Skip to main content

Full text of "Silurian trilobites from the northern Yukon Territory"

See other formats


</> 

^ 

B 

=  oo 

P.S. 

=  a> 

Ro 

=  a> 

£ 

=  0) 

682 

^■^ 

UJ 

■3 

=  o 

no . 153 

s 

=  -^ 

=  o 

ce 

=    T*~ 

< 

-CD 

1 

^1^ 

o 

-  ^~ 

-1 

"CO 

•* 

" 

>- 

o 

E 

— 

ROM 

Royal  Ontario  Museum 


I  a  Hciai  I  Mcrii  K5 


CONTRIBUnONS 


Silurian  Trilobites  from 
the  Northern  Yukon  Territory 


Rolf  Ludvigsen  and  Ronald  R  Tripp 


ROYAL  ONTARIO  MUSEUM  LIFE  SCIENCES  PUBLICATIONS 
INSTRUCTIONS  TO  AUTHORS 


Authors  should  prepare  their  manuscripts  carefully  accord- 
ing to  the  following  instructions;  failure  to  do  so  will  result 
in  the  manuscript's  being  returned  to  the  author  for 
revision.  All  manuscripts  are  considered  on  the  under- 
standing that  they  are  not  currently  offered  for  publication 
elsewhere. 

1.  General  Papers  for  publication  are  accepted  from 
ROM  staff  members  and  research  associates,  and  from 
researchers  reporting  on  work  done  with  ROM  collec- 
tions. Monographs  on  the  flora  and/or  fauna  of  Ontario 
may  be  considered  for  publication  by  authors  not 
affiliated  with  the  ROM.  Financial  contributions  to- 
wards publication  will  be  welcome.  Authors  are 
expected  to  write  clearly  and  concisely  and  to  omit  any 
material  not  essential  for  an  understanding  of  the  main 
theme  of  the  paper. 

2.  Format  Manuscripts  (including  captions,  syn- 
onymies, literature  cited,  and  tables)  should  be  typed 
with  double  space  on  11"  x  SV2"  paper  with  a  IVi" 
margin  on  all  sides.  Three  xerox  copies  should  be 
submitted  to  the  Senior  Editor  of  the  Editorial  Board; 
the  original  should  be  retained  by  the  author(s).  The 
submission  should  include  a  separate  sheet  giving  the 
author(s)  names  and  affiliations,  the  title  of  the 
publication,  the  series  for  which  it  is  submitted,  the 
number  of  typed  pages,  the  number  of  tables,  and  the 
number  of  plates  or  figures.  Manuscripts  should 
normally  be  organized  in  the  following  order:  Con- 
tents, Abstract,  Introduction,  Materials  and  Methods, 
Results,  Discussion,  Conclusions,  Summary  (if  manu- 
script is  long).  Acknowledgements,  Appendices,  and 
Literature  Cited.  Authors  are  encouraged  to  include 
foreign-language  translations  of  the  Summary,  if 
appropriate.  Main  headings  should  be  centred;  sub- 
headings should  be  left-justified  to  the  text  margin. 
The  first  line  of  the  first  paragraph  in  each  new  section 
should  not  be  indented.  Literature  citations  in  the  text 
should  be  in  the  form  "Jones  (1972)"  or  "(Jones, 
1972)"  or  "(Smith,  1960:71-79,  fig.  17)". 

3.  Standard  Sources  The  primary  authority  on  ques- 
tions of  format  and  style  is  Guide  to  Authors ,  available 
from  ROM  Publication  Services.  For  matters  not 
covered  in  the  Guide,  consult  CBE  Style  Manual  (Fifth 
Edition).  Other  standard  sources  are  as  follows:  for 


English  spelling.  The  Concise  Oxford  Dictionary;  for 
Canadian  place  names  and  coordinates,  Canada 
Gazetteer  Atlas;  for  the  spelling  of  geographic  names, 
The  Times  Atlas . 

4.  Abstract  All  papers  must  be  preceded  by  a  short, 
factual  abstract,  about  one  per  cent  of  the  text  in 
length.  The  abstract  may  be  followed  by  four  to  six  key 
words  in  parentheses. 

5.  Taxonomy  The  name  of  a  taxon  should  be  given  in 
full  in  headings,  at  the  beginnings  of  paragraphs,  and  at 
its  first  occurrence  in  the  text.  Give  the  authority  and 
date,  if  appropriate,  with  the  first  mention  of  each 
taxon,  but  not  thereafter.  Taxonomic  papers,  particu- 
larly synonymies,  should  follow  the  layout  in  Life 
Sciences  Contributions  beginning  with  No.  136.  Inter- 
national Codes  of  Biological  Nomenclature  must  be 
followed. 

6.  Literature  Cited  A  complete  list  of  references,  in 
alphabetical  order  of  authors,  must  be  given  at  the  end 
of  the  paper.  When  two  or  more  works  of  one  author 
are  cited,  they  should  be  listed  chronologically.  The 
names  of  journals  should  not  be  abbreviated.  For 
correct  bibliographic  form,  see  Life  Sciences  Contrib- 
utions beginning  with  No.  136. 

7.  Tables  All  tables  should  be  typed  on  separate  sheets 
and  numbered  consecutively  in  arable  numerals  in  the 
order  of  their  first  mention  in  the  text.  Mark  the 
location  of  each  table  in  the  margin  of  the  text. 

8.  Plates,  Figures,  and  Text-figures  Illustrations  may 
be  designated  according  to  the  conventions  of  the 
author's  discipline;  in  some  disciplines  grouped  photo- 
graphs of  scientific  subject  matter  are  commonly 
termed  Plates,  while  line  drawings  and  locality  and 
other  illustrations  that  occupy  a  full  page  or  less  are 
Text-figures.  Usage  must  be  consistent  throughout  the 
paper.  A  full-page  illustration  for  a  Contribution,  with 
its  caption,  should  be  sized  to  fit  an  area  of  17.3  x 
22.75  cm;  for  Occasional  Papers,  the  area  is  14.1  x 
21.2  cm.  If  captions  are  lengthy,  they  may  be  placed 
on  the  facing  page.  A  scale  or  magnification  factor 
should  be  included.  Authors  are  reminded  that  when 
illustrations  are  reduced  magnification  factors  will 
change,  and  that  they  are  responsible  for  the  conver- 
sion. For  details,  see  Guide  to  Authors. 


LIFE  SCIENCES  CONTRIBUTIONS  153 


Silurian  Trilobites  from 
the  Northern  Yukon  Territory 


Rolf  Ludvigsen 

and 
Ronald  R  Tripp 


ROM 

ROYAL  ONTARIO  MUSEUM 
TORONTO 


ROYAL  ONTARIO  MUSEUM 

PUBLICATIONS  IN  LIFE  SCIENCES 

The  Royal  Ontario  Museum  publishes  three  series  in  the  Life  Sciences: 

contributions:  a  numbered  series  of  original  scientific  publications. 

OCCASIONAL  papers:  a  numbered  series  of  original  scientific  publications,  primarily 

short  and  of  taxonomic  significance. 

MISCELLANEOUS  PUBLICATIONS:  an  unnumbered  series  on  a  variety  of  subjects. 

All  manuscripts  considered  for  publication  are  subject  to  the  scrutiny  and  editorial 
policies  of  the  Life  Sciences  Editorial  Board,  and  to  independent  refereeing  by  two 
or  more  persons,  other  than  Museum  staff,  who  are  authorities  in  the  particular  field 
involved. 


LIFE  SCIENCES  EDITORIAL  BOARD 
Senior  editor:  D.  C.  Darling 
Editor:  R.  W.  Murphy 
Editor:  J.  H.  McAndrews 
External  editor:  C.  S.  Churcher 

Manuscript  editor:  E.  J.  Crossman 
Production  editor:  J.  E.  Hawken 


Rolf  Ludvigsen  is  research  associate,  Department  of  Invertebrate  Palaeontology, 
Royal  Ontario  Museum,  Toronto,  and  head  of  the  Denman  Institute  for  Research 
on  Trilobites,  4062  Wren  Road,  Denman  Island,  British  Columbia  VOR  ITO. 

Ronald  P.  Tripp  is  also  research  associate.  Department  of  Invertebrate  Palaeon- 
tology, Royal  Ontario  Museum,  Toronto.  He  currently  resides  at  41  Kirk  Drive, 
Thornhill,  Ontario  L3T  3K8. 


Canadian  Cataloguing  in  Publication  Data 

Ludvigsen,  Rolf,  1944- 

Silurian  trilobites  from  the  northern  Yukon  Territory 

(Life  sciences  contributions,  ISSN  0384-8159  ;  153) 
Includes  bibliographical  references. 
ISBN  0-88854-349-2 

1.  Trilobites.  2.  Paleontology  —  Silurian. 
3.  Paleontology  —  Yukon  Territory.  I.  Tripp,  Ronald 
P.  (Ronald  Pearson),  1914-    .     II.  Royal  Ontario 
Museum.  III.  Title.  IV.  Series. 

OE821.L83  1989        565'.393'097191         €89-09501 1-3 


Publication  date:  1  February  1990 

ISBN  0-88854-349-2 

ISSN  0384-8159 

©  Royal  Ontario  Museum,  1989 

100  Oueen's  Park,  Toronto,  Canada  M5S  2C6 

PRINTED  AND  BOUND  IN  CANADA  BY  GAGNE  PRESS 


lb 


Contents 


Abstract         1 
Introduction         1 
Stratigraphy         2 

Road  River  Formation        2 
Unnamed  Carbonates        4 
Age  and  Correlation        4 

AA  2-4.5  (Road  River  Formation)        4 
BB  131  (Unnamed  Carbonates)        4 
AA  95  (Road  River  Formation)        5 
Trilobite  Associations        5 
'     Otarion  Association        5 
Stenopareia  Association        5 
Hedstroemia  Association        6 
Materials  and  Methods        7 
Systematic  Palaeontology        8 

Family  Styginidae  Vogdes,  1890        8 
Subfamily  Bumastinae  Raymond,  1916        8 
Genus  Paracybantyx  gen.  nov.        8 

Paracybantyx  asulcatus  sp.  nov.        8 
Indeterminate  bumastine        9 
Subfamily  Scutelluinae  Richter  and  Richter 
Genus  Kosovopeltis  Snadjr,  1958        9 
Kosovopeltis  borealis  (Poulsen,  1934) 
Kosovopeltisl  spp.         14 
Indeterminate  scutelluine         14 
Family  Illaenidae  Hawle  and  Corda,  1847         14 
Subfamily  Illaeninae  Hawle  and  Corda,  1847 
Genus  Stenopareia  Holm,  1886         14 

Stenopareia  illtyd  sp.  nov.         14 
Indeterminate  illaenid         15 
Family  Proetidae  Salter,  1864         15 

?Subfamily  Crassiproetinae  Osmolska,  1970 
Genus  Hedstroemia  Pfibyl  and  Vanek         15 


14 


15 


Hedstroemia  kutchini  sp.  nov.         15 
Hedstroemia  sourdoughi  sp.  nov.         17 
Subfamily  Warburgellinae  Owens,  1973         17 
Genus  Prantlia  Pfibyl,  1946         17 
Prantlia  vagrans  sp.  nov.         17 
Subfamily  uncertain         19 

Indeterminate  proetid  A         19 
Indeterminate  proetid  B         19 
Family  Aulacopleuridae  Angelin,  1854        20 
Genus  Otarion  Zenker,  1833        20 

Subgenus  Songkania  Chang,  1974        20 
Otarion  (Songkania)  socialis  (Poulsen,  1934) 
Family  Harpidae  Hawle  and  Corda,  1847        21 
Genus  Scotoharpes  Lamont,  1948        21 

Scotoharpes  raaschi  Norford,  1973        21 


20 


111 


Family  Cheiruridae  Hawle  and  Corda,  1847        22 
Subfamily  Cheirurinae  Hawle  and  Corda,  1847        22 
Genus  Cheirums  Beyrich,  1845         22 
Cheimrus  sp.        22 
Family  Encrinuridae  Angelin,  1854        22 
Subfamily  Encrinurinae  Angelin,  1854        22 
Genus  Cromus  Barrande,  1852        22 

Cromus  princeps  (Poulsen,  1934)        22 
Genus  Encrinuraspis  Webby,  Moors,  and  McLean,  1970        24 

Encrinuraspis  sp.         24 
Genus  Balizoma  Holloway,  1980        24 

Balizoma  aff.  B.  obtusus  (Angelin,  1851)        24 
Indeterminate  encrurine        25 
Family  Calymenidae  Milne-Edwards,  1840        26 
Subfamily  uncertain        26 

Indeterminate  calymenid        26 
Family  Lichidae  Hawle  and  Corda,  1847        26 
Subfamily  Lichinae  Hawle  and  Corda,  1847        26 
Genus  Dicranopeltis  Beyrich,  1845        26 
Dicranopeltis  sp.        26 
Subfamily  uncertain        26 
Indeterminate  lichid        26 
Family  Odontopleuridae  Burmeister,  1843        27 
Subfamily  Odontopleurinae  Burmeister,  1843        27 
Genus  Leonaspis  Richter  and  Richter,  1917        27 

Leonaspis  semiglabra  (Poulsen,  1934)        27 
Indeterminate  odontopleurine        28 
Acknowledgements        29 
Literature  Cited        30 
Plates        34 


IV 


Silurian  Trilobites  from 
the  Northern  Yukon  Territory 


Abstract 

Silurian  trilobites  are  described  from  two  contrasting  facies  in  the  northern  Yukon 
Territory:  basinal  sediments  of  the  Road  River  Formation  at  Prongs  Creek  and 
shallow-water  limestones  of  the  Illtyd  Range.  An  Otarion  Association  from  dark 
grey,  argillaceous  lime  mudstones  (Lower  Silurian)  consists  of  Kosovopeltis,  Otarion 
(Songkania),  Cromus,  and  Leonaspis.  These  trilobites  are  identical  to  those  described 
by  Poulsen  (1934)  from  his  Cape  Schuchert  Formation  of  North  Greenland.  A 
Stenopareia  Association  from  off-white  biosparites  (Lower  Silurian)  includes  Steno- 
pareia,  a  bumastine,  Kosovopeltis,  and  Scotoharpes.  AHedstroemia  Association  occurs 
in  an  Upper  Silurian  debris  flow.  It  includes  Hedstroemia,  Prantlia,  Balizoma,  and 
Paracybantyx. 

An  incomplete  ontogeny  of  Kosovopeltis  borealis  (Poulsen)  comprises  a  protaspis 
and  four  different  transitory  pygidia. 

The  bumastine  genus  Paracybantyx  is  new.  New  species  are  Paracybantyx  asulcatus, 
Stenopareia  illtyd,  Hedstroemia  kutchini,  H.  sourdoughi,  and  Prantlia  vagrans. 


Introduction 


Silurian  rocks  crop  out  as  two  contrasting  facies  in 
the  northern  Yukon  Territory:  as  basinal  shales  of  the 
Road  River  Formation  within  the  Richardson  and 
Blackstone  troughs  in  the  Peel  River-Wind  River  area 
(Lenz,  1972),  and  as  thick-bedded  to  massive  carbon- 
ates, yet  unnamed,  on  the  Mackenzie  Platform  in  the 
Bonnet  Plume  River  area  and  on  the  Yukon  Block  in 
the  Porcupine  River  area  (Text-fig.  1).  In  the  basinal 
shales  exceptionally  complete  stratigraphic  successions 
of  graptolites  are  present  (Lenz  and  Pedder,  1972; 
Lenz,  1982),  but  in  the  platform  carbonates  well-pre- 
served fossils  of  Silurian  age  are  uncommon,  with  the 
exception  of  locally  abundant  tabulate  corals  and  pen- 
tamerid  brachiopods.  The  best-preserved  and  most- 
diverse  assemblages  of  Silurian  shelly  fossils  in  the 
Yukon  Territory  are  found  in  dark  grey,  argillaceous 
limestones  deposited  on  the  margins  of  the  troughs, 
close  to  facies  transitions  with  shallow-water  carbon- 
ates in  areas  along  the  Wind  River  such  as  Prongs 
Creek  (Raasch,  Norford,  and  Wilson,  1961;  Lenz,  1970) 
and  Royal  Creek  (Lenz,  1977;  Jackson,  Lenz,  and  Ped- 
der, 1978).  These  assemblages  are  strongly  dominated 
by  brachiopods,  but  a  few  include  substantial  numbers 


of  trilobites  of  types  that  are  either  unknown  from 
northern  Canada  or  incompletely  documented. 

Rich  Silurian  trilobite  assemblages  have  been 
described  from  the  Whittaker  and  Delorme  formations 
farther  to  the  south  in  the  Mackenzie  Mountains  of  the 
District  of  Mackenzie  (Perry  and  Chatterton,  1977; 
Chatterton  and  Perry,  1983),  and  smaller  assemblages 
have  been  described  from  different  localities  to  the 
north  in  the  Canadian  Arctic  Islands  (Bolton,  1965; 
Perry  and  Chatterton,  1977;  Thomas  and  Narbonne, 
1979)  and  North  Greenland  (Poulsen,  1934;  Lane, 
1979,  1984;  Lane  and  Owens,  1982).  In  the  Yukon 
Territory,  however,  Silurian  trilobites  have  been  docu- 
mented from  only  two  Lower  Silurian  localities — one 
from  dark  grey  limestones  of  the  Road  River  Formation 
at  Prongs  Creek  (Raasch,  Norford,  and  Wilson,  1961) 
and  one  from  off-white  limestone  in  the  nearby  Illtyd 
Range  (Norford,  1973).  In  this  paper,  we  reevaluate 
and  describe  fully  both  these  trilobite  assemblages  on 
the  basis  of  larger  and  more  complete  collections  than 
were  available  to  previous  investigators.  We  also  deal 
with  a  new  trilobite  fauna  from  the  Upper  Silurian  part 
of  the  Road  River  Formation  on  Prongs  Creek. 


1 


LOCALITY  MAP 

AND 

SILURIAN  LITHOFACIES 


shale  and  interbedded 
dar1(  limestone^ 


light  coloured  carbonates 


Text-FIG.  1.  Lx)cality  map  of  the  northern  Yukon  Territory  showing  Section  AA  on  Prongs  Creek 
and  Section  BB  in  the  Illtyd  Range.  The  generahzed  Silurian  hthofacies  map  is  adapted  from  Lenz 
(1972,  fig.  9). 


Stratigraphy 


ROAD  RIVER  FORMATION 
The  Road  River  Formation  was  raised  to  group  status 
by  Fritz  (1985),  who  considered  four  undesignated  map 
units  in  the  Richardson  Mountains  to  constitute  forma- 
tions. Until  such  time  as  these  map  units  are  defined 
and  formally  named,  we  retain  the  formational  status 
of  the  Road  River.  Within  the  Richardson  Trough 
north  of  the  Peel  River,  the  Road  River  Formation 
consists  of  more  than  one  thousand  metres  of  shales, 
cherts,  and  limestones  of  Cambrian,  Ordovician,  Silu- 
rian, and  Devonian  age.  The  axis  of  this  intracratonic 
trough  swings  east  along  the  Bonnet  Plume  River  to 
join  the  Selwyn  Trough  to  the  south  (Lenz,  1979,  fig.  1; 
Norris,  1985:40).  During  the  Silurian,  a  narrow  north- 
south  embayment  off  the  Richardson  Trough  devel- 
oped near  the  headwaters  and  along  the  tributaries 
of  the  Wind  River.  Here,  the  Road  River  Formation 
comprises  a  recessive  sequence  of  calcareous  shales 
and  argillaceous  limestones  which  rests  abruptly  on 
resistant  Ordovician  carbonates  (see  Lenz,  1972,  fig.  8; 
Norris,  1985,  fig.  10).  On  Prongs  Creek,  the  lower  con- 


tact of  the  Road  River  is  concordant,  but  apparently 
disconformable  because  Upper  Ordovician  (Rich- 
mondian;  Norford,  1964)  strata  are  followed  directly  by 
mid-Lower  Silurian  strata.  Unconformities  of  similar 
magnitude  occur  at  the  same  interval  in  shelf  succes- 
sions of  most  other  areas  of  western  North  America 
(Lenz,  1976). 

Starting  about  50  m  above  its  base  on  Prongs  Creek 
(Text-fig.  2),  the  Road  River  Formation  begins  to  dis- 
play evidence  of  relief  associated  with  nearby  carbonate 
banks.  Contorted  bedding,  slumps,  and  thick  debris 
flows  consisting  of  jumbled  fossils  and  small  lithoclasts 
become  common.  The  debris  flows  were  probably 
derived  from  the  flanks  of  shallow  carbonate  banks 
such  as  those  now  exposed  in  the  Illtyd  Range  to  the 
east  or  near  the  headwaters  of  the  Hart  River  to  the 
southwest. 

Sample  AA  2-4.5  was  obtained  from  medium-bed- 
ded, highly  argillaceous  lime  mudstones  of  deep-water 
aspect,  at  the  base  of  the  Road  River  Formation.  Sam- 
ple AA  95  was  collected  from  a  prominent  2-m-thick 


SECTION  AA 


SECTION  BB 


PRONGS  CREEK 
65"17'N.  135"42'W 


ILLTYD  RANGE 
65"14'N.135"12'W 


UNNAMED    0 

ORDOVICIAN 

CARBONATES 


AAgs 


C/D 


180m- 

J 

1       ) 

160- 

^ 

lAfl- 

V 

IfU 

120- 

1 

^ 

) 

100- 

■• 

80- 

60- 

<c 

QC 

) 

^    40- 

J 

=i     9n- 

1      1 

So       ^U 

S 

ca 

) 

n. 

) 

AA  2-4.5 


BB131 


LIMESTONE 

SHALE 

COVERED  INTERVAL 

»io§?,oo^o)      DEBRIS  FLOW 
SLUMP 


Text-fig.  2.  Graphic  lithological  log  of  Section  AA,  through  the  lower  part  of  the  Road  River 
Formation  on  Prongs  Creek,  and  of  Section  BB,  through  unnamed  Ordovician  and  Silurian  carbonates 
in  the  Illtyd  Range.  Sample  BB  131  was  collected  131  m  above  the  base  of  massive  and  resistant  Silurian 
limestones,  that  is,  at  unit  3  of  Norford's  (1964)  Section  5. 


debris  flow  located  95  m  above  the  base  of  the  for- 
mation. 


UNNAMED  CARBONATES 
The  Illtyd  Range  exposes  a  thick  sequence  of  poorly 
fossiliferous,  thick-bedded  to  massive,  shallow-v^ater 
limestones  of  probable  Ordovician,  Silurian,  and  De- 
vonian age  (Norford,  1964;  Lenz,  1972;  Norris,  1985). 


This  carbonate  bank  maintained  itself  while  sediments 
of  the  Road  River  Formation  accumulated  in  the  Rich- 
ardson Trough  farther  to  the  north. 

Norford  (1964:36)  measured  a  distinctive  unit  3  of 
the  unnamed  carbonates  consisting  of  200  m  of  massive, 
crystalline  off-white  limestone,  which  weathers  into 
steep  pinnacles;  Norford's  unit  3  is  probably  entirely  of 
Early  Silurian  age.  Sample  BB  131  was  collected  131  m 
above  the  base  of  this  unit. 


Age  and  Correlation 


AA  2-4.5  (ROAD  RIVER  FORMATION) 
Raasch,  Norford,  and  Wilson  ( 1961)  described  brachio- 
pods,  trilobites,  and  graptolites  from  samples  collected 
at  unspecified  levels  across  a  50-m  interval,  starting  at 
the  top  of  the  resistant  Ordovician  carbonates  at  the 
gorge  of  Prongs  Creek.  These  samples  included  a  trilo- 
bite  fauna  with  Aulacopleura  socialis,  herein  referred 
to  as  Otarion  (Songkania)  socialis  and  identical  to  the 
fauna  from  our  sample  AA  2-4.5,  as  well  as  a  graptolite 
fauna  representing  the  Lower  Silurian  Monograptus 
turriculatus  Zone.  A  measured  section  in  Norford 
(1964:49,127)  located  the  O.  (5.)  socialis  fauna  in  the 
lower  6  m  of  the  Road  River  Formation  on  Prongs 
Creek,  the  M.  turriculatus  Zone  a  few  metres  higher, 
followed  by  the  M.  spiralis  Zone  some  10  to  21  m 
upsection. 

