Full text of "Oceanus"
H. B. BIGELOW ISSUE
VOL. XIV, NO. 2, JULY 1968
ON THE COVER-
HENRY BRYANT BIGELOW
1879
1967
Leader in the Study of the Sea. Worthy Exemplar of the
Agassiz tradition. Biologist: Distinguished Teacher. Judicious
Advisor. Humanist. Sportsman.
Author of "Oceanography, its Scope, Problems and Eco-
nomic Importance", which led to the establishment of the
Woods Hole Oceanographic Institution in 1930 and laid the
foundation of modern oceanography.
Director 1930-1940. President 1940-1950. Chairman of the
Board of Trustees 1950-1960. Founder Chairman 1960-1967.
Jan H;thn, Editor
Published quarterly and distributed to the Associates, to
Marine libraries and universities around the world, to
other educational institutions, to major city public
libraries and to other organizations and publications.
Library of Congress Catalogue Card Number: 59-34518
Noel B. McLean
Chairman, Board oi Trustees
Paul M. Fye
President and Director
Columbus O'D. Iselin
H. 8. Bigelow Oceanographer
Bostwick H. Ketchum
Associofe Director
Arthur E. Maxwell
Associate Director
Vol. XIV, No. 2 July 1968
( ] f"^ C /\ INwj | J C^ THE WOODS HOLE OCEANOGRAPHIC INSTITUTION
™ Woods Hole, Massachusetts
Q
OCEANOGRAPHY has been aptly defined as the study of the world below
the surface of the sea; it should include the contact zone between sea and atmos-
phere. According to present-day acceptance it has to do with all the characteristics
of the bottom and margins of the sea, of the sea water, and of the inhabitants of
the latter. Thus widely combining geophysics, geochemistry, and biology, it is
inclusive, as is, of course, characteristic of any 'young' science: and modern oceanog-
raphy is in its youth. But in this case it is not so much immaturity that is responsible
for the fact that these several sub-sciences are still grouped together, but rather the
realization that the physics, chemistry, and biology of the sea water are not only
important per se, but that in most of the basic problems of the sea all three of these
subdivisions have a part. And with every advance in our knowledge of the sea
making this interdependence more and more apparent, it is not likely that we shall
soon see any general abandonment of this concept of oceanography as a mother
science, the branches of which, though necessarily attacked by different disciplines,
are intertwined too closely to be torn apart. Every oceanic biologist should, there-
fore, be grounded in the principles of geophysics and geochemistry; every chemical
or physical oceanographer in some of the oceanic aspects of biology."
HENRY BRYANT BIGELOW
HIS definition of oceanography was written so well, with such vision that I
would challenge anyone to find or submit a better one, even to-day.
In April 1927, the President of the National Academy of Sciences, Professor
A. A. Michelson, appointed a committee with Frank R. Lillie as the Chairman, to
consider the share of the United States of America in a world-wide program of
oceanographic research and report to the Academy. Subsequently, Dr. Bigelow
was invited to make investigations and prepare a report. The report led the
Academy to recommend the establishment of a well-equipped oceanographic
institution on the east coast. The result was that our Institution was established almost
full blown in the course of a year, with Dr. Bigelow as director.* I urge anyone
who has not done SO to read the book "Oceanography, its Scope, Problems and
Economic Importance", Houghton Mifflin, 1931 which contains parts of the original
report. Many of Dr .Bigelow's recommendations are as valid in 1968 as they were
in 1929.
Paul M. Fye
Director
Most books tell what their authors
know or think they know. Henry B.
Bigelow's "Oceanography" (Houghton,
Mifflin) is devoted to telling what Mr.
Bigelow does not know, to what, in fact,
no one knows.
Lewis Gannett
(Book Review, N. Y. Times, 1931)
*For a full account of the developments see Chapter IX in: "The Woods Hole Marine Biological
Laboratory" by Frank R. Lillie. The Univ. of Chicago Press. 1944.
,
HENRY BRYANT BIGELOW
3 October 1879 — 11 December 1967
An Appreciation . . .
H,
.ENRY BRYANT BIGELOW died
on December llth, 1967, aged 88 years.
The world seemed suddenly to have be-
come appreciably poorer. When 1 first
met Henry Bigelow he had recently lost
a son in a mountaineering accident, and
the impression that I gained was of a
stricken saint. Saintliness was a quality
that he would have disclaimed. He was
a many-sided, warm and human person,
loving the open air and the occupations
that go with it. I have not previously
heard of a saint who so much enjoyed
partridge shooting. Nevertheless, my first
impression was to be borne out by my
later experience of him. From his boy-
hood and for the whole of his life Henry
loved the outdoors and every facet of
natural life. At the age of 26 he married
Elizabeth Perkins Shattuck, who shared
this love and accompanied him on many
journeys. It was indeed tragic that they
should lose not only a son in the out-
doors, but shortly afterwards their elder
daughter in an accident with a horse.
They always treated their many friends
with great generosity. In the early years
of the Second World War we lived in
Lowestoft, which was rather too near the
enemy and rather often lightly bom-
barded. It was characteristic of the
Bigelows to offer to take our children and,
as it were, adopt them for the duration
of the war. This seemed to us a very
sensible action to take, so much so that
it was; I think, three days before we
decided to decline it. After the war we
did not decline but joyfully accepted an
equally generous offer to take one of our
children, who had suffered a serious ill-
ness, and treat her as a Bigelow daughter
for a year. These kindnesses were only
examples, though large ones, of the way
that the Bigelows treated their friends
who visited them. There was in their
behaviour as hosts not only the utmost
consideration but also a determination to
take trouble to make the visits exceed-
ingly interesting for their guests. They
remain as vivid memories.
There must have been a score or more
sayings of Henry Bigelow that should be
down on paper. Two have stayed with
me over the decades. One was the re-
minder of Mark Twain's definition of
ignorance; "not so much not knowing
things, as knowing things that ain't so."
The other was a dirge of woe about the
mistake of ever becoming a Director. "I
can't think why anybody tries for it."
I was often to think of that later when I
learned from my own experience that the
staff bring to the Director only the prob-
lems to which there is no good solution.
They solve all the easy and pleasant ones
themselves; and there is almost no limit
to the kind of problem that crops up
among a staff of any reasonable size.
Looking over the list of Henry Bigelow's
associates from Europe, I feel that one
of his great qualities was that he had a
definite effect on everybody who worked
near him or dealt with him in any way. I
remember myself the impact he made on
the International Council for the Explora-
tion of the Sea when he came to see us in
Europe in March 1931 as representative
of the North American Committee on
Fishery Investigation. Throughout the
proceedings the conference was richer
whenever he was present. I am sure that
it was the same when European workers
came to work in association with him.
One had the feeling that he was a man of
such excellence and such exceeding pleas-
antness that not for a moment would one
relax in the effort to do one's very best in
order to support him as far as possible.
That was my personal feeling and it is
clear and to me at least, very remarkable,
that he must have had the same effect on
the eleven or so people whose names are
in front of me: Hjort, Helland-Hansen,
Schmidt, Knudsen, Maurice, Stanley
Gardiner, D'Arcy Thompson, Vedel
Taning, F. S. Russell and le Danois. A. G.
Huntsman of Canada and Bigelow were,
as I saw during the Passamaquoddy
Investigations, close colleagues and joint
venturers in many an enterprise. Out of
the friendship with Hjort came their joint
fishing for prawns in U.S. deep water
similar to that of the Norwegian fjords
and so — I have always supposed — the
development of this fishery in the Gulf of
Maine and elsewhere.
I remember D'Arcy Thompson, who at
that time was by no means recognized as
he deserved to be, holding forth on the
subject of professors who took all the
limelight for themselves, and those others
whose chief monument was a series of
very distinguished students. On the latter
score Bigelow ranks high. We have not
only Herrington, Nesbit, Schroeder, Sette
and Walford, all of whom are recognized
as being of the first rank in fishery and
marine research, but also Smith, Ricketts,
Hoyle and Graves of the International Ice
Patrol, whose work is known all over the
world, and one who' became his colleague
— George L. Clarke. Two students were
to succeed him in the directorship at
Woods Hole: Columbus OTJ. Iselin and
Edward H. Smith.
That is not to say that Bigelow put
teaching before research. He did not seek
the limelight but his record is one of
absolutely steady and painstaking research
from contact with the field. Always he
put the importance of field observations
high. There is a story that once he was
so angry with a student who drew the
insides of an animal from his imagination
that his outburst disqualified him from
being allowed near any student for quite
some years.
As a young man, between the ages of
23 and 28, Bigelow published papers on
various biological subjects, but already at
the age of 25 he was working on coelen-
terates including medusae from the Mai-
dive Islands, where he had been on an
expedition with Alexander Agassiz. This
was the beginning of what I am inclined
to call the coelenterate period of Bigelow's
biological work, and it continued as his
main interest for 16 years. It really ran
on for much longer than that with isolated
papers, as his bibliography shows. There
was a paper on medusae as late as 1940.
Sir Frederick Russell writes to me—
"Throughout his career Bigelow had a
lasting interest in the systematics and
biology of the pelagic cnidarians on which
group he was an acknowledged master.
His report in 1909 on the medusae of the
eastern tropical Pacific collected by the
Albatross is a classic and set the standard
for his many succeeding papers. It is
sufficient surely to say that his name
stands among the few who have laid the
foundations of our knowledge of this
group. Bigelow studied also the siphon-
ophores, the group in which in his latter
years he collaborated with Mary Sears.
His report in 1911 on the Albatross siph-
onophores was of the same standard as
that on the medusae. It is said by Totton
in his 1965 Synopsis of the Siphonophora
that the 1911 report is 'the most useful
systematic report on the Siphonophora
that has ever been written.' Bigelow thus
undoubtedly ranks as a great systematic
zoologist."
The life of the young man up to the
age of 33 was based on the Museum of
Comparative Zoology at Harvard where
Bigelow had graduated in 1901. The
Museum life was broken by expeditions
with Agassiz, the one to the Maldive
Islands already mentioned and others to
the east and tropical Pacific and the West
Indies.
Following a meeting with Sir John
Murray in the Museum, there began in
1912 what must be considered as the
second and major work of Bigelow's life,
the cruises in the Gulf of Maine. The
schooner Grampus was made available for
a joint expedition by the Museum and the
United States Bureau of Fisheries, and
was conducted by Henry Bigelow for
1 2 years. Although he suffered from sea-
sickness he spent the greater part of
every year in making observations in the
Gulf of Maine with very primitive re-
sources and mainly as a "one-man band."
This is where the patient determination
of the good field observer was called upon
to a degree that cannot fail to arouse our
admiration. The three book-size mono-
graphs that resulted were respectively on
the fishes, the plankton and the hydrog-
raphy of the Gulf. And each is a classic
because the completeness derives from
close observation at sea. On the fishes he
had the help of W. W. Welsh until his
untimely death, thereafter he had to com-
plete it himself. It has always seemed to
me that these monographs, since I first
encountered them in 1930 on joining the
Passamaquoddy Commission, gave a
better and more coherent account than
that work done by so many more hands
in an area of comparable size, namely the
North Sea. I found in the highly uncertain
and difficult area of the Bay of Fundy that
there was at least this firm and reliable
basis on the parent sea, namely the Gulf
of Maine.
