Sable Island, with a catalogue of its vascular plants

I9ZI

BIOLOGY LIBRARY

Proceedings of the Boston Society of Natural History.

VOL. 36, No. 1,
p. 1-103, pis. 1, 2.

CONTRIBUTIONS FROM THE GRAY HERBARIUM OF
HARVARD UNIVERSITY. NEW SERIES.— No. LXII.

SABLE ISLAND, WITH A CATALOGUE OF ITS VASCULAR PLANTS.

By HAROLD ST. JOHN.

BOSTON:

PRINTED FOR THE SOCIETY,
MARCH, 1921.

BIOLOGY LIBRARY"

Proceedings of the Boston Society of Natural History.

VOL. 36, No. 1,
p. 1-103, pis. 1, 2.

CONTRIBUTIONS FROM THE GRAY HERBARIUM OF
HARVARD UNIVERSITY. NEW SERIES.— No. LXII.

I S 3 U 3 d

Mar. 14 1921

SABLE ISLAND, WITH A CATALOGUE OF ITS VASCULAR PLANTS.

BY HAROLD ST. JOHN.

BOSTON:

PRINTED FOR THE SOCIETY.
MARCH, 1921.

•*• "• .* I I •* •

^bLOGY:lllBlURY
•:*:I: :"•.":•: : A* ":

S3

JB10LOOJ*

/f'rf-

CONTENTS.

Introduction 5

Present status of Sable Island 0

History

Early history 7

First Humane Establishment, 1801 17

Diminishing size of Sable Island 18

Changes in Wallace Lake 23

Zoology

The endemic fresh-water sponge 25

Ipswich Sparrow 25

Native and introduced animals 27

Sable Island ponies 28

Botany

Early botanical records 32

Plant habitats 39

Phytogeography 44

Forestry experiments 47

Catalogue of the vascular plants 56

List of abbreviations 98

List of new species, varieties, and forms 98

Tabular statement of families, genera, species, varieties, and

forms of the native or adventive flora 99

Bibliography 101

M71380

INTRODUCTION. j v,* /•", \ : ,„ j • ' ; ,r >v

IN the summer of 1913, the writer made a botanical collecting trip
to Sable Island, Nova Scotia. The journey was taken at the sugges-
tion of Prof. Merritt L. Fernald, without whose continued inspiration
and practical assistance, its results oould scarcely have been brought
together in the present report. There are many other acknowledg-
ments to make, especially to Dr. B. L. Robinson, who arranged to
have the writer go as a collector from the Gray Herbarium, and who
has forwarded in every way the completion of the work. Miss Mary
A. Day Librarian of the Gray Herbarium, has frequently been of
great assistance, especially in bibliographical matters. The writer
wishes particularly to express his thanks to the responsible Canadian
Government officials because of their constant readiness to make the
expedition possible and pleasant. Unless a shipwrecked waif, one
may not land on Sable Island without a permit from the Government.
Mr. A. Johnston, Deputy Minister of Marine and Fisheries, of Otta-
wa, and Mr. C. H. Harvey, Agent of Marine and Fisheries, at Hali-
fax, gave permission to visit the island and arranged for transporta-
tion on Government steamers. The Superintendent of Sable Is-
land, Capt. J. U. Blakeney, both officially and personally, was help-
ful in every way possible, as were the members of the staff of the Life
Saving Stations, the Lighthouses, and the Marconi Station. In Hal-
ifax by good fortune it was possible to meet Mr. Robert J. Bouteillier,
former Superintendent of Sable Island. His unusual intelligence and
keen powers of observation had given him during his long period of
residence 28 years, an unrivalled knowledge of Sable Island and its
phenomena. This knowledge he has frequently shared. To the
late Mr. J. M. Macoun of the Canadian Geological Survey and to Dr.
H. T. Giissow of the Central Experimental Farm, Ottawa, thanks are
extended for the loan of specimens. Mr. Edwin R. Jump has kindly
read part of the manuscript and checked it with his intensive knowl-
edge of the history of Sable Island. The accompanying plates were
drawn by Mr. F. Schuyler Mathews.

6 PROCEEDINGS: BOSTON SOCIETY NATURAL HISTORY.

PRESENT STATUS OF SABLE ISLAND.

Stretching between Cape Cod and Newfoundland is a series of
shoals or banks, Nantucket Shoals, Georges Bank, Brown 's Bank, La
Have Bank, Sambro Bank, Emerald Bank, Sable Island Bank, Mid-
dle Ground, CPJISO Bank, Misaine Bank, Artimon Bank, Banquereau,
St. Pierre Bank, Green Banks, and the Grand Banks of Newfoundland.
In all this stretch there is but one spot above high- tide level, Sable
Island, a long crescent of sand dunes, twenty miles in length and less
than one mile broad.

The visitor to Sable Island will start from Halifax, Nova Scotia,
and steam eastward 150 miles. If the weather is calm and there have
been no northerly winds for two or three days, the steamer will ap-
proach the northerly, that is to say, the inner side of the crescent-
shaped island, and anchor a mile or more from land. Surf -boats put
out from the beach and soon the landing of the few passengers and
the very important supplies is begun. On the way to the beach there
are three troublesome bars that must be crossed on the crest of a big
wave, so the trip is exciting enough for the most venturesome, and all
the passengers are glad to have the boat's nose ground in the soft sand
of the beach, above which rises a steep sand dune. If he climbs the
tall look-out mast crowning it, he will see that this dune is continued
as a ridge or range of dunes skirting the top of the North Beach
throughout the whole length of the island, and that this ridge called
the North Ridge, forms the backbone of the island. Near the east
end of the island the dunes attain their greatest height, and at one
place between Life Saving Stations Nos. 3 and 4, the North Ridge rises to
a peak called Rigging Hill, nearly 100 feet in height. From the North
Ridge the dunes run inland diminishing in height and separated by
dry or wet dune hollows. In some places there are definite cross-
ridges of dunes. In every case these have their western faces bare, a
condition caused by the constant erosion of the prevailing westerly
winds. From the west end of the island, for a distance of twelve
miles, the central strip is occupied by a large salt lake, Wallace Lake.
The drifting sand has recently filled up a section of the lake a mile
long and divided it into two unequal parts. The farther shore of
Wallace Lake is formed by a narrow strip of sand, the South Beach.
Near the eastern end of Wallace Lake there are a few dunes on the
Sruth Beach, the only remnants of the protecting ridge of dunes that

ST. JOHN: SABLE ISLAND. 7

used to run the whole length of that beach. In the larger dune hol-
lows are fresh-water ponds, and near the shores, and especially at the
eastern end of Wallace Lake, are series of brackish ponds. The dunes,
especially those near the sea, and the pond shores are well covered
with vegetation. The beach grass forms a thin covering over all but
the most recent dunes and flats, but there are great stretches, espec-
ially near the East End, where the blown sand is beyond control, drift-
ing over everything and forming a barren desert of shifting white sand.
This is a bird's-eye view of Sable Island as it was in 1913, but we know
from trustworthy records that many changes had taken place and
that previously it was very different, at least in size.

EARLY HISTORY OF SABLE ISLAND.

Who was the first of the European voyagers to sight Sable Island,
we cannot now say. It is certain, though, that at the beginning of
the 16th century, the fishermen of western Europe were acquainted
with it.1 "This is shown by maps of the period One preserved
in the royal library at Munich, marked as made by Pedro Reinel,
who is described by Herrera as ' a Portuguese pilot of much fame/
and supposed to be of about the year 1505, has it under the name of
Santa Cruz.

"On the 13th March, 1521, the King of Portugal granted to Joan
Alvarez Fagundez a large territory embracing Nova Scotia and ad-
jacencies, together with various islands lying off it, which he is said
to have discovered on a previous voyage, and among them is Santa
Cruz."

"Gastaldi, a distinguished Italian cartographer, in a map of 1548,
represents it under the name Isolla del Arena, and he is followed by
his countryman, Zaltieri in 1566. But as early as 1546 Joannes
Freire, a Portuguese mapmaker, calls it I. de Sable, * * * and by
the end of that period it seems to have been commonly known by that
name."

This is no place to give a detailed history of Sable Island; conse-
quently only the more important facts, especially those bearing on
its physiography or natural history, will be mentioned.

1 Much of this historical data has been freely drawn from Patterson, Rev.
George: Sable Island: Its History and Phenomena. Trans. Roy. Soc.
Can. xii. §2. 3-49 (1894).

8 PROCEEDINGS: BOSTON SOCIETY NATURAL HISTORY.

Many of the early voyagers refer to the herds of cattle to be found
on the island, and there is a great deal of conflicting evidence as to
how and when they got there. According to Champlain, they were
left there about the year 1552 by the Portuguese. "Not only does
Champlain mention the fact, but we find the same asserted by the
historian of Sir Humphrey Gilbert's expedition. That intrepid mar-
iner sailed from Newfoundland in 1583 for the American coast in-
tending, after making Cape Breton, to go to Sable Island, as the writ-
er says, ' upon intelligence we had of a Portugal who was himself pre-
sent when the Portugals, above thirty years past/ consequently be-
fore 1553, 'did put into the same island neat and swine to breed,
which were since exceedingly multiplied.' Eight days after sailing
from Newfoundland, or early in the morning of the 29th of
August the largest ship of the three in the fleet, the 'Admiral' of 120
tons, with Maurice Browne, captain, and Richard Clarke, master,
first ran among shoals, then stroke aground and had soone after
her sterne and hinder partes beaten in peeces'."1 It has been gen-
erally interpreted as by Brymner2 that this happened on Sable Is-
land. There are two accounts of the event, one by Clarke, a relation
of Richard Clarke, the master of the Admiral, the other by Hayes,
captain and owner of the Golden Hinde. These contradictory ac-
counts are both given by Hakluyt. All of the evidence has been re-
viewed by Patterson3 who concludes that the wreck of the Admiral
could not have taken place upon Sable Island and that it pro-
bably occured upon Cape Breton, near Louisbourg.

"The island1 and the cattle upon it next come into notice by the
expedition of Troilus du Mesgouez, Marquis de la Roche. He
was a Catholic nobleman of Brittany, who had from his youth been
connected with the French court. He agreed with the King to found
a colony in America, and for that purpose received from him a com-
mission in which he was named lieutenant-general of Canada, Hochel-
aga, Newfoundland, Labrador, and the countries adjacent, with
sovereign power over this vast domain. This commission was first

1 Patterson, I. c. 8.

2 Brymner, Douglas: Rept. on Canadian Archives, pp. xxv-xxvii (1895).

3 Patterson, Rev. George: Termination of Sir Humphrey Gilbert's Expe-
dition. Trans. Roy. Soc. Can. 2nd ser. iii. part 2, 113-27, 2 illustr. and 1
chart (1897).

ST. JOHN: SABLE ISLAND. 9

issued in 1578. " Biggar tells us1 that "he did not set sail until 1584.
Unfortunately his largest vessel with over one hundred colonists on
board was wrecked near Brouague and the voyage had to be aban-
doned."

"In that year [1598] he set out with one small vessel, under Chef
d'hotel, a distinguished Norman pilot. * * * His expedition was
so modest, not to say cheap, in its proportion and equipment as to
seem quite unworthy of its ambitious mission, or the vice-regal rank
of its commander. One vessel constituted the fleet, and it is so small,
that, according to a contemporary chronicle, you could wash your
hands in the water without leaving the deck, while forty out of the
sixty men comprising the marquis' army of occupation and evangel-
ization, were convicts chosen from the royal prisons/'2

Biggar, who has investigated many of the old archives, gives us a
somewhat different account. He quotes the contract made in March,
1597, between la Roche and Chefdostel, master of the La Catherine
of 170 tons. Chefdostel was to transport a company of soldiers to
Sable Island on condition that la Roche should pay for half the car-
go of salt, half the wages of the crew, and the whole of the provisions.
A year later la Roche, failing to attract bonafide colonists, was allow-
ed to take convicts from the jails of Brittany and Normandy. On
the 16th of March, 1598, la Roche made a new contract with Chef-
dostel who for 600 crowns was to transport the convicts to Sable Is-
land. Two days later a similar contract was made with Jehan Girot,
master of the Frangoise, who having a smaller vessel was to receive
100 crowns.

The Marquis de la Roche obtained 200 or 250 convicts, male and
female, from the prisons, but it appears that he allowed many of these
to purchase their freedom before sailing. He set sail in 1 598 and on reach-
ing Sable Island landed 40, 50, or 60 of the convicts,3 leaving with
them a small supply of provisions and goods; then he sailed away to

1 Biggar, H. P.: The Early Trading Companies of New France, 39 (1901).

2 Oxley, J. M.: Mag. of Amer. Hist. xv. 166 (1886).

3 Charlevoix, P. F. X. : Histoire et Description de la Nouvelle France, i. 109
(1744), says 40 convicts were landed; Gosselin, E. : Early French Voyages to
Newfoundland, Mag. Am. Hist. viii. 288 (1882), says that the colonists "with
the exception of fifty, refused to disembark, and compelled de la Roche to
bring them back to France"; Biggar, H. P. : The Early Trading Companies
of New France, 40 (1901), says that only sixty persons were actually landed on
the island.

10 PROCEEDINGS: BOSTON SOCIETY NATURAL HISTORY.

explore the neighboring coast of Acadia. He intended "to select a
site for settlement, to which he proposed afterwards to remove them.
On his return he was caught by a tempest, which drove him east-
ward. His frail bark was obliged to run before the storm, and at last
he reached France, intending soon to return. But misfortune attend-
ed him. The Due de Moncoeur is said to have cast him into prison.
At all events five years elapsed before anything could be done for the
relief of the unfortunate creatures he had left behind."1

" At first it would seem as if on being thus released from all restraint
they fought with one another like entrapped rats, for Les-carbot tells
that 'ces gens se mutinerent, et se couperent la gorge Tun a Pautre'.
Then as the horror of their situation fully dawned upon them, and
they realized that only by harmonious co-operation could any life be
preserved, better counsels prevailed, and systematic efforts were put
forth to secure a maintenance. From the wreck of a Spanish ship
they built themselves huts, the ocean furnished them with fire-wood,
the wild cattle with meat, the seals with clothing, and with some
seeds and farming implements happily included among the 'bagage'
mentioned by Les-carbot, they carried on agricultural operations in a
sheltered valley by the lake-side whose tradition remains to this day
by the locality being known as the French Gardens.

" Despite these alleviations in the rigor of their fate, however, the
utter absence of the most necessary comforts, and their own evil
deeds so reduced their numbers that when, in 1603, the King sent a
vessel [under Chef d'h6tel, the same pilot] to bring them back, only
eleven out of the original forty were found alive, clad in their self-
made seal-skin garments, broken, haggard, and unkempt, they were
presented before Henry IV., and their harrowing tale so touched the
royal heart that they each received a full pardon for their crimes, and
a solatium of fifty golden crowns. The strangest part of the story
remains yet to be told. Undeterred by an experience that was surely
sufficient to appall the stoutest hearted, these Rip Van Winkles of the
sea, whose names may still be found in record in the Registres
d' Audience du Parliament de Rouen, returned to their place of exile, and
drove a thriving trade in furs and ivory with their mother country for
many years, until one by one they passed away."2

1 Patterson, I c. 8.

2 Oxley, I c. 167.

ST. JOHN: SABLE ISLAND. 11

From Governor John Winthrop's Journal1 we learn that "Mr. John
Rose, being cast ashore there in the [Mary and Jane] two years since
[1633], and making a small pinnace of the wreck of his ship, sailed
thence to the French upon the main, being thirty leagues off, by
whom he was detained prisoner, and forced to pilot them to the is-
land, where they had great store of sea-horse and cattle, and black
foxes; and they left seventeen men upon the island to inhabit it. The
island is thirty miles long, two miles broad in most places, a mere sand,
yet full of fresh water in ponds, etc. He saw about eight hundred
cattle, small and great, all red, and the largest he ever saw, and many
foxes whereof some perfect black. There is no wood upon it, but
store of wild peas and flags by the ponds, and grass. In the middle
of it is a pond of salt water, ten miles long, full of plaice etc. "

"In 1634 the island was granted, along with Port Royal and La
Heve, by the Company of the Hundred Associates, to Claude de
Razilli, brother of Isaac de Razilli, who had been appointed comman-
der or governor-in-chief of Acadia, and who had commenced a settle-
ment at La Heve."2

In the following year, 1635, according to Governor John Winthrop1,
" Mr. Graves, in the James, and Mr. Hodges, in the Rebecka, set sail
for the Isle of Sable for sea horse (which are there in great number)
and wild cows. The company which went now, carried

twelve landmen, two mastiffs, a house and a shallop.

"[August 26.1 They returned from their voyage. They found
there upon the island sixteen Frenchmen, who had wintered there,
and built a little fort, and killed some black foxes. They had killed
also many of the cattle, so as they found not above one hundred and
forty, and but two or three calves. They could kill but few sea-horse,
by reason they were forced to travel so far in the sand as they were
too weak to stick them, and they came away at such time as they
[the sea-horse or walrus] use to go up highest to eat green peas. The
winter there is very cold, and the snow above knee deep. "

Commander de Razilli died that year or the next, and his brother
transferred the rights of both to Charnisay, and the French seem to
have abandoned the island.

1 Winthrop, John: The History of New England from 1630 to 1649, edited
by James Savage, i. 162 (1825).

2 Patterson, George: Supplementary Notes on Sable Island. Trans. Roy.
Soc. Can. 2nd series, iii. § 2, 133 (1897).

12 PROCEEDINGS: BOSTON SOCIETY NATURAL HISTORY.

Governor Winthrop also records1 that in the summer of 1642 "the
merchants of Boston sent out a vessel again to the isle of Sable, with
12 men, to stay there a year. They sent again in the 8th month, and
in three weeks the vessel returned and brought home 400 pair of sea
horse teeth, which were esteemed worth £300, and left all the men
well and 12 tons of oil and many skins, which they could not bring
away, being put from the island in a storm. "

In the 4th month of 1642, "the adventurers to the Isle of Sable
fetched off their men and goods all safe. The oil, teeth seal and
horse hides, and some black fox skins came near to £1500."2

As we learn from a letter by Bishop Saint Vallier, written in 1686,
the Acadians caught and shipped large numbers of the wild cattle to
their homes on the mainland, where they domesticated them. We
do not find the wild cattle mentioned after this time.

During the early part of the 18th century we hear very little of
Sable Island. It was next brought into prominence by the Rev. An-
drew Le Mercier, a graduate of Geneva and of old Huguenot stock,
who, in 1719, became pastor of the French Protestant Church in Bos-
ton. In 1729, on the arrival of Governor Phillips in Nova Scotia, Le
Mercier proposed to him to plant a colony of French Protestants in
Nova Scotia. The Governor recommended a grant of 5,000 acres,
but nothing came of it. On the 6th of March, 1738, we find Le Mer-
cier petitioning3 Governor Armstrong for a grant of Sable Island, but
after approval of his petition, he was unwilling to pay the penny an
acre quit-rent. At this time, Le Mercier sent stock to the island pre-
paratory to moving his family there. In 1740, he again applied for
a grant of the island arguing4 that as the land is " low, boggy and sandy
soil, with large ponds or settlings of water occasioned by the overflow-
ings of the tides, he thinks the penny an acre too much for what can
not be improved."

. At the instance of Le Mercier, the Governor of Nova Scotia issued
two proclamations forbidding any molestation of Le Mercier's estab-
lishment on Sable Island. Nevertheless, he suffered losses and ad-
vertised in a Boston paper5, in 1744, a reward of £40 for the detection

1 Winthrop, I c. ii. 34.

2 Winthrop, I. c. 67.

3 Murdoch, Beamish: Hist, of Nova Scotia, i. 523 (1865).
*Ibti., ii. 6 (1866).

6 Boston Evening-Post, Jan. 30 (1744).

ST. JOHN: SABLE ISLAND. 13

of the plunderers, saying, "Notwithstanding those two Proclama-
tions, the low of Money, which is the Root of all Evil, is so deeply root-
ed in the Hearts of some Fishermen, that they have sundry Times
Stole our Cattle and our Goods, regarding neither the Laws of God
or of Man, neither Justice to me, or Humanity to Shipwreck'd Men,
which by their Wickedness they endeavor to Starve, and minding
neither natural or revealed Religion and their eternal Damnation,
nor even their own temporal Interest, which is certainly not to hin-
der but to promote the abovesaid Settlement, since it may be their
Case one Time or other to be cast away upon the Island Sables, and
to want there those Things which they have carried off. "

In the year 1746, the Due d' Anville, in his expedition against the
British colonies, was overtaken by a severe storm near this island and
lost a transport and a fire-ship.

In 1753, Le Mercier published a detailed notice of Sable Island.1
It is really an advertisement, by means of which he hoped to sell the
island, so we must understand and discount the very rosy light in
which it is portrayed. As the article is of very considerable interest,
and as it is not readily available to all readers, it seems worth while
to quote it here in its entirety.

"TO BE SOLD by me the Subscriber
"(Andrew Le Mercier, Pastor of the French Church)

"THE ISLAND Sables.
" The Publick hath here a short description of it for nothing.

" SAID Island is situated at the Distance of about 40 Leagues from
Halifax, thirty from Cape Breton, and 50 from Newfoundland; a good
Market for the Produce of the Island, Cattle & Roots of all sorts. It
is about 28 Miles long, one Mile over, and contains about 10,000 Acres
of Land, 500 of which are quite barren, all the rest produces or may
bear something. Their are neither River or Brooks or fresh Water,
but everywhere even upon the Beach you may come to fresh clear
Water by digging about 3 feet, by which means the root of the Grass
is always kept cool and alive, so that it cannot be much subject to a
Drought, as it was experienced three Years ago. The Climate may
be called temperate, for as in Winter the Snow hardly lies above three

1Le Mercier, Andrew: The Island Sables. Boston Weekly News Letter,
February 8 (1753).

14 PROCEEDINGS: BOSTON SOCIETY NATURAL HISTORY.

Days on the Ground, so it is never extream hot in Summer, and it is
a rare thing to be frightened by any Thunder. It bears no venomous
Creatures of any sort, and hardly any Flies. — The high Winds clear
the air, which makes it healthy; and nature hath furnished it with
medicinal Plants and Shrubs: — It produces naturally near 20
sorts of Berries, out of which some People suppose very good
Liquors and Wines might be expressed — It looks all green in Winter
with the Juniper Bushes and red in Summer with the large Straw-
berries and other wild Fruits which it bears. — It hath abundance of
wild or Beach Pease, which fatten the Cattle very well: — By several
Pieces of petrified Wood found there it is supposed that the Sand hath
a Property of petrifying Wood. — Within these seven or eight Years
Providence hath opened a Communication between the great Pond
(fifteen Miles long) and the Sea, which hath made a safe and large
Harbour, but the Entrance is barred so that large and sharp Vessels
cannot get into it; but as there is about 8 Feet of Water over the Bar
at high Water there is sufficient Passage (as we know by Experience)
for Vessels of 30 Tuns or more, if not built Sharp. — The Ponds abound
with Flounders and Eels; the Beech itself with Clams and Sand Eels;
the Air with Fowls, and especially with black Ducks, so as to make
money with their Feathers. The Soil is so natural for all sorts of Roots,
especially Turnipe, that they are not only uncommonly sweet there but
also uncommonly large, some weighing 7 Pounds a piece: — Rye grows
there very naturally and also Wheat at the Rate of 13 Bushels per
acre. It is supposed that Flax would grow there very well ; it would
also produce Indian Corn well enough if the high Winds in the Fall
did not break it: — There is neither Trees (but many Bushes) nor
Stones. — The Grass is tall, thick and hath a very sweet taste and
nourishing Property; there is some English Grass, but the other is
more profitable, and there is enough to feed some thousand Heads
of Cattle: — Horses breed and grow there without Care or Trouble;
there is all Winter long Grass enough or near enough for them, so that
they eat but little of the Hay which is made for them in the Summer
or the Fall. — The raising of Sheep, Horn-Cattle, and especially of
Horses is the most Advantagious (as for the Grain there are not above
400 Acres where it may be raised). The Care of Gardens and Cattle
take up our People's Time in Summer, in Winter they go to kill Seils
and boil their Fat into Oyl, as well as that of Whales, which now and
then are cast away dead upon the Beach. The Island finds them in

ST. JOHN: SABLE ISLAND. 15

Turf and the Sea brings them Wood; so they are not deprived of the
Necessaries of Life, nor without Profits of several Sorts; besides their
having the pleasure of saving many Men's Lives, according to the
motto of the Island, viz — Destruo & Salvo. When I took Possession
of the Island there was no four-footed Creatures upon it, but a few
foxes some red and some black (some of which remain to this Day)
now there are I suppose about 90 Sheep, between 20 or 30 Horses in-
cluding Colts, Stallions and breeding Mares, about 30 or 40 Cows
tame and Wild, and 40 Hogs. There are all sorts of Utensils for
Farming and trying Fat, several Boats and six or seven small Houses
and Warehouses. The advantages which do acrue or may acrue from
the Improvement of that Place are so great that I would not easily
part with it if I was so skilful in Navigation and Shipping as is nec-
essary: That Ignorance of mine induces me (not any Defect in the
Island itself) to part with it. If any Person desires to purchase it,
and to know further about it, they may see at my House a Map and
Plan of it, or if they live at a Distance by letters sent (Postage free)
they may enquire about any Thing, they want to be satisfied in, and
I will endeavor to give them all the Light they desire. I must know
their Mind within 2 or 3 Months, that the Crew now upon the Is-
land, may be disposed of accordingly."

" Boston, the 5th Day of Andrew Le Mercier,

" February, 1 763 Pastor of the French Church. ' '

It does not appear that Le Mercier found a purchaser. He died on
March 31st, 1764, and his will, drawn on the 7th of November, 1761,
does not mention Sable Island. At least in 1760, the island was un-
inhabited and a certain Boston merchant, Thomas Hancock1, desir-
ing to relieve the sufferings of those shipwrecked, fitted out a schooner
with "Horses, Cows, Sheep, Goats, Hogs and Animals likely to live
on the Island. They were landed there and generally answered very
well."

In 1760, a vessel with a part of the 43d regiment returning from
the capture of Quebec, was wrecked on the island. The evidence of
this was found long afterward. "In the year 1842, during a severe
gale, an old landmark in the form of a pyramid, said to be one hun-
dred feet high, was completely blown away, exposing some small huts
built of the timbers and planks of a vessel. On examination they
were found to contain quite a number of articles of furniture, stores

1 Kept, on Canadian Archives, 86 (1895).

16 PROCEEDINGS: BOSTON SOCIETY' NATURAL HISTORY.

put in boxes, bales of blankets, a quantity of military shoes, and,
among other articles, a dog-collar of brass, on which was engraved
the name of Major Elliott, 43rd regiment. On referring to the re-
cords of the regiment, however, it was found that the party had been
taken off the island. The site of the encampment is now under at
least five fathoms of water."1

In 1774, permission was granted by Governor Legge, and approved
by the King, to Michael Flannigan and his associates to reside on the
island.2 We know nothing of their intentions or the length of their
stay.

During the War of the American Revolution, American privateers
frequently visited Sable Island and made great inroads on all its re-
sources. By the close of the hostilities none of the animals remained,
except a few of the horses.

Moses Gerrish, a Newburyport skipper, was shipwrecked on Sable
Island on a homeward voyage from the Banks, November 9, 1787.
The provisions which he and his crew saved, and a number of young
seal lasted them about 60 days when they "had recourse to the horses

* * * * we killed and eat 13 of them. * * * Being with-
out ammunition, we were obliged to dig pits to betray horses, it be-
ing impossible to get them in any other way."3 He was rescued on
the 18th of April by Capt. Nathaniel Preble of the schooner Betsy.

In the year 1789, a certain Jesse Lawrence, "who lived on the isle
of Sable, to receive wrecked people, and to carry on the seal fishery,
was attacked by people from Massachusetts, who landed there and
wantonly pillaged and destroyed his house and effects, and then com-
pelled him to leave the island. He received some compensation from
Governor Hancock [of Massachusetts] and his council, which still left
him a sufferer. "4

During the last few years of the 18th century, Sable Island was the
scene of many disastrous shipwrecks, and at this time objects of great
value and foreign origin, laces, jewelry, etc., were seen in the cabins of
certain Nova-Scotian fishermen, and ugly tales were told about wreck-
Patterson, George: Sable Island. Trans. Roy. Soc. Can. xii. §2, 11-12
(1894).
2 Murdoch, Beamish: Hist, of Nova-Scotia, ii. 526 (1866).