Both  Raasch,  Norford,  and  Wilson  (1961)  and  Nor- 
ford (1964)  indicated  a  late  Llandovery  age  for  the 
Otarion  fauna  on  Prongs  Creek  based  on  its  position 
relative  to  the  position  of  the  M  turriculatus  Zone.  This 
age  assessment  receives  support  from  an  abundant,  but 
low-diversity,  conodont  fauna  from  sample  AA  2-4.5. 
According  to  Godfrey  Nowlan  of  the  Geological  Survey 
of  Canada  (pers.  comm.,  1987),  the  sample  is  domi- 
nated by  "Oulodus"  fluegeli  (Walliser)  and  includes 
Dapsilodus  obliquicostatus,  Ozarkodina  excavata  exca- 
vata,  Panderodus  gracilis,  and  Walliserodus  sancticlair. 
Nowlan  noted  that,  in  other  parts  of  the  Yukon  Terri- 
tory, "O.  "fluegeli  is  common  in  strata  bearing  grapto- 
lites of  the  M.  turriculatus  Zone  and  further  suggested 
that  this  association  of  conodont  elements  probably 
represents  a  deep-water  biofacies. 

Raasch  {in  Raasch,  Norford,  and  Wilson,  1961)  rec- 
ognized that  the  four  species  of  trilobites  comprising 
the  O.  (S.)  socialis  fauna  on  Prongs  Creek  are  identical 
to  those  described  by  Poulsen  (1934),  which  had  been 
collected  by  Lauge  Koch  from  different  localities  of  the 
Cape  Schuchert  Formation  in  Washington  Land,  North 
Greenland.  These  trilobites  must  have  been  conspicu- 
ous elements  of  the  Cape  Schuchert  Formation  because 


Koch  had  previously  referred  these  strata  to  the  "Are- 
thusina  ( =  Aulacopleura)  beds"  (see  Dawes  and  Haller, 
1979;  Hurst,  1980:74). 

There  is  considerable  uncertainty  about  the  prove- 
nance of  the  Otarion  fauna  in  North  Greenland.  The 
Silurian  stratigraphic  framework  of  Washington  Land 
was  revised  by  Hurst  (1980),  who  restricted  Koch's 
Cape  Schuchert  Formation  to  black  bituminous  lime 
mudstones  of  Llandovery  age;  the  overlying  shales  and 
mudstones  were  assigned  to  the  Lafayette  Bugt  Forma- 
tion of  middle  Llandovery  to  Ludlow  age.  Koch's  local- 
ity data  were  definitely  generalized  and  possibly 
unreliable  (Norford,  1972:9).  Apparently  Otarion 
occurs  in  both  formations,  but  neither  Norford  (1972) 
nor  Hurst  (1980)  located  this  trilobite  in  Lower  Silurian 
stratigraphic  sections  of  Washington  Land.  It  is  known 
with  certainty  from  only  a  single  stratigraphically 
located  collection  in  North  Greenland.  According  to 
John  S.  Peel  of  the  Greenland  Geological  Survey,  O. 
(S.) socialis  and  Cromus princeps  occur  in  GGU  sample 
216841,  collected  from  Norford's  (1972:13)  unit  4, 
which  is  overlain  (in  unit  6)  by  graptolites  of  the  M. 
turriculatus  Zone.  These  rock  units  were  assigned  to 
the  Cape  Phillips  Formation  by  Norford  (1972)  and  to 
the  Lafayette  Bugt  Formation  by  Hurst  (1980). 

In  summary,  trilobite  collection  AA  2-4.5,  with  Ota- 
rion {Songkania),  Kosovopeltis,  Cromus,  and  Leonaspis 
from  the  lowest  Road  River  Formation  on  Prongs 
Creek,  is  Early  Silurian  in  age  and  equivalent  to,  or 
slightly  older  than,  the  M.  turriculatus  Zone.  A  faunule 
with  Otarion  {Songkania)  and  Cromus  from  the  Lafa- 
yette Bugt  Formation  near  Kap  Schuchert  in  North 
Greenland  is  approximately  the  same  age. 


BB  131  (UNNAMED  CARBONATES) 

Norford  (1964,  1973)  recorded  a  sparse  trilobite  fauna 
of  Scotoharpes  raaschi  Norford,  Encrinurus  cf.  E. 
princeps  Poulsen,  Scutellum  sp.,  and  an  illaenid  at  GSC 
locality  53109  from  a  1-m  interval  425  m  above  the  base 


of  an  unnamed  carbonate  unit  in  the  liltyd  Range;  he 
dated  this  fauna  as  late  Llandovery.  This  interval  of 
massive,  off-white,  coarsely  crystalline  biosparite, 
located  131m  above  the  base  of  Norford's  unit  3,  was 
re-collected  as  locality  BB  131.  A  meagre  conodont 
fauna  of  14  fragmentary  specimens,  including  l^Oulo- 
dus" fluegeli,  Panderodus  gracilis,  and  Walliserodus  sp., 
was  identified  by  G.  Nowlan  (pers.  comm.,  1987),  who 
suggested  that  it  was  probably  of  late  Llandovery  age. 


AA  95  (ROAD  RIVER  FORMATION) 
Lenz  (1970)  described  a  moderately  rich  fauna  of  Late 
Silurian  brachiopods  from  a  thick  limestone  bed 
located  106  m  above  the  base  of  the  Road  River  Forma- 
tion on  Prongs  Creek.  Re-collection  of  this  bed  yielded 
a  large  number  of  well-preserved  trilobites.  According 
to  Ludvigsen's  measured  section,  this  bed  is  located 


95  m  above  the  base  of  the  formation;  therefore,  our 
sample  is  designated  AA  95.  On  the  basis  of  graptolite 
faunas  below  and  above,  Lenz  (1970)  correlated  the 
fossiliferous  bed  with  either  the  latest  Ludlow  or 
the  earliest  Pridoli,  an  age  assignment  consistent  with 
biostratigraphic  information  from  a  meagre  conodont 
fauna.  Later  Jackson,  Lenz,  and  Pedder  (1978:20) 
assigned  the  overlying  graptolite  collection  to  the 
Monograptus  formosus  Zone,  which  in  central  Europe 
comprises  the  basal  zone  of  the  Pridoli. 

The  trilobite  fauna  from  AA  95  consists  largely  of 
new  species  and,  therefore,  contributes  little  informa- 
tion toward  an  age  assignment  and  correlation  of  this 
unit.  We  tentatively  correlate  AA  95  with  the  upper 
Ludlow  on  the  basis  of  the  overlying  graptolites.  The 
trilobites,  in  particular  Prantlia  vagrans  sp.  nov.  and 
Balizoma  aff.  B.  obtusus  (Angelin),  have  greater  affini- 
ties to  Ludlow  than  to  Pridoli  species. 


Trilobite  Associations 


Each  of  the  three  samples  of  Silurian  trilobites  from  the 
northern  Yukon  Territory  dealt  with  here  is  dominated 
numerically  by  a  different  family  (Text-fig.  3,  Table  1), 
and  each  association  clearly  owes  its  composition  to 
environmental  factors  (see  also  Ludvigsen  et  al.,  1986). 


OTARION  ASSOCIATION 

Because  of  its  size,  Kosovopeltis  is  the  most  conspicuous 
trilobite  in  sample  AA  2-4.5,  but  the  association  is 
named  for  Otarion  which,  though  small,  is  numerically 
dominant.  The  Otarion  Association  occurs  in  dark  grey, 
highly  argillaceous  lime  mudstones  of  the  lower  few 
metres  of  the  Road  River  Formation  at  Prongs  Creek, 
in  association  with  a  low-diversity  brachiopod  fauna 
(Norford,  in  Raasch,  Norford,  and  Wilson,  1961).  The 
strata  appear  to  be  of  deep-water  aspect,  a  setting  that 
receives  support  from  the  low  diversity  of  the  trilobite 
fauna  and  from  the  association  of  conodont  elements 
(G.  Nowlan,  pers.  comm.,  1987). 

Aulacopleurids  typically  constitute  minor  elements 
of  trilobite  associations  in  off-platform  graptolite  shale 
basins  (for  example,  Thomas,  1979,  fig.  2),  but  we  are 
not  aware  of  any  published  account  of  another  trilobite 
assemblage  such  as  the  Otarion  Association  that  is  dom- 
inated by  an  aulacopleurid. 


STENOPAREIA  ASSOCIATION 

A  small  collection  from  locality  BB  131  is  dominated  by 
Stenopareia  and  an  indeterminate  bumastine.  It  came 


from  an  interval  of  off-white  crystalline  biosparite  in 
the  Lower  Silurian  part  of  an  unnamed  unit  in  the  Illtyd 
Range;  this  unit  records  shallow-water  carbonate  bank 
deposition  during  most  of  the  Silurian  and  Early  Dev- 
onian (Text-fig.  1).  The  Stenopareia  Association  shows 
no  evidence  of  transportation  and  is,  presumably, 
autochthonous.  This  association  in  the  Illtyd  Range  is 
very  similar  to  that  described  by  Lane  (1979)  from 
white,  coarsely  crystalline  limestones  of  the  upper  part 
of  the  Alequatsiad  Fiord  Formation  (mid-Lland- 
overy)  near  Kap  Schuchert,  North  Greenland, 
which  also  is  dominated  by  Stenopareia  and  bumastines. 

The  Early  Silurian  Stenopareia  Association  of  the 
Yukon  Territory  and  Greenland  is  clearly  part  of  the 
illaenid-cheirurid  associations  that  also  occur  widely  in 
Ordovician  carbonate  build-ups  and  in  subtidal  shelf 
settings  in  other  areas  of  Laurentia  (Westrop,  1983). 
The  Stenopareia  Association  itself  seems  to  be  a  shelf 
assemblage;  it  differs  from  contemporaneous  build-up 
assemblages  in,  for  example,  the  Pentamerus  Bjerg  For- 
mation of  North  Greenland,  which  is  dominated  by  a 
proetine  and  a  scutelluine  (Lane  and  Owens,  1982),  or 
the  Hopkinson  Dolomite  of  Iowa,  which  is  character- 
ized by  a  lichid  and  a  cheirurid  (Mikulic,  1981). 

Within  the  limits  of  correlation  possible  using  con- 
odont biostratigraphy  of  the  Road  River  Formation  on 
Prongs  Creek  and  of  unnamed  carbonates  of  the  Illtyd 
Range,  the  Otarion  Association  from  dark  grey,  argilla- 
ceous lime  mudstones  is  of  the  same  age  as  the  higher- 
diversity  Stenopareia  Association  from  off-white 
biosparites. 


PARACYBANTYX 


BAUZOMA 


HEDSTROEMIA 


PRANTUA 


AA95  n=172 

HEDSTROEMIA    ASSOCIATION 

UPPER  SILURIAN 


CROMUS 


LEONASPIS 


KOSOVOPELTIS. 


SCOTOHARPES 


OTARION 


KOSOVOPELTIS 


STENOPAREIA 


AA2-4.5 


OTARION  ASSOCIATION 


n=420 


BUMASTINE 


BB131  n=29 

STENOPAREIA  ASSOCIATION 


LOWER  SILURIAN 

Text-fig.  3.  Pie  diagrams  showing  generic  relative  abundance  of  specimens  in  the  three  trilobite 
associations  deah  with  in  this  study. 


HEDSTROEMIA  ASSOCIATION 

A  2-m-thick  debris  flow  in  the  Upper  Silurian  part  of 
the  Road  River  Formation  on  Prongs  Creek  yielded 
a  diverse  brachiopod  fauna  of  17  species,  dominated 
numerically  by  the  smooth  atrypoid  Cryptatrypa  (Lenz, 
1970),  and  a  trilobite  assemblage  of  7  species  that  we 
name  the  Hedstroemia  Association.  About  two-thirds 
of  the  specimens  in  this  association  belong  to  3  proetine 
and  warburgelline  species;  the  remaining  specimens 
are  bumastines,  encrinurids,  and  lichids. 

The  debris  flows  display  scoured  bases  and  lack  inter- 
nal grading.  They  appear  to  be  the  products  of  slumps 
that  swept  shells  and  small  (less  than  1  cm)  limestone 
clasts  off  the  sides  of  the  adjoining  carbonate  banks 
and  into  the  centre  of  the  shale  embayment  (see  also 


Lenz,  1977). 

The  Hedstroemia  Association  is  different  from  the 
few  Upper  Silurian  trilobite  faunas  described  from 
northern  Canada  to  date.  Faunas  from  shallow  subtidal 
settings  in  the  Road  River  Formation  on  Cornwallis 
Island  in  the  Canadian  Arctic  appear  to  be  dominated 
by  the  warburgelline  Helokybe,  the  encrinurid  Encri- 
nurus,  and  the  lichid  Hemiarges  (Thomas  and  Nar- 
bonne,  1979). 

The  dominance  of  proetines  and  warburgellines  in 
the  Hedstroemia  Association  is  matched  by  the  ProetusI 
Warburgella  Association  from  shelf  limestones  of  the 
British  Wenlock  (Thomas,  1979),  but  that  association 
shows  considerably  higher  generic  diversity. 


Table  1.  Summary  of  frequencies. 

comp.,  complete;  craAj.,  cephala/cranidia;/jy/>o.,  hypostomes;/?>'g.,  pygidia;  to/a/,  number  of  specimens 
of  the  most  frequent  part;  %,  percentage  of  the  total  number  of  specimens. 


Species 


comp. 


cran. 


hypo. 


pyg- 


total 


% 


Lower  Silurian 

AA  2^.5,  Prongs  Creek 
Kosovopeltis  borealis 
Otarion  (Songkania)  socialis 
Cromus  princeps 
Leonaspis  semiglabra 

BB  131,  Illtyd  Range 
Kosovopeltis'?  spp. 
Indeterminate  bumastine 
Stenopareia  illtyd  sp.  nov. 
Indeterminate  illaenid 
Indeterminate  proetid  B 
Scotoharpes  raaschi 
Cheirurus  sp. 
Encrinuraspis  sp. 
Indeterminate  calymenid 
Dicranopeltis  sp. 
Indeterminate  odontopleurine 


Otarion  Association 

2 

78 

19 

116 

116 

27 

7 

270 

3 

78 

270 

65 

1 

10 

4 

23 

23 

5 

1 

8 

4 

11 

11 

3 

Stenopa 

reia 

Association 

— 

1 

— 

3 

3 

11 

— 

8 

— 

1 

8 

29 

— 

9 

— 

6 

9 

32 

— 

1 

— 

— 

1 

3 

— 

1 

1 

1 

1 

3 

- 

2 

— 

— 

2 

7 

— 

1 

— 

1 

1 

3 

— 

— 

1 

1 

3 

— 

— 

1 

1 

3 

- 

1 

— 

1 

1 

3 

— 

1 

— 

— 

1 

3 

Upper  Silurian 

AA  95,  Prongs  Creek 
Paracybantyx  asulcatus  gen.  et  sp.  nov. 
Indeterminate  scutelluine 
Hedstroemia  kutchini  sp.  nov. 
Hedstroemia  sourdoughi  sp.  nov. 
Prantlia  vagrans  sp.  nov. 
Indeterminate  proetid  A 
Balizoma  aff.  B.  obtusus 
Indeterminate  encrinurine 
Indeterminate  lichid 


Hedstroemia  Association 


19 

2 

24 

24 

14 

1 

— 

— 

1 

1 

9 

2 

40 

40 

23 

8 

— 

25 

25 

14 

16 

— 

48 

48 

28 

1 

1 

1 

5 

1 

27 

27 

15 

1 

— 

— 

1 

1 

3 

5 

5 

5 

3 

Materials  and  Methods 


All  the  figured  specimens  that  were  collected  have  been 
deposited  at  the  Royal  Ontario  Museum;  their  regis- 
tered numbers  bear  the  prefix  ROM.  Other  specimens 
illustrated  are  in  the  collection  of  the  Geological  Survey 
of  Canada,  Ottawa,  and  are  prefixed  GSC. 

As  far  as  possible,  plates  are  arranged  in  the  order 
of  the  systematic  section.  Upper  Silurian  trilobites  from 
AA  95  constitute  Plates  1,  6,  7,  11.  Lower  Silurian 
trilobites  from  AA  2-4.5  constitute  Plates  2-4,  8,  10, 
12;  Plate  4  comprises  scanning  electron  micrographs 
prepared  at  the  University  of  Toronto.  Lower  Silurian 


trilobites  from  BB  131  constitute  Plates  5  and  9.  Plate 
13  comprises  photographs  of  plaster  casts  of  Poulsen's 
(1934)  original  specimens  from  North  Greenland.  Orig- 
inals are  housed  in  the  Mineralogical  and  Geological 
Museum,  University  of  Copenhagen  (MMH). 

The  terminology  used  is  essentially  that  defined  by 
Harrington,  Moore,  and  Stubblefield  {in  Moore, 
1959:117-126).  Glabellar  lobes,  furrows,  and  muscle 
impressions  are  numbered  from  back  to  front  and  sym- 
bolized by  L,  S,  and  G,  respectively.  The  occipital  ring 
is  regarded  as  part  of  the  glabella. 


Systematic  Palaeontology 


Family  Styginidae  Vogdes,  1890 


DISCUSSION 

Lane  and  Thomas  (1983:141)  have  argued  that  numer- 
ous genera  previously  referred  to  separate  famihes  and 
subfamihes  of  effaced  trilobites  should  be  included  in 


an  undivided  family  Styginidae.  In  this  paper  we  prefer 
to  continue  the  use  of  the  subfamilies  Stygininae,  Scu- 
telluinae,  and  Bumastinae  as  an  aid  to  grouping  the 
large  number  of  genera  in  the  family. 


Subfamily  Bumastinae  Raymond,  1916 


Genus  Paracybantyx  gen.  nov. 

DERIVATION  OF  NAME 

Name  derived  from  Latin  para  (beside)  and  Cybantyx. 
Gender  masculine. 

DIAGNOSIS 

Cranidium  broad,  lacking  anterior  border  and  furrow. 
Axial  furrow  bowed  inward,  faint  posteriorly.  Pygidium 
convex,  85  to  100  per  cent  as  wide  as  long,  effaced. 
Surface  finely  pitted. 

TYPE  SPECIES 

Paracybantyx  asulcatus  sp.  nov.,  locality  AA  95  (Upper 
Silurian),  Road  River  Formation,  Prongs  Creek,  Yukon 
Territory,  Canada. 

OTHER  SPECIES 

None. 

DISCUSSION 

The  absence  of  the  anterior  border  and  furrow  pre- 
cludes inclusion  of  this  species  in  the  genus  Cybantyx, 
Lane  and  Thomas  {in  Thomas,  1978),  which  it  other- 
wise resembles. 


Paracybantyx  asulcatus  sp.  nov. 

PI.  1,  figs.  1-15;  PI.  11,  figs.  1-5 

DERIVATION  OF  NAME 

Specific  name  derived  from  Latin  a  (without)  and  sul- 
catus  (furrowed),  referring  to  the  absence  of  the  ante- 
rior border  furrow. 

HOLOTYPE 

ROM  45344  (cranidium,  PI.  1,  figs.  4,5),  locality  AA 
95  (Upper  Silurian),  Road  River  Formation,  Prongs 
Creek,  Yukon  Territory,  Canada. 

DIAGNOSIS 

As  for  genus. 


MATERIAL 

From  AA  95  (Upper  Silurian),  Prongs  Creek:  19  crani- 
dia,  4  librigenae,  2  hypostomes,  24  pygidia. 

DESCRIPTION 

Cranidium  85  to  95  per  cent  as  long  as  wide,  longitu- 
dinal curvature  strongest  toward  front,  evenly  convex 
transversely,  broadly  rounded  in  outline  anteriorly. 
Glabella  wide,  narrowest  opposite  palpebral  lobe 
where  it  occupies  two-thirds  width  between  margins, 
widening  forward  and  backward.  Small  tubercle  near 
posteromedian  margin.  Occipital  ring  and  furrow 
effaced.  Axial  furrow  broad  and  shallow  at  back,  deep- 
ening forward,  bowed  more  or  less  strongly  inward, 
terminating  in  large,  rounded  anterior  pit  opposite  one- 
tenth  cranidial  length  from  front.  On  larger  specimens, 
axial  furrow  effaced  anteriorly  and  posteriorly.  Genal 
muscle  impression  alongside  axial  furrow  on  fixigena 
almost  one-fifth  length  of  cranidium,  situated  at  own 
length  anterior  to  posterior  margin;  outline  of  impres- 
sion running  parallel  to  that  of  palpebral  lobe.  Palpe- 
bral lobe  slightly  swollen  and  gently  rounded  in  outline, 
one-quarter  length  of  cranidium,  with  posterior 
extremity  opposite  that  of  lateral  muscle  impression. 
Anterior  border  and  furrow  absent.  Anterior  branch  of 
facial  suture  running  outward,  parallel  to  axial  furrow 
at  first,  and  then  curving  forward  and  inward;  posterior 
branch  directed  backward  and  slightly  outward.  Crani- 
dium faintly  pitted,  with  faint  terrace  ridges  running 
parallel  to  anterior  margin  at  front. 

Incomplete  librigenae  show  a  comparatively  small 
eye  without  socle.  Genal  angle  aspinous.  Doublure 
broad,  weakly  convex.  Anterior  extension  curves 
inward  and  upward;  on  inner  margin,  just  in  front  of 
eye,  a  single  pit  projects  inward  and  dorsally  upward 
(PI.  11,  fig.  2).  This  pit  would  lie  immediately  below 
anterior  pit  at  front  of  axial  furrow — compare  Failleana 
calva  Chatterton  and  Ludvigsen  (1976,  pi.  6,  figs.  5,12- 
16).  The  pit  in  the  doublure,  which  opposes  the  anterior 
pit  in  Remopleurides  (Whittington,  1959,  fig.  3c),  is  anal- 
ogous. 

Hypostome  incomplete  but  comparable  to  that  of 


8 


Bumastus  and  Cyhantyx  in  the  swollen  middle  body, 
lateral  lobe  consisting  of  large  macula,  and  depressed 
border.  Prosopon  of  middle  body  rugose  and  pitted. 

Pygidium  strongly  convex,  rounded  triangular  to 
nearly  subovate  in  outline,  85  to  100  per  cent  as  long 
as  wide,  almost  completely  effaced;  height  45  to  55  per 
cent  sagittal  length.  Immature  pygidia  wider  than  long. 
Triangular  axis  faintly  marked  by  slight  change  of  con- 
vexity in  some  specimens.  Articulating  facet  marked  off 
by  a  faint  oblique  ridge;  coarse  terrace  lines  running 
parallel  to  and  overstepping  posterior  ridge,  with  steep 
surface  facing  backward;  raised  lines  bending  perpen- 
dicularly backward  at  margin.  Doublure  broad,  30  per 
cent  length  of  pygidium;  about  15  shallow  discontinu- 
ous terrace  ridges,  equally  spaced,  running  parallel  to 
margin.  Surface  finely  pitted;  fine,  short  raised  lines 
running  inward/backward  for  a  short  distance  abaxially 
(PI.  1,  fig.  15). 

DISCUSSION 

The  pygidium  of  this  species  is  remarkably  similar  to 
that  of  specimens  from  the  Lower  Silurian  of  northeast 
Greenland,  described  as  "Goldillaenid  Genus  and  spe- 
cies indet.  2"  by  Lane  (1972:347,  pi.  62,  figs.  10-14). 
The  cranidium  differs  from  that  of  Lane's  material  in 
being  much  wider,  with  wider  glabella,  and  in  having 
axial  furrows  bowed  inward  and  shallowing  posteriorly. 
Lane's  material  has  a  terraced  anterior  border  and 
border  furrow  similar  to  that  of  Cyhantyx  anaglyptos 
Lane  and  Thomas  {in  Thomas,  1978:18,  pi.  5,  figs.  1-8). 
The  absence  of  the  border  and  border  furrow  in  the 
Road  River  material  is  the  main  feature  of  the  new 
genus  Paracybantyx.  Both  the  Yukon  and  the  Green- 
land species  resemble  the  type  species  of  Cyhantyx  in 
the  comparatively  narrow,  featureless  pygidium.  Vari- 
able features  in  the  cranidium  of  P.  asulcatus  sp.  nov. 
are  the  degree  of  inward  curvature  of  the  axial  furrows, 
the  anterior  and  posterior  effacement  of  the  axial  fur- 


rows in  larger  specimens,  and  the  proportions  and  con- 
vexity of  the  pygidium. 

Ptilillaenus  Lu  (1962),  a  monotypic  genus  from  the 
Middle  Silurian  of  China,  has  an  extended  axial  furrow 
terminating  in  an  anterior  pit  and  lacks  the  anterior 
border,  but  in  that  taxon  the  glabella  is  narrow. 


Indeterminate  bumastine 

PI.  5,  figs.  13,14 

MATERIAL 

From  BB  131  (Lower  Silurian),  Illtyd  Range:  8  crani- 
dia,  1  pygidium. 

