Skip to main content

Full text of "Rangeland monitoring in Willmore Wilderness Park"

See other formats


RANSELAND  MONITOfttNS 
IN 

WILLMORE  WILDERNESS  PARK 


Progress  Report  for 
Foothills  Model  Forest 


Prepared  by 


Cameron  Lane 


Michael  Willoughby 


1998 


Digitized  by  the  Internet  Archive 
in  2016 


https://archive.org/details/rangelandmonitorOOIane 


Progress  Report  I,  1998  1 


INTRODUCTION 

Willmore  Wilderness  Park  is  a 4597  square  kilometre  area  in  west-central  Alberta  located 
adjacent  to  the  north  side  of  Jasper  National  Park  and  east  of  the  British  Columbia  border. 
Established  in  1959,  it  spans  a broad  transition  zone  from  boreal  forest  to  Rocky  Mountains. 
Being  a wilderness  park,  and  managed  under  such  legislation,  the  main  use  of  the  park  is  for 
recreation.  Motorized  vehicle  use  is  prohibited  within  the  park,  instead  cross  country  skiers, 
hikers  and  back  country  horse  users  provide  significant  levels  of  traffic  on  the  network  of  trails 
scattered  throughout  the  park’s  valleys  and  mountain  passes.  The  majority  of  use  in  the  park 
each  year  is  during  the  summer  and  fall  months.  The  use  on  the  rangelands  comes  in  the  form  of 
recreational  horse  use,  commercial  guides  and  outfitters,  offering  backcountry  trail  riding, 
camping  in  the  summer,  and  hunting  in  the  fall. 

The  increasing  levels  of  horse  use  in  Willmore  has  created  concern  for  the  condition  of 
native  ranges  found  throughout  the  park.  With  most  of  the  park  being  heavily  forested,  grazing 
opportunities  are  limited  to  the  valley  bottoms  and  moist,  semi-open  drainages.  Trails 
throughout  the  park  generally  follow  the  more  accessible  valley  bottoms.  Traditional  camping 
sites  located  along  many  trails  are  receiving  heavier  intensities  of  grazing  pressure  than  they  can 
presently  sustain.  As  a result,  change  to  the  species  composition  and  the  productivity  of  the 
native  ranges  are  occurring  in  some  areas.  The  invasion  of  non-native  species  on  heavily  used 
areas  and  the  retention  of  adequate  supplies  of  winter  forage  for  wildlife  are  also  areas  of 
concern. 

Recently,  there  has  also  been  concern  with  the  rate  the  native  grasslands  have  been 
encroached  by  shrubs.  This  is  a serious  problem  because  most  of  the  productive  grasslands 
become  inaccessible  and  less  productive  for  both  horses  and  wildlife.  It  is  believed  that  the  lack 
of  fire  within  the  Park  has  allowed  shrubs  to  expand  onto  the  remaining  grassland  community 
types. 

A detailed  classification  of  the  rangeland  resource  in  Willmore  was  completed  by  Bork 
(1994).  It  included  lists  of  plant  community  types,  major  plant  species,  forage  production  and 
response  to  grazing  pressure.  At  this  time  it  was  also  recognised  that  long-term  monitoring  of  a 
number  of  these  types  was  required  to  determine,  range  condition  and  trend,  the  effect  of  horse 
and  wildlife  grazing  on  biomass  production,  soils  and  watersheds  and  to  determine  the 
successional  changes  on  these  rangelands  in  the  presence  and  absence  of  grazing  and  fire 
disturbance.  In  1998  a number  of  sites  were  established  to  examine  the  effects  of  shrub 
encroachment  onto  grasslands,  the  effect  of  prescribed  burning  on  shrub  and  tree  cover  and  the 
effect  of  horse  and  wildlife  grazing  on  grassland  vegetation.  The  specific  objectives  of  the  study 
were  to: 

1 . Monitor  shrub  encroachment  onto  a Arctic  Rough  fescue-Tufted  hairgrass  dominated 
community  type  near  Eagles  Nest  Cabin. 

2.  Monitor  shrub  encroachment  onto  a Tufted  hairgrass-Sedge  dominated  community  type  at 
Sunset  Creek. 

3.  Monitor  the  effect  of  a 1990  prescribed  bum  on  a Bog  birch-Willow/Bog  sedge-Sedge 
dominated  community  type  at  Monaghan  Flats. 

4.  Monitor  the  effect  of  a prescribed  bum  on  an  Aspen  forest  dominated  community  at  Kvass 
flats  in  the  presence  and  absence  of  horse  grazing. 


Progress  Report  I,  1998  2 

5.  Monitor  the  successional  changes  of  a moderately  to  heavily  grazed  Slender  wheatgrass-Sedge 
dominated  community  in  the  presence  and  absence  of  horse  grazing  at  the  Sulphur  River  cabin. 

6.  Monitor  the  effect  of  big  horn  sheep  and  wildlife  grazing  on  a White  Mountain  avens-Sedge 
dominated  community  at  Hayden  ridge. 