That had not been so in 1912. Until
Bigelow started, there was virtually no
knowledge of the biology of the off-shore
waters, and for one man to have made
such a clear and complete job of a rela-
tively large area, which has a wide mouth
open to the ocean, was a monumental job
of which any man could be proud even if
he had done nothing else in his whole life.
I think that we can fairly call this phase
of the work by the name 'oceanography,'
and just as Henry Bigelow sailed as as-
sistant to one of the original founders of
oceanography, we might call him one of
the founders of the new oceanography,
that is oceanography with an ecological
aim, so that instead of the mere descrip-
tion of what there was in the sea, there
should be an explanation of the inter-
connections based on full knowledge and
the applications of other branches of
science.
He developed this idea from 1927 on-
wards as secretary of the Committee on
Oceanography of the National Academy
of Sciences. His report to the Academy
on the United States contribution to the
study of the oceans resulted in the found-
ing of the Woods Hole Oceanographic
Institution, of which he was the first
Director. Later he was President and
then Chairman of the Board of Trustees
and his association with the Institution
lasted for 30 years.
On the staffing of the new institution I
quote the account in the preface to
"Bigelow Volume" of this journal in 1955
— "The task of assembling a staff for
the new oceanographic institution at
Woods Hole was not an easy one for there
was little raw material with which to
work. There were a few young men with
some experience at sea and by combing
the museums of the country doubtless he
could have assembled a respectable group
of experts on special groups of marine
organisms. The primary objective how-
ever was to give impetus to oceanographic
studies in the universities and there was
the developing viewpoint to be fostered.
He chose the bolder course of educating
a new generation drawn from the univer-
sities: physical chemists, meteorologists,
physiologists, bacteriologists, whoever
could be persuaded that scope for their
skills could be found in studies at sea."
That quotation, I think, substantiates
my view that Henry Bigelow was a founder
of modern oceanography. From this group
of men of diverse skills and knowledge
that he formed at Woods Hole has grown
one of the world's most famed oceano-
graphic institutes and one that continues
to lead in many branches of marine
science.
Already in 1927, Henry Bigelow had
begun a collaboration with William C.
Schroeder, which was the beginning of the
third phase in his biological work, that of
writing systematic treatises on the fish of
the North Atlantic, including the Gulf of
Maine. This was the work that continued
until his death. It was clear even in 1930
when I was in contact with that side of the
North Atlantic, that the systematics of the
fish was by no means complete in spite of
the excellent work that had been done by
Bigelow's predecessors. Year by year, and
sometime more than once a year, the gap
was filled in, brick by brick as it were,
including his monumental work as Part 1
of the Fishes of the Western North Atlantic
in 1948, Part 2 in 1953 and in collabora-
tion with others, Parts 3 and 4 in 1963
and 1964. As lately as 1965, there ap-
peared A further account of batoid fishes
from the Western Atlantic and Notes on a
small collection of rajiids from the sub-
Antarctic region. A paper in 1956 had
announced even a new family of Batoid
fish. I will hazard the opinion that a great
many biologists have gone to their graves
without adding as much in their lifetime to
knowledge as Henry Bigelow did in this,
his third department of professional work.
Bigelow's progress from the position of
a comparatively obscure assistant in the
Museum of Comparative Zoology to full
professorship at Harvard in 1931 could
not be called very rapid academic promo-
tion, but nevertheless, he felt strongly his
obligation to his students and maintained
his teaching for many years, not only in
oceanography, but also in invertebrate
zoology. He maintained his professorship
until the age of 70, and I have heard of
him attending at the Museum until very
much later, indeed he was still studying the
fishes there to within a very short while of
his death. His last paper is "in press" at
the present writing.
Bigelow's work was generally recog-
nized. He was granted an honorary degree
by Yale University and then by Harvard
and by the University of Oslo. He received
the Johannes Schmidt Medal, the Agassiz
Medal, the Elliot Medal, the Bowie Medal,
the Monaco Medal and was the first recip-
ient of the Henry Bryant Bigelow Medal
for Oceanography, established in his hon-
our in 1966 by the trustees of the Woods
Hole Oceanographic Institution. He was
elected to membership of the National
Academy of Sciences, the American
Academy of Arts and Sciences and the
American Philosophical Society. He was
affiliated with the Norske Videnskaps
Akademi, the Royal Geographical Society
of London, the Zoological Society of
London and the Marine Biological As-
sociation of the United Kingdom.
In spite of all these notable achieve-
ments, I feel sure that Henry Bigelow
himself would be more pleased than any-
thing else that we had noted his remark-
ably long record. It would please him I
am sure to think that his published papers
should extend over 68 years, from 1901-
1968. We know that he was quite proud
that he had been on the staff at Harvard
for longer than any other person had been,
in the whole of the long and distinguished
history of that university. Technically
Henry Bigelow can be described as having
bridged the period from the original
oceanography to modern oceanography
and the present day. Truly, however, his
character seems timeless. He would have
delighted the people of the Elizabethan
period, or those of early New England or,
I steadfastly believe, those of the times
that lie ahead.
He is survived by his widow Elizabeth,
a son Frederick Shattuck Bigelow and
daughter Mary, Mrs. Lamar Soutter.
MICHAEL GRAHAM
Rivington
Bo/fon
England
Reprinted by permission of the Pergamon
Press from: Deep Seo Research, Vol. 15, No. 2,
April 1968
THE HARVARD CRIMSON
WEDNESDAY, DECEMBER 10, 1930.
Professor Bigelow Heads Oceanographic Institute
Begun by $2,500,000 Rockefeller Foundation Gift
Harvard Staff Will Assist in
New Enterprise at
Woods Hole
Undergraduates Will be Able
to Participate in
Informal Study
J™"'
^^^^^hk^^^'V M ^P*tt M •
*T [•• '«
Dr. Bigelow at a departure of the 'Atlantis'. At left is Columbus O'D. Iselin. At right the
late Captain Henry Mandley, Jr., second mate on the vessel and one of the last of the
American whalemen. Jhe lady is unidentified.
T
0 attempt to write adequately about
Henry Bryant Bigelow is extremely diffi-
cult, especially for one who had the
privilege of being one of his students. I
discovered Dr. Bigelow when I was 21.
Thus, I have known him and have sought
out his advice during all of my mature life.
His advice was always good.
I was a junior at Harvard before I was
smart enough to discover that Harvard
had Dr. Bigelow. I had a terrible time
finding him, but I finally located him on
the top floor of the Museum of Coopera-
tive Zoology in a much cluttered room,
bending over a very dead fish with William
Schroeder. In ten minutes my entire
career was changed. I was supposed to be
a banker.
1 told him about my growing interest
in marine science and hardly looking up
from his little fish he told me that I was
reading in the wrong library. For anything
having to do with oceanography, the
library at the Museum was much the better
one. I still have the notes which I made
while reading in those days and they
include Dr. Bigelow's recommendations
for what he considered the more important
aspects of marine science on which one
should focus attention.
Dr. Bigelow and several of his student
friends, each of whom became a full pro-
fessor at Harvard, had made a summer's
cruise along the coast of Labrador. Twenty
years later, I essentially retraced their
steps. He and his associates had certainly
skimmed off the scientific cream. We
found in 1928 poor pickings, although we
had much fun.
The next winter, when I returned to the
Museum, Dr. Bigelow was in the midst
of two mammoth projects: he had just
about finished his classical studies of all
aspects of the Gulf of Maine and at the
same time he was serving as the secretary
for a National Academy of Sciences Com-
mittee on Oceanography. I was able to
help him some on his writings about the
Gulf of Maine, but in his thinking about
the future of oceanography he was so
much ahead of me that I gave up. The
book that he wrote remains to this day
the bible of marine science. He outlined
all the problems that have kept his many
students busy during the subsequent
40 odd years. It will require many more
years to complete the job that he so clearly
outlined.
As I came to know Dr. Bigelow as a
man, rather than just as a scientist, I began
to realize how much of an outdoor man he
really was. He was a dead shot all his days,
he could sail a racing sloop about as well
as his friend and neighbor, Charles Francis
Adams; he could paddle a canoe or row
a boat a great deal better; he enjoyed
mountain climbing and he seriously took
up skiing at the age of 60. His one physical
weakness was that in the open ocean he
was often seasick.
On his daily trips to Cambridge, he
continued to grind out important science.
Many of the references are of book length.
He leaves behind a daughter and a son,
and an especially lovely wife. His privi-
leged students, such as I, stand in
amazement at how much the man accom-
plished. While one can resort to claiming
that he worked dilligently at it for at least
68 years, I doubt that anyone has ever
accomplished more for the general welfare
of marine science than Henry Bryant
Bigelow. You will find more complete
accounts of his remarkable achievements,
but I choose to be brief because I doubt
that any of his other students ever had
the chance that I had to know the whole
man.
C. O'D. /se/in
H. B. Bigelow Oceanographer
Dr. Bigelow and Mr. W. C. Schroeder, life-
long collaborators, on "Bigelow Day".
August 19, 1960.
M
.Y first meeting with Dr. Henry B. Bigelow was in the spring of 1923 in
Washington, D. C. at the U.S. Bureau of Fisheries. His visit concerned a cod
tagging project to which 1 had been assigned. I invited him to lunch and he, being
a New Englander, I selected a restaurant noted for its seafoods. However, seafood
was not his dish. Also, he insisted on paying for his meal inasmuch as the Govern-
ment was paying him four dollars a day for hotel and meals. So that was that.
Little did I know how fortunate I was to have joined up with Dr. Bigelow,
for my close association with him lasted without interruption until his death in
December 1967. Never was there a cross word between us. Any job he tackled
was sure to be a success and one has only to read his "Memories of a Long and
Active Life", published in 1964, to realize how truly active he was. Pessimism
certainly was not a part of his life whereas humor was. Languages, French,
German, Spanish, etc. he could handle well and I was amused one day when he
was paid a visit by a French colleague with whom he carried out an animated
conversation in the native tongue. 1 say 1 was amused because it was the only
time in our life long association that I was to hear Dr. Bigelow speak French.
W. C. Schroeder
8
For many years Dr. Bigelow was President of the Tihonet Club, a fishing club at Wareham,
Mass., and for the last two years, until his death, he was Honorary Club President.
I
HAVE fished with Henry a good many times over quite a good many years. Our
fishing acquaintance started by Henry showing me all the little known spots where
trout are apt to hide, especially in hot weather. He knew a half dozen or so of such
spots which I think at that time nobody else had found. Probably on account of
that, in all the years I have fished Tihonet I have so far never failed to catch at
least one trout per day.
Three times Henry and I arranged a fishing party at Tihonet with James B.
Conant and James Phinney Baxter. We would split our guests between us for
fishing, and assemble at meals, where the conversation was most stimulating.
Baxter's limitless memory would start Conant off, and Henry and I put in an
occasional remark, either to keep the two going, or to shift them to another subject.