DESCRIPTION 

Cranidium  60  per  cent  as  long  as  wide,  strongly  convex. 
Glabella  effaced,  except  for  lunule  at  60  per  cent  length 
from  front.  Posteromedian  tubercle  at  10  per  cent 
length  from  back.  Anterior  pits  small,  shallow,  and 
rounded,  70  per  cent  maximum  width  of  cranidium 
apart,  and  20  per  cent  length  of  cranidium  from  front. 
Palpebral  lobe  40  per  cent  length  of  cranidium,  placed 
far  back,  weakly  rounded. 

Pygidium  (not  illustrated)  65  per  cent  as  long  as  wide, 
strongly  convex.  Axis  60  per  cent  anterior  width,  dying 
out  in  a  short  distance.  Anterolateral  angle  oblique. 
Surface  smooth  except  for  faint  terrace  ridges  on  front 
of  cranidium. 

DISCUSSION 

The  presence  of  the  anterior  pits  suggests  a  relationship 
to  species  such  as  Bumastus?  phrix  Lane  and  Thomas 
{in  Thomas,  1978:14,  pi.  3,  figs.  1-22)  and  B.l  xestos 
Lane  and  Thomas  {in  Thomas,  1978:16,  pi.  4,  figs.  2-5, 
7,18),  both  from  the  British  Wenlock.  The  present 
species  is  distinguished  by  a  number  of  features,  partic- 
ularly the  effacement  of  the  axial  furrows. 


Subfamily  Scuteliuinae  Richter  and  Ricliter,  1955 


Genus  Kosovopeltis  §najdr,  1958 

TYPE  SPECIES 

Kosovopeltis  svobodai  Snajdr,  1958,  Kopanina  Forma- 
tion (Upper  Silurian),  Kosov,  Prague  district,  Czecho- 
slovakia. 


Scutellum  horealis — Raasch  in  Raasch,  Norford,  and 
Wilson,  1961:477,  figs.  5.6-8,10  (non  fig.  5.9  =  Leo- 
naspis  semiglahra). 

Scutellum  horealis — Norford,  1962,  pi.  8,  fig.  7. 

Scutellum  horealis — Norford  et  al.,  1970,  pi.  8,  fig.  9. 


Kosovopeltis  horealis  (Poulsen,  1934) 

PI.  2,  figs.  1-12;  PI.  3,  figs.  1-10;  PI.  4,  figs.  1-13;  PI. 
13,  figs.  1,2;  Text-figs.  4,  5 A 

Goldius  horealis  Pouisen,  1934:27,  pl.  3,  figs.  14,15. 


HOLOTYPE 

MMH  3267  (cranidium,  figured  by  Poulsen,  1934,  pl.  3, 
fig.  14;  in  this  paper,  Pl.  13,  fig.  1),  Cape  Schuchert 
Formation  (Lower  Silurian),  Kap  Schuchert,  North 
Greenland. 


I      0.5  mm     ^ 


1mm 


1mm 


Text-FIG.  4.  Incomplete  ontogeny  oi  Kosovopeltis  borealis  (Poulsen).  v4,  Protaspis,  ROM  42160.  B, 
Smallest  transitory  pygidium,  ROM  42166.  C,  Meraspid  cranidium,  ROM  42161.  D,  Transitory  pygid- 
ium,  ROM  42165.  E,  Transitory  pygidium  with  two  protothoracic  segments  attached,  ROM  42163.  F, 
Transitory  pygidium  with  one  protothoracic  segment  attached,  ROM  42162. 


MATERIAL 

From  AA  2-4.5  (Lower  Silurian),  Prongs  Creek:  2  dor- 
sal shields,  78  cranidia,  librigenae,  rostral  plates,  19 
hypostomes,  116  pygidia. 

DESCRIPTION 

Cephalon  about  25  per  cent  as  long  as  wide.  Glabella 
moderately  convex  for  most  of  its  length,  strongly  con- 
vex and  downturned  at  front,  narrowing  strongly  back- 
ward to  30  to  40  per  cent  anterior  width;  anterolateral 
angles  strongly  rounded.  Width  of  occipital  ring  greater 
than  width  across  posterior  glabellar  ring.  Occipital 
ring  bowed  backward,  summit  at  posterior  margin; 
minute  occipital  tubercle  centrally  situated.  Occipital 


furrow  deep  and  broad  mesially,  expanding  laterally 
into  large,  smooth  muscle  impressions.  LI  not  swollen, 
defined  only  by  short,  oblique  SI;  a  faint  transverse 
depression  marks  off  preoccipital  ring  on  internal  sur- 
face only.  Muscle  scar  Gl  slightly  depressed,  15  per 
cent  length  of  glabella,  placed  at  about  own  length 
anterior  to  occipital  furrow,  30  per  cent  width  of  gla- 
bella; G2  and  G3  indicated  by  faint,  short,  smooth 
lateral  depressions  at  50  per  cent  and  25  per  cent  length 
of  glabella  from  front,  respectively.  Anterior  border  of 
cranidium  extending  only  a  short  distance  laterally  in 
front  of  glabella  and  fixigena.  Axial  furrow  deepening 
steadily  backward,  bowed  inward.  Fixigena  broad,  con- 
vex. Genal  muscle  area  extending  alongside  LI  and 


10 


B 


Text-fig.  5.  Reconstructions  of  the  four  trilobite  species  from  AA  2^.5,  Prongs  Creek.  ^4,  Kosovo- 
peltis  borealis  (Poulsen).  B,  Otarion  (Songkania)  socialis  (Poulsen).  C,  Cromus  princeps  (Poulsen).  D, 
Leonaspis  semiglabra  (Poulsen). 


Gl,  smooth,  slightly  depressed.  Posterior  border  much 
wider  (exsag.)  than  occipital  ring  adaxially,  narrowing 
strongly  to  midwidth  of  fixigena.  Posterior  border  fur- 
row shallow  and  strongly  oblique  adaxially.  Palpebral 
lobe  at  summit  of  fixigena,  opposite  LI,  25  per  cent 
length  of  glabella,  horizontal,  standing  higher  than  gla- 
bella. Eye  ridge  running  obliquely  backward  and  out- 
ward from  opposite  G3,  dying  out  toward  back  of 
palpebral  lobe.  Anterior  branch  of  facial  suture  run- 
ning forward  and  outward,  curving  forward  strongly 
at  anterior  margin.  Posterior  branch  curving  obliquely 
outward,  cutting  posterior  margin  slightly  beyond 
extent  of  palpebral  lobe. 

Librigena  falcate,  sloping  steeply  outward;  genal 
spine  narrowing  slowly  backward,  extending  to  third 
thoracic  segment.  Eye  strongly  convex;  fully  developed 
lenses  hexagonal  in  outline,  0.02  mm  in  diameter  (PI. 
4,  figs.  8,9).  Socle  absent.  Subocular  furrow  broad.  Field 
divided  by  a  depression  widening  and  curving  inward 
toward  back;  outer  area  narrower  and  more  strongly 
swollen,  widening  backward.  Lateral  border  sloping 
inward  to  a  broad  border  furrow,  furrow  also  widening 
backward.  Doublure  strongly  convex,  widening  and 
projecting  at  front,  extending  to  inner  area  of  librigena, 
and  becoming  less  convex  posteriorly. 

Rostral  plate  25  per  cent  as  long  as  wide,  as  wide  as 
glabella  anteriorly,  extending  30  per  cent  sagittal  length 
of  cranidium,  subtrapezoidal  in  outline,  with  anterior 
and  posterior  margins  evenly  convex  forward  and  paral- 
lel. Convexity  moderate;  posterolateral  angle  upturned. 
Rostral  suture  submarginal,  with  connective  sutures 
bowed  gently  inward. 

Hypostome  shield-shaped,  80  per  cent  as  long  as 
wide.  Anterior  wing  narrowly  pointed,  wide  (tr.),  with- 
out articulating  process.  Middle  body  strongly  swollen. 
Middle  furrow  short  but  strong,  marking  off  small  lat- 
eral lobe  and  macula.  Lateral  furrow  broad.  Postero- 
lateral border  of  uniform  width,  with  inward  slope 
decreasing  posteriorly.  Posterior  margin  broadly 
rounded. 

Number  of  thoracic  segments  uncertain  (dorsal 
shield  [PI.  2,  fig.  2]  appears  to  be  complete  with  eight 
segments,  but  has  some  telescoping  at  the  back).  Axis 
25  per  cent  width  of  thorax,  narrowing  slightly  back- 
ward, gently  convex  transversely.  Articulating  half- 
rings  half  sagittal  length  of  rings,  bearing  faint,  trans- 
verse raised  lines.  Pleural  lobe  horizontally  extended 
as  far  as  fulcrum  at  70  per  cent  width,  sloping  gently 
outward  abaxially.  Pleura  narrows  abaxially;  articulat- 
ing facet  bluntly  terminated.  Doublure  extends  to 
fulcrum. 

Pygidium  70  to  85  per  cent  as  long  as  wide,  gently 
convex.  Axis  20  per  cent  length  and  width  of  pygidium, 
swollen.  Articulating  half-ring  strongly  marked  off  by 


continuous  furrow.  Three  rings  distinguishable  on 
internal  surface.  Posterior  area  tripartite,  with  median 
lobe  swollen,  and  marked  off  by  longitudinal  depres- 
sions; three  apodemal  pits  in  longitudinal  depression 
marking  positions  of  fourth  to  sixth  ring  furrows.  Axial 
furrow  uniformly  deep  throughout.  Pleural  lobe  with 
seven  subequal  pairs  of  ribs,  and  a  median  rib  flaring 
posteriorly  to  three  times  anterior  width.  Rib  furrows 
almost  straight,  progressively  wider  and  shallower 
toward  back,  not  quite  reaching  margin.  Longitudinal 
ridge  extending  for  much  of  postaxial  length.  Doublure 
35  per  cent  sagittal  length  of  pygidium,  weakly  convex 
in  ventral  view;  anterior  margin  simple,  marked  on 
dorsal  surface  by  a  low  ridge  separating  convex  inner 
area  of  pleural  lobe  from  concave  outer  area  (holcos 
of  Helbert  et  al.,  1982:132).  Seven  broad  depressions 
corresponding  to  pleural  ribs.  Longitudinal  ridge  ante- 
riorly. Fifteen  or  more  semicontinuous  terrace  ridges 
running  parallel  to  anterior  margin,  fainter,  wavy,  and 
more  closely  spaced  in  outer  area. 

Wavy,  raised  lines  on  surface,  except  in  furrows  and 
muscle  areas,  distantly  spaced,  but  more  closely  spaced 
near  margins.  Lines  run  as  follows:  gently  convex  for- 
ward on  glabella;  convex  inward  on  fixigena,  outward 
on  field  of  librigena;  V  backward  on  lateral  border, 
with  outer  limbs  longer  and  more  closely  spaced;  longi- 
tudinal on  inner  side  of  genal  spine;  forming  a  reticu- 
late pattern  at  base  of  genal  spine;  parallel  to  margin  on 
rostral  plate;  convex  backward  on  hypostome,  including 
macula;  longitudinal  on  thoracic  segments;  oblique  on 
first  two  pygidial  ribs  and  essentially  transverse  on  sub- 
sequent ribs. 


Protaspides.  Protaspis  0.8-0.9  mm  in  sagittal  length 
(PI.  4,  figs.  1,2;  Text-fig.  4A),  subquadrate,  slightly 
wider  than  long.  Cranidium  55  per  cent  total  length; 
glabella  parallel  sided,  25  per  cent  width  of  cranidium, 
strongly  convex  transversely,  weakly  convex  longitudi- 
nally. Occipital  ring  as  wide  as  glabella,  convex.  Occipi- 
tal furrow  broad,  more  shallow  than  axial  furrow.  Axial 
furrow  deep  and  broad.  Cheek  broad  and  subquadrate, 
strongly  convex  and  downturned  laterally,  apparently 
without  border  or  librigena;  a  pair  of  tubercles,  70  per 
cent  maximum  width  of  protaspis  apart,  toward  front. 
Posterior  border  15  per  cent  sagittal  length  of  crani- 
dium, sharply  convex.  Posterior  border  furrow  deep 
and  broad.  Genal  spine  not  preserved.  Pygidium  tripar- 
tite, very  strongly  inflated,  comprising  three  segments 
ending  in  free  points,  and  a  broadly  rounded  unseg- 
mented  area  with  a  fourth  pair  of  small  free  points 
laterally.  Axis  15  per  cent  width  of  pygidium  anteriorly; 
narrowing  backward  to  a  point  at  posterior  margin; 
separating,  but  lower  than,  the  even  more  strongly  con- 


12 


vex  pleural  lobes;  with  three  rings  strongly  marked  off 
by  broad  ring  furrows.  Axial  furrow  strong.  First  and 
second  pleural  ribs  almost  as  strongly  developed  as 
occipital  segment,  becoming  less  swollen  laterally  and 
produced  into  slender,  backwardly  directed  spines  15 
per  cent  sagittal  length  of  protaspis.  Third  pleural  rib 
weak.  Third  spine  at  least  as  long  as  first  and  second, 
projecting  beyond  margin  for  half  its  length. 


Meraspides.  Meraspid  cranidium  1.5  mm  in  sagittal 
length  (PI.  4,  figs.  3,4;  Text-fig.  4C),  Raymondaspis -like 
in  its  subparallel-sided  glabella.  Glabella  80  per  cent 
as  wide  as  long,  with  basal  width  60  per  cent  anterior 
width,  strongly  convex  anteriorly.  Axial  furrow  deep. 
Anterior  border  indistinct  mesially,  developing  abaxi- 
ally;  anterior  margin  flexed  upward  mesially.  Fixigena 
strongly  convex,  twice  width  of  glabella  at  back;  eye 
ridge  near  front  almost  transverse.  Posterior  border 
depressed,  transverse.  Posterior  border  furrow  widens 
abaxially,  shallow.  Transverse  raised  lines  on  glabella; 
fixigena  faintly  granular. 

Smallest  transitory  pygidium  0.4  mm  in  sagittal 
length  (PI.  4,  figs.  12,13;  Text-fig.  4B),  incorporating 
four  segments  with  free  points.  Articulating  half-ring 
as  long  as  first  ring,  strongly  convex.  First  free  point 
directed  outwardly,  second  obliquely,  third  and  fourth 
posteriorly,  hindmost  longest  and  projecting  well 
beyond  posterior  margin.  Convexity  of  pleural  lobe  of 
future  pygidium  increasing  rapidly  backward,  rising 
above  axial  area.  Surface  finely  granular. 

Transitory  pygidium  0.8  mm  in  sagittal  length  (PI.  4, 
figs.  10,11;  Text-fig.  4D),  incorporating  six  segments 
with  free  points.  Triangular  in  outline,  50  per  cent  as 
long  as  wide.  Segments  decreasing  in  definition  back- 
ward, and  free  points  becoming  less  oblique.  Future 
pygidium  strongly  convex;  axis  shorter,  more  elevated 
above  convex  pleural  lobe.  Surface  granular. 

Transitory  pygidium  2.5  mm  in  sagittal  length  (PI.  4, 
figs.  6,7;  Text-fig.  4E),  incorporating  two  protothoracic 
segments  with  free  points  and  pygidium  with  seven 
pleural  ribs.  Triangular  in  outline,  55  per  cent  as  long 
as  wide.  Axis  20  per  cent  anterior  width,  50  per  cent 
length.  Free  points  becoming  successively  shorter. 
Pygidium  convex  toward  back,  axis  not  depressed.  Sur- 
face smooth. 

Transitory  pygidium  2.8  mm  in  sagittal  length  (PI.  4, 
fig.  5;  Text-fig.  4F),  incorporating  one  protothoracic 
segment  with  free  points.  Future  pygidium  with  four 
axial  rings,  large  and  swollen  terminus,  and  seven  pleu- 
ral ribs;  broadly  rounded  and  more  adult  in  outline,  60 
per  cent  as  long  as  wide.  Pygidium  strongly  convex, 
particularly  at  back.  Axis  20  per  cent  width  and  35  per 
cent  length.  First  two  pygidial  ribs  much  wider  (exsag.) 


than  subsequent  pleurae.  Surface  smooth. 


DISCUSSION 

K.  borealis  (Poulsen,  1934:27,  pi.  3,  figs.  14,15)  from 
the  Cape  Schuchert  Formation,  North  Greenland,  was 
based  on  four  cranidia.  Cranidia  from  the  Road  River 
Formation  are  identical  in  gross  morphology.  Minor 
features  supporting  specific  identity  are  the  minute 
occipital  tubercle  and  heavy  occipital  prosopon.  The 
Road  River  specimens  are  distinguished  from  the  Kap 
Schuchert  material  by  the  following  differences:  (1)  the 
prosopon  of  raised  lines  is  more  dense;  (2)  granulation 
of  the  exoskeleton  is  absent;  (3)  the  eye  ridge  is  broader 
(exsag.). 

The  species  complies  with  Snajdr's  diagnosis  oiKoso- 
vopeltis  (1958:177;  1960:65).  It  differs  from  the  type 
species,  K.  svobodai  Snajdr,  and  from  K.  partschi,  both 
from  the  Kopanina  Formation  of  Czechoslovakia,  in 
that  the  glabella  expands  evenly  and  not  abruptly  near 
the  front,  and  that  the  pygidium  is  more  broadly 
rounded. 

Two  scutelluine  ontogenies  have  been  described 
from  well-preserved  material  of  the  Taemas  Formation 
(Lower  Devonian)  of  New  South  Wales:  Dentaloscutel- 
lum  hudsoni  Chatterton  (1971:12,  pi.  1,  figs.  1-22;  pi.  2, 
figs.  1-14;  pi.  3,  figs.  1-12;  pi.  24,  fig.  15)  and  Scutellum 
calvum  Chatterton  (1971:22,  pi.  3,  figs.  21,22;  pi.  4,  figs. 
1-24;  pi.  5,  figs.  1-24).  The  Road  River  Formation 
protaspides  described  above  bear  a  general  resem- 
blance to  the  late  protaspides  of  both  species  from  the 
Taemas  Formation,  differing  in  having  a  narrow  and 
parallel-sided  glabella,  broad  fixigena,  and  longer 
spines.  The  meraspid  cranidium  from  the  Road  River 
Formation  differs  in  having  broader  fixigena  and  large 
eyes  that  are  forwardly  placed,  and  in  lacking  an  occipi- 
tal spine.  There  is  a  close  resemblance  between  the 
smallest  transitory  pygidia  of  K.  borealis  and  S.  calvum 
(Chatterton,  1971,  text-fig.  6D);  larger  transitory  pygi- 
dia of  K  borealis  differ  from  those  of  5.  calvum  in  having 
protothoracic  spines  of  equal  length  (cf.  alternating 
lengths).  The  adult  oiK.  borealis  does  not  resemble  the 
adult  of  either  Taemas  Formation  species. 

Snajdr  (1960,  pi.  3,  fig.  6)  has  illustrated  a  meraspid 
cranidium  of  the  type  species  bearing  an  occipital  spine; 
this  spine  was  lost  in  the  hoiaspis.  It  is  unlikely  that 
such  a  spine  was  present  in  K.  borealis. 

Feist  (1970)  has  described  protaspides  and  meras- 
pides of  Breviscutellum  (Meridioscutellum)  sp.  from  the 
Emsian  and  Eifelian  of  the  Montagne  Noire,  France. 
The  smallest  protaspis,  1.96  mm  in  sagittal  length,  has 
8  protothoracic  segments  developed;  the  largest  has  10, 
the  number  in  the  adult.  These  protaspides  contrast 
sharply  with  those  from  the  Road  River  Formation 


13 


described  above  in  most  features;  our  largest  protas- 
pides  are  0.9  mm  in  length  and  have  only  4  segments, 
indicated  by  free  points.  There  is  some  similarity  in  the 
meraspides  in  the  development  of  the  adult  pygidial 
characters. 


in  K.  borealis,  with  terrace  ridges  more  widely  spaced 
and  more  strongly  scalloped.  The  three  pygidia  differ 
from  each  other  in  the  construction  of  the  axis  and  the 
median  rib,  amongst  other  features,  but  all  are  probably 
attributable  to  Kosovopeltis. 


Kosovopeltisl  spp. 

PI.  9,  figs.  8-11 


Indeterminate  scutelluine 

PI.  11,  figs.  6,7 


MATERIAL 

From  BB  131  (Lower  Silurian),  Illtyd  Range:  1  crani- 
dium,  3  pygidia. 


MATERIAL 

From  AA  95  (Upper  Silurian),  Prongs  Creek:  1  cra- 
nidium. 


DISCUSSION 

The  fragmentary  cranidium  differs  from  K.  borealis  in 
having  a  straighter  axial  furrow,  longer  occipital  ring, 
weaker  occipital  furrow,  narrower  fixigena,  and  small 
palpebral  lobe  posteriorly  placed.  The  three  pygidia 
belong  to  more  than  one  species.  All  differ  from  K. 
borealis  in  having  a  wider  axis,  more  strongly  curved 
posterior  rib  furrows,  and  an  evenly  convex  surface; 
one  specimen  shows  the  doublure,  which  is  longer  than 


DISCUSSION 

This  cranidium  differs  from  Paracybantyx  asulcatus  sp. 
nov.  in  being  less  convex  and  in  having  an  anterior 
border,  a  faint  occipital  furrow,  a  smaller  genal  muscle 
area  and  palpebral  lobe,  broader  fixigena,  a  conspicu- 
ous eye  line,  and  coarsely  pitted  prosopon.  The  crani- 
dium is  somewhat  similar  to  that  of  Planiscutellum 
kitharos  Lane  and  Thomas  {in  Thomas,  1978:27,  pi.  6, 
figs.  1-8)  from  the  British  Wenlock,  but  it  has  a  much 
wider  axis  and  a  faint  occipital  furrow. 


Family  Illaenidae  Hawie  and  Corda,  1847 
Subfamily  Illaeninae  HawIe  and  Corda,  1847 


Genus  Stenopareia  Holm,  1886 

TYPE  SPECIES 

Illaenus  linnarssoni  Holm,  1882,  Boda  Limestone  (Ash- 
gill),  Dalarna,  Sweden. 


cent  length  of  cranidium,  at  own  length  from  posterior 
margin.  Axial  furrows  convergent.  Dendritic  muscle 
impressions  strongly  developed  on  glabella  and  fixi- 
gena. Axis  of  pygidium  subtriangular,  long,  and  wide. 


Stenopareia  illtyd  sp.  nov. 

PI.  5,  figs.  1-11 

DERIVATION  OF  NAME 

Specific  name  derived  from  the  Illtyd  Range,  Yukon 
Territory. 

HOLOTYPE 

ROM  42168  (cranidium,  PI.  5,  figs.  3,4),  locality  BB  131 
(Lower  Silurian),  unnamed  carbonates,  Illtyd  Range, 
Yukon  Territory,  Canada. 

MATEIUAL 

From  BB  131  (Lower  Silurian),  Illtyd  Range:  9  crani- 
dia,  6  pygidia. 

DIAGNOSIS 

Cranidium  with  strong  convexity;  palpebral  lobes  1 0  per 


DESCRIPTION 

Length  (in  normal  view)  65  to  80  per  cent  width,  con- 
vexity strong.  Glabella  55  per  cent  basal  width,  narrow- 
ing forward,  but  widening  slightly  at  forefont; 
independent  convexity  slight.  On  internal  moulds  of 
glabella,  shallow  radiating  ridges  and  furrows  arranged 
in  dendritic  pattern  alongside  smooth  median  area; 
foremost  ridge  large,  extending  beyond  glabella,  and 
continuous  with  ridges  radiating  in  a  quarter  segment 
from  posterior  inner  extremity  of  fixigena.  Axial  furrow 
broad,  directed  inward  for  most  of  length,  widening 
into  shallow  depressed  lunule,  and  curving  outward 
at  front.  Fixigena  sloping  steeply  outward  with  weak 
convexity.  Palpebral  lobe  10  per  cent  length  of  crani- 
dium, situated  at  own  length  from  posterior  margin, 
level,  and  continuous  with  fixigena.  Anterior  branch  of 
facial  suture  running  almost  straight  forward  from  eye; 
posterior  branch  running  outward  and  backward.  Inter- 
nal surface  smooth  except  for  muscle  impressions. 


14 


External  surface  sparsely  pitted.  Faint,  transverse 
raised  lines  on  front  of  cranidium. 

Pygidium  50  to  60  per  cent  as  long  as  wide,  convexity 
strong  posteriorly.  Axis  subtriangular,  35  per  cent  ante- 
rior width,  undefined  at  back  except  by  slight  convexity. 
Axial  furrow  broad  and  shallow  anteriorly,  becoming 
steadily  shallower  and  dying  out  anterior  to  midlength. 
Pleural  lobe  sloping  steeply  outward,  anterolateral 
angle  narrowly  rounded,  facet  steep.  Surface  covered 
with  transverse  anastomosing  wavy  lines  on  well-pre- 
served specimens. 

