to Funafuti, 142
*Dean, B., on Hopkins Laboratory, 28

Deaths from Wild Animals in India, 430

Decapods, pigments of, 9

"Denkschr. Akad. Wiss. Wien," 228

Derby and Mayer Museum, 137

Devizes Mus., 328

Diatoms, reproduction of, 10
* Dimorphodon macronyx, 191
*Dipeltis carri, 399
*Dipeltis diplodiscus, 399

Distribution, geographical, of Dragon-
Flies, 4
"Distribution, geogr., of Foraminifera, 17

Dragon-Flies, geogr. distr., 4

Dublin Mus., 223

Duerden on work in Jamaica, 288

Dyke-Rocks from S. India, 15

*Earthqtjake, June 12, 1897, 231
"East Asia," 135
E. London, Cape Colony, prehistoric

man, 334
Echinoderms of Funafuti, 6
Edentata, origin of, 150, 152
Embryonic Shell of Bivalves, 10
Emary, Percy, 211
Entomology, Australian, 292
Epping Forest Mus., 70
"Essex Naturalist," 227
Ethnology of Funafuti, 423
Evolution, 240, 317

,, Karl Pearson on, 50

,, Woman's Influence in, 89

, , Variation in Man and Woman,

115
,, Reproductive Divergence, 181
Evans on Flint Implements, 219
Expeditions —

Abruzzi (Alaska), 288

Andree, 66, 145

Andrews (Christmas Island), 211

Belgian Antarctic, 67

Bogdanovitch (Kamtschatka), 138

Bryant (Alaska), 68

Columbia Univ. (Alaska), 288

436

INDEX

[1897

Expeditions — {continued) —
Conway (Spitzbergen), 138
David (Funafuti), 142
Dickson (Fuego), 158
Dmitrieff (Abyssinia), 430
Drizhenko (Baikal), 138
Evans (Alaska), 139
Fewkes (Pueblo Region), 138
Fitzgerald (Aconcagua), 140
Haddon (Torres Straits), 67
Jackson -Harmsworth, 224
Nossilov (Siberia), 353
Peary, 68, 145

Perkin's (Sandwich Isles), 67
Port Barrow (Alaska), 138
Putnam (Anthropology), 68
Rothschild (Galapagos), 138
Russ. Geogr. Soc. (Roshan, &c), 66
Spurr (Alaska), 354
Wakeham (Hudson's Bay), 140.

Exploration, Polar, 145

Explorations, Sheldon (Blue Mts.), 66

Fauna, Irish, 223
Fauna of Deep Sea, 361
Fauna, protection of, 75
" Feuille Jeunes Nat.," 281, 349
Fibre-plants, a catalogue of, 373
Fishes, Atlantic, 301
Field, H. H., 285
Flint Implements, 219
" Flora of British India," 355
Flora, protection of, 75
Flowers and Bees, 100
Flowers, Seed Production of Cut, 337
Fluckioer Medal, 284
*Foraminifera, distribution of, 17
Forest-bed Vertebrata, 213
Foster, Michael, 354
Franz Josef Land, 224
Freezing of Plants, 230
" Frou-frou" and Feathers, 76
Funafuti, 5, 6, 231, 289, 359, 360, 423
Fungi and their hosts, 86

Gadow on Anat. of Birds, 144
Galapagos Exped., 138
Ganodonta, 151, 152
Gardening, school of, 213
Gee Fellowship, 213
Geogr. Inst, of Lisbon, 212
Geol. Congress, 294
Geological Nomenclature, 321
Geological Sections in Museums, 431
Geol. Survey of Canada, 354
Geol. Soc. France, 284
Geol. Survey of Japan, 140
Geologists' Assoc, 211
Geology, Arctic, 145
Geology in N.S. Wales, 232
Geol. Survey of C. Colony, 286
Geol. Survey of United Kingdom, 77
German Assoc. Nat., 212
German Botan. Soc, 212
German Zool. Soc, 212
Qingko, new discovery in, 85
dill on Oceanic Ichthyology, 71
Glands in Insects, 148
Glasgow Mus., 131