I remember that on one of these occasions Henry had complained that Harvard had
retired him too early. Both Conant and I maintained that, if it were not for his
distinction, he would have been retired earlier. At the time of his retirement 1 had
commissioned Henry to use his vast knowledge about fish and their habitat, plus
his increased leisure, to find out why our best fishing pond, the Frogfoot Reservoir,
became so murky in the summer months of each year that fly fishing was totally
unproductive. As far as I could see, Henry did nothing about it, but the Reservoir
did clear just before this particular trip with Conant and Baxter. Henry and Conant
had a lengthy discussion about why it had cleared, and decided that the copper in
the natural gas pipeline which had recently been laid under the Reservoir had done
the trick. I am not sure that they were right, because the Reservoir has reverted
to its murkiness.
As recently as two years ago, Henry and I went on our last Tihonet fishing
expedition together. In spite of his age, he insisted on helping me lift the canoe on
and off the car, and on carrying one end of it from the road to the water. He com-
plained about his casting, saying his wrists had lost their spring; but he handled a
line of proper length, and when we fished a narrow, winding stream running through
a cranberry bog, with a strong wind, Henry caught his fly on the cranberry bushes
less than I did.
While Henry's conversation was always interesting, I do not remember any
"bon mots" as good as the one Parker Perry has contributed. It was Henry's obvious
enjoyment of the fishing, the decisions of where to go and what fly to use, the anec-
dotes of his early fishing experiences, and above all his friendly companionship,
that made our trips together so memorable for me.
Charles A. Coolidge
17 OUR of us were chatting after supper,
and I asked Dr. Bigelow a question.
"Dr. Bigelow, you are one of the world's
most prominent authorities on ichthyology,
and I believe you have perhaps fished for
trout and salmon in more rivers and
streams throughout the world than any
other living American. As you know, I
too love the sport and I have tested many
of the more popular theories for successful
fishing. Would you pass on to me your
own formula for success?"
Dr. Bigelow replied: "Well, Parker, I
have known you since you were a little
boy and yes, 1 will share with you my
secret of successful fishing."
I waited with bated breath, for this
pearl of wisdom from such a great
authority.
And then, Dr. Bigelow with his quizzi-
cal smile said: "Be there when the fish
are biting!"
Parker D. Perry
H.B.8. on board the 'Atlantis'
with J. Greenwood.
J_ HE summer months I spent at Woods
Hole, between 1931 and 1941, were
always a sheer delight to me, scientifically
speaking, largely due to the genius of
Henry Bigelow, who never missed an
opportunity to come to my laboratory on
the second floor of the main building. He
usually brought with him a visiting scien-
tist or just dropped in for a few minutes
chat. His humor and genial manner were
highly stimulating and gave me a much
broader outlook of the problems dealing
with the sea.
Dr. Bigelow's first question to me when
I met him in the spring of 1931, at the
home of Professor Conklin in Princeton,*
after I had been informed of the plans
for the Woods Hole Institution, was: "Do
you think that we should also consider
marine bacteria"? The twinkle in his eye
and my appreciation of his profound
knowledge of marine processes, as shown
in his classical book on "oceanography"
*See my paper on "Marine bacteria" in the
1955 volume of Deep Sea Research dedicated to
Dr. Bigelow.
that led to the establishment of the Insti-
tute, convinced me that he was testing
me for my own knowledge of the prob-
lems involved. Without hesitation, my
answer was in the affirmative. When, at
the end of the month's stay in 1931 at
Woods Hole, I presented to him a plan
for organizing a marine bacteriology
program, he asked me again: "Would you
like to do it"? There was again only one
answer, namely, a positive one.
Henry Bigelow's humor was well ex-
pressed in his talks at the weekly meet-
ings of the staff. He addressed the first
meeting in 1931, on the subject: "The
seas that I vomited in." Thus he set the
tone for others to follow. I believe that
it was my turn the following week. I
remember bringing with me, for illustrat-
ing my talk, a few Petri plates and
Erlenmeyer flasks. He did not fail to ask
pertinent questions and make comments.
These were most illuminating and highly
stimulating. The following morning he
came down to what he liked to refer to
jokingly as my "harem"* to talk further
about the role of bacteria in marine
processes.
One day, I believe it was in 1932, he
brought with him the eminent Norwegian
algologist and oceanographer, Professor
H. Gran, who spent that summer at the
Institution. When Gran saw the auto-
clave in my laboratory, he turned to
Bigelow and exclaimed: "That is exactly
the equipment that I will need for my
work." When I asked Gran the purpose
of the autoclave in algal studies, he re-
plied: "To prepare soil extract. I cannot
grow my algae in sea water without it."
Both Bigelow and I were amazed by this
statement. I suggested that perhaps the
soil extract provided the necessary iron in
proper combinations for algal growth and
photosynthesis. Gran replied: "No, I do
not believe it since we have tested various
organic compounds of iron without any
success." I proceeded then to prepare a
synthetic ferrolignoprotein complex. Gran
tested it, and to both Bigelow's and my
delight, it worked just as well as the soil
extract.
*He coined this term because of the fact that
most of my assistants then and in subsequent
summers were women.
10
r
"The ship was rocking in her usual manner."
Who can ever forget my first trip on
the 'Atlantis' in 1932. In addition to
myself and my first assistant, there were
on the ship, Bigelow, Rakestraw, Gran,
and I believe also Redfield, and one or
two other scientists. Rakestraw shared
the cabin with me. The ship was rocking
in her usual manner. After I laid down
on my bunk, I could not get up for more
than 24 hours. Rakestraw apparently
felt as bad as I did, but he managed to
get up every few hours, rush to the toilet,
then for an hour or so to the laboratory,
and then to the bunk again. I felt so
miserable that any courage that I may
have had when I went on the ship left me.
I well remember Bigelow, opening the
door of the cabin, taking one good look
at me, and announcing that: "All food
would be wasted on him." Finally, the
sun was up, and I felt somewhat better,
I went outside and sat down on the deck
of the ship, with Bigelow and Gran,
listening to their stories about seasickness.
They spoke of various seas, ranging from
Lofoten Islands off the Norwegian coast,
to the west coast of South Africa. I listened
but was completely unable to go into the
lab or even return to the cabin. The
Captain (McMurray) brought me a glass
of rum toddy, which tasted rather good.
Finally, Bigelow turned to me and said:
"You better stay on shore and have your
assistant go to sea and collect the water
and bottom samples that you require for
your work." Unfortunately, my assistant
(Reuszer) was also sick at that time and
I did not see him until four days later,
when we were returning to port. It was
only when Charlie Renn became my
second assistant the following year, that
I could follow Bigelow's advice.
One more story. Although this does
not involve Bigelow himself, it is too
good a story not to be told here. It was
my last summer (1942) in Woods Hole.
We were in the midst of World War II,
and the Institution was completely oc-
cupied with naval projects. A room was
rented for me at the Marine Biological
Laboratory where I spent exactly one
month. My only collaborators were Dr.
Cornelia Carey and one graduate as-
11
sistant. Since I was at that time busily
engaged in the search for antibiotics, f I
made an attempt to determine whether
marine bacteria also include antibiotic-
producing organisms. We enriched, daily,
flasks containing fresh water with living
cultures of Escherichia coli.* The latter
were rapidly disappearing when added to
the water. There appeared to be develop-
ing in the water something (I still do not
know whether it was a living organism
or a chemical agent) that killed the bac-
teria. Since our time at Woods Hole was
soon coming to an end, I decided to take
the flasks with the enriched water to New
Brunswick and try to do the isolation
work in my laboratory at Rutgers. When
it was time for us to leave, Dr. Carey and
I discovered to our complete disgust that
our assistant, in an effort to leave a clean
laboratory, washed up all the valuable
flasks with the enriched water. There
went our whole summer's work literally
down the sink. I was glad that Dr. Bigelow
was not there, to look upon my dis-
couraged face.
That was the end of my active scien-
tific connection with the Oceanographic
Institution, and well it might be, since it
was also the end of the directorship of
Dr. Bigelow. Without his constant guid-
ance and encouragement, any further
work in the field of oceanography on my
part would have lacked the luster and
perspective that only the master could
inspire, and the master was Henry B.
Bigelow.
Selman A. Waksman
Professor Emeritus
Rutgers — The State University
*This was a method that I often used at that
time in an attempt to isolate antibiotic-producing
organisms from the soil.
TDr. Waksman modestly omits that he re-
ceived the Nobel Prize in Medicine in 1952. We
believe that he and Professor August Krogh of
Copenhagen were the only two Nobel Prize
winners who have been connected with our
Institution. (Ed.)
The Anderson Sampler, used to obtain
sediments for bacteriological studies.
"Finally, the sun was up, and I felt somewhat
better. I went outside and sat on the deck".
Dr. Waksman ahead of the pilot house of
the 'Atlantis'.
12
"Watcli out Archie . . .
You're sitting on your cigar
N.
O one would have called Dr. Bigelow
an organization man. Yet, he did produce
an organization, and a peculiarly effective
one, out of some of the world's most
unorganizable people. He did it by being
more of an individual than any of them,
and they became docile and momentarily
cooperative.
The most useful administrative principle
in Dr. Bigelow's system was his "open
door policy." Early in the Institution's
first meetings, Dr. Bigelow announced that
he liked to see what was going on, and he
liked to feel welcome to drop in. He said
that he deplored the cellular pattern of
the new biological labs at Harvard where
every professor was protected by an inno-
cent girl or an old battle axe in the front
office. It frightened off the students who
should have the benefit of a full paid
professor now and then. He did not want
that in his Institution, he said.
He made this seem selfish, but what he
really had in mind was that those of us
who were groping around for ideas in
oceanography could visit and learn from
one another. He knew that most worth-
while people were shy, but that their
curiosity could overcome shyness, and this
could lead to learning something new just
by dropping in to investigate a smell or
a buzzing noise.
Dr. Bigelow used to drop in to visit in
Dr. Selman Waksman's old microbio-
logical laboratory on the second floor of
the old building. The smells always chal-
lenged him. He said that we smelled like
a menhaden plant. Then he would ask a
few questions, say one or two words, and
you had something to chew on for the rest
of the summer.
Dr. Bigelow liked to watch things hap-
pen. Now and then he would stop by to
glance at the races in the Hole. He knew
exactly when a boat would go aground or
get caught in an eddy. 1 do not think that
he especially liked small boat racing; it
was too slow and ritualistic. He called it
turtle racing.
Dr. Bigelow's eyes were always out
ahead of his conversation. That gave him
an edge. He liked people to use their
eyes as well as their heads, and he was
especially disappointed that few used the
big cast concrete aquarium tables that
were installed in all laboratories. He
would roam around the building and men-
tion this. He had hoped that everyone
would have an aquarium to stimulate his
ocean thinking. It let him down that they
boxed those tables in with plywood, made
storage space of them, and committed
other inanities.
His own sharp lookout convinced him
that everybody around the Institution was
accident prone, and he was concerned
about poles leaning on tables, flasks and
bottles too close to the edge, and unat-
tended flames. Once this helped me out of
a difficult spot.
In my first few years at the Oceano-
graphic I worked on the parasite of eel
grass disease and Dr. Bigelow was so
pleased with the project that he used to
bring notables in the laboratory so that
he could tell them about its progress.