DISCUSSION 

S.  illtyd  sp.  nov.  closely  resembles  5.?  julli  Norford 
(1981:7,  pi.  6;  pi.  10,  figs.  8-10)  from  the  Attawapiskat 
Formation  of  northern  Ontario,  but  differs  in  having 
much  stronger  cranidial  axial  furrows  and  a  less  trian- 
gular pygidium.  In  both  species,  the  muscle  scars,  or 
caecal  markings,  on  glabellae  and  fixigenae  are  compa- 
rable. Both  species  also  resemble  Stenopareia  sp.  of 
Lane  (1972:348,  pi.  61,  figs.  13-15)  from  the  Drommebj- 
erg  Limestone  (Lower  Silurian),  northeastern  Green- 
land, a  species  with  comparable  muscle  scars  that  are 
preserved  on  the  external  surface  of  the  glabella  only. 


Indeterminate  illaenid 

PI.  5,  fig.  12 

MATERIAL 

From  BB  131  (Lower  Silurian),  Illtyd  Range:  1 
cephalon. 

DESCRIPTION 

Cephalon  50  per  cent  as  long  as  wide,  strongly  convex. 
Glabella  as  long  as  wide,  parallel  sided.  Palpebral  lobe 
35  per  cent  length  of  cephalon,  50  per  cent  own  length 
from  posterior  margin.  Librigena  narrow,  gently  con- 
vex. Eye  separated  from  cheek  by  broad  depression. 
Genal  angle  broadly  rounded.  Surface  of  cranidium 
with  extremely  faint  raised  lines  convergent  backward 
on  glabella;  minute  occipital  tubercle  posteriorly 
placed. 

DISCUSSION 

The  cephalon  differs  from  S.  illtyd  in  having  a  parallel- 
sided  glabella,  shallower  axial  furrows,  and  compara- 
tively large  eyes  sited  far  back.  It  is  unlikely  that  this 
cephalon  can  be  included  in  Stenopareia,  and  its  generic 
affinities  are  not  clear. 


Family  Proetidae  Salter,  1864 
?Subfamily  Crassiproetinae  Osmolska,  1970 


Genus  Hedstroemia  Pfibyl  and  Vanek,  1978 

TYPE  SPECIES 

Proetus  delicatus  Hedstrom  (1923:4,  pi.  1,  figs.  1-15), 
Halla  Beds,  unit  b  (upper,  probably  uppermost,  Wen- 
lock),  Horsne  Canal,  Gotland,  Sweden. 


nine  rings  and  eight  pairs  of  pleurae.  Prosopon  finely 
granular. 

MATERIAL 

From  AA  95  (Upper  Silurian),  Prongs  Creek:  9  crani- 
dia,  14  librigenae,  2  hypostomes,  40  pygidia. 


Hedstroemia  kutchini  sp.  nov. 

Pi.  6,  figs.  1-14 

DERIVATION  OF  NAME 

Species  named  after  the  Kutchin  tribe  who  formerly 
inhabited  extensive  areas  of  the  northern  Yukon  Ter- 
ritory. 

HOLOTYPE 

ROM  45347  (cranidium,  PI.  6,  figs.  3,4),  locality  AA 
95  (Upper  Silurian),  Road  River  Formation,  Prongs 
Creek,  Yukon  Territory,  Canada. 

DIAGNOSIS 

Cephalon  with  intramarginal  ridge  between  field  and 
border.  Genal  spine  absent.  Pygidium  elongate  with 


DESCRIPTION 

Glabella  90  per  cent  sagittal  length  of  cranidium,  80  to 
90  per  cent  as  wide  as  long,  moderately  convex,  strongly 
defined,  olive  shaped  or  tongue  shaped  in  outline. 
Occipital  ring  narrowing  rapidly  abaxially,  with  small 
occipital  tubercle  placed  slightly  posterior  to  mid- 
length.  Occipital  furrow  and  axial  furrow  moderately 
deep  and  narrow.  Occipital  lobe  large,  convex,  strongly 
demarcated,  extending  sideways  well  beyond  main  part 
of  ring.  LI  faintly  defined,  with  slight  independent  con- 
vexity, almost  30  per  cent  maximum  glabellar  width. 
SI  convex  forward,  directed  inward  and  backward,  wid- 
ening near  midlength,  fading  at  back;  SI  bifurcates 
adaxially,  with  anterior  branch  short,  shallow,  and 
transverse.  S2  shallow,  25  per  cent  width  of  glabella, 
directed  slightly  backward,  situated  at  35  per  cent 
length  of  glabella  from  front.  S3  faint,  parallel  to  S2, 
situated  at  25  per  cent  length  of  glabella  from  front. 


15 


Anterior  border  of  uniform  width  (sag.,  exsag.), 
upturned,  convex,  wider  (tr.)  than  glabella.  Anterior 
border  furrow  deep  and  broad.  Between  front  of  fixi- 
gena  and  anterior  border  furrow,  a  uniformly  narrow 
and  slightly  oblique  intramarginal  ridge,  continuous  or 
discontinuous  mesially,  marked  off  from  preocular  area 
of  fixigena  by  a  clear-cut  furrow  and  by  independent 
convexity;  prosopon  agreeing  with  the  anterior  border 
and  differing  from  the  preocular  fixigena  in  lacking 
granulation;  this  ridge  continuing  onto  the  librigena. 
Preocular  area  of  fixigena  moderately  swollen.  Palpe- 
bral lobe  25  per  cent  length  of  cranidium,  horizontal, 
with  midlength  just  posterior  to  front  of  SI  and  anterior 
extremity  just  posterior  to  S2;  palpebral  furrow  faint, 
shallow,  running  parallel  to  margin.  Postocular  fixigena 
unknown.  Anterior  branch  of  facial  suture  commencing 
close  to  axial  furrow,  curving  forward  and  outward  at 
first,  and  then  running  longitudinally.  Glabella,  preocu- 
lar fixigena,  and  palpebral  lobe,  except  in  furrows, 
closely,  uniformly,  and  finely  granular;  anterior  border 
smooth  except  for  raised  lines  running  parallel  to 
margin. 

Eye  strongly  convex,  sloping  outward,  with  subocular 
furrow  deep  and  broad.  Socle  swollen,  narrowing  back- 
ward, marked  off  by  a  strong  furrow.  Field  gently  con- 
vex; intramarginal  ridge  at  front  of  fixigena  continuing 
abaxially  on  field  of  librigena  as  a  lateral  ridge,  widen- 
ing somewhat  backward  and  dying  out  before  reaching 
posterior  border  furrow.  Lateral  border  furrow  slightly 
stronger  than  furrow  marking  off  the  lateral  ridge  and 
also  dying  out  before  posterior  border  furrow.  Lateral 
and  posterior  borders  strongly  convex,  confluent.  Genal 
angle  broadly  rounded.  Field  coarsely  and  shallowly 
pitted,  matching  prosopon  of  fixigena.  Surface  of  field 
roughened,  with  raised  lines  parallel  to  margin  on  lat- 
eral border. 

Hypostome  as  wide  as  long.  Middle  body  large,  well 
defined,  convex,  extending  to  anterior  margin.  Middle 
furrow  oblique,  short  and  shallow,  commencing  at  65 
per  cent  length  of  middle  body  from  front.  Lateral  lobe 
with  oval  macula  abaxially,  merging  with  middle  body 
adaxially.  Lateral  furrow  deepens  and  widens  steadily 
backward,  continuous  with  posterior  furrow,  which  is 
broad  and  strongly  convex  backward.  Lateral  borders 
raised,  subparallel,  widening  steadily  backward,  and 
slightly  outturned  just  posterior  to  level  of  middle  fur- 
rows. Posterior  border  depressed,  strongly  convex  back- 
ward in  outline.  Anterolateral  wing  subquadrate, 
downturned;  articulating  process  absent.  Middle  body 
faintly  and  coarsely  pitted,  bearing  raised  lines  mesi- 
ally, divergent  backward  for  most  of  length,  transverse 
anteriorly.  Raised  lines  on  lateral  border  running  paral- 
lel to  margin. 

Pygidium  60  to  75  per  cent  as  long  as  wide,  strongly 


convex  in  both  directions,  high  in  profile,  with  height 
60  to  70  per  cent  sagittal  length.  Axis  convex,  45  to  50 
per  cent  maximum  width  and  80  to  90  per  cent  length 
of  pygidium,  narrowing  strongly  backward  to  rounded 
tip,  composed  of  nine  rings  and  a  short  terminus.  Ring 
furrows  shallow,  gently  sinuous,  bowed  backward  mesi- 
ally; furrows  toward  front  strong,  becoming  successively 
fainter  toward  back,  particularly  abaxially.  Paired  mus- 
cle insertion  scars  distinguishable  on  some  specimens. 
Axial  furrow  clear  cut.  Pleural  lobe  convex.  Seven  well- 
defined  pleurae;  eighth  faint.  First  pleural  furrow 
broad,  narrowing  abaxially,  but  reaching  lateral  margin; 
first  interpleural  furrow  well  developed,  dying  out  at 
lateral  depression.  Subsequent  pleural  and  interpleural 
furrows  successively  fainter,  dying  out  at  lateral  depres- 
sion. Lateral  border  uniformly  narrow,  sloping  outward 
with  moderate  convexity.  Border  depression  strong  but 
ending  at  first  pleura.  Articulating  facet  smooth.  Sur- 
face densely  but  somewhat  variably  granular. 


DISCUSSION 

H.  kutchini  sp.  nov.  closely  resembles  the  type  species, 
H.  delicata  (Hedstrom,  1923:4,  pi.  1,  figs.  1-15),  Halla 
Beds,  Horsne  Canal,  Gotland,  Sweden;  an  allied  form 
has  been  described  under  open  nomenclature  by  Hel- 
bert  et  al.  (1982:138)  from  the  Lower  Silurian  of  the 
Oslo  Region,  Norway.  Bob  Owens  (pers.  comm.,  1987) 
confirms  that  H.  delicata  has  a  flat  intramarginal  area 
between  the  border  furrow  and  the  change  of  slope  of 
the  field  of  the  fixigena  and  librigena,  comparable  with 
the  intramarginal  ridge  of  H.  kutchini;  Owens  also  con- 
firms that  H.  kutchini  differs  from  H.  delicata  in  having 
stronger  lateral  glabellar  furrows  and  a  less-angular 
frontal  glabellar  lobe,  in  lacking  a  genal  spine,  in  having 
a  hypostome  with  more  pronounced  posterior  wings 
and  a  broader  posterior  border  furrow,  and  in  having  a 
pygidium  composed  of  fewer  segments  with  a  narrower 
border.  Shared  features  are  the  greatly  swollen  occipi- 
tal lobes;  similar  hypostomes,  particularly  as  regards 
the  prosopon;  and  the  faint  pygidial  ring  furrows  with 
paired  muscle  scars  abaxially.  H.  kutchini  bears  a  resem- 
blance to  Coniproetus  {Coniproetus)  affinis  affinis 
(Boucek,  1933;  see  Snajdr,  1980:73,  pi.  9,  figs.  3-11), 
from  the  basal  Lochov  Formation  (Lochovian),  Repor- 
yje,  Prague,  Czechoslovakia,  particularly  as  regards  gla- 
bellar features,  the  librigena,  the  hypostome,  and  the 
distinctably  faint  ring  furrows  of  the  pygidium.  H.  kut- 
chini differs  in  having  stronger  lateral  glabellar  furrows, 
a  narrower  (sag.,  exsag.)  anterior  border,  more  posteri- 
orly placed  palpebral  lobes,  an  intramarginal  ridge,  and 
a  more  elongate  pygidium  with  eight  pleural  ribs.  The 
pygidium  of//,  kutchini  also  differs  in  proportions,  and 
in  having  stronger  pleural  segmentation,  and  a  much 


16 


narrower  and  more  strongly  defined  border;  these 
pygidial  features  readily  distinguish  Hedstroemia  from 
Coniproetus. 

The  hypostome  bears  a  resemblance  to  that  of  Co- 
niproetus (C)  whittakerensis  (Chatterton  and  Perry, 
1977,  pi.  1,  figs.  7-10)  from  the  Early  Devonian  of 
northwestern  Canada,  but  differs  in  having  a  more- 
rounded  posterior  border  and  raised  lines  on  the  front 
of  the  middle  body  that  run  transversely,  not  longitudi- 
nally. There  is  little  resemblance  between  the  cranidia 
of  the  two  species — H.  kutchini  has  a  much  broader  (tr.) 
glabella,  and  narrower  (sag.,  exsag.)  anterior  border. 


Hedstroemia  sourdoughi  sp.  nov. 

PI.  6,  figs.  16-24 

DERIVATION  OF  NAME 

Species  named  after  those  prospectors  (Sourdoughs) 
who  chose  the  all-Canadian  route  to  the  goldfields — 
down  the  Mackenzie  River,  up  the  Peel  River,  up  the 
Wind  River,  past  Prongs  Creek,  and  then  overland  to 
the  Klondike. 

HOLOTYPE 

ROM  45332  (cranidium,  PI.  6,  figs.  22,23),  locality  AA 
95  (Upper  Silurian),  Road  River  Formation,  Prongs 
Creek,  Yukon  Territory,  Canada. 

DIAGNOSIS 

Glabella  strongly  convex,  frontal  lobe  rounded.  Pygi- 
dium  short,  composed  of  eight  rings  and  six  pairs  of 
pleurae;  axis  comparatively  narrow;  ring  furrows  well 
defined;  border  broad.  Prosopon  coarsely  granular. 


MATERIAL 

From  AA  95  (Upper  Silurian),  Prongs  Creek:  8  crani- 
dia, 2  librigenae,  25  pygidia. 

DESCRIPTION 

Cranidium  closely  similar  to//,  kutchini  sp.  nov.  in  many 
respects,  differing  in  the  following  features.  Glabella 
more  convex.  Occipital  tubercle  small  or  absent.  Occi- 
pital furrow  deeper,  SI  stronger,  S2  and  S3  fainter. 
Intramarginal  ridge  present  but  discontinuous  mesially. 
Pygidium  shorter,  50  to  60  per  cent  as  long  as  wide. 
Axis  of  eight  rings  and  a  short  terminus;  ring  furrows 
much  deeper  and  less  sinuous.  Paired  muscle  insertion 
scars  distinct  on  surface  of  most  specimens.  Pleural 
lobe  more  convex,  with  six  pleurae  and  deeper  and 
broader  border  depression;  border  broader,  of  uniform 
width.  Prosopon  of  cranidium  and  pygidium  coarsely 
and  densely  (cf.  finely)  granular. 

DISCUSSION 

H.  sourdoughi  sp.  nov.  closely  resembles  //.  kutchini  sp. 
nov.  in  cranidial  features,  particularly  in  the  presence 
of  the  intramarginal  ridge.  It  also  stands  close  to  Co- 
niproetus bohemicus  Hawle  and  Corda  (see  Snajdr, 
1980:58,  pi.  6,  figs.  1-14;  pi.  61,  fig.  4;  pi.  63,  fig.  6)  from 
the  Koneprusy  Limestone,  Czechoslovakia,  particularly 
as  regards  glabellar  outline,  the  definition  of  the  lateral 
glabellar  furrows,  strong  pygidial  ring  furrows,  broad 
pygidial  border,  and  coarse  prosopon.  H.  sourdoughi  sp. 
nov.  differs  from  H.  kutchini  in  having  an  intramarginal 
ridge  and  stronger  pygidial  furrows.  The  cranidium 
of  //.  sourdoughi  differs  from  that  of  C.  bohemicus  in 
having  a  narrower  (sag.)  anterior  border,  smaller  palpe- 
bral lobes,  and  an  intramarginal  ridge  (discontinuous 
mesially). 


Subfamily  Warburgellinae  Owens,  1973 


Genus  Prantlia  Pfibyl,  1946 

TYPE  SPECIES 

Proetus  longulus  Hawle  and  Corda,  1847,  Kopanina 
Formation,  Upper  Silurian,  Prague  district,  Czecho- 
slovakia. 


Prantlia  vagrans  sp.  nov. 

PI.  7,  figs.  1-15 


HOLOTYPE 

ROM  45363  (pygidium,  PI.  7,  figs.  6,7),  locality  AA 
95  (Upper  Silurian),  Road  River  Formation,  Prongs 
Creek,  Yukon  Territory,  Canada. 

DIAGNOSIS 

A  warburgelline  with  short  frontal  area,  glabella  80  per 
cent  sagittal  length  of  cranidium,  supplementary  lobe 
adaxial  to  LI,  strong  SI,  and  posterior  bands  of  second 
and  third  pygidial  pleurae  crossing  border. 


DERIVATION  OF  NAME 

Specific  name  derived  from  Latin  vagrans  (wandering), 
in  allusion  to  the  wide  distribution  of  this  genus. 


MATERIAL 

From  AA  95  (Upper  Silurian),  Prongs  Creek:  16  crani- 
dia, 22  librigenae,  48  pygidia. 


17 


DESCRIPTION 

Glabella  80  per  cent  sagittal  length  of  cranidium,  75 
per  cent  as  wide  as  long,  moderately  convex,  strongly 
defined,  anterior  outline  narrowly  rounded.  Occipital 
ring  narrowing  rapidly  abaxially;  occipital  tubercle 
small,  centrally  placed.  Occipital  lobe  large,  convex, 
strongly  demarcated,  extending  sideways  well  beyond 
main  part  of  ring.  Occipital  furrow  deep  and  moder- 
ately broad.  LI  strongly  defined,  subtriangular,  with 
strong  independent  convexity,  30  per  cent  maximum 
glabellar  width.  SI  deepening  rapidly,  running 
obliquely  inward  and  backward,  shallowing  and  widen- 
ing at  back.  In  several  specimens,  SI  forming  a  short, 
transverse  branch  of  varying  strength  toward  front  of 
LI,  defining  a  small  supplementary  lobe  marked  by 
a  short  furrow  posteriorly  and  by  slight  independent 
convexity.  S2  faintly  impressed,  25  per  cent  width  of 
glabella,  almost  transverse,  situated  at  30  per  cent 
length  of  glabella  from  front.  S3  as  S2  but  slightly  con- 
vergent forward,  situated  at  25  per  cent  length  of  gla- 
bella from  front.  Axial  furrow  straight,  extremely  deep 
and  broad.  Preglabellar  area  marked  off  from  preocu- 
lar  fixigenae  by  a  shallow,  almost  transverse  depression. 
Anterior  border  one-third  length  of  preglabellar  area, 
hardly  narrowing  abaxially,  convex.  Anterior  border 
furrow  shallow  but  distinct.  Frontal  area  weakly  convex 
and  marked  off  from  the  more  strongly  convex  preocu- 
lar  fixigena  by  a  faint  but  broad  depression  convex 
forward.  Palpebral  lobe  small,  25  per  cent  length  of 
cranidium,  horizontal,  with  anterior  extremity  opposite 
S2;  palpebral  furrow  faint,  shallow.  Postocular  fixigena 
unknown.  Anterior  branch  of  facial  suture  commencing 
close  to  axial  furrow,  curving  forward  and  outward,  and 
bending  inward  at  anterior  border  furrow.  Glabella 
closely  granular,  except  in  furrows,  with  granulation 
becoming  finer  toward  front;  anterior  border  finely 
granular,  with  delicate  raised  lines  running  parallel  to 
that  border;  preglabellar  area  and  preocular  fixigena 
coarsely  and  shallowly  pitted,  with  raised  lines  and  a 
few  scattered  granules;  palpebral  lobe  finely  granular. 
Eye  strongly  convex  and  sloping  outward,  separated 
by  shallow  furrow  from  low,  narrow  socle  set  on  a  ridge 
narrowing  backward.  Field  convex.  Lateral  border  fur- 
row deep  and  broad,  continuing  into  genal  spine;  lateral 
border  ill  defined,  half  minimum  width  of  field,  extend- 
ing alongside  genal  spine.  Posterior  border  strongly 
developed  and  extended  alongside  broad-based  genal 
spine  reaching  backward  for  about  35  per  cent  esti- 
mated sagittal  length  of  cephalon.  Field  coarsely  and 
shallowly  pitted,  matching  prosopon  of  fixigena.  Closely 
spaced  raised  lines  run  forward  and  inward  on  outer 
area  of  lateral  border;  posterior  to  midlength,  raised 
lines  become  chevron  shaped,  with  shorter,  posteriorly 


directed  limb  on  inner  area  of  border;  posterior  border 
with  similar  prosopon  alongside  spine. 

Pygidium  60  to  70  per  cent  as  long  as  wide,  moder- 
ately convex  in  both  directions.  Axis  30  to  35  per  cent 
maximum  width  of  pygidium,  85  to  90  per  cent  length 
of  pygidium,  narrowing  slowly  backward  to  rounded 
tip,  composed  of  twelve  rings  and  a  short  terminus. 
Ring  furrows  gently  sinuous,  strong  anteriorly,  becom- 
ing successively  fainter,  particularly  abaxially.  Axial 
furrow  narrow.  Pleural  lobe  convex;  border  depression 
strong  but  dying  out  at  first  pleura.  Seven  well-defined 
pleurae;  eighth  faint.  First  pleural  furrow  broad,  nar- 
rowing abaxially,  but  reaching  lateral  margin;  first  inter- 
pleural furrow  uniformly  narrow  and  shallow,  just 
reaching  lateral  margin.  Subsequent  pleural  and  inter- 
pleural furrows  deep  and  broad  adaxially,  successively 
fainter,  and  dying  out  at  lateral  border  furrow,  except 
second  and  third  posterior  bands  and  interpleural  fur- 
rows extending  halfway  across  lateral  border.  Lateral 
border  narrowing  slightly  forward,  sloping  outward 
with  moderate  convexity.  Articulating  facet  smooth. 
Doublure  as  wide  as  lateral  border.  Ten  almost-contin- 
uous terrace  lines  running  subparallel  to  margin.  Sur- 
face granular;  raised  lines  directed  inward  and  forward 
on  anterior  part  of  border.  One  pygidium  (PI.  7,  fig.  13) 
showing  a  deformity  in  having  a  slight  embayment  in 
the  posterior  outline. 

A  meraspid  cranidium,  2.2  mm  in  sagittal  length  (PI. 
7,  fig.  10),  differing  little  from  adult  cranidium  except 
in  its  narrower  glabella  and  smaller  occipital  lobe. 


DISCUSSION 

P.  vagrans  sp.  nov.  bears  a  close  resemblance  to  the 
type  species,  Prantlia  longula  Snajdr  (1980:180,  pi.  34, 
figs.  1-8),  in  many  respects,  such  as  the  following:  gla- 
bellar outline,  development  of  the  lateral  glabellar  fur- 
rows, large  occipital  lobes,  segmentation  and  narrow 
axis  of  pygidium,  and  the  manner  in  which  the  lateral 
border  furrow  dies  out  at  the  first  pleura.  P.  vagrans 
differs  from  the  type  species  in  the  following  features: 
(1)  the  glabella  is  80  per  cent  the  length  of  the  crani- 
dium (cf.  65  to  70  per  cent),  the  preglabellar  field  being 
much  shorter;  (2)  S2  is  transverse  (cf.  slightly  conver- 
gent backward);  (3)  the  frontal  lobe  is  narrower;  (4) 
the  pygidium  is  relatively  longer,  being  comprised  of  12 
(cf.  10)  rings,  and  has  a  narrower  and  more  convex 
border;  (5)  the  postaxial  ridge  on  the  pygidium  is 
absent. 

The  librigena  of  P.  vagrans  resembles  that  of  the 
warburgelline  Tetinia  in  morphology  and  also  particu- 
larly in  the  oblique  raised  lines  on  the  outer  area  of  the 
lateral  border.  Prantlia  differs  from  Warburgella  in  the 


18 


absence  of  the  tropidium. 

Other  species  of  Prantlia — P.  longifrons  (Lindstrom, 
1885),  from  the  Hemse  Beds  (Upper  Silurian),  Got- 
land, Sweden;  P.  grindrodi  Owens  (1973;  Thomas, 
1978),  Wenlock  Shale,  Malvern,  United  Kingdom;  and 
P.  canberrensis  Chatterton  and  Campbell  (1980),  Lower 
Silurian,  Canberra,  Australia — differ  considerably 
from  the  type  species  and  from  P.  vagrans,  as  the  com- 
parison in  Table  2  demonstrates;  the  subgenus  Ma/vem- 
ocare  has  been  proposed  for  P.  grindrodi  by  Pfibyl  and 
Vanek  (1978).  Chatterton  and  Campbell  (1980:85)  con- 
sidered Latiproetus  Lu  (1962:162)  to  be  synonymous 


with  Prantlia,  drawing  attention  to  the  similarity 
between  the  type  species  L.  latilimbatus  (Grabau)  and 
P.  grindrodi.  Kobayashi  (1985:419)  considered  Latiproe- 
tus to  be  valid,  and  he  referred  Prantlia  biloba  Koba- 
yashi and  Hamada  (1974:118,  pi.  12,  figs.  8,9a,b), 
Okanari,  Shikoku  Island,  Japan,  to  Latiproetus;  he 
regarded  Chuanqianoproetus  Wu,  1977;  Xiushuiproetus 
Q.  Zhang  in  Qiu  et  al.,  1983;  and  possibly  Malvernocare 
as  subgenera  of  the  genus.  In  our  opinion,  more 
detailed  knowledge  about  the  morphology  of  the  taxa 
concerned  is  required  before  a  satisfactory  revision  can 
be  proposed. 