Grahamston, Albany Mus., 141, 286, 336
Granivorous Insects, 7
Graptolites in N.S. AVales, 232
Great Auk, in Ireland, 149
Great Britain, Geology, 77
Greenland, Undercurrent, 48

Map of E. Coast, 67
Grehant, Louis, 67
Godman, F. Ducane, 66
Golden Eagle, 72
Government and Provincial Museums,

74
Giinther, R. T., 211

Halifax, Nat. Hist. Mus., 69
*Halitherium, 298

Hamilton Biol. Station, 139

Harkness Scholarship, 139

Hartog, M., on Heredity, 233, 305

Harvard Univ., 213
■"Hastings, Kitchen Middens, 40, 94

Helix hortensis fossil, 228

Hemlock Lake Biol. Station, 138

Henslow, G., on Natural Selection among
Plants, 166

Heredity, 233, 305

,, of Acquired Modifications, 247

Hill, Alexander, 353

"Hirondelle" Fishes, 301

Holmes, E. M., 284

Holothuria, brood in, 226
,, spicules, 83

Hooker, Sir J. D. , 355

Hope College, 285
*Hopkins' Laboratory, 28

Howorth, H. H., on Geological Arrange-
ment and Nomenclature, 321

Hull Scientific Club, 141, 354, 430

Human Race, AVoman and Evolution of,
89

Humphry Library, 212

Hutchinson Scholarship, 139

Hutton, F. W.j on Organic Evolution,
240

Hyatt, A., on Woman and Evolution, 89

* Iclithijosaurus communis, 193

Illinois Hospital Laboratory, 429

Inheritance of acquired characters, 357

India, basic dykes in, 15

India, facetted pebbles of, 197

Indiana Acad. Sci., 285
"Indian Earthquake, 231

Indianopolis Botan. Garden, 355

Insects, North American Granivorous, 7
,, glands in, 148
,, Control, California, 148
,, of N. America, 225

" Intermediare Biol.," 281

International Floating Biological Station,
297

Internat. Geol. Congress, 294

"Inter. Journ. Micros. Nat. Sci.", 350

Internat. Postal Congress, 139

Irish Fauna, origin of, 223

Irish Field Club Union, 211

" Irish Naturalist," 135, 149

Iron and steel testing, 70

Isolation as factor of Evolution, 240

1897]

INDEX

437

Jackson legacies, 2S 1

Japan, Botanical Discovery, 85

,, Brittle Star, 84

,, Natural Science, 82
Jamaica, 212

,, Biology in. 28*

,, Johns Hopkins at, 138

,, Institute, 288

,, New Serial tor, 370
Jeffrey, John, 87
"Jersey Evening Post," 229

,, Lobster Fishery, 229

,, Nat. Sci. Assoc., 212, 2S7, 430

,, Proposed Mus., 212
" ,, Times," 229
Jennyi] Street Mus., 214
Jordan, K.. on Reproductive Divergence,

317
"Journ. Coll. Sci., Tokyo,"' 153
" ,, Conchyliol," 16
" „ Geol.,"61
" ,, Malacol,"61
«« ,, Morph.," 135
" „ NY. Entoni. Soc," 208, 225
" ,, Physiol.," 9
" ,, - School Geog.," 60
Jubilee Honours, list of, 141

Kamtschatka Exped.. 138
Kelvingrove Mus., 131
Kidd on inheritance of acquired charac-
ters, 357
"Kitchen Middens, Hastings, 40, 94
Kitson, R. H., 139
Klebs, G., on Algae, 107
Kolliker, A. von, 284
Koch and Rinderpest, 284