7.  Assess  overall  range  condition  and  determine  appropriate  carrying  capacities  (Horse  Use 
Days)  for  specific  range  community  types  throughout  the  park. 

PHYSICAL  CONDITIONS  OF  WILLMORE  WILDERNESS  PARK 

Willmore  covers  both  foothill  and  mountain  landforms  and  receives  both  boreal  and 
cordilleran  climate  influences  with  significant  variations  in  temperature,  elevation,  slope  and 
precipitation  (Strong  1992).  The  result  is  a wide  array  of  plant  communities  in  transition  across 
the  span  of  the  park.  The  higher  elevations  of  the  park  are  represented  by  the  Alpine  and 
Subalpine  subregions,  with  only  limited  corridors  along  the  lower  elevation,  i.e.  river  valleys, 
which  are  indicative  of  the  Upper  Foothills  subregion  (Strong  and  Thompson  1995). 

Alpine  subregion 

The  alpine  environment  generally  occurs  above  timberline.  Ogilvie  (1969),  found 
timberline  to  be  controlled  by  low  temperature,  wind  desiccation,  avalanching  and  snow  depth. 
The  alpine  plants  and  communities  show  adaptations  to  these  extreme  environmental  conditions. 
The  alpine  plant  communities  tend  to  be  low  growing  where  they  are  protected  from  the  wind 
and  benefit  from  the  warmer  temperatures  close  to  the  ground  (Ogilvie  1969).  On  south  facing, 
wind  swept  ridges  the  bog  sedge  and  white  dryad  communities  are  found.  At  slightly  lower 
elevations  where  snow  accumulates  the  low  growing  willow  communities  predominate  (arctic 
willow,  snow  willow,  rock  willow).  On  the  north  facing  slopes  where  snow  accumulates  the 
blackening  sedge  and  heather  community  types  are  found.  In  the  valley  bottoms  below 
timberline  the  willow,  bog  birch,  and  grassy  meadow  community  types  are  typical.  The  sequence 
of  plant  communities  in  the  Alpine  and  upper  Subalpine  is  outlined  in  Willoughby  and  Smith 
(1998). 


Subalpine  subregion 

The  subalpine  subregion  is  a Rocky  Mountain  altitudinal  vegetation  zone  with  its  upper 
boundary  formed  by  the  Alpine  subregion,  whereas  the  lower  boundary  abuts  the  Montane, 
Foothills  parkland  and  the  Upper  Foothills  subregions.  In  Alberta,  the  subalpine  extends  from 
1525  m to  2175  m at  its  southernmost  occurrence  and  from  1360  m to  2000  m in  the  vicinity  of 
Grande  Cache  (Strong  1992).  The  subalpine  has  a cordilleran  climate  characterised  by  snowy, 
cold  winters  and  showery  cool  summers.  Annual  precipitation  ranges  from  329  mm  to  916  mm, 
with  maximum  precipitation  falling  during  July.  The  subalpine  receives  more  precipitation 
during  the  winter  months  than  any  subregion  (Strong  1992).  The  mean  summer  temperatures 
averages  9.4  °C  and  winter  temperatures  typically  average  -8.9  °C  with  December  and  January 


Progress  Report  I,  1998  3 

being  the  coldest  months.  The  cold  winter  temperatures  help  to  maintain  the  snowpack  which 
makes  this  an  important  watershed  area. 

The  majority  of  the  vegetation  is  dominated  by  serai  lodgepole  pine  forests  at  lower 
elevations  with  Engelmann  spruce  and  subalpine  fir  forests  being  more  common  at  higher 
elevations.  At  timberline  dwarf  spruce,  subalpine  and  whitebark  pine  are  typical  of  the  transition 
to  the  Alpine  subregion.  Imperfectly  drained  bottomlands  are  dominated  by  willow,  bog  birch, 
sedge,  tufted  hairgrass  and  California  oatgrass  species  and  the  steep  south  facing  slopes  are  often 
dominated  by  fescue,  hairy  wildrye,  wheatgrass  and  junegrass  species  (Willoughby  and  Smith 
1998). 


Upper  Foothills  subregion 

This  subregion  is  found  in  an  elevation  range  below  the  subalpine  and  above  the  Lower 
Foothills  subregions.  It  ranges  in  elevation  from  1200- 1500m  at  lower  latitudes  and  from  1000- 
1250  m at  higher  latitudes.  It  is  dominated  by  closed  canopy  lodgepole  pine  forests  with  the 
potential  climax  species  on  reference  sites  being  white  spruce  and  black  spruce.  This  subregion 
can  be  distinguished  from  the  Subalpine  subregion  by  the  lack  of  engelmann  spruce  and  from  the 
Lower  Foothills  by  the  lack  of  aspen. 

This  subregion  has  a boreal  climate  which  is  modified  by  the  Rocky  Mountains.  The 
average  annual  precipitation  is  538  mm  with  over  half  the  precipitation  received  in  the  summer 
months  (340  mm).  The  temperature  averages  1 1.5  °C  in  the  summer  and  -6.0  °C  in  the  winter. 
These  temperatures  are  milder  and  not  nearly  as  extreme  as  the  other  subregions  within  the 
Boreal  forest  and  Foothills  natural  regions. 