Table  2.  Summary  of  diagnostic  characters  of  the  species  oi  Prantlia. 
glab.,  glabellar;  %,  as  percentage  of;  cranid.,  cranidial;  no.,  number. 


Species 

longula 

vagrans 

canberrensis 

longifrons 

grindrodi 

CEPHALON 

glab.  shape 

triangular 

triangular 

bell 

bell 

bell 

glab.  length  %  cranid.  length 

68 

82 

66 

61 

62 

genal  spines 

yes 

yes 

yes 

? 

yes 

THORAX 

no.  of  segments 

9 

? 

8 

9 

10 

PYGIDIUM 

no.  of  rings 

10 

12 

9-10 

10 

7 

no.  of  pleurae 

8 

8 

faint 

8 

5 

Subfamily  uncertain 


Indeterminate  proetid  A 

PI.  6,  fig.  15 


Indeterminate  proetid  B 

PI.  9,  figs.  4,5 


MATERIAL 

From   AA   95    (Upper   Silurian),   Prongs   Creek:    1 
hypostome. 


MATERIAL 

From  BB  131  (Lower  Silurian),  Illtyd  Range:  1  crani- 
dium,  1  hypostome,  1  pygidium. 


DISCUSSION 

One  small  hypostome  (PI.  6,  fig.  15)  lacks  the  posterior 
embayment  of  warburgellines,  and  differs  greatly  from 
the  hypostome  of  H.  kutchini  in  the  following  features: 
it  is  much  more  elongate,  with  different  prosopon;  the 
middle  body  is  pinched  in  and  produced  anteriorly; 
paired  posterolateral  denticles  are  present.  We  do  not 
know  of  a  comparable  hypostome  and  leave  its  system- 
atic position  undecided. 


DESCRIPTION 

Fragmentary  cranidium  with  subquadrate  glabella  as 
long  as  wide.  Lateral  lobes  apparently  absent.  Pregla- 
bellar  and  axial  furrows  shallow.  Occipital  ring  10  per 
cent  length  of  cranidium.  Occipital  tubercle  and  lobe 
absent.  Preglabellar  area  20  per  cent  length  of  crani- 
dium, not  downturned;  preglabellar  field  gently  convex. 
Anterior  border  short.  Anterior  furrow  shallow. 

On  hypostome,  width  across  posterior  wings  85  per 
cent  length.  Middle  body  swollen,  strongly  defined. 


19 


Middle  furrow  commencing  at  60  per  cent  length  of 
hypostome  from  front,  inclined  backward  and  inward 
for  20  per  cent  width.  Lateral  lobe  composed  almost 
entirely  of  strongly  swollen,  smooth  macula.  Lateral 
furrow  shallow  anteriorly,  becoming  deeper  and 
broader  toward  back,  bending  outward  opposite  mac- 
ula. Posterior  furrow  convex  backward,  broad,  and  shal- 
low. Lateral  border  narrow,  raised,  continuous  with 
posterior  border;  posterior  border  broader  mesially; 
lateral  denticle  absent.  Raised  lines  running  backward 


and  outward  on  middle  body,  parallel  to  margin  on 
borders. 

DISCUSSION 

The  hypostome  resembles  that  of  Hedstroemia  kutchini 
sp.  nov.,  particularly  in  the  rounded  posterior  outline 
and  large  maculae,  but  differs  in  having  an  undepressed 
posterior  border  and  in  prosopon.  The  cranidium  and 
unillustrated  pygidium  are  unlike  Hedstroemia  and  are 
unidentifiable. 


Family  Aulacopleuridae  Angelin,  1854 


Genus  Otarion  Zenker,  1833 

TYPE  SPECIES 

Otarion  diffractum  Zenker,  1833,  from  Upper  Silurian 
rocks  near  Beroun,  Prague  district,  Czechoslovakia. 

DISCUSSION 

In  their  review  of  the  family  Aulacopleuridae,  Thomas 
and  Owens  (1978)  suggested  that  Otarion  {Otarion)  be 
restricted  to  Late  Silurian  aulacopleurid  species  with, 
among  other  features,  faint  eye  ridges  visible  on  inter- 
nal moulds,  a  subparallel-sided  glabella,  weakly  diver- 
gent preocular  facial  sutures,  and  13  to  17  thoracic 
segments,  the  sixth  segment  bearing  an  axial  spine. 
They  proposed  that  O.  {Aulacopleura)  be  restricted  to 
species  from  the  Ordovician  to  Middle  Devonian  with 
strong  eye  ridges  evident  on  the  external  surface  and 
with  18  to  22  thoracic  segments,  none  bearing  an  axial 
spine.  Aulacopleura  socialis  (Poulsen),  from  the  Early 
Silurian,  bears  conspicuous  eye  ridges,  a  glabella  of 
parabolic  outline,  widely  divergent  facial  sutures,  and 
12  thoracic  segments,  with  an  axial  spine  on  the  sixth 
segment  in  some  specimens.  These  features  preclude 
assignment  to  either  subgenus,  but  are  shared  with 
Songkania  Chang  from  the  Early  Silurian  of  southwest 
China,  which  we  regard  as  a  third  subgenus  of  Otarion. 


Subgenus  Songkania  Chang,  1974 

TYPE  SPECIES 

Songkania  hanjiadianensis  Chang,  1974,  Early  Silurian, 
southwest  China. 

Otarion  {Songkania)  socialis  (Poulsen,  1934) 

PI.  4,  fig.  14;  PI.  8,  figs.  1-12;  PI.  12,  figs.  14-16;  PI. 
13,  figs.  3-6;  Text-fig.  5B 

Aulacopleura  socialis  Poulsen,  1934:21,  pi.  2,  figs.  24- 

27. 


Aulacopleura  socialis — Raasch  in  Raasch,  Norford,  and 
Wilson,  1961:471,  fig.  4.1-9. 

HOLOTYPE 

MMH  3251  (cranidium,  figured  by  Poulsen,  1934,  pi.  2, 
fig.  25;  in  this  paper,  PI.  13,  figs.  3,4),  Cape  Schuchert 
Formation  (Lower  Silurian),  Kap  Schuchert,  North 
Greenland. 

MATERIAL 

From  AA  2-4.5  (Lower  Silurian),  Prongs  Creek:  7  dor- 
sal shields,  270  cranidia,  librigenae,  3  hypostomes,  78 
pygidia. 

DESCRIPTION 

Length  of  cephalon  40  per  cent  width  opposite  occipital 
ring.  Glabella  80  to  90  per  cent  as  wide  as  long,  55 
to  60  per  cent  length  of  cranidium  (in  normal  view), 
subquadrate,  gently  convex;  anterolateral  angles 
broadly  rounded.  Occipital  ring  moderately  convex, 
with  posterior  margin  bowed  backward.  Occipital 
tubercle  centrally  placed.  Occipital  furrow  shallower 
than  axial  furrow.  LI  with  slight  independent  convexity, 
30  per  cent  length  of  glabella  and  20  per  cent  width  of 
glabella.  SI  broad  and  strong  anteriorly,  becoming 
weak  posteriorly,  running  obliquely  backward  to  occipi- 
tal furrow.  S2  short,  distinct  only  on  internal  surface. 
Preglabellar  and  axial  furrows  continuous,  deepening 
posteriorly.  Preglabellar  field  as  long  as  glabella  when 
measured  along  surface,  curving  downward  with  mod- 
erate convexity,  confluent  with  fixigena.  Fixigena  wide, 
sloping  inward  from  palpebral  lobe.  Palpebral  lobe  hor- 
izontally extended,  with  extremities  almost  twice  width 
of  glabella  apart;  midlength  of  palpebral  lobe  opposite 
midlength  of  glabella.  Eye  ridge  strong,  slightly  oblique, 
divided  by  a  median  furrow.  Anterior  border  moder- 
ately wide  and  convex,  with  sagittal  length  greater  than 
exsagittal  length.  Anterior  border  furrow  uniformly 
well  defined.  Anterior  branch  of  facial  suture  running 
sinuously  forward  and  outward,  cutting  anterior  margin 


20 


at  65  per  cent  width  across  genal  angles.  Posterior 
branch  running  backward  and  outward,  cutting  margin 
at  80  per  cent  width  across  genal  angles.  Doublure 
extending  to  border  furrow. 

Eye  20  per  cent  sagittal  length  of  cephalon;  strong 
convexity  differentiating  from  narrow  socle;  socle 
marked  off  from  librigena  by  a  broad,  shallow  furrow. 
Field  of  librigena  considerably  wider  than  preglabellar 
area,  moderately  convex,  sloping  outward;  caecae  pres- 
ent on  some  specimens.  Lateral  border  convex,  30  per 
cent  minimum  width  of  field,  continuous  with  anterior 
and  posterior  borders;  anterior  and  posterior  borders 
widening  rapidly  adaxially.  Genal  spine  long  and  slen- 
der, extending  to  sixth'  thoracic  segment,  arising 
abruptly  at  genal  angle,  directed  slightly  outward  and 
backward,  almost  straight. 

Rostral  plate  unknown.  Hypostome  elongate.  Mid- 
dle body  large,  extending  to  anterior  margin,  strongly 
convex.  Lateral  lobes  large,  uniting  to  form  a  posterior 
lobe  with  independent  convexity.  Middle  furrow 
oblique,  shallow.  Anterior  wing  small.  Lateral  border 
narrow,  convex,  directed  longitudinally  for  much  of 
length,  diverging  posteriorly,  and  curving  round  to 
unite  with  rounded  posterior  border.  Lateral  denticle 
absent. 

Thorax  composed  of  12  segments.  Axis  30  per  cent 
width  of  thorax  anteriorly,  narrowing  to  65  per  cent 
anterior  width  of  axis  posteriorly,  gently  convex  trans- 
versely. Axial  furrow  well  defined.  First  five  rings  with 
swollen  lateral  nodes.  Articulating  half-ring  more  than 
half  length  of  ring.  Pleural  lobe  horizontally  extended 
adaxially,  gently  downturned  at  fulcrum  at  60  per  cent 
width.  Pleura  composed  of  anterior  and  more  strongly 
swollen  posterior  bands,  separated  by  median  pleural 
furrow;  extremity  of  pleura  rectangular.  Axial  spine  on 
sixth  ring  on  at  least  two  individuals  (PI.  8,  figs.  6-8), 
tapering  slowly  and  curving  low  over  axis  to  twelfth 
ring;  spine  certainly  absent  on  other  specimens  (PI.  8, 
fig.  5). 


Pygidium  35  to  40  per  cent  as  long  as  wide.  Axis  30 
per  cent  anterior  width  of  pygidium,  85  per  cent  length 
of  pygidium,  moderately  convex.  Terminus  broadly 
rounded.  Five  rings  clearly  marked  by  continuous  ring 
furrows,  successively  shorter.  Pleural  area  increases 
strongly  in  convexity  toward  back.  Border  uniformly 
narrow,  continuous.  Four  well-defined  pleurae  and  a 
posterior  area;  anterior  bands  confluent  with  border, 
widening  abaxially.  Posterior  bands  more  swollen,  nar- 
rowing out  at  border  furrow,  delimited  by  pleural  and 
interpleural  furrows;  pleural  and  interpleural  furrows 
fuse  to  form  border  depression.  Doublure  narrow. 

Surface  smooth  except  as  follows:  coarse  granules  on 
glabella;  two  pairs  of  small  granules  on  adaxial  area 
of  fixigena,  anterior  pair  closer  to  axial  furrow  than 
posterior  pair;  a  row  of  granules  on  occipital  and  tho- 
racic rings;  faint  granules  on  axis  of  pygidium.  External 
surface  of  field  of  librigena  closely  and  shallowly  pitted; 
lateral  border  of  librigena  with  very  faint,  closely 
spaced  raised  lines  running  parallel  to  margin.  Internal 
surface  of  librigena  smooth. 

DISCUSSION 

The  only  differences  between  the  specimens  from  the 
Road  River  Formation  and  the  type  material  from 
North  Greenland  are  the  stronger  granulation  and  the 
weaker  development  of  S2  in  the  Road  River  Forma- 
tion material.  It  is  not  known  whether  or  not  an  axial 
thoracic  spine  was  present  in  the  Greenland  material; 
the  material  under  description  is  dimorphic  in  this 
respect. 

The  cranidium  of  O.  (5. )  socialis  resembles  O.  {S. ) 
pijiazhaiensis  Chang  (1974:174,  pi.  81,  fig.  10)  more 
closely  than  it  does  the  type  species,  O.  (S. )  hanjiadia- 
nensis  Chang  (1974:174,  pi.  80,  figs.  3,4;  pi.  81,  fig.  9); 
differences  in  the  Road  River  Formation  material  from 
that  of  both  other  species  are  the  broader  LI,  the  longer 
preglabellar  field,  and  the  presence  of  granulation. 


Family  Harpidae  Hawie  and  Corda,  1847 


Genus  Scotoharpes  Lamont,  1948 

TYPE  SPECIES 

Scotoharpes  domina  Lamont,  1948,  Whether  Law  Linn 
Formation  (upper  Llandovery),  Whether  Law  Linn, 
North  Esk  Inlier,  Scotland. 

Scotoharpes  raaschi  Norford,  1973 

PI.  9,  figs.  1-3 

Scotoharpes  raaschi  Norford,  1973:20,  pi.  2,  figs.  1,3-5. 


HOLOTYPE 

GSC  27794  (cephalon,  figured  by  Norford,  1973,  pi.  2, 
figs.  1,3-5),  Lower  Silurian,  GSC  locality  53109  (proba- 
bly the  same  as  BB  131),  Illtyd  Range,  Yukon  Territory, 
Canada. 

MATERIAL 

From  BB  131  (Lower  Silurian),  Illtyd  Range:  2  cephala. 

DESCRIPTION 

Cephalon  65  per  cent  as  long  (sag.)  as  wide.  Glabella 


21 


40  to  45  per  cent  length  of  cephalon  and  20  per  cent 
width  of  cephalon,  moderately  swollen,  as  wide  as  long. 
Width  of  occipital  ring  equal  to  width  across  LI;  occipi- 
tal tubercle  strong,  anteriorly  placed.  Occipital  furrow 
shallow,  transverse.  LI  small,  30  per  cent  length  of 
glabella,  projecting  only  slightly  sideways.  SI  shallow, 
curving  inward  and  dying  out  anterior  to  midlength  of 
LL  Preglabellar  and  axial  furrows  continuous,  shallow. 
Ala  moderately  large,  30  per  cent  width  of  glabella, 
sloping  outward  and  depressed  abaxially,  narrowing 
and  dying  out  anterior  to  midlength  of  glabella.  Fixed 
cheek  convex;  a  low  ridge  outlining  ala  anteriorly.  Eye 
tubercle  only  slightly  elevated,  30  per  cent  width  of 
cephalon  from  midline,  situated  opposite  forefront  of 
glabella.  Eye  ridge  clearly  defined,  essentially  trans- 
verse; ridge  of  comparable  strength  running  obliquely 
outward  from  eye  tubercle  to  cheek  roll.  Cheek  roll 
extending  almost  to  glabella  anteriorly,  sloping  steeply 
outward,  narrowing  and  dying  out  at  60  per  cent  length 


from  front.  Posterior  border  short,  convex,  curving 
strongly  backward  abaxially.  Girder  weak.  Brim  flat- 
tened, slightly  wider  anteriorly  than  laterally;  prolonga- 
tion 40  per  cent  sagittal  length  of  cephalon,  narrowing 
slowly  backward,  slightly  inturned  posteriorly.  Mar- 
ginal band  narrow,  smooth.  Doublure  of  occipital  ring 
almost  reaches  occipital  furrow.  Glabella,  occipital 
ring,  and  ala  smooth;  cheek  coarsely  pitted,  with  pits 
on  cheek  roll  finer  than  on  cheek  and  arranged  in 
ramifying,  radiating  rows  separated  by  fine  caecae.  Cae- 
cae  continuing  20  per  cent  distance  across  brim.  Brim 
finely  pitted.  Pits  on  either  side  of  girder  larger. 

DISCUSSION 

A  point  of  particular  resemblance  of  our  material  to  S. 
raaschi  Norford  is  the  ridge  running  obliquely  outward 
from  the  eye  tubercle.  The  occipital  tubercle  described 
above  is  present  on  the  external  surface  only  and  is  not 
preserved  on  the  holotype  cephalon. 


Family  Cheiruridae  Hawle  and  Corda,  1847 
Subfamily  Cheirurinae  Hawle  and  Corda,  1847 


Genus  Cheirurus  Beyrich,  1845 

TYPE  SPECIES 

Cheirurus   insignis    Beyrich,    1845,    Liten    Formation 
(Upper  Silurian),  Prague  district,  Czechoslovakia. 


DESCRIPTION 

Anterior  part  of  glabella  (all  that  is  known)  expanding 
slightly  forward,  moderately  convex.  S2  and  S3  curving 
gently  backward,  30  per  cent  width  of  glabella.  Anterior 
border  short;  anterior  border  furrow  shallow  mesially, 
deeper  abaxially.  Prosopon  faintly  granular.  The  unil- 
lustrated  librigena  is  of  generalized  cheirurine  type. 


Cheirurus  sp. 

PI.  5,  figs.  15,16 

MATERIAL 

From  BB  131  (Lower  Silurian),  Illtyd  Range:  1  crani- 
dium,  1  fragmentary  librigena. 


DISCUSSION 

This  species  differs  from  C.  certus  Poulsen  (1934:28,  pi. 
3,  fig.  16)  and  C.  hyperboreus  Poulsen  (1934:29,  pi.  3, 
figs.  17,18),  both  from  the  Cape  Schuchert  Formation, 
North  Greenland,  in  its  shorter,  less-expanded  frontal 
lobe. 


Family  Encrinuridae  Angelin,  1854 
Subfamily  Encrinurinae  Angelin,  1854 


Genus  Cromus  Barrande,  1852 

TYPE  SPECIES 

Trilobites  intercostatus  Barrande,  1846,  Kopanina  For- 
mation (Upper  Silurian),  Prague  district,  Czechoslo- 
vakia. 

Cromus  princeps  (Poulsen,  1934) 

PI.  10,  figs.  1-8;  PI.  13,  figs.  7-12;  Text-fig.  5C 

Encrinurus  moderatus  Poulsen,  1934:31,  pi.  3,  fig.  20 


(non  figs.  21,22). 
Encrinurus  princeps  Poulsen,  1934:33,  pi.  3,  figs.  23-27. 
Encrinurus  princeps — Raasch  in  Raasch,  Norford,  and 

Wilson,  1961,  fig.  5.1-5. 
Encrinurus  cf.  E.  princeps — Norford,  1962,  pi.  8,  fig.  14. 
Encrinurus  cf.  E.  princeps — Norford  et  al.,  1970,  pi.  8, 

fig.  14. 
Cromus  princeps — Strusz,  1980:10. 
Cromus  princeps — Snajdr,  1985:16. 
Encrinurus  moderatus — Lane,  1988:99,  pi.  5,  figs.  7,?8. 


22 


HOLOTYPE 

MMH  3276  (cranidium,  figured  by  Poulsen,  1934,  pi.  3, 
fig.  23;  in  this  paper,  PI.  13,  figs.  10,11),  Cape  Schuchert 
Formation  (Lower  Silurian),  Kap  Schuchert,  North 
Greenland. 

MATERIAL 

From  AA  2-4.5  (Lower  Silurian),  Prongs  Creek:  1  dor- 
sal shield,  10  cranidia,  librigenae,  4  hypostomes,  23 
pygidia. 


DESCRIPTION 

Cranidium  45  per  cent  as  long  as  wide.  Glabella  70  to 
80  per  cent  as  wide  as  long,  moderately  convex  in  both 
directions;  width  across  L2  60  to  65  per  cent  maximum 
width.  Occipital  ring  wider  than  width  across  LI,  with 
transverse  posterior  margin  narrowing  slightly  abaxi- 
ally.  Occipital  furrow  broad  and  shallow  mesially,  shal- 
lower than  axial  furrow  abaxially;  rounded  apodeme  at 
extremity.  LI  consisting  of  a  ridge  35  per  cent  width 
of  glabella,  directed  somewhat  forward  adaxially;  L2 
shorter  than  L3,  nodular;  L3  subquadrate.  SI  almost 
continuous;  S2  and  S3  broad  abaxially,  dying  out  adaxi- 
ally, 35  per  cent  width  of  glabella.  Frontal  lobe  40 
to  45  per  cent  length  of  glabella,  evenly  and  strongly 
rounded  in  outline.  Axial  furrow  deeper  and  broader 
than  preglabellar  furrow,  widening  backward;  apo- 
demes  adaxially  at  extremities  of  SI  and  S2.  Preglabel- 
lar furrow  deep  and  wide  abaxially,  becoming  shallower 
and  narrower  mesially.  Anterior  border  of  cranidium 
moderately  wide  abaxially,  narrowing  and  almost  dying 
out  mesially.  A  longitudinal  median  depression  cross- 
ing anterior  border  and  preglabellar  furrow,  and  run- 
ning onto  forefront  of  glabella;  this  depression  stronger 
in  small  specimens.  Fixigena  wide,  sloping  inward  from 
eye  with  strong  convexity  and  outward  to  genal  angle 
with  weaker  convexity.  Palpebral  lobe  almost  20  per 
cent  length  of  cranidium  and  marked  off  from  fixigena 
by  a  broad,  shallow  depression;  anterior  extremity  of 
palpebral  lobe  placed  opposite,  and  at  twice  width 
across,  L3.  Posterior  border  narrower  (exsag.)  than 
occipital  ring,  widening  slowly  abaxially  and  rapidly 
adjacent  to  genal  angle,  depressed  well  below  level  of 
fixigena  abaxially.  Lateral  border  ill  defined.  Posterior 
border  furrow  deep  adaxially,  where  continuous  with 
lateral  furrow.  Genal  spine  thornlike,  very  short, 
directed  backward  and  slightly  outward.  Anterior 
branch  of  facial  suture  curving  forward  and  inward, 
delimiting  anterior  border  of  cranidium.  Posterior 
branch  curving  outward  and  backward,  cutting  lateral 
margin  opposite  occipital  furrow. 

Eye  pedunculate;  lens  surface  occupying  half  height 
of  stalk;  stalk  marked  off  by  a  broad  depression  from 


field.  Field  of  librigena  gently  convex.  Preglabellar  lobe 
25  per  cent  length  of  cranidium,  weakly  convex.  Lateral 
border  strongly  convex,  less  than  half  minimum  width 
of  field,  continuous  with  anterior  border,  curving 
inward  and  widening  at  back.  Lateral  border  furrow 
uniformly  deep  and  broad.  Anterior  border  furrow 
deep  and  broad  at  axial  furrow,  narrowing  and  dying 
out  by  midwidth  of  preglabellar  lobe. 

Rostral  plate  unknown,  but  conformation  between 
librigenae  indicating  a  narrow  plate  widening  forward, 
as  shown  in  reconstruction. 

Hypostome  75  per  cent  as  wide  as  long.  Middle  body 
strongly  swollen,  longitudinally  ovate,  with  a  less- 
inflated  terminal  area.  Rhynchos  broad,  with  indepen- 
dent convexity  anteriorly  but  projecting  slightly,  length 
equalling  half  that  of  middle  body.  Lateral  lobe  com- 
prising a  small,  smooth  macula.  Lateral  furrow  demar- 
cating middle  body  strongly.  Lateral  border  narrow, 
flattened,  merging  with  posterior  tongue;  tongue  25  per 
cent  length  of  hypostome  and  with  rounded  tip.  Middle 
body  closely  and  shallowly  pitted,  more  coarsely  so 
anteriorly. 