* Essex Journal and New Hampshire Packet (1788) ; and Boston Herald and
Journal, December 28 (1917).

4 Murdoch, I. c. iii. 78 (1867); and Nova Scotia Gazette, February 10 (1789).

ST. JOHN: SABLE ISLAND. 17

ers and pirates preying on any unfortunates cast upon the island. So
notorious was this condition, that at the instance of Sir John Went-
worth an act was passed in 1801 for the protection of shipwrecked
property; and unauthorized persons were forbidden to dwell on
Sable Island, and were forcibly removed.

The captain and the crew of one cf the vessels cast away at this
time were forced to stay on Sable Island through the winter. It be-
came the Captain's custom after each storm to examine the part of the
island most affected by it. In doing this he counted over 40 wrecks,
which had been uncovered, not one of which was visible before.

FIRST HUMANE ESTABLISHMENT, 1801.

On the 25th of June, 1801, the House of Assembly of Nova Scotia
authorized the settling of three families on Sable Island and voted
£600 to defray the expenses. James Morris was appointed the first
Superintendent, and on the 13th of October, he with his family and
assistants was landed on the island. The object was to save the lives
and the property of people shipwrecked on the island. Three years
later, by an official report, we learn that from five wrecks, Supt. Mor-
ris and his staff were responsible for saving the lives of 41 persons and
£2,300 worth of property.

Between 1801 and 1913, there have been 176 known wrecks on the
Island, and it is estimated from bits of wreckage that at least as many
"missing ships" have struck and gone down with all hands on the
more distant parts of the bars. The Northwest Bar extends 1 1 miles
beyond the West End of the island and the Northeast Bar 16 miles
beyond the East End, so that in time of storms the island and its bars
form a line of breakers and shoals nearly 50 miles long that bodes
ill for any mariner who attempts to cross.

During the War of 1812, President Madison issued strict orders that
"the public and private armed vessels of the United States are not to
interrupt any British unarmed vessels bound to Sable Island, and
laden with supplies for the humane establishment at that place."1

The establishment has continued to the present day, supported at
first by the government of Nova Scotia, then by Nova Scotia and
Great Britain jointly, and now by Canada and Great Britain. In
1913, it consisted of five Life Saving Stations and two lighthouses,
with a staff of twenty-one men, and a Marconi Station with five men, the

lNiles' Weekly Register, iii. 191 (1812).

18 PROCEEDINGS: BOSTON SOCIETY NATURAL HISTORY.

total population including the families being about sixty persons. In
the records of this establishment we have continuous detailed informa-
tion as to the conditions on Sable Island.

DIMINISHING SIZE or SABLE ISLAND.

We find Sable Island represented on the early charts of the coast
of North America such as that by Reinel, in 1505, by Rotz in 1542,
by Joannes Freire in 1546, by Vaz Dourado in 1573, and by that of
Hakluyt in 1598-1600. It also appears on the small-scale maps by
Philippe Buache in 1736, and that by Bellin in 1757.

In 1766 and 1767, Joseph Frederick Wallet Des Barres made a sur-
vey of Sable Island, published1 in 1777 and 1779. It is drawn on
two different scales, the larger about one-half a mile to the inch.
He gives several hundred soundings near the island and locates it be-
tween 60° 01' and 60° 32' W. Long. The island itself is shown as a
long flat crescent, in shape much as it is to-day, and 30 miles long
by 2 miles broad. The second highest hill is 146 feet above sea
level. The center of the island is shown with an inland lake 12
feet in depth, with an opening to the sea on the north side. Al-
most continuous ridges of dunes shelter this lake on both the north
and the south sides. Des Barres says, "The whole island is composed
of fine white sand, much coarser than any of the soundings about it,
and inter-mixed with small transparent stones. Its face is very brok-
en, and hove up in little hills, knobs and cliffs, wildly heaped together,
within which are hollows and ponds of fresh water, * * * . The
Ram's Head is the highest hill on this island; it has a steep cliff on the
north west and falls gently to the south east. The Naked Sand Hills
are one hundred and forty-six feet of perpendicular height above the
level of high-water mark, ***** Gratia Hill is a knob at
the top of a cliff the height of which is one hundred and twenty-six
feet * * V'2

Of this same period is a chart by Capt. John Montresor: Map of
Nova Scotia or Acadia; with the Islands of Cape Breton and St.
John's, from Actual Surveys, by Capt. Montresor, 1768. The scale
is about 6 miles to the inch. Sable Island is shown as 30 % miles in
length by 2 miles in breadth. The salt lake has an opening at its
western end through the South Beach. The dunes extend half-way

1 Atlantic Neptune, i (1777 and 1779).

2 Des Barres, I c. 68.

ST. JOHN: SABLE ISLAND. 19

down the South Beach, but the remainder is shown as a mere sand
flat. There is no detail as to the fresh- water ponds or the individual
dunes.

Another British Admiralty chart of Sable Island, dated 1770, ap-
peared as Chart 8 in Robert Sayer's North American Pilot of 1779.
These charts were drawn from original surveys by James Cook, Mi-
chael Lane, Surveyors, Joseph Gilbert, and other officers in the King's
Service, and they were engraved by Thomas Jeffreys, and printed by
R. Sayer and J. Bennett. Although this Sayer chart was, like the
Des Barres chart, an official British Admiralty chart and was pub-
lished in a volume of the same year as the second issue of the Des Bar-
res chart, and although there is no indication of the identity of the
surveyor of the Sayer chart, yet the two charts were undoubtedly
based on two distinct and independent surveys. The Sayer chart is
on the scale about 3 miles to the inch. The outline of the island is
the same flat crescent, like that shown by Des Barres, and the length
is " about 30 Miles, in Breadth across the Pond, Meadow and upland
a Mile;" but the details are quite different. There is no indication
of the height of the sand dunes, and the local place-names differ. The
opening from the salt lake through the North Ridge has been drifted
over and appears as a sand flat, marked, "The Place to Dig for a
Harbour. " Instead there is an opening through the South Beach at
the western end of the salt lake. The South Beach is shown with a
line of dunes running for six miles from the east end, then for the rest of
its length it is shown as a mere sand flat with a few remnants of dunes.
This chart lacks the detail of the location of the fresh-water ponds
and the numerous ridges of dunes such as appears on the Des Barres
chart.

Superintendent James Morris, in 1801, estimated one hill at the
east end to be 200 feet high and others to be 150 feet high.

Lieut. Burton, in 1808, made a survey of the island when it was pro-
posed to place a lighthouse there.. He reported the island to be 30
miles in length and 2 miles in breadth, with hills from 150 to 200 feet,
beginning at the west end, and attaining their greatest elevation at
Mount Knight, its eastern extremity.

When, in 1802, the position for the main station was chosen, it was
one remarkably sheltered among the sand hills, 5 miles from the West
End.

" In 1814 the Superintendent, Mr. Hudson, wrote the Government,
that owing to the rapid manner in which the island was being washed

20 PROCEEDINGS: BOSTON SOCIETY NATURAL HISTORY.

away it would be necessary for him to remove the establishment to
a more secure position; that within 4 years previous, 4 miles had gone
entirely from the west end, leaving but a mile between him and the
sea which was advancing steadily. On the north side an area equal
to 4,0 ft. wide and 3 miles long had gone bodily from the island during
a single night. He intended to move the buildings to a place called
'Middle Houses', 3 miles further east.

"In 1820 the Superintendent again wrote the Government, that
not only had the old site of the main station gone seaward; but the
sea was again encroaching to such an alarming extent that he would
be obliged to once more remove the station, and had selected a place
known as the 'Haul over/ 4 miles further east. Here it enjoyed a
short respite when again the sea threatened its foundation. * * *
again the sea advanced, the two following winters were noted for the
frequency of storms, and the havoc made along the sand cliffs, every
gale sensibly diminishing the western portion of the island, toppling
great masses of sand hills into the surf below as well as changing the
surface of the interior. One instance * * * when thousands of
tons of sand were carried from the beach and strewn over the island,
smothering vegetation, so that hundreds of horses died for want of
food."1

It has been argued by J. B. Gilpin2, and following him by Prof.
John Macoun3, that the action of the wind is here always constructive,
that it takes the sand from the dry upper beach, moves it inland and
builds it up into the dunes, but that it does not act as a waster. It
does build up, of course, but on the lee side it is also picking up the
sand grains and carrying them out over the sea, where at the slightest
lull they drop into the water, and are lost, as far as Sable Island is
concerned. That the wind is constantly shifting the sand in what-
ever direction the wind happens to blow, is forcibly brought to the
attention of anyone who ventures out of doors in a strong wind. If
the wind is blowing 20 miles an hour or more, it picks up so much sand
that it acts like a veritable sand-blast. In consequence all the lights
of glass in the windows become quickly dulled and soon so abraded
that they are no longer transparent but only translucent. Any trav-
eller feels it and is forced to shield his eyes, face, and hands from its
severe action.

1 Macdonald, S. D.: Trans. N. S. Inst. Nat. Sci. vi. part 2, 113 (1884).

2Gilpin, J. B.: Sable Island, 19 (1858).

* Ann. Rep. Geol. Surv. Can. n. s. xii. 213A (1899).

ST. JOHN: SABLE ISLAND. 21

As stated, this shifting of the sand often completely buries the veg-
etation of considerable areas. This is indicated by the layers of dark
peat usually less than an inch in thickness that may be seen in vert-
ical sections of the dunes such as are often exposed when the wind
opens a new gulch. In 1913, two of the Life Saving Stations, no. 2
and no. 4, were seriously threatened with being buried by the shift-
ing sand. Both were situated near and in the lee of the North Ridge,
the high and nearly continuous line of grass-covered dunes that skirts
the crest of the North Beach. In each case the wind had made a break
and opened a gulch in the North Ridge opposite the stations. Every
north wind enlarged the two gulches and piled the sand, tons of it,
around the two stations. The necessity cf moving these stations was
seriously being considered.

The old main station-house was again moved, two miles farther
east. When the sea later undermined the new foundation, it took
the old house too.

A chart of Sable Island by Capt. Joseph Darby was published in
1824 and revised in 1829. It is on the scale of 3 miles to the inch.
The island is shown as 25 J/£ miles long, and the South Beach is
shown with an almost continuous line of dunes. Wallace Lake ap-
pears 15 miles in length, and with the dunes extending 2 miles beyond
its western end.

Capt. Darby reports in Blunt' s Coast Pilot of 1832, " I have known
this island for 28 years, during which time the west end has decreased
in length 7 miles, although the outer breakers of the N. W. bar have
the same bearings from the west end of the Island as they formerly
had, demonstrating that the whole bank and bar are travelling east-
ward. "

Mr. Miller, in 1833, selected a site for a lighthouse, but in 1837, on
revisiting it, he found that it had undergone a complete change and
he was forced to recommend a temporary site and a lighthouse such
as could be easily removed.

A severe gale in 1842, completely demolished an old landmark, a
pyramidal hill near the west-end station said to be 100 feet in height,
Under this were found relics left by Maj. Elliott and men of the 43d
Regiment, wrecked here in 1761.

The Hon. Joseph Howe visited the island as Commissioner in 1851.
In his report is the startling statement that during 30 years, 11 miles
by actual measurement of the western end had been washed away.

22 PROCEEDINGS: BOSTON SOCIETY NATURAL HISTORY.

At this time, 1851, Capt. H. W. Bayfield1 made another survey of
Sable Island and the bank about it. He determined the position of
the East and West Ends as 59° 45' 59" W. long., and 60° 8' 57" W.
long. "The east extreme of the sand hills alone remains unchanged
for comparison with the observations of Admiral Ogle's officers [in
1828], and it is satisfactory to find, that there was not only no reason
to find fault with their determination, but that their latitude and al-
so the meridian distance from Halifax is the same as ours, within two
or three seconds of space. About two miles of the west end of the
Island have been washed away since they observed in 1828, and this
reduction of the Island, and consequent addition to the western bar
is reported to have been in operation at least since 1811, and seems
almost certain to continue. A comparison some years hence with the
present survey, can alone show precisely the amount of waste in any
given time, the correctness or otherwise of the reported shifting of the
bars, and of the opinion that the Island is insensibly becoming nar-
rower, &c. All agree that there has been no material change in the
east end of the Island within the memory of anyone acquainted with
it, * * *."

For the next twenty years the island enjoyed a period of compara-
tive stability and calm.

The winter of 1881-82, was marked by a succession of severe gales
in which great erosion took place. The winds wasted from the sur-
face of the dunes and the waves chopped off whole sections from the
end of the island. During one gale an area of 70 feet by one-quarter
mile vanished, as a month later in a few hours did 33 feet of the whole
breadth of the island. Early in February occurred another violent
gale, this time coincident with a high run of tides. The sea had worn
away the embankment of dunes to within forty feet of a bluff on
which stood the light-keeper's barn. All hands stood by. The cat-
tle were removed to the porch of the lighthouse. As the staff were
watching the force of the waves that were undermining the embank-
ment, suddenly they saw a depression in the margin of the cliff, and
the next instant an area equal to 48 feet wide and one-quarter mile
long vanished into the breakers on the north side. During the night
the forty feet in front of the barn vanished, and the next morning the
barn itself went crashing down into the waves.

1 Bayfield, Capt. H. W.: Append, to Journ. of House of Assembly, Prov.
of N. S. no. 24, 167-168 (1851).

ST. JOHN: SABLE ISLAND. 23

The sea was now within 12 feet of the West Lighthouse, a splendid
tower built in 1873 at a cost of $40,000. During two days of un-
usually quiet weather, a heavy ground-swell set in from the south-
east undermining the embankment till the lighthouse canted over
dangerously. Before the crash the apparatus was removed. Later it
was installed about a mile further east. The sea continued to ad-
vance and in 1888 the light was again removed, two miles farther east.

From this time, another period of comparative stability started.
It will be seen that such has been the regular course of events: dur-
ing a few years every storm causes violent destruction of a part of the
island, then follows a period of 10, 20, or 40 years of quiet. This is
probably to be explained by the protecting action of the sand washed
from the island and deposited on the surrounding bars during the
years of active erosion. The building-up of these bars makes a pro-
tecting ring upon which the waves break their fury before reaching
the island. When these bars have been worn down the waves can
again vigorously attack the island, and another period of destruction
ensues.

We have no more recent survey, but only the observations of those
stationed on the island, which tell us that it is now twenty miles long,
less than one mile broad, and its highest point, Rigging Hill, nearly
100 feet high.

CHANGES IN WALLACE LAKE.

The physical changes in Sable Island are also evidenced in Wallace
Lake, the great salt-water pond that occupies the center of the island
for over half its length.

Le Mercier gives us our first good account1 of this lake, in the year
1753. "Within these seven or eight Years, Providence hath opened
a Communication between the great Pond (fifteen Miles long) and
the Sea, which hath made a safe and large Harbour; but the Entrance
is barred so that large and sharp Vessels cannot get into it; but as
there is about 8 Feet of Water over the Bar at high Water there is
sufficient Passage (as we know by Experience) for Vessels of 30 Tuns
or more, if not built Sharp. "

On Des Barres' chart from the survey of 1766 and 1767 the lake is
shown very much as at present, but with a broad opening to the sea
through the dunes on the north side, with soundings in its center of

Boston Weekly News Letter, February 8 (1753).

24 PROCEEDINGS: BOSTON SOCIETY NATURAL HISTORY.

12 feet, and with a total length of 12 miles. Beyond its western end
the sand dunes stretched continuously for about 5 miles. The South
Beach was half a mile in width and had an almost continuous line of
dunes 50 feet in height. In 1808, Superintendent James Morris
writes of this channel, " It is completely shut, and it is difficult to
trace where it has been." In 1828, Superintendent Edward Hodg-
son refers to this obliterated channel, urging that it be reopened.
Some years afterward a terrific storm made a breach in the South
Beach, again opening the salt pond to the sea, and making it available
as a harbor for small vessels. In 1836, during a severe storm two
American fishermen ran into this protected harbor for shelter, but the
storm completely blocked up the channel, imprisoning the vessels,
whose weathered timbers now lie on the shores of Wallace Lake. One
of the gales in the winter of 1881 opened a gulch toward the eastern
end, which so drained the lake as to reduce it to 8 miles in length, and
rendered it so shallow as to be no longer useful in transporting ma-
terials from one Life Saving Station to another. This gulch is now
closed, and all the dunes beyond the western end of the lake have been
washed away, only a narrow beach now separating the lake at this
point from the sea. The waves have eaten off almost all of the South
Beach, all of the line of dunes is gone except a small remnant near the
eastern end, and the beach itself is so narrow now, that waves break
over it in heavy weather. It is no longer possible to maintain a Life
Saving Station on this South Beach. There is usually an opening,
now through one or another part of the narrow South Beach. The
wind has drifted sand across and filled up a strip, a mile wide in 1913,
dividing Wallace Lake into two unequal parts.

If we look back over this evidence and draw a contrast, it is a very
striking one, for from various surveys of 1766-67, 1768, 1770, and
1801, the island was about 30 miles long, 1 to 2 miles broad, with hills
150 to 200 feet high; whereas now it is but 20 miles long, hardly 1
mile broad, and the highest hill does not even attain 100 feet.

If the determination of the location of the island in the earlier sur-
veys was correct, the whole island has been moving slowly eastward.
The prevailing winds are westerly; the western end of the island is the
lower and has suffered all of the severe erosion by wind and storm;
and the eastern end is broader, with higher hills, and more drifting
unanchored sand. As the bare undercut western side of the cross-
ridges of dunes testifies the prevailing westerly winds are the dom-

ST. JOHN: SABLE ISLAND. 25

inant eroding factor on the surface of the island, so that it is quite
possible that the whole island is, under the compulsion of these west-
erly winds, slowly creeping eastward along the summit of the Sable
Island Bank.

In any case, the island is rapidly wasting away. Three hundred
years from now Sable Island, in all probability, will have vanished,
and then there will be no lighthouse to warn the mariners of those
times from the treacherous bars on the summit of the Sable Island
Bank. The study of its fauna and flora will then be ancient history,
only to be pursued by consulting the few specimens in the larger mus-
eums and herbaria.

THE ENDEMIC FRESH-WATER SPONGE.

An endemic species of fresh-water sponge, Heteromeyenia macouni
Mac Kay1 has been described from Sable Island. " This sponge was
collected in considerable abundance on the 18th of August, 1899, by
Professor John Macoun, Botanist of the Geological Survey of Canada,
in the fresh water pond found in the center of that great sand-shoal
in the Atlantic Ocean, well known as Sable Island, nearly one hun-
dred miles from Nova Scotia, the nearest part of the continent. It
was growing around the submerged portion of the slender stems of
Myriophyllum tenellum, Bigelow, in green, compact, lobular masses,
showing, where broken, numerous orange yellow gemmules.

"It appears to approach most nearly to the following fresh water
sponges described by Potts : Heteromeyenia ryderi v. baleni, found from
Florida to New Jersey, in its spiculation; and Heteromeyenia ryderi v.
walshii, from Gilder Pond, Massachusetts, in the fasciculation of its
skeleton spicules." Gilder Pond is at 1,800 feet altitude on the side
of Mt. Everett, Mount Washington, Berkshire County, Massachu-
setts.2

IPSWICH SPARROW.

The Ipswich Sparrow, first discovered in 1868 by C. J. Maynard
among the sand dunes at Ipswich, has constantly been a source of
interest to ornithologists. Repeated observations along the Atlan-
tic seacoast proved it to be a regular migrant starting south from Nova
Scotia in September, stopping at the bleak wind-swept areas of sand
dunes on its journey to Maine, Virginia or sometimes to Georgia.

*Mac Kay, A. H.: Fresh Water Sponge from Sable Island. Trans.
N. S. Inst. Sci. x. 319-322 (1900).

2Proc. Acad. Nat. Sci. Philadelphia, 231 (1887).

26 PROCEEDINGS: BOSTON SOCIETY NATURAL HISTORY.

In the early spring this shy, quiet bird follows the coast northward to
its nesting grounds. In 1884, Robert Ridgway1 suggested that a ser-
ies cf eggs from Sable Island, collected by J. P. Dodd in July, 1862,
might in reality be those of the Ipswich Sparrow.

Immediately Dr. C. Hart Merriam2 wrote to Rev. W. A. Des Brisay,
a resident missionary at Sable Island, and obtained a specimen of
the common "Gray Bird" of the Island. The fact that this proved to
be an Ipswich Sparrow added another link to the chain of accumula-
ting evidence . It remained for Dr. Jonathan D wight, Jr. , however, act-
ually to determine the breeding-haunts of this large pale-colored spar-
row. In 1894, Dr. Dwight visited Sable Island, remaining there from
the 28th of May till the 14th of June. During that time he found the
Ipswich Sparrow breeding there; he studied its song, its habits; he
collected sets of eggs and the cleverly hidden nests; and he learned
that some of these " Gray Birds" as they are called by the Life Savers
on Sable Island, are all the year residents, though most of them mi-
grate southward in the fall.

Persistent search on the mainland of Nova Scotia, on Cape Breton,
on Prince Edward Island, and among the sand hills of the Magdalen
Islands has failed to reveal or even hint that the Ipswich Sparrow ever
breeds anywhere except on Sable Island.

The bird is so small and so retiring that it has never attracted the
notice of the fishermen, hunters, and desperadoes, who for centuries,
just hew many no one can say, have frequented the island and brought
persecution or destruction to one or another kind of animal life. Al-
though neither man nor other living enemies disturb the bird, it does
seem seriously threatened by other factors.

Since all of the individuals of this species breed on Sable Island,
is there a definite maximum of breeding pairs that can be supported?
Of course this must be answered in the affirmative, and on a bleak,
sterile island of about fifteen square miles in area, this maximum num-
ber cannot be very large and it must now be smaller than in the past
when Sable Island was much larger in size. But what of the future,
when more and more of the island disappears in the waves, till finally
it ceases to exist? Will the Ipswich Sparrow seek a new breeding-
ground, or is it a species grown so conservative that it cannot make
the change, and will vanish with its island he me? The writer makes

iAuk, i. 292 (1884).
2 Auk, i. 390 (1884).

ST. JOHN: SABLE ISLAND. 27

no attempt to answer these questions that he has posed, but leaves
them for the reader, or to the observers of future generations.

NATIVE AND INTRODUCED ANIMALS.

Most of the early voyagers were drawn to Sable Island because of
the animal life, natural or introduced, that existed there. The Portu-
guese fishermen, about 1520, placed cattle on the island, where they
persisted and multiplied greatly.

Johannes de Laet, in 1633, mentions the cattle and swine, as well
as seals and black foxes.

The convicts abandoned by Marquis de la Roche in 1598, lived on
the cattle and clothed themselves in the skins of the seals.

John Rose of Boston, when shipwrecked on Sable Island in 1633,
saw, "about 800 cattle, small and great all red, and the largest he
ever saw, and many foxes whereof some perfect black." In the
years that followed many parties sailed from Boston to the island to
hunt the wild cattle, black fox, and the walrus.

The cattle must have been killed off in the mean time for Andrew
Le Mercier says, "When I took Possession of the Island [1738] there
was no four-footed creatures upon it, but a few foxes some red and
some black (some of which remain to this day) [1753]." From his
time on there are frequent mentions of wild horses or ponies on the
island, but these we consider elsewhere.

In 1801, with the outfit of the Humane Establishment, there were
introduced on the island 1 three-year old bull, 2 young cows in calf,
1 young boar, 2 young sows, 1 male and 1 female goat, 2 rams, 8
ewes, and 1 horse. Superintendent Morris, in 1802, referred to the
wild horses, " the only animals found on the island, if we except the
rats and mice, which at one time became very troublesome." Of
the animals introduced, it was found that the sheep did not thrive,
all dying except two pet lambs brought up in the house. Several
later attempts were made to maintain them on the island, but though
done with care, all were unsuccessful. " The animals seemed to thrive,
but one after another would be found dead, though quite fat. The
officers in charge of the admiralty survey reported that they found a
plant which was fatal to sheep."1 It has not been possible to deter-
mine who made this report, nor to what species it alludes.

The hogs ran wild and soon became quite fierce. They were all
destroyed in 1814 because of their ghoulish tastes when shipwrecks
occurred.

1 Patterson, George: Trans. Roy. Soc. Can. xii. § 2, 20 (1894).

28 PROCEEDINGS: BOSTON SOCIETY NATURAL HISTORY.

English rabbits were introduced, and they multiplied so that they
formed an abundant source of food. Then rats escaping from wrecked
vessels reached the island and became so numerous as to be a plague,
eating up so much of the stores that Superintendent Morris and his
men were seriously threatened with starvation. Then the rats by
killing the young, nearly annihilated the stock of rabbits. The gov-
ernment sent out a number of cats, which killed the rats, and then
finished the rabbits. The cats soon became very wild and so num-
erous as to be troublesome. Dogs were then imported, and they,
helped by men with shot-guns, finished the cats. Rabbits were again
introduced and throve, until they were discovered by a snowy owl.
The owls soon came in numbers to this happy hunting-ground, and
they finished the rabbits. In 1882, rabbits were again introduced,
and the story is almost parallel with the foregoing. They multiplied
and became such a nuisance that in 1889, seven cats were brought
from Halifax, and in 1890, thirty more. While the cats were winter-
ing and fattening on the rabbits, seven red foxes were brought from
the mainland and in a single season they made an end of all the rab-
bits and cats. These records show in a very graphic way what hap-
pens when an additional species of animal is introduced on a small
island, what a severe struggle for existence takes place between it and
the species already there.

SABLE ISLAND PONIES.

From nearly every recent voyager to Sable Island, we get accounts
of more or less fullness about the wild ponies, but we must turn to
J. Bernard Gilpin1 for the best record. He assumes that the pres-
ent gangs of Sable Island ponies are the descendants of a few horses
of ordinary New England stock landed there by the Rev. Andrew Le
Mercier about one hundred and fifty years before [1714]. This ap-
proximate date is earlier than Le Mercier's actual connection with
the island, for2 "on the 6th of March, 1738, he wrote to Governor
Armstrong [of Nova Scotia], inclosing a petition for a grant of it, on
behalf of himself and his associates. His design was stated as being
to stcck it with such domestic animals as might be useful in preserv-
ing the lives of mariners who might escape from shipwrecks; though,

1 Gilpin, J. Bernard : On Introduced Species of Nova Scotia. Trans N.
S. Inst. Nat. Sci. i. part 2. 60 (1864).

2 Patterson, George: Sable Island: Its History and Phenomena. Trans.
Roy. Soc. Can. xii. § 2. 11 (1894).

ST. JOHN: SABLE ISLAND. 29

from the suitableness of much of the soil for grazing and the oppor-
tunities afforded for seal hunting, they no doubt hoped to combine
profit with benevolence. The petition was approved, but the grant
does not seem to have actually passed. He was unwilling to pay
the penny an acre quit rent demanded by the instructions of his maj-
esty's government. * * * in the mean time Mr. M. sent a stock
of cattle to the island, preparatory to removing his family thither.

"In 1740 he again applies for a grant of the island, but represents
that as the land is, ' low, boggy and sandy soil, with large ponds or
settlings of water occasioned by the overflowing of the tides, he thinks
the penny an acre, too much for what cannot be improved. ' On the
16th August Governor Mascarene writes to the board of trade that
it would be to the advantage of the public to encourage the settle-
ment, by affording relief to the ship-wrecked, and profitable to the
proprietors by grazing, fishing, and killing seals for their oil skins.
Le Mercier does not even then seem to have received his grant, but
he continued to have cattle on the island for some years, and also
some settlers, and through his efforts many lives were saved. But
he complains that evil-disposed fishermen stole his cattle and goods,
and in 1744 we find him advertising in Boston papers a reward of £40
for the discovery of the depredators. "

In 1753, Le Mercier1 writes, "When I took Possession of the Island
there was no four-footed Creatures upon it, but a few foxes some red
and some black (some of which remain to this Day) now there are I
suppose about 90 Sheep, between 20 or 30 Horses including Colts,
Stallions and breeding Mares, about 30 or 4%0 Cows tame and Wild,
and 40 Hogs."