The  native  grass  and  shrubland  community  types  are  found  in  the  valley  bottoms 
adjacent  to  streams  and  rivers  throughout  the  Upper  Foothills  subregion.  Deep  snow 
accumulations  and/or  cold  air  drainage  prevent  trees  from  growing  in  these  valley  bottoms 
(Daubenmire  1978).  These  grass  and  shrublands,  historically  burned  frequently  further 
preventing  tree  encroachment.  The  sequence  of  grass  and  shrubland  community  types  in  the 
Upper  Foothills  is  outlined  in  Willoughby  and  Smith  (1997). 

METHODS 

The  transects  established  in  Willmore  will  become  part  of  the  Alberta  Environmental 
Protection’s  permanent  rangeland  reference  area  program.  The  Rangeland  Reference  Area 
program  administered  by  the  Land  and  Forest  Service  was  established  by  the  Eastern  Rockies 
Forest  Conservation  Board  to  assess  range  condition  and  monitor  trend  on  rangelands  within  the 
boundaries  of  the  Rocky  Mountain  Forest  Reserve  (RMFR).  To  date  fifty-nine  reference  areas 
have  been  established  throughout  the  foothills  of  Alberta  extending  from  south  of  Blairmore  to 
Willmore  Park.  These  areas  include  permanently  marked  grazed  and  ungrazed  transects. 

Species  composition  data  has  been  recorded  on  these  transects  since  1953  when  many  of  the  sites 
were  established.  Recently,  the  data  of  many  of  these  sites  has  been  analysed  in  order  to 
determine  the  successional  pathways  in  the  presence  and  absence  of  grazing.  This  long-term 
data  used  in  conjunction  with  a detailed  ecological  classification  of  the  range  community  types 
will  help  to  determine  the  health  of  the  forested  rangelands  in  the  province. 


Progress  Report  I,  1998  4 

Reference  sites  were  established  on  areas  that  represented  primary  range.  Originally  sites 
thought  to  be  in  poor  range  condition  were  selected.  These  sites  were  usually  represented  by 
open  grasslands  on  south- facing  slopes,  benchlands  and  terraces.  The  reference  sites  were  not 
located  near  salt  or  within  100-ft.  (30-m)  of  a fence.  The  preferred  distance  from  a water  source 
was  greater  than  1000-ft.  (300-m)  but  less  than  1-mi.  (1.6-km). 

The  majority  of  the  reference  sites  consist  of  a fenced  exclosure  and  a 100-ft  (33-m) 
transect  inside  and  outside  the  exclosure.  The  outside  transect  was  situated  25-ft  (8-m)  or  greater 
from  the  edge  of  the  exclosure.  A number  of  reference  areas  consist  only  of  permanently  marked 
transects.  At  3 -in.  (7-cm)  intervals,  the  basal  frequency  of  the  plant  species  were  recorded  using 
Parker's  loop  (Parker  1954).  In  1982,  the  canopy  cover  of  the  plant  species  was  also  recorded  (at 
6-ft.  (1.8-m)  intervals)  using  a 20x50  cm  Daubenmire  frame.  Presently,  the  transects  are  being 
recorded  every  three  years.  All  the  basal  frequency  data  prior  to  1980  was  converted  to  canopy 
cover  using  regression  analysis.  In  Willmore  all  transects  are  30  m long  and  each  transect  will  be 
read  every  2 m.  Forbs,  grass,  moss  and  lichen  canopy  cover  will  be  recorded  in  a 20x50  cm 
quadrat  and  canopy  cover  of  shrubs  will  be  recorded  in  a 1 m2  quadrat.  At  each  transect  one  to 
five  50x100  cm  quadrats  were  clipped  , separated  into  trees,  shrubs,  forbs  and  graminoids,  oven 
dried  and  weighed.  The  recommended  stocking  rate  is  based  on  50%  of  the  total  production  and 
the  fact  one  horse  unit  requires  682  kg  of  dry  weight  material  for  one  month  of  grazing. 

A combination  of  both  ordination  (DECORANA)  (Gauch  1982)  and  cluster  analysis 
(SAS)  will  be  used  to  group  the  inside  and  outside  transects  of  different  years.  These  techniques 
combine  the  sites  based  on  the  similarity  of  species  composition.  The  groupings  from  cluster 
analysis  are  overlain  on  the  site  ordination. 


RESULTS 

Willoughby  (1997,1998)  has  found  that  it  takes  20-30  years  of  continuous  monitoring 
before  species  composition  changes  can  be  detected  from  reduced  grazing  pressure  or  as  a result 
of  shrub  encroachment.  It  is  likely  that  it  will  take  longer  to  detect  species  composition  changes 
in  the  grass  and  shrublands  of  Willmore  because  of  the  harsh  growing  conditions  found  in  the 
mountainous  terrain.  The  results  outlined  here  will  discuss  the  general  ecology,  objectives  and 
expected  results  for  each  site  established  in  Willmore  in  1998. 