Pygidium  triangular  in  outline,  55  to  60  per  cent  as 
long  as  wide.  Axis  25  per  cent  anterior  width  and  90 
per  cent  length  of  pygidium,  composed  of  20  rings; 
first  six  rings  continuous,  subsequent  rings  becoming 
discontinuous  mesially.  Ring  furrows  successively  shal- 
lower toward  back.  Axial  furrow  deep  and  broad  anteri- 
orly, becoming  narrower  and  shallower  posteriorly. 
Pleural  lobe  weakly  convex  to  midwidth,  downcurved 
abaxially.  Ten  pleural  ribs;  tenth  rib  postaxial,  with  tip 
generally  bluntly  fused  with  ninth;  ribs  flat  topped, 
widening  steadily;  tips  of  ribs  pointed  and  outturned, 
more  bluntly  so  posteriorly.  Ribs  successively  directed 
increasingly  backward  and  outward,  tenth  parallel.  Rib 
furrows  deep  and  broad,  widening  slightly  abaxially. 
Anterior  band  of  first  pleura  with  clear  articulating 
facet.  Four  congruent  axial  and  pleural  segments.  Ven- 
tral border  uniformly  narrow;  inner  margin  straight; 
junction  evenly  rounded,  unembayed. 

Surface  of  cephalon,  except  on  occipital  segment  and 
in  furrows,  closely  tuberculate;  tubercles  of  mixed  sizes, 
diameter  of  largest  being  8  per  cent  maximum  width  of 
frontal  lobe;  about  one  hundred  tubercles  on  adult 
glabella,  many  perforate.  A  quincunx  of  small  tubercles 
composed  of  Ll-1;  Sl-0;  L2-1.  Remainder  of  tubercles 
randomly  distributed.  Occipital  segment  finely  and 
sparsely  granular.  A  single  row  of  tubercles  on  anterior 
border  of  cranidium.  Tubercles  on  genae  larger  adaxi- 
ally. Pygidium  granular;  three  or  four  small  median 
tubercles  on  axis  of  pygidium  randomly  spaced.  Attri- 
bute coding  (Temple  and  Tripp,  1979):  1-0;  2-20;  3-0; 
4-1;  5-1;  6-10;  7-0;  8-1;  9-4;  10-1;  ll-'/2;  12-1;  13-1;  14- 
1;  15-0;  16-1;  17-0;  18-0;  19-0;  20-0;  21-1;  22-1;  23-0;  24- 


23 


0;  25-1;  26-0;  27-100;  28-12;  29-0;  30-2.5;  31-0;  32-1;  33- 
8;  34-0. 

Small  pygidia  have  fewer  segments  and  more  strongly 
developed  ring  furrows.  On  one  pygidium,  3  mm  in 
sagittal  length  (PI.  10,  fig.  5),  ninth  and  tenth  rings 
bifurcate  laterally,  third  and  fourth  right  ribs  fused 
abaxially. 

DISCUSSION 

The  holotype  of  Encrinurus  moderatus  Poulsen 
(1934:31,  pi.  3,  fig.  20),  from  the  Cape  Schuchert  For- 
mation, St.  George  Fiord,  North  Greenland,  is  a  small 
cranidium,  5.0  mm  in  length,  attributable  to  Cromus 
princeps;  thus  moderatus  is  a  junior  subjective  synonym 
of princeps.  The  two  pygidia  from  the  same  horizon  and 
locality  referred  to  E.  moderatus  by  Poulsen  (1934,  pi. 
3,  figs.  21,22)  are  not  attributable  to  Cromus;  they  are 
distinct  from  the  pygidium  from  Cape  Constitution 
named  Encrinurus  inflatus  by  Poulsen  (1934,  pi.  3,  fig. 
19). 

C  princeps  most  closely  resembles  C.  novaki  (Freeh, 
1888:735,  pi.  29,  figs.  5-9),  from  beds  of  Middle  Silurian 
age  in  the  Carnic  Alps;  C.  novaki  also  possesses  an 
anteromedian  furrow  and  short  genal  spines.  C. 
princeps  differs  in  that  the  eyes  are  placed  farther  back 
and  the  tuberculation  is  coarser. 


congruent  axial  and  pleural  segments.  Apart  from  the 
four  axial  tubercles,  prosopon  greatly  subdued. 

DISCUSSION 

This  pygidium  has  much  in  common  with  Balizoma — 
the  low  number  of  rings  and  pleurae,  large  axial  tuber- 
cles, and  longitudinal  axial  furrow — but  must  be 
excluded  from  Balizoma  under  Ramskold's  (1986) 
definition  on  account  of  the  high  ring-to-pleura  ratio. 
Furthermore,  the  pleural  area  is  not  strongly  down- 
turned,  and  the  pleural  ribs  are  narrow  and  without 
large  tubercles. 

Snajdr  (1985)  reestablished  Encrinuraspis  Webby, 
Moors,  and  McLean  (1970),  considered  by  Strusz 
(1980)  as  a  junior  synonym  of  Cromus.  The  case  for 
retention  is  disputable,  but  Encrinuraspis  may  prove  to 
be  a  useful  taxon  for  species  not  readily  attributable 
elsewhere,  and  the  Illtyd  Range  pygidium  is  a  case  in 
question. 


Genus  Balizoma  Holloway,  1980 

TYPE  SPECIES 

Calymene  variolaris  Brongniart,  1822,  Much  Wenlock 
Limestone  Formation,  Dudley,  West  Midlands,  United 
Kingdom. 


Genus  Encrinuraspis  Webby,  Moors,  and  McLean, 

1970 

TYPE  SPECIES 

Encrinuraspis  optimus  Webby,  Moors,  and  McLean, 
1970,  Malongulli  Formation  (?Caradoc  Series),  New 
South  Wales,  Australia. 


Balizoma  aff.  B.  obtusus  (Angelin,  1851) 

PI.  11,  figs.  8-10,12-18 


MATERIAL 


From  AA  95  (Upper  Silurian),  Prongs  Creek:  5  crani- 
dia,  1  librigena,  1  hypostome,  27  pygidia. 


Encrinuraspis  sp. 

PI.  9,  fig.  6 

MATERIAL 

From  BB  131  (Lower  Silurian),  Illtyd  Range:  1 
pygidium. 

DESCRIPTION 

Pygidium  70  per  cent  as  long  as  wide,  moderately  and 
evenly  convex.  Axis  30  per  cent  anterior  width  and  80 
per  cent  length,  tapering  to  a  point.  Twelve  rings,  of 
which  first  six  continuous;  a  longitudinal  median 
depression  as  deep  as  ring  furrows  interrupting  poste- 
rior rings.  Large  median  tubercles  on  fourth,  sixth,  and 
eighth  rings.  Pleural  lobe  downcurved  with  seven  ribs 
widening  slightly  and  a  broad  postaxial  ridge  compris- 
ing fused  eighth  ribs.  Ring-to-pleura  ratio  1.7.  Two 


DESCRIPTION 

Glabella  90  per  cent  as  wide  as  long,  with  width  across 
L2  60  per  cent  width  across  frontal  lobe,  moderately 
rounded  in  outline,  uniformly  convex  longitudinally 
and  transversely.  Occipital  ring  short  (sag.),  wider  than 
base  of  preoccipital  glabella,  strongly  arched  trans- 
versely; occipital  furrow  deep  and  broad.  Frontal  lobe 
45  percent  sagittal  length  of  glabella.  LI  and  SI  almost 
obsolete.  L2  and  L3  represented  by  comparatively  small 
nodular  tubercles.  S2  and  S3  short,  broad,  shallow  fur- 
rows, discontinuous  mesially.  Axial  furrow  deep  and 
broad,  with  fossula  near  front.  Preglabellar  furrow  shal- 
low. Eleven  moderately  sized  tubercles  on  anterior 
border  of  cranidium;  lateral  tubercle  not  enlarged. 
Fixigena  convex.  Posterior  border  short  (sag.),  incom- 
plete; posterior  border  furrow  deep  and  broad.  Genal 
angle  unknown.  Cranidium  finely  and  densely  tubercu- 
late;  larger  tubercles  perforate.  Basal  diameter  of  wid- 


24 


est  glabellar  tubercles  10  per  cent  maximum  width  of 
glabella  across  L4;  a  pair  of  larger  tubercles  opposite 
L2;  remaining  tubercles  not  clearly  symmetrically 
arranged;  total  number  about  60.  A  single  row  of  small 
tubercles  on  occipital  ring  and  posterior  border. 

Librigena  incompletely  known,  with  comparatively 
small  field  and  broad  lateral  border.  Rostral  plate 
unknown. 

Hypostome  rhombic,  with  width  (excluding  anterior 
wings)  75  per  cent  length  and  anterior  margin  narrowly 
rounded.  Middle  body  inflated,  well  defined  by  strong 
lateral  furrow.  Rhynchos  large,  projecting  somewhat 
anterior  to  middle  body,  widening  slightly  backward, 
and  dying  out  near  midl6ngth  of  middle  body.  Macula 
small  but  distinct.  Anterior  border  short.  Anterior  wing 
large,  sloping  obliquely  upward.  Lateral  border  narrow, 
depressed.  Posterior  tongue  almost  20  per  cent  length 
of  hypostome,  horizontally  extended.  Surface  of  middle 
body  granular,  with  a  few  pits  and  folds. 

Pygidium  triangular  in  outline,  strongly  convex  in 
both  directions,  high  in  profile,  with  width  85  to  95  per 
cent  length  (average  width-to-length  ratio  1.1:1).  Axis 
35  per  cent  maximum  width  of  pygidium,  strongly  con- 
vex transversely,  with  13  rings  and  a  terminus;  postaxial 
ridge  short,  reaching  posterior  margin  in  a  few  speci- 
mens. Rings  continuous.  Sagittal  groove  lacking  on 
external  moulds,  shallower  than  ring  furrows  alongside 
tubercles  on  internal  moulds.  Ring  furrows  broad  and 
deep.  Sagittal  tubercles  only  slightly  larger  than  abaxial 
ring  tubercles,  absent  on  first  and  second  rings,  fre- 
quently on  successive  rings  toward  back.  Axial  furrow 
deep  anteriorly,  becoming  weaker  posteriorly.  Nine 
strong  pleural  ribs;  tenth  pair  short  and  joined  at  tips, 
or  fused  in  a  postaxial  ridge;  ribs  parallel  sided,  directed 
increasingly  strongly  backward,  curving  downward  at 
fulcrum.  Four  or  five  small  tubercles  on  each  pleural 
rib.  Tips  of  ribs  projecting  in  short  free  points.  Four 
rings  and  pleurae  congruent.  Rib  furrows  deep  and 
broad  throughout.  Ring-to-pleura  ratio  (R/P)  as 
defined  by  Ramskold  (1986:529)  1.2-1.3. 


DISCUSSION 

It  is  Ramskold's  opinion  (pers.  comm.,  1987)  that  this 
material  falls  within  the  range  of  the  abundant  Swedish 
species  B.  obtusus  (Angelin,  1851:3,  pi.  4,  fig.  9;  see 
Ramskold,  1986:561,  pi.  40,  fig.  2;  pi.  48,  figs.  1-14;  pi. 
49,  figs.  1-10),  from  the  Mulde  Beds  (Middle  Silurian), 
Klinteberg  Marl,  Hemse  Beds,  and  Eke  Beds  (Upper 
Silurian),  Gotland,  Sweden.  Ramskold  recognized 
three  morphological  forms:  Form  A,  the  "type  form," 
restricted  to  the  northeastern  limestone  areas  in  the 
Hemse  Beds  and  the  Eke  Beds  at  Lau  Backar;  Form 


B,  restricted  to  the  "marl"  west  and  south  of  the  south- 
western outcrops  of  the  Hemse  Beds  limestone  area; 
and  Form  C,  known  only  from  pygidia  from  the  upper 
Eke  Beds.  The  hypostome  from  AA  95  is  similar  in 
main  characters  to  that  of  5.  obtusus  (Ramskold,  1986, 
pi.  48,  fig.  1)  but  differs  in  having  a  less  strongly  defined, 
unwaisted  rhynchos;  in  size,  it  is  appropriate  to  B.  aff. 
B.  obtusus,  but  it  should  possibly  be  attributed  to  the 
indeterminate  encrinurine  described  below.  The  pygi- 
dia under  description  most  closely  resemble  B.  obtusus 
Form  B,  but  differ  in  the  width-to-length  proportions — 
85  to  95  per  cent  for  Road  River  Formation  specimens, 
compared  to  65  to  85  per  cent  for  B.  obtusus  Form  B. 
Ramskold  (1986:66)  has  discussed  the  possibility  that 
B.  rosensteinae  (Tripp,  Temple,  and  Gass,  1977:860, 
pi.  115,  figs.  1-13),  from  the  Ludlow  Series,  United 
Kingdom,  and  B.  dimitrovi  Perry  and  Chatterton 
(1979:589,  pi.  72,  figs.  1-3;  pi.  73,  figs.  1-17,29-31;  pi. 
74,  figs.  1-14,18-23,30-35),  from  the  upper  Whittaker 
and  lower  Delorme  formations  (Wenlock  to  lower  Lud- 
low), Delorme  Range,  Mackenzie  Mountains,  Canada, 
are  synonymous  with  B.  obtusus.  Ramskold  (1986:561) 
has  restricted  the  genus  Balizoma  to  species  with  a 
ring-to-pleura  ratio  (R/P)  of  1.1-1.4,  thus  excluding  the 
two  Bohemian  species  of  Pridoli  age  Encrinur- 
aspisl  subvariolaris  concomitans  Pfibyl  and  Vanek, 
1962,  and  Encrinuraspis?  testosteron  Snajdr,  1981,  which 
have  higher  ring-to-pleura  ratios  (R/P)  of  1.6  and  1.8, 
respectively. 


Indeterminate  encrinurine 

PI.  11,  fig.  11 

MATERIAL 

From  AA  95  (Upper  Silurian),  Prongs  Creek:  1 
cranidium. 

DISCUSSION 

This  single  cranidium  differs  considerably  from  that  of 
Balizoma  aff.  B.  obtusus  and  of  most  other  species  of 
Balizoma  in  the  following  features:  (1)  twice  as  large; 
(2)  glabella  narrowing  more  strongly  backward;  (3) 
smaller,  multituberculate  lateral  lobes;  (4)  tubercles  on 
glabella  and  anterior  border  of  cranidium  double  in 
number  and  much  smaller  in  size;  (5)  smaller  tubercles 
adaxially  on  fixigena.  Balizoma  is  the  genus  that  this 
cranidium  most  closely  resembles,  but  the  small  tuber- 
cles and  lateral  glabellar  lobes  exclude  this  cranidium 
from  that  genus  as  currently  understood.  The  lateral 
lobes  are  completely  unlike  Cromus,  and  the  shape  of 
the  cranidium  and  features  of  the  prosopon  are  unlike 
Encrinuraspis. 


25 


Family  Calymenidae  Milne-Edwards,  1840 
Subfamily  uncertain 


Indeterminate  calymenid 

PI.  9,  fig.  7 

MATERIAL 

From  BB  131  (Lower  Silurian),  Illtyd  Range:  1 
pygidium. 

DESCRIPTION 

Length  65  per  cent  width;  convexity  strong.  Axis  35  per 
cent  anterior  width,  95  per  cent  length  of  pygidium, 
narrowing  steadily  backward  to  broadly  rounded  tip, 
composed  of  eight  rings  and  a  terminus.  Ring  furrows 
deep   and   broad   anteriorly,   becoming   successively 


weaker  toward  back.  Articulating  half-ring  and  furrow 
well  developed.  Axial  furrow  deep,  increasing  in  width 
toward  back.  Pleural  lobe  evenly  convex;  four  strongly 
developed,  flat-topped  ribs  curving  outward  and  back- 
ward; fifth  rib  flanking  axial  furrow  and  directed  back- 
ward. Interpleural  furrows  weak,  dying  out  adaxially; 
pleural  furrows  strong.  Articulating  half  pleura  strong 
adaxially.  Surface  smooth. 


DISCUSSION 

It  is  impossible  to  assign  this  single  pygidium  to  a  genus 
or  subfamily. 


Family  Lichidae  Hawle  and  Corda,  1847 
Subfamily  Lichinae  Hawle  and  Corda,  1847 


Genus  Dicranopeltis  Beyrich,  1845 

TYPE  SPECIES 

Lichas  Scabra  Beyrich,  1845,  Liten  Formation  (Upper 
Silurian),  Prague  district,  Czechoslovakia. 


Dicranopeltis  sp. 

PI.  10,  figs.  10-12 

MATERIAL 

From  BB  131  (Lower  Silurian),  Illtyd  Range:  1  crani- 
dium,  1  pygidium. 

DESCRIPTION 

Cranidium  strongly  convex  in  both  directions.  Occipital 
ring  incomplete.  Occipital  furrow  as  deep  as  axial  fur- 
row. Median  lobe  narrowing  slowly  and  steadily  back- 
ward to  about  50  per  cent  anterior  width  when  opposite 
SI,  and  then  expanding  posteriorly;  preoccipital  de- 
pression connecting  inner  extremities  of  S 1 .  Bullar  lobe 
half  length  of  cranidium,  with  strong  independent  con- 
vexity. LI  and  fixigena  fused.  Basal  glabellar  lobe 


absent.  Longitudinal  furrow  deep  and  narrow.  Axial 
furrow  continuous  with  SI,  curving  gently  inward  to 
longitudinal  furrow. 

Pygidium  65  per  cent  as  long  as  wide.  Axis  strongly 
convex,  30  per  cent  anterior  width,  narrowing  steadily 
backward,  not  pointed;  three  rings  and  furrows  contin- 
uous across  axis;  a  swollen  terminus  sloping  downward 
and  backward  to  depressed  tip  of  axis.  Axial  furrows 
deep  and  narrow  anteriorly,  becoming  shallow  posteri- 
orly, convergent.  Pleural  lobe  flattened;  three  pairs  of 
furrowed  pleurae  ending  in  short,  free  points.  Dou- 
blure gently  convex;  terrace  ridges  strong. 

Prosopon  tuberculate,  coarser  on  pygidium  than  on 
cranidium. 


DISCUSSION 

The  cranidium  resembles  that  of  the  type  species  D. 
scabra  (Beyrich;  see  Barrande,  1852,  pi.  28,  figs.  22-26) 
in  conformation  and  in  the  presence  of  the  preoccipital 
furrow,  but  differs  in  the  absence  of  basal  glabellar 
lobes.  The  pygidium  is  distinctive  in  its  long,  swollen, 
and  strongly  segmented  axis. 


Subfamily  uncertain 


Indeterminate  lichid 

PI.  7,  figs.  16-20 

MATERLVL 

From  AA  95  (Upper  Silurian),  Prongs  Creek:  3  crani- 
dia,  2  hypostomes,  5  pygidia. 


DISCUSSION 

This  lichid  material  is  too  sparse  to  justify  formal 
description.  The  two  incomplete  cranidia  illustrated 
are  similar  in  gross  morphology,  but  have  different 
prosopon  features  and  slight  differences  in  convexity 
of  lobes  and  in  courses  of  furrows;  in  both  cranidia,  the 


26 


longitudinal  furrow  is  continuous  anteriorly,  and  it  is 
unknown  whether  a  basal  glabellar  lobe  was  present  or 
not.  The  specimens  appear  to  belong  to  the  subfamily 
Trochurinae  (=  Ceratarginae,  see  Thomas  and  Hol- 
loway,  1988).  The  two  hypostomes  would  unhesitatingly 
be  referred  to  the  subfamily  Trochurinae  on  account 
of  the  broad,  unembayed  posterior  border  and  circum- 
scribed middle  body.  All  the  pygidia  are  remarkable  in 
that  they  resemble  Amphilichas  (subfamily  Tetralichi- 
nae,  recorded  only  from  the  Ordovician  System)  in  the 
pointed  axis  and  absence  of  pleural  furrows  on  the  third 
pleurae;  there  is  a  small  median  embayment  in  the 
posterior  margin,  but  no  extended  free  point  to  the 
third  pleura.  These  pygidia  differ  conspicuously  from 
those  of  the  Trochurinae  in  outline,  in  having  an 
unswollen  posterior  band,  and  in  the  absence  of  a  lat- 
eral border.  At  first  sight,  therefore,  the  pygidia  belong 
to  a  different  subfamily  from  that  of  the  cranidia  and 
hypostomes. 

A  comparable  conflict  arises  regarding  the  lichid 
described  as  Dicranogmus  skinneri  by  Perry  and  Chat- 
terton  (1977:308,  pi.  6,  figs.  16-21),  from  Cape  Phillips 
Formation  (Middle  Silurian),  Baillie-Hamilton  Island, 
Canadian  Arctic  Archipelago.  The  cranidium  of  this 


species  closely  resembles  that  of  the  trochurine  Dicra- 
nogmus pustulatus  Hawie  and  Corda  (1847:146,  pi.  7, 
fig.  77a,b),  the  type  species,  from  the  Upper  Silurian, 
Czechoslovakia,  the  hypostome  and  pygidium  of  which 
are  unknown.  The  hypostome  of  D.  skinneri  is  trochur- 
ine also.  The  pygidium  isAmphilichas-like  in  its  pointed 
axis  and  unfurrowed,  flattened  third  pleurae.  The  origi- 
nal grounds  for  associating  the  parts,  based  on  occur- 
rence and  particularly  on  the  prosopon,  are  convincing. 

Although  the  Prongs  Creek  and  the  Baillie-Hamilton 
Island  specimens  are  dissimilar  in  many  respects,  these 
two  enigmatic  associations  in  northern  Canada  are 
unlikely  to  be  coincidental.  The  Tetralichinae  and  Tro- 
churinae are  sister  subfamilies,  and  it  may  be  that  a 
rootstock  persisted  in  this  area  into  the  Silurian  Period. 

Subfamilies  of  the  Lichidae  are  consistent  in  the 
morphology  and  comparative  anatomy  of  the  parts  with 
the  exception  of  the  above  examples  and  another  sur- 
prising anomaly  in  the  Cape  Phillips  Formation.  This 
is  the  form  described  as  Lichid  n.  gen.,  n.  sp.  (subfamily 
Ceratarginae)  by  Perry  and  Chatterton  (1977:303,  pi. 
7,  figs.  1-9),  in  which  pygidia  of  Radiolichas  type  are 
associated  with  inappropriate  cranidia. 


Family  Odontopleuridae  Burmeister,  1843 
Subfamily  Odontopleurinae  Burmeister,  1843 


Genus  Leonaspis  Richter  and  Richter,  1917 

TYPE  SPECIES 

Odontopleura  leonhardi  Barrande,  1846,  Kopanina  For- 
mation (Upper  Silurian),  Prague  district,  Czechoslo- 
vakia. 


Leonaspis  semiglabra  (Poulsen,  1934) 

PI.  12,  figs.  1-13;  PI.  13,  figs.  13,14;  Text-fig.  5D 

Ceratocephala     (sens,     lat.)    groenlandica     Poulsen, 

1934:24,  pi.  3,  fig.  5  (non  figs.  6,7). 
Ceratocephala      (Leonaspisl)     semiglabra      Poulsen, 

1934:25,  pi.  3,  fig.  8  (non  fig.  9  =  groenlandica). 
Leonaspis  semiglabra — Raasch/n  Raasch,  Norford,  and 

Wilson,  1961:474,  fig.  4.10-18. 
Scutellum  borealis — Raasch  in  Raasch,  Norford,  and 

Wilson,  1961:474,  fig.  5.9  (non  figs.  6-8). 

HOLOTYPE 

MMH  3261  (cranidium,  figured  by  Poulsen,  1934,  pi.  3, 
fig.  8;  in  this  paper,  PI.  13,  fig.  13),  Cape  Schuchert 
Formation  (Lower  Silurian),  Kap  Schuchert,  North 
Greenland. 


MATERIAL 

From  AA  2-4.5  (Lower  Silurian),  Prongs  Creek:  1  dor- 
sal shield,  8  cranidia,  librigenae,  4  hypostomes,  11 
pygidia. 

DESCRIPTION 

Cranidium  25  per  cent  length  of  dorsal  shield,  60  per 
cent  as  long  as  wide,  moderately  convex.  Glabella  80 
to  85  per  cent  as  wide  as  long.  Occipital  ring  20  per  cent 
length  of  cranidium,  without  lobes  or  spines;  occipital 
tubercle  somewhat  enlarged.  Central  lobe  well  defined 
by  strong  independent  convexity,  subparallel  sided  but 
constricted  opposite  LI  and  L2,  expanding  anteriorly; 
frontal  lobe,  where  broadly  rounded,  60  per  cent  width 
across  LI.  LI  rounded,  swollen,  30  per  cent  basal  width 
of  glabella.  SI  deep,  oblique,  widening  at  apodeme 
at  extremity,  shallow  at  back.  L2  elongatedly  ovate, 
swollen,  25  per  cent  glabellar  width,  circumscribed.  S2 
oblique,  apodeme  at  extremity,  thence  running  back- 
ward, shallowing  at  SI.  L3  and  S3  absent.  Axial  furrows 
strongly  divergent  backward,  comparatively  shallow. 
Anterior  border  uniformly  short,  transverse.  Fixigena 
15  per  cent  width  of  cranidium,  narrowing  steadily  for- 
ward, gently  convex.  Eye  ridge  narrow  (tr.),  extending 
almost  to  posterior  border  furrow. 