Laboratory for testing iron and steel,

70
Lacepede's Tableaux, 432
" Lancet," 351
Lankester, E. Ray, on Pteraspidae, &c,

45
La Plata Mus., 353
Lenian Missouri Edueat. Assoc, 285
Lepi<loptera, Neuration of, 374
Lichenotheca Universalis Miiller-Argau,

70
Literature —

Carcinology, 255
Flowers and insects, 106
Reptiles extinct, 190
See also Bibliography.
Little Barrier Island, 69
Liverpool Mus., 137
Lobster Fishery, 229
Louisiana Soc. Mus., 354
Louisiana Soc. Nat., 354, 429
Lowell Lectures, 354
Liitken, C. F. , on Steenstrup, 159
Lyons Univ., 355

M'Coy, Sir F., 211, 429
M'Kay, G. R., on Antiquity of Man in
Cape Colony, 334
,, on Castor Oil Plant, 335
Madagascar, 149 ; extinct Birds, 149
,, Experiment Station, 211

Malpighi Statue, 285

Mammalia, Tertiary, 256

Mammals of Lost Antarctic Continent,
221
,, Origin of Edentata, 150
,, Protection of, 75

Manchester .Micro. Soc, 78
,, Mus. 35 I

Man, Prehistoric, 334

Marine Biol. Assoc, 287
•Marine Biol. Lab., 28

Marsupials, 290

Mayenec, Mus. 298

Medicinal Plants of North Amer., 353

Megrim and Cod, 216

Mental development of child, 293

Miall on Biology, 219

Mias, 359

Micromotoscope, the, 149

Microscopy and photography, 149

Mimicry, 224

Mississippi Summer School of Biology,
137

Missouri Botan. Gai'den, 138

Moellendorff, O. F. von, 284

Mollusca, Brit. Pleist., 227

Monotremes, Temperature, 290

Montana Univ., 137

Moonwort in Yorkshire, 141

Moscow Univ. Mus., 69

Miiller-Argau Collection, 70

Midler Botan. Soc, 138

Miillerornis, 1 50

Murray, George, 212
*Murray, J., on Foraminifera Distribution,
17

Museums, 3, 5, 62, 63, 66, 67, 68, 69,
70, 74, 131, 132. 134, 137, 138, 139,
140, 141, 142, 143, 150, 155, 161, 162,
190, 191, 192, 194, 213, 214, 215, 223,
283,284, 286, 287, 288, 289, 298. 302,
328, 336, 348, 353, 354; 355, 360. 387.
See under name of town