Eagles  Nest  Cabin  transect 

This  transect  was  established  in  a Arctic  Rough  fescue-Tufted  Hairgrass  dominated 
community  just  south  of  Eagles  Nest  cabin  (Appendix  A)  to  examine  the  effect  of  shrub 
encroachment  onto  the  native  grasslands.  This  community  type  is  transitional  between  the 
Subalpine  and  Upper  Foothills  subregions.  It  represents  the  transition  zone  from  the  dry 
Junegrass/Sage  dominated  slopes  to  the  moist  tufted  hairgrass,  sedge  dominated  community 
types  (Willoughby  and  Smith  1997).  These  grasslands  are  fairly  moist  and  have  well  developed 
soils  which  makes  them  very  productive.  Morgantini  and  Russell  (1983),  found  that  rough 
fescue  dominated  community  types  were  the  primary  foraging  areas  for  elk  in  the  Ya  Ha  Tinda 
area.  The  presence  of  rough  fescue  likely  makes  this  community  type  important  for  wildlife  in 
Willmore. 


Progress  Report  I,  1998  5 

Succession  in  the  absence  of  disturbance  is  to  a Bog  birch/Rough  fescue  dominated 
community  (Willoughby  and  Smith  1997).  The  Bog  birch  community  type  generally  has  a half 
to  a third  less  forage  than  the  rough  fescue  dominated  community  types. 

Sunset  Creek  transect 

This  transect  was  established  in  a Tufted  hairgrass-Sedge  dominated  community  type  at 
the  confluence  of  the  Sunset  creek  and  the  North  Berland  river  (Appendix  A)  in  order  to  examine 
the  effect  of  shrub  encroachment  onto  the  native  grasslands.  This  community  type  is  typical  of 
moist  meadows  in  both  the  Subalpine  and  Upper  Foothills  subregions  (Willoughby  and  Smith 
1997).  This  community  type  is  drier  than  the  pure  sedge  meadows,  but  moister  than  the  rough 
fescue  dominated  community  types. 

Willoughby  (1998)  found  that  when  this  community  is  protected  from  grazing  or  fire  for 
25-30  years,  willow  and  bog  birch  expand  and  tufted  hairgrass  and  sedge  decline  in  the  Upper 
Foothills  subregion.  The  decline  in  graminoid  cover  also  results  in  a decline  in  available  forage 
production  (2200  to  1800  kg/ha). 

Monaghan  burn  transect 

This  transect  was  established  at  Monaghan  flats  (Appendix  A)  in  order  to  examine  the 
effect  of  the  1990  prescribed  bum  on  the  Bog  birch-Willow/Bog  sedge  dominated  community. 
The  purpose  of  the  original  bum  was  to  reduce  willow  and  bog  birch  cover  in  an  effort  to 
increase  forage  supply  (MacCallum  and  Yakimchuk  1992).  Initial  results  indicate  that  there  has 
been  a decline  in  willow  cover  and  an  increase  in  bog  birch  cover  to  near  pre-bum  levels  in  1998 
(Table  1). 

Table  1 : Percent  cover  and  composition  for  willow  and  bog  birch  on  Monaghan  flats  for  prebum 
1990,  post  bum  1990,1991  and  1998. 


%cover  %composition 


Year 

90 

90 

91 

98 

90 

90 

91 

98 

Willow 

34 

20 

27 

10 

75 

93 

90 

45 

Bog  birch 

11 

1 

3 

12 

26 

7 

10 

55 

MacCallum  and  Yakimchuk  (1992)  found  burning  of  the  Monoghan  flats  meadow 
initially  reduced  the  height  and  canopy  cover  of  birch  and  willow  and  shifted  the  composition  to 
favour  willow,  but  they  felt  that  both  bog  birch  and  willow  would  increase  to  pre-bum  levels 
within  7-10  years.  Eight  years  after  the  bum  bog  birch  had  recovered  to  pre-bum  levels  and 
willow  had  declined.  The  decline  in  willow  is  likely  the  result  of  not  having  the  transect  located 
in  exactly  the  same  place  as  the  previous  transects.  The  increase  in  bog  birch  cover  after  fire  is 
similar  to  the  results  Bork  et  al.  (1996)  found  at  Seven  Mile  flats  in  the  Upper  Foothills 


Progress  Report  I,  1998  6 

subregion.  They  found  that  bog  birch  continued  to  increase  in  cover  despite  being  burned  3 
times  in  10  years.  They  felt  that  periodic  burning  (3-5  year  interval)  would  be  needed  to  control 
bog  birch  regrowth. 

The  presence  of  bog  sedge  in  this  community  indicates  that  this  community  type  is 
located  within  the  Subalpine  subregion.  Willoughby  and  Smith  (1998)  found  that  bog  sedge 
cover  increased  when  one  moved  from  the  Upper  Foothills  to  the  Subalpine  subregion.  It  is 
important  that  this  site  continued  to  monitored  because  there  is  no  other  prescribed  bum  sites 
within  the  Subalpine  subregion  that  are  currently  being  monitored. 