Word came that Dr. A. G. Huntsman of
the Canadian Fisheries Board was going
to be brought up to see what we were
doing. 1 was scared to death. My
Canadian friends had told me about Dr.
Huntsman- -A. G. stood for Almighty
God. Dr. Huntsman was supposed to
converse with migrating herring in classical
Greek. Although I could make small talk
on composts and fertilizers, Greek of any
kind was impossible, and I was headed
for humiliation. (Later, when I got to
know Dr. Huntsman better, I found him
most humane. But it is good for the young
to have a severe model, now and then.)
Dr. Bigelow arrived with Dr. Huntsman
and introductions were finished in two
seconds. Then there was a long awkward
pause, Dr. Huntsman lit a cigar, walked
about a bit, came back to my corner,
backed away, and began to sit down on a
window table, passing up the chair that I
moved to him.
Suddenly, Dr .Bigelow said, "Watch out
Archie, you're sitting on your cigar."
13
Dr. Waksman seated on the rail chats
with Professor H. Gran.
Dr. Charles E. Renn at Woods Hole in 1934.
Dr. Huntsman was an inch off the table
when the idea connected, and he went up
two feet without touching the floor. It was
superb levitation and physically impos-
sible. Dr. Bigelow broke up in stitches,
Dr. Huntsman turned a lovely pink, and
I was relieved. I do not believe that Dr.
Bigelow created the situation, but I am
certain that he saw it as a way of breaking
the ice and getting me unfrozen. I liked
Dr. Huntsman from that moment on.
This sort of physical alertness touched
everything that Dr. Bigelow managed. His
eyes told you before the words came.
During the Friday night seminars, in which
we all groped our way to basic ideas
about oceanography — and especially the
Gulf of Maine — Dr. Bigelow extracted,
edited, summarized, and clarified with the
most economical mixture of finished and
unfinished short sentences, encouraging
nods, leaps to the chart, and groans that
could be produced for the benefit of the
young. He would tell about what he had
seen and you saw it.
You knew that he was looking — and
that he cared a lot. He didn't tell you
that. But this sense made you do more,
and I will bet that more lazy biologists and
dilatory intellectuals achieved twice their
expected quota and at least half their
stated aims because of it.
Dr. Bigelow could assess character and
potential quicker and more reliably than
any computer or promotion board that
I ever saw. In the early spring meet-
ings of the fellows were held at the
Museum of Comparative Zoology to re-
view applications for fellowships at Woods
Hole. Letters and recommendations were
in order and Dr. Bigelow would review
and comment from the top of the stack
down. A word or sentence would catch
his fancy and a minute analysis would
follow — later, when we met the successful
candidate in the fleshpots of the Cape, we
found the analysis profoundly correct.
Among other strong beliefs, Dr. Bigelow
believed that incipient oceanographers
should go out on the 'Atlantis' before they
made elaborate plans. One of my first trips
was in the company of Dr. Bigelow, Dr.
Waksman and Dr. Gran. Dr. Waksman
14
had used his thumb on a small scale map
of the Gulf of Maine to indicate areas
where we were to pull up bacteriological
samples, and after that he took to his bunk
and stayed there. Everybody was seasick,
it was gray, miserable and pure diesel
exhaust — the 'Atlantis' at her worst in the
worst water in the world, the Gulf of
Maine.
And I can remember Dr. Bigelow, pale
green, making rounds to Dr. Waksman
with whorn he was much concerned. "I
never heard of anyone dying of seasick-
ness," he said, "but then 1 never saw
anyone this sick."
I have an old photograph of Dr. Bige-
low, Dr. Waksman, and Dr. Gran, sitting
in the sun and talking by the locker aft of
the deck laboratory on the first bright calm
day following the bout. I have never dared
show it.
When Dr. Bigelow broke into the
laboratory on an impulse visit, he would
sometimes find his way into his theme
with an exploration of the wonderful ways
of people. Once he introduced his request
that we change a cruise schedule with a
tale about the odd things that went on in
the then new Coonamessett Ranch where
he was staying temporarily.
"I don't understand it," he said, "they
give you two face cloths every day, but no
plug for the tub. You know, I think that
the maid hoards bathtub plugs and leaves
an extra face cloth to clear her conscience.
Anyway, I plug the bathtub with a face
cloth."
This put us so far off base that we were
happy to accede to his request that we fit
in with the new arrangement that he had
thought up.
Charles E. Renn
Professor, Dept. of
Environmental Engineering
Science. The Johns Hopkins
University
"The 'Atlantis' at her worst in the worst water of the world". The unknown photographer
of this fine illustration must have been standing on the top of the upper laboratory to
show the vessel rolling under storm trysail.
15
Dr. Bigelow on fhe wheel of the 'Grampus'
in 1912.
Charles Francis Adams on the wheel
of the 'Yankee'.
CORRESPONDENCE WITH C.F.A.
D.
*R. BIGELOW carried on a lively correspondence with his friend Charles Francis
Adams, then Secretary of the Navy, which provides an insight in their personalities
as well as Dr. Bigelow's foresight. Interesting also was the fact that although they
addressed each other as "Dear Henry" and "Dear Charlie", or "Charles", they
signed their letters generally as: "C.F.A." and "H.B.B." and sometimes with their
full names.
Dear Charles:
July 2, 1930
I don't know if you have heard the news of the establishment of the new
institution for Oceanography at Woods Hole. At any rate it's happened, as an
outcome of the general survey that the Committee on Oceanography of the
National Academy carried out; perhaps you'll remember that you and I talked a
little about this. The Rockefeller Foundation has given two and one half millions
and it's my fate to be the first director (of course, this doesn't mean any loosening
of my ties here). The enclosed announcement (if you read any of it) gives an idea
what it's all about.
We are to have a laboratory at Woods Hole on which work has already been
started, and you will be glad to hear that we are to build a fine oceanographic
ship. She is 149 ft. long on top, gross tonnage 350-360, 300 Hp Diesel engine,
rigged as a ketch with a pretty fair sail plan. She is intended to be able to go
anywhere at any time and for cruises of any length, carrying half a dozen scientists;
fitted for every kind of deep sea work. We have just let the contract to Burmeister
& Wain in Copenhagen who bid $147,000, as against the $258,000, by the lowest
American bidder. We hope she'll be in commission next June. George Owen and
Frank Minot drew the plans and they are working out the details of the machinery,
which are quite complex and, of course, the most important thing about her. If
you would be interested to see the plans, I'll bring them down the next time I
come to Washington.
16
BURMEISTER & WAIN
"Columbus Iselin is to be the first captain '
Columbus Iselin is to be the first captain and we think it will be a great
advantage to have a scientific captain as was done on the "Carnegie" and this
brings me around to the immediate matter of this letter. Columbus plans to join
the Naval Reserve, and when we were talking it over the other day, it occurred to
me that it might be a good idea for the director to do so likewise, i.e. for the
director always to be in the Naval Reserve — so as to strengthen the liaison between
the Navy and the Institution. With its endowment and the prestige it has behind
it, the institution is bound to occupy a decidedly important position in the scientific
world, unless I turn out to be a fizzle as a director, and many occasions are bound
to arise when cooperation with the Hydrographic Office will be helpful to both.
I am thinking of such things as soundings, exploration of currents, etc. to which
we will devote much attention with the best and most modern methods. We also
plan some work on the meteorological side.
If the Navy and the new Institution should decide that it would be wise to
have some connection more definite than simple friendship, I suppose the present
director (being me) would be appropriate enough for the Naval Reserve on the
basis of sea experience, etc. However, when my successor comes along, he may
17
not be a seaman, but is sure to be a leading oceanographer. Therefore, it might
be better, from the beginning, to establish a precedent of associating him with the
Navy on the basis of eminence in a profession (namely oceanography) in which
the Navy is concerned. 1 wish you would think all this over and let me know
how it strikes you. I could come down to Washington to talk it over with you if
you think it worth while, or perhaps can see you sometime when you are in
Boston. There is no hurry about it for the institution won't be in active operation
until next spring.
Elizabeth and three of the children departed for Norway, via England, last
Wednesday. I expect to follow with Betty on the twentieth of this month, to meet
them in Switzerland for three weeks climbing, to be home about September
twentieth. Somehow I must have a paper sent over now and then to tell me how
you are getting on with the 'Yankee1. We were all delighted to hear that you are
to sail her.
Yours,
tamscript
Woods Hole for Orders: Atlantis Seeks a Cargo of Scientists
Dear Charlie:
. . . Congratulations on the way you're pushing the "Yankee"* through the water.
We're all much excited.
July 3, 1930
My dear Henry:
. . . It's nice of you to take an interest in YANKEE, but I am afraid that she is too
big and is not the horse to bet on.
*Four yachts had been built for the 1930 'Enterprise' was selected over 'Weetamoe',
America's Cup, challenged by Sir Thomas 'Whirlwind' and 'Yankee', the latter skippered
Lipton with 'Shamrock V. After hard trials by Charles Francis Adams. (Ed.)
April 30, 1931
Dear Charlie:
Here is the thing that I have on my mind: We are planning to start at Woods
Hole next summer some observations on wind velocities in relation to the actual
stress exerted on the surface of the water. To do this, we need a ship theodolite.
But we find that, not only are these instruments very expensive, but that we cannot
possibly have one built in time to use this summer. So I have had Gardner Emmons,
who is to work on this problem, write to the Navy Bureau of Aeronautics to see if
we could perhaps borrow one.
I gather from Lt. Lockharfs reply that one can be spared, but that it would
be rather contrary to rule to loan it to any person or institution not connected with
the Navy. He suggests that I could sign for it as a member of the Naval Reserve,
if the loan were approved.
18
As long as there is an instrument that can be spared, it seems to me entirely
appropriate for the Navy to loan it to the Woods Hole Institution, for all the data
that we get as to pilot balloons will be of interest to the Bureau of Aeronautics. So
won't you approve the loan so it can be made? Of course I'll sign for it and we
would be responsible for replacement if anything happened to it. As I said, it is
an expensive little gadget costing about $1,000: — technical name — ship theodolite.
Yours,
My dear Henry:
May 2, 1931
That theodolite has been shipped to you or shipped to the Naval Reserve for
you. If it does not appear in due season let me know.
I don't know just what you are about, but yachtsmen would be interested if
your observations included the retardation of air movement by the surface of the
water. In other words, we would like to know, how much less rapidly the wind
moves; say 10 feet up, than it does; say 50 feet up. Obviously, this is a pretty vague
subject, as retardation must vary with the strength of the wind and the roughness
of the sea. I know you are not observing for the benefit of yachtsmen, but it is
possible you might produce a by-product of some value without extra effort.
Affectionately,
Dear Charlie:
May 4, 1931
It's good news that the theodolite is starting to travel our way. Many thanks.
You brought up an interesting problem with regard to the retardation of air
movement by the surface of the water at small distances above the land. I confess
I hadn't thought of this, but I can see how observations taken, say 10 and 50 feet
up, might bear very directly on the matter of interaction between sea surface and
air. Next time I see Rossby I'll consult him as to how observations to this end can
be taken. I don't know how one controls the height at which balloons float or
whether one can put .up kites and register the pull on their strings, but will look into
it. If we get something out of it that will be of help to yachtsmen, so much the better.