It is said that about this time Le Mercier, failing to find a pur-
chaser, abandoned his interests on Sable Island. Even though we
cannot substantiate this, we can demonstrate that horses were placed
on Sable Island by Thomas Hancock.

About 1760, according to Lieutenant-Governor Sir John Went-
worth,2 Thomas Hancock, a Boston merchant, desiring to relieve the
suffering of those that chanced to be shipwrecked on Sable Island,
fitted out a schooner and upon her embarked "Horses, Cows, Sheep,
Goats, Hogs and Animals likely to live on the Island. These were
landed there and generally answered very well. No great depre-
dations were made on them till the commencement of the American

Boston Weekly News-Letter, February 8 (1753).
2 Kept, on Canadian Archives, 86 (1895).

30 PROCEEDINGS: BOSTON SOCIETY NATURAL HISTORY.

War, during the course of which, privateersmen, and lawless persons
of every description frequently landed on the island, and by the close
of the War none of the Animals remained except a number of Horses.
These Horses have been the means of affording food to many unfor-
tunate persons who have since been thrown on the Island. * * *
Many of them have been wantonly shot by persons wintering on the
island for the purpose of wrecking. By such means as these, the
greater part of the horses have been destroyed, and unless some rem-
edy is found, this last hope of the unfortunate Mariner, will be entire-
ly cut off."

Thus it is certain that horses of New England stock were left on
Sable Island in 1753, or at least in 1760, and that Gilpin's assumption
that these were the parent stock of the present-day Sable Island ponies
is quite justified.

Gilpin describes them as he found them, "about four hundred in
number, divided into about six herds, or gangs (so called), each gang
headed by an old male, who was sufficiently conspicuous by his masses
of mane and tail. Each herd had its separate feeding ground, to
which the individuals composing it seemed to be equally attached, as
to their leader. On driving over the Island, and mixing all herds,
promiscuously, as we once did, by the next morning they had return-
ed to their separate feeding grounds, some of them travelling ten or
twelve miles during the night. On riding towards them the herd was
seen grazing at the distance of a mile, with several outlying parties.
The leader was observed repeatedly to drive these outlying mares
and young horses into the general herd, who all now began a general
retreat at a slow trot, with the exception of the old stallion, who faced
the approaching party, passing backwards and forwards, frequently
stopping and tossing back the mane from his eyes. The resemblance
to a convoy crowding all sail to leeward, and a frigate in stays await-
ing the enemy, was perfect. On pressing him, however, with our rid-
ing horses, he joined his herd now in a gallop, but keeping always in
the rear. His instinct taught him the unequal match with man, but
the air of leadership was unmistakable. They often fight among
themselves, one stallion visiting the herd of a second. I saw a horse
nearly disabled in one of these encounters. The young horses, be-
tween two and three years old, are driven out of the herd by the lead-
er. I watched one, hour after hour, driving a young grey colt with
the most furious bites, to a distance. The young horses live in small
bands on the outskirts of the herd, and sometimes an old or disabled

ST. JOHN: SABLE ISLAND. 31

mare, unable to keep up, drops behind; she is an object of the great-
est attraction to them, soon produces foals, and thus a nucleus of a
new herd is formed.

" I never saw one lying down to rest. They seem to sleep standing.
They persistingly refuse the shelter of a stable, or the society of man,
always moving from him. In the roughest weather escaping from the
stable they would put a mile or two between them and it, before they
stopped to graze; in this respect differing widely from the semi-wild
cattle, which besieged the barn doors with their lowing during the
winter. * * *

" To sum up then what we read from this narrow page in natural
history, opened to our view, and in which my sole assumption is
their origin from two or three individuals, we find that, left to them-
selves, following the laws of natural selection, their descendants in
one hundred and fifty years, have returned to the habits and manners
of the tarpany, or only stock of wild horses now existing in the world.
That, in regard to their form they differ in some respects from the
tarpany, though agreeing with them in size, hairy head, and thick
coat: but, although differing from these, they have wonderfully re-
produced forms, of whose existence we only know from the sculptures
of Nineveh and the friezes of the Parthenon, where we find the low
stature contrasted by the tall rider, the abundant tail and mane either
cropped or tied and plaited, to prevent its encumbering the rider, the
hairy jowl and horizontal head, and the short and cock-thrappled
neck, and in some figures the short croup and low tail. *

"As regards colour we find that the original stock carried with
them the germ of all colours known from ages, not only the bays and
browns which we consider the natural colours, but the more startling
varieties of pure white, and piebald, — piebalds known from ages, on
old China coin, upon the ancient Thracian hills, from whose back
Attila ravished worlds, and the mark of whose foot, it was his boast,
that neither nature nor man could efface. We find, too, the chest-
nuts prevailing with their extremities coloured like their bodies, their
tails and manes growing ever lighter, and a tendency to a dark streak
on the back and withers; lastly, the blue greys or mouse or tans, with
the same dark streak. Here, too, there is nothing new; the ancient
Assyrian dun, and the Phrygian cerulean breeds of the time of Ho-
mer, are all prototypes, though the latter is scarcely known among our
domestic breeds."

32 PROCEEDINGS: BOSTON SOCIETY NATURAL HISTORY.

At various times the government authorities concerned with Sable
Island have tried to improve the breed of the ponies. "A few un-
successful experiments1 have been tried, and the tame horses being let
loose, have been killed by the wild ones." Howe recommends, in
conclusion, the introduction of blooded stallions. This, too, has been
tried, without results. To one familiar with the history of the Sable
Island ponies, this failure is not surprising, for the newly introduced
horses are set loose and allowed to breed freely with the wild ponies.
No artificial selection is exercised, and as these new horses and their
offspring exist under the same living conditions that wrought the
horses from New England into Sable Island ponies, they, or rather
their offspring, become Sable Island ponies, and no "improvement in
the breed" is realized.

EARLY BOTANICAL RECORDS.

The botanical history of Sable Island is not very extensive but it
begins with a record of extraordinary interest.

Johannes de Laet in the third, which is a Latin edition of his work
mentions2 in his account of Sable Island, or Insula de Sable as he calls
it, "fruticeta multa, paucissimae arbores, humus fere nuda aut lev-
iter herbida;." When translated this is; "there are many thickets of
shrubs, very few trees, the soil is almost bare or lightly clothed with
vegetation. " To the present state of the island these statements are
all applicable, the sand dunes are bare, or lightly clothed with vege-
tation, there are thickets of shrubs formed mostly of Rosa mrqiniana
Mill., but also of Myrica carolinensis Mill., Ilex verticillata (L.) Gray,
Viburnum cassinoides L., and Rubus arcuans Fernald & St. John,
but at present there are no native trees of any sort. This clause
which is 'quoted and translated from de Laet does not occur in the first
and second editions of his work, which are in Dutch. It is added to
the end of the paragraph devoted to Sable Island in the third or Lat-
in edition, and it appears with similar wording in the fourth or French
edition. Johannes de Laet was born in Antwerp in 1585 and died in
Amsterdam in 1649. He had direct connections with the new world,
being a "patroon" of Rensselaerswyck (now Albany, N. Y.) where
his daughter and son-in-law had settled, and he was also a director of
the Dutch West India Company. This official connection would

1Howe, Joseph: Append, to Journ. of House of. Assembly Prov. N. S.
162 (1851).
2 Laet, Johannes de: Novus Orbis seu Descript. Indiae Occ. ed. 3, 37 (1633).

ST. JOHN: SABLE ISLAND. 33

give him access to the records of the Company and it is probably in
this way that de Laet gained his information about Sable Island.

He relates the early history of the island, the attempt to found a
colony there by Baron de Lery, of the stocking of the island with cat-
tle and pigs, the incident of Marquis de la Roche and the convicts
whom he abandoned on the island, describes the series of deeps and
shallows, that is the bars which surround the island, and the conse-
quent difficulty in making a landing, and he cautions, "nor in my
opinion is it reasonably worth while (neque sane, ut opinor, mere-
tur)." The absolute accuracy of these other statements about Sable
Island by de Laet confirms the value of his statement that at 1633,
the time of his writing, or a few years before, there were a very few
trees on the island. The botanists of his time were still classifying
plants on the basis of their habit, whether herbaceous, shrubby, or
arborescent, so there is no reason for thinking that he did not know
a tree from a shrub. Comparable regions on the mainland, such as
Cape Cod or Plum Island, Massachusetts, have even in many ex-
posed parts, clumps of trees in the hollows between the dunes. Of
course, as far back as 1633, Sable Island was much larger than it is
at present, and its sand hills much higher, so there would have been
more sheltered spots in which trees could grow. Taken all in all, every
bit of evidence seems to indicate that deLaet's statement can be accept-
ed at face value, that in 1633, or shortly before then, there were a
few native trees growing on Sable Island.

From Gov. John Winthrop's Journal1 we learn that, in 1633, a cer-
tain John Rose was wrecked in the Mary and Jane on Sable Island.
From the timbers of his wrecked vessel he managed to construct a
small pinnace in which he made his way to Acadia. There he was
detained a prisoner by the French, and forced to pilot them back to
Sable Island in their search for walrus and cattle. Finally, being
set free, Rose returned to Boston. He reported great numbers of
cattle and foxes and, " There is no wood upon it, but store of wild peas
and flags by the ponds, and grass."

In 1753, Andrew Le Mercier published2 the next notice of Sable
Island that contains any reference to its natural history. "It pro-
duces naturally near 20 sorts of Berries, out of which some People
suppose very good Liquors and Wines might be expressed — It looks

1 Winthrop, John: The History of New England from 1630 to 1649, edited
by James Savage, i. 162 (1825).

2 Boston Weekly News Letter, Feb. 8 (1753.)

34 PROCEEDINGS: BOSTON SOCIETY NATURAL HISTORY.

all green in Winter with the Juniper Bushes and red in Summer with
the large Strawberries and other wild Fruits which it bears. — It hath
abundance of wild or Beach Pease, which fatten the Cattle very well.

* * * There is neither Trees (but many Bushes) nor Stones.
— The Grass is tall, thick and hath a very sweet taste and nourish-
ing Property; there is some English Grass, but the other is more pro-
fitable, and there is enough to feed some thousand Heads of Cattle. "

All of the native plants mentioned by Le Mercier, juniper bushes,
strawberries (though they hardly color the ground red), and beach
pease, grow there to-day.

With reference to the quotation from de Laet given above, it will
be noticed that Le Mercier says, " There is neither Trees (but many
Bushes) nor Stones" and that John Rose reported "no wood upon
it" in 1633, so by the year 1753 any trees which had formerly existed
on Sable Island had, in all probability disappeared.

Joseph Frederick Wallet Des Barres made a survey of Sable Island
in 1766 and 1767 in compliance with orders from the British Admir-
alty. In his page and a half of " Remarks on the Isle of Sable, "* we
find, "The whole island is composed of fine white sand, much coarser
than any of the soundings about it, and intermixed with small trans-
parent stones. Its face is very broken, and hove up in little hills,
knobs and cliffs, wildly heaped together, within which are hollows and
ponds of fresh water, the skirts of which abound with cranberries the
whole year, and with blueberries &c. in their season, as also with
ducks, snipej, and other birds. This sandy island affords a great
plenty of beach grass, wild pease, and other herbages, for the support
of the horses, cows, hogs, &c. which are running wild upon it. It
grows no trees but abundance of wreck and drift wood may be picked
up along shore for fuel. "

Seth Coleman reported2 to Lieutenant-Governor Sir John Went-
worth on conditions at Sable Island as he found them June 24th,
1801, saying, "The soil in general is nearly the same excepting upon
the upland, which is principally of a nature to produce Beach Grass
intermixed with the wild Pea, and round the Edge of the Pond, there
is a finer kind of grass, but much of the same quality, and I discover-
ed some small spots of English Grass, and on the boarders of the Pond
Vegetables might be raised, if enclosed for Gardens, and

1 Des Barres, Joseph Frederick Wallet: The Isle of Sable, Survey'd in 1766
and 1767. Atlantic Neptune, i. 68 (1777).
2Rept. on Canadian Archives, 91 (1895).

ST. JOHN: SABLE ISLAND. 35

I have no doubt but Indian Corn might be produced, but not in large
quantities. "

In 1850, Joseph Howe visited Sable Island, and reported1, " I was
agreeably surprised to find it covered, for nearly its whole length of
five and twenty miles, with natural grass and wild peas, and sustain-
ing by its spontaneous production, five hundred head of wild horses,
and ten or twelve head of cattle.

" Cranberries of large size, and fine flavour, grow in abundance on
Sable Island. A few barrels of these are generally picked in the au-
tumn, but the cranberry, as a source of income, or a means of em-
ployment, has scarcely ever been thought of by our people."

An anonymous writer2 says, "It was in the year 1851, when employ-
ed as one of the assistants in the Admiralty Survey of the Gulf of St.
Lawrence, that orders were unexpectedly received to proceed to Sable
Island, and report upon the erection of a lighthouse. * * * The
amount and variety of vegetation on this gigantic sand bar is ex-
traordinary. Besides several kinds of grass, there are wild peas, and
other plants, affording subsistence to between 400 and 500 wild horses,
and an innumerable colony of rats and rabbits, as well as the domes-
tic cattle kept for the use of the establishment. * * * In the
neighbourhood of the chief residence, where white clover and other
grasses have been sown, so luxuriant is the yield that over 100 tons
of hay are made annually. There are several edible berries, the
strawberry in the richest profusion covering the ground upon which
we rode, with none to gather them. Cranberries abound/'

In 1858, J. B. Gilpin published3 a charming little book on Sable
Island in which he devotes one paragraph to its botanical features :

" A Botanist would give a scientific list of thirty or forty varieties
of shrubs and plants. Trees there are none, and the usual shrubs
are dwarf t to a few inches; a little ground juniper and low with- wood
would not afford a riding-cane. Tall coarse grasses cover the sur-
face of the ground, alternating with sandy barrens and snowy peaks
of blown sand. The wild rose, blue lily, and wild pea enamel the
valleys. Strawberries, blueberries and cranberries are in abundance.
They are measured by bucket-fulls; and as Autumn heats yellow the

1 Howe, Joseph: Appendix to Journ. of House of Assembly, Prov. of N. S.
no. 24, 161-164(1851).

2 The Leisure Hour, xxx. 432-433 (1881).

3 Gilpin, J. Bernard: Sable Island, Its Past History, Present Appearance,
Natural History etc. 18-19 (1858).

36 PROCEEDINGS: BOSTON SOCIETY NATURAL HISTORY.

luxuriant green, the tall, mallow, gay golden rods and wild China-
asters are swept by the heaving gales."

Joseph Charles Tache*, in 18851, published a book which in so far
as it refers to Sable Island is very little but a free translation of J. B.
Gilpin's "Sable Island." In a different form he reproduces Gil-
pin's paragraph on the botanical productions of the island. For
some reason he feels that Gilpin's estimate of the size of the flora was
not adequate, and he, Tache, says2, "On a dit qu'un botaniste pourrait
y observer trente a quarante espeees ou varietes; mais il est certain
qu'un catalogue complet des plantes de Pile et de ses rivages, qui com-
prendrait les mousses, les algues et les plantes d'occasion, aurait beau-
coup plus d'etendue que cela."

In 1890, an anonymous writer3 makes the first mention of the oc-
currence of blackberries on the island: "On the shores of the lake,
which extends for about eight miles, may be gathered in their season
the wild pea, wild roses, lilies, asters, strawberries, blackberries, and
cranberries. From these wild fruits a small revenue is derived by the
men of the life-saving station, who gather and ship them to Nova
Scotia."

The Rev. George Patterson in his article4 devotes one sentence to
the flowers and fruits. All of the species mentioned occur in Gilpin's
"Sable Island" with almost the identical wording, and Patterson re-
fers to him in a footnote on the following page.

The first naturalist to visit Sable Island was Dr. Jonathan Dwight,
Jr. From the 28th of May until the 14th of June, 1894, he was on
the island with the special object of ascertaining the breeding-home
and habits of the Ipswich Sparrow, which were at that time quite
unknown. This he accomplished very successfully.

Although it was quite early in the season, Dr. Dwight gave con-
siderable attention to the flora. "It5 was impossible to study sat-
isfactorily the flora of Sable Island, for at the time of my visit few
of the plants had more than just opened their earliest buds, and of

1 Tache, Joseph Charles: Les Sablons (L'lle de Sable) et L'lle Saint-Bar-
nabe, 1-354 (1885).
2 1 c. 29.

3 Anonymous: The Graveyard of the Atlantic. All the Year Round,
Ixvi. 517-522 (1890).

4 Patterson, Rev. George: Sable Island, Its History and Phenomena.
Trans. Roy. Soc. Can. xii. § 2. 5 (1894).

6 Dwight, Jonathan, Jr.: The Ipswich Sparrow. Mem. Nuttall Ornith.
Club, ii. 12-13 (1895).

ST. JOHN: SABLE ISLAND. 37

the species collected, many could not be positively identified even by
so able a botanist as Dr. N. L. Britton of Columbia College, who was
kind enough to make the attempt for me and to furnish the scientific
names. * * * The blueberry bushes were blossoming the second
week in June, many of the tiny sprigs trailing in the sand, partly cov-
ered by it, and the leaf buds of the rose bushes were little more than
half unfolded." This short quotation will give a hint of the con-
dition of the vegetation and Dr. Dwight's interest in it. He says1
"my specimens show that not less than forty species occur." "I*
make no pretense to a complete enumeration of the plants of Sable
Island, for reasons given, but those that I have mentioned are among
the most conspicuous and characteristic of its flora, which resembles
in many respects that of the adjacent mainland. "

He mentions several species that have been cultivated, and also
some that were presumably introduced, but to him appeared so thor-
oughly naturalized that they were hard to distinguish from the nat-
ive ones. To quote his own words3: "Timothy (Phleum pratense L.)
and Red-top Grass (Agrostis alba vulgaris With.), as well as Red Clo-
ver (Trifolium pratense L.), have been cultivated near the stations,
and White Clover (T. repens L.) is frequently met with, but man's
influence has been at work on the island for so many centuries that it
is almost impossible to draw the line between indigenous species, if
such there be, and those artificially introduced. * * * Before
my departure nearly the whole surface had acquired a visibly greener
tinge with here and there the ruddy glow of blossoming Sorrel (Rumex
Acetosella L.) while such weeds as the Beach Pea (Lathy rus maritimus
(L.)), Everlasting (Gnaphalium sp.?), and Meadow-rue (Thalictrum
sp.?) were becoming conspicuous."

It is quite true as Dr. Dwight says, that some of the introduced
species have made themselves thoroughly at home on the island, but
the writer in no case had any difficulty in deciding whether or not a
plant was a native. Trifolium repens is frequent on the island, par-
ticularly on the dry sands near the Life Saving Stations and along the
shores of the adjacent ponds where the cattle and the domesticated
ponies browse continually. It does not occur in the remoter parts of

1 Dwight, I. c. 13.

2 Dwight, I c. 14.

3 Dwight, I c. 12.

38 PROCEEDINGS: BOSTON SOCIETY NATURAL HISTORY.

the island, and does not seem to the writer to be a native plant. Ru-
mex Acetosella is obviously an introduced species.

Observations in 18511 confirm that the white clover is an introduced
species here: "In the neighbourhood of the chief residence, where white
clover and other grasses have been sown, so luxuriant is the yield that
over 100 tons of hay are made annually."

Why Dr. Dwight called Lathyrus maritimus and the Thalictrum
weeds, is not made clear, and the writer cannot imagine any explan-
ation of it. They are both characteristic of and generally distributed
on the dry sand dunes, which are surely a habitat on which native
plants would be expected.

Dr. Dwight mentions in his paper by generic or specific names
twenty-seven plants. The remaining thirteen are presumably im-
mature and at that time almost indeterminable specimens. The
plants are all in the Herbarium of the New York Botanical Garden,
but no list of them was kept.

Dwight's admirable scholarly report contains as well as his data
and remarks upon the Ipswich Sparrow, chapters on various features
of Sable Island: the History of Sable Island, its Physical Aspect, its
Climate, its Flora, its resident Mammals, and Birds.

The first botanist to visit Sable Island was the Botanist of the
Canadian Geological Survey, John Macoun, who landed on the island
July 20, 1899, ancl remained there for five weeks. In his Report for
that year2 he gives a general account of the island and some mention
of its flora. On the mooted question whether the island was ever
wooded he brings some evidence. "I am inclined3 to believe that
trees have never grown upon the island. On one occasion I saw roots
protruding from under a sand-hill over thirty feet high, and on dig-
ging them out found that they represented part of the remains of a
specimen of Juniperus Sabina procumbens (creeping juniper). It was
rooted in a layer of black soil and when taken out showed that it had
lain flat on the ground. Two of the roots, including the bark, meas-
ured 3% and 3% inches in diameter respectively, while the crown,
where the branches began to spread was over seventeen inches in cir-
cumference or nearly six inches in diameter. This growth and others
observed under sand-hills indicate long periods of vegetation without
encroachment of sand, so that when these shrubs lived, the lagoon was

1 The Leisure Hour, xxx. 432 (1881).

2 Ann. Rep. Can. Geol. Surv. xii. n. s. 212-219 A (1899).
1 Macoun, I c., 217 A.

ST. JOHN: SABLE ISLAND. 39

a quiet lake and the north side of the island was miles removed, as no
sand reached these localities for many years.

"Though there are no trees on the island and shrubs never attain
more than a foot in height, these, if sheltered from the sea air and
winter gales attain a considerable size. About fourteen years ago,
Mr. Boutellier planted a willow and an elm, both of which are now
about five feet high. Every summer they make a fine growth, but
during the winter are killed back to the point at which they are pro-
tected by an adjcining fence. Even in summer, as I learned from
my own observations, the leaves above the shelter of the fence are
small and badly formed, and after a strong gale or heavy fog the ten-
der ones become blackened or shrivelled at the edges, while those
that were protected were very large and well formed." The two
planted trees mentioned by John Macoun, were still living in 1913,
that is twenty-eight years after their planting. They had good stur-
dy trunks for about two feet, then bushed out into broom-like heads
of innumerable fine shoots that stretched up above the protecting
board fence. As John Macoun stated, each year all of these upright
shoots are killed back to the level of the top of the fence.

He makes the generalization that "all the shrubs are natives of
Newfoundland and Nova Scotia."1 This seems to be the case, with
the exception of Rubus arcuans which is not known from Newfound-
land, and at that time was not known to Professor Macoun.

PLANT HABITATS.

On an island consisting of a 20-mile stretch of sand dunes there can
be little diversity of plant habitats. Nevertheless, a variety of these
is found on Sable Island, and they may be distinguished as follows:

SEA BEACHES. — These are of pure white sand. This is true, ex-
cept for one bit of the South Beach, east of the Life Saving Station
No. 3, where magnetite, as iron sand, is so abundant as to alter the color.
The vegetation of this strip, however, is not perceptibly different from
that on other parts of the beach. Because of the encroachment of
the waves, the beach is very steep, the loose dry sand rising abruptly
to the base of a dune. At the very top of the beach in the soft, wind-
blown sand are a few clumps of Arenaria peploides L., var. robusta
Fernald, all of them with their young shoots gone, eaten off by the
gangs of wild ponies. Here and there are small single plants of Cakile
edentula (Bigel.) Hook.; otherwise the beach is bare of vegetation.

1 Macoun, L c. 218 A.

40 PROCEEDINGS: BOSTON SOCIETY NATURAL HISTORY.

SAND FLATS and SAND SPITS. — Not long ago the salt lake, Wal-
lace Lake, was sheltered by rows of dunes on both its north and its
south shores, but now from most of the south side the dunes have been
swept away, and between the southern shore of Wallace Lake and the
South Beach of the Island, there is nothing but a great sand flat over
which the waves break during all heavy storms. Sand spits and dry
bars quite similar in character extend out for some distance from
either end of the island. On all of these the Arenaria thrives, and
here also it is despoiled by the ponies, so much so that it is almost im-
possible to find fruiting specimens. The bareness of these stretches
is also broken by occasional mats of Limosella subulata Ives.

WALLACE LAKE and the BRACKISH PONDS. — Wallace Lake, though
often for short periods shut off from the sea, is quite as salt as is the
sea itself. In the lake is an abundant growth of Zoster a marina L.,
which is not met with elsewhere.

Especially at the eastern end of Wallace Lake, near Life Saving
Station No. 3, and near the Wireless Station are series of ponds reach-
ed by the salt water only during the heaviest fall and winter storms.
These ponds form a perfect series from the outer ones which are quite
brackish to the inner which are fresh. These brackish ponds have a
much more abundant vegetation than does Wallace Lake. In them
are great masses of Pond weeds, Potamogeton bupleuroides Fernald,
P. pectinatus L., and P. pusillus L., var. capitatus Benn., as well as
Ruppia maritima L., var. longipes Hagstrom. Around the borders
of these ponds will be found Carex Oederi Retz., var. pumila (Coss. &
Germain) Fernald, and great clumps of Spartina Michauxiana Hitchc.,
Aster novi-belgii L., var. litoreus Gray, and Scirpus acutus Muhl.

LAKE BEACH. — As the tides in Wallace Lake are very small or
none at all, and as the waves during storms cannot become large and
destructive, the Lake Beach has an abundant vegetation on its broad
expanse. Over great stretches it is covered with a smooth green
carpet made up of numerous species, among which are Juncus bu-
fonius L., var. halophilus Buchenau & Fernald, Chenopodium ru-
brum L., Spergularia leiosperma (Kindb.) F. Schmidt, Ranunculus
Cymbalaria Pursh, Potentilla pacifica Howell, Plantago major L., var.
intermedia (Gilibert) Dene., and P. decipiens Barneoud. Out of the
sward formed by these lowly plants grow the less numerous taller ones,
such as Rumex maritimus L., var. fueginus (Phil.) Duse"n, and Atrip-
lex patula L., var. hastata (L.) Gray.

ST. JOHN: SABLE ISLAND. 41

SAND DUNES. — If one may be allowed to generalize, the whole
island is only a series of undulating sand dunes. All of them are in a
continuous state of flux, but at any one time they can all be placed
into one of several categories. A strong sea breeze blowing at low
tide will pick up grain after grain of sand from the dry upper half of
the beach, and transfer it inland. A storm wind, while doing the
same thing, will often make a breach in the outer side of the most ex-
posed dune, whirl away the sand from the roots of the protecting
vegetation, and soon form a deep gully from which the sand is swirl-
ed inland without obstruction. Coming from either of these sources,
the sand is blown inland, then dumped in a quiet place. Whatever
happens to be beneath, pond, cranberry-bog, or Life Saving Station,
is buried by the new dune. These most recently formed dunes are to
be met with all over the island, and are, of course, without vegetation.
During the growing season the plants near by will tend to colonize
them and, unless the boisterous winds keep them in constant motion,
young plants will come up on them and tend to hold them in place.
The first to appear in such situations is the Beach Grass, Ammophila
breviligulata Fernald. Soon after, Lathyrus maritimus (L.) Bigel.
and Solidago sempervirens L. appear. If other storms do not inter-
fere by shifting the dune to still another place, these plants will spread,
and before long the dune will be fairly covered with vegetation and
anchored by roots. Other species will creep in and join these three
dominant ones, and soon the dune has on it many species such as Des-
champsia flexuosa (L.) Trin., Festuca rubra L., Smilacina stellata
(L.) Desf., Fragaria mrginiana Duchesne, var. terrae^novae (Rydb.)
Fernald & Wiegand, Rosa mrginiana Mill., Convolvulus sepium L.,
and Anaphalis margaritacea (L.) B. & H., var. subalpina Gray. On
the protected slopes of the more permanent dunes these species, es-
pecially the Rose, the Beach Pea, and the Morning Glory, form a
tangle that is waist-high and very difficult to penetrate.