Kvass  burn  exclosure 

This  exclosure  was  established  in  a burned  aspen  stand  adjacent  to  Kvass  flats  (Appendix 
A)  in  order  to  examine  the  effects  of  fire  and  horse  grazing  on  aspen  regeneration  and  forage 
production.  Currently,  the  dominant  vegetation  of  the  burned  site  is  rose  and  hairy  wildrye  and 
there  is  little  evidence  of  aspen  regeneration.  It  also  appears  there  has  been  a dramatic  increase 
in  forage  supply  from  an  unbumed  aspen  forest  500  kg/ha  (Bork  1994)  to  over  1600  kg/ha  in  the 
burned  area  (Table  3).  However,  further  work  will  have  to  be  done  in  the  adjacent  unbumed 
aspen  forest  in  order  to  make  direct  comparisons  between  pre  and  post  burning  at  this  site. 

Sulphur  exclosure 

This  exclosure  was  established  in  a Slender  wheatgrass-Sedge  dominated  community 
type,  near  the  Sulphur  River  cabin  (Appendix  A).  The  site  has  been  extensively  utilized  by 
horses.  Bork  (1994)  felt  that  this  community  type  represented  heavily  grazed  tufted  hairgrass  or 
rough  fescue  dominated  community  types.  It  was  felt  that  heavy  grazing  pressure  caused  fescue 
or  hairgrass  to  decline  in  the  stand  and  allowed  sedge  and  slender  wheatgrass  to  increase.  By 
establishing  an  exclosure  at  this  site  the  successional  pathways  of  this  community  type  in  the 
presence  and  absence  of  grazing  can  be  determined.  An  understanding  of  the  successional 
pathways  will  allow  range  condition  of  this  site  and  similar  community  types  within  Willmore  to 
be  determined. 

Hayden  ridge  exclosure 

This  wildlife  exclosure  was  established  by  a MSc  student  in  a White  mountain  avens 
dominated  community  in  the  mid  1970's  (Appendix  A).  These  white  mountain  aven 
communities  are  extensively  utilized  by  bighorn  sheep  during  the  winter  months  because  they 
remain  snow  free.  Transect  readings  from  both  inside  and  outside  the  exclosure  indicate  only 
slight  differences  between  the  grazed  and  ungrazed  transects  (Table  2).  The  outside  transect  has 
a larger  number  of  species  which  one  would  expect  in  a grazed  situation  (Willoughby  1995). 

The  inside  transect  has  a lower  number  of  species  and  evidence  of  low  growing  woody  species 
(willow,  bilberry)  which  are  not  found  on  the  outside  transect.  The  increase  in  woody  species 
inside  the  exclosure  maybe  the  result  of  increased  moisture  and  not  the  result  of  being  ungrazed 
by  wildlife.  Exclosures  in  Southern  Alberta  tend  to  be  moister  in  the  absence  of  grazing  because 
the  increased  litter  inside  the  exclosure  tends  to  catch  more  snow.  Efforts  are  currently  being 


made  to  locate  the  original  data  from  this  study. 


Progress  Report  I,  1998  7 


Progress  Report  I,  1998  8 

Table  2.  Species  canopy  cover  inside  and  outside  the  Hayden  ridge  exclosure  in  Willmore 
Wilderness  Park  in  1998. 

Species  In  Out 


Grasses 


Bog  sedge 

6 

1 

Hairy  wildrye 

6 

9 

Arctic  rough  fescue 

T 

T 

Forbs 

White  mountain  avens 

39 

42 

Alpine  hedysarum 

2 

T 

Alpine  bistort 

4 

3 

White  camas 

1 

1 

Shrubs 

Dwarf  bilberry 

T 

- 

Rock  willow 

T 

- 

Lichens 

Reindeer  lichen 

40 

10 

Dog  lichen 

- 

2 

Species  richness 

19 

25 

DISCUSSION  AND  MANAGEMENT  IMPLICATIONS 

Monitoring  these  reference  sites  in  Willmore  will  establish  a benchmark  to  determine  the 
ecological  climax  and  successional  changes  of  these  range  communities.  It  will  provide  an 
assessment  of  range  condition  of  similar  range  types  altered  by  domestic  or  wildlife  grazing, 
flooding,  or  lack  of  natural  wild  fire.  Understanding  succession  and  the  ecological  diversity  of 
these  range  types  will  assist  in  developing  management  schemes  throughout  the  park. 

In  addition  to  monitoring  species  diversity,  biomass  production  was  also  collected  to 
determine  the  amount  of  forage  available  for  domestic  and  wildlife  grazing.  Based  on  current 
biomass  production  (kg/ha)  carrying  capacities  of  each  site  were  assessed  based  on  50% 
allocation  of  total  production  and  1 .5  Animal  Units  for  a horse.  This  establishes  a stocking  rate 
(Horse  Days  per  hectare)  to  enable  land  managers  to  allocate  appropriate  amount  of  horse  use 
levels  that  sustain  the  natural  range  types  within  a given  area  (Table  3). 