Anyhow I am not sure that it isn't rather a duty to tackle any job that seems
to have a direct practical bearing — there are few enough of them that do.
Affectionately,
I-
"Anyhow / am not sure that it isn't rather a
duty to tackle a job that seems to have a
practical bearing — there are few enough
of them that do."
The 'scrounged' theodolite on board ' the
'Atlantis' in October 1931. C.O'D. Iselin in
the background.
H.8.8. as director.
Sept. 26, 1932
Dear Henry:
In reply to your letter of 8 September in which you suggest that an officer from
the U.S.S. HANNIBAL make a trip of about a week's duration in the Gulf of Maine
aboard the ATLANTIS, I am glad to inform you that arrangements have been made
for Commander C. C. Slayton, the commanding officer of the U.S.S. HANNIBAL
to make the trip.
I have forwarded your letter to Admiral Gherardi in the Hydrographic Office
and he has noted your recommendations for acquainting the personnel of the
HANNIBAL with the instruments and methods in use on the ATLANTIS for
obtaining deep sea observations.
The Navy hopes to be able to continue its oceanographic work in the future
and especially on its surveying vessels when such work will not interfere with their
regular surveying program.
Sincerely yours,
My dear Henry:
August 3, 1933
To my regret bordering on despair, I find that your annual meeting is right in the
middle of the New York Yacht Club cruise. That is my only period of real vacation,
and as you know, my most sacred one. I had really looked forward to coming to
your annual meeting this year, but I just can't find it in my soul to desert and do so.
Perhaps you will show me over the situation some other time.
Ever sincerely yours,
C.F.A. as Secretary
of the Navy.
20
w.
HAT Dr. Bigelow has meant to
oceanography has been the result of a
vision, and you know how difficult it is to
communicate visions. He communicated
parts of it to various people. The word
"exciting" typified the atmosphere that
H.B.B. created.
The list of his publications does not
provide an idea of their importance. A
publication is extremely cheap now com-
pared to former times; it is easier to get
things published. The wealth of material,
of pertinent material, and the thorough-
ness with which he and his associates
made sure that they put in real facts is
what counted.
Dr. Bigelow created an exciting atmos-
phere and had an enormous effect on
stimulating people. I saw him occasion-
ally and have been much affected by his
personality. His conduct of a meeting
was inimitable. Somehow he had a queer
combination of lively humor and dead
seriousness. I knew him for some 50 years
and learned that he saw a job that no one
was doing. You have to go out on the
ocean and ask: why?
One of his first pieces of work — I am
relying on memory — was on Bermuda and
find out, as I put it, how land is made out
of water. He found evidence that the
Bermuda Rock was made out of hard
skeletons. Probably that was a demonstra-
tion of the importance of life in making
things.
When I first met Henry he had been in
contact with Johann Hjort and had told
Hjort about the redfish being taken at
Eastport, Maine. Hjort opined that "that
fish does -not behave that way at air.
Henry said: "It does". The arresting fact
is that he brought this to Hjort's attention.
Bigelow had that spirit of discovery and
when he went after something you knew
it was not just a passing whim. He went
after it with vigor and did a thorough job.
No one else so fully deserves recognition
for what he has done for oceanography.
A. G. Huntsman
Professor Emeritus
Univ. of Toronto
Dr. Hunfsman with Dr. Bigelow at the
presentation of the "Bigelow Volume".
January 24, 1956.
II etait considere comme "le Pere de
L'Oceanographie americaine". . . .
Comble d'honneurs et d'annees, il
disparait, laissants dans la tristesse
toute le Communaute des Oceano-
graphes.
H. L
(Cahiers Oceanographique, 20(3)
21
R,
.EPEATEDLY, I urged him to em-
ploy a secretary to help him with his
publications. His reply was: "No scientist
should ever have a secretary. If he has
one, he would answer his mail and if he
answers his mail, he has no time for
scientific work."
H.B.B. used to say at election time that
he was going to vote against them all.
When asked why he preferred the
crooked politician to the reform candidate
he replied that the crooked politician
would not kill the goose that laid the
golden egg.
George C. Shattuck, M.D.
Dean Bumpus o/b /he 'Atlantis' with a Bumpus-Clarke
stramin net, the "Chariot", equipped with wheels to keep
the net opening away from the ocean bottom.
J
OHN ARMSTRONG and I shared a lab one winter in George Clarke's suite at
the Biological Laboratories at Harvard. John was studying for his Ph.D. He had
passed his written exams but with some reservation. He knew a lot about marine
animals but had a minimum to offer about terrestrial ones. Bigelow's comment
was "Better study up on the land animals. You don't want your knowledge to rise
and fall with the tide."
When Armstrong turned in his thesis, Bigelow was busy so he laid it on the
corner of the desk. A week later Dr. Bigelow called him over to his office and
told him to rewrite the thesis. Armstrong was not certain whether Bigelow had
read it or not, as the paper was exactly where Armstrong had left it on the desk.
When Armstrong commenced to remonstrate Bigelow said "Rewrite it, every
paper needs to be rewritten!" So poor uncertain John rewrote it, much to his
own benefit.
Dean F. Bumpus
Senior Scientist
on our staff.
22
T
HERE are two items concerning Dr. Bigelow that I would like to mention, just
in case others have not already done so.* In the early years of the Institution,
when most of us were University staff members who inhabited the institution only
in the summer time, he encouraged each of us to feel that our work was of interest
to every one else in the buliding. Following his example, every one kept the door
or lab open as an invitation to others to come in, and indeed the Director was a
frequent and welcome visitor. His New England manner of getting directly to the
crux of a matter was always delightful and at the same time inspiring.
Each year in the early spring the research staff of the Institution would come
together for a meeting at Harvard. The purpose of this was to prepare a budget
for the expenses of the Institution for the coming season, earmarking or sanction-
ing definite amounts to individuals with projects or apparatus being prepared. The
procedure was always referred to by Dr. Bigelow as "slicing the melon" — a
delightful word picture which has become almost a password between Dr. George
Clarke and myself for evoking pleasant memories of those days.
Edmond E. Watson
Acting Head, Dept. of Physics.
This aspect of the Institution was mentioned Queen's University, Ontario.
by many of the contributors. Obviously it made
a deep and lasting impression. (Ed.)
Dr. Watson with the Watson current
meter. A. C. Woodcock at right.
Dr. Bigelow's course in Oceanic Biology
was really "marine biology" and inspired
me to go on and establish ecology as a
subject at Harvard, and to expand the
course into two courses, one on the princi-
ples of ecology* and the other in bio-
logical oceanography. Thus, H. B. B. was
an ecologist without knowing it!
One day members of the staff were
discussing what to do about the behaviour
of another staff member, when H. B.
Bigelow showed his tolerance of the foibles
of others by urging us to give the offender
another chance and saying "Well, we're
all basically 's, you know."
George L Clarke
Professor of Biology
Harvard University
*Which led to the publication of my book:
"Elements of Ecology", John Wiley & Sons,
1954.
Dr. Clarke at Woods Hole in 1933.
23
I
SPENT most of the winter of 1931 at
sea on the trawler 'Kingfisher' under
Captain Sylvester Dunn out of Groton,
Connecticut. This followed some previous
months in the company's loft learning
how to make and repair nets (14<f an
hour); now the business at hand was to
weigh each haul as it was spilled on deck
in an attempt to assess the loss in weight
at landing several days to two weeks later,
and, ultimately to have a hand in an
improved design of storage bins for iced
fish on board ship.
In a way and by a means then and
now conveniently obscure to me, H.B.B.
was instrumental in landing me that job
with the Portland Trawling Company.
Came spring and I found myself en
route to England, where I spent several
months on trawlers, herring drifters, and
the research vessel 'George Bligh' under
Captain Stewart out of Lowestoft. Then
to Copenhagen to join the 'Atlantis' as a
so-called "able seaman" on her memo-
rable maiden voyage to Plymouth (Eng-
land), Boston, and Woods Hole. H.B.B. 's
fine Italian hand again.
He and his life-long friend, Archibald
G. Huntsman, the latter under wholly
different circumstances, started me on a
course I have never regretted for a single
second.
Now the times come full circle. One
of the main architects and author-in-chief
of the first volumes of the Fishes of the
Western North Atlantic, Sears Founda-
tion for Marine Research, Yale Uni-
versity, was Harvardian Bigelow (Yale
ScrD., 1941).
May it be given to a whole company
of us in many areas of marine research
collectively to fill H.B.B.'s gargantuan
shoes.
Daniel Merriman
Director
Sears Foundation for Marine Research.
On the 'Atlantis' maiden voyage. Left—
Knute Nielsen, a Danish sailor who remained
on board for several years. Right— Ona
McClunen, second engineer. Background,
looking up — John Churchill, supercargo.
Behind McClunen— Terence Keough, sailor.
H.B.B. in 1932.
24
z
LJ
Many scientists
were laid low by
the movements
of the gimballed
mess table on the
'Atlantis'.
" . . . as the archi-
tect of the
scientific program
of the
International
Ice Patrol."
A
DAY or two before I was to make
my first trip on the 'Atlantis' on a one
week cruise across the Gulf Stream, about
two-thirds of the way to Bermuda and
return, Dr. Bigelow called me into his
office in his inimitable manner asked
whether I got seasick. 1 had to confess
that 1 really did not know since I had
never been to sea. Whether he actually
believed in the principle or not, he then
went on to assure me that seasickness was
50% psychological. For the most part,
the subsequent voyage was quite smooth
and no real test arose until the 'Atlantis'
made an "anchor station" in the Gulf
Stream to attempt current measurement.
The roll of the ship and the consequent
movement of the gimbaled mess table
plus the evening meal that day of liver
and bacon shortly sent me to the rail in
spite of a strong application of Dr.
Bigelow's remedy.
Charles M. Weiss
Professor, Dept. of
Environmental Sciences and
Engineering, The Univ. of
North Carolina.
Dr. Bigelow was a great believer in
observations. As the architect of the
scientific program of the International Ice
Patrol, he urged me to "go out and take
a look at the icebergs for yourself." Indeed,
while flying over the bergs, I observed
details which I hadn't noticed on photo-
graphs but after personal observations was
able to identify.
Dr. Bigelow was able to get to the heart
of a problem quickly, omitting no impor-
tant details. When I told him of my studies
of upwelling, he recounted that when he
was with Alexander Agassiz on the
'Albatross' expedition to the eastern tropi-
cal Pacific (1904), their ship was becalmed
off Peru. It was his way of saying that
upwelling was not a continuous process.
In the years I have shared an office with
him in his beloved Museum of Compara-
tive Zoology at Harvard, 1 came to know
him as a special kind of man — knowing,
friendly, and plain spoken."
Irving I. Schell
Ocean-Atmosphere Research
Institute
Cambridge, Massachusetts
25
Only H. B. B. would have thought
of such a contraption
I
T is somewhat difficult to adjust to the
idea that I am considered an "old timer"
in the Museum of Comparative Zoology,
but the fact is that I am of the few remain-
ing who worked with H.B.B. as a graduate
student. In those days T. Barbour was
Director of the Museum, and the situation
could best be described as "broke, but
happy". The Museum endowment was
totally inadequate to pay the staff, and
T. Barbour had collected a devoted group
of volunteers, many with little or no prev-
ious training in zoology, who kept the
collections in order and the Museum going.