EMPETRUM HEATHS. — These are in reality the ultimate stage in
the evolution of the sand dune. They are found in the middle of the
broadest part of the island, the place most protected from the erod-
ing elements. The dunes themselves are low and undulating, and
covering them is a low vegetation, composed especially of the trail-
ing branches of Empetrum nigrum L., Juniperus communis L., var.
megistocarpa Fernald & St. John, and Juniperus horizontalis Moench.
Together they form a green, springy carpet nearly a foot in thick-
ness. Mixed with the dominant species are of course others, such

42 PROCEEDINGS: BOSTON SOCIETY NATURAL HISTORY.

as Ammophila breviligulata Fernald, Lathyrus maritimus (L.) Bigel.,
Solidago sempervirens L., and Aster novi-belgii L., which are ubi-
quitous on all the drier parts of the island ; there are also such species
as Coptis trifolia (L.) Salisb., Pyrus arbutifolia (L.) L. f., var. atro-
purpurea (Britton) Robinson, Vaccinium pennsyhanicum Lam., Tri-
entalis borealis Raf., Mitchella repens L., Lonicera caerulea L., var.
calvescens Fernald & Wiegand, Linnaea borealis L., var. americana
(Forbes) Rehder, and Viburnum cassinoides L. These stretches here
called Empetrum Heaths are what J. Macoun in his article called the
" old land. " In this area he found Polypodium vulgare L., a surpris-
ing plant to find on a sand-dune island. Yet we learn from Warming1
that in northern Europe it occurs on the gray sand dunes, and Fern-
aid & Long found it in 1919 on sheltered wooded slopes of sand hills
at Provincetown on Cape Cod.

DUNE HOLLOWS — The shallow hollows between the dunes are
often dry and destitute of vegetation, but if the hollows are deep,
they approach the water table which is relatively high.

This water table has frequently been commented upon; for it is
well known that clear fresh water can be obtained by digging a few inches
or feet in any of the dune hollows. The level of this water table has,
of course, a relation to the height of the water in the fresh-water
ponds. But through all this is a fundamental factor which we can-
not yet explain. There is no evidence to show that there is any hard
or impervious stratum underlying Sable Island. If such a layer ex-
isted near the surface it would surely be known, and it would have
to be near the surface to govern the relative position of the water
table as observed. To the best of the writer's knowledge, no deep
borings have ever been made on the island. In discussing this ob-
scure feature of Sable Island, Sir J. W. Dawson2 says, " Pools of fresh
water, however, appear in places, which would seem to imply that
there is an impervious subsoil. This may, however, be caused by the
floating of rain water on water-soaked sand, an appearance which
may sometimes be observed on ordinary sand beaches, where, in con-
sequence of their resting on the surface of the sea-water, these pools
or springs sometimes rise and fall with the tide. I am not aware,
however, that this occurs at Sable Island." Any such tidal vari-
ation in the level of the fresh-water ponds would be very conspicuous,
but no such feature has ever been observed on the island. We must

1 Warming , Eugene: Oecology of Plants. English ed. 267 (1909).

2 Dawson, Sir John William: Acadian Geology, ed. 3, 37 (1878).

ST. JOHN: SABLE ISLAND. 43

leave this problem, then, having advanced no farther than the stat-
ing of the difficulty. These wet dune hollows support the most abun-
dant vegetation of any part of the island. The first plant to appear
and the quickest to spread is Vaccinium macrocarpon Ait., and it
forms a thick carpet in all of the wet hollows, though it is sometimes
obscured by taller-growing plants. Conspicuous among its compan-
ions in such places are Lycopodium inundatum L., Car ex canescens
L., var. disjuncta Fernald, Juncus balticus Willd., var. littoralis En-
gelm., J. articulatus L., var. obtusatus Engelm., Sisyrinchium gram-
ineum Curtis, Calopogon pulchellus (Sw.) R. Br., Hypericum mrgin-
icum L., Viola lanceolata L., Lysimachia terrestris (L.) BSP., Lycopus
uniflorus Michx., var. ovatus Fernald & St. John, and Agalinis pau-
percula (Gray) Britton, var. neoscotica (Greene) Pennell & St. John.

FRESH- WATER PONDS. — A mere stage beyond the wet dune hollows
are the fresh-water ponds which occupy all of the deepest dune hol-
lows. Some are only seasonal and disappear during any dry spell,
but a considerable number are permanently maintained by the rain
water.

Most of these ponds have a pure sand bottom, but a few of the deep-
er and more permanent have accumulated a layer of black muck over
the bottom. Around their shores they have the cranberries and most
of the other plants characteristic of the wet dune hollows, but they
have many additional species, as Eleocharis palustris (L.) R. & S.,
Juncus bulbosus L., Iris versicolor L., Rumex Britannica L., Polygo-
num hydropiperoides Michx., var. psilostachyum St. John, Tillaea
aquatica L., Potentilla monspeliensis L., var. norvegica (L.) Rydb., P.
palustris (L.) Scop., Lathyrus palustris L., vars. macranthus (T. G.
White) Fernald, and retusus Fernald & St. John, Epilobium molle
Torr., var. sabulonense Fernald, Centaurium umbellatum Gilib., Men-
yanthes trifoliata L., and Teucrium canadense L., var. littorale (Bick-
nell) Fernald.

In one area, that part of the "old land" bordering the fresh-water
ponds near the Marconi Station, conditions have been stable enough,
and the vegetation vigorous enough, to form a deposit of loamy soil.
It does not exceed a few acres in extent and nowhere is it more than
a foot and a half in thickness. It lies directly on the white sand that
forms the rest of the island. The vegetation on this loamy area is
more vigorous, but not different in character from that around the
borders of other fresh-water ponds. In the shallow borders of the
ponds is another series of species, not to be found in the wet dune hoi-

44 PROCEEDINGS: BOSTON SOCIETY NATURAL HISTORY.

lows. Among these are Typha latifolia L., Potamogeton polygonifo-
lius Pourret, P. epihydrus Raf., Eriocaulon septangulare With., Nym-
phozanthus mriegatus (Engelm.) Fernald, Myriophyllum tenellum
Bigel., Hippuris vulgaris L., and Lobelia Dortmanna L.

PHYTOGEOGRAPHY .

In studying the geographic affinities of the flora of Sable Island,
it was realized that this problem was but a small part of the much
larger one of the relations and sources of the floras of Newfoundland,
Prince Edward Island, and adjacent regions. It was, in fact, in the
hope of throwing some light on this larger question that the trip to
Sable Island was planned. And now, in this discussion of the flora,
the general scheme used by Prof. M. L. Fernald in his analysis of the
geographic relationships of the flora of Newfoundland1, has been fol-
lowed as far as it is applicable to this smaller flora.

There is an element of definitely adventive plants, 51 in number.
These are in most cases confined to the immediate neighborhood of
the Life Saving Stations or the lighthouses, in the cultivated fields,
along the paths, or near the stables. A few species such as Anthoxan-
thum odoratum L., Rumex crispus L., Rumex Acetosella L., Cerastium
wilgatum L., Trifolium repens L., and Cirsium arvense (L.) Scop,
have spread to the shores of the fresh-water ponds or to the dry dunes,
and made themselves very much at home. In every case, however,
they can be demonstrated as a foreign element in the flora. As a
result of the very extensive tree planting on the island there are a
few species or individual trees that have survived and must be con-
sidered now as a part of the flora. These planted species total 15 in
number. Together with the 51 adventives they give us a total of 66
plants, which will be excluded from the further discussion of the phy-
togeography of the island.

The native flora consists of 147 species, varieties, and forms. They
fall into the primary classes:

Class I . Boreal types.

Class II. Southwestern types.

Class III. Endemic plants or species unknown on the American contin-
ent.

Class I. Boreal Types. — This class includes all of the plants that
occur to the north of Newfoundland in Labrador proper, south-west-
ern Greenland, or the Arctic regions. A few of the species could

i Fernald, M. L.: Rhodora, xiii. 136 (1911).

ST. JOHN: SABLE ISLAND. 45

be classed as Arctic, but the great majority are Hudsonian or Canad-
ian types, and it does not, in considering this region, seem worth
while to try to distinguish between them. The boreal types total
45 plants, = 30 per cent, of the Sable Island flora.

A few examples will indicate the make-up of this class: Elymus
arenarius L., var. wllosus E. Mey., Spiranthes Romanzoffiana Cham.,
Arenaria lateriflora L., var. typica (Regel) St. John, Drosera rotundi-
folia L., Fragaria virginiana Duchesne, var. terrae^novae (Rydb.)
Fernald & Wiegand, Potentilla palustris (L.) Scop., var. parvifolia
(Raf.) Fernald & Long, P. tridentata Ait., Empetrum nigrum L., Hip-
puris vulgaris L., Ligusticum scothicum L., Coelopleurum lucidum (L.)
Fernald, Cornus canadensis L., Menyanthes trifoliata L., Euphrasia
purpurea Reeks, var. Randii (Robinson) Fernald & Wiegand, Plan-
tago decipiens Barneoud, Linnaea borealis L., var. americana (Forbes)
Rehder, Anaphalis margaritacea (L.) B. & H., var. subalpina Gray,
and Senecio Pseudo-Arnica Less.

Class II.1 Southwestern Types. — This class consists of plants found
chiefly in regions to the southwest of Newfoundland. It totals 83
plants = 55 per cent, of the flora. It falls into three subdivisions.

Subclass A. Canadian and Alleghanian plants mostly common to
Newfoundland, Nova Scotia, New Brunswick and coastal New Eng-
land, but unknown in eastern Saguenay County, Quebec, or Labrador.
These total 36 plants = 24 per cent, of the flora.

As typical of this subclass may be listed: Polypodium vulgare L.,
Osmunda cinnamomea L., Scirpus acutus Muhl., Spartina Michaux-
iana Hitchc., Habenaria bracteata (Willd.) R. Br. (does not reach
Newfoundland), Rubus hispidus Michx., Hypericum mrginicum L.,
Galium Claytoni Michx., Mitchella repens L. (does not reach New-
foundland), and Viburnum cassinoides L.

Subclass B. Species having affinities with the Southern Coastal
Plain, usually belonging to genera or having nearly related species

1 Class II of Prof. Fernald's discussion (1. c. p. 138), the Western types, is
represented on Sable Island by only two plants, Polygonum hydropiperoides
Michx., Var. psilostachyum St. John, occurring on Sable Island and along the
Columbia River in Washington, and Lycopus uniflorus Michx., var. ovatus
Fernald & St. John, occurring on Sable Island, at Canso, Nova Scotia, and at
Sullivan's Gulch, Portland, Oregon. If Sable Island contained a greater di-
versity of soils it is probable that more of these western plants would occur
there. Many of them are calcicoles, so it is not surprising that they are not
to be found on Sable Island, which presents nothing but sand, wet or dry.

46 PROCEEDINGS: BOSTON SOCIETY NATURAL HISTORY.

characteristic of the southern Coastal Plain, but themselves extend-
ing beyond its geological limits, following the sandy or acid-peaty
soils northward and inland. These total 24 species =16 per cent, of
the flora.

To typify this subclass we can cite: Panicum huachucae Ashe,
Eriocaulon septangulare With., Juncus canadensis J. Gay, Sisyrin-
chium gramineum Curtis, Calopogon pulchellus (Sw.) R. Br., Pyrus
arbutifolia (L.) L. f., var. atropurpurea (Britton) Robinson, Ilex verti-
cillata (L.) Gray, Myriophyllum tenellum Bigel., Utricularia cornuta
Michx., Lobelia Dortmanna L.

Subclass C. Southern Coastal Plain species ranging from Texas,
Florida, the Carolinas, or New Jersey northward along the sandy
coastal strip, Long Island, Nantucket, Cape Cod, to Sable Island, to
Newfoundland, or Prince Edward Island, uncommon or unknown in-
land in continental eastern Canada. These total 23 plants = 15
per cent, of the flora. It is noteworthy that the endemic fresh-water
sponge, Heteromeyenia macouni Mac Kay, has as its nearest relatives
H. ryderi, var. baleni, ranging from Florida to New Jersey, and H.
ryderi, var. walshii from Gilder Pond, Mount Washington, Massa-
chusetts.

This subclass contains Ammophila breviligulata Fernald, Agropyron
repens (L.) Beauv., var. pilosum Scribn., Carex silicea Olney, Carex
hormathodes Fernald, Juncus articulatus L., var. obtusatus Engelm.,
Habenaria lacera (Michx.) R. Br., Myrica carolinensis Mill., Tillaea
aquatica L., Rosa virginiana Mill., Viola primulifolia L., Centuncu-
lus minimus L., Teucrium canadense L., var. littorale (Bicknell) Fer-
nald, Limosella subulata Ives, and Plantago major L., var. intermedia
(Gilibert) Dene.

Class III. Endemic Plants or Species unknown on the American
Continent. — This includes 10 plants = 7 per cent, of the flora.

Subclass A. Endemic Plants. — This includes 6 plants = 4 per
cent, of the flora. It is notable that in no case were the characters
of the endemic plants strong enough to be considered specific; in every
case they had to be treated as of formal or varietal rank. The six
endemic plants are: Juncus pelocarpus Mey., var. sabulonensis St.
John, Calopogon pulchellus (Sw.) R. Br., f. latifolius St. John, Lathy-
rus palustris L., var. retusus Fernald & St. John, Epilobium molle Torr.,
var. sabulonense Fernald, Bartonia iodandra Robinson, var. sabul-
onensis Fernald, Hieracium scabrum Michx., var. leucocaule Fernald
& St. John.

ST. JOHN: SABLE ISLAND. 47

Subclass B. Species characteristic of western Europe, not known
in Iceland, Greenland, or Labrador, but occurring on Sable Island,
and usually on St. Pierre, Miquelon, and the Avalon Peninsula of
Newfoundland. This includes 4 plants = 3 per cent, of the flora.
They are: Potamogeton polygonifolius Pourret, Juncus bulbosus L.,
Polygonum Rail Bab., and Centaurium umbellatum Gilib.

The 8 plants which are not included in any of these classes are either
members of critical groups now under revision, or recently described
species whose ranges are as yet imperfectly known.

FORESTRY EXPERIMENTS.

Since 1801, the government of Nova Scotia, and later that of Can-
ada have maintained one or more Life Saving Stations on Sable Island.
The buildings of these establishments have been constantly threat-
ened with destruction, either by burial in the drifting sand, or by be-
ing engulfed in the waves of a severe storm that might wash away the
very site on which the buildings stand. Under these circumstances
it is not strange that an attempt was made to hold in place the drift-
ing sand hills that compose the island.

In 1900, Sir Louis Da vies, Minister of Marine and Fisheries, re-
quested William Saunders, Director of the Dominion Experimental
Farms, " to consider the subject of a somewhat extensive experiment
in tree planting on Sable Island." That same year Dr. Saunders1
in company with Lieut.-Col. F. F. Gourdeau visited the seacoast of
Brittany, " to see the results of the planting of pine forests there on
the drifting sands on the ocean shores, to gain information as to the
methods adopted in planting and the varieties of trees which have
been successfully grown. * * *

" On returning to Ottawa a list of such sorts as were likely to be
suitable was prepared with quantities desired. The trees and shrubs
chosen included a large number of those which have succeeded well
in drifting sands in France to which were added a number of other
varieties which from Canadian experience were likely to prove use-
ful for that purpose. Small lots of many other species were added to
lend interest to the collection and to test their hardiness and adapt-
ability to the climate of Sable Island. This list included in all

1 Saunders, Wm.: Experiments in Tree Planting on Sable Island, Do-
minion Experimental Farms, Report, 63-77 (1901).

48 PROCEEDINGS: BOSTON SOCIETY NATURAL HISTORY.

68,755 evergreens of 25 varieties, and 12,590 deciduous sorts of 79 va-
rieties,"— as well as 50 pounds of the seed of the Maritime Pine,
Pinus maritima. This large shipment reached Sable Island the mid-
dle of May, 1901, and under the direction of Lieut.-Col. Gourdeau
and Mr. Saunders, planting was started at once. The crates were un-
packed and the young trees, almost all of which arrived in good con-
dition, were placed in trenches in the moist sand with their roots well
covered. The work of planting the thousands of trees was pushed
forward vigorously and completed on the 17th of June. Of the trees
about 300 were planted near the East End Lighthouse, about 1000
at No. 2 Life Saving Station, about 5,000 at No. 3 L. S. S., about
3,000 at No. 4 L. S. S., and the remainder at Gourdeau Park, a section
near the Wireless Station formed of low rolling dunes covered with
a thick mat of trailing Juniperus and Empetrum. This area is one
of those called Empetrum Heaths, where a thin layer of dark humus
has been formed above the white sand.

An accurate statement of the nature and conditions of the soil
and the climate of Sable Island where these young trees were
planted is given by Mr. Saunders.1

"I brought with me a sample of the almost pure sand forming the
soil on the top of the sandy bluff on which the first plantation was
made in which the sand binding grass was growing, also two samples
of the black peaty layer which covers the sand to a depth of 3 to 4
inches over a large portion of the central part of the island, probably
to the extent of 1,800 to 2,000 acres. One of these was taken from
the large area chosen for the plantation to be known as Gourdeau Park,
and the other was from similar soil some miles further east. I also
brought a sample of similar material picked up on the beach on the
south shore where it was being washed by the sea. A fifth sample
consisted of a bunch of the sand-binding grass Ammophila arenaria
[= A. breviligulata Fernald]. These were submitted to the Chemist
of the Experimental Farms, Mr. F. T. Shutt, for analysis, who re-
ports on them as follows:

'Analysis and Report on Samples From Sable Island.
(By Frank T. Shutt, Chemist, Dominion Experimental Farms.

'No. 1. Sample of the sand from field on top of the bluff, northeast of the
look-out, where first forest clump was planted. It contains roots of grass
Ammophila arenaria [A. breviligulata]. Weight of sand 2 pounds 13 ounces,
containing % ounces of grass roots.

1 Saunders, Wm., Z. c.

ST. JOHN: SABLE ISLAND. 49

'Analysis of this sand after separation of the greater part of the fibre showed
.0018 per cent of nitrogen.

'Digestion of this sand with hydrochloric acid (sp. gr. 1.115) at the temper-
ature of boiling water for 5 hours, showed that .412 per cent had passed into
solution.

'The examination of this acid solution gave the following data:

'Oxide of iron and alumina 328

'Lime 062

'Phosphoric acid 012

'Potash: — By the spectroscope, traces of potash were plainly discernable.
With the usual reagent (platinic chloride) only a very faint precipitation was
obtained when working on an acid solution from 10 grams of the sand.

'No. 2. Sample of peaty soil from surface underlaid by sand in central part
of island 1^ miles east of residence of Superintendent where a large block of
trees has been planted, locality known as Gourdeau Park, layer 3 to 4 inches
thick.

'Analysis of (air-dried) peaty soil: —

p.c.

'Moisture 4. 87

'Organic matter 22. 22

'Mineral matter practically sand 72 . 91

100

'Nitrogen in organic matter 878

'No. 3. Representative sample of peaty soil covering a large area some dis-
tance east of where No. 2 was taken, from 3 to 4 inches deep, and underlaid
by sand. Weight soil, air-dried, 3 pounds 12^ ounces, containing 5^ ounces
fibre.

'Analysis of (air-dried) peaty soil: —

p. c.

'Moisture 1.48

'Organic matter 8 . 63

'Mineral matter practically sand 89. 89

100

'Nitrogen in organic matter . 271

'No. 4. Sample from a large lump of peaty soil found on the beach on the
south shore, being washed by the sea. It contains a considerable amount of
semi-decayed eel grass Zostera maritima. Weight of soil, air-dried, 1 pound
5 ounces, containing 2% ounces fibre, principally eel grass.
'Analysis of (air-dried) peaty soil : —

p. c.

'Moisture 3.00

'Organic matter 9. 50

'Mineral matter practically sand 87. 50

100

50 PROCEEDINGS: BOSTON SOCIETY NATURAL HISTORY.

'Nitrogen in organic matter 267

'The above three samples are similar in character, and no doubt also as to
origin. They may be considered as semi-decayed vegetable matter (largely
fibrous) and sand, and practically the only point of difference between them
lies in the varying proportions of these two constituents. In the air-dried
condition the sand can be very easily separated from the organic matter by
shaking and sifting, showing that there is no intimate incorporation of these
constituents as in the case of true soils.

'The plant food they contain other than nitrogen is present in very small
amounts, and we must suppose exists in such a condition that it is only slowly
set free for plant use.

'No. 5. Analysis of the (air-dried) grass or hay Ammophila arenaria [A.
breviligulata] from Sable Island, chiefly barren stems:

p. c.

'Moisture 12. 42

'Protein 13.81

'Fat 81

'Fibre 41.00

'Carbo-hydrates 26. 71

'Ash 5.25

100

'In protein or albuminoids this grass makes a very good showing, being quite
equal in respect to these important nutrients to many of our highly esteemed
cultivated grasses.

'The percentage of fibre is above the average, and this together with the
somewhat high protein, necessarily makes the carbo-hydrates (starch, sugar,
&c.) much lower than usual. This hay contains 5.25 per cent ash or mineral
matter, which on further examination is found to include 1.37 per cent of
sand. This sand had remained attached to the grass in spite of all care be-
ing taken to separate it.

'The indications are that though probably somewhat less digestible than the
best hays made from grass cut before seeding, this Sable Island grass has a
distinct and even moderately high feeding value due to its comparatively
speaking large protein content.'

" The results obtained by Mr. Shutt are very interesting and valu-
able. The ponies, of which there are four bands numbering about
120 in all running wild on the island, feed almost entirely on this grass
which looks tough and hard and does not impress one as likely to be
very nutritious. The ponies, however, do well on it, and even the
domestic cattle use it considerably, although they are said to pre-
fer timothy and clover. The fact that this grass has a decided nu-
tritive character is now demonstrated.

ST. JOHN: SABLE ISLAND. 51

"Arrangements for the use of artificial fertilizers.

" Realizing at the outset that it was probable that the soil of some
of the sites which might be chosen for tree planting On the island
would be deficient in the elements of fertility needed for the healthy
growth of trees, a sufficient quantity of artificial fertilizers was taken
to Sable Island with the trees. These included nitrate of soda, mur-
iate of potash, superphosphate of lime with a few barrels of quick
lime. Instructions were left with the Superintendent as to the use of
these after the trees were planted, and the proportions in which they
should be mixed. That after mixing they should be diluted with an
equal bulk of sand and scattered in small proportion over the ground
once a month for three months, leaving a small portion of each plan-
tation untreated for comparison. This would probably give the trees
at the start sufficient plant food for healthy growth.

"A natural source of plant food.

"There is one source of plant food on Sable Island which should
not be overlooked. Sea birds are most abundant there. After trav-
elling over the greater part of the island and seeing the immense
number of terns everywhere, from a rough computation of the num-
ber per acre and the acreage of the island we estimated that these
birds alone did not fall far short of a million on the island. They feed
on small fish, and they are so incessantly active that they consume
large quantities and their droppings are seen on every hand. This
perennial source of fertility must have its effect. Like the guano on
the sea-girt islands in parts of South America this material is very
rich in plant food, which is in readily soluble forms and the quantity
deposited every year would probably be sufficient to supply a con-
siderable part of the small proportion of these elements needed for
healthy tree growth. Traces only of these useful elements are found
in the clear, pure sand which covers so large a part of the surface of
the island, probably for the reason that this fertilizing material if
not promptly taken up by plant roots is so soluble that it is soon
washed through the porous sand by frequent rains and its accumula-
tion is thus prevented.

"Conditions of climate — strong winds.

"The climate is a very singular one, and one of the chief difficulties
in the way of rapid success in tree planting is the force and constancy

52 PROCEEDINGS: BOSTON SOCIETY NATURAL HISTORY.

of the. winds, and the frequency of the gales. From the meteorolog-
ical tables here given, prepared by Mr. W. T. Ellis from material
kindly furnished by Mr. R. F. Stupart, Director of the Meteorological
Service of Canada, covering nearly four years, it appears that the
average hourly velocity of the wind during the whole of that period
has been more than 18 miles, while the gales have averaged over 10
each month when the winds have ranged mostly from 40 to 65 miles
an hour. A study of the temperatures will show that there are no
extremes of heat or cold on the island; that the highest temperature
during the past four years has been 78, and the lowest point reached
by the thermometer during the same period was 5 above zero.

Months.

Maximum.

Minimum.

Total Preci-
pitation.

Average
hourly veloci-
ty of wind.

Maximum
velocity.

Number of
gales.

1

1

1898.
January

0

48.5

0

6.0

Inches.
5.65

Miles.
21.5

48

Days.

18

Days.
15

Days.
2

February

43.0

17.0

1.54

18.7

64

14

20

2

March

46.5

23.5

3.20

17.8

46

17

20

9

April

53.0

27.0

4.90

19.8

38

18

16

10

May

60.5

33.0

2.90

15.7

41

7

24

8

June

66.0

39.0

3.12

15.9

39

9

20

14

July
August
September
October

75.0
77.0
73.5
61.5

45.5
58.0
46.0
39.5

4.55
4.44
5.89
3.85

11.8
12.0
16.6
18.6

25
27
42
36

1
2
9
13

17
18
19
20

10
17

7
6

November

63.0

30.0

8.68

19.6

49

18

16

9

December

52.0

18.0

6.64

23.7

59

20

16

6

Averages

59.95

31.87

4.61

17.6

42.8

12

18

8

1899.
January

48 5

7 5

2.17

24.4

53

21

19

3

February

39 0

9 0

2 78

26.0

65

19

17

g

March

47 5

17 0

4 96

22.6

46

20

22

13

April

48 0

29 0

1 65

19.5

56

13

22

12

May

59 0

28 0

2 62

18.2

39

10

21

7

June

64 5

41 0

4 97

12 8

27

3

16

11

July

71 0

52 0

2 30

14 9

31

5

22

21

August

74 5

56 0

3 76

12 6

32

2

20

2

September

72.0

48.0

3.52

16.0

40

7

20

8

October

69.0

44.0

5.71

16.8

46

9

22

6

November

59.5

32.0

2.66

20.0

56

12

18

8

December

53 0

24 0

4 31

18 8

49

18

17

6

Averages

58.79

32.29

3.45

18.5

45

12

19

8

ST. JOHN: SABLE ISLAND.

53

Months.

Maximum.

Minimum.

Total Preci-
pitation.

Average
hourly veloci-
ty of wind.

Maximum
velocity.

Number of
gales.

1

1

1900.

k

January

o
52.5

0

17.0

Inches.
5.76

Miles.
23.7

56

Days.
20

Days.
14

Days.
5

February . . .

52.0

7.0

3.59

26.5

56

20

17

3

March

48.5

15.5

6.15

22.2

52

19

16

8

April

52.5

32.5

5.55

19.4

46

16

14

6

May

57.8

34.0

3.04

16.2

37

6

19

7

June

69.0

40.0

2.84

14.2

27

6

21

14

July

75.0

49.0

2.25

13.4

32

3

23

18

August

73.0

51.0

6.16

13.6

40

4

17

6

September

70.0

47.0

5.66

16.2

49

7

17

8

October

66.0

37.0

2.31

17.4

51

11

21

5

November ....

60.5

27.0

2.94

22.7

46

24

11

8

December

49.0

20.0

2.94

21.8

52

15

14

3

Averages

60.48

31.41

4.09

18.9

45

12

17

7

1901.
January .

47.0

5.0

3.24

22.7

58

14

19

9

February . . .

45.5

19.0

3.21

21.9

45

9

12

4

March

47.0

19.0

4.04

20.2

56

12

23

11

April

54.0

34.0

2.36

19.4

60

4

24

17

May

57.0

34.0

4 97

13.3

34

1

18

10

June

63.0

44.0

2.38

14.8

36

1

24

15

July

77.0

53.0

2.90

12.9

36

0

28

19

August
September
October

78.0
76.5
68.0

60.0
48.0
41.0

3.36
1.65
4.52

11.3
17.4
18.4

34
42

48

1
5
4

26
26
25

13

7
9

November

57.5

30.0

2.10

18.2

62

7

23

o

December

Averages

60.95

35.18

3.17

17.3

46

5

22

10

"The plantations started very well, all of the young trees taking
root and the seed of the Maritime Pine germinated and came up 'as
thick as it can stand, and * * * very fine and strong'."