Mus. Hist. Nat., Paris, 67, 155, 286

Mus. Pract. Geol., 214

Museums, 215

,, and Lecture Rooms Syndicate,

143
„ provincial, 74
,, Assoc, 74, 131

Nansen, 354

"Naturalist," 12, 135

Natural Science in Japan, 82

Natural Selection among Plants, 166

"Nature," 145

"Nauch., Oboz.," 60

" New Age," 350

Newberry Fund, 67

New Brunswick N. H. Soc, 287

New Guinea, spear-throwers, 156

" Neues Jahrb. Min.," 81

New South Wales, 232

New York Botan. Garden, 213

„ Nat. Hist. Mus., 66

,, Zool. Park, 36

North America, Insects, 7
N. Atlantic Fishes, 301
Norway, Beaver, 300

438

INDEX

[1897

Obituaries —

Abbadie, A. T. d\ 65
Acbon, H. d', 65
Allport, S., 283
Archer, W., 352
Asclian, C. Q., 210
Auerbacb, L., 428
Bastin, E. S., 65
Beclard, F., 210
Biart, L., 65, 210
Bodington, A., 65
Breitenlolmer, J., 65
Brodie, P. B., 426
Bueknill, J. Chas., 209
Bugnion, C. J. J. M., 65
Calderwood, H., 428
Calori, L., 428
Calvert, J. , 428
Carter, H. V., 65
Chudzinski, Th., 210
Console, M. A., 210
Cross, J. E., 65
Deroubaix, Dr, 65
Devvevre, A., 65
Dickson, O., 65
Dollfus, Mme., 65
Douglas, R., 210
Drechsel, E., 428
Elias, N., 209
Feulard, Dr, 65
Fissore, G., 428
Franks, A. \V., 62
Green, T., Qb
Gregory, E. L. , 65
Le Gros, E., 428
Hamilton, J., 65
Haucrbton, S., 428
Heddle, M. F., 428
Heiberg, H., 428
Heidenhain, R., 428
Heydenreich, G., 210
Hofer. D., 210
Hodgkinson, J. B., 65
Holmgren, Dr, 352
Hollander, L., 65
Horn, W., 65
Humphrey, J. E., 352
Hunter, R., 210
Huth, E., 352
James, J. F., 65
Johnston, Thos. B., 283
Jones, J. W., 210
Jordan, A., 65
Jullien, J., 210
Juranyi, L. , 65
Kessler, H. F., 65
Keyser, P. D., 65
Klatt, F. W., 65
Knabe, 210
Kolbel, K., 65
Kortschagin, A. N., 65
Kubary, J. S., 65
Laing," S., 209
Lemoine. J., 65
Liebenon, W., 352
Linell, M. L., 65
Macfarland, J. E., 65
Magi tot, E., 65
Maelure, E., 352

Obituaries — [continued) —

Malmgren, A. J., 210

Manen, L., 65

Marine, W., 428

Matthews, A., 427

Mietsehke, 428

Millais, E., 283

Mojsisovics, A., 352

Moquart, A., 210

Mueller, F., 64

Midler, D., 210

Neminar, E., 65

Nevill, H., 65

Nobile, A., 210

Oertel, Prof., 210

Ossowski, G., 210

Pasquier, L. du, 65

Petzold, K. W., 352

Piper, G. H., 428

Plugge, P. C, 210

Pulsky, F. A., 283

Robertson, C. A. L.f 65

Ross, A. M., 428

Roy, C. S., 352, 426

Russow, E. , 65

Sachs, J. von, 63

Sakaki, S., 65

Salter, S. J. A., 210

San Leon, V. T. di, 210

Schmidt, E., 352

Scholz, Ch., 65

Schutzenberger, P., 210

Sclater, B. L., 209

Scott, W., 428

Seelig, F., 65

Sintenis, M. , 428

Steenstrup, Johannes J. S. , 88, 159

Stocquart, A., 65

Stoeber, 296

Straub, F. C, 210

Sutton, A., 210

Teinturier, J. M., 65

Traill, G. W., 65

Travis, I. N., 428

Trumbull, J. H., 352

Tunner, P., 210

Verlot, P. B. L., 210

Vogel, K., 352

Volger, O., 428

Wankel, H., 65

Watson, E. Y., 427

Welcher, Dr, 352

Wells, Chas. F., 210

Wight, R. A., 210

Wilckens, M., 210

Wolfert, Dr, 210
Oceanic Ichthyology, 71
Ogilby on Australian Nat. Hist, and

Funafuti, 359
Obio State Univ., 213
Oldham, R. D., on facetted pebbles, 197
Ophiurid, Japan, 83
Ord on Museums, 215
Oregon Botan. Assoc, 87
Organic Evolution, 240
Orgyin, 8
Orizaba, 140

Ostracoderms of Cope, 144
Ova of Vertebrate, 153

1897]

INDEX

439

Owen's College, 353

Packard on artheopods, 72
Pamir Dwarfs, 67

Parasites, 7, 8, 86
*Paria8auru8 baini, 195

Paris Mus. Hist. Nat., 67, 155, 286

Patagonia, 12 1 I

Patagonian geology, 221, 222, 364

Pearson, Karl, on Evolution, 50 ; on
Variability, 115

Pebbles, facetted, 197

Peel Park Mus., Salford, 132

Pennsylvania Univ. Mus., 139

" Pensiero Moderna," 208

Peoria Univ., 285

Perthshire Nat. Hist. Mus., 131, 354
,, Soc. Nat. ScL, 35 1

Phenacomys, 3

Philadelphia Acad. Sci., 287

•• Photogram," 60, 135

Photography of moving organisms, 149

Physiology of the senses, 69

Phyllopods, British, 7'.'