However,  it  must  be  understood  that  to  ensure  the  continued  productivity  and  survival  of 
some  native  range  types,  particularly  those  that  have  been  overgrazed,  much  lower  stocking  rates 
are  needed  for  range  recovery  to  occur.  Domestic  grazing  can  also  be  used,  in  conjunction  with 
prescribed  fire,  to  restrict  shrub  and  tree  encroachment  thereby  protecting  these  natural  range 
types. 

Monitoring  species  composition  and  biomass  production  establishes  an  ecological 


Progress  Report  I,  1998  9 

evaluation  of  how  these  range  types  are  changing  overtime  based  on  current  management 
practices.  It  provides  information  on  the  condition  of  the  park  and  provides  guidelines  on  how  to 
manage  these  range  types  to  maximize  species  richness,  diversity,  productivity,  wildlife  habitat, 
and  aesthetics. 

Table  3.  Biomass  production  and  stocking  rates  for  sites  monitored  in  Willmore  Wilderness 
Park,  1998. 


Site  Description 

Range  Community  Types 

Biomass 

Production 

(kg/ha) 

Stocking  Rate 
(H.D./ha) 

Kvass  Flats 

Aspen-Rose/Hairy  Wild  Rye 

1645 

37 

Sulphur-Kvass 

Slender  Wheatgrass  - Sedge 

693 

15 

Monoghan  Flats 

Bog  birch-Willow/Bog  Sedge 

2022 

45 

Hayden  Ridge 

White  Mountain  Avens 

289 

Non-use 

Sunset  Creek 

Tufted  Hairgrass-Sedge 

2264 

50 

Eaglesnest 

Arctic  Rough  Fescue-Tufted 
Hairgrass 

1374 

30 

Progress  Report  I,  1998  10 

LITERATURE  CITED 

Bork,  E.  1994.  Ecological  classification  and  management  of  native  range  in  Willmore 
Wilderness  Park.  Alberta  Environmental  Protection.  Forest  Management  Division.  Edmonton, 
AB.  Pub.  no.  T/282.  65pp. 

Bork,  E,  D.  Smith  and  M.G.  Willoughby.  1996.  Prescribed  burning  of  bog  birch. 
Rangelands.  18:  4-7. 

Daubenmire,  R.  1978.  Plant  Geography.  Academic  Press.  New  York.  338  pp. 

Gauch,  H.G.  1982.  Multivariate  analysis  in  community  ecology.  Cambridge  University 
Press.  Cambridge,  298  pp. 

Ogilvie,  R.T.  1969.  The  mountain  forest  and  alpine  zones  of  Alberta.  In  Vegetation  Soils 
and  Wildlife.  Edited  by  J.G.  Nelson  and  M.J.  Chambers.  Methuen  Publications,  Toronto,  pp  24- 
44. 


Parker,  K.W.  1954.  A method  for  measuring  trend  in  range  condition  on  national  forest 
ranges.  U.S.  Forest  Service,  Washington,  D.C.  26pp. 

MacCallum,  B.  and  R.  Yakimchuk.  1992.  Evaluation  of  the  effects  of  one  prescribed  bum 
on  a Willow/Bog  birch  meadow  in  the  Subalpine  Ecoregion  of  Alberta.  Rocky  Mtn.  Elk 
Foundation  and  Alberta  Fish  and  Wildlife  Division.  50pp. 

Morgantini,  L.E.  and  W.B.  Russell.  1983.  An  assessment  of  three  selected  elk  winter 
ranges  in  the  Rocky  Mountain  Region.  Alberta  Fish  and  Wildlife.  Edmonton,  AB.  265  pp. 

Strong,  W.L.  1992.  Ecoregions  and  ecodistricts  of  Alberta.  Vol.  I.  Alberta  Forestry  Lands 
and  Wildlife,  Land  Information  Services  Division,  Resource  Information  Branch,  Edmonton, 

AB.  T/244.  77pp. 

Strong,  W.L.  and  J.M.  Thompson.  1995.  Ecodistricts  of  Alberta.  Summary  of 
Biophysical  Attributes.  Alberta  Environmental  Protection,  Resource  Data  Division.  Edmonton, 
AB.  Pub.  no.  T/319.  91pp. 

Willougbhy,  M.G.  1995.  Species  diversity  and  how  it  is  affected  by  livestock  grazing  on 
Alberta’s  Eastern  slopes.  Proceedings  Fifth  International  Rangeland  Congress.  Salt  Lake  City, 
Utah.  July  1995.  Pg.  610-611. 

Willoughby,  M.G.  and  D.  Smith.  1997.  Range  plant  community  types  and  carrying 
capacity  for  the  Upper  Foothills  subregion.  Dept,  of  Environmental  Protection.  Land  and  Forest 
Service.  Edmonton.  AB.  Pub.  No.  T/356.  76pp. 


Progress  Report  I,  1998  1 1 

Willoughby,  M.G.  and  D.  Smith.  1998.  Range  plant  community  types  and  carrying 
capacity  for  the  Subalpine  subregion.  Dept,  of  Environmental  Protection.  Land  and  Forest 
Service.  Edmonton.  AB.  108pp. 