27 


Librigena  sloping  outward.  Eye  sessile,  posteriorly 
placed.  Field  broad,  gently  convex.  Lateral  border  20 
per  cent  minimum  width  of  field,  widening  backward. 
Lateral  border  furrow  shallow.  Genal  spine  curving 
backward  and  outward,  extending  as  far  as  seventh 
thoracic  segment.  Seventeen  or  more  outwardly 
directed  lateral  spines,  hindmost  on  genal  spine;  ante- 
rior few  spines  shorter  than  width  of  border,  squat,  and 
blunt;  subsequent  spines  longer  than  width  of  border 
and  successively  longer,  slender,  and  pointed.  Dou- 
blure smooth,  extending  to  lateral  border  furrow. 

Hypostome  subquadrate,  squat,  slightly  wider  than 
long.  Middle  body  subquadrate,  gently  swollen,  extend- 
ing to  anterior  margin.  Middle  furrow  short,  oblique. 
Lateral  lobe  half  length  of  middle  body  abaxially,  nar- 
row. Lateral  border  narrow,  convex,  widening  and  less 
swollen  posterior  to  midlength;  posterior  wings  project 
strongly,  situated  60  per  cent  length  from  front.  Lateral 
furrow  very  shallow  alongside  lateral  lobe,  broad  and 
well  defined  posteriorly.  Posterior  border  essentially 
transverse  but  bowed  backward  mesially,  weakly 
convex. 

Thorax  55  per  cent  length  of  dorsal  shield;  nine  tho- 
racic segments  on  disarticulated  dorsal  shield.  Axis  30 
per  cent  anterior  width  of  thorax,  arched  transversely; 
lateral  nodes  well  developed.  Axial  furrow  shallow  and 
broad.  Pleura  horizontal,  comprising  a  short  (exsag.), 
slightly  swollen  anterior  band  separated  by  a  broad, 
shallow  furrow  from  longer  (exsag.)  and  much  more 
swollen  posterior  band;  posterior  band  terminating  in 
a  long,  slender  spine.  Spines  successively  longer  and 
more  backwardly  directed.  A  row  of  granules  on  poste- 
rior margin  of  rings;  posterior  bands  of  pleurae  weakly 
granular. 

Pygidium,  excluding  spines,  30  to  35  per  cent  as  long 
as  wide.  First  ring  and  furrow  strong.  Second  ring 
almost  equally  swollen;  ring  furrow  dying  out  abaxially. 
Third  ring  stunted;  posterior  margin  bowed  backward. 
Axial  furrow  shallow  alongside  first  ring,  deep  and 
broad  posteriorly.  Pleural  lobe  largely  occupied  by 
swollen  rib  running  obliquely  from  opposite  first  ring  to 
great  spine.  Lateral  border  widening  backward,  faintly 
developed  at  great  spine.  Five  pairs  of  spines:  foremost 


pair  small;  second  and  third  pairs  gradational  in  length 
to  fourth  pair  (great  spines);  fourth  pair  twice  sagittal 
length  of  pygidium;  fifth  pair  as  long  as  third  pair. 

Prosopon  consisting  of  tubercles  of  various  sizes;  a 
single  row  of  tubercles  on  anterior  border  and  eye 
ridge. 

DISCUSSION 

The  holotype  cranidium  of  L.  semiglabra  (Poulsen)  is 
incomplete  posteriorly,  and  it  is  not  possible  to  be  cer- 
tain whether  occipital  spines  were  present  or  not.  The 
Road  River  Formation  cranidia  agree  in  other  features, 
and  we  follow  Raasch  in  Raasch,  Norford,  and  Wilson 
(1961)  in  considering  these  cranidia  conspecific  with 
the  L.  semiglabra  holotype.  The  holotype  cranidium  of 
L.  groenlandica  (Poulsen,  1934:24,  pi.  3,  fig.  6),  also 
from  Kap  Schuchert,  differs  markedly  from  L.  semigla- 
bra in  its  rounded  anterior  margin  and  broader  fixigena. 
Only  one  form  of  the  various  odontopleurid  skeletal 
elements  is  present  in  the  Road  River  Formation  mate- 
rial, indicating  a  single  species.  The  librigena  attributed 
to  L.  groenlandica  by  Poulsen  (1934,  pi.  3,  fig.  5;  this 
paper,  PI.  13,  fig.  14)  corresponds  to  our  material;  it 
differs  from  the  one  referred  to  semiglabra  by  Poulsen 
(1934,  pi.  3,  fig.  9)  in  its  narrower  border  and  denser 
tuberculation. 


Indeterminate  odontopleurine 

PI.  10,  fig.  9 

MATERIAL 

From  BB  131  (Lower  Silurian),  Illtyd  Range:  1 
cranidium. 

DISCUSSION 

This  cranidium  differs  from  the  cranidia  attributed  to 
L.  semiglabra  in  having  a  more  parallel-sided  median 
glabellar  lobe,  a  more  convex  frontal  lobe,  coarser 
tuberculation,  and  a  nontuberculate  adaxial  portion 
of  the  fixigena.  Although  this  specimen  is  probably 
attributable  to  Leonaspis,  the  generic  reference  is  best 
left  undecided. 


28 


Acknowledgements 


We  thank  Bob  Owens,  Alan  Thomas,  and  Lars  Ram- 
skold  for  information  and  opinions  on  some  of  these 
trilobites.  Valdemar  Poulsen  of  the  University  of 
Copenhagen  kindly  provided  plaster  casts  of  C. 
Poulsen's  trilobite  types  from  North  Greenland.  We 
thank  Godfrey  Nowlan  of  the  Geological  Survey  of 
Canada  for  identification  of  the  conodont  faunas.  Brian 


O'Donovan  printed  the  trilobite  photographs  from  our 
negatives.  The  figures  were  prepared  by  David  Sargent 
and  Ilgvars  Steins.  David  Rudkin,  Janet  Waddington, 
and  Joan  Burke  of  the  Royal  Ontario  Museum  were 
very  helpful  with  a  variety  of  palaeontological,  curato- 
rial, and  editorial  matters.  This  project  was  supported 
by  NSERC  Operating  Grant  A3825  to  Rolf  Ludvigsen. 


29 


Literature  Cited 


ANGELIN,  N.  P. 

1851  Palaeontologia  Svecicae.  I:  Iconographia  crusta- 
ceorum  formationis  transitionis.  Holmiae.  Fasc. 
1:1-24. 

1854  Palaeontologia  Scandinavica.  I:  Crustacea  forma- 
tionis transitionis.  Academiae  Regiae  Scientar- 
ium  Suecanae,  Holmiae,  pp.  21-92. 

BARRANDE,  J. 

1846      Notice  preliminaire  sur  le  Systeme  Trilobites  de 
Boheme.  Leipsig.  97  pp. 
■    1852      Systeme  Silurien  du  centre  de  la  Boheme.  lere 
partie.  Recherches  paleontologiques,  vol.  1 .  Crus- 
taces.  Trilobites.  Prague  et  Paris.  935  pp. 

BEYRICH,  E. 

1845       Ueber  einige  bohmische  Trilobiten.  Berlin.  47  pp. 
bouCek,  b. 

1933  O  novych  trilobitech  ceskeho  gotlandienu.  Cast  I. 
Vestnik  Statigraphi  geologisch  Ustredniho  9: 171- 
179. 

BOLTON,  T.  E. 

1965  Trilobites  from  the  Upper  Silurian  rocks  of  the 
Canadian  Arctic  Archipelago:  Encrinurus  {Fram- 
mia)  and  Hemiarges.  Geological  Survey  of  Can- 
ada, Bulletin  134:1-14. 

BRONGNIART,  A. 

1822  Les  Trilobites.  In  Brongniart,  A.  and  A.  G.  Des- 
marest,  Histoire  naturelle  des  crustaces  fossiles, 
sous  les  rapports  zoologiques  et  geologiques. 
Paris  and  Strasbourg,  F.  G.  Leverault.  154  pp. 

BURMEISTER,  H. 

1843  Die  Organisation  der  Trilobiten.  Berlin,  Georg 
Reimer.  147  pp. 

CHANG,  W. 

1974  Silurian  Trilobita.  In  A  handbook  of  the  stratigra- 
phy and  palaeontology  in  southwest  China. 
Beijing,  Academic  and  Science  Press.  454  pp. 

CHATTERTON,  B.  D.  E. 

1971  Taxonomy  and  ontogeny  of  Siluro-Devonian  tri- 
lobites from  near  Yass,  New  South  Wales.  Palae- 
ontographica  (Abt.  A)  137:1-108. 

CHATTERTON,  B.  D.  E.  and  K.  S.  W.  CAMPBELL 

1980  Silurian  trilobites  from  near  Canberra  and  some 
related  forms  from  the  Yass  Basin.  Palaeonto- 
graphica  (Abt.  A)  167:77-119. 

CHATTERTON,  B.  D.  E.  and  R.  LUDVIGSEN 

1976  Silicified  Middle  Ordovician  trilobites  from  the 
South  Nahanni  River  area.  District  of  Mackenzie, 
Canada.  Palaeontographica  (Abt.  A)  154:1-106. 

CHATTERTON,  B.  D.  E.  and  D.  PERRY 

1977  Lochkovian  trilobites  and  conodonts  from  north- 
western Canada.  Journal  of  Paleontology  5 1:772- 
796. 

1983  Silicified  Silurian  odontopleurid  trilobites  from 
the  Mackenzie  Mountains.  Palaeontographica 
Canadiana  1:1-126. 


DAWES,  P.  R.  and  J.  haller 

1979  Historical  aspects  in  the  geological  investigation 
of  northern  Greenland.  Part  1.  New  maps  and 
photographs  from  the  2nd  Thule  Expedition 
1916-1918  and  the  Bicentenary  Jubilee  Expedi- 
tion 1920-1923.  Meddelelserom  Gr0nland  200:1- 
38. 

FEIST,  R. 

1970      Breviscutellum  {Meridioscutellum)  n.  sg.  (Trilo- 
bite)  et  son  developpement  larvaire.  Geobios 
3(Fasc.  4):41-73. 
frech,  f.  f. 

1888      Uber  das  Devon  der  Ostalen.  Deutsche  geologi- 
sche  Gesellschaft,  Zeitschrift  39:659-738. 
fritz,  w.  h. 

1985  The  basal  contact  of  the  Road  River  Group — a 
proposal  for  its  location  in  the  type  area  and  in 
other  selected  areas  in  the  northern  Canadian 
Cordillera.  Geological  Survey  of  Canada,  Paper 
85-lB:205-215. 
hawle,  I.  and  A.  J.  c.  corda 

1847      Prodrom  einer  Monographic  der  bohmischen  Tri- 
lobiten. Prague.  176  pp. 
hedstrom,  h. 

1923      Contributions  to  the  fossil  fauna  of  Gotland.  Sver- 
iges  Geologiska  Undersokning  316:3-15. 
helbert,  g.  j.,  p.  d.  lane,  r.  m.  OWENS,  D.  J.  sivETER,  and  A.  T. 

THOMAS 

1982  Lower  Silurian  trilobites  from  the  Oslo  Region. 
lUGS  Subcommission  on  Silurian  stratigraphy. 
Field  Meeting,  Oslo  Region  1982.  In  Worsley, 
D.,  ed.,  Palaeontological  Contributions  from  the 
University  of  Oslo  178:129-148. 
holloway,  d.  j. 

1980  Middle  Silurian  trilobites  from  Arkansas  and 
Oklahoma,  U.S.A.  Palaeontographica  (Abt.  A) 
170:1-85. 

holm,  g. 

1882  De  Svenska  arterna  af  Trilobitslaktet  Illaenus 
(Dalman).  Kunglige  Svenska  Vetenskapsakade- 
miens,  Bihang  till  Handlingar  7:1-148. 

1886  Revision  der  ostbaltischen  silurischen  Trilobiten. 
Abtheilung  3.  Illaeniden.  Memoires  de  I'Acade- 
mie  imperiale  des  sciences  de  St.-Petersbourg 
33:1-173. 

HURST,  J.  M. 

1980  Silurian  stratigraphy  and  facies  distribution  in 
Washington  Land  and  western  Hall  Land,  North 
Greenland.  Gr0nlands  Geologiske  Unders0gelse, 
Bulletin  138:1-95. 

JACKSON,  D.  E.,  A.  C.  LENZ,  and  A.  E.  H.  PEDDER 

1978  Late  Silurian  and  Early  Devonian  graptolite, 
brachiopod  and  coral  faunas  from  northwestern 
and  arctic  Canada.  Geological  Association  of 
Canada,  Special  Paper  17:1-159. 


30 


KOBAYASHI,  T. 

1985  On  two  Silurian  trilobitc  genera,  Prantliu  and  La- 
tiproetus.  Proceedings  of  the  Japan  Academy, 
Series  B:  Physical  and  Biological  Sciences  61:419- 

421. 

KOBAYASHI,  T.  and  T.  HAMADA 

1974  Silurian  trilobites  of  Japan  in  comparison  with 
Asian,  Pacific  and  other  faunas.  Palaeontological 
Society  of  Japan,  Special  Paper  18:1-155. 

I.AMONT,  A. 

1948       Scottish    dragons.    Quarry    Managers'    Journal 
31:531-535. 
LANE,  P.  D. 

1972  New  trilobites  from  the  Silurian  of  north-east 
Greenland,  with  a  note  on  trilobite  faunas  in  pure 
limestones.  Palaeontology  15:336-364. 

1979  Llandovery  trilobites  from  Washington  Land, 
North  Greenland.  Gr0nlands  Geologiske  Under- 
s0gelse.  Bulletin  131:1-37. 

1984  Silurian  trilobites  from  Hall  Land  and  Nyeboe 
Land,  western  Greenland.  Gr0nlands  Geologiske 
Unders0geise,  Rapport  121:53-75. 

1 988  Silurian  trilobites  from  Peary  Land,  central  North 
Greenland.  Gr0nlands  Geologiske  Unders0gelse, 
Rapport  137:93-117. 

LANE,  P.  D.  and  R.  M.  OWENS 

1982  Silurian  trilobites  from  Kap  Schuchert,  Washing- 
ton Land,  western  North  Greenland.  Gr0nlands 
Geologiske  Unders0gelse,  Rapport  108:41-69. 

LANE,  P.  D.  and  A.  T.  THOMAS 

1983  A  review  of  the  trilobite  suborder  Scutelluina. 
Special  Papers  in  Palaeontology  30:141-160. 

LENZ,  A.  c. 

1970  Late  Silurian  brachiopods  of  Prongs  Creek, 
northern  Yukon.  Journal  of  Paleontology  44:480- 
500. 

1972  Ordovician  and  Devonian  history  of  northern 
Yukon  and  adjacent  District  of  Mackenzie.  Bulle- 
tin of  Canadian  Petroleum  Geology  20:321-361. 

1976  Late  Ordovician-Early  Silurian  glaciation  and  the 
Ordovician-Silurian  boundary  in  the  northern 
Canadian  Cordillera.  Geology  4:313-317. 

1977  Upper  Silurian  and  Lower  Devonian  brachiopods 
of  Royal  Creek,  Yukon,  Canada.  Palaeonto- 
graphica  (Abt.  A)  159:37-138. 

1979  Llandoverian  graptolite  zonation  in  the  northern 
Canadian  Cordillera.  Acta  Palaeontologica 
Polonica  24:137-153. 

1982  Llandoverian  graptolites  of  the  northern  Cana- 
dian Cordillera:  Petalograptus,  Cephalograptus, 
Rhaphidograptus,  Dimorphograptus,  Retiolitidae, 
and  Monograptidae.  Royal  Ontario  Museum, 
Life  Sciences  Contributions  130:1-154. 

LENZ,  A.  C.  and  A.  E.  H.  PEDDER 

1972  Lower  and  Middle  Paleozoic  sediments  and  pale- 
ontology of  Royal  Creek  and  Peel  River,  Yukon, 
and  Powell  Creek,  N.W.T.  24th  International 
Geological  Congress,  Montreal,  Guidebook  to 
Field  Excursion  Al:1^3. 


LINDSTROM,  G. 

1885       Forteckning  pa   Gotlands  siluriska  crustaccer. 
Kunglige   Svenska   Vetenskapsakademicns,  Of- 
versigt  Handlingar  34:1-89. 
LU,  Y.-H. 

1962  Restudy  on  Grabau's  three  Silurian  trilobites 
from  Hupeh.  Acta  Palaeontologia  Sinica  10:158- 
173. 

LUDVIGSEN,  R.,  S.  R.  WESTROP,  B.  R.  PRATT,  P.  A.  TUFFNELL,  and 
G.  R.  YOUNG 

1986       Paleoscene  #3.  Dual  biostratigraphy:  zones  and 
biofacies.  Geoscience  Canada  13:139-154. 
MIKULIC,  D.  G. 

1981  Trilobites  in  Paleozoic  carbonate  buildups.  Leth- 
aia  14:45-56. 

MILNE-EDWARDS,  H. 

1840  Histoire  naturelle  des  crustaces,  comprenant 
I'anatomie,  la  physiologic  et  la  classification  de 
ces  animaux.  Paris.  638  pp. 

MOORE,  R.  C. 

1959  Treatise  on  invertebrate  paleontology.  Part  0. 
Arthropoda  1.  Lawrence,  Geological  Society  of 
America  and  University  of  Kansas  Press.  560  pp. 

NORFORD,  B.  S. 

1962  Illustrations  of  Canadian  fossils:  Cambrian, 
Ordovician  and  Silurian  of  the  western  Cordil- 
lera. Geological  Survey  of  Canada,  Paper  62- 
14:1-25. 

1964  Reconnaissance  of  the  Ordovician  and  Silurian 
rocks  of  northern  Yukon  Territory.  Geological 
Survey  of  Canada,  Paper  63-39:1-139. 

1972  Silurian  stratigraphic  sections  at  Kap  Tyson, 
Offley  0,  and  Kap  Schuchert,  northwestern 
Greenland.  Meddelelser  om  Gr0nland  195:1-40. 

1973  Lower  Silurian  species  of  the  trilobite  Scotoharpes 
from  Canada  and  northeastern  Greenland.  Geo- 
logical Survey  of  Canada,  Bulletin  222:9-33. 

1981  The  trilobite  fauna  of  the  Silurian  Attawapiskat 
Formation,  northern  Ontario  and  northern  Mani- 
toba. Geological  Survey  of  Canada,  Bulletin 
327:1-37. 

NORFORD,  B.  S.,  T.  E.  BOLTON,  M.  J.  COPELAND,  L.  M.  GUMMING, 
and  G.  W.  SINCLAIR 

1970  Ordovician  and  Silurian  faunas.  In  Douglas,  R. 
J.  W.,  ed.,  Geology  and  economic  minerals  of 
Canada.  Geological  Survey  of  Canada,  Economic 
Geology  Report  1:601-613. 

NORRIS,  A.  W. 

1985  Stratigraphy  of  Devonian  outcrop  belts  in  north- 
ern Yukon  Territory  and  northwestern  District  of 
Mackenzie  (Operation  Porcupine  area).  Geologi- 
cal Survey  of  Canada,  Memoir  410:1-81. 

OSMOLSKA,  H. 

1970  Revision  of  non-cyrtosymbolinid  trilobites  from 
the  Tournasian-Namurian  of  Eurasia.  Palaeonto- 
logia Polonica  23:1-165. 

OWENS,  R.  M. 

1973  British  Ordovician  and  Silurian  Proetidae  (Tri- 
lobita).  Palaeontographical  Society  Monograph. 


31 


London,  Palaeontographical  Society.  98  pp. 

PERRY,  D.  and  B.  D.  E.  CHATTERTON 

1977  Silurian  (Wenlockian)  trilobites  from  Baillie- 
Hamilton  Island,  Canadian  Arctic  Archipelago. 
Canadian  Journal  of  Earth  Sciences  14:285-317. 

1979      Wenlock  trilobites  and  brachiopods  from  the 

Mackenzie  Mountains,  north-western  Canada. 

Palaeontology  22:569-607. 
POULSEN,  c. 

1934      The  Silurian  faunas  of  North  Greenland.  1.  The 

fauna  of  the  Cape  Schuchert  Formation.  Med- 

delelser  om  Gr0nland  72:1-46. 

PRIBYL,  A. 

1946  O  nekolika  novych  trilobitovych  rodech  z  ceskeho 
siluru  a  devonu.  Pfi'roda  38:1-7. 

PRIBYL,  A.  and  J.  VANEK 

1962  Trilobitova  fauna  ceskeho  svrchniho  siluru  (bud- 
nanu  a  lochkovu)  a  jeji  biostratigraficky  vyznam. 
Sborni'k  Narodnfho  Muzea  v  Praze  18:25-46. 

1978  Studie  zu  einiger  neuen  Trilobiten  der  Proetidae- 
Familie.  Acta  Universiteatis  Carolinae-Geolica 
1-2:163-182. 

QIU,  H.,  Y.  LU,  Z.  ZHU,  D.  BI,  T.  LIN,  Z.  ZHOU,  Q.  ZHANG,  Y.  QIAN, 
T.  JU,  N.  HAN,  and  X.  WEI 

1983      Trilobita.    In    Palaeontological    Atlas    of   East 

China.  Beijing,  Geological  Publishing  House,  pp. 

28-254.  [In  Chinese] 

RAASCH,  G.  O.,  B.  S.  NORFORD,  and  D.  W.  R.  WILSON 

1961  The  Silurian  Aulacopleura  Socialis  in  the  Yukon 
Territory.  In  Raasch,  G.  O.,  ed..  Geology  of  the 
Arctic.  Toronto,  University  of  Toronto  Press,  vol. 
1,  pp.  466-480. 

RAMSKOLD,  L. 

1986  Silurian  encrinurid  trilobites  from  Gotland  and 
Dalarna,  Sweden.  Palaeontology  29:527-575. 

RAYMOND,  p.  E. 

1916  New  and  old  Silurian  trilobites  from  southeastern 
Wisconsin,  with  notes  on  the  genera  of  the  Illaeni- 
dae.  Harvard  Museum  of  Comparative  Zoology, 
Bulletin  60:1^1. 

RICHTER,  R.  and  E,  RICHTER 

1917  iJber  die  Einteilung  der  Familie  Acidaspidae  und 
iiber  einige  ihrer  devonischen  Vertreter.  Zentral- 
blatt  fiir  Mineralogie,  Geologic  und  Palaontolo- 
gie,  pp.  462-472. 

1955  Scutelluidae  n.n.  (Tril.).  Scnckenbcrgiana  leth- 
aea  36:291-293. 

SALTER,  J.  W. 

1864      A  monograph  of  the  British  trilobites  from  the 
Cambrian,  Silurian,  and  Devonian  formations. 
Palaeontographical  Society  Monograph.  London, 
Palaeontographical  Society.  80  pp. 
Snajdr,  m. 

1958  Nekolik  novych  rodu  trilobitu  z  celede  Scutellui- 
dae. Vestnik  Ustfedniho  ustavu  geologickeho 
33:1-263. 

1960      A  study  of  the  Family  Scutelluidae  (Trilobitae). 


Rozpravy  Ustfedniho  ustavu  geologickeho  26:11- 
221. 

1980  Bohemian  Silurian  and  Devonian  Proetidae  (Tri- 
lobita). Rozpravy  Ustfedniho  ustavu  geologi- 
ckeho 45:1-323. 

1981  New  Silurian  and  Devonian  trilobites  (Barran- 
dian,  Czechoslovakia).  Vestnik  Ustfedniho  us- 
tavu geologickeho  56:301-303. 

1985  Bohemian  representatives  of  the  subfamily  Encri- 
nurinae,  Trilobita.  Sbornik  Geologickych  Ved 
Paleontologie  27:9-46. 

STRUSZ,  D.  L, 

1980  The  Encrinuridae  and  related  trilobite  families, 
with  a  description  of  Silurian  species  from  south- 
eastern Australia.  Palaeontographica  (Abt.  A) 
168:1-68. 

TEMPLE,  J.  T.  and  R.  p.  TRIPP 

1979  An  investigation  of  the  Encrinuridae  (Trilobita) 
by  numerical  taxonomic  methods.  Transactions 
of  the  Royal  Society  of  Edinburgh  70:223-250. 

THOMAS,  A.  T. 

1978  British  Wenlock  trilobites.  Part  1.  Palaeonto- 
graphical Society  Monograph.  London,  Palae- 
ontographical Society.  56  pp. 

1979  Trilobite  associations  in  the  British  Wenlock. 
Geological  Society  of  London,  Special  Publica- 
tion 8:447^52. 