Pigments of Decapods, 9

Pinus Jeffreyi, 87

Plant-Chemistry, 12

Plants, Freezing of, 230

,, Natural Selection, 166
,, and the Weather, 12
•Plateau Man, 327

Pleistocene Mollusca, British, 227
*Plesio8auru8 rostratus, 193

Pleurotomaria beyrichi, 139

Plon Biol. Station, 66, 138

Polar Exploration, 145

" Policlinico," 80

Polymorphism in Algae, 107
*Portraits, "Challenger," 3

Postages on specimens, 139

"Press," Christchurcb, N.Z., 60

Pribyloff Islands, survey, 67

Primroses, 13

"Proc. Biol. Soc., Washington," 4, 87

" ,, Geol. Ass.," 227

" ,, Linn. Soc," 156, 229, 282, 292

" ,, Roy. Irish Acad.," 61, 223

" ,, Roy. Soc.," 61

" .. R. Soc, Dublin," 4

" „ Roy. Soc, Edin.," 11

" ,, Roy. Soc, Victoria," 282, 291
* Protocaris marslii, 399

" Psychol. Review," 293, 350

Psychology, 69

Pteraspidae, 45

Publications, False Dates of, 16

Purpurin, 13

"Puss "moth, 148

" Quart. Journ. Geol. Soc," 158, 282
Quart. Journ. Micros. ScL, 61, 217, 282
Quick, R., on Plateau Man, 432

Radcliffe Lirrary, 70, 429
Radiolaria, Pre-Cambrian, 229
Raffles Mus., Singapore, 141
Rath, G. von, 66

" Rec Geol. Surv., India," 15, 231
"Rep. Geol. Surv., N.S.W.," 232

"Rep. Geol. Surv., U.K.," 77
*Reports, "Challenger, "contributors to, 3

Reproduction of Diatoms, 10
Reproductive Divergence, 181, 317, 401
* Reptiles, Restoration of extinct, 190
,, temperature, 290
Reviews —

Acloque's Faune de France, 130
"Aeronautical Annual," 1897, 60
L'Annee Biologkpue, 80
Austral. Mus. Funafuti Mem., 5, 231,

423
Baron's Madagascar Geology, 281
Bateman's Vivarium, 3 11
Bonney's William Pengelly, 346
Brit. Mus. Fossil Invertebrates, 132
Bryan and Rosenberg's Mechanics of

Fluids, 276
Campbell's Bibliography, 342
"Challenger" Portraits, 3
Collett's Poissons. 301
Concise Natural History, 205
Crick and Foord's Fossil Cephalopoda,

Part III., 203
Davies' Physiography, 275
Dawson's Primeval Life, 133
Delage and Herouard's Zoologie Con-
crete, 200
Dolbear's Natural Philosophy, 276
Drude's Geographie Botanique, 207
Foord and Crick's Fossil Cephalopoda,

Part III., 203
Foster-Barham's Westmorelandshire's

Field Geology, 134
Geikie's British Volcanoes, 55
Geikie's Founders of Geology, 415
Gill's Our Naturalists, 134
Gray's N. Amer. Flora, 340
Hansen's Choniostomatidae, 271
Harrison's Geology, 276
Herouard and Delage's Zoologie Con-
crete, 200
Hertwig's Zoologie, 128
Hofmann's Beetle-collector's Hand-
book, 130
Holland's Hill-slopes around Naini-

Tal, 279
Kirby's Lepidoptera, 206
Koken's Leitfossilien, 269
Lewis' Diamond, 278
Martin's Nature-Chat, 344
Merrill's Death of Rocks, 417
Miall's Round the Year, 59
Munro's Prehistoric Problems, 273
Museums Assoc. Rep., 131
Ogilvie's Madreporarian Types of

Corals, 124
Paget's John Hunter, 346
Parker's Biology, 348
Parker's Wiedersheim's Vertebrates.