Looking back on it, the Museum was a
remarkable combination at that time, for
heading the staff were outstanding scien-
tists, and perhaps greatest among them
was H.B.B.
In the meaning of the present day, to
call a scientist an "amateur" is deroga-
tory, for it implies lack of serious applica-
tion to the work at hand in comparison to
the professional. Actually the word is
"love", and the amateur is the person who
works at something because he loves it.
The men who gathered at T. Barbour's
"eateria" for lunch were amateurs in the
finest sense and it was a joy for a graduate
student to sit in a corner and listen to
them. H.B.B. and T.B. made a fascinating
contrast. The former, lean, slightly stooped,
with a thin face and bright blue eyes that
are seen only in those that make their
business about the great waters. The latter
a huge man, with a deep voice, a great
laugh, and a habit of curling his forelock
between thumb and forefinger when in
deep thought. The conversation covered
many subjects and almost always it had
its basis in natural history. Both men
were great sportsmen and had travelled
widely, but the thing that made it exciting
was their remarkable power of observation
and their ability to ask imaginative ques-
tions, and even derive some fascinating
answers. Their enthusiasm permeated the
place, and it was contagious.
In spite Of his love of sport, H.B.B. was
a rigorous scientist, and was brought up
in the strict scientific discipline of the turn
of the century. He once told me that his
sponsor, E. L. Mark, allowed him to work
on a thesis problem for a year before sug-
gesting that he look up the work of some
German published years before. As Mark
knew he would, H.B.B. found that he had
been thoroughly "scooped", and thus the
lesson was learned that you must know
the "literature" before embarking on the
problem. This kind of discipline would
start a riot among our present day gradu-
ate body, but H.B.B. swallowed the pill
and even ended up by being fond of
E. L. Mark.
It was this scientific rigor, plus a willing-
ness to work unstintingly and an ability to
put his finger on the nub of the question
that made H.B.B. the great scientist he
was. In the mid-thirties he gave a course
with George Clarke in marine biology
which was outstandingly good. As we took
notes, it seemed that H.B.B. was giving his
lectures with effortless ease, yet they were
packed with information and masterpieces
of clarity. Behind the smooth performance
was weeks of hard work, plus a touch of
genius. He attended every laboratory, and
it was here that his enthusiasm, clarity of
thought, and ingenuity really shone. The
students loved him, for he was completely
natural with them, and his gentle Yankee
wit kept them on their toes. He hated
scientific jargon, and his simple, unclut-
tered approach to a problem was the best
of training for all of us. His "Fishes of the
Gulf of Maine" is a prime example of
exact scientific writing, made readable and
interesting by omitting artificiality.
I never fished or hunted with him,
though we used to talk about it a lot. Here
too, his inquiring mind was always work-
ing. No one knows why a salmon rises to
a fly, but H.B.B. rose one in Grande Pool
on a burnt match tied to a bare line. Only
26
H.B.B. would have thought of such a con-
traption, let alone being able to cast it.
He and my Uncle Ted went up to Grande
River in the early forties and had a
splendid season, though it was the last
time for both of them. Both were great
amateurs, one Professor of Physics and
founder of the laboratory that bears his
name, the other Alexander Agassiz Pro-
fessor of Zoology and founder of the
Woods Hole Oceanographic Institution. I
like to think of them at that most beautiful
pool, with the clear water swirling, twenty
feet deep through the Jaws and spreading
silently below. H.B.B. is trying to raise
one of the long grey shadows lying along
the Ledge with a dry fly of his own tying,
and T. L. is in the shade watching him,
smoking his pipe.
Charles P. Lyman
Assoc. Professor of Anatomy
Harvard Medical School
Oceanographer
He plumbs the secret depths of ocean
Past canyon walls and jagged peaks,
His fancy is intrigued by motion
Of tides and currents, while he seeks
The final answers to defeating
Sea-mysteries resolved by none.
He hears the heart of sea-life beating
Fathoms below his hydrophone,
Yet he can never hope to plunder
The sea as men have robbed the land,
For always she will make him wonder
But never let him understand.
Louise Crenshaw Ray
Dec. 16, 1953
Copyright 1953,
Reprinted by permission of the authoress and
The New York Times Company.
We deeply regret to announce the sudden
death of Chief Backus on July 21. He also
was part and parcel of our Institution's
beginning and traditions.
Chief Backus in the early days,
wearing cap and badge.
BAILOR, scientist and gentleman, Dr.
Bigelow was all of these. I was shipmates
with him several times on the old 'Atlantis'
and I never saw him suffer from mal de
mer, and he really enjoyed a cruise. He
was a Lt. Commander in the First World
War with the Navy, and had a lot of sea-
going experience on the 'Albatross' be-
longing to the Fisheries. As a young
biologist, I remember he and Captain
Carlson gabbing about the old days, and
when Henry Bigelow got fresh with the
skipper and cussed him, Carlson chased
him around the deck with a halibut maul.
Another time on the 'Atlantis', I was fish-
ing over the side with an underwater light
and caught a huge squid, which I put in
a large wooden tub on deck and called
Doc and Dr. A. Redfield (this was I think
in 1932) and they were looking at it and
moving it around, when the squid let go
a blast of ink, and blew half the water out
of the tub all over them. They were a
mess, and I laughed at them, and they
chased me, and were going to dip me in
that gorey mess but I disappeared below.
Dr. Bigelow was always interested in the
scientific work on the ship. Ashore,
whether talking to any of the scientists or
the other people working around the
buildings or ship, he always had our
interests at heart, and was a perfect host
at any of the parties, or cocktail get-
togethers, which we used to have in the
good old days of the Institution. Yes, he
was truly a gentleman.
Harold Backus
*Chief Backus 'came on board' during the
building of the 'Atlantis'. One of the oldest
hands at Woods Hole, he was Chief Engineer
of the 'Atlantis' for 25 years.
27
I
N 1955, a group of Dr. Bigelow's
former students and associates decided to
honor him for his contributions to marine
biology and oceanography. The twenty-
fifth anniversary of the Institution's found-
ing appeared to be a fitting occasion. A
volume, containing 48 scientific contribu-
tions was completed by the end of the
anniversary year and a leather bound copy
was presented to Dr. Bigelow at a gather-
ing in the Director's Room at the Museum
of Comparative Zoology, Harvard Uni-
versity on January 24, 1956.
In the foreword, Dr. A. C. Redfield
explained succinctly how much one man
can do to motivate others to do their best.
We quote: "Henry Bryant Bigelow, you
have broadened the vision, sharpened the
perception, fortified the determination,
simplified the outlook, improved the stand-
ards, and corrected the folly of each of us."
In his reply, Dr. Bigelow mentioned
that years ago he was invited to dinner at
Copenhagen. "An old Danish custom
demands that the host gives you a speech.
Now, all the Danish I knew were the
words for thanks, butter and Skol, which
everyone knows. So, instead of returning
the speech I just said: Tak and Skol, and
sat down. This is what I want to do now;
Tak and Skol, friends. I just want to add
this: I was in a very lucky position in
oceanography, there just weren't enough
oceanographers around and so there was
no opposition. There were lots of medals
for oceanography and if you stayed alive
long enough and out of trouble you had
to get the medals since they had nowhere
else to go. But this book is different. No
one has to do it. Nobody has to take all
this trouble to sit down and write papers
and print them. No one needs to take the
trouble to tell a fellow how nice he is.
Tak and Skol again, friends. This is the
end."
B
IGELOW, THE MAN, was so versatile and remarkable that one might go on
endlessly paying tribute. His "Memories of a Long and Active Life", The Cosmos
Press, Cambridge, 1964, provides a great deal of information. What struck me
most were his repeated references to "one of the amusing incidents which seem
(automatically) to come my way." "One of those amusing experiences with which
my life has been "peppered". Difficulties and hardships are glossed over; his ship
being torpedoed by a German submarine in World War I is made amusing.
A typical account went ". . . in Naples (1901) we climbed Mount Vesuvius
and visited Pompeii: I also had an unexpected adventure, for while I was walking
across the open square in front of the famous Naples Aquarium, a man, who
emerged from a roadway across the square, began shooting at me with a revolver,
without endangering me, however, for he was aiming far above my head! When
his gun was empty a policeman appeared upon the scene and arrested him. Fortun-
ately, the policeman understood French, and on my inquiring what all the trouble
was about, he replied, "I think, sir, he mistook you for his friend!"
How a man who, at the drop of a hat, went off shooting or fishing, "acting on
the principal that one should never allow business to interfere with pleasure",
accomplished as much as he did, was explained by his long time associate, Wm. C.
Schroeder. "H. B. never wasted a moment - - when he worked, he worked hard."
Little has been said in this volume about his dear wife Elizabeth Perkins
Shattuck whom he married in 1906 and promptly took on a honeymoon canoe trip
to Newfoundland. His wife's canoe capsized in rapids of the swollen Loyds River
and she lost her toilet articles. Since she was wearing an old pair of sneakers full
of holes: "Obviously, then our first job was to make her a serviceable pair of shoes!"
Whereupon Dr. Bigelow described how he walked a mile or two to shoot a caribou
and explained how to make a serviceable shoe from the legskin of a caribou and how
to tan the skin by boiling some cherry and maple bark in a solution of baking
powder and soak the shoes so that the inside part would not continue "disgustingly
slimy". Nothing seems to have fazed him. Nothing seems to have daunted him.
Jan Hahn
28
BIBLIOGRAPHY OF HENRY BRYANT BIGELOW
(1902) Birds of the northeastern coast of Labrador. The Auk, 19, 24-31 .
(1904) Medusae from the Maldive Islands. Bull. Mus. Comp. Zool., Harvard Coll., 39 (9), 245-269,
9 pis.
(1904) The sense of hearing in the goldfish, Carassius auratus L. Am. Natur., 38 (448), 275-284.
(1905) The shoal-water deposits of the Bermuda Banks. Proc. Am. Acad. Arts Sci., 40 (15), 559-592.
(1907) On hybrids between the mallard (Anas boschas) and certain other ducks. The Auk, 24 (4),
382-388.
(1907) Studies on the nuclear cycle of Gonionemus murbachii A. G. MAYER. Bull. Mus. Comp.
Zool, Harvard Coll., 48 (4), 287-399, 8 pis.
(1909) Coelenterates from Labrador and Newfoundland, collected by Mr. OWEN BRYANT from
July to October, 1908. Proc. U.S. natn. Mus., 37 (1706), 301-320, Pis. 30-32.
(1909) Cruise of the U.S. Fisheries Schooner Grampus in the Gulf Stream during July, 1908, with
description of a new Medusa (Bythotiaridae). Bull. Mus. Comp. Zool., Harvard Coll., 52 (12),
195-210, 1 pi.
(1909) Report on the scientific results of the Expedition to the Eastern Tropical Pacific, in charge of
ALEXANDER AGASSIZ, by the U.S. Fish Commission Steamer Albatross, from October,
1904, to March, 1905, Lieut. Commander L. M. GARRETT, U.S.N., Commanding. XVI. The
Medusae. Mem. Mus. Comp. Zool., Harvard Coll., 37, 243 pp., 48 pis.