THOMAS,  A.  T.  and  D.  J.  HOLLOW  AY 

1988  Classification  and  phylogeny  of  the  trilobite  order 
Lichida.  Philosophical  Transactions  of  the  Royal 
Society  of  London,  Series  B  321:179-262. 

THOMAS,  A.  T.  and  G.  M.  NARBONNE 

1979  Silurian  trilobites  from  arctic  Canada.  Geological 
Magazine  116:1-19. 

THOMAS,  A.  T.  and  R.  M.  OWENS 

1978  A  review  of  the  trilobite  family  Aulacopleuridae. 
Palaeontology  21:65-81. 

TRIPP,  R.  p.,  J.  T.  TEMPLE,  and  K.  C.  GASS 

1977  The  Silurian  trilobite  Encrinurus  variolaris  and 
allied  species,  with  notes  on  Frammia.  Palaeon- 
tology 20:847-867. 

VOGDES,  A.  W. 

1890  A  bibliography  of  Palaeozoic  Crustacea  from 
1698  to  1889  including  a  list  of  North  American 
species  and  a  systematic  arrangement  of  genera. 
United  States  Geological  Survey,  Bulletin  63:1- 
177. 

WEBBY,  B.  D.,  H.  T.  MOORS,  and  R.  A.  McLEAN 

1970      Malongullia  and  Encrinuraspis,  new  Ordovician 
trilobites  from  New  South  Wales,  Australia.  Jour- 
nal of  Paleontology  44:881-887. 
WESTROP,  S.  R. 

1983  The  life  habits  of  the  Ordovician  illaenine  trilo- 
bite ^MWfl^to/rfe*.  Lethaia  16:15-24. 

WHITTINGTON,  H.  B. 

1959  Silicified  Middle  Ordovician  trilobites:  Remo- 
pleurididae,      Trinucleidae,      Raphiophoridae, 


32 


Endymioniidae.  Harvard  Museum  of  Compar-  ZENKER,  J.  C. 

ative  Zoology,  Bulletin  121:371-496.  1833       Beitrage  zur  Naturgcschichtc  dor  Urwclt.  Organ- 

wu,  H.  ische  Restc  (Petrefecten)  aus  der  Altcnburger 

1977      Comments  on  new  genera  and  species  of  Silurian-  Braunkohlen-Formation     dem     Blankenburger 

Devonian  trilobites  in  southwest  China  and  their  Ouadersandstein,  jenaischen  bunten  Sandstein 

significance.  Acta  Palaeontologia  Sinica  16:95-  und  bohmischen  Uebergangsgcbirge.  Jena.  67  pp. 
117. 


33 


Plate  1,  figs.  1-15. 

Paracybantyx  asulcatus  gen.  et  sp.  nov.,  locality  AA  95,  Road  River  Formation,  Prongs  Creek,  Yukon 
Territory,  Canada. 

1-3.  Cranidium,  dorsal,  frontal,  and  oblique  views,  ROM  45343,  x  2. 

4,5.  Holotype  cranidium,  lateral  and  dorsal  views,  ROM  45344,  x  4. 

6.  Cranidium,  dorsal  view,  ROM  45376,  x  3. 

7-9.  Cranidium,  dorsal,  frontal,  and  oblique  views,  ROM  45330,  x  4. 

10,11.  Pygidium,  lateral  and  dorsal  views,  ROM  45342,  x  2. 

12.  Hypostome,  latex  impression,  ventral  view,  ROM  45375,  x  6. 

13,14.  Pygidium,  lateral  and  dorsal  views,  ROM  45360,  x  2. 

15.  Pygidium,  lateral  view  enlarged  to  show  prosopon,  ROM  45360,  x  4. 


34 


13 


Plate  2,  figs.  1-12. 

Kosovopeltis  borealis  (Poulsen),  locality  AA  2^.5,  Road  River  Formation,  Prongs  Creek,  Yukon 
Territory,  Canada. 

1,2.  Complete  specimen,  dorsal  views,  ROM  42143,  x  4. 

3.  Librigena,  ventral  view,  ROM  42144,  x  3. 

4.  Rostral  plate,  ventral  view,  ROM  42145,  x  4. 

5,6.  Cranidium,  dorsal  and  oblique  views,  ROM  42146,  x  4. 

7.  Hypostome,  ventral  view,  ROM  42147,  x  9. 

8.  Hypostome,  ventral  view,  ROM  42148,  x  9. 

9.  Cranidium,  dorsal  view,  ROM  42149,  x  9. 

10.  Pygidium,  latex  impression,  dorsal  view,  ROM  42150,  x  9. 

11.  Pygidium,  dorsal  view,  ROM  42151,  x  1.4. 

12.  Pygidium,  dorsal  view,  ROM  42152,  x  1.4. 


36 


Plate  3,  figs.  1-10. 

Kosovopeltis  borealis  (Poulsen),  locality  AA  2^.5,  Road  River  Formation,  Prongs  Creek,  Yukon 
Territory,  Canada. 

1.  Cranidium,  latex  impression,  dorsal  view,  ROM  42153,  x  4. 

2.  Pygidium,  latex  impression,  dorsal  view,  ROM  42154,  x  1.7. 

3-5.  Cranidium  with  rostral  plate,  dorsal,  anterior,  and  ventral  views,  ROM  42155,  x  2. 

6.  Librigena,  dorsal  view,  ROM  42156,  x  3. 

7.  Pygidium,  latex  impression,  ventral  view,  ROM  42157a,  x  1.7. 

8.  Slab  crowded  with  pygidia,  ROM  42157,  x  1. 

9.  Librigena,  dorsal  view,  ROM  42158,  x  4. 

10.  Cranidium,  latex  impression,  dorsal  view,  ROM  42159,  x  4. 


38 


Plate  4,  figs.  1-14. 

Figs.  1-13.  Kosovopeltis  borealis  (Poulsen),  locality  AA  2^.5,  Road  River  Formation,  Prongs  Creek, 
Yukon  Territory,  Canada. 

1,2.  Protaspis,  latex  impression,  dorsal  and  oblique  views,  ROM  42160,  x  56. 

3,4.  Meraspid  cranidium,  oblique  and  dorsal  views,  ROM  42161,  x  24. 

5.  Transitory  pygidium  with  one  protothoracic  segment  attached,  dorsal  view,  ROM  42162,  x  12. 

6,7.  Transitory  pygidium  with  two  protothoracic  segments  attached,  latex  impression,  dorsal  and 
oblique  views,  ROM  42163,  x  12. 

8,9.  Internal  mould  of  lens  surface  of  holaspid  eye,  ROM  42164,  x  100  and  x  500. 

10,11.  Transitory  pygidium,  latex  impression,  oblique  and  dorsal  views,  ROM  42165,  x  50. 

12,13.  Smallest  transitory  pygidium,  ROM  42166,  x  56  and  x  92. 

Fig.  14.  Otarion  {Songkania)  socialis  (Poulsen),  locality  AA  2-4.5,  Road  River  Formation,  Prongs 
Creek,  Yukon  Territory,  Canada,  hypostome,  ventral  view,  ROM  42204,  x  24. 


40 


Plate  5,  figs.  1-16. 

All  specimens  are  from  locality  BB  131,  unnamed  carbonates,  Illtyd  Range,  Yukon  Territory,  Canada. 

Figs.  1-11.  Stenopareia  illtyd  sp.  nov. 

1,2.  Cranidium,  dorsal  and  oblique  views,  ROM  42167,  x  3. 

3,4.  Holotype  cranidium,  dorsal  and  anterior  views,  ROM  42168,  x  3. 

5,6.  Cranidium,  dorsal  and  anterior  views,  ROM  42169,  x  3. 

7.  Pygidium,  dorsal  view,  ROM  42170,  x  9. 

8,9.  Pygidium,  dorsal  and  lateral  views,  ROM  42171,  x  4. 

10,11.  Pygidium,  dorsal  and  oblique  views,  ROM  42172,  x  5. 

Fig.  12.  Indeterminate  illaenid,  cephalon,  dorsal  view,  ROM  42173,  x  3. 

Figs.  13,14.  Indeterminate  bumastine,  cranidium,  dorsal  and  anterior  views,  ROM  42174,  x  9. 

Figs.  15,16.  Cheirurus  sp.,  cranidium,  lateral  and  dorsal  views,  ROM  42175,  x  5. 


42 


Plate  6,  figs.  1-24. 

Figs.  1-14.  Hedstroemia  kutchini  sp.  nov.,  locality  AA  95,  Road  River  Formation,  Prongs  Creek, 
Yukon  Territory,  Canada. 

1,2.  Cranidium,  dorsal  and  oblique  views,  ROM  45371,  x  5. 

3,4.  Holotype  cranidium,  dorsal  and  oblique  views,  ROM  45347,  x  6. 

5.  Cranidium,  dorsal  view,  ROM  45348,  x  6. 

6,7.  Pygidium,  dorsal  and  lateral  views,  ROM  45334,  x  4. 

8.  Pygidium,  dorsal  view,  ROM  45335,  x  4. 

9,10.  Pygidium,  dorsal  and  lateral  views,  ROM  45328a,  x  4. 

11.  Librigena,  dorsal  view,  ROM  45372,  x  6. 

12.  Librigena,  latex  impression,  dorsal  view,  ROM  45358,  x  5. 

13.  Hypostome,  ventral  view,  ROM  45329,  x  8. 

14.  Hypostome,  ventral  view,  ROM  45370,  x  8. 

Fig.  15.  Indeterminate  proetid  A,  locality  AA  95,  Road  River  Formation,  Prongs  Creek,  Yukon 
Territory,  Canada,  hypostome,  ventral  view,  ROM  45338b,  x  8. 

Figs.  16-24.  Hedstroemia  sourdoughi  sp.  nov.,  locality  AA  95,  Road  River  Formation,  Prongs  Creek, 
Yukon  Territory,  Canada. 

16.  Pygidium,  dorsal  view,  ROM  45333,  x  4. 

17-19.  Pygidium,  posterior,  lateral,  and  dorsal  views,  ROM  45331,  x  6. 

20.  Pygidium,  dorsal  view,  ROM  45323,  x  5. 

21.  Cranidium,  latex  impression,  dorsal  view,  ROM  45357,  x  4. 
22,23.  Holotype  cranidium,  dorsal  and  oblique  views,  ROM  45332,  x  4. 
24.  Cranidium,  dorsal  view,  ROM  45326,  x  6. 


44 


Plate  7,  figs.  1-20. 

Figs.  1-15.  Prantlia  vagrans  sp.  nov.,  locality  AA  95,  Road  River  Formation,  Prongs  Creek,  Yukon 
Territory,  Canada. 

1.  Cranidium,  dorsal  view,  ROM  45339,  x  4. 

2.  Cranidium,  dorsal  view,  ROM  45340,  x  4. 

3.  Cranidium,  latex  impression,  dorsal  view,  ROM  45353,  x  6. 

4.  Cranidium,  dorsal  view,  ROM  45365,  x  6. 

5.  Librigena,  showing  narrow  doublure,  ventral  view,  ROM  45327,  x  5. 
6,7.  Holotype  pygidium,  dorsal  and  oblique  views,  ROM  45363,  x  6. 

8.  Pygidium,  dorsal  view,  ROM  45337,  x  4. 

9.  Pygidium,  dorsal  view,  ROM  45336a,  x  4. 

10.  Meraspid  cranidium,  latex  impression,  ROM  45351,  x  8. 

11.  Pygidium,  showing  narrow  doublure,  ventral  view,  ROM  45364,  x  4. 

12.  Pygidium,  dorsal  view,  ROM  45328b,  x  4. 

13.  Pygidium,  dorsal  view,  ROM  45341,  x  5. 

14.  Librigena,  oblique  view,  ROM  45338a,  x  5. 

15.  Librigena,  latex  impression,  oblique  view,  ROM  45355,  x  4. 

Figs.  16-20.  Indeterminate  lichid,  locality  AA  95,  Road  River  Formation,  Prongs  Creek,  Yukon 
Territory,  Canada. 

16.  Pygidium,  dorsal  view,  ROM  45361,  x  2. 

17.  Pygidium,  dorsal  view,  ROM  45366b,  x  2. 

18.  Cranidium,  dorsal  view,  ROM  45349,  x  5. 

19.  Cranidium,  dorsal  view,  ROM  47356,  x  5. 

20.  Hypostome,  latex  impression,  ventral  view,  ROM  45354,  x  5. 


46 


Plate  8,  figs.  1-12. 

Otarion  (Songkania)  socialis  (Poulsen),  locality  AA  2-4.5,  Road  River  Formation,  Prongs  Creek, 
Yukon  Territory,  Canada. 

1,2.  Complete  specimen,  dorsal  and  oblique  views,  ROM  42176,  x  7.5. 

3,4.  Cranidium,  dorsal  and  anterior  views,  ROM  42177,  x  9. 

5.  Complete  specimen  lacking  axial  spine  on  sixth  segment,  dorsal  view,  ROM  42178,  x  7.5. 

6,7.  Complete  specimen  with  axial  spine  on  sixth  segment,  dorsal  and  oblique  views,  ROM  42179, 
X  6. 

8.  Cephalon  and  thorax  with  axial  spine  on  sixth  segment,  oblique  view,  ROM  42180,  x  5. 

9.  Librigena,  oblique  view,  ROM  42181,  x  9. 

10,11.  Complete  specimen,  dorsal  and  oblique  views,  ROM  42182,  x  7.5. 
12.  Librigena,  oblique  view,  ROM  42183,  x  9. 


48 


Plate  9,  figs.  1-11. 

All  specimens  are  from  locality  BB  131,  unnamed  carbonates,  Illtyd  Range,  Yukon  Territory,  Canada. 

Figs.  1-3.  Scotoharpes  raaschi  Norford,  1973. 

1,3.  Cephalon,  dorsal  and  oblique  views,  ROM  42184,  x  5. 

2.  Cephalon,  latex  impression,  dorsal  view,  ROM  42185,  x  5. 

Figs.  4,5.  Indeterminate  proetid  B. 

4.  Hypostome,  ventral  view,  ROM  42186,  x  5. 

5.  Cranidium,  dorsal  view,  ROM  42187,  x  5. 

Fig.  6.  Encrinuraspis  sp.,  pygidium,  dorsal  view,  ROM  42188,  x  9. 

Fig.  7.  Indeterminate  calymenid,  pygidium,  dorsal  view,  ROM  42189,  x  4. 

Figs.  8-11.  Kosovopeltisl  spp. 

8.  Pygidium,  dorsal  view,  ROM  42190,  x  5. 

9.  Cranidium,  dorsal  view,  ROM  42191,  x  9. 

10.  Pygidium,  dorsal  view,  ROM  42192,  x  4. 

11.  Pygidium,  dorsal  view,  ROM  42193,  x  4. 


50 


Plate  10,  figs.  1-12. 

Figs.  1-8.  Cromus  princeps  (Poulsen),  locality  AA  2-4.5,  Road  River  Formation,  Prongs  Creek, 
Yukon  Territory,  Canada. 

1,2.  Cranidium,  oblique  and  dorsal  views,  ROM  42194,  x  4. 

3.  Hypostome,  ventral  view,  ROM  42195,  x  9. 

4.  Librigena,  oblique  view,  ROM  42196,  x  5. 

5.  Pygidium  (deformed),  dorsal  view,  ROM  42197,  x  9. 

6.  Cranidium,  dorsal  view,  ROM  42198,  x  9. 

7.  Pygidium,  dorsal  view,  ROM  42199,  x  4. 

8.  Pygidium,  dorsal  view,  ROM  42200,  x  4. 

Fig.  9.  Indeterminate  odontopleurine,  locality  BB  131,  unnamed  carbonates,  Illtyd  Range,  Yukon 
Territory,  Canada,  cranidium,  dorsal  view,  ROM  42201,  x  9. 

Figs.  10-12.  Dicranopeltis  sp.,  locality  BB  131,  unnamed  carbonates,  Illtyd  Range,  Yukon  Territory, 
Canada. 

10,11.  Cranidium,  dorsal  and  oblique  views,  latex  impression,  ROM  42202,  x  9. 
12.  Pygidium,  dorsal  view,  ROM  42203,  x  9. 


52 


Plate  11,  figs.  1-18. 

Figs.  1-5.  Paracybantyx  asulcatus  gen.  et  sp.  nov.,  locality  AA  95,  Road  River  Formation,  Prongs 
Creek,  Yukon  Territory,  Canada. 

1.  Pygidium,  dorsal  view,  ROM  45345,  x  2. 

2.  Librigena,  ventral  view  showing  pit  in  doublure,  ROM  45366a,  x  4. 

3.  Librigena,  latex  impression,  oblique  view  showing  doublure,  ROM  45352,  x  4. 

4.  Pygidial  doublure,  latex  impression,  ventral  view,  ROM  45374,  x  4. 

5.  Pygidium,  dorsal  view,  ROM  45369,  x  6. 

Figs.  6,7.  Indeterminate  scutelluine,  locality  AA  95,  Road  River  Formation,  Prongs  Creek,  Yukon 
Territory,  Canada,  cranidium,  dorsal  view,  ROM  45359,  x  4  and  x  8. 

Figs.  8-10,  12-18.  Balizoma  aff.  B.  obtusus  (Angelin),  locality  AA  95,  Road  River  Formation,  Prongs 
Creek,  Yukon  Territory,  Canada. 

8.  Pygidium,  dorsal  view,  ROM  45325,  x  6. 

9,10.  Pygidium,  latex  impression,  oblique  and  dorsal  views,  ROM  45350,  x  4. 

12.  Cranidium,  dorsal  view,  ROM  45336b,  x  4. 

13,14.  Pygidium,  dorsal  and  lateral  views,  ROM  45324,  x  4. 

15,16.  Pygidium,  posterior  and  dorsal  views,  ROM  45367,  x  4. 

17,18.  Hypostome,  oblique  and  ventral  views,  ROM  45362,  x  6. 

Fig.  11.  Indeterminate  encrinurine,  locality  AA  95,  Road  River  Formation,  Prongs  Creek,  Yukon 
Territory,  Canada,  cranidium,  dorsal  view,  ROM  45373,  x  3. 


54 


Plate  12,  figs.  1-16. 

Figs.  1-13.  Leonaspis  semiglabra  (Poulsen),  locality  AA  2^.5,  Road  River  Formation,  Prongs  Creek, 
Yukon  Territory,  Canada. 

1.  Cranidium,  latex  impression,  dorsal  view,  ROM  42205,  x  9. 

2.  Hypostome,  ventral  view,  ROM  42206,  x  9. 

3.  Pygidium,  dorsal  view,  ROM  42207,  x  9. 

4.  Cranidium,  latex  impression,  dorsal  view,  ROM  42208,  x  9. 

5.  Cranidium,  latex  impression,  dorsal  view,  GSC  15399,  x  9. 

6.  Cranidium,  latex  impression,  dorsal  view,  GSC  15398,  x  9. 

7.  Cranidium,  latex  impression,  dorsal  view,  ROM  42209,  x  9. 

8.  Pygidium,  dorsal  view,  GSC  15700,  x  9. 

9.  Pygidium,  dorsal  view,  GSC  15701,  x  9. 

10.  Pygidium,  dorsal  view,  ROM  42210,  x  9. 

11.  Librigena,  oblique  view,  ROM  42211,  x  9. 

12.  Pygidium,  dorsal  view,  ROM  42212,  x  9. 

13.  Incomplete  specimen,  dorsal  view,  ROM  42213,  x  6. 

Figs.  14—16.  Otarion  (Songkania)  socialis  (Poulsen),  locality  AA  2-4.5,  Road  River  Formation,  Prongs 
Creek,  Yukon  Territory,  Canada. 

14.  Cranidium,  dorsal  view,  GSC  15392,  x  9. 

15.  Pygidium,  dorsal  view,  ROM  42214,  x  9. 

16.  Pygidium,  dorsal  view,  GSC  15393,  x  9. 


56 


Plate  13,  figs.  1-14. 

Figs.  1,2.  Kosovopeltis  borealis  (Poulsen),  Cape  Schuchert  Formation  of  Poulsen  (1934),  Kap  Schu- 
chert.  North  Greenland. 

1.  Holotype  cranidium,  dorsal  view,  MMH  3267,  x  3. 

2.  Cranidium,  dorsal  view,  MMH  3268,  x  3. 

Figs.  3-6.  Otarion  (Songkania)  socialis  (Poulsen),  Cape  Schuchert  Formation,  Kap  Schuchert,  North 
Greenland. 

3,4.  Holotypecranidium,  dorsal  and  anterior  views,  MMH  3251,  x  9.  Note  caecae  crossing  preglabel- 
lar  field  abaxially. 

5.  Librigena,  oblique  view,  MMH  3252,  x  6. 

6.  Pygidium,  dorsal  view,  MMH  3253,  x  9. 

Figs.  7-12.  Cromus princeps  (Poulsen),  Cape  Schuchert  Formation,  Kap  Schuchert,  North  Greenland. 

7.  Pygidium,  dorsal  view,  MMH  3278,  x  3. 

8.  I^gidium,  dorsal  view,  MMH  3279,  x  3. 

9.  Pygidium,  dorsal  view,  MMH  3280,  x  3. 

10,11.  Holotype  cranidium,  dorsal  and  oblique  views,  MMH  3276,  x  4. 

12.  Librigena,  oblique  view,  MMH  3277,  x  3. 

Figs.  13,14.  Leonaspis  semiglabra  (Poulsen),  Cape  Schuchert  Formation,  Kap  Schuchert,  North 
Greenland. 

13.  Holotype  cranidium,  dorsal  view,  MMH  3261,  x  9. 

14.  Librigena,  oblique  view,  attributed  to  L.  groenlandica  by  Poulsen,  MMH  3258,  x  9. 


58 


Life  Sciences  Contributions  are  a  numbered  series  of  scientific  publications  of  varied 
subject  matter  published  by  the  Royal  Ontario  Museum.  Most  recent  contributions 
include: 

145  An  Annotated  Checklist  of  the  Fishes  of  the  Chagos 
Archipelago,  Central  Indian  Ocean 

Richard  Winterbottom,  Alan  R.  Emery,  and  Erling  Holm 
1989,  226  pp.,  ill.,  $48.50,  ISBN  0-88854-329-8 

146  Stipatocrinus,  a  New  and  Unusual  Camerate  Crinoid 
from  the  Lower  Silurian  of  Western  New  York 
James  D.  Eckert  and  Carlton  E.  Brett 

1987,  17  pp.,  ill.,  $6.00,  ISBN  0-88854-336-0 

147  Biostratigraphy  and  Palaeontology  of  the  Scollard 
Formation,  Late  Cretaceous  and  Paleocene  of  Alberta 
Loris  S.  Russell 

1987,  23  pp.,  ill.,  $7.00,  ISBN  0-88854-338-7 

148  Shallow-Water  Hydroids  of  Bermuda:  The 
Athecatae 

Dale  R.  Calder 

1988,  107  pp.,  ill.,  $24.50,  ISBN  0-88854-339-5 

149  Occurrence  of  the  Cladid  Inadunate  Crinoid 
Thalamocrinus  in  the  Silurian  (Wenlockian)  of 
New  York  and  Ontario 

George  C.  Mcintosh  and  Carlton  E.  Brett 
1988,  17  pp.,  ill.,  $7.75,  ISBN  0-88854-342-5 

150  Late  Cretaceous-Early  Tertiary  Dinoflagellates 
and  Acritarchs  from  the  Kashi  Area,  Tarim  Basin, 
Xinjiang  Province,  China 

Mao  Shaozhi  and  Geoffrey  Norris 

1988,  93  pp.,  ill.,  $23.00,  ISBN  0-88854-334-4 

151  The  Structure  of  the  Call  Note  System  of  the 
Warbling  Vireo 

Daryl  Howes-Jones  and  Jon  C.  Barlow 

1988,  36  pp.,  ill.,  $10.25,  ISBN  0-88854-343-3 

152  The  Type  Species  of  the  Ordovician  Trilobite  Genus 
Isotelus:  I.  gigas  Dekay,  1824 

David  M.  Rudkin  and  Ronald  P.  Tripp 

1989,  19  pp.,  ill.,  $10.25,  ISBN  0-88854-345-X 

The  Royal  Ontario  Museum  also  publishes  Life  Sciences  Miscellaneous  Publications 
and  Life  Sciences  Occasional  Papers. 


A  complete  catalogue  of  publications  in  print  is  available  from: 

Publication  Services 

Royal  Ontario  Museum 

100  Queen's  Park 

Toronto,  Ontario 

Canada  M5S  2C6 

(416)  586-5581 

Fax  (416)  586-5863 


•'^'-'IS 


ISBN  0-88854-349-2 
ISSN  0384-8159