348
Pearson's Chances of Death, &c, 50
Pelseneer's Zoologie, 340
Pengelly's William Pengelly, 346
Poirault's Drude's Geographie Bo-

tanique, 207
Reynold's Vertebrate Skeleton, 347
Ribot's Psychology of Emotions,
343

440

INDEX

[1897

Reviews — (continued) —

Rosenberg and Brvan's Mechanics of

Fluids, 276
Russel's Volcanoes of N. America, 421
Saville-Kent's Naturalist in Australia,

265
Schiller on Darwinism and Design,

408
Skertchly's Physical Geography, 275
Scherren's Through a Pocket- Lens, 129
Schniewind-Thies'Septalnectarien, 277
Scripture's New Psychology, 343
Trouessart's Catalogus Mammalium,

424
Wilson's Applied Nature, 280
" Rev. G6n. Botan.," 60
"Rev. Ital. Sociol.," 60
" Rev. Mus. Paulista," 351
"Rev. Nueva," 61
"Rev. Quindic Psicol.," 61
"Rev. Sci.," 2
Rliinoceros in Singapore, 359 ; tichor-

hinus skin, 141
*Ridewood, W. G. , on Extinct Reptiles, 190
Ridley on Birds and Mammals of Singa-
pore, 359
Rocks, Death of, 417
Romanes Lecturer, 429
Royal Botanic Society, 213
Rum, bad, 87
Russia, geology of, 294
St Petersburg Zool. Mus., 141
Salamander, Giant, at Paris, 138
Salford, Peel Park Mus., 132
Salix, 14, 143

San Francisco Zool. Gardens, 66
Santa Cruz formation, 222
Surcidiomis, 150
Schleswig-Holstein Mus., 131
"Science," 61, 208, 281
Science in Elementary Schools, 69
"Scientific American," 149
Schafer, E. A., 284
Sclcrotinia hetcroica, 86
' Scot. Geog. Mag.," 60, 134, 158
"Scot. Med. Surg. Journ., 281
*Sclater, P. L., on Zool. Park, N.Y., 36
*Sea-Co\v, 29S
Sea-Cucumbers, 83
Sebastopol Biol. Stations, 137
Seed Production of Cut Flowers, 337
Selborne Society, 76
Seton-Karr's Implements, 137
Shell in Bivalves, Embryonic, 10
Sherborn, C. Davies, 211

,, on Lacepede's Tableaux, 432

Shrewsbury Mus., 140
Sliute Scholarship, 67
Singapore, Rattles Mus., 141
Sinclair on Funafuti, 360
Sirenia, the, 223, 298
Slugs, 71
Smith, B. Leigh, on Arctic Undercurrent,