(191 1) Biscayan plankton collected during a cruise of H.M.S. Research, 1900. XIII. The Siphono-
phora. Trans. Linn. Soc., Land., (2nd ser., Zool.), 10 (10), 337-358, PI. 28.
(1911) Report on the scientific results of the Expedition to the Eastern Tropical Pacific, in charge
of ALEXANDER AGASSIZ, by the U.S. Fish Commission Steamer Albatross, from October,
1904 to March, 1905, Lieut. Commander L. M. GARRETT, U.S.N., Commanding. XXIII.
The Siphonophorae. Mem. Mus. Comp. Zool., Harvard Coll., 38 (2), 173-402, 32 pis.
(1911) The work of the Michael Sars in the North Atlantic in 1910. (A review). Science, n.s., 34,
7-10.
(191 1) Fishes and Medusae of the intermediate depths. A note on the work of the Michael Sars.
Nature, Land., 86, 483.
(1912) Reports on the scientific results of the Expedition to the Eastern Tropical Pacific, in charge
of ALEXANDER AGASSIZ, by the U.S. Fish Commission Steamer Albatross, from October,
1904 to March, 1905, Lieut. Commander L. M. GARRETT, Commanding. XXVI. The
ctenophores. Bull. Mus. Comp. Zool., Harvard Coll., 54 (12), 369-404, 2 pis.
(1912) Scientific results of the Philippine cruise of the Fisheries Steamer Albatross, 1907-1910,
22. Preliminary account of one new genus and three new species of Medusae from the
Philippines. Proc. U.S. natn. Mus., 43 (1931), 253-260.
(1913) Medusae and Siphonophorae collected by the U.S. Fisheries Steamer Albatross in the north-
western Pacific, 1906. Proc. U.S. natn. Mus., 44 (1946), 1-119, 6 pis., 2 text figs.
(1913) Oceanographic cruises of the U.S. Fisheries Schooner Grampus, 1912-1913. Science, n.s.,
38 (982), 599-601.
(1913) A new closing-net for horizontal use, with a suggested method of testing the catenary in
fast towing. Int. Rev. Ges. Hydrobiol. Hydrogr., 5, 576-580, 8 text figs.
(1914) Explorations in the Gulf of Maine, July and August 1912, by the U.S. Fisheries Schooner
Grampus. Oceanography and notes on the plankton. Bull. Mus. Comp. Zool., Harvard Coll.,
58(2), 31-147, 9 pis.
(1914) Fauna of New England. 12. List of the Medusae Craspedotae, Siphonophorae, Scypho-
medusae, Ctenophorae. Occ. Papers, Boston Soc. Nat. Hist., 7, 1-37.
(1914) Note on the medusan genus Stomolophus from San Diego. Univ. Calif. Publ. Zool., 13 (10),
239-241.
(1914) Oceanography and plankton of Massachusetts Bay and adjacent waters, November 1912-
May, 1913. Bull. Mus. Comp. Zool., Harvard Coll., 58 (10), 383-420, 1 pi., 7 text figs.
(1915) Epheretmus, a new genus of Trachomedusae. Proc. U.S. natn. Mus., 49 (21 14), 399-404, pi. 59.
(1915) Exploration of the coast water between Nova Scotia and Chesapeake Bay, July and August,
1913, by the U.S. Fisheries Schooner Grampus. Oceanography and plankton. Bull. Mus.
Comp. Zool., Harvard Coll., 59 (4), 151-359, 2 pis., 82 text figs.
(1916) Halimedusa, a new genus of Anthomedusae. Trans. R. Soc., Canada, (3), 10 (4), 91-95, 1 pi.
29
(1917) Explorations of the coast water between Cape Cod and Halifax, in 1914 and 1915, by the
U.S. Fisheries Schooner Grampus. Oceanography and plankton. Bull. Mus. Comp. Zoo!.,
Harvard Coll., 61 (8), 163-357, 1 pi., 100 text figs.
(1917) Explorations of the United States Coast and Geodetic Survey Steamer Bache in the western
Atlantic, January-March 1914 under the direction of the United States Bureau of Fisheries.
Oceanography. U.S. Bur. Fish Doc. 833 (App. 5 to Rept. U.S. Comm. Fish, for 1915),
1-62, 53 text figs., 1 fold-in.
(1918) Some Medusae and Siphonophorae from the western Atlantic. Bull. Mus. Comp. Zoo!.,
Harvard Coll., 62 (8), 365-442.
(1919) Hydromedusae, siphonophores and ctenophores of the Albatross Philippine Expedition.
Contributions to the biology of the Philippine Archipelago and adjacent regions. Bull. U.S.
natn. Mus., 100, 1 (5), 279-362, Pis. 39-43.
(1920) Medusae and ctenophores from the Canadian Arctic Expedition, 1913-1918. Rept. Canadian
Arctic Exped., 1913-1918, 8 (H), 22 pp., 2 pis.
(1922) Exploration of the coastal water off the northeastern United States in 1916 by the U.S.
Fisheries Schooner Grampus, Bull. Mus. Comp. ZooL, Harvard Coll., 65 (5), 85-188, 53
text figs.
(1925) Oceanic circulation. Science, 62, 317-319.
(1925) Recent oceanographic work carried on jointly by the Museum of Comparative Zoology
and by the U.S. Bureau of Fisheries. Bull. Nat. Res. Council, No. 53, 69-70.
(1926) Plankton of the offshore waters of the Gulf of Maine. Bull. U.S. Bur. Fish., 40 (2), 1-509.
134 text figs.
(1927) Physical oceanography of the Gulf of Maine. Bull. U.S. Bur. Fish., 40 (2), 511-1027, 207
text figs.
(1927) Dynamic oceanography of the Gulf of Maine. Bull. Nat. Res. Council, No. 61, 206-211.
(1928) Exploration of the waters of the Gulf of Maine. Geogr. Rev., 18, 232-260.
(1928) Scyphomedusae from the Arcturus Oceanographic Expedition. Zoologica, N. Y. Zool. Soc.,
8 (10), 495-524, Figs. 180-184.
(1929) Museum of Comparative Zoology. Its cooperation with the International Ice Patrol and the
U.S. Bureau of Fisheries. Harvard Alumni Bull., 31, 433-434.
(1930) A developing view-point in oceanography. Science, 71 (1830), 84-89.
(1930) The Woods Hole Oceanographic Institution. Harvard Alumni Bull., 32, 749-750.
(1930) The Woods Hole Oceanographic Institution. Science, 71, 277-278.
(1930) The Woods Hole Oceanographic Institution. /. du Cons., 5 (2), 226-228.
(1931) Siphonophorae from the Arcturus Oceanographic Expedition. Zoologica, N.Y. Zool. Soc.,
8 (11), 525-592, text figs. 185-220.
(1931) Oceanography; its scope, problems and economic importance. Houghton Mifflin Co.,
N.Y., and Boston, 263 pp.
(1933) Studies of the waters on the continental shelf, Cape Cod to Chesapeake Bay. 1. The cycle
of temperature. Pap. Phys. Oceanogr. Meteorol., 2 (4), 1-135, 66 text figs.
(1938) Plankton of the Bermuda Oceanographic Expeditions. VIII. Medusae taken during the years
1929 and 1930. Zoologica, N. Y. Zool. Soc., 23 (2), 99-189, 23 text figs.
(1940) Eastern Pacific Expeditions of the New York Zoological Society. XX. Medusae of the
Templeton Crocker and Eastern Pacific " Zaca " Expeditions, 1936-1938. Zooligica, N. Y.
Zool. Soc., 25 (3), 281-321, text figs 1-20.
(1952) Thomas Barbour. Biogr. Mem., Nat. Acad. Sci., 27, 13-45.
(1961) A new species of the Cetomimid genus Gyrinomimus from the Gulf of Mexico. Breviora, No.
145,2pp.
(1963) Superclass Pisces, Class Osteichthyes, key to orders. Mem. Sears Found. Mar. Res., 1 (3), 1-17
(1963) Isospondyli, characters and keys to suborders and families. Mem. Sears Found. Mar. Res., 1
(3), 88-104.
(1963) Suborder Elopoidea, characters and key to families. Mem. Sears Found. Mar. Res., 1 (3),
107-108.
(1963) Suborder Clupeoidea, characters and key to families. Mem. Sears Found. Mar. Res., 1 (3),
148-150.
(1963) Family Alepocephalidae (interim account). Mem. Sears Found. Mar. Res., 1 (3), 250-252.
(1963) Family Searsiidae (interim account). Mem. Sears Found. Mar. Res., 1 (3), 254-255.
(1963) Suborder Salmonoidae, characters and key to families. Mem. Sears Found. Mar. Res., 1 (3),
455-456.
(1963) Genus Salvelinus; genus Cristovomer. Mem. Sears Found. Mar. Res., 1 (3), 503-544.
(1963) Family Coregonidae. Mem. Sears Found. Mar. Res., 1 (3), 547-551.
(1964) Suborder Bathylaconoidea. Mem. Sears Found. Mar. Res., 1 (4), 561-564.
BIGELOW, H. B. and EDMONDSON, W. T. (1947), Wind waves at sea, breakers and surf. U.S. Navy
Hydrogr. Office Pub. 602, xii plus 177 pp., 57 text figs., 24 pis. (Also translated into Russian
in 1951 by B. B. SHTOKGANA).
BIGELOW, H. B. and FARFANTE, I. P. (1948), Fishes of the Western North Atlantic. Chap. 1. Lance-
lets. Mem. Sears Found. Mar. Res., 1, 1-28, 3 text figs.
BIGELOW, H. B. and ISELIN, C. (1927), Oceanographic reconnaissance of the northern sector of the
Labrador current. Science, 65 (1691), 551-552.
30
BIGELOW, H. B. and LESLIE, MAURINE (1930), Reconnaissance of the waters and plankton of Monterey
Bay, July 1928. Bull. Mus. Comp. Zool., Harvard Coll., 70 (5), 429-481, 43 text figs.
BIGELOW, H. B., LILLICK, Lois C. and SEARS, MARY (1940), Phytoplankton and planktonic protozoa
of the offshore waters of the Gulf of Maine. 1. Numerical distribution. Trans. Amer. Phil. Soc.,
n.s., 31 (3), 149-191, 10 text figs.
BIGELOW, H. B. and SCHROEDER, W. C. (1927), Notes on northwest Atlantic sharks and skates. Bull.
Mus. Comp. Zool., Harvard Coll., 68 (5), 239-251.
BIGELOW, H. B. and SCHROEDER, W. C. (1929), A rare Bramid fish (Taractes princeps Johnson) in the
northwestern Atlantic. Bull. Mus. Comp. Zool., Harvard Coll., 69 (2), 41-50, 1 pi.
BIGELOW, H. B. and SCHROEDER, W. C. (1934), Canadian Atlantic Fauna. 12. Chordata. 12d.
Marsipobranchii (Lampreys). 12e. Elasmobranchii (Sharks and rays). 12f. Holocephali (Chim-
aeroids). Univ. Toronto Press for Biol. Bd., Canada, 38 pp., 35 text figs.