This brief statement of the planting of the trees on Sable Island
should impress the reader with the great care with which the plan
was devised and the diligence with which the laborious planting was
executed.

The Superintendent of Sable Island, R. J. Bouteillier, took a keen
interest in the whole project and did all that a man could to insure
its success. From his reports we learn that the trees began almost
immediately to succumb to the severity of the climate. In his first

54 PROCEEDINGS: BOSTON SOCIETY NATURAL HISTORY.

report he had to mention a discouraging loss. " I may say that al-
most everything planted seems to have taken root, those you first
put in are budding freely, although I regret to say that on Friday last
we had a moderate gale which lasted about 24 hours when the wind
at times exceeded 40 miles an hour. I find that on the trees with soft
leaves which had just opened, they were burned off as if from frost.
The pines and spruces were not affected as far as could be observed."
In the fall of 1901, November 5th, Supt. Bouteillier wrote, "With
regard to the condition of the trees the latter part of the summer was
very dry, so much so that our vegetables are less than a half crop, so
that you can see it must have been trying for the trees.

"Rainfall—

June, 2.38 inches; spread well over the whole month; fogs as well.
July, 2.90 inches; spread well over the whole month; fair; warmer.
August 1 to 13, 3.36 inches; no fogs; very warm.
September 8 to 30, 1.65 inches; no fogs; very warm; dry gales.
October 3 to 24, 3.60 inches; no fogs; warm; some high winds.

"You will see from this that the trying time was from August 13
to October 3, with only 1.65 of rain, no fogs and very warm weather
for Sable Island. The thermometer averaged high all summer.

"This drought killed most of the weaklings, and the high winds
burned the leaves off the deciduous trees between September 21 and
26, during which time it blew a continuous gale from S. W. around to
north. After the gale subsided, the leaves were as though a fire had
run close to the trees and scorched them. It was not cold, and we
have had no frost yet.

"Many of these trees were very promising, and some of them are
Ludding again since we have had rains. * * *

" Now, as I think I have shown you the worst side, I will show the
other. All the evergreens looked dull during the drought, but after
we had a few rains they improved wonderfully. All the pines, ex-
cept the white pine P. strobus are looking splendidly and have made
growth. The plants from the pine seed also grew well, but lately I
noticed that many were turning a bluish cast. Some spruces sur-
vive, but few look promising. Arbor-vitae suffered much from
drought, but there are many promising specimens in various locali-
ties.

''This general statement of the conditions of the trees applies to
all planted in the various localities, but I think Gourdeau Park, 1}^

ST. JOHN: SABLE ISLAND. 55

miles east of main station, is most promising, and next is 4th station
plot. In all plots planted the weeds and grass has grown freely, and
I am satisfied now that this is best for the trees; it gives shelter. If
the ground had been kept clear the drifting sand would abrade the
bark, and it is very noticeable that trees do best where sheltered by
grass or wild plants. In 'Gourdeau Park' there is shelter owing to
the conformation of the ground, and the slopes have different expos-
ures. I find where the slopes are exposed to the south-west and west
winds (our prevailing winds) the trees are least promising. "

In the following year, Dr. Saunders in an additional report1 gave
the latest news concerning the plantation on Sable Island. The first
letter received in 1902 was written May 26. In this Mr. Bouteillier
says, "I will give you the latest news of the trees. Our winter has
been very mild; not much snow and not much frost. When a cold
snap occurred it was followed by enough mild weather to take all the
frost cut of the ground. March was very mild; April was cold and
windy, and that has continued up to a week ago. Many pines that
seemed to stand the winter went red in March and April, and many
that turned color have recovered and are putting out new buds.
Survivors of Austrian, Mountain and Maritime pines are the most
promising, and those that are not doing well are the small specimens ;
nearly all the larger ones planted are killed. A few spruces of all
kinds survive, but they are not promising. Of the arbor vitae only
a few are living. Juniper of both kinds nearly all dead; perhaps four
or five survivors.

"Of the Maritime pines raised from the seed you brought, these
were killed wherever they were scattered on the bare ground, but
where they came up among the grass they are growing finely in this
shelter, and there are thousands now green and putting out new buds.
When sowing these I put them in thick, and after they came up I
thought that in spots they were too thick; but this was their salvation,
as the winds subsequently killed those on the outside, while those in
the middle of these bunches were protected and have remained green.

"The deciduous trees were killed down from the top, some to the
ground, others killed outright, but they are no exceptions, all are
killed at least half way down. Included in these are Pyrus pruni-
folia, P. baccata, Caragana arborescens and Silver Poplar. All these
deciduous sorts put out leaves a month ago, but lately we have had

1 Saunders, Wm.: Reports from Sable Island in 1902, I. c. 56-58 (1902).

56 PROCEEDINGS: BOSTON SOCIETY NATURAL HISTORY.

very high winds and all the leaves are more or less blighted, and some
of the gooseberry and currant bushes are stripped. As I have mention-
ed before shelter is necessary here to success."

Supt. Bouteillier in the succeeding years continued to report on
the condition of the young trees. Each year his report was more and
more like a list of casualties due to the wind or the drought. In 1910,
he made a careful census1 of the survivors, finding 72 live.

During my visit to Sable Island in 1913, I was naturally much in-
terested in the result of the tree planting, and carefully inspected
each of the sites. I found 77 individuals. In all cases Supt. Bou-
teillier and I did not identify the trees as the same, but this is easy
to understand as all of them are little dwarfed, blasted sprigs which
never flower or fruit and which have very abnormal foliage. In all
the important details we do agree, that out of the original planting
in 1901 of 81,345 trees, as well as 50 pounds of seed of Pinus maritima
there are now but 75 or so individuals alive, none of these exceeding
the height of the sheltering Beach Grass. The attempt to forest
these sand dunes was an absolute failure.

After a review of all the circumstances connected with this tree
planting, no error in planning, no omission, no carelessness or acci-
dent in the planting is apparent. Large numbers of the trees that
have successfully reclaimed similar areas were used, as well as a great
variety of other possible trees and shrubs. It would seem that, al-
though a few trees probably did grow on the island as late as 1633
the decreased size and height of the island since then had so reduced
the amount of shelter from the fierce winds and storms that at pres-
ent no trees could be made to stand the extreme climatic conditions.
This remains, however, a distinct challenge to the foresters. It is
hoped that sometime they may be able to meet it successfully.

CATALOGUE OF THE VASCULAR PLANTS.

In the following catalogue different fonts of type are used to dis-
tinguish the different elements of the flora.
Native plants are indicated by full-faced type.
Adventive plants are indicated by large and small capitals.
Discredited records are enclosed in brackets.

1 Dominion Experimental Farms, Report of the Director, Results of Exper-
iments in Tree Planting on Sable Island, 54-55 (1910).

ST. JOHN: SABLE ISLAND. 57

POLYPODIACEAE.

[ASPIDIUM SPINULOSUM Sw., var. DILATATUM (Hoffm.) Hook. The
record of this fern for Sable Island is based on a communication from
H. T. Gussow, but he writes that the plant was in " too fragmentary
a condition to be placed in the Herbarium." The determination of
this plant cannot now be verified.]

Polypodium vulgare L. Known only from one collection, on the
old land at Island Pond, very rare, J. Macoun (C. no. 22,695).
Spores mature, — late July.

OSMUNDACEAE.

Osmunda cinnamomea L. Local, but abundant by the marshy
shores of the fresh ponds at the eastern end of Wallace Lake, near
Life Saving Station No. 3. Collected by J. Macoun; H. T. Gus-
sow; H. St. John, no. 1,108 (H).

LYCOPODIACEAE.

Lycopodium inundatum L. Somewhat general in the wet dune
hollows. J. Macoun; H. T. Gussow; H. St. John, nos. 1,109 and
1,110 (H).

Spores mature, — September.

PINACEAE.

PINUS MONTANA Mill. Six trees planted near Life Saving Station
No. 3, in a grassy dune hollow have survived from the five thousand
set out in 1901, but they are not over two feet in height, and are
hidden by a luxuriant growth of Ammophila. H. St. John, no. 1,111

(H).

P» SYLVESTRIS L. A few trees out of the ten thousand planted in
1901 near Life Saving Station No. 4, are still living but they are
overtopped by the Ammophila. H. St. John, no. 1,112 (H).

PICEA CANADENSIS (Mill.) B. S. P. One tree surviving at Life
Saving Station, No. 4, from the planting in 1901 of 2,500 young trees.
H. St. John, no. 1,113 (H).

[JUNIPERUS COMMUNIS recorded by J. Macoun (M. p. 216A) is
probably of the var. megistocarpa.]

58 PROCEEDINGS: BOSTON SOCIETY NATURAL HISTORY.

Juniperus communis L., var. megistocarpa Fernald & St.
John, n. var., J. communem, var. montanam ramis prostratis foliis
latis brevibus incurvantibus similans sed differt fructubus major-
ibus, 9-13 mm. diametro; seminibus majoribus, 5-7 mm. longis.

Resembling J. communis L., var. montana Ait. in its prostrate
branches and short broad incurved leaves, but differing from it by
its larger fruit, 9-13 mm. in diameter, and by its larger seeds, 5-7 mm.
long.

NEWFOUNDLAND: serpentine and magnesian limestone barrens,
northeastern base and slopes of Blomidon ("Blow-me-down")
Mountains, Bay of Islands, August 21, 1910, M. L. Fernald and K.
M. Wiegand, no. 2,422 (H).

QUEBEC, MAGDALEN ISLANDS: sand ridges back of the Narrows,
Alright Island, August 21, 1912, M. L. Fernald, Bayard Long, and
Harold St. John, no. 6,729 (TYPE in Gray Herb.); sand hills between
East Cape and East Point, Coffin Island, M. L. Fernald, Bayard
Long, and Harold St. John, no. 6,728 (H) ; sand dunes, Brion Island,
Aug. 6, 1914, Harold St. John, no. 2,040 (H).

NOVA SCOTIA: Empetrum heaths near Gourdeau park, Sable
Island, Aug. 23, 1913, Harold St. John, no. 1,114 (H); sprawling on
sand dunes, Empetrum heaths, Whalepost, Sable Island, Aug. 30,
1913, Harold St. John, no. 1,115 (H).

Common on Sable Island on the dry slopes of the fixed dunes.
This variety is probably the only one on the Island. In 1753 Andrew
Le Mercier (L) described the Island as looking "all green in winter
with the Juniper bushes."

In 1766 and 1767, J. F. W. Des Banes observed "juniper &c., in
their season" (Atlantic Neptune, i. 68, 1777).

"A little ground juniper," is referred to by J. B. Gilpin (G. p. 18);
"On y trouve, en fait de fruits, les baies du ge*nevrier rampant"
(T. p. 29).

Fr. — August and September.

[J. COMMUNIS L., var. DEPRESSA Pursh. Collected by J. Macoun
and H. T. Giissow, and probably to be referred to the preceding
variety.]

[J. NANA Willd. The plant mentioned by Jonathan Dwight, Jr.,
(D. pp. 9 and 12) is probably J. communis, var. megistocarpa.]

J. horizontalis Moench. Dry sheltered slopes of the more perma-
nent dunes. J. Macoun writes (M. p. 217A), "On one occasion I saw
roots protruding from under a sand-hill over thirty feet high, and
on digging them out found that they represented part of the remains

ST. JOHN: SABLE ISLAND. 59

of a specimen of Juniperus Sabina procumbens (creeping juniper).
It was rooted in a layer of black soil and when taken out showed
that it had lain flat on the ground. Two of the roots, including the
bark, measured 3*^6 and 3% inches in diameter respectively, while
the crown, where the branches began to spread was over seventeen
inches in circumference or nearly six inches in diameter." Quite
common on the old land, J. Macoun (C. no. 22,607); trailing on the
sand dunes, Whalepost, H. St. John, nos. 1,116 and 1,117 (H).
FL, Fr. — August and September.

[J. PROCUMBENS recorded by J. Macoun (M. p. 218A) is probably
J. horizontalis.]

[J. SABINA PROCUMBENS recorded by J. Macoun (M. p. 21 7A) is
J. horizontalis.]

TYPHACEAE.

Typha latif olia L. Local, growing only by the border of the fresh
ponds at the east end of Wallace Lake, J. Macoun; and swampy
edge of fresh-water pond near Life Saving Station No. 3, H. St. John,
no. 1,118 (H).

Fr. — September.

SPARGANIACEAE.

Sparganium angustifolium Michx. Common in the perma-
nent fresh-water ponds. J. Macoun (C. nos. 22,637 and 22,637a);
H. St. John, nos. 1,119 and 1,120 (H).

FL — July and August. Fr. — August and September.

[S. SIMPLEX Huds. of J. Macoun is S. angustifolium.]
POTAMOGETONACEAE.

Potamogeton polygonifolius Pourret. Abundant in the fresh-
water ponds. It will grow even in ponds that dry up for a part of
the summer, but it probably does not fruit in these except in a wet
season. In such exsiccated ponds the plant appears as a tight pros-
trate rosette of apparently sessile leaves. J. Macoun (C. no. 22,095)
— for the first notice of this, see A. Bennett, Journal of Botany, xxx.
198 (1901). H. St. John, nos. 1,121 and 1,122 (H).

Fr. — August and September.

P. epihydrus Raf. Very common in the fresh ponds. J. Ma-
coun (C. no. 22,073); H. St. John, no. 1,123 (H).

FL — July and August. Fr. — August and September.

60 PROCEEDINGS: BOSTON SOCIETY NATURAL HISTORY.

P. bupleuroides Fernald. Common in brackish ponds. J. Ma-
coun (C. no. 22,081); H. T. Gussow (E); H. St. John, no. 1,124 (H).
Fr. — August and September.

[P. PERFOLIATUS L. The specimens from Sable Island interpreted
as this prove to be the American P. bupleuroides.]

[P. FRIESII Rupr. J. Macoun's collection (C. no. 22,097) proves
to be P. pusillus, var. capitatus.]

P. pusillus L., var. capitatus Benn. Abundant in the brackish
ponds. The type collection was made in pools, July 27, 1899, J.
Macoun (C. no. 22,096 and 22,097); H. St. John, no. 1,125 (H).

FL, Fr. — July and August.

[P. STURROCKII Benn. In Fryer's Potamogetons of the British
Isles, 85 (1915) Arthur Bennett records this plant from Sable Island.]

P. pectinatus L. Common in the brackish pools. J. Macoun
(C. nos. 22,071 and 22,072); H. St. John, no. 1,126 (H).
FL, Fr.— August.

[P. PECTINATUS L., f. PSEUDOMARINUS Benn. In the Journal of
Botany, xxxix. 199 (1901) Bennett makes the combination and
credits the plant to Sable Island.]

[P. FILIFORMIS Pers. The collection by J. Macoun called this, is
P. pectinatus.]

[RUPPIA MARITIMA L. J. Macoun's collection so named proves
to be var. longipes.]

Ruppia maritima L., var. longipes Hagstrom. Abundant in
Wallace Lake and the brackish ponds. J. Macoun (C. no. 22,635) ;
H. St. John, no. 1,127 (H).

FL, Fr. — August.

Zostera marina L. Common in Wallace Lake and washed up
on the sea beaches. J. Dwight, Jr., (D. pp. 13 & 40) mentions
that it "abounds in the lagoon, and occurs as drift along its shores"
and that the nest of the Ipswich Sparrow may be partly made of
"eel-grass. " Listed by J. Macoun; and H. T. Gussow. H. St. John,
no. 1,128 (H).

ST. JOHN: SABLE ISLAND. 61

GRAMINEAE.

Panicum huachucae Asbe. Occasional in the drier spots.
J. Macoun (C. no. 22,708), labeled P. implicatum; H. St. John, nos.
1,129 and 1,130 (H).

Fr. — July and August.

[PANICUM IMPLICATUM Scribn. J. Macoun 's collection was so
labeled by Hitchcock and Chase, but the size of the spikelets and the
character of the pubescence indicate that this plant should rather
be treated as P. huachucae.]

ECHINOCHLOA CRUSGALLi (L.) Beauv. A garden weed at the Main
Life Saving Station. H. St. John, no. 1,131 (H).
Fr. — September.

ANTHOXANTHUM ODORATUM L. Established on the drier, more
stable parts of the island. J. Macoun (M. p. 218A) comments on
the abundance of this species on the old land and argues that it
appears native there, or at least is " a resident of such long standing
that it has made itself at home in all suitable places. " H . St. John,
no. 1,132 (H).

Fr. — August.

PHLEUM PRATENSE L. Planted and well established near the
Life Saving Stations. Observed by J. Dwight, Jr. (D. p. 12);
collected by J. Macoun; H. St. John, no. 1,133 (H).

Fl., Fr.— August.

AGROSTIS ALBA L., var. VULGARIS (With.) Thurb. Cultivated
near the stations, according to J. Dwight, Jr. (D. p. 12).

A. alba L., var. maritima (Lam.) G. F. W. Mey. Abundant in
the dune hollows and at the margins of the fresh-water ponds. Col-
lected by J. Macoun; H. T. Gussow (E); H. St. John, nos. 1,134 and
1,135 (H).

Fr. — August.

A. — [A collection by J. Macoun (C. no. 73,060) obviously belongs
to the alba series, but I have been unable to place it to my
satisfaction.

[A. HIEMALIS (Walt.) B. S. P. Both Macoun and Gussow list
this species, but the plants are probably to be interpreted as of the
var. geminata.]

62 PROCEEDINGS: BOSTON SOCIETY NATURAL HISTORY.

A. hiemalis (Walt.) B. S. P., var. geminata (Trin.) Hitchc.
A common plant, sprawling on the sand in the wet or the dry dune
hollows. A. S. Hitchcock in his monograph of the North American
Species of Agrostis, Bull. Bur. Plant Industry, Ixviii. 43 (1905),
cites one sheet with awnless spikelets, but this phase is apparently
common. H. St. John, nos. 1,136 and 1,365 (H).

FL, Fr— August.

Ammophila breviligulata Fernald. (A. arenaria of Am. authors,
not Link.) Abundant on all the drier parts of the island. Without
doubt this is .the most important plant on the island, for without it
nothing would stay the erosive action of the wind, the storms, and
the sea, and in a very short time the whole island would be reduced
to a treacherous submerged bar, such as now extend out from either
end of the island for more than fifteen miles. The Beach Grass does
what none of the hundred odd species planted for this purpose suc-
ceeded in doing, for in most parts of the island it actually does anchor
the sand and prevent the dunes from being dissipated by the winds.
Even the earlier explorers such as Des Barres, mention "a great
plenty of beach grass" (Atlantic Neptune, i. 68, 1777); in 1801,
Seth Coleman found the soil of Sable Island, " of a nature to produce
Beach Grass " (Rept. on Canadian Archives, 91, 1895). John Ma-
coun (M. p. 215A): "All the sandhills are covered with sandgrass
(Ammophila) and the wonderful vigour of this grass is well shown
everywhere, but more particularly where the sand has just been
deposited, or is in a raw state. I found one underground stem or
stolon over twelve feet long which had sixty-four series of roots and
no less than forty-seven tufts of leaves. The growing point was so
hard and sharp that it might almost penetrate wood."

Another equally important use of the Beach Grass is that of pro-
viding the fodder that supports the gangs of wild and semi-domesti-
cated ponies, as well as the cattle. To one familiar with it in other
places the Beach Grass would seem like very poor fodder. On the
sheltered slopes of many of the dunes, it grows here shoulder high,
deep green, and juicy and succulent, so much so that I used to pull
young shoots and chew them as I plodded over the soft sand and
forced my way through the tangle of Beach Pea. It seemed to me
that two factors might jointly or singly explain the unusually tender
and succulent condition of the Beach Grass here: the cool, very moist
climate; the regular cutting and harvesting of it as a hay crop over

ST. JOHN: SABLE ISLAND. 63

large areas. During my stay at the Main Life Saving Station owr
sixty tons of this crop were stored away within the huge barns. Such
a conspicuous plant was naturally observed by J. Dwight, Jr.; J.
Macoun; H. T. Gussow; H. St. John, no. 1,137 (H).
Fl. — Late August and September.

[A. ARENARIA (L.) Link. All records belong to the American A.
breiiligulata.]

Deschampsia flexuosa (L.) Trin. On the drier parts of the
island. J. Macoun; H. T. Gussow (E); H. St. John, no. 1,138 (H).
Fr— July.

[D. ALBA R. & S. Gussow' s specimen so named is D. flexuosa.]

AVENA SATIVA L. A weed at the Main Life Saving Station.
//. St. John, no. 1,139 (H).

A. SATIVA L., var. ORIENTALIS (Schreb.) Richter. A weed at the
Main Life Saving Station. H. St. John, no. 1,140 (H).

Danthonia spicata (L.) Beauv. On the old land, not rare.
Found only by J. Macoun (C. no. 22,688).
Fr. — July.

Spartina Michauxiana Hitchc. Occasional at the borders of the
brackish ponds. Found by J. Macoun; H. T. Gussow; H. St. John,
nos. 1,141 and 1,142 (H).

Fl. — August.

POA ANNUA L. A weed near the stations. Collected by J. Macoun
(C. no. 22,682).
FL— July.

P. PALUSTRIS L. (P. triflora Gilib.) Planted in a field near the
Main Life Saving Station. J. Macoun (C. no. 22,681).
FL— July.

P. pratensis L. Generally distributed and frequent on the dry
dunes. In 1753, Andrew Le Mercier (L) remarked, "there is some
English Grass"; and in 1801, Seth Coleman found "some small spots
of English Grass" (Rept. on Canadian Archives, 91, 1895).

Listed by J. Macoun; H. T. Gussow; H. St. John, no. 1,143 (H).

Fr. — August.

64 PROCEEDINGS: BOSTON SOCIETY NATURAL HISTORY.

Glyceria Fernaldii (Hitchc.) St. John. (G. pallida, var. Fernaldii
Hitchc.) In marshy spots, East End, J. Macoun (C. no. 22,684).
Fr. — Early August.

Festuca rubra L. Common on the drier parts of the island.
Collected by J. Macoun (C. no. 22,686); H. T. Gilssow; H. St. John,
no. 1,144 (H).

FL— July. Fr.— August.

F. rubra L., var. glaucescens (Hegetschw. & Heer) Richter.
Common on the nearly bare dunes where the coarse glaucous leaves
form great tufts. H. St. John, nos. 1,145, 1,146, and 1,147 (H).

Fr. — August.

BROMUS SECALINUS L. A fugitive weed. In meadow grass, rare.
J. Macoun (C. no. 22,671).
Fr. — July.

AGROPYRON REPENS L. Established near the Life Saving Stations.
Recorded by J. Macoun; H. St. John, no. 1,148 (H).
Fr. — August.

A. repens L., var. pilosum Scribn. On sand dunes remote from
the Life Saving Stations and apparently native. H. St. John, no.
1,149 (H).

FL— August.

HORDEUM JUBATUM L. A weed at the Main Life Saving Station.
Reported by J. Macoun; H. St. John, no. 1,150 (H).
Fr. — August and September.

Elymus arenarius L., var. villosus E. Mey. (E. arenarius of
Am. authors; E. mollis Trin.) Very rare on the island, occurring,
as far as known, only along the top of a narrow ridge of dunes extend-
ing a short distance from the eastern end of Wallace Lake along the
South Beach. This line of dunes has been rapidly washing away and
the remnants are still exposed to the action of the storms. This
grass luxuriates here, sending its culms up to a height of six feet or
more, but the station is in great danger of being destroyed. H. St.
John, no. 1,151 (H).

Fr. — September.

CYPERACEAE.

Eleocharis palustris (L.) R. & S. Abundantly fringing the
borders of the permanent and semi-permanent fresh-water ponds.

ST. JOHN: SABLE ISLAND. 65

J. Macoun (C. nos. 77,185, 77,186, 77,163, 22,648); H. T. Gussow;
H. St. John, no. 1,152 (H).
Fl. — August.

E. palustris (L.) R. & S., var. glaucescens (Willd.) Gray. Even
more common than the preceding, but found sprawling on the drier
sand flats or in nearly bare dune hollows. J. Macoun (C. nos. 22,640,
22,647, and 77,187); H. St. John, nos. 1,153, 1,154, and 1,155 (H).

Fl. — August. Fr. — August and September.

Scirpus nanus Spreng. Found only by the brackish margins of
Wallace Lake. J. Macoun (C. no. 22,649); H. T. Gussow; H. Si.
John, no. 1,156 (H).

Fl., Fr.— September.

S. americanus Pers. Common in the dune hollows. J. Macoun
(C. no. 22,632); H. T. Gussow; H. St. John, no. 1,157 (H).
FL — August.

S. acutus Muhl. (S. occidentalis (Wats.) Chase.) Brackish and
nearly fresh ponds near Wallace Lake. Some of the specimens have
been named S. validus but none seems to belong in that species. J.
Macoun (C. no. 22,633) is very young material. H. T. Gussow's
collection has well developed achenes only 2 mm. long, but the spike-
lets are borne for the most part in glomerules, so the plant is treated
as of this species. H. St. John, nos. 1,158 and 1,159 (H) do not have
long spikelets, but the achenes are large, 2.5 mm. long, and the
scales are long and overlapping. These specimens with a mingling
of characters of S. validus and of S. acutus raise the question as to
the distinctness of these two species.

Fr. — September.

[S. OCCIDENTALIS (WTats.) Chase is S. acutus.]

[S. VALIDUS Vahl. The specimens from Sable Island that have
been called this seem better treated as S. acutus.]

S. campestris Britton, var. paludosus (A. Nelson) Fernald.
Brackish ponds near Wallace Lake. J. Macoun (C. no. 22,634);
H. St. John, no. 1,160 (H).

Fr. — September

Carex hormathodes Fernald. Wet margins of the fresh ponds,
common. J. Macoun; H. St. John, nos. 1,161, 1,162, and 1,163 (H).
Fr. — August and September.

66 PROCEEDINGS: BOSTON SOCIETY NATURAL HISTORY.

[C. STRAMINEA Willd. The specimen so labeled by J. Macoun is
C. hormathodes.]

C. silicea Olney. Uniformly distributed on the dunes and drier
sand flats. J. Macoun; H. St. John, no. 1,164 (H).
Fl, Fr.— August.

C. echinata Murr. (C. stellulata Good.) Borders of ponds
and wet dune hollows. J. Macoun (C. no. 23,037); H. St. John, no.
1,165 (H).

Fr. — July and August.

C. echinata Murr., var. cephalantha Bailey. Found at the
East End, J. Macoun (C. no. 77,162 and 22,065).
Fr.— July.

C. canescens L., var. disjuncta Fernald. Common along the
pond margins and in the wet dune hollows. J. Macoun (C. nos.
23,070 and 23,071); H. St. John, no. 1,166 (H).

Fr. — July to September.

C. deflexa Horriem. Found only by J. Macoun (C. no. 23,089).
Fr.— July.

C. Oederi Retz., var. pumila (Coss. & Germain) Fernald. Wet
usually turfy borders of brackish ponds. J. Macoun (C. no. 23,088) ;
H. St. John, no. 1,167 (H).

Fr. — July and August.

ERIOCAULACEAE.

Eriocaulon septangulare With. (E. articulatum (Huds.) Mor-
ong.) Very abundant at the wet margins of the fresh-water ponds.
J. Macoun; H. St. John, no. 1,168 (H).

Fr. — August.

JUNCACEAE.

Juncus bufonius L. Wet sand near Wallace Lake. Collected
by J. Macoun; H. T. Gussow; H. St. John, no. 1,169 (H).
FL, Fr.— August.

J. bufonius L., var. halophilus Buchenau & Fernald. Brackish
beach of Wallace Lake, H. St. John, no. 1,170 (H).
FL, Fr.— August.

ST. JOHN: SABLE ISLAND. 67

J. tenuis Willd. Common on the sand dunes. Collected by
J. Macoun; H. T. Gussow; H. St. John, nos. 1,171 and 1,172 (H).

FL, £r. — August and September.

[J. BALTIC recorded by J. Macoun (M. p. 218A) is J. balticus, var.
littoralis.]

J. balticus Willd., var. littoralis Engelm. Very common in the
wet or dry dune hollows. Collected by J. Dwight, Jr. (D. p. 12);
J. Macoun; H. T. Gussow; H. St. John, no. 1,173 (H).