Willoughby,  M.G.  1997.  Rangeland  Reference  Areas;  Castle  River  range  condition  and 
trend  from  1953-1995.  Dept,  of  Environmental  Protection.  Land  and  Forest  Service.  Edmonton. 
AB.  Pub.  No.  T/358.  22pp. 

Willoughby,  M.G.  1998.  Rangeland  Reference  Areas;  Seven  mile  creek  range  condition 
and  trend  from  1964-1997.  Dept,  of  Environmental  Protection.  Land  and  Forest  Service. 
Edmonton.  AB.  Pub.  No.  T/403.  20pp. 


APPENDIX  A: 


SITE  DESCRIPTIONS  AND  PHOTOS 


Eagle’s  nest  cabin  transect 


Region  - Northeast  Slopes;  District  - Foothills;  Date  established  - 1998;  Location  - 
Twp.  52,  Rge.  4 Sec.  22  NW  W6  (N  53.30.477,  W1 18.29.946);  Elevation  -1614  m; 
Nutrients  - permesotrophic;  Drainage  - well;  Moisture  - subhygric;  Geological 
formation:  Old  flood  plain,  Glacial  Fluvial  parent  material;  Soil  Classification  - Orthic 
Regosol;  Description  of  Area  - rough  fescue,  hairy  wildrye,  tufted  hairgrass  meadow 
surrounded  by  willow  and  bog  birch  shrublands;  Major  species  present,  rough  fescue 
(Festuca  scabrella),  tufted  hairgrass  (Deschampsia  cespitosa),  slender  wheatgrass 
(Agropyron  trachycaulum),  hairy  wildrye  (Elymus  innovatus)  sedge  spp  (Carex  spp.) 
Veiny  meadow  rue  (Thalictrum  venulosum),  yellow  beardtongue  (Penstemon  confertus); 
Serai  stage  - young  edaphic  climax;  Transect  locations  -30  m long,  read  every  2 m 
starting  at  2 m,  read  on  right  hand  side  of  the  tape,  read  from  west  to  east;  This  transect 
was  one  of  a number  of  transects  established  to  monitor  shrub  encroachment  onto  the 
remaining  grassland  meadows  within  Willmore  Wilderness  Park. 


■ 


. 


■ 


Sunset  transect 


Region  - Northeast  Slopes;  District  - Foothills;  Date  established  - 1998;  Location  - 
Twp.  54,  Rge.  5 Sec.  30  SE  W6  (N  53.41.982,  W 118.43.600);  Elevation -1630  m; 
Nutrients  - permesotrophic;  Drainage  - well;  Moisture  - subhygric-hygric;  Parent 
material:  Fluvial;  Soil  Classification:  Cumulic  Humic  Regosol;  Description  of  Area  - 
tufted  hairgrass  meadow  surrounded  by  willow  and  bog  birch  shrublands;  Major  species 
present  tall  lungwort  (Mertensia  paniculata),  monkshood  (Aconitum  delphinifolium), 
tufted  hairgrass  (Deschampsia  cespitosa),  slender  wheatgrass  (Agropyron  trachycaulum), 
sedge  spp  (Carex  spp.)  Veiny  meadow  rue  (Thalictrum  venulosum);  Serai  stage  - young 
edaphic  climax;  Transect  locations  - 30  m long,  read  every  2 m starting  at  2 m,  read  on 
right  hand  side  of  tape  from  north  to  south;  This  transect  was  one  of  a number  of 
transects  established  to  monitor  shrub  encroachment  onto  the  remaining  grassland 
meadows  within  Willmore  Wilderness  Park. 


Monoghan  bum  transect 


Region  - Northeast  Slopes;  District  - Foothills;  Date  established  - 1998;  Location  - 
Twp.  53,  Rge.  7 Sec.  23  SE  W6  (N  53.35.227,  W1 18.55.172);  Elevation  -1530  m; 
Nutrients  - permesotrophic;  Drainage  - well;  Moisture  - subhygric;  Soil  Classification  - 
Orthic  Humic  Regosol;  Parent  material-alluvial  deposits  on  top  of  outwash  gravels; 
Description  of  Area  - Bog  birch  , willow  shrubland  which  was  burned  in  the  spring  of 
1990;  Major  species  present,  Bog  birch  (Betula  glandulosa),  willow  (Salix  spp.),  bog 
sedge  (Kobresia  myosuroides),  slender  wheatgrass  (Agropyron  trachycaulum),  sedge  spp 
(Carex  spp.)  California  oatgrass  (Danthonia  califomica),  strawberry  (Fragaria  virginiana); 
Serai  stage  - young  edaphic  climax;  Transect  locations  - 30  m long,  read  every  2 m 
starting  at  2 m,  read  on  right  hand  side  of  tape  from  east  to  west;  This  transect  was 
established  to  monitor  the  effects  of  the  1990  bum  on  bog  birch  and  willow  cover  at 
Monoghan  flats  within  Willmore  Wilderness  Park. 