BIGELOW, H. B. and SCHROEDER, W. C. (1935), Two rare fishes, Notacanthus phasganorus Goode and
Lycichthys latifrons (Steenstrup and Hallgrimsson), from the Nova Scotian banks. Proc. Boston
Soc. Nat. Hist., 41 (2), 13-18, PI. 3.
BIGELOW, H. B. and SCHROEDER, W. C. (1936), Supplemental notes on fishes of the Gulf of Maine.
Bull. U.S. Bur. Fish., 48 (Bull No. 20), 319-343.
BIGELOW, H. B. and SCHROEDER, W. C. (1937), A record of Centrolophus niger (Gmelin) from the
western Atlantic. Copeia, 1937 (1), 51.
BIGELOW, H. B. and SCHROEDER, W. C. (1939), Notes on the fauna above mud bottoms in deep water
in the Gulf of Maine. Biol. Bull., 46 (3), 305-324, 8 text-figs.
BIGELOW, H. B. and SCHROEDER. W. C. (1940), Notes on New England fishes — Carcharodon carcharias
(Linnaeus). Copeia, 1940 (2), 139.
BIGELOW, H. B. and SCHROEDER, W. C. (1940), Some deep sea fishes from the North Atlantic. Copeia,
1940(4), 231-238.
BIGELOW, H. B. and SCHROEDER, W. C. (1940), Sharks of the genus Mustelus in the western Atlantic.
Proc. Boston Soc. Nat. Hist., 41 (8), 417-438, Pis. 14-19.
BIGELOW, H. B. and SCHROEDER, W. C. (1941), Cephalurus, a new genus of Scyliorhinid shark with
redescription of the genotype Catulus cephalus, Gilbert. Copeia 1941 (2), 73-76, 4 figs.
BIGELOW, H. B. and SCHROEDER, W. C. (1944), New sharks from the western North Atlantic. Proc.
New England Zool. Club, 23, 21-36, Pis. 7-10.
BIGELOW, H. B. and SCHROEDER, W. C. (1945), Guide to commercial shark fishing in the Caribbean
area. Anglo-American Caribbean Commission, Washington, D.C., 149 pp., 56 figs. (Also
Fishery Leaflet, U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service No. 135).
BIGELOW, H. B. and SCHROEDER, W. C. (1947), Record of a tilefish, Lopholatilus chamaeleonticeps
Goode and Bean for the Gulf of Mexico. Copeia, 1947 (1), 62-63.
BIGELOW, H. B. and SCHROEDER, W. C. (1948), New genera and species of Batoid fishes. /. Mar.
Res., 7 (3), 543-566, Figs. 1-9.
BIGELOW, H. B. and SCHROEDER, W. C. (1948), Fishes of the Western North Atlantic. Ch. 2. Cyclo-
stomes. Ch. 3. Sharks. Mem., Sears Found. Mar. Res., 1 (1), 29-546, 103 text figs.
BIGELOW, H. B. and SCHROEDER, W. C. (1950), New and little known cartilaginous fishes from the
Atlantic. Bull. Mus. Comp. Zool, Harvard Coll., 103 (7), 385-408, 7 pis.
BIGELOW, H. B. and SCHROEDER, W. C. (1951), A new genus and species of Acanthobatid skate from
the Gulf of Mexico. J. Washington Acad. Sci., 41 (3), 1 10-113, 1 text fig.
BIGELOW, H. B. and SCHROEDER, W. C. (1951), Three new skates and a new Chimaerid fish from the
Gulf of Mexico. /. Washington Acad. Sci., 41 (12), 383-392, 4 text figs.
BIGELOW, H. B. and SCHROEDER, W. C. (1952), A new species of the cyclostome genus Paramyxine
from the Gulf of Mexico. Breviora, No. 8, 10 pp., 6 text figs.
BIGELOW, H. B. and SCHROEDER, W. C. (1953), Fishes of the Gulf of Maine. First Revision. Fish
and Wildlife Service, Fish. Bull., 53 (Fish. Bull. 74), 1-577, 288 text figs.
BIGELOW, H. B. and SCHROEDER, W. C. (1953), Fishes of the Western North Atlantic. Ch. 1. Saw-
fishes, Guitarfishes, Skates and Rays. Ch. 2. Chimaeroids. Mem., Sears Found. Mar. Res., 1
(2), 588 pp., 127 text figs.
BIGELOW, H. B. and SCHROEDER, W. C. (1954), Deep water elasmobranchs and chimaeroids from the
northwestern Atlantic slope. Bull. Mus. Comp. Zool., Harvard Coll., 112 (2), 37-87, 7 text figs.
BIGELOW, H. B. and SCHROEDER, W. C. (1954), A new family, a new genus and two new species of
Batoid fishes from the Gulf of Mexico. Breviora, No. 24, 16 pp., 4 text figs.
BIGELOW, H. B. and SCHROEDER, W. C. (1955), Occurrence off the Middle and North Atlantic United
States of the offshore hake Merluccius albidus (Mitchill) 1818, and of the blue whiting Gadus
(Micromesistius} poutassou (Risso) 1826. Bull. Mus. Comp. Zool., Harvard Coll., 113 (2), 205-226,
3 text figs.
BIGELOW, H. B. and SCHROEDER, W. C. (1957), A study of the sharks of the suborder Squaloidea.
Bull. Mus. Comp. Zool., Harvard Coll., Ill (1), 1-150.
BIGELOW, H. B. and SCHROEDER, W. C. (1958), A large white shark, Carcharodon carcharias, taken
in Massachusetts Bay, Copeia, 1958 (1), 54-55.
BIGELOW, H. B. and SCHROEDER, W. C. (1958), Four new Rajidsfrom the Gulf of Mexico. Bull. Mus.
Comp. Zool., Harvard Coll., 119 (2), 201-233.
BIGELOW, H. B. and SCHROEDER, W. C. (1961), Carcharhinus nicaraguensis, a synonym of the bull
shark. Copeia, 1961 (3), 359.
31
BIGELOW, H. B. and SCHROEDER, W. C. (1962), New and little known Batoid fishes from the Western
Atlantic. Bull. Mus. Comp. Zool., Harvard Coll., 128 (2), 159-244.
BIGELOW, H. B. and SCHROEDER, W. C. (1963), Preface. In: Sharks and survival, P. W. Gilbert, editor,
D. C. Heath and Co., vii-viii.
BIGELOW, H. B. and SCHROEDER, W. C. (1963), Family Osmeridae. Mem. Sears Found. Mar. Res.,
1 (3), 131-139.
BIGELOW, H. B. and SCHROEDER, W. C. (1964), A new skate, Raja cervigoni, from Venezuela and the
Guianas. Breviora, No. 209, 1-5.
BIGELOW, H. B. and SCHROEDER, W. C. (1965), A further account of Batoid fishes from the Western
Atlantic. Bull. Mus. Comp. Zool., Harvard. Coll., 132 (5), 443-477.
BIGELOW, H. B. and SCHROEDER, W. C. (1965), Notes on a small collection of Rajids from the sub-
Antarctic region. Limnol. Oceanogr., Suppl. to Vol. 10, R38-R49.
BIGELOW, H. B. and SCHROEDER, W. C. (1968), Additional notes on Batoid fishes from the Western
Atlantic. Breviora.
BIGELOW, H. B. and SCHROEDER, W. C. (1968) New records of two geographically restricted species
of western Atlantic skates: Breviraja yucatansis and Dactylobatus armatus. Copeia, 1968 (3).
BIGELOW, H. B., SCHROEDER, W. C. and SPRINGER, STEWART (1943), A new species of Carcharinus
from the western Atlantic. Proc. New England Zool. Club, 22, 69-74.
BIGELOW, H. B., SCHROEDER, W. C. and SPRINGER, STEWART (1953), New and little known sharks from
the Atlantic and from the Gulf of Mexico. Bull. Mus. Comp. Zool, Harvard Coll., 109 (3), 213-276,
10 text figs.
BIGELOW, H. B. and SEARS, MARY (1935), Studies of the waters of the continental shelf, Cape Cod to
Chesapeake Bay. II. Salinity. Pap. Phys. Oceanogr. MeteoroL, 4 (1), 1-94, 55 text figs.
BIGELOW, H. B. and SEARS, MARY (1937), H 2. Siphonophorae. Kept. Danish Oceanogr. Exped.,
1908-10, to the Mediterranean and Adjacent Seas, 2 (Biol.), 144 pp., 83 text figs.
BIGELOW, H. B. and SEARS, MARY (1939), Studies of the waters of the continental shelf, Cape Cod to
Cape Hatteras. III. A volumetric study of the zooplankton. Mem. Mus. Comp. Zool., Harvard
Coll., 54 (4), 183-378, 42 text figs.
BIGELOW, H. B. and WELSH, W. W. (1925), Fishes of the Gulf of Maine. Bull. U.S. Bur. Fish., 40 (1).
1-567, 278 text figs.
BARBOUR, THOMAS and BIGELOW, H. B. (1944), A new giant Ceriatid fish. Proc. New England Zool,
Club, 32, 9-15, Pis. 4-6.
BIGELOW, H. B. AND SCHROEDER, W. C. ( 1 968 ), New records of two geographically restricted species
of Western Atlantic skates; Breviraja yucatensis and Dactylobatus armatus. Copeia, 1968 (3).
UH 17ZV
The editor apologizes if any of the illustrations in this issue are not properly
identified and credited. In our search for old photographs it turned out only too
often that negatives or prints had no identification whatsoever. Corrections from
readers will be appreciated. We thank the many persons who helped us, particularly
Mr. Norman T. Allen, archivist of the Institution, whose files and memory are a
goldmine of information; also Mr. Dean F. Bumpus, Mr. Harold Backus and
Dr. George L. Clarke.
Other memorabilia connected with Dr. Bigelow appeared in "Oceanus":
Dedication of Bigelow Volume, Vol. IV, No. 2
"On Fish and Fisheries", by H. B. Bigelow, Vol. IV, No. 2
H. B. Bigelow Medal Editorial, Vol. VII, No. 1
Photograph of the four directors, Vol. VII, No. 1
"A Medal for Dr. Bigelow", Vol. VII, No. 4
"Of H. B. Bigelow and Fishes", by W. C. Schroeder, Vol. VII, No. 2
"He hated to have his picture taken, and had a decided repugnance for cameras
and candid camera people, especially."
The Board of Trustees has voted to name the original
building of our Institution the Henry Bryant Bigelow Building.
A bronze plaque will be designed and placed in a
prominent position.
John Donne's
s 17
Contents
H. 8. Bigelow Volume
ECIATION
by Michael Gra/iom
CORRESPONDENCE WITH CHARLES FRANCIS ADAMS
BIBLIOGRAPHY OF HENRY BRYANT BIGELOW
Contributors
Paul M. Fye
C.O'D. Iselin
W. C. Schroeder
Charles A. Cootidge
m
"Selman A. Waksman 10
Charles E. Renn
A. G**Hvntsman
George C. Shattuck 2
frying f. Schell
Charles P. Lyma
o. 2 July 1
WOODS HOLE OCEANOGRAPHIC INSTITUTION
•<*»
WOODS HOLE, MASSACHUSETTS