FL, Fr.— August.

J. canadensis J. Gay. Common in the dune hollows. J. Ma-
coun; H. T. Gussow; H. St. John, nos. 1,174 and 1,175 (H).
FL — August. Fr. — August and September.

J. pelocarpus Mey., var. sabulonensis, n. var., pros tratus omni-
bus partibus forma typica multo minor; foliis teretibus, septis vix
visibilibus; floribus in cymam contractam aggregatis; capsulo 2.5-
3.5 mm. longo, 1-1.5 mm. diametro igitur crassitudine dimidium
longitudinis subaequante.

Prostrate, very much reduced in all parts: the septa scarcely
showing on the terete leaf blades: flowers more nearly approximate
in the reduced cyme: capsule 2.5-3.5 mm. long, 1-1.5 mm. wide,
averaging nearly one half as wide as long, while in J. pelocarpus the
capsules are 3-4 mm. long, and 1-1.5 mm. wide> averaging one third
as wide as long. The bulbiferous form is not known to occur in the
var. sabulonensis.

NOVA SCOTIA: shallow ponds, Sable Island, Aug. 16, 1899, J. Ma-
coun (C. no. 22,631); sprawling in wet dune hollow, Sable Island,
Aug. 30, 1913, H. St. John, no. 1,176 (TYPE in Gray Herb.).

J. bulbosus L. Common along the marshy borders of fresh-
water ponds. J. Macoun (C. no. 22,623) see J. M. Macoun, Ottawa
Nat. xv. (Contributions to Canadian Bot. xiv.) 79 (1901); H. St.
John, no. 1,177 (H).

FL, Fr.— August.

[J. ARTICULATUS L. of J. Macoun is J. pelocarpus, var. sabulonensis .]

J. articulatus L., var. obtusatus Engelm. Very common, in
the wet dune hollows. H. T. Gussow (E); H. St. John, nos. 1,178,
1,179, and 1,180 (H).

Fr. — August and September.

Luzula campestris (L.) DC., var. acadiensis Fernald. See
Rhodora, xix. 38 (1917). Common on the dry dunes that are fixed

68 PROCEEDINGS: BOSTON SOCIETY NATURAL HISTORY.

by semi-abundant vegetation. H. St. John, nos. 1,181 and 1,182
(H). All records for the var. multiflora should probably go here.
Fr. — August. 9

[JUNCOIDES CAMPESTRE (L.) recorded by J. Dwight, Jr., (D. p. 12)
is treated as Luzula campestris, var. acadiensis.]

LILIACEAE.

Smilacina stellata (L.) Desf. Found throughout, on the drier
dunes that are anchored by a covering of larger vegetation. J.
Dwight, Jr.; J. Macoun; H. T. Gussow; H. St. John, no. 1,183 (H).

Fr. — August, uncommon.

IRIDACEAE.

Iris versicolor L. Common by the wet pond margins. John
Rose, in 1633, saw "flags by the ponds" (Winthrop, John: Hist, of
N. E., ed. James Savage, i. 162 (1825)). J. B. Gilpin records
(G. p. 18), "The wild rose, blue lily and wild pea enamel the valleys."
It has seemed evident to me that Gilpin's "blue lily" must be Iris
versicolor. J. Dwight, Jr. (D. p. 14) refers to the "blue lilies,"
"that are said to bloom later in the season, I failed to obtain any
specimens." J. Macoun; H. T. Gussow; H. St. John, nos. 1,184
and 1,185 (H).

FL, Fr. — August and September.

Sisyrinchium gramineum Curtis. Abundant in the wet dune
hollows all over the island. Recorded as S. graminoides Bicknell
by Bicknell, Bull. Torr. Bot. Club, xxvii. 239 (1900). J. Macoun
(C. nos. 76,855, 76,856, and 76,857); H. St. John, no. 1,186 (H).

FL, Fr. — July and August.

[S. ANGUSTIFOLIUM Mill. All records of this from Sable Island
should be interpreted as S. gramineum.]

ORCHIDACEAE.

Habenaria bracteata (Willd.) R. Br. In boggy spots near
Island Pond. Found only by J. Macoun (C. no. 22,614). This
specimen has been recorded by Ames as H. viridis R. Br., var. brac-
teata Gray, in his Orchidaceae, iv. 24 (1910).

Fr.— July.

[H. VIRIDIS R. Br., var. BRACTEATA Gray recorded by Ames is
//. bracteata.]

ST. JOHN: SABLE ISLAND. 69

H. clavellata (Michx.) Spreng. Occasional on turfy banks near
the fresh-water ponds. J. Macoun; H. T. Gussoiv (E); H. St.
John, nos. 1,187 and 1,188 (H).

Fl, Fr.— September.

H. lacera (Michx.) R. Br. Occasional on turfy banks and in the
wet dune hollows. J. Macoun; H. T. Gussow (E); H. St. John,
nos. 1,189, 1,190, 1,191, and 1,192 (H).

FL — August. Fr. — September.

Calopogon pulchellus (Sw.) R. Br. Frequent in the wet dune
hollows. J. Macoun; H. T. Gussow; H. St. John, nos. 1.193 and
1,194 (H).

Fl. — August.

C. pulchellus (Sw.) R. Br., forma latifolius n. f., foliis oblongo-
vel elliptici-lanceolatis, 7-11 cm. longis, 1.3-2.8 cm. latis.

Leaves oblong- or elliptic-lanceolate, 7-11 cm. long, 1.3-2.8 cm.
wide.

NOVA SCOTIA: wet dune hollow, Sable Island, Aug. 27, 1913,
H. St. John, no. 1,195 (TYPE in Gray Herb.).

Spiranthes Romanzoffiana Cham. In damp boggy spots.
Found only by J. Macoun (C. no. 22,603).
Fl— July.

SALICACEAE.

SALIX VIMINALIS L. A planted specimen has survived at life
Saving Station No. 3, and attained a height of six feet. It showed no
signs of having fruited. H. St. John, no. 1,196 (H).

MYRICACEAE.

Myrica carolinensis Mill. Scattered clumps on the dry dunes.
J. Macoun; H. T. Gussow; H. St. John, no. 1,197 (H).
Fr. — August.

M. CERIFERA L. Recorded by J. Dwight, Jr. (D. pp. 13 & 42)
and by J. Macoun (M. p. 2 18 A), but the specimens are undoubtedly
M . carolinensis.

BETULACEAE.

BETULA PENDULA Roth. Planted in 1901, and one tree surviving
near Life Saving Station No. 4, although not equalling the Sand
Grass (Ammophila) in height. H. St. John, no. 1,198 (H).

70 PROCEEDINGS: BOSTON SOCIETY NATURAL HISTORY.

B. ALBA L. (B. PUBESCENS Ehrh.) Two thousand trees were
planted in 1901 in Gourdeau Park and a few are still growing there,
but are not over two feet in height. H. St. John, no. 1,199 (H).

POLYGONACEAE.

Rum ex Britannic a L. Occurring only along the swampy mar-
gins of the fresh-water ponds extending beyond the eastern end of
Wallace Lake, near Life Saving Station No. 3. J. Macoun (C. no.
22,595); H. St. John, no. 1,200 (H).

FL — August. Fr. — September.

[R. OCCIDENTALS Wats. The plant so listed by J. Macoun is
R. Britannica.]

R. CRISPUS L. Introduced and common near the Life Saving
Stations, rare elsewhere. J. Macoun; H. St. John, nos. 1,201, 1,202,
and 1,203 (H).

Fr. — August and September.

R. maritimus L., var. fueginus (Phil.) Dusen. See St. John
Rhodora, xvii. 81 (1915). Abundant on the brackish beaches of
Wallace Lake, and appearing as a weed in the gardens through the
use as a fertilizer of sea-weed collected on the beach of the lake.
J. Macoun (C. no. 22,549); H. St. John, nos. 1,204, 1,205,1,206,1,207,
and 1,208 (H).

Fl. — August. Fr. — September.

R. ACETOSELLA L. Thoroughly established on the drier parts of
the island, especially near the Life Saving Stations. Mentioned by
J. Dwight, Jr. (D. pp. 13 &.42). Listed by J. Macoun; and H. T.
Gussow; H. St. John, no. 1,209 (H).
Fl. — August.

Polygonum Rail Bab. Wet dune hollow, possibly brackish.
Known only from the collection, H. St. John, no. 1,210 (H).
Fl. — August.

[P. FOWLERI Robinson. The plant so listed by J. Macoun is P.
aviculare.]

P. AVICULARE L. Well established near the Life Saving Stations.
J. Macoun (C. no. 22,599, also as door-weed M. p. 218A); H. St.
John, nos. 1,211, and 1,212 (H).
FL, Fr. — August and September.

ST. JOHN: SABLE ISLAND. 71

P. LAPATHIFOLIUM L. In a potato field, East End Post, J. Macoun
(C. no. 22,590).

FL, Fr.— July.

P. LAPATHIFOLIUM L., var. PROSTRATUM Wimmer. Brackish
beach of Wallace Lake near the Main Life Saving Station. H. St.
John, no. 1,361 (H). Material of this number was distributed
under an unpublished manuscript name.

FL, .Fr.— September.

P. SCABRUM Moench (P. TOMENTOSUM Schrank). A weed at the
Main Life Saving Station. H. St. John, no. 1,213 (H).

FL, Fr.— August.

P. HYDROPIPER L. Introduced around buildings, Main Life Sav-
ing Station, J. Macoun (C. no. 22,582).
FL, Fr. — August.

P. PERSICARIA L. A weed at the Main Life Saving Station. H.
St. John, no. 1,214 (H).
FL, Fr.— August.

P. hydropiperoides Michx., var. psilostachyum, n. var.,
P. hydropiperoidem simulans sed differt ocreolis glabris eciliolatis,
marginibus pellucidis; foliis glabris vel glabratis brevioribus, 4-8
cm. longis, 0.8-2.4 cm. latis.

Differing from P. hydropiperoides, which has leaves pubescent at
least on the midrib and near the margins and often throughout, in
having glabrous eciliolate ocreolae which have scarious transparent
margins, and in the glabrous or glabrate comparatively short leaves,
4-8 cm. long, 0.8-2.4 cm. wide.

NOVA SCOTIA : in muddy ponds and by their borders, Sable Is-
land, Aug. 3, 1899, J. Macoun (C. no. 22,583); Sable Island, Sept.,
1911, H. T. Gussow (E); shallow fresh-water pond, Sable Island,
Aug. 16, 1913, H. St. John, no. 1,215 (H); swampy edge of fresh-
water pond, Sable Island, Aug. 23, 1913, H. St. John, no. 1,216
(TYPE in Gray Herb.). WASHINGTON: White Salmon, Oct., 1880,
W. N. Suksdorf, no. 483 (H); Columbia River Bottom, Klickitat
Co., Oct. 12, 1881, W. N. Suksdorf, no. 56 (H & P).

To the last-cited specimen there is a reference in a letter from W.
N. Suksdorf to Dr. Sereno Watson, dated Oct. 20, 1881. "It is an
indigenous plant no doubt, very frequent on low bottom lands near
the Columbia River; perennial, the prostrate stems rooting at the
joints, the flowering portion mostly ascending." On the list is a
note in Dr. Watson's handwriting, "but bracts not ciliate." So it

72 PROCEEDINGS: BOSTON SOCIETY NATURAL HISTORY.

appears that Dr. Watson had noticed one of the characters of the
var. psilostachyum, but he took no action.

P. CONVOLVULUS L. A weed at the Main Life Saving Station.
J. Macoun; H. St. John, no. 1,217 (H).
FL, Fr.— August.

CHENOPODIACEAE.

Chenopodium rubrum L. Common on the brackish beach of
Wallace Lake. J. Macoun; H. T. Gussow; H. St. John, no. 1,218
(H).

Fr. — September.

C. ALBUM L. A weed at the Main Life Saving Station. J. Ma-
coun; (also as "lamb's quarter" M. p. 218 A); H. St. John, no.
1,219 (H).

/'/.—August.

A narrow-leaved form is also established at the Main Life Saving
Station. H. St. John, no. 1,220 (H).

Fl. — September.

Atriplex patula L., var. hastata (L.) Gray. Common on the
wet brackish beach of Wallace Lake. J. Macoun; H. T. Gussow;
H. St. John, no. 1,221 (H).

Fr.— September.

CARYOPHYLLACEAE.

Spergularia leiosperma (Kindberg) F. Schmidt. See Fernald &
Wiegand, Rhodora, xii. 162 (1910). Common on the brackish sandy
beach of Wallace Lake. J. Macoun (C. no. 21,151); H. T. Gussow
(E); H. St. John, nos. 1,222 and 1,223 (H).

Fl. — August. Fr. — August and September.

[S. CANADENSIS (Pers.) Don of J. Macoun and H. T. Gussow is S.
leiosperma.]

SPERGULA ARVENSIS L. A weed at the Main Life Saving Station.
J. Macoun; H. St. John, nos. 1,224 and 1,225 (H).
Fl. — August and September. Fr. — September.

Sagina procumbens L. Frequent in the wet dune hollows.
J. Macoun; H. St. John, no. 1,226 (H); H. S. Glazebrook (H).
Fl. — June to August. Fr. — July to August.

ST. JOHN: SABLE ISLAND. 73

Arenaria lateriflora L., var. typica (Regel) St. John. Turfy
banks and grass-covered dunes. J. Macoun; H. T. Gussow; H. St.
John, no. 1,227 (H).

Fr. — August.

[A. GROENLANDICA (Retz.) is recorded by J. Dwight, Jr. (D. p.
14). I searched for this specimen in the Herbarium of the New York
Botanical Garden, but could not find it. I strongly suspect the plant
is A. lateriflora, var. typica.]

[A. PEPLOIDES L. Recorded by J. Dwight, Jr. (D. p. 14) and by
J. Macoun (M. p. 213A) is probably to be treated as of the var.

robusta.]

A. peploides L., var. robusta Fernald. See Rhodora, xi. 114
(1909). Very abundant at the top of the beaches, on the dry bars
and sand spits. As is the case with Ammophila, this plant plays an
important part in the affairs of the island. The terns of three sorts
which nest on the sand flats, almost invariably place their nests in a
clump of the Arenaria. From a somewhat unusual cause, a botanist
finds great difficulty in collecting good specimens of this abundant
plant. For weeks he can inspect clump after clump of the Arenaria
and find that in each case there has been an earlier visitor, and a
very destructive one. This succulent, free-growing plant is the
choicest fodder of the "gangs" of wild ponies that roam the island,
and as these total anywhere from two to four hundred ponies, it is
easy to see how they would make serious depredations on any plant
growing only in a limited portion of an area of about fifteen square
miles. Taking the hint from the ponies, I myself tried munching a
sprig of the Arenaria, and found it of good texture, juicy and with a
strong but not unpleasant taste resembling that of cabbage. J.
Dwight, Jr. (D. p. 14); J. Macoun; H. T. Gussow; H. St. John,
no. 1,228 (H).

Fr. — August.

STELLARIA GRAMINEA L. A weed, established at the Main Life
Saving Station. J. Macoun; H. St. John, no. 1,229 (H).
FL, Fr. — August.

S. MEDIA (L.) Cyrill. A weed, thoroughly established at the
Main Life Saving Station. J. Macoun (C. no. 21,154); H. St. John,
no. 1,230 (H).

FL, Fr. — July and August.

74 PROCEEDINGS: BOSTON SOCIETY NATURAL HISTORY.

[S. MEDIA (L.) Cyrill., ssp. NEGLECTA Weihe. Theo. Holm, in the
Ottawa Nat. xv. 37-41 (1901), records this from Sable Island, basing
it on J. Macoun's collection (C. no. 21,154). I have examined this
specimen and can see no justification for separating it from <S. media.]

[S. MEDIA (L.) Cyrill., var. PROCERA Klett & Richter. Recorded
in Gray's Man. ed. 7, 382 (1908), is to be treated as S. media.]

CERASTIUM VULGATUM L. Established on the dry dunes near the
Life Saving Stations. J. Macoun; H. St. John, no. 1,231 (H); H.
S. Glazebrook (H).

Fl. — June to August. Fr. — August.

SILENE NOCTIFLORA L. A weed at Life Saving Station No. 3.
H. St. John, no. 1,232 (H).
Fr. — September.

PORTULACACEAE.

[MONTIA FONTANA L. Listed by J. Macoun, but the specimen is
Tillaea aquatica.]

PORTULACA OLERACEA L. A weed, observed in the garden of the
Main Life Saving Station.

NYMPHAEACEAE.

Nymphozanthus variegatus (Engelm.) Fernald. See Rhodora,
xxi. 187 (1919). Abundant in the small ponds which at all times are
absolutely isolated from the sea. J. Macoun (C. no. 21,142); H.
St. John, no. 1,233 (H).

Fl. — July and August. Fr. — August.

[NUPHAR ADVENA Ait. All records from the island are to be con-
sidered as Nymphozanthus variegatus.]

RANUNCULACEAE.

Ranunculus Cymbalaria Pursh. Common on the brackish
beaches. J. Macoun (C. no. 21,130); H. St. John, no. 1,234 (H).
FL, Fr. — July to September.

[R. CYMBALARIA Pursh, var. ALPINUS Hook, recorded by J. Ma-
coun. The specimen is better treated as R. Cymbalaria.]

ST. JOHN: SABLE ISLAND. 75

R. reptans L. (R. Flammula, var. reptans (L.) Meyer.) Very
common in the wet dune hollows. J. Macoun; H. T. Gussow; H.
St. John, no. 1,235 (H).

FL, Fr.— August.

R. REPENS L. A rare introduction. Found only by J. Macoun
(C. no. 21,132).
Fr. — August.

R. ACRIS L. A weed at the Main Life Saving Station. J. Macoun;
H. St. John, no. 1,236 and 1,237 (H).

FL — August and September. Fr. — September.

[THALICTRUM DIOICUM L. Listed by J. Macoun, and H. T. Gussow,
but the specimens are T. polygamum, var. hebecarpum.]

Thalictrum polygamum Muhl., var. hebecarpum Fernald.
Common on the stable, well vegetated dunes. J. Dwight, Jr. (D.
p. 13) mentions as one of the weeds " Thalictrum sp.?" As there is
but one species of Meadow Rue growing on the island, and that very
commonly, we can feel reasonably sure that J. Dwight, Jr., found T.
polygamum, var. hebecarpum. It is hard to understand, however,
why he called it a weed. J. Macoun (C. no. 21,134); H.T. Gussow
(E); H. St. John, no. 1,238 (H).

Fl. — July and August. Fr. — August and September.

[T. ZIBELLINUM Greene. In the Ottawa Naturalist, xxiv. 30
(1910) this new species was published, based upon the collection of
J. Macoun (C. no. 21,134). I have examined the suite of specimens
collected under this number and feel no hesitation about stating that
the plant should be treated as T. polygamum, var. hebecarpum.]

Coptis trifolia (L.) Salisb. On the more permanent, grass-
covered dunes. J. Macoun; H. St. John, no. 1,239 (H); H. S. Glaze-
brook (H).

FL— June.

CRUCIFERAE.

CAPSELLA BURSA-PASTORIS (L.) Medic. A weed at the Main Life
Saving Station. J. Macoun; (also as "shepherd's purse" M. p.
218 A); H. St. John, no. 1,240 (H).

FL, Fr.— August.

76 PROCEEDINGS: BOSTON SOCIETY NATURAL HISTORY.

Cakile edentula (Bigel.) Hook. Common on the sea strands
and along the brackish beach of Wallace Lake. J. Macoun; H. T.
Gussow (E); H. St. John, no. 1,241 (H).

FL, Fr. — August.

RAPHANUS SATIVUS L. Established at the Main Life Saving Sta-
tion. H. St. John, no. 1,242 (H).
FL — August.

BRASSICA ARVENSIS (L.) Ktze. A weed near the Life Saving Sta-
tions. J. Macoun; H. St. John, no. 1,243 (H).
FL — August.

SISYMBRIUM OFFICINALE (L.) Scop. A weed near Life Saving
Station, No. 3. H. St. John, no. 1,244 (H).
FL, />.— September.

DROSERACEAE.

Drosera rotundifolia L. Common in the wet dune hollows and
on the margins of the fresh-water ponds. J. Macoun; H. T. Gussow;
H. St. John, no. 1,245 (H).

FL, Fr. — August.

D. longifolia L. In wet sand and bogs, found only by J. Macoun
(C. no. 21,187).
FL — August.

CRASSULACEAE.

Tillaea aquatica L. Forming pure mats at the wet borders of
the fresh-water ponds. J. Macoun (C. no. 21,156); H. St. John,
nos. 1,246 and 1,247 (H).

FL, Fr. — July and August.

The three collections of this plant from Sable Island show, in the
same clump, plants which have "nearly sessile" flowers and fruit,
and other plants bearing nearly sessile flowers in the upper axils and
peduncled ones in the lower axils. According to our present Ameri-
can treatments, we should have to recognize in these apparently
pure clumps two species. An examination of the American material
of Tillaea Vaillantii Willd. shows that in every known locality T.
aquatica occurs and occurs more abundantly, that its characters are
a matter of degree, not strictly definable. Consequently the author
feels that T. Vaillantii of American authors should be treated as
identical with T. aquatica. The inference must not be drawn that

ST. JOHN: SABLE ISLAND. 77

the author is discounting T. Vaillantii Willd. of Europe, which is a
valid and distinct species.

SAXIFRAGACEAE.

HYDRANGEA PANICULATA Sieb., var. GBANDIFLORA Sieb. From the
twenty-five planted in 1901, one is still surviving at Life Saving
Station, No 3. H. St. John, no. 1,248 (H).

ROSACEAE.

Pyrus arbutifolia (L.) L. f., var. atropurpurea (Britton) Robin-
son. Common on the more permanent, well vegetated parts of the
island. J. Macoun (C. no. 21,174); H. St. John, nos. 1,249 and
1,250.

Fr. — August.

[P. MELANOCARPA (Michx.) Willd. Listed by H. T. Gussow on
the basis of a field determination. It is doubtless to be considered
as P. arbutifolia, var. atropurpurea.]

[FRAGARIA VIRGINIANA Duchesne. Listed by H. T. Gussow on
the basis of a field determination. The plant was undoubtedly of
the var. terrae-novae.]

Fragaria virginiana Duchesne, var. terrae-novae (Rydb.) Fer-
nald & Wiegand. See Rhodora, xiii. 106 (1911). Common on the
semi-permanent dunes, and in the turfy hollows. Andrew Le Mer-
cier in 1753 described the island as looking all "red in summer with
the large Strawberries." We must remember, however, that by
means of this article Le Mercier hoped to sell the island, which was
then his private property. J. B. Gilpin in 1858 (G. p. 18) mentioned
the "Strawberries." Similarly J. C. Tache speaks of "les fraises,"
(T. p. 29). J. Dwight, Jr.; J. Macoun (C. nos. 21,172 and 21,182);
H. T. Gussow; H. St. John, no. 1,251 (H).

Fl. — June.

[F. CANADENSIS Michx. recorded by J. Dwight, Jr., is F. virgin-
iana, var. terrae-novae.]

[POTENTILLA MONSPELiENSis L. The records of J. Macoun, and
H. T. Gussow should be for var. norvegica.]

Potentilla monspeliensis L., var. norvegica (L.) Rydb. Com-
mon around the margins cf the fresh-water ponds. J. Macoun (C.
no. 21,176); H. T. Gussow (E); H. St. John, nos. 1,252 and 1,253
(H).

FL, Fr. — August and September.

78 PROCEEDINGS: BOSTON SOCIETY NATURAL HISTORY.

P. palustris (L.) Scop. Occasional on the wet pond margins.
Listed by J. Macoun; H. St. John, nos. 1,254, 1,255, and 1,362 (H).
Fr. — September.

P. palustris (L.) Scop, approaching var. parvifolia (Raf.) Fernald
& Long. See Rhodora, xvi. 10 (1914). Swampy edge of a fresh
pond, near the east end of Wallace Lake, growing in the same colony
with P. palustris. H. St. John, no. 1,256 (H).

Fr. — September.

P. tridentata Ait. Occasional on the sand dunes. Listed by
J. Macoun; and H. T. Gussow. H. St. John, no. 1,257 (H).

Fl— August.

P. pacifica Howell. See Rhodora xi. 8 (1909). Abundant along
the brackish beaches of Wallace Lake. H. T. Gussow (E); H. St.
John, no. 1,258 (H).

FL, Fr. — August.

[P. ANSERINA L. Listed by J. Macoun, but is probably P. paci-
fica]

Rubus hispidus L. Known from this area only by a small frag-
ment collected by J. Macoun (C. no. 21,139 in part) (H).

Rubus arcuans Fernald & St. John, n. sp., arcuans deinde pros-
tratus; turionibus aculeis 3-4.5 mm. longis robustis curvatis re-
trorsis valde armatis; foliis plerumque trifoliolatis aliquando quin-
quefoliolatis vel subquinquef oliolatis ; foliolis obovatis acutis vel
suborbiculatis coriaceis supra nigri-viridibus subtus pallidi-viridibus
grosse dupliciterque serratis, 3.5-8.5 cm. longis, 2-6.2 cm. latis,
costa media subter aculeis raris instructa, costis minute pilosis:
ramis floriferis prostratis ; foliis trifoliolatis vel simplicibus ; foliolis cori-
aceio obovatis grosse dupliciterque serratis 2.5-8 cm. longis, 1.5-7 cm.
latis, costis subter pilosis; inflorescentia racemosa vel compositi-
racemosa foliosa interrupta, 0.6-3.2 dm. longa; pedicellis 1.5-4 cm.
longis, densissime pilosis aculeis aliquando glandulis paucis stipitatis
munitis; sepalis lanceolati-ovatis ; petalis albis spatulatis, 7-11
mm. longis; fructibus globosis.

Arching and becoming prostrate: canes of the first year thickly
beset with strong curved retrorse bristles, which are 3-4.5 mm. in
length: the leaves normally 3-foliolate, but sometimes 5-foliolate
or imperfectly so; the leaflets obovate with an acute tip or nearly
orbicular, coriaceous, dark green above, light green beneath, coarsely
doubly serrate, 3.5-8.5 cm. long, 2-6.2 cm. wide; the midrib armed
beneath with scattered prickles; the veins finely pilose: fruiting
canes prostrate, with trifoliolate or simple leaves; the coriaceous leaf-

ST. JOHN: SABLE ISLAND. 79

lets obovate, pilose on the veins, coarsely and doubly serrate, 2.5-8
cm. long, 1.5-7 cm. wide: the inflorescence an interrupted leafy sub-
cylindric simple or compound raceme, 0.6-3.2 dm. long; pedicels
1.5-4 cm. long, very densely pilose, armed with prickles and at times
with a few stipitate glands; sepals lance-ovate; petals white, spatu-
late, 7-11 mm. long; fruit globose.

PRINCE EDWARD ISLAND: dry open soil, Dundee, Aug. 26, 1912,
M. L. Fernald, Bayard Long, and Harold St. John, no. 7,652 (TYPE
in Gray Herb.); railroad banks, Mt. Stewart, July 30, 1912, M. L.
Fernald, E. B. Bartram, Bayard Long, and Harold St. John, nos.
7,655 and 7,654 (H); Miscouche, Sept. 12, 1909, W. H. Blanchard,
no. 806 (H). NOVA SCOTIA: Pictou, July 22, 1907, C. B. Robinson,
no. 574 (H). SABLE ISLAND: July 24, 1899, J. Macoun (C. no. 21,193
in part); sprawling among Ammophila on sand dunes, Aug. 26, 1913,
H. St. John, no. 1,259 (H). MASSACHUSETTS: damp dune hollows
east of Race Point Life Saving Station, Provincetown, August 2, 1919,
Fernald & Long, no. 18,585.

Rydberg cites with some doubt the Macoun nos. 21,183 and
21,193 from Sable Island as Rubus nigricans X recurvans, Bull. Torr.
Bot. Cl. xlii. 476 (1915); and on the following page he cites no.
21,193 as Rubus nigricans X procumbens. On p. 478 he cites the C.
B. Robinson no. 574 as Rubus hispidus X nigricans.

An anonymous writer reports " blackberries " on Sable Island
(All the Year Round, Ix. 521, 1890).

This species of the Maritime Provinces and Cape Cod differs from
RMardaius Blanchard by having broadly obovate more coriaceous
leaflets, abundant strong prickles, densely villous and ordinarily
glandless but bristly pedicels; instead of the broadly lanceolate
leaflets tapering to each end, the less numerous weaker prickles,
and the less pubescent and copiously glandular pedicels of that
species; from R. setosus Bigel. by having strong prickles thickened
at the base and broad obovate bluntly serrate dark green coriaceous
leaflets, instead of fine setae and narrower oblanceolate sharply
serrate paler leaflets, long-trailing tips of the branches and essen-
tially glandless pedicels; from R. hispidus L. by its much coarser
habit, strong prickles, larger leaves, and its more elongate coarser
inflorescence with larger corolla and larger seeds (averaging 3 mm.
in length), the comparatively delicate R. hispidus having fine weak
prickles and more rounded smaller leaflets and small fruits with seeds
averaging 2 mm. in length.

FL, Fr.— August.

Rosa virginiana Mill. Very common on the more stable sand
dunes throughout the island. "The wild rose" is mentioned by
J. B. Gilpin (G. p. 18). J. C. Tache says, "La plus belle plante
d'ornement est le rosier sauvage, qui vient a merveille, sur cette

80 PROCEEDINGS: BOSTON SOCIETY NATURAL HISTORY.

terre si souvent enveloppee de brouillards et visitee par les orages"
(T. p. 29). J. Macoun; H. T. Giissow; H. St. John, no. 1,260 (H).
Fr. — August and September.

[R. NITIDA Willd., is a tentative determination put on material
in young leaf collected by J. Dwight, Jr. (D. p. 13). The plant is
doubtless R. mrginiana.]

LEGUMINOSAE.

CYTISUS SCOPARIUS (L.) Link. In 1901 there were planted
1,000 bushes of this species. In 1913 there was to be seen but one
small clump which still survived in Gourdeau Park. H. St. John,
no. 1,261 (H).

TRIFOLIUM PRATENSE L. A weed, well established around the
Life Saving Stations. J. Dwight, Jr. (D. p. 12) states that this
species has "been cultivated near the stations." H. T. Giissow ;
H. St. John, no. 1,262 (H).

Fl. — August and September.

T. REPENS L. Dry sand flats and pond shores. An anonymous
writer who visited Sable Island in 1851 says, " In the neighbourhood
of the chief residence, where white clover and other grasses have been
sown, so luxuriant is the yield that over 100 tons of hay are made
annually" (Leisure Hour, xxx. 433, 1881).

J. Dwight, Jr., (D. p. 12) in referring to this species says, "Man's
influence has been at work on the island for so many centuries that
it is almost impossible to draw the line between indigenous species,
if such there be, and those artificially introduced." This species
grows particularly on the dry sands near the Life Saving Stations
and along the shores of the adjacent ponds where the cattle and the
domesticated ponies browse continually, and because of this it seemed
to the writer that the White Clover was one of the species that was
obviously introduced. Listed by J. Macoun (also as " white clover, "
M. p. 218A); H. St. John, no. 1,263 (H).

FL, Fr.— August.

T. HYBRIDUM L. A garden weed. Listed by J. 'Macoun; H. St.
John, no. 1,264 (H).
FL, Fr. — September.

Lathyrus maritimus (L.) Bigel. Very abundant all over the
island, and an able ally of the Sand Grass in its perpetual defensive

ST. JOHN: SABLE ISLAND. 81

against the eroding forces that threaten to destroy the island. In
1633 John Rose reported, "store of wild peas" (Winthrop, John: His-
tory of New England from 1630 to 1 649, ed. James Savage i. 162, 1825).
Writing in 1753 Andrew Le Mercier (L) says of the island, "It
hath abundance of Wild or Beach Pease, which fatten the cattle very
well." In 1766 and 1767 Joseph Frederick Wallet Des Banes
found "wild pease" (Atlantic Neptune i. 68, 1777). Seth Coleman
in 1801 found the "wild Pea" (Kept, on Canadian Archives 91,1895).
Joseph Howe, in 1851, "was agreeably surprised to find it covered,
for nearly its whole length of five and twenty miles, with natural
grass and wild peas" (Append, to Journ. cf House of Assembly of
N. S. 161, 1851). The "wild pea" is mentioned by J. B. Gilpin,
1858 (G. p. 18). J. C. Tache mentions the abundance of the"Len-
tille du Canada, qu'on nomme ici 'pois sauvages'" (T. p. 29).
J. Dwight, Jr. (D. p. 13) lists this with Gnaphalium sp. and calls
them both weeds! Macoun says (M. p. 215A), "This one species
of grass [Ammophila arenaria] with the wild pea (Lathyrus maritimus)
constitutes the bulk of the wild hay cut for winter fodder and the
winter pasturage of the wild horses." Listed by J. Macoun and
H. T. Gussow. H. St. John, nos. 1,265 and 1, 266 (H).
FL, Fr. — August.

[L. PALUSTRIS L. of J. Macoun's and H. T. Gussow's list is of the
var. macranthus.]

L. palustris L., var. macranthus (T. G. White) Fernald. See
Rhodora, xiii. 50 (1911). Abundant at the swampy or sandy borders
of the fresh-water ponds. J. Macoun (C. nos. 21,165 and 21,195);
H. T. Gussow (E); H. St. John, nos. 1,267 and 1,268 (H).

FL, Fr. — August and September.

[L. PALUSTRIS L., var. MYRTIFOLIUS (Muhl.) Gray of J. Macoun's
list is of the var. macranthus.]

L. palustris L., var. retusus Fernald & St. John, n. var., sub-
pilosus, caule tenue paulo alato, stipulis lanceolatis semisagittatis
8-18 mm. longis, foliolis 2-3-jugis spatulatis vel cuneato-ellipticis
mucronatis retusis 2-4.5 cm. longis, 0.6-1.6 cm. latis, cirrhis 2-4-
fidis, 4-floris, 1.2—1.6 cm. longis, legumine 4 cm. longo.

Somewhat pilose throughout: the stem slender, slightly winged:
stipules lanceolate, semisagittate, 8-18 mm. long: leaflets of 2 or 3
pairs, spatulate or cuneate-elliptic, mucronate, retuse, 2-4.5 cm.
long, 0.6-1.6 cm. wide: tendrils well developed, 2-4-parted: flowers
4 in number, 1.2-1.6 cm. in length: the pod 4 cm. long.

82 PROCEEDINGS: BOSTON SOCIETY' NATURAL HISTORY.

NOVA SCOTIA: edge of fresh-water pond, Sable Island, Aug. 21,
1913, Harold St. John, no. 1,271 (TYPE in Gray Herb.).

This endemic variety differs from all the other known varieties
of Lathyrus palustris in having the leaves broadest near the tip, and
tapering gradually to a cuneate base.

FL, Fr. — August.

EMPETRACEAE.

Empetrum nigrum L. Very abundant on the low undulating
dunes and sheltered slopes in the more stable parts of the island.
The juicy, attractively colored, but unpleasantly flavored berries
form a part of the food of the birds that visit the island, especially
the Curlews. They are sometimes used by the residents of the is-
land in the manufacture of a slightly alcoholic drink. The berries
are crushed, then after the addition of sugar or molasses the juice is
put in a dark air-tight receptacle until the fermentation takes place.
J. Dwight, Jr. (D. pp. 9 & 12) noticed that a large part of the island
"is carpeted with the evergreen Crowberry (Empetrwnnigrumlj.)."
J. Macoun also comments upon its abundance (M. p. 2 15 A, 216 A
& 218A). It is listed by H. T. Giissow. H. St. John, nos. 1,269 and
1,270 (H).

Fr. — August and September.

AQUIFOLIACEAE.

Ilex verticillata (L.) Gray. Occasional on the dry slopes of
shifting dunes. H. St. John, no. 2,041 (H).
Not observed in flower or fruit.

ACERACEAE.

ACER PLATANOIDES L. One sapling surviving at Life Saving
Station, No. 3. In 1901 in the large planting there were 500 of these
trees set out. H. St. John, no. 1,272 (H).

RHAMNACEAE.

RHAMNUS FRANGULA L. A few ragged shrubs still surviving at
Gourdeau Park. None of them exceed 2 feet in height. In 1901
there were 100 bushes of this set out. H. St. John, no. 1,273 (H).

MALVACEAE.

[J. B. Gilpin (G. p. 18-9) in 1858 devotes a single paragraph to
the flora, beginning with, "A Botanist would give a scientific list of

ST. JOHN: SABLE ISLAND. 83

thirty or forty varieties of shrubs and plants." He mentions ten
species, closing with the phrase, "and as Autumn heats yellow the
luxuriant green, the tall, mallow, gay golden rods and wild China-
asters are swept by the heaving gales." J. C. Tache (T. p. 28-9)
in 1885 refers to eight of these ten species in a passage which is noth-
ing but a free translation from Gilpin. For instance Tache begins
with, "La Flore des Sablons n'a point ete completement catalogued
on a dit qu'un botaniste pourrait y observer trente a quarante especes
ou varietes; * * * * Ces deux plantes fourrageres, auxquelles
s'adjoignent la verge d'or, la mauve et des autres especes * * * '
Tache, it will be seen has taken Gilpin's "tall, mallow," literally
and records it definitely as, "la mauve." Gilpin's sentence, as it
stands, is inconsistent, for if there were no comma after "tall, "it
would be clear that he wished to record some tall mallow. As it is,
he seems to be setting off by commas a series of adjectives ail quali-
fying "golden rods," and we may perhaps interpret "mallow" as
a misprint for "mellow." No one of the four naturalists to visit
Sable Island has found anything that could be called or mistaken
for a "tall, mallow." Consequently, it seems better to drop this
record as a probable error.]

GUTTIFERAE.

Hypericum boreale (Britton) Bicknell. Abundant in the wet
dune hollows. J. Macoun (C. no. 21,158). Listed by H. T. Gussow.
H. St. John, nos. 1,274 and 1,275 (H).

FL, Fr— August.

[H. MUTILUM L. of J. Macouri's list is H. boreale.]

H. virginicum L. Occasional in the wet dune hollows and cran-
berry bogs. J. Macoun (C. no. 21,157); listed by H. T. Gussow;
H. St. John, no. 1,276 (H).

FL — July and August.

VIOLACEAE.

Viola septentrionalis Greene. Collected only by H. S. Glaze-
brook, the Station Master of Life Saving Station No. 3.
FL — June. .

[V. OBLIOUA Hill (Blue Violets) is recorded by J. Dwight, Jr.
(D. p. 13). A search in the Herbarium of the New York Botanical

84 PROCEEDINGS: BOSTON SOCIETY NATURAL HISTORY.

Garden failed to reveal this specimen. It probably is to be re-
garded as V. septentrionalis.]

V. lanceolata L. Abundant in the wet dune hollows. [Recorded
by J. Dwight, Jr. (D. p. 13), but the specimens on which this is
based are V. primulifolia.] Listed by H. T. Gussow. H. St. John,
no. 1,277 (H).

Fl. — June and July. Fr. — August.

V. primulifolia L. Rare, on dry sandy banks. Collected by
J. Dwight, Jr.; H. St. John, no. 1,278 (H).
Fl. — June to August.

V. pallens (Banks) Brainerd. Common in the wet dune hollows,
and along the swampy borders of the fresh-water ponds. H. Si.
John, nos. 1,279, 1,280, and 1,281 (H).

Fr. — August and September.

[V. BLANDA Willd. is listed by H. T. Gussow. The plant on which
the record is based proves to be V. incognita, var. Forbesii.]

V. incognita Brainerd, var. Forbesii Brainerd. See Bull. Torr.
Bot. Cl. xxxviii. 8 (1911). Found only by //. T. Gussow (E); and
H. S. Glazebrook (H).

Fl. — June. Fr. — September.

ONAGRACEAE.

Epilobium molle Torr., var. sabulonense Fernald. Rbodora,
xx. 31 (1918). Quoting from the original publication "habitu foliis-
que ut apud f ormam typicam ; caulibus f oliisque dense cinereo-pilosis,
pilis adpressis incurvatis; capsulis cinereo-pilosis valde glandulosis.

"Habit and foliage as in the typical form: stems and leaves densely
cinereous-pilose with appressed incurved hairs: capsules cinereous-
pilose, copiously glandular. ' '

NOVA SCOTIA: swampy edge of fresh-water pond at Life Saving
Station No. 3, Sable Island, Sept. 9, 1913, Harold St. John, no. 1,282
(TYPE in Gray Herb.) ; rare, in a bog at No. 3 Station, Sable Island,
(1899) John Macoun (C. no. 21,189).

Flt Fr.— September.

"The only Epilobium known from Sable Island, 100 miles off the
coast of Nova Scotia, is a plant collected in 1899 by Prof. John Mac-
oun and in 1913 secured in quantity by Dr. Harold St. John; and from

ST. JOHN: SABLE ISLAND. 85

the observations of both these explorers apparently the only member
of the genus on the island. The plant in habit, outline of foliage, and
large flowers, as well as in the characters of its calyx and seeds, ex-
actly matches the common E. molle Torr. of the mainland, while the
capsules have the peculiar glandular pubescence which is found upon
the capsules of E. molle, but in the Sable Island plant much more
highly developed than is common in mainland specimens. The
stems and the leaves of the Sable Island plant, however, are
densely cinereous with appressed and incurved hairs, exactly as
in E. densum Raf.; E. molle having the stems, leaves, etc., densely
covered with fine, straight conspicuously spreading pubescence.

"This Sable Island plant with the technical characters of calyx, pet-
als, etc., and the glandular pubescence of the capsule, and the exact
habit and leaf-outline of E. molle, but with the pubescence of the
leaves and stems exactly as in E. densum would, if found upon the main-
land, be promptly called a hybrid between those two species. But
neither of the species has been detected on Sable Island, a region of
sufficiently limited area to give assurance that the extended explor-
ations of Macoun in 1899, of Giissow in 1911, and of St. John in 1913,
when the latter explorer spent four weeks in an intensive study of the
flora, would have brought to light any other existing member of the
genus. Upon Sable Island, then, this plant, combining the characters
of two ordinarily distinct species of the mainland, cannot be accepted
as a hybrid, at least of modern origin. There is, moreover, reason to
believe that the flora of Sable Island reached that area during the
late Pleistocene and has been isolated from the mainland 'flora since
that time. However long this period may have been, whether es-
timated by thousands or tens of thousands of years, it has certainly
been a sufficient time for the Sable Island plant to have become thor-
oughly fixed in its characters, and even if, many thousands of years
ago, it may have originated as a hybrid, it has upon Sable Island in-
tensified its characters and become a thoroughly constant plant.

"The case of this plant is exactly comparable with that of E. densum,
\ar.nesophilum * * * the peculiar variant of E. densum found upon New-
foundland and the Magdalen Islands, where no true E. densum is
found, but in those areas suggesting that it might have originated in
the long-distant past by the hybridization of E. densum of the South
and E. palustre of the North. Whether these plants have had such
an origin is entirely problematical and it may as confidently be argued

86 PROCEEDINGS: BOSTON SOCIETY NATURAL HISTORY.

that they are local developments, which by insular isolation have be-
come fixed entities, and are really the result of natural selection.
Whatever the origin of these plants may be, they are now absolutely
definite and consistent."1

[E. MOLLE Torr., of Macoun' s list is based on one of the plants cit-
ed above as E. molle, var. sabuloneiwe.]

Oenothera cruciata Nutt. Occasional on the slopes of the dry
dunes. J. Macoun (C. no. 21,193 in part); H. St. John, no. 1,283
(H).

Fl. — July and August. Fr. — August and September.

[O. OAKESIANA Robbins. The material so reported by J.
Macoun, (C. no. 21,193) is in part 0. cruciata, in part 0. muricata}

O. muricata L. Common on the slopes of the dry dunes. Col-
lected by J. Macoun (C. nos. 78,527, and 21,193 in part); H. St.
John, nos. 1,284 and 1,285 (H).

FL, Fr— August.

HALORAGIDACEAE.

Myriophyllum tenellum Bigel. Very abundant and forming
solid bands submersed or emersed at the borders of the fresh-watei
ponds. Dr. A. H. MacKay in Trans. N. S. Inst. Sci. x. 320 (1900)
mentions specimens found by J. Macoun. Listed by J. Macoun,
and H. T. Giissow. H. St. John, nos. 1,287, and 1,288 (H).

Fl. — July and August. Fr. — September.

Hippuris vulgaris L. In the swampy margins of a few of the
larger and more permanent fresh-water ponds. Listed by J. Ma-
coun; and H. T. Giissow. H. St. John, no. 1,289 (H).

Fl., Fr. — August.

UMBELLIFERAE.

Ligusticum scothicum L. One single clump observed near the
brackish margin of Wallace Lake. H. St. John, no. 1,290 (H).

FL, Fr. — August.

Coelopleurum lucidum (L.) Fernald. (C. actaeifolium (Michx.)
C. & R.) Infrequent on the slopes of the turf-covered dunes. Listed
by J. Macoun; and H. T. Giissow. H. St. John, nos. 1,291, 1,292,
and 1,293 (H).

FL, Fr.— September.

1 Fernald, I. c. 30-31.

ST. JOHN: SABLE ISLAND. 87

PASTINACA SATIVA L. Planted in the garden of the East End
Lighthouse. H. St. John, no. 1,294 (H).
Fr. — September.

DAUCUS CAROTA L. A weed in the garden at Life Saving Station
No. 4. H. St. John, no. 1,295 (H).
FL— September.

CORNACEAE.

Gornus canadensis L. This species has been observed and col-
lected only by J. Dwight, Jr. (D. pp. 13 and 42).

ERICACEAE.

CALLUNA VULGARIS (L.) Hull. Adventive but not well established,
growing on the sheltered turf-covered slopes of the dunes. When
J. Macoun visited Sable Island in 1899, he did not find Calluna.
H. T. Gussow in 1911 collected it and noted, "found about J^ mile
west of Marconi Station, 3 solitary clumps and 1 solitary clump 10
miles East, close to No. 3 Station." In 1913, during my visit, only
two clumps were observed, both being in Gourdeau Park, the locality
near the Marconi Station mentioned by Gussow. It will be noticed
that the first records of Calluna on the island come after the year
1901, when the large forestry planting was done. The trees were in
greater part imported from a French nursery and Mr. R. J. Bouteil-
lier, at that time Superintendent of the island, tells me that al-
though Calluna was not included in the list of imported plants, it
sprang up soon after near them, and was in all probability used for,
or carried in, the protective packing around the trees. Collected
by H. T. Gussow (E); and H. St. John, no. 1,296 (H).

FL — August and September.

Vaccinium pennsylvanicum Lam. Very abundant on the low
turf -covered dunes and undulating barrens. In 1766 and 1767, J.
F. W. Des Banes observed "blueberries— &c., in their season"
(Atlantic Neptune, i. 68, 1777). J. B. Gilpin writing in 1858 re-
marks that "blueberries * * * are in abundance" (G. p. 18).
J. C. Tache mentions, " On y trouve, en fait des fruits, * * * les
bluets" (T. p. 29). J. Dwight in 1895 reports this species in blossom
the second week of June (D. pp. 13 and 42). Listed by J. Macoun
(also M. p. 218A); and H. T. Gussow. H. St. John, no. 1,297 (H).

FL — June. Fr. — September.

88 PROCEEDINGS: BOSTON SOCIETY NATURAL HISTORY.

V. macrocarpon Ait. Very abundant in most of the wet dune
hollows. The cranberries form the only crop produced on the island
that is of any importance. From 50 to 200 barrels are picked and
exported every year. J. F. W. Des Bar res reported that in 1766
and 1767 he found, "hollows and ponds of fresh-water, the skirts
of which abound with cranberries the whole year" (Atlantic Nep-
tune, i. 68, 1777). Joseph Howe in 1851 found that "Cranberries
of Large size, and fine flavour, grow in abundance on Sable Island.
A few barrels of these are generally picked in the autumn, but the
cranberry, as a source of income, or a means of employment, has
scarcely ever been thought of by our people" (Append, to Journ.
of House of Assembly, Prov. of N. S. 161, 1851). J. B. Gilpin
recorded in 1858 that "cranberries are in abundance (G. p. 18).
J. C. Tache mentions that, "on y trouve, en fait des fruits, *
les atocas." "Les atocas y abondent et constituent un objet
d 'exportation, dont la valeur annuelle s'e*l£ve a quelques cen-
taines de piastres," (T. p. 29). J. Dwight, Jr. (D. p. 13) speaks of
the abundance of "Cranberries (Schollera macrocarpa (Ait.))."
They are also included in the lists of J. Macoun (also M. p. 21 5 A
& 216A); and H. T. Gussow. H. St. John, no 1,298 (H).

Fr. — August and September.

[V. OXYCOCCUS L. The only record for this species is by Capt.
Fawson in his report, October 15, 1801 (see Murdoch, Beamish:
Hist, of Nova-Scotia ii. 6, 1866), where he refers to it by the common
name, " bogberries. " He mentions both "bogberries" and "cran-
berries," so he is apparently intending to distinguish between the
two, but as there are no other records of the former from the island
and no specimens, this record needs confirmation.]

PRIMULACEAE.

Lysimachia terrestris (L.) B. S. P. Occasional in the wet dune
hollows. Listed by J. Macoun; and H. T. Gussow. H. St. John,
nos. 1,299, and 1,300 (H).

Fl. — August.

Trientalis borealis Raf. (T. americana (Pers). Pursh). Com-
mon on the turf-covered dunes and barrens. Listed by J. Macoun.
H. St. John, nos. 1,301 and 1,302 (H); H. S. Glazebrook (H).

FL— June.

ST. JOHN: SABLE ISLAND. 89

Centunculus minimus L. Locally found on bare sand flats
which are occasionally flooded by the sea. J. Macoun (C. no. 22,544) ;
H. St. John, no. 1,303 (H).

FL, Fr. — August.

GENTIANACEAE.

[SABBATIA CHLOROIDES Pursh. "The chief annual is of southern
extraction." The material on which this record of J. Macoun' s
(M. p. 2 18 A) is based is Centaurium umbellatum.]

Bartonia iodandra Robinson, var. sabulonensis Fernald, n.
var., a forma typica recedit floribus numerosis (4-30), ramibus saepe
dichotomis, pedunculis valde clavatis, calyce valde fisso lobis pler-
umque distinctis.

Differing from the typical form in its more numerous (4-30)
flowers; the branches often dichotomous; peduncles more clavate;
calyx deeply cleft, the lobes mostly distinct.

NOVA SCOTIA: swampy edges of fresh ponds, Sable Island, August
30 and September 12, 1913, H. St. John, nos. 1,306, 1,307 (TYPE in
Gray Herb.).

FL — August and September. Fr. — September.

In typical Bartonia iodandra of Newfoundland and Cape Breton
the 1-7-flowered plants have simple branches and the peduncles are
more filiform. The calyx in all the Newfoundland and Cape Breton
material (examined from eight regions) is cleft only % to ^ to the
base, the tube being 1-2 mm long and nerveless. The Sable Island
plant with usually more numerous flowers on often forking branches
rarely has a definite calyx-tube, most of the material showing the
calyx with lobes distinct essentially to the base, the margins of the
outer lobes decurrent down the peduncle. In this character the
Sable Island plant approaches the more southern B. virginica (L.)
B S P. and B. paniculata (Michx.) Robinson, in both of which the
calyx-lobes are essentially distinct. In those more southern yellow-
ish-stemmed plants, however, the yellowish-green calyx-lobes and
the usually yellowish leaves are firm and subulate and the yellow
corolla is at most 5 mm. long. The Sable Island plant has the leaves
scattered or alternate as in B. paniculata but, like those of B. iodandra,
they are ovate to oblong-lanceolate, bluntish and purple. The stem
likewise is purple, the calyx-lobes flat and thin, ovate to oblong-
lanceolate, and the mature petaloid whitish corolla 5-6 mm. long, all
characters of B. iodandra. The anthers of B. iodandra are generally

90 PROCEEDINGS: BOSTON SOCIETY NATURAL HISTORY.

purple though sometimes becoming yellowish; those of var. sabulo-
nensis at first purple, but in maturity, becoming yellow like those of
the more southern species. On Newfoundland and Cape Breton
B. iodandra is in flower through August, but the Sable Island plant
is some weeks later, the material collected August 30, being only in
bud.

Combining the color, foliage, and most of the flower-characters
of B. wdandra with the habit and more deeply cleft calyx of B.
paniculata, the Sable Island plant presents an interesting transition.
B. paniculata is characteristic of the Coastal Plain from Louisiana
to southeastern Massachusetts, rarely extending to southernmost
Maine. B. iodandra in typical development is confined to Cape
Breton and Newfoundland; and the transitional plant to the isolated
Sable Island, one of the last remnants of the ancient continental
shelf which extended from southern New England to the Newfound-
land banks. It would thus seem probable that the widely distrib-
uted southern B. paniculata originally spread northward on the
continental shelf, becoming modified toward the North, the Sable
Island plant still retaining some distinctive paracw/ata-characters,
which have disappeared from the more northern and further isolated
B. iodandra of Cape Breton and Newfoundland.

Menyanthes trifoliata L. "Quite rare, in ponds at No. 3 sta-
tion." Found only by J. Macoun (C. no. 22,541).

Centaurium umbellatum Gilib. Very common in the wet
dune hollows, and by the wet sandy borders of the fresh-water ponds.
Not near the Life Saving Stations or the Lighthouses and not giving
any indication of being introduced. This species has been known
in North America for a long time, but it has universally been treated
in botanical manuals as an introduced plant. This seems to be
the true explanation in the greater number of the cases, such as the
record from Concord, Massachusetts,1 A. W. Hosmer reporting it "found
at Concord in 1890, not seen since." The species is occasional
in the State of Michigan, but there it also seems to be an introduction.

There is, however, a station near Oswego, New York, which has
been known for nearly a hundred years. In 1833 Beck reported,2

*As Erythraea Centaurium Pers., Rhodora i. 224 (1899).
2As Erythraea Centaurium Pers., Beck, L. C.: Bot. of N. and Middle States,
242 (1833).

ST. JOHN: SABLE ISLAND. 91

" I have specimens of this plant which were found near Oswego, N. Y.,
by the Rev. David Brown of Lockport. It is apparently indigenous. "
In 1865, J. A. Paine commented,1 "Meadows and pastures, Oswego,
two miles northward near the Lake shore; two or three miles south
of the city and east of the river, borders of woods. Local." The
evidence presented by the collectors and the field observers would
certainly tend to indicate that in this case, at least, the plant was a
native. In this connection the form of the successive records of
the species from Sable Island is illuminating. The plant seems first to
have been recorded from Sable Island (under the name E[RYTHRAEA]
CENTAURIUM Pers.) in Macoun's Catalogue, ii. 342 (1890) : " Sandy
wastes on Sable Island off the coast of Nova Scotia. Collected July,
1870. (Mrs. Almond). " This record now appears in Gray's Manual2 as
"Waste grounds, N. S.;" in Britton and Brown's Illustrated Flora,3
"In waste places, Nova Scotia — Naturalized from Europe." Now
"sandy wastes" on Sable Island are not "waste places;" they are in
the strictest sense the sand dunes, and not a habitat in which the
plants could be assumed to be introduced.

Collected by J. Macoun (C. no. 22,543); and by H. T. Gussow
(E); H. St. John, nos. 1,304, and 1,305 (H).

Fl. — August and September. Fr. — September.

CONVOLVULACEAE.

Convolvulus sepium L. Abundant on the slopes of the dry
dunes, where the stems intertwine for great distances between the
culms of Ammophila and Lathyrus maritimus, helping in the formation
of the dense tangles in the more sheltered places. Listed by J.
Macoun. H. St. John, nos. 1,359 and 1,360 (H).

FL, Fr. — September.

BORAGINACEAE.

LAPPULA ECHINATA Gilib. A single adventive specimen found
near the Main Life Saving Station. H. St. John, no. 1,308 (H).
FL— August.

*As Erythraea Cenfaurium Pers. Paine, J. A.: Cat. of PI. Found inOneida
Co., and Vicinity, 64 (116) (1865).

2Robinson, B. L., and Fernald, M. L.: Gray's Manual, ed. 7, 656 (1908).

3As Centaurium Centaurium (L.) W. F. Wight, Britton and Brown: 111.
FL, ed. 2, iii. 2 (1913).

92 PROCEEDINGS: BOSTON SOCIETY NATURAL HISTORY.

LABIATAE.

Teucrium canadense L., var. littorale (Bicknell) Fernald.
Observed only on the turfy shores of the fresh-water ponds near the
eastern end of Wallace Lake. H. St. John, no. 1,309 (H).

Fl. — September.

GALEOPSIS TETRAHIT L., var. BIFIDA (Boenn.) Lejeune & Court-
ois. A weed at the Main Life Saving Station. H. St. John, no.
1,310 (H),

FL, Fr. — September.

[LYCOPUS UNIFLORUS Michx. Listed by J. Macoun and H. T.
Giissow. These collections are undoubtedly of the following variety.]

Lycopus uniflorus Michx., var. ovatus Fernald & St. John, n.
var., foliis sessilibus vel brevi-petiolatis ovato-lanceolatis vel del-
toideo-ovatis grosse serratis, dentibus 4-6 acris prorsum vergentibus.

Leaves sessile or short petioled, ovate-lanceolate or deltoid-ovate,
coarsely serrate with 4-6 sharp teeth which point directly forward.

NOVA SCOTIA: wet dune hollow, Sable Island, August 15, 1913,
H. St. John, no. 1,311 (TYPE in Gray Herb.); Canso, August 17,
1900, J. Fowler, in part (H). OREGON: Sullivan's Gulch, Portland,
July 14, 1902, E. P. Sheldon, no. 10,888 (H).

Mentha arvensis L. Observed only on turfy knolls by the shore
of the fresh-water ponds at the eastern end of Wallace Lake. H.
St. John, nos. 1,312 and 1,313 (H).

FL — September.

[M. CANADENSIS L. of J. Macoun's list is probably the preceding,
M . arvensis]

SOLANACEAE.

SOLANUM NIGRUM L. A weed thoroughly established in the gardens
of the Main Life Saving Station. Listed by J. Macoun. H. T.
Giissow (E); H. St. John, no. 1,314 (H).

FL — August and September. Fr. — September.

LYCIUM EUROPAEUM L. A few bushes planted and surviving in
the garden at Life Saving Station No. 3. H. 'St. John, no. 1,315 (H).

SCROPHULARIACEAE.

Limosella subulata Ives. See Fernald, Rhodora, xx. 164 (1918).
Abundant on the brackish beach of, and sand flats near Wallace
Lake. Listed by J. Macoun. H. St. John, no. 1,316 (H).

FL, Fr.— August.

ST. JOHN: SABLE ISLAND. 93

Agalinis paupercula (Gray) Britton, var. neoscotica Fennel 1 &
St. John, n. comb., Gerardia neoscotica Greene, Leaflets of Bot. Ob-
serv. and Grit. ii. 106-7 (1910). Greene's type, collected by himself
at Middleton, Nova Scotia, has been examined by Dr. Pennell and
myself and we feel that it and the Sable Island plant belong in the
same category. The var. neoscotica differs from A. paupercula in
being only 1-2.5 dm. in height, in having the leaves broader, being
broadly linear, 1-3 cm. long and 1.5-4.5 mm. wide; the lobes of the
calyx are unusually long, 3-8 mm. and of unequal length; the corolla
lobes are scarcely at all spreading; the anther sacs are glabrous.

Common in the wet dune hollows. J. Macoun (C. no. 22,576);
H. St. John, nos. 1,317 and 1,318 (H).

FL, Fr. — August.

[GERARDIA PAUPERCULA (Gray) Britton of J. Macoun's list is
Agalinis paupercula, var. neoscotica.]

Euphrasia purpurea Reeks, var. Randii (Robinson) Fernald
& Wiegand. Common in the boggy dune hollows. H. St. John,
no. 1,319 (H).

FL, Fr. — August.

Euphrasia americana Wettst. Listed by H. T. Gussow.

Rhinanthus Crista-galli L. Common on the drier, turf-covered
dunes. Collected by J. Macoun (C. no. 22,577); H. T. Gussow (E);
H. St. John, no. 1,320 (H).

FL — July. Fr. — July and August.

[R. OBLONGIFOLIUS Fernald of J. Macoun's list is R. Crista-galli
L.]

LENTIBULARIACEAE^

Utricularia cornuta Michx. Found only by J. Macoun (C. no.

22,574).
FL— July.

PLANTAGINACEAE.

PLANTAGO MAJOR L. Listed by H. T. Gussow.

P. major L., var. intermedia (Gilib.) Dene. Brackish beaches
of Wallace Lake. Listed by J. Macoun. H. St. John, no. 1,321
(H).

FL, Fr.— August.

94 PROCEEDINGS: BOSTON SOCIETY NATURAL HISTORY.

P. decipiens Barneoud. Common on the brackish beaches of
Wallace Lake and the brackish ponds. Listed by J. Macoun; and
H. T. Gussow. H. St. John, no. 1,322 (H).

Fly Fr. — August.

RUBIACEAE.

Galium trifidum L. Very common in the wet dune hollows and
along the swampy borders of the fresh-water ponds. J. Macoun
(C. no. 81,150); H. T. Gussow (E); H. St. John, no. 1,324 (H).

FL, Fr. — August and September. •

[G. TINCTORIUM L., of J. Macoun and H. T. Gussow is G. trifi-
dum.]

G. Clayton! Michx. In the wet dune hollows. H. St. John, no.
1,323 (H).
FL, Fr. — August.

Mitchella repens L. Uncommon and local, on turf-covered
dunes. J. Dwight, Jr., records this (D. p. 13). Listed by J. Ma-
coun; and H. T. Gussow. H. St. John, no. 1,325 (H).

Fr. — August.

CAPRIFOLIACEAE.

Lonicera caerulea L., var. calvescens Fernald & Wiegand, Rho-
dora, xii. 210 (1910). On the turf-covered dunes. Collected by
J. Dwight, Jr.; and J. Macoun (C. no. 22,491).

Not observed in flower or fruit.

Linnaea borealis L., var. americana (Forbes) Render. Creep-
ing between the stems of the prostrate Junipers and Empetrum where
they form a thick turf on the low dunes. Listed by /. Macoun;
and H. T. Gussow. H. St. John, no. 1,326 (H).

Not observed in flower or fruit.

Viburnum cassinoides L. Occasional on the turf-covered dunes.
J. B. Gilpin wrote in 1858 (G. p. 18), "The usual shrubs are dwarf t
to a few inches; * * * [the] low with-wood would not afford a
riding cane." Listed by J. Macoun; and H. T. Gussow. H. St.
John, nos. 1,327 and 1,328 (H).

Not observed in flower or fruit.

ST. JOHN: SABLE ISLAND. 95

CAMPANULACEAE.

Lobelia Dortmanna L. Abundant along the wet margins of the
fresh-water ponds. Listed by J. Macoun. H. St. John, no. 1,329
(H).

Fl, Fr.— August.

COMPOSITAE.

Solidago sempervirens L. Common in all of the drier parts of
the island, especially so along the North, and the South Ridge, which
are ranges of dunes close to and parallel with the sea beaches. J. B.
Gilpin in 1858 (G. p. 19) remarked upon the "gay golden rods."
J. C. Tache mentions "la verge d'or" (T. p. 29). Collected by
J. Macoun (C. no. 22,535); and H. T. Gussow (E); H. St. John,
nos. 1,330-1,334 (H).

Fl. — September.

Aster novi-belgii L. Very abundant on the dry dunes, or even
at the swampy borders of the fresh-water ponds. J. B. Gilpin (G.
pp. 18-9) in 1858 noted, " As autumn heats yellow the luxuriant green,
the tall, mallow, gay golden rods and wild China-asters are swept
by the heaving gales." Collected by J. Macoun (C. no. 22,502);
H. T. Gussow (E); H. St. John, nos. 1,335-1,339 (H).

Fl. — Middle of August to September.

A. novi-belgii L., var. litoreus Gray. Occasional at the edge" of
the brackish ponds. J. Macoun (C. no. 22,502); H. St. John, no.
1,340 (H).

[ANAPHALIS MARGARITACEA (L.) B. & H. of J. Macoun and pre-
sumably of H. T. Gussow is the following var. subalpina.]

Anaphalis margaritacea (L.) B. & H., var. subalpina Gray.
Very common on the dry dunes and barrens. J. Macoun (C. no.
22,515); H. St. John, no. 1,341 (H).

FL— August.

Gnaphalium obtusifolium L. (G. polycephalum Michx.)
Abundant on the dry dunes and barrens. J. D wight's mention
(D. p. 13) of "Gnaphalium sp?" which he dubs a weed should prob-
ably be referred here. Listed by J. Macoun. H. T. Gussow (E);
H. St. John, nos. 1,342 and 1,343 (H).

FL, Fr. — August and September.

96 PROCEEDINGS: BOSTON SOCIETY NATURAL HISTORY.

G. ULIGINOSUM L. A weed well established at the Main Life
Saving Station. Listed by J. Macoun. H. St. John, no. 1,344 (H).
FL, Fr. — August.

RTJDBECKIA HIRTA L. A weed collected by J. Macoun (C. no.
23,439) in 1899 but not observed by the subsequent botanical col-
lectors.

FL — August.

Bidens frondosa L. Listed by J. Macoun.

B. connata Muhl., var. petiolata (Nutt.) Farwell. See Fernald,
Rhodora, x. 200 (1908). Infrequent, at the borders of fresh-water
ponds. H. T. Gussow (E); H. St. John, no. 1,345 (H).

FL, Fr. — September.

[B. CERNUA L. of H. T. Gussow is B. connata, var. petiolata.]

[ACHILLEA MILLEFOLIUM L. is listed by J. Macoun-, and H. T.
Gussow. The material is probably identical with that collected by
the author and cited under the following, A. lanulosa.}

Achillea lanulosa Nutt. Very abundant on the dry dunes and
barrens. H. St. John, no. 1,346 (H).
FL — August.

ANTHEMIS COTULA L. Thoroughly established at the Main Life
Saving Station. Listed by J. Macoun; H. T. Gussow. H. St.
John, no. 1,347 (H).

FL, Fr. — August.

CHRYSANTHEMUM LEUCANTHEMUM L., var. PINNATIFIDUM Lecoq
& Lamotte. A weed at the Main Life Saving Station. H. St. John,
no. 1,348 (H).

FL — August.

Senecio Pseudo- Arnica Less. Infrequent in the gulches near the
sea and at the top of the beaches. Listed by J. Macoun; and H. T.
Gussow. H. St. John, no. 1,349 (H).

FL, Fr. — August.

CIRSIUM ARVENSE (L.) Scop. A weed thoroughly established near
the Life Saving Stations and spreading. Listed by J. Macoun. H.
T. Gussow (E); H. St. John, no. 1,350 (H).

FL, Fr. — August and September.

ST. JOHN: SABLE ISLAND. 97

CICHORIUM INTYBUS L. A weed at the Main Life Saving Station.
Only one plant seen. H. St. John, no. 1,351 (H).
Fr. — September.

LEONTODON AUTUMNALIS L. Thoroughly established near the
Life Saving Stations. Listed by J. Macoun (also mentioned, "fall
dandelion" M. p. 218A); and H. T. Gussow. H. St. John, no. 1,352
(H).

Fl, Fr.— August.

TARAXACUM OFFICINALE Weber. A weed in the garden at the
Main Life Saving Station. Listed by J. Macoun. H. St. John,
no. 1,353 (H).

FL, Fr.— August.

SONCHUS ASPER (L.) Hill. A weed at the Main Life Saving Sta-
tion. H. St. John, no. 1,354 (H).
FL, Fr.— August.

Prenanthes trifoliolata (Cass.) Fernald. Occasional on all
the drier parts of the island. Collected by J. Macoun (C. no. 22,522);
H. T. Gussow (E); and H. St. John, no. 1,355 (H).

FL, Fr. — August and September.

P. nana (Bigel.) Torr. Infrequent on the turf -covered dunes.
H. St. John,no. 1,356 (H).
FL— August.

Hieracium scabrum Michx., var. leucocaule Fernald & St.
John. Rhodora, xvi. 182 (1914). To the present date this variety
is still an endemic of Sable Island. It occurs scattered over the
barrens between Life Saving Station No. 3 and the East End Light-
house. Collected by J. Macoun (C. no. 22,525); H. T. Gussow (E);
H. St. John, nos. 1,357 and 1,358 (H).

FL, Fr.— September.

[H. CANADENSE Michx. of J. Macoun's list is H. scabrum, var.
leucocaule}

98 PROCEEDINGS: BOSTON SOCIETY NATURAL HISTORY.

LIST OP ABBREVIATIONS.

(C) = Herbarium of the Canadian Geological Survey.

(D) = Dwight, Jonathan, Jr. : The Ipswich Sparrow. Mem. Nuttall
Ornith. Club, ii. 1-56 (1895).

(E) = Herbarium of the Central Experimental Farm, Ottawa, Canada.
(G) = Gilpin, John Bernard: Sable Island. 1-24 (1858).

(H) = Gray Herbarium of Harvard University.

(L) = Le Mercier, Andrew: The Island Sables. Boston Weekly News
Letter. February 8 (1753).

(M) = Macoun, John: Sable Island. Ann. Rep. Can. Geol. Surv. n. s.
xii. 212A-219A (1899).

(P) = Herbarium of the Academy of Natural Sciences of Philadelphia,
Pennsylvania.

(T) = Tache, Jean Charles: Les Sablons, 1-154 (1885).

NEW SPECIES, VARIETIES, AISD FORMS.

Juniperus communis L., var. megistocarpa Fernald & St. John
Juncus pelocarpus Mey., var. sabulonensis St. John
Calopogon puLhellus (Sw.) R. Br. f., latifolius St. John
Polygonum hydropiperoides Michx., var. psilostachyum St. John
Rubus arcuans Fernald & St. John
Lathyrus palustris L., var. retusus Fernald & St. John
Bartonia iodandra Robinson, var. sabulonensis Fernald
Lycopus uniflorus Michx., var. ovatus Fernald & St. John
Agalinis pauper cula (Gray) Britton, var. neoscotica (Greene) Pennell
& St. John.

ST. JOHN: SABLE ISLAND.

99

TABULAR STATEMENT OP FAMILIES, GENERA, SPECIES, VARIETIES,

AND FORMS OF THE NATIVE OR ADVENTIVE FLORA.

Families .

Genera.

ii

i*

Adventive
Species.

Native
Varieties.

Adventive
Varieties.

Native
Forms.

Polypodiaceae

1

i

Osmundaceae

1

i

Lycopodlaceae

1

i

Pinaceae

1

i

1

Typhaceae . .

1

i

Sparganiaceae

1

i

Potamogetonaceae

3

5

2

Gramineae

17

8

9

5

2

Cyperaceae

3

8

5

Erio caulaceae

1

I

Juncaceae

2

3

5

Liliaceae

1

1

Iridaceae

2

2

Orchidaceae

3

4

1

i

Myricaceae

1

1

Polygonaceae

2

2

7

2

2

Chenopodiaceae

2

1

1

1

Caryophyllaceae

7

2

5

2

Portulacaceae

1

1

Nymphaeaceae

1

I

Ranunculaceae

3

3

2

1

Cruciferae

5

1

4

Droseraceae

1

2

Crassulaceae ....

1

1

Rosaceae

7

6

4

Leguminosae

2

1

3

2

Empetraceae . . .

1

1

Aquif oliaceae . .

1

1

Guttiferae

1

2

Violaceae

1

4

1

100 PROCEEDINGS: BOSTON SOCIETY NATURAL HISTORY.

Families.

|

pi

|!

Adventive
Species.

Native
Varieties.

Adventive
Varieties.

Native
Forms.

Onagraceae

2

2

1

Haloragidaceae

2

2

Umbellif erae

3

2

1

Cornaceae

1

1

Ericaceae

2

2

1

Primu laceae

3

3

Gentianaceae

3

2

1

Convolvulaceae

1

1

Boraginaceae

1

1

Labiatae

4

1

2

1

Solanaceae

1

1

Scrophulariaceae

4

3

2

Lentibulariaceae

1

1

Plantaginaceae . . .

1

1

1

1

Rubiaceae

2

3

Caprif oliaceae

3

1

2

Campanulaceae

1

1

Compositae

17

8

8

4

1

Totals

127

101

45

45

6

1

Total of native and adventive
species, varieties and forms
Planted species not included in
preceding table

198
15

Total flora

213

ST. JOHN: SABLE ISLAND.

BIBLIOGRAPHY.

Anonymous: The Graveyard of the Atlantic. All the Year Round, Ixvi.
517-522 (1890).

Anonymous: Sable Island. The Leisure Hour, xxx. 432-434 (1881). The
author was one of the assistants in the Admiralty Survey of the Gulf of St.
Lawrence, and visited Sable Island in 1851.

Bayfield, Capt. H. W. : Report to the Hydrographer of the Navy. Appen-
dix to Journal of House of Assembly, Province of Nova Scotia, no. 24,
167-168 (1851), and no. 8, 78-79 (1852).

Biggar, H. P.: The Early Trading Companies of New France. 1-308
(1901).

Brymner, Douglas: Report on Canadian Archives, pp. xxv-xxvii (1895).

Canadian Forestry Association, Officers of: Tree Planting on Sable
Island. Rod and Gun in Canada, v. 466-470 (1904).

Charlevoix, Pierre Francois Xavier de: Histoire et Description Generate
de la Nouvelle France, 3 vols. (1744).

Coleman, Seth: Report to Sir John Wentworth, Lieutenant Governor of
Nova Scotia. Report on Canadian Archives, 91-92 (1895).

Darby, Joseph: Chart of Sable Island. - Published 8 April (1824), revised
(1829).

Dawson, John William: Acadian Geology, 36-38 (1878).

Des Barres, Joseph Frederick Wallet: The Isle of Sable. Surveyed in
1766 and 1767 to Order of the Right Honourable the Lords Commissioners
of the Admiralty. Atlantic Neptune, i. 68, 2 charts, 12 illustr. (1777
and 1779).

Dwight, Jonathan, Jr.: The Ipswich Sparrow and its Summer Home.
Memoirs of the Nuttall Ornithological Club, no. 2. 1-56, 1 plate (1895).

Gilpin, J[ohn] Bernard: On Introduced Species of Nova Scotia. Trans-
actions of the Nova Scotian Institute of Natural Science, i. (printed ii.)
part 2, 60-68 (1864).

Sable Island, Its Past History, Present Appearance, Natural History, &c.,

including Darby, Joseph: A Description of the Shipwreck of the American
Schooner Arno, Lost on the Island, September 19, 1846, and including
Howe, the Hon. Joseph: Sable Island, A Poem, and including Willis, J.:
Mollusca of Sable Island, so far as ascertained up to 1858, 1-35, 3 illustr.
(1858).

Gosselin, E.: Early French Voyages to Newfoundland. Translation.
Mag. Am. Hist. viii. 286-290 (1882).

Halleck, Charles: The Secrets of Sable Island. Harper's Monthly, xxxiv.
4-19, 10 illustr. (1867).

Howe, John: A Letter to Robert Murray Esqr., Captain of H. M. Ship
Asia. Report on Canadian Archives, 89-90 (1895).

Howe, Joseph: Condition and Past Management of the Humane Establish-
ment at Sable Island, a Report to Lieut, genl. Sir John Harvey, dated
October 21, 1850. Appendix to Journal of House of Assembly, Province
of Nova Scotia, no. 24, 160-166 (1851), and no. 8, 70-76 (1852).

102 :. I^&GEEDINGS: BOSTON SOCIETY NATURAL HISTORY.

Sable Island, a Poem. See Gilpin, J. B.: Sable Island, 31-34 (1858).

Jacombe, F. W. H.: The Problem of Sable Island. Canadian Forestry
Journal, ix. 91-92 (1913).

de Laet, Johannes: Novus Orbis seu Descriptionis Indiae Occidentalis.
ed. 3, 1-690 (1633).

Le Mercier, Rev. Andrew: The Island Sables. To be sold by me the Sub-
criber. The Publick hath here a short description of it for nothing. Bos-
ton Weekly News Letter, February 8 (1753).

Macdonald, Simon D.: Geological Notes. Sable Island. Transactions
of the Nova Scotian Institute of Natural Science, v. part 4, 337-338 (1882).

— Sable Island (continued). Transactions of the Nova Scotian Institute

of Natural Science, vi. part 2, 110-119 (1884).

Sable Island, No. 3. — Its Probable Origin and Submergence. Trans-
actions of the Nova Scotian Institute of Natural Science, vi. part 4, 265-280
(1886).

Macoun, John: Sable Island. Annual Report of the Canadian Geological
Survey, n. s. xii. 212A-219A (1899).

Merriam, C. Hart: Breeding of Passerculus princeps on Sable Island.
Auk, i. 390 (1884).

Montresor, Capt. John: Map of Nova Scotia or Acadia; with the Islands
of Cape Breton and St. John's from Actual Surveys (1768).

Murdoch, Beamish: History of Nova-Scotia, 3 vols. (1865-1867).

Oxley, J. Macdonald: An Ocean Grave- Yard. Scribner's Magazine, i.
603-610, 2 illustr., 1 map (1887).

Historic Aspects of Sable Island. Magazine of American History,

xv. 162-170 (1886).

Patterson, Rev. George: Sable Island: Its History and Phenomena.
Transactions of the Royal Society of Canada, xii. section 2, 3-49, 1 map
(1894).

Supplementary notes on Sable Island. Transactions of the Royal

Society of Canada, second series, iii. section 2, 131-138 (1897).

Ridgway, Robert: The Probable Breeding-place of Passerculus princeps.
Auk, i. 292-293 (1884).

Saunders, William: Experiments in Tree Planting on Sable Island. Re-
port of the Director of the Dominion Experimental Farms, 63-77 (1901).

Reports from Sable Island in 1902. Report of the Director of the

Dominion Experimental Farms, 56-58 (1902).

Sayer, Robert: The North American Pilot for Newfoundland, Labradore,
the Gulf and River St. Lawrence: being a collection of Sixty Accurate
Charts and Plans, drawn from original surveys: taken by James Cook and
Michael Lane, Surveyors, and Joseph Gilbert, and other Officers in the
King's Service (1779).

Scambler, Lieut. Joseph: A Letter to Lieut. Governor, Sir John Wentworth,
written from, His Majesty's Tender Cutter Trepassey, at Sydney, 17th
May, 1800. Report on Canadian Archives, 88-89 (1895).

Scott, Marshall Owen: Changing Aspects of Sable Island. Canadian
Magazine, xviii. 341-349, 5 illustr., 2 charts (1901-1902).

ST. JOHN: SABLE ISLAND. 103

Tache, Jean Charles: Les Sablons (L'lle de Sable) et L'lle Saint Barnabe,

1-154 (1885).
Uniacke, Richard John: The Address of the House of Representatives in

General Assembly: To His Excellency Sir John Wentworth, Lieutenant

Governor of Nova Scotia. 25 June, 1801. Report on Canadian Ar-
chives, 92-93 (1895).
Wentworth, Sir John: A Letter to Seth Coleman of Dartmouth in Nova

Scotia, from Halifax, Nova Scotia, 11 June, 1801. Report on Canadian

Archives, 90-91 (1895).
Observations upon an Establishment proposed to be made on the Isle

of Sable, for the relief of the distressed, and the Preservation of Property.

Also, Statement of Facts relating to the Isle of Sable [1800]. Report on

Canadian Archives, 84-88 (1895).
Willis, J.: Mollusca of Sable Island, so far as ascertained up to 1858. This

is included in Gilpin, J. B. : Sable Island, 35 (1858) .
Winsor, Justin: Narrative and Critical History of America. 8 vols.

(1888-1889).

ST. JOHN— Sable Island.

EXPLANATION OF PLATES.
PLATE 1.

1. Juncus pelocarpus E. Mey., var. sahuLonensis St. John, n. var. Habit
sketch from the type, X 2.

la. Detail of fruit of the type, X 5.
Ib. Seed of the type, X 10.

2. Juncus pelocarpus E. Mey. Detail of fruit after Buchenau, F.: Jun-
caceae. Pflanzenreich, iv. fam. 36, f. 84 E (1906).

3. Polygonum hydropiperoides Michx., var. psilostachyum St. John. Habit
sketch from the type, X 1A>

3a. Detail of inflorescence showing the eciliate ocreolae, from the type,
X 2.

4. Calopogon pulchellus (Sw.) R. Br., forma latifolius St. John. Habit
sketch of the type, X 1A.

5. Polygonum lapathifolium L., var. prostratum Wimmer. Habit sketch
showing the tip half of one of the prostrate branches, from St. John, no.
1,361, Sable Island, Nova Scotia, September 4, 1913, X 1A>

5a. Detail of a spike, X 2.

5b. A single fruit showing the raised anchor-like nerves on the two outer

sepals, from the above, X 5.
5c. A mature achene, from the above, X 5.

6. Lathyrus palustris L., var. retusus Fernald & St. John. Habit view of
several median leaves of the type, X %•

ST. JOHN. — SABLE ISLAND.

PLATE

PROC. BOSTON Soc. NAT. HIST. VOL. 36.

ST. JOHN— Sable Island.

PLATE 2.

7. Rubus arcuans Fernald & St. John. Habit sketch of fruiting branchlet
of the type, X V^

7a. Flowering spray drawn from the specimen St. John, no. 1,259 from

Sable Island, Nova Scotia, X 1A.

7b. Detail of the base of a fruiting pedicel of the type, X 4.
7c. Sketch of a segment of a first-year cane and a single leaf from the type,

X H-
7d. Enlarged view of a portion of a first-year cane of the type, X 2.

8. Epilobium molle Torr., var. sabulonense Fernald. Detail of a portion
of the stem and the base of a leaf showing the appressed pubescence,
from the type, X 4.

9. Lycopus uniflorus Michx., var. ovatus Fernald & St. John. Habit
sketch of the type, X 1A.

10. Bartonia iodandra Robinson, var. sabulonensis Fernald. Habit sketch
of the upper half of a plant, from the type, X 1.

lOa. Enlarged view of a single flower, from the type, X 2.

11. Bartonia iodandra Robinson. Enlarged view of a single flower, drawn
from M. L. Fernald & K. M . Wiegand, no. 3,913, Birchy Cove, New-
foundland, Aug. 11, 1910, X 2.

12. Agalinis paupercida (Gray) Britton, var. neoscotica (Greene) Pennell
& St. John. Habit view drawn from St. John, no. 1,318, Sable Island,
Nova Scotia, Aug. 18, 1913, X Y*

12a. Corolla seen from within, drawn from St. John, no. 1,318, X 1.

12b. Enlarged view of an anther and part of its filament, showing the gla-
brous line of dehiscence of the anther sacs and the attachment of the
hairs to the nearer side of the filament, drawn from St. John, no. 1,318,
X 10.

13. Hieracium scabrum Michx., var. leucocaule Fernald & St. John. Habit
sketch of a plant on the type sheet, X 1A>

14. Hieracium scabrum Michx. Base of plant showing characteristic
villous pubescence of the petioles and the base of the stem, drawn from
the specimen, Ezra Brainerd, Cobble Hill, New Haven, Vermont, Aug.
18, 1898, X 1A-

ST. JOHN. — SABLE ISLAND.

PLATE 2.

PROC. BOSTON Soc. NAT. HIST. VOL. 36.

THIS BOOK IS DUE ON THE LAST DATE
STAMPED BELOW

AN INITIAL FINE OF 25 CENTS

WILL BE ASSESSED FOR FAILURE TO RETURN
THIS BOOK ON THE DATE DUE. THE PENALTY
WILL INCREASE TO SO CENTS ON THE FOURTH
DAY AND TO $1.OO ON THE SEVENTH DAY
OVERDUE.

BIOLOGY LIBRARY

LD 21-10m-7,'39(402s)

i . m. ney. u. o. r«. ui

051,13'

THE UNIVERSITY OF CALIFORNIA LIBRARY