' 


■ 


Kvass  bum  exclosure 


Region  - Northeast  Slopes;  District  - Foothills;  Date  established  - 1998;  Location  - 
Twp.  56,  Rge.  9 Sec.  3 NEW6(N  53.49.02,  W1 19.14.850);  Elevation -1060 m;  Aspect 
- 180°;  Slope  - 20%;  Nutrients  - mesotrophic;  Drainage  - well;  Moisture  - mesic;  Soil 
Classification  - Orthic  Humic  Regosol;  Parent  material  - coarse  textured  colluvial 
deposits,  on  slopes  above  the  Smoky  River;  Description  of  Area  - aspen  stands  which 
were  burned  in  1996;  Major  species  present,  slender  wheatgrass  (Agropyron 
trachycaulum),  sedge  spp  (Carex  spp.)  hairy  wildrye  (Elymus  innovatus)  snowberry 
(Symphoricarpos  occidentalis),  rose  (Rosa  acicularis),  strawberry  (Fragaria  virginiana), 
Lindley’s  aster  (Aster  ciliolatus),  showy  aster  (Aster  conspicuus);  Serai  stage  - early 
serai;  Exclosure  construction  - 20  x 30  m with  wood  and  steel  posts  and  two  strands  of 
barbed  wire;  Transect  locations  - 30  m long,  read  every  2 m starting  at  2 m,  read  on  right 
hand  side  of  tape  from  north  to  south,  the  outside  transect  is  located  3 m to  the  east  of  the 
exclosure  and  is  read  from  north  to  south;  This  exclosure  was  established  to  monitor  the 
effects  of  the  prescribed  bum  at  Kvass  flats  in  Willmore  Wilderness  Park 


Sulphur  exclosure 


Region  - Northeast  Slopes;  District  - Foothills;  Date  established  - 1998;  Location  - 
Twp.  54,  Rge.  8 Sec.  13  NE  W6  (N  53.40.080,  W1 19.02.196);  Elevation  -1634  m; 
Nutrients  - mesotrophic;  Drainage  - well;  Moisture  - mesic  - subhygric;  Soil 
Classification  - Orthic  Regosol;  Parent  material  - coarse  textured  fluvial  deposits, 
adjacent  to  the  Sulphur  River;  Description  of  Area  - grazed  sedge,  slender  wheatgrass 
meadow  surrounded  by  willow  and  bog  birch  shrublands;  Major  species  present,  slender 
wheatgrass  (Agropyron  trachycaulum),  sedge  spp  (Carex  spp.) , sheep  fescue  (Festuca 
saximontana),  alpine  milkvetch  (Astragalus  alpinus),  mouse  eared  chickweed  (Cerastium 
arvense),  strawberry  (Fragaria  virginiana);  Serai  stage  - young  edaphic  climax;  Exclosure 
construction  - 20  x 30  m with  wood  and  steel  posts  and  two  strands  of  barbed  wire; 
Transect  locations  - 30  m long,  read  every  2 m starting  at  2 m,  read  on  right  hand  side  of 
tape  from  north  to  south,  outside  transect  located  3 m on  north  side  of  the  exclosure  and 
read  from  south  to  north;  This  exclosure  was  established  to  monitor  shrub  encroachment 
and  recovery  of  heavily  grazed  grassland  meadows  within  Willmore  Wilderness  Park. 


Hayden  ridge  exclosure 


Region  - Northeast  Slopes;  District  - Foothills;  Date  established  - 1976?;  Location  - 
Twp.  55,  Rge.  7 Sec.  21  NE  W6  (N53.46.170  W1 18.58.608);  Elevation  - 1878  m;  Aspect 
- 180°;  Slope  - 30%;  Nutrients  - submesotrophic;  Drainage  - rapidly;  Moisture  - 
subxeric;  Soil  Classification  - non-soil;  Parent  material  - coarse  textured  sandstone  shale 
deposits,  on  ridge  tops  overlooking  the  Sulphur  River;  Description  of  Area  - dry 
windswept  snow  free  ridges;  Major  species  present,  white  mountain  avens  (Dryas 
integrifolia,  D.  octopetala),  bog  sedge  (Kobresia  myosuroides),  hairy  wildrye  (Elymus 
innovatus)  alpine  bistort  (Polygonum  viviparum),  reindeer  lichen  (Cladina  spp);  Serai 
stage  - mature  edaphic  climax;  Exclosure  construction  - 20  x 30  m with  wood  and  steel 
posts  and  8 ft  page  wire;  Transect  locations  - 30  m long,  read  every  2 m starting  at  2 m, 
read  on  right  hand  side  of  tape  from  northeast  to  southwest,  the  outside  transect  is 
located  3 m to  the  east  of  the  exclosure  and  is  read  from  south  to  north;  This  exclosure 
was  established  in  the  mid  1970’s  to  monitor  the  effects  of  the  bighorn  sheep  grazing  in 
Willmore  Wilderness  Park 


. 


j 


. 


National  Library  of  Canada 
Bibliotheque  nationale  du  Canada 


3286  52094766  0