48
Smithsonian Inst., 353
Society helo^tique, 139
Sommering Prize, 212
Sofia Univ.. 355
Solifugae, 226

Solpuga, 226

Somerset Arch. Nat. Hist. Soc, 287

S. America, Edentate Mammals, 152
,, Mammals. 221

,, Tertiary Mammalia, 256

S. African Republic Museum, 286
,, Museum, 68, 286

South-Eastern Union of Sci. Soc, 70, 73,
214

S. India, Basic Dyke-Rocks, 15

Spanish Universities, 67

Spendiarov, L., 355

,, Fund, 355

Spear-throwers, 156

Springfield Zool. Club, 138

Spitzbergen, Undercurrent, 48

Stebbing, T. R. R. , on Carcinology, 251
*Steenstrup, J. J., 88, 159

Stomachs of Birds, 146

Stratigraphical Geology, 364

" Studies from Nature," 281

Swansea Mus. , 353

Swansea Univ. College, 353

Swedish Arctic Expedition, 366

Sydney, Australian Mus., 5, 143, 231,
289, 360

Tansley, A. G. See Klebs on Algae

Taunton Mus. , 287

Tayler, J. L., on Acquired Modifications,

247
Technical Education Grant, 73
"Technol. Quart," 282
Temperatures of Vertebrates, 290
Termites of Australia, 292
Tertiary Mammalia, 256
*Thomson, Chas. Wyville, 3
Thomson, Joseph, 66
Thurlow Meteorite, 354
Tierra del Fuego, 158
Titanus Gold Medal, 66
" Timehri," 351
"Times" on Archaeology, 219
Tokyo Imp. Coll. tSci., 67
Training of Biologists, 217
"Trans. Entotn. Soc, London," 148
"Trans. Manchester Micros. Soc," 78
"Trans. N.Y. Acad. Sci.," 61
"Trans. Perth Soc. Nat. Sci.," 350
"Trans. S. E. Union Sci. Soc," 73
Trefoils, 13
Trepanning, 154
Triassic Cephalopoda, 228
Tribonyx, 150
Trinidad, 212

Undercurrent in Arctic Ocean, 48
US. Dept. Agriculture, 148
U.S. Geolog. Survey, 431
U.S. Nat. Mus., 138, 213, 288
Univ. Coll., Liverpool, 213
Univ. Degrees for Women, 1

,, Extension Lectures, 355

,, of London, 214
Urumiya, Lake, 211

Variability, scientific measure of, 115
Vernon, H. M. , on Reproductive Diverg-
ence, 181, 404

1897]

INDEX

441

Yertebrata, Ova of, 153
Virginia, Geol. Survey of W., 285
Victoria Institute, Worcester, 140
" Victorian Naturalist," 293
Volcanoes of N. America, 421

Washington Zool. Park, 353

Wasps and Weather, 368

Weather and Plants, 12

Weather and Wasps, 368

Weldon, W. F. R., on Karl Pearson's

"Chances of Death," 50
"Westminster Review," 69, 135
Whidbome's Devonian types, 143
White, Alex., 284
Whitechapel Public Library, 14, 355

,, Mus., 140, 355

Whyte, Alex., 139
Willows, 14, 113
Wiltshire Library, 67
Winchester Col. Mus., 70
Wing Ncuration of Lepidoptera, 374
Wuhner Forest, preservation of, 431
Women at Cambridge, 1

of the future,
bearded, 2, 215
and feathers, 76,

359

Women in Univ. of Chicago, 284
,, Influence in Evolution, 89

Woodward, A. S. on Cope's Ostracoderms,
144

Wood-bison, 139

Woodward, Henry, 212

Woodwardian Mus., 67

Worcester Mus., 140, 141

Yale Univ., 213, 355
"Year Book U.S. Dept
Yellow Fever Bacillus, 285

Agric.,'

208

Zamia, 157

Zamias, 156

"Zeitschr. Pflanz. krank.," 86

"Zool. Anz.,"80, 226

" ,, Bull.," 135

" ,, Forsch. Austral. ; Malay. Archi-

pel.," 223
" ,, Jahr. Ber.,"81

,, Mus. Cambridge, 348

,, Park, N.Y., 36
" ,, Rec," 81

,, Soc. Medal, 139
Zurich, Mus., 197
Zwaardemaker, Dr, 66

2 I

Ai^H

'-O

■J>(

'#&.

Sv u

Internet Archive Audio

Featured

Top

Images

Featured

Top

Software

Featured

Top

Books

Featured

Top

Video

Featured

Top

Mobile Apps

Browser Extensions

Archive-It Subscription

Save Page Now

Full text of "Natural science"

